Work Text:
You appear casual and unconcerned while sitting at a bus stop along Atlantic Avenue. In reality you were subtly, carefully scanning the streets and taking note of each passerby. You may be a born and raised New Yorker, but wandering around Brooklyn feels different than Queens, where you've always lived. You take pride in being from Queens and it's easily your preferred choice of the five boroughs because, while no part of New York City could really be described as quiet, Queens is at least more quiet and laid back compared to Brooklyn (and definitely more laidback than Manhattan). But, Brooklyn's energy is still pretty great and you can't deny that you've been slowly falling in love with the area as you've explored it with your new friends in recent months.
Regardless, when you were alone, the borough's different vibe kept you on high alert and hyper aware of the fact that you weren't completely familiar with these neighborhoods. Not to mention that you'd been picking up the tendencies of your aforementioned friends and now find yourself instinctually taking inventory of your surroundings when in any unfamiliar place.
You sigh and check the time impatiently before bringing your attention back to the street. Noticing a lull in the foot traffic, you're finally able to duck into the nearby alleyway unseen and get to the manhole. With practiced movements you silently remove the cover and take a few steps down the ladder. Once fully underground, you remember to slide the cover back into place before continuing your careful descent. You yawn as you reach the ground, feeling glad that the walk to the lair is fairly short and easy from this entrance. You also feel glad that you've become pretty comfortable in the tunnels.
It hadn't been funny to you at the time, but lately you could actually chuckle about the memory of when you'd gotten lost on your first solo trek down to your friends' lair. Just a few months ago you had texted the guys in near hysterics about being lost in the sewers. You'd followed that up with a call to Donatello so he could find you with the location tracking feature on the secondary phone he'd gifted you. But, in all your panic, you'd dialed Michelangelo instead so he'd been the one to come find you. Donnie had never even tracked your tPhone because, despite you being close to tears from thinking you were lost deep in the sewer system, Mikey only needed to know the tunnel number before he came and found you only three tunnels away. It was kind of embarrassing when Mikey led you to his brothers and April who were all waiting at the entrance concerned and then surprised that Mikey had found you so quickly. You recalled how you mumbled lame excuses about sleep deprivation and having more anxiety lately because of school, which had both been true but not quite true enough to justify your overreaction.
Everyone was pretty nice about it though, considering that the situation was a bit ridiculous. You'd only had to endure a minimal amount of good-natured teasing for the rest of the afternoon mostly from Raphael and Casey, who had shown up not long after and immediately gotten caught up with the situation. At one point the two best friends had taken a few shots at you for being "directionally challenged" and April had jumped to your defense and helped you roast the two of them back, which has become somewhat of a normal dynamic for the 4 of you. In no time at all you had found yourself back in good spirits and able to enjoy a rare evening where everyone could hang out.
Then that night, April had offered to leave together, though she would technically be going out of her way. She lived in Queens like you, but in a different neighborhood that was closer to Brooklyn's border. Even so, she had walked side by side with you and shared tips from the guys about navigating the sewers and pointed out her own observations and "landmarks" that she'd memorized. That night had been the catalyst for becoming closer friends with April and the whole day was a memory you looked back on fondly. Now, even as you're only half paying attention, lost in your reminiscing, you easily recognize the inconspicuous tunnel that leads to the lair's entrance.
Donnie is first to notice your arrival. You happily greet him, pleasantly surprised to find him lounging on the couch alone in front of the TV and with seemingly no plans to go work in his lab or the garage. He seems relaxed today and you're happy because he clearly deserves it. You guys converse casually about the discovery channel special he’s watching and how yesterday’s calculus exam ended up going. He's just asked for updates on your math teacher's terrible lectures when Mikey and Raphael exit the dojo and come into the living room laughing and bantering. They take a seat with you guys as they offer hellos and seamlessly join the conversation.
You don't know why exactly, but the atmosphere is different tonight. There's a sense of peace and calm, which can be a rare occurrence in the lair. The guys certainly know how to relax and have fun but lately it's more likely for them to be planning a stakeout, a counterattack, or some infiltration into enemy territory. So it was great to feel like everyone was at ease for once. Currently you're chatting with Raph, but you've occasionally been glancing around to find the missing fourth turtle. Donnie's focus has fully shifted back to the documentary on TV and Mikey had just wandered into the kitchen in search of snacks for everyone. So, after what's probably the tenth time of you glancing around, you turn back to Raph only to find him shaking his head. "You’re so obvious. You could just ask where he is, ya know." He points out. He's sporting an amused smile and his voice has a teasing tone. You're fully aware of what he means but you only shrug, refusing to show any kind of reaction to his taunting.
