Work Text:
The first time you meet him, it’s chaos.
A big mutant pig is trying to flatten a food truck while people are scattering, screaming. You, however, are standing perfectly still on the opposite sidewalk, a bag of new markers clutched in your hand. You’re frozen—not from fear, but fascination. Because that thing? It’s not CGI, not a costume.
It’s real, and it’s wrecking that truck like it’s got a personal vendetta.
A shimmering, electric-blue tear in reality appears in mid-air. From it, four figures leap out like characters in a comic book: giant turtles. Your expression remains placid, a carefully constructed mask of indifference. But your brain is firing on all cylinders.
The one in the blue mask, all swagger, lands with a flourish closest to you. “Don’t worry, citizen! The situation is officially under control, courtesy of the best in the biz!” He winks, a cocky grin plastered on his face.
You just blink at him, your head tilting a fraction of an inch.
He falters for a second, his grin tightening. He’s clearly accustomed to a more … expressive reaction. Awe, perhaps? A little light swooning? You give him none of it. You simply watch as he and the other turtles engage the pig-mutant.
The big red-masked one charges first. His movements are powerful, grounded, all brute force and surprisingly agile lunges. He roars something about a “pork chop” as he body-slams the pig mutant, who stumbles back with an enraged shout.
The one in orange is pure kinetic energy. He moves like a dancer or a gymnast as he uses a glowing chain to wrap around the pig’s arm. He’s all smiles and whoops, a sunburst of joyful expression.
The blue-masked turtle is the showman. He doesn’t just run; he zips through self-made portals, appearing behind the pig to land a kick, then vanishing before the counter-swing. A smirk is practically glued to his face. “Bit of a ham, aren’t ya?” he quips.
And the purple one hangs back for a few moments. He mutters calculations, something about trajectories and structural integrity, before his staff extends with a purple glow, rocketing forward to whack the mutant pig square in the back of the knee.
The four turtles are a study in contrasts, a perfect team composition. Your artist’s eye catalogues them instantly.
The fight is over as fast as it started. Unceremoniously, the big red one shoves the dazed pig mutant, who’s tangled in the orange one’s chain, back through a blue portal. The portal snaps shut, leaving behind a wrecked food truck and four turtle guys.
When it’s over, the blue one saunters back over, leaning against a light post, trying to look casual. “See? Easy peasy. You can, uh, stop being paralyzed with fear now.”
“I wasn’t,” you state, your voice flat.
“Oh. Right. Cool.” He rubs the back of his neck, the confident aura dimming slightly. “Nerves of steel. I dig it. The name’s Leo.” He holds out a three-fingered hand. “I’m the face-man of the team. The charm. The je ne sais quoi.” His grin reemerges again, just a little more uncertain this time.
You look at his hand, then back at his face, and after a beat, shift your marker bag to the other arm and shake it. “Okay.”
“Okay? That’s it?” he asks, incredulous. “I just saved this entire city block from becoming a mutant’s lunch buffet and all I get is ‘Okay’?”
“You didn’t save me,” you clarify, your tone unchanging. “I was on the other side of the street. My trajectory was not intersecting with his. Thank you for the spectacle, though. It was … interesting.”
Leo blinks, and you practically see the gears turning in his head. Like he’s trying to crack a puzzle he’s never encountered before: someone who isn’t falling all over themselves to gush about how cool he is. He lets out a soft chuckle, clearly unsure what to do with your clinical tone.
“Interesting,” he repeats, cocking his head. “Right. That’s one word for it. Another word might be—oh, I dunno—awesome? Epic? Ninja-rific?”
You blink again, and this time your lip twitches. Just a flicker. Barely there. But Leo notices. His eyes narrow slightly as he squints.
“Was that almost a smile?” he asks, leaning forward, as if he’s trying to catch it again.
“No,” you lie, because yes, it absolutely was.
You reach into your hoodie pocket, pull out a small sketchbook, and flip it open to a blank page. Leo watches you, confused.
“Can you stand like that again?” you ask, voice still neutral, eyes already scanning his posture. “The pose. Against the pole.”
“… Wait, seriously?”
“Mm,” you hum, pencil already in hand. “The light catches off your gear in an interesting way. It’s a useful reference.”
