Chapter Text
Original covers by @ancoris_art
LXIX
SPACE INVADERS SCORE
SOB — 195,448
DFL — 153,560
RSB — 130,934
JFP — 127,563
BVC — 120,974
That Saturday in early August 1993 was unusually lively at the arcade in the shopping centre. Not only were parents taking the chance to let their kids run wild on the machines, but there were also rumours swirling that the infamous RSB was about to beat DFL’s record on Space Invaders.
That arcade cabinet was a proper classic—it had been there for over eighteen years and had kept score the entire time. No one had ever managed to beat the name at the very top of the leaderboard, some SOB who’d played religiously between ’79 and ’81 and then vanished without a trace. But everyone knew DFL—Danny, to those in the know—a bloke in his mid-twenties who’d become a bit of a local legend thanks to his band.
Every time the shop’s bell rang, all heads turned towards the entrance, hoping it was RSB. Even Joe, the lad behind the counter selling tokens, was nervous. He couldn’t quite remember who RSB was exactly—loads of people came and went, after all—so he figured he’d just wait for the crowd to make a fuss and help him spot the bloke... or maybe the bird.
Didn’t take long before he showed up. The bell rang for what felt like the thousandth time, and in walked a boy with a skateboard in one hand and a Walkman in the other. Every bit of chatter and laughter in the arcade died instantly, drowned out by the beeping and chimes of the machines. He was accompanied by a girl whose neck was so stacked with silver chains Joe’s eyes started to sting.
RSB slung the skateboard over his shoulder and clipped the Walkman to the waistband of his black jeans as he strolled up to the counter. He had jet-black hair, perfectly messy, with a fringe swept up and shaped by the arch of his headphones. His eyes were a deep grey flecked with blue, his nose lightly dusted with freckles. The faint stubble on his chin betrayed the fact he was still underage.
Even so, he was taller than Joe, and there was something a bit unnerving about being stared down by that lanky lad whose features oozed natural arrogance. He tugged the headphones down around his neck.
"One token for Space Invaders," he muttered, sighing like he was already bored.
"Just one token?" the girl frowned, leaning her elbows on the counter.
"Just one token," he confirmed, the corners of his lips twitching into a smug grin.
"We're selling a minimum of three tokens today..." Joe said, the coins in the till clinking as he opened the drawer.
"Three tokens, then." RSB twisted his mouth in distaste, slipping his hand into his jeans pocket. Joe noticed he was wearing fingerless leather gloves.
"That’ll be sixty pence," Joe said, watching RSB pull out the coins and count them slowly.
"Wouldn’t it be easier to just give him a quid and have him give you forty pence back?" the girl asked, bouncing one leg impatiently. She had a thick accent and was probably foreign.
"What for, if I’ve got exact change?!" He handed the money to Joe. "Want the other two tokens?"
"Get ready to lose at Street Fighter!" the girl snatched up the tokens and shoved them into the pocket of her shorts.
"I'm not planning on playing anything but Space Invaders today, Lua," he muttered, rolling his eyes.
As RSB turned and began his confident stride toward the Space Invaders machine, the sounds of the arcade seemed to dim. All eyes were on him. It was as though he were a bloody celebrity among the crowd of teens, and even a few of the older lads looked on with a hint of respect.
Lua let out a snobbish little laugh, her fingers playing with the chains around her neck as she leaned against the Star Wars pinball machine beside Space Invaders, shooing away the boys who’d been playing there.
RSB stopped in front of the cabinet and tossed a token into the air, catching it with a confident flick. A few girls sighed audibly. He set his skateboard on the floor and ran his index finger along the coin slot before inserting the token. The game fired up, and instantly a crowd began to gather behind him. It was as if nothing else in the arcade mattered—all eyes were locked on the screen in front of him.
As the aliens descended, he manoeuvred with almost instinctive skill. A little tic made him stretch his mouth every time he fired, predicting the invaders’ movements and taking them out column by column with precise, calculated strategy.
The score kept climbing, and the crowd’s excitement grew with every level he cleared. Now and then someone shouted encouragement, and excited whispers rippled through the group each time RSB pulled off a controversial or meticulous technique.
"Want some water?" Lua asked, arms crossed.
RSB, his gaze fixed unblinkingly on the screen, simply shook his head in refusal. The white light from the aliens flashed in his grey eyes, turning them to platinum.
The first hour flew by. No one even noticed another person entering the arcade—a young woman with platinum blonde hair and clothes that looked like they belonged to the last century, which made Joe assume she was in costume or something. She wore sunglasses and craned her neck, scanning the crowd for her mates, weaving her way through until she reached RSB and Lua.
"You're late," he muttered sharply, not even glancing her way.
"I know, sorry, my brother took ages and—"
"You owe me for this one, Mims," RSB cut her off, oblivious to the dirty looks a few of the girls nearby shot her way.
"Come over here and stop bothering him, Mimi," Lua said, slinging an arm around Mimi’s neck and pulling her over to the pinball machine, resting her head on the girl’s shoulder.
The contrast between Lua and Mimi was stark. First, the hair—Lua’s was as black as Mimi’s was white. Then their skin—Lua’s was dark as chocolate, Mimi’s pale as porcelain. One thing they did share was their average height and build.
"Is he close to a hundred?!" Mimi asked quietly, eyes fixed on the screen.
Lua gave a proud little smirk.
"A hundred thousand," she corrected, weaving her fingers through the pale strands of her friend’s hair.
Mimi nodded, arms crossed, one leg bouncing incessantly. She wore a white blouse with a frilly collar and puffed sleeves, making her stand out a fair bit in the arcade—though everyone’s attention was firmly fixed on RSB.
"Yeah, I think I’ll get him some water..." Lua murmured, slipping away from Mimi and heading toward the snack bar to grab a bottle.
RSB was working the joystick and fire button feverishly, completely tuned out from the crowd behind him, moving as if by sheer muscle memory. Mimi let out a long sigh, biting the inside of her cheeks, one hand adjusting her glasses, the other resting against the pinball machine.
"What?" RSB pierced the silence, still staring dead ahead at the game.
Mimi opened and closed her mouth a few times before speaking.
"Did you read The Prophet today?" She tried to keep her voice even, but it was enough to make RSB glance away from the screen for a split second before locking his focus back in place.
"Why the fuck are you wearing sunglasses in an arcade?" he shot back, his jaw tightening, sharp cheekbones flexing with the motion.
"I’ve got a headache," Mimi whispered, pretending to look over at Lua across the room.
RSB didn’t seem to care much about her excuse. Not until the score ticked over to 155,000 and a cheer rippled through the crowd. Lua hadn’t even made it back with the water yet when he shot his hand out like a viper, snatching Mimi’s sunglasses off in a flash.
She flinched, trying to hide the purple bruise blossoming on her eyelid, her eyes wide as she turned her face away in shame. RSB didn’t get the chance to say a word, though, as the crowd immediately surged around him, congratulating him as his score overtook DFL’s, landing him in second place on the all-time leaderboard. He couldn’t have cared less—clearly irritated by the scraps of parchment with phone numbers the girls handed him and the lads slapping his back.
RSB had to push his way through the crowd to finally reach Mimi. He didn’t need to look at her to know she was tearing up, nor did he need to say anything for her to go on the defensive.
"I fell!" she insisted, trying to snatch the sunglasses back from RSB. He was taller, and simply raised his hand, the grey of his eyes sharpening into twin daggers.
"You really think that lie’s going to work on me, Victoria?!" RSB hissed, his voice laced with hurt. "Which one of those little shits did this to you, huh?" He planted his hands on his hips.
"Seriously? I did everything I could to come see you today, and you—"
"Everything?! You showed up late!" RSB cut her off, voice raised and harsh. Victoria narrowed her eyes and took a step back. "Who did it?"
She let out a short, bitter laugh. There was nothing amused about it. The caramel of her eyes burned with rage.
"I knew I shouldn’t have come here..." Victoria spun on her heel, but couldn’t get far—Lua was standing in her way.
"What is it?" she asked, handing the bottle of water to RSB, eyeing her friend as she crossed her arms. "What happened to your eye?"
RSB drank furiously, the plastic bottle crinkling under his grip until it was fully crushed. He tossed it in the bin with more force than was necessary.
"Go on, tell her, Victoria," RSB said, nodding toward Lua, a bitter smirk pulling at his lips.
Victoria rolled her eyes, her mouth twisting in disdain. She snatched the sunglasses from RSB’s hand with a sharp movement, wiping at the corners of her eyes with the back of her hand.
"Mimi..." he murmured, stepping closer with a sigh.
"You know you can talk to us, Mims," Lua said gently, opening her arms for a hug. But Victoria shrank back, shaking her head. "What happened?"
"Nothing, I just fell!" she insisted again, which made RSB exhale sharply in frustration and Lua give a weary smile.
"Why don’t you trust us? We’re your friends!" he snapped, voice cutting through the arcade’s bleeps and bloops. His heart was pounding hard enough to burst, furious.
Victoria slowly straightened her spine, her expression hardening with every breath. Her eyes, once frightened, now flared with fury.
"I knew I shouldn’t have come!" she spat, casting one last scathing look at the two of them before shoving her sunglasses on and storming toward the exit.
"Victoria!" RSB made a move to go after her, but a group of excitable girls blocked his path. "Mimi!"
Lua shrugged, tying her hair up into a ponytail as she shot a look of disdain at the fangirls crowding around RSB, trying to strike up conversation. She shooed them all off before helping him search for Victoria, scanning the second floor of the shopping centre with sharp eyes—but she was already gone.
"Yeah... congratulations," she said, feigning enthusiasm as she gave RSB a shake by the shoulders. "Now all that’s left is to beat that SOB bloke’s record..."
RSB let out a long sigh, his thin lips pressed into a hard line. He ran a hand through his short, black hair, fixing his fringe before staring at his reflection in a shop window. Despite the victory, he felt like a bloody loser. He dropped the skateboard to the ground with a clatter.
"You were a bit out of line back there," Lua said offhandedly, nudging the nose of the board with her foot as she leaned against the mezzanine railing. "Didn’t have to go that far."
"It’s not the first time, Luana." He used her full name like she wasn’t grasping the seriousness of it.
"It’s just... I don’t think it’s easy for her," the girl retorted with the same sharp edge.
"I never said I thought it was. I just... why does she keep lying? It’s obvious that—"
"If it were you in her shoes, would you tell anyone?" Luana cut him off, wetting her full lips.
RSB shook his head, resting one foot on the skateboard and rocking it back and forth.
"I don’t know. I’ve never been through anything like that," he admitted, stuffing his hands into the pockets of his jeans.
"Yeah, exactly." Lua gave a knowing smile, which made RSB shrug dismissively. "Why are you so on edge lately? Never seen you like this... is it because of The Prophet today?"
"What?" RSB felt his cheeks flush as he glanced down toward the lower floor. "No, why are you all asking me that? What’s even in The Prophet?"
"If it’s not the paper, then what’s got you acting like this?" Luana ignored his question, drumming her nails against the iron railing.
"Acting like what?!" RSB snapped, his lips pressed tight, clearly thrown.
Luana stared at him for a long moment, narrowing her eyes as though trying to read something buried between the lines. She shrugged, fiddled idly with the charms on her chains, and exhaled slowly as she watched the shoppers below. RSB clicked his tongue.
"Just say it, Lua," he said, nudging her with his elbow.
"You fancy her, don’t you?!" Luana grinned, all mockery.
"What? No!" RSB’s voice came out higher than usual, and his face flushed crimson. "Where the fuck did you get that from?!"
"By Merlin’s balls, you like her!" She slapped a hand to her mouth in mock shock, then grabbed his shoulder with glee. "Since when?"
"I don’t... I don’t... I don’t fancy her!" RSB stammered, scandalised by the absurdity of the accusation, wriggling free of her grip.
"Since when?" Luana pressed, leaning on the railing with her elbows, amusement dancing across her face.
"Oh, piss off..." he muttered, hopping onto his skateboard and pushing off.
"Running away?!" she called after him, hands on her hips.
RSB didn’t even bother to look back, flipping her the middle finger as he weaved through the shoppers. A security guard immediately started after him, shouting that skateboarding was forbidden inside the shopping centre.
He didn’t so much as flinch, slipping on his headphones and pressing play on the Walkman.
[Song: Rainbow — Do You Close Your Eyes]
"Regulus Black is in loooove!" Luana sang out behind him before bursting into loud, unrestrained laughter.
Mystery to me is something I can't see
But I see you very well
You slinky, cool, nobody's fool
But there's something inside I can tell
Regulus picked up speed, weaving expertly between people and obstacles. His balance was flawless, and the security guards fell farther and farther behind. Some people chuckled, others tutted in disapproval—but Regulus couldn’t care less. A mischievous grin played on his lips as he neared the exit, just as the automatic doors slid open.
I know a poor man, a rich man
I know I can talk to a king
But nobody here is gonna tell me
I can't find out one thing
His eyes locked onto the final obstacle: a long staircase with a perfect rail for a grind. Without slowing, he aligned his board and, with inhuman precision, launched into a smooth grind down the entire length. The manoeuvre was so flawlessly executed it earned a round of applause from onlookers.
As he landed, a wave of muggy heat slapped him across the face. The sun wasn’t just blazing—it seemed hell-bent on scorching everyone alive. He skidded to a halt, adjusted his headphones, and pushed off again.
I see your glow around you
Open your arms
'Cause I'm walking to you, coming straight or through
Maybe I'm wrong but I know it won't take long to see
Regulus propelled himself forward, the skateboard glued to his feet, launching off the curb to cross the empty street, then again to hop onto the opposite pavement. Despite his speed, the suffocating heat clung to him—there was barely any breeze, and what little there was felt like a hairdryer to the face.
His mind was racing. What Luana had said made absolutely no sense—he wasn’t in love with Mimi. She was his childhood best mate, his next-door neighbour. He bloody well knew she fancied Cedric Diggory and even Harry Potter—especially those sodding green eyes of his.
Do you close your eyes
Do you close your eyes
Do you close your eyes
When you're making love? Yeah, yeah
Making sweet love to me, yeah
Not that Regulus was jealous, of course. He clearly didn’t feel that burning twist in his chest or that sudden dampness in his palms every time she mentioned the boys she fancied. Nor did he make a habit of booting over the second-years’ gobstones game whenever he left the clock tower courtyard after one of her rambling crush rants.
Mimi was his best friend—just like Luana. It was completely normal for him to like her. But that was it… liking her. As a mate.
Right?
The logical trend is that I'll know in the end
The things that make you smile
To right from the start, I'll take an aim at your heart
And know that all the while
He sighed, bending his knees as he approached a park bench, prepping for a flashier trick. With a precise push, he launched himself into a perfect kickflip, the board spinning cleanly beneath him before he landed it smoothly and continued gliding forward without missing a beat.
I know a rich man, a poor man
I know I can talk to a king, yeah
So nobody here is gonna make me believe
I can't find out one thing
The music in his ears was pure fuel, and he was especially obsessed with Rainbow. According to his Uncle Remus, he’d been listening to them since he was in nappies and never stopped. He had all their tapes—including a super rare release he’d inherited from his parents.
I see your glow around you
Open your arms
'Cause I'm coming, running, straight or through
I could be wrong but I know it won't take long to see
London summers had always been hot, but today was downright hellish. Regulus felt the sweat trickling down behind his ears and along his neck, already regretting the jeans. Should’ve gone out in shorts—but he always chose style over comfort. He cruised around a fountain full of playing children and continued until he reached a crossing, where he picked up his skateboard and waited for the light to change.
His Uncle Remus didn’t live far from the shopping centre. Technically, the house was Regulus’s too, though he still stayed with his aunt and uncle in a place further out from central London. Remus’s home, on the other hand, was much more central—bit of a gem, really.
Do you close your eyes
Do you close your eyes
Do you close your eyes
When you're making love?
It didn’t take long for him to reach the place. He came to a stop, grabbing his board as he jogged up the front steps. Panting, the sun roasting the back of his neck, he rang the bell a few times. Then he pulled the headphones down around his neck and paused the tape just before Stargazer could kick in.
"Uncle?!" he called, trying to peer through the glass of the front door—but he couldn’t see a thing.
He looked both ways down the street, crouched down, retrieved the key from beneath the wisteria pot, and let himself in without ceremony. He stomped his trainers on the doormat and crossed the foyer, greeted by the refreshing cool air inside.
Regulus left the skateboard in a corner and craned his neck towards the kitchen, only to find it empty. He downed a good amount of cold water before walking into the living room, letting his sweaty fingers brush across the black cover draped over the grand piano. His eyes scanned the mantelpiece, the trio of sofas arranged around the telly, and the corridor that led to the bedrooms.
"Uncle?!" he called out again.
No response. He was alone.
Regulus trailed his dirty fingers along the bedroom doors, pushing open the last one gingerly: a dusty, long-abandoned studio. Some equipment still remained—the drum toms and a couple of synths set further back. A broken amp sat next to a shattered frame holding the cover of Toto’s first album, and in one corner lay a worn-out, grimy kitten plushie.
He closed the door, checking the clock. Nearly four in the afternoon. Remus should’ve been back by now. Regulus took a deep breath and wiped the sweat from his brow with the back of his hand. Growing impatient, he took a few steps back and opened the door to another room—one with a large double bed strewn with clothes.
It had been left like that for twelve years, and it always struck Regulus how nothing ever changed. The dragon-hide leather jacket still lay gleaming and untouched atop the blanket, the aviator sunglasses beside it. His eyes drifted to the dresser in the corner, where a handful of magical photographs moved in slow, eerie loops.
Regulus sighed, stepped into the bathroom, and splashed water on his face. He stared at his reflection in the mirror—at the freckles across his nose, the grey-blue of his eyes, and the mess of sweat-damp hair from skating. His cheeks were flushed, definitely sunburnt from the harsh exposure on the way over.
He dried his face, opened the cabinet drawer, and found a cream that had expired years ago. Cracking it open, a soft vanilla scent hit his nose, making him smile faintly before tucking it back away. He really should’ve just left the room and not touched anything—his uncle had always asked him not to.
But Remus wasn’t home.
Regulus stripped off and stepped into the shower, letting the cold water wash the sweat from his skin. He skimmed through the dozens of magical cosmetics lined up on the shelves, eventually reaching for one that looked bizarre and smelled even worse. He gave up on the lot when he realised most were long past their expiry date—after all, when was the last time anyone had used them?
Twelve years?!
He stepped out of the shower and soaked the entire bathroom while fumbling around for a towel, eventually wrapping himself in one. Opening the drawers, he found a faded David Bowie T-shirt and pulled it on, along with a pair of chain-covered jeans that fit him perfectly—as if they’d been made for him, though they clearly weren’t. He grabbed his watch from the pocket of his old jeans and slipped it into the new pair.
Regulus left his hair wet, brushing the fringe to the side in that way that always made the fourth-year girls sigh. Did Mimi like his hair like this? He rolled his eyes at the thought, scooping up his sweaty clothes and shoving them into a plastic bag before sprawling himself across his uncle’s sofa.
He reached an arm toward the coffee table, trying to grab the telly remote. But a copy of The Daily Prophet lay in the way, and he couldn’t help but freeze as his eyes landed on the enormous photo splashed across the front page: a gaunt-faced man with long, tangled hair blinked slowly at Regulus.
BLACK ESCAPES!
Sirius Black, possibly the most infamous prisoner ever to be held in Azkaban fortress, has escaped. The information was confirmed today by the Ministry of Magic. “We are doing all we can to recapture Black,” said the Minister of Magic, Cornelius Fudge, this morning, “and we beg the magical community to remain calm.” Fudge has been criticized by some members of the International Federation of Warlocks for informing the Muggle Prime Minister of the crisis.
“Well, really, I had to, don’t you know,” said an irritable Fudge. “Black is mad. He’s a danger to anyone who crosses him, magic or Muggle. I have the Prime Minister’s assurance that he will not breathe a word of Black’s true identity to anyone. And let’s face it — who’d believe him if he did?” While Muggles have been told that Black is carrying a gun (a kind of metal wand that Muggles use to kill each other), the magical community lives in fear of a massacre like that of twelve years ago, when Black murdered thirteen people with a single curse.
It became hard to swallow when Sirius's eyes—fierce even in print—seemed to pierce straight through him. Regulus gasped, as if he’d just finished a long run, and turned his face away sharply. His heart pounded painfully in his chest. Soft, distant memories echoed in his mind, sending shivers racing across his skin.
He didn’t realise he was crying. Didn’t notice the breath catching in his throat or how the air seemed to vanish from the room. He stood, his muscles stiff with tension. His gaze immediately shot toward the small cord that dangled from the ceiling—leading to the attic.
His fingers tingled. His pulse faltered. He looked toward the front door, then back to the hallway, the battle inside him raging violently.
Then he gave in to the impulse.
He crossed the hallway and tugged the cord, unfolding the ladder with a dull creak.
The one place he was strictly forbidden to go. The attic.
Regulus had never been the type to break family rules—though doing it at Hogwarts was bloody brilliant fun. He gripped the ladder with both hands, eyes lingering for a moment on the Signet etched onto his left hand. A hereditary mark, almost like a tattoo: two serpents intertwining into the shape of an infinity symbol, each biting the other’s tail in a circle.
He climbed up and was immediately hit by the sharp scent of dust. Drawing his wand from his pocket, he whispered, "Lumos," and light illuminated the triangular space, full of cobwebs and mystery. Boxes were stacked everywhere—some labelled, others not. Regulus grimaced and crawled over to the nearest one, where Scarlett was scrawled in bold letters on a strip of tape.
He opened the box, sneezing as the pungent stench of mildew wafted up. Hundreds of vinyl records were packed inside, along with all sorts of random trinkets. He thumbed through a stack of what looked like polaroids, flipping the top one over.
It showed a woman with black hair and striking blue eyes, laughing as she hugged an enormous black dog. It was a magical photo, and as the dog licked her face, she pulled away with a comical grimace. Regulus found himself smiling in spite of everything, gently brushing his fingers over her face. His heartbeat slowed, the anger melting into something else—something quieter, older. Nostalgia, though he couldn’t place the memory.
He just knew it felt good.
Because now he was crying again—but for a completely different reason.
He turned the photo over. A messy scrawl read:
Scarlett and Padfoot, summer of '78.
Regulus traced a finger over Scarlett’s name and slid the photo into his pocket.
Then he picked up the next one.
Scarlett was being held in the arms of a tall, bearded man with shoulder-length black hair and tattoos covering his arms and chest. The wind blew through his hair, and he wore the very same aviator sunglasses Regulus had seen on the bed earlier. The man leaned down to kiss Scarlett with the kind of passion that made her arms tighten around his neck, her legs stretching with the contact. They were on a beach. They were smiling. The photo repeated the kiss in an endless loop.
Regulus choked on his own spit, as if he'd just taken a punch to the gut. His fingers clenched the edge of the photograph so tightly his knuckles turned white. He flipped it over.
Scarius, summer of '78, Brighton.
Suddenly, the attic felt too hot, too tight, too full. Regulus shot up, cracking his head against the sloped ceiling with a loud thud. Dust rained into his eyes and he winced, shaking his head as he scrambled backwards, patting the floor blindly until he found the stairs. He clambered down, gasping for breath, brushing the grime off his clothes in jerky, frantic motions.
He needed another shower.
Regulus sneezed, coughed, and darted back to the bathroom, splashing water over his face again. He hadn’t even realised he was still holding the photos. When he looked up, he saw one of them in the mirror, lying on the counter.
The sound of the front door opening made his heart thump louder than it already was, his emotions colliding in a chaotic blur. Regulus grabbed the polaroids and made his way slowly toward the living room, his mind a furnace of wild thoughts.
"Reg? You're home already?!" Remus’s voice carried in from the kitchen as he set down a bunch of shopping bags. He entered the living room with a smile on his face. "How was the arcade?"
Regulus’s reply was to hurl the photograph onto the copy of the Daily Prophet with Sirius Black’s face staring up from the front page.
Remus’s smile vanished instantly. The colour drained from his face, and his dark eyes widened slightly as he stepped closer, gaze flicking between the photo and the paper.
"They loved each other!" Regulus let the fury pour out, his voice cracking under the weight of emotion. "All these years—you lied to me!"
"You went up into the attic?!" Remus’s tone was accusatory, his eyes darting toward the hallway. His expression faltered when he saw the ladder still extended.
"Don’t you dare try to change the subject!" Regulus roared, rage washing over him in a blinding wave, breaking through the layers of self-control and dragging more tears to the surface. "Why did you lie to me?!"
"I didn’t—" Remus drew in a very deep breath, then another. He pressed his fingers hard against his temples. "Regulus… can we maybe not do this today? The moon—"
"Oh, for Merlin’s sake, you’ve lied to me my whole life and now you want to wait for the bloody lunar phase before you decide to tell me the truth?!" Regulus snapped, his voice ragged as he gestured wildly, barely keeping himself together.
"Reg, please… I…" Remus let out all the air in his lungs, scratching at the grey in his beard. "I was hired. I’m going to be your professor…"
"She died. And still… still you don’t want to talk about her. Uncle Orfy won’t talk about her. Nate won’t talk about her. But I want to—I deserve to!" Regulus rubbed at his eyes, trying to stop the tears from stinging. "Why?!"
"Reg…"
"It can’t be that the only thing she ever was… was a Death Eater!" Regulus pressed on, sniffling. "Why didn’t you tell me the truth? What happened between them?"
"Reg… Scarlett and Sirius, they…" Remus’s bottom lip trembled. He was putting up a herculean effort not to cry himself, running his finger over the scars on his face as he tried to explain something he barely understood himself.
Regulus waited. Remus didn’t continue. He just exhaled shakily and buried his face in his hands.
"You went into his room," Remus murmured at last, after a long silence, not daring to meet his gaze.
Regulus let out a bitter laugh, shoving the photo back into his pocket before jabbing a finger toward his uncle’s face.
"You’re unbelievable, Lupin!" he spat, then stormed over to his skateboard. He snatched it up in anger, grabbed his bag of clothes, and looked at Remus one last time. "I thought…" he gasped for air, feeling like he couldn’t breathe, "I thought you, of all people, would tell me the truth. You were their friend, Uncle. I… I remember him. I was young, but I remember him. He used to sing to me, that’s why I love Rainbow so much, because he…"
"Regulus… he betrayed us. They both did. The McKinnons, the Potters—"
"For Merlin’s sake, can’t you see past that?!" Regulus screamed, the tears scorching hot down his cheeks. "You know what? Go fuck yourself!" he hissed, plunging his hand into the Floo powder on the hearth.
"Regulus!" his uncle cried out—less of a scolding and more of a plea.
But Regulus didn’t stay to hear whatever else Remus had to say. Not like he was going to tell him the truth anyway. He stepped into the fireplace, letting the emerald flames swallow him whole, and emerged in his own house—nearly colliding with his Uncle Orfeu, who was reading the paper in his armchair.
"Reg?" Orfeu folded the paper shut at once, as though terrified his nephew might see the headline. "You’re back already? I thought you were having dinner with Remus—"
"No… I’m not having dinner with him," Regulus muttered bitterly, dropping his skateboard to the floor and kicking off, rolling slowly towards his room.
"Hey, what did we say about skating indoors?!" Orfeu shouted, but was promptly ignored. "Regulus Sirius Black!" he called out, more sharply.
"Leave me alone!" Regulus bellowed, hurling his clothes into the laundry basket with force. He grabbed his gloves and pulled them on, shooting a sideways glance at the door just as his uncle opened it.
"What happened, Reggie?!" Orfeu leaned on the doorframe, his face knotted with worry, dark brown hair tied back in a loose, half-done ponytail. "Is it about the paper? About… Sirius?"
Regulus swiped his arm across his face, wanting nothing more than to dig his nails into his cheeks and tear the flesh away until this burning ache in his chest disappeared. He looked at Orfeu, trying—failing—to hide what he was feeling.
He pulled the photo from his pocket and held it up.
Orfeu went pale. His green eyes darted instantly to the ceiling, and he recoiled.
"That wasn’t her, Reg," he said, barely above a whisper, but the grief in his voice hit Regulus like a punch to the chest.
"They loved each other."
"Scarlett loved Regulus," he corrected quickly, his voice vibrating with dread. "Not Sirius."
"They looked happy in this photo."
"Oh, Reg, she was good at pretending. She could make you believe anything. She was manipulative… she was…" Orfeu’s fingers slid up the sleeve of his long shirt, brushing against the burn scars that laced his arm. "It was her fault. She wasn’t a good person. The only good thing she ever did… was you."
Regulus shook his head slowly.
"I don’t believe you. You lied to me, just like Remus. Who’s to say you’re not lying now too?!" he spat, shoving past his uncle and storming out of the room. "You, Nate, Remus… three bloody liars!"
"Reggie…" Orfeu murmured, eyes squeezing shut as the boy slammed the front door behind him.
Regulus bounded down the steps outside his home, then sank down onto the concrete ledge at the front. He hugged his legs to his chest and rested his chin on his knees, rewinding his Rainbow tape, trying to drown out Orfeu’s words, repeating to himself over and over that it was all lies.
He needed it to be lies. His mother couldn’t be a monster—not when everyone already said she was. Not when the Slytherin bastards congratulated him for being the son of Death Eaters, for the murder of the McKinnons, for the murder of the Potters…
He wiped away the last of his tears as the sun dipped between the rooftops, sinking into the horizon and casting skeletal shadows across the pavement. His head ached, his eyes burned, and his chest smoked like it might burst. He pulled the photo from his pocket again, gently rubbing a thumb over Scarlett’s face.
The urge to cry rose once more.
He swallowed hard as a cluster of white-haired heads came into view, quickly trying to wipe away the evidence of tears before Victoria climbed the steps beside her brothers: Vinny, the eldest; Vin, the middle one; and Victoria’s twin, Victor. All of them were Slytherins, like Regulus. He’d known them his entire life, though he never cared much for the older two.
"Alright, Reg?" Vinny gave a smug little smirk. Regulus eyed his knuckles, searching for something that might incriminate him.
"Hey, Vinny," Regulus replied casually, greeting him with a quick slap of hands. Vin came next—nothing on him either.
Victor gave a small nod, and Victoria lingered, watching the trio head through the door right next to Regulus’s—their houses were semi-detached.
"What happened?" she asked, her tone laced with concern as she touched his shoulder lightly. Regulus stared at her slender fingers and long nails before raising his gaze to her face—the face that made his heart splinter into a thousand tiny pieces. And to the bruise that turned his chest to molten stone.
Victoria had the kind of beauty pure-blood families prized: refined brows, a sharp nose, a delicate chin, lips shaped like a heart—velvety and red, inviting. Regulus swallowed thickly, feeling foolish.
"Nothing," he lied, looking away toward the empty street.
"You read The Prophet," she guessed, leaning on the ledge in front of him. "Look, Reg… if you want—"
"I'm fine," Regulus cut her off, pretending to be far too interested in fiddling with his Walkman to look at her. "Just needed some air."
"I thought you were having dinner with your uncle Lupin," she went on. The streetlamps flickered on, casting long shadows across her face, turning her eyes to deep brown.
"I was." It was all he said.
Victoria’s fingers slipped from his shoulder, trailing down to his knee, gently guiding his face toward hers by the chin.
"Reg…"
"Are you going to tell me the truth?" Regulus didn’t even try to hide the bitterness in his voice.
Victoria sighed, licked her lips, and gave him two soft pats on the shoulder.
"You know I can’t," she murmured, glancing nervously toward the door of her house. "Either way…"
"Just go, Victoria. Leave me alone," Regulus snapped. He regretted it immediately. All he really wanted was for her to stay. But if she wasn’t going to tell him the truth, then he wouldn’t give her his either. Not even she could fill the gaping hole in his chest—a feeling that had haunted him since he was a child. It wouldn’t change now, not just because Sirius was on the run.
She twisted her lips in annoyance and slipped into her house. Regulus gave himself a couple of light slaps to the face, feeling like a complete idiot.
If it were Harry Potter, she would’ve told him!
A strange chill crept down the back of his neck, giving him the unmistakable feeling of being watched. But when he glanced both ways down the street, there was no one. Somewhere in the distance, a bin clattered to the ground and a few dogs barked, but nothing seemed out of place. He shook off the feeling and returned to his own personal mess, pulling his silver watch from his pocket and clenching it in his palm until it hurt.
It pissed him off how often he was compared to Harry Potter. He’d never even spoken to the bloke, but of course they’d both ended up at the centre of gossip when the Chamber of Secrets had been opened the year before. And again—Harry, the son of celebrated wizards who’d died fighting Voldemort. And Regulus?
He was the son of two Death Eaters.
And yet, he and Harry had more in common than people liked to admit. Regulus had grown up with his uncles too. He’d been the target of cruel whispers, even accused of being the Heir of Slytherin. He hated how quick people were to believe he was dangerous just because of his bloodline.
He pulled the photo from his pocket and opened his watch. Inside was the old family portrait—his mother sitting stiffly in a chair, dressed in Victorian-style robes, her face set in a mournful scowl as if attending a funeral. His father stood behind her, one hand on her shoulder, equally stern. Like it was all just a formality.
He turned his eyes to the photo from the attic, where his mother looked so genuinely happy it made his chest twist. He exhaled slowly, fingers brushing across her smiling face, the sorrow hitting him like a punch to the gut.
Regulus and Harry also shared one more thing in common: A godfather.
The fugitive, the murderer, the madman Sirius Black.
.
.
.
He was so, so, so tiny. His feet were barely the size of Sirius’s thumb, his little hands clinging desperately to his fingers as though searching for something— someone —to hold onto. Sirius gasped, adjusting the collar of his T-shirt like it was choking him, though it was the vertigo, the overwhelming sensation crashing over him, that made it hard to breathe.
“S-S-Sirius… Regulus…” Scarlett stammered, her bloodied fingertips clinging to his elbow. “Regulus… Sirius…” she repeated, pupils blown wide. “Black.”
Sirius’s stomach churned as he was ushered out of the surgery room by the healers, heart hammering in his chest with something so small and fragile cradled against it. He looked down at the black tuft of hair crowning baby Reggie’s head, at the little mouth that puckered and blew bubbles, then stretched into a wild, messy smile.
He had never wanted anything more in his life than for a child to be his.
Still reeling from what had just happened, his clothes soaked in Scarlett’s blood, his body trembling with the crash of adrenaline, Sirius could hardly process it all.
“Regulus Sirius, huh?” he murmured to the tiny baby, as if he could understand. Reggie reached up with his tiny arms, grabbing a handful of Sirius’s hair and tugging it gently. Just like his mother, Reg had a Signet on his left hand. “You like my hair?”
A single teardrop fell onto Regulus’s cheek, and Sirius quickly wiped it away. He hadn’t even noticed his own eyes brimming—tears washing away the fury, the bitterness, everything he’d felt until now, drowned by something as pure as a newborn’s breath.
“Are you the father?” one of the nurses asked, clipboard in hand, quill poised mid-air as she eyed him.
He had never wanted to say yes to anything more.
His jaw clenched. He licked his lips.
“Uncle,” he corrected her, forcing the word out like it tasted wrong.
“Oh,” she said, raising her brows as she flipped through a few pages on the clipboard. “Sirius Orion Black?”
“That’s right.” He heard a small grunt from baby Reggie and glanced down with concern—but the baby had already fallen asleep in his arms, breathing softly.
“You’re listed as the child’s godfather,” the nurse noted, handing him the quill. “According to your brother’s will.”
“What?” The floor seemed to tilt under him. His knees went weak. “Godfather?”
“That’s correct. Has the mother chosen the name?”
“Regulus Sirius Black,” Sirius answered, the words tumbling from his mouth before he could stop them—too dazed to do anything else but stand there, holding the child like his own world was unraveling.
He looked down at Reggie again, his chest churning with a hundred contradictory emotions. He should hate this child. He should’ve walked away, refused to help Scarlett, run from the war and all of it. Regulus Sirius was the living proof of betrayal—Scarlett’s betrayal, and his brother’s.
Scarlett, ever cruel, had named the boy after him.
So why, then, was every instinct in Sirius screaming to protect this baby? Even from himself?
He was so… delicate. Defenceless. He had Scarlett’s nose.
Something foul and burning twisted in his gut. Bile clawed at his throat.
He had never envied his brother more than he did in that moment.
Sirius had never wished so desperately that the child were his.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Notes:
For those who didn’t catch it, all the mentions of Reggie in the Azkaban conversations were about Scarlett’s son Reggie—not Red, Sirius’s brother.
If you ever reread Act I, the Azkaban dialogues will make total sense now.
Chapter 2: Why don’t we make believe that we’re sorry?
Summary:
Whiskers and Padfoot are on the run
Chapter Text
LXX
[Song: Toto — Make Believe]
The moonlight filtered through the swaying pines. Whiskers bristled her tuxedo fur, peering between the roots, staying downwind so the mouse wouldn’t catch her scent. Tensing her back paws and readying herself in full alert, her pupils widened to see better in the dark.
Why don't we make believe we're in love again?
Who said the crimson moon doesn't shine?
Where do people go when they're lookin' for that
One of a kind?
Whiskers gave a little wiggle, raised her tail, and pounced, catching the tiny mouse, her mouth watering as the taste of blood hit her tongue. Proud of herself, she perked her ears, catching the heavy footsteps of Padfoot not far off.
She wanted to eat the animal on her own, but perhaps Padfoot needed the food more—he was much larger than she was, and they’d been running for days to put distance between them and Azkaban. Whiskers slinked through the tree roots silently; after all, she wasn’t the only predator out that night. The forest was dense and dark, but it didn’t take her long to spot the pale light cast by their ghosts.
Why don't we make believe that we're sorry?
Why must we hold it all inside?
Where do lovers go when they're runnin' and there's no
Place to hide?
Prongs was bounding about, keeping pace with Padfoot. Regulus and Lily were a little further off, trying to navigate using the stars. As she neared the group, Whiskers felt a bit self-conscious seeing that Padfoot had hunted down a massive boar. He, too, seemed to expect to share dinner with her, his ears twitching subtly at the sight of the little mouse in the cat’s mouth.
Impressed—and slightly intimidated—by the size of the prey, Whiskers ate the mouse and joined in on the boar, after a decade and a half of consuming nothing but that vile Azkaban slop. Her mouth watered and, for a moment, she could hardly chew; the hunger still ached even after she was full. To remember the taste of meat was like tasting the nectar of the gods—that meal was the best thing she’d ever eaten in her life.
At least, as far as she could recall. Which wasn’t much. She remembered foods, what she liked and disliked, but not the taste itself. Once properly fed, Whiskers and Padfoot began looking for a place to rest and digest their meal.
The day we met in the pouring rain
We went our separate ways
No matter which way the wind blows now
Hang on to it anyhow
Don't ever say it could never be the same
Whiskers noticed that Padfoot kept licking his hip obsessively, trying to mask the limp in his gait. Concerned, she attempted to approach for a closer look, but as she did, Padfoot let out a low growl—a clear signal for her to keep her distance.
Whiskers lowered her ears and tail, signalling that she meant no harm. Padfoot sniffed the top of her head, licked her ears, then turned his face sharply toward a suspicious sound. They bolted through the forest, breaking into a vast grassy field.
Why don't we make believe we're in love again?
Who said the crimson moon doesn't shine?
Where do people go when they're lookin' for that
One of a kind?
The wind brushed through the grasses, swaying them like waves stirred by the tide. Padfoot wagged his tail and barked at Whiskers before sprinting into the tall grass and crouching down low. Whiskers didn’t immediately understand what he was up to—until she caught him watching her intently, then dashing forward to nudge her head with his snout before darting off again at full speed.
Whiskers huffed, ears perking up as she ducked beneath the undergrowth, hiding herself and tuning in to the sound of Padfoot’s heavy breathing. Once she located him, she quickly nipped at his heel and took off, prompting the dog to give a little leap and chase after her across the clearing.
Why don't we make believe that we're sorry?
Why must we hold it all inside?
Where do lovers go when they're runnin' and there's no
Place to hide?"
It was strange, simply knowing she could go anywhere she pleased, whenever she wanted. The feeling of freedom was so intense it made Whiskers dizzy. She flopped into the grass, abandoning the game of escape from Padfoot. He, too, lay down beside her, rolling in the plants and panting heavily.
Holding hands on a summer day
(No more pretendin')
You took it all away
I didn't come here to change your mind
Lead you on or waste your time
All alone in the evening?
The sky above them was a show in itself. The surrounding darkness sharpened the milky dust stretched across the night’s canvas, where the stars sparkled at their brightest. Whiskers narrowed her eyes slightly, the soft breeze brushing her fur, the scents of the night confirming they were alone in the middle of nowhere.
Why don't we make believe?
Whiskers tilted her snout slightly to the side, gazing at Padfoot. His grey eyes scanned the sky, and she quickly looked away when their eyes met—only to notice tiny stars flickering between them.
Stars?
No… not stars.
Fireflies.
Scarlett watched, stunned, as the tiny insects fluttered around her face, one landing on her nose. The touch was subtle, strange—their little legs felt rough against her skin. She froze, eyes wide, hands trembling. Her heart stuttered in her chest.
She heard a snort and her gaze immediately snapped to the side, locking onto Sirius. The fireflies had settled in his long black hair, and for a moment, it looked as though they were mirroring the starry sky.
His grey irises shimmered as if they were absorbing all the light those tiny creatures emitted, as if they were igniting everything that the time they'd spent apart had failed to extinguish, as if the spark of that thing between them—the thing that clawed at them and caressed them—was still… alive. Latent, dormant, nearly gone.
Why don't we make believe that we're sorry?
Why must we hold it all inside?
Where do lovers go when they're runnin' and there's no
Place to hide?
But it was still there, as if all those fourteen years apart hadn’t been enough. Nothing was. Nothing could smother the erratic beats of their hearts, the sweat on their fingers, the looks brimming with unspoken hope.
There was so much stuck in their throats, but neither of them wanted to let it out. They were free from Azkaban, yet not free from their demons, their guilt, or their crimes. Not free from the hatred… nor from the love.
Why don't we make believe?
It was raw. It stung and burned, but it also soothed, uplifted, calmed. Scarlett held her breath when Sirius’s tattooed pinky brushed against hers. It was a gentle touch, nearly nonexistent, yet it awakened a hundred sensations in her body she barely remembered. A warm pulse quivered through her muscles, dilated her pupils, sent a shiver up her neck.
With his other hand, Sirius reached out, extending his index finger to the tip of her nose, gently brushing away the firefly perched there. The creature took flight, and Sirius's eyes followed it until it melted into the stars above.
A shadow of a smile crossed Sirius’s lips. His expression softened slowly, the silver in his gaze rippling with something Scarlett couldn’t quite name. Then he turned serious, the grass dancing between them as the gentle breeze brushed their cheeks. Her stomach flipped.
"I’m not going to hurt you," Sirius murmured, his eyes locked on hers.
Scarlett tensed, her hands turning to stone as Sirius’s pinky looped around hers in a slow, deliberate, measured movement.
"You should," she whispered, so softly that the wind carried her words away with ease.
The silver in his gaze crawled and wavered, swallowed by the shadows cast by Sirius’s long lashes. His lips parted slowly, and he drew in a breath, as if weighing what to say.
“You… did you really want to? Come back?” he asked, brow furrowing, his eyes glinting with a mix of excitement and guilt.
Scarlett nodded softly, Sirius’s handsome face blurring as tears spilled over, forcing her to rub her eyes. He took a deep breath, still not letting go of her pinky, simply gazing at the sky, torn between staying still or reaching out to comfort her.
But Sirius was human, and the pain Scarlett had caused him wasn’t easily healed—let alone forgotten. So, he did nothing. He should’ve been shouting at her, hurting her, just as she’d suggested. Sirius wasn’t cruel, not anymore—he had once been cruel to someone he loved, and the outcome had been catastrophic.
And as much as he hated Scarlett with every fibre of his being, there was still a part of him that loved her. A piece the Dementors hadn’t managed to rip away, a fracture he himself couldn’t mend. It was stronger than him, like it was etched into his soul, woven into his very core, his heart.
“I’m sorry,” Scarlett said again, wiping the tears with the sleeve of her pyjamas.
Sirius pressed his lips together and nodded.
“I know.” He released her hand. Those words had stirred something deep inside him—something he wasn’t ready to face. “Me too.”
Then Sirius shifted back into Padfoot. It was easier to exist with all that had happened in the dog’s skin, where things weren’t so complicated, where his emotions weren’t tangled, where hate wasn’t laced with the thorns of love.
The fireflies vanished, plunging them into a darkness not even the stars could dispel. Scarlett curled into herself and became Whiskers once more.
They slept.
They barely noticed the sun rise, the birdsong, the scent of dew. Whiskers was so cosy in her soft, fluffy bed she could’ve slept for days. But the bed disagreed—it dumped her onto the cold grass, jolting her awake as she tried to make sense of what had happened.
Padfoot gave her head a brief lick, and only then did she realise her bed had been the dog himself. He gave a full-body shake, black fur rippling, and started sniffing the wind in search of breakfast. Whiskers let him hunt alone, still a bit dazed from the blissful night’s rest.
“You’re heading that way,” said Lily, pointing toward a rise in the grassy land, where a mountain stood in the distance. Whiskers yawned, stretching out, her eyes on her friend’s red hair as it danced in the breeze.
She looked around for her other ghosts, but Regulus and James seemed to be scouting the area. Lily sat beside her, hugging her knees, watching her with unease.
“Scarlett… you’re not going to kill him, are you? Peter.” She bit her lower lip. “I know what he did, but… you need him alive to prove Sirius’s innocence.”
Whiskers tilted her head to the side, as if seeing Lily from a different angle might help her better understand what she meant. It wasn’t her revenge, anyway. She’d leave it in Sirius’s hands.
Padfoot soon returned, carrying a massive bird. Whiskers ate, savouring every second of the salty flavour softening her taste buds, the food weighing down her stomach, making her feel alive. It was strange. In Azkaban, it was as if she’d been just a shell of herself. A… ghost.
After finishing the meal, Whiskers set the pace, following Lily’s direction. As they trekked through the forest, a clearing caught their attention with the sharp stench of rot. It wasn’t like the natural smells of the woods—it was… meat. Rotting meat.
They found a camp that looked like it had been attacked by a large creature. There were signs of a struggle and, more disturbingly, a few dead bodies. Whiskers narrowed her eyes, spotting James and Regulus inside one of the tents.
“Scarlett, come here!” James waved her over, and the cat padded through the grisly scene to where they were. “Look!” He pointed to a key, seemingly unbothered by whatever fate had befallen the dead.
Whiskers looked at James, tail swishing side to side.
“It’s a car key, Whiskers,” Regulus explained, pointing to a stuffed backpack. “Supplies. For your trip.”
Scarlett shifted back from her Animagus form and picked up the car key.
“I don’t remember how to drive,” she whispered, hoping Sirius didn’t hear her.
“I’ll help you,” James offered with a reassuring smile. “That way you’ll get there much faster… wherever it is you’re going, anyway?”
Scarlett snorted, shrugging. She hadn’t the faintest idea at the moment—she just wanted to get as far from Azkaban as possible. She opened the backpack and shoved in as many clothes as she could, then downed an entire bottle of water she found inside.
“But where’s the car?” Regulus stroked his chin, poking his head outside the tent. “You can’t see anything from here and I didn’t spot any roads along the way.”
“Just use Accio,” James rolled his eyes, as if the answer were painfully obvious. “It’ll show up in no time…”
James was right. Scarlett pulled her wand from the waistband of her trousers—her wand.
“She’s going to cast Accio on the car and get flattened by it…” Regulus elbowed James. “ …brilliant , Jay.”
“Well… I didn’t think that far ahead,” James laughed, taking off his glasses to rub his face.
“Yeah, I can tell,” Regulus retorted with a condescending tone, only to be shoved by James out of the tent. The two of them burst into laughter, tumbling into a scuffle with their feet tangled in the canvas. Scarlett watched it unfold with a strange detachment, the voices and laughter echoing in the back of her mind—memories tucked away in a dark, hidden box.
Since when had they become such good friends?
The wind rustled the tent and sunlight filtered through, casting a glare that made Scarlett squint. She turned sharply, instinctively on alert… but it was only a mirror. Slowly, she bent down, picked it up—and her eyes widened at the sight of her own reflection.
She looked awful. Sunken eyes, stretched cheeks, bloodless lips. She looked like a corpse. And her hair—more tangled than a bird’s nest. It was the first time she’d felt ashamed of her own appearance. Azkaban hadn’t stolen all her memories, but it had robbed her of a piece of her youth.
She still looked younger than she really was, even like this, but she bore marks that few her age carried. Her hands moved instinctively along her spine, where the scars from Azkaban had etched her suffering into flesh.
She shook her head to chase the thoughts away. Grabbing a hunting knife from the backpack, she pulled her hair forward and cut it just below her shoulders. Then she changed clothes—slipping into army trousers, a pair of boots, and a white tank top. She was so thin that the clothes looked oversized on her, even though they were a normal fit.
When she stepped out of the tent, she found Sirius standing in the middle of the extinguished campfire, staring at the corpses in horror.
“What are you doing?” His eyes scanned her with cold precision.
For a few seconds, Scarlett wondered the same.
“I… I…” she stammered, clearing her throat. It was strange, speaking to Sirius like that. It was strange being outside Azkaban. Everything felt like unfamiliar ground. “Gathering… supplies.”
“These people are dead and you’re robbing them?!” His voice was hoarse. Scarlett understood. It was strange for her too, speaking so much after years of barely speaking at all—to anyone but her ghosts.
“It’s not like they’ll need it,” Scarlett shrugged, slinging the backpack over her shoulder. “Do you want to catch Wormtail or not?!”
Sirius raised his eyebrows, as if her response had caught him off guard. Then he just breathed in deeply and nodded. He didn’t really know what he was doing either. The very idea of freedom was so distant, it had never even occurred to him to reach for it.
It didn’t take him long to return, now dressed in a pair of light-washed jeans and a colourful T-shirt that made James stifle a laugh.
“I don’t see… how changing clothes and grabbing all this stuff is going to help us. It’s much easier to move in Animagus form… especially with Dementors possibly on our tail,” Sirius panted, out of breath after speaking so much.
Scarlett raised the car key and gave it a shake, making him frown.
“You remember how to drive?” he asked, genuinely surprised.
“No, Sirius, but just leave it to Daddy here—he’s got it covered,” James said, pointing to himself with a cheeky grin.
“I think I’ve got it,” Scarlett ignored him, glancing around. “Now we just need to find where it is…”
“Here!” Lily called from somewhere between the trees. “It’s over here!”
“Can you Apparate?” Sirius remained detached from all the commotion caused by the ghosts.
Scarlett shook her head, licking her lips.
“I don’t know. I don’t think so.”
He bit the inside of his cheek, nodding slightly.
“I cast Evanesco on your things in the tent… it’s best if we erase all traces of ourselves here.” Sirius stretched his arms out, rolling up the sleeves of his shirt. Scarlett watched, hypnotised, as his tattoos came into view along with the burn scar.
She didn’t recognise most of the designs. There were moon phases, musical notes, dates...
Dates.
21.10.1978
31.07.1980
“Scar?” It wasn’t Sirius who pulled her from her daze. It was Regulus, appearing beside his brother. His ghostly glow was nearly drowned out by the sunlight streaming through the trees. “You alright?”
But Scarlett’s gaze remained fixed on Sirius. He’d finished rolling up the second sleeve and now stared back at her. He was so pale he looked like a vampire. His eyes had gone indifferent, his face wearing an impassive mask.
“I think the car’s over there,” Scarlett whispered, pointing in Lily’s direction. She climbed the incline and they walked through the trees until they found the vehicle parked in a patch of dirt, near a road.
The smell of damp earth made her feel a bit dizzy. The morning sounds filled the air so intensely it overwhelmed her—she wasn’t used to so much noise, not any that wasn’t the waves crashing against Azkaban’s stone walls. It was disorienting to realise the world was so much more than that dark, hellish hole.
“Slot the key in the door,” James instructed, and Scarlett did as told. She unlocked the doors while Sirius scanned the surroundings and the sky, as if expecting the weather to suddenly darken and the Dementors to descend upon them.
The sky, however, was blue and clear, the sun shining in all its brilliance. Scarlett sat in the driver’s seat, running her hand across the cold dashboard. It felt strange to settle into something as comfortable as that leather seat.
Outside, Sirius leaned against the car, watching Scarlett move as if guided by some strange instinct. He placed his hand on the car’s handle and opened the door, lowering himself into the back seat. He ran his fingers along the leather, picking up a crumpled piece of paper that had been tucked there.
A map.
Sirius stepped out of the car again, eyes locking onto a nearby sign showing mileage. He searched for it on the tiny lines of the map, finally finding it in the far north. Pressing a dirty finger to the spot, he traced the route endlessly southward to England. They were far from London—it would take at least a full day of non-stop travel.
The car engine’s rumble grated in his ears, making him clutch the map tighter in his hands. Sirius still felt too dazed from the escape to act with any real clarity, and he was quietly thankful that Scarlett had taken the lead.
He got back in, set the map on the passenger seat, and lay down across the back, folding his long legs and staring up at the mildewed ceiling. Scarlett avoided looking at him, shifting gears just as James had instructed. But the car stalled.
“You’ve got to push the clutch harder…” James leaned over the dashboard, watching how Scarlett was using the pedals. “Now press the gearstick… put it in reverse…”
Scarlett sighed, knowing she couldn’t say anything back to her friend. She didn’t want Sirius thinking she was mad—more than he already did. She simply shook her head, to James’s clear annoyance.
“Like this, see…” He hesitated for a second as his eyes fell on Scarlett’s Signet, uncovered now that her left hand was on the gearstick. Then, brushing it off, he pressed his palm down onto hers.
Something very strange happened.
James felt the gearstick between his fingers—and he didn’t phase through it. Quite the opposite. He could feel the leather surface pressed to his palm, cold and lifeless. Scarlett glanced at him through the rear-view mirror, her expression alarmed.
James moved his hand, shifting the gear. Except it wasn’t his hand doing it—it was Scarlett’s. The Signet turned, slowly, and he felt a tug in his chest.
“What the fuck?!” James stared at her, face coloured with shock. “I’m controlling your hand?”
Scarlett looked deeply displeased but nodded, trying to pull James’s hand away from hers, only to find she had no control over her own limb.
“You’re leaving without us?!” Lily climbed into the car through the boot, peering at them via the mirror. Regulus followed suit.
“I’m stuck to Scarlett!” James announced, his initial shock giving way to an expression of pure amazement. “I can control her hand!” He raised his own left hand, causing Scar’s to lift with it.
Lily and Regulus exchanged a look.
“Are you alright?” Sirius peered between the seats at her. Scarlett, pale and hyperventilating, simply nodded.
She couldn’t control her left arm. It felt numb, useless—though the idiot James took full advantage, brushing the steering wheel as if it were some grand joke.
“This isn’t going to work,” she muttered, trying to glance at the ghost, but he was hidden behind the seat.
“We could still go in Animagus form…” Sirius shrugged, frowning slightly at the subtle rocking of the car. “The engine noise is bloody annoying.”
“Maybe… that’s for the best…” Scarlett began, but then slapped herself across the face. She jumped at the sting, and Sirius raised an eyebrow. “Just sleepy,” she muttered, clearing her throat and shooting a glare at James through the mirror.
“C’mon, I’ve got it in reverse—hit the gas so we can get moving…” James continued, clearly enjoying the bizarre connection.
With no other option, Scarlett obeyed, steering with her right hand.
“Clutch…” he prompted, so she could shift into first. He beamed proudly as they finally rolled onto the road. “Scarmes at its finest!” he sang.
“Scarmes?!” Regulus grimaced.
“Jamelett is tacky!” he defended.
“They’re both awful,” Lily said, lying back in the boot with her face resting against Sirius’s seat. “I never thought I’d see you and Sirius like this again…” She met Scarlett’s eyes in the rear-view mirror. “Together.”
Scarlett chose to ignore the comment, keeping her attention fixed on the road ahead.
“Are we going the right way?” she asked, mustering a surprising amount of courage to get the words out.
Sirius turned in his seat, lying on his side.
“We are,” was all he said.
“Where are we going?” she pressed the clutch again, pretending not to hear James’s smug little laugh as he guided the gear shift.
“London.” Sirius began detangling one of the many knots in his elbow-length hair. “I need to see my godsons before we go after Wormtail.”
The mere mention of his godsons made Scarlett hold her breath, shoving down the overwhelming urge to cry. When she glanced at the rear-view mirror again, she noticed Sirius had turned into Padfoot, the dog’s grey eyes avoiding hers at all costs.
Sirius’s words hadn’t only struck Scarlett. The previous cheer drained from the car. Regulus stared off into nothing. Lily absentmindedly stroked Padfoot’s fur, and James’s grin vanished.
Rain began to drum against the car’s windows, and James flicked on the windscreen wipers. Scarlett couldn’t relax, knowing full well that by now they were likely being hunted by an army of Dementors—especially with the weather turning stormy. The sound of water pelting the car’s metal shell and the occasional rumble of the engine kept startling her.
After the first hour of driving, her legs began to ache. It was nothing compared to the pain she’d endured before, so she kept going. The rain grew heavier, forcing Scarlett to turn on the headlights even though it was still daylight.
“What do you think about stopping?” James broke the silence as they passed a hotel sign. They had to be close to England by now. “This rain’s only going to get worse, and you don’t look so great…”
Scarlett exhaled sharply. James switched on the indicator, and she turned the wheel, pulling up in front of a modest roadside hotel. Her palms started to sweat in the cold draft that seeped through the car, her heart thudding in time with the thunder that split the sky in flashes of light.
She stared at the hotel’s neon sign, catching Padfoot lifting his head at the sudden halt.
“Let’s give the rain a chance to pass,” Scarlett murmured, rummaging through her backpack for the food bars she’d packed. She took a bite and grimaced, offering it to Padfoot. He only sniffed it before laying his head back down on the seat, uninterested.
“Why don’t you get some rest? On a real bed?” Lily glanced at her, still trying to stroke Padfoot.
Scarlett abruptly opened the car door and stepped out, letting the rain drench her. James remained inside, the strange connection between them fading. The icy drops stripped away all the safety the car’s warmth had given her. Her dirty hair stuck to her face, her clothes instantly soaked through.
“I thought you wanted to see your son… as soon as possible,” Scarlett said when Lily followed her out.
There was a covered area nearby, but what was rain to someone who had endured so much? Scarlett didn’t care.
“I do. But it won’t mean anything if you crash this car and kill both of you! You’d be better off Apparating or using the Floo—”
“The fireplaces are definitely being watched,” Regulus cut in, stepping into the conversation, shielding his face from the ghostly rain. “And you can’t Apparate. I highly doubt Sirius can either.”
Lily pursed her lips at Regulus’s words, because she knew he was right.
“Just go get a room, Scarlett. There’s no way this hotel in the middle of nowhere doesn’t have one!” she snapped, hands planted on her hips in a distinctly maternal stance.
Scarlett opened her mouth to snap back, but a woman with an umbrella approached so quickly she barely had time to retreat to the car.
“Good evening, do you need any help?!” the woman asked, bending slightly and squinting through the downpour to see properly.
Scarlett’s blood froze. Her eyes widened, lips pressed tight, and she took a step back.
“Ma’am… Miss?!” the woman corrected herself, now holding the umbrella with just one hand. She began making odd gestures with the other.
Scarlett moved to grab her wand and hit the nosy stranger with a *Confundus*, but Lily was quicker—taking control of her left hand the same way James had done before. Scarlett gasped as her fingers began forming strange symbols, mirroring the woman’s.
What the fuck was happening?
“Grab the money from your wallet,” Lily commanded, her voice so close to Scarlett’s ear it felt like she was speaking from inside her skull.
With her free hand, Scarlett fumbled through her trouser pocket, pulling out her wallet and handing the woman a £100 note. The woman accepted the money, gestured a few more times, and then placed a key in Scarlett’s palm before walking away.
Scarlett and Regulus exchanged a look before turning to Lily.
“I told her you were deaf, that you needed a room for the night, and that you’d show your ID in the morning. She said there’s a vending machine in the lobby and that you could stay in one of the outer rooms since you prefer… privacy.” Lily pointed toward the more secluded units.
“Deaf, huh?” Scarlett still hadn’t entirely processed what just happened, staring at the raindrops bouncing off the key in her hand.
“Yeah, British Sign Language,” Lily shrugged. “I had a great-aunt who was deaf…”
“She should get out of this rain,” Regulus cut in, trying to place a hand on Scarlett’s shoulder, only for it to pass right through her. “Before she gets sick.”
Scarlett wiped her face, pushing away the excess water as she walked toward the room.
Inside the car, Padfoot watched her through the window, fogging up the glass with his warm breath. He didn’t quite understand what she was doing, but his tail thumped instinctively on the seat when he saw her moving away. His heart gave a hopeful flutter—maybe she’d found some tasty food.
He licked the cold glass to get a better view. Scarlett stopped in front of a door and began waving her arms.
“No, just because they’ve used my hand already doesn’t mean * you * get to as well!” Scar shouted, her muffled voice cutting through the rain and slamming into Padfoot’s ears with force. “I don’t care—you three are staying out here. Got it?!” She straightened her spine, glaring at nothing.
Padfoot flattened his ears and let out a soft whimper. Then she walked back to the car, soaking wet. She opened the door for him and motioned for him to come out. Padfoot bolted, taking shelter in the spot where she’d just been shouting moments ago. He looked around, checking to make sure she * had * been talking to herself.
Scarlett unlocked the room door and let him in before stepping inside and closing it. Though her face was drenched from the rain, Padfoot was certain she’d been crying. The scent of salt didn’t lie, nor did the faint sniff she gave as she walked into the small hotel room.
Her gaze swept over the double bed, the side table, the television, and the mini-fridge—the latter humming with a low, irritating sound. Padfoot padded after her, claws clicking softly against the wooden floor. When she vanished from view, his heartbeat quickened, and he followed her scent until he reached the bathroom door.
Padfoot’s ears perked at the sound of the shower turning on. He peeked through the slight gap in the door and watched Scarlett undress and step beneath the hot stream of water. He extended his snout, canine eyes tracing every inch of her.
Sirius leaned lightly on the doorframe, the bathroom light setting his silver irises ablaze with gold. There she was—the woman he had both loved and hated so fiercely. Beneath the cascade of scalding water, pale as the ghosts of their past, as colourless as all his fears. Her reddish-brown hair exactly as it had been the day he met her. The burn mark on her right arm. The Signet on her left hand. The tattoo of the star with glasses and the constellation of Canis Major on her back. The scars etched into her skin by the torture she endured.
It terrified him how easily she could awaken both the best and the worst in him. Sirius wanted to grab her by the hair and scream at her. He wanted to hold her and erase every single memory they shared. He wanted to rip that twisting, spiralling thing from his chest. He wanted to erase the fucking day they met.
If only they were strangers…
Scarlett bowed her head, pressed one hand to the tiled wall, and let her shoulders shake in silent sobs. Sirius dug his nails into the wooden frame, heart tearing open in his chest. The air grew thin. It was hard to stop looking at her—she was a magnetic force pulling his gaze. But it was even harder not to cry too.
He turned his body and leaned against the wall, sliding down until he was seated on the floor. Covered his face with both hands. It felt strange not to be alone anymore after so many years. More than that—it was tormenting to be in Scarlett’s presence. She was the symbol of his failure, the embodiment of all his demons, the other half of his mosaic. So many pieces of him were in her—and of her, in him.
The similarity between them was glaring—and so was the difference. Sirius was innocent. Even if he blamed himself for his friends’ deaths—he wouldn’t be a hypocrite and deny his share—Scarlett had killed the McKinnons with the Killing Curse. She had * wanted * to kill them. And Sirius… all Sirius had ever wanted… was to protect.
Protect the ones he loved.
He’d tried to protect Regulus. Scarlett. Lily and James.
In the end, it was all his fault. If he’d gone to meet Regulus… if he hadn’t let Scarlett walk away… if he hadn’t suggested Peter…
Sirius swallowed his sobs as he heard the shower shut off, quickly transforming back into Padfoot and sitting beside the door like a silent guard. Scarlett didn’t take long to come out, wearing a loose dress and tossing her backpack onto the bed.
“If you want to shower—”
Padfoot didn’t let her finish. He pushed past her straight into the bathroom. Sirius turned the water on and stepped under it without a second thought, the hot stream lashing against his shoulders and finally relaxing his aching muscles. He couldn’t remember the last time he felt something like that. Closing his eyes, he let the negative sensations and painful memories be washed away by the sound of running water. He barely remembered the injury in his hip anymore.
He swore he’d stay in there a decade, using up every last bit of the hotel soap. The water ran brown off his feet. He was filthy—especially his hair. He tried to shampoo it, but it was so tangled it hardly mattered. Letting the water cascade over him, he closed the drain and turned on the tap for the bathtub. The scalding water swallowed his feet, then his shins, until he sat down and hugged his knees, resting his chin on them.
He stared at his dancing reflection on the water’s surface. His thick eyebrows, corpse-like eyes, the heavy beard.
A quiet throat-clear came from the door, and he glanced sideways.
“I’m going to look for something to eat… do you… need anything?” As soon as their eyes met, colour rose to Scarlett’s pale face—realising he was fully submerged in the bath.
Sirius shook his head, instantly regretting it. She just stepped back and disappeared from the doorway. He inhaled.
“Scar!” he called, his voice echoing against the bathroom tiles.
Scar. Scar. Scar.
Why had he called her that? His heart skipped a few beats. Her face reappeared, delicate brows gently raised.
“Y-you…” he faltered, turning his face forward, digging through his chest for the courage that had once come so easily to him—and now was so painfully scarce. “Could you help me with my hair?”
She stood frozen in the doorway for a few seconds, as if she didn’t know what to do. Then she nodded, dropped her backpack to the floor and grabbed a chair from the room, setting it beside the porcelain tub. She pulled a brush from her bag and tilted her head slightly, as if hearing something only she could hear.
Scarlett lifted his hair from the water, casting a spell to keep it from soaking the entire bathroom. Then she used another charm to soften the strands as she began brushing the ends gently, working her way up little by little.
Sirius exhaled through his mouth. The only sounds were the dripping from his hair and beard, his reflection rippling on the water’s surface, and his eyes—watching Scarlett intently; analysing her, dissecting her.
“Thank you… for saving me in Azkaban. He was going to kill me.” It was she who finally broke the tension building in the silence between them. “You didn’t have a choice… either way. It was him or you.”
What was she doing—trying to comfort him? Sirius turned his face, but not toward her. He didn’t want to look. He’d rather she stay quiet, because her words stirred something rancid in his chest. Something he’d chewed on for years—sharp, bitter, and unforgiving.
“No choice? Is that what you told yourself after you killed the McKinnons?”
Scarlett’s breath trembled against his shoulder, warm and laced with hesitation.
“I had to prove my loyalty,” she said softly, her words brushing against Sirius’s neck. She shifted on the chair, her hands twitching. Her mouth opened more than once, as if she were trying to shape something coherent to say—but nothing came. Then she pressed her lips together in a thin line, cold tears sliding down her cheeks.
“For Reggie?” Sirius pressed.
He knew Scarlett. Knew her more than he wished he did—more than he * should * have. He knew full well she wouldn’t hand him answers easily. Like him, she was a hoarder. She loved tucking things away into the darkest corners of her heart until they festered into violent, irreversible wounds—until they began to kill her from the inside out.
And she wouldn’t fight it. It was far easier to let it eat her alive than face it. They nurtured their poisons with the same intensity they nurtured their love. Maybe that was why they were here now—wounding and sheltering each other like waves erasing drawings in the sand, only for new ones to emerge.
“I couldn’t risk his life… or let him become a test subject like Orfy,” she confessed, after a long, silent pause.
Sirius’s gaze drifted over the surface of the bathwater, trying to picture what she had gone through. But any empathy he tried to summon was tangled in everything she’d done to him—her betrayal. And that made it impossible to see things clearly, impossible to understand her.
Sirius would never understand her—let alone forgive her.
“You never liked Marlene,” he shot back, bitterness thick in his voice.
Scarlett sobbed.
“She was my friend too,” she whispered painfully, her voice barely audible.
“And you killed her with a Killing Curse,” Sirius went on, not giving her a second to breathe. Scarlett froze mid-motion, blinking rapidly, her breath caught in her chest. “I thought you hated her. Because we… were something.”
Scarlett stared at her rippling reflection in the water, her blue eyes hardening into icy spikes. But the tears softened that frost, loosening the tension and flooding her gaze with a thousand memories.
“At first, I did. But later… don’t you remember, Sirius?” Scarlett held his agonised gaze, the light flickering in her blazing irises.
Sirius let out a shaky breath, curling inward, hiding half his face in his knees and leaving only his eyes visible.
“They took so much from me,” he admitted, his voice as stormy as the rain still hammering outside. “Good memories. Anything that could’ve made me smile…” He hissed out a breath, squeezing his eyes shut. He didn’t want to cry.
“It’s not all bad,” she tried to console him, in the worst possible way. “The good memories… those are the ones that hurt the most.” Her voice fractured into a hundred broken tones, her eyes locked on his back.
In a barely perceptible movement, Sirius turned his head, meeting her eyes. His heart clenched violently, gushing pain through every nerve ending in his body. Her eyes were so blue it almost hurt to look at them. Scarlett touched his back and a jolt ripped through his core, shattering every doubt and igniting a dozen warm sensations behind his ears—ones he hadn’t felt in years.
“We did this one just after my parents died,” she said, wiping the tears away with the back of her hand, never breaking eye contact. Sirius realised she was talking about the tattoo on her back. “I got Canis Major, and you… you got Sagittarius. My star sign.”
Sirius fumbled over the spot she indicated, searching for the shape with his fingertips. Scarlett took his hand, guiding it to the faint ridge in her skin. Her hand was soft and cold. Welcoming, and edged like glass. It was impossible not to drown in the blue of her irises, pulled under by her trapped sorrow, her ambiguous actions, her suffocating melancholy.
The air between them shimmered, sparked, crackled—as if unsure whether to push them apart or pull them closer. What hurt Sirius, too, was the fact that Scarlett had never met her son, not even after everything she'd done. Yet he didn’t look away, didn’t pull back from her touch.
“He was so, so small…” he whispered, helplessly dragged under the tide of those ocean eyes. “Reggie never cried much. Not even when his colic was awful or when his teeth were coming in…” A sad smile curved his lips. Scarlett’s features began to harden with tension. “He’s got greyish-blue eyes. Freckles all over his face—just like you.”
Sirius’s gaze traced the markings on her skin, then returned to those dangerously deep irises. The ocean became rough, violent, waves crashing against him, slamming him into the cliff walls of her pupils, forcing him to resurface just to breathe.
“His hair… like mine. Like… like * his*,” he corrected, stumbling.
Scarlett bowed her head, her hair dripping forward as she resumed brushing another section, fighting the sobs building in her throat. It was a losing battle—they both knew it—yet she clung to it, unwilling to expose any more vulnerability than she already had. Her face fractured in another wave of tears.
Sirius didn’t know what he was supposed to feel. Shouldn’t he be happy? That’s what he’d always wanted to throw in her face during those three years he’d raised Reggie, when he’d been the boy’s father. That she hadn’t been there. So why did saying it hurt so fucking much?
Seeing her like that had the same effect as tugging the strings of his heart until they snapped.
“I’m sorry.” His mouth betrayed him—but there was honesty behind the words.
Scarlett shook her head, trembling hands dipping his newly brushed, clean hair into the bath, clouding the water with grime once more.
“It’s fine,” she lied, rising to her feet. “I… I’ll go… find us something to eat.”
Like the coward she was, Scarlett ran.
Sirius felt like an idiot. She always had the power to make him feel that way—like a fool, even after doing the right thing. That was why he cried the moment she left the room, until the bathwater turned unbearably cold and reminded him of the presence of the Dementors.
.
.
.
Scarlett leaned against the wall outside, drawing in as much air as she could, the damp wind brushing against the raw skin of her cheeks. She stared at the curtain of water pouring from the roof ahead, spraying droplets across her face.
"Alright?" Regulus stepped through the rain, hands buried in his dark green cloak, his eyes shadowed.
Scarlett gasped, hugging herself.
"This is your fault." She hissed, rubbing the Signet furiously. "All of this is your fucking fault."
He licked his lips and gave that guilt-ridden smile, closing his eyes as if her words might physically wound him.
"I was just trying to protect you." Regulus kept his head bowed, unable to look at her.
"Protect me? You could’ve freed me long before this, Regulus!" she growled, the sob caught in her throat.
"And risk Orfy’s life?!" He lifted his gaze to hers, his irises gleaming with fury. "Risk Reggie?!"
"He was already at risk!" Scarlett jabbed a finger in his face. Regulus swatted at her hand in vain. "I was at risk!"
"I know, but… what did you expect me to do?! I… I was only seventeen, for fuck’s sake! I was trying to save you!"
"Oh yeah? And look where I am now!" Scarlett flung her arms open, her breath hitching. "I can’t even tell him the truth! You didn’t even let me leave..."
"Because you were all I had, Scarlett!" Regulus cut her off, tears making his eyes shine like stars. "You and Reg… you were all I fucking had."
Scarlett’s features twisted, a wave of disgust rolling through her. Regulus’s thin lips trembled, as though he were searching for a magic word that could undo every mistake he’d made, all the harm he’d caused, all the pain he’d inflicted.
But there was nothing he could do. Magic had its limits—especially for someone like him, just a damned and tormented soul. No god, angel, or demon could undo what he’d done to the two people he’d loved most.
And hated most, too.
"You’ve always had to take what belongs to your brother, haven’t you, Regulus?!" Scarlett spat, jaw clenched.
That was the nail in his coffin. Regulus only lowered his head, black hair falling over his face, hiding his expression. Scarlett didn’t need to see to know exactly how his lips were pressed into a tight line, eyes half-lidded, nose twisted. She knew him better than she wanted to, and hurting him was one of the few things that brought her some measure of comfort on that stormy summer night.
Scarlett genuinely couldn’t remember how she’d ended up at the small diner next to the hotel, where a telly mounted above the counter cast a harsh glow across the dimly lit room. She squinted to see the image, the presenter’s voice cutting through the low hum just as a massive photo of Sirius appeared on the screen.
“… the public is warned that Black is armed and extremely dangerous. A special hot line has been set up, and any sighting of Black should be reported immediately.”
Scarlett’s gaze shot to the clock. Only a few days since their escape, and it was already on Muggle telly?! Why had they only shown Sirius? Her questions were swept away by the sudden, gnawing hunger that hit her as the scent of frying oil wafted through the air. She glanced at the menu and decided to order the daily special.
The waitress gave her a funny look, but quickly plastered on a polite smile when Scarlett left a generous tip. She leaned her elbows on the counter, grabbed the takeaway, and tried to ignore how much her mouth was watering until she could finally eat.
When she got back to the room, none of her ghosts were waiting at the door. She stepped in and didn’t see Sirius. She left the food on the table and peeked toward the bathroom door, noticing he was inside, murmuring a few spells at his hair.
She didn’t need to call him—he came out the instant the scent of food hit his nose.
"Fish and chips?" He tore the bag open with more force than necessary, closing his eyes and groaning in pure delight as he bit into the first piece of battered fish. "This is the best thing I’ve eaten in my entire life..."
Scarlett gave in to a chip, feeling the crunch dissolve any lingering tension in her chest. It wasn’t long before her fingers were greasy, her eyes shut, savouring every salty bite of her meal. She even risked a small chuckle at the sight of Sirius looking just as entranced.
He cracked open his Coke and took a swig straight from the bottle, only to spit it out immediately.
"Didn’t remember it being that sweet..." Sirius grimaced, setting it aside. "And the fizz..."
"I’ve never liked fizzy drinks." Scarlett offered him her lemonade.
"You can have it." He pushed the bottle back to her.
"I’ll drink the minibar water." Scarlett handed the lemonade over again.
Sirius sighed, shrugged, and enjoyed the tangy sweetness of the green drink. Scarlett unwrapped the desserts, prompting Sirius to raise an eyebrow.
"By the way..." Scarlett didn’t leave him the chance to talk. "You were on the telly."
Sirius gave her a curious look before sniffing his dessert.
"I was? What d’you mean?" He picked up a plastic fork and held it politely, trying to figure out what it was.
"Strawberry cake." Scarlett tapped her fingers on the table. "Your favourite." She stared at the dessert. "According to the news, you’re armed and extremely dangerous." There was the faintest trace of irony in her voice, just enough for Sirius to furrow his brow, too engrossed in his cake to comment. "No mention of me."
Sirius chewed in silence, wiping the icing from his beard with his little finger before licking it. Scarlett gathered up the wrappers and dropped them into the bin without leaving her seat.
"Doesn’t make sense." He wiped his lips with a napkin, and Scarlett nearly laughed at how meticulously he folded it. "Unless… they just didn’t tell the Muggles you escaped too."
"Probably," Scarlett agreed.
The silence that settled between them felt odd. The lamp flickered, rain hammered the windows, and thunder rumbled in the distance. Sirius was now wearing a green T-shirt and a pair of white trousers that looked nothing like his style. He stood up and threw himself onto the bed, letting out a long groan as he rolled around in the sheets like he still had Padfoot’s instincts.
Scarlett gave a faint smile, folding her arms and pushing the chair back to prop her feet up on the table.
"Take the bed. I’ll sleep in the chair." She let her head hang over the backrest.
"What?!" Sirius didn’t bother to hide the outrage in his voice. "It’s not like we’ve never shared a bed before." He argued, a hint of cockiness colouring his tone.
Or maybe she was just imagining it.
Scarlett exhaled sharply, standing up in one go.
"Don’t complain later if I won’t get up..." She almost smiled as she flopped onto the bed, sinking into the plush mattress, clean sheets, and fluffy pillows. It felt like a dream.
"I won’t complain," Sirius replied, voice muffled against the pillow. "Just be careful… I’m armed and extremely dangerous."
Scarlett froze for a moment, turning to look at him to make sure it was a joke. Sirius, however, seemed to just shut down, falling asleep the second he closed his eyes. Scarlett couldn’t help but watch him—the calm expression he wore, the way his brow smoothed out, the faint wrinkles at the corners of his eyes relaxing.
She didn’t allow herself to smile. Sirius never slept in Azkaban, and seeing him able to rest now sent a chill down her spine.
Did Sirius feel safe with her?
He shouldn’t.
Should he?
Scarlett brushed aside a strand of his hair that had fallen onto her side of the bed. The brittle, dried-out strands still carried a trace of softness—one Scarlett remembered well. She turned off the room’s light and stared at the ceiling, the lightning outside casting flashes across the curtains and projecting shadows onto her face.
Her gaze landed on the odd-looking remote on the bedside table. Scarlett picked it up and pressed a button that gave a soft beep and… nothing. She looked at the telly, then at Sirius. Nothing. Until a low hum began to fill the room, and she lifted her head, trying to locate the source of the noise.
Sirius, still in the exact position he’d fallen asleep in, suddenly woke. He gasped, looking around, his face pale in the dark.
"Dementor, dementor, dementor..." he repeated, searching for his wand, voice trembling.
"No, no, no..." Scarlett pressed the button on the remote again and grabbed his hands before he did something stupid. "It’s alright. It’s just the air con. There are no dementors here." She tried to soothe him, even as her heart hammered in her throat from the fright he gave her. "I’m here. I’m right here!" Scarlett clasped Sirius’s hands in hers, blowing warm air onto his trembling fingers.
He looked at her, his eyes adjusting to the dark. The silver in his irises shimmered—unsteady, volatile, shifting.
"We’re safe now." Scarlett said it with such certainty that Sirius simply accepted it.
Still breathing hard, he lay back down, sliding across the mattress to wrap an arm around her waist and press his face into her belly. She went still, feeling him stroke her left hand, tracing the Ouroboros with his thumb.
Scarlett’s whole body shivered, her breath quickened, muscles tensing. Sirius didn’t seem to care. If he did, he didn’t show it. His touch was warm—unbearably warm—and cunning. It set her soul alight. He could hear her heartbeat, her hesitation, her stiffness. She knew he could.
Sirius was cruel—so cruel that he never stayed away from her, even when he should have. No, he had to hold her like that, hide his face in her stomach, capture her dominant hand. If a dementor walked in, they’d be utterly defenceless.
"Do you want me to move?" he asked softly.
Scarlett didn’t understand. She knew he hated her—he’d made that perfectly clear. So why was he curled up on her like a boy seeking the safety of his mum? Maybe that was all it was. Maybe he just needed to feel safe, no matter who it was with.
"No," she whispered back, resting her head on the pillow, trying not to move, focusing on the rough pad of Sirius’s thumb brushing over her Signet.
It was just a touch, just a tender gesture, but it sent Scarlett’s mind spiralling into a whirlwind of jumbled, paralysing memories and impressions, devouring her sanity and her fears with a ravenous hunger. Scarlett wanted to dive into that feeling and drown in it, leaving everything behind; in a place lush and green where it was just her, Sirius, and no one else.
It was incredibly difficult to resist that dark hair. She managed during the first hour, while Sirius snored softly against her skin, radiating an unbearable heat. She was already sweating, and yet she couldn’t summon the courage to push him away.
He used to hold her like that when he was upset—fifteen years ago.
Before what happened.
Before… before everything.
Scarlett fell asleep running her fingers through Sirius’s hair, even knowing she didn’t deserve any of it.
She didn’t deserve love—least of all the love of Sirius Black.
.
.
.
It was easier for both of them to pretend that night had never happened, and that’s exactly how it went all the way to London. Padfoot behaved himself the entire trip, though he did try to nick Scarlett’s chocolate ice cream and pissed on the tyre of a motorbike he found appealing—to mark his territory, of course.
They ditched the car near the city. Scarlett used *Evanesco* on the vehicle, and it was bizarre to watch it vanish into thin air. Padfoot and Whiskers quickly took off through the packed summer streets—young people heading to clubs, families coming out of the cinema, adults off to the pubs. Padfoot couldn’t help but wonder what things might’ve been like if...
If...
No.
He shoved the thought aside as he read the nearby street signs, stopping only when he found the one pointing to Privet Drive. Whiskers followed close behind, walking quickly over the hot tarmac. Night had just fallen, the streetlamps flickering on automatically.
Padfoot halted as a scent hit him—broomstick and hair; sweet and floral, sparking something deep in the dog’s mind. A burst of laughter, bright and contagious. Padfoot wagged his tail, turning sharply to follow that scent, so familiar and yet so conflicting. He picked up his pace to a trot, sticking to the neighbours' lawns to spare his paws from the hot pavement.
He barked for Whiskers to keep up, turning onto Magnolia Crescent and darting down an alley beside a tall, barred wall. He ran and ran, then stopped dead at the sight of messy black hair, as wild as a bird’s nest.
Something twisted in his chest. Whiskers skidded to a stop beside him, ears perked. Padfoot stood frozen with excitement, his whole body flushed with heat, as if he’d just laid eyes on someone he loved deeply.
James.
The boy was hauling a heavy trunk, wand in hand. Padfoot wanted to approach, but Whiskers blocked his path with her body. He hesitated—long enough for the boy to narrow his eyes behind round glasses, peering into the dark alley.
He’d forgotten so many things. But not James. The memory of his friend lying lifeless at the foot of the stairs on Halloween threatened to rip his heart open, but Lily’s green, gentle eyes swept the thought away, making him step back. That wasn’t James.
It was Harry—his godson, James and Lily’s son.
"Lumos," Harry whispered, and his wand lit up. Whiskers shoved against Padfoot’s chest, but the dog was too big for her to move him even an inch.
Harry took a step back, tripping over his trunk and nearly falling. Padfoot startled, Whiskers hissed, and the two of them bolted down the narrow alley to the other side, panting hard just as the loud screech of the Knight Bus echoed from the next street over.
Padfoot and Whiskers exchanged a glance.
Then they took off running again.
.
.
.
Scarlett rested her face against the cold walls of the corner house. She felt cold, despite the stifling heat of that London summer. A boy stepped out of the nearest house, headphones on, skateboard in hand. He glanced around before sitting on the stairwell’s ledge, gazing upward as if he might glimpse the stars from there—but the city lights drowned them out far too easily.
She didn’t realise she was rubbing her Signet over and over, nor how her heart was being crushed with every beat. As if the more she saw, the more that painful, infectious poison spread through her body, frying her tendons, burning her to the core. It was the longing for something she’d never lived, the ache for something she’d never held, the nostalgia for a head of hair she’d never kissed.
Regulus swung his legs in time with the music in his ears, until two girls appeared on the pavement. He waved to them, hopped off the ledge and skated towards them, drifting slowly away from Scarlett, turning into an indistinct blur.
Sirius caught her hand, stopping her from harming the Signet more than she already had. She didn’t cry anymore. All her tears were gone, leaving behind only the bitter taste of time she couldn’t reclaim, of sand slipping far too easily through her fingers, of years that would never return. Scarlett had never truly known Regulus. The wind whipped through her hair, across her cheeks, and through the narrow space between her and Sirius.
She lifted her gaze to him, feeling a tremor, a stirring inside her; like there was a hook caught in her chest, pulling her toward him. Blue met grey. There was no explaining how those silver eyes managed to pierce her soul, turn her secrets inside out, sink themselves into her sorrow.
"He looks so much like his father..." Scarlett breathed, her gaze drifting to Red, a little behind his brother. He didn’t even glance her way, lost in his own torment.
.
.
.
"You didn’t notice the fire until that moment, sir?"
James blinked, his peripheral vision catching the ashes gathered on the window frame beside him. His eyes darted to Sirius, being examined not far off, then to the Auror.
"No, it was... it was like... there wasn’t a fire at all," he said, throat dry. His stomach heavy, heart thudding in his chest.
His gaze landed on the tall, blond man who stepped into the house: Thanatos Gaunt. His shoulders were dusted with soot, his face a stone mask. Those caramel-coloured eyes locked onto James’s, shadowed with sorrow. A chill ran down James’s spine.
Nate gave the slightest shake of his head before closing his eyes.
James’s knees buckled, forcing him to lean against the window. Bile scorched his throat and he exhaled, covering his mouth with one hand.
James cried—softly—doing his best to keep Sirius from hearing.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 3: She showed me the best side of love and never gave up on me
Chapter Text
LXXI
“… everything was calm. We didn’t hear a thing until… there was an explosion and the fire sprang up all at once. I woke and bolted the moment I saw the flames; they were already raging, and Sirius emerged from the smoke with Scarlett. I called to him—the heat was overwhelming, and so was the smoke…
"You didn’t notice the fire until that moment, sir?"
"No, it was... it was like... there wasn’t a fire at all,"
Silence. Sirius recognised that voice, but it seemed too distant to reach. When he opened his eyes, a yellow, diffused light dazzled his vision. He tried to shield himself from it, but a hand gripped his face and fingers forced his eyelids open.
He tried to move his right arm to break free, but he couldn’t lift it.
It wasn’t long before the light snapped out, and some voices whispered softly things he couldn’t comprehend.
His eyes burned, as did his throat and his entire respiratory system. He drank something that eased the pain but also made him choke. He hurled his torso forward, gasping heavily, as if he couldn’t breathe properly. His hair was plastered to his cheeks and someone called his name, though he could barely make out the words.
“Mr Black?!“ The baritone, precise voice made him look to one side, his vision gradually focusing on the tall, well‑tailored figure of a man in his forties. A notebook and quill hovered before him. “Is he all right?”
Sirius had no time to answer. A woman grasped his chin once more, and he shook his head, snarling to break free.
“He seems fine, but his lungs have been affected. I’ve managed to heal the first‑ and second‑degree burns. There’s still a third‑degree burn on his right arm.”
“I imagine injuries from cursed fire are difficult to treat.” The man turned his gaze to Sirius, whose consciousness flickered. “Mr Black, may I take your statement?”
Something sparked within Sirius’s mind and he made a movement as if to stand up, but a hand on his shoulder forced him to remain seated.
“James.” Sirius rasped hoarsely and searched for his friend with his gaze, noting they were in the Potters’ sitting room. James, a short distance away, hurried over, removing his glasses from his damp face and crouching before him.
“Hey, Sirius…” He forced a smile, though the deep shadows under his eyes stained his face and betrayed his tears. “How are you feeling?”
Sirius flared his nostrils, the smell of smoke clinging to them. He felt nauseous. He remembered the heat, waking in terror, carrying Scarlett with him.
Scarlett.
“Where…?”
“She’s fine.” James gripped his left hand firmly. “You needn’t worry, she’s safe.”
“James…” Sirius repeated his friend’s name with more gravity. “The Gaunts…”
He swallowed hard, his dark eyes never leaving James’s for an instant. James brushed a strand of hair behind Sirius’s ear before shaking his head, the smile fading in a trace of sorrow.
Sirius brought his hand to his mouth and James swiftly produced a bucket. He vomited, feeling his friend rub his bare, sweaty back — only then realising how filthy he was.
“It’s all right… it’s normal…” James repeated so gently that Sirius couldn’t make sense of what was happening.
Tears streamed down unbidden. Sirius touched his right arm, bandaged with something cold and numbing. He looked at his own trembling hand, the fingers blackened with ash.
“James… I need to see her.” Sirius said, fighting to keep his eyes open. “Where… James, where…”
Sirius couldn’t finish the sentence. His mind drifted to a remote place where echoes threw off his balance and icy breaths sent shivers down his spine. He tried to move away, tried to run, tried to leave, but all his body could do was remain inert, allowing only his eyes to survey the surroundings.
The Potters’ sitting room. The wall clock swung its pendulum from side to side, people bustled to and fro, James rose and Euphemia brought him a glass of water. Sirius watched the clear liquid ripple, raising his gaze to the man seated diagonally across — Fleamont, running a hand through his dark hair as he stared out of the window.
Sirius sipped the water, pressing his lips together as the nausea returned. He bowed his head, resting it between his knees, gulping for air. It felt as though his throat were inflamed, constricting the oxygen and making it scarce.
“Mr Black?” the man called. Sirius summoned a tremendous effort to meet his gaze, the glass chilling his palms.
“What?” Sirius heard himself say, blinking incessantly as though it would clear his vision.
“Your statement.”
Statement? Sirius rubbed his eyes slowly, an infernal throbbing in his skull. Ah, yes — he should speak of what happened. What happened?
The smoke gave way to the fire, the fire gave way to screams, the screams gave way to Scarlett. Sirius’s sweaty fingers tugging at the window latch, trying to open it in vain.
“I couldn’t… get out.” He drank another glass of water, the coolness scraping his throat. He coughed.
“How so?” The man put his hand on his chin, the quill moving up and down.
“The window wouldn’t open.” Sirius replied, as if it were obvious. “I couldn’t Disapparate. And… Scarlett… Scarlett… where is she?!” He lurched forward, feeling a sharp pain in his ankle as he rose.
“Hey, hey, hey… steady on…” James wrapped an arm around his waist and the room spun faster; Sirius staggered and knocked the glass to the floor.
“It’s all right, dear…” Euphemia’s voice tried to soothe the adrenaline pounding in his chest.
“What do you mean…the window wouldn’t open?!” the man pressed, to Sirius’s dismay. “How did you all get out?”
“I… I…” Sirius gasped for air as if choking, casting a terrified glance at James. “I didn’t… I used… I blasted the wall…”
“Let him go upstairs; I’ll take his statement later.” Another voice cut in, one he recognised. Sirius looked over his shoulder, and it took him a few seconds to place the serious blond man behind him.
“Nate…” Sirius felt his body shiver. It was Scarlett’s uncle. “Nate…”
“I know.” He cut him off, placing a hand on his shoulder in a paternal gesture. “She’s upstairs.”
Sirius didn’t know what to say or think. James carried him up the stairs, and it was agony to use his good leg, for even it was sore. He braced himself with his other hand on the banister and stopped outside a room where several Healers bustled in and out, until they were alone.
“They had to put her to sleep.” James murmured, his voice strained as though on the verge of tears. “She wouldn’t stop screaming…”
Sirius hesitated before looking at Scarlett lying in bed. She still wore the same pyjamas from that night, though stained with soot and ash. Her right arm was also bandaged, her hair tangled and her face…
It felt as though the world had not ended. Scarlett slept with such placidity that Sirius wished to keep her like that forever, untouched by loss, distant from pain. James dug his fingernails into his waist without noticing. It hurt him too. Sirius wanted so desperately to protect Scarlett that seeing her safe was a relief, yet also a torment.
“What… what should I say?!” he asked, voice trembling.
James regarded him, frowning slowly.
“What do you mean?” he whispered, nostrils flaring.
“To her… what should I say to her?” Sirius panted, hand clenched on the doorframe.
James studied him for a long moment, his expression cracking with unshed tears. Sirius turned back to Scarlett, fighting to remain calm, to appear in control. None of his own wounds hurt as much as the thought of Scarlett’s agony when she woke.
“It was cursed fire…” James sighed deeply. “They stood no chance.”
Sirius’s ears rang. Cursed fire.
“What? It was… an attack?” Sirius squinted, consciousness wavering.
“It’s still… not confirmed yet,” James sniffed. “Do you want to sit down?”
“Put me on the bed,” Sirius requested.
The sheets clung to his clammy skin. He moved carefully, lying down beside Scarlett, his arm tucked beneath her cheek. James brought over a chair and sat, drawing his knees to his chest.
“Get some rest, Padfoot,” James brushed Sirius’s dark hair from his face. “You need to recuperate.”
“I can’t.” Sirius wrinkled his nose and squeezed his eyes shut, fighting back tears. “I can’t.”
“I’ll be here when you or Scar wake up,” James tried to reassure him.
Sirius shook his head. “I have to be here when she wakes… I have to…”
“She won’t wake just yet,” James said, wiping tears from his face. “Fancy a sleeping draught?”
“No.” Sirius let his gaze roam over Scarlett—her pale, ash‑smudged face, freckles barely peeking through, thick lashes. A sudden twitch of her cheek. The flutter of her closed eyes.
He didn’t want to sleep. He was good at keeping vigil—had done it countless times at Grimmauld Place when Bellatrix abused Regulus—hovering at the edge of slumber without crossing it. He could hear footsteps on the landing, voices downstairs, James’s ragged sobs.
He stayed like that for the first three hours, but by the fourth his exhaustion began to demand its due, and on the fifth he slipped over the border of sleep and blacked out.
.
.
.
The spiral of smoke stung Scarlett’s eyes. She reached towards the blaze, where a figure rustled amid the crackling flames. She could neither breathe properly nor see clearly through the tears and the falling debris. Yet she was certain it was Orfy.
“Orfy...” she whispered, using the last of her breath, her trembling fingers reaching, in vain, to touch him.
But the more she stretched out her fingers, the farther he seemed. Her vision began to fleck with tiny black dots, and she summoned all her strength to clench her hands around her wand, to try to disapparate, but her mind was shrouded by something colourless and formless; something that tasted of embers and metal.
Magic.
Scarlett tried to summon her ancestral magic, but Sirius was quicker and everything went dark.
She awoke with a shiver. The blinds barred most of the light, but pinpricks of brightness still forced their way into the room: glinting on the bedside table, on the varnished wooden headboard, on Sirius’s dark hair smudged with soot beside her.
He was asleep, his heavy breathing forming a soft snore. One arm tucked beneath his head, the other—bandaged—resting just above his chest. Scarlett blinked several times, her throat dry. She let her eyes adjust to the half-light and shifted carefully in the bed so as not to wake Sirius. Of course, it was in vain, for his eyes opened the moment the mattress dipped.
She hadn’t noticed the grime caked on Sirius’s face, nor how parched his lips had grown. He cleared his throat, and the hint of his voice echoed a hundred things through her mind: memories of fire and death, of screams and agony. Scarlett’s eyes flew open, her sockets brimming with tears.
Her lips trembled and she steadied her racing heart, feeling Sirius’s fingers entwine with hers.
“I... I had... a strange nightmare,” she admitted, though she knew it was but an illusion. She remembered the flaming lash on her arm because it was throbbing.
Sirius let go of her hand hesitantly, as if locked in an internal, chaotic battle. He moistened his lips, guilt shining in those starry eyes tinged with morbidity.
“Sirius...” she murmured, her voice cracked. “Orfy... my... my...”
Scarlett could not finish her words. The pain scorched her core as if a piece of her soul had been violently torn away; dulling her senses and making gravity feel heavier, so that breathing was laboured, thinking was arduous, and merely existing was exhausting. A knot closed in her throat.
“I’m so sorry,” Sirius murmured, placing his palm against her cheek.
A searing pressure lodged in her heart. Scarlett pressed her hand against it as if she could ease it, as if she could tear away the burning realisation that her parents and Orfy… that they…
They…
Scarlett gasped, recoiling from Sirius like a hiss.
“That can’t be true… no… it just can’t be true, can it…”
“Scar…” Sirius murmured softly.
But she didn’t hear him, springing to her feet. She barely noticed the slight aches in her muscles, the fatigue in her body, the weight on her lungs. Sirius called to her again, but she ignored him as she left the room, her gaze wandering around the landing where she could see the ground floor of the house packed with people.
Conversations fell silent the moment she came into view. Scarlett swallowed hard. She had always loathed being the centre of attention, but in that moment she scarcely cared, only now realising that she was in the Potters’ home. Her gaze inevitably settled on Thanatos, whose hands had slipped into his pockets and whose sorrow graced his handsome features.
“Where are they?” her voice barely emerged. “Where are they, Uncle?”
Thanatos remained motionless, averting her gaze as he shook his head.
“They’re gone, Scar,” he replied, his tone gentle. “I’m so sorry.”
Scarlett swallowed again, her chest hit by another searing, smouldering stab. She barely noticed herself hastening down the stairs in a frenzy, dodging the arms that tried to hold her back, her lungs protesting the sudden exertion.
“Let her be,” Thanatos commanded.
A blinding shaft of light streamed through the window by the Potters’ door. Scarlett flung it open, greeted by a gust speckled with ash and the acrid smell of smoke. She raised her hand to shield her face from the glare, her heart hammering in her chest, the sensation of fire licking her skin triggering her fight‑or‑flight instincts.
Scarlett lifted her eyes beyond the shafts of light; the orange glow of the sun was fading, casting a stark shadow over her home. Over what remained of her home. The second floor was gone, and the wooden frame was blackened by the flames, soot swirling into the sky in a vortex.
Her house had become ruins. The poppy‑filled garden no longer existed, the fountain melted by the heat of the blaze, and the garage seemed to be the only thing left relatively intact, perhaps because it was separate from the main structure.
A desperate sob rose in Scarlett’s throat, escaping uncontrollably. She fell to her knees on the hot tarmac beneath the ash fall, her hands sinking into the filth her home had spat out. The ashes that had once been her bed, her room, her piano. She barely registered the members of the Ministry’s Department of Magical Accidents and Catastrophes at work, nor the people standing behind her.
No word or pain could describe what Scarlett felt in that moment as she watched what had once been her home become the symbol of her family’s loss. It was as if every laugh, every happy memory, had been ground to dust and poured into an ashtray.
Scarlett screamed until her throat bled, until her vocal cords gave out, until her head throbbed and her vision became a hazy blur. Sirius knelt beside her, stroking her back, trying to soften the cruelty of reality.
“You… you should have let me go… run into the fire…” she sobbed through her tears. “You…”
“No.” Sirius cut in without a moment’s hesitation. “I would never… never let you.”
Scarlett reached up to Sirius, digging her fingers into his hair. He offered no resistance, allowing her to pull him until their faces were inches apart, her hot breath mingling with his, her furious eyes burning into him.
“YOU SHOULD HAVE LET ME DIE!” she screamed, her voice raw and strangled. “WHY DIDN’T YOU LET ME GO? I TOLD YOU TO LET ME GO!!!”
Scarlett delivered a fierce slap to Sirius’s cheek, yet he barely flinched, merely holding her gaze. She squeezed her eyes shut, wiping away the last of her tears, those blue eyes looking exhausted and haunted, her lips trembling.
Gently, Sirius pressed his forehead against hers. Scarlett squeezed her eyes tighter, her shoulders shaking, though no more tears came. He slid one hand into her hair and the other around her waist, pulling her firmly against him.
She allowed herself to be held, her heart pounding so fiercely that he could feel every beat. Sirius tightened his embrace, letting Scarlett rest her forehead on his shoulder.
Without a word, he kissed the top of her head with tenderness. As the first stars appeared in the sky, he decided to carry her back inside, gritting his teeth against the pain in his ankle, ignoring the stab of agony with each step, focused solely on quieting Scarlett’s relentless sobs.
James helped him ascend the stairs, and Sirius returned to the bathroom, seating Scarlett on the edge of the bath, her face swollen, her expression utterly desolate. He swallowed the urge to weep and drew a deep breath, turning to his friend.
“Could you fetch a couple of towels?” he said, regaining his composure. James nodded and slipped away, leaving them alone.
Scarlett didn’t have the courage to look at him, keeping her head bowed, arms wrapped around herself and trembling violently as though she were freezing. Sirius began to unwrap his arm, Scarlett could see the white bandage falling onto the light‑coloured floor mottled with soot. Then he removed his clothes.
“Lift your arms,” Sirius instructed, and Scarlett did so without so much as moving her eyes. He pulled off her pyjama top, then her bottoms, and unwound the bandage from her forearm.
She heard the shower start and felt the steam caress her skin. Sirius set her upright as though she were a doll, and hot water cascaded over her head, creating strange echoes, running into her ears and dripping from the tip of her nose. Her cheeks stung from crying and she pressed her swollen lips together.
“Close your eyes.”
Scarlett obeyed, sensing Sirius’s warm fingertips gently rubbing the grime from her face. Then he placed a soft kiss on her forehead, her cheeks, the tip of her nose and on her lips. She shrank, lowering her head to stare at her right forearm. The burn had turned into a raised, reddened scar crossing her skin and continuing onto Sirius’s arm.
“I’m going to wash your hair now, all right?”
She nodded, squeezing her eyes shut as Sirius’s fingers carefully massaged her scalp. Scarlett’s whole body tingled, as if in that moment everything were right. Suds bubbled through her locks and Sirius allowed himself a small smile as he piled her hair on top of her head in a loose bun.
Scarlett half‑closed her eyes, startled by the laugh that reverberated around the bathroom walls. No sooner had Sirius’s smile appeared than it faded; water ran down his cheeks, plastering his dark hair to his shoulders and dripping from his long lashes.
Sirius touched the curve of her neck with the tip of his finger, then slowly trailed it down her breast and over her abdomen, until he slid his hand to her waist and drew her into another embrace. There was no malice, nor desire—this was a side of Sirius Scarlett wasn’t yet acquainted with; each touch was a gesture of care steeped in comfort.
Scarlett felt her hair loosen and tumble down her back as he rinsed it, the water sweeping the suds from her locks and washing over her skin. Sirius ran his fingers through the strands slowly, his nose resting against her forehead as he traced a gentle caress down her spine.
And she hugged him back, listening to Sirius’s heart beating in time with her own, breaking the silence of the bathroom and holding all her pieces together. Scarlett’s heart pounded so fiercely she felt numb, detached, in shock. She drew a deep breath, her chest contracting painfully as she exhaled.
Sirius turned off the shower and carefully wrapped Scarlett in a towel, pulling her into another tight, comforting embrace. Scarlett didn’t even reciprocate. He was soaking the entire bathroom, but he didn’t seem to mind, trying to offer her any sort of consolation in the warmth of that closeness.
He kissed her forehead and stepped into the shower himself. Scarlett remained standing, staring at her wet toes, her hair dripping onto the pale tiles, clutching the towel as if it were something very precious. Sirius emerged from the cubicle, a cloud of steam trailing him. He dried himself off and led Scarlett back to the bedroom, where she noticed something was different.
The bed had been made and clean clothes lay on top of it. Scarlett thought she was in her own room and believed everything was all right. But the ashes clinging to the window shattered her illusion, shaking her chest and tearing at the chords of her heart. The pain was so sharp and intense that she felt dizzy, dislocated, her mind striving to push those thoughts away as she tried to process what had happened.
“Raise your arms,” Sirius murmured. Scarlett didn’t hear him, too lost in her grief. In her melancholy. “Love…” He placed his warm hand on her shoulder. Scarlett stared at his reddened fingers, the dirty nails, the fine hairs on the back of his hand, the greenish trace of his veins winding along his wrist, forearm and biceps, the tips of his damp hair, his perfect lips, his sculpted nose… his starry eyes.
“What?” Scarlett whispered so softly that Sirius didn’t catch it.
“Raise your arms,” he repeated calmly.
Scarlett let the towel drop as she lifted her arms, feeling the nightshirt slide down her body, clinging to the dampness of her hair. She gasped, recoiling, as though with every beat of her heart the loss was being infused into her blood, coursing through her veins, muscles, tendons and organs.
It was as if reality wore a matte veil she could not penetrate—too distant to touch, yet close enough to graze its coarse surface across her skin, branding her forever with what had occurred. She looked once more at the scar on her forearm, unmoved when Sirius combed through her hair, murmuring apologies whenever a tangle tugged.
Scarlett didn’t open her mouth. It was as though she weren’t really there, as if the true Scarlett had plunged into the flames and this was merely her shell—hollow inside and motionless on the outside. She sat on the edge of the bed, her limbs tingling and her head buzzing. She punched her chest, sobbing, trying to quell the frantic burn piercing her.
Two light taps sounded at the door. Scarlett saw Sirius’s feet shifting in a calculated dance.
He placed a plate of pancakes, smothered in maple syrup, on her lap. Scarlett dropped her gaze slowly, lethargic, staring at her reflection in the amber pool. It looked like someone else looking back, a fissure of herself, a twisted, exfoliated fragment.
“You need to eat,” Sirius murmured, his bright silver-grey eyes narrowing, one hand resting on her knee, the other supporting the plate.
“I’m not… I’m not hungry,” Scarlett heard herself say, turning her head.
“You need to eat,” he insisted, glancing towards someone in the doorway.
“I’m not hungry,” Scarlett repeated like a scratched record.
Sirius sighed, brushing his thumb across her cheek. It was subtle, yet so attentive that Scarlett felt alive for a moment. But then grief swallowed every colour and meaning.
She lay back on the bed, moving as though each twitch required a monumental effort. It was as if the very air stung her with tiny needles at every shift—and none of those pricks was as intense as the one that stole her heartbeat and turned the air in her lungs into molten lava.
Sirius lay down behind her, his warm breath ruffling her hair at the nape of her neck, ghosting across her cheeks, drying her eyes.
“I’m here, all right?” Sirius murmured, holding her as if he could steal away her burden, as if he could fill the void left by her loss or, at least, pretend that everything was all right. Scarlett gave a slight nod, sobbing copiously as her tears returned.
Sirius threaded his fingers through her hair, kissing her brow and dabbing at her tears. But even that bright, glowing warmth embracing them was not enough to soften her pain.
Nothing would be.
.
.
.
As soon as the sun shone in the dawn’s iridescent sky, Sirius gently disentangled himself from Scarlett. He didn’t want to wake her—and, truth be told, given how soundly she slept, he probably wouldn’t. He eased out of bed and changed quickly, taking care not to make a sound. Slinging an empty suitcase over his shoulder, he slipped from the room.
Sirius made his way to James’s chamber. James was already awake… or perhaps hadn’t slept at all. He stared at the Gaunts’ house through the dusty window until he became aware of a figure reflected in the glass, watching him over his own shoulder.
“Hey,” James murmured flatly.
Sirius forced a smile but couldn’t meet his friend’s eyes. “You could…” he began, words catching as a sob threatened to break free. He cleared his throat. “…stay with her? I… need to go to the bank. It’ll only be quick—I might even be back before she wakes.”
“Of course I can,” James replied, licking his lips and turning fully to him. “Are you all right?!”
There was genuine concern in his voice—one that made Sirius’s heart clench. He loved James dearly, but he despised his timing.
“I am,” Sirius lied swiftly. “Thanks… for looking after her.”
James saw straight through him but offered only a rueful smile. “Anytime you need, Padfoot.” He returned his gaze to the window.
Sirius hurried downstairs and found Thanatos seated at the table, filling out an enormous parchment while puffing on a cigar. Remus sat beside him with a cup of tea but rose when he saw Sirius enter.
“Ah, you’ve arrived,” Nate said, nodding at Remus to follow him.
“Have you spoken to her yet, Sirius?” Nate asked, lifting his gaze through the curling smoke.
“She… isn’t ready to make any decisions,” Sirius replied, swallowing hard to steady his voice.
Nate merely exhaled, returning to his report. Sirius and Remus then moved over to the fireplace, scooping a handful of Floo powder.
They emerged in Diagon Alley, where the sun had not yet pierced the shop roofs nor touched the cobbled streets. They climbed the white marble steps of Gringotts, crossed the vast foyer, and halted before a goblin whose expression was as unfriendly as ever. Sirius sympathised—he, too, detested early mornings. He produced the key to the vault from his pocket; the goblin clerk beckoned him onwards to the subterranean corridors.
The journey in the cart was silent. Sirius was usually captivated by how deftly goblins manoeuvred the narrow-gauge tracks through the tunnels, but not today. Instead, he sensed Remus’s gaze burning into the back of his neck and deliberately kept his eyes fixed on the dimly lit passage ahead.
Arriving at his vault and opening it, he was met with countless piles of gold. His uncle had amassed a considerable fortune before his death. Sirius stared at the coins for a long while, unsure of what to do. Remus took the suitcase from his shoulder and opened it.
“How much do you need?” he asked, turning to his friend, the coins casting golden reflections on his face.
“A lot. It’s for a house in London, and that must cost a small fortune,” Sirius ran a hand through his hair.
“You didn’t look at the price?” Remus raised an eyebrow, resting his hand on his knee. “You haven’t even seen the house?!”
“I didn’t have time!” Sirius snapped, defensive. He crouched beside Remus and began sweeping Galleons into the suitcase.
“I know, it’s just…” Remus helped him, hauling the case free with great effort. “You’ve not said a word until now.”
“There’s nothing to say.” Sirius gestured to the goblin, who charmed the case and loaded it onto the cart.
“Mate, it was in the paper,” Remus dropped his voice. “They’re saying it might have been the Death Eaters.”
Sirius put his hands on his hips, exhaling sharply as he looked at Remus.
“I don’t want to talk about it.” They resumed their seats in the cart.
“When will you want to talk, then?!” Remus sounded irritated, his face shadowed with concern. The full moon was nearing.
Sirius’s response was silence for the entire return journey. He changed all that gold into Muggle money and descended the marble steps; the sun now slanted across the floor, and a few shops were beginning to open.
“Sirius…” Remus’s hand clenched on his shoulder, forcing him to halt midway down the Floo landing. “Stop suffering in silence!”
Sirius gripped the strap of the suitcase between his fingers, grinding his teeth to suppress everything he’d been through. He shot a sharp glance at Remus, flaring his nostrils.
“I’m not suffering in silence,” Sirius hissed, shoving Remus with his free hand. “I’m holding the reins of the situation and… being the strong link.”
“You don’t have to be strong all the time, Pads!” Remus grabbed the collar of his T‑shirt. “I’m here, I’m your friend, for fuck’s sake!”
Sirius exhaled slowly in a weak, bitter laugh.
“I need to be strong for her,” he said, rubbing his face, fighting back the urge to cry. “I can’t fall apart—not now, not when she needs me. Because I’m all she has left and only I can gather her pieces. Maybe I won’t succeed, maybe everything I’m doing is in vain and she’ll keep hating and blaming me, but I have to try.” Sirius thrust a hand into his hair, scratching fiercely. “Scarlett… she showed me the best side of love and never gave up on me… not even when I was a right arse and…I…I…I need to be strong, Remus, so I’m going to pack everything I feel into a coffin and bury it in my chest, and maybe one day—someday—I’ll allow myself to feel what I ought to feel. But not now. She needs me.” He spoke without pause, gasping for breath.
“Sirius… that isn’t healthy,” Remus whispered, still holding him.
Sirius spread his hand out and took a heavy step back.
“Healthy…” he muttered mockingly. “Do you know what would be healthy, Remus? Not losing your bloody family to arson!” he shouted at the top of his lungs, the words echoing off the still-closed shopfronts of Diagon Alley.
“I’m not talking about her—I’m talking about you! You can’t take on the whole world and pretend everything’s fine, you can’t shoulder all that weight by yourself! It won’t do you any good!” Remus raised his voice in turn, standing tall. He was taller than Sirius, yet it still wasn’t enough to intimidate his friend.
“I’m not a selfish bastard like you!” Sirius accused, pointing his finger at Remus. “And I’m no coward who thinks the answer to everything is pushing away my friends!”
Remus let out a strangled laugh—not one of joy.
“But that’s exactly what you’re doing!” he exclaimed, spreading his arms. “Pushing away everyone who’s trying to help you!”
“You want to help me, Remus?!” Sirius forced his expression and voice into control to keep from breaking down. “I need a house with five bedrooms, a garage, a garden… the living room has to be big enough for a grand piano and…,” he panted, his body stiffening as he expelled the urge to weep, “a music shop nearby. And it has to be in London.”
Remus furrowed his brow, utterly taken aback.
“Tomorrow morning, we’ll go and look at that?” Remus approached him, gripping his shoulders.
Sirius nodded.
“Tomorrow, we’ll go and look.” Sirius repeated, as Remus embraced him. He pressed his lips together and wrinkled his nose, battling against the tears that threatened to prick his eyes.
He pulled himself together swiftly, forcing a smile as he turned back towards the Floo grate.
.
.
.
Thanatos Gaunt settled into his armchair, watching the colourful sprites dance across the television screen.
Regulus, perched on the sofa, had his eyes glued to the newly purchased Mega Man 6, lips parted and barely blinking.
“Be careful… the floor’s going to catch fire…” Nate warned, sipping his blackcurrant rum.
Regulus maintained his dazed expression, all his concentration focused on manoeuvring his fingers over the Super Nintendo controller’s buttons. Nate took the opportunity to sift through the pile of mail, skimming the letters with disinterest as he scratched at his greying goatee.
“This boss is a nightmare…” Regulus muttered during the battle with Flame Man.
Thanatos raised his eyebrows when he saw that the Hogwarts letter contained more than he’d anticipated.
“Reg…” he called to his nephew. Regulus paused the game and turned to face his uncle. “You’ve been appointed a prefect this year… congratulations.” Nate offered a proud smile and patted the boy’s shoulder. “Top of the class, eh?”
Regulus beamed from ear to ear as he took the letter from his uncle, slightly incredulous, especially after all the pranks he’d pulled alongside Luana. But he was easily one of Slytherin’s best students in his year, despite the Potions Master’s disdain and his slip‑ups in Divination classes (which he particularly loathed and had no intention of attending in his fifth year).
“Your father was a prefect too.” Thanatos resumed sipping his whisky, crossing his legs.
“Yeah, I know.” Regulus’s smile vanished, the telly casting vivid colours across the freckles on his cheeks.
“Your uncle told me what you did,” Nate said, growing serious as he swirled his glass. “He wants to have a word with you…”
“I don’t want to talk to him.” Regulus huffed, unpausing the game and pretending to be too busy defeating Flame Man to continue the discussion.
“I don’t think you have a choice in the matter, young man.” Thanatos replied condescendingly, which only made Regulus glare back at him and see Mega Man immolated by the boss.
“You’ve lied to me all these years!” he retorted, his voice rising. He threw the controller onto the table as he stood.
“It wasn’t that important…”
“It wasn’t that important to tell me that my mother loved my uncle and not my father?!” His voice drowned out his great‑uncle’s.
“Reg…” came the warning. “She’s dead.”
“I know she’s dead! I’m reminded of it every bloody day!” he panted, tossing his hair back and striding to the fireplace.
“What are you doing?!”
“I’m going to see my uncle. I don’t want to be caught between… the two of you.” Regulus spoke the last words with remorse. “I don’t know what happened between you, but… it’s pathetic watching you both pretend everything’s fine.”
Thanatos squeezed the glass, his knuckles whitening. Regulus knew he’d struck a sore spot for his great‑uncle, the failed relationship with Remus. Nate exhaled, closing his eyes.
“Sometimes… no matter how much you love someone, no matter how hard you try to make it work… it’s just not enough.” He moistened his lips, downing the contents of the glass in one. He cleared his throat. “I think that’s what happened with your mother and Uncle Sirius.”
Regulus clenched his fists, his jaw tightening. He grabbed the Floo Powder and left his great‑uncle without a reply, appearing at Remus’s house.
No. At the house that was his too, because originally that home belonged to Sirius…
And he was Sirius’s heir, therefore the house was his.
The kitchen light was on, as was Remus’s bedroom. Regulus walked down the dark corridor, the yellow glow bathing him as he knocked softly on his uncle’s door. His gaze invariably halted at the entrance to the next room… Sirius’s room.
Regulus pressed his lips together.
“Come in, Reg.” Remus’s voice drove him from those thoughts. Regulus pushed the door open with a creak and saw his uncle seated on the bed with a book in his lap. “How are you?”
“I’m struggling to get past Flame Man…” he murmured, a hint of irony in his tone.
Remus smiled, closing his book gently, and motioned for him to sit in the desk chair. Regulus obeyed, but the light atmosphere between them quickly grew tense.
“I received my Hogwarts letter today… I’ve been appointed a Slytherin prefect.” He offered a shy smile.
“Congratulations, Reggie. You deserve it, and… on that note…” Remus leaned back against the headboard. “I’ve been appointed Professor of Defence Against the Dark Arts this year.”
“What?!” Reg couldn’t believe what he was hearing. “Seriously?!”
“Yes, really. That’s what I wanted to tell you at dinner…” Remus’s smile vanished, weariness etching his features. “Listen, Reg, I never meant… to lie to you.”
Regulus hugged the back of the chair, resting his chin on it.
“Then why lie? Why always avoid the subject of my parents? I know about the war… I know what she did… it’s just that…”
Remus’s gaze was fixed on his nephew, but then it drifted far away, to a time when he’d been frightened and alone, when everyone he loved was imprisoned or dead. He shuddered; his mouth went dry, and it was hard to swallow.
“We were friends, you know that… all of us. Me, your mother… Sirius… Peter, James and Lily…”
“Potter’s parents…” Reg muttered acidly.
“Yes, Harry’s parents,” Remus scratched at the scar on his chin. “Scarlett… loved playing the piano. She could sit on the stool for hours, playing one melody after another… she was brilliant at Queen, Pink Floyd… but what she truly loved was playing Toto.”
“I know, I have all her Toto tapes…” Regulus said with an uneasy smile, not taking his eyes off his uncle.
“There was something I dare say she loved more than playing the piano…” Remus blinked several times, as if trying to recall something just out of reach. “It was Sirius. They loved each other dearly, Reg. It was an intense love, a burning… overwhelming love. We couldn’t see it at first because we were young and naive, but… oh, they were in love, they loved each other so much that they destroyed themselves.”
Regulus raked his fingers over the wood of the chair, listening eagerly, remembering the photograph of Sirius and his mother kissing passionately. But then… why wasn’t Sirius his father?!
“They fought because of your father.” Remus continued, as if reading his thoughts. “Scarlett… thought she could save him. From the Death Eaters. She left and never came back and, a few weeks later, married your father… some said they’d been together the whole time. It affected your Uncle Sirius deeply, not just psychologically but during the war… he nearly died searching for her.”
Regulus looked away. He’d heard a great deal about his mother from his uncle Orfeu and, even knowing most of it was lies planted by the Death Eaters, Orfeu always insisted how treacherous and vile she was. His heart tightened at the thought that maybe he was right. Why would she do that to Sirius?! Especially if they loved each other so much…
“Shortly afterwards, you were born. You were premature, so you needed special care. Peter, Lily, James and I took turns helping Sirius with you. It was a difficult time because… he already had issues with drinking and after Scarlett left, it got much worse and then you arrived and… Sirius was broken. Desolate. And then came his betrayal and…” Remus’s eyes filled with tears. “It made no sense, because Sirius and James were inseparable, they could speak with a look. But you were his priority, Reg and… I don’t know, I… I think… that he did it because if Voldemort won, Scarlett would be set free and then… and then you might have a family…” He buried his face in his hands again, sobbing quietly.
“So… it was for my sake?!” Regulus asked, his mouth twisting in disgust.
“No! That’s not what I meant…” Remus sighed, rubbing his eyes. “Sirius was so impulsive and… maybe… maybe he… I… I don’t know, Reg,” he confessed, fixing those brown eyes on Regulus. “The war changed everyone. We were forced to grow up overnight.”
Regulus tapped his heel against the floor, anxiously. “Did it change my mother too? What was she like before the war?”
Remus stared into the past, his pupils reflecting a hundred bittersweet memories.
“She changed after her parents died and Orfy was caught… in the fire.” He shifted on the bed. “She and Sirius moved in together not long after… Reg, your mother was… besotted with Sirius. Back at school, he outshone everyone. He always loved the limelight, the centre of attention, and he was… suffocating. And Scarlett was utterly blind for him. She would have done anything for him… even if it meant getting herself expelled. It’s not as if she cared much back then… after losing her parents, she became very withdrawn. She suffered a great deal. And Sirius was equally mesmerised by her… he was the one who convinced us to take Scarlett to the McKinnons’ before… before it all, before Marlene’s uncle was murdered and before everyone became Secret Keepers. I didn’t suspect anything at the time because Sirius was so affected by Marl’s death, but… I suppose… I suppose he was a very good actor, because…”
Silence. Remus stifled a sob, pushing it away, running a hand through his brown hair shot with white. He was eighteen years younger than Thanatos, yet he looked every bit his age.
“What do you think he’s after? Sirius? My mother’s dead, so…” Regulus struggled to voice those harsh words. He was still reeling from so much information. He knew of his parents’ friendship, but had no idea of the details, let alone his mother’s love for his uncle.
It was unfair to have remained in the dark for so long, and Regulus couldn’t hide the hurt from Remus.
“I don’t know, Reg… honestly… I don’t know. I fear he might come after you… or Harry…”
“Why would he go after Potter?” Reg snapped.
“I don’t know… maybe… because he’s the Boy Who Lived…”
Regulus felt his chest swell with jealousy.
“What do you think of that? His escape…”
Remus shrugged, licking his lips. “Part of me wants him caught… to make him pay… another part still can’t believe what he’s done.” He ran a hand through his hair, staring at nothing for a few seconds before climbing down from the bed. “Come here, I want to show you something…”
Regulus followed Remus out of the room, stopping beside him in the corridor.
“Your uncle was a brilliant wizard. He set up an entire security scheme in this house because of you… not everyone who entered here had access to your room, only a select few. He devised an enchantment that conceals certain rooms from outsiders. Almost a Fidelius within a Fidelius…” Remus flourished his wand. “Totus Occulta.”
A door appeared between the studio and Sirius’s room. Regulus ran his fingers along the doorknob, glancing at Remus as if to ask permission. Remus nodded.
“When your mother married your father, your uncle placed her belongings in this room before it became yours, and he kept it like that even when you came to live with him.” Remus crossed his arms as Regulus opened the door, revealing a room much like Sirius’s, albeit with boxes piled in one corner and a few childish items in another.
He walked to the small table where several photographs of Scarlett and Sirius stood. There was one in particular of him kneeling, opening a small box, asking her to marry him. Regulus picked up the picture, a faint smile tugging at his lips as he took in his mother’s joyful expression.
“When she was imprisoned… the Ministry left this box of her things with your uncle.” Remus tapped the box on the bed. Regulus looked at him. “That’s why you saw nothing of theirs before… before you rummaged through the attic. Sirius left everything… everything that reminded him of her here. Except the drawing‑room piano.”
Regulus returned the photograph and stepped forward to the box at the edge of the bed, lifting the lid slowly. Inside was a miscellany of items. He pulled out a golden pocket watch and, upon opening it, found a photograph of a child sticking out their tongue. He sifted through some clothes, nudged an iron orb aside and noticed two glints at the bottom, picking them up.
Two engagement rings. One set with a black diamond and small brilliant‑cut diamonds. The other with a ruby and tiny diamonds along the band. He glanced back at the engagement photo and saw which ring came from the box: the one with the black stone. His gaze lingered on the ruby ring; he slipped it onto his little finger, where it fitted perfectly.
“Did she love him?” Regulus looked up at Remus, who watched him silently from the doorway. “My father… did she love him?”
Remus sighed. “I… I don’t know, Reg. They were very close friends… she called him Red, that was the… special nickname she gave him. But…” He drew in a steadying breath. “I think only she could have told you that.”
Regulus clenched the black‑stone ring in his palm until it hurt. He would never know. Scarlett was dead. He made a frustrated sound as he nodded.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 4: Love doesn’t evaporate when things get tough
Summary:
Scarlett tormenting Sirius with her bare presence.
Chapter Text
LXXII
The idea of leaving Scotland, going to London only to head straight back to Scotland was bloody stupid, but it was hard to think straight after more than ten years in Azkaban. Whiskers was already tired of racing across the open fields and through the forest, especially since Padfoot was slowing down by the minute and looked utterly exhausted.
They kept pressing north until Padfoot stopped, panting and wobbly. He settled himself among a tangle of thick roots, which made a perfect bed.
Whiskers let him rest and set off to hunt, followed by a spectral Prongs. At one point, James appeared, peering around with curiosity.
“I reckon I’ve been here before…” he muttered to himself, casting light into the gloom so that the cat could see a large rabbit hiding beneath the undergrowth.
She managed to catch the creature with relative ease thanks to James’s help, returning to Padfoot and dropping the prey before him. She nudged it with her paw as she backed away.
Padfoot turned his snout aside, ignoring her with a low whine.
Whiskers’ shadow stretched until it became a woman. Scarlett sighed, gripping the straps of her rucksack with both hands and gazing up at the leaves, lightly tinged yellow, above them.
“What’s up? You haven’t eaten all day…” Scarlett crouched, resting her arms on her knees as she stared at him. The dog avoided her gaze. “Hey…” She reached out her hand, stroking his matted fur. Padfoot cowered, licking his flank. “Go on, you can eat it; there’s a spare bar left…”
Padfoot sneezed and barked, reluctantly sinking his teeth into the rabbit.
“Don’t bark at me!” Scarlett pressed on. “I know you’re injured. And in pain. Do you want me to take a look or…”
He snarled as he ate, intimidating her with his pale eyes.
“You’re feeling rough, aren’t you? It’s not rotten food—it’s the fourth day, and you just seem to be getting worse.” She straightened as she stood.
Padfoot paid her no mind, too occupied with his dinner. Scarlett huffed and opened her rucksack, munching on one of the bars—foul-tasting—as she sat on a root, her eyes never leaving the dog.
Sirius was a prat, and that stubborn streak was far worse in his canine form… or perhaps he was just as bloody stubborn as a dog.
“Sirius…” she called. Padfoot wagged his tail but didn’t even turn to look at her. “Sirius, this is serious.”
Scarlett drew her wand from her pocket, and Padfoot truly trusted her—he barely moved. She waited until he’d finished eating and immediately forced him to shift back, the dog’s body stretching until the man appeared, unsteady and bewildered.
“What the fuck, Scarlett?!” he ground out.
“What the fuck do you mean, I should ask you!” she shot back, pointing her wand at him, impatient. It wasn’t the first time she’d done this.
Azkaban hadn’t been kind to Sirius; yet he looked worse than he had there. Deep shadows ringed his eyes, and an intense pallor had washed over his drawn face, stealing whatever colour remained from his lips and leaving them trembling.
“I’m fine!” Sirius rolled his eyes, waving his hand as though begging her to drop it.
“You look bloody awful!” Scarlett shot back.
“I spent twelve years in Azkaban; awful is still bloody brilliant!” he retorted, running a hand through his hair impatiently.
Scarlett lunged at Sirius with astonishing speed, gripping his pale throat so swiftly he didn’t have time to react, lungs gulping air, eyes wide as though she were about to attack him.
“You’re burning up with fever!” Scarlett snapped, prompting him to jerk away roughly.
“Don’t… touch me!” Sirius growled, pressing a hand where Scarlett had touched him, as though wounded. He blinked, lethargic, breathing irregularly. “Leave me alone.”
“Sirius… let me see!” Scarlett lowered her voice, as though tending to an injured pup.
He shook his head, twisting his features, unable to meet her gaze.
“It’s nothing, for fuck’s sake…” he muttered, pulling away.
He moved so slowly that Scarlett easily caught up with him, cornering him against a massive tree trunk. She clenched her fists, a strange worry lodging itself in her chest.
In truth, that worry had always been there—especially when she was certain they’d force her to kill him. Since they’d fled Azkaban, however, the feeling had lain dormant only to wake sharp and poignant.
Why were her heartbeats racing and her pupils dilating? Her mouth had gone dry.
“Come one, Sirius! It’s your waist, isn’t it?!” Scarlett insisted, unembarrassed as Sirius’s shadow enveloped her silhouette, tall and indistinct.
“I’m fine!” Sirius wrapped his arms around himself, closing his features as he looked up at the wind whispering through the trees. “It was… stupid. I’d kept a vial of poison, and when you used that spell on the veil, it shattered… but… it was just glass.”
The shadows of the leaves danced across his face, the muscles of his jaw standing out as he clenched his teeth. A bead of sweat glistened as it ran from his sideburns to his beard.
“Pull your trousers down.” Scarlett ordered, still holding her wand. It didn’t take long for him to register her words, and a wicked little grin tugged at his lips.
Her cheeks burned. It was as if, for a second, they were teenagers.
“Are you sure?” Sirius asked, though he didn’t show it openly—Scarlett knew he was enjoying this.
“Oh, Sirius, it’s nothing I haven’t seen before!” She slipped her wand into her pocket, crossing her arms and rolling her lips in contempt.
“You spent fifteen years without seeing…” Even weakened, he continued the teasing, swollen with pride.
“Sirius!” Scarlett scolded him.
“Okay… okay!” Sirius grabbed the waistband of his trousers and lowered them just enough for Scarlett to see dark veins snaking across his iliac bone, which jutted out sharply from his thinness. Her gaze slid aside against her will to where his dark hair trailed from his navel down to…
“That looks like tentacle venom…” Lily, a little behind her, remarked.
Scarlett jolted, her hand flying to her chest.
“Got you frightened? I thought you’d seen it before…” Sirius taunted in his lazy drawl, earning Scarlett’s withering glare.
Why was he acting like that?
“Shut up,” Scarlett muttered, hauling his trousers back up with more force than necessary.
Sirius didn’t take his eyes off her for a moment, sending her heart racing.
“Sirius’s luck is that the venom isn’t very concentrated; the bad news is that if it isn’t treated… he’ll die,” Lily said so calmly that Scarlett blinked, stunned. She rubbed her eyes. “You’re going to need to brew an antidote.”
“It’s tentacle venom, Sirius,” Scarlett murmured. “You need an antidote.”
“What?!” He almost shouted. “That’s not fucking funny, Scarlett”
“I’m not joking.” She tried to sound serious, but her cheeks were burning and she could barely meet his gaze.
Sirius grew sombre, narrowing his eyes at her as the wind tossed his dark locks over his pallid face.
“I’m not going to die because of some bloody stupid venom after surviving twelve bloody years in prison!” Sirius sniffed, wiping sweat from his brow with the collar of his shirt. “How exactly are we meant to make the antidote?”
Scarlett looked to Lily, who was stroking her chin in thought.
“Assuming you can’t get a mandrake any time soon… dittany, lavender essence, blind-worm mucus and pink-pod spores. We’ll need a cauldron. The good part is most ingredients can be foraged… ” Lily flicked her red hair over her shoulder. “The bad part is getting hold of a cauldron.”
“I need a cauldron,” Scarlett said to Sirius, exhaling. “Where are we?”
He lifted his gaze to the clear sky, orienting himself by the stars. Strands of moonlight filtered through the leaves, caressing his ashen cheeks, thick beard and long hair, turning his silver eyes to platinum. Scarlett would never grow used to his beauty, even in his cadaverous thinness and ghostly pallor.
“We’re coming up on the Scottish border now.” Sirius lowered his eyes to her, swallowing hard.
“Coming up on the border?” James, standing a little way off, cast his light between Sirius and Scarlett as he stepped between them. “Hold on… ask him where exactly…”
Scarlett crouched and pulled the map from her rucksack, unfolding it and using Lumos to illuminate their route.
“Show me on the map.” Scarlett turned the paper towards him and Sirius thrust his trembling finger where it read: Kielder Forest.
“There’s an Order hideout here!” James peered at the map beside his friend as though he could actually see it. “Padfoot and I were there on one of our missions—he’ll remember it!”
Scarlett moistened her lips, thinking what to say.
“You’ve never been here before, have you? On your… missions… or something?” she raised an eyebrow nonchalantly.
Sirius stared at her doubtfully, his sunken eyes probing the recesses of his mind. Then he pressed his lips into a thin line and slowly shook his head. “I… I don’t… I can’t remember.”
Scarlett looked at James, then back at him. “It’s all right. We’ll manage…” She tried to infuse confidence into her words, but there was a pang of desperation too.
“Bloody hell, I escape that Azkaban hellhole only to…” Sirius ran a hand across his face in frustration. “Why can’t things go right for… two fucking minutes?!” He leaned back against a tree trunk with a sigh, staring up at the canopy.
“I think I know where the hideout is.” James removed his spectacles and rubbed the bridge of his nose. “Come on, Scar, it’s this way…”
“I’m just off for a piss; be right back…” Scarlett announced, hesitating before she shifted. “You’d better stay in Padfoot’s form for now.”
“If you need anything, shout.” Sirius barely registered what she said.
Scarlett transformed into Whiskers and darted after James, who was now in Prongs form. The stag moved gracefully through the forest, and Scarlett followed its ethereal glow. The warm night breeze ruffled her whiskers and soon they halted in a small clearing, where the moonlight flooded in, brushing the grass with silver.
“Use Revelio…” James instructed, scanning for the hideout.
Scarlett drew her wand and cast the spell; the magic swirled around them in a blue-tinted shield, radiating out until it struck something nearby and revealed it with a subtle flash. They exchanged glances and Scarlett reached out to touch the glow, but James halted her with a gesture. “It’s protected. You won’t get in.” He slid his glasses up his nose, hands on his hips.
“Then why the hell did you bring me here?!” Scarlett exhaled, uneasy.
“Sirius was in the Order, he’ll probably manage…” James shook his head, as if it were obvious. “What’s wrong?”
“What do you think?!” Scarlett didn’t spare the irony in her tone, but she had to swallow the tears that threatened to spill from her eyes.
He opened and closed his mouth several times, regarding her with such pity that Scarlett felt sick. She loved James—she always had, even after she walked away—but damn, she hated that look of his. And he’d given it so many times that she simply stopped telling him things. She hated feeling like a poor little thing.
“There must be… cauldrons in there. Or something similar… can’t you conjure one?” he asked softly.
“It’s been so long since I’ve seen a cauldron that I’m not even sure what one looks like… I don’t want to risk being attacked by some unknown object if the conjuration goes wrong.” Scarlett gave an awkward smile, rubbing her hands together. “I’ll call Padfoot…”
James only nodded, remaining where he was. Lily soon emerged from the trees and he embraced her tightly. Despite trying not to show it, he was holding back tears. Seeing his son for just a moment was enough to freeze his legs and open a wound in his heart that would never heal.
Lily stroked his tousled hair, choked with nostalgia at having Harry in her arms, singing to him, putting him to bed. Why was he out there in the street like that? Just thinking about it…
She’d truly hoped Petunia would be good to her son. She’d never met her nephew Dudley—the war had prevented it and, even before she died, she knew her son might fall into his aunt and uncle’s hands. She just hadn’t expected it to happen so tragically… because, whoever Sirius was, he’d loved Harry with all his heart and been a faultless godfather.
It hurt so much to see him and not even be able to touch him or tell him how much she loved him…
James wiped the tears from Lily’s cheeks, kissing her gently. “He needs to be cleared…” she murmured. “Harry… and Reg…”
“I know.” James held her close. “And he will… but… what about Scar?”
Lily sniffed, seeking the gaze of the man she loved so much, those hazel eyes that left her enraptured.
“We’ll hound her until she comes round… and at least tells Harry how much we love him.”
“I think he already knows that.” James smiled, tucking a red lock behind her ear.
“It’s never too much to say you love someone.” She smiled too, pressing their noses together. “I love you.”
James closed his eyes. The moonlight washed over them, pale and dancing, giving the impression they were one.
“I love you too.”
They parted when Scarlett appeared with Padfoot, who promptly turned back into Sirius. He looked very weak, though he hated to show it. Colour drained from his face and his eyes seemed heavy; sweat dotted his forehead.
“How did you find this place?” Sirius opened the door and for a moment Scarlett saw nothing. Gradually, however, the cottage revealed itself: the moss‑covered stone walls, the simple wooden door, the tall chimney.
Sirius plunged into the darkness of the house and Scarlett hesitated.
“I… sniffed it out.” She bit her lower lip as she stepped in, spotting Sirius’s silhouette holding his wand with Lumos alight at the end. “I think there’s a bit of, er, ancient magic in here…”
Sirius didn’t seem to doubt her—if he did, he showed no sign of it. The cottage comprised only one room besides the bathroom. It was devoid of furniture, and the fireplace bore a huge scorch mark climbing up to the roof. In the corners, rubbish was scattered, and Sirius hissed at the sight of the filthy floor.
“It’s less unhealthy to sleep out in the woods than in here.” He grumbled quietly, the Lumos glow rendering him as white as a ghost.
“I’ll sort everything…” Scarlett opened a window to let in some air. “Accio cauldron!”
A small cauldron flew towards her, spinning relentlessly. Scarlett was struck square in the chest, her back slamming against the wall as all the air whooshed from her lungs. She coughed several times, hearing Sirius’s footsteps moving towards her.
“You alright?” he asked, concern in his voice.
“I’m fine…” Scarlett murmured, a whip of pain lancing through her ribs. She forced a smile through the grimace. “Really… I’m fine.”
“It’s small but it’ll do…” Lily said, her head poking in through the window into the room.
Scarlett gave a startled jolt, dropping the cauldron then snatching it before it could fall again with uncanny dexterity. Sirius frowned, raising a hand before his face as though the Lumos light was beginning to irritate him.
“What’s wrong with you?!” Sirius’s mouth tightened into a crease. “That’s the second time you’ve been startled like that…”
“Nothing.” Scarlett replied so softly he only understood because he read her lips. She began to wave her wand, using Evanesco on the rubbish and enchanting the remains of a broom so it swept the excess dirt outside.
“I’m not going to hurt you, Scar.” Sirius’s voice was thick with hurt, but also regret. “No one will ever hurt you like that again.”
Scarlett fixed him with a stern look, her eyes wary. A doubtful crease formed slowly on her brow.
“I thought we’d moved past that.” She gathered her hair in her hands and tied it back. “Making broken promises.” She looked at him again, now with coldness.
Before Azkaban, Sirius had a ready answer for everything. That Sirius was gone, as light as dust in the wind; the stupid, frivolous, arrogant youth had been ripped from his core, leaving behind a man haunted by too many ghosts and too little courage.
Scarlett lit a few candles and conjured a bed, gesturing for him to lie down. Sirius felt profoundly uneasy about the situation; he hated being the weak link, especially with Scarlett making him feel like a helpless child. With a weary sigh, he lay down without hesitation.
The mattress wasn’t as good as the one at the hotel, but it was a damn sight better than a heap of roots and leaves. Scarlett spread a blanket over it and slid her rucksack under his head to serve as a pillow.
Scarlett’s auburn-tinted strands fell loose, brushing his shoulders and lightly grazing his face. Sirius caught a lock of hair between his forefinger and thumb, the flame from the candles glowing on the strands until they gleamed copper.
“You cut your hair,” Sirius murmured, trailing his fingertips across the dark strands. He’d expected Scarlett to drop her gaze and blush, but instead she fixed him with an impetuous look, her eyes piercing his like silver forging into gold.
Sirius’s heart hammered in his chest. Scarlett took his hand and, for a moment, he was certain she was going to force him to let his hair fall. Yet all she did was drink him in with her gaze, her cool fingertips stuck to his sweaty palm. He felt a figure bend over him and press a kiss to his lips—a reflection of a long-ago day when she’d tended to him just the same.
Scarlett’s gaze roamed over his face, lingering on his mouth. She let out a weak, sour laugh before abruptly stepping back. Sirius remained lying there, staring up at the wailing shadows on the ceiling, his heart pounding in his ears.
He ran a hand over his sweaty face; his head was heavy and his body limp. Lost in thought, he wondered if this was the fevered dream of a dying man in Azkaban. It made sense, in a perverse way—perhaps it was all the invention of his delirious mind and he was still trapped and hallucinating.
It was almost ironic, a touch perverse, that he’d broken out with the only person in the world who made his blood fizz with hate and hallucinate with desire. He gasped, clutching the blanket between his fingers; a whirlwind of emotions caressed his cheeks, clawed at his chest, whispered indecencies in his ear and slapped insults at his very core.
No matter how much he denied it, Scarlett still held immense power over him. He was just a mortal man who’d suffered for love, who’d never stopped thinking of the woman disguised as a succubus who’d abandoned him with the same fervour that had tamed him. The woman who had forced him to care for her son, that mixture of hate and love, the boy he’d so desperately wished was his own.
He was so dazed that he barely noticed the air wheezing in and out of his chest, nor the sweat that plastered his hair to the nape of his neck; or the gentle night breeze drifting in through the half‑open window. He felt horribly ill and exhausted, but he wouldn’t succumb to sleep—not until Scarlett returned.
If only there were a charm to make him forget her just as the Dementors had dissolved his memories…
Sirius jolted as he heard the door open, only now registering the sound of drizzle outside. The ajar window spattered icy droplets against his arm and he rubbed his eyes, sighing. Scarlett raised her wand and ignited the space beneath the cauldron, seating herself with her legs crossed sideways towards him.
Scarlett shot him a worried look and he nodded, as if to say he was all right. She worked the cauldron with adept hands, as though she hadn’t spent fifteen years without touching one, murmuring incantations he couldn’t quite catch.
She was talking to herself. That much was certain. A fact Sirius deliberately chose to ignore. Scar may not have lost as many memories as he had, but just imagining what she must have endured all those years in Azkaban…
Sent chills ran down his spine. His eyes kept drifting to Scarlett, against his will; she drew his gaze so effortlessly that resisting felt futile. The dance of candlelight on her skin was hypnotic, her blue eyes shifting to a purple hue. It was slightly unnerving how she’d scarcely aged—there wasn’t a single wrinkle at the corners of her eyes, on her cheeks, or on her eyelids.
She was the same Scarlett he’d loved and cared for, whom he’d hurt and lost. As if they were still seventeen with a whole life ahead of them. Yet her eyes betrayed her age; there was suffering in them. Always had been, to tell the truth… but never so intense, nor so deep. It was rooted in her, just like her melancholy and introversion.
Scarlett ladled the potion into a vial and filled a bottle with water using Aguamenti. She extinguished the cauldron, allowing thick smoke to slither across the floor as she crossed to Sirius.
“Can you sit up?” she asked, placing the water and potion in a corner of the bed, her expression solemn.
Sirius wet his lips, the salty tang of sweat coating his palate. He pulled a face. He could sit up, but he didn’t want to, so he simply shook his head.
Scarlett exhaled and crawled onto the mattress, rolling Sirius onto his side. He let himself go slack, making her task far more difficult when she slid her arms beneath his chest and hauled him upright, his back resting against her torso.
With a weary sigh, Sirius allowed himself to rest his head on her chest, drinking in her hair as the sharp scent of belonging stunned him. Scarlett’s breath brushed against his forehead and he hesitated before opening his eyes, staring at her in the suffocating silence.
“You’re freezing,” Sirius murmured, shadows dancing across Scarlett’s face as the candles flickered.
“You’re the one who’s burning up, Sirius,” she replied, holding the vial of potion in one hand while her other arm wrapped from his shoulder to his waist. “Drink.”
He grimaced as the foul potion rasped down his throat, making him want to be sick. Then he gulped down plenty of water, letting the antidote settle in his stomach. It felt… strange to be in her arms like that. He sensed something that even her presence in Azkaban hadn’t conveyed…
Safety. So sublime and sure that Sirius gasped when Scarlett laid him back down on the bed, the same sensation that had hit him when he’d embraced her at the hotel. He hated it, hated Scarlett for making him feel that way, and hated himself even more for allowing it—and for liking it.
Scarlett had been a Death Eater, had murdered the McKinnons… why… why couldn’t he stop loving her? The hate was there, stabbing at his heart, but so was the love. He never knew he could feel both so intensely, assumed they would cancel each other out. In that moment, they were simply two sides of the same coin.
“Are you hungry?” she asked, pulling him from that spiral of conflicting thoughts. “There’s still a bar left…”
Sirius’s mouth watered. It was true he’d eaten a rabbit in Padfoot’s form, but it hadn’t nearly been enough—for a dog, let alone a man.
“I’m not eating those revolting bars,” Sirius grumbled, curling up under the blanket.
Scarlett allowed a small smile to escape, pulling one out of her rucksack and chucked it onto the bed.
“Eat,” she commanded in that authoritative tone. Sirius flicked the bar off the bed with his fingertip, listening to it clatter on the floor. Scarlett drew in a steadying breath. “Sirius…”
“Scarlett,” he shot back, never taking his eyes off her, enjoying a rather privileged view as she bent to retrieve the bar.
“I’m not going out to hunt in this bloody rain…” she said, putting the packet back on the bed and thumping the mattress. “Come on, eat up.”
Sirius clenched his jaw, twisting his lips as he peeled back the metallic wrapper. He sniffed it and then licked the bar, making a face.
“What is that black stuff?” he bit carefully, waiting for an answer before he chewed.
Scarlett hugged herself and Sirius noticed that she was soaking wet from the rain.
“Something you hate a lot,” Scarlett said as she sat on the edge of the bed. “Eat up.”
Sirius regretted taking the bite, but forced himself to chew, ignoring the bittersweet taste. He pushed himself to eat the lot, drinking more water once he’d finished.
“Raisins and prunes are still abominable even after Azkaban,” Sirius remarked with a smile. Then he grew serious, his eyes widening little by little.
“You can smile, Sirius. There’s no Dementor about.” Scarlett kicked off her shoes and lay down, far enough away not to touch Sirius, and simply stared at the ceiling.
Sirius stayed motionless, his face turned towards her, Scarlett’s withdrawn figure and bare form taking on his shadows.
“I know,” Sirius murmured. Scarlett rolled her eyes at him without moving her head. “It’s just… hard…”
Sirius still felt disoriented, struggling to believe they’d escaped. He knew there were no Dementors here, that he wasn’t in Azkaban, yet something lodged deep in his soul still made him believe he was trapped. A fleeting stain that had burrowed so deep into the fissure of his mind after all that time incarcerated that… it seemed impossible to shake.
The candle flames crackled softly in resonance with the gentle rain outside. Scarlett’s eyes absorbed the trembling, yellowish light, her blue becoming tinged with orange.
She exhaled fully through her mouth.
“I was still bleeding,” she murmured softly, her voice wavering.
Sirius watched, rapt, as her neck muscles tensed and her jaw jutted out when she pressed her lips together.
“I… when I was arrested… the anaesthetic hadn’t even worn off properly yet,” Scarlett closed her eyes as if trying to contain something stronger than herself. “The trial… I replayed it in my head so many times… I forgot what your eyes looked like. I wanted so much… so much to tell you about Reg, I… I couldn’t, Sirius. I was too weak. They… they wouldn’t even let me see him… I didn’t… even hold him…” A tremor cut off her breath.
She placed her hand against her chest, clenching it there as if she could excise the pain tearing at her heart. Sirius didn’t want to cry, but Scarlett’s words seemed to dampen his eyes with ease.
“I wanted you to die.” He drew in a breath, massaging his throat, trying to ease the pressure there. “But when I saw you on that stretcher… drenched in blood… holding my hand… begging me to save your son… I…” He swallowed hard, fighting back a sob. “I regretted it.”
“I wanted to die.” She admitted, her voice barely a whisper.
Scarlett covered her face with her hands, her chest convulsing in unwanted sobs. Sirius didn’t dare look away—there was a grim satisfaction in seeing her cry like that, feeling how deeply it pained her, just as it had pained him. It was as though the scar she’d left on his soul was being cleansed by her tears.
It was a relief, in a way, to realise Scarlett wasn’t the psychopath he’d so feared, but simply a frightened girl swollen with grief. She remained his mirror image, his other half—the piece of himself he was at once ashamed of and fiercely proud to love.
“In Azkaban, I found out… it was Selwyn who tortured Orfy. And I made her pay…” She sniffed, brushing her tears away with the back of her hand, her gaze fixed on him.
Sirius didn’t know whom she meant, so he stayed silent, waiting for her to continue, but she only averted her eyes; the firelight flickering orange across her youthful features.
“He looks like you.” She pressed the Signet into the mattress with force. “Regulus.”
That was a low blow. So low that Sirius felt a lone tear slip from his eye like a falling star, tracing a line across his face, over the bridge of his nose and down his cheek until it vanished into the blankets.
“He used to call me Daddy.” Sirius licked his lips, meeting her gaze, allowing himself to be exposed. Scarlett had a knack for that—stripping him bare, leaving him raw and vulnerable. “I didn’t want to, but… James insisted, saying I was his father all the same… and I…” He rubbed his eyes. “I wanted to take Regulus’s place just as he had taken mine.”
Scarlett’s brow furrowed, her lips trembling as though on the verge of speech. She hesitated, curling in on herself, her eyes drifting into memories.
“Peter… what do you intend to do with him… when we catch him?” Scarlett’s blue eyes locked onto his, ominous and unyielding.
Sirius twisted his lips as a bitter tang stained his palate. Peter Pettigrew. He clenched his fists and ground his jaw as hard as a vice, half his face shrouded in gloomy shadow, the other half bathed in the warm glow of the candles.
The grey of his eyes deepened until it was leaden.
“I’m going to do what I should’ve done when I first found that bastard,” Sirius let his anger speak for him, his voice darkening with each word. “I’ll avenge James and Lily’s deaths. I’m going to kill him.”
Scarlett raised her eyebrows, as if doubting his words. Sirius watched her throat move as she swallowed, blinking and gathering her thoughts.
“Don’t do it, Sirius,” she pleaded.
“What?” Sirius huffed, frowning.
“James… he wouldn’t want you to.” Scarlett’s lower lip trembled, fear flickering in her eyes.
Sirius flared his nostrils and his eyes grew wide with exasperation.
“Yes, but James isn’t here, is he? And do you know why?” He raised his voice with every phrase. “I’ve killed once before—I can do it again.”
“Killing a stranger is… different from killing a friend,” Scarlett said so honestly that Sirius rolled his eyes.
“Marlene was innocent. Peter is guilty!” Sirius snapped, his gaze razor‑sharp. “He… he…”
“Do you think you can live with the weight of his death, Sirius?” Scarlett cut in, her voice barely a whisper.
The candles crackled softly. Sirius exhaled noisily through his nose.
“More than I already live with the weight of James and Lily’s deaths?!” he panted, each word cracking, each tear threatening to fall.
Scarlett shook her head.
“It wasn’t your fault, Sirius.”
“It bloody well was.” Sirius answered swiftly, feeling a sudden heat. “I was the one who suggested Peter—me…”
“And James agreed!” she replied, sorrow tinging her words, undeterred by his anger. “He agreed.”
“Yes, but if I… if I…” Sirius stammered, the air growing thin. “If I hadn’t…”
“Sirius…” Scarlett spoke his name so gently that he clenched his teeth.
“It was all my fault. You left, Reg died… I pushed Remus away, I… I killed James and Lily and…”
“No, Sirius…”
“I remember…” Sirius pressed on, ignoring her protest. “The arguments. I was drunk all the time. I hurt you, Scarlett… so many times… I knew I was hurting you and I kept going—I deserved to be alone. And yet, despite everything, you loved me. And I…” Sirius laughed, not in joy, tears spilling as he covered his face with one hand. "I would’ve left too, if I were you."
Scarlett was crying too.
Sirius and Scarlett had so much in common.
Pain was one of them.
Sirius let the emotions pour from his chest—coloured sparks and morbid shadows; a latent, fervent whirlwind brimming with regret and passion, everything he’d buried in his heart over twelve years of imprisonment: the deaths of his friends, the suffering inflicted by Dementors, the slender thread of hope that had kept him sane, the agonising choice between killing or rescuing Scarlett from that inferno.
They were all his facets, his reflections in a shattered mirror, his dark and cursed mosaic. The Sirius who gained and lost, the Sirius who loved and hurt, the Sirius who ended up alone when all he’d ever wanted was to protect those he loved.
Fault. That was what he’d always been—from the moment he was born, from the moment he’d grown up. His father had always told him he was a defective piece, something that not even the purest blood could redeem: a stain on the sacred Black lineage, so ancient and hallowed that it was already rotten.
Sirius Black clung to Scarlett as if he were falling and only she could save him from the inevitable plunge. He knew, however, that she was the anchor around his ankle and would make that fall all the more painful. Yet he didn’t let her go—he dragged her with him over the dark, vertiginous cliff, drowning her alongside him in his secrets and fears.
Scarlett stroked his hair slowly, numbing Sirius with the subtle gesture, sending shivers through his entire body. He was sweaty and still feverish; she was cold and trembling. Sirius inhaled the soft notes of Scarlett’s vanilla perfume. He knew it was all in his head—it was impossible for a scent to cling so strongly after fifteen years.
Yet, just as the perfume seemed present, so did the Scarlett he’d loved. And that only made him cry harder, soaking the dark blouse she wore, trying to speak when he could not, trying to squeeze her neck with the same violence he longed to kiss her. Scarlett had always been like this—she’d always awakened his demons with ease, made him feel so at home that he couldn’t be anyone but himself.
Sirius’s sobs took a long time to subside. Years and years of pent‑up feeling had been eating him from the inside. His chest was so battered now that it throbbed painfully from so much crying. Sirius’s fingers tangled in the fabric of Scarlett’s blouse, pulling her close, forcing her to hold him.
Sirius’s gaze travelled along Scarlett’s arm, watching the candlelight dance across her pale skin, her dark hair flowing like water, her clear eyes deep and enigmatic. He blinked several times, allowing his vision to focus on her heart‑shaped face, the freckles sprinkled across her nose and cheeks, and her lips pressed into a sad smile.
“‘You’re freezing,’” Sirius murmured hoarsely. He tugged the blanket over her, burying his face in her chest until he could hear the rapid beating of her heart, that organ which had once slipped so easily through his fingers.
Was Scarlett’s heart still his?
“I got a bit wet in the rain searching for the potion ingredients,” she said, her voice resonating against his ear in her ribcage. Sirius didn’t dare look at her—not when he felt so comfortable there. He could kill her as easily as possess her.
He ran his hand down her back, feeling the protruding bones of her spine beneath his fingertips. Azkaban had been unkind to both of them. Scarlett’s pulse gradually slowed, growing accustomed to Sirius’s presence, though it still beat with the same exhilaration he shared.
He drew in a deep breath, summoning every scrap of courage he had, and slowly lifted his gaze, plunging into the two clear blue pools of her eyes.
“It was Halloween,” Sirius began, pressing his face against her before pulling back slightly to look at her. “I… went to check on Wormtail, to make sure he was all right. But he wasn’t at the hideout. I panicked… there were no signs of a struggle. I grabbed Nancy and…” He gasped, feeling Scarlett press him tighter, her warmth scrambling his senses. “When I reached Godric’s Hollow, the Potters’ house… it was… in pieces.” He sobbed, though no tears fell. “Hagrid… was standing outside with Harry. I ran in… desperate… and…” Sirius began to hyperventilate, trying to banish the memories, the shock. “I chased after them… found James on the stairs… and Lily…”
Sirius felt Scarlett’s cold palm against his cheek and closed his eyes, intoxicated that he had shared this with someone—and that someone was her. He had dwelt on it far too long in Azkaban.
“I went after him. It was… it was easy. Wormtail… he couldn’t shake the tracking charm I’d placed on him. He was hiding in Muggle London… I didn’t even think to draw my wand when we started arguing… he blew up the street and vanished, fleeing into the sewers with the other rats… a dozen Muggles killed… their remains scattered everywhere…”
Scarlett brushed his tears away and Sirius felt overwhelmed by everything surging in his chest. He was spent not only from the poison but also from finally letting it all out, from sharing that pain with someone. No… it wasn’t just anyone. It was Scarlett. One of the reasons for his misery, his unhappiness, his misfortune. The girl with flowers in her hair who had carried him to heaven and abandoned him in hell. The woman who left him astonished and enraged.
The personification of his ruin, in body and soul.
“I need to kill him. For them… for all the time I spent locked up…” he looked at her again, sniffling. Even in the low light, he saw the blue of her irises darken, harden and draw away.
Sirius felt fear bubble in his body, sending shivers down his spine. He didn’t recognise this Scarlett, and seeing her sharp reflection was a little frightening. She’d let him see her murderous side—cold, bloodthirsty. The Scarlett who’d killed Marl.
“So you’ll have your revenge,” she said, her words slipping coldly from her pale lips and sliding into Sirius’s hair like serpents.
Sirius had never been afraid of Scarlett. Not like this. His whole body stiffened, every spark of warmth drained away. His touch grew tense. Fearful.
Scarlett shattered his rigidity by pressing a gentle kiss to his forehead. It was quick enough that he had no time to react, yet slow enough for a hundred sensations to flood him anew: laughter echoing in his core, sweet words whispered at his nape, warm caresses on his shoulders, along his collarbone, behind his ear.
“Sorry…” she murmured, as if she’d just done something wrong. “Old habit.”
The warmth returned as though the sun itself were gilding his skin, not the flicker of candlelight. Sirius was so intoxicated by the edges of those memories curling at his fingertips that he could do nothing. He clenched his fist, trying to grasp them, trying to reclaim them: three, two, or perhaps just one. His fingertips pressed into the fine mesh of memory and it exploded; vivid, bright, impetuous.
Sirius entered the room only to find it empty. The bed lay under a tangle of blankets, the table untouched and the wardrobe closed. He went to the bathroom, his heart stuttering when he saw she wasn’t there. He took a step forward, then froze as he noticed a slight movement under the covers.
He closed his eyes and exhaled before walking to the bed, lifting the layers of fabric slowly. Whiskers lay curled in that blanket cave, her blue eyes opening gradually as light seeped into her hiding place.
“Hey… kitten…” Sirius murmured, scratching at her neck. She purred in response.
The cat stretched lazily, yawning as she lengthened. Bit by bit she shifted back into her human form, her face red and swollen from crying. Scarlett looked visibly shaken; the pain etched in every line of her expression. She barely had the strength to stand and instead settled to sit on the edge of the bed.
“Sorry…” she whispered, voice trembling, unable to meet his gaze. “I just can’t… I can’t deal with it… when I’m in Whiskers’ form it’s… it’s easier…” She hesitated, hugging herself. “The pain… isn’t so intense.”
Sirius curved the corner of his mouth, soothing all those frightening feelings away before they could surface.
“I’m… I’m being a burden. To you,” Scar continued, her long, wet lashes fluttering. “I… I’d understand if… if you…” She seemed to summon every ounce of strength to say the words. “If you wanted to end it. You… you should live your life… be happy… with someone else…” She mouthed the last word silently.
It was as if every one of Scar’s words drove a nail into his heart. He clenched his fists, his shoulders quivering with tension and fear. It was terrifying to see the woman he loved in such pain, as though nothing in the world could make her feel happy again, no matter how hard he tried. There was no glue or fitting that could mend all her shattered pieces scattered across the room…
But Sirius would not give up. He was stubborn, masochistic and hard‑headed; not the sort to turn his back on love, however bitter it might be. And he loved Scarlett… loved her fiercely… she was the very air in his lungs, the pulse that drove his heart; she was his waking thought and his last before sleep, his other half, his girl, his rock.
Sirius forced Scar to meet his gaze by cradling her damp cheeks in his hands, refusing to accept those words. His eyes met hers, trying to pull her from that erratic stupor, from the destructive spiral she was trapped in, dragging her from the stormy sea of her own sorrow.
“Scar… listen to me,” he murmured, steady and certain. “Love doesn’t evaporate when things get tough. And my love for you… it only grows stronger. I’m here with you, Scar, every step, every moment, no matter how fucking rough it gets. You will never, ever be a burden to me.” He leaned in, pressing his lips to hers like he was sealing every word with a promise. He pulled back just enough to look her in the eyes, so close that their breaths mingled. “We’re in this together, whether you like it or not. We’ll get through this, through the pain, no matter how long it takes. You are more important to me than anything. Do you understand?”
Scarlett only nodded, tears still streaming down her face, her eyes heavy with guilt and remorse. Sirius kissed her forehead, pressing her to his chest, holding her so tightly he could almost suffocate her. Scarlett didn’t mind; she buried herself in him as though trying to steal a little of his composure for her own, seeking relief from the pain. Sirius’s love was intoxicating, almost the only thing keeping her anchored amid her overwhelmed thoughts.
How could she not love that dimpled grin, the ebullient laughter, the starry eyes, the insufferable cheek? Sirius Black was everything Scarlett had longed for. And life, while taking with one hand, gifted with the other.
“I love you.” She declared against his T‑shirt.
Sirius smiled, lost in the scent of her hair.
“I love you too, kitten.”
Sirius awoke as dawn brightened the sky, flooding through the window crack with blinding light. He looked around, momentarily believing himself still in the Potters’ bedroom, searching the bed for Scarlett. She was no longer there, though the memory remained fresh in his mind, in the kisses they had shared, in the words he had spoken with such fervour.
His lips tingled. He touched them slowly, intoxicated by the sweet sensation swelling in his chest. Something was blooming in his heart; delicate and intense. Sublime. Skittish. Breathless.
“Sirius…” Scarlett stood against the light, her face merely a silhouette surrounded by the blaze invading the small Order of the Phoenix hideout. “We need to go.”
The antidote had worked; at least she was much better.
Still drowsy, Sirius caught her wrist in reflex. Scarlett’s pupils widened in surprise, her pulse racing. A pinpoint throb struck his own heart and the silence echoing between them sent an inexplicable tug through their gazes.
He knew she felt it too; it was imprinted in the flecks of green in her irises, concealed with such effort beneath her eyelids, veiled by a layer of dissembling.
“Please…” she pleaded, closing her eyes for a long moment. “I don’t want to hurt you again.”
Sirius released her, struck by those two blue eyes turned into stakes. Cold and sharp. Scarlett touched the place where Sirius had held her as though wounded, retreating back into that dark, stinging, silent place within herself.
The song of birds filled the chasm between them. Sirius looked to the ceiling beams, doubt gnawing at him from within.
Certainty as well.
Fifteen years apart hadn’t been enough to kill what they had.
Nothing ever would.
.
.
.
It was easy to find an empty compartment on the Hogwarts Express when Regulus stepped aboard with Remus and Victoria. They’d arrived early, mainly because his uncle was feeling rather worn out. They wasted no time settling into one of the carriages, but just after Regulus had stowed the trunks on the luggage rack, Gemma Farley appeared in the doorway, eyeing Remus as though he were a mangy cur.
“Black, Rookwood… fetch your prefect badges, get changed into your robes and meet me in the first carriage. We’re holding the prefects’ meeting there.” Despite the smile on her face, her tone had a decidedly condescending edge. The Slytherin girl brushed her Head Prefect badge against her chest, spun on her heel and left them.
Regulus glanced at Victoria, who merely shrugged, then looked to his uncle. Remus gave a wan smile, his scar‑marked face drawn with exhaustion.
“Off you go; it’s not as though I’m exactly the best company right now…” he smiled, giving Regulus a parting tap on the shoulder. “Alright, Reg?”
Regulus didn’t reply at once, but he soon forced a smile and nodded, hands buried in his jeans pockets. “All good. I’ll see you tomorrow, Uncle.” He bade Remus farewell before awkwardly stepping out of the compartment. He felt Victoria’s gaze on him, and he looked away as a gaggle of Hufflepuff first‑years began dashing about and the train’s whistle blew.
The first carriage was crammed with people; it was the busiest of them all and, as always, reserved only for the prefects. They received a wary look from Percy Weasley as they passed the Gryffindor compartment and entered Slytherin’s, where Head Prefects Gemma Farley and Achilles Selwyn stood by the sliding door.
Regulus and Victoria settled into the only spare seat, eyeing Luke Avery and Aphelandra Pyke, who were a year above them. He’d never spoken much to Luke, but Aphelandra, leader of Slytherin’s Gobstones Club, despite her pale and slightly unkempt appearance, had a rather pleasant presence.
He couldn’t say the same of Achilles Selwyn. That boy was insufferable, forever trying to terrify the younger students because his uncle had been a Death Eater, as if that were something to boast about rather than be ashamed of. Beside him, Victoria pulled a notebook from her pocket and sharpened a charcoal pencil.
“So, as you know, prefects are responsible for maintaining the House’s decorum and patrolling the Hogwarts Express and the school. We can no longer deduct points from other Houses, only from our own, so please be extremely cautious about taking points off, as that penalises the entire House. Only dock points for very serious offences. We can also ask our Head of House to issue detentions, so it’s far better for the student to serve a detention than for us to lose points…”
Regulus honestly only heard the first minute; after that, his mind wandered far away. His fingers twisted the earphones of his Walkman incessantly as he wondered how much longer Gemma would go on without even pausing for breath.
Next to her, Achilles wore that detestable little smirk, leaning against the closed door without so much as taking a seat. Regulus felt the Hogwarts Express begin to move, the station falling away to reveal rolling countryside.
When she finally finished, Gemma settled beside Victoria, forcing Regulus to shift over and sit by the window.
“Right then… Black…” Achilles began, running a hand through his vivid red hair. “Is it true your uncle’s going to kill Harry Potter?”
Regulus frowned and let out a long sigh. Every eye in the carriage turned to him.
“What do you think?” He pulled the Walkman from his pocket, and everyone recoiled as if he’d brandished something lethal. Victoria alone paid them no heed, sketching quietly in her notebook.
“Well… he’s not going to finish the job, is he? You know, after handing the Potters… over to the Dark Lord.” Achilles shrugged, his grin mocking.
If Selwyn thought that line would rattle Regulus, he was sorely mistaken. Regulus’s face hardened into an iron mask; he shrugged off the remark and popped the earphones into his ears.
“According to the letters we exchanged… yes. He’s keen to kill Potter.” Regulus spoke low, as though sharing a dangerous secret.
Achilles’s brow furrowed.
“You actually exchanged letters?!” He folded his arms and glanced at the door, ensuring no one was eavesdropping.
“Of course we did, every Thursday. He looked after me when I was a child, you know? He’s my godfather.” Regulus continued, utterly unfazed. Victoria’s lips curved into the faintest, almost imperceptible smile. “He even made friends with a Dementor. His name’s Georgino.”
Aphelandra let out a laugh; Luke scratched his chin; Gemma stared as though he were some kind of alien. Achilles’s smirk vanished.
“Oh, fuck off, Black! You’d never have exchanged letters!” He relaxed his stance, waving his hands as if swatting away a fly.
Regulus gave a malicious grin and rewound his tape.
“The letters part was a lie, but… with my father dead and my mother in Azkaban, he looked after me until I was three because he’s my godfather, so…” Regulus stood and clipped the Walkman to his waistband. “Can I get on with patrol now?”
The carriage grew so silent that the only sound was the train ploughing through the wind. Victoria snapped her notebook shut and rose in one graceful movement.
“Y-you may…” Achilles stammered, utterly taken aback.
The others merely lowered their gazes, keeping silent. Among certain circles of Slytherin, being the son of a Death Eater lent him a measure of prestige, not to mention that he belonged to one of the most distinguished pure‑blood families—even though his mother was deemed half‑blood, he was still regarded as pure. Besides, she was a Gaunt, albeit disowned, and her name carried weight among the supremacists.
Regulus glanced at the back of his left hand, where a charm concealed his Signet. Only a handful of students knew of its existence—among them Luana, Victoria and her brothers.
He wondered if Remus was still asleep. The full moon had been the day before, so most likely he was. He smiled to himself, proud that his uncle had secured a post at Hogwarts and a little fearful that he might deliver more pointed lectures now that they were physically closer.
He looked at Victoria beside him, clutching her notebook under her arm and twisting her hair into a bun with her charcoal pencil. She glanced at him from the corner of her eye and offered a gentle smile.
Regulus felt as if his heart had been struck by an arrow, caught in a whirlwind, an earthquake. He leaned against the window to let a group of Ravenclaws pass by without tearing his eyes away from Victoria.
Then they resumed walking, Regulus too dazed by Victoria to utter a single comment on their patrol, which amounted to nothing more than a stroll back to their compartment.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 5: Some things no words could heal.
Chapter Text
LXXIII
Regulus and Victoria stopped in front of the carriage where a sleeping Remus and his luggage were, only to find Harry Potter, his gormless-looking mate, and the know-it-all with him. The three of them stared back, puzzled.
They’d never exchanged more than three or four words before. Victoria, however, gave them a small wave and slowly slid open the door to the compartment. Regulus noticed just how green the boy’s eyes were—so intense and bright they reminded him of one of his grandmother Walburga’s more garish necklaces. They also reminded him of the eyes of a red-haired girl with easy smiles and gentle words…
"Do you think we could…" she began, but Regulus placed a hand on her shoulder, cutting her off. Victoria shot him a confused glance.
"Oi, aren’t you that Black bloke’s nephew?!" the ginger lad asked, gripping a lump beneath his robes, hiding it from the squashed-faced cat in the know-it-all’s lap.
Regulus tilted his chin at the most arrogant angle he could manage, the blue of his eyes freezing the boy’s grey ones.
"Come on, Victoria," he muttered, curtly.
"But there’s space…"
Regulus sighed, pulled his friend along and slammed the compartment door shut. She quickly wriggled free, her breathing quickening, eyes wide. As if he was about to hurt her. Reg slowly opened his hand, showing her he wasn’t a threat, then gently rested his palm on her shoulder.
"Sorry. Sorry…" Regulus murmured, all the pride draining from him in a wave of embarrassment. "I didn’t… didn’t mean…"
"It’s all right." Victoria hid behind a smile. "What’s the problem with sitting in the same compartment as him? I mean, it’s not like…"
"No." Regulus cut her off, casting a quick glance at the three who were still watching them warily.
He motioned for Victoria to follow him, and they made their way through the carriages searching for Luana until they found her in a compartment beside Victor (Victoria’s twin brother), with Cedric Diggory and Gabriel Truman from Hufflepuff playing Exploding Snap near the window.
"There you are!" Lua sang out, her hands resting behind her head as she stretched her legs across the front seat. "Thought you weren’t coming back!"
Regulus offered a charming smile as he slid in beside Diggory, with Victoria across from him.
"Farley wouldn’t shut up…" he grumbled, unwinding the wire of his headphones. "Thought the speech was never going to end."
"Every time she starts one of those patrol talks with the other prefects, I just grab my stuff and leave… she goes on till the bloody next day," Gabriel muttered, smoke rising from the card he’d just discarded.
"Dead!" Cedric declared, slapping his hand on the deck.
"Better luck next time, Truman!" Lua teased, folding her arms and throwing Diggory a very suggestive look. He seemed to be doing everything possible to avoid her gaze. Across the way, Victor huffed, annoyed with the whole situation, and turned to stare out the window.
Regulus wasn’t particularly close to the Hufflepuffs, but Diggory and Truman were also prefects and in the same year as him. Besides, Cedric was Hufflepuff’s Seeker despite having the build of a Beater, while Regulus was Slytherin’s Beater.
The same position his mother had held.
The game of Exploding Snap continued and Victoria leaned forward, resting her elbows on her knees as she gestured for Regulus to come closer.
"What’s the deal with Potter?" she asked in a hushed tone, her platinum hair brushing Regulus’s shoulder.
The closeness made him blush.
"Seriously? After all that mess with the Chamber of Secrets last year?!" he complained, rolling his eyes. "Besides, why would we sit with them?! Our mates are here." He nodded towards the game.
"Our mates? You can’t stand Truman and you barely speak to Diggory." She hugged her notebook, licking her lips. Regulus’s gaze lingered on the soft, inviting skin of her peach-coloured mouth before slowly drifting up her delicate nose and landing on her caramel eyes.
Victoria looked at Cedric, giving him the chance to get a clearer look at her long white lashes, as fine and subtle as snowflakes. She covered her face with her hand and gave a little giggle when Diggory looked her way. It was only a second, but enough for Regulus to notice the exchange. He recoiled suddenly, leaning back against the seat as something hot and unpleasant thudded in his chest, his heart feeling like it was being crushed.
Regulus shoved his headphones on and hit play, giving Victoria no chance to resume the conversation. She stared at him, slightly thrown, raising an eyebrow at Lua. Luana just shrugged, eyes still fixed on Cedric as though he were something bordering on divine.
Cedric Diggory was handsome—or at least that’s what all the girls said about him. Like Regulus, he had dark hair and grey eyes, though Cedric’s grey was bright, while Reggie’s was like starlight soaked in blue.
He exhaled through his nose and settled back, arms crossed, letting the rocking of the train lull him into a light sleep. He woke up when a thick layer of rain began to blur the windows and the plump witch stood at the compartment door with the trolley.
"What do you want?" Victoria asked, fishing a few Sickles and Galleons from her pocket.
"Nothing," Regulus muttered moodily. "What time is it?" He stared into the darkness slowly swallowing the last of the light outside, yawning.
Lua pulled a watch from her pocket and rubbed her eyes.
"Nearly there," she said, turning towards the window, as did everyone else.
"Why’s the weather so grim?" Truman asked, touching the damp glass and drawing a pumpkin on it.
"Odd," Cedric said as well, looking rather concerned as he munched on a Chocolate Frog.
Regulus didn’t even notice the witch handing out sweets to the others, too busy swapping the cassette in his Walkman, digging around in his enchanted pockets for the Led Zeppelin tape. He stopped when a Pepper Imp appeared in front of his face, his eyes focusing on the slender fingers and the perfectly painted dark green nails.
"Cheers, Mimi," Regulus murmured, taking the sweet and feeling his annoyance slowly begin to fade.
Victoria smiled—a genuine smile that sent something fluttering in his stomach. Regulus swallowed hard, watching as she offered a sweet to everyone in the compartment, stopping at Cedric last. Cedric raised an eyebrow at her, but quickly accepted it with a polite smile.
Regulus couldn’t help but notice the faint blush tinting his friend’s cheeks. His heart dropped like a stone, the warmth inside him turning to ash in an instant. He stood up abruptly, drawing everyone's attention.
"I'm getting changed," was all he said as he left them.
He felt stifled, and more than a little panicked. What was Victoria’s deal? Fancying Diggory? What was so bloody special about him anyway, other than that chisel-jawed face that made every girl in Hogwarts swoon? He sighed, rolling his eyes as he made his way back to the compartment where his things were, brushing past Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle in the corridor. Draco shot him a smug little smirk, like they were mates. Regulus returned it with a scowl.
They were second cousins, and for some reason the boy seemed to think that meant they should talk or be friends. Which was ridiculous—Regulus was also distantly related to Victoria and half the bloody pure-bloods in the school, including that oaf Crabbe. Didn’t mean anything.
Regulus took a deep breath before opening the door to the compartment and stepping in, not bothering to ask permission or excuse himself.
"Need to grab my clothes… they’re in my trunk," was all he said, ignoring the stares from the three inside as he reached for the overhead rack.
The ginger shrugged, the girl ran a hand through her hair, and Harry shut the door to keep the cat from slipping out. Regulus shoved his hand into the trunk just as the lanterns lining the corridor and luggage rack flickered on. The trunk crunched his fingers as the train gave a sudden jolt.
"We must be nearly there…" the redhead murmured, leaning forward to peer past Lupin and out the window, which was now completely dark.
He’d barely spoken when the train began to slow down. Regulus pulled out a change of clothes and ran a hand through his fringe, ignoring them just as thoroughly as they were ignoring him.
"Brilliant," the boy went on, standing up to try and get a better look outside as Regulus left the compartment. "I’m starving. Can’t wait to get to the feast…"
"We’re not there yet," the girl said, checking her watch. "So why are we stopping?"
Regulus slid the door shut, feeling the train slow even further. When the pistons’ rumbling finally ceased, the wind and rain howled as they pelted the windows. He was the only one in the corridor, but soon enough, curious faces began popping up at the doors of the compartments. He quickened his pace back toward where his friends were, stumbling slightly as the Hogwarts Express gave a sudden jolt and came to a complete stop.
He clutched the clothes to his chest as a frigid draught swept down the corridor, slipping into the compartment just as the lights went out, plunging them into total darkness.
"What’s going on?" Lua asked quietly. "Are we there?!"
"No," Regulus answered calmly, feeling along the walls until he found the seat.
The sound of Regulus sitting back down was drowned by the tense, heavy breathing around him. He tried to appear composed, though his fingers were digging into the fabric of his uniform, and the compartment window was fogging up even faster.
"I’m going to see what’s happening." Diggory made to stand, but the sound of someone shoving him back cut through the dark.
"No, stay there!" Victor snapped. "You’re right by the window—try and see what’s going on!"
Cedric let out a loud sigh, pulled his wand from his pocket and cast Lumos, as did Regulus and Luana. The six of them exchanged glances. Gabriel wiped the window with the sleeve of his cloak and squinted to try and make something out.
"Can’t see a thing…"
Restless, Regulus stood again, leaving the clothes on the bench, his hand closing around the door latch. But before he could pull it, the door was yanked open violently. He flinched—a tall, cloaked figure loomed in front of him. His eyes widened, and he took a step back, his fingers tightening around his wand, trying to look brave even as fear surged cold and sharp through his chest.
The hood turned—towards Victoria. An icy chill froze the air in Regulus’s lungs, and without thinking, he stepped in front of her, shielding her with his body. She gasped, her warm breath brushing the back of his neck just as she stood, pressing herself against the wall as if she could somehow melt into it.
"Sirius Black."
He heard a voice so sharp it sounded like metal scraping porcelain, and his whole body shuddered with agony.
"He's not here!" Regulus shouted, fear lacing every word. Victoria gripped his shirt, pulling him towards her as if she could somehow shield him from the creature. "Go away, he’s not here!"
The hooded figure turned its focus to him again, and Regulus felt his legs go weak, his body pressing Victoria’s against the wall, his hands slick with cold sweat as they clung to the back of the bench.
"He… is… not… here!" Regulus repeated, voice thread-thin, the breath caught in his throat.
The creature began to drift away, slowly, floating. Victoria sobbed quietly against the back of his neck, her fingers buried in his T-shirt. Regulus hoped the Dementor would leave, move on to the next compartment, but it lingered—just hovered there—as if waiting for something, as if…
The cold dried out Regulus’s eyes, but he was too terrified to lift his hands and rub them. His body was trembling now and he didn’t know whether it was from fear or the temperature. Then, gradually, the chill crept from his lungs to his ears, bringing a splitting headache with it, forcing him to shut his eyes.
"No!" He heard himself scream, though the voice was a child’s. "I want my daddy! Where’s my daddy?" His eyes filled with tears, blurring the sight of the house-elf who was caring for him. "Where’s my daddy?"
"Penny is so sorry, my little master…" the elf murmured, stroking his dark hair, kissing his forehead.
"Thanatos Gaunt," a man’s voice echoed in his mind. "Black asked me to hand the boy over to him."
"B-b-but sir… the grandmother of my little master… his grandmother is still… still alive…" Penny pleaded, holding Regulus tightly, as though she could protect him from the world.
"His grandmother was an accomplice to the Death Eaters," the man replied, stepping closer. "With his legal guardian imprisoned, Gaunt is his closest relative and an old friend. He’ll take good care of young Black. Besides… this is what his master asked me to do before being sent to Azkaban."
"I WANT MY DADDY!" Regulus screamed, thrashing about. "DADDY, DADDY, DADDY!"
There was a bang. Someone rushed in, breathing hard.
"Reggie!" It was his Uncle Lupin.
Regulus reached for him, face streaked with tears and spit.
"Uncle, my daddy!" he whimpered, squeezing his eyes shut. "I want my daddy…"
Remus looked terrible, his face just as red as Regulus’s—if not more. Still, he smiled so tenderly as he scooped the boy into his arms that, for a second, it felt like everything might be all right.
"I’ve got him, Alastor. I’ll take him to Nate." Remus rubbed his back gently, soothing his sobs, letting Regulus rest his head on his shoulder. "It’s going to be all right, Reggie. It’s going to be all right…"
.
.
.
"It's normal to feel nauseous and unwell while taking the potion. That’s why it’s recommended you only use it once a week. It also has side effects, such as cancelling out some contraceptives..."
Though Scarlett stared fixedly at the healer, it was as if she weren’t really there. The instructions quickly dissolved into meaningless noise, and the light streaming through the windows behind that witch stung her eyes, forcing her to rub them. She couldn’t remember how many days had passed. In truth, she didn’t know much of anything anymore.
She was still numb, forcing herself not to fall apart in front of those strangers, pushing away any feeling that threatened to take hold of her chest. Her gaze slowly slipped down to the burn scar on her right forearm, her fingers tracing over it gently.
Her appearance was much improved, but no matter how hard the healers tried, that scar would never fade. The blast-ended skrewt had scorched her skin so deeply it had left a permanent mark.
"Miss Gaunt…" the woman’s sharp voice snapped her back into focus. "Did you understand?!"
"Yes," Scarlett lied. She just wanted it to be over.
But no sooner had the woman left than another man sat at the desk across from her, trapping her in her catatonic state once more. He opened a leather briefcase and began pulling out a thick stack of papers, placing them in front of Scarlett as though she could make sense of any of it.
"Miss Gaunt, this was your parents’ will. As the sole heir, you’ve been left everything… the house in Switzerland… the vaults in Switzerland and Britain… the land and any possessions that survived the fire…"
Scarlett’s gaze shifted to the window. More precisely, to the two shirtless lads under the scorching sun. Sirius and Remus were pulling something bright and shiny out of the garage. She squinted to see: it was Nancy—Sirius’s motorbike. The Christmas present she’d given him.
Sirius was holding the handlebars on one side, guiding the bike, while Remus pushed it from behind. Then James reversed the car carefully out of the garage. The tarmac shimmered under the intense rays of sunlight, the ash no longer floating in the air. For a moment, it didn’t even look like her house had burned down. The Department of Magical Accidents and Catastrophes had done an excellent job cleaning up the scene of destruction, even though the house itself remained in ruins.
Scarlett’s eyes settled on the man’s hands as he pushed two keys towards her, along with countless documents. Then he stood, and in his place sat her uncle Nate. He laced his fingers together, blinking repeatedly, as though it took great effort to figure out what to say.
"Scar…" her uncle murmured, his face carved into a mask of stone. He was never one to hide his feelings, which only led Scarlett to believe there was far more to the story than she’d been told.
But honestly, Scarlett didn’t want to know.
She stared at him, raising her brows, prompting him to go on.
"We need to talk about… the funeral." He wetted his lips, the shadows under his caramel eyes deepening. "I think… they’d have wanted to… rest beside your sister."
Scarlett took a deep breath, lifting her eyes to meet his.
"Funeral?" She didn’t bother hiding the sarcasm in her tone. "Why the fuck would we have a funeral? There’s not even a body." Her chest tightened, fists clenching at her sides.
Thanatos seemed to study her reaction carefully.
"Because… your family—our family—wants to gather, to… honour… your parents… and Orfy." He cleared his throat, as if it was hard for him too.
Scarlett sniffed derisively.
"My family burned to death," she muttered, her voice sharp as acid.
"Your great-grandparents are arranging a Portkey to take us to Italy… to place the headstones." Thanatos continued, undeterred. "They asked if you had any preference… colour, or…"
"I couldn’t care less," Scarlett snapped, cutting him off. Thanatos swallowed hard. "I don’t want to. And I’m not going."
She turned her head toward the door as Sirius and Remus’s voices drifted up the stairs.
"What do you want, then?!" he asked, licking his lips, elbows on the desk, chin resting on his hands.
Scarlett clenched her jaw, brows drawing together as her shoulders tensed.
"What I want, you can’t give me." The pain was raw in her voice, tears stinging her already-blurred eyes. "Can you bring the dead back to life?"
Thanatos Gaunt had always been the kind of man who knew what to do in every situation. Not only a famous Auror, but a natural-born leader. Yet even he had his flaws, and one of them was his utter lack of tact in dealing with this. Not only was he investigating the death of his own brother, but he was trying to look after a niece who scared him with just how much she reminded him of himself at her age.
"No," he answered bitterly.
"That’s what I thought." Scarlett stood, her chair scraping loudly against the floor as she pushed it back. She grabbed the keys and documents and left the study, wiping the tears from her cheeks with the back of her hand—only to come face to face with Sirius and Remus.
They froze for a moment in silence, until Scarlett slipped past them into the bedroom where she’d been sleeping. She threw everything onto the bed and crouched down, covering her face with her hands, sucking in a breath through her nose and letting it out through her mouth, the pulsing grief threatening to sink its claws deep into her chest.
Scarlett reached out and picked up the potion the mediwitch had given her earlier. Potion for Melancholy , she read on the label, opened it, and swallowed the whole thing in one go, pulling a face. She lay back on the bed, put on her headphones, hit play on the Walkman, rested her hands on her stomach and stared at the spinning ceiling fan.
Out of the corner of her eye, she noticed Sirius sitting on the bed, his worried face filling her field of vision, blocking the blades of the fan, his dark hair closing off the world around her like a curtain.
Scarlett got lost in his gaze, in Robert Plant’s voice echoing through her ears, until Sirius pulled her headphones off and kissed her lips. She blinked, distracted, curling her fingertips into his hair.
"Love…" he murmured, in that insufferable tone of his. "…I want to claim my Valentine’s Day present."
She closed her eyes as Sirius brushed his nose against hers, his warm breath caressing her cheeks. She tried to remember what his bloody present had been, trying to break through the shock, forcing her mind to dig past the traumatic events that had defined the start of her summer all the way back to that fateful Valentine’s Day in winter.
"The tattoo?!" Scarlett asked, her voice hoarse. "You don’t need me to do that." She put her headphones back on—only for Sirius to take them off again.
"I know." He propped his elbow up on the bed, gently running his fingers through her hair. "It’s just that…" His eyes darted around the room before returning to hers. "I’m scared of needles…"
Scarlett raised an eyebrow, her fingers tracing through the beard Sirius had been growing, tugging lightly at the corner of his moustache.
"You want a tattoo and you’re scared of needles?" she asked, sceptically.
"Yeah, I… I come from a pure-blood family, I didn’t even know how tattoos were made before all this…"
Scarlett wanted to laugh at her boyfriend’s absurdity. But she’d lost so much, the weight of everything had stripped meaning from most things. So, she stared at Sirius for a long while before managing to find a reply.
"Er, then… then d-don’t do it," she stammered, clearing her throat.
The grey in Sirius’s eyes shimmered with confusion.
"I’m scared and I want you to come with me!" he confessed, pouting.
A chill ran through Scarlett’s stomach. She cupped his face, feeling the softness of his skin against her palm, the dimples forming as his pout turned into a smile.
"I… I don’t know…" she hesitated, swallowing hard.
"Please, kitten. I need you," Sirius murmured seriously, his thick brow knitting over his forehead.
Scarlett pressed her lips together. She was the worst girlfriend in the world. She knew exactly what Sirius had been doing while she spent her days crying in corners—trying to salvage whatever he could from the garage, making sure she was eating properly (and no, she wasn’t, and she didn’t care), having hushed arguments with Nate about who she’d be living with, and a hundred other things that Scarlett simply let slip by because she was still in a daze.
Her entire family was dead. What was she supposed to do? It all felt like one horrific nightmare on loop. She kept expecting to wake up—but that moment never came.
It was a constant pain, one that stole her breath and punched her in the stomach every time something reminded her of her parents or of Orfy. Before she knew it, she’d be drowning in tears, curled up and numb. She still couldn’t process what had happened.
Scarlett let out all the air in her lungs, nodding at last. Sirius’s smile lingered, though it turned slightly melancholic. He kissed her lips once more and stood from the bed, running a hand through his beard as he looked over his trunk for something to wear.
"You need to buy clothes…" Sirius went on, tossing her a T-shirt and a pair of shorts. "You haven’t had any since…"
He didn’t finish the sentence. He didn’t need to. The sharp pang hit Scarlett’s chest all the same, and she dug her nails into the blanket, trying to dull the sting.
"Could you… could you lend me… a jumper?" she asked, avoiding his gaze, though she discreetly hid the scar on her forearm.
Sirius understood at once, nodding as he grabbed his Rainbow jumper and handed it to her. Scarlett got changed, lethargic, dizzy. It felt like every time she left the bedroom, her senses went on high alert. As though something was about to go terribly wrong. As though…
As though…
As though she were about to lose her family all over again.
It manifested in all sorts of ways. She couldn’t stand the smell of smoke. She and Sirius both took dreamless sleep potion to keep the nightmares at bay. She still woke up drenched in sweat, heart pounding, struggling to breathe.
And that was with only a week passed since the incident. Scarlett hadn’t even realised—she only found out by overhearing a conversation between Euphemia and Fleamont after she’d pulled on the jumper and stepped out of the room. To her, the days were like a light switch: flicking on and off. Too far away to reach out and make time pass faster, too helpless to bring it closer and slow it down.
Scarlett was like a statue. Watching everything through the eyes of her stone skin—helpless and rigid, untouchable and cold. No matter how scorching that bloody summer was, she always felt frozen, as if she were on the verge of hypothermia.
Perhaps it was because of the constant chills rippling over her skin every time her gaze fell on the Atari Orfy had left in James’s living room, or when Fleamont crossed his legs to read the paper just like Morfeu used to, or the fleeting moments when Euphemia bent down to pick something up and, just for a second, Scarlett mistook her for her mum.
They were there, everywhere. And it was nearly impossible to detach herself from the longing. It was mad to think they would never be there again—that Scarlett would never again endure a ridiculous game of UNO beside her brother, or be on the receiving end of her father’s disapproving look if she drank all the milk straight from the bottle. Or… that she’d never again feel that tight, fluttery nervousness she always got around her mum.
No. They weren’t there anymore. And Scarlett found herself crying again, clutching the Rainbow jumper between her fingers, her eyes fixed on the parquet floor of the Potters’ house. Funny how she’d never noticed the imperfections in their flooring before—like the yellowish stain near the fridge in the kitchen, or that one loose wooden tile on the upstairs landing.
Scarlett looked at the narrow beam of light coming through one of the kitchen windows, reaching for her fingers. She tucked her hand beneath the thick fabric of the jumper, the conversations spinning around her never quite making sense. She lifted her gaze to Sirius beside her. He’d always been incredibly tactile, and this moment was no exception—one hand held a slice of toast covered in jam, the other rested on her shoulder.
Scarlett narrowed her eyes slightly, studying Sirius’s calloused fingers, and the rings he wore. The one on his thumb was made of coconut shell, the one on his index finger a smooth silver band, almost like a wedding ring. On his middle finger was a ring with a raven emblem. And on his ring finger, their commitment ring. Black. Black like his hair. Like the T-shirt he wore. Like the long lashes that framed his starry eyes. Her gaze drifted, finally landing on James.
He was just as quiet as she was. Lost. She’d heard him crying in Euphemia’s lap more than once. James’s mother was so delicate and kind that Scarlett always felt guilty saying no to her—like refusing the endless plates of pancakes she made. Scar knew Mrs Potter only wanted to help, but pancakes reminded her of her mum and…
It was just so, so, so hard to exist among the everyday things. Scarlett was constantly trying to remember something while simultaneously fighting to forget. It was an exhausting duality that always ended the same way: with Scarlett crouched on the floor, sobbing, biting her own thigh as hard as she could just to see if the pain of the bite could be stronger than the one tearing through her chest.
It wasn’t.
Nothing was.
Nothing ever would be.
So she forced herself to give her best smile that morning when Remus brought her a tub of chocolate-hazelnut ice cream. The smile was no more than a slight curve of her lips, but it was enough for her to hear Sirius exhale, relieved, and for James to finally force himself to eat something.
In the first two days, Scarlett hadn’t eaten a thing. On the third, Sirius had watched over her until she’d managed to get down a large apple. On the fourth, she’d even enjoyed the apple and drank a bit of milk. On the fifth, she pretended to feel ill so she wouldn’t be forced to eat the damn pancakes. On the sixth… she shoved the food in her mouth and spat it all into the toilet.
And on the seventh…
Well, this was the seventh day, and it was a bit harder to pretend she was eating when everyone at the table was watching her. Not directly, but sideways glances, subtle ones, as though they were just making sure she was okay. And if “okay” meant barely talking to anyone, not wanting to leave the room, and spending most of her time in Animagus form to keep from crying until her eyes burned—then Scarlett had never been better.
She didn’t want to leave. She knew Sirius wasn’t scared of needles—her boyfriend feared very few things, and none of them were stupid needles. But she also knew that sooner or later, she’d have to leave the house. And, truth be told, the idea of being somewhere other than the Potters’ did bring a tiny sense of relief.
It was torture being in the house directly across from hers… or rather, what was left of it.
"…it’s in Muggle London," Sirius explained, sipping from a cup of coffee. "It’s not dangerous."
"Even so, I’ll have to go with you," Nate said, folding his arms and leaning back in his chair. "Can’t just assume it’s safe… especially with…" He cast a subtle glance in Scarlett’s direction, which made Sirius sigh.
"Fine," he agreed, reluctantly. "Everyone ready? We’ll take the Floo to Diagon Alley and then from there—"
Scarlett really liked Sirius’s voice. It reminded her of Jim Morrison’s—drawled, deep, and lazy when he wanted it to be. Then it would turn wild and rasped when he was angry. Velvet-soft and low when aroused. He’d throw it into his nose just before saying something outrageous or cracking a joke.
Sirius’s hand shifted on her shoulder as Scarlett finished her massive 200ml glass of milk. It was enough to sustain her for the morning.
She stared at the green sand in her palm before throwing it into the fireplace. The flames consumed her, and the Potters’ living room was replaced by the fireplaces of Diagon Alley. It was bustling with activity—children running about with ice cream-smeared faces and parents scrambling behind them. Aurors stood watch at every corner and dark alley, like silent shadows keeping guard.
Sirius wrapped his arm around her shoulder possessively. Not just that—he kept looking around, eyes darting warily. Not that it was necessary; Nate and two other Aurors were escorting them. Remus and James lagged behind, and oddly, the only ones speaking were Sirius and Remus.
James—the most talkative of them all—hadn’t said a single word.
Scarlett squinted against the bright sunlight, and Sirius smiled, taking the aviator sunglasses from the collar of his white T-shirt and sliding them onto her face. Scarlett wasn’t sure if she’d smiled back, but she was certain she’d made some sort of ridiculous expression because Sirius’s laughter deepened.
Scarlett watched the shopfronts pass by one by one, until the magical ones gave way to Muggle ones. She glanced at the clothing displays with little interest. She knew she’d have to buy an entirely new wardrobe—after all, she’d lost everything in the…
In the…
In the fire.
Scarlett swallowed hard, forcing back the lump in her throat. She lowered her head, crossing her arms tightly as if to hide her face. It wasn’t enough. Back in Diagon Alley, she’d already noticed a few people pointing at her. Scarlett tried her best to ignore the newspaper shop. Her uncle had already had more than enough fights with The Prophet ’s editors over their vile, twisted articles on the investigation.
It wasn’t as if Scarlett cared. Newspapers reminded her of her father, so they were one of the hundreds of things she avoided with religious fervour.
They entered a shopping centre. Scarlett stepped onto the escalator. She didn’t really register where they were until a bright, colourful shop emerged at the top—the arcade. Her chest tightened at the sight, making her stumble as the steps levelled out. If it hadn’t been for Sirius, she would’ve taken a nasty fall.
"You all right?" Sirius arched his brows slightly, the arcade neons casting purple and turquoise across his silver-grey irises, making it look like stars had burst into supernovae.
Sirius Black was beautiful even with dark circles under his eyes and a furrow of worry carved between his brows.
"Just… tripped," Scarlett heard herself say, her cheeks flushing as she looked away.
It was still amazing how one look from him could make her feel like a girl again.
They carried on. Scarlett folded her arms, resting her head against Sirius’s chest, letting him lead her. Even though the heat inside the shopping centre was stifling, she felt cold.
She felt as dead as her family. Maybe her body was just reflecting that.
Scarlett froze as she caught a glimpse of a familiar-looking head of brown hair in a shop window’s reflection. A tall man, full beard, aquiline nose. Her heart thundered wildly in her chest, as though it knew this person, as though it had known him forever. She turned sharply, eyes focusing in seconds, expectation fraying the edges of reality.
She exhaled when she saw it wasn’t her father. Just a man who looked a lot like him. Scarlett blinked, dazed, unsure if she was walking forward or backward. Sirius followed her gaze, stopping on the stranger now handing ice creams to his two daughters.
Scarlett dug her nails into her Ouroboros, retreating deep into a comforting corner of her mind as the urge to cry became unbearable. She didn’t scream or wail, didn’t even make a sound. Just soft little drops slipping silently down her face while Sirius wrapped his arms around her, pressing gentle kisses to her cheek in comfort.
Scarlett focused on Sirius’s heartbeat. It was fast, as though in a rush—strong, like it was afraid. She understood. This hurt him too. And if their roles were reversed, it would tear her apart the same way.
She sniffled and murmured that she was fine before they carried on, stopping in front of the tattoo studio. Scarlett’s vision was too blurry to make sense of any of the designs in the portfolio Sirius was flipping through from his seat. She settled into the chair directly in front of him.
"What's your star sign?" Sirius turned his head toward her.
It took Scarlett a moment to realise he was speaking to her.
"What?" she whispered, rubbing her eyes to see him more clearly.
"Your sign, love." He said it with such tenderness that Scarlett felt herself melt.
"Uh, ah… I think… um… Sagittarius." Scarlett scratched her head, suddenly self-conscious.
Sirius pulled off his T-shirt, and Scarlett’s gaze got lost in the sight of his torso. His chiselled abs, the defined arms, the chest she loved resting against. He wasn’t overly muscular, nor was he skinny. Lean—just the right amount of sharp and soft.
"I want the Sagittarius constellation… right here." He pointed to the middle of his back, just below the nape.
The tattoo artist began asking him questions Scarlett didn’t hear. She was too spellbound by how the white light in the studio reflected off Sirius’s skin, highlighting the tiny freckles scattered across his back—like dark stars in a pale universe. His complexion was so soft, it looked like marble.
White. White like a ghost, a sculpture, like the clouds streaking across the sky. There was something slightly haunting about the paleness of his skin. Pure-blood genes, she supposed.
He lay on his stomach. Scarlett dragged the chair closer, sat in it backwards and rested her chin on the backrest. She brushed Sirius’s hair aside from where the artist had begun sketching the constellation with a blue pen. He looked at her, reaching one hand out, and she laced her fingers through his without hesitation.
Scarlett could feel the sweat on Sirius’s palm seeping into the glove on her left hand. In return, she ran her thumb slowly across the back of his hand, tracing the bulging veins that mapped their way down to his forearm.
"Hey… lie here…" he motioned to the space beside his face. Scarlett folded her arms on the chair and rested her head there, turning her cheek toward him, meeting his eyes upside down.
"Nervous?" Scarlett asked quietly, tucking a stray lock of hair behind her ear.
Sirius’s lips stretched into a smile that woke butterflies in her stomach. His grey eyes sparkled with excitement and just a touch of nervous energy.
"Just a bit," he said, voice suddenly serious.
Scarlett held still, stoic, as if she’d just gazed into the eyes of Medusa. Letting herself be pulled into the molten silver of Sirius’s gaze, into his unspoken promises, into the flicker of his yearning. His otherwise symmetrical face began to shift—his nose twitched, lips pressed tight, eyes squinted. The buzz of the tattoo machine was soft, ironically the only sound Scarlett’s ears could register.
"Does it hurt?" Scarlett asked softly. Sirius forced a calm expression, but she could see the tight clench of his jaw.
"Not… not too much," he wavered, his Adam’s apple bobbing as he swallowed. "It’s like… like he’s dragging the tip of a quill across your skin… but hard…"
Scarlett craned her neck to see the tattooist at work, but Sirius gripped her hand tighter. She lay back down, brushing her hair out of her face.
"Don’t leave me," he whispered, his eyes shining until the light turned to tears. "Please."
Scarlett shook her head, catching the stray tears with her thumb and brushing them away. His skin was soft beneath her touch despite the stubble. Sirius closed his eyes slowly, lashes glistening with moisture, nostrils flaring gently.
"Never," she whispered, stroking his cheeks with a tenderness that made the moment feel weightless.
Sirius smiled, but the mask cracked a second later into a choked sob. He let out a low grunt, trying to push it down, to focus on the needles relentlessly piercing his skin. But it was hard—especially when Scarlett’s eyes held him so easily, dragging up all the memories from that cursed day, sending shivers down his spine.
It was enough for guilt to curl like smoke in Scarlett’s already battered heart. She squeezed her burning eyes shut, unable to cry with him, though every part of her ached to do so.
"I’m sorry… for saying those things to you…" Scarlett murmured, feeling the uneven rhythm of Sirius’s breath against her forehead. "I didn’t mean to… to blame you. I know that doesn’t make it right, but—"
Sirius nodded faintly, his lips pressed into a tight line as he sniffled.
"It’s all right. I’m not… I’m not crying because of that. It’s just… I didn’t think it would hurt this much." He ducked behind the half-truth. Scarlett knew it was a lie. And he knew that she knew. It was written all over his tear-stained face, gleamed in the red-rimmed eyes… etched into the furrows that weighed down his brow.
"I’m here," Scarlett whispered, her voice cracking. She ran her thumb across his thick brows, and Sirius let out a faint laugh from his chest. She knew how uncomfortable he was showing his vulnerabilities.
"I know," he murmured, closing his eyes again, sinking into the gentleness of her touch.
"It’s all right to cry," she added.
And that was all it took to disarm Sirius—his defences, his barriers, the tension wound into every muscle. He pressed his nose to hers and wept again, trying not to move too much and ruin the tattoo. Letting Scarlett’s tenderness soothe the burning ember of everything he’d buried in his chest, the torn fissure in his soul, the pieces he’d left behind. The memories he’d shattered just to keep moving forward.
Their eyes met again, and Sirius took a deep breath.
"I just… I hate seeing you suffer like this," he confessed, voice thick with emotion. "I feel so fucking helpless. I want to make you happy… I want to… I… I just…"
He tried to smile, to slip back into the mask of cheerfulness, but it crumbled almost instantly, replaced by an expression of raw sadness. The gleam in his eyes dimmed into grief, the kind that crashes in like a wave and leaves nothing standing.
"I’m sorry… I should’ve… I should’ve listened to you… should’ve gone back… into the fire and—"
"No." Scarlett cut him off, even though part of her wanted to hear him say it. She knew it was an illusion. A sweet, warm, comforting illusion to think about what they could have done. But that wouldn’t get them anywhere. "You did… you did what you could, my love. You… saved me."
In that moment, Scarlett said those last words with gratitude. She’d regret saying them, sometimes. But she couldn’t have known that then. Scarlett loved that man, and that feeling wouldn’t change with the passing years. It might stretch or shrink, burn brightly or fade to a flicker… but it would never disappear. It was as natural as the air in her lungs, the chill brushing her cheeks, the sunlight warming her skin.
Sirius took in her words in silence, and the buzz of the tattoo machine filled the space between them. There was nothing else to say. The emotion surrounding them, formless and yet so exact, was enough. He squeezed her hand tighter, and for a few seconds, Scarlett didn’t feel like the most miserable woman in the world—she felt like the most loved.
The feeling didn’t last long, but it was enough to let her feel something beyond pain for once. A small flicker of warmth in her chest, a breath of wind at her neck, a shiver down the base of her spine. She hadn’t thought she’d be capable of feeling that again—not after everything.
It was as if happiness had been amputated from her, and even the mere shadow of it sent her spiralling into panic. Sirius, however, had a way of pulling her out of that spiral—his eyes anchoring her to the earth, holding her steady in the storm, shielding her from the hurricane.
Sirius Black.
Her rainbow at the end of the storm.
The tattooist finished the design, wiping away the excess ink with a cloth. Sirius sat up, inspecting his back in the mirror. On his right shoulder blade was the dancing strawberry they’d drawn together on Halloween night.
Scarlett sighed. That day felt like it had been a lifetime ago…
Sirius liked the result so much he decided to get his hands tattooed too. Remus looked impressed, clearly itching to get a tattoo of his own. James, leaning in the corner of the room, barely glanced at the constellation on his friend’s back.
Scarlett forced a smile when Remus said something to her while sketching the runes Sirius had asked for. Her mind drifted again, watching the grimace Sirius made as the artist moved across his knuckles, then the back of his hand.
"It hurts way more on the hand…" he grumbled, biting his lower lip before casting a revitalised glance at Scarlett. "Can you tie my hair back?"
It took her a few seconds to realise he was speaking to her. She was still distant. Nodding, she circled the chair and stood behind him. It didn’t feel warm in the studio—not to Scarlett, at least. But Sirius clearly disagreed, judging by the sweat trailing down his neck, his shoulder muscles glistening with it.
Scarlett got a better look at the constellation on his back. The skin was red, irritated, and slightly swollen, but the contrast of the black ink on his pale complexion only accentuated his natural allure. She gathered his hair and began to braid it, her mind awash with a hundred thoughts.
"You're letting someone touch your hair like that, Pads?!" James’s voice came from behind her, and she glanced over her shoulder. "You must really love her."
There was something uneasy in James’s voice. A touch of forced irony, too. He took off his glasses to rub the bridge of his nose, shrouded in that prickly silence he carried lately. Scarlett rested her chin on Sirius’s forehead, arms draped over his shoulders, watching the artist ink the Toto sword onto his hand.
"Can I get a tattoo too, today?" Scarlett asked Sirius.
He looked at her in surprise.
"Of course you can."
Once the artist finished Sirius’s hands, Scarlett lay on the chair, face down, and lifted her jumper. His eyes widened, startled, as if he thought she was about to take her top off completely. She lay back on the chair, and Sirius gathered her hair.
"I want the Canis Major constellation. Same one you had done on your hand…" Scarlett said, pointing to the stars inked across the back of Sirius’s hand.
The sensation really was like a quill tip being dragged across her skin. But the pain was barely more than a faint sting, a trivial irritation. Like the bites she gave her own thigh—it didn’t come anywhere close to the colossus that crushed her heart. So insignificant, it almost tickled.
Sirius kept running his fingers through her hair like he was deeply unsettled by the thought of Scarlett feeling the sting of the needle. Scarlett didn’t mind—in fact, she liked the way his fingers moved across her scalp, how he could be so gentle, so careful, as if trying to stitch the wounds in her heart shut with a single act of love.
It was futile… but Sirius had always been the kind to punch stone, to insist on the impossible, to bash his head against walls. He always tried to keep his promises, no matter how bitter, no matter how out of reach. Sirius Black was a bloody masochist.
Scarlett hissed softly as she got up from the chair, turning to view the artwork on her back in the mirror.
"It’s beautiful," Sirius murmured beside her, leaning in close. "You know the best part? I’m gonna see it every time you’re on all fours for me…"
She smacked his arm, face turning crimson. No one else had heard it, but a shy smile curled her lips. It wasn’t happiness, not really, but it came so naturally that Scarlett was left surprised with herself.
Sirius paid, and they left the studio. She had to avoid holding his hand for the next few days, but that didn’t stop him from keeping his arm around her shoulders—careful not to touch the fresh tattoo across her back.
"What are we eating?" he asked, dragging them all toward the food court.
The smell of fried food made Scarlett’s stomach growl loudly. James, Remus, and Sirius turned to stare at her.
"That was you?!" Remus raised an eyebrow, incredulous.
"It was Sirius," Scarlett said, tossing her boyfriend a conspiratorial look.
"I’m starving," he shrugged, then winked at her. "Fish and chips?"
.
.
.
Scarlett stared down at her tray of fish and chips, not touching it. Remus and Sirius were eating like trolls, and even James ended up snatching a chip before giving in to the meal. Scarlett poked one piece of battered fish with her index finger, the heat pulsing into her fingertip, turning it pink.
"Not eating?" Sirius looked at her, wiping his mouth with a napkin and folding it with that annoyingly precise elegance of his.
"Not hungry," Scarlett whispered, scratching her nose to chase away the scent tormenting her.
"But it’s so good…" he said, biting into a chunk of fish and closing his eyes like it was the most divine thing he’d ever tasted.
Scarlett blinked a few times, then finally dared to pick up a piece. She bit into it slowly, carefully, her mouth watering as the crunch echoed in her ears and the delicious flavour of fried fish coated her tongue. Sirius was right. Or maybe she really was starving. She couldn’t even remember the last time she’d felt hunger.
She ate everything faster than she should have, licking her fingers at the end, already considering grabbing another portion. She couldn’t ignore the breath Sirius released as he watched her eat like that, nor the gentle smile he gave her when they stood up from the table.
"Want more?" he asked, offering his hand.
"No," Scarlett lied, staring at the floor.
It was hard to swallow her pride and walk away from the food court when Sirius simply accepted her answer. Scarlett didn’t want to go back to the Potters’ house—though being out on the street wasn’t exactly comforting either, staying in Godric’s Hollow was unbearable.
She barely realised she’d stopped in front of a clothing shop.
"You want to go in?" Sirius asked, stretching his neck to peek at the racks inside.
"No…" Scarlett shook her head. But Sirius took her hand and gently pulled her along as he pushed open the shop door.
"It’s all right, we can have a look…" he encouraged her.
Scarlett hesitated. She didn’t want to overstep her own limits, but in the end, she nodded, and they stepped into the shop together. Inside, the place was full of clothes in every colour and style. She ran her hand along the garments on the hangers, trying to keep her composure as she picked one up. It was hard—especially with her chest starting to boil over.
The last time she’d been in a shop like this was with her mum, helping her pick out a dress alongside Lily and Pandora. Scarlett gasped and let the shirt fall to the floor like it had caught fire. Her body began to tremble from the sheer effort of holding in the tears—not in front of strangers, not in a bloody clothing shop!
Luckily, her reaction caught Sirius’s attention. He quickly dropped the clothes he’d been holding and rushed to her.
"Hey, hey, hey…" he murmured, wrapping his arms around her. "It’s okay…"
"Can we… can we go back? P-please…" she stammered, coughing as she struggled to make sense.
"Back? You mean home?" he asked gently, trying to comfort her. "Scar… you… you need to get some clothes, love. At least something for the funeral…"
Scarlett began to hyperventilate, clutching Sirius’s T-shirt as if it were the only thing keeping her from collapsing. Just the mention of the funeral made her legs give way beneath her.
"No, please… please… I just want to go home…" she sobbed, breathing hard. "Please, Sirius…"
"It’s okay, love." He kissed her forehead, trying to soothe her as he led her out of the shop. "It’s all right, I’m here…" Sirius whispered in her ear.
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, wishing with everything in her that someone would finally shake her awake from this nightmare.
.
.
.
It was easy to sleep… but waking up was the hard part. Scarlett opened her eyes in the middle of the night, disoriented. Even though she’d spent the entire week in a lethargic haze, she felt utterly drained. Her emotions were in ruins. Beside her, Sirius slept deeply, his breathing steady, expression peaceful.
She moved carefully to avoid waking him, slipping out of bed slowly, every muscle in her body protesting under the weight of accumulated stress. Her only comfort was the sight of Sirius so calm, his jaw twitching slightly before he let out a soft snore.
Scarlett crossed the bedroom feeling heavy and unsteady, rubbing her eyes as the unprocessed grief settled on her shoulders like lead. She forced herself to leave so as not to disturb him, tiptoeing across the Potters' landing.
From the bannister, she could see a light dancing in the darkness downstairs. Scarlett descended the steps, drawn to the soft glow like a moth to a flame. When she entered the sitting room, she saw James’s slender silhouette, messy-haired, hunched in front of the telly.
He was playing Adventure on the Atari—Orfy’s favourite game. James had promised to beat the level for him… before everything happened.
A violent wave of nostalgia stole the breath from Scarlett’s lungs, screaming for her to run back to the safety of the bedroom, of Sirius’s arms. But she didn’t move. She narrowed her eyes against the flicker of the screen.
Silently, she approached James. He sat on the carpet, and when his hazel eyes—now tinged purple in the glow—landed on her, his brows lifted slowly. Scarlett settled beside him, resting her head on his shoulder. In return, he placed his chin on her forehead, one arm still working the joystick, his glasses crooked on his face.
The only sound between them was the music and beeps of the game.
Scarlett felt James’s tears as they dampened her skin, heard him sniff quietly, wipe his face, and carry on with the game. He didn’t speak. There was nothing to be said, nothing to mend. All that remained were memories and promises—and James seemed determined to keep every single one.
They stayed like that, just existing together, bathed in the basic colours of the game screen until morning came and Sirius found them in the same position, the end screen blinking endlessly.
Sirius crouched behind them and wrapped them both in his arms, planting a kiss on the top of each of their heads, holding them tight, saying nothing.
Some things no words could heal.
Loss was one of them.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 6: But I know that I love you so
Chapter Text
LXXIV
"She said she doesn’t want to go," Sirius repeated for the thousandth time, massaging his temples.
Thanatos sighed and knocked back his glass of firewhisky.
"She needs to… be there, Sirius." Nate fixed those caramel eyes on him, bloodshot and swollen from the drink and grief. "Doesn’t she have any other friends? Besides you three?"
Sirius watched the amber liquid swirl inside the glass bottle before pouring himself another drink. He couldn’t smoke anymore after what happened, so he had to settle for alcohol. The drink burned its way down, and Sirius grunted, swirling the glass before finishing it off.
"Of course she does." He met Nate’s gaze again. "Do you want me to summon them all?"
"She needs support… Merlin knows how shit I am at that." Scarlett’s uncle gave a strained smile. "Morfeu always knew how to…," he licked his lips, searching for the right words, "make death feel like a see-you-later, not a goodbye. When Bonnie died, he carried the weight like it was nothing. Like he was made for it." He shrugged, pulling a cigarette from his metal case. "He was my older brother… and good at everything. And me…," Nate smiled again as he lit the cigarette, "I’m just a fucked-up Auror. I don’t know if I can help her, Sirius."
Sirius waved the smoke away from his face before it could overwhelm his nostrils. He exhaled through his mouth and leaned his head back against the chair, staring at the upper level.
"Can you get me some addresses? I was going to send them with Scar’s owl, but…," Sirius lowered his gaze to Nate.
"Yeah, I can. Write down the names and I’ll head to the Ministry in a bit… see if there’s any update on the case and—"
"It was them, wasn’t it?" Sirius cut in. "The Death Eaters."
Thanatos tapped the cigarette against the ashtray, his pupils narrowing as his eyes widened.
"Everything pointed that way, but the lack of the Dark Mark in the sky is a strong sign it wasn’t…" He took a deep drag. "The Death Eaters take pride in their kills."
Sirius frowned at the ache in his chest. He stayed silent for quite a while.
"How?!" he whispered, drawing Nate’s eyes back to him.
The Auror shook his head slowly, blowing the smoke upward.
"Someone who had access to the house… but… after Christmas… impossible. No one from outside could get in. And it’s hard to be sure because Scarlett… won’t talk to me."
"She needs time." Sirius drummed his fingers on the firewhisky bottle.
A sorrowful smile crept onto Thanatos’s face.
"Time never heals, Sirius." He held the glowing cigarette between his lips. "It just distances… but it never heals."
.
.
.
Sirius sat on his motorbike for quite a while, roasting under the blazing sun, sweat gluing the leather jacket to his arms as he tried to figure out what to say. He stared at the flower garden of the house next door, thumbs drumming relentlessly on the handlebars. Then he exhaled sharply and pulled into the small space in front of the garage, dismounting in one fluid motion as he kicked down the side stand.
He checked the address scrawled on the scrap of paper and shoved it into the pocket of his jeans, adjusting the aviator sunglasses that kept slipping down the bridge of his nose. He climbed the steps and licked his lips, his hand hovering near the doorbell.
He pressed it carefully, the soft chime audible from inside the house. Stepping back, he wiped the sweat from his forehead with the back of his hand before stuffing it into his pocket. It wasn’t long before a pale blonde girl opened the door, casting him a bored glance before straightening up as if she’d just been electrocuted.
Under normal circumstances, Sirius would’ve laughed. His lips barely moved.
"Good afternoon. Is Lily in? I need to speak with her," was all he said.
The girl opened and closed her mouth a few times, then raised her eyebrows and gave a small nod.
"Who is it, darling?" A red-haired woman appeared behind her in the doorway, breaking into a wide smile when she saw Sirius.
"He wants to speak with Lily." The girl’s face shut down the second she turned back to her mother.
"Would you like to come in...?" Mrs Evans gestured, her smile so warm that it took Sirius a second to catch the hint in her tone.
"Sirius." He gave a sheepish smile, noticing both Mrs Evans and Lily’s sister craning their necks to look at the motorbike parked outside.
"Yes, Sirius, won’t you come in? I’ll fetch Lily… it’s murderously hot out there…"
"You must be dying in that jacket." There was a certain bite to Lily’s sister’s tone that made Sirius click his fingers in irritation.
"Petunia, go and fetch your sister!" Mrs Evans said — kindly, though it was clearly an order. She reminded him a bit of Euphemia. "So then…" She opened the door wider and motioned for Sirius to come in.
"Thank you, Mrs Evans." Sirius gave a little bow as he removed his sunglasses and stepped inside.
The Evans’ home was a classic English suburban house — red-bricked, with a spacious living room and a stairwell wall filled with photographs.
"Lily! You’ve got company!" Petunia shouted up the stairs, then turned back to Sirius with a grin stretched ear to ear.
"You must be parched… I’ve just made some lemonade, would you like some? Petunia, fetch the lemonade, darling, would you?!" She didn’t even wait for Sirius to respond, motioning for him to sit on the enormous guava-coloured sofa as she settled into the armchair beside it. "Where did you meet Lily? Are you also…" She glanced around, then leaned in towards Sirius. "A wizard?"
Sirius masked his discomfort with a smug smile. He was good at that — had been trained his whole life to conceal what he didn’t feel, as naturally as the blood running through his veins.
"Yes. We studied together." Sirius let his gaze roam over the house’s décor — overly colourful and crammed with floral motifs. There were dogwoods woven into the rug, primroses on the wallpaper, magnolias painted onto the china on display.
"Do you know Mary as well? She pops round here from time to time." Mrs Evans glanced toward the kitchen, scratching her neck before looking back at him. "Such a lovely girl! Very talented."
"I do." Sirius forced a crooked smile. "But Evans… Lily…" he corrected himself with a small cough, "she’s one of the top in our year at Potions. The professor practically worships her…"
He trailed off as he caught Petunia returning from the kitchen in his peripheral vision.
"So, you’re a wizard too?!" she huffed, handing him the tray with a glass of lemonade. "Of course you are — why else would you be friends with Lily…"
"Petunia," her mother snapped, shooting her a look before turning back to Sirius with a pleasant smile. "It’s nice and cool, I’ve just made it…" She took the lemonade from the tray and placed it in his hand, watching him with eager eyes. "You’re such a handsome young man!"
No etiquette lesson drilled into him by his family had prepared him to respond appropriately to the awkwardness of that Muggle woman. He simply nodded and smiled, sheepish.
"Thank you." He ran a hand through his hair, trying to play off the compliment. He usually liked being complimented — thrived on having his ego stroked. But the usual pleasure wasn’t there.
"What are you doing here?!" Lily had just finished coming down the stairs, walking over to him with loudly flapping slippers.
"Lily! What sort of manners are those?!" her mother stood up, hands on her hips.
Her hair was tied up in a messy bun, and there was nothing gentle about her eyes in that moment.
"Can we talk?" Sirius was grateful the embarrassing moment had ended with her arrival. "Alone." He glanced at her mother for only a second before returning his gaze to Lily.
All the tension and suspicion in Lily’s expression began to melt under the weight of urgency in Sirius’s voice. She blinked, nodded, and gave her mum a soft smile.
"Yes, darling, I’m going… it was a pleasure, Sirius." Mrs Evans pinched Sirius’s nose affectionately before rising from the armchair and shooing Petunia off to the kitchen with her.
"The pleasure was mine, Mrs Evans…" he murmured, staring at his reflection in the lemonade.
"Did something happen?" Lily asked, sitting where her mother had been moments before.
"It did." Sirius wet his lips. He’d rehearsed saying this a hundred times, and now that he was here, the words scattered like ash. "Didn’t you read the paper?"
"The paper? The Prophet?" She raised an eyebrow. "No… because of my parents… they get worried about the war."
Sirius nodded, taking a sip of the lemonade and letting the tartness twist through his taste buds.
"Scar’s parents… and her brother… died in a fire." He fought hard to keep his voice from cracking mid-sentence. He drew in a breath, fixing Lily with a hardened stare. "The funeral’s the day after tomorrow and… she’s lost everything… hasn’t even got clothes to wear… if you could lend her something… and if… you could come…" He spoke so quickly it took Lily a moment to register.
"What?" she whispered, stunned.
Lily covered her mouth with both hands, her eyes welling up with tears. Sirius rubbed his fingers along the chilled glass, fighting not to cry too. He couldn’t. Not while he still had things to do — things Nate had asked of him.
"How?! Is she… is she alright?" she gasped, wiping away the tears, her face painted with sorrow.
Sirius wanted to say yes. He didn’t. He shook his head reluctantly.
"I don’t know what else to do." It slipped out, and he wasn’t sure why he’d said it to Lily Evans. "If you want to—"
"Of course I want to go!" she cut him off, sniffling, her face flushing red. "I’ll be there."
Sirius merely nodded, pulling a folded piece of paper from his jeans pocket. He waved it and held it out to her.
"It’s the address for the Potters’ Floo," he explained before standing. "It’ll be after lunch."
"Sirius…"
"I’ve got to go, still have more places to be." He cut her off again, heading towards the door.
Lily stood quickly and followed him, her face caught between surprise and sorrow. She opened the door before he could reach the handle. Sirius avoided her gaze, slipped on his sunglasses, and gave a small wave.
"Sirius…" Lily called after him again. He inhaled deeply and closed his eyes for a second before glancing at her sideways. "Are you alright?"
He froze like a statue for a moment.
"I will be," he lied, scratching his nose before heading back to his motorbike. "Oh… Evans… you should put a protective charm around your house. It’s… dangerous. Especially for you…"
"I will." Lily watched him kick-start the bike and roar off, blending into the stream of traffic down the road.
.
.
.
Before the fire, Sirius, James, and Remus had worked on Nancy to make her stable enough for solo flights, and they’d refined an invisibility charm, linking it to a button. It was the first time Sirius had flown alone, without James riding his broom alongside him.
It felt… odd. On the way to Lily’s house, he’d been so troubled he hardly noticed the wind whipping at his cheeks, buzzing in his ears, tossing his hair. Nor had he paid much attention to getting used to the balance of the motorbike or the view far below. The sun was beginning to set behind him, streaking the sky above with orange, pink, and lilac.
Sirius nosed Nancy downward, preparing to land, and touched down in a deserted alley. He turned off the invisibility charm and flicked on the headlights, cruising between terraced houses that reminded him a great deal of Grimmauld Place, slowing as he reached what should have been the Malfoy residence. Unlike the Evans home, the magic thick in the air here didn’t even allow him to see the house. Definitely a Fidelius.
He parked and dismounted, kicking down the stand, and stared at the gap where number 44 should have stood. He patted his pocket, retrieving the letter Pandora had sent him and read the address. The parchment burned away as the Malfoy home revealed itself: white walls draped in ivy, rooftops bursting with flowers, decorated with spinning pinwheels. A perfectly symmetrical garden at the front reminded him of the sprawling estates he’d visited as a child.
Disowned or not, they were still Malfoys.
Sirius grabbed the serpent-shaped knocker and struck the door three times. He’d barely stepped back and removed his sunglasses when the door opened to reveal a house-elf who looked him over top to bottom before offering a gentle smile.
"Yes, sir?" She raised an eyebrow at Sirius’s clothes, her long ears twitching as a sound from inside caught her attention.
"Black. Sirius Black. I’ve come to speak with Miss Malfoy."
"Ah, yes, of course, do come in…" She stepped aside, giving a slight bow.
If the Evans house was a textbook Muggle residence, the Malfoy home was a pure-blood manor, though there were Muggle artefacts dotted here and there. Unlike Grimmauld Place, they used electricity, and not all the portraits moved.
He was led into a large, elegant parlour with red curtains and armchairs, a Persian rug, wood-panelled walls, and floor-to-ceiling windows.
A soft throat-clearing drew his attention, his gaze landing on Pandora Malfoy, standing beside the grand piano. She always carried an air of serenity in her expression, and the way she held herself unsettled him, especially her stare. It was as if she could see all his faults with the mere flick of her pale irises.
"Hello, Sirius. How was the trip?" She clasped her hands in front of her body, and only then did he notice the gaudy dress she was wearing, covered in flamboyant sunflowers.
He shifted his eyes back to her delicate face.
"It was quick. Evans doesn’t live far from you." He tried to force a smile, but this girl made him deeply uncomfortable.
Pandora gestured for him to sit. As soon as Sirius relaxed his legs and leaned back into the upholstery, she turned her head.
"Mindy, would you bring us a refreshment?" she asked the house-elf.
"Of course, little Pan!" the elf’s voice practically bubbled with joy.
Sirius raised an eyebrow. He’d never seen anyone speak to a house-elf like that, but he made no comment.
"How is she?" Pandora sat on the piano bench, adjusting the hem of her dress over her knees.
Sirius cracked his knuckles one by one, eyes still fixed on her. Trying to find a word that could answer the question without making him break.
"Devastated." He clasped his hands, resting his chin on his fingers. "She can barely get out of bed."
Pandora nodded, her gaze drifting to the arabesque-covered rug, her pink lips twitching. She looked like one of the porcelain dolls his cousins used to play with, her skin just as delicate, her eyebrows pale.
"And you?" she asked, moving closer, her platinum hair spilling over her shoulders like strands of moonlight.
"I thought you’d be in Ireland with Lovegood." Sirius dodged the question, not breaking eye contact.
"I was going to, until I read the paper last week…" Pan tossed her curls over her shoulder.
"The funeral’s the day after tomorrow. Here’s the address for the Potters’ Floo… we’re getting to the place via a Portkey…" He reached into his pocket and pulled out the note, handing it to Pandora. "If your parents want to come too…"
"Yes, of course, I think they’d like to." She didn’t even glance at the address, her eyes fixed on him as though trying to draw all his emotions to the surface.
Sirius clenched his fists, suppressing those emotions, snuffing them out like a hundred birthday candles all at once, forcing the breath from his lungs.
"I need to go." He stood, forcing a half-smile. "Oh, if you could bring a few black dresses… so she can try some on and… she didn’t want to buy any and I… I didn’t have time, either." He swallowed hard, once again caught in the snare of those clear, knowing eyes.
Pandora offered a sombre smile, the kind that made it seem she knew exactly what he was thinking, like she could see right into his soul. Sirius took a step back, suddenly feeling exposed and intruded upon, his gaze darting to the piano.
"I… I probably have a few she could try. Although Scarlett does have a taste for some pretty tacky stuff sometimes…" she teased, making Sirius frown. Their fashion opinions had always clashed. "You look like a lost little puppy."
Sirius glared at her, his expression slowly darkening. He looked not just insulted, but also unsure. Afraid. Pandora Malfoy had always been odd to him — now that oddness felt almost repulsive.
"Shoving everything down like that is going to kill you someday," she went on, undisturbed by his reaction.
"Fuck off, Malfoy," Sirius hissed, jaw tightening. "You don’t know—"
"No, I don’t," she cut in, glancing at the house-elf who had just returned with a tray carrying a jug and two crystal glasses. "Sit."
"I need to go," he repeated, neck muscles taut. "I know where the exit is."
"Mindy just made this for you!" Pandora insisted, pouring out two glasses. "Come on, Black, I don’t bite."
"I’m not scared, Malfoy." Sirius rolled his eyes, exhaling a dry scoff.
"No? Then why are you running?" She picked up the glasses and held one out, tilting her head with an incisive smile.
"I’m not… running." Sirius snorted derisively. "I just…"
His mouth froze, and he licked his lower lip several times, trying to summon arguments, words that made sense — anything to end the unbearable moment. But nothing came, because if it did, he’d break. And if he broke, he’d cry. And crying in front of Pandora Malfoy was absolutely not part of the plan.
"You know, when I saw you and Scar for the first time in the carriage on the way to Hogwarts… I felt a bit sorry for her, I’ll admit. I thought… that Black boy’s going to shatter her heart into so many pieces she might never put them back together. And I knew it would happen, because I knew you. At least, I thought I did." She sipped her drink, placing his on the table. "You were always cruel to anyone from Slytherin. You and your mates… always pulling pranks on us, even the ones who’d never done anything to you."
Sirius blinked, not expecting those words to hit him so hard.
"I… I didn’t… I didn’t know…"
"But—" Pandora cut him off once again, turning the glass slowly in her hands. "…you made her so happy that I couldn’t understand it. How could Scarlett fall for a boy so reckless, childish, and shallow? You hurt her… more than once. You were a tosser, and I thought— I truly believed you were everything Regulus said you were. But then I saw the way you looked at her while you danced at the Winter Ball… it’s the same way you’re looking at me now. That lost, slightly arrogant look, trying to mask your longing with smugness, acting like a prat just to avoid admitting how you actually feel. I realised then that you loved her… and that you weren’t as cowardly as Regulus, too afraid to step forward— but you also weren’t brave enough to say it out loud.
"And then you two started dating, and I had to put up with you, and it turned out… you’re not that bad. I mean, I still think you’re a tosser… but you saved her life. And now you’re shouldering all the weight she’d be carrying if she were alone. But… you’re not Atlas, Sirius. You can’t carry the whole bloody world on your shoulders."
Pandora’s face blurred suddenly. Sirius blinked hard, forcing back the tears that surged uncontrollably in a wave, choking him, making him gasp as he tried to suppress them. But they were too many, as if Pandora’s words had unwrapped everything he’d been holding in for days—tearing open the wound in his chest, making it bleed again. The feeling of waking in a panic, the agony of hearing Scarlett cry out for Orfeu, the desperation of holding her back, of stopping her from walking into the fire.
The scream Scarlett gave when she realised they were the only ones who made it out alive.
Sirius shuddered all over, a wave of nausea rising through his body, bile burning his throat. He wasn’t just crying—he was sobbing and coughing like he couldn’t breathe, like his lungs were still full of smoke and Scarlett’s screams were tangled with the crackling of flames.
Pandora pulled him into a hug, though he didn’t return it. His hands stayed over his face, his body curled in on itself, feeling the soft pats she gave his back, her ridiculous dress brushing against his leather jacket.
"That’s what friends are for, you know?" she murmured. "To help you carry the weight of the world."
Sirius only grunted, his mechanical breathing swallowing his words and stealing his breath. Not that he needed to say anything—Pandora had dissected him with such ease that he felt utterly foolish now, crying in the arms of his girlfriend’s best friend after refusing to do the same with Remus. A flush of shame surged at his core, and he made a half-hearted attempt to push her away, but Pandora didn’t let him.
"I…" was all that left his lips, the sound trembling and vague.
"I know, Sirius." Pandora said it with such gentleness that he wanted to scream at her. "I know."
Despite everything, Sirius Black was still just a seventeen-year-old boy with too much trauma and too little emotional intelligence. So all that followed were muddled words, soaked in suffering. He was terrible at this—admitting weakness, asking for help. Pandora knew that. Regulus and Sirius weren’t all that different—they’d come from the same home, were raised the same twisted way, the warped touch of their parents still etched deep into them.
Usually, it was Scarlett who comforted Sirius. And when the roles reversed, he felt that absence keenly. He missed having someone hold him without judgement or bitterness—just… understanding. He couldn’t do that with Remus; their bond hadn’t been the same since what he did with Snape. He still felt inhibited, hesitant.
And Pandora… she was doing a bloody good job of piecing him back together. One hand rubbing his back, the other stroking his hair. Sirius didn’t let just anyone touch his hair—that alone was a strong vote of trust, not to shove her away the moment those pale, thin fingers brushed through his dark locks.
Before he even realised, he was back on the sofa, sipping that damned refreshment. His chest was riddled with involuntary spasms, making it hard to drink without choking. Even so, he forced himself to do it, calming slowly, wiping his wet, red face with one hand.
"What do you need?" Pandora asked, crossing her legs. As if he hadn’t just been sobbing like a child moments earlier.
Sirius shrugged, pushing his hair behind his ears.
"Apart from the clothes? If… if you could get there early and…" He faltered, clearing his throat. "Talk to her a bit. I don’t know. I’ve never planned a funeral before, but it’s mostly up to Scar’s family… it’ll be in Italy, or something…"
"And after that? Are you two moving in together?" The question was so direct it left Sirius reeling.
"I don’t know… she… she didn’t want to live with me before everything happened… I think she’s going to stay with her uncle…" Sirius pressed his lips together, trying to hide the hurt that crept in with the words. "But I bought a house. And I want to… I’ve been looking for a piano… for her. She had a Steinway & Sons, and I checked the prices of a few… but I’ve got no bloody clue which one to get."
Pandora smiled, clearly pleased.
"My uncle owns a piano shop. He can help us out. If you want, of course." She tapped her fingers along the arm of the sofa. "What else?"
"I think… I think that’s it." Sirius faltered, still a bit stunned by how she’d taken the reins of the situation.
"Very well. I’ll speak to him and send you an answer. I’ll get to the Potters’ place early too. And… thank you for proving I was partially wrong about you." She grinned, lightening the mood.
Sirius allowed himself a scoffing chuckle as he stood.
"Partially?" He placed a hand over his chest in mock offence. "I’m the nicest bloke in that school!"
"Oh, not even close!" Pandora elbowed him as she passed.
"You’re a Slytherin, your opinion doesn’t count!" He followed her to the hallway.
"I was going to say you have the best hair in Hogwarts, but since my opinion’s irrelevant…" She waved her hand as though brushing the subject away.
"It counts… partially ," Sirius said with casual ease as he stepped out of the Malfoy house when Pandora opened the door for him.
She leaned against the doorframe and crossed her arms. That discomfort he’d always felt in her presence was gone now. He bid her farewell with a small smile, slipping on his sunglasses.
"Sirius…" Pandora called after him as he was halfway across the symmetrical garden. "Take care of her."
"I will," he replied, raising a hand in a wave as he pulled the motorbike keys from his pocket.
"And stop riding that bloody motorbike drunk… I could smell the whisky from here." Pandora scrunched her nose, like he reeked. Then her voice turned serious. "Scarlett won’t survive losing you too."
Sirius couldn’t stop the stab of guilt that lodged itself in his chest at the rebuke. He wasn’t drunk — or at least he didn’t think he was — but Pandora was right.
"Yes, ma’am." He nodded as he mounted Nancy. "Thanks, Pandora." He finally managed to say, his voice soft, with a shy smile.
"You can call me Pan."
"If I call you Pan, Regulus’ll kill me." He kicked the starter pedal of the bike. "See you the day after tomorrow… Pan."
Sirius revved the engine before she could respond.
.
.
.
Scarlett ran her fingers over the dozens of black dresses laid out on her bed, unable to choose one. They all looked the same, meaningless… dead.
"I don’t want to go, Pan," Scarlett murmured, lifting her gaze to her friend. "I don’t want to go."
It was the first time she’d ever seen Pandora in somber clothing. Her curls were pinned up in a bun and she wore no makeup, yet her cheeks were perfectly rosy, like a doll’s.
"Scar…" She touched her shoulder firmly. "Your parents deserve a farewell, and you deserve the chance to say goodbye."
Scarlett gave a melancholy smile, wrapping her arms around herself as if trying to hold in all the emotions threatening to burst from her chest. She blinked, shaking her head as if to push everything away, her face contorting in a grimace of sorrow, though not a single tear fell.
"I don’t know if I’m ready, Pan." Her voice cracked several times, as if speaking were too much to bear. "I don’t think I ever will be." She stared at the dresses, though she wasn’t really seeing them. She was far too busy trying to bury the pain in her chest, desperate to be rid of it. "I just… I want it all to disappear and…"
What was the point in saying anything? As fleeting as the wind leaving her lungs, her family’s life had been snatched away. Nothing she said could change that, no matter how much she wished it, how hard she begged — what was done was done, and all that was left was acceptance. Pandora pulled her into a hug and kissed her cheek in a way that reminded her painfully of her mother.
Scarlett remained frozen, as if staying perfectly still might make time pause and rewind, undoing life’s cruelties and bringing back those who never should’ve gone. It was asking too much — she knew that. She asked anyway, rubbing her Ouroboros.
Sirius appeared at the door, dressed in black from head to toe. That was his colour — it always had been. Black suited him, gave him an air of nobility and grace. He looked at her with that ever-present worry, smiling in that way that always made her heart skip a beat, even if he wasn’t truly happy. Sirius was good at pretending he didn’t feel anything. Scarlett was shit at it, because all she could offer back was a grimace to dam the pain spilling out of her chest.
"Dull," Scarlett muttered at the dress she was holding, tossing it to the floor. She knew Lily had brought it, but she couldn’t help herself.
"Why don’t you try this one?" Lily suggested as she stepped out of the bathroom, dressed so elegantly that Scarlett wrinkled her nose.
"Why are you even here? We’re not friends..."
"Scarlett," Sirius scolded, like she was a little girl. She shot him a sharp look before exhaling and nodding.
"Sorry," she mumbled, facing the redhead, who replied with a kind smile. "Ugly, too long, I hate strapless, too hot for this time of year..." She discarded four more, leaving five.
"My favourite is this one," Pandora pointed to a sleeveless dress that fell just to the knees, made of a matte fabric.
"Mine too," Lily agreed, lifting it and holding it up in front of Scarlett’s body as if trying to measure whether it would fit.
And that was a mistake, because Scarlett got lost in those brilliant green eyes that seemed to transport her to another reality — a place where all that existed was the whisper of the wind, the green of the grass, and the warmth of the sun. She nodded silently, after staring at Lily for what felt like an eternity.
Scarlett took a step back and pulled off Sirius’s David Bowie T-shirt without a shred of shame, making her boyfriend’s eyes go wide, Lily cover her face in embarrassment, and Pandora raise an eyebrow at the sight of her breasts.