As of late this has become a bad habit of Raphael's. He clearly finds it amusing to point out your apparently poorly concealed interest in Leonardo whenever possible. It had all started one day when he had casually mentioned that he knew about your crush on his older brother and then went on to state that you make it pretty obvious. That had been extra embarrassing for you since you'd been too caught off guard to deny it or say anything really. But he had specifically brought it up when you two were alone for a moment, so you'd chosen to believe he would handle this delicately. That belief quickly went out the window after he began making comments and asking questions more often and whenever he thought he could get away with it. This had started an awful, new dynamic where Raph would tease you or try to embarrass you and you'd either whisper-yell at him to knock it off or pull him to the side to tell him off. Even worse? Raph had eventually stopped hesitating to taunt you when his younger brothers were nearby or in earshot. Naturally, Donnie, Mikey, and even Casey soon found out once they'd been witness to one too many of Raph's incessant comments.
Initially, you’d disagreed when Raph said you were making your feelings obvious. After all, he was the only one who'd seemed to realize at that point. April had sensed something a bit later once you two started hanging out more, but she'd promised to keep your secret and had clearly done so. You had answered her questions and confided in her because you were so happy to speak to your only female friend that not only knew about the turtles, but was way less prone to teasing than Raphael. April never said anything about your feelings for Leo being obvious, though she had figured it out on her own.
When the other three found out, they'd all pretty much said it wasn't clear to them that you liked him. "I figured you could just sense that our big brother really needed some love and attention and that's why you're so extra nice to him." Mikey had said without looking up from the dinner he was plating. Raph had snorted at that and you'd felt the heat rising in your face. Casey shrugged and said "Well you've been acting the same way from the start so I just figured the heart eyes you make at him sometimes are because you're so grateful that he saved your life or whatever." Raph had a good laugh at that comment but you'd been even more outraged than you were embarrassed. Sure, you may not have been super great at concealing your emotions about most things, but there was no way this crush was so out of hand that you'd unknowingly been "making heart eyes" that were clear as day to everyone else. You'd said as much back to Casey but Raph had snorted at that too and called you delusional. The others mostly just chuckled while April had patted your back and reassured you that they were all exaggerating.
That might have made you feel better if Donnie hadn't picked that moment to half-joke that "If anything, I would've predicted that you and Raph had a thing. I've observed that you two are always whispering together and that he also teases you to the point that you blush and become embarrassed." WHAT!? You couldn't believe that was the conclusion Donnie had come to and you were suddenly concerned that Leo could've come to the same one.
You had a brief thought that Donnie's comment might have been embarrassing for Raph too, but he was howling with laughter before you'd even processed the comment. He had tears in his eyes by the time you gave Donnie a sincerely horrified look. "That's only because he's been ruthlessly bugging me about Leo! Obviously!" you defended. You slumped in your chair and covered your face with your hands. If you could have it your way then none of them would know, but clearly that ship has sailed. Feeling exposed and a tad overwhelmed, you had quietly reflected on your behavior toward Leo as the others shifted to a new conversation. Then you spent the first part of dinner worrying about what Leo had noticed and what conclusions he had drawn.
You tried to clear your head of any worries and play it cool. At this point your only saving grace was that no one had been cruel enough to actually say anything in front of Leonardo yet. You sure didn’t want to be the one to say something dumb and out your own feelings at this point. ‘Just be chill.’ you try to tell yourself.
Raph's voice breaks through your thoughts and you blink, startled. "I guess I'll tell you anyway." Raph offers after you still don't reply. "He left for a run and said he'd be gone for about two hours." Raphael explained as he pulled out his tPhone. "And if he meant it, then he should be back any minute." He continues as he checks the time.
As if on cue, Leo arrives at the entrance looking only slightly winded. His eyes practically light up upon seeing you and he makes his way over, quickly pulling you into a hug. You embrace him back, the familiar feelings of warmth and comfort making you smile as usual. Raph instantly groans but Donnie is polite enough to wait a few seconds before complaining about his blocked view of the TV. Behind you Mikey can be heard muttering something about how Leo 'never greets me that way'. Hoping your face doesn't betray how flustered you are, you pull away avoiding the others' gazes. "It's uh, nice to see you (Y/N)." Leo says with a half smile. You meet his eyes and smile too. "Yeah it's been a while." You reply. "Weren't you just down here like 3 days ago?" Mikey counters. You turn to glare at him while Raph and Donnie laugh at you. Everyone settles a moment later as you sit back down and scoot over to make room for Leo.