He grins again, but this time it’s real. No performance, no swagger. Just genuine curiosity and amusement. “I mean, sure,” he says, striking the pose again. “Can’t blame you for wanting to capture this,” he gestures to himself with a dramatic flair.
You ignore the ego and start sketching, your lines fast and confident, all business. Leo watches you work, trying not to fidget. He lasts about twenty seconds.
“So, you draw a lotta turtles or …?”
You pause, your pencil hovering above the page. “No. Just things that don’t usually exist.”
He opens his mouth, then shuts it. That one hit him somewhere under the shell.
You say little else before he gets yanked away by his team. The purple one is rambling something about cleanup duty as Leo cuts the air with his swords, forming a portal. He throws a glance back at you before the others disappear through it.
“See you around, Miss Unshakeable!” he calls before entering behind them.
He does see you around.
Because it seems he makes it his personal mission to. He “randomly” bumps into you a week later outside an art supply store. You’re exiting with a fresh sketchbook and a bag of sculpting clay.
“Fancy seeing you here!” he says, popping out from behind a mailbox.
“Is it?” you ask, not breaking stride.
“So, what’s with all the arts and crafts?” he presses, jogging to keep up. He gestures to your bag. “You an artist?”
“I appreciate the arts, and I dabble,” you respond, which is both true and evasive.
“Dabble,” he repeats, a smile playing on his lips. “You know, my brother Mikey is an artist. You guys would probably have a lot of things to talk about.”
You give a noncommittal hum. You’re not trying to be difficult; small talk is just an inefficient use of energy. And you’re more excited about taking your haul home and starting work on some new projects than entertaining this turtle man—even if you find his persistence oddly charming.
Your quiet nature and dispassionate responses put most people off. They mistake your stillness for disinterest or condescension and eventually drift away. But this turtle seems to take it as a challenge.
His persistence becomes a strange new constant in your life.
He shows up when you’re leaving the library, juggling a stack of books on animation theory and visual storytelling. Materializes on a fire escape across from the coffee shop where you sit for hours, just watching people and drawing in your sketchbooks. He never pushes too hard, never demands more than you offer, which is usually just a brief, neutral acknowledgment of his presence.
He seems content to orbit you, throwing out jokes and puns like sparks, waiting for one to catch fire.
Tonight, you’re on a rooftop overlooking the city, your favorite sketchbook open on your lap. The cool night air is a welcome relief. Below, the traffic is a river of lights. But up here, it’s quiet. Just you, your pencil, and the stars overhead.
“You always pick the best views,” comes a voice from behind you.
You don’t turn around. “I don’t pick them. I just find them.”
Leo walks up, slower than usual; he’s learned not to barrel into your space. He crouches nearby, elbows resting on his knees. You sense him watching your hand move on the page, but he says nothing at first.
“What is it tonight?” he finally asks.
You pause just long enough to glance at him. “Cityscape. But stylized.”
He leans in a bit, eyes scanning the clean lines and shifting architecture on the page. “Stylized how?”
You don’t answer right away. You’re shading in a rooftop, letting the movement of your hand do the talking for a few more seconds. Then, “I’m experimenting with contrast. Real shapes, exaggerated lighting. Like how old noir films used city shadows to tell a story.”
He whistles low under his breath. “Dang. You don’t just ‘dabble,’ huh?”
You glance at him again. This time your expression softens—just a trace. “I don’t like being watched while I work.”
He leans back immediately, hands up. “Copy that. Silent admiration only.”
A comfortable silence settles between you. He keeps his promise, watching the city lights instead of your moving hand. You work for another ten minutes, cross-hatching the deep shadows of an alleyway, adding the glow of a neon sign. Then, on an impulse you don’t fully understand, you turn the sketchbook towards him without a word.
Leo’s eyes widen, his jaw literally dropping for a second before he snaps it shut. “Whoa. Okay. That’s … wow.” He looks from the page to the city skyline and back again. “That’s not just what it looks like, that’s what it feels like. All moody and atmospheric.” He points a finger at a specific building you rendered. “How did you do that with the lines? It looks like it’s leaning, but it’s not.”