Then she slipped off her shorts and put on the dress in one smooth motion, with Pandora helping to adjust the shoulders and Lily tugging it down over her legs, until it fit just right. She heard Sirius sigh, still leaning against the doorframe, staring at her like she was the only thing that existed in the world.
"Let’s just get this over with," Scarlett grumbled, taking the fascinator Lily handed her.
Sirius remained in the doorway, blocking the path, forcing her to meet those two glittering stars. He tossed his hair back with a flick of his head and leaned in, cupping her face in both hands.
"Where’s my kiss?" He furrowed his brow, and Scarlett’s heart thundered in her chest.
Their lips touched so softly it could barely be called a kiss — more like a caress that echoed across her skin and reverberated through her soul, soothing the gaping vortex spinning in her chest.
"I’ll be with you the whole time, alright?" Sirius’s voice passed over her lips, their noses brushing together.
"I know." Scarlett allowed herself to smile, wrapped in the sweet mist that was Sirius. "I love you."
"I know." He ran his fingers through her hair and kissed her forehead. "I love you."
Their hands intertwined before they descended the staircase of the Potters’ house. Scarlett’s gaze drifted over everyone present. Fabian and Gideon Prewett, James, Remus, Fleamont, Ignatius Prewett, Dominic Malfoy, Frank Longbottom, and the Aurors accompanying them — all of them removed their hats. Euphemia, Lucretia Black, Alice Longbottom, and Iris Malfoy offered kind smiles and words of comfort.
"Ready?" Her uncle Nate emerged from the Floo fireplace, carrying a plant jar.
Sirius looked at Scarlett, giving her hand a gentle squeeze to snap her out of the catatonic daze.
"Ready," Scar murmured, and she was the first to touch the jar when Thanatos set it on a table and whispered the spell to activate it.
Everything spun. The floral scent of the Potters’ house was replaced by the salt air, the warm, humid breeze, the blazing sun, the island stretching over the tranquil waters of the Adriatic Sea. The sea was such a brilliant, crystalline blue that it looked like the sky had been dyed aquamarine.
It felt strange to be there after two years. It was as if she’d lived an entire lifetime away. So picturesque, so bucolic, it felt like another reality — as though the events of the outside world weren’t significant enough to reach this sanctuary her great-great-grandparents had built with such care.
On one side stretched a vast lavender field, a family estate. The rows were in full bloom, tinting the landscape in purples and blues, filling the air with a soothing fragrance.
On the other side lay the cemetery, embraced by weeping willows. She had never understood why her great-great-grandmother loved them so much, but now, in the sacred silence that danced between their branches, Scarlett understood. The soft music the summer breeze played through the leaves was somewhat mournful, nostalgic, introspective.
She watched the dance of the light green leaves, her gaze drifting to the stocks, pansies, and red roses blooming between the gravestones, bringing colour to the pale stones, decorating death with life.
"Scar!" A voice she knew well called out. A little distance away, part of her family awaited them. Her cousin Aether ran up to her, his bowler hat flying off his dark hair as he pulled her into a tight hug.
She stiffened completely, feeling Sirius let go of her hand as Aether squeezed her in a way only longing could.
"I’m so, so, so sorry..." he whispered into her ear, full of sorrow.
Aether Sallow was shorter than Sirius but taller than Scarlett. He had dark brown hair and light brown eyes. There was an undeniable resemblance between them, especially because of the freckles across his face.
"That’s enough, Terry," Scarlett muttered, pushing him away. "You’ve hugged me enough for the whole bloody year..." she grumbled, pulling a thoroughly unimpressed face.
"Stop being a cow," he shot back, only to receive a sharp smack to the back of the head from Scarlett. "Ow, alright, alright, I was joking…"
"Yeah, that’s enough, Terry, she doesn’t even like you," Moros shoved Aether roughly, making Sirius sidestep the stumbling boy.
Scarlett took a deep breath before accepting a hug from Moros. Unlike his brother, he was tall and blond, with sun-kissed skin and no freckles. They had different mothers.
"I wish I were seeing you under different circumstances, Scarly, but... I’m here now," he said, kissing her forehead a dozen times before finally letting go.
Scar hated how clingy her family was.
Then it was time to greet her uncles. Erebus was Nyx’s older brother, so alike her that Scarlett’s chest tightened as he pulled her into his arms. Then came her grandfather Leto, before the Gaunt side of the family overwhelmed her with hugs, kisses, and tender gestures that made her cry instinctively.
"You’re her boyfriend?!" Aether greeted Sirius with a handshake.
"Sirius Black," he introduced himself, feeling the boy deliberately apply pressure to his palm. He squeezed back, raising an eyebrow.
"When the old man sees you, he’ll want to die…" Moros remarked, stepping beside his brother and giving Sirius an amused look. "Moros Sallow, pleasure to meet you."
"He’s going to launch into that speech of his about how he spat into the wind…" Aether gave a mischievous grin. "You can call me Terry, Sirius."
Sirius returned a tight-lipped smile before shaking his head.
"You’re as handsome as my granddaughter said…" Scarlett’s grandfather, Leto, commented as he held onto his hat against the wind. "Welcome to Sallow Island, Sirius."
Leto didn’t look a day over thirty, which threw Sirius completely. Then a man of his same height, with plenty of freckles across his face, stepped forward and offered his hand. His brown hair was streaked with white, and his eyes burned amber in the sunlight.
"You must be Sirius Black," he said, raising his chin and offering a courteous smile. Sirius simply nodded. "You saved her, Black… and for that, we will be forever grateful."
"Did you know he’s a descendant of Phineas, grandad?" Moros said with a sly grin.
"I know, Rossy. And if you don’t stop pestering him about it, I’ll tell your gran and she’ll hex you for the rest of the summer…"
That must’ve been serious, because Moros’s brow creased and his grin turned into a startled expression.
"He was only joking, grandad…" Aether stepped in to defend his brother, but fell silent at a single gesture from the man.
"This isn’t the time or place for that, Terry. Show some respect for your uncles — we’re here to honour their memory, not to be cruel to our guests." He shot Aether a scathing look. "I’m Sebastian Sallow, Scarly’s great-great-grandfather."
Sirius blinked a few times, trying to do the maths on the age of a man who didn’t look a day over fifty. He failed, distracted by the sheer number of people he had to greet. He shook so many hands, received so many thank-yous, it all became a blur — as if he were some kind of hero.
He might have been, but Sirius couldn’t feel anything beyond failure.
Scarlett remained in the arms of her great-great-grandmother until everyone had exchanged pleasantries and stood waiting for her to move. She had never quite got used to her great-grandmother’s two-coloured eyes — one red, the other grey. Every time that crimson iris scrutinised her, a chill ran up her spine. Still, she smiled and accepted the kiss to her forehead with gratitude.
Melanie Sallow never seemed to change. Scar always remembered her the same way — easy smiles, golden hair, and enigmatic eyes. The statue in the Forbidden Forest didn’t do her beauty justice, nor her grace.
"You’ll go first, my dear," she murmured into Scarlett’s hair.
Scarlett straightened up, nodding, searching the crowd for Sirius. He moved through her cousins like a fish swimming against the current, drawn towards her as though guided by starlight.
Sirius took her hand and she gasped, biting her lower lip hard, forcing her legs to move through the wind-swept grass. She passed the graves of her family — Ominis and Anne Gaunt, Melly and Vince Rookwood, Adam and Fanny Gaunt… and her great-grandmother who had gifted her the piano, Gwendolyn Sallow, née Weasley.
Her chest tightened painfully and she buried her face in Sirius’s black tailcoat, letting the fine fabric absorb her tears. She barely registered the movement near her parents’ and Orfy’s headstones. She was far too immersed in the soothing strokes Sirius drew down her spine, the way his arm curled securely around her waist. Scarlett took a deep breath, turning gently at the sound of a guitar being strummed.
Moros was playing the opening chords of a song. Scarlett stood in silence as Aether began to sing — and that was the final straw. Rage overwhelmed grief, so blinding that Scarlett spun on her heel, eyes bulging as she glared at her cousins.
[Song: Led Zeppelin — The Rain Song]
"Is this the bloody Beatles?!" she snapped, making several of her relatives flinch in surprise.
"Um, yeah…" Terry confirmed, his voice faltering. "Orfy… liked the Beatles… didn’t he?" He shrugged, bewildered by the sudden outburst.
Moros, however, didn’t stop playing the melody — which only seemed to enrage Scarlett further. Unable to restrain herself, she tore away from Sirius and stormed towards her cousins. She marched up to Moros, who was holding the guitar, and tried to wrench it from his hands.
"Stop playing this shit!" she hissed, her voice trembling.
He resisted at first, shocked and confused by Scarlett’s sudden aggression, engaged in a tug of war with her over the guitar. That was when Sirius stepped in, placing himself beside Scarlett, just as stunned as the others.
It is the springtime of my loving
The second season I am to know
"Let go of the guitar, Sallow," he said, tone laced with threat.
Moros obeyed, lifting his hands as though surrendering. With the instrument in her grasp, Scarlett let the whirlwind of emotions burst from her chest. She dragged the guitar towards her parents’ gravestone, raising it as high as she could.
You are the sunlight in my growing
So little warmth I've felt before
It isn't hard to feel me glowing
I watched the fire that grew so low, oh
"ORFY NEVER LIKED THE BLOODY BEATLES!" Scarlett screamed, slamming the guitar against the stone. "He liked…" The vibration of the strings on impact echoed through her words. "… the Jackson Five! You’re a bloody moron, Aether — no one likes this crap except you and James!"
"I’m sorry, Scarly, I—" Aether stepped forward, but Sirius blocked him with an outstretched arm.
"I hate you! You cut my hair when I was seven and laughed at me with Missy… and you, Moros — you act like a little angel, but I know it was you who set my doll on fire that summer in ’70!" She jabbed her finger at both of them.
Sirius didn’t know whether he should move closer or wait for the rage to pass. To be honest, he wasn’t even sure it was safe to touch her just yet, so he stayed put.
"James Potter…" Scarlett’s voice was thick with fury and regret, making James straighten up in shock. "No one likes the Beatles, people only listen to that rubbish because they don’t know any better! Grow up and get some actual taste in music — the Beatles are for little kids!"
James looked around at everyone, his face flushed and lips parted in astonishment.
"Remus, it’s bloody impossible to guess what’s wrong with you if you stay silent all bloody day! Say something — none of us have a crystal ball to figure it out! Lily, you act all innocent in front of everyone, but I know you read erotic novels! And Pandora… I hate how much you look like a bloody doll! Why is your skin so smooth and so… bloody perfect?! Fuck off!" She took a sharp breath, her blue eyes piercing through everyone in her path. "You’re a coward!" she shouted, pointing at her great-great-grandmother. "You built this perfect little world, isolated from everything, instead of using your power to end the war! With you, it wouldn’t have lasted a bloody year! My parents wouldn’t have died! Orfy would still be here and—" Scarlett scrubbed the tears from her face angrily.
"My dear…" Melanie tried to speak.
"No!" Scarlett slammed the guitar’s arm against the gravestone. "And you!" Her finger shot toward Sirius. "I hate you. I hate your stupid, rebellious, perfect hair, how your eyes look like fucking stars, how bloody beautiful you are. I hate how you make me feel like the most incredible girl in the universe. I hate the way you hide your emotions, how hard you try to make us work. How you make me feel loved. I hate how, when I scream at you and curse you out, you kiss me in return. I hate the way you hold me when I fall apart. For Merlin’s sake, I hate how hard you’re trying to make me happy after everything that happened… even when you know I feel like shit… you’re still there, holding my hand and telling me it’s going to be okay… I hate that I can’t do anything but cry and curl up in that fucking bed and… you were supposed to break my heart, Sirius, not give yours to me in return ! "
Scarlett stepped back, breathless and tear-streaked, kicking the broken bits of the guitar as sobs spilled down her flushed cheeks. Then she flipped off the entire crowd and ran.
.
.
.
Scarlett lay back in the grass, staring at the enormous cloud overhead shaped like a girl with flowers in her hair. It swallowed all the light and warmth the sun offered, as if mirroring her state of mind.
"I ruined everything, didn’t I, grandad?" Scar asked softly, not even moving her eyes.
Lightning flashed in the sky, casting flickers of light across her face.
"Everyone deals with grief in their own way," Sebastian said, blowing out cigar smoke, holding it delicately in one hand. "But you did leave Rossy and Terry properly gobsmacked..."
"I’ll apologise later..." Scarlett sighed.
Sebastian sat beside her, resting his elbow on his knee, his brown eyes lifting to stare at the same point in the sky as hers. The wind stirred his hair, rustled the collar of his shirt, and carried away the cigar smoke.
It is the summer of my smiles
Flee from me, keepers of the gloom
"Will it go away? This pain. Will it go away someday?" Scarlett placed both hands on her chest, pressing her lips together as she awaited an answer.
Sebastian let out a low, nostalgic laugh — not one of joy, but of something older, heavier.
Speak to me only with your eyes
It is to you, I give this tune
Ain't so hard to recognize, oh
These things are clear to all from time to time, ooh
"No, my dear," he replied, lowering his gaze to her. Sebastian Sallow was a handsome man; like Scarlett, his face was dusted with freckles. A symmetrical nose and chocolate-brown eyes. "One day, you’ll think you’ve moved on... until something reminds you of them, and it all comes back — like a punch to the gut. We only ever learn to live with their absence, Scar… but learning to live without them? Impossible." He reached out and stroked her hair gently.
"There has to be something… anything… that can be done… that—" she stammered, wiping away her tears with frustration. "It’s not fair…"
"Life is fleeting, Scarly. We still have the privilege of time being less cruel to us because of the ancient magic, but that doesn’t apply to those we love. I lost my sister, my best mates, my nephews… Death, she’s always there. Lurking, waiting to wrap you up, kiss you, and take you away… and all we’re left with are the moments we had, the memories we nurtured, the loves we allowed to bloom. And one day, even that fades away."
The wind picked up, bringing with it a delicious summer rain. Miasmas fizzed above them, though thunder rolled without lightning. Scarlett watched the birds that had taken shelter in the trees burst into flight, vanishing into the grey expanse.
"Had to be a Black, huh?" Sebastian teased, shielding his face from the drops with his hand. "You’ve got more than fifty cousins and you had to go and choose him?!"
Scarlett let out a laugh from deep within, a sound that shattered all the rigidity, slicing through the pain that had been tearing her apart.
Talk, talk, talk, talk
Hey, I felt the coldness of my winter
"Don’t stay out in the rain too long, Scarly, or you’ll catch a chill," Sebastian said as he stood, glancing down at her one last time before walking away.
Scarlett nearly scoffed at that. She wasn’t worried about colds, or the chill now creeping through her shivering limbs, or the sound of waves crashing against the nearby cliffs. So many things had stopped making sense. Tears mixed with the rain, but she wasn’t exactly crying or curling up in grief. She simply accepted what life had given — and what it had taken.
I never thought it would ever go
I cursed the gloom that set upon us, 'pon us, 'pon us
But I know that I love you so
It was almost cathartic, the realisation that half the things she'd once thought important now didn’t matter at all. All the petty arguments, the hidden grudges, the trivial irritations. All the guilt she carried about her mother, the anxiety over her father, the frustration with Orfy. It had all turned to ash with the fire — carried away by the breeze of death.
Oh, but I know
That I love you so
The rain stopped falling on her face, and she opened her eyes. It was Sirius, holding an umbrella, his face painted with worry and tenderness. He leaned down toward her, black hair falling forward, his eyes reflecting the flashes in the sky.
"You’ll catch a cold if you stay out in the rain," he murmured gently, meeting her gaze.
These are the seasons of emotion
And like the wind, they rise and fall
This is the wonder of devotion
"If I get sick, you’ll take care of me," she replied, a melancholic smile playing on her lips, her voice carrying a certainty that made it sound like fact.
Sirius returned the smile, quietly resigned. Scarlett felt butterflies stir in her stomach.
I see the torch
We all must hold
"What choice do I have?" he teased, sitting down beside her. The wind whipped the rain sideways, dampening their shoulders.
Scarlett rose slowly, bracing herself with both hands on the wet grass, seeking his gaze in the light of a passing lightning bolt. Sirius was still holding the umbrella, shielding them partially from the downpour.
"Is there anything else you hate that I should know about?" he asked, brushing the wet hair from his face.
"This stupid hat." Scarlett tugged at the fascinator and yanked it from her hair with force, flinging it away like a discus.
This is the mystery of the quotient, quotient
Upon us all, upon us all, a little rain must fall
Just a little rain, oh, yeah
She wrapped her arms around Sirius, resting her face on his shoulder as she settled onto his lap. He held her close, letting the umbrella be carried off by the wind, the rain quickly soaking through their clothes, speckling his short beard.
"You're freezing," Sirius said, his warm palm cupping Scarlett’s cheek. She looked up at him without moving, her eyes locked on those two stars woven into his dark hair.
"You're warm," she whispered, finding comfort in his heat.
Scarlett lifted her head and kissed Sirius. The world around them seemed to slow down. The sounds of the island — the murmur of the sea, the whisper of the wind, the song of the storm — all became part of that thing that surged in Scarlett’s blood and settled in Sirius’s veins. It was cold and warm, pain and peace, rain and sunlight.
It was imprinted in the scent of lavender, the smell of wet earth, the salt of the sea breeze. In the soft touch of their tongues, the promise etched deep in their chests, the warmth of their mouths, the mischief in their hands, the roaring of their hearts.
Simple and complicated, it was anguish and longing, attraction and obsession, solid and fluid. The thread that had so fiercely ensnared them, wrapped and bound in an irrevocable, coarse, sharp knot — impossible to undo.
It was love. A young love, naïve and whimsical. Illusory and hopeful.
Sweet.
Sweet as a summer rain.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 7: TODAY & ALWAYS
Chapter Text
LXXV
Scarlett nestled against Sirius’s chest, hypnotised by the way the firelight played across his pale face. They were wrapped in a blanket, and he held a mug of hot chocolate, despite it being summer. Beside them, on the same sofa, Remus was engaged in a light conversation with Pandora, Lily and Moros, who were seated on the diagonal couch. Aether was sprawled out in an armchair, sipping on some pumpkin juice.
“So… you met at Hogwarts?” Aether asked, eyeing them.
“Us two?” Sirius pointed between himself and Scarlett. Aether nodded. “Nah, Scar, she… she… was… James’s neighbour,” he explained, toying with a strand of his girlfriend’s hair.
“I already knew them,” Fleamont chimed in. “I met Leto when I was doing business in Italy.”
“And Sirius practically lived at my house, so…” James shrugged.
A few of Scarlett’s relatives gathered around the fireplace, watching the conversation unfold.
“Are they all Slytherins?” Sebastian asked, gesturing toward them.
Scarlett gave an awkward smile as she shook her head.
“Sirius is a Gryffindor, grandad,” she said, resting her forehead against her boyfriend’s chin.
“A Black? In Gryffindor?” The patriarch raised his eyebrows in surprise.
“In my defence… I’m the only Black in history to end up in Gryffindor,” Sirius said, sipping from his hot chocolate.
“We’re all Gryffindors. Only Malfoy’s a Slytherin—her and Scar,” James added.
“Not sure if I should be happy or gutted…” Sebastian frowned.
“Speaking of which… do you have a relative called Phineas Nigellus?” Moros asked, and all eyes turned to Sirius.
He gave a sheepish smile.
“Funny, the first conversation I had with Orfy was exactly about that…” His lips curled into a nostalgic grin. “Whether I knew he had boils.”
The comment drew a burst of laughter from the gathered family members, and Scarlett took a deep breath, savouring the sweetness the memory left on her tongue.
“Orfy was a little demon,” Moros said, putting his sandwich aside. “Once I tied him upside down on grandma’s tree for a laugh, and when he managed to get free, the little fucker sicced a snake on me! Don’t think I’ve ever legged it that fast in my life—he was pissing himself laughing!”
“True, you came home bawling like Scarly did when I cut her hair,” Aether said, wiping his face as if drying fake tears.
“Fuck off, Terry!” Moros flipped his brother the finger.
“He caught me and Sirius snogging in the kitchen,” Scarlett added, her eyes on the steam curling up from the hot chocolate in front of her face.
Sirius scratched his eye, lips stretching into a genuine smile.
“Bloody hell, that’s right… on top of interrupting our kiss, he blackmailed us,” he added, savouring the memory.
“Classic Orfy…” Aether was smiling. And crying.
“He made Sirius beat up some lads who were picking on him at the arcade… or he’d tell Mum and Dad,” Scar went on, shrinking further under the blanket as Sirius’s hand found hers, gripping it before the wave of emotion could sweep her away.
“And did you beat them up?” Moros stared at Sirius.
“Knocked all three of them down, but ended up with a shiner…”
“All that just so your parents wouldn’t find out about you two? You wanted to keep it that quiet?” Sebastian prodded, clearly amused by the flush rising in Scarlett’s cheeks.
“It was Sirius’s idea!” Scarlett protested.
“You… you asked me if I had a problem with it and why I kissed you!” Sirius looked at her, jaw dropped, like she’d just betrayed him.
“You weren’t supposed to kiss me!” Scarlett covered her cheeks with her hands to hide the shame.
“No, no… Scarlett… you kissed me back!” Sirius shot back, flustered. “More than once!”
“Sirius… you really wanna have this conversation in front of my entire family?!” Scarlett laughed, wanting to bury herself in the blanket.
“Oh, don’t mind us, carry on… we don’t care…” Her great-great-grandmother, Melanie, said, waving a hand in their direction. “You two are just adorable.”
“You two are just adorable…” Moros mimicked Melanie in a high-pitched voice, earning a smack on the head from Sebastian. “Oi!”
“Show some respect to your great-great-grandmother, you little git!” he scolded, though all authority faded the moment his wife hugged him.
“Now we know where she gets her grace from…” James teased, patting Scar on the head.
“Shut it, Jamie!” Scarlett rolled her eyes as she finished her hot chocolate.
The conversation carried on through the afternoon, and by nightfall, most of her family had already left, leaving only Scarlett’s guests and the hosts of the house, Sebastian and Melanie.
“Scarly, darling, may I have a word?” her great-great-grandmother called gently, motioning for her to follow.
Scarlett nodded, unwrapping herself from the blanket and feeling Sirius’s hand tighten around hers.
“I’ll be right back,” she whispered to him. “I’ll be fine.”
“Really?” Sirius narrowed his eyes suspiciously before softening with a smile. “Alright. If anything happens… scream.”
Scarlett let out a small laugh, shaking her head as she stepped out of the cosy sitting room. She walked down a hallway lined with family photographs and entered her great-great-grandfather’s study. Sebastian Sallow was already there with his grandson Leto, as well as Thanatos Gaunt, who was the great-great-grandson of her twin sister.
“I don’t think it’s safe, Nate,” Leto said, leaning against the desk, while Thanatos sat on one side and Sebastian on the other.
“Ah, Scarly.” Sebastian gave her a worried smile, motioning for her to come closer.
Scarlett’s eyes swept across her great-great-grandfather’s study. She couldn’t recall how many times she’d snuck in there without permission, playing with Bonnie and later with Orfy, always getting caught by the portrait of Miriam, who had just arrived now, a book in her arms and spectacles dangling from a chain on her nose.
“Oh, if it isn’t a face I haven’t seen in a while…” Miriam smiled, and Scarlett gave her a shy wave. “I’m sorry for what happened, dear.”
Scarlett had been feeling much lighter throughout the day, but Miriam’s words pressed a sudden weight onto her chest, dragging her back to the reason she was there. Her fingers instinctively traced the scar on her forearm, her eyes fixed on the floor.
“Thank you, Miriam.”
Melanie entered and shut the study door, sitting beside Sebastian, her grey and red eyes locking onto Scarlett with unnerving intensity.
“Scarlett, we need to decide who you’re going to stay with,” she said, folding her arms. Her expression was stern. The red eye gave Scarlett a shiver.
“What do you mean, who I’m going to stay with?” Scar looked from Nate to Leto. “I’m of age—I don’t need a bloody babysitter…”
“That’s not the problem, my dear,” her grandfather Leto said, taking her hand and pulling back the glove until the Ouroboros was revealed. He bore a Signet on his left hand as well—a snake curled around itself. “You-Know-Who is after the Signets and… there’s no safer place in the world than our island.”
Scarlett’s breath caught, and she gripped her grandfather’s chair, eyes brimming.
“You want me to stay here?” she asked, staring at Sebastian. He nodded. “I’m not running away!”
“No one’s talking about running, Scarlett,” Melanie said sharply. “It’s dangerous out there. The death of your parents, and of Orfy…”
Scarlett’s brows knitted together, her nostrils flaring.
“I’m not a coward! I’m not… I’m not going to run just because—” she began to snap, only to be cut off by Sebastian.
“This isn’t about bravery or cowardice, Scarly,” he said, wetting his lips. “They tried to kidnap Missy on the same day as the attack on your house. And we’ve decided to close the island again. No one in, no one out.”
Scarlett blinked, stunned, unable to believe what she’d just heard.
“What?”
“We did the same during the Great War,” Melanie said, running a hand through her golden hair streaked with white. “At least until this war is over…”
“No!” Scarlett gasped. “I’m not going to hide like you lot do!”
“You can live with me, Scar,” Nate suggested, a cigar clamped between his lips. “My place is safe and—”
“I’m not living with you, Uncle!” Scarlett screwed up her face as if it were the most ridiculous idea she’d ever heard. “I can bloody well live on my own!”
“You can’t live alone. It’s far too dangerous, my angel,” Leto tried to soothe her, which only made Scarlett more exasperated.
“Oh, so I’ve got to do whatever you lot say? What I want doesn’t matter?”
“No, Scarlett, but we can’t allow your Signet—”
“So it’s the Ouroboros you’re worried about, not me?!” Scarlett’s voice rose. “Believe me, if I’d had a choice not to be born with this fucking thing, I’d have taken it!”
Melanie fell silent with a hiss of breath, massaging her temples. She too bore a Signet—a serpent that coiled from her upper arm all the way down to the back of her hand. She had passed that mark to all her direct descendants.
“I’ll look after her,” Thanatos said, tapping his cigar on the ashtray. “I’m not staying on the island anyway…”
“I’m not living with you, Uncle!” Scarlett growled, her glare sharp enough to cut glass.
“Dumbledore offered me the post for Defence Against the Dark Arts. I think I’ll take it. That way, I’ll be nearby…” he added, sounding bored.
“Scarly… we just want what’s best for you. For you to be happy. To prevent what happened to your family…” Sebastian looked at her with unease.
“For fuck’s sake, grandad, that’s low—even for you!” Scar snapped, slamming her hand down on the desk. “My family would still be here if you lot had left this godforsaken hole and actually done something about Voldemort!”
The mention of the name unravelled the tension in the room. Melanie exhaled as if trying to hold something back, her heterochromatic eyes fixed on Scarlett—one grey, flashing like a storm, the other crimson, gleaming like fresh blood.
“I defeated Ranrok… Victor Rookwood… Victoire Rookwood… Ruth Singer…” Melanie spun her wedding ring furiously around her finger. “I lost too many along the way. And the moment I struck one down, another rose in their place… Grindelwald… and now, Voldemort. It’s a never-ending fight, Scarlett, and I… I’m tired. I’ve lived a hundred years and with each passing one, I’m more certain—I’m no heroine, and I don’t want to be. That path only brings sorrow and death. And I… I just want you to be happy.”
Scarlett let out a laugh laced with bitter scorn.
“I won’t be happy here, gran. Away from everything… away from my friends…”
“You’ll be with your family,” Leto said gently, offering a sad smile.
“They’re my family too, Grandpa,” Scarlett replied, brushing a hand through his blond hair.
“Can’t believe we’re being traded for a Gryffindor Black,” Sebastian said with a smirk, finally breaking the tension in the room.
Scarlett gave a small, bashful shake of her head.
“I really like him,” she admitted at last.
“I hope he makes you happy,” Melanie said softly, looking at her with warmth. “The moment you leave the island…”
“I won’t come back,” Scar finished for her, the smile dissolving into sadness. “So this is goodbye, then?”
“Yes… until the war ends,” Sebastian said quietly, as if waiting for her to change her mind.
Scarlett didn’t.
Saying goodbye to them wasn’t easy. It felt like losing what was left of her family all over again. She cried quietly in her great-great-grandparents’ arms, gave her grandfather a tight hug, received kisses on the forehead from her cousins, and waved to Miriam’s portrait, which watched her with such gentleness that Scarlett felt a pang of guilt.
She walked alone among the gravestones, laying flowers at her parents’ grave and then at Bonnie’s. Staying on the island, with that concrete reminder that they were gone, would’ve been unbearable. As much as they’d helped her pull herself together, being there without her parents and Orfy just felt… wrong. Like something was missing.
Scarlett joined the group gathered near the lavender fields, where the Portkey that would take them back to the Potters’ house awaited. She scanned the crowd for Sirius and spotted him walking among the lavender beside her great-great-grandfather.
“It was very brave of you to save her from the fire, Black,” Sebastian said, gazing at the stars before looking at him. The night made his eyes so dark it was hard to tell the iris from the pupil. “I know I already thanked you once, but I wanted to thank you again.”
Sirius shoved his hands into the pockets of his frock coat and came to a halt, feeling the lilac blooms brush against his trousers. He looked up at Sebastian, wanting to feel glad to hear those words, but all he felt was disappointment. His mouth tasted like ash.
“I should’ve… I should’ve gone back into the fire and… looked for Orfy… Scar saw him… he was still alive and… she tried… b-but I didn’t let her…” Sirius stammered, clearing his throat, trying to sound more composed. “I should’ve…”
“You did what you could, Black,” Sebastian said, placing a hand on his shoulder, the wind ruffling his brown hair, his dark tie, his black coat. “Not everyone can be saved.”
“I wish they could,” Sirius murmured, his voice barely audible. He was still a bit stunned by how welcoming Scarlett’s family had been, by the fact this man was a hundred years old, and by the gnawing anxiety of what lay ahead.
“You’re not a hero, Black. Their deaths aren’t your fault.”
Sirius clenched his fists. Wasn’t it? How had someone broken into the Gaunt house like that? He was one of the few who had unrestricted access—aside from James, Remus, and Peter. It didn’t make any sense…
“It’s time,” Sebastian announced.
Sirius weaved through the crowd, searching for Scarlett, and found her chatting cheerfully with Pandora and Lily. The two of them looked quite amazed by her family’s island. Sirius wrapped his arms around her from behind, resting his chin on her shoulder as his thoughts drifted.
Then came the farewells, and once again, they were separated.
“If you hurt her, I’ll kill you,” Scarlett’s grandfather warned him, a little smirk full of menace playing on his lips.
Sirius simply accepted the threat.
“We’ll all kill you, Black,” her great-great-grandmother added, hugging Leto as she joined the send-off.
“I won’t hurt her,” Sirius replied, playing along, lifting his hands in surrender. “Promise!”
“Good.” Sebastian gave him a firm pat on the shoulder. “Look after her, yeah?”
“I will,” Sirius nodded, receiving a flurry of handshakes before rejoining James and Remus, who both pulled him into a hug.
“How you holding up?” James asked, adjusting his glasses.
Sirius shrugged, scanning the silvery and red heads for Scarlett.
“I’ve been better.”
Scarlett, Lily and Pandora soon joined them. Scarlett wrapped Sirius in a tight hug, pulling him aside from the others, taking advantage of the queue forming to use the Portkey.
“So… your offer… about us living together…” Scarlett pressed her lips together, tilting her head up to look at him. “Does it still stand?”
Sirius plunged into those ocean eyes, into their warm, inviting depths where a hundred stars shimmered. He wanted to live inside those irises forever.
“Of course it does,” Sirius answered, tucking a stray lock of hair behind Scarlett’s ear. The wind stirred, lifting her hair as their gazes held through the hush of night.
“Then I accept.” Scarlett’s voice trembled, not from hesitation, but from a blend of sorrow and guilt.
Sirius swallowed hard, the raw and awkward pain he was trying to keep sealed in his chest threatening to break through the cracks she so easily opened.
“I don’t know what the future holds, but…” His words came low… burning. “As long as we’re together, it’ll be alright. Yeah?” He wasn’t just saying it to her—he needed to hear it too. “I love you, Scarlett. I’ll always love you.”
Scarlett nodded, and Sirius stroked the freckles on her cheek with his thumb, pressing a soft kiss to the tip of her nose.
“I love you too, Sirius. Today and always.”
Under the silent witness of the stars drifting above the Adriatic Sea, Sirius and Scarlett sealed their words with a kiss.
There had been many lies in their twisted relationship.
Love wasn’t one of them.
And the moment they parted… everything went wrong.
.
.
.
Regulus huffed as he lowered his headphones. The carriage rattled with a creak, and the rain outside blurred the otherwise beautiful view of Hogwarts Castle across the Black Lake.
“Are you sure you’re alright, Reg?” Remus ran a hand over his tired face, then slipped it into the pocket of his blazer. “Fancy a bit of chocolate?”
“I told you I’m fine, Uncle!” he snapped, folding his arms and ignoring Lua’s watchful gaze beside the professor. “I didn’t even faint! It was just… just a vision.”
Remus didn’t seem convinced, because he gently touched Regulus’s cheek to check his temperature.
“What did you see?” he asked, running his hand through the boy’s black hair, a small smile tugging at his lips when he saw he was okay.
Regulus clenched his fists, his eyes drifting to the rain-spattered window for a few seconds. The breath caught in his lungs before he forced it out in one hard exhale.
“The day he… didn’t come back.” He shrugged, faking a smile that only made his discomfort more obvious. “But then the dementor drifted away and… everything went back to normal,” he added when he noticed Remus staying silent.
“Has your uncle Nate talked to you about it?” Remus leaned forward, resting his elbows on his knees. “About Sirius?”
“That I shouldn’t go looking for him, and if I see him, I’m to tell the Headmaster straight away?!” He let out an irritated sigh. “Yeah, he told me.”
Remus simply nodded, leaning back in his seat.
“You can always come to me too, if you see anything strange. Any of you, actually…” He glanced over at Luana and Victoria. “Anything at all… come to me. You know where my office is.”
“Yes, Professor Lupin,” Lua was the only one who responded. Victoria gave a sly smile and turned back to the window.
Regulus put his headphones back on and pulled out his pocket watch, staring at the photo of his parents looking back at him as though it were the saddest day of their lives. He brushed his thumb across Scar’s face, then Red’s, and closed the lid, feeling the tick of the second hand in the palm of his hand.
The carriage came to a swaying stop, and Remus was the first to step out, followed by Regulus. He helped Victoria and Lua disembark.
“…did the creepy old dementor scare you too, Weasley?” Draco Malfoy, a few steps up, was pestering Harry’s friend.
“Is there a problem?” Remus asked calmly.
Malfoy shot the professor a defiant look.
“Oh, no… uh… Professor,” he replied sarcastically, letting out a snicker before heading up the steps with Crabbe and Goyle flanking him.
Remus inhaled deeply, watching them go. Regulus didn’t linger long, giving his uncle a quick wave before following the stream of students. He, Victoria, and Luana sat down across from Victor, Vin, and Aphelandra Pyke at the Slytherin table in the Great Hall.
“Is it true your psycho uncle’s coming to Hogwarts?” Vin asked just as the Sorting Hat finished its song.
Regulus flashed a smug smile, tapping his fingers against an empty silver goblet.
“Maybe,” he replied, clapping as a girl was sorted into Slytherin.
“Wouldn’t it be brilliant if he finished what he started?” Vin went on, grooming his eyebrows with his little finger. “The Boy Who Lived would become The Boy Who Died.”
Lua, Victor, and Aphelandra burst out laughing, while Victoria’s face soured. She shot her brother a withering glare.
“Shut up, Vin,” she muttered, resting her elbows on the table. “He’s just a kid…”
“He’s not just a kid, he’s a freak!” Victor scoffed, rolling his eyes. “What sort of person doesn’t die from a Killing Curse?!”
“Why are you defending him?” Regulus asked Victoria, the smile still stretched across his face.
“I’m not.” She rolled her eyes and pulled a small notebook from her skirt pocket, curling inwards into her own introspective world as she began to draw.
“Alright, lads, sweepstakes time. When’s Black gonna get Potter? Autumn, winter or spring?” Luna pulled a magical box from her bag, which had drawings marking each season. “Minimum bet’s ten knuts.”
Vin was the first, throwing in a Galleon on winter. Aphelandra and Victor both placed their bets on spring—so did Regulus.
“If Reg’s going for spring, then I trust him,” Aphelandra said with a wink, flashing a wide grin. Her slightly gapped front teeth gave her a quirky kind of charm.
Victor and Vin exchanged glances before smirking nastily at Regulus.
“Yeah, he’s dead good with bets… did I tell you he guessed who’d get petrified last year?” Victor nudged the others into the conversation, but Regulus didn’t respond.
His thoughts had drifted far away—to a day when he’d been too young to understand right from wrong, but old enough to remember.
Sirius had been murmuring a tune softly to himself while focusing on the stove: his hair tied at the nape of his neck, his beard dusted with flour, and his apron clumsily knotted around his waist.
Regulus tugged at his trousers, and Sirius glanced down at him over his shoulder.
“Daddy, what’re you doin’?”
“Isn’t it obvious?!” Sirius crouched, scooping him up in one sweeping motion. “Pancakes, of course.”
The world grew bigger as Reg wrapped his arms around Sirius’s neck, seeing everything from his height—where he could spot all the utensils across the counter, including the pale batter Sirius had just poured into the frying pan.
“Pankicks…” Regulus echoed, one hand stroking Sirius’s beard, the other clinging to the collar of his T-shirt. “With… um… stwawbewwy?”
“With strawberry…” Sirius confirmed, giving the frying pan a shake to loosen the batter. “Wanna see a bit of magic?”
Reggie nodded enthusiastically, one finger buried in his nose.
“Yesh.”
“Repeat after me: Flipendo.”
“Flip… endo? Flipendo.” Reggie munched on a booger, trying to grasp what the word meant.
“Say it again.” Sirius looked at him, grinning.
“Flipendo!”
Sirius flicked the pan up in one smooth motion, sending the pancake flipping through the air and landing raw-side-down on the griddle. His mouth dropped open in mock surprise before he broke into a smile.
“Sweet Merlin, Reggie, you’re a wizard! You just cast your first spell!” he teased, grabbing Regulus with both arms and stepping away from the stove, lifting him as high as he could. “You’re brilliant, son!”
Regulus burst into giggles as Sirius buried his face in his belly, tickling him mercilessly. And he caught himself laughing like an idiot—just as Dumbledore’s voice began echoing louder and louder, pulling him out of the daydream.
“…and while you are with us, it must be made absolutely clear that no one is to leave the school without permission. Dementors are not fooled by tricks or disguises, not even Invisibility Cloaks. It is not in their nature to comprehend pleas or excuses. Therefore, I warn each and every one of you not to give these guards any reason to harm you. I appeal to our prefects and our Head Boy and Head Girl to ensure that no student comes into conflict with the dementors.”
Taking advantage of the fact that everyone’s attention was fixed on Dumbledore, Reg fumbled in his cloak pocket and pulled out the photograph he’d found in the attic of Lupin’s house: Sirius holding Scarlett in his arms, kissing her with an expression so solemn it made Regulus smile too—before quickly tucking the photo away again when movement caught the edge of his vision.
He knew he shouldn’t be thinking about seeking out his uncle—he had no clue what state of mind Sirius might be in after twelve years in Azkaban—but at the same time, there were questions only he could answer. Regulus was tapping his foot incessantly against the floor until Victoria gently touched his thigh, giving him a faint smile as a quiet request to stop.
Regulus muttered an apology, his mind racing at the thought that his godfather might actually be coming to Hogwarts. And if he really was—what harm could there be in speaking to him? Sirius had cared for him with so much love and affection, that much he remembered, even Remus had admitted it. Was he still that same person… or was it all just an act? A mask?
He ran a hand through his hair and let out a breath. Sirius was a murderer. He’d killed over a dozen Muggles. He shouldn’t even be considering looking for him. It was far too dangerous. Remus was right.
He clapped politely when his uncle was introduced by Dumbledore, shaking his head in an effort to rid himself of the thoughts. It wasn’t long before the platters and goblets filled themselves with food and drink—Regulus showed less enthusiasm than his stomach, though he did help himself to a large portion of chicken pie and roast lamb.
When Dumbledore announced it was time to return to their dormitories, Regulus sprang to his feet the moment Gemma signalled for him and Victoria to come over. Reluctantly, he wove through the students and stopped in front of the Head Girl.
“I need you two to stay in the hall and keep an eye out for any stragglers… absolutely no one gets left behind!” she instructed sharply before turning away and beckoning the first-years to follow her.
“Sure,” Regulus muttered without an ounce of enthusiasm.
He gazed up at the ceiling, where heavy grey clouds spit lightning now and again, mimicking the storm that raged outside. The wind stirred the hem of his cloak and pushed Victoria’s white hair onto his shoulder. He hesitated, then caught a few strands between his fingers, drawing Mimi’s gaze.
The hundreds of floating candles above cast an amber glow over the caramel in her eyes. Her long white lashes were barely visible, and her eyebrows hardly contrasted against her pale skin, making her expressions seem far softer than they truly were. Her lips, however—rosy and full, shaped like a heart—were brushed with a soft cherry gloss.
“Reg?” Victoria called gently, drawing his eyes up from the slope of her nose until he met her gaze. The Great Hall had never felt so quiet.
“Mimi?” he answered, feeling his face warm.
“I think… I think everyone’s gone now,” she said, swallowing hard and pressing those perfectly shaped lips into a shy smile.
Regulus's heart felt like it was trying to claw its way out of his chest.
“Um, yeah, best we go look for anyone who got lost, then…” he said, clasping his hands behind his back as he started walking toward the exit with Victoria beside him.
They’d known each other since before Hogwarts, and yet Regulus had never grown used to the dangerous proximity she led him into. It didn’t just make his neck stiffen—there were the brushes of hands, the knocks of elbows, the shoulders bumping together. Subtle. Instinctive. Normal for two friends who’d known each other for so long.
Still, Regulus could never ignore the shiver that raced through him whenever Victoria’s fingers touched his. And he always glanced at her out of the corner of his eye, wondering if she felt that same flutter in her stomach every time it happened.
Victoria, however, never let anything slip on her face—though the hand not brushing his was clutching her notebook tight.
There weren’t any stragglers in the corridors. At least, none near the Grand Staircase. Most students seemed to have taken the warning about the dementors seriously. Regulus stayed silent the whole way, watching the last few students enter the Slytherin common room.
“I think that’s everyone,” Gemma assessed, with Achilles standing guard on the opposite side of the entrance. “Tomorrow night we’re meeting to plan patrols, after dinner, in the Astronomy Tower. Be there!”
“Yes, ma’am.” Regulus gave an awkward little salute before heading into the common room and descending the stairs past the mermaid fountain, Victoria’s familiar presence at his side. “Goodnight, Mimi,” he murmured, just before turning off toward the boys’ dorms.
“Reg…” Her voice was no more than a breath, but it was enough to make him turn around at once.
Merlin help him—sometimes he hated himself for how quick he always was to respond to her.
“What?” he asked, one brow arched. Victoria stepped closer, lips forming a soft smile.
“Thank you… for earlier. For… for protecting me. I mean, it was… it was stupid of you to do that, but… really brave too.” She stammered, blinking rapidly.
“Oh, come on, Mimi.” Regulus tousled her hair with a wide grin, his heart skipping a few beats. “What kind of gentleman would I be if I didn’t?”
She simply rolled her eyes and gave him a gentle shove, a shy expression on her face.
“Goodnight, Reggie.” She looked back at him one last time, the flames of the green candelabras turning the caramel of her eyes to jade.
Regulus watched her climb the stairs and disappear into the corridor of the girls’ dormitories. He shook his head, trying to wipe the foolish smile off his face as he made his way to his room. He shared it with Victoria’s twin, Victor, along with Adrian Pucey, Miles Bletchley, and Terence Higgs.
“Flint talk to you?” Miles asked, flopping onto his bed. He was as blond as Terence, though his eyes were dark, while Higgs’s were light.
“No,” Regulus replied, unfastening his cloak, his gaze drifting over Terence and Adrian before returning to Miles. “Why?”
“I reckon you’ll need to speak with Snape…” Pucey chimed in, tossing a towel over his shoulder. He was one of Slytherin’s Chasers.
Regulus gave a puzzled smile as he loosened his tie.
“With all the drama surrounding your uncle and… well, I think Flint’s planning to bench you. At least until Black gets caught,” Miles said, pulling a face like he was trying to be sympathetic. He was the team’s Keeper.
“What?” Regulus flared his nostrils, gripping the tie in his fist. “What’s my uncle got to do with me?”
“Er… security reasons… something like that…” Pucey gave him a pat on the shoulder before locking himself in the bathroom.
“It’s not like I’m helping him sneak into Hogwarts!” Regulus growled, yanking open his shirt with more force than necessary.
Victor, Miles, and Terence exchanged glances before looking at him.
“So… it’s not true? You’re not helping Black?” Terence asked, crossing his legs and balancing a packet of Every Flavour Beans between his knees.
“Of course not! Who told you that?” Regulus put his hands on his hips, a deep frown creasing his brow. The blue in his eyes iced over.
“Er… Selwyn…” Terence gave an awkward grin, tossing a bean into the air and catching it in his mouth.
“For Merlin’s balls, I was joking!” Regulus let out a nervous laugh as he grabbed a clean change of clothes. “Selwyn’s a tosser. And besides, Black’s not even here—how the hell could I be helping him?!”
Victor rolled onto his stomach, propping his chin in his hands.
“How do you know he’s not here?” he asked, his white brows tensing and furrowing his forehead.
“Because I read the Prophet! If he were here… we’d know,” Regulus snapped, glancing toward the bathroom door. Why was Pucey taking so long?
“Leave him alone, Terry,” Miles said, chucking a pillow at his friend.
“Alright, alright, I was just… curious,” Terence said, raising his hands in surrender. “But hey… Reggie, at least they’re benching you because your nutter uncle’s on the loose and not because some rich bastard’s daddy bought everyone a Nimbus and stole your spot…”
He didn’t bother hiding the bitterness in his voice. Terence had been Slytherin’s Seeker before Lucius Malfoy bought his son onto the team the year before.
“Malfoy’s a right bloody arse, but those Nimbuses are something else…” Miles said in mock-seriousness, raising his index finger as if delivering a sermon. Terence retaliated by lobbing the pillow back at him.
“Oh, shut up, Miles—Malfoy’s awful. I hope you lot lose every match!” Terence shot back, flipping him the finger.
“I’m talking to Snape tomorrow,” Regulus said finally, before banging on the bathroom door. “Hurry the hell up, Pucey!”
“Oh, you know what that means, Reg… probably having a nice little wank,” Victor said with a wicked grin, prompting exaggerated groans of disgust from the other three.
No response came from the bathroom.
“Speaking of wanks, Aphelandra Pyke was practically drooling over Reg today,” Victor added, his tone thick with implication, which didn’t sit well with Regulus.
“She’s weird, mate,” Miles said, shaking his head. “And if you’re gonna go for someone a year up, you’ve got a whole buffet of options… right, Reg?”
“Yeah,” Regulus replied simply, leaning against the doorframe with his clean clothes hugged to his chest.
“And you’re always hanging around with Rookwood and Teixeira…” Terence said, right before gagging on a vomit-flavoured bean. He clutched his mouth dramatically.
“Ugh, not my sister, mate!” Victor grimaced. “And Luana’s completely off her rocker—no sane bloke would date her…”
“I’ve known Victoria my whole life, it’d be… weird…” Regulus let out a tight breath and shrugged. “And Luana’s… just a friend. They’re all just friends.”
“Really? So you wouldn’t mind if I asked Rookwood to Hogsmeade?” Terence asked, seeming entirely genuine.
Regulus’s heart skipped a few beats, and he dug his nails into the fabric of his clothes. He fought to keep his expression smooth, his emotions swirling just beneath the surface.
Yes, Terry, I’d mind. I’ve liked Victoria since I was eight, so get your beady eyes off her or I’ll claw them out myself…
Regulus took a deep breath, loosened his grip, and shook his head with feigned ease.
“What? No! ’Course not…” he said with a laugh that didn’t reach his eyes. “She’s like… a sister to me.”
“Told you,” Miles said, reclining with his hands behind his head. “If he fancied her, he’d have done something by now.”
“I dunno, they’re always together,” Terence defended himself, tipping the box of sweets into his mouth. “You mind talking to her about me?”
“You can bugger right off with that idea, Higgs—no one here’s getting with my sister!” Victor snapped, shooting him a deadly glare. “Besides, Dad got a proposal from the Averys—Luke wants her hand in marriage.”
Victor’s revelation hit Regulus like a punch to the gut. He didn’t even try to hide the shock from his face—and neither did the other boys. His saliva thickened, forcing a cough as the words lodged in his throat.
“Wait, what?” Terence asked, mouth still half-full.
“Yeah… they’re meant to marry next year, when she comes of age…” Victor said offhandedly. “She wasn’t too keen on the idea, but it’s not like she’s got much of a choice…” He didn’t seem bothered in the slightest.
The silence that followed was louder than a shout. Regulus could hear his own heartbeat, the crackling of the heater, and the quiet clack when Terence tossed the box of beans into the bin.
“I thought… I thought that kind of thing was over. I mean… you lot aren’t even part of the Sacred Twenty-Eight…” Miles attempted a laugh, awkward and dry.
“Oh, but the Rookwoods are an ancient family,” Victor said, twisting his mouth into a proud smirk. “And we’ve been pure for four generations.”
“But why just your sister… I mean… you and your brothers… none of you were promised off, were you?” Miles asked, now sitting upright on his bed, clearly intrigued.
“Not yet. This was just… an opportunity that came up. It’s pretty common in pure-blood families. Tell them, Reg.” Victor gestured toward him.
Regulus swallowed hard.
“Well, yeah, I mean… since the fall of… er, the Dark Lord… that sort of thing’s mostly been left behind,” he mumbled.
“Didn’t your uncle get locked up too?” Terence asked, sitting up straighter.
“Yeah… Augustus Rookwood… a Death Eater… like Reg’s uncle,” Victor said with a wicked glint in his eye. “But Father sees it as a political alliance—especially with the dark times creeping back in.”
Miles scoffed like it was the most absurd thing he’d heard.
“Dark times? You-Know-Who’s already been defeated.” He didn’t bother to mask the disdain in his voice.
“Has he?” Victor’s eyes darkened, shadowed with something grim.
The bathroom door flung open with a suddenness that made Regulus jump. Pucey stepped out, shirt slung over one shoulder and a towel over the other, trailing steam behind him.
“All yours, Reggie. Try not to cry in there, yeah?” he joked, ruffling Regulus’s hair.
Regulus shot him a glare, shoving past with a scowl before closing the door with a sharp snap behind him.
He stared at his fogged reflection in the mirror. Victoria’s getting married? To Luke Avery? Just the thought of the two of them together made his palms sweat, a shiver crawling up the back of his neck. He let out a shaky breath and stepped under the shower, his mind racing.
What exactly had Victor meant by all that?
Was Sirius really coming to Hogwarts?
After leaving the bathroom and bidding goodnight to his roommates, Regulus closed the dark green canopy of his bed and pulled out the photo of his mum cuddling the dog, studying it under the soft glow of his Lumos. The white beams danced across her cheeks every time she shut her eyes and the dog licked her face.
He flipped the photo over, his fingers tracing the inscription.
Scarlett and Padfoot, summer of ’78.
He smiled to himself, trying to smother the nervous flutter that always came creeping back whenever his thoughts drifted—almost involuntarily—to Victoria.
He extinguished his wand and forced himself to sleep.
.
.
.
The next morning, the first thing Regulus did after breakfast was make his way to the staff table to speak with Snape, who was glaring at Lupin with an expression even more disgusted than usual.
“Professor, I—”
“Can’t you see I’m busy, Black?” Snape cut him off, his eyes flashing with disdain.
Regulus straightened up, clasping his hands behind his back.
“Yes, but—”
“If this is about your position on the Slytherin team, it’s already been given to Lucian Bole, a year above you,” Snape said, reclining in his high-backed chair and sipping his tea with a sniff of contempt.
“But, Professor, I—”
“It’s not up for discussion, Black. It was a decision made in agreement with the Headmaster.” Snape’s voice rose just enough to hint at his morbid enjoyment of the boy’s frustration. “Now, if you’ll excuse me…”
Regulus merely nodded, his face burning with anger. He ignored his uncle’s attempt to call him back, weaving through the students now leaving their tables, still dizzy from what had just happened. Murmurs and whispers followed him as he passed a group of Gryffindor girls mid-conversation, leaving him even more on edge.
“So? What did he say?” Terence swung his bag over his shoulder and jogged to catch up with Regulus, raking a hand through his blond hair.
“Yeah, I’m out.” Regulus didn’t bother hiding the bitterness in his voice. “Said it was a decision made with the Headmaster…”
“Dumbledore?” Terence asked, frowning as they stopped in the antechamber outside the Great Hall. “Why?”
“It’s pretty obvious, Terry.” Regulus gave a smile, but it wasn’t one of joy. “I just don’t get it. Why should I have to pay for something that’s not even my fault?!”
“What’s going on?” Luana slipped into the conversation, tucking her silver chains beneath her cloak as McGonagall swept past them, her gaze sharp and suspicious.
“Snape booted Reggie off the Quidditch team,” Terence explained, clapping a hand on Regulus’s shoulder. “Because of his uncle.”
“Oh, of course,” Luana sneered, hugging her books to her chest. “Because obviously, you'd fly up there on your broom and carry him into Hogwarts like a passenger, yeah?” She rolled her eyes. “But I’m not surprised. Snape’s never really liked Reg.”
“Snape’s never really liked anyone,” Terence added, craning his neck to make sure the Potions Master wasn’t lurking nearby—he had a knack for showing up whenever his name was mentioned. “The only one he seems to like is Malfoy… and even that’s a stretch.”
“Well, he is the son of a Death Eater,” Luana said, as if Terence were a halfwit.
“Reg’s the son of two Death Eaters… and the nephew of another,” Terence raised his brows. “Your math’s a bit off, Teixeira.”
Lua sighed and opened her mouth to argue, but deflated almost immediately, letting the air out of her lungs as she tied her wavy black hair into a ponytail.
“I’ve run out of arguments,” she said with a sympathetic smile, pulling Regulus into a hug. “I’m sorry, Reggie.”
“It’s fine,” he replied in a tone that made it clear nothing was fine at all. “Have you seen Mimi?”
“She went out to the gardens with Diggory…” Lua glanced at her nails nonchalantly. “Why don’t you go after her?”
“Why would he go after her?” Terence pulled a face. “She’s probably got her tongue halfway down Diggory’s throat by now.”
Regulus shot Terence a death glare before turning back to Lua.
“Why would I go after her?” he repeated, exhaling sharply through his nose in disdain.
“Pfft! You’re such a loser, Reg,” Luana said, elbowing him lightly.
“Why is he a loser?” Terence looked between them, then his face lit up with a mischievous grin as he grabbed Regulus by both shoulders. “Oh no…”
“What?” Regulus shrugged him off more forcefully than necessary.
“You fancy her!” Terence exclaimed, practically bouncing.
“No!” Regulus snapped, his expression closing off as he stepped away from them. “I don’t know what you’re talking about!”
“It’s so obvious—how did I never notice before?!” Terence hurried after him, gleeful. “I won’t tell anyone, mate, but seriously… why haven’t you ever asked her out?”
Regulus had started the school year on the worst possible note. Not only had he been kicked off the Quidditch team, but now Lua and Terry knew his secret, and all he wanted was to crawl into a hole and disappear. His cheeks burned red, with both anger and embarrassment.
“It’s not that simple, Terry!” he said, dragging a hand down his face. “It’s… it’s complicated.”
“I was gonna say it isn’t, but now that she’s promised to someone… good luck, Reg.”
“Promised?” Lua wedged herself between the two of them, her elbows resting on their shoulders. “What do you mean, promised?”
He didn’t get the chance to explain—because just then, the bell rang, and they rushed off to the greenhouses.
Later that same day, Regulus was struggling not to fall asleep in Professor Binns’s class. Half the room was already deep into their tenth dream. Victoria, seated beside him, was diligently taking notes with her usual infuriating calm, while Luana was far more focused on crafting paper airplanes in increasingly complex shapes to attack Fred Weasley on the other side of the room.
Regulus tracked the path of one particular plane, which soared across the classroom and nearly took out the Gryffindor’s eye, prompting a stifled giggle from Luana.
“The next one’s gonna blind you!” she threatened with mock menace.
Fred was the textbook Weasley—flaming red hair, a spray of freckles, and a bit shorter than Regulus, with a rather prominent nose.
“You want war, Teixeira? Then you’ll have it!” he hissed, so forcefully he accidentally spat on his twin brother, who was dozing beside him.
With a precise flick of his wand, Fred turned his parchment into a swarm of tiny, lightning-fast paper planes that shot toward Luana with impressive speed. She, in turn, performed a graceful wand flourish, sending her own larger, more destructive planes to intercept his in a silent, spectacular mid-air battle.
Meanwhile, a small, distinctly different plane glided toward Regulus’s desk, landing gently atop his notes. He unfolded it to find handwriting so perfect it might have been etched.
Meet me in the DADA tower after class.
— R. J. L.
Regulus folded the note and slipped it into his pocket, only to be assaulted moments later by a sudden swarm of planes. He sprang from his seat with a jolt, swatting at the stinging paper bites that hit his neck and hands.
“Argh, Weasley!” he barked, drawing his wand and setting the offending papers alight in one fluid motion.
“What’s the matter? Gonna cry, Black?!” Fred mocked, lips puckered in a taunting pout.
“Is there a problem, gentlemen?!” the ghostly professor lifted his eyes from his book, scratching at his long white sideburns.
“She started it!” Fred pointed at Luana, who was now doubled over laughing.
“Me? Why would I ever attack my best friend?!” she feigned offence. “It was Weasley who attacked Black… look, Professor, he’s bleeding!” Luana took Regulus’s hand and held up the palm, where thin, red cuts shimmered against his skin.
“Oh, Mister Weasley… Mister Black… this sort of behaviour will get you nowhere! You know, as my father always used to say…” He trailed off, mouth agape, eyes closing as he promptly fell asleep mid-sentence.
Fred gave Regulus a smug, viperish grin, clearly pleased with himself. Reg hadn’t even noticed the stinging cuts until Lua pointed them out, the burn flaring up as he muttered healing spells and sealed them with a wave of his wand. Then he fixed Fred with a look of pure loathing.
“Blimey, you really do look like your uncle…” Fred whispered, eyes wide in mock fear. “Go on then, raise your wand—I know you want to. Must be just as barmy as he is…”
“Shut your mouth,” Regulus growled.
“Then again… not much to brag about with your family tree, is there?” Fred added, twirling his quill lazily. “Son and nephew of murderers…”
The bell rang, snapping the class awake in a jolt. But the smirk never left Fred’s face, and that—more than anything—made Regulus want to hex him through the floor.
Regulus, however, prided himself on his self-control. So he merely clicked his tongue and adopted a nonchalant expression as he shoved his things into his bag and strode out of the classroom. He had more important things to deal with.
“Don’t mind him, Reggie—he’s just jealous ’cause he’s a broke little tosser!” Victoria raised her voice, shooting Fred a glare so sharp it could cut.
“Yeah, look at his patched-up robes…” Luana added, flicking her ponytail as she passed by the twins.
“Piss off!” the twins replied in perfect unison, clearly uninterested in starting an argument.
“Where are you going?” Victoria asked as she noticed Regulus veering off from the path to the Great Hall.
“I… I’m going to speak with my uncle.” He pressed his lips together, palms sweating when he saw the faint flicker of disappointment on her face. “So… I’ll see you in the common room?”
“Alright.” Regulus just nodded and walked away as fast as he could, trying to keep his breathing steady. Victoria had always been his best friend—they told each other everything. So why had she hidden the engagement from him?
What’s wrong with that girl?
His questions dissolved as soon as he spotted Remus standing by the staircase leading to the Defence Against the Dark Arts classroom. There was a faint smile on his face, and his hair was swept back. The flickering candlelight painted his grey blazer in shades of orange.
“How was your first day, Reggie?” Remus asked, leaning his elbows on the banister, his brown eyes catching sparks of gold.
Regulus swallowed all the disappointment that weighed down the day before forcing a smile and pretending excitement about the topic.
“It was… great. I… studied… a lot,” he said, flatly.
Concern crept into Remus’s features.
“I heard… er, your talk with Severus… Listen, I tried speaking with Dumbledore—tried to convince him to let you play—but… he thought it was too risky having you out of the castle and…”
“You’re afraid I’ll help my uncle?!” Regulus snapped, unable to hide the sharp edge in his voice.
“No! Of course not…” Remus looked genuinely caught off guard. “We just don’t know what he wants, and we thought it’d be safer if…”
“We? Was that decision yours too?!”
“Well, I… I just want to protect you, Reggie.” Remus placed a hand on his shoulder, as though willing the words to stick. “Sirius loved you like mad and… I don’t know, what if he tries to kidnap you and—”
“Why would he do that?!”
“Because he loved you. So much.”
Regulus let out a bitter laugh that rattled his chest. His grey eyes hardened like iron.
“Not like that matters…” he muttered, gaze dropping to his shoes.
Remus took a deep breath, keeping his hand on Regulus’s shoulder. He pulled him gently into the shadowed corner of the stairwell, beside a clock that had never once told the right time.
“That look you just made… it was the same one your mum used to make when she was really upset but didn’t want anyone to notice,” Remus said with a soft smile, wrapping his arms around Regulus and planting a kiss on his hair. “I promise—it’ll only be until he’s caught, alright?”
Regulus nodded. What choice did he have?
“Now… I’m going to show you a place your mum once showed us…” Remus glanced both ways and pulled his wand from his coat, giving it a smooth twist.
The old clock gave a loud click, and the hidden door groaned open. Regulus frowned, looking up at his uncle, who gave him a mischievous smile and beckoned him inside. With a quiet Lumos, they descended the damp, musty stairs, eventually reaching a gate at the bottom.
Remus heaved it open with a resounding clang, and the room beyond flickered to life—dozens of almost burnt-out candles ignited, casting a warm glow over a space filled with odd instruments and wooden partitions dividing the room into sections. He walked slowly, running his fingers along the edge of a switched-off keyboard, following its cable until it vanished into a far shadowed corner.
“This was… her room, sort of,” Remus said as he walked to a strange little switch tucked into the corner of the hall and flicked it up.
A grid of incandescent lights buzzed to life overhead. Some flickered or didn’t turn on at all, but it was enough to make Regulus blink several times as his eyes adjusted. He took in the battered drum kit, the guitar and pedal board, a bass propped up on a bench. There was even an old sofa with a half-played wizard chess board on the cushion, missing a few pieces.
“What do you mean her room? And how is there even power down here?” Regulus asked, stopping next to the drum kit, spotting a polaroid faced-down.
“It was a surprise we made for her… when… when she lost her family,” Remus said, clearing his throat. The yellowish lights deepened the lines of weariness in his face. “We all took music lessons together, and this became our little retreat. I was on bass, James played guitar, Sirius was on drums… and Scar played the keys.” He chuckled, but it was a sad, distant sound. “I used to sing, though we all took turns… James was dreadful, Sirius could hold his own as backing vocals, but your mum—she could really sing.”
He stopped beside the mic stand, looking at it sideways, as if remembering something only he could see.
Regulus was too stunned to respond. He picked up the polaroid and turned it over.
James was sticking out his tongue with his arm around Remus. On the other side, Sirius was fast asleep on Scarlett’s shoulder, while she, slightly apart from the rest, was dozing against the window of the car.
Without meaning to, Regulus found himself smiling. Just a little.
And then he turned the photo around to show his uncle.
“I remember that day,” Remus said, his voice low. His jaw tensed as he looked up at the lights on the ceiling, as though trying to contain the roiling storm inside. “We’d gone to the water park.”
“I can’t believe this place was here the whole time and you never told me!” Regulus said, half-complaining, though the smile lingered on his face. He handed the photo back and ran his finger over the dusty cymbal before moving deeper into the space, pushing open a half-ajar door.
“That was their room,” Remus said from behind, his voice softer now—like the words themselves might collapse if spoken too loudly. He didn’t follow.
“Can I…?” Regulus glanced at him out the corner of his eye, curiosity fizzing at his fingertips.
“Of course you can…” Remus leaned on the arm of the sofa, staying back.
The room was enormous. A massive bed with faded, mould-speckled green velvet sheets sat at the centre, a sofa placed at its foot, a wooden wardrobe in the corner, an old heater against the far wall, and a dozen books scattered near a sideboard. The stone wall behind it was plastered with photos and posters.
Regulus reached out, touching a The Doors poster where the four members were split across separate frames, then moved to one of Pink Floyd, before stopping at an open tape player. His fingers brushed across the cracked, dusty wood as his eyes wandered to the polaroids stuck all across the wall.
Most were of Scarlett and Sirius together, though some included the whole group: dressed as Star Wars characters for Halloween; what looked like someone’s birthday; a Christmas photo; Sirius laughing with James on his shoulders; Remus and Lily sharing a joint; Peter and Scarlett in sunglasses, holding drinks in some dark, unknown bar.
One photo stood out—Sirius proposing to Scarlett again. But this one didn’t move. Regulus brushed the dust from it with his knuckles, and it peeled away, pulling several others with it, revealing the stone wall beneath.
There was something etched into the rock, rough and primitive, carved around a crooked heart. Regulus could make it out:
SCARIUS
I’M THE STAR, YOU’RE THE COLOUR
STAY WITH ME FOREVER?
Beneath that, written in a neater, unmistakably different script—his mother’s:
I WILL.
TODAY & ALWAYS.
His fingers trembled as he traced her words in the stone. He closed his eyes, blinking away the sting as the weight of the room—of everything it held—pressed into his chest. He tried to picture her there, laughing, playing, singing. Living.
He slipped a hand into his pocket and pulled out Scarlett’s watch. Opening it, he stared at the tiny photo inside—Sirius pulling a face and sticking his tongue out.
Regulus looked up at the ceiling and didn’t fight the tears that stung his eyes. He placed the watch gently on the sideboard, left open, and stepped backward out of the room—out of that little sliver of infinity that had once belonged to his mother. The memories wrapped around him like mist, heavy and inescapable.
Today and always.
Some things, perhaps, could be eternal.
Regulus wished Scarlett was one of them.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 8: She had rainbow eyes
Summary:
Two broken souls choosing each other every single day, even when everything hurts
Chapter Text
LXXVI
"Scarlett..." The voice, distorted by the fire and muffled by the smoke, called out to her.
She turned her face towards the sound, rising amidst the flames, running and running but never reaching it, the silhouette before the embers stretching a hand towards her.
"Orfy..." Scarlett whispered, a trace of breath escaping her lips. "Orfy... Orfy... ORFY!"
Her vision gradually blurred and the sound of the flames vanished all of a sudden. As her retinas struggled to adjust to the darkness of the room, all she could see were the starry eyes. Dilated, terrified pupils, dishevelled black hair, and a pair of dark circles sinking into pale skin.
"Hey..." Sirius’s expression wavered between shock and concern, his warm hands cradling Scarlett’s cheeks, forcing her to look at him.
"I... I forgot..." she murmured, still half-asleep. "The potion."
Sirius nodded slowly, pulling her against his chest, intoxicating her with his sweet scent, letting the bitter feeling that crawled through her body from the nightmare be driven away by his presence. Her breathing was still uneven and fast, triggering a crying fit.
"It’s alright, you’re safe," he said, his voice rough. "I’m here."
"I know," Scarlett gasped, wrapping her arms around his waist. "I know."
Her blurred gaze inevitably wandered to the window. Even covered by the blinds, Scarlett knew exactly what lay on the other side. She shuddered, despite the sweat clinging to her from the nightmare. Sirius gently untangled her hair from the nape of her neck, blowing softly as he stroked her scalp.
Scarlett let her tears soak into Sirius’s T-shirt as she closed her eyes, focusing on the strong beat of his heart, losing herself in the man who was all she had left.
Sirius held her the way he always did, with a tenderness she had never imagined he could possess. After a while, once her breathing began to steady and her sobs subsided, Scarlett gazed at him through the darkness of the room, feeling the gentle caress of his foot brushing against hers, the soothing stroke of his fingers through her hair.
"Can we get out of here for a bit?" she asked, her voice cracking. "I can’t... it’s hard staying here knowing that... my house is just there and..."
The words died in her throat. Scarlett swallowed hard, sniffling as Sirius pressed a tender kiss to the tip of her nose before slipping out of bed, rummaging through his trunk for some clothes.
"Let’s get out of here, then," he said, flashing the dimpled smile that always stirred the butterflies in her stomach. "I’ve got a surprise for you."
"Surprise?" Scarlett hugged her knees, eyeing the T-shirt and shorts he’d tossed onto the bed.
"Uh-huh," Sirius grunted. There was a glint in his eyes, a mixture of mischief and excitement that Scarlett couldn’t quite decipher, narrowing her eyes slightly as her boyfriend switched on the bedside lamp and started getting undressed.
She had to admit, Sirius’s tattoos only made his innate charm even harder to resist, drawing her gaze with ease. She was far too mesmerised by the way his muscles flexed when he pulled on his T-shirt, catching her watching with a lopsided grin.
"Enjoying the view, are you?" he asked, a mischievous look on his face as he threw on his leather jacket.
"You’re gorgeous," Scarlett murmured, resting her chin on her knees.
Sirius’s grin deepened and he shook his head, looking away, his cheeks flushing pink.
"Even all scruffy and knackered-looking?" he teased, biting his bottom lip, clearly relishing her reaction.
"Sirius... you’re fit even starkers," Scarlett shot back, making him clutch his chest and gasp dramatically in mock offence.
" Especially starkers, you mean..." he corrected, snatching the motorbike keys off the table. "Come on then, crybaby, get dressed..."
"I’m not a crybaby!" Scarlett grumbled, rubbing her nose as she got up with a long yawn. "Are you just going to stand there gawping?!"
Sirius raised an eyebrow before letting out a soft laugh.
"’Course not, wouldn’t dream of watching you change, I’m a proper gentleman!" he said in an exaggerated tone, turning his back to her — though not without sneaking a glance over his shoulder.
"I know you’re peeking..." Scar said as she pulled off her clothes, making Sirius quickly turn his face back around.
"Nothing I haven’t seen before..." he said, still grinning like an idiot.
"You haven’t... not this past week," Scarlett added, wrapping her arms around herself. "You can look now."
"That’s true. I haven’t had the pleasure of seeing the tattoo yet," Sirius said, sliding his arms round her waist and kissing her forehead. "Maybe tonight..."
Scarlett gave him a shy little smile at the suggestion, glancing down at the shoes Euphemia had lent her. She still hadn’t been out to buy new clothes.
They crept downstairs, careful not to wake anyone. Sirius grabbed a few buns and a bottle of milk from the fridge, handing it to Scarlett.
"Feeling peckish?" he asked, taking a big bite out of a blueberry muffin, getting jam smeared all over his face.
Scarlett nodded, wiping Sirius’s face with her thumb before licking it clean. She pulled a face at the bittersweet taste of the jam, downing the rest of the milk in greedy gulps. Sirius stayed leaning against the counter, watching her with that daft smile that refused to leave his face.
"What?" Scarlett asked, setting the bottle down on the sink.
"I remember the first time you did that... I was... bloody terrified. And turned on," he said, brushing the muffin crumbs off his jacket.
"Oh, Sirius..." Scarlett groaned, running a hand over her face in embarrassment.
"It’s not every day a girl knocks back a bottle of milk like that in front of me... especially when that girl’s you," he said, pushing off the counter.
"So, what’s the surprise?" Scar asked, feeling herself smiling back at him, infected by his silly grin.
"I can’t tell you. That’s not how surprises work, is it?" He frowned, taking her hand and pulling her towards the door.
Scarlett hesitated as Sirius turned the handle, her heart still heavy, her gaze dropping straight to the floor. Things were a bit less tense, but the melancholy still clung to her. The urge to cry rose again, and she had to summon every ounce of strength she had to hold it back as Sirius led her through the Potters’ garden to where Nancy was parked.
She clutched her T-shirt tightly, as if that could somehow lend her some sort of courage, the wisterias dancing with the song of the wind at her feet. The main street of Godric’s Hollow was deserted, the silence of the early hours wrapping around them. The night was bright, even with the waxing moon.
Sirius unzipped his leather jacket and helped her into it.
"You’ll freeze," he murmured, pressing a kiss to the curve of her neck before climbing onto the motorbike and folding up the kickstand.
"A ride?" Scarlett rubbed her eyes, trying to hide the tears that stubbornly kept slipping out. "That’s the surprise?"
He gave her a mysterious smile, tapping the pillion seat twice. Scarlett zipped up the jacket and climbed onto the bike, flinching slightly as the cold wind cut through the night.
"You’ll see," he said, glancing at her over his shoulder. "Hold on to me."
Scarlett wrapped her arms around him from behind, looking for a place to rest her feet.
"Watch the exhaust..." he warned, nudging her ankle onto the footpeg with his heel. "Ready?"
Scarlett took a deep breath, grabbing a fistful of Sirius’s shirt.
"Ready," she whispered, barely audible.
Sirius smiled, tied back his hair, and started the engine, the roar swallowing the hush of the night. He backed them up with his feet before easing onto the road. Scarlett caught, out of the corner of her eye, the dark blur of her house flashing past as Sirius picked up speed, the streetlights turning into streaks of yellow against the night.
Scarlett felt her stomach flip when Sirius pulled a lever and lifted the front of the motorbike, gasping in shock as they began to climb rapidly, the lights around them falling away beneath their feet. Her heart raced, the wind howling in her ears, whipping her hair back.
Godric’s Hollow became a scattering of tiny lights, shrinking into the distance until it disappeared entirely into the vastness of the night, giving way to enormous green fields washed silver by the moon. Scarlett’s gaze lifted, the stars inching closer.
The night was almost cloudless, so Sirius kept climbing until they reached the level of the wisps above, pulling the lever again to steady the bike, slowing down until they were simply floating.
"Scar... come to the front," Sirius said, his voice firm against the rush of the wind.
Scarlett frowned, resting her chin on his shoulder.
"What do you mean?"
"Climb over me and sit in front. I’ll hold you."
Scarlett let out an incredulous laugh.
"What? Are you mental?" she spluttered, feeling a shiver run through her just at the thought.
"I’m not going to let you fall," Sirius said, lifting his hands, waiting for her to take them. "Trust me," he added, with a small, steady smile.
The idea of shifting seats this high up was bloody terrifying, even with the rock-solid trust Sirius inspired. Her hands were slick with sweat, her body prickled all over, and the wind felt as though it might tear her away. Scarlett drew a deep breath for courage, lacing her fingers through his and bracing her other hand on his shoulder.
She rose carefully, stepping onto the leather seat and trembling as the night breeze kissed her cheeks. Sirius held her tight, filling her with a strange, solid sense of safety. With slow, careful movements, Scarlett swung one leg over his shoulder, then the other, ignoring every primal warning screaming at her.
[Music: Rainbow — Rainbow Eyes]
Her eyes met the falling stars reflected in his as she lowered herself slowly, clutching his muscular shoulders, the air growing thinner around her.
The moment she sat, facing him, Scarlett wrapped her arms tightly around him, her heart hammering against her ribs.
Sirius smiled, running a hand through her hair.
She's been gone since yesterday
Oh I didn't care
Never cared for yesterdays
Fancies in the air
"See? Told you I wouldn’t let you fall," he said, tucking a rebellious lock behind her ear and gently lifting her chin with his finger, making her look at him. "Look there..." he said, pointing at the sky while keeping a firm hold on her waist. "That’s the Ursae Majoris."
Scarlett watched Sirius’s fingers trace the outline of the constellation, the dimples in his cheeks deepening with his perfect, toothy smile. The moonlight, as always, was generous to him, highlighting his striking aristocratic features, turning the silver of his eyes into platinum, and brushing his hair with white.
"And that one..." he pointed behind Scarlett, his smile fading, though there was pride in his voice. "That’s the Canis Major. Can you see it?"
"It’s behind me," Scarlett said, lifting her head and arching her back as much as she could.
"Lie back," Sirius suggested, squeezing her hips gently. Scarlett looked at him in astonishment, her knees touching his.
"Sirius... I’m not sure that’s wise..."
"It’s alright to be scared," he said, stroking her cheek lightly. "Close your eyes."
No sighs or mysteries
She lay golden in the sun
No broken harmonies
But I've lost my way
She had rainbow eyes
Scarlett wanted to protest, her lower lip trembling, fear spreading through her body like frantic tentacles. She took a deep breath, slowly closing her eyes, surrendering entirely to Sirius’s idea. He placed one hand at her waist and the other between her shoulder blades. Despite the uncertainty, there was a steadiness about him that made all Scarlett’s doubts evaporate.
"Let your body go," he instructed.
Rainbow eyes
Rainbow eyes
It took everything she had to obey, squeezing her eyes shut as tightly as possible, her stomach lurching with vertigo. Why was she so afraid of dying? Wasn’t it exactly what she had longed for after her family was gone?
Just as Sirius had carried her from the fire, he held her now as she leaned slowly backwards, almost touching the motorbike’s panel, her head dropping back, arms dangling loose, her fingertips slicing through the rushing wind. Her hair billowed over her shoulders and back, lifting as though it were being pulled upwards by the moonlight.
"Open your eyes," Sirius whispered, so softly that his words were almost snatched away by the breeze.
Love should be a simple blend
A whispering on the shore
No clever words you can't defend
They lead to never more
Scarlett opened them, finding the constellation of the Canis Major floating above them, the star Sirius burning bright, outshining all the others around it.
Sirius was watching too, his irises shadowed with a melancholy so deep it made tears shimmer in them, falling as though they were forged from the same fire as the stars.
It was beautiful — and a little frightening — to gaze at the tiny burning points so closely, as if nothing happening down below could touch them. They were simply helpless witnesses to the storms of life, to the relentlessness of death, as ancient as time itself.
Scarlett’s dry eyes filled with tears, carried away by the wind. She had never been superstitious, never believed in gods or prophecies, but in that moment, under the watchful gaze of the brightest star in the night sky, she felt closer to her family than she had in a long time. As if they weren’t truly gone.
No sighs or mysteries
She lay golden in the sun
No broken harmonies
But I've lost my way
She had rainbow eyes
"Have you ever thought that... they were here before us and they'll stay here long after everything's turned to ashes?" Scarlett murmured.
"Even stars die, Scar," Sirius said, looking at her with those eyes forged from stardust.
Rainbow eyes
Rainbow eyes
Scarlett gave a sad smile. Not even the stars were immune to death. And yet, she felt lucky. Among supernovas, fusions, and galaxies, the brightest star in the sky had found her and given her its heart so freely. Of course, she had been burned many times — after all, no matter how beautiful they are, stars are essentially blazing balls of fire. It’s hard not to orbit them, because the same heat that scorches, also warms; it boils and it blazes.
And once caught in the orbit, it’s almost impossible to break free. Gravity had bound them, forcing them to move around one another until they stabilised. By then, it was too late. Scarlett knew, with absolute certainty, that she would love Sirius until all that was left of them were ashes and memories, until the stars themselves burned out and only the cold void remained. And if there was a life after this one, she would love him there too.
Sirius looked at Scarlett, at the hundreds of constellations reflected in her ocean-blue eyes.
"I know that... nothing I do... will ever take away the pain you feel... but I..." He opened and closed his mouth, tracing Scarlett’s jaw with his thumb. "...I’ll always hold you, no matter what..."
Scarlett gasped, closing her eyes, letting the sense of freedom stirred by the cold wind and the security sparked by Sirius’s hands give her enough courage to try climbing out of the dark, jagged cliff she had been stranded on for so long — the brutal rollercoaster of grief, the longing anchored deep in her chest.
Sirius wasn’t lying. Even when Scarlett had gone, he had held on to her. And he would again, time after time...
Scarlett and Sirius had been doomed to each other for a very long time.
Summer nights are colder now
They've taken down the fair
And all the lights have died somehow
Or were they ever there
"Hold on to me — your surprise is coming now," Sirius said, pulling her against his chest, and Scarlett clung to him. She didn’t have time to react, because he moved the bike’s lever and they began to descend at high speed.
All Scarlett could see, wrapped around her boyfriend facing him, was the moon surrounded by stars, until the buildings rose up in front of them, the city lights reflected in the dark windows.
The buildings gave way to houses, most of them built to the same pattern — single-storey, with sprawling gardens.
Sirius pulled over and helped her down. Scarlett wasn’t quite sure what was happening, her gaze sweeping over the symmetrical hedges of the house in front of them and the steps leading up to the door. Sirius squeezed her hand and, still in a daze, she let him guide her towards a neatly kept garden full of red poppies.
The same flowers from the garden of her house in Godric’s Hollow.
No sighs or mysteries
She lay golden in the sun
No broken harmonies
But I've lost my way
When Sirius unlocked the door with the key attached to the motorbike keyring, Scarlett grew even more confused. She stepped inside, stunned, finding herself in an empty hallway.
"I wanted to bring you here once it was fully furnished, but..." Sirius began, shrugging casually, though the gleam of excitement in his eyes was impossible to miss. "It’s our house."
She had rainbow eyes
Scarlett let out an incredulous laugh as she walked further in, her eyes falling on the hallway that led straight to the kitchen.
"Our house?" she asked, her voice breaking, on the verge of tears again.
Sirius nodded, closing the door behind her.
"Yeah. After everything that happened... we needed a fresh start. Somewhere just for us." He pulled her along with him.
"I... I thought... you were buying a house for yourself and not... I mean, I didn’t... didn’t imagine..." Scarlett stammered, completely overwhelmed and lost for words. The walls were white, unadorned; the floor bare; the fireplace cold and dark.
Sirius smiled, spinning her in his arms until they stepped into the living room, where a huge grand piano gleamed under the lights he switched on. Scarlett’s eyes widened, her heart hammering against her ribs.
It was a Steinway & Sons, black with a glossy wood finish, and luxurious touches of red and gold.
She lifted the keyboard lid, her gaze lingering over the ivory keys.
"You... you... did all this for us?!" she said, lifting her eyes to Sirius, not daring to press the keys. Her voice trembled.
"Yeah," Sirius replied, coming closer and resting his hand on the piano lid. "For us. For a future together... and everything we’ve still got ahead of us."
Sirius wrapped his arms around her from behind, resting his chin on top of her black hair. Scarlett stayed rigid at the contact, her hands refusing to touch the keys, her breathing ragged.
"Do you still remember how to play?" Sirius teased gently, though Scarlett didn’t even attempt a smile. It was as if the piano was an echo of her past — part of the ashes she was desperately trying to dissolve. For a moment, Sirius regretted buying it. "Why don’t you play a little?"
"I don’t... I... I’m not sure if..."
"We can try," Sirius said, dropping a soft kiss into her hair before settling himself on the bench and motioning for her to sit beside him.
Scarlett nodded and positioned herself at his side, her hands trembling above the keys.
She inhaled through her mouth, exhaling sharply, forcing her tendons to press the ivory hard enough for the hammers to strike the strings.
But the familiar feeling of lightness, the lift she used to feel every time she sat at the instrument, wasn’t there. Nor was the urge to transform her pain into music.
She felt heavy, weighed down as if made of lead, even as she tried to will herself into the right state of mind... it was too difficult, too far away.
"I can’t, I can’t, I can’t..." she whispered to herself, hyperventilating. "I can’t..."
"It’s alright," Sirius said, pulling her into a sudden, fierce hug that made her forget how to breathe for a second. "It’s alright, I’m here. You’ll manage."
"I don’t know if..."
Sirius sniffed, bringing Scarlett’s hands back to the keys with him, his own resting atop hers as he started to play the introduction of a tune she recognised but didn’t care enough to name.
She tried to follow him, but her fingers felt like they’d turned to stone.
She turned her face towards Sirius.
In profile, he looked like one of those gods the Muggles used to carve into statues — the epitome of a pure-blood wizard’s beauty, noble and symmetrical features, lips perfectly shaped, and those eyes...
Scarlett lost herself for a few seconds in that sea of silver.
"Come on, love, you used to play this with your eyes closed," he said, smiling — and the whole world around her seemed to tremble, the edges of his face blurring.
Scarlett looked down at Sirius’s long fingers, pressing the keys with hesitation, as though he wasn’t quite sure of the notes either. She wasn’t sure anymore, either.
The scar on his right forearm caught the light from the chandelier, standing out starkly.
Scarlett instinctively pulled down the sleeve of her leather jacket, staring at the continuation of the burn on her own arm.
"I can’t, Sirius..." she whimpered, dragging her trembling fingers across her face. "I’m sorry..."
"No, hey... it’s alright," Sirius said, making her look at him by holding her cheeks. "Why don’t I show you the rest of our house?"
Our house.
Scarlett blinked a few times, stunned. Sirius tugged her along through the living room — large enough to fit the grand piano and still leave plenty of space — and led her into the hallway where the bedrooms were.
"There are four bedrooms, but we can always use a spell to expand the space if we need more rooms... I mean, what if besides Sirius Junior and Ronnie James Dio, there’s a mini-Scarlett on the way?!" He burst out laughing at the absurdity of what he’d just said, but it was enough to make Scarlett smile too, even through her tears.
"But... there are four bedrooms," Scar said, running her hand over the white door of one, opening it and watching the corridor light slice into the dark, empty room.
"I know... it’s just that..." Sirius took a deep breath, leaning against the wall beside her, looking at her with uncertainty. "I... I was thinking about... asking Regulus to live with us. If... if that’s not a problem for you, of course."
Scarlett absorbed those words in silence.
The hurt from what Red had done to her hadn’t faded after everything that had happened; it had only become another thorn twisting itself around her heart.
For a few seconds, it felt like she was suffocating, her hand tightening around the doorknob.
"It’s fine..." Scarlett lied, the relief she had been feeling peeling away under the memory of the argument with Regulus... when he had attacked her and wiped her memory.
"This will probably be our bedroom..." Sirius said, switching on the light and beckoning her to follow.
Scarlett stepped cautiously into the room, crossing her arms as she trailed behind him into the bathroom, where an enormous bathtub sat in front of a floor-to-ceiling window, looking out over the grounds.
"Tada!" he said, pointing at the tub as if unveiling some grand discovery.
"Was this your surprise?" Scar asked, her lips curving into a small smile at the enthusiastic way Sirius nodded.
"Exactly! The surprise was the bathtub all along... maybe now you’ll actually have a bath every day..."
"But I do have a bath every day!" she protested, pretending to be offended.
"Not after we shag!" Sirius said, narrowing his eyes playfully as he brushed past her back into the bedroom.
"That’s because sometimes we shag after I’ve already had a bath!" she retorted, chasing after him down the corridor towards the kitchen. "You wear me out!"
Sirius flashed a wicked grin, grabbing her by the waist.
"Can’t blame you... who could resist this?" he said, gesturing at himself before spinning Scarlett round in his arms.
Scarlett loved Sirius — especially when he was full of himself. It was like one of the fuels that kept him shining, even if it was sometimes utterly infuriating.
There was no denying it: Sirius was the sun, and Scarlett only had eyes for him.
"Fully fitted kitchen, with an oven for you to make your cakes and all your little Muggle things..." Sirius said, propping his elbows on the counter. "And an island in the middle for when we get tired of shagging in bed," he added, drumming his fingers against the pale marble.
"Sirius!" Scarlett scolded him, her voice a few tones higher than usual, her face burning red.
"What would you rather I say? Carnal acts? Lovemaking?" He scratched at his now rather impressive beard. "Sex?"
"Shut up," Scar said, rolling her eyes and waving her hand as if trying to physically bat the subject away.
"Fellatio?" he continued, circling the island towards her.
"Fellatio doesn’t cover everything, you idiot," Scarlett huffed, dodging Sirius as he tried to grab her.
"No? Then what exactly is fellatio?" The mischief wasn’t just dancing on his lips — it flooded his eyes and deepened the dimples in his cheeks.
"No! Don't even start!" Scarlett pointed a stern finger at him. "I’m serious!"
Sirius straightened up, raising his hands in mock innocence, though the wickedness only grew in his expression.
"What? I didn’t do anything!" he said, as if the very idea was outrageous.
Scarlett let a playful grin light up her face as she backed out into the living room.
"You’ll never catch me!" she challenged, laughing as she darted down the hallway, hearing Sirius’s heavy, fast footsteps thudding behind her.
Scarlett glanced both ways at the end of the corridor before diving into the last room.
It was as spacious as the master bedroom, and the windows gave a view of something very dark in their garden. She didn’t have the chance to find out what it was, though, because Sirius came into the room, placing his hands on his hips and advancing towards her, his breathing heavy.
"Seriously? Is that all you've got?" he teased, letting his hair loose only to tie it back up again.
Scar flexed her knees slightly, giving him a look of pure condescension. Then, before he could react, she bolted again, ducking as Sirius lunged for her, slipping past him and racing back down the corridor towards the kitchen, a little out of breath.
"Never underestimate a Slytherin, Mister Black!" she sang, striding around the kitchen island as she stripped off her leather jacket, waiting for Sirius.
But he didn’t appear.
Carefully, she stretched her head out of the kitchen, her gaze sweeping the living room.
No sign of Sirius.
She stepped back — and bumped straight into something, letting out a startled squeak that turned into a laugh.
Sirius caught her by the waist, lifting her clean off the floor. Scarlett let out a nervous laugh as he hoisted her over his shoulder. She kicked her legs on purpose, trying to make him put her down, but Sirius clearly had other plans — he held her easily with one arm as he carried her to the piano, where he gently laid her down on the lid.
Scarlett’s laughter began to fade, though her eyes remained fixed on him, her chest aching, her lungs burning. She couldn’t remember feeling this happy in days — it was as if the sun had finally risen, blessing her with its warmth.
Something bright and overwhelming unfurled inside her, wrapping itself around the pain, quickening her heartbeat, leaving her utterly stunned.
She had felt so suffocated for so long that it was like remembering how to breathe again, how to see the world without everything being painted in grey, realising that there was still beauty left — even if her family were no longer there.
Sirius leaned over her, his face mere inches from hers, his eyes molten with amusement and desire, the stray locks of his hair brushing against her cheeks.
"Got you," he murmured into the tiny space between them, before dissolving it completely with a kiss.
Scarlett closed her eyes, sinking into his lips like someone falling into the fleeting happiness of a perfect moment, praying it would never end, that the warmth would never fade, that the stars would never go out.
She had missed this.
The thirst that made her tangle her tongue with his, the dazed, intoxicated state he provoked where nothing in the world mattered except for them, the fire that burned in her chest and grew into an inferno at his touch.
And Scarlett let herself burn, biting his lower lip in the way she knew drove him mad, tugging hard at his black hair and breaking the kiss, hearing the tortured gasps that only heightened her own desire.
His tattooed hands slid down her torso, tugging her T-shirt upwards. Scarlett closed her eyes and lifted her arms, feeling the fabric vanish and leaving nothing but Sirius’s ragged breathing at her collarbone, where he began to mark her skin with a trail of bruising kisses of varying intensity, his hands busy kneading and pinching her breasts.
Scarlett rolled her eyes back, clutching at his hair as if afraid his wicked mouth might abandon her skin.
But Sirius would never tire of Scarlett — so his fingers gave her hardened nipples one last sharp twist before he tried to push her breasts together, nipping at them both at once.
It was enough to make Scar shudder, her lips almost begging him to hurry.
But she needed to be patient, so she bit down a desperate moan as the fire in her veins prickled across her skin the instant one of Sirius’s hands slipped inside the shorts she was wearing, rubbing her over her knickers.
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, focusing on the wicked fingers tracing random patterns over the fabric, her legs automatically relaxing and falling open as far as they could, giving him room to settle his hips between them.
Sirius soon trailed his kisses back up, his beard rasping deliciously against her neck until he recaptured her lips in a wet, urgent kiss.
Scarlett sat up and reached for his belt with clumsy urgency, her fingers fumbling at the buckle. His trousers fell to the floor with a thud, and he wasted no time tugging Scarlett’s shorts away, leaving her completely naked.
She pulled at Sirius’s T-shirt and he simply lifted his arms for her to peel it off.
He climbed onto the piano lid, his shadow swallowing her up the moment their mouths found each other again, kissing her like it was as essential as the air filling his lungs.
Scarlett was burning, so hot that Sirius pinned her back against the lid as he positioned himself between her legs.
His cock, already hard, throbbed as the familiar heat of her brushed against the head.
Scarlett took a deep breath into the kiss and Sirius pulled her legs up, resting her ankles over his shoulders in a rather unconventional position.
Scarlett’s eyes widened slightly, her hips lifting as Sirius pushed inside her slowly, making her thighs tremble with the sweet burn his thick length brought, stretching and filling her as if it were the very first time, the snug grip of her wet walls clutching at him.
Sirius locked eyes with her as he sank all the way in.
The position let him reach so deep that Scarlett felt the tip of him brushing against her cervix in a slight, aching pressure.
He didn’t move — he was too overwhelmed by the feeling of being utterly one with her.
Sirius twisted a lock of Scarlett’s hair around his finger, their noses brushing, their mouths barely apart as their breath mingled, languid and shaky.
Scarlett licked at his lips, trying to coax him to move, but Sirius was so lost in her he barely reacted, his thumb gently stroking her ankle, his nose nuzzling along her cheeks.
"I love you," he murmured against her mouth, his voice a raw scrape of feeling. "I love you so much."
Sirius blinked hard, as if trying to focus better on Scarlett’s face, on the stunned lines softening her expression.
"I love you too," she whispered, tightening her arms around him. "So much."
Sirius moved with long, deliberate thrusts, pulling out and pushing back in so slowly that Scarlett tried to lower her legs, desperate to force him to speed up.
But she only realised it wasn’t just about sex when Sirius drove into her a few more times without breaking eye contact, drawing her into those twin pools of bright silver, into the blown pupils, into the reflection of her own soul.
Scarlett was a lost soul.
As lost as Sirius.
There was no place in the world they could truly call their own, so they would have to carve it out, earn it, or claim it.
And what better place to belong than with each other?
It was all they had.
Sirius found himself in Scarlett.
Scarlett plunged into Sirius, claiming his heart as if it had never belonged to anyone else.
In return, Sirius stitched his soul to hers, using the thread that bound their tragic fates together.
Scarlett dug her nails into his muscular arms, the slow, dragging rhythm enough to make the tension starting to boil low in her belly build steadily, fed by the rough, cadenced moans spilling from Sirius’s lips, his deep voice vibrating against her mouth, his body trembling above hers.
The lust that tightened her muscles at the sight of him — so undone, so helpless in her grasp — awakened a fierce sense of possession. Sirius was as much hers as she was his, and her vision blurred at the sight of those eyes, the ones that could tear her apart or make her whole with terrifying ease.
Scarlett curled her toes and let a broken moan rasp from the back of her throat, the steady thrusts beginning to hurt with the overwhelming intensity.
She parted her lips to warn him she was close, but Sirius seized her mouth in a demanding, suffocating kiss, sealing a pact between them that would make them just as miserable as it would make them happy.
He thrust harder, rough grunts vibrating against Scarlett’s tongue as he felt the flood of pleasure breaking through him, sucking at her lower lip as he came.
The way Sirius twisted deep inside her pulled Scarlett into release effortlessly, her walls clamping tight around him, letting all the rigid tension built within her unravel in wave after wave of spasms, ragged moans and trembling limbs.
He stayed buried inside her, the kiss ending with a wet, shameless sound.
Sirius rested his head against Scarlett’s chest, lowering her legs, listening to the frantic drum of her heart, her breath whipping across his neck.
She hugged him close, the wild pulse melting every thought from her mind, their mingled sweat and the heat of their bodies binding them in a connection that felt stronger than the veil between life and death.
Scarlett traced the line of Sirius’s spine slowly with her fingertips, feeling his soft skin shiver under her touch. He gave a subtle smile, lifting his face to press a kiss to the corner of her lips before pulling out of her, pushing his trembling fingers back inside to keep his seed from spilling out.
The wicked side of Sirius loved seeing her filled with his cum.
"I’m amazed the lid of this piano’s holding us..." Scarlett murmured as Sirius lay back down over her.
"For the price I paid for it, it’d bloody well better last through eight generations before even thinking about cracking..." he snorted a laugh, closing his eyes as Scarlett raked her fingers gently through his hair.
She shielded her eyes with a hand against the bright chandelier above them, still wrapped in the intoxicating haze that came from shagging Sirius Black.
He soon reached for his wand and doused the lights, so the only glow came from the large windows around the piano, lit faintly by the streetlamps outside.
"Was it very expensive?" Scar asked, lowering her gaze to him.
"Uh-huh," he grunted, the sound rumbling through his chest. "Nearly cost as much as this house..."
"What?" Scarlett frowned, her fingers weaving through the strands of his black hair. "I knew it was expensive... but not that expensive..."
"I wanted to buy one just like — or close to — the one you had. And this is the top brand... It’s alright. My uncle left me enough," he added lazily.
"Sirius..." Scarlett called softly.
He rested his hand between her breasts, propping his chin on the back of it, peering up at her curiously, a few locks of hair falling into his face.
"I’m... I’m sorry for..." she faltered, chasing after the words scrambling to escape her mind. "...for being so absent these past weeks."
She ran her fingers along the tattooed bones of his hand, stopping at his rings, feeling the coolness of the metal against her skin.
"I didn’t even... notice... or realise what you were doing and—"
"Scar..."
"Let me finish," she whispered, wetting her lips, her face burning with the fresh tears gathering in her eyes. "I can’t even tell you how grateful I am... for everything you’ve done and are still doing and... I’m sorry if—"
"You don’t need to apologise to me, Scarlett," Sirius said, wiping her tears gently, a soft smile touching his lips. "We’re in this together. You’re not getting rid of me that easily," he added proudly, giving her a kiss before standing up, stretching as he let out a long, lazy yawn.
"Getting rid of you? Abandoning a dog on the street’s a crime," Scarlett teased, pushing up on her elbows to watch him.
Sirius snorted a laugh, flipping her off.
"Shut it," he said, digging around in his backpack, shoving his whole arm inside. "Do you want to go back, or...?"
Scarlett drummed her fingers on the wood, flicking her wand to light up the room.
Sirius rubbed at his eyes with a groan.
"Could we... could we sleep here?!" she asked, lowering her gaze to between her legs where the thick liquid was trickling down. She cleaned herself with a non-verbal spell and slid off the piano, using her T-shirt to wipe the sweat marks from the wood.
"We could... what are you doing?" Sirius raised an eyebrow as he pulled a large box from the backpack — a massive sleeping bag package.
"Cleaning my piano?!" she retorted, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
Sirius let out a bark of laughter. The sight of Scarlett, naked, scrubbing the piano lid with her T-shirt was... not exactly what he’d expected.
"Alright then..." he shrugged, pulling the sleeping bag out of the box. "You want to sleep here in the living room or... in the bedroom?"
"Either’s fine..." Scarlett watched as Sirius turned the sleeping bag around in every possible angle.
"What are you doing?" she asked.
"Trying to figure out how the hell this thing opens," he grumbled, tossing it onto the floor and blowing out a loud breath in frustration.
"Have you read the instructions?"
Sirius stared at her like she’d just suggested something utterly insane.
"Instructions? No one reads that rubbish!" he said, putting his hands on his hips and shaking his hair loose from its tie.
Scarlett sighed, quietly fascinated by how the light washed out Sirius’s skin even further, her gaze roaming over every inch of his naked body, even the scars on his leg, and she smiled genuinely at the thought that this man was hers.
"There must be a zip... or something to open it..." she suggested, pulling on her clothes under the heavy stare of her boyfriend. "You’ve never used the sleeping bag before?"
"No, it’s not even mine..." Sirius stood there, completely unbothered.
"No? Whose is it, then?"
"I think it’s Wormtail’s."
"Are you not going to get dressed?!" Scarlett asked with a half-embarrassed laugh.
"Why would I? I’m in my own house," he huffed arrogantly.
"The neighbours might see you starkers through the windows..." she said, sitting on the floor and running her hands along the sleeping bag, finally finding the very well-hidden zip.
"Their lucky day," Sirius grinned smugly, making Scarlett let out a disgusted noise. "What?"
"I wish I had your self-esteem, Sirius..." Scar said as she unzipped the bag and glanced up at him.
"You should. Half of Hogwarts fancied you," he said, gathering up his clothes and tugging on just his underwear.
"They didn’t fancy me, they fancied my Signet..."
Sirius grabbed the sleeping bag and took her hand, leading her into their bedroom.
"Of course not, the Signet’s just a bonus," he said, rolling his eyes. "But... Scar... if we ever had kids... um..." Sirius spread the sleeping bag out on the floor, trying — and failing — to hide the nerves flickering across his face. "They’d have one too, wouldn’t they?"
"They would," Scarlett said, crawling into the sleeping bag with a yawn. "That’s why... I don’t know, it’s a bit complicated, really..."
Sirius slipped in beside her, resting his cheek on his hand as he gazed at her, switching off the lights so the only glow came from the windows, flooding the room with moonlight.
"I know, I’m not even thinking about it properly now, it’s just that..." He wrapped an arm around her, pulling her close against his chest, his heart hammering beneath her ear. "...I'm just excited about our life together. Far away... away from everything."
Scarlett’s eyes gleamed with sadness.
She could almost touch the aching loneliness inside her as she breathed in deeply.
She’d felt so hollow for so long that even a fleeting glimpse of happiness was enough to make her cling to it desperately, hoping it might ease the crushing weight of grief on her chest.
Unfortunately, her great-great-grandfather Sebastian had been right.
"So am I," Scarlett murmured against his chest, feeling it rise and fall slowly beneath her. "Goodnight, Sirius."
"Goodnight, kitten."
.
.
.
Sirius buried his face into the sleeping bag when the sun rose, one arm flopping out lazily.
The summer heat was unbearable, and he woke up drenched in sweat, squirming and kicking until he realised Scarlett was no longer lying beside him.
"Scar?" he called out, his voice echoing drowsily around the empty room, hoarse and thick with sleep. The sunlight stabbed at his still-sleepy eyes.
He cleared his throat and scrambled up, his heart beating faster with rising worry.
Shielding his eyes with one hand, he stumbled down the corridor towards the other rooms, his vision still blurred with exhaustion.
"Scarlett?" he called again, a little louder this time.
Blinking furiously, he rubbed at his eyes with both palms, stopping only when he heard a soft splash from outside.
He followed the sound to the back door beside the laundry room, accessible through the living room. The fresh morning air hit his face as he opened it.
Bathed in the golden light of the sun, Scarlett was swimming in the pool, the water around her shimmering like liquid gold.
As she surfaced, Scarlett looked over at Sirius with a playful smile — completely naked.
Sirius let out a breathless laugh of sheer relief, his heart slowing as he drank in the sight of her so carefree and uninhibited.
Still chuckling to himself for having worried so much, he wandered over to the nearest lounger and collapsed onto it, unable to wipe the smile off his face.
"You never said there was a pool..." Scarlett said as she swam lazily, a smile playing on her lips.
"Ah, I was a bit busy... chasing my girlfriend..." Sirius rolled his eyes. "...and shagging her on top of the piano."
"On top of the piano? How shameless!" Scarlett gasped, pretending to be scandalised. "It was boiling and I didn’t want to wake you..."
"The house has air conditioning, you know?!" Sirius crossed his arms, his eyes roaming over her body with open lust.
"No!" Scarlett splashed water at him before diving under again.
"Now you know," Sirius teased as she resurfaced. "But the pool was on purpose. Didn’t you use to swim in the river every morning at Durmstrang?"
Scarlett nodded, squinting against the brightness.
"How do you know that? I never told you," she said, resting her chin on her hand as she leaned against the pool edge.
Sirius’s smile faltered, though he tried to keep it in place.
"Your dad told me... when he taught me how to ride the bike."
"I did swim, but only for the first two years... after that, it got too dangerous," Scarlett said, forcing her face to stay serene before she turned and began swimming again.
The sound of water lapping against the pool was the only thing between them.
Sirius let himself relax a little, setting aside all the stress he’d been carrying just to watch Scarlett spinning in the water with such grace and ease.
"Don’t you want to come in?" she asked after a long stretch of silence.
"No," Sirius said, standing up as his stomach gave a loud growl. "Can I invite Prongs over? He had no idea about the surprise either... it was Moony who helped me find the house, actually."
"Of course you can... and I do need to buy some clothes... bikinis..." Scarlett cleared her throat awkwardly.
"Want to go to the shopping centre today?"
"Yeah..." she said, forcing herself to sound enthusiastic. "Could you ask Lily and Pandora too? And Remus?"
"I can," Sirius nodded. "Want to take the chance to buy the furniture as well?"
Scarlett tapped her finger thoughtfully against her lower lip.
"I think so. Might as well take advantage of having James and Remus to help carry everything, right?"
"Who do you think helped haul the piano into the living room?" Sirius scratched the back of his neck. "Me, Remus, and Pandora."
"Pandora? How come?"
"Bought it from her uncle," he shrugged. "I’m heading inside — you shouldn’t stay out here too long, you know the neighbours can see you starkers from here." He added casually.
"What?" Scarlett spun around, alarmed, but all she could see beyond the ivy-covered wall were a few apple trees.
Sirius burst out laughing at her reaction.
"Oh, piss off, Sirius!" she shouted, splashing water at him, forcing him to dart back inside.
"Only joking!" Sirius sang as he headed for the living room, pulling the Two-Way Mirror from the pocket of his jeans.
"James," he said, and the pale face of his best mate rippled into view, James rubbing one eye and sighing heavily.
"Padfoot, where the fuck have you been?!" James muttered, looking absolutely pissed off.
"I need you to get Pandora, Evans, and Remus. Get everyone over to your house and use the Scarius Floo address. Can you do that?"
James just blinked lazily.
"What?" He wrinkled his nose and glanced to the side. "You get that, Wormtail?"
"I got it. You didn’t?"
"Wormtail’s back from France?" Sirius frowned.
"Got back as soon as I could!" Peter shoved his face into the mirror’s reflection, throwing an arm around James’s shoulders. "What’s with the address?"
"You’ll see!" Sirius grinned mischievously. "And bring food! I’m starving."
"Capisce," Peter said, disappearing from view, while James remained completely deadpan.
"What’s the matter?" Sirius didn’t bother hiding the irritation on his face. "Did I do something?"
"It’s not what you did — it’s that you didn’t tell me you were just going to disappear with Scarlett in the middle of the night!" James said, wearing a sour smile.
Sirius licked his lips, raising his brows, the silver of his eyes flickering between stiffness and an attempt at patience.
"I’m sorry, alright? She had a nightmare, asked me to take her out and—"
"That’s not the bloody point, Sirius!" James cut him off. "I was scared out of my mind, wondering what the hell could’ve happened!"
"We’re fine!" Sirius tried to justify, tension stiffening his shoulders. "I don’t get it, James—"
"You’re not fine. And you barely even talk to me!" James snapped, clearing his throat roughly. "And now you’re just... what, moving somewhere else without saying a word?!"
Sirius opened his mouth, scrambling for something to say — but the truth was, he had no bloody clue what to say.
As much as he hated to admit it, James was right. There was too much weighing on him right now, and he hadn’t wanted to add his best mate onto that list.
"I wanted... I wanted it to be a surprise," Sirius mumbled, his face burning with shame. "I’m... I’m sorry, James, I thought..."
"Wow. Congratulations, Sirius." James clapped his hands sarcastically. "Is that what you wanted to hear?"
"Why are you acting like this?"
"Because I’m still here too, Sirius! For both of you! But all you’ve done these past days is push me away. For fuck’s sake, I lost them too!" James’s voice cracked halfway through, and he clenched his jaw, breathing deeper to steady himself. "And all my best mate’s done these past days is piss off out of the house doing Merlin knows what, and when he bothered to come back, he just hid away in bed with his girlfriend. You went, like, three bloody days without even looking me in the face!"
Sirius ground his teeth, forcing down the wave of desperation threatening to crash into his chest, a vein bulging at his neck from the tension in his jaw.
"I don’t have the time or the fucking headspace for your tantrum right now, James," Sirius hissed, narrowing his eyes at his friend. "I love you, you’re my best mate, but..." The hand holding the mirror trembled slightly, and he took a deep breath. "I’m dealing with too much right now."
"Why... why did I even think you’d care?!" James whispered, wiping away a rogue tear that slipped from behind his glasses.
"Because I do care!" Sirius gasped, blinking rapidly, trying to keep himself from crying too. "Just get over here, please..."
James pulled off his glasses and scrubbed at his face roughly, exhaling long and hard as though trying to wrestle his emotions back under control.
"Fine," he muttered reluctantly. "Whatever..."
Sirius watched, hurt and stunned, as the image of his friend blurred and vanished.
He took a very deep breath, tilting his head back to stare at the ceiling of his own house, his mind a roaring storm of everything weighing him down, the air slicing painfully at his lungs.
He forced himself to smile when Scarlett came back inside, wearing his T-shirt and dripping water all over the wooden floor.
"I spoke to James, they’re on their way..." Sirius said, pretending to be busy stuffing the mirror shard back into his jeans pocket. "Are you hungry?"
"Starving," Scarlett smiled, drying herself with a flick of her wand. "Are you alright?"
Sirius had never once felt grateful to his parents for anything. In that moment, though, he silently thanked them for the years spent learning to control his face — because when he pulled on his smiling mask and nodded, the silver in his eyes was already darkened by all the worries gnawing at him.
"Everything’s great," he said smoothly, his voice light and easy.
Maybe that was why Scarlett simply made a sound of agreement and kissed him on the cheek before spinning on her heel.
"I’m going to have a shower."
"Alright," Sirius said, leaning heavily against the piano, his hands gripping the lid tight.
As soon as Scarlett disappeared into the bedroom, the air rushed from his lungs all at once and he covered his face with both hands, wrestling to steady his breathing, fighting the crushing pressure trying to choke him.
"Everything’s great," he repeated to himself, cracking his neck before starting to get dressed.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 9: That's how easy love can be
Summary:
“You don’t have to carry it all alone… not anymore.”
Chapter Text
LXXVII
The shopping centre was just a few minutes’ walk from the new house Sirius had bought. The sun, however, showed them no mercy. As soon as they reached the shaded, air-conditioned space, he leaned against a pillar and wiped the sweat from his forehead with the back of his hand, listening to James and Peter grumble while Remus, Scarlett, Pandora, and Lily claimed the bench nearby.
"We could take the car next time..." Sirius sighed, resting his head against the cold marble of the column. "I think I’ve scorched my bloody face..."
"You said the shopping centre was five bloody minutes away!" James complained, wiping his glasses on the hem of his T-shirt. "But I counted ten."
"Oh, Prongs... for Merlin’s sake..." Remus sighed, all awkward on the wooden bench. "Five or ten, what difference does it make?"
"The difference is my bloody bollocks are sweating, Moony." James pointed out, running a hand through his damp hair, so irate he barely filtered his words.
"James, no one wants to hear about your bollocks!" Scarlett took a deep breath and crossed her arms, feeling a bit self-conscious about the clothes she was wearing.
It was one of Sirius’s T-shirts with a motorbike printed on it—long enough to pass for a dress. And that earned her puzzled glances from passers-by, as if she were some sort of pauper.
"Never thought I’d go to a shopping centre and hear Potter go on about his bollocks..." Pandora remarked casually. "So, while the boys go look at furniture, why don’t we pop into the clothes shops?" She looked over at Scarlett and Lily.
"Brilliant idea!" Lily stood up with a faint smile. "Shall we?"
Sirius turned his face towards Scarlett, as if he knew she was staring at him, silently asking for permission. There was hesitation in the blue of her eyes, and a hint of nerves too.
"You gonna be alright?" he asked, walking up to her and holding out her hand.
Sirius pulled her up and immediately wrapped her in a hug, ignoring the sweat that clung to their skin.
"I think so," Scar murmured against his T-shirt. "What are you lot going to do?"
They parted, and Sirius shoved his hands into the pockets of his chain-hung jeans, his gaze sweeping across the shops before returning to her.
"We can start looking at furniture..." he suggested with a shrug.
"Any idea about colours?" Remus stood too, tracing the scars on his face with his forefinger.
"I want a black sofa," Scarlett requested, taking a few steps back. "Leather."
"Yes, ma’am." Sirius gave her a soft smile. "Anything else?"
Scarlett shrugged and followed Pandora and Lily past the shop windows, disappearing into the crowd. Peter slung an arm around Sirius and James with a pleased grin.
"So... Marauders on a shopping spree?" he tried to lift the mood.
Only Remus seemed to share the sentiment, as James turned his face away and Sirius merely nodded in agreement.
"Do you lot think I should buy a telly?" Sirius asked after a long stretch of silence.
"Why wouldn’t you?" Peter seemed to be trying to lighten the mood with his usual grins... to no avail.
"Dunno... if Scar’s even going to want one, after what happened," Sirius explained, pausing in front of a shop window.
"Should’ve asked her that before she left," James muttered, clicking his tongue. "Too late now."
Sirius pressed his lips into a thin, rigid line as the silver in his eyes turned into twin sharp blades.
"Whatever..." he murmured, walking on.
It was a bit difficult to keep his composure with James acting like that. And it was impossible not to feel unsettled by the fact that his best mate refused to even look at him, let alone react to his sarcastic remarks as they wandered through the shops, checking prices. Remus and Peter had picked up on the weird tension since the moment James refused to greet him when they arrived at the new house.
They had never had a proper row in all their years of friendship—sure, Sirius could be explosive at times (well, many times), but James always made an effort to understand him, especially since they could usually communicate with a single glance. But how was that supposed to work if James was deliberately ignoring him?
Of course Sirius understood his mate’s pain. James was right, but Sirius couldn’t bring himself to open up just then—because if he did, he’d fall apart, and what happened in front of Malfoy had already been humiliating enough. He didn’t want to be the weak link again, not when things were finally going well. It was the first day Scarlett hadn’t cried—not in front of him, at least. And that alone was enough for Sirius to bury it all back inside and fake a smile as they stepped into the furniture shop.
He didn’t really have a clue what he was looking for, to be honest. Thank Merlin Wormtail took the reins, starting with the bedroom furniture and moving on to the kitchen. Remus had the best sense of what matched with what, so he was put in charge of choosing the furniture style.
James didn’t drop the scowl from his face once—not even when Remus told Sirius to stand at the end of the bed to check if it came up to his waist, just to make sure it would allow for… ease of movement during any hip action with Scarlett.
"The bed’s got to be special..." Remus carried on, leaning his elbows on the wooden frame. "... it’s where you two are going to make little Sirius Junior!"
"For Merlin’s sake, Moony..." Peter pulled a disgusted face. "We get the idea."
"Why don’t you just conjure the bloody furniture? Do you really need to waste the money your uncle left you on all this crap?!" James let out a noise of disgust. "You’re clearly only buying all this shit to give us something to do!"
"I’m not forcing anyone to stay. If you want to leave, then piss off." Sirius snapped like a whip, killing the smiles on Remus and Peter’s faces.
"What the fuck is wrong with you two?!" Remus lowered his voice, as if worried someone might overhear their argument.
"I don’t know. What’s wrong, Sirius?!" James elbowed him. Sirius flinched and took a step back.
"Don’t touch me, James!" Sirius warned, his jaw tight. "There’s nothing going on between us—he just wants attention..."
"I just want attention?!" James laughed, full of scorn. "Have you looked in the fucking mirror lately, Sirius?!"
"I don’t have time for that..." Sirius muttered, weaving between Peter and Remus to get away.
"Yeah, go on, do what you’ve always done best!" James snapped, not even moving.
Sirius stopped as if someone had electrocuted him. He glanced sideways at James, his face stone-cold, nostrils flared, brows knitted. His emotions boiled in his chest, searing. He clenched his fists as hard as he could, the knuckles going white.
"Fuck you, Potter!" His voice rang out, distorted, like it wasn’t even his—just pure rage. "Get out!"
His mask probably cracked at that moment, because James’s reaction was to widen his eyes and let his mouth fall slightly open, his smugness melting into shame. But he said nothing, so Sirius stormed off, breathing hard and uneven.
Sirius straightened up and expertly regained control over his expression, distancing himself once more from the emotions that haunted him. He faked a charming smile for the shop assistant as he picked out furniture here and there according to Peter and Remus’s suggestions, while James wandered among the home décor, looking a bit lost.
"If you take all the furniture together, I can offer you a brilliant discount..." the woman said, a bit too forward for Sirius’s taste, but he merely raised an eyebrow, encouraging her to go on. "But we don’t have a black leather sofa in stock. We’ve got other dark colours... brown and grey..."
"No black?" Sirius didn’t bother to hide the disdain in his voice. "I... need the sofa to be black."
"I’m sorry, Mr Black, but..." the woman looked flustered, "...they’re all sold out and we won’t have more until next month..."
"Is there another shop in here that sells a black leather sofa?!" Sirius barked.
"Yes, Mr Black, but if you take all the furniture from here I can offer you a fantastic price..."
"I don’t want a fantastic price, I want a fucking black sofa!" Sirius shouted, his heart thundering in his chest.
"Oi!" James interrupted the argument. "Stop yelling at the woman, Sirius. You’re going to get yourself chucked out of the shopping centre."
"Excuse me a moment..." Sirius growled through gritted teeth, turning to James with a pointed finger. "I just need a black sofa, James. If you can’t help, then stop bloody getting in the way!"
The indignation in his best mate seemed to have cooled, because James simply deflated, frowning and folding his arms.
"Why does it have to be black? You’re going to pay way more for such a stupid detail. You can change the colour later..."
"It has to be black," Sirius cut in firmly. "You don’t get it, James..."
"Why?" James clearly didn’t care much about the subject, which only wound Sirius up further.
He hissed, running a hand through his black hair in hesitation.
"Because... it’s what Scarlett wants," he replied, as if it were obvious.
But James had known him far too long not to see what was buried behind that unusual stubbornness.
"Seriously, what’s going on? Why does the décor need to be perfect?"
Sirius rolled his eyes, rubbing them harder than necessary as he tried to organise his thoughts.
"Because... Scarlett..." he drew in a deep breath, trying to buy time to figure out what to say. "She... she wants this sofa and... it has to be perfect, alright? It has to... has to be... enough." He stumbled over the words, all the confidence he'd been faking cracking under his friend’s persistence.
"Enough?" James stepped closer, giving him that look Sirius fucking hated.
A lump formed in his throat.
"Yes!" he looked away for just a second. "I need... I need to be enough for her!" His eyes widened, his voice soaked in frustration. It didn’t take much more for his pieces to begin falling, one by one, like James had dissolved whatever was holding them together. "You’re right, James. You always were. I’m a piece of shit, a selfish bastard... I stopped her from running into the fire, from joining her family. And... and... and I... I..." He gasped, placing both hands on his head with a pained smile. "I’ve hurt her so much, James, and I... I don’t want to... I need to deserve her after everything I’ve done... it’s like... like someone carved a hole in her heart and... and nothing I do..."
The words tumbled out, one after the other, soaked in anguish and guilt.
His shoulders shook as he brought his hands to his face, trying to stop the tears from falling. But it was too much—everything was too much—it was eating him alive, and before he realised, he was choking, his mouth dry, oxygen refusing to reach his brain.
His vision blurred, his chest tightened; Sirius placed a hand to his throat, as if that might somehow force it to open wider, his breath coming in short, ragged bursts. He didn’t fully understand what was happening—just that he felt like he was crumbling, like a statue of sand being struck by a violent wave.
Sirius filled his lungs with as much air as he could.
"How... how... can I... make her happy?" he sobbed, against the collar of James’s T-shirt. "She’s lost everything and... and I... I’ve hurt her so many times... I don’t want to hurt her again, I don’t want her to regret... being saved. I... I’m scared, James, so fucking scared..."
The words spilled out against his will. His blood pounded in his ears—chaotic, muddled—as he struggled to breathe, to pull himself back together from the sharp shards that remained. James was speaking to him, but Sirius didn’t even hear—too focused on silencing the panic hammering in his chest and smoothing over the rough edge that twisted inside his heart.
"I’m scared," Sirius whispered, sniffling, once he managed to wrestle the chaos under control. James pulled him tighter against his chest, as if to affirm he was there without needing to say a word.
Sirius drew in a breath, letting it settle slowly into his lungs, accidentally catching the hazel eyes of his friend. It was hard not to punch him in the face with all the pity lines softening his pupils, but then James softened—as he always did—and hugged Sirius even harder, lifting him slightly in the furniture shop as he let out a long, exaggerated groan.
"Can’t believe you’re crying over a girl, Padfoot," James chuckled into his ear, and all the tension Sirius had built inside shattered into a fit of uncontrolled laughter, echoing with everything he’d buried deep in his heart.
"She’s not just any girl, Prongs. She’s the girl," he confided to his friend, voice thick.
"You don’t have to be afraid. You’re not alone in this, Pads." James ran a hand over his face, wiping away the moisture from his tears. Sirius closed his eyes, letting his friend do all the work.
"I know," he admitted softly, almost to himself.
"Then stop pushing us away! Stop pushing me away!" James gripped his jaw, and Sirius slowly opened his eyes, blinking until the blurred vision sharpened on the face of his best mate, letting himself be held in those determined eyes.
"Can you forgive me, Prongs?" Sirius swallowed hard, his lower lip trembling.
"’Course I can. I’ll always forgive you, Padfoot." He pressed a kiss to Sirius’s forehead before hugging him again. "You bloody idiot."
"Sorry... I promise I’ll buy you a massive slice of cherry pie," Sirius said, unable to stop the faint smile that crossed his lips.
"A slice?" James gave him two firm pats on the shoulder—harder than necessary. "I deserve the whole bloody pie, Sirius Black," he declared, half-threatening.
"The whole pie it is, Mr Prongs," Sirius nodded, ruffling James’s hair even more.
.
.
.
Scarlett let out all the air in her lungs as she stared at the massive pile of clothes Lily and Pandora had set aside for her to try on. She closed her eyes and picked up a set, facing her reflection in the fitting room mirror.
Her appearance was far better than it had been on the previous days, and yet, there was still a trace of ruin on her face. She pressed her index fingers to the corners of her lips and curled them upwards, trying to hold the smile after letting go.
"Ready, Scar?" Pandora’s voice from the other side snapped her out of her trance.
"Almost..." Scarlett quickly changed into a pair of black jeans and a long-sleeved, off-the-shoulder top. Despite the heat outside, the shop’s air conditioning was strong enough to keep her from sweating to death.
She pulled the curtain aside, instantly scrutinised by Lily and Pandora.
"You look like Janis Joplin," Lily remarked, a few hangers in hand.
"Right?! Doesn’t she?" Pandora beamed. "You and Sirius walk around like you’re a pair of rock stars!"
Scarlett shook her head and laughed at the comparisons, her cheeks burning with embarrassment. But suddenly, the smile vanished, giving way to a serious, introspective expression.
"What is it, Scar?" Pandora immediately caught the shift.
"Nothing, it’s stupid..."
"Spit it out!" Pandora pressed, adding more clothes to the ever-growing pile Scarlett still had to try on.
"It’s just..." Scarlett took a deep breath, glancing around before meeting their eyes. "This... guilt... for feeling happy..." she confessed. "My parents and my brother are dead and here I am, picking out clothes and... laughing."
Her gaze slipped to the floor, though all she could really focus on were the words she’d just spoken. Her parents and Orfy were dead. No tears came, even if her heart bled at the thought.
"Scar..." Lily’s hand landed on her shoulder, and Scarlett found herself staring at her perfectly painted red and gold nails. "You don’t need to feel guilty. They’d want you to be happy. Your life goes on and... the people we love never really leave us. They stay right here." She touched her chest. Scarlett might’ve found that a bit odd in other circumstances, but all she could do was fall into the trap of those pale green eyes, untouched by even a trace of brown.
She nodded with a nostalgic smile.
"I suppose so..." she whispered, her heart thudding painfully against her ribs.
Pandora pretended to pick out a few more clothes, and Lily busied herself organising the discarded pieces.
"Can’t believe you’re dating and about to move in with Sirius! Who would’ve thought, eh?" Pan tried to lighten the mood, running a hand through her platinum hair.
"I never imagined the ever-so-womaniser Sirius Black would fall that hard for someone. It’s shocking," Lily added. "He’s a heartbreaker, you know?!"
Scarlett allowed herself to drift into the conversation, grabbing more clothes before shutting herself back into the fitting room.
"I know—I thought he’d break mine too..." she admitted as she undressed. "But it turns out... I don’t know... we’re really similar."
"It’s bloody delicious watching Sirius Black worship the ground you walk on..." Lily turned to look at her just as she pulled the curtain open.
"After being a complete arsehole, it’s the least he could do." Pan gave an approving smile at the outfit.
"What do you mean?"
"What, you didn’t hear about it?"
"Oh, Malfoy, I skip most Hogwarts gossip..." Lily shrugged.
"Sirius has issues with jealousy. And with his brother," Scarlett explained as she grabbed more pieces. "But that’s been sorted. And Regulus and I aren’t friends anymore."
Pandora scoffed, sitting on the armchair and crossing her legs.
"Still haven’t sorted things out?!"
"There’s nothing to sort out!" Scarlett called from the fitting room.
"What did he do?" Lily sounded intrigued.
Scarlett fell silent for a while.
"He hit me by accident with a non-verbal spell... but that’s not all... he, uh, tried to stir shit between me and Sirius after Slytherin won the Quidditch final..." She pulled the curtain open again, now wearing a fitted The Runaways T-shirt and a pair of frayed denim shorts. "And to top it all off, Sirius wants to invite him to live with us!"
Pandora grimaced.
"And what did you say?" Lily’s lips twisted at the revelation.
"That it was fine... what was I supposed to say?!" Scarlett replied sharply.
"The truth, Scarlett. You should’ve told him the truth," Pandora said with a chastising tone.
"I think Sirius will only invite him once he comes of age... and Regulus turned sixteen this year, so not until next year..."
They sorted the clothes into three piles and carried them over to the till. The shop assistant looked genuinely surprised by the amount of outfits, but Scarlett was too busy having a pleasant chat about Edgar Bones with Lily to care.
Sirius, James, Remus and Peter arrived just in time to see them paying, all four of them staring at the mountain of bags.
"Bloody hell, did you buy the whole shop?!" James joked, stunned.
"Less talking, more carrying, Potter." Lily gestured for him to start picking up bags, and he obeyed without hesitation, wearing a daft expression on his face.
Meanwhile, Sirius pulled out a wad of cash from his pocket and paid for everything without batting an eye at the cost. Remus and Peter also helped carry the lot, leaving the last few bags for Sirius.
"I lost my entire bloody wardrobe, James!" Scarlett huffed, crossing her arms in frustration.
"You’re not even going to wear half of this stuff..." he pushed his glasses up with his wrist. "You don’t even have a wardrobe yet!"
Scarlett flipped him off as they made their way to the next stop. To the surprise of the boys, it was a lingerie shop—with some rather suggestive pieces on display.
"You’re going in there?" Sirius looked at her, half in disbelief.
She only flashed a mischievous grin as she disappeared inside with Pandora and Lily. Sirius gave an awkward smile, exchanging glances with the others, who simply dropped the bags on the floor and leaned against the window display.
"That girl’s going to be the death of me," he muttered, a blush creeping up his cheeks.
"Is Pads blushing?" Remus grabbed his chin. "Think they’ve got a cute little pink collar in there for you?"
"And puppy ears?" Peter chimed in.
"And plushy paws?!" James waved his hands like they were dog paws.
"There’s nothing like that in there!" Sirius snorted, laughing.
"Think she’ll buy one of those?" Peter pointed to a lacy red bodysuit with cut-outs over the nipples and crotch.
"If I die lying down... you’ll know the reason why." Sirius crossed his arms over his chest, playing dead.
"Bloody hell, dying mid-shag..." James grumbled, nudging Sirius.
"Why not? It’s a happy way to go..." Remus reasoned.
"Happy? Without finishing? And stark naked?!"
"Oh, come on, Prongs, no one’s going to care about that tiny little todger..." Sirius feigned winding up a slap to his mate’s bollocks, making James flinch.
"Not tiny, ‘cause it’ll be hard!" James stuck out his tongue.
"If someone dies with a stiffy... how long does it stay stiff?" Peter tapped his chin, thinking.
"Well, considering an erection’s just blood in your glorious bit... it should last a decent while," Remus brushed his fringe from his face.
"How long, Moony? I want exact numbers!" James gestured dramatically.
"I dunno, I’m not a Healer," Remus shrugged.
After a while, Scarlett waved at Sirius from inside the shop, signalling that it was time to pay. He looked at his mates, then took a deep breath and walked over to his girlfriend, clearly uncomfortable. His embarrassment only grew as he took in the lingerie on display. Sirius Black had shagged his fair share of girls in his life, but none of them had worn anything half as daring as what he was seeing in that place—and the thought of Scarlett in any of it made him instantly hard.
He cleared his throat, adjusting his trousers to hide his erection.
"What’s the matter?" Scarlett noticed his awkwardness, eyeing him from head to toe.
"None," Sirius replied, trying to keep his composure, though a nervous laugh slipped out as he became the centre of attention—not just from his girlfriend but from her friends as well.
After paying for the purchases, Sirius found himself carrying oddly fragrant pink bags. The moment he stepped out of the shop, a blinding flash hit him.
"Capturing the moment Padfoot bought lacy knickers for himself..." Peter teased, shaking the Polaroid as the image developed.
The whole group burst into laughter, particularly at Sirius’s very obvious discomfort.
"You lot are the worst friends in the world!" he declared, snatching the bags off the floor. "Any other shop, love?" he asked Scarlett, still looking mortified.
She let out a cheeky giggle that made his skin tingle.
"Shoes... makeup... and I think that’s it."
Sirius made no effort to hide how completely fed up he was with the whole ordeal. By the end of the day, the group finally left the shopping centre, the boys with arms overloaded with bags while the girls walked ahead eating ice cream.
"I’ll never forget the look on dear Padfoot’s face in the lingerie shop. Priceless. Thank Merlin Wormtail took a photo!" James said, laughing.
"I was merely admiring the art on the mannequins, Mr Prongs!" Sirius pretended to be offended, furrowing his brow.
"Art on the mannequins..." Peter echoed like a catchphrase.
"Relax, Sirius, you’ll get used to it. Maybe you’ll even prefer the art on a person rather than a mannequin," Scar said it with such filthy teasing that Sirius had to take a deep breath not to wipe that smug little smirk off her face by yanking her hair.
"Speaking of which, Scar, are you giving Sirius a private art lesson later?" Pandora asked with such casual innocence that Remus let out a barking laugh, James’s eyes nearly popped out of his head, Peter arched a brow, and Lily slapped a hand over her mouth.
"Pandora!" Scarlett scolded, blushing furiously.
Sirius grinned at the outrageous comment—and at his girlfriend’s adorable reaction.
"I’m always open to learning," he said with a wink, biting his lower lip.
"Spare us the details, you two!" James groaned with exaggerated disgust.
"In my defence... it was Pan who started it!" Sirius shrugged off the accusation as they reached a crossing.
"Changing the subject—I'm genuinely impressed by how many bags we’ve managed to accumulate," Remus said, rolling his shoulders and stretching. "Feels like we’re opening a shop, not moving into a house."
"Honestly, I don’t know what I’d do without you lot. Thanks, really," Scarlett said, glancing sideways at them as she licked her ice cream in a way that made Sirius tap his foot impatiently.
"Padfoot would’ve carried all three hundred bags on his own..." James nudged his glasses up with his shoulder.
"Then we shouldn’t have come... I’d have loved to see Sirius hauling all this with those incredibly muscular Beater arms of his..." Peter smirked teasingly.
"It’s sweet, seeing you two building something together." Lily was the first to cross the street when the pedestrian light turned green. "Almost a bit inspiring..."
"Ugh." Sirius pulled a face, as did Pandora and Peter. "Who even invited Evans to this outing?"
"You did!" James pointed a finger at him.
"Was it Sirius? I thought it was you, Potter." Lily pouted. "If I’d known it was Sirius, I wouldn’t have come..."
"So you only said yes because it was me asking?" There was irony in James’s voice. A bit of hope too.
"Maybe." Lily shot him a teasing smile before continuing on, and James looked like he’d been hit by a Stunning Spell, frozen on the pavement until Sirius smacked him round the head.
"Close your mouth, mate, or you’ll swallow a mosquito..." he mocked.
"Suck my bollocks, Padfoot!" James feigned laughter at the jab.
"Your sweaty bollocks? Nah, I’m good."
When they got back to the house, Sirius dropped the bags to the floor and unlocked the door. The vibe between them was so light and easy that he barely noticed the presence in the sitting room at first. For a moment, Sirius straightened and reached for his wand—but relaxed as soon as he saw it was Thanatos.
"I need to speak to you two," he said, eyes on Scarlett and Sirius. "Now."
All the laughter snapped tight, then shattered under the weight of Scarlett’s uncle’s words. The boys exchanged glances and set the bags aside. Scarlett took Sirius’s hand and gestured for Thanatos to follow them to the bedroom.
Sirius raised a brow, uncertain, as he shut the door behind them. Thanatos paced through the room, glancing out at the pool through the window before turning to them with a stern expression.
"Have you both lost your minds? Going out like that, without telling anyone, not saying where you were going?!" His voice, though laced with concern, was clearly tinged with anger.
Scarlett clenched her fists, not hiding how annoyed she was at his unexpected approach.
"I don’t live with you, Uncle. I don’t owe you any explanations!" she snapped, firm and unwavering, feeling Sirius’s hands rest gently on her shoulders—his silent support warm and grounding behind her.
"Scarlett... after your parents died, you became a potential target!" he raised his voice. "It’s dangerous to go out without protection."
"I don’t need a bloody babysitter!" she shouted back, her voice breaking into tears. Sirius immediately wrapped his arms around her from behind, as though trying to hold her together.
"Scarlett... a preliminary report from the investigation has come out," Thanatos continued, unaffected by her reaction. "It seems the fire was caused by Orfy’s accidental magic."
Scarlett gasped like she’d just been slapped across the face.
"What?" she trembled, narrowing her eyes at her uncle. "No! That doesn’t make sense! I saw him, Uncle—he was alive, and… it was fiendfyre… and he is... was just a kid, he didn’t know any curses, he couldn’t..." She spoke so fast the words tangled, her sobs disrupting the flow. "It can’t be true..."
"It’s not definitive yet, Scar..." he said gently, stepping closer. "But it’s the direction the investigation is leaning and—"
"NO!" Scarlett screamed, silencing him. "It wasn’t him! It can’t have been him, it doesn’t make sense!"
"Based on your statement and Sirius’s, there were no signs of anyone else entering your home..."
"How not?!" Sirius cut in, his self-control slipping with frightening ease. "There was clearly a spell cast to make us sleep so deeply—I felt it, it was in my report!"
"It’s something very intangible—"
"They did a magical exam on me and confirmed it!" Sirius interrupted again, gripping Scarlett tighter in anger without realising it. "You were there!"
"I can’t interfere with the investigation..." Thanatos lowered his voice, running his hands over his face.
Scarlett tore herself away from Sirius violently, bolting from the room and slamming the door with a deafening bang. Thanatos stared at the spot where she’d vanished for a long moment, lost in thought.
"You had to ruin this day, didn’t you?!" Sirius growled, leaning back against the wall. "Bloody hell, Nate."
"Ruin it? I was worried about you! She can’t go out like that. And you haven’t even put protection spells on this house yet!"
"I haven’t had time, Gaunt!" Sirius shot back, his glare blistering.
"Then make time, because my brother, his wife, and their son died for far less!" Thanatos snapped, nostrils flaring, his voice cutting and merciless.
Sirius let out a dismissive laugh, drumming his fingers against the wall as he stared up at the ceiling light.
"When you said you were shit at this, I didn’t think you meant this shit. You’re not just fucked in the head, Nate. You’re a proper tosser." His gaze bore straight through him.
"Scarlett losing her parents doesn’t exempt her from being told off, Sirius—especially when she’s being so bloody irresponsible, acting like we’re not in the middle of a fucking war!" Thanatos cracked his neck, breath sharp and fast.
"For Merlin’s sake, Thanatos, can’t you see past your own bloody nose?!" Sirius shot back, holding himself back from decking that smug face. "Do you think she should just stay locked in her room all day crying over her family?!"
"I want her safe!" Thanatos ran a hand through his blond hair, utterly exasperated. "You promised to keep her safe, but all you’ve done so far is put her in danger!"
"Oh, go fuck yourself, Thanatos!" Sirius spat, raising both middle fingers at him. "Do you have any idea how long it took her to smile the way she smiled today? No, because you’re a bloody failure who’s done nothing but drown yourself in fags and booze while I— I —was there for her, doing everything I could to help her feel better!" He pounded his own chest with a fist, barely holding back the urge to swing.
"You’re her boyfriend—that’s the bare minimum you should be doing!" Thanatos remained still, chin raised. "Unless this is a complaint. Unless she’s too much for you. If that’s the case, she can live with me, no problem. It’d be safer anyway..."
That was the final straw.
Sirius lunged, just as Thanatos whipped out his wand from its holster and pressed it to Sirius’s throat. In a flash, Sirius froze—his fists clenched, neck muscles taut, veins bulging at his temple.
"Scarlett will never be a burden to me," Sirius growled. "Never."
Thanatos turned his head to the side. The arrogance melted away as he gave a bitter, twisted smile, his wand trembling loosely between his fingers. He stepped back with a slow, deliberate grace, tucking it away as his gaze drifted into the void.
"Her mother’s family... the Sallows... they’re cursed, Sirius," Thanatos murmured, lifting his eyes slowly to meet his. "You’ll never live in peace because of the Signet. And if you have children..."
"Get out of my house." Sirius pointed to the door, squaring his shoulders and dragging in as much air as his lungs could hold. "GET OUT OF MY HOUSE!" he roared, his throat burning, not giving a damn if the others heard the shouting. His eyes bulged, wild and furious, his face flushed, lips curled with rage. "NOW, GAUNT!"
He stepped forward as if to lunge again, but Thanatos Disapparated before he could be touched.
Hyperventilating, Sirius stared at the pale glimmer of the waning day reflected in the pool’s surface. Then, slowly, he turned and walked to the bedroom door, opening it.
He stood frozen in the doorway for a moment, watching the sunlight spill across the wooden floorboards in slanted golden lines. He took a deep breath, inhaling the faint, unfamiliar scent of the new house, exhaling as if to blow the chaos out of his mind.
He made his way to the sitting room, where Peter, Lily, Pandora, and Remus had been chatting about lighter things. The conversation dissolved the instant they saw him.
Sirius cleared his throat.
"Where is she?"
"Out back with Prongs..." Peter answered, gesturing toward the poolside.
"Right... can you lot help me with the protection spells around the house?" Sirius asked, holding himself together behind a mask of calm.
"Of course we can," Lily said at once, pulling out her wand.
"I can’t, I’m still underage..." Pandora said quietly, pressing her lips together.
"You know that rucksack James brought?" Sirius looked at her. "It’s bottomless and still has food in it—can you take it out to the pool area?"
"Alright." She headed to the kitchen as the others followed Sirius.
.
.
.
Scarlett sat on the edge of the pool, dipping her feet into the cool water. Under other circumstances, she might have relished the contrast between the warm summer air and the refreshing pool. But no smile softened her features. There was a bitter taste lingering in her mouth.
She heard heavy footsteps behind her. James sat beside her without a word, lowering his legs into the water and nudging her foot with his. Then, he took her hand. Scarlett wiped her tears away with the back of the other. They stayed like that, silent, the muffled echoes of the argument between Sirius and Thanatos lingering in the background.
"I’m sorry, Scar," James murmured after a while, his fingers tracing gentle circles on her knuckles.
Scarlett turned slightly to glance at him out of the corner of her eye. The setting sun cast gold across his cheeks, his nose, and the rims of his glasses, reflecting off the clear lenses. She lifted her gaze to the sky, where a corridor of grey-tinged clouds was brushed by dusk, framing the moon already glowing against the violet canvas of night.
"You heard the argument?" she asked, still looking up.
"Er, kind of impossible not to… with all the yelling," he admitted with a sheepish smile. "But you do know we’re here for you, right? For both of you. No matter what happens."
In response, Scarlett squeezed his hand.
"It’s just… so… hard," she confessed, sniffling. "When we’re having fun, smiling... it feels so good, because I haven’t felt that since it all happened… but then… suddenly, I feel alone. Like… like there’s a wall between us. Like I’m cut off from the world, from all of you, like happiness is being ripped from my chest… close enough to see it, but... just far enough that I can’t reach it... does that make any sense?"
"Of course it does. I don’t even know... how I’d handle it if I were in your place..." James let go of her hand just to wrap his arm around her. Scarlett rested her head on his shoulder. "I know it’s hard, but you don’t have to go through it alone." He buried his face gently in her hair.
Pandora soon appeared, carrying James’s rucksack, slowly pulling food out from inside. Ham and cheese sandwiches cut into triangles; leafy green salads with cherry tomatoes and croutons; breaded fish bites with lemon sauce.
Scarlett couldn’t help the small smile that escaped her when she realised it had all been prepared by Euphemia. She gently pulled away from James and stood, spotting Sirius and Peter approaching from one side of the fence, Lily and Remus from the other. They were chanting protective and concealment spells to make the house unplottable.
Once they finished, everyone sat down to eat. Pandora also pulled a few bottles of alcohol from the bag, and Scarlett let the argument drift away as the sting of blackcurrant rum burned down her throat.
"I think we all need to talk," Remus said, stepping in front of Scarlett and Sirius, hands on his hips.
"I don’t want to talk about what happened..." Sirius muttered, wiping sauce from his beard with his thumb.
"No! You two are going to listen to what I have to say." He snapped back with authority, pushing Sirius back into his chair when he made to get up. "It’s obvious… to everyone here…" His eyes swept over each of their friends. "…how much you’re both suffering. And how much you’ve shut down because of it. But… when we’re suffering, it means we’re carrying more than we can bear."
"Ironic, coming from you," Sirius muttered bitterly.
"Shut up, Padfoot!" Remus scolded. "You don’t have to handle everything on your own! That’s why we’re here—to share the burden, so you don’t have to suffer alone! Seeing you both like this hurts… because you wrap yourselves in this impenetrable shell and it’s impossible to help you like that!"
"You’re such a hypocrite!" Sirius jabbed a finger at him.
"I might be, Sirius, but I still care about you." Remus pinched his friend’s nose, and Sirius pulled a face in response. "So when you feel like you’re suffering, promise me you’ll tell us, yeah?"
Sirius and Scarlett couldn’t hide how uncomfortable they looked, so completely exposed. Remus stood his ground, waiting for an answer.
"Yeah," they both agreed at the same time.
"Not just a ‘yeah’! I want a ‘yes, Remus’!" he corrected, like they were schoolchildren.
"Yes, Remus," they repeated, much less enthusiastically.
"Alright, now you can play," he said, gesturing for them to get up.
Taking advantage of the moment, James pulled his cassette player from the rucksack, set it on one of the loungers, and pressed play.
[Music: The Jackson 5 — ABC]
A sudden gust of nostalgia hit Scarlett like a slap. Her eyes widened, her lips pressed together, and the alcohol in her system made everything feel off-kilter. It was Orfy’s favourite song. Her grip tightened around the bottle of rum, and it took her a while to notice James’s hand extended towards her.
You went to school to learn, girl
Things you never knew before
Like “I” before “E” except after “C”
And why 2 plus 2 makes 4
Now, now, now…
"Come on, let’s dance." It wasn’t a request, though his thin-lipped smile was gently encouraging.
Scarlett wanted to say no, but James grabbed her wrist and pulled her up from the chair.
"This tape’s from Orfy… he lent it to me…" he said, placing his other hand gently on her shoulder.
I'm gonna teach you, teach you, teach you
All about love, girl, all about love
Sit yourself down, take a seat
All you gotta do is repeat after me…
"You… you know how to dance the boogie woogie?" Scarlett stammered, trying to soothe the tide threatening to drag her back into tears.
"Of course I do!" James flashed a confident grin, spinning her in his arms just like he did during their dance classes at the Undercroft.
The two began to move together, with James leading skilfully and Scarlett following along, her laughter bubbling out freely. She used to dance the boogie with Orfeu when they were younger. It was an exaggerated, slightly ridiculous dance—and she was genuinely surprised at how decent James was, matching her loose, carefree moves with ease.
A B C, it's easy as
1 2 3, as simple as
Do re mi, A B C, 1 2 3
Baby, you and me, girl…
"What a weird dance…" Sirius muttered to Lily before sipping his whisky.
"It’s a musical style and an American dance," she replied, mid-bite of her sandwich. "Bit bluesy, y’know?"
"Looks difficult."
"That’s because it is."
Come on and love me just a little bit
I'm gonna teach you how to sing it out
Come on, come on, come on
Let me tell you what it's all about…
Scarlett kept missing steps. She couldn’t have cared less—she was far too drunk for that. James then caught her by the waist and they spun again, morphing into a clumsy, unbalanced waltz until Scarlett broke away and danced on her own, flailing her arms like waves while bending at the waist.
James tried to pull her back upright, but slipped, and the two of them collapsed onto the ground. Sirius shot up in alarm, but they were already laughing uproariously, Scarlett clamping her hand over her mouth as she looked at James beside her, his arm scraped from the fall.
A B C, it's easy as
1 2 3, as simple as
Do re mi, A B C, 1 2 3
Baby, you and me, girl…
"You can’t dance for shit!" she smacked him playfully, and James curled up in defence.
"How can you be good at boogie woogie and completely rubbish at waltzing?!"
"Oh, shut up, James!" Scarlett rolled her eyes, staring up at the starry sky above them.
"You two alright?" Sirius walked over, concern etched on his face.
"We’re fine," Scarlett waved him off like she was swatting away a fly. "It’s James who can’t bloody dance..."
A B C, it's easy, it's like counting up to 3
Singing simple melodies
That's how easy love can be
Singing simple melodies
1 2 3, baby, you and me…
"Alright then." Sirius didn’t sound entirely convinced, but stayed nearby, chatting with Pandora and Lily.
"Want to see something funny?" Scarlett looked at James with a mischievous smile.
"What?" he asked, pushing his glasses back up his nose.
With a swift flick of her wand, Scarlett conjured a sphere of water from the pool, levitating it into the air. She stood slowly, guiding the floating orb with her until—dramatically—she hurled it at Sirius.
It hit him square on the top of the head, splashing water over everyone nearby. He blinked a few times, stunned, then licked his lower lip as he turned to face Scarlett, mischief shimmering in the grey of his eyes.
"Oh, you did not just do that..." he murmured as she burst into laughter. Without missing a beat, Sirius took one step towards her, his smile turning wicked. Before Scarlett could react, he gave her a solid shove straight into the pool. "Oops," he said, placing a hand over his mouth like he’d done something terribly wrong.
Scarlett let out a squeal as she hit the water, vanishing for a moment that felt far longer than it should’ve. When she didn’t immediately surface, Sirius’s grin faltered, replaced by a flicker of concern.
"Scarlett?!" he called, crouching at the edge of the pool. "Scar?"
Without a second thought, he jumped in after her, heart pounding. Sirius grabbed hold of her and pulled her up in one swift, panicked motion. The moment Scarlett emerged, she burst out laughing. Sirius wanted to scold her, but her bright, unrestrained laughter made him exhale in pure relief—and then laugh right along with her.
"You two deserve each other," James said disapprovingly as he stood up—though the grin on his face betrayed him.
Scarlett threw her arms around Sirius, pushing her wet hair out of her face. He looked at her, trying his best to stay annoyed, but it was hopeless.
"My hero," she sang, before kissing him, his scratchy stubble brushing against her lips.
That's how easy love can be...
Sirius smiled into the kiss, holding her close while the others groaned in exaggerated disgust. Then he broke the kiss, drew his wand, and pointed it slyly at James’s back.
"Accio!"
Suddenly, James’s shirt yanked him backwards, throwing him off balance and straight into the pool, sending up a wave that drenched everyone nearby. Laughter erupted as James surfaced, stunned and dripping.
"Bloody hell, Padfoot, my glasses!" he shouted, flailing about, seeing nothing but blurred smudges.
"Calm down, I’ll get them!" Sirius dove under.
Meanwhile, Peter bolted and cannonballed into the pool, splashing the girls. Remus hesitated, then rolled into a somersault and followed suit.
Scarlett couldn’t touch the bottom of the pool, but Sirius and the others could, so she wrapped her arms around her boyfriend from behind. The dimples in his ever-present smile made her heart race. He kissed her gently on the cheek.
"Why haven’t you two got in yet? The water’s perfect!" Scarlett called, splashing water at them.
"I didn’t even bring a bikini!" Lily shook her head firmly.
"And I’m always freezing," Pandora replied, sounding utterly unimpressed.
"Keep them distracted..." James murmured to Sirius and Scarlett before swimming quietly to the opposite edge of the pool.
"After the inferno we walked through today, you deserve this!" Scarlett continued, splashing more water their way. Both girls stood up, stepping back to move the chairs away from the pool’s edge.
That was all the opening James needed. With a swift movement, he shoved Pandora in—her shriek piercing the air as she hit the water.
"Don’t even think about it, Potter..." Lily lifted her hands in surrender—then bolted treacherously toward the far side of the pool.
"Oh no you don’t, Lily!" James chased after her.
They ran back and forth until she nearly tripped dodging his arms, but James caught her in a firm embrace. Lily shrieked and wriggled to get free, but James was far stronger. With a gleam of triumph, he jumped into the pool with her, both vanishing beneath the surface for a few moments.
When they finally came up, they were still holding onto each other. A moment of silence fell across the group as they exchanged a glance—then abruptly let go, clearly flustered.
Scarlett and Sirius exchanged a glance of shared mischief and knowing. The way the pool lights rippled across Sirius’s pale skin made him look like one of Hogwarts’ ghosts. He brushed a lock of hair behind Scarlett’s ear as he wrapped his arms around her, their faces so close their breaths intertwined.
"Operation Jily this summer?" he asked softly, his voice muffled by the water.
"Yes, sir." Scarlett smiled, sinking into the silver of his eyes like someone falling into the warmth of requited love. "Thank you for… for talking to my uncle."
Sirius nodded, caressing her cheek with quiet tenderness.
"No problem. I’ll handle him." He kissed the tip of her wet nose.
"Are you hurting?" Scarlett didn’t look away, trying to unearth all the things Sirius had buried over the past days. He blinked, attempting to keep the tears at bay—but they quickly mixed with the water.
Sirius rested his head on her shoulder, letting Scarlett drown him in the soft tracing of her fingers along his nape, in the calm lapping of the water around them, in the laughter of their friends. In the sweetness that wrapped around them, in that cruel, magnetic love that pulled them helplessly into each other.
"You don’t have to carry all of it alone," Scarlett whispered, even knowing full well how alike they were—natural hoarders of pain. It was hard not to box it all up and bury it in the heart, but… Remus had been right.
They weren’t alone.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 10: Because Sirius was mad about her
Chapter Text
LXXVIII
"Oi, Reg, did you hear?!" Terence called from the other side of the Slytherin table, but Regulus paid him no mind. He was far too immersed in his Rainbow tape, ears blocked with headphones, hand scribbling out the essay Remus had asked for on counter-curses. "Regulus?"
With an irked sigh, Terence chucked a cinnamon bun at him. Regulus jolted and looked up, brushing the sugar off his parchment with his pinkie. He shrugged his shoulder to nudge the headphones aside and raised his eyebrows.
"What?" He didn’t bother hiding the irritation in his voice.
Terence leaned forward over the table like he was about to share a secret.
"Did you read the Prophet today? Apparently, some Muggle spotted your uncle not far from here." He cupped a hand to the corner of his mouth.
Regulus snapped his quill by accident, swearing under his breath as the tip pricked his finger. He closed his hand quickly to stop the blood from dripping onto the parchment.
"No, I didn’t." He admitted, pressing his lips together.
"Why’s he coming here? Is it true that... he wants to finish the job? Kill Potter? I mean... I know he’s your uncle and all, but if I were Potter, I reckon I’d have finished him off after what he did..."
Terence’s voice drifted away as memories floated to the surface of Regulus’ mind like soap bubbles. Sirius had sat him on his lap, tattooed hands stretched out over the grand piano in the parlour. He was playing the notes clumsily, like he was still trying to find the right key, checking against the sheet music.
"Doh, Re, Mi…" He repositioned his fingers over the keys, playing them with more confidence. "Your mum... loved this one..."
Despite the smile on his face, his voice was heavy with sorrow.
"Bloody difficult song..." He pulled a face, as if he'd just done something wrong.
"Daddy, wha’s bloodee?" Regulus stuck his pinkie in his mouth.
"It’s a very bad word you’re not allowed to say. It’s... naughty grown-up stuff." Sirius pressed the keys again, and Regulus felt the muscle in his thigh tense as he pushed the piano pedal.
"Hmm… wha’ moosic is that?"
"It’s a song called Georgy Porgy." Sirius tossed his hair to the side and rested his cheek on the crown of Regulus’ head, the scratch of his stubble making the boy groan dramatically.
"Wha’s a Zhorzy Porzy?" Regulus tried to think what that could mean, but nothing came to mind.
"It’s a bloke who’s... hmm... a tosser." Sirius went back to playing the intro.
"Wha’s a tossah?"
Sirius gave a confused smile.
"It’s a... a silly man." He kept murmuring the tune.
"A silly man? Like dat guy who fighted wiv you and Unkie Jamie ‘cause... ‘cause you wasn’ wearin’ your... um, your hedmet when you was goin’ vroom vroom..."
Sirius stifled a laugh at the comment, still pressing the keys but keeping his hands still.
"It’s helmet, love," he corrected, trying to sound firm.
"Hedmet," Reggie repeated, not catching the difference.
That was all it took for Sirius to shut his eyes and burst into a full laugh, squeezing Regulus’ cheeks and planting a kiss on his hair.
"Why you laughin’?" Regulus frowned, rubbing his messy black hair with his little hands.
"Because I’m happy... because you’re perfect..." Sirius pulled him close in a tight hug, and Regulus snuggled into his dad’s tattooed arms.
"Reg?"
The memory shattered into a million pieces the moment a hand with green-painted nails grabbed his bloodied finger.
Regulus jerked his knees into the table in shock, knocking over a goblet of pumpkin juice right onto his parchment, the sweet haze of the memory clouding his senses.
Victoria, now seated beside him, was watching him with concern.
"Did you hurt yourself?" She made him open his hand, gently wiping the blood with a cloth napkin.
He couldn’t answer. Not while Victoria was touching him with such care, her slender fingers leaving a fizzy trail across his skin.
"He snapped his quill by accident..." Terence explained, shoving a hunk of lamb into his mouth.
"Oh, shit, your essay!" Victoria whipped out her wand with practised ease, drying the juice with a flick, though the parchment was already soaked and stained. But her attention returned to his finger, healing it with a quick charm. "All better."
Regulus had no bloody idea what kind of expression he was wearing just then. Probably something between a dazed prat and a lovesick fool, because she gave him that smile—the one that made her already-adorable rosy cheeks look even sweeter. He chuckled too, still reeling from the echo of Sirius’ piano notes ringing in his memory.
So fast it came—and went. The moment vanished, and nostalgia twisted deep in his chest as the reality returned: Sirius was now a fugitive, and Victoria was getting married—barely had the decency to tell him.
"What’s got you off with the fairies?" she asked, still holding his hand, as if she hadn’t a clue how much her touch tortured him.
He yanked his wrist away suddenly, and her eyes widened a little—those caramel irises no longer soft and sugary, the bitterness rising to the surface as she locked herself behind her usual walls. Victoria’s eyes darkened until they were nearly black.
Words hovered in the space between them, but neither dared to speak them aloud.
Regulus simply turned his face away, hurriedly gathering his roll of parchment as the bell rang. Laughter and shitty comments followed him like a curse as he headed off to Defence Against the Dark Arts. He barely noticed Lua and Victor joining the group, nor Victoria’s forced laugh at one of her brother’s jokes, or Lua’s nasty remarks about his uncle being spotted nearby.
He gripped the strap of his bag tightly as they passed a large group of Gryffindors, his gaze falling on a shorter boy with a distinctive lightning-shaped scar on his forehead. Regulus was caught by those green eyes—so bloody intense that even Potter’s round specs couldn’t dull the pull.
"'Ello, Hawwy," Regulus waved at the little boy sleeping in his Uncle James’ arms. "He’s sweeping?"
"Babies sleep a lot, Reggie," James said, adjusting his glasses while rocking his son. "You were the same at that age—always nodding off."
"Um..." Regulus mumbled, sucking on his finger. "He’s so widdle-widdle."
"You were even smaller than him when you were born..."
"Ummm..." Reggie grunted, pouting with a squishy little face.
"Sirius, Reg—" James started to shout, then immediately winced as Harry stirred in his arms. He bit his lower lip, realising he'd cocked up. He cupped his hand over the baby’s ear. "Come change your kid’s bloody nappy!"
No sooner had James finished speaking than Harry let out a shrill, ear-splitting wail. Sirius came running in from the kitchen with Lily beside him, scooping Regulus up in both arms with a look of absolute disgust on his face.
"Sweet Merlin, how many bloody kilos did you shit?!" he laughed, recoiling from the shrieking Harry.
"Dunno…" Reg shrugged.
"Lils, do you mind giving me a hand with the charm? Left my wand in the kitchen," Sirius glanced sideways at her, letting Regulus snuggle into his chest.
"This is gonna cost you a night off, Black!" she rolled her eyes, whipping out her wand and vanishing the mess with a murmured spell—though the rotten stench still lingered. "Just because I’m a mum now doesn’t mean I’ll be doin’ your dirty work for you!"
"Oh, please, when have I ever refused to clean this little bugger’s shits?!" Sirius rolled his eyes right back, carrying Reggie to a bedroom where a changing table had been set up.
"Daddy… I’m not a shittah!" Regulus grumbled as Sirius pulled down his shorts and started opening the nappy.
"No? Then explain this to me, Mister Regulus Sirius Black!" Sirius fanned his nose dramatically, chucking the dirty nappy into the bin and finishing the job with a cleansing wipe.
"Daddy… when’s Mummy comin’ back?" he asked, kicking his feet impatiently against the edge of the table.
Sirius froze mid-motion, like his brain had suddenly been unplugged—as if he were a robot whose systems had just been rebooted. There was something in his expression, something Regulus didn’t yet understand, but it made his dad’s brows knit together, his jaw clench, and those storm-grey eyes cloud over with something sharp and aching.
"I don’t know, Reg." The reply was barely a breath, and something inside Regulus twisted. A yearning, a longing, a nostalgia for something he’d never had and couldn’t even name.
Regulus stopped dead in his tracks, causing Luana to crash straight into his back. She stumbled, grabbing hold of one of the Weasley twins across the corridor to steady herself, nearly knocking him over in the process. Reg’s eyes followed Harry, watching him over his shoulder as the Gryffindor crowd continued down the hallway to their next lesson.
"What the bloody hell, Teixeira?!" one of the twins snapped.
"Don’t touch me, you filthy pauper!" Luana barked back, dusting off her clothes as though Fred Weasley’s family’s finances might somehow be contagious.
"Go back to the bananaland!" George sneered.
"Shut your gob, you right-leaning wonky bastard!" Luana folded her arms and flipped both middle fingers as she stepped back, gripping Regulus' shoulder straight after. "Oi, what the fuck was that, Reg? You zoning out or something?!"
"Get off my back, Luana," Regulus hissed, shrugging his shoulder hard to shake her off.
"Bloody hell, someone’s on the rag today!" she muttered, glancing over at Victoria. "What’s crawled up his arse, Mimi?!"
"No idea," Victoria sighed in a tone of bored disinterest, avoiding Regulus' eyes entirely.
Not that he gave a toss. Beneath that placid shell, Regulus was putting every ounce of effort into not losing it completely. And he was close— too close. His sanity felt like it could vanish with a snap of someone’s fingers. He could feel that ancient magic slithering through his chest, curling around his fingers, whispering in his ears.
It was easier to push it all down by diving into warm, familiar memories now that he couldn’t take it out on the bloody Bludger. He barely registered Remus’ explanation about the Patronus, too tangled in the chaos of his own mind.
"The memory has to be powerful, a moment when you were truly happy... but that alone won’t do it. Hold onto the feeling and recite the incantation... Expecto Patronum." Remus spoke with calm clarity, hands in his trouser pockets. "A Patronus is a difficult charm, and it will be on your OWLs. If you lot want into the advanced class next year, I suggest you practise."
Regulus drew his wand from his pocket, staring at the yellow candlelight glinting off the dark mahogany handle, inlaid with deep green. He watched Lua and Victoria beside him copying Lupin’s wand motion, repeating the incantation—but absolutely nothing happened.
"Uncle Lup—er—I mean..." Luana cleared her throat when a few Gryffindors threw her strange looks. "Professor Lupin... could I get a bit of help?"
"Uncle Lupin..." Fred and George mimicked in high-pitched baby voices—though their grins vanished when the professor walked past with a serious expression.
"How can I help, Lua?" he asked gently, clasping his hands behind his back, though his gaze lingered briefly on Regulus.
"The spell’s not working. Nothing comes out of my wand!" she complained, nodding towards Adrian Pucey’s wand, where the faintest wisp of silver gas was curling out.
"What are you thinking of?" Remus asked, a small smile playing on his lips.
"The first time I smacked my neighbour with my skateboard." Luana crossed her arms, her silver necklaces clinking loudly against her collarbones. "And it is a good memory because I remember feeling really bloody happy!"
Remus raised an eyebrow, letting out a nasal chuckle as he placed a hand on her shoulder.
"That’s not quite enough, Lua. You need a memory that... makes your heart race just by thinking of it. And you don’t have to be laughing, exactly… just… happy."
"But I… dunno if I’ve got one like that!" she muttered, lips drawing into a pout.
"Of course you’ve got a memory like that," Remus reassured her gently. "You just need to dig a little deeper. Alright?"
"Yeah... I guess so," Luana grumbled, going back to practising.
"Anyone else need help?" Remus turned to Regulus and Victoria, forcing the same tone he used with the other students.
"No, we’re alright..." Mimi said, gripping her wand with both hands, eyes fixed on Reg. "Aren’t we?"
Regulus took a moment before replying.
"Yeah," he said simply, eyes dropping to the floor.
"Could you come by my office after dinner, Reg?" Remus asked quietly, almost in a whisper, as if he were afraid the Gryffindors might overhear.
Reggie only nodded, shooting his uncle a look of discomfort before Remus moved away.
"So… what memory are you thinking of?" Victoria asked, eyes on him. On any other day, Regulus would’ve met her gaze with the same intensity—but today, the frustration weighed too heavy on him.
"Do you remember when we snuck off to the playground near home with your Invisibility Cloak?"
Regulus hadn’t wanted to remember—but he couldn’t stop the small smile that tugged at the corner of his mouth.
"You scraped yourself up all over that seesaw..." He let himself fall into the warmth of those caramel eyes, sweet as honey.
"Because you made me fall off!" Victoria placed her hands on her hips, mouth agape as if properly offended.
"Only ‘cause you told me to jump on my side!" Regulus’ smile grew wider, the earlier tension easing with the sound of their laughter.
"But I was smaller than you—obviously that was going to happen!" she argued, her snow-pale brows drawing together.
"You’re older than me, Victoria. I was your responsibility." On instinct, Regulus slipped his arm over her shoulder, unaware of just how dangerously close they’d become.
"Yeah… you were," she replied softly, the smile now fading into a trail of something far more uncertain.
Regulus didn’t pull away.
He was too lost in the way her pale lashes framed her eyes; the tiny freckle beside her left one; the platinum strands of hair cascading over her shoulders like threads of moonlight. The way her makeup-flushed cheeks turned an even deeper pink; the sharp bob of her throat as she swallowed; the gleam of cherry gloss on her parted lips.
Beautiful… so beautiful it hurt. It scrambled his heartbeat, dissolved the entire world around him, made his blood rush like wildfire.
"Think of that... when you... when you try the spell," Mimi whispered, her voice oddly shaky and affected before she stepped away, cracking the little dome Regulus had built around the two of them.
Many things had a vice grip on his heart that school year. Victoria was one of them. He remembered that day perfectly—their breathless, belly-deep laughter echoing in his chest, Victoria’s flushed cheeks, the butterflies in his stomach as they flew up and down on the seesaw.
"Expecto Patronum!" Regulus recited, and his wand spat out a few silvery sparks, though nothing truly formed. He took a deep breath, cracked his neck, and tried to shut out the whole class chanting the same words over and over.
He let the memories simmer through his mind, grasping at a very specific one, letting it flood his vision, warming his body, bringing colour and life to the Potters' home in Godric’s Hollow.
He didn’t remember much of the inside of the house—but there was a sofa, because that’s where Sirius and James used to sit while they talked. He couldn’t recall the colour or the texture of the fabric—he was always in someone’s lap. And when he felt the rough, scarred hands wrapped around his little fingers, he realised he’d been curled up with Remus, watching the glass of juice he was sipping from.
"Reg, when you go off to Hogwarts, what’re you gonna say to the Sorting Hat?" Sirius had come closer, those bright eyes fixed on his son.
"GWYFFINDO’!" Regulus shouted, throwing his little arms in the air, practically vibrating with excitement.
Remus choked on his juice and James burst into a laughing fit. But all Reggie cared about was the proud expression on Sirius’ face.
"Expecto Patronum!" Regulus flicked his wand sharply—and a silver blur erupted from the tip, only to dissolve like mist in the wind.
"Bloody hell, you almost had it!" Luana clapped a hand over her mouth in surprise. Luckily, her reaction didn’t draw attention from the others. "Were you thinking about your mad uncle?!"
"Stop calling him mad, Luana!" Victoria snapped, biting the inside of her cheek.
"Sorry…" she gave a sheepish smile. "You know I’m only messing about, right, Reg?"
"I know," Regulus replied curtly. "Just... think of something that really made you happy, Lua."
"Ugh, I’ve accepted I’m gonna fail the DADA OWL..." she sighed, going back to her practice.
"You won’t, we’ll help you—same way you help us in Herbology and Care of Magical Creatures..." Victoria gave her friend a few encouraging pats on the shoulder.
"Yeah... alright then." Lua shrugged with a small, bashful smile.
Regulus smiled too, though he pretended to be too busy practising. He let the feeling wash over him again, flicking his wrist as he spoke the incantation—another silver blur, which vanished just as quickly as it came. He took a deep breath, biting his lower lip as he sank, once more, into that memory.
Into James’ loud, unhinged laughter, the restrained way Remus chuckled, and the way Sirius looked at him. Those irises brimming with pride, shaded with brooding silence, tinged with longing. His face lit up in the purest smile, but his eyes looked like they were moments away from crying with the deepest, sharpest pain.
It was that same look Sirius had given him when he played Georgy Porgy, his fingers now more confident on the keys, the melody echoing through Regulus as if it could reach a time before he was born—as if it could touch a feeling so strong it almost became real, so toxic it could choke him, and so volatile it was impossible to hold on to.
With his chin resting on Regulus’ head, Sirius began to cry in silence. The tears fell through his beard, dampening Reggie’s forehead. He kept smiling, unaware of the torment his father carried, too busy hugging him tightly.
" It’s not your situation… I just need contemplation over you.. ." Sirius sang in a hoarse voice. " I’m not so systematic, it’s just that I’m an addict for your love… "
Regulus closed his eyes, feeling his father’s heartbeat matching the rhythm of the song, like it was trying to say he was there—still there. He stroked his dad’s beard with tiny fingers. Sirius smiled and kissed his hand without missing a note, as if the music was stronger than him. Like an instinct, a roar from deep within his chest, a reflection of days long gone, stolen away by the wind.
"I’m not the only one that holds you… I never ever should’ve told you, you’re my only girl… you’re my… my…"
He faltered, exhaling, chest tightening.
"Only world."
Sirius sniffed, pulling his fingers back from the piano like the keys had caught fire. He wiped his face with the collar of his shirt and wrapped his arms around Regulus, breathing in his baby scent as he shut his eyes tightly.
"Your mum loves this song," he confessed, threading his fingers through his son’s silky hair.
"And I love yooou, Daddy!" Regulus mumbled with sleepy affection into his father’s dark locks.
Sirius smiled, tickling him. Reg squirmed in his arms, laughing so hard a bit of snot came out, then hugged Sirius tightly straight after. If there was one thing his father had never denied him, it was his arms.
"I love you too, son."
Scarlett turned her face away from the dog’s slobbery tongue, her expression lit with purest happiness.
"Expecto Patronum!" Regulus repeated the incantation.
"What the bloody hell, Reg?!" Lua said, hands on her hips, stunned.
A massive feline had leapt from his wand, scattering silvery light across the entire DADA classroom and drawing the attention of everyone present. The lion stood proudly atop the professor’s desk, raised its head, and let out a deep, echoing roar before vanishing into mist. Regulus stood frozen, just as shocked as the rest.
"A lion?!" Victoria stared at him, wide-eyed.
"Very well done, Reg—Mr Black," Remus corrected himself with a small cough. "Twenty points to Slytherin."
"I can’t believe that Slytherin’s Patronus is a lion!" one of the Gryffindors burst out, clearly disgruntled.
Regulus gave his uncle a confident smile, who returned it with unmistakable pride. The bell rang soon after, but it wasn’t enough to break the moment. After so many grey days, something light and gentle settled over Reg—a warmth, soft and full of kindness. For a few seconds, the weight of Sirius being on the run, and the aching absence of his mother, simply vanished. It was fleeting, but it was real. He hugged Remus tightly once all the other students had left and only he, Lua, and Mimi remained in the room.
"I’m so proud of you!" Remus kissed the top of his head, just like Sirius used to. "And by the way… happy birthday."
Reggie buried his face in his uncle’s patched-up robes, not saying a word, wishing he could stay in his arms the entire day. He wasn’t used to celebrating his birthday—his father and grandfather had both died on the very day he was born. Although, before Sirius was sent to Azkaban... they had celebrated his first three birthdays.
The weight returned quickly, wrapping around him again as soon as Remus let go. Regulus stepped back, pressing his lips together. Victoria’s hand touched the back of his neck as she whispered her congratulations. But the joy of conjuring his Patronus dissolved like frost in sunlight the moment they stepped out of the classroom and Reg found himself under the suspicious glares of the other students.
"How did Dumbledore even allow you in this school?!" Angelina Johnson, Chaser for the Gryffindor team, looked him up and down with disgust. "You’re clearly helping your murderer uncle."
"Shut your mouth, Johnson!" Victoria hissed, her white hair flickering as though threatening to change colour.
Regulus pretended not to notice, but the tension between Slytherin and the other houses had only grown worse with the rumours that he was aiding Sirius Black. Obviously, it had just been a joke on the Hogwarts Express, but it was enough to set the entire school ablaze with gossip, spreading like wildfire along a lit fuse.
He forced a smile as he accepted congratulations from Miles, Terence, and Adrian at dinner—though a number of the Slytherins looked none too pleased that his Patronus had taken the form of a lion. And that only made him retreat deeper into his own thoughts.
.
.
.
"We’ll wait out here..." Victoria gave him a faint smile, leaning back against the wood-panelled corridor wall.
"Yeah... just don’t take forever… I’ve got to go shake down Weasley for that money I lent him..." Luana muttered as she plonked herself on the floor.
“You? Lending money to the twins?!”
"It was just one of them, and I’ll be paid back—with interest and a late fee." Luana rolled her eyes, resting her head against the wooden panelling.
"How can you be so sure? They can barely afford their school supplies…"
Regulus gave the door two light taps, and it swung open with a gentle creak. He gave a small wave to the girls before stepping into the lamplit room. He’d never been inside a professor’s quarters before and was surprised by how spacious Remus’ was: a large sofa against the left-hand wall, two more around the fireplace, Persian rugs covering the floor, a drinks cabinet, trunks, a magical mirror, and a grandfather clock ticking softly with its pendulum swinging.
Remus sat in front of the fire, a modest tea set laid out and already steeping.
"Come in, Reg," he said, gesturing to the sofa beside him, the firelight casting shadows across his tired face.
Regulus walked over and sat down, arms crossed over his chest. The open space made the room feel chillier, even with the fire burning.
"What were you thinking about when you cast your Patronus?" Remus handed him a teacup, his gentle smile steady.
The porcelain was warm against his fingers, taking the bite out of the October air. Regulus regretted leaving his scarf in the common room. He looked at Remus with hesitation, like he was afraid of how his uncle might respond.
"Sirius..." The name of his godfather made Remus’ eyes widen slightly. "Before he... before he was arrested... he used to sing to me. On the piano. And I remembered... once, when he played and sang Georgy Porgy, and... after that, he told me he loved me."
He shouldn’t have felt bad saying it aloud. But the way Remus’ brown eyes suddenly went stiff—just slightly—made the regret seep into every pore of his skin. Thank Merlin he hadn’t mentioned the photo of his mum.
"You didn’t..." Remus paused, as if weighing his words. "You didn’t think of any of your other uncles?"
Regulus took a sip of tea, the hot liquid burning slightly down his throat. He shook his head, eyes fixed on his wavering reflection in the dark drink.
"Reg, why this... obsession with Sirius?"
There was no anger in Remus’ question. But no softness, either.
"What?!" He let out a baffled laugh. "I… what do you mean, obsession?"
"You clearly had happier moments in your life… I know that because I was there. From the beginning. I was part of your upbringing."
Regulus wet his lips, holding his gaze steady.
"Because… I was never an obligation to him. Not like I was to the rest of you. He loved me. Properly. And I don’t even know how… seeing as I’m the son of the woman he loved and his own brother."
Remus’ expression shifted from wary to deeply sorrowful.
"You were never… never an obligation to me, Reg. And I… I love you."
He placed one hand over his heart, the other closing gently around his nephew’s fingers.
"It’s different, Uncle." Reg murmured, eyes drifting to the photographs on the marble mantelpiece above the fire. "You were always with Nate. You never told him off when he hinted I was just like my mum. You lied to me for years—even when I begged to know about her. Sirius never lied to me."
"He did lie. You just don’t remember," Remus replied sharply. "You were too young."
"He loved me!" Regulus’ voice shook as it rose, cutting through the air. "More than any of you ever did!"
"Don’t talk about what you don’t understand, Reg!" Remus didn’t bother hiding the pain in his voice. "I was trying to protect you—"
"Protect me from the truth?!"
"You want the truth, Reg?" Shadows from the fire danced across Remus’ face, deepening the lines and scars like ink on old parchment. "Scarlett left. Sirius became an alcoholic. Then she married your father, came crawling back to your uncle with her tail between her legs—pregnant with you. He still held out for her. But there was one very important detail no one knew... Scarlett killed the McKinnons." Regulus went pale. Remus didn’t stop. "The trial was short. She didn’t deny a thing. Meanwhile, your uncle—he had to raise you, alone. Because your father died before you were even born..."
"I know that part!" Regulus cut him off, grinding his teeth. "I want to know what it was like... before that. What she was like before everything fell apart. Nate never talks about it, and Orfy... I don’t know what’s true and what’s the aftermath of torture. You’re all I’ve got. So please... just tell me something about her. Anything. I know what she did, I just... I just wanted to know her. Like I knew my uncle. Even if it was only for three years... two... even one. I—"
"Reg..." Remus let out a long breath.
"I’m not in the right headspace to talk about that. Not now."
"You never are, Uncle." Regulus slammed the teacup onto the table so hard it sloshed over the rim. "Sirius would’ve told me. Even if it hurt. He would’ve told me."
"Because Sirius was mad about her... so mad he was willing to betray James and Lily..." Remus’ expression darkened with remorse, his lips pressing together as if to stop the words from going any further.
Regulus wilted, swallowing down the urge to cry.
"Would you have told me the truth if I hadn’t found out?" he finally asked, after a long stretch of silence.
Remus tilted his head slightly in his direction before closing his eyes and shaking his head.
"Why not?"
"Because I know you—and I know you’ll try to go after Sirius. So let me be clear—you won’t succeed. I’ve revoked your permission to go to Hogsmeade, and I want your Invisibility Cloak handed in tomorrow without fail."
Regulus stiffened, clenching his fists.
"What?!" He scowled, stunned.
"You’ll stay in the castle, and Professor Snape will ensure you remain here during the full moon week."
"But... we’re all going to Hogsmeade for Halloween and—"
"Reggie..." Remus used that patronising tone he hated. "Please. Don’t make this harder than it already is."
Regulus stared at him for a long time. The only sound in the room was the crackle of the fire, casting orange light across his face, brushing over his freckles and kindling the steel in his eyes. His whole body was tense—flared nostrils, tight jaw, lips twisted in defiance.
It was hard to hold back everything crawling under his skin, but Regulus gathered up each feeling threatening to sabotage his control—and hurled them away as he shut his eyes. Then, suddenly, he exhaled... and smiled.
His lips curved into a hollow smile. Cold.
The kind of expression he knew unsettled his uncle deeply—because Remus blinked, visibly thrown by his reaction. It was a defence mechanism Reg had honed in response to Nate’s constant impatience with his temper: suppressing everything like wind sweeping through fog.
"Alright." His voice was calm. "I’ll drop off the cloak here after lunch tomorrow."
Remus nodded slowly, shoulders sagging, clearly relieved by the apparent surrender. But he knew—it was only a mask Regulus forced himself to wear.
"Anything else, Uncle?"
Reggie’s eyes never left his. Not even the firelight burning in his gaze could melt the sharp ice-blue streaks that danced through the grey.
"I think... I think that’s it, Reg," Remus stammered, still thrown by his nephew’s composure.
"I’ll head back to my common room, then." He stood in one smooth, deliberate movement, brushing past Remus without so much as a glance. "Good night, Uncle."
Remus looked so stunned he barely reacted as Regulus made for the door.
"Reg…" he called out. Regulus glanced over his shoulder as he opened it. "It’s going to be alright, yeah? I love you."
Regulus didn’t reply. His emotions were caged in that moment, but if he answered, he might unleash them all at once. He only managed a forced smile before stepping out of the room—right into Luana stacking a dozen Galleons and Victoria sketching the sleeping figure in the portrait before her.
"All done?!" Luana ran a hand through her wavy hair, glancing at him sideways.
He barely acknowledged her, walking faster and faster through the narrow halls of Hogwarts as if searching for the safety of a mother’s lap or a father’s arms. But Regulus knew he’d never have that. His best chance had been with Remus—and his uncle had shattered it without a moment’s hesitation.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 11: Sirius was at Hogwarts
Chapter Text
LXXIX
The cold October wind tousled Regulus’s hair the moment he stepped through the main gates, crossed the courtyard, and pushed open the iron gate. He began descending the countless stone steps in one go, skipping some in his frantic reflexes, the magical torches lighting the path towards the Boathouse.
Panting and sweating, Regulus passed right by the building and sat at the edge of the Black Lake, his feet swinging in sync with the storm coiling in his chest. He didn’t want to cry. Regulus Black wasn’t the kind of boy who found comfort in tears, so he filled his lungs with air and twisted his vocal cords into a guttural scream that tightened every muscle in his body and tore through the calm of the star-dappled surface of the lake; birds shot up from the nearby trees, and the ancient magic resonated inside him with the same fury as his voice.
Everything pointed to Sirius heading to Hogwarts.
Scarlett was dead.
His biological father was dead, too.
He couldn’t go after Sirius.
He wanted to go after Sirius.
Should he go after Sirius?
Why not? Sirius would never hurt him.
Would he?
Regulus sighed, staring at his blurred reflection in the water. Doubt thrashed at his core, ripping through his chest violently, his hands gripping the stone ground as he shook his head in confusion. Why was Sirius heading to Hogwarts? Was he coming after him? Or after Potter?
What the fuck was Remus’s problem?
Regulus felt himself swallowed by a whirlpool of doubt, of certainty, of fear, of longing. Sirius was a murderer. He’d killed thirteen people. He’d betrayed the Potters. Why the hell did he still think his godfather was a good person? Why did he cling to that?!
As much as he despised him, Harry Potter was an orphan because of Sirius Black. Regulus’s breath caught. It couldn’t be that Sirius— his Sirius—would be cruel enough for that! That the man who’d taught him so much about love was nothing more than a flowered shard of a killer.
He pulled the photo of Sirius and Scarlett from the pocket of his trousers. They looked so happy it hurt. Why did love have to fucking hurt so much? Regulus ran a hand through his sleek black hair, the kiss looping over and over, the sun shining behind them, the waves crashing in the background with a yellow ball being pushed by the tide. His fingers brushed over Sirius’s face, then Scarlett’s, his gaze lingering on the bikini she wore.
He pulled out another photo from his pocket. It had been taken the same day—Scarlett hadn’t changed, and the yellow ball still floated atop the crest of the waves, just behind Padfoot. Regulus smiled—a genuine smile as he drank in Scarlett’s euphoric expression, the happiness she’d felt on a day when she was still alive.
A delicate hand touched Regulus’s shoulder. Victoria sat down beside him, though she didn’t dare let her feet dangle over the edge of the platform. Regulus knew she had never been taught how to swim. He also knew Victoria hated insects. And Mondays. And loud, attention-seeking girls. She hated it when Luana borrowed her clothes and never gave them back, when people chewed with their mouths open, or when she left a drawing unfinished. And above all, Victoria Rookwood hated summer.
Reggie was fully aware that this girl—the one he so desperately wanted to call his—would never truly belong to him.
She was a broken piece of an otherwise beautiful ornament, but there would always be something missing. Something ugly, or maybe something beautiful—who cared? She was a little porcelain doll doomed to live under the rule of her family, the fearsome Rookwoods. Victoria would make a respectable match with Luke Avery, and Regulus would witness it all from his place of helpless silence and bitter regret.
Victoria looked at him, and it was hard not to be swept away by those honey-coloured eyes, though in the dusk of night they turned to brown, nearly onyx. Her hair was as white as the moon drifting above the Black Lake. Her lips—his downfall. She embraced him, as if she wanted Regulus to share the weight pressing down on her chest.
Regulus didn’t. With him, it was always all or nothing; if he couldn’t have Victoria entirely, then he’d rather not give himself at all. Although... he, too, was just a boy tossed into a sea of uncertainty, born of misfortune, the result of all his mother’s reckless choices, the cause of his father’s death. The salvation of his godfather. Not that he knew that at the time, of course, no matter how much he longed to. Regulus knew more about his friends than he did about himself.
"Are you cold?" Victoria asked, but all he could focus on was the warmth of her, seeping into his body in that one-sided embrace. Regulus remained still, as if her cherry perfume were toxic.
One of Victoria’s hands gently stroked the nape of his neck, the other clutched the back of his cloak. Regulus buried his face in her moonlit hair, resting his forehead on Mimi’s shoulder. He focused on the paralysing sensation she caused in him, awakening his instincts as if she were poisonous.
Regulus had never wanted so badly to be poisoned.
"No," he whispered, voice muffled against her cloak. It was a lie. It was fucking freezing, but Regulus wasn’t about to admit it. Not when he slowly turned his face towards her, his aristocratic nose brushing along Victoria’s jawline.
His gaze slipped from her prominent cheekbone to her thick lashes, landing on those caramel irises. She watched him out of the corner of her eye, stars speckling her gaze as if they were trying to build an impossible bridge between them. Victoria swallowed hard, as if unaware of how close he was. Or, perhaps, because she knew exactly how close he was—and didn’t want him to pull away.
Regulus’s eyes lingered on her mouth, glistening softly with cherry lip balm. He raised a hand, his thumb fitting perfectly into the delicate dip of her chin, as though it had been made for his finger. Victoria’s skin was soft, warm, forbidden. He grew bolder, lifting her lower lip with the pad of his thumb, feeling the sticky cherry gloss under his touch.
“You’re so beautiful,” Regulus whispered, the words carried away by the strong wind that tossed his hair and Victoria’s alike.
He wasn’t lying. Bathed in the light of the moon and stars, Victoria Rookwood looked like Aphrodite herself, with flushed lips and tear-laced eyes. A blush bloomed across her cheeks, as if she didn’t know just how stunning she was. She did, of course—but her grace wasn’t enough to balance how rotten she felt on the inside. That’s why every one of her instincts screamed at her to run.
But the truth was, Victoria Rookwood was just as chained to Regulus as he was to her. They just didn’t know it yet.
Regulus traced his nose along her flushed cheek, brushing it against hers until it met the tip of her nose, their warm breaths mingling, chasing the cold away. He inched closer, drawn to that cherry scent like a sailor to a siren’s call.
Their lips met in a fleeting touch. It was ephemeral, as soft as a butterfly landing on a flower. Victoria’s hand slid up into his hair, fingers tangling and tugging hard enough to make his scalp burn, forcing him to lift his face. This time, she was the one who kissed him, her other hand gripping the back of his neck like she meant to hold him there forever.
Victoria’s storm met Regulus’s storm. And that gentle kiss was swept up in the tempest. She sucked on his lower lip, and Reggie gasped in surprise. Taking advantage, Victoria’s tongue slipped into his mouth, spreading that sweet cherry taste, her arms winding round his neck while he gripped her waist and pulled her closer—like she might be able to melt the frost that was crawling up his body and setting itself deep in his bones.
Their tongues brushed in a clumsy, curious dance—exploratory. Regulus had had his fair share of kisses before—a Ravenclaw girl in his third year, a Hufflepuff, and four Slytherins in his fourth—but none of them had ever made his body resonate like Victoria Rookwood did.
He never thought it was possible to feel so much heat. She was a bloody matchstick, igniting every part of him in ways he hadn’t thought imaginable, her impetuous touch in his hair knocking him completely off balance.
Regulus wanted Victoria—he always had—but she was the apple perched too high on the branch, always just out of reach, as if trying to protect him from temptation. But Reg wanted her, even without fully understanding what he felt, even with all the mess clawing at his chest. And frankly, he was tired of bottling it all up.
Victoria shoved him away abruptly. Regulus caught himself on both hands against the cold stone ground, too dazed to notice the approaching footsteps. His entire focus was on a flushed and flustered Mimi, her lips swollen, her cloak creased.
Then he followed her gaze—only to see Luana accompanied by Luke Avery, Aphelandra Pyke, and Achilles Selwyn. It was dark there, though the torches by the Boathouse threw a flickering glow over the group.
Regulus’s breath caught when he spotted them. With a twisted expression, Avery whipped out his wand, and a yellow flash slammed into Victoria, sending her flying backwards into the lake. She barely had time to look at him, terror in her eyes, before she was swallowed by the star-speckled black waters.
“What the fuck, Avery?!” Luana shouted, snapping Reggie out of his daze.
“I can’t believe you snogged my fiancée!” Luke roared, lunging at Regulus.
The shouting above was a blur of garbled noise beneath the surface. Victoria was engulfed by the Black Lake, dragged under as though an anchor had been chained to her ankle. She should have fought—thrashed her arms in a desperate attempt to swim despite not knowing how. Doing what she’d always done best: thrashing in her golden cage, like a bird that longed for freedom more than anything, but when faced with an open door, froze in fear.
Should she fly free into the sky, singing unbound into the vastness of the world—or settle for her song reaching only the ears of her captors, in the small, safe space they gave her?
Victoria Rookwood was exactly what her parents expected: an obedient girl, resigned to her fate, raised to be the perfect match for a pure-blood family.
Which was rather tragic for someone so young. Victoria wanted to be so much more. Every time she tried, her parents clipped her wings, her brothers plucked her feathers, and she was drowned over and over again in a bathtub full of ice—as if the cold might bring back her sense of reason, as if losing consciousness and nearly dying with water in her lungs might somehow tame her.
And it worked… for a while. Until something cracked inside her—snapped so deeply that it was as though she no longer cared about anything. It was the first time Vin hit her, because she’d laughed when he’d tried to cast the Blasting Curse and ended up singeing off his own eyebrows.
Victoria had never been punched in the ribs before. The blow knocked all the air from her lungs, and she doubled over, hands clutching the aching spot. Despite the pain, a strange laugh clawed its way up her throat, slid over her vocal cords, and burst out uncontrollably, breathless and wild.
Vin had grabbed her by the hair, yanking her like a rag doll. Victoria might have been afraid—if she could. But the laughter wouldn’t stop, as if her brother’s failure were the funniest thing she’d ever seen.
He drowned her that day.
Vinny often did that when he got frustrated. Victor was the only one who never hurt her, though he always stood there watching in silence from some corner, his gaze distant. As if afraid he might be next.
That was the problem with pure-blood families: either you were like them, or you were broken by them.
The start of the school year at Hogwarts was always the hardest. Hiding the bruises? Done. Walking as though her ankle hadn’t been twisted the day before because her brother had been frustrated? Done. Wrapping her torso because a couple of ribs might be cracked? Done.
Regulus was a fleeting moment of happiness in her summer, though he, too, was rather withdrawn. They both were, in the end. Maybe that was why they were so close. They didn’t need to chatter endlessly like Luana, but they weren’t frozen in silence like Victor, either.
She and Reggie had a dialogue in their eyes—one that said, “ I’m hurting but I don’t want to talk about it. Will you stay with me?” or “ I really need you here but I don’t know how to ask.” Or, better still: “I like you, but I’ve got too many issues to hold down a relationship and I don’t want to hurt you. Will you stay anyway?”
Simple—and, at the same time, unbearably complex. Victoria was a mess, and so was Regulus. Frightened, cowardly, both of them loved stacking up all the terrible things that had ever happened to them just to compare and see, yes—they’d won the misfortune contest! They were teenagers. And like all good teenagers, they resented imperfection.
Her fingertips were already numb with cold when something pulled her to the surface. Something with silver eyes flecked with blue. The kind of blue only visible at midday, when the sun blazed at its highest and the sky was so intense, so deep, that Victoria felt herself swallowed whole—only to be hurled back by quicksilver and consumed by dark pupils.
As though shocked by sudden electricity, she began to thrash. It was irrational, something rooted so deep in her core she couldn’t control it.
“It’s me…” Reggie whispered, lips trembling and wet. “It’s me, Mimi, it’s me…” he repeated, his voice gentle, soothing that defensive mechanism back into slumber.
Regulus held her with one arm, droplets dripping from his long black lashes as he brushed the freckles on her cheeks. Victoria gasped in the night air, drawing it into her lungs in a choked spasm. Reg pulled her close, her back against his chest, while he swam with the other arm.
And she couldn’t help but look up at the starry sky, her breath forming a fine mist as it left her lips. Her hand clutched Regulus’s triceps, eyes drifting toward Hogwarts. At that hour, the castle blazed with the glow of hundreds of candles, their light shimmering through the windows, towering above the Black Lake like something sacred and unreachable.
Luana reached out a hand from the shore. Victoria grabbed it and was hauled from the water. She was shaking, but it wasn’t from the cold. There was something else writhing in her chest—the sight of the cage door flung open, the bittersweet taste of freedom, the ache to take a step forward even if it meant stumbling two steps back.
Victoria lifted her eyes to Luke Avery. He wasn’t an ugly boy, but he wasn’t handsome like Cedric, nor aristocratic like Regulus. He was just some kid who thought blood meant more than anything else.
“What the fuck, Victoria?!” Luke shouted at her, as though she owed him any kind of explanation.
Her caramel eyes turned to quicksand, ready to pull him under and drown him in the dark whirl of her irises.
She’d been raised to be an obedient girl—but being the youngest of three boys, Victoria also knew how to be feral when she needed to be. She clenched her fists tightly as she stood. The icy wind wrapped around her and tore away what little self-restraint she had left. She took a step out of her gilded cage as she approached Avery. Rage spiralled behind her, tugging the strings in her head as though she were nothing but a puppet. She forced it back, like blowing smoke from her face.
“I knew there was something going on between you and Black, but to shag him when our parents have already signed—”
Luke Avery’s voice grated on her nerves, especially those bland lips, the dull eyes, the blond hair, the red patches on his cheeks… the way he treated her like property, just as her entire family did. The fury returned, brushing the nape of her neck, whispering temptations from the edge of her mind.
“—I’ll demand the contract be annulled. I won’t marry some slag like you—”
She took a deep breath, the way she always did when being submerged in a tub full of ice, letting the water flood her lungs until they burned so badly she blacked out. And that thing curled in her chest just as fast as the air filled it. Her hair flared a fiery red, and she moved—swift as a striking serpent.
Victoria punched Luke square in the mouth. He stumbled back, Luana gasped, Achilles barely reacted, and Aphelandra burst into laughter. Pain shot through her wrist, sharp and blinding, as if she’d broken something. At the same time, hot blood stamped itself across the pale skin of her hand. She’d endured far worse.
She hit him again—mimicking the rib punch Vin had once given her. Luke doubled over, and Victoria understood instantly why her brothers did this: it was delicious to overpower someone with brute force. Her mouth watered, heart hammering, and she tasted Avery’s blood on her knuckles, the metallic bitterness lighting up her tongue.
Finally, she struck him right on the nose. She felt the cartilage crack beneath her bones. She wasn’t the strongest of fighters, didn’t have much muscle, but the sheer surprise was enough—Avery couldn’t even reach for his wand.
And she laughed. Laughed like she’d just been hit herself, her voice echoing across the Black Lake and the Boathouse, rattling the other prefects like she was mad.
“What the fuck are you doing, Rookwood?!” Achilles asked, too stunned to step in.
He was ignored.
"You're so fucking pathetic!" she hissed between fits of laughter. "I’d never marry a piece of shit like you, Avery!" She spat on the ground, covering her lips with her bruised palm, the blood and welts darkening her pale skin. "And you will annul this contract, Luke—but not because you want to."
Victoria loomed over him, her face twisted with fury, her body trembling, seething, hatred pulsing hot through her veins.
"You’re going to call off this engagement or I’ll kill you," she threatened, her face so close to Luke’s that she could feel his panicked breaths against her nose. He looked even more repulsive from that angle.
"Y-you’re insane…" Luke stammered, his nose still bleeding.
"Am I?" She flashed a vicious smile, licking her lips, savouring every second she saw fear refracted in Luke’s dark eyes. "You haven’t seen anything yet, Avery..."
The moment, however, was broken when someone grabbed her. She didn’t need to look. She knew exactly whose hands they were—the weight of Regulus’s grip on her wrists, the feel of his breath against her neck, the thrum of his heart pounding into her spine, the heavy steps, the water dripping from his hair onto her shoulders. She’d known him her whole life, and that hold made her lash out violently.
"That’s enough, Victoria!" Regulus growled, trying to stop her.
Panic thumped through her chest like alarm bells. She fought against it, kicking, twisting, and Regulus let go in shock, as if afraid he’d hurt her. It was the perfect opening—and she slapped him. Hard. Her hand cracked across his face, his lips parting slightly, the pale skin blooming with the shape of her fingers.
Victoria stared at him, stunned. Reggie was paler than usual, his lips trembling, drained of colour from the cold—and from the sting of her hand. She didn’t want the fun to end—not when she was enjoying it so much. But she knew she’d crossed a line, even if part of her still relished what she’d done to Avery. Her fist ached. The guilt began to rise.
"Fuck off!" she snarled, backing away from Regulus in one harsh movement. Her hair shifted from red to deep indigo as she stormed toward the stairs, leaving a trail of water in her wake.
Regulus didn’t move. The cold seemed to seep into his bones, freezing his muscles, congealing the blood in his head. His icy fingers reached for the bruise now forming on his cheek.
"Fucking hell, Black…" Luke panted, lifting his dark eyes to Reggie. "You bastard… sneaky little prick…"
"You heard her, Avery," Luana said, staring him down with a smirk. "She’s gonna kill you—and I’ll bury the body."
Regulus blinked, pulling himself together as he took in the state Avery was in.
"Wait till everyone hears how you cried… like a little girl… after getting your arse handed to you by Victoria," he sneered, earning a laugh from Aphelandra.
"You lot… are going to… regret this," Luke warned through clenched teeth. "You’d… better watch yourselves."
"Watch ourselves? Look who’s flat on the floor. If I were you, I’d keep my distance. She follows through on her promises," Regulus said coolly, stepping past Avery and heading up the stairs, trembling from the cold.
.
.
.
It was hard pretending nothing had happened for the rest of the week, avoiding Victoria between classes and enduring Luana’s puzzled stares. He barely slept in the days that followed, his heart threatening to leap out of his chest at any moment. Pucey and Miles's relentless attempts to find out what had happened annoyed him so much that he was forced to make up a lie about having accidentally fallen into the Black Lake and hitting his cheek on something that just happened to be shaped exactly like a hand.
Halloween morning arrived, and he hadn’t shut his eyes all night. He heard Miles getting up, full of excitement about buying new Quidditch gloves, while Pucey grumbled in yet another episode of sleepwalking. Taking advantage of the light-hearted mood, Regulus masked the light bruise on his face with a charm and got dressed, an odd rush of anticipation stirring in his veins as he scanned the common room for Victoria. He’d decided—he was going to talk to her. About the slap, about the kiss. As soon as they were alone in the Slytherin common room.
She was sitting with Luana and Victor on one of the sofas, sipping tea with her usual composed expression. But the moment she saw Regulus, her face clouded, her eyes widened, and her lips tensed. The happiness that had been building in Regulus’s chest solidified into a block of ice.
"Reggie!" Luana sang, twisted awkwardly across the sofa. "We going to Hogsmeade?"
Regulus swallowed hard, still shaken by Mimi’s reaction. He touched his bruised cheek as if trying to confirm the events of that night had really happened.
"No… can’t," he mumbled, stuffing his hands in his pockets and shrugging. "My uncle forbade me."
"What?" Victor leaned back, propping a hand behind his head to look at him. "Why?"
"Because of Sirius," he replied, barely more than a whisper.
The group exchanged a tense, loaded silence.
"It’s alright, I’ll stay here. You lot go ahead…" He tried his best to sound indifferent. "Wasn’t planning on buying anything anyway…"
"Reg…" Victoria licked her lips, visibly awkward. "I could stay with you…"
"No, go," he cut in sharply. "It’s fine. I’ve got Transfiguration homework to do anyway…"
All Regulus wanted—more than anything—was for Mimi to insist, to fight for him. But she didn’t. She simply nodded and gestured for her twin brother and Luana to get up.
“See you at the party later?” she asked before leaving.
Regulus forced himself not to fall into the trap of looking at her. He merely nodded, his expression unreadable.
He returned to the dormitory feeling like a complete failure. Every ounce of happiness he’d carefully cultivated in secret now felt thorny, raw, abrasive. He threw himself onto the bed without even bothering to pull the covers over himself, trying—and failing—to block out Victoria as she forced her way back into his thoughts.
Being alone was his fate.
He woke a little before lunch and stared up at the canopy of his bed for longer than he’d care to admit. He felt the blanket. He didn’t remember covering himself. With a sigh of irritation, he sat up, opened his trunk, and rummaged for his invisibility cloak.
His mother’s inheritance.
He didn’t find it.
His heart kicked into a rapid, panicked rhythm the moment his fingers searched through his clothes, scattering them in growing desperation. He always kept it tucked safely beside his socks.
Breathing heavily, Regulus stood, raking a hand through his hair and glancing around as if the cloak might just appear. He cursed under his breath and stormed out of the common room, unconsciously rubbing his bruised cheek with his knuckles. The Great Hall was packed with first- and second-years having lunch, all of them turning their curious little heads as he passed.
He forced himself to eat something before hurrying toward Remus’s office. He knew the full moon was near, just not the exact day. The door was slightly ajar, and as he got close, he heard his uncle’s voice.
“Is that so?” Lupin asked.
Regulus turned his face toward the gap, catching sight of a very messy head of hair belonging to a boy seated with his back to the door.
“Some people reckon he’d do anything to get the Defence Against the Dark Arts post,” the boy said.
Regulus would have eavesdropped longer if he could, but the urgency of his missing cloak made him even more frantic than before. He knocked twice and entered without ceremony.
“Horrible…” Lupin muttered, sipping from his goblet. “Ah, Reggie, there you are!” he beamed.
Regulus wiped his sweaty palms on his trousers, his eyes landing on Harry Potter sitting across from Remus.
“I believe you already know Harry…” Remus gestured to the boy, and the two of them exchanged a quick glance.
“Hi, Potter,” Regulus murmured awkwardly. “Uncle, I need to—”
“Uncle?” Harry shot Regulus a suspicious look. He’d never heard anyone refer to a professor like that before.
“Can it wait, Reg? I really need to get back to work,” Remus gave him a tired smile, though his tone was layered with much more. “I’ll see you both at the party later.”
The full moon, of course.
“Alright…” Regulus exhaled, deciding not to bring up the cloak—he didn’t want to get more wound up than he already was. “Looks like I’m not the only one banned from going to Hogsmeade…” he muttered as he left his uncle’s office, Harry trailing behind.
“You were banned from going to Hogsmeade too? Why?” the boy asked.
Regulus glanced sideways at him, eyes landing on the lightning-bolt scar that cut through the pale skin of the Boy Who Lived.
“Ask my uncle— I mean… Professor Lupin,” he corrected himself with a slight cough and kept walking.
“He’s related to you?” Harry matched Regulus’s pace without hesitation.
Regulus licked his lips, unsure whether to admit Remus had been married to his great-uncle Thanatos. Then the thought flickered—why should he explain anything to Potter?
“Sort of… I grew up with him,” Regulus shrugged, not taking his eyes off the Gryffindor. There was a strange warmth buried deep in his chest for Harry, something desperate to rise to the surface.
He didn’t say anything else—just kept walking, though his stride naturally matched Harry’s.
“So why didn’t you go to Hogsmeade?” Regulus asked after a long stretch of silence.
“My aunt and uncle didn’t sign the permission slip… they’re Muggles. Didn’t understand what the… uh, form was for.” He adjusted his glasses on his nose.
“That’s shit…” Regulus muttered. “Your mum’s side?”
Harry nodded, his expression dull. A strange surge of empathy rose in Regulus when the boy seemed to wilt.
“You grew up with Professor Lupin, then? He’s the best Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher we’ve ever had…”
Regulus shoved his hands in his pockets, unsure what or how to respond to Harry. Best say nothing; after all, his parents had been Death Eaters, and his godfather was literally the reason Harry’s parents were dead.
“The best, yeah?” Reg didn’t hide the proud smile that crept onto his lips. “Hope he lasts longer than a year… but you know what they say—curse on the job…”
"Yeah… me too," Harry admitted, and they both came to a halt as they encountered a rather familiar figure in the corridor.
Snape narrowed his black eyes at the sight of Harry, then raised a single brow at Regulus. Regulus straightened at once, the sinister gleam in the professor’s watchful gaze making him feel, quite suddenly, like he was about to be caught misbehaving.
"What are the two of you doing?!" Snape sneered, lips curling with undisguised contempt.
"Walking," Harry shot back immediately, staring at him with a boldness that left Regulus speechless.
Snape clicked his tongue in derision, scrutinising Regulus closely. He leaned in towards him.
"I know what you and Lupin are planning, Black. I suggest you stay away from Potter," he said in a nasal, low voice—just quiet enough that Harry wouldn’t catch it.
"What?" Regulus frowned. "What are you talking about, Professor?"
"Don’t associate with his kind, Black," Snape said sharply, his eyes flicking to Harry with clear disgust. "Get back to your common room."
"Why?"
"Because I said so," Snape snapped, eyes narrowing on Regulus. "Now, Black."
Regulus huffed but obeyed in silence. He glanced at Harry with a small smirk tugging at the corner of his mouth, feigning a turn toward the Slytherin common room—but instead veered off, heading back to the Defence Against the Dark Arts tower. He slipped into the old clock and descended the hidden staircase into the Undercroft.
He didn’t know exactly what he was doing there—his head was too tangled, too noisy. Victoria’s kiss and slap, the missing cloak, the strange tension of his conversation with Harry… it all sat on top of everything else he was already dealing with. He lit the sconces, his eyes passing over the abandoned instruments as he walked among them, heading for the room that had once belonged to his mother.
He reached the sideboard, where some of the photos had fallen over, just below the engraved inscription on the wall. Regulus picked them up one by one, searching for one that included James and Scarlett. Most of them featured at least her, Sirius, and himself.
Then he found one—different from the rest. James was dipping Scarlett in an awkward dance move, both laughing mid-motion. Regulus wiped the photo clean with the sleeve of his cloak and tucked it into his pocket, the chill of the gallery curling around his legs. His eyes wandered across the dusty furniture—until they caught on a patch cleaner than the rest.
He arched a brow and turned his head, narrowing his eyes.
That was exactly where he’d left his mother’s watch.
The watch that was no longer there.
Regulus opened drawers, searched cupboards, rummaged around the books, cast Accio, even overturned the bed… nothing.
His heart skipped several beats, saliva thick in his mouth. First the invisibility cloak. Now the watch… Sirius knew about the Undercroft—he knew .
His knees went weak, his breath caught and staggered in his throat.
Sirius was at Hogwarts.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 12: When the sun rises… the stars and the moon vanish
Chapter Text
LXXX
Hogsmeade was ready for Halloween. Pumpkins decorated the streets and shopfronts, pulling grimacing faces and startling a few witches and wizards who came too close. Swarms of bats flitted around the signposts in the middle of the village, and scarecrows wearing wizard hats waved cheerfully at passersby. On the noticeboard in the village’s Central Square, three posters in a row displayed the face of a hollow-cheeked man with tangled long hair.
Regulus crossed his arms, staring at the agitated portrait of his brother, the guilt settling heavy in his chest. He still couldn’t believe Sirius had been locked up for twelve years, completely innocent. Worse still, he had escaped and dragged Scarlett into his suicidal mission to hunt down Peter Pettigrew.
Sirius and Scarlett had always been reckless—and this time, it was going to get them killed.
“Curious…” Lily’s voice echoed slightly, a little behind him. “They’re only looking for Sirius.”
“Do you think they know?” Regulus turned slightly to the side, avoiding her gaze. “That she’s alive?”
“They who?” Lily looked towards a scarecrow that waved at a pedestrian.
“The Ministry.” He glanced sideways at her.
“No idea,” Lily replied, and Regulus turned his face back to the posters of his brother. “I mean… the experiments…” She went on, stepping up beside him. “Who even knew about them? Because if Scarlett killed everyone involved, then… she’s dead.”
Regulus caught a flicker of movement in his peripheral vision. Whiskers, Padfoot and Prongs were sniffing around one of the empty alleyways in search of food.
“The prisoners thought she was dead… which makes sense, after vanishing for that long. But… the Ministry’s higher-ups… there’s no way to know for sure.”
Lily turned her face towards Hogwarts. The tops of the castle towers were visible from where they stood, the pale moonlight sliding over the dark rooftops.
“Do you think they’re friends?” she asked softly. “Harry and Reg?”
Regulus shrugged.
“I suppose… you’d have to be there to find out.”
Lily tapped her foot against the ground, impatient.
“Do you think they’re happy?”
“I hope so,” Regulus admitted quietly. “There’s been enough misery with the rest of us…”
Lily sniffed, gently, her piercing green eyes locked on Regulus.
“You love her,” she stated, pressing her lips into a thin line.
“Of course I love her. She’s my best friend,” Regulus replied, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
“I mean… you look at her like she’s some unreachable star,” Lily murmured, glancing over at Padfoot and Whiskers, who were playing innocently on the grass behind the shop.
Regulus allowed a flicker of vanity to pass across his face as he lifted his gaze to the sky. A sad smile tugged at his lips when an odd urge to cry welled up inside him. But a bitter coldness bubbled in the iron of his eyes, and he drew back into himself, wiping all trace of emotion from his expression.
“There was a time… when I thought she might fancy me,” Regulus murmured, his voice flat. “But Sirius was always the sun. And when the sun rises… the stars and the moon vanish.”
There was a fair bit of hurt in Regulus’s voice, and he made no effort to hide it. He simply stepped back, following Prongs, Padfoot and Whiskers down the cobbled path. The darkness of night was pushed back by the ghostly glow they emitted, their gazes lifting gradually towards the shining castle atop the hill: yellow, orange and red twinkled in the hundreds of windows, swallowing up the silvery moonlight.
“Never thought I’d see Hogwarts after I died,” Lily whispered, staring at the school with a nostalgic air.
Her gaze, however, didn’t stop on the stone structure. There was something more there, too.
Floating black dots. Whiskers, Padfoot and the ghosts raised their heads, staring at the black cloaks billowing in the icy October wind. They made their way towards the Forbidden Forest, the ominous presence of the Dementors making everything colder, more sorrowful. Whiskers advanced onto the grass under the meagre moonlight, pressing the knot of the Whomping Willow.
Padfoot and Prongs went in, followed by Regulus and Lily. The tunnel of dark stone reflected the lights of the ghosts, who crowded close as Padfoot and Whiskers stopped in front of a door. Scarlett grew larger, drawing her wand from her overcoat.
“Alohomora,” she whispered, and the lock clicked before she turned the handle and opened the door. Padfoot was the first to enter the Shrieking Shack, the stench of dust and mould flooding their nostrils.
James glanced around, the faint light seeping in through the cracks in the boarded-up windows. He headed straight down the corridor, following Scar and Padfoot up to the first floor, where there was quite a spacious suite. Some remnants of the Marauders still lingered there: claw marks on the walls from Moony and Padfoot, a battered statue Prongs used to sharpen his antlers, and a Persian rug Wormtail used to gnaw on.
Scarlett waved her wand so that the bed, once completely destroyed and thick with dust, gradually rebuilt itself. The filthy mattress and sheets transformed from brown to white, clean as though freshly laundered.
Regulus looked up at the ceiling—remarkably intact. He ran a hand across a dusty grand piano with its lid open, his fingers brushing the keys just as he noticed Scarlett watching him.
“Do you remember when… I asked you to play that song—the one you used to play when you met Sirius?” he asked Scarlett, watching those light blue eyes harden. “Do you remember what you said to me?”
She didn’t reply. Not just because she couldn’t, with Padfoot standing right there, but because Regulus genuinely wanted to know if she remembered. His heart was pounding in his chest, and his hands felt clammy. Scarlett curled her lip in disgust.
Regulus shook his head, staring at the dusty upholstered bench, trying to push away the memory of Scarlett playing * The Great Gig in the Sky * on the piano at Grimmauld Place, her face streaked with tears, her belly swollen, her golden hair cascading over her shoulders.
He turned his face away, feeling Lily and James’s eyes on him. There was so much they didn’t know—and if Regulus had his way, they never would. He was a monster—but it was better that his friends never found that out. Just like Scarlett never had, not until it was far too late.
“I’m going to see Harry…” Lily sighed, taking James’s hand and leaving them there.
Scarlett found a few candles and lit them upstairs—in the bedroom, the hallway, and the bathroom. The place was in a dreadful state, but nothing a few spells couldn’t fix. She was surprised the toilet still flushed.
“Stop it, Regulus,” Scarlett whispered, clenching her jaw as she looked up at him.
“Stop what?” He traced Scarlett’s jaw with the knuckles of his fingers, passing straight through her, pretending he could touch her.
Scarlett hissed under her breath, the sound of Padfoot’s footsteps echoing in the room. She swallowed hard, bowing her head as she took a deep breath.
“You know exactly what I’m talking about.” Scarlett pressed her lips together, as though trying to hold something back from deep within her chest.
Regulus smiled—a sly, bitter smile.
“It doesn’t matter… you know that, don’t you? Sirius is never going to forgive you. Reggie is mine.” Regulus placed both hands against the wall, either side of her, as if Scarlett couldn’t simply walk through him. “And to Sirius, you’ll always be the woman he loved—the one who had a child with the brother he’s always hated.”
Scarlett blinked, lifting her gaze to meet his, nostrils flared. She studied him with those sharp, tormented blue eyes. Regulus wet his lips, eyes locked with hers.
“You’re right…” Scarlett leaned her head back against the wall, holding his gaze. The candlelight cast flickering shadows across her pale skin. “But you’re dead, Regulus. And the only person I ever loved was Sirius. It was never you. My heart… was always his. Just like always, you tried to take something that belonged to your brother… and just like always, you failed.” She gave him a cutting smile.
Regulus leaned his face closer to Scarlett’s. She pressed her whole body against the wall, as if he could actually touch her, their noses nearly brushing, Red’s non-existent breath being inhaled by Scar.
“The truth doesn’t matter, Scarlett. To Sirius, you’ll always be the woman who betrayed him with his brother. You’ll always be mine.” He smiled as the ice in Scarlett’s eyes cracked. “He’ll never know the truth.”
“Sirius isn’t stupid. Sooner or later, he’ll figure it out…” Scarlett blinked, glancing towards the corridor, fearing Padfoot might be there, even though he clearly still lingered in the room. “Are you scared, Red?” She turned her gaze back to him, her eyes wild and heavy like a stormy sea.
“Why would I be scared!? I’m already dead.” Regulus let out a bitter laugh.
“Because if everything goes well, you’ll have a front-row seat to watch your brother be happy… and nothing you do will change that… not this time.” Scarlett drummed her fingers against the wood, amused by how Red’s expression shifted from composed to repulsed.
“I always wanted you to be happy.” Regulus swallowed hard, stepping back abruptly. “You came to me!”
“You could’ve let me go.” Scarlett didn’t bother hiding the remorse in her voice.
“Orfy would be dead.”
“But I’d be free. Me and Sirius…” She closed her eyes, as though trying to dream of a future that would never come to be. “We could’ve been happy.”
“No, you wouldn’t,” Regulus said, unsmiling. There was regret in his face, as if the fairytale had turned out far more twisted than even he had believed. “You two would’ve destroyed each other.”
“Not with Reg…”
“You think a baby fixes a relationship, Scar?!” Regulus shook his head. “Sirius raising him on his own was the best thing that could’ve happened. It gave him the chance to grow up… and it gave you the same. Something that never would’ve happened if you’d stayed together. You were always dependent on each other, in this… compulsive, obsessive… sick kind of way.”
“You don’t know what you’re talking about, Regulus,” she exhaled sharply.
“Oh, I know. I lived through your bloody drama for three whole years. I’ve known Sirius my entire life. And I know you better than I’d like.” Red tried to cup Scarlett’s face, only for his hand to pass right through her hollow cheek. “Scarius was always doomed to fall apart eventually. You just never saw it.”
“What do you want, Regulus?” Scarlett gasped, the candlelight crackling softly.
His response was a lazy smile as he adjusted the collar of his impeccably green frock coat.
“I’m going to see our son,” was all Regulus said before leaving her alone in that claustrophobic bathroom.
Scarlett dug her nails into her scalp, sliding down the cobweb-covered wall until she sat on the dusty floor. She used her wand to clean everything she could, her eyes lost in her own reflection in the porcelain sink. Regulus’s words hammered through the chambers of her mind. * You’ll always be the woman who betrayed him with his brother. *
She exhaled and pushed herself up, stepping into the bedroom still a little dizzy from the argument. Sirius had taken off his coat, his long-sleeved shirt and undershirt, scratching absently at his tattooed chest. Scarlett couldn’t make out the shapes of the designs clearly because he wouldn’t stay still, but she knew there were many.
“These bloody fleas are going to kill me…” he muttered, casting a protective charm on himself.
Scarlett couldn’t think of a reply. All she could focus on was the way the yellow candlelight danced across Sirius’s bare torso, glinting over his scars and emphasising his sharp bones. He glanced sideways at her, his face bathed in flickering light.
“Got anything for the itching in the bag?”
* My heart was always his* —her own voice echoed in her head. She needed to correct it: * her heart will always be his. * Scarlett gasped at the realisation, her pulse drumming in her ears.
“I think… I think so,” she faltered, opening the bag and pretending to search for what he’d asked, though all she could focus on was the resounding feeling numbing her senses and stirring soft memories deep in her mind. She pulled out a potion with dittany and handed it to him. “I can try to find something in Hogsmeade tomorrow…”
“Did you see how many of them there were?!” Sirius grabbed a cloth and soaked it in the potion, dabbing it across his skin. “Fuck, we need a plan.”
“We just need to get into the Gryffindor common room…” Scarlett shrugged, as though it were obvious.
“We can’t…” Sirius sighed, sitting on the bed. “What if he told the Ministry?”
“He?” Scarlett cleaned off an armchair and sat down, curling into herself.
“Remus. If he told them I’m an Animagus…” He wilted, pulling his clothes back on. “They’ll know.”
“I reckon if they knew… it’d be on the posters, wouldn’t it?” Scarlett crossed her arms, staring at the piano.
“I don’t know…” Sirius lowered his gaze, tossing his hair back over his shoulders. Then he jumped up on the bed, his eyes going wide as he immediately stared at the ceiling, lips trembling. “Dementor, Scarlett, Dementor…” He drew his wand, his hands trembling.
Scarlett looked up and around as well, but there was nothing. Sirius, however, was utterly convinced something was there, trying over and over again to cast his Patronus… all in vain. Scar stood and walked over to him, the floorboards creaking beneath her feet. Sirius sucked in a deep breath when she grabbed his wrist.
“They’re going to get me… I can’t be caught… I can’t go back to Azkaban…” Sirius stammered, panic darkening the grey of his irises, pumping desperation through his veins, making his pulse flutter.
Scarlett hissed softly, placing a finger to his lips. Sirius fell silent at once.
“Listen.” Scarlett stepped closer, tucking a handful of his black hair behind his ear. “It’s just the wind. That’s not a Dementor’s cold.” She rubbed both of Sirius’s hands with hers, the wind whispering faintly against the cracked glass panes of the house. “It’s just the wind.”
Sirius stared at her, his eyes brimming with tears, his whole body trembling. His breath was ragged, brushing against her chin. It was just the cold wind slipping through the gaps in the boards and the cracks in the walls of the Shrieking Shack.
“You need to sleep,” Scarlett went on, blowing warm air into Sirius’s hands. “Sleep. I’ll keep watch…”
Sirius let go of one hand, scratching at his collarbone, while the other traced her fingertips with his.
“We could sleep… I’ll turn into Padfoot and—”
“No… sleep like this. Padfoot’s crawling with fleas. You already got spotted by that Muggle because of them, and I don’t want it happening again… not now, not when we’re this close.” Scarlett nodded towards the bed.
Sirius accepted the decision silently, though there was a moment when their eyes met, and there was far more in his than he let on. He took off his shoes and sank into the bed with a soft, groaning sigh.
Silence. The candles flickered with the wind, and despite the stillness, Scarlett knew Sirius hadn’t fallen asleep.
“Scar…” he called after a few minutes.
Scarlett went to him, hugging herself against the cold. She raised her eyebrows, trying not to drown in the hypnotic silver of his eyes. Sirius brushed a strand of hair away from her face to get a better look at her.
“Could you…” He tensed his lips and pressed them together before continuing. “Stay here with me? I mean…” He scratched his beard, squinting slightly. “Padfoot and Whiskers have been curled up together these past nights… feels weird… sleeping alone…”
Scarlett might’ve laughed at him if she hadn’t been so shaken.
*The only person I ever loved was Sirius.*
She drew a deep breath, rubbing her cold, clammy fingers together.
“Of course.” She agreed, taking off her shoes and slipping under the blankets, sitting with her back against the headboard. She didn’t want to admit it, but it was so warm there that she silently thanked Sirius for the offer.
She ran her fingers through Sirius’s tangled hair, and he curled up in her lap, one hand resting on her thigh, his head settling on the other. He turned his face towards her abdomen, hiding it there like a child too shy to greet a stranger. They didn’t exchange a glance, not a single word.
Even so, Scarlett could feel the furious thud of Sirius’s heart pounding against her leg, matching the same chaotic rhythm as her own. She tilted her head back, staring at the wooden canopy of the bed. She hated it when hearts beat in resonance, when hers sped up every time he touched her, when skin brushed skin, when fingers clung to one another. She hated how permissive she was with Sirius—always had been. She always gave in to what he wanted.
She could have said no, could have made up an excuse, could have even let him sleep as Padfoot. But Scarlett was a traitor—more than that, she betrayed herself every time Sirius asked her for something. The answer was always yes. She’d said no to him far too many times before. She rubbed her temples in frustration, holding back tears as Sirius’s thumb stroked gently along her thigh.
Scarlett despised her own indulgence toward Sirius because she wanted him. Even knowing there was no future for them. No forgiveness. No spell strong enough to undo what she’d done to him.
She watched Sirius slowly sink into sleep, his warm breath fanning across her stomach, his thumb’s soft caress giving way to a full-hand twitch as his body began to relax.
Padfoot often woke startled, likely from some nightmare. Scarlett knew there was nothing that could truly keep them away. Still, she ran her fingers through his hair, hoping to chase them off, her touch soft and tender across the black locks she loved so deeply.
She closed her eyes slowly, guilt dancing freely in her heart like a thorned rose.
*We could’ve been happy.*
*No, you wouldn’t.*
Sirius tilted his head slightly upward, nestling half his face against her belly, the other half so calm it was hard to believe he was the most wanted man in the wizarding world.
Scarlett allowed herself a faint smile, gently brushing her finger across Sirius’s thick eyebrows. He barely stirred, sunk deep in sleep as though the woman who made him feel so safe wasn’t the same woman who’d also been the source of his unhappiness. The reason behind hundreds of nights he cried himself to sleep, behind the times he drank until he blacked out, behind how much he’d loathed raising a child that wasn’t even his.
It was suffocating to know just how much pain Scarlett had caused Sirius. Impossible not to cry. Impossible not to feel the weight of guilt. Regulus was right. Sirius would always hate her… and Scarlett would always love him. It was the natural order of things, like the sky being blue, the sun scorching, the moon bright.
With a sorrowful smile, Scarlett tried to find comfort in knowing Sirius would never forgive her.
.
.
.
Harry Potter was sleeping peacefully in the Gryffindor dormitory. Without his glasses, he looked like any other sleeping boy in that school… if not for the lightning bolt scar on his forehead. Or the perpetually messy hair. Or the wide jaw just like his father’s. The nose that resembled his mother’s.
Had he not been deep in sleep, he might have noticed the chill on his scar when the ghost of James Potter leaned over and kissed it. Or Lily’s arm wrapping around his waist as she settled behind him. James placed both hands on the chest of drawers, gazing down at his son and wife with pride, admiration, and a fierce sense of belonging blooming in his chest.
He had always loved seeing Lily sleeping with Harry in her arms, her red hair splayed across the white sheets. He had never imagined he’d witness that again—with a thirteen-year-old Harry.
“You’re perfect,” James whispered, the moonlight streaming through the window washing out his glow.
“Come on, lie down with us,” Lily smiled, patting the empty space on the other side of the bed.
James’s face lit up as he took off his glasses too, setting them next to Harry’s, and nestled into the bed as though his son could feel his presence there. Of course, he couldn’t—it was ridiculous—but James liked to believe he could. After all, dreaming never hurt anyone. He propped his elbow on the pillow and rested his head in his hand, staring at Harry and Lily with that daft grin growing ever wider.
“He looks so much like you…” Lily ran her fingers through Harry’s hair, ghosting over the unruly strands. “Even the hair…”
“But he’s got your eyes,” James winked at Lily, hugging Harry and intertwining his fingers with hers. “And your nose.”
“He’s practically your clone, James,” she rolled her eyes.
“Don’t be daft,” James chuckled. “He’s a hundred percent Jily. I bet he’s just like you in class… clever and cheeky.”
“I suppose there’s only one way to find out.” She nuzzled her face into the crook of their son’s neck—though no scent reached her, she liked to imagine he smelled floral, just like her. “Tomorrow, we’re following him all day.”
James wetted his lips in agreement, lying down on the bed as well.
“Goodnight, love,” he murmured with a yawn, even though ghosts didn’t sleep.
“Goodnight, love. Goodnight, my son.” She kissed the nape of Harry’s neck.
“Goodnight, son,” James whispered, pretending to pinch his nose.
.
.
.
Red never finished his final year at Hogwarts. He tried, of course, but between the missions the Dark Lord assigned him and the responsibility of protecting Scarlett, he simply ran out of time to study. Not that he needed it—he was an exemplary student, brilliant, one of the best in his year. And his role in Voldemort’s army would grant him far more advantages than Outstanding marks on his NEWTs.
And stepping away from Hogwarts meant stepping away from Pandora.
He never forgot the last time he saw her. Autumn had just arrived at Hogwarts, shaking yellowed leaves from the trees and carpeting the stone floor of the Clock Tower courtyard. Pan was seated on one of the stone benches, reading a spellbook, whispering softly the incantation she was practising. Regulus, meanwhile, leaned against the pillar behind her, watching her in profile. As if trying to etch her image into his memory, as if he didn’t want to forget her.
“You two really got married,” Pandora murmured, after a long silence.
Regulus pulled a cigarette from a metal case. After lighting it, he watched the smoke rise in front of his nose. The cold wind blew, lifting Pandora’s fair hair and brushing through Red’s dark strands.
“How is she?” She didn’t seem bothered by Regulus’s silence, though there was curiosity in her words.
“She’s fine.” Regulus took a long drag, resting his head against the cold stone. “She’s pregnant.”
Pandora looked at him at once, her brows rising in shock.
“What?” she whispered, her pale eyes filled with worry.
“Yeah… I’m going to be a father.” Red exhaled the smoke slowly, his voice lacking the enthusiasm one might expect.
“And are you ready to be a father?” Pandora’s voice turned hard, laced with judgement. Regulus gave a snort of contempt.
“I don’t think that’s something anyone’s really ready for.”
“Can I visit her?” Pandora ignored his reply.
Regulus swallowed thickly, staring up at the twilight sky.
“No… it’s not safe.” He spoke so quietly she barely heard him.
“So it’s true, then. You’re one of them.” Pandora snapped her book shut. “Is she with you of her own free will?”
“What kind of question is that, Malfoy?”
“Don’t lie to me, Regulus!” Pandora leaned on the backrest of the bench as she turned to face him. “Are you holding her hostage?”
Regulus blinked, feigning distraction as he released a puff of smoke.
“Of course not.”
“Why did you two get married… right after she left?! Very… convenient… I mean, now she’s pregnant…”
He didn’t like the implication in Pandora’s tone—not one bit.
“I did it to protect her—something Sirius never could,” he hissed, smacking the cigarette hard against the stone pillar until it went out. The thread of smoke curled between him and Pandora. “Pregnancies with women who bear the Signet are different. They progress faster than normal.”
Pandora remained still, those pale eyes of hers digging for the truth in him. But Regulus gave her nothing—not even a flicker of hesitation.
“Do you love her?” she asked at last, cutting through the silence after a long pause.
Regulus closed his eyes and nodded slowly, allowing himself a moment of honesty.
“She’s all I have,” he admitted, shoving his hands into the pockets of his Slytherin cloak. “All I’ve got left.”
Pandora furrowed her brow, lips parting as she drew breath. She looked genuinely surprised by his sincerity.
“You do realise it’s never going to be mutual, don’t you? She loves your brother. A marriage and a child won’t change that.”
Regulus barely noticed the way his jaw tightened, his fists clenching, trying to mask the fear beneath his expressionless exterior.
“It doesn’t matter. She’s my wife. The mother of my child.” He looked her dead in the eye, his tone dark. “What she feels, what Sirius feels… doesn’t matter.”
“Even after all these years, you still think the people you ‘love’ are yours to own, don’t you?” Pandora drew sarcastic air-quotes as she stood. “Why do you do this?”
Regulus felt his mouth go dry at the question. His gaze hardened.
“I’m just trying to protect her,” he said again, this time quieter. “I just…”
“No.” She twisted her lips in disgust. “You’re doing it for yourself, Regulus. Just like you always have.”
“That’s not true!” His control slipped for only a moment. Regulus cleared his throat, sighing through his nose. “You don’t know what you’re talking about!”
“I really hope she’s not suffering. That she’s not being held against her will…” Pandora stood and stepped calmly towards him, wand in hand. “Because… if I find out that Scarlett’s being kept by you and your rotten family… I’ll kill you.” She pressed the tip of her wand to Regulus’s throat, her bottom lip trembling. “I swear I’ll fucking kill you.”
Regulus lifted his chin. He knew Pandora wouldn’t hurt him—not really—but the threat still stung. Because deep down, she might be right. He wrinkled his nose and exhaled with a scoff full of contempt. Tears streamed down Pandora’s delicate cheeks, and Regulus took a step back.
It was the last time they ever saw each other.
Now, he looked at the stone bench as if she were still there. Seeking comfort in the silence of the courtyard, in the heaps of yellowing leaves drifting with the wind, pinned to the ground by the cold. As if he could still finish that conversation with Pandora.
A shadow passed him, and Regulus glanced sideways over his shoulder. His heart leapt in his chest as a head of platinum-blonde hair flicked across his peripheral vision and disappeared into the castle. His shoulders stiffened. He blinked several times, as if trying to ensure it wasn’t some sort of mirage.
He barely realised he was following the girl’s path, quickening his pace as he passed through the door and saw her—bathed in the glow of the tall candelabras lighting the entrance of Hogwarts: wavy, platinum-blonde hair cascaded down her back in thick waves. An aquiline nose, different from the upturned one he remembered. The eyes, however, were nearly identical.
Regulus gasped, freezing as though struck by a *Petrificus Totalus*.
“Pandora…” he whispered, even though the girl in front of him wore a Ravenclaw uniform. She was shorter, with an adorable fringe, but her pale skin was just like Pan’s—porcelain-like, her features so delicate she looked like a doll.
“Miss Lovegood, may I ask what you’re doing here at this hour?!” Professor Sprout tapped her on the shoulder, sounding concerned.
“I’m looking for my shoes!” she pointed at her bare feet, following the professor up the stairs.
“Oh, dear, these children…” Sprout shook her head, the conversation trailing off into distant murmurs.
Regulus didn’t take his eyes off her, too stunned to move. He barely noticed another figure approaching—a knight with an arrow lodged in his forehead.
“Good evening, sir…” The knight lifted his visor, squinting slightly at Regulus.
Red took a moment to realise the ghost was addressing him, still staring, dazed.
“What?” he whispered, eyes wide as he looked at the figure before him.
“Have you, by chance, seen Duncan Ashe around?” The knight rested one hand on the hilt of his sword. “A lad about this tall, Slytherin student…” He held his hand beside his body for scale.
Regulus simply shook his head, prompting a bored huff from the ghost.
“Right, thank you…” The knight floated off down the corridor leading to the Grand Staircase.
It took several seconds for Red to process everything that had just happened. Xenophilius and Pandora had had a daughter and…
The ghosts of Hogwarts could see and hear him.
.
.
.
“Scarlett, please…”
The dagger had grown slick in her fingers. Scarlett staggered backwards, landing flat on her arse. She dropped the weapon. Jim Avery had become a corpse drenched in blood—and so had she. The crimson filth clung to her robes, arms and legs. It was as though he’d given her a lovely, warm hug. She let herself fall flat on the floor, staring up at the black, dismal ceiling as every limb trembled.
Scarlett jolted awake, heart in her throat. Still groggy, her legs gave out beneath her, stumbling through the room as her hands groped for the nearest wall, her head spinning, her senses scrambled. She made it to the bathroom and vomited into the toilet, her entire body shaking. She stared down at her hands—white as death. No blood. Just a nightmare. Just sweat.
She wiped the tears from her face, rubbing her eyes, her breathing ragged, cold air rushing into her lungs and snapping her senses back into place. Scarlett placed a hand on the porcelain sink and wept quietly, no sound leaving her mouth as she held her breath.
She turned on the tap and waited for the muddy water to run clear before plunging her face into the basin, washing the sweat from her skin with both hands. There was no mirror, but if there had been, she was certain she’d look a fucking mess.
She took several deep breaths before returning to the corridor, eyeing the stub of the extinguished candle, daylight now piercing through the slats in the boarded-up windows. She went back to the bedroom, finding Sirius hugging his knees, staring into nothing.
They might be free. They might be in Hogwarts. But they'd never be free of what Azkaban had done to them. Scarlett rubbed her arms, pulling on her overcoat and fastening it slowly. Sirius remained in that catatonic state for a good while.
“It’s Halloween today,” he whispered, licking his chapped lips. “The day they…”
His voice faded.
Sirius curled inwards, digging his nails into his trousers as old and new, forgotten and remembered, seething and scalding emotions fought for dominance. So chaotic he forgot how to breathe, coughing violently when his lungs could no longer bear the lack of oxygen, his mind scrambling to drive away the image of James collapsed in the rubble, that lifeless gaze, the glimpse of Lily’s feet in Harry’s nursery.
He swallowed it all down in one painful gulp, finally drawing breath. Then he lowered his legs from the bed and leaned his face into Scarlett’s neck as she approached and pulled him into a hug. Sirius didn’t want hugs. Didn’t want comfort or sweet words.
Sirius wanted revenge—and he would have it, one way or another.
“Sirius… is my Invisibility Cloak with Regulus?” Scarlett’s voice murmured against his ear. He didn’t even move, as something bitter scorched the back of his throat, making him clear it.
“Probably,” he grunted, gently pushing her away. “I’m going hunting.”
There weren’t many creatures left in the Forbidden Forest due to the presence of the Dementors, but it was daytime, and Sirius needed some air. He transformed into Padfoot and tore through the corridor of the Shrieking Shack, slipping through the hole beneath the Whomping Willow in a mad dash before the tree could land a hit.
Padfoot bounded between the roots, sunlight refracting off his dark fur, the wind tugging at it as he ran as fast as his legs would carry him, the breath from his mouth turning into a fine mist. He circled the lake, trying to imagine Prongs running beside him, the sound of the stag’s hooves at his heels like old times, when they played tag in the forest. Little by little, the longing began to melt away in the sweet illusion that James was still there.
He spotted a massive stag on the other side of the clearing. The dog’s eyes widened, fur bristling as hundreds of memories surged through his mind. Padfoot barked, scaring the creature away, but the glimpse was enough. Enough to intoxicate him with the feeling that Prongs was there with him, even if it was a lie—he let himself be poisoned by the warm sensation of the world he used to know.
Panting and hungry, Padfoot began sniffing the ground for food, still pretending he wasn’t alone. Searching, in particular, for the scent of a rat.
A rat with a missing toe.
But all he found was a strange, squashed-faced cat with yellow eyes.
.
.
.
Whiskers slipped into Hogwarts Castle with great care. At that hour, the first students were beginning to wake, buzzing with excitement for Halloween. She skirted along the corridors beside groups of students heading for the Grand Staircase, ignoring the wave of nostalgia threatening to consume her. She sidestepped a few other cats along the way and waited for the stairs to align in front of her before climbing up alongside a group of Hufflepuff girls.
The conversations were always shallow—boys, how boring the teachers were, the never-ending homework. Whiskers leapt from one staircase to another, making her way down to the dungeons, where green-trimmed uniforms marked out the Slytherins. She wandered casually among the students, slipping through the common room entrance behind a large group as they exited, not needing to say the password.
Her heart pounding in her throat, Whiskers descended the stairs behind the mermaid statue, her gaze scanning the Slytherin common room hungrily. She didn’t have to look hard to find him: Regulus had just left the dormitories, his hair still tousled as if he’d only just woken up.
“Reggie!” a dark-skinned girl with black hair called, stretched out across the sofa. “We going to Hogsmeade?”
Whiskers didn’t take her eyes off him, as though the black-haired, grey-blue-eyed boy was the only thing in the world she could see. He was so grown. Regulus was taller than her now, slender, with the aristocratic Black nose—though it was freckled over.
“No… can’t. My uncle forbade me.” He didn’t look the least bit pleased.
She needed to focus on stealing the Invisibility Cloak, but… how was she supposed to do that with her son standing right there in front of her? It was the second time Scarlett had laid eyes on him, though it felt like the first. They were so much closer now—close enough for her to notice the light-grey flecks in his eyes, the way he flexed his jaw, that smile full of dimples.
Just like his father.
Her heart was beating so loudly she feared someone might hear it.
“He’s so big…” The voice made Whiskers bristle all over, catching sight of Red a little way behind, watching Reggie with a soft smile. “He’s the same age you were when I met you…”
“What? Why?” asked another girl, this one with white hair.
“Because of Sirius,” he said quietly.
Whiskers felt a sting of jealousy at the way he said Sirius’s name—with a kind of tenderness and affection she hadn’t expected him to have… but it made sense. It had been Sirius who raised him, after all. Scarlett had been imprisoned. The cat lowered her gaze to the polished shoes walking past her.
“It’s fine, I’ll stay here. You lot go ahead…”
The cat darted toward the boys’ dormitory, following the pleasant scent of Regulus to his room. Her son wore a cologne very similar to Sirius’s—sweet and fresh. She couldn’t quite name it, and the familiarity was another knife to the heart. Red watched her silently from the doorway, the iron in his eyes rusted.
Once certain they were alone, Scarlett carefully opened the trunk bearing her son’s initials: R.S.B. Her fingers brushed over the letters as she closed her eyes, letting the darkness of her lids pull and sharpen a memory.
She remembered the pain, the sweat that plastered her hair to her face, the metallic scent. Blood. She was covered in blood from the waist down, and Sirius’s hand had been the only solid thing she could cling to. Her vision was too blurred to focus on anything, the diffused lights blinding her completely.
Scarlett had been in pain for so long it had become familiar—so familiar that when it stopped, it felt wrong. And then came the cry, slicing through the muffled voices that rippled around her.
“He’s coming,” Red pulled her out of her trance. Instinctively, she stepped back and hid behind the canopy of the neighbouring bed, listening to her son’s footsteps on the greenish carpet that covered the floor.
Reggie threw himself onto the bed, exhaling sharply, kicking off his shoes in an irritated motion. He fell asleep just like that, his breathing growing heavier as he sank into Morpheus’s arms.
With a flick of her wand, Scarlett conjured a shimmering dust that glowed gently around her son, wrapping him in a dense sleep. She couldn’t risk him waking up, even if all she wanted in the world was to hold him. She stepped forward on silent feet, sitting gently on the edge of the bed, listening to the soft creak of the mattress.
From the doorway, Red smiled. The kind of smile he always fought against.
She dared to touch her son’s face—his pale, velvet-soft skin. Reggie’s nostrils flared in a brief spasm, and Scarlett quickly lifted her hand, letting it hover in the air, waiting for him to settle before reaching out again. She leaned down, nuzzling into his neck, breathing in the scent of his cologne mixed with his hair and robes.
Scarlett twirled a finger in a lock of black hair, just as soft as his father’s. She buried her nose in the short strands, pressing a kiss to the crown of Reggie’s head. Then she pulled the blanket from the foot of the bed and draped it carefully over him. With a heavy heart and reluctant hands, she stepped back, blinking hard to force away the tears threatening to spill.