The evening progresses without much excitement between watching a comically bad movie that Mikey found while channel surfing and catching up with April and Master Splinter. When it nears 8:30pm you announce your departure and check to see if April wants to join you. She declines and tells you to get home safe so you leave with a promise to stay later on Friday. "Do you want me to walk you?" Leo asks. It's tempting, but you decline. "I'm taking the closer subway stop and I have a few things to do before I go to sleep so I need to hurry. Next time though." you explain regretfully. He nods. "Text me when you get home." Leo reminds from the door. "Of course." you smile. After a quick hug you're out the door and heading home with him still on your mind.
Leo turns back towards the living room to find April and his brothers all staring at him with various expressions. Raph is smirking and Leo feels a twinge of irritation. He turns to April who's looking at him almost expectantly. Before he can question her, Donnie speaks up "When are you going to confess to her?" Leo visibly tenses though his face gives away nothing. He chooses to ignore them and heads towards the kitchen instead. Of course, they won't allow him out of it that easily and they follow the oldest turtle to the counter. "You probably shouldn't try to deny it either because we know for sure that you like her, dude." Mikey interjects. Despite his discomfort and his instinct to deny their claims Leo quietly admits that he does in fact like you. They all grin victoriously but then he adds that he can't bring himself to tell you. "Well, Raph doesn't call you fearless for nothing, Leo. We can help you figure out the right way to tell her if you want." April offers. Leo wants to counter that the nickname is sarcastic anyway, but he actually stops to contemplate because he knows that April at least would take this seriously and actually try to be helpful. It seems like she has been close with you lately too. "Well ... I have been thinking of doing something for her since her birthday's soon." Leo explains. All eyes turn to Mikey as he whoops loudly. "Guys we should totally have a birthday party for her! We can all decorate and set up a dance floor! We'll dance and get her a cake then, at the end before she leaves, Leo can tell her." Mikey proposed.Instantly the kitchen was abuzz. Everyone seemed pleased and interested at the prospect of a party. No one seemed to have any objections and Leo was just happy to be on the receiving end of one of Mikey's solid plans.
Leo's tPhone buzzes and he smiles automatically as he reads the sweet goodnight message you had sent him. He begins typing out a reply when Mikey suddenly appears over his shoulder, glancing at the texts. "Wow. You really do need to tell her." He emphasizes. Leo snatches his phone from view and glares at Mikey as his gratitude towards him instantly waivers. Ignoring his glare, Mikey only turns to everyone else and says, "Imagine how happy he'll look when we actually get them together." Leo's brothers laugh at his embarrassment as he slinks off to his room. But it was decided. The guys were throwing you a birthday party.
The next day the planning started. Although your birthday was on Saturday the guys were planning your party for Friday since you'd already confirmed you were coming back to the lair then. It was Tuesday so they had to move fast. Leo had asked April and Casey for assistance with some decorations after school. He also needed help with the source of his recent anxiety: your gift. Raphael, Donatello, Michelangelo, and Casey had already decided to get you one gift from all of them. Another gift would come from April who revealed that she was simply going to get something you'd really liked at the mall when you two went a few weeks back. Since you and Casey had been friends for years Casey probably knew you a little better than April did. That also meant that his input into the group gift would likely result in a present you'd actually like. Leo was stumped. At one point Master Splinter had come into the living room to see what all the excitement was about. They were sheepish as they explained their idea, instantly aware of how they got so carried away that they forgot to ask permission. He had quickly approved of his sons' plan and said he may even have a small gift for you as well. Now Leo was really feeling the pressure to find the perfect gift.
After brainstorming with April, who gently shot down some of his suggestions, he finally decided on a custom necklace. They looked online for a bit before deciding on a simple but gorgeous locket design. The silver chain held a silver heart with small patterned indentations and had room for a small engravement. Leo took the majority of his savings to April and explained his final plan. She smiled supportively and agreed that Leo's idea was perfect. With her promise to go to the jeweler after school tomorrow and the progress they made with planning, Leo felt more at ease. He finally allowed himself to feel excitement for the next two days instead of worry.