“Foreshortening and forced perspective,” you say, your voice a little softer than usual. “You change the vanishing points to create a sense of unease or drama.”
He just stares at you, a look of genuine awe on his face. “Okay, that’s it,” he says, pushing himself up from his crouch. “You gotta come to the lair sometime.”
You raise an eyebrow, your default mask of neutrality sliding back into place. “The what?”
“Home,” he says, as if it’s the most obvious answer in the world. “I told you my brother Mikey is an artist. I think the two of you should meet.”
You get the feeling his invitation is more about him having an excuse to be near you than getting to know his brother.
You hesitate for a moment, weighing the inherent risks of entering a dwelling with four mutant turtles against your burning, academic curiosity. Curiosity wins. “Okay,” you say.
Leo’s grin is blinding. “Same place, same time tomorrow?”
“Fine,” you reply.
It’s the exact neutral tone you always use, but he pumps a fist like he just won the lottery. Your mouth twitches again, another almost-smile you don’t hide this time as you return to sketching the skyline. Leo stays a few more minutes before saying goodbye and disappearing into a shimmer of blue light.
For the first time since you met him, you find yourself counting down the hours until your next encounter.
The next night, Leo’s waiting for you on the rooftop. He’s sitting on the ledge, legs dangling over the side, watching the street below. He looks up as you approach, and his grin is immediate and warm.
“Right on time. Punctuality. I like it,” he says, hopping to his feet. “Alright, Miss Unshakeable. Ready for the grand tour?”
With a practiced flick of his wrist, he slices a glowing blue circle into the air in front of him. The portal shimmers, showing a distorted, chaotic glimpse of what looks like a living room.
“… That’s the lair?” you ask, peering through the swirling portal.
He beams. “Home sweet sewer.”
There’s a mash-up of furniture styles, comics scattered about, and pizza boxes stacked on a coffee table. It looks like a college dorm room. But you also notice the details: how the lighting is layered in ways that suggest intentional design, how some of the clutter follows a certain rhythm of use. Lived-in. Functional. Personal.
“Interesting,” you murmur, stepping through.
The world dissolves into a smudge of blue and white for a dizzying second. It’s not unpleasant, just disorienting, like being pushed through static. You emerge into the lair, feet landing softly on a rug. There’s music in the background, something lo-fi and mellow, a contrast to the chaotic visuals. Immediately, you take in the scene.
Fairy lights dangle in arcs across the room. Half-finished paper mâché sculptures fill a corner. Sprawling, colorful murals cover another wall. Some are wild and abstract, others meticulous and character-driven.
“Did Mikey do all this?” you ask.
“Most of it,” Leo replies proudly, stepping beside you. “He’s kind of our in-house genius. Well, visual genius. Donnie’s got the tech stuff covered.”
You nod once, already walking forward. Your fingers twitch at your side, itching to run a hand across the art pieces. But you resist. You’re a guest; observation comes first.
And then you see him—Mikey—the orange-masked turtle across the room, paint on his hands and an unfinished canvas in front of him.
“Yo!” he says, springing up and smearing blue across his own plastron in the process. “You actually brought her! This is awesome!”
He’s a whirlwind of enthusiasm, but your focus is already elsewhere. You walk right past his outstretched hand, your eyes locked on the canvas he was just working on. He stops, confused for a second, then follows your gaze.
“Your use of underpainting is impressive,” you state, your voice still measured, but with a new current of excitement running beneath it. You point to a section of the canvas. “Is that a grisaille method, or are you just layering warm and cool tones to build depth?”
Mikey’s jaw drops before his eyes go wide and sparkle. “Whoa! You know about grisaille? I was doing a blended approach! Using a burnt umber base to get the shadows right before I even think about color. It makes the final layers pop more, you know?”
“I know,” you say, and for the first time, a real, tangible energy radiates from you. You’re not smiling, but your eyes are bright with focus. “It’s a classical technique. Most modern painters skip it, they go for direct color application. But this—this gives it soul.”
Leo watches this exchange from a few feet away, a look of utter bewilderment on his face. He’s seen you talk, but not like this; he’s never seen you look so alive.
“What’s going on in here?” a deep voice rumbles.