She knelt once more at her son’s trunk, opening it delicately, searching through the clutter for the Invisibility Cloak. Naturally, he would’ve hidden it somewhere secure—and given what the cloak was, it had to be in a very specific place, somewhere he’d never lose it.
She found it tucked beside his meticulously folded socks. She smiled, pulling it over her shoulders as she looked at him one last time. Still unable to believe that this boy— this boy —was the child who had driven her to make every mistake that ruined her life. Her chest tightened at the thought of Marl, her forearm burning with the memory of that name.
She paused in the doorway, unable to tear her eyes from Reggie, as if afraid she might never see him again once she stepped outside. Regulus, beside her, was staring too; his smile had turned sorrowful.
He was the first to step away, glancing at Scarlett over his shoulder.
“Scar… let’s go,” Red said softly, nodding for her to follow.
Scarlett left the room—though every part of her ached to stay.
.
.
.
The corridors of Hogwarts were darker than she remembered. A place that had once been her home—where she’d grown close to her friends and deepened her love, where she had lived through some of the lowest points of her life—and the highest, too.
She hardly noticed her feet carrying her towards the Undercroft. She opened it with her wand in a mechanical motion, the ticking of the clock inside quickening the rhythm of her heart. Still dazed from seeing Regulus, Scarlett descended the stairs into the space that had remained unchanged since they left in that ill-fated year: 1978.
The year everything went wrong.
She didn’t recall the events exactly, but even the act of imagining was enough to send shivers down her spine. She ran her fingers along the dusty walls, stopping in front of the door to her and Sirius’s room, now corroded with time.
There was no need to light her wand; the daylight filtering through the ceiling grates, paired with Red’s soft glow, was enough to see by. She spotted the fallen photographs on the sideboard, a wistful smile touching her lips when her eyes landed on the inscription carved into the wall—done by her and Sirius what felt like a lifetime ago.
She could almost hear Lily’s laughter, James’s jokes, Peter’s whining, Remus’s tutting… Sirius’s affectionate words. She looked toward the clock across the room… her old pocket watch glinting in the scattered light. It had been left there long after the others, as it had barely a trace of dust.
She picked it up and stared at the image of Sirius sticking his tongue out at her. Tears, thick with nostalgia, welled in Scarlett’s eyes and ran down her cheeks. She closed the watch, her gaze sweeping across the room, getting lost in a time when that space had been alive—when her friends were still breathing, when the war hadn’t torn everything apart.
The world Scarlett and Sirius had known no longer existed. It had been blown away, scattered like autumn leaves in the wind, melted like winter snow beneath the sun. Buffeted like dandelions in summer, drowned by spring’s rain.
The future Scarlett had once dreamed of had been ripped away and shattered into a hundred fragments. What if she’d never left? Was Regulus right—would she and Sirius have fallen apart anyway? Or might they have made it work? Would Reg and Harry have had their families?
Scarlett wiped the tears from her face, her expression void of emotion. She and Sirius had made their choices, and nothing could change the last fifteen years. No matter how much she longed to…
She clutched the pocket watch tightly in her hand and pulled the Invisibility Cloak over herself once more.
Life was giving her a second chance.
She would not waste it.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 13: We can’t go back. We’ve got to live with the choices we made
Chapter Text
LXXXI
It was painful trying to grasp the memories swimming in his mind, like fish of varying shapes and colours. Some were missing fins, others their flippers, phalanges, eyes, gills. Sirius watched them, paralysed and afraid. His fingers didn’t dare touch the sacred water of all that remained: memories of days that would never return, tainted and crumbling from the deaths of James and Lily, the lash marks on Regulus, Scarlett abandoning and betraying him, the fire.
There were one or two untouched by the Dementors. Sirius, however, wasn’t brave enough to reach for them. He knew that if he did, he’d feel hope. And hope was the last thing he could allow himself to feel at that moment. He was certain that sooner or later, it would vanish, and no illusion could dull the harsh truth: Sirius Black was doomed to lose everyone he loved.
So, he preferred to watch the fish swimming in circles from a safe distance, without disturbing them. He curled up at the foot of the bed, his gaze drifting across the room in the Shrieking Shack: the cracked mantlepiece, the worn-down piano, the rug moth-eaten to tatters. He heard Scarlett’s footsteps downstairs, but didn’t so much as flinch.
He knew her well enough to recognise the pressure of her tiny feet against the floor, the rhythm of her steps, the way she would touch down with her heel first before the rest of her foot. The way she came up stairs was a bit chaotic—it always had been, ever since she lived in Godric’s Hollow.
He barely looked at her when she entered the room, her face tight with that expression she always wore when she was anxious. Sirius could feel Scarlett’s restlessness from right where he was.
"I got the cloak." She let the invisibility fabric float in front of Sirius’s face, as if that would get his attention. "And I nicked this..."
Sirius stared at the cinnamon roll she placed on his bent knee, eating another in silence. The icing sugar dusted across his black trousers. He picked it up, feeling the softness of the dough against his fingertips, the smell of cinnamon flooding his nose and echoing in his ears with a voice he knew well, but couldn’t quite place.
He closed his eyes.
James Potter smelled of cinnamon. His heart collapsed at the realisation, his hand crushing the pastry with all the strength he had, ruining it. One of the fish glanced back at him, and Sirius saw James with Harry in his arms, humming a tune. His hair was messy, his glasses nearly slipping off his face. James adjusted them with his pinky, a tic he’d had since he started wearing glasses in third year at Hogwarts.
Now, Sirius remembered that. James turned his face slightly towards him, a tired smile tugging at his thin lips.
"All right, Padfoot?" he asked, until his face wavered several times, dissolving into the sight of the ruined pastry in the palm of his hand. The scent of cinnamon made him dizzy.
"Sirius? Are you all right?" Scarlett was staring at him, worried. Sirius’s gaze was drawn to hers, his whole body shivering at her presence.
He still wasn’t used to Scarlett being there, by his side, after so many years apart. The memories she starred in leapt out of his fish tank, trying to claim space in Sirius’s mind, but he didn’t allow it. He and Scarlett always brought out the worst in each other. They became fire and storm, inferno and hurricane at the snap of a finger. And fear overtook him, bubbling through his veins like the air filling his lungs. James had always been braver than Sirius, the perfect Gryffindor. He was never afraid to love or be loved—things Sirius had always feared.
Perhaps it was his defence mechanism. Sirius couldn’t bear to lose anyone else. He’d lost too much already. Suffered too much. He flung the dough onto the rug, slapping his hand against his trousers, the longing flooding his chest. James and Lily were dead. In Azkaban, it had been easy to cope, because he was far from everything and everyone...
But now, back at Hogwarts, a place teeming with echoes of the past… it was so hard Sirius could barely remember to breathe.
"Let’s just get this over with," Sirius muttered, his gaze catching on a glint in his peripheral vision. A shard of glass. He reached for it, the sharp edges slicing into his skin. He shoved it into his pocket before getting up, healing the cuts with a non-verbal spell.
"We need to wait for the party..." She pulled a watch from her pocket. Golden, with a chain fastened to her trouser waistband. Something chimed in the back of Sirius’s mind, but he didn’t pay it much attention. "It’ll start in an hour."
Sirius simply returned to watching his memories swimming in his imaginary tank.
"I saw him… Reg." Scarlett went on, sitting down in the armchair. The words, however, seemed to slip from her. Her gaze returned to Sirius. "He..."
Her lips trembled. Sirius blinked slowly, Reggie’s joyful laugh echoing at the back of his neck. He still couldn’t believe the child he’d once cared for so dearly was already a fifteen-year-old boy. And Harry...
Sirius clenched his fists, tightening his jaw. Harry was an orphan because of him. He wanted to cry, though not a single tear stung his eyes. The mission was simple, painfully simple: enter Gryffindor’s common room and rip Peter’s life away with the same fury that James and Lily’s had been stolen.
He wouldn’t mind using the Killing Curse for that, though, at first, his deepest desire was to make Peter suffer. He’d used the Unforgivables before, and in the state of mind he was in… it would be far too easy.
"He reminds me of you," Scarlett added, the pain locked inside her threatening to overwhelm her.
Sirius gave a short sniff of a laugh, though his lips didn’t twitch. Of course Reggie looked like him—he was his brother’s son, after all. And he and Regulus had more in common than Sirius cared to admit.
"Sirius..." Scarlett called his name. He looked at her again. "Are you all right?"
It was bloody hard not to yell at her. That was the second time she’d asked him that, and Sirius desperately wanted to ignore her. Physically, he felt fine—aside from the bloody annoying flea bites, his colour was coming back, and he didn’t look half as wrecked anymore. Emotionally, though, he was in pieces.
"If you could go back in time... what would you have done differently?" he asked in return.
Scarlett raised her eyebrows, frowning. She ran her thumb along her sugar-coated lips, licking it as she thought.
"Everything." Her voice was barely more than a whisper. "Nothing." She seemed just as tortured by remorse as he was. "We... we can’t go back, Sirius. We’ve got to live with the choices we made."
That was what terrified him most: having to live with the mistakes he’d made. Trusting Peter Pettigrew. Being the cause of his best friends’ deaths, of his brother’s death, of Scarlett’s imprisonment, of Remus pulling away. He regretted every second of his past, and if he could, he’d have done everything differently. He’d have stopped Scarlett from leaving, talked to Remus, been the Secret Keeper himself. Bloody hell, he’d have died gladly for Voldemort if it meant James, Lily and Harry would’ve been safe.
If only Sirius had known his life would turn into this bloody tragedy...
It was as if the stars that once mapped his destiny had gone out, one by one, leaving only dense, vast emptiness. The void. The darkness. The ache, the longing, the gnawing sense that something was fundamentally wrong. In the end, his father had been right. He was a mistake, an aberration, unfit to belong among the pure-bloods or among his friends. A little creature who didn’t belong anywhere—except, perhaps, in the heart of a criminal.
When the time came, Sirius transformed into Padfoot. He and Whiskers made their way through the Forbidden Forest, entering a half-collapsed cave. He vaguely remembered the place, from the night he and Prongs stopped Moony from going after Whiskers and Mittens. They didn’t trust the castle’s secret passages—not when they couldn’t risk getting caught.
Scarlett lit the darkness with her wand, and Padfoot followed her through the rocks until they reached a staircase that led upwards. He was quite out of breath by the time they reached the top of the steps.
"The Map Chamber," Scarlett announced.
They were in a rotunda, illuminated by a graceful glow that seemed to emanate from the very air. The floor was covered by a vast, gleaming map of much of Scotland, blue lines weaving together to form the outline of Hogwarts Castle and the lands surrounding it. On the walls, enormous frames held empty portraits.
Sirius knew this place. He’d been there with Regulus, Scarlett, and James... on a day that felt like ages ago. His body shivered sharply with the memory of his injured brother, James looking worried, Scarlett in a panic. The day Dimitri and Sasha were with Remus.
He shook his head, trying to dispel the thoughts. He followed Scarlett up a spiral staircase, bluish lights glowing from the vaulted ceiling. Another flight of stairs made Sirius realise they were in one of Hogwarts’ towers, though he wasn’t sure which.
Scarlett handed him the invisibility cloak.
"I’m going ahead to see if anyone’s there, and I’ll wag my tail if the coast’s clear. We’ll go into Gryffindor’s common room together, but if I need to throw someone off, the password is Fortuna Major," Scarlett whispered to him.
"Fortuna Major," Sirius repeated, trying to burn it into his memory. "Fortuna Major, Fortuna Major, Fortuna Major..." He watched Scar transform into Whiskers and head down the corridor, signalling him to follow.
The route to the Grand Staircase went just like that. Hidden under the invisibility cloak, Sirius watched the staircases shift direction from time to time, waiting for Whiskers to give him the all-clear. She seemed slightly preoccupied with someone approaching from the main corridor, delaying her signal for Sirius to move forward.
It wasn’t strange to see a cat like her around—Hogwarts was full of them. Some belonged to students, others were strays. Except for Mrs Norris. She was a bloody menace, and as if summoned by his very thoughts, Filch’s snitch of a cat seemed to catch a scent in the corridor just behind, prompting Whiskers to dart toward her as if to distract her.
It was the chance Sirius needed to clumsily clamber onto the moving staircase, his body jolting as he mechanically leapt over the trick step. Laughter echoed from one of the floors below, sending a cascade of shivers down Sirius’s spine, as though he were that fifteen-year-old boy again, walking beside his friends on the way to their common room.
His body moved on its own. Sirius jumped from one staircase to another, his hand touching the cold railing like he used to when he was flanked by James, Peter, and Remus. The other clutched the invisibility cloak tightly.
Gryffindor Tower sat high above, so by the time he reached the top floor, his hands were trembling violently, slick with sweat as his body wavered with each step. It was impossible not to think about what he would do to Wormtail in that moment—his fingers brushing the shard of glass in his pocket, his dark gaze sweeping the lonely, silent corridor, the flames of the candelabras howling above him.
He let the invisibility cloak slip from his shoulders and fall away, the hood of the jacket beneath his overcoat enough to shadow his face. The nearby portraits seemed far too absorbed in themselves to notice him.
No one seemed to believe Sirius could breach Hogwarts, not with the Dementors guarding it. He exhaled at the realisation that they were all wrong—and he would, in a rather poetic fashion, kill Peter Pettigrew on the same night James and Lily had been murdered.
The Fat Lady stared at him, just as she had fifteen years ago. Sirius felt his head spin, like something was missing. He looked around, hoping for the ghostly traces of his friends to be there: James’s cheeky quips, Remus’s silent glances, Peter’s ridiculous remarks. Marlene’s harmonious laughter. The way Lily would roll her eyes. Mary offering a shy smile. Scarlett earning glares from her housemates.
A knot formed in his throat, his eyes blurring on the pink, flamboyant dress of the portrait’s figure. His fingers clenched around the shard of glass in his pocket. Ghosts of the past scrambled through his mind, echoing in his memory tank, disturbing his fish. The words slipped from his head before he could even speak them.
"Password?" the Fat Lady asked, arms crossed and face unimpressed.
Sirius swallowed hard. He looked over his shoulder, searching for Scarlett, but all he saw was the reflection of the orange flames licking the polished stone floor.
"For… For..." he stammered, eyes widening as his whole body tensed. There’d been a day when he and James had forgotten the password to get into the common room, back in their first year at Hogwarts.
The two of them had laughed so hard, racing down to the kitchens to steal food from the house-elves and taking the chance to roam the corridors the prefects didn’t patrol, getting to know even more of the place that would become their home far more than their actual homes ever had.
The happiness of the memory nearly shattered his murderous impulse. Sirius gasped, placing a hand over his chest, squeezing his eyes shut as he fought back tears.
"You're not getting in without the password..." the woman said, inspecting her nails with utter boredom.
Sirius clenched his jaw so hard his teeth ground together. Tension rippled through his shoulders, his heart leaping to his throat. James's laughter tangled with the memory of straddling Nancy, turning the key, the motorbike’s rumble in his legs, soaring through the sky toward Wormtail’s hideout.
The breathless dread he’d felt upon realising Peter wasn’t there—no struggle, no sign of a fight.
"Let me in," Sirius mumbled, locking eyes with her again.
"Only with the password..." She barely acknowledged him.
Sirius growled, like he was still in Padfoot’s skin.
"LET ME IN!" he bellowed, his voice crashing against the stone walls. In, in, in. He was so close he could taste Peter’s fear in the back of his throat.
The Fat Lady arched an eyebrow, leaning in as if trying to get a better look.
"Who are you?" she asked, tossing her curly hair over her shoulder.
"LET ME IN, YOU FUCKING BITCH!" Sirius roared, throwing his head back, letting the hood slip from his shoulders as he drew the shard of glass from his pocket. "NOW!"
Her expression changed in an instant—from curious to sheer, unfiltered terror.
"Merlin’s beard... Sirius Black..."
His fish tank cracked. Sirius could no longer feel the air entering his lungs; the only thing flooding and fuelling his body now was pure, volatile rage.
"LET ME IN, YOU FILTHY WHORE, OR I’LL TEAR YOU TO FUCKING SHREDS!" Sirius thrust the shard forward, gripping it so tightly it tore into his hand. "I don’t have time for this..." he muttered, voice breaking.
"You're Sirius Black!" the Fat Lady cried, pressing a hand to her mouth.
"LET ME IN!" Sirius howled with every ounce of breath left in him, slashing at the portrait in wild, uncoordinated swings, his chest burning, his eyes blind with tears. "Let me in... fuck... I need to... I need to..."
A psychotic laugh jolted Sirius out of his trance. Peeves was hovering nearby, thoroughly entertained by the Fat Lady fleeing from portrait to portrait in full-blown panic. It snapped Sirius back to reality—he saw what he’d done. He couldn’t be caught. Not now.
His legs moved of their own accord, and he bolted down the corridor, yanking the hood over his head as the portraits began whispering furiously to one another.
He barely remembered where he’d left the cloak. A hand yanked him into the stairway as it shifted from the Grand Staircase, and he instinctively pressed the glass to Scarlett’s neck, his eyes bulging in alarm. He hadn’t even realised he was still holding it—leaving a trail of blood behind him wherever he went.
"What are you doing?!" Scarlett sounded just as terrified as he was.
"The cloak... the cloak... the cloak..." Sirius stammered. "I... left it... behind..."
Scarlett darted back up the stairs, and Sirius stared at the blood dripping from his hand, the shard embedded in his palm, his pale reflection dancing in the dirty glass. He was so fucking pathetic. He wasn’t even good enough to avenge his friends... but he couldn’t get caught. And yet, he was so bloody close...
He heard Scarlett coming back, clumsily wiping up his blood from the floor, covering him with the cloak. On shaky legs, Sirius let her pull him back along the path they’d used to get in, the lights of the Map Chamber gleaming on his gaunt, ashen face, fading as he surrendered to a suffocating sob.
"Let me see..." She reached for him, but Sirius slapped her hand away.
"Leave me alone!" he snapped, stumbling back. "Just leave me the fuck alone..."
"Sirius..."
He didn’t listen to Scarlett. Not when his memory tank was threatening to drown him, the fish staring back with those grotesque, lifeless, bulging eyes—eyes that knew every wretched thing he’d done. He shifted into Padfoot, limping as he descended the spiral staircase, whimpering softly as he passed through the darkened cave, finally finding the light of the exit after running like a headless rat through the confusing corridors.
Even with his injured paw, Padfoot bolted back to the Shrieking Shack, breath ragged, the violent branches of the Whomping Willow crashing to the ground in thunderous warning. Padfoot was a large dog, an easy target. Still, he kept running like a blind, stupid bull chasing a red rag.
He felt the sting along his back as one of the branches whipped over him in a formless blur, the tree hauling the rest of its limbs up to crush him. That would be the end, then—Sirius Black, escaped from Azkaban, crushed to death by the Whomping Willow.
By sheer luck—or maybe pure misfortune—he wouldn’t die on the same day as James and Lily. The tree stilled, its branches shedding fragile, orange leaves onto Padfoot’s fur. Whiskers, panting, had pressed the knot in the roots.
Padfoot barely seemed to care, continuing down the tunnel. The pain ripping through his heart was far worse than the gashes on his back, which were bleeding freely. In the bedroom on the second floor, the dog turned in circles on the mouldy, tattered rug and collapsed, whimpering quietly.
The disordered sound of Scarlett’s footsteps climbing the stairs made his ears twitch.
"Sirius!" She sounded properly worried. If he were in his right mind, he might’ve laughed. "Why did you do that? Why did you go alone?"
He wanted to stay silent, but it was stronger than him. Sirius growled from the sharp pain searing through his back, lifting a blazing glare toward Scarlett.
"You... you said..."
"Have you gone completely mental?" she cut him off. "If you keep doing shit like this, you're going to get yourself killed!"
Sirius let out a bitter smile.
"It’s not... like anyone would give a fuck, anyway," he muttered through the pain. James and Lily were dead. Sirius was such a useless fuck he couldn’t even catch a rat.
Scarlett slowly sat beside him, as if trying to show she meant no harm. She reached out, gently touching his beard. Sirius gasped, her thumb catching his tears, the rage slowly, gradually dissolving in the presence of the woman who awakened all his demons.
"I’d care," she said.
And it was enough for Sirius’s bloodied hand to release the shard of glass and close around that pale, slender neck. Scarlett’s eyes widened. Sirius used his body weight to overpower her, rolling on top of her, his other hand gripping her chin, forcing her to look at him.
"Liar," he hissed through clenched teeth. "Fucking liar..."
Scarlett was crying too. Sirius wiped her tears with his wounded fingers. In a sudden, raw burst of clarity, he threw himself to the side, hands trembling, eyes losing focus on the cobwebbed ceiling. So many things were crashing around in his chest that he felt completely detached from reality, the little fish he often watched now splashing him, slapping him with their fins, biting at his fingertips.
It was too much. It was Halloween, and it was too much. He didn’t want to think, didn’t want to imagine, didn’t even want to remember. The glimpse of James lying on the floor that cursed night was enough to make him shift into Padfoot again, the pressure in his chest muffled slightly by the dog’s ignorance of human complexity. It wasn’t enough to relieve it fully, but at least he could breathe without feeling like his skull might explode…
Scarlett was hyperventilating, watching him with hesitation. She pulled her wand from her pocket, her trembling hand reaching for his injured paw.
"Let me..."
Padfoot growled, snapping at the air. So close to biting her delicate fingers. Reflexively, Scarlett flinched. He whimpered when the cold wind stung the open wounds on his back.
"Padfoot... you’re badly hurt..."
He merely turned his head to the side, frustration flooding every pore of his body. It felt like the moment he’d been thrown into Azkaban all over again—his mind crushed under the unbearable weight of loss. James’s lifeless eyes staring blankly, his glasses askew, his pupils empty. Harry’s wailing outside, the cold breeze of that sinister autumn night cutting through the silence.
Sirius licked his lips, the smell of his own blood thick in his nostrils. His heart was pounding so hard it threatened to crack his ribs, blood thundering in his ears. The cold had seeped into his bones. Tears soaked his cheeks.
If James were here… he’d know what to do. Not always, to be fair. But at least Sirius would have his friend’s lap to rest in, his tight embrace, his wise words.
His entire back was raw and flayed from the Whomping Willow’s branches, and still the deepest pain lay in his chest. The longing. The crushing realisation that the world made no sense without his best mate in it. He covered his eyes with his hands, smearing blood across his face, the metallic scent making him grimace.
Sirius didn’t know how long he cried, curled on that mouldy rug, trying to hide from the memories that swept through him, leaving a bitter taste in his mouth. The knowledge that there was nothing— nothing —he could do to bring James back. To relive the days when they’d just been carefree boys.
Before the war. Before… the prophecy.
He didn’t move when he heard Scarlett murmuring a healing spell over his back. The burning eased slowly. It wasn’t enough to quiet the pain gnawing at his chest, nor the cruel truth that James and Lily weren’t there because of him.
How cruel it was to live in a world without James! Without his jokes, his knowing glances, his habit of pushing his glasses up his nose with his pinky finger.
He felt his hair being gently brushed away from his face. Scarlett took his wrist with such tenderness he barely noticed she was healing the wound in his palm. Sirius glanced sideways at her—at that thin, Azkaban-twisted face, at those eyes that sent both shivers and butterflies through his gut.
Sirius Black was cursed. So selfish, cruel and broken that he couldn’t carry that curse alone. So he cursed Scarlett with his love, binding her in comfortable chains, in sweet promises, in obscene touches. He became everything she ever wanted… but a shackle is still a shackle. Sirius had chained Scarlett to him forever.
"It’s my fault, Scarlett… they died because of me..."
Scarlett wrapped her arms around him tightly, stealing all his thoughts and words. Sirius simply closed his eyes, sinking into the woman with the name of a colour, as if she might hold the answers to his questions. He knew she didn’t—Scarlett was more like the temptation hanging from the top of the apple tree. Beautiful on the outside, rotten to the core. Just like him.
Even so, Sirius allowed himself to be held by her once more, pressing his face to Scarlett’s chest, listening to her heartbeat, her heavy breathing, her fingers threading through his tangled hair. Letting himself drown in the non-existent scent of vanilla, letting the little golden fish swim around him, intoxicating him with a sensation that had neither form nor sound, but somehow dulled the edges of his suffering, bit by bit.
"It wasn’t your fault..." Scarlett murmured into his hair. "It never was, my love. Never was..."
My love.
Sirius almost laughed at the delusion in his own head. That Scarlett wasn’t real—none of it was. He was certain now that everything was just a trick of the mind, that he was still rotting in Azkaban. Maybe it was the effect of the Dementors’ Kiss.
Yes, exactly that. He was already dead. That’s why he felt so fucking miserable. He was just a ghost drifting through his own illusion. He was just...
He rested his face on Scarlett’s shoulder, burying his nose in the curve of her neck, her brown hair brushing against his cheeks. His other arm came up to wrap around her shoulders, letting the full weight of his body lean into hers. The truth was, Sirius was exhausted, and all he needed—desperately—was a place to rest.
"I didn’t... I couldn’t..." he whispered, eyes closing.
"It’s all right. We’ll have other chances..."
"He looks so much like him..." Sirius’s jaw tightened. "Harry. He looks so bloody much like James."
"He does," Scarlett replied, her voice so soft Sirius barely noticed she was crying too. "Sirius... they need us. Harry... Reg..."
Scarlett's voice grew more distant, dissonant, as Sirius sank deeper into the water with his little fish, letting his limbs relax and the weight of his body be carried by a foamy tide. Feeling, for some unfathomable reason... safe.
Sirius fell asleep.
And for the first time since he’d escaped Azkaban, he didn’t have nightmares.
.
.
.
Sirius was at Hogwarts.
It was all Regulus could think about.
He paced in circles across the common room, trying to imagine how Sirius had got in. Or when. Or where. Or…
Maybe Uncle Lupin had taken his cloak and not told him. No, that didn’t make sense—if he’d entered the Slytherin common room, Regulus would’ve known... or Snape would have... or maybe...
Regulus rubbed his eyes hard, ignoring the odd looks from the first and second years. It wasn’t long before the Hogsmeade trip ended, and more and more Slytherins returned to the common room—only making him more agitated.
He hated crowded spaces.
He didn’t have much of a choice when his friends practically dragged him to the Halloween party in the Great Hall. Regulus was so tormented he barely noticed Victoria’s suggestive smiles, or the stomach-ache potion Luana had bought to slip to the Weasley twins, or the dirty looks Victor was throwing around. No.
All Reg could do was glance around restlessly, like he was searching for someone, his brain burning trying to figure out how Sirius had entered the castle without being seen.
Unless…
He was in disguise. Regulus narrowed his eyes at his Quidditch mates, trying to spot anything off. Pucey spilled a bit of pumpkin juice down his cloak, Terry let out a very suspicious sneeze when the Bloody Baron passed them, and Miles didn’t laugh when Nearly Headless Nick reenacted (for the fiftieth time) his failed beheading.
Regulus bit the inside of his cheek, glancing across the hall, not even realising he was staring directly at Harry. The boy gave him a shy smile and waved. Frowning slightly, Reg waved back, the calm in his chest twisting into a sharp point that pierced straight through his heart.
What if Sirius really was after Harry?
No... he wouldn’t do that. He wouldn’t...
Sirius was a convicted murderer. Because of him, Harry’s parents were dead. A wave of suffocating guilt rose in his chest, and Regulus coughed, like he could force it out. Harry’s friends were staring too, and Luna gave him a solid thump on the back, thinking he was choking.
"You all right?" Victoria looked at him with a hint of worry.
"Fine..." Regulus avoided her gaze by pretending to sip his juice.
The party ended with a spectacle put on by the Hogwarts ghosts—one Regulus didn’t pay the slightest attention to. His head was pounding by then, and everyone began shuffling back to their common rooms, the anxiety hardening into fear.
Sirius wouldn’t kill Harry.
Would he?
Maybe Remus was right, and he wasn’t the man Reg thought he was.
"Reggie, can we talk?" Victoria gently tugged at the sleeve of his cloak, her cheeks slightly flushed.
Bloody hell, they hadn’t even talked about the kiss at the Boathouse yet. His eyes instinctively scanned the crowd of Slytherins for Luke Avery, but he was nowhere to be seen. Regulus opened and closed his mouth a few times.
"Can we... talk later?!" He ran a hand through his hair, flashing a nervous smile.
"What’s going on?" she asked, arms folded in that insistent way Regulus hated.
"Nothing," he replied quickly, trying to edge away from her, but she cornered him near the fireplace.
"What happened? Did Avery say something to you?" She raised an eyebrow, just as Snape’s voice called out from the background, ordering everyone off to bed.
"No." Regulus scoffed, like what she’d said was ridiculous. "It’s nothing..."
"Seriously, you don’t want to talk about what happened?!" she said, hands on her hips, clearly restless. "I know I messed up, and I wanted to say sorry for—"
"Look, Mimi, can we talk about this later?" Regulus glanced towards the entrance to the common room, where Aphelandra Pyke had just walked in. "I’ve... I’ve got too much on my mind right now..."
Victoria’s glare flicked between Regulus and Aphelandra, her lips slowly parting. She blinked several times, stunned.
"You don’t have to say anything, Regulus. I get it," she whispered, shoving him out of her way with a sharp, aggressive push.
"You get it?!" Regulus stared at her, confused. "What’s that supposed to mean?"
Victoria didn’t bother answering. She marched off toward the girls’ dormitory.
"Vic..." Regulus started to call after her, but was cut off by Snape.
"All students, back to the Great Hall. Move, now!" he barked, with the help of Gemma and Achilles, who were entering the dormitories to gather the Slytherins. "Rookwood, Avery, Pyke, Black. Make sure everyone heads to the Great Hall."
Regulus didn’t understand at first. But when he saw Gemma waving along a group of first-years still in their pyjamas, ushering them out of the common room, it clicked.
His heart began to hammer wildly. This could only mean one thing: they knew Sirius was in the castle. He fought the impulse to bolt down the corridors looking for him, patting a group of third-years on the shoulder as he ushered them along, weaving through the crowd until he caught up with Snape.
"Professor... what’s going on?!" Regulus didn’t bother hiding the tension in his voice.
Snape narrowed his eyes, pushing his greasy hair behind his ear.
"Just do as you’ve been told, Black," he said, remaining firmly in place. "Or is there something you know that I don’t?"
A small laugh escaped Regulus.
"Excuse me?" His expression hardened instantly.
"You weren’t made a prefect to question me, Black. Do as I said, understood?" Snape raised his eyebrows with a patronising smirk.
Regulus was the top student in his year, but he still didn’t understand why he’d been made a prefect. Snape seemed to like him only because his parents had been Death Eaters, but the favouritism ended there. There was always a guarded wariness in the professor’s posture that unsettled him.
"Yes, sir," Regulus replied as he caught sight of Victoria’s white mane among a group of students.
He quickened his pace to reach her. The girl, however, deliberately ignored him, pretending to comfort a younger student who couldn’t have been older than Harry.
"It’s all right, Sirius Black didn’t get in... it’s impossible, we’re protected by the Dementors..."
The direct mention of his uncle was enough to make the Slytherins turn and stare at Regulus, whispers trailing him with every step. It felt like it took an eternity to return to the Great Hall, the prefects remaining at the entrance while the large crowd of Slytherins joined the Hufflepuffs, Ravenclaws, and Gryffindors.
"The professors and I need to conduct a thorough search of the castle," the Headmaster announced once Professors McGonagall and Flitwick had waved the prefects inside, closing the heavy doors to the entrance hall behind them. "I’m afraid, for your own safety, you’ll all need to spend the night here. I want the prefects stationed at the exits to the entrance hall, and I’ll task the Head Boy and Girl with overseeing it. They are to alert me immediately if there’s any disturbance." Dumbledore turned to Percy Weasley, the Gryffindor Head Boy. "Send one of the ghosts to inform me."
Dumbledore paused as he reached the door and added:
"Ah, yes, you’ll be needing..."
With a casual flick of his wand, the long tables slid to the edges of the room, and with another tap, the floor was suddenly covered with hundreds of fluffy, purple sleeping bags.
"Sleep well," he said, closing the door behind him as he left.
Regulus’s head was spinning. He’d been right. Sirius was in the castle. He had to leave the Great Hall, had to go after him...
"Everyone into a sleeping bag!" Weasley shouted. "Come on, no more chatting! Lights out in ten minutes!"
Sirius was in Hogwarts.
Regulus took a hurried step toward the exit, but stopped dead as he came face to face with Professor McGonagall.
"Mr Black..." she said, peering at him sternly through those square spectacles. "Is there a problem?"
"No... nothing, Professor." Regulus forced his best bored expression, pretending to choose one of the remaining sleeping bags, all the while watching Luana squabble with who was probably Fred Weasley over one of them.
"I saw it first!" he protested, tugging hard.
"I grabbed it first!" Luana retorted, wrapping herself in it on purpose just to make him let go.
"Weasley!" Regulus called out, holding a sleeping bag. Fred glanced at him sideways. "Leave her alone!" He threw the bag at the Gryffindor with more force than intended, making him stumble.
"Your white knight’s here, Teixeira!" Fred sneered, reaching again for her sleeping bag. Luana pulled back, clutching it like it was a priceless relic.
"Go suck a troll dick, Weasley!" she shot him the finger.
A group of Ravenclaws hissed at them to shut up.
"Is it true the Fat Lady’s portrait was all slashed up?!" Victoria asked as she approached, carefully stepping over someone on the floor.
Fred scratched his nose crudely and flicked a booger in the direction of a group of Slytherins.
"Yeah, looks like Black tried to break in there..."
Regulus’s blood turned to ice. Why had Sirius tried to get into the Gryffindor common room? Was he after Harry? Did... did his uncle think he’d been sorted into Gryffindor? Why do it on Halloween, of all days, when the common rooms were likely empty?
"The Gryffindor common room?!" Victoria pressed, her clear interest making Reggie even more exasperated.
"According to Peeves..." Fred shrugged, scanning the crowd for his mates.
"What do you mean, according to Peeves ?" Luana chimed in, clearly intrigued, her silver necklaces catching the flickering light of the floating candles.
"Black, Rookwood, Teixeira, Fred!" Percy barked with authority. "Why aren’t you all in your sleeping bags yet?!"
"Because I’m looking for George..." Fred began to explain.
"The lights are going out now!" Percy cut in.
All the candles extinguished at once, plunging them into darkness. The only illumination came from the silvery ghosts floating overhead, deep in conversation with the other prefects, and from the enchanted ceiling reflecting the star-strewn sky above.
"Oh, for fuck’s sake!" Fred muttered, resigning himself to lie down beside Luana and Regulus.
"What’s wrong? Gonna cry ‘cause your brother’s not here to cuddle with you?" Lua teased.
"Aren’t you lot meant to be patrolling the exits or something?" he muttered, avoiding her as he flopped face down into his sleeping bag. "Doing your boring prefect duties?"
"Well, yes, but your brother told us to lie down..." Victoria’s white hair glowed against the purple fabric.
"And you’re just gonna do whatever that prat tells you to?!" Fred scoffed.
"What exactly happened, Weasley?" Regulus pressed, lying on his side now.
He heard Fred take a deep breath.
"No one got into the Gryffindor common room ‘cause your mad uncle slashed up the Fat Lady’s portrait… and then Peeves turned up saying it was him..." the boy replied, sounding tired.
Regulus’s heart was pounding so hard he could barely think. Sirius was in the castle. He jumped to his feet, accidentally stepping on Fred’s hand.
"Ow!" the Gryffindor yelped.
"Where are you going?" Luana whispered.
"Bathroom," Regulus lied, hurrying off while trying not to step on anyone. It was a bit tricky in the dark, but the girls quickly forgave any misstep the moment they realised the owner of the glossy, ridiculously expensive Trapobelo shoes was none other than Regulus Black.
What he didn’t expect was Victoria following him. They both stopped in front of the doors to the entrance hall, coming face to face with Percy Weasley and the Ravenclaw prefect, Penelope Clearwater.
"I need the loo," Regulus said urgently.
"You can do your business by the stairs at the far end of the hall…" Percy pointed towards a dark, nearly invisible corner.
Regulus looked where he pointed, then back at the prefect, raising an eyebrow.
"I’m not pissing in a room full of people!" he snapped, fists clenched. The only light between them came from the Fat Friar, floating a few metres above.
"No one’s leaving this hall until Dumbledore returns," Percy said firmly, clearly enjoying the look of outrage on Reggie’s face. He picked up a chamber pot left in the corner and held it out. "You can take the stairs if you want a bit more privacy..."
Huffing in frustration, Regulus snatched the chamber pot with a sharp motion and stomped toward a quieter spot, not bothering to apologise as he stepped on a few hands and toes. Victoria followed him again.
"Are you insane, Reg?!" she asked, keeping her voice low.
Regulus slammed the chamber pot onto the floor, making as much noise as he could.
"Insane? He’s here, Victoria! I need to talk to him!" he retorted, his hands fumbling at his waistband for the buckle of his belt.
"With all the professors combing the castle? It’s better if he’s not here!" she scolded, leaning against the far wall.
"None of this makes sense... none of it..." Regulus let out a breath, rubbing his forehead with one hand as he tried to focus on relieving his bladder.
The sound of him hitting the chamber pot drowned out the murmurs in the hall.
"Are you actually pissing?!" she asked, surprised.
"Obviously. What, you thought I was lying?"
"I did."
"Well… I was." Regulus finished, gave the obligatory shake, and zipped up. "But then I needed to go anyway." He cast Evanesco and Scourgify to clean the pot.
"That’s disgusting," Victoria muttered in disgust. "You’re not even going to wash your hands?"
"Where, exactly?" He glanced around, shrugging.
"Umm… dunno." She let out a soft giggle.
And in the midst of all the vertiginous chaos swirling around him, that was enough—for butterflies to stir in Reggie’s stomach.
"Mimi..."
"Reg..." they both said at the same time.
The silence that followed was mutual too.
"Er, I..."
A nearby group hissed at them to shut up. Regulus ran a hand through his hair, frustrated and tense. Victoria slipped her fingers around his wrist, gently tugging him back towards their spot. Regulus didn’t want the touch to stop—his hand reached for hers as they settled beside Luana and Fred. Victoria, however, pulled away on instinct.
"Don’t come at me with your pissy hand!" she whispered through a soft giggle, curling into her sleeping bag.
For a moment, Regulus allowed himself to just be a lovesick boy, pulling the covers up as he reached for Victoria’s hand beside him, hooking his pinky around hers.
"You pee?" Lua whispered, shifting in her bag.
"Mm-hm," Regulus grunted in confirmation, daring to slide his palm into Victoria’s, brushing his thumb in a soft caress over her skin.
"Is it true you snaked Avery?" Fred turned towards him, though it was too dark for Reg to see his face.
"What?" Regulus didn’t even try to hide the surprise in his voice.
"Heard a few rumours... that you snaked him, Rookwood decked him, then decked you and stormed off... but I also heard you’re just as mental as your uncle and you’re helping him sneak around the castle..."
Regulus inhaled sharply. He knew Fred Weasley not just because they were in the same year, but because they were Quidditch rivals. Both beaters for their respective houses, though they’d never actually spoken properly before.
"What’s your obsession with Reggie, Weasley?" Luana interjected in a low voice.
"I wasn’t talking to you, Teixeira." He gave an exaggerated sigh. "You Slytherins are weird—bit hard to tell which one’s the real psycho when you’re all bunched up together... but alone..."
"I’m not helping him," Regulus said, as though the suggestion was beyond ridiculous. "He’s a murderer, Weasley. You really think I’d help him kill more people?!"
He heard Fred shift in his sleeping bag.
"Dunno. Word is you said you would..." he replied offhandedly.
Regulus let out an irritated breath, tightening his hold on Victoria’s hand.
"It was a joke!" he snapped. "I don’t even remember what my uncle was like."
He was grateful for the darkness. Regulus feared someone might’ve seen the lie all over his face.
"So... you really did snake Avery?" Fred pressed, still curious.
"Yes, Weasley! Happy now?" It was Victoria who answered, louder than she should have, triggering a cascade of annoyed hissing from all sides.
"Good to know. Avery’s a bloody tosser. Grassed me up to McGonagall ‘cause I used permanent sticking charm on Selwyn’s shoe before Transfiguration," Fred said with a self-satisfied laugh, like he’d just shared a brilliant prank.
"If you think we’re going to slag off our own Housemates, you’re sorely mistaken, Weasley," Luana replied, her voice laced with scorn. "But yes, Avery is pathetic."
"Who invited you to the conversation, Teixeira?"
"You’re the one in the wrong place!"
"For Merlin’s balls, will you two get a bloody room?" Regulus muttered, rolling over toward Victoria.
Fred let out a snide cackle.
"I don’t shag people who owe me money," Luana snapped, clearly fed up.
"You don’t? Brilliant. Consider the debt permanently unpaid!" Fred shot back without missing a beat.
"If you don’t pay me, I’ll go after your family!"
"Didn’t know you were a bloody loan shark..." Fred nudged Luana, who gave a startled squeak.
"Oi, Weasley! Don’t touch me, you... indigent rat!"
"Will you lot just shut the fuck up?!" Victoria raised her voice, exhaling sharply. "Bloody hell."
The silence that followed didn’t last long.
"...Did you just fart?" Regulus whispered, pulling the blanket over his nose.
"I did." Fred confirmed without a shred of shame.
"Oh, for fuck’s sake..." Luana groaned, covering her face too.
"Pepper Imps always mess up my stomach," Fred said, patting his belly. "Can you hear the gases working their magic?"
Regulus slapped a hand over his mouth and started laughing. Not just out of disbelief at the situation. He truly hadn’t expected to be laughing at Fred Weasley’s flatulence on the same night Sirius had broken into Hogwarts, but things had become so absurd he could barely process them.
The laughter soon dissolved into silent tears. Victoria’s hands found his face, and she slowly inched closer, until their bodies were so near that their warmth blended together. She slipped under his blanket, and Reg, heart pounding against his ribs, remained still. He felt her white hair curling against his arm, her head resting on his shoulder, her fingers gently wiping away his tears.
Taking advantage of the anonymity the darkness granted, he turned his face towards hers, pressing his nose softly to her forehead. She was warm—not the kind of heat that flares up on a chaotic night like this, but the kind that quiets the blood and hushes the thoughts that wouldn’t stop screaming in his mind.
But Victoria wasn’t enough to fill the hollow in his chest. Nothing would be.
It was older than her—a need, an absence, a little ache that had always lingered in him and flared every time he saw a child with their parents.
Of course he was grateful to his aunt and uncle for raising him, but... it wasn’t the same.
It never would be.
He sighed, drifting out of his contemplative chaos. The heavy breathing of Luana as she drifted to sleep, and Fred’s obnoxiously loud snoring, filled the space.
"What do you want to say to him?" Victoria murmured against his ear.
Regulus’s whole body stiffened, his arm tensing. He ran his fingers through her snow-white hair, breathing in the scent of camellias. He clicked his tongue, trying to weave a lie, but gave up.
"I don’t know," Reg admitted, moistening his lips. "About him… about my mum… my dad…" he muttered, focusing on the tingling sensation her thumb left on his cheek. "I just… I want to understand. Why he did what he did..."
Victoria hummed in response, shifting to settle more comfortably on his arm, her hand tentatively resting on his chest. Reg gasped softly, the warmth of her palm radiating a calm he hadn’t felt in ages. He waited for something more from her, something clear—but instead, her breathing slowed, deepened, and he realised she’d fallen asleep.
Regulus didn’t sleep.
The next morning, Dumbledore announced that he had found a replacement for the Fat Lady. Reg couldn’t have cared less. He shoved as much food into his mouth as possible and left the Great Hall before even finishing his last bite, acutely aware of the professors' suspicious eyes following him. He was sure Lupin would want a word after last night, but with the full moon approaching, that conversation would have to wait—especially amid the rumours and whispers about Sirius Black’s break-in.
Regulus searched every corridor he could, hunting for the only person who might have the answers he needed. He climbed the stairs of the Clock Tower, already breathless when he was suddenly grabbed by the arms—Fred and George Weasley had been lurking on one of the landings.
"Morning, Black!" Fred grinned mischievously.
"Where’s the fire?" George raised an eyebrow.
Reg took a very, very deep breath once they let go, finding himself trapped between them and the stone wall.
"You’re not helping your uncle break into the castle, are you?" George went on, placing his hands on his hips like some self-styled investigator.
"Where were you going, then?" Fred narrowed his eyes.
"Oh, for fuck’s sake, I’m not helping him!" Regulus snapped, fists clenched. "Bloody hell… I said that yesterday!"
"I don’t believe you!" Fred brushed a hand down Reg’s robes, pretending to straighten them.
"Slytherins lie," George added smoothly.
"Give us one good reason not to lock you in the upstairs cupboard..." Fred challenged, arms folded across his puffed-out chest, expression deadly serious.
Regulus filled his lungs to reply, only to be interrupted when Peeves appeared behind the twins with a devilish grin plastered across his face. Before Regulus could warn them, the poltergeist flung a large sheet over Fred and George, causing them to jump in alarm.
Then, objects scattered across the floor began flying toward them, pelting Fred and George, who couldn’t see a thing through the sheet. Taking advantage of the chaos, Regulus bolted. A bell smacked him right in the ribs, and he ducked just in time as a brick zipped past his head. Fred and George shouted at Peeves, whose only response was a theatrical cackle before he soared off in the same direction as Reg, leaving behind a trail of eerie, echoing laughter.
"Sirius Black is bad, bow-wow-wow…" Peeves sang mockingly, barking like a dog before vanishing down the corridor.
Regulus stood frozen, trying to process Peeves’s words. He didn’t get the chance to ask what had happened, and even if he had, expecting a straight answer from Peeves was like expecting manners from a Blast-Ended Skrewt. Still, the poltergeist had given him something far more valuable.
He pulled the photos from his cloak pocket, holding one in each hand. Scarlett kissing Sirius on the beach, Scarlett hugging Padfoot in the very same moment.
"Bad, bow-wow-wow…" Reg echoed, his eyes slowly widening.
Of course no one had noticed a man wandering around the castle—because there hadn’t been one.
How hadn’t he seen it before? He wanted to slap himself for taking so long to realise.
Sirius Black was Padfoot.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 14: I missed you so much
Summary:
When memory fails, music remembers.
Chapter Text
LXXXII
The school talked of nothing but Sirius Black for the next few days. The theories about how he had entered the castle became wilder and wilder; but none seemed quite as convincing as Achilles Selwyn’s, who told everyone—shamelessly—that Regulus had helped his uncle.
Of course, it was a lie. Not that Reg would’ve minded; if he knew what Sirius was up to at Hogwarts, he’d obviously have helped him. But then again, if Sirius was there because of Harry… what would he want with Harry?
Regulus sighed. His godfather wouldn’t be capable of killing the other godson. Would he?
Naturally, after everything that had happened, Regulus was being closely watched. Not only did Gemma Farley and Aphelandra Pyke seem to follow him wherever he went, but his Uncle Lupin now treated him as if he were made of glass. As if the very mention of Sirius hurt him.
“Hey! Those frisbees are banned!” Victoria scolded a Hufflepuff first-year, snatching the object mid-air with surprising ease. The disc growled at her. “You could hurt someone with that!”
While she argued with the Hufflepuff, Luana joined the group; her black hair was tied up in a high bun and her neck shimmered with layers of silver chains. As soon as the boy vanished with his mates, muttering about nosy Slytherins, Lua swiped the frisbee from Victoria’s hand.
“I’ve always wanted one of these!” She tossed it into the air, humming with delight as the toy growled and tried to bite a portrait.
“Luana!” Victoria snatched it back, tucking it under her arm. “How old are you? Eleven?!”
“Alright, alright, Miss Goody Two-Shoes…” Lua raised her hands in mock surrender. “I was just… assessing the danger… of the product…” She gave a mischievous grin and snatched the frisbee again with a sly little flick.
“Fine, but you’d better give it back!” Victoria huffed, rolling her eyes.
Regulus remained detached from their chatter about a prank the Weasley twins had pulled on a Ravenclaw boy. He adjusted his satchel and sidestepped a few girls who eyed him warily, halting when Terence and Miles joined the group.
“Slytherin’s not playing Gryffindor this weekend anymore…” Miles commented, leaning against the wooden panelling. “Malfoy still hasn’t recovered.”
Regulus exhaled, hissing with disdain.
“Still not better? What a weak little tosser,” Terry scoffed, munching on a handful of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans. “Hope he doesn’t recover in time for the next one—I’d love to take his spot…”
“As if that’d ever happen,” Miles sneered, pinching a bean from Terry’s box. “But don’t feel bad—without Regulus on the team, you’d get a Bludger to the face riding that ancient broom of yours.”
“Ugh, I don’t need a top-of-the-range broom to play well!” Terry flipped him off, shielding his sweets defensively.
Their banter carried on until Luana launched the frisbee straight at the Weasley twins as they passed down the corridor—smacking Fred right in the head. The disc bit into his hair, and he let out an impressively high-pitched yelp.
The Slytherins turned to look immediately. Fred yanked the frisbee free, only to find a tuft of red hair caught between its teeth.
“Reg, look what you’ve done!” Luana slapped a hand over her mouth.
“What?” Regulus stared at her, then at the twins. “That wasn’t me…”
“You’re dead, Black!” George jabbed a finger in his direction. “Proper dead!”
“It was Luana!” he protested, but it was already too late. Fred cast a jinx at him, only for Victoria to block it just in time with a Shield Charm.
“Oi, put the wand away!” she barked, and in the next instant the Slytherins all had their wands out. The twins smirked arrogantly. Fred tossed the frisbee to the floor, and George stomped on it.
“You lot are going to regret this,” they said in unison, Fred clutching the sore patch on his head where his hair had been torn out. “You especially, Teixeira.”
Luana responded by mimicking Fred’s startled shriek, then burst into wicked laughter.
“What is wrong with you?!” Regulus snapped at Luana, his fingers gripping her shoulder with more force than he meant. “Can’t you go one bloody second without causing trouble?”
“Oh, come off it, it was hilarious!” she boasted, stretching her arms and glancing around at the other Slytherins for validation.
“The last people I wanted to piss off were the Weasleys… they’re mental. They’ll make our lives hell,” Terry muttered, clutching his Arithmancy book to his chest.
“Brace yourself for retaliation…” Victoria murmured to Reggie, her lips close to his ear.
Regulus swallowed hard.
“They owe me! I’ll make their lives hell till they pay me back!” Lua declared, arms crossed with righteous fury.
They made their way to Transfiguration. Regulus paid no attention to half of McGonagall’s instructions, his mind racing as he tried to figure out how Sirius had entered the castle in Padfoot form. He considered asking the portraits near the entrances, but he knew that would look far too suspicious. He needed to act as naturally as possible.
All thoughts were sucked out of his mind the moment his gaze landed on Victoria, whose focus was entirely on turning her hedgehog into a pin-filled haystack.
They hadn’t talked about what had happened. To be honest, Regulus had no idea what to say. He liked her—of course he did—but at the same time, he was far too caught up in Sirius’s escape to even begin untangling what he felt. He was also afraid, that silly fear of ruining the friendship if things went wrong between them.
Reggie sighed. He’d dreamed for years about kissing Victoria and now that it had actually happened, he felt utterly lost. He really wanted to ask Remus for advice, but his uncle seemed so consumed with worry over Sirius that Reg didn’t want to bother him.
The bell rang soon enough, and as they stepped out of the classroom, a bomb filled with shocking pink ink exploded right over Regulus, splattering everyone behind him—Victoria, Lua, Miles, Pucey, Victor, and Terence.
Regulus straightened up, eyes wide as he took in his uniform and now-vividly-pink hair. The colour was so bright it looked practically fluorescent, and passing students didn’t even try to hold in their laughter. He only glanced sideways at Lua, who let out a sheepish chuckle.
“If they want war, they’ll have it!” she declared, as if she’d just enlisted herself in the army.
“I can’t believe you dragged us into your little childish feud with the Weasleys,” Victoria muttered, gently wiping Regulus’s face with a handkerchief.
“Reggie looks like a Puffskein…” Miles joked, patting his ink-covered shoulder.
“Let’s hope it’s not permanent,” Pucey grumbled, wiping droplets off his cloak.
“So, it’s true? You two are dating?” Victor asked flatly.
Victoria licked her lips, staring at her brother in disbelief.
“Well, I suppose we…” she murmured, but trailed off mid-sentence.
“Weren’t you snogging Diggory?” Victor arched an eyebrow, his smile turning cruel.
Regulus felt his stomach twist, stepping away from Victoria on instinct. His gaze dropped to the floor, ink dripping from his hair.
“No, it was… it was just a kiss,” she said with an awkward smile, grabbing Reggie’s cloak. But he pulled away from her in a sudden motion.
“You kissed Cedric?!” Lua frowned. “And didn’t tell me?!”
“We sort of… it wasn’t… it wasn’t serious…” she stammered.
Reggie stepped back, stunned as if he’d been slapped. He didn’t know what to say, let alone what to think. Victoria had kissed Cedric? When? Where? It was yet another thought to stew among the many already crammed into his head, fuelling the erratic pounding of his heart and the tremble in his hands.
“It was before… before us…” she tried to explain, but Regulus silenced her with a raised hand.
“I don’t want to know, Victoria,” Regulus hissed, quickening his pace down the corridor, leaving a trail of bright pink behind him.
“Seriously? You’re going to be mad about this? We weren’t even together!” she raised her voice, and the chatter in the corridor died as students turned to stare. “At least he took the initiative and kissed me! Something you never had the guts to do!”
Regulus stopped dead in his tracks at her words, though he didn’t turn to look at her. He liked Victoria—he really did—but in that moment, the feeling felt like a blade shoved deep into his chest. She was right—he knew she was right—but that didn’t stop the rising tide of insecurity from bubbling inside him, turning his distress into tears. He couldn’t be seen crying, so he kept moving, hurrying down the stairs and into the boys’ bathroom on the second floor, not caring how ridiculous he looked.
He didn’t really know what he was doing, his fingers tingling with anxiety as he turned on the tap and shoved his head under the cold water, trying to wash the dye from his hair and face—letting the tears flow freely with it.
He heard a small moan coming from one of the stalls, but couldn’t be bothered to check where it came from.
“Slipped in the puddle of ink, did you?” Myrtle’s voice dripped with mockery, her ghostly reflection peering at Regulus through the mirror. “Poor thing! Are you crying?”
“No!” Regulus snapped, lips drawn into a tight line as he pulled his head from the sink, thankful the water disguised his tears. “Go haunt someone else, Myrtle.” He rubbed his face with both hands, trying to scrub away the last of the pigment from his temples.
“What happened, Reggie?” she floated behind him, pouting. “Who did this to you?” She pretended to stroke his hair.
Regulus flinched away from her touch. He didn’t have time for this—he needed to figure out how Sirius had got in… but it was so hard to think clearly when all he wanted to do was cry. Not just because of the whole Victoria and Cedric revelation, but because of everything. Everything weighing on him.
He took a deep breath, scrubbing his face hard. He didn’t want to let any of it spill out. If he did, he’d let out far more than he could handle. Better to fold it all up and push it deep, deep down.
“…Diggory’s the Hufflepuff captain, according to Oliver…” Harry fell silent the moment he saw Regulus. His mate Weasley let out a snort, then clapped a hand over his mouth.
The three of them stood in an awkward silence.
“Hi, Harry. Hi, Ron,” Myrtle said sweetly, giving them a coy little wave.
“What are you doing here? Go to the girls’ loo!” Ron grimaced, and Myrtle let out a shrill laugh.
“I was admiring poor little Reggie Black covered in pink…” She looked at Regulus with mock affection, pretending to pinch his nose. “We got along so well, you know—when I was alive, there was this girl, Olivia…”
“Myrtle… I really don’t care.” Regulus cut her off curtly, huffing as he headed for the door.
“Regulus Black!” she shrieked, making both Harry and Ron clap their hands over their ears. “You’ll regret saying that!”
“What are you going to do? Kill yourself?” Regulus clicked his tongue.
Ron couldn’t help himself and burst out laughing, dragging Harry out of the bathroom just as Myrtle started screeching and making the toilets overflow.
“Who did that to you?” Harry asked as they walked, keeping a safe distance so the pink wouldn’t stain him—Ron flanking Regulus on the other side.
“Weasley,” was all Regulus said.
“Fred or George?” Ron asked, a bit too eagerly.
“Is there a difference?” Reggie didn’t mean to sound rude, so he gave a half-smile after the remark.
“Course there is! Fred’s usually the one who talks George into pulling the, uh, more explosive pranks… but aren’t you a Prefect?” Ron continued. “Didn’t know they messed with Prefects too.”
“A friend of mine messed with them and now I’m the one paying for it…” Reg muttered.
His day had already been strange and bloody awful, so he didn’t even mind walking through the halls with the two Gryffindors, who, oddly enough, seemed to be heading in the same direction as him.
“How’s Malfoy doing?” Harry asked, glancing over at him. “Gryffindor’s playing Hufflepuff instead ‘cause he’s still injured…”
“No idea. I don’t speak to him.” Regulus sighed as he spotted Gemma Farley walking at the end of the corridor.
“But you’re on the Quidditch team together,” Ron pointed out, pushing the conversation along.
Regulus abruptly veered towards the viaduct, hoping Gemma would lose his trail.
“Snape kicked me off the team,” he explained, looking at Harry. Those green eyes stirred an inexplicable longing in him—a nostalgia for a time that only lived in memory. “Because of my uncle.”
The two Gryffindors exchanged a quiet glance.
“That’s good,” Ron said with a shrug. “I mean—for Gryffindor.” He cleared his throat awkwardly.
Regulus arched a corner of his mouth.
“Suppose it is.” He stopped at the top of the Grand Staircase, checking his pocket watch—the wedding photo of his parents moving gently on the inside of the lid. The three boys stood in another moment of awkward silence. “Well… see you around. Good luck in the match, Potter.”
“Cheers,” Harry replied shyly, and Ron gave him a wave.
The two of them watched Regulus disappear down the path towards the dungeons.
“Still think he’s helping his uncle?” Ron adjusted the strap of his bag, glancing sideways at his mate.
Harry shook his head.
“No idea.”
.
.
.
Padfoot had gone out hunting. The clouds were gathering in the sky, glinting with distant flashes and thunder. His nose sniffed the scent of rain, the sweetness of magical plants, the trail of woodland creatures… and the distinct smell of a cat.
Not Whiskers.
No.
That yellow-eyed cat had been trailing him for a while now, and he’d pretended not to notice—until he faked chasing a squirrel and vanished from the feline’s view.
He circled back around the clearing and caught it off guard. The cat hissed, fur bristling. Padfoot lowered his head, growling—not menacingly, but with caution. Offering a sense of calm, yet keeping his distance. He twitched his snout slightly, then darted back toward the Shrieking Shack, using a large stick to press the knot on the tree.
The cat followed at a distance, entering the tunnel and stopping at the shack’s door, hesitant.
The dog grew, and Sirius walked up to the empty upper floor. Scarlett had gone out to Hogsmeade. They hadn’t spoken since what happened on Halloween. Sirius barely looked at her—shame and regret steadily eating away at his courage. He didn’t want to hurt her, nor did he want to seek comfort from her.
Scarlett was cunning, and he couldn’t fall under her spell—not again. Not when he was this close to catching Peter.
His gaze flicked to the cat, now batting at a loose thread from the carpet, claws tapping softly on the wooden floor.
“You’re just a cat,” Sirius muttered to himself, leaning on the piano. “Well cared for. Not a stray. You live in Hogsmeade, maybe?”
The cat paid him little mind, slipping beneath the bed.
“Or Hogwarts?!” he guessed, scratching the scruff of his chin. “If you’re from Hogwarts, maybe you could catch a rat for me, huh?”
It was a ridiculous idea—he knew that. Still, he allowed himself a faint smile, rubbing his face. It was a relief to talk to someone—or something—that wasn’t Scarlett. Not that he didn’t like talking to her, but there was too much weight between them, too many things unsaid. One wrong word and it could all unravel, and he didn’t feel like tiptoeing around her just then.
“Ginger? Carrot? Tabby?” he threw out some names at the feline, who darted out from under the bed and pounced on an old shoe, kicking at it with its back legs. “Sunny?”
Sirius was so amused watching the cat do something so delightfully ordinary that he jumped when he saw Scarlett at the foot of the stairs—her face bleak, her coat damp.
“Who were you talking to?” she asked, scanning the room with suspicion.
“No one.” Sirius’s eyes drifted to the bag she was carrying.
“No one? Is that what the cat rolling on the floor is called?” Scarlett opened the bag and pulled out a package. “Why did you let it in here? It could be an Animagus!”
“It’s not an Animagus,” Sirius said, placing his hands on his hips and letting out a long sigh. “Look at it. It’s playing with a cockroach!” He let out a small yelp and leapt onto the bed as if the creature might kill him.
Scarlett crushed the cockroach with one sharp step, her lips curling into a grin.
“You’re still scared of cockroaches?!” she asked in a wicked tone, and the cat looked up at her with curiosity.
“What? I’m not scared of cockroaches,” Sirius scoffed, as if the notion were outrageous. “Never have been.”
“Yes, you were,” Scar insisted, crouching to stroke the cat. It sniffed her fingers, then hissed and puffed up.
“No, I wasn’t.” Sirius’s expression darkened.
“Yes, you were,” she repeated, with an edge of irony that clearly grated on him.
“Oh, now you remember everything, do you?!” he snapped.
She drew her brows together, jaw clenched.
“Why are you angry?” Scar didn’t hide her displeasure.
“I’m not…” Sirius licked his lips and cleared his throat, exhaling hard. “I’m frustrated, alright? I… I got so close to… catching the rat that…” He rubbed his forehead. Just mentioning it gave him a headache. “I’m a bloody failure.”
“We’ll get another chance,” Scarlett said gently, stepping closer with the package in hand.
“Not as good as the Halloween feast…” he mumbled, looking at Scarlett as she held out the wrapped parcel. “What’s this?”
“Third of November.” She pressed her lips together into a soft smile. “Happy birthday, Sirius.”
Any words he might’ve said were stolen by the gesture. Sirius stared at the foil-wrapped parcel for a few seconds, blinking blankly, before looking up at her like a lost pup—falling into those ocean eyes for just a moment.
He slowly unwrapped the slice of cake, the scent of sugar filling his nostrils and setting his stomach off with a low growl.
“There’s a Quidditch match this weekend… Gryffindor versus Hufflepuff…” She sat in the armchair, watching the cat roll about on the rug. “Harry’s Gryffindor’s Seeker.”
“James was, too…” Sirius murmured, the flicker of joy vanishing as swiftly as it had come. “And Marl was… Beater…”
Scarlett sobered instantly, curling into herself the way she always did when that topic surfaced.
“So were you.” She met his gaze. “You were Gryffindor’s Beater, remember?”
Sirius’s eyes widened slightly, his brow tightening.
“No.” The reply was bitter. “I don’t remember.”
His attention returned to the cake, lips twitching unconsciously as he stared at the slice of white sponge, whipped cream and strawberries.
His mouth watered.
Strawberry cake was his favourite.
He hadn’t remembered that—not until Scarlett bought him one back at the hotel, after they fled Azkaban.
The resentment in his chest became fine little stakes, pressing into his heart as he ate. The sweet flavour awakened a mixture of sensations in his mind—pleasant and light… though tinged with guilt.
He wiped the cream from his beard and closed his eyes, savouring the sugar as it tingled across his palate.
The cat suddenly darted downstairs. Scarlett rose to follow it.
“Scar…” Sirius called, and she paused in the doorway, glancing back over her shoulder. “I’m sorry.”
She sniffed, lips tightening with a look of quiet regret.
“You’re not the one who needs to apologise, Sirius.”
Scarlett descended the stairs, and Sirius stared at the empty wrapper, shutting out any feeling that dared creep up from his chest.
.
.
.
Victoria Rookwood hated herself.
And that feeling was a constant in her life. She hated her parents, her brothers—it was only natural she’d be included in that bundle. There were few things she didn’t hate, to be honest. Her nickname, which had been affectionately given to her by Regulus. The colour white. The fact she was a Metamorphmagus, even though she didn’t have full control over her abilities.
Cedric Diggory, because he had been kind to her every time they’d spoken, without expecting anything in return.
There were also things she liked. Yes, because liking and not hating were two completely different things. She adored Luana, for example, even though her friend had a few screws loose.
She liked Reggie too. Maybe “liked” wasn’t the right word, but...
She didn’t know exactly when she’d started liking Regulus. The truth was, there had always been something between them, a twisted similarity that allowed them to talk without even saying a word. It was almost instinctive, as if they’d always known each other even though they barely spoke.
Unlike the yelling from her parents and the violence from her brothers, her dialogue with Reggie happened in silence—in the subtle movements, in the contemplation of their own chaos. In the absence of something she hadn’t realised she was supposed to feel.
It was common for them to climb onto the ledge of the staircase that faced Reggie’s house and sit listening to music in silence. Victoria, in particular, loved Nirvana. Regulus hated it—he thought Kurt Cobain was far too bleak. Which was fair enough; they couldn’t agree on everything, but Victoria adored grunge. It was, in fact, a more depressive genre of rock, and she found it fascinating how the vocalists managed to channel the music into raw emotion.
For example, every time she listened to Black by Pearl Jam, she could feel the pain in Eddie Vedder’s voice from losing the woman he loved. In the same way she could tell how Regulus was feeling just by sitting next to him, without needing to ask. It only took a glance, a touch, a half-smile. A certain tone.
Regulus didn’t like Pearl Jam either. Nor Alice in Chains. He stuck closely to the bands his mum and godfather were into, which annoyed Victoria a bit. Toto and Rainbow were decent, but already a bit outdated. Rainbow especially—they hadn’t made a good album since Dio left.
She didn’t know exactly why, but that’s what she was thinking about when she was called into her brother Vin’s room. He was in his final year at Hogwarts, so he’d been granted the privilege of having a room to himself.
Her eyes wandered across the scrolls, meticulously rolled and sorted by subject, the book spines arranged by the authors’ surnames, the rare collection of signed Quidditch cards.
Vin entered a moment after she arrived. He was tall—perhaps a little shorter than Reggie—though his spiked white hair gave him a few extra centimetres. His eyes, however, were different from Victoria’s. They were darker, chocolate brown flecked with hazel. The lamplight danced in his pupils, his expression as severe as their father’s.
"What the fuck do you think you’re doing, Victoria?!" Vin snapped acidly, circling her in a menacing way.
Under normal circumstances, Victoria would’ve felt fear and a burning pit in her stomach. She was already so wrecked she didn’t feel a damn thing.
"Why do you care?" she looked at him with condescension.
In a swift movement, Vin’s hand clamped around Victoria’s neck, slamming her aggressively against the wall. The impact knocked the air from her lungs and threw her heart off rhythm. She gasped, eyes wide, lifting her head to glare at him without losing her composure.
"I don’t want some dumb slag like you fucking up the position Dad got me at the Ministry," he snarled, curling his lip.
"And why would I ruin your job? It’s not my fault you’re such an incompet—" Victoria couldn’t finish the sentence. Vin’s hand closed around her throat so tightly it choked the words from her, a sick pressure blooming in her skull as his nails dug into the skin at the back of her neck.
"What was that you were saying?" Vin stretched his lips into a sarcastic grin. Victoria gripped his wrists, trying to force him off her, but he used the weight of his body to pin her against the wall, pressing harder. His sharp breath scraped against her cheeks.
Victoria’s vision began to fill with black spots as she choked on her own lack of air. Then, suddenly, her brother let go, and she collapsed to the floor, gasping, blinking rapidly, her whole respiratory system ablaze.
"You’re lucky, Victoria. Mum was thrilled to hear Regulus finally fell for your charms. Everyone always thought you two would end up married, but he never had the balls to do anything about it. Well, looks like someone finally did..." He chuckled to himself, sitting on the bed as if he’d just done something routine.
Through her coughing and the desperate search for air, Victoria laughed too. Vin’s face hardened.
"What the fuck’s so funny?!" he glared at her, heel thudding repeatedly against the floor.
She cleared her throat, flexed her jaw as her neck throbbed, and shrugged, as if it were nothing, as she got to her feet, swaying slightly.
"I told Mum you two are dating and she’s over the moon about it. So make sure he asks you out... I don’t know, suck his cock, do what you do best, yeah?" He turned to one of his scrolls, ending the conversation with his rhetorical jab.
Victoria leaned against the bookshelf, fingers fumbling for her wand in the pocket of her cloak as the oxygen slowly made its way back to her brain. Vin caught her reflection in the bedroom mirror, his wide lips pressed into a thin line, a dark shadow falling across his brown eyes.
She wanted nothing more than to make him feel the pain he constantly inflicted on her. Maybe if she didn’t hate herself so much, she could. Her hand drifted, touching the raw skin on her neck, where the bruise shaped like Vin’s hand was already marring her pale complexion.
Swallowing with difficulty, she left the room, disoriented. She went down the stairs, passed the statue of Merlin, and ended up tripping halfway through, catching herself on a table to avoid falling. A sudden hiss made her glance down at the cat she’d accidentally kicked. It was a black-and-white tom with a ridiculous-looking moustache.
"Sorry..." she whispered, as if the feline could understand her.
She continued on towards her dorm, desperately searching for her scarf. Her hands fumbled over the trunk until she found it and wrapped it around her neck, burying her face in her palms as the headache settled into a steady, nagging throb.
"Fuck." She took three deep breaths before looking at herself in the mirror, wiping the tears away, and stilling the tremble in her hands. She reined in her emotions and stepped out of the dorm once more—only to run straight into Regulus, who was talking to Miles and Terence.
One look was enough for Regulus to understand what she needed. He followed her out of the common room, using her prefect privileges to climb the Astronomy Tower uninterrupted, stopping where the telescopes creaked under the wind and the cold bit into their cheeks.
Victoria rubbed her hands together, blowing warm breath into them just as Regulus appeared, his silhouette stretched long against the glow from the room and the moonlight spilling over them. His expression was dark with seriousness, tinged with hesitation.
"Why didn’t you ever do anything?" she asked, stroking her scarf as though afraid the wind might carry it away.
Regulus let out a deep breath, turning as he leaned against the pillar beside her, arms folded. One side of his face was lit by the moon, the other shrouded in the column’s shadow. Victoria plucked at the wind like she could touch the presence of Reg—the presence she had always longed to hold, that almost-tangible thing between them.
"It’s just..." He bit his lower lip. "There’s too much going on right now."
Victoria shook her head. She wasn’t having that. It wasn’t enough—it didn’t even come close to explaining everything between them.
"You never even tried!" she snapped. "Not even before... before all this shit with your uncle!"
Silence stretched between them, a chasm of too many looks and not enough words. Of unspoken feelings, of complacency and unease.
"I was scared," Regulus admitted, summoning a courage he didn’t feel.
"Scared?" Victoria’s voice rose as she took a step closer. "Scared of what?!"
That invisible wall between them was hard to breach. Regulus stared at her, the starlight glinting in his eyes, full of everything he wanted to say but wouldn’t allow himself.
"You were always right. I never had the guts—and Cedric’s better than me in every fucking way." Regulus licked his lips, bitterness weighing down his voice. "We’d never work out..."
"What?!" Victoria cut him off, fists clenched, barely holding back the urge to punch him.
"You should go out with him, Victoria. He’s Hufflepuff’s captain, he’s good-looking and—"
"Oh, for Merlin’s sake, Regulus!" she gasped, his words hurting her far more than she cared to admit. "I’m sorry we snogged, all right? I never thought you actually liked me!"
"No!" Regulus smiled—but it wasn’t humour. "Stop lying. You know! You’ve known since third year!" he accused, jabbing a finger at her.
Victoria hissed, slapping his hand away, hard. The wind howled between them, whipping their Slytherin cloaks.
"And since third year I’ve been waiting, Regulus!" she shouted, coughing from the force, her throat raw. "And you never... never..." She wiped her tears with trembling hands, her gaze cooling as frantic justifications ran through her mind. "You’re a fucking coward!"
Regulus’ bitter smile deepened. He dragged a hand over his face, biting his tongue the way he always did before saying something he’d regret.
"We’d never work, Victoria," he muttered, defeated. The tension etched into his features, the muscles of his jaw tightening. "I’m chaos... and you’re chaos. We’d destroy each other. Just like we are now!"
Victoria didn’t flinch. She lifted her chin and met his gaze with equal intensity.
"You’re no chaos, Regulus. You’re spineless! Always have been!" she went on, her words ringing out among the telescopes. "You take everything on the chin, head down like the obedient little lapdog you are!"
And though she could see how much those words wounded him, Victoria felt deeply relieved. She wanted to hurt him just as much as he had hurt her.
"Take a look at yourself in the mirror," Regulus sneered, giving her a once-over dripping with disdain. "You get beaten up by your brothers and don’t even—"
"SHUT UP!" she screamed, her vocal cords straining as her arm shot forward, and in the next second, the tip of her wand was pressed against Reggie’s nose. "Shut your fucking mouth, Regulus!"
He stayed still, turning his face slightly, tongue dragging slowly across his lips, eyes softening just long enough to sharpen like steel.
"Go on, then," Reggie said coldly. "Hurt me. Isn’t that what you want?"
Victoria Rookwood hated herself so much she was capable of hurting one of the few people she loved. With her jaw clenched and eyes narrowed, she lowered her hand slowly, her whole body trembling. Not from the cold—but from the terrifying realisation of who she might actually be. That the violence so carefully hidden deep inside her was now pointed at Regulus.
"I love you, Victoria. I’ve always loved you," Regulus said, meeting her gaze as he rested his head against the pillar.
The confession lacked even the faintest trace of romance; his voice was stained with anguish.
"Then... why... why can’t we..."
"I wish things were that simple." He gave her a sorrowful smile as he closed his eyes. "I really... don’t know if... I don’t know if I can deal with this right now. I’m sorry, Mimi..."
Victoria had never thought she could hate Regulus. But the rejection hit her so hard it twisted her lips, flared her nostrils, and made her raise her sharp gaze to him, fighting the emotions threatening to drown her. Her hair—white as his was black—turned crimson like fresh blood.
"You’re going to regret this, Regulus." That was all she said before leaving him behind, chest blazing with rage, nails digging deep into her palms.
She let the blinding fury take over, carrying her down all those stairs straight to the Great Hall. She scanned for the tall, dark-haired boy at the Hufflepuff table and, with not a flicker of hesitation, marched straight over and kissed him in front of everyone.
.
.
.
Whiskers and Padfoot made their way through the pouring rain towards the Quidditch stadium. They used the storm to slip in unnoticed amongst the crowd, climbing as high as they could into the sparsely occupied stands. It was hard to see from there, though—the players were drenched, and the thunder that lit up the pitch came in bursts, drowning out both the crowd and the commentator.
None of them was as elated as James. Besides his son, family, and friends, Quidditch was what he missed most of all. Watching Harry play filled him with something he’d never felt before—a pride laced with exhilaration, like the very first time he’d flown on a broomstick.
Padfoot gave a bark as Harry flew past the edge of the stadium. Lily covered her mouth with her hands, and Regulus smiled, crossing his arms and casting a sideways glance at his friend.
"This reminds me of the first match in sixth year..." he remarked. "The friendly."
"The one where we kicked Slytherin’s arse? I’ll never forget that," James mocked, shoving his glasses up his nose, the rain passing through them like ghostly water.
"You only won because I held Scarlett," Regulus muttered, rolling his eyes.
"With or without Avery, we’d have won!" Lily allowed herself a brief distraction from the match, jumping into the conversation before turning her attention impatiently back to the game.
"No, you wouldn’t have," Red said dryly, watching Hufflepuff’s Seeker zip past them. "And you lost the Cup that year, so..."
"After three undefeated seasons!" James shot back, craning his neck to get a better view. "Look at him—he flies just like his dad!"
"Funny that, considering you only won the Cup when you played as a Chaser the next year... maybe Seeker just isn’t your thing, Potter!" Regulus teased, nudging him with an elbow.
"Piss off—I won three years in a row as Seeker..." James elbowed him back.
Padfoot was bouncing with excitement in the rain-soaked stands. Thunder cracked in the distance, but all he could see was a sopping-wet Harry darting after the Snitch with precision—the boy was good, really bloody good. Just like his father. The thought made the excitement in him twist into sharp little stings against his heart. There had been someone else who flew like that too, a boy with black hair and steel-grey eyes. Someone who bore the same name as his godson. Yes—the brother he’d tried so hard to forget in Azkaban.
Regulus.
Padfoot let out a low grunt, shaking off the water and the shiver that ran through him. It wasn’t the rain’s fault, yet his canine instincts tried to rid him of it anyway. He glanced at Whiskers right beside him, just as absorbed in the match as he was. Scarlett played Quidditch too... same position as him, though she was a Slytherin.
The flashes of lightning seared through Padfoot’s mind, dragging up a memory long since corroded. He was clutching his broom, on a day much like this one, chasing after a completely drenched girl. He’d lobbed a Bludger her way and, when she dodged, Sirius pulled up alongside her.
"Red!" he’d shouted, his face bright with that cheeky, rain-slicked grin.
Scarlett looked at him, raising a brow.
"What?" she asked, clearly confused.
"The colour of your dress… when you go to the ball with me. It’ll be red!"
Scarlett grinned—and for a moment, the world wobbled around her rain-soaked beauty. Padfoot shook himself again, trying to shake off the all-too-familiar shiver creeping up his spine.
He glanced up at the sky, at the thick clouds. A flash of lightning revealed a swarm of Dementors drifting between them, like holes eating through white cloth. His heart raced, his fur bristled, and fear spread through every inch of his body.
Regulus looked up too, holding his breath at the sheer number of creatures up there.
"Dementor," he murmured, oblivious to James and Lily’s cheering. "Dementor, dementor, Scarlett… Dementor!"
Whiskers, absorbed in the match, gave a startled hop as the ghost’s voice broke through to her. Lily and James looked skyward too, their faces tightening with dread at the looming danger.
Padfoot and Whiskers shot off, weaving through the crowd still fixated on the match. The cat slipped and ended up tumbling into the lap of a white-haired girl cheering wildly for Hufflepuff. On reflex, Whiskers hissed and scratched the girl’s arm, then darted through the other spectators until she found Padfoot again on the stairway.
"No!" James shouted, running back up the stands with Lily close behind. "Harry!"
Padfoot froze as the crowd went silent, all eyes fixed on what had just happened—Harry was falling. Whiskers pushed off the ground, ready to return, and Dumbledore was quick to break the fall. At that moment, the audience noticed the Dementors.
Whiskers bit Padfoot’s paw, snapping him out of his daze, and the two of them bolted down the steps towards the pitch. She glanced around frantically, trying to guess where the Dementors might strike next, but they seemed too fixated on the stadium to care about what happened outside it. She would not let them take Sirius—not if she had to drive them off with a feeble excuse for a Patronus.
Regulus stayed beside her, while Lily and James lagged behind.
"That way, that way!" he pointed to Whiskers, his eyes never leaving the sky as he scanned for the creatures.
The path to the Whomping Willow had never felt so terrifying. Whiskers and Padfoot ran as though their lives depended on it, their paws sinking into the muddy ground. Splinters of wood were scattered around the tree, and Whiskers had to leap to avoid injury, clawing at the knot in the roots. Padfoot darted straight through, vanishing into the tunnel like a shadow.
Scarlett transformed back at the door, her teeth chattering from the cold, shoulders tense. Her eyes scanned every inch of the entrance, wand at the ready. She shut the door and locked it, following the wet trail left by Padfoot leading upstairs.
She followed it, trying to steady the thunderous beat of her heart, reaching for some good memory buried deep in her mind. All that surfaced was a distant piano melody, stirring waves of emotion she wasn’t ready to face. She let out a breath as her gaze landed on the bedroom, on Padfoot huddled beneath the bed.
Warm tears rolled down Scarlett’s cheeks. She didn’t wipe them away. She simply sat beside the bed, resting her chin on her hands, and reached out to stroke the soaked fur of the black dog.
"We’re safe," she murmured quietly.
Padfoot didn’t move, trembling uncontrollably, whimpering softly. Scarlett brushed aside the damp fur hanging over his eyes—those grey irises now glazed with terror. She sighed as the dog turned his face away, slipping from her reach.
She sat there for a moment, the cold seeping into her skin, making her muscles tremble. Then she rose carefully, peeled off her wet clothes, and dried herself with a spell before slipping into the dry ones she had in her backpack.
"Hey, Padfoot... I’m here. They’re not going to hurt you," she tried to reassure him, but the dog didn’t respond.
She stood again and paced aimlessly about the room, her eyes drifting towards the piano. The old, dust-covered instrument bore no maker’s mark, no lid, its strings likely slack or snapped. She barely realised she was walking towards it, nor that she was reaching out a finger toward middle C.
The key felt cold beneath her touch. Dirt pressed into her fingertips. She pushed it down, felt the hammer lift slightly and strike the string—a discordant resonance hit her like a jolt. Scarlett straightened, calming her breath. She stepped sideways, her finger still pressing the key, and sat on the dusty bench.
Her bare feet found the metal pedals. She blinked a few times, trying to remember what they were for. Ah, yes. The right one was the sustain, her favourite. It lifted the dampers so the strings could keep vibrating, extending the sound and enriching the tone with added harmonics. She’d learned that from her great-grandmother, Gwendolyn Weasley.
The left pedal, known as the una corda, shifted the hammers so they struck only one string of each key.
But what Scarlett was looking for was the middle one—the sostenuto. It varied depending on the piano, but on that one, it served to mute the strings. That was what she needed. Despite the storm outside, she didn’t want anyone hearing her play. She pressed it down and locked it in place, turning her gaze back to the keys.
It had been fifteen years since she’d touched a piano. With a flick of her wand, she tuned and repaired the strings. She took a deep breath, pulling the bench closer. Her eyes drifted to Padfoot under the bed, his dark fur melding with the shadows. Lightning split the sky outside, slicing through the silence and making the candlelight flicker, casting distorted shadows across the walls.
Scarlett ran her fingers over the keys, now dusty and familiar. She closed her eyes, trying to recall the dozens of pieces she could once play without even needing to see the notes. But there were too many. The melodies slipped through her fingers, even though the muscle memory was etched deep within her.
[Music: Josh Cohen — The Great Gig in the Sky (Piano Cover)]
Her fingers began to move on their own, dancing through the first chords of the song. The gentle introduction flowed easily, drawing out a tangled storm from her chest. Scarlett might have tried to stop herself, fearing that too much would be released, that she would drown in whatever came loose.
But it was too late. She had surrendered to the music—and it was stronger than she was. It pulled everything from her that needed pulling, and planted in her what needed planting.
Padfoot’s ears perked up at the sound, the vibration of the notes washing over him like they were slowly submerging him into the waters of the River Styx, before his memories had been devoured and torn apart by Dementors. Back to a warm summer night in 1976.
The memory hit him like a plunge into a whirlpool. Everything spun. The music was slowly muffled, and the sight of Scarlett’s feet pressing the piano pedals was swept away by the resonant current of his little aquarium full of fish.
Sirius let all the air out of his lungs as he stroked the cracked glass of his pocket watch. There was a painful tightness in his chest, an unbearable ache that reminded him he’d gone to the Potters’ house without saying a single word to Regulus. He scrubbed at his eyes fiercely. He didn’t want to cry.
And he didn’t cry. Sirius Black wasn’t the kind of boy who sought comfort in tears. So, he ripped out everything that stabbed at his chest and twisted his features into his trademark arrogant grin just as James appeared at the door of his bedroom.
"We need to head down—looks like we’re meeting the new neighbours..." James adjusted his glasses, leaning against the doorframe.
Sirius instinctively slipped the watch back into his pocket and gave his mate a playful elbow to get him moving.
"New neighbours, huh?" he asked, glancing at James as they crossed the landing. "Anything interesting?"
"According to Dad, there’s a girl our age," James replied, flashing a wicked grin. He sat on the bannister and slid down to the lower floor, nearly toppling over when his mum suddenly emerged from the kitchen. "Ah—hi, Mum!"
"Darling… please don’t do that again. You’ll end up hurting yourself," she scolded, though her voice was so gentle it barely qualified as a reprimand.
"Forgive Prongs, Effie—he’s yet to master the art of descending stairs," Sirius teased, suddenly jumping onto his mate’s back. James caught his legs and held him there with a laugh.
Fleamont cleared his throat loudly from the top of the stairs, prompting James to release Sirius and glance up at his father.
"Behave yourselves, boys. Please," Fleamont said, with a firmer tone than his wife’s. "And no unnecessary jokes."
"Yes, sir," James replied, shooting a cheeky look at Sirius.
"What? I didn’t say anything," Sirius defended himself, swatting James on the shoulder.
"That goes for you too, Padfoot," James said, shoving him lightly. Sirius stumbled, laughing.
"Me? I’ve never made an untimely joke in my life!" Sirius strutted toward the door, stretching as he stepped outside. The summer breeze brushed his cheeks and tousled his long black hair. Night had just fallen over Godric’s Hollow.
Sirius crossed the street, eyes drawn to the fountain in front of the house opposite—still running—and the vast garden of poppies. The house, once abandoned and run-down, had taken on new life: the broken tiles were gone, the entrance was clean, and the lights glowing inside gave away the presence of its new inhabitants. In the left window—one of the sitting rooms—he caught a silhouette moving with a sort of delicate precision.
A song grew louder as they approached. As Fleamont knocked on the door, Sirius felt something stir inside him, coursing through his veins the moment the door opened and the music surged—some Muggle song, by some Muggle band. He never imagined he’d hear Pink Floyd coming from a wizarding household.
His legs carried him toward the sound on their own, like a siren’s song was calling him. His gaze swept through the foyer, into the sitting room with the television, then snapped to the right and—there she was. With her back to them. Reddish-brown hair fell over her shoulders, her hands a blur over the keys, striking with force and precision. Sirius felt spellbound, the deep notes thudding against his chest as she moved like someone entranced.
He greeted the hosts with his most charming smile, completely indifferent to Mrs Gaunt’s flattery or the snobbish tone her son used when speaking to James.
Mr Gaunt looked over at his daughter with an expression of pride.
"Ah, best wait until she finishes the piece. She won’t hear a word you say," he remarked, a fond smile lighting his face.
Sirius wanted very much to ignore her and focus on understanding who the Gaunts were, but his eyes simply wouldn’t leave her. He could feel the tension mixed with agony and catharsis in the way she played, as if the notes were transmuting every pent-up emotion in her chest into something tangible.
He stepped closer, noticing the glove she wore on her left hand, the precision of her fingers, her utter immersion in the music—so deep she didn’t even glance at him. He saw the tears running down her cheeks, the fierce expression, the tendons straining on the backs of her hands each time she pressed a key. Something twisted in Sirius’s chest. He couldn’t name it; he only knew his hand instinctively reached for the pocket watch Regulus had given him, rubbing it urgently between his fingers.
The tempo began to ease, and what had sounded like pain and anxiety slowly transformed into calm and hope. Her eyes were still closed, her hands drifting over the keys as though she knew every inch of the instrument by heart, as though the piano were part of her body, its structure embedded in her being. The high notes filled the room with delicate softness, and as she opened her eyes slowly, she hesitated before striking the final chord—reluctant to let the moment end, unwilling for the music to stop.
The last chord reverberated with melancholy, fading gently, and her long brown lashes lifted to reveal a pair of tear-brimmed, icy-blue eyes. Sirius was still soaked through, but his body had stopped trembling. There was a warmth blooming in his chest, thawing him from the inside out, dulling every awful remnant of the Dementors’ lingering touch.
He remembered. Now, he remembered that day.
"Pink Floyd?" Sirius asked, his voice fragile, barely there. Just as he’d asked her when they first met.
Scarlett sniffled and nodded, a smile tugging faintly at her lips.
Sirius wiped her tears, his cold fingers fitting under her delicate chin, his thumb brushing her lower lip. In that moment, he felt like the same Sirius from eighteen years ago—the arrogant, foolish boy who cared too much about a stupid watch and the crumbling relationship with his brother. Who worried about what his friends thought of him... and about a girl he once tucked flowers into the hair of—who, in return, stole his heart.
Even knowing he might regret it, Sirius embraced Scarlett and buried his face in her neck, in her hair, in her very soul. A thousand visions of what they could’ve been surged through his mind, flooding the shadows of all they’d lost and swirling the bitterness of everything they’d gained.
"I missed you so much, Scar," Sirius murmured, clutching her tightly, letting himself drown in the intoxicating feeling she brought him. "So, so much."
Scarlett kissed his cheek, a pale smile brushing her lips. This was her— his Scarlett, the girl he had loved with everything he had, and lost with the same intensity.
"I missed you too, Sirius," she whispered, her fingers tenderly stroking his wet hair.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 15: We’ve met before. When we were kids.
Notes:
Yep, I did it again. Posted the english chapter in the Portuguese version lol. Thanks @Persephone_D for warning me <3
Chapter Text
LXXXIII
Regulus hadn’t spoken to Victoria after what happened. Not that he could, really. She was always around Cedric, from prefect meetings to the Great Hall. She didn’t dare look at him—not even in class. She acted like nothing had happened, clinging to her group of friends and avoiding eye contact with Reg in the corridors at all costs.
That was good.
So why the fuck did it hurt so much?
Why did it feel like something was being ripped out of his chest every time he saw Victoria laughing melodically with that bunch of Hufflepuff wankers? It made his blood boil.
It was on Sunday afternoon, the day after Gryffindor’s disastrous match against Hufflepuff, that Remus called him into his office. Regulus, already weary from Luana’s failed attempts to cheer him up by hexing every bloody soul who walked past her with Trip Jinxes—a Ravenclaw girl nearly broke her nose and they’d almost landed in detention—just sighed as he stepped into the Defence Against the Dark Arts classroom.
He glanced at the aquariums filled with the little creatures he’d studied the previous year—grindylows, kappas, hinkypunks and the like. His gaze skimmed over the desks until it landed on Remus, who was seated, marking some essays. His greying hair shimmered under the torchlight, and his brown eyes flared amber when he looked up at Reg.
“Reggie…” he said, beckoning him over. “How are you doing?”
Regulus shrugged.
“Fine,” he replied, in the tone of someone who clearly wasn’t.
“What’s going on?” Remus set his quill into the inkwell and raised an eyebrow. “Is it about Sirius?”
Regulus just lowered his head, unsure what to say. He was afraid that if he started talking, he wouldn’t be able to stop.
“It’s just…” He rolled his shoulders, pressing his lips together. He opened his mouth as if to speak but changed his mind. “What was she like at Hogwarts?”
“She? Your mum?” Remus leaned his elbows on the desk, the deep shadows under his eyes darkening. Regulus nodded.
“She liked Defence Against the Dark Arts…” Remus glanced at the scrolls in front of him, though he clearly wasn’t seeing them. In that moment, he was staring into the past. “She was brilliant at duelling. We used to take the piss out of her because she’d gone to Durmstrang, so she knew spells the rest of us didn’t, which gave her a bloody huge advantage. She had this… friend of ours… Dorcas… she was a beast. No one could beat Dorcas—except your mum.”
A nostalgic smile tugged at Remus’s lips, only to give way to guilt. The flicker of the candlelight deepened the lines of his scars as he scratched his chin and turned back to Regulus.
“She was… really bloody good,” he finished, solemnly.
“I wish I’d known her,” Regulus admitted in a quiet voice, the storm of emotions threatening to tear through his chest. But he didn’t let it, pushing the feeling away with a long exhale.
Remus didn’t say anything more.
“Did you see the match?!” Regulus changed the subject, and his uncle straightened up as if startled.
“Er, no. But I heard about it… I mean, the ending…” He looked rather uneasy. “The Dementors… they shouldn’t have been on school grounds. Dumbledore was livid about their presence.”
“Yeah, calming the crowd was a bloody nightmare…” Regulus bit his lower lip, remembering Gemma screaming for the prefects not to let the younger students bolt up the stairs in panic. “It was mad how Dumbledore stopped Potter’s fall and—”
“Reg…” Remus cut in, and Regulus fell silent immediately. “I think Sirius is after Harry,” he said quietly.
“What?” Reggie blinked, confused. “Why…”
“I don’t know, but he tried to break into Gryffindor Tower, so…”
“Yeah, but he doesn’t know I’m in Slytherin, does he?!” Regulus shot back, leaning on the desk. “He always said I’d end up in Gryffindor.”
Remus frowned.
“You remember that?!” He rubbed his moustache. “Well… I reckon he already knows what House you’re in… but what I mean is… have you seen or heard anything odd recently? Since he broke into the school?”
Regulus swallowed hard. It was obvious Remus knew Sirius was Padfoot. Or… did he? That photo had been in his mum’s things, after all. But they’d been best mates. What if it was something only Sirius and Scarlett knew? Should he say something? Did Remus know Scarlett’s watch had vanished? Was Sirius really after Harry? Would he actually try to kill him? Could his uncle be capable of that?!
“Reggie? Are you alright? You’ve gone pale.” Remus stood up, concerned. “Did something happen?”
Regulus’s eyes went wide, his heart hammering in his chest. He needed to come up with something, anything to throw his uncle off. Remus knew him too well—he’d see right through a lie. He had to—
“I snogged Mimi,” he blurted out, clearing his throat.
“Mimi?!” Remus folded his arms, stepping beside him. He was taller than Regulus, and his shadow completely engulfed him.
“She… she wanted something serious, but I… I dunno, uncle, I think I fucked up.” Regulus felt his face burn. It was good to let a bit of the weight off his chest, even if it made him feel like a total idiot. He wished all his problems were just about fancying Victoria, and not…
“What do you mean, you fucked up?” Remus gave his wand a twirl, and the kettle began to boil.
“I told her I didn’t know if I could handle it right now,” Regulus muttered, burying his face in his hands, feeling like a complete fool.
Remus pulled him into a hug, giving him a few reassuring pats on the back. That was all it took for Reggie to start crying—though he didn’t want to. He clenched his chest as tightly as he could to stop any sound from escaping.
It was true that, out of all his uncles, he was closest to Remus. Which was almost ironic, considering they weren’t even blood-related. Remus had been the only constant presence in his life—even though he’d tried to move on after everything that happened, every single door had shut in his face… even after fighting so fiercely against Voldemort in the war.
And although Thanatos had enough money to live comfortably without working a single day, Remus pushed himself to earn his own keep, even if that meant jumping from one job to another because of the lycanthropy. He even managed to land positions in the Muggle world, but he never kept them for long. When he and Thanatos split, Regulus let his uncle live in the house that was legally his. It was part inheritance, part excuse to stay away from Orfeu and Thanatos during the summer holidays.
Not that he didn’t love his other two uncles, but the connection he had with Remus was much deeper—maybe because Rem had known him since he was just a baby. Regulus always felt more at ease with him, though never entirely. None of his uncles had ever satisfied his curiosity about his parents or Sirius. It had always been a forbidden topic, and for the longest time, Reg had learned to live with that.
Not anymore. Now, Regulus would have the truth—one way or another.
He had to find Sirius. He had to understand.
But right then, he allowed himself to be comforted by Remus. He clung tightly to his uncle and opened up about kissing Mimi, about the two of them falling asleep together in the Great Hall on Halloween night, and the chat they had at the top of the Astronomy Tower. Remus listened to everything attentively, pulling away only to prepare some tea, then sitting beside him, rubbing his back as if he could somehow ease the storm spiralling in his nephew’s chest.
Remus had always been his most consistent emotional support, even if Regulus still felt insecure around him when it came to his parents and Sirius.
“…and now she’s dating Cedric,” Regulus confessed, his voice thick with remorse.
“Diggory? The Hufflepuff lad?” Remus sipped his bagged tea. Reggie nodded. “He reminds me of you.”
“What? Me and him have nothing in common!” Reg sniffed, wiping his nose with the back of his hand. “He barely talks… he practically shat himself when the Dementors got near on the Hogwarts Express…”
Remus let a small smile slip.
“What’s so funny?” Regulus hissed, his expression hardening.
“I’m not laughing at you, Reg, I just…” Remus wet his lips and gave a small shrug. “Being young and in love.”
“What’s funny about that?” Reggie looked away, focusing on the steam rising from his tea.
“It’s… nice. Remembering what that felt like.” Remus tapped his fingers on the edge of his cup. “Reggie, Victoria isn’t the only girl in the world. And given the way she acted after you told her you weren’t ready… well, you did the right thing. She would’ve walked all over you at the first chance. She’s your first love, Regulus, and most people don’t end up with their first love. You’ll meet other people, kiss other mouths… I’m sure half the girls in this school are mad about you.”
“But I don’t want other girls, I want her!” Regulus stomped his foot. “She… she… she’s the girl, Uncle, and it’s not just some silly crush! I’ve fancied her since I was younger and… it’s like… it’s like Sirius and my mum…”
Remus sighed and shook his head.
“Reg… don’t project their relationship onto yours,” he murmured, running a hand through his greying hair. “You’re completely different people.”
Regulus blew on his tea and took a loud sip.
“That’s not what I meant.” He looked up at his uncle. “I love her, Uncle. I don’t want anyone else… I want Mimi,” he insisted, rubbing his eyes roughly.
“I know, Reg. I know.” Remus offered him a sad smile, gently brushing his nephew’s hair back. “But it’s not the end of the world. You’ll be alright.”
Regulus wasn’t so sure about that, but he believed him anyway. After pulling himself together and finishing his tea, his uncle kissed his forehead and began gathering his things to head off to his quarters.
“Oh, Reg…” Remus called, just before Regulus left the room. “Could you keep an eye on Harry? In case… in case anything strange happens… or if you see something out of the ordinary… don’t hesitate to tell Dumbledore, alright?”
“Alright,” Regulus nodded, though he wasn’t thrilled about it. “So… he really is after Potter?”
“That’s the most likely scenario.” Remus shut his folder. “Ah, your Invisibility Cloak… you forgot to bring it.”
Regulus felt his neck heat up. He swallowed hard.
“Yeah, about that… I think I left it at home… couldn’t find it in my trunk…” He pretended to glance outside the classroom. It wasn’t exactly a lie, since the cloak wasn’t with his things. But he was certain he’d brought it to Hogwarts.
“Oh… alright then.” Remus didn’t seem suspicious. If he was, he didn’t show it.
“Good night, Uncle,” Regulus said quickly.
“Good night, Reg.”
Regulus quickened his pace as he descended the stairs, his sweaty hand slipping along the cold marble banister. His eyes darted towards the clock to the right, the one that faced the Undercroft. Making sure he was alone, he slipped inside, lit the sconces, and jumped down the steps.
Dust particles floated in front of his face, and the musty scent made him wrinkle his nose. Did Remus really believe Sirius was after Harry? Regulus made his way through the gallery, letting his fingers graze the cymbal from his godfather’s drum set, crossing the room until he reached the bedroom.
He didn’t know why, but he stopped in front of the inscription on the wall, where most of the photos had already come loose. Regulus drew his wand and began cleaning them, smiling softly to himself at the special moments frozen in time.
One in particular showed his mother wrapped in James Potter’s arms. Harry really did look a lot like him. The two of them looked like they were dancing a waltz, and he was fairly certain Sirius had taken the photo—there was a tattooed finger accidentally intruding on the edge of the frame.
Scarlett and James wore broad smiles, gazing at each other with such ease that, for a few seconds, all of Regulus’s worries melted away. He clutched the photo to his chest, wishing his mother were there. It would never become reality, but it didn’t hurt to dream.
He bit his lower lip as he gathered up all the photos and stuffed them into the pocket of his cloak, folding his arms just as a cold breeze howled through the gallery, causing the cymbals outside the bedroom to sway gently.
Regulus’s eyes dropped to the dusty floor—to the footprints. His heart pounded when he placed his own foot next to a singular set of prints, the sole clearly smaller than his. He raised an eyebrow, following them. He couldn’t remember the size of Sirius’s feet, but they sure as hell shouldn’t be smaller than his.
Or should they?
The prints stopped in front of the keyboards and shifted over to the drum kit, where all that remained of the aquatic club photo that had once sat atop the drum’s snare was its dusty imprint on the skin. Regulus ran a trembling finger over where the image had been. He was certain it had still been there when the watch disappeared. Drawing his wand from his pocket, he pointed it at the footprints.
“Revelio!” he cast, eyes locked on the markings. Nothing. Then, he whispered a tracking charm, and the footprints lit up with a soft blue glow.
Regulus followed them out of the clock, to the portrait where the tracks simply vanished. There were no more prints, no further signs—only the photograph lying at his feet. The marble floor was gleaming, and he cursed silently at the bloody house-elves responsible for cleaning the place as he bent to pick it up.
When had Sirius taken the photo? Had he dropped it? What if it had been recent? What if he really was hunting Harry? The flood of questions made Reggie bolt towards the viaduct, heading for the hospital wing. He stopped running as soon as he reached the top of the spiral staircase, panting hard for breath.
Madam Pomfrey was far too busy dealing with a boy who was vomiting slugs to pay any mind to Regulus, who crossed between the beds until he reached Harry’s. The boy was talking to Ron and his know-it-all friend, but their conversation cut off the moment all three turned to stare at him.
For a moment, Regulus wondered why he was even there. He scratched the back of his neck and gave a sheepish smile. Harry looked pale, hair a mess, with a wary, slippery sort of gaze.
“Hi…” he waved, approaching with hesitation.
“Alright, Black?” Ron greeted him like they were old mates, earning a confused glance from the girl.
“Hi.” Harry lowered his gaze to the side table. Regulus followed his eyes, noticing a bouquet of flowers with crawling caterpillars that looked like yellow cabbages and a card tucked beneath a fruit bowl.
“You played well yesterday,” Regulus blurted, a bit too quickly.
Harry scratched at the lightning-shaped scar on his forehead.
“We lost,” he muttered, disheartened.
“It wasn’t your fault… either way,” Reg tried to cheer him up, but the attempt only seemed to deepen the gloom on Harry’s face. Regulus looked away, eyes catching on the floor—scattered with damp shards of wood. “Is that… your broom?!”
“What’s left of it.” Harry shrugged.
“If you want… I could… er, lend you mine.” Regulus offered, frowning at his own words. “I mean, I’m off the team anyway and… if I ever get back on, I’ve got a spare at home.”
He regretted it immediately. The three of them looked like they wanted to skin him alive, and he hadn’t expected to feel this uncomfortable in their presence. He rubbed his fingers hard, absentmindedly stroking the glove he wore on his left hand.
“Er, thanks, but I think I’ll pass…” Harry replied slowly, like he didn’t quite know what to say.
“You don’t have to worry, it’s not cursed.” Regulus joked with a small laugh that only made things more awkward. He wanted to bury his head in the floor.
“Not like you’d admit it if it was…” the bushy-haired girl shot back, rolling her eyes.
“Hermione!” Ron snapped, frowning at her.
“What? I’m just stating the obvious… and honestly, who loans someone a broom?! And you’re his nephew—how do we know—”
“I’d never hurt Harry.” Regulus cut her off, voice sharp. “You don’t remember, but we’ve met before.” He looked directly at Harry. “When we were kids.”
“What?!” Harry asked, as if that were the most ridiculous thing he’d ever heard.
“Our parents… they were friends…” Regulus stammered, trying to sound steady. A curious glint lit up in Harry’s green eyes. “I remember your parents…” He reached into his cloak pocket, fingers brushing against the bundle of photos he’d taken from the gallery, prompting the three of them to exchange confused glances. He pulled out the picture of James and Scarlett dancing and held it out to Harry. “That’s my mum, Scarlett. And that’s your dad.”
Harry took the Polaroid as though it were some priceless treasure. Hermione and Ron leaned in over his shoulders to get a better look.
“What are they doing?” Harry asked, looking up at him while adjusting his glasses.
“Dancing, I think.” Regulus licked his lips. His blood was thundering in his veins.
“You remember them?!” Harry’s expression softened, letting Ron take the photo from his hands.
“Vaguely. Your mum… she had your eyes. And your dad… I remember him being funny. He… he and…” Regulus cut off, swallowing hard before he could say Sirius’s name. He really shouldn’t have revealed he knew them.
“Why isn’t it moving? Is it a Muggle photo?!” Ron looked at Hermione.
“It’s a Polaroid, Ron,” she sighed.
“He and who?” Harry barely noticed the bickering.
“All right, children, time to let him rest,” Madam Pomfrey appeared conveniently at that exact moment, sparing Regulus from having to come up with a lie.
He wanted nothing more than to slap himself. He shouldn’t have said that—especially not when his uncle was literally trying to kill Harry Potter! For Merlin’s sake, Regulus. He took a deep breath and forced a smile, giving Harry a wave, though the boy still looked like he was waiting for an answer.
“Catch you later!” Regulus called as he turned and walked briskly away from the hospital wing.
He hoped “later” meant never. How the hell was he supposed to explain that Sirius had raised him until he was three—the same Sirius responsible for his parents’ deaths? He’d never felt so bloody stupid in his life. He hurried back to the dormitory, diving under the covers before any of his housemates could get a word out.
.
.
.
Sirius lay on the mouldy rug of the Shrieking Shack, staring at the cobwebs dancing across the ceiling in the breeze. Beside him, the cat he’d affectionately nicknamed Ginger was happily devouring a massive spider it had hunted down earlier in the house. He had an idea in his head—one he knew was utterly idiotic—and yet, he couldn’t shake it off.
He’d refused to leave the Shrieking Shack since what had happened on the Quidditch pitch, even after Scarlett told him the grounds were clear following Professor Flitwick’s inspection of the Whomping Willow. At first, they panicked, thinking Flitwick had been sent by Dumbledore, but in reality, he didn’t even seem aware of the tunnel beneath the tree.
Which, to be perfectly honest, was a bloody relief.
Until… Sirius realised he’d come to collect the remains of a broomstick.
Harry’s broomstick.
He stroked the beard covering his chin and neck, pausing as his eyes landed on the tattoos sprawled across his fingers and the back of his hand. Ginger rolled over and nestled against his arm, grabbing his attention. Sirius scratched the cat’s head, earning a loud purr in return.
The idea wouldn’t leave him alone, hammering inside his skull until he sighed and nodded to himself. If James were there, he’d definitely tell him to go through with it without even blinking—after all, this was about Harry. And if the kid was anything like his dad, Quidditch was bound to be one of his greatest passions. Being left without a broom at this point in the term was just… unforgivably unfair.
And if there was one thing Sirius knew too fucking well, it was injustice. He drummed his fingers against the ruined rug until the cat leapt onto his chest, demanding more affection. With a lopsided grin, Sirius scratched the feline’s back, making it stretch out in bliss.
“You could do me a favour, couldn’t you?” he raised a brow at the creature, watching it close its eyes and lean into the stroking of its orange fur.
It wasn’t just that Sirius refused to leave the Shrieking Shack—he couldn’t. It was one of those days. The kind that left him hollowed out. He couldn’t quite explain why—maybe twelve years in Azkaban had done more of a number on him than he liked to admit—but it felt like, with each passing day, his emotions were bubbling closer to the surface, rawer and louder than ever.
They weren’t the sharp, ravenous emotions that had so often visited him in Azkaban. This was something else entirely—grander, messier, more diverse. Some were gentle, like a summer breeze. Others, wild and raging, like a storm. They bloomed so much more easily now, and he felt as if he were lying in the middle of a vast, flowering field—full of scents and colours and petals and thorns and gusts and leaves and trunks and branches and roots and seeds and dewdrops and memories and laughter and tears and birds and bees and hummingbirds and wasps and all the things his mind had once been forced to erase.
But now, things were coming back. Slowly. The colours grew more vivid and saturated, the contrasts more intense, the breeze turned to gust, to hurricane, the waves crashed over him and spat him back out, the sun burned as much as it warmed. He hadn’t seen the snow yet, but he was certain that when he did, more memories would surface.
And he wasn’t sure if he was ready for that.
“Do you take commands? If I sent you to the Owl Post, would you go?!” Sirius tilted his head down to look at the cat sprawled lazily across his chest. “If I told you to buy a broom… how much do you reckon a new broom costs?”
He licked his cracked lips, just as he heard Scarlett coming up the stairs. He looked up to see her upside down, wrapped in her black overcoat, reddish-brown hair wild and tangled.
His gaze locked onto her delicate face. After only a few months out of Azkaban, the difference was stark. Not only had colour returned to her skin, but her features had filled out, become stronger. The hollows under her eyes weren’t as deep anymore—though still darkened with shadows—her cheeks had regained shape, and there was a flicker of hope in her eyes now that made Sirius’s chest ache.
“Talking to the cat again?” she teased. “Why are you lying on the floor?”
Sirius shrugged.
“Helps me think,” he replied, his stomach growling as the scent of food filled the room.
Scarlett popped open a container of fish and chips. Sirius’s mouth watered, and even Ginger seemed intrigued, lifting its head and perking up its ears.
“Where’s the Invisibility Cloak?” Sirius asked, waiting for the cat to hop off his chest so he could sit up.
Scarlett turned her head away, pretending to be far too preoccupied with rummaging through the takeaway bag to meet his gaze.
“I dunno… I think… I think I dropped it… when we ran…” she stammered, biting down hard on the dry skin of her lip until it bled.
“You dropped it?” Sirius didn’t bother hiding the disbelief in his voice. “Before we left?!”
“I think so.” She confirmed it, licking her finger as she bit into a chip. “You eating or what?”
“I need the cloak,” he said at last, wiping his fingers on his trousers before picking up a battered fish fillet.
“What for?” Scarlett sat down on the bed, crossing her legs.
Sirius hated the tingling nerves that sparked in his fingertips every time Scarlett looked at him like that. It made him feel like an open book, like she could slip past every wall he’d ever built and glimpse the real Sirius, curled up and shaking in the darkest corner of his soul.
He exhaled deeply, chewing as he gathered his thoughts.
“I need to go to Hogsmeade,” he explained.
“Why not go as Padfoot? You do know Dementors can see through the cloak, right?!” Scarlett snapped.
Sirius narrowed his eyes at her.
“Yes, I know,” he replied firmly. “I just… I can’t be seen. Not even as Padfoot. If Remus—”
“If Remus had told anyone, your face would be plastered on every bloody poster in the country with ‘Animagus’ printed underneath it.” She cut him off, running her fingers through her hair. “Anyway, I don’t remember where the cloak is.”
Scarlett deliberately avoided his gaze. Sirius stood up, positioning himself in front of her, stuffing his hand with chips and fish.
“What do you mean you don’t remember?!” He didn’t look away from her, scanning her face for the truth.
“We… we were running and…” she dropped her gaze, her long dark lashes twitching with the rapid movement of her irises. “…I think it fell.”
Sirius hissed through his teeth, pushing his hair back behind his ears to get it out of the way as he started shovelling food into his mouth. A long silence followed, broken only by the sound of chewing as Sirius ate and Scarlett picked at her chips. Ginger padded over to the food box, intrigued, but Scarlett waved him off with a quick flick of her hand.
“I’ve got something for you…” Scar patted the pocket of her coat, sliding two fingers in along the seam. The pocket was torn. “Oh, you’ve got to be kidding me…” she muttered, raking her hands through her hair and massaging her temples.
A pause settled between them.
“What’s the next step?” Sirius finally asked, tipping what was left in the box straight into his mouth. Scarlett furrowed her brow, both hands planted on the bed.
“We need to let things settle down a bit… security at Hogwarts has doubled,” she said, sipping from the bottle of water she’d brought with her. “Besides, he probably knows you’re after him… but he doesn’t know about me. We can’t risk it.”
Sirius threw himself down dramatically beside her on the bed, arms flung wide, head beginning to throb.
“Fucking rat.”
That was all he said, and Scarlett glanced at him from the corner of her eye.
“We’ll get him.” She placed a hand on his leg, and Sirius’s thigh muscle twitched like he’d been hit with a jolt of electricity.
The touch sent a surge of warmth through his entire body, a heat laced with tenderness that softened every jagged edge of his resistance. But as if she’d noticed his reaction, Scarlett immediately pulled her hand away and turned forward, retreating into silence as she sipped her water.
“I know,” Sirius whispered, chest tightening at the thought of James and Lily. He wouldn’t sleep in peace until he avenged their deaths—not until Peter Pettigrew drew his final breath.
He’d dreamed so many times of wringing that bloody rat’s neck that he couldn’t feel the slightest bit of relief knowing Peter was this close to Harry and Regulus. He was a coward—Sirius had known Peter his whole life, knew damn well the rat would never try anything against Harry. Not without Voldemort’s say-so—especially since, to the Death Eaters, Peter was the reason the Dark Lord had fallen. He was the one who gave away the Potters’ location.
Sirius still remembered the furious howls of Peter’s name in Azkaban. The Death Eaters had screamed for vengeance just as much as he had.
“Do you think you could get the cloak for me? I really need to go to Hogsmeade, just for something,” Sirius said, brushing his leg against Scarlett’s. She looked at him, uncertain. “Please?”
Sirius knew Scarlett. He knew how cunning, cruel, and vengeful she could be. He also knew her weakness—she couldn’t say no to him. Sirius didn’t remember everything, but he was sure of that. She wouldn’t be able to resist him for long.
“I’ll… I’ll look for it later. When the corridors are emptier…” she murmured, nodding awkwardly.
He still wasn’t used to smiling—not with the threat of Dementors constantly looming—but he made the effort, letting the corner of his mouth curl just enough to bring a flush to her cheeks. For a brief moment, it was as if they were teenagers again.
“Thanks, Scar.” Sirius didn’t move his leg, keeping it pressed lightly against hers on purpose. Scarlett, caught by his smile, merely nodded and stayed completely still, as if she didn’t want the moment to end.
“Always, Sirius.” She gave his leg a light pat before springing up suddenly, like touching him had set her hand on fire.
Sirius was the flame. Scarlett knew that being this close to him was dangerous—and she didn’t want to get burned. Not now, not when everything between them was finally starting to feel okay.
.
.
.
Two weeks before the end of term, the sky suddenly brightened into a glaring milky white, and one morning the school grounds awoke beneath a blanket of glittering frost. Inside the castle, there was a definite buzz of Christmas in the air. Professor Flitwick had already decorated his classroom with twinkling lights that were, in fact, real fluttering fairies. The students were content, chatting away about their plans for the Christmas holidays.
Regulus couldn’t have cared less. He ate his breakfast in a foul mood, eyes fixed on Victoria over at the Hufflepuff table with her arms slung around Cedric’s shoulders. Beside him, Luana and Miles were arguing over the latest Quidditch match, where Ravenclaw had trounced Hufflepuff. It had been immensely satisfying to watch Cedric lose that game—but Victoria’s reaction, all sweet and consoling toward her boyfriend, was infuriating.
The two shared a sneaky kiss, and Regulus dropped his cutlery onto his plate with a loud clatter.
“I think I’m going to be sick,” he muttered, drawing Terence’s attention from across the table.
“I thought you two were together,” Terry remarked casually, dabbing his mouth with a cloth napkin.
“Well, you thought wrong,” Regulus replied curtly.
“Have you decided where you’re spending Christmas?” Luana turned to him, chewing noisily on a strip of bacon.
Regulus ground his teeth.
“No.” He went back to staring at his egg, stirring the spoon around the nearly hollow shell. “I think I’ll stay here. My uncle… Lupin… he’s staying too.” He cleared his throat.
“Lupin’s your uncle?” Terry frowned. “I noticed you knew each other, but I didn’t realise he was family.”
“He was. They split.” Regulus explained without much enthusiasm. “You staying?”
Luana shrugged, narrowing her eyes as the Weasley twins strutted into the hall.
“If you stay, I’ll stay.” She wrapped an arm around him, trying to lift his spirits.
Regulus answered with a tired sigh.
“Well, if you lot are staying, I suppose I have no choice but to stay as well…” Terry placed a hand dramatically over his heart.
“Oh, get over yourself, Terence. No one invited you,” Luana said, flinging a piece of toast at him. “Don’t you have a family or something?!”
“I do, but…” Terry chuckled. “Isn’t it a bit sus for you to hang around here? What with all that drama involving your uncle?”
Regulus cracked the shell of his egg with unnecessary force.
“I don’t care what people think,” he said flatly, crossing his arms, lips curling in annoyance.
“You going to Hogsmeade today?” Luana changed the subject, brushing a hand through Regulus’s hair.
He shrugged her off. He knew it was just her way—she had no sense of personal space thanks to how she was raised—but he was growing tired of the condescending way she treated him since everything with Victoria.
“Can’t.” Regulus sighed bitterly, standing up.
“Want me to bring you something back?”
Regulus simply shook his head and left the Great Hall, head down. He hurried through the corridors, making his way back to the Slytherin common room. He sidestepped a black-and-white cat just before he could trip over it and collapsed onto his bed, silently thanking Merlin he hadn’t run into Harry along the way.
Harry had tried to speak to him several times, and each time, Reg found a way to escape, taking advantage of the fact that Malfoy was far too interested in whatever the Gryffindor had to say—always shooing him away by imitating Dementors with his cronies. Luckily, Harry seemed to have given up… which left Regulus both relieved and guilty. He could tell him the truth, but he had no idea how. Besides, Harry should already know who Sirius Black was, and revealing that Sirius had been named godfather to both of them—and worse, that he’d raised Regulus as a child—would make Harry hate him.
It was better this way.
Regulus drifted back to sleep, burying his head beneath the pillow. He hoped to dream of Scarlett or Sirius, clutching their photo to his chest as if that would summon them into his subconscious.
He woke up cold, blinking several times until his eyes could focus on the deep green canopy of his bed. The only light in the dormitory came from the heater and the candelabras near the bathroom. He yawned and stretched, abandoning the warmth of the bed for the tomb-like chill outside. Feeling around in the pocket of his crumpled cloak, he searched for his pocket watch.
He stared at the little image of his father, Regulus, resting a hand on his mother’s shoulder, that same enigmatic look in his eyes. Reggie ran a finger across the fogged glass of the watch and saw that it was two in the afternoon. Still groggy, he leaned against his half-open trunk.
He frowned. He remembered closing it.
Running a hand through his messy hair, he crouched beside it and opened it fully. Amongst his neatly arranged socks, there was a space he recognised as if it were carved into him.
Regulus reached in between the socks and pulled out his Invisibility Cloak. He scratched his head, eyebrows knitting together. There was no way it had been there the whole time… it hadn’t. He was sure of it.
Wasn’t he?
He was too sleepy to think straight. Rubbing his eyes, he shrugged, deciding that it could only be a sign.
He was going to look for Padfoot in Hogsmeade.
.
.
.
Padfoot didn’t remember snow. He was utterly mesmerised as he stared up at the flurries drifting down from the sky, slow and silent, dissolving against his damp snout. He sneezed, shaking the snow from his fur before hurrying off towards Hogsmeade. His pawprints dotted the white carpet that stretched across the Hogwarts grounds, the pads of his feet already numb from the cold.
The village of Hogsmeade looked like something off a Christmas card, and Padfoot felt a sudden wave of joy wash over him as he watched the narrow streets buzzing with Hogwarts students. Cloaks billowed this way and that as they passed, their laughter and lively chatter painting the festive air with warmth.
It was easy to be just another stray dog wandering through the wizarding crowd. Padfoot sat in an alley and watched a group of Ravenclaws emerge from Honeydukes, bags in hand, the scent of sweets wafting towards him, mouth-watering and thick. His stomach growled.
He licked his nose and ambled along through the wizards and witches, sniffing his way toward Spinwitches’ Sporting Needs. He didn’t quite remember where the shop was. The village looked like a maze buried in whipped cream, but he remembered the name. Prongs had dragged him there so many bloody times for Quidditch gear that it was etched into his brain.
Thinking of Prongs made him lower his head and ears with a soft whimper, absorbing the countless smells of Hogsmeade—from the sharp perfume of a group of giggling Hufflepuffs to the rich, buttery scent of hot butterbeer drifting out from the Three Broomsticks. He eventually found the shop after trailing a trio of laughing Slytherins, who were boasting about some prank they were planning for the next Quidditch match.
Padfoot wanted desperately to eavesdrop, but he stopped in front of the shop window instead. His snout pointed at a sign stuck next to the display of broomsticks, fogging the glass with his breath.
— BY THE ORDER OF —
THE MINISTRY OF MAGIC
Customers are reminded that until further notice, dementors will be patrolling the streets of Hogsmeade every night after sundown. This measure has been put in place for the safety of Hogsmeade residents and will be lifted upon the recapture of Sirius BLack. It is therefore advisable that you complete your shopping well before nightfall.
Merry Christmas!
Padfoot shivered all over. He needed to hurry—he didn’t want to risk running into a Dementor, even though there were still a few hours of daylight left. It was unsettling, walking around in this kind of cold, the sort that made him constantly feel like one of those creatures was nearby. If he hadn’t been somewhere so crowded, he might’ve lost it completely when the wind picked up and sliced even colder through his fur.
His gaze skimmed across the items in the window display, landing on a stunning Firebolt perched above all the others, with a small iron plaque mounted just beneath it:
THE FIREBOLT
This state-of-the-art racing broom sports a stream-lined, superfine handle of ash, treated with a diamond-hard polish and hand-numbered with its own registration number. Each individually selected birch twig in the broomtail has been honed to aerodynamic perfection, giving the Firebolt unsurpassable balance and pinpoint precision. The Firebolt has an acceleration of 150 miles an hour in ten seconds and incorporates an unbreakable Braking Charm. Price: 500 galleons.
Padfoot let out a low grunt at the price of the broom. Five hundred Galleons?! Bloody hell. Ridiculously expensive. But it wasn’t like he had to worry too much about the cost—he’d had plenty in his Gringotts account (at least, before being thrown into prison), and with the death of his family, he’d probably inherited a chunk of the Black fortune. Even if he hadn’t, he’d spent twelve years away from Harry without giving him a single gift. The first present he ever gave his godson had been a broomstick—so it was only fair that his Christmas gift be the Firebolt.
Firebolt. The name stirred something in him… oh, right. Scarlett had one too. He watched his breath mist in the air, a wave of melancholy washing over him.
Padfoot veered away from the shop window, nose to the ground, following the scent trail toward the post office. It wasn’t far. A little voice at the back of his mind told him this was madness. He was the most wanted man in the country, and buying a broomstick for Harry had to be the stupidest idea he’d ever had (at least from what he could remember—which surely would change if he ever recalled the pranks he pulled back at Hogwarts). He was fairly certain Scarlett would kill him if she found out, so he had to do this quietly.
The post office was packed, full of witches and wizards hurrying to send Christmas gifts to their families. Taking advantage of the crowd, Padfoot weaved between the customers and delicately snatched a small order form pad between his teeth. Wasting no time, he darted back outside. The snow was falling harder now.
His ears picked up something behind him—odd sounds, crunching, movement—but a quick glance over his shoulder showed nothing unusual. A black-and-white cat appeared, and Padfoot’s ears perked, relaxing slightly when he saw it was only Whiskers.
Then something very strange happened.
Whiskers vanished, and he heard a startled yelp, a dull thud—something falling—and the snow in front of him puffed outward. Padfoot recoiled, his whole body bristling, taking a small leap backward. Suddenly, a freckled, flushed face in a state of absolute shock turned to look at him.
Reggie.
Padfoot froze, heart pounding so fast it felt like his blood had turned to steam. The boy’s grey eyes, dusted with blue, caught the falling snowflakes between them, tiny white flecks settling in his black fur.
“Padfoot…” Reggie whispered, the word steaming from his pale lips.
He knows. Regulus had recognised him. Whiskers hissed and scratched the boy’s leg. He yelped, just loud enough for the cat to shoot a frantic glance at Padfoot—and the two of them bolted, vanishing like shadows across the thick, snowy streets of Hogsmeade.
Regulus rolled across the ground, hand stretched out toward nothing. The pain in his ankle was searing, but it was nothing compared to the shock of having seen Padfoot with his own eyes. It was him—he knew it—and Sirius had recognised him, too. That canine form had the same eyes as his godfather, and Regulus’s heart was pounding so fast and so hard he thought it might give out. He couldn’t breathe—oxygen didn’t seem to be reaching his brain.
“Reg? What are you doing down there?” Luana approached with a steaming mug of hot chocolate. At her side, Miles and Terence stared at him, wide-eyed.
Regulus lay on his stomach, half his body covered by the cloak, the other half exposed. He curled in on himself, trying to get up, but the scratch on his leg was deep. Blood stained the pristine snow crimson.
He didn’t get a chance to answer—someone yanked the cloak the rest of the way off.
Regulus glanced over his shoulder and met the furious gaze of Remus. His lips were drawn tight, brows razor-sharp; his usually pale face had flushed a dangerous shade of purple. Regulus couldn’t remember ever seeing his uncle this angry before—he could swear there was a vein bulging on his forehead. His moustache twitched as he stared down at the Invisibility Cloak in his hands.
“Left the cloak at home, did you?!” he snapped, not even trying to mask the exasperation in his voice.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 16: Not everything we went through was awful
Chapter Text
LXXXIV
"Have you gone bloody mad, Sirius?!" Scarlett snapped, hands on her hips.
"I was only trying to—"
"He saw you!" she cut him off, gesturing wildly. "If I hadn’t been there—"
"He doesn’t know I’m Padfoot!" Sirius was so worked up he didn’t even hesitate to lie. "Maybe he just—"
"Then what the fuck was he doing following you?!"
"I don’t know, fuck! I don’t know!" Sirius shouted back, his breath coming in short, ragged bursts. If he hadn’t been caught so off guard, he’d be furious. But the shock was still crawling over his skin, sending a cold shiver down his spine.
"Why were you in Hogsmeade?"
"I told you I needed to go there! But you conveniently dropped the cloak... the cloak Reggie was using!" he shot back, accusatory.
Scarlett let out a bitter smile, shaking her head.
"Oh no, don’t you dare try and turn this around on me!" she snapped, jaw tight, those disturbingly blue eyes stabbing into him. "You nearly got exposed!"
He threw himself onto the bed, running frustrated fingers through his hair, inhaling deeply to try and calm the storm thrashing in his chest.
"Yeah, I nearly got exposed because you lied about the cloak!" he growled, turning his face to her, jaw clenched. "Why did you lie?!"
Scarlett’s expression hovered somewhere between outrage and shock. Sirius knew her—he’d taken a stab in the dark and hit bullseye. He saw it instantly: she was lying too. Shame flickered in her eyes and she looked away, taking a step back and letting all the air out of her lungs.
"I didn’t lie," she muttered, as though genuinely hurt. "The cloak fell and—"
"And Reggie just happened to find it lying on the floor at Hogwarts?" Sirius finished for her, dripping with sarcasm. "Why did you give it back?" He rested his hand over his face, elbow sinking into the mattress.
Scarlett let out a dry, bitter laugh, pressing her lips together and wrinkling her nose. He had no clue that three ghosts were shouting all sorts of excuses in her ears at that very moment, but he noticed the way her shoulders stiffened like she was crumbling under the weight.
"I was scared you’d sneak into Hogwarts on your own and get caught," she murmured, leaning against the bedroom wall and hiding her face in her hands.
Sirius raised his eyebrows, stunned. He hadn’t expected her to actually tell him the truth.
"I didn’t..." He started trying to come up with an excuse, but scoffed when he realised he didn’t have one. There was a kernel of truth in what Scarlett had said—without the cloak, it was much harder for him to move around Hogwarts, leaving the job to her. "Why didn’t you tell me that before?"
Scarlett hugged her own body, shrinking into herself and giving a little shrug.
"I thought... you’d get angry," she said, biting her lower lip. "You were quite... off your head."
Sirius clenched his fists, nostrils flaring as he looked at her. What the hell did she mean by off his head? He felt suffocated, shame creeping into every crack where impatience might have fuelled his response. He hated feeling vulnerable, and he’d spent most of those days leaning on Scarlett like a crutch while trying to recover, while trying to...
Trying to accept that James and Lily were dead.
There wasn’t a single day he didn’t miss them—James especially. And the fact that Scarlett was using that to dig at him ignited a furious, thorny anger deep in his chest, scraping him raw as he struggled to rein it in.
With his jaw clenched tight, Sirius let out a bitter laugh that echoed through the room, fingers curling into the bedsheet as if trying to play it cool.
"Of course I was off my head. You’ve betrayed me once—what makes you think I’d trust you not to do it again?" he hissed. "You’ve already lied about the cloak—what’s next?"
Sirius watched, almost hungrily, as his words struck her. Hesitation flickered across her face, swallowed quickly by guilt—her pupils wavered and she rubbed her Signet under her glove, just like she always did when she was nervous. And she had every reason to be—Sirius wanted to wound her, and he’d bloody well succeeded. Seeing her react like that made the remorse crawl down his spine, prickling his neck like maybe he was the one in the wrong.
"I didn’t..." she began, but then thought better of it—her lips sealed shut and didn’t part again. The candlelight from the candelabra cast flickering shadows across her pale face. Her blue eyes were muddied by her sins and regrets. Then, in a sudden movement, she turned on her heel and stormed out of the room.
Sirius blinked hard, pushing himself up in a flash.
"Scar..." he called, but Scarlett slammed the bathroom door so hard a puff of dust shook loose from the ceiling.
His hand landed on the doorknob, the cold metal stinging his fingertips. But his wrist stayed frozen. He heard her cast Aguamenti to fill the tub, then another charm to heat it. The shadows beneath the door shifted, showing she’d undressed. A long, aching sigh slipped from her lips as she sank into the hot water.
He stood there, unmoving, listening to the gentle sloshing of water against porcelain... and the ragged, sob-choked breaths Scarlett tried to stifle. Something twisted inside his gut, a strange heat curling there—something he didn’t quite remember feeling before.
"Why couldn’t you keep your bloody mouth shut, Scarlett?!" she muttered, before plunging beneath the water and resurfacing with an anguished moan. "Get out of here, you perv!"
Sirius let go of the doorknob as if it had burned him, his face flushing red in an instant. He shot back into the bedroom, feeling dizzy. And embarrassed. And... aroused?! He glanced down at the bulge in his trousers and cursed under his breath, running a hand through his beard as he tried to piece his thoughts together.
Regulus had recognised him. Which meant he knew Sirius was Padfoot. But... how? Thanatos didn’t know he was an Animagus. Only Remus... had Remus told him? And if he had, what made Sirius think he was the only one who knew? Could Reggie know about Scarlett too? Why hadn’t he recognised her?
The Ministry was only after him, so... was she officially dead?!
Sirius rubbed at his temple, his head starting to throb. A flash of fur in his peripheral vision made him glance about the room until he spotted Ginger, a moth trapped between his teeth. The cat growled at Sirius, tail high, and rubbed against his ankles.
"Well, look at that—just the bloke I needed..." Sirius crouched down, reaching under the bed. He grabbed the purchase order pad he’d hidden there while still in Padfoot form and stared at the blank sheet, cracking his knuckles.
He drew his wand, racking his brain for the charm he needed. He couldn’t put his own name down, so... he’d use Harry’s. What was his signature like? Being his godson, Harry surely had access to his vault... did he even know that? Were there enough Galleons for a broom?
With a flourish, the words began to appear on the order form:
Purchaser: Harry James Potter
Bank: Gringotts
Vault: 711
Amount: Five hundred Galleons
Shop: Spinwitches Sporting Needs
Item: Firebolt
Delivery: Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry
Note: Gift wrap, if possible
Sirius penned a rather elaborate version of Harry’s signature, hoping whoever received the order wouldn’t bother verifying it. He was a master at forging signatures—he’d faked Dumbledore’s more times than he could count, and he knew older wizards rarely wasted time checking such things.
Then he looked down at Ginger, who purred loudly as Sirius scratched his head. Tearing the order from the pad, he held it out to the cat.
"Think you can take this to the post office? Come on, you’re a clever cat. If I leave this house as Padfoot and head back to Hogsmeade, the lady of the house will have my hide." He joked, and the cat gently took the parchment in his mouth. "Hogsmeade... post office," he repeated, slowly gesturing.
Ginger tilted his head, and as if he knew exactly what he was doing, bolted from the room and bounded down the stairs.
Sirius slumped into the armchair with a mischievous grin. He had no clue if the cat would actually manage to send the order, but he bloody well hoped so. At the same time, he knew it was probably foolish to get his hopes up.
It would never work—too many bloody variables.
.
.
.
Regulus was grounded. Arms crossed and a permanent scowl carved into his face, he barely glanced at Madam Pomfrey as she healed the scratch on his leg with as much care as if the boy were dying of pain.
All he felt was restlessness. He didn’t want to go back to Hogwarts, and he didn’t want to be without his cloak either. He’d almost spoken to Sirius—if he hadn’t tripped over that bloody cat, and if his uncle hadn’t found him in the middle of the chaos…
He wanted to slap himself. He left the hospital wing and endured Remus’s never-ending lecture without taking in a word of it. Sirius was Padfoot. He’d seen Sirius in Hogsmeade. It was him... and Sirius had recognised him.
Maybe now they’d finally... finally get a chance to talk?! Regulus rubbed his hands together in the bitter cold of Remus’s room.
"Are you done yet?" Regulus muttered, despondent.
Remus frowned, lips parting in disbelief at his nephew’s cheek.
"Am I done?! Regulus... you’re being completely irresponsible! In Hogsmeade while Sirius is on the loose! Have you lost your mind? Do you have any idea how much danger you were in—"
"What’s he going to do, kill me? Thought he was after Potter..." Reg cut in, only to be immediately interrupted.
"That’s not funny, Regulus!" Remus shoved his hands deep into the pockets of his faded blazer. "I don’t know what to do with you anymore."
"Send me to Azkaban," Reg said flatly, leaning his head against the back of the sofa.
Sirius had seen him. Sirius had recognised him.
"Cut it out!" Remus snapped, jabbing a finger at him. "What’s your bloody problem?"
Regulus smiled. Though really, it was only the shape of a smile.
"Isn’t it obvious? Me. I’m the problem, Uncle. Always have been." He turned his face to Remus, the lines of his expression sharpening, brows drawn tighter by the second.
"What?"
"My dad died before I was even born, then my mum had me and got locked up, forcing Sirius to raise me. Then he got locked up and I ended up with Uncle Nate—but he never had the patience, so you ended up doing more for me than he ever did. If you don’t know what to do with me, imagine how I feel. Maybe you lot will just hand me off to someone else... Orfy, maybe. Yeah, him—the one who can’t even look at me because I remind him of my mum." His smile now was thick with bitterness. "I’ve been rejected my whole life. One more or less won’t make a fucking difference... but don’t worry, Uncle. I’m fifteen, which means in two years I’ll be of age, and then you won’t have to put up with me much longer."
Remus’s face, usually pale and ashen, flushed deep red. He pressed his lips together, eyes gleaming with fury in tune with the amber glow of the candelabra.
"I lost them too, Reg," Remus hissed, stepping toward his nephew with slow, heavy strides. "All of them. James, Lily, your mum, Sirius..."
"Sirius is still alive!" Regulus burst out, digging his nails into his scalp. "And they’re going to lock him up—"
"For Merlin’s sake, Regulus!" Remus’s voice thundered over his. "Sirius is a murderer! He killed a dozen Muggles... he killed Lily and James! Our best friends! Harry’s an orphan because of him!" he shouted, tears now streaking down his cheeks. "Because of him." He wiped them away angrily.
Regulus recoiled. He still refused to believe Sirius was capable of that. He’d recognised him—he could see his godfather under the dog’s skin, the joyful man who used to play the piano for him, who tucked him into bed, who made him strawberry pancakes every morning. Sirius couldn’t have done it. Not his Sirius. The man his mother had loved.
A storm of emotion began clawing its way out of his chest. Regulus simply inhaled sharply through his nose as he stood, reigning them in like a puppet master tugging the right strings to bury them deep again.
"Where are you going, Reg?" Remus asked, watching him with dark eyes, the scars on his face casting ominous shadows across his expression.
"I don’t know. What do you want me to say?" Regulus replied, his calm beginning to crack. "He’s a murderer. My mum was a murderer too. So was my dad. Happy now? I spend my life wondering what it would’ve been like to be raised by people who committed unforgivable crimes. Hoping that despite everything they did... they’d love me. Because... because... they’re all I’ve got."
Tears threatened, but Regulus forced them back.
"What are you talking about?!" Remus asked, voice breaking. "You’ve got me, you’ve got your uncles... and we love you. I know it wasn’t perfect, but... we did everything we could to make you happy, we—"
"I know, Uncle. I know." Reggie took a deep breath, eyes squeezed shut. "But it wasn’t enough to quiet how much I miss them. I know it’s stupid, but..."
Remus sank into the sofa, burying his face in his hands. His shoulders shook with a silent sob. Then he wiped his tears and ran a hand over his moustache, not daring to look at Regulus.
"I’m sorry if I wasn’t enough. I did my best."
Reggie felt a sharp pain in his chest, like he’d been stabbed. Regret. Because the expression on Remus’s face wasn’t anger or outrage anymore—it was... disappointment. Disappointment in himself. And a bit of exhaustion too.
"I didn’t mean... I didn’t mean to..." Reggie stammered, reaching a hand toward his uncle, trying to gather back the sharp words he’d flung. "I-I’m sorry..."
"I need to be alone," Remus whispered, rising from the sofa so quickly that Reg couldn’t stop him.
Regulus opened and closed his mouth several times, utterly lost for words. But it was too late; Remus slammed his bedroom door shut, leaving him there in the sitting room, the crackling fireplace the only sound cutting through the agonising silence.
"Shit," Reg muttered, biting his tongue, wishing he’d kept his mouth shut. Despite everything, Remus had been the one who cared for him most. And all he’d given back was bitterness.
He left his uncle’s rooms still reeling from everything he’d said and everything that had happened. He didn’t want to believe Sirius was some cold-blooded killer, not even with all the damning evidence. Reg gasped, leaning against the wall near the Grand Staircase when the urge to cry became too strong to fight. He was an idiot.
The biggest, most complete idiot of them all.
"Black!"
A voice he knew all too well called out. He didn’t pay it much attention. He was too lost in his own chaos to care about anything else.
"Black!" the voice came again, and he saw that it was Harry.
The Gryffindor stood tall, as if ready to go head-to-head with him. Harry was shorter than Regulus, and had to tilt his chin to meet his eyes.
"You forgot to mention something very important that day!" He had his wand in his hand, gripping it so tightly his knuckles were white. "Your uncle handed my parents over to Voldemort!"
Regulus couldn’t have cared less about what Harry was saying. He wasn’t even fully there in that moment—just a powerless, silent observer to the whirlwind of emotions tearing through him. In a sudden motion, he turned his back on the boy and started walking away.
"Stop running away!" This time, Harry dared to point the wand at him. Reg’s gaze locked on the tip of the holly wand, trailing down the boy’s arm to his sweaty fingers clamped around the wood, his wrist faintly trembling. "Why didn’t you tell me your uncle was a traitor?! Oh, maybe because he raised you until you were three?! Or because your mum went out with him?! Or because he’s our godfather?! Why didn’t anyone tell me..."
"Harry… lower your wand," Hermione whispered. Regulus glanced away, eyes drifting toward the empty corridor. Besides Harry and his friend, Ron was there too.
A thousand possible responses raced through Regulus’s mind, but the truth was, he had nothing to say. All that came out was a tired sniff and a weary shrug of his shoulders.
"I didn’t know what to tell you," he finally confessed. "You were going to react like this… and… what was I supposed to say? I remember you, because Sirius used to take me to your parents’ house, and I used to watch you in your dad’s arms. I know that every night before bed, James would play you a Beatles song on the guitar. Your mum, Lily, she’d sing. And I remember her singing like an angel."
Harry slowly lowered his wand, his face twisting with the onset of tears. He shoved his glasses up in that same twitch James used to have. His bright green eyes, so sharp and clear, scraped over Regulus like a blade.
They barely noticed the corridor beginning to fill with students leaving the Great Hall on their way back to their common rooms.
"What’s going on here?" A boy with pale blond hair and a mocking tone looked down at Harry with disdain. "Why are you talking to that blood traitor, Regulus?"
Reggie turned to face the shorter boy in Slytherin robes. Draco looked far too interested in the scene, and his two goons were already sidling up beside him.
"It’s none of your business, Malfoy," Harry growled, pocketing his wand and spinning on his heel, marching off at a brisk pace. Percy Weasley, distinguished by his pointed hat, followed closely behind him. Ron and Hermione remained.
"I wasn’t talking to you, Potter!" Draco muttered, narrowing his eyes at the other two Gryffindors. "What are you lot doing here?!"
Hermione opened her mouth to answer, but Ron tugged her by the wrist and the two of them followed the current of students down the corridor.
"Why are you talking to me, Malfoy? We’re not friends!" Regulus crossed his arms, glaring at him from head to toe.
Draco cleared his throat, lifting his chin the way all those pompous pure-bloods did when they were about to say something insufferable.
"Because we’re family," he replied, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
Regulus gave a snort of derisive laughter, already turning to leave him standing there.
"You and half of Slytherin. Doesn’t mean much..."
"Actually, my mother... she... she was telling me the other day... about your father."
Regulus froze, his fingers tightening around the fabric of his cloak.
"My father?"
"Yeah, they were cousins..." Draco rolled his eyes. "She said he was very... respectable. Despite marrying your mum."
"What’s that supposed to mean?" Reg raised an eyebrow.
Draco seemed to enjoy the confusion on his face.
"That he only married her because your grandfather was obsessed with the Gaunts of the Signet line... so... is it true you’ve got one?" He grinned wickedly, eyes flicking down to Regulus’s gloved left hand.
Regulus clenched his fists, fury bubbling through his bones. He really wanted to punch Draco Malfoy’s smug little face in—but he didn’t. He’d gotten himself into enough trouble already... and what Draco said actually made sense. Why else would his mother marry Regulus?!
She seemed head over heels for Sirius the very same year she married his father. There was no way she could’ve just fallen out of love with Sirius and suddenly loved Regulus...
Unless...
Had she loved them both?
Regulus just shook his head and left Malfoy and his bodyguards behind, his thoughts frying as he tried to untangle his parents’ marriage. The Signet on the back of his hand itched at the mere mention of it. Hardly anyone knew he had one—Victoria and Luana were the only Hogwarts students who’d ever seen it.
"Reg!" As if summoned by his thoughts, Lua threw her arms around him the moment he stepped into the Slytherin common room, hugging him so tight he could barely breathe.
"Lua..." he muttered, with only half the energy she had. He gently pushed her away and drew in a deep breath, letting it out in one long gust.
"Are you feeling better? Did Madam Pomfrey sort out the scratches?!"
The excitement that had lit up her face at seeing him quickly shifted to concern. Sometimes, Reggie was honestly surprised by how freely Luana wore her emotions—no filter, no shame.
"Yeah. Left a scar, but... it’s fine." Regulus offered a small, shy smile, shoving his hands into his pockets.
"I’m sure it was a cat attack..." She adjusted her bun, lowering her voice like she was sharing a secret. "I mean, there’s this cat... really odd... I’ve seen it wandering around here a few times... I’ve tripped over it too. Oh, and during the Hufflepuff match, it landed on Mimi’s lap and scratched her arms—"
"Lua... if this is your way of pushing me to talk to Victoria—"
"No, it’s not about that!" she interrupted quickly, slinging an arm over his shoulders and pulling him with her toward the massive windows, where the green fire from the chandeliers reflected in the polished glass.
"Have you noticed that tuxedo cat... lurking about?" she narrowed her dark eyes suspiciously, her long brows drawing tight with unease.
"Luana… look at this common room. There are, like, fifteen cats just in here." Regulus let out a nasal laugh, sitting on the built-in window bench. "And thirteen of them are tuxedos."
"This one’s different, Reg!" she insisted, pointing to a cluster of cats sleeping near the fireplace. "I swear he’s been watching us…"
Regulus scoffed. He didn’t have time for his friend’s nonsense—he was too busy drowning in his own thoughts. His gaze drifted instinctively toward the mermaid staircase, where a long white mane stood out starkly against a black Slytherin cloak.
Victoria covered her mouth as she laughed at a joke from Pucey, but her eyes soon met Regulus and Luana. Her smile faded immediately, her gaze dropping to the stone floor. She clutched her books tighter, squared her shoulders, and made her way over.
"Are you alright? Lua said you were in the hospital wing…" she asked, touching his shoulder like nothing had happened.
Reggie’s grey eyes turned to steel, raking over her with cold severity. Victoria swallowed and pulled her hand back, her face tightening in visible dismay.
"I’m fine. Just a stray cat," he muttered, jaw clenching.
"A cat? I was attacked by one too—during the Hufflepuff match against Gryffindor..." She tugged up the sleeve of her cloak and shirt, revealing the scar from the scratch. "When the Dementors—"
"It’s the same cat!" Luana interrupted, grabbing her friend’s wrist. "I’m telling you, Reggie, there’s something weird—"
"Oh, Luana, stop making stuff up," Regulus groaned, pushing his fringe out of his eyes and exhaling sharply. "Seriously."
She just shrugged, giving up on the subject.
"Have you figured out how your uncle got in here?" Victoria asked after a long, heavy pause.
Regulus looked away, then back at her with a glare.
"Keep your voice down!" he hissed, wrinkling his nose. He’d wanted to tell them over the past few weeks about Sirius being Padfoot, about their encounter—but chose not to. Especially not with Mimi around—not after her childish behaviour. "Maybe… maybe he just doesn’t look the way people expect," Regulus muttered, pushing off the wall and walking toward the dormitory stairs.
"Off to bed already?!" Luana bit the inside of her cheek when Reggie nodded. "You’re really staying here for Christmas?"
Regulus nodded once more before disappearing down the corridor to the boys’ dormitories.
Victoria let out a sigh, glancing at her friend.
"Do you think he’ll forgive me?" she asked quietly.
Luana shrugged.
"What you did to him was a real dick move, Mimi," she said bluntly.
Mimi’s posture deflated like a collapsed soufflé. It was strange seeing Luana without her usual teasing grin.
"You should apologise."
"Apologise? I didn’t do anything wrong!" Victoria scoffed with a sardonic laugh. "I just—"
"Oh, Mimi… not even you believe that." Lua frowned, her brows drawing together. "Anyway, what’s he like?"
"Ced?" Victoria’s face lit up with a sweet smile. "He’s lovely. Everything Regulus failed to be," she added, starry-eyed.
"They do kind of look alike… physically, I mean." Lua pursed her lips. "But I still prefer Reg. In this House, we do not fraternise with Hufflepuffs." She crossed her fingers solemnly, as if making a sacred vow.
Victoria laughed, casting one last glance toward the boys’ dormitory.
Cedric wasn’t Regulus. He never would be.
Her smile faded as Luana tugged her toward the girls’ dorms.
.
.
.
Maybe staying at the castle for Christmas hadn’t been the brightest idea. With fewer students around, it meant being watched was much easier. As a prefect, Regulus had been saddled with responsibilities he hadn’t anticipated. He now patrolled the highest towers — something he was fairly sure had been Remus’s doing, a preventative measure to stop him sneaking off to Hogsmeade — and had to write up detailed reports on everything, even when absolutely nothing happened (aside from the fact that Peeves had tormented him non-stop for the first two days).
He didn’t do the rounds alone. Aphelandra Pyke had also stayed behind for the holidays, and as a sixth-year prefect, she was assigned to accompany him. Naturally, Regulus paid her no mind — not even when she offered easy smiles or let her hand linger in places it shouldn’t.
He took advantage of the quiet days to study for his OWLs. Most of the time, Luana was plotting her revenge against the Weasleys while moaning about how hard it was to cast a Patronus. It didn’t take long for Regulus to tire of her constant griping and drag her out to practise in the snow-blanketed garden just outside the castle.
Reggie squinted against the glaring brightness, lifting a hand to shade his face as he raised his wand.
"The trick is… to focus on the feeling of the memory. The happiness in it," he explained, rotating his wrist. "Expecto Patronum!" A lion burst from the tip of his wand, racing across the snow-dusted fountain. Its pale glow mingled with the fridge-like winter sunlight before leaping into the air and dissolving into silvery mist.
Luana rolled her eyes, arms crossed.
"Show-off," she muttered, but resumed practising straight after.
Christmas arrived before long. Regulus wanted to patrol Hogwarts that day, especially because the castle was nearly deserted — almost exactly like it had been on Halloween, according to his calculations. He’d wandered the corridors so many times by now he could recite every crack in the stone, and he’d become acquainted with countless figures from various portraits.
As he made his way to the Great Hall for Christmas lunch, he spotted Aphelandra leaning against the marble banister of the main staircase. She waved at him, skipping over with an annoyingly cheerful bounce in her step.
"Merry Christmas, Regulus," she said, eyeing him with interest. "Why are you always wandering the corridors? There’s no one left to monitor…"
Reggie flinched as a cold draft swept past them, rustling the streamers overhead.
"Just making sure everything’s in order," he replied, glancing at the great doors of the Hall. "Well, we’d better head in..."
"Ah, Reggie Black!" A ghost called out, loud and clear. Regulus turned toward him, raising an eyebrow. It was a knight with an arrow lodged in the middle of his forehead. "You’ve cut your hair?! I preferred it longer!" he said, tugging on the reins of his horse as he approached.
Regulus licked his upper lip, visibly thrown off. He’d never spoken to that ghost before.
"Er... s-sorry, have we met?" he asked, clearing his throat and arching a brow.
"Don’t be cheeky, boy!" the ghost said, pointing a spectral finger at him before beaming at Aphelandra. "Miss, I am the Black Knight."
Aphelandra gave a graceful curtsy.
"Charmed," she said, tossing her dark hair over her shoulder. "Aphelandra Pyke."
"And how is your friend… what’s her name again…" The ghost tapped a finger against his chin, thinking. "Ah, yes! Luna! Luna Lovegood."
"What? I don’t even know who—"
"I’ve found where they hid her pair of shoes. They’re in the Astronomy Tower. As soon as you reach the one hundred and seventh step, just look up at the wooden rafters and you’ll see them…" He gestured vaguely toward the tower, then glanced at an invisible watch. "Well, I must be off, can’t be late for the ghosts’ Christmas party! Lovely chatting with you!"
He spurred his horse into a gallop, disappearing in the direction of the dungeons.
Regulus and Aphelandra stood staring into the empty space for quite some time.
"What was that?" she asked, giving him a curious smile.
"I’ve no idea."
.
.
.
James knew he needed to tell someone.
Even though Lily disagreed, firmly believing that Sirius couldn’t have done it, it was obvious. He’d known Sirius his entire life—only he would have sent Harry a Firebolt. Besides, they needed to refine Scarlett’s plan: capture Wormtail and hand him over to the Ministry. But to do that, she’d have to speak to Dumbledore.
However, approaching the Headmaster without getting hexed or thrown in a cell would require some… special measures.
First, getting into his office. Not just anyone could manage that and… thinking about it, breaking into Dumbledore’s office did sound like an incredibly stupid plan. Especially with everyone on high alert because of Sirius. But it was the only time they could catch the Headmaster alone.
There was another problem too: James and Regulus didn’t always know the password to his office — and aside from changing constantly, they’d recently learned that the ghosts at Hogwarts could see them.
And there was always a ghost drifting through those corridors. James couldn’t risk being seen, even though Regulus had already been recognised by a passing knight. Thankfully, the ghost hadn’t realised that this Regulus and little Reggie were not the same person.
James didn’t even want to imagine what would happen if he were recognised. Besides, no living person—aside from Scarlett—could see them. And it was clear they were doing a brilliant job keeping an eye on Harry and Regulus—not to mention Wormtail, though facing that rat was both difficult and sickening.
He fully understood Sirius’s rage. Still… it was hard to imagine him actually killing Peter. If he were honest, James still hadn’t wrapped his head around what had happened to their group of friends. He preferred to deal with the urgent matters first and leave the heartbreak for later.
Getting Sirius cleared was their top priority.
It was odd, but the thing James liked most about being a ghost was getting to watch Scarlett and Sirius interact again without them realising he was there. Not that he was some sort of voyeur (and not like he needed to be—he’d seen both of them starkers anyway), but rather the comfort in noticing that they still held traces of the young pair he’d loved so fiercely. It had always been James who comforted Scarlett whenever she and Sirius rowed. And it was James who’d held Sirius up when Scarlett left. Seeing that, despite everything, they still got along…
It made him grin like an idiot at the walls.
He’d always known they’d end up together. And now, they had a real chance at being a family. James had no idea what future lay ahead for him and Lily, so cruelly bound to Scarlett. But he knew that seeing them happy made him happy—and, right now, that was all that mattered.
At the same time, he feared for Scarlett. She often stared off into nothing, fingers absently brushing the scar on her forearm, or the Signet on the back of her hand. Lost in memories. Bitter or sweet? James couldn’t tell. But she seemed more and more weighed down with each passing day.
He didn’t know exactly what month it was, but the snow still fell outside, so it must’ve been January or February. Scarlett and Sirius were getting closer, though that invisible barrier between them still loomed, immovable. There were stolen glances, subtle smiles, and hesitant touches. It was like they were meeting each other all over again. As if they were learning how to live with the new versions of themselves, trying to add those fragments to a broken, misshapen mosaic. But it was hard picking up the pieces—they were sharp, fragile... and even harder to fit together, as they never seemed to match. Only repel.
Scarlett watched, hypnotised, the swirling mix of fire and snow reflected in the mirror above the mantelpiece. She avoided looking directly at her own reflection as much as possible. She didn’t recognise herself—not just because of Azkaban, but because… she still looked so young.
And that hurt.
She looked like the same eighteen-year-old girl who had made all the wrong choices. As if she weren’t shattered inside. Constantly waking from sleep to the sound of her own screams, her muscles locking up as though she were being tortured all over again. As if the crimson flashes of the Cruciatus still licked across her skin in unbearable, burning agony.
Scarlett would never go back to Azkaban. She’d rather die than return.
Maybe that’s why the thought of sneaking into Dumbledore’s office filled her with such dread. He’d never trusted her—not even back when they were just students—and she’d never been a member of the Order of the Phoenix, unlike all her friends... and Sirius.
She shrank at the thought of all the dead.
She’d been there when Fab and Gid were killed—saving Sirius in the process. She didn’t remember much, but muddled flashes of that day still invaded her mind from time to time. Gideon’s surprise at seeing her, the look he gave her stomach before attacking without hesitation.
She pulled the watch from the pocket of her overcoat.
She didn’t dare open it again.
She knew the moment she saw the image of young Sirius pulling a face at her, she’d break down in tears.
"What are you thinking about?" James’s voice pulled her out of her reverie. She glanced over her shoulder at him and slipped the watch back into her pocket, his ghostly glow reflecting in the mirror as he sat on the arm of the chair.
Scar gave a distracted half-smile.
"Azkaban." The smile vanished as soon as the word left her lips. "I’m scared, Jamie."
James wanted to hold her, even knowing it wasn’t possible. His fingers passed through her auburn-brown hair in a futile attempt at comfort.
"Scared of what? Of going back?"
She nodded.
"I don’t know if I… if I can. I can’t… I still feel... the Cruciatus hitting me… the pain… the terror… do you really think the plan to clear Sirius will work? He seems hell-bent on killing Peter."
James swallowed hard, removing his glasses to wipe them on the hem of his coat.
"I don’t know, Scar. But if he kills Wormtail… how’s he going to prove he’s innocent? Is he just going to spend the rest of his life on the run? Harry… and Reg… they need you both."
"How am I supposed to be with them, Jamie? Everyone thinks I’m dead."
"We’ll think of something." He gave her that warm, familiar smile—the one that always made Scarlett’s problems seem small and stupid. "He still fancies you, you know."
Scarlett turned her gaze back to the worn, threadbare rug, burying her head between her knees.
"Stop it," she muttered, her voice muffled.
James made a noise of disgust.
"Is it really that terrifying, the idea of you two getting back together?" he teased, slipping his glasses back onto his face. "Just because he looks like Jim Morrison post-heavy drugs?"
Scarlett allowed herself to laugh at that.
"Jim Morrison died post-heavy drugs, Jamie," she said, turning her head toward him, her blue eyes glinting with a rare flicker of amusement he hadn’t seen in ages.
"And you’re telling me Padfoot doesn’t look like a corpse?"
"He does not!" Scarlett rubbed her eyes, feeling her cheeks heat.
"You really do love him! Because he looks awful! Like he’s pushing fifty!"
"He doesn’t!" she huffed. "It’s the beard… it’s always made him look older than he is… ever since our last year at Hogwarts. Remember how he insisted on growing it out?"
James smiled at the memory, nodding.
"Remember when he passed out drunk and you grabbed that witchy magazine about facial hair and made his moustache grow out like Salvador Dalí’s? I gave you a comb and we sat there styling it so it stuck straight out… then Sirius woke up, threw up all over himself… and when we dragged him to the loo, he screamed the moment he saw his reflection—" Scarlett’s expression softened into a wide smile, and for some reason, the laughter made her want to cry. "What was it he yelled again?"
"‘What have you done to my moustache?!’" James flailed his arms dramatically, raising his voice into a shrill impression. "‘I’m going to kill you—’" He mimed retching mid-sentence.
Scarlett’s laughter rang through the Shrieking Shack, even though her instincts screamed at her to stop—to stop laughing, stop feeling joy, stop remembering a time when their biggest worry was whether Sirius would stop vomiting or not.
She wanted so badly to rest her head on James’s shoulder like she used to—and knowing that was impossible turned all the joy into sharp little tears clawing at her heart.
"What’s so funny?" Sirius’s voice echoed from the staircase.
Scarlett straightened up, eyes wide. She hadn’t realised he was there. She shrank slightly, resting her chin on her knees as he stepped into the room with a dinner bag in hand. James shot her a knowing smile before slipping away, leaving the two alone.
"I-I-I just..." she stammered, trying to gather her thoughts. It was like Sirius’s mere presence had the power to scramble them. "I was remembering something."
"Remembering what?" Sirius tucked his hair behind one ear and set the bag down on the bed before sitting opposite her.
James was wrong.
Sirius was still beautiful, even beneath all the hardened edges Azkaban had carved into him. His grey eyes now gleamed like polished silver, and the pale skin on his face no longer looked stretched so thin. His long lashes half-veiled the soft lines around his eyes, and his lips had regained their natural, arrogant curve.
He looked at her with those wide pupils that were her undoing. Scarlett turned her face away, pretending to be overly curious about whatever he’d brought instead of answering.
"What’s for dinner?" she asked, changing the subject and avoiding his gaze.
Sirius pulled out a polystyrene container from the bag and popped it open to reveal Cornish pasties—filled with beef, potato, onion, and turnip. Scarlett’s stomach growled loudly and her mouth watered.
"Snagged this off some unsuspecting kid," he said smugly, wickedly pleased with himself.
"Sirius!" Scarlett scolded him, as if he’d committed some horrid crime.
"She won’t even remember it!" he shrugged, getting up to offer her one.
"I thought you weren’t going back to Hogsmeade after what happened," Scarlett said, nibbling the crust, her eyes fluttering shut as the rich flavour danced across her tongue.
"Yeah… and I didn’t. Technically, I nicked it from a roadside vendor. I wasn’t about to risk Hogsmeade with nightfall that close," he admitted, sitting back down on the bed. "What were you remembering?"
Scarlett licked her lips, savouring every last second of the greasy, glorious taste of the pasty, even though it had gone cold.
"That time you were pissed out of your mind and I… and James… made your moustache look like Salvador Dalí’s," she said slowly, sucking her fingers clean. Sirius glanced sideways toward the window, where the wind howled through the cracks, tossing the ends of his hair and the collar of his coat. "It’s alright, it’s not the Dementors," she said softly, reassuring him.
Sirius wiped a bit of sauce from his beard with his thumb. He tried to stay serious, but the corners of his mouth curled upwards. The silver in his eyes turned soft, carefree, and the two of them started laughing.
"You remember?!" Scarlett covered her mouth with her hand.
"I was pissed!" he defended, shoulders shaking with amusement.
"Yeah, but... you woke up the next day so angry… but it was bloody hilarious…" Scarlett threw her head back, resting it against the back of the armchair. "You threw up so much…"
Sirius brushed some crumbs off the collar of his coat.
"And you looked after me," he added, the amusement slowly fading. "You and Prongs."
Prongs.
Scarlett smiled at the nickname and nodded.
"So… you do remember." She cleared her throat, suddenly self-conscious.
"Yeah… now I do." Sirius looked at her again, and for a few seconds they went quiet—serious—before smiling once more. "What happened?"
"What do you mean?" Scarlett crumpled the food wrapper and lobbed it at the bag, missing entirely.
"You’re… happy," Sirius said, vanishing the rubbish with a quick Evanesco, leaning his face against the bedpost without taking his eyes off her. "I haven’t seen you like this since we escaped."
Scarlett felt her cheeks warm. She hadn’t allowed herself to feel hope in ages, and even the faintest hint of imagining a future with Sirius, Regulus, and Harry made the pasty in her stomach twist uneasily.
"Not everything we went through was awful," she murmured, tinged with sadness. "Actually… a lot of it was good."
Sirius stayed still, running his tongue over his lower lip.
"It was, yeah," he agreed softly. "But then… you left, and the war..." He sniffed, rubbing his nose with the back of his hand. "The war tore us apart."
The light atmosphere grew heavy. The candles crackled faintly, and Scarlett shivered as another gust of wind blew into the room—dry and bitter. Sirius’s eyes widened slightly, his fingers twitching around his wand.
"You can sleep. I’ll keep watch," Scarlett offered, rising from the armchair.
"I’m not tired," Sirius replied, tucking his wand away slowly, like he was fighting against his instincts. "Besides, you always take first watch and never actually sleep."
"I slept plenty in Azkaban." Scarlett pressed her lips into a thin line, her voice laced with dry irony.
"Yeah, that’s why you’ve got those charming under-eye bags," he shot back quickly, clearly enjoying the way she scowled in surprise. "Go on, Scarlett—get some bloody sleep."
"Alright, Dad," she muttered, rolling her eyes as she took off her coat and slid under the covers. The blankets were freezing, but any cold she might have felt was driven off by the look Sirius gave her over his shoulder.
He took off his own coat as well, laying it across the piano bench before climbing into bed beside her. They’d been sleeping like that for days now—close, but never crossing a line. Still, the scent of Sirius clung to the sheets: a mix of something sweet and crisp that she couldn’t quite place.
She never really knew, to be honest. She just knew that was Sirius’s scent—part cologne, part skin. He lay there staring up at the wooden canopy of the bed, hands resting on his stomach, tattooed fingers fidgeting endlessly. Lost in thought. Scarlett turned her head slightly upward, her eyes following his gaze to the same invisible point: tomorrow.
For a fleeting moment, it was just Scarlett and Sirius, lying side by side in the bed of the Shrieking Shack, dreaming of a future where happiness might actually be possible. Not two Azkaban convicts. Not a murderer and an innocent man.
"You need to be proven innocent," Scarlett murmured.
Sirius turned his head to look at her, his cheek sinking into the soft pillow, black hair tracing the sharp edges of his face, tumbling down his neck, spilling across the white sheets like tendrils of midnight sky. Silence fell again, and Scarlett had the distinct feeling they were thinking the exact same thing.
"Peter needs to die," he said firmly. "Then I’ll worry about proving anything."
Scarlett sighed, moistening her lips.
"Peter is the key to your innocence, Sirius," she tried to explain, though there was hesitation in her voice.
Sirius shook his head.
"No, he’s not. They didn’t even give me a trial. Just chucked me straight into Azkaban." His voice was barely more than a whisper, tinged with something raw and frightened. "I can’t risk it."
Scarlett understood.
As much as she wanted to argue, to convince him that turning Peter in was the right thing, she understood his fear.
It was her fear too.
She was just as terrified of going back to that hell.
"Alright then," she said softly, reluctantly. "But Harry and Reg..."
The sentence hung between them. Harry and Reg. What was she meant to say? The boys didn’t even know her. She was Regulus’s mother, yes, but why would he choose to stay with her? And Harry...
"We’ll be their family," Sirius said simply, as if it were simple. "We’ll live in our—" he cleared his throat. "In the house we bought… and… well, we’ll be a family."
Scarlett’s heart thudded just imagining it. Of course Sirius would include her—she was Regulus’s mother, and he was the boy’s uncle and godfather.
She exhaled deeply. James was wrong—he didn’t love her. He couldn’t. There was fondness, yes, a bond built on history and survival. But love?
That was asking too much.
Which was ironic, really—because Scarlett did love Sirius.
It was as certain as the sunrise and the death of stars. Just because she’d buried that feeling when she was locked away in Azkaban didn’t mean it had vanished. It had always been there, quiet and careful… but unchanged.
Sirius was woven into her very DNA the same way her eyes were blue and her skin was pale—etched into her like the freckles across her face and the tattoos inked into her back. He belonged to her heart, to her past, to her present—bound to her in a way that could never truly be severed.
Reggie was the proof of that connection—the evidence that love could both create and destroy.
She didn’t realise when sleep claimed her, nor when Sirius gently hooked his pinky finger around hers.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 17: Love will survive somehow, somewhere
Chapter Text
LXXXV
"She needs to know, James." Regulus leaned against the remains of the kitchen counter in the Shrieking Shack.
"If that broom was a gift from Sirius, do you really think half the Ministry hasn’t already tracked the purchase order?!"
"But… Harry’s been training with it just fine and… and nothing’s changed in Hogsmeade. There aren’t any Aurors there, just… Dementors."
"And how do you know there aren’t any Aurors?! Have you been stationed there, watching?!" Regulus snapped, folding his arms. "Do you even realise the danger they’re in? I always knew Sirius was thick, but you as well?!"
James wrinkled his nose.
"He’s not thick… he’s my best mate," he muttered, clearly shaken. "My dream’s always been to become a professional player. And… and… Sirius knew that. He’d never leave Harry unprotected. I know it was a bloody stupid move, but… Sirius is a lot more than you think he is."
"I don’t care what I think of Sirius or what I don’t. Scarlett needs to know." He stared his friend down with those steely, unflinching eyes.
"She can’t know… not now. They’ll fall out, Red. They’re finally getting along so well!" James grabbed his shoulders, looking at him with those hazel eyes behind his glasses.
"I don’t give a toss, Jay! He’s putting the two of them in danger over some whim!" Regulus rolled his eyes in frustration.
"It’s not a whim!" James’s voice cracked, thick with emotion. "It’s for my son. He’s his godfather… to both of our kids."
Regulus let out a laugh — cold and hollow.
"You and Scarlett always bloody covered for Sirius. Didn’t matter what kind of shit he pulled, the pair of you were always there, ready with the excuses. But I’m not letting his recklessness land her back in Azkaban. I won’t let her be a lab rat again." He shot James a sharp look.
"Do you still hate him? After everything he’s been through?" James didn’t seem upset, nor particularly surprised. He’d followed the whole saga between Regulus and Sirius — only ever hearing one side of it, of course — but now he had the chance to understand Red’s.
"I don’t hate him," Regulus confessed, and before he could say anything else, the door creaked open and Scarlett appeared, cheeks flushed from the cold, her coat damp with snow.
She looked at them as if silently asking what was going on. James swallowed hard, his expression clearly betraying that things were anything but normal. Regulus, on the other hand, wiped any trace of emotion from his face.
"You need to know something…" Red shrugged James’s hands off his shoulders, staring directly at Scarlett. "Sirius bought Harry a Firebolt."
Scarlett remained silent, and Lily stepped through the door behind her.
"Ready to watch Gryffindor stomp Ravenclaw?!" The redhead wore a wide grin on her face, which quickly faded as she noticed the expression on her friends’ faces. "Did something happen?"
Without saying a word, Scarlett headed upstairs. She found Sirius playing with the ginger cat, dangling a shoelace. She leaned against the doorframe, eyes blazing at him, her nails scraping along the seam of her gloves, tension thrumming in her shoulders.
She didn’t want to argue, but the mere thought of going back to Azkaban sent an endless chill through her gut, twisting her stomach and dampening her palms with cold sweat. Panic swallowed her whole, and breathing became a task.
"Sirius…" she called out, the shock of the discovery turning quickly into fury. "You gave Harry a Firebolt?"
The smile vanished from Sirius’s face. He looked up at her, his irises twin pools of restless, gleaming silver. A thousand lies flickered across his eyes, but Scarlett could read every one of them. He cleared his throat.
"Yes." That was all he said, turning his attention back to the cat.
Scarlett exhaled sharply through her teeth, scrubbing at the Signet on the back of her hand with force.
"You’re unbelievable, Sirius," she muttered, trying not to let the panic show.
"It’s just a bloody broom, no one’s going to find out. I ordered it in Harry’s name—"
"Just a bloody broom?!" Scar cut him off. "Why are you constantly putting us at risk?! What the fuck is wrong with you?"
The cat gave a startled hop as Scarlett’s voice rose, and Sirius dropped the string to the floor.
"What’s wrong with me? The boy lost his broom, I wasn’t going to leave him without one! I’m his godfather!" Sirius snapped back, visibly irritated.
"You could’ve told me! And even if you signed it under his name, where the hell did that money come from?!"
"I tried, that’s why I wanted the fucking Invisibility Cloak, but you made up some little lie so I sorted it myself!"
"You should’ve told me anyway! You need to trust me, Sirius!" Scarlett gasped, on the verge of tears. She wasn’t sure whether she was crying from fear, frustration, or the sting of betrayal from Sirius’s reckless behaviour. Her words, however, made his jaw tighten, fury igniting behind his gaze.
"Trust you?" He stepped closer, lifting his chin at its most arrogant angle, eyeing her like a predator. "After everything you’ve done to me, you still expect me to trust you?!"
Scarlett felt a knot beginning to form in her throat. The sob rising in her chest, tears pooling in her eyes. She didn’t want to cry in front of Sirius—she’d broken down too many times already, and she couldn’t bear to feel any more vulnerable than she already did around him.
"This isn’t going to work if you don’t trust me," she replied, hating how shaky and fragile her voice sounded.
Sirius wet his lips, the silver of his gaze sharpening into twin blades.
"Did you think about me when he was fucking you?" His atrocious question came out no louder than a whisper.
"What?" Scarlett blinked, unable to believe what she’d just heard. Her heart roared in her chest, despair crashing over her like a tidal wave, forcing tears down her cheeks.
[Music: Journey — Who’s Crying Now]
Sirius stepped closer, so near now that Scarlett could feel his dark hair brushing against her shoulders. He was a head taller, and the light seeping in through the cracks in the window wasn’t enough to banish the malevolent shadow cloaking his eyes.
"Did you think about me when Regulus was fucking you?" Sirius repeated cruelly.
Before Scarlett even realised it, her hand struck his face, slapping him hard. His black hair fell forward, hiding his features, but it couldn’t conceal his eyes. In the shadow he cast over her, the silver turned to steel.
It's been a mystery
But still they try to see
Why something good can hurt so bad
Caught on a one-way street
The taste of bittersweet
Love will survive somehow, somewhere
Sirius grabbed her by the neck, pressing Scarlett’s body against the wall. He wasn’t choking her, not truly—it was more a silent threat, a demand that she answer his question. For a moment, they just stared at each other, neither looking away.
Scarlett clenched her jaw as he loomed closer, tears blurring her vision, leaving only the darker hues of Sirius’s eyes in focus—the same iron that haunted Regulus’s irises. And in the next second, the man standing before her wasn’t Sirius anymore.
It was Red.
One love, feeds the fire
One heart, burns desire
I wonder who's crying now?
Two hearts, born to run
Who'll be the lonely one?
I wonder who's crying now?
The gas lamps in Regulus’s bedroom at Grimmauld Place flickered softly, their flames trembling as the door creaked open under the force of the wind. Scarlett clenched the velvet fabric of her dress between her fingers, seated on the bed. Regulus knelt in front of her, gently running his forefinger over her swollen belly.
"You don’t know what you’re talking about." Scarlett was so tense her neck ached.
"I’m not lying, Scar." The orange flame danced in Regulus’s irises. "I love you."
She slapped him hard across the face, her left hand leaving a red mark on the right side of his cheek. He closed his eyes, as if he were afraid.
"Shut your mouth!" Scarlett hissed. "You don’t know what that even means. You don’t know what love is!"
Regulus gripped her chin, forcing her into silence. Scarlett flinched at the touch, clutching his wrist tightly, unable to see him clearly as her vision was blurred with tears. Red’s hand was cold—so cold, just like his eyes. It had always been that way. He was the moon, and only the sun could give him warmth.
But Sirius wasn’t there.
So many stormy nights
So many wrong or rights
Neither could change their headstrong ways
And in a lover's rage
They turn another page
The fighting is worth the love they save
Regulus traced her jaw with his fingers, sliding them down to her throat. He could feel the frantic pulse of her blood, the air rushing in and out, the tense contraction of her muscles. The fear. He brushed his lips against hers, and she could taste the Firewhisky, even though they hadn’t properly kissed yet.
"You can say his name while we’re together, I don’t care," Red murmured against her lips, parting them as he kissed her softly. "Because I love you, and you’re mine."
Regulus’s mouth tasted of whisky and cigarettes—much like Sirius’s. But his tongue was shyer, gentler; and there wasn’t even a flicker of the fire she felt when she was with Sirius. Still, Red was right about one thing: it was easy to imagine he was the elder brother, especially with his fingers buried in her slightly wavy black hair.
One love, feeds the fire
One heart, burns desire
I wonder who's crying now?
Two hearts, born to run
Who’ll be the lonely one?
I wonder who's crying now?
Regulus laid her down on the bed, positioning himself over Scarlett as he deepened the kiss, grazing her lower lip with his teeth and brushing his tongue against hers, trying to silence all the voices that told him she would never be his—the certainty that she would never love him, the fear that she would leave.
He pinned Scarlett beneath his body when she made a move to push him away, clinging to her like a drowning man to a lifeboat. Regulus tangled his fingers in her blonde hair, smiling faintly into the kiss as he brooded over his fate.
There he was, once again, trying to take something that wasn’t his and never would be. Scarlett belonged to Sirius, the child was Sirius’s, and he was only there to be another replacement for his brother’s mistakes, trying to fix something that wasn’t even broken. Trying to belong, trying to give… knowing he’d never receive anything in return. But it was all Regulus had, and he had sworn to himself that he would never be alone again.
Only so many tears you can cry
'Til the heartache is over
And now you can say your love
Will never die
That’s why he would protect them with everything he had, opening his eyes only to find Scarlett’s already open. Drowning in that blue ocean, stormy and relentless, that Red had hated for so long. It was that rare moment that he noticed the hint of green around her pupils. He broke the kiss to catch his breath, stroking her soft cheeks.
It was that same look, that exact look Regulus had when he told her he loved her. The same look Sirius was giving her now. Scarlett felt sick. Sick with herself, with what she’d had to do to protect Reggie. Sirius’s expression shifted. He looked… sorry, as though he understood the shades of emotion in her eyes.
"You never loved him." Sirius’s lower lip trembled.
No. There was only room for Sirius Black in Scarlett Gaunt’s heart.
One love, feeds the fire
One heart, burns desire
I wonder who's crying now?
Two hearts, born to run
Who’ll be the lonely one?
I wonder who's crying now?
Scarlett felt Sirius’s breath ruffle a few strands of hair across her face and that was enough to make her shove him away reflexively, stumbling to the side as she tried to escape. But Sirius was faster, stronger—he grabbed her arm before she could leave the room.
"Why?" Sirius roared, gripping her wrist so tightly Scarlett felt her hand go numb. "If you didn’t love him, then why did you marry him… why did you have a child? Did he force you?" There were traces of anguish in his voice. Anguish… and something else.
Fear.
Between sobs, Scarlett shrank in on herself. She couldn’t look at him. She just shook her head, blinded by tears.
"Let go of me, Sirius." Scarlett pleaded, her voice barely more than a whisper.
"Tell me, Scarlett! Why?" he bellowed, yanking her toward him again. "Why?!"
"Let me go, Sirius. Let me go…" she repeated, hyperventilating. "Please…"
"Did he force you?"
"No!" Scarlett screamed back, and Sirius released her as if he’d been slapped all over again.
She stumbled backwards, gasping for air as she headed toward the stairs. She didn’t know where she was going—she just needed to get away from him.
"Scarlett!" he called out, his heavy steps pounding against the wooden floor.
More memories crashed into her, blinding and brutal, and she fell down the stairs.
One memory in particular made her choke on her own breath.
A pair of red eyes, pupils slit like a cat’s, gleaming with satisfaction at having Scarlett before him—on her knees, utterly at the mercy of his desires.
"We will create the most powerful wizard this world has ever seen," he declared, wearing a cruel smile.
Sirius tried to lift her. Scarlett felt dizzy, like the oxygen wasn’t reaching her brain. Her emotions rose in a violent surge inside her chest, and it took an immense effort to calm them enough to shift into Whiskers’ form. She bolted, running as fast as she could away from Sirius.
She tore through the tunnel of the Shrieking Shack in an instant. She didn’t even bother pressing the knot on the tree, darting between the snow-covered roots, hearing the Whomping Willow stir from its long slumber, shaking itself as it sensed movement.
The tree struck the ground with a thunderous crash near where she had passed, forcing her to glance back in fright. Padfoot was right behind her but halted at the tunnel’s mouth the moment a branch swooped past, tearing through the fresh carpet of snow.
Whiskers didn’t stop. The frigid wind tore through her lungs, her breath misted at her snout, and the sun vanished behind the looming trees until she was swallowed by the dim hush of the desolate Forbidden Forest.
.
.
.
Sirius frantically searched the roots of the Willow, scrambling to find the knot. The moment he pressed it, he shifted into Padfoot and took off, following the pawprints of the cat. He sniffed the air and quickened his pace in the direction she’d gone, slowing only when the fur along his spine bristled with instinct.
Padfoot looked up at the clear sky, at the ominous presences lurking among the trees. He desperately wanted to keep searching for Whiskers, but his fear surged violently as the chill of the Dementors triggered every alarm in his body, forcing him to turn back without a second thought, bolting for the dubious safety of the Shrieking Shack.
As soon as he transformed back, Sirius was gasping at the foot of the stairs, his whole body trembling as if he might be attacked at any moment. Just the thought of a Dementor nearby was enough to make his heart thunder with dread. At the same time, memories of the day Scarlett left threatened to resurface.
Sirius dug his nails into his hair, focusing only on breathing. Inhale, exhale. He had no idea how long he sat there doing just that, resisting the urge to break down in tears. He couldn’t fall apart. Not now. He had to focus, regain control, and—
A feline silhouette darted past him, fast. Sirius looked toward it, rubbing his eyes to see better.
"Whiskers?" he whispered, breathless. The cat’s eyes gleamed in the dark as it approached slowly, its feather-duster tail raised high. It wasn’t Whiskers. It was only Ginger. Just as Sirius opened his mouth to ask if he’d seen the cat, he noticed something clutched in the tom’s mouth.
Sirius reached out his hand and Ginger dropped a crumpled bit of paper into it. With shaky fingers, he unfolded it and squinted as he stood and moved closer to a candlestick, where a lone flame still flickered, dancing over the white page.
This week’s passwords for the Gryffindor common room…
He blinked several times, trying to be sure of what he was seeing. It had to be a sign. He’d search for Scarlett later… besides, she knew how to take care of herself.
At least, that’s what Sirius told himself as he imagined wrapping his hands around that miserable rat and squeezing until nothing was left but a mangled, pulpy mass of flesh, bone, fur, and blood.
.
.
.
Sir Cadogan was feeding his fat grey pony that night, after Gryffindor's victory over Ravenclaw. He was feeling rather glum, as none of the Hogwarts students wanted to duel him.
“Cowards!” the knight grumbled, watching his steed chew its supper. By that hour, it seemed everyone had gone to bed, and the corridor outside Gryffindor Tower was unusually quiet—the only sounds were the whisper of the wind and the distant snores from the portraits lining the main staircase.
Sir Cadogan turned to remove the saddle from his pony when a shadow began to stretch toward him. With a smug smile, he drew his sword and pointed it at the approaching figure: a hooded man.
“Halt!” he barked, standing tall, adrenaline coursing through his body at the sight of what appeared to be a worthy foe. “Ah, an intruder! State the password or prepare for combat, knave!” he taunted, eagerly awaiting a fiery response from the man before him.
The man simply pulled a piece of paper from his pocket and cleared his throat, fixing him with cold grey eyes.
“Caput Draconis.” He tapped the paper impatiently with his fingers.
“Incorrect!” Sir Cadogan slashed his sword through the air.
“Sporagons,” the man continued.
“Wrong!” the knight jumped slightly, as if gravely insulted.
“Fizzing whisbee…”
“No! Clearly, you are an invader! I shall ring the bell!” Still armed and alert, Sir Cadogan darted to the far left of his frame.
“Thong!” the man insisted.
Sir Cadogan paused before pulling the cord, turning back toward the man. A flicker of doubt mingled with his usual knightly bravado softened his expression.
“Did you mean… sarong?” he asked cautiously, with a faint note of pride at having caught an error.
The intruder squinted at the parchment again.
“Yes, I meant… sarong,” he said, running a hand through his thick beard, a wicked smile twisting his lips.
With a resigned sigh, still holding himself like a proper knight, Sir Cadogan stepped aside to let the man through.
“Very well, you’ve bested me this time!” He gestured with his sword, though the hooded figure barely acknowledged him.
Sirius had eyes only for the rat. He paid no mind to the flood of memories or nostalgia that crept in as he entered the common room, charging up the boys’ staircase as though he’d never left Hogwarts. He wouldn’t allow himself to get emotional—not like last time.
He didn’t even flinch when he noticed young Weasley shared the dorm with Harry. His eyes scanned the beds, moonlight pouring through the windows and bathing the room. His gaze settled on a trunk with colourful lettering: Longbottom. Something stirred at the back of Sirius’s mind, but he didn’t dwell on it.
The rat. He needed to find the rat. He flared his nostrils, instinctively acting like Padfoot, sniffing the air. It wasn’t hard to locate Weasley’s bed, and surely the rat would be with him—Wormtail always did prefer comfort.
He pulled out the rusted knife he’d found in the Shrieking Shack’s kitchen and slashed through the bed curtains in wild, desperate movements, his fingers slick with sweat as the splinters of metal dug into his skin.
Wormtail wasn’t there. Sirius felt his throat burn with bile as he backed away—just as he locked eyes with the boy.
Weasley screamed.
And Sirius had never run so fast in his life.
.
.
.
Scarlett could hear her heart pounding in her ears as she plunged deeper into the Forbidden Forest, running like a runaway train—fleeing not just from Sirius, but from her past and her memories.
She was sure James, Lily, and Regulus were shouting at her. But all she could hear was the rush of blood in her ears, the cold creeping into her coat, the air leaving her lips in thick clouds.
It was dark—so dark that the only light came from her ghosts. But her eyes stung and were so dry that she could barely see a hand’s breadth in front of her. She stumbled over a root and was swallowed by the soft snow on the ground.
She blinked rapidly, waiting for her sight to adjust to the gloom, watching the beams of moonlight splinter through the canopy of trees, fading before they could even touch the damp earth. Her face was wet and she didn’t know whether it was sweat or tears. Probably both.
James called her name over and over. He sounded terrified, but Scarlett paid him no mind, focusing instead on getting to her feet, ignoring the ache in her muscles from overexertion. She braced herself against a tree trunk and pushed up—only for a violent chill to race through her entire body, as though her bones themselves had frozen.
She collapsed again, and a foul stench twisted the meagre contents of her stomach. Scarlett’s eyes widened as cloaked figures approached hungrily.
She wasn’t quick enough to reach her glove, let alone cast a Patronus. Not that it would have worked—but she could have tried.
Too late. It was like plunging into a frozen lake, her limbs prickling with a numbness she couldn’t control. Cracking sounds echoed in her ears, until she opened her eyes—and a cold hand was clutching her chin.
The fingers were unnaturally long, the skin eerily pale. She stared into the pair of red eyes before her. No fear came—not even the hint of it—though she knew there should have been. Scarlett had heard stories about Voldemort before, but none of them did justice to what he truly was: a distorted cross between a serpent and a man, something so desecrated it should have been forbidden to exist. Grotesque and vile.
Scarlett didn’t show anything. It was beyond her—something in the back of her mind kept her expressions in check. She was nothing more than a puppet in Regulus’s hands.
"I'm afraid that won't be possible, my lord," Regulus murmured, his tone flat. Scarlett had no idea how he managed to remain in perfect control of the situation, as if it were all just a formality.
"Why not?" Voldemort's serpentine face contorted with impatience.
"Because we…" There was the slightest hitch in Regulus’s voice—no more than a fraction of a second—but enough for every eye to turn toward him. "…I got her pregnant."
Evan Rosier was the first to laugh—a laugh steeped in poison.
"I knew you wouldn’t be able to keep your cock in your trousers… that’s why you rushed the wedding…" he sneered, amusement gleaming with sickness in his eyes. "But you two barely even had time to—"
"As I said… we were together before that," Regulus sighed, unshaken. "And she’s my wife. I shouldn’t have to apologise for getting her pregnant."
Voldemort released Scarlett abruptly, turning his scrutiny onto Regulus with predatory sharpness.
"And who’s to say the child isn’t your brother’s?" the Dark Lord straightened in eerie silence, circling him like a vulture.
"He’s mine, my lord," Regulus said, motionless. "We can… conduct a test. If you believe it is necessary."
Bellatrix stepped closer, trying to catch any flicker of doubt Regulus might betray. But he was far too skilled at masking what he chose to hide—his expression carved from the purest pure-blood arrogance.
"But if there’s a chance the child is your brother’s, no test will be conclusive until the birth," she said, narrowing her eyes in suspicion.
"We could give her an acceleration draught. Nine months reduced to half… four and a half, five at most," Amanda Wilkes offered from within the circle of Death Eaters.
"Are you trying to kill her, Wilkes?" Regulus shot her a glare that could burn.
"She bears a Signet—she’s strong enough," Amanda replied, bowing her head quickly as the Dark Lord turned to face her.
The memory faded like sand slipping beneath the tide, and the last thing to vanish into the darkness were Voldemort’s piercing red eyes—giving way to another vision.
"You shouldn’t have come," Regulus didn’t shout, but his voice frayed with unhinged notes. "Have you gone completely mad?"
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, her head throbbing, her wrists numb from being bound. Her face streaked with tears.
"You needed me," she whispered, guilt soaking every syllable.
Regulus laughed—a cruel, scornful bark.
"I never needed you." His eyes weren’t just cold—they were distant. Corrosive. "You’re lucky it was me who caught you… if it had been Rosier…" He ran a hand through his hair, agitated. "What the fuck use would you be to me? Especially carrying Sirius’s child!"
.
.
.
Scarlett let out a strangled sound, like she was being choked, though it was only the Dementors making that dreadful rattling noise as they sucked the life from her.
“We need to do something!” Lily screamed, though she didn’t dare move closer. Above them, a dozen Dementors floated down to enjoy the feast, eager to take their turn with Scarlett.
“Jay… do you remember in Azkaban…” Regulus was breathing fast, like the air had thinned. “When they went for Sirius…”
He didn’t need to say more. James nodded and stepped forward, but Regulus held him back, grabbing his arm.
“Wait… Lily… do you think you could cast spells using her hand?” Red stared at her.
“I-I don’t… I don’t know,” she murmured, her voice trembling with terror.
“We’ve got no choice.” Regulus looked at James. “Now!”
The two of them launched themselves from the roots and leapt. James passed through the Dementor attacking Scarlett, and Regulus hit the ones surrounding her. The creatures’ attention turned to them, and Lily rushed forward as the boys pulled away, their ghostly light beginning to fade.
Lily looked up. The swarm of Dementors now seemed more interested in the phantoms than in Scarlett. She crouched beside her and felt a subtle vibration as her hand neared the Signet, as though it were calling to her. Lily drew a deep breath and connected with Scarlett.
It was like the world suddenly started spinning faster. Lily felt herself slipping, a cold drop in her stomach like freefalling through something unreal. Her back slammed against the ground. The impact knocked the breath from her lungs.
Dazed, she blinked up at the snow-covered branches above her, the cold, damp earth pressing against her fingertips, and a terrible fatigue anchoring her body to the spot with a crushing weight on her chest.
She coughed, gasping desperately as though she hadn’t breathed in years. She felt wretched—sickened and dizzy. Regulus and James’s voices reached her ears, but they were warped, distant. She fumbled across the ground, her gloves caked in soil. She rolled onto her side and forced herself upright, bracing against a nearby tree.
She vomited, coughing uncontrollably. Her trembling fingers reached for the white wand. Her entire body shuddered from weakness, wracked by wave after wave of chills. She pulled off her gloves and rubbed her eyes, then stared in astonishment at the Signet glowing on her left hand.
She let out all the air from her lungs, which turned to mist against her lips. Lily was controlling Scarlett’s entire body now—not just her hand, as she’d done before. She ran her fingers along the roots of the tree beneath her, feeling their roughness against her fingertips. She inhaled the scents of the night—the dawn’s dew, the sterility of the Forbidden Forest.
“Lily!” James shouted at the top of his lungs. “The Patronus!”
Lily looked toward her husband’s voice, startled. She grabbed the wand and summoned all the strength she had to rise to her feet, squinting against the light of the two ghosts sprinting towards her in desperation.
Magic rang through her body, licking at her fingers, coursing through her veins, burning in her core. How long had it been since she’d felt that metallic crackle pulsing inside her?
Lily gasped, moving her wrist in the motion of a spell she knew by heart. She didn’t need to say the incantation aloud, but she couldn’t resist the urge to hear her own voice as she spoke:
“Expecto Patronum!”
A silver doe burst from Scarlett’s wand, her hooves drowning out the night’s noises as she galloped toward the two ghosts, erupting in a burst of white light that drove the Dementors back, scattering them between the trees.
She remained standing, even as her vision began to blur. Lily had so much she wanted to say, but the moment she opened her mouth, Scarlett’s body collapsed unconscious to the ground—and Lily remained upright, as though she'd just been torn from a warm, blanketed bed, hugging her own body against the dull, empty sensations of being a ghost.
“What the hell was that?” Regulus asked, panting hard.
“You alright, Lils?” James pulled her into a hug, his hands roaming over her as if checking for some unseen injury.
“I… I’m fine,” she said unsteadily, though the stunned look on her face refused to leave. “I went into Scarlett’s body. Like… like a possession.”
The three of them looked between one another, then down at her lying on the ground.
“You did what?” James stared at her, utterly disbelieving.
.
.
.
Scarlett didn’t want to wake up. But something very cold was brushing against her neck, enough to become annoying. She opened her eyes slowly, shutting them again at once because of the brightness. There was a thin silhouette above her face, dark, and Scar might have panicked if her head weren’t hurting so much.
"Sssscarlett?" the serpent hissed, tilting its head, its red eyes curious.
She rubbed her eyes to see better. She knew that reptile.
"T-Tar?!" Scar groaned, closing her eyes again as her ghosts leaned over her.
"Scar?" Red asked.
"You alright?" James pushed his glasses up awkwardly.
"How are you feeling?" Lily tried to stroke her hair.
Scarlett just wanted to sleep a bit more, but it was bloody freezing. She could barely feel her nose and ears—probably frostbitten. Same for the tips of her fingers. She forced herself to sit up, though all she managed was to lean against the tree trunk, seated on its roots.
"Shit," she whispered, feeling Tar slithering over her coat. "What the hell happened?"
"I don’t... know... how long... it’sss been," the snake coiled affectionately around her arm. "You look... awful."
"Well... that’s one way to put it," Scarlett muttered, lethargic, lifting her gaze towards the ghosts.
"Dementors attacked you," James explained. "Red and I lured them away and—"
"And I used the Patronus to drive them off," Lily added, shrinking as if she could feel the chill of that morning. "I... I took control of your body, Scar. It was my Patronus."
"It’s true. It wasn’t a cat, it was a doe," Regulus turned suddenly, as if he’d heard something. "You’d better get back..."
"I can’t." Scarlett sighed, too weak to sound any more assertive. Tar looked at her, puzzled.
"Sssscarlett? Why are you here?"
Scar swallowed hard, doing her best not to think about the memories of the day before.
"Dementors," she muttered, pulling the glove back onto her left hand.
"I noticsssed they’d vanissshed... from the foressst..." The snake flicked her forked tongue. "Wasssss that... you?"
Her only answer was a nod. Her body felt like it weighed a tonne, her head was pounding, and she was far too sluggish to move.
"They were sssscaring away all the creaturesss in the foressst..." Tar slid down onto the roots. "Are you going back to Hogwartsss?"
"Yeah... Hogwarts." Scarlett tried to stand again, but failed.
A strange vibration in the ground caught her attention. She and the ghosts exchanged looks, and Tar darted beneath the roots, as if frightened.
"What isss that?" the serpent lifted her head in the direction of the sound.
Regulus craned his neck, his eyes widening to twice their size.
"Troll, troll, troll..." he repeated, each word more urgent than the last.
Scarlett immediately forced herself upright, even with her legs trembling beneath her. She pushed into the trees, with Tar guiding her path while her ghosts urged her to go faster.
Not that she was slacking off—she was utterly exhausted, starving and frozen. Her leg muscles felt like they’d turned to stone. Even though her heart was hammering in her chest, flooding her body with adrenaline, running was out of the question.
She tried anyway—and ended up tumbling down an embankment, getting covered in scrapes and scratches, a thin mist rising from her wounds due to the bitter cold. Scarlett dragged herself through the icy mud, propping herself up on her elbows, trying to grab hold of something to help her rise.
But her body was slowly refusing to obey her commands, and as soon as the troll spotted its vulnerable prey, it hurled a rock at her. Scarlett shut her eyes and raised her forearm to shield her face, as if not seeing it would somehow save her.
Then, she felt a yank deep in her chest, as if a string tied to her hand vibrated so violently it numbed all her senses. She opened her eyes and drew her wand, shielding herself with a non-verbal Shield Charm.
Scarlett had no fucking idea what was happening, because it wasn’t her doing any of it. It was like she was just a spectator in her own body, which moved on its own as if it knew exactly what to do.
Regulus was dazzled by the sensation of wielding a wand again. With the cold stiffening his limbs, the heart pounding, the sheer pulse of life in every fibre of his being. He understood all too well how wretched Scarlett’s condition was—he was, after all, inside her body—but his will to survive was far stronger than hers.
He wouldn’t let her die like this. Not after everything they’d been through.
The troll hurled another stone.
"Avada Kedavra!" he hissed the cursed words, tracing the lightning bolt with the wand. A flash of green shot through the trees, ripping the air like thunder and striking the troll square in the chest. Its body crashed to the ground with a deafening thud.
The rock struck Scarlett’s leg dead on and she screamed at the sharp, burning pain that surged through her entire body, falling onto her back in the mud as she bit down on her lip in agony. She could feel blood soaking through her trousers, her vision swam with black specks, and her consciousness flickered.
Then, as if awakened by the Killing Curse, her Signet stirred on the back of her hand; spinning, spinning and spinning and spinning and spinning...
A blinding light engulfed her. The Veil billowed before her, both inviting and menacing. Scarlett reached out towards it, and the moment her fingers touched it, a deafening maelstrom erupted around her, swallowing her whole until all that remained was her mother, kneeling on the ground with a blonde child in her lap, runes drawn around them in blood. Scarlett tried to call out to her, but Nyx couldn’t hear her, and she was dragged away, as though something were pulling at her feet.
Scarlett thrashed about, the Veil rippled, and she rolled onto the cold marble floor, gasping for air, dazed and disoriented.
"Scarlett…" a voice called. Morfeu, collapsed at her side, was coughing uncontrollably. "Sweetheart… what have you done?"
What have you done?
What have you done?
What have you done?
A boy was being dragged into the water by countless inferi, writhing in desperation, trying to fight off the cadaverous hands that clung to him and kept pulling him under, but it was useless—there were too many. He looked at Scarlett and whispered her name with the last breath he had, the iron in his eyes fading with death’s kiss.
Scarlett called out to him, but he didn’t hear. A shrill, high-pitched laugh made her whole body bristle with fear. She turned to look behind her, towards the sound.
"Lily, take Harry and go! It’s him! Go! Run! I’ll hold him off…" James’s tall silhouette dropped the guitar to the floor, the instrument giving off an indistinct noise as he stumbled out of the room just as a door burst open.
"Not Harry! Not Harry! Please… not Harry!"
"Stand aside, you silly girl… stand aside, now!"
"Not Harry, please no, take me, kill me instead—"
"This is my last warning—"
"Not Harry! Please… have mercy… have mercy… not Harry! Not Harry! Please — I’ll do anything—"
"Stand aside. Stand aside, girl!"
The green light flashed and reflected in the red eyes of the murderer, in the irises of the victim, in the pupils of the baby in the cot, in the glasses of the father, in the skin of the martyr. Scarlett screamed for those she had lost, tears pouring from her eyes, each drop rippling the world around her, dissolving the vision, halting the spin of the Signet.
She was running in Whiskers’s body. It wasn’t her controlling it—she was in a half-sleep state, her vision dimming with each flash of sunlight on the soft snow. Each time her tiny paws hit the ground, pain spread through her body like venom. Her back left leg was broken and lifted off the ground in her frantic, limping sprint towards Hogwarts, accompanied by Tar.
Regulus left Scarlett’s body the moment he reached the Hogwarts grounds, bolting up the steps and searching for the Black Knight, as if the ghost might be able to help him.
James and Lily stayed beside Whiskers, trying to keep her conscious, but the cat was bleeding heavily and her leg was in a dreadful state. They hadn’t expected any student to be awake at that hour, let alone one practising a Patronus while grumbling about her repeated failures.
"What a bloody stupid spell. Why the hell isn’t my memory of winning the skate championship enough?!" She was from Slytherin. She wore so many necklaces around her neck that the sunlight reflecting off them almost blinded her face. It didn’t take long for her to follow the trail of Whiskers’s blood, her brow furrowed, stopping when she found the wounded cat on the ground. "Sweet Merlin! Are you still alive?!" She crouched down, checking Whiskers’s pulse. Glancing both ways, she noted the trail led from the Hogwarts grounds. "Don’t worry, I’ll take care of you…"
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 18: He wanted love to come as easily as hate did
Notes:
[Trigger warning: Post-traumatic stress disorder, depression]
Chapter Text
LXXXVI
Scarlett woke to the smell of coffee. For those brief seconds between sleep and waking, she was back home in Godric’s Hollow. Her family was still alive, and her biggest worry was getting annoyed with her mum, sneaking milk from her dad, or winding up Orfy. She was nearly drifting off again when the voices coming from the living room pulled her out of her dreams.
She didn’t want to get up, but couldn’t stay lying down any longer once she felt the burn in her stomach. Scarlett stumbled to the bathroom and threw up all the pizza she’d eaten the night before. Ever since she’d started taking the Draught of Melancholy, it was normal for her to end up vomiting before bed or after waking.
It was that or not be able to get out of bed at all.
She washed her face and brushed her teeth harder than she needed to, scrubbing until the sour taste was replaced by mint. She stared at her reflection in the mirror, following the drop that slid from her forehead to the freckled bridge of her nose, down her cheek to her chin.
It was strange to look in the mirror and see the same person she’d always seen, because on the outside, she looked the same. But inside… nothing was the same. It never would be. Absentmindedly, she caressed the burn scar on her right arm. It looked better than it once had, but it would never fade completely.
The irrefutable proof of what had happened.
Scarlett took a deep breath and dried her face, running her hand through her hair. The black was fading now, turning into a dark brown. She couldn’t even remember the charm to dye it anymore. It felt like it had been so long since she’d used that stupid magazine spell to darken it that some things were simply slipping from her memory.
She rubbed her eyes and got changed, certain there were visitors in the house. She took three deep breaths and stepped out of the bedroom.
“You’re not getting it. She grabbed the juice jug and launched it right into Avery’s face like she was aiming a bloody Bludger!” Sirius’s voice was getting louder down the corridor.
“No fucking way,” a man replied, laughing in disbelief.
“Fucking way. She smacked Mulciber too,” Sirius went on, sounding rather amused by the whole thing. “I swear, in that moment I thought… that’s it. She’s the one. I’m head over fucking heels.”
Scarlett found Sirius sitting on the floor with a screwdriver in hand. Beside him was a three-legged chair, while Gideon Prewett held the fourth leg, leaning on it. Both looked up at her, and Sirius’s face lit up with a roguish grin.
Her heart lurched all at once.
"Ah, speak of the devil..." He stood up and pulled her into a tight hug. Scarlett squeezed him back, ignoring the sudden wave of tears threatening to swallow her whole. Sirius stroked her spine, making her melt slowly in his arms.
"Morning, kitten," he whispered in her ear, sending shivers down her entire body.
"Morning, love," Scarlett blushed, falling right into the trap of those silver eyes. She rose up on her toes to kiss him, prompting Sirius to tilt his head so their lips could meet delicately.
"Are you alright?" he asked, resting his forehead against hers. Scarlett pressed her lips into a thin line and nodded, Sirius’s breath brushing against her cheeks. "You’re looking pale."
Scarlett swallowed hard, quickly glancing around and catching sight of Frank Longbottom. She turned her gaze back to Sirius, a sheepish smile crossing her lips.
"It’s just... the potion." She stepped back, running her hand through her hair before giving a small wave to the other two.
"Did you throw up?" Sirius pulled her back by the waist, worry etched across his face. "Again?"
"This potion’s bloody strong..." Scarlett sighed, waving her hand in front of her face as though it were nothing.
"You need to eat," Sirius said in a stern, almost paternal tone. "Prongs is making pancakes and Wormtail’s sorted the coffee."
Scarlett just nodded, slipping out of his arms. For some reason, she felt like a complete loser. Besides, she wasn’t used to the house being this crowded.
"What are you lot doing?" Scarlett asked, watching Gideon grab a chair leg while Frank held the rest of it in place.
"Fixing the chair," Sirius replied, brandishing the screwdriver.
Scarlett frowned, forcing herself to chuckle.
"You do realise there are spells for that, don’t you?!" She couldn’t help the sharp tone that crept into her voice.
Gideon scratched at his ginger moustache and Sirius raised an eyebrow.
"We want to do it the Muggle way," Frank explained, wiping sweat from his face with his shoulder. It was hot in there, even with the central cooling charm on.
"Good luck with that," she muttered, shaking her head in disbelief as she eyed the still-unassembled pile of furniture. "If you need my help with a few charms..."
Sirius snorted a laugh.
"We’ve got it," he shot back, screwing in the leg with Gid.
Scarlett headed to the kitchen, where Peter was leaning against the counter with a cup of coffee in hand and James was flipping pancakes on the stove. Alice Longbottom was seated at the table with Fabian Prewett. The four of them were caught up in a lively chat about life after Hogwarts.
"I’m hoping to get a job at the Ministry... same sort my dad used to have..." Peter was saying, blowing on his mug.
"And you, Jamie?" Alice turned to him, her short blonde hair held back with a brown headband.
"Professional Quidditch player..." James said, pushing his glasses up his nose. "But, you know, with the war..."
"Scar!" Peter spotted her in the kitchen doorway, a grin spreading across his face.
"Hey, Pete," Scarlett murmured, clenching her jaw at the pungent smell of coffee. Her eyes inevitably landed on Fabian Prewett, who was reading the Daily Prophet across from her, the front page screaming: GAUNT CASE WRAPPED IN CONTROVERSY.
Beneath the headline was a photo of her, younger, with her parents. Fabian jolted at the table, banging his knees with a loud thud. He snapped the paper shut as if trying to stop Scarlett from seeing it, but it was already too late.
"Good morning, Scarlett!" Alice stood and hugged her.
Scar didn’t hug back. She stood still, an awkward smile twisting her face.
"Oi, Scar, want some pancakes?!" James glanced over at her, flipping the batter in the pan.
"Not hungry," she muttered, shaking her head, uneasy with so many people in her house.
Well, it had been like that all week. Fabian, Gideon, Remus, James and Peter had helped Sirius unload the furniture, and Alice and Frank had reinforced the defensive spells. But she hadn’t expected them all to keep coming around. It wasn’t that their presence made her feel bad, but she hated the way they looked at her.
Like she was some poor thing for losing her family.
"Not hungry, my arse. Sit down and eat, go on..." James narrowed his eyes, plating up the pancakes and reaching for the maple syrup.
"Coffee?" Peter offered.
"I don’t drink coffee!" Scarlett snapped, yanking open the fridge in frustration. She grabbed the bottle of milk and plonked herself down noisily, shooting James a defiant look as she drank straight from the bottle.
"Stop yelling at Wormtail! He didn’t do anything to you!" James handed her the plate of pancakes, holding his breath. "What’s your problem?"
Scarlett swallowed hard, feeling Fabian and Alice’s eyes on her, her face burning with anger. She shot to her feet, knocking the chair over, and shoved the milk bottle under her arm as she stormed out of the house.
She shielded her face from the brightness outside. The morning sun gleamed off rooftops, the warm asphalt, the blooming gardens where a group of children were playing. Thanks to the Muggle-repelling charms, none dared come near their house, though it was still possible to watch them live their lives as if a war wasn’t tearing everything else apart.
Scarlett’s heart twisted with envy. She wanted that life. Maybe, if her family hadn’t been magical, they’d still all be together. But then… she wouldn’t have met any of her friends. Least of all Sirius. She sipped her cold milk, the warm breeze tugging at her hair.
Soon, the front door opened. At first, Scarlett thought it was Sirius, but it was actually Gideon who stepped out, holding a steaming mug of coffee and wearing a nostalgic smile. He leaned against the porch pillar and looked at her, though Scar avoided his gaze.
"I miss him," Gid murmured, scratching at his ginger moustache. "Your dad."
"I do too," Scarlett replied, unmoving. Not a hair on her head shifted. Inside, though, a storm threatened to rise in her chest. She swallowed it back with a breath. "Every single day."
Gideon smiled, blowing on his coffee before taking a sip.
"You look like him," he went on, eyes scanning her face. "He… he was really proud of you."
Scarlett tightened her grip on the milk bottle, though her face stayed neutral.
"I’m not so sure about that," she admitted, after a pause.
"Course he was. Couldn’t stop talking about you at work." Gideon gave her a comforting smile—one Scarlett dismissed at once.
"It doesn’t matter anymore. He’s dead." She turned and went back inside, tossing the milk bottle into the bin.
She wasn’t going to let it affect her. She wouldn’t allow it.
Inside, she walked into a casual conversation between Sirius, Fabian and Frank, who had just finished assembling the chair. James, Wormtail and Alice were sitting on the sofa, clapping like they were the audience at some show.
"Right, all done. Come on, kitten, try it out—see if it holds up!" Sirius waved at her with such enthusiasm that Scarlett gave a faint, tired smile and nodded.
She barely settled into the seat when one of the legs gave out beneath her, sending her sprawling awkwardly to the floor. James was the first to laugh, followed by the others, their laughter filling the room in chaotic bursts. To Scar, already emotionally worn thin, it felt more like humiliation than harmless fun—especially when she glanced at Sirius and saw him laughing too.
Fighting to keep her composure, she tried to hold back the tears… but the wave of shame that prickled down her spine was too much, and they started spilling down her cheeks. Noticing her reaction, Sirius immediately moved to help her—but Fabian was faster, reaching out with a hand and a suddenly serious look on his face.
In a reflex driven by rage and built-up pain, Scarlett slapped Fabian’s arm—hard. He stepped back, startled by the outburst.
"You know how to fight?" he asked, raising one ginger eyebrow as he rubbed the spot where she’d hit him.
Scarlett wiped her tears away more harshly than necessary before getting to her feet and shooting a scalding glare at Sirius—then turning that same look on Fabian.
"Of course I can fight. I studied at Durmstrang," she snapped. "Why, you up for a beating?"
Sirius took a step toward her, but Fabian stopped him halfway. The fun had long since vanished; the others were exchanging uneasy glances.
"Why don’t we take this outside?" Fabian said with a sarcastic smile, which only irritated her further. "Maybe you’ll channel that rage into something useful..."
"I’m not angry!" Scarlett barked—though her tone said otherwise. "Bloody hell!"
"Imagine if you were..." Fab goaded her, giving her a pat on the shoulder. Scarlett recoiled, jaw clenched.
"Fuck off, Prewett!" she snapped, brushing her shoulder with disgust. "Don’t touch me!"
"Or what?" Fabian pinched her in the ribs.
Scarlett shoved him hard enough that he nearly toppled onto Frank.
"DON’T FUCKING TOUCH ME!" she screamed. Sirius tried to step in, but Fabian held him back again.
"Then come on. Let’s go outside. Come on, Gaunt, if you’re so desperate to get smacked about..." He headed toward the pool area. Scarlett, body burning with fury, followed with fists already clenched. Sirius went after them, Frank not far behind.
"Love, it was just a—"
"I don’t care!" Scarlett cut Sirius off, her glare so fierce he actually stepped back. "It wasn’t funny!"
"Come on then, Gaunt, show me what they teach you at your supremacist little school..." Fabian waved her forward, shoving sun loungers out of the way.
"And where did you learn to fight? Surely not at Hogwarts..." Scarlett narrowed her eyes, the summer wind whipping through her hair.
"In Auror training... we learn hand-to-hand combat," he replied with a shrug, planting his stance. He was stockier than Sirius, shorter too, but built with more muscle. His frame reminded her of Dimitri.
He struck first—quick for his size—just a series of probing attacks to gauge her defences.
Despite her initial surprise, Scarlett reacted on instinct. She dodged with a certain grace, spinning her body to build momentum and countered with a sharp kick. Fabian threw his torso back to avoid it, and the bout quickly became a violent dance. Scarlett poured all her rage and frustration into her aggressive strikes. Though she'd gone a year without proper training—after all, she hadn’t fought properly since Hogwarts—her muscle memory gave her precise, intricate blows and a nimble guard.
It didn’t take long for Fabian to adapt to Scarlett’s erratic style, defending himself with skill and retaliating with precision.
"Land a single blow on my girl and I’ll snap you in half, Prewett!" Sirius threatened from one of the loungers, sat beside Frank.
"It’s more likely she’ll snap me than you will..." Fabian shot back, breathless.
Their bodies moved in perfect sync, as if a silent rhythm pulsed between them. Scarlett, spotting an opening as Fabian’s attention shifted momentarily to Sirius, landed a strong punch on his shoulder, forcing him to stumble back. He grinned, despite the hit.
"That all you’ve got?" he challenged, the taunt unmistakable in his voice.
Though breathing heavily, Scarlett doubled down, increasing the ferocity of her attacks without dropping her guard. Fabian was good—better than she was. She knew it, could tell he was holding back. But that didn’t mean she would.
There was a fire blazing in her core, making her feel alive. It pounded through her heart, tensed her muscles, flushed her cheeks. Fabian was all she could see through the haze of adrenaline, deflecting a hook by twisting her arm up to protect her face, her clothes soaked in sweat.
Scarlett ducked under another strike, bracing one hand on the ground and kicking upward, square in Fabian’s abdomen. He slipped backward and fell. Gasping, his face a mixture of surprise and admiration, Scarlett offered him her hand. Fabian took it, and she pulled him back to his feet with a shared, unspoken sense of respect.
"You’re good," he said, pulling her into a hug. Scarlett stiffened at first, but then smiled and accepted it. "You could be an Auror... we could put in a recommendation..."
"Yeah, he’s right," Frank said from beside Sirius, clearly impressed.
"She doesn’t want to be an Auror," Sirius cut in, rising to his feet with a proud grin on his face. "She’s going to be a professional pianist."
The mention of the piano made her heart stretch with a single beat. She hadn’t touched it once since they’d moved. Despite the bitter taste that crept into her mouth, Scarlett couldn’t stop herself from smiling.
"Maybe I’ll change my mind," she said with a shrug, catching Sirius’s gaze. The silver in his irises sparkled at the idea. "Scarius hunting down dark wizards, huh?"
Sirius grinned from ear to ear, and the sight sent a warm shiver down her spine. He was handsome—always had been—but that smile, that smile made her giddy. The way his dimples deepened, the worryless gleam in his eyes, the long lashes catching a blue tint under the sun...
"We’d kick a lot of arse," Sirius agreed, his tone dripping with that signature bravado. "Just like Frank and Alice. Sirius and Scarlett Black!" He seemed so caught up in the sweet fantasy that he hardly noticed what he’d just said.
Scarlett’s smile faded, but not because she felt sad. The embarrassment came crashing back, flushing her cheeks and making her palms even sweatier than they already were.
Scarlett Black.
Yes… she would like to be called Scarlett Black if they ever got married one day. Just thinking about it sent a shiver down her spine.
"So then, Mr Black, shall we get back to assembling the furniture?" Frank didn’t sound particularly enthusiastic—if anything, he seemed exhausted.
"Yeah... I’m coming..." Sirius shoved Fabian out of the way on purpose, earning a sharp elbow in return.
Scarlett remained rooted to the spot, panting slightly, a smile playing at her lips. She was entranced by the sight of that pale-skinned, black-haired man looking at her as though she were the only thing that mattered in the entire world. He opened his arms and pulled her into a fierce hug, as though she might vanish at any second.
"You were incredible, love," he murmured, kissing her flushed cheek.
"Sirius! I’m all sweaty!" Scarlett whined, burying her face in his neck.
Sirius had grown a beard—a neatly trimmed moustache rested above his upper lip, while dark strands framed his jawline and chin. His cheeks, however, remained clean-shaven, which made him look older than he really was.
"You are... you need a shower..." he said with a cheeky grin.
"Sirius, the house is full and—" she began to protest, but he swiftly scooped her up, her legs instinctively wrapping around his waist.
"And we’re pretending no one in there knows we fuck?!" he scoffed. "I don’t care, love."
"Sirius..." Scarlett whispered, flustered, resting her head on his shoulder as she stroked the beard along his chin. "I don’t want them to hear us..."
"Then just don’t make any noise," he replied, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
Scarlett smiled again, shaking her head.
"Can we wait till everyone’s gone?! I know you’ve got that exhibitionist streak, but I—"
"Alright, kitten," he said, kissing the corner of her mouth, his beard tickling her cheek. "But you’re having a shower now, yeah? You stink."
"Oh, piss off!" Scarlett smacked him on the back, and Sirius bit his bottom lip with a look that said he’d rather liked it, setting her down again.
"And what’re you gonna do if I don’t shut up?" he murmured in her ear, pressing a kiss to her earlobe.
Scarlett shivered, her whole body on edge as Sirius’s lips trailed along her neck.
"Sirius, stop!" she protested again, pulling away from him completely flustered. "Later!"
He sighed, impatient, then relented with a light smack on her arse.
"Later," Sirius echoed, going off to find the screwdriver to help Frank and Fabian.
Scarlett slipped quickly into the bedroom and shut the door behind her, diving under the shower in an attempt to extinguish the fire Sirius had lit in her body. Her fingers traced the burn scar on her forearm slowly, her heart pounding as her mind fought to push away the memories of that day.
She rested her head against the tiled wall, letting the hot water lash across her back, and finally allowed herself to cry freely, her sobs echoing off the bathroom walls. The emptiness gnawing inside her twisted and stretched, but it no longer consumed her the way it once had. On the contrary, it was contained now, though it still resonated through every fibre of her being, conjuring tears to her eyes.
Scarlett didn’t know how long she stayed there, focusing on the sound of water pouring over her skin and splattering against the glass pane. She didn’t know exactly what she was doing, but the ache in her muscles and the faint bruises beginning to bloom on her body eventually pulled her out of the whirlwind in her mind.
After dressing, she stepped out of the bathroom, drying her hair with a charm. She reached for her witch fashion magazine and found the enchantment to change her hair colour, dyeing the strands black once more.
The smell of lunch greeted her as she opened the door. Her stomach growled, and she bit the inside of her cheek upon seeing the table laid out. The group had begun to gather, sharing stories from their time at Gryffindor. Apparently, Fab and Gid were four years older, and Alice and Frank, two.
Scarlett helped herself to the summer salad Alice and Peter had made, smiling now and then as though she were following the conversation, though she couldn’t really keep up. She understood what Frank was talking about, but she couldn’t access his excitement, nor his joy. It was as if Scarlett had been severed from those feelings, like they’d been amputated.
Sirius’s hand soon found her shoulder, his fingers tracing her collarbone as he listened and laughed at something James had said. Scarlett stared at her plate, feeling painfully out of place, her gaze drifting to Gideon Prewett, who offered her a gentle smile.
She looked away, back to her food, forcing a smile when Sirius said something about their relationship and kissed her cheek. He withdrew his hand from her shoulder only to take her hand under the table, lacing their fingers together. He looked at her—his expression light, but there was a flicker of concern in the graphite streaks cutting through the silver of his eyes.
"You alright?" he whispered.
Scarlett simply nodded, stuffing her mouth with salad so she wouldn’t have to say anything. The days when the house was full were the hardest—she kept catching herself looking for Orfy or her parents, as if they might suddenly appear, laughing and saying the whole thing had been some stupid prank.
It was easier when it was just her and Sirius, or just her and the Marauders, because she’d grown used to their presence without her family around. Having everyone there reminded her of Christmas, and the urge to cry crept up on her once again.
She forced it away with a deep breath. The torture of lunch ended when Fabian, Alice and Frank had to leave for work, leaving only Gideon and Peter behind to help Sirius with the furniture. Scarlett kept herself busy charming the plates to return to the kitchen. She leaned over the counter, flipping through a housewitch magazine to find the spell that would make the dishes wash themselves.
Beside her, a tall boy with messy hair leaned on the counter too, arms folded as he pushed his glasses up his nose. He was close—so close their arms were touching, and his cinnamon scent wrapped around her.
"Spell for cleaning carpets," James read one of the titles in a bored tone that made Scarlett laugh.
"Since you’re not doing anything, help me find the one for washing dishes..." Scarlett rolled her eyes, and James rested his head on her shoulder.
"Wood furniture cleaning, wooden floor cleaning, porcelain cleaning?" He raised a brow, glancing sideways at her.
"It’s washing, not cleaning!" Scarlett huffed, flipping the page harder than necessary. James snorted a laugh.
"Sorry for being a prick earlier," he murmured, sincerity lacing the warm brown of his eyes. A hint of worry, too. "I know it’s not... easy."
"But you were right. I shouldn’t have snapped at Pete like that." Scarlett pressed her lips into a guilty smile. "It’s not fair to take it out on..." She muttered a few more incoherent words before falling into silence.
"I know." James scratched his head, mussing up his already wild hair. "How is he?" he asked in a lower voice, like they were sharing a secret.
Scarlett wetted her lips, craning her neck slightly to check if Sirius was nearby. She exhaled slowly when she heard him arguing over bookshelf assembly with Gid and Peter.
She took a deep breath, resting her chin in her hand as she flipped through more pages.
"He doesn’t sleep. He thinks I haven’t noticed, but... I have. On the nights I forget the dreamless potion, he’s always in bed with me. But sometimes I get up to go to the loo in the middle of the night and he’s gone... comes back looking on edge."
James raised his eyebrows.
"What do you mean?"
"Any odd noise... anything out of place... he’s up and checking. Sometimes in Padfoot form. He checks every room, every corner, and only when he’s sure everything’s alright does he come back to bed."
Scarlett turned back to the magazine, finally finding the spell she’d been after. She cast it on the plates, and the sponge began to move on its own, scrubbing them clean.
"Want me to talk to him?" James turned, resting his hands and waist against the counter, back to her.
"That... that would be good, Jamie. He’s not okay. And I... I don’t know what to do."
Saying it aloud hurt. Scarlett ran her hands over her face, feeling like a complete failure. Sirius had saved her from the fire, stayed by her side through that hellish month, and now she couldn’t do the same for him. She couldn’t make him feel okay—not the way he did for her. She held her breath, suffocating on the thought.
"I feel like an anchor, Jamie. Pulling him down..."
"No." James cut her off. "Don’t say that."
"I don’t know what else to do. I don’t..." Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, hands still covering her face, hoping it might stop the tears from coming.
It didn’t work. She sniffled quietly, and James pulled her into a hug. Her burning tears blurred her vision as she buried her face in his Puddlemere United shirt, doing her best not to attract Sirius’s attention from the other room.
James rubbed her back with one hand, the other gently stroking her hair.
"It’s alright. You’re not in this alone, you’ve got us too. We’re going to help you. I promise."
Scarlett didn’t know what else to do. She’d always been a burden to her parents—now she’d become one to Sirius. It was as if she’d been born solely to bring disappointment, to weigh down the people she loved.
One small noise from the sitting room was enough to make her shove James away with the same force she used to banish her tears. She wiped her cheeks quickly, sniffing as she ran a hand over her nose, trying to compose herself.
James opened his mouth to say something but stayed silent.
Sirius appeared in the kitchen doorway, letting his hair fall from its ponytail and dusting off the tank top he was wearing.
"I'm gonna need to pop over to the builders’ shop with Gid... you wanna come?" Sirius looked at her, but Scarlett turned her gaze to the sink where the dishes were washing themselves, pretending to check if the charm was still working.
"No." Scarlett replied so quietly that Sirius only caught it by reading her lips. "You can go."
Sirius furrowed his brows, concern hidden in the focused lines of his expression.
"You alright?" He placed a hand on the curve of Scarlett’s waist, and she nodded, faking a smile.
"Yeah, just... figuring out how to get everything tidy..." Scarlett offered as an excuse, carefully avoiding the trap of those silver eyes.
Sirius gave her a suspicious look before pressing a kiss to her hair.
"Alright, then. Look after her, Prongs." He patted his mate on the shoulder in farewell.
"Got it, Padfoot." James gave a mock salute.
Sirius and Gideon Apparated away, just as Peter came over holding a VHS tape with a mischievous grin spreading across his face.
"Since you two ditched me and Moony at Christmas when we went to watch Carrie, we’re watching it now!" he declared, motioning for the two of them to follow him. "I managed to record it when it was on telly last week..."
Scarlett didn’t feel like watching anything, but she didn’t have much of a choice once James made popcorn and made her lie down with her head in his lap, stretching her legs over Peter as the film began.
.
.
.
Sirius had been to plenty of Muggle shops in his life—but never a builders’ supply store. He and Gideon were met with curious looks (perhaps because Gid was in full business attire despite the bloody scorching heat), or maybe because Sirius was wearing trousers covered in chains, which seemed to make the workers assume he was some kind of punk.
Either way, they stopped in front of several paint cans stacked into a triangle, the smell of cut wood and solvent making Sirius wrinkle his nose. His attention drifted to a shelf full of wallpaper rolls, fingers trailing over them until he found one with silver arabesques.
With a faint smile tugging at his lips, Sirius picked it up and carried it over to Gideon, who was standing in front of a curtain display. His red hair was perfectly combed to one side, and he was scratching his moustache as he examined the samples.
"Did you find the drill bit?" Sirius asked, and his cousin gave him a distracted look.
"Yeah, the clerk went to get it..." He turned back to the curtains.
"You alright?" Sirius pressed, placing a hand on his shoulder. "You’ve been totally out of it all day."
Gideon looked at him again, the light irises reflecting the fluttering sample curtains. He bit his lower lip, crossing his arms. Sirius and James had learned all the wrong things at Hogwarts thanks to Fabian and Gideon—the pranks, the secret places, the dodgy jinxes—but the time spent apart after the twins graduated had driven a subtle wedge between them. Even though Sirius still felt close to him, there was a hesitation there he couldn’t quite untangle.
"Do you know someone named... Rustov?" Gideon raised an eyebrow.
Sirius’s entire body tensed, his jaw clenching at the name. Gid caught the shift instantly—his attention turned sharp.
"Why?" Sirius snapped before realising he’d clenched his fists.
"Do you know him or not?"
Sirius took a deep breath, stepped away for a moment, then moved closer again like he wasn’t sure what to do with himself.
"I do," he said, managing to keep composed, though a black stain was spreading across his chest. "Why?"
"This... letter arrived. At my office. A week after the fire... addressed to Morfeu." Gideon avoided his gaze. "From someone named Nikolai Rustov. I wanted to give it to Thanatos, but..." He shrugged. "... I ended up forgetting. Then another one came—this time addressed to Scarlett."
The tension crackling through Sirius’s frame only grew stronger. He clenched his jaw even tighter, neck muscles straining. He could barely turn his head.
"You’ve got both?"
Gideon nodded, slipping his hands into his pockets, then pulling out two envelopes and handing them to Sirius.
"I wanted to give them to Scarlett sooner, but she... didn’t seem in the right place for it." He gave a sheepish smile.
"You did the right thing. Let me handle it." Sirius shoved the letters into his trouser pocket without even glancing at them. He knew if he did, he’d tear them apart.
It was hard to keep the rage from boiling over in his chest, but easy enough to pretend for Gideon’s sake, pretending to flick through more wallpaper samples as he handed over the one he’d picked out. He weaved back between the other customers, not daring to touch the letters.
He was going to give them to Scarlett. He had to... but he didn’t want to make things worse. He’d promised to protect her. Best he read them first—so she wouldn’t be blindsided. Sirius exhaled slowly and walked to the till when Gideon waved him over, paid for the supplies, and left the shop with his mind racing.
"Shall we head back?" Gideon asked, watching the cars pass along the avenue.
Sirius gripped the bag tightly, uneasy.
"I... I don’t know..." he muttered, running a hand through his hair.
"I can take you to the bar me and Morfeu used to hit on our breaks. You know, for when you wanna take Scar sometime... They’ve got the best starters in all of Mayfair."
Sirius only nodded, doing his best not to think about those letters, gripping Gideon’s arm as they Disapparated. The world spun, and they reappeared in an empty alleyway that led onto a commercial street in London. The two of them stepped into a bar where red neon signs glowed: The Hanged Man, with an upside-down man dangling by one foot.
The interior was dimly lit, with a stage lacking a band and a distinctly rustic aesthetic—old photographs lined the walls, worn musical instruments were mounted as decoration, and memorabilia from bands that had played there—like Fleetwood Mac and Queen—added character to the space.
Gideon picked a table near the stage and ordered two beers. They settled in, and Sirius scanned the room with clear suspicion.
"It’s alright, no wizards around here..." Gid murmured, winking at the woman behind the bar. "Place is too tucked away for that."
"What if someone followed us?"
"No one followed us, Sirius. Relax, mate." He gave him a playful kick in the shin as the beers arrived. "Besides, you owe me a few pints for helping you with the furniture..."
Sirius smirked, rolling his eyes.
"Yeah, Gid, let’s pretend I never helped you with anything..." he muttered dryly.
"Oh, come off it. How many years has it been since we talked like this? And now that you’re dating my boss’s daughter..." He cleared his throat. "Ex-boss, I mean... I know things are rough, and I want to help."
"And why the sudden interest in helping?" Sirius didn’t ease up. If anything, the scepticism in his tone sharpened.
Gideon let out a long sigh, drinking his beer like it was water, his red moustache dripping with foam.
"You’re my cousin. Why wouldn’t I help you?!"
Sirius smiled. It didn’t mean he was amused.
"Oh, please, Gid. Half the bloody pure-blood population are my cousins, and that’s never been a reason for anything. This is about Scarlett, isn’t it?"
Gideon nodded slowly, licking his lips.
"Yeah. It’s about Scarlett. She can’t..." He looked away for a few seconds. "She can’t get caught up in this, Sirius. You know what I mean?"
"So it was the Death Eaters, then?" Sirius’s brow furrowed.
"Who else would it be?" Gid gestured to the waitress for another beer.
Sirius hadn’t even touched his.
"What happened? What really happened, Gid?" He leaned forward, elbows on the table, turning his beer glass in his hands while staring at his cousin with intense scrutiny.
"No one knows exactly, to be honest... there’s been a lot of obstruction in cases tied to Death Eater connections. But... that doesn’t necessarily mean it was one of them. Aunt Lucy tried to take charge of the case, but the Minister for Magic wouldn’t allow it—because she’s a Black by birth and because of your parents..." He took a small sip of his drink. "Well, they weren’t going to hand it off to rookies like Fab or Alice and Frank... and Nate can’t do much, being personally involved."
"It was one of them, Gid. I know it. There was... something off..."
"That’s what we suspect too," the redhead cut in, drumming his fingers on the condensation of his pint glass.
"We?" Sirius raised his eyebrows, the fizz from the beer catching in the scruff of his chin. "Dumbledore’s little army?"
Gideon looked mildly surprised by that.
"Little army?"
"When Snivellus nearly killed me, Selwyn claimed we were rallying to Dumbledore’s little army. Makes me wonder if that’s what you lot are doing... Scarlett’s parents... James’s parents..." Sirius speculated, the silver in his eyes hardening into cold steel.
"Yeah." Gideon answered bluntly, downing the rest of his beer and signalling for another.
Sirius hadn’t expected such a direct response.
"I want in," he offered, without hesitation.
"No." Gid wiped his moustache with a napkin. "Absolutely not."
"I can—"
"You’re not fit for it, Sirius." His voice was oddly flat.
"What do you mean I’m not fit? I’m perfectly fine!" Sirius’s voice rose, his hand slamming onto the table.
Gideon gave him a doubtful look, thanking the waitress for the new pint while eyeing Sirius carefully.
"No one who’s been through what you and Scarlett have is perfectly fine. It’s... too much. Especially at your age—"
"I want to help!" Sirius cut him off. "Scarlett’s parents were killed in retaliation, weren’t they?"
"Sirius... you’re in no condition to help us. In fact, you’d only get in the way. And we don’t know that. What we do know is that four teenagers were kidnapped by Death Eaters at last year’s Halloween party. And they suddenly disappeared from captivity. The British Ministry of Magic received a magical trace alert from James Potter casting spells in a bloody doughnut shop in New York the same night... I wonder what that might’ve been about..."
Sirius’s eyes widened, his lips pressing into a thin line.
"Yeah, someone drugged us, and Scarlett got us out with her bloody multi-portkey. Is that what you wanted to hear, Gid?" he snapped, trying hard to maintain a veneer of calm, even though all he really wanted was to scream. But it didn’t take much effort to retreat behind that growing numbness, insulating himself from the rage rippling beneath the surface.
"What I’m saying is, you lot are reckless. You’re just kids—"
"I’m of age!"
"—and you don’t need to be worrying about this yet. Leave the war to the adults." He ignored the interruption entirely.
"Right, because you lot are doing such a brilliant job handling it, aren’t you?!" Sirius growled, standing abruptly. "I’m going to the loo."
Sirius followed the neon sign, his head swarming with thoughts. The letters shifted restlessly in his pocket. Could it have been... Dimitri? Or his family? Scarlett had never said whether he might join the Death Eaters, but... if the Rustovs had done it out of revenge? Could it be...
A sharp scream from a table full of women pierced the fragile bubble of normalcy Sirius had wrapped around himself, pulling buried memories of that day to the surface. The scream was painfully like Scarlett’s—so exact it carved through his memory, lodging the terror deep where he'd tried to forget it.
He gasped, desperate for air. His heart raced. His hands trembled. A wave of nausea struck him hard. He staggered back, leaning on the wall like it was the only thing keeping him afloat in a crashing sea. The heat became unbearable, sweat tracing down his cheeks and the back of his neck. It felt like something was choking him—he simply couldn’t breathe.
Not that he minded. He could swear he smelled smoke.
And that sent every nerve in his body into high alert. A rising dread crawled over his skin with every frantic thump of his heart.
He remembered glancing at the loo sign again before bolting towards it. He burst in, locking the door behind him. His heart was spiralling out of control now, breath shallow and erratic. Sweat dripped from his brow. It was hot, so blisteringly hot that Sirius felt like he was about to black out from the sheer intensity of it.
The nausea returned violently, and he found himself kneeling on the cold bathroom tiles, retching up every bit of that bloody summer salad as he fought to stay conscious amidst the storm of emotions crashing down on him.
He had no idea how long he stayed like that, only that at some point he started scrubbing at the scar on his arm—hard—like it was burning, even though he knew it was all in his head. He kept his eyes open, forcing them to stay that way, because if he closed them, he’d see Scarlett—trying to run back into the flaming house.
Sirius shoved his sweat-matted hair behind his ear, trying to focus on his breathing. His chest seized as he inhaled deeply, holding it as long as he could before forcing it out in a slow, painful release. Sweat stung his eyes, making them tear up.
He curled into himself, head between his knees, and wept without restraint.
He tore off the chains of restraint he’d clung to since the fire—the ones that had muffled every memory, every reaction, every flicker of panic. His nails dug into his arms at the mere possibility of it all happening again.
No.
It wouldn’t happen again—because he’d protect Scarlett.
He’d promised to take care of her, and that’s what he was doing. He’d just forgotten that he wasn’t doing well either, even if he didn’t show it. He was good at hiding things—he’d done it his whole life in his parents’ house—so why couldn’t he do the same with his girlfriend and his friends?
He didn’t even notice that he was gripping his own hair, or that his clothes were stuck to his skin with sweat. Or that his heart hurt so much it felt like he could barely breathe. The flashes from that day kept trying to take hold of his mind, but Sirius didn’t let them win—he fought back until all that lingered in his thoughts were the good memories he’d built in their new home. Scarlett’s face when he told her he’d done it all for their future. The two of them swimming in the pool. James and Scar dancing the boogie.
Sirius stared up at the white ceiling of the bathroom, his sweaty fingers brushing over the cold tile.
It’s not real.
It’s not real.
It’s not real.
He cast a few spells to dry his clothes and washed his face in the sink, trying to pull himself back together. There was a constant buzzing in the back of his head, something that had started with the fire. It stopped him from sleeping, from relaxing, from feeling safe. He was constantly checking, rechecking, making sure things were alright—and it had left dark circles beneath his eyes that he covered with a charm each morning.
An avalanche of feelings crashed against his chest. He was so bloody tired he could’ve fallen asleep right there on the bathroom floor. Sirius looked up at his reflection in the mirror, dragging his hands through his beard. It wasn’t for nothing that he’d let it grow—he didn’t want to be the same Sirius he’d been before. He wanted to hold on to the good things Scarlett had helped him grow, but at the same time, he wanted to kill off the weeds his parents had planted deep in his core.
He wanted to be someone different. He wanted to have saved Orfy. He wanted to have never raised a hand against Reggie. He wanted to be strong—so strong that no one he loved would ever suffer again. It was a foolish thought, especially in this world, but it was enough to ease the pain twisting in his chest, to quiet it little by little, to lock it away in that ivory box buried deep in his heart. The pain of loss, of helplessness, of guilt.
He could have saved Orfy. Maybe even Scarlett’s parents... if he’d gone back, if he’d listened to her...
Sirius was a failure.
He didn’t even know why he kept trying. It felt like everything he did ended in tragedy. He was a tragedy. A star doomed to burn everyone who got too close. It was hard to stop that self-hatred from taking root—harder still to hack away at the rough branches it grew.
The man in the mirror stared back at him, his breath fogging the glass. Sirius didn’t want that filthy feeling pulsing through his veins—at least not like this—but it always came so easily. Hatred had always been easier. As if it were etched into his very DNA. As if it were some cursed inheritance from his wretched, pure bloodline.
He wanted love to come as easily as hate did.
Sirius drew in a deep breath, slipped on his mask of indifference, and wiped away any trace of tears. He fixed his hair and stepped out of the bathroom, full of smiles and silent glances—though inside, he was completely lost. He returned to the table with Gid and sat down just as he waved over the waitress.
"You took your time. Everything alright?" his cousin slurred slightly. He was already drunk.
"Could you bring me something stronger? Whisky?" Sirius offered the waitress a charming smile before turning back to Gid. "All good. I stepped out for a smoke," he lied, drumming his fingers on the table.
"Thought you’d quit," Gideon said, lifting his glass in a toast as Sirius’s drink arrived.
"No one ever really quits, Gid... they just stretch out the time between smokes." He held the lie, tossing back the glass with a wince.
Then he signalled for the waitress to bring over the whole bottle.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 19: There’s something wrong with me
Chapter Text
LXXXVII
"Merlin’s bloody beard!" James slapped a hand over his mouth as the suspenseful music filled the room.
Scarlett, lying with her head in his lap and her feet on Peter’s, scooped a handful of popcorn from the bowl resting on her stomach and shoved it into her mouth, eyes locked on the telly.
"Did Tommy just die?!" James went on, pushing his glasses up his nose.
She was still trying to make sense of what was happening. She’d slept through half the film, and now, for some reason, Carrie was drenched in red paint.
"Shut it and watch, Prongs!" Peter chucked popcorn at James before crunching noisily on his own.
"She’s killing her classmates?!" Scar rubbed her eyes, baffled.
"She’s killing everyone!" James’s shock turned into awe. "The girl’s gone barmy!"
When the school hall burst into flames, James and Peter glanced at Scarlett with concern. She grabbed more popcorn, her gaze glued to the screen, seemingly unfazed. The truth was, she was far too tired to give a toss about what was happening in the film.
Still, every noise from outside made Scarlett sit up and glance at the door, hoping it was Sirius. His presence had been so constant that his absence felt wrong — she’d spent the last several days practically glued to him. Waking up without him there was... off.
It made her anxious.
The film ended, and with each passing minute without Sirius returning home, another nail drove itself into her chest. Scar couldn’t relax, not even while watching an explosive game of wizard snap between James and Peter, sparks flying as one of the cards went off. She kept rubbing her Signet, the growing unease in her chest becoming impossible to ignore as dusk fell and still no sign of Sirius.
"James… could you… use the mirror?" she asked, resting her chin on her knees.
"Ah, left the mirror at home," he said, scratching the back of his neck. "But I can fetch it if you want…"
"No, don’t worry about it." She forced a smile.
"Pads and Gid probably haven’t found the drill yet… they’re bloody shite to find, to be fair. My Muggle uncle’s got a box full of them for that very reason…" Peter offered her a reassuring smile, his small eyes full of kindness. "Then again, we could just use a spell and have all this put together in no time…" He gestured toward the piles of furniture pieces in the back of the room.
"I think it’s been therapeutic for him," James said, discarding a card that exploded with a bang right in Peter’s face, showering him with sparks. Scarlett allowed herself a smile. "You’re dead, tosser."
"Argh, Prongs! That’s not fair, you played twice in a row!" Peter grumbled, reshuffling the cards.
"You snooze, you lose." James shrugged with a smug grin.
It was incredible how the boys still managed to be childish, even as adults. The brief distraction of the moment made Scarlett hesitate when she heard the door opening. All three craned their necks, and Sirius and Gideon appeared, laughing exaggeratedly.
Scarlett shot up at once, her heart racing as she rushed over to hug Sirius. He squeezed her back, a little too hard. The smell of alcohol made her wrinkle her nose in disgust.
"Where’ve you been? You disappeared for ages…" James also stepped closer, hands on his hips.