Later that night Leonardo was pulled from his meditation by three sharp knocks on his door. He senses that it's Master Splinter before the door even opens. "My son. I am sorry to have interrupted your meditation but in light of hearing about your gift to (y/n) I wanted to check up on you." 'How did he even know? I just decided a few hours ago!' Pushing his thoughts away, Leo smiled appreciatively and welcomed his Sensei into the room. "Thank you, Sensei. I'm fine and I think she'll really like it." "Leonardo, I am not merely concerned about whether (y/n) will take a liking to your gift. Though I am sure that she will. This party is also an opportunity to reveal your true feelings to her, is it not?" Leo felt the blood rushing to his face but managed a slow nod while still (barely) maintaining eye contact with Splinter. He shouldn't be surprised that Splinter had already figured out the part he wasn't being told. "I have noticed for quite some time. However, I am still surprised and a bit hurt that you haven't come to speak to me about how you were feeling. “Leo opened his mouth to protest and apologize but Splinter held up a paw. “You have done nothing wrong my son. I am sorry if I have not made you feel that you could come to me about this. I also know that you are still a teenager and it is difficult to open up sometimes. I will not let your choice to keep your feelings private stop me from giving you my blessing." Sensei reassured. Leo's whole body relaxed and he smiled sincerely at his Sensei. His dad knew just what to say to ease his worries. Most of the time.
"I'm sorry for not being open with you Sensei. I just hesitated because I know how you felt about Donnie's advances towards April." "My son, your approach to this situation is much different from your brother's. You are more cautious in your actions and I trust that any interactions between yourself and (y/n) have not caused her discomfort. That is why I trust in you to make your own choices about this." Leo took great comfort and reassurance from Master Splinter's revelations as well as the hand resting on his shoulder. "I'm still really worried, Master Splinter. What am I gonna do if after all of this planning, things go wrong? I don't know if I'll still be able to face her if she doesn't feel the same." Leo admits. Splinter places a gentle hand on Leo's shoulder as he replies: "I've come to believe that you are as much a natural born worrier as a leader. It is the only explanation as to why you are still plagued with constant worry after all of your successes. I know that strategies and battle tactics are your forté but do not doubt that you are also smart in affairs of the heart, Leonardo. (Y/N) possesses a rare genuineness and is great at accepting others for who they really are. Surely she is aware of the similar traits you two possess and agrees that you would be a great pair. All things considered, I have a strong belief that your plans for tomorrow will go well." Leonardo was quick to throw his arms around his Sensei and thank him once more. Though Master Splinter was far from unloving, he did not often show outright physical affection. His love and care were shown effectively through his words. However in the occasional instance when he did show physical affection, like now, Leonardo always welcomed and appreciated it. Sensei merely smiled reassuringly before making his exit. Leo was last to go to sleep that night but he drifted off feeling content and at peace.
~~~~~
Balloons of your favorite color were bobbing around the lair’s living room and bumping into the streamers strung from the ceiling. Reusable cups, plates, and cutlery sat out on the table with pizza boxes stacked high next to them. Raph and Donnie were doing some last minute straightening up as Michelangelo put the final touches on the two tier birthday cake he'd been carefully making all afternoon. With the cake iced and placed on a fancy server, Mikey exited the kitchen just as April and Casey arrived. Casey called out a quick greeting and April followed, carrying a gift bag with her.
"It's really nice that you guys are doing this for (y/n)." April says. "This way she can celebrate with her friends today and then her family tomorrow." She sets the bag down under the table and admires the decorations. "Where's Leo? I figured he'd be out here stressing like nobody's business." Casey asks while lazily dropping onto the couch. Rolling his eyes at Casey's sprawled form, Raph answers, "Well he was stressing so we sent him out on another training run while we finished things up. He got back a little bit ago and is showering before he leaves to go to her house." "Well I know (y/n)'s really confused because when I talked to her in class today she told me Leo was being mysterious and that he only said he had a birthday surprise for her. So she has no idea what's going on. She also said she was going to take a nap and do homework after school since she wasn't allowed to come over right away. But Leo should go soon because she seemed even more curious by the time school ended." April told everyone. "Well in that case I'm definitely leaving right now." Leo declared.
Everyone turned to look at their leader as he emerged from the bedroom hallway, a small gift box clutched in his hand. "Go get your girl." Raph grinned supportively with a rough pat on Leo's shoulder. "Yeah! Hurry up and get your girlfriend Leo! I wanna get this party started!" Mikey shouts energetically. Leo rolls his eyes good naturedly and bids everyone goodbye as he takes off for the surface.
Your home is not far from Casey's apartment. It sits in a line of quaint looking townhouses just a few streets away. Leo heads towards the end of the block where your house is conveniently located for easy rooftop access. He maneuvers down the side of the building and swings around on to your tiny deck and fire escape all while avoiding the illuminated area from the nearby street light. You hear one knock on the glass and spot Leo through the intentional gap you left in your curtains. You quickly pull him inside and away from the semi-populated streets below.