You turn to see the red-masked turtle emerge from a doorway. He’s huge, built like a fortress, and he’s frowning, his arms crossed over his chest. His gaze is suspicious as it lands on you. “You guys brought a human into the lair? Are you out of your minds?”
You don’t flinch. You don’t cower. Your artist’s eye takes him in, cataloging the sheer mass, the powerful lines of his form, the way his spiked shell contrasts with the powerful curves of his muscles.
“You have a very strong silhouette,” you say plainly. “Dynamic. It implies immense power even at rest.”
He blinks and uncrosses his arms, his guard lowering. “… Uh. Thanks?” He looks at Leo, completely thrown off balance. Leo just shrugs, a grin on his face.
The purple-masked turtle walks into the room, his gaze sweeping over you with detached curiosity. “So this is the emotional anomaly you’ve been studying, Leon.”
“She’s not an anomaly, Donnie, she’s a person,” Leo says, rolling his eyes.
You ignore the commentary and step closer to Mikey’s easel, tilting your head at a subtle angle as your fingers hover above the canvas. “May I?”
Mikey nods eagerly, already pulling out a fresh brush for you. “Go nuts.”
After the other two leave, Leo observes you, arms folded, as you begin work on the painting. You dip the brush in a warm ochre tone, then add a fine texture to the corner of the canvas. Your strokes are precise, economic, but confident.
You murmur as you work, half to yourself, half to Mikey. “This shadow’s too cool. It breaks the temperature balance. If we push the warmth here, the character’s expression will read better.”
“Yes! That’s what I was thinking,” Mikey agrees as he watches you, “but I couldn’t figure out where to start.” He looks at Leo like this one’s a keeper.
Leo gives him a lazy thumbs up but says nothing. He’s too busy watching the way your brow furrows in concentration. He realizes, with a strange jolt, that this is your version of opening up. You’re still quiet, still expressionless on the surface. But you’re pouring pieces of yourself into the canvas.
You work in a state of hyper-focused harmony with Mikey. An hour melts away into a seamless flow of mixing paints, passing brushes, and pointing out compositional flaws and strengths. Mikey is a sponge, soaking up every technical term you use.
All the while, Leo continues to watch you: how your shoulders, usually held with such rigid control, have relaxed. The focused intensity in your eyes, a fire he’s never seen there before. He notices the small, almost imperceptible quirk of your lips when you execute a difficult blending technique.
He’s seeing, for the first time, what’s behind the mask. It isn’t a void of emotion; it’s a universe of passion so deep and concentrated that you feel you have to keep it under lock and key. He thought he was trying to crack a code, but he realizes now he was just looking at the cover of a book.
This—the real you—is the story inside.
Mikey looks from you, to Leo, then back again. “I have to go do something,” he says, stepping back from the canvas and wiping his hands on a rag. “Go ahead and keep painting.”
You look up from the canvas, your focus breaking for the first time as you watch Mikey leave the communal area. Then, as you continue working on the canvas, you say without looking up, “You’ve been very quiet.”
Leo uncrosses his arms and goes over to you. “Just observing a master at work,” he states. You start to put your neutral mask back on, the stillness returning to your features.
He notices. “Don’t,” he pleads softly.
You pause and look at him, one brow raised in a silent question.
“Don’t put it away,” he clarifies, stepping a little closer. “The … everything. The passion. I like it.” He gestures vaguely toward your face. “It’s a good look for you.”
A warmth spreads through your chest. You look down, running your thumb over the handle of a paintbrush. “It’s not for display.”
“Then why hide it?” he asks, his voice genuinely curious. “You’re brilliant. Why pretend to be a blank slate?”
You take a moment to consider the question, to formulate an answer that is both true and concise. “People’s expectations are loud,” you finally say, meeting his gaze. “It’s easier to create when it’s quiet.”
He nods slowly, understanding dawning in his eyes. He gets it. The noise, the pressure. He deals with it in the exact opposite way.
“So you go quiet,” he muses, “and I get loud.”
It’s your turn to be intrigued. You tilt your head, analyzing him not as a subject for a sketch, but as a person. “The face-man,” you recall. “The charm. The showman. Is that your mask?”