The kiss Sirius gave Scarlett only deepened her discomfort. Her hands began to tremble, and her blood boiled with fury when she realised how drunk he was — he could barely stand on his own. Noticing her expression, Sirius tried to tickle her, which only pushed Scarlett further into exasperation. She shoved him, and he stumbled, swaying until he caught himself against the wall. Gideon set the bag of supplies on the floor, offering a sheepish smile before taking his leave.
"Why the face? We just went out to have a bit of fun!" Sirius said with a giggle, trying to pull Scarlett back into a hug, only to give up when she shot him a murderous glare.
"Fun?" Scarlett began to laugh uncontrollably. "Why the fuck do you always have to be such a fucking arsehole?" Her voice jumped two octaves, her finger jabbing at Sirius’s nose. "You’re a selfish, idiotic, irresponsible twat!"
Scarlett stepped back, panting, brushing her hair from her face. James and Peter exchanged a deeply awkward look, clearly at a loss.
"If I’m all that, why are you with me?" Sirius swallowed hard, the softness in his eyes replaced by something cold and rigid.
Scarlett took a very, very deep breath, trying to be rational. Sirius was drunk — she wasn’t. But the fear of losing him surged through her, and thinking clearly was near impossible.
"You can’t just disappear like that, not now, not in the middle of a bloody war!" Her expression crumpled as tears poured down her cheeks. "You don’t live alone!"
Sirius rubbed his face, sighing lazily, far too intoxicated to grasp the seriousness of the situation.
"Oh, Scarlett…" He gave a bitter smile. "It’s not like you ever wanted to live with me in the first place." His words were laced with a thorny bitterness. And too late, he realised he’d gone too far, regret flashing through his features.
Scarlett gasped, struck brutally by his words. All arguments fled her mind, her heart slammed painfully against her ribs, and her sobs grew uncontrollable. Her rage twisted into anguish, tearing through every pore of her body.
Before Sirius could attempt to apologise, Scarlett shook her head, silencing him with a glare, then spun on her heel. She stormed off to the bedroom, slamming the door behind her. Sirius blinked a few times, trying to absorb what had just happened, the alcohol clouding his judgement.
He pushed himself in the direction of the bedroom, intent on fixing his mistake and calming Scarlett down. But James was quicker. He intercepted him halfway, shoving him forcefully into a nearby chair. Sirius couldn't regain his balance, completely baffled by his friend’s sudden reaction.
To be honest, Sirius had completely forgotten James and Peter were still there.
"When are you going to grow up and act like a bloody man, huh?!" James bellowed, making Sirius’s head throb. "She’s been worried sick about you this whole time!"
Sirius furrowed his brows, nostrils flaring as his cheeks flushed with heat.
"I just went out and had a few drinks. I don’t see why everyone’s kicking off!" he shot back defensively, the hairs on the back of his neck bristling at the sharp way James was staring at him.
"You’re living with her now, Sirius. That means she deserves answers. Do you get that?" James asked, voice laced with condescension.
Sirius’s expression darkened, the alcohol washing away any remaining traces of reason.
"Scarlett and I aren’t married." He licked his lips, rubbing at his eyes. The dizziness was creeping in.
"That doesn’t fucking matter, Sirius!" James snapped, losing patience. "From the moment you decided to live together, it’s as good as!"
Sirius stared coldly at James. He knew his mate was right, but pride wouldn’t let him admit it. He exhaled sharply through his nose, dragging his hands down his face, the sting of failure clawing at the cracks in his soul — cracks that ran so deep, his self-hatred only grew heavier.
The thick silence pressed down on Sirius’s chest like a weight he couldn’t bear. He didn’t know what to say, only that he wanted to get up and apologise. He wanted to hold Scarlett, let the love between them silence the voices of his demons.
James, however, seemed to know exactly what he was thinking. He gripped Sirius’s shoulder tightly, glaring at him again — his glasses doing nothing to soften the fury behind his eyes.
"Sit the fuck down and shut it! Before you make this even worse!" he hissed, turning to Peter. "Get him a glass of water."
Sirius had never seen James this angry before. Sure, they’d rowed a few times, but James had never laid hands on him. Usually, it was the other way around.
James knocked gently on the bedroom door, glancing over his shoulder to make sure Sirius was still seated.
"Piss off." Scarlett’s voice came from the other side — fragile, shaken.
Without waiting for an invitation, James opened the door and stepped inside, finding Scarlett lying with her back to him. He didn’t need to get any closer to know she was crying — even though she was trying to hide it, the sobs that escaped her chest gave her away. She glanced at him from the corner of her eye, sniffling as she wiped her nose with the back of her hand.
"Scar… do you…" He cleared his throat, jaw tightening. "Do you want me to take Sirius to my place?" His voice was thick with concern. "He can sleep there and I’ll stay here. I don’t want to leave you on your own." James added, leaning against the doorframe.
Scarlett simply shrugged. She was far too emotionally drained to deal with any of it, curling further into the sheets, briefly considering transforming into Whiskers and vanishing altogether.
"I’m tired… just want to sleep," she whispered.
James nodded, gently pulling the door shut as he left the room.
Scarlett cried herself to sleep.
.
.
.
Regulus still couldn’t bring himself to believe Sirius was really after Harry. To stain the image he held of his godfather with the truth — that he was a cold, bloodthirsty killer — only made the melancholy heavier. He clutched his satchel as he entered the library, eyes scanning the empty tables. There weren’t many; most of the first and second years were there revising for exams.
He weaved between tables, stopping at one of the few with a spare chair, where Hermione sat with her nose buried in three enormous books. She didn’t even glance up, too engrossed in her work, scribbling fervently on a piece of parchment.
"Can I sit here?" Regulus pointed to the chair diagonally across from her, and the girl, still completely absorbed, merely nodded. She seemed to change her mind the moment he started pulling materials from his bag and settling in — her eyes widened and her cheeks flushed with colour.
Regulus unrolled the parchment for the essay Professor Binns had assigned on the Goblin Rebellion of 1890, in which one of his ancestors had led the wizarding forces to victory. He scratched his forehead as he dipped his quill in the inkwell, then looked back up at Hermione.
She was a small girl with bright, dark eyes and a mass of wild brown curls. Her pale cheeks were now tinged scarlet. Regulus frowned, not understanding why she was staring at him like that.
"What?" he asked. "Is there something on my face?" He turned back to his writing.
Hermione cleared her throat, unable to ignore him any longer.
"What are you doing here?" she asked, frowning as she tilted her chin up.
"I’m doing my homework," Regulus shrugged, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world. "Why are you here? It’s the last Hogsmeade visit. Why aren’t you with Harry and Ron?"
The girl twisted her mouth, flipping the page of the book she was reading with a sigh.
"Why didn’t you go to Hogsmeade?" she shot back, clearly in a foul mood.
Regulus wasn’t sure why he was bothering trying to have a conversation with her. Maybe it was because he’d been feeling a bit lonely the past few days — ever since Luana had found that injured cat outside the castle, she’d only had time for it, and Victoria hadn’t even bothered to speak to him. Miles was on edge about the Quidditch final, and Terry was getting along brilliantly with Aphelandra Pyke (rumour had it they were snogging).
So the idea of sitting in the library and chatting with Harry Potter’s know-it-all friend hadn’t seemed so bad — at least not at first. He regretted it the moment he realised she was actually waiting for a response.
"I’m not allowed to leave the castle. Because of my uncle," he said flatly. "How’s your friend, anyway?"
The news that Sirius had nearly stabbed Ron Weasley had spread through the school like wildfire. The boy had become a bit of a celebrity, and Regulus couldn’t feel good about it — not with concrete proof that Sirius was trying to kill Harry and didn’t give a toss about him.
What else could he expect, though? Sirius was a murderer. The sooner he accepted that, the better. The Minister for Magic had even given the Dementors permission to kiss him on sight.
The thought made Regulus’s stomach burn.
"I don’t know," Hermione pulled him out of his thoughts. "We’re not speaking." She wilted a little, her expression overtaken by loneliness. "My cat ate Ron’s rat."
Regulus frowned.
"Seriously?"
"Yeah." She bit her lower lip. "Ron was really upset — the rat had been in the family for ages… like ten years, I think."
A faint smile softened Regulus’s features.
"A rat that lived ten years?!" He rested his chin on his hand. "That’s weird. They usually live what… two, maybe four years? Well, either way, it was living on borrowed time." He wasn’t sure why he was trying to cheer her up, but Hermione offered him a small, genuine smile, and he allowed himself to feel a little lighter.
"Tell that to Ron… he’s absolutely heartbroken," she said, the smile fading into something sadder.
"He’ll get over it." Regulus returned to scribbling on his parchment, glancing at her out of the corner of his eye. Hermione tucked a thick strand of hair behind her ear and returned to her reading.
They stayed in silence until Regulus finished his homework.
"Why are you reading books about magical creature trials?" he asked eventually, making her look up, clearly embarrassed.
"Did you hear what happened in our Care of Magical Creatures lesson? With the hippogriff?"
"That Malfoy got hurt? Briefly heard about it," Regulus said, rolling up his parchment as soon as the ink dried. "Why?"
"Well… Hagrid asked me to… to help him defend the hippogriff. Seems it’s gone to the Ministry because of Malfoy’s dad…" She pressed her lips into a thin line. "You’re related to them, aren’t you?"
Regulus glanced at her as he tucked the parchment into his bag.
"His mum was my dad’s cousin." He folded his arms, letting the back of the chair take his weight. "Doesn’t mean much, really. Most pure-blood families are tangled up with each other in one way or another…"
"Hmm…" Hermione hummed. "Your dad… did he pass away?" She didn’t hide the caution in her voice.
"Yeah." Regulus licked his lips. "I never met him. He died the day I was born." He looked away, eyes drifting to the bookshelves, noticing groups of girls whispering and staring at them. "My mum was imprisoned a few days later… died about… five years ago in Azkaban."
He had no idea why he was telling Hermione all this, but it felt good to let it out — to share it with someone who hadn’t known him since he was a child, who wouldn’t make him feel small through years of built-up judgement. He knew she was judging him, of course — he could see it in the reflection of the library lights in her brown eyes. But at the same time, she looked like she was analysing him, trying to weigh what he’d said.
"I’m sorry about your parents," Hermione offered, giving his hand a gentle pat. Regulus just shook his head dismissively.
"It’s fine. Can’t really miss what you never had…" He yawned, pretending to be bored.
"Why didn’t you tell Harry about… about Sirius…" she stammered, shifting onto her knees on the chair and leaning over the book to get closer.
Regulus took a deep breath, trying to find a response that made sense.
"How exactly was I supposed to tell him our godfather was the reason his parents are dead?!" he shot back, the air rushing from his lungs.
Hermione said nothing, clearly unsure how to respond. Regulus understood — he probably shouldn’t have said that.
"What do your parents do?" he asked, changing the subject. She seemed relieved, furrowing her brow like she was trying to come up with an appropriate answer.
"They’re dentists." She nodded.
"Dentists?"
"Yeah… they take care of people’s teeth."
"So you’re Muggle-born?" Regulus frowned. Hermione nodded again. "Didn’t know that."
"You didn’t? Malfoy makes sure to announce it at every opportunity," she muttered, grumpily.
Regulus laughed.
"I’m not friends with him… what’s your surname again?"
"Granger. But you can call me Hermione," she offered, her cheeks going even redder.
He extended his hand to her.
"Regulus… or Reggie, if you prefer." He shook her hand, noting the nervous sweat on her fingers. "Can I help you with the hippogriff’s defence?"
"Y-yes, of course," she stammered, pushing one of the books across the table towards him.
Regulus dove into the research, grateful that the new distraction was enough to pull him away — even momentarily — from the things that had been haunting him these past days. The fact that Sirius was in Hogsmeade in his Animagus form, that he had attacked the Gryffindor common room, that he was ignoring his existence. Maybe… maybe it wouldn’t hurt to step away from all of it for a few minutes.
.
.
.
Scarlett woke up in the middle of the night, her eyes so swollen she could barely open them. She got up and noticed Padfoot lying on the floor at the foot of the bed. He perked his ears up when she walked to the bathroom to wash her face with cold water. It didn’t help much. She brushed her teeth and went back to sleep without saying a word, deliberately ignoring the dog.
She woke up several times during the night, hearing Padfoot’s paws clicking softly against the wooden floor of the other rooms before he returned to the bedroom and lay down in the same spot. She didn’t even realise morning had come, nor did she notice Padfoot’s absence. What she did notice were the murmurs and hushed voices near the door.
She spent the entire day like that, waking only when it was already dark again, the only light in the room spilling in from the crack beneath the door. She forced herself to sleep again, wondering why the exhaustion she felt wasn’t going away despite so many hours of sleep.
She was dragged under by the currents of a strange dream. She was standing in front of Grimmauld Place, with Regulus beside her, holding her hand. Snow crowned the roof of the house, as well as the playground behind them. It was cold, so cold she could hardly breathe.
Red said something to her, but she didn’t understand. The two of them climbed the worn stone steps, and she stared fixedly at the door that had just appeared. Regulus grabbed the silver doorknob, shaped like a coiled serpent. The door opened with a strange click.
Scarlett lifted her gaze across the threshold, where there was a hallway flanked by old-fashioned gas lamps that hissed softly. The lighting was dim, flickering, and there was a silhouette at the end of the corridor — a tall man with his back to her, wearing a dark green frock coat.
Her whole body trembled, heart thundering in her ears. Scarlett stopped walking, stepping back, but Regulus’s hand pushed her forward. She wanted to say no, wanted to beg him to stop, but all that escaped her lips was a hesitant gasp.
She woke with something warm and sticky brushing her fingers. Scarlett grunted, pulling away, feeling a cold snout against her palm, the dream fading into nothing. She blinked a few times, trying to see in the gloom. Padfoot shoved her hand onto his head, asking for affection.
Scarlett huffed, rolling over in bed, her heart still racing.
"You’re not expecting me to forgive you just because you’re in dog form." She whispered, her voice raspy. She turned under the covers, making room for him at her side. Padfoot climbed up, his black fur tickling her. He sniffed her cheeks, then licked them.
"Stop it, Padfoot… stop…" she muttered, annoyed. "My face is burning."
He whimpered softly, settling down. Scarlett sniffled and stretched out, hugging the dog like he was a massive stuffed bear, hoping she wouldn’t wake up smelling like him the next day.
Not that she gave a damn about much of anything at that moment, drifting back off to sleep.
This time, she dreamt of her house in Godric’s Hollow. Regulus was there again. Which was odd, considering the only time he’d ever been to her home was when Orion and Walburga had shown up with Sirius for that disastrous dinner.
In the dream, though, Red was wearing a coat stained with blood. There was blood on her bed, too. He ran his thumb across her cheek, and Scarlett stared at him, startled. A strange feeling throbbed in her chest, something that sent frantic shivers breaking out across her skin.
"Grab your multi-portkey and take me back," Red ordered, and Scarlett obeyed without hesitation.
The whole world spun in reverse and Scarlett jolted awake, not even realising it was Sirius now in bed with her, his strong arms wrapped around her and his tattooed fingers tangled in her hair.
"What is it?" His voice was hoarse and drowsy.
Scarlett pulled away and sat at the edge of the mattress, feeling wrung out from so much crying. It was still night, and she hadn’t the faintest idea whether it had just got dark or if dawn was approaching.
"Love?" Sirius stroked her arm with the pads of his fingers, trying to catch her attention. "Do you want anything?"
"Water," Scar murmured, hugging herself as a wave of cold suddenly washed over her, despite the sweat clinging to her skin.
She heard the creak of the bed as Sirius rolled to the other side and got up. She stayed frozen, afraid that if she moved even a little, she’d fall apart. And her face hurt far too much for that.
Sirius switched on the light in the hallway, letting it spill into the dark bedroom. He crouched in front of Scarlett and handed her the glass. Her vision was blurry, and all she could focus on was drinking the water in greedy gulps. Sirius placed his hand on her knee, tracing aimless patterns on the bone with his thumb.
"Scar…" He licked his lips, trying to meet her gaze. But Scarlett turned her head, handing the glass back.
"Just… leave me alone, Sirius." She had to summon every last shred of strength to get the words out, her voice raw and wounded.
"No, Scar, I didn’t—"
"This is why I didn’t want to live with you," she went on, ignoring him. "Sometimes you act like a bloody five-year-old and go around hurting anyone in your path just because you feel attacked."
Sirius swallowed hard, the muscle in his jaw tightening as he clenched it, his neck tensing. Scarlett lay back down, curling into the sheets, trying to ignore the bitter taste in her mouth. Sirius, however, caught her wrist, stopping her from turning her back to him.
"Scarlett…"
"I told you to leave me the fuck alone!"
"You’ve been in this bed for three days now." Sirius slid his hand down to hers, interlacing their fingers. "At least… get up for a bit… have a bath…"
"Leave me alone." She repeated, yanking her hand away with a sudden motion. "Please, just leave…"
"No," Sirius murmured, firm. "I’m running you a bath."
"Stop it, Sirius." Scarlett let out a long sigh. The tears kept threatening to return, but she couldn’t cry anymore — all she could manage were dry sobs.
She heard the sound of water running into the tub and cupboard doors opening. She had no clue what was even in those cupboards; Euphemia Potter had done nearly all the shopping for the house. Scarlett shoved the pillow over her head, shutting her eyes, drifting in a half-numb state. She sensed Sirius’s shadow stretching from the light in the bathroom, and she half-opened her eyes, turning her face towards him.
"Come on, it’s ready." Sirius walked over to her, unwrapping the sheet from her leg. "Come on, love… get undressed."
"No, Sirius. I told you, I don’t want to."
"I didn’t ask if you wanted to, Scarlett. Just get on with it." He used that tone she loathed — all commanding and overbearing. "If you don’t take your clothes off, I’ll chuck you into the bath fully dressed."
A laugh nearly vibrated Scarlett’s throat, but she stifled it.
"Fuck off."
It was funny how Sirius had blown up over so much less the day of their fight, but now, sober and racked with guilt, he was acting like a lost puppy.
"Please, love. For me." He took her hand and placed it on his head, just like he had when he was in Padfoot form. "Please. Don’t punish yourself for the shite I’ve done."
Scarlett kept ignoring him, but as always, Sirius could be a bloody nuisance when he wanted to be. And usually, he got his way — especially with something he truly desired. All that time living together had given Scarlett an undeniable truth: Sirius Black always got what he wanted, one way or another.
"Love…" He poked her ribs, making her squirm from the tickles. "Kitten…"
Scarlett let out a groan of annoyance, covering her sides with her arms. That left her in the perfect position for Sirius to scoop her up in one swift motion, lifting her without the slightest effort. It was no secret she’d lost weight — she barely ate, and when she did, that damned Draught of Melancholy made her throw most of it back up.
It was easier not to eat. She’d lost most of her muscle, though traces of it still lingered. The bathroom light blinded her for a moment when Sirius set her down, closing the door as if he were afraid she might bolt back to bed.
He looked wrecked. Heavy dark circles under his eyes, hair a mess, lips pale. But his eyes — those still held the same spark, the same arrogance. Scarlett hugged herself tightly, shivering all over. That had become normal too — feeling cold even in the sweltering heat of summer.
"Need help getting undressed?" Sirius stepped closer, but she only shook her head, curling inwards.
Scarlett undressed slowly, still drowsy. She stepped carefully into the tub, letting the hot water soak the sweat from her skin. She stared at the little flowers floating on the surface, and her lips curled slightly. Sirius sat beside the bathtub, resting his head on the edge, getting some of his black hair wet.
In front of them, there was a mirror. Scarlett stared into it, seeing her boyfriend utterly defeated. His tattoos stood out starkly against pale skin, his bare chest rising with heavy breaths, legs crossed, arms resting on the porcelain edge of the tub.
"I didn’t mean to say those things." He didn’t lift his head. "Will you forgive me?"
Scarlett stayed silent, the only sound between them the gentle sloshing of water against the sides of the bath. The moment Sirius turned his face just enough for the bathroom’s white light to catch his silver eyes, the hurt struck her all at once. Sirius noticed — the glint in his eyes was quickly replaced with shame.
She didn’t want to understand him. But she did. There were things she was ashamed of too — and he knew them all. She could see the holes in his soul because hers was rotting from the same disease; the kind made of regret and fury. The desperate wish to do things differently and still screwing it up the same way. That feeling that nothing she did would change a thing, because in the end, she'd always lose her family.
Scarlett felt so empty, and yet so completely burdened. Like an anchor sinking into a wild ocean, one that pulls you down and folds you and breaks you and slices you and splits you — until all that’s left is a girl with too many traumas and not enough reactions. Sirius was there too, just as deep, that same thing yanking and thrashing them around, tethering them to a connection full of dependencies and bubbles on the verge of bursting.
It was as if they gave up their breath for one another, only for both to end up drowning. That was their problem — they loved each other so much they forgot about themselves. They saw so much of themselves in the other that they thought loving just that part was enough, forgetting that love was supposed to embrace everything — the good, the bad, the passions and the tempers. The things that brought them joy, and the things that didn’t.
For Scarius, it had always been too late. They were bound together not just by love — but by pain, by trauma, by fear. Fear of being alone, fear of facing themselves, fear of recognising that the world is infinite — an infinite that ends, that dies, that is reborn.
It was a relationship ruled by fear. Fear of hurting, fear of wounding, fear of losing. Sirius had already lost too much. So had Scarlett. That’s why they clung to each other like they could be salvation — and in the end, they were each other’s destruction.
Scarlett brushed the stray locks of Sirius’s hair from his face, allowing herself to really look into the sea of silver in his eyes — filled with remorse and hesitation. She was drawn in easily, seeing her own tormented soul reflected in pupils as dark as the night sky outside. She didn’t like what she saw. Scarlett had never liked herself much — but in that moment, she had never hated herself more.
Sirius Black could give her hell just as easily as he gave her heaven. It wasn’t healthy, and it certainly wasn’t ideal, but that man made her feel unbearably exposed and fragile. And the worst part? Safe. Even when showing him her soul, even when confessing her sins, even when hearing cruel words spill from those damned lips — she couldn’t pull away. She couldn’t bring herself to send him away.
Because she didn’t want to. Scarlett wanted to stay with Sirius for the rest of her life and have her happily ever after — it was ridiculous and naive, but she liked imagining herself marrying him and having kids, living a simple life like their idiot Muggle neighbours. She envied them — oh, how Scarlett envied them!
She didn’t care about war. All she wanted was love. The searing love of Sirius Black.
Her gaze travelled across his face — his noble nose, sharp cheekbones, broad jawline. The dark stubble that gave him a rugged sort of maturity. His soft, pink lips, perfectly shaped. His long, curled lashes. The crease that formed on his brow when he raised his eyebrows. The vulnerability laid bare in his expression.
"I love you, Sirius, but I hate when you hurt me like this." Scarlett rested her face on her knees. "I hate when you don’t tell me things and I only find out when you’re angry."
Sirius furrowed his brows, clearly bothered.
"What do you mean?" He didn’t take his eyes off her, the bathroom light dancing in his starry gaze.
"I didn’t know you were upset because I refused to move in with you," she explained calmly, taking advantage of the numbness that dulled everything, as if she were sedated. "Why didn’t you tell me?"
Sirius muttered a few words before closing his mouth again. As if they didn’t make any sense.
"I didn’t know what to say… after… after the fire… I just…" He squeezed his eyes shut, rubbing at them. "I didn’t want to make you cry."
"You did anyway." Scarlett turned her face towards the water, burying it in her hands.
"I’m sorry." Sirius brushed the strands of hair from her forehead, tucking them behind her ear. "I was pissed."
"That’s not an excuse."
He let the air drain from his lungs.
"I know."
"You haven’t been sleeping." Scarlett’s blue eyes searched for his grey ones, anchoring them, letting the colours dance with one another, spinning between the bathwater and the overhead light. Reflecting off the dampness on her face and the sweat glistening on his cheeks. From the freckles on her nose to the stubble on his chin.
Truth came easy in this closeness. Sirius couldn’t keep things from Scarlett for long — no matter how hard he tried, he always ended up giving in, just like she did. Resisting each other had grown exhausting, and they’d both learned to stop trying.
"There’s something wrong with me." He said it so softly, with so much fear in his voice, that Scarlett lifted her head, her brow furrowing. "I can’t sleep because I… I feel like… if I do…" Sirius wet his lips. "…it’ll all happen again, and I’ll lose you. I can’t sleep. Not until I know everything’s alright and… sometimes I… I get lost in what happened. One sound, one smell, one little thing that reminds me of that day and I’m right back in that hell and… I don’t know what to do, Scar. I’m scared."
All the tarnish in the silver of his gaze was washed away by his tears.
A subtle smile brushed Sirius’s lips as Scar ran her fingers through his hair, chasing away the panic that threatened to claw up his throat and choke him. One single caress was enough to pull him back from his demons.
Scarlett had always held a great deal of power over Sirius — and this time would be no different.
Because what echoed between them was stronger than fire or death. It was what had kept them alive. It was Sirius’s breath in Scarlett’s heartbeat — pulsing like magic, the sweetest and most unforgiving spell, capable of killing and dying. It drew out the very best and the very worst in them both.
"You don’t have to be afraid, Sirius. I’ve spent all this time so caught in my own pain I didn’t see yours… I’m sorry I haven’t been able to do much. I miss them. Every single day… and I…" The unstoppable sob returned. "I’m sorry."
Sirius shook his head and pulled her into a hug, sending water spilling over the edge of the bath. He didn’t care — all that mattered was the way Scarlett clung to him like he was a lifeline, pressing him against her chest as though she could shield herself inside his heart.
"It’s alright." He kissed her damp forehead, running his fingers through her hair. "I talked to Prongs. And he… he suggested I go to St Mungo’s. I haven’t booked anything yet. I didn’t want to leave you on your own. Will you come with me?"
Scarlett nodded, playing with a lock of his hair.
"I didn’t know you were going through all this. I’m sorry," she murmured, kissing his collarbone, her fingertips tracing the scar that slashed diagonally across his chest.
"It’s alright. I don’t want any secrets between us." Sirius went on, cupping her face in his hands, one thumb brushing the base of her throat where her pulse thudded beneath his touch. "I love you."
Scarlett was drawn so easily into the silver of Sirius’s eyes she didn’t realise she was drowning at the edge of them. His breath brushed her lips, and he paused — foreheads pressed together, their noses touching. He didn’t dare kiss her yet.
"I love you so much that just the thought of losing you…" He swallowed slowly, his breath caught in the space between them, his fingers sliding down Scarlett’s neck, across her collarbone, and pinching gently at her hardened nipple. Scarlett gasped. "I don’t want to lose you."
"Never." Scarlett trembled as Sirius’s hand sank beneath the water, never leaving her skin, reaching between her legs. "I never will…" Whatever words were left on her lips were silenced by his mouth.
He pulled off his shorts and stepped into the bath. Scarlett melted into the kiss, her blood stirring, her body tingling with something that had nothing to do with cold, or fear, or the warm temperature of the water. Sirius seemed to feel it too, kissing her back with a heat that defied the water surrounding them.
As if nothing else mattered.
Sirius positioned himself over her, soaking the entire bathroom floor. His fingers traced Scarlett’s inner thighs in the same rhythm with which he invaded her mouth with his tongue, drinking in everything she hadn’t given him in the past few days, demanding everything that was rightfully his; all of Scarlett’s thoughts, her fears, her restraints. Apologising at the same time he intoxicated her with his impulsiveness. Scarlett allowed herself to burn in his arms—it was the natural order of things. She always came back to Sirius.
A low moan rumbled from deep in Scarlett’s throat when Sirius rubbed her clit with his thumb, his other fingers teasing her as they brushed along her cunt, prompting Scarlett to reach for Sirius’s groin only to find his cock already hard, hot, and throbbing.
Sirius growled when she wanked him, applying pressure with her palm and fingers, making him lift his head, break the kiss and roll his eyes. The water had gone cold by now, but it wasn’t enough to cool the fire boiling between them. Scarlett got on her knees and shoved him, forcing him to sit in the tub, climbing onto his lap as she seized control of that salacious dance.
He really didn’t want to give in, let alone surrender control to Scarlett, but he had no choice when she bit his neck and rubbed her cunt against his erection, a wicked smile curling her lips. Sirius gripped her curvaceous waist, far too enchanted by the shivers her nails sent across his chest to try and take over.
He slid himself between Scarlett’s legs as she knelt, refusing to sit down on his lap. Sirius grew impatient, pulling her closer, kissing her collarbone and nibbling on her nipples, his stubble leaving her pale skin flushed red. Scarlett tilted her head back, her hair dipping into the water while Sirius sucked noisily at the skin between her breasts, tickling her with his moustache.
It wasn’t just an apology—it was a reminder that, despite everything she said, Scarlett belonged to him just as fiercely as he belonged to her. She moaned into his hair and that was all it took to dissolve the last bit of hesitation in Sirius.
He licked his way back up—over her breasts, her collarbone, her neck, her jaw—until he reached her mouth, biting her lower lip so she’d part it for his tongue. She gasped and moaned again into his mouth. Sirius sucked Scarlett’s tongue, adjusting himself better in the tub as he pulled her down onto his cock.
Scarlett resisted, a lustful curve forming at the corner of her lips mid-kiss—one that Sirius stole for himself as he pushed her knees apart and made her slide along the porcelain, pulling her against him, seeking her tight heat as if it were as vital to him as the air filling his lungs.
Sirius gripped the nape of Scarlett’s neck firmly, his other hand forcing her hips down until he felt the head of his cock press against her cunt. Sirius opened his eyes, easing the intensity of the kiss, letting their lips merely touch without tongue, watching as her freckles darkened against her pale skin, her nose twitching in anticipation, the connection between them tightening, her eyelids squeezing shut and her brown lashes fluttering.
"Look at me, love," Sirius demanded, exhaling through his mouth, the breath lifting the stray strands of Scarlett’s hair.
Scar opened her eyes slowly, all rationality fogged over by a heady, honeyed haze. That was the effect Sirius Black had on her. Love was far too simple a word to describe it—it was devotion masked as codependency and compulsion. Addiction. Torment. Longing and agony, possessiveness and submission. It was the chime of magic and the stretch of shadows. The bitterness of life and the sweetness of death.
Sirius pulled her down, slowly, entering her in a breathless rhythm. Fevered. The hairs on his entire body stood on end as Scarlett’s warmth enveloped him, forcing him to lean his head back against the edge of the tub, gripping her waist so tightly it would leave marks. The water churned around them, splashing onto their cheeks, making Scar’s skin shimmer as if she were a marble sculpture—the Goddess of Love herself descending from Olympus to rip out his heart and place it on display among her vast collection.
Scarlett braced her hands on Sirius’s shoulders as she sat on his lap, feeling him fully inside her, the stretch a delicious burn. She pressed their foreheads together as she began to ride him slowly, her movements dragging, blessed by the growls Sirius let out against her lips.
He grabbed her arse with one hand, the other slipping between their thighs, circling her clit with his thumb. Scarlett sighed, licking Sirius’s lower lip as she kept the rhythm slow, deliberately torturing him without giving in to his hunger. Sirius squeezed his eyes shut, hissing, his cock twitching inside her, warning her he was close. She clenched around him and Sirius’s eyes flew open, his lips parting as he let out a moan.
"I'm going to come like this," he rasped, swallowing hard, pressing his lips together in a desperate attempt to last a little longer.
Scarlett smiled—a wicked, depraved grin. Nothing gave her more pleasure than seeing Sirius completely at the mercy of his own filthy desires, black hair tousled and spread along the edge of the tub, his face lost to ecstasy. It was intoxicating, the way Sirius’s cock struck every delicious spot inside her, sending tremors down her legs and shaky gasps across her lips.
"You’ll come with me or you won’t come at all," Scarlett threatened, digging her nails into his shoulders so hard she drew blood, increasing the pace.
Sirius had no choice—his breath grew short with the rising tension of orgasm, which hit him the moment Scarlett’s moan echoed into his mouth. He licked her lips as he lost himself in the warm, wet walls clenching around his cock, pulling her down against his waist, thrusting deep, jaw clenched as he spilled his release inside her, claiming her as his.
"Mine," Sirius murmured, almost unconsciously, catching her gaze while still immersed in that frenzy of peaks, of passion and worship. "You’re mine."
Scarlett’s body was his. Her soul was his. Her heart too.
"All yours," she agreed, her voice lazy as she scattered kisses across his beard, his chin and cheeks, stopping at the tip of his nose. "Only yours."
Sirius held her close, resting his face between her breasts, listening to her heartbeat echoing in sync with his own, possessing Scarlett once and for all. The cold water swirling between them wasn’t enough to break the bond that chained them together. Sirius was still inside her—and in that moment, he decided he wouldn’t wait for social conventions or anyone’s approval.
As soon as she was better, he would ask Scarlett to marry him.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 20: I feel like Icarus, flying too near the sun
Chapter Text
LXXXVIII
Whiskers opened her eyes and yawned lazily, stretching her front paws. As she tried to stretch the back ones, a searing pain made her whimper. She squeezed her eyes shut, letting her sight adjust to the dim surroundings. Lamps softened the gloom and a few candles crackled atop the tables, their light glinting off the dark green velvet canopy of the beds.
She blinked several times. She knew this place. She’d been here before, she...
She tried to get up, but was stopped by the throbbing pain running through her right paw, shooting up her spine. The cat let out an agonised growl, realising she was lying on one of the tables, resting on a cushion and covered with a sheet in such a way that she couldn’t see the injured limb.
Her gaze swept across the room again, noticing a dozen quills laid neatly beside her, along with a notebook and potion flasks. She was on the desk of one of the Slytherin dormitories. Judging by the tidiness and the clothes laid out on one of the beds, she guessed it was the girls’ dormitory.
Whiskers tried to return to her human form, but the pain numbed her from her magic. Her ears perked up as the door opened and two girls entered the room. One was dark-skinned, her hair as black as Sirius’s, her accent foreign. The other had hair as white as Pandora’s, skin pale as milk, and spoke with such harshness it made the cat’s head ache. She knew them. They were Reggie’s friends.
"He said he wanted to focus on his N.E.W.T.s this year instead of staying with me! Can you believe that?!" the fair-haired one complained, throwing herself onto the bed nearest the door. "It’s fucking ridiculous!" Her face was flushed. She’d clearly been crying earlier.
The dark girl stifled a laugh with her hand, her attention turning to Whiskers. The cat shut her eyes and pretended to sleep.
"Sweet Salazar, Victoria..." she huffed, inspecting the cat’s injured paw. "Cedric’s far too proper for you, he was completely mortified when you offered to help me get back at the Weasleys..."
Whiskers tensed the muscles in her paw as the girl ran her fingers through her fur, murmuring a pain relief spell.
"The bone’s back in place..." she muttered to herself, ignoring her friend’s whining.
Bone? The cat tried to remember what had happened to land her there, but her memory was a lazy jumble of things she didn’t want to digest. Not right then. So all she did was bare her whiskers and pretend she was under a sleep charm.
"This is all Regulus’s fault! If he’d just asked me out..." the one called Victoria let her feet thump against the bed as she exhaled with a little frustrated squeal.
Whiskers opened just one eye, paying close attention to the conversation.
"Why do you need a bloke so badly?!" the foreign girl shot her friend a sidelong glance, a few strands of hair escaping the bun pinned at the back of her head.
"I don’t need a bloke that badly!" Victoria protested, tossing a pillow at her friend, who caught it mid-air. "I’ve always liked Reg, Luana!"
"If you actually liked Reggie, you’d have respected his choice!" Luana snapped, hurling the pillow back. "You shouldn’t have done that. He’s still pretty upset with you—he already was, what with all that stuff going on with his uncle, and your bloody tantrum just made it worse..."
"I am not throwing a tantrum!" Victoria gripped her hair tightly, though the pitch of her voice said otherwise.
Whiskers covered her ears with her paws. She wasn’t in the mood for teenage drama right now—not when her head had finally started piecing events together. Where were her ghosts?! She glanced down at her front left paw, wondering if there was any way she could summon them there.
Probably not.
"Especially after Black tried to break into Gryffindor Tower again and failed to kill the younger Weasley..."
Whiskers turned her head slightly towards Luana, who stood with her arms crossed, back to her and facing Victoria.
"Younger Weasley?" Victoria sniffled into a tissue, rubbing her reddened eyes.
"Yeah… one of the zillion Weasleys, but the youngest..."
"Potter’s mate?"
"Yeah, that one! Apparently Sirius Black nearly made mincemeat out of him..." she added with a mocking little snort.
"Heard Pucey talking about it earlier," Victoria said, her voice nasal. "I wanted to talk to Reg, but... he doesn’t believe his uncle could do something like that. What am I supposed to say to make him wake up? Sirius Black spent twelve years in Azkaban! His brain’s probably turned to mush and what’s left is a complete nutter."
No, no, no, no, no. Sirius tried to break into the Gryffindor common room again? Had he managed to catch Peter? She hoped not. She needed to get to him.
"Wasn’t he already mental before Azkaban?!" Luana grunted, thinking aloud. "I reckon you should talk to Reg. He’s not doing well, Mimi." She crouched down in front of her trunk, pulling out a few potion vials. "He’s like you, pretends he doesn’t care but..."
"We are nothing alike!" she snapped, standing up from the bed.
"Imagine if you were..."
Whiskers tried to get up once more, letting out a hiss of pain before collapsing back down. Luana turned to her at once, concern written all over her face, placing the little bottles on the table and gently stroking the cat’s chin.
"Oh, you’re awake," she said in a high-pitched voice. "Your leg’s still healing, you’re going to need to stay here a while longer..."
Whiskers turned her face away, trying to transform back, but all that coursed through her body was the burning pain in her leg, radiating through her veins in sync with her blood. It hurt so much she felt dizzy.
"Is this the cat that fell on me during that match when the Dementors showed up?" Victoria stepped closer, the tip of her nose still red from crying. Whiskers flattened her ears and hissed at her.
"I thought so too, but... there are loads of tuxedo cats about. There’s this one I’ve tripped over like three times and, even though they look alike, I’m not sure it’s the same one..." Luana murmured, her dark eyes fixed on Whiskers. "This one’s female."
Despite the doubt, Whiskers knew the truth. She was the cat Luana had stumbled over all those times—just like Regulus. It was a bit odd being a cat with human habits, and little accidents like that just happened. The cat pulled her cutest face, pupils widening at the two of them.
"Aww, she’s so sweet!" Luana cooed, rubbing her head.
"She does look like her... that white smudge like a moustache on her snout... it’s identical, isn’t it?" Victoria went on, sounding suspicious.
Whiskers whimpered, licking Luana’s fingers, which made the girl giggle at the roughness of her tongue.
"I don’t think so..." She waved a hand in front of her face like brushing the thought away. "Besides... it’s just a cat." Luana coaxed Whiskers into taking a healing potion, one for pain, and one for sleep. As soon as the cat dozed off, she grabbed Victoria by the collar of her shirt and dragged her out of the room.
"Oi, Luana, what the hell are you doing?!" Victoria complained as they reached the centre of the common room.
"She’s definitely not just a cat!" Luana hissed, as if sharing some top-secret revelation.
Victoria arched her eyebrows and curled her lips.
"What are you on about?"
"The cat, Mimi!" Luana gestured back towards the dormitories. "She’s not just a cat! She... she’s been watching us since before Black’s break-ins. I’ve bumped into her like three times because she’s always watching Reg. And after I found her—conveniently—just outside Hogwarts the morning after Black’s last attack... there were no more attacks!" She glanced around and leaned in closer to her friend.
"Where are you going with this, Lua?" Victoria asked, suspicious.
"Reggie said maybe he’s not in the form people expect. What if it’s a cat? What if... the cat is Sirius Black?!" She clapped her hands like she’d just made the biggest revelation of her life. Then she grabbed a biscuit from the side table and stuck it in her mouth like a pipe. "I’m a genius!"
Victoria burst out laughing, grabbing Lua by both arms as she tried to speak through the laughter, but couldn’t. It took several long seconds for her to calm down.
"You’re not using the dodgy stuff you sell around, are you?" Mimi wiped a lone tear from her cheek as the laughter subsided, still panting. "Stop being mental, girl. If Sirius were the cat, he’d be male, not female. And there’s no way he’s a Metamorphmagus like me, ‘cause he’d be registered. So if he were an Animagus—which is already bloody unlikely—that cat would have to be male."
Luana muttered a few silent curses, clenching her fists, because Victoria was right. How had she missed that detail?! She was one of the best students in Care of Magical Creatures. She smacked her own forehead for such a ridiculous theory. Instead of giving up, though, she huffed and decided she’d research the matter more thoroughly.
"I’m going to the library," she declared, stomping up the mermaid fountain staircase.
Victoria shrugged—it wasn’t like she had much of an opinion on the matter. She scanned the common room with her eyes and spotted Regulus, deeply focused on his N.E.W.T. studies at one of the corner tables, Walkman headphones over his ears. She didn’t want to go over to him, especially since it’d look like she was crawling back. Still, the distance between them gnawed at her.
He was her childhood friend, they’d spent their whole lives together, and now walking past him in the corridor felt wrong... Cedric was a great stand-in—he was even her boyfriend—but she couldn’t get Regulus out of her head, like he’d been stuck there with a Permanent Sticking Charm.
She missed him. More than she wanted to admit. And Cedric just wasn’t enough to fill the hole gouged out in her chest. It felt wrong that they hadn’t spoken in all those weeks.
She wandered over casually, flashing a smile at Flint and Pucey playing wizard’s chess at a nearby table, then stopped beside Reggie, casting a shadow over his parchment. He stopped writing at once, glancing up at her as he pushed one of the Walkman’s headphones aside.
"Hi." Victoria ran a hand through her hair and over her face, hoping he wouldn’t notice the traces of tears still clinging to her features.
"Hi." Regulus returned to his notes, giving her little attention.
Victoria pressed her lips into a thin line, sitting down in the chair opposite Reg. His left hand, still gloved, gave a twitch and he gripped the quill too tightly, snapping it by accident.
Regulus sighed, bit his lower lip, and pulled out a spare quill, dipping it in the inkwell while deliberately ignoring Victoria, tapping his foot to the beat of the music.
"What are you listening to?" She leaned over the table, propping herself up on her elbows, trying to seem casual.
He leaned back in his chair without meeting her gaze.
"Whitesnake. Fool for Your Loving." Reg replied curtly, giving her no chance to keep the conversation going as he turned his attention back to his notes.
Victoria nearly laughed. She hated Whitesnake—especially the passive-aggressive message Reggie was clearly sending through the song. A pang hit her chest, but she was already numb to all of it. It wasn’t just Regulus’s rejection that irritated her, but his utter indifference. And he knew exactly how to rile her up.
It was easier to be a coward than to own up to what she really felt. Victoria took a deep breath, clenching her jaw. Then she plastered on a breezy smile.
"What are you studying?" She craned her neck to try and read his notes. Reg gripped his quill again, knuckles turning white.
"What do you want, Victoria?" Reg didn’t bother to hide the bite in his voice. "Had enough of Diggory?"
She laughed haughtily, blinking in surprise at his words. She knew Regulus was pissed off, but he’d never spoken to her like that before. Maybe she deserved it. Maybe she wanted him to act like this, not like some bloody lifeless statue.
"Oh? Jealous, are you?" Mimi shot back, giving him a venomous glare.
"Jealous of Diggory? I feel sorry for him, if you must know," he snapped in return.
His words made a pulsing vein pop at Victoria’s temple. She’d expected a reaction like that, but she wasn’t mentally prepared for the sheer contempt he showed her so effortlessly. Her smug smile turned spiteful, fingers reaching for the inkwell with quiet intent.
She’d always liked Regulus’s handwriting. It wasn’t too ornate or messy—it was the perfect balance of legible and beautiful. She remembered when they studied at that primary school for wizards in Mayfair and how he’d learnt to read and write before anyone else—he’d always been bloody clever.
He was always trying to stand out in everything, as if he needed to earn the approval of his uncles. Remus had been the most loving with him, and Reg adored him. She knew that adoration wasn’t so welcome anymore—not after Sirius ran away. Victoria sighed. Regulus always had this stupid habit of shutting himself off from his emotions. She knew because she did the same—though it was harder to freeze them out the way he did with her.
Then, driven by a snake-like impulse of rage and indignation, Victoria tipped the ink over Regulus’s parchment, destroying his notes. He stopped moving instantly, as if struck by a jinx, and lifted his glare to her—his eyes the colour of steel folded over itself.
Her malicious smile took on a satisfied, smug twist, which only seemed to aggravate Reg even more. In one precise movement, he scooped up some of the ink with his hand and splattered it across Victoria’s face. She shut her eyes and stumbled back, lips parting in shock and outrage.
"Regulus!" she shouted, her voice shooting up two octaves, hands scrubbing at her eyes.
She heard Reggie let out a nasal laugh, though it faded quickly when he inhaled sharply.
"Did I hurt you?" he murmured, voice trembling, thick with fear.
With her breathing short, Victoria kept her eyes tightly shut, hands still covering her face, her features slowly twisting under the strain of trying not to cry. Of course she was hurt—nothing stung more than rejection, not even Vin’s punches or her family’s disdain.
"Shit, Mimi, I’m sorry..." Regulus stood up, knocking the chair over. He hurried around the table and grabbed her wrist. "Is it hurting?"
Victoria gave a reluctant nod. All she wanted was to run from Regulus and bury herself in her bedcovers. She wanted to rip him from her mind with the same force Vin used when trying to tear out her feathers, but nowhere felt safe—Regulus Black was like a curse that followed her wherever she went, burrowing into her heart and keeping her from moving on. He was so selfish he didn’t even let Cedric in.
Maybe it was because Reg had been there for too long. She liked Regulus more than she liked herself. She felt something cold against her back and realised it was a counter. Reg soaked a towel and gently dabbed at her eyes with the utmost care, as though she were about to shatter.
Victoria rested her hand against Regulus’s chest, slipping it beneath his cloak until she found his racing heart. She felt his chest tighten, his breath falter, fear trying to push the effects of her touch away. She understood what that was. His defences were razor-sharp too—just the hint of a threat and everything went on high alert.
"You alright?" Reg’s voice vanished into the moment.
But she knew there was one thing Regulus couldn’t resist for long—because she couldn’t either. She opened her eyes slowly, paying no mind to his question. All she saw was the blue of his eyes melting beneath the golden light of the bathroom, its rays setting fire to the grey of his irises, pupils dilating until Victoria sank into them, making her swallow hard and clutch the collar of his T-shirt.
Contrary to what she’d expected, Regulus didn’t pull away. He remained there, still, studying her expression, just as caught in that shared gaze as she was. It was how they spoke—because eyes didn’t lie. They were the mirror of the soul, and right then, it was as if Victoria’s caramel eyes had turned into quicksand, dragging Regulus down with hunger, swallowing him whole until he reached the oasis only he could see in the desert dunes of her irises.
She was the only one who could rouse his sleeping soul, deliver the jolt that shook him awake, that brought chaos to his forced stillness. Opening his eyes, unblocking his ears, heating the emotions that floated in his chest until they boiled over. It was anger, rebellion, frustration. It was also desire, fear, and thrill. Regulus panted under the overwhelming reaction Victoria Rookwood’s simple touch could provoke in him, the storm that had begun to roar inside him.
He touched Victoria’s cheek gently, as though he were doing something wrong. She held her breath, throat tensing with the slow movement of a swallow. His grey eyes traced the speckles of ink across the pale skin of her cheeks.
"I never meant to make you cry." Regulus’s breath stirred the stray strands of her hair, pushing them back, brushing over her cheeks.
"You did anyway." She shot back, bitter, though she hadn’t meant to say anything. She kept her chin high, eyes locked with Reggie’s.
He blinked a few times, thumb sketching a little heart in the ink on her cheek. His gaze dropped briefly to her lips, then darted back to Victoria’s eyes as if he’d caught a glimpse of something forbidden. With his other hand, he brushed aside a strand of her white hair that kept falling in front of her nose, curling his finger around it, watching as her cheeks flushed pink.
"Sorry, I..." he began, only for the words to be blown away when Victoria leaned in, pressing her forehead to his. Her cherry-stained lips hovered dangerously close to his.
He made a motion to pull away, but Victoria gripped his collar tightly, holding him in place, refusing to let him surrender to his instincts of self-preservation. His pupils flickered, and his mouth opened and closed several times.
"Stop running," Victoria commanded, like he was a lost puppy—and Regulus obeyed, as if under the Imperius Curse. "Stop resisting."
Reggie smiled—a smile full of pain and fury—biting his lower lip hard, as though it were the only thing keeping every emotion in his chest from erupting. He began to shake, as if from cold, or rage, or the sheer effort of resisting something so much stronger than himself.
"You haunt me, Victoria," he whispered through clenched teeth. "You haunt me every day with the kiss you never should’ve given me."
"Stop resisting!" she repeated, like she knew exactly what Regulus was doing. Like she could feel the emotions crawling beneath her palm on his chest. "You said you loved me!"
Regulus swallowed hard, as if her words had wounded him, as if love itself were dangerous. As if it could hurt him. As if it could abandon him—like all the others had. His father, his mother, Sirius. He didn’t want Victoria to join that list.
"I do love you!" he choked, the raw truth thick in his voice, his fingers twitching at the admission because he knew there was no turning back. He’d spoken his feelings aloud once more, and the weight of them hit like a punch to the gut, rising through his throat in a shiver, rooting into his heart, spreading through his bones, binding him to Victoria in a way no words could truly express. "I don’t want to hurt you. You... you’re everything I’ve ever wanted and—"
"Words are wind, Reg," she cut in, her warm breath caressing the fine down that circled Regulus’s lips. "If you love me, stay with me."
There was still a safe distance between their mouths, one Regulus longed to close after her declaration—but fear and turmoil held him back; what he felt for her wasn’t the problem.
His Patronus might well have been a lion. Sirius, Remus, Orfeu—they were all Gryffindors. But he was still a serpent, and no matter how wise snakes might be, they were also wary, cautious, reluctant to trust. Reg wouldn’t let himself be intoxicated by her words again. Victoria didn’t understand—she had the power to open his Pandora’s box, and he didn’t want to hurt her.
He wanted to be, and didn’t want to be, like Sirius and Scarlett.
"Every time we’re close... I feel like Icarus, flying too near the sun. About to fall." His fingers threaded through her hair, hand cupping the back of her neck, feeling her pulse racing beneath his touch, lips brushing against hers, letting temptation seep into his defences, toppling them like a house of cards.
Regulus let himself fall, nibbling on Victoria’s lower lip, tracing the soft skin coated in lipstick, the taste of cherry scrambling the torrent in his chest. Victoria’s hand slid from his collar up his neck, fisting in his hair and yanking him closer, as if they could get any closer at all.
Victoria scorched her fears away with that kiss, their tongues meeting in the clumsy, desperate way of those who had waited too long. Regulus sighed, a growl rumbling in his throat as he pressed his body to hers, surrendering to the overwhelming flood of having Victoria in his arms, losing himself in the heat of her lips like he’d always dreamed.
Reggie had never thought falling could feel this good—even if he feared what came after. The rationality that had always guided him was crushed beneath Victoria, whose hands roamed his body as if sculpting a statue in his likeness—exploring his back, gliding over his chest, gripping his arms.
Suddenly, it was far too hot in the bathroom of his dormitory. Regulus felt a bead of sweat slide down his spine as he realised how aroused he was—especially when Victoria let out a soft moan as he slid his hands to her waist.
He wanted to pull away, to find his senses again, to retrieve the reason that usually anchored him—but Victoria had stolen his breath, his thoughts, and every restraint. She was a hurricane, tearing him apart from the inside out, and when the kiss ended, there would be nothing left but wreckage.
Still, Regulus kept going, committing to memory the taste of Victoria’s lips as they parted with a sinful sound. He bit her delicate chin softly as he traced a path to her pale neck, kissing the tender skin until urgency took hold. He nuzzled her ear before closing his lips where her blood pulsed, the tang of alcohol and sweet perfume flooding his mouth as he marked her skin in a desperate frenzy.
Unlike their first kiss, marked by tenderness and soft affection, this one carried an overwhelming urgency that Reggie couldn’t begin to understand. Victoria Rookwood seized his chin with authority, pulling him to her. Her languid eyes pierced through him, dominating him without needing a single word. There was no spell that could free him from the enchantment that was Victoria Rookwood.
That was the Black men’s curse: to be broken and pieced back together by the women they loved.
"Stay with me," she asked, though there was a thread of warning in her voice.
"I will," Regulus agreed, too intoxicated to consider the consequences.
The bathroom door burst open, but Victoria didn’t even flinch. She was holding something far more important in her hand—the organ thudding against her palm, racing. The heart of Regulus Black.
"What the fuck, Reg?!" Victor looked horrified by the scene before him. "What are you... what are you two—"
"What’s the matter? Catch Reggie having a wank?" Terry, from outside, seemed amused by Victor’s reaction—until he saw them. "Victoria?!"
Regulus cleared his throat, completely dumbfounded.
"Er, we... I threw ink on her and—"
"We’re dating," Victoria cut in. Terry started laughing. Victor’s horrified expression only deepened.
"Aren’t you dating Diggory?!" he went on, looking thoroughly incredulous. "Bloody hell, Victoria, you can’t just go around acting like a—"
"Careful with your next words, Victor," Regulus warned, his tone dark. "Or I’ll knock your fucking teeth out."
"What the fuck’s going on in the loo? I need a shit!" Miles shouted from the bedroom, clearly irritated.
Regulus grabbed Victoria’s hand and glared daggers at Victor. Victor, for his part, turned his face and stepped aside, allowing them to pass while Terry watched them with admiration. Victoria, however, quickened her pace to get out of there, deeply embarrassed by everything she’d just done.
As they exited the bathroom, she came face to face with Miles sprawled on the bed and Pucey pulling off his shirt.
"What’s Rookwood..." Miles paused mid-sentence. "Holy shit, Reggie Black, you’re my fucking hero!"
"Shut the fuck up, Miles!" Victor snapped, arms crossed tight.
"I can’t believe you cheated on Diggory!" Pucey looked stunned.
She didn’t stay to hear more praise thrown Regulus’s way. With her heart pounding in her ears, Victoria rushed down the boys’ dormitory stairs and charged up to the girls’ side, locking herself in the bathroom with her breath coming in shallow gasps. She looked at herself in the mirror—lips swollen, cheeks flushed. Slowly, she turned her face to the side and brushed her fingers over the little heart Reggie had drawn on her left cheek.
.
.
.
Scarlett rested her chin in the palm of her hand, trailing her fingers through Sirius’s soft, black hair. She felt his gentle breath warming her chest, the scratch of his stubble against the fabric of her pyjamas. His long lashes twitched in time with the flickers beneath his eyelids.
She traced the tip of her finger along his aristocratic nose, utterly enamoured by her boyfriend’s beauty. It was as though his face had been sculpted by hand—from the contours of his nose to the sharpness of his jawline, the prominent cheekbones to the flawless, marble-like skin untouched by so much as a blemish.
Sirius Black was the epitome of pure-blood beauty. Hair as black as a midnight sky, skin as pale as the moon. Long fingers covered in rings that fit so perfectly between hers, as if they’d been made for it. The muscles in his back contracted and relaxed with every breath. Peace played across his features.
Scarlett loved him. She loved how safe he made her feel, how at ease he was being himself with her, how willing he was to be vulnerable in her presence. She loved his erratic charm, his tarnished defiance, his excessive shamelessness. It was hard not to love Sirius Black.
It was also hard not to hate him.
She hated his suffocating ego. Hated how he lashed out when he felt cornered. Hated how permissive she was with him, how quickly she forgave him. Most of all, she hated it when Sirius tried to carry the weight of the whole world just to protect her from her nightmares and demons. It made her feel weak and powerless—two adjectives on the long list of things Scarlett despised.
She’d felt that way enough during the fire, and even thinking about being overcome by those emotions made her hands start to sweat.
She didn’t know how long she stayed there, stroking Sirius’s hair as he slept. He needed rest—she knew he’d barely closed his eyes in the days she’d been confined to bed. So she’d made him take a sleeping draught and stayed with him, keeping him company and getting lost in her own thoughts about a future that made her stomach twist just imagining it.
There were only two weeks left until their final year at Hogwarts. Scarlett didn’t know how to feel about that. Of course she wanted to finish her studies, but at the same time, school no longer seemed to matter… not after what had happened.
A lot of things had lost their meaning after the fire, truth be told. Hogwarts was one of them. Scarlett couldn’t see the point of it while a war was raging, claiming lives every single day. She hadn’t read in detail about the murders—but she knew they were happening, especially under the rule of the Death Eaters. Her parents had been victims of them.
She had no proof, but she knew it. The certainty was carved into her very core: they had been murdered. The theory about Orfy was wrong. She’d seen her brother. Orfeu had called her in the midst of the flames, he...
Scarlett shook her head, chasing those thoughts away, narrowing her eyes at the strands of light piercing the room through the gaps in the curtains. She looked back at Sirius, still in the same position, his face nestled into her chest, the weight of his jaw pressing on her bruised ribs.
She gently nudged him aside, shifting his body off hers and releasing his hand from her fingers. It was no easy task, as Sirius seemed perfectly content wrapped in the warmth of their contact. It was summer, which meant the air conditioning was on, leaving the room with a pleasant chill.
Scarlett got up, pressed a kiss to his lips, and tucked him in. Sirius stirred, sinking deeper into the blanket with a sleepy groan. She crept out of the room on tiptoe, stretching as she entered the corridor. She shielded her eyes against the brightness.
It was the first time since everything that had happened that Scarlett hadn’t struggled to get out of bed. In fact, she couldn’t even remember feeling that barrier. All she wanted now was to make pancakes with strawberries for Sirius like his uncle used to at Christmas—he’d taken care of her enough.
Now it was her turn to do something special for him.
The pancake batter came together quickly, and thank Merlin there were strawberries in the fridge. Just as she finished rinsing them, a loud crackling from the sitting room drew her attention. Scarlett left the pan sizzling on the hob and turned to find James stepping out of the fireplace, covered in soot and with hair more chaotic than usual.
"Scar!" He beamed from ear to ear, pulling his dirty glasses off his face. "Sirius didn’t answer when I called him through the mirror—I got worried..."
"He’s fine. Just sleeping." Scarlett gave his cheek a playful pinch, swept up by his joy. "He hasn’t slept a wink these past few days... I made him take a sleeping draught and..."
"So you two are alright?!" James stepped in and gave her a lazy hug. Scarlett nodded, brushing the soot off his shoulders. "You made up?"
"We did." Scarlett exhaled deeply. "Speaking of which... he mentioned he talked to you... about St Mungo’s..."
"That’s why I came over—my mum said you can just walk in and wait to be seen, no need to book anything. I figured we could go today, I even called Lily—"
"You what?!" Scarlett arched a brow, lips stretching into a crooked smile. Before James could explain, her eyes widened as the scent of burnt food reached her nose. "Shit—the pancakes!"
The two of them rushed to the kitchen, where the frying pan had failed to flip the batter with the charm, and the smoke and burnt smell paralysed Scarlett on the spot. James acted quickly—he chucked the pancake into the sink and flung the windows open, oblivious to Scarlett’s reaction as she leaned against the kitchen wall for support, her legs trembling.
With a flourish of his wand, the smoke was cleared and the stench vanished. James gave her a forced smile, though his eyes watered. It had been traumatic for him too.
"You alright?" He touched her cheeks, those hazel eyes always so kind. Scarlett nodded, pushing away the shivers that the memories of that day sent crawling across her skin.
She washed the pan and took a deep breath, summoning the courage to try making pancakes again. She poured the batter into the pan and stood watching it firm up and take colour while James grabbed a mug and filled it with coffee.
Scarlett drifted into her own little introspective world as she finished Sirius’s pancakes, setting aside a few for James while she sliced strawberries and placed them around the stack the same way Sirius used to for her. She even risked eating one of the fruits, savouring the sweet and sour burst on her tongue.
"Something smells good..." came Sirius’s sing-song voice as he wandered into the kitchen like he’d just woken up—hair tousled, shirtless, rubbing the sleep from his eyes.
"Morning, Pads." James elbowed a sleepy and unsuspecting Sirius in the ribs.
"Morning, Prongs," Sirius muttered, clutching the sore spot with a grimace. "Should’ve slept longer, but you showed up through the Floo and woke me up." He flipped him the finger.
"What d’you mean, you were woken up?" James brushed off the gesture, sipping his coffee.
Sirius ignored him, wrapping his arms around Scarlett from behind. He was warm, his unruly hair tickling her neck as he leaned down and kissed her lips, nuzzling into the curve of her neck.
"Morning, kitten," he murmured into her hair. Scarlett couldn’t help but smile.
"Morning, love." Scarlett picked up the cutlery and offered the plate to Sirius. "I made pancakes with strawberries."
Sirius blinked a few times, still groggy, his pink lips stretching into a grin as his eyes lit up with genuine joy.
"Pancakes with strawberries! The best breakfast in the world!" he declared as if Scarlett didn’t already know that, planting a wet kiss on her cheek. "Are you eating with me?"
Scarlett, utterly ensnared by the phenomenon that was shirtless Sirius Black at nine in the morning, simply nodded. The tattoos on his fingers only made him more charming than he already was, and when he moved to the table and turned his back, giving her a view of the ink on his back, she found herself feeling as light as a feather. As if, just maybe, everything was alright.
"What did you put in this batter? It's really good," Sirius said, rolling his eyes towards James as he offered him a piece. "Go on, Prongs, have some."
"I already ate at home..." James declined with a shake of the head.
"Eat," Sirius insisted, fixing him with a pointed look.
Meanwhile, Scarlett had gone to fetch a mug for Sirius, stretching up towards the highest shelf. Unfortunately, she was far too short to reach it, and her wand was on the other counter, so she did the obvious—stood on tiptoe, one hand braced against the cupboard, trying to hook the handle of one of the mugs and failing miserably.
James reluctantly accepted the bite of pancake and immediately pulled a face, grabbing a napkin and spitting it out into it, quickly wrapping it up while glancing at Scar to make sure she was still busy.
"It’s awful!" he whispered behind a hand, scandalised. "Did she use salt instead of sugar?"
Sirius, beside him, struggled to hold back a laugh as he cut off a large piece of pancake and vanished it with an Evanesco, leaving only a quarter of the original left.
"Definitely..." He turned his attention back to his girlfriend, who was still valiantly trying to reach the mug.
"Why didn’t you vanish the whole thing?!" James asked, drinking his coffee to get rid of the salty taste.
"It’d be too obvious if I did!" Sirius shot back, like it was the most obvious thing in the world, and started eating the strawberries. "And she made the pancakes just for me… after everything that happened… seems only fair."
James shrugged and the two returned to observing Scarlett and her mug-fetching endeavour.
"Why doesn’t she use her wand?" He frowned, pouring himself more coffee.
"She always does this," Sirius said, clearly amused. "Takes her about two minutes to admit defeat and call me. Watch." He snatched James’s mug, blowing gently on the coffee while his mate sighed.
"Love..." Scarlett looked at them out of the corner of her eye, arm still stretched up holding the cupboard door. "Can you get the mug for me?"
"Of course." Sirius stood and winked at James, handing Scarlett the mug before returning to his seat at the table.
"I can’t believe you store the cups up high just so Scarlett has to ask you for help," James said, incredulous. "You’re the worst boyfriend in history."
Sirius wrinkled his nose with that insufferable smugness, pressing a kiss to Scarlett when she set the mug down on the table.
"It’s my love language," he admitted, stuffing the rest of the pancake into his mouth and chasing it with a massive gulp of coffee.
"I thought we were sharing the pancake!" Scarlett put her hands on her hips, fishing the last strawberry off Sirius’s plate.
"It was just so good... I couldn’t help myself," he lied with a charming smile. "James said he’s dying to have one..."
"Oh, if you want I can make one for you—"
"No, no need!" James said that far louder than intended. "I already ate at home and I’m on a diet... you know… I had a growth spurt this summer and if I don’t maintain my weight, I’ll lose my spot as Seeker on the team..."
Scarlett shrugged and poured herself some tea. Before she could sit down, Sirius whipped his head towards the sitting room so quickly his neck cracked just as the fireplace flared green with flames.
"Excuse me… ah… um… Scar?!" Lily’s voice made James sit up at once, ruffling his hair and checking his reflection in the side of his mug to see if anything was stuck in his teeth.
"In the kitchen!" Scarlett shouted back.
Lily greeted them with a shy smile, her red hair tied in a ponytail and wearing a brightly coloured floral dress. Her cheeks flushed crimson the moment she noticed Sirius shirtless, her gaze quickly shifting to James, who was staring at her like she was the most beautiful thing he’d ever seen.
"Prongs... you’ve got drool right there..." Sirius teased, earning himself an elbow to the ribs.
"I do not... ugh, shut up!" James shot him a glare before softening his expression. "Hi, Lily! You look gorgeous today!"
"James." She rolled her eyes before crossing the kitchen island to give Scarlett a hug. "How are you?"
"I’m alright," Scarlett replied with a faint smile, grabbing the milk from the fridge. "James told me he invited you—"
"You invited Lily—" James cut in, correcting her before she could finish the sentence.
"Did I?" Scarlett raised a brow. James squinted at her, adjusting his glasses. "Right. I did. I definitely invited you... to come with us to St Mungo’s about Sirius..." She cleared her throat when Lily gave her a puzzled look.
"What’s wrong with you?" the redhead asked, turning towards Sirius as she settled at the table.
"Ball ache," James answered for him, grinning wickedly. Scarlett stifled a laugh, while Sirius placed a hand on his hip and gave James a glare.
"Yeah, you know how it is... Scarlett’s very demanding..." Sirius rolled his eyes, thoroughly self-satisfied. "You’d understand if you ever had sex, but since you’re still a virgin—" He took a sip of his coffee and promptly choked as James smacked him on the back.
"I am not a virgin!" he squeaked. "I... I..."
"James... no one wants to know," Lily cut him off, her tone so sharp it left him speechless. He deflated into his chair and finished his coffee in silence.
"Do you want some pancakes?" Scarlett broke the awkward silence, turning to Lily, whose guilty glance didn’t leave James.
"Er, I ate at home..."
"They’re really good, Evans," Sirius said, licking his lips and hiding the teasing tone behind his words. "Really, really good."
"She said she already ate..." James tried to defend her.
"Then I’ll have one," Lily said with that signature smile only she could manage, her green eyes full of kindness and warmth that soothed any tension still hanging in the air. "Sorry, I didn’t mean to be rude to you."
James shook his head as he rested his elbows on the table.
"It’s fine, you were right. It’s not like anyone cares anyway," he muttered, glancing at the clock on the wall.
"Oh, stop that, Prongs," Sirius sighed, clearly annoyed. "We all care about you..."
"Forget it, Pads." James clicked his tongue and bumped his shoulder against Sirius’s.
Scarlett served Lily her pancake with strawberries, just as she’d done for Sirius. Since the batter was still piping hot, they waited for it to cool a bit until Lily cut off a piece, while Scarlett drank milk straight from the bottle.
As soon as Lily began to chew, her expression twisted into a grimace. Sirius burst out laughing and James quickly handed her a napkin. She spat the pancake into the paper and took a swig of Sirius’s coffee, shivering at the taste.
"You put salt instead of sugar!" Lily exclaimed with disgust before breaking into a grin.
"Did I?" Scarlett tore off a piece of the pancake and took a bite, reacting just like Lily. "Bloody hell, that’s awful..." She started to laugh. "And you ate the whole thing?!"
Sirius shrugged with a smug grin.
"Of course I did, I wasn’t going to be rude. Pancakes with strawberries is my favourite breakfast!" He said it with such conviction that Scarlett believed him instantly.
"He used Evanesco on half of it..." James ratted him out, earning a punch to the ribs from Sirius.
"Shut it, snitch!"
Lily laughed too, and all of a sudden, Scarlett felt like crying. She couldn’t remember the last time she’d had a conversation like that—one where she was actively involved and genuinely enjoying herself, without feeling distant or disconnected.
James’s gaze settled on Lily, whose cheeks were already rosy from her makeup but began to redden further. Her lips pressed into a thin line and her smile faded, though amusement still danced in the vivid green of her eyes. James looked away, gripping his empty mug a little too tightly.
"I think I’m going to be sick," Sirius muttered, watching the two of them before getting up to wrap his arms around Scarlett. "Have you seen the back room?"
"No. What’s in there?" Scarlett looked at him from the corner of her eye, letting his body heat radiate into hers, his tattooed fingers finding the curve of her waist with ease.
"We put everything they managed to salvage in there..." He trailed off halfway through the sentence, his lips tightening before he forced a half-smile.
Scarlett just nodded, and the two of them made their way into the corridor, stopping in front of the room where piles and piles of boxes were stacked. She had no idea when they’d been brought in. She ran her fingers across the old, wrinkled cardboard until her eyes landed on one labelled: Home.
She knelt in front of the box and opened it, finding a pair of medals her parents had received for their service at the Swiss Ministry and… her eyes were immediately drawn to the orb glowing in deep azure, ancestral magic ringing in her ears and sending chills up her spine. Her multi-portkey. She held it tightly, the copper-coloured metal now blackened, but it still looked functional.
"Your Hogwarts things survived… I think your dad must’ve taken your trunk to the garage beforehand… and, erm, your cloak’s here… your Christmas present too…" Sirius pulled the trunk out from where it had been hidden in the corner, opening it to show her the Invisibility Cloak and the box of jewellery he’d given her.
Scarlett licked her lips, clenching the orb tightly in one hand while holding the cloak in the other. She resisted the urge to cry. She didn’t want to feel sad anymore. Truthfully, Scarlett didn’t want to feel anything. Sirius needed her, so she folded up every feeling that threatened to rise and shoved them deep inside her chest, forcing a smile as she stood and hugged her cloak.
"There’s… there’s something else, too," Sirius stammered, retrieving two letters from a pile.
She had never opened the messages sent to her by friends about what had happened to her family. She hadn’t wanted to—because reading them would make everything too real, and reality was already cruel enough. She had to take things one day at a time, and she wasn’t ready yet. Sirius placed the pair of letters in her hand just as she set her Invisibility Cloak aside.
Scarlett grit her teeth when she read the names: Dimitri and his father, Nikolai.
"Gid said those letters turned up at your father’s office at the Ministry and asked me to pass them on to you," Sirius continued, his voice full of unease. "I told you I wouldn’t keep anything from you anymore… if you want… we can read them—"
"No." Scarlett squeezed the letters in her hand, shaking her head firmly, her heart lodged in her throat. "Not now. Not with you like this."
"You know… I’ll never let him hurt you again, don’t you?" Sirius threaded his fingers through her hair, gently forcing her to look at him. "Never."
"I know." Scarlett bathed in the sincerity of Sirius’s gaze, in the starlight silver that melted into platinum.
"We should get dressed…" he suggested, helping her to her feet.
"I’ll be right there." Scarlett gave a stiff smile, her eyes straying back to the orb.
"Alright." Sirius kissed the corner of her lips and left her alone.
Scarlett turned her head slowly toward the boxes, only now noticing the smell of mildew and dust. She flinched as she picked up the cloak from the floor and slung it over her shoulder, breathing in deeply, absorbing everything that remained.
She squeezed her eyes shut so tightly that stars burst beneath her eyelids—but she didn’t cry. She was tired of crying. She blinked a few times, her gaze landing on the two letters in her hands, her fingers pressing the parchment so hard her wrist trembled.
The time for mourning was over.
It was time to fight back.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 21: Sorry… for not killing you when I had the chance!
Chapter Text
LXXXIX
Every time Orion whipped him and Sirius had to crawl back to his room, bleeding and weak, he would stop in the corridor of his house and stare at the paintings hung along the wall. Each one belonged to a respectable Black — though there were so many that Sirius honestly couldn’t even remember their names. Then, he'd step into his room just as Kreacher appeared, grumbling that he was bleeding all over the pristine floors of Grimmauld Place. Sirius would lie down on the bed, letting the house-elf tend to his wounds.
Kreacher had never been kind to him. Whenever he cleaned the cuts, he would always take longer than necessary while Sirius writhed on the bed and swallowed back his cries. He wouldn’t show weakness in front of the elf, not under those conditions. Once he was properly patched up, Sirius would be left alone.
That was the worst part of all. He’d rather be in the presence of his father, hurting him, than be left alone. Being alone meant being stuck with his own company, listening to his own thoughts, facing his own presence.
Sirius had never liked being alone. Of course, once he was a teenager, he had his moments sneaking off for a cigarette here and there, but he was never truly alone. At Hogwarts, he always knew exactly where his mates were wandering about.
Alone meant unsafe. And Sirius hated feeling that way, teetering on edge, waiting to hear his mother’s heels clacking up the stairs or being woken in the dead of night to face his father in the study. It always came with the ominous sense that something awful was about to happen.
Every time he found himself alone, it ended in a lecture or a beating. Regulus rarely saw what went on, but whenever Sirius got thrashed, his younger brother always found a way to sneak into his room and stay with him. Even if he did absolutely nothing, just having him there, lying beside him on the bed, running fingers through his hair… just not being alone… it was enough.
Now, Sirius stared at the still-life landscape paintings on the walls of St Mungo’s. The fruit shifted subtly, pretending to be inanimate. He, on the other hand, was wrapped in a catatonic state as though he'd just been beaten by his father.
The wounds, however, weren’t physical. Though they stung as if they were. Sirius had never felt this before — an overwhelming fear of something that hadn’t even happened yet, but felt like it was just about to. His stomach burned just at the thought. He looked around for Scarlett, spotting her speaking with the receptionist, James at her side. Lily sat next to him, though he hadn’t paid her much attention.
The truth was, Sirius felt a little lost when he was away from Scarlett and James, even if it was only by a few metres. Their absence plunged him into a thick, suffocating loneliness he didn’t know how to navigate. It was as if that wrongness he kept sensing drew nearer, skulking at the edge of his mind, laughing at the base of his ear, rippling through the corridor shadows.
Sirius clenched his jaw, rubbing the scar on his forearm incessantly, his foot tapping against the floor as he kept his eyes locked on his girlfriend and best friend. A pale hand, nails perfectly painted orange, clasped his wrist, and Sirius flared his nostrils, glaring at Lily with hostility.
"You're going to end up hurting yourself." She said it so gently that Sirius wanted to rip that sweet little face in two.
"Don't touch me, Evans," he snapped, yanking his arm free.
"Sorry." Lily gave him an awkward smile, shrinking back slightly.
Sirius turned his gaze back to the pear in the painting, which rolled slightly from side to side, trying to balance itself in the basket.
"You're not here because of whatever James mentioned earlier." She murmured it. It wasn’t a question.
Sirius remained motionless.
"I'm sorry for what happened. This can’t be easy." Lily went on, also staring at the pear. "You’re not alone, Sirius."
He wanted to laugh. But his face stayed as impassive as his parents had always taught him to keep it. Emotions make you weak, they used to say. They forgot to tell him they also turned you into a ticking time bomb. He caught himself instinctively running a hand over the back of his trousers, where the scars were hidden, only stopping when he saw Scarlett and James returning.
Why the fuck had James brought Lily with them to the hospital? Especially for something that was clearly about him? Sirius sighed.
Sometimes he hated how bloody oblivious his best mate could be.
The restless anxiety bubbling inside him burst like a soap bubble the second Scarlett hugged him. Sirius buried his face in her chest, clinging to her like the ground beneath him was about to give way. As if something awful was bound to happen — he knew it — the certainty was carved into his bones, rattling his insides.
Sirius closed his eyes as Scarlett threaded her fingers through his black hair, her nails brushing his scalp, dissolving his thoughts one by one, blowing them out like a handful of candles. He breathed in her vanilla scent, drowning in the overwhelming sensation of being in the arms of the woman he loved — the woman who made him feel loved.
Sometimes it was hard to believe how much Scarlett loved him. Not even his own mother had managed to love him. And yet, Sirius was loved by Scarlett with such ease and readiness that it left him dazed. It made his fears melt away, his restlessness dissolve, his impatience fade. Scarlett had always had that narcotic effect on him, like her very presence could make everything else cease to matter. She smothered every single one of his demons and, most of all, she kept him company.
Maybe it was the fact that the two of them recognised the loneliness in each other. A certain kind of loneliness that clings to you even when you're surrounded by people, even when you're smiling and talking. Because it built transparent barriers around them, isolating them without them realising it; only noticing when the feelings they shared with others became discordant. When the happiness their friends felt couldn’t quite reach them with the same intensity, as though they were somehow undeserving of it.
Ah, that was the word! Sirius felt undeserving. Undeserving of Scarlett’s love, of James, Remus and Peter’s friendship, of the affection of everyone he cared for. He knew he would let them down in the end — that’s what Sirius always did. He was a spiral of disappointment and destruction. He had done it to Regulus and he would do it to everyone else, until eventually, he was alone again.
Sirius pulled Scarlett even closer, as if he could crawl inside her to shield himself from the world. To shield himself from himself. He knew her heart belonged to him, and if he could, he’d take refuge inside it, where it was warm and safe. Where her love bloomed in an eternal spring.
“Are you alright?” she asked, tucking his unruly strands of hair behind his ears.
He looked up, sinking into those ocean-blue eyes, bathing in the warm waters of Scarlett’s care, allowing himself to be vulnerable in that small space that felt so secure: the arms of the woman he loved. Sirius nuzzled into Scarlett’s chest, hoping that feeling would soak into him entirely, washing away every trace of agony.
Scarlett kissed his forehead, and the violent wave crashing in his chest broke into a gentle mist of water and clouds. Sirius exhaled a breath he hadn’t realised he was holding, letting Scarlett’s loving aura intoxicate him with an indescribable lightness, as though the blood in his veins had turned to morphine.
Scarlett’s love was like a drug, and Sirius let it sedate every worry until, one day, the overdose would come. But not now, not when he was so utterly focused on the rhythm of her heartbeat, the knots she was undoing in his hair, the soft kisses she pressed to his forehead.
The world could go up in flames, and Sirius wouldn’t so much as flinch.
His hands slid down Scarlett’s waist, pausing at the bulge in her pocket. He tugged out the object that had been pressing irritably into his ribs.
Sirius blinked, letting his vision absorb the multi-portkey in his palm. The metal was cold against his skin. There was undeniably magic there, even if he couldn’t see it. It was in the soft chime it made in the air around them, in the metallic tang that crept into his mouth.
“I’ll never feel bad as long as you’re hugging me like this,” Sirius admitted, a genuine, dimpled smile lighting up his face. Scarlett smiled back, and butterflies took flight in her stomach.
“The receptionist said the mediwitch will see you shortly,” she explained, cupping his face in both hands. Sirius turned his head to kiss them.
“I don’t think I need a consultation anymore. If I could just stay like this with you forever, that’d be enough…”
A soft laugh rumbled from Scarlett’s chest, making him chuckle too.
“I can’t stay hugging you forever. How would I make savoury pancakes like this?” she complained, scratching her freckled nose.
“Exactly! I’m sparing the world from your savoury pancakes…” Sirius rolled his eyes, though genuine amusement flickered across his face.
“Savoury pancakes are delicacies in Switzerland!” she said, placing a hand on her chest in mock offence.
“Not only can’t you cook pancakes, but you also can’t lie,” Sirius teased, burying his face in Scarlett’s belly, laughing at her adorable reaction—her cheeks flushed red, lips parted.
“Sirius!” she scolded, a few notes louder than usual.
He looked up at her.
“I love you,” he murmured, watching intently as the red in her face shifted from embarrassment to something more overwhelming.
“I love you too, you idiot,” she said, furrowing her brows before sealing their lips in a kiss that reinforced the silent promise of the fleeting eternity they so desperately sought.
“Sirius Black?!” a mediwitch called, prompting him to lift his head and look in the direction of the voice.
He hesitated, the warmth of Scarlett’s body slipping away as the embrace ended.
“That’s me,” he said, clearing his throat.
“You can come in.” The mediwitch gestured for him to follow her into the room.
Sirius and Scarlett exchanged a look, and she stepped back, urging him to get up with her eyes. It felt as though his knees had suddenly turned to stone. Then James gave him a pat on the shoulder, and he clung to the courage that so desperately wanted to escape, rising to his feet and ignoring Lily’s attention. He left the multi-portkey on the seat behind him.
“We’ll be right here when you’re done,” Scarlett tried to comfort him, and Sirius felt like a helpless little boy.
Of course she’d be there when he came out. Scarlett was always there for him, even when all Sirius ever did was hide his feelings. He felt like a fool for having kept them hidden for so long.
He gave a sheepish smile before stepping into the examination room. The door shut behind him, and Scarlett, James and Lily remained standing as if expecting him to walk right back out.
But he didn’t.
So Scarlett let all the air leave her lungs and leaned against the wall, slipping her multi-portkey into her bag as she rubbed at her eyes. Seeing Sirius like that unsettled her, because there wasn’t much she could do to help him. Even though she was exhausted, she was doing her best to be there with him.
Scarlett was the worst girlfriend in the world.
“Why don’t we go up to the fifth floor and have some tea?” Lily suggested.
“You two go ahead, I just need to use the loo…” Scarlett dropped her gaze to the floor, her hand fidgeting in her bag. “I’ll meet you there.”
She didn’t actually know where the bathroom was — she just needed a space to breathe, somewhere without people. Which was a bit stupid, really. Bathrooms were usually cramped and stifling… but Scarlett wasn’t thinking clearly at the moment. The guilt was eating her alive.
Sirius had to be strong for her all the time and she couldn’t even manage that much.
She didn’t hold back the tears before finding the loo, but as soon as she did, she walked in and shoved her face under the tap.
When you’ve spent too long crying, you start trying to avoid that burning sensation that comes with endless tears. Scarlett blew her nose and pulled herself together, staring into the cracked mirror. A jagged line split her reflection in two. The Scarlett who wanted to be strong — and the weak one she actually was.
She took a deep breath, pushing the thoughts aside. Dried her face and reached into her pocket for her wand — knocking loose one of the letters she’d tucked there. Scarlett crouched down automatically, her gaze falling on it.
The crumpled paper bore the perfectly aligned, ornate handwriting of Dimitri, with her name marked as the recipient. Scarlett straightened, and for a moment it was as though the letter itself was distorting, drawing away from her, growing smaller and more insignificant with each heartbeat.
“Go on,” Dimitri had shoved her forward. Scarlett stumbled ahead, the darkness of the corridor funnelling into shafts of light spilling from the room beyond. Trevors’ white teeth gleamed when he smiled upon seeing Marlene’s younger brother.
The paper felt cold against her fingers. Scarlett shuddered, her hands slick with sweat as she gripped her wand.
He’s just a child, Scarlett wanted to say. Just a child.
She squeezed her eyes shut, her fingers trembling around that cursed letter. The tears came again. She slid a finger along the rough paper, wedging a nail between the wax seal and the parchment. Her breath caught in her throat, and she tried to resist the urge to open it. She should do it with Sirius.
But Sirius was already hurting enough, and she didn’t want to make it worse.
So, in an unthinking motion, Scarlett opened the letter.
.
.
.
The tea room was large and far less crowded than the ground floor. James ran a hand through his hair, ruffling it before pulling out a chair for a rather awkward-looking Lily. He sat down across from her, watching the porcelain teapots float over to their table and pour them each a cup of black tea.
“Milk?” James straightened up, adopting a comically serious posture.
“No, thank you.” Lily dropped two sugar cubes into her tea and watched the steam rise in a slow, translucent dance.
James added milk to his own, his glasses fogging up as he took a sip. He took them off and wiped the lenses on the hem of his T-shirt.
“Wouldn’t it be easier to use a spell?” Lily took a sip of her tea, then added another sugar cube.
“I like… not using magic for this. It’s a habit.” James explained, placing the glasses back on his face and nudging them up his nose with his pinky.
“You’ve got this habit too… of pushing your glasses like that…” She mimicked him, and James let out a loud, unrestrained laugh.
“I… I… you know what I’m like… I mean, I like collecting little habits,” he said, as if it were one of his finest traits.
Lily just let out a soft snort of laughter, glancing at her tea as the lightness of the moment slowly shifted into something heavier. James still couldn’t believe he was there with Lily.
Of course, he’d never have imagined they’d end up having anything remotely like a date at St Mungo’s, but it was just the two of them at a tiny table that could barely fit the cups, so close that their knees brushed now and then. He could see every shade of green in her irises, the way she scrunched her nose every time the tea’s steam kissed it, the delicate freckles dusting the skin beneath her eyes. He could even pick out the auburn glints in her dark red hair.
James opened his mouth to speak, but no words came, so he closed it again, pouring himself more tea — and topping up Lily’s cup too. She simply nodded in thanks, but didn’t add any sugar or even touch the porcelain handle.
“Can I ask you something?” James finally broke the silence. Lily nodded, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear. “Why do you still talk to Sniv—” He cleared his throat, trying to keep his voice steady. “I mean, to Snape? After… after what happened… in fifth year…”
Lily pressed her lips together in distaste, her pale hands gripping the porcelain as she stared at her own reflection in the dark liquid.
“I don’t know, James. Trying to stop the inevitable, I suppose.” She let out a long breath. “Our friendship died that day, but… I still… how can he be so… so bloody stupid to hang around with Avery and Mulciber and… join You-Know-Who?!”
“You think he…”
“No.” She answered quickly, spinning the cup in her hands. “We were friends our whole lives and… suddenly, I just don’t recognise him anymore.”
“He’s a prick, Lily.”
“He wasn’t always like that.”
“He was from the moment he stepped onto the Hogwarts Express and—”
“You and Sirius never gave him a moment’s peace!” she snapped, raising her voice and slapping a hand down on the table. “You were always tormenting him!”
James fell silent before the argument could escalate further.
“Scarlett should be back by now, shouldn’t she?” Lily craned her neck, glancing around the room.
James shot to his feet, scanning the area as a new group stepped off the lift, but Scarlett wasn’t among them.
“Shit…” James muttered under his breath, striding quickly toward the exit. “Shit, shit, shit…”
.
.
.
Whiskers prowled through the shadowy alleyway, lined entirely with shops devoted to the Dark Arts, stopping in front of the display window of Borgin & Burkes, cluttered with shrunken heads and a magnificent opal cursed necklace. Her attention shifted to a doorway further back, where two wizards were negotiating in a distinctly suspicious manner.
A group of Aurors passed through the corridor, forcing the cat to duck behind a wall of old bricks. The men by the doorway quickly scattered, and Whiskers raised her eyes to a sign indicating that she was indeed in Knockturn Alley. Last summer, she had come to the alley to rescue Sirius from Dimitri’s clutches.
She’d never imagined she’d be back there because of him. Of her own free will. Her claws sprang from her paws just thinking about what she wanted to do to him, but she shoved the thoughts aside and turned her gaze back to Borgin & Burkes, circling the shop in search of the mentioned entrance.
She stopped the moment she spotted a statue of a wizard in a dead-end alley. There was no indication of who he was, but the cat promptly became a woman, and Scarlett pulled the letter from her pocket and unfolded it, reading the instructions.
… move your wand as indicated. The statue will shift, revealing a staircase. Descend and head left, where an arena will form before your very eyes.
Scarlett took the Invisibility Cloak from her bag and covered herself, doing as instructed. A staircase shrouded in gloom unfurled before her, and she took a deep breath, sweat dampening her palms. She clutched the fabric of the cloak tightly between her fingers, descending each step as she surrendered to the madness of what she was about to do.
She thought Dimitri might still affect her — that his biting words in the letter might sting. And they did, but not in the way she expected. She didn’t feel fear, nor disgust. No. It was as if a cluster of storm clouds were gathering in her chest, a thunderclap rumbling in the depths of her soul as her blood began to boil.
Dimitri had gone too far. He’d abused her, hurt Sirius, threatened Remus. Scarlett clenched her jaw, the storm within her swelling with devastating force. Someone had to pay for the death of her family — and Dimitri Rustov would be the first.
She licked her lips, her mouth watering at the mere thought of vengeance flooding her core and twisting grief into fury. Into rage. Into hatred. The very emotions she had always repressed, because she’d always had them in abundance. At Durmstrang, she’d constantly struggled to control her anger — and it was no coincidence she’d been one of the top students, channelling those searing emotions into every spell, every strike.
Anger wasn’t always a bad thing. Scarlett used it as fuel in that moment, even as reason tried to sabotage her dangerous plans. What she was doing was reckless — the sort of stupidity no true Slytherin would risk, so deeply did they value self-preservation.
But this wasn’t the Scarlett of Slytherin. This was the Scarlett of Gryffindor, as if all the time she’d spent with Sirius had encouraged her to be led by impulsiveness and blind courage. Not that it made much difference. She and Sirius were far too alike. The difference was that Scarlett could do what needed to be done.
She didn’t have much left to lose, anyway. Her family was dead. Sirius wasn’t doing well — and it was her fault. And she didn’t want to be the Scarlett who couldn’t get out of bed anymore, paralysed by fear of what had happened. She wanted her parents back just as fiercely as she wanted to hurt the one who did this to them. Who did this to Sirius. Who did this to her.
As she turned left, she realised the place truly was an arena. It was a vast underground chamber lit by torches in green, blue and orange, alternated along each column, the flames casting an eerie glow across the space. At the centre stood a battle cage where a crowd had gathered, the sound of cheering engulfing her the closer she came, her heart pounding in her chest.
Up above, in glowing letters, a sign read: PROODIE VS MCNAIR.
Most of the witches and wizards wore masks, placing bets with one another on who would win. Some smoked herb, others snorted fairy dust, and a few daring souls popped something beneath their tongues. Scarlett flinched when a bell rang, loud and piercing, ending the match between the two combatants. The names on the sign changed instantly, met with murmurs of approval and jeers alike.
Scarlett gasped, pressing herself against a wall as a large group of wizards passed her, all wearing masks she recognised all too well. She swallowed hard, eyes fixed on the blue flames dancing across the metallic surface of one of the Death Eaters who appeared to be patrolling the place.
A quiet voice at the back of her mind asked what the fuck she thought she was doing there, urging her to leave. Scarlett ignored it, blinking back the tears as a sudden wave of terror tried to take hold of her body. She banished it as quickly as it came, letting the venomous taste of vengeance be the only thing coursing through her veins.
She didn’t want to cry anymore. Didn’t want to suffer anymore. She wanted someone to pay — and that someone was Dimitri Rustov!
Scarlett drew breath with the same surge as her courage, pushing away from the wall as she followed a witch wearing a tall hat and velvet green robes, scanning the noisy crowd for any sign of Dimitri as the audience began to cheer for the next duelists. She shook off the tremble in her legs and advanced along the outer edge of the arena, where a few wizards sat on stools, smoking and drinking.
She swerved to one side to avoid colliding with two drunken men, reaching out to steady herself against the wall — but her hand slipped straight through, and she fell through the fitted stones, the sound of her impact completely drowned by the roar of the crowd echoing through the corridor.
A secret passage.
Scarlett glanced back at the arena. Then forward, into the passageway, where doors lined the walls until the light disappeared entirely into darkness, forming what looked like an endless tunnel.
She licked her lips, got up, and hurried on, not daring to open the closed doors but peeking into the rooms with doors ajar. Most of them held nothing remarkable — until Scar stopped dead in front of a massive board, covered in photos and criss-crossing strings in red, blue, and green. Her eyes widened as she spotted an image of her mother, alongside Fabian and Alice Longbottom, all connected to a man she didn’t recognise. Nyx’s photograph bore a large red X across her face and a bright circle drawn around that unknown man.
And it wasn’t just that. There were also photos of Dumbledore, Frank, Gideon, Dorcas Meadowes, Edgar Bones, and even Marlene McKinnon — all linked to a variety of wizards dressed in formal plum-coloured robes, bearing a symbol on their chests. Scarlett squinted, trying to make out the insignia, but straightened up quickly at the sound of a door slamming.
She snatched the circled photo and stuffed it into her bag, her eyes darting nervously to a few sheets of parchment scattered on the desk. Her fingers trembled when she saw they were all blank. She pulled out her wand and touched the tip to the parchment.
“Revelio,” she whispered — and tendrils of ink began to swirl and connect, slowly forming a message:
Scarlett Gaunt sticking her filthy little half-blood nose where it doesn’t belong.
Her eyebrows lifted at the insult, and she stuffed the parchments into her bag. It might be something important… though truthfully, she’d only grabbed the papers for the sheer pleasure of burning them later.
She peeked through the door — the crowd’s shouting had quieted somewhat, likely meaning they were already switching duelists. She slipped back into the corridor, intending to return to the arena — only to freeze when she saw two dark figures with metallic masks standing there. Scarlett darted into the first room she could find, careful not to touch a single thing.
It was quite similar to the previous room, but the board on the wall was clean — though a photograph stood on the sideboard in the corner, captioned: Howlers, Class of ’75.
Scarlett shivered from head to toe as she looked at herself and Dimitri standing in front of five other Durmstrang students, all seven of them wearing wolf pelts draped over their shoulders, eyes painted with dark pigment, arms crossed and noses turned up. She drew her wand at the sound of approaching footsteps.
Dimitri and Sasha entered the room, and Scarlett froze, her breath catching as her lungs locked tight. Her fingers twisted in the cloak as though she weren’t wearing it, the hand holding her wand starting to tremble.
“I don’t think Smedley’s going to last,” Sasha remarked in Russian, leaning against the sideboard. “You’re going to lose your money.”
“I’m not going to lose a fucking thing,” Dimitri shot back arrogantly. His blond hair was slicked back, and the vertical scar over his left eye was hidden behind a monocle. He was taller than her, though just a bit shorter than Sirius.
His coarse features grew darker as his expression stiffened. Then Dimitri looked straight at her, the edges of his face softening into a viperous smile.
“Welcome, Scarlett,” he murmured in heavily accented English, his voice laced with dark satisfaction.
Scarlett held her breath, instinctively backing away, glancing towards the exit and then back to him, her mind racing to make sense of what had just happened. Sasha laughed, folding her arms.
“I knew you were here,” Dimitri went on, smile widening. “The moment I felt someone breach the protections on the corridor…”
With every inch of her body taut, Scarlett revealed herself, stowing away the cloak without lowering her wand. She was ready for a fight, her gaze darting between Sasha and Dimitri.
“You… said you knew something,” she said, clearing her throat but keeping her voice steady. “What do you know?”
Dimitri stayed where he was, stroking the rough stubble on his chin without moving an inch. He didn’t seem to be in any rush to start a fight — unlike Scarlett, who was already growing impatient.
“I’ve waited a long time for this,” he said in a tone of triumph.
The moment Scarlett flicked her wrist to cast an offensive spell, Dimitri snapped his fingers — and in the blink of an eye, the world spun and ground to an abrupt halt. She had been Apparated directly into the battle cage, under the stunned gazes of the crowd surrounding the arena.
The sudden transition from the room to the roar of the audience left Scarlett disoriented. At the centre of the cage, the colourful torchlight flickered between her and Dimitri. As she lifted her eyes, the glowing sign above read: RUSTOV VS GAUNT.
Scarlett immediately shoved her hand into her bag, searching for her multi-portkey as Dimitri spun his wand between his fingers like a predator sizing up his prey. She blinked a few times, the crowd beginning to boo at the lack of action between them — and for a moment, the shock and fear were drowned out by the storm howling in her chest, banishing any hesitation in favour of a blinding certainty: Dimitri was going to pay.
“I’ve waited a long time for this too!” Scarlett shouted, gripping her wand tightly. “I’m going to kill you!”
Channelling her rage alongside the magic thrumming within her, Scarlett fired a Confringo powered by her ancestral magic. It slammed into Dimitri’s shield and detonated with a blast, sparks flying into the spectators who erupted with screams of excitement. Spells whizzed through the air like fireworks, multicoloured sparks sizzling across the ground, bursting on the ceiling, exploding between them.
Scarlett and Dimitri had been the top students of their year at Durmstrang. That wasn’t a coincidence — they’d trained hard to get there. Their friendship had been forged through rivalry, each striving for leadership of the Howlers, turning into a teenage romance until it was poisoned by betrayal.
No — what Dimitri felt had never truly been love. It was that same controlling, toxic possessiveness so common in pure-blood families.
Dimitri had broken Scarlett, and she would never recover. So it was only fair to break him too.
“Did you hear Orfy scream, sweetheart?” Dimitri bellowed at her. Above his grin, the look he shot her was pure mockery.
“Shut your mouth!” Scarlett hissed, like she was in her Animagus form — the hairs on her body bristling, sweat dripping down her face.
Dimitri deflected her spell with finesse, the red sparks rebounding off the bars of the cage. He counter-attacked with precision, but Scarlett poured more and more ancestral magic into her spells, making them harder to defend against. His shield cracked, then shattered beneath a barrage of lightning bolts erupting endlessly from her wand, forcing him backwards.
“Is it true he’s the one who burned your family?” he goaded, sending spells back at her — catching her slightly off-guard with his words and slipping a well-aimed Expulso through her defences, slamming her into the bars.
The air was knocked from her lungs, the crowd’s roaring disorienting her. It wasn’t like a Quidditch pitch where she could fly high enough to escape the noise — the cacophony here was so grating it made her ears ache. Her hands scrambled over the iron floor, searching for her wand, but a shadow fell over her and she gasped, feeling the icy tip of Dimitri’s wand press against her neck like the blade of a knife.
“Apologise!” he demanded, his voice a blend of irritation and satisfaction.
Scarlett hadn’t fully processed what had just happened, her entire body numbed by the adrenaline coursing through her veins, her pupils blown wide as she curled her nose in defiance.
“Sorry…” She only mouthed the word. “For not killing you when I had the chance!”
Dimitri frowned as though he hadn’t understood. Fuelled by blind boldness, Scarlett slammed her elbow into Dimitri’s nose, making him stagger back, eyes wide with surprise. Before he could raise his wand again, she disarmed him with a swift, precise kick, the crowd's roaring growing louder as the two fell into hand-to-hand combat.
It was obvious Dimitri would overpower her. Not only had she gone a year without training, she’d lost most of her muscle. The fight turned brutal — Scarlett defending against Dimitri’s blows with her elbows and legs, trying to strike back, but he was stronger and far more experienced.
Scarlett threw herself into Dimitri’s chest, staying close so he couldn’t get the full swing of his punches, waiting for him to try and lock his arms around her neck. As soon as he went in for a chokehold, Scarlett dropped low and bit into his arm, clawing at his throat with her nails like she was back in Whiskers’ skin.
He howled in pain, and the metallic taste flooded Scarlett’s mouth, awakening something feral deep inside her. She tore a chunk from Dimitri’s forearm, spitting it to the floor as he writhed in agony. Scarlett broke away, the arena’s lights blinding her, the crowd’s screams swallowing her whole and making the world quake around her.
She could hardly believe what she’d done as she wiped blood from her lips, her hands trembling in shock. Her gaze swept the floor, searching for her wand, thoughts racing. There was a war raging inside her — part of her wanted to finish it, the other was terrified of what this path was turning her into.
She crouched to retrieve her wand, but something grabbed her ankle and yanked her back hard, slamming her against the metal floor. Scarlett sprang up, but it was too late: Dimitri had seized her wand. Even with blood gushing from his arm, he rose with a triumphant expression, his smile savage and his eyes glinting with cruel delight. Without hesitation, he pointed the wand at her as she fumbled frantically in her bag for the multi-portkey.
“Crucio!”
It was the first time she had ever been struck by that curse. The crowd’s screams grew distant as the red bolt hit her ribs, licking her skin like lava, forcing her into a writhing heap on the floor as she tried, uselessly, to escape the torment the curse inflicted.
It felt as if her bones were being snapped slowly, one by one, her muscles shredded by a dull blade, and her heart was about to explode. Scarlett could barely breathe, soaked in sweat, her own agonised cries lost in the deafening roars that echoed across the arena.
“Rustov! Rustov! Rustov!” — the macabre chant, dripping with morbid fascination, seemed to swell Dimitri’s ego even more, bathing in the crowd’s adoration, his wand steady as he prolonged the curse on Scarlett. He wasn’t the only one in that place seeking revenge.
Scarlett didn’t know how long it took before Dimitri finally ended the curse. All she knew was that once he did, she remained collapsed on the floor of the cage, gasping, her face slick with tears and sweat. Breathing was torment; the pain throbbed in her bones and echoed through every part of her body.
Wearing a distorted smile of satisfaction, Dimitri grabbed her by the collar and hauled her closer. Their faces were so near she could feel his breath against the dampness of her cheeks, wrapped in the perverse aura he radiated.
“Nothing in the world…” he whispered, his voice thick with sadism, “…will ever give me the same satisfaction as watching you suffer like this.”
Scarlett blinked several times, trying to focus on his face, but she couldn’t. She didn’t know whether it was from the tears, the exhaustion, or the sharp throbbing pain slicing through her skull. The crowd was howling for Dimitri to finish her off. Scarlett sank into the darkness of her ex-boyfriend’s pupils, into the chaos that surrounded him — and into the flickers of gold that hinted at the wolf inside him.
“Kill her, kill her, kill her, kill her!” the voices roared in unison.
Dimitri pressed the tip of the wand against Scarlett’s throat, hesitating. A glimpse of a long-distant day flickered across his vision, lightening the darkness in the blue of his eyes.
[Music: The Beatles — While My Guitar Gently Weeps]
"Did it work?" Dimitri asked, furrowing his brows.
Scarlett looked at him sideways before pressing play on the tape deck, the Beatles’ song softly surrounding them until Dimitri turned up the volume.
"Skip it, this one’s too slow!" Scarlett reached out to fast-forward the tape, but Dimitri caught her wrist.
"No. This one’s good." He gave a shy smile when he noticed she didn’t flinch at his touch.
"You like this? It’s like… the second to last track on the tape. I never really get to it." Scarlett shrugged, hopping up to sit on the desk.
I look at you all, see the love there that's sleeping
While my guitar gently weeps
I look at the floor and I see it needs sweeping
Still my guitar gently weeps
Dimitri pressed his lips together.
"I like anything the Beatles put out," he admitted.
"I thought you didn’t, ‘cause they’re British… and because of your family."
"They don’t need to know everything I do." Dimitri leaned against the desk beside Scarlett, the two of them watching their reflections in the enormous mirror hanging in front of them, its golden frame carved with angels.
"Keeping secrets from mummy and daddy, Rustov?!" Scarlett flashed a sharp grin. "Didn’t think you were the type."
I don't know why nobody told you
How to unfold your love
I don't know how someone controlled you
They bought and sold you
"I’m not that thirteen-year-old boy anymore…" he huffed. "Besides, it’s a bit tiring always having to compete with you."
Scarlett tilted her head in that way he hated — her overwhelming ego flashing its claws as she gave him a smile full of perfect teeth that sent a shiver through his whole body.
"What’s it like knowing you’ll always come in second?" she asked with a sneer, her hand brushing against his as if by accident — but she didn’t pull away.
He hated that girl’s boldness, even as he revelled in it.
"What’s it—"
He didn’t get the chance to finish his retort. Scarlett yanked him violently towards her, sealing his lips in a quick kiss that made his whole body freeze. As if she’d just hit him with a spell. There was no enchantment, though — it was the way his heart began to hammer madly at the contact, his hands trembled, and he took a step back, eyes wide as saucers.
I look at the world and I notice it's turning
While my guitar gently weeps
With every mistake, we must surely be learning
Still my guitar gently weeps
It was on that day that Dimitri Rustov fell in love with Scarlett Gaunt. Far too stunned to say a word, he simply watched as she stepped down from the desk and left him behind, a sated smile on her lips.
Scarlett took refuge in the darkness behind her own eyelids as Dimitri licked the blood trickling from her split lower lip and kissed her in the centre of the arena — the violent storm inside her tearing her apart, begging to be released, pleading to reduce that man to ash. She gripped the front of his shirt, trying to push away, but he held her so tightly it was impossible to break free, denying her any escape as his tongue sought hers and her hand searched blindly along the floor.
“Come on.” Dimitri let out a bored sigh, dragging her along with him down an empty corridor. “I promised you compensation, didn’t I?”
Scarlett felt bile rise in her throat as she twisted in his grasp, the memory stealing her self-control, making her tremble with revulsion. She bit down on his lower lip — just as she had before.
Dimitri’s eyes snapped open and he jerked his face away, the taste of blood once more filling her mouth — snapping her out of her stupor.
That was all she needed to reclaim her wand, the magic coursing through her like a hurricane, the blue of her eyes glowing in resonance with her ancestral magic.
“Crucio!” Scarlett hissed, and the red lightning laced with blue struck him full-force.
I don't know how you were diverted
You were perverted too
I don't know how you were inverted
No one alerted you
It was as though, suddenly, the roars of the crowd didn’t exist anymore — because all Scarlett could hear, see, and feel was Dimitri writhing on the floor, his screams of agony fuelling the euphoria building inside her, curling her lips into a smile and glazing her eyes with intoxication. It was as if he were being scalded alive, twisting and jerking across the ground, begging her to stop.
Scarlett didn’t stop. She held the curse, tilting her chin up.
“Gaunt! Gaunt! Gaunt! Gaunt!” — the spectators bellowed, invoking a kind of frenzy she had never experienced before.
It was the delight of hurting the man who had caused her so much pain and fear. The man who always made her feel dirty, who shackled her with trauma. With abuse. Who made her feel ashamed, the reason behind her parents’ screams. Who had stolen her self-esteem and her confidence. Who had made her feel small and powerless. Useless — and so, so, so weak and afraid.
I look at you all, see the love there that's sleeping
While my guitar gently weeps
I look, look at you all
Still my guitar gently weeps
Not anymore. Never again. Scarlett clenched her jaw, ending the curse with a flourish, her heart leaping into her throat. She took a deep breath. This was it. She was going to kill Dimitri Rustov in front of all those people. She raised her wand at him, recalling the moment she’d learned the three Unforgivable Curses.
“You have to mean it,” her cousin Terry’s voice echoed in her mind. “You have to want to control, want to torture… want to kill. If you don’t, it won’t work. Words without intent are just wind. They’re called unforgivable for a reason.”
Scarlett spat in Dimitri’s face as the crowd erupted around her.
“You lost, Dimitri!” Her voice dripped with contempt. “Like the jealous piece of shit you’ve always been. You’ll always be beneath me!” She raised her wand at him once more.
Avada Kedavra.
Two little words were all it would take to erase Dimitri Rustov from existence. The crowd, witnessing Scarlett’s hesitation, burst into a cacophony of cheers and boos, resuming the chant they’d shouted when she was the one lying on the floor.
“Kill him, kill him, kill him, kill him, kill him!”
“Avada…” Scarlett felt her hand falter at the first word. “Avada…”
She closed her eyes and shook her head. As exultant as it was to see Dimitri like that — broken, defeated — a sliver of conscience still echoed in her mind. What was she doing? She was about to kill him in front of hundreds of witnesses. And the Death Eaters knew she was there. It was only a matter of time before she’d be pulled from the cage and forced to face them.
“You owe me a life debt!” Scarlett shouted, jabbing a finger in his face before reaching into her bag, swallowed by the crowd’s boos. She grabbed her multi-portkey and activated it. As everything began to spin, something latched onto her foot.
In a vortex of light and distorted sound, Scarlett landed amidst the ashes of a ruined house, dragging Dimitri with her. This wasn’t where she had planned to arrive. The smell of burning still clung to the air. Disoriented, she staggered backwards, choking on the sudden lack of breath. She reached into her bag to grab the Portkey again, but before she could activate it, Dimitri threw his body into hers like a charging bull, knocking her to the ground.
Scarlett hit the floor hard, coughing and gasping for air. Dimitri swung a punch at her face, but his arms were still weakened from the Cruciatus Curse, and the blow missed by inches. That was all she needed — with sharp reflexes, Scarlett countered, landing a strike right to his throat. Dimitri clutched at his neck, his red face darkening to purple.
Only now did Scarlett realise how sore and exhausted she truly was from the Unforgivable she’d taken. But that didn’t stop her. She twisted her body and got to her feet, shoving Dimitri and knocking him flat to the ground, letting the fury command her limbs. He was going to regret ever laying a hand on her.
Scarlett clenched both fists and let her body move on instinct, slamming her knuckles into Dimitri’s face with all the strength her trembling arms could muster, a scream escaping her throat in the release — a cathartic purge of everything she’d bottled up inside: all the pain, the rage, the sorrow, the shame, the fury.
“Imperio!” Dimitri’s voice slipped into her ears like a siren’s song. “Come back.”
“I think I like you,” he had once admitted, beneath the shadow of the pine tree.
“I like you the way I like the Beatles,” Dimitri had shrugged, lips curled in a shy smile.
“I don’t know how someone controlled you…” he had hummed, stroking her hair. “They bought and sold you…” He had leaned in to kiss her.
Scarlett felt the bones in her hands cracking with the repeated blows, but she didn’t stop. In that moment, she was nothing more than a vengeful spirit, pouring all her agony into her tormentor — trying to inflict on him the same anguish he had carved into her, trying to tear a piece of his soul just as he had torn hers, trying to break him with the same intensity.
It was impossible and Scarlett knew it. But she was fire — and that meant she would consume him, burn him down until there was nothing left but ash, even if it meant extinguishing herself in the process. That didn’t matter. The only thing that mattered was the way Dimitri moved less and less with each hit, how his face had become unrecognisable, how his hands fumbled across the floor in search of anything that might save him.
Scarlett was already gasping for breath, more exhausted than she had been after taking the Cruciatus. Maybe that was why she didn’t see it coming — Dimitri grabbing a splintered plank from the floor and striking her squarely on the head. Her body rolled across the crumbling ground, fingers scraping through debris, her pale face now streaked with red. Dimitri spat out a few teeth, then yanked her close by the collar of her shirt, tightening his hands around her throat.
Scarlett laughed at the sight of him: his dark blue eyes bloodshot, his face swollen and purple, mouth gushing blood. Even though it was hard to focus — the blow to the head had been brutal, and she’d fought him after taking a Cruciatus — she could tell Dimitri was far worse off than she was. And she had to admire his sheer stubbornness. She hadn’t expected him to get back up.
Not that it really mattered anymore. Her awareness drifted away in warm, fizzing waves, rocking her into a deep, dreamless sleep — though she could’ve sworn she heard Sirius’s voice.
Sirius.
The thought of him sent a sharp pang through her chest, and yet it warmed her too.
If she wasn’t already dead, Sirius would probably kill her.
She would’ve laughed again — if she hadn’t passed out.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 22: Hello, Reggie
Chapter Text
XC
"I can't sleep. I can't… relax. I keep thinking I'm going to wake up in that hell again… that I'll hear Scarlett screaming again… that… that she'll blame me again." He stammered, drawing back. "At the same time… all I want is to go back to that scene and save Orfy."
Sirius covered his face with his hands, resting his elbows on his knees as he closed his eyes and let out a hiss of breath.
"Do you feel guilty?" The woman was staring at him intently.
"She wanted to go back into the fire. I didn’t let her, but… I… it should have been me going back to look for her brother and—"
"Suppose you had managed to go back into the burning house," the mediwitch said, twirling her quill between her fingers. "What would have happened?"
Sirius clenched his jaw, leaning back on the sofa, glancing towards the door as a pang of uncertainty struck him. He slid his hand into his pocket and held onto his watch, feeling the vibration of the hand ticking against his palm.
"I would have saved Orfy."
"Or you would have died, and now your girlfriend would be alone." A pained smile passed over the witch’s full lips. "You can’t… fix things, Sirius."
"I wish I could," he admitted, softly. "She… I don’t think I… I can’t fill… I can’t make her feel happy… the way she was before everything."
"Do you feel frustrated?"
Sirius nodded.
"I…" He swallowed hard, glancing once more at the door. He hated feeling this vulnerable, especially without Scarlett nearby. It was disorienting. "I don’t feel like I’m enough to… make up for how much she misses her family."
The woman didn’t move, watching him as if trying to peer into his mind. Sirius looked away.
"You’re never going to be able to do that, Sirius. You’re not Scarlett’s father, or her mother, or her brother. You’re her boyfriend, and that’s your place. Don’t try to fill a role that doesn’t belong to you."
"What should I do, then? I’m afraid… I’m afraid to leave her alone and then things…"
"No, you’re not afraid of leaving her alone. You’re the one who’s afraid of being alone, clinging to her in every way you can, terrified she’ll leave you. You walked in here and all you talked about was your girlfriend, what she’s been through, while completely ignoring your own feelings."
Sirius blinked a few times, trying to process what that presumptuous woman had just said.
"I don’t… my feelings don’t matter. All that matters is her."
"I understand what you’re doing for her, Sirius, and you’re both going through a hard time. But the more you repress, the more you bottle up… the more it snowballs and comes out in other ways. You said sometimes you go back to the day of the fire. What’s that like?"
Sirius rubbed his sweaty hands together, then scratched the tip of his nose, trying to steady the emotions threatening to drown him.
"If I hear a scream or… smoke… if it gets too hot… it’s like… it’s like I relive what happened. And I panic," he muttered, uncomfortable. "Fire… flashes… sometimes I’m asleep and… I wake up thinking…"
The words died in his throat. Sirius had never felt so weak—not when all he wanted was to be strong. He cracked his neck in an attempt to relax his tense shoulders, running a hand through his hair as the woman shook her head and jotted something down on her parchment.
"Is that why you can’t sleep? Do you have nightmares too?"
"I can’t sleep because I feel like if I do… it’ll all happen again and… I… I put up protective spells all around the house and our fireplace is untraceable. But… any fluctuation in the wards… a Muggle getting too close or… even an animal passing by… I feel it. And I can’t relax… when someone comes through the Floo, I sense it because I’m linked to the protection spells and I have to know who’s arrived. Is it my best friend or… someone coming to kill my girl?!" he gasped by the end, breathless, his whole body rigid. "I can’t… I just can’t… I have to protect her, do you understand?"
"Sirius… it’s normal for you to feel this way. What’s not normal is for you to still feel unsafe in your own home, unable to rest. When you do sleep, do you take potions?"
"The last time I slept—which was last night—I took a Dreamless Sleep Potion. It’s not that… I don’t feel safe, I just… I don’t want it to happen again."
"Your friends… the ones you mentioned… can they sleep over at your house?"
"If I ask… I don’t see why not."
"You’re going to sleep three times a week with the aid of the Dreamless Sleep Potion, and on those nights, you’ll ask one of them to stay at your house too. Do you think they’d be willing to do that?"
"I think… I think they would." Sirius nodded, albeit reluctantly.
"So, shall I see you next week? Our time’s up." She rolled up the prescription for Sirius, who pulled the watch Scarlett had given him from his pocket to check the time. The hands, however, were making a strange countdown — twenty minutes and ticking down.
Sirius tapped the watch against his palm to see if it would return to normal time, but it kept counting backwards. He gave an awkward smile to the mediwitch and took the prescription, letting out a deep breath as he stepped out of the office.
"Can I book you in for the same day next week?" the mediwitch asked, arms folded.
"Yeah, sure… uh…" Sirius realised he didn’t know her name. "Sorry, but…"
"Asca Dimitrescu." She smiled. "You can call me Asca."
Sirius simply nodded, drifting down the corridor in a stupor, only to find James looking rather anxious at the end of it, glancing desperately at Lily.
"She’s not in any of the bathrooms," Lily said, her nose wrinkling, expression shifting the moment she spotted Sirius.
"What is it?" he asked, heart kicking into a gallop as he looked at James.
"Pads…" his friend drew in a breath, gripping him by the shoulders. "Scar’s gone."
.
.
.
Regulus had thought the restlessness in his chest would finally ease once he made his relationship with Victoria official. Despite Cedric Diggory's funereal silence and the sharp remarks from both his housemates and the Hufflepuffs, no one seemed particularly surprised that they were together. He’d also gone out of his way to avoid Victoria’s older brother and twin. He didn’t want to hear whatever they had to say about the relationship. He wasn’t expecting any sort of approval from them anyway.
The agitation, however, only grew worse. After Sirius’s latest attempt to break in, school security had become even more aggressive. The professors no longer tolerated any attempt to leave the castle, and any loophole or opportunity was shut down by them, Filch, or the prefects. And although Regulus was a prefect, he was certain Aphelandra Pyke had her eyes on him at all times.
Victoria, however, was always by his side, which sometimes made Aphelandra drop her guard, giving him the chance to try planning an escape. He needed to speak to Sirius now that he knew his godfather was in Hogsmeade — and more than that, he had to understand why he was supposedly trying to kill Harry Potter.
Of course he didn’t want to kill Harry… or did he?
Regulus massaged his temples. It was still hard to accept that his godfather really was the murderer everyone claimed he was.
"What’s got your head pounding like that?" Luana asked, spreading jam over her toast.
"Nothing," Regulus lied, sipping his pumpkin juice.
"It’s about your uncle, isn’t it? Mimi told me." She bit into her toast, licking the filling from her lips. "You’ve got massive bags under your eyes, Reggie."
"No, I just…" He sighed. "I need to go to Hogsmeade. Without anyone knowing. And when I say anyone, that includes Victoria." He clapped a hand over his mouth and glanced across the Great Hall to make sure Mimi hadn’t arrived yet.
"Why?" Luana frowned.
"I need to… buy… some things." Regulus cleared his throat.
"What do you need? I can go and get it for you." Luana shrugged, unconcerned by his request.
"So you know how to sneak out of the castle? Not through the statue passageway that Filch keeps watch over?"
Luana narrowed her eyes suspiciously at the question.
"You’re not trying to sneak out to talk to your mad uncle, are you?" She dabbed her lips with a napkin. "Besides, if Black doesn’t catch Potter by spring, we’re losing the bet, and I can’t risk losing more money now that the Weasleys are acting like they’re not going to pay up!"
"I can’t believe you’re still taking that bet seriously!" Regulus tried to steer the conversation elsewhere.
"Money’s money, Reggie. I wasn’t born into a pure-blooded golden cradle like some people…" Luana fanned her face with a casual flick of her hand. "I’ve got to work for my coin."
"You smuggle illegal goods into Hogwarts and sell them. I’m not entirely sure that qualifies as work." Regulus set his goblet down with more force than was strictly necessary.
"Oh, now you’re going to throw it in my face that I sold an expired Filibuster to those Ravenclaw brats and one of them nearly went blind?! Not my fault if they don’t know how to read a bloody label!" she shot back, flinging herself against the backrest of her chair.
"Good morning!" Victoria beamed with that radiant smile that made Regulus’s whole world tilt. He smiled back, sliding an arm around her shoulders and deliberately ignoring the sharp glares from his fellow Slytherins.
"Morning, Mimi!" Luana greeted her with a wave.
Regulus, on the other hand, took the liberty of kissing her cheek, feeling her skin grow warm as colour flushed her face.
"Good morning, Mims," Reggie whispered in her ear, amused by the flustered look that clouded her features.
"Morning, Reg." Mimi lowered her face, then looked up at him with those eyes that made his heart pound faster.
Victor sat down across from Regulus and beside Luana, shooting them both a disdainful look.
"So… it’s true then. You two are really together." He toyed with the silver cutlery, not once breaking eye contact. "I mean, until she—" He stopped halfway through the sentence, wetting his lower lip as he noticed Regulus clenching his fists.
"Finish that sentence, Victor, and I’ll break your fucking jaw." Regulus hissed, straightening up as his whole body tensed like a coiled spring.
"Alright, relax, I was only joking…" Victor smiled, his tone saying otherwise. "Who’d have thought? Reggie Black baring his claws…"
"Yeah, you haven’t seen anything. There was this one time he got into a proper scrap with some lads who were chatting me up at the skate ramp…" Luana tried to ease the tension, but fell silent as Vin appeared behind her and Victor. He clapped slowly, eyes fixed on his younger sister with poisonous intent.
"Congratulations, Victoria. Dad’s absolutely thrilled to know his precious only daughter changes boyfriends as often as she changes her knickers." There was a dark glint dancing in his deep brown eyes, a crooked smile tainting his lips.
Regulus heard Victoria let out a snort of disdain.
"Oh, is he also thrilled to know his precious middle son lost his Ministry job for being an incompetent twat?" she shot back, with a fire Regulus hadn’t seen in her for ages.
"I lost my job because you’re a filthy slag!" Vin roared, slamming his hand down on the table with such force the cutlery clattered.
What happened next was very, very quick.
Victoria leapt onto the table in one sudden motion and landed a resounding slap across her brother’s face, the blow snapping his head to the side, his eyes bulging in stunned disbelief. He grabbed her chin with one hand, the other pulled back to punch her—only to be intercepted by Regulus, who stepped between them and smashed an elbow straight into Vin’s nose, sending him stumbling backwards.
That was all it took for students from the surrounding tables to leap to their feet in a classic Hogwarts fight chant. Regulus yanked Victoria behind him and charged at Vin, skating across the surface of the table, kicking plates and cutlery aside, before landing on the other end and seizing him by the collar.
Vin might have been Reg’s height, but he was a coward, too stunned by Victoria’s retaliation to react in time. He took a punch to the jaw and crashed to the floor.
Regulus didn’t stop. He didn’t know why—he just knew he couldn’t. Everything he’d bottled up over the past days spiralled out of his chest and snapped the last strings tethering his self-control. Reason dissolved from his mind, replaced by the raw burn of rage and anguish—each punch dulling the torment inside him, each throb of his fists a release, allowing every conflicting feeling to erupt in a storm of fury.
Vin tried to shield himself, curling up as the runaway train named Regulus Black pummelled him again and again, caught in a frenzy, a guttural growl ripping from his throat until he felt the blood from that pathetic, spineless bastard stain his knuckles. The crowd around them swelled, the cheers of a fight turning into gasps of alarm, Victoria’s voice behind him begging him to stop—until Terry and Miles grabbed him, wrestling him off Vin.
Regulus didn’t even realise he was panting, or sweating. All he could see was Vin Rookwood’s bloodied face, white hair flecked with red, and the scorn that once twisted his expression now replaced by sheer fear.
"Touch her again and you’re dead, Rookwood!" he threatened, finger trembling as he pointed at him. "Next time I won’t stop!"
"Mr Black, what is the meaning of this?!" Professor McGonagall’s voice cut through the chaos as she pushed her way through the throng of students.
Regulus didn’t have time to answer.
"We were just talking and then Vin lunged at Victoria and—" Lua began to explain.
"Shut your filthy foreign mouth!" Vin bellowed, wiping blood from his face with the sleeve of his jumper. "That… lunatic… he just came at me—he’s mental, just like his uncle—"
Regulus surged forward again, but Miles and Terry held him back, gripping his arms and shoulders tightly.
"He’s lying, Professor, he nearly hit me and—" Victoria tried to continue.
"Enough, I won’t hear another word!" the Deputy Headmistress snapped, her chin lifted as she glared at them over the top of her square spectacles. "Honestly! That’ll be fifty points from Slytherin and detention for you, Mr Black. Rookwood, off to the Hospital Wing, you’re bleeding all over the floor. Teixeira, I sincerely hope that’s not a Dungbomb in your pocket. And I will be speaking to Professor Snape about this!" She pointed sternly at Reggie and Mimi. "Two Slytherin prefects involved in this… This is not how we conduct ourselves at Hogwarts!"
Vin stood, brushing off Victor’s help as he stormed out of the Great Hall, weaving between the other students.
"I’m sorry, Professor, but—" Victoria tried to justify Regulus’s actions, but McGonagall silenced her with a firm wave.
"No more, Miss Rookwood! You two should be setting an example for your House!"
"It’s fine," Regulus muttered, distant. He shot a warning look at Terry and Miles as he shrugged out of their grip. "You’re right, Professor." He pulled the prefect badge from his shirt and placed it on the table.
"What are you doing?!" Victoria grabbed the badge, trying to hand it back.
"Oh, right, let’s pretend no one here thinks I’m trying to help my uncle, shall we?!" He gave a bitter smile, eyes resting on the Professor as she frowned deeply. "To be honest, I’ve no idea why Professor Snape gave me that badge in the first place when no one bloody trusts me."
"Mr Black, don’t try to change the subject!" Minerva snapped, fixing him with a stern glare. "Your uncle has nothing to do with this."
"On the contrary, Professor." He scoffed. "My uncle has everything to do with this." He spun on his heel and strode out of the Hall, fists throbbing with pain.
Regulus left the castle feeling like he couldn’t breathe. The looks he was getting felt like they were scorching into his back, and his hands were trembling violently, his heart pounding in his ears, sweat making his clothes cling to his skin. He didn’t know exactly what he was doing—just that he ended up crouching in front of the garden fountain and plunging his hands into it, trying to soothe the pounding ache in his bones.
He exhaled hard, only just now remembering to breathe. He tried to go through one of the breathing exercises Uncle Remus had taught him, but he couldn’t manage to breathe out slowly—he was too agitated for that. He wiped the sweat from his face on his shoulder, lips twitching at the dull relief the cold water brought to his aching knuckles.
"You do realise that fountain is filthy and you’re going to get an infection sticking your hands in it, right?" a girl with hair as red as the scarlet of her Gryffindor uniform smiled, brown eyes sparkling with the light reflecting off the water.
Regulus squinted at her, pulling a face.
"I didn’t really think it through when I… er, stuck my hands in," he admitted, pulling them out and grimacing.
"Why don’t you go see Madam Pomfrey?" she said, rolling up the parchment that had been on her lap and shading her face with her hand against the sunlight.
Regulus just shrugged, sitting on the edge of the fountain as he noticed bruises beginning to blossom across his pale skin.
"Fred said you’re a few screws short," the girl chuckled, tossing her things into a bag between her knees.
"Fred?" Regulus raised an eyebrow.
"Yeah. One of my brothers," she replied, as though it were obvious.
"Bloody hell, how many Weasleys are there in this school?" Regulus muttered, making her laugh.
"Loads. I’m the youngest."
"I didn’t know there was a girl Weasley."
"I’m the only girl born into generations of blokes." The Weasley slung her bag over her shoulder. "Is it true you’re helping your uncle?"
Regulus smiled, shaking his head in disbelief.
"And what if I am?" he mocked, shooting her a sarcastic look.
"You'll regret it!" she snapped, nostrils flaring.
"And what are you going to do?" Regulus stood, towering over her.
"Regulus!" A familiar voice called his name, and the Weasley girl frowned at the newcomer.
"Hermione?" she asked, scratching at her red hair.
"What is it, Ginny?" Hermione stopped beside them, her backpack so stuffed with books it looked like it might burst.
"You’re friends?" Ginny looked back and forth between them before settling her gaze on Hermione. "He… Hermione, he’s…"
"I know who he is, Ginny." Hermione cleared her throat, running a hand through her hair as though trying to tame its thickness. "Don’t listen to Fred and George."
Ginny didn’t seem convinced. Her brown eyes narrowed suspiciously beneath her fiery brows, then she raised her chin and turned on her heel, walking off without another word.
"What happened to your hands?" Hermione offered a sheepish smile, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear.
"Oh… nothing much. Got into a fight," he shrugged the matter off, his eyes flicking uneasily to her overloaded bag. "Why are you carrying so many books? Don’t you have an exam today?"
Hermione grew serious, her gaze dropping to the ground.
"Er, yeah. I’m trying to revise everything I can, but…" She cleared her throat again. "I came here to thank you for helping with Buckbeak’s defence. The appeal is being heard today… Fudge is here in person."
Regulus opened and closed his fists, a surprised crease forming in his brow.
"Fudge? The Minister?" He felt a knot form in his throat. "He’s here just for an appeal?!"
"And for your uncle, too," Hermione admitted quietly, watching his reaction carefully. "It’s true, isn’t it? You are helping him?"
"What?" Regulus snapped. "I’m not!" He clenched his fists again, grinding his teeth through the pain. "Don’t you have like… an exam right now, Granger?!"
Hermione didn’t flinch. A wrinkle formed between her brows.
"Stay away from Harry, Regulus," she murmured, voice low but laced with threat. "Or I’ll tell your Uncle Lupin."
"Tell him what, Hermione? I’m not—"
"That you’re helping Sirius!" she raised her voice, cutting him off.
Regulus gave her a smile that wasn’t a smile at all, swallowing every bitter word he wanted to hurl at the arrogant Gryffindor. He didn’t know why, but he didn’t want to be cruel to her. Not more than he already had. He didn’t even notice when Hermione walked away, only that he’d sat down on the edge of the fountain again, letting his head fall between his knees.
He should have been studying for his N.E.W.T.s, which were just weeks away, but all he could think about was Sirius. And now Fudge was in the castle. Things never seemed quite right—Regulus felt like his life was in a constant state of chaos, and the more he tried to sort it all out, the messier it became.
He looked up when a shadow fell over him, instantly enveloped by Victoria’s presence as he wrapped his arms around her waist and buried his face in her stomach. She stroked his black hair in silence—silence that was, somehow, enough for them to speak volumes.
Regulus no longer knew what to feel. He’d never been a conductor who could orchestrate emotions well, but after pouring out his fury on Vin in that violent catharsis, he felt a little lighter. The feelings still threatened to suffocate him, but they were duller now.
He needed to get to Hogsmeade. If he could, he would have bolted straight for the village—but part of him hesitated. He was afraid… afraid of seeing Sirius. It was all he wanted, and yet the thing he feared most. What if… what if they were all right about him? What if Sirius had never truly been the man Regulus thought he knew, and was just a shadow of someone long gone?
No. He couldn’t accept that. He refused to.
He fumbled in his pocket, trembling, swollen fingers searching for the photo he kept so carefully. Victoria’s fingers threaded through his hair in a soft rhythm as he looked down at the picture, a sad smile tugging at his lips at the sight of Sirius and Scarlett so happy. His heart ached—as if that happiness were corrosive. As if it had claws and was ready to tear into him.
Victoria took the photo, drying his tears with her thumb, eyes widening.
"Is that your mum and your uncle?" she asked, sounding surprised.
Regulus nodded.
" ‘Scarius, summer of ’78’? " she read from the back, brow arching. "What’s ‘Scarius’ ? Sounds like the name of a constellation."
"Scarlett and Sirius, I suppose," Regulus muttered, wiping his face on Mimi’s shirt.
"So… your mum and your uncle… but… you were born in ’78. How could she have been with your uncle and… with your dad?"
Regulus let out a long sigh.
"I don’t know, Mims. It’s something only my uncle can tell me… why Scarius went wrong."
Victoria held his chin, gently lifting his gaze to meet hers.
"Is that why you want to go to Hogsmeade? Luana told me."
"Luana’s a bloody gossip," Regulus grumbled.
"She is. Meet me at the Defence Against the Dark Arts Tower after your detention."
Regulus furrowed his brow, giving her a sheepish smile.
"Why? You planning to take me to Hogsmeade?"
"Exactly," Victoria said, giving him a kiss on the tip of the nose before tugging him back toward the castle.
.
.
.
Padfoot whimpered softly as he slunk beneath the bed in the Shrieking Shack. He had searched all around the Whomping Willow for Whiskers—he wouldn’t dare venture into the Forbidden Forest teeming with Dementors, nor try to break into Hogwarts again, though there had been a lingering trace of her scent that led him there: the vanilla aroma that brushed warm hues along the edges of his mind, teasing him with sweet memories of days that would never return. Days when he’d known exactly what happiness felt like. Before the Dementors had corroded that feeling with their putrid touch.
Some part of Sirius knew he’d never rid himself of their presence—not that he needed much help ruining things. Sirius was a master at it, and had been swift in souring things with Scarlett, driving her away with his acid tongue.
He’d always done that, truth be told. Scarlett always left in the end, and it was always his fault. Sirius ruined everything and everyone. He’d wrecked Scarlett’s life, got James and Lily killed, pushed Remus away. Turned his back on Regulus. That was his fate—to end up alone. It was what he feared most, and ironically, what he always ended up with.
Sirius curled in on himself beneath the bed, watching the cobwebs shimmer where the light trickled in through cracks in the walls of the Shrieking Shack. He didn’t move for a long while. He kept shifting between himself and Padfoot, always seeking refuge in the dog when the pain got too sharp, too raw, too thorny.
The pain he caused Scarlett was the same pain that tore him apart. Sirius had always been like this—never able to hold things in for too long—he had to erupt. And usually, it was Scarlett who got hurt. Even so, she stayed by his side… for a while.
Until… until that damned watch Regulus gave him.
Sirius should’ve thrown it away.
Padfoot thudded his tail against the floor, whining again. He missed Whiskers. Missed the warmth she gave him, her soft fur, her licks and even her bites. Hunting with her, playing, teasing her. He hated being alone—especially in that house.
Not in that place that stirred up so many faded memories. He remembered when he and Moony had come to blows once, when the wolf had turned on Wormtail during a full moon when Remus had been particularly stressed. He and Prongs had had to pull the werewolf off the rat, giving Peter the chance to escape and leaving the rest of them behind.
Padfoot had fought for dominance with Moony, and with Prongs' help, he’d managed to subdue him. In a way, defeating Moony had made him the leader of their little pack. He’d had to fight the wolf many times after that, especially because Prongs, being prey, often bore the brunt of Moony’s frustrations.
The dog bristled at the reflection of feline eyes glowing in the darkness. He crouched low, heart thudding with the sudden hope that it might be Whiskers. But it wasn’t her… it was only Ginger. The cat brought him a mouse, offering it up as if he somehow knew Padfoot hadn’t eaten in days.
He swallowed the meal in a single gulp, crawling out from beneath the bed with his stomach burning. He needed to eat. Ginger motioned for him to follow. Padfoot hesitated, still searching for Whiskers. But she wasn’t there—no matter how much he wished she was. His gaze locked on the piano, and he whimpered once more, pressing his nose against the keys, letting Scarlett’s scent seep into his mind like a soft poison, as if she were still with him.
Padfoot dug up what little spark of joy remained in him and followed Ginger, playing and hunting through the night together. The air was much warmer now; the snow had melted, and the night wind was nothing more than a gentle breeze.
His attention turned to the castle—Hogwarts—with its glowing windows and pointed towers. Something twisted in his chest. Fear and longing. He rolled onto his back on the grass, staring up at the stars, trying to chase away the memory of when he’d placed flowers in the hair of a girl curled up in the Potters’ garden.
Padfoot picked a small yellow flower from the ground, carrying it back with him to the Shrieking Shack, hoping it might serve as his apology to Scarlett.
But, just like in the summer of ’78, Scarlett didn’t come back.
He waited every day at the door of the Shrieking Shack, the Whomping Willow docile, Ginger curled at his side. His eyes scanned the darkness, watching, hoping a black-and-white she-cat might return to him.
She would come back to him. She had to come back, because…
Because she was all he had. Just as he was all she had.
But again, in ’78, they had only each other—and she never came back.
His heart began to pound with dread. His eyes fixed on the clouds veiling the full moon in a soft, woolly sea just before he and Ginger bolted through the dew-kissed grass, the icy dampness soaking into their paws and setting his nerves on edge. He sniffed the air, every muscle tight, searching for her.
Could it be… could Scarlett…?
No.
She was alive. She had to be. She was just… what if the Dementors had found her?
Padfoot drank in the night breeze, trying to catch a note of vanilla—but all his nose found was the scent of apple pie. That smell… he knew it well.
The smell of the rat.
A low growl rumbled from Padfoot’s throat as he picked up the trail. Ginger noticed it too, quickening his pace and darting ahead. Padfoot slowed, nose twitching. There was something else in the air. Broom polish… and sweetness. Floral. A child’s laugh rang out, high and echoing. It stunned him, made his tail wag reflexively, confused.
Ginger’s glowing yellow eyes locked onto something ahead—something Padfoot couldn’t yet see.
Not yet.
But the scents grew stronger, clearer, and Padfoot crouched low, front legs folding as he slipped into a hunter’s stance.
“Crookshanks!” a high-pitched voice whimpered. “No, go away, Crookshanks! Go away!”
But Ginger was getting nearer, ignoring the girl.
“Scabbers — NO!”
Padfoot’s pupils locked on the large, fat, balding rat that appeared from the underbrush.
Apple pie. Apple pie. Apple pie. It was the same scent as the rat…
The same scent as…
Peter Pettigrew.
Padfoot didn’t tear his gaze away from the rat, even as three children suddenly came running after the creature, which was being pursued by Ginger. Padfoot wasn’t far behind, lurking in the shadows, recognising that it was James there.
James and the Invisibility Cloak.
Padfoot’s heart was pounding so hard it felt like it had stopped altogether.
“Get away from him — stay away — Scabbers… come here —”
The boy — the Weasley kid who’d been in the paper with the rat on his shoulder — threw himself to the ground and grabbed Wormtail tightly. James and the frizzy-haired girl nearly crashed on top of Weasley as he shoved the rat into his pocket.
“Ron — come on — back under the cloak — Dumbledore — the Minister — they’ll be coming back out in a minute…”
Padfoot was hyperventilating, ears pricking as Wormtail let out frantic squeals. He bared his teeth and lunged—pushing James back with his front paws in an unthinking move, the flood of memories starring his best friend threatening to unmoor him, but the dog forced them away as his eyes locked with James’s.
That wasn’t James.
James was dead, Sirius.
That was Harry Potter—his godson.
With every beat of his heart, something sharp and frozen stabbed into his chest.
Padfoot landed hard, growling, launching himself into another charge. Harry tried to get up while Ron was on his feet—and that was the perfect opening. He aimed for the rat and bit down… but it was too soft to be Wormtail.
He’d bitten Ron.
In a desperate burst, Padfoot barrelled into Harry, knocking him aside as he yanked Ron violently toward the Whomping Willow, Ginger sprinting close behind. The boy screamed and struggled, but the dog was big and strong, and even out of shape, he carried Ron like a rag doll.
It wasn’t that he wanted to hurt the boy, but he was already half-mad with the stress of Scarlett’s disappearance and all his failed attempts to capture Wormtail—he wouldn’t waste this chance.
Padfoot dragged Ron into the passage beneath the Whomping Willow, his mouth dripping with saliva at the mere thought that the blood soaking his jaws would soon be that of the wretched rat.
That night, Sirius Black would kill Peter Pettigrew.
He would avenge the Potters’ deaths—and the twelve years stolen from him in Azkaban.
.
.
.
Regulus let out a sharp breath as he found Fred and George Weasley already waiting in detention. He crossed his arms, gripping the cloth Filch had handed him as the twins turned to look at him.
"I want those suits of armour gleaming!" the Hogwarts caretaker narrowed his eyes at the three of them, holding out his hand.
Fred and George rolled their eyes and handed over their wands. Regulus hesitated for a moment, then followed suit. The Squib gave a sneering grin before gesturing for them to get to work. Regulus, his fist still aching, chose the last suit in the row in hopes of staying as far away from the twins as possible. They, however, seemed to have other plans, positioning themselves at the suit right beside him, watching him with great interest.
Filch left them with Madam Norris as he went to investigate a suspicious noise.
Regulus pressed his lips into a thin line, wrinkling his nose as he was forced to use his injured hand, half-heartedly polishing the metal armguard.
"Bet his face is hurting more," Fred commented with a smirk.
"Yeah, proper show you put on earlier," George added, craning his neck to peer after Filch’s departure.
"You’ve already snaked for Avery’s girl, and now Diggory’s… I’m starting to think you’ve got a thing for girls who are already taken," Fred went on, leaving the cloth draped across the visor of the armour.
Regulus, feigning intense focus on the polishing, ignored them completely.
"Why so quiet, Black? You do know your uncle nearly killed my brother, don’t you?!" Fred leaned his elbow on the armour’s shoulder plate, eyes locked on Regulus. "You helped him get in, didn’t you?"
Regulus sighed deeply, pausing his cleaning to stare back at them with a look of sheer boredom.
"Well? You going to answer, or just keep quiet?"
"What difference does it make? You’re not going to believe me anyway." Regulus shrugged, returning to scrubbing the metal.
The twins exchanged a look, and George pulled a wand from his pocket, sitting on a bench and polishing both his and his brother’s armour with a casual flick. Regulus frowned.
"You didn’t hand your wand over to Filch?!"
"It was just a spare," George grinned, lacing his hands behind his head. "Filch always does that—he can’t tell a real wand from a fake one."
"You’ve never had detention before?" Fred joined his brother on the bench, the flickering torchlight dancing across their hair, turning the red into a vivid scarlet.
"I have, but… never with Filch," Regulus admitted, surprised at how sharp the twins actually were. "Why are you two here?"
"I swapped out the first-years’ training brooms for Muggle ones…" Fred said it like it was the most normal thing in the world.
"I hexed our older brother’s shoes so they’d start tap-dancing every time he was alone with a girl…" George raised his hand and Fred high-fived it proudly.
"Wow." Regulus furrowed his brow, then returned to work.
"So… you punched your brother-in-law today because he laid hands on your girlfriend?" George asked, casually levitating his cloth with a flick of his wand. "Never thought Slytherin would produce a white knight like you." He rested his elbows on his knees.
"Oh, yeah, the girls are doomed now that you only hang out with Rookwood and Teixeira," Fred chimed in with a smirk. "What is it, do you date them both or what?"
"No need to be jealous, Weasley. Nothing going on between me and Luana," Regulus shot back, a wicked little grin curling his lips.
Fred Weasley gaped at him in mock outrage.
"As if I’d want anything with that foreigner!" He scrubbed at his shirt like he was trying to wipe off invisible filth.
"You owe a debt," Regulus raised his eyebrows. "Both of you, actually."
"We both nothing— Fred borrowed the money from her!" George raised his hands like he wanted no part in it.
"What’s mine is yours, mate," Fred said, clapping his brother reassuringly on the shoulder. "But I’ll pay her back. I don’t like owing anyone."
"You’d better…" Regulus muttered, returning to his task. A strange vibration tickled his pocket. With his free hand, he reached in and found it: his father’s watch. He flipped it open and frowned—the hands were moving backwards, as if time itself were running out.
A countdown.
Regulus shrugged and tucked it back into his pocket. Must be broken.
Fred and George, meanwhile, were having a grand time flaunting the fact that they didn’t have to polish anything by hand, and Regulus was far too proud to ask for help.
“Wanna see something cool, Black?” Fred raised his wand, letting his cleaning cloth fall directly onto Regulus’s head. He simply brushed it aside, ignoring them. “Black!”
“I’m busy.” Regulus shook his head, and his suit of armour gleamed at once. He turned to the twins. “What?”
“You’re coming with us,” George said in a mock-cheerful tone.
“I’m not going anywhere.” Regulus moved to the next suit of armour, but Fred cleaned it with a flick of his wand. Regulus’s jaw tightened. “What do you want?”
“To get you out of here,” Fred confessed, scratching his neck a little sheepishly. “Come on, it’ll be fun!”
Regulus, clearly nowhere near as enthused as the twins, simply went back to polishing with a frustrated sigh.
“Leave me alone.”
“You’re not staying here!” George clamped a hand down on his shoulder, and Regulus tensed, shooting him a sharp glance.
He glared at the Gryffindor, who immediately let go. Regulus knew the Weasleys — not just because they were in the same year, but because they were also Beaters for their respective teams — and he was well aware neither had ever shown the slightest fondness for Slytherins. Regulus had never been close to any Gryffindors. The only ones he spoke to regularly were Harry and his lot. The only reason he ever exchanged words with the twins was because of Luana.
And he knew exactly why they wanted him out of there. Regulus wasn’t going anywhere — not now that Mimi had finally agreed to help him get to Hogsmeade, not when the chance to speak with Sirius was this close to becoming real.
“Filch won’t be back for ages…” Fred ran a hand through his fiery hair, nodding for Regulus to follow.
“I said no!” he hissed, holding his ground.
“Come on, Black, it’s gonna be wicked!” George grabbed him by the collar, trying to force him to walk. When Regulus made to pull away, the Gryffindor raised his wand. “It’s not like you can defend yourself.”
Swallowing hard, Regulus clenched his swollen fists. He didn’t want another fight — not with Sirius so near. He wouldn’t let him slip through his fingers again. So he relented, allowing himself to be led by the twins, who exchanged matching mischievous grins.
“You won’t need your wand for what we’ve got planned…” Fred said from his left, gripping his arm too, just to make sure he wouldn’t bolt. “And we do need a distraction…”
A dozen possibilities raced through Reg’s mind. If he hit Fred first, then George… would he manage to escape? What if he tried to snatch one of their wands — George looked distracted enough. If he just…
In a swift movement, Regulus stamped on George’s foot, making him stumble. He threw his torso backwards just as Fred grabbed at his jumper. He flung out his arms and let the Gryffindor’s own momentum do the rest—ripping the jumper clean off. Then, in a sharp evasive manoeuvre, Reg launched himself backwards and sprinted off, footsteps echoing down the empty corridors in the late-night hush.
Fred and George, stunned by his quick reaction, recovered almost immediately and gave chase.
“Come back here, Black!” Fred shouted, his voice laced with grit.
Heart thundering in his chest, Regulus glanced at the two diverging corridors ahead and veered left, the sound of the twins’ pounding steps close behind. He made for the Great Hall, hoping to run into a member of staff who might save him from the mad Weasley brothers.
“We were going to prank Diggory!” George called out, breathless. “Bloody hell, he’s fast!”
“I know!” Fred wheezed, starting to lag behind.
“Petrify her, petrify her!” a familiar voice rang out from another corridor, and before Regulus knew it, Victoria and Luana came barreling into the stairway intersection, colliding violently with Fred and George.
All four tumbled to the floor, and Regulus slowed instantly, catching sight of the cat sprinting toward him. Luana groped frantically for her wand, and Victoria was shoving George Weasley away with a look of pure disgust.
“Regulus, petrify her! It’s Sirius Black!” Luana gasped, eyes wide as she pointed at the feline.
What? Why would she think that cat was Sirius Black?! The animal was still staring straight at him—those piercing blue eyes, the distinctive whisker markings on her muzzle. Regulus raised a brow, a cold jolt twisting in his gut as something flickered deep in his mind. A tremor. A shift. A song. A smile.
Regulus stood frozen as the cat ran past, eyes never leaving his. He knew that look. That shade of sky-blue, those narrowed pupils, the irises lined with thin black filaments. His fingers instinctively gripped the pocket of his trousers.
“She’s going to get away!” Luana shouted, but Regulus didn’t hear her.
[Music: Fleetwood Mac — Landslide]
A woman with black hair and blue eyes hugged a large black dog. She turned her head and smiled as he licked her cheek. The image reset—the smile drawing itself slowly across her lips—and Regulus felt something tug hard inside his chest. Like a thread tied to his soul. A call, echoing in him.
"I took my love, I took it down…" the voice sang, distant and trembling.
"Climbed a mountain and I turned around…
And I saw my reflection in the snow-covered hills
'Til the landslide brought me down…"
And Regulus stood there, staring after the cat with a heart ready to shatter.
“Petrificus Totalus!” Fred cast the spell before the cat could round the corner, her small body hitting the floor with a soft thud.
“She’s not Black!” Victoria snapped, her voice distant. “I told you, Lua…” she added, but Luana wasn’t having it.
“She ran when I mentioned Sirius!” the girl insisted. “She understood me, Mimi! And besides, he could easily have used a transfiguration spell to disguise himself!”
Oh, mirror in the sky, what is love?
Can the child within my heart rise above?
Can I sail through the changin’ ocean tides?
Can I handle the seasons of my life?
“What kind of ridiculous idea is that?” George stood up, brushing off his clothes.
“How do you think he got into the castle so many times?!” Luana shot back, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
“Alright… that does make a bit of sense,” Fred muttered, begrudgingly.
But Regulus wasn’t listening to any of it. Not a word. He crouched down and lifted the cat into his arms with trembling hands, his heart pounding in his ears. His vision blurred beneath the weight of a hope he didn’t want to feel—because it was foolish. The most foolish thing imaginable. It was just a cat. A cat with whiskers and blue eyes who couldn’t possibly be Sirius—because Sirius was a dog.
Well, I’ve been afraid of changin’
’Cause I’ve built my life around you
But time makes you bolder
Even children get older
And I’m gettin’ older too…
Then why was his chest so tight? Why was there a lump in his throat, and why did this uncontrollable urge to cry threaten to force tears from his eyes? Regulus could barely breathe. It was as if the argument behind him had faded into white noise. All he could see was the cat in his arms—those blue eyes staring at him with fear, remorse, hesitation… and something else, too.
The shade of blue was so pale, he could see through every mask the feline tried to wear. This wasn’t just any cat. Her pupils widened slowly, her muzzle shifted. A solitary tear carved a crooked path down Regulus’s left cheek.
He’d never felt so foolish. His trembling hands made his entire body quake. Victoria lifted the spell, and—unlike what he expected—the cat didn’t flee. She looked down, then back up at him. Regulus’s chest locked tight, unable to draw another breath. His lips quivered.
She leapt down with graceful ease.
Luana, Victoria, Fred, and George stood with their wands raised, though she paid them no attention.
No.
Well, I’ve been afraid of changin’
’Cause I’ve built my life around you
But time makes you bolder
Even children get older
And I’m gettin’ older too
I’m gettin’ older too…
Before Regulus’s eyes, Whiskers began to shift—her form warping slowly as fur drew back into pale skin, white as candle wax; as russet-tinged brown hair fell over a freckled, angular face. Someone nearby gasped, the sound sharp in the silent corridor. Her eyes remained shut, as if not seeing them might make the moment easier. More… bearable.
A sad smile tugged at the corners of the woman’s lips. She was shorter than anyone there, yet something about her stance commanded the space—an unspoken weight in her presence. The moment those blue eyes landed on Regulus, he felt the blood in his veins evaporate.
“Hello, Reggie,” she said, her husky voice fracturing the silence that hung over the group.
Ah, take my love, take it down
Oh, climb a mountain and turn around
And if you see my reflection in the snow-covered hills…
Regulus remained perfectly still, not even breathing, as though he were watching all of his dreams take shape in front of him. His eyes were wide, mouth parted, unable to speak—anything, anything. Words, thoughts, actions, all vanished. He felt that if he moved, even an inch, the fragile instant would melt away into illusion.
Well, the landslide will bring it down
And if you see my reflection in the snow-covered hills
Well, the landslide will bring it down
Oh, the landslide will bring it down…
And then, something broke inside him. All the emotions he’d been holding back surged to the surface in a devastating wave, erupting in sobs he didn’t even try to hold in. There was no reason to.
With a single breathless impulse, he threw himself forward, arms locking around Scarlett in a crushing embrace. Disbelieving.
He clung to her coat as though she might vanish at any moment. In a way, it felt like she would. It was the kind of dream that hurt—and still, he didn’t want to wake up. His fingers wandered through her tousled hair, over her thin back, her sharp cheekbones, feeling her tears dampen beneath his fingertips. Etching into memory the sheer exultation of holding her. Regulus sank to his knees without letting go, melting into the warmth of Scarlett’s touch as she gently stroked his hair, one arm cradling his shoulders.
He gripped her waist tightly, his sobs uncontrollable now, breath stolen, the world around him gone—there was only his mother. He sniffled, forcing every shred of that embrace into his mind, the feeling of her combing his hair with her fingers, the other hand rubbing slow, grounding circles across his back.
He didn’t understand, and he didn’t want to. All he wanted was Scarlett. All he wanted was to stay wrapped in that embrace. All he wanted was to fall asleep beneath her soothing touch.
“Mum.” Regulus wept into Scarlett’s stomach. He knew it wasn’t real. Of course he did. And yet he let himself drown in that illusion, his chest wracked with sobs that stole his words, his breath, his very sense of being. “Is it really you?”
It was strange. All he wanted was to smile—but all he could do was cry.
Scarlett buried her face in his hair, her body trembling with her own sobs. It was Scarlett—Scarlett from the photographs, from the fragmented stories, from a life so heartbreakingly incomplete. The woman who had given him life… and had never had the chance to know him.
Fifteen years. Fifteen years had stood between them, and yet it felt like no time at all. It felt as though she’d always been there. As though…
“It’s me,” she whispered, pressing a kiss to his forehead, and Regulus felt the world tilt. Reality was too much to take in. He could barely see her through the flood of tears.
“It’s me, Reg.”
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 23: This isn’t where my life begins. But it is where yours ends.
Notes:
Hi guys, sorry for the delay. No, I haven’t forgotten you! Life’s just been crazy, moving countries and working with different people can be really exhausting. On top of that, I was enjoying the part of the story I’m currently writing so much that I just went with the flow. Anyway, I hope you enjoy it! The new chapter will probably be up on Friday.
Chapter Text
XCI
Scarlett had no idea why she did it. It had been an impulsive and careless act, one that could bring bitter consequences. But she couldn’t resist the lost look Regulus had given her while still in Whiskers’ form. It was as if she could see the reflection of her love for Sirius in those iris clouded with longing.
She didn’t quite know what to say. Or what to do. But she cried as well. Cried for the misfortunes of life — for the fifteen years she had lost locked away, far from her son. She hadn’t seen him grow, hadn’t taught him to play Quidditch or cast spells. She’d never tucked him in at night or whispered sweet words and all the motherly clichés she’d received from her own and witnessed among her friends.
She’d never been there, and for a moment, she felt unworthy. The memories of when she was pregnant tried to stain that sublime moment. Scarlett wouldn’t let them climb the wall of her heart, knocking them down by holding Regulus tight against her.
Scarlett hadn’t known it was possible to love someone she didn’t even know.
It was different when she looked at Regulus through Whiskers’ form. The feeling had always been there, latent. And it had been easy to control when she focused on her goals, because he never paid her any attention. Not like he had in that bloody corridor. Not when it felt so much like he’d recognised her, even though he’d never seen her.
Not when he reminded her so much of Sirius.
Scarlett wanted to tell him the truth, even knowing she couldn’t.
“Mum?” One of the redheaded boys — who scarily resembled the Prewetts — looked horrified.
“Wasn’t she, like… dead?!” the other continued, grimacing.
Reggie, however, barely moved. Scarlett sought out Red with her gaze — the ghost watched them from the shadow of one of the corridor corners, his ethereal glow shimmering across the castle’s stone walls. At least he’d had the decency to keep his distance.
“Scarlett… you have to go,” he warned her, and Scar swallowed her sob, trying to shake off the stupor her son had pulled her into.
“Reg, I…”
“I knew you lot had skived off detention, you little scoundrels!” Argus Filch appeared at the far end of the corridor, with Madam Norris in his arms. He let the cat down and hurried forward, making the twins stiffen at once.
“Oh, bollocks…” Luana muttered, stepping in front of Regulus and Scarlett. “Fred, I need a favour.”
“No bloody way I’m distracting Filch for you lot! Especially knowing Black’s Death Eater mum…”
“You owe me a hundred Galleons! And if I add interest and penalty…”
Scarlett stepped back, shifting once more into Whiskers and leaving Regulus stunned.
“We need to go!” Victoria grabbed hold of Regulus and Luana’s wrists, dragging them back.
Red rolled his eyes, thoroughly out of patience with the school drama unfolding before him.
“James sent me to find you urgently — you need to get to the Defence Against the Dark Arts Tower… he said the map is in Lupin’s office.”
Whiskers looked at Red, ignoring the ongoing bickering. What did he mean, Lupin’s office? Remus was a professor?
“He said you’ll be able to find Peter using the map,” Red finished, casting an exasperated glance towards the squabble.
George Weasley folded his arms and lobbed a Filibuster firework in Filch’s direction to slow him down. The fireworks exploded in a shower of bright, colourful sparks, causing the caretaker to trip and fall, scaring Madam Norris half to death.
“I’m not staying here to hold him off by myself!” George looked properly offended by the suggestion. “You’re the one who took the money from Teixeira!”
“And I gave you half!” Fred argued, hands on his hips.
“We don’t have time for this!” Victoria hissed through gritted teeth. “Just throw another firework and—”
“Oh, come on, George, I covered for you when you wanted to peek into the Hufflepuff girls’ changing room last year!”
“Because you lost the bet…”
“I’m the eldest!” Fred ended the row, sticking his nose in the air.
Meanwhile, Regulus quickly scooped Whiskers into his arms, afraid she might bolt again. The cat looked at him curiously as he hugged her, as if still seeking the safety of a mother’s arms. As if he still needed them. She rubbed her snout against Reggie’s cheek, curling her tail over his shoulder.
“Fine!” George agreed, begrudgingly. “Go!”
Whiskers dug her claws into Regulus’ cloak as he began to run, followed closely by his mates and Red. The ghost looked genuinely worried about what they might encounter in the secret passages, now empty due to curfew.
As soon as they reached the Grand Staircase, the cat turned back into a woman and Scarlett found herself facing her son once more — he stared at her like a lost little pup, his friends just as baffled. She drew a breath, trying to catch the words that kept slipping through her fingers, her heart pounding in her chest.
“I didn’t die.” It was all she could manage.
Regulus hugged her again, and she was overwhelmed with the sheer feeling of having him in her arms.
“Yeah, we noticed,” Fred muttered, only to receive an elbow from Luana.
“Focus, Scarlett!” Red snapped her back to reality. “Defence Against the Dark Arts Tower!”
Once again, Scarlett wiped away her tears as she tried to form a sentence that made sense.
“I need… I need to go to R-Remus’s office. Remus… he’s a professor here, isn’t he?!” she stammered, gently stepping away from Regulus. “Reg, I need your help. I need you to take me there.”
“No, my uncle… he… he hates you. He’ll want to call the Aurors and… Fudge… Fudge is here, Mum, because of Sirius… You saw Sirius, didn’t you!? It was you who knocked me over in Hogsmeade…”
Remus hates you.
Scarlett swallowed hard. She’d repeated those words countless times in Azkaban, but hearing them from someone else’s lips hurt more than she’d like to admit. How could he not hate her? Scarlett had killed the McKinnons. She remembered clearly how happy Remus had been at Maurie’s birthday, laughing loudly and dancing to the Jackson 5 with her.
Fuck, that had been so long ago. Sixteen years, to be exact.
“Mum!” Reggie shook her, snapping her out of her daze. “What’s going on?!”
“The map… I need the map…” she mumbled, blinking rapidly. “I need to get Wormtail and… and take him to Dumbledore… before… before Sirius… Reg, I need—”
“Mum, I… I don’t—”
“The rat, Regulus, the rat…”
“Oh, brilliant! His mum’s as mental as his uncle…”
“Mum… I don’t understand.” Sirius held her bony face in both hands, forcing her to look at him. “Breathe. Breathe. Breathe.” He filled his lungs with air and she mimicked him, focusing her gaze on those grey eyes flecked with blue. No. Sirius didn’t have blue in his eyes… that was Reggie. Her son.
Her son.
Scarlett gasped, taking a step back.
What was she saying?
Ah, yes.
“Sirius… is innocent.” Scarlett closed her eyes, muffling the high-pitched ringing in her ears.
“Peter. Talk about Peter,” Red instructed, checking something on the doors flanked by sleeping portraits.
“Sirius was never the Secret-Keeper. Peter was. Peter Pettigrew…”
“Peter’s dead!” Victoria looked uncomfortable too. “And the… the Muggles?!”
“He’s not dead.” Scarlett looked at the girl coldly. “He’s an Animagus, he’s been hiding in the form of a rat all these years, living with a wizarding family… Wes… Wes… Weasel?!” She couldn’t recall the surname.
Red caught her attention.
“That door… it’ll take you straight to the DADA Tower. You just need to ask nicely.” He gestured towards a door with a worn handle.
“Wouldn’t it be Weasley?!” Luana was fidgeting with one of her many silver necklaces around her neck.
“Yes! Redheads. Like you.” Scarlett pointed at Fred and avoided looking at Regulus, afraid that if she did, she’d slip back into shock. “Open, please,” she murmured.
The door clicked open, and the darkness of the passage lit up as the torches ignited by themselves. Scarlett gestured for them to go in.
“So you’re telling me the one who betrayed the Potters was an Animagus who’s been living with my family for over ten years?!” Fred was the first to step inside, the flickering torchlight making his hair look like it was ablaze.
Regulus, still stunned, waited for his mother to go through before closing the door with a chivalrous gesture, embracing her once more. Scarlett slung an arm around his shoulder, trying to focus on her task. Truth be told, all she wanted was to hold her son and tell him everything that had happened — even though she could barely think straight at the moment.
“Didn’t your brother have a rat or something?” Luana whispered, beneath the crackling of the torches.
“He did, but it died… and besides, he’s been with the family for… what…?” He widened his eyes at the girl. “Ten years?!”
“No rat lives that long!” Victoria still didn’t sound convinced. “You’re saying… by Merlin… an Animagus lived among you all that time?”
“Is it the rat Hermione’s cat ate?!” Regulus frowned.
“She might be lying!”
“She’s not lying!” Reg snapped sharply. “Why would she lie? And how would she know your family had a rat?”
“W-well, because…”
“We don’t have time for this!” Scarlett pulled her son along.
Red slipped out of the tunnel and poked his head through the door.
“All clear — come on. Quickly!”
They emerged just beneath the staircase that led to the Defence Against the Dark Arts office. Scarlett made to go up, but Regulus pulled her behind the clock when they heard a suspicious noise coming from the room. Victoria, Fred and Luana joined them, ducking down as a figure in black robes and greasy hair descended the stairs.
“Of course he was involved in this!” the professor grumbled, clearly furious. “Lupin’s been helping Black all along…”
Scarlett rubbed her eyes to be sure of what she was seeing. Was that Severus Snape?! She furrowed her brow, feeling Regulus’ breath on her shoulder.
“Snape’s a professor?” she whispered, as Red prowled the hall to check whether Snape would come back.
“You know him?!” In the dim light, Regulus’ grey eyes turned to steel. Steel, like Red’s. Scarlett felt a chill run down her spine.
“Unfortunately.” Scarlett sighed and climbed the staircase in a flash. “We were at school together.”
Regulus exhaled, nodding. Of course his mum knew Snape — after all, he’d been at school with Remus as well.
“With Snape?!” Victoria and Luana echoed in disbelief.
“This whole thing’s getting more and more mental…” Fred scratched his nose, pushing the door to the office open.
Scarlett glanced over her shoulder, watching Red ascend the stairs as he followed her towards the office. With him on her left and Reggie on her right, Scar did her best to avoid the ambivalent feelings bubbling in her chest as she entered that place.
There were many memories there. Sweet and bitter, warm and cold. Scarlett didn’t want to unwrap them just now, so she walked between the desks, where moonlight filtered faintly through the windows, stopping at the professor’s desk. There was a steaming potion in a goblet, and beside it…
Her heart quickened more than it already had.
The Marauder’s Map.
“What’s this?” Luana pulled her wand from her pocket and lit the room with a quiet Lumos.
“A map,” Scarlett whispered, scanning it with Red to find where Peter was.
“A… map?” Regulus tilted his head slightly as he observed the moving ink dots. “Of Hogwarts?!”
“Yes, it shows the entire castle and the grounds around it… you don’t know it? Remus never told you about it?” Scarlett fell into the trap of looking at her son, whose irises reflected the light of Luana’s wand, the steel melting into platinum.
“No,” Reg admitted, his cheeks flushing. “He didn’t like talking about his time here… with you lot.”
Scarlett didn’t take her eyes off her son, catching what he meant. Remus didn’t talk because of her and Sirius? Her heart skipped a few beats.
“You know the Marauder’s Map?!” Fred shoved his big nose over the map, only to be pushed aside by Victoria.
“Of course I do.” Scarlett didn’t even know why she was still answering the boy’s questions.
“How am I supposed to find Peter in the middle of all these people?!” Luana pointed at the Slytherin Common Room, where the names were so crammed together it was hard to make any of them out, requiring sharp focus to distinguish one from another.
“Do you know Messrs. Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs, purveyors of aids to magical mischief-makers?” Fred went on, ignoring Luana’s comment.
“Read the last name… it’s easier that way,” Scarlett said, ignoring him.
“You’re a Marauder?!”
“For Merlin’s bloody balls, Fred, shut it!” Luana smacked him hard on the head.
“Ow, Teixeira! I’m just trying to understand… Black’s mum shows up alive and… starts saying all this mad stuff…”
“I don’t even know what you’re doing here!”
“Both of you, shut it!” Regulus barked, glaring at them with exasperation. “Bloody hell!”
Scarlett laughed, looking at Reg. He smiled too. He had Sirius’s smile. Her whole body trembled as she returned to searching for Peter on the map, her smile fading soon after. Regulus, however, was still watching her, and Scarlett didn’t know what to do.
“Here, got him!” Victoria pointed to the Whomping Willow.
He wasn’t alone. Surrounding the name Peter Pettigrew were Ronald Weasley, Hermione Granger, and Remus Lupin. Just below them: Sirius Black, Harry Potter… and Severus Snape. There was another ink dot there, slightly apart. James Potter. Scarlett’s gaze swept across the area, landing on Lily Potter at the edge of the Forbidden Forest. Ahead of her, Harry Potter and Hermione Granger.
Scarlett parted her lips and rubbed her eyes to make sure she was seeing it right. In addition to the map showing her ghosts, Harry and Hermione were duplicated.
“What is it?” Red followed her gaze, raising an eyebrow. “That’s impossible.”
“Who’s James…” Victoria began, but fell silent as Scarlett folded the map with sudden force.
“It’s not impossible. The map never lies, Red.” Scarlett reopened it, this time not letting the others look.
“What?” Reggie rested his chin on her shoulder, causing her to shift slightly from the contact. He was just as tactile as Sirius.
“Nothing.” Scarlett drummed her fingers against the map before folding it again and stuffing it into the waistband of her trousers. “I need to get to the Whomping Willow.”
“I’m coming with you,” Regulus volunteered.
“So am I,” Victoria said, grabbing his hand in a way that made Scarlett wrinkle her nose in faint disapproval.
“Me too,” added Luana and Fred in unison.
“No!” Scarlett let out a laugh at the absurdity of taking four teenagers with her. “Absolutely not. You’re staying here while I deal with this!”
“I’m not letting you go alone!” Reggie didn’t hide the panic in his voice. “Please.”
Scarlett clenched her jaw, the darkness of the room slowly dissolving into the silvery glow of moonlight sliding across the wooden floor. She looked to Red, whose gaze had drifted far away.
“We haven’t got time,” he murmured, as if he knew exactly what she was thinking. “They’ll only get in the way.”
Scarlett took a deep breath.
“Fine, but if I tell you to stop… you stop. Or I’ll petrify you on the spot!” Scarlett warned, drawing her wand and handing the map to Regulus. “I want you to keep your eyes on Peter… just Peter. The other names don’t matter. I need him to clear Sirius’ name.”
Of course, it was a risky move, considering he could easily notice James’ name stuck close to Sirius and Harry, not to mention Lily’s further off. But Scarlett wasn’t in the right state of mind — all she wanted was to catch Peter, and hoped that Remus might be able to convince Sirius.
At least… she thought he could.
The moment they stepped out of the office, the incorporeal, colourful figure of Peeves was waiting for them with a mischievous grin.
“What have we here? Out of bed, are we?!” he taunted, somersaulting gleefully in mid-air. Regulus stepped in front of Scarlett, shielding her from the poltergeist’s view.
“Shit!” Reggie whispered, searching for a way out.
“Ugh, Peeves…” Luana called out. “Even Moaning Myrtle does a better job of bothering students!”
“What are you doing?!” Victoria hissed, eyes wide as the poltergeist tugged his bow tie with such force it snapped back with a loud crack, making them all flinch.
“No one causes more chaos than Peeves, the supreme poltergeist of Hogwarts!” he declared, affronted and indignant at the comparison, his carved expression full of scorn and disbelief.
“Oh, me and George are way better than y—” Fred didn’t get to finish the insult, as books, scrolls, and bits of armour suddenly came flying at them.
Scarlett instantly transformed into Whiskers, and Regulus scooped her up, the map tucked under his other arm, bolting along the upper landing with Victoria close behind.
“That’s all you’ve got, Peeves? I thought you were more creative!” Fred taunted, dodging the path of a book with a quick flick of his wand.
Regulus, Whiskers, and Mimi sped away from the chaos the poltergeist had unleashed, dashing through a hallway flanked by statues that saluted as they passed, then down the stairs near the portrait of Wendelin the Weird. They made their way into the entrance hall, Peeves’s screeches echoing off the marble walls, and stopped near a few house-elves who were scrubbing the floor.
“Where to?” Regulus muttered to Whiskers, who placed a paw on the map over the Hieroglyphics Hall.
Whiskers settled her front paws on Reggie’s shoulder, pressing her snout to his neck, which was speckled red. She couldn’t tell if it was nerves or sheer awe. His dark hair carried a fresh scent, one that made her glance at Red just behind them.
Towards the ghost who had claimed him as his own to protect him.
“Black!” a female voice echoed, one Regulus recognised, and he froze in place. Victoria, beside him, ducked behind a display case. “You can’t be wandering about at this hour! The Minister—”
A tall figure with greasy hair appeared beside Reggie, clearing his throat theatrically and eyeing Aphelandra Pyke with disdain.
“Professor Snape…” she breathed, eyes going wide as she froze. “I didn’t realise…”
Whiskers bristled entirely upon noticing the man there — bizarrely dressed in the Slytherin girls’ uniform.
“Er, sorry, I… I didn’t kn-know…” the prefect’s voice grew quieter and quieter.
Regulus lowered his head, staring at the floor, until the girl awkwardly said her goodbyes and walked off to another part of the castle. Snape, beside him, slowly began to transform — his hair turning blonde, his features softening into an angelic face. Regulus and Victoria exchanged glances before smiling, and Whiskers tilted her head at the silent look between them, feeling Regulus’s heart begin to race.
Even the way he looked at someone with love reminded her of Sirius.
It didn’t take them long to arrive at the sphinx in front of the Hieroglyphics Hall. Scarlett returned to her human form and checked the map, while Red traced the wall symbols with his ghostly fingers until the secret passage’s opening.
“Why here?” Reggie asked as Scarlett turned her back, mimicking Red’s motions over the hieroglyphs.
“It’s the castle’s passageway to the Forbidden Forest,” Scarlett pressed the inscription, making a click echo that startled both him and Victoria.
The path was more of a hole near the bottom of the wall, one Scarlett could pass through with ease thanks to her small frame. She crouched and slipped in, helping Regulus and Victoria after her. She cast Lumos with her wand as she shot down the tunnel, feeling the spring breeze brushing her cheeks.
“Mum!” Regulus called out.
Mum.
Scarlett felt her stomach twist and her hands grow clammy. She glanced sideways at her son, not realising she was crying again. No. She couldn’t think about that now. She needed to catch Wormtail.
“What is it?” she swallowed hard, trying not to sound harsh.
Moonlight drifted gently through the tunnel’s mouth, spilling over Regulus’s black hair, tinting his eyes with silver. The map wavered in his hands.
“I love you.” Regulus said it with such warmth that guilt bloomed in Scarlett’s chest like a weed — poisoned as all the other vile feelings rooted deep within her.
And he looked at her not like Sirius. He looked at her like her. The same look she used to give her own mother. As if he wanted to say so much, but couldn’t. As if he were holding up the weight of the whole world, begging for help. Scarlett felt the light of Red behind her, encircling her, his breathless presence grazing the back of her neck.
“Scar… you need to—” He fell silent the instant Scarlett raised a finger, commanding him to be quiet.
Scarlett loved Reggie… but she was unworthy of his love. Fifteen years. She’d spent fifteen years away, never saw him, never even spoke a word to him. And he had returned that silence with a love she couldn’t possibly match. Because his love was tender, naive. Pure. Everything Scarlett never was, and never would be. She was bitter, cruel. A killer.
Scarlett didn’t deserve Reggie’s love. Even though all she wanted was to accept it and return it. To hold him and let him take shelter in her heart the way Sirius had, time and time again. The way Red had, too. But her love was corrosive — toxic and pernicious — and all Reggie deserved was a love full to the brim, filled with laughter and gentle touches. A love that had never known pain, or sorrow, or regret.
Scarlett was unworthy of love. What had that feeling ever given her, besides warm tears and cold smiles? Helplessness and fear? Dread and remorse? She didn’t want love; she’d been too brutalised by it. Love had brought her to Sirius’s soul only to have them tear each other apart until they were lost again — wandering alone, crying alone, brooding alone: it had ended in Azkaban. In torture. In suffering.
She loved Reggie, she knew she did. It was carved into her very being. But she didn’t want to suffer. And love — however tender and soft it might seem — had claws, too. Teeth. It was fire, and Scarlett… Scarlett didn’t want to burn. Not again. She was afraid. And how could she not be? She’d spent fifteen years regretting that she had ever loved Sirius Black. Not a single day passed without that feeling.
It was her love that had brought her here, that tide of black hair and starry eyes. It was her love that gave her Reggie. It was her love that led her to the Death Eaters. They said it was easy to die for love — but to kill for love? Scarlett had killed for it. Love had steered her decisions, and let’s be honest, her life was a never-ending storm.
The rain paused occasionally, of course, offering moments to breathe, even to laugh. Then it returned — with a biting wind, deafening thunder, and crashing waves. Scarlett stepped back, hyperventilating, wiping away the unwelcome tears that kept insisting on returning.
A howl made a dozen thoughts bloom at once in the depths of her mind. She snatched the map from Reggie’s hands with force. Wormtail was now veering into the forest, while Sirius and Remus were drawing dangerously close, the other names quickly falling behind.
Scarlett lifted her eyes to the night sky, stepping out of the tunnel.
It was a full moon.
“Sirius…” Scarlett whispered. Red looked at the map and shifted into Mittens, vanishing into the trees.
“Mum?” Reggie called again, his expression breaking into tears. “Why are you—”
“Get back to the castle!” Scarlett cut him off with an authoritative tone. “Now! It’s full moon!”
“I’m not leaving you!” Reg took a step towards her, followed by Victoria.
“It’s not safe—”
“Mum…”
“It’s not safe!” Scarlett shouted, breathless. “It’s not safe. I need to…” Her eyes darted back to the map. Sirius and Remus were dangerously close, and Wormtail had stopped running, taking cover in a nearby clearing.
She had to save Sirius — but how? Go after him and Remus, or after Wormtail? Scarlett blinked the tears away with force, trying to think, trying to breathe, trying to claw her way out of that confused, agonising spiral. She didn’t deserve love! She never had. Love had never been kind to her. So why should she accept it now!?
“Tell Dumbledore,” Scarlett sniffed, placing the map in her son’s hands. “He… he’ll know what to do.”
It was all she said before dashing into the forest, leaving an inconsolable Regulus behind. Victoria pulled him into a hug, stroking his hair, trying to hush his loud, uncontrolled sobs. The silence of rejection hurt more than anything Scarlett could have possibly said. Maybe Remus had been right all along. Maybe…
“No.” Regulus murmured, pulling away from Victoria. “I won’t let them go.”
“Reg… your mum said—”
“I know what she said!” he snapped, wiping his face on the shoulder of his cloak. “But I… I can’t… I won’t… I… I need your wand.”
“Reg…”
“Mimi, please.” He all but begged, his tear-filled eyes locking with hers. “Please.”
“I’m coming with you,” Victoria replied, resolute. “I’m not leaving you… I can’t leave you…”
“No, I need you to do something for me.” Regulus shook his head. “Can you get my Invisibility Cloak from my uncle’s chambers? And wait here… for when we come back…”
“Reg, I don’t want to leave you.” Victoria held his sweaty hands tightly.
“Please, Mimi. I… I really need—” He looked at her like he was on the verge of losing everything he’d just found.
Victoria nodded, reluctantly.
“Promise me you’ll come back?”
“I’ll come back.” Regulus swallowed hard, the force of the frenzy he’d fallen into pouring from his eyes. “I promise.”
“Reg… I love you.” Victoria declared with a gentle smile.
Her words were like a cold breeze in the anarchy of Regulus’s chest. He smiled too.
“I love you.” He brought her hand to his chest. She brushed a handful of hair from his forehead, tucking it back with care before kissing him softly.
Regulus stared at her. There was a sharp pain rooted in his core, and she could see it — in the flickers of blue shading the grey, in the moonlight glowing in his dark pupil.
As soon as they parted, Regulus turned his eyes to the map — and ran.
.
.
.
A tuxedo blur moved swiftly between leaves and shadows, flanked by a black cat with white mittens. It found Lily’s ghost atop a ridge, and she looked down at them, stunned.
“Scarlett, go after Peter! Sirius will be fine!” she instructed, and Mittens glanced at Whiskers, as if to tell her he would stay with Lily.
As much as Whiskers longed to check if Padfoot was all right, she knew she couldn’t waste time. She wanted to give him the freedom he so deserved, so she followed the path she’d seen on the map. Prongs joined her shortly after, lighting the hostile darkness of the forest.
Whiskers didn’t stop, not even when her body began to tire and her paws throbbed. No. She wouldn’t stop until she found that wretched traitor. Her mouth watered at the very thought of hunting him. She leapt over roots, dug her claws into the earth to climb a slope, and reached the clearing, sniffing the air.
The unmistakeable scent of apple pie filled her nose, making her entire body bristle, baring her teeth in anticipation, tracking him through the fallen leaves and damp soil.
The rat appeared just as her pupils dilated to their fullest to pierce the darkness — its long tail dragging on the ground as it leapt onto a log. Whiskers pounced with precision before he could disappear into the wood, her jaws closing firmly around the nearly hairless creature.
Wormtail squealed in fear and pain as Whiskers sank her fangs into him, squirming uselessly in the predator’s grip. She dug her claws into his body to stop him from escaping, but before she could finish him off, the rat began to grow, forcing her to release him.
“It’s really him…” James whispered, his expression heavy with sorrow. He turned away, refusing to look at his treacherous friend.
Scarlett pointed her wand at Peter, pressing it into his sagging neck. Peter was still the same pitiful little man he’d always been, with watery eyes and wrinkled skin. He’d stayed in his Animagus form for so long that his nose had a rat-like look to it. He was thin, though his skin hung in folds. The crown of his head was bald, and the few strands of hair left were faded and scruffy.
Breathing short and ragged, Wormtail darted his eyes in every direction, trying to think of a way to flee.
“You… you… y-you died!” he stammered, trembling with fear.
“I came back from hell just for you,” Scarlett hissed, her face twisted in pure rage, the fury rising so quickly in her head she could hear her heartbeat roaring in her ears.
“Why?” James removed his glasses, burying his face in his hands as he wept. Scarlett was crying too.
“Why, Pete? They were your friends. James… he… why did you turn against the ones who loved you?”
Peter, trembling, was still trying to grasp the fact that it was Scarlett pinning him to the ground. His quivering lips slowly curled into a morbid smile.
“For… for the same reason… you killed the McKinnons, Scar,” he said seriously. “We’re the same.”
Rage swelled within Scarlett so violently that she slapped him hard across the face, making his twitchy little nose bleed. Peter cowered, squealing like he was still in Wormtail’s form.
“We’re nothing alike!” Scarlett shouted, her voice echoing through the forest. “You gave up James and Lily because you’re a coward. I killed the McKinnons to protect!” She gasped for breath, an unbearable pressure crushing her chest. “You think we’re on the same level? Traitor!” she spat, full of contempt.
Peter laughed again, the shrill sound scraping against Scarlett’s nerves.
“We were always the same, Scar. Since Hogwarts. We… we always knew there were things that had to be… had to be done.” He faltered. “I just… I just wanted… wanted the war to end… so many lives lost… all our friends…”
James, who’d been crouched down until then, leapt to his feet.
“Liar!” he roared, his ghostly finger jabbing Peter in the face.
“Bloody liar,” Scarlett echoed, stiff with fury. “You gave up James and Lily because you’re a coward!”
Peter wiped away his tears with shaky fingers.
“They threatened me… said they’d kill me… they’d kill my mum…” he choked out, his voice breaking. “What choice did I have?”
“Then you… your mum… and your whole filthy family… should have died!” Scarlett hissed, turning to look at James, silently asking for his permission.
He shook his head.
“I regret it… I regret what I did.” Peter’s words only fuelled the fire whipping violently through Scarlett’s chest. “Every day… every single day, I—”
“Your regret won’t bring James and Lily back,” Scarlett said coldly, her voice heavy with unhealable grief. To claim remorse now was an insult to the memory of her friends.
She would make him pay.
“Scar, please… please… I can… I can turn myself in to the Ministry and… and Sirius… he… Sirius… please…” he whimpered, and Scarlett could’ve sworn he’d pissed himself.
She nearly laughed with scorn.
“Twelve years.” Scarlett took a deep breath. “Sirius spent twelve years in prison because of you. Nothing you do now can erase that.”
“Please… James wouldn’t have wanted this… he wouldn’t have wanted… you to kill me just to… avenge his death. You knew him as well as I did, you know what he was like…”
That was the last straw. Scarlett shuddered from head to toe.
“James wouldn’t have wanted me to kill you?” she said, avoiding the gaze of his ghost, who had curled back into himself, hugging his knees and weeping. “And you think you have the right to speak about what James would’ve wanted?!”
She pressed the wand so hard into Peter’s neck that a thin line of blood began to trickle from his flabby throat.
“You know what James would’ve wanted, Wormtail? He would’ve wanted to raise his son… teach him to fly on a broomstick… to play Quidditch… he wanted to live, Peter! And you took that from him! You sacrificed him! And for what? To live like a rat… for all these years…” She wiped the tears from her face with a harsh motion, sobbing. “How did we never see who you truly were?!”
“Please, Scar… I can… I can help you… help you start over… have a new life, I… if you kill me, Sirius… he’ll be arrested again… and you… you’ll never see him again. We can… we can start again. Your life. Sirius’s life, we can…”
Scarlett looked to James — his hands buried in his messy hair, face pressed into his knees as he cried. Nothing hurt more than seeing her best friend like that. A shadow of who he had once been. A ghost condemned to wander by her side and relive every sorrow of his life.
It wouldn’t be fair to offer James the chance to kill Peter. No. She would do it with her own hands, as she had done so many times before. Sirius had been right. Peter Pettigrew was guilty and deserved to die for the ruin he had caused.
“This isn’t where my life begins, Peter,” she said softly. “But it is where yours ends.”
Scarlett rose, taking a step back, never lowering her wand. Peter was too terrified to try anything, sobbing uncontrollably as he begged for mercy. For clemency. Where was that mercy when he handed James and Lily over to Voldemort?
He was right about one thing, though.
Scarlett could do what needed to be done to protect her own. The McKinnons were proof of that. She would kill her friends, her enemies — Merlin, she’d even kill innocents — if it meant keeping the ones she loved safe.
It was tragic, how Scarlett had tried in every possible way to do just that, and failed time and again. Sirius too. They were bound by the same chains. They always had been, because Sirius Black and Scarlett Gaunt were two sides of the same coin. Forged from the same material: blood, fury, and martyrdom. Sirius would die to protect; Scarlett would kill.
“Goodbye, Wormtail.” Scarlett whispered, drawing a breath as she prepared herself, mentally and emotionally, for what she was about to do.
“Scar, no!” James lifted his gaze to her, hazel eyes swirling with so many feelings she couldn’t make sense of them all. But what startled her most was the resignation. “Please don’t.”
“He killed you,” Scarlett whispered. “He took away your chance to… to live beside your son…”
“I know.” James raised his face, wiping his damp cheeks. “But you shouldn’t carry that burden. The burden of killing him… please…”
“Avenge the death of my friends? That’s no burden, James.” She looked back to Wormtail — curled up on the ground, weeping. “Avada—”
Her vocal cords failed her as an icy chill began to root itself deep in her body, dragging to the surface of her mind her own voice.
Her own scream.
With a shiver that slithered from the base of her spine to the back of her neck, Scarlett collapsed to her knees. The creatures bled into the shadows of the full moon night, gliding along the treetops, the sound of rattles churning her stomach. Peter let out a shriek of terror. James shouted something she couldn’t process. Her mind was seized — pulled brutally somewhere else.
A shadow in the fire. He opened his eyes, bronze irises reflecting the dancing flames of the room, soot-streaked hair falling across his face. He called her name. Scarlett reached for him, the air thinning from the unbearable heat.
“Orfy…” she responded, trying to reach him. “Orfy… Orfy… ORFY!”
“Orfy is alive.” The flames vanished, replaced by Regulus’s impassive face, the Grimmauld Place tapestry behind him, his long fingers stroking the scorched image of Sirius. “If I let you go, he’ll die.”
“No… please… Red… you don’t understand…”
The tapestry and Regulus vanished like sand on the wind. Darkness enveloped her, lit only by distant candles. A woman, cradling a blond-haired child in the centre of a runic circle, whispered something over and over again — words Scarlett couldn’t understand.
Nyx turned to her suddenly, casting a sidelong glance, her eyes red and swollen.
“Mummy?” Scarlett murmured in a child’s voice.
“I can’t bring her back.” She spoke with a trembling voice. “I can’t…”
The candles were snuffed out, and from the gloom Scarlett saw Sirius beneath a single glowing lamppost, leaning on a windowsill, one hand holding a glass of whisky, the other a lit cigarette. He looked awful — deep bags under his eyes, a scruffy beard, his hair tangled. A baby was crying somewhere in the background. He only moved to take another drag.
“I miss you,” Sirius confessed in a whisper. “I know I shouldn’t, but I do. I don’t think I’ll ever stop.”
“I’m here…” Scarlett whispered, stepping closer. “I’m here, Sirius.”
He didn’t hear her, exhaling the smoke before downing the whisky in a single gulp.
The moment Scarlett touched him, Sirius vanished — like the smoke that had left his lips.
“No, no, no…” she trembled, hugging herself tightly. “Sirius? Jamie? Lily? Red? … Reggie?!”
Scarlett heard a distant roar, the darkness shattering into fragments as a burst of silvery light washed over the forest, pushing the Dementors away in a shockwave. She gasped desperately, then vomited. Her body was drenched in sweat, trembling uncontrollably, but all she could focus her blurred vision on was Peter — collapsed, coughing, trying to transform into his Animagus form.
She gripped her wand. She wouldn’t let him escape, not this time — she’d make him pay…
“Avada… Avada Kedavr—”
“Expelliarmus!” The red spell cracked through the air, disarming her. “Petrificus Totalus!”
“No!” Scarlett thought the bolt of white light was meant for her, but it struck Peter in his rat form, freezing him. She blinked repeatedly, trying to make out the figure standing among the trees, wand still pointed at her. For a second, she thought of Orfy, shrouded in flame… but it wasn’t him. “Reg?!”
“You really are a killer?” he asked, his tone cold. Eyes hard as iron. “I thought… I thought you were going to bring him to Dumbledore.”
“What are you doing here? You… you shouldn’t be… Remus… the full moon…”
“I wasn’t going to leave you alone.” Regulus sighed, and his voice splintered into pieces. “Mum… you…”
He couldn’t finish.
“Sirius is innocent.” Scarlett cleared her throat, wiping the sweat from her brow with the sleeve of her dark shirt. “I’m not.”
Regulus blinked, opening and closing his mouth on words that wouldn’t come. Trying to justify the unjustifiable. Fighting the beliefs he’d had forced upon him all his life — that his mother was a killer, a monster beyond redemption.
“I had to prove my loyalty…” Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, shame seeping into every layer of her being. “To protect Orfy… to protect you…”
Maybe Peter hadn’t been so wrong after all. Maybe they were more alike than she dared admit. Marlene had been their friend, too. And Scarlett had betrayed them just the same. The tears streamed down her face like acid, the bitter taste of regret making her stomach feel as though it were filled with lead.
Her gaze settled on the paralysed rat, where James’s ghost stood watching — eyes narrowed, lips twisted, nostrils flared. Disgust. Rage.
“You were one of my best mates…” he whispered, as if Peter could still hear him. “You were there for the happiest moments of my life… and the worst ones too.” He wiped the tears away with trembling fingers. “You comforted me when my parents died, you helped me take care of Sirius when Scarlett left, you… you were at my wedding, mate. I almost… I almost asked you to be my best man because I didn’t want to burden Sirius too much… and you… you sold us off like pigs to slaughter.” He shook his head, disgusted and disappointed.
“You know what’s worst about all of this, Pete?” Scarlett forced herself to stand, even though she felt horrifically sick. “James, more than anyone, loved you. He believed in you. Helped you every time you needed it.” She picked up the rat — and it was hard not to crush him in her hands until he was nothing but a mess of flesh, skin, bone and viscera. “And you killed him. Not to save lives… not to end the war. But because you’re a coward.” She let out a long breath. “It’s quite ironic… that Gryffindor produced the most cowardly wizard of them all.”
A howl shattered the silence of the forest. Scarlett turned her head towards her son, though she didn’t meet his eyes.
“We need to go…” she said, starting the walk back to the castle, choking down any flicker of emotion trying to pull the strings in her mind. She knew that if she allowed herself to feel, she’d snap that rat’s neck — and Sirius’s chance at justice would be gone.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 24: I want to give her even a fraction of what she gives me
Chapter Text
XCII
Scarlett huddled beneath the Invisibility Cloak as they climbed the spiral staircase that led to the tower of Dumbledore’s office. She was desperate to go after Sirius—especially after Lily had told her that Snape had captured him and Red had revealed that the Minister was there to hand him over to the Dementors. He was going to be Kissed.
She couldn’t allow that. And the only way to save him would be to give up Peter.
The truth was that Scarlett was exhausted—not just physically but emotionally. A dreadful anxiety was spreading through her like poison. She avoided looking at Red and James at all costs, fighting the urge to kill Wormtail and to speak to Reggie. Her son’s gaze burned into her back, yet she still refused to return it.
"We’ll go and see how Harry is… will you two be all right?" Lily asked Scarlett and Red, who simply nodded. "Right, well, if you need anything…"
"Just… be careful with the other ghosts," Red warned her. "If they see you…"
They discussed the nuances of there being two Harrys and two Hermiones (the girl whose name was duplicated on the map), but Scarlett paid no attention. Her gaze was fixed on Peter, still Petrified and his eyes increasingly glazed with terror. She allowed herself a small smile as she pictured him being sucked dry by the Dementors as he had been earlier. The memory made her shudder.
She didn’t even know how she was still on her feet—perhaps the adrenaline still pumping through her veins was dulling the awful sensation of having been attacked by Dementors. Even if a trace remained in her body, it was nothing she wasn’t already used to.
Scarlett sighed as she halted in front of the gargoyle. She could barely remember what it looked like any more. Victoria took the lead, glancing back before speaking the password:
"Pepper Imps," she murmured, and the way opened for them.
Her sweating grew worse with every step she climbed, and she stopped in front of the door just as it swung open. Scarlett straightened, slipping out from beneath the Invisibility Cloak as the portraits of the headmasters who were still awake stared at her. She hadn’t thought she would ever see Fawkes again; the phoenix was perched behind the door, watching her with interest.
The circular office looked exactly the same as it had sixteen years ago. Delicate instruments on spindly-legged tables puffed smoke and hummed; the light flickered as the wind drifted in through the open balcony doors, and the Headmaster, seated behind his desk, wore the same nonchalant expression as ever.
Scarlett took a deep breath and threw Peter onto the desk. Wasting no time, she raised her wand, and she could’ve sworn she saw the Headmaster’s shoulders tense. She reversed Peter’s transfiguration under Dumbledore’s intense gaze.
"I…" Scarlett began, trying to gather the words in her mind to pour out the whole story to the Headmaster. But he raised a hand, cutting her off.
"Sirius has already told me everything," he said, with a calmness that only made Scarlett more anxious.
What did he mean by everything?
She didn’t have time to ask. A shiver ran down her spine, her eyes scanning the room. She spun around quickly, shoving Regulus and Victoria behind her as she noticed a suspicious movement, wand at the ready.
Professor Minerva McGonagall raised her chin, her square glasses glinting under the chandelier light. Her wand was pointed straight at Scarlett.
"Sirius Black may be innocent… but what about you? How do you justify what you did to the McKinnons?" she asked, her voice sharp with accusation.
"Minerva, please, calm yourself," Dumbledore intervened, rising to his feet, making Scarlett swallow hard. "The Aurors are on their way."
"Dumbledore…" Scarlett gasped, tears shimmering in her eyes.
"I know, Scarlett." He fixed her with a piercing look. "He told me everything."
She lowered her wand, as though a great weight had been lifted from her shoulders. Her gaze drifted from Minerva to Peter, to Victoria, then finally settled on Regulus. Scarlett gave her son a sorrowful smile before turning back to Dumbledore.
"Please… don’t send me back," she whispered. "I’d rather die."
"No one will die tonight, Mrs Black." Dumbledore’s eyes remained on her, as if studying every flicker of emotion. Then he gestured to the fireplace behind him. "Use the Floo to go to Professor Flitwitck’s office. Sirius is there." He opened one of the drawers in his desk and drew out a golden ring. "This… will guide you to a safe place."
"No…" Regulus whispered, gripping Scarlett’s wrist. "Mum…"
"You have to go. The Aurors will be here any moment." The Headmaster extended the ring to her, and the gleam of its stone made Scarlett squint. "I suggest you both go with Mrs Black," he said, looking to Reggie and Victoria.
Scarlett cast one final glance at Peter, still Petrified and unconscious. A wave of disgust surged through her. Red, standing a little apart, was staring intently at one of the portraits of the former headmasters.
"Will he be cleared?"
"I will do everything in my power to see that he is." There was honesty in Dumbledore’s voice. And sorrow, too. He knew everything. Knew about Peter, the Potters, what she and Sirius had endured in Azkaban. She sniffed, wiped her tears, and reached for the Floo powder, hoping her son and Victoria would follow suit.
Then, the green flames licked at her body, and she let herself be whisked away to the Charms classroom.
.
.
.
If someone had told him sixteen years ago that he'd die being Kissed by a Dementor, Sirius would have laughed at the absurdity. In fact, he probably would’ve been rather entertained by the tragic end that awaited him. It sounded like a sick joke. But there he was, in that stupid office in Charms' classroom after being captured by Snape, weakened from an attack by the non-beings and by Moony, feeling—once again—like a complete failure.
It was astounding how many times he managed to mess everything up. Failing to save the people he loved, failing to find happiness, failing to catch the bloody rat. His only consolation was knowing that Harry now knew he was innocent. So did Remus. Not that there was much they could do about it—Sirius could only sink further into bitterness as he tried to imagine a different reality, one where things had turned out differently.
If only Scarlett…
It seemed to be his fate to watch her walk away and wait for her to return. She never did. He should’ve been used to that by now. But he wasn’t—he never would be. Her abandoning him had been the cataclysm that triggered all the tragedies of his life—James and Lily’s death, and now, his own. If she had never left during the Wizarding War, she would’ve been the Secret-Keeper. Voldemort would never have extracted the Potters’ location from her—Scarlett was far tougher than any average witch. She knew Dark Magic. She—
Fuck, Scarlett.
It was all her fault. All of it.
And yet, why did he keep glancing at the door like he expected her to walk through and save him?
Of course Scarlett wouldn’t show up. She’d gone. Who knew where she was now—probably far, far away. Maybe even dead. Fuck, she could be dead, and here he was blaming her for every misfortune in his life. Sirius laughed at his own misery, the same way he’d laughed when he realised what Peter had done to him in Muggle London.
"You left me again… and here I am, missing you. Again," he whispered to himself, burying his hands in his tangled hair. "I’m so fucking pathetic."
A sound from the window made his eyes scan the room, landing on the stained-glass panes where the moonlight spilled across the wooden floor. Sirius didn’t move, though his heart thundered in his throat, blood rushing so fast it was dizzying.
More knocks—and Sirius noticed there was something on the other side of the window. He squinted to see more clearly, his jaw dropping in shock at the sight of a wildly dishevelled mane of hair and vivid green eyes behind a pair of round glasses.
He leapt from the chair and rushed to the window, trying to open it, but it was locked. He looked back at Harry, now realising Hermione was with him—and, strangely, the two of them were bobbing up and down. They were… riding something.
Hermione drew her wand and the window flew open.
Sirius could barely breathe.
"How — how —?" he croaked, his eyes landing on the hippogriff beneath them, wings beating to keep them level.
"Get on — there’s not much time," Harry said, gripping the creature firmly by the sides of its slick neck to keep it steady. "You’ve got to get out of here — the dementors are coming — Macnair’s gone to get them"
Sirius grabbed the sides of the window frame and heaved his head and shoulders out of it. He was so thin he managed to fling a leg over Buckbeack’s back and pull himself onto the hippogriff behind Hermione.
"Okay, Buckbeak, up! Harry urged, shaking at the rope. "Up to the tower — come on!"
The hippogriff gave one sweep of its mighty wings and they were soaring upward again, high as the top of the West Tower. Buckbeak landed, with a cleeter on the battlements where a vacant cell stood further back and a stairwell that Sirius assumed led to the Charms classroom.
"Sirius, you’d better go, quick!" Harry panted. "They’ll reach Flitwick’s office any moment and they’ll find out you’re gone."
Buckbeak pawed at the ground, tossing his sharp head.
"What happened to the other boy? Ron?" Sirius croaked.
"He’s going to be okay. He’s still out of it, but Madam Pomfrey says she’ll be able to make him better. Quick — go —"
But Sirius didn’t move, staring down at Harry with intensity. Those eyes so like Lily’s, that frame so eerily reminiscent of James.
"How can I ever thank you, Harry?" Sirius murmured, sliding off the creature. He wasn’t leaving without hugging him.
"No, Sirius, you have to go!" Harry pushed him, wide-eyed with panic.
"I’m not going without giving my godso—" Sirius broke off as he felt something tug—violently and unseen—at his chest. He snapped his gaze to the stairs.
An inevitable pull. An uncontrollable force.
.
.
.
Sirius hurled himself at Dimitri, knocking him off Scarlett and crashing onto the scorched wooden floor with him. With an animalistic reflex, he drew back his fist and aimed for the bloodied face of the werewolf, the muscles in his arm turning to stone as he noticed Dimitri wasn’t even trying to defend himself—his mouth was hanging open, breath rasping.
With his fist still raised, Sirius flinched as Dimitri’s swollen lips curled into a smile.
"You came… to save… your girlfriend?!" he wheezed, barely able to move his jaw. "Too… late. She’s probably… already d—"
Sirius felt the bones in Dimitri’s face shatter beneath his knuckles as he landed a solid punch to the boy’s already-broken nose. He stood, dizzy, his mind reeling and his breath shallow, gaze sweeping over what remained of the Gaunt house. All composure had fled, replaced by raw panic, his eyes misting and unfocused, landing briefly on Lily and James, who were shouting things he couldn’t make out.
Beneath his feet, what had once been polished wood flooring was blackened by fire, crumbling with every step he took. The columns of the house still stood, as did the path to the staircase… as if they were bones in the skeleton of a place he felt had been more of a home than Grimmauld Place ever was.
Sirius was hyperventilating, hand clapped over his mouth as he spotted Scarlett unconscious, her face covered in wounds. He staggered to a corner, bracing himself against one of the pillars as he retched, every pore of his body smoking with anxiety, still unable to grasp what was happening.
It had been hard enough to stay sane at St Mungo’s when James told him Scarlett had vanished. He was lucky he’d noticed she was carrying the multi-portkey—the first thing he did was Apparate to every place he knew she had saved. The cave near Hogwarts, the playground in London… the Gaunt house. Why had she come here?
And… Dimitri?!
"Sirius!" Lily grabbed his face with both hands, and he met those luminous green eyes. "We need to get her to St Mungo’s. Sirius! I need your help! Scarlett needs your help!"
Truth be told, he was running on pure instinct—just like when he’d found her bloodied in the girls’ changing room at Hogwarts. He couldn’t bear to look at her, felt like his heart would rip from his chest if he did. James stayed with Dimitri while he and Lily took Scarlett, one supporting each side, and together they Disapparated straight to the hospital.
He felt like he was going to faint at any moment, his breath catching in his throat every time he tried to draw in more oxygen than his lungs could manage, clutching Scarlett’s wrist far too tightly without even realising.
He only let go when Lily asked, and Scarlett was placed on a stretcher. Sirius grabbed onto the railing as he followed her down an unnaturally white and empty corridor, where he was then left outside the room, utterly unable to process anything being said to him. He was merely a spectator in his own body.
He had expected to return to the hospital for his next appointment—not to bring in his girlfriend, barely alive, covered in blood and bruises. He no longer had control over his tears, simply letting them fall freely down his cheeks, his blurred vision trying to focus on the door to Scarlett’s room.
Sirius had no idea how long he stood there, frozen and disoriented. But he knew it had only taken one hour. One hour away from Scarlett was all it took for her to nearly die, for Fleamont and Frank to try and figure out what she’d gotten herself into, for Dimitri Rustov to be arrested by Aurors, for Euphemia to embrace him like a mother and make him cry like a little boy.
Worst of all, Sirius couldn’t even bring himself to be angry at Scarlett. All the fury burning in his gut was directed at himself—for being naïve enough to think she wouldn’t read the letters, to believe Scarlett would wait for him.
He hated how alike they were, because he understood her. Sirius would’ve done the exact same in her place. And still, all the desperation and agony he’d felt when she disappeared clung to his tongue like bitterness he couldn’t swallow, and it was near impossible to separate himself from the hurt when it had already rooted so deeply in his heart. James tried to console him, though he knew there was nothing he could say to ease the anguish twisting in Sirius’s chest. Not even when Peter and Remus arrived, clapping his shoulder and trying to lighten the mood with idiotic jokes.
"I’ll… grab something for us to eat," Lily soon said, leaving them.
When the mediwitch emerged from Scarlett’s room, all Sirius could hear for a long moment was the ticking of the clock above his head. She cleared her throat, hugging the clipboard she held to her chest.
"Is any of you a relative of Scarlett Gaunt?" the woman asked, looking between Sirius, James, Peter and Remus.
James gave Sirius a shove, snapping him out of his daze.
"I… I’m her boyfriend," he said, blinking several times as if trying to dispel the chaos in his mind. He was feeling so much all at once, he had no idea how to stop it, how to keep that invisible thread from tightening around his throat and choking him in his own torment.
"She has no next of kin of som—" the woman stopped mid-sentence when Thanatos Gaunt appeared, dressed in his distinctive Auror robes, fixing Sirius with a cold, piercing stare.
"How the fuck did Scarlett sneak into an illegal duelling arena right under your bloody nose?!" Thanatos barked, his brows furrowing in rage.
A burning reflux crawled up Sirius’s throat. He had never felt so utterly useless. He’d promised to protect Scarlett, and all he’d done… was look after himself. He had no idea what to say, no justification—his words failed him. Sirius licked his lower lip and simply lowered his head, covering his face with both hands, trying to ignore the humiliation of crying in front of Nate.
"We’re wondering the same thing!" James stepped in, standing protectively in front of his best mate. "We didn’t even know that—"
"I left my niece in your care, and now we’ll be lucky if she doesn’t go straight from here to Azkaban!" Thanatos cut him off. "She used an Unforgivable in front of a hundred witnesses!"
"What?" Peter whispered, recoiling. "She…"
"I knew it—knew I shouldn’t have left her with you—"
"Watch your tone, Gaunt!" Remus snapped, stepping forward and jabbing a finger in Thanatos’s face. "It’s not Sirius’s fault! She disappeared!"
"Of course it’s his fault! He took respo—"
"He's not well!" James shoved Thanatos back, an uncharacteristic flash of fury in his eyes. "You think he’s not suffering?! He was in that fucking fire too, Gaunt, and he saved Scarlett! Not you! So I suggest you calm the fuck down… or we’re going to have a problem!"
"Oh, what, is this some sort of competition now? Who’s suffering the most?" Thanatos scoffed, voice dripping with sarcasm.
A loud throat-clear from the mediwitch cut through the argument, drawing all eyes.
"I need a family member to collect Miss Gaunt’s personal belongings," she said, completely unfazed by the tension in the room. "Additionally… I must inform you that Miss Gaunt shows scarring consistent with the Cruciatus Curse, which I’m required to report to the Aurors."
She brought out Scarlett’s bag from the room, along with two letters and a multi-portkey. James took the letter and the orb, while Nate grabbed the bag.
"Cruciatus?!" Sirius lifted his head, staring at the mediwitch.
"Precisely. But we’ve done an excellent job treating the burns—there’ll be no lasting scarring. She also suffered a skull fracture and breaks in the metacarpals of both hands. All have been repaired, but it will take time for her to fully regain movement, and she may experience swelling in her wrists. She hasn’t woken up yet..."
"Cruciatus Curse…" Nate muttered, his gaze flicking between the mediwitch and the door to Scarlett’s room. "Maybe I can work with that… self-defence…" he murmured, then abruptly stepped away, lost in thought.
Sirius reached for the letters in James’s hand, but Remus stopped him before he could read them.
"I don’t think you’re in the right state for this, Sirius," Remus said with such tenderness that Sirius felt a violent urge to punch his friend square in the face. "I’m serious."
"I’m fine!" Sirius snarled through gritted teeth. "I just…" He wiped the tears from his face aggressively. "Fuck, this is my fault. All of it…"
"Stop. It’s not your fault!" Remus shot him a look, those dark eyes flaring with a hint of gold. "I know you, and I know you’re torturing yourself over this, but it’s not going to help—"
"She nearly died because of me!" Sirius shouted, gasping as he shoved him. "Fuck… I can’t… I can’t even take care of her…"
"Yeah, because you need to take care of yourself first, mate." Remus gripped his face firmly, forcing him to look at him. "It’s okay to not be okay. Stop acting like this is the end of the world. Fuck’s sake, we’re here for you!"
"You don’t get it, Rem. I promised I’d look after her. She’s my responsibility." Sirius shook his head, snorting bitterly.
"Mate," James cut in, throwing his arms around both of them, "she’s our responsibility."
"What?" Sirius muttered, frowning.
"She’s our responsibility, Pads," Remus nodded.
"Mine too," Peter added, wrapping his arms around them from the other side.
"No, she’s my girlfriend, so—"
"And she’s our friend," James smiled. "You’re clearly not handling this on your own, Pads. Let us carry some of it with you."
"Scar… isn’t a burden," Sirius sniffled.
"The burden’s not Scar, mate," Remus rolled his eyes. "The burden is what you’re going through. I know you think you can take it all on alone… but there’s no reason you have to. Not with us here."
"Yeah, like, Jim Morrison didn’t do The Doors on his own!" Peter chimed in, rubbing Sirius’s back encouragingly.
"We’re the Marauders. We became Animagi," James said softly, "so Moony wouldn’t be alone. We’re not letting you go through this shit on your own either. "Besides, someone’s got to give her a proper bollocking for how bloody stupid this all was."
Sirius gave a faint smile at their ridiculous loyalty.
"She’s gonna get an earful when she wakes up…" he murmured, rubbing his eyes. "That woman’s going to be the death of me."
"Yeah, mate, told you from the start…" James teased, ruffling his hair.
"Remus… give me Dimitri’s letter," Sirius said, locking eyes with him. It wasn’t a request.
"We’re reading it together," Remus replied firmly. "Or do you honestly think… she wouldn’t want that?"
"I don’t think Scarlett’s in any state to want anything," Sirius hissed, snatching the letters.
"You sure you’re up for this?" James nudged his glasses up his nose and leaned his head against Sirius’s shoulder. "I mean, if you’re not…"
"You're afraid I’ll go after him?" Sirius raised an eyebrow. "He’s with the Aurors, isn’t he?"
"And since when has that ever stopped you from doing anything?!" Peter shot back, deadpan.
"I won’t. I promise." Sirius lifted both hands in surrender. "Seriously. I just… I need to understand. What she did… it doesn’t make sense. And I… I need to understand. I feel… betrayed. And Scar… she’d never— never betray me."
"Yeah. That’s not like her at all." Remus sighed deeply and gestured for Sirius to sit. "Want me to read it?"
Sirius handed him the letter and dropped into the chair, his eyes flicking briefly toward Thanatos, who was speaking with a group of Aurors, Scarlett’s bag slung over his shoulder.
He looked back to Remus, who clenched his jaw as he read silently for a few moments—then began aloud:
My sincerest condolences on the death of your family. Shame it wasn’t me who did it—I would’ve quite enjoyed hearing your parents scream as the fire swallowed them. Even little Orpheus is gone. Such a pity. He was a good boy. I do hope you’re suffering. Just imagining how much you must’ve cried makes my mouth water.
You still owe me for what you did to me at Durmstrang. You know me—I don’t forgive. Not even after your life turned into this tragic little mess.
It’s a bit ironic, isn’t it? How everything went to shit after you started shagging that Black. Serves you right. That’s what you get for choosing him over me.
You and I, with your Signet, could’ve been so much more than just another stupid couple.
We could’ve taken down everyone. Even the Dark Lord, if we wanted.
But you’re weak, gorgeous. You always have been. So here’s a little incentive:
In Knockturn Alley, in the side alley next to Borgin & Burkes, there’s a statue of a wizard. Move your wand as shown. The statue will shift, revealing a staircase. Go down, then left—the arena will unfold before your eyes.
We call it the Battle Arena. I would’ve shown you that place if you hadn’t lost your mind that bloody night at the ball. It’s a great place to hone your duelling skills—I know you’re good, but I want to destroy you in front of a crowd.
And maybe, just maybe, I’ve got a lead on who did that to your parents.
I’ll be there every day of the summer waiting for you. I want a rematch—and you’re never without your pet dog or his little friends, so come alone.
Can’t wait to see you, sweetheart.
All yours,
Dimi.
The silence between them was louder than any scream. Peter looked horrified, Remus’s face twisted with restrained emotion, and James’s hand tightened on Sirius’s shoulder as if trying to keep his fury in check. It was too much to process—but Sirius’s heartbeat slowed, an unexpected flicker of empathy for Scarlett softening the bitterness of betrayal that still gnawed at him.
"James…" Sirius whispered his friend’s name, and James looked at him with those hazel eyes Sirius had always trusted. "Do you think… do you think it was Dimitri?"
"Dimitri?" James frowned.
"The fire. Do you think it was him?"
James opened and closed his mouth, clearly unsure of how to answer.
"He says it wasn’t him, but… there’s no way to know," Remus muttered, folding the letter with more force than necessary, his breathing uneven. "Fuck…"
"I have to go after him." Sirius shot to his feet, only to be immediately held back by both James and Remus.
"No, Sirius!" James forced him back down into the chair. "You’re staying right here!"
"But I need to—"
"You need to calm down!" Remus handed the letter back to him. "You’re going to do something stupid if you keep this up…"
"Fuck." Sirius exhaled all the air in his lungs.
As difficult as it was to rationalise any of it, he knew Remus and James were right. But his moment of contemplation was short-lived—Thanatos returned, handing back Scarlett’s bag. Sirius reached out to take it, but Nate let go too early, causing it to tip upside-down and spill several personal items across the floor.
"Shit," Sirius muttered, blocking some wayward Galleons with the toe of his boot.
"Sorry," Thanatos murmured, kneeling to collect a pile of blank parchment—only to freeze as he noticed a photograph among them. He snatched it up, eyes locking on the image of a Wizengamot member, the figure’s robes clearly recognisable. What made him go rigid was the red circle drawn around the person’s face.
Nate’s expression shifted—his eyes widened in alarm as he spun towards Sirius, panic threading into the sharp lines of his face.
"Where did she get this?!" he demanded.
"I don’t know." Sirius shrugged, utterly bewildered. "Scar doesn’t normally carry around photos of random old wizards, far as I know."
Nate’s blond brows pulled into a deep frown. He gathered the blank pages, setting the photo aside.
"She wouldn’t… would she?" the Auror murmured to himself, then drew his wand. "Revelio!"
The spell hit the parchment—and lines bled across the pages, converging into words:
Thanatos Gaunt, the shame of the flesh, abomination. Your father wished you had died instead of Morfeu.
Nate’s face flickered from shock to something far more haunted. He rotated his wand in a fluid motion, and a silver falcon burst forth—a Patronus.
"White and Purple, mission compromised. Abort immediately," he commanded, and the falcon beat its wings and vanished into the walls of the hospital. He raised his wand again, summoning a second falcon. "Black, rendezvous in twenty."
The silver falcon flew swiftly past the four of them and vanished into the corridor.
"Nate… what the hell—" Remus stopped as the Auror raised a finger.
"I need you all to stay here with Scarlett. Let me know the moment she’s fit for transport." He tucked the parchment under his arm.
"What are those papers?!" James rubbed the bridge of his nose, tension rising.
"That’s… classified. But if it’s what I think it is…" Nate gave a disbelieving smile. "Dixon, can you take over security here?!"
Sirius and James exchanged a look.
"White and Purple…" James murmured. "Do you think… Nate’s working with my parents?"
He didn’t get a chance to answer—Lily appeared carrying sandwiches and several juice boxes. Sirius only realised how hungry he was after the first bite, glancing down at his knuckles, still red from punching Dimitri.
He clenched his hand the moment he thought of him, the words from the letter fuelling the fury threatening to tear through his chest. He smothered it with a deep breath and stood up again, refusing to stay in that bloody chair.
"Give me your flask." He held out a hand to Remus, whose brow arched immediately.
"Why?"
"Because I want a drink, obviously," Sirius snapped, as if it were the most logical thing in the world.
Remus let out a mocking laugh.
"Here, have a pack of cigarettes instead."
"I don’t want cigarettes, I want whisky!" Sirius huffed, reaching for Remus’s pocket, which he promptly shielded with both hands.
"What you want is easy , Pads!" Remus flipped him off, making Lily let out a sound of disgust.
"I thought you were the most restrained of them," she said, glaring at him with disdain.
"I am, Evans—that’s why I haven’t handed Sirius the flask!" he shot back, hand on his chest like a falsely accused saint.
"Oh, just give Pads the bloody flask, Moony," James folded his arms. "The poor bastard’s about to explode."
"That’s exactly why I won’t! It’s like pouring petrol on a bonfire!" Remus laughed nasally, and Peter nodded in agreement.
"Yeah, better not… if Scarlett wakes up…" Wormtail began, but was cut off.
"If she wakes up, I’m not having that conversation with her. I don’t want to hurt her. James, that mess is yours." Sirius clapped his friend’s shoulder.
"Fine, I’ll take the hit—because you’re my best mate. Now Moony, for Merlin’s sake, give him the bloody flask!" James kicked Remus’s shin, who retaliated with a knee to the thigh.
"Only if you promise not to do anything stupid!" Remus growled, clearly annoyed.
"I promise!" Sirius huffed, grabbing the flask the moment it was handed over and storming off down the corridor.
"Where are you going?" Peter made to follow, but James held him back.
"To get some air!"
.
.
.
Sirius Black had never really learned how to deal with his frustration. Raised in an unstable household, it was hard not to live in a constant state of alert—he had never felt safe. Not until he started at Hogwarts.
He and James always joked that Remus was the most guarded of the Marauders, but the truth was that Sirius only let his friends see what he wanted them to see. Because, for the first time in his life, he felt like he had control over something. That he could dress how he liked without being slapped in the face, that he could spend time with whomever he pleased without being beaten for it. That he didn’t need to suppress his emotions just to earn the approval of those around him.
Of course, that didn’t stop him from hiding certain things—especially after the summer holidays, or the Christmas break, or Easter.
His friends didn’t know what he endured at his parents’ house. James had been the first to find out, catching a glimpse of the scars, though he never asked a single question. He always respected Sirius’s silence. Remus found out that Sirius had whipped Regulus not long after it happened. Wormtail had overheard a rumour from older Slytherins about tension in the Black family after Bellatrix had done something to Orion’s sons.
Naturally, it took some time for the three of them to piece things together. Even so, none of them ever demanded an explanation. In fact, Sirius never told them the whole story of what happened at Grimmauld Place. The only person who knew everything—straight from his mouth—was Scarlett. It took him years to work up the courage to speak about it; the trauma was so deeply ingrained that his instinct was always to pull away, to shut down, to disappear.
But that didn’t mean he had ever really overcome it. He hadn’t. It still poisoned everything inside him—this searing rage locked meticulously in his chest, nestled beside boxes of hurt, regret, rejection. Why couldn’t his parents love him the way they loved Regulus? Why was love so hard for him? So painful? It wasn’t like this with his friends. It wasn’t like this with Scarlett. So why was it so hard to love himself?
Sirius had always been quick to shoulder blame, to punish himself. It was what he’d been taught all his life—his father’s plans failed? Sirius was whipped. His mother spilled tea on her favourite dress? He was punished. Sirius embarrassed the family? He was "disciplined"—a polite word for having his mind invaded by his father, who would twist whatever he found into a weapon of shame.
It was all he had ever known, and breaking free from that was excruciating—even though he knew, rationally, that none of it had been his fault, something deep inside him refused to let go of that belief. It was suffocating. He might’ve escaped his parents’ clutches, but the wounds they’d left behind still throbbed, still festered. Sirius needed to tear that rot out of his chest—or it would consume him.
He took another sip of the whisky, letting the burn lull his senses, searing its way down his throat. He hadn’t even known there was a rooftop garden on the top floor of St Mungo’s, where tulips, mallows, lilies, and deep red roses bloomed even in summer, perfuming the air with a sharp, intoxicating fragrance.
He looked up at the sky, where London’s light pollution blurred the stars. Still, a few managed to pierce through the city’s smog—tiny, defiant points of light. He turned his gaze to a bed of roses on his left, ignoring the pale-skinned, red-haired girl who sat down on the same bench—not close enough to touch, but near enough that her presence was unmistakable.
Sirius exhaled and took another swig of the whisky.
"I want to be alone," he muttered, almost pleading.
"I’m not leaving, even if you don’t want company," she replied, stubborn as ever. Sirius scrunched his nose and rolled his eyes, letting the alcohol blur his restraint.
"You’re not even going to offer me a sip?" she asked, raising an eyebrow and folding her arms.
"No." Sirius’s answer cracked out like a whip—quick, sharp—but there was a hint of teasing in his tone.
Lily snatched the flask from his hand with infuriating ease. The alcohol had dulled his reflexes. Sirius feigned annoyance, though a sly smile crept across his face.
"Why are you here, Lily?" he finally asked. "We’re not even friends."
Lily returned the flask by thumping it against his chest a bit harder than necessary.
"Of course we’re friends. Although… I’m closer to Scar."
Sirius raised an eyebrow, sceptical.
"But didn’t you used to think Scarlett was shallow, childish and a bloody bully? Just like me?" His voice was edged with accusation.
Lily flushed but held his gaze, the garden lights highlighting the piercing green of her eyes.
"You are all those things," she admitted. "But you’re also much more. I don’t hate you, Sirius. Even if James drives me up the wall."
Sirius smirked, shrugging.
"Then go bother James."
She refused, staying exactly where she was.
"I know how gutted Scar would be if you did something stupid and I didn’t try to stop you."
Frowning, Sirius tossed his hair back and rested his elbow on the back of the bench. He didn’t want Lily’s words to affect him in any way—but it was impossible not to feel stung. Scarlett was the one who had ruined things. Not him!
"You and Scar are so alike," Lily went on, grabbing the flask again. Sirius didn’t stop her. "It’s funny, considering you’re Gryffindor and she’s Slytherin."
"Nobody knows this," Sirius muttered, "but I was a hatstall between Slytherin and Gryffindor. Because of my family." He shrugged, resting his head on his arm, letting the emotions that choked him wash away in the tide of inebriation. The fizzy lull of the whisky softened the hammering in his chest. "I… found myself in Scar."
Lily bent her knees on the bench and rested her head against the back too, gazing at the sky before glancing sideways at him.
"What do you mean?"
"She… accepted me for who I am," Sirius admitted. "She knows me… the side I show. And the side I try to hide. She saw my underside, my extremes, my sins. And she still chose to love me."
"Oh, Sirius, half of Hogwarts loves you."
"It’s different, Lily. I’ve never… felt anything like this."
"I thought you and Marl—"
"What we had was convenience, not love. And Scarlett…" The words floated between them, suspended in the warm air, until Sirius caught them and anchored them in truth. "…she loved me with such ease, such… lightness. Like it was the most natural thing in the world. Like she didn’t have to force it, but also like she needed to. And I tried to run from it only to end up—at the end of it all—finding her again. Scar… she makes me feel safe. In a way I can’t even explain. Seen. It’s like… no matter what I do, she’ll still love me. And I’m terrified of ruining it."
Lily didn’t look away. She listened—really listened—with a quiet, open attention that made Sirius feel a little exposed.
"She loves you so much too, Sirius," she said softly, offering her hand. Sirius gripped those pale fingers with so much force they turned pink.
"It’s my fault, Lily." He shook his head. "I shouldn’t have given her the letters… I shouldn’t have… hurt her. I didn’t… it’s all my fault." He tried to hold back, but the emotions burst at the seams. "I’m a fucking failure. I’ve always been. I can’t even… I can’t even protect the ones I love. Orfy and…"
"It’s okay to be sad and cry, Sirius…" Lily said softly.
"No! It’s not okay!" His voice came out raw, scraped thin with pain.
"It’s normal to feel sad and frustrated. What’s not normal…" She squeezed his hand in return. "…is blaming yourself like this."
"But it is my fault!"
"I didn’t realise You-Know-Who started a war just to ruin Sirius Black’s life," she snapped, her tone biting. "Merlin, I wish I had that kind of ego. Not everything is about you—especially not what happened to Scarlett’s family. That wasn’t your fault. Neither was what she did."
"But I… I…"
"There was nothing you could’ve done except save her, Sirius. And you did. You saved her. You’re a hero. You saved her life. But don’t crucify yourself for the deaths that happened. It was a tragedy. It wasn’t your fault. It never was. Why do you blame yourself so much?"
Sirius shrugged, burying his face in his arm.
"I… I don’t know… she blamed me. Right after they died. And maybe… maybe she was right."
"She wasn’t," Lily sighed. "Sirius, there are things in this world that are completely out of our control. You can’t keep expecting every awful thing that happens—to you or to Scar—to be your fault. Life is more about pretending we have control than actually having it. The sooner you accept that this is one insane ride where you might be piloting the ship, but not the universe around it… the sooner you’ll realise there’s nothing crueller than torturing yourself over the inevitable."
"I wish I could control it. I want to make her happy. I want… I want to give her even a fraction of what she gives me. But since the fire…" he sobbed, turning his face slightly towards Lily, "…I just… I can’t. I don’t think I ever will again."
His lips trembled, pressing together in a desperate attempt to hold in the sobs, but his cheeks were soon wet with tears—fleeting and luminous like the stars still winking overhead. Lily ran her fingers through his hair, and Sirius collapsed into her arms, crying for what felt like the hundredth time that day.
"Sirius… she’s grieving something massive. You can’t replace her parents. Or her brother. But… she chose you. As her partner. And… despite all my reservations about you—which are plenty…" Her lips curved into a gentle smile. "She loves you. Deeply."
That much was true.
But love alone wasn’t enough… not anymore.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 25: What is love, if not magic?
Notes:
Trigger warning: self-harm
Chapter Text
XCIII
The sun was rising in the streaked eastern sky, casting light over the dew-soaked trees of the cemetery, illuminating the paths between the gravestones. Scarlett hunched over, her hands occupied with holding a bouquet of flowers she’d picked along the way: stocks, carnations, and lilies made up the colourful arrangement. The sound of the sea crashing against the cliffs carried the scent of salt air, laced with the sweetness of the bouquet.
"Not going to place the flowers, love?" A voice she knew all too well sounded just above her. Scarlett turned her head so fast her neck cracked.
"Daddy!" She murmured, as if she hadn’t seen him in a long time, though he hadn’t once left her side.
Morfeu smiled, stroking his beard before pulling her closer, placing a kiss on her hair.
"What is it, Scarly?"
She pressed her lips together, squinting up at the blue sky where its hue faded into the shimmering sea along the horizon. Her gaze returned to the gravestone in front of her, the marble gleaming golden where the sun hit it.
Violett ‘Bonnie Blue’ Gaunt
21/12/1959 – 24/12/1964
"I don’t know what to do." Scarlett exhaled all the air in her lungs, watching a tiny butterfly land on one of the flowers in her bouquet, its white wings standing out against the violet petal.
"You don’t need to do anything." Morfeu stroked her hair, a sad smile touching his lips as he looked at the headstone.
"I wish… I wish Bonnie were here." She confessed, filled with sorrow.
Morfeu sighed, nodding slowly.
"So do I, love."
"I wish she hadn’t died." Scarlett watched the butterfly walk among the flowers. "If I die, will I find her on the other side?!"
Morfeu narrowed his eyes, crouching down with a breathy smile full of tenderness.
"Maybe yes… maybe no…" He tilted his head from side to side, weighing his answer. "Who knows?!"
"So… I… I’ll never… see her again?!" Scarlett half-closed her eyes, which moistened at the thought.
"You don’t need to see her… for her to be with you, my love."
"But I want to see Bonnie… I miss her… I…" Her brow furrowed, something strange slithering through her chest. "And I’ll never find her and…"
"You don’t know that, sweetheart." Morfeu interrupted gently, placing his hands on her shoulders.
"But you said…"
"I don’t know either, Scarly." Her father’s smile became pained. "Uncertainty is the only certainty we have in life. Except, of course, for death."
Scarlett followed the butterfly with her eyes, extending a finger towards it, feeling the tiny feet grip her fingertip as it landed right on her nail.
"I’m scared. I want… I want to die to see her again… but… I don’t want to leave you. I…"
"Are you afraid of death… or of being alone?" Morfeu brushed a few strands of her reddish-brown hair back behind her ear.
Scarlett let her gaze roam over her father’s face, settling on his green eyes, where blades of grass framed the scene reflected in his dark pupils. She didn’t know. Scarlett didn’t mind being alone, and ever since what happened to her sister, she’d often lose herself in her colourful world, listening to music on her Walkman.
"Of death." She confessed, studying the butterfly, which opened and closed its wings slightly, yet refused to take flight.
Morfeu slowly shook his head, placing his hand beneath hers, supporting it as the butterfly clung to Scarlett’s finger, unwilling to fly away.
"Death, Scarly… is what gives life its meaning… knowing your time is limited, fleeting. It’s death that gives value to our existence, whether short or long. The point is… it’s not longevity that matters, love. It’s the quality of the days you live. There’s no use living too long if you’re miserable." He kissed her forehead. "Besides… death is always lurking. If we show fear, it strikes faster than the darkness devours the light…" Morfeu’s thumb brushed the back of Scar’s hand, where the mark of the snake biting its own tail rested. The Ouroboros. "However… if we show no fear…"
Scarlett looked at her father, whose parted lips murmured words that were muffled by the brightness of the sun; she whispered something that was carried away by the wind. The bouquet fell onto the gravestone, the butterfly took off, and Scarlett reached for Morfeu’s robes as she felt terribly light, as though she were about to float away.
She tried to scream, fought to stay in that illusion a moment longer, but the wind carried her off, and the sun that had shone so brilliantly in that spring morning transformed into an irritatingly white light that burned her retinas.
"Daddy… no… please…" She mumbled sluggishly. Her lips felt clumsy, and she hissed as a sharp pain tugged at the tendons when she tried to move her fingers.
She blinked several times, cleared her throat until her eyes adjusted to the overwhelming whiteness of that place. It was maddening, even more so when a tall figure in navy-blue robes stood at the foot of the bed, just a hazy silhouette.
Scarlett wanted to rub her eyes, but couldn’t even lift her arms. Something was draining her strength, slowing her heartbeat, forcing her body to relax.
"Dad?" she repeated, trying to frown, but couldn’t feel her face.
"I’m afraid I’m not your dad, Miss Gaunt." The calm voice wasn’t unfamiliar to her.
Scarlett blinked a few more times, slowly, though she had the impression she was blinking far too quickly.
"Dumbledore?!" There was doubt in her voice, although the more she looked at the silhouette before her, the more certain she became that the man could only be the Headmaster of Hogwarts. There was something long and white across his chest that looked very much like a beard… or a rather flamboyant tie.
"Precisely, Miss Gaunt."
"Why… why are you…"
Scarlett didn’t understand. She tried to search her mind for the past events, the reason why she was there, bathing in the darkness of her own eyelids as she faced the ribbons of memory stretched out before her, swaying with the tide of her consciousness. But every time she tried to touch one, it simply dissolved, like paper submerged in water.
"Miss Gaunt… is it true you entered a place full of dark wizards?"
She wanted to laugh, but her mouth was sluggish, so all that escaped was a soft, amused snort. What was he talking about?
"Where is my dad?" Scar returned the question.
"Your father… just like your brother and your mother, has passed away, Miss Gaunt," Dumbledore said, his tone tinged with caution. "I’m terribly sorry."
Of course they were dead. Why had she thought otherwise? The dream with her father had felt so real. It wasn’t just a dream… it was a memory. And the feeling had been so vivid, because… because Morfeu had still been there. Alive. As alive as the memory itself. Thinking about it left a bitter taste in her mouth.
"I didn’t…" Her eyes grew even more clouded, and Dumbledore was now a watercolour of blue, yellow, white and silver until she squeezed the tears from her eyes.
"It’s normal to feel confused. You took quite a blow to the head."
Scarlett tried to feel for where she was hurt, but once again, her arms wouldn’t respond to her commands. Not fully. Her wrists throbbed.
"Sirius…"
"He’s alright… more or less," the Headmaster replied, pacing from one side of the room to the other as if weighing his words. "Miss Gaunt… you were in possession of some… documents… and a photograph…"
Suddenly, Scarlett’s mind was flooded with warped, high-pitched screams. A crowd shouting her name over and over. Begging her to kill. Booing. Roaring into chaos. The battle arena. Multicoloured spells flashing from the tip of Dimitri’s wand. The two of them grappling. Crimson sparks glowing on her skin. Her own scream. Dimitri begging her to stop. The ashes of her home. Sirius calling out to her.
Now, she remembered very well what had happened.
"Yes… yes…" Scar tried to force her memory further, but her heartbeat grew stronger, blood pulsing painfully through her brain. "I… I went… I went into this… invisible wall and… there was this room with… with…" She stammered, gasping. "Photos. I remember seeing… a picture of my mum. And… McKinnon?!"
"Could you give me that memory? It would be… very helpful… if I knew exactly what you saw."
Scarlett looked at Dumbledore again, as if trying to determine whether it really was him. A bit difficult, since the Headmaster’s face was just a blur. Still, she nodded. What else could she do? She was far too dazed to think clearly. She watched the dark wooden wand touch gently against her forehead as she focused on the memory, feeling a subtle breeze when a small light slid out of her mind.
Dumbledore moved one of his arms and the light refracted into a container. Probably a little vial. Hard to tell.
"Why… why can’t I…"
"Oh, don’t worry, Miss Gaunt. Your vision will return to normal soon enough," Dumbledore assured her, touching her foot. Scarlett wiggled her toes slowly, only now realising she still had legs. "It was very… reckless of you to do what you did… Scarlett." He allowed himself the liberty of using her first name. "However, I believe your actions may have saved Fabian Prewett and Alice Longbottom." He gave her heel a few reassuring pats, which made her process what he had said.
"They… were in… danger?!" Scarlett sighed, speaking slowly. Her tongue was sluggish.
"They likely wouldn’t be with us now if not for you." Dumbledore was probably smiling. Scarlett didn’t need to see clearly to know. "Your friends, however, were very worried. Especially Sirius."
The mention of Sirius’s name sent a wave of regret flooding through the sedation pulsing in her veins, a futile attempt to quicken her pulse. She truly wanted to feel awful, yearned for a shiver to run down her spine, but it was as though she were far too exhausted for that. So the feelings converged deep inside her, causing a pain that was nothing more than the sense that she’d done something wrong—without the energy to truly be affected by it.
"I know you’ve lost your family… but not all family has to be by blood. And I saw those boys welcome you in a way they’ve never done for anyone else. You are deeply loved, Scarlett, and I would like you not to put yourself in danger like this again."
Scarlett wanted to laugh. Who did that old man think he was to be saying such things to her?
"I’m not…" she began to say, but got lost in the thoughts that invaded her head like a swarm of bees, buzzing in her ears in an irritating hum. "I don’t… Sirius shouldn’t worry about me. I’m a burden to them. To all of them, really. Sirius should worry about himself… about… trying… trying to feel better and…"
Then guilt flooded her, scalding, hardening her muscles and dissolving her tendons until tears were once again forced from her eyes. Scarlett felt nauseous, the mattress seemed to be slowly swallowing her like she were sinking into a stormy sea. She had gone after Dimitri when Sirius was taking care of himself. He had been unwell because of her… because she had messed everything up.
"Don’t be so hard on yourself, Miss Gaunt," Dumbledore said gently, though she barely registered it.
"Dumbledore… could you… could you tell Sirius that I’m sorry? That… that I…"
"Why don’t you tell him yourself? He’s just outside the room and I’m certain he wouldn’t waste a single second being away if he knew you were awake," he replied with quiet insistence.
That only made Scarlett cry harder.
"I can’t… I can’t… you don’t understand. I don’t deserve it, I… he must’ve been worried about me this whole time and… I can’t face him… please…"
"What is it you believe you don’t deserve?" He didn’t move. Scarlett sobbed over and over before lifting her gaze towards him, towards the blue blur in her vision.
She opened and closed her mouth several times before managing a response.
"Sirius’s love." She sniffled.
"Do you love him, Miss Gaunt?" Dumbledore asked, after a long, silent pause.
"More than anything." She admitted, trembling.
"Then the two of you will be alright." He smiled, stepping back. "Love is powerful. It can hurt just as deeply as it can heal."
Scarlett turned her face to dry her tears on the bedsheet. Dumbledore didn’t understand what she meant, and it felt almost impossible to explain.
"I don’t think love can heal this, Professor. If there were something… it would be a spell… some kind of magic…" She lowered her gaze to the damp sheets that covered her.
Dumbledore turned back to her, as if studying her pain.
"And what is love, Miss Gaunt, if not magic?" he murmured, and Scarlett knew he was smiling again.
She had no answer for that. Not that Dumbledore gave her the time to find one, for she heard the door open and close, and then she was alone. She focused on steadying her breathing and holding back the tears. But it was a grating task, especially with the remorse trying to seize whatever was left inside her chest.
Scarlett had already lost too much. Her sister, her parents, and her brother; each one taking a piece of her with them as they left. And she didn’t want to become that hollow, lifeless shell she had been right after the tragedy, though it was incredibly hard to avoid when she heard Sirius’s heavy footsteps entering the room.
She couldn’t even look at him, her body tingling with shame, with regret. She pressed her lips into a thin line, trying to hold back the whimper that kept climbing up her throat, fighting to reach her vocal cords. She didn’t allow it. She squeezed her eyes shut before letting them wander around the room, stopping at the two figures beside her, feeling Sirius’s fingers carefully intertwining with hers.
"I’m… I’m… s-sorry…" was all she managed to say, stammering, her chest shaking with sobs. "Please, Sirius… I’m sorry…" Her expression twisted as she lost the strength to stifle her crying. "I’m sorry…"
Sirius pulled a handkerchief from his pocket, drying her tears with such piercing tenderness it almost felt cruel. Scarlett felt even worse, her face already aching and her throat raw.
"I don’t want to talk about this now, Scarlett." Sirius swallowed hard, stroking her hair. She blinked several times, forcing the tears out, trying to focus on his pale, rigid face. On his starry eyes. But all she could make out were the dark outlines of his hair, beard, and his diffused pale skin.
"Sirius… please…"
"We’ll talk about it at home, alright?" he said it so gently it was unnerving. Scarlett tried to hold his hand back, but she could barely move. "How are you feeling?"
"How… how are you feeling?!" she threw the question back at him, hearing him sigh.
He stayed quiet. It was as if he were holding himself back from saying something inappropriate, so silence was safer.
The door opened. Sirius and James turned to look.
"She’s awake? I need to run a few tests…" It was a female voice. "It’s best if you wait outside."
"Sirius…" Scarlett called again, trying to stop him from going. From leaving her alone. He looked at her. "I… I love you."
Sirius stood there for a few seconds before leaning down and pressing his face to her forehead, then kissing her and stroking her hair.
"I love you too, kitten," he whispered, voice tight and hoarse. "It’s going to be alright."
Scarlett nodded, the warmth of Sirius’s hand fading slowly from hers, his silhouette retreating until it disappeared. She wished she could undo what she’d done, turn back time and never have gone after Dimitri. She wanted to make him happy as much as he made her. To prioritise him as much as he prioritised her. She longed to heal him from all the wounds she never meant to cause. She knew these things took time, but she wished there were a magic word that could fix everything.
The idea that magic could fix everything was almost funny. Her shattered pieces, her mosaic, the man she loved. The death of her family. But it didn’t fix things, it wasn’t a silver bullet and it wasn’t immaculate. It was just another tool—words and lights, hisses and sparks. Much like love; it could mend things, but it could never be mended. In the end, Dumbledore had been right.
What is love, if not magic?
.
.
.
Scarlett’s vision gradually returned, and she was discharged on the third day. Her wrists were no longer as swollen, though still rather sore. She wasn’t allowed to lift anything or exert herself much; Sirius actively avoided looking her in the eye once they got home. Scarlett still couldn’t see sharply, but it was obvious how often he stared at the floor or pretended to be far too busy to glance at her.
James was there too. Not much had been said during her time in the hospital—Scarlett couldn’t go long without crying, and Sirius seemed just as lost as she was. She’d apologised multiple times, and her boyfriend’s response had been silence. And it hurt. Scarlett didn’t know what to do.
Especially after learning that she was being investigated for what had happened in the arena. Dimitri had been released a day later—most likely because his father had used all his influence to keep him out of prison, particularly given that he was a Soviet citizen and the British Ministry wouldn’t want to further strain ties with the Soviet Ministry. Either way, the investigation was underway, with both their names involved, along with a dozen others tied to the Dark Arts.
Her saving grace had been Thanatos and Dumbledore stepping in on her behalf. Without them, she’d probably already be locked up. She didn’t know the full details, but it was exactly like the summer before: her parents and uncle doing everything they could to cover up the incident involving her and Dimitri.
Scarlett felt like she was caught in a spiral. Except now, she’d lost her family.
As soon as she got home, the first thing she did was take a long shower. The hot water helped soothe the throbbing in her hands, brought out her bruises, and silenced the noise in her mind.
Washing her hair was agony, and she somewhat regretted turning down Sirius’s help, but she gritted her teeth through the pain and forced herself to step out of the shower, carefully feeling her way so she wouldn’t bump into anything. Her vision was still blurry at times, especially in the steam of the bathroom.
She dried herself carelessly, dressing while still damp. Her post-shower nemesis was brushing her hair: the mere thought of closing her fist around the handle of the brush felt like torture. She heard the bedroom door creak open but didn’t look back. She was too busy forcing herself to ignore the pain in her bones as she tried to grip the bloody brush.
"Let me do it," James whispered, taking the object from her hand with a firm grip. Scarlett stared at him through the vanity mirror, expecting it to be Sirius.
No.
Sirius was still avoiding her.
James Potter was tall and skinny like a stick. His dark brown hair was as messy as ever, and he pushed his glasses up the bridge of his nose before beginning to brush her strands with the utmost care. Scarlett didn’t take her eyes off him, watching the way the light danced across the transparent lenses and reflected on his pale skin, his hazel eyes turning amber.