The automatic smile you always have with Leo has shown up and Leo smiles in a similar manner back at you. One of you initiates a hug and you both linger a bit longer than necessary before pulling apart and smiling again. "Hi." You say finally. "Happy almost Birthday." Leo says back. You thank him and then huff quietly as he hands you a small gift box with a shiny bow on top. "You honestly didn't have to get me anything you know." You say as you inspect the little box. "You're very special to me (y/n) and I want you to have a great birthday." Leo says seriously. You stop turning the box around in your hands and look straight at him when you hear the unusual tone of his voice. Looking right into your eyes, Leo takes a deep breath before saying he has something to tell you. Your heartbeat picks up but you try to remain relaxed as you smile and assure him that you're listening.
"(Y/n) my family and I are so grateful to know you and we couldn't be more appreciative for your loyalty and help over the last few months. I'm so happy we've become so close and I couldn't picture my life without your friendship now. Recently I've been feeling kind of um, different around you and I realized it's because I sort of uh, really like you? As more than a friend? And I just thought that I should maybe tell you that..." Leo trailed off and it was dead silent in the room as he broke eye contact with you. All you could hear was your heart pumping in your ears and you took a few seconds to compose yourself. To Leo, the few seconds without your response felt like an eternity. Finally, with a giant grin on your face, you grabbed Leo's three fingered hands back in yours. His eyes snapped back up to you and you saw how nervous and worried he looked. "Leo, I really like you too." you say while squeezing his hands. "As more than a friend." You clarify. The bewildered look on his face as he processes your words, makes you laugh. "Oh. Oh. Really? You aren't just saying that?" Another laugh as you shake your head and assure him that you really do feel the same. You guys share another hug and a smile before you're reminded of the abandoned gift box. "Can I open it now?" You ask as you pull Leo to sit with you on your bed. "Absolutely." Leo nods as he wraps an arm around you.
You gently pull the lid off and then smile at the beautiful necklace sitting inside. You carefully lift it up and run your finger over the intricate designs on the locket's surface. With a grateful smile you pull the necklace around your neck and clasp it in the back. You lean away to find yourself in the mirror across the room and smile at your reflection. "So…do you like it?" Leo asks quietly. "Yes. I love it. Thank you, Leonardo." "You're welcome, (y/n). There's actually one more thing." Leo reaches around you and turns the locket to the side. Now you see a minuscule button and as his large finger presses it, you watch in awe as it opens up the locket.
Leo's hand moves away and you examine the images on the inside. One side features a group photo of you, the guys, Master Splinter, April and Casey taken with a selfie stick. The other side has a picture you've never seen before. It was taken in the lair and neither you nor Leo appear to be aware of the camera. You're together on the couch laughing at whatever was on tv and your legs are stacked with each other's as your head leans on his shoulder. "Wow.” The two of you looked great together and the picture was absolutely melting your heart. “ I think this might be my favorite candid picture ever." You say looking up at him. "Mine too. When I told April I wanted to get you a locket she said she had the perfect picture in mind. And of course I agreed when I saw it. I’m actually glad she’s been so obsessed with that Canon." You chuckle and take his hand again. "I can't thank you enough Leo. This really is perfect and I'm never taking it off." Leo smiles possibly the happiest smile you've ever seen on him and tells you you're welcome. It's quiet again as you both stare at each other happily. Your eyes scan his face and you can feel yourself leaning closer to him. Leo's expression is more concentrated now and he's closing in on you as well. Just as you're only a few inches apart you hear footsteps right outside your door.
The door's not completely shut so you don't have much warning as you jerk away from Leo just before your mom walks in. "Oh! I thought I heard you talking to someone. How are you, Leonardo?" Your mom asks warmly. "I'm great Ms. (y/l/n)! It's good to see you." You don't miss the way your mom scans over you two and takes in your close positioning. Eyes leaving your mom, you glance at Leo and can see his cheeks are a bit flushed and he's now sitting stiffly while not looking at you. His arm isn't pulling you close now and instead rests loosely behind you "I had actually just come by to give (y/n) her birthday gift. And if it's okay with you, my family and I wanted to spend some time with the birthday girl tonight." Leo explains. Your mom beams, charmed as usual by Leo. "That's very thoughtful of you, Leo. Of course that's okay just don't keep her out too late because I have a great breakfast planned for the morning. You have a nice evening and tell your family hello for me." She pulls the door *mostly* shut but not before she aims a knowing look at you.