He lets out a short, self-deprecating laugh. “Something like that. Can’t have the team thinking their leader is ever scared or out of his depth, can we? Someone’s gotta be the distraction, the one with the quips and the plan that sounds so crazy it just might work.” He rubs the back of his neck, a familiar tell you’ve cataloged. “It’s a role. Gets a little heavy sometimes.”
A silence stretches between you, but it’s not empty. It’s filled with a sudden, startling sense of mutual understanding. You both curate a persona to protect what’s most important.
Leo takes another step closer. Now he’s right beside you, standing in front of the easel. He doesn’t look at the painting. His eyes are fixed on you. “Well,” he says, his voice barely above a whisper. “I’m glad you let me see behind yours, Miss Unshakeable.”
Your heart does a funny little flip-flop in your chest. And then, you do something you’ve never done for him, or for most people. You offer him a real, unambiguous smile. It feels foreign on your own face, but right.
He stares at your smile like it’s the most incredible work of art he’s ever seen. His own smile widens, and he hesitates for a fraction of a second before he gently tucks a stray strand of hair behind your ear. His touch is soft, and it sends a jolt straight through you.
He leans in a little, his eyes searching yours, and the entire sprawling, chaotic lair seems to shrink until it’s only the two of you. You don’t pull back.
For once, your brain isn’t racing with techniques or reference points. You’re not analyzing angles or lighting or negative space. You’re just here. Present. Staring into Leo’s eyes, which—under all that bravado and showmanship—are filled with vulnerability.
It should be overwhelming. But it’s not.
Instead, you are calm. For the first time, the constant storm of analysis in your mind goes silent. There is only the quiet space between you and him, a pocket of stillness in the lair.
You find yourself leaning in, a magnetic pull you have no desire to fight. He mirrors the movement, his eyes flicking from your eyes down to your lips and back again. Your eyes flutter closed, your breath catching in your throat as he leans closer. His lips are mere centimeters away from yours.
“Leo!”
You both spring apart as if electrocuted. Your eyes fly open to see Donnie standing in the doorway, not even looking at you, his gaze fixed on a glowing device strapped to his wrist. Leo whirls around, a flush creeping up his neck.
“Donnie! Seriously? What part of ‘we have a guest’ translates to ‘barge in whenever you feel like it’?” Leo sputters, running a hand over his face in frustration.
Donnie finally looks up, his expression completely unfazed. He takes in the scene: the two of you standing a conspicuous six feet apart and the visible mortification on his brother’s face. “My apologies,” he says, his tone anything but apologetic. “I was not barging. I was entering a communal area of my home to retrieve something.”
You feel the heat rise in your own cheeks, and your mask of neutrality slams back into place with the force of a bank vault door. You clear your throat, your posture becoming rigid once more. “It’s getting late,” you state, your voice perfectly level, betraying none of the chaos churning in your chest. “I should go home.”
Leo’s face falls, his frustration with Donnie instantly replaced by a look of panic. “Wait, no, you don’t have to—”
“It’s fine,” you cut him off, but your tone is softer than you intend. You turn to him, managing a small, tight nod. “Thank you for … the tour. And the painting session.”
Leo deflates, but he recovers quickly, stepping forward to slice open a portal. “You, uh … you should come back,” he says, his voice a little quiet. “Soon. I mean, you and Mikey didn’t even get to finish your … paint-sterpiece.” He winces at his own word choice.
You look from his hopeful face to the swirling portal. “I’d like that,” you say, and the faintest hint of a smile touches your lips again.
A wave of relief washes over Leo’s face, and his own trademark grin returns, genuine and bright. He gives you a small, almost shy wave as you step through the portal. The world dissolves into blue—and a moment later, you’re standing under the night sky, the cool air a balm on your still-warm cheeks.
You take a steadying breath, trying to ground yourself—but you’re still back there. With him.
Your fingers curl instinctively, still remembering the feel of his hand brushing your hair back. The almost-kiss you didn’t realize you wanted until it was right there. You exhale slowly, heart still thudding.
You’re not someone who gets caught up in people. They’re messy, unpredictable. But Leo? He’s predictably unpredictable. Loud in all the ways that should irritate you. Yet somehow, it doesn’t. Not anymore.
Because for the first time in forever, you want to be seen—not by the world. But by him.
Leo.