Scarlett placed her feet on the stool and hugged her knees, the silence dancing stubbornly between them, refusing to leave. After a stretch of time that felt endless, James cleared his throat, drawing Scar’s gaze back to him.
"Scar… you can’t… do that sort of thing." He hesitated, not stopping the brushing. "We were really worried and…"
"I know I fucked up. I already apologised," Scarlett snapped, her voice sharp.
James sighed.
"Let me finish!" He set the brush aside. "We… it was a massive scare, what you did. Sirius was frantic, I was frantic, even Lily was! You can’t… you can’t expect us to just accept… whatever it was you thought you were doing! Going to Dimitri alone?! With half of You-Know-Who’s army after you?!"
"I already said I’m sorry!" Scarlett repeated, as if he were too thick to understand.
"That’s not the point!" James raised his voice for just a moment. She’d never seen him like that before—not with her. Only Sirius had ever heard that tone. "It’s not the first time you’ve done this!"
Scarlett shot to her feet, facing James with defiance, even though he was much taller than her.
"What do you mean by that, Potter?!" she spat, jaw clenched.
James didn’t flinch.
"That you’re reckless!" he snapped, his brows furrowed. "Last summer you went out on your own to get that Pink Floyd tape… and we came with you…"
"So you’re pissed because you weren’t invited?!" Scarlett laughed—a cruel, mocking sound. James frowned.
"That’s not… that’s not what I meant."
"Then what did you mean?" she hissed, voice cutting.
"I DON’T WANT TO LOSE YOU!" James clenched his fists, turning his face away just as his expression cracked with tears. "For fuck’s sake, Scar, you’re my best friend! I don’t want to lose you!"
Scarlett felt guilt punch her in the stomach. That feeling had starred in every one of her days at the hospital and now it returned full force, tightening her throat and speeding up her heartbeat. She sat back down on the stool, deflating, her wet hair clinging to her shoulders, dripping onto the floor.
"I’m sorry… I thought… I thought…" Scarlett tried to summon the events of when she’d found Dimitri again, but it was still a bit hazy. "That he knew something… something about what happened to my parents. I know it was stupid, but… I really…"
Scarlett fell silent as James pulled her into a tight hug, the scent of cinnamon leaving her dazed. She rested her face against her friend’s chest, who was kneeling in front of her, and cried quietly.
"Scar… you can’t keep doing this. You lost your family, but… you’re not alone. You’re my family too. You… Sirius… Remus and Peter… but we can’t look after you like this, constantly trying to stop you from getting yourself hurt! You’re an adult now and you need to act like one. We’re in the middle of a war! Do you understand what I’m saying?"
Scarlett, her cheeks flushed from shame and regret, only nodded. She couldn’t speak, her whole body beginning to sweat cold with the remorse of everything she’d done. Just imagining how James, how Sirius must have felt…
She felt like she might vomit.
James, however, after that paternal lecture, kissed her forehead, and for a brief instant, Scar allowed herself to imagine it was Morfeu doing it. It was fleeting and illusory, but it calmed her enough for the tears to stop.
"I’m sorry, Jamie," Scarlett murmured, head lowered, embarrassed.
"You don’t owe me the apology." He stepped back, as if it was painfully difficult for him to leave her like that.
"I know. I already said sorry to Sirius, but he…"
"How would you react if it were him in your place?" James cut her off, running his fingers through her hair, pinching her chin gently with his index finger to make her look at him.
"I… I don’t know, Jamie." Scarlett wiped her nose, grunting when she caught sight of her bruised wrist and scraped skin.
"You two are so… so alike," James admitted, exhaling sharply. "And at the same time, you’re both so afraid of each other it’s like you don’t even know one another. Like you’re not together. Like you don’t love each other. I don’t get it. Why didn’t you read the letter with him? Wasn’t that what you’d agreed to do?"
"Because…" Scarlett swallowed hard. "I didn’t want… I didn’t want to make it worse. He’s like this because of me, Jamie, because he saved me and…"
"Stop it, Scar," James said, with infuriating gentleness. "It wasn’t your fault. It wasn’t anyone’s fault. It was a tragedy. But… not telling him still hurt him just the same. You just left, walked away, and thought everything would be fine?! That we’d be okay with what you did?"
Scarlett flinched at the lecture, remembering Dimitri hitting her with the Cruciatus. She rested her face against James’s abdomen, shaking her head.
"I didn’t… I didn’t think…"
"Then start thinking, Scarlett, because if you keep this up, you’ll lose Sirius too!" James warned her, torn between comforting and scolding. "Don’t destroy yourself like this. Your family’s gone, but that doesn’t mean you have to throw your life away just to be closer to them."
James was right. But reason couldn’t reach her emotionally in that moment, so all Scarlett did was harden her expression and glare at her friend. Her chest burned, her eyes widened. Her entire body felt like it was simmering.
"Just… get out, James," she whispered through gritted teeth. "Get out!"
"I haven’t finished—"
"Fuck off!" Scarlett raised her voice, standing up again, straightening her posture as her face contorted and she pierced him with her stare. "I told you to get out!"
"Scar—"
"GET OUT! NOW!" She grabbed the brush and threatened to throw it at him. He backed away. "GET. THE FUCK. OUT OF MY ROOM!"
James looked at her with such pity that it made her feel even worse. She lowered the brush, hands shaking, breath ragged. He turned on his heel and did as he was told. The rage choked her breathing, and Scarlett screamed, slamming the brush into the door with a crash, digging her nails into her scalp as she collapsed to the floor, biting her thigh hard, trying to make the pain in her heart stop, trying to shift it somewhere else, trying to rid herself of that vile feeling.
She only stopped when she tasted iron in her mouth, her leg now bleeding heavily. She placed one hand over the bite and leaned her back against the bed, her gaze drifting to the ceiling, then to the window, landing on the sunbeams illuminating the floating dust in the room. Blood and saliva trickled from the corners of her mouth.
Scarlett reached for her wand atop the vanity, smearing its red handle with blood, pointing it at the wound, trying to focus on a healing spell, but all she could summon were hexes and curses, not magic meant to mend—so she gave up.
The bedroom door opened and she didn’t even flinch. It was as if she no longer had the strength. Sirius sat down in front of her, his gaze slippery and afraid. He drew his wand and pointed it at the bloody bite, but Scarlett pushed his hand away, refusing the help.
Sirius, however, didn’t relent, ignoring her stubbornness as he finally looked at her with those stormy, clouded irises. Scarlett shivered head to toe, her soul laid bare under his gaze—a mix of worry and anguish surging in those eyes so beautiful and so tormented.
"Scarlett… please… stop this," he pleaded, gently moving her hand away from the wound. With the other, he flicked his wand and healed the bite— the pain vanished, yet a lingering trail of self-punishment clung to Scarlett, as if she couldn’t help but punish herself.
"S-sorry…" she stammered, breaking into tears again, the blood on her cheeks mixing with her tears. "I’m sorry…"
Sirius wrapped his arms around her, letting her bury her face in his shoulder, seeking solace in his presence.
"Why did you do this?" he asked softly, though there were traces of sorrow and worry in his voice.
Scarlett clutched at his shirt tightly, ignoring the tremble in her hands, drowning in the piercing sense of safety and belonging that he gave her. It was so overwhelming she felt dizzy, drinking in his scent between sobs.
"My heart… it hurts so much… and I… I’m tired… of feeling pain…" she confessed in a broken whisper.
Sirius held her tighter, as if he could wring the suffering out of her. As if he could rid himself of his own. He kissed her hair and rested his chin on her forehead, letting her cry everything she had left in his arms with a patience she didn’t believe Sirius was capable of.
Then, he slid one arm beneath her legs and the other around her waist and lifted her into his arms, carrying her out of the room and into the sitting room where James was distractedly watching the telly, glancing at them from the corner of his eye without turning his head.
Sirius laid her on the sofa next to James, then headed straight for the kitchen. Scarlett simply curled into herself, matching his silence with her own. Sirius returned with a handkerchief and wiped the blood from her lips as he settled beside her. James stood and brought over a few potion vials, placing them in Scarlett’s lap.
"For the pain, and to help your body recover," he explained, pointing to each bottle. Scarlett looked at her friend, words caught in her throat.
She and James stared at each other for a long moment.
"Sorry I shouted," she said at last, drawing in a deep breath and surrendering.
She drank the potions and looked at Sirius, whose face was resting in the hand propped up against the back of the sofa. He pulled her closer, guiding her to lie down in his lap, stretching his legs across James. The telly was nothing more than a soft glow filtered through her weary eyes, and still Scarlett didn’t move, hearing Sirius and James both chuckle when one of the characters said something funny.
That wasn’t what she was paying attention to, though. Her nape prickled when Sirius’s ringed fingers traced a path through her hair that made her close her eyes and drift, as if her spirit had just left her body. She let herself be carried by the current of black hair and starry eyes, falling asleep on his lap just as he had done countless times in hers.
The pain in her chest lost its grip. It was still there, but it felt disarmed. It screamed and hissed, it threw brushes and tried to bite, but it could no longer do any damage. No more than had already been done.
Sirius Black could tame her demons with such ease that Scarlett felt captive to him—captive to his touch, captive to his love. It was so intense that it paralysed her, elevated her, intoxicated her. She was bewitched, numbed, and delirious. Sirius Black ran through her system with the same urgency as blood through her veins, as vital as the air in her lungs. Scarlett adored him, idolised him, loved him. He was a spotlight that left her blinded, bound, and utterly undone.
The worst part? She liked it. She gave in to that dependency, bathed in that crimson, hot, bubbling lake of love full of promises, expectations, and heartbreak. It was like dancing on the edge of a cliff, walking a tightrope between extremes, spinning on a thin sheet of ice.
She would fall eventually—she knew that—but she also knew Sirius would catch her… so everything was alright.
After all, what is love, if not magic?
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 26: I will be there at your side to remind you how I still love you
Chapter Text
XCIV
Scarlett had no idea how long she’d been asleep. All she knew was that, when she woke up, blinking lazily, the light from the television was the only thing illuminating the room. Half of her face was numb, resting on Sirius’ thigh, one of his hands tangled in her hair, the other resting on her back. He was snoring softly, legs propped up on the coffee table.
The truth was, she didn’t want to wake up. She couldn’t remember the last time she’d slept like that—feeling so peaceful… so safe. Like she wasn’t missing anything at all.
Then guilt struck her like lightning. Scarlett lost the breath in her lungs, her chest rising and falling too fast as the cracks in her heart threatened to deepen. Whoever said grief got easier with time was a bloody liar.
It only ever seemed to get worse. And it wasn’t exactly because she missed the people she loved—no, it was because the space their absence left behind kept expanding, and the moment she remembered to miss them, that space was instantly filled with guilt. The feeling stabbed through her chest with such force that Scarlett began to sob, gasping, rising to her feet with a hand over her heart, her whole body trembling.
“Scar?” Sirius’ groggy voice called out as he pulled her into a hug from behind, still half-asleep. “It’s alright, it’s alright, it’s alright…” he murmured, kissing her hair, as if he could chase away her anguish like he had done earlier.
As much as Scarlett wished he could, he couldn’t this time. She clung to his arms, rigid, her breathing shallow. She felt dizzy, disoriented—and her stomach burned as if it were trying to outmatch the pain tearing through her heart.
“I…” she murmured, trying to turn her face toward Sirius, searching for those silver eyes that always pulled her out of her own chaos, wanting to dive into that mercury sea and drown in his love.
But the moment their eyes met, Scarlett saw that Sirius was crying too. His heart bore cracks of its own. He felt pain, and absence, and grief. And it hurt even more to realise that he’d been suffering just as much, and she hadn’t seen it—too caught up in her own battles to notice him.
Fuck, she should be helping him too. But how could she, when she couldn’t even help herself?
Scarlett reached out, her hand trembling as she touched Sirius’ face, wiping away the warm tears. The silver in his gaze was tarnished with distress, with a guilt different to hers, but filled with torments just as deep—and in the blackness of his pupils, she saw her own reflection in the abyss.
The wall Sirius had so painstakingly built to keep the darkness in his chest at bay was starting to crumble—just like him. His breath came fast against Scarlett’s cheek, black strands of hair clinging to his jaw, wet lashes brushing against her forehead.
“Can you forgive me?” Scarlett asked softly.
“I don’t know if… if I’ve got the strength for that,” Sirius replied, his voice raw. “I… I’m fucking exhausted and… I don’t…” He panted, as though he were trying to choose his next words with care. Seeing him like that stirred shame in the whirlwind bubbling at Scarlett’s core. “I thought… I thought I was going to lose you.”
Scarlett closed her eyes as Sirius held the hand she still had pressed to his cheek. The skin was raw and tender, but the sting of his touch was nothing compared to the pain inside her. It wasn’t just grief. It wasn’t just anguish. Scarlett had never liked herself much and was always quick to self-flagellate, but in that moment, she hated herself more than she ever had before. She had never meant to make him suffer—and seeing the pain dancing in those silver eyes was suffocating.
She shifted in Sirius’ lap, turning to face him and wrapping her arms around him. Letting him bury his face in the curve of her neck and cry, letting his pain pour onto her until her own could blend with his—dissolve and be purged. And even though Scarlett had been the one to cause it this time—and even though it fucking hurt—she understood. She had felt the same when he hurt her days ago.
In the end, they were just two souls whose only home was each other’s heart. And that made it easier to wound one another—because they were no longer alone, and every action echoed through the other. It was the connection that hurt so much. The love, too. And it shouldn’t.
Love wasn’t supposed to hurt. It wasn’t meant to be selfish or hard, it wasn’t meant to shatter or exhaust or destroy. Love was meant to be understanding, balanced, sublime… gentle. It should be forgiving, effortless and willing; it should heal, not harm. It should be the light that banished the demons lurking in the darkest corners of their hearts—not feed them. Love should fill them with joy and hope for brighter days, should be the soft breeze of a summer’s night, the warm rain of dusk, the scarlet glow of dawn.
The love between Scarius was supposed to help them mend this pain, neutralise the sorrow, find in each other the strength they lacked.
Not… not make it worse.
Scarlett ran her fingers gently through Sirius’ hair, letting him release the weight he’d been carrying. In the beginning, he had cared for her with such devotion that she hadn’t known what to do with it. She’d never seen that side of Sirius before. And now, when it was her turn to give back, all she had offered him in return was despair, fear and turmoil.
And yet, Sirius was still there—seeking comfort in her. Hoping she could be his anchor, just as he had been hers. That Scarlett could be the water to extinguish the burning embers of his agony, of his helplessness, of his wounds. She tried to swallow back her tears, but it was impossible. The heart of the brightest star in the sky belonged to her—and all she had done with it was try to turn it into dust. Into a shooting star. A lost celestial body.
Scarlett took a deep breath and kissed Sirius’ hair, making herself a silent promise. She would never leave him again, never make him suffer. Her love would not be destructive, nor corrosive. It would be whole, light, and noble. Because that’s what Sirius deserved. A love without claws, without teeth or whips. A love that asked for nothing in return, a love that brought him calm instead of chaos.
“When I read the letter… I felt so much anger…” Scarlett confessed, her fingers combing through the soft black strands. Sirius held her so tightly she could no longer tell where her body ended and his began, nor where the heat between them originated—if it came from her or from Sirius, or if the moisture on her face and neck came from her tears, from his, or both. “I thought… I thought I could find something in it and… and get revenge… for what he did to me… for what he said… I was blinded. All I felt… all I breathed and heard… was hatred. It filled me with such intensity that…” Her lips trembled, her confession swallowed by her sobs, the hiccups cutting off her voice.
Sirius slowly raised his face, long curved lashes glistening, the tip of his nose red, his eyes glassy. He bit his lower lip, kissing a tear that slipped down Scarlett’s chin, resting his forehead against hers. His breath was warm, burning against the damp heat of their cheeks, their noses brushing.
He breathed in through his mouth.
“Love… you can’t let anger consume you like that,” he whispered, the words brushing her lips with how close their faces were. “More than anyone, I know what that’s like.” A faint, broken laugh twisted his features.
Sirius blinked, the silver in his eyes purified by silent tears. “And… I know it’s hard after everything that happened, but… you can’t think there aren’t consequences to what you did. You almost ended up in Azkaban and…” His bottom lip trembled. “Just the thought of losing you… it’s too much. Haven’t we suffered enough already?!” He sniffled. “Please… don’t do this anymore. Don’t leave me alone. I… I need you, Scarlett, and I know that’s not ideal, but… I love you so much and I can’t… I can’t bear to be without you. So please… please…” He shut his eyes, his expression crumpling into a sob. “I love you so much. Don’t leave me.”
Scarlett cupped his cheeks in her hands, her heart breaking at the sight of him crying because of her. The tears she had caused seeped through her fingers like tiny needles burrowing into her bloodstream, a sharp pain coursing through her whole body as though she’d been struck by the Cruciatus Curse all over again—her bones throbbing, tendons resonating, muscles seizing. Sirius was crying because of her. This time it wasn’t Regulus, it wasn’t Orion or Walburga—it was her. She’d hurt him, even though she never meant to. And she didn’t know how to fix it.
“I’m sorry,” she whispered, no longer knowing how many times she’d said those words. “I’m sorry, Sirius, I never meant to… please, I promise I’ll never do it again. I didn’t… I never wanted to hurt you or… or make you cry… I didn’t… I didn’t think—”
“Then think!” Sirius cut her off. “Because it’s not just about you anymore. It’s about us. You said that night I came back pissed that I didn’t live alone anymore. That I was selfish. But so are you. We’re alike. That’s why… that’s why we work. Because we… we understand each other. And I do understand, truly, what you felt when you read the letter. I felt it too. But… I need you to understand me too, Scar. I need your help. I can’t handle us on my own. I’ll always take care of you, but I… I need to be taken care of too.” He sobbed, and Scarlett gently wiped his tears away. “I can’t do this on my own.”
“You’re not alone, Sirius,” Scarlett murmured, her voice trembling with guilt. “I’m here.”
“I know.” He nuzzled his face along hers, resting it against her shoulder. Scarlett stroked his dark hair. “I know.”
“I love you too, and I don’t want to lose you… I never… I’m sorry. Please.” She inhaled the sweet scent of his hair, allowing herself to be consumed by the man who, in that moment, was nothing more than a frightened boy. “Will you let me take care of you?”
Sirius’ hands traced a tender path down her spine, his arms wrapping around her, his dark hair brushing her neck. He nodded, raising his head again to look at her. His eyes were puffy and glistening, free of resentment, though the silver still carried painful echoes.
“I forgive you… if you never do this again.” Though it sounded like a demand, his tone was a plea.
“I won’t ever do it again,” Scarlett replied sincerely. “Never. I promise.” She pressed her nose to his. “I’ll never leave you.”
She let her hand glide across Sirius’ chest until it rested over his heart, feeling its strong rhythm under her palm. As if that touch could mend the cracks in his heart, could heal him, could summon the love they shared—his for her, and hers for him. It was there, spiralling between them, fuelling the tears and the comfort, the fear and the certainty. Scarlett wished that her love could be enough to make Sirius feel safe, to make him feel cared for.
Locking eyes with her, Sirius gently took her bruised, sensitive wrist and mirrored her gesture, placing her hand over his chest, then laying his own hand atop hers. With his free hand, he echoed her movement, resting it over her heart. Feeling the frantic beating beneath his palm. Scarlett covered Sirius’ tattooed fingers with hers, allowing their hearts to fall in sync as they held each other’s gaze, letting their bodies resonate with everything they wanted to say but hadn’t, everything they longed to do but hadn’t done… with everything they promised and never fulfilled.
Sirius noticed how Scarlett’s blue eyes held soft traces of green near her dilated pupils. Scarlett noticed how the silver in Sirius’ irises turned to platinum under the white glow of the television, his black hair flowing over his face like a river of darkness, his lashes framing the glimmering greys of his gaze.
The heartbeats, the stares, the silence.
It was as if they were one.
Scarlett kissed him. The television flickered, its images dancing across Sirius’ pale skin as he pulled off his shirt, the whiteness of his torso stark against the dimness of the room. There was no urgency in that kiss, but there was intensity. It was Scarlett’s apology, unfolding from her tongue as she licked Sirius’ lips, asking for entry, nibbling until he parted them and joined her in the sinful dance.
Bracing her knees on the sofa, Scarlett pushed herself up to gain height, but Sirius slipped between her legs and pressed her back, laying her down on the cushions and covering her with his body. He resisted her attempt at control, reclaiming it without force, undressing her slowly, never breaking the kiss—drinking in her breath, her intentions, her rage and her guilt.
Sirius wanted to return Scarlett to herself, even if that meant stealing every foul feeling from her soul. And he did just that, stripping completely after her, their tongues no longer gentle but lustful, warmth turning to fire, the darkness igniting with want and wickedness. His favourite part of sex was always this—the fevered press of Scarlett’s body against his, skin on skin, heart to heart, surrender and dominance entwined.
He palmed her breasts, teased her hardened nipples, slid his fingers down to her heat. Breaking the kiss, he brushed his thumb across her spit-slick lower lip, pushing it into her mouth, pressing against her tongue as he entered her with his middle and ring fingers. Scarlett rolled her eyes back and moaned, sucking on his finger as her back arched. The wet heat from both ends of her body made Sirius so hard his cock throbbed with anticipation.
He traced his hand down her tense jaw, caressing the delicate skin of her neck, capturing her mouth with hunger as his fingers searched inside her for that spot he knew so well—deep within her slick walls—tongues tangling, pouring into her all the torment she’d made him feel.
Scarlett’s moans echoed in his mouth, pulling a sharp ache low in his belly. He toyed with her, pressing where she craved most, her moans rising into cries, her body writhing beneath his until he pulled his fingers out abruptly. She broke the kiss, eyes wide with confusion, a whimper slipping from her lips.
Sirius just smiled, adjusting himself between her trembling thighs, and entered her in one stroke. Scarlett tensed, arching with a sharp intake of breath that bloomed into a sound of pure pleasure. Sirius closed his eyes at the wet heat that surrounded him, her walls clenching so tightly it made his head spin.
He guided Scarlett’s hand to his chest, to his heart, placing his own over hers—their frantic, disoriented heartbeats intensifying a connection that was so much more than fleshly desire or raw emotion. It was the touch of souls, the unspoken promise, the absence and the grief, the guilt and the tears. Words soaked in love, the rage and the fury, the control and the yearning, the tension and the sense of belonging.
What bound them physically was tied to what chained them irrevocably.
It was Sirius Black’s way of saying he forgave her. That he was still hurt. That he loved her too. And that, even in pain, he would never leave her. That walking away was never an option. Their souls were already entwined by something far greater than anger, hatred, grief, or even love. It was all of that and more—it was every piece of them, every reflection in a cracked mirror, every shard of light and shadow they’d ever nurtured, now bearing fruit: bitter, sharp, sour… and sweet.
Sirius quickened his pace in a long, languid stroke, sliding deliciously into Scarlett, their bodies burning and trembling. Scarlett gasped into his lips, meeting his gaze with one of utter surrender. Sirius couldn’t help the possessive pang that coursed through him, swallowing her lust-laced moans in another kiss, telling her she was his, thrusting deeper, surrendering to the pleasure.
Sirius Black had never truly considered having a child—not now, not in the midst of a war, not when he hadn’t even finished school… but for some reason, in that moment of shared climax, he wished his seed would take root in Scarlett, the same way he wanted her to belong to him forever. That their love could take shape, become proof that fate had already written their path—and they had no choice but to follow it. Together.
It was a selfish, twisted thought—one Sirius quickly chased away as he watched Scarlett spasm with ecstasy beneath him, her tight cunt milking him, her body trembling around him. He relished the sensation of finishing inside her once again, the haze of knowing she loved him with equal fervour, and that all he truly wanted was to spend the rest of his life by her side.
Sirius smiled to himself as he watched her in the aftermath—flushed and warm in his arms, sweaty and breathless. Her hair clung to her face, her lips were swollen, her eyes unfocused, nostrils flared. Her chest rose and fell rapidly. Sirius slipped out of her and lay against her heart, listening to it race. He took her hand in his, eyes trailing over the marks on her skin, and kissed them with such tenderness that Scarlett glanced down at him, placing a kiss to his temple.
“If we shag like that every time we fight…” she murmured, drowsy, “maybe we should argue more often.”
Sirius shook his head, feeling Scarlett’s fingers trail down his bare back. He stretched his arm and brushed his fingertip over her face—tracing her soft brows, the damp cheekbones sticky with sweat and tears, following the line of her jaw until he reached her lips.
Scarlett smiled and bit the tip of his finger. Sirius made a face and pinched her cheeks until she grinned again.
“If we had a kid…” Sirius ran his fingers through Scarlett’s dark hair. “Could he be called Sirius Junior?”
She frowned, then pulled a face.
“No.” Scarlett sighed lazily, as though sex with Sirius were soporific. “You can have Sirius in the name, but no Junior.”
“But he can’t be just Sirius—I’m already Sirius,” he replied, rolling his eyes like it was obvious.
“Then give him another name too…” Scarlett shrugged, uninterested in the subject.
“But I want my name in his,” Sirius pouted, softening when she rewarded him with a long head-stroke.
“Then call him Sirius something… James Sirius… I don’t know,” Scarlett mumbled, yawning.
“I’m not naming my firstborn James!”
“What if it’s a girl?” she challenged, narrowing her eyes. “You gonna name her Sirius too?”
Sirius bit the inside of his cheek, thinking.
“Scarlett… Sirisa.” He chuckled at his own suggestion.
“Siri,” Scar burst into laughter, the sound vibrating through her ribcage.
“Siria.” Sirius rested his hand between her breasts and laid his chin there. “Scarlett Siria Black,” he declared, dead serious.
“No.” Scarlett rubbed her eyes. “Absolutely not.”
“It’s a great name! And it has yours in it!”
“Sirius… forget this idea of naming our firstborn after yourself.” Scarlett waved the air in front of her face like she could bat the thought away.
“I just think we should discuss the possibilities.”
“Possibilities?” She raised an eyebrow.
“Our future.” Sirius wet his lips. “I mean, we live together and…”
“Children?”
“That too.”
Sirius took the Ouroboros hand, gently stroking the etched scales, pulling a soft gasp from Scarlett.
“We haven’t even graduated yet… we’re not even married…”
“Yet,” Sirius cut in.
Scarlett mumbled something unintelligible, her pale cheeks gaining a flush of colour. The white light of the television danced over the freckles scattered across her nose, over her slightly arched brows, over her parted lips. She pressed them into a thin line, eyes studying Sirius’ expression. She wasn’t hesitant—just caught off guard.
“Is that a proposal?” she asked, clearing her throat.
“No.” Sirius smiled. “Not yet.”
Beneath his palm, Sirius felt Scarlett’s heart race violently.
“Should I be preparing myself?” she asked, swallowing hard.
“Maybe.” Sirius smirked, giving a shrug.
Scarlett let out a disbelieving laugh, shaking her head.
“Bloody tosser.” She tried to pull her hand free, but Sirius held onto it, eyeing the bruised skin over her protruding bones. He traced the raised veins with his fingers, stopping just before the swelling in her wrist.
“Does it hurt?” he asked, meeting her gaze again, watching the sharp movement of her throat as nerves took hold.
“A bit,” Scarlett admitted, lowering her eyes to the back of her hand. “Nothing I haven’t felt before.”
Sirius’ smile faded at her words, because he remembered—Scarlett had been a victim of the Cruciatus Curse. And suddenly, a weight settled in his chest. It was as if she knew exactly what he was thinking, because her gaze drifted away into the void before settling on the piano.
She hadn’t played it since they moved in. Not since her parents died. Of course he’d encouraged her to try again, but Scarlett had been resolute. Sirius had even found an old notebook of sheet music among her things and left it on the stand above the keys.
The static flicker of the television danced in her blue eyes, the black-and-white specks dripping down her pale face like raindrops. Scarlett was pulled inward, into her own mind—into days when it hadn’t been difficult to sit at the bench and let her fingers run across the keys. Into days when she didn’t feel so achingly hollow or unbearably overwhelmed.
Into the days when she played to escape what Dimitri had done to her. Now, reality felt so brutal that not even music could soothe the longing.
“Do you want to play?” Sirius asked softly, and Scarlett looked at him, uneasy.
“I… I don’t know…” She took a deep breath. “I don’t know if I can.” Her hands opened and closed, jaw clenched tight.
“Because of your hands?” he asked, holding her gaze.
“That too.” Her lips twisted, shoulders shrinking inwards.
“Do you want to try?” he offered gently, kissing her fingers. “I’ll help you.”
Scarlett smiled, nibbling her bottom lip in contemplation before nodding. Sirius let out a long groan as he pulled himself off her, stretching as he stood. His eyes traced every inch of Scarlett’s body, a wicked little smirk curling his lips at the sight of her—naked and relaxed on their sofa.
Their house.
Sirius felt his heart swell with tenderness, a warmth rushing through him that muddled his senses and deepened his grin.
“I’m dating the most beautiful woman in the world,” he said aloud, pulling on his pants and a pair of joggers.
Scarlett smiled, burying her face in the cushions bashfully.
“Shut up,” she mumbled, all coyness as she found his old Toto band tee buried in the folds of the sofa. “You’re the pretty one here.”
“I am pretty,” Sirius said, shaking his shoulders smugly. “We’re the most beautiful couple in the world.”
“Prettier than David and Angela Bowie?” Scarlett asked innocently, tapping her lower lip as if pondering the thought.
“Love… you outshine Angela,” Sirius ran a hand through his hair, cleaning between Scarlett’s legs with a non-verbal spell.
“And you outshine David,” she replied, slipping on his shirt and her knickers, exhaling deeply—prompting a sceptical glance from Sirius.
“Yeah, I think I’m better looking than him,” he said with such certainty that Scarlett made a disgusted noise. “You said it,” he added smugly.
Scarlett gave a small smile, which widened when he wrapped his arms around her from behind. Sirius kissed her cheek as he guided her toward the piano, stopping before it. He watched as she sat on the bench and lifted the lid, her gaze scanning the keys before glancing sideways at him.
“Don’t you want to sit?” she offered, shifting to make space beside her.
“No,” Sirius replied, resting his elbows gently on her shoulders and kissing the top of her head. He tugged the blackout curtain aside with a flourish, letting the dusky light of early evening pour through and flood the room. He squinted against the brightness, reached out, and opened the sheet music notebook, flipping through until he found a page that wasn’t too overtaken by mould.
Sirius had no idea how to read music, but Scarlett was already placing her foot on the pedal and her fingers on the keys as though it were second nature. Still, she didn’t press down.
Sirius gently pressed one of her fingers, pushing it purposefully into a key.
The hammer struck the strings, the note vibrating through Scarlett’s entire body, making her flinch and sending goosebumps rippling across her skin.
Scarlett wavered, as if she’d been holding her breath for far too long; memories, sounds, and sensations overtaking her mind in a rush. A warm ache blossomed in her chest—full of thorns and sharp roots—and yet, though it stung, it made her smile. It was like pouring water into the fractures of her soul: it burned, and it soothed.
Sirius buried his nose in Scarlett’s hair and followed her lead as she played the opening notes of the song, still hesitant. But he could feel the intention in her fingers beneath his, breaking through the uncertainty by gently pressing her down into the keys, urging her on—until she snapped the bonds of loss and let her hands relax, her fingers gliding over the ivory as she repeated the notes until they rang with conviction. Sirius kept his palms resting lightly atop hers as Scarlett wove the cascading introduction.
[Music: Queen — Love Of My Life]
It felt strange to hear the trembling arpeggios drifting so melancholically through the room—it was as if she hadn’t touched the instrument in ages. And at the same time, as if she’d never stopped. Her eyes searched for Sirius’, and he was focused intently on the melody, as if trying to memorise every moment, following the fluid movements of her hands. His firm chest pressed against her back, heart beating with steady calm.
“Love of my life… you’ve hurt me…” Sirius sang softly, their eyes meeting—and the rest of the world faded to nothing, swallowed by the blue-rimmed depth of Scarlett’s irises.
You’ve broken my heart, and now you leave me
Love of my life, can’t you see?
Bring it back, bring it back, don’t take it away from me
Because you don’t know what it means to me…
The full moon bathed the top of the West Tower, its light glinting off the slick stone floor. Harry tugged at Sirius’ arm, trying to get him to climb onto the hippogriff, but he couldn’t move.
Regulus emerged from the staircase, his grey-blue eyes widening the moment he saw him. The boy dashed toward Sirius, throwing himself into his arms. With his heart in his throat and tears in his eyes, Sirius clutched Reggie tightly. His black hair still fell in soft waves, and his pointed nose was freckled just as Sirius remembered, though now Regulus stood nearly his height.
“Sirius,” he murmured through tears. “It’s really you.”
“It’s me,” Sirius confirmed, kissing his forehead again and again. “It’s me, son.”
“I knew you were innocent,” Reggie wept. “I knew it, I knew it.”
Sirius gave a pained smile, reaching out to pull Harry into the embrace. The boy, confused and awkward, tensed but didn’t pull away. He accepted Sirius’ kisses atop his head and remained still as a statue.
As if he didn’t know what affection was.
“My two boys,” he whispered, wiping at his tears. “I missed you both so much. You look so much like him, Harry.” His voice cracked. Then he turned to Reggie. “And you… you look just like your mother.”
Love of my life, don't leave me
You’ve taken my love, you now desert me
Love of my life, can't you see?
Bring it back, bring it back, don't take it away from me
Because you don't know what it means to me…
Regulus looked at him with a mix of embarrassment and awe, and Sirius glanced between the two. His heart was tugged again—Scarlett stood at the top of the stairs, hands in the pockets of her coat, brown hair swaying gently in the wind’s caress, a sorrowful smile on her lips. She was crying too.
He gestured for her to join them.
Scarlett shook her head.
“Please,” he mouthed.
She licked her lips, wiped her tears, hesitated… but eventually relented, approaching them slowly, embracing them with uncertainty. Sirius and Regulus, however, pulled her into the hug with such force she had no choice but to give in just as fiercely.
“I got him,” Scarlett murmured, clearing her throat. “Peter. He’s with Dumbledore.”
Sirius felt his knees go weak.
“What? You…”
“You’re going to be free, Sirius.” She looked him dead in the eye, that unmistakable resolve colouring the blue of her gaze.
“And we’re going to be a family.” He said it with such conviction that Scarlett felt a shiver deep in her belly—but she didn’t contradict him.
Harry, whose eyes had grown twice their size upon seeing Scarlett, seemed utterly bewildered, completely unaware of the cold breeze brushing the back of his neck, or the strange, gentle breath that whispered soft, loving words by his ear.
You will remember when this is blown over
And everything’s all by the way
When I grow older, I will be there at your side
To remind you how I still love you…
“You… you’re the mum…”
“She is my mum,” Regulus interrupted gently. “She’s alive.”
Scarlett blinked a few times before meeting Harry’s gaze directly, nodding as she ran her hand through his messy hair—just like James’.
“You’re the spitting image of your dad, Harry.” She smiled. “But the eyes…”
“Exactly like Lily’s,” Sirius finished, and Harry lowered his head, cheeks turning pink.
“You need to go.” Hermione was wringing her hands anxiously. “The Dementors…”
The mention of the non-beings caused the embrace to dissolve gradually. Sirius stepped back, still reeling, still processing that Peter had been captured—by Scarlett.
He opened his mouth to speak, but then closed it again. Every word spinning through his mind suddenly felt meaningless.
“Sirius…” Harry gave him a nudge toward the hippogriff, who was too busy pawing at the stone floor to care, while Hermione held tightly to its lead.
Sirius just nodded, mounting Buckbeak as though he’d done it all his life. He turned to Scarlett, his long black hair tumbling over his shoulders in a glossy cascade, glinting under the silver light of the moon.
“You coming, kitten?”
The nickname sent a tingle down her spine—a sensation she hadn’t felt in so long, she couldn’t even remember its name. Her arms were still around Regulus and Harry. The former clung to her so tightly she doubted she could’ve broken free on her own. The latter tensed slightly, a pensive look crossing his face, as if only now fully grasping that Scarlett had been the one to catch Peter.
“I’m coming,” Scarlett said, locking eyes with her son. His gaze lifted to hers, flickering “I love you too, son,” she said softly, kissing his forehead before inhaling the scent of his messy hair and letting him go. Regulus held onto her hand until the last possible moment, the contact breaking reluctantly.
“We’ll see each other again,” Sirius said with certainty. “You are — truly your father’s son, Harry… and you, Reg… you’re every inch your mother’s.”
The hippogriff didn’t so much as flinch at Scarlett’s presence. With Sirius’ help, she climbed onto its back, the stormy grey crest gleaming beneath the moonlight, its fiery orange eyes fixed on her. Buckbeak raised his massive wings as Sirius gripped his flanks, and they soared into the sky.
Back, hurry back, please bring it back home to me
Because you don’t know what it means to me
Love of my life
Love of my life…
Scarlett clung to Sirius, the two of them looking down as the night wind bit at their cheeks and sent their hair flying. Below, Harry, Reggie, Hermione and Victoria shrank into faint specks against the vast silhouette of Hogwarts as Buckbeak climbed higher.
It was quiet up there—so quiet Scarlett feared Sirius could hear the hammering of her heart. But he was looking up, not down—towards the stars. His beard stirred with the wind, the angles of his face sharpened by thinness, and those two silver pools of his eyes drifted back to her, as if he knew he was being watched.
Scarlett met his gaze with equal intensity, her entire body buzzing beneath the burn of his stare.
“You came back,” he said softly, the wind carrying the words like whispers. But she didn’t need to hear them. She knew exactly what he said.
“Of course I came back,” Scarlett smiled awkwardly. “I always wanted to be back…”
Sirius’ pale lips twisted into something bitter.
“But that day… you didn’t come back.”
Scarlett took a deep breath, hugging Sirius tighter. She wasn’t afraid of falling—but pretended she was, just so she wouldn’t have to admit how much she liked resting her chin on his shoulder, how much she liked being so close she could watch his Adam’s apple bob when he swallowed.
“I tried…” Scarlett confessed.
Sirius said nothing. He only looked ahead, eyes fixed on the moon hurtling towards them. Scarlett shut her eyes, burying her face into his coat.
“Sirius…” she said quietly. He glanced at her out of the corner of his eye. “Do you think you’ll ever forgive me? For everything I did?”
His face shifted into that arrogant mask she knew so well—a shield, nothing more—but he narrowed his eyes, nostrils flaring slightly, lips twitching as though he both wanted and feared to give her an answer.
“I don’t know,” he whispered, brushing aside the strands of hair that floated across her face. “What happened to you?”
The change of subject was a blessing. Scarlett’s heart was hammering so hard she thought it might crack her ribs. She both dreaded and longed for his answer. If he forgave her, then maybe…
No. Scarlett blew out the little spark of hope that tried to ignite in her chest, shifting her gaze to Regulus flying below them on his ghostly broom, chatting with James and Lily about the meeting of their sons. She dug her nails into Sirius’ coat, aching to tell him the truth even though she knew she couldn’t.
“Long story,” she exhaled, the breath leaving her lungs like a weight falling from her shoulders. “How was your little trip to the Whomping Willow with Moony and Snivellus?!”
Sirius smiled again, and the flutter in her stomach came back full force.
“Harry hit Snape with a Stunner so strong he went flying onto the bed in the Shrieking Shack…”
Sirius’ laugh was contagious, and it crept its way into Scarlett’s chest until she couldn’t hold it back.
“What?!” she laughed nasally, then quickly forced a serious expression.
Sirius didn’t take his eyes off her.
“You can smile, Scar. No Dementors around…”
Scarlett looked away, embarrassed. Why the hell was she feeling that way around Sirius?
“I just…” she clenched her jaw, trying to grasp the words that so easily slipped from her. “Harry’s very much his mother’s son, too…”
Sirius nodded, watching the hippogriff’s wings glide on an air current. He hadn’t fully processed everything—it still felt like a dream. He was terrified he’d wake up and find it all a delusion from some corner of his Azkaban-shattered mind.
“What the hell is Dumbledore thinking, hiring Snape?” he asked, his voice cutting through the wind’s howl.
“No idea. Doesn’t make any sense…” Scarlett shrugged as Sirius tugged gently at Buckbeak’s reins.
“I spent over ten years locked up, and he still looks like a bloody virgin…”
“You think he’s still a virgin?” Scarlett jumped into the conversation, relieved by the shift in tone.
“Absolutely,” Sirius said with conviction. “What woman in her right mind… I mean, the man doesn’t even look like he bathes.”
“Snivellus being Snivellus…” Scarlett muttered with distaste. It was almost impressive how slating Snape could unite even the bitterest enemies.
The moon was swallowed by the clouds, vanishing like a snuffed-out lamp, plunging them into dense darkness. Buckbeak flapped harder, climbing higher, and Sirius lowered his gaze when a faint spark caught his eye—coming from Scarlett’s hand.
“What’s that?” he asked, taking hold of her fingers, brushing over the ring whose gem now cast a glow to the left.
Scarlett leaned behind him, peeking over his shoulder.
“Oh… it’s the ring Dumbledore gave me,” she replied, not quite noticing how close their faces were now, side by side. “He said it would guide us somewhere safe…”
Sirius nudged Buckbeak gently to the left, adjusting their course until the ring’s glow pointed straight ahead.
“So… Peter…” he continued, not letting go of her hand as his other gripped the hippogriff’s feathered back.
“I found him in the Forbidden Forest. When you and Moony were… well…”
“You used the map?” Sirius noticed just how near she was—but made no move to draw back.
“Yes. It was in Remus’ office. Wormtail… he was just standing in a clearing. I think he was hiding from the Dementors. I went after him… and… Reg was there too. He… he used the Patronus and drove them away…”
Scarlett couldn’t see Sirius’ face in the dark, but she could feel the bitterness creeping into his silence—the shadow of nearly being taken by the Dementors.
“I nearly died,” he admitted, taking a deep breath. “I was nearly Kissed.”
“What?!” Her heart skipped more than a beat at the thought.
“Someone… someone saved us,” Sirius stammered. “I saw… I saw him, Scar.”
Scarlett remembered the duplicate names on the map, and Lily’s explanation of the event unfolding in the forest.
“Who?”
“Prongs,” Sirius whispered, breathless. “I saw him. The Patronus… it was his…”
Scarlett wanted to cry, but didn’t. It was too tragic—too surreal. The Marauders had reunited that night, in a phenomenon that might never happen again. James was dead. Peter was on his way to Azkaban. And Sirius…
“You’re going to be free,” she said, pride colouring her voice.
“We’re going to be a family.” Sirius said it with such certainty that it ached.
“Why do you keep including me in that?” Scarlett asked softly. “I’m not innocent… and officially, I’m dead and…”
“Dumbledore will sort it,” Sirius interrupted, firm. “He always does.”
Scarlett was momentarily lost for words at the naïveté in his voice.
“He didn’t sort you, did he?!” she snapped. “If it hadn’t been for me… you never would’ve had a chance to prove your innocence…”
Sirius’ shoulders tensed, his jaw clenched tight.
“If it hadn’t been for you, none of this would’ve happened. Because you would’ve been the Secret Keeper…” Sirius snapped, voice sharp as a whip. “James and Lily…”
He didn’t finish the sentence.
The wind blew between them—cold and dry. Scarlett didn’t think she deserved soft words spoken under starlight, but she didn’t want Sirius’ harshness either. She wasn’t ready to expect anything gentler from him. All she’d known in the years she'd been locked away was agony, fear, and pain—and the threat of feeling something else, something unfamiliar, of hurting him again… that terrified her.
In the end, that was what she did—hurt Sirius again and again. And for some reason, he still chose to torture himself by staying close.
“He looks a lot like me,” Sirius said through a strained breath. “Reggie… he’s taller than Regulus ever was.” He tightened his grip on Scarlett’s hand, trying to force her to look at him. “Scarlett. Look at me.” It wasn’t a request.
Scarlett tensed all over. It took every ounce of willpower to turn her gaze toward Sirius, feeling her soul laid bare beneath those star-forged eyes.
“Is Reggie mine?”
Red raised his head at once. So did James and Lily. The three of them watched the moment unfold, tension thick in the air like storm clouds.
Scarlett loosened her grip on Sirius’ coat, tried to pull away—but where could she go? Buckbeak tilted downward again, gliding, and she had no choice but to be pierced by those steel-grey irises. A shaky breath escaped Sirius’ throat, tremulous with dread.
“Yes,” Scarlett wanted to say. “Reggie is yours. That’s why I couldn’t come back. I had to protect him. I had to protect you.”
But the vow she made was stronger than her will.
“No.” Her lips formed the lie coldly. The magic allowed nothing else. “He’s not yours.”
Sirius stayed still, as if trying to rip the truth from her anyway—but it was as though she’d just punched the air out of his lungs. The hope that had been quietly growing in his chest was snuffed out in an instant.
He turned his face forward, jaw tight, his profile like a statue—silent, unreadable. Scarlett saw the faint shimmer of tears on his cheeks, flickering like the stars above.
But Sirius remained motionless; as though his soul had just slipped out of his body. As though a Dementor had kissed him after all.
Scarlett wanted to cry—but nothing came. Maybe it was better that way. If Sirius ever knew the truth… he’d fight for it, no matter what. But if he believed Reggie was Red’s son, it would be easier for him to hate her. To reject her. To be disgusted by her.
She had already accepted that she didn’t deserve Sirius Black.
They were both fire.
They had burned before.
And they would burn again.
And Scarlett swore, with every breath in her, she would never hurt him again.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 27: I'm not leaving you
Chapter Text
XCV
Regulus Black had always been the spare. To his parents, to Sirius, to Scarlett. He was repeatedly the second choice. Invariably replaced. Eternally alone. He spent three years with Scarlett in that hell, only to have James and Lily with him now—only to lose Scarlett once again to his brother.
He knew it was only a matter of time before the two of them got back together. They’d always been far too dependent on one another, always fire burning everything and everyone in their path. They turned his life to ashes. First, Sirius ran away from Grimmauld Place, dumped the weight of the Black House on his shoulders, and took Scarlett for himself. Then, she came looking for him and, by helping her...
He ended up dead.
That was why, when James and Lily joined Sirius, Scarlett, Reggie, and Harry in that embrace, he stayed behind. He was never part of it, even though he was the registered father of Reg. His fate was, incessantly, the one thing he feared the most: being alone.
It was... strange. Regulus truly wanted Sirius and Scarlett to be happy. But then, why did seeing them like that hurt so much? It couldn’t be that... that he really...
He was dead. He shouldn’t be feeling these things. He shouldn’t be feeling anything. But the pain in his chest was overwhelming, suffocating, and excruciating. He placed a hand over his heart, gasping for breath, filling his lungs with air that didn’t even exist. He lowered his head and watched as his lurid tears fell from his face and vanished before they could touch the grass.
When Regulus was alive, he had been a master at masking his emotions. As if flicking a switch on and off, he could pretend not to feel, hide what he did feel, mimic what he was supposed to feel. He prided himself on it—it was how he’d survived the hostile world of pure-bloods. It was what made his mother kiss his cheeks and fill his ears with praise. Walburga had even hugged him—something she didn’t do with their father.
It should’ve been easier to control his emotions after death. It was the opposite, because now he was invisible even to Scarlett. She only had eyes for Sirius. She always had—she chased him like a flower seeks the sun. James and Lily were busy with their own thoughts about their son... and he...
He was alone once again.
His mind drifted to Pandora, and his tears intensified. He so badly wanted to tell Scarlett what had happened to her, but...
He deserved this. Deserved her hatred, her scolding. Truth be told, sometimes Regulus just wanted to disappear. He longed for his eternal rest without Scarlett or Sirius. Just the quiet darkness and endless nothing. But Regulus was paying for his sins from when he was alive and, by Merlin, he just wanted it to end.
This was far worse than Azkaban. A disturbed Scarlett with missing memories he could handle, but her and Sirius together… it was too much.
The two of them together were too much.
Regulus wanted to be with them. He wanted to have been part of their lives—not the way things had turned out, but the right way. Yet Regulus knew Sirius would never give Scarlett up, and he was far too selfish to hand her over to his brother, so everything would go wrong… again.
It was his fate, to ruin everything between his best friend and his brother. If he couldn’t be happy, then neither would they.
He wiped his tears away angrily, trying to banish those thoughts, but the emotions were volatile, lashing at his chest relentlessly. He held his breath as he felt a touch on his shoulder. He was a ghost, barely aware of his own existence, but he could clearly feel the sensation on his shoulder, as if a gentle weight, lacking warmth or substance, was pressing down on his scapula.
Regulus glanced back out of the corner of his eye to see the harmonious face of Lily Evans, her pale green eyes fixed on him with a knowing expression that seemed to understand every wrong he’d ever committed. He shuddered at the thought she might know his crimes. His stomach burned, and he forced himself to swallow the sob building in his throat.
"Why are you crying?" she asked, sitting beside him on the tree trunk.
Sirius and Scarlett had just landed with the hippogriff, following the glow of the ring guiding them through the forest, trying to get the creature to follow them, though it now seemed wary.
"I think he’s hungry," James said to Scarlett, who repeated it to Sirius. His brother huffed, transformed into Padfoot, and began sniffing the air, hunting for prey for the hippogriff.
Regulus didn’t take his eyes off Lily, nor did he hide his discomfort. In another life, she could have easily been in Slytherin. She wasn’t just clever—she was incredibly perceptive. He couldn’t slip up around her, not with so much at stake.
"Why didn’t you join us when we hugged Reggie and Harry?" she asked, resting her elbows on her knees. The wind caught her red hair, brushing it against Regulus’s shoulder. He turned his face forward, licking his lips.
"Because I…" Regulus paused, afraid Lily would see straight through the lie. "I don’t know him."
Lily raised an eyebrow.
"I don’t know Harry either, and yet—"
"It’s different," Regulus cut her off. "I died before he was even born. I never knew him."
With a melancholy smile, Lily ran her fingers through his hair in a maternal gesture.
"Still… he’s your son."
He’s not my son, Red wanted to say. He clenched his jaw.
"It doesn’t matter. I’m dead. I never…" His lips trembled. "I never imagined I’d have a family. And when Scarlett," he gasped, "told me she was pregnant… I had never wanted something so badly… someone… to love me… to…"
Someone who would never leave me, he thought, not daring to say it out loud.
"Did she love you?" Lily narrowed her eyes, brows drawing together.
Regulus wanted so badly to say yes.
"No." He confessed, dropping his gaze to the grass, speckled with dew. "Scarlett’s heart… only ever had room for Sirius." He didn’t hide the bitterness in his voice, his lips pressing into a tight line.
Lily flared her nostrils slightly, not looking away, her fingers threading through his dark, wavy hair.
"Why, Regulus? Why did you do that to Sirius?"
With his jaw clenched like a vice, Red stared at Lily. The steel in his eyes burned with anger.
"I didn’t do anything to him. It was Scarlett who came after me," he spat. "Thinking she could save me, that I’d turn my back on the Dark Lord just because she asked me to. And then," he filtered his next words with great care. Lily was far too perceptive for his liking. "I needed her cooperation because of Orfy. Voldemort… he had hostages from every Death Eater’s family."
"Then why didn’t he use Orfy before to recruit her?"
Regulus’s shoulders dropped at the question.
"Technically, almost no one knew he was alive, because he was a test subject. The Death Eaters were all too curious about understanding the Signets. I," he cleared his throat, "found out by accident that he was still alive. When Scarlett came looking for me that summer… Voldemort used Orfy to force her into obedience." He sighed, exhausted. "And then she got pregnant and… honestly, it was a stroke of luck she did, because the Dark Lord was desperate to have a child with a Signet."
Regulus didn’t hide the disgust on his face, nor did Lily.
"Because of that, Scarlett was forced to take a pregnancy acceleration potion. I came up with a plan to escape and promised I’d protect her. I saved Orfy, handed him over to Thanatos, set it up so the blame would fall on the Selwyns. Voldemort summoned the Death Eaters and demanded a house-elf. I lent him Kreacher. The rest of the story you already know." He ran a hand through his hair in frustration. "The moment I died, I was pulled back, the same way you and James were. To Scarlett, crying and bleeding. I thought she was going to die too. She wanted to die. But she can’t die. And I thought the baby wouldn’t survive because she was bleeding so much and used the multi-portkey to go to Sirius. So I ended up accepting that the child," he exhaled sharply, "was gone. But when I heard the cry…"
Regulus shrugged, apathetic. Was it that he didn’t love Reggie because he was Sirius’s son? Or perhaps because he had been given his name, and Regulus felt somehow unworthy of the tribute. Scarlett shouldn’t have named him after him.
Lily furrowed her brow, encouraging him to go on.
"I didn’t feel it. I couldn’t feel… that… thing… James always talks about, from when Harry was born. I was happy, yes, because he was alive. I cried because I was dead… but… I don’t… I don’t know if I love him, Lily." He didn’t stop the tears from returning. "The truth is… I don’t know what love is. Scarlett tried to show me, yes, but she never… loved me."
Lily gave him a pitying look and Regulus flinched.
"Of course she loved you. Maybe not in the way you wanted… I remember how she used to talk about the things you did together at Hogwarts. With nostalgia… and guilt. She blamed herself for you becoming a Death Eater."
Regulus didn’t want to be affected by the revelation, but it was impossible to stop the stab in his chest. He took a deep breath, swallowing down the chaos rising in his throat.
"What I mean is," he began again, in a calmer, more controlled tone, "how could I love Reggie… if I don’t know what love is? What am I supposed to feel? How am I supposed to act? What should I say? My father… never even looked at me. He only had eyes for Sirius. My mother… I think she loved me, but… it was a distant kind of love. Cold. Pretentious. I wasn’t her son, I was her little trophy. She didn’t love me for who I was, she loved what I represented. The Most Noble House of Black. The purest blood among the Sacred Twenty-Eight. I don’t think anyone ever loved me. And I don’t think I’ve ever loved anyone, either."
Lily pursed her lips, a hundred thoughts flickering through her green-flecked irises. There was a moment of complete silence before she broke it with a gentle smile.
"Love is spontaneous, Regulus." Lily said it with such tenderness, and touched his face with such softness, that he felt fragile. "It has no shackles, no rules, no concern for blood purity. It comes of its own accord… and leaves the same way. We don’t control it, though it can be nurtured with gestures and words, promises and intentions… and then one day, it might simply grow tired and die. Disappear. Leave behind a painful emptiness in your chest. But that’s the beauty of love…" She offered a kind smile, and Red felt one corner of his mouth twitch upward in spite of himself. "You’re constantly regulating your feelings… smothering them while pretending to feel what you think you should. Your heart is hollow. Superficial… and nothing can grow in soil that shallow, that barren. You are inhospitable."
"That’s not true." Regulus let the smile that insisted on curving his lips dissolve. "There was one constant feeling in my life, rooted deep in my core." He cleared his throat, not stepping out of Lily’s reach. "Anger."
She tilted her head to the side, her smile fading.
"Really? I never saw you explode. Sirius, on the other hand, exploded all the time. And you… you just bottled it up, didn’t you? Bottled it and bottled it and bottled it… I wonder if there was ever a moment when those emotions boiled over." Though she spoke in a speculative tone, Lily knew full well it had happened. She just didn’t know when.
To Regulus, feeling vulnerable was so unnatural that he thought he must be ill, even in death. Despite all his tactics to divert Lily’s attention to other subjects, she always managed to trap him with his own words, making him feel like nothing more than a naïve boy speaking with a grown woman.
"There was," he finally admitted, not hiding the regret in his voice. "Twice."
Lily narrowed her gaze at him, taking his chin in her hand.
"Was one of them with Scar?"
Regulus froze like a statue, swallowing the lump in his throat, his eyes widening. He went pale, his bottom lip trembling.
"Both."
Lily’s brows drew together, sharp.
"Did you hurt her?"
His heart felt like it was trying to punch its way out of his chest. Regulus shut his eyes and pressed his mouth into a line, nodding. Tears carved an acidic path down his cheeks.
"I did," he whispered.
Lily remained still, her hand on his chin growing clammy.
"It’s ironic, hurting the only person you love," she murmured, harshly, though there was no judgement in her voice.
"I don’t know… how to love…" Regulus gasped. "Scarlett was the only person who…"
He gave up trying to continue, tearing himself from Lily’s grip with a sudden movement and burying his face in his hands, shrugging again, this time with less strength.
"… who didn’t give up on me. And all I gave her in return was…" Regulus let out a bitter smile. "hurting her."
Lily swallowed hard, rubbing his back hesitantly.
"What did you do, Regulus?"
He bit his lips, ripping at the dry skin as if that would stop him from speaking.
"I could’ve let her go. But… I didn’t." Regulus twisted his expression, holding back the torrent of emotion rising in his chest. "I was afraid. I didn’t want… I didn’t want to be alone."
"And then Orfy would’ve been used to lure her anyway."
"But Scar would’ve been free… she would’ve gone back to Sirius…" He looked around, as if afraid someone else might overhear. "And you’d all still be alive."
"Or we could have chosen Sirius as the Secret Keeper. Or Voldemort might have gone after another child and we’d have been safe. Or I might not have gotten pregnant… if, if, if… sitting here speculating won’t get us anywhere, Regulus. What’s done is done and it’s too late for regrets."
"Things weren’t supposed to end like this!" Regulus raised his voice, gesturing violently. "I didn’t… I wasn’t supposed to die… not with… with so much…"
"That’s exactly why you died. You carved out bits of yourself just to survive your family. That’s why you can’t love." Lily scoffed. "Living your whole life trying not to feel anything… what a bloody waste."
Regulus narrowed his eyes, outraged by the insolence in her tone. Who did this mudblood think she was? He clenched his fists and filled his lungs with air, ready to spit out a hundred insults at her, but Lily smiled, as if she’d been expecting just that. Regulus released all the air at once and deflated, burying his face between his knees.
"I’m dead… it doesn’t matter anymore." His voice came out muffled.
Lily clicked her tongue in disdain.
"Of course it matters. You were already dead long before you actually died, Red. And now… now you’ve got a chance to let yourself feel. To learn how to stop repressing, to let feelings bloom in your chest with intensity, with thorns, with poison. With lightness. With screams and sweet words, with excruciating silences and icy tears." She traced her hand along his coat, placing it over his chest. Regulus, though trying to control his expression, couldn’t hide the erratic beating of his heart. "Let them summon the selfish Regulus, the fearful Regulus, the one who felt anger, the one who sacrificed himself to try and defeat Voldemort, the one who tried every possible way to survive and forgot to live. The Regulus who wants to love, who loves Scarlett and hates Sirius. Who hates Scarlett and loves Sirius. Who doesn’t know what love is. Who wants to find out how he feels about his son. We’re dead, Regulus, but our emotions are still vivid."
Regulus rolled his eyes at all that nonsense.
"I can’t," he muttered through gritted teeth.
"Why not?"
"Because I don’t know how to do it any other way."
"No one was born walking. You learn. And James and I are here to teach you." She said it in such a maternal tone that Regulus felt compelled to accept it.
"I’m not… I’m not worth it, Lily." He shook his head.
"Scar saw something in you, and I trust her judgement."
"You shouldn’t." He swallowed hard. "I’m not… a good person."
"You can be one now."
"Lily… I’m far from deserving redemption."
"That’s the whole point of redemption, Red. No one ever truly deserves it. Besides… you sacrificed yourself to save the people you loved."
"I didn’t sacrifice myself to save anyone." Regulus corrected her with disdain. "I died because I was stupid."
"You could’ve sent Kreacher to call Scarlett… or your mother. Even Sirius, to come save you. But you didn’t… because they would’ve become targets." She stood up and clasped her hands behind her back, turning to the side. "But facing Voldemort like that, alone? That was very brave of you. There’s a bit of Gryffindor in you, after all."
Regulus laughed bitterly, surprised at how foreign the sound felt. It had been a long time since he’d felt his vocal cords vibrate like that.
"There’s nothing Gryffindor about me, Evans," he replied, offended. "I’m not stupid, much less reckless."
"You just said you died because you were stupid, so your argument is invalid." Lily gave a teasing little smile and pinched his nose.
"Sweet Salazar, you’re insufferable." Regulus turned his face away with a huff of laughter.
"Sirius used to say the same thing." She boasted, ruffling his hair like she did with Harry. "You spend too much time dwelling on what happened. And I know you’re not telling me everything. But sooner or later… you’ll have to thaw that block of ice you’ve got in place of a heart."
His expression hardened once more, the iron in his eyes turning blank and narrowed. Lily only said those things to comfort him—Regulus was the only one who saw his true self. A boy without a heart, completely miserable. It was easy to lie to himself when he was alone—that his life had meant something, that Scarlett had loved him, that Reggie was his son… that his existence had any weight.
In the end, Regulus was nothing more than another puppet for his parents, an empty shell, a corpse. Lily was right about him—Red had been dead long before he actually died. He was nothing but a shadow, a flicker, a silhouette of Sirius.
And it was strange, wanting to become what he had always hated.
.
.
.
With Buckbeak properly fed, Scarlett and Sirius continued through the forest, guided by the ring, in an incorrigible silence. It was nearing dawn when they stopped in front of a small stone cottage; the door wasn’t even large enough for a human to pass through without crawling, and the chimney was puffing out smoke, signalling someone was inside.
The ring went dark. Scarlett and Sirius exchanged glances, each waiting for the other to take the lead. It was Buckbeak who acted, knocking his beak quite forcefully against a tiny hidden window, making Scarlett straighten up and Sirius widen his eyes.
Before they could stop him, the little hatch opened and a house-elf appeared, wearing a miniature top hat and an extremely long tea towel. Her bat-like ears twitched and her large, glimmering blue eyes wobbled slightly, as if she were seeing a ghost.
“M-m-m-m-m-miss G-Gaunt?!” she squeaked, her voice shrill. Then she looked at Sirius. “Master Black…”
“Penny,” Sirius greeted her with a small nod, pulling Buckbeak’s lead to stop him from hammering the window.
Scarlett took a deep breath, pressing her lips into a thin line.
“Hello, Penny,” Scarlett offered her a friendly smile, surprised. “What are you…”
“I mean, Mistress Black,” the elf corrected herself with a cough, adjusting her makeshift tea-towel dress. “They told Penny… well… Penny didn’t know…”
“Dumbledore… sent us here.” Scarlett showed her the ring. The elf peered at the stone, placing a finger on her prominent chin as she examined it. “He said… the ring would lead us to somewhere safe.”
“Penny was informed of Master Black’s arrival, but not of Mistress as well…” She eyed Buckbeak suspiciously, whose amber eyes were curiously studying Penny.
“Wait a second… I bought you…” Sirius stepped in front of the hippogriff, blocking his view of her. “So that means…”
“My little Master Black freed Penny,” she replied with lofty pride.
Sirius narrowed his gaze, hands on his hips.
“Reggie freed you?!” He didn’t hide the disbelief in his voice.
“Precisely.” She scratched her chin again, glancing at Scarlett. “Penny has orders to take Master Black to my little master’s house, but there is nothing… for Mistress.” The house-elf rested her gaze on Scarlett. “I don’t know…”
“She’s coming with me.” Sirius cut in sharply.
“Penny does not know if Master Lupin would approve of that,” the elf said coolly, unbothered by Sirius’s mood.
Scarlett wrapped her arms around herself. It wasn’t from the cold.
My uncle hates you, Regulus’s voice echoed in her mind. She hadn’t been feeling so drained thanks to the adrenaline still pumping through her from the escape, but now it was as if her body suddenly remembered the dementor attack, and her mind spun, causing her to stagger.
She barely noticed she was leaning against Buckbeak’s satin feathers, who rubbed his head against her shoulder, asking for affection. Scarlett blinked a few times, regaining her balance. Sirius looked at her with concern before turning back to the elf.
"Remus doesn’t have to like it. We’re responsible for your master!" Sirius huffed, impatient. "Penny… please." He set aside his pride, bending to her level. "I need your help."
Penny narrowed her eyes at Sirius, crossing her disproportionately large arms. Scarlett still didn’t quite understand—what did he mean, Sirius bought her? When had that happened? She remembered the elf had been purchased by the Potters to help Euphemia and Fleamont with the household and with the Order of the Phoenix.
Then Scarlett took a step back as her heart skipped a beat and Buckbeak pulled away, sniffing the wind that rustled through the leaves.
Euphemia and Fleamont.
Scarlett scanned the forest for the pale, glimmering figure of James, but he was darting joyfully between the trees in his stag form. She’d ask him later.
"Very well. Penny will help you. Will speak with the young Master Black… to make sure that… his mother…" She shot Scarlett a sharp glance. "has permission to stay in his house."
"Ridiculous," Sirius rolled his eyes. "Of course she does."
"Penny must remind you that Mistress Black is a traitor." She stared at Sirius. "She killed the McKinnons… became one of them… the deaths of Order members…"
"I know!" Sirius raised his voice. "But you don’t know the full story—"
"Sirius…" Scarlett placed a trembling hand on his shoulder. "It’s all right. I can… I can go to Orfy…"
"Penny does not believe Master Gaunt would want to see you," the elf murmured regretfully.
Scarlett felt her heart pierced by something razor-sharp, blood spilling through her chest, seeping into her organs, choking her voice.
"What? Why?" It was Sirius who asked, stunned.
"Master Gaunt believes that… that Mistress Black caused him great suffering." Penny lowered her gaze.
Buckbeak nuzzled Scarlett’s hair with his beak, but she didn’t move. Tears burned at her eyes, but Scarlett didn’t want to cry. Not in front of Sirius. She didn’t want to feel sad. She didn’t want to feel anything at all. Her whole body trembled from the pain in her chest, but she didn’t cry.
"But I… I never…" Scarlett stammered, confused. "I didn’t…"
"It’s all right… it’s all right… we’ll sort this out…" Sirius whispered, meaning to embrace her, but Scarlett pulled away.
"Just go with Penny, Sirius." She curled in on herself. "You need to… stay safe… until Peter…"
"I’m not leaving you!" Sirius cut her off, gripping her hand.
Scarlett’s pulse was so frantic she barely heard him, dizzy from the flood of sensations blooming in her chest. Remus hated her, Orfy thought she had made him suffer.
"I shouldn’t have run. I didn’t…"
"Stop!" Sirius yanked her close with roughness. "Would you rather have been tortured to death?" He was breathing heavily, gripping her chin and forcing her to look at him.
Scarlett didn’t want to look at him, didn’t want to drown in those silver eyes, because she knew if she did, she’d give in. Sirius could be awfully persuasive when he wanted to be, and Scarlett was far too tired to resist him.
"That’s what I deserved," she whispered, indifferent.
"No." Sirius replied firmly, wrapping his arms around her. "You’ve already suffered enough."
Scarlett disagreed, but didn’t say so. She was too busy burying her face into Sirius’s chest, breathing in his sweet, nonexistent scent, her fingers digging into his worn-out coat. The way Sirius wove his fingers through her hair calmed the searing emotions inside her, dulling their edge, allowing her heart to beat without feeling like it was being shoved through a meat grinder.
"Let’s go home, yeah?" Sirius held her tighter, pulling her back from her own private chaos. She only nodded, slowly.
"Penny…"
The house-elf looked anything but pleased, but she grabbed hold of all of them—including the hippogriff—and the whole world spun. When they reappeared in the garden of the house that had once been theirs, Scarlett brought a hand to her mouth.
She hadn’t Apparated in fifteen years; she didn’t even remember what it felt like. If there had been anything in her stomach, she would’ve been sick. But the nausea faded the moment she looked to the side, to the rays of sunlight plunging into the pool, turning its surface into liquid gold. Scarlett raised a hand to shield her eyes, listening to the gentle lap of water against the edges, the song of birds, the fresh scent of morning dew.
Her eyes scanned the whole perimeter, echoes of memories reverberating at the back of her mind, threatening to surge forward, but Scarlett pushed them away as she took a deep breath and stared at the house.
Penny was talking to Sirius, but Scarlett wasn’t listening. Her legs moved on their own, heart pounding so wildly she thought it might burst. She slowly opened the back door leading into the sitting room, her muscles tensing at a smell she couldn’t quite place—something long-forgotten that made the hairs on her neck stand on end.
It was all so familiar. Some of the furniture was different, a few things had been moved around, but the house was still the same. So much had happened, more than ten years had gone by…
Everything felt just as it had before, and Scarlett clenched her jaw. Sunlight poured in through the floor-to-ceiling windows, gleaming off the leather sofa, the television screen, the marble mantelpiece. The dusty cover draped over the piano.
Scarlett quickened her pace, the air leaving her lungs and refusing to return. She touched the dark fabric and gently pulled it back, revealing the perfectly polished instrument, just as she had left it. She brushed her fingers over the Steinway & Sons logo and ran her hand along the lid, hesitating.
It was the exact same piano. As though no time had passed, as though she was still the Scarlett who had just left Hogwarts, the Scarlett who loved Sirius, who loved her friends, whose only real worry was not to be swallowed by depression.
It had seemed so impossible back then, and now, so simple. She ran her fingertips along the varnished wood, her gaze drifting to the ghosts of James, Lily, and Regulus as they wandered through the house with the same curiosity she felt.
"I remember this day," James smiled, leaning in to study one of the photos on the mantel. "It was when Reggie took his first step."
Scarlett didn’t move. The house was still the same, but many details were missing or had been replaced. Just like her. She wrapped her arms around herself, gazing out the window beside her.
Summer was still two months away, but the children were already on holiday. Some were riding their bikes down the quiet street, others playing football or laughing together. Scarlett stepped closer to the glass, still with her arms folded.
The world hadn’t stopped while she was imprisoned, and Scarlett felt a pang of envy toward those children. That innocence, that time, the laughter and the carefree life. She didn’t remember her own childhood very clearly, but she believed it had been a happy one. She knew she had loved her family, though there were many details she could no longer recall.
She remembered Orfy, though. The two of them dancing at Christmas. Scarlett’s gaze instinctively swept across the room, as if trying to picture it with a decorated tree and a space much larger than it now seemed, even though she knew that Christmas had been celebrated in the house that burned down.
Remus and Orfeu were the only people she had left besides Sirius… and they hated her. Scarlett thought she might cry at the thought again, but she was tired of hating herself. The attack from the Dementors was beginning to take its toll, weighing down her vision and numbing her senses.
She licked her lips. Her mouth was dry.
She walked into the kitchen, opening cupboards and looking for a glass. It was in the same place as always—on the highest shelf. Scarlett stretched as far as she could, but it wasn’t enough to reach it.
A tattooed arm crossed her view, passed her hand, and took the glass. She had barely noticed Sirius standing behind her, glancing sideways at him. His expression was serious, though there was kindness in his gesture.
"Thanks," she murmured. The glass was cold against her fingers.
Sirius didn’t reply. He simply opened the other cupboard doors as if searching for something. Then his chapped lips stretched into a smile when he pulled out a basket full of Honeydukes sweets.
"I knew he still kept this here…" He placed the basket on the table, grabbing a box of Exploding Bonbons. "You were attacked by Dementors too, weren’t you?"
Scarlett nodded, though the sour taste coating her mouth wasn’t from the attack. She picked up one of the bonbons and bit into it, feeling the sugar explode on her tongue, numbing her taste buds. She closed her eyes, sitting down as she savoured the sensation, and reached for another.
"Feeling better?" There was a stubborn smile on Sirius’s face. His eyes, however, were barbed. As if he were trying to live in the moment but couldn’t quite let go of the past.
"I think so." Scarlett shifted her focus to the wrapper, crumpling the foil between her fingers.
Penny entered the kitchen too, eyeing the pair of them with indignation.
"Chocolate at six in the morning?!" she grumbled, snapping her fingers. A frying pan appeared on the stove, and she opened the fridge, humming softly to herself.
"I didn’t realise chocolate had a schedule," Sirius sighed, licking his fingers.
"You need proper nourishment!" the elf raised a finger, not even looking at them. "You look like two corpses in wigs!"
Scarlett, mid-sip of water, choked. Sirius let out a snort of laughter, glancing over at her, and the joy that flickered across his face was so genuine that she found herself coughing and laughing too. She couldn’t remember the last time she felt such a spontaneous burst of joy, ignoring the voices screaming at her to stop smiling.
As if there were Dementors nearby.
There was something far more dangerous than them in that kitchen, however.
Sirius Black, looking at her like they were eighteen again with an entire life ahead of them. Scarlett shivered, her smile faltering, her gaze trying to pull away—but it felt impossible. He had always been her weakness, her anchor, her safe place. And as much as she wanted to deny those feelings and push away all the tenderness and love she still held for him, she knew she couldn’t.
He had always been stronger than her. It was as if Scarlett were just a passenger on life’s road, never truly in control of the wheel. Sirius had always been her inevitable stop, even when she wished he were the last one. But that wasn’t fair—neither to him nor to herself. Scarlett was a pariah with no future. Sirius would probably be exonerated.
And she, once again, would end up behind bars.
The thought sent a chill crawling across her skin.
"You’re going to hurt yourself doing that," Sirius said quietly.
Scarlett hadn’t even realised she was rubbing the Signet so hard, her hands tucked beneath the table as she abruptly stopped. Sirius looked over at Penny, who had just served up two plates of eggs and bacon, placing them neatly on the table. Scarlett hadn’t even registered the mouth-watering scent, but the moment her eyes landed on the food, her stomach growled and her mouth watered.
The buttery aroma flooded her mind and she devoured everything ravenously, closing her eyes with every bite of crispy bacon. Sirius seemed just as focused on his breakfast, not saying a word.
Penny watched them with pride.
"Penny will prepare a bath for Mistress Black…" she announced. "Penny cannot bear the stench of hippogriff… and foot odour."
Scarlett blinked a few times to make sure she’d heard that correctly, glancing at Sirius as he disguised a laugh with a cough.
"Can you believe this elf?" he said after chewing.
It was hard to stop the faint blush rising in her cheeks, harder still to stay silent. Sirius clearly noticed the flush on her face, because his grin widened, dimples showing faintly beneath his gaunt cheeks. They were subtle now from the weight loss, but still… still there.
"She called me a wig-wearing corpse and smelly… in under ten minutes," Scarlett said with a small smile, grabbing another Exploding Bonbon.
"And you’re not even that bad…" Sirius rolled his eyes mischievously.
Scarlett raised an eyebrow before kicking his shin. He jolted, knees knocking the table and making the cutlery clink.
"You’ve got no room to talk, Jim Morrison post-drugs!" she huffed, folding her arms.
Sirius tried to stay serious, but the corners of his mouth had already begun to curl. Scarlett stared him down, her lips stretched in a smile teetering on the edge of a laugh.
"Do you mean Jim before or after he died?" Sirius raised his eyebrows, amusement dancing in the silver of his gaze.
Scarlett pressed her lips together, holding back her laugh.
"After," she admitted, bursting into giggles.
Sirius hadn’t planned on going with her, but the two of them were already laughing again—a happiness that had nothing to do with the jokes about their appearances or the absurdity of everything that had happened. It was the butterflies-in-the-stomach feeling of the unknown, of the future, of whatever threads fate had spun for them; whether the coarse strings were nearing their end and the delicate ones just beginning.
He shook his head and placed a hand on his chest dramatically, as though his ego had been bruised.
"At least I don’t stink."
"That’s because you’ve grown used to your own stink," Scarlett replied, flashing her most innocent smile.
The silver in Sirius’s eyes hardened into mischief.
"And to yours as well. It was almost strange being in the Shrieking Shack without you there…" he continued, but then fell silent, suddenly aware of what he was saying. As if it were something wrong, he watched Scarlett’s reaction closely.
A long silence followed, and their eyes remained locked.
"What now, Sirius?" Scarlett asked, curling in slightly.
"I know as much as you do," he admitted, taking a deep breath.
Scarlett nodded, unsure what to do. Or what to say. Thankfully, Penny reappeared, her arms wet and covered in soapy bubbles.
"Shall we?" The question came out more like an order.
With one last look at Sirius, Scarlett followed the elf from the kitchen into the corridor of bedrooms, her heart pounding as she took in the sight of the closed doors. Had Remus kept everything the same?
She stopped in front of the room that had once belonged to her and Sirius. She couldn’t step over the threshold, as though the doorway had been cursed. Penny looked at her with suspicion and mild confusion, as though expecting Scarlett to reveal herself as a Death Eater at any moment.
Ignoring the emotions bubbling in her chest, Scarlett stepped into the room, her gaze sweeping across the bed, where a leather jacket lay atop the blanket beside a pair of aviator sunglasses. She wanted to soften her expression when a chill raced down her spine at the memory of Sirius in that jacket and those glasses—but she blew the thought away.
It was impossible to ignore the dresser in the corner. Her eyes flitted quickly over the photos, her heart thudding painfully against her ribs as she realised not a single one featured her.
"Mistress Black, if you would kindly remove your garments," Penny said in an offhand tone, now standing beside the bath.
Scarlett obeyed, unbuttoning her coat and letting it fall to the floor, staring down at the tub filled with foam and bath salts that gave off a sweet, pleasant scent.
She didn’t want to look at herself in the mirror, but it was impossible to avoid. The woman staring back at her looked uncannily like her and yet disturbingly different. Perhaps it was in the eyes. Or maybe it was the visible anorexia. She could still recognise herself in the eyes—but not in the appearance.
When she began to pull up her shirt and felt the scars beneath her fingers, Scarlett froze. She traced the path of one of them, feeling them spread across her back like lightning slicing through the sky. Her breakfast twisted in her stomach at the memory of being seared by the Cruciatus Curse. She hesitated.
Penny continued examining her with severe scrutiny, watching her body from head to toe.
Scarlett cleared her throat.
"Could you… turn around?" she asked, forcing a polite tone, which only made her voice come out shrill.
"Penny cannot," the elf replied condescendingly.
"Please?" Scarlett insisted, her voice trembling with hints of vulnerability.
"What is Mistress Black hiding?" Penny narrowed her eyes, stepping closer.
"Nothing! And stop calling me Mistress Black…" Scarlett stepped back, positioning herself on the edge of the tub. "I don’t…"
Penny grabbed the hem of her shirt and yanked it upwards. A wave of desperation surged in Scarlett’s chest as she clutched the fabric, preventing her.
"No, Penny, stop!" she all but begged, her voice cracking as the air caught in her throat. She didn’t want to feel more exposed than she already did. She didn’t want Penny, or anyone, to see her body like that. "Penny, stop!"
"Penny does not trust Mistress. Penny does not trust Death Eaters!" The elf was unmoved, and the two of them locked into a tug-of-war.
"No! I’m not… I’m not one of them anymore… I…" Scarlett tried to fight back, but it was hard. The words slipped away before she could find them, her hands trembling as she dug her nails into the shirt. "Stop!"
"What the bloody hell is going on here?!" Sirius appeared in the doorway, his confused expression quickly replaced by fury at the sight of Penny tugging at Scarlett’s shirt.
"Penny knew Mistress Black was hiding something…" the elf panted, as though exerting great effort.
"I’m not!" Scarlett managed to say between sobs, hugging herself in a desperate attempt at protection.
"Penny, get out… now!" Sirius commanded, his voice vibrating with rage.
"Penny cannot. Penny only answers to young Master Black. Besides, Mistress Black is already endangering the safety of the house… I cannot allow her to hurt anyone…"
"She won’t!" he shouted, slamming his hand against the marble countertop with a crack. "I told you to get out!"
Penny wrinkled her nose and pressed her lips together. Swallowing her sobs, Scarlett pulled off her shirt, now completely naked, her eyes fixed on the white bathroom tiles, her entire body trembling.
"Happy now?" she asked softly, her breathing turning into silent weeping.
The elf looked somewhat disappointed and surprised. She had clearly expected Scarlett to be hiding something.
"Very well, Mistress Black." She cast a shamefaced glance at Sirius before leaving them alone.
Sirius took a step toward her, but Scarlett flinched. He turned his face away, as though trying not to look at her while still wanting to offer some kind of comfort.
Scarlett felt like a statue. Her muscles were as hard as stone, though her heart was pounding so violently it felt ready to burst. A headache began to throb behind her eyes, and her hands gripped her shoulders in a futile effort to cover her breasts.
"C-could you… could you p-please… l-leave me alone?" she stammered, her voice no more than a breath, eyes brimming with fear and shame.
Sirius looked at her for just a second before casting his gaze back down at the floor, his heartbeat slipping out of rhythm. The way Scarlett’s face contorted—how she pressed her lips together and wrinkled her nose—transformed the familiar closeness he once felt beside her into something unrecognisable.
He knew that pleading, skittish look in her eyes, but he didn’t know what caused it now. He also knew Scarlett’s body like the back of his hand… yet now, the years they’d spent apart seemed to have split a fault line between them. Sirius had no idea what she was thinking. Her blue eyes had turned to such ice that he could neither break through them nor soften them.
"I can’t… leave you like this." He made no effort to hide the worry in his voice, and the more he looked at her, the more it felt like those eyes were skinning his heart raw.
"Please…" Scarlett mouthed the word silently, tears slipping down her cheeks and splashing onto the floor.
All Sirius wanted was to hold her—even after everything she’d done to him. He knew he was the only one who could give her the sense of safety she so desperately sought, because she was his safe place, too. But all he saw in Scarlett’s eyes was apprehension and shame.
It hurt to realise that maybe Scarlett didn’t see him the same way he saw her. It was agonising to step back, to yield, to avert his eyes. He paused in the doorway, standing in profile, not daring to look at her.
"If you need anything… just call me," he said, forcing a reassuring smile before leaving her.
Scarlett turned to face the mirror, her back now reflected, her eyes fixed on the reddened appearance of her scars. A wave of disgust surged through her—disgust at herself, fury and bitterness for everything she had been forced to endure. She stepped into the hot water, wishing it could heal not only the wounds etched into her skin, but also the ones festering deep within her soul. She longed for her tears to cleanse more than the grime beneath her fingernails—she wanted them to wash away all the rot buried in the darkest corners of her being.
It was exhausting to rid herself of it all—Azkaban had left marks that would remain with her for the rest of her life, just like the war. And now that she was free, she had no idea what came next. Not that she had really thought about it before… but it was tiring, endlessly tiring, to fight just to find her place in a world that seemed determined to rip her apart.
And worst of all, Sirius still insisted on being there. Cursing her with his kindness, torturing her with his gentleness, twisting her up inside with his tenderness.
Penny was right. Scarlett shouldn’t have come with him. She should have… she should have…
She took a deep breath and slid beneath the surface, watching the air bubbles rise slowly to the top, the foam swirling, and the sunlight from the window rippling along the water’s surface.
Scarlett closed her eyes and prayed the future might be generous and warm. Even though she knew she didn’t deserve it. Even though she knew she would ruin everything in the end… all she wanted was to be happy. That’s what everyone wants, in the end. Happiness.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 28: I don’t know how to touch you any other way
Chapter Text
XCVI
Scarlett had been soaking in the bath so long her fingers had wrinkled and her skin was saturated with the sweet scent of bath salts. She blew on the foam, watching it float down until it landed on the floor, then pulled some back to her chest, lathering it into her hair.
“Knock knock”
She heard a voice from the other side of the door.
“Come in…” she sighed, turning her gaze as James’s ghost drifted through the door, his eyes squeezed shut, cracking one open cautiously.
“What was that earlier? I saw Sirius having a proper go at Penny…” He summoned a ghostly little stool and sat on it, resting his elbows on the edge of the tub. “Never thought I’d see her back off like that either.”
Scarlett just shrugged, saying nothing.
“She said you were hiding something.” James went on, nudging his glasses up the bridge of his nose with his pinkie. “What happened?”
Scarlett pressed her lips together, moistening them as she mulled over what to say.
“She just freaked out… nutty elf…” she muttered, pretending to be far too engrossed in the bubbles to meet her friend’s gaze.
“Hm… right…” James grunted, clearly unconvinced.
“Can I ask you something?” Scarlett’s voice wavered across the tiled walls of the bathroom.
James scooped up some of her bubbles, forming a ghostly handful of foam, tossing it in the air and watching it drift upwards.
“Go on.”
“What happened to your parents?”
James kept his eyes on the air above, though he no longer saw the present. The foam shimmered in the lenses of his glasses as it fell slowly, memories gleaming in his retinas. His eyes brimmed with tears. Slowly, he lowered his head, hazel irises still lost in days when Fleamont and Euphemia were alive, when life was rosy and war was only a distant threat.
He didn’t move his head, only cast a sidelong glance at Scarlett. The curiosity on his face had vanished without a trace, replaced by a grief nothing in this world could mend—a grief Scarlett knew all too well.
The grief of losing your parents.
James removed his glasses, wiping his tears with the palm of his hand. He gave a small smile, filled with nostalgia and sorrow.
“Dragon Pox…” he murmured, shoulders tensing as if the weight of the world had just landed on them. “Not long after I married Lily…”
Scarlett felt her throat tighten, swallowing thickly as she cried along with him. She knew exactly what James was feeling, and it hurt even more knowing there was nothing she could do to make it better.
“I’m really sorry, Jamie. Truly.” Scarlett’s hand passed straight through James’s in a failed attempt to comfort him.
“I get it now, the things you used to say. About… about never really getting over it. About… never being the same again. And about how the pain…” He drew in a breath, placing a hand over his chest. “Bloody hell, I’m dead and it still hurts!”
Scarlett sniffled in agreement.
“Not even death can cure the ache of missing someone…” she whispered, hugging her knees. “Did you find them? When… when you died?”
James shook his head.
“I just… as soon as I died… everything went dark and… I woke up in Azkaban.” He pressed his lips together. “Same thing happened to Lily and Regulus.”
“But Lily… didn’t she die after you? Why did it take her so long to… show up?”
James scratched his chin.
“I know as much as you do. The ones running the group are her and Red…” He shrugged. Though his voice was slightly nasal, there was no trace of tears on his face. The cheer he’d shown earlier, however, had not returned. “Scar… are you going to stay with Sirius?”
Scarlett wanted to play dumb, pretend she didn’t understand the question, but James was staring right at her and it was far too difficult to lie to him.
“What do you mean stay with Sirius?!”
“You know… you, him, Harry, Reg…” James folded his arms on the edge of the tub and rested his chin on his hands. “Like… like a family.”
Scarlett shuddered at the suggestion. She’d barely come to terms with the fact she had a son—let alone one not even fifteen years old—never mind another child and… Sirius at her side. It was a recipe for disaster. They’d already gone wrong once without kids, the thought of it with...
She didn’t know what to say, so all she did was slip beneath the water to buy herself time to think. It was still warm and pleasant—probably Penny’s doing—but there wasn’t much oxygen, and she couldn’t hide for long.
It wasn’t really up to her, anyway. Sirius’s innocence and her sentence in Azkaban were completely different matters.
She resurfaced with her eyes closed, breathing in deeply as she pushed the wet strands of hair from her face. James hadn’t moved, his messy hair rippling in the water’s reflection.
“I don’t know,” she said honestly. “I know I’m not going back to Azkaban… never again. I’d rather die.”
“Stop saying that,” James scolded her, in that paternal tone she absolutely loathed.
“You’re already dead, you don’t get a say,” she snapped back, though her voice carried a trace of irony.
James shot her a sharp look.
“We also need to figure out how your Signet works.”
Scarlett furrowed her brow, letting out a scornful laugh.
“I’ll never be used as a bloody lab rat again!” she raised her voice, shaking her head over and over, heart pounding in her throat. “Never again, never again…”
“That’s not what I meant… more like… we were able to control your body and…” James gestured vaguely, as though things might make more sense from another angle. “What else can we do?!”
“I don’t know, Jamie…” Scarlett huffed. “I’m scared.”
“Scared of what?” he arched a brow.
“Of my Signet… of what might happen tomorrow… if they find out I’m alive… if they learn about the experiments… if they try… if they try to lock me up again… I won’t… I won’t survive it… it could all go to shit, Jamie. And I… I can’t take it anymore.” Her lips trembled.
James looked at her with pity, and that made her recoil.
“You caught Wormtail.” He was trying to sound assertive, though he seemed just as unsure as she was. “Sirius will be free and… and he’ll take care of you.”
Scarlett let out a bitter laugh.
“I seriously doubt that. I really do.”
“He loves you,” James went on, unfazed. “And you love him.”
“He doesn’t…” Scarlett couldn’t finish the sentence, not even she believed it. It was clear as day, transparent like the soap bubbles popping around her in the bath. “I don’t…”
She couldn’t say she didn’t love him either. Sirius Black had been her first love, the only man she had ever truly loved. He was like a stubborn stain clinging to her chest—greedy and possessive. There was only room for him in there. He was the only one who had ever stolen what was most precious to her: her heart, her laughter, and her tears.
Even after everything…
Scarlett hated herself for still loving him. She knew she would regret it—she always regretted loving Sirius Black—but knowing it was mutual… it was like accepting that the sweet poison would kill her once more, drive her mad and reckless, push her to do terrible things.
And still, there she was, silently begging that Sirius truly did love her, even after all she’d done to him.
“I don’t deserve it… not after everything… I don’t deserve him, Jamie.” Scarlett whimpered, resigned. “He suffered so much… because of me…”
“He made you suffer too.”
“Not nearly as much as what I did to him! I married his brother, had a child…” Scarlett clutched at her hair, tugging hard until her scalp burned. “I killed Marl… Maurie… and I… I’m a monster, Jamie. He can’t love me.”
“Lucky for you, we don’t get to choose who we love.” James let out a nasal, rueful laugh. “But he did suffer. I remember it well… he cried for so many nights… drowned himself in alcohol and drugs when you were gone… he went mad. I honestly thought he’d die without you. But then again… your relationship was always codependent. He couldn’t live without you and you couldn’t live without him. He nearly died, yeah, but he learnt to stand on his own two feet without using you as a crutch.” His features darkened slightly and he clicked his tongue. “What I’m trying to say is… it wasn’t all your fault, you know?”
“But I should have been there for him!” Scarlett snapped, voice rising in pitch. “I never should have left…”
“Why did you go? You can’t tell me you walked into that trap just to save Regulus!”
Scarlett swallowed thickly. The memory of that day threatened to force its way in, but she pushed it aside with a shake of her head.
“I…” She tried to speak, but once again, the magic drew the breath from her throat, slicing through her words like severed vocal cords. “I felt responsible for him…” It wasn’t a lie, but it wasn’t the whole truth either.
“The rumours… about you two… being together before all that…”
“They were lies. We only played into it so that… so that the story of us would seem more believable. So Voldemort would buy it. Marrying Red was… convenient. We had to make it look real or…”
“Or…?”
Or Voldemort would kill Reggie, Scarlett tried to say. But not a single word passed her lips—bound as they were by the pact she had made.
“Or he’d think I was a spy.” Scarlett said, once again offering only a fraction of the truth.
James squinted as he nodded gently.
“Fuck… I can’t even imagine what you went through.” His voice was little more than a whisper. “I’m sorry… I…” He exhaled sharply. “I know life hasn’t been kind to you, Scar… but… it’s giving you a second chance. A chance not everyone gets. I’d know that better than anyone.” His expression filled with sorrow. “And there were moments… when you were happy. I know because… because I was there.” He rubbed his eyes before looking at her. “What I’m saying is… don’t let this chance slip through your fingers.”
Scarlett pressed her lips together, the light dancing on the surface of the water reflecting in the lenses of James’s glasses. She made a move to respond, but no words came. Of course she saw her escape from Azkaban as a second chance to make things different from how they’d been—but it was so terrifying she couldn’t even move.
In Azkaban, she knew exactly what to expect. Wake up, sun exposure, five-minute soak in hot water, experiment, end of day. Now…
She didn’t know what to do. What she should do, what she wanted to do, or even what the right thing to do was. And Sirius’s presence scrambled all her instincts even more. She lifted her hands from the water, staring once more at her wrinkled, trembling fingers. Could they really grasp this chance?
More likely, she’d ruin everything. Just like all the other times.
She looked back at James—only to realise he was no longer there.
She stepped out of the bath and wrapped herself in the towels Penny had left folded on the counter, opening drawers until she found a hairbrush beside a bottle of vanilla-scented lotion. A faint smile touched her lips. Scarlett picked it up and unscrewed the lid, bringing it to her nose.
A warmth spread through her chest, as though joy had crept in unnoticed. Then that joy dressed itself in melancholy, and finally stood naked as longing. Scarlett rubbed a bit of the lotion on the back of her hand, the cream hardened slightly from how long it had been left untouched.
She hadn’t expected it to still be there. It was probably expired. She couldn’t have cared less, slathering it onto her skin with urgency, as if trying to cover herself in that light, fleeting, and yet deeply stirring sensation. It was as if something had stirred in the very core of her being, in a place the Dementors hadn’t managed to rot.
A place where something real still lived—a Scarlett who’d never been imprisoned, who’d never run from Sirius, who’d never discovered the pregnancy.
She froze, fear soaking her heartbeat in an unnerving latency. She didn’t want to tug at those tangled threads in her chest—not right now—especially without knowing if they were hiding a wasps’ nest.
But that vanilla scent gave her a kind of courage she hadn’t remembered missing.
“Penny…” Scarlett called out, and the elf appeared a moment later in the doorway. “Do you know… any spell for…” She paused, searching for the right words. “… my teeth?”
Penny’s eyes—which were already enormous—grew even wider when Scarlett showed her the yellowed state of her teeth.
“Funny… Master Black asked Penny for the very same thing just now…” she said, frowning as she waved her fingers in front of Scarlett’s face, whose eyebrows knitted in confusion. “All done.”
Scarlett turned to the mirror immediately—her teeth were now white in a natural-looking way, and she glanced at the elf without fear, smiling from ear to ear.
“Thank you, Penny.” She stuffed her mouth with toothpaste, trying to get rid of the bitter taste that still clung to her palate.
The elf remained where she was, watching her closely.
“Penny wanted to apologise… for the way…” She cleared her throat. “She treated Mistress Black. Penny thought… Penny didn’t know… Master Black told Penny… what the mistress did… to save him. In Azkaban.”
Scarlett’s joy faded as quickly as it had bloomed. She spat out the toothpaste and rinsed her mouth before answering.
“You don’t need to apologise.” She pretended to be too busy brushing her hair to meet her eyes. “I would never… never hurt Sirius.”
Penny didn’t seem convinced. Or if she was, she didn’t show it. She simply disapparated with a soft pop.
Scarlett left the bathroom, spotting a set of clean clothes folded on the bed. She couldn’t remember if they had ever belonged to her, but it didn’t really matter. They didn’t fit. Scarlett was far too thin now; the shirt was Toto’s, and the shorts didn’t even cling to her waist.
Nothing a Shrinking Charm couldn’t fix.
She took a deep breath before leaving the room, heading to the living room with such nerves that she ended up bumping into someone unexpected along the way.
“Sorry, Si—” Scarlett stopped dead the moment she looked up.
Time had not been kind to Remus. In truth, very little ever had. Scarlett remembered he hadn’t always had so many scars on his face, nor so many grey strands in his brown hair. Wrinkles lined the corners of his eyes, and a rather distinctive moustache covered the space between his nose and upper lip—though not enough to hide the revulsion on his face as he pushed her away.
He was tall. So tall Scarlett felt an unconscious flicker of fear. If he wanted to kill her right then, with his bare hands, he easily could have. But Remus Lupin had always been less impulsive than Sirius, more measured than James.
“So… it’s true.” He took a step back, the sharp lines of his jaw tensing and relaxing, as though he were weighing what to say. “You’re alive.”
The cutting look he gave her was enough to lacerate every shred of certainty Scarlett had been clinging to, feeding her doubts, making room for the voices that kept repeating she was a murderer, a monster, a traitor. The unspoken accusations were written plainly in the brown of his eyes.
Sirius appeared from the kitchen, a surprised crease forming between his brows when he saw Remus standing there.
“Why didn’t you tell me anything?” The look he threw at Sirius was soaked in bitterness.
“Because…” Sirius faltered, wetting his lips, glancing at Scarlett and then back at Remus. “I… I didn’t think she was coming back.”
Remus let out a snort of derision, stepping backwards until he stopped, leaning against the mantelpiece. Scarlett stood frozen, eyes fixed on the floor, heart racing so fast it made her dizzy. She didn’t know what else to do but cry.
“She abandoned you again?!” he nearly shouted, his pale face hollow with dark circles under his eyes.
“I didn’t—” Scarlett tried to defend herself, but Sirius held up a hand to stop her, stepping closer to the two of them.
“Moony… calm down,” he said firmly. “Didn’t Dumbledore tell you what happened?”
“He didn’t have… much time. Asked me to give you this letter…” Remus held out the parchment to Sirius, refusing to look at Scarlett.
Sirius sighed as he read his name written in Dumbledore’s elegant script, then looked back at his friend.
“She’s the one who caught Wormtail,” he explained, but Remus’s expression didn’t shift.
“She’s a murderer, Sirius!” Remus barked. “She killed Marl… killed the McKinnons…” His voice cracked halfway through the sentence.
Scarlett’s entire body trembled with shame, every muscle coiled in tension. She swallowed hard and took a few steps back, ready to retreat to the bedroom, but Sirius caught her arm.
“Let me go, Sirius…” Scarlett managed, trying to hold back the tears. “Please.”
“He won’t hurt you…” Sirius said it with such certainty that Scarlett desperately wanted to believe him.
“Yeah… unlike you, I don’t hurt my friends.” Remus didn’t hold back the venom in his tone, spitting the words. “Or… who I thought were my friends.”
Scarlett summoned all the courage she had and met Remus’s eyes once more, studying his stern face, etched with grief and resentment. She wanted to say something—anything—that might untangle the knots buried in that heavy stare. But it had been fifteen years. Fifteen years of being blamed for a crime she had committed. For betraying the man she loved. For joining the very ones who had slaughtered her family.
Lily and James were there too, just as stunned as Sirius.
“I did it for—”
“Don’t you dare say his name!” Remus exploded, pointing a trembling finger at Scarlett, eyes wide, nostrils flared.
“That’s enough, Remus!” Sirius pulled Scarlett behind him protectively. “You don’t know what happened—”
“I know exactly what happened, Sirius!” Remus barked out a bitter laugh. “You brought a murderer into my home!”
“This house is as much mine as it is yours!” Sirius shot back, trying to stay calm, though Remus’s fury was starting to infect him—his breath coming short and sharp.
“It might have been—but you two were locked up and—” Remus blinked rapidly, then rubbed his temples in a futile attempt to steady himself. “Merlin… you’re actually going to defend her…”
“You don’t know what happened!” Sirius roared.
“Oh right—she killed Marlene to protect Reggie?!” he scoffed, voice thick with sarcasm. Seeing Sirius’s expression, Remus began to clap slowly. “How bloody convenient! What next—she handed over the Order’s secrets for Orfy?!”
Scarlett leaned back against the wall as her legs threatened to give out. She fought with everything she had not to cry, not to let it show—but it was impossible. Remus was right about every single thing he'd said, and in that moment, she wished she were dead.
“I…” she stammered, unable to form any coherent sentence, not when the sobs burst from her chest, tearing away her words and her control.
“It was your brother who saved Orfeu, not her! She’s lying, Sirius, how can you believe—how—”
“That’s enough, Remus…”
“After everything she did… after the state she left you in—”
“Remus…”
“She betrayed you with your own brother and you still—”
“I SAID THAT’S ENOUGH!” Sirius bellowed, grabbing Remus by the collar. “Shut the fuck up! You don’t know what happened! You don’t know the hell we had to go through…” His voice cracked. He was crying now too.
The hard set of Remus’s features began to splinter under the weight of Sirius’s tone.
“The hell you two went through in Azkaban?” His lips curled into a bitter smile. “You didn’t deserve what happened to you, Sirius… but she…”
Scarlett knew Remus was right. But she couldn’t rationalise anything—not when the chasm of emotion inside her stretched wide and hollow, not when her tears burned and robbed her of breath. Taking advantage of Sirius’s momentary distraction, she forced herself to move. She stumbled backward, still dazed, bolting down the corridor and into the bedroom that had once belonged to her and Sirius, slamming the door shut behind her.
“Scar!” Sirius called out, his voice desperate as he turned toward where she’d gone, ready to follow—but Remus hissed and crossed his arms. “Penny!” he called, and the elf apparated into the sitting room at once at the sound of her name. “Go after Scarlett—and don’t let her leave the house!”
Though the elf didn’t like being ordered around like that, she obeyed without hesitation.
“Never thought you, of all people, would take her side,” Remus whispered, his voice laced with indignation.
Sirius clenched his jaw, tears pricking at his eyes and blurring the image of his friend standing before him. He missed James. James would’ve helped him gather his thoughts into something that made sense. But Remus’s words had rattled him—because there was truth in them. And the memory of how much Scarlett had made him suffer still lingered somewhere deep in his chest, swept beneath the rug, waiting to crawl out when he least expected it.
He shook his head to dispel those thoughts, blinking back the tears with force.
“I saw what they did to her…” Sirius wiped his nose, watching Remus’s brown eyes shimmer with gold—the wolf stirring. He raised an eyebrow, asking without words. “The Ministry was experimenting on her. On… her Signet. They tried to… tried to make her kill me. That’s how we escaped…”
Remus’s eyes flooded with concern, his brow furrowing in disbelief.
“What?”
“She was…” He took a deep breath, trying to ease the pressure in his chest. “Tortured… in every way… physically, mentally… loads of Cruciatus…”
“What?” Horror replaced the disbelief on Remus’s face, like a punch to the gut.
“I really wanted… to feel good… seeing her like that… after everything she did to me…” Sirius went on, pausing whenever it felt like the air just wasn’t reaching his lungs. “But I couldn’t. I wanted so badly to let what I felt for her rot… and use it as fuel for the anger—for everything she put me through… but I’m not… I’m not a fucking monster, no matter how hard I tried… I couldn’t… I wasn’t going to leave her like that.” Sirius held his breath, rubbing his eyes with his knuckles, wiping away the tears with the palms of his hands. “This thing… it’s stronger than me,” he admitted, in a turbulent exhale.
Remus didn’t move an inch, but his gaze chilled so suddenly that Sirius looked down at the floor, the back of his neck burning, chest thudding. He felt ashamed for opening up to him like that—as if Remus were a stranger.
Twelve years without seeing him… like it or not, they were different people now.
“I need to return to Hogwarts,” was all Remus said, visibly shaken as he grabbed a handful of Floo powder.
“Moony…” Sirius said the nickname with a choked voice. “You can’t tell anyone… about her… please… the Ministry…”
“I won’t.” Remus answered honestly. He didn’t seem pleased with Scarlett’s presence in his home, but the outrage had subsided. He had come to terms with it—like someone who both feared and expected it all along. His shoulders tensed as he raised his hand and walked toward the fireplace. He paused, glancing at Sirius from the corner of his eye. “Will you be alright… alone… with her?”
Sirius swallowed hard. The truth was, no. He would never truly be safe with Scarlett. She stirred too many things in him—both beautiful and wicked. His best and worst sides. He nodded, and though Remus didn’t believe him, he was too disarmed to challenge it.
He watched as the emerald flames swallowed his friend, while a vacuum pulled at the hollow inside his chest. He looked around the sitting room, as if expecting someone else to be there.
As if hoping James might be there.
His hand brushed the back of the sofa, sweet memories of him and his best friend watching telly together bringing a small smile to his lips. Sirius closed his eyes tightly and shook his head, chasing them away as he made his way to the bedroom. He opened the door without even knocking.
Penny was sitting cross-legged on the floor, arms folded.
“Mistress Black is under the bed,” she said, lifting the bedspread with an indignant huff.
Sirius crouched down and spotted the tuxedo cat pressed up against the farthest wall, curled up and bristling. When he reached out to her, Whiskers hissed, her blue eyes gleaming in the darkness.
“Scar…” he called, slipping half his body beneath the bed until he could reach her. Whiskers growled, baring her teeth and claws. Sirius froze, resting his chin on his shoulder as he placed his hand on the cold floor, letting her sniff him. “I’m not going to hurt you. No one’s going to hurt you.”
Whiskers eyed him with suspicion, her body tense, ready to flee at the slightest movement. But Sirius remained completely still, giving her time to grow used to his presence.
“He won’t tell, Scar,” Sirius said, pouring as much conviction into his tone as he could—though something deep in his mind still doubted Remus. “You’re not going back to Azkaban.”
The cat gently brushed her whiskers against Sirius’s fingers, allowing him to scratch her under the chin, while his other hand stroked her ears, until he gripped her firmly and pulled her against his chest, holding her there as he slid across the floor to emerge from the tight space. Whiskers remained curled up, her fur still bristled, and her narrow pupils scanned the room as if expecting to detect some lurking threat—but all that was there, apart from the two of them, was Penny.
“Mistress Black never told Penny she was an Animagus,” the elf said, looking at Sirius with those enormous, pale eyes.
Sirius gave a nostalgic smile.
“We all were.” He kept stroking the cat, trying to soothe her.
“Even little Master Potter?”
“Yes. It was actually his idea.” Sirius stood with a grunt, holding Whiskers in one arm. “He always had the most brilliant—and most idiotic—ideas.”
Penny nodded in agreement.
“Penny misses the Potters,” the elf said, barely above a whisper.
“I do too, Penny,” Sirius admitted, tenderly. “I always will.”
The elf gave him a small, encouraging pat on the leg before disapparating, leaving them alone. Sirius sat on the bed, resting his back against the headboard, letting Whiskers slide into his lap. He could feel every bone in her frame beneath his hand, though she was far sturdier than she’d been when they fled Azkaban. Both of them had gained a fair bit of weight, but were still thin.
Sirius watched the sunbeams flood the room through the windows, shining off the glass of the picture frames, the polished wood of the dresser, and his leather jacket at the foot of the bed. Whiskers’s fur was no longer raised, though he could feel the uneven rhythm of her breathing in his lap.
He drew in a deep breath, taking in the scent of that room he never thought he’d see again, his eyes wandering over the posters on the walls, the glow-in-the-dark stars on the ceiling he and Scarlett had stuck up long ago.
He didn’t remember them being there, but he spotted Sirius in Canis Major easily, as well as the constellations of Monoceros, Orion, Gemini, Hydra, Puppis, Lepus, and Canis Minor.
Whiskers was also gazing up at the ceiling, and it didn’t take long before the cat slowly shed her form, giving way to Scarlett, who allowed herself to rest her head on his chest, her eyes lost in the stars. She was in the past—not in that room. Sirius knew that, of course… he knew her better than he liked to admit.
Instinctively, he curled his fingers through the reddish-brown strands of her hair, in a gesture so meaningful it drew her back to him, their eyes locking. After fifteen years, those eyes were still the same—they held the same icy, searing tone that could both burn and freeze him with ease.
Scarlett ran her fingers along his beard, which had been trimmed close to the skin, up to his long black hair, now brushed and slightly wavy. Sirius closed his eyes, caught in the spell of Scarlett’s scent, which he only now noticed: the smell of vanilla climbed into his brain, softening every nerve ending like morphine, sending a shiver down his spine and a warmth to his lower abdomen—perhaps not unrelated to the fact she was sitting in his lap.
“You had a bath,” she said, clearing her throat, her voice hoarse from crying, eyes swollen and red.
Sirius’s handsome face wore a distracted half-smile, the grey of his eyes soaking in all the warmth the sun threw into the room.
“You weren’t the only one who needed one.” He traced Scarlett’s jaw with his thumb, feeling her muscles tense immediately, her throat shifting as she swallowed slowly, warm breath brushing against his hand.
Scarlett lowered her face, breaking eye contact and pulling away from his touch, resting her ear just above Sirius’s heart and placing her hand there, in the gentle opening of his shirt buttons, where pale skin was inked with designs. It was hard not to explore them with her fingers, harder still not to notice his skin reacting beneath her touch.
Sirius adjusted his position, unbuttoning his shirt further so she could see the whole design.
“Amalgamation,” Sirius revealed, placing his hand over Scarlett’s atop the symbol. He pulled the fabric aside, making her lift her head from his chest. “Gar, Odin’s Spear…” he explained, pointing to the rune just below his right collarbone. “Nauthiz.” He guided her fingers to the left of his sternum, where, beneath several other runic inscriptions, a name sat directly over his heart.
Sirius quickly pulled his shirt back up, slipping it over his shoulders and turning his gaze away, his heartbeat thundering when he realised what he had just shown her—hoping Scarlett hadn’t noticed what it was. But she had.
“I already knew these,” she murmured, trying to break the heavy tension that had settled between them.
“Just making sure you hadn’t forgotten…” Sirius shrugged casually, though his entire body seemed to tremble as Scarlett curled back into him, nestling her face into his neck.
He breathed slowly, trying to ignore the presence of Scarlett spreading across his skin like poison, a prickling sensation blooming where she had touched his chest, triggering something strange in his stomach. Everything got worse when Scarlett hugged him, folding her legs into his lap and turning to the side.
His arms moved at once, holding her and pulling her tightly against his body, trying to reassure her that everything would be alright—even though he wasn’t sure of it himself.
Scarlett sniffled, wiping her nose before resting her head on his shoulder again, her hair brushing against his neck. A low, trembling breath escaped her throat. Sirius could barely move or breathe properly, the hypnotic daylight dancing across Scarlett’s hair, her exposed nape, the half of her face shadowed with fear, her curled lashes.
She looked at him, and butterflies took flight in Sirius’s stomach, the pressure in his chest giving way to a warmth both comforting and sublime.
“How are you feeling?” Sirius pulled her closer to him, as if to emphasise his question.
Scarlett closed her eyes, letting Sirius bear the full weight of her body—including the heavy burden crushing her shoulders. She took a deep breath, as though only now able to do so, her fingers gently tugging at the beard on his chin.
“I’m scared…” she confessed, her voice muffled against his shirt.
“Scared?” Sirius got lost in the play of light reflecting on Scarlett’s pale skin.
“I don’t want to… I won’t go back to Azkaban…” Scarlett wavered with the thought. “But… at the same time…” Her eyelids lifted. Their gazes locked once more. “Safe. You make me feel safe. You always did… like… like…”
Like you were my home, she meant to say, but the words died on her lips when Sirius’s expression slowly hardened, the silver in his eyes melting and evaporating in its own quiet rebellion.
Sirius cupped her face, though there was hesitation in his features. The warmth of his palm spread across her body in a shiver.
“Why do you touch me like that?” Scarlett asked so softly he only understood because he was watching her pale, cracked lips.
Sirius considered a hundred evasions for that question, but none of them seemed quite as compelling as the truth.
“Because I don’t know how to touch you any other way.” He was certain he could hear Scarlett’s heart pounding wildly as he leaned towards her and rested his forehead against hers, as though asking her for some kind of permission, his dark hair cascading around them, swallowing the light of the room and trapping them in a world where only they existed.
“I thought you hated me,” Scarlett whispered, her lips hovering near his, their breaths becoming one.
“And I do,” Sirius told the truth—but there was also a silent ache in the depths of his being, an urge to say something that had no sound, no meaning, no form.
It was a word—just one little word—that would make them burn until everything turned to ash and ruin. The word tattooed forever above his heart. Sirius threw himself into those deep-abyss eyes that formed the sheer wall of her pupils, ringed by the clear ocean of her irises.
Every instinct in him screamed for him to stop what he was doing—that this was madness, that he was insane. That he couldn’t keep walking this tightrope, not with Scarlett hoping he’d fall while also waiting for him on the other side.
There was an intimacy between them, one they’d built years ago and that still lingered. The intimacy of being understood. No word in the world could ever match the impact of losing himself in those eyes, in those ocean-labyrinths, because eyes never lie.
Scarlett still loved him, even if she’d never admit it. The feeling was translucent in her gaze, there in the green that surrounded her pupils and in the dark lines cutting through that luminous blue. In the uncertain way her long lashes fluttered shut when she blinked, in the flare of her nostrils, in the way she still stroked his beard. In the trembling sigh that left her lips just before they were covered by his.
Scarlett’s whole body shuddered at the touch. There was no impatience, no fear—it was a union heavy with resentment and longing that left her frozen. Sirius’s hands slid down her body, resting at her waist, but he didn’t move further, holding back as if waiting for her to push him away.
Scarlett didn’t pull back—she didn’t want to. The kiss awakened so much in her chest she was dazed, as if she didn’t remember what it was like to be kissed and yet had never forgotten. The way his beard scratched against her skin, the way his hands gripped her hips, the way his lips found hers again in a movement full of yearning.
She let herself be swept away by the scent of his aftershave—which was still the same—as if those damned fifteen years had turned to dust and they were still just two teenagers discovering that love could be cruel. Scarlett shifted in Sirius’s lap, wrapping her legs around his waist, knees pressed into the mattress so they were at eye level. She brushed her mouth against his and tasted him with the tip of her tongue. Sirius parted his lips and slid a hand down Scarlett’s back, fingers tangling in her straight hair as he pulled her closer—his body hardening from the mere contact.
Scarlett covered Sirius’s mouth with her own, slowly, and he let her curious, exploring tongue come to know him as if she had never done so before. Desire unravelled through his body as her hands cradled his cheeks, their tongues dancing in a slow, warm rhythm as though they had all the time in the world to explore each other—Sirius melting in the arms of the woman who had devastated him and whom he had longed for, for so very long.
He held her with a careful pressure, heart racing wildly when Scarlett let out a soft moan—and that was enough for him to deepen the kiss with a sudden intensity, his tongue demanding back everything Scarlett had taken from him. She responded with equal fervour, the fire that hadn’t burned in nearly fifteen years roaring to life between them. Sirius slipped his fingers beneath the hem of Scarlett’s shirt, touching the skin of her back with tender reverence, feeling the raised patterns of scars that marked her.
Scarlett broke the contact the moment she felt Sirius’s fingertips there, pulling his hand away—but she didn’t move back. Their noses still brushed, and he felt her breath falter, her lips now trembling where moments ago they had met his.
“I don’t deserve you,” Scarlett whispered, closing her eyes and turning her face away, as though it were too difficult not to carry on with the kiss.
“No, you don’t,” Sirius agreed, without thinking. After everything she’d done, Scarlett didn’t deserve him. And yet, his heart dismissed that notion as nonsense. If it were true—why did he still want her so badly?
Before he could say anything more, a salty scent reached his nose, mingling with the intoxicating vanilla perfume clinging to Scarlett’s skin and the cool sharpness of his aftershave. He saw tears freckling her cheeks, her chest heaving as she bowed her head and covered her face with her hands.
Her shoulders curled inward, and she began to cry again, making Sirius mentally curse himself for what he’d said. Seeing her like that—exposed, vulnerable—made his heart pound so hard he thought it might burst. Sirius wanted to comfort her with soft, meaningless words, but stayed silent. With Scarlett, once he started, he couldn’t stop. She dissolved all his barriers, his restraint, his civility. He wanted to claim her as his just as much as he wanted her to suffer for everything she’d put him through. It was ambivalent, painful, bittersweet.
Even so, Sirius held her, just like he used to. He had once promised he’d always be Scarlett’s safe harbour, no matter what might happen—and though he’d broken many of his promises, that was one he took pride in keeping, refusing to break it even if it meant shattering his own heart in the end.
The moment she’d calmed down, Scarlett pulled away with a sudden movement, sliding across the mattress until she slipped under the blanket and laid her head in Sirius’s lap, without looking at him. He took a deep breath, trying to shake off the intoxicating fog that kept him tethered to her but… if he were being honest? He didn’t want to leave. The heat of their bodies still tingled across his skin, warming his muscles, twisting in his gut.
Sirius ran his fingers gently through her hair in a soft caress. Scarlett closed her eyes and filled her lungs, hiding her face. They remained in that indivisible silence… not that it was a bad thing. There were many things he wanted—and needed—to say, but they could wait. He was so close to his long-dreamed freedom, too much was happening at once, and he needed time to process it all.
He watched Scarlett asleep in his lap—the woman who had shown him how love could be both comforting and atrocious. Who had lifted him to the heavens and left him in hell. A knot formed in his throat at the thought.
It wasn’t fair to stay with Scarlett like that. It wasn’t fair to her, and it certainly wasn’t fair to him. So Sirius gently lifted her head from his leg, slipped out of bed and left the room without a sound, gasping for air the moment he reached the hallway, bracing both hands against the wall as his emotions tried to settle inside him, knotting into an even worse tangle than before.
“What the fuck are you doing, Sirius?!” he muttered to himself under his breath as he tried to compose himself. He exhaled through his mouth and glanced to the side—to find Penny watching him with a mix of nosiness and a touch of amusement.
“Is Master Black all right?” she asked in her most innocent voice, glancing pointedly at his waist.
Sirius didn’t even answer. He adjusted his trousers as casually as he could to hide his erection, face burning. He licked his lips—still tasting Scarlett’s mouth—and shook his head, trying to banish the effect she had on him, mentally cursing himself for still being hard.
He picked up Dumbledore’s letter and stomped off to the back garden, slamming the door behind him and letting the sunlight wash over his body as he tried to dissolve the haze of stupor and force that bloody woman out of his head.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 29: Because that’s what she does. It’s who she is.
Chapter Text
XCVII
Regulus hadn’t shut his eyes all night. As soon as he and Victoria had parted ways with Harry and Hermione in the corridors of Hogwarts, they met Luana in the Slytherin Common Room, fresh from a solid detention and burdened with a million questions.
He couldn’t answer a single one, as his mind was racing, his palms sweating, and his heart refusing to settle. The moment he lay in his dormitory bed, he stared up at the green and silver canopy for what felt like hours, barely breathing at the mere thought of what might happen next.
Scarlett was alive.
Sirius was free and had said they’d be a family.
Just the thought… his whole body broke out in goosebumps, as if everything he’d ever dreamed of was finally becoming real. He still feared it might all be a dream, that he’d simply wake up and realise it had been an illusion. Perhaps that’s why he didn’t want to sleep. He didn’t want to wander back into a world where Scarlett didn’t exist.
No. He wanted to live in this reality where she was still alive and… and she…
Regulus wiped his tears, lost and breathless. There was that undeniable fear coiled in his chest because she had told him she was guilty, and yet a voice in the back of his mind kept trying to soothe him, as if she were wrong. As if she didn’t know what she was saying.
That was it, it had been in the heat of the moment. So, they’d be a family and… he’d watch films with Scarlett and Sirius, they’d have barbecues on weekends and he’d teach them how to play Mario Kart on his Super Nintendo. He’d invite Victoria and Luana and they’d go to the cinema, he’d show off his tricks on the skateboard and…
Guilt twisted in his chest when he thought of Remus. How was his uncle? Did he know anything? It was a full moon and he was in the Forbidden Forest. Regulus had seen his name on the map, just like James Potter’s… or was that all in his head?!
He rubbed his eyes as Pucey was the first to get up, locking himself in the bathroom carefully so as not to wake the others. Regulus stayed in bed until Pucey came out, being the next to head in, taking a long shower in an attempt to calm down.
The weather was rather hot, so Regulus simply put on his trousers and shirt, tying his tie perfectly at the neck before stepping out of the bathroom after styling his fringe just the way he knew Victoria liked. As he left, he tried to act as normal as possible, slipping the Marauder’s Map into the waistband of his trousers and greeting Miles and Terry with a good morning, quickening his pace as he left the dorm, scanning the heads over the sofas for Luana and Victoria.
He found them where they always sat—by the fireplace. Before he could open his mouth, Gemma Farley cleared her throat loudly, catching all three of their attention.
"Black, Rookwood, and Teixeira… Dumbledore’s asking for the three of you in his office. It’s urgent." She whispered the message. "I do hope you lot won’t lose more points for Slytherin than Teixeira already did last night by being out of the dorm after curfew!"
"Chill out, Miss Stick-in-the-Mud," Luana rolled her eyes, playing with one of the pendants on her silver chains. "It’s probably nothing serious."
"Aren’t you meant to be studying for your NEWTs or something?" Victoria added with a mocking tone.
"I just don’t want Slytherin to lose the House Cup because of you!" Gemma’s face flushed red and she ran a hand through her perfectly styled hair. "We’re already short on prefects as it is…" She shot Regulus a scrutinising look.
Regulus might have come up with a rather sharp retort under normal circumstances, but all he did was head for the Common Room exit without so much as a word, fighting the urge to sprint to the Headmaster’s office.
Could he have news about his mother? About Sirius? Had Peter already confessed to being the Secret-Keeper? Everything seemed quiet for now, which suggested the Ministry hadn’t made a formal statement yet.
He barely noticed when Victoria took his hand, anchoring him back to reality. Her caramel eyes shimmered with affection, and Reg felt the worst of his anxiety melt away beneath the warmth of her loving smile as she gave his hand a gentle squeeze.
"Mimi told me…" Luana whispered, squeezing between them and throwing her arms around their shoulders, pushing them apart to Regulus’s displeasure. "About Sirius and your mum…"
Victoria hissed, motioning frantically for her to hush. Luana tilted her head back, lips pressed together and eyes wide like she’d just realised she’d said something terribly wrong.
"Not here, Lua!" Regulus joined Mimi in scolding her, prompting Luana to roll her eyes.
"Alright, alright. My bad," she huffed, though her mood didn’t stay sour for long. "How are you feeling?"
Regulus didn’t bother to hide the grin that stretched from ear to ear.
"I… I don’t know." He sobered up at the thought that everything could still go wrong. "I still can’t believe it…"
He fell silent as they came upon Fred and George standing in front of the gargoyle, with Percy Weasley waiting with his arms crossed as if expecting them.
"Glad you’re all here," the Gryffindor Head Boy looked them up and down before offering a courteous smile. "Lemon drop."
The gargoyle moved aside to let them pass, the spiral staircase emerged, and, reluctantly, Percy remained behind, waving them on. The five exchanged glances, and Regulus took the lead, climbing the steps with adrenaline surging through his veins.
He knocked twice before the door opened, and Reggie felt his heart pound at the memory of being there with his mother just a few hours earlier. The hum of silver instruments filled the air with a gentle mist, and now, most of the portraits of former headmasters were awake, locked in a heated debate about the previous night’s events.
Behind the desk, Dumbledore was drumming his fingers lightly on the wood, waiting for them all to step forward. When Fred crossed the threshold and closed the door behind them, the headmaster conjured a chair for each of them with a graceful flick of his finger. Regulus instinctively reached for Victoria’s hand, his entire body slick with nervous sweat.
"Please, sit down." He gestured, and all five of them obeyed. "I’ve asked you here so we can speak about what happened. I trust you’ve kept yesterday’s nocturnal adventure discreet?"
Regulus nodded, as did Victoria and Luana.
"Yes," the twins answered in unison.
"Excellent. Then I’ll need you to make an oath." Dumbledore adjusted his half-moon spectacles as he moved his wand, causing a beige pot to float into view. Scoops of ice cream were served into several small silver bowls, each one settling into their hands. "Lemon sorbet, anyone?"
Regulus stared at the pale green sorbet before looking up at the headmaster.
"An oath?" he frowned, not touching the dessert.
"Yes… well, I know none of you would willingly speak of what occurred, but… this is simply to ensure no one outside finds out. Apart from Harry and Miss Granger, of course," he explained, stroking his beard. "The information that Mrs. Black is alive is… quite critical."
" How is she alive?!" It was George who asked, already halfway through his sorbet. "I mean… we all…"
"The Ministry sent a letter confirming her death in ’88," Regulus cut him off.
George and Fred’s mouths fell open in shock.
"But then… what about your uncle?" Fred narrowed his eyes, suspicious.
Regulus looked to Dumbledore, as if seeking permission. The headmaster gave a small nod.
"He was here as well. We met… remember what my mum said about the rat?! We managed to capture him. What happened to him, Professor? Did you hand him over to the Aurors?"
"Yes… the entire case has been turned over to the Ministry," Dumbledore replied evenly. "Except, of course, for the fact that your mother is alive."
"So Sirius is going to be cleared? Do you know where they are? Can I send them a letter?" Regulus blurted everything out so quickly that the headmaster frowned, as if trying to make sense of his words.
"First, the oath… then I shall answer your questions, Mr Black." Dumbledore cleared his throat, studying each of them closely. "It’s quite simple—you must swear on your magic that you won’t tell anyone about Mrs. Black. Unless that person already knows she’s alive."
Victoria raised her hand gently, and Dumbledore nodded for her to speak.
"And what if I don’t want to swear?" she asked with a note of defiance.
Dumbledore gave her a faint smile, as if quietly admiring her boldness.
"This isn’t for Mrs. Black’s safety, Miss Rookwood. It’s for yours."
"Why ours?!" George folded his arms, suspicious.
Regulus didn’t take his eyes off the headmaster, his heart thudding at what he might say.
"Mrs. Black was a high-ranking member of the Death Eaters and possesses… complex abilities. Abilities that would be greatly valuable to the return of—"
"Voldemort?!" Regulus cut in, breathless. "You mean she’d help him—"
"No, no," Dumbledore waved the notion away, as if it weren’t particularly significant. "Not willingly, at any rate."
"Didn’t get any of that," Fred muttered, shrugging as he scratched his chin. "What’s Voldemort got to do with it?"
In a rare display of impatience, Dumbledore waved his hand as if to steer the conversation elsewhere.
"I’m afraid we don’t have time for that sort of discussion right now, Mr Weasley." He motioned with his long fingers for them to draw their wands. "Have any of you performed a magical oath before?"
"No," Luana answered, clearly displeased with what they were about to do. "What happens if I decide to talk about Reggie’s scrawny mum to someone else?"
"You won’t be able to," Dumbledore said with a mild smile, as if the answer were obvious.
"I swear on my magic not to tell anyone about my mother," Regulus was the first to speak. He felt a chill crawl up the base of his spine as he said the words, as though something had wrapped around his vocal cords and tethered itself to the magic coursing through his body.
"I swear on my magic not to tell anyone about Mrs. Black," the others repeated, hesitant.
Dumbledore took a bite of his lemon sorbet before speaking again:
"I know none of you would ever willingly speak of her, but we can’t afford to make any mistakes after everything she’s been through." He finished, dabbing his lips with a napkin. "You’re dismissed."
"What, already?!" Luana looked outraged. "I haven’t even finished my sorbet!"
"But my questions…" Regulus whispered, and the headmaster gave him another kind smile.
"Ah, yes, your questions… let’s see…" He opened a stack of letters laid out on his desk. "Mr Pettigrew escaped," he said it so plainly that Regulus felt his whole body tremble.
"What?!" He shot to his feet.
"However…" Dumbledore raised his hand, asking him to let him finish. "He confessed to his crimes, and the Ministry is in possession of his wand. They also have Mr Black’s wand. That means they’ll perform a spell residue test to determine who really killed the Muggles that night… and who cast the Fidelius Charm on the Potters. From what your uncle told me, it was he who cast the Fidelius for Peter and James. So yes, Mr Black, he will most likely be exonerated." He sipped his jasmine tea slowly, completely unfazed by the group’s impatient stares. "They’re staying at the house that belongs to you in London, and yes, you may write to them. Professor Lupin will personally deliver the letters."
"So I… I can visit them?!" Regulus didn’t even try to hide his excitement at the thought of seeing them again.
"I’m afraid that won’t be possible… not until the Ministry reaches a decision regarding Sirius." Dumbledore’s gaze, though warm, held a glint of mystery. "Your great-uncle Thanatos Gaunt has been informed about… your mother."
"How did Peter escape?" Victoria asked, and only then did Regulus notice she was still holding his hand.
"I’d like to know that myself, Miss Rookwood." Dumbledore softened his expression, scratching his nose. "But I believe you have a trip to Hogsmeade to attend to, haven’t you?"
Regulus had a hundred more questions, but couldn’t voice a single one. All that echoed through his mind was that Sirius might be exonerated, that he and his mother were at his house in London, the three of them becoming a family and…
Before he even realised, he was descending the stairs from Dumbledore’s office, guided by Victoria, completely lost in his daydreams of a future so close he could almost taste the happiness.
"So… your mum…" Fred nudged him with his elbow, snapping him out of it. "Was it really her who caught the rat?"
Regulus remembered seeing Scarlett collapsed in the Forbidden Forest, begging for the torture to stop as she was attacked by dementors, writhing in the leaves as though her body were on fire. The memory sent a chill rippling through him, and he shuddered for a moment, relieved that he’d made it to her in time and cast his Patronus.
"She caught him and we brought him to Dumbledore’s office… Professor McGonagall was there too…" he confided to the Gryffindor, not entirely sure why he was doing so. "Then… we said goodbye and…"
"I can’t believe Scabbers was a… a bloke!" George muttered under his breath. "D’you reckon he’s ever seen Ron naked? Or Percy?"
Fred and Luana burst into loud laughter, then exchanged disgusted looks.
"If he saw Percy naked… poor sod… probably traumatised him for life," Fred said, still grinning. "Do you think Mum and Dad know?"
"Doubt it," George shrugged. "Hope not. Imagine if they found out we got mixed up in more trouble… I don’t fancy getting a bollocking."
While the twins chatted, Regulus, Victoria, and Luana veered off at a fork in the corridor, causing them to stop abruptly.
"Oi! Where are you lot going?!" George put his hands on his hips, following after them. "Aren’t we going to Hogsmeade?!"
"I need to speak to my uncle!" Regulus frowned as he noticed they were still tagging along. "What is it, Weasley?"
"Just… err… we wanted to say sorry," Fred offered with a sheepish grin. "About… well… the pranks."
"Yeah… we didn’t know about… um, ninety-nine per cent of Slytherin being tossers and…" George trailed off, scratching the back of his neck.
"We didn’t know about all the stuff with your uncle and your mum. That’s all," Fred finished, clapping his hands like he was trying to bring the awkward moment to a close. "Our bad."
Regulus didn’t care much about what the twins thought of him, but the apology did take a bit of the edge off his overwhelming excitement. He gave them a genuine smile.
"It’s fine…" He meant to sound more assertive, but truthfully, all he wanted was to get to his uncle as soon as possible.
The lightness of the moment was brutally slaughtered when the five of them found Professor Snape blocking the corridor, hands clasped behind his back, his dark eyes gleaming with twisted satisfaction and his lips curled in contempt.
"Mr Black…" the professor’s features hardened. "I suggest you do speak to your uncle. He must be… quite shaken…" He bared his crooked teeth in a triumphant smirk.
Regulus wanted badly to ignore Snape, but the scrutinising glare from the man rooted him to the spot, matching it with one of equal intensity.
"Shaken?"
Snape gave no explanation, spinning on his heel as his black cloak flared dramatically behind him, disappearing down the corridor as stealthily as he’d appeared. Regulus quickened his pace, the others following close behind, but a large crowd gathered at the entrance to the Great Hall was blocking the way.
"Oi, Reggie!" Terry ran up to them, waving from a distance. "Why didn’t you say your uncle Lupin’s a werewolf?!" he asked, breathless, leaning on Luana.
"What?" Regulus stared at him, flustered, and Miles joined the group, asking:
"Is it true what Professor Snape said?!"
"Lupin’s a werewolf?" Fred looked at Luana, grimacing.
"Is that why he’s always sick?" George joined the interrogation.
"What… what did he sa—" Regulus stammered, but Miles cut him off.
"He just told everyone in Slytherin that Lupin’s a werewolf…" Miles explained, stunned. "Is it true?"
Reg looked at Victoria, as if hoping for some sort of support, but she only shrugged, just as shocked as he was.
"It is…" he finally confirmed, and Terry’s jaw dropped.
"Why didn’t you tell me?!" Luana looked downright offended, smacking him on the head. "Now that you and Mimi are together, you’re keeping little secrets from me?!"
"I didn’t even tell her!" Regulus defended himself, throwing his hands up.
"It was kind of obvious." Victoria rolled her eyes in a condescending tone. "He always disappeared at the full moon…"
"Merlin’s bloody balls, you were raised by a werewolf!" Miles clutched his head.
"Is it true that if a dog barks at him, he barks back?" Terry didn’t seem as shocked as Miles.
"Does he smell like wet dog after the full moon? Like, do they actually need an extra shower or is that just a myth?" Fred joined in, barely hiding a grin.
"If I throw a stick, will he run after it?" George raised his eyebrows, hand on his chin, as if seriously considering it.
"Does he have a collar with his name on it?" Luana joined in the teasing, earning a shove from Victoria.
Regulus did not share in his friends’ amusement—not after the unbelievable news about what that bastard Snape had done. Fuming, he shoved past Miles and George and quickened his pace, pushing through the crowd in a rush to reach his uncle’s office.
.
.
.
Remus watched, absorbed, as his belongings were packed away into his suitcase. One hand held Dumbledore’s letter. The other, his wand. His mind, however, was far from the present. It was busy unearthing painful and sweet memories he had worked so hard to lock away at the back of a drawer, dusty and thick with cobwebs.
It had been hard enough to clean them off—harder still to touch them—because those were days that would never return, yet had once made the world feel more vibrant, more bearable, more… palatable. A time when he didn’t feel vertiginously alone, nor forgotten or neglected. When James, Lily, Sirius, Scarlett and Peter were part of his everyday life. A time when he couldn’t even imagine being apart from his friends.
He couldn’t have fathomed that, sixteen years later, he would be teaching at Hogwarts with Sirius a fugitive, Scarlett returned from the dead, and Peter the cause of all the tragedy that had befallen the Potters—contrary to what he had believed.
It was unthinkable. Almost laughable, how naïve and ignorant they had been about so many things, even as they enlisted to fight in the war for a better world… even having won…
All Remus had been left with was loss.
Truth be told, he hadn’t even noticed it happening at first—things slipping away little by little. Scarlett had been the first. Then Sirius, slowly stopping speaking to him, resenting things Remus hadn’t even known he’d done. Perhaps it was because he’d tried to make Sirius see Scarlett for who she really was… well, it didn’t matter anymore. Then came James and Lily… and Peter.
Being alone was his fate.
It was true he looked after Reggie right after Sirius’s imprisonment. But he’d had to return the boy to Thanatos, and somehow, along the way, he ended up in a relationship with Scarlett’s uncle. It hadn’t been planned, not something he had even considered—it just… happened. Remus had felt so utterly alone, and Thanatos had too. It was easy to see the two of them would end up together.
Of course they resisted, that first year… but on Reggie’s fourth birthday, just days before the anniversary of the Potters’ deaths, of Peter’s, and of Sirius’s imprisonment… it was too much. Taking shelter in Thanatos Gaunt’s arms had felt almost like a necessity.
They were happy for a time. They were a family. Then Orfy was released from St Mungo’s to live with them and… the sandcastle began to crumble. It had weathered many waves, endured many stampedes… but he eventually realised that, in his desperation not to be alone, he had allowed so many things to happen…
It no longer made sense. He loved Reggie—he always would—but his relationship with Thanatos had grown cold. Dealing with Orfy and Reg had been too much for his partner; Nate got overwhelmed by the weight of that responsibility. Remus had always taken on Regulus’s duties as his own. He enrolled him in school, taught him how to manage his emotions, helped him cherish good memories of Sirius even knowing what he had done.
It was Remus who taught Reggie to swim, to ride a bike, and to skateboard. He was the one who gave him his first Walkman, who taught him how to play the guitar, who advised him about Victoria, who had been there for him every step of the way. And it was suffocating to know that, no matter what he did… Reggie only had eyes for Sirius and Scarlett.
He was watching Regulus slip through his fingers like sand through time, just as Nate had. Just as it had happened with Sirius during the Wizarding War. He felt like a failure. He loved Reg as if he were his own son, raised him like a son. And yet, the little boy with shy eyes and an easy smile would always be too busy looking up at the sky, at the stars that would always be out of reach—while Remus remained at his side, untouched.
It was painfully hard to accept that he had raised Reggie all those years only to be cast aside in the end. The presence of Sirius and the existence of Scarlett threatened him more than he wanted to admit, because he knew Reg would always choose them. That in the end, he would always be alone.
He wiped his tears with a worn handkerchief that had once belonged to Fabian Prewett. Thinking of him made Remus’s chest burn like it was on fire, the taste of bile creeping up into his mouth. He had lost so much. So many people. Friends, family, lovers. Sixteen years had passed, but it felt like an entire lifetime.
He still remembered the horrifying sensation when he learned of his mother’s death. He pushed the memory aside with a sharp exhale, trying not to think about all the people he had loved and who were no longer there. Trying… trying not to dwell on the tragedy that was his life, that was the life of everyone he had ever known. Trying…
What was he even trying to do anymore?
He sniffed hard and wiped his tears for good, steadying himself as he swallowed down the anguish threatening to tear out of his chest. He couldn’t fall apart—not here, not at Hogwarts, not in his final minutes as a professor. One of the only respectable jobs he’d held in years.
Remus sighed and bent down to pick up a quill set stored in his desk, catching movement from the corner of his eye. He heard a gentle knock at the half-open door, and when he turned, he saw it was Harry.
His heart dropped, and he forced himself to smile.
"Hello, Harry." He packed the quills into his worn-out suitcase.
"I just saw Hagrid," Harry said, cheeks flushed from running. "And he said you’d resigned. It’s not true, is it?"
"I’m afraid it is." Remus opened the drawers of his desk with more force than necessary and began emptying them.
"Why?" Harry asked. "The Ministry of Magic don’t think you were helping Sirius, do they?
Remus paused for a moment, then moved to the door. Before he could close it, Regulus burst into the room, breathless and dishevelled. He hadn’t wanted to deal with both his nephew and Harry at the same time, but he didn’t have much choice when the two exchanged a wave, full of anticipation.
"Alright, Harry?" Regulus grinned, dropping into an empty chair.
"Hi." Harry bit the inside of his cheek, staring at Lupin.
"No," Remus continued the conversation, ignoring Reg. "Professor Dumbledore managed to convince Fudge that I was trying to save your lives." He exhaled deeply as he sat on the edge of the desk. "That was the final straw for Severus. I think the loss of the Order of Merlin hit him hard. So he — er — accidentally let slip that I am a werewolf this morning at breakfast."
"Order of Merlin?!" Regulus looked properly confused, having walked in halfway through the conversation. "Why the hell would Snape be getting an Order?"
Remus shot Reg a warning look at the language, folding his arms.
"For capturing Sirius," he said, lowering his gaze.
"You’re not leaving just because of that!" Harry looked stunned. "Peter was caught and—"
"This time tomorrow, the owls will start arriving from parents… they will not want a werewolf teaching their children, Harry. And after last night, I see their point. I could have bitten any of you… that must never happen again."
"You’re the best Defence Against the Dark Arts teacher we’ve ever had!" Harry argued, incredulous. "Don’t go!"
Making eye contact with Harry only made his heart twist further—his resemblance to James was uncanny.
"And Peter’s been caught! Who even cares about—" Regulus joined in with Harry, leaving Remus rather thrown off, falling silent as he resumed emptying the drawers.
"How did you… manage to catch Peter?" Remus pretended to be too busy to lift his gaze to his nephew.
Regulus told him everything, from Scarlett’s appearance in her Animagus form in the Hogwarts corridors to his lion Patronus in the Forbidden Forest. Harry listened intently, and Remus couldn’t help the nostalgic smile that tugged at his lips.
"By the way…" Reg pulled the Marauder’s Map from his waistband and handed it back to Remus. "Thought I’d return it to one of its owners… Moony."
The nickname made every hair on Remus’s body stand on end. Reggie was so much like Sirius, and at the same time, some of his mannerisms were an exact copy of Scarlett. And both sides frightened him, because until recently, Sirius and Scarlett were thought to be murderers, and remembering them had been nothing but painful. He didn’t like thinking about either of them.
"You used a Patronus last night too, didn’t you, Harry?" Remus shifted the subject, looking at the boy.
"How’d you know about that?" Harry asked, surprised.
"Reggie’s Patronus alone wouldn’t have been enough to drive off all those Dementors..."
It was Harry’s turn to recount what had happened. When he finished, Remus found himself smiling once more.
"Yes, your father was always a stag when he transformed. You got it right… that’s why we called him Prongs. And Padfoot… well, I’m sure you already know, Reg."
Remus tossed the last of his books into a box, shut the drawers of his desk, and turned to face them.
"Here — I brought this back from the Shrieking Shack last night…" He returned the Invisibility Cloak to Harry. "And…" He hesitated, then handed the Marauder’s Map back to Reggie. "I am no longer a teacher, so I don’t feel guilty about giving you this back as well. It’s no use to me, and I daresay you’ll find uses for it."
"You told me that Moony, Wormtail, Padfoot and Prongs would’ve wanted me to lure me out of school… you said that they’d have thought it was funny," Harry said quietly.
"And so we would have." Remus bent down to shut his suitcase. "I have no hesitation in saying that James would have been highly disappointed if his son had never found any of the secret passages out of the castle. And Scarlett, for that matter! She knows about tunnels no one else can access… I think that’s how she and Sirius managed to sneak in unnoticed…" He grew serious again, trying not to show how upset he really was.
"It’s about them I wanted to speak to you…" Regulus began, but he was interrupted by a knock at the door.
Harry swiftly tucked away the Invisibility Cloak and took the Marauder’s Map from Regulus’s hand, realising he was too stunned to react.
It was Professor Dumbledore. He didn’t seem surprised to find them there.
"Your carriage is at the gates, Remus," he announced.
"Thank you, Headmaster."
Remus picked up his old suitcase, and Regulus hurried over to grab the empty grindylow tank.
"Let me carry it…" he murmured, trying to smile at his uncle, but it was hard to hide how nervous he felt.
"Thank you, Reg." Remus ruffled his hair gently, the way he always did when he was truly grateful for something. "Well — good-bye, Harry. I’m sure we’ll see each other again… you’re welcome to visit the house over the summer if you’d like…" He turned to Dumbledore. "Headmaster, there’s no need to walk me to the gate. I’ll manage on my own..."
"Good-bye, then, Remus," Dumbledore replied soberly. Remus shook his hand and, with a final wave to Harry and a faint smile, left the room with Reggie by his side.
Remus descended the staircase completely devoid of emotion. He didn’t want to give voice to the frustration gnawing at him from within, or the fear flaying him from without. He gripped the suitcase so tightly his fingers turned white.
"Are you going home?" Reggie asked, with a note of hopefulness Remus didn’t share. His only reply was a nod, and the smile that spread across Regulus’s lips made his throat tighten. "Could you… could you take them a letter? I’ll write it quickly…"
"I can," Remus whispered, his mouth tasting bitter, as if he’d swallowed a mouthful of ashes. "Of course I can."
Regulus beamed as they stopped beside a bench. He set the tank down on it and pulled a scrap of parchment from his pocket, along with a quill and a small inkwell. Crouching to the ground, he began to scribble, crossing things out furiously not long after.
Remus remained where he was, holding his emotions in check while his mind wandered to the past—to the day he’d run, breathless and light-headed, to that wretched house of Sirius’s. That day, he was still recovering from the full moon.
Fireworks had been erupting constantly, in bursts of colour and sound above him, casting flickers of warm hues across his face. Remus had looked up at the brilliant colours fading slowly, signalling the fall of Lord Voldemort, but all he needed in that moment was to know Reggie was safe, that he—
The front door had already been open, which only drained what little breath he had left. He drew his wand swiftly.
"Reggie!" he’d called out for the little boy, only to find Alastor Moody pointing a wand at him, and Penny holding Scarlett’s son in her arms.
Regulus had reached out to him, asking to be picked up, his face red and swollen from crying so much.
"Uncle, my daddy!" he’d whimpered, squeezing his eyes shut.
Despite everything that had happened, Remus couldn’t help but smile, lifting him into his arms as the boy’s tears soaked the scars on his face. An indescribable relief washed through him as he held Reggie close, gently rubbing his back, letting him rest his head on his shoulder.
The little boy clung to him, and suddenly the swirling storm of emotions whipping through his chest began to settle, the chaos slowly freezing into place. The world, which had been ripped from under his feet with such violence, began to turn again—slowly, but surely—and he could breathe a little more easily.
"I’ll take him to Nate, Alastor," Remus said, sniffing softly as he looked at the Auror. "Everything’s going to be alright, Reggie, it’s going to be alright…"
The war had taken so much from him. Regulus and Harry were the small seeds of hope sown in a sea of death and devastation. He couldn’t see Harry—not until Dumbledore deemed it safe—but he could see Reggie, his quiet light in those dark, wretched days. A victory that tasted like loss.
James and Lily… Peter and Sirius…
No. He wouldn’t go there. Not now. Moody gave him a look that was part pity, part heavy recognition.
"I’m sorry, Lupin," he said, giving his shoulder a firm pat. "You’re all too bloody young for this… all of you were."
Remus nodded, lowering his gaze to Reggie’s mop of black hair, breathing him in as if the scent could drive back the creeping guilt and grief threatening to consume him like fire on a fuse.
It was the same hair he was staring at now—years later—as Reg sat, head bowed, scribbling his letters. His chest ached once again, full of longing for friends long gone, and the weight of facing the future without them. Of raising the child of two people he had hated for so long. He didn’t realise he was crying, and Reggie didn’t notice—he was far too busy with his letters.
Once more, Remus felt discarded. The air burned like acid in his lungs. Regulus stood up suddenly, folding the parchment and handing it to him in an eager movement. But the smile on his face faded as soon as he caught sight of his uncle’s expression.
"What’s wrong?" he asked gently, reaching up to touch Remus’s chin. "You don’t have to cry, Uncle. Sirius… Sirius said we’d be a family! Me, you, him, Harry… my mum…" With every name, every word that left his lips, Remus felt another knife to the heart.
" You are my family, Reg." He whispered it with such anguish that he could barely see his nephew’s reaction. "But I’ll never be enough."
Regulus stepped back, as if slapped.
"No, no… that’s not what I meant…"
Remus didn’t want to hear it. Didn’t want to hear anything. He took the letters from Reg’s hand and kept walking, too lost in the anarchy whispering in his ears and tearing his chest apart.
"Uncle!" Regulus called after him, grabbing the tank and following. "I meant that all of us—we're going to be together!"
Together? A bitter, scornful laugh rose in Remus’s throat, but he choked it down, quickening his pace to get away from Regulus. There was nothing to be done—he would never be with his friends again. They were all gone. The people who remained—those fragments of Sirius and Scarlett—might have looked like his friends, but they weren’t. Not truly. Not anymore.
Not just because of Azkaban, but...
How could they still be the same after everything that had happened? Each of them had become a fractured, warped version of who they once were. They had to—just to survive in a world that cruel, that brutal. So they wouldn’t be crushed completely. The joyful teenagers they had once been had vanished, and all that remained were shells, constantly trying to remember the past, trying to hold onto a time when all they had to worry about were their grades, their romances, and what careers to pursue.
They were so anchored to the past they couldn’t move forward into the future. James and Lily were gone. Wormtail was in prison. Scarlett had killed the McKinnons… And the most tragic of all was that Sirius still had traces of himself left. He still clung to Scarlett, even when she knew it was a lost cause.
"We’re not going to be together, Reg," Remus whispered, stopping in front of the main gates and glancing sideways at his nephew. "We can’t be a family..."
"But they’re your friends!" Regulus insisted, following him down the steps.
"They were my friends," he corrected, placing himself in front of the carriage without meeting Regulus’s gaze. "Those people… I don’t know them anymore, Reg. I don’t even know if I ever really knew them back then." He faltered, clearing his throat. "But I do know you. And I know your mother is going to hurt you. Don’t build up hope around her. All she’ll bring you is disappointment."
Regulus gasped, eyebrows raised in disbelief. He placed the tank down on the carriage.
"Why are you telling me this?!" He didn’t bother hiding the hurt in his voice.
"I don’t want you to get hurt. Not the way Sirius did." Remus still refused to meet his eyes. Saying it was just as painful for him.
"I know you don’t like her but… please… please could you at least try?! Please, Uncle. You… I love you so much and… I don’t want… you’ve been my family this whole time, but… I want to know them too! I’ve always wanted to… I don’t… please. She can’t be… she can’t be everything you say she is!"
Remus placed his suitcase in the carriage, turning his face towards Reg, though he didn’t dare meet his eyes.
"I truly hope I’m wrong, Reg—and that she proves herself worthy of your love. You deserve that. You’ve always deserved a mother who loved you with all her heart and would bend the world to your will. But sadly… Scarlett isn’t that, Regulus. She’s going to let you down, she’s going to hurt you. Because that’s what she does. It’s who she is."
Regulus stepped back down two steps, breath unsteady as he tried to hold back his tears. Remus wanted so badly to turn around and embrace him, to say everything would be alright, that he would always be there. But he was far too tired—fresh from the full moon, a stressful confrontation, and a humiliating resignation. He was frustrated with his own failure. He had no idea what he’d do for work now.
Before he could even register it, he was seated in the carriage, pulling away from Hogwarts—pulling away from the black-haired, love-starved boy he loved like a son.
Remus leaned back against the bench and began to cry.
Feeling, once again, completely alone in the vastness of a world that had returned to him only the fractured remnants of two of his dearest friends.
It was strange—he’d never spent a single day in Azkaban, and yet he felt just like they did: broken, addicted, and worn down to the bone.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 30: I was losing myself trying not to lose you
Chapter Text
XCVIII
Scarlett thrashed on the floor, her whole body burning as if it were in flames. She couldn’t scream, couldn’t breathe, let alone break free. Red sparks floated in her blue irises, dancing across her skin in erratic movements. All she could hear were the crackling noises and her own desperate attempt to draw breath, the shock coursing through her even more intensely due to the sweat pouring from her body in a vain effort to protect itself or ease the pain.
She woke up boiling hot.
"You alright?" A voice she knew all too well pulled her from her trance, dragging her into those iron-grey eyes. Regulus was lying next to her, head resting on his arm, his ethereal glow mingling with the sunlight pouring into the room, forcing her to squint.
Panting and drenched in sweat, Scarlett forced herself upright, her head still spinning.
"Mm-hmm." She grunted, peeling strands of hair off her cheeks.
The unease the dream had stirred still lingered, hammering in her chest and leaving the tips of her fingers numb.
"You were having a nightmare." Regulus sighed. It wasn’t a question. Scarlett looked at him again, and something twisted in her chest. Memories of lying in bed together, staring into each other’s eyes and sharing all their fears, trying to find comfort and safety in one another.
"It was nothing." Scarlett stood and went to the bathroom to wash her face.
Regulus remained where he was, rolling onto his back, eyes fixed on the stars on the ceiling. When Scarlett returned, she perched on the edge of the bed, and he sat up, wearing that smile with his eyes he reserved only for her, the usual rigidity of his expression giving way to softness.
"I love you." He let it slip, quietly, as though he both wanted her to hear it and didn’t.
Scarlett swallowed hard with an awkward sniff.
"You’re dead." She shot back, turning her gaze to the sunbeams rippling across the light wooden floor.
"That wasn’t enough to kill what I feel for you." Regulus insisted, melancholic.
"That’s not love, Red." She shook her head. "You just… never knew anything better than what I gave you."
Regulus wiped the hurt from his face with a shake of his head.
"I know I can’t compete with him. I never could." He hugged his knees and rested his chin atop them. "But… if I were alive…"
"You’re dead, and I don’t love you." Scarlett cut him off harshly, getting out of bed again. "Stop trying to fill my ears with your lies!"
"I’m not lying!" Regulus roared, clenching his fists until his knuckles turned white. "I never lied about that."
"Then why don’t you tell James and Lily the truth?" Scarlett asked bitterly, glancing sideways at him.
His grey eyes, always cold and impassive, flared with rage. Regulus flared his nostrils and twisted his lips, raising his nose arrogantly.
"Because… Reggie is my son. And you’re my woman. The two of you belong to me, only to me, and if I have any say in it, no one will ever know the truth!" He spat his venom, grinding his teeth, his expression darkened with prideful contempt.
Scarlett wetted her lips and exhaled slowly. It always amazed her how that boy could be so deceitful and manipulative. He had spent years by her side in Azkaban, and she was grateful his presence hadn’t driven her insane… and yet, she felt haunted. He was the proof of all her mistakes, the demon that whispered in her ear, the anchor that dragged her to the ocean floor.
"There it is. The real Regulus Black." Scarlett remarked with a biting smile. "The boy I always refused to see… because I thought you were a much better person than you seemed. Turns out, you’re actually far worse than you let on. You’re a bloody monster, just like your father."
She didn’t wait for a response. She left the room feeling somewhat suffocated, wandering aimlessly through the house, finding Penny preparing lunch in the kitchen. Scarlett still hadn’t gotten used to any of it and tried desperately not to think about tomorrow or Azkaban. Her gaze drifted into the living room, quickly drawn to the piano.
Though she wanted desperately to play it, she backed away as if the instrument might hurt her. She didn’t want to throw her emotions even further out of balance. She stopped walking when she heard Sirius’s voice in the back garden, leaning against the floor-to-ceiling windows and spotting him feeding Buckbeak with huge chunks of meat.
"Stay… stay!" Sirius commanded, stepping back as the hippogriff obeyed him. "Good lad!" He tossed another hunk of meat.
After feeding him, Sirius began to stroke the creature’s grey plumage, talking to the hippogriff, who responded with soft, contented sounds. Sirius smiled so effortlessly that Scarlett felt winded, her hands pressing against the hot glass as she became hypnotised by his laughter while he played with Buckbeak.
That wasn’t the Sirius who had spent twelve years locked away in Azkaban. That was the Sirius she’d fallen in love with, all easy smiles and frivolous mischief. She was so absorbed in the sight of them that she jumped when their eyes met, his beautiful smile deepening and making Scarlett freeze in place, as if it were Medusa herself staring back at her.
Sirius waved for her to come over. Scarlett sighed and shook her head, but he insisted, placing his hands on his hips. She couldn’t help but smile, not with Sirius looking at her like that, the sun kissing his angular face and gilding his cheeks, shining through his long black hair and turning the silver in his eyes into iridescent pools of gold.
"Come on!"
Despite her reluctance, Scarlett gave in and stepped outside, walking towards the garden. Saying no to Sirius was exhausting. He knew how to be persistent.
The midday sun caressed her skin with a warmth that startled her at first, making her glance around as if something were wrong.
She looked up, half-expecting Dementors to be hovering there, but the only things drifting across the blue sky were clouds. Scarlett raised a hand to shield her face from the sunlight, feeling the gentle breeze cooling the intense heat.
She stopped beside Sirius, beneath the shade of a weeping willow. She didn’t remember planting that tree, but her attention was soon captured entirely by the hippogriff and Sirius. The sun shone brilliantly, making the water in the pool glisten as though a myriad of tiny stars danced across its surface.
"I think he likes me," Sirius remarked, not taking his eyes off Scar.
"And who doesn’t?" Scarlett retorted dryly, a little more at ease now, watching the lacy shadows of the leaves dance across the hippogriff’s stormy plumage.
"Snape." Sirius was quick with the reply, and Buckbeak responded in agreement, making Scarlett snort a laugh.
"Snape doesn’t count, he doesn’t like anyone and no one likes him either," she replied, folding her arms.
"Dumbledore does," Sirius went on, pulling another chunk of meat from his pocket. "Can you tie my hair up?"
Scarlett nodded. Sirius crouched beside Buckbeak, who had settled down on the yellowed grass. She ran her fingers through his raven-feather-like hair, gently wavy and soft. The wind stirred the strands slowly as Scarlett combed through them delicately with her fingertips, gathering them into a ponytail.
Sirius sighed, the back of his neck gleaming with sweat as Scarlett began to twist his hair into a bun.
"Sorry… about earlier. A-about the… um, kiss and… for before too… for freaking out…" she stammered, feeling her hands begin to sweat. "I just…"
"I’d have freaked out too if I were you," he said casually. "I get it, Scar. But… I’m the one who shouldn’t have kissed you…"
Scarlett cracked her knuckles as Sirius’s hair began to stick to her fingers, her heart pounding in her chest.
"Then… let’s just forget it ever happened and… move on." She faltered, wishing she could dive into the pool and escape the awkwardness of the moment.
For a long while, all that surrounded them were the sounds of Buckbeak, the water lapping against the edges of the pool, and the summer breeze.
"The Ministry really did think you were dead." Sirius kept stroking the creature as Scarlett finished his bun. "Dumbledore sent me a letter earlier. You’ve got a grave and everything in Azkaban..."
Scarlett inhaled deeply, securing the hairstyle before giving Sirius a small tap on the shoulder to signal she was done. She sat beside him, watching as he ran his hand through his hair.
"Perfect, thanks." Sirius smiled gently, scratching at the beard on his chin. "Dumbledore also said that… well, as far as he knows, you’re officially dead and… no one’s looking for you. But… it’s better you stay here just to… just to be safe."
"Trapped in your house?" She couldn’t help the sarcastic tone as she pulled her legs close and rested her head on them.
"Not… trapped." Sirius wrinkled his nose. "This house is yours too. It’s more… for your safety."
"Oh, right, my safety…" she muttered, staring at the dried grass. "I don’t trust Dumbledore."
"You should."
"I killed the McKinnons, why does he trust me?! I’m a Death Eater, I—"
"You were… not anymore." Sirius corrected her, watching her slowly. "He trusts you."
"He shouldn’t. Neither should you." Scarlett spat, hiding her face in the space between her legs.
Sirius only exhaled loudly, running his fingers along the crest of Buckbeak’s head. She knew what he was thinking, could almost hear his guesses in that bland silence. Sirius was far too clever, but what annoyed her most was how indulgent he was when it came to Dumbledore.
"Can I ask you something?" Sirius didn’t look at her, pretending to be far too occupied giving the hippogriff attention.
Scarlett didn’t lift her face, keeping it buried between her knees.
"You can."
"Is it true that pregnancies in women with a Signet are different? We both know it wasn’t enough time for Reggie to be that developed, even if he was premature."
Scarlett’s heart was beating so fast she could barely feel her limbs. Her blood roared in her ears, and she didn’t dare look at Sirius, staying frozen in place, her palm caressing the withered grass. She felt that if she moved, she might fall apart again.
"Voldemort wanted me to… to have his child." It wasn’t as hard to say as she’d thought. She took a deep breath. "So I was forced to take a potion that… accelerated the baby’s development." She swallowed with difficulty. "He wanted me to have Reggie quickly so that…"
The words died in her throat, overtaken by the sob that seized her vocal cords. Scarlett felt sick. Sick of herself. Sick of what she had allowed them to do to her because she thought it was the only way to save her own. She curled in on herself, clutching the grass as if trying to ease the pressure in her chest. It felt like she might drown at any moment.
Sirius touched her hand gently, slipping his fingers between hers, covering her Signet with his sweaty palm. Scarlett gasped, trembling, looking at him as if he might hurt her. But all Sirius gave her was gentleness, easing her fingers open and guiding her hand to Buckbeak’s soft feathers.
Tears pricked at her eyes and turned Sirius’s face into a blur of white and gold, silver and blue, scarlet and black. He brushed his knuckles along her cheeks, catching the bright trail of her tears.
She had felt lost and abandoned for so long that now, with her life regaining meaning, all she could feel was disorientation.
"I’m sorry, Scar. For everything you went through," Sirius whispered.
Scarlett shook her head, as if trying to say she deserved it. That it was all her fault, the fault of her naivety, her foolishness...
"I’m sorry for everything I put you through," she said, resting her face in Sirius’s palm and letting her fingers drift through Buckbeak’s plumage. Sirius still held her other hand, fingers intertwined, their eyes drawn to one another. "If I’d known… I never should have…"
"Shhh…" Sirius hushed her, slipping his thumb beneath her chin. "It’s over now."
"But you—"
"I need time for that, Scar," he said before she could finish. He knew exactly what she was about to say. Old wounds weren’t easily untangled, nor festering ones quickly healed.
"I’m sorry."
Sirius hissed as he exhaled.
"If you apologise one more time, I’m throwing you in that pool," he warned, serious, though a hint of irony coloured his tone.
Scarlett didn’t care. She was far too focused on the calm that spread through her entire body with the way Sirius gently traced her jaw. She looked up at him, at those starry eyes whose lashes curved like a setting sun over glimmering irises. The world shrank to that small moment, when Sirius let go of her hand and brought his lips close to her Signet, only to be interrupted as Buckbeak shoved his head between them, asking for attention.
"I think he likes you." Sirius took her hand again, guiding it to stroke the hippogriff, who let out a very pleased sound.
She couldn’t help but offer a shy smile when she looked at Sirius again, the tightness in her chest easing little by little, until she felt comfortable enough to stroke Buckbeak without Sirius guiding her.
Scarlett sniffled, running a hand over the bridge of her nose as she swallowed the sob, pushing away all the agony that threatened to steal that light moment from her.
"Have you ever stopped to think about the way we escaped from Hogwarts?" she asked, looking at Sirius without turning her head.
"On the back of a hippogriff while talking about Snape’s sex life? No." Sirius shrugged, trying to keep a straight face as he pressed his lips together.
He turned his head to look at her and they both started laughing. Scarlett felt her entire body tingle with something that had nothing to do with cold or fear. The sound of Sirius’s laugh, mixed with the look of pure happiness on his face, enchanted her so thoroughly that all she could do was let the joy claw its way out of her chest, infecting everything around her.
The colours grew warmer, summer softened, and Scarlett blushed like a teenager. Butterflies fluttered in her stomach. Sirius’s gaze scrambled all her senses.
The moment ended the instant the door to the house opened. They both turned to it, still smiling, only to find a very unimpressed Remus.
"Lunch is ready." That was all he said before slamming it shut.
Scarlett’s smile vanished instantly, joy corroded by guilt. Sirius felt the same, growing visibly uneasy.
They exchanged a brief glance before heading back inside.
.
.
.
Scarlett couldn’t enjoy the delicious summer salad Penny had made. Not only did the dish remind her of Euphemia Potter, but the letter Remus had handed her seemed to stare at her constantly, as though begging to be opened, like the serpent tempting Eve to take the forbidden fruit.
She gave up eating the moment Remus scrutinised her. The atmosphere between them was already dreadful—they hadn’t even greeted each other—and Sirius, despite trying to talk to him, also seemed uncomfortable with the tension. The only one unbothered was Penny, who ate her salad noisily, completely oblivious to the sharp glances and irritated sighs.
Thanking the heavens that Sirius was the first to leave the table, Scarlett followed shortly after, setting her cutlery down and taking the letter with her as she stepped out of the dining room. But Remus followed her, and so did Sirius.
The three of them stopped in the living room, and Scarlett pretended to be wholly absorbed by her piano to initiate the conversation, sitting on the bench and lifting the lid. Sirius leaned against the window beside the instrument, and Remus rested against the wall just behind Scarlett.
"Peter’s escaped." Remus broke the uncomfortable silence, his brown eyes gleaming enigmatically.
"I know." Sirius drummed his fingers on the windowpane, pretending to watch the movement of the other houses.
"Escaped?" Scarlett finally gathered enough courage to speak.
"I didn’t want to worry you about it," Sirius explained, and Remus exhaled in that way he always did when he wasn’t surprised.
"Peter knows you’re alive, doesn’t he?" Remus stroked the scar on his chin.
"And what’s he going to do? Tell the Ministry about her? He’s probably crawling back into some sewer… knows his life’s hanging by a thread. If I or Scarlett—"
"Doesn’t matter." Remus cut him off. "The Ministry hasn’t made any public statement about him, which means no one’s actively looking for him. Not as far as we know."
Scarlett lifted her gaze to Sirius, resting her elbows on the piano lid.
"But then… won’t they clear Sirius’s name?" Scarlett tried her best to keep her voice steady, her eyes scanning the room until they landed on James and Lily, who were sitting on the sofa, listening attentively.
"They’re going to perform Priori Incantatem on both wands… but I think maybe… they’ll do it with you at the hearing," Remus said, looking seriously at Sirius. "And that means…"
"I’ll have to turn myself in to the Ministry." Sirius murmured, licking his lips.
"That’s not going to happen." Scarlett turned to Remus. "They’ll lock him up again…"
"Sirius is innocent, Scarlett. I find it very unlikely the Ministry won’t admit their mistake when all the evidence points to it." Remus cut her off bluntly. "You, on the other hand—"
Scarlett swallowed hard, clutching the letter in her fingers as she stood up abruptly, her face gradually twisting with the emotions beginning to rise.
"What do you mean by that?" Rage trembled in her voice. Remus, whose face was marked by a sarcastic smile, didn’t look away, as if fully aware of the storm he was sowing. "Yes, I killed Marlene!" She charged like a bull, shoving him violently against the wall. His back hit with a loud thud. "I killed the McKinnons, all of them with the Killing Curse!" Scarlett snarled, grabbing the worn collar of his T-shirt. "Is that what you wanted to hear, Remus?! That I’m a murderer? Do you want me to apologise for all the bloody shit that’s happened?" She was screaming so loudly and so close to his face that Remus had to lift his chin, clench his fists and tense every muscle in his body in a herculean effort not to strike back.
Scarlett shoved him again, and luckily Sirius stepped in, wrapping his arms around her from behind and pulling her away from Remus, whose body stayed pressed to the wall because it felt safer that way.
"That’s enough, Scarlett!" Sirius scolded, with that infuriating tone she despised. Scarlett struggled to break free, thrashing as the tears returned. She wanted to leave a scar on Remus’s face, but Sirius wouldn’t allow it, holding her arms and dragging her away from him.
"No… I’m not… I’m not going… back… to… Azkaban!" Scarlett gasped, restrained by Sirius.
Remus, still sheltered by the wall, said nothing. His jaw worked relentlessly to chew through the anger threatening to take over, through the dark instincts whispered in his ear by the wolf. He knew he wouldn’t be able to hold himself back for long, not with the full moon only the night before, not when Scarlett managed to awaken the same violence he had so naturally embraced during the Wizarding War.
Without another word, he turned sharply and marched to the fireplace, throwing the Floo powder with more force than necessary as he called out a destination neither Sirius nor Scarlett heard.
Their breathing was too heavy for that, Scarlett’s entire body shaking with fury and fear as Sirius’s hands dared not release her, as if he feared she might vanish.
Scarlett stopped struggling, wilting in Sirius’s arms, her chest rising and falling rapidly in a desperate attempt to calm her emotions.
"Breathe… just breathe…" Sirius murmured in her ear, lowering himself to the floor as Scarlett’s legs gave out. It felt like she was falling into a bottomless pit and pulling Sirius down with her.
"Let go of me, Sirius…" she mumbled through her sobs. "Let me go, please."
Sirius gradually loosened his grip, letting Scarlett rest against the floor as she wept uncontrollably. She got up with difficulty, leaning over the nearby sofa, her breathing erratic.
Across the room, Penny was watching them with wide, frightened eyes.
Scarlett staggered, curling into herself until she became Whiskers. She leapt onto the piano, grabbed the letter in her mouth, and bolted, hiding in the farthest room of the house, the one that had once been their studio, the place that smelled of mildew and the past.
She tucked herself behind one of the many boxes. She was found by a just-as-stunned Lily. The ghost sat beside her, hugging her knees, watching the soft daylight being blocked by the slatted blinds on the windows. The only light in that room came from Lily herself, who looked at Scarlett with those eyes so green, so kind, and so soothing that it was impossible not to be swept away by them, far from her tangled emotions.
"I’m going to tell you the same thing I told you years ago." Lily brushed her hair back behind her shoulders. "The only way out is through. You can’t trick your emotions forever and you know that, Scar. Feel the fear, the pain, the anxiety, the agony. The anguish. Feel it all… and then, let it go."
Whiskers didn’t want to feel anything. She wanted to be one of those inanimate objects in the boxes, the ones that didn’t have to deal with the complexities of a life stained by crime and punishment. An existence riddled with loss and suffering. But Whiskers was human, despite being in the skin of a cat.
And Scarlett soon shed her feline form, only to be hit by the violent waves crashing against her chest, pulled under by them, hurled into stone walls, spun by the saltwater current. Lily stayed with her the entire time, speaking sweet and encouraging words. Not that it made much difference. Scarlett was underwater, her ears blocked, her breath gone.
She had suppressed her feelings for so long out of fear of pain that she had forgotten not all feelings were necessarily bad. Many of the waves knocked her down and nearly drowned her, but many also tickled her and gently pushed her across the surface, showing her how beautiful the sky was on that summer afternoon. Many were warm, soft, with black hair and starry eyes.
Scarlett clutched the letter to her chest, breathing deeply and slowly, resting her back against one of the boxes, Lily’s concerned gaze a fixed point in the middle of her inner storm. She was smiling, that kind, familiar smile that made Scarlett feel like an idiot for crying and feeling miserable.
"Lils…" she called out to her friend, who shook her head gently. "Have you ever felt uncomfortable in your own skin? In being yourself?"
Lily’s smile held a trace of sadness.
"I have." Her translucent hand passed through Scarlett’s. "My family were Muggles, remember? That feeling followed me through almost my entire childhood..."
Scarlett, her face swollen and eyes red, frowned at the answer.
"Right… your sister was a slag." She gave a forced smile. "How did you… feel… comfortable?"
"I realised that this was who I was… that there was nothing I could do about it, it was beyond my control. That I had to accept myself and love myself as I was… not as I wished to be." Lily pressed her lips into a thin line. "I know… the weight of what you’ve done hangs over you every single day. But, Scar… you… you have to forgive yourself."
"How can I forgive myself when I… killed… five people… with a spell that… only works if you truly… mean it?" she asked, her breath faltering.
"You didn’t have a choice." Lily offered her a soft absolution.
She was right. Marlene knew too much. Scarlett clenched her fists as that realisation washed over her. She knew. She was the only one who knew.
"Why don’t you read your son’s letter?" Lily suggested, her pink lips curving into a smile full of kindness.
Scarlett nodded, breaking the seal with a courage she didn’t feel, unfolding the letter until she was met with a perfectly neat handwriting that looked strikingly similar to her own. The faint ink marks on the page made her realise that Regulus, like her, was left-handed.
Dear Mum,
I hope everything’s alright at Uncle Remus’s house.
I know you like listening to music, so if you go into Sirius’s room and open the second drawer of the desk, you’ll find the walkman that used to be yours. The last tape you listened to is still in there.
I also know you like playing the piano. I don’t think anyone’s ever touched the one in the sitting room, but I’m sure it still works fine.
Your things are in a box on the bed in the room that used to be mine. (The one between the studio and Sirius’s room)
I don’t know if I’ll be able to send you any more letters, but I really wanted to tell you that you’re everything I dreamed of.
Everything Sirius ever told me about you.
There’s so much I want to say, and yet I have no idea what to say!
So, I hope Sirius gets cleared and that we can be a family.
I can’t wait to hear your stories about Hogwarts!
See you in the summer holidays?
Love you!
— Reggie
Scarlett hugged the letter as if she were hugging her son. It was still so strange to accept that she was the mother of a fifteen-year-old boy. She pulled herself together after the tears and offered the letter to Lily, whose lips curved into that kind, familiar smile that always made Scarlett forget all her problems.
"He's so sweet. Always was." Lily looked at her, those green eyes flickering with longing. "When Sirius used to visit us with him… Reg would watch Harry while he slept in James’s lap… and sometimes James would read to both of them and they’d end up falling asleep on top of him…" Her smile was heavy with tenderness, softening Scarlett’s expression. "There was this day when… he asked Sirius… where you were. He couldn’t understand why Harry had both a mum and a dad around. I mean… Sirius told him you’d come back one day. And he waited patiently, but… he liked curling up on my lap. And when he fell asleep, he thought I was you. It’s funny, because… Reg never actually met you. Only saw photos and… still… he couldn’t wait to meet you."
"I thought… I thought he’d hate me. Before… before I saw him." Scarlett filled her lungs with air, holding it. "After… after everything I did… I thought Sirius…"
"It was really hard on him at first." Lily looked toward the light slipping through the slats of the blind, her pale face tinged with gold. "He couldn’t… get out of bed. He was shattered. And during those months you were gone, he drowned himself in drugs and alcohol and… we had to get him clean. So me, James, Remus and Peter…" The last name was spoken with hesitation. "We did everything we could to take care of both of them… until Sirius felt well enough to… be with him on his own. But it was really hard… you’d just been arrested and Regulus had died…"
Scarlett had no more tears left, though she felt the urge to cry as she finally let her breath go.
"I caused all this pain for him and even so…" Scarlett murmured, with a trembling sigh. "Even so he’s here… saying we’re going to be a family and…"
"Sirius changed a lot, Scar. Grew up so much after you were sent away. He became… infinitely better than he used to be. More melancholy too. But he… I don’t know if I would’ve handled things any better with Reggie. I don’t know if I’d have spoken kindly about you to him, not after… after everything."
"He’s so much like the Sirius from before, and at the same time…" Scarlett lowered her gaze, her smile tinged with regret.
"Sirius had to raise the child who was the result of the man he hated with the woman he loved more than he loved himself." Lily continued, her voice taking on a sorrowful tone. "He was so broken that… I’m honestly surprised by how well he’s handling things."
Scarlett exhaled deeply, shaking her head.
"You’re telling me he’s about to explode any moment?"
Lily shook her head.
"No. He doesn’t do that anymore. Not the way you’re thinking… he’s not a ticking time bomb now." She scratched her head, as if considering it. "At least… I hope not."
Scarlett nodded, taking in the sting of Lily’s words in silence. Of course it hurt — hearing all the pain she’d caused Sirius from someone else was very different from her own self-inflicted guilt. The discomfort in her own skin returned with force, a searing tightness blooming in her stomach. She wasn’t sure if she should keep talking or not, but the door to the studio opened and the light came on.
"Alright?" Sirius leaned against the doorframe, arms crossed.
It was so hard to resist the look he gave her. Sirius Black would always manage to surprise her with his effortless beauty, even with the remnants of Azkaban still clinging to him. His pale skin was slowly losing its sickly cast, his hair cascading down to his elbows in such soft waves that he hardly looked like someone who’d spent more than a decade in prison.
Sirius offered her a gentle smile, revealing the dimples not hidden by his thick beard. His eyes sparkled as he drummed his fingers on his arm, as if waiting for an answer.
Scarlett gave him none.
"Scarlett?" He raised one of his thick eyebrows, making her blink as she was snapped out of his powerful aura.
"Sirius?" she whispered, standing up as she folded Reggie’s letter.
"You alright?" he asked again, more slowly this time.
Scarlett shook her head, pressing her lips together. She opened her mouth as if to say something, but changed her mind, merely shrugging and rubbing her fingers against the paper.
"Penny made tea and biscuits." Sirius nodded towards the hallway.
Scarlett bumped into a teddy bear among the boxes. At the sight of it, her heart began to race. She barely noticed herself picking up the grimy, musty little kitten, let alone the fact she was hyperventilating. A movement in her peripheral vision drew her attention to the door, where Sirius had just stepped away.
She carried the stuffed toy with her, setting it on the piano along with the letter. Then she made her way to the kitchen, where Sirius seemed very focused on rummaging through the drawers.
"Will Mistress Black be wanting coffee as well?" the elf asked, scowling at Sirius.
"Mistress Black doesn’t like coffee, Penny." He found a packet of cigarettes at the back of one of the drawers, opening it to check for any left, grinning mischievously as he placed one between his lips. "But she does like tea."
Scarlett stole a biscuit from the table, earning a disapproving glare from Penny.
"They haven’t cooled yet!" she scolded, her face hardening in horror as Sirius, cigarette still in his mouth, leaned over the hob and lit it on the flame heating the water for the coffee. "Master Black… could you please stop acting like a baboon for… five minutes!" she shrieked, making Sirius cover his ears.
"For Merlin’s bloody sake, Penny…" Sirius muttered, holding the cigarette at the corner of his mouth. "There’s no need for all this drama..."
While watching the scene unfold, Scarlett poured two cups of tea, added milk just the way Sirius liked it, and circled the saucers with biscuits.
"Master Lupin doesn’t like smoking in his house!" retorted the elf, her face flushed with irritation.
"You do know this house is mine too, don’t you?!"
"Sirius…" Scarlett called, holding a cup in each hand. "Come on, let’s go to the garden."
He opened and closed his mouth, glancing between Scarlett and Penny before conceding and following her outside.
As Scarlett was greeted once more by the fresh scent of the garden, the setting sun brushed her pale cheeks, freckled nose and chapped lips with soft strokes of gold. Through a corridor of purple clouds tinted pink by twilight, the moon had already begun to rise in a lilac-tinged sky.
She still wasn’t used to that warm breeze. After so much cold in Azkaban, her body found the mild air strangely unsettling. Scarlett set Sirius’s saucer and her own on the pool’s edge before sitting down, sinking her feet into the cold water and watching it lap against the sides, the last rays of sunlight casting a feverish shimmer across the rippling surface.
Sirius settled beside her, dipping his feet in as well, inhaling deeply and blowing the smoke upwards before offering her the cigarette. Scarlett declined, biting into a biscuit.
"Your memory is coming back," she said, eyes fixed on her wavering reflection in the pool.
Sirius sipped his tea, as if weighing his response. The wind carried the ashes from his cigarette away, and both turned to look at Buckbeak, who slept peacefully beneath the weeping willow.
"Because of the coffee? I remember that because it’s not a good memory. And the Dementors made sure I didn’t forget a single bad one." He narrowed his eyes slightly as he smoked.
Scarlett felt a sharp pang in her chest.
"What did I do to make that memory count as a bad one?"
A bitter smile stained Sirius’s lips.
"It wasn’t something you did." That was all he said.
They sat in silence for a while, in between Sirius’s drags of smoke, sips of black tea, and bites of biscuits.
"You talk about me, but you also remember how I take my tea." He licked his lips, wiping them with the back of his hand. "I suppose that makes us even."
"The Dementors didn’t come after me too much." She explained, her eyes on the rippling image of Sirius in the water. "Not that they needed to… it wasn’t like I…" She stopped, noticing the direction the conversation was heading. She cleared her throat, tucking her hair behind her ear. "Actually, I… I wanted to thank you."
Sirius looked at her, tossing his hair back with that same deliberate movement he hadn’t lost after fifteen years. He stubbed out the cigarette on the stone floor, tapping the butt repeatedly.
"For what?" There was hesitation in his voice. Curiosity too.
"Oh, it’s… it’s nothing big." She said it more for herself than for him. "It’s more… for… for what you did with Reg. For taking care of him. And… and for… for saying good things… about me. To him." She cleared her throat again, feeling it tighten. "Thank you."
Scarlett pressed her lips into a near-smile. The silver in Sirius’s eyes refracted the fading tones of dusk, highlighting their oxidised, abandoned depths. A flicker of vulnerability passed through his pupils, leaving him so stunned that he said nothing at all.
They weren’t sitting close enough for Sirius to lean his body into Scarlett’s, but close enough that he could have reached for her hand. It was incredibly hard not to. He felt like it was the right thing to do, something almost instinctive. As though being near Scarlett without touching her skin was simply unnatural.
Sirius blinked a few times, distracted, before catching himself smiling like an idiot.
"Did he… did he say that? In the letter?" He tried to sound as confident as possible. If Scarlett noticed any note of insecurity, she didn’t show it.
"Yes, he… he said…" Scarlett gripped the edge of the pool with both hands. "That I’m everything you told him I was. I assume that’s something good…"
"Yeah, I only told him the good things about you…" Sirius replied, the pale of his cheeks gaining a little colour, his voice dropping lower with every word. "It’s not like I thought the two of you would ever actually meet, so I… I spoke about the Scarlett I hoped you would have been. The mother I wished you were. The woman I…" He didn’t finish the sentence, letting his words stretch thin in the evening air.
Scarlett almost cried again, but no tears came. The shame she felt made her gaze drift away from Sirius, getting lost in the starless sky.
"I just… I only did what I thought was right," he finished, just as embarrassed as she was.
"I really wish I had been the woman you wanted me to be," she confessed, trying not to sound too affected. "I truly do."
"I didn’t like myself back then either." Sirius clenched his jaw as he exhaled. "I… I was losing myself trying not to lose you. And in the end, I hurt you… made you leave."
Scarlett swallowed hard, guilt tearing at her throat.
"It was… it was my choice to leave…" She rubbed her eyes hard, only making them sting more. "When I was imprisoned… I begged every day for you to hate me. It made things easier, because I thought you’d be happier that way. But… at the same time…" She wet her lips. "There was this tiny thread of hope that maybe you still liked me. That maybe you still… loved me." She smiled. It wasn’t one of joy. "It was a stupid, selfish thought, but it’s what kept me sane for a while." That and Regulus’s presence, though she couldn’t say it aloud. "When I realised there was no way out, that I’d be there forever… I wished for you and Reg to be happy… just like Lily and James… Remus… Pete… you all deserved that."
She moved her feet in the water as the garden lights flickered on, along with the pool lights, casting pale tones over her skin. When she noticed Sirius watching her with a blank expression, she wanted to disappear. She didn’t quite know why she was saying all of that—perhaps because she’d kept it bottled up for sixteen bloody years. Perhaps because she finally had everything she’d ever wanted by her side.
It still felt like a dream, the kind of dream she never wanted to wake from, because she knew it would never come back. So Scarlett froze her breath and stopped moving, as if trying to stretch that moment into eternity.
Sirius’s mask cracked into a smug smile touched with misanthropy. The shadows of night caressed his face gently, darkening his eyes and blending into his hair.
"We were happy." He admitted, nodding slowly. "There was a moment, in the middle of all that war and madness… when we were happy. It was brief, but… it was so good." The smile deepened, only to vanish again. "I miss them. I miss those days. I miss letting James comfort me and Lily give me a motherly scolding. I miss the looks, the touches… the voices. Sometimes I panic, thinking I’m forgetting the details… Lily’s London accent and the stupid Muggle slang James used to repeat. The way they smiled… the shape of their faces. Their expressions… their presence."
Scarlett looked around for her ghosts, but they weren’t there. Suddenly, it was as if they were no longer bound to her, and her heart burned. It was exactly what Sirius was going through. She wanted so badly to tell him about her Signet and what it did… but Sirius would never believe her.
To be honest, she barely believed it herself. It all felt like a delusion of her broken mind. Maybe it was. She might have blamed Azkaban, if she hadn’t seen Regulus before she was even sentenced.
She found herself looking up at the sky. The cobalt had swallowed the lilac, but no stars had appeared. Sirius raised his gaze too, brushing his hand against Scarlett’s in a quiet motion. She didn’t move, but a soft smile touched her lips.
"I was happy with you lot," she admitted quietly. Sirius glanced sideways at her, his hair lifting gently in the breeze. "Shame we can’t see the stars in the city."
"Course you can," Sirius rolled his shoulders, letting go of some of the tension. "Look—there… Altair." He pointed skywards. "At the head of Aquila."
Scarlett squinted, trying to make it out, but saw nothing. She tilted her face towards Sirius’s arm, resting her chin on his shoulder as she tried to spot it.
"I don’t see anything."
"I can see it from here!" Sirius shot back, with that infuriatingly smug tone of his.
Scarlett smiled and elbowed him just below the ribs. He let out a grunt.
"There’s no bloody star there!" she protested, kicking her feet in the water.
"There is, you just can’t see it," Sirius rolled his eyes, clearly amused by her reaction.
"You can’t either!" This time, Scarlett laughed. She couldn’t help it. When she noticed Sirius hadn’t responded, she sobered slightly, though she held his gaze, her expression softening with nostalgia. He’d rested his arm back on the ground again, his pinkie brushing hers as if it were the most natural thing in the world.
"What is it?"
Sirius dropped his gaze to their hands side by side, tracing a finger over the back of Scarlett’s, following the path of her pale veins up to her elbow, where he gently stroked her skin with his knuckle, all the way to her shoulder. Scarlett exhaled slowly, the touch sending a persistent shiver down her spine.
She closed her eyes, focusing on the overwhelming sensation of Sirius’s finger gliding along the curve of her shoulder to her neck, stopping just behind her ear where he cupped her whole face. The way his thumb swept across her jaw sent a jolt through her body, awakening memories and feelings that knotted her throat and twisted in her belly.
When she opened her eyes, she was met by those two shining stars. Sirius had moved closer, one hand over hers on the edge of the pool and the other cradling her chin, his face mere centimetres from hers. Her cheeks burned under his piercing gaze, trying to pull her into the shadowed depths of his pupils.
"Sirius?" she whispered. She wasn’t sure if it was a plea or a warning.
Perhaps both.
As if waking from a trance, Sirius blinked several times and straightened up, letting go of her as though she’d suddenly caught fire.
"Nothing," he said, barely audible. "It’s nothing."
It was easy to see the lie in his expression. But Sirius didn’t give Scarlett time to examine him more closely—he pulled his legs from the pool and stood abruptly. He looked so disoriented that he stared out into the garden, lost, before bending down to pick up the cups and heading back into the house like his life depended on it.
Scarlett placed a hand over her heart in an attempt to soothe the swell of emotions threatening to overwhelm her. She turned her gaze back to the sky—so very much like her. Dark, lonely and decaying. Deprived of one of its greatest triumphs: the stars.
With a defeated sigh, Scarlett pulled her now-wrinkled legs from the pool and went back inside.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 31: She is the tear that hangs inside my soul forever
Chapter Text
XCIX
"Do you... do you think Remus will be alright?" Scarlett asked, watching Sirius sitting on the sofa, rereading the letter Reggie had written him. He rested his elbow on his knee and turned his face towards her, but didn’t meet her gaze. As if looking at her was somehow forbidden.
Since the conversation by the pool, he’d been quite withdrawn. His expression was rigid, and he avoided looking at her. They’d had dinner in complete silence, and he’d barely even said goodbye to Penny.
"He knows how to take care of himself," Sirius replied, not really paying her much attention.
Scarlett turned her eyes to the lid of the piano, lifting it slowly, flinching as the ivory keys stared back at her.
"It’s just that… this is his home," she murmured, dispirited, running her fingers across the cold keys.
"This house is yours too," Sirius said, walking over to her, folding up Reggie’s letter and staring at the stuffed kitten beside the music stand. His expression grew so tense it looked like it might shatter, his sharp jaw clenching tight.
Scarlett slowly turned her face to him, meeting his eyes. The distance between them wasn’t far, but it felt like miles. It was because of his stare, fixed on the plush cat. Lost in thought. His hands clenched into fists and his Adam’s apple bobbed hard as he swallowed with difficulty. His long lashes fluttered rapidly, and he jerked his head so hard his neck cracked.
He seemed to come to his senses, stepping back and slowly walking toward the corridor, stopping just before vanishing from Scarlett’s view.
"I'm going to bed," he said flatly, taking a step, then pausing again. "You can stay in the other room. Reggie's old one."
Scarlett didn’t even have time to respond before he disappeared down the corridor. All the courage she’d been gathering to try playing the piano vanished. She pulled her feet up onto the bench and rested her chin on her knees.
Of course she hadn’t thought they’d sleep together. So why did she feel so disappointed after what Sirius had said? He was right. It was what she wanted — to keep her distance from him. Even so, she found herself touching her lips, remembering the kiss he’d given her, the dizzying sensation that had rippled through her entire body.
She shook her head, trying to drive those thoughts away. She pressed the piano’s soft pedal and swapped her self-torment over Sirius for her struggle with the instrument. The notes had flowed so easily when she played in the Shrieking Shack, but now...
It had been easy because that piano had never belonged to her. Now, in the house that once had, on the instrument that had been hers... it was much harder. Scarlett didn’t know what emotions it would stir up — or which memories. She wasn’t sure if she was ready to face them. Not now. She knew there were too many good things… far too many.
But it was exactly the good feelings that hurt the most.
Her hands hovered above the keys, fingers casting shapeless shadows on the polished ivory. Scarlett took a deep breath and closed her eyes, trying to weave some melody, but her arms wouldn’t move. It wasn’t just fear — it felt almost like an instinct for self-preservation. She knew she would fall apart, and she had no idea whether Sirius would be there to catch her again.
Better not to risk it. She’d leaned on him far too much already. She couldn’t do that to him — she wasn’t that cruel… even though, as selfish as it was to want him, she knew full well she’d never have him again. Not in the same way. It wouldn’t be fair to him.
"The piece you played in the Shrieking Shack..." Regulus’s voice made her stiffen, her gaze searching until it found him at the far end of the room, in front of the window facing the pool. The same window where she’d watched Sirius feeding Buckbeak earlier. "The same music you played when you first met Sirius. You also played it at Grimmauld Place."
He stood side-on, not looking at her. His green frock coat gleamed against the glass of the window, as translucent as he was.
"I don’t remember playing it," Scarlett said, swallowing hard against the bile that burned her throat.
"What do you remember from your time there?" Regulus slowly turned his face towards her, his iron-grey eyes catching all the light from the lampposts and the moon, turning the same shade as Sirius’s eyes.
Red’s eyes, naturally dark, always needed a lot of light to spark like stars... unlike his brother’s, which were paler and brighter by nature. A very fitting reflection of the two of them: the sun and the moon. The heir and the spare.
"Not much," Scarlett murmured, glancing down the corridor to make sure Sirius was asleep. She didn’t want him hearing her talking to herself. "I remember… us." Her gaze dropped to the floor, refusing to meet his. "But they’re… scattered fragments. They fade so easily. Why?"
Regulus leaned back against the window, hands tucked into his pockets, looking straight at her.
"Nothing," he lied, glancing outside, his black hair brushed by the shimmering reflection from the pool. "Let me know when you remember."
Scarlett wanted to ask, wanted to know why it mattered so much to him. It wasn’t the first time he’d brought it up — but before she could speak, he stepped through the glass, joining Lily and James in the back garden.
She sighed in frustration and closed the piano lid, watched only by the plush kitten.
She ran her fingers over the mould-speckled snout, ignoring the bubbling sensation in her chest. The silence of the night was broken by the fridge clicking in the kitchen, by the faint hum of electricity coursing through the walls, by the soft buzzing of some electronic device inside the cabinet.
After spending so long in the inhospitable silence of Azkaban, those sounds were easy to pick up. Even easier to be affected by — the whole atmosphere felt heavy. Stifling. She stood and walked over to the cabinet, pushing past the stacked vinyls, recoiling instinctively from the scent of ashes that clung to them.
Scarlett turned her attention to the record player, eyeing the vinyl that gleamed under the room’s light, then the album sleeve that bore Jeff Buckley’s name and the title Grace. She placed the needle on the vinyl and turned the volume down to the bare minimum, looking for the switch to turn it on.
"No… James, no… please…"
It was Sirius’s voice.
"Please, please, please..."
Scarlett froze.
"JAMES!"
Before she knew it, she was bolting down the corridor, clumsily drawing her wand as she burst into Sirius’s room.
The room was drowned in darkness, lit only by the wailing lights pouring in through the single window not covered by blinds. Sirius jerked his head violently to the side, mumbling incoherently, his face and bare chest glistening with sweat. Scarlett didn’t hesitate, her unsteady hands fumbling across the mattress until they reached his shoulder, shaking him firmly.
"Sirius, wake up..." she said, quieter than she should have. "Sirius..."
Scar gasped sharply when she was grabbed by the shirt and thrown down onto the bed with such force the air was knocked from her lungs. Sirius rolled on top of her in a reflexive act of self-defence, one elbow pinning her throat, the other hand still clutching her shirt. Her wand clattered to the floor.
Sirius’s hair fell over her shoulders like a cascade of shadows, his entire body taut. His rapid breathing was the only sound between them, his grey eyes wide and dilated. If he’d been in Padfoot’s form, his hackles would’ve been raised, teeth bared, ready to strike.
Moonlight flared in his silvery eyes, snapping him out of the trance as he slowly began to recognise her. His predatory stance softened gradually and he exhaled a sharp breath, releasing his grip on her. His face went pale as his expression relaxed, brushing away a stray tear with his shoulder. He sat up slowly on the bed, blinking several times.
"Sorry... I didn’t..." he faltered, groggy. "I didn’t mean to do that. I thought..." His voice broke and he rubbed his eyes with his knuckles, forcing out the tears. "I’m sorry."
Scarlett remained still, her entire body tense, her heart pounding in her throat. She truly thought he was going to hurt her, and although part of her believed she deserved it, the shock still pulsed through her veins.
She opened her mouth to say something, but Sirius wrapped his arms around her waist and buried his face against her stomach, nestling himself between her legs, clutching her desperately. Holding her as though trying to banish the terrifying sensation of the nightmare.
For a moment, Scarlett was too stunned to react. In the next, she reached out for him, resting one hand on his bare shoulder while the other slid through his long black hair, feeling his heavy, uneven breathing against her abdomen.
“It’s alright now,” she murmured, lifting her head to look at him. “I’m here.”
“I know,” Sirius breathed, the warm words trailing over her skin.
His back shimmered in the moonlight, revealing his tattoos. Some she recognised, others she didn’t — many were runes.
She remembered how fascinated he’d become with them in their final year at Hogwarts and caught herself smiling, though the faint flicker of joy quickly dimmed as her gaze returned to Sirius — to the face hidden behind his dark hair, the strands shifting slightly with his ragged breath.
“It was a nightmare, wasn’t it?” she asked, the question more rhetorical than anything. Sirius nodded in response. “You were… calling for James…” With every word, her voice grew softer. He nodded again.
Scarlett fell silent, waiting for Sirius to speak… but he said nothing. She stroked his hair gently, pushing it from his face, brushing her fingers along the stubble of his cheeks, tracing the line of his sideburns, lightly scratching his scalp. It was a touch born of instinct, but she froze the moment he gripped her shirt and tugged it upward, exposing the scars that ran across her waist.
She wanted to cover them, but it was too late — Sirius’s fingers were already gliding over them, as though committing each one to memory. Scarlett held her breath like she’d been shocked. The touch scrambled her heartbeat, sending shivers through her body in a way that made her gasp. Sirius noticed, lifting his gaze, locking eyes with hers.
“It’s alright. I’ve got scars too.”
It was hard — unbearably hard — to be looked at like that. By those eyes that pierced straight through to her soul with such ease, that invaded her in a way that didn’t hurt. That made her feel unbearably exposed. Sirius had always been immune to her defences, slipping through them with maddening simplicity. That was how he stole her heart, how he took her virginity, how he asked her to marry him.
It had always been that way with Sirius Black — he asked the question, and the answer was always yes.
Scarlett tensed when he lifted her chin and his hands slid beneath her shirt like a wave spilling over the shore. She drew in all the air she could manage, Sirius’s fingertips leaving trails of fire across her skin.
She wanted desperately to say something, but it was as if she’d forgotten how to speak. A tingling sensation rippled through her entire body, making her legs tremble and forcing the breath from her lungs. His hands settled on her waist, fingers pressing into her pale skin until she bit her lip when his nails dug in.
Sirius braced his knees on the bed and moved over her, lifting her shirt with him until he pulled it off. She wasn’t wearing a bra — fair enough, as he was shirtless too. Scarlett covered her breasts with her hands, cheeks blazing. Sirius gave her a crooked smile, their faces so close that the air she breathed in had just left his lungs. His black hair curtained the world around Scarlett’s face, letting only a few strands of light filter in, glinting in those sea spray-tossed blue eyes.
He leaned in, pressing their foreheads together in a silent promise of a kiss, but didn’t move further. As if asking for permission. Scarlett, mesmerised, watched his pupils drink her in with reverence. And that was all it took for her heart to turn the aching void inside her into something else — into acceptance. The way she’d been feeling lost and alone faded, replaced by the pull that surged in her chest and tugged Sirius in like a tide. Or perhaps the pull had always been his.
But it was that thing — that unnameable thing — they both knew so well. The thing that let them hold each other fully, even on days they didn’t know who they were. That gave meaning to words never spoken, promises never made, wounds never healed.
Scarlett felt her eyes sting. She carried so much in her heart; life had not been kind to her. Anxiety and fear for the future tried to betray her, creeping in to whisper in her ear — but Sirius’s very presence melted them away into warmth, into tenderness, into certainty.
She parted her lips and that was all the answer he needed. Sirius closed the space between them, grazing her lower lip with his teeth, tracing the edge of her mouth with his tongue. Scarlett gasped, and Sirius kissed her like it was the first time — slow, exploring, with languid strokes of his tongue, letting the weight of his body gradually sink into hers.
Sirius braced his knees on the mattress, one hand on Scarlett’s cheek, the other trailing down her neck, feeling her breath hitch beneath his palm, the stubborn way her throat moved under his touch. Her arms were still between them, shielding her breasts. The kiss deepened — bold, breathless, consuming. Scarlett let all her breath dissolve into the taste of Sirius’s mouth, shivering at the soft caress of his thumb along her throat.
Being in that position was utterly disarming. She was completely vulnerable. Sirius could do whatever he wanted to her — and Scarlett wanted that. Her legs gave way, relaxing and opening for him to settle between them. Sirius instantly pressed his erection against her pelvis, drawing a sharp arch of her hips.
He grasped her chin, turning her face to the side with a swift motion as he continued kissing down along her jaw, tracing the path of pulsing blood along her neck, the other hand anchoring her by the curve of her shoulder, making her a prisoner of his lips.
Scarlett spread her fingers over Sirius’s chest when he moved to lie on top of her. She opened her mouth to speak, but all that escaped was a loud gasp — the way he sucked on her skin made her entire body writhe, until he bit her, hard.
It was enough to make her moan, feeling Sirius’s arousal throb between her thighs despite the layers of clothing still separating them. He looked up at her with a ravenous gaze, lit with surrender. Scarlett realised then — she did have a kind of power over him. She just didn’t want to use it. Not yet. Not when he was dominating her with such skill, not when walking that sharp edge felt so fucking good.
Sirius released her chin, sliding his hand down her side until it found its way between her legs, drawing slow, teasing circles on her thighs as he stamped kisses and scorching breaths onto her neck.
Scarlett was dazed. Her entire body slowly coming alight with a heat she hadn’t felt in so long — a pulsing need in her core, a knot tightening in her belly, Sirius’s thumb sketching an erratic pattern of chills along the inside of her thigh.
“Sirius…” Scarlett said his name like a caress, sending a shuddering wave through both of them. “We can’t… we can’t do this.” He was still savouring the slender column of her neck — until he caught the salty scent of her tears.
It was nearly impossible to think rationally with his body pressed against Scarlett’s like that, but Sirius didn’t need to deliberate. He never had to beg for Scarlett’s love; it was one of the few he’d never had to work for.
“This doesn’t have to mean anything,” he murmured against her damp skin, marked by his lips, even though they both knew it would mean everything.
Scarlett desperately wanted to push him away and run. But she also wanted him to stay right there, on top of her, wanted him beneath her — inside her. Slowly, she moved her arms from between them, allowing Sirius to press his chest to hers, pale feverish skin scorching away any hesitation she might’ve held. Her fingers tangled in his black hair as he trailed kisses down her throat.
Sirius rose and claimed her mouth again. There was no gentleness left, no caution or restraint. He gave himself over to Scarlett completely, biting her cracked lips as his hands travelled lower, mapping every inch of the body that had always belonged to him. He traced the sharp lines of her collarbone, the curve of her breasts, the rise and fall of her ribs.
The kiss broke once more, and Scarlett moaned beneath Sirius’s gaze as he began to nip at her nipple. Starry-grey eyes darkened with desire as he deliberately brushed his stubble over her areola, making her shudder from head to toe.
He took one of her hands and guided it down to his erection, drawing a sharp gasp from her at the surge of sensation. He sucked her nipple harder, releasing it with a deliciously depraved sound.
“What do you want, kitten?” he murmured, dragging his stubble purposefully across the space between her breasts, leaving a reddened trail in his wake.
Scarlett rolled her eyes back, her head sinking into the mattress as a helpless weakness seized her body — tightening low in her belly.
Her gaze locked with Sirius’s, drawn to the precipice of those ravenous pupils, her lower lip trembling as her chest rose and fell with a weight that had nothing to do with his body pressing into hers.
He’d said it didn’t mean anything. But Scarlett wanted it to mean something. She knew she had no right… but deep down, she wished it could mean they might end up together… even though she knew full well that would never happen.
“I want you,” she managed, swallowing hard, the moonlight illuminating the tattoos across Sirius’s chest — the single word inked above his heart. Scarius.
It was all he needed to hear. The rest of her sentence dissolved into her mouth as Sirius kissed her again, full of need and longing, as if he could drag from her the same answer to that thing burning in his chest, searing and freezing all at once.
It was there — in the heat of the kiss, in the tremble of the touch, in the thrum of two hearts beating in painful resonance.
Scarlett tasted of sin, and Sirius was the most repeat offender of all sinners, kissing her with ferocity, burning in that blinding, lashing passion, that delicious martyrdom, unleashing every restraint that had kept him from making her his. Scarlett grabbed his cock over his trousers, and that was his undoing.
Sirius yanked down Scarlett’s shorts and knickers in one swift motion so fast she barely had time to react, left completely naked, a pang low in her belly at the way Sirius devoured her with his gaze, lingering on her scars in such a way that she instinctively covered her waist with her hands.
He noticed, leaning forward to her abdomen, his long hair brushing against her goose-pimpled skin. He placed a soft kiss just above her navel, gently taking one of her hands and moving it aside, making Scarlett press her lips together and shut her eyes in embarrassment and exposure. Sirius caressed the scars branching like lightning across her belly, kissing each one slowly, tenderly.
Scarlett wept once again, hating him for making her feel so accepted. Her body wasn’t the same anymore, not the one he had known, and still there he was, worshipping her as if they were eighteen again and had some kind of future ahead of them.
Sirius lowered his head further, scraping his beard against her abdomen, running his fingers over her cunt, grunting at how wet she already was. He pressed his thumb to her clit, and Scarlett moaned, her whole body quivering with the electricity that melted her muscles.
He watched eagerly the way Scarlett writhed when he circled that special spot. Sirius bit his lower lip as he brought his hand lower and slid a finger inside her, closing his eyes at how tight and wet she felt.
He lifted his gaze to Scarlett, her mouth letting out shallow breaths, face flushed, tears shimmering on her cheeks like tiny stars. Her legs trembled as if she were on the edge. Sirius moved his finger, and it was enough to make her tilt her head back with a drawn-out moan, her walls clenching him over and over.
Sirius added a second finger, and Scarlett tensed, clawing at the sheets and digging her heels into them, the moan of pleasure turning into a cry of pain. He didn’t move his hand further, waiting for her to adjust to the stretch of his two fingers. He briefly recalled the night he’d taken her virginity.
His cock throbbed beneath his trousers, and he withdrew his fingers only to sink them back in again, drawing a whimper from her as he revelled in how slick she was, fighting the thought of being inside her with his cock. He was certain he wouldn’t last long.
Truth be told, Sirius was already close just from seeing her like that.
He began moving his wrist again, slowly, feeling Scarlett tense her entire body once more.
"Does it hurt?" he asked softly, hoping the answer would be no. "You’re too tense."
Scarlett blinked a few times, nodding.
"I need... I need you," she stammered, her eyes clouded with lust.
Sirius buried his fingers inside her as deep as he could, and Scarlett turned her face to the sides, a pained expression twisting her features.
"You can’t take two fingers..." he pointed out, even though he ached to sink into her and finally make her his. "I’ll hurt you..."
"I know... but I need you. Please... I need..." She couldn’t finish the sentence, as Sirius curled his fingers and pushed them upwards, making her mouth fall open with a loud moan.
"Are you sure?" Sirius felt her walls clench around him in a rhythm that took him by surprise. If he kept going, she was going to come.
"Fuck... fuck... yes, Sirius, please..."
[Music: Jeff Buckley – Lover, You Should’ve Come Over]
Sirius pulled his fingers from Scar, earning a breathy whimper of protest, but he was already shoving down his trousers, smearing his cock in her wetness before climbing over her body again, covering her with his own, grunting as he bit down on her lower lip and pulled it into his mouth.
Without giving Scar time to recover, Sirius captured her lips with his once more, plunging his tongue deep as he pressed the head of his cock against her drenched cunt.
Their eyes locked—her pupils blown wide, the blue of her irises clear and luminous. She raised her hips with a desperate moan and threw her head back as Sirius sank into her with one long thrust, hissing at the tight grip of her walls around him.
Looking out the door I see the rain
Fall upon the funeral mourners
Parading in a wake of sad relations
As their shoes fill up with water
She clung to his arms with such force that Sirius felt the sting of her nails digging into his skin—and it only drove him further into madness, pushing in and pulling out in long, slow strokes, a guttural moan rising from his throat.
Sirius stayed buried inside Scarlett for a few moments, giving her time to adjust to him, even though she was so tight it was hurting him. Still, he didn’t relent, waiting for her to mould around the shape of his cock, trying to mark her as his in every way possible.
Maybe I'm too young
To keep good love from going wrong
But tonight you're on my mind
So... you'll never know
Scarlett was breathing fast, completely dizzy from the burning, aching sensation. It felt as though Sirius were tearing her apart from the inside, and something warm was dripping between her legs. She opened her eyes slowly, met by a sea of mercury, swallowed by the gleaming silver of Sirius’s irises. He pressed his forehead to hers, his hot breath brushing against her lips before he kissed her again. Scarlett’s hands disappeared into his long black hair, trailing down his tattooed, sweat-slicked chest, scratching over each design, committing every sharp bone to memory.
Broken down and hungry for your love
With no way to feed it
Where are you tonight?
Child, ya know how much I need it
Sirius Black was a masterpiece, even after a decade in Azkaban. He was a demon who made her head spin and her body burn, who would make her regret every choice—right or wrong. Being connected to him like that, after so long, was intoxicating. She could live in those star-like eyes, even knowing everything she’d done to him.
Too young to hold on
And too old to just break free and run
Scarlett kissed Sirius back, those three little words caught in her throat, trying to reach her vocal cords—but Sirius moved, breaking the eye contact to look down where their bodies were joined, his eyes widening slightly.
"Scar... I think... I think I hurt you," he said slowly, like he was drunk. "You’re bleeding."
"I know," Scarlett exhaled through her mouth, wrapping her legs around Sirius’s waist. "Don’t stop."
"But—"
Scarlett reached up, clutching a fistful of his dark hair, stealing the words from his lips as she pulled him down and kissed him.
"I know. I told you to keep going, for fuck’s sake," she whispered against his mouth, hooking her heels into his arse and tilting her hips upwards.
Sometimes a man gets carried away
When he feels like should be having his fun
Much too blind to see the damage he's done
Sometimes a man must awake to find that
Really he has no one
She didn’t have to say it twice. The next moment, he was thrusting into her again—no hesitation, no gentleness. He gripped her shoulders and buried himself so deep that Scarlett cried out in pain as he struck her cervix, giving her no time to recover. Sirius set a brutal rhythm, drawing moans of sheer ecstasy from her lips.
So I'll wait for you, love
And I'll burn
Will I ever see your sweet return?
Oh, will I ever learn?
Oh-oh, lover, you should've come over
'Cause it's not too late
Sirius completely lost control as he danced along the razor-thin line between pain and pleasure, growling with the physical strain, his hands sliding down to her hips to pull her into him as he slammed forward. Sweat began to drip from his brow, falling onto Scarlett’s breasts, her eyes trailing over his tattooed torso with a reverent fascination, all the way down to where their bodies were joined.
He looked down too, watching his cock appear and disappear inside her. Panting, never breaking the rhythm of that obscene dance, Sirius trailed one hand up over Scarlett’s breasts and into her hair, tugging her close until their noses touched and their eyes locked. She bit down on her lower lip to muffle the moans falling from her mouth, her brows drawn together in that expression Sirius knew so well.
She was close.
So was he.
Their gaze never faltered as they reached their climax—together.
Lonely is the room, the bed is made
The open window lets the rain in
Burning in the corner is the only one who dreams
He had you with him
The sensation was shattering. Scarlett cried as she moaned Sirius’s name, her entire body convulsing with waves of pleasure while he licked her tears slowly, his hot tongue gliding across the freckles on her cheeks as he bathed in that delirious blend of pain and bliss, her blue eyes never leaving his.
My body turns
And yearns for a sleep that won't ever come
It's never over
My kingdom for a kiss upon her shoulder
It's never over
All my riches for her smiles
When I've slept so soft against her
Sirius nipped at her lips and pushed her back against the mattress, pinning her beneath him as he emptied himself inside her with one hot spurt after another, growling, snarling. She wrapped her arms around him, still writhing in that fusion of iron-tanged blood, the thickness of semen, the salt of tears, the sheen of sweat and the acidity of saliva. Dazed, she felt Sirius’s heart pounding against hers, their breaths stitched together, their eyes searching for everything they had lost and found again in each other.
It's never over
All my blood for the sweetness of her laughter
It's never over
She is the tear that hangs inside my soul forever
The emptiness inside them was drowned by the fire that lit and consumed them, that transformed them into this erratic, desperate blaze, overflowing into a kiss that burned and seared, that needed oxygen and petrol, that demanded far more than they could ever give. That love which turned them to ash, which destroyed them and ground them down, that love which had kept them sane—the cause of all their crimes and all their sentences.
It was love and hate, hurt and longing. All the words they hadn’t said in fifteen years apart. That time hadn’t been enough to kill it—it was chronic by now; Sirius didn’t know how to be without Scarlett, and the feeling was mutual. They needed each other like they needed oxygen.
And that terrified them.
Terrified Sirius, especially.
Oh, but maybe I'm just too young
To keep good love from going wrong
Scarlett was springtime. His springtime, making a hundred flowers bloom in his chest. Primroses, poppies, wisterias, magnolias, lilacs, lilies, petunias... roses of every colour, thorns and all. She brought out the best in him—the arrogant, self-assured Sirius, the Sirius who hated as easily as he loved, the Sirius who had once begged her never to leave.
Oh-oh-oh, lover
You should've come over, yeah, yes
Yes, I feel too young to hold on
And much too old to break free and run
Too deaf, dumb and blind to see the damage I've done
Sweet lover, you should've come over
He had missed this. Scarlett made him feel alive, as if he hadn’t just spent twelve years in Azkaban, as if all his misfortunes mattered because they were shared with hers. Only she could understand him—they were two fragments of a tapestry woven by the flavours of friendship and the bitterness of loss. She was his other half in the mirror. She always had been, ever since he first saw her playing the piano at Godric’s Hollow, Sirius had known—forever—that his path was set, and that woman would be his downfall.
Oh, love, well I've waited for you
Lover, lover, lover
Lover, love, love, love, love, love, love!
Lover, you should've come over
'Cause it's not too late
They stayed like that for quite some time, staring into each other, still joined in a connection that was far more than the pleasure of flesh or the pain of belonging. It was the lack of certainty, the fear they might simply vanish. The disbelief at being together again. The acceptance of all their new fractures within an undefined mosaic.
It was the exposure of everything they needed to heal in one another, the embracing of what was missing, the understanding that things were chaotic—but that was okay.
Because they were together.
That all the fear of abandonment, rejection, neglect, betrayals, violence and silencing hadn’t been for nothing. That it all meant something.
It had to mean something.
Sirius loved Scarlett and Scarlett loved Sirius, and they were no longer those two reckless youths. They were much more—and far less. They were everything and nothing. They were broken in a way that could never fully mend, but they were older now. They were… held.
Scarlett hugged him tightly, and Sirius cupped her face in both hands, slowly pulling out of her, still hard. She let out a painful gasp, and Sirius kissed her in a silent apology, dragging his lips once more along her neck, using his tongue, trailing tender kisses down her body.
Her collarbones, her breasts, her ribs, her navel, the burn mark on her right forearm—one Sirius also bore—the scars at her waist where she instinctively curled inwards, reaching for the bedsheet. But Sirius didn’t let her hide. In a sudden movement, he flipped her onto her stomach.
Scarlett tried to resist, attempting to turn back and shield the marks on her back, but Sirius was already tracing them with his fingertips, making her close her eyes and bury her face in her hands. She felt his lips brushing her tattoos on the nape of her neck and shoulder blade, moving down her spine, his fingers gliding along her curves, stopping at the place she knew was the most affected part of her body—where she had so often been hit with the Cruciatus at near point-blank.
The marks were spiral-shaped, spreading in lightning-like patterns in an intricate web, reaching halfway up her spine and branching out, crossing her waist to her belly. They stretched just above her hips, with some tendrils nearly reaching her shoulders. It was hard to tell their full extent just by looking; the moonlight made Scarlett’s pale skin even paler, making the scars blend and shimmer.
But Sirius felt each one of them beneath his hands, kissing them, letting his beard leave a trail of red across her soft skin, descending to her arse, where he bit her right cheek. Smiling and kissing every inch of her with adoration.
Despite the discomfort, Scarlett smiled too, casting him a side-glance full of intensity. Sirius’s hair fell over her body as he gripped her right ankle and lifted her leg, kissing it, trailing to her calf, biting at her thigh...
"What are you doing?" Scarlett panted, her face flushing.
"What I should’ve done before you left," he looked up at her. "Worshipping you."
Scarlett let out a dry, ironic laugh.
"There’s nothing to worship," she murmured, mostly to herself. "My body isn’t the same anymore."
"Neither are we. For better or worse," Sirius went on, unfazed, scattering kisses along her back until he reached her ear, biting the lobe and drawing a gasp from her. "Besides, I’m just repaying what you did for me. I know exactly what it’s like to be ashamed of your own body..."
His needy lips traced Scarlett’s left shoulder, his hands running over her curved hips as he turned her onto her back, pulling her on top of him. She rested her head on his chest, feeling Sirius’s rough fingers glide over her back in a familiar caress, hair sticking to her marred skin, his beard prickling against her forehead.
"If I weren’t so bloody dehydrated after coming that much… I’d fuck you again," he murmured, velvet-voiced and wicked.
She rolled her eyes bashfully, her gaze slipping to the tattoo above his heart, and found herself smiling, feeling the pulse beneath her fingertips as she traced the little word inked there. She knew Sirius was watching her, but she pretended to be too busy to give him the satisfaction.
"I didn’t know this one," Scarlett commented, leaving her hand there as Sirius’s heartbeat thudded harder, more defiant.
"Yeah, neither did I," he sighed, his fingers trailing goosebumps over her Signet. "Woke up one day and it was just… there."
Scarlett raised a brow at him, but Sirius merely shrugged, inhaling audibly. He didn’t know what else to say. There wasn’t much left to say. He didn’t want to ask whether it meant anything. If it didn’t… then why were they holding each other like this, as if they’d never been apart? Why was his heart racing? And why did she feel so bloody at ease in his arms?
"Did I hurt you too much?" he asked suddenly, breaking the awkward silence, his hand coming to rest at the base of her spine, stirring a pleasant tingling through Scarlett’s worn-out body. He used to place it there every night when they were just students at Hogwarts, right before they fell asleep.
"I’ve been through worse," Scarlett muttered sarcastically, though the grim weight of the response wiped the smirk from Sirius’s face.
"I’m sorry." He kissed her forehead.
"It’s fine. It’s over." She replied in a tone that meant the exact opposite. "Ruined half my body, but it’s over."
Sirius felt a stab in his chest.
"It didn’t ruin your body," he frowned. "That’s impossible."
"Of course you’d say that… I’m the first person you’ve shagged in… Merlin knows how many years…" Scar shook her head dismissively. "I mean… my breasts—" she turned onto her side, cupping one of them.
"They’re not saggy." Sirius’s brows knitted in honest confusion.
"I didn’t say they’re saggy!" Scarlett shot him a glare, indignant. "Just… not as perky as they used to be…"
Sirius laughed, stroking his beard.
"Of course not, you had a kid. They got bigger."
"They didn’t—"
Scarlett stopped talking the moment she realised the absurdity of the conversation—especially with the mention of Reggie. Sirius noticed. His smile vanished without a trace. He took a deep breath, as if trying to oxygenate his thoughts.
"Sorry." She lowered her gaze, making a move to pull away, but Sirius didn’t let her.
"For what?"
"I don’t know. For everything."
"Everything? You regret everything?"
Scarlett shook her head.
"Everything I did to you. For…" Her heart clenched painfully in her chest.
"Do you regret what we had?"
She wanted to say no. But she didn’t want to lie.
"Yes. I never meant to make you suffer." She admitted, her voice trembling. "I’m sorry."
Sirius tapped his fingers gently against her spine, the warmth of his palm spreading through Scarlett’s body like venom.
"I made you suffer too." Sirius’s gaze was dragged into the past. Memories corrupted by Dementors, crashing into each other until they became a never-ending nightmare. He hugged Scarlett tightly, using her fierce presence to drive them away. "Forgive me?"
Scarlett let out a huff of laughter.
"Of course I forgive you." She ran her fingers through his hair as he loosened the embrace. Scarlett wanted so badly to ask if he could forgive her too, but she feared the answer. It was too soon to ask again. She knew Sirius Black well—knew how bitter he could be. Resilient too.
"Sirius… what do you remember?" she asked after a long stretch of silence.
"What do you mean?" He closed his eyes as Scarlett traced her fingers through his beard.
"The past. What do you remember?"
Sirius tensed his jaw. With his free hand, he brushed over the back of his thighs, where countless scars left by his parents marred his skin. He kept his eyes shut, summoning the memories in the darkness behind his lids.
"I remember you crying. And me crying because I was the one who made you cry," he confessed, voice wavering. "The day I… hit Reg. My brother." He struggled to breathe, clenching his eyes shut as the lines of his face began to crack. "James… in the rubble…" A tremor rippled through his body uncontrollably. Scarlett lifted her head, catching the way Sirius’s expression was slowly fracturing. "Lily…"
Sirius realised he was crying. Silently, without sobs or gasps. He was crying, and Scarlett was wiping away his tears with her thumbs.
"You, in a bed soaked with blood… me holding Reggie in my arms and thinking… wishing… that he was mine… of… of James… fallen. His eyes, Scar… his eyes…" Sirius placed a hand over his mouth as the sob took hold of his throat. "He was lying at the bottom of the stairs… dead. I remember the all-consuming cold, the silence, the feeling of my heart being torn to shreds in my chest. The pain was so deep it… it felt like my soul was being ripped from my body. He died… and I couldn’t do anything. I… I miss him so much. So much. I still can’t believe it…"
Sirius buried his face in Scarlett’s neck, pulling her closer, as if he could take shelter inside her. Seeking the safety that dulled his senses and soothed his pain—but not even she could muffle the agony of having lost his best friend. His brother. His soulmate. James had been everything Sirius ever wanted to be, everything he wished he were—his example, his compass, his favourite person in the whole fucking world.
And it hurt—Merlin, how it hurt—to know he’d never see him again. Hurt even more to know he never got to say goodbye. That his friend died on some stupid Halloween fantasy night and he hadn’t even been there to celebrate with them. That James left—and left him behind in this world. Sirius wished he’d been at the Potters’ house that night. If not to save them, then at least to die with them.
He sheltered in Scarlett like a fool taking refuge beneath a tree during a storm. The rain no longer touched him, but the odds of a lightning strike were high. And that was exactly what he wanted—to die inside that love while the rest of the world was wrecked by the tempest. Nothing else mattered anymore. He, Scarlett and Remus were all that was left.
He focused on the way she stroked his hair, calming him with kisses across his face, soft touches to his cheeks. Sirius drowned in Scarlett, allowing her to soothe the chaos unraveling inside him with chaos of her own. It wasn’t ideal—but they were never an ideal couple. Never healthy, never perfect. Just two people trying to weather the tides of love and the hangover of grief.
Just two people afraid of being alone.
It was hard, too, to bury the resentment he still felt for Scarlett deep in his chest. When he finally opened his eyes, sniffling softly, she was already asleep in his arms. Sirius caught her with his gaze, noting the peaceful expression on her face, her calm breath, her steady heartbeat.
So… vulnerable.
He could do anything to Scarlett. He could kill her. He didn’t need to go that far—he could hurt her, take her wand from the bedside table and curse her with any number of the Black family’s dark enchantments. Inflict upon her all the pain she’d ever caused him. He could strangle her until the life drained from her eyes and she was as lifeless as James.
Sirius shook his head slightly, trying to dispel the thoughts.
Wanting and doing are two very different things.
Sirius was no coward. He would never actually do that to Scarlett—no matter how much he might want to. Perhaps it was some remnant of his Gryffindor chivalry. Perhaps because he’d already done it to her too many times before. Still, he was vengeful, and the temptation to watch her suffer, to make her pay for the suffering she’d caused him… had a certain bitter allure.
It was wrong—he knew that—but it made the hurt feel less intense. Less powerful. It reduced it to a blurry smudge indistinguishable from the rest of his dark past.
He caught himself caressing Scarlett’s back, the raised scars beneath his fingertips, and his stomach twisted. He felt sick. Before he was imprisoned, he’d been tortured by having to care for Regulus—the boy he had so desperately wished was his. Always wondering if Scarlett was suffering as much as he was— wanting her to be. As if that could somehow satisfy all the pain she’d caused him.
But Scarlett had been tortured too… in a far worse way than he had. He had spent years wishing harm upon her, and seeing it come true filled him with disgust. Disgust at the petty, bitter wish he’d once made coming to life.
Sirius gasped, stunned by the depth of his own cruelty, pressing his lips to the top of Scarlett’s head as he held her tighter against him. There had been a time when he’d sworn to protect her from the world… but he hadn’t protected her from himself.
He wouldn’t repeat the same mistakes.
Not this time.
In the middle of the night, Scarlett slipped into the threshold between sleep and waking, her eyes fluttering open slightly to the pale light spilling across the room.
No. The light wasn’t coming from the windows.
A chill ran down her spine, and she turned towards the corner of the room, where a ghostly figure stood with his hands in his pockets, iron-grey eyes watching her like a predator.
"He’ll never forgive you." Regulus’s voice echoed at the edge of her mind, souring her throat with a sudden wave of nausea. "Never."
Scarlett shivered, trying to open her mouth to respond—but Sirius instinctively pulled her tighter to his chest, and the glow was swallowed by the dark, making it easy to let her consciousness slip once more into the blackness behind her eyelids.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 32: You could spend another hundred years in Azkaban and you still wouldn’t deserve him!
Chapter Text
C
Scarlett didn’t want to wake up. Even though it was summer, she’d spent fifteen years in Azkaban and cherished any kind of warmth she could gather—especially the heat of Sirius’s body pressed against hers, his warm breath caressing the back of her neck.
She cleared her throat, shifting slightly, blinking slowly as she glanced over her shoulder. The pieces of what had happened hadn’t quite clicked into place yet—she was far too lazy to bother. But the moment she felt Sirius’s soft breathing turn heavy, the memories of the previous night came crashing back all at once.
Behind her, Sirius let go and slowly rolled to the other side of the bed, stretching with a silent yawn. Scarlett stayed perfectly still, keeping her eyes shut. It was hard staying in that position with her heart thudding in her chest, but she wasn’t ready to face Sirius—not now, and definitely not to talk about what had happened between them.
She felt the mattress shift as Sirius sat up, stretching his arms and rolling his neck. Scarlett swallowed hard. They were still naked. A noise from outside drew Sirius’s attention towards the door, making the bed creak. Then he began dressing quickly, as though something urgent had just struck him.
Without saying a word, Sirius hurried out of the room, gently closing the door behind him as if afraid to wake her. Scarlett, still wrapped in the sheets, took a deep breath and rubbed her eyes with her knuckles. She stared at the side of the bed where Sirius had been, something warm pulsing through her veins.
Something that made her entire body melt.
She stared at the starry ceiling, the stars nearly indistinguishable against the pale background. Her eyes scanned the windows, only one of which let in a sliver of daylight. She scratched the back of her neck before sitting up, searching for her clothes strewn across the bed. She grimaced at the sting between her legs, eyes going wide as she remembered they hadn’t used any contraceptive charm.
Her vision clouded with black dots as she stood up too fast, her pulse racing. She threw on whatever clothes she could find, grabbed her wand from the floor, and stumbled toward the bedroom door.
"…how can you just ignore this and… sleep with her?!" Remus’s voice echoed down the corridor, though panic blurred the words in Scarlett’s ears. All she needed was to speak to Sirius.
"It’s not that simple, Remus! Things aren’t black and white!" Sirius shot back, running his hands through his messy hair.
Both Sirius and Remus straightened abruptly when Scarlett appeared in the living room—still dishevelled, and looking dreadfully pale.
“We need to talk.” She said to Sirius, completely ignoring Remus, whose gaze flicked from the clock on the mantelpiece to Sirius.
“The Ministry won’t wait. Your testimony is crucial,” Remus avoided her just as fiercely, not even bothering to explain what was happening. “You’ve got twenty minutes.”
Sirius opened and closed his mouth a few times, stunned.
“What’s he talking about?” Scarlett murmured, all the calm she’d felt replaced by an endless churn in her stomach. Blood began to roar in her ears.
“The Ministry’s summoning me…” He looked at her, the silver in his eyes clouded with uncertainty. “To give my statement… about everything that happened…”
Scarlett took a step back, pale as death. She no longer even remembered what she was doing there. Her heart was pounding so fast it felt like it might explode. She took a deep breath, trying to regain control, steadying herself on the arm of the sofa.
“You can’t go,” she gasped, trembling. “They’ll lock you up again…”
“They won’t,” Remus cut in harshly. “Dumbledore’s intervened for Sirius. He’s given the Ministry all the evidence. Madam Bones—”
“The same way they officially killed me?!” Scarlett hissed, clenching her fists. “Sirius…”
“I have to go, Scar. It’s the only way we can… have a normal life,” he faltered, swallowing hard.
“For you to have a normal life,” she corrected quietly. “You can’t go…”
“Scar… if it weren’t for you…” He stepped closer in a long stride. “I’d still be a fugitive. But… with Peter caught, and Dumbledore’s support…”
“Sirius, you need to go,” Remus sighed, impatient. “Or you’ll miss your chance to clear your name for good.”
“When I get back, Scar, I promise we’ll talk. Alright?” He tried to keep his voice steady, though he seemed just as nervous as she was.
Scarlett opened her mouth to speak, but the thoughts dissolved before she could grasp them. She was still staring at Sirius, and the way hope had crept into the silver of his eyes shattered every argument she had. With the bitter taste of helplessness on her tongue, she simply lowered her gaze. She no longer knew what to do.
“I think you’ve still got a suit in your wardrobe,” Remus said as he passed her on his way to the corridor. “You showing up at the Ministry in pyjamas wouldn’t be ideal…”
Sirius kept looking at Scarlett, as though he wanted to say something but didn’t have the faintest idea what. Then Remus called his name, and he seemed to give up, heading off to his room.
Scarlett stood frozen, staring down at her feet on the dark green rug. Trying to digest what she’d just learned, trying to remember what had seemed so urgent to tell Sirius. Then she looked up, scanning the room for her ghosts—finding James’s head poking through the wall that led to the corridor.
“I think you’ll want to hear this,” James said, nodding for her to follow.
Glancing around to make sure Penny wasn’t nearby, Scarlett transformed into Whiskers and padded stealthily over to James’s side, sharpening her hearing and peeking through the narrow gap in the ajar door with just one eye.
Remus stood with his arms crossed, leaning against the sideboard while Sirius buttoned up his shirt.
“How can you leave Scarlett wandering around on her own, not even Penny keeping an eye on her? She could’ve run off, Sirius!” he scolded, jaw tightening.
“And where would she go? She’s got no one, Remus,” Sirius replied with a sarcastic smile. Whiskers lowered her ears, wilting. “Besides… it’s not like she’s locked up here…” He was fastening the last button on his shirt. “Is it?”
Remus fell silent for a few seconds, the grey in his face flushing with colour. He scratched the scar on his chin, as if searching for the right words.
“No. Of course not. She just can’t leave.” He shrugged.
Sirius slipped his tie into place over the shirt collar but didn’t knot it. One hand gripped the bedpost, the other rested on his hip.
“That’s literally the definition of someone being locked up, Remus,” Sirius growled, upper lip curling.
“Don’t try and change the subject, Sirius.” Remus held his ground, though his brown eyes glinted gold. “You’re obsessed with her!”
“It wasn’t anything serious,” Sirius rolled his eyes, tucking his shirt into his trousers. “It was just…” He cast a charm on his hair, making it perfectly tousled. “We needed to blow off some steam and… it just happened. It’s been twelve bloody years without shagging, cut me some slack!”
Whiskers would have been mortified by the look James gave her. But in her feline form, the subject didn’t embarrass her—nor did it truly upset her. Luckily, all emotions were dulled on her cat skin, because if she were still Scarlett, she’d probably be falling to pieces.
“I don’t believe you,” Remus muttered, nose wrinkling.
“Believe what you like,” Sirius finished lacing up his shoes and turned toward the door.
Whiskers bolted back to the sitting room and shifted back to her human form, while the ache in her chest still felt like nothing more than a pinprick. She used that moment to search for Penny and found her dusting a shelf of tapes, barely sparing her a glance.
Scarlett ran her hands down her face, trying to settle the anxiety bubbling inside her. Her expression turned serious as Sirius and Remus entered the room, both silent. She sat down on the sofa, exhaling deeply, trying to remember what she had meant to say to him—trying to push away the conversation she’d just overheard.
“Sirius…” she called, and he shoved his hands into his pockets, raising his eyebrows in silent question. She didn’t even register how handsome he looked in the suit. There was something she needed to ask him… but what was it? Desperation swallowed her words with frightening ease. “I have to tell you something… I need to…” Reggie is your son, she tried to say, but the words coiled in her throat like a serpent. Her tongue refused to move. Her eyes widened in panic.
“Scar? Are you alright?” His voice echoed, distant, but Scarlett barely heard it. She felt dizzy, her head pounding, eyes welling with tears. “Hey, hey… it’s okay.” He cupped her face with both hands, pulling her out of her own terror, anchoring her in those stormy-grey irises that sparkled like stars in the night sky. “I really need to go now, but the moment I’m back, we’ll talk. Alright?”
Scarlett’s lower lip trembled as Sirius gently wiped her tears away, washing away everything she ached to say in that charged space between them. He smiled, trying to lend her a shred of courage, and Scarlett was utterly lost in the dimples on his cheeks and the way his eyes followed the curve of his own smile.
“Mm-hmm.” She grunted, too entranced by the spell Sirius had cast over her to let her emotions rise.
He kissed her forehead, sending a wave of calm through her body, as though all the panic that threatened to drown her had melted away in the warmth of Sirius Black’s touch. She blinked several times, too stunned to react. Her heart slowed its tempo but gained in strength, thudding so hard it felt like it might burst free.
Then he let go of her face, and Scarlett felt herself plummeting into a void. She watched, paralysed, as Sirius walked away and reached for the jar of Floo powder. She wanted to stop him, to beg him not to go—would’ve dropped to her knees if that’s what it took. But she couldn’t move.
Somewhere deep down, she wanted to believe Sirius’s words. In that unspoken promise. Even though she feared it wasn’t real, even after hearing that venom-laced argument with Remus that threatened to poison her hope… there she stood, watching the man she loved walk back into the lions’ den.
“Don’t do anything until I get back. Please.” He gave her a look full of indulgent warmth, as if he knew her far too well, as if she were still the same person from before Azkaban.
Scarlett shook her head, and it was all he needed to step into the fireplace and vanish in a whirl of green flames, calling out the Ministry’s Floo address.
The moment he disappeared, she collapsed into herself, hyperventilating as she pressed her hands to her face, struggling to control her breathing, fending off the suffocating pressure pressing down on her chest. All she could do was focus on breathing—deep in, deep out.
“Mistress Black, would you like to have breakfast in the sitting room?” Penny’s voice pierced through her vacant state.
Scarlett slowly removed her hands from her face and turned her head. She hadn’t realised how tense she was until she felt her whole body loosen at the elf’s question—and her stomach growled in reply. Penny said nothing more, simply turned back to the kitchen, and soon dishes began apparating onto the coffee table: boiled eggs, baskets of toast with jam, a tray of tea, and so many other things that Scarlett’s mouth watered.
She still found it strange, being allowed to eat whenever she wanted rather than only during set hours of the day. There was so much food, she didn’t even know where to begin. She reached out for a piece of toast but ended up pouring herself some tea instead. She saw the ghostly shimmer of James out of the corner of her eye and looked down at her arm with regret.
“I want to be alone,” she said, ignoring her friend’s gaze. She knew if she looked at him properly, he’d pull her into a conversation she wasn’t ready to have.
“Dumbledore asked me to keep an eye on you,” came Remus’s voice, and Scarlett jumped, spilling hot tea over her hand. James turned as well, caught just as off guard by Remus’s sudden appearance.
Scarlett cursed under her breath, setting the cup down quickly and dabbing the tea away with a napkin. The skin where her Ouroboros circled had turned red, the sting making her clench her teeth.
She barely noticed Remus approach in silence, crouching in front of her and offering his hand. Scarlett flinched as though about to be struck, drawing her arm in against her waist.
It was impossible not to look into those chocolate-brown eyes, their darker streaks shimmering gold. Scarlett tensed her jaw, shoulders drawn in, waiting for Remus to back away. He licked his lips and gently tapped her shoulder with a single finger.
“Let me see,” Remus murmured, watching her expression. “I’m not going to hurt you.”
Scarlett hesitated. Her hand didn’t even hurt that much, truth be told—she had grown quite numb to pain. What frightened her was Remus’s closeness: she could see every scar on his right hand. There was a time she knew nearly all of them… but now, after so many years, Remus had earned new ones.
They all had new scars, but Remus couldn’t hide his. They stood out plainly—etched across his hands, his cheeks, his heart.
Shrugging her shoulders, Scar allowed Remus to examine the back of her hand, watching how his face no longer looked quite so drawn or grey. Still, his features carried far too many marks for someone so young. He looked years older than Sirius, partly due to the greying hair—and the moustache certainly didn’t help make him seem any younger. To the unknowing eye, someone might even mistake Scarlett for his daughter.
With a flick of his wand, the burning sensation gave way to a cool, soothing one, her skin enveloped in a pale green light as the redness vanished.
“There we go,” he said, though he didn’t release her hand. Remus looked down at the floor before lifting his gaze, guilt and hesitation furrowing his brow. “You haven’t aged a day,” he commented, as if he could read her thoughts.
Scarlett’s lips almost twitched into a half-smile, but her nerves held it back. Remus Lupin had always been like that—always able to read his friends with ease. The most observant and reserved of them all, he knew more than he let on and had always been the moral compass of the group. Scarlett had always held a fondness for him. Not only because of his condition as a werewolf, but also because there was something inside him that spoke to something inside her.
The weight of an unspeakable secret.
The fate of being a danger to others.
The fear of hurting the ones you love.
Scarlett and Remus had always had much in common—especially after his mother died during their final year at Hogwarts. She had been the only one able to get him out of bed.
She had been the only one he ever shared his darkest secret with.
She was also the only one he’d hurt that year… because of Dimitri.
“You caught Pete,” Remus cut through the silence, his thumb brushing gently over her Signet. Scarlett exhaled sharply at the unwelcome touch, her entire arm tensing. “Even though he escaped… I think Sirius might actually get out of this.”
Scarlett remained silent, locking eyes with Remus, trying to decipher what he truly meant beneath the words. He was skilled at this—using emotional triggers to draw out the answers he sought. He may have been a Gryffindor, but like all the Marauders, there was a touch of Slytherin in him too.
When he realised she wasn’t going to speak, Remus finally pulled back, settling into the armchair at a diagonal angle to her, helping himself to a portion of toast and eggs. He looked preoccupied with eating, but Scarlett could feel the occasional glances he cast her way, like he was still assessing her through the sharp quiet.
Scarlett leaned forward and reached for her teacup, noticing a photograph just behind it. She picked it up and brought it closer, unconsciously caressing the wooden frame as she took in the sight of Sirius—wearing aviator sunglasses, a leather jacket, and a grin stretching from ear to ear—riding his motorbike. On the back, Orfeu clung to his waist, his head thrown back, mouth open and tongue out mid-scream.
Her eyes fixed on her brother’s face, the look of pure bliss that softened his entire expression. His auburn-brown hair whipped wildly in the wind as he gripped Sirius’s jacket for dear life.
Scarlett caught herself smiling at the memory. She remembered that holiday break well. The sweetness that brushed her heart quickly turned to sharp needles that shredded it as the memory of being wrapped in Morfeu’s arms overtook her, making her clutch the photograph tighter and press her lips together.
“I want to see Orfy.” She hugged the picture to her chest, not daring to look at Remus. She’d thought asking would be harder than it actually was.
“That’s out of the question,” Remus replied firmly. “He wouldn’t be able to bear seeing you.”
“Why?” Scarlett frowned, her nostrils flaring as anger burned hot in her stomach. She threw her head back against the sofa, eyes shut, burying her face against her knees. “It was because of the torture, wasn’t it?”
She could feel Remus’s scorching stare on her.
“How do you know that?” His voice wasn’t just demanding—it was full of fear. He still couldn’t fully accept that the woman before him was both the monster that had haunted his nightmares, and the one who’d gifted him the sweetest dream of all: Reggie.
“Regulus told me,” Scarlett said flatly. “I avenged him.”
She could hear Remus’s fists tightening.
“You avenged him?”
“Helena Selwyn tortured him for a year and a half… so… I killed her,” she replied, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
Remus’s eyes widened, his brows drawing together in disbelief.
“You… you…”
“Amanda Wilkes was next. She used to force me to take a potion… one that accelerated Reg’s development. It was… it was agony. A nine-month child growing in… three, maybe four?” Scarlett exhaled deeply. “I thought I was going to die. I wanted to die.”
Remus didn’t know what to feel, let alone how to respond. Even in the war, he had never deliberately killed anyone. The closest he’d come was when he and Sirius had nearly killed Wormtail at the Shrieking Shack—and if it hadn’t been for Harry’s intervention…
He wanted to judge Scarlett through the lens of his immaculate, lofty moral compass—but the truth was, he understood how she felt. He knew the fury of injustice, the bitter sting of resentment, the cold finality of revenge. He didn’t want to understand her—Scarlett was a murderer. She had killed Marl, betrayed Sirius, she… she…
Remus wanted to say so many things and, at the same time, nothing at all. What could he possibly say to the girl who had once been his best friend and switched sides so swiftly they hadn’t even had time to brace for impact? The girl who had trampled on Sirius’s heart until it shattered beyond repair? Who became a Death Eater. Married Regulus. Had a little boy who had been one of the only bright sparks in the endless darkness of the Wizarding War.
As much as it repulsed him to see Scarlett in his house, living as though she hadn’t killed five—no, now seven —people, some part of him still searched for the friend he had lost. It was stupid, unrealistic, but Remus still longed for her to smile and say that, even if the world was cruel, he would always have his friends.
He loved her. And she was one of the few things left from the happiest time of his life.
She was like one of those faded memories we try to recall in vivid detail—hazy, precious, almost too golden to be true. Because back then… everything was easier. Everything was more colourful, more intense. But it was also so naïve, so frivolous, so superficial… his biggest worry had been getting good marks and fulfilling his duties as a prefect.
Remus didn’t want to smile at the burst of nostalgia that rose in his chest—but he couldn’t stop it. He opened his mouth to speak, but the feeling was so overwhelming he just sat there, mouth ajar, saying nothing.