You groan and will yourself to stay alive instead of dying on the spot like you have the urge to. Imagining the conversation with her later already makes you uncomfortable. Your heartbeat started to decrease and you thanked the Lord that your mom already knew about the giant turtle currently in your room. The story of how she first met Leonardo and Mikey one night is a rather amusing one and you smile at the memory. Next to you, Leo still looks flustered and zoned out so you bump his shoulder to get his attention. "You ready to take me to the lair?" He exhales and the redness in his face finally diminishes. "Oh, right. I'm ready whenever you are." he says standing up. You call out a goodbye to your mom as you sling a purse over your shoulder, shut off the lights and maneuver out of the window. Leo helps you onto the rooftop and once ready, you guys link hands and take off towards the lair.
Any of the remaining awkwardness from your almost moment has melted by the time you've hit the tunnels. As per usual, you guys start talking about everything and anything. Switching from deep conversation to more light hearted, as well as jumping from topic to topic without a moment's notice. You guys are nearing the lair and debating whether visiting France or Italy would be more fun when Leo starts to seem nervous. You squeeze his hand to regain his attention. "You okay?" You ask skeptically. "Hmm? Yeah I'm good! Oh look! It's the lair. We're at the lair! Good ol' lair!" Leo is rambling and much louder than necessary . You raise one eyebrow at him and stop walking. "You're being even weirder than usual. What’s up with you?" Leo just tugs on your hand to pull you the remaining steps to the entrance.
As you go inside you notice how quiet and still everything is. You’re instantly on guard and just as you're about to whisper to Leo, the lights flicker on. "Surprise!" Everyone shouts. Noisemakers and whistles are blown and your eyes widen as you take in all the decorations. Balloons, streamers, a tablecloth, and they're all your favorite color. "Aw! You guys!" You gush. A flash goes off and you turn to see April with her Canon yet again. Everyone comes up to hug you and give their mandatory birthday wishes. A giant grin is plastered on your face all the while. "Thank you guys so much! You really did surprise me. Leo didn't even give it away though he was being a weirdo." "Hey!" Leo protests. "You are so welcome (y/n)!" Mikey says. "I hope you're ready because we have pizza, music, movies, and an awesome cake I made just for you." "I am so ready!" You exclaim. "Woo! Let's get this party started then!" Mikey pushes a button on the remote and the music starts blasting from the tv and stereo. Before you can move, Leo squeezes your hand and whispers in your ear that he's going to talk to Master Splinter. You squeeze back and smile at him as he leaves.
You decide to join Casey and April who are dancing across the room. Although dancing may be inaccurate when it's really just Casey moving awkwardly and showing off the worst dance moves ever while April does something more appropriate and tries not to laugh at Casey. A few minutes later, while Casey is busy trying out some hip hop moves he saw in the song's music video, April turns to you with a smile. "Having fun?" She asks. "I am! I still can't believe you guys did all of this for me. I feel so special." You say. "We were happy to throw a party for you. I'm glad you like it." April pauses and glances at your neck. "That's a pretty necklace." She adds knowingly. You give her a sincere smile and remember what Leo said. "Thank you for the picture of us. I really love it." "You're so welcome! I’ll text it to you so you can save it on your phone too. Soooo….” You look away from the necklace and up at her skeptically as you register the change in her voice. “I guess you guys were holding hands because you were just so grateful for the necklace, right?" April teases with feigned innocence. You try and fail to not look embarrassed. "Well actually…we both admitted to liking the other, “April is nearly squealing. “And we're kind of together now... I think?" you confess shyly. April only grins and says it's about time. Casey, who you didn't know was paying attention, whoops from behind you and says, "Damn right it's about time! Congrats (y/n)!" You roll your eyes good naturedly and allow yourself to smile despite your embarrassment.
The three of you wander over to the others who are eating pizza already. Mikey scoots over after declaring that “the birthday girl must have enough room to eat comfortably." Casey and April grab their own plates while your pizza is personally served to you by Raph. You offer him a sincere thank you and play along with their ridiculous treatment of you. Everyone chats as you munch on the pizza and you're reminded of just how lucky you are to know these people.