Scarlett looked exactly like the girl he’d met at the Leaky Cauldron a lifetime ago. At least in appearance. It was as though she were still sixteen. It was terrifying, this sensation that the woman before him was his friend—not the Death Eater. Now, he understood what Sirius had felt.
Scarlett was everything they had lost.
Youth. Innocence. Friendship.
And being near her was terrifying—because it felt like they hadn’t lost anything at all.
As if it had all just been a horrible dream. As if they were still at Hogwarts, and the worst thing he had to worry about was someone finding out he was a werewolf.
“What happened… when you left? Was it really a trap?” Remus finally asked, the question that had been lodged in his throat for years.
“Regulus caught me,” Scarlett murmured, her voice muffled between her knees. “He was never in danger. He activated the watch and got me. I had to… had to pretend… that I was loyal. That it was all part of a plan.”
“A plan? Why?”
Because of Reggie. Because I was pregnant, was what Scarlett meant to say.
“Orfy,” she blurted instead, scrambling for a coherent thread that wouldn’t unravel. “I had to cooperate or… he would’ve been killed.”
It wasn’t a lie. But it wasn’t the truth either. Voldemort would never have killed Orfeu—his prized experiment. But Scarlett hoped Remus wouldn’t see through the excuse.
“Is that why you betrayed us? Why you gave up the McKinnons’ location?” Remus’s voice rose, thick with disbelief. “We were at Maurie’s birthday weeks before! You can’t be that cruel—”
“I didn’t have a choice!” Scarlett cut in, her shoulders curling inward. “I had to become one of them… I…”
Marl knew, Scarlett wanted to say. She knew—so she had to die…
“He wouldn’t have killed Orfy! He was one of the few Signet-blood Gaunts left—”
“Yes, and why do you think I was forced to accelerate my pregnancy?” Scarlett shot back, clutching the photograph to her chest so tightly it hurt to breathe. “He wanted a child with me!”
The suspicion on Remus’s face twisted into revulsion.
“He wanted a child with Signet,” he muttered to himself.
Scarlett only smiled. It was either that or collapse in sobs.
“No… that… that doesn’t make sense… why did you marry Regulus? Why did you… the Prewetts… you were there when they died, weren’t you?!”
Scarlett drew a sharp breath, trying to sidestep the avalanche of questions, while agony bubbled up, threatening to spill.
“Remus, please—I need to see Orfeu, please…”
“You can’t see him, you can’t leave this place!” Remus snapped, livid.
“Please… he… he’s my brother… and I—”
“You can’t!” he roared.
Scarlett barely noticed she was crying—it had become as natural to her as breathing. And where would she go? She has no one, Remus… Sirius’s voice echoed in her mind, sharpening the blade in her chest.
“Please… he’s all I have left…” Scarlett faltered, sliding off the sofa and down to her knees on the floor. “You… you’re not the only one who lost everything.”
Remus stood abruptly, fists clenched at his sides, face turning a deep shade of purple from pure exasperation. The scars along his face caught the light, deepening the shadows in his golden eyes—highlighting the wolf within.
“No, Scarlett,” he growled, entirely at the mercy of the rage flooding his veins. “Sirius also lost everything while you played house with Regulus and murdered the McKinnons!”
Scarlett let out a hiss, as though wounded in her Animagus form, both hands pressing into the living room rug. Her head rang with the thundering pulse in her ears—it felt like she'd taken a punch straight to the gut. Her blood began to boil with the acidic sting of injustice on her tongue. She pushed herself upright, bracing against the sofa, her eyes drilling into Remus’s.
“I didn’t want to… I never meant to escape Azkaban with Sirius…” she whispered, her voice breaking beneath the sob she tried to hold back. “I only did it because… he asked me to. Because he needed me. But I… I should’ve stayed. I know what I did to him, Remus. And I regret it. Every day I regret leaving… I—” Her words were cut short by a sob.
Remus was crying too. There was a flicker of empathy in his eyes, but it was quickly devoured by the ominous presence of the wolf, turning brown to gold. Tears of grief streaked down his ashen cheeks. He pressed a trembling hand to his chest as if to quiet the pain burning there.
“I don’t deserve him,” Scarlett confessed, more to herself than to Remus.
He sniffed sharply, dragging a hand across his nose with more force than necessary.
“You could spend another hundred years in Azkaban, Scarlett, and you still wouldn’t deserve him!” Remus spat, his jaw clenched so tight he could barely open his mouth. “You never would.”
Scarlett’s knees buckled. She staggered back a few steps, dizzy, stunned. Remus was right—he usually was. Why had she ever thought Sirius might change his mind? He hadn’t even forgiven her… she was a monster. It was time to accept it.
“You were my best friend,” Remus whimpered, backing away himself, as if it were safer to keep his distance. “My best friend… you held me when I needed it most… and then you stabbed me in the back. You led the Death Eaters to the McKinnons’ house—to the family Sirius and I vouched for! Who trusted us! Who welcomed you into their home without hesitation! And you killed them!”
Scarlett couldn’t see clearly anymore—she couldn’t breathe or think. She didn’t want to return to that night. She didn’t want to remember the look Marlene had given her. She didn’t want to hear Dimitri’s voice, pushing her to go through with it.
“I’m sorry…” was all that escaped her lips.
What else could she say? She was guilty of everything Remus accused her of. How much more would she need to suffer to pay for her crimes? How many more Cruciatus would she have to endure? How many more innocents would have to die? How many more apologies would she have to whisper into the void?
“I don’t want your apologies!” Remus snapped. “If it weren’t for Dumbledore and for Reggie, you’d be out of my house!” He pressed his hands over his face, trying to catch his breath. “Reggie… he loves you so much.”
Scarlett gasped at the mention of her son. She loved him just as much. But she didn’t deserve his love. Nor Remus’s. Nor Sirius’s. And certainly not Reggie’s.
“But… he doesn’t know you,” Remus went on, clearing his throat. “Reggie’s an amazing boy. And you are going to be his mother, Scarlett. You’re going to be the mother he deserves. You’re going to make him happy every single day, because that’s the bare minimum of what you owe him. But I know you. I know you’re a bloody coward, and you’re going to run the first chance you get—just like you ran from Sirius. You have a talent for poisoning everything you touch. So if you break his heart, if you hurt him… you’ll wish you’d never escaped Azkaban.”
Scarlett didn’t know when she shifted into Whiskers. All she knew was that she bolted from the room, dashing into the first open bedroom she could find. She squeezed herself under a chest of drawers, cramming into the smallest, hottest space possible. She could have hidden behind a wardrobe, or crept under the bed—but she was in such a deep, catatonic state she didn’t even care that her breathing was coming in short, ragged bursts.
When Scarlett had first been imprisoned, she often caught herself wondering what she could’ve done differently to avoid ending up there. But those thoughts attracted the Dementors, so eventually, she learned to daydream of something else: of escaping Azkaban. Of being free.
Free… from everything. From the war. From the consequences of what she’d done. Free even from her friends. From all the pain and all the suffering she had caused. From the shame, the guilt, the endless regret. She imagined starting over. Meeting everyone again for the first time—bumping into Sirius at some band gig she liked, seeing James and Lily at the cinema, finding Remus in a quiet bookshop.
They’d become friends all over again.
After all, they’d done it once.
It couldn’t be that hard to do it again.
She had dreamt of that life for years, but now that she was living it, the thought of it made her dizzy. Whiskers let out a long breath and crept out once her heartbeat had steadied and her mind had cleared. She found herself in the room Sirius had once said belonged to Regulus. One corner was stacked with boxes, the other filled with childhood odds and ends.
She ran her fingers across a small table cluttered with photos of them—pictures that used to sit proudly on the mantelpiece back when she and Sirius…
Back when they were engaged.
Her gaze landed on the image of Sirius kneeling, opening a small box. She could still hear his proposal that day, playing beneath the sound of The Doors, the bittersweet memory seeping into the bitterness that already choked her chest. Her fingers traced the glass of the frame, trying to keep the warm feelings at bay. She had been so happy that day. So happy. Thinking about it now made all that joy crumble to ash on her tongue.
Instinctively, she looked down at her own hand. Where the black diamond ring had always sat—faithfully—even after she left. Her eyes dropped to the ring Dumbledore had given her before they fled Hogwarts. And on a sudden impulse, Scarlett pulled at it.
It didn’t budge.
She pulled again, harder, but the metal clung to her skin as if fused to the bone. Her heart skipped a beat. She bit down on the band and yanked, to no avail.
Scarlett exhaled sharply through her mouth, drawing her wand from her pocket. She pointed it at the ring.
“Engorgio!”
A flash of cold, blue light wrapped around the ring—only to dissipate instantly, repelled by a pearly shimmer.
She blinked several times. The wand trembled slightly in her grip. The ring was enchanted? She couldn’t take it off.
“You bastard,” she muttered, raising her wand again. “Reducto!”
The bluish spell rebounded off the ring, throwing sparks across the room. The wave of panic tried to hit her again, but Scarlett forced it back with another long breath.
“Evanesco!” she growled, flicking her wrist in a circle to cast the Vanishing Spell. Like the others, it did nothing. “Fuck!”
“What’s wrong?”
Regulus appeared in the doorway, and Scarlett reflexively aimed her wand at him at his sudden entrance.
She didn’t want to deal with Regulus right now. She was emotionally wrung dry. She’d grown used to his presence in Azkaban when they were alone—but now? She preferred the quiet he left behind. And yet… he was the only one who understood her darkness. The only one who had embraced it, who had accepted her as the monster she’d become. The one who had encouraged her to be that monster.
Scarlett shivered all over at the thought.
Maybe… maybe he could help her.
“Dumbledore.” She held out her hand, showing him the golden ring on her index finger. Regulus simply raised an eyebrow, stepping closer to examine it.
“It’s a magical tracking artefact,” he said, tilting his head slightly as he bit at the dry skin of his lower lip. “You can’t take it off?”
“No,” Scarlett huffed, flopping onto the bed. “Bloody hell.”
Regulus only let out a short laugh, the corner of his mouth twitching with amusement. He glanced at the photos on the table, and his face quickly slid behind that unreadable mask. His eyes, however, sharpened the moment they caught the picture of Sirius on one knee, proposing.
“What room is this?” he asked, scanning the boxes and the stored children’s items.
Scarlett flared her nostrils, resting her elbow on her knees as she stared at the box on the bed, frowning at the familiarity that object stirred in her.
“This room was meant to be yours,” she admitted, pretending to be far too interested in the box to meet his gaze.
Regulus’s expression froze. His eyes melted. The stiff line of his posture cracked. He smiled again—but not with humour. The iron in his gaze bared its teeth, and his breathing lost its rhythm.
“What?” he asked, no control left in his wavering voice.
Scarlett opened the box and examined the contents: clothes, something bright, and something else that pulsed with a faint ringing she knew all too well. Her hand extended instinctively toward the sound, but she stopped as her eyes caught the gleam of the bright object.
An engagement ring.
The ring Sirius had used to propose to her.
It was ice-cold against her trembling fingers. The black diamond shimmered in the sunlight, along with the smaller stones encircling it. A paralysing shiver ran through her as the memory of that day tried, once again, to burst forth in vivid colour and echoing voices that seemed to surge from within her own body.
“What do you mean it was my room?!” Regulus’s shout yanked her violently from that sensation, shattering the images and sounds like ripples breaking apart on water. Scarlett snapped her head toward him, her neck twinging from the sudden motion.
She exhaled sharply through her teeth, clutching the ring tight in her palm and pressing it against her chest. She didn’t know if she was ready to relive that day.
Truthfully…
She wasn’t ready for much of anything. Maybe she never would be.
“When Sirius bought this house… he planned for this room to be yours,” Scarlett said, her tone flat. “He hoped you’d come live with us once you reached of age…”
Regulus opened his mouth as if the right words were perched on the tip of his tongue, but nothing came. His brow furrowed, lips twisting as he took a few steps back—as though Scarlett’s words were too dangerous to hold. As though he couldn’t bear the idea that Sirius might be more than the monstrous, shifting figure he’d come to despise.
As though, in another life, Sirius might’ve saved him from their parents’ clutches.
Regulus exhaled sharply as the realisation struck him—he had wanted that. In Azkaban, he had regretted not accepting Sirius’s offer all those years ago, before the Slytherin match. Even if it meant living with the Potters, even if—
“He… wanted to save you,” Scarlett continued, as if fully aware of the weight behind her words. “I bet he still loves you, even after everything.” She let her head fall back, eyes lost in the ceiling. “Sirius was always everything we couldn’t be.”
With his jaw clenched tight as iron, Regulus glared at her, the grey of his eyes burning with rage, catching the sunlight until they looked like molten bronze.
“A drunken, pathetic wreck?” Regulus scoffed, voice laced with poison. “Shall I remind you it was he who sent you away? He who let you walk into my arms—”
“Oh, Regulus, I know the shit I did!” Scarlett snapped, voice rising to push his barbs away. “And I know exactly how you feel about him. You're dead, and still—”
“Oh, excuse me, Scarlett, for not fawning over the brother who always hated me and thinks I died a coward!” he spat back, voice sharp with long-held fury.
“He knows you didn’t die a coward. I told him you died protecting me and Reg!” Scarlett shouted, nose wrinkled, upper lip curling with frustration. “What more do you want?!”
Regulus dragged a hand through his hair, shaking his head in disbelief.
“He doesn’t even miss me,” he muttered, face twisted as if he were about to cry. But not a single tear glistened in his eyes. “But James… he misses James every bloody day. Every single day.”
Scarlett let out a soft, bitter laugh.
“Why are you surprised?” she asked coolly. “James was always the brother you could never be.”
She stared at him like a blade, the ice-blue of her eyes piercing as frozen stakes.
Regulus looked at her with such venom that Scarlett could have sworn she felt her limbs dissolving under the weight of that ghost who had haunted her for so long. Then he turned on his heel and left her alone.
Scarlett hugged her knees, her gaze naturally drifting toward the nearby box as she slid Sirius’s ring onto her right ring finger—the place it never should have left. She kissed the black diamond and closed her eyes, letting the tide of memories from the previous night carry her away from the disturbing presence of Regulus. A soft smile tried to tug at her lips, but she didn’t allow it.
A restless warmth spread through her veins, calming her pulse as her mind wandered back to Sirius. They had kissed feverishly, made love like the world might end, slept tangled together as if separation were unbearable—and still… it hadn’t been enough. She couldn’t forget his voice saying she had no one. Those words turned everything they’d done into a cruel betrayal. Even if it was true that Scarlett was painfully, utterly alone, she had hoped that at least…
At least he would be someone she could count on.
And yet…
It wasn’t fair to Sirius. Scarlett knew that. She couldn’t demand such a thing from him. Still, she wished—hoped—that maybe they could be a family. She didn’t want to believe it. She didn’t want to be disappointed again. Her life had already been far too much of a disaster, and the mere thought that they could ever be happy felt… so utopian, so distant, she couldn’t even picture it. It was like a star: a streak of light in the dark.
Close enough to see—but far too far to reach.
Scarlett slid her hand into the box, the pulse of ancient magic tingling against her palm and fingertips, radiating a crackling warmth through her entire body. Her mouth watered, her Signet tingling with the stored power humming from the orb.
She pulled out the multi-portkey, the ancestral magic so thick it left a cool sheen on her skin. As she lifted it from the box, its light illuminated the entire room. Scarlett ran her fingers over its rounded body, inspecting the mechanisms and concentric rings that rotated, each corresponding to a different destination.
There were many locations stored in it—Hogwarts, New York, the playground near Grimmauld Place. Some more obscure ones as well. But one in particular caught her attention: Gaunt Manor, 122.
Scarlett’s body jolted, her breath narrowing. That was her Uncle Thanatos’s address. Her palm began to sweat.
Did he still live there? Was he alive? She knew he was.
But what she didn’t know was—did he know she was alive?
Her gaze froze on the ring around her index finger. Besides… it’s not like she’s locked up here… is it? Sirius’s voice echoed in her mind, chased by Remus’s bitter reply: No. Of course not. She just can’t leave.
It was so painfully obvious that Scarlett wanted to slap herself. Not only was she a prisoner in that house—she was being tracked by Dumbledore through the ring. They didn’t trust her, that much was crystal clear. And this—this was just one more drop in the ocean of dread digging claws into her chest.
Was Dumbledore planning to hand her over to the Ministry too, like Sirius had just done? Would Sirius even be cleared? And if he wasn’t? What would become of her?
And what if… what if this was all a setup—just another twisted experiment? Another test subject for some mad plan?
Her head buzzed with questions and the sick fear of what came next. Being kept in the dark like this—completely powerless—was unbearable.
She found herself stroking her Signet. Her eyes were dry. She had cried too much. Apologised too much. And yet… what if Sirius really was acquitted? She couldn't leave. She couldn't stay without him. It wasn't fair…
But again, he had said she had no one.
So why would he care if she disappeared? Remus would be glad. And Dumbledore? She had probably become such a tiresome burden that he was counting down the days to be rid of her.
The ring made everything clearer now.
She’d be imprisoned either way—in Azkaban, or in this house that used to be home. Scarlett pressed her lips together, gripping the multi-portkey with both hands, her heart hammering as she braced herself for what she was about to do.
She turned the gears.
The world spun backwards in a blur of impossible motion. Colours and shapes smudged together into a smear of nausea. Scarlett clung to the feeling just long enough before it dropped her, unceremoniously, onto a polished wooden floor—where she promptly vomited her dainty breakfast all over an exquisite Persian rug.
The flickering light of a television cast strange shadows. A flurry of cards were tossed into the air as someone jolted upright on the sofa, twisting around in astonishment.
Staring at her.
Scarlett blinked rapidly, trying to process what she had just done—but her gaze locked onto the boy in front of her. Dark hair falling to his shoulders, tied loosely at the nape of his neck. A face still sharp, still familiar… but every trace of boyhood now gone.
And his eyes—green, deep as moss, unreadable and still. The narrow pupils glimmered with her reflection.
The silence between them buzzed with the static of the television.
“Orfy?” Scarlett mouthed, no sound escaping her lips.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 33: You need to leave the past behind
Chapter Text
CI
James struggled to prevent his ghostly state from vexing him. It was exceedingly difficult to remain unaffected while witnessing the way his friends behaved towards one another. He understood Remus, however unwillingly; he knew what that bitter tang in his mouth and that sting in his heart felt like.
When he discovered that it had been Scarlett who murdered the McKinnons, his world quite literally fell apart. Lily refused to believe it. And he was stunned when he went to the trial to support Sirius, seeing her utterly broken and resigned, accepting all the blame. He recoiled at the thought that his friend, the girl he loved so dearly, could be capable of killing someone.
Of course, James had already felt deeply betrayed when he learned that she had married Regulus Black and become a Death Eater. Those were devastating blows to him and, before he knew it, without even having the time to digest the treachery…
Scarlett was arrested shortly after giving birth.
He remembered holding an inconsolable Sirius as Alice and Frank arrived at St Mungo’s Hospital to take her away, still bleeding. He was bewildered that she could have had a child so early in the pregnancy, perplexed as to the reason for her imprisonment. After all, she was a Death Eater, yet many managed to escape Azkaban by claiming that Voldemort had coerced them or that they had been under the Imperius Curse.
Scarlett, however, was not among them. She professed her guilt with her chin held high and a vacant look in her eyes. It was on this premise that Lily clung, refusing to believe that Scar could be a monster. James… resisted at first, but as he helped care for Sirius and Reggie, witnessing his friend’s anguish, recalling the day he read in the newspaper that the McKinnons had died…
He remembered Lily crying through the entire night. And the mere thought that it had been Scarlett who did all that…
James sat down beside Remus, who was sobbing desolately, gripping his grey hair so tightly as to muffle the sound. He had always been like that — hiding his pain remarkably well. It was one of the reasons Sirius had grown suspicious of him back in 1980.
Yet… the truth was that he was suffering, only in a different way.
James murmured, removing his spectacles to wipe his own tears, "The war broke you too, Moony. How did we… how did we end up like this?"
At Christmas 1980, each of them made a wish to Father Christmas. On that occasion, Frank was dressed up as the jolly old fellow. They had this tradition of betting amongst themselves to see who would play Father Christmas that year — James in ’77, Moony in ’78, Peter in ’79 and Sirius would take on the role in ’81.
On Christmas night of 1980, James had wished for his parents to recover from Dragon Pox. It didn’t work, of course — they died all the same. Had they not been ill, he would’ve wished for the war to finally be won. Only then would he have felt safe enough to follow his dream and begin a career as a professional Quidditch player.
Sirius had wished to complete his Auror training, to help hasten the war’s end and give Reggie a better world. Peter had wished for the war to end as well — just like Alice and Lily.
And Remus? Remus had wished for a job. Not for peace, nor for Voldemort’s defeat. He’d long since grown used to surviving in a hostile world ever since leaving Hogwarts. For him, it was just another ordinary day in the life of a werewolf. No one understood his wish at the time — in fact, it only served to make Sirius even more suspicious of him months later.
James understood now. Remus had always been the loneliest of them because no one truly understood him. Whether they liked it or not, he, Sirius and Peter had all been born into privilege. Sure, each of them had their own personal problems, but none of them had to live with lycanthropy. They didn’t know what it was like to carry a twisted, savage version of oneself inside their own mind, governed by the unnatural instincts of their condition.
And no matter how often they tried to keep Moony company during full moons, there was always a melancholy about him. A lone-wolf quality. And Moony seemed to accept that. His missions for the Order were highly classified, and he didn’t have a partner like James and Sirius did.
He was always alone.
Sometimes, it was almost as if he preferred it. As if he feared hurting someone — both in his cursed form and in his human one. And yet, he longed for companionship. It was a duality Remus had wrestled with all his life — the torment of solitude against the relief of knowing he couldn’t hurt anyone; the peace of having company coupled with the panic that he might.
“I’m scared too,” James murmured, hugging his knees and resting his chin on them as he sat beside his friend. “But you’re not alone, Moony. No matter how much you think you are… you never were. You know that, don’t you?”
He’d grown used to his words being met with silence. Only Scarlett could interact with them — even so, he kept trying to speak to the people he loved. It was more for himself than anything else. It helped him stay sane. It helped him process everything that was happening.
Everything still felt like a dream. He constantly caught himself thinking about Harry, checking what day of the week it was to figure out which lessons he’d have, what he’d be doing during his breaks, how he might be feeling. He knew it was too much to ask, hoping to actually speak to his son, but he wished for it anyway, silently, desperately.
Wished that one day it might come true.
That he could hold him, talk to him. Give him Quidditch tips, help with his Transfiguration homework, even scold him for bad behaviour.
Merlin, James would do anything to be able to live alongside his son. It wasn’t fair that he was doomed to watch over him forever from his silent little corner. He didn’t want to be dead. He wanted to be alive, he wanted…
James shook his head, trying to banish the thoughts. He was here to try and help Moony, not to wallow in his own misery.
“At least you have a chance to make things different,” James murmured. He barely noticed Lily’s presence until she hugged him from behind.
“Talking to Rem?” she asked, pressing a kiss to his neck. He nodded, eyes fluttering shut as he sought refuge in the arms of the woman he loved.
“If only he’d listen…”
“Even if you were alive, darling, he wouldn’t listen. He never did.” Lily smiled, pressing a kiss to his messy hair.
“At least I tried…” James shrugged, putting his glasses back on.
Remus remained curled up on the bed, though the crying seemed to have stopped.
“Do you think he’ll be cleared?” Lily asked, brushing kisses across James’s cheeks, coaxing a faint smile from his lips.
“Definitely. They deserve it. They… they need to be a family.”
Lily nodded in agreement. James wound his fingers into her fiery hair, letting the worries slip from his mind under the numbing comfort her presence always brought.
But the moment didn’t last long.
In the blink of an eye, the two of them were violently yanked backwards and the world spun so fast James didn’t even have time to react. And when it stopped, there wasn’t even time to think.
He tumbled to the floor and passed through a car, only coming to a halt when he caught hold of a cupboard. Being a ghost, it had become second nature to phase through some things and not others — as though he could somehow choose what was intangible to him.
He blinked repeatedly, vision blurred, finally focusing on where they were: a rather fancy garage. Two sports cars were parked inside, their bodywork so polished it practically gleamed.
Lily rose to her feet on the other side of a red vehicle, running a hand through her hair and glancing around, just as disoriented as James.
“What the bloody hell just happened?!” she said, frowning.
“I haven’t got the foggiest, posy,” James sighed, disorientated. He thrust his head inside the car, staring at the key tossed on the seat, the chrome steering wheel, the speedometer that went up to 265 km/h. “Bloody hell, that’s brilliant…”
“I reckon she disapparated,” came Regulus Black’s voice as his head appeared through the window of the black car.
“She can’t disapparate,” Lily said, looking around, trying to get her bearings. “Where is she…”
Her words were cut short by a loud crash. The three of them exchanged glances before sprinting towards the sound, through a door, into a spacious room that James recognised. He had no time to process it, however, before he saw Scarlett lying on her back atop what looked like a glass table, someone pinning her down.
She didn’t struggle, though her hands gripped her assailant’s wrists. James froze for a few heartbeats as Regulus’s expression shifted from surprise to horror.
“Orfy?!” he murmured, incredulous.
James couldn’t believe it was Orfeu. First, because the boy’s face was twisted with rage as he strangled Scarlett. Second, he didn’t resemble the cheerful lad he’d once known. It only clicked that it really was Orfy when James noticed the burn scars on his arms.
“I TOLD YOU TO GO AWAY!” Orfeu screamed through gritted teeth. “I TOLD YOU TO LEAVE ME ALONE!”
Scarlett had no chance to reply. Her face was flushed, veins standing out on her temples, her eyes nearly bulging. Her fingertips were going numb. A wave of dizziness washed over James, making him stagger sideways as though his brain were being starved of oxygen.
He blinked repeatedly, trying to focus on something, and Lily’s strangled gasp told him that she and Regulus were experiencing the same phenomenon. It felt almost like dying again, except death never came while his mind turned to porridge.
James had no clear memory of what he did next—he only felt a tug at his chest as if a rope were tied to his heart. He touched the imagined cord and a fierce vibration coursed through every cell in his body, sending him hurtling into a dreadful sensation, as if slipping off a cliff.
The ground seemed endless until, at last, it arrived, and he felt his back impaled by something exceedingly sharp. His priority, though, was freeing himself from the hands choking his throat. He heard his own strangled voice as he prised Orfy’s wrists free and landed a wild kick to the boy’s ribs, sending him crashing aside and off Scarlett.
Although he occupied Scarlett’s body, it felt as if James possessed all the strength he’d had when alive—a twenty-one-year-old man in his prime. He coughed, desperately gulping for breath as he hyperventilated, his hands slipping on the shards of glass as he fought to rise.
“Don’t think I’m going to tell Reggie about any of this!” Orfy thundered, brandishing his wand. “What more do you want?”
James rubbed his shoulders to clear his eyes, every breath scorching his lungs as though they were aflame. He coughed again, attempting to speak—but all that came out was an unintelligible gasp.
“Why don’t you go after Sirius, then, hm? You saw he broke out Azkaban, didn’t you?!” Orfy continued, as though Scarlett understood him perfectly. “Another life you’ve wrecked!” He lifted his chin and levelled his wand at her.
“Orfy, no!” James croaked, pressing his blood-stained hand before his face as if it might shield him from whatever curse Orfy was about to cast. “Please, stop this.”
Orfy’s green eyes widened, glimmering with disturbed light. His jaw dropped in surprise, his wand trembling in his fist.
“James?!” he spluttered, as though on the verge of tears. “Why… why… your voice… you’re speaking… like him?!”
The question gave James just enough time to draw his own wand from the pocket of the shorts Scarlett wore, flicking it free in a swift motion while his chest heaved with ragged breaths.
“Lower your wand, Orfy,” he bade, clearing his throat. “I’m not here to hurt you.”
“How are you doing this?” Orfy retreated a pace, easing his arm down. “I never told you what happened to the Potters!”
“Because it’s not Scarlett speaking,” James panted, bracing himself on a corner table to push upright. “It’s James.”
Orfy staggered back a few more paces. Gone was the nine-year-old boy James once knew—in his place stood a grown man, with long dark-brown hair and a sprinkling of stubble along his jaw.
“It’s me, Orfy. Lower your wand,” James insisted, raising his hands in surrender. “I won’t hurt you.”
In his peripheral vision, James made out Regulus’s pale shimmer in a corner and Lily at his side.
“He won’t believe you,” Red warned. “Don’t let your guard down, Jay.”
“He will,” James countered, glancing at Regulus for a brief moment. “I gave you tips on how to kiss Emma Duggins at New Year ’77, alongside Wormtail. I lost a bet to you and had to hand over my autographed Puddlemere United cards—only you got knocked out in the second round of the Adventure, so you gave them back.”
A look of bewilderment creased Orfy’s brow. He narrowed his eyes, knuckles whitening as he gripped his wand. He flared his nostrils, weighing James’s words.
“Jay…” Regulus murmured, eyeing Orfy’s hand. “Don’t trust him.”
“It’s all right, I won’t hurt you,” James repeated slowly, lowering his hands.
Orfy stared him up and down before his lips curled into an expression of scorn.
“Liar, liar, LIAR!” he roared, sweeping his arm in one motion and unleashing a non-verbal spell at James.
James was hurled backwards into the door leading to the garage. The impact was so violent he phased through it, splintering the wood and aggravating the wounds along his back. He might have cracked a rib. Perhaps more than one.
His ears rang, his vision swam, and every breath was ragged. James rolled among the debris beneath him, his heart pounding in his throat, adrenaline muting the pain to a mere annoyance.
For a moment, he forgot he inhabited Scarlett’s body. He rubbed his eyes with the backs of his hands, crawling backwards, then raised an arm to level his wand at the door.
“Bloody hell…” he murmured, tasting copper on his tongue. He could’ve stayed dead for all he knew, but that metallic tang of blood was unmistakable.
On instinct, James sent a purple curse streaking towards the shadow of Orfy as it closed in. The boy ducked behind a wall, and James staggered back to take cover behind an iron cabinet.
“He’s to the left of the wall!” Lily’s voice guided him, flitting between Orfy and James. “Are you alright, darling?”
James pressed his lips together, catching sight of Lily’s pale form as he leaned on the cabinet.
“I’ve been better.” He offered a cheeky grin before wincing in pain.
“Why is he attacking?” Lily turned her gaze to Regulus, who watched Orfy intently.
“Blast the wall, Jay,” Red instructed, ignoring the question.
“But he might get hurt!” Lily stepped towards the other ghost. “He can’t…”
“Orfy’s a Gaunt, Lily—he’s well drilled. It’s not a Bombarda that’ll kill him.” Regulus’s sombre whisper sent a chill through Lily’s very bones.
“But… and afterwards? How do we get out of here?!” she pleaded, looking to James.
It was hard to focus on the conversation when Orfy swept his arm through the doorframe and cast a spell at the exact moment James did, the multicoloured lights colliding with a hissing clash and ricocheting off one of the walls. In the reflection of the metal cabinet, James saw himself in Scarlett’s body—her appearance unchanged, save for her eyes, which now shone the same hazel brown as his.
He brushed at the grazes and cuts on his face before noticing the sports car a few metres away, its paint gleaming so brightly it hurt his eyes.
“I know how we’ll get out of here,” James murmured, dragging himself to the far side of the cabinet and nodding for Lily to warn him when Orfy struck again.
“Now!” she signalled.
Without even opening his mouth, James sent a Bombarda flying; the wall exploded and Orfy was hurled backwards.
“Fumos!” James flicked his wrist and a yellow light flared from the tip of his wand as a curtain of smoke billowed forth, shrouding the room.
Lily ran after Orfy, and Regulus stood his ground, a pale, indistinct glow amid the haze.
“He’ll be fine,” James told her.
He hauled himself, unsteady, towards the car and smashed his face against the windscreen. A groan escaped him as he pressed a hand to his nose, tasting the hot blood trickling down.
“Shit, I forgot I’m not a ghost anymore…” he muttered, stumbling to open the door and dive into the driver’s seat. He groped at the dashboard for the key—certain he’d seen it earlier—and indeed found it on the seat as he clipped in his belt.
“What on earth are you doing?” Red exclaimed, gobsmacked. “Is that your escape plan?”
“Shut up and get in!” James yelled, waving him down before engaging reverse.
“Lily!” Regulus called. “We need to go!”
Lily looked confused to see James manoeuvring the car in the garage.
“Do you have the gate remote?!” she asked as she slid into the passenger seat, patting her robes.
“I don’t need one…” James wound down the window and hurled another Bombarda, blasting the garage gate apart. “Come on, Red!”
With no time to lose, Regulus leapt onto Lily’s lap and James reversed out, shifting into first and second so swiftly he barely heard the engine’s roar or saw the houses blur past. He was so rattled he didn’t notice the traffic light, nor the elderly lady crossing the street whom he almost ran down.
“James!” Lily screamed, making him stamp on the brakes and squeal the tyres. He turned into a car park and came to a stop, still panting and disorientated. He stared at the “H” on the steering wheel for a long moment before Lily called again, “JAMES! Scar… you… you’re hurt?!”
Oh, it was true. James drew Scarlett’s wand and pointed it at his own face, mending the broken nose and wincing as he healed the cuts on his back—though he knew there was little magic could do for the bruises already throbbing, especially around his neck. Only a potion would truly fix those. His robes, however, were ruined.
He was about to restart the engine when a sudden lightness overtook him, as if nothing tethered him to the world. He floated free of Scarlett’s body, relinquishing every sensation that made him feel alive, banged his head on the roof and toppled onto Regulus, who was in Lily’s lap.
“Can’t fit one more here!” Regulus pushed James onto Scarlett, and he phased straight through her, tumbling out of the car.
Scarlett banged her forehead on the steering wheel and lay motionless.
“Do you think she’s dead?” Red slipped from Lily’s lap, his hand passing through Scar’s face.
“I think if she’d died… we’d have died, too…” Lily conjectured, folding her arms.
“Why did you shove me?!” James pushed his head back through the window.
“I wanted to be dead… then I wouldn’t have to hear you lot yelling in my ear…” Scarlett slurred, forehead pressed to the wheel, hair tumbling across her face.
“Are you all right?” Lily approached her as if to touch her, even though she couldn’t. “How do you feel?”
Scarlett merely curled into herself in the seat, shrugging without daring to look at them.
“Scar… I’m so sorry. I think… the torture with Orfy…”
“Get out, Regulus,” she snarled without looking at him. “This is your fault. It’s all your fault!”
“I’m sorry, I tried—”
“Shut up!” she cut him off with a hiss. “Get out, leave me alone!”
Regulus opened his mouth to argue but ended up nodding, phasing through the car and wandering aimlessly around the car park. James and Lily stayed silent, and Scarlett met their gaze with tear-filled eyes.
“All I did was… was… was… for him…” she stammered, covering her face with her hands as she sobbed. “He tried to kill me. Orfy tried to kill me. You should have let him kill me!”
“Don’t say that…” James half-closed his eyes, as though the pain tearing Scarlett’s heart was the same pain he felt.
“Sirius was right… I’ve got no one…”
“It’s not making any sense! You’ve got us!” Lily snapped, hurt. “You’ll always have us, Scar. You just need to… you just need to come home… to Remus’s house… and…”
“And we’ll be some perfect little family straight out of a telly commercial?!” Scarlett laughed, acidic.
“Yes, you’ll be happy!” Lily persisted with that drivel, which only served to further exasperate Scarlett.
“Happy?!” Her laugh faltered, but the bitterness remained. “I don’t deserve happiness, Lily.”
“For Merlin’s sake, Scarlett, you need to leave the past behind!” Lily raised her voice, tossing her perfect red hair over her shoulder.
Scarlett dug her nails into her scalp, tugging until her head burned.
“Leave the past behind?! How… how am I supposed to leave the bloody past behind with the lot of you haunting me?!” She shook her head, trying to fix her focus on her physical pain. “Speak up, Evans!”
Lily’s green eyes—always so vivid and kind—shrank with a remorse Scarlett had never seen before. Lily Evans was no one’s pushover, but in that moment Scarlett saw how deeply her words had stung, how they made sense. Her friend dropped her gaze, silenced. James flitted between the two of them, opening and closing his mouth before giving up on speaking.
Scarlett climbed out of the car, her entire back throbbing as though she’d been beaten. Breathing hurt, standing hurt, walking hurt. But Scarlett and pain were old friends, so she simply strode off aimlessly through the shopping centre’s concourse, as though trying to clear her head without a gaggle of ghosts screaming in her ear.
It was unbearable having her best friends following her like that. They showed no boundaries, she had no privacy, and she couldn’t even die in peace. Sometimes she couldn’t hear her own thoughts. She felt suffocated.
And she hadn’t even begun to process what’d happened with Orfy. She wasn’t ready to deal with that. She’d collapse, and she didn’t want to break down again, because that would mean having to return to Sirius—and the truth was…
Sirius had been right. She was alone. With or without ghosts… she had no future while in Azkaban, and now she was free… any hope of a future seemed a distant dream. Things felt more uncertain than ever. There was Reggie, of course, but two months still remained until the end of term at Hogwarts, and Scarlett didn’t want to have to live with Remus, or Sirius, or even with her ghosts.
She just wanted to be alone.
Scarlett sighed—very, very slowly. She didn’t need to be imprisoned to punish herself; she did it gladly, unconsciously. She raised her gaze to the window of a music shop, eyeing the vinyls by bands and singers she’d never heard of, gleaming instruments never played, and posters for albums never released.
Whenever she felt like this, she turned to music. It was an unbreakable connection she had with herself, with her family, with her history. She played the piano not merely because it was beautiful or because she enjoyed it, but because it was cathartic. It helped her channel her emotions outward.
Scarlett’s eyes immediately searched for the piano at the back of the shop. It wasn’t the grand piano she had at home, but any glimpse of the instrument usually lifted her spirits in an inexplicable way.
That the sight of the piano stirred nothing within her core was just another ingredient added to the cauldron bubbling up in her chest. In that moment, Scarlett realised something inside her was broken—something that could never be mended.
It wasn’t only about music, about pianos or about leaving the past behind. It was about everything she represented, about all the anger she harboured towards herself, all the self-resentment she kept in a little velvet box inside her heart. It was strange, looking at herself and finding the only love she could see was the love she felt for Sirius.
Sirius and Scarlett had grown up together, and there would always be a part of him within her. The love she felt for Sirius, though… it had been there so long she didn’t know how to live without it. It was what she’d clung to in order to survive the Death Eaters and Grimmauld Place, what had kept her determined for so long… what had made her realise she was incapable of loving herself as well.
Sirius’s love was etched so deeply into her chest that it only emphasised the emptiness she felt when she saw her own reflection in the cracked mirror. There were so many Scarletts there, and she didn’t like a single one of them. She didn’t know exactly why she hated herself so much—perhaps it was the wildly questionable choices she’d made, perhaps it was the friends she had killed, perhaps the fact that she was alive and free while James and Lily were dead and bound to her.
They deserved a happy family—and not… not her.
Remus had been right, and all Scarlett deserved was Azkaban.
It would’ve been so much easier if she’d stayed dead to everyone. Especially to Orfeu, who seemed to despise her so utterly. She knew he’d been tortured, that Wilkes had invaded his mind with illusions and false memories, but she’d never imagined that… that she’d become part of it. That Orfeu would hate her for things she’d never done.
Well, he’d probably hate her anyway for the McKinnons’ murders, so…
Scarlett sighed, trying to unwind those thoughts as determinedly as she tried to escape her past. How could she do that by moving in with Remus, with Sirius at her side every single day? Her ghosts were bad enough…
Her gaze drifted to the shop window and settled on a flyer stuck in the corner of the glass:
Space Travelers (covers band) seeking pianist/keyboardist. Call 4002-8922 or arrange an audition with Mike at the music shop.
Scarlett peered inside, reading the name-tags of the shop assistants until she found Mike—a tall, lanky chap in his mid-twenties who, from a distance, might’ve been mistaken for Moony.
She looked back at the piano, then at the car, and finally across the street at Regulus’s shimmer. She drew a deep breath, climbed into the car, retrieved the red leather jacket from the passenger seat, cast a quick charm to conceal her bruises and lacerations from her brother’s attempted murder, and flat-out ignored James and Lily’s questions.
She slipped on the jacket, got out of the car and walked into the music shop.
.
.
.
The last time Sirius had been in this place was on 23 October 1978—two days after Reggie was born and two years before Harry. Yet nothing about the venue had changed: the dark stone walls lit by braziers remained the same, as did the empty benches on each side of him, though now the higher tiers were filled with many dark silhouettes. Conversation and whispers died the moment the door closed behind him.
Sirius’s gaze fell on the chair in the centre of the room, its arms fitted with chains. It was where Scarlett had been condemned for the McKinnons’ murder. He watched, breath catching, as the chains came alive and bound her there.
His heart raced. Dumbledore’s hand rested on his shoulder, urging him onward.
Drawing a deep breath, Sirius stepped forward and sat in the chair himself, attempting to ignore the scrutinising stares of the audience. The chains rattled, but they did not hold him. He exhaled slowly and turned to face the spectators in the galleries.
There must have been well over a hundred people present, though only one in the middle of the front row caught his eye: Cornelius Fudge, the Minister for Magic. The man who had given him that newspaper almost a year ago in Azkaban. He would have to thank him for that later.
Dumbledore, immediately to his left, wore the robes of Chief Wizard of the Supreme Court of Wizards. Though his presence indicated the case’s reopening by the Wizengamot, he was meant to remain impartial, intervening only if he felt it necessary.
Sirius scanned the broad-boned witch to the left of Fudge—square-jawed, with cropped grey hair—her monacle glinting irritatingly in his vision. Her eyes triggered a fleeting memory in his mind, dissolving before he could seize it. To the right of the Minister sat another witch, but Sirius paid her little heed.
“Very well,” Fudge said, stroking his moustache as he inclined his head towards Sirius. “Shall we begin?” He addressed the other wizards, who all nodded. “This is the hearing of the first of May, to take evidence from Sirius Orion Black III, who was arrested on the first of November, 1981, for the massacre in London—twelve Muggle deaths, plus Peter Pettigrew—and for having betrayed the Potters’ whereabouts to the Dark Lord.” He rubbed his hands together as he fixed Sirius with a stare. “Are you Sirius Orion Black III, residing at 14 Saltoun Road, Brixton, London?”
“Yes,” Sirius said, moistening his lips as the muttering in the hall surged once more.
“Very well, then let us proceed.” Fudge unrolled another parchment. “Prosecutors in the Ministry of Magic versus Sirius Black: Cornelius Oswald Fudge, Minister for Magic; Amelia Susannah Bones, Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement; Dolores Jane Umbridge, Senior Under-secretary to the Minister…”
Sirius ceased to listen the moment he glanced over his shoulder towards the seat he had occupied at Scarlett’s hearing. He did not wish to recall that day, yet the atmosphere of this place drew him back little by little—not only by its oppressive formality, but by the way the Court regarded him with such repulsion, as though his guilt were self-evident.
“…in light of the new evidence presented by the Chief Wizard of the Court, together with the imprisonment and escape of Peter Pettigrew, the case has been reopened and is under fresh investigation. Mr Black, would you kindly tell us what occurred on the night of the twenty-eighth of October, 1981?”
Sirius cast a furtive glance at Dumbledore before clearing his throat and drawing in a steadying breath, banishing the sordid feelings that slithered through the memory. The silence following Fudge’s question was so thick he could hear his own heartbeat.
He collected his thoughts. He could not mention Harry’s prophecy.
“James and Lily Potter…” He swallowed, clenching his fists slowly. “They needed a Secret-Keeper for their house…” He looked to Dumbledore, who gave him a subtle nod to continue. “We knew the Death Eaters were after the Potters… we’d been fighting them in the war for nearly three years…” He rubbed his fingertips over the worn wood of the chair. “James then suggested I become the Secret-Keeper. He was my best friend. I would have done anything for him, but…” His voice wavered. Every time he thought of James, it felt as though the very breath had been sucked from his lungs. “It was far too obvious that I’d be the Keeper. So I suggested Peter instead. No one would ever suspect him to be the Secret-Keeper and… and… I’d draw the Death Eaters away from him. But… we didn’t know… we could never have guessed… that he was a traitor.”
“Then… in fact, Peter Pettigrew was the Secret-Keeper… and he betrayed the Potters to the Dark Lord?” Fudge’s voice cut through the hall.
“Precisely, Minister.”
A murmur swept through the benches, rippling down the galleries.
“Can you prove this?” Fudge demanded, holding Sirius with an unyielding stare.
“Yes, Minister. I was the one who wove the Fidelius Charm for James and Peter. I…” Sirius said loudly, running a hand over his throat to ease the tightness. “I performed the Fidelius. It’s an extremely complex spell, and Peter… he didn’t know how to cast it.”
“Very well. A wand-lore examination will follow once these questions are answered. Now, what occurred on the night of the first of November, 1981?”
The whispers died to silence.
Sirius’s entire body prickled. His nostrils flared, his spine straightened, and his pupils dilated in primal alertness. Had he been in Padfoot’s form, his ears would have flattened and his fangs bared.
He did not wish to summon that memory, so he spoke tersely, recounting how he tracked down Wormtail, followed him to confront him, and how, to his shock, Peter severed his own finger, obliterated the street, and fled alongside the other rats…
“‘The Aurors’ report stated that Peter Pettigrew was an Animagus. Were you aware of this, sir?” Fudge interrupted.
Sirius moistened his lips and glanced again at Dumbledore.
“We all were, Minister,” he confessed, and the murmur rose once more. “James, Peter and I became Animagi—illegally—in our fifth year at Hogwarts…” He paused there, unwilling to speak of Moony.
“You never registered?” came a shrill voice from the witch seated to the Minister’s right. “That is a crime, Mr Black.”
Sirius fought back a laugh—several on the Court shared the sentiment.
“It was how I got into Hogwarts, Minister,” he continued, ignoring her. “But my target was never Harry. It never was. With the newspaper you gave me in Azkaban…” He noted Fudge’s blush at that admission. “…I saw that Peter was living with a Muggle family. They were on the front page.”
Fudge began to protest, but Amelia Bones held up the Prophet and flipped it towards Sirius.
“Is this rat Peter Pettigrew?” she asked, surprised.
“If you’d look properly,” Sirius said, raising his little finger. “You’ll note he’s missing a digit. That’s how I knew it was him—and that he was at Hogwarts.”
“So you went to Hogwarts to avenge your friends’ deaths?” the other witch asked, petulantly.
Sirius shook his head. “And to protect my godson. I didn’t know what Peter planned. He was hated among the Death Eaters—I heard them screaming his name in Azkaban. After all, their Dark Lord vanished because of Peter’s betrayal. Peter wouldn’t leave his hiding place either if not for a whisper… a hint of Voldemort’s return…” That name made several in the galleries hold their breath. “Peter would complete what his master tried thirteen years ago. I could not allow that—I promised to protect my best friend’s son, I…”
His voice faltered as sobs threatened to rise. Sirius expelled them with a slow exhale, wiping his eyes and looking down, focusing only on each inhalation and exhalation. He felt tormented by his own memories.
“And how did you escape from Azkaban?” Fudge raised a hand to still the whispering.
Ah, now it was time to tell the tale he and Dumbledore had agreed upon.
“It was in my Animagus form… I turned into a dog… Dementors are blind, so they didn’t notice… I slipped through the bars… swam to shore,” he shrugged. “And then I made my way to Hogwarts.”
“Impossible!” the witch to Fudge’s right leapt to her feet. “Not only were you an unregistered Animagus, you used it to break out of Azkaban…”
“Let him speak, Dolores,” Fudge admonished, casting a reproving glance at his Undersecretary.
“I tried to catch Peter every time… whenever they thought I was after Harry. It was the rat I meant to find. Why would I kill my godson?! He… he’s all I have left…”
All I have left of my best friend, he almost said, but choked on the words.
“Shall we move to the evidence, Mr Black?” said Madam Bones, still poring over the newspaper as she folded it and made notes on her parchment.
“Yes,” Sirius nodded.
Three Aurors appeared, summoned a table, and placed a pair of wands upon it. He recognised his own at once—it was a Black family heirloom, passed down to the eldest son, and he’d had it since childhood. Despite his hatred for his kin, he used to relish reminding his mother that the wand of the Most Ancient and Most Noble House of Black was wielded by a blood-traitor—to defeat the supremacists and Death Eaters.
“Mr Black, could you identify your wand?” Madam Bones instructed, beckoning him forward.
Sirius stepped to the table under the predatory gaze of the Aurors, who seemed poised to pounce at any sudden move. He picked up the rune-etched wand, stroking its shaft as its warm magic tingled in his fingers. It felt utterly different from the wand he’d swiped from Scarlett’s tormentors in Azkaban. This one felt made for him—though it had never chosen him in the traditional sense. It sat so naturally in his hand that it felt like part of himself, and a soft breeze coursed through him as his magic reconnected with it after all those years.
“This is mine,” Sirius said, laying it gently back on the table before looking at Peter’s wand. One of the Aurors confirmed with a nod to the Court.
“Priori Incantatem!” another Auror shouted, pointing a wand at Sirius’s heirloom. The wand began to vibrate fiercely. Sirius instinctively stepped forward to steady it, but Dumbledore gently held his arm to restrain him.
“Retrahere.” His voice echoed, distant, as the purple tracking charm flared before giving way to a series of everyday spells, until a thread of golden light welled from his wand’s tip as he cast the Fidelius, binding James’s secret into Peter’s very soul.
A figure of that day filled the space between Sirius and the table: shadows of himself, holding wands between James and Peter. James’s translucent figure leaned close to Peter’s ear and whispered the secret. Sirius gasped, pressing a hand to his chest, as if he could touch that strange semblance of his friend. It was formless, indistinct, yet Sirius knew it was James.
His heart thundered so fiercely he feared he might collapse, until the shadows gradually dissipated into the gloom of the Courtroom Ten, where the braziers’ flames danced upon the stone walls. Sirius blinked several times, drying his sweating palms against his trousers.
“Mr Black’s testimony has been concise thus far,” Madam Bones’s thundering voice broke him from his stupor. “Now, let us do Pettigrew’s.”
The Aurors repeated the procedure, and Wormtail’s wand quivered before disgorging his spells:
“Confringo!” Peter’s sharp voice sent a wave of revulsion through Sirius. The scarlet curse flared and died away. It was Scarlett who had taught them the Blasting Curse, and Peter had used it to obliterate the London street. Several more disguising charms flickered at the wand’s tip, and before the Auror could stop them, a green light hissed into the floor, conjuring a thick mist that coalesced into a skull. “Morsmordre.”
Sirius drew a shuddering breath as much of the Court exhaled in horror—some even clasping their hands over their mouths—while the serpent slithered from the skull’s maw before fading away. Amelia Bones stared, wide-eyed, and a pulsing vein throbbed at Cornelius Fudge’s temple.
“I believe there can be no further doubt as to what transpired,” Madam Bones declared, turning to the Minister for Magic, who appeared too astonished to speak.
“Surely we cannot simply overlook the other crimes of Sirius Black, Madam?” Dolores Umbridge sneered, regarding Sirius as though he were refuse. “An illegal Animagus for years, an escape from Azkaban…”
Amelia Bones fixed Umbridge with a scorching glare.
“May I remind you, Miss Umbridge, that Sirius Black spent twelve years in Azkaban as an innocent man?” she enunciated sternly.
“But he is not innocent!” Umbridge spat back.
“It seems any sentence he might have faced for being an unregistered Animagus has already been served. Moreover, I fail to see how escaping from Azkaban as an innocent could constitute a crime… may I remind this entire Court that Sirius Black never received a formal trial—he was sent straight to Azkaban on nothing more than Dumbledore’s testimony,” she said, nodding towards the Headmaster. “That Black was the Secret-Keeper was sufficient for the gavel to fall and for him to serve an unjust sentence. What we do in this House is dispense justice, not injustice or vengeance. We can never restore the twelve years the defendant spent imprisoned, but at least we can grant him the justice he deserves, can we not?”
Several witches and wizards around her began to murmur in agreement, others nodded, while a small group shook their heads in dissent.
“We still have many questions to address…” Fudge admitted, still unnerved by the Dark Mark conjured from Pettigrew’s wand. “For instance, why was he laughing…”
“I believe that no further inquiry diminishes the defendant’s innocence, Minister,” Madam Bones retorted, her tone sharp as a whip. Those who had furrowed their brows now whispered assent. “Those in favour of clearing the accused of all charges?”
Sirius watched, stunned and speechless, as a hundred hands shot into the air. He glanced at Dumbledore, as though to ask if this were truly happening, but the old wizard remained proud and impassive, as if merely fulfilling a formality.
“And those in favour of conviction?”
A dozen wizards raised their hands—Sirius was certain they all hailed from respected pure-blood families. He made a point of regarding them with the utmost contempt. Fudge appeared momentarily at a loss, looking first to the gallery, then to Madam Bones, before folding his arms and nodding.
“Very well, then… Sirius Black… cleared of all charges.”
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 34: Just hold me close
Chapter Text
CII
"This is outrageous!" Dolores roared, rising to her feet. She was a short, plump woman who looked like a toad, with a broad, sagging face. Her large, slightly bulging eyes were fixed on Sirius. "That man is a criminal..."
"That’s enough, Dolores," Fudge snapped, through gritted teeth.
"But… but… Minister… we haven’t even heard the witnesses yet… the wands might be mixed up… and… and the Hippogriff—"
"They’re not mixed up, Dolores, I was there when he was arrested," Fudge hissed, scorching her with his gaze.
"But… what are we going to tell the Prophet?! That Sirius Black is innocent?! He’s a maniac, Minister—"
"The Undersecretary is worried about public opinion?!" Amelia Bones looked at her in disbelief.
"Of course I am, Madam! What reputation would the government have after admitting this..."
"And the government’s reputation is more important than the life of an innocent man?!" She curled her lip in disdain. Fudge let out an awkward snort of laughter and Umbridge fell silent, gathering up her parchments, exasperated. "Very well, session adjourned. Mr Black, would you come with me?"
Sirius hadn’t paid the slightest attention to any of the argument. All that echoed in his mind was the word innocent, and anything said after that didn’t even register.
"Mr Black?!" Amelia Bones called again, pulling him from his daze. Dumbledore was there too, beside him. "Come with me to my office..."
Sirius stood still for a moment, until the woman gave him a sideways glance. His body suddenly jolted into action, and he followed her. He had no idea how many flights of stairs they climbed or which floor the lift stopped on—his head was spinning. He felt dizzy and wary. Waiting for something to go wrong, waiting for the floor to vanish beneath his feet or for him to wake from a dream. Even with Dumbledore at his side, he had never felt so unsure.
The place was not unfamiliar. He scanned the open area, subdivided into cubicles buzzing with conversation, paper aeroplanes darting in and out like broomsticks. A crooked sign read: Auror Headquarters.
He spotted wanted posters with his face on them in one of the rooms, and the chatter died at once, the Aurors’ eyes burning into the back of his neck, but Sirius paid them no mind. When had he been there before?
Madam Bones opened the oak door to her office, where the name Amelia Bones was engraved in golden letters. Sirius stopped in front of a chair, his gaze drifting about, his mind trying to grasp at the memories beginning to surface. His attention fixed on a photograph atop the Head of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement’s desk.
In it, there was a tall, red-haired man with grey eyes. He was smiling, holding a child in one arm and his wife wrapped under the other, who cradled a baby. Sirius tilted his head to the side, voices from the past whispering in his ears.
"Edgar," he said, without meaning to. He blinked a few times, looking at the photo beside it: a man who resembled Edgar, but with dark eyes and appearing much older, standing with his wife and three children in the picture. "Edmund...?"
Now, the name Bones was beginning to make sense in his head. Edgar had been a member of the Order of the Phoenix, and like many of them... he’d been murdered.
"They’re my younger brothers..." Amelia gave a smile full of sorrow. "Edgar always spoke highly of you."
Sirius raised his eyebrows, gazing at her in surprise.
"Highly?"
"Yes, you were friends, weren’t you?"
Sirius opened and closed his mouth before clicking his tongue and turning back to the photo of Edgar smiling with his child in his arms.
"Sorry, Madam. Azkaban... took a lot from me," he admitted awkwardly. "The good memories..."
Amelia’s expression shifted from nostalgia to compassion. Sirius clenched his fists. He didn’t want pity — that was exactly why he hated talking about the gaps in his memory with people.
"Edgar and the whole family were murdered by Death Eaters... a bit before the Potters..."
Sirius knew he ought to feel something at the revelation, but the truth was he felt nothing. Edgar seemed familiar, but he’d lost so much that one more name in the heap didn’t make any difference.
"I'm sorry, Madam Bones," he murmured with a nod.
"So am I, Black." She picked up the portrait of Edmund. "And Eddy... well, he hated you and your best friend… he was in love with Potter’s wife… what was her name again?"
"Lily." Sirius answered so quickly he barely had time to register what he’d just said.
"Ah yes, Lily… he used to write to me, fuming about the pair of them..."
"Yeah… I remember we ruined their date at Madam Puddifoot’s..." Sirius caught himself smiling, the happy expression leaving a bitter taste in his mouth.
James and Lily were dead.
The smile vanished.
"Precisely." Madam Bones gestured for Sirius to take a seat. He barely noticed Dumbledore’s absence. "But we’re not here to talk about the past."
Sirius settled into the leather chair, glancing at the door and wondering when Dumbledore had left. His heart tried to quicken, but calmed again as his attention returned to the photo of Edgar and his family. Who could’ve killed them?
Two knocks at the door made him glance over his shoulder, where a very tall, dark-skinned man entered. He set a long box atop the desk, greeting Madam Bones with a reserved nod.
"Madam Bones. Black." He glanced at him, and the name of the man slipped from Sirius's lips at once.
"Shacklebolt," Sirius blurted, startled by how quickly the man's image had flooded his mind. Where did he know him from?
"Good to see you." The man gave him a pat on the shoulder before leaving the room.
Sirius hadn’t even had time to think when Madam Bones offered him tea. He stared at his own reflection in the scarlet liquid and swirled it with the white of the milk, turning it pink.
Madam Bones watched Sirius for a moment before speaking:
"Mr Black, the Ministry acknowledges the grave mistake that was made in condemning you without a fair trial. As part of our compensation for the years you lost, we are offering financial reparations. Additionally, Albus Dumbledore has recommended that you resume your Auror training." She maintained her composed and formal posture with such ease that Sirius found himself reminded of his younger brother.
He took a sip of tea during the long, uncomfortable silence that followed. It was a lot to take in, too many memories fighting to leap out of their tank, and he couldn’t afford to lose control right now.
"Madam Bones, I... I’ve just come out of Azkaban." Sirius hadn’t meant for the words to sound so sharp. He cleared his throat. "How would I finish Auror training… I’ve forgotten so much..."
"I understand your hesitation." She didn’t seem surprised. "It would indeed be a challenging path, especially because yes, there are still members within our Ministry who may question your loyalty. However, the offer is being made because we believe in your ability and resilience—after all, no one had ever escaped from Azkaban before you." She sipped her tea. "Moreover, your records from when you undertook training clearly state that you were more capable than many of our senior Aurors in handling Dark wizards."
Sirius shook his head sceptically, offering a faint, awkward smile.
"I’m not the same man I was twelve years ago, Madam Bones," he said, with a bitterness that seeped into every word. "The Dementors tore something out of me that I’m not sure I can get back..."
"Ah, yes, we’re also offering a recovery therapy programme through our mediwizards at St Mungo’s. We know that... the presence of Dementors is profoundly damaging to any sane wizard and... I truly am sorry for everything you went through, Mr Black."
There was guilt in the woman’s eyes. Curiosity too. She was studying his every move meticulously, as though trying to be sure he truly was innocent.
He needed time to take it all in, but the idea of resuming Auror training was beyond absurd — he couldn’t even picture himself outside of Azkaban, let alone as an Auror. It was too big a leap, and he didn’t want trouble. He only wished to live in peace with his family.
"Your decision will be respected, Mr Black, whatever it may be. The Ministry is here to support you in whatever path you choose. And should you decide not to continue Auror training, we will still ensure you receive financial compensation. It’s the very least we owe for the time unjustly taken from you." She tapped her fingernails on the corner of the wooden desk.
"I... don’t know," was all he managed to say.
"Take as much time as you need. We’re here to help you transition into whatever life you choose from here on." She offered him a gentle smile.
Sirius merely nodded, his eyes drifting to the box on the desk.
"Your wand," Amelia explained, opening the ivory lid. "It was kept in evidence for your case… now that the case is closed, there’s no longer any need for the Ministry to keep it..."
Before he realised it, his hand had reached for it, feeling the magic hum from the base of his spine to the tips of his fingers. Once, the wand’s grip had been made of exquisite mahogany, adorned with the Black family crest in silver filigree: the shield with three ravens and the family motto.
Sirius had ripped that hilt off and replaced it with another, made of varnished oak with red and gold detailing at the ends.
She also gave him a folder full of documents, which Sirius honestly didn’t care about. He hadn’t expected to get his wand back, let alone his freedom or... any kind of life that wasn’t spent in a cage in Azkaban. He’d dreamed of being free when they were trying to capture Peter at Hogwarts, and now that dream had become reality...
It didn’t feel real. It felt like an illusion bound to shatter at any moment. Sirius kept waiting for the moment he would open his eyes and wake up—to feel the cold of the Dementors draining his hope, to let the darkness of Azkaban smother this fevered dream. He was certain it was only a hallucination of his own making. It couldn’t possibly be true.
He didn’t want to believe it was true. He couldn’t bear the disappointment of finding out it had all been a lie. He didn’t want to. He barely noticed the tears soaking into his beard, nor the handkerchief Madam Bones handed him.
"Thank you," he murmured quietly, dabbing the moisture from his face.
"Dumbledore is waiting by the lift corridor." She pressed her lips into an awkward smile, as though she had no idea what to do in a moment like this.
Neither did Sirius, but he stood up and forced a smile.
"Thank you again, Madam Bones." He took a deep breath, bracing himself for something to go wrong—for someone to burst through the door and declare it had all been a lie, that he was guilty and going back to Azkaban.
But nothing happened. Sirius left Madam Bones’ office in a daze, staring at the carpeted floor of the cubicles until he turned the corner and found Dumbledore waiting. The old wizard wore a thoughtful expression, but his eyes lit up at the sight of Sirius.
"Was your conversation with Madam Bones pleasant?" he asked, clasping his hands as they waited for the lift.
Sirius rubbed his eyes, feeling utterly drained.
"Why… why did you recommend me to resume Auror training?!" he demanded, glaring at the wizard, which made Dumbledore’s brows twitch slightly.
"I believe resuming the course will not only aid in your rehabilitation, but also grant you an opportunity to investigate certain irregularities within the Ministry," he replied, as though carefully selecting each word. "And to keep our mutual friend out of trouble."
"You want me to babysit Scar—" Sirius cut himself off as the lift arrived on their floor with a rattle of gears. The golden gate slid back; two women exited (not without casting him curious, mildly intrigued glances), and he and Dumbledore stepped inside, followed by a flurry of paper aeroplanes.
"Oh, we both know our mutual friend’s uncanny ability to find herself in... extraordinarily anarchic situations," Dumbledore chuckled at his own words, as the planes floated lazily around his silver mane.
"I’m not going to babysit her," Sirius said firmly. "And why do you think I could make any difference here?! You’ve already got plenty of powerful friends."
Dumbledore raised his gaze to the memorandums, the purple planes dancing in the reflection of his half-moon spectacles. Then he turned back to Sirius with a small, almost wistful smile.
"That’s true, Sirius. But only you can investigate our friend’s situation... and, if necessary, find out if there are others like her."
Sirius arched his eyebrows sharply, lifting his chin with defiance.
"I thought you just wanted me to keep an eye on her," he muttered, scowling at the evasive, typically Dumbledorean reply.
"That too," the Headmaster confirmed, looking out as the lift doors opened and more planes piled up beneath the glowing lamp.
Sirius exhaled through his teeth, shaking his head.
"I can’t do it," he admitted, his voice low. "I… she… we…" He faltered, trying to form a coherent thought. "We’ll destroy each other just like we did in the past."
Dumbledore stroked his beard once again with maddening calm.
"You’re not the same people you once were."
Sirius swallowed hard.
"No... we’re not."
He wasn’t sure whether that was a good or a bad thing. His heart skipped a few beats. Azkaban had left cracks in them that would never fully heal. That was one of the many things they had in common. He closed his eyes and let himself sink into the memory of the night before, his whole body shivering at the overwhelming sensation of having her again. Of making her his. Then he thought of her that morning, sleeping peacefully in his arms as though that was the safest place in the world.
What was it she wanted to tell him that morning?
Sirius had no time to speculate. As soon as the lift doors opened onto the Atrium, he was met with a barrage of blinding camera flashes and a throng of reporters shouting unintelligible questions while a crowd protested against his exoneration.
.
.
.
"What do you mean she’s gone?!" Sirius demanded, his smile bearing only the shape of one.
Remus ran a hand down his face with force, as though he were carrying the weight of the world on his shoulders. He collapsed into the armchair in the sitting room, letting his head fall back against the cushion, unable to meet Sirius’s gaze.
"We argued… she went into Reggie’s room… and vanished," he answered, as if it were obvious.
Sirius took a deep breath, clenching his fists as he stomped down the hall to Regulus’s bedroom. Before his imprisonment, entering that room had always been a little daunting. All of his memories with Scarlett were in there — the photos, the recordings, her personal belongings, everything that survived the fire...
He scanned the room until he reached the bed, where a clearly disturbed box sat. He had never touched it since Scarlett had been imprisoned. He hadn’t wanted to think about her — not more than he already did. He tipped it onto the mattress, rifling through the knick-knacks that spilled over the sheets, as if any of them might contain a clue.
He turned his head to the side, catching sight of the photo where Scarlett beamed with a wide smile as he knelt down, opening the little box with a black diamond ring inside. The memory snagged at his chest like a fishhook, yanking his heart so violently that tears were forced to the surface.
Sirius blinked them away angrily, scrubbing at his eyes with more pressure than was wise. He stepped back, trying to swim to the surface of that dark, churning, catatonic place inside himself. Nostalgia mixed with pain coiled around his heart with such force he could scarcely feel it beating anymore.
Remus was leaning against the doorframe, arms crossed as he watched.
"I’m going after her," Sirius murmured, meeting his eyes. "She can’t have gone far..."
"Sirius..." Remus stepped into the room, his lower lip trembling as though he didn’t know what to say. There was guilt hidden in the worn lines of his face. "Have you forgiven her?"
Of all the questions Remus could have asked, that was the last Sirius would’ve expected. He felt ashamed to speak the truth, yet knew full well that Remus would see through any excuse he might conjure.
"No," he admitted, wetting his lips as he took another deep breath, rubbing at his neck to ease the pressure tightening there.
"Then why?" Remus asked quietly. "Three years, Sirius... three years you were miserable over what she did and then she comes back and you... you’re back together again?! After what she did? She’s a monster!" Remus snapped, struggling to swallow back his own tears.
He didn’t want to argue about it in that moment, but it was all too easy to engage in the discussion just to suppress the unbearable pressure in his chest and stifle the guilt that haunted him for being so lenient with Scarlett after everything she’d done. Love and hate flayed his core in a macabre dance.
"If she’s a monster, then so am I," Sirius retorted coldly. "I killed James and Lily."
Remus exhaled sharply, as if what he’d just heard was ludicrous.
"No, it’s… it’s different. You were innocent! You—"
"I was the one who suggested Wormtail," Sirius cut in. "Before we escaped Azkaban, I killed a wizard with my own hands..."
"Sirius, she used the Killing Curse!" Remus snapped, nearly shouting.
"We both killed. Innocent, guilty… what difference does it make? A life is a life." Sirius felt bile burn its way up his throat. The sting wasn’t nearly enough to cover the hypocrisy in his voice.
"I can’t believe you’re making excuses for her!" Remus tried to control his tone, but it only made his words sound more uncertain. "You haven’t forgiven her, and yet… you’re still trying to justify—"
Sirius shook his head and sat down on the bed, burying his face in his hands.
Remus was right. He always was. Scarlett had killed Marlene and her entire family. Sirius hadn’t killed the Potters directly, but he had killed that wizard in Azkaban in a life-or-death situation.
There was something inherently similar in the nature of the act, though.
They had both done it to protect.
It was something far stronger than he was. Sirius had no idea what souls were made of, but he was certain of one thing: his and Scarlett’s had been forged from the same material. Dark, dense, and enduring like mist that lingers until morning breaks. It burned as quickly as it cooled. They were so alike, it was infuriating.
"You don’t understand, Remus. She did it… to protect. To protect Orfy… and Reg…"
"And you believe her?!" Remus laughed bitterly, incredulous. "Of course she’d say that—she’ll say anything to… to try and justify…"
"You think she’s lying?" Sirius cut in again, shooting his friend a reluctant look. "Why would she lie?"
"I don’t know, Sirius, I don’t know what goes on in her head. I don’t… I don’t know her. Not anymore."
"But I know her, Rem." Sirius wiped away the tears that refused to stop falling. "I didn’t want to know her, but… I don’t know, Remus, I can’t… I can’t leave her. I can’t turn my back on her. She’s everything I lost… she’s… I see Regulus in her as much as I see myself. The good moments and the bad, the memories and the pain. I need her, Remus. I don’t even understand it myself… I still love her… and I hate her… she broke me and put me back together and…" He sniffed, embarrassed to be opening up like that to his friend. "No one ever wanted to admit it, but… we’re both fire, Remus. We always have been."
Remus clenched his jaw, his sharp gaze following every word Sirius spoke, as though truly trying to understand whatever it was he was trying to explain.
"Yeah… you’re both fire," he agreed, a throbbing anger pulsing in his veins. "And you’re going to burn each other all over again! And I won’t be here to pick up your pieces, Sirius!"
Sirius shook his head, trying to mask the bitterness of being misunderstood. He should be used to it by now. Only Scarlett ever understood him fully. He couldn’t expect that from Remus, but even so… he wanted him to understand.
"Haven’t we suffered enough already, Moony?" he asked softly, appealing to the old nickname. He heard Remus sigh, as though he too were trying to hold back everything bottled up in his chest.
"Apparently, you haven’t." Remus went on, unyielding. "You’re desperate to be shattered by her all over again..."
"Remus, things aren’t black and white!" Sirius growled, lifting his eyes to him. "They’re fucking grey!"
"Fuck off, Sirius! I won’t let… I won’t allow… her to ruin everything I’ve built! I won’t be left alone again! I won’t… fuck… who do you think— I had twelve fucking years of hell too!"
Sirius shot up suddenly, taking an instinctive step toward Remus.
"You can be sure that whatever you went through doesn’t come close to what we went through… to the torture she endured..." He panted, overwhelmed by the echo of Azkaban’s rotted memories.
Remus was struggling not to cry, the emotion rising hot in his throat.
"She was tortured, I know, you both told me, but… that torture doesn’t erase what she did..."
"No, it doesn’t," Sirius said flatly, forcing the air from his lungs. "But… if she hadn’t done what she did, she wouldn’t have been tortured." He lowered his gaze. "How many more years of suffering did she deserve to pay for what she did, Moony? Ten? Twenty? Thirty? A hundred?!"
Remus had no answer to that. The truth was he couldn’t bring himself to believe the story—even though he knew it wasn’t a lie. Accepting that Scarlett had been tortured meant accepting that the murder of the McKinnons had been paid for with a cruelty far greater than what they had endured. It meant admitting that all the years he’d spent resenting and blaming Scarlett hadn’t been in vain, because his thirst for justice—bordering on vengeance—had been satisfied.
He shuddered, a look of revulsion settling over his face.
"So… she was tortured… is that why… you’re together now…"
"We’re not together," Sirius denied firmly. "I haven’t forgiven her."
"But you slept with her..."
Sirius exhaled, running a hand through his long hair as he closed his eyes.
"I hate her, Remus. Deeply. And I love her just as much," he confessed, collapsing back onto the bed as he finally let the words escape. "I don’t expect you to understand. I don’t understand it either. She… brings things out in me… things I didn’t know were there. Good things… and bad..."
"You two were always like that," Remus whispered, brushing the scar on his chin. "You brought out the best and the worst in each other."
"I know." Sirius let out a huff. "I hurt her like hell, too."
"You always deserved each other." A faint shadow of a smile flickered across Remus’s lips.
"I can’t… I can’t let her go, Remus." Sirius ran a hand over his face, hiding any trace of tears.
"Can’t… or won’t?"
Sirius didn’t know how to answer that. He felt like a fool for everything he’d said, and he didn’t want to untangle the mess called Scarlett Gaunt from his chest. But the weight in his ribs had lessened after opening up to Remus like that. Of course, it hadn’t come close to pulling at the barbed wires of his feelings for Scarlett, but he couldn’t live with that suspicious look in Moony’s eyes because of her.
"I don’t know," he murmured. "I’m just a man suffering from love."
Remus gave a soft snort of laughter, his expression easing.
"And still the drama queen, it seems."
Sirius clicked his tongue and flipped him off as he stood up.
"Fuck off."
Remus tilted his head, stepping aside to let him pass through the doorway. Sirius pulled his wand from his pocket, breathing a little more freely. His gaze lingered on the mouldy, grimy little stuffed cat atop the piano, a flash of some far-off day glinting in his eyes. The day she gave him that stupid toy. Now, the tuxedo kitten was covered in mould, with a few tears and the grime of time.
But it was still the same cat… it just needed a bit of mending.
Maybe he should have been more desperate about Scarlett’s disappearance, but all that occupied his mind in that moment was what she had wanted to tell him before he left for the Ministry.
It had seemed important.
Sirius flicked his wrist and whispered the spell Dumbledore had taught him to track her through the ring that had guided them during their escape from Hogwarts.
.
.
.
[Music: Bonnie Raitt — I Can’t Make You Love Me]
Sirius chuckled to himself as he stared at the neon sign that read The Hanged Man, with a man dangling upside down by one foot. The golden thread from Scarlett’s ring had led him there. He pushed through the double doors and was greeted by a dimly lit space, rustic and lined with photographs, musical instruments on display, and memorabilia from various bands.
He shoved his hands into his pockets and wandered deeper into the venue, nearly empty at that hour. There was, however, a cluster of people at the stage—and Sirius spotted her immediately: Scarlett had just settled at the piano, studying a sheet of music while the vocalist stepped up to the mic and three men spread out across the other instruments.
Turn down the lights
Turn down the bed
Turn down these voices inside my head
Lay down with me
Tell me no lies
Just hold me close, don’t patronise
Don’t patronise me
Sirius hardly registered who the others were. His eyes were fixed solely on Scarlett. The girl whose hair he once wove flowers into. What the hell was she doing there? And where did she get that red leather jacket? One of the spotlights hit her so strongly she looked like a sculpture; her reddish-brown hair spilling down her shoulders, her blue eyes catching the white flecks from the lights all around her.
He was so entranced that he barely moved to let a few people pass, before leaning against a wall that gave him a clear view of the stage. The vocalist tested the mic a few times, and all eyes turned to Scarlett, who signalled the drummer—and the two began to play together.
His entire body tingled as memories floated through his mind like soap bubbles. Sirius didn’t want to pop them, not just yet. Watching Scarlett play like that gave him such an intense déjà vu that, for a moment, the bar melted away and became the Hogwarts Undercroft once more.
'Cause I can't make you love me if you don't
You can't make your heart feel something it won't
Here in the dark, in these final hours
I will lay down my heart and I'll feel the power
But you won't, no you won't
'Cause I can't make you love me, if you don't
Every time he’d broken into the castle, he hadn’t so much as gone near the clock in the Defence Against the Dark Arts Tower. It was almost instinctive—a protective reflex. He knew that if he did, if he opened that clock and descended the stairs, if he stepped into that refuge of so many good memories… he would crumble like a sandcastle struck by a crashing wave.
He watched, entranced, as Scarlett’s hands glided over the keys with ease, as though she knew exactly what she was doing. James, beside her, accompanied her with his guitar. Remus had one foot propped on a bench, watching. Sirius barely registered where he was, until the golden shimmer of the cymbals caught his eye and made him squint.
He’d left the drumsticks atop the snare, observing as Scarlett and James wove the melody together with the low hum of Remus’s bass—the three of them exchanging glances of shared understanding, while he felt strangely excluded from it all.
It was the same sense of detachment that washed over him now, watching her play on that stage, eyes closed in total concentration and surrender—as if she belonged to another world entirely. As if she weren’t Scarlett Gaunt, a convicted murderer sentenced to life in prison.
She was just Scarlett, playing a silly song on a silly piano in a silly bar.
I’ll close my eyes, then I won’t see
The love you don’t feel when you’re holding me
Morning will come and I’ll do what’s right
Just give me till then to give up this fight
And I will give up this fight
Sirius’s chest swelled with jealousy and envy. He wanted that too—he wanted to be just another familiar face among strangers connected by music. He wanted to be just Sirius, playing drums with just Scarlett at the piano. But there was no space there for him, so he resigned himself to being merely a powerless spectator to the depth Scarlett poured into her instrument.
He couldn’t help but feel like an intruder. Since Azkaban, he’d only seen Scarlett smile like that to herself when she played the piano in the Shrieking Shack. It wasn’t just a smile; she radiated delight, a sense of belonging. She lost and found herself in the notes, in her own pain, in her own mistakes. Watching her like that—so passionate, so immersed—left him awestruck… but also deeply sad.
'Cause I can't make you love me if you don't
You can't make your heart feel something it won't
Here in the dark, in these final hours
I will lay down my heart and I'll feel the power
But you won't, no you won't
'Cause I can't make you love me, if you don't
Scarlett’s smile widened when she hit a wrong note. There was a sparkle in her eyes, a fluidity in her movements, a subtlety that made the music all the more melancholic. It was the same Scarlett he’d seen play so many times in the past—she was that impulsive, reckless girl, the smiling girl, the depressed girl. His Scarlett. The girl he had loved with all his heart, whom he had given himself to with just as much torment as she now poured into the music.
Anger surged in his chest, searing. Sirius didn’t want to admit it, but seeing her so happy like that without him— hurt. It hurt more than he’d thought it would. He wanted Scarlett to be happy, but he wanted her to be happy with him, with their family—not with a bunch of strangers in some random pub in London.
He wanted to make her as happy as the music did. He wanted to be the cause of that spontaneous smile, those open glances, those measured movements. He wanted… he wanted none of the shit between them to have happened. He wanted them to have stopped time after leaving Hogwarts and to have started life again now. No war, no betrayal, no Azkaban.
Scarlett opened her eyes and met his gaze at once. As if she’d sensed him. As if she knew he’d be there.
Sirius didn’t move.
The blue of her eyes flickered with something undefinable — surprise, recognition… rejection? The music didn’t stop. Scarlett kept playing as though the song itself was stronger than she was.
Sirius shrank back. He would always be the symbol of Scarlett’s past, just as she would always be the embodiment of every mistake he’d ever made. How could anything between them take root in such dry, inhospitable soil? How could they possibly have a future when their past was steeped in pain and regret? How could they ever be a family when their love was so tangled with hate?
Tears prickled at his blurred eyes, but Sirius didn’t look away. Neither did Scarlett. She said nothing, and yet he believed everything.
He wanted to remember her like this—joyful, doing something she loved—not… not how he usually remembered her. Not crying over the things he’d done. He wanted to make her happy, but he knew he could never offer her that kind of pure, cathartic joy.
Sirius lowered his head, breaking eye contact with a nod. Before the song had even ended, he turned on his heel and walked away, stopping just before the door. He looked back over his shoulder one last time, as if trying to justify the unjustifiable, offering himself a thousand excuses to drag her out of there by force.
Scarlett was still staring back at him, the white spotlight glowing in her ocean-coloured eyes. He wanted to open his mouth and beg, ask her to come with him, to tell her she had to… but she wasn’t a prisoner. Dumbledore had asked him to keep an eye on her, not to lock her away in the house that had once belonged to them both.
When the first tear slipped down Scarlett’s cheek, Sirius left.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 35: I want you to love me
Chapter Text
CIII
It was still dark when Sirius awoke with an irritating song playing in his mind. He opened his eyes slowly, inhaling deeply as he was overwhelmed by the sweet scent of vanilla emanating from the beautiful, pale, naked body beside him. His lips curved into a smile as his gaze slid down the contours of Scarlett’s silhouette, lingering on her rosy nipples, skimming her narrow waist, and stopping at the delicate skin between her legs, hidden beneath the white sheets.
Sirius kissed the star tattoo on her right shoulder blade, his fingers trailing softly down her back, outlining the constellation of Canis Major just below her nape, then tracing along the pronounced bones of her spine. Scarlett’s breathing hitched, but she didn’t open her eyes, nor did she move, though Sirius could feel her silken skin shivering under his touch.
He placed a gentle kiss on the curve of her neck, making her curl lazily into the sheets. Sirius hummed the tune in his head, bringing his lips up to the shell of her ear, where he nibbled on her earlobe.
[Music: Fleetwood Mac — Black Magic Woman]
“I got a black magic woman…” he murmured, covering Scarlett’s body with his own, trailing kisses along her slender neck until he latched onto the pulse point with a slow, deliberate suck.
Scarlett squirmed beneath him, her fingers digging into the mattress as a moan slipped from her lips.
“Yes, I got a black magic woman,” he sang against her skin, threading his fingers through her thick, dark hair strewn across the pillow, lifting her head to watch her lips part with her heavy breathing. “Got me so blind I can’t see…”
Sirius pressed his body against hers, grinding his morning erection into the curve of her arse. She swallowed hard, trying to turn to face him, but Sirius stopped her, grabbing her by the hair and sweeping it out of his way, leaving her utterly vulnerable to him.
“But she’s a black magic woman, and she’s trying to make a devil out of me.” His tongue dragged from her shoulder to her nape, making her writhe beneath him.
With a wicked, hungry smile, Sirius turned her face and brushed his lips against hers so faintly that she moaned in frustration, and his cock throbbed with desire.
“Sirius…” Scarlett pleaded, her eyes half-lidded, long lashes casting shadows over the blue of her gaze.
“Shhh…” he hushed her, placing his forefinger on her needy lips before catching her bottom one between his thumb and finger, narrowing his gaze upon her.
“Don’t turn your back on me, baby,” he went on, slowly prying Scarlett’s thighs apart with his knee, positioning himself between her legs and propping himself up on his elbows. “You’re messin’ around with your tricks.”
Sirius rubbed his hard-on along Scarlett’s inner thigh, hearing her gasp as she reflexively pushed her hips against him, making him crane his neck and search for the heat between her legs, pressing his chest to her back. He watched her turn her face to the side, closing her eyes as his cock slid along her soaked slit until it pressed against her clit.
“Don’t turn your back on me, baby,” Sirius repeated, rolling his hips slowly, grinding his length through her wetness, stealing some of her slick for himself as she spread her legs wider, offering herself up to him.
But Sirius was far too entertained by having her like this to give in so soon. He focused on teasing her, gliding languidly between her folds in unhurried strokes, earning a frustrated moan as she lifted her hips, desperate for more friction.
“Stop… torturing me!” Scarlett complained, moaning loudly when he punished her with a sharp smack on her arse, her eyes pleading in the most delicious way. “Please…”
“But I need you so bad, magic woman,” Sirius ignored her, closing his eyes in delight as she grew wetter by the second, making it easier for him to slip back and forth. “I can’t leave you alone…”
Scarlett tried to brace one hand against the mattress for more control, but Sirius was faster—he grabbed her by the nape and caught her wrist, pushing her down into the bed and clicking his tongue as he denied her even a shred of power.
“I need you so bad…” Sirius purred in her ear, hands gliding over her body until they locked onto her hips, pinning her in place as he slid into her with one slow, deliberate thrust.
Arching her back, Scarlett shuddered beneath him while Sirius drowned in the heat, the wetness, and the lingering soreness from the night before. A wicked grin curved across his lips as she pushed her arse back against him, clenching around his cock just as he thrust into her again, losing himself in the warmth of his girlfriend.
Scarlett couldn’t do anything but let out breathless moans under Sirius’s torturously slow rhythm, feeling that familiar knot start to coil deep in her belly. She clutched at the sheets as his cock found a new, delicious angle inside her. He lay his body over hers, kissing her cheek without breaking pace.
“Yes, I need you, darling,” he sighed, biting down gently on her lower lip. “I want you to love me…” His voice cracked into a moan as he picked up the pace, each thrust fuelled with such intensity it felt as though his life depended on it.
Their eyes met, and Sirius brushed his stubbled jaw against Scarlett’s lips before kissing her, catching the shaky breaths that escaped her mouth with his greedy, lust-filled tongue. Scarlett trembled beneath him, her breath coming quicker as she neared the edge. Sirius could feel her tightening around him, so he thrust deeper, stealing the air from her lungs.
“Love… look at me.” He faltered, met by those ocean-blue eyes, then wrapped his arms around her, never losing the rhythm as he deliberately rubbed her clit in time with each thrust, pushing her towards the brink.
He pulled almost all the way out and then buried himself fully again the moment he felt her squeezing him with ecstasy, watching her feet lift and tense as her body convulsed beneath him. Scarlett cried out, and Sirius bit her neck, thrusting one, two, three more times before he came. Scarlett gasped as she felt his cock swell inside her, spilling his release into her tight, quivering walls.
Breathing out every last drop of air in his lungs, Sirius stayed draped over Scarlett, resting his face on her shoulder, his dark hair clinging to his cheeks, breath still shallow as he held her close, his heart pounding against her back.
“I love you,” he murmured, kissing her lips. “So, so, so, so much.”
Scarlett smiled, her gaze full of that feeling that always melted Sirius from the inside out.
“I love you too, you perv,” she sighed, stroking the beard on his chin.
Sirius pulled out slowly, careful not to hurt her, then eased himself back down onto the mattress, drawing her into his arms again with a lazy, indulgent hug, sheltering himself in the arms of the woman who had become his safe haven.
Scarlett gazed into those eyes that held every shade of grey in the world, reflecting her image back to her and dissolving into a thousand unspoken, forbidden wants. She arched an eyebrow as she watched him bury his face between her breasts and let out a languid groan.
“What is it?” she asked, realising Sirius had let his entire weight rest on her. “Are you alright?”
“Mm-hmm,” he grunted, twirling his fingers in the ends of her dark hair. “I want to stay here forever,” he murmured, tracing Scarlett’s collarbone with his fingertips. “Lying in bed, wrapped in your arms. We’d make love forever and… hmm… die of dehydration.”
Scarlett chuckled at the absurdity of his words, gently pushing him aside as she disentangled herself from his arms and legs.
“Why are you getting up?”
“I need to take my potion… and a shower, too,” Scarlett said, glancing down between her legs where Sirius’s release was trickling out. “I don’t want to mess up the sheets.”
“A spell could sort that…” he grumbled.
“You know what day it is.” Scarlett yawned, giving Sirius a playful smack on the arse before heading to the bathroom.
Sirius rolled around in the sheets, dragging a pillow over his face. Today was the day the owls would arrive with the school supply lists for the coming year. So much had happened that the thought of Hogwarts felt like some sweet, distant memory.
Thanatos had pulled a few strings at the Ministry to stall the investigation into Scarlett’s case until it was quietly shelved for lack of evidence. That meant Dimitri got off scot-free as well, but what truly mattered was that the documents she had stolen from the Death Eaters had saved the lives of several members of Dumbledore’s organisation…
An organisation Sirius and James had been adamant about probing Euphemia and Fleamont to join. Of course, the Potters had dodged the subject every time it was brought up, but it was becoming increasingly obvious that they were working alongside Dumbledore in the war.
Sirius drifted into thought, sinking into a light doze and barely registered Scarlett leaving the room after her shower, leaving him alone. Things with her were still somewhat fragile. There was no manual for how to behave with someone who had just lost their family, but he constantly tried to show he was there for her, despite everything.
And that seemed to be enough, for now, even if the flashbacks to the day of the fire could only be kept at bay with a sleeping draught at night and calming potions when it felt like his emotions might explode from his chest. It wasn’t ideal, but he couldn’t risk going to another therapy session just to discover Scarlett had got herself into more trouble.
With James, Remus and Peter’s help, though, things felt a bit easier. More bearable. Sirius could let himself breathe more freely when they were around—occasionally even allowing himself to get pissed just to shove the worries aside.
He took a while to get out of bed. It wasn’t just laziness—he was simply exhausted after everything that had happened. A kind of exhaustion that didn’t seem to go away, no matter how much he slept. He finally stirred when he felt a presence flicker to life in the fireplace, stretching groggily as he stepped out of the bedroom stark naked, scratching his head as he followed the delicious scent of breakfast like he was under a spell.
As soon as he reached the kitchen, a high-pitched scream made him clamp his hands over his ears and squeeze his eyes shut.
“I know I’m fit, Lily, but there’s no need to make such a fuss…” Sirius grumbled, rubbing his eyes as he squinted at the Gryffindor girl and his girlfriend standing in the kitchen.
Scarlett merely raised an eyebrow, shooting him a sharp look.
“Go put something on, Sirius!” she snapped, and he obeyed with a raised-hands surrender.
“Yes, Mistress,” he muttered with a cheeky grin, catching a glimpse of Lily spinning round with her face as red as her hair.
He returned to the kitchen dressed.
“I think I’ve lost my appetite,” Lily complained as Scarlett placed pancakes on her plate, arms crossed. “Do you always strut around starkers?!”
“It’s my house, why wouldn’t I walk around naked?” Sirius replied, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
Lily was still deeply embarrassed, actively avoiding looking directly at him.
“Ugh… why do I still get surprised…” she muttered with a noise of disapproval, helping herself to coffee.
Scarlett simply shook her head, serving pancakes onto Sirius’s plate, earning herself a wink in thanks.
“So, Sirius…” Scarlett tried to break the awkward tension as she sat down at the table. “Lily’s been made Head Girl of Gryffindor.”
Sirius used his wand to catch a pair of toast slices popping out of the toaster, pretending to be busy spreading jam as he considered what to say.
“Congratulations… I suppose,” he offered her a soft smile, which made Lily relax. “Why am I not surprised?”
“Don’t think I’ll go easy on you and James just because we’re friends now…” Lily warned in that bossy tone Sirius loathed. “Besides, with Remus as the other Head, I’m sure he’ll already be covering for all your nonsense…”
“Are you happy?” Scarlett cut in, steering the subject elsewhere with a calm expression. Sirius tried to read her, and was quietly relieved to notice she didn’t seem as melancholic as she had on other days.
“Of course I’m happy, I worked hard for that badge!” Lily said, placing a hand over her chest dramatically, as if insulted.
“Little Miss Perfect earned it,” Sirius goaded, his smile taking on a mischievous edge.
“Fuck off, Black,” Lily scoffed, flipping him the middle finger.
“What? That was a compliment!”
“Sirius… leave Lils alone,” Scarlett huffed a soft laugh, making Sirius lose himself in the curve of those oh-so-inviting lips.
“Our letters arrived, by the way. Nothing special for us, unlike little Miss Perfect…” She picked up the red and gold envelope, which Lily promptly snatched from her hands.
“Didn’t know the Head Girl letter was different…” Sirius narrowed his eyes, hiding the trace of arrogance in his voice.
“Neither did I. I’m going to frame it at home,” Lily joked, though Sirius was fairly certain she actually would.
Once they’d finished breakfast, Sirius took care of the dishes while Lily and Scarlett chatted in the sitting room. After charming the sponge and tap to handle the cleaning, he stared out the kitchen window, watching a group of Muggle children playing some sport he didn’t recognise.
He leaned against the marble counter, smiling along with the sound of their laughter, imagining himself years from now with Scarlett, two or three kids, Sunday lunches at James and Lily’s place — because at some point, Lily would realise James was the love of her life, they’d get married, and have two or three kids of their own — and the Potters and the Blacks would be the best of friends.
But the smile faded with the daydream as he was hit with the harsh truth that none of it would ever be real while the war still raged. He made his way into the sitting room, brushing off the darker thoughts as he flopped onto the sofa and rested his head in Scarlett’s lap, silently demanding head-strokes. He melted into the way her fingers moved through his hair, her touch spreading a delicious softness through his body, her vanilla scent dragging him into the abyss of belonging.
It felt like Scarlett’s lap had been made for him to lie on. Like her fingers had been designed to thread through his hair, like the space between her legs had been crafted to hold him with the same intensity that could bring him to bliss.
His peaceful state didn’t last long.
Sirius’s head snapped up abruptly at the sudden shift in the Floo network. Scarlett and Lily’s conversation came to an abrupt halt as Remus stepped out of the fireplace, brows furrowed and nostrils flared.
“I wasn’t made Head Boy—just a prefect,” he announced, shrugging as he cast a searching glance at Sirius. “Probably because of what happened that night at the Shrieking Shack…” The brown of his eyes flashed gold at the mention, making Sirius lift a brow.
“What happened at the Shrieking Shack?” Lily looked between Remus and Sirius with curious concern.
“And how is that my fault?!” Sirius snapped, his nose wrinkling at the implication as he leaned on the backrest of the sofa.
“If Remus isn’t Head Boy, then who…”
The green flames roared to life, silencing Scarlett as James stepped out with a triumphant grin and a red and gold letter clutched in his hand.
“Guess who’s been made Head Boy of Gryffindor?!” he shouted, clearly elated by the news.
The anger threatening to rise in Sirius’s chest evaporated in a fit of hysterical laughter, fuelled by Scarlett’s euphoric reaction as she covered her face in disbelief — James and Lily were going to be Head Boy and Head Girl.
“What? You?” Lily shot up from her chair, voice shrill with disbelief. “What in Merlin’s name was McGonagall thinking when she picked you?!”
James, too thrilled to care, especially after seeing Lily holding a letter identical to his, dashed over and launched himself onto Sirius and Scarlett with an exuberant hug. Remus cracked a smile too, despite the clear pang of frustration. Lily huffed, snatching James’s letter and scanning it with a sceptical glare.
“What’s so bloody funny?” she muttered, glancing at Remus.
“Head students get their own shared dormitory…” he explained, scratching the scar on his chin.
Lily’s face twisted into horror. She turned to James, who looked so happy he hadn’t yet realised the full implications of the situation. The two of them, alone, in a private dormitory?! She dropped his letter like it was cursed, already envisioning the nightmare of having James Potter as her roommate.
“No!” she declared, clutching her chest. “No way, not happening, absolutely not!”
“Oh, come off it, Lily. Everyone here knows you fancy him…” Sirius teased, locking James in a playful headlock. “My boy Prongs is irresistible…”
Lily shot Sirius a look of such pure disgust it looked like she might be sick. Scarlett shook her head and slipped away from the boys, reaching her friend and giving her some light, encouraging pats on the shoulder.
“Just warning you in advance — he snores. Loud. So loud you’ll think you’re sleeping next to a bloody tractor.” Scarlett’s comment earned a chorus of laughter.
Remus snorted and rolled his eyes.
“It’s like a bloody orchestra of tractors when he and Wormtail fall asleep. No one survives it.”
“If it gets too bad, just shove a sock down his throat — works like a charm. I used to do that first year,” Sirius added, as if it were perfectly reasonable.
James flopped dramatically on the sofa before getting to his feet, looking thoroughly scandalised.
“Oi! I can hear everything!” he protested, shoving his glasses back up his nose.
“And you’re meant to!” Sirius mussed his brown hair, making James grin.
“I still can’t believe we’re going to share a dorm…” James’s grin widened further, which only made Lily grimace with a face full of revulsion. “My dreams are finally coming true…”
“Dream? More like a bloody nightmare!” Lily snapped, placing her hands on her hips in pure irritation. “Let me make one thing clear, James — if you try any of that marriage proposal nonsense like you did in fourth year, I’ll hex you so bad you’ll be begging to give up the badge!”
James, who had been floating somewhere near the clouds with excitement, sobered instantly at the threat, looking at her with such wary apprehension that Lily almost felt bad for being so condescending.
Sirius opened his mouth, ready to drop another scathing remark, but paused as another presence sparked in the Floo. Pandora Malfoy and Xenophilius Lovegood appeared in the emerald flames, and Sirius narrowed his eyes slightly as the pair’s platinum hair caught the sunlight with an almost celestial gleam.
“What’s so funny?” Pandora asked, hand in hand with her boyfriend.
“James and Lily were made Head Boy and Head Girl of Gryffindor…” Scarlett explained, greeting her friend with a nod.
“Potter… Head Boy?! McGonagall’s lost her mind, clearly,” Pandora said with a frown, her pale eyes turning to James. “My condolences, Lily.”
“Why condolences? I’m like… one of the top students at Hogwarts…” James began, puffing his chest slightly.
He didn’t even get to finish the sentence before Scarlett, Lily, Remus, Pandora and Xenophilius burst into laughter. James fell silent, crossing his arms and pursing his lips at the sound of their collective mockery. Sirius slung an arm around his shoulders and knocked him down onto the sofa.
“Don’t let it get to you, Prongs — they’re just jealous ‘cause you and I are Minnie’s favourite students…”
“I reckon next time you call Professor McGonagall Minnie, she’s going to transfigure you into a jar of pickles,” Lily remarked flatly.
“Or a dog,” Pandora added nonchalantly, drawing Sirius’s curious gaze.
“Is everyone here, then?!” Scarlett didn’t give him a chance to respond, steering the conversation swiftly away.
“Yes, time to go shopping,” Sirius said, rubbing his hands together like he was about to get up to no good.
.
.
.
Diagon Alley was bustling with life at that time of year. It was the end of summer, which meant most witches and wizards were there to stock up on supplies before the school year began. Unlike most of his friends, Sirius still had a fair stash of Galleons left over after buying the house, so he and Scarlett were waiting on the marble steps of Gringotts after meeting Peter in the enormous queue at Flourish and Blotts.
The sea of people moved endlessly while Thanatos and Dixon kept a short distance, but their watchful eyes never strayed from the pair. Sirius had grown used to the silent presence of his girlfriend’s uncle, but Scarlett, on the other hand, seemed visibly irritated by the way people stared at her. Sirius silently thanked the calming potion he’d taken before leaving the house — he was certain he’d have been a bundle of nerves amidst so many people otherwise.
Trying to shield Scarlett from the unwanted attention, Sirius wrapped his arms around her, pulling her close. She rested her head against his chest and there they stayed, feeling the warm breeze on their faces and listening to the murmur of conversations all around them. Just one still point in a constantly shifting crowd, caught in their own rose-tinted world.
Sirius trailed his fingers along the bridge of Scarlett’s nose, following the freckles up to her forehead, then down her brows and along her cheeks, eliciting a gentle smile that sent a flutter through his stomach.
“Did you know I love you?” he whispered in her ear, watching with delight as her pale cheeks flushed with colour.
“Just found out,” she replied wryly, nestling into his neck. “I think I love you too.”
“Think?” Sirius grinned, pressing a kiss to her forehead.
“Yeah, maybe… but I’m not completely sure yet.”
Sirius growled playfully, and Scarlett laughed again — a laugh he felt vibrate straight into his core. He pulled her even tighter against him, trying to hold the moment in place, afraid it would slip through his fingers. The breeze played with her dark hair, parting it just enough for the sunlight to dance across her adorably flushed face. Her plush lips slowly relaxed, and the look she gave him was pure, unfiltered devotion. Sirius smiled like a fool, completely entranced by this woman who made his heart pound and quieted every thought in his head.
Unfortunately, the moment came to an end when James, Lily, Remus, Peter, Pandora and Xenophilius returned with their coin bags filled with Galleons. Sirius kept Scarlett at his side the entire time they wandered in and out of shops, as though afraid someone might snatch her away at any moment. They chose their books, part of their supplies, and school uniforms too.
When they stopped by the Quidditch supplies shop, Scarlett lingered for quite some time in front of the new Slytherin team cloak, her gaze fixed on it, utterly lost in thought.
“What is it?” Sirius asked softly, returning a pair of shoulder pads to the display stand.
Scarlett looked at him for only a second, her blue irises sparking before she turned away, jaw tightening as she swallowed hard.
“It’s just…” she began, her voice raspy and strained. “I don’t… I don’t know if I’m going to stay on the Quidditch team.”
Sirius raised an eyebrow, resting his elbow against one of the racks as he stepped closer.
“What do you mean?”
She blinked rapidly, avoiding his eyes as she searched for the right words.
“I’m not deaf, Sirius. I know what people are saying about the fire… about the Death Eaters. How can I play on a team full of…” Her bottom lip trembled, and Sirius placed a hand on her shoulder, trying to offer her some strength. “Of Death Eaters — and future Death Eaters?!”
“You don’t know that,” Sirius said with a quiet sigh, but Scarlett let out a bitter snort.
“Don’t I?! Selwyn is one, even if he’s graduated. Rosier and Crouch… Nott… Regulus… how can I stand on the pitch next to people who belong — or will belong — to the cult that murdered my entire family?!”
Sirius had no argument against that. First, because he couldn’t bring himself to believe his brother might truly be one of them. Second… Scarlett loved Quidditch. He thought of all the times he’d seen her beaming on her broom during matches, even when they were rivals — and the thought of never seeing her like that again stabbed at his heart.
“We could talk to Dumbledore… he might sort something out,” Sirius offered. “What do you think?”
Scarlett shook her head, her face so drawn and dry that it made the dark circles beneath her eyes even more pronounced. It hadn’t been an easy time for either of them, but they cared for one another with such respect and devotion that it made the weight a little easier to carry.
“Doesn’t matter,” she whispered.
Even with all their mutual support, Sirius knew when Scarlett needed space — so he didn’t push the matter. After they left the shop with their arms full of bags and met back up with Pandora and Xenophilius, Sirius noticed Scarlett staring across the street at a particular building.
The headquarters of the Daily Prophet, with the day’s edition displayed in the window. The headline read: DEATH EATERS KILL FIFTEEN IN SURREY. But that wasn’t what caught his attention.
Near the bottom of the front page was a photo of Scarlett, under the line: Miss Gaunt’s Case Closed Due to Lack of Evidence.
Before Sirius could open his mouth to distract her, Xenophilius slipped his hands into his pockets and stepped up beside her, drawing her attention with a quiet nod. Sirius didn’t know him very well, but watched in silence as the boy — with his cloud-white hair and peculiar, dreamy aura — calmly pulled a photograph from his pocket to change the subject.
“Is it true there are Yetis hiding in the Swiss Alps?!” Xenophilius asked, eyes wide with excitement. “A friend of my dad’s took this photo over the summer and swore up and down it was a Yeti…”
Scarlett gave a bashful smile as she took the photo from his hand, lifting it up for a better look.
“Doesn’t look like a Yeti… more like a…” She pressed her lips together. “Troll.”
“I thought the same thing!” Xenophilius crossed his arms and stepped aside so he wouldn’t block the pavement. “Pan told me you lived there… is it true there are loads of Basilisks in Switzerland?”
“Yes. Even though breeding them is banned, there are loads hiding in remote forests near the lakes and mountains… Even with the Ministry isolating certain areas, it wasn’t unusual for some wizard to get petrified — or killed — every year…”
“Wow… that’s… wow.” He lifted his eyebrows, clearly amazed.
Sirius licked his lips as he noticed Pandora leaning casually against the shop window beside him, a faint smile dancing on her porcelain features. She met his gaze and set her bags down.
“How do you know?” he asked, after a long, pensive pause.
“Know what?” Pandora feigned ignorance, watching as James offered Lily a cone of clotted cream and berry ice cream. Remus and Peter were chatting animatedly across the street about the outcome of the last Quidditch match. “Your brother told me,” she admitted at last.
“Of course he did,” Sirius muttered, sounding nonchalant, though there was a faint note of displeasure in his voice. “Regulus is a snitch.”
Pandora offered a distracted smile, running her fingers through her snowy white hair as she fell into thought.
“Who’d have guessed that mangy mutt from Hogsmeade was actually you…”
Sirius cut her off with an exaggerated groan, placing a hand dramatically on his chest.
“First of all… I do not have fleas. Secondly, you’re welcome for protecting you and Scarlett from Rosier and Crouch. And from my idiot brother, too.”
Pandora raised a single eyebrow.
“Protect me? As I recall, your brother and his pals were three prats to me while you just stood there barking, and Scarlett was far too dazed to be much use.”
“What did you want me to do?!” Sirius snapped, his voice rising a few notches, which immediately softened Pandora’s expression.
“You could have bitten Rosier’s neck off, torn off Crouch’s leg…” she began listing calmly. “Shoved your brother into the lake behind Hogsmeade.”
Sirius feigned shock at the suggestions, giving her a slow once-over.
“Being vengeful and cruel is definitely a Slytherin prerequisite…”
“When’s Scarlett ever been vengeful and cruel to you?” Pandora countered, tapping a finger to her chin like she was giving it serious thought.
“Every bloody day.” Sirius whispered, lifting the collar of his black shirt to reveal a purpling bruise on his neck. “See this? A cry for help. She assaulted me… with her lips. Then she sat on me. Violently.”
“Sweet Merlin, Sirius, stop, I get it!” Pandora swatted his words away with a wave of her hand. “You’re looking after each other, right?! I don’t want to… be an aunt… too soon!”
Sirius burst out laughing at Pandora’s discomfort, resting his head against the shop window.
“Of course we are,” he said, shrugging with mock seriousness. “But it’s not like it’d be the end of the world if Scarlett were pregnant.” He jiggled his shoulders and covered his mouth with his hand as if sharing a juicy secret with Pandora.
“She’s just lost her family — I don’t think she’s ready for that,” Pandora replied, eyes wide in alarm.
“I know, I’m only joking…” Sirius eased the tension beginning to flicker in her pale gaze. “We haven’t even finished school yet… but… um… that actually reminds me — I need your help with something.”
Pandora turned her head towards Scarlett and Xenophilius, who had stopped in front of the Magical Menagerie and were chatting about the creatures in the window.
“You’re going to propose, aren’t you?” she said, raising an eyebrow, her sharp eyes catching him off guard.
“Of course she told you.” Sirius sighed, rubbing the back of his neck, looking slightly sheepish. “Can you help me figure out… help me choose her ring?”
“I’ll help,” Pandora agreed so breezily that Sirius exhaled all at once, shoulders relaxing.
“Want to rope in Evans too for this mission?”
“I will — as soon as James stops clinging to her. He’s over the moon about sharing a dormitory with her…”
“Poor Lily…” Pandora shook her head with a sigh of mock disapproval. “Who would’ve thought she’d end up falling for Potter after all?”
“She’s the girl of his dreams, let the lad enjoy it…” Sirius nudged Pandora with his shoulder. “At least he doesn’t just sit there quietly while his mates make nasty remarks…”
“What are you talking about?” Pandora’s brows furrowed.
“My brother.”
“Ah.” Pandora’s expression was tinged with a wistful sadness. “He made his choice.” She glanced sideways at Sirius. “And I made mine.”
“I really thought we’d be in-laws one day,” Sirius teased, earning an elbow to the ribs from Pandora. “But Reg, he…”
He didn’t finish the sentence. The pained look he gave her before shutting his eyes and rubbing his eyebrow said it all. In quiet understanding, she squeezed his arm. He lowered his gaze, then forced a smile back onto his lips.
“Want to see something funny?” he asked, pushing away from the window.
“What?”
Sirius picked up his bags and strolled casually toward Scarlett, saying something low that made her glance to the side. Then he dropped to one knee in front of her.
Scarlett’s gentle expression melted into shock in a matter of seconds — she slapped both hands over her mouth. Around them, James, Lily, Peter and Remus craned their necks to see what was happening, while Xenophilius widened his eyes and looked over his shoulder at Pandora, completely unsure of what to do.
“Sirius, what are you doing?!” Scarlett demanded, her hands still clamped over her reddening face.
Sirius looked up at her, maintaining a completely serious expression.
“Tying my bootlace,” he replied casually, knotting the lace on his combat boot with agonising slowness.
Scarlett’s face flushed crimson with mortification. She raised her hand, and Sirius instinctively shielded himself with his forearm, laughing as their friends erupted into snickers and giggles.
“You idiot!” she shouted, aiming another playful slap his way. “I can’t believe you—!”
Scarlett was cut off when Sirius jumped to his feet and wrapped her in a laughing hug, tickling her mercilessly. She struggled, half-heartedly trying to fend him off, her faux anger dissolving into helpless laughter — and that sound alone sent a warm, buoyant bloom through Sirius’s chest. He kissed her softly.
“What?” he teased. “Did you really think I’d be that cheesy and propose in the middle of Diagon Alley?!”
“Don’t talk to me!” Scarlett huffed, trying to sound cross — but the smile tugging at her lips betrayed her entirely.
Genuine happiness swelled within her so suddenly it made her dizzy. For the first time in what felt like forever, the grief and tension melted from her shoulders, giving her space to breathe — without guilt, without misery, without the crushing weight. It was as if the burden on her chest had been lifted and shared by her friends, allowing her one frivolous, golden moment of peace in the middle of the street.
She leaned in and brushed her nose against Sirius’s, sinking into the man who would always be her ruin.
“So, you wanted to be proposed to in Diagon Alley?” Sirius asked, lips curling into that wicked grin, dimples flashing devilishly. Scarlett stroked the scruff along his jaw, her freckles glowing against the blush still colouring her cheeks.
“No, I just…” she drew in a shaky breath, still rattled by how Sirius could make her feel so vulnerable with so many eyes around. “You startled me, that’s all.”
“Startled you? So you don’t want to marry me?!” Sirius pulled a pout, furrowing his brow in mock despair.
“Are you asking me?” Scarlett played along, voice hushed as his breath grazed her chin.
“Depends. Would you say yes?” Sirius swallowed thickly, his heart galloping inside his chest.
Scarlett studied him, her eyes full of a hunger and hesitation he recognised all too well. He read every flicker of her emotion — the way her brows pinched ever so slightly, the purse of her lips, her delicate fingers combing through his dark hair before tucking a lock behind his ear.
“Is this a proposal?” she pressed, her blush deepening, a flicker of hesitation crossing his own expression.
Sirius loosened his hold slightly and shook his head, though his hands remained firm on her waist.
“Not yet,” he said playfully, stealing another kiss as she rolled her eyes and sighed.
Scarlett was so overwhelmed her whole body trembled at the weight of Sirius’s intent. Her heart thudded so loudly she feared he might hear it.
“Leaky Cauldron?!” James suddenly shoved his head between them, breaking the moment.
“Leaky Cauldron,” Sirius replied without taking his eyes off Scarlett, the stupid, smitten smile still stuck to his face.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 36: Nothing hurts more than love
Chapter Text
CIV
The memories of entering the Leaky Cauldron with the Potters and Sirius the previous year flooded Scarlett’s mind, intoxicating her with a sensation so sublime she barely noticed the place was packed with people.
Diagon Alley was already fairly crowded, but it seemed there was some sort of event going on in the pub that no one had realised until then. On a makeshift stage, a tall man with a distinguished moustache and a pointed wizard’s hat was answering questions from a swarm of reporters.
"Excuse me, sirs…" A blonde woman with a disingenuous expression blocked the group’s path. "I’m afraid there are no available tables at the Cauldron today… I suggest you come back at another time."
Thanatos stepped forward, running a hand through his fair hair as he offered his most charming smile.
"Wasn’t the Minister for Magic’s conference supposed to be in the Ministry Atrium?!" he asked, giving a wave to a few fellow Aurors scattered around the place.
"It was, initially, but plans changed. The Minister wants to get closer to the public… to ensure them he’s doing all he can to contain the threat of You-Know-Who."
Scarlett was so lost in her own thoughts she stood on tiptoe to get a look at the Minister for Magic. Harold Minchum was delivering a speech about his measures to increase security at Azkaban, while a man circled around him snapping photos with a massive camera that let out puffs of purple smoke with every blinding flash.
"We could go to the ice cream parlour…" James nearly shouted his suggestion so his voice could rise above the hubbub inside the pub.
"I already had ice cream!" Lily muttered, annoyed that they were clogging the entrance.
"I haven’t." Sirius pulled Scarlett closer as a couple asked to pass.
"Neither have we," Pandora said with a shrug, folding her arms.
"Then let’s head to the parlour," said Dixon, the Auror accompanying Thanatos in escorting Scarlett, stepping a pace towards the exit.
The group began moving out. Scarlett, however, was still utterly absorbed, listening intently as the Minister answered a question about placing more Dementors in Azkaban. Her boyfriend hooked an arm around her to guide her along, but she didn’t budge—causing Sirius to stumble into Nate, who then collided with the blonde woman, resulting in a minor commotion in the midst of the crowd.
"Sorry!" Scarlett apologised to the woman, helping her regain her balance. She noticed a gleaming badge on the woman’s chest but didn’t have time to make out what it was, as the audience at the conference had suddenly turned their attention to her.
"Are you Scarlett Gaunt?!" the woman asked, just as a staggering silence swept across the pub.
Scarlett flinched under the weight of the overwhelming attention. She loathed the spotlight—not just the stares, but the way people looked at her made her insides twist, as though she were some sort of circus animal. Instinctively, she reached behind her for Sirius’s hand and gripped it tightly. The air around her felt strangely stifling.
"Oh, Miss Gaunt, what a marvellous surprise to have you here!" the Minister gestured in her direction, a calculated smile stretching across his greying moustache. "Why don’t you come up here for a few photos?"
Scarlett immediately looked to Sirius, eyes wide. The blonde woman gave an awkward smile as she motioned for Scarlett to go ahead, and Thanatos pressed his lips together in disapproval but said nothing. Scarlett hesitated, whispers blooming in the crowd as people began to part and make space. She took a step forward, her gaze locked with Sirius’s, who looked just as lost.
Thanatos touched her shoulder, drawing her attention. Scarlett felt her breath catch in her throat.
"Go on," he instructed, nodding toward the snaking path that led up to the makeshift stage. "I’ll come with you."
" Sirius is coming with me." Scarlett pulled her boyfriend along, taking a deep breath as they walked into the buzzing swarm of onlookers, her palms slick with sweat.
They exchanged another glance as the Minister stepped aside slightly to make room for her to stand. Scarlett let go of Sirius and climbed up, feeling foolish in her Muggle clothes among a sea of witches and wizards. Harold Minchum wore a long satin-grey robe, a lacy cravat, and a cameo brooch bearing the Ministry’s golden insignia.
"Smile, dear," he said, flashing his immaculate teeth.
Scarlett couldn’t smile—especially not when the crowd erupted into applause and the photographer snapped so many photos her eyes began to sting. Her face probably looked more like a grimace than anything else. She waved away some of the smoke with her hand, sweat prickling over her entire body in a heat that had nothing to do with temperature.
"Miss Gaunt, is it true the incident that took your family’s life was caused by your younger brother?!" A woman’s voice rang out—everywhere and nowhere at once. Scarlett couldn’t quite see through the haze, rubbing her eyes with her knuckles.
"What?" she whispered, though her voice came out oddly loud due to the amplification charm on the stage.
"We’re not here to ask questions about Miss Gaunt’s private life," the Minister cut through the rising murmur.
"Then why did you call her up here?!" another reporter demanded, met with sounds of agreement from the crowd.
"The Gaunts served the Ministry of Magic with great courage, and I’m certain Miss Gaunt will follow in her parents’ footsteps—won’t you, my dear?"
Though the question had been rhetorical, Scarlett couldn’t hear anything beyond the pandemonium of her own breath, the dizzying rush of blood coursing through her body, and the sweat soaking her blouse, dampening the exposed skin of her shoulders.
She searched for Sirius among the sea of hostile faces, but it was difficult with her vision still blurred from the flash. Each blink left her momentarily blind.
"I’d like to take this moment to announce the Ministry’s new programme, in which the brightest students of Hogwarts will be eligible to join our Auror training course without needing to pass the preliminary exams—only the final assessments. The programme has been designed to ensure the continued safety of the wizarding world…"
Scarlett wiped her forehead with the back of her hand, wondering what she was even doing there, while the photographer kept firing off shot after shot. She finally managed to breathe properly when she spotted Sirius just beneath the stage, a single step below her. She instinctively reached out his hand, and he took hers firmly, as if trying to pass on some sliver of Gryffindor courage to her.
"Is it true you and Black are getting married?!" a reporter near Sirius shouted, completely ignoring the Minister’s speech.
Another flash went off, and Scarlett took a step back, turning towards Minister Minchum.
"I need to… I-I need to go," she stammered, praying no one had heard her words. The Minister gave her a courteous smile and nodded, shaking her hand. One more photo.
"Of course, dear, of course! I’ll be in touch with you soon to sort out the details of your enrolment…"
Scarlett heard no more. She tightened her grip on Sirius’s hand, and that alone was enough for him to guide her away from the stage as a flood of questions crashed down upon them from the crowd.
"Was it your brother or Death Eaters?"
"How did you survive?"
"Are you a Death Eater?"
"Is You-Know-Who really your cousin?"
"Sir, I suggest you step back," Dixon warned a particularly persistent journalist.
"Tom, we need a private room!" Thanatos bellowed.
Oblivious to the chaos unfolding around her, Scarlett let herself be carried by the tide that was Sirius Black—who held her tightly and practically lifted her off the ground when her legs refused to move up the stairs.
She heard the discordant slam of a door closing, then Sirius placed her on a sofa, and someone handed her a cup of tea—perhaps not in that order. Scarlett couldn’t be sure of much at that moment. All she knew was that she burnt her tongue on the tea, and Remus, Peter, and James were in the corner of the room deep in animated discussion. Lily, Pandora, and Xenophilius were speaking to her, but their words made no sense—like they were speaking an entirely different language.
"Where’s Sirius?" she heard herself ask, pressing her fingers to her lips as the swelling of her tongue registered.
"He’s on his way," said either Lily or Pandora—Scarlett couldn’t tell which.
There was something else she needed to say, but the thought slipped away. She was far too busy trying to untangle the knot that had formed in her stomach, to ease the tightness winding itself around her throat.
She handed her tea to Xenophilius and hugged her knees to her chest, resting her chin atop them as she slowly began to feel tethered to reality again. The murmured conversation between James, Peter and Remus started to make sense; Pandora’s worried glance brought her to attention, and Lily’s gentle smile distracted her.
But none of them had the effect Sirius did: the moment he entered the room and their eyes met, the world started spinning properly again, as though absolutely nothing had happened. Scarlett released her legs and collapsed into the man named after a star as he sat beside her on the sofa, seeking the security she so desperately lacked.
Sirius wrapped his arms around her tightly, silencing all the indecipherable voices in her mind like he’d blown out a hundred candles at once, focusing her entirely on the sound of his rebellious heart, grounding her in the warm, narcotic sensation that spread through her veins and calmed her pulse.
Just as she closed her eyes, she startled at the sound of Thanatos’s gravelly voice echoing against the walls:
"I can’t believe he used you for… propaganda!" he raged, scratching his nose furiously. "And then announced to everyone that you’re joining that bloody stupid programme…"
"Why would the Minister do something like that?!" Xenophilius sounded as baffled as the rest of them.
"Isn’t it obvious?!" Lily’s brows furrowed with a sobering seriousness. "He wants Scar’s support."
Scarlett drew in a deep breath of Sirius’s sweet scent, using it to tame the feelings lashing at her chest. She softened the fear until it resembled comfort, folded the insecurity until it looked like calm, and shattered the grief into so many pieces it would take time to pull itself back together—leaving her unreachable, just for now.
"Why would he want my support?" she muttered, feeling Sirius’s tattooed fingers weave gently through her hair.
Thanatos stepped closer with a measured movement, hands on his hips and posture guarded.
"Because of your Signet," he said, drawing his wand from his pocket. "I need to speak to you in private, Scarlett." The request sounded far more like an order.
"That’s not happening," Sirius hissed darkly, staring Nate down with cold defiance.
"Black… this is serious."
"I know," he shot back with determined intensity. "I’m not leaving her alone with you, Gaunt."
Scarlett straightened up, shaking her head as she tried to summon the courage that so often slipped through her fingers. She fought to hold her pieces together, to ease the weight Sirius carried on her behalf. He needed care too, and she knew this conversation would be draining—so she tilted her chin, filled her lungs, cleared her throat, and gently disentangled herself from his embrace.
"It’s all right," she said, doing her utmost to sound resolute. "It’s okay, love." She gave a small smile, stroking his cheek. "We… we’ve needed to have this conversation since…" Her voice cracked, but she pressed on. "Since what happened."
Sirius pressed his lips together, the sharp lines of his face stiffening with worry. He looked at Nate—his silver stare hardening, forged into something as sharp as steel. But then his starlit eyes met Scarlett’s, and the steel melted into stardust. His pupils widened, and his mouth softened.
"Are you sure?" he murmured, gripping her hand tightly.
"I am." Scarlett forced a smile, turning the rings on Sirius’s fingers before letting go. "It’s all right."
"Really?" He didn’t move, narrowing his eyes. Scarlett held his gaze with equal intent.
"Really." She spoke with such gentleness that Sirius had no choice but to yield.
He rose, kissed the back of her hand and then her lips, cast one last warning look at Thanatos, and left them alone.
Niece and uncle stared at one another for what felt like an eternity—each waiting for the other to speak. When it became clear Scarlett had no intention of voicing what was in her mind, Thanatos dragged a chair forward and sat down opposite her, crossing his legs as he weighed his words.
"This won’t go in the official report, but… it could only have been the Death Eaters." He wetted his lips, eyes fixed on Scarlett, whose gaze remained locked on a stain on the sofa. "It was someone who had access to your house, but everyone you listed had an alibi. Which makes me think it was someone you didn’t know had already been there."
"What do you mean, alibis—" Scarlett’s brow furrowed, and then she raised one of them. "You investigated my friends?!"
"Well, yes. Anyone’s a suspect." Thanatos clicked his fingers, as if that explained it. It was so easy to speak about work with his colleagues or to strangers. Doing so with Scarlett, though, was a torment—it made him feel exposed. Perhaps it was the way she looked at him, her pupils drenched in a darkness he’d never seen before. "But we checked… Potter was at home… Lupin too… Pettigrew was in France…"
Scarlett ground her teeth as she released a slow, deliberate breath, fighting against the devastating quake that threatened to rip her balance away.
"But that’s not the point," Thanatos continued, clearing his throat. He reached out to take her hand, but she tucked it tightly between her knees, shoulders curling inward. "Why are you treating me like this?"
Scarlett turned her gaze on him. Just her eyes—no other muscle moved—and it was as though she’d drifted miles away in an instant. The blue of her irises hardened to ice; her pupils grew so dark and fathomless that Nate felt a chill in his gut.
"Why did you go after your ex-boyfriend?" he pressed, leaning closer, unshaken by her reaction. "Who taught you the Cruciatus Curse?"
Scarlett swallowed hard, the tension in her body electrifying every inch of her. Her jaw was clenched so tightly it made her neck ache. She licked her lips and drew in air through her mouth, eyes closed.
"Terry," she admitted in a whisper.
Thanatos exhaled sharply through his teeth.
"Aether?!" His voice rose. "When?"
"Ch-Christmas… '74…" Scarlett stammered, locking her chest to stave off the sob. Suddenly, she felt like a little girl caught doing something terribly wrong.
"What else?" Thanatos demanded, staring at her with burning intensity. "What else did he teach you, Scarlett?"
"He taught me all… all the Unforgivables." She confessed, squeezing her eyes shut as pressure built behind her temples.
"Of course he did…" he muttered, placing a hand on Scarlett’s knee. "Why did you use an Unforgivable on Rustov? I know something happened last year at Durmstrang, and I know it had to do with your ex. Why were you expelled?"
Scarlett’s hands fumbled across the sofa, seeking Sirius. She shouldn't have sent him away. She inhaled slowly, digging her nails into the worn leather of the seat. She thought about lying—saying it had been a prank gone wrong, like the ones Sirius and James used to pull, or that she’d accidentally hurt Dimitri with ancestral magic. But in the end, her lips trembled and her eyes began to glisten.
"I… I wanted to hurt him," Scarlett croaked, tucking a few wild strands of hair behind her ear. "He… forced me…"
Come back.
Dimitri’s voice echoed, distant yet vivid enough to ignite the memory.
The words lodged in her throat, and her whole body stiffened, hand still gripping the cold doorknob in her mind. The golden corridor light thinned as she closed the door, drowning in shadow when the sliver of light vanished.
"He raped you?!" Nate barely made a sound—but the question hit like thunder.
Scarlett didn’t know if oral sex was considered rape, so instead, she told him everything. Her voice had turned stiff. Embarrassed. But she didn’t stop—just like she hadn’t when telling her parents. She recounted even the moment when Dimitri went after Sirius in Knockturn Alley, and when he appeared on the grounds of Hogwarts with Sasha, threatening Remus.
"He… sent me this letter." She gave a weak, bitter smile. How arrogant she’d been. How foolish. "Telling me how to access the arena. So… I went there… took the documents… he threw me in the middle of the stage and… attacked me. Said… he wanted to watch me suffer… I didn’t… I couldn’t see anything beyond… I don’t know, I just wanted… I wanted to make him suffer just as much and…"
She fell silent as Nate pulled her into a hug. Scarlett didn’t move, letting his hands soothe her back, pressing her close to his chest. His chin rested against her forehead. Tears fell into her hair. They stayed like that for a long time, weeping in a silence that had nothing to do with fear or shame. Scarlett, with her head against Nate’s chest, wiped her tears soundlessly. No matter how much she cried, the pain never went away.
Still, she was silently grateful for having taken her melancholy potion that morning. Otherwise, she’d be sobbing uncontrollably by now.
"I’m so sorry, Scarly. I should’ve been there for you, I should’ve—"
"I don’t know if I want to go back to Hogwarts," Scarlett interrupted softly.
Nate pulled a handkerchief from his pocket and handed it to her without letting go.
"No? Why not?"
"It was the Death Eaters, wasn’t it? Half of Slytherin… are Death Eaters… the other half… are just waiting their turn… I can’t… they killed my family, Uncle, they—"
"Hogwarts is safe."
Scarlett gave a snort full of scorn, shaking her head.
"It’s not."
"Of course it is, Dumbledore made sure—"
"Dumbledore turns a blind eye to what happens in that school." Scarlett gripped Nate’s forearm tightly. "Did you know one of the students hit me with a Bludger on purpose during a match and then ambushed me in the locker room and broke my arm?"
"What do you mean ambushed? And on purpose?"
Scarlett told him everything Avery had done—with Mulciber and Snape’s help. Though he was crying, Thanatos kept his face expressionless. But Scarlett knew full well what was running through her uncle’s mind. That urge for revenge was something that blossomed all too easily in the face of injustice—especially against those we love.
"I’ll be teaching Defence Against the Dark Arts this year, Scar, I—"
"It doesn’t matter, Uncle. How can I stay in a place… full of… of people who…" Her voice cracked. "They’re dead, Uncle! Dad… Mum… Orfy… and I couldn’t do anything. I would’ve died too if it weren’t for Sirius, I would’ve—"
"But you didn’t!" Thanatos cut her off. "You’re alive, and I’m certain… certain they would’ve wanted you to keep going and—"
"Keep going?! How am I supposed to do that?! It’s so… it’s so hard… I’m trying… but it’s too hard…"
"I know, Scarly, I know… but… you can’t give up. I will… I promise I’ll look after you too. It’s not fair—"
"I don’t want to go back to Hogwarts," she repeated, her voice choked with sobs. "I don’t want to, I don’t want to, I don’t…"
"Scarlett… look at me." Thanatos wiped away her tears, gripping her by the shoulders. "We need you."
Scarlett blinked several times, rubbing her nose as she tried to make sense of what Nate was saying.
"We?"
"To end this war. To… stop more families from dying…" He faltered, as if unsure how to put it into words. "To carry on your mum’s work."
"What… what are you… what do you mean by that?!" Scarlett pressed her palms to her temples, trying to quell the throbbing pain in her head.
Nate took a deep breath, stepping back and lowering himself into the chair again.
"We need… your ancestral magic. You-Know-Who is searching for artefacts your great-aunt Evie created… we… we need you, Scar."
Scarlett shook her head, firm and frantic.
"I can’t… I can’t…"
"You want to find out who did this to your parents?" That line made her look up at him instantly, her heart hammering. "I’m not… I’m not asking for an answer right now, but… some of those artefacts are housed at Hogwarts, and… Dumbledore would help you."
"How… how would finding those artefacts help—"
"If we win the war, the Death Eaters will talk. I know them, Scarly—only a few are truly loyal. We need you."
Scarlett held his gaze, though inwardly she was slipping far, far away.
"I don’t know… I don’t know if I can, Uncle. I… I’m scared. I don’t want to… I don’t want to lose anyone else. I don’t want to—" She gasped for air, shutting her eyes to relieve the pounding in her skull.
"You won’t lose anyone else." Thanatos said it with such conviction that for a second, Scarlett almost believed him.
"You don’t know that." She rested her face against her forearm.
"I know that if this war keeps going… there’ll be more deaths. And it won’t just be my brother, my sister-in-law, and my nephew I’ll be grieving. We’ve lost too much already, Scar. Far too much."
"I don’t know if I can," Scarlett repeated, her voice breaking.
"Just… think about it. Please?" Nate kissed her forehead, and the gesture sent a wave through her body—a feeling she’d almost forgotten. The acceptance she’d longed for from her family, and now… it no longer seemed to matter.
"I’ll think about it." She stood from the sofa, a strange restlessness surging through her core, pacing back and forth across the room.
"Does Sirius know?" Nate asked, propping his elbow on the back of the chair. "That you don’t want to go back to Hogwarts?"
Scarlett shook her head, picking up the pace, circling the room as if trying to piece together arguments in her mind. She’d been putting it off all week. Everything had been going so well—too well—for her to worry Sirius again. She still blamed herself for the mistake she made in going after Dimitri.
"I’ve no idea what to say," she huffed.
"You need to talk to him," Nate advised with a sigh. "Scarly… when we choose to share our lives with someone… it means sharing everything. And that includes the fears and the doubts. Why are you so reluctant to open up?"
Scarlett pressed her lips together until they formed a thin line, shooting him a sideways glance.
"I don’t want to be a burden," she confessed.
Thanatos visibly wilted, guilt flooding his features.
"I’m sorry. I never should’ve said those things about you." He took hold of Scarlett’s wrist. "You’re not a burden, Scar. You never were. But… your Signet…" He turned her hand over, pulling back the glove that concealed the Ouroboros. "It’s something highly coveted, and it’s going to bring you a lot of trouble." He brushed the mark where the serpent devoured its own tail, and Scarlett instinctively pulled away.
"It’s fine," she sighed, though her voice betrayed her. "I just don’t want to… don’t want to hurt him."
Nate let out a soft smile, rubbing her shoulder as he rose.
"Someone always ends up hurt in the end," he said, kissing her cheek before opening the door.
Sirius, James, Lily, Remus, Peter, Pandora, and Xenophilius were waiting just outside, leaning against the corridor wall. Scarlett froze before crossing the threshold, opened her mouth to speak to Sirius—then realised she had no idea what to say, and closed it again.
It was intimidating, being looked at like that. He was so clearly worried, so achingly attentive, that guilt began carving a twisted path through her chest, turning into a burn in the pit of her stomach.
The moment he took a step towards her, she stepped back—glancing around to avoid the focus of her friends' eyes.
"Needtogototheloo." She said it so quickly that no one understood. Sirius reached out to grab her, but his hand froze mid-air as Scarlett slipped past him like a hurricane, diving through the first door she spotted marked Toilets.
Sirius kept his hand suspended for a second longer, staring at Thanatos, who looked just as stunned as he was. The dread spreading through his chest rooted itself deep.
"What happened? What did you say to her?"
"We talked… about some things," Nate replied, and Sirius’s eyes sparked with fury.
"For fuck’s sake, do you always have to be such a prick?" he hissed, striding quickly towards where Scarlett had gone, the entire group following behind him.
Hissing in frustration, Sirius pressed his forehead to the bathroom door, dragging a hand through his hair as though trying to hold together the cracks in his composure.
"Do you want us to go check if she’s okay?" Lily’s voice pulled him from the chaos of his thoughts. Her green eyes, soft and warm, muffled the panic beginning to crush his chest.
"Please." Sirius turned and leaned against the wall beside the door to let Lily and Pandora slip in.
Scarlett buried her face between her knees, hating herself, hating her cowardice, and hating Sirius—because he had the power to wake every one of her demons with a single look. It was easy to throw up her breakfast when all she could think about was his reaction, as if he’d explode at her words, as if he were still the same boy from the start of their relationship.
But she knew he wasn’t. He wasn’t that short-tempered boy anymore. Which meant he’d do everything he could to reconcile her refusal to return to Hogwarts with his studies. And that would likely drive him mad. Maybe he’d even follow in her footsteps and leave school too.
No. He wouldn’t. They’d already shared dreams, and Sirius wanted to be an Auror.
And her? She wasn’t so sure anymore. Her future felt distant, murky. She didn’t want to think about it. She just wanted to cling to the past. She wanted to go back to the year before, when her parents were still alive and life was rose-tinted.
She heard the bathroom door open, followed by footsteps approaching her stall.
"Scar?" Pandora called gently, fully aware she was behind the door.
A ragged sob escaped her lips. Scarlett covered her mouth with her hand, as if that might stop the scalding wave of emotion rising in her chest.
"Are you okay?" Lily asked, her tone genuinely concerned.
Scarlett swallowed hard, stepping out of the stall without looking at either of them. She rested a hand on the sink to rinse her mouth and splash water on her face. She ignored the red and silver blurs behind her, the hands gently rubbing her back, the subtle smile that curved Pandora’s lips, or the way Lily dabbed her face dry without being asked.
"Did you throw up? It’s the melancholy potion, isn’t it?" Lily asked when Scarlett opened her eyes.
"Yeah… but… I’m fine…" Scarlett blew her nose into a tissue, turning to face the mirror. "The potion’s strong."
"I thought you’d stopped taking it," Pandora said, watching her through the reflection, her pale eyes seeming to read everything Scarlett tried to conceal. "I mean… you’re so much better than… just after everything happened."
Scarlett shook her head.
"If it weren’t for the potion, I wouldn’t even be able to get out of bed."
Lily pursed her lips, gently brushing Scarlett’s dark hair back over her tense shoulders.
"What happened?" she asked with such tenderness that Scarlett felt ashamed for not knowing how to answer.
"Did your uncle say something?" Pandora remained leaning against the wall behind them.
"No, no… it wasn’t that." The corner of Scarlett’s mouth twitched into a faint, forced smile. "I just… I don’t know if I want to go back to Hogwarts." She finally spoke the truth, then turned her gaze back to the sink drain.
"Because of what happened?" Lily barely reacted, her fingers stroking Scarlett’s hair in a maternal gesture. Scarlett nodded.
"It was the Death Eaters, Lils, and…" She stopped when the weight in her chest became too heavy. "I don’t know if I can…"
"A good portion of your year in Slytherin’s probably already become Death Eaters…" Pandora said flatly. "Were they the ones who killed your family?"
Scarlett nodded with difficulty, her neck stiff as stone. Lily inhaled sharply, placing a hand over her mouth at the revelation.
"I don’t know what to do," Scarlett admitted, squeezing her eyes shut to keep the tears at bay. "I don’t know what to say."
"They’d never do anything to you… not at Hogwarts," Pandora tried to reassure her. "And you’ve got me in Slytherin… and Regulus…"
Scarlett’s lips twisted in displeasure. She took a few steps back, leaned against the same wall as Pandora, then slid down until she was sitting on the floor, burying her face in her hands.
"Regulus…" she sighed, clearly irritated. "You knew it was him stealing your stuff, didn’t you?!"
Pandora sat beside her, followed by Lily, before looking down at the floor and shaking her head.
"What do you mean, stealing my stuff?"
"When Scar got sorted into Slytherin…" Pan began explaining, "I noticed she was really close with the Marauders and… um… I asked her to tell them to stop nicking my ties. Regulus told me it was them. Then he said it was a magical creature and you backed him up…" She pointed at Scarlett with a tone that was half accusing, half teasing.
"I just… wanted you two to be friends," Scarlett said as Pandora laid her head on her shoulder. "I thought… I thought he might be different."
"Why did you think that?" Lily asked, resting her head on Scarlett’s other shoulder.
"He reminds me of my brother," she sighed, squeezing her friends’ hands.
"How was he stealing my stuff?"
A small, unexpected smile curled Scarlett’s lips.
"He’s an Animagus. A cat, more specifically. That’s how he got into your dormitory."
"Clever. Very clever…" Pan touched her chin, thinking. "And how did you find that out?"
Scarlett told them how she’d got revenge for the snake incident by using the Boggart. Then she’d seen a cat running off with a tie in its mouth and Petrified it, Transfiguring it until it became Regulus Black. Lily and Pandora burst out laughing, trying to picture the scene.
"Never thought he’d turn into a cute little kitten… he’s bloody terrifying most of the time, to be honest," Lily said between giggles.
"He only seems terrifying, but he’s actually a complete coward. Did all of that just to talk to me?!"
"A bit romantic, if you ask me…" the Gryffindor muttered with an eye roll.
"Not when his friends decided to humiliate me and he just joined in with them…" Pandora grumbled, her voice heavy with resentment.
"Oh. Sorry. You’re right." Lily gave her a light pat on the leg.
"And well… after he attacked me…" Scarlett exhaled slowly. "I don’t know if he’s got the balls to give me any sort of support in Slytherin."
"Rosier likes you," Pandora said thoughtfully. "We could use that to our advantage…"
"Rosier’s probably already got the Dark Mark inked on his arm…"
"How are you feeling?" Lily changed the subject, gently stroking the back of Scarlett’s hand.
It was a loaded question. Scarlett tilted her head from side to side, trying to form a reply without lying or dodging.
"Exhausted," she murmured flatly. "My life’s been flipped upside down and… I don’t know if I can keep up with Hogwarts anymore…"
She didn’t get to finish. The bathroom door opened, and James stepped in, pointing at the three of them before pushing his glasses up his nose.
"Told you they never left," James said, crossing his arms just as Sirius strode in without hesitation, his eyes slightly wide, brow furrowed, the silver of his gaze melting the moment it found Scarlett.
"Are you okay?" he asked, so full of worry that Scarlett felt a pang of guilt stab at her chest. It was a feeling that had visited her countless times—one she had grown used to—but in that moment, she wished it could disappear, just for a minute. The guilt, the fear, the anguish—it was all too much.
Her only answer was to press her lips together, trying to hold back the sob that trembled at the edge of her throat. It was hopeless—she knew it. Sirius knelt in front of her and cupped her face in both hands, forcing her to meet his eyes, melting every one of her defences with a single look.
Scarlett didn’t want to say it, but suddenly the words were pouring out of her mouth:
"I don’t know… if I want… d-don’t know if I want to go back… to Hogwarts…"
She collapsed against his chest, hating herself for being so weak, so fragile, so afraid. Clutching at Sirius’s shirt as if he too might be torn from her the way her family had been.
Sirius wrapped his arms around her tightly.
"Why not?" he asked—not with judgement, not with anger or frustration. Just… understanding.
Scarlett swallowed hard.
"Fear. I’m afraid," she admitted, her voice muffled against the collar of his dark shirt.
"It’s okay to be afraid. But I’ll be with you. I’ll always be with you," Sirius murmured into her ear.
"And it’s not like you’ve only got Padfoot for company," James added, rolling his eyes as he joined the hug. "You were my neighbour before you were his girlfriend…" He stroked her hair, a grin tugging at his lips. "You’re like a sister to me. And besides, who else is going to yank Pads’ leash when he inevitably screws up?"
Scarlett didn’t even get a chance to resist or answer.
"You’re one of my best friends, and even though I have to put up with your idiot boyfriend and his equally idiotic friends…" Pandora wrapped her arms around Scarlett, Sirius, and James, throwing them all a sarcastic glance, "I love your company. Hogwarts wouldn’t be the same without you."
"I thought I was your only best friend," Scarlett mumbled, her voice muffled in the group embrace.
"Get over yourself, Gaunt. Honestly," Pan clicked her tongue playfully.
"I know we’re not that close, and you lot have messed with me a fair bit…" Lily gestured pointedly at James and Sirius. "But as Head Girl, I can… cover for you at Hogwarts. If you want to sleep in the boys’ dormitory or… I don’t know…"
Sirius pulled Lily into the hug, cutting her off.
"Well, I was thinking we could all take Muggle music classes this year as our electives. As a prefect, I can slot us into the emptiest time slots—if you’re up for it, Scar… It’s always been my dream to become a bassist in a rock band, anyway…" Remus said it with such gravity that Scarlett almost believed him—until he gave a small laugh and joined the group hug.
"I know the house-elves. We could sneak in some gas potions into the Slytherin table food… or burping powder. Whistling worms? Vomit hexes? Or we could just steal loads of food from there without having to go to the Great Hall…" Peter rubbed his chin thoughtfully, then ruffled James’s hair and tightened the hug.
"Well…" Xenophilius looked rather sheepish amidst his friends' sudden burst of warmth. "As Ravenclaw’s Head Boy this year, I can turn a blind eye if you feel like smashing Avery’s face in again…"
It was impossible not to smile at that. Scarlett regretted many things that had happened at Hogwarts—but punching Avery right in the middle of the Great Hall certainly wasn’t one of them. In fact, he rather deserved another round.
Scarlett closed her eyes, letting the tears flow freely, breathing in the comforting scent of Sirius and sinking into the protective warmth of the group hug from the people she loved. The weight of loss didn’t vanish—but it softened. It became… bearable.
It didn’t heal, and it didn’t fade—but it eased.
She smiled through the tears, deeply grateful that her friends could make her days more bearable. Her reality more palatable. Her life a little lighter.
They were the best gift Hogwarts had ever given her.
And what was friendship, if not lightness, complicity, and understanding?
The sweet trace in bitter days.
It was strange to have gained all of them by losing so many others.
Scarlett knew none of them could ever fill the space her family had once occupied—and that the hollow would always ache—but she was not someone who had limits for love.
And they all fit inside her heart, even if only Sirius held the key to its most remote, frozen, and shadowed chamber. The place only he could ever occupy.
The altar of obsessive love—poisonous, binding, addictive. The love that chained them to each other. That both numbed and intoxicated them.
The kind of love that made them better people every day… and also brought out the very worst in them. It was something unconscious.
After all, they were only teenagers, discovering that love could be as calm, lukewarm, and tender as it was fierce, furious, and razor-sharp.
Just naive youths who swore never to leave the other alone—and that was precisely what led to their loneliness.
Perhaps that was the true ingredient of tragedy. Love, fear, and a dash of cowardice.
Or was it impulsive courage?
Gryffindor and Slytherin—what difference does it make?
Scarius’s fate was already sealed, and no friendship in the world would stop them from loving each other.
And nothing—absolutely nothing—hurts more than love.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 37: For being my friend. My best mate. My brother.
Chapter Text
CV
Sirius took a deep, very deep breath. He ran his hands over his face, silently begging for the day to end.
But it just wouldn’t.
First, he hadn’t expected to go to Thanatos’s house so soon. Second—seeing Orfy… it yanked something jagged and buried straight out of his chest, flooding it with blood and sending a sharp, raw pain through him.
He was huge now, and looked so much like Morfeu…
It was strange, seeing him. One of Sirius’s few memories of Orfeu was… from the day of the fire. And he hadn’t even seen him in the flames. The Dementors had shattered parts of his recollections, but finding him now, panicked and crying… it stirred things in Sirius’s soul he didn’t even know were still there.
Fuck, he felt like he was about to fall apart.
The hug had been instinctive. He clutched the boy to him as he cried too, though silently. It was as if Orfeu were still just a kid—that fierce, cheerful little thing who used to get jealous over Scarlett… who Sirius had once taken on a motorbike ride… who he’d promised to take flying, just as soon as Nancy was stable.
He never got the chance. He’d thought Orfeu was lost forever in the world of the dead. And yet, here he was, crying in his arms, too shaken by Scarlett’s presence to say anything more than fragmented, incoherent stammers.
Sirius had blamed himself for years on end for Orfeu’s death. He’d wished he could go back, that he’d had the chance to save him—to run back into the fire—to… to make Scarlett’s screams stop. And he was alive. Scared and traumatised? Yes. But… it was more than Sirius had ever dared hope for. The guilt that had rooted itself so deep in him began to dissolve, and with it went the weight of the world crushing his shoulders.
“You’re alive,” Sirius murmured, breathing in the boy’s hair. “I thought… we thought…”
“She came here, Sirius, she came here…” he got the words out, his face puffy and wet. His nose was covered in freckles—but unlike his sister’s, they were softer, more subtle. “She came to get me… she came to get me again…”
In Azkaban, I found out… it was Selwyn who tortured Orfy. And I made her pay… Scarlett’s voice echoed in his head.
“She didn’t come to get you, Orfy, she came to visit…”
“No!” he screamed, his breathing growing ragged. “Don’t you see what she did, Sirius?! She…” He wiped his tears on his sleeve. “She killed my parents. Her and… and the… if it weren’t for… if it weren’t for Regulus… I’d be… I’d be locked up…”
“It wasn’t her who killed your parents!” Sirius cut him off. Orfeu shoved him violently, making him stumble backwards.
“It was her!” he shouted, those once gentle green eyes now sharp and wild. “Why are you defending her?! She ruined your life! You should be in Azkaban!”
Sirius was crying now—for what had been done to Orfeu. The boy was still in there, hidden beneath the revulsion and outrage of a man crushed by trauma and fear. He clutched his own body tightly, and the Signet on the back of his left hand was the only untouched part—his fingers and wrists were covered in scars. Instinctively, Sirius reached for his own burn from that night, tugging back his sleeve to brush his fingers over the raised, red skin, ringed with tattoos.
He tried to step closer, but Orfeu curled his lip and pointed his wand at him.
“Orfy?” a woman’s voice called from behind Sirius. He glanced over his shoulder, frowning as he saw a woman running through the blasted remains of the garage wall toward Orfeu—who instantly dropped his guard and gripped her tightly, as if she were as vital to him as the air in his lungs.
“I heard what happened—it’s all right, it’s all right…”
Sirius stepped back a few paces, still dizzy, still trying to process the onslaught of feelings crashing through his chest. Memories of moments spent in that place threatened to flare behind his eyes like a film reel, but he wouldn’t allow it. He hissed them away, searching for Thanatos amid the wreckage of the house.
But his gaze landed on the doorway to a room with a large poster of a band called Whitesnake . Reggie’s room. He felt tempted to go in, but Nate appeared from the kitchen, holding two glasses of firewhisky, offering him one.
The hesitation stiffened Sirius’s arm before he accepted. He’d struggled with alcohol and drugs in the past, and even though it had been more than a decade, the old defences were still there. He ignored the voice screaming at him not to do it—and silenced it the moment the amber liquid burned down his throat, numbing everything.
He sniffed, wiping any trace of tears away with his knuckles as he followed Nate to the study. Before stepping inside, he glanced one last time at Orfeu, heart aching at the sight of the boy being held by that woman.
It was strange, seeing him as a man now. Sirius still felt like he was twenty-one, not…
Not thirty-four.
“I heard you were cleared,” Nate said as he sat with polite precision in his leather armchair, lighting a cigarette. He hadn’t aged much, though the lines on his forehead, around his eyes, and mouth had deepened. His blond hair was darker now, threaded subtly with white strands. It was still hard to believe thirteen years had passed.
Sirius remained silent for quite a while, sipping the whisky, letting all the information settle in his mind. Scarlett… had been here before she touched the Hanged Man? They’d duelled and—
“He has sporadic episodes. Hardly any, lately, actually,” Thanatos interrupted his thoughts, exhaling smoke as he narrowed his eyes.
“I didn’t know she’d come here. That she’d… have access to your house…”
“Yeah, neither did I,” Nate muttered, blowing smoke before slamming the window open, breathing in the fresh air outside. “Did you see her?”
Sirius nodded, accepting a cigarette from Thanatos’s metal case and settling into the chair across from the desk. He took a long drag, trying to calm the tangle of emotions twisting in his chest.
“I saw her. She was… playing the piano. At a bar.” He drank a deep swig of whisky, feeling his eyes sting with tears.
Thanatos gave him a sceptical look, tapping ash into the tray before resting his elbow on the chair’s arm.
“After all those years in Azkaban, she still knows how to play piano?” He gave a wistful, bitter smile.
“She’s still the same,” Sirius replied, cracking his fingers and slowly blowing out the smoke.
Nate clicked his tongue as if unconvinced, but said nothing, pouring himself another glass of firewhisky. Sirius didn’t need to ask what was on his mind—he could see it in the way Nate curled his lip and stared blankly into space. He’d been the same when Scarlett’s family died. When they found out what she did to the McKinnons.
“Nate… let me handle this, all right?”
He hadn’t even finished the sentence before Thanatos laughed—a harsh, bitter laugh. Sunlight flooded through the open window, illuminating half of his tanned face and casting the other half into shadow. A deep line creased his mouth.
“The last time I let you handle things, my niece became a Death Eater, killed five people, and got a life sentence in Azkaban.” He crushed the cigarette violently into the ashtray.
Sirius tightened the strings of his emotions, strangling them until his face became unreadable—a mask of calm he didn’t actually feel. One of the few useful things his parents had taught him.
Thanatos was right, though. He’d always been right. Scarlett leaving…
That had been his fault.
“I’m not the same man I was thirteen years ago.” There was guilt in his voice. Embarrassment, too.
He wanted to be that man—but it was… impossible. The arrogant, vibrant, uncompromising Sirius had been stripped from him so brutally that all he could do now was watch the remnants echo inside him, clinging to the threads he’d left behind, the traces of what he’d once built, still standing only because time or shame hadn’t yet crushed them completely.
Thanatos didn’t look away. Sirius felt the tension unraveling in his body despite the nicotine and the alcohol. He blinked slowly, focusing on the thin trail of smoke rising from the tip of his cigarette.
“No?” Thanatos drummed his fingers against the edge of the desk.
“Azkaban breaks anyone.” The answer was right on the tip of his tongue.
A universal truth. Just thinking about that place made him feel sick, a terrible shiver running through his body like he might faint. He still hadn’t gotten used to the sudden chill of air conditioners. His mind, as always, wandered instinctively to Scarlett—to the moment he woke in the hotel room, frightened, and she’d wrapped her arms around him.
Something soft and warm bloomed in his pupils and slowed the racing of his heart. He hardly noticed his fingers clutching his pocket watch, thumb rubbing endlessly over the glass cover as he drifted back to the night he denied Scarlett forgiveness even as he claimed her. He didn’t know whether the dizziness he felt came from the memory or the whisky. The memory was so fresh, vivid and alive that it was… strange.
Because it was untouched by the Dementors.
And yet, somewhere deep in his gut, Sirius had the gut-wrenching feeling that one day even that would be warped.
It was hard to swallow the whisky. Harder still to exhale the smoke from his lungs.
His eyes drifted to the fish tank, full of shattered, mangled, colourless little things. But that memory—the kiss he gave Scarlett, the way she gave herself to him, body and soul—was one of the only ones still whole. The only one not swimming clumsily or blindly.
It was… one of the few things he truly had that was his.
An afternoon on the lips of the woman he longed for.
A night in the arms of the woman he loved.
And for some reason, hope bloomed in Sirius’s chest again—in a mirage of vivid, riotous colour. Warm. Cruel.
Hope frightened him as much as love did, because he’d had so little of either.
He had Scarlett for only two years of his life.
He lost her for fifteen.
And here he was, wanting her all over again, even knowing he shouldn’t. It was foolish to hope for it—to protect that love, that spark of hope—but…
Her sweet scent, her sparking touch, her piercing gaze. Her velvet lips, her siren’s voice, her smile steeped in suffering. Her introversion. Her hair—whatever colour it happened to be; black, brown, blonde—her pale skin. The freckles scattered across her face. Her long, curled lashes. Her delicate nose.
Scarlett Gaunt was his greatest weakness because only she had the power to dissolve his barriers and magnify his vulnerabilities. She still held so much sway over him—even after all this time, even after leaving to play piano in some ridiculous band and not even coming back to their house.
Sirius might have freed himself from alcohol and drugs once—but Scarlett remained his favourite addiction. No matter how many times he swam away, he always ended up drawn back, pulled under by the girl who put flowers in her hair.
It was the natural order of things.
“I’m sorry.” Thanatos’s hard-set expression softened, the guilt bleeding in. “How is she?”
Sirius rubbed his temples, sighing so heavily that the black strands falling over his face lifted with the force of it.
“They tortured her. They did experiments on her Signet.” He tried to banish the images of the scars on her back.
“What?” Thanatos’s eyes flew wide.
He told him how Scarlett had been taken from her cell constantly, how she always returned catatonic, withdrawn—until the day she came back with broken bones and scars from the Cruciatus Curse. How they forced her to kill other inmates. Thanatos took it all in silently, the discomfort on his face slowly melting into horror.
“Dumbledore’s suggested I finish my Auror training to investigate this, and… I think I’m going to accept,” Sirius added, breaking the silence.
“You’ve just come out of Azkaban and you want to become an Auror?” Thanatos cleared his throat, stunned. “I can pull a few strings for you… I’m retired now, but I still know a lot of people. Word that you were cleared has spread quickly among the Aurors. I’m surprised it hasn’t hit the Prophet yet.”
Given the harassment he’d already faced at the Ministry, Sirius was just as surprised the decision hadn’t made the papers.
“It won’t be long now… After twelve years branded as guilty… it still feels like a dream, being declared innocent.” He murmured it, rising from the chair and stubbing out the cigarette in the ashtray. His gaze drifted to the fireplace, to the sparkling green powder arranged above the marble console. “Can I say goodbye to Orfy?”
Thanatos turned his empty glass slowly in his hand, again and again—before deciding to ignore the question altogether.
“I saw your brother before he died.” The words made Sirius freeze. His whole body turned to stone. It took great effort just to lift his gaze and meet Nate’s eyes. “He saved Orfy,” Nate went on. “The Order’s intelligence had caught wind of a Death Eater wanting to defect. It was him. Someone probably found out—that’s why he died…”
In Azkaban, Sirius had thought about Regulus constantly. At least in the beginning—blaming him for everything that happened. Him and Scarlett. Him, Scarlett, and Peter. But once he was free, there wasn’t a single solid moment when his thoughts drifted willingly to his brother. No.
Because thinking of Regulus meant remembering the betrayal—remembering that Reggie wasn’t his, that Scarlett had stabbed him in the most excruciating way possible.
Sirius shuddered.
“Scarlett said he died to protect Reggie,” Sirius said, though it sounded more like he was trying to convince himself than Nate.
“He told me he was trying to make a better world for his son. And that everything Scarlett did… was for Reggie.” Nate took a deep breath. “I still don’t understand how that justifies killing five people…” He rested his head on his fist, weariness lining his features.
Sirius replayed some of his past conversations with Scarlett, trying to find any thread that could validate what she had done. The crimes she’d committed.
“She needed to prove her loyalty…” Sirius echoed what she’d told him, though he didn’t quite believe it himself. That topic was too raw. Too jagged. “Why didn’t you tell me… about Orfy?” The question had been hammering in his mind from the moment he stepped into Thanatos’s home. “During the war. You… you’d been with him since ‘78. Since Scarlett was imprisoned.”
“The Death Eaters couldn’t know. No one could. And after you were caught… with Voldemort’s fall and the arrests of his followers…”
“Yes, but—” Sirius cut him off, scratching at the beard along his jaw. “You testified against Scarlett in the McKinnon case, you…”
“Saving Orfy didn’t erase what she did,” Nate replied coolly, with that same condescending tone that had always grated on Sirius.
“But you didn’t say anything —about my brother saving Scarlett’s brother… about him wanting to defect, about—”
“He died before he could pass anything on, Sirius.” Nate folded his arms, resting his elbows on the desk.
“And officially, he died a coward!” Sirius snapped, raising his voice and narrowing his eyes at Scarlett’s uncle. “He saved Orfy!”
“No one can know it was your brother.” Thanatos shook his head, completely unfazed by Sirius’s growing frustration. “There are still Death Eaters out there.”
“What difference does it make? Regulus is dead!”
“Because it could paint a target on Reggie’s back,” Nate growled, clenching his fists. “Death Eaters… they’re vengeful, Sirius. If they found out Regulus betrayed them—”
“But he died exactly because he betrayed them—saving Orfy and… and trying to protect Reggie…”
“Yeah, well—not everyone needs to know that,” Thanatos replied, impatience creeping into his voice.
“That… doesn’t make sense,” Sirius murmured to himself. Why would Regulus die to protect Reggie? If his brother had been killed for being a traitor, then Reg would have been in danger either way.
In Azkaban, he hadn’t pressed Scarlett harder because he’d been too stunned, too terrified, barely able to string words together. And after he’d driven her away with those venomous words in the Shrieking Shack… he’d avoided the subject entirely. But now, rethinking everything that had happened… she had been too brief when talking about his brother. Yes, she’d said Regulus regretted what he’d done—but…
It hadn’t been enough.
It never would be, not for their relationship.
Not for anything between him and Regulus.
“Scarlett told me the Death Eaters tortured Orfy… because of the Signet…” he changed the subject, making a mental note to question her more about Regulus later.
Thanatos turned his face slightly, gazing out at the garden through the window with a mask of indifference—though his eyes shone with something far more bleak.
“Yeah, I reckon you figured that out.” He tried to smile, but it twisted into more of a grimace. “Orfy’s a lot better than he was, but… the hallucinations… they’ve started up again since you escaped Azkaban. Anything that brings back the past—before the fire…” He took a long breath, rubbing the deep circles under his eyes. “It’s best you keep Scarlett away from Orfeu.”
Sirius smiled. A smile that held everything but joy.
“I don’t think she’ll be back after this…” he said thickly, resting his hands on his hips. “But I’ll keep an eye on her either way.”
Thanatos only nodded. Sirius took a step toward the door, but hesitated—then turned back.
“Did Regulus say anything else when he gave you Orfy?”
Scarlett’s uncle paused for a moment before pulling out his wand and a small phial. He touched the tip of the wand to his temple and drew out a soft strand of light, slipping it gently into the bottle. Then, he held it out to Sirius, whose eyes lit up at the glow of the memory.
The glass was cold against his palm. He clutched it tightly as his heart thundered in his chest. He didn’t know if he was ready to see Regulus again—but it was one of the few pieces left of his brother before he died, and…
“Take care of her, Sirius.” Thanatos’s voice cut through the dizzying spiral of thoughts about Regulus. “And you can keep my car—give it to her. She’ll need it more than I do.”
“I’ll look after her,” Sirius said softly, this time hoping— truly hoping—that things might finally go right.
That things might finally be different.
He tucked the phial into his pocket and left the study, looking for Orfy.
He found him sitting at the kitchen table, his long, reddish-brown hair hanging forward, hiding his face where it rested on the chair back. The woman who had entered earlier—a petite blonde—was stirring a cauldron filled with a greenish potion.
Orfeu looked up at him, lower lip trembling.
“She… she… she’s coming for you, Sirius,” he stammered, tears spilling from his eyes. “Scar… be careful… she’s coming for you… she’s going to hurt you…”
Sirius blinked a few times, unsure what to say—or do. Once again, he caught himself rubbing the burn scar on his forearm. Doubting his own sanity, even as he looked Orfeu in the eyes.
Could it really be true? Had Scarlett done everything… for her brother and her son?
“She was always… always with Regulus… since before… since you two… she and Regulus…”
“What are you talking about, Orfy?” Sirius asked gently. Seeing him in that state knocked the air right out of his lungs.
“The fire… it was Scar… it was her, Sirius, she… she and Regulus…” He opened and closed his mouth several times before exhaling a long, shaky breath. “My mum said… s-said it wasn’t true, but… I… I know it, Sirius, I know it was them…”
Despite not even knowing the woman tending the potion, Sirius exchanged a confused glance with her before turning back to Orfy—to those greenish-brown eyes, to the boy he still struggled to believe was alive.
“Orfy… your mother’s gone,” Sirius said softly, trying to soothe him.
“But she was here… and then Scarlett… she…” He rubbed his eyes with the heels of his palms before continuing. “James was here too.”
Sirius’s throat clenched violently. He took a step back.
He could cope with hearing about Scarlett. Even about Regulus.
But James…
It was too much.
The woman he loved, the brother he despised, and his best friend…
It was too much.
He wanted so badly to dismiss Orfeu’s words, to push away the image of James—dead—but it was like the memory had rooted itself in his brain. A coldness washed over him, sudden and suffocating, like he was being hit by a Dementor. The same cold he’d felt that autumn night.
He shook his head, violently trying to banish the thoughts.
No matter how much time passed, Halloween 1981 would always haunt him.
“Drink,” the woman said, handing the potion to Orfeu, who was still mumbling incoherently—none of which Sirius could focus on.
“June Alcott. Lovely to meet you,” she added, offering her hand.
He looked down at her fingers—small, pale, delicate—and stared.
“Sirius Black,” he introduced himself, shaking her hand with a limp grip. He was still reeling from Orfeu’s words. The torture he’d endured… it hadn’t just left physical scars.
“I know who you are,” she said politely. “My brother was a few years below you at school—you were his hero for quite a while…”
Sirius heard her words, but didn’t acknowledge them. His eyes remained fixed on Orfeu, who had now drunk the potion and fallen silent, sitting still, sniffing and wiping the dampness from his face.
The boy Sirius had known was still there—hidden behind long hair and a dazed expression—but he was there.
“Orfy?” he called gently, drawing those green-flecked eyes to his. “Are you all right?”
“I am.” Orfeu nodded, a shy smile tugging at his lips. “Sorry, Sirius… I…” He rubbed at his brow, thinking. “This is June—my girlfriend.”
June smiled as well, her hand gently massaging Orfeu’s shoulder. Sirius furrowed his brow. It was strange to see Orfy no longer as a nine-year-old boy.
“Girlfriend?” he blurted, incredulous. “Are you even old enough for that?”
Orfeu’s smile widened as he wrapped his arms around her waist, resting his head against her stomach.
“Yes… she told me you’d been cleared…” His cheeks coloured as he averted his gaze with a bashful grin.
“How do you know I was cleared?”
“I’m finishing my Auror training,” June answered, shrugging her shoulders and stroking Orfeu’s hair. “There’s no other topic in the Department of Magical Law Enforcement right now but your innocence.”
Sirius wasn’t sure whether to feel pleased or annoyed.
He went with the second.
His eyes drifted toward the living room, where the wall had been blown apart earlier—but now, there wasn’t a trace left of the possible duel between Scarlett and Orfeu. He wanted to ask about her, but dismissed the thought. Orfeu seemed lucid now, and it was better not to stir him again.
“Reg… must be so happy,” Orfeu murmured, tucking a dark strand behind his ear. “He always… always asked me about you… about his parents…”
The mention of Reggie softened Sirius’s restlessness into a genuine smile as he recalled the letter he’d received—the love of a boy who had never doubted him. The boy he wished could be his.
Sirius wanted to talk about his godson—wanted it badly—but there was something else nagging at his heart. The weight of the glass phial in his pocket. He wanted to ask about his brother. The words reached his lips—
But never made it out.
“I should go,” was all he said.
“Yeah… of course.” Orfeu’s smile dimmed a little, tinged with regret. “Sorry again… it doesn’t happen all the time, just… sometimes.” He looked up at him, embarrassed. “Sorry.”
Sirius felt his chest tighten at the sincerity laced into Orfeu’s apology.
“It’s all right, Orfy,” he replied, offering his most reassuring smile.
“I know you’re probably really busy, but…” Orfeu tilted his head slightly. “I’ve got a motorbike. If you ever fancy a ride sometime… like the old days…”
“Deal.”
Sirius walked over to the fireplace, waved his farewell, and let the green flames carry him away from Thanatos’s house—from Orfy, from bitter memories and sugar-coated illusions.
Carried away from everything…
Except Scarlett.
.
.
.
“Order of the Phoenix.” James crossed his legs on the sofa, enjoying his slice of cherry pie. “That’s the name of Dumbledore’s organisation—the one my parents are part of.”
It took Sirius a few seconds to register what James had just said. They were both sprawled across the couch, minutes away from leaving for Platform 9 ¾. Their final year at Hogwarts was about to begin, and a restless energy buzzed in Sirius’s chest.
Before he ran away from home, he could hardly sleep—counting the days until he could finally escape the dark, hostile halls of Grimmauld Place for the warm and welcoming safety of Hogwarts. If Sirius had known what peace truly felt like—living away from his family—he would’ve fled much sooner.
He owed that to Scarlett, as always. The catalyst for all the good in his life… and the bad, too. Not that it was her fault, but living with the memories of the fire was no easy thing. Any time he sweated too much, felt too anxious, too hot… he’d start to suffocate. And it was beyond his control.
“Sirius?” James’s voice pulled him from the fog of thought. “You all right?”
Sirius looked into those hazel eyes. No lens in the world could filter out the concern in his best mate’s gaze, nor soften the unease in his voice. Plastering on his most arrogant smile, Sirius gave a small nod, glancing down at his untouched slice of pie.
“Just… thinking.” He offered the dessert to James, who accepted it with a grin. “Hogwarts, Scarlett, and… everything.”
“You don’t need to worry about any of that. Dumbledore’s already sorting things, I’m sure of it. And we’ve got your back.” James said it like it was the simplest thing in the world.
Sirius took a very, very deep breath.
“I know…” He tucked a few stray strands of hair behind his ear. “What were you saying about the organisation again?”
“Ah, yeah… the Order of the Phoenix…” James went on, lowering his voice like he was sharing something top secret. “I pressed my dad about it yesterday, but he didn’t tell me much—as usual. Said I’d only find out once I finish Hogwarts. But from what I’ve overheard… they protect Ministry officials. The ones on the Wizengamot, mostly. The honest ones… or those not tied to You-Know-Who. They run escorts, break curses, rescue Muggle targets…”
Sirius didn’t quite know what to think.
Once upon a time, he would’ve joined this so-called Order of the Phoenix without blinking.
Now… his priorities had shifted.
His gaze drifted across the room, instinctively seeking her—landing on the kitchen, where Scarlett was chatting with Remus and Peter about the recent death of Elvis Presley.
“Do you think… do you think it’s wise? For Scar to come back to Hogwarts…” Sirius asked in a whisper.
James tilted his head, shrugging.
“Will she be safer with us around? Yeah. But… whether it’s good for her… only she can really say.” He gave Sirius a pat between the shoulder blades. “Then again… if she said she’s coming back to Hogwarts, then she is. We both know Scar only ever does what she wants.”
There was irony in his tone—but also a flicker of worry. Sirius felt the same.
“What d’you think about the two of us graduating, moving to a random island in the middle of nowhere, living off coconuts and… seawater?” Sirius suggested, a cheeky grin spreading across his face.
“And sunscreen—unless you want to end up looking like a bloody prawn.” James ran a hand through his perpetually messy hair.
“We’d play Muggle sports on the beach… fly around on brooms… wave at distant ships…”
“Take in the occasional castaway…” James added.
“And there’d be no war. No Order of the Phoenix, no Death Eaters. Just me, you, Scar, Moony, Wormtail… maybe Lily—and we’d be happy.” Sirius said it with such solemnity that for a moment, James nearly believed him.
They looked at each other, trying to hold it in—then burst into unrestrained laughter.
In the future, Sirius would remember that day… and wish they had followed through with the plan.
But in the past, all he did was rest his head on his best friend’s chest, listening to the steady rhythm of his heartbeat, feeling James run his fingers through his hair—speaking to him without saying a single word.
James’s heartbeat pulsed calmly beneath Sirius’s ear. He let that serenity soak into him, seep through his veins, dissolve the weight pressing down on his shoulders. He loved being an adult, but he also loved a warm lap to collapse into—and James’s was nothing like Scarlett’s. It wasn’t a place where he felt the need to speak. He didn’t have to.
James and Sirius shared a connection that defied logic—something in their souls that had recognised each other from the start. Sirius had known it the moment they locked eyes on the Hogwarts Express: that this boy with the easy grin, gentle eyes and tangled hair would be his best friend.
He would be everything Sirius had always wanted Reggie to be.
Of course, back then, he and Regulus were still close. But James had never echoed the prejudices of their world, never belittled others for their bloodline. He was never compared to Sirius, never competed with him, and never left him in the shadows.
James was a pillar. A steady one. He gave Sirius something he’d never had before—emotional safety. He was Sirius’s first glimpse of what true friendship looked like: no agenda, no strings, no sudden betrayals.
James Potter was everything Sirius Black longed to be. Loved. Admired. Welcomed. Spoiled.
James was everything Sirius wished Regulus could’ve been.
He was his first real experience of love—the kind that didn’t wound, didn’t bite, didn’t tear him apart.
Until Scarlett came. As shattered and bruised as he was…
Sirius hugged James tightly, afraid he might vanish.
James hugged him right back, resting his chin gently on top of his friend’s head.
“Prongs…”
“Hm?” James grunted.
“Thanks.”
Sirius heard James’s laugh rumble deep in his chest, muffling the rhythm of his heart.
“For what, Pads?”
“For being my friend. My best mate. My brother.”
Sirius pulled back to look at him—and saw that soft mix of surprise and embarrassment flicker in James’s hazel eyes.
He’d expected a sarcastic remark, a joke, some quip to break the weight of what he’d just said.
But James offered him something else— understanding.
And Sirius took it, gratefully.
“You’re my best mate too… the brother I always wished I had.” He tweaked Sirius’s nose. “I love you, Pads.”
“Even when I’m a complete arsehole?”
“Even when you’re a complete arsehole.”
Sirius snorted a laugh, mussing James’s hair even further.
“Love you too, Prongs.”
“Ugh, Scarlett, your boyfriend’s cheating on you with Prongs in the living room…” Peter groaned, pulling a disgusted face and pretending to vomit into the fireplace.
“What?” James asked, tossing a cushion at Peter. “No one’s snogging here, mate!”
“‘Love you too, Prongs’,” Peter mimicked Sirius in a childish voice, making Scarlett and Remus burst into laughter as they came out of the kitchen.
“It was a perfectly masculine display of affection!” James said, lifting his chin and folding his arms.
“No need to be jealous, Peter, I love you too,” Sirius said, reaching out to pull him onto the sofa.
But Wormtail backed away, exaggerating a look of disgust—though the twitch of a smile tugged at his lips.
“Get off!” Peter shrieked with laughter. “What’s got into you? Did you drink a love potion?”
“He kissed James and went all soft,” Remus said deadpan.
“Oh, don’t be upset, Moony, I love you too… even if I was a bit of a prat to you… I love you in my own way,” Sirius said, flinging a cushion at him.
Remus caught it and hugged it with mock tenderness.
“James, what did you do to my boyfriend?!” Scarlett asked, feigning outrage at Sirius’s sudden outpouring of affection. “Did you two drink something?!”
“Of course not! D’you think I only say I love you lot when I’m pissed?!” Sirius turned to look at his friends—who all nodded in unison. “Oh, come on, liars…”
“You say you love Scar all the time, but us?” James pouted, sinking into the sofa.
“Yeah, Scar this, Scar that…” Remus threw himself into the armchair, swinging his legs over the armrest.
“That’s it. We’ve been mates since first year and now he only cares about the girlfriend…” Peter added, dramatically slumping against the wall.
“Can you blame me? Look at this woman!” Sirius stretched his arms towards Scarlett, pulling her into his lap on the sofa. “How could I not be mad about her?”
“Are you sure you’re okay?” Scarlett placed the back of her hand on his forehead, pretending to check for fever.
“Perfectly fine. Just feeling nostalgic—it’s our last year at Hogwarts… we need to make a list of all the places we need to shag before the NEWTs…”
“Too much information,” Remus said, fanning his hand dramatically to change the subject.
“Do you ever think about anything besides shagging?” Peter asked, brows furrowed.
“If you two keep shagging like that, there’s gonna be a baby Sirius soon… Uncle Prongs already loves him.” James threw his arms around both Sirius and Scarlett, earning a sharp elbow from her.
“Forget that, James! There won’t be any baby for a good few years!” Scarlett scolded, though smiling.
“Two years, tops,” Sirius added, trying not to laugh as she shot him a scorching look. “Three? Three and a half? Four?”
“Sirius… marriage first. Then baby,” Scarlett said as if explaining something very simple to someone very slow.
“I already proposed and you keep playing hard to get…” he teased, earning a smack on the shoulder. “Ow!”
“You’re ridiculous!” Scar grumbled, only to be wrapped tighter in his arms as Sirius buried his face in her chest.
“What the hell is this sticky stuff…” James muttered, tugging at the hem of his shirt as he leaned in to sniff the sofa cushion.
“I wouldn’t do that if I were you,” Remus said with an amused grin.
“Did you shag on this sofa?!” James whipped around to face Sirius, his expression twisted with disgust.
“Obviously.” Sirius rolled his eyes, just as James leapt off the sofa like it had bitten him. “And the armchair too…” he added, still lounging.
Remus remained right where he was, utterly unfazed.
“…living room table, the fireplace console, the piano… the wall Peter’s leaning on…”
Peter wrinkled his lips and glanced over his shoulder, as if looking for some hidden stain.
“…kitchen island, the counters, all four bedrooms… the bathtub… my bed, obviously… oh, and the sunlounger outside…”
“For Merlin’s sake, Sirius, we get it!” James groaned, clamping his hands over his ears as Scarlett covered her face in embarrassment.
“The pool?” Remus asked, looking far too entertained.
“Sex in a pool is shite,” Sirius replied with a wicked grin, locking eyes with Scarlett. “Zero lubrication, it stings, and once you finish everything’s just floating around…”
“WE GET IT!” James shouted again, cutting him off.
Sirius watched, delighted, as Scarlett’s already flushed cheeks turned an even deeper shade of red when she caught the heated look he sent her way.
“We’ve never shagged on the Hogwarts Express…” he mused, licking his lips.
“For Merlin’s sake, Sirius, we’re not shagging on the train…” Scarlett gave a nervous smile, her eyes wide.
“The loo in the last carriage is perfect…” Remus began—before getting hit square in the face with a flying cushion courtesy of James.
“You are not shagging on the Express! Not with me and Lily as Head Boy and Girl—”
“No one needs to know.” Sirius shrugged.
“I ALREADY KNOW!” James snapped.
“Besides,” Sirius added, flashing a wicked smile, “you’ll be very busy in all those Head meetings with Lily… just the two of you in the first carriage…”
“Yeah, show her your magic quill,” Peter chimed in, joining the teasing.
“And teach her how to take notes using just your middle and ring fingers…” Remus added, shifting to the edge of his seat while making an exaggeratedly suggestive hand gesture.
“Just don’t get her too excited,” Sirius warned, “silencing charms don’t work on the Hogwarts Express.”
“Maybe… with a bit of hands-on leadership, Lily will stop being such a bossy cow?” Scarlett added, slipping easily into the joke. “You might even help her relax.”
James was now so red, so utterly dumbfounded, that a thick vein was visibly pulsing in the middle of his forehead.
“Just be careful not to rock the carriage too much,” Peter added, elbowing Remus. “Wouldn’t look great for Gryffindor if both Head Students lost points for their house.”
“Controlling the carriage is easy, Prongs… if you need any tips on that,” Sirius added with a wink.
James let out a sharp hiss, planting his hands on his hips in mock indignation.
“Come on, James, show me your patrol schedule…” Remus said in a high-pitched voice, tossing his imaginary long hair over his shoulder like Lily.
“Shall we supervise a detention up in the Astronomy Tower?” Sirius asked, lowering his voice to a sultry whisper, resting a finger on his bottom lip.
“Show me your Nimbus in the broom cupboard?” Scarlett teased, grinning with wicked glee.
“James, why does my Amortentia smell like stag?!” Peter cried—and that was the last straw.
James hissed dramatically, shook his head as though utterly scandalised—then burst out laughing with the others. Sirius, Scarlett, Peter, and Remus joined him in a riot of uncontrollable laughter. Sirius laughed so hard he nearly cried, Remus clutched his stomach, Peter was seconds from collapsing to the floor, and Scarlett had to wipe her eyes with her knuckles, gasping for air.
Sirius’s laugh was loud, shameless, and completely contagious.
“You lot are the worst friends in the world, and I hate you all!” James roared, still grinning from ear to ear.
“Oh, come off it—you’re just mad we didn’t let you get back to Lily!” Sirius teased, eyebrows wiggling as he gave him a punch in the shoulder.
James shook his head, brushing the jab aside with a flick of the wrist as he moved toward his trunk and checked the time.
“Right, that’s it!” he announced, flipping open his pocket watch. “Time’s up! Our last year at Hogwarts. Ready?”
A strange, fluttering chill settled in Sirius’s stomach. His palms were damp, and he instinctively pulled Scarlett closer, as if holding her could keep the nerves at bay. But the way she looked up at him—those clear blue eyes, those soft pink lips curled into a smile—burned away every fear. It purged every doubt.
And from deep within his chest, courage rose like the sun climbing from behind the clouds.
“Ready,” they both said at once.
They grabbed their trunks, clasped hands and Disapparated to Platform 9 ¾.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 38: Mates
Chapter Text
CVI
SIRIUS BLACK CLEARED OF ALL CHARGES!
In a shocking twist that has shaken the wizarding world, Sirius Black has been officially cleared of all charges, including the murder of twelve Muggles and the betrayal of his friends, James and Lily Potter. The true culprit—who had escaped justice for years—was identified as Peter Pettigrew, who faked his own death and had been living all this time in his Animagus form… as a rat.
WANTED: PETER PETTIGREW
A photograph from his Hogwarts yearbook was printed just beside the image of him as Wormtail, perched on Ron’s shoulder.
Regulus rubbed his eyes hard, still unable to believe what he was reading. He was wedged between Victoria and Luana, both of whom were gaping at the headline. On impulse, he slapped himself across the face.
Sirius had been cleared.
For a moment, he felt absolutely nothing. As though all the dread and anguish he’d bottled up over Sirius’s situation had vanished into a vacuum. But then, it hit him—emotions surged, burning in his chest and spilling from his eyes. He kept staring at the headline, reading it over and over, trying to brand it into his mind:
Sirius had been cleared.
They could be a family.
He was so stunned he didn’t even hear the rising murmur in the Great Hall, the heads turning his way, the crowd forming behind him to catch a glimpse of the newspaper. Disbelief echoed off every stone wall, even drawing Professor McGonagall’s attention as she craned her neck from the staff table to see what the commotion was about.
Regulus wasn’t the kind of boy to wear his heart on his sleeve, but he didn’t care about crying in public now. In truth, no one seemed to care either—everyone was mesmerised by the news of his godfather’s exoneration.
It was easy to surrender when Victoria’s arms slipped around his shoulders and he let the paper fall, burying himself in his girlfriend as though into a warm, gentle sea—one that finally welcomed him with soft waves after years of chaos. He breathed in the scent of her white hair, sweetened with cherry blossom, brushing the pale skin of her neck with the tip of his nose.
Regulus usually avoided being too physically affectionate with Victoria in public, wary of the gossip that still circled them and Cedric—whispers about how Mimi had betrayed the Hufflepuff boy with Reggie, fuelling cruel names and spiteful rumours. But none of that mattered now.
There they stood, wrapped in each other in the middle of the Great Hall, until the crowd began to part and the curious gazes turned his way once more.
He subtly pulled away from Mimi, wrapping an arm possessively around her waist, his expression softening as he spotted the dark, messy hair of a boy in glasses, flanked by his two fellow Gryffindors.
Regulus rose slowly from the Slytherin table bench, locking eyes with Harry's green gaze with such apprehension that the boy pressed his lips into a thin line. The whispering swelled around them. Victor, Terry and Miles stepped aside so he, Mimi and Luana could approach the Gryffindor trio.
“Is it true?” Harry asked, cutting through the sepulchral, unnatural silence that had taken over. Hundreds of heads turned immediately to Regulus, awaiting his answer.
“Yes. Sirius has been cleared.”
There was an unusual tension in every witch and wizard’s stare. As if they half-expected Regulus to suddenly lunge at Harry’s throat, as he had done to Vin days before. He waited for a reply, but Harry didn’t give one. He looked too stunned to form words, lost in the same daze Regulus himself had felt only minutes ago.
Then, Harry beamed—a smile so radiant that Reggie found himself smiling back, swept into a gentle, sun-washed memory. A distant, faded day when James and Sirius had pretended they were flying a spaceship with the two boys until Harry had vomited all over his father’s brand-new shirt.
“Wait a minute—if your uncle wasn’t the killer… then why… why did he break into Hogwarts?!” Miles blurted out, waving the newspaper in his hand.
“Isn’t it obvious? Because of the rat!” Victoria snapped, her tone dripping with disdain.
“A rat that belonged to the Weasley!” Draco Malfoy stood up from the Slytherin table, pointing at Ron in an accusatory tone. “Don’t you think it’s suspicious? He’s a Pettigrew accomplice! He’s been harbouring him all this time... The Ministry should investigate—”
“Shut it, Malfoy!” Hermione barked, shooting daggers at him. Draco instinctively took a step back, eyes momentarily wide—
Then his face twisted into smug arrogance.
“Watch your mouth, you filthy little Mudblood...”
“That’s enough!” Percy Weasley cut across the argument sternly, glaring at the Slytherins and then at the Gryffindors with sharp authority, clearly revelling in the fact they all obeyed. “This discussion ends now, or you’ll all lose points and spend the evening in detention.”
Hermione curled her lip in disdain, narrowing her eyes at Draco before Regulus tugged Victoria and Mimi closer, nodding to the Gryffindor trio to follow them out of the Great Hall—leaving a trail of hushed chatter and wild speculation in their wake.
“Malfoy’s such a tosser—I can’t believe he accused me because of Pettigrew!” Ron burst out as the group made their way towards the gardens. “Now I’m going to be a bloody suspect in all this…”
“Don’t listen to him, Ron, he just wants to get a rise out of you,” Hermione huffed, clutching her books tightly to her chest.
“Very brave of you, telling Malfoy to shut it like that…” Victoria chimed in, flashing her a warm smile.
“That’s because you didn’t see what she did when—”
Harry didn’t get to finish the sentence—Hermione slapped a hand over his mouth.
“Don’t say it, Harry!” she hissed, her pale face turning the shade of a ripe tomato.
Regulus, still replaying the headline in his mind, halted in his tracks and glanced at the two of them, one eyebrow raised. It was odd being around Harry and his friends like this—he’d harboured a certain aversion to them ever since the incident with the Chamber of Secrets the previous year. And now, here they were, almost as if they were… part of his circle.
“What did you do, Granger?” Luana asked curiously, toying with the silver chain around her neck as she waited for an answer.
“She punched Draco,” Ron offered, making Hermione even more mortified. She dropped her books and covered her face with both hands.
“Ron!” she scolded, elbowing him in the stomach.
“Ow!”
“Wait—what?” Regulus exchanged glances with Victoria, Luana, Harry, and Ron before turning a teasing smile on Hermione.
Her silence said it all—and made him laugh. Luana and Victoria joined in too. Regulus wasn’t exactly close to Draco Malfoy, despite being second cousins, but the idea of Hermione Granger clocking the pompous Slytherin square in the face was surprisingly satisfying. Especially given Draco’s pedigree of smug, bigoted views.
Laughing like that, unburdened and free, felt bloody brilliant. The unbearable weight that had crushed his chest all year lifted, leaving behind a lightness so soft it made him feel he could float.
He threw himself onto the grass beside the Black Lake, the smile still stretching across his face, cheeks sore from grinning.
“What’s so funny?” came a familiar voice, not far off—and there were the Weasley twins approaching.
Luana opened her mouth to answer but was promptly silenced by Hermione’s frantic look, shaking her head in wild warning. Lua clicked her tongue and shrugged, as if she hadn’t the faintest clue.
“Sirius was cleared,” Victoria said instead, sitting down and letting Regulus rest his head in her lap. “We did it!”
“We did it?” George Weasley frowned, leaning against the tree casting a broad shadow over them. “What do you mean, we?”
Victoria rolled her eyes and crossed her arms. Fred dropped onto one of the roots, fiddling with a Filibuster and eyeing the group with suspicion.
“Harry, fraternising with Slytherins…” he commented idly.
“It’s over, Weasley—the Boy Who Lived is ours now!” Luana threw an arm around Harry’s shoulders, yanking him closer. He shrank visibly, his eyes going wide, his cheeks flushing deep pink.
“Lua!” Regulus scolded, and she let go at once with a sheepish grin. “Sorry—Luana’s got no sense of personal space,” he said to Harry, though he was really glaring at his friend. “Anyway… now that Sirius is free—blimey… Sirius…”
He still couldn’t believe it.
The sun shimmered over the Black Lake in a golden staircase of light, autumn now a memory, replaced by summer’s irritating little gnats and humid warmth. The sky was spotless, not a cloud in sight.
Harry looked embarrassed, clearly unsure what to say. That sweaty-palmed, fluttery-chested feeling reminded him of the last days of summer holidays, when he was itching to get back to Hogwarts. But this—this was something else entirely. The idea that he wouldn’t be going back to the Dursleys this summer… that he could… that he would live with Sirius…
Words failed him.
Then fear crept in, curling around the fragile hope blooming in his chest, poisoning it with doubt. What if Sirius hadn’t meant it? What if that promise, made under the full moon, had been just a dream?
“Harry… when Sirius said we’d be a family…” Regulus spoke slowly, awkwardly, clearly struggling with the words. “Did he mean that… erm… you’d live with us? I mean, if you wanted to leave your aunt and uncle’s, of course…”
Harry opened and closed his mouth several times, trying to respond—but Fred and George’s laughter and Ron’s loud, snorting chuckle didn’t help.
“I mean… he is your godfather. And my mum—” Reg cut himself off at once, realising he’d just said something he shouldn’t have. His eyes flicked to Ron, who technically wasn’t supposed to know Scarlett was alive.
“They told me,” Ron revealed, hugging his knees. “About what happened… with Buckbeak, Sirius… and your mum.”
“Did you know your brothers helped a convicted criminal catch Pettigrew?” Luana said mockingly, earning a middle finger from Fred.
“You two were part of it?!” Ron stared at them.
“If you tell Mum, or Dad… or Percy… I’ll transfigure your pillow into a spider again,” Fred warned, tossing the Filibuster banana in the air with one hand.
“I won’t say anything—but why the hell did I have to hear it from your girlfriend?! You’re my brother!” Ron grumbled, chucking a pebble into the lake.
Regulus and Victoria burst out laughing at that. Luana made a disgusted noise in her throat.
“First of all… she’s not my girlfriend! I’d never date a Slytherin—especially that scheming one… Second…” He was ticking off his points under Luana’s disgusted glare. “Dumbledore made us promise not to tell anyone who didn’t already know. I figured since Harry told you about Reg’s mum being alive, then… well, it was fine. But I didn’t know you knew, so… yeah, wasn’t much I could do.” He shrugged, lacing his fingers behind his head as he lay back against the trunk.
“Back to the point…” Regulus turned to Harry, who was resting an elbow on his knee. His vivid green eyes caught the warm hues of summer sunlight, turning the fresh grass-green of his irises to burnished gold.
“I really think my d—err… I mean, Sirius…” He cleared his throat. “He’s probably going to ask you to move in with us and… um… it’d be nice if…” He trailed off. What the hell was he saying? “I mean, your aunt and uncle are Muggles, right, but if you—”
“Yeah, it would… it would be nice,” Harry stammered, nudging his glasses up the bridge of his nose with his little finger. “I’d love that.”
Regulus felt his cheeks grow warm, just as Victoria cupped them in her palms, gazing down at him with a mixture of pride and tenderness.
“I suppose… I’ve never properly introduced you,” he said awkwardly. “This is my girlfriend, Victoria Rookwood.” Reggie motioned to Mimi, who gave Harry a cheeky wink. “And Luana Teixeira. My best friend.”
Lua pouted playfully at the introduction, then grinned.
“Ronald Weasley and Hermione Granger,” Harry introduced his own friends.
“I already knew Reggie,” Hermione said, slightly smug.
“What?” Harry and Ron said in unison.
“Who do you think helped me defend Buckbeak when Crookshanks supposedly ate Scabbers?” she sighed, using a book as a makeshift pillow in the grass.
“You already knew her, huh?” Victoria teased, pinching Regulus’s nose.
“We’re just friends!” Regulus lifted both hands in surrender.
“Hmm, yes, friends…” Hermione replied, looking away.
“Besides, you were far too busy with Cedric Diggory…” he added in a sing-song voice, drawing laughter from the twins.
Victoria smiled too—though the smile didn’t quite reach her eyes. Her caramel gaze darkened, slowly turning pitch-black.
“Are you going to the Quidditch World Cup?!” Luana changed the subject quickly, and Reggie’s shoulders visibly relaxed.
“Maybe,” George replied, brushing his fringe out of his eyes as the summer breeze rippled through the grass between them. “Dad’s trying to get tickets from a bloke at the Ministry…”
“My father has a box for the final,” Victoria said, biting her lower lip. “If you’d like to come with me…” she offered, glancing at her boyfriend.
“Er… are you sure? After what I did to your brother…” Reggie gave an awkward smile.
“Yeah, you’re right… I’d best see what the mood’s like at home,” Victoria agreed, running her fingers through Regulus’s dark hair, which was sprawled across her lap.
“I worked all bloody year just so I could see the matches, even lost a bunch of gold to you two… I will be going,” Luana huffed, sticking her nose in the air as she eyed the giant squid stretching its massive tentacles after a sixth-year tossed it some toast.
“Relax, Teixeira, I’ll pay you back—with interest and late fees!” Fred snapped, mock-annoyed.
“I don’t want your money!”
“Funny, a few days ago you were desperate for it…”
“Are they always like this?” Harry asked quietly, leaning in towards Regulus.
“Yeah… since third year,” Reggie confided, watching the two continue bickering. “That, my friend, is called love.”
Harry let out a quiet snort, while Hermione frowned.
“Love? Sounds more like they want to kill each other,” Ron said, pulling a face.
“It’s perfectly normal to want to kill someone you love every now and then,” Victoria said airily, inspecting her nails.
Regulus pretended not to hear the remark, and Harry gave him a look that said you’re in trouble.
“I’ve got the Marauder’s Map, by the way,” Harry said, scratching his head and swatting at a pesky gnat. “Do you need it?”
“No…” Reggie flared his nostrils slightly, thinking back to the night his mother had been there. He still hadn’t received a reply to his letter—neither from her nor from Sirius. “It’s fine, you can keep it…”
“You never told us who the Marauders really were!” George said, pointing an accusatory finger at Regulus.
“Padfoot was Sirius, Moony was Remus, Wormtail was Peter…” He glanced at Harry.
“And Prongs was my dad,” Harry finished with a shy smile.
“Have you ever heard of the Beatles, Harry?” Regulus asked, ignoring the approving noises from the twins.
“Beatles?”
“Muggle band,” Hermione explained, running her hands through her thick hair.
“Your dad’s favourite band. I’m not a huge fan, but we’ve got some of his tapes at home. I think my d—err… Sirius…”
“Why didn’t you ever tell me that before?” Harry interrupted. There was no accusation in his voice—only hesitation.
“Tell you what?”
“That you knew me. That you knew my parents.”
Regulus didn’t have an answer ready, so he pretended to busy himself by gently tracing his fingers over Victoria’s hand before turning back to Harry.
“I didn’t… I didn’t want to talk about Sirius. I mean… he was the reason your parents…” He trailed off. He didn’t need to finish the sentence.
Harry looked up at him, eyes filled with sorrow.
“But he wasn’t.”
Regulus drew in a long, steady breath.
“No, it wasn’t him… deep down I… I had doubts, but…” Regulus shrugged. “Sirius raised me until I was three… then in ’81… he was arrested.” He lowered his gaze to the dancing lights glimmering across the Black Lake’s surface. “My great-uncle on my mum’s side and my uncle Remus looked after me after that… I’ve also got another uncle who was… well, badly affected by the war, and none of them liked to talk about Sirius or my mum, so… all I had were my memories of him.”
It was hard—painful—to admit that in front of people he barely knew. Merlin, even the Weasley twins had heard it! Regulus wanted to bury his face in the lake. But then Victoria’s hand brushed tenderly against his cheek, and the shame melted into something quieter—peace. No one looked at him with mockery or judgement. Only… understanding.
Something unfamiliar crept through his chest. A sense of comfort laced with… belonging. He kissed the inside of Mimi’s palm and slowly rose from her lap, feeling as calm as the still waters behind him.
“My mum was supposed to be dead too… and I grew up with my aunt and uncle. My parents also died in the war.” Regulus tilted his head, reserved but sincere. “We’ve got a lot in common, Harry.” He hesitated. “The difference is… our parents were on opposite sides.” He ran his tongue over his bottom lip, deep in thought. “But that doesn’t mean we have to follow in their footsteps.”
He opened and closed his hand a few times before extending it towards Harry.
“Sorry I never said anything.” His words rang with honesty—tinged with doubt. “Mates?”
A breeze swept through the gardens, lifting Reggie’s dark hair and flicking Harry’s fringe into his eyes. They did share a few physical similarities: pale skin in contrast with inky black hair, defiant eyes, a natural pull towards chaos.
Harry was skinny and small for his age; Reggie was tall, athletic. Both were intricate blends of their parents. Scarlett had given Regulus her brooding sharpness; Sirius, his courage and arrogance. Harry had inherited James’s recklessness and resolve, Lily’s resilience and wit.
Both boys were the result of the same feeling—the same spell, the same magic. Born of stolen glances and bashful smiles. Of sweet words and bitter tears. Living proof of the hope and resistance of youth who refused to accept a world warped by tyranny.
And they were also the reason for their parents’ destruction.
Two boys born of love—who had spent their lives yearning for it.
Harry didn’t know what that kind of love was—the love Regulus had clearly experienced: the presence of people who valued him simply for being who he was. From his own family, all Harry had ever received was contempt and neglect—for the simple crime of being a wizard. Just the idea of anything different, of receiving even the tiniest crumb of love without having to beg for it…
His hands tingled. He swallowed hard, clenched his fist, then slowly stretched out his arm, locking eyes with Reggie’s stormy blue-grey gaze. It was odd how they shifted in colour depending on the light around him—like fish scales, flickering from starlit silver to cobalt.
He’d never really paid much attention to Regulus before—not until that year, not until the day he found out Sirius Black had escaped from Azkaban.
He’d never cared much to know any Slytherins personally. Even though they played on opposing teams, Harry had never had any real problem with Reggie. And he certainly never imagined that this boy had once known his parents—had known him.
Harry was too young to remember his time with James and Lily. But he would’ve given anything to recall the way his mum looked at him, or the sound of his dad’s laugh.
Well, it seemed he’d have to make do with the memories that Regulus, Sirius, and Scarlett carried of them.
“Mates,” Harry said, gripping Reggie’s hand—sealing a friendship that would one day cost both of them their lives.
.
.
.
Victoria Rookwood hated herself.
That was nothing new. It was hard to like yourself when you came from a family that was so demanding, so toxic, so suffocating. Her mother should have been thrilled to hear about her dating Regulus—but thanks to Vin’s interference, she was certain a punishment would be waiting for her the moment she stepped off the Hogwarts Express.
It wasn’t just that she’d dated Cedric Diggory for a short while. It was that she’d cheated on him—with Regulus.
And the news had spread fast—like vultures chasing carrion—reaching her parents, who sent her a letter with just one sentence:
We will address your transgressions at home.
That was it. Just that. Not even a hello, not a how are you, darling? Not that they were ever the kind of parents to say that sort of thing—but still… Victoria wanted them to be.
She wished they were normal. Like Luana’s parents—divorced, yes, and not particularly well-off, but still the kind of people who treated their daughter like she was worthy of love simply by existing.
Lua didn’t need to be top of her class, or perfect, or useful, to be loved. She was already incredible—but she didn’t have to bleed for validation the way Victoria did.
It was hard not to envy her.
It was hard not to feel anything at all, to be honest.
It was even harder to ignore the smug little grin Vin gave her every time their eyes met. Or the way Victor always lowered his head in front of their older brothers—never once daring to stand his ground.
And yet, hiding her own feelings from Regulus had been… surprisingly easy.
He seemed too preoccupied with his own troubles—Sirius’s exoneration, his newfound friendship with Harry Potter. Of course, the flicker of jealousy she’d felt in her chest when that Hermione girl had called him by his nickname still rankled. Especially after finding out they’d had some sort of interaction in the past.
Apparently, Victoria wasn’t the only one with secrets.
Not that she feared losing Reggie to Hermione—Merlin forbid. That was unthinkable. But still… it gnawed at her, the way the girl looked at him. It was the same look the Slytherin girls gave him when he smiled in the common room—wide-eyed, awestruck, like he’d hung the stars himself.
That was why Victoria made a point of clinging to Regulus and shooting daggers at anyone who dared glance his way—cutting them off before they even thought of saying a word to him.
Dating Regulus Black… it was like stepping out of a gilded cage and soaring into open skies. With the constant fear of being snatched mid-flight by a predator—her brothers… her parents. Dreading the moment she’d have to return to her prison, yet catching glimpses of a world that was so much more than the little box she'd been raised in.
The horizon felt as far away as her happiness.
And yet—she was happy with Reggie. He gave her space to be herself, and at the same time, gently pushed her to be better. It was strange. She felt unmoored… and yet finally seen.
She didn’t understand the full cost of loving someone, but she was starting to feel it—especially with the end of term drawing near.
Soon, she’d have to go back. Back to her cage.
Fear tried to dig its roots into her chest again, but Victoria wouldn’t let it. She wouldn’t let fear dictate her next steps. Not anymore. Never again.
“What are you thinking about?” Regulus’s voice snapped her from her thoughts. She glanced sideways at him, the corners of her lips curling into a soft smile.
“Nothing,” she lied, shifting her gaze toward the squabbling suits of armour nearby.
Regulus simply nodded, not noticing the quiet war behind her words.
After their N.E.W.T.s, there was still a month of classes left—mostly electives. The news about Sirius still rippled through the school, and suspicion followed them in every corridor. That was why she and Regulus often slipped away to the fifth floor—where the infamous broom cupboards were tucked away.
“Nothing?” Reggie teased, opening the door behind him.
Victoria raised a brow, then shoved him playfully into the cramped, dusty space full of brooms.
"Nothing," she murmured, stepping closer. Her fingers glided over the freckled skin of Reggie’s face, trailing down to his bottom lip, coaxing a heavy sigh from him.
She shut the door behind her, plunging them into darkness, fully aware of what she wanted to do. Regulus, however, seemed to have his own idea, as he seized her waist with both hands, pinning her between the door and his body. Victoria gasped, gripping the lapel of his shirt.
Regulus tasted the cherry on her lips with the tip of his tongue before kissing her deeply, his heartbeat thundering in his ears. Victoria melted into the fervour of his touch, her lips parting as one of his hands tangled in her white hair while the other traced the line of her spine down to the curve of her arse.
She broke the kiss, resting her head back against the door, drawing in a deep breath in search of air.
"Still nothing?" Regulus murmured into her ear, voice thick with desire. Victoria's hands slid down his chest, still clothed, her fingers closing around his green-and-silver tie.
"I don't know..." she replied, before claiming his lips again, their tongues colliding in a hot, desperate kiss. Her whole body tingled as Regulus ground his hips against hers, desire surging through her limbs, igniting every muscle with each throb of her pulse.
It was hard to think with Regulus pressed up against her like that, their breath mingling in shaky pants, every electrifying touch and maddening moan muddling her mind. His lips travelled down her jaw to her neck, and Victoria rolled her eyes back as his wet tongue traced over the exposed skin beneath her collar, his hands tugging the neckline down, his body pressing harder as if he wanted to fuse with her.
It was getting very hot. Maybe it was the stifling air in the cramped cupboard, the smell of dust and wood… or maybe it was because Victoria slipped her hand into Reggie's trousers, earning a startled grunt and a full-body shudder as her fingers wrapped around his erection, her thumb brushing the swollen tip.
"Mimi..." Regulus breathed out, his mouth climbing back up to hers for another kiss.
"Reggie," she whispered against his lips, biting them gently.
Victoria’s hand slid lower, making his whole body arch as she stroked him, and Regulus hissed, one hand tightening in her hair while the other slipped beneath her skirt, pressing against the thin fabric of her knickers, fingers teasing that dangerous place.
He moved them in torturously slow circles, making Victoria rise up on her toes.
At that moment, the door swung open. The sudden flood of light from the corridor blinded them both, and Regulus instinctively pulled Victoria toward him to keep her from stumbling backwards, catching himself on a few broom handles as he gasped for air. He squinted, trying to make out who had interrupted them.
“Well, well… what do we have here?” Luke Avery blocked the exit with his body, a malicious grin stretched across his face. Arms folded, dark eyes gleaming, he surveyed the pair of them with cruel amusement.
Victoria, still breathless from the kiss, quickly stepped away from Regulus, pressing herself against the shelving opposite, her eyes wide with surprise—and a flicker of shame.
“We were just…” she began, but trailed off as soon as she noticed the way Luke was staring at her.
“Just…?” Luke prompted, his gaze raking down her figure like she were meat on display.
“It’s none of your business, Avery.” Regulus swallowed the nerves rising in his throat and slipped into his usual insolent posture, stepping forward with his chin lifted and eyes hard as steel.
Luke didn’t even look at him. His attention was fixed solely on Victoria.
“Your parents are going to love this…”
“No.” Victoria cut in immediately, her voice sharp with alarm. “I didn’t… we didn’t… Avery…” she stammered, panic tightening her throat. “You can’t tell them. You can’t—”
She had promised herself she would be brave. But in a moment like that, it was so damn hard not to be afraid. Her parents were already furious with her, and now…
To her growing horror, Luke let out a low, satisfied chuckle.
“Oh, I will tell them. They’re going to love knowing that all the rumours about their perfect little girl are true…”
Regulus stepped forward again, fists clenched and jaw tight, but Victoria grabbed his arm to hold him back.
“I’m serious, Avery, if you say a word—”
But Luke barely acknowledged her. He stepped away, his twisted smile widening as he began strolling down the corridor.
“What are you going to do about it?” he called over his shoulder, hands laced behind his head as he walked calmly away.
Victoria burst from the cupboard, followed closely by Regulus.
“Avery!” she called again, but he didn’t turn around. “I’m not joking, Avery! You can’t tell—”
Regulus was ready to charge at the Slytherin prefect, his entire stance coiled like a spring, but Victoria was quicker. She drew her wand and pointed it at Luke, her arm trembling.
Avery stopped and turned, his brow furrowed.
“Avery, I’m serious…”
“What are you going to do? Curse me?” he interrupted, that smug smirk still stamped on his face. “You’re a coward, Rookwood. You really think I don’t know exactly who you are?”
Regulus should have been alarmed by Victoria’s sudden display—but he knew her too well. It was a bluff. She would never attack someone, not a fellow student, not over something so petty and cruel.
He adjusted his trousers quickly to hide just how hard he still was, waiting for her to pull a threat or some clever retort from her sleeve. That was usually how they escaped these situations—through manipulation, through Slytherin finesse and veiled blackmail.
But then, her hair flared. A wild blaze of yellow, orange, and scarlet lit up her scalp as if she were catching fire. Regulus stared, stunned, as she raised her wand and cast a spell.
A flash of red light shot from the tip and hit Luke square in the chest.
The boy was blasted backwards, colliding hard with a row of suits of armour. They crashed to the ground with a deafening clang.
Regulus went pale, jaw slack, instinctively reaching to lower Victoria’s hand.
“What the fuck are you doing, Victoria?!” His voice was sharp with urgency—and shock.
Victoria swallowed hard, blinking rapidly as her breath came faster, shorter, like her lungs couldn’t keep up.
“What happened here?”
Aphelandra Pyke had appeared, drawn by the sound of falling armour. Her eyes widened at the scene before her.
Regulus snatched Victoria’s wand from her hand before she could even register what was happening. Her pulse pounded in her ears, a disorienting drumbeat of dread. She glanced at Luke’s slumped body, and her gaze dropped to her own shaking hands.
Her hair had turned violet.
“It was me.”
Regulus stepped forward, his voice low and controlled. “It was an accident,” he said, clearing his throat, tone dark and measured, expression wiped clean of guilt. “I… I don’t know why I did it.”
Aphelandra stared, speechless at his cold candour, kneeling beside Luke to check his pulse.
A crowd was beginning to form—students curious, eager, some disappointed to find the broom cupboards occupied by more than just snogging couples.
Regulus didn’t even glance at Victoria as he let go of her hand and followed Aphelandra toward Dumbledore’s office.
.
.
.
“The Pensieve’s in the attic?” Sirius asked, eyes still fixed on his own face on the front page of the newspaper.
Remus folded the paper, studying him quietly as he bit the corner of his lip.
“I think so,” he said with a shrug, returning to his reading. “Accio should work.”
Sirius nodded, sipping his coffee. The air between them was… strained. Tense.
Remus didn’t approve of letting Scarlett run loose like this—it was too dangerous now that Peter knew she was alive. And Remus was right. Sirius knew it. But he couldn’t bring himself to order her home.
She hadn’t come back. Not since she started playing piano in that stupid band or working in that dodgy Muggle bar. It was like she’d forgotten who she was.
Sirius wanted— needed —to ignore the fact that he’d taken too much from her, because if he didn’t…
He might very well go down there, cuff her, and drag her back where it was safe.
In the past, he’d carried that same responsibility—to keep her safe. To look after her. To make her happy. And he had failed.
Scarlett had left and never come back.
That was why he had accepted Dumbledore’s offer. Why he’d resumed his Auror training. Why he kept an eye on her. Sirius knew all too well that Scarlett would never accept being caged again. So he did what little he could—making sure she was alive, making sure she was still out there.
It wasn’t a role he particularly enjoyed, but he wasn’t so selfish as to only think of himself. He’d done that far too many times.
“Thanks, Moony,” Sirius muttered as he rose from the chair, walking into the corridor and staring up at the string that released the attic stair. He yanked it, feeling the weight of the small vial Nate had given him pressing against his pocket.
He climbed the steps, covering his nose against the thick scent of dust. Raising his wand, he paused for a long while, his gaze fixed on a box labelled Scarlett —a flicker of memory brushing his ears and sending a chill down his neck.
He had agreed to treatment at St Mungo’s for the lingering effects of Azkaban. The first session was scheduled for next week. He licked his lips, cracking his neck as he exhaled slowly. Sirius didn’t know if he truly wanted to revisit those memories.
Sometimes, he thought the weight the Dementors had placed on them might have been a kind of mercy. Perhaps forgetting the good things was actually a blessing.
What had Scarlett said about that once?
“It’s the good memories that hurt the most.”
Sirius shook his head, trying to dispel the thought.
“Accio Pensieve.” The stone basin soared toward him, crashing into a few boxes and bits of old furniture along the way. Sirius caught it against his chest with a grunt, the impact knocking the breath from his lungs.
He carried it carefully down the steps, kicked the last one up to retract the ladder, and stepped into his bedroom. Placing the Pensieve onto his desk, he ran his fingers over the dust-covered runes carved into the rim, wiping them clean with a damp cloth.
His hand faltered as he drew the vial from his pocket. The pale light of the memory within danced, igniting the starlight in his eyes.
Sirius drew in a deep, deep breath. He didn’t know if he was ready to see his brother again, even if it was just a memory. The image of Regulus in his mind was distant—distorted. Just a frightened boy, flinching from the whip of Sirius’s temper.
And now… to imagine him as the villain and not the victim…
It hurt.
Regulus had caused the greatest miseries of his life. And Sirius would never forgive him.
He hated how his younger brother could still make him feel so small, so helpless, so bitter. So rejected. Regulus had always been the favourite. The chosen one. The Black family treasure. Not just by Walburga—But by Scarlett too. Regulus had taken everything from him.
Everything.
Sirius hadn’t realised he was crying. Nor that he was clutching the crystal vial so tightly he nearly shattered it in his palm. He didn’t want past pain to cloud the truth of what he might see. But it was hard. He was just a man—haunted by the past, the family that broke him, and the love that never belonged to him.
He placed the vial beside the Pensieve and turned on his heel, leaving the room.
He wasn’t ready.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 39: Was love really that frightening, Scarlett?
Chapter Text
CVII
Scarlett stroked the black diamond on her ring, her mind drifting to a past both distant and vividly present. The blinking fairy lights she and Sirius had used to decorate the Christmas tree, the hideous jumpers Euphemia had knitted for them, the absolutely mad performance they gave of Bohemian Rhapsody. She was fairly sure they’d sung off-key and slightly out of time, but in her memory, it was a moment that—
A moment that made her want to cry.
She took a long sip of whisky, staring into her blurred reflection in the amber liquid. She twirled a completely bleached strand of hair around her finger — nearly white. It brought out the blue in her eyes and the freckles on her face, though it didn’t contrast as strikingly with her pale skin as her previous reddish-brown hue had. Still, she liked the change. The more distance she could put between herself and her old image, the better.
“And you, Star?” A male voice pulled her from her thoughts, and her eyes swept across the others at the bar.
The place was already closed, so there were no customers left — just the band members, who’d only just finished packing up the gear. Scarlett — a temporary addition to the group — had accepted their invitation for a post-show drink.
It had been the third gig of the Space Travelers, fronted by the guitarist and backing vocalist Danny Lancaster, the son of the venue’s owner. He was a lad in his mid-twenties, mildly famous for having the band, and he wasn’t a bad musician either. In fact, none of them were. But the gap between them and Scarlett was stark, even after all her years in Azkaban.
“I what?” Scarlett raised an eyebrow as she knocked back her drink, squinting at Mike, the drummer. He was a striking man, tall and lean, reminding her quite a bit of Remus with his dark eyes and long frame. His choppy hair, however, was golden — coppery, depending on the lighting.
“We want to know if our lovely Stargazer has ever shagged in public,” said Stacy, the vocalist, cracking all her fingers at once with a sly smile on her graceful face.
“Yes.” That was all she said, drawing groans of protest from the group.
“Yes? What kind of answer is that?” Lenny, the youngest of the lot, sat on a stool beside her. He ran a hand through his dark, spiky hair, clearly waiting for more.
Scarlett sighed, sliding her glass down the bar towards Danny, who stood on the other side. She hoped he’d refill it, but the guitarist didn’t move.
“We want to know where it happened,” Stacy said, inspecting her nails before glancing back up. The coloured lights from the stage danced across her deep brown skin, washing it in shades of turquoise and orange.
“No details, it’s probably bollocks,” Mike shrugged, elbowing Lenny.
“It was… on New Year’s,” Scarlett confessed, letting the alcohol melt her defences. “Nineteen seventy… seven?!” She frowned at Danny, who handed back her refilled glass.
“Seventy-seven?” Stacy pulled a face, quickly mirrored by Lenny. Danny stifled a laugh behind his hand.
“Forgot you’re fifty…” Mike scratched his chin.
“I was a kid in ’77.” Lenny rubbed his arm.
“With who?” Stacy rested her chin on her hands, visibly entertained.
“My boyfriend at the time.” She twirled the glass in her hand, her drunken blue eyes taking on a shadowed hue. “Why do you lot want to know so badly?”
“It’s not like we know much about you…” Danny murmured, frowning.
Scarlett gripped the glass more tightly, tilting her head to the side in a gesture of thinly veiled impatience.
“Right. What else d’you want to know about me?”
Stacy and Danny exchanged glances, as did Mike and Lenny. Scarlett might’ve felt a flicker of nerves if she weren’t so thoroughly drunk—and didn’t even stop to consider that she might say something she’d need to Obliviate them for later. She just hoped they were as pissed as she was.
“Whose car is that?” Danny was the first to speak.
“My uncle’s. I had a row with my brother, ended up leaving home and… keeping the car as a sort of compensation.” She swallowed hard. Even through the whisky haze, just mentioning her brother made her voice falter.
“Compensation?” Mike tossed one of his drumsticks into the air and caught it again.
“Yeah… dunno if you lot noticed, but I kind of don’t have a proper place to stay.” She laughed at her own misfortune. Stacy sobered, and Lenny gave her a look filled with pity. Scarlett clenched her fist, itching to wipe that expression off the bassist’s face.
“You said you’d just come back to the UK. Where were you?” Stacy pressed, picking at the last of a portion of chips.
Scarlett blinked, distracted, her smile twisting.
“Switzerland.” She pursed her lips. Not entirely a lie… but she couldn’t exactly say Azkaban.
“You lived there with your family?” Lenny looked like he’d believe anything she said. Scarlett cleared her throat, eyes flitting to the empty tables in the dark. Where were her ghosts when she needed them most?
“I lived with them, but… they died… so…” She tried to say it with firmness, but in her drunken state, it came out shaky. “I lived alone for a while. A long while. Then I came back here.”
“You came back?” Danny frowned, as if he’d just caught her in a lie.
“I lived with them here, so… they died and I went to Switzerland, and then…” Scarlett corrected herself, rubbing her eyes with her knuckles. “Came back here.”
“Sorry to ask, but… how did they die?” Stacy was still watching her closely.
Scarlett instinctively slipped her fingers under the sleeve of her red jacket, tracing the burn scar along her arm with her fingertips.
“It was a fire. A few years ago…” She shrugged, trying to make it sound like nothing.
“How long are you planning to stay around? It’s just… you’re really good on piano and keyboard, and… well… if you’re sticking around for a few months…” Danny tilted his head.
“One, two years…” Scarlett guessed. She hadn’t the faintest idea. Truth was, she didn’t know what the fuck she was doing. She just wanted to be part of the band.
Lenny leaned across the bar and whispered something to Danny, who ran a hand through his long hair and poured Scarlett another whisky.
“My dad’s looking for a waitress and… um, there’s a flat free upstairs, if you’re interested…”
It took Scarlett a moment to realise it was an offer. Sleeping in Thanatos’s sports car in her Whiskers form wasn’t exactly the height of comfort, but it wasn’t like she needed a permanent place… in truth, the last thing she wanted was something permanent.
The less attention she attracted, the better.
Which, coming from a girl who wanted to play in a band, sounded a bit hypocritical — but Scarlett wasn’t sober, and it somehow felt perfectly logical to accept the brothers’ offer.
“I’ll take it,” she said, wetting her lips before raising her glass in a toast. “It’s not like I’m a convicted murderer fresh out of prison or anything…”
Her remark made them all burst into laughter — including herself, for having told a truth so thoroughly veiled in omission.
“Is there anything we should know about you?” Mike asked, accepting a cigarette from Danny.
Scarlett looked around again, hoping James, Lily, or Regulus would appear to help her. It felt strange to be without them like this, as if… as if she were normal again. And yet… she’d never felt so alone. Not even when she was locked up at Grimmauld Place, or imprisoned in Azkaban…
For a moment, she felt like a normal person.
“I’ve got a son,” she admitted, exhaling slowly, her features softening. “His name’s Regulus. He’s fifteen and… he goes to boarding school.”
They all gaped at her.
“Wait… you’re married?” Stacy all but shouted the question.
“Widowed,” Scarlett said quietly, twisting her ring on her finger and biting her lower lip.
“What kind of name is Regulus?” Lenny pulled a face, patting her shoulder.
“It’s the name of a star in the Leo constellation,” she explained, surprised she could still recall that through the fog of drink.
“Ohhh, that’s why your nickname in the band is Stargazer!” Danny concluded, settling onto the edge of the bar. “Suddenly it all makes sense…”
Scarlett merely nodded slowly, trying not to think about Reggie.
“Interrogation over?” She hadn’t meant the question to sound harsh, but failed. The alcohol brought all the sting right to the centre of her chest.
“Over,” Danny said, raising his hands in surrender. “D’you want the flat key now?”
“Yes, please,” Scarlett answered so quickly it took him a second to process.
Danny slipped out from behind the bar, crouched to rummage through a drawer, and pulled out a key to hand her — though he didn’t let go just yet.
“What’s your full name?” he asked, eyes fixed on hers, fishing for the truth.
Danny was a handsome lad, of Asian descent, dark-eyed with skin that looked like it had never seen the sun — unlike his brother, who was a fair bit more tanned.
The question caught Scarlett off guard. She couldn’t give her real name — she’d be far too easy to track down — but it was difficult to come up with something far removed from her reality. And she’d just mentioned Reggie, so…
Her head began to pound.
“Melanie… Black,” she said at last, swallowing with difficulty. “But… you lot can call me Scar.”
“Why Scar? Star from Stargazer is clearly better,” Mike teased, eyeing her with a kind of lewdness that made her skin crawl.
Scarlett had a sharp reply on her tongue but bit it back. The conversation soon wound down; Stacy needed to get home and offered Mike a lift. Danny and Lenny lived in one of the upstairs flats, so they headed up together and left Scar to explore her new place alone.
“The bar opens at eight — be downstairs so my dad can go over the job with you,” Danny said before leaving.
Feeling the strange absence of her ghosts, Scarlett crossed the room in total darkness until she stopped in front of the bedroom — simple, with a bed, a wardrobe, nightstands, and a tall window that stretched floor to ceiling, more like a glass door.
She stared out at the street in the early hours, completely deserted. A chill skittered down her spine when the shadows of the night seemed to stretch across the pavement, and Scarlett instantly ducked behind the wall, overtaken by the eerie sensation of being watched.
But there was no one down there.
Scarlett then pulled a golden chain from her pocket until her watch slipped from the leather lining of her coat, catching the glow of the streetlights filtering through her window.
She popped it open with a soft click and smiled to herself at the little boy inside sticking his tongue out — allowing her mind to drift to Sirius and Reggie.
She hugged the watch to her chest, collapsed onto the bed, and curled up tight, pressing it close to her heart as if trying to calm the wild pounding that shook her whole body. What was she doing? Why was she hiding like this?
She’d spun countless lies to a bunch of strangers just to… just to…
She breathed deeply, sobs catching in her throat.
Was love really that frightening, Scarlett?
.
.
.
Scarlett squinted slightly as the rising sun caught the black diamond of her ring, the surrounding stones glittering so fiercely that she shielded her face with her hand, setting the jewel down on the bedside table.
Still half-asleep, she pulled on the red leather jacket that had once belonged to Thanatos and wrestled with the stuck window, muttering curses under her breath as she forced it open with her arms until the frame gave way with a loud bang. She sighed, letting the morning breeze — laced with the scents of London — wash into her room. At that hour, the roads were already filling with traffic, and the pavements bustled with life.
She fished her watch from her pocket and flipped it open, gazing at the photo of young Sirius sticking his tongue out at her. A distracted smile crept onto her lips, only to be quickly extinguished by a wave of guilt. She ran her fingers over the glass above the hands, watching them twitch erratically. She thumped the watch against the wall a few times until the hands froze at twelve and refused to budge.
“Shit,” she muttered, resting her head against the wooden window frame. She’d fix it later with a Reparo.
Closing her eyes, she tried to order her thoughts.
It had been two weeks since she’d left Sirius’s house after the row with Remus. Two weeks since… since Orfy…
Scarlett drew in a deep breath, massaging her temples and pushing down any feeling that dared try to claw at her heart. She couldn’t think about it. She couldn’t—
Her gaze landed on the letter beside the ring. She still hadn’t replied to Reggie. Truth was, she had no idea what to say. Fifteen years in prison and suddenly — a fifteen-year-old son.
It had been exhausting trying to ignore James, Lily and Regulus and their endless arguments about what she was doing. Playing keyboard in a Muggle band? Far too risky. She could be seen, recognised — Peter knew about her…
And yet, there was something strangely comforting about being surrounded by people who had absolutely no idea who she really was. That was why she’d ignored the trio for days on end — until they finally relented and began helping her, realising that despite how far from ideal the situation was, and despite Sirius not being around…
She’d never felt so light. So free. So… independent.
The nightmares would never leave her, of course — the past was always eager to come clawing back. But when Scarlett was awake, when she was playing music with her band, or just having small talk with her bandmates, or even working as a waitress in that bloody bar…
She was just a girl who’d been kicked out by her uncle, trying to find her way in the world.
And not… not a criminal.
Not a murderer.
Scarlett wrestled with the stubborn window once more, using all her strength to force it shut — it stuck every bloody time she opened it. She pulled on a pair of trousers she’d found in one of the boxes tucked into the corner of the tiny bedroom and opened the door, only to be greeted by James and Regulus mid-argument.
“It’s my turn to cook, you already made that disgusting meatball taco thing yesterday!” Regulus accused, finger jabbing towards James’s face.
“I only cooked dinner last night because you threw a hissy fit when the strawberries ran out!” James shot back, arms crossed.
Slouched on the battered sofa, Lily was flicking through a ghostly Muggle magazine. She didn’t even glance up, and Scarlett sighed, her eyes scanning the cramped living room for her bottle of whisky.
She spotted it just as Regulus and James stormed past the bar into the kitchen — which, inconveniently, was part of the same room. Scarlett crouched down and retrieved the bottle, which was nearly empty. She popped the cap off with the corner of her mouth and let the burn dull her palate, washing out the rising pitch of her two ghosts as they bickered louder and louder.
Clearing her throat, she leaned on the back of the sofa for balance.
She had discovered something very, very amusing.
Her ghosts vanished when she was drunk.
She capped the bottle and tossed it onto the sofa, earning a scathing glare from Lily — who hadn’t spoken to her in days, not since realising Scarlett was just using her pain to run from her problems, her crimes, and her responsibilities. There’d been a nasty row between them, one Scarlett didn’t remember all that well, seeing as she hadn’t been entirely in her right mind.
Being in a band had its perks — like easy access to alcohol and a selection of drugs at mate’s rates. Not that she touched the latter. That was a firm line she wouldn’t cross. But alcohol… fuck, she understood all too well now why Sirius had spent most of ’78 pissed off his face.
It made everything feel so much further away. So much less important. So… small. Her problems shrank down to little nothings instead of the towering waves constantly threatening to drown her.
“Shut up!” Scarlett barked, rubbing her eyes. “It’s seven in the bloody morning! For fuck’s sake…”
Lily propped her elbow on the stained armrest, craning her neck to watch Scarlett snap at James and Regulus, cutting short their opportunity to cook that morning. That had been the deal — they could take over Scarlett’s body to make whatever dish they fancied, then try it, and leave her alone.
Of course, that was only the version of events they allowed Scarlett to see. Behind the scenes, the three of them were scheming — quietly planning how to convince her to go back to Sirius, to go home, to return to their family.
Because like it or not… they were family. And families were meant to stick together. Apart, they were weakened — they always were. That’s how she’d ended up dead in the first place. That’s how…
Lily snapped her magazine shut and retrieved the little notebook she’d been scribbling in since Azkaban. She flipped it open to the exact page she was after — the one with a locket circled over and over again.
The Locket of Salazar Slytherin.
A Horcrux made by Voldemort, possibly still intact. A house-elf would hardly have the power to destroy it. Lily couldn’t quite remember what, exactly, was needed to take care of such a thing, but she was fairly certain even elf magic wouldn’t be enough.
Which meant Voldemort hadn’t truly been defeated. That her son wasn’t safe.
And if the holidays rolled around and Scarlett was still acting like a bloody coward, Lily would possess her and drag her arse back to Sirius’s house by force. Regulus was against the plan, but James always backed her — two against one.
Merlin, why did Scarlett have to be like this? Sure, nearly getting murdered by her brother had shattered her, and she flat-out refused to talk about it. But Lily hated when she closed herself off like that — just like she’d done in her final year at Hogwarts. Everyone had thought it was because of her family’s death, or later, because she was a Death Eater. But after all this time living alongside her…
All Lily could see was a wounded, skittish kitten. Startled by her own shadow, always trying to outrun it like the devil dodging the cross. But shadows never truly left us — not even when light erased all trace of darkness. Scarlett might not see it, but her shadow was still there. Her crimes were still there. And if she didn’t learn to face her past, it would tear her to pieces all over again.
Clinging to music wouldn’t save her from the coming storm. It would only be another anchor dragging her down into the depths.
Lily let out a quiet, bitter chuckle as she glanced out the window beside her, at the figure cloaked in black sitting on the fire escape of the building across the street, a cigarette burning between pale fingers.
Scarlett, meanwhile, had slammed the bathroom door behind her. She couldn’t help but catch her own reflection in the tiny mirror above the sink, running her fingers over the dark circles under her eyes — emphasised by her platinum hair and ghost-pale skin. Her eyes were rimmed with a persistent redness, the kind only a wicked hangover could leave behind. If she had a cauldron, she might’ve brewed a potion, but she couldn’t recall the ingredients, and Lily sure as hell wouldn’t help her, so she’d have to settle for the Muggle way of handling it.
Wait until the pounding in her skull and the heaviness in her limbs finally wore off.
She cleared her throat as she opened the drawer, pulling out the packet of the test she'd bought the night before. She’d really meant to take it straight after buying it, but she’d been late for the gig and, before she knew it, far too drunk and exhausted.
Her fingers trembled so badly she couldn’t manage to open the packaging, so she tore it with her teeth and spat the foil wrapper onto the floor, lowering herself onto the toilet, trying to focus solely on pissing. She’d done this before — but with a wizarding potion, not with Muggle tech. The test wasn’t as reliable as the potions used to be, but it was better than nothing.
She couldn’t risk getting pregnant. Not again. Not when… not when everything was such a mess. Sirius, Reggie, Harry, Remus, Orfeu, Thanatos, her ghosts, the tortures…
The thought alone made her stomach churn.
She couldn’t be pregnant with Sirius’s child again. She’d fucked it up badly enough the first time. Things had already gone wrong so many times in her life — surely not again —
Scarlett took a deep, deep breath as she set the test on the bathroom counter. She lifted her gaze to the ceiling, noting a faint yellowish stain in the white paint near the light fixture.
What was Sirius doing right now?
She shook her head, trying to banish him from her thoughts. She had no right to think of him. She knew full well he would never forgive her. She hadn’t forgiven herself either. She did what needed to be done. It was something she and Regulus shared — inflicting a lesser harm to prevent a greater one.
At least, that’s what she told herself every time the nightmares of Marlene came for her — the moment the green flash swallowed the blue of her eyes along with the lives of those she'd betrayed.
She only realised she’d been holding her breath when it finally whooshed into her lungs as she looked down at the result: negative. The tension in her shoulders slowly began to loosen, her body wilting in quiet relief.
She tossed the device into the bin, combed through her hair with her fingers, and began getting ready for another day as a waitress at The Hanged Man. It was a fairly simple job — taking orders, wiping tables, and, when needed, working the bar as a bartender. She tied her hair up into a rushed bun and left the flat without so much as a bite of breakfast.
James and Regulus’s row had done a fine job of killing her appetite.
“Wow, you look rough,” Danny remarked as she came down the stairs into the pub. “Did you stay till Mike and Stacy left?”
Scarlett allowed herself a small smile, rolling her eyes as she reached for the apron hanging behind the bar. Danny kept staring, which made her a little self-conscious. He was a handsome man — his Asian features made him stand out in a crowd — but that was it. Scarlett’s eyes were far too used to chasing the brightest star in the night sky to ever settle again for the mundane.
Her nickname in the band was Stargazer, after all. One of Rainbow’s most iconic songs.
Sirius’s favourite band…
“No, I left just after you,” she replied, her smile tinged with embarrassment. “Unlike those two, you and I actually have to work…”
Danny let out a nasal laugh, the glow of the bathroom sign above them casting his pale face in shades of red.
“We don’t have to work…” he yawned, lacing his fingers behind his head. “I like helping my dad. And you… well, eventually you’re going to go back to your uncle’s place…”
Scarlett wet her lips and tucked her hands into the apron pockets, her eyes seeming to absorb all the warmth from the golden light above them — only to transform it into a chill that melted the grin off Danny’s face. And where would she go? She has no one, Remus, Sirius’s voice cracked through the walls of her mind like a whip.
“What? Is the thought of going back that revolting?” Danny asked, still casually. “I’ve got a brother, Star. I know how fights like that work…”
Just the suggestion — just thinking about Orfy’s hands around her throat — made her stomach churn violently. If she’d eaten anything, she’d be retching. But with nothing in her system, all she felt was the acid burn of bile clawing up her oesophagus. She forced herself to swallow the bitter taste and poured herself a glass of water, sipping slowly.
“You don’t understand,” she whispered, pulling the notepad from her apron and tearing out the used pages.
“No, I don’t understand. I don’t understand most things about you, to be honest.” he said, taking the bar key and heading to unlock the front door. But halfway there, he paused. “What d’you think about going for a wander in Piccadilly after shift?”
The offer made Scarlett snort in surprise, scratching her nose while she fumbled for a reply that wouldn’t sound harsh.
“What, am I too young for you?” Danny furrowed his brow, placing a hand dramatically over his chest.
“I’m ten years older than you, Daniel,” Scarlett said pointedly, his full name laced with gentle condescension. “Go find a girl your own age!”
He unlocked the door, flipped the sign to Open, and crossed his arms as he strolled back over to her. Scarlett heard her ghosts coming down the stairs that led to the bar; James, of course, was the loudest, skipping the last step with a thud. Lily had light footsteps, while Regulus moved with composed precision.
“I still can’t believe you were born in ’59 and look younger than me!” Danny returned the key to the cabinet and rested his hands on his hips. “What’s the secret?”
“Genetics.” Scarlett shrugged one shoulder, coolly, her gaze flicking sideways to catch a glimpse of her ghostly companions.
“Genetics? I’m the one with Japanese heritage here!”
“Playing keyboard helps too…” she replied deadpan, though the corner of her mouth threatened to curve into a smile.
“Guess I picked the wrong instrument, then…” he pouted. “But seriously, if you do fancy going out tonight—”
Danny stopped mid-sentence as the little bell above the door jingled, announcing the arrival of the first customer. It was Scarlett’s second week at The Hanged Man, and that sound always put her on edge for more reasons than she cared to admit. The odds of someone recognising her were low — incredibly low — but they still existed. So, the moment the bell rang, she looked at the door and carried on with her work. It had become instinct. And each time it wasn’t someone from her past, she felt her muscles loosen and her confidence grow.
Caution was never excessive. Not in her case. Not when she’d accepted such a reckless job in a bar right in the middle of London. Still… who would recognise her after all those years in Azkaban? Most of the people who’d known her were either dead… or imprisoned. Which meant… the chances were practically zero.
Even so, the person who had just stepped through the door made Scarlett drop her notepad to the floor, her heart slamming against her ribs as the colour drained from her face.
They belonged to that 1%.
They were part of her past, her present — and her future.
Scarlett didn’t flinch. She met those starry eyes with the same fierce defiance burning in her own.
.
.
.
Obscured by the buildings and the long chimneys belching smoke, the sky faded into a phosphorescent indigo hue, melting into a lighter blue just above the skyscrapers, which shyly reflected the early morning lights. The dawn had only begun to brush faint streaks of pink across the clouds.
It was still quite dark when Sirius revved up his motorbike on the near-empty streets of London. The deep growl of the engine echoed between the buildings while the cold wind whipped at his black leather jacket.
The neon façades of a few shops cast warm colours across his helmet, until he slowed and came to a stop — the image of a hanged man reflected in the polished surface of his visor.
Sirius circled the block, parking discreetly on the opposite side of the street. His bike was a Kawasaki Ninja — the queen of sport bikes. Zero to two hundred in ten seconds, entirely black from frame to exhaust, with just a few chrome details that gave it a sleek, sophisticated edge.
Unlike Nancy — which had belonged to Scarlett’s father and now resided with Hagrid — the Ninja had been his choice. He bought it with a small portion of the compensation he’d received from the Ministry. Sure, he could travel to his Auror training by Floo or Apparition, but for Merlin’s sake — he was Sirius Black. He’d spent twelve bloody years caged like an animal. All he wanted now was freedom.
Freedom… and everything that had been ripped from him by Peter and the war.
He wanted his family back.
And family, unfortunately, included Scarlett.
Sirius removed his helmet, raking a hand through his hair. He tucked his leather gloves into the pocket of his trousers and drew his wand from the nearly invisible holster strapped to his left leg. His eyes fixed on the window above the bar — first floor of the building.
“Revelio,” he intoned. A blue light swallowed the darkness of the car park before spreading and fading, revealing a thin, gleaming golden thread. Sirius extended his arm and caught it, feeling the magic thrum from his palm down to the centre of his chest.
The thread was nothing more than the visible manifestation of the barrier he’d conjured around the entire block where the bar sat. Everyone who crossed the perimeter had been Muggles. No wizards. No suspects.
His gaze followed the thread as it stretched and curved round the corner. Sirius moved his wand and imbued another protective enchantment:
“Exclusio Magus,” he murmured, and the gold shimmered with a deep violet hue. “Repulso Malintentio.”
He was learning a thing or two at Auror training.
He pulled his pocket watch free, flipping the lid open to check the time. The hands, however, were spinning wildly. Sirius pressed the button on the side, and the mechanism began a countdown. A sad smile tugged at his features. With his thumb, he brushed over the photograph glued to the inside of the golden lid — himself with Reggie on his shoulders, James holding Harry in his lap, Lily curled into her husband’s side. The three of them on the sofa. On the floor, Remus and Peter were sprawled out, pulling faces at the camera.
Sirius’s heart squeezed, but no tears came. With his wand in the other hand, he tapped it gently to the photo, casting Revelio without even uttering the word. Blue light rippled across the image like fire, engulfing it and revealing another picture underneath.
Kneeling, completely naked, Scarlett looked up at him with parted lips and a flush in her freckled cheeks.
Sirius swallowed hard and snapped the watch shut by reflex. He took a deep breath, rubbing his face with the back of his hand before pacing slowly along the block, tracing the golden thread again to ensure it was unbroken.
One could never be too careful. Especially where Scarlett was concerned…
Scarlett.
He tried so hard not to think about her that, when he inevitably did, it felt almost sinful.
Sirius lit a cigarette, drawing in a long drag as the sun pierced through the mirrored glass of the high-rises, scattering light in a thousand directions — casting long shadows across the heart of London as it stirred awake.
Exhaling smoke, he climbed the fire escape of the building opposite the bar and leaned against the red brick wall. Across the street, he spotted a girl with bleached hair and sky-coloured eyes struggling to open her window, then peering down at the street below.
When he saw her holding her own pocket watch, Sirius instinctively took his from his coat once again, running his thumb across the cold, golden lid. He took another drag, eyes never leaving her as the city buzzed beneath his feet.
Scarlett smiled, and Sirius shivered.
The smile vanished as quickly as it came, but the chill in his body lingered. Not even the cigarette could chase off that creeping sensation he got every time he saw her happy. A strange cocktail of guilt, awe, and… remorse.
She was happy without him.
Sirius should feel happy for her too. But at the same time… he felt a flicker of jealousy. A pinch of indignation. She had such an eerie ease when it came to leaving everything behind — taking on a new identity as though none of it mattered. As though he didn’t matter. As though everything they’d had… the bond that tethered them together…
He admired Scarlett’s ability to leave everything behind, while all he could do was claw at the wreckage of his past in a desperate attempt to make peace with it — just to keep going. He wished he could be detached enough to simply ignore what had happened, to live like the waitress of some crumbling pub, the keyboardist in a band that wasn’t even half as talented as she was.
Sirius lit another cigarette, but even the nicotine couldn’t hold a candle to the mere glimpse of Scarlett Gaunt.
He hated himself for it. Hated himself for everything he was doing because of her — for accepting Dumbledore’s offer, for protecting her, for staying close even after everything she’d done to him. For trying to justify her crimes, even when he knew she wasn’t telling him the whole truth.
He hated her — of course he did. That emotion was always there, festering quietly beneath the surface. He hated her impulsiveness, her cowardice, her fear.
Sirius hated Scarlett because she was his cracked reflection in the mirror. They had so much in common it felt almost cruel that she now wanted to live like he didn’t even exist. As if he would just stay away because she’d chosen to vanish and play house in some godforsaken corner of London, living a lie.
If James was his favourite person in the world, Scarlett was the only one who completed him. The one who returned his missing pieces. Who stitched together the darkest parts of his soul. Who saw him for who he was — not who he pretended to be. She was the reason for his innocence now… and his condemnation in the past.
He shut his eyes and took a slow, steady breath, then exhaled just as quietly. He gathered every last shred of courage he had and made his way down the fire escape, crossing the street soon after. A quick look to each side, then he slipped into a narrow alley.
His shadow began to distort.
A massive black dog rounded the corner, weaving silently between early commuters until it stopped beside one of the bar’s windows. Its ears perked up, listening.
“We don’t have to work…” came a man’s voice from inside. “I like helping my dad. And you… well, eventually you’re going to go back to your uncle’s place…”
There was a pause, footsteps on wooden floorboards.
“What? Is the thought of going back that revolting?” Danny asked, still casually. “I’ve got a brother, Star. I know how fights like that work…”
Padfoot huffed quietly at the nickname. Why did that bloke insist on calling her Star? It wasn’t Star. It was Scar. And the wrong nickname sounded bloody wrong — jarring, clumsy on the tongue.
“You don’t understand,” Scarlett’s voice replied at last.
Padfoot whimpered softly, his pale eyes fixed on the welcome mat by the door.
She sounded… tired. Guarded. And he hated how familiar that was.
“No, I don’t understand. I don’t understand most things about you, to be honest.” A clinking sound scraped at Padfoot’s ears. “What d’you think about going for a wander in Piccadilly after shift?”
Padfoot’s ears shot up, his jaw tightening.
“What, am I too young for you?”
“I’m ten years older than you, Daniel,” Scarlett replied, the condescension in her voice making Padfoot’s tail twitch in irritation. “Go find a girl your own age!”
What was that strange, coiling sensation twisting in his chest? Padfoot didn’t know, but he didn’t like it — at all. He looked around, then retreated into the alley again, hiding behind a rubbish bin.
Sirius stomped toward the front of the bar, opening the door with more force than necessary.
“If you do fancy going out tonight…” That idiotic pretty-boy was still going on, and Sirius clenched his fists, though his eyes didn’t even flick in Danny’s direction.
No. His gaze was locked on her.
Scarlett’s notepad slipped from her hand. Her face — her beautiful face, with perfectly curled lashes, delicate lips, and slightly upturned nose — drained of colour so quickly it was like watching a storm move in. Her skin turned the same lifeless shade it had when they’d escaped Azkaban. That dead-white pallor, tinged with grey, like her blood had frozen in her veins.
Sirius shoved his hands into his jacket pockets in a calculated motion, staring at her with the same stillness. Scarlett didn’t flinch. Her blue eyes chilled so swiftly he barely had time to register it, losing the chance to see whatever answer she might have given to Danny’s invitation.
She never was good at hiding her emotions. Every time she tried, she wore the same expression — her gaze hollowed, and her movements became mechanical.
“Good morning! Table for how many?” Danny broke the silence with a wide grin that showed his crooked teeth.
Sirius glanced at him for the briefest second before turning back to Scarlett. But she had already bent down, picked up her notepad, and walked away as if he were just any other customer.