A few minutes later you finally spot Leo and Master Splinter outside of the dojo where they had disappeared to talk. Leo makes eye contact with you from across the room and you both smile bashfully. He breaks it off to respond to Sensei and you smile down at your empty plate instead. Raphael, having seen the whole thing, pokes you in the side. You glance up, still smiling, and flush at the knowing look he gives you. "Nice necklace." He says, without trying to hide his amusement. You don't even dignify that with a response. Donnie and Mikey look up though, glance at the locket around your neck and give you their own cheesy grins. In a similar fashion to April, Donnie simply says it's about time, with Mikey agreeing. You smile at their easy acceptance and still don't say a word.
By this point everyone's plates are empty and you stand up to begin collecting them much to Mikey's horror. Ignoring his claim that 'the birthday girl can't clean everything up' you make a stack of plates and head towards the kitchen. You intersect with Master Splinter and Leo who have apparently decided to join the party now. Leo smiles as he turns to head towards the kitchen ahead of you. Master Splinter stops you with a hand on your shoulder before you can follow. "Leonardo has told me of the evening's events. I trust the two of you will be happy together?" Sensei asks. Sensing only sincerity in his voice relaxes you as you tell Sensei that you believe you will. He seems satisfied and wishes you happy birthday once more before heading over to claim some remaining pizza.
Still balancing the plates, you head over to the kitchen and finally drop them all into the trash. Leo is busying himself with putting away the few dishes from the dishwasher. He's just closed the last cupboard when you approach him. "You know," you say to him. "I get the vibe that in addition to the necklace, this party was also all your idea." Leo places the towel on the island before turning to look at you, poker face already in place. "Not sure why you'd think that. But even if it was true, why is it a problem?" "Because you're being too generous to me for just one birthday." "Too generous? Well I suggest you get used to it because it's probably going to be the same level of generosity a year from now as well." "Does a year from now mean my birthday or our anniversary?" You ask. "Well... I guess it would be both." He says slowly. "You really made this hard on yourself by putting two important events the day after each other." You grin at him. "Well I plan to exceed your expectations anyway so don't worry." He assures as his arms carefully wrap around you and pull you closer. You follow suit and put your hands around his neck. "In all seriousness, thank you Leo. You've made this such a wonderful day." "No problem, (y/n). You deserve all of it. Although I should tell you that the party was Mikey's idea." You laugh and nod easily because that's a believable explanation based on the Mikey you know. "Well, I'm still giving you all the credit." "I'll gladly take it." You both grin at each other, not needing words to convey how happy you are. This easy back and forth bantering that works so well for you guys reminds you why you fell for him to begin with. Akin to earlier, the two of you slowly lean in.
Unfortunately, Mikey bursts into the kitchen, calling both of your names and making you jump. Mikey groans when he sees your close proximity and asks if 'the two of you are always going to be making out now'. Despite your face heating up yet again, you glare at him. You insist that you weren't even doing anything, because you weren't, thanks to him. Luckily Leo chases Mikey back through the doorway, telling him to mind his own business with a face that’s equally red.
He glances back at you with a sheepish expression before grabbing your hand to go join the others. With a disappointed sigh you follow his lead but decide to enjoy the remainder of the party. Two dance battles, half of a terrible movie, 2 slices of cake, 3 birthday presents, and a bonus dance battle later, you find yourself wishing everyone a goodnight and giving your final thank you's. It’s late but Leo accompanies you as you exit the lair and head out into the slightly cool night air. "So did you have fun?" He asks casually. "Do you even have to ask? Every second was fantastic!" You reply honestly. "I really appreciate it, even though you apparently weren't the one to plan it." Leo just grins and gives your hand a tight squeeze.
You guys reach your house a bit later and you think about how although it wasn't as conversation heavy as usual, the walk was still pleasant due to being in Leo's presence. Getting down to your fire escape was trickier for you than going up, but this time Leo didn't have to be shy about hooking his arm around you and carefully maneuvering the both of you to the window. Even when you'd reached your deck in one piece Leo still kept his arm around you. The wind was gentler than most nights but still had a slight chill to it. You guys seemed immune as you stood outside and looked out across the city. The traveling cars in the distance really created a beautiful scene along with the flickering lights of buildings from blocks away. Rough as it may be, New York City was beautiful.
Minutes went by without either of you saying anything. You were simply taking in the view and enjoying the other’s company. "What do you think would've happened if I hadn't been nearby on the night you guys stopped that weapons exchange?" You asked, effectively shattering the comfortable silence. The night you met Leo and his brothers had been a scary one. A local gang had plans to trade some illegal weapons with another gang that worked mostly underground, at a pier at the edge of the city. This had been on a night when you were sitting by the water and doing some journaling as you sometimes did on stressful days. Your bad timing had almost gotten you killed by the local gang. You'd caught the attention of a gang member when you were walking back to the main street. You had felt dread and, without looking to see who was watching, instinctively started to run. Your pursuer had been closing in but something whizzed through the air and apparently cut across his torso, leaving him to double over in pain as he cursed and swore. You were aware that he stopped running but weren’t deterred from seeking refuge behind a dumpster until he was really gone.