“One,” Sirius replied with polite calm, though his teeth were grinding behind his smile.
Danny led him to a table by the window, set down a menu, and told him to call if he needed anything. Sirius’s grin twisted into something sharp and cruel as he watched the boy walk away.
He muttered a single word under his breath — and Danny promptly tripped over a chair leg and went down hard.
The very first thing Scarlett did was shoot Sirius a death glare.
He simply kept smiling, elbows on the table, chin resting in his interlocked hands, daring her with his stare.
She stormed over to help Danny, eyes wide, jaw clenched.
“Are you alright?” Scarlett reached out to help him, but Danny waved a hand in front of his face, getting up on his own.
“Yeah, just… scraped my hand.” He gave a sheepish smile, showing her the reddened skin. “I’ll put some antiseptic on and be right back… you okay handling him on your own?” He nodded toward Sirius.
“Why wouldn’t I be?” She flicked a strand of fringe out of her eyes, irritation rising with every second that smug grin stayed plastered on Sirius’s arrogant face.
“I dunno… you two are looking at each other weird…” Danny glanced back and forth between them, and Scarlett punched him in the arm.
“Ow!”
“Go deal with your hand!” she ordered, and the boy obeyed without further argument.
Scarlett turned to James and Lily, who were cackling without an ounce of shame, while Regulus shook his head in disapproval — though the amusement in his eyes betrayed him.
“What a clumsy kid…” James sang, as if Sirius were entirely innocent. Lily nodded beside him, and Regulus rolled his eyes. The three of them lounged at one of the more distant tables, and if she’d been alone, she would’ve flipped them off without hesitation.
Since she wasn’t alone, Scarlett drew in a deep breath and strode towards Sirius, gripping her notepad so tightly her hands were trembling.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 40: It’s over. That happiness, that time… it’s gone…
Chapter Text
CVIII
“What do you want?” Scarlett didn’t spare the harshness in her tone. Her blue eyes were veiled by that sharp layer of coldness she used as a defence mechanism.
Sirius wet his lips, trying to thaw the frost enough to reach the real Scarlett hidden behind all her subterfuge, but she seemed immovable. He narrowed his gaze on her, eyebrows drawn together in an incisive arc. Silver clashed with ice, each trying to pull the other into the abyss behind their narrowed pupils.
But neither Scarlett nor Sirius gave in, so he did the obvious:
“Coffee, no sugar. Pancakes with strawberries and maple syrup.” His words dripped with cynicism. Scarlett laughed.
It was a dry, hollow laugh, tinged with bitterness that made Sirius’s blood pulse with something toxic. A chill ran through him as if he were falling endlessly into the dark, bottomless wells of Scarlett’s eyes. He had never felt that kind of discomfort around her before; had never imagined a joke could make her seem so unbearable.
The Scarlett he remembered was gone, replaced by the bitter grown woman whose freezing gaze bore into him with such searing intensity that it roused his own demons, summoned by the ones inside her.
Sirius clenched his jaw, swallowing the urge to grab her by the hair, haul her onto the table and whisper in her ear exactly what he wanted. He knew all too well how to rip that fire from her—just his lips and fingers could bend her to his desires.
“What do you want from me, Sirius?” she kept the apathetic tone, lips tightening with irritation.
“Reggie’s caused trouble at Hogwarts,” he said bluntly.
“What?” Scarlett’s eyes widened, all her defences collapsing as if she hadn’t expected him to bring up Reg. “What did he do?”
“He attacked another student.” Sirius ran a hand through his rebellious hair. “Dumbledore wrote you a letter, but I… er, wanted to give it to you somewhere less... Muggle.” He cast a disparaging look toward the kitchen doors, where Danny had just walked out.
“What’s the problem?” Scarlett’s brows furrowed as she crossed her arms.
“Won’t your boyfriend find it odd, a letter from Hogwarts? Does he even know what Hogwarts is?” Sirius frowned with his usual arrogance—part sarcastic, part serious.
A laugh soaked in scorn escaped Scarlett’s lips, her face flushing with disbelief and embarrassment. Sirius drank in her reaction so intently, he wasn’t sure whether to be pleased or offended. She tilted her head to meet his eye, one hand braced on the corner of the table, the other clenched as if ready to punch him.
“You’re ridiculous!” Scarlett hissed, so close that Sirius could feel the breath of her words brushing against his beard and the taste of her mouth lingering on his lips. Her blue eyes were no longer cold; they were bubbling now, ready to scald him.
“I’ll be home after six...” Sirius murmured with his usual insufferable insolence, catching a strand of her platinum hair between his index and middle fingers, inspecting the bleached locks with a half-lidded gaze. “This colour doesn’t suit you.”
Scarlett hissed, slapping his hand away as she stepped back, the retort burning on her tongue fizzling out in her throat the moment Danny reached them.
“Everything alright over here?” he asked, eyes narrowing with suspicion.
“Perfectly,” Sirius replied with a cheeky grin, dropping a fifty-pound note on the table. “See you later.” He turned to leave, throwing a wicked look over his shoulder.
Scarlett stood silent, stunned, as she watched him exit the bar. Danny, beside her, scratched the back of his neck, glancing from her to the door, clearly waiting for an explanation. Her ghosts, seated at the other table, looked utterly gobsmacked.
“Do you know him?” the boy asked, ignoring the little bell announcing more customers arriving.
“No.” She lied, tearing the note in half and avoiding his gaze.
That was all she said to Danny before hurrying off to serve the new guests.
.
.
.
Sirius wore a triumphant smirk as he entered the Ministry of Magic, though his heart felt as if it were moments away from being fed into a meat grinder. He crossed the vast and opulent Atrium, well aware of the curious stares following him.
His nomination to complete the Auror programme had nearly caused a scandal, as if the whole thing were part of some grand conspiracy to place him inside the Ministry in order to resurrect Lord Voldemort. Absolute nonsense, but there was always some idiot who believed it—even a few fellow Aurors eyed him with thinly veiled distrust.
Not that he gave a toss. After years in Azkaban, he’d learnt not to care about most things. He tossed a Sickle into the water mirror of the fountain and headed toward the far end of the Atrium, joining the long queue for the lifts. He didn’t mind the wait, nor the nudge he felt on his shoulder.
His mind was teeming with so many thoughts that he barely registered the blonde presence beside him. For a moment, he thought it was Scarlett, but this woman was different; her hair fell to her shoulders, her jaw was square, her nose short. Immediately, she reminded him of someone else. A girl from his past with platinum hair, a face so delicate it looked like porcelain, and dazzling blue eyes.
Her name echoed in the back of his mind.
Pandora.
“Hello, Sirius Black.” The witch greeted him with an awkward smile. “Looks like you’ve advanced into my class. How are you moving through the exams so quickly?” She furrowed her brow, gripping the strap of her beige handbag.
“I’ve done the tests before,” Sirius replied, trying to place her. She didn’t feel unfamiliar, but the thought of Pandora had knocked him out of orbit.
Where the hell was she?
“June. June Alcott.” She shrugged. “Orfy’s girlfriend…”
“Oh, right.” Sirius rolled his eyes, slipping on his usual placid mask. “Still weird to think he’s old enough for that.”
June laughed, and the two stepped into the lift alongside half a dozen other witches and wizards. Sirius stared at his reflection in the gilded, ornamented grille, feeling strangely uneasy next to June.
“He likes you,” she said, fanning a memo that hovered above her head. “He spent the whole week talking about how cool you were when he was younger…”
“Were? I’m not anymore?” Sirius scrunched his nose in mock offence.
“He used to say you were the coolest boyfriend his sister ever had…” June stopped mid-sentence, her smile faltering. “I think that was the only time he ever mentioned her without it being negative.”
Sirius looked down at his boots, feeling the jolt as the lift came to a stop.
“Level Seven, Department of Magical Games and Sports,” chimed a calm, feminine voice as the doors slid open.
“She loves him,” he murmured, before clearing his throat. “Loved. I mean.”
June’s eyes shimmered with sympathy.
“I know she died,” she said softly, steadying herself on the handrail as the lift resumed its climb.
“Level Six, Department of Magical Transportation.”
The doors opened again, and a few witches and wizards disembarked as a swarm of memos flew inside. As the lift rose once more, June continued:
“You must be relieved…”
“Relieved?” Sirius’s question cut through the air so sharply it made her flinch.
“I-I mean…” she stammered, swallowing hard. “After… everything she did… betraying you, your friends… didn’t she murder an entire wizarding family?”
“Level Five, Department of International Magical Co-operation.”
Sirius’s lips pressed into a hard line, the lift’s yellowish light sharpening the silver in his eyes into a blade of steel, reflecting the seething fury that simmered just beneath.
On impulse, he stepped off, swept along with a storm of memos, and found himself in a long white corridor branching off into countless rooms. June’s voice called out after him, but it was swallowed by the sea of bustling witches and wizards in heated discussions, giving Sirius the distinct impression he’d just walked into an anthill.
He stepped to the side as a fleet of memos floated past and paused in front of the lifts, waiting for the next one. Amid the chaos, Sirius allowed himself a breath, leaning back against the wall behind him, tuning in to the scattered conversations his ears could catch, trying to drown out the accusatory voices murmuring at the back of his mind.
After everything she did…
Why was he still doing this for Scarlett? Why did he keep putting himself through it? Why…
Sirius wished he could rip her out of his chest the way the Dementors had torn his happy memories away. Maybe then he wouldn’t feel so bloody guilty for everything he’d done to her. Yes, she’d hurt him too, but if only he hadn’t let her walk away that day…
If only he’d… tried harder to make her stay, if only he hadn’t let jealousy drive his tongue and alcohol cloud his judgement…
Sirius gasped for breath, the voices around him turning to incomprehensible static. His heart pounded against his ribcage, like it was trying to smash its way out. Sweat gathered beneath his leather jacket, and his mouth went dry—he felt like he couldn’t breathe.
The what-ifs pummelled his mind one after the other, slicing down through his brain and lodging like shrapnel in his chest.
Regulus becoming a Death Eater was his fault.
Scarlett leaving…
Remus pulling away…
And James and Lily…
They were dead because of him.
Sirius Black was the reason every person he loved had ended up ruined. It didn’t matter how hard he tried to do the right thing, how much he longed to tear away the poison his parents had poured into him… the ending was always the same.
He would always end up alone.
But Sirius was stubborn. He refused to accept what fate kept handing him. He couldn’t accept it. It wasn’t fair. Life had never been fair to him—he’d spent twelve years in the hellhole of Azkaban, twelve years reliving the worst moments of his life without pause. Now that he was free, he deserved to be happy. After all the suffering, all the pain, all the bloody heartache… he deserved happiness. He needed happiness the way he needed Scarlett, or he’d collapse. His whole body tingled with that same sickening buzz he’d felt when he first heard about the wedding— Scarlett’s wedding —to Regulus.
It was like standing at the edge of a cliff, and the only thing keeping him from falling was the responsibility he had to his godsons—and the fragile, flickering hope of one day being happy again. Happy with his family. With Scarlett, with Remus, and with their boys.
Was that too much to ask?
Sirius had never been particularly religious, but in that moment, he found himself begging— begging life to go easy on him. To let him be happy. Just a little. Even if it was only scraps…
He was tired of suffering. He wished James were there to pick up his pieces, or that Scarlett would at least pretend to care. He needed someone —anyone—other than himself. He’d spent far too long alone in Azkaban and he… he…
He didn’t want to live in a world where his best friend no longer existed. Where the girl he loved had left him again. A world where his brother died a coward’s death.
What was the point of any of it? Why…
“Sirius?” A voice called to him, but he was drowning so violently in his own thoughts that he didn’t hear it.
Why did his life have to be such chaos? He just wanted peace…
“Sirius?” The voice came again, and he blinked several times, yanked from the spiral of his mind as something strange filled his lungs. He gasped, realising it was air. “Padfoot?”
Sirius looked up into the face of his best friend, at the new lines etched into his skin, the extra scars, the streaks of grey threading through the brown of his hair. Remus’s wide, dark eyes were laced with concern.
“Moony…” he murmured, swearing he was crying, even though no tears shone on his cheeks. He ran a hand over his sweaty forehead, focusing on the oxygen filling his brain and pouring past his lips. “What… what are you…”
His mind was still spinning, but now he had something to hold on to. He let Remus be the fixed point in the eye of his emotional storm.
“What are you doing here?”
Remus glanced over his shoulder at the wizards still deep in their animated discussion, oblivious to anything else.
“Dropped off my CV for… well, you know, in case they need extra help… with the Quidditch World Cup…” he faltered, rubbing the scar on his chin. “Figured they’ll be needing staff for that…”
Sirius exhaled slowly, clenching his hand over his friend’s shoulder. Ever since Remus had resigned from Hogwarts, he’d been searching for work that matched his experience. But who would hire a werewolf? Suddenly, all of Sirius’s problems felt very small.
“Want to get lunch later?” he offered, prompting Remus to raise his eyebrows slightly.
Despite the strange air between them and all the regrets of the past, he nodded.
“Er—sure. Who’s looking after Buckbeak?” Remus asked, leaning against the wall beside him as a throng of irate wizards stormed past.
“Penny,” Sirius snorted through his nose, recalling the panicked look the elf had given him when he asked her to keep an eye on the hippogriff. “Leaky Cauldron?”
“Half twelve.” Remus agreed, giving him a pat on the shoulder before spotting a very official-looking wizard in ornate robes. He quickened his pace to catch up.
Sirius badly wanted a cigarette at that moment, but the room was already too crowded and stuffy, so he simply made his way to the now-empty lift and waited as the floors ticked by, memos floating in and out until the voice finally announced:
“Level Two, Department of Magical Law Enforcement.”
He stepped out and made his way down the corridor lined with doors, turning a corner into a room full of auror hopefuls. The briefing had already begun, and the look of disapproval he received from Kingsley Shacklebolt was nothing short of withering. Sirius took the last available seat, nearest to the door, and rested his chin in his palm, not bothering to take notes like everyone else.
He spotted June’s blonde head in the front row, seated next to a woman with bubblegum-pink hair. Honestly, he wasn’t paying attention to a single word being said—nor did he need to. His skills with Memory Charms far exceeded the standard requirement. One of the few useful things his father had ever taught him.
The sudden scrape of chairs as the other trainees stood startled him. His eyes flicked to the board, spotting the date of the final tests. Some would be done in pairs—since most aurors operated with partners—but the more critical evaluations would be conducted solo.
Sirius tapped his fingers on the desk as Kingsley signalled to him. He stood and made his way down the aisle, passing by June and the pink-haired witch. The latter’s mouth opened as if she were about to say something, but it closed the moment he walked past. The two women whispered to each other and left the room.
“I’ve got something for you,” Kingsley said, handing him a folder. “It’s ultra-confidential, so I’d advise taking good care of it.” He smiled like he used to, and for a brief moment, Sirius could almost believe James, Lily, and Regulus weren’t dead, that he and Remus were still close, and that Scarlett had never left.
He shook the thought away and opened the folder carefully—only to be met with Scarlett’s glassy blue eyes staring out from a photograph taken just after her arrest. Her name was written in bold at the top, and a red CONFIDENTIAL stamp slashed diagonally across the page.
“I don’t usually ask questions, especially when it comes to a request from Dumbledore,” Kingsley said, arms folded, the candlelight glinting against his dark skin. “But… wasn’t she your ex?”
“Yeah.” Sirius sighed, voice flat with disinterest.
“Funny. That file was pulled not long ago for an active investigation…” Kingsley went on. His tone was innocent enough, but Sirius could hear the layered intent in his voice, the glimmer of meaning behind his eyes.
“Why?” Sirius asked, face unreadable—though a subtle spark of worry flickered in the silver of his eyes.
Shacklebolt shook his head.
“Something to do with her family…” he muttered, lips tightening as his gaze drifted toward the door.
“Are you done? We need you.” An auror called, and Shacklebolt gave Sirius a firm pat on the shoulder.
“You’ve got until autumn to return the documents,” he said, heading for the exit.
Sirius took a deep breath, clutching the folder to his chest as if it could somehow lessen the weight pressing down on him. With a quick Reducio, he shrank it and slipped it into his trouser pocket.
.
.
.
The Leaky Cauldron was crowded at that hour, but Sirius managed to find a booth tucked away along the wall, almost hidden. He sank into it, shrinking into himself at the sight of the threads of memory curling and weaving through the air, waiting to be tugged.
He ignored them. He couldn’t afford to lose himself in memories of a past so vivid, so faded, so… happy.
Remus found him minutes later, sliding into the seat opposite and signalling Tom for two butterbeers. Sirius greeted him with a faint smile, and they remained silent for a while—the only sounds were the murmur of distant conversations and the crackling candle between them.
“So…” Remus leaned his elbows on the table. “How’s the programme going?”
“Brilliant.” Sirius bit down on his lower lip, toying with the flame between his fingers in an effort to distract himself.
“Did you talk to her?” Remus pulled the candle out of Sirius’s reach, frowning. “About Reggie.”
Sirius scrunched up his nose and let out a low growl, more dog than man. Remus blew out the candle just as Tom arrived with two steaming mugs.
“I did,” he admitted, sipping the butterbeer and wishing it were Firewhisky.
“And?” Remus prompted, foam clinging to his moustache.
Sirius responded with a shrug, gulping down another mouthful as though he were parched—when really, he just didn’t know what to say.
“What does that mean?” Remus mirrored his shrug, visibly irritated.
“I dunno. I told her to come over later…”
“You told her?” Remus raised an eyebrow. “You should order her. She shouldn’t even be roaming free to begin with—”
“I’m not going to force her to stay locked up—”
“I’m not talking about locking her up, I’m saying… be more assertive, Sirius! It’s insane you two can’t stay in the same house! You used to barely leave the bloody bedroom!”
Sirius hissed, the smile curdling on his lips.
“We’re not those teenagers anymore,” he snapped, irritable.
“Aren’t you?” Remus dabbed the foam from his moustache with a napkin. “Because you’re both acting exactly like them…”
“I’m not…” Sirius faltered, instantly on the defensive. “I’m not—what the fuck do you want me to do?!”
Remus swirled the handle of his mug back and forth before taking another drink.
“We outgrow love, like other things
And put it in a drawer
Till it an Antique Fashion shows
Like costumes grandsires wore.” he recited, staring into his own reflection in the cloudy bottom of the mug.
Sirius frowned, narrowing his eyes.
“Are you drunk off one butterbeer?!”
“It’s a poem, you twat.” Remus curled his upper lip. “Take your bloody costume off and shove it in the drawer.”
Sirius tore off his leather jacket and flung it violently onto the bench.
“What else?”
“That’s not what I meant.”
“Remus, you’re not some bloody sphinx!” Sirius barked, downing the rest of his drink.
“You need to put whatever’s between you and Scarlett in the drawer, Padfoot,” he said, relenting as he ordered two more butterbeers. “I mean… love is fragile and perishable… it’s meant to lose value over time, not gain it. This… this love between you two…”
“Oh, Remus, believe me… I wish our love was fragile. But it’s not. It’s relentless, it’s rigid, it’s… it’s like a fucking drug.”
“Yeah, well, it shouldn’t be. Love’s not supposed to weigh you down, Padfoot. It’s not supposed to be stiff. It’s meant to free you… not trap you.”
Sirius ran a hand over his face, clearly agitated.
“It’s all I know, Remus. Her love… it’s all I know…”
“Bollocks,” Remus cut in, just as Tom dropped off the next round. “What about us? What about James?”
“Don’t say his name,” Sirius shot back, eyes darkening.
“Padfoot… Sirius… I watched you destroy yourself over this. You’re… you’re emotionally raw, Sirius. And Scarlett—she gets to you in ways you don’t even notice. I’m not saying it’s intentional, but—”
“You don’t understand, Remus.”
“Oh, don’t give me that bloody excuse again!” He sighed, his lips twisting with frustration.
“I owe her, alright? After everything I did—”
“What do you mean?”
Sirius sniffed, scratching at his nose.
“She left… Regulus died… we drifted apart… James and Lily…”
“Stop torturing yourself like this!” Remus scowled, rubbing at the scars on his face with more force than necessary. “None of that was your fault! Everything that happened—”
“But if I… if I had just—”
“Sirius—”
“If I’d just done something… but all I did was drink and—”
A desperate sob caught in his throat. Sirius let the tears fall, pushing them down his cheeks even as he wiped at his eyes with angry hands. No sound escaped, but his grief sat like lead between them.
He wished, more than anything, that his love could be as fragile as he was.
He felt like a lost, helpless boy. It was a feeling that had haunted most of his life—only dulled by the presence of his friends and Scarlett—but solitude seemed to be the one constant in his existence. What he truly wanted was to be held as often as loneliness claimed him.
“That’s why I’m telling you this, Sirius.” Remus slid closer on the built-in bench and pulled him into a hug. “If you keep bottling everything up like this, you’re going to end up taking it out on other things… on the drink… on the drugs… on love.”
Remus’s unbalanced wisdom was maddeningly unfair. And Sirius knew exactly what he meant, no matter how much he liked to bury his feelings deep in his chest and pretend everything was under control—it was a lie. He had never had control over anything, and the sooner he accepted his own helplessness, the better.
That’s why, the moment he stepped out of the Leaky Cauldron, he made his way straight to St Mungo’s.
.
.
.
The ticking of the wall clock was the only sound in the office of Healer Asca Dimitrescu, seated in a modest chair while, across from her on a sofa, Sirius Orion Black sat with his legs crossed, clad head to toe in biker leathers. She had an excellent memory and recalled perfectly the first session they had together.
The first—and last.
According to her records, he had been a seventeen-year-old boy suffering from Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder, night terrors, chronic anxiety, emotional dysregulation, and likely bipolar tendencies. After so long in Azkaban, depression was almost a certainty.
Asca adjusted the square glasses on her face. It was a bit difficult to keep writing if he remained silent.
“So… Mr Black…” she wetted her lips, tapping the end of her quill on the top of her notebook. “I received your referral from the Ministry, and you stated that many of your memories were damaged by the Dementors. The chances of recovering them are quite high, and—”
“I’m not sure I want to remember,” Sirius murmured.
His expression was carved with a kind of pride and defiance she recognised in many of her patients—but this was a Black, born and raised to the highest pure-blood standards of society. He knew how to wear his face like a weapon. A storm might’ve been raging within him, but all he showed was smugness.
“Why not?” Asca asked gently.
The question made his jaw tighten beneath his neatly trimmed beard. He ran a hand through his long black hair, which reached his elbows.
“Because it’s the good memories… that hurt the most.” His voice came out clean, clear, and precise.
Asca admired the effort it took for him to keep his walls so high, even though they were thin, brittle—ready to shatter.
“Why would they hurt?” she asked.
He swallowed slowly, rubbing his fingers incessantly over a pocket watch he held, his gaze drifting around the room until it finally settled on her.
“Because I…” His expression cracked, and he gasped, clutching the watch tightly in his palm.
“You lost people,” Asca prompted gently. “Is that why?”
Sirius’s trembling lips opened and closed a few times.
“Not just because of that.” He ran his tongue along his teeth, tilting his head from side to side as though weighing something heavy. “I was… happy. So happy that…”
Asca watched, her heart quietly aching, as the proud, composed posture melted away. He buried his head between his knees, fingers clawing into his scalp. Even though he tried to stifle it, the sobs were there—ravaging his voice and soaking his cheeks.
“It’s over. That happiness, that time… it’s gone…”
“And why does that have to hurt?”
Sirius gasped. Wasn’t it obvious?
“I’ll never see my friends again… I’ll never be happy like that again… I’ll never get the life I dreamed of…”
“And you’re sad because it ended?”
His shoulders trembled with the weight of his sobs. He lifted his head slightly, silver eyes gleaming through the curtain of black hair like stars against a night sky.
“How could I not be?” he shot back, the words edged with a morbid sarcasm.
“I think that… if something makes us grieve when it ends,” Asca said softly, offering him a handkerchief—he didn’t move to take it—“and it hurts because it can’t be relived… then it means it was truly special while it lasted.”
“The truth, Sirius, is that… everything ends. Everything dies, everything disappears. We’ll all be forgotten less than a hundred years after we’re gone. What matters—what really matters—are those memories. Those people. The ones who touched you so deeply that their absence still aches.
“That’s love, Sirius. That pain you feel is love. And it’s something good in a world full of so many awful things.
“It’s normal to fear reliving the past… but only through it can we make peace with ourselves.
“The good memories hurt… because they’re what made your life worth living. They give meaning to the suffering. They legitimise your bonds, strengthen your friendships, and make your love eternal.”
Sirius couldn’t respond. The truth was, he could barely think. There was still so much left unresolved inside his chest: Scarlett’s absence. Regulus’s death. The birth of his nephew. The birth of Harry. Remus’s distance. Wormtail’s betrayal… The murder of James and Lily. The years in Azkaban.
It was all still there—heavy, jagged, and unhealed.
It was something his mind fought hard to forget—like it was trying to scrub away the kaleidoscopic brightness of the tragedy that had become his life. But even dimmed, it cast its funereal shadows across Sirius’s eyes; his past replayed itself in flickering spectres on the walls of his memory, etched into his retinas as irrevocably as the tattoos carved into his skin.
It was a relentless task not to drown in his own pessimism, not to flagellate himself over his past mistakes, not to gnaw endlessly on the idiotic decision to suggest Peter as Secret Keeper.
And the most agonising truth of all… was having to live in a world where James Potter no longer existed.
The war had cost him everything. Back then, they were just foolish kids who truly believed they could change the world.
What a cruel delusion.
The world hadn’t just crushed them—it had buried half of them.
From his Gryffindor year, only he, Remus, and four others were still alive to that day. All the rest—all seventeen —were dead.
And it was terrifying to know how few had survived. Victory hadn’t come crowned in golden, immaculate laurels… but rather with a wreath soaked in the blood of an entire generation, pulverised so the world might be better.
Sirius would give anything to have his friends back. Anything. Even if it meant a darker world. Even if it meant Voldemort reigning. Even if innocents died by the dozens in the streets.
He just wanted…
He just wanted that time back.
The time when happiness wasn’t stitched through with guilt or grief. When love intoxicated him and numbed him with the frivolities of life…
When the only thing he had to worry about was crafting the perfect proposal for Scarlett.
.
.
.
“I wonder what Reggie did,” Lily murmured, resting her cheek against the window glass, watching Regulus through the rear-view mirror.
Though Red acted as if he barely knew his son, the time she’d spent at Hogwarts watching him from a distance had been enough to unravel the boy of fifteen who reminded her so much of his brother. Reggie had inherited many of Sirius’s traits—the way he flipped his black hair back, the arrogant tilt of his gaze, the dimpled smirk that made the girls swoon.
Like Sirius, he was proud, impulsive, and daring. But he was also headstrong, determined, and wild as fire—just like his mother. Scarlett’s legacy lived not only in the blue of his eyes, the shape of his nose, or the freckles across his face. Reggie was a Black of the Signet.
Everything Orion had ever dreamed of—even before he and Sirius were born—was embodied in that boy. That was why their father had always spared Sirius from the arranged marriages. That was why…
Regulus clenched his jaw, fists tightening, eyes squeezed shut as if trying to dam the tide threatening to drag him back toward the truth of his crimes.
Reggie Black had absolutely nothing of Regulus Black in him.
Yes, they might look alike—especially with Reggie’s haircut—but their resemblance came from the simple fact that he was Sirius’s son. And Red and Sirius were so alike.
Though no one knew the truth about the boy’s paternity, it was still a bitter thing to witness—the sheer devotion that glowed in Reggie’s eyes every time Sirius was mentioned. That fierce, radiant affection was humbling.
Regulus had named Sirius godfather to Reggie because he knew—even after all the shit between them, even knowing that the boy was his and Scarlett’s—Sirius would care for him in the way they had never been cared for. With love, tenderness, and respect.
Sirius… was better than him. Always had been. And he’d gone above and beyond. Because Reggie had a gentleness and a sensitivity that neither of them had ever been taught to nurture. He was a quiet boy, yes—sometimes withdrawn—but he cared deeply for the people he loved. And unlike Red, he tried to protect them. Just like Sirius did.
Reg would never be his son. And Sirius… Sirius was always excellent at stealing everything that should have belonged to him. Orion’s favour. Scarlett’s love. Reggie’s fatherhood.
That had always been his burden—to live in his brother’s shadow. Even in death, he remained exactly where their parents had placed him. It was ingrained so deeply in Red’s being that he couldn’t rise above it. He couldn’t claim the title of heir, nor settle into the place of a spare. He belonged to neither.
Regulus was a pariah. And in trying to carve out a space for himself in the world, he stole everything that had been Sirius’s—his name, his woman, and his child. He thought that would make him happy, because Sirius had been happy. And he wanted that happiness. Even if it meant destroying his brother.
The most ironic part of all?
Red had never been happy. He didn’t know what it was—not truly. He had never known the sound of those melodic laughs Sirius shared with his friends. Never moved with that carefree swagger down the corridors, hand in hand with Scarlett. Never felt the devotion they carried in their gaze for one another.
He had taken it all… and still never had what truly mattered.
And Scarlett… he had thought she might be his light at the end of the tunnel, that she could teach him what that elusive kind of love was—the one everyone else seemed to give so easily, so freely. But the love she gave him… it wasn’t what he longed for. It wasn’t the love she gave to Sirius.
He was dead, and he was still coveting everything that belonged to his brother.
At least Sirius didn’t know that Reg was his son.
At least in that —he had won.
He exhaled slowly, lips stained with a wan, bitter smile. His gaze drifted sideways to James, who was casually reading a Muggle motorcycle magazine. They were in the backseat—initially, the car only had front seats; but he, James, and Lily had combined their charmwork to expand the interior and add compartments like the back row. From the outside, they didn’t show up at all, and there was an anti-Muggle barrier in case Scarlett ever felt like giving the idiots in her band a lift.
“Red?” Lily called him again, her green eyes gently coaxing his thoughts back to the surface. He simply raised an eyebrow, as if weighing everything he’d already unravelled in his own head.
If Reggie was in trouble, odds were it would be over something Sirius would’ve gotten into as well. But Red would never admit that—he couldn’t bear the idea that his brother would steal that role too.
“I don’t know,” he muttered with boredom, shifting his gaze to the window. The amber streetlights blinked past in a quick rhythm, casting a fleeting warmth across his pale face—though it wasn’t nearly enough to thaw the ice that had overtaken his heart.
Scarlett pulled up in front of Sirius’s house, but didn’t step out. She tapped her fingers on the steering wheel, the blue of her eyes rippling with hesitation. Then, taking a deep breath, she opened the door and got out, gesturing for them to stay in the car.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 41: Part of her still hoped that she and Sirius might find their way back to each other.
Chapter Text
CIX
In front of the door, Scarlett remained still for a moment. Her hand trembled over the doorbell. She glanced over her shoulder, making sure her ghosts were in the car, and drew a deep breath, trying to gather every last shard of courage she could find.
She pressed the button with her sweaty index finger, hearing the ding-dong echo from inside. Adjusting the bag she held in the other hand, she rubbed incessantly at the Ouroboros beneath her jacket sleeve.
Penny answered the door, her bulging eyes scanning Scarlett with distrust. A faint smile tightened Scarlett’s lips, but the elf didn’t lower her guard.
“Come in, Mistress Black.” She stepped back, making room for her to pass. “Master Black is in the sitting room.”
Scarlett merely nodded, noticing Sirius’s leather jacket hanging in the vestibule, and left hers there as well. She stepped further in, struck by the scent that unfurled her memories, flooding her with that pungent feeling of nostalgia, of safety… and of happiness.
The good moments whispered at the nape of her neck, begging to be remembered, but Scarlett shoved them away as she strode purposefully towards the sitting room. Sirius was seated in the armchair, a folder in his lap and a parchment floating at his right, with a quill scribbling frantically over it. He wore a white dress shirt, the same black leather trousers and the pair of boots he’d had on at the bar that morning.
He lifted his face and met her gaze without blinking. His long hair was tied back in a poorly done bun. Black strands framed his pale, angular face, aristocratic features softened by smooth skin. Even after Azkaban, Sirius Black managed to be effortlessly handsome. His tattooed fingers, adorned with rings, leafed through the folder, but he didn’t take his eyes off her.
Scarlett bit her lower lip and forced herself to take another step, offering him the bag she carried.
He didn’t move a single inch.
“Penny.” He called the elf, who took the bag and headed for the kitchen, leaving them alone. “Sit.” He commanded, his voice entirely devoid of emotion.
As much as Scarlett didn’t want to obey — the indifference in Sirius’s tone struck her harder than she’d like to admit — she chose to sit on the sofa beside him, tearing her gaze away from his grey eyes as she pretended to look at the photographs on the table.
There was something strange burrowing a crooked path through her chest. Something Scarlett had kept buried for so long, she could no longer remember what it was. She had felt like this with Sirius before — uncomfortable and intimidated. The occasion wasn’t so distant…
Ah, yes. It had been the day they’d fought and she’d gone after Regulus.
She dug her nails into the Ouroboros, forcing herself to flee from the memory.
“Who killed my father? Was it you or Dimitri?” Sirius broke her train of thought, asking the question with unnerving ease.
Scarlett straightened, lifting her chin with insolence as she stared at him.
“I thought you knew. Said your mother told you the truth.” She replied, hoping to jab at him.
Sirius, however, remained calm. Infuriatingly calm.
“That’s the problem, she didn’t tell me who killed him and I didn’t care to ask. But… in the Ministry’s investigation, you and he are the suspects. It slipped my mind… that he was a Death Eater too… that he was at Grimmauld Place when Regulus and Orion died.” His voice lowered with each word. He looked at her with a piercing, resolute stare.
Scarlett clenched her fists tightly, nostrils flaring as her face grew hot. She wasn’t here to talk about Dimitri or Orion.
“You don’t know what happened that day.” She ground her jaw, eyes drifting to the rug.
“What happened?” Sirius shot back instantly.
She rubbed at her temples, summoning that fateful afternoon in her mind: blood, tapestry, Walburga. She couldn’t piece it all together—only latch onto scattered fragments.
“I remember wanting to die,” she breathed out, long and slow, trying to gather her thoughts. Her confession made the floating quill stop scribbling; the parchment dropped onto the table. Sirius remained motionless. “I got this… letter. From Regulus, telling me he was dead.” Her eyes welled with tears, but Scarlett swallowed them back. “Dimitri came to get me. Your father didn’t let me go, so… he killed him.”
“And you killed Dimitri.” Sirius concluded in a dark tone. Scarlett nodded, vacant. “How?”
“Your mother gave me her wand.” She swallowed thickly, a knot forming in her throat.
“That’s how you came to me? Because of the wand? You Apparated…”
“I didn’t Apparate,” Scarlett cut him off. “Kreacher had my multi-portkey. Regulus left it with him so that… so that I couldn’t run.”
Sirius frowned.
“So that you couldn’t run? Why would you run? Orfy was a hostage, wasn’t he?”
A sharp, breathy laugh escaped Scarlett’s lips. It held no humour.
“Why do you think I would run, Sirius?” Her voice cracked as she spoke his name.
He clenched his fists, tilting his head back as though Scarlett had just slapped him, blinking rapidly.
“Running from Voldemort?” Although it was a rhetorical question, Sirius desperately wanted Scarlett to answer. She only lowered her gaze, retreating into herself as she wrapped her arms around her body.
Sirius shook his head, pressed his lips into a line and scratched at the beard on his chin. He opened his mouth as if to say something, then seemed to change his mind. They fell into silence. There was so much to be said, yet neither of them knew how to begin. He shifted uncomfortably in the armchair, making it creak.
“What did you feel when you killed Dimitri?”
Scarlett raised her eyes to Sirius, carefully untangling the opalescent threads of that cursed day. The reply was already on the tip of her tongue:
“Nothing.”
He arched a brow with arrogance.
“Not even satisfaction? Revenge fulfilled? Nothing?” Although he sounded sceptical, there was unease behind his words too.
Scarlett shook her head, still unsure of what to say, allowing the truth to flow unfiltered.
“Would you feel satisfaction crushing a cockroach under your boot? That’s exactly what I felt.” She forced a tired smile. “He was a nemesis to me, but when I killed him… he was nothing. Not even the dust beneath my feet. Killing him was just… ridding the world of his rotten existence. But no, I didn’t enjoy it. I felt nothing.” She gave a slight shrug. “The weight I once gave him… to what he did to me… it didn’t exist anymore. He died like the insignificant worm he was.”
Sirius ran a hand through his hair, taking in her words. Scarlett couldn’t even recall Dimitri’s face anymore — he’d become nothing more than a shadow from a past that no longer mattered.
“You did all that while bleeding?” His question was laced with hesitation and tinged with guilt.
“And in labour, yes.” Scarlett watched, detached, as the silver in Sirius’s eyes boiled over, evaporating into a stormy grey. As though he was trying to picture what she’d endured.
Scarlett lowered her gaze. There was a reason she didn’t remember her time at Grimmauld Place in detail. The trauma had been so intense that her mind had built colossal walls to seal those memories away, marking them with a bright red warning: danger.
Penny brought them tea. Not even the pleasant scent of jasmine managed to ease Scarlett’s state of alert. Her eyes immediately darted to the garden windows at the sound of movement outside. She spotted Buckbeak playing with a leather ball, nudging it with the plume on his head.
“Scar…” Sirius called her, his voice taut. “What were you going to say to me the day of the hearing?”
Scarlett held her left ring finger, seeking the comfort her wedding band once provided — but it wasn’t there. She pressed her lips together and shook her head, debating whether to tell the truth.
And where would she go? She has no one, Remus.
“Nothing,” she muttered flatly. “It was nothing.”
Sirius let out a bitter snort of laughter.
“Why are you lying?”
“Why would I tell the truth? I’ve got no one anyway.” Scarlett snapped, her words lashing out like a whip.
Sirius’s face twisted in surprise.
“You heard our conversation. Of course you did,” he said more to himself than to her. “Look, Scarlett, I don’t know what Remus said to you during your argument…”
You could spend another hundred years in Azkaban, Scarlett, and you still wouldn’t deserve him!
She flinched.
“…but we’re a family. You just left… went after Orfy and…”
“We’re not a family.” Scarlett cut him off, emotion spilling out in tears. “You, Remus and Orfy… you made that perfectly clear.”
“I never said that…”
“You didn’t have to.”
“Why are you angry at me? I’m the one who should be angry! I got back from the Ministry and you were gone. I thought something had happened, then I find out you turned up at your uncle’s house and next thing I know, I find you in a pub like everything’s bloody fine!”
Scarlett’s body burned with rage, her tendons tensed, nostrils flared.
“Where else was I supposed to go?!” She stood, tears blurring her vision. “You made it very clear to Remus that I had no one, and he made bloody sure to remind me that this isn’t my home and never will be!” she shouted, breath catching painfully in her throat. “And Orfy… he…” She shook her head, trying to chase away the words about her brother. “You all hate me, you blame me, you judge me — why would I stay?!”
Sirius stood too, stunned flashes breaking through the stormy grey of his eyes.
“I don’t… I don’t hate you,” he murmured, holding her gaze, his voice thick with anguish.
“No?” Scarlett’s lips twisted into a bitter smile. “Then you’re a liar. Because you’ve told me you hate me more than once!”
Sirius wetted his lips, his placid mask threatening to crack under the weight of her truth.
“I…” Sirius faltered, feeling like a boy caught doing something wrong. He hated Scarlett for making him feel this way; she still held too much power over him.
Sirius Black exhaled deeply. He wished he could love as fiercely as he could hate.
Scarlett wiped the tears from her cheeks quickly, as though unwilling to show she’d been crying. Their eyes found each other, and Sirius cursed the pathetic flicker of pleading he knew was visible in his gaze.
“I don’t hate you, I…” Sirius’s lower lip trembled. “I hate what you did to me. I hate the way you… make me feel… vulnerable. Trapped. Defenceless.”
Scarlett’s heart was pounding so hard she feared he could hear it. She was caught completely off guard, unsure of what to say as hope began to take root in her chest. Sirius made her feel the same way, and it was terrifying to know he would always be her weakness. That the hole in her chest named Sirius Black would always make her feel exposed, awakening the longing to make every hidden yearning real. To make the idea of having a family feel… tangible. But even the suggestion of happiness made Scarlett step back. She wasn’t worthy of that. She wasn’t worthy of any of it.
“It’s all right to hate me. I hate myself too,” she confessed, her voice thick with tears. “I just…”
“I don’t hate you.” Sirius stepped forward but stopped abruptly halfway, as though going any further would be too dangerous. It was Scarlett Gaunt in front of him, and he knew that the moment he touched her, he wouldn’t be able to stop. He never could with her. “I just… I hate… what we did to each other.”
Scarlett nodded faintly.
“So do I.” She drew inward, brushing away the tears as she stared at the floor. “I know you’ll never forgive me, but… I keep hoping you will.” The anger had vanished from her face, leaving only sorrow behind. “Can you forgive me?”
Sirius collapsed into the armchair, new and old emotions warring for control in his chest as he focused on breathing — just breathing. The rancid, festering vortex of the past clashing violently with the breezy, matured whirlwind of the present.
He wanted more than anything to say he forgave her — but the truth was, he didn’t. He couldn’t. If not for Scarlett’s reckless choices, they’d be married by now, probably with Reggie and more children, with James and Lily still alive, living a sweet and quiet life.
“I always wanted our son to be named Sirius.” His words barely made it out, more breath than voice. “But you gave my name to his son. To your son with him .” He swallowed slowly, unlocking the cage of bitterness inside his chest. “I knew you were vengeful, Scarlett. But cruel? Why? You knew that… that was my dream. My dream. And you and Regulus stole it from me…”
She narrowed her eyes, as if Sirius’s irises really were stars — burning so brightly they were blinding her.
“Because…” Scarlett began to speak, her body trembling. For a moment, Sirius was certain she was about to break down in tears, but she swallowed it the instant she opened her mouth again to continue. “Because…”
The words rose in her throat. Because he’s your son — your idiot, stupid, thick-headed fool… Georgy Porgy!, she tried to say, but the words burst like bubbles all at once, collapsing into a deafening silence and stealing the air from her lungs. Her eyes widened in panic as the pact tore violently through her body. Something warm ran from her nose, the magic amplifying the pressure in her skull, choking her all at once.
“Scarlett?” Sirius called her name, but she didn’t hear.
Scarlett made a strangled sound, trying to breathe, clinging to consciousness with the same desperation with which she longed to tell Sirius the truth. But her body gave out. Her eyes rolled back until only white showed, and her limbs began to convulse uncontrollably.
Sirius threw himself to the floor at once, panic overtaking his body the moment he grabbed her. Desperate tears blurred his vision, and for a terrifying second, Scarlett’s face became James’s. His heart stopped. His blood froze. His bones shattered.
“No, no, no, no…” Sirius repeated, the cold invading him with brutal force. “No, no, please, no…” He lowered his face, burying it in the lifeless chest of James. Holding him tightly, as if he could give back a breath of life, as if he could…
The sound of a heartbeat pulled him out of his daze. Sirius squeezed his eyes shut, drowning in the scent of vanilla rising from the bleached hair matted against his cheeks. The one in his arms wasn’t James. It was Scarlett.
“Penny… Penny… PENNY!” he screamed, having no idea what to do.
The elf appeared with a snap, her eyes doubling in size at the sight before her.
“Do something!” Though it sounded like a command, Sirius was begging.
Without hesitation, Penny reached forward with two fingers, grasping something invisible and yanking it violently backward. Scarlett jolted in his arms, then went still, her breathing laboured. The house-elf remained focused on what she held, examining it closely. Then she turned to Sirius, her expression solemn.
“Mistress Black bears a debt…” she revealed, her tone oblique. “A pact.”
Sirius could barely think, the desperation seeping into every last layer of his self-control. He stared at Scarlett’s pallid face, blood trickling from her nose and staining her dark shirt, her throat expanding in a desperate effort to make space for oxygen to return to her brain. He checked that she was stable, until Penny’s words finally sank in.
“What?” His voice came out as little more than a breathless whisper, his fingers gripping the sleeve of Scarlett’s shirt so tightly they were nearly tearing the fabric.
“It’s a dangerous spell, Master Black — one that prevents her from revealing information. A blood pact.” Penny’s eyes remained fixed on the invisible.
It took a long moment for the information to settle in his mind.
“A blood pact?” Sirius focused on slowing his breath, inhaling deeply and releasing it slowly. “How do you know that?”
The small figure stepped closer, offering him a napkin to clean the blood from Scarlett’s nose. Sirius took it with a trembling hand, heart pounding in his ears.
“Penny can see it.” She stretched her lips into an enigmatic smile. “Penny knows that Master and Mistress Black have a blood pact too.”
Sirius sniffed, too shaken by what had just happened to process what the elf was saying.
“What are you talking about, Penny?” he murmured, drained. His body shivered with chills that made his stomach turn.
“A pact sealed with blood and promises,” she went on. “Penny can see the cords that bind one to the other. Love… domination… devotion. You share a bond woven in the past.”
“That’s impossible… we never made… a pact.” Sirius spoke between breaths, the air growing thinner with every word. “That’s dark magic.”
“It is not dark magic,” Penny corrected him, her tone free of any reproach. “Pacts are made willingly. Yours… and the other one she bears, both were.”
“Why…” He didn’t understand. His eyes roamed back to Scarlett in his arms, her face so serene it was hard to believe she’d been seizing just minutes before. “I don’t…”
“Penny can see the magic, Master Black. Your bond is powerful, fed by suffering and love. But the other… the other was forged in fear. In love too, but there is more fear than love.” Her voice grew sombre. “That is why Penny does not trust Mistress Black. She hides secrets she cannot reveal. Secrets woven with the blood of your blood.”
Sirius blinked several times, his mind reeling, waves of emotion crashing violently inside him.
“Blood of my blood? My entire family’s dead. If… if this really is a pact, then how…” He stammered, trying to put it all together. “Why can’t she speak?”
“A pact is a contract, Master Black. Depending on its clauses, the debt doesn’t dissolve with the death of one of the parties,” Penny explained. “Usually, pacts kill those who try to break them. Mistress Black was lucky…”
Sirius shook his head, distancing himself from all of it as he gently laid Scarlett on the sofa, kneeling beside her. He didn’t care about luck or misfortune, didn’t want to hear about pacts or deaths or the past — he just wanted to be sure she was all right, that the voices in his head would finally quiet.
“Thank you, Penny. You’re dismissed for tonight.”
“But sir…”
“If anything happens, I’ll call you.” Sirius cut her off, resolute.
She vanished with a snap, the same way she had appeared.
Filling his lungs with air, Sirius rested his ear against Scarlett’s chest, just as he had done with James on Halloween night. He closed his eyes, focusing on the life inside her — on her heart beating steady and strong, on her ragged breathing, on the warmth of her skin. He lifted his gaze to her face, and though pale, it was not stained by the lifelessness James’s had been. Her eyes were shut, her eyelids twitching, her lips moving faintly.
Sirius tightened his hold around Scarlett possessively, pushing away the memory of cradling James, clinging to the precious rhythm pulsing beneath her skin. Letting his own heartbeat fall into resonance with hers, poisoning himself with the intoxicating sensation only that woman could ever bring him.
“I like listening to your heartbeat,” Sirius whispered, gently tucking the platinum strands away from her cheeks, not daring to lift his face. “It’s like… like I can touch your soul.”
The panic had faded, leaving only the inexplicable urge to protect that woman with every fibre of his being. To make her happy. To turn all her dreams into reality. And so he stayed there, lying beside her, guarding Scarlett as though she were something very, very precious.
.
.
.
“What do you think Sirius is going to do if he finds out the child is his?” Regulus asked, straightening like a bird of prey. “If the Dark Lord finds out? He’ll kill your child, just to put one of his own inside you.” His venomous lips neared her ear. “If the child is mine… he won’t. He’ll be safe.”
The iron in Regulus’s eyes — so cold and unyielding — bore into her with brutal intensity. Scarlett felt she was about to vomit, her body soaked in sweat and trembling. Red’s merciless, rigid face turned translucent, fading slowly — until it gave way to a boy with bright eyes and golden hair.
Maurie.
When Scarlett had first met him, he’d been a cheerful, playful child who reminded her of Orfeu. Back then, the thought had been painful — but now, in the shadows of the McKinnon house, Maurice no longer wore his dazzling smile. The radiant light that had once seemed woven into him had vanished.
No.
In that moment, Maurice McKinnon was sobbing uncontrollably as Johann Travers yanked him by the collar, his parents’ screams echoing desperately around them. Scarlett held her breath. She had the distinct feeling that if she moved, she would vomit at her own feet.
What was she doing?
Her hand slipped, slowly, down to her belly. Angus and Elspeth were pleading for their son’s life. He was just a child.
A tremor rippled through Scarlett’s body. He was the same age as Orfy. She fought off the nausea, focusing only on keeping her wand steady — on ignoring the terrified look Maurie shot her way.
“Do the honours, Scar,” Dimitri whispered, his lips near her cheek. Scarlett turned her face away in revulsion.
The truth was, Scarlett hadn’t expected the entire family to be home after the death of Marlene’s uncle. She wasn’t prepared to kill so many people — even if it meant protecting Orfeu and her unborn child.
“What’s wrong? Changed your mind?”
“The first time’s always the hardest, Gaunt,” Travers said, shoving Maurie roughly to the ground, a sadistic grin stretching across his face. “Though… if the rumours are true…”
“What’s with the hesitation? You’re the one who brought us here, Scar,” Dimitri circled her like a predator.
“Shut up,” she hissed, jaw tight. Too much was at stake. “I don’t know how the Dark Lord allowed a repulsive werewolf like you to join us.”
Johann frowned, clearly surprised, and Dimitri shot her a murderous look, seething with outrage.
“Listen here, you filthy bitch—” He lunged at her, but Travers held him back.
“Focus on the mission, Rustov!” the Death Eater barked, shoving him away.
It was just enough time for Scarlett to glance at the McKinnons, her heart shattering under the weight of the desperation that had wrapped itself around them.
“Traitor!” Elspeth screamed. In Scarlett’s memory, Mrs McKinnon’s face was nothing but a blur. “We opened our home to you…”
“Mummy, I don’t want to die…” Maurie whimpered, face buried in his hands. “I don’t want to die…”
“Come on, Gaunt, we don’t have time!” Johann yanked Maurie toward him abruptly. The boy curled into a ball, as if that could somehow shield him from death.
“Marlene knows, so she has to die,” Regulus’s voice echoed in her mind. “Use it to prove your loyalty.”
“Every time you kill… a part of you dies too,” Now it was her cousin Aether’s voice. “It’s like a crack that will stay open in your soul forever.”
The figures melted like mist in the wind, clearing space for a faceless, voiceless, formless woman who rose before Scarlett, one hand facing downward, the other turned upward.
“One life for one life,” the words came from everywhere and nowhere all at once. “Have you come to bargain, dancer of eternity? How many souls do you carry with you?”
Scarlett awoke thrashing violently, as if something were burning her whole body — especially her left arm. She gasped for air, trembling as she exhaled everything through her mouth when something held her still.
No — not something. Someone.
“It’s all right, it’s all right, it’s all right…” Sirius murmured in a voice that was almost hypnotic. “It was just a nightmare…”
Scarlett collapsed into Sirius’s chest like a ship lost at sea, burying her face into the collar of his white T-shirt as if she no longer needed to breathe, his tattooed arms pulling her close to assure her that she was safe.
But she felt anything but safe.
“Sirius, I… I need to go,” she stammered, still dazed and trying to push him away — but Sirius refused to let her go.
“No.” His voice was gentle. But firm. “You’re in no condition to drive…”
“Please, Sirius, please…”
Scarlett needed to leave. She needed to slam her head against the wall the way she had in Azkaban, just to forget what she’d done — what she’d had to do — to protect Orfy and Reggie. She needed to…
“What were you dreaming about?” he pressed. “Was it the McKinnons?”
The emotions she had drowned now came pouring out. But not in tears like earlier. Her entire body seized up, and Scarlett felt horribly suffocated. Even though she was breathing relentlessly, it was as if the air refused to reach her brain. She told herself she did what she had to do, that she had done it to protect — but at the same time…
“Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey…” Sirius cupped her chin, lifting it until her gaze locked with that sea of silver she knew so well. She was pulled in aggressively, consumed by the vastness of those irises, letting herself sink into her warped reflection within the darkness of Sirius’s pupils. “You’re okay. Just breathe… just breathe…”
Scarlett gripped a fistful of her own hair and yanked hard, though the burning on her scalp didn’t come close to matching the pain boiling in her heart. She gave in again, pressing her forehead to Sirius’s… wanting to tell him so much, but not a single word left her lips.
In that moment, Scarlett Gaunt realised she was broken in a way that could never be fixed. Not even the man named after a star could manage it. And still, she clung to him as if he weren’t moments away from obliterating her with his light, his heat, his suffocating presence.
She didn’t know when or how her heart had stopped trying to leap out of her chest, or when Sirius had stopped her from biting her own leg, or when oxygen had finally stopped playing hard to get.
All Scarlett knew was that she was on the sofa, lying against Sirius’s chest, with some random programme flickering on the telly. She could hear the gallop of his heartbeat, her own ragged breath, and feel his ring-clad fingers combing through her hair.
The sensation that everything was finally okay surged through her — along with her dinner. She shot upright, hand clamped over her mouth. Sirius stared at her, startled, trying to ask what was wrong, but then Scarlett darted to the bathroom, slammed the door, and threw up.
What was wrong? Scarlett planted a hand on the sink and looked into the mirror.
There it was. The mistake. Right in front of her. The woman staring back.
She rinsed her mouth and tried to organise her thoughts, but her head was far too tired. All she felt was a dull, confusing throb behind her eyes.
She caught a glimpse of her stupid, bleached strand of hair. It didn’t matter what shade she dyed it, or whether she layered or teased it like a rock star. Her hair would still be her hair.
She would still be herself.
She turned away from her reflection, raised her wand and darkened her hair back to its natural reddish-brown. The gesture made her feel utterly foolish — to think she could leave everything behind. She wanted to punch herself for being so naïve.
Scarlett left the bathroom without any real purpose, simply wandering dazed through the living room.
“Scar…” The concern in Sirius’s eyes only made her nausea worse. “Are you all right?”
Scarlett deflated, sinking down onto the armrest beside him.
“I don’t know,” she admitted lethargically.
Sirius’s lips pressed into a thin, serious line.
“You fainted.” There was truth in his words — truth and omission. Scarlett noticed, but didn’t want to unravel that thread. Not now.
“I need to go…” Scarlett reached for the car keys on the table. “We’ll talk later about… about Reg…”
“Why did you dye your hair?” Sirius cut in, the television’s glow dancing across his pale face.
It took Scarlett a moment to understand the question. Even longer to come up with an answer.
“No matter what I do… I’ll still be me.” Her voice cracked, but she didn’t cry. She didn’t want to cry. She was tired of crying.
“What’s wrong with that? I like you.” He ran his tattooed fingers across the back of her hand, leaving a warm trail that sent a shiver through her entire body.
“Sirius…” Scarlett shook her head, trying to dismiss what she’d just heard as she pulled her hand away abruptly, hugging it to her chest.
He sighed and left the sofa, as if something had come to mind — but then a song began playing on the television, and he froze in place as though he’d just been hit with a Full Body-Bind Curse.
“Come on, dance with me.” Sirius immediately reached out his hand to her. She responded with a grimace, so he leaned in and grabbed her hand anyway. “It’s Fleetwood Mac!”
“I need to go…” Scarlett mumbled, but Sirius snatched the car key from her and tossed it onto the coffee table.
“Come on…” He nudged her knee, a determined smile playing on his lips. “Dance with me… the song’s short.”
Scarlett stared at him, and for a moment, they just looked at each other — one holding the other’s gaze. The silver in his eyes was tinted now with something deeper, gentler, indulgent. Sirius tugged her to her feet, pulling her from the sofa and toward him. Scarlett instinctively wrapped her arms around his waist, and his smile widened as he laced his fingers through hers.
Reluctantly, Scarlett squeezed Sirius’s hand back, overwhelmed by the strange sensation of their fingers fitting so perfectly — as if they were meant to.
She lifted her eyes to Sirius, watching as his long, sleek black hair framed his striking aristocratic features. Guilt settled in her chest, gnawing at her insides, leaving a bitter taste in her mouth. What was she doing?
She didn’t have time to figure it out. Sirius had already begun to lead her through the limited space of the sitting room, and she had little choice but to let herself be carried along by the man with the name — and the eyes — of a star.
Sirius had that infuriating ability to be the antidote to her most sordid feelings, because it only took one stupid dance for her to rest her head against his chest, silencing the demons that waited patiently in the shadows of her mind, ravenous to drag her back into hell.
But something more than his presence kept them at bay. It was something sublime, warm, and graceful. It made her heart race, sent a pleasant tingling through her palms, stirred the butterflies in her stomach. The same sensation that swept over her the moment she stepped into the house, that shook her when she hugged Reggie for the first time. That intimidated her whenever Sirius held her with such gentleness and awe.
There was something else there, too. Twined with fear and guilt — but the fleeting glimpse of happiness was enough to set love free from those feelings, if only for a few seconds. Scarlett gasped, tears shimmering in her eyes. And then hatred surged forth, shoving the love away and shattering the image of Sirius reflected in her gaze.
She hated him for having the power to make her long for happiness, to make her want a family with him, to dream of a life they could’ve had before the war tore it all apart.
Above all, Sirius Black had the power to reduce her self-control to dust.
He made her feel like she wasn’t a killer or a criminal.
Scarlett hated him for making her feel human — not the monster she had come to believe she was. She didn’t even consider herself a person. She couldn’t gather the shattered pieces of herself off the floor, but Sirius… fuck, Sirius not only picked them up — he tried to fit them back together as if to remind her there was still a version of herself that wasn’t so loathsome.
The cracks would always be there, no matter how many times he fitted them into place.
And more and more, Scarlett was breaking into smaller pieces — sharper, more misshapen. There would come a time when Sirius wouldn’t be able to piece her back together at all.
She didn’t want to feel hope, or happiness, or love — but with Sirius, it was always like this.
He dragged to the surface everything she tried so hard to bury, everything she thought she didn’t deserve to feel. And it was so bloody difficult to suppress it all when, in his arms, what she wanted more than anything was to believe they could have a future. Even knowing it was a sweet illusion, Scarlett bathed in the idea of having the heart of the brightest star in the sky entirely for herself.
“I love you.” Sirius spoke the three forbidden words. “I love you, Scarlett.”
The declaration struck a raw, lacerating fear deep within her core. Scarlett gasped, unable to believe what she’d just heard, her instincts scrambling to erect an impenetrable wall between them. Yet, even so, she hesitated… daring to believe that, somehow, her prayers might finally be answered.
“Even… after everything?” The question slipped from her lips and landed against the fabric of Sirius’s T-shirt. Scarlett looked up at him, searching his gaze for truth. And when she found it, all her walls crumbled into ashes, the silver of his eyes catalysing every emotion surging in her chest.
“Even after everything.” He swallowed thickly, his eyes glistening. “Even after everything,” he repeated, voice trembling.
Scarlett wanted nothing more than to surrender to the promise his silence had woven, the vow sealed by their locked gazes. She wanted to believe in the dreadful possibility of happiness.
Happiness with Sirius.
But she’d made that mistake before. And as stubborn as she was, fear smothered hope, remorse devoured joy, and love drowned beneath the weight of guilt. What followed her mistake had been a chain of tragedies — both of them in Azkaban, James, Lily, and Regulus dead, and Remus left alone.
The dance was over.
She couldn’t let Sirius make her feel this way. She couldn’t be worthy of him. Worthy of love. Worthy of happiness — even if only in fragments, even if it was just a utopian idea that one day, maybe, they could be happy.
It was too much. It was all too much.
Scarlett pulled away, terror creeping into every pore, her heart thudding in panicked bursts. She had to get out. She couldn’t look at Sirius anymore. Or be with him.
In truth, she couldn’t even bear to be with herself — but she had no control over that.
She did, however, have control over Sirius.
And so, from some place buried deep within her, she summoned the strength to resist the overwhelming urge to stay.
She forced herself to grab the car keys.
“I… I have to go,” she stammered, ears ringing as if she'd just gone deaf, vision blurred from tears. She barely recognised her own voice. It felt like it belonged to someone else entirely.
Scarlett Gaunt was afraid of love.
She clutched her chest, heart skipping violently as the world tilted around her. She began to run, stumbling but not stopping — fleeing from happiness, from love, from Sirius. She opened the front door, the streetlights outside blinding her like stage spotlights.
Scarlett didn’t need to be imprisoned to be punished.
And yet, part of her still hoped that she and Sirius might find their way back to each other.
She had wanted to say it — to say she loved him too.
But she was a hypocrite, ambivalent and dissonant. Three words that defined her well: a girl unable to let go of the past because it had been both the best — and the worst — time of her life.
Unable to live in the present. Unable to imagine a future.
She wasn’t sure how she got into the car — or even how she managed to start it — but when she noticed, she was already driving, speeding through the busy London streets while her ghosts tore at her ears with questions.
She ignored them fervently, far too busy running from the man who was her shadow, her other half… and her fate.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 42: The things we lose have a way of coming back to us in the end
Chapter Text
CX
The Hogwarts Express belched thick clouds of smoke, swallowing up the parents and students crowding Platform 9 ¾. Sirius’s owl, Ann, hooted cheerfully as the group paused to say their farewells to the Potters, the Lupins and Mrs Pettigrew.
Taking advantage of the smoke that hid her from the watchful eyes of the witches and wizards around, Scarlett watched James embrace Fleamont and Sirius, Euphemia. Remus was receiving instructions from his parents about the full moon, while Mrs Pettigrew squeezed Peter’s chubby cheeks. Though it was exhausting to feign excitement, a forced smile stretched across her lips.
Scarlett glanced around, as if waiting for someone else, even though she knew everyone who was meant to be there was already present. None of the silhouettes lost in the haze were her parents or Orfy. They were gone forever.
Her attention drifted to the door of the next carriage, and she let out a long sigh, rubbing the Ouroboros with the fabric of her glove.
“I’m going to find a compartment…” Scarlett announced quietly, as if hoping no one would hear her, but every gaze fell upon her.
“But already? Aren’t you going to say goodbye…” Hope Lupin began, but she fell silent when Euphemia gently touched her shoulder.
“I… I’ll come back before the Express departs…” Scarlett stammered with a nervous smile. It was an obvious lie.
No one reprimanded her. No one forced her to hug them or display the sort of affection that would embarrass any teenager. Euphemia, Hope and Mrs Pettigrew didn’t give her a stern look, nor did Fleamont or Lyall dismantle her flimsy excuse to deliver some paternalistic lecture.
Nothing.
It was as though even they didn’t know what to say.
Scarlett clenched her fists, swallowing hard. Anger rose, sharp and hot, churning in her stomach with a nauseating spasm and threatening to erupt at any moment. She hated being treated with such condescension, and she hated even more the pitying looks she received. She knew they meant no harm, but the anger was there, bitter on her tongue and twisting her expression.
“I’ll come with you…” Sirius volunteered.
“No need.” Her reply was short and harsh.
She spun on her heel and boarded without looking back.
Her head buzzed like a beehive. The first carriage was religiously reserved for the prefects, so Scarlett continued past it. She walked by Emmeline Vance, now Hufflepuff’s Head Girl, and Dorcas Meadowes, Ravenclaw’s Head Girl. She ignored their waves, not even bothering to glance at them.
“Gaunt!”
The call made her stop abruptly. Evan Rosier emerged from the compartment beside her, only his head poking out. Scarlett glanced at him from the corner of her eye without turning her head. There were other figures inside, but she couldn’t quite make them out.
“Since Heitor and Emily graduated last year, we’ve got two openings on our Quidditch team. I want you to pick the next Beater, so we’ll be holding tryouts next Monday.”
Scarlett blinked, distracted, waiting for him to go on. Evan frowned, expecting a reply. There was no concern or caution in those dark eyes. Only the usual insolence.
She very much wanted to say she was quitting the team, but she knew Rosier wouldn’t accept her decision, and she was far too tired to argue. So her response was merely a brief nod before taking a long step forward, trying to move away from conversations where she was the subject.
She stopped immediately as she nearly collided with someone who had just boarded. Scarlett’s gaze travelled over the pristine white shirt, the pearly tie, the sharp, tense jawline. It climbed the long, slender nose until it met the ever-unyielding, cold eyes — which slowly widened.
Regulus wetted his lips, clutching the book in his arms even tighter, his face growing pale. It was as though he were staring at a ghost.
Scarlett had the impression he’d grown taller — or perhaps she had shrunk — and she stood frozen, waiting for him to step aside. But Regulus remained paralysed before her, his lips parting slowly, as if he hadn’t the faintest idea what to say.
“I…”
“Would you mind moving?” Scarlett asked curtly. As if she didn’t know him.
The steel in his eyes faltered, quickly invaded by the shadow of fear. His cracked lips pressed together until they formed a crease. Regulus let go of the book with one hand, lifting it towards Scarlett’s shoulder, but the look she shot him was so cold, so piercing, that his hand froze mid-air. He seemed to think better of it and retreated, gripping his book once more.
“I need to get through.” She went on, watching fear spread its tentacles through the lines of Regulus’s expression as he struggled to regain control in one of his rare displays of vulnerability.
“For Merlin’s sake, Reggie, let the girl pass!” Evan muttered from the doorway of his compartment.
Regulus stepped aside, and Scarlett hurried past him, ignoring that familiar feeling that always surfaced whenever she was near him. As though she were in Orfeu’s presence.
“Scar…” he called after her.
Red would never be her brother; on the contrary, she’d stood by him and, in return, he had stabbed her in the back. For that reason, she ignored him as she continued searching for an empty compartment, desperately distancing herself from the first carriage and feeling the stares of the other witches and wizards burning into her back.
The moment she found one, she slipped inside as though fleeing a fire, her heart lodged in her throat and her hands trembling uncontrollably. With a quick glance behind her, she gripped the handle and tried to slide the door shut, only for her frustration to mount when it jammed.
Under normal circumstances she would have given up and moved on to the next compartment, but the whispers and the looks aimed at her made anger bare its teeth in her chest. Before she even realised it, she was yanking the door violently, again and again. On the fourth attempt, the door finally gave way — but not before slamming shut hard on her left hand.
The impact struck her Ouroboros dead-on, and a cry of pain threatened to tear from her throat, but Scarlett refused to let it. She clenched her jaw, curling in on herself, clutching her injured hand as her expression twisted, trying to subdue the waves of agony that radiated through her entire body as if she’d been scalded.
Tears overpowered her stubbornness, and Scarlett leaned her forehead against the door in protest, trying to swallow them back, but it was too late. In defeat, she slumped to the floor and rested her head against the nearest seat. She pulled off her glove and gently massaged the back of her hand, which was already starting to swell.
She barely reacted when the door was softly opened and then closed again. Silvery hair fell across her palms as Pandora rested her head on Scarlett’s shoulder, staring at the same vague, unfocused point.
“What did the poor door do to deserve such an attack?” she asked with such lightness that Scarlett felt as though she were in an entirely different dimension from her friend, for all she could feel was the unbearable weight pressing in on her from every side, as though gravity itself had grown heavier.
She wanted so much to laugh, but she was far too exhausted for that. Her reply was only a subtle shrug. Pandora’s pale eyes rested on her hand, throbbing with pain, and Scarlett thought she might fuss over it, since it was clear a bone was broken there. But Pan simply turned her face towards the window, watching the bustle outside.
It was strange how even the physical pain she felt wasn’t enough to soothe the void expanding in her chest, sucking everything away until Scarlett was reduced to an inanimate, silent version of herself. As if she were nothing but a hollow shell.
She barely realised she was staring at the same spot as Pandora, at the station through the polished glass of the window, where Lily Evans was easily recognisable by her fiery red hair. She threw her head back, and Scarlett could hear her laughter even from inside as she hugged her father.
Lily’s mother kissed her on the forehead, while her sister, scowling, merely waved before lowering her gaze and folding her arms. The Gryffindor’s smile cooled and she stepped back, blowing kisses to her parents as she hopped aboard, the pistons hissing with the train’s final warning.
Scarlett had never thought she’d envy Lily. The way her father waved her off, arms swinging joyfully, while her mother shouted for her to get good marks and behave herself. By Merlin, she even envied the look of disdain her sister gave her!
“I thought… I thought I’d have more time with them,” Scarlett murmured, her voice cracked and brittle. Pandora raised her brows. “I wish I’d had more time with my family.”
Pan let out a soft huff, gently wiping Scarlett’s tears away with her thumbs. Scar had the impression she was far too fragile, or perhaps it was simply because her hand was still broken and neither of them seemed to care.
“Oh, Scar…” Pandora caressed her chin before pinching her nose lightly. “The time we spend with the people we love is never going to be enough…” Sadness adorned her features, curving her lips downward as she pressed them together. “We’ll always wish for more.”
Scarlett didn’t want sound arguments or flowery words, but what Pandora said struck her in such a way that the air thinned around her. She squeezed the glove over her injured hand, sniffling as she tried to stifle her sobs.
Even so, she still wished she’d had more time. She wished she could go back and live it all over again. She wanted to be that frivolous, prickly girl whose only worries were hiding what Dimitri had done to her and not falling for Sirius. Of course it had all gone wrong — her plans rarely went right — but all her worries back then seemed so trivial now that she could do nothing but resent not prolonging the hugs, nurturing the smiles, and letting go of the grudges.
She knew it was a selfish thought, and somewhat unfair to herself, but the longing drowned out reason. She’d endure her mother shouting in her ear every day if it meant having them back. Perhaps she was even idolising her family, but it was hard to dwell on the bad moments when the good ones were all that lined the edges of her mind.
“Things… they’re meant to… get easier… with… time, aren’t they?!” Scarlett gasped, sobbing with each word. Holding back her tears, ignoring people’s reactions when they looked at her, and smothering the constant sting of frustration in her heart was utterly exhausting. She felt drained to the bone.
“I don’t think things ever get easier, Scar,” Pandora replied, brushing her hair from her face and tucking it neatly behind her ear. Scarlett looked into those pale eyes, as clear as a pristine, glassy lake. “Just… less difficult.”
Scarlett sniffled, staring at her gloved hand with the bulge in the palm. She pressed the broken bone, her face tightening in pain, hoping her heart would stop skipping beats. But one pain didn’t cancel out the other—on the contrary, it only piled on top of it, and Scarlett groaned, squeezing her eyes shut. Pandora caught her uninjured hand, stopping her from hurting herself further.
“Scar…” The soft call made Scarlett lower her face in shame, bracing herself for a reprimand, a look of disapproval, or an exasperated sigh. But when she looked at Pandora, all she found was a clean, untainted empathy, free of any judgement. “The things we lose have a way of coming back to us in the end…” Pandora glanced briefly towards the door before returning her gaze. “Sometimes, not always in the way we expect.”
At that exact moment, the compartment door burst open, revealing Sirius, James, Remus and Peter. They were hauling their heavy trunks and Ann’s cage. The moment Sirius saw Scarlett’s state, he dropped the luggage instantly and knelt in front of her, his eyes nearly popping out of their sockets at the sight of her hand.
Scarlett licked her lips, sniffling as she pointed with her good hand towards the entrance.
“The door tried to kill me,” she murmured, with exasperating seriousness.
Sirius bit his lower lip, glancing at where she’d pointed. When his eyes returned to hers, he kissed her fingers tenderly before drawing his wand from his pocket.
“And by the looks of it, it nearly succeeded.” He rolled his eyes as if it were just another everyday mishap, flicking his wand. Scarlett let out a pained grunt as the bone snapped back into place, though the swelling remained.
“You know me—I can’t go five minutes without putting my life in danger…” she quipped, allowing herself the faintest smile as she slipped off her gloves.
“Good thing I always carry a swelling solution…” James pulled a small bottle from the pocket of his trousers, placing it carefully in Scarlett’s good hand.
“And why is that, hmm?!” Remus raised a brow, draping his arm over James’s shoulder. “And I… well, I always have chocolate…” He fished a bar out of his bag. “Because… why not?!” He flashed an intimate smile at his friends, who knew perfectly well the reason.
“She doesn’t like chocolate.” Peter snatched the packet from Remus.
“No problem, I like it.” Sirius snatched the chocolate from Peter, lifting his arm high so he couldn’t reach it. “She prefers chocolate cake with filling.”
“Lucky for you, my mum makes the best chocolate cake in the whole of the UK…” Peter gave up on reclaiming the bar and tossed his bag onto one of the seats, pulling out a container from it while a mocking grin curved over his thin lips.
“Swelling potion, chocolate, chocolate cake with filling, two metres away from the murderous door… what more could you possibly need?” Sirius held the bar between his teeth as he reached for Peter’s cake, earning a warning slap.
Scarlett rested her face against Sirius’s chest and picked up a piece of the cake, the scales of the Ouroboros on her swollen hand glinting under the pale light streaming abundantly through the windows. Her gaze flicked to Pandora for just a second.
“I think…” She licked the filling from her fingers, still chewing. “I think I’ve got everything I need.”
The pistons hissed, and Sirius took advantage of the distraction to sneak a bite of her cake. Scarlett feigned outrage, raising her hand as if to smack him with the dessert, but the train suddenly lurched into motion, and she ended up splattering the cake squarely across Sirius’s face.
The silence that fell over the compartment was razor-sharp. Scarlett’s eyes widened and her mouth opened to apologise, but she was struck mute by Sirius’s reaction—he calmly tasted some of the frosting with the tip of his finger.
“Pete, your mum really does make the best chocolate cake in the UK…” he remarked, turning to Scarlett with a reflexive swiftness, pulling her onto his lap. Then he swiped a generous portion of Peter’s cake and smeared it over Scarlett’s face, and her laughter burst out instantly, infecting him just as quickly.
Peter tried to guard the remaining cake like it was treasure, but James snatched the tub from his hands and smacked it into Remus’s hair, who didn’t hesitate to retaliate by smearing frosting over his friend’s glasses. Pandora, seizing the chaos, pinched a bit of cake from Scarlett’s cheek and dabbed it onto Peter’s nose.
Scarlett couldn’t stop laughing at the sight of Sirius’s face, the flawless pale skin of his left cheek smeared with cake—even his eyelids. He tried wiping it off, but the sponge was sticky, and she took advantage of it to spread it further into his beard.
Sirius nipped at her fingers, licking them slowly as malice curled into his smile. Scarlett felt her cheeks burn, silently grateful her face was still covered in chocolate.
“Why haven’t you lot put your luggage away yet?!” Lily appeared at the doorway of the compartment, hands on her hips and an authoritative glare fixed on them. She scanned each one of them, raised her brows and blinked a few times. “What the hell happened in here?!”
Before anyone could come up with a reasonable answer, the entire group burst into uncontrollable laughter. Lily tried to hold her composure and keep a stern expression, but it slowly melted away when she noticed Scarlett was already breathless from laughing so hard and Sirius was wiping tears from the corners of his eyes. James was without his glasses, blindly searching for his wand, which was currently with Remus. Pandora and Peter, the least affected, were eating the leftover frosting from the lid of the container.
Lily filled her lungs, ready to unleash a lecture, but she caught herself smiling too, the façade of the Head Girl crumbling completely as she allowed herself to be infected by the group’s joy.
“It was Sirius,” Scarlett said, pointing at her boyfriend with a chocolate-smeared finger before licking it clean.
“Yes, my crime was loving too much…” He placed both hands dramatically on his chest, resting his head against the back of the seat.
“This compartment had better be spotless and the luggage put away by the time I get back!” Lily recomposed herself, pointing at each of them in turn with an intimidating air. “And that goes especially for you, Potter!”
“Yes, ma’am!” James saluted, squinting hard to see her without his glasses.
“And don’t forget the prefects’ meeting!” she reminded James and Remus, spinning on her heel to inspect the other compartments.
As soon as Lily disappeared from view, Sirius cleaned everything with a simple charm. The chocolate was gone, but the laughter lingered. James sprawled across the seat with a goofy grin stretching his lips, while Remus and Pandora used Wingardium Leviosa to stow the trunks.
“Why haven’t you lot put your luggage away yet?!” Sirius suddenly mimicked Lily, holding onto Scarlett as she settled in his lap.
“What the hell happened in here?!” Remus continued the act, dropping his jaw in mock horror and placing a hand just over his heart.
“This compartment had better be spotless and the luggage put away by the time I get back!” Peter crossed his arms and lifted his nose in the air. “And that goes especially for you, Potter!” He pinched James’s nose, earning himself an elbow in return.
“Yes, ma’am!” Scarlett straightened up, imitating her friend’s reply.
“And don’t forget the prefects’ meeting!” Pandora half-closed her eyes and spun her body dramatically, her long platinum hair cascading with the motion.
“Good God, what have Sirius and James done to you?!” Remus asked, alarmed, as if she were an entirely different person.
“Absolutely nothing! I don’t even talk to those two.” She rolled her eyes, though a sly little smile crept onto her face. “I’m only friends with Scar, and I’ve been recruited for Mission Jily 1977.”
James, whose face was already twisted in embarrassment, now turned completely red.
“What?” He jumped up from the seat. “What are you on about?”
“Nothing, it’s nothing… just rubbish…” Peter fanned James’s face as if it were no big deal.
“This year Lily’s going to ride you so hard she’ll pop your cherry!” Sirius said far louder than he should have, drawing the attention of students passing by in the corridor.
“Shut up, Padfoot!” James pleaded, his voice shooting up two octaves higher than usual.
“It’s not like it’s news…” Remus shrugged, holding a quill in his mouth as he pulled a book from his bag. “Everyone knows you fancy her.”
James sighed, uncomfortable with Pandora being part of the conversation.
“Yeah, but… I mean…”
“Relax, James. Lily might seem like a fortress… but deep down, her heart melts quicker than butter.” Pandora gave him an encouraging pat on the shoulder, making him smile.
Meanwhile, in Sirius’s lap, Scarlett drew her knees together and rested her head on his shoulder, inhaling the scent of her boyfriend deeply, intoxicated by the sweet yet refreshing notes. She drank the swelling potion for her hand and closed her eyes, feeling Sirius’s tattooed fingers run through her hair, his lips pressing gently against her forehead, his arms wrapping around her in a protective embrace.
Scarlett placed her hand on Sirius’s chest, focusing on the steady rhythm of his heartbeat, letting hers fall into sync with his, gradually calming. Though the pain and the loss would never truly fade, the constant presence of love and support made things just a little less difficult. She nestled even closer into her boyfriend, drowning in the man who was her refuge, her rainbow after the storm.
Truly, things didn’t get easier… but, indeed, they were becoming less difficult.
.
.
.
The city lights flickered rapidly at the edges of Scarlett’s vision, the car engine growling as she shifted into fourth gear. The glow her ghosts emitted wasn’t enough to save her from her own darkness. Their words were nothing more than distant echoes.
All she could hear was her own ragged breathing, her frantic heartbeat, and the whirling fragments of memory. Scarlett pressed her foot harder on the accelerator, making the flashes of streetlight streak faster across the car as everything around her dissolved into a blur.
[Music: Radiohead – Exit Music (For a Film)]
“Very well.” The voice was nothing more than a hiss. Scarlett could have had her eyes closed and still felt the macabre presence of that man circling her slowly, as though savouring her submission. “You… have proven yourself worthy.” Voldemort stopped in front of her, his cold, smooth fingers touching her left wrist. “You will become a Death Eater.”
Scarlett opened her eyes.
Marlene was shaking her head, the smile on her lips dying away little by little, just like the sunlight on her face, dimming until shadow swallowed half of it. The vibrant life in her pale eyes was diluted by the reflection of her murderer—the girl she had once called a friend.
Wake from your sleep
The drying of your tears
Today, we escape
We escape
It was hard for Scarlett to remember the sound Marlene’s body made when it hit the floor, because ever since she’d killed Maurie… her ears could hardly register anything. She heard the odd noise here and there, whispers and pleas, curses and blessings. But Scarlett couldn’t feel much anymore; she had killed five people with the Killing Curse.
Her soul had been torn apart so many times she felt as though she were floating, as if she too had just died. She knew she was alive, because she could feel the vibrations of Dimitri’s clapping echoing against her back, and Johann watching her with a sick fascination. Scarlett carefully holstered her wand, the Ouroboros on the back of her hand tingling.
Pack and get dressed
Before your father hears us
Before all hell breaks loose
She looked back, and the McKinnon house was gone, but Dimitri remained. Grimmauld Place stayed dark and morbid, yet… for some reason, Scarlett felt like she was home.
“We are two monsters, Scarlett.” He raised his goblet of elf wine, as if trying to see through the purplish liquid. “You saw that in me at Durmstrang, and I see it in you now. We are made of the same fury… the same blood.” He sipped his wine. “Hunting others as powerful as ourselves… tearing them apart until only one remains.”
Breathe, keep breathing
Don't lose your nerve
Breathe, keep breathing
I can't do this alone
Scarlett grabbed Dimitri’s wrist when he tried to touch her shoulder, fixing him with a sharp, disdainful glare.
“I’m not a pathetic coward like you,” she heard herself say, her lips twisting. “I don’t hide behind Unforgivables.”
“Scarlett?”
The sound of Regulus’s voice made her look at him, and the haunting corridors dissolved, replaced by their bedroom.
“Are you in pain?”
Scarlett was curled up in a foetal position on Red’s bed, under emerald-green blankets. Though she looked at him, she didn’t see him. Her vision was blurred with tears. She blinked them away forcefully, finally focusing on the tragic, slender boy who had taken on adult features, even if he still seemed barely more than an adolescent. His iron eyes, once so relentless and unyielding, were now rusted and cracked. Vulnerable.
She wanted to kill him with the same intensity she wanted to protect him.
Sing us a song
A song to keep us warm
There's such a chill
Such a chill
“I don’t feel anything anymore,” she replied, her voice trembling. “I’m just a shell.”
Regulus slipped off his jacket, tilting his face slightly as though he already understood exactly what she meant.
“Is this how you felt? Back at Hogwarts?” He sat beside her, gently stroking her hair. “When you said you couldn’t get out of bed?”
Scarlett nodded slowly, her gaze sliding to the flames crackling in the fireplace. It was the only light thinning the darkness in the room, casting gaunt shadows along the walls, over the bedposts, across her pale, hollow-eyed face.
You can laugh
A spineless laugh
We hope your rules and wisdom choke you
“It’s like… I’m sinking.” She drew a deep breath, but even the air didn’t stir any feeling in her body. “There’s a hand trying to pull me to the surface, trying to reach my arm… but I can’t move. I can’t swim. And I can’t even let go of my breath to end the suffering.” She closed her eyes as Red’s fingers softly caressed her cheek. “The things I think would make me better don’t make sense anymore, and the things I’m afraid to do are probably the ones that would help… but… in the end… I’m adrift, drowning… I don’t want to die… but I don’t want to live either.”
Regulus pressed his lips to her forehead, then slipped under the blanket, his arms weaving through the sheets to pull her close, his hands resting on her swollen belly.
“Does that make sense?”
Red cupped her face, and Scarlett looked into his eyes, searching for some scrap of comfort. But Regulus Black was the moon. The storm. The iron. And Scarlett needed the sun, the rainbow, the silver that soothed her fears and stirred her daring.
“It does,” he murmured, his lips against her forehead.
Still… she tried. She tried to sink into Regulus the way she did with Sirius; but Red and she were the same kind of piece, and they could never fit. While the elder brother was her half, her foundation, the younger was…
He was the demon whispering in her ear. He was the shove that sent her off the cliff, the gravity that dragged her into the fall, the rope tightening around her neck. He was the weakness that stopped her from swimming out of that catatonic state.
“As soon as the baby’s born and you’re strong enough to Apparate… we’ll run away. And then you’ll never suffer again… I’ll protect you. I’ll protect you both.”
Now we are one in everlasting peace
We hope that you choke, that you choke
We hope that you choke, that you choke
We hope that you choke, that you choke
Voldemort pressed his wand to her left forearm, and Scarlett heard her own scream. A vivid red pattern began to form on her skin as it burned, like cursed fire branding her once again. She remembered clenching her jaw so hard her skull felt as though it would crack, her breath narrowing, her shoulders tensing—but she didn’t cry.
Pain was already an old friend.
Scarlett shifted into fifth, the final gear, the power of the engine vibrating all around her as she tried to outrun her own thoughts. The speed pressed her body into the leather seat, the screams of her ghosts growing ever more fragmented and disjointed.
Filled with a strange sense of stasis, she felt an endless cold in her stomach when something invaded her body. It was the same sensation that had visited her the moment Orfy—
The moment Orfeu tried to strangle her.
It was James, stripping away her free will, trying to slow the car by dropping a gear, but it was too late; the vehicle began spinning out of control on the road, tyres screeching loud against the asphalt, smoke rising around them, the stench of burnt rubber filling her nostrils.
In a desperate attempt to regain control, James yanked the wheel in the opposite direction, and his face smashed violently against the window, his nose breaking with the force of the impact.
The car finally stopped after spinning several times.
Panting and disoriented, Scarlett stumbled out, blood from her broken nose mixing with the tears stinging her eyes as they streamed down her cheeks. She leaned against the car, breathing heavily, the metallic taste in her mouth making her stomach churn.
“WHAT DO YOU THINK YOU’RE DOING?!” Lily screamed, her eyes brimming with tears. “ARE YOU COMPLETELY MAD?!”
Scarlett knelt on the asphalt, marked by the trail of her tyres, covering her ears with her hands. She wanted so badly to tell Lily to shut up, but she was in shock.
“Were you trying to kill yourself?” James asked, his tone dark, tinged with fear.
She shook her head slowly, wincing at the sharp pain as she opened her mouth, spitting blood onto the ground.
“Regulus…” she called softly. Red walked to her side. Unlike James and Lily, there was no fear in his gaze. Which made sense—he was already dead. What was there left for him to fear? “I need… I need a list…”
“What are you talk—” Lily began, but Regulus silenced her with a single look.
“I need you to write down the names of every single Death Eater… all of them…”
Regulus clenched his jaw, his brow furrowing subtly.
“Why?”
Scarlett blinked repeatedly, and a pernicious rage unfurled in her chest, as if it had finally found the perfect place to exist. It fed on everything the Death Eaters had forced her to do, on all the lives she had taken, all she’d been made to accept, all the terror she had endured.
It was far too easy to blame the Death Eaters for her mistakes, far too convenient to heap upon them all the miseries of her life. And it was the perfect chance for her sorrow and helplessness to ignite and forge themselves into a searing, crimson fury, transforming into a cold, grim thirst.
Scarlett could never go back in time to undo the mistakes of her past… but she could make them pay in the present. She could make them suffer as much as she had; perhaps even more.
It was all she wanted—revenge. Revenge for the deaths of Regulus, Lily and James; revenge for Sirius’s imprisonment, for Remus’s loneliness, and Orfy’s madness. For the McKinnons. For the fifteen years she’d spent locked away. For her family.
“I’ll make them pay. Every single one of them… for everything they did. And they’ll pay dearly. They’ll pay dearly for it.”
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 43: I reckon our performance really did deserve applause
Chapter Text
CXI
Scarlett opened her eyes and was greeted by the sharp yet sweet and refreshing scent of Sirius’s cologne. She had no idea how long she’d been asleep in his lap, but when she yawned and lazily lifted her face from his leather jacket, she found the carriage almost empty.
Peter was the only one there, gnawing at his fingernails while reading a Muggle comic book. Through the train windows, she glimpsed the misty weather ahead; stretches of freezing fog followed by sudden bursts of dazzling sunlight.
Scar lay stretched across Sirius’s lap, one of his arms draped around her waist while the other rested on the seat’s back, where he had his chin propped. Sirius stroked the fabric of her crimson overcoat with his thumb, inhaling deeply as he slid the walkman headphones down to his neck.
“It's alright, you can sleep,” he murmured, his half-lidded eyes glinting beneath long, dark lashes.
“Where are the others?” Scarlett sighed softly, clinging to Sirius so the warmth between them wouldn’t fade.
Peter lifted his gaze from the comic, raising his fair eyebrows as if to make sure the question was meant for him.
“Prongs and Moony went to the prefects’ meeting… Malfoy went off to the carriage with her boyfriend…” He uncrossed his legs. “I think I’ll go get changed.”
“Good idea, Wormtail.” Sirius cracked his neck, his lips curling into a smile full of wicked intent. “We’ll make the most of it and get changed here too…”
Peter rolled his eyes, snapping the comic shut with a thud. He grabbed his bag and left the compartment, a faint blush brushing his cheeks. Sirius slowly turned his face towards Scarlett, his black hair falling rebelliously over his cheeks, lust glimmering in his gaze and dimples.
“What?” Scarlett pressed a finger to her lower lip, feigning innocence.
“You can get changed…” he purred, squeezing Scarlett’s hips in that way that always made her gasp the way he loved. “No one’s going to see you naked…”
“I’m not going to be naked.” She arched a brow, pushing herself up from his lap, but he didn’t allow it, pulling her back in closer. “Sirius!”
He simply flicked his wand and the glass of the compartment turned opaque. Scarlett couldn’t help but smile, reminded of the year before when they’d changed clothes with their backs to each other, holding the door shut.
“Sirius… if James and Remus…”
“They won’t be back anytime soon.” He waved a hand dismissively in front of his face, utterly unconcerned at the thought of being caught. “Besides… it’s our last year… might be our last ride to Hogwarts on the Express…”
Scarlett felt her pulse quicken, heat rushing to her face. It was an impossible task to resist the molten mercury hunger in Sirius’s eyes, which drank in the sunlight and mirrored the paralysing mist outside. His hand at her waist began to slide, slowly, beneath her overcoat.
“You’re such an exhibitionist.” Scarlett guided his tattooed fingers, heavy with rings, to her left breast, where Sirius massaged through the layers of her winter clothes.
“Just keep quiet and no one will notice,” he shot back, as if it were the simplest thing in the world.
Scarlett parted her lips to respond, but Sirius silenced her with his thumb, brushing it across her rosy mouth, feeling her warm breath ghost against his fingertip. She drew in a sharp breath when, with his other hand, Sirius began unbuttoning her blouse. Scarlett could have slipped away if she wanted, could have stood abruptly or simply slid out of his lap. But it was far too late for that; she was captive to his ravenous gaze, swept away by a sea of silver filled with undertow and desire.
“Not going to get changed?” Sirius teased, his voice laced with irony and dark lust.
Her only reply was a shy, flustered smile as she tried to swim free from the abyss of his black pupils—dense, devouring, storm-churned. Sirius hooked Scarlett’s leg around his waist, positioning her to straddle him, his cock hardening with the heat of her body pressed against his.
“Do you want me to stop?” Their faces were so close the question tickled her cheeks. Scarlett couldn’t speak; it was as if Sirius had stolen every thought, every word, every shred of restraint she had left. Maybe it was his brazen beauty, maybe it was the dizzying pull of his stare—or maybe it was because Scarlett wanted him to ruin her in every possible way in that damned carriage.
All she knew was that she wanted Sirius coaxing out her filthiest moans even as he muffled them, covering her mouth and tightening his hand around her throat.
Scarlett closed her eyes the instant Sirius’s lips met hers. Kissing him was one of the wonders of the world, just like fucking him or exchanging glances; feeling him spill inside her, or the way he touched her, protected her, worshipped her. His lips were intoxicatingly sweet like the cruellest poison, his tongue mastering her with effortless dominance, and his hands finishing with the buttons of her shirt so he could pinch and knead her breasts.
The kiss quickened with each hard, racing beat of her heart. Scarlett let her overcoat slip to the floor as the intoxicating heat spread from her belly to the rest of her body. A gasp escaped her mouth when Sirius nipped her lower lip, his hot, wet tongue trailing up to the lobe of her ear.
“Fuck, Sirius…” Scarlett moaned when he grazed his teeth along a path that stopped at the curve of her neck, his damp lips finding her bare collarbone before gliding all the way back to her ear.
It was almost impossible to do anything but surrender to Sirius Black. Scarlett glanced up at the luggage racks while her boyfriend teased her stiffened nipples, her whole body shivering under the touch of her favourite incubus.
“Your skin is so soft…” he murmured against her neck, the vibrations sending an electrifying cascade through her body.
Scarlett’s fingers tangled in the leather jacket as Sirius stretched his arms to slip it off, shedding his David Bowie T-shirt right after. His skin was warm beneath her palms. The chill of the carriage raised goosebumps across his pale flesh, but Scarlett was quick to spark tingling trails over Sirius’s body, tracing the muscles she already knew, the scar on his chest from Snape’s curse, the tattoos on his back where her left hand slid up to tangle in midnight-black hair; her right hand travelled the opposite way, dragging her knuckles down his taut abdomen, daring further as she caressed the dark hair just below his navel, following the path that would lead her exactly where she wanted to be.
Sirius’s breathing grew heavier as Scarlett braced her knees on the seat and lifted her hips, her fingers snaking over his jeans, stroking the growing erection with her thumb. Straightening with a sinful ease, Sirius gave her a wicked little smirk as he sprawled his arms along the seatback, relaxing into the moment and surrendering control to Scarlett. His star-bright eyes gleamed with intoxicated pride even as they devoured her with hunger, roaming over her bare, hardened breasts, her ragged breathing, the flushed heat painting her cheeks.
When Sirius’s eyes met hers again, he licked his lips and leaned in to trap her in another kiss.
Scarlett pressed harder as she rubbed Sirius’s cock through his jeans, making his legs falter. She would have smirked if Sirius wasn’t kissing her with such greedy abandon, his commanding tongue dominating hers while his filthy hands groped her breasts, the tips of his thumbs brushing over her nipples, circling them with maddening precision.
He swallowed her moans as Scar unfastened his belt, unzipped his jeans and rubbed her palm against the thin fabric of his underwear, tugging it down slightly to caress the swollen, slick head already wet with pre-cum.
But Sirius clearly had other plans. He gripped Scarlett firmly by the waist and stood abruptly, pinning her body between his and the cold window, where the idyllic landscapes outside reflected the sun sinking below the horizon.
“What are you…” Scarlett began to ask, her voice muffled by her ragged breathing. She couldn’t finish the question, because Sirius yanked her trousers down in one swift motion, leaving her utterly bare in the compartment. Her eyes darted instantly to the glass of the door, but she couldn’t see much of the corridor beyond faint, shapeless figures.
Sirius’s answer was an insatiable look. He stripped the rest of his clothes and slowly sank to his knees, his eyes locked on Scarlett’s as his lips parted, inching his face between her thighs. His feverish tongue touched her inner hip first, spreading warm saliva over her delicate pelvis, trailing upward to her abdomen, past her ribs, along her collarbones—stopping only to sink his teeth lightly into her neck.
Scarlett arched her back, clamping one hand over her mouth while the other gripped the window rail. The wet path left by Sirius’s tongue, once hot, now sent shivers darting through her entire body. With a filthy little smirk, vulgarity dancing in the dimples of his face, he traced the path back down, his chin’s stubble grazing her pale skin, speckling it with red.
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut and bit down on her lips, stifling a desperate moan. Sirius curled his tongue around one of her nipples, sucking it before pulling away with an audible pop, his gaze never once leaving hers, those molten-silver eyes igniting with elation as they revered her naked, trembling body.
He gripped her waist, holding her in a firm but comforting prison. Sirius lifted one of Scarlett’s legs over his shoulder, bringing his lips to the very centre of her thighs. He exhaled a heated breath over her lower lips, watching in fascination as her body quivered in anticipation.
His fingers pressed into the bones of her hips as he buried his tongue in her cunt, licking slowly from her entrance all the way to her clit, intoxicated by the wetness spilling from her. His stubble rasped deliciously against her soft folds. Scarlett grabbed fistfuls of his black hair, dragging her nails over his scalp, keeping herself balanced on one foot while the other hand clutched the window frame to stop the Express’s motion from tipping her over.
It was impossibly hard not to moan, but Scarlett tried her best to hold back the sounds of pleasure her throat ached to release. Biting her lower lip, she went up on tiptoe the moment Sirius slid his middle finger inside her, inch by inch. The ring finger followed, and Scarlett yanked at his hair in retaliation as her walls clenched tightly around him, betraying her restraint with a ragged, breathless moan. Sirius growled, the vibration humming against her aching core as his long fingers twisted into a cruel, torturous rhythm, catalysed by the wicked flicks of his tongue.
He narrowed his gaze on Scarlett, sucking her clit as he watched every rapturous expression that adorned her face. She had little choice but to let the heat consume her legs and rise through the rest of her body in uncontrollable waves, grinding helplessly against Sirius’s mouth as she writhed, struggling to keep her breathing steady. In return, he rewarded her by moving his fingers in perfect sync with her convulsions, lapping up her release before it could spill down his cheeks.
Scarlett had no idea how long she’d remained standing there, propped against the window with one leg draped over Sirius’s shoulder. When she finally opened her eyes, her body was so numb and languid she barely noticed the fogged glass against her back—or that Sirius had pulled his face away from her swollen cunt. Still kneeling, he now gripped his long, thick cock, the flushed red tip gleaming furiously.
With her heart thundering in her chest, Scarlett watched Sirius stroke himself slowly, his fist gliding from the throbbing base of his length up to the head, which disappeared between his thumb and forefinger before he slid his hand back down, tightening the grip as he returned.
Recovering herself bit by bit, Scarlett eased her leg off Sirius’s shoulder, giving him more room to move. She licked her lips, still trembling, and slowly crouched down. Sirius raised a brow, staring at her with a devilish smile spreading into his dimples.
“Stand up,” she murmured, still breathless. “Stand up, Sirius…”
Sirius furrowed his brow, still not entirely sure what she intended, but obeyed without hesitation. Scarlett lifted her eyes to him, completely naked, her gaze lingering on his hard, impatient cock, desperate to fill her with his cum.
For a moment, the only sound surrounding them was the rumble of the train as night began to swallow the day and the lanterns flickered on.
“What are you…” Sirius cut himself off when Scarlett took his cock in her hand and placed a delicate kiss along the side of it, trailing lower to his pelvis. One hand held him firmly at the base while the other rested on his thigh, stroking over his scars. His eyes widened, his length twitching when Scarlett slowly dragged her lips over the tip, kissing the sensitive head.
“Are you cer—”
He shut his eyes the moment Scarlett licked the most sensitive spot on the head of his cock.
“Fuck…” Sirius sighed, gathering Scarlett’s hair and holding it in a makeshift ponytail.
“I’ll need your help. I’m not really sure what I’m doing…”
“Just keep going. Just keep going…” he nearly begged, gazing down at her with raw admiration and hungry longing.
Scarlett obeyed, licking him again, the salty taste imprinting itself on her tongue. It wasn’t bad, just unfamiliar. She didn’t stop, daring to wrap her lips around the head of Sirius’s cock, sucking it gently.
Sirius immediately tilted his head back and exhaled through parted lips, his jaw tightening as he clamped it shut, breathing deeply to stifle a moan. A red warning light flickered in the back of Scarlett’s mind—memories and sensations threatening to drag her into panic, to cloud her senses—but she forced her eyes wide open, anchoring herself in the sight of Sirius’s pure ecstasy, his wild black hair falling over his defined shoulders as his chest heaved with each heavy breath, silver eyes searching for hers.
This wasn’t Dimitri Rustov.
This was Sirius Black—her rainbow, the man who pulled her from the fire and kept her company on the cliff edge of loss. The man who carried the whole world on his shoulders while all she could do was lie there and pray it was just a nightmare.
Scarlett filled her lungs and deepened her suction, moving her hand along the length of his cock, mimicking the rhythm. Sirius slowly shook his head, his neck taut, lips trembling. Scarlett decided to take him deeper, past the swollen head, feeling Sirius’s thigh quiver beneath her palm, his grip on her hair tightening with a near-desperate force.
Seeing Sirius undone and vulnerable like that sent molten lava coursing through her veins, intoxicating her with an unrelenting need to have his cock inside her, fucking her until she saw stars. Scarlett kept her pace steady, but each time she drew her head back up she heightened the suction, and Sirius’s entire expression contorted as if it took unimaginable effort not to come. He yanked her hair back hard, forcing her to stop, a thin string of spit still connecting her sinful lips to the tip of his cock.
“I’m gonna… I’ll come like this…” he admitted, between desperate pants. “I want to come inside you.”
Scarlett barely had time to process his words before Sirius gripped her shoulders and hauled her up, pressing her against the window again. Before she could react, he spun her around, leaving her back to him, the icy glass contrasting sharply with the searing heat of his body, sending rigidity to her nipples and a shiver through her frame.
Night had fallen, leaving nothing outside but shadow-drenched scenery, while the light of the carriage cast a sensual reflection—Sirius behind Scarlett, a smile edged with eroticism painting his lush lips.
In answer, Scarlett arched her arse back, silently begging him to thrust into her with force. But all Sirius did was tease her, rubbing himself along the entrance of her slick cunt, provoking her mercilessly. With her torso and half her face pressed to the window, Scarlett shot him an exasperated look as her fogged breath clung desperately to the glass.
“Stop… stop teasing me… please…” she whimpered, her hands clutching the window frame.
Sirius smirked, raising just one brow.
“I know, kitten, but I need you to be quiet…” he asked, with feigned innocence. “As much as I’d love everyone to hear what I’m doing to you, I don’t fancy starting the year by losing points…”
“Shut up and fuck me!” Scarlett growled, and Sirius, being a good boyfriend, obeyed.
The cold of the glass was nowhere near enough to dull the dizzying sensation of Sirius’s cock stretching her desperate walls, sending waves of pleasure rippling through her muscles, her veins, her very core. Sirius pulled back only to thrust into her fully, driving his hips with a maddening, nerve-racking rhythm.
The moment Scarlett parted her lips to moan, Sirius slipped his thumb between them, burying the sound. With his other hand gripping her waist, he quickened the pace of his thrusts, going so deep and hard that Scarlett’s entire body was pressed flush against the window, her feet lifting off the floor.
Even with her muffled moans, the sound of Sirius’s hips slamming into Scarlett’s arse was loud enough to be heard outside the compartment. Not that he cared; the warm, wet clutch of Scarlett’s walls, the way they coated and squeezed his cock, was enough to strip him of all rationality. The hand that clutched her waist slid upward, taking hold of hers where it braced against the glass, their fingers intertwining as they steadied themselves on the slick, steamy window.
In that position, Scarlett could feel Sirius reaching places she hadn’t even known existed, intoxicating her with the approach of a second orgasm, her whole body tensing in euphoria. His cock rubbed perfectly against her slick, tight walls, dragging her to bliss all over again.
Sirius pulled his thumb from her lips and covered her mouth with his palm instead. Her walls clamped down on him in sheer frenzy, driving him right over the edge until he reached the clouds. He buried himself deep in Scarlett and let her milk him with the shuddering spasms of her cunt, filling her, pulse after pulse, with his hot release.
For a few long seconds, the only sound in the carriage was their heavy breathing.
“What are they doing?!” A voice they both knew all too well rang from outside, sounding anything but pleased.
“Clapping,” James answered, his voice betraying a nervous edge.
“Clapping?! They didn’t even respond when I called them…”
“You heard them, they were clapping too loud,” James justified with a breathless laugh.
“James, move away from the door!” Lily cleared her throat sharply. “Now!”
“They’re getting changed, Lily, unless you really want to see them starkers…”
“You just said they were clapping—why would they be naked?!”
“Because they’re getting changed…”
“Don’t try that pathetic excuse on me, Potter!” she snapped, her voice rising.
Sirius carefully slipped out of Scarlett, stumbling back and bracing both hands on the fogged glass. Scarlett fumbled for support against the window frame, feeling the lingering wave of release trickle from her swollen cunt down the insides of her thighs, dripping onto the floor.
Once she steadied herself, she glanced sideways at Sirius—his face flushed, his hair stuck damply to his cheeks. He scrambled to gather their scattered clothes around the compartment, dressing hurriedly while Scarlett could do little more than stay upright, still drunk on the aftershocks of her second orgasm.
Sirius dressed so fast she barely noticed, until he grabbed her overcoat and draped it over her shoulders, buttoning it up and discreetly hiding her clothes beneath it on the seat. Then he pulled her back onto his lap just as the compartment door slid open.
At that exact moment, Sirius started clapping. Scarlett narrowed her eyes at him, utterly baffled.
Lily and James stood in the doorway—she with her hands planted on her hips, he fussing nervously with his glasses.
“We saw a stag…” Sirius explained with feigned innocence, throwing James a cheeky wink.
“A deer, Padfoot. A deer,” James corrected tightly, clenching his jaw.
Lily shot them a sour look and forced a smile, then pointed towards the smudged marks on the window. It didn’t take much inspection to understand what had just happened in there—Scarlett’s entire body was practically imprinted on the misted glass. Sirius swallowed hard, his grin faltering into one of awkward guilt.
“Very funny.” Lily’s green eyes lost all pretense of kindness as they burned into both of them. “Twenty points from Slytherin and Gryffindor.” Her tone allowed no room for protest. “Scarlett, get properly dressed. Sirius, fix your clothes. I can’t believe we’re already in the negative before term has even started!”
Without another word, she spun on her heel and marched down the corridor of the Express, revealing a group of nosy students clustered behind her. James quickly slid the door shut, shooing away the audience.
“You alright?” Sirius asked, kissing Scarlett’s cheek.
“Mmhm,” Scar grunted with a soft smile. She slipped off Sirius’s lap and reached for her clothes on the seat to get dressed.
With her face still flushed from the embarrassing situation, Scarlett wiped between her thighs before slipping her trousers back on. Their eyes met in the quiet that followed, and the corners of Sirius’s mouth curved into a mischievous smile.
“I reckon our performance really did deserve applause,” he remarked, his gaze glinting with mischief.
Scarlett pressed her lips together, trying to hold it in, but soon both of them burst into laughter.
“It wasn’t a deer, it was a stag!” she mimicked James, laughing loudly as she fumbled with the button of her blouse.
Sirius’s laughter joined hers—rich, warm, and disarming—banishing any lingering shame Scarlett might have felt. They laughed so hard they ended up clinging to each other for balance, eventually collapsing together on the seat. Scarlett stretched out her legs and Sirius sprawled on top of her, still chuckling, wrapping an arm around her shoulders to pull her close.
“You know I love you, yeah? Even when we’re on the verge of being expelled for indecency.”
Scarlett rolled her eyes, fastening the last button with a stubborn smile.
“And I love you, even when you make me start the year losing house points…”
Sirius shook his head, rubbing his hand over his stubble as a thought struck him.
“Just imagine, fifteen years from now, us telling our kids about our crazy adventures at Hogwarts.”
Scarlett snorted a laugh, covering her face with her hands, torn between punching Sirius or burying herself in a hole out of pure mortification.
“No, Sirius, they will never, ever know the things we’ve done! Some secrets are meant to stay between us!” she protested, utterly incredulous.
Sirius moved closer, embracing her, gently taking her hands away from her face. The liquid silver of his eyes burned with an unspoken promise as he replied.
“I completely agree,” he said with a shrug, his voice low and velvety, tinged with arrogant charm. “But it’s fun to think that, one day, we’ll have a bunch of little secrets running around, born from all our mischief.”
Scarlett frowned, turning her gaze aside as she wet her lips, feeling Sirius rest his temple against her cheek.
“Oh, just imagine how thrilled McGonagall would be…” she teased, giving him a light shove.
“I’d give anything to see her face the day our kids—and James’s—start at Hogwarts. I think she’d tear her hair out and retire on the spot…”
“Our kids and James’s?!” Scarlett turned her face toward him, and Sirius nodded without hesitation.
“Yeah. They’d go to school together and be best mates, just like their parents…” he said, as if it were the simplest, most obvious thing in the world.
The carriage door slid open again, and James stepped in, shutting it quickly behind him as if half-expecting one of them to still be naked.
“Why haven’t you two put your uniforms on?!” he asked condescendingly, running his hand over his Head Boy badge.
Scarlett and Sirius exchanged a look, the amusement from earlier flooding back with full force, and soon their cheeks ached from laughing so hard.
Sirius wanted so badly to pull Scarlett into his arms, to hold onto her forever, but he had no control over memory. He watched, helplessly, as the freckled face he loved so much slowly dissolved, giving way to the stark, overly bright light of Asca’s consulting room.
He blinked slowly, regaining awareness, surfacing from the sweet undertow that left a pleasant ache lingering in his body. Now that the memory was whole, Sirius felt a strange sharp softness in his heart. He couldn’t explain it—it was both blissful and painful all at once.
“And?” The woman’s voice slipped into his ears.
Sirius remained lying there, rubbing his eyes with his knuckles, letting his heartbeat settle as his mind clung to the image of Scarlett—eyes closed, face pressed against the fogged train window, lips wrapped around his thumb, sucking it as he thrust into her.
When he finally sat up, he realised his trousers had grown uncomfortably tight at the crotch. He cleared his throat and placed a cushion over his lap, still lethargic from the therapy. Resting his hands on the edges of the couch, he lifted his gaze to Asca, seated directly opposite him.
“What did you remember?” She rested her elbows on the arms of her chair.
Sirius exhaled deeply, tilting his head side to side as he searched for the right words.
“The journey to Hogwarts… our last year,” he murmured, running a hand through his hair, combing it out with his fingers.
“Our?”
“Yeah… I was with Scarlett…” he admitted hoarsely. “We were….” He cleared his throat. “…talking about the future.”
Sirius didn’t want to lie, but he also didn’t want to confess that he’d shagged Scarlett in the carriage and lost points for Gryffindor.
“The future?”
“Mm.” He nodded faintly. “We had this idea that… our kids and James’s would be friends at Hogwarts and…” Any trace of happiness drained from his face, never to return. He lowered his gaze and hunched his shoulders, rubbing the rings on his fingers over and over with his thumbs. “Well, it’s stupid to even say that out loud now, because we… because she…”
“She had a child with your brother,” Asca finished for him.
Sirius only nodded.
“There’s still a lot that’s… hazy in my mind about when we… when we fought, but… when she came back…” He swallowed with difficulty. “She asked me for forgiveness.” His lips pressed into a thin line as he glanced up at Asca. “Before… b-before she was arrested and… and died.” His voice faltered, stumbling over the thought of the therapist realising Scarlett was still alive.
Asca, however, simply tapped her pen lightly against her knee, her gaze holding his with quiet intensity.
“And did you forgive her?”
Sirius clenched his hands into fists, watching his knuckles blanch under the pressure, his fingers cracking with the strain.
“This isn’t fair,” he rasped, ignoring the tears burning at the corners of his eyes.
“It isn’t fair to forgive her?”
“I want to… I wanted to, but… she hurt me so much. She destroyed me. And she thinks she can just say she’s sorry and go live her bloody little happy life like nothing ever happened, and then… I’m still at the bottom of the pit, and… I wanted… I wanted so badly to forgive her, but… I don’t know if I can. It’s not fair. What she did to me wasn’t fair, but… what I did to her wasn’t fair either. And I hate it. I hate… I hate what we did to each other… I just wanted… I just wanted to go back and undo it all… all this shit… stop her from leaving… from… from being arrested and… it’s not fair!”
“Forgiveness isn’t about fairness, Sirius.” Asca wet her lips before speaking again. “And it might sound simple, but it isn’t. They’re just little words waiting at the back of your throat, and you think you just have to let them out. But it doesn’t work like that. The longer you hold onto them, the deeper they slip into your core until they’re trapped between your ribs, your lungs… your heart.”
“And how do I even…” He drew in a shaky breath, trying to clear his thoughts. “I hurt her too, Dimitrescu. More than once. I was drunk for almost the whole summer, and I hurt her… I knew I was hurting her and I still kept going and… I don’t know what to do. I try to justify my forgiveness because I did horrible things too, but it’s so hard… If she hadn’t left, we’d be living our dream, we…”
“You can’t know that, Sirius.”
“Of course I can—we… we loved each other!”
“Just because two people love each other…” Asca replied with an infuriating calmness, “…doesn’t mean they’d stay together.”
“But we should have! And now… and now she…” I told her I loved her and she ignored me, he wanted to say, but the words never left his mouth.
“She died,” Asca continued softly, a sad smile ghosting her lips. “And still you feel the need to forgive her.”
“It’s eating me alive…” he admitted, exhaling a harsh breath. “I want to forgive her, but… I don’t know how.”
“The secret to forgiveness, Sirius,” Asca said gently, “is that it’s more about ourselves than about the other person. When we hold on to those words, when they stay buried in our chest… every mistake we’ve made, all the wrong things we’ve done cling to that caged forgiveness so tightly they can’t break free. And that’s the point, Sirius. You need to forgive yourself first. You need to let go of all the harm you caused her, all the pain and regret… only then will you be able to forgive her too. It’s not about accumulating—it’s about releasing. You didn’t know how to be better back then… and that’s alright. Everyone is the villain in someone’s story.”
For a moment, Sirius wondered if he’d been the villain in Scarlett’s life. It was easier to believe the opposite. The indifference with which she’d reacted to his confession still ached—a thorn lodged deep in his heart. She’d been a bloody coward—always had been, really—and he didn’t know why it still surprised him the way she’d run from him. As if the mere glimpse of a future together was her worst nightmare.
He didn’t know if he could forgive himself, either. As much as he beat himself up over it, Scarlett hadn’t left without reason. It wasn’t just because of Regulus; he knew her far too well for that. She was—once again—running. And Sirius understood. He would’ve done the same if the roles had been reversed.
“I don’t know if I can,” he whispered. “I’m a fucking mess and… shit, I still have to go to Hogwarts… Reggie’s got himself into trouble…” He glanced at his pocket watch.
“You talk about your godson like he’s your son.”
“I wish he was,” Sirius shot back without thinking. He rubbed his temples. “Before I was sent to prison… when he was just a kid… I called him my son. And he called me dad. A fair trade, since my brother… made me the godfather of his son. The son he had with the woman I loved.” His voice was laced with bitterness he didn’t bother to hide.
Asca shifted in her chair.
“So… you did that to get back at your brother? You don’t like Reggie?”
Sirius let out a short, nasal laugh, but there was no humour in it.
“I love that boy like he’s my own,” he said, his gaze wandering across the room until it fixed on some empty spot. “He should have been mine.”
“And he’s not your son?”
“No! He’s not!” Sirius’s voice spiked before breaking, the air leaving his lungs in a ragged sigh. His shoulders slumped. “We… we planned a life together… kids… a family that would go against everything I was raised to believe…”
“But… didn’t you win in the end? He’s your son. He calls you dad. You raised him when he was little and—”
“No, he won!” Sirius cut her off sharply. “He took my woman, he stole our future, he… he… he dragged her into that supremacist cult and… fuck, I wouldn’t even doubt he forced her to… to…”
He couldn’t finish.
He knew Regulus. At least, he thought he did. And Sirius wasn’t sure if his brother could really go that far to achieve his goals. In truth, he feared finding out Regulus wasn’t the monster he so often painted him to be, because that would mean Scarlett bore more guilt than Sirius wanted to admit. And it was already hard enough to try forgiving her for the McKinnons… and for Reggie. He didn’t want to discover she was capable of even more.
How had the girl he’d once shared dreams with, the one he’d loved with every fibre of his being, become… that? The woman who turned her back on him and murdered their own friends?
The image of Scarlett as she was now floated through his mind; a shattered reflection of the girl he had once loved. Just as broken as he was. No—more broken than him. Far more. His torment during the years in Azkaban had been only the dementors, but her…
He shook his head violently. He didn’t want to think about that. He didn’t want to feel empathy for her. He only wanted a way to rip her out of his chest—even if it meant cutting away a piece of his heart to do it. He was tired— exhausted —of suffering because of Scarlett. Of hoping she wouldn’t repeat the same mistakes. Of longing for her to act without fear clouding her decisions.
“Do you think your brother was capable of this?”
“I don’t know… I don’t know. I don’t think I ever really knew him,” Sirius said, closing his eyes. “I don’t think anyone really knew him.”
“I’m sorry for your loss. For all of them.”
“It was… it was so long ago…” he panted, suddenly short of breath.
“No matter how much time passes, Sirius. Grief never really leaves us.”
“I don’t miss him. In truth, all I feel for him is anger.” He rose to his feet, adjusting the leather jacket on his shoulders. “He was a bloody snake. I always knew it… and I never did anything…”
“What should you have done?”
Sirius opened his mouth to answer, but nothing came out. He stayed silent. He didn’t know. He felt disoriented, his eyes darting towards the door before he glanced again at his pocket watch.
What should he have done to keep Regulus from becoming who he became?
He clenched the watch tight in his palm, his shoulders shaking. He felt like he’d done everything he could… yet something deep in his mind whispered that he could’ve done more. That he could have insisted more. That he could have…
But it was too late to think about that now.
Sirius gave a brief nod of farewell and left the consulting room with his ears ringing and his vision blurred by the tears he refused to let fall.
.
.
.
Sirius’s face was flushed and swollen when he stepped out of the fireplace into his home. Remus wouldn’t be back for a while, still relentlessly searching for a proper job, and Sirius hadn’t expected to find Penny in the kitchen. He was certain he’d given her the day off after hearing her quietly collecting the empty bottles of house-elf wine he’d downed after being abandoned by Scarlett.
“What are you doing?” he asked, leaning against the archway at the kitchen entrance.
Penny twitched one of her enormous ears in his direction but didn’t look at him.
“Throwing away the food Mistress Black brought…” She was holding a bag filled with still-sealed packages.
“Wait.” His tongue betrayed him faster than he liked. “Er… what… what’s in there?”
Penny curled her lips in distaste, opening the bag and pulling out each item. Sugar-free coffee, pancakes with strawberries and maple syrup… and something wrapped in metallic paper that Sirius barely realised he’d picked up from the counter. He unwrapped it slowly, his hands faltering when he caught a glimpse of what it was.
A slice of strawberry cake.
The simple sight of the dessert was enough to shatter all the walls he’d built since her rejection the night before. The urge to cry surged up his throat uncontrollably; he held his breath tight, but the tears still carved cruel tracks down his cheeks. Sirius clenched his jaw and turned his face away from Penny immediately.
“Get out…” he rasped. “Get out, Penny…”
“Mister Black…”
“I TOLD YOU TO GET OUT!” Sirius roared, making the elf’s ears perk up as she straightened her posture. “OUT!”
She didn’t obey.
“Penny knows Mister Black is hurting,” she said in a measured, emotionless tone. “But Penny will not accept being treated like this!”
Sirius didn’t hear her. He was too busy trying not to fall apart over that stupid cake, over the memories its sweet scent dragged back, making his mouth water despite himself.
“You don’t need to worry. The bond that ties you together guarantees Mistress Black will always return to you…” Penny tried to console him.
Sirius furrowed his brows, glancing at her sideways. Hope tried to rise in his chest, but he crushed it viciously with a sniff. Scarlett wouldn’t come back because she loved him, but because of some stupid pact. Some ridiculous spell from when they were two foolish teenagers doing foolish things.
“You’re not helping, Penny,” he muttered through sobs. “Fuck. Shit. Bloody hell…” He dug a finger into the cake and tasted it, closing his eyes and sinking down onto the kitchen floor. Memories danced at the edges of his mind like figures in dresses of every colour—all of them bearing the face of the girl he’d once tucked flowers into the hair of. “I don’t want to hear about her anymore. I don’t want her to come back.”
He didn’t want to see Scarlett again—Merlin, he wanted to pretend she was dead. And yet, hope was deceitful. It lingered with the same relentless determination as his love for her. When Sirius let his guard down, it rooted itself deep, filling spaces in his chest he hadn’t even known were there.
He remained on the floor, eating the cake and staring blankly at the kitchen ceiling, Penny watching him with quiet pity.
Scarlett would come back.
And yet… how long would it take before she left again?
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 44: We’re different people now
Chapter Text
CXII
Sirius let his gaze wander across the room, crammed with ancient books lining the shelves right up to the vaulted ceiling, before it came to rest on the slumbering portraits of Hogwarts’ former headmasters. Strange devices hummed here and there, and curious magical artefacts lay scattered across the cabinets. At the centre stood a large oak desk, cluttered with parchment and a few peculiar silver instruments. Behind it, a vast window revealed the grounds of Hogwarts, the lake glinting beyond the glass and making him narrow his eyes slightly.
Dumbledore stood by Fawkes’s perch, gently stroking the phoenix with an inscrutable expression etched into the lines of his face.
“Sirius!”
The call made him turn instantly towards the voice.
Reggie crossed the office in a flash, flinging his arms round his godfather with all the strength he had. Sirius embraced him at once, a genuine smile tugging at his lips as he buried his nose in the boy’s dark hair and closed his eyes, imprinting into his very being the sensation of holding him. Reg was a head shorter than Sirius, but judging by the way he kept growing, he’d surpass him in a few years.
“Hi, Reggie.” Sirius ruffled the boy’s hair, cupping his face in both hands and studying his features – the freckled face so much like his mother’s, the aristocratic nose, the delicate lips. And those storm-grey eyes, streaked with blue like a tempest shot through with lightning.
“I missed you.” Regulus smiled once more. He had Scarlett’s smile, which sent a chill down Sirius’s spine. “I really missed you.” He pulled him into another hug.
Sirius kissed his hair, shaking his head as if he knew exactly what the boy meant. The torment he’d endured in Azkaban, trying to remember the bright peal of Reggie’s laughter, was finally over – for now he could witness the little boy’s happiness in person, the one he loved so fiercely.
His eyes filled with tears. Sirius didn’t know if they were from happiness or sadness…
Perhaps both.
He swallowed the lump in his throat with ease, pulling Reggie tighter into his arms as if he could shield him the way Scarlett once had. Trying to pass on the same sense of safety she’d given him.
“I missed you too,” he confessed, whispering before he parted from Reg. “Could we talk… alone?” Sirius looked towards Dumbledore.
“Of course. If you’d care to step out onto the veranda…” The Headmaster gestured towards a door just before the staircase that led up to his desk.
Sirius simply nodded, leading Reggie along, his eyes lingering with a flicker of disdain on the Slytherin uniform. He softened his gaze when he realised Reg was watching him.
As he opened the balcony door, the cold wind whipped through his long hair, forcing him to tie it back into a loose bun. Regulus, meanwhile, was utterly captivated by the view—the mountain range encircling the castle, the Black Lake glinting like molten mercury. The late afternoon light washed over the landscape, gilding the orange and yellow trees in shimmering gold.
“Merlin, I… I’ve only ever seen this balcony from a broomstick…” Reggie said, his voice carrying over the gusts.
“Yeah, James and I stumbled on it in our third year… tried to play a prank on Dumbledore back then, but it didn’t exactly go to plan.” Sirius smiled faintly at the memory. Therapy had helped a fair bit with the damage the Dementors had left behind, and while plenty of his memories were still frayed, he was slowly piecing most of them back together.
“What did you do?!” Regulus frowned, shielding his face from the sun’s glare.
“We put a dungbomb right in the archway of the door… waited for him to pass through…” Sirius rolled his eyes just thinking about it. “But it wasn’t him who came through…”
“Who was it?” Reg’s grin grew wider with every word Sirius spoke.
“McGonagall. Merlin, she was livid…” Sirius let out a laugh. “Gave us a fortnight’s worth of detentions… and separate ones at that! James wanted to curl up and die when he found out…”
The warmth that swelled in his chest turned to a sharp ache, twisting his smile into a quiet mask of anguish. Sirius drew a slow, deep breath, just as Asca had taught him, letting the ache ebb away as he exhaled.
Thinking about James was still… far too raw.
“Why didn’t my mum come?” Reggie asked, distracted by the sight of the giant squid stretching its tentacles across the Black Lake.
Sirius folded his arms, gripping the leather of his jacket as he tried to conjure an excuse that wouldn’t wound Reggie. He knew all too well what it felt like to be hurt by Scarlett—though Sirius was hardly blameless himself. Even so… he didn’t want the boy to resent her. So he wrestled his emotions into place and gave his godson’s shoulder an encouraging pat.
“Reg, your mum, she…” She’s a bloody nightmare. No. He couldn’t say that. He cleared his throat. “She’s… got her own struggles.” Sirius clenched his jaw. Regulus stayed silent, waiting for him to go on. “Er, after Azkaban… we… I mean, she… needs some time, you understand? She’s… been through a lot.”
“I know what Dementors do to people, Uncle.” There was a shadowed note in Reggie’s voice that made Sirius shiver.
“She… she’s not well. None of us are. And she… she loves you, Reg, she just needs a bit of time to… to…”
To pretend absolutely nothing happened, to go back to behaving like she’s seventeen. No. Argh, Sirius, focus!
“…to process… everything that’s happened… she was in Azkaban longer than I was, and… she went through more and… she’s not well.”
The grey-blue of Regulus’s eyes wavered, his brows slowly knitting together as his lips pressed into a tight line.
“Is there anything I can do? Could I write her another letter? Maybe…”
Sirius swallowed hard. He wanted so badly to blame himself for Scarlett leaving yet again. He should have held his tongue, but… he needed to say those three words sooner or later. Even knowing how she’d react.
“That’s a good idea…”
“Is she at home?” Reggie leaned on the balcony rail. “At—at your house, I mean. In central London.”
“Oh, erm, no.” Sirius rubbed his clammy palms on his trousers, avoiding his godson’s sceptical gaze with an unusual hesitation. “She… went to visit Orfy. And…”
“For Merlin’s sake, did he do something to her?!” Reg cut in, disbelief turning to fear. “Did he hurt her?!”
“No…” he answered, though he wasn’t entirely sure. “She… she’s fine.” He faltered. He knew Scarlett was fine. At least, she seemed fine. Physically, anyway. “She was shaken by what happened, she knew he’d been tortured, but… she didn’t know…”
“Orfy thinks the one who tortured him was my mum.” The sun flashed in Reggie’s eyes, swallowing the blue and igniting the grey like embers. “He thinks… she was the one responsible for… for my grandparents’ deaths… but… but I know that’s a lie, because…” He tried to explain, his voice climbing with each word.
“It wasn’t her, Reg.” Sirius gripped his shoulders tightly, as if trying to anchor him with his hands. “I spoke with your Uncle Nate. And Orfy… what they did to him…”
“Are you sure she’s all right?!” Reggie’s eyes filled with tears and Sirius gave him a reassuring smile, ruffling his dark hair.
“He didn’t hurt her, but… she needs time after that. It was… it was too much for her. Your mum… she always does this, Reggie.”
“Does what?” Regulus raised his brows, Sirius’s shadow reflected in the dark of his pupils.
Runs when things get tough because she’s a bloody coward, he wanted to say. But then he remembered her hiding around the house in Whiskers’s skin, just as she used to at Hogwarts in her final year.
His heart missed a beat as he realised she ran because she was afraid.
“She pulls away from people when she needs them most.” Sirius let the words slip out as he drew a deep breath.
“B-but… but you…” Regulus faltered. “You’re going to look after her, aren’t you?! I mean, you… you love each other!”
Sirius instinctively stepped back, as though he’d just taken a punch to the gut. He wanted desperately to pretend everything was under control, but his defences were threatening to give way, and not even the cold whipping at his cheeks could dull his reaction.
“What… who… who told you…”
Regulus slipped a hand into his pocket and drew out a photograph, placing it carefully in Sirius’s palm so the wind wouldn’t snatch it away. It took a monumental effort for Sirius to lower his gaze to the image.
The moment his eyes fell upon it—him holding Scarlett in his arms as they kissed with abandon—his heart simply stopped. His breath caught. His blood seemed to congeal in his veins, splintering into fine shards of ice that needled through his nerves with vicious precision.
The memory hit him in full force, spiralling round him with the same intensity as the wind, making the sun blaze sharper and the Black Lake churn into frothing waves. Scarlett’s body pressed close to his, warm and soft, her arms looped around his neck, her head tipped back, sunlight catching on the beads of sweat along her torso, her collarbone… her flushed cheeks.
Then his heart jolted back into life; his blood boiled, surging along its courses, thawing his muscles and fuelling the memory. The tang of salt on the air filled his senses, the rush of the sea roared, and James’s loud laughter rang out—the idiot clutching his camera—while Remus held Mary close, Marlene and Dorcas sat on a blanket further back, and Lily clutched her ridiculously large hat, shouting at James.
“Careful with the sea, love, you’ll end up ruining the camera!” she warned him, one hand planted on her hip.
“Photo, lovebirds! Photo!” James called, waving.
Sirius turned his gaze back to Scarlett, who was looking at him with such an intensity that he lost himself for a moment. Her long, curled lashes glinted in the sunlight, and the clear blue of her eyes was steeped in an intoxicating fascination. Leaning in slowly, Sirius claimed those lips that were his undoing; salty, surrendered.
The click of the camera was enough to drag him back. His fingers gripped the photograph so tightly it was on the verge of crumpling. His heart thudded so fiercely he thought it might give out, his mouth ran dry, and his eyes blurred. He blinked hard, looking back at Reggie as he handed the photo over, trying to purge the warm effervescence spreading through his body—quick and lethal as poison.
“I wish… I wish it were that simple,” Sirius confessed, rubbing the bridge of his nose and shrugging. “That photo… it was taken a long time ago, Reg.”
Regulus frowned, tucking the photograph away as though it were something precious.
“The Sirius and Scarlett in that picture don’t exist anymore,” he went on, his voice laced with quiet sadness. “We’re different people now.”
“I know… I know about my dad, but… you… you looked so happy and…” Reggie’s voice trembled, his nostrils flaring. He opened and closed his mouth, as if unwilling to let his fairytale start to unravel. “I, I thought…”
Blinking back tears, Regulus fell silent. His eyes searched for some kind of explanation, a word that might mend the love he’d believed in and shed light on what had happened with Scarius. Why they’d gone wrong.
Sirius hugged him again, pulling the boy tightly into his arms as though trying to comfort him with the same intensity he longed to comfort himself. The kind of embrace Scarlett and James had always given him. The safety they had passed on so effortlessly.
The silence was muffled by the icy breeze.
“We need to talk about… about what you did, Reggie,” Sirius finally said, holding his godson’s fringe between his fingers as he looked him in the eye. “According to Dumbledore’s letter, you attacked a classmate…”
Regulus drew slightly back from Sirius, spinning a ring nervously on his little finger. The sunlight glinted off the ruby, drawing Sirius’s attention to the jewel. It was Scarlett and Regulus’s engagement ring. Sirius felt a lump rise in his throat, forcing it down as he shifted his gaze to the back of Reggie’s hand, noting the absence of the Signet there. Had he used a spell to conceal it?
“I… it was… it was an accident.” Reg’s eyes reflected a heart overflowing, anxious and afraid. Sirius wanted to say it was all right, that he could tell him anything, but he stayed quiet, encouraging him to go on with just a look.
“I… me and Mimi… uh, Victoria…” Reggie cleared his throat. “We… we were in this… er, broom cupboard and…” His cheeks flushed red. “Luke… he saw us and… he threatened her and… I… I don’t know, it was… it was an accident.” He fixed his gaze on the floor, as if bracing for a long, stern lecture.
But Sirius could see right through his godson’s words. By Merlin, he displayed all of Scarlett’s little tells when she lied! The shifty look, the millisecond hesitation, the exaggerated affirmations as though he were trying to convince himself of what had happened.
The look Reggie gave him, however, completely disarmed him: those storm-grey eyes streaked with blue were pleading for understanding. Sirius softened his expression, drawing in a deep breath and ignoring the turmoil of his own racing pulse.
“I know, that’s what Dumbledore’s letter said,” Sirius replied, not letting his suspicion colour his voice. On the contrary, he kept it calm, even, ignoring the way the mere memory of Scarlett still sent ripples through his body. “I want to know what really happened.”
Regulus turned his face towards the balcony rail—not quickly enough to hide the torment in his eyes. Sirius arched an eyebrow, stepped back and leaned his hips against the stone balustrade, keeping his gaze fixed on his godson, waiting. Reggie held his breath, then let it out slowly, as if trying to keep himself in check.
“Er, I… Mimi… Victoria…”
“Your girlfriend?!” Though it came out as a question, Sirius’s tone made it sound like a statement. Reggie gave a small nod.
“She’s from that family… Rookwood…”
“I know the Rookwoods,” Sirius muttered darkly.
“I’m certain they hit her. Her parents… or her brothers… I’m not entirely sure, but…” Regulus blinked a few times, resting his elbows on the rail. Sirius caught himself absently running a hand over the scars on his thigh through the fabric of his trousers. “Well, I… I took the blame, because… I didn’t want… I mean, her brother…”
“So she’s the one who attacked the boy, then?!” Sirius cut in, holding Reggie’s hand gently, his eyes flicking to the ring on his little finger. His jaw tightened.
“I took the blame. I didn’t want her… her to be punished for it and… well, it’s not as if I was going to get a beating…”
Sirius gave a short, quiet huff of laughter, giving his godson a light pat on the shoulder as he rested both palms on the railing. He looked up at the clear sky, already beginning to fade. His heart eased its rhythm as he realised how much Reggie was like him—despite being Regulus’s son. A kind of muted satisfaction and skewed pride swelled in his chest, enough that Sirius couldn’t stop the smile creeping at the corners of his mouth.
“On Halloween in ’76…” He glanced at his godson from the corner of his eye without turning his head. “We were more or less kidnapped by Death Eaters…”
“What?” Reggie’s brow knitted, his attention sharpening hungrily.
“Oh, it was nothing much… your mum ended up saving us with her Portkey… but what I’m saying is… when we got back, Dumbledore was livid. He wanted to strip James and Remus of their prefect badges, so I took the blame. Just like you took the blame for this…” He watched Regulus rest his head on his arm. Sirius slipped an arm around the boy’s shoulders, pulling him closer, savouring the feeling of having that sweet, smiling lad in his arms again.
“So… I’m not getting a telling-off?!” Reg’s voice, muffled against his leather jacket, made Sirius burst out laughing.
“For protecting the people you love? No.” Sirius kissed his hair, shaking his head. “On the contrary, when you’re back from the holidays… I’ll make you so many strawberry pancakes you’ll be sick of them.”
Reggie looked up at him with so much expectation, so much hope, so much nervous energy that Sirius silently vowed to make every single one of his godsons’ wishes come true. He would give them everything he never had—he’d been doing that for Reggie since he was a tiny child—and he would keep doing it. He’d make Harry and Reggie be what Sirius and Red never managed to be, what he and James once were. Brothers from different mothers and fathers, but a steady, happy family.
“Do you think… that my mum…”
“She’ll be there.” Sirius nodded, knowing exactly what Reggie meant. He would make Scarlett spend time with her son and Harry in the summer, even if he had to drag her by the hair.
It wasn’t ideal to have to go that far—he didn’t want to force Scarlett into anything she didn’t want—but Reggie and Harry deserved a family, and Sirius would give that to them. He would make them happy and drown himself in that happiness until he reclaimed his own, fulfilling his faded, battered dream of building a family that was the complete opposite of his own. He would kill the Black legacy without a shred of remorse—and he almost wished his mother were still alive just so she could see that everything she despised most was happening.
Instinctively, Sirius’s gaze fell to the ring on Reggie’s little finger. He ran his thumb across the cold stone, letting a tangle of emotions rise from deep in his chest to the surface.
“The Black engagement ring. Before it belonged to your mum, it belonged to mine,” he murmured, and Reggie pulled away slightly, looking down at the jewel. “A charming lady,” Sirius added with a sarcastic little laugh. “She did everything she could to steal you away from me.”
“She wanted to stay with me when you were sent to prison,” Regulus confessed, slipping the ring off and holding it up, watching the ruby catch the golden sunlight and refract it into violet rays. “I visited her a few times…”
“You visited?!”
“Yeah, some weekends… a bit before she died… Uncle Nate always came with me, and the two of them would argue over the things she said… she used to say that… that I was precious and that… that she needed to teach me how to be a respectable pure-blood…”
“Oh, I bet she did…” Sirius’s smile soured on his lips. “She thought she’d get custody of you. She accused your mum of a crime she didn’t commit just for that, you know?!”
“What crime?!” Reg frowned.
“Your grandfather’s murder.” Sirius’s face turned grave. “It wasn’t her.”
“And the McKinnons? She… she said she did it for me. For Orfy.” Reggie lowered his gaze. “If that’s true, then… she did it to protect us…”
Sirius had used that very same reasoning to justify Scarlett’s actions to Remus, but hearing it from Reggie’s lips made him want to believe it. As if it were true. As if she were someone far more tragic than the nightmare he had constructed, as if she didn’t have fangs or cruelty, easing the mountain of blame he had piled on her.
Sirius didn’t want to feel empathy for Scarlett. For Merlin’s sake, he didn’t want to feel anything for her, but he couldn’t control his emotions in that moment, not with the anguish clawing up his throat and leaving his chest in a sudden rush of breath.
He wanted to confirm to Reggie that she had indeed done it to protect them, but even his lies had their limits. And he didn’t know if Scarlett was capable of lying to her own son.
He looked at Reggie, but all he saw was a blur. Tears clouded his vision. Scarlett’s reactions had never made more sense than they did now; the terror, the hesitation, the regret. The way her eyes unfocused from reality, the way her throat shifted under the tension that bound her, how her composure dissolved into a penance Sirius had first thought was fear of owning up, but now… now he believed it was fear of unravelling the truth.
As if it were far too terrifying to face the idea that she had killed five people with the most unforgivable curse of all to protect her brother and her son. Sirius didn’t want to put himself in her place, but it was so hard to stop himself when the tears traced a warm, wet path down his cheeks, disappearing into his beard.
“She told you that?!” he heard himself ask. There was fear in his voice. Fear and longing.
“Yes, she… said she had to protect us and prove her loyalty.” Reggie said it with a strange tone, as if he too were trying to grow accustomed to his mother’s crimes. “Are you… crying?”
Voldemort wanted me to… to have his child, Scarlett’s voice echoed in his mind. He wanted me to have Reggie quickly so that…
If she’d had a child with Voldemort, would he have killed Reggie? Would he have done something to him? Would he have turned Reggie into an experiment the way he had Orfeu?! But… it didn’t make sense. None of it made sense. Orion and Walburga, Regulus and she had been loyal to the Dark Lord, and he would never harm the heir of the Black family.
So why… why did Scarlett need to protect Reg?
“No.” He lied. He knew there were things Scarlett wasn’t telling him about what had happened; after all, there was a blood pact involved. Were the two connected?
Sirius clenched his fists. It was because of the Signet. It had to be.
The balcony door opened, and Sirius quickly wiped his tears away with the back of his hand, finding Dumbledore standing there, a mild smile on his face as the sun glinted off his half-moon spectacles. Reggie didn’t take his eyes off his godfather, as though the headmaster’s imposing presence meant nothing to him.
“Mr Black, I’m afraid your time with Sirius has come to an end,” Dumbledore announced, his silver beard swaying gently in the wind. “We need to speak. Alone.” It sounded more like an instruction than a request. The Headmaster studied Sirius briefly before turning on his heel and heading back into his office.
Regulus immediately hugged him tightly, burying his face in his coat.
“See you in two weeks, son… er, I mean, Reg.” Sirius cleared his throat with an awkward little laugh, watching the sweet smile his godson gave him.
“All right, Dad,” Reggie teased, stepping back. “Can I… send you letters?”
“No,” Sirius said, rolling his eyes with a hint of sarcasm. “You must!”
“Tell Uncle Rem I love him and that I miss him and… tell my mum that… that I hope she gets better and…” His eyes widened, his chest swelling like he desperately needed to say the right thing. “That I love her.”
“Consider it done, Reg.” Sirius gave him a warm, reassuring smile, watching him walk through the doorway before stopping and glancing back over his shoulder.
“Sirius?” Reggie called, though he was still looking right at him. “I love you.”
For a few seconds, Sirius was speechless. How long had it been since he’d heard those words? Especially… from Reggie. The smile that spread across his lips was unstoppable and radiant, showing his perfect teeth as his whole body was wrapped in a softness as light as a summer night.
“Love you too, lad.” Sirius winked at his godson, who gave him a little wave before disappearing.
He stayed out there for a few minutes, letting the information settle in his mind. He rubbed his eyes and cracked his neck. It felt as though the more he tried to swim against the tide called Scarlett Gaunt, the more she dragged him back. It was exhausting, suffocating, terrifying. Everything about that woman filled him with panic—from her icy eyes to the delicate little toes on her feet; from the freckles on her cheeks to the hair he had once adorned with a dozen colourful flowers.
When he stepped back into the office, he found Dumbledore standing in front of the windows behind his desk, watching the tiny dark specks that were the students having picnics on the Hogwarts lawns. Sirius positioned himself beside the Headmaster, clasping his hands behind his back, still dazed. He needed to talk to Scarlett, even if it was the last thing he wanted.
“I want to see Harry,” Sirius said, earning a sidelong glance from the Headmaster.
“I’m afraid that won’t be possible, Sirius. We need to talk,” Dumbledore replied without relinquishing his lofty composure. “I know you want Harry to spend the summer at your house.”
Sirius slowly furrowed his brow, trying to untangle what Dumbledore was leaving unsaid.
“And…?” he prompted the Headmaster to continue.
“He needs to stay at his aunt and uncle’s.”
The pause in Sirius’s reaction was obliterated by the throbbing anger coursing through his veins, his features hardening as his gaze grew sharper. Dumbledore remained unshaken, the corner of his mouth curling ever so slightly, as if he’d been expecting that very response from Sirius.
“There isn’t the slightest chance of that happening, Albus,” Sirius growled, jaw clenched tight.
“Harry needs—”
“With all due respect, Albus, I’m not letting Harry spend the summer in the house of those filthy Muggles!”
“Those filthy Muggles are his family… they’ve looked after Harry since he was a baby…”
Sirius laughed, a laugh dripping with scorn.
“I know exactly who they are; I met them at the Evans’ funeral! They’re despicable people, Albus… petty, small-minded, cruel… I saw the way Lily’s sister treated her for being a witch! You cannot let Harry go on growing up in that environment!” His voice rose with every word.
“And what do you suggest, Sirius? That he grows up with our mutual friend? With a murderer?” Dumbledore’s tone was so placid behind the narrowed eyes and the glint of his glasses that it took Sirius a moment to catch the irony in it.
“What?” Sirius gasped, stunned. “No… Scarlett…”
“And what assurance do I have that she wouldn’t harm Harry?” the Headmaster cut him off. Though there was no rudeness in his words, there was a dismissive firmness that stung all the same.
“She’d never do that!” Sirius gritted his teeth at the mere suggestion, feeling for a moment like a Hogwarts student again, being told off by Dumbledore.
“The same way she wouldn’t harm the McKinnons?” The old wizard stroked his beard.
“She didn’t have a choice! She… she did it to protect—” Sirius tried to justify, hating how his voice faltered in that instant.
“And what if she has no choice this time either?” Dumbledore studied him over the glinting lenses of his spectacles.
“She would never do that and… even if she tried… I’d never allow it, Dumbledore. Never.” Sirius tried to pour as much conviction as he could into the statement, but it wasn’t much, not when he’d been blindsided like this. He loathed how easily he’d become a hostage to his own feelings.
“It’s far too risky, Sirius. Harry will go to his aunt and uncle’s for the summer. He must stay there for Lily’s blood protection to hold.”
“It isn’t too risky!” Sirius almost shouted, his voice overtaking the Headmaster’s. “And… he doesn’t have to stay the entire summer for the protection to work! It isn’t fair that he grows up with those people…”
“It isn’t fair. But it’s the safest option.” Dumbledore fixed him with an unbearably resolute look.
Sirius shuddered, his self-control slipping bit by bit through his fingers, the words scattering from his mind, logic unravelled by emotion. Cold perplexity crept through his body, bringing with it a wave of nausea. It was as if the remnants of the war would never be left behind, no matter how hard he scrubbed and tried to rid himself of them.
“I have rights over him, Dumbledore! I’m his godfather!” His nostrils flared, his face twisting until it became a mask of steel.
“I know. But while his guardianship remains in my name, he will go to his aunt and uncle’s.” The Headmaster dismissed his protests as one might a sulky child.
Sirius felt the air grow thin. It was as though James was being torn from him all over again. He clenched his fists so hard his nails bit into his palms. Then he drew a deep breath and tried to marshal his arguments.
“I’ve done everything you’ve asked of me up to now—I’m investigating the Department of Mysteries, I’m looking after Scarlett, I’m finishing my Auror training… all I’m asking is for Harry to spend the summer with me…” His plea slipped into a supplication. Sirius didn’t care. He’d have gone down on his knees if it meant having Harry with him.
“Do not attempt to oppose me, Sirius. My word is final.” Dumbledore lifted his chin in a gesture of quiet authority.
Sirius nodded slowly, the blood bubbling through his veins, searing his bones, melting his heart. He staggered back, retreating with quick strides, the rush of blood loud in his ears. He stopped just before activating his portkey, his pocket watch in hand, squeezing it in his palm as though willing it to give him courage.
“We’ll see about that,” he muttered to himself, not caring whether Dumbledore heard.
.
.
.
Sirius could barely take in what Alastor Moody was saying. Twirling his quill endlessly between his fingers, he pored over the book on his desk, its title reading: Spells Involving Blood and Their Peculiarities. The page Sirius was fixated on detailed the bond of blood charm.
The very spell Dumbledore had used on Harry after James and Lily’s deaths to keep him safe in his aunt and uncle’s house. There were a few ridiculous rules, of course, like always referring to the Dursleys’ house as his home and having to visit at least once a year, for a minimum of eight hours. That meant Sirius couldn’t collect him the same day he returned from Hogwarts, but…
The next day. Yes, that was it. Perfect. Dumbledore wouldn’t suspect a thing, and Sirius could still prove that Scarlett wasn’t a threat. He smiled to himself at the plan he’d just concocted, snapping the book shut as he noticed everyone else rising from their chairs.
“Black! Tonks! Stay put!” Moody barked, shooing the other trainees away with a flick of his hand, his tone as sharp and irritable as ever.
The last time Sirius had seen the retired Auror—back when he was arrested—Mad-Eye Moody still had his full nose, an extra eye, and an extra leg. Now, the old paranoid wizard narrowed his mismatched eyes: one small, dark and shrewd, the other large, round, electric blue—the magical eye that could see through walls, doors, and the back of Moody’s own head.
Sirius gathered his things and glanced at the girl with short, spiky hair the colour of screaming violet. She’d stayed behind as well. Her dark, sparkling eyes watched him with curiosity, and her pale, heart-shaped face reminded him of someone else. Or… perhaps he knew her already.
Wait—did Moody just say Tonks?!
He knew someone with that surname. He… he’d married into Sirius’s family and then… they’d had a daughter. Who was she, Sirius?!
“Dora?!” The name slipped from his lips in a breath.
“Took you long enough!” Tonks planted both hands on her hips before yanking him into a sudden hug. “Weeks, Sirius—weeks I’ve been waiting for you to recognise me!”
Sirius was far too gobsmacked to answer, trying to push Tonks back so he could get a better look at her, but she clung on, squeezing him like she was eager to strangle him. He shot Moody a nervous glance, silently pleading for help.
“Och, Tonks! Let the man breathe!” Mad-Eye snapped, irritation dripping from his voice as he folded his arms. His magical eye spun madly in its socket, rolling full circle. “By Merlin’s bloody balls, lass, you’ll crush him!”
“All right, all right, my fault…” She rolled her eyes, stepping back from Sirius and promptly tripping over a chair, landing on her backside with a thud. “Whoa—since when was that chair there?!”
“I cannae believe you two are the best this lot has to offer…” Moody muttered, drumming his fingers against a pile of folders on his desk. “Know what this is?!”
Sirius helped Tonks up, pressing his lips together to hold back a laugh. She shot him a glare that could have burned a hole in his head. Since when had that little hellion of a girl turned into… a woman?! He had no idea what to say, so he kept his mouth shut.
Mad-Eye cleared his throat loudly, giving the folders a sharp smack with his finger.
“A pile of folders,” Tonks answered, as if it were obvious.
“Reports,” Sirius corrected, arching a brow at his cousin. He wanted badly to ask about Andromeda and Ted, but he kept his expression serious as he turned back to Moody.
“Good. Reports,” the retired Auror snapped. “And they’re about a very important Ministry investigation, and you two’ll be handling it.”
“But we haven’t even graduated yet…” Tonks began, but Moody cut her off with a lifted finger.
“And I’m retired—aye, yet here I am. The Ministry’s up to its neck in work and down on Aurors, so the trainees most likely to pass their exams get a wee taste of the admin side. Besides, you’ve dealt with this kind before, Black.”
Sirius frowned.
“What kind of person?”
“Bearer of a Signet,” Moody growled, his tone laced with irritation. “Right. Go through the report, get it back to me by month’s end. Off you go.” He waved them away like a man eager to be rid of them.
Sirius made a monumental effort not to show even a flicker of suspicion. Moody was paranoid enough as it was; even now, when he seemed casual, if Sirius exhaled too quick or too slow, or let a hint of tension slip, it’d draw Mad-Eye’s notice. So he kept tight control over himself, masking it all with bored indifference as he scooped up half the folders and headed for the door.
“So, Sirius, fancy lunch at mine?!” Tonks chirped the moment they stepped outside the room.
It took him a few seconds to process what she’d just said. His mind was still reeling from what Moody had implied about him having dealt with Bearers of a Signet before. He stopped walking. So did Tonks.
“Sirius? You all right?” Her hair shifted to bubblegum pink. “What’s with that face? Got a bit emotional? Blood pressure drop? Leave the cooker on?”
Sirius very much wanted to tell Nymphadora to shut it, but Kingsley passed by and added another folder to his stack. The name Pandora Lovegood leapt out at him at once, and his heart skipped a few beats.
“Dora… less. Much less.” He ruffled her pink hair the way he used to when she was a child, which annoyed her to no end.
“Argh, stop it!” Pulling away with a grimace, Tonks meticulously adjusted it back into its original spiky shape.
“Thanks for the invite—maybe another day.” Sirius pushed aside all the emotions bubbling in his chest. He hadn’t expected to see Tonks here. He didn’t want to dredge up the memories that came with her.
He sighed. He only wanted a minute of peace and the certainty that Harry would spend the summer with him. He just wanted his bloody family together. Was that too much to ask?
Well, when it came to Scarlett and Dumbledore, apparently it was.
“When I told Mum about you, she was really surprised. From Azkaban prisoner to Auror trainee… I don’t know how you managed it, but plenty of people weren’t happy the Ministry put you here…”
“I know that, Dora.” Sirius avoided looking at the folders he carried, tucking them under his arm. “I’ll pay your mother a visit later…”
“Tomorrow afternoon I’m going to the Leaky Cauldron with June and Orfeu… you should come too. They’d love to see you!”
Sirius drew his brows together and narrowed his eyes slightly.
“How do you know them?!”
“Because I was in the same year as June, and Orfeu was four years above us. And now he works with another old Hogwarts mate… Bill Weasley—you might remember him…”
He really wanted to talk to Tonks about everything that had happened in the past, but his head wasn’t in it, so all he did was shrug and give a bewildered smile.
“I need to go, Dora…” he murmured, giving his cousin a light pat on the shoulder before following the crowd towards the lifts.
The moment Sirius arrived home, he tossed the folders onto the table in the sitting room, his gaze wandering briefly to the garden where Penny was feeding Buckbeak. He ran his fingers along the stack, stopping at Pandora’s file, his hand lingering on the tab. He tried to prise it open, but his palms grew damp, and his breath caught in his throat.
Sirius vaguely remembered the wedding invitation he’d received from Pan and Xen. The sharp pain that had slashed through his chest at not having Scarlett by his side; the regret of not going to see his friend marry, even if it meant going alone. He faintly recalled Pan visiting him during the grim days when he was getting clean from the drugs, and then… she’d married Xenophilius, and the two of them had gone to keep safe from the war in some isolated Lovegood residence.
He couldn’t remember the last time he’d spoken to Pandora. But holding that memory of her invitation in his mind dragged forward another wedding, one that filled his eyes to the brim with tears.
James and Lily’s wedding. Or Jily’s do, as the closest friends had called it.
Sirius hardly noticed himself wandering aimlessly through the house, until he stopped in front of the room that had once been the studio. Boxes were stacked high, the canvases were dusty, the instruments packed away… there were so many memories in that room, but he couldn’t quite reach any of them. They were all frayed scraps, fragile and incomplete, as though the dementors had stretched them until they tore into faded pieces with no beginning, middle, or end.
He drew his wand and, with a flick, the boxes sprang open, instruments assembling themselves one by one: the stands for Scarlett’s keyboards, the bass and guitar amplifiers that had once belonged to Remus and James… and the parts of the drum kit.
Leaning against the doorframe, Sirius watched as the shelves slotted neatly together, holding the cymbals, toms, the snare, and finally the bass drum with its double pedal. A wave crashed through his whole body as his legs carried him into the room that felt as though it had turned back time.
His drum kit was acrylic—he had a wooden one too, but he hadn’t touched it since Scarlett was imprisoned. Playing it would’ve been an act of rebellion, as the wooden kit had been a gift from her. Sirius didn’t want anything that reminded him of her—nothing except for Reggie. His nephew was the one constant in his life that ensured he could never fully stop thinking about her. So, the black acrylic kit had become his main instrument while the Tama stayed packed away, untouched ever since.
He sat down on the stool, feeling the rough grain of the worn drumsticks against his fingertips. He pressed his feet into the pedals, the thrum of the bass drum vibrating through his whole body. Sirius cracked his neck and tentatively struck the snare and toms, closing his eyes as though trying to capture, with his hands, the memories fluttering around him like butterflies.
He wasn’t there to remember, so he let the memories circle him but never settle, never touch. He kept himself in motion, hammering out erratic rhythms on the drums as if he could somehow rediscover the connection he once felt with music.
Sirius knew all too well that to become a Death Eater one had to kill—Muggles, Muggle-borns, or enemies of the Dark Lord. That was how Scarlett had become one—by killing the McKinnons. But all of them? Five lives taken to save two? No… that didn’t add up.
She could have killed five Muggles in the street. So why the McKinnons? Why Marlene?! Was she forced? Did they use Orfy… no. Scarlett had access to the McKinnons’ house the moment Marlene’s uncle was murdered—making everyone who set foot in that house Secret Keepers.
Sirius made the cymbal hiss with a chaotic flourish, doubling the tempo of his movements. With his breath ragged, sweat running through his beard, and his body taut with tension, the answer hit him like a jolt.
Regulus.
Regulus had saved Orfeu from Voldemort. Orfy had been tortured by Voldemort. He was a test subject. If Scarlett was loyal to him, then Orfeu shouldn’t have been kept that way… should he? He knew the Dark Lord had been known to reward his followers, so what had Scarlett gained from the deaths of the McKinnons? It couldn’t have been just the Dark Mark. And there was still the blood pact…
Sirius struck the cymbals again, letting them ring out in the air as his arms hung there, the drumsticks slipping from his damp fingers. He eased his posture, shoulders sagging as he slowly stood up.
He needed to visit Thanatos’s memory in the Pensieve.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 45: I want a better world for my son
Notes:
Sorry for the delay. I had a creative outburst and was writing like crazy to finally reach the Goblet of Fire, and I did it! Hehe. Anyway, hope you guys like it! <3
Chapter Text
CXIII
The silence at the Slytherin table was almost tangible. Eyes darted back and forth, but always landed on Scarlett, whose attention was entirely fixed on the Gryffindor table across the Great Hall, where Sirius Black and James Potter were craning their necks to keep an eye on her. Pandora Malfoy, sitting beside her, pretended to listen to Dumbledore's speech, but her left hand was clasping Scarlett’s right one beneath the table.
"You going to be alright? If you want, I can ask—"
"I will." Scarlett replied with such certainty that Sirius fell silent. They were ascending the entrance stairs of the castle, where Minerva was instructing the students to move along.
"Are you sure?"
"I am, Sirius." She rolled her eyes, then gave him a smile so sweet it left him speechless.
"Alright then… are we going to the Undercroft together?!" Sirius pulled her by the waist, steering her out of the way of a few hurried Hufflepuffs.
"Shall I fetch you from the Gryffindor Common Room with the cloak?!" Scarlett suggested, frowning at Lily who was arguing with Peeves up ahead.
“…there is a war at our doorstep. Many of you have lost family members, friends, loved ones. Many had to go into hiding over the holidays or, in some cases, even considered not returning for the school year. I’d like to reiterate that there is no safer place in Great Britain than Hogwarts. And that always, no matter what happens, there will be a place for you at our school. However, we are implementing some safety measures…” Dumbledore’s voice invaded her thoughts, but Scarlett shook it off.
“Or we could meet halfway… on the musician’s staircase?!” The concern in Sirius’s eyes should have reassured Scarlett, but all she felt was irritation.
"I'll fetch you from your common room!" she replied firmly.
The Great Hall filled with applause, and Scarlett blinked, jerking her head back in surprise as she was pulled out of her reverie. At the staff table, her uncle Thanatos Gaunt was acknowledging the clapping with a nod. His caramel eyes were fixed directly on her, and as a reflex, she joined in the applause.
The Slytherin table buzzed with breathless sighs at the excitement of having a Gaunt teaching Dark Arts at the school. Scarlett searched for Sirius among the students, finding him deep in a heated discussion with Marlene.
Scarlett simply crossed her arms, staring at the platters and plates that were beginning to fill with food and drink. She speared a pea from a roast lamb with mashed potatoes, watching the steam curl up from the little green seed.
"Gaunt, your uncle’s going to teach us DADA! He’s so handsome!" Amanda Wilkes tried to make conversation, but was deliberately ignored.
"Does he have a girlfriend?" Charlotte Greengrass leaned on the table.
Scarlett let out a nasal laugh, her face taking on a wicked edge.
"Why are you lot talking to me, little Death Eater wannabes?" she hissed, stabbing her fork into a piece of lamb with more force than necessary, drawing nearby glances.
"What? We didn’t—"
"We didn’t do anything to your family!" Wilkes cut Greengrass off, twirling a strand of her red hair around her finger.
"We? So you admit you’re one of them?!" Scarlett pierced Amanda with a glare, gripping the fork so tightly her knuckles had gone white.
"Convenient, isn’t it? All of them dying, except for you…" Jim Avery butted into the conversation, curling his lips into a sneer. Brandon Nott, beside him, burst out laughing.
The indifference was swiftly overtaken by rage, which threatened to erupt the moment Scarlett grabbed her dinner knife and slammed it into the table with a loud crack, silencing the nearby chatter and drawing the attention of the Bloody Baron. Pandora instantly reached for her hand, and Avery’s smirk widened, as did Nott’s interest.
"Next time you open your mouth… I’ll ram this knife down your throat." The threat rolled so naturally off her lips that Avery’s face flickered with surprise, and the surrounding Slytherins’ eyes went wide.
"Love to see you try," Jim kept provoking, drumming his fingers beside his own knife in challenge.
The two students seated between them were nearly toppling backwards on the bench, trying to put some distance. Scarlett tensed her whole body, ready to repeat the punches she'd landed on Avery the previous year, but the House ghost drifted between them, his chains rattling and phantom blood dripping across the roast lamb.
"Gentlefolk, I suggest you refrain from a massacre in the Great Hall. Dumbledore would be rather displeased if such a thing occurred." The ghost looked at them with weary disdain.
"All fine here," Jim shrugged, shooting Wilkes, Greengrass and Nott a smug look. "Just a bit of friendly banter."
Scarlett released the knife handle, resting her elbows on the table as she held back the eruption building in her chest. Pandora filled her plate with a variety of food, and Scarlett spent a good while deciding what to eat first.
The look she and Avery exchanged, however, sparked and crackled. Dinner was soon brought to a close by Dumbledore, whose speech barely registered in Scarlett’s ears. She took a deep breath, smothering her anger as she stood and followed the crowd of Slytherins towards the common room. She ignored Regulus the entire way, who kept a few steps behind in silence, though his eyes flicked to her every other minute.
It was easy to shut her ears to the cruel remarks of her Housemates. Scarlett sank into a state of such deep torpor that it was Pandora who guided her up the mermaid staircase, and the two stopped in front of Merlin’s statue as the seventh-years were introduced to their special quarters.
Apparently, Slytherin offered individual rooms to seventh-year students, which were accessed by ascending the steps winding around the sculpture of the famous wizard. All of a sudden, the already crowded space felt stifling. Regulus weaved through several Slytherins to reach her, his face cloaked in its usual mask of apathy.
“All seventh-years, follow me — we’re going to show you your rooms…” Evan Rosier, newly appointed Head Boy, gestured for the seventh-years to enter the corridor. His lips curled into a smirk as he caught sight of Scarlett amid the sea of students, before moving to the front of the line.
“Scar…” Regulus called her.
Scarlett was staring at the floor, glancing sideways at Red when he touched her shoulder. She looked different. Her face had grown thinner, dark circles sunk deep under her eyes, and the cunning glint that used to dance in her gaze was gone. All that remained in her ocean eyes was stifling silence — and green flames howling within pitch-dark pupils.
Regulus felt his stomach twist, dinner burning its way up his throat. He opened his mouth to speak, but the way Scarlett looked at him — cold and distant, like she didn’t even recognise him — hurt more than he cared to admit. Still, he didn’t let go of her shoulder, feeling the jut of bone beneath the heavy cloak.
“I can… I can show you to your room…” Red finally said, after clearing his throat.
“No need.” Scarlett replied, her voice void of anger. No outrage… no sorrow. Nothing at all, as if she were one of his mother’s eerie dolls. Regulus froze, lost for words. Lost for action.
Then she walked past him and climbed the staircase without once looking back. Pandora made to follow, but Wilkes stopped her with a condescending smile.
“Only seventh-years allowed down that corridor…” She seemed to relish barring Pan from proceeding, her gaze sliding to Regulus beside her. “Or prefects…” Amanda flicked Red’s badge with a smirk.
Pandora and Regulus exchanged a glance, and she clenched her jaw, nodding for him to follow Scarlett. He understood immediately, climbing the stairs in search of his brother’s girlfriend. Leading the group, Evan was calling out names and directing each student to their respective room. Red quickened his pace towards him, hoping to get a better view of the end of the corridor.
The space wasn’t packed, but it wasn’t designed for the crowd that had gathered either. There were no more than twenty-two seventh-years, and half had already gone into their dormitories.
“Scarlett Gaunt,” Evan called out, and Regulus rose onto his toes to see Scar stepping forward from beside Helena Selwyn and Amanda Wilkes, heading towards her room.
He moved in her direction, but ended up bumping into Avery, who ignored him completely. He was far too busy whispering and exchanging conspiratorial looks with Snape and Mulciber, whose stifled snickers echoed just as Scarlett reached for the doorknob.
Regulus frowned, speeding up the moment his danger instinct shrieked in his ears. He shoved people out of his way, but it wasn’t enough to reach Scarlett in time.
As soon as she opened the door, thick black smoke poured out into the corridor, rising in chaotic spirals as wild flames erupted all at once, licking the air and the doorframe.
Scarlett’s breath caught in her throat at once, the wave of heat knocking her backwards as a cascade of memories lit up in her mind with the same speed as the flash of fire — the flames growing in her gaze while reality diminished.
“Scarlett…” the voice called her, a dark silhouette wreathed in fire. “Scarlett!” it repeated, reaching out a hand to her. She tried to move, tried to grab him, tried to save herself… tried to scream for Orfy. But the blaze swallowed him whole, the world around her turning to ash, and she collapsed onto the floor, the fire climbing the walls and sending the other Slytherins into panic, until someone shouted Riddikulus and—
The flames turned into confetti, but the screaming didn’t stop — though there were laughs too. Scarlett couldn’t be sure. The sounds felt distant. Her heart pounded furiously, as if determined to break through her ribs, and her ears were ringing. Sweat streamed down her cheeks… or were they tears?
The fire was gone, but Scarlett could still hear it crackling, the suffocating heat crawling under her skin, the smoke poisoning her lungs. She couldn’t breathe, coughing uncontrollably, her consciousness flickering. She blinked away the tears, the laughter growing louder, louder…
Regulus, wand in hand, made to approach Scarlett, but Evan grabbed him by the cloak. He tried to break free, but the Head Boy was stronger and seemed determined to let Scarlett endure the ordeal.
“Let me go, Evan…” Red demanded, his voice firm. “Let me go!”
“No.” Rosier looked at him with a lopsided smile, turning his attention back to Scarlett. “You already ruined it by scaring the boggart off… now, you’ll help her only when I say so. Got that, Reggie?!”
A chill ran down Regulus’s neck at the command, his eyes widening as he saw Scarlett collapsed on the floor, while Avery, Mulciber, and Snape’s laughter echoed around them, ripping him from his orbit. He lifted his wand hand again, but Rosier caught his wrist and pushed it down.
“Let’s find out who the real Scarlett is…” Evan murmured to Regulus, his dark irises gleaming with sick amusement. “Whether she’ll run… or whether she’ll fight.”
Scarlett, eyes wide and hands trembling, could do little more than cry and gasp for breath. Her chest rose and fell rapidly, the scraps of oxygen she managed to draw in expelled just as quickly by coughing and ragged sobs. She hadn’t even tried to get up, remaining on the cold, dark metal floor. Avery and Mulciber were still laughing, though Snape no longer seemed to find it funny.
Despite her blurred vision, she could make out the outlines of the three Slytherins a short distance away. She turned her gaze back to the door of her room — now perfectly normal. No sign of fire.
The unbearable heat had turned to a bone-deep chill, creeping into her heart and speeding up the eruption rising in her chest; the terror transmuted into rage. The sweat clinging to her clothes and dripping from her brow was no longer from fear. The ice in her veins turned to embers — and the embers to lava, pumping seething fury through every inch of her body.
Avery and Mulciber’s mouths were still curled in cruel satisfaction. Snape joined them as they turned their backs on Scarlett, heading towards their rooms.
Curled on the ground, Scarlett slowly began to move, every limb shaking violently. Her posture shifted — the shadow on the wall transforming from a frightened creature into a hunter lying in wait. She raised her head, black hair clinging thickly to her face, but it wasn’t enough to conceal the vengeful lightning in her blue eyes. Regulus took a step back as a metallic taste filled his mouth — a kind of magic only Scarlett possessed.
Ancient magic.
With an almost instinctive movement, she raised her wand — her hands still trembling, but the spell was precise.
“Crucio!” she snarled, with a ferocity even she didn’t recognise. Red sparks laced with ancestral blue erupted from her wand and struck Mulciber with such force that he was hurled violently against the far wall of the corridor, then slid to the floor, unconscious.
A deafening silence followed the attack, broken only by Evan Rosier’s sarcastic applause as he watched the scene with a look of approval. Snape and Avery, startled, drew their wands, and Regulus swiftly did the same, stepping in front of Scarlett.
“Lower your wands, all three of you,” Evan ordered, still smiling, his gaze locked on Scarlett. “This is Dark Lord business.” He swept his eyes over the other seventh-years who stood in stunned silence, witnessing what had just happened. “If Slughorn or Dumbledore find out what happened here… well, you know what we do to snitches.” His grin turned razor-sharp.
Though she tried her best to hold it in, Scarlett began to sob uncontrollably, violent tremors wracking her body as the shock and guilt rebounded. She felt so exhausted she hadn’t yet processed what she had done — stress causing black spots to bloom in her vision.
“Scarlett…”
“Sirius…” was all she managed to say, before surrendering to the exhaustion.
.
.
.
“Isn’t this band from your time?” Mike tossed a drumstick into the air and caught it. Scarlett pretended to be far too busy fiddling with her borrowed synthesiser, until something moved in her peripheral vision. Reflexively, she ducked, and the drumstick flew past her in a blink.
“What the fuck, Mike?!” Scarlett raised an eyebrow, watching the drummer flash a grin that could melt any girl under twenty.
“I’m talking to you!” he complained, hand on his chest as though heartbroken by the neglect.
“What the fuck are you on about?” she muttered, crouching beside the cable case and beginning to unravel one, eyeing him sideways.
“Jethro Tull.” Mike planted his feet on the tom and crossed his legs. If he weren’t so blonde and skinny, he might’ve passed for a Sirius knock-off, purely because of his personality. In appearance, though, he looked more like Remus.
Her personal nightmare. A bizarre chimera of Sirius and Remus — the two people who hated her most at the moment.
“Yeah. My dad loved those twats…” She plugged one end of the cable into the speaker, the other into the synth. “But between them and Yes? Definitely Yes.”
“But… Yes doesn’t have a flute,” he grumbled, lighting a cigarette. “Jethro Tull does.”
“Neither do we.” Scarlett pressed a few keys, clicking her tongue while searching for the right tone.
“You could synthesise one,” Mike shot back, like it was the easiest thing in the world.
Scarlett gave him a look of disdain, tilting her chin up just as Danny, Lenny and Stacy arrived carrying the bass, guitar, amps and mic stands.
“I could,” she sighed, wearing a smug expression. “But will I?”
“Please?” Mike clasped his hands together like he was praying.
“Nope.”
“I’ll pack up your synths after the gig…”
“No.”
“I’ll give you… shoulder massages…”
“If you touch my shoulders, you’d better learn to play the drums with your feet!”
“I’ll wash your car for the next four weekends!”
“What are you lot arguing about?” Danny chimed in, eyeing them with suspicion.
“Jethro Tull,” Mike rolled his eyes, clearly bored. “They’re a good band!”
“No one said they weren’t,” Scarlett sat down on her stool, resting her hands on her knees.
“We could play one of their songs at the ball, huh?” Lenny raised his eyebrows quickly, showing an irritating enthusiasm for Mike’s daft idea.
“I’m not singing it. My voice doesn’t suit Anderson’s tone.” Stacy snatched Mike’s cigarette, slinging an arm over his shoulders as she took a drag.
“Danny can sing,” Scar decided, flexing her fingers.
“Me? Why not you?!” he shot back condescendingly.
“Oh yes, let’s have the soprano sing a baritone’s part!”
“Just take it up a few octaves,” Mike agreed with a shrug.
“Oh, fuck off.” Scarlett flipped them off.
“Alright, I’ll sing it,” Danny raised his hands in defeat. “Speaking of which… where were you last night?”
Scarlett pretended the question wasn’t aimed at her, playing a few notes on the synth until she noticed everyone staring at her.
“What? Are you all keeping tabs on me now?”
“I told you she pretends to be clueless!” Mike clapped his hands, pointing at Scarlett.
“We’re just… curious,” Lenny said as he pulled the bass from its case, slinging the strap over his shoulder.
“You went to see that hottie who walked into the bar that day, didn’t you?” A mocking grin spread across Danny’s face.
“What are you talking about?!” Scarlett played dumb once again, feeling her face heat up. Instinctively, she glanced at her ghosts, seated by the mixing desk.
“Oops, they’ve found out…” James said casually, nudging Regulus with his elbow.
“I told you they’d found out,” Red muttered, eating what looked like a strawberry ice lolly.
“Just say you were with him,” Lily shrugged. “I mean, why not?”
“I… I… I…” Scarlett stammered, blinking rapidly. “I don’t know who you’re talking about.”
“Oh! She thinks just because she’s fifty years older than us, we don’t know anything…” Mike teased, folding his arms and puffing out a cloud of smoke.
“Oh, for fuck’s sake…” Scarlett groaned, rolling her eyes and tipping her head to the side in exasperation. “He’s no one.”
“No one? He looked like he knew you…” Danny plugged his amp into the socket, gripping his guitar with both hands, plectrum between his lips.
Scarlett lifted her gaze to the two brothers — both tall, broad-shouldered, and sharp-featured with their unmistakable Asian traits. She swallowed hard; the way everyone was staring at her with such eager curiosity made her feel cornered. With a huff of surrender, she exhaled all the air from her lungs and rubbed her temples.
“He’s my brother-in-law,” she admitted, irritated.
“See? Told you!” Danny clapped in triumph while Stacy and Mike exchanged looks.
“Your brother-in-law? The brother of your husband who… died?” the vocalist continued the interrogation, clearly intrigued.
The grins on Danny and Lenny’s faces vanished, and Scarlett nodded, sighing.
“My son got into trouble at school and he… er, he came to let me know.” She murmured, cracking her knuckles one by one and wincing as her still-swollen wrist twinged from the night before. Thank Merlin she was wearing gloves. “Was that all?”
The humour that had been dancing around the group vanished as quickly as the discomfort set in. Lenny was the first to pat her on the shoulder and offer a comforting smile.
“It’s alright… I mean, it’s been a long time since he… yeah,” Scarlett found herself, unintentionally, glancing towards Regulus. He was no longer at the mixing desk with James and Lily. Now he sat in the back of the bar, his ethereal glow casting light over the darkened chairs in the far corner.
“You looked really uncomfortable when he showed up…” Danny went on, earning a swift kick to the shin from Mike. “Oi, mate!”
“We don’t… exactly get along,” Scarlett muttered, twisting her lips.
“Need us to rough him up a bit?” Lenny puffed out his chest, flexing the still-toned muscles earned from his early-morning canoeing.
“What? No.” She laughed at the absurd idea. The only thing Lenny would manage against Sirius was passing out after a single punch. She knew Sirius — and even weakened from Azkaban, he was still an excellent fighter. “I mean, we barely talk. He only came here because he’s my son’s godfather.”
“Why would you name someone you don’t get along with to be your kid’s godfather?!” Stacy frowned.
Scarlett didn’t want to show just how much that question cut her, so she masked it with a sardonic smile and scratched at the Signet beneath her glove.
“We got on back then,” she shrugged one shoulder.
“And what happened?” Mike, who had tried to silence Danny earlier, now looked the most curious of all.
“We found out life isn’t all strawberries and cream,” Scarlett adjusted herself on the keyboard stool, running her fingers over a few keys while staring at the bloody ring Dumbledore had given her, wrapped around her index finger. Then her eyes drifted to Sirius’s engagement ring — the black diamond caught the dim barlight and swelled her chest with greedy guilt. Shivering slightly, she forced a smile and turned back to her bandmates. “Are we playing or are you all planning to chit-chat till sunrise?”
“Jethro Tull!” Mike crowed, spinning his drumsticks between his fingers.
“No!” Stacy and Lenny barked in unison.
Scarlett just shook her head, teasing the bridge of a song that made Mike bounce excitedly behind his kit.
.
.
.
[Jethro Tull — Locomotive Breath]
The cat moved so silently she became one with the slithering shadows cast over the cobbled ground. She slipped into an alleyway as she watched a tall man with a ridiculous hat leaving Borgin & Burkes at one in the morning.
Her target carried a bag under his arm as if it held something of great value. The feline followed him through a narrow passageway — a place she knew all too well from her days as a Death Eater. The man took a deep breath, looked around, and closed his eyes.
In the sparse gloom at the corner of the passage, the cat stretched in an unnatural motion until the fur retracted, the claws vanished, the fangs disappeared — and in their place stood something far more dangerous: a woman fuelled by vengeance.
The moment the man prepared to Disapparate, she leapt with lethal speed, seizing him mid-Disapparition. They spun into a chaotic, disorienting whirlwind, the lights of London twisting into a kaleidoscope of yellow and white as they struggled.
The force of the uncontrolled Apparition hurled them straight into a massive mahogany table, which cracked in two under the impact of their spinning bodies. For a moment, all that could be heard were their ragged breaths, pained groans, and the crackle of the fireplace — the room’s only source of light.
Stunned and disoriented, the wizard scrambled out from beneath one of the table’s legs, fumbling on the floor in search of his wand. The intruder rolled across the marble floor, rising with difficulty as she leaned against the fireplace surround. The orange light danced across her all-black attire, flickering over the mask that concealed her nose and mouth, revealing only her eyes — eyes whose ocean-blue had become two blazing pools of incandescent scarlet.
In the shuffling madness
Of the locomotive breath
Runs the all-time loser
Headlong to his death
She straightened, standing before the fire, swallowing the man on the floor in the shadow her body cast. Her silhouette rippled in the mirrors flanking the room, along the hand-painted walls, in the opulence riddled with serpents embedded in every detail of the manor she had just invaded.
“No… no… no… please, don’t kill me!” he begged, crawling across the floor like a pathetic slug, as if he could escape.
Oh, he feels the piston scraping
Steam breaking on his brow
Old Charlie stole the handle
And the train it won't stop
Oh no way to slow down
“Kill you? Why would I kill you?” The woman’s voice wasn’t unfamiliar, but the wizard was far too stunned to place it, his heart pounding in his chest as his eyes swept the remains of the shattered table in search of his wand.
“You’re the hunter, aren’t you? The Death Eater Huntress.”
He sees his children jumping off
At the stations one by one
His woman and his best friend
In bed and having fun
She clicked her tongue and shook her head, approaching slowly. The man immediately noticed — she wasn’t holding a wand. Did she not have one? His eyes widened. Recovering from the initial shock, he let adrenaline swallow his pain as he surged forward, charging her like a bull.
He grabbed her by the waist and rammed her against the opposite wall, but she suddenly shrank down, throwing him off balance and causing him to stumble over his own feet. He collapsed onto the floor — clutching something furry and furious. The cat raked its claws across his hands, forcing him to release it, and it grew once more into the woman — who grabbed him by the hair and yanked his face up close to hers.
Oh, he's crawling down the corridor
On his hands and knees
Old Charlie stole the handle
And the train it won't stop going
No way to slow down
Hey
He tried to retaliate, aiming a sharp elbow toward her masked face, but she drove her fist into his throat with such brutal force that his breath fled and didn’t return. He coughed frantically for air, spluttering as the attacker’s looming shadow slipped between the silver serpents carved into the fireplace.
There was something else nearby. Something thin and dark, with flickering firelight dancing across its polished handle.
His wand.
Seizing the moment as her gaze flicked briefly to the side, he pushed himself up on his knees and snatched the wand, raising it to strike— but a hiss froze him in place. The silver serpents along the fireplace came to life, striking with uncanny speed. One coiled around his arm. The other wrapped tight around his throat.
He hears the silence howling
Catches angels as they fall
And the all-time winner
Has got him by the balls
The pressure in his head intensified exponentially as his grip on the wand's handle weakened. The serpent twisted his arm and his wand clattered to the floor, his survival instincts failing as the rest of the snake-shaped ornaments around the room joined in the attack, pinning him down under the woman’s hissing commands.
His vision blurred, and though his heartbeat remained rapid, it no longer brought oxygen to his brain. This was it. He was going to die — at the hands of the Death Eater Huntress. He was going to...
The snake around his neck loosened its grip, and he gasped for air in huge, ragged gulps, eyes streaming, body locked stiff. The woman crouched beside him, gripping his chin between thumb and forefinger, forcing him to meet those eyes — the only part of her face left uncovered.
Oh, he picks up Gideon's Bible
Open at page one
I think God he stole the handle
And the train it won't stop going
No way to slow down
No way to slow down
No way to slow down
Her skin was as pale as a corpse’s.
He knew only two people who were Parselmouths — and both of them were dead.
And yet, the woman pulled down her mask to reveal a face he never expected to see again.
“Ssss… Scar… lett?!” he choked, disbelieving.
“Heitor.” She greeted him like they were still Housemates.
“Y-you died!” Heitor Selwyn stammered, panic washing away any composure he might’ve clung to.
“I did,” Scarlett replied coldly. “But did you really think I wouldn’t drag you down with me?”
“No, no, no, no—” he repeated, the serpents tightening around his ankles and wrists each time he jerked in panic. “What… what do you want? Is it really you?! They said—”
“I want names,” Scarlett cut in, her voice vibrating with fury. “And you’re going to give me those names. Every last one of them.”
“You… you killed my sister…”
“And you’ll be next if you don’t cooperate,” she snarled, flashing a wicked grin.
Heitor felt dangerously close to wetting himself.
“I’ll tell you, I’ll tell you whatever you want… please… I… I—”
“Shut the fuck up!” Scarlett roared, a savage gleam flickering in her eyes. “Who killed my family?!”
He flinched at the question, his mind racing. She didn’t know?
“I… I don’t…” Heitor swallowed hard, his Adam’s apple bobbing. “I don’t know who exactly…” he confessed, fear dilating his pupils. “But I heard… I heard it was… it was an order from higher up. And they used it… as part of an initiation.”
Scarlett didn’t even flinch at the revelation. She looked terrifyingly similar to the teenager he’d once known nearly two decades ago — but there was a cruel instinct shadowing her features now, something he never thought Scarlett capable of showing.
“Don’t dodge my question, Selwyn,” she growled, leaning in closer. “I want names. Who gave the order? Who carried it out?”
Heitor’s already laboured breathing grew even more shallow.
“Only… only the Dark Lord’s inner circle knew…” Tears glistened down his cheeks, bathed in the orange glow of the fire. “Please…”
“Names, Selwyn!” she bellowed.
“L-L-Lestranges… all three… Rosier… Crouch… Black… Dolohov… Rookwood… Nott… Snape… M-Malfoy…”
Scarlett turned her face slightly, as if hearing something only she could hear.
“Lying bastard,” she hissed, signalling the snake around his neck to tighten its hold.
Eyes bulging, Heitor struggled against the reptiles of metal, wood and iron, but it was useless. After several long minutes of choked gurgling, the serpent finally loosened, and he hyperventilated, vision blurred, body drained.
“Regulus was part of the inner circle, yet… that information was kept to the closest…”
“Is that… what… he let you… believe?” Heitor, despite everything, let out a disturbing laugh. Scarlett clenched her fist and raised it, ready to strike. “Wait, wait! It must’ve been… one… one of the Death Eaters who was initiated that year…” he said quickly, squinting one eye shut. “Nott… Crouch… Wilkes… Avery… Mulciber… Rustov…”
“Who else?”
“Black!”
“Regulus didn’t join until the following year.”
“Er… uh, Brandon… Brandon will know… his father was in the inner circle… he… I’ll give you the address of the place he usually goes… just… please… leave me be…”
“Leave you be?” Scarlett mocked. “Like you lot left my family in peace?! Oh, Heitor… I know you’ve got a family now… married Greengrass… had kids…”
“Scarlett… please… I’ll do anything you want…”
She reached into her pocket and unfolded a piece of parchment, casting a spell on it.
“Say the address.”
As Heitor recited it, the words appeared magically on the parchment, as though an invisible quill were writing. Scarlett tucked the note away. Only then did Selwyn truly notice how thin she was. Azkaban’s doing. He might have laughed at that — if he weren’t utterly terrified.
“Very good, Heitor…” she nodded, though the fireplace’s flames couldn’t melt the ice in her eyes. “If the address is false… I’ll be paying you another visit.”
“N-no… it’s not false. I swear… I promise!”
Scarlett smiled. But above that smile, her eyes burned with a thirst for vengeance… and a hint of cruelty.
“We’ll see.” She stood, backing away from him with her wand at the ready. “What were you doing at Borgin & Burkes?”
Heitor furrowed his brow, sweat gleaming on his shaved head and trickling down his neck.
“I… I… my wife… she has a… a blood curse… and I… I’m trying… to undo it…”
Despite her rigidity, a flicker of surprise crossed Scarlett’s eyes. The serpents slowly began to release him, though he remained on the ground, as if expecting some sort of trap. But she simply flicked her wand and the shattered dining table repaired itself, wooden shards groaning as they rejoined.
“Very well. See you in hell.” She pointed her wand at him.
“No, no, no! I gave you what you wanted—”
“Obliviate.”
.
.
.
Sirius felt a chill crawl down his spine as he came upon a shadowy, damp, endless corridor. Droplets fell from the nearby stalactites, and wind howled along the walls, mournful and hollow. He looked back, to where Thanatos stood, wand in hand and a monocle pressed to his eye to see in the dark. Thanatos passed through Sirius as if he were mist, moving cautiously through the corridor. Sirius followed.
The tunnel seemed to stretch on forever.
Thanatos's unease was evident. His breathing, though controlled, carried traces of anxiety, and his movements grew tenser, more alert and wary with each step. He cast Homenum Revelio repeatedly, but nothing responded.
Then, the sound of something cracking made Nate freeze like a statue. At what appeared to be the end of the corridor, a silhouette slowly began to rise, but it was so dark Sirius couldn’t make it out.
As if hearing his thoughts, light flooded the darkness, consuming it and forcing Sirius to shield his face with his hand. The black stone walls were painted in pearlescent white, and the figure on the other side slowly lifted his face to Thanatos. His pale skin was touched by ethereal light, and blood trickled from his forehead, splitting at the bridge of his nose and running down both cheeks. And his eyes… there was a steel-like resolve in them, one that left Sirius reeling.
Regulus.
Sirius couldn’t recall the last time he’d seen his brother, though he was fairly certain it had been at Hogwarts. The memories of the Wizarding War were still hazy and thorn-riddled. He didn’t want to stir that hornet’s nest — not yet.
The image he had of his brother, however, was that of him collapsed near the stairs of Grimmauld Place, his back soaked in blood, iron-grey eyes radiating a hatred so deep they were never the same again after that day.
Regulus… Regulus had always been like that. He clung to hatred and shunned love. Sirius remembered now. Before the lashings, he and Reggie had been inseparable. While Sirius was striking, attention-seeking and full of smiles, Regulus was the opposite. Brooding, shy, introverted. He preferred books to people. Sirius had a strong, athletic build — but the younger one… he had always looked fragile. Small. Vulnerable.
How could he not have felt the unbearable urge to protect Regulus from the entire world? Sirius had done everything he could to shield him — from their parents, their governness, even from the spiteful, prejudiced opinions of Kreacher.
What Sirius hadn’t expected… was that he himself might one day be Regulus’s tormentor.
“Black?!” Thanatos snapped him out of his thoughts, dragging him back into the moment.
Regulus was no longer that fragile little boy. In fact, there was nothing fragile about the man before him. His black, wavy hair was a little longer, falling heavily over his forehead, and he seemed taller. Perhaps it was just Sirius’s perception — he still thought of his brother as a child and not...
Not a man fighting on the opposite side of the war.
An enemy.
Kneeling on the damp floor, Regulus released his wand into the air, where it hovered as he parted his dragonhide cloak, revealing the boy cradled against his chest. Orfeu was almost unrecognisable, his cheeks blackened with soot, his body alarmingly thin. His cracked lips barely moved, as if he were dead. But his eyes… they fluttered open slowly, fixing on Regulus. The Lumos light brought a flicker of life to the dull green of his irises.
Sirius barely noticed himself moving closer, his gaze locked hungrily on Regulus. Thanatos remained frozen, ready to strike, as though expecting the whole thing to be a trap.
“I didn’t expect you to be the informant.” Nate’s voice lashed against the shadowed walls, sending shivers across Sirius’s skin.
That place reminded him of Azkaban.
“They think Orfeu is dead,” Regulus said flatly, ignoring the remark. His tone was clipped, and his words held a coldness Sirius recognised as pure façade. “It’s better that no one knows he’s alive. That he was rescued.”
“Reg…” Orfy croaked, hoarse.
“Shhh…” Regulus hushed him gently, running his thumbs over the boy’s cheeks as if trying to wipe the grime away — but he failed. “It’s alright now, Orfy. I saved you.”
“You’re with her, aren’t you? With Scar… she’s going to get me, she’s going to—”
“No, she’s not here. She…” Regulus’s lips trembled. His eyes — usually so impassive — now showed real fear. Sirius looked closer at his brother’s face: the thick eyebrows so like his own, the pale cheeks, the beads of sweat sliding down his temples, the redness creeping into the edges of his eyes. “It’s alright, Orfy… you’re alright now…” he repeated, though there was hesitation in his voice.
In that moment, Regulus looked like a statue. His skin resembled marble, his grey eyes had turned to stone — cloudy, emotionless, immune to tears. Something stirred in Sirius’s core, making his heart pound in his chest and his breath catch in his throat. The rigidity in his gaze, the innate disdain, the unbearable air of superiority…
Regulus was the perfect reflection of Orion Black.
Everything Sirius had ever feared.
Regulus then softened his expression, and his thin lips curved into a reassuring smile that left Sirius breathless. He couldn’t tell whether it was a genuine display of warmth or just another mask. His brother seemed to know exactly what he was doing.
“No… no… she’s going to get me… she’s going to hurt me…” Orfeu’s pupils dilated, the black swallowing the green as quickly as fear flooded his body.
It took only a small gesture from Regulus to send the boy to sleep. He didn’t even touch his wand, let alone speak the incantation. Sirius didn’t want to admit it, but his brother had become a powerful wizard.
“What’s he talking about?” Thanatos asked, approaching cautiously without letting his guard down, eyes fixed on Regulus. “What did Scarlett do to him?”
“Nothing,” he snapped, cutting Nate off sharply. Thanatos’s brows furrowed at the rudeness. “She never hurt Orfy. On the contrary. Everything she did… was to protect him. To protect our son.”
Thanatos scoffed audibly, disbelief etched into every line of his face.
“Protect him from whom?!”
“Take Orfeu, Gaunt,” Regulus murmured, ignoring the question. “Hide him. Protect him. Don’t let anyone know…” He cut himself off abruptly, lips pressing into a line as he squeezed his eyes shut, visibly straining not to show he was in pain. “No one can know about him.”
Thanatos picked Orfeu up as if he were a rag doll, always keeping his wand arm free. He stepped back slowly, cradling the boy’s head against his shoulder while keeping Regulus in his line of sight.
“I have to go. He’s calling me…”
“No, you need to give me the information—”
“I will. I just need to be sure… that it’s what I think it is…” Regulus spoke slowly, clenching his jaw so tightly that the muscles in his face cast sharp shadows across his jawline. Whatever youthful warmth his earlier smile had brought to his features was now completely gone — replaced by a man far too young to die and far too bound to ever truly live.
“Why?” Thanatos asked softly — yet the word echoed through the tunnel, over and over.
Why?
Why?
Why?
Why?
Why?
Regulus straightened. His unnaturally pale skin made him resemble a ghost, haunted by his own darker reflection — his shadow stretching and shifting along the walls with every movement he made. He looked at Thanatos for several long seconds, his expression cold. The Lumos light lit the grey of his eyes, but it wasn’t enough to touch the winding darkness within his pupils.
A flicker Sirius didn’t recognise cut across the iron of Regulus’s gaze, turning it to lead. He couldn’t tell if it was exposure, fear… or manipulation.
Perhaps it was all three.
Regulus licked his chapped lips and parted his mouth slightly, remaining expressionless.
“I’m doing this because I want a better world for my son.” He ran his hand over his left forearm, then pulled his cloak back over himself.
“Regulus… Scarlett…” Thanatos’s voice faltered for a second. “Is she… is she alright?”
Watching the scene unfold, Sirius grew increasingly certain that he had never truly known his younger brother… yet, the way Regulus’s steely eyes clouded over with hollow justification and blind conviction made Sirius understand the answer was no.
Scarlett was not alright.
“I’ll be here tomorrow. Same time.” That was all Regulus said before Disapparating with a crack.
The next moment, Sirius was soaring aimlessly through darkness before landing on his feet in his bedroom, now lit by the pale hues of twilight.
Regulus and Scarlett were working against Voldemort?! What was the information he was going to give Thanatos? Was that why he died?!
Sirius rubbed his eyes harshly with his knuckles, forcing the breath from his lungs. He couldn’t put it off any longer.
He needed to speak to Scarlett.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 46: You can’t protect her from everything
Chapter Text
CXIV
The Gryffindor common room was relatively full at that hour, with students from third year up to the last still sprawled across sofas and tables, whispering and murmuring about everything that had happened over the holidays.
Sirius, James, Remus and Peter were by one of the windows, slightly away from the crowd. Peter and Remus were playing wizard chess on the lion rug, Sirius was sprawled out in an armchair, and James was leaning over a love seat, eyes fixed on Lily, who was chatting with Mary on the other side of the room.
"What time are you meeting Scar at the Undercroft?" Peter asked, scratching his chin. "Might swing by the kitchens and grab something to eat..."
"She said she'd meet me here." Sirius was bouncing his foot restlessly. "It’s been fifteen minutes already, d’you think—"
"Chill, mate, she’s on her way." James pushed his glasses up his nose, shifting on the sofa as Marlene approached. "Alright, Marl?!"
"Heard you already lost points for Gryffindor on the Express..." she remarked, sitting down beside James with a casual little grin.
"I’ll make up for it later." Sirius brushed it off, glancing at his watch again.
Marlene shifted in her seat, visibly uneasy.
"I need to talk to your girlfriend," she said at last, earning a look from each of the Marauders.
Sirius sighed, running a hand through his hair. He didn’t need more problems than he already had.
"Best not, Marl." He felt the watch vibrate against his palm, the hands spinning wildly before settling into a countdown.
"I see," she murmured, staring at Peter and Remus’s chess game.
Did she, really? Sirius doubted it. And anyway, what did she want with Scarlett? The last time they’d spoken, his girlfriend had nearly killed him. Not that she hadn’t been right to do so, but Sirius didn’t want to give Marlene any leeway, even if she was with Dorcas now.
"Right, I’d better go..." Sirius announced, snapping the lid of his watch shut. He rose from the armchair with his hands in the pockets of his cloak. "I’ll grab my trunk tomorrow, when there’s fewer people about..."
The awkward atmosphere Marlene had brought didn’t fade once Sirius left. On the contrary, James stood up from the sofa as well, following his friend and weaving through the students clustered by the fire. They stepped through the portrait hole and Sirius frowned when he spotted Pandora and Regulus practically carrying Scarlett.
He barely registered his legs beginning to pick up speed down the corridor, heading towards the three of them, who’d come to a stop. Sirius felt his heart lurch violently in his chest, watching in panic as Scarlett remained standing, staring at the floor, frozen and withdrawn. She stood still for so long he thought she might not even be breathing, snatching her from Regulus and Pandora in a rush of panic.
Before he could ask what had happened, Scarlett collapsed in his arms with a desperate sob, her breath hitching in ragged spasms as she clung to his cloak so tightly her nails dug into the fabric. Sirius turned her towards him, trying to meet her eyes, but she buried her face in his chest. She couldn’t breathe, couldn’t speak, couldn’t even move.
It wasn’t the first time she’d fallen into that state. Sirius shoved down the guilt threatening to spread through his core and brought his lips close to her ear, holding her face with one hand while the other wrapped around her waist.
"It’s alright now. It’s alright… you’re safe," he murmured softly, brushing his thumb along her chin, lifting it gently in an attempt to catch her evasive gaze. "Look at me, Scar. It’s alright, I’m here."
Scarlett was looking at him, but Sirius knew she wasn’t really seeing him. So he turned his face to the side and rested his chin against her forehead, pressing her head to his chest. He took a deep breath, the sweet scent of her shampoo mixed with the vanilla of her skin anchoring him, helping him ignore the fear trying to undermine his resolve.
"Listen to my heartbeat," he said, his warm words slipping into her ink-black hair. "Breathe with me."
Blinking repeatedly, Scarlett nodded just as her whole body trembled. Sirius inhaled slowly and deeply, feeling her chest convulse against his, her breathing short and frantic. Still, he continued, stroking her hair, sensing the tension in her muscles begin to ebb, her breathing slowly evening out.
The tremor in her hands hadn’t faded, but the stuttered sobs subsided, letting her breathe with more control, uninterrupted. Even so, Scarlett remained clinging to him, and Sirius swallowed hard, a lump rising in his throat. He kissed her forehead and glanced sideways at James, without loosening his embrace.
"I’ll be right back," his best friend whispered, as if reading his thoughts.
Sirius turned to Pandora and Regulus, who were watching them in shock — as though they had no idea what to do.
"You’re safe now," he repeated, diving into those ocean-blue eyes, grounding her with his presence. "I’m here."
The world stopped spinning quite so violently. Scarlett’s body felt utterly exhausted, but at the same time… it was as if everything was alright, because she was anchored to her safe harbour. It didn’t matter if she fell or got hurt — Sirius would always be there to catch her. Scarlett closed her eyes, still breathless, but her heart was flooded with the balm only the man with starry eyes could give her.
His question was enough to make Scarlett’s eyes widen in fear, glancing sideways at Regulus before hiding her face in Sirius’s chest like a scolded child. He too looked at his brother, whose usually cold expression was now clouded with an unusual hesitation.
The silence between them was broken by the heavy footsteps of James, his Head Boy badge gleaming under the candelabra’s light.
"We’ve cleared out the common room," he said, placing his hands on his hips.
"Love, I need you to go with James," Sirius murmured, brushing the black strands stuck to her cheeks. Scarlett’s response was to clutch tighter at his Gryffindor cloak. "It’ll be quick. I promise." He pressed several kisses to the top of her head, gradually loosening his hold. "I’ll be right behind you."
"No," Scarlett croaked. Sirius tried to pull away again. "No!"
"Kitten, kitten… kitten…" He held her chin, forcing her to look at him. "I need you to go with James." He didn’t hide the impatience in his voice. "Please, Scar."
Scarlett blinked slowly, her blue eyes bathed in the moonlight pouring through the windows. Sirius caressed her damp cheeks, taking in her reddened eyes and swollen nose.
"Please," he asked again, feeling Scarlett slowly release her grip on him. "Before you even notice… I’ll be back."
Sirius kissed Scarlett’s forehead, and she only nodded. James threw an arm around her shoulders and steered her down the corridor, trying to spark up a cheerful conversation, but all Scar did was glance sideways at Sirius, Regulus, and Pandora before stepping through the portrait hole.
Sirius’s protective stance stiffened, his gaze sharpened and his jaw tensed. He turned to face Regulus with calculated precision, squaring up as he took a step towards his brother.
"What happened?" he asked, curtly, with a look that demanded the truth.
Regulus lifted his chin, adjusting his expression into a mask of blank indifference — just the way Orion had taught them. Sirius clenched his fists, flaring his nostrils as he studied his brother through the silence, trying to spot even the faintest trace of vulnerability in those unyielding iron eyes. But there was none.
Pandora’s gaze bounced between the two brothers before she jabbed Regulus with her elbow, noticing he wasn’t going to answer Sirius.
"If you don’t tell him, I will!" she snapped, folding her arms.
"You don’t even know exactly what happened…" Regulus replied sharply, making her take a step to her brother’s side.
"What happened, Pan?" Sirius asked. The nickname alone was enough to make Regulus lose his composure, his brows furrowing as he stared at Pandora like he couldn’t quite grasp that level of intimacy. The Gryffindor offered a subtle smile, which went unnoticed.
She opened her mouth to reply, but Regulus was quicker:
"It was a prank." He cleared his throat under Sirius’s piercing gaze. "Avery, Mulciber and Snape… they put a Boggart in Scar’s room. When she opened the door… everything went up in flames."
Regulus watched, with growing dread, as the concern in Sirius’s eyes melted into rage. He’d seen his brother react like that plenty of times before — especially the previous year when Rosier had blamed Snape. He wanted so badly to feel bad when he saw suspicion arch Sirius’s brows, but what right did he have?
Sirius was right to doubt him. Everyone was.
"She fought back," Red went on. "Hit Mulciber with a Cruciatus so strong he passed out. I ran to her and… she was losing it and…"
Sirius inhaled slowly, the grey of his eyes rippling with the avalanche of emotions threatening to consume him. Regulus braced himself for the explosion — a scream, a storm, maybe even a march straight to the Slytherin common room to go after Avery and Mulciber… but the man in front of him didn’t seem to be the same boy who’d grown up beside him at Grimmauld Place. He showed every sign of fury coursing through his veins, but he didn’t take it out on him — or on Pandora.
"Rosier ordered everyone who saw it to keep quiet, but, well…" Regulus swallowed thickly as his brother’s gaze turned back to him. His stomach twisted at the way Sirius studied him, the silver of his eyes pressing against the iron of his own, searching — trying to be sure he was telling the truth.
Regulus wanted to tell him everything, to break down in tears and hold him tight, to say he was sorry. He knew how hard Sirius was holding himself together, that the walls around him were just a mask — that deep down, he wasn’t as calm as he seemed.
Despite appearances, Sirius had always been the more sensitive of the two. And as much as Regulus harboured a burning hatred for his brother… there was something else there, too.
Something that…
Regulus sighed. It was too late to untangle any of that now, so he kept quiet, his gaze dropping to the dark stone floor.
"Is it true?" Sirius’s voice came out clean and sharp. Distant. Cold.
Regulus pressed his dry lips together and gave a slight, trembling nod. Sirius shook his head, releasing a sharp exhale and dragging a hand through the long hair that fell past his shoulders.
"Is she going to be alright?" Pandora was so close to Sirius that something twisted in Regulus’s chest. Instinctively, his expression hardened, the iron of his gaze soaking up all the shadows in the corridor until it turned as dark as coal, his irises blending with his dilated pupils.
"She will, yes." Sirius placed a hand on Pandora’s shoulder, and a soft smile curled her rosy lips. "No need to worry, Pan."
Regulus took a quiet step back, the interaction tightening the twist in his chest. It was hard to swallow past the tension stiffening his muscles, but he forced himself to when Pandora looked his way.
"Thanks for keeping an eye on her," Sirius said, casting him one last look before turning on his heel and heading back to the Gryffindor common room.
Pandora shoved her hands into the pockets of her cloak and started walking, glancing over her shoulder when she noticed Red hadn’t budged an inch.
"Why did he call you Pan?!" Regulus didn’t bother to hide the bitterness in his voice, curling his lips as if the very word disgusted him.
"Because we’re friends," she replied, rolling her eyes like it was the most obvious thing in the world.
Regulus clenched his jaw, fists curling tight.
"But you used to hate him!" he laughed, a disbelieving sound. Acidic.
"Not anymore." Pandora shrugged, as if her previous opinion of Sirius didn’t matter in the slightest. She walked on, and Regulus suddenly found himself alone.
Again.
The blood in his chest bubbled until it burst; his face burned, his teeth ground together. Regulus tried to snuff out the sparks of hatred rising in his core, narrowing his breathing and forcing out the chilling sense of loneliness from his lungs. He wanted to cry, but no tears came. He wasn’t the kind of man who sought comfort in crying; tears were for the weak, for those who believed love was more than just a word full of embellishments and delusions. For those who tried to fill their emptiness with presence, with promises, with affection.
Regulus looked back, to where Sirius had gone. Then forward, where Pandora was heading towards the Grand Staircase.
"You’ll always leave me alone," he muttered to himself.
He followed neither path. Instead, he spoke the password to the nearby portrait and stepped through it, vanishing into the shadows of Hogwarts.
.
.
.
Scarlett hugged her knees. The tears kept trying to return, even though she didn’t want to cry anymore. The shock still crawled through her body, prickling her muscles with a dull ache. James, seated beside her, was idly untangling the ends of her hair in a gesture of resignation. He’d suggested Scarlett file her nails, but she stubbornly ignored him. It was as if he didn’t exist.
Sirius entered the room, his gaze immediately landing on Scarlett, whose hunched posture and distant stare made him press his lips together and crease his brow. James gave a shrug, as if to say everything that could’ve been done had been.
With a small nod of thanks to his friend, Sirius took his place beside Scarlett on the bed. Gently, he touched her shoulder, trying to ease the armour of apathy in which she’d hidden herself.
"Scar…" he whispered, nuzzling his nose against her cheek.
Scarlett lifted her gaze to him slowly, as though it took great effort.
"I…" Her own hoarse voice echoed in her ears, fragile and broken. "I’m going to be expelled. I’m going to be expelled, I’m—"
"Shhh…" Sirius silenced her with a kiss at the corner of her lips. "Let’s lie down for a bit, yeah?"
Though she tried to pretend otherwise, Scarlett was still deeply shaken. It became more and more obvious whenever she moved — her limbs trembled and wavered at the mere suggestion of relaxing.
Hesitantly, she watched as Sirius peeled back each layer of her defences, taking one finger at a time, guiding her unsteady hands away from her folded legs and placing them gently on the velvety scarlet blanket. He untied her boots and let them drop to the floor, then slowly stretched out her legs. Scarlett stared at her dark socks as he crawled across the bed, pulling her up and helping her settle onto the mattress.
She wanted so badly to give voice to the weight of her thoughts, to tell Sirius that she’d used an Unforgivable Curse at Hogwarts and that she would be expelled for it, but his touch seemed to incinerate every coherent thought in her mind. Scarlett couldn’t do anything but surrender to Sirius’s care.
The moment her head sank into the pillow, she wished she could just close her eyes and sleep. But he curled up behind her and wrapped her in his arms, spreading over her tormented body the warmth and safety he so desperately wished for her. The ache in her muscles was soothed by the softness of the plush blanket; the ringing in her ears was muffled by his warm breath and kisses at the nape of her neck; the fear was driven back by the gentle caress he traced along her cheek.
Scarlett closed her eyes and let out a sob as the tears returned, curling even tighter against Sirius’s chest, seeking refuge in his presence. He didn’t let go — on the contrary, he only held her closer.
"I’m here, love. You’re not going to go through this again. Never again." He promised, not bothering to hide how shaken he was himself. "I’m sorry. I won’t leave you alone again…"
Remus arrived with the potion Sirius had asked him to fetch. Scarlett recoiled, hiding her face beneath the blanket, loathing the fact her friends were seeing her like that… so helpless and unravelling. The Scarlett from before the fire would already be plotting revenge — not…
Not sobbing like a little child in her boyfriend’s arms.
"Drink," Sirius whispered in her ear, holding the potion bottle out in front of her.
Scarlett was already taking a fair amount of potions. For melancholy, twice a week. Dreamless sleep every night. Calming draughts as needed throughout the day. The shimmering hue of the sleeping potion was all too familiar, and she drank it without protest, handing the empty vial back to him and breathing in the man who was her anchor, her sanctuary.
No matter how tired Sirius was himself, he didn’t take his eyes off Scarlett for even a second. He watched as exhaustion took her slowly, her chest rising and falling in soft, steady rhythm. The stress had taken its toll, and she drifted off quickly, though her heart was beating so fast Sirius could see the vein pulsing in her neck and feel the thrum of it in her forearm.
Peter appeared in the doorway with a grin from ear to ear, arms full with a cauldron brimming with rich, chocolate-filled cake. But the moment he opened his mouth, James and Remus silenced him with a sharp hiss. He blinked wide-eyed and carefully placed the cauldron on the desk beside Sirius’s bed, catching a curious glance from his friend.
"Got her favourite..." Peter whispered, then backed away to sit at the foot of his own bed.
"What happened?" James asked, furrowing his brow as he picked at a piece of the dessert.
Sirius rested his chin in his free hand, elbow propped up on the pillow as he looked at his friends. Regulus’s revelation still echoed in his mind, but he was carrying so much at once that just thinking about what had happened to Scarlett…
He sighed, feeling utterly overwhelmed.
"Avery, Mulciber and Snape played a prank on her," Sirius hissed, his gaze sharpening into steel. He swallowed hard before continuing. "They put a Boggart in her room, and when she opened the door… it turned into fire. Obviously."
"They… they…" James tried to speak with his mouth full of cake, but Sirius cut him off.
"Wait—there’s more." Sirius let out a cynical, stunned laugh.
"More?!" Remus scratched his chin, leaning against his desk.
"She used the Cruciatus Curse on Mulciber… apparently he passed out on the spot… and then she went into shock and Regulus—"
"Hang on, who told you this? Your brother?" James narrowed his eyes suspiciously, wiping the corner of his mouth with his thumb. Sirius nodded. "And what if he’s lying?! He did it during the Snape incident — what makes you think he’s not lying now?"
Sirius licked his lips. James had a point. Remus nodded as well, stroking the scars on his face the way he always did when he was deep in thought.
"I don’t… that’s just what he told me," Sirius muttered with a weary sigh.
"Scar needs to stop using that curse," Remus murmured, concerned. Peter laughed. "No, I mean it. This is the third time she’s done it."
"It doesn’t matter. I’m going to make them pay," Sirius growled, his eyes flashing with fury. "Avery, Snape and Mulciber—"
"No, Padfoot! We need to take this to Dumbledore!" James shoved his glasses up his nose, resolute.
Sirius smiled — a cold, dangerous smile.
"If Dumbledore finds out, she’ll be expelled!" He ran a hand over his beard, glancing to make sure Scarlett was still asleep. He didn’t want to wake her — or worse, lose control. "He can’t know."
"And how do you know he doesn’t already?" Remus slid off his desk onto his bed, kicking off his shoes without taking his eyes off Sirius.
"Apparently Rosier ordered everyone to keep quiet." Sirius exhaled fully, dragging a hand through his beard.
"But that’s just what your brother said…"
"It doesn’t matter what he said, Prongs — I need your help to make sure that bloody Slytherin trio never messes with Scarlett again!" Sirius snapped, one hand shielding his girlfriend’s ear, a throbbing vein bulging at his temple. "If we’d acted last year—"
"Padfoot, no!" James shot back, finger pointed accusingly at him. "This has gone too far! This isn’t just some house rivalry anymore—"
"They’ll never leave her alone, James!" he argued, exasperated.
"We don’t have to tell Dumbledore exactly what happened," Remus said, sounding detached from the heated exchange. "Alright, I’ve got an idea. Be right back." He shoved his shoes back on just as quickly as he’d kicked them off, and disappeared from the room in a flash.
Sirius rubbed his eyes with the knuckles of his fingers harder than he should have. Frustration was quick to take the place of anger, his gaze drifting to Scarlett, fast asleep with a peaceful expression nestled in his arms. He wished he could keep her like that forever — safe, calm, and comfortable.
There was a moment of absolute silence. Sirius hated arguing like that with James; it felt like they were out of sync, as if his friend no longer understood him — and that put him on edge.
James was his best friend. They couldn’t be fighting like this.
Sirius deflated, pretending to be too busy stroking Scarlett’s hair until he gave in and looked over at James, who was already lying on his bed.
"Maybe… maybe she was right. About not coming back to Hogwarts. Maybe she shouldn’t have come back…" he said, his voice tinged with guilt.
"Why not?! Out there, you’d be alone… here, you’ve got us…" James murmured, rolling over on the mattress to face Sirius.
"Yeah, but we weren’t with her when it happened, were we?!" Sirius didn’t mean to sound harsh, but the words sat at the edge of his tongue and James seemed to feel the lash of them physically — he shrank back into his blankets.
"Next time, we will be…"
"It’s not enough!" Sirius felt the anger burn his throat and exhaled deeply in an attempt to force it out. "I should’ve been there with her. I should be the one protecting her, I—"
"You can’t protect her from everything, Padfoot." There was sorrow in James’s voice — and a kind of resignation that made it hard for Sirius to keep his composure.
"I know," he admitted reluctantly, closing his eyes and breathing in the vanilla scent of Scarlett, not daring to nuzzle her neck as if she were far too precious to disturb.
"You’re doing everything you can…" James continued, resting his chin on the back of his hand. "Stop being so hard on yourself."
"I just…" Sirius tried to explain, but one look was enough for James to understand.
"I know." James’s hazel eyes shimmered behind his glasses, and a faint smile crossed his lips.
Two soft knocks on the door made them both turn their heads towards the sound, and Peter — mouth full of cake and fingers sticky — shuffled over to open it. Lily stood in the doorway, her brows furrowed and lips parted with concern. James jumped from his bed, running a hand awkwardly through his hair.
"Is she alright?" Lily asked softly.
Sirius licked his lips, leaning back against the pillow to get a better look at her.
"She will be," he replied, trying to inject certainty into his voice — though he doubted Lily believed him, judging by the worried way she looked at him.
"Brought a calming draught," Lily said, handing it to Peter, who took the vial in his free hand.
"Oh, she’s already had a sleeping potion…" Sirius replied, pressing his lips together with a shrug.
"It’s not for her. It’s for you," Lily retorted, resolutely. James let out a quiet chuckle, and Sirius didn’t know what to say — so he said nothing. "What happened?"
Peter shoved all his cake-smeared fingers into his mouth to keep from speaking. James and Sirius exchanged glances, and though the Head Boy straightened up as if to respond, it was Sirius who spoke.
He left out the part about Scarlett fighting back, of course — he didn’t want Lily growing suspicious, and he didn’t entirely trust Regulus’s version either. As much as he wished he could, he knew exactly what kind of snake his brother was, especially after returning from their parents’ house. Orion and Walburga had probably filled Red’s head with so much rot that just thinking about it… Sirius sighed.
"Wait, Snape was involved in this?!" Lily’s pale face flushed red, and she pressed her lips together, visibly furious. Sirius had seen her like that before — though usually, he or James were the targets of her wrath. Knowing that Snape was about to get an earful from the girl he fancied made Sirius allow himself a small smile.
"That’s what I was told," he said, raising his hands in mock surrender.
Lily inhaled deeply, shaking her head before looking at James.
"Scar can stay here, no problem," she decided, eyeing the nearby cauldron full of chocolate cake with suspicion. She opened her mouth to ask where they’d got that much food but thought better of it. "Are you sleeping in our dorm or here tonight?"
The question was aimed at James, though it took him a few seconds to realise.
"Oh, right, um…" He cleared his throat, glancing at Sirius and Peter. "Mind if I—"
"No, not at all!" Peter waved a hand in front of his face as if he couldn’t care less.
"Go on, I’ll tell Moony you’re not spooning him tonight — sacrifices must be made…" Sirius said with a smirk, and Lily let out a small snort of laughter.
"Oh, we’re not… it’s not like that… you do know the Prefects’ rooms are separate, right?!" James was now blushing to the tips of his ears, giving a nervous little laugh as he scratched the back of his neck. Lily’s laughter grew louder.
"Prongs… just go already, mate!" Sirius urged, tossing a pillow at him.
James obeyed, eyes wide and lips twitching as he tried (and failed) to suppress the smile spreading across his face. He and Lily disappeared a second later, leaving Peter to close the door behind them, giving Sirius a suggestive look.
"I really doubt anything’s going to happen between those two," Sirius said, running a hand through his black hair, watching Peter cross the room to the bathroom.
"Yeah, same," Peter replied, spending some time washing his hands and brushing his teeth.
"Wormtail…" Sirius called as he emerged from the bathroom, stroking Scarlett’s pale cheek.
"What is it, Padfoot?" Peter asked, sitting on his bed and pulling on a pair of crochet socks — no doubt a gift from his mum.
Despite his calm expression, there was a flicker of cruelty and wildness gleaming in the stormy grey of Sirius’s eyes.
"I need your help."
There was something dark in Sirius’s voice.
Something that made Peter shiver — and nod.
.
.
.
The marble floor was cold against her cheek. Scarlett shut her eyes as the red flashes struck her violently, and the sensation of her bones being shattered made her scream.
She could’ve been under the curse for days, hours, or mere minutes — she wouldn’t have known the difference. The pain wasn’t just excruciating; it crawled up her spine and sank its claws into her brain as if determined to burst every neuron. She couldn’t think, couldn’t react — Merlin, she couldn’t even move as the red bolts seared her skin, fried her flesh, melted her consciousness.
All Scarlett wanted was to die. She’d begged for death so many times she couldn’t remember the last time she wished for the opposite.
The cold marble gave way to a soft, comfortable pillow. The tremors she felt no longer came from the Cruciatus, and her blurred vision wasn’t from tears.
Scarlett woke so abruptly from sleep that she was still stunned. Her ragged breathing was the only sound in the room, as she thrashed against sweat-drenched sheets. Light seeped in through the windows, blocked in part by the blinds. It took her several minutes to recognise where she was, glancing around the small, stifling bedroom as she wiped the sweat from her face with the collar of her T-shirt.
Her head was heavy, pounding, and she couldn’t tell if it was from the nightmare or from last night’s drinking. Dread coiled inside her, and she glanced about, as if hoping someone might be there… but she was alone.
Taking a deep breath, she sat up in bed, her head spinning. She crossed her legs and rested her elbows on her knees, burying her face in her palms. Each beat of her heart sent another sharp pulse through her skull.
After a few minutes, she slid out of bed, unsteady, gripping the furniture along the way to keep herself from falling. She took a quick, cold, unsatisfying shower. As soon as she opened the bedroom door, the conversation between her ghosts came to an abrupt stop. She walked straight past them, filled a glass with water, and took a few sips before stopping in front of a frame hung just above the fireplace.
"Revelio," Scarlett murmured, without a wand, and the images began to form on the pale surface — dark lines weaving together into illustrations, names, and connections.
At the top of it all, forming a pyramid, was the name Voldemort. Beneath him, his most loyal Death Eaters, part of the inner circle. Then, the other Death Eaters. And finally, the contributors — Greyback, giants, and goblins.
"Staring at the board won’t make the answer magically appear," Lily remarked, eyeing her with bitterness.
Scarlett ignored her. Ever since the confrontation with Heitor Selwyn and the information he’d handed over, they’d had a fierce row about what to do next. Regulus and Scarlett wanted to go to the address given and interrogate Brandon Nott, but James and Lily insisted it was a trap.
"That shouldn’t be our priority! We need to go to Grimmauld Place to make sure Kreacher—"
"No chance," Scarlett cut her off, twisting her ring around her finger. "I’m not going back to that mausoleum."
"Then call Kreacher! He’ll be able to tell you if he destroyed the Horcrux or not—"
"Kreacher belongs to Reggie, not Scar," Regulus objected to Lily’s suggestion. "Unless… with Sirius back—"
"—he might’ve inherited Kreacher?!" James finished the sentence. "More likely he belongs to Reg. Just like Penny did."
"No, it’s different. He inherited Penny from Sirius, but Kreacher was my mother’s. So, when she died—"
"But she disowned Sirius, didn’t she?!" Lily sighed, growing impatient. "So Kreacher belongs to Reg."
As the debate unravelled in the room, none of the three noticed that Scarlett had her face buried in her hands, crying. In truth, even Scarlett hadn’t realised. She didn’t know why she was crying — it was as if she had no control over the tears spilling freely down her cheeks. She sniffed and wiped them away discreetly, lifting her eyes back to the board, trying to focus on the little names even though none of it made any sense anymore.
All she really wanted was to grab her car and drive into central London — to a house near the shopping centre and the music shop. To a place she once called home. But… she couldn’t go back. She didn’t deserve to go back. So she forced herself to focus on the mission before she had to head down to work.
"We need Nott… we need to find out who it was…" Scarlett forced herself to speak, her voice cracked and thin.
"And what if whoever did it is already dead?!" James stepped closer, his pale glow reflecting against the stone hearth. "I mean, from this list… Rosier, Crouch, Avery, Rustov, Wilkes and Helena Selwyn are all dead. The last four were killed by you. The rest are in Azkaban."
"But someone gave the order," she countered, rubbing at her eyes. The brightness of the room was stabbing at her retinas. "We could interrogate Snape — we’ve broken into Hogwarts before…"
"It wasn’t Snape," Regulus murmured, bored.
"How do you know?" Lily looked at him, raising a single eyebrow.
"He joined later. He became a Death Eater by killing Freya Hopper."
"It was him?!" James didn’t bother to hide the shock on his face, nor did Lily conceal the sadness clouding hers. "So if it wasn’t Snape or Rosier… the ones who joined that year and were part of Voldemort’s inner circle were Crouch and Nott… and only Nott is still alive."
"It’s too risky." Releasing a breathless sigh, Lily dropped onto the sofa as if exhausted. "If we follow the Horcrux trail—"
"Please, Lily, I… I can’t go back to that place…" Scarlett spoke in a tone of desperate pleading, and her ghosts feared she was about to cry again. "We… we’re going in circles. Maybe it’s better if we go after someone who didn’t join in ‘77… someone from the inner circle…"
"Mulciber? Malfoy?" James suggested. "I remember Lucius Malfoy — slimy little bastard…"
"He’s married to my cousin," Regulus said, tilting his head from side to side to crack his neck. "I wonder if I still have access to Malfoy Manor? Could I Apparate there using your body, Scar?" he mused, staring into nothing as he rubbed his chin.
Scarlett didn’t respond. She remained in that catatonic silence, eyes fixed on the board, though Regulus was sure she was far, far away. He’d seen her like that before — as had James, whose worried gaze turned to Regulus.
Then, as if suddenly remembering something important, Scarlett grabbed her bag from the table, her coat from the vestibule, and left the flat without so much as a goodbye.
"I think she’s going to have a mental breakdown," Regulus admitted, heavy-hearted. "She already had one in Azkaban… before you lot."
"She had one at Hogwarts, too." James pulled Lily into a hug. She looked so worried that all she could do was let out a deep, audible sigh.
The patchy silences always came first — as if Scarlett were straining to bury her thoughts and feelings. It wouldn’t be long before she started acting recklessly — more recklessly than she already was. And that was the most dangerous version of Scarlett, because she had immense destructive potential when she was emotionally unbalanced.
"What did you do when it happened with you?" James asked, resting his chin on Lily’s shoulder. "Sirius has always been the best at getting through to Scar when she shuts down emotionally… and me… well, I haven’t got a clue how to help her."
Regulus’s expression, usually so measured and composed, slipped into distress and settled into true anguish. It was such a raw and sudden display that James and Lily were certain he was being honest when he began to tell them what had happened:
Scarlett was pressed against the cold, dim wall, hugging her knees, curled in on herself as if trying to disappear from the gaze of anyone passing the cell. Regulus watched her from the top bunk, legs dangling over the edge, hands braced on the damp stone. She wasn’t looking at anything in particular — in fact, if he hadn’t seen the rise and fall of her chest, he might have sworn she was dead.
"Scar…" he called gently, but she didn’t even glance at him.
She’d been like that for days. The cell door would open and close for her daily hour of sunlight, but she wouldn’t move. As if she were some morbid, inanimate fixture of the cell. She only left when the shackles appeared — and when she returned, she’d sit back down in that exact same spot, in that exact same posture.
Regulus jumped down to the floor, walking over to her and trying to touch her shoulder. Still, she didn’t move.
"What are you thinking about?"
She said nothing. By his count, it had been a week and a half. He’d tried walking the block, listening in on anything remotely interesting from the other inmates, just to have something to say to her. But…
Scarlett didn’t even acknowledge him. And for a moment, he was certain she couldn’t see him at all.
So he did the only thing he could think of — he provoked her.
"You think Sirius’ll ever be able to love Reggie?"
His question rang out against the cell’s grim walls with such force that she turned her head slightly towards him, eyes already rimmed with suffering — now filled with tears too.
The answer she gave was to bash the right side of her head against the stone wall — slowly at first, then harder with every hit.
Though he knew how cruel his question had been, Regulus regretted it instantly. He should’ve chosen his words more carefully… but what else was he meant to do? Stay silent? He couldn’t just watch her like that, not doing anything.
In the blink of an eye, Scarlett’s pale white face was streaked in crimson, hot and sticky blood dripping down her cheek, her neck, soaking her striped pyjamas from the shoulder down to her torso.
Regulus… didn’t know what to do. What could he have done?
He tried to hold her. He shouted at her. He ordered her to stop. Scarlett didn’t. She went on, torturing him with the harrowing sight of her utterly broken — disturbed beyond reach — and there was nothing he could do but bear witness.
He couldn’t go on. The sobs wouldn’t let him. And he hated how powerless he felt when he cried. It was his last resort — and even then…
He felt awful when Lily and James hugged him, as if they were trying to mend the cracks in his heart with a kind of affection he didn’t recognise. Of course, they couldn’t — Regulus was dead. How do you fix a ghostly heart that doesn’t even beat?
How could he be a better person from the other side?
Regulus gasped weakly.
Why did his chest ache so much? He didn’t need to breathe, so why did he feel a stabbing pain in his heart every time it should have pulsed? It was stronger than him, a reflex of being alive. He wasn’t meant to feel this pain, this blistering regret. He was dead! Why… why did he still need to feel anything at all?
"She was tortured by whoever ran those experiments on her… but when she came back…" Regulus shrugged, clinging to James’s coat and Lily’s jumper as if trying to anchor himself. "She couldn’t remember much of what happened at Grimmauld Place. In fact, she didn’t really remember Sirius either. It was like… like there was a block in her memories or… as if she’d genuinely forgotten. Years later, you came along and…" His voice broke and he cleared his throat, as if trying to polish his own feelings. "We need to… we need to make Scar visit Sirius…"
He buried his face into James and Lily’s shoulders, trying to push away the memories of seeing Scarlett like that — of the panic that consumed him. Now, he understood perfectly why she’d tried so hard to forget everything. He would’ve done the same, had he been her.
"We will, Red… we will…" Lily whispered, stroking his hair with the same tenderness Scarlett used to show when they lay in bed and shared all their fears, their dreams, and their hopes. "I’ve got a plan."
Regulus wanted so badly to hear the plan, but he was too dazed by the embrace, so he let himself be held — as if by confessing all his sins, he could somehow be forgiven. Even knowing it was an illusion — a sweet, unfair, comforting illusion — he sank into the feeling and hugged them tightly, as though they were his salvation.
And deep down, where the true Regulus still lived — the real boy who carried all the regret and all the sin — he wished James and Lily Potter truly could be his salvation.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 47: The dreams in which I’m dying are the best I’ve ever had
Notes:
Trigger warning: Panic attack, suicidal thoughts, suicide attempt
Chapter Text
CXV
Her mind might’ve been foggy and heavy from the hangover, but her fingers moved over the synthesiser keys with such dexterity that Scarlett sometimes doubted whether she was really playing or if it was all just in her head.
The excited screams, the thrill and the singing echoing in unison with Stacy’s voice—reverberating in her chest like a hundred blazing sparks—were enough for Scarlett to be sure it was real.
In the darkness of the Hanged Man, crimson and blue lights danced across the crowd, until they turned to the band, the scarlet glow spilling over the figure standing in front of the two synthesisers. The warm tones of the lights swallowed Scarlett—her hair completely bleached and her pale skin—into a sea of eternal red.
She closed her eyes and tilted her head back. Her hands moved mechanically across the notes, but she was in such an intense frenzy that her brain didn’t seem to be processing anything anymore. She was utterly immersed in the song that pierced her damned soul.
Music was the only comfort in her grey days.
Even though Scarlett knew she should’ve left, there was something deep in her chest telling her it wasn’t right. It was as if anything that pulled her away from Sirius was... wrong. Unnatural. Sirius Black was the current dragging her beneath the waves, and no matter how hard she swam, in the end, she’d always be drawn to the man with starry eyes.
As she hit the final chord, the applause was so loud it jolted her out of her thoughts. Eyes half-closed, Scarlett walked alongside her bandmates and waved to the crowd—she wasn’t too worried at that moment about the chance of being recognised. She wore sunglasses, and in her head, no one would recognise her like that.
Scarlett stepped down from the stage, trading a smile with Danny and getting a pat on the back from Mike. She made her way to the table reserved for them, settling onto the booth seat against the wall.
“We smashed it tonight!” Lenny slapped the table in excitement. “Did you lot hear how many girls screamed when I was introduced?!”
“What’s the point, mate, you don’t even like girls,” Mike said, bored, earning a smack on the head from Stacy. “Ow!”
“Leave him alone!” she scolded, grabbing the basket of chips Danny had brought over.
“And what about all the blokes screaming for Star?!” the guitarist added with a teasing grin, nibbling on one of the chips.
“What?” Scarlett looked at him, completely out of sync with the conversation. She was still breathless and wired. “What blokes?”
“In the crowd… some were so taken by your beauty they barely sang. Just stood there, staring at you…” he went on, leaning his elbows on the table.
Scarlett’s heart skipped a few beats.
“What d’you mean, staring at me?!” she didn’t hide the panic in her voice.
“They were admiring you!” Danny rolled his eyes, licking his fingers. “Good Lord, no need to freak out, they’re just fans…”
“Or maybe they hate you for taking Roger’s place! That’s a possibility…” Mike joked, drumming an imaginary kit with two chips before stuffing them into his mouth. “Oi, you’re coming to my birthday after this, right?!”
Scarlett stared at him. In the dim light, he looked a lot like Remus.
My uncle… he… he hates you , Reggie’s voice whipped through her mind, making her blink rapidly.
“We could hit the arcade before my birthday,” Danny piped up, leaning over the table as if trying to get closer to her. “I wanna beat the record that little twat stole from me last summer…”
The laughter around her dissolved into nothing but a buzz as Scarlett’s chest was flooded by a torrent she’d been trying hard not to release. She stood up abruptly and plunged into the sea of bodies on the dance floor, walking quickly toward somewhere—nowhere.
Why don’t you go after Sirius, then, hm? You saw he broke out Azkaban, didn’t you?! Just one more life you’ve wrecked!
Scarlett faltered, clinging to the urgent need to find a place where she could breathe. Her head throbbed, but the throbbing was welcome—it muffled the ambient noise, scrambled her thoughts, made every conversation around her unintelligible.
When she finally found the side exit, she pushed the door harder than necessary. She filled her lungs with a deep breath of air, shuddering as the night breeze hit her, even though it wasn’t particularly cold. It was nearly summer—one of those mild spring nights. Scarlett tried to calm her thundering heart, even as her breathing came in shallow gasps.
She looked around and, once certain she was completely alone, allowed the voices that haunted her to weigh down on her shoulders, forcing her to bend under the burden. She crouched against the rough wall, drawing her knees to her chest as the tears ran silently down her face.
Cars rushed past on the nearby street, and the music leaked through the cracks of the pub door, slicing the silence with the sounds of the pulsating metropolis at the heart of the country. Scarlett felt so much, it was as if she didn’t feel anything at all anymore. She felt torn apart by every accusation that demanded far more than she could ever give, breaking her into pieces that didn’t belong in this world.
I hate what you did to me. , Sirius’s voice—shaky, brittle—was the cherry on top. I hate what we did to each other.
Scarlett gasped, digging her nails into her scalp as she clutched a fistful of bleached hair. She screwed her eyes shut, pressed her lips together, and tried to stay perfectly still—like a statue. Maybe that way the tears would go away.
They only grew more plentiful.
I knew you were vengeful, Scarlett. But cruel?
She raised her eyes to the sky, hoping to catch sight of a star, but all she could see were blurs. Even if she wasn’t crying, it would’ve been impossible to see them from there. The city lights drowned them out with ease.
There was so much she wanted to say to Sirius. She wished she’d stayed, every time she’d left. She wished… she’d said that…
I love you, Scarlett. Even after everything.
That she loved him, too. But her love was rusted, and she had no idea how to scrub the corrosion from that feeling. She didn’t want to hurt him—not again, not after all the pain she’d already caused. She needed to protect Sirius, especially from herself.
He would rebuild his life easily—he was still young, still had a bright future ahead of him…
And Scarlett…
Scarlett would carry on her life sentence, trapped in a life that wasn’t hers, never meant to be, but was all that remained. The only thing she’d managed to build during the few short weeks she’d lived freely in the city.
It wasn’t easy—being part of a band while hiding her real identity. It was exhausting, dodging the rabid fans, the praise, the constant event invitations—because the more she went out, the more likely she was to be recognised. And even though the wizarding community was small compared to London, the mere possibility of being caught again…
A chill in her stomach made her sway.
Music was the only thing that could numb her from her fate.
At the same time, it was painfully hard to remember to breathe when all she wanted was for her lungs to stop forever. For her heart to stop beating. To lie down, close her eyes, and not be visited by nightmares, by memories, or ghosts.
By nothing.
It would’ve been better for everyone. Scarlett wished she could trade her life for Lily and James’s.
They… they would’ve done so much better than her. They would’ve raised Reggie the way he deserved, the way they always had. While she… she didn’t have the faintest idea how to handle Harry.
Tired. She was tired. So tired. She needed to drown herself in alcohol to sleep, or she simply couldn’t shut her eyes. Every time she did, even for a few minutes, Marl’s face would flash in her mind. Or Avery’s. One-Eyed’s. Maurie’s… all the ones she’d killed without mercy.
Scarlett wished Sirius were there.
No matter how warm his presence was—so much so that she sometimes felt scorched by it—she longed for him to hold her in that way that made the whole world disappear, that silenced the voices, erased the fear.
Being in his arms was like being wrapped in a soft, warm blanket where nothing bad could ever touch her.
Letting the air slip from her lungs, she released a bitter laugh. Why was she so obsessed with Sirius?! It was as if she were tied to him by an unbreakable rope.
She had no idea how long she sat there, the alcohol painfully fading as sobriety crept back in. She wiped the tears from her face quickly as she noticed Lily’s presence.
Her friend’s ghost approached—flaming red hair pulled into a ponytail, her clothes covered in sequins as if she were about to head off to a rock concert.
In a way, she just had.
“Dreams are funny things… they come true when we least expect it,” Lily murmured, crouching beside her. Scarlett raised an eyebrow. “You wanted to be a famous keyboardist, remember?”
Shaking her head, Scar searched her faded memory for the moment she’d shared that dream with her friend. A warmth spread through her chest, sublime and soothing, steadying her breath and loosening the tension that had stiffened her muscles.
“Yeah, but… that’s not what I meant…” Scar exhaled sharply, burying her face in her knees. “That’s not how I pictured it.”
Lily hugged her knees too, watching the cars roll by on the road nearby before turning her attentive green eyes back to Scarlett.
“How did you picture it?”
The question made her lift her gaze, and blue met green.
Scarlett’s irises soaked up the darkness of the alley, so that the glow of the streetlamps floated across her eyes like stars drifting across the sky. Even though she was staring directly at Lily, she wasn’t really seeing her. She saw the past.
Days when smiles outnumbered tears, when love enveloped her constantly and no sharp regrets haunted her. Days when Scarlett knew exactly what the word happiness meant. Now, though, it was just a collection of letters that didn’t mean much at all.
Sirius had made her laugh a few times, true—but never in the way she thought he would. Never in that way that left her breathless, that made her cheeks ache from smiling, that wrapped her heart in something warm and gentle.
They said that when you cast the Killing Curse, you lost a piece of your soul.
That meant Scarlett had lost six.
And happiness…
Happiness seemed to be one of them.
“Playing in some daft band… but not… not this daft band.” Scarlett murmured, her voice openly frayed. “Not alone.”
“You mean the band you lot had in seventh year at Hogwarts?!” Lily rested her cheek on Scarlett’s shoulder, her pale glow reflecting in eyes clouded by the past.
“Yeah… you know… me, Sirius, Jamie, Rem…” She shrugged, wrinkling her nose. “And then… our kids would be mates and… we’d have… we’d have our family.”
Lily let out a soft chuckle, nodding.
“And that’s exactly what you’ve got in your hands… and you’re letting it slip right through your fingers. Sirius, Remus… Harry and Reg. A family.”
“It’s not the same!” Scarlett snapped, bitter. “And I… I don’t… I don’t deserve—”
“When are you going to drop this miserable self-pity, Scarlett? Summer’s nearly here, and what are you going to do when the boys go home for the holidays?! Keep ignoring them? Keep… no, not living—that’s not the right word. Surviving this shitty life you’ve carved out for yourself?! Hunting down wizards like some headless bloody chicken, thinking you’ll actually find the one who killed your family?”
“I can’t, Lily! I can’t hurt them…”
“Why do you run from happiness every time it dares to smile at you? What are you so afraid of?” Despite the softness of her tone, there was steel behind the question.
Lily Evans had always been sharp and straight to the point. Scarlett used to find it funny, watching her be that way with James.
It wasn’t funny anymore.
“Of myself, Lily! I’m scared of myself! I… I—”
Lily rolled her eyes at the same old answer.
“Yes, you hurt Sirius! You messed up, you fucked things up, you killed people! You also suffered for years, went through hell in Azkaban for the same fuck-ups! Why are you still punishing yourself?! You’re free!”
Scarlett let out a breathless laugh, her face contorting right after, as if trying to suppress the hurt.
“It’s not enough.”
“You don’t get to decide that.” Lily hissed, slapping her palms against her knees.
“My pain won’t bring Marl or her family back.”
Lily’s expression softened. She reached out to touch Scarlett’s hand, even though she knew it was useless.
“You need to talk to Sirius.”
“I won’t.”
“Scar—”
“My life doesn’t revolve around Sirius!” she burst out, which was a lie. Her life might not revolve around him, but her thoughts sure as hell did. “Fuck’s sake!”
Taking a deep breath, Lily stood up and looked down at Scarlett with her arms crossed, chin tilted in that superior little way of hers.
“He wants to talk to you too,” she said simply, before walking straight through the wall and leaving Scarlett alone again.
She wanted desperately to ask how Lily knew that, but Scar remained where she was, clenching and unclenching her jaw like she was chewing her own thoughts.
The last time they’d seen each other, Sirius had bared his heart to her… and she’d bolted. Like the coward she was. She didn’t want to crawl back with her tail between her legs but—bloody hell!
Sirius Black always knew exactly how to get under her skin. And if she was craving a bit of self-flagellation, all it took was a glimpse of him for the guilt to bare its claws and rip her to shreds.
Fine. She could at least check if Sirius was alright.
Didn’t mean she’d talk to him. She couldn’t afford to. She wouldn’t survive the weight of the look he’d probably give her—full of regret. Full of pain.
Because that’s what Scarlett Gaunt was: a painful regret.
.
.
.
According to Penny, Sirius would be at the Leaky Cauldron that evening. Scarlett didn’t want to go to Diagon Alley—especially not after questioning Heitor Selwyn—but things always felt more bearable when she was in her cat skin, especially when it came to ridiculous, reckless ideas.
At the very least, going after Sirius meant she could quieten her ghosts for a while.
She saw Prongs and Mittens running down the crowded streets with Lily, weaving between witches and wizards just out of work.
Whiskers slipped into the pub the moment the door opened and a couple walked out. The place was so packed that some patrons were standing around waiting for seats, making it difficult for the cat to move without getting stepped on.
She took shelter in the hollow of one of the unlit fireplaces, scanning the room for Sirius. It was hard to get a proper view from such a low vantage point, but then she heard a laugh that made her ears perk and her tail stick up.
She leapt quietly into the next fireplace, slipping beneath a crowded table. From there, she could see the legs of a group of four—and one of them…
Whiskers’s heart thudded in her chest.
Orfy was laughing so hard it made her feel warm inside.
That warmth soon became fine sparks burning through her heart, and she whimpered.
She almost turned to leave, but just as she moved, her gaze landed on the person with their back to her.
Sirius.
He wore his leather jacket, his biker boots and padded motorbike trousers. His long hair was tied up in a bun, and next to him sat a woman whose hair flickered between bubblegum pink and blinding purple.
She gestured wildly, then rested her head on Sirius’s shoulder with a familiarity that made Whiskers’s stomach twist.
Cats weren’t supposed to feel jealousy— shouldn’t feel jealousy—but her fur bristled, and her claws dug into the stone floor at the sight.
She strained to hear what they were saying, but the noise was overwhelming, and she could barely focus on her own breathing. A dizzy wave hit her, as if she’d just been kicked. Her tail lashed behind her in an almost uncontrollable urge to hiss and scratch the pink-haired woman.
And she might’ve done just that—
If it weren’t for the fear of rejection that dissolved the sharp glare of jealousy, wrapping her in a heavy, paralysing fog. She had no right to feel this way. Sirius was moving on—and that was what she wanted.