From your dark vantage point in the shadows was where you'd first seen the four mutated turtles. Another gang member fell victim to what you later learned was a throwing star as the battle reached its conclusion. The turtles had tracked the gangs’ activity and managed to take a portion of their forces out before you became involved.You remembered watching in awe as their quick, well practiced movements had easily disabled the dozens of men pouring into the area in 5 minutes flat. The strange creatures had been celebrating and slowly approaching your location. You have no idea what compelled you, even to this day, especially when you were still recovering from your chase with the gang member, but you slowly emerged from your spot when they were about 30 feet away and just stood in the low light that the alley provided. This was the first instance that you witnessed their agility and speed. Within seconds the four beings had had their weapons out and taken a defensive stance. You stared in complete fascination, as well as fear of what you'd gotten yourself into, and simply said "Hi?".
The one wearing a blue face mask and standing in front slowly lowered his weapons although he was clearly unsure if he should trust you. The other creatures had followed his example but made no further moves and the word 'leader' popped into your head upon seeing this. As your brain slowed down enough to process what had just happened, you realized that the blue masked person was the one that had thrown the sharp projectile at your pursuer and effectively saved you. "Who are you?" Orange Mask had asked curiously. "I'm (y/n). One of those guys was chasing me so I'm really glad you guys showed up.” You turned to Blue Mask and said to him directly, “Thanks for that thing you threw at him. You really saved me.“ He seemed at a loss for words but gave you a nervous smile. The rest of the creatures had continued to stare and scrutinize you in the darkness until a familiar voice had you all turning your heads skyward. None other than Casey Jones came swinging down from the adjacent building's fire escape in a grand entrance.
"Aw you guys didn't save me any goons to take down?" He complained as he saw the defenseless bodies scattered around. "Casey?!" You exclaimed gaping. His head whipped over to you. "(Y/n)!? What the hell are you doing here?" "Well I was hanging at the docks until I started being chased and uh now I'm meeting your friends apparently..." "What!? What good for nothing creep was chasing you?" "So this bonehead's a friend of yours?" Raphael cut in. Sending a mock glare at his friend Casey answered "Yeah. We've been friends and classmates for years. April knows (y/n) too." 'So April knew these people(?) too?' "(Y/n) These are the turtles. My secret but close friends I sometimes mention? They're ninjas and I usually patrol the city with them." "Ninjas?" You ask warily, eyeing the weapons that are still strapped to their backs, or shells. "Yes, ninjas. Donatello's the tall one in purple, Mikey's the dude in orange, Raph's my best bud in red, and the leader is Leonardo in blue." "You smiled at them and committed their names to memory. Fortunately, they hadn't taken too much getting used to. It obviously helped that you were already trusted by Casey and April because within a few weeks you were entrusted with the location of their lair. The rest is history.
"I don't know," Leo replied, breaking you out of your memories. "But I'm really glad I don't have to wonder." He stated emotion heavy in his voice. You turned to look at him and he was already staring at you. A couple different emotions were identifiable as you looked each other in the eyes. Clear vulnerability was present as you both stood with all your walls down. Slight disbelief could be seen in Leo's eyes as well as an almost overwhelming happiness that was probably also reflected in your own. The soft breeze drifted past again and you took a breath. "Me too." You whispered, never breaking eye contact. Deciding you couldn't wait anymore, you deliberately pulled him closer as your arms found their new place around his neck and his hands automatically settled on your hips. He lowered his head towards you and your forehead rested against his for a moment. You both closed your eyes and your lips finally met after the earlier failed attempts. It took a moment to fit your mouths together properly but there was no denying the almost dizzying electricity you both were instantly feeling.
You guys remained together for several moments, sharing a kiss that was slow yet deliberate and conveyed all the happiness you'd both been feeling today. Finally breaking apart, you couldn't do much but stare into the cerulean eyes in front of you and once again thank your lucky stars for the turn your life had taken. The weirdness and craziness could get overwhelming at times but Leo was a blessing and you wouldn't dream of ever changing a thing that led you to this very special moment. Everything was and always would be undoubtedly worth it. And you would undoubtedly remember this birthday forever.