Unlike her, he deserved to be happy.
Even if it meant she’d live her pitiful little life watching him achieve all his dreams.
Building a family with someone else—someone who loved him the way he deserved. Someone kind, soft-hearted, someone who made him laugh every single day.
Someone capable of saying I love you too instead of running away.
Whiskers slowly backed away, careful not to get kicked. She picked up pace as she headed out of the bar, weaving quickly between the patrons while desperation surged through her veins, poisoning her senses.
What a bloody stupid idea!
Just before slipping out of the pub, she cast one last glance towards Sirius—watching him laugh, unburdened, unhurt, without regrets. His rings gleamed under the candlelight as he spun a butterbeer tankard endlessly between his fingers. The fur along her spine stood on end when she felt a pull in her chest. And as if he’d felt it too, Sirius turned his head slightly in her direction.
Whiskers held her breath, hoping he wouldn’t spot her in the crowd. She took a few hesitant steps back, bumping into hurried feet here and there.
Sirius didn’t move.
It was like he’d just looked straight into the eyes of Medusa. His expression turned serious at once, the butterbeer now still in his hand, his silver eyes wide—fixing on the cat, trapping her in the depths of his pupils. Then Sirius stood up abruptly, his stool crashing to the floor with a loud thud.
Whiskers bolted from the pub, vanishing into the darkness around the corner.
.
.
.
“Scar… you alright?!” James was looking at her in that way that, under normal circumstances, would’ve made her spill all her most morbid secrets.
But Scarlett didn’t feel normal.
She was far too busy murdering the hope that, for some reason, still lived in her chest—the expectation that Sirius would wait for her. That somehow, despite everything, he still loved her after all the times she’d stomped on his heart.
Scarlett knew it was asking too much of Sirius—but he always had a way of surprising her. For better or worse.
“I’ve got the feeling I’ve seen that woman before… the one with the pink hair…” James muttered, exhaling in frustration at Scarlett’s silence.
She wasn’t sure if her paralysis was because she didn’t want to talk about it or because she simply couldn’t.
She stood up mechanically and finished getting dressed. Not even the shower she’d taken had been enough to rinse off the melancholy that clung to her like a second skin—slipping beneath it, poisoning her veins, weakening her muscles.
Lily and Regulus kept hovering around Scarlett with that insufferably concerned look in their eyes—she honestly had no idea what they were saying anymore.
It was like her very existence was winding down, fading piece by piece, until all that remained was an empty shell.
Scarlett ignored them as she grabbed the car keys and descended the stairs of the building, stepping out into the bustling London nightlife.
She touched the ring Sirius had given her, then ran her hand across the leather jacket that once belonged to Thanatos—as if making sure she hadn’t forgotten anything.
Scarlett started up her sports car—the infamous red Honda NSX—and shot through the streets like she was in some kind of mad rush.
At first, driving had been difficult, but with James’s help, she’d learned to get around the city on her own—though her ghosts never left her side.
She didn’t need to check the rear-view mirror to know all three of them were there, sitting in the back seat, casting their pale, spectral glow across the interior.
Scarlett parked in front of a building, glancing up at the flat where a party was clearly underway. The music was so loud it echoed through the crowded street, and the balcony was packed with people drinking and chatting.
“Really? Mike’s party?” Regulus didn’t bother to hide the disgust in his voice, sneering at the sight of the balcony.
“Oh, shut the fuck up, Regulus,” Scarlett hissed, slamming the car door harder than necessary. “Stay in the bloody car, all three of you!” she snapped, finger raised. “Give me one fucking minute of peace.”
She didn’t know why it made her feel so guilty, speaking to them like that. They were ghosts—why should she care about how they felt?!
With an exasperated sigh, she marched up the building’s staircase to Mike’s floor. The door was open, and several guests were spilling out into the corridor, chatting and smoking with one another.
Scarlett weaved her way through the crowd, and as soon as she reached the apartment’s living room, she squinted at the spinning light globe on the ceiling, its chequered beams flashing across her. The place was packed with people dancing and drinking, and she wouldn’t have expected anything less—Mike was somewhat well-known in the artistic scene.
The first to spot her was Danny, sitting on one of the sofas with Lenny and Stacy. They waved at her excitedly, and Scarlett summoned every last bit of strength she had left to smile and approach, the bass of the music pounding through her body like the beats of her own heart.
“Well, look who showed up!” Danny sang lazily. “You… ran off earlier…”
“Leave her alone, Daniel!” Stacy kicked him in the shin, and he pulled a face.
“I was just saying hi!” he protested, hands raised.
“Mike’s busy… if you’re thinking about talking to him…” Lenny shouted over the noise, nodding towards a cluster of girls where the drummer stood at the centre. “Want something to drink?”
Scarlett simply nodded, lowering herself into the empty spot on the sofa. Stacy slid onto the floor, leaning her elbow on the coffee table as she arranged her neat rows of cocaine with a business card.
“Want some?” she offered, licking her lips as she rolled up a note.
“No.” Scar turned away, looking at Lenny.
“She doesn’t do drugs, Anastasia,” he said, folding his arms and grabbing the rolled-up note once Stacy had finished snorting the first line.
Danny returned with a drink that gave off a strange, bitter smell. Scarlett took one sip, grimaced, then downed the rest in one go, feeling the alcohol burn its way through her throat, larynx, and stomach. But the burn was nothing compared to the dizzying emptiness in her chest.
So she got up and went to get more—dipping her glass directly into the punch bowl.
She didn’t know how many drinks she had. She only knew that, at some point, she found herself lying on the sofa where Danny, Lenny and Stacy had been before.
The loud music pulsed through her body, but in her head, it was nothing but a distant buzz swallowed by the chaos of her thoughts. She felt her body sinking into the sofa like it was slipping into a frozen lake. Trying to block out the noise, blind herself, forget Sirius.
But to do that, she’d have to tear out a part of herself. The pain and the passion clouded her will, smothered her awareness. Drowned her free will. She wanted and didn’t want. She longed for it and feared it. She forgave and resented.
Scarlett gasped, squeezing her eyes shut tightly. She couldn’t allow herself to think. Not about the past, not the future. The former was a page so sweet and yet so tragic, that replaying it in her mind would finish her off entirely. And the latter… ah, the future was a gaping void, a wasteland, an unknown Scarlett wasn’t sure she wanted to face.
She was surrounded by people… but felt utterly alone. Her gaze wandered up to the ceiling, landing on the spinning light globe that shimmered just like Sirius’s eyes. Unpredictable. Scorching. Petrifying. No matter what she did, the globe kept spinning and casting its light over her. And Scarlett wanted so badly to be one of those people dancing—but all she could do was admire its beauty and drink in its glow. Enchanted by the man with starry eyes.
Scarlett hated herself.
It made sense for people to hate her. Her brother, her friend, and her love hated her too. So why shouldn’t she? Sirius had been right about everything he said. Scarlett was a thief. She stole his dreams, his brother, his son. She stole his love.
No. Scarlett couldn’t love Sirius. Not again.
She tried to rise from the sofa, but barely moved. She was afraid—or perhaps she hoped—to die there. She wanted many things, but none more than Sirius Black. He was her love, her sorrow, and she’d do anything to torture herself by staying away from him. They’d gone too far already, they had…
She touched her lips, remembering when Sirius kissed her—when he claimed her with such hunger she felt dizzy just from the memory. This doesn’t have to mean anything, he’d told her, right before she begged for him. Scarlett felt her heart squeezed through a funnel. Despite his warning, she had bathed in Sirius Black like a dying woman stumbling upon water.
And then, she left. To protect him. Because Remus was right. He always was—especially when it came to her and Sirius. Scarlett could spend a hundred years in Azkaban, tortured, broken, left to rot. She could wither away. She could even die.
Still, she wouldn’t deserve him. Sirius was too good for her. He raised her son. Spoke kindly of her to him. Held onto her—even when he knew she was a lost cause. It was hard to accept that Sirius Black was out of reach, but she played the judge, the jury, and the executioner all too well. Sirius wouldn’t forgive her—how could he? Why had she ever believed he would?
Back then, Sirius forgave her for everything, even when she couldn’t forgive herself.
Scarlett shook her head, forcing the warm memories away before they could break through the wall of self-inflicted punishment. She wasn’t allowed to feel these things. She’d spent so long repelling them—because of the Dementors’ presence—that now, she didn’t deserve them anymore.
She deserved all of this. Every bit of self-inflicted suffering. Because maybe, just maybe, it would make her a better person. Someone capable of loving Sirius the right way. Someone who could look her son in the eye and say how deeply she loved him—even if the circumstances of his conception were more traumatic than…
No, Scarlett, you can’t think about the past!
Not Sirius. Not Regulus…
Stop thinking.
Just stop…
"Are you alright, Star?" Danny shouted beside her, drawing her half-lidded gaze.
"Tired," she murmured, not really caring whether he heard or not. She'd been lying on that sofa for hours and felt exhausted. In truth, exhaustion had become routine. Her disordered thoughts demanded too much from her. "Tired of everything."
"What are you on about?" he laughed, with a sort of naïve youthfulness that made Scarlett long to steal that carefree feeling for herself.
"Don't know." She took a deep breath, blinking slowly.
"You're pissed," Danny stated the obvious, ruffling his hair in a way that was eerily similar to Sirius.
Scarlett’s heart reacted instantly, wrapped in the illusion that the man beside her might actually be the one who was her undoing.
"So are you." She reached out, touching the collar of Danny’s cropped T-shirt, which exposed his stomach. His hair was just as black as Sirius’s, and she dared to run her fingers through the soft strands.
He flushed, smiling so gently that Scarlett suddenly understood the hunger of the Dementors. Because she felt it too—the need to steal that joy, to feel light, to live a life where she could feel truly happy.
Scarlett pulled Danny in and kissed him.
There wasn’t even a spark—nothing like what she had with Sirius. No electricity, no thrill, no shiver. Just… nothing. It was like kissing a blank wall. Cold, flavourless… empty. Devoid of meaning or emotion. No connection. It was mechanical, like opening a door or drinking water. It wasn’t… special.
And still, Danny didn’t hesitate to kiss her back, reclining on the sofa in an attempt to deepen it, waiting for her to let him in, to let him taste the mouth he’d long desired. Scarlett, however, pulled away as if her mind had suddenly cleared. He looked at her, confused, his face so close she could feel his boozy breath against her skin.
"I need to… I need to…"
[Tears For Fears — Mad World]
The music shattered her words, because the guests began to shout and raise their hands. Scarlett took advantage of the distraction to crawl off the sofa—using a side table to push herself up. She bumped into a few people and staggered her way to the balcony.
All around me are familiar faces
Worn out places, worn out faces
Bright and early for their daily races
Going nowhere, going nowhere
Their tears are filling up their glasses
No expression, no expression
Hide my head, I want to drown my sorrow
No tomorrow, no tomorrow
She’d hoped Danny might be able to fill the hole Sirius had left in her chest, but there was no relief—no escape. Only… a reminder that she was so broken no smiling twenty-five-year-old boy could ever put her back together.
I hate what you did to me. I hate what we did to each other.
“So do I,” Scarlett murmured, utterly captive to the annihilating nature of love.
And I find it kind of funny, I find it kind of sad
The dreams in which I'm dying are the best I've ever had
I find it hard to tell you 'cause I find it hard to take
When people run in circles, it's a very, very
Mad world
Mad world
Scarlett felt as out of place there as she did anywhere else. The music was dissonant, even though the lyrics made perfect sense. She’d made so many wrong choices, hurt so many people… the best thing she could do for Sirius was to leave him be.
But how could she?
How could she just disappear from the only person who ever felt like home? Who was her place in the world? Her anchor, her safety, her saviour? It wasn’t fair. It wasn’t right.
Sirius belonged to her just as she belonged to him.
Too late.
Sirius had moved on.
That was her fate—to watch the man she loved be happy with someone else.
Scarlett looked up at the sky; it was clear. Only one star sparkled directly above her, as if it were watching her. As if it were judging her.
“Can you forgive me?” she asked the star. “Can you give me another chance?”
The star didn’t answer.
They rarely do, Scarlett.
That’s why she looked behind her, made sure no one was watching, and turned into Whiskers. It was strange being drunk in her feline skin—stranger still to climb down all those fire escape steps without tumbling.
Once she reached the ground, she returned to her human form and staggered towards her car. The fleeting relief of becoming a cat was quickly crushed beneath the emotions tearing through her body like a runaway train, reducing her to a mere passenger.
And I find it kind of funny, I find it kind of sad
The dreams in which I'm dying are the best I've ever had
I find it hard to tell you 'cause I find it hard to take
When people run in circles, it's a very, very
Mad world
Mad world
She got into the car and started it, glancing at the rear-view mirror. A lopsided, sinister smile crept onto her lips when she realised her ghosts weren’t there.
Ah… right. Alcohol made them disappear.
That was brilliant—none of them could interfere with what she wanted to do. Now all she had to do was find a lamppost and hit it at full speed! But… she was far too drunk for that. Maybe… drive the car straight into the Thames? No, no, no. She didn’t want to drown.
Regulus drowned.
The thought made her shudder.
The streetlights flashed past the car in quick succession, and through her drunken haze, all she could see were blurry smudges of the world around her. Wait a second. Did she actually want to die?
Regulus had once told her she couldn’t die. Her heart felt like it was about to burst in her chest just from considering it…
Was that her punishment then? To watch everyone she loved live on and grow old, while she remained untouched by time, paralysed by choices, imprisoned by her own crimes?
If that was true, then maybe she should’ve stayed in Azkaban. At least there, she’d have been spared the sight of happiness returning to those she loved—because all she had to do was accept that they could live perfectly well without her.
And Scar… despite everything she’d done… still had the tiniest shred of ego left. Was staying away really best for everyone? Or was it best for her? Sirius always called her selfish—and now she was starting to believe him.
But if that were true, Scarlett never would’ve killed the McKinnons to protect Reggie and Sirius. So maybe… maybe she could hold onto that and—
Scarlett didn’t remember much after aiming for the lamppost.
And I find it kind of funny, I find it kind of sad
The dreams in which I'm dying are the best I've ever had
I find it hard to tell you 'cause I find it hard to take
When people run in circles, it's a very, very
Mad world
Mad world
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 48: I want to love you, but I don’t know how. I’m not worthy of your love.
Chapter Text
CXVI
Sirius knew Scarlett, knew her so well that he very nearly laughed when he realised the cat in the Leaky Cauldron was her. At the same time, he very much wanted to grab her by the neck and ask if she had some sort of problem.
“What is it?” Orfy tied his hair back into a ponytail, draping an arm across the back of June’s chair.
“I… I thought… I saw someone… I knew.” Sirius mumbled, sinking back into his seat and praying no one could hear the hammering of his heart. “I was mistaken.”
Tonks was also glancing towards the door, but she gave a satisfied smile when Tom arrived with her fish and chips. Sirius sipped his steaming butterbeer, watching his reflection in the caramel liquid. His face was now slightly hollowed, though the remnants of Azkaban were still there: the deep shadows beneath his eyes, the overly pale skin… the melancholy in his gaze.
Alright, it wasn’t just Azkaban’s doing. In truth, Sirius was making an immeasurable effort not to feel overwhelmed by everything going on. So, he avoided thinking about it, letting the alcohol push his worries away and bring out his recklessness.
“So, Orfy, for the holidays… I was thinking…” Sirius cleared his throat, looking at his former brother-in-law. “If Reggie could stay with us.”
“’Course he can.” Orfeu frowned, savouring a shepherd’s pie. “He always spends the summer with Remus. It’s closer to the shopping centre and he’s always at the arcade.”
“The arcade? The one we went to…”
“Yeah, that’s the one.” A faint smile tugged at the boy’s lips before he turned serious again. “You smacked those lads about… and I told them you were my sister’s boyfriend…”
“I miss that day,” Sirius admitted, and Tonks made a sound of disgust.
“I don’t,” Orfy shot back with rudeness. June rubbed his back, as though trying to comfort him over something.
Sirius furrowed his brow, turning the butterbeer mug in his hands as he tried to make sense of what the boy meant.
“Why not? It was a good day, wasn’t it?” he pressed, eyes fixed on Orfy.
“Because she was there.” The bitterness in Orpheus’s voice made him swallow hard.
“Sirius…”
“Orfy… your sister loved you.” He ignored June’s warning, leaning his elbows on the table.
“She didn’t love me.” Despite Orfy’s explosive reactions to the subject in the past, this time he barely moved. “She only ever loved Regulus.”
“What are you talking about?” Sirius murmured, both dreading and yearning for the answer. Tonks and June stayed silent, as though on alert, waiting for Orfeu to lose control.
“It was him, Sirius! It was him! You haven’t realised that until now?” His voice rose with each word. “It was him who saved me!” Unbuttoning the cuff of his shirt, he showed the scars on his arm. “It was him, Sirius! He’s the one who got me out of there!”
“I know, Orfy! I know…”
“No, you don’t!” he exploded, his voice several octaves higher than normal. “You don’t know!”
“Orfy… you need to calm down,” Sirius urged, unmoved by the boy’s outburst. “I know it was Regulus… your uncle showed me the memory…”
“You’re not understanding!” He pressed on, his breathing uneven.
“That’s enough, Sirius!” Tonks cut him off before he could continue questioning, her hand tightening on his shoulder.
“Sorry,” he said, dropping his gaze back to his mug.
Orfeu merely nodded and wrapped his arms around June, hiding his face in her chest in a way that was eerily similar to how Scarlett used to do with him. The memory sent a sharp pang through his heart. Why had she gone after him?
Instinctively, Sirius glanced towards the bar’s exit, but she was no longer there. Tonks changed the subject, trying to lighten the tension, but he couldn’t bring himself to listen.
It was true—he had tried to speak to Scarlett all week, even arriving outside the Hanging Man an hour before they opened. Sirius would climb the fire escape of the building opposite and watch her wake, pause in front of the window after opening it with difficulty, and look down at the traffic below. Then she would stand for quite a while in the living room, watching what he assumed was the television.
At times, she would bury her face in her hands, and Sirius knew she was crying. It was agony to see her like that and be unable to do anything, but the thorns of rejection still poisoned his heart. And he didn’t want to pull them out—it was safer to keep them there, a constant reminder of what Scarlett was capable of doing to him.
He hadn’t learnt from the first time she abandoned him; perhaps now he might finally convince himself it was madness to desire a future with her.
It was easy to understand his emotional dependence once his memories had begun to return. He had thought Scarlett was his other half, fitting into him perfectly. But people weren’t made of halves; they were whole in themselves. Scarlett was so much more than the piece that had once been missing in Sirius. She was so much more than the girl he loved, who had broken his heart with the same determination she had once mended it.
Just as he was.
Sirius was so much more than the man who had sunk into an inescapable addiction. He was more than the shouting, the fights, and the break-ups; more than the twisted things his parents had planted in him. And it was unbearably difficult to accept that he wasn’t defined by the things he had suffered.
Harder still was not feeling lost without Scarlett, because she had been his foundation, his emotional anchor, his abyss, and his salvation. When she left sixteen years ago, he had felt exactly the same. He no longer knew how to love anyone the way he had loved Scarlett, because she had taken his love with her, leaving nothing but a dizzying void in his chest.
And now, she lived as if nothing had ever happened.
As if they hadn’t made love, hadn’t fallen asleep in each other’s arms, as if he hadn’t told her he loved her even after everything. And Scarlett, as always, had burned him until all that remained of Sirius was ash.
He let out a breath steeped in resentment, forcing a smile and talking about anything other than Scarlett, though his mind insisted on wandering back to her. He laughed at one of the pranks Tonks and June had pulled at Hogwarts, recounted some of the mischief he and James had got up to, and pretended not to care too much when the two of them praised him for being the best in the trainee Auror class.
At the end of the night, he bid farewell to Orfeu and June and watched them vanish into the green flames of the Diagon Alley Floo fireplace, all the while brooding over the fact that Regulus and Scarlett were working together to bring down Voldemort. It was a huge leap to make from the memory he’d seen, but it was the only thing that made sense.
He took a deep breath, trying to summon the courage to go and see her.
“You’ve got to stop mentioning your ex-girlfriend to Orfeu,” Tonks remarked casually. “It’s a touchy subject for him.”
“I know, but…” Sirius tried to marshal his arguments. “It’s not fair for him to say those things about her. Scarlett loves Orfy, Tonks. Loved.” He corrected himself with a cough. “And she did everything… to keep him safe. To protect him.”
“Protect him? He was tortured for years on end, Sirius.” She folded her arms, her bubblegum-pink hair darkening until it matched his own. “By Death Eaters. She was one of them.”
Sirius clenched his jaw, merely shrugging his shoulders. He couldn’t say what he wanted, so he stayed silent. Tonks couldn’t possibly know Scarlett was alive, and every time Sirius thought about her and her involvement with Regulus… everything grew murkier. It was hard to think rationally when his chest fizzed with jealousy.
A bitter laugh slipped from him. Why was he jealous? Regulus was dead. Dead after saving Orfeu. Trying to make a better world for his son…
Realising that hurt. Stripping away the monster’s skin he’d always draped over his brother and facing what he had truly been doing… it hurt. It shouldn’t, of course; the right thing would be to feel proud of Regulus — for being different from their parents. For doing what Sirius had spent his whole life doing — swimming against the current, being good even when all he got in return was punishment.
Regulus wasn’t the coward or the snake Sirius had always liked to paint him as. Nor was he the helpless victim he’d pretended to be when they were children…
Sirius had never really known Regulus. Perhaps that was what stung the most. Perhaps it was the guilt he felt for never having been able to protect him. Or perhaps it was the bottled-up anger for everything Regulus had done to him. And what did it matter? Regulus was dead.
The wound Sirius carried, however, was very much alive — crawling through his chest and sending shivers down his spine, leaving a sour taste in his mouth. Just to think… just to imagine him and Scarlett together…
“You alright?” Tonks raised a single eyebrow, shoving her hands into the pockets of her high-waisted jeans. “I’ve been talking non-stop for about fifteen minutes and you’ve still got that daft look on your face.”
Sirius furrowed his brow, looking at his cousin with seriousness before breaking his expression into a grin, giving her a light nudge with his elbow. She shoved him back in retaliation, her light eyes shifting colour until they settled into a deep brown, almost black.
In all his years in Azkaban, he’d never imagined that the smiling, mischievous little girl would one day become his partner in the Auror Office. He might have laughed at how peculiar and biting fate could be, because Tonks was a refreshing breeze in the sea of lava that churned in his chest. She was young, vivid, and full of life; her easy-going, playful nature reminded him a great deal of James.
Being with her was, in a way, like being with his old friend. Even if it wasn’t quite the same, she made his days a little lighter. And though he’d never admit it, he liked having her around. If he’d had a daughter, he’d have wanted her to be like Dora.
“You’re thinking about her, aren’t you?!” She stopped walking as they joined the queue at Florean Fortescue’s.
“What?” Sirius blinked, caught off guard, his gaze drifting to the display of ice-cream flavours that seemed to whisper in his mind.
“Scarlett,” Tonks went on, her soft features taking on a suspicious edge. She didn’t give him the chance to deny it. “What was she like?”
The question caught Sirius unawares. He was far more used to speaking about Scarlett with Remus — well, because he knew she was alive — and sometimes with his therapist without making it clear she hadn’t died, but… in every case, he rehearsed what he was going to say to avoid giving too much away. It was stupid and senseless, considering he trusted his friend and Asca implicitly, but it was part of his defence mechanism.
It was unconscious.
Scarlett was one of his vulnerabilities, and he didn’t like revealing that to others. Even if those others were… Dora.
“Difficult to handle.” He wet his lips, reaching into his pocket for a few Sickles. The shadow cast by the ice-cream parlour’s façade over the silver in Sirius’s eyes didn’t fade as they bought cones and sat at the tables set out along Diagon Alley. “She understood me like no one else.” He tried his chocolate-and-hazelnut ice-cream. Tonks had chosen the same flavour. “Stupid, stubborn, fearful, impulsive, idiotic, childish… fierce… headstrong.” The words came rattling out, one after the other, impossible to hold back. “Loving. Kind… conceited. Delicate. Not the kind of delicate because she was fragile, but the kind of person you’re afraid to hurt because she’s already been hurt too much.” He let out a heavy sigh. “Resilient. Cheerful… affectionate, but also blunt when she wanted to be. She… she is… was… like a refuge. A refuge from a shattered paradise.” He smiled to himself — a painful, coarse smile.
Which Scarlett was he talking about? The one from the past, or the one from the present?
Was there a difference? She was both… and, at the same time, neither.
“She didn’t make sense,” he finished, the smile fading as the ice cream dripped down his fingers.
“I don’t think people make sense, Sirius.” Tonks bit into her cone, her hair now a blaring shade of violet. “I mean, look at you — from Azkaban’s most dangerous prisoner to innocent, and now one of the top trainee Aurors. It’s contradictory, it’s ambiguous. People are like that.” She shrugged.
“She was…” Sirius shut his mouth at once to stop himself going on, sinking into a contemplative silence that had nothing contemplative about it. It was just another attempt to smother the flash in his mind of the girl whose hair he’d once adorned with flowers.
“You talk about her as if you still loved her.” She dabbed her mouth with a napkin, her multicoloured eyes fixed on him.
“And I do.” The confession slipped out faster than his mind could filter it, and he hoped Tonks was too wrapped up in her ice cream to have heard him.
But she had.
“Sirius… she’s dead.” Tonks rolled her eyes with a trace of sarcasm.
“Tell that to my heart.” His expression cooled, a shadow passing through his gaze before he let out a dry laugh.
“I can’t tell if that’s extremely romantic or terribly tragic.” Though she said it softly, there was a calculated weight to her words — one that unsettled him deeply.
“Why not both?!” Sirius shrugged, masking the calm he didn’t feel.
“Because… love shouldn’t be tragic!” Tonks gestured, blowing all the air from her lungs. “It… it should be light, not… not a burden.”
Sirius clenched his jaw at Nymphadora’s naivety. The silver in his eyes narrowed, the lines on his face hardening. Who was she to say what love should or shouldn’t be? Tonks had grown up in a stable home, raised by parents who loved her. She had never known the devastating nature of love, nor its claws, its teeth, its bites, its screams, its lashes.
It was maddeningly irritating how much she reminded him of James.
“That’s not how love works, Tonks,” he murmured, lips tightening.
“I know you can’t be happy in Azkaban, but why do you always have to be so bloody melancholic?!” she teased, kicking his shin beneath the table.
“I’m not… you’re the one who brought it up!” Sirius gave a snort of disdain, and Tonks clicked her tongue, irritated.
“Alright, alright… let’s change the subject!” she relented, crossing her legs. “Excited for tomorrow? You’ve been going on about the summer holidays for days now…”
“No.” His face didn’t so much as twitch as he lied. “I’m fine.”
“You’re a brilliant liar,” Tonks muttered, getting to her feet. “But it’s not good to lie to your partner, Sirius!”
“You’re not my partner, Nymphadora,” he teased, watching with amusement as Dora’s purple hair heated into a vivid, blazing red.
“Stop calling me that!” Lifting her leg to kick him, Dora ended up stumbling and falling to the floor on her own.
His mocking grin broke into a malicious laugh.
“You’d better head home before you actually hurt yourself and I get the blame…” He helped her up, the corners of his mouth still curled into a sly smile.
“This never happened!” Nymphadora brushed down her casual, somewhat Muggle-ish clothes. Jeans suited her. “Never!”
“You definitely didn’t fall over in Florean Fortescue’s tonight…” Sirius tickled her before receiving a sharp slap.
“Oh, look who’s talking! The man still in love with the girlfriend who died… Merlin knows how many years ago!”
“She was my fiancée, actually!”
“And she married your brother!”
“Ow!” Sirius pressed a hand to his chest in theatrical offence. “You just want to humiliate me so you don’t feel alone, don’t you?”
“No!” she denied in a squeaky voice. “Yes. But… I’ve got to go! So… take care, necrophile!”
“Send my love to your mum!” he called after her with a wave, watching Dora’s hair return to its bubblegum-pink hue.
She only rolled her eyes before Disapparating.
Sirius stayed seated in the ice-cream parlour until closing time.
He delayed leaving as long as possible before forcing himself to step out into Diagon Alley, where his Ninja was parked. Swinging onto the bike, he lifted his gaze to the London night sky: all he could see were the glowing windows of towering buildings and the inhospitable darkness of a dome entirely void of stars.
He slid on his helmet and started the engine, murmuring a spell that sent a golden thread glowing along the streets of the city, pointing the way to Scarlett.
.
.
.
The party was a blur of lights and colours, shadows and dancing silhouettes. From the balcony, everything was clearer still — especially with how easily Sirius spotted Scarlett there, leaning on the balustrade. She was the complete opposite of everyone else: dimmed, unmoving, grey. She stared at the sky while most people moved with such speed there was no chance to focus on anything.
Sirius cut the Ninja’s engine and made to dismount, but stopped when he saw Scarlett shrink down into Whiskers — leaping down the stairs with unnatural agility. Blinking to follow her movement, he wanted to go after her, but in an instant Scarlett was back, climbing into her car and slamming the door shut.
For all his love of motorbikes, Sirius had to admit the Honda NSX was a beautiful specimen, its engine growling in a tone harsher than his Kawasaki. She sped off, shooting down the street without bothering to stop at the red light, and almost instinctively, Sirius followed.
She was heading home. He’d taken that route plenty of times; he knew the streets of London well by now.
After all, someone had to keep an eye on Scarlett.
The engine of his Ninja roared higher with each gear shift, and he kept a safe distance as he noticed Scarlett’s Honda weaving across the empty lane, his breath misting inside the helmet as he realised she was drunk.
Of course she was drunk.
Why did he still expect any semblance of caution from Scarlett?!
They reached a busy road, forcing Sirius to draw his wand, his other hand gripping the handlebars tightly. Manoeuvring deftly between cars, he cast a spell to repel the Muggles; their vehicles began diverting into side streets, leaving him and Scarlett alone… until a flash of blue and red cut through the darkness, the strobing lights accompanied by the wail of a siren behind them.
Glancing over his shoulder, Sirius spotted the police officer tailing Scarlett. With a flick of his wrist, a pink light burst from his wand and struck the officer squarely. Suddenly disoriented, the Muggle veered off in another direction, the siren’s sound fading away between the mirrored buildings.
Sirius slid his wand back into the holster of his coat, his black helmet reflecting the houses whipping past as he gunned the throttle to match Scarlett’s pace. She sped past the Hanging Man building, and for a few distracted seconds, Sirius lost the Honda’s tail.
“What the hell are you doing, Scarlett?!” he muttered to himself as he realised she wasn’t slowing down.
Twisting the throttle, Sirius pushed harder, the sound of the red car and the black bike’s pursuit tearing through the London streets. He leaned his body over the motorcycle, cutting through the wind resistance and closing the gap once more. His aim was to get her attention, to make her brake, but she was hurtling dangerously close towards a lamppost at the end of the street and, as if knowing exactly what to do, Sirius drew his wand again, steadying the bike with his left hand.
With his heart pounding and panic clawing at his throat, Sirius aimed the wand in one smooth, precise movement, pointing at the Honda NSX as he whispered:
“Aresto Momentum!”
Scarlett’s car jolted, slowing as though an invisible force were dragging it backwards, the spell cushioning its momentum until it came to a complete halt mere inches from a fatal impact with the lamppost, hovering gently before settling with half its frame over the road and the other half on the pavement.
Sirius exhaled all the air in his lungs, fogging his visor even further. Quickly downshifting, he took a sharp turn in the road to circle back towards Scarlett.
With his heart set on splintering his ribs and his throat strangled by the lack of air, Sirius tore off his helmet, dismounted, and strode heavily towards the red car, wrenching the door open with all the force behind his movement.
“ARE YOU BLOODY MAD?!” His voice exploded, echoing through the shuttered shops around them, his ragged breathing catching in his chest every time he tried to draw in air.
He wanted nothing more than to shout at her, but the fury blazing through his veins was smothered by remorse, the sordid feeling turning inward as he realised she was in shock. He wanted to keep shouting, to ask why she’d been speeding straight towards the lamppost… but the obvious answer hit him like a punch to the gut, bile burning up his throat.
For a few seconds, all Sirius could hear was the tumult of his own pulse. Scarlett remained still, staring ahead as if he weren’t there, her fists clamped so tightly on the wheel that her knuckles had gone white.
“Scar… Scarlett…” he heard himself call her, but she didn’t so much as glance at him.
It was as if he didn’t exist.
“Why won’t you just let me die, Regulus?” Scarlett murmured, her gaze drifting slowly across Sirius’s face, her pupils clouded by drink. “Just… let me die.” She rested her forehead against the steering wheel, curling in on herself. “Let me die.”
Sirius didn’t know what to do. For so long, he’d wished Scarlett was dead — because then he would be free from the chains of his love, the taste of her bitterness, the comfort of her warmth. To see her wishing it…
He clenched his jaw, moving on an uncontrollable impulse. Unfastening her seat belt — at least she was wearing one — he gently pulled her from the car. She neither resisted nor reacted. Holding her tightly, he’d planned to Disapparate, but seeing how she could barely stand made him abandon the idea. He didn’t want to Splinch her, so he forced himself to lift her into his arms.
“You’re dead — why can’t I die too?” Scarlett faltered, resting her head on his shoulder, the scent of vanilla flooding Sirius’s senses.
Sirius closed his eyes for a moment, drinking in the aroma that set butterflies loose in his stomach before returning to reality. He walked around the car and placed her in the passenger seat, sliding into the driver’s side himself. The engine was still running, so he simply reversed off the pavement and pulled away, heading towards the Hanging Man and making a mental note of where he’d left his bike so he could Apparate back for it after getting her home.
“I saw him,” Scarlett went on, her head tilted back against the seat, eyes closed. “He’s so beautiful. No wonder… he’s found someone else. He’s like… like the sun. No matter… no matter how far I reach out, I…” She pressed her lips together. “I’ll never reach him.”
Sirius glanced at her from the corner of his eye, knowing exactly what she was talking about but pretending not to understand. He couldn’t understand. He didn’t want to give breath to the flame that was trying to rekindle in his chest.
“He should’ve left me in Azkaban,” Scarlett spoke calmly under the influence of drink, as though she were almost asleep. “Let me rot in Azkaban.”
“What are you talk—”
“You know very well, Regulus.” She cut him off, lethargic. “Stop playing the fool!”
Scarlett was so drunk she thought he was Regulus?! Sirius didn’t want to think too hard. He couldn’t think, hesitate, or even entertain the thought. Not with Scarlett beside him, singing in his ears like a siren.
“We’re here.” Pensive, he parked beside the Hanging Man building. Why had Scarlett tried to crash into the lamppost?
Sirius barely had time to switch off the engine before Scarlett opened the door and, off-balance, fell straight onto the pavement. He got out of the car and rounded it in an instant, finding her lying on the kerb with her face resting on her forearm, as though trying to find comfort in the cold, hard concrete.
“For Merlin’s sake, Scarlett…” he grumbled, groaning as he lifted her into his arms. She was light, but his muscles were rigid, as though he’d just finished an intense workout, his breathing heavy.
“This is new…” she whispered, nestling into his chest, close to his heart.
Sirius carried her to the building’s door, propping her against the wall while fishing the keys from the pocket of her red leather jacket. He unlocked it and climbed the stairs carefully so as not to drop her.
“Bloody hell, I’m too old… for this…” he panted, stepping into Scarlett’s flat and kicking a few bottles out of the way.
He laid her down carefully on the worn sofa, catching his breath as he took in the state of the place. The light from the streetlamps streamed through the windows, faintly illuminating the furniture in the living room, glinting off the whisky bottles on the floor and highlighting the dust covering the ornaments. The sink in the kitchen, open to the living room, overflowed with dirty dishes.
Scarlett had tried to crash into a lamppost.
He shook his head in an effort to drive the thought away, leaning against the arm of the sofa. Turning his head, he noticed Scarlett watching him, and a chill in his stomach made him shiver. He ran a hand through his dishevelled hair; her blue eyes followed the movement.
“I know what you’re going to say, but he’s everything I’ve ever wanted,” she mumbled, swallowing hard. “But… I don’t deserve him. A hundred years in Azkaban and still… I wouldn’t deserve him.”
Sirius raised an eyebrow. What was she talking about?
“And… if the price to protect him from myself was for him to hate me, then so be it. I don’t much like myself either. Never have, really. And now… now when I start to like myself… when I start to live my dream…” Her blue eyes were locked on his star-like ones. Sirius drew in a sharp breath, a spark flaring in his chest as all his defences crumbled to dust before the woman he loved. Scarlett was looking into his soul, the turbulent ocean of her irises becoming more and more inviting, the darkness of her pupils pulling him to the edge of the precipice.
Sirius felt he could dive into those eyes and spend his entire life there, even if it all seemed to be falling apart. Even if Scarlett’s soul felt incomplete since the last time he’d seen her, as if it were cracked. Splintered. Broken.
“I feel so alone. Constantly remembering Marl, what I’ve done, Azkaban, the tortures… I can still feel the Cruciatus echoing in my bones. I can still feel Avery’s blood on my hands… hot and sticky—” She glanced down at her open, trembling palms as if they were stained. “I can still feel the engulfing fear that… that suddenly I’ll be back in that cage and… and they’ll torture me again.”
“Scar…” Sirius called her name, trying to sound steady, but his voice was no more than a wavering gasp.
“I’m scared. I’m so scared. I have constant nightmares. That’s why… why I’m drinking so much… I wanted to forget, Sirius, and I wanted to sleep in peace, without you haunting me. Without nightmares, without Marl or Maurie, without Cruciatus or Azkaban, just…” She opened and closed her mouth a few times, and Sirius knelt before her, struck by her confession. “I know I don’t deserve it, but I wanted a bit of peace.”
A tangle of feelings rose in his chest, but Sirius swallowed them down with difficulty. Dazed, he tried to take in everything she was saying.
“Then why don’t you go to him? Talk to him?” The question left his lips reluctantly.
“I can’t. I can’t…”
“Why not?!”
“I killed them, Regulus.” She gasped, clapping a hand over her mouth. “Maurie… Marl… the McKinnons… they weren’t all supposed to be there! It all went wrong. Your bloody plan… it all went wrong.”
Sirius stayed silent for several minutes, digesting the information. There was more to that story — with Scarlett, there always was more.
“He’ll never forgive me.” Disgust was rooted in her voice, the lines of her face trying to hide the pain in the shadows of her expression, even as she fought to contain the deep suffering that coloured the blue of her eyes.
Sirius’s expression twisted, as though it hurt him too.
“And if he forgives you?” The question was no more than a languid sigh.
Scarlett let out a weary little huff of a smile.
“Ah, Red, get one thing into your head… Scarlett Gaunt and happiness in the same sentence just doesn’t exist.” She lowered her gaze, her long lashes casting a sombre shadow across her irises, obscuring her expression. “I kissed Danny.”
Sirius’s heart twisted at the revelation and his chest boiled over, evaporating anything he might have said to console her. He barely noticed his hands curling into fists. He knew Scarlett hadn’t belonged to him for a long time, though he wished otherwise.
An irresistible urge to hurt her flooded through him. Not in a way that would make her cry — but in a way that would make her beg for more. He clenched his jaw. Scarlett was his, only his, and the only mouth she should ever be kissing was his.
Sirius straightened, electricity running through him, hungry to make her regret kissing someone else. But she went on:
“You know what I felt? Nothing.” She exhaled sharply, and Sirius threw his head back as if she’d just slapped him. The jealousy cooled, leaving only the taste of ashes in his mouth. “It was like kissing you, Red. I felt nothing.”
If the words that had filled his head moments before had turned to vapour, now they were gone entirely — never to return. Sirius wanted to hold Scarlett, and yet he felt like a lost little boy. She had never loved Regulus — that had been clear in every interaction between them — but it was as though she hadn’t even liked his brother.
Why did you two get married? he wanted to ask. Why did you try to crash into the lamppost?
“I wanted… I wanted Sirius to be here. He’s the only one who makes me feel safe… I know… I know it’s not fair… that he doesn’t deserve that…”
Sirius might have laughed at how utterly contradictory Scarlett could be… until his gaze fell upon the black diamond ring that glinted on her finger when she hid her face in her hands.
That was the end of him.
New and old emotions wrestled within him for dominance, and the wound that had never healed began to bleed freely, flooding his chest with all the things he’d buried over the years. He wanted to leave the past behind, but it was impossible not to be seized by the grief and fear knotted tight in his throat. And it was exhausting to resist the rage born of his remorse.
Now, Sirius wanted to hurt her in a way that would make her cry. He could squeeze that slender, pale neck until she stopped moving, could dig his nails into the vein pulsing beneath her white skin, could bite her lower lip as he took her slowly and made her moan his name.
Sirius Black could do many things — though, no matter how much he yearned for it, cruelty was not one of them. Not with Scarlett. Not with his Scarlett.
“Scar…” he called her, and she moved her fingers away just enough for her sea-blue eyes to meet his starry ones. “I’m here.”
“I’m not talking about you. I’m talking about Sirius.” Scarlett blinked slowly, as though her eyelids were heavy.
“I’m not Regulus, Scar.” He unzipped his leather jacket, tugging back the sleeve of his black T-shirt. He did the same with Scarlett’s jacket, placing his arm alongside hers, letting his sly gaze rest on the burn scar that cut across both their forearms, completing each other.
Scarlett’s eyes widened, lifting them slowly as the weight of everything she’d just said sank in. She wanted to run, but her body wouldn’t obey her, and it became all the harder to pull away when Sirius held her as if he could piece her scattered fragments back together again. But he couldn’t. In truth, Sirius Black was the very cause of her destruction. Every shard she had painstakingly fitted together in the two weeks away from him crumbled like a house of cards.
Scarlett was weak — unable to resist Sirius, unable to say no to him, unable to fight against the feeling that bound them in such an excruciating way. She liked it, liked to suffer for him, liked to martyr herself. It felt good; it let her indulge in the fantasy of being taken back, of being loved as she had always longed for, of having the heart of the brightest star in the night sky all to herself.
She knew it would never come true, but they were only harmless suppositions — or so she told herself — ones that surely wouldn’t turn into barbed hooks tearing viciously at her heart when she finally realised that, in truth, it never would be real. Tears welled in her eyes and began to fall, one after another, dragging up things from the depths of her soul she hadn’t even known were there. Twisted things and loving things, painful things and tender things. Pulling her out of her dissociative shell, reality poured down her face like a torrential rain, enclosing her in the blinding presence of Sirius.
“I’m sorry…” she whispered into his jacket, sobbing, curling entirely in on herself as though that embrace was the only thing holding her pain in place. “I’m sorry.”
Sirius wanted to lie and tell her it was all right, but… knowing she felt safe in his presence left him just as intoxicated as she was. He hated the way his heart leapt when Scar’s warm, damp cheek brushed the curve of his neck. And he betrayed himself by lowering his face once more, breathing in that vanilla scent that could summon so many moments from the past. Sirius hated himself for giving in to that exquisite torture, to the desire that flared inside him every time her warm breath spread across his gooseflesh.
His tattooed fingers traced the length of Scarlett’s back as he let the weight of his body be supported by the knee braced on the sofa, leaning over her and pulling her closer, pressing her chest to his, feeling every nuance of her muscles, her shallow, hitching breaths, her trembling hesitation. Scarlett moved her face away just enough to look at him, still so close that Sirius could taste the alcohol on her breath.
“I want to love you, Sirius, but I don’t know how. I’m not worthy of your love.” Her voice came out shaky, thick, drawn-out.
Sirius Black was, once again, undone by Scarlett Gaunt.
If there had been any reluctance in his actions before, now there was none.
He didn’t know what Scarlett felt when she kissed him, but the instant their mouths touched, a shiver ran through his body as his lips moved over hers, caressing them, savouring them, worshipping them.
Scarlett was warm, her fevered palms brushing his beard before one arm curled over his shoulder, the other gripping the lapel of his T-shirt. Sirius pulled her tighter against him, a hint of desperation in the press of their mouths, feeling the taut gasp Scarlett breathed out the moment he sank his hand into her ridiculously bleached hair.
Feeling the fierce hammer of Scarlett’s heart against his chest, Sirius gave way to her tongue, tasting the burn of alcohol tracing the roof of his mouth. The intoxication wasn’t limited to the fiery kiss, but also to Scarlett’s languid movements. She clearly wanted to keep control of the moment; surrendering herself entirely to whatever it was that danced between them. That thing with a name, with a shape, with a start date… and an end date.
Scarlett was drunk, and Sirius could have done whatever he pleased with her.
That was why he pushed her away gently, parting their mouths and their bodies, trying to summon reason back into his head after Scarlett had driven it away so easily.
Sirius knew that just one kiss would never sate him. He wasn’t a man who took crumbs; he would have all of her, or nothing at all.
And this woman was dangerous. She was sly, spiteful. She could bring him to his knees with the snap of her fingers. Sirius was going to stand, but stopped when Scarlett’s fingertips slid through a lock of his hair, tucking it carefully behind his ear. As though he were something fragile.
Sirius followed the movement of her hand, the gleam of the black diamond on her ring finger blinding him like a spotlight. The engagement ring he’d given her when they were still happy. Before the war. Before… before everything.
The memory of that day rose in his mind like iridescent bubbles, but Sirius burst them before they could take hold of him. The sweet taste of Scarlett’s kiss had turned bitter in his mouth, and he pressed his tongue to the roof as though trying to stop it. As though trying to keep the past sealed inside its untouched snow globe, where everything was perfect and everyone was happy.
“You’re so, so beautiful.” Scarlett murmured, stroking his cheek. Sirius squeezed his eyes shut, feeling his self-control melt between her fingers. “The brightest star in the night sky. My star. My weakness. My love.”
He opened his eyes, greeted by the inviting, glimmering calm of Scarlett’s irises. It was like a pool bathed in summer sunlight; cool, yet delicious. Full, high, and overflowing. Begging him to dive in, to taste and delight in it. And even though he knew exactly what it felt like to swim in the tranquil waters of those inebriated eyes, even though he wanted to float in them forever, carried away by the affectionate words Scarlett was pouring into his ears…
She was only saying those things because she was drunk. Sirius knew her—knew exactly how alcohol could thin her walls and turn her into one of his favourite Scarletts…
Even so, it wouldn’t be fair to her, and Sirius Black was no longer the teenager who once let himself be led by intoxicated promises.
“You need to sleep.” That was all he said in response to Scarlett’s advance, sliding his arm beneath her legs and lifting her into his arms once more.
He placed Scarlett gently onto her bed, ignoring the confused look she gave him.
“Sleep with me.” she asked, her adorably flushed cheeks making the freckles on her face stand out. “Please, Sirius.” She closed her eyes, long lashes fanning over her cheekbones. “Don’t leave me alone.”
Sirius didn’t answer. He didn’t need to. Even so, Scarlett smiled, sighed, and snuggled into the sheets, kicking off her shoes. She opened her eyes again, her expression shifting into something weary, the dark circles under her eyes sinking deeper into her skin.
“I never leave you alone.” he whispered, hoping she wouldn’t hear him. He reached into the enchanted pocket of his leather trousers and pulled out a hangover potion, bit the cork free, and cupped Scarlett’s cheek to keep her from drifting into sleep. “You need to drink this, or you’ll be in a dreadful state tomorrow.”
Scarlett grunted, pulling a face and turning her head away. But it didn’t take long for her to give in, peering at Sirius through half-lidded eyes. She let out a disgusted sound as she drank down the entire contents of the potion, clapping a hand over her mouth as though she were about to be sick.
“All right?” Sirius asked, threading his fingertips into the pale, platinum-blonde strands of her hair. Scarlett sniffled, closed her eyes, and nodded, clutching his wrist with surprising strength, as though she feared he might leave.
“It’s not the same with other people,” Scarlett confided, brushing her nose against the back of Sirius’s hand. “It’s not the same when I’m with you.”
Sirius pressed his lips to Scarlett’s fingers, one by one, feeling the cold, black diamond against his mouth before nodding and lowering his forehead to her hand.
“No… it isn’t,” he agreed, before abruptly straightening up. If he stayed there a moment longer, he’d give in.
He made sure Scarlett had fallen asleep safely, cast one last glance at her from the doorway, and left.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 49: Listen carefully to the sound of your loneliness
Chapter Text
CXVII
The sun was rising from the sea on the horizon, setting the waters ablaze with red and gold, brushing the crests of the waves with its light. The stars faded from the sky with the arrival of dawn, and the cold, salty, humid wind caressed Scarlett’s cheeks. She sank her feet into the cool sand and rested her chin on her knees, one hand placed over her belly, the other stroking her engagement ring.
"Sirius is an idiot." The firm voice drew her attention. Scarlett glanced over her shoulder, taking in the tall woman with perfectly curled blonde hair.
Marlene approached and sat down beside her, rubbing her feet endlessly in the sand.
"I don’t know when this started… and I don’t know how to stop it." Scarlett sighed, the sea breeze whipping her hair.
"I don’t think that’s your problem." Marl pushed her golden locks behind her ears.
"No? He’s like this because of the fire… and Halloween…"
"Which is not your fault." She cut her off. "Neither that nor Sirius becoming a drunken arse."
"But I don’t… I don’t know what to do, Marl." Hiding her face between her knees, Scarlett tried to quell the crushing weight in her chest. "I don’t know how to help him."
"It’s not you who has to do something, Scar." She lifted her head, the sun painting her bronzed cheeks. "It’s him who has to take the initiative to quit. Not you."
"But… but what if I…"
"It’s an addiction, Scarlett. There’s nothing you can do without him truly wanting it."
Scarlett raised her head just enough for her black hair not to block her view of Marlene, though her graceful face was now blurred and confused, like a wet painting. She tried to reach out to the image of her friend, but Marl slowly drifted away, the sand carried off by the wind and the sea swallowed by the darkness of her eyelids.
The touch of a sunbeam woke her.
It was the first time in that room that Scarlett hadn’t woken with a start from a nightmare or with her head heavy from a hangover. On the contrary, she felt well despite the hunger. Her eyes swept the strangely clean room, and the relaxed state of her body was replaced by an electrifying tension.
Scarlett grabbed her wand from the table and tiptoed, still drowsy, to the bedroom door. She opened it carefully, peeking through the crack into the living room.
Lily was sitting on the sofa, chatting animatedly with Regulus, while James waited impatiently in the kitchen, as it was his day to cook. But that wasn’t what caught her attention: the place was impeccably clean and tidy. The bottles scattered on the floor, the dishes in the sink, the grime on the furniture… all gone.
She left the bedroom without hiding the confusion on her face, ignoring the looks her ghosts threw at her.
"It was Penny," Lily explained with an excitement Scarlett didn’t share. "She came here and—"
"How does Penny have access to my house?" Scar cut her friend’s sentence short, casting an exasperated look at Regulus.
He merely raised an eyebrow in insolent fashion.
"You’re the one who should know. Have you forgotten we’ve no idea what happens to you when you’re pissed?" he retorted with condescension.
Scarlett let out a precise, incredulous hiss of breath. Despair wanted to quicken the beat of her heart, but there was something in her veins warming her reactions. Relaxing her muscles. Leaving her memory in disarray.
"Today’s the day when Harry and Reg—"
"Shut up, James," Scarlett hissed, losing herself in the events of the previous night until her ghosts’ protests became nothing but a drone. She saw Lily’s wide green eyes glaring at her, Regulus’s grey ones gone rigid, and the chocolate-brown of James’s irises cracking as if he were deeply hurt.
She wanted to apologise, to say something that would make him smile, but James merely pressed his lips together and walked through the wall, vanishing. What had happened the night before? She couldn’t remember. Penny… why Penny…
She immediately rushed to the blank board, checking whether her plans had been discovered. Lily followed her, buzzing in her ear without pause to the point of tears. Scarlett couldn’t understand. Why was she crying? She sought some form of comfort in Regulus, but he only turned his face aside, refusing to meet her eyes.
"I think the best thing you ever did was leave Reggie to Sirius, really. You’d have been a very disappointing mother to him! More than you already are!" Lily lashed out, striding towards the wall before disappearing.
Scarlett felt nothing at her friend’s words. She knew she should, but she didn’t. It was as though her feelings had slipped through the ramparts of her mind and vanished into the world, just like her ghosts. And still, tears rolled down her cheeks. Even without wanting to cry. Even without…
"Scar…" Red called her, but she waved it off as though it didn’t matter.
She spun on her heels, showered, got dressed, and began her day at the Hanging Man. The shift working as a bartender was one of the quietest — she didn’t need to rush back and forth taking and delivering orders. It was only a matter of making the drinks ordered, washing glasses or goblets, and, finally, the lunch hour.
"So… Star…" Danny sat down beside her, resting his elbows on the table and flashing a grin from ear to ear. "At the party…"
Ah. The party. She recalled one thing or another — and one of them was kissing Danny. Then, she went down the stairs, got into the car and…
She remembered the growl of the engine, the way she swiftly shifted gears, the speed climbing exponentially. Her heart skipped a beat and a faint, awkward smile brushed her lips before she wiped them with a napkin.
"What about the party?" she shot back, visibly embarrassed.
Danny frowned, shoving a huge piece of chicken into his mouth and shrugging at her reaction.
"Nothing… just… er, wanted to know if… if you… enjoyed yourself." He stammered, then cleared his throat and patted his chest.
Scarlett searched the room for her ghosts, but there was no sign of them. Her heart skipped another beat as a strange sense of insecurity coiled around her. She forced a smile and nodded, wondering why they were angry… even though she knew the answer.
She knew exactly what day it was, though she pretended not to. It was better that way. She was no longer a witch, and she couldn’t bear to look at Sirius, because now he had his family. He’d been quick to replace her. And Regulus… as much as she wanted to see him, it was better that he was raised by Sirius. Lily had been right.
"They dropped this off earlier for you…" Danny slid a small folded piece of paper across the table. "It was your brother-in-law."
Scarlett sighed. It was enough for her thoughts to stray to Sirius for him to materialise. She picked up the paper and unfolded it, stroking the refined, beautiful handwriting.
King’s Cross Station, 7 p.m.
Come as Whiskers.
SOB
The time she spent staring at the paper felt like both a second and an eternity. Then, slowly, she closed her palm around it and crumpled the note. She blinked a few times, distracted, and turned to Danny, changing the subject.
She had never seen Danny talk about a gig with such excitement. Scarlett still hadn’t confirmed she was going, and he tried to convince her, as a considerable portion of the setlist was Fleetwood Mac and she was a very good pianist, but…
Scarlett very much wanted to see Reggie, even knowing that…
"Thing is, a gig at The Hope & Anchor is a big deal. You know Joy Division played there, right? And The Cure!" He gestured enthusiastically, and Scarlett felt exhausted from trying to pretend she felt the same.
She clenched her jaw tightly and nodded at Danny, sinking into her chair.
"I know." She lied. She’d only discovered Joy Division recently and had been arrested shortly after The Cure formed. She had no idea where they’d played or hadn’t played. "I just… what time?"
"Seven. There’s still time… you know the songs, don’t you?"
"I do." Scarlett gave a timid smile. Apparently, music was the only thing she was good at. The only social circle where people didn’t openly despise her. She swallowed with difficulty, holding her pocket watch beneath the table, hoping it might give her some kind of strength or…
"So, you in or not?" Danny nudged her gently, his eyes gleaming with excitement. "This’ll be a huge opportunity for us. Before long we’ll be opening for famous bands and…"
You could spend another hundred years in Azkaban, Scarlett, and you still wouldn’t deserve him! You never would.
Scarlett shivered all over, Remus’s voice echoing in her mind until all that remained of her thoughts was the mountain of guilt, grief, and anger she held towards herself.
"Alright." Her reply was barely more than a breath. "I’ll play tonight."
.
.
.
Sirius let out a sharp breath, tapping his foot against the floor as he checked his pocket watch every minute. His gaze kept darting to the entrance of Platform 9 ¾. He’d given Scarlett the benefit of the doubt, but the creeping sense of regret began to gnaw at him as he saw it was already seven o’clock and she hadn’t even arrived.
Remus, leaning against the wall beside him, swathed in a coat and hat from head to toe in the middle of summer, gave him a reassuring pat on the shoulder, wearing an expression of weariness.
"Told you she wouldn’t come," he muttered, turning his face towards the Hogwarts Express, which had just arrived.
With a heavy sigh, Sirius masked the amalgam of disappointment and resignation that crossed his face, watching the train pull in as the pounding of his heart grew stronger.
The smell of smoke, the anxious parents, the screech of the brakes — it all bloomed into a surreal sensation in his chest, bringing back every time he’d returned from Hogwarts. He had always hated spending the holidays at home; he’d have rather stayed at school, even alone… just the thought of seeing his parents again…
His heart thudded, even with Orion and Walburga long dead. He knew the sense of danger washing over him was nothing more than an irrational reflex, and he caught himself on the verge of tears.
No.
Now the roles were reversed. He was the one standing there to collect his children from the platform, and he would do everything in his power to make sure they never felt the fear and dread he had of his own parents. He would break the sadistic, sick cycle of the House of Black. He would kill the violent, raging, sharp-edged love, and instead nurture one that listens, respects, and welcomes.
The doors of the Hogwarts Express finally opened and the students began disembarking one by one. Sirius and Remus hurried forward until they spotted Harry and Regulus with their friends.
The worry over Scarlett vanished for a moment when Sirius opened his arms and Reggie was the first to hurl himself into the embrace as if they hadn’t seen each other in ages. Harry, with a shy smile, stopped beside him, waiting his turn, but Sirius wrapped his arms around him as well, lifting him slightly off the ground, swept up in all the euphoria and joy pumping through his veins.
"Reg! Harry!" He planted a kiss on each of their heads, ruffling his godson’s messy hair in the same way he used to with James. The texture of the strands was identical to his friend’s. "Just look at you two! You’ve grown so much!" He set them back down.
Reggie’s freckled smile was the spitting image of Scarlett’s. His black hair, however, reminded Sirius of his brother. The shape of his face, the steel burning in his gaze, the aristocratic nose. He’d inherited all the imposing features of the Blacks, though mixed with the Gaunt legacy.
Harry, a little timid, quickly averted his gaze as if unsure what to say. His green eyes were a perfect copy of Lily’s, though everything else…
Ah, it was as if James had never died. As if he were right there beside him again, only now at thirteen years old. Back when Sirius too was just a naïve boy, before he had lashed out at Red, before…
Sirius felt the urge to cry again, having them both there with him. Accepting that those two babies were now towering boys at Hogwarts.
His boys.
He glanced around, feeling a little lost.
He wished Scarlett were there.
All of Harry’s and Reg’s friends stared at Sirius as if he were a ghost — Hermione, Ron, Victoria, Luana, Fred and George Weasley.
Then a wave of whispers swept across the platform as the other students realised that was the pardoned-convict Sirius Black, and Remus Lupin, the werewolf professor. A gap formed between the rest of the crowd and Sirius, as though they carried the plague itself.
Sirius wrinkled his nose and rolled his eyes, turning to his nephew:
"Got your letter last week. I reckon you’ll get at least ten Outstandings." He slung an arm around Reg’s shoulders.
"Where’s my mum?" The boy ignored him entirely, scanning the sea of witches and wizards for Scarlett.
Sirius bit his lower lip, doing the same, trying to keep the flame of hope alive that she might still appear, that she was only late.
She didn’t.
"She… must have had something come up." He quickly offered the excuse, forcing a carefree smile. Reggie also tried to hide his disappointment, though the blue of his eyes was now shadowed by sadness.
"But we’ve got a surprise for you…" Remus hugged Regulus, whose melancholy expression was swapped for laughter when his uncle tickled him.
"Surprise?"
Sirius turned his attention to Harry, his hand tightening on the boy’s nape as he took in the lightning-bolt scar, half-hidden by the rebellious fringe yet still visible. The boy still seemed too stunned to say anything.
"I still can’t believe Scabbers was Peter Pettigrew…" Ron mumbled, and Sirius laughed.
"I reckon I owe you an apology, Weasley…"
"Ron… RONALD! FRED! GEORGE! GET AWAY FROM HIM!" A loud, flame-haired woman in a hideous dress burst onto the platform, waving frantically at her sons. "GET AWAY FROM SIRIUS BLACK!"
Sirius narrowed his eyes as he recognised the eldest sister of the Prewett twins. Her name was on the tip of his tongue but kept slipping away with maddening ease. She was looking at him with such wariness as she approached that Sirius felt like a criminal all over again.
"Molly, love, Sirius was cleared! He’s no longer a fugitive, it’s fine." Her husband, Arthur, arrived, panting. "He’s been proven innocent."
Despite his words, the woman’s expression remained tight and distrustful. In response, Sirius arched a brow and tilted his chin to its most arrogant angle.
"It’s alright, Mrs Weasley." It was Harry who tried to smooth things over, though awkwardly.
"Oh, Harry, dear!" Molly gave the boy a quick hug. "I hope you had a good year, despite what happened…"
"It was great!" He cut her off before she could finish.
Molly turned to her children, motioning for them to follow.
"Come along, Arthur, get Ginny’s bags. Boys, with me!" the matriarch commanded, and her brood obeyed, offering clumsy goodbyes.
"I’ll get in touch about the Quidditch World Cup!" Ron called to Harry as they left.
With a strained smile, Arthur did as he was told, though not without turning back to them first.
"Sorry about that, Sirius, Harry… Molly’s still… concerned." He murmured, looking a little embarrassed.
"It’s fine." Sirius only shrugged one shoulder, watching him disappear into the crowd. "Blimey, how many children does she have?!"
"Seven." Harry and Hermione answered in unison.
"Yeah… we know some of them, don’t we?" He glanced sidelong at Remus, who nodded in confirmation. "But… by Merlin’s balls. Seven children."
"The twins are in my year." Regulus crossed his arms as the shock of red hair vanished into the exit. "They’re Beaters too, only for Gryffindor."
His nephew’s comment made Sirius widen his eyes and pull Harry closer.
"So, did you like the Firebolt I gave you?!" he asked, watching his godson’s reaction intently.
"It was you?!" Harry adjusted his glasses, his awkward expression breaking into a surprised smile. "I… I loved it! It was… it was the best present I’ve ever had. Thank you so much, Sirius!"
"Ah, I told you it was him!" Hermione exclaimed triumphantly.
"Consider the broom the equivalent of thirteen years’ worth of presents from your godfather!" Sirius buried his face in Harry’s hair, feeling the boy shrink under the touch. He didn’t seem used to that sort of affection, so Sirius stepped back.
"I can’t believe you gave him a broom and didn’t get caught," Remus remarked, eyeing him from the corner of his eye. "How did you manage that?"
"Ah…" Sirius smiled, glancing at Hermione’s cat in her arms. "I had Crookshanks take the purchase order to the Owl Office for me. Used Harry’s name, but the gold came from my vault." He stroked the cat, who began to purr. "He’s very clever."
"He is… if only we’d realised sooner that Wormtail was Peter…" Hermione sighed, dispirited.
"Don’t worry. Now the whole country’s after him…" Sirius said, though even he didn’t believe Peter would be caught any time soon.
"So, um, Sirius, about what you said… at the Whomping Willow… about… about me living with you…" Harry stammered, staring fixedly at a portly man with a thick black moustache who was approaching with a sour expression.
Sirius remembered Vernon Dursley all too well. He didn’t bother hiding the disdain in his face as he looked at the man, though Harry’s guardian didn’t seem to recognise him.
"I know, Harry. I’ll come to get you to spend the holidays with me, alright?" he promised, crouching so he was at his godson’s height.
"When?" Harry’s face lit up at the possibility.
"You’ll see." Sirius gave a mischievous little smile. "But I need you to go with your uncle now…" he encouraged, his heart tearing in two at the disappointed lines that flickered across Harry’s face.
"Alright…" he agreed reluctantly.
Harry pushed his trolley with his trunk and Hedwig’s cage towards his uncle, who didn’t take his eyes off Sirius.
"Who’s that?" Vernon growled.
"He’s my godfather," Harry replied, cynical.
"Godfather?" he spluttered. "You don’t have a godfather!"
"I do, actually…" Harry didn’t hide the mocking smile on his face. "He was my mum and dad’s best friend. And he’s a convicted murderer, but he escaped from the wizard prison and is in disguise so no one recognises him. He’s going to keep in touch with me… hear my news… make sure I’m happy… and if you shout and make a scene, he’ll come after you… he’s escaped prison once, he can do it again…"
Sirius had no idea what Harry had said to his uncle, but the way the man’s expression was overtaken by pure terror made him want to laugh. Vernon quickened his pace out of the station, leaving Harry behind, who glanced over his shoulder and waved goodbye before heading for the exit.
Hermione, Victoria and Luana said their goodbyes to Regulus, and Sirius gripped his nephew’s shoulders with both hands, glancing between him and his girlfriend’s family with a suggestive smile tugging at his lips.
"Rookwood, eh?" he teased, and Reggie’s face flushed crimson.
"Leave him alone, Sirius." Remus shook his head. "Victoria’s a lovely girl. Isn’t she, Reg?"
"Mm-hm." He dropped his gaze to the floor, hauling his trunk and owl cage along.
"He told you about her?!" Sirius began making his way towards the exit, followed by the other two.
Remus and Reggie exchanged a knowing look.
"Of course he did. While you were trying to catch Peter, Reg was trying to catch Victoria…" he joked.
"Uncle!" Regulus gaped at him, scandalised. "I didn’t… she’s the one who caught me!"
"What do you mean she caught you?" Sirius shoved his hands into his pockets, glancing sidelong at Reg.
"I didn’t want to go out with her because, well… er, with everything going on…" Reg’s voice carried a nervous edge, his eyes darting around the station. "But now we’re together, so it’s all working out…"
"I want the whole story!" Sirius pressed a hand to his chest before adjusting the leather jacket on his shoulders.
"There’s not much to tell." Reggie wet his lips. "She kissed me in the bathroom of my dorm and—"
"What were you doing in your dorm bathroom?" Sirius asked with a mischievous grin.
"Nothing!" he denied, voice cracking. "I just… was washing her face because I, er, accidentally splashed her with paint…"
"I still don’t get how the two of you kissing in the bathroom led to a relationship." Remus prodded, shoving his hands into the pockets of his worn coat.
Regulus took a deep breath, glancing frantically around as if looking for a hole to bury his head in.
"Because… we got caught by my dorm mates and, er, she said… that we were going out." He let the air out of his lungs, his shoulders loosening as if he’d just lifted a weight from them.
"Hang on, so you didn’t actually ask her out?!" Sirius furrowed his brow, running a hand through his black hair.
"Not exactly…"
"Sounds like someone I know…" Remus murmured with sarcasm.
Sirius shot him a look, his friend’s grey face taking on a wicked edge.
"What? Me?!" He pointed at himself, brows knitting together.
"I remember you saying Scarlett held a gun to your head to make you ask her out," Remus explained evenly.
Sirius had half a mind to punch his friend in the face at the mention of Scarlett. He didn’t want the conversation to drift back to her, yet something syrupy slid into his memory, leaving a sweet taste in his mouth.
"What’s that supposed to mean?" His own voice echoed in his mind — soft, yet eager at the same time.
"Sorry for making you jealous," Scarlett admitted, tracing his angular jaw with her forefinger. "I was… an idiot. I… I just wanted—"
"…to be asked to be my girlfriend." He finished for her with a playful smile. "So, will you go out with me?"
"I will." She answered after an enigmatic pause. "You’re mine… and I’m yours."
The anger quickly dissolved in the warmth of the memory of Scarlett’s body against his — soft and warm. He clenched his fists, dazed by the mere sensation of having her in his arms, even as he tried to resist the poison of her words from the night before.
I want to love you, Sirius, but I don’t know how. I’m not worthy of your love.
Suddenly, breathing became difficult. She hadn’t even managed to come and collect her son from the station — so why was he thinking of her with such fondness and not with… with anger? Remorse? He should hate her, not…
…not hope she could be different.
Sirius ran his hand over his leather jacket, over the space he left between the zip and his chest so she could fit there in Whiskers’ skin. What if, instead, she was out there trying to run into a lamppost again?
The thought knocked the air from his lungs.
"Is this your bike?!" Regulus’s voice shattered his train of thought as he bounded down the steps and stared, wide-eyed, at the Ninja, running his fingers along the black chassis.
Sirius blew away those thoughts with a gust and broke into a lopsided grin.
"Ready for a different sort of trip, Reg?!" Sirius planted his hands on his hips, the hot, stifling wind tossing his hair.
"You’re joking?! I’ve always wanted to ride this thing!" He quickly grabbed the helmet hanging from the handlebars, adjusting it carefully before hugging Sirius again, completely awed by the surprise.
"I’ll Apparate with your things… see you at home." Remus kissed Regulus on the forehead, picking up the owl cage and the trunk. "Alright?" he murmured to Sirius, who simply nodded.
"It’s not so different from riding a broom…" Sirius remarked, fitting his own helmet. "But I prefer the bike — it’s steadier than a broom."
He checked everything was secure and gestured for Reg to climb on, waiting for him to settle in and hold on. Looking around, he drew the footrest up, started the engine, and felt Reggie’s hands grip his leather jacket.
"Watch the exhaust…" he warned, making sure Reg’s feet were in the right place before revving the engine. "Hold on tight!"
Sirius shut the visor and they left the station, merging into London traffic. The evening light bathed the city in shades of gold and rose, tinting the glass-fronted buildings and washing the historic architecture in the pastel colours of the day’s final rays.
He hadn’t yet cast the spell to make the bike fly — the last time he’d done that was when he flew to Godric’s Hollow and…
He swallowed hard, weaving through the traffic as tears pricked at his eyes. He glanced at Reg in the rear-view mirror, with the strange feeling that it was actually James back there, and that they were still just two reckless teenagers. No war, no betrayal, no Scarlett having left him, no deaths. Just… him, his best mate, and his Muggle motorbike.
But James wasn’t there anymore… he had promised to look after Harry if anything happened to his best friend, and there was nothing — not even Dumbledore or Voldemort — that could keep him from the boy. So, he swallowed all the frustration of not having Scarlett there with him and tucked it beside his heart, ready to charge her for it later.
Truth be told, there were plenty of things he wanted to hold her accountable for. Her absence at such an important moment was only one more for the list.
For all his dawdling, it didn’t take long for Sirius to reach the residential streets where the lights in the houses were beginning to flicker on, signalling the day’s end. The sun had fully set by the time they arrived home, twilight yielding to night.
He parked in the garage and Reg dismounted, pulling off his helmet and running a hand through his hair, his face adorned with the most beautiful of smiles. Sirius’s heart thudded.
"It really is quite different from flying a broom, but… I loved it." He pressed his lips together, sheepish. "Thanks, Dad."
Sirius was lost for words for a moment, as if doubting what he’d just heard. As if twelve years in Azkaban had turned to dust and the boy before him was once again the little lad he’d loved with all his strength and raised as his own.
"You’re welcome, son," he whispered, dizzy and sceptical of everything that was happening.
He was free. And Reg and Harry… they were going to live with him. They would be a family. They would…
They would be happy. Finally happy.
The thought made Sirius’s heart race wildly. He climbed off the bike, feeling terribly empty and overwhelmingly full all at once.
He wished Scarlett were there. He wished James and Lily were there. Merlin, he even wished Regulus were there. Any kind of happiness felt incomplete without them.
[Music: Fleetwood Mac – Dreams]
Sirius stepped inside just after Reggie, greeted by the delicious smell of dinner Remus was cooking to the sound of a Fleetwood Mac record spinning in the sitting room. He took off his jacket and boots, turning up the air conditioning. He only realised how much he was sweating when he sank into the leather sofa and his arms stuck to it.
Now here you go again
You say you want your freedom
Well, who am I to keep you down?
It's only right that you should
Play the way you feel it
But listen carefully
To the sound of your loneliness
"You gave her a ring?" He broke the silence, eyeing Reg, who had just flopped into the armchair with a weary huff.
"A ring? For Mimi?" The boy frowned. "We’re not engaged, we’re just dating…"
"Even so, you need to give her a promise ring!"
"Did you give my mum one?!" Reg didn’t seem to measure his words, and they stung more than Sirius could have imagined.
Instinctively, his eyes went to the ring on Reg’s little finger — the engagement ring Regulus had given Scarlett.
"I did." He shifted uncomfortably on the sofa. "Remus never showed you the photo?!"
"He never showed me anything about you lot…" Reggie said quietly, as if not wanting Lupin to hear.
Like a heartbeat drives you mad
In the stillness of remembering what you had
And what you lost
And what you had
And what you lost
Sirius would never get used to the fact that Remus, Nate, and Orfeu had hidden his relationship with Scarlett. As if Scarius had never existed. As if…
Would things have been better if Scarius had never existed? If Scarlett had chosen James or Remus… or if she had never left…
He ran a hand down his face, rubbing his eyes hard. He would gladly have accepted seeing Scarlett with James or Remus if it meant she was happy. Truly happy. That she wouldn’t be speeding towards a lamppost…
Oh, thunder only happens when it’s rainin’
Players only love you when they’re playin’
Say women, they will come and they will go
When the rain washes you clean, you’ll know
You’ll know
It’s not the same with other people. It’s not the same when I’m with you.
Scarlett could be with his friends, but she would always belong to him. Just as he would always belong to her. It was far too late for that — he was a shooting star, and she would always be the girl who reached him before he hit the ground.
"Well, then tomorrow we’re going out to buy a ring for you to give her," he said, picking the thread of the conversation back up, his expression softening.
Regulus gave a faint smile, then curled into the armchair, cracking his fingers non-stop. Sirius’s gaze lingered on the back of the boy’s left hand, where the Signet should have been, but he was probably using a Disguise Charm as there was nothing there.
He remembered the design well — two serpents intertwined to form the outline of the infinity symbol, one biting the other’s tail in a circle. Now Reggie’s hand was grown, but when he’d been just a baby, that tiny hand would often cling tightly to Sirius’s thumb, and it was hard to get him to let go. As if, for some reason, that little being who couldn’t even speak yet was already afraid of being abandoned.
"Why didn’t she come?" Reg swallowed hard right after asking the question, as if afraid of the answer. Afraid of Scarlett’s rejection.
Ah. That was a feeling Sirius knew all too well.
Now here I go again
I see the crystal visions
I keep my visions to myself
It’s only me who wants to wrap around your dreams
And have you any dreams you’d like to sell?
Dreams of loneliness
"Did something happen? I’m worried about her." He went on, not breaking eye contact.
Sirius stayed still, determined to drown the growing discomfort knotting in his throat. He drew a slow breath and pressed his lips together, nodding as he eased the tension in his neck.
"She’s fine…" He cleared his throat, wiping his sweaty palms on the hem of his T-shirt.
"Why are you lying?" Reggie cut in, the grey of his eyes turning into two sharpened daggers. "What happened to her?"
Sirius turned his face away, fixing his gaze on the newspaper on the table, trying to mask his unease and project self-control.
Like a heartbeat drives you mad
In the stillness of remembering what you had
And what you lost
And what you had
Ooh, what you lost
"I don’t know, Reg, but something must have happened for her not to come…" he replied, failing to keep his voice steady.
Regulus stared at him for a long moment, his expression hard, doubting every word out of his mouth. Tension rippled across Sirius’s shoulders, and he felt strangely intimidated, as if the boy in front of him were suddenly his brother and not… not his nephew.
"So it’s true then?!" His voice trembled. It was hard — so very hard — to look at him, but Sirius forced himself to lift his gaze to Reg. "All she ever does is let people down and hurt them?!"
Thunder only happens when it’s rainin’
Players only love you when they’re playin’
Women, they will come and they will go
When the rain washes you clean, you’ll know
Sirius wanted to say no, wanted to proclaim all of Scarlett’s good qualities… but the hurt struck him like lightning, stripping him bare of excuses and pretences. It shattered the idealised image he’d built of her, stopping him from passing it on to Reggie.
The truth was… yes, she knew very well how to let people down. But it wasn’t the only thing she knew how to do — though, for now, all Sirius could focus on was the bitterness beginning to stir in his core, revealing the rotten roots embedded in his heart.
He didn’t answer. He didn’t know what to answer. He was left in the same stunned state he’d always been in when confronted by his younger brother: not knowing what to do, not knowing what to reveal, and not knowing what to say. It was as if everything that might leave his lips would be irrelevant.
"I’m not hungry anymore." Reggie let out a disillusioned sigh and stood, hesitating for only a second before heading into the bedroom, as though waiting for Sirius to utter some magic word that would fix Scarlett and turn them into a happy family.
Sirius clenched his fists.
He didn’t know if he could fix anyone, but that didn’t mean he wouldn’t try.
Oh, thunder only happens when it’s rainin’
Players only love you when they’re playin’
Say women, they will come and they will go
When the rain washes you clean, you’ll know
You’ll know
You will know
Oh, you’ll know
.
.
.
Scarlett adjusted her synthesiser, the keys reflecting the glow of the spotlights that bathed the stage in blue and red. The pub was full that night, and the nervous energy among her bandmates was almost tangible.
At her cue, Mike counted them in and they began the performance. Stacy’s vocal range was strikingly similar to Stevie Nicks’s, making the set feel comfortable. The backing vocals were handled by Scarlett, who commanded her synthesiser with the melodic flow of the music. She would never forget that night — not because it was a particularly important event for the band, but because…
It was her acceptance that she was a failure and there were no more fixes left. Scarlett was lost, and not even the guidance of the brightest star in the sky was enough to fill the cracks in her heart.
Meanwhile, on the chaotic streets of London, Sirius Black rode his Ninja at a speed well above the legal limit for public roads. Weaving through traffic, he followed the golden thread that led him to Scarlett, with worry and anger bursting from his chest.
The pub was packed with people, and Sirius couldn’t have cared less. He pulled up abruptly, parking the bike anywhere on the pavement, and yanked off his helmet, tossing it onto the motorbike with a sharp movement. He could already hear the music from outside, pushing open the bar doors without a care for whether he bumped into someone.
The crowd began to applaud as he made his way through, not bothering to hide his furious expression the moment his gaze found the stage, the lights washing his vision red with rage.
Scarlett was among the musicians, giving her stupid little bow and receiving thunderous applause from the crowd, but soon they stepped out of the spotlight to make way for the next band. Sirius pushed through to the backstage area, ignoring the curious glances thrown his way. It was easy enough to get past the security guards — they already looked tired at the end of the set — and even easier to spot the name Stargazer on one of the dressing-room doors.
He walked in just as Scarlett was changing. She turned suddenly at the sound of the door slamming open, covering her breasts with her hands in an instant reflex of surprise and embarrassment.
Nothing Sirius hadn’t seen before.
Before he could step forward, however, the door swung open again, and Sirius merely shifted his gaze, catching sight of Danny from the corner of his eye, aggression dancing in the silver of his irises. The guitarist’s look went from confused to defensive the moment he realised who it was.
"What are you doing here?" Danny straightened, his hand tightening on Sirius’s shoulder in a veiled threat.
"None of your business." Sirius shot him a withering glare, not backing down in the slightest.
The musician glanced at Scarlett, as though searching for some cue on what to do.
"Do you want me to get him out of here?!" His voice faltered for just a second, and that was enough for Sirius to let out a sharp, derisive huff.
He took a step towards Scar, shrugging Danny’s grip violently off his shoulder.
"If you lay a hand on me again, you can kiss your guitar career goodbye!" Sirius hissed, fists clenched, jaw so tight his teeth ground together.
Scarlett, covering her torso with her jacket, tilted her head slightly as she fixed Sirius with a piercing look.
"No, it’s fine, Danny. You can go. Thanks." She cut in, slipping on the garment while flicking her gaze between the two of them, leaving them alone.
Silence stretched long enough to become almost unsettling. Scarlett remained still, eyes wide and locked on Sirius as though she expected him to hurt her. As though she wanted him to.
And as much as Sirius wanted to hurt her, he wouldn’t. So he shoved his hands deep into the pockets of his leather trousers, where they were safer. He didn’t trust them to be free in Scarlett’s presence.
And she looked far too well for someone who had tried to kill herself the night before.
"What the fuck is your problem?"
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 50: You’re poison running through my veins
Chapter Text
CXVIII
Sirius waited for an explanation, and Scarlett offered none. She remained in her sepulchral silence, much like the one he had shown Reggie moments before. And it was ironic how he demanded from her something he couldn’t bring himself to do either. Still, the fury smouldered in his chest, making his heart fizz with anger that Scarlett was playing in some stupid gig instead of having gone to fetch Reggie.
He was trying to prove to his nephew that Scarlett wasn’t a disappointment, but it was painfully hard to rationalise what she was doing. And she knew she was being a bloody idiot, because she kept silent and motionless, her gaze fixed on the floor.
Sirius Black could have set the whole world alight with his stare, but instead he chose to burn Scarlett with his irises, incandescent with rage. The silver turned into pools of molten bronze, and it was a real struggle to control his breathing when all he wanted was to take his frustrations out on her.
“You’re not going to say anything?” he pressed, not bothering to hide the hurt etched on his face.
“What do you want me to say, Sirius?” she finally spoke, her voice breaking, tears glinting in her eyes.
Sirius let out a huff full of disdain as he raked a hand through his tangled hair, trying to make sense of Scarlett’s reasons while at the same time wanting to shout at her.
“I can’t believe you skipped going to the platform to fetch Reg and see Harry so you could… play!” He tried to hold back, but his voice rose on the last word.
“It’s all I’ve got!” she shot back quickly, her lower lip trembling. “The band’s all I’ve got!”
Sirius laughed — a harsh, humourless sound. He couldn’t believe what he was hearing.
“Oh yeah? And whose choice was that?!” He wetted his lips, folding his arms to stop himself from pulling her into his arms when the overwhelming urge hit the moment her first tear slid down over the freckles on her face.
Her eyes didn’t leave his for a single second, though she stepped back and shrank in on herself like a cornered animal. Had she been in Whiskers’ skin, her fur would have been standing on end. She clenched her jaw as though trying to contain the very same thing Sirius felt battering at his core.
“At least they don’t hate me.” Her words were subtle, almost a whisper, yet they piled a weight onto Sirius’s chest.
He wanted to step closer, yet he didn’t move. It was far too hard to control himself with Scarlett like this, his most primal instincts torn between hurting her and holding her, the anger giving way to confusion which, in turn, became a strange kind of understanding.
In the past, there had been a time when all his friends had hated him, and Scarlett had been the only one to stand wholly by his side. Perhaps that was why he was still here, waiting for an explanation, trying to give meaning to that thing tearing his chest apart.
“Orfy… Remus… you…” she went on, as if hearing his thoughts, but Sirius cut across her.
“I don’t hate you. I’ve told you that, I… I don’t…”
“It doesn’t matter anymore.” She hissed, slipping on her coat and turning her back to Sirius as she rummaged in the bag on the table behind her, wiping away her tears with the occasional sniff.
“You’d rather spend your time snogging that idiot guitarist than with your own son?” Sirius goaded her, and Scarlett fell into his trap like a puffskein into a snare, whipping her head round so fast towards him that her neck cracked.
“What?” The bewilderment was plain in her eyes. Sirius’s lips curled into a smug smile.
“Don’t remember? You’re the one who told me that yesterday.” He allowed himself a single step forward, just one, feeling Scarlett’s aura latch onto his own with such force that he had to tense his legs to keep from being drawn to her. “You told me a fair few things, actually.”
Scarlett blinked slowly, as if trying to remember, but there was a void in her mind. With the amount of drink she’d had, coupled with the hangover potion… it was impossible for her to recall.
“What things?” Her eyes widened, her voice laced with shock and fear.
“Things.” Sirius kept the smugness on his face, which only made her more irritable.
“What things, Sirius?!” Now there was an impatient edge to her voice. Scarlett dropped the bag to one side and stepped closer to him; the open jacket covered her breasts perfectly, but left the strip between them and all the way down to her navel bare.
Sirius swallowed hard and took a step back.
My star. My weakness. My love.
“That you…” He faltered for a moment, trying to pick up the thread of his thoughts. “That you wanted to love me, but didn’t know how. That you weren’t worthy of love.”
Scarlett’s defiant stance dissolved, and a deep sadness surfaced in her gaze. She opened and closed her mouth several times, hugging herself as though trying to find something — anything — she could say to undo all her mistakes. But mistakes are rarely undone, especially those made fifteen years ago.
“Why did you try to crash into the lamppost?” The question finally slipped from his lips before he even realised. Scarlett’s pupils dilated, swallowing the blue of her eyes in opaque black. Fearful. Reluctant.
“I… I-I d-don’t… remember…” she stammered, turning pale. Her gaze dropped slowly to the floor.
“You wanted to kill yourself?” Sirius hadn’t meant for his voice to come out so rancorous, yet it was hard to keep control when the woman he loved looked so shattered before him. When the woman he loved had wished for death above anything else. When what she was going through was far more than she let on, or than he knew.
“No, n-no, I…” Scarlett faltered, the tears returning as she tried to muster a convincing answer.
She couldn’t.
“No?” he pressed, cloaked beneath a façade of calm he didn’t feel. “Sounded the opposite to me.”
She drew in a deep breath, as if trying to contain the emotions threatening to swallow her whole. Sirius now allowed himself to move closer, though he had no intention whatsoever of embracing her or telling her it would all be fine. No. He wanted to understand her, to find some trace of what truly went on in her head. His eyes searched hers, an attempt to dissect her with the precision only he possessed.
“I don’t know what I was thinking,” Scarlett admitted, her voice unsteady. “I just… I was so drunk… confused, lost.”
“Scarlett, you’re destroying yourself. This isn’t just about us, or about Reggie… it’s about you as well. You need help!” Sirius gasped, the conflicting emotions leaving him reeling.
“I don’t deserve help, I… you don’t understand, Sirius.” She merely shrugged. “You don’t understand.”
Sirius let a bitter laugh slip from his lips, the emotions crashing through his chest in a chaotic storm, quickening his pulse and clouding his mind. There were many things he didn’t understand — but he knew all too well the searing pain capable of crushing even the strongest man until all he wanted was death.
He hadn’t remembered the feeling he’d had when he discovered Scarlett and Regulus had married. He remembered it now. And if that old wound that had come to visit him was even a third of what Scarlett felt, then…
Well, then he understood her. He didn’t agree — but he understood.
“Scarlett… we are not the sum of our mistakes.” Sirius eased his stance, taking another step forward, close enough to reach for her, his hand extending in her direction but not daring to touch.
“I am. You should have left me in Azkaban, you—”
“I wish you could see yourself the way I see you.” He murmured it freely, catching her off guard.
Scarlett arched her brows and parted her lips slightly, her gaze roaming over his face before she stepped forward, tilting her head so his hand could brush her cheek.
“As a murderer?” There was so much acidity in her voice that Sirius’s expression twisted. She broke the touch, pulling her face away. “As the woman who betrayed you?”
Sirius let the air out in one rush, the rage bubbling in his chest again like a volcano on the brink of eruption. How could she think that of him after… after everything they’d been through? It wasn’t as though Sirius hadn’t accused her of all that before, but for Merlin’s sake, he’d told her he loved her!
Wasn’t that enough?
“You are so… so much more than that.” He let his mouth be ruled by his heart.
“I’m not!” Scarlett screamed, her breathing fast and shallow. “I’m not! And if I died… it would be better for everyo—”
“Don’t you finish that sentence!” Sirius cut her off with a roar, his finger jabbing towards her face. “Don’t you dare finish that sentence!”
“It should’ve been me… instead of James and Lily, it should’ve been me…”
“But it wasn’t, Scarlett, and as much as I wanted to have died in their place too, here we are.” Sirius murmured, surrendering to the dizzying sensation that he was still trapped. As if his freedom was just another part of his purgatory. His prison, however, was nothing more than a girl whose hair he’d once adorned with flowers.
“No… you and them… you’d have been a family… with Reg and Harry…”
“We can still be a family!” Sirius shouted, feeling suffocated.
“We can’t… we can’t…” She shook her head slowly, sobbing. “We can’t. James and Lily could’ve…”
The fury ignited his reason and pulled tight the strings in his head. Before Sirius even realised, he was bellowing:
“THEY’RE DEAD! JAMES AND LILY ARE DEAD!”
Scarlett sucked in a sharp breath, fear flooding her expression. Sirius wanted so badly to apologise, yet his whole body was trembling with what he’d just said… with the tears streaking his face, with the longing bursting from his chest.
She was right about one thing, though. James and Lily would, indeed, have known what to do. James especially — he always knew. It was almost a special skill of his. Sirius swallowed hard, the sorrow now devoured by hatred. His best friends were dead because of him. It was he who had suggested Peter, it was he who…
“I can’t.” Scarlett sighed, walking back to her bag on the table. “I can’t be the mother Reg needs…”
“Yes, you can!” he snarled, stomping after her.
“No, Sirius, I can’t—”
“Yes, you bloody well can!” He slammed his hand down on the table, the crack making her jump. “All these years I’ve spent with Reg, I’ve told him how bloody amazing you are, so you’re going to act like you are!”
“No! Don’t you get it, Sirius?! I’d just… I’d just hurt him and… I… I don’t deserve—”
“For fuck’s sake, why do you keep repeating that shit?!”
“Remus told me I could spend another hundred years in Azkaban and I still wouldn’t deserve you…” Scarlett whispered, so close to Sirius he could feel her words slipping through his beard and smell the salt of the tears running down her delicate chin. “You should’ve left me in Azkaban…”
“Scarlett… whatever your sentence was, you’ve already served it!”
“No, it was a life sentence, it—”
“It doesn’t matter, you’re free now!” Sirius raked a hand through his hair, trying to step away, yet his body didn’t move, as though the pull between him and Scarlett wouldn’t allow it.
“I just want you to leave me alone, Sirius… please… I can’t take it…”
“You should’ve thought of that before you made me godfather to your son.” With his teeth clenched, Sirius barely moved his lips.
Seeing Scarlett like this hurt him; what hurt more was knowing she would never be the woman Reg believed her to be.
The woman he wished she had been.
“Sirius… please…”
“No.”
“You’ll be happy… without me…”
“I said no!” he repeated, louder.
Another band was starting their set on stage.
“Sirius… go away.” Despite her cracked voice, Scarlett sounded firm.
“I’m not leaving without you.” Sirius gripped her forearm, feeling the rapid pulse beneath his fingertips.
“Let me go!”
“You’re going to see your son, even if I have to drag you there by your hair…”
Scarlett began struggling violently, but Sirius didn’t so much as flinch, tightening his grip. Then, in a desperate impulse, she made a quick attempt to grab his wand from the inside pocket of his coat. But he anticipated the move and stopped her, seizing both her wrists in a firm hold, lifting them above her head and pinning them to the cold dressing-room mirror.
Writhing under his hold, Scarlett raised her head to bite him, but Sirius shoved her neck back with his other arm, his forearm pressing against her taut, gasping throat, forcing her to lean back against the mirror.
“Let me go, Sirius!” she roared with all the breath she had.
“Shut up!” he shot back, locking Scarlett’s legs against the table to keep her from kicking him.
“Make me, you bastard,” Scarlett hissed, hyperventilating.
Sirius didn’t know if it was an invitation or a threat, so he let his most primal instincts corrupt his sanity. He surged forward, pressing his body into Scarlett’s and claimed those damned lips for himself.
There was nothing civilised about that kiss. It was pure need made flesh, all teeth, tongue, and frantic breaths. Scarlett bit his lower lip, bringing the coppery tang into their searing connection. Sirius didn’t pull back, his fingers closing around her slender neck, the chill of his rings tickling the hot, damp skin.
He’d thought Scarlett would use her legs to push him away, but was surprised when they locked around his waist and pulled him closer, forcing a grunt from him as the heat of her sex radiated against his erection. Sirius wanted nothing more than to rip off that stupid skirt that kept him from seeing the insides of her thighs, but his hands were far too busy holding her down as their mouths deepened the kiss, tasting those lips laced with alcohol.
Sirius sucked her tongue before breaking their lips apart to dive into her heaving, delicate neck, dragging his teeth over pale, gooseflesh skin and sucking just beneath her ear, making her writhe. He pulled her chin to the side, revelling in the heavy gasps Scarlett tried to smother by pressing her lips together, grinding her pelvis into his in retaliation.
Growling as though he were Padfoot in the flesh, Sirius trailed his path of bruising kisses down to Scar’s collarbone, nipping the bone and using his free hand to push her coat aside, baring her breasts. He palmed one and took the nipple of the other into his mouth with a sound that was downright indecent. Scarlett’s chest rose and fell sharply, and he smiled.
A wicked, lust-soaked smile.
Sirius released her wrists to brace himself on the table, rubbing against her body and teasing the hardened peak between finger and thumb the way he knew she liked. That was the trouble with knowing her — he knew exactly what drove her mad with want.
And though he’d wanted so badly to shout at Scarlett for the shit she was pulling, it was far too late for that now. He couldn’t stop anymore. He never could with her. He needed more — needed to have her wholly, body and soul, the way he always had. Even if rejection tried to drag him back into the light, whispering in the back of his mind that she didn’t love him…
He knew that wasn’t true. Scarlett’s heart was his. So much his that he slid his hand into the valley between her full breasts and felt the beat against his palm — fast and hungry, strong and steady. It only beat like that for Sirius Black, the owner of that damned, rotten heart.
It was far too easy to be blinded by the darkness Scarlett had steeped him in. There was nothing else in the world but her, but his rage and frustration, but the mistakes she made, but the need to claim her and remind her she belonged to him, only him — that Scarlett might kiss other mouths, but none of them made her feel like this. None of them set her chest ablaze like the wildfire called Sirius Black.
Scarlett’s hands sought his hair, tugging hard, and Sirius pushed his hips into hers, making his arousal more than evident — hard enough to make her want to apologise for every wrong she’d ever done, for neglecting her son, and for never having told him she loved him back.
Sirius trailed his lips down her ribs and stomach, stopping when he reached her skirt, his fingers tracing the scars from Cruciatus, the muscles beneath twitching under his touch. He lifted his gaze to her, one hand slipping down over that bloody skirt and deliberately brushing his fingertips over her throbbing clit and the cunt that was begging to be touched. Scarlett parted her lips and propped herself up on her elbows; all her arrogance had been washed away by the desire coursing through her body, making her captive to Sirius.
His lips curved into a smile and he stood, not moving his hips away. He yanked Scarlett roughly closer to him, spinning her so she was face down. She let out a small gasp of surprise, trying to push herself up with her hands, but Sirius seized her hair and slammed her against the table, her full torso and cheek colliding with the warm wood.
“Sirius…”
“I told you to shut your mouth!” he all but shouted, his voice cutting above the music in the background. He yanked up Scarlett’s skirt and landed a sharp smack to her arse, making it jiggle. “You’re not opening your fucking mouth until you apologise…”
Scarlett’s eyes widened as she looked at him over her shoulder — until Sirius tugged her hair and forced her to meet his gaze in the mirror, only inches from her face.
“Always a slut for me…” he murmured, caressing the curve of her arse where the shape of his hand was beginning to bloom.
“Please…” she started, but fell silent when another slap landed on the same spot.
“Wrong request.” Sirius’s brows furrowed, a perversion steeped in vengeance dancing in his star-bright eyes. “Apologise for leaving your son waiting for you!”
Scarlett stared at him with submission until her pupils dilated and her lips twisted into a masochistic smile.
“No…”
Another slap, and she couldn’t hold back the moan. She was enjoying this, and Sirius almost unzipped his leather trousers right then and there to fuck her to the sound of Alice Cooper.
Almost.
The control, however, was as tangible in his hands as Scarlett’s body was subdued beneath his will, so he went back to stroking the fever-hot, reddened skin of her rounded arse, waiting for her to apologise… and aching for her not to.
“You know very well what bad girls deserve…” he purred, grinding his cock — still trapped beneath layers of fabric — against Scarlett’s soaked cunt. “I’m not giving you what you want until you give me what I want.”
Scarlett bit her lower lip, blinking slowly as her cheeks flushed, as if she were some innocent woman, as if they’d never played this game before. As if Sirius wasn’t desperate to take her, to mark her pale skin with bruises, to come inside her and wish that, this time, she’d bear his child.
“Sorry…” Her voice came out thick, the breath leaving her treacherous lips dampening the tabletop.
Sirius wasn’t convinced, squeezing Scarlett’s arse right where he knew it would hurt, the muscle tightening under his fingertips.
“For what?” he demanded, yanking her bleached hair harder, forcing her to lift her head and meet his gaze in the mirror.
Breathless, Scarlett licked her trembling lips and smiled — a sordid smile, equal parts pleasure and malice. Her blue irises, veiled by long dark lashes, gleamed in challenge.
“Can’t quite remember…”
This time, Sirius struck her so hard she jolted the table forward with her body, a cry of pain tearing from her lips. The red of her skin was already beginning to bloom into purple.
“No? You sure about that?” His question was thick with amusement.
Having Scarlett submissive was delicious, but punishing her like this after so long… Sirius could barely keep his cock in his trousers.
“No… I know, I know…” she mumbled, stealthy tears welling at the corners of her eyes. “Sorry… sorry for… for cheating on you…”
She closed her eyes when the next slap came, pressing her lips into a tight line to hold back another cry, though the tears now only made it hotter.
“No need to apologise for that — I know this little cunt only gets like this for me,” Sirius boasted with exasperating arrogance. “I doubt very much my brother ever got you this way.”
“I moaned your name when I was with him…” she confessed, breathless.
Sirius hesitated for only a second before smacking her so hard Scarlett began to cry. She wasn’t telling the truth — it was just part of the game, only…
He wetted his lips, his cock throbbing, aching to fuck her. Sirius clenched his jaw and breathed slowly, his tattooed hand caressing the bruised skin once more, the cold of his rings rubbing against the burning flesh making her squirm.
“You filthy whore… you fucked my brother thinking of me?!” He hadn’t wanted to ask that, but his mind was far from clear in that moment.
“Sorry for leaving…”
Ah, that was the last straw. Sirius raised his hand high, the muscles in his arm already taut, ready to make her regret saying that…
[Music: Alice Cooper – Poison]
But fuck, Sirius Black was weak — he might have been in the position to tame that wild, twisted woman, but in truth, he was the victim. It was Scarlett who was bending him until he was on his knees for her. Sirius clenched his teeth, digging his nails into the bruise until it bled, tasting the metallic tang as he licked his fingers. Then he opened his trousers, his cock landing against Scarlett’s arse right over the sore spot.
She shuddered in pain and desire.
Your cruel device
Your blood, like ice
One look, could kill
My pain, your thrill
If he’d been stronger, he’d have slapped her so hard she probably wouldn’t have been able to sit again. If he’d been stronger, he’d have made her beg for him. If he’d been stronger… he’d have stopped her from walking away. But Scarlett was hungry for everything he was about to give her, and Sirius ached to be consumed again by that cruel woman.
He pushed her black knickers aside, not bothering to slick himself against her cunt. No. If she wasn’t going to obey, then she’d be punished. He gripped himself at the base and drove into her, making her arch her back and let out a languid moan, her walls burning from the sheer size and sudden intrusion.
I wanna love you but I better not touch (don’t touch)
I wanna hold you, but my senses tell me to stop
I wanna kiss you but I want it too much
I wanna taste you but your lips are venomous poison
You’re poison, running through my veins
You’re poison
I don’t want to break these chains
With their hips aligned, he gave Scarlett no time to adjust to his length, fucking her with a brutal rhythm, his pelvis smacking into her arse as the music pounded in the background, driving into her deep and relentless, revelling in the steady pace of her moans; in the way her tight cunt was hot and dripping, clutching his cock with every thrust, leaving him dizzy from the molten, wet pleasure Scarlett wrapped him in.
Your mouth, so hot
Your web, I’m caught
Your skin, so wet
Black lace, on sweat
Sirius watched her through the mirror, still gripping her hair with one hand, tugging it wickedly without slowing his thrusts, feeling her body begin to tremble and the steady pulse of her cunt around his cock grow more insistent. Scarlett’s platinum strands clung to her face, and all she could do was moan and writhe, her hands trying to hold onto the edge of the table — but Sirius released her hair and caught one of her wrists, yanking her arm back and folding it over her spine, pinning her in place.
I hear you calling and it's needles and pins
I wanna hurt you just to hear you screaming my name
Don't want to touch you but you're under my skin (deep in)
I wanna kiss you but your lips are venomous poison
You're poison, running through my veins
You're poison
I don't want to break these chains
Poison
Scarlett’s moans turned into tortured cries, merging with the chorus of the song that underscored their depraved union. She lifted her feet from the floor, hooking her ankles around Sirius’s knee as if to ensure he wouldn’t stop; but the moment she felt the heat begin to unfurl from her womb to sweep through her entire body, Sirius pulled out — and didn’t return.
The heat became a painful ache pooling in her belly, making her cry all the more, her whole body trembling from the ruined, interrupted pleasure, her eyes desperately searching Sirius’s.
One look, could kill
My pain, your thrill
“What, you thought I was going to let you come without giving me the proper apology?” Sirius panted, holding his voice steady so it wouldn’t waver, his cock throbbing from the lost friction.
“Sorry… I’m sorry… sorry for not going with you… to fetch Reggie… to see Harry… please… please… please…” she begged, lethargic, blinking slowly as though drunk — intoxicated by the sensations his cock awoke in her. “Please, Sirius!”
Sirius took her again, driving into her so hard the table was lifting with every thrust, his hips slamming against Scarlett’s arse with a loud, depraved sound, his free hand gripping the bruised flesh and squeezing deliberately just as he watched her, through the mirror, roll her eyes back, arch her spine, and moan his name — the orgasm trembling until it hit with certainty.
I wanna love you but I better not touch
I wanna hold you, but my senses tell me to stop
I wanna kiss you but I want it too much
I wanna taste you but your lips are venomous poison
You’re poison, running through my veins
You’re poison
I don’t want to break these chains
Poison
He didn’t stop. Scarlett came and cried with each wave of euphoria, her whole body spasming as her walls clamped violently around his cock, and he kept the same aggressive, feral rhythm, lifting his head as the pleasure coiled through his core, ready to explode. Sirius locked eyes with Scarlett in the mirror, which shook with every thrust, the table dragging away from the wall as he used her climax as the perfect lubricant to flood her with his cum.
Sirius expelled all the air from his lungs through his mouth and drove into Scarlett with brutal force a few more times before stopping, burying himself deep inside her as his cock throbbed, spilling thick, hot seed into her. He bit his lower lip to smother the drawn-out groans. He wouldn’t give her that privilege.
I wanna love you but I better not touch
I wanna hold you, but my senses tell me to stop
I wanna kiss you but I want it too much
I wanna taste you but your lips are venomous poison
Yeah, well I don't want to break these chains
Poison
Runnin' deep inside my veins
Burnin' deep inside my brain
Poisoning
I don't want to break these chains
Poison
I don't want to break these chains
His hand still gripped her bruised arse, while the other released Scarlett’s wrist to brace against the table, sweat dripping from his chin and brow. Sirius didn’t pull out of her — his cock was still rock hard, buried deep in the tight, hot wetness, and he didn’t care if her cunt was now sore and swollen from the ferocity of it.
Breathing heavily, Sirius watched the semen slide down the base of his cock and drip to the floor, pressing his hips into her as if trying to stop his cum from leaking out, as if making sure his intentions were clear; that there was no doubt left that Scarlett was his. Then, showing all the care he’d lacked at the start, Sirius slid out of her slowly, hearing her whimper and noticing more of his seed start to spill — only for him to promptly push it back in with his forefinger.
Scarlett was still trembling, her chest rising and falling without pause, her head resting on the table, eyes shut. Sirius traced one of the scars on her back with his finger — a Cruciatus mark running up along her ribs and stopping just short of her nape — and her pale skin shivered instantly beneath his touch. His gaze travelled over the bleached strands of hair spilled across the table, until it met the pair of half-lidded blue eyes peeking from behind them.
“Tomorrow afternoon I’m meeting you at your work and we’re going out.” It wasn’t a request. Sirius fastened his trousers, still dizzy from what he’d just done. “Best not run off this time. Even my patience has limits, Scarlett.”
“No… I won’t run.” Scarlett panted softly.
“I don’t believe you.” Sirius wet his lips, arrogantly drinking in the destruction he’d left in his wake — flushed cheeks, obedient gaze, sweat-slick body, ragged breathing, shaky legs, the print of his hand stamped across her right cheek, and her cunt swollen, stuffed with his cum.
Scarlett opened her mouth to say something, but Sirius didn’t stay to hear it.
.
.
.
It was another one of those days Scarlett didn’t want to wake up. She pretended to still be asleep, listening to the hushed whispers here and there and the hurried footsteps of Remus and Peter. Sirius still had his arms around her, his warm breath brushing the nape of her neck, his tattooed hand holding hers beneath the blankets. She shifted slightly and he murmured something inaudible, burying his face in her hair.
Scarlett sighed, carefully disentangling herself from Sirius when she realised she was still in her uniform, cloak included. She opened the canopy and slipped out of the bed, her bare feet meeting the cold rug of the dormitory. Remus was fastening his tie in front of the room’s mirror, and Peter was brushing his teeth in the bathroom.
“Sleep well?” Remus asked, glancing at her out of the corner of his eye. “I woke up three times because of Peter’s snoring…”
Though her head felt heavy and her face ached from the tears of the night before, a faint smile crossed her lips. Scarlett sat atop Sirius’s trunk and pulled on her socks and shoes under Remus’s gaze.
“Didn’t notice… the sleeping draught knocks me out…” She stood, smoothing down her creased uniform and adjusting the green-and-silver tie. “Shit…”
Remus flicked his wand, and Scarlett’s clothes instantly took on a flawless appearance, as if they’d just been laundered and pressed.
“Better than losing points for the state of your uniform.” He smiled, tucking his wand away and folding his arms. “First lesson’s Advanced Potions.”
“I know.” Scar grunted, still hoarse. “I need to grab my trunk and—”
“You’re not going to the Slytherin common room on your own, not a fucking chance.” Sirius’s lazy voice drifted from behind the canopies.
“My things are there!” Scarlett argued, glancing at Peter, who stepped out of the bathroom and whispered her a good morning.
“We’ll share my book, and I’ve got loads of spare quills and parchment.” Sirius’s face appeared through the gap in the scarlet-and-gold curtains. He rubbed his eyes and looked at her, his black hair falling wildly across his face, his beard rumpled. “Besides, we need to talk about what happened yesterday.”
A frantic shiver snaked its way through Scarlett’s body, making her shrink back involuntarily. Remus looked away, and Peter pretended to be far too busy checking the supplies he was stuffing into his bag.
“I didn’t—”
“Regulus told me what happened, but I don’t trust him.” Sirius ignored her protest, stepping out of bed and stretching, the muscles in his lean frame showing beneath his pyjamas. “Was it Avery, Mulciber, and Snape?”
Scarlett wanted badly to answer in words, but her voice wouldn’t come, so she simply nodded. Sirius shook his head, inhaling deeply as he raised his arms to pull on a white shirt.
“And you attacked Mulciber with a Cruciatus?!”
Remus looked at them through the reflection in the mirror, and Peter stopped what he was doing, staring at the pair from across his bed. Scarlett kept her gaze fixed on her own hands, rubbing her thumbs together like a shy little girl. She lifted her eyes to Sirius, and he didn’t need her to say another word.
“I’m sorry,” she murmured, her voice catching. “I didn’t… I didn’t think… they were laughing and… I was so scared…”
Sirius pulled her into his arms, stifling the suffocating feeling that crept over her. Scarlett swallowed hard, resting her face against his chest as he pressed a kiss to her forehead.
“You need to stop using that curse,” he whispered into her hair.
“I’m going to get expelled…”
“No, you’re not,” Remus replied as he fastened his cloak. “Dumbledore doesn’t know.”
“Yet.” Scarlett breathed in slowly, guilt lodging itself in her chest like a thorny branch.
“Regulus said the Slytherins won’t tell,” Sirius said, stepping back to grab his bag, his gaze strangely slippery.
Scarlett understood. She couldn’t look herself in the mirror either. Her mouth still tasted of shame and failure.
“It’s not like it’d be a bad thing… if I were expelled…” She cleared her throat, noticing the way Sirius yanked the zip of his bag—covered in Muggle band badges—a little harder than necessary.
“You’re not going to be expelled,” he shot back bluntly. “If that little Slytherin trio never got expelled after all the shit they’ve pulled…”
“They didn’t use an Unforgivable…”
“They did, two years ago on Mary,” Peter cut in, slinging his bag over his shoulder. “Difference is, there weren’t as many people around to witness it.”
“See? Everything’s going to be fine, love.” Sirius cupped her face in both hands, kissing her softly on the lips. “Relax.”
Scarlett forced a smile and shook her head, though she was anything but relaxed. She felt drained before the day had even begun and ended up grabbing a slice of chocolate cake from Sirius’s table, closing her eyes as the sugar melted in her mouth and sent a little flicker of serotonin through her brain. Her gaze drifted around the room, settling on Sirius combing his hair in front of the mirror before casting a non-verbal charm that left the black locks glossy and rebelliously untamed.
“Aren’t you going to get ready?” he asked, turning to her.
“I will… yeah.” Scarlett ran a hand through her tangled hair and reached for Sirius’s brush.
“You sure you’re alright? If you want to stay in bed—”
“No, I’m fine.” Her voice was almost a whisper.
It was such an obvious lie that Scarlett didn’t bother to put any effort into faking it. She felt as though she were sinking into something nameless, as if every time she managed to feel alright, another wave would crash over her and drag her straight back down into the depths.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 51: Our greatest blessing… and our greatest curse
Chapter Text
CXIX
The Advanced Potions class had fewer and fewer students each week, owing to timetable clashes and the priority given to those sitting their NEWTs that year. From Slytherin, only Scarlett Gaunt, Evan Rosier, Severus Snape and Brandon Nott remained. From Gryffindor, Slughorn’s favourite Lily Evans was joined by the other lions of her House: Sirius Black, James Potter, Marlene McKinnon and Mary MacDonald. Representing Ravenclaw, Dorcas Meadowes and Xenophilius Lovegood had taken their places at the back of the classroom. The Hufflepuffs, Emmeline Vance and Dedalus Diggle, were the last to arrive, crowding in with the rather sizeable group waiting for the door to open.
Professor Horace Slughorn soon beckoned them inside and stood in front of his desk, his hands folded over his large belly and a pleasant smile spreading across his face at the sight of so many students deciding to continue with his subject, especially Lily and Severus.
“Welcome to your final year of Advanced Potions!” he said with a cheerfulness only Lily seemed to share. “Today we shall begin brewing Polyjuice Potion! As it takes roughly a month to mature, I’ll be evaluating the results at the end. I’ll also be pairing you off, and every day I’ll rotate one student to serve as my assistant, since we are an odd number.” He stroked his walrus-like whiskers, as though pondering the choice. Lily Evans was already sitting bolt upright, ready to be singled out for praise by the professor. “Miss Gaunt, how about being my assistant today?”
Scarlett’s heart gave a violent thump as all eyes turned to her, especially those of her fellow Slytherins. They acted as though absolutely nothing had happened, and it was unsettling to be thrust into the spotlight like that, for she constantly felt eyes on her whenever she walked the corridors. Sirius squeezed her hand, urging her forward, and she accepted Slughorn’s offer with a small nod, pressing her lips together in an attempt at a smile.
Horace handed her a clipboard and a sheet of parchment, accompanied by a self-inking quill. He motioned for Scarlett to stand at his side and began assigning the pairs:
“James Potter and Evan Rosier…” The decision made the two glare at one another in disgust. James scratched his ear, as if to be sure he’d heard correctly. “Marlene McKinnon and Dorcas Meadowes…” The wide grins of celebration on their faces were plain to see. “Sirius Black and Severus Snape…” Sirius promptly choked on his own saliva and Snape’s eyes widened in pure horror. “Mary MacDonald and Xenophilius Lovegood. Emmeline Vance and Brandon Nott. Dedalus Diggle and Lily Evans. You may collect your ingredients…”
The students began moving towards the shelves lined with jars, and Sirius, standing still amidst the bustle, raised his hand. Slughorn exhaled heavily and shook his head.
“No, Mr Black, there will be no changing partners!” The professor then turned towards Scarlett, his stern expression softening as his lips curved into a reassuring smile. “And how are you, my dear?” he asked in a kindly, almost paternal tone that made Scarlett feel dangerously close to tears. Luckily, before she could answer, Slughorn beckoned Lily over, and it gave her just enough time to swallow the sadness and soften her features.
“I don’t know.” Scarlett faltered, lowering her gaze to her shoes. She wanted to say she was fine, but she had uttered those two little words so many times while feeling utterly wretched that they had taken on a negative weight of their own. “Honestly… I don’t know.”
Horace Slughorn pressed his thin lips together, his pale green eyes catching everything hidden behind her words.
“Would you like to return to your dormitory? It’s quite all right if you do…”
Though the suggestion was sorely tempting, Scarlett declined with an awkward expression, her eyes drifting to Sirius, who seemed thoroughly disgruntled at his cauldron. It didn’t take long before those starry eyes lifted to her, his handsome face breaking into the kind of smile that sent butterflies soaring in her stomach.
“Thank you, professor.” She ventured a half-smile, and Slughorn patted her shoulder.
“If you feel unwell… or want to step out… you needn’t even ask, my dear.” Horace sighed as James and Evan began squabbling over who would fetch the supplies. “Mr Potter, Mr Rosier—if you don’t decide, I’ll be docking points from both of you!” he threatened firmly. “I know you’re very talented in my subject, so your role today will be to assist anyone in need—fetching missing ingredients and guiding those straying too far from the mark. Do you think you can manage that?”
“Of course, professor.” Scarlett felt both flattered and insulted by the way she was being treated. She understood the reason for the condescension, yet at the same time she felt like a porcelain doll on the verge of shattering. It was rather tiring to be regarded that way by everyone.
The classroom grew noisy as students dragged equipment and pulled cauldrons close to their workstations, the clattering of weights being added to the scales making Scarlett squeeze her eyes shut at the sharp ringing in her ears.
“Scar!” Xen called, waving her over from his desk. Scarlett quickened her pace towards him, greeting Mary with a faint smile.
“Could you grab us some chrysalises from the storeroom?”
“Of course.” She immediately made her way towards the corner of the room.
As she drew closer, furious murmurs halted her steps and she craned her neck slightly forward, finding Lily and Snape inside.
“You’ve gone too far, Severus!” The disappointment and anger in her friend’s voice were unmistakable.
“She deserved it! She’s Black’s girlfriend…” Snape did not bother to hide the coldness in his reply, but Lily cut across him.
“How could you be so cruel to Scarlett after everything she’s been through?!” The girl all but shouted, her voice sharper than usual.
“She doesn’t magically become a victim just because she’s lost her family, Evans,” he sneered with an irritable sigh.
“Whose side are you on?!” Lily demanded, sharp and indignant.
There was a moment of silence, then Snape laughed—a mocking, splintered, brittle laugh.
“I thought that was clear enough, Mudblood…”
The crack of Lily’s slap rang out so loudly that Scarlett straightened up, pretending to grab some random ingredient from one of the jars just as her friend stormed out of the storeroom: stomping her feet, fists clenched and eyes brimming with tears. Scarlett looked at her and took a step forward, but Snape appeared with a hand pressed to his cheek and his eyes wide. His dark irises fixed insolently on Scarlett, and for a moment he seemed about to speak—but thought better of it. He only huffed and returned to the station he shared with Sirius.
Seeing Severus Snape in that state sparked something inside her, and Scarlett realised it was happiness. Happiness tainted with anger, yes, but still she found amusement in the bewildered expression on his face as he ignored Sirius’s provocations. She collected the chrysalises and brought them back to Xen and Mary.
The Ravenclaw left his partner feverishly flicking through Advanced Studies in Potion-Making and leaned over Scarlett’s bench, pushing his platinum hair back.
“Pan told me about what Snape and the others did,” he whispered, resting a gentle hand on her shoulder. “Are you all right?”
Scarlett tried to keep her composure, forcing herself as much as she could to smile, but her lips would not obey. The fire, Orfy, the cold iron floor beneath her hands, the sweat on her fingers as she cast the Cruciatus on Avery… the memories tore through her mind in a violent whirlwind, sending shivers she could not control coursing through her body.
“I don’t want to think about it now…” Scarlett inhaled, letting the breath out slowly. “Thank you for worrying, Xen.”
Xenophilius offered her a gentle smile that gradually eased the weight pressing down on Scarlett’s body. Though he was a strange, cross-eyed boy, it was easy to understand why Pandora liked him. Without her preconceived opinion of Regulus clouding her judgement, she could see that Xen was attentive and kind—two things Red would never be.
“If you’d like to go to Hogsmeade at the weekend…” he tried to cheer her up, “we could get everyone together and book out the top floor of the Three Broomsticks…”
“I don’t think I’ll be going out this weekend, Xen…” Scarlett murmured, clearing her throat in a poor attempt to hide the sadness in her eyes.
Before the conversation could continue, the classroom door burst open, and Regulus stepped inside, his blank expression scanning the students until it landed on her.
“Professor, sorry to interrupt, but the Headmaster requires Miss Gaunt’s presence in his office. It’s urgent.”
She immediately exchanged a glance with Sirius, two stations away. He was stirring his cauldron, no attempt made to hide the worry etched into his features, his jaw muscles taut with strain.
“I’ll go with her.” He volunteered, much to Slughorn’s displeasure.
“Mr Black, only Miss Gaunt was requested…”
“I’m not letting her walk alone to the office!” Sirius raised his voice, drawing a frown from the professor.
“But she isn’t alone, is she?” Evan Rosier remarked, dropping ingredients into his cauldron without lifting his eyes from the scene unfolding before him.
“Precisely—Miss Gaunt will be escorted by your brother!” Horace abandoned his genial tone for a more authoritarian stance.
Sirius hissed under his breath, slipping an arm around Scarlett’s shoulders as he guided her towards the door. It was one of the rare moments when the full attention of the class left him uneasy.
“I can still come with you,” he whispered into her ear, his storm-grey eyes bubbling with concern.
“It’s fine, Sirius.” She huffed, shoving her hands into the pockets of her cloak. “I don’t need a bodyguard.”
“I just want to be sure—”
“For Merlin’s sake, I’m fine!” Scarlett let the breath out in an exasperated hiss, her shoulders tensing. “Bloody hell…”
“Keep an eye on her,” Sirius said to Regulus, his tone grave and urgent.
His brother’s iron-grey eyes softened for just a moment, and he gave a small nod—enough to make Sirius believe him, even if doubt still gnawed at him. It was hard to trust Regulus after the lie that had sent Snape to the Whomping Willow, but Red would never try anything under these circumstances… not with everyone knowing it was he who escorted her to Dumbledore’s office.
Then he watched, heart hammering in his chest, as Scarlett and Regulus left the classroom. He returned to his station, only for James to clap him on the back, making him let out a foolish laugh.
“Merlin’s balls, Black, you left the cauldron and nearly burnt the potion!” Snape snapped, his greasy hair plastered to his sallow cheeks from the steam rising off the bubbling water.
“Shut it, Snivellus,” Sirius hissed, yanking the nearest book towards him. Though his first intention was to check the potion’s instructions, his purpose quickly shifted to revenge when he realised the book was Snape’s. His eyes swept over the scribbled notes in the margins—especially one marked Sectumsempra. Curious, he leaned in to read the description.
He knew that curse. That was the spell…
“What the hell are you reading, Black?! We need more chrysalises!” Snape barked, his scornful tone enough to make Sirius want to lash out and hit the filthy little half-blood—but he had a different idea in mind. Instead, he merely rolled his eyes and dragged his feet deliberately as he sauntered towards the shelves in the storeroom.
His fingers trailed over jars of mandrakes, billywigs, passed the chrysalises, and stopped on the lid of a thick, yellowish-green liquid. With a malicious grin, he grabbed a sample of bubotuber pus along with a jar of chrysalises, returning to the cauldron. He pretended to weigh the green insects carefully on the scales, all the while plotting how best to keep Snape distracted.
Sirius stretched out his hand, seized the annotated book, cleared his throat, and selected the most smug expression from his vast repertoire.
“Vulnera… sanentur… What the fuck is this, Snape?!” He fixed his eyes on the Slytherin, whose usual look of disdain widened in shock, his lips parting and his nostrils flaring.
“Give that back, you idiot!” Severus abandoned the cauldron, but Sirius purposefully raised the book higher, holding it out of reach. “Black!”
“Oops…” Sirius tossed the book away, his grin widening at the sight of Snape scrambling desperately to recover it. Taking advantage of the distraction, he quickly leaned over the cauldron and poured in the bubotuber pus, feigning the addition of chrysalises just as Snape returned.
“I don’t know what Slughorn was thinking, pairing me with the thickest student in the class…” Snape muttered, stirring the potion furiously as though afraid it had burnt while he was away. The liquid was turning far too dark, making him flick impatiently through his notebook. “Black, what have you—”
Snape realised the change too late.
The explosion was violent. The cauldron burst, hurling its contents straight into Snape’s face. He let out a panicked scream as massive, oozing boils erupted across his pallid skin.
The entire classroom froze, and the initial shock quickly dissolved into muffled sniggers, then erupted into roaring laughter. Snape, livid, shot daggers at Sirius with his eyes. The Gryffindor struggled to keep a straight face, but ended up laughing along with the others, his elbows propped casually on the workstation.
Sirius’s grin faded fast, his expression hardening into something hostile. Snape faltered—he knew that look.
“Touch my girl again, Snape, and next time I’ll blast tentacula venom all over that disgusting face of yours!” Sirius threatened through gritted teeth.
“Snivellus has finally hit puberty…” James muttered under his breath to Sirius, still laughing.
Snape couldn’t reply; his whole face was far too inflamed, pus seeping from the boils with the slightest movement of his facial muscles. Slughorn hurried over as quickly as someone so rotund and sedentary could manage, pointing his wand at the Slytherin’s face to ease the pain with a charm.
“Black! This is utterly unacceptable!” The professor wiped a sweaty hand over his bald head. “Evans, dear, please escort him to Dumbledore’s office! I’ll explain the situation myself… once I’ve seen Snape to the hospital wing…”
Lily was the only one not laughing, though she didn’t lift a finger to help Snape either. She cast Sirius a disapproving look and nodded for him to follow her.
Sirius laced his hands behind his head and stretched his back, pleased with himself for having got his revenge on Snape—and for earning a trip to Dumbledore’s office with so little effort.
.
.
.
The possibility that Scarlett had been summoned to Dumbledore’s office for casting the Cruciatus Curse on Mulciber was high, but she only pieced it together as she ascended the spiral staircase beside Regulus, leading up to the gargoyle at the office entrance.
Her insides twisted at the thought she was about to be expelled… again. What would her parents have thought? They’d probably be disappointed all over again. Would her mother shout? Would her father look stricken? She didn’t want to think about it—but she would give anything to hear her mother’s yelling again, or to see the appalled look on her father’s face.
When she finally told them about Dimitri… about what he had done…
They were gone.
Scarlett wrapped her arms around herself, trying to stop her inevitable collapse.
“You all right?” Regulus asked from four steps above, glancing at her from the corner of his eye. He’d been silent so long that Scarlett had honestly forgotten he was there.
“Do I look all right?” she spat, turning her gaze towards the polished wooden banister, gripping it tightly. “I’m about to be expelled from another school!”
“You’re not going to be expelled…”
“And how can you be so sure?” Scarlett shot back, cutting him off before he could finish the sentence.
Regulus exhaled sharply through his nose, furrowing his brows as he turned to face her.
“Isn’t it obvious? Everyone’s afraid of Rosier.” His cold eyes regarded her with utter detachment.
“Because he’s a Death Eater.” She murmured, refusing to look away from him. Regulus wiped his face clean of expression, his eyes sparking with something Scarlett couldn’t read. “Are you one of them?”
He clicked his tongue, glancing aside for a moment, neither confirming nor denying.
“Do you think I’m one of them?” Regulus’s voice turned rigid, the very same tone Sirius used when he felt threatened.
Scarlett shrugged, swallowing down how much the strangeness between them hurt. Regulus had once been so dear to her, and seeing that now he was nothing more than a stranger… well, she ought not to feel that way. Regulus deserved this treatment. He had gone into her mind and…
“I don’t know.” She gasped, refusing to let the tears gathering in her eyes spill over. “I don’t know who you are.” A breathless, exasperated laugh escaped her lips. “Who are you, Regulus?”
She didn’t wait for an answer. She quickened her pace, taking the steps two at a time, leaving him behind. Regulus might not show it, but his helplessness in the face of that question was plain—at least to Scarlett. He was nothing but a snake, waiting to strike, and she would not be made a fool of. Not by him. Not again.
When Regulus caught up, stopping before the gargoyle, he had the decency to remain silent as the statue moved aside to let Scarlett through. He stayed behind, watching her with those iron eyes tarnished with rust.
Dumbledore’s circular office was no stranger to her, yet Scarlett barely registered the mystical objects or the portraits of former headmasters observing her with curiosity and caution. Her throat felt parched as her eyes fell on the tall, white-haired man seated at the desk, and her palms grew clammy when she saw her uncle Thanatos standing with his back to her, gazing out of the vast stairwell window behind Dumbledore’s chair.
A shiver ran up her neck as Nate greeted her with a crooked smile before turning back to the view of the Hogwarts grounds.
“Please, Scarlett, sit down.” Dumbledore said kindly, gesturing to the chair before his desk.
Her stomach twisted as she obeyed, reflux threatening to rise, though Scarlett swallowed it down and fixed her gaze on her hands resting on the armrests, her gloved fingers tapping incessantly against the fine upholstery.
Brilliant. Her uncle was here to witness her expulsion!
She pressed her lips together. She felt as though she was about to be sick right at her feet.
“As you must know, Scarly, our family has a long history at Hogwarts.” Nate slid his hands into his pockets as he turned to face her. “And Aunt Evie hid an artefact of ancient magic here, in the caverns beneath the castle.”
She opened and closed her mouth, blinking rapidly. Wasn’t she about to be scolded? Expelled? She let out a harsh breath. She had already argued this with her uncle at the Leaky Cauldron.
Dumbledore slid an old map across the desk towards her, a detailed scheme showing areas of Hogwarts previously unknown. The castle’s underground. Scarlett immediately lifted her gaze to her uncle, grinding her teeth.
“I haven’t decided yet…”
“This map—” Thanatos cut her off, his tone dry. “—suggests the artefact is hidden in a cave that can only be accessed through the Black Lake. And you, being from the side of the family capable of wielding ancient magic, are the only one who can retrieve it.”
Scarlett frowned, trying to steady her breathing and process what she’d just heard.
“Uncle… I… I still…” She cracked her knuckles. “I still haven’t decided… besides, why would I even want to do this?! Why would I involve myself in it?!”
“It is a very powerful artefact, Miss Gaunt.” Dumbledore stroked his beard, exchanging a meaningful look with Thanatos. “It is sought after by the Death Eaters and… it could prove decisive in the war.”
“The war?” She burst into hysterical laughter, wiping the sweat from her palms onto her Slytherin cloak. “Fuck the war!”
“Scar, we—”
“No!” This time it was she who cut Nate off, her finger jabbing in his direction and then at Dumbledore. “I don’t care! If this artefact really is tied to ancient magic, if I never go after it, it will never be found… and besides, I’d be the only one able to use it! It makes no sense…”
Thanatos let out a bitter laugh, leaning against the glass of the window as she spoke, and Scarlett felt like a naïve little girl trying to argue with two sensible adults.
“Yes, Scarlett, we need you.” He wet his lips, casting her a bold look. “We need you to win this war, to stop You-Know-Who!”
She hadn’t expected such a candid declaration, blinking rapidly as she tried to digest his words. Was Thanatos mad? Or was this a nightmare? If her father were alive, he would have finished his brother off with his bare fists.
“No.” She repeated, shrinking back. “I’ve lost my parents, I won’t risk myself…”
“You have the chance to help us win the war—and in doing so, we might discover who killed them!”
Scarlett shot to her feet, the chair crashing to the floor with a bang that silenced her uncle. He straightened his posture as though expecting her to come towards him, but Scarlett remained on the far side of the desk, her eyes hardening into ice, the sharp blue cutting through everything in sight. Nate opened his mouth to speak, but Scarlett silenced him with a raised hand.
“I can’t believe you… that you…” She sniffed, fury igniting in her chest and setting fire to every other feeling around it. “You’d use my family’s death against me!”
Her voice thundered through the office, and even Dumbledore reacted to the sound, lifting one white eyebrow. Thanatos circled the desk as if to embrace her, but a single look from her stopped him cold. He exhaled sharply and shook his head, trying to gather his thoughts.
“No, Scarly, I didn’t… I didn’t mean it like that…”
Scarlett was in no mood to listen. All that echoed in her ears was the pounding of her heart, all she breathed in was freezing air, and all she felt was a blinding rage. She fled the staircase so quickly she barely realised her feet were touching the ground, only noticing she was out of the Headmaster’s office when her gaze landed on the pale, aristocratic face of Regulus.
“What happened?” He betrayed a kind of concern Scarlett had never seen from him before—but she didn’t care.
In truth, she didn’t even stop to answer him. She ran as though her life depended on it, her legs carrying her through Hogwarts’ corridors at such speed she became little more than a blur among students, suits of armour, portraits, ghosts, and a poltergeist determined to topple a clutch of first-years into a puddle leaking from the haunted girls’ bathroom.
She had no memory of how she left the castle, but the moment the faint morning light brushed against her skin, she transformed into Whiskers. Her heart still thundered and her lungs still screamed for air, but she did not stop. The rage ebbed, yet her paws continued pounding in desperate, relentless rhythm, carrying her away from the castle as fast as she could—away from the questions she didn’t want to face and the answers she didn’t want to give.
Scarlett returned to her human form at the edge of the Forbidden Forest, near the gamekeeper’s hut where Professor Kettleburn usually held Care of Magical Creatures lessons. At that hour there was no one there—perhaps because of the heavy clouds sweeping across the sky, or the thunder that growled every passing minute… or perhaps because the first drops of rain had begun to fall.
She looked up at the flashes of light announcing the storm, casting shadows across her face. She longed to cry, but all she did was sink to her knees in the wet grass and let the rain soak her robes and hair. It was as though the sky reflected her chest: confused, thunderous, and raging.
Her gaze swept the grounds, instinctively searching for Sirius. He wasn’t there—of course he wasn’t there. No matter how much she wished he was…
She wanted to go back to the castle, back to the safety of Sirius’s arms, back into the heart of the man she loved.
So she forced herself upright, her body heavy with a weariness that had nothing to do with her running. She took a few steps across the sodden lawn until she found a slick puddle, slipping so suddenly she hardly felt her ankle twist. She only realised she was hurt when she hit the ground again and the sharp pain shot through her leg.
Why the fuck had she run outside? What a stupid idea, Scarlett!
She would have punched herself in the face if she hadn’t been too busy crying, her tears mixing with the rain as she tried to smother the sobs. She tried to rise again—a futile attempt, for she soon realised the uselessness of her efforts and let herself fall back onto the drenched grass, staring up at the grey sky as the raindrops traced uneven paths down her face.
The mists shimmered, effervescent and shrill—just as the pain in her chest sliced her heart apart. Scarlett closed her eyes, forcing her breathing under control, forcing down the sobs.
“Ssssscarlett?” The hiss of her name made her turn her head, spotting the black serpent gliding through the green of the field. “Are you all rightsss?”
Tar hadn’t changed much in a year, her dark scales glistening under the rain, her red eyes studying her curiously as she coiled himself around her arm as though trying to hide from the storm—and somehow to comfort her.
The question only made her want to cry more.
“No.” It was the first time she’d ever answered in the negative. “I’m not, and I don’t know when I’ll ever be all right again.” Her voice cracked on the last words.
The snake slithered up her arm until he poked his head out from Scarlett’s cloak collar, her forked black tongue flicking each time she tilted her head, trying to understand why Scarlett was like this.
“You’re hurtsss?!”
“Yes.” She sniffled, looking at Tar.
“Where? I can help…”
“It’s not a wound you can see, Tar.” Scarlett smiled faintly at the reptile’s innocence. “It hurts here.” She pressed her hand against her chest.
“What’sss there?”
“Something called a heart, Tar.”
“Heartsss? What is a heartsss?”
Scarlett rubbed her eyes, unsure whether it was the tears or the raindrops that stung them.
“It’s the weight that constantly reminds us we’re alive, but that one day we’ll die. Our greatest blessing… and our greatest curse.” She lifted her gaze back to the snake, raising a hand before her face to shield it from the rain.
“And do you likessss it?” Tar seemed not to understand what she meant.
“The heart? Not right now.”
“Then letsss rip it out!” The serpent flicked her tongue in excitement.
“But if I do that… I’ll die.”
“Yessss, but… the pain…” Tar hissed, coiling herself around her chest. “How will Sssscarlett sssstop feeling pain?”
She didn’t know the answer, but thought of one all the same. It wasn’t long before the rain ceased to fall directly on her, though it still poured around, for a vast shadow had covered her. Scarlett wiped her eyes and saw the enormous Hogwarts gamekeeper holding an umbrella nearly the size of a tent. He scratched his thick beard and squinted, trying to recognise her.
“What on earth are yeh doin’ out here?!” the half-giant asked, his voice deep and alarmed.
“Taking a shower,” she quipped, making the gamekeeper place his hands on his hips.
“Don’t yeh know it’s no good standin’ out in the rain like this?!” He held out a huge hand. “Come along, before yeh catch yer death…”
Scarlett almost laughed. A cold was the least of her problems. She accepted his help, rising carefully so as not to worsen her already aching ankle. He guided her gently into the hut, where he quickly noticed her sprain and offered her a place on a worn leather sofa that smelled faintly of wet dog.
And speaking of dogs, the moment she stepped inside the hut, a massive slobbering Neapolitan Mastiff inspected her suspiciously, as if she were hiding something. Tar, tucked beneath her cloak, shifted slowly, winding herself up to her shoulder while the dog sniffed at her feet.
“Ah, Fang, let the girl through!” the gamekeeper scolded, tugging at the dog’s collar. The mastiff obeyed at once, though not without giving Scarlett one last wary sniff.
There was only one room in the hut. A copper kettle whistled on the stove, and in one corner stood a huge bed draped with a patchwork quilt, while the sofa rested beside a small fireplace.
“Make yourself at home,” he said, releasing Fang, who immediately tried to leap at Scarlett—though he was stopped by the gamekeeper yanking the collar again. “Fang!”
“It’s all right, I think I can handle a slobbery dog…” she teased, and Fang glared at her. “I don’t think he likes me.”
“He reckons yeh’re hidin’ summat…” the half-giant muttered, settling Fang by his bed and wagging a warning finger at him. “Here, a towel…”
The towel he handed her was as large as a curtain, and Scarlett quickly wrapped herself up to stop dripping water all over the hut.
“I am hiding something…” Scarlett confessed, earning a puzzled look from the gamekeeper. Tar lifted her head from her cloak collar, and the half-giant’s eyebrows shot up.
“A snake?!” He approached cautiously—Fang did too, though at first the dog backed away, only to perk up his ears and wag his tail moments later.
Scarlett smiled faintly, the throbbing in her ankle worsening with the cold. She settled back on the sofa, stretching her leg out to rest it against the edge of Fang’s bed. For a fleeting moment, she wondered what the hell she was even doing there.
“Her name’s Tar,” she answered after a pause. “The snake.”
“Oh… ah… she’s… yours, then?!” He watched as Fang tilted his head and growled at Tar, who slid down from Scarlett’s body and began to slither across the floor in a strangely friendly fashion.
“No… she lives in the forest…” Scarlett explained. “She’s my friend.”
“Yeh… yeh can talk to snakes?!” the gamekeeper stammered, blinking hard as if trying to see her more clearly. “Oh… oh… you’re a Gaunt! Sirius’s girl!”
Scarlett’s brows knitted together.
“How do you…”
“He’s a good lad, Sirius Black! Him an’ James Potter… I spent their first four years chuckin’ ’em out the Forbidden Forest…” He poured boiling water into a great big teapot. “Name’s Hagrid, by the way… I remember last year, that Quidditch match when yeh got knocked out… Sirius went mad lookin’ for flowers to bring yeh. Good lad, he is…”
A small smile crept onto Scarlett’s lips at the memory of the flowers on the little table beside her hospital bed. She hardly even felt the cold anymore.
“How’s yer ankle, then? Want me ter fetch Sirius?!”
“No… no need to call anyone, Hagrid, thank you.” She murmured, wiggling her toes and shutting her eyes as the pain plucked at her tendons. “I just… needed to be alone for a bit.”
Hagrid only nodded, handing her a steaming mug.
“Here, this’ll warm yeh up.” He offered her a smile, retreating to the kitchen to rummage for biscuits.
Scarlett unwrapped herself slightly from the towel and lifted the mug to her lips. She had never tasted such dreadful tea in her life—it was horribly unpleasant on the tongue, as though she were licking soil mixed with dried plums and coffee grounds. She choked quietly, glancing at Hagrid as he reached for a plate to serve the biscuits. Taking advantage of his distraction, she spat the tea back into the mug, trying to hide the grimace twisting her face.
The biscuits nearly cracked her teeth, though she pretended to enjoy them after managing to bite through the first piece, giving up on the rest and quietly returning it to the plate. Hagrid settled into his chair with Fang sprawled across his lap, the firelight flickering between them.
Tar climbed her way up Scarlett’s good leg, sliding along until she coiled around her left arm, keeping only her head poked out from the opening of Scarlett’s cloak.
She didn’t know what to say. She didn’t even know what she was doing there—she ought to have been running back to the castle—but the hut was oddly cosy and comfortable. Outside, the rain lashed against the stone walls, yet the cold wind couldn’t enter, and the fire radiated a pleasant warmth. Scarlett hunched into herself, her hair dripping onto the towel, her gaze fixed on the scarlet flame that cast scattered shadows across the single room.
“What were yeh doin’ out o’ the castle, eh?!” Hagrid asked, as though Hogwarts were such a welcoming place that fleeing from it seemed sheer madness.
Scarlett sighed, shrugging.
“I don’t know,” she murmured, lowering her eyes to her ankle, which was beginning to swell. She drew her wand from her cloak and dried her hair and robes with a charm, though her body began to tremble. She wasn’t sure if it was from the cold—or from…
“It’s dangerous out there, Miss Gaunt, especially now, with the war on!” He raked a hand through his shaggy hair, on the verge of continuing, but thought better of it, realising that whatever he was about to say was inappropriate.
“I know.” Scarlett swallowed hard. “You can call me Scar.”
The half-giant offered her a sad smile, stroking Fang’s wrinkled head.
“Heard what happened to yer parents,” he said, sipping his mug of tea and wetting his beard. “I’m real sorry, Miss Gaun’—er, Scar.”
Scarlett’s face twisted, exhausted from hearing those words, exhausted from trying to bury the suffocating pressure that clawed at her chest every single day. Two months since her parents had gone, and not a day passed without her feeling it.
“It hurts all the time,” she admitted, her voice breaking. “It hurts so much I sometimes think I won’t survive it.”
She didn’t know why she was opening up to the half-giant, but it felt good to tell someone who didn’t know her the way her friends and Sirius did. With them, it was as if the subject was worn out, as though one day they might tire of her grief. Sometimes she couldn’t even bear herself. There were days she wanted nothing more than to swallow enough potions to sleep and pretend she didn’t exist.
Hagrid shifted in his chair, making it creak. He stretched out an arm, grabbed a biscuit, bit into it and brushed the crumbs off the collar of his waistcoat.
“When I were twelve… I lost me dad.” Scratching his nose, he took another gulp of tea. “And me mum, well, she left when I were grown. Always miss ’em, ’specially me dad—he raised me…”
“I’m sorry, Hagrid.” Scarlett looked down at her ankle, trying to flex her foot and feeling a sharp sting shoot through it. She screwed her eyes shut. The ankle seemed a mere detail compared to the weight inside her. “This pain… it’s exhausting. I feel tired all the time. I don’t know… what to do… to make it stop.”
“There ain’t no runnin’ from grief, nor escapin’ it.” Hagrid wiped his beard with a giant rag. “Best thing is ter let yerself feel it. The pain… it becomes part o’ who we are. It never really goes away, yeh see? Yeh just learn how ter live with it.”
Scarlett felt her eyes brim with tears. Everyone said that, but to her it was an endless battle with grief—a battle she was always losing.
“And that pain…” he went on, reaching for another biscuit, “is proof beyond doubt how much yeh loved yer family, an’ how much yeh’ll miss ’em. It’s a bitter reminder that yeh lost ’em—but it’s also… the unshakable truth that yeh had ’em for years of yer life, an’ were happy with ’em.”
Hagrid was right. But reason and her heart weren’t agreeing in that moment, so Scarlett’s only response was to curl up beneath the towel, hugging her legs and resting her chin on her knee. The half-giant stood and fetched an enormous blanket, swapping it for the towel when he noticed she was trembling.
Though he suspected the trembling had nothing to do with the cold.
“Yeh should be in class right now,” Hagrid tried to sound reproachful, but couldn’t quite manage it.
“I should.” Scarlett agreed, feeling strangely safe, far from everything and everyone. “Don’t worry, Hagrid, they’ll find me.” She settled back into the sofa, laying her head against the armrest.
“Yeh not plannin’ on sleepin’ here, are yeh?!”
With her eyes fixed on the fire’s crackle, Scarlett only shrugged, feeling Tar nestle against the curve of her neck as though she too wanted a nap.
“Sirius is very good at finding me.” She sighed. “What isn’t he good at?”
“Scar… yeh can’t sleep here. Dumbledore—”
“Dumbledore knows. Where d’you think I’ve just been?!” Scarlett closed her eyes, trying to blow her thoughts away. “Him and my uncle… scheming behind my back…”
Hagrid didn’t understand a word of it, but he gave up on sending her away when he noticed the rain had grown heavier. He stood, gathering the mugs and the biscuits, leaving them on the table. Fang had already sprawled across his bed, resting his head gently on Scarlett’s good foot.
When he opened the door of the hut to head back to his work, he was met with James Potter, Lily Evans—and Sirius Black.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 52: But I have no one. No one but you.
Chapter Text
CXX
Sirius was already used to being escorted by Lily to Dumbledore’s office, but it was the first time she had done so after they had become friends. It felt strange, for he knew she was judging him with her eyes, especially after he had received a lecture from the Headmaster to which he had quite honestly paid no attention. He had expected to find Scarlett there, and not… not Thanatos.
"Where is Scarlett?!" he demanded, glaring at Nate.
Scarlett’s uncle merely ran a hand through his blond hair, exchanging a suspicious glance with Dumbledore before replying:
"She’s already been released."
"What did you want with her?!" Sirius shifted his gaze between the two of them. Dumbledore was like an inanimate gargoyle, betraying absolutely nothing.
Thanatos licked his lips, looking towards the rain that had begun to lash against the window beside him.
"Family business," Nate answered, without the decency to even look at him.
Sirius let out a scoff of a smile that bore no trace of happiness and spun on his heels to march out of the office in the most disrespectful manner possible, not even bothering to bid farewell. Lily followed him, appalled, and Sirius ran straight into his brother, leaning against the wall outside. By his presence there, Sirius had assumed Scarlett was in the Headmaster’s office, but now…
"Where is she?!" He lifted his chin, scrutinising his brother sternly.
Regulus barely moved, his hands shoved into the pockets of his trousers and his elbows propped against the wall. He only raised his eyes to his brother, one eyebrow arching, the volatile steel of his gaze darkening slowly.
"I don’t know. She ran off," Regulus revealed, monotone.
Sirius’s hauteur began to ebb away as he realised the way he had treated his brother, as though they were still enemies, as though… as though the weeds of discord their parents had planted between them had flourished that summer; as they naturally always did.
Sirius exhaled and loosened the tension in his shoulders, trying to say something to his brother, but in the end… the urgency of finding Scarlett ran roughshod over his words and he merely nodded, stepping forwards, hesitating when Regulus pushed himself off the wall. It was a subtle movement, almost imperceptible, yet instantly caught by Sirius’s eye.
Regulus parted his lips slightly, but if he had meant to say anything, his words stiffened in the air. Why hadn’t Sirius asked if he was all right? Of course he wouldn’t — his brother had eyes only for Scarlett now, and he was being cast aside… again. As much as he wanted to vent, as much as he longed to apologise, as much as he wished to…
I did something terrible, Regulus wanted to say, even knowing Sirius would never forgive him, much less take him in.
"I…" His voice came out languid, and Sirius looked at him in surprise as though that was precisely what he had been waiting for. Regulus swallowed hard, trying to go on even though his tongue felt swollen and his vocal cords, rigid. "I… I-I can… fetch her trunk and… give it to you later."
Sirius began to nod slowly in agreement.
"Al… all right. That’s fine." He stammered, feeling like a fool. "Thank you, Reg."
"You’re welcome, Sirius." He tried to smile, but all he managed was to press his lips together.
"We… we’ll see each other later, then." Sirius gave a half-smile before hastening down the corridor, Lily at his heels.
"What was that about?" She cast a sidelong glance at Regulus before catching up with Sirius. "I thought you didn’t like your brother."
"It’s not that I don’t like him, it’s just…" Sirius began, trying to make sense of it, but everything that came to mind sounded idiotic. "It’s a brother thing, Lily."
"A brother thing?" Her face darkened with a bitter smile. "I know exactly what you mean."
"Ah, right, you’ve got a sister too. I remember her from when I went to your house."
"An older sister," Lily added, tucking her red hair behind her ears. "She’s getting married."
"Let me guess: you’re going to be bridesmaid and you don’t know whether to wear a yellow dress full of bows or a pink one with frills on the sleeves." Sirius looked at her with sarcasm.
Lily didn’t smile — quite the opposite, the lines of her face filled with bitterness.
"She hasn’t actually asked me," her voice was almost a whisper, and her eyes, usually so vivid and kind, were now veiled with a sticky shadow.
Sirius stopped walking, processing what he had just heard.
"She didn’t ask you?!"
"No, she… she thinks we, wizards, are freaks, and… she doesn’t want a freak at her wedding." Lily sniffed, rubbing her knuckles against her eyes as though trying to stop the tears.
"With all due respect, Lily, but what a bitch!" Sirius nearly shouted, incredulous. "What did your parents say?!"
"What were they supposed to say? It’s her wedding…"
Sirius had never felt so much empathy for Lily as he did in that moment, because he understood exactly the kind of frustration she was feeling. And it was so intense that he actually forgot for a few seconds that he was looking for Scarlett.
"Shit siblings…" Sirius muttered, and Lily agreed with a nod. "Her loss if she doesn’t want you at the wedding — in fact, it’s better you don’t go, she doesn’t deserve your presen…" He stopped speaking when the girl turned and immediately hugged him.
Sirius stood frozen for a few seconds, not knowing what to do. Then, slowly, he began to relax his muscles and embraced her back, resting his chin on her deep red hair and rubbing Lily’s back as he usually did with Scarlett.
He understood all too well the feeling of not being wanted by one’s own family. Of being rejected for being who you were. He knew far more than he should of the pain of contempt and the abandonment of those who should love and protect him.
"I know it’s hard to break free from the ties our mothers’ wombs bound us with, but you’re far too incredible to cry over someone who doesn’t give you the slightest consideration." Sirius whispered, breathing in the floral scent of her perfume.
Lily gave a sniffly little laugh, pulling away as she hid the traces of tears edging her eyes and dampening her freckles.
"Stop being nice to me, Black, I know you only put up with me because of Scarlett and James." She teased, rolling her eyes.
"That’s true, Miss Goody Two-Shoes." Sirius placed a hand dramatically on his chest, making her laugh. Then he pulled his Two-Way Mirror from his pocket. "James."
His own reflection in the mirror rippled until it was replaced by the image of his best friend.
"Pads? Where are you?" James shoved his glasses up his nose, with the students of Advanced Potions behind him. Judging by the looks of it, the class had just finished.
"Coming down the Trophy Room staircase now… you’ve got the Map, haven’t you?!" Sirius kept Lily out of sight. "Shall we meet at the main entrance?!"
"All right. Should I call the others?! I think Wormtail and Moony are off to DADA now…"
"No, we should find Scar and go with her to class…" Sirius scratched at his beard, wondering where Scarlett had got to. Hopefully not in the Undercroft — he didn’t want to show it to Lily. Even though they were friends, he feared she might snitch about the place to the professors.
"All right, see you there." James’s reflection vanished and Sirius pocketed the mirror.
"That explains so much…" Lily muttered, descending the staircase.
"What do you mean?!" Sirius trailed his fingers along the banister.
"How you and Potter are always glued together and… and always seem to know everything!"
"Yeah, I’ll admit the Two-Way Mirror’s very handy when we’re serving different detentions… which is usually the case, since Filch knows us, as do all the professors…"
"You lot are so privileged! Born into wizarding families and… look at that, I wouldn’t even know where to get one of those!" Lily shook her shoulders, indignant.
Sirius’s good humour was murdered by the remark.
"I don’t think being born into a family like mine is a privilege, Evans." He shot back, sharp as a lash.
Lily paled, staring at him in shock.
"Er… I didn’t… sorry. I didn’t mean it like that. But… so it’s true?! That your parents…" She clapped a hand over her mouth as she realised what she was saying, eyes widening.
Sirius stopped in the middle of the staircase, his brow furrowing as he scrutinised Lily with brutality.
"That my parents…?" Any trace of warmth in his tone vanished, replaced by the innate arrogance of the pure-bloods.
Lily clenched her teeth and gave an uncomfortable smile.
"There was… there was this day… when Marl had a row with Dorcas and ended up drunk in the dormitory and… she… she said that… you always pulled your trousers on when she tried… to see you… completely naked. But… there was this one day she saw you had scars on your legs. Like… like marks… from whips."
Sirius didn’t know whether he was more enraged that he hadn’t realised Marlene had noticed, or that Lily knew about his scars. Or perhaps the fury came from the look of pity she gave him, as if he were nothing but a poor wretch, as if… as if… as if his presumption and insolence were nothing but a kind of armour so he could protect himself from looks like that.
"That was the privilege I received from my family, Evans." That was all he said, taciturn, before storming down the stairs as fast as lightning.
.
.
.
"Son of a bitch…" Scarlett muttered, walking without trying to limp, though it was difficult after the slaps and the brutality with which Sirius had fucked her. She glanced in the bedroom mirror at the skin mottled with bruises in the shape of his hand. He had hit so hard that even his rings were imprinted on her swollen flesh.
"Scar, what do you want to eat…" James poked his head through the door and fell silent the moment he caught her reflection in the mirror.
"GET OUT!" she screamed, hurling a pillow at the door with violence, but James had already vanished. "For fuck’s sake!"
She drew a deep breath, pulled on one of the few clean clothes she still had (a pair of jeans and a black T-shirt that left her navel bare), swallowed a painkiller and left the room, walking as naturally as possible, which in her condition was little more than a limp.
James avoided eye contact, Regulus was leaning against the kitchen counter watching her in a decidedly suggestive way, and Lily snapped her little notebook shut and breathed deeply, bored.
"What happened yesterday?" Despite the question, Red’s tone was accusatory.
"What do you mean?" Scarlett used her most irritated voice, yanking the fridge door open with more force than necessary.
"You know exactly what we’re talking about!" James stepped between the door and Scarlett, blocking her path as she shut the fridge.
"You didn’t go to the platform." It wasn’t a question. Lily let out a short, bitter laugh. "Of course you didn’t."
Scarlett swallowed with difficulty, drinking straight from the milk bottle rather than answering. She wasn’t going to fall into that trap, nor would she admit what Sirius had done to her. She already felt humiliated enough. Her eyes swept the room, widening when she noticed there was no rubbish on the floor, no dishes in the sink, no dust on the furniture. She pressed a hand to her chest — her heart was pounding so hard she felt suffocated. She immediately reached for her wand, but Regulus was quick with the explanation:
"Penny came round and cleaned the flat." He ran a hand through his hair, bored.
Scarlett darted over to her investigation board, but it didn’t appear to have been touched. How come Penny…
"Reggie must be so disappointed…" Lily went on, her gaze burning into Scarlett’s back. "He thought you… he thought you were incredible."
Scarlett doubled over as though she had just taken a punch to the stomach.
"Yeah, Lily, you don’t need to rub it in my face how much I let people down." Scarlett snapped, tossing the milk carton into the bin and forcing down the urge to cry as she let out a long breath.
"That’s not the problem, Scarlett, the problem is that you don’t do anything about it!" Lily raised her voice, springing up from the sofa. "You just… you drop to your knees in the mud and you never get back up!"
"If I get back up, I’ll just fall again. Better to stay on the ground — it’s where I belong." She retorted, checking the time on her pocket watch and deliberately ignoring the photo of Sirius pulling a face at her. "I need to work."
The three ghosts watched, powerless, as Scarlett left them behind. She slammed the flat door with a bang. Regulus sighed, running his hand through his hair in the same way Sirius did.
"I told you to stop pressuring her." He shot Lily a cutting look, making her straighten and flare her nostrils.
"Oh, Scarlett can handle hearing some hard truths!" The ghost came closer to him, tilting her chin. "I won’t just sit here, watching her torment herself while our children… when we could be with them!"
"No… no, we couldn’t." He didn’t flinch before her challenging expression. "We’re dead. We’ll never be able to…"
"But we’re here! We can see them grow up, we can advise Scar on how to raise them, we can… we can make her tell the truth and…"
"Yes, Lily, and everyone would brand her insane." Regulus shook his head with disdain. "We shouldn’t even be here. We’re… anomalies of nature. Souls trapped inside another soul."
"But we are here, Regulus! We are here, and we can make Scarlett, Sirius, Remus, Reggie and Harry happy!"
Regulus ran a hand over his face, weary, and ended the discussion by retreating into his own silent corner within his mind, sitting on the sofa and burying his face in his hands.
"I think Sirius went to see her," James finally said after a long silence. "I accidentally saw her looking at herself in the mirror and… er, she’s walking the same way she did after he took her virginity…"
"You think they shagged?! But… why… Sirius should be fighting with her, not…"
"Come on, love, have you forgotten the Scarius dynamic?!" James lightened the weight of the moment with a genuine smile. "They fight, and then they shag."
Lily’s expression softened as a myriad of memories swept through her mind.
"Was it like that with you too?" The question was directed at Regulus, who merely raised an eyebrow. "Did you fight and then shag?"
Lily’s jab worked, for Red’s face immediately emptied itself of any emotion that might have surfaced. The memory, however, floated to the surface of his mind, swallowing reality and clouding him with the past.
"No. I won’t betray him, I won’t…" Scarlett faltered, breathless.
"You betrayed him the moment you married me, Scarlett," he murmured. "Show me that love. Show me that thing that made you so reckless, that made Sirius give up everything. That made you betray your friends and kill the McKinnons. Show me that love, Scarlett. And I’ll make you see me as though I were him. Just… love me. Love me the way you love him. Give me your heart… and I’ll give you mine."
Scarlett shut her eyes tightly, forcing the air from her lungs. When she opened them, a cruel resolution swam in her ocean-blue gaze.
"Then make me."
Regulus furrowed his brow.
"Make me see you as if you were him."
Regulus drew his wand from the inner pocket of his frock coat, sliding the tip slowly along Scarlett’s chemise until it touched her chin. He whispered a spell and, suddenly, the man before her was no longer Regulus.
He was Sirius.
He was her Sirius.
Scarlett gasped, even knowing it was only an illusion… it felt so real. Her fingers brushed through the long black hair, along the angular jaw dusted with beard, the straight nose. The eyes, however, did not lie: they held the same dark grey as Regulus’s. But it was easy to imagine it was just a trick of the light, that the man was Sirius.
She kissed him, and for an instant that seemed infinite, Regulus tasted the love of Scarius.
Regulus had never felt such envy of his brother as he did that day.
.
.
.
"Why are you walking like that?" Danny looked at her with a furrowed brow.
Scarlett tied on her apron and picked up the notepad, leaning her elbows on the counter as she tried to think of an excuse.
"Twisted my leg yesterday…" Scarlett pressed her lips together with a nervous shrug. "Do you need me at the bar, or…"
"What did your brother-in-law want?" He pretended to wipe away a non-existent mark from the wooden counter, though his dark eyes hadn’t left her for a second. "He seemed… off."
Scarlett ran a hand along her jaw with a nervous little smile, searching for a convincing reply.
"Oh, because of the summer…" She cleared her throat. "My son and my godson are on holiday and… could I leave early today?"
Danny narrowed his eyes in suspicion.
"You’ve got a godson?!" His black brows drew together, one arching a moment later. "Why didn’t you tell me that?!"
It took Scarlett a few seconds to process what she had just said, and then to grasp Danny’s question. She had never been formally named Harry’s godmother, and although she was almost certain James and Lily would have given her that role, something twisted strangely in her chest.
She hadn’t been there when they married, nor at Harry’s birth. She had no right whatsoever to call herself his godmother…
"It’s not the sort of thing I go telling people…" Scarlett deflected, pretending to be offended at the suggestion and hiding just how much it affected her.
"When are you going to bring them here?" He tossed his fringe back. "Your son and your godson."
"Er… why would I bring them here?!" Playing dumb, Scarlett watched Danny unlock the front door and flip the sign to open.
"Because I want to meet them!" He planted his hands on his hips.
"Danny…" Scarlett glanced around, moistening her lips and rubbing her Signet with her gloved hand. "That kiss…"
"It was only a kiss." He cut her off, waving her words away with a careless flick. "I want to meet them because we’re friends, and I’m sure they’re good lads."
Scarlett couldn’t have said whether they were or not. She inhaled deeply, holding her breath so as not to show her discomfort. Then she exhaled and gave a reluctant nod.
"You could even bring them to one of the gigs — I reckon we could sort out a couple of passes… but it’d have to be on a quieter night… Tuesday or Wednesday, ‘cause no underage allowed…" Danny mused, stopping when the bell jingled, announcing the arrival of customers.
She didn’t want to think about the possibility of taking Reggie and Harry to one of her shows. She was paranoid enough already, afraid of being recognised, even with the repelling charms and the subtle alterations she cast on her appearance.
Even after fifteen years locked away, the chances of running into someone she knew — even in predominantly Muggle settings…
A shiver ran the length of her body and made her tremble. It wasn’t safe. What she was doing was already reckless enough; she didn’t need to invite more trouble. And Sirius… what on earth did Sirius want from her?!
Scarlett had spent the entire morning casting impatient glances towards the entrance whenever someone came in, her heart skipping beats at the thought of seeing him.
Wait. Expectation?! No, she wasn’t hoping he would come to her! It was more that she had no choice, and he had made that painfully clear the night before. With an irritable sigh, she placed a hand over the bruised swell of her backside.
He had made it far too clear.
Her gaze snapped to the door automatically when he finally arrived. Sirius Black was always an event, and he knew it — he knew how handsome he was, knew how the leather jacket, biker trousers and boots suited him, knew how to leave his long hair perfectly untamed, knew how to wear those aviator shades on the bridge of his sharp, aristocratic nose; knew that his gallant smile drew a cascade of sighs from schoolgirls and the ravenous attention of single women, married women, and even men.
Scarlett wanted to slap herself when she realised she was on the verge of sighing like the teenagers, unable to tear her eyes away. Sirius possessed an inexplicable allure. He was the sun — everyone orbited him, craving just a little of his light. But in the same way he shone, he was selfish too. He liked the spotlight all to himself.
After all, he was never the kind of man to share.
Sirius sat at the table closest to Scarlett, and her heart pounded so hard it felt ready to burst out of her chest. Danny shot her a puzzled look, and she merely shrugged, approaching as casually as she could, keeping her eyes lowered to the floor as she waited for him to order.
Yet he remained silent, so Scarlett took the initiative:
"Are you ready to order?" She swallowed hard, tapping her pen against the notepad without pause.
Sirius opened the menu with disinterest, the rings on his fingers glinting in the golden lamplight against his pale skin.
"What time do you finish?" Ignoring her question, Sirius turned his head casually towards her, his gaze making her cheeks burn as she recalled what he’d said the day before.
"Three," Scarlett murmured, checking her pocket watch. Her shift was almost over. "Half an hour from now."
"Hm… right." Sirius went back to flicking through the menu, though he wasn’t really looking at it. Scarlett knew full well he was watching her through the mirrored lenses of his sunglasses. "What do you recommend?"
She stepped closer, flipping back a few pages and pointing to the rib burger with chips. Sirius lowered his sunglasses and bit his lower lip in thought, then nodded and lifted his gaze to her, probing her with his silver irises, drinking her in with those dark pupils and making her feel naked, though layers of clothing still covered her.
"I’ll have that one." He ran a hand through his hair, tossing it back.
"And to drink?" Scarlett didn’t dare look him straight in the eye, pretending to check the menu.
"A lager." Drumming his fingers on the table, Sirius kept staring at her as if amused by her awkwardness. "Ah, almost forgot…" He pulled a small vial from the pocket of his jacket, extending it towards her. "So we won’t have… mishaps."
A contraceptive potion. Scarlett let out a bitter laugh, taking it from him, the black diamond of her ring glinting between her pale fingers and catching Sirius’s attention. The smile on his lips slackened. Scarlett hid her hand, her heart galloping in her chest.
"I should’ve taken it before you…" She stopped, letting out a long sigh instead. Spinning on her heel, she went to put the order through to the kitchen. Then she headed for the bar, feeling Sirius’s ravenous attention burning into her.
She glanced around and swallowed the potion, her face twisting into a grimace at the bittersweet taste. Then she filled a pint glass with beer.
"What’s he doing here?!" Danny asked, his eyes darting between Sirius and Scarlett as he poured himself a beer from the minibar.
"Oh, we’re going to sort some things out when my shift ends…" Scarlett explained, trying to sound disinterested, though her heart was hammering so hard she swore everyone in the bar could hear it.
"How the hell does he manage to look that stylish?!" the guitarist muttered, narrowing his eyes at Sirius.
"I used to wonder that every day back when we were at school…" Scarlett picked up the glass and placed it on the tray, heading back to serve Sirius’s beer in a desperate attempt to walk as normally as she could.
She failed, because a gleam of amusement painted the silver of his eyes.
"Why are you walking like that?!" His tone was insufferably smug. Had she not been at work, she would have punched that perfectly straight nose of his.
Instead, without missing a beat and with a forced smile, she flipped him the middle finger before turning to serve another customer — feeling like a teenager again when she realised her cheeks were burning and her stomach fluttered with butterflies.
The thirty minutes seemed to stretch into three hours. As she served the customers, her gaze occasionally strayed towards Sirius, who was watching her from his table with voracious attention. She didn’t need to ask what was going through his head. It was far too easy to read him — especially when she set his burger down on the table.
Sirius widened his lips into that pretentious, dimpled smile, and Scarlett hurried to wipe down the table beside him, catching him fold his arms through her peripheral vision.
"Why are you avoiding me?" The question was so direct that she scrubbed the table harder than necessary.
"What? I’m not… I’m not avoiding you." She made no effort to hide the sulky, clipped tone. "I’m working!"
Sirius kept smiling, a boyish gleam flickering in his eyes as he leaned forward on the table, resting his elbows to draw closer to Scarlett.
"Are you uncomfortable because of last night?" The mocking lilt in the words made her expression stiffen, her face burning, her heart pounding in her chest.
She would not let Sirius Black humiliate her again — not at her workplace!
"There’s no reason for me to be uncomfortable." She glanced around to make sure no one nearby could hear. "It’s not as if that night meant anything." She shot back, her gaze venomous.
Sirius stiffened, the colour draining from his face. Scarlett pulled away abruptly, and he remained seated, staring at his lunch. Then, suddenly, he stood, picked up the burger, laid a hundred-pound note on the table and walked out of the restaurant without another word.
The sweltering heat outside hit him full on. Sirius longed to climb onto his Ninja and ride off, but he hadn’t come there for Scarlett. That was why he drew a deep breath, swallowed down the urge to scream at her in the bloody restaurant, and leaned against his motorbike, taking a hefty bite of the burger.
Fuck, he was hungry.
"It didn’t mean anything…" he muttered, letting out an irritable laugh as he chewed. "Didn’t mean anything… fucking liar…"
Sirius neglected so many things that still needed settling with Scarlett… and it was bloody hard to stop everything from spilling over. He lit a cigarette and tried to calm himself, exhaling the smoke slowly as he watched the heavy summer traffic — the throngs of passers-by, the cars jammed together on the road.
When he finished, he tossed both burger and stub in the bin. He tied his hair back in a ponytail, sweat dampening his nape, and closed his eyes — not reacting to the tug that yanked at his chest as though he were a puppet. That silent warning, that idle reminder, that wretched connection. Before Penny, that pull in his chest signalling Scarlett’s presence had been something natural to him, but now…
He knew it was because of the pact. The pact he and Scarlett had sealed in the heat of flesh, where they spoke shallow promises and chained themselves to one another with a cruel fate. Sirius didn’t want to be there, didn’t want to depend on her, but… what choice did he have? Whether he liked it or not, Scarlett was still all he had left. Remus would never agree to what he was about to do. Nate wouldn’t even take him seriously, and Orfy, well…
None of them would do. None of them was Scarlett.
"I need your car." That was all Sirius said, opening his eyes to look at her through the dark lenses of his aviators. His expression was veiled by an arrogant shadow. He wasn’t asking.
Scarlett raised an eyebrow, hands on her hips.
"And do you even remember how to drive, after all these years?" She tilted her head, half-playful, half-serious.
"You’re the one driving. We’re going to Surrey." Sirius pushed himself off the motorbike, scanning the car park for Scarlett’s Honda.
"Surrey?! Why?" Scarlett fished her keys out, still baffled.
"We’re going to get Harry." He looked straight at her, slipping off his sunglasses and tucking them into the collar of his black shirt. "He’s spending the summer with us."
Scarlett froze for a moment, processing the words and covering her left ear, as if to block out some sound coming from that direction.
"And why should I drive an hour to Surrey when we can Apparate straight there? Or use the Floo Network?" She swept the bleached strands out of her face, tucking them behind her ear. The sun turned her blue eyes to green-gold.
Sirius grunted, rolled his eyes and pressed his lips together.
"I don’t want the Ministry knowing he isn’t at his uncle and aunt’s. Floo travel is monitored for underage wizards, and Apparition is tracked…"
"Why don’t you want the Ministry to know?!" Scarlett looked so genuinely alarmed that Sirius almost thought she cared about Harry’s safety.
"Because it’s something Dumbledore would do everything in his power to stop," he finally said. "You’re the only one who can help me and… if I could’ve asked someone else, I would have. But I have no one, Scarlett. No one but you."
Scarlett stayed silent for a long moment, hugging her own body. It didn’t take long for their eyes to meet and hold, pierced by the blare of horns, shouts and laughter rising from the busy street. There was no plea in Sirius’s gaze, nor was there warmth. There was hurt laced with desperation, longing and pain. Expectation… and disappointment.
"All right," Scarlett whispered, breaking the fleeting eye contact.
"I knew it, I knew he wouldn’t leave Harry with them!" James leapt with joy, hugging Lily exuberantly. "Harry’s going to Sirius’s… and you too, Scar!"
She wasn’t entirely sure about it, but she didn’t want to think on the matter. She gestured for Sirius to follow, and they walked over to her car: the Honda NSX gleamed as though freshly polished, the rays of sunlight painting the red with rose and the black with amber.
"It’s only got two seats, but I’ve charmed it to be larger inside…" She slid into the driver’s seat, watching the luminescence of her ghosts in the back: James kissing the face of a smiling Lily, and Regulus, lost in his thoughts of remorse, watching her with that smile in his eyes only he could manage.
"Sirius is such a lapdog…" Red muttered, sinking into the seat. "Can’t keep away from you."
Scarlett might have told him to shut it, but Sirius climbed in and settled into the passenger seat, eyeing the dashboard with interest, pressing the buttons of the stereo until it spat out the tape inside.
"A-ha?!" He read the title before slotting it back in.
"They’re… a Norwegian band…" Scarlett replied, feigning disinterest as she started the car and checked the mirrors. "They’re good. The third track’s my favourite… it’s the one that gives the album its name…" She slipped it into reverse, manoeuvring out of the car park.
"Good? Better than Toto?" Sirius fixed her with an incisive look, and Scarlett shook her head.
"Not a fucking chance."
He grinned, and Scarlett caught herself grinning too. Their eyes lingered on one another, but she quickly sobered and turned back to the road, pretending she was too busy driving to pay him attention.
Sirius looked out at the passing scenery, focusing on the reflection in the glass — Scarlett, assured and confident. She drove fast, impatient, yet always in control. Her gaze kept sliding in his direction, but she never dared look at him directly, always snapping those blue eyes back to the road. As though he were something forbidden.
Forbidden and tempting.
The silence, however, gnawed at him. There was so much to say, yet no word would come. As though they were hiding in the stone walls of his mind and it would take Herculean effort to coax them past his lips.
Sirius shifted in his seat, restless, adjusting his belt, crossing his arms, stretching his legs up onto the dashboard.
"Get your feet off the dash, Sirius!" The rebuke came at once, even though Scarlett barely glanced at him.
"Come take them off." He challenged, but one look from her was enough to make him surrender, raising his hands as he pulled his feet away. "All right, all right — only joking!"
"What’s wrong? Can’t keep still?"
"No." He adjusted the strap of his wand holster on his left leg. "I can’t bloody wait to get Harry out of that filthy Muggle house…"
"I know what you mean, Sirius. I know what you mean." Lily agreed, her face right beside his. "Good thing you were brave enough to force Scar along, otherwise we’d still be waiting to see our son…"
Scarlett rolled her eyes, flooring the clutch as she shifted gear.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 53: I don’t want you to kill for me. I want you to live for me.
Chapter Text
CXXI
After a few minutes, once they had left central London behind, Sirius opened the glove compartment searching for something to pass the time. He pulled out a magazine, his brows knitting as he saw Playgirl with Bret Michaels on the cover.
"What's this?" He showed her the magazine, a mischievous smile spreading across his lips.
Scarlett cast a quick glance, enough to send heat rushing to her cheeks and make her heart lurch.
"I don't know." She tried to keep her voice steady and detached, though she knew full well it wouldn't convince him.
He flipped through the magazine, finding several photos of the Poison frontman in suggestive poses. His grin deepened.
"Why have you got a magazine of naked blokes in the glove compartment?!" Sirius teased, turning the magazine towards her.
James, Lily and Regulus shoved their heads into the space between the seats to see a photo of Bret Michaels that made James cover Lily’s eyes at the indecency.
"By Merlin’s balls… whose magazine is this?!" James looked at Regulus, unable to contain his laughter.
"Nate?" Red pulled a face and sank back into his seat.
"Oh, that is definitely Nate’s…" Lily flopped back against the upholstery too, bursting into loud laughter. "Good luck explaining that one, Scar!"
"That… i-it’s not mine!" Scarlett glanced at the magazine again, stammering defensively, avoiding his gaze.
Sirius laughed as well, and the sound of it, mingled with James and Lily’s, made her heart falter. She wanted to join them, to laugh melodically, to share in that feeling she both fled from and craved. But all that came was the urge to cry, so she held her breath and gripped the steering wheel tightly.
"You're a terrible liar!" Sirius accused, flipping through more pages with that persistent grin on his face.
"No, I swear, it’s not mine!" she insisted, eyes fixed on the road. A strange sensation slithered through her body, leaving the tips of her fingers numb.
Sirius shut the magazine and rested half his face against the dashboard, staring at her intently, lips curved. The silver of his eyes plunged into sordid feelings only to resurface with the warmth of affection and tenderness.
"Stop it, Scar." His velvety voice spoke her name with such sweetness that Scarlett could almost taste sugar on her palate, her heart now pounding in her chest, blood rushing through her veins as fast as her Honda sped down the road.
"Stop what?" Her reply was laced with confusion, though she knew exactly what he meant.
But she didn’t want to know. She didn’t want to talk about it, not in front of her ghosts.
Sirius blew out a breath, grunting at the same time. He shoved the magazine back into the glove compartment and slammed it shut with a clatter that made Scarlett whip her head to glare at him.
"You can’t just bloody well pretend nothing happened!" he almost shouted, folding his arms as the silver of his gaze hardened into steel.
"I told you they shagged!" James crowed from the back seat. "Who the hell d’you think you’re fooling, Scar?!"
Scarlett swallowed hard, seizing the chance to stop and pay the toll, pretending she was far too busy gathering coins off the dashboard. Her ghosts already drove her mad—now the three of them and Sirius… bloody hell, the road to Surrey was going to be endless. She regretted ever agreeing to Sirius, for giving in, for doing what he wanted.
It was always the same in the end—Sirius always got his way with her.
And saying no to him was so fucking exhausting.
"I’m not pretending it didn’t happen, only that it didn’t mean anything." The retort burned on the tip of her tongue.
Sirius let out a laugh, sharp and dripping with sarcasm, a piss-poor attempt to cover his wounded pride.
"Didn’t mean anything?" His voice rose as he yanked against the seatbelt to turn towards her. "Didn’t mean anything?! Stop taking the piss—why do you keep lying to yourself?"
Scarlett ground her jaw under Sirius’s cutting stare.
"Why are you so worked up?! You’re the one who said it didn’t have to mean a thing!" she snapped, her knuckles whitening on the steering wheel.
Sirius hissed, as though she’d just slapped him. His eyes burned with fury, laced through with raw vulnerability.
"Yeah, Scarlett, I lied!" he shot back, his voice cracking with frustration. "We both know that… this thing… between us… it’s always meant everything!" He dragged a hand down his beard, then scratched the back of his neck as though trying to get a grip. "I… I was scared… scared you’d wreck me again! Because that’s what you do to me! I… I build my bloody house of cards and you knock it down with a look… your rejection… your silence." He scrubbed at his eyes with the back of his hand. "I… I told you I loved you… even after everything… and you… you couldn’t even bloody say it back!"
Tears threatened to spill from Scarlett’s eyes, despite her relentless effort to hold them in.
"Sirius… I don’t deserve this," she whispered, hoarse. Hesitant. "You, your love… happiness… Harry and Reggie… I don’t deserve any of it."
Sirius gasped, his tied-back hair spilling over his shoulders like the London night sky—black, unyielding, stripped of stars. Even if they gleamed in his grey eyes, all Scarlett could see was the man who would forever twist guilt tight around her heart.
"Scar… you’re not your worst fucking moment!" Sirius’s voice came low, heavy. "You’ve been carrying trauma so long you think suffering’s the only way to exist. And if you’re not suffering, you don’t think you’re real!"
Scarlett clenched her teeth, struggling to look at him, her shoulders tight and her neck feeling as though it had turned to stone.
"And what the hell do you know about suffering, Sirius?! WHAT?!" Scarlett screamed the question, the final words torn from her in the rage that ate away at her.
"I KNOW ENOUGH!" Sirius roared back, clutching at the burn scar on his forearm, turning his face towards the window.
"No… you don’t know." In a hiss, Scarlett dragged his attention back to her. "You don’t know what it’s like to look five people in the eye before slaughtering them in cold blood. You don’t know what it’s like to defend yourself in labour against a psychotic werewolf. To be locked up without ever having seen your own bloody child. To be tortured for years." She spat the words like a cat ready to strike. "No, Sirius, you don’t know what suffering is!" she went on, her voice climbing higher with every syllable. "And I hope you never do. If it’s up to me, you never will."
Sirius’s face flushed scarlet. The silver in his eyes blazed so fiercely it all but spat fire, until tears welled to smother the furious storm within—tears that begged him to lash out, to unleash his demons, to hurl at Scarlett every vicious word that had burned in his throat through the years he had felt like the most wretched man alive.
Through the damned three years he had raised her son. Hers and Regulus’s. Through the hellish months he had searched for her, nearly dying for it, only to read in some sodding newspaper of her marriage to his brother. Through the searing agony of realising he had lost the woman he loved for good. Through the look she had given him in the courtroom, before she was sent to Azkaban, before she was handed a life sentence.
Sirius Black and suffering were old mates. Scarlett had no right to monopolise it, however fucking selfish she might be. And yet… a voice deep in his mind whispered she was right. That what he had seen her endure in Azkaban was only the tip of the iceberg, that the reckless choices she made over and over weren’t as senseless as they seemed.
She was afraid. Sirius knew it—she’d told him so. And he knew well what it was to be ruled by fear, to be bent and broken and steered by it.
"You’re never going to forgive me." She tried to wipe away the furtive tears by rubbing her face against her shoulder, slowing the car as she dropped down a gear. "And I deserve that."
Sirius shook his head, biting down on his lower lip in a feeble attempt to keep the tears at bay. But the heat of them slid down his cheeks regardless of his will. His eyes fixed on Scarlett, watching her from the corner, trying to tell her she was wrong. That he was willing to forgive her. That he wanted to forgive her.
But it would have been a lie. Deep down, in the searing darkness lodged in a corner of his heart, seeing Scarlett so broken fed so much of the hatred he had cultivated… that watching her like this made him feel good. Sirius felt sickened by himself, pressing a hand to his chest. Sickened that his clamours for vengeance had been granted, that the woman who had shattered him was now far more broken than he had ever been.
Once, he had desperately wished Scarlett would suffer. He had craved it, the thought of it made his mouth water, his palms sweat, his nape prickle. It was one of those shames he kept swept under the rug, waiting for the right moment to remind him that even he could be cruel to the one he loved. That he wasn’t only Scarlett’s victim, but one of her executioners too.
"Scar… you don’t need my forgiveness. You need to forgive yourself first." He sniffed, rubbing his tears into his beard. "There’s no bloody point… in you crucifying yourself like this."
"I don’t know how to do that," she admitted, sobbing. "How could I forgive myself? After… after everything I’ve done…" She dropped another gear and flicked on the indicator, braking slowly until she rolled to a complete stop on the hard shoulder.
The sound of the hazard lights, ticking in time with their ragged breaths, echoed between them for what felt like an age.
"Last Halloween…" Sirius spoke with difficulty, running his fingers over the silver rings on his hand. "I asked you what you’d have done differently. And you told me we can’t go back. That we’ve got to live with the choices we made." He wet his lips, and Scarlett turned anguished eyes towards him. "And… I agree. We do have to live with the choices we made, but we can’t be prisoners to them. And we… we’ve been shackled far too long already."
"You say that, but… you’re as chained up as I am." Scarlett sniffled, wiping her nose with her hand. "Hypocrite."
"I wasn’t the one who nearly drove into a lamppost." Sirius shot back, harsh, not caring about the flicker of sorrow that passed through her blue eyes. "I’m not the one running away from my own son."
Scarlett clasped her hands tighter on the steering wheel and lowered her forehead to rest there, shutting her eyes, hiding her face. Something withered inside her, and she feared it was her heart.
"I didn’t see another way…" she gasped, her voice muffled against her arms. "Orfy tried to kill me. Remus… made it clear how much he hates me. And you… you chase after me because I’ve got a piece of you that you’ll never get back. Just like you’ve got a piece of me. And even knowing that, you still try… try to feel like before. Before everything. When… we were happy." She sniffled, swallowing slowly. "But we’re never going to be happy like that again, Sirius."
It was the truth. Scarlett embodied everything he had lost. His youth, his happiness, his love. His family. The days when James was by his side, when he was forced to put up with Regulus, the golden age of his life. When all the problems in the world couldn’t suffocate him, when life was light, easy, sweet. Days when… when he could sleep soundly because the woman he loved was beside him and he knew his friends would soon drop by to see him.
Maybe he was romanticising it, maybe his adolescence hadn’t even been that brilliant, but bloody hell, for Sirius, those days had been magnificent. It was as though the sun never stopped shining, the war would never come, and everyone who mattered would remain in eternal joy.
Sirius drew in a deep breath, the air turning to fire in his lungs.
"We can try," he murmured, running a hand gently down her back, feeling the ridges of her spine beneath his fingertips. "Please? For me."
Scarlett turned her swollen face towards him, eyes bloodshot, cheeks wet.
"I don’t want… I don’t want to let Reg down. I don’t want to let you down."
"You already are, Scarlett." He didn’t spare the cruelty in his reply, his lower lip trembling. "We’ll go pick up Harry, you’ll come home and we’ll have dinner together. You’ll talk to Reg, you’ll ignore Remus and… you can leave whenever the fuck you want. I won’t chain you there. Just… can you do that? Can you do that for me?" Sirius leaned across the dashboard, bringing his face close to hers, breaking through the layer of hesitation in those cold eyes, his hand settling against her hot, blotched cheek. "Can you bloody do that for me?"
Scarlett closed her eyes, as if that touch alone were enough to melt away her reluctance, her thoughts, her fears. Her body shivered with the sparks that spread across her skin from his touch, softening her muscles, slowing her pulse. Sirius stroked her cheek with his thumb, never letting his gaze stray from her.
Breathing became difficult. Sirius had that effect on her; he stole her breath, her reason, the darkness woven into her soul. He was the sun, and it was impossible to fight his pull, his brilliance. His suffocating heat. Surrendering, she nodded, holding his hand, feeling the cold rings against her warm palm.
"I’d do anything for you," Scarlett whispered, a small, fleetingly intimate smile tugging at her lips. "I’d kill for you, Sirius."
Sirius let out a laugh, unsettled, not sure if she was being ironic or not. He wanted to believe she was, even though he knew it wasn’t a joke.
"I don’t want you to kill for me, Scarlett." He brushed her bleached fringe off her damp cheeks and tucked it behind her ear. "I want you to live for me. I want you to forgive yourself. I want… I want you to let yourself be happy. I want you to know your son, I want you to stop tearing yourself apart. I want you to heal. Killing… killing’s easy, Scarlett. Destroying’s easy. Saying sorry’s easy." He pressed his forehead to hers, drinking her in—the silver of his gaze, the depth of her pupils, the strings of her heart. "But healing… mending… building… ah, that’s the hard bit. We both know just how fucking hard it is." He brushed the tips of their noses together. "Can you do that for me?"
"Sirius… I can’t… I don’t deserve this, I can’t…" she faltered, refusing to digest those words, refusing to let them carve into her skin, into her soul.
"That’s not what I asked," he cut across her, though without a shred of harshness. There was only tenderness in his voice. Every word came from his very core. "Can you do that for me?"
Scarlett blinked several times, her dark lashes jewelled with droplets, framing eyes full of torment, fear, doubt. She had a thousand reasons to say no, she wanted to say no, to list all the ways what he asked was impossible.
But it was Sirius Black with his face pressed close to hers, his breath mingling with hers, his nose brushing against hers. Sirius Black whispering soft words in her ear just to steal her heart one more time… and she would give in. Sirius asked her the question and the answer was always yes. When she’d said no, everything had gone to hell. And it was so fucking hard to deny him when he held her hostage with such ease.
"I can." The reply was no more than a breath, but he understood at once.
Sirius pressed a kiss to her lips. Not quick, not lingering. As though he were sealing the pact with that touch, taking Scarlett’s hand afterwards, his mouth grazing the ring on her finger as if to say more, before kissing the band and stroking her fingers, finally pulling back to settle himself in his seat.
Scarlett remained frozen, as though she’d just looked straight at Medusa. Her cheek still burned from Sirius’s touch, her lips tingled, her fingers trembled.
"Right then… let’s go get Harry." He gave her a wink.
Scarlett was too dazed to react.
Phantom hands rested on her shoulder and she glanced at her friends through the rear-view mirror, rubbing her eyes with her knuckles to see them more clearly.
"Let’s go get Harry, Scar," James murmured, with that tenderness that always pulled an unconscious smile to her face.
"He needs you. They need you." Lily smiled, pressing her lips together, drawing her into the calm of her gaze. "Harry and Reg."
"And Sirius…" Regulus added reluctantly, casting a melancholy look at his brother. "He needs you. And you need him."
"Let’s go get Harry," she agreed at last.
She started the car and pulled back onto the road.
.
.
.
Harry Potter had never been allowed to keep his school things in his room. The Dursleys never permitted it; he’d been forced to lock his trunk with all his belongings in the cupboard under the stairs. But of course, the Dursleys’ behaviour had changed once they discovered Harry had an extremely dangerous wizard for a godfather. Naturally, the boy had left out the rather convenient detail that Sirius had been cleared.
It was only his second day back at his aunt and uncle’s house, and he couldn’t take his eyes off the window, waiting for a letter from his godfather. Yet no owl came, and when it was nearing four o’clock, he reached for his stack of books and quickly found what he was after — the leather-bound photo album Hagrid had given him three years ago, filled with magical pictures of his parents. He sat down on the bed and turned the pages.
He stopped at one where a large group of people were gathered on a beach — Harry had never bothered to ask who was who, so elated had he been when Hagrid gave him the album of his parents’ memories that he hadn’t questioned the image at all.
He still didn’t know most of them, but he recognised some faces the moment he saw them: Remus’s light brown hair was not yet streaked with grey and his face bore fewer scars. He was smiling, gazing with open affection at a dark-haired woman with strong brows. Peter Pettigrew crouched in the sand, waving. Beside him, two girls sat wrapped in one another’s arms on a beach towel. Behind them, his parents smiled radiantly — Lily holding a wide-brimmed hat, James squinting against the glare of the sun. And right next to them, Sirius had his arm slung around Scarlett’s shoulder, the two of them kissing.
Harry frowned. As far as he knew, Scarlett was Regulus’s mother, and Regulus was Sirius’s nephew. And she had been a Death Eater, imprisoned for it, which meant that… but wait, Sirius had also been imprisoned for supposedly being a Death Eater, and he never was. So surely the same must apply to Scarlett.
He reached for the bedside table and picked up the photograph Regulus had given him — the Polaroid where his father and Scarlett were dancing. Harry carefully opened the slot beneath the beach picture and slid the Polaroid inside, brushing his thumb over James’s cheerful face.
Then he turned a few more pages until he reached the day of his parents’ wedding. There was James, waving at him with a bright smile, his jet-black hair — the same hair Harry had inherited — sticking up in every direction. There was Lily, radiant with happiness, arm in arm with his father. And there… was Sirius. Handsome and laughing. Alone. Now, after being cleared, he looked far more like his younger self in that picture than the gaunt, hollow-faced man the papers had shown when he had first escaped Azkaban.
Scarlett hadn’t gone to his parents’ wedding?
Harry flipped through a few more pages, his eyes widening as he found another photograph from the ceremony: James with his grandparents, whose names Harry didn’t know, but in the background, amongst the white flowers, Sirius was pacing back and forth, holding something, almost as if he were dancing. His back was turned, head bowed, dark hair falling over his shoulders.
He was cradling someone. Probably Regulus.
Harry’s stomach growled.
He put the album aside, closing it, and looked out into the garden through the window. Silence reigned in Privet Drive as usual, and Harry sighed, wondering about the long-awaited owl from his godfather. When would Sirius come to fetch him? In a week? Two? Three?
He only hoped he’d be able to spend his birthday with him.
Harry went downstairs and, as soon as he stepped into the kitchen, he frowned at the sight of his cousin Dudley, red-faced and puffed up with frustration, hammering his fists against the table like a tantrum-throwing toddler.
"I don’t want to eat this!" he bellowed, pointing in disgust at the slice of grapefruit on his plate. "I want chocolate cake!"
Aunt Petunia, her face as sour as ever, patted her son’s shoulder while shrinking into herself, as though she too were suffering.
"Diddykins, darling, eat your grapefruit!" she coaxed, her voice trembling. The boy shot her a furious look.
Uncle Vernon let out a great sigh that made his thick moustache bristle, and glared at Harry standing in the kitchen doorway.
"What are you staring at, boy?!" he growled, but before Harry could reply, the suburban tranquillity was shattered by a deep roar of an engine, and every head in the kitchen turned at once towards the window overlooking the street.
His uncle sprang up from his chair and yanked back the floral curtain, narrowing his eyes as he saw a vehicle pull up directly in front of the house. It was a sports car, its red bodywork gleaming under the summer sun, and Uncle Vernon’s face flushed crimson as he realised the intruder wasn’t going anywhere.
"Whose car is that?!" Vernon growled, outraged, as though the mere presence of the vehicle was a personal affront.
Uncle Vernon stormed towards the hall. Quick as a flash, Dudley swiped a piece of chocolate cake from the stand, taking advantage of his mother’s distraction as she peered out of the window. The front door was wrenched open by Vernon, panicked that the sports car might be drawing the neighbours’ attention.
Outside, a short woman with platinum hair and a tall, broad-shouldered man in full biker leathers — boots and a black leather jacket — climbed out of the car with such cool condescension that Vernon’s fury doubled on the spot.
"YOU CAN’T PARK ON MY DRIVE!" Uncle Vernon bellowed, the vein in his forehead bulging fit to burst. Aunt Petunia hurried to his side at the door, her eyes darting between the car and the visitors, a doubtful crease forming between her thin brows.
The man, after a pause to take in the less-than-hospitable welcome, removed his aviator sunglasses and folded his muscular arms. His handsome face made Petunia’s eyes widen, and his posture radiated such natural authority that Vernon’s gaze flicked nervously towards the shotgun propped in the corner of the hall.
"I’m here for my godson," he declared, with an arrogance so innate that Vernon instinctively stepped back.
"And who the devil are you?!" Harry’s uncle demanded, curling his lips in suspicion.
The man opened his mouth to answer, but Aunt Petunia was quicker:
"Oh my God, it’s that man from the news! The murderer… SIRIUS BLACK!" She paled, her voice shaking, before darting back into the house in a frantic scramble for the telephone.
The platinum-haired woman followed her in, sweeping past Vernon as though he were invisible. He made a half-hearted move to block her, but one look at Sirius Black was enough to make him think twice.
Petunia clutched at the phone as though her life depended on it, jabbing the numbers for the police with trembling fingers… but the woman was quicker. With a savage yank, she tore the cord straight from the wall, making Petunia recoil with a choked sob of terror.
"Please, don’t hurt me!" she begged, raising her hands as if she were being held at gunpoint.
Ignoring her, the woman swept her eyes around the sitting room as though searching for something… or someone. Something of value, Petunia supposed, shooting a desperate glance at Vernon. The intruder strode into the kitchen, where she found a fat boy and Harry — whose eyes widened to the size of saucers at the sight of her. He hadn’t expected her to have dyed her hair. Without hesitation, the woman smiled at Harry in a way that warmed the boy’s heart.
"Grab your things, Harry. You’re spending the summer with us," she announced, so casually that Harry found himself frozen for a few seconds.
Harry hesitated, still processing what was happening, until Sirius appeared behind Scarlett, his face lighting up with a grin almost identical to the one he wore in the photograph from his parents’ wedding.
"Come on, Harry, we’ve still got an hour’s drive to London," Sirius said, leaning against the kitchen doorframe.
Dudley sat gaping, chocolate smeared across his teeth. He glanced at the couple and then at Harry, before shoving another chunk of cake into his mouth.
Harry bolted upstairs to gather his things, his heart hammering frantically at the realisation that he was leaving the Dursleys’ house on the very first day of summer holidays.
"For Salazar’s sake, are you raising a child or a bloody pig?!" Scarlett snapped, eyeing Dudley with disdain. Aunt Petunia immediately stiffened, clearly offended, lifting a finger to contradict her, but Scarlett pressed on: "I remember you…" She turned on Petunia with a look of sheer repulsion. "At your parents’ funeral."
Harry’s aunt blinked, covering her mouth at the unexpected connection, as though something long-forgotten had resurfaced.
"You… you were the friends…"
"Of your sister." Scarlett spat the words, venomous. "Lily would’ve been heartbroken to see how you treat her son."
"B-but… but… but… he… he is treated well!" Petunia stammered, a nervous smile twitching on her lips.
"Dressed in rags two sizes too big for him, bolting up the stairs like lightning to escape with people he’s only just met? No… I don’t call that being well treated, Petunia." Her retort cracked like a whip, and Harry’s aunt grew even paler than before.
The Dursleys exchanged a panicked look.
"Please don’t turn us into bats!" Petunia squeezed her eyes shut and clasped her hands together as though praying.
Sirius would’ve laughed at her reaction, if he hadn’t also noticed Harry’s behaviour.
"You don’t need to worry about Harry any longer, because he’s living with us now. If Dumbledore asks what happened, you tell him his godfather came to fetch him," Sirius said, his impatience cutting through every syllable.
"Dumbledore… doesn’t know?!" Petunia faltered, gesturing to Dudley as he poked his head around the doorframe to stare at them.
Silence. Scarlett glanced at Sirius.
"I’ll go see if he needs help," she offered, darting up the stairs in a flash.
"You can’t take him!" Petunia carried on, clutching at her chest in agitation. "He… he made it perfectly clear… the spell… the protection…" she managed, clearing her throat.
"Harry’s already spent more than twelve hours in this house, which means the protection’s in place until next year," Sirius explained, throwing an anxious glance towards the landing above.
Scarlett glanced into each room, hearing Harry’s hurried footsteps at the end of the corridor and watching him stuff his belongings together in a rush. His trunk lay open as he shoved the rest of his things inside — spellbooks and quills, along with his Invisibility Cloak, the Firebolt Sirius had given him, and the Marauder’s Map. He tore down the calendar from the wall, the one with the countdown to the first of September, and tossed it aside.
"What’s missing?" Scarlett leaned against the doorframe, and Harry looked back over his shoulder at her a little warily. She was short, almost his height, and her face was delicate, though there was a hardness lurking there that she hadn’t shown when she’d entered the kitchen earlier. Her blue eyes were shrewd, sharp, and a little unnerving — as though she could read every thought in his head. She didn’t look Sirius’s age; on the contrary, she seemed as though she’d only just turned eighteen.
"Er… it’s… Hedwig. My owl," he muttered, and with a flick of her wand Scarlett cleaned out the cage. He gave her a timid smile of thanks. "That’s… that’s it, I think."
"Brilliant." She picked up the cage, and Harry dragged his trunk down the stairs.
"Let’s go," Sirius declared, hefting Harry’s trunk and gesturing for him to go on ahead.
Together, the three of them left the house without so much as a goodbye.
Sirius opened the boot. Although it was a sports car and clearly didn’t look as though it could fit Harry’s trunk, Scarlett had already taken the liberty of casting a spell to expand the space. Sirius shut the boot and Scarlett opened the passenger door for Harry to climb in.
"How am I supposed to come with you if the car’s only got two seats?!" He raised his brows and screwed up his nose.
"You’ll sit on Sirius’s lap," Scarlett said it so naturally that Harry blinked, awkward, until he realised she was joking. "Get in and you’ll see…"
When he poked his head inside the car, he found there were back seats after all — as though it were a normal five-seater. His mouth fell open, both impressed and relieved that he wouldn’t have to perch on Sirius’s lap, or squash in with the boot… or worse, be left behind.
He settled himself into the back, securing Hedwig’s cage beside him with the seatbelt. Scarlett took the wheel and Sirius slid into the passenger seat. The engine roared to life as she shifted into reverse, and Harry stared, breathless and transfixed, as Number Four, Privet Drive shrank away until it vanished from view.
How many times had he dreamed of this moment?
Harry couldn’t have said. But he could hardly contain the excitement swelling in his chest, for it brimmed over into tears in his eyes. He pretended to adjust his glasses, wiping them away discreetly until Sirius turned in his seat, fixing his godson with a serious look. He hadn’t cut his hair; the long black locks still reached a little past his elbows, and his face now looked healthy — almost as though he’d never spent twelve years in Azkaban.
"Listen, Harry, there are some rules you’ve got to follow if you want the blood protection to hold. You must always refer to your aunt and uncle’s house as your home, even if it isn’t, all right?"
Harry furrowed his brows, still struggling to believe what was happening.
"You mean… my mum’s protection?!"
"Exactly." Sirius nodded. "When she sacrificed herself for you, Dumbledore cast a spell on your aunt so that the protection extended to where you lived with her. The house stays protected as long as you return every year and spend at least twelve hours there."
Harry absorbed the explanation, watching the sun sink across the sky like a needle, setting the horizon ablaze in yellow, orange and red.
"So…" he began, breaking the silence with a nervous cough, "I’m going to… live with you?"
"Yes, Harry, you’ll be with us this summer. Unless… unless you don’t want to…" Sirius scratched at his beard, only now seeming to consider the possibility. "I mean, er, you’ll have to share a room with Reggie while me and Remus sort out another bedroom. But there’s plenty of space — worst comes to worst we’ll remodel the studio and—"
"I can help with that," Scarlett smiled, eyes still on the road.
"Sounds… sounds good," Harry blushed, admiring the scenery rushing too quickly past the window.
"It’ll be a good time for you," Sirius said, giving him a pat on the leg before turning back round.
"You’ll feel at home," Scarlett agreed. "You’re part of the family now."
Harry lowered his gaze, rubbing his hands together nervously as though he didn’t know what to do with them. Hedwig nipped at his finger as if to calm him, and he remembered when Regulus had told him they’d be living together.
"There’s still one thing I don’t get," he said at last, drawing both their attentions. Sirius glanced at him sidelong, and Scarlett met his eyes in the rear-view mirror. "Are you two… a couple?"
Scarlett choked on her own saliva, and Sirius opened his mouth as if he hadn’t seen the question coming, raising a finger to reply — but then fell silent, exchanging an embarrassed look with her.
"Do we look like a couple?!" Sirius forced a grin.
"Er, well…" Harry shrugged. "You act like you are."
"Do we really?" Scarlett stretched her neck, trying to ease the tension in her shoulders.
"You look at each other the way my parents do in the photos I’ve got of them," the boy remarked. "And there’s a picture of everyone at the beach… with you two… but I don’t get it, because you’re Regulus’s mum and Sirius, you’re his uncle…"
"Well, that’s a long stor—"
"Yes, Harry, we are a couple!" Scarlett cut across them, her voice shooting up two octaves. They both stiffened into silence, staying that way as they registered the aggressive way she changed gear. "Are you hungry? Because I am!" She swerved into the car park, tyres screeching, and came to a halt sprawled across two spaces.
Scarlett climbed out, slamming the door behind her and marching so fast towards the diner that neither of them had time to react.
Harry checked Hedwig was all right and unbuckled his belt, casting a confused glance at Sirius.
"Did I… say something wrong?" he asked, stepping out and staring at the skid marks on the tarmac.
Sirius let out a long sigh, lips curving into a stubborn smile after Scarlett’s confession.
"Women, Harry… bloody women…" His godfather slung an arm around his shoulders, pulling him close as they walked towards the diner entrance. "They don’t make a lick of sense."
Harry chuckled softly. When they stepped inside, they found Scarlett staring up at the menu, pretending not to have noticed their arrival. Sirius came up behind her, letting his hand slide casually around her narrow waist with an intimacy that brought a flush of colour to her cheeks. She glanced at him from the corner of her eye, and the look they shared was enough to rekindle the fire that always seemed to surround them.
Please, Sirius, don’t leave me alone.
I never leave you alone.
The words floated between them, vivid, resonant. Relentless.
It’s not the same with other people.
No… it isn’t.
Something flickered in Sirius’s chest and tugged at Scarlett’s heart as though an anchor were lodged there. The pact, the promise, the feeling. He ached to unpick everything he had just uncovered, but he couldn’t — not here, not now. His fingers had slipped beneath the hem of Scarlett’s blouse, tracing the delicate, scarred skin beneath with his touch.
"Can I look at the menu?" Harry’s voice chased away the unspoken pleas of their hearts, dragging them back to reality.
"Order whatever you like, Harry," Sirius said, amused by Scarlett’s adorable reaction, the way she turned her head aside to hide how flustered she was, or how her cheeks grew steadily redder.
"Really?" Harry’s incredulity was plain. He flipped through the menu before making up his mind. "Burger and chips… and a milkshake!"
"I’ll have a milkshake too," Scarlett breathed, her sea-blue eyes glittering with the same yearning that set Sirius’s heartbeat racing. "And you?"
"I’ll handle the order. Go grab a table." He gestured towards a spot by the window.
Sirius stayed where he was, watching Harry and Scarlett walk away, sitting down together. He caught every movement of his godson, the way he spoke animatedly with Scarlett, with his smiles and his pauses. He didn’t miss her reactions either — the way her gaze softened in Harry’s presence, how she could become his favourite version of herself just to please a boy she barely knew.
How his wishes were coming true — and how terrifying that was.
He closed his eyes, the smile slowly fading. He let the tears fall unchecked, stunned by how much Harry resembled James, overwhelmed by the intoxicating rush his godson’s presence gave him, haunted by what it meant for Scarius to be a couple again… and at the same time…
Sad. Inexplicably sad, unrelentingly sad, inexorably sad. A piece of him was missing, and he had no idea how to get it back, because it was gone for good. Because it had died the instant his best mate did. Because it had been ripped from him the moment he clutched the corpse of the person he’d loved more than any other in the whole fucking world.
"I wish you were here," he murmured, a sharp, stabbing pain spreading through his chest. "I wish you were both here." He wiped his tears with the sleeve of his jacket, slipping on his sunglasses to hide the evidence. "He’s just like you, Prongs… but he talks like you, Lils…"
"I know, Pads… I know…" James tried to hold him, tried to hug him even though his arms could never wrap around his best friend again. "Thank you for everything you’re doing for him…"
"We’re here with you, Sirius," Lily brushed her fingers over Sirius’s pale face as if to wipe away his tears. "You just can’t see us."
"I’ll do for them what I couldn’t do for you…" he exhaled, emptying his lungs.
Sirius pulled himself together and ordered the burgers, chips and milkshakes. He carried the full tray over to the table — his sadness washed away by joy, silencing the voices that blamed him for the Potters’ deaths, allowing himself, in that meal, to live without the crushing weight of his best friends’ loss pressing down on his heart.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 54: Monsters
Chapter Text
CXXII
"I have the impression those two will end up destroying one another." Thanatos Gaunt remarked, settling into the leather chair.
Dumbledore smiled, casting him an enigmatic look. He turned his face towards the exit of his office and ran his fingers over his long, crooked nose.
"They are good children, Thanatos." the Headmaster observed, adjusting the purple cloak draped over his shoulders.
"Even good people are capable of doing evil, Albus." Nate commented with a sombre, pessimistic air. "I hardly recognise her anymore. Scarlett, she… " He shook his head.
"She is an adult now. Adults rarely behave like the children we once knew." Dumbledore mused, turning back to him.
"I know that." Thanatos drummed his fingers against the arms of the chair, impatient. "I know how to make her cooperate, but you will need to do something you will not like, Dumbledore."
The Headmaster studied Nate through his half-moon spectacles, blue eyes glittering as if he were trying to decipher what the new DADA professor meant.
"Scarlett is a Gaunt on her father’s side…" he continued. "But a Sallow on her mother’s. The Signet is her mother’s inheritance, and the Sallows are…"
"I know the Sallows, Thanatos. I once witnessed the Heroine of Hogwarts wield her Signet. It is a formidable ability, with the potential to make a wizard relentless." He sighed. "It is exactly what we need to win this war. However… it is far too much power in the hands of a girl who has just lost her parents."
"That is why I told you you’ll need to do something you will not like." Nate wet his lips, running a hand through his blond hair. "You know… the Sallows… they cross all boundaries when it comes to love… or hatred."
Dumbledore narrowed his eyes ever so slightly, pressing his fingers together as if weighing the proposal implicit in his words.
"Why do you bear such hatred for the Sallows?"
The question struck Thanatos squarely. He smiled, a smile that was all shape and no warmth.
"Because they too have the extraordinary talent of shattering a heart without remorse, to the point of leaving it beyond repair." He huffed, fumbling for his metal cigarette case in the pocket of his jacket. "Would you have any contact with the Headmaster of Durmstrang?"
.
.
.
"Well… I am in no hurry. Are you lot?" Sirius asked quietly, sitting himself at Hagrid’s table while the gamekeeper fetched three chipped mugs with only his forefinger.
"Erm… no…" Lily murmured, watching the rain thicken outside, tucking back strands of her red hair whose tips were still damp after they had crossed the grounds under the downpour. "I had never been in here before…" she commented, admiring the cramped yet incredibly cosy space.
"If I’d known I were gettin’ visitors, I’d’ve tidied up a bit…" Hagrid chuckled low, setting the mugs down by the fire. "I’ll make us all a cuppa!"
"You don’t need to tidy anything, Hagrid, it’s perfect as it is!" James pulled out a chair for Lily, a wide grin spreading across his lips.
"’Ow’s yer dad, James? Ain’t seen him fer ages…"
While they chatted, Sirius drifted closer to Scarlett, watching her sleep. Her relaxed features warmed his heart, and he smiled sadly, realising all that peace would vanish the moment she opened her eyes. He threaded his fingers through Scar’s black hair, leaning down to press a kiss to her forehead—when something dark stirred beneath her robes and slid out from the collar of her shirt.
Sirius jolted, every hair on his body bristling as though he were in Padfoot’s skin.
"Bloody hell, there’s a snake…" he gasped, bewildered, staring at the creature’s red eyes.
Fang, sprawled at Scarlett’s feet, barely twitched.
"Aye, Scarlett came in wi’ tha’ snake… first time I ever saw a Parselmouth talkin’ to a beast. She’s called Tar," Hagrid said, pouring out the tea and watching them from the corner of his eye.
"Scarlett’s a Parselmouth?!" Lily frowned, regretting having picked up a biscuit once she realised it was far too hard to bite into.
"She’s a Gaunt." Sirius shrugged. "Direct descendant of Salazar Slytherin. The difference between her and You-Know-Who is that her branch of the family was disowned a long time ago…"
At the mention of Voldemort, Hagrid slopped a bit of tea on the floor before setting the mugs down on the table. He wiped the sweat from his brow and rubbed at his moustache, perching on the edge of his bed as he looked at the three of them.
"She’s a nice one…" the gamekeeper muttered, meaning the serpent, which tilted its head curiously as it regarded Sirius.
"I’ve seen her before… last year, when I was looking for Marl’s broom around the grounds…" Despite her seemingly tame nature, Sirius didn’t dare move any closer to Tar. The reptile slid down to the floor and disappeared where Fang was lying.
"Anyroad, ye’ll have ter take Scarlett back up ter Hogwarts. She’s turned her ankle." Hagrid pinched one of his biscuits and chewed loudly.
Sirius rounded the sofa, pulling the blanket from Scarlett’s feet to examine the twist and swelling of her ankle. It didn’t look too bad, but the thought of her running off alone, once again, through that damned school…
A chill went through him.
"How’d she do that?" he asked, unable to mask his concern.
"Must’ve slipped… rain were already comin’ down an’ she were layin’ on the grass when I found her." Hagrid took a swig of his tea, wetting his moustache.
Letting out a breath through his nose, Sirius covered her again and crouched at her side, stroking her damp hair, pressing soft kisses to her forehead. He heard her sigh, shifting faintly as she tried to hide her face in the blanket, but Sirius wouldn’t allow it.
"Hey…" he whispered, his voice little more than a breath, resting his forehead against hers.
"Hey…" Scarlett grumbled in reply, her long lashes fluttering as her eyes opened slowly, still heavy with sleep.
"I’m here." A small smile adorned Sirius’s rosy lips.
"Mhm… you are…" she murmured, her fingers reaching for the rough stubble of his beard as she caressed his angular chin. Scarlett tried to move, but the twinge in her ankle was enough to keep her still.
"Shall we head back to the castle?" he suggested, wrapping his arm around her, drawing her close, feeling just how cold she was.
"Let’s…" she agreed, before looping her arms round Sirius’s neck, allowing herself to be lifted by him, who raised her only after making sure she was comfortable and safe. "Thank you for having her, Hagrid, James’ll pop by later to tell you all about his girlfriend…"
"Girlfriend?!" Lily drew her brows together, folding her arms.
"Ah, you two’re datin’? That’s grand! Always said ter James ye’d end up together…" Hagrid clapped the Head Boy hard on the back, leaving him winded and unable to defend himself.
"We’re not… dating!" Clenching her fists, Lily spun on her heel towards the door, her face burning. "I would never date Potter!"
James coughed several times, bracing himself against the table as he caught his breath, clutching Sirius’s cloak so he wouldn’t escape without him.
"I hate you!" he muttered, one hand pressed to his chest.
"Hate me? You love me…" Sirius wrinkled his nose, throwing Scarlett—nestled in his arms—a playful look. "And you, do you love me or hate me?"
"Depends… will you lie down with me once we get back to the castle?" Scarlett gazed up at him, coy.
"My love, you never need ask me twice…" Sirius brushed his nose against hers, inhaling her vanilla scent. "Oi… give us a hand here, you two…"
The Head Boy and Girl stretched the Invisibility Cloak over them, and with Lily muttering Wingardium Leviosa, she levitated the cloak above their heads to shield them from the rain. It was daytime, though the gloom made it feel more like evening. James tugged the Marauder’s Map from the waistband of his trousers, entirely forgetting Lily was beside him.
"What’s that?!" she pointed at the scrap of parchment, squinting at the tiny inked dots.
On the way out, it had been easy enough to hide the map when Sirius distracted her with natural ease whilst James searched the grounds of Hogwarts for Scarlett. But now…
"It’s a map." Sirius drew a deep breath, his shoulders cracking beneath Scarlett’s weight.
"Don’t say!" Lily mocked, fixing James with a scathing glare. "And what are those names?!"
"Er, yeah, well… it’s just…"
"The map covers the grounds of Hogwarts and lists every student, professor, ghost…" Sirius went on, receiving a desperate look from James, begging him to shut his mouth. "How d’you think we’re always one step ahead of everything?!"
Lily violently snatched the map from James’s hands, gaping as she realised everything Sirius said was true.
"So… that’s why you… you always knew where I was! In the library, in the gardens, in the common room…"
"Oi, oi, oi, oi, oi!" Sirius jerked to the side when droplets spattered onto him and Scarlett thanks to Lily’s lapse in concentration whilst levitating the cloak. "The map only got fully finished in our fifth year, so no, most of the time we were just following you about…"
"Even worse!" Lily’s face twisted in outrage.
"For Merlin’s sake, Lily… you knew perfectly well what you were gettin’ yourself into hanging about with us…" Scarlett grumbled sleepily. "Sirius used the map to spy on me, too!"
"What? Me? I never did that…" He rolled his eyes and shrugged as if the idea were ridiculous. "I only wanted to make sure you were all right, and if it weren’t for the map, you might not even be here with us… not after Avery broke your arm…" His voice faltered gradually as he mentioned the incident.
"I remember that." Lily slipped, and was caught by James, offering him an awkward smile of thanks. "Why wasn’t he expelled?!"
"His father’s on the Ministry committee for Hogwarts. Must’ve pulled every string to keep him from being thrown out…" James muttered darkly, running a hand through his hair as the wind pushed droplets across his cheeks.
"It doesn’t matter anymore. It’s over." Scarlett let out an irritable sigh, burying her face into the curve of Sirius’s neck.
They reached the courtyard and entered through the antechamber of the Great Hall. The place was bustling, and they ignored the curious glances. Lily swiftly adjusted her Head Girl badge, as if she were attending to her official duties.
"I’ll keep an eye on Avery and Mulciber…" she promised Scarlett, meeting her gaze. "They won’t bother you again, Scar."
Sirius snorted a bitter smile, licking his lips as though he doubted that very much.
"She’s right, Padfoot. You’ll have to let us handle them…" James cut in, as though trying to prevent whatever reckless scheme Sirius might be weaving to get his revenge. And he knew Sirius far too well not to suspect it—his best mate never forgot this kind of thing, especially when someone had hurt the one he loved.
"I didn’t say anything…" Sirius shot his friend a sly look, adjusting Scarlett in his arms and resting his chin atop her forehead. "But… Lily’s right about one thing." His smile turned cruel. "Mulciber and Avery’ll never lay a hand on Scarlett again."
.
.
.
Scarlett had fallen asleep in Sirius’s arms, wrapped in the scarlet blankets of his dormitory. She dreamt something strange. At that stage, all her dreams were strange, always burdened with tongues of fire, tearful pleas and distorted images. She wasn’t sure whether they were memories or figments of her subconscious, but her mother was in every one of them, like an insistent haunting. Orfy too. Which was odd, since her father never appeared. No matter how much she longed for him…
That morning’s dream, however, unfolded within a house of gas lamps and dwellers with iron eyes. A corridor filled with portraits watching her, and a cold hand stroking her chin, whispering poisoned words into her ear.
Scarlett didn’t understand. She only knew she was afraid. Terribly afraid.
She woke with her heart leaping into her throat, a sordid feeling coiling in her chest like a serpent. Sirius’s tattooed, heated hands pressed at her waist, his arm curling round her, sliding up her back until it reached her face. Scarlett kept her eyes closed, lulled by the warmth and comfort of his touch.
Sirius slipped beneath the blankets, pressing a soft kiss to her cheek before slowly drawing back, reaching for the edge of the bed.
"How’s the ankle?" he asked, pulling the canopy aside to let a few rays of light spill into the space. His black hair was tousled, his beard unkempt, and his eyes still heavy with sleep. And yet Sirius Black was the most handsome man in the world; the dimples appeared at once when he smiled, his grey irises shone in delight as they lingered on Scarlett, and the messy strands of hair somehow managed to enhance his beauty.
"I don’t know…" Scar hesitated, languid. "Still hurting."
"Hm…" he grunted, checking the pocket watch on his bedside. It was already lunch time. "Are you hungry?"
"I don’t know…" Scarlett laid her head against her hand, turning her body to gaze at him. "I’m just tired."
"Tired?! My love, we’ve slept the whole morning through…" Sirius teased, until he noticed guilt creeping into Scarlett’s expression.
"Sorry." Lowering her gaze, she hugged her knees, burying her face against them.
"No… you’ve no reason to apologise to me." Sirius swallowed, threading his fingers through her messy hair. "I wasn’t arguing with you."
"I know." A sad smile twisted her lips. "I just… feel so tired…"
"It’s all right." Sirius sealed his words with a kiss to her shoulder. "Rest. I’ll fetch us something to eat…"
"’Kay…" she replied without sound, watching Sirius rise from the bed and use a spell to smooth his shirt, fastening the tie afterwards.
He combed his hair, threw on his cloak and gave her a wink before leaving the room. Scarlett remained still, hoping Sirius would go and return in a heartbeat, even though she knew that to reach the kitchens he had to descend the whole of the Grand Staircase.
With a dragging yawn, she checked her ankle. It would probably need more professional attention, yet she didn’t want to stay in the hospital wing. Just the thought of being alone, even with Pomfrey nearby… the mere possibility of falling victim to Mulciber and Avery…
Scarlett shuddered. Her stomach growled loudly and she sank into the pillow, trying to drift back into sleep as she shut her eyes. It was a vain attempt, not only because of her hunger, but because the pain in her ankle was starting to become bothersome.
She raised her head at the sound of two knocks.
The door opened, and the perfect face of Marlene McKinnon slipped through the gap, her golden wavy hair tumbling over her shoulders like a mane. She looked at her and smiled, a kind of smile Scar had never seen her wear before. At least, not directed at her. It was friendly, casual and… tinged with embarrassment.
"Can we talk?" Marlene’s tone was pleasant, though Scarlett knew it was nothing but a façade. She had always tolerated the Gryffindor’s presence, but saw no reason to speak with her alone, so her answer was a firm shake of the head. Marlene’s eyes widened, as though she hadn’t expected that reply, as though she were certain Scarlett would say yes. "I didn’t come here to talk about Sirius, if that’s what you want to know." She dared to step into the room, closing the door and leaning her body against it.
"I said no." Scarlett murmured darkly, shooting her a cutting look.
"It’s about your mother." Marlene pressed on, ignoring the refusal.
Scarlett clicked her tongue, blowing all the air from her lungs. If her ankle weren’t swollen, she might have leapt at Marlene’s throat.
"We worked together. For… for Dumbledore." Marlene faltered, tucking her golden hair behind her ears, brushing her pink cheeks with her hands.
Scarlett blinked several times, massaging her temples, trying to make sense of what Marlene was saying.
"What?!" The question came out as little more than a confused breath, her gaze cutting across to the girl. "What do you mean you worked together?"
"Your mother was an exceptional witch. She… before she died, she… left some things… in her office… and I was given the freedom to take them…"
"What are you talking about, McKinnon?!" Scarlett snarled, silencing her. "Why the bloody hell would you two be working together?!"
"I… I was her apprentice." Marlene swallowed slowly, licking her full lips. "In the Order of the Phoenix. And she…" The girl shoved her hand into her pockets and pulled out a locket. "She’d have wanted you to have this. It was…"
Scarlett lifted her gaze to the pendant, to the jet carved with mother-of-pearl in the shape of a waning moon. The opalescence of the stone shimmered against the ocean of her eyes. She sat up in bed as Marlene stepped closer, offering her the locket. Scarlett accepted it with a slight nod. There was a knot in her throat that kept her from speaking at that moment, and her fingers traced the pendant, a melancholy tension drawing tight the lines of her face.
"My father gave it to her… on their tenth wedding anniversary." She held back her tears, refusing to let her emotions rise. "What do you mean by… Order of the Phoenix?!"
Marlene opened her mouth, then closed it, shaking her head as though caught off guard.
"Well… Dumbledore… he hasn’t told you? About… about the Order…" She twisted a golden strand round her finger, her nail painted a vain shade of red. "I thought…"
"Oh, he told me." Scarlett clenched the locket in her palm until it hurt. "I’m not helping him. I won’t get involved in this. I’ve already lost my family—what more does he want from me?" She spared no harshness, pressing the locket to her chest.
Marlene stepped back, nodding.
"I understand…" She bit her lower lip, uncertain of what to do. "There are… a few more things… I need to give you. They were hers. Do you want me to bring them here…"
"I want you to leave me alone, McKinnon." Scarlett cut across her. Beneath the veneer of calm, her words were sharp. "Leave me alone."
She hadn’t thought Marlene would listen, and was surprised to see her respect the request and open the door, leaving her alone without another word. There was nothing left to be said. Scarlett didn’t want to think about her mother, didn’t want to think about her father… she didn’t want to think at all. She didn’t want to feel. And she had no desire whatsoever to leave that bed, so she lay back down, burrowing beneath the blankets.
She caressed the locket that had belonged to her mother, her fingertip running over the raised curve of the waning moon, wondering if heaven and hell were real, and asking herself where her family had gone. She felt that if they had gone to heaven, then she was bound for hell… and vice versa.
.
.
.
Sirius strode with long, chaotic, heavy steps. He loosened the tie around his neck, hoping the suffocating sensation would ease, but it made no difference. He still felt breathless. Seeing Scarlett like that awakened every dark thing he kept buried in his chest, and it was suffocating to know that nothing he did was ever enough to help her feel better.
Nothing seemed to be enough.
Sirius no longer knew what to do.
Or what to feel.
Or… what to say.
He no longer knew anything at all.
He knew there was no cure for Scarlett’s heart, no caress nor comfort that could erase what had happened. And the same was true for him, but it was easier to smother his own fears when Scarlett was his priority.
"Sirius…" A voice he knew all too well pulled him from his reverie. He slowed his pace, eyes sweeping the Grand Staircase until they landed on a pale, angular face much like his own. Regulus was beginning to shed most of his childish features; from the delicate cut of his cheekbones to the faintest trace of beard along his chin. His voice, too, had deepened, though it had not yet reached Sirius’s baritone. "Is she all right?"
Sirius clenched his fists, biting the skin of his lower lip. How he wished—how he wished Scarlett were all right! Only then would he feel all right himself.
"I don’t know, Reg." There was honesty in his words. Exhaustion, too. Sirius dragged a hand through his hair, drawing a deep breath as though only now realising he was able to. As though the words alone were enough to release the flow of air in his body. "I don’t know." His voice cracked, though he forced the tears down his throat.
It was Mulciber, Snape and Avery’s fault. That stupid little prank had dragged Scarlett to the bottom of the pit, and they would regret it. Sirius didn’t want to be expelled, but if that was the price for avenging her against the Slytherin trio…
Regulus placed a hand upon his shoulder. Sirius froze, drawing in a sharp breath, eyes widening in surprise as he looked up at him.
"I… I took… Scar’s trunk…" He pulled the object from his pocket, the trunk shrunken to fit in his palm. "If you could give it to her…"
"All right." His answer came out a whisper. Regulus arched his brows, squeezing his shoulder as if trying to draw him back into focus.
"Are you all right?" The question was rhetorical. They both knew it, and even so, Sirius gave a crooked smile and nodded, holding his breath as he clenched his jaw.
"I’ve got to go…" Sirius muttered, taking a step forward, only to stop as he looked back at his brother. A rush of nostalgia struck him with brutal force, and he pressed his lips together, the tears growing ever harder to stifle. "Are you all right?"
Sirius knew the answer was no, even with Regulus’s confirming nod. They were two liars. Two brothers too ashamed to admit what they felt to one another, fearing it might later be used against them. As though their parents still interfered in their bond, as though all they had ever learnt was how to wound one another and not… not to comfort. To listen. To understand.
Before he realised it, Sirius cupped Reggie’s cheek the way he used to when they were children. A time before Hogwarts, before Scarlett, before James or House divides: it was only him and Reg trying to survive in a competitive, hostile home. Despite the terror he endured, Sirius missed those days. He missed seeing Regulus as a part of him, and not as… as a stranger. An opponent. A snake.
The longing fled quickly as he remembered what he had been forced to endure at the hands of Orion and Walburga. The pursuit of perfection that left scars he would carry forever… the demand to embrace an ideology that preached the death of people for something they had never chosen.
Sirius brushed his hands over the back of his thighs instinctively, breaking away from Regulus’s touch as he stepped back, breath hitching when he saw his brother was just as shaken as he was.
He wanted to say everything in his head, wanted to ask so much, wanted to invite him once more to live with him—especially now that he had a house of his own… and yet…
He was carrying too much at that moment, and he couldn’t bear another rejection. Not when the last one was still so raw; the words hammering in his mind, sharp and throbbing.
I’d rather die at Grimmauld Place than live with you!
Sirius brushed past Regulus and continued his descent towards the kitchens.
.
.
.
Peter Pettigrew walked alone through the empty, silent corridors of Hogwarts. Hugging his Astronomy materials to his chest, he descended the staircase from the classroom, glancing constantly over his shoulder in suspicion. It didn’t take long for his fears to be confirmed: Jim Avery had begun tailing him, skulking in the shadows, his cruel smile widening as he realised Peter was on his own.
It was enough to make Peter quicken his pace, taking the steps two at a time. Avery’s long legs easily matched his rhythm, and soon the two of them were running.
Peter darted swiftly towards a stretch of corridor where a highly polished door had materialised on the wall. Without hesitation, he slipped inside—followed by Jim Avery, who laughed as he realised he had just cornered the Gryffindor.
The room that unfolded before them was vast and spacious, lined with stone pillars and worn mirrors along the walls. Peter’s reflection moved within each one, his breath coming fast, eyes brimming as they fixed on Avery when the chase came to an end.
The Slytherin smiled, triumphant.
"You won’t escape me, Pettigrew." He ran a hand through his long, ragged hair.
Peter’s frightened expression shifted so quickly into arrogance that Avery faltered, his heavy, ragged breathing the only sound between them.
"I wasn’t running." Pettigrew smiled as well—and the door behind him slammed shut.
Jim stiffened, his face turning slowly towards the sound, as though his neck had just turned to stone. He swallowed hard when he saw the figure leaning against the door, arms crossed, his features intrinsically arrogant. Sirius Black held his wand between tattooed fingers, and his sharp nose tilted higher as he fixed Avery with his gaze.
The Slytherin had never feared a Gryffindor before. Not until that day. Not until he was caught by the latent fury blazing in Sirius Black’s grey eyes, silver transformed into two incandescent pools of bronze.
.
.
.
Regulus Black had waited the entire week for Scarlett to leave the Gryffindor dormitory. The question she had asked him had haunted him all those days, but by Friday he no longer held any hope she would come out of her rooms. Sirius had said she’d twisted her ankle, so she couldn’t get out of bed, and yet…
That could be resolved with a potion and a spell. Pomfrey could mend her in less than an hour. Sirius knew it, James knew it, and still… they spun excuse after excuse to exempt Scarlett from leaving the dormitory. Not even Dumbledore was pleased with the situation, and Regulus could have sworn he’d heard Thanatos Gaunt grumbling about it in one of that morning’s DADA lessons.
Regulus shifted in his chair, gathering his things as Charms came to an end. Barty, beside him, seemed far too absorbed twirling his quill between his fingers to put his belongings into his bag.
"You do realise that if she doesn’t show up on Monday… she’s out of the team, don’t you?" he finally said, as though reading his thoughts.
"She’ll show up." Reg slung his bag over his shoulder, shoving his hands into the pockets of his trousers. "She’s hurt."
"I mean, I get the whole business of losing her family and all that… but we can’t risk being a player short, you know how competitive Evan is…" Barty shot him a sarcastic little smile. "She’s your responsibility, Reggie, and the Dark Lord would like her recruited this year, if possible."
"I know that." Regulus retorted, austere. "You don’t need to tell me my role. I know very well what must be done."
"Do you, really?" Barty spread a mocking grin, and Reg fixed him with a long, cutting stare, his mouth tightening into a severe line.
"Are you questioning me?" The question came with a disdainful sniff.
Barty’s smile faltered, his upper lip curling before he lowered his head and glanced away in a gesture of surrender.
"No. Just joking." He clapped Regulus on the chest before starting to collect his things from the desk.
Regulus’s heart thundered in his chest, blood rushing so fast through his veins that his body felt numb. He knew it wasn’t a joke, that rumours travelled fast among the Slytherins… that he had lost the power and the control he once held over Scarlett. And it was all Evan’s fault—his stupid idea to tell Sirius about Snape last year!
It had cost him his only friend.
Regulus pulled a crumpled scrap of parchment from his pocket, but tucked it away again as Barty waved for them to leave the classroom. It was easy enough to lose Crouch amidst the throng of students pouring out of lessons, weaving his way between a group of Hufflepuff girls until he reached the Astronomy Tower, climbing the stairs in a rush.
I don’t know. I don’t know who you are. Scarlett’s voice was his only companion that afternoon. Who are you, Regulus?
It was a touch ironic, her asking him that question when she herself harboured demons deep in her heart that only surfaced when she was enraged. The Cruciatus she’d cast on Mulciber was proof enough. Regulus had seen Scarlett react that way before; when Snape attacked Sirius in the Three Broomsticks. If it hadn’t been for him, she would have killed Snape with a Killing Curse.
That, coupled with the rumours that she had stormed into an illegal duelling ring and struck her former boyfriend with a Cruciatus…
Bloody hell, Scarlett was more fit to be a Death Eater than he was.
The thought made his stomach twist.
Regulus veered off course, his head so full he scarcely needed to think before the wooden door appeared in the stone wall. He passed through into the chamber lined with mirrors, seeking one in particular, unlike all the others.
It was a magnificent piece, towering to the ceiling, its gilt-carved frame resting on clawed feet. An inscription was etched across the top: Erised stra ehru oyt ube cafru oyt on wohsi
And there he was, reflected, wearing his placid mask—and at his side, Scarlett embraced him as though he were dearly beloved. She wasn’t the only one there; all of Sirius’s friends surrounded him as if he were their brother: James grinning, his hand on his shoulder, Lupin gazing at him with admiration, and Pettigrew practically revering him. He was Sirius—loved and cherished by his friends. Free of the chains of being a Black. And behind them all, Orion and Walburga looked on with such pride that Regulus knew at once it could only be an illusion. A sweet, soft, and beguiling illusion.
Scarlett kissed his cheek and Regulus touched the spot, as if it were real.
Then, in the depths of the glass, Sirius appeared, standing close by their parents. He did not smile as the others did—on the contrary, the silver of his eyes was laced with envy and hatred.
And was that what Regulus wanted? To make him feel everything he had made Regulus feel?
Regulus glanced over his shoulder, heart pounding in his chest as if there were the slightest chance his brother truly stood there.
There was no one. He was alone, as always.
He turned back to the mirror. Sirius still lingered in the background, watching him coldly, while Scarlett never once spared the elder brother a look. She had eyes only for him. Regulus wet his cracked lips, mouth watering.
That was what he wanted, wasn’t it? To take revenge on Sirius?
He let out a long sigh. That was the danger of illusions. They had no flaw—therefore they were unreal. Fantasies born of petty, selfish desires, created to sate a hunger that would never be satisfied, for they could never become reality.
Regulus deluded himself all the same, even knowing it was wrong, even not truly wishing to cause his brother any harm. The Mirror of Erised revealed only the deepest desire of one’s heart, and yet… it wasn’t truly what Regulus wanted… besides, what harm would there be in taking Sirius’s place? Regulus was already the heir of the House of Black, so why couldn’t he take his friends and his girlfriend too? Why couldn’t he strip Sirius of everything, when his brother hadn’t hesitated to do the same to him?!
If it weren’t for Sirius, he would never have had to do what he had done… he would never… he would never have been their father’s prisoner, he would never…
Regulus bent over, placing his hands on his knees, hyperventilating as though he had just run some exhausting sprint. He needed to tell Sirius. He needed to tell Scarlett. They were in danger. She was in danger.
The prophecy was clear and… and… and he…
Regulus filled his lungs once more, desperation sinking its claws into his throat, thinning his oxygen, scattering his thoughts.
Sirius and Scarlett could not be together.
The door of the Room of Requirement burst open and Regulus recoiled, hiding behind the gilded frame of the Mirror of Erised, narrowing his eyes at whoever had just entered. His heart hammered so fast it felt as though it had stopped.
Sirius shut the door behind him and pressed himself to the wall, standing with his back just beside the entrance, wand in hand. Red’s mouth went dry and his entire body tensed at the possibility Sirius had discovered everything—that his brother had come for him, that he had…
Regulus could scarcely breathe, his hand flying to his mouth to smother any sound, too terrified to notice his brother had no intention of leaving the doorway any time soon. He jolted when the door was flung open again—this time it was Peter Pettigrew who entered, his pudgy reflection multiplying across the countless polished surfaces of the chamber.
And behind him, Jim Avery with a predatory grin.
Regulus glanced about, checking that his own reflection wasn’t visible from where they stood, but the group’s attention was far from noticing him, so he stayed frozen in place.
"You won’t escape me, Pettigrew." Jim’s image swelled across the mirrors, his Slytherin cloak dragging along the stone floor.
"I wasn’t running." Peter’s shrill voice ricocheted through the room.
Regulus took a misstep to the side, turning his face towards the mirrors on the right, where he could see Sirius slamming the door shut and leaning against it with an air of superiority. He had seen that expression before, and his body shuddered as the reflection of the irreverent boy was drowned out by the image of a warped man—a man who would do anything to bring glory to his family.
Sirius looked identical to their father. The cold, piercing eyes, the impassive features, the insolent voice. His whole body tingled. He had been a victim of that Sirius before.
"Remember what you did to Scarlett at the start of the week, Avery?!" Rage laced the icy sparks of Sirius’s tone.
Jim’s naturally disdainful, sneering face shifted into an expression of fear, his eyes darting around as though searching for an escape route. Regulus shrank back, praying Avery would not see him. But, luckily for him, panic got the better of fear.
Jim cleared his throat, regaining his composure, his treacherous lips twisting into a defiant grin.
"It was only a joke, you blood trai—" He had no time to finish, nor to draw his wand. Sirius disarmed him with a sharp flick, silencing him.
Realising he had no more options, Avery straightened and lunged like a bull at Sirius, seizing the Gryffindor round the waist and hurling him with force against the door.
Sirius lost the air in his lungs with the impact, but he knew he had to react the moment he hit the floor. Just as Avery lifted his leg to stamp on him, Sirius, still on the ground, drove a swift, precise kick straight between the Slytherin’s legs. The blow was so fierce that Jim collapsed with a shrill cry of pain.
Taking advantage of the moment, Sirius rolled and sprang to his feet, straightening his uniform before positioning himself behind Jim, shoving him with the sole of his boot and wrenching his left arm back. Avery panted with pain, and Sirius revelled in the sight, hurting him just as much as he had hurt Scarlett.
"Why are you crying? It was only a joke, wasn’t it?!" he asked, sarcastic, savouring the terror that coloured Avery’s eyes the instant he realised the position he was in—the same one he had forced Scarlett into in the changing rooms the year before. The anticipation of what was about to happen made him thrash in desperation.
Sirius shifted his weight onto his heel, pressing him harder against the stone floor, his countless reflections in the mirror accentuating his cruel smile.
"What’s on that arm you don’t want me to see?!" Though the tone was laced with irony, there was a glint of seriousness in his words.
Though he had always considered Jim Avery a threat and a potential Death Eater, Sirius had never imagined he might already be one. With a sharp Diffindo, he slit the sleeve of the Slytherin’s shirt, pushing the fabric aside with the tip of his wand—only to find a black tattoo: a skull, with a serpent slithering from its mouth, staining the pale skin.
The Dark Mark.
Regulus’s eyes widened—just as Sirius’s did.
"Please, Black… I’ll never touch your girlfriend again, I swear, just don’t—"
Regulus clapped a hand over his mouth. Sirius moved like a predator, pressing his heel into Avery’s elbow and, without hesitation, drove his weight down until the arm snapped. The desperate scream tore through the chamber, and Regulus covered his ears, tears spilling down his cheeks as he saw who truly stood behind Jim Avery: the perfect image of Orion Black. All the worn, rotten principles of the Blacks; the brutality, the mercilessness, the cold-bloodedness of a pure-blood.
"Good." Sirius’s voice cut through Avery’s sobbing, deep and dry. Regulus shuddered. "Next time you touch her, Avery, I’ll snap your neck."
Pettigrew shuffled towards Sirius, hunched, as though terrified of being noticed by his friend and becoming the target of his wrath—though his eyes shone with exultation at Jim’s submissive state. Sirius, however, took a few steps back, staring at what he had just done, as though he couldn’t quite grasp the result of letting rage pull the strings of his heart. His gaze swept the room, his breath ragged, his hands unsteady.
Amid the countless reflections in the mirrored walls, Sirius fixed upon one—and froze, mouth half open. Regulus turned his face in the same direction, his eyes meeting his brother’s in the leaden surface.
Crouched, Regulus rose just enough to retreat, shallow breaths spinning his head and scorching his stomach. How could he tell Sirius the truth, when his brother was the monster under the bed? If he did this to Avery over a prank on Scarlett, imagine what he would do to him if he ever found out…
Sirius, too, was crying, moving towards the mirror as if trying to speak, as if trying to erase what had just happened, as if trying to explain what he had just done.
As if he could erase the image Regulus now had of him, as if he could shatter that damned mirror and reforge himself into the man he truly was, the man he wanted his brother to know. The Sirius who wasn’t violent, reckless, or cruel. The Sirius Scarlett had helped him to be, the Sirius who…
Regulus held his gaze, the grey hardening like iron, his tears oxidising into rancour. Sirius stopped, hating how much he looked like his father in the reflection that flickered within Regulus’s pupils.
Then Avery’s groan of pain broke the eye contact, and Sirius wiped his tears away with the sleeve of his cloak, composing himself beneath a façade of calm.
"If you breathe a word of this to anyone, Avery… I’ll tell Dumbledore about your tattoo and you’ll rot in Azkaban." He warned, spun on his heel and left, Peter trailing after him.
Regulus leaned against a pillar, his body sliding down the wall until he collapsed onto the floor once more, trying to plug the holes in his heart that had begun to spill all the despair he had repressed. He pressed his lips together, shut his eyes, and tried to smother any sound as he wept, his whole body trembling violently, the urge to vomit surging and ebbing.
Sirius was a monster… just as he was. That was what the Blacks had always been.
Monsters.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 55: We tried to save each other and ended up condemning ourselves
Chapter Text
CXXIII
The heavy rain hammered against the car’s bodywork, slowing the traffic and turning what should have been an hour’s journey into three. Scarlett was exhausted from constantly braking and accelerating.
"How did you meet my dad?" Harry leaned forward, bracing himself against both the passenger’s and driver’s seats, wedging himself between Scarlett and Sirius.
James, with Lily on his lap beside Harry, poked his head past Scarlett’s seat as though he too wanted to join in the story. Regulus, whose gaze had been fixed on the window, turned to them as well, curious about what Sirius would say.
"On the Express…" Sirius shrugged, as if it were obvious. "When I boarded, I ended up bumping into some scruffy-haired bloke who was staring, in the daftest way possible, at a red-haired girl…"
Sirius steadied himself by gripping the nearest cabin door, the pistons hissing as the train began to move.
"Sorry, sorry!" The boy was still gaping, following the redhead as if hypnotised.
With a disdainful sigh, Sirius went after them, looking for the cabin where his father had left his luggage. To his misfortune—or, as he later considered, his luck—the pair had entered the same compartment. The girl took the best spot by the window, and Sirius sat down beside her, facing the daft one.
"What’s wrong with you? You look as if you’ve been hexed…" Sirius crossed his legs, sprawling over the rest of the seat.
It took the boy a moment to realise Sirius was talking to him, and he gave a nervous laugh as though he’d just been caught doing something wrong.
"What’s wrong with me? Nothing’s wrong with me!" He raked a hand through his hair, making the mess worse. "I bumped into you by accident, I didn’t see you…"
Sirius raised a brow, doubtful of his words, but then a faint smile crossed his lips.
"All right." He glanced at the girl, who had tears in her eyes, before turning back to him. "What’s your name?"
"James. James Potter."
"Sirius Black."
The two shook hands, not knowing that this friendship would change everything.
"Oh my God… you followed me onto the Express?!" Lily stared at James, frowning.
The ghost nodded casually.
"Of course I did! I fell hopelessly in love the moment I saw you…"
Regulus made a disgusted sound.
"Yes, Harry, the girl sitting next to me was your mother…" Sirius went on, the nostalgic smile on his lips melting into melancholy. "Truth be told, I hadn’t really paid her much attention back then… but she sat beside me again, after being Sorted into Gryffindor…"
"And you became friends?!" Harry asked, eager.
"No." Sirius furrowed his brows, moistening his lips. "We only became friends in our last year at Hogwarts…"
"But… but she and my dad…"
"They only started dating in the last year…" Scarlett said, glancing at him through the rear-view mirror. "She hated your dad."
"Hate is a very strong word…" Sirius waved off Scarlett’s words. "If I’m not mistaken, the first time she argued with him, she called him an arrogant toerag…"
"What’s a toerag?" Harry laughed.
"A scoundrel," Lily replied.
"A scoundrel," Scarlett echoed.
"I remember you calling me that!" James furrowed his brows, pushing his glasses up his nose.
"Arrogant toerag," Regulus muttered before bursting into laughter.
"You stuck floating gum in my hair!" Lily defended herself, giving her husband’s arm a smack.
"How did they end up married if she hated my dad?" A frown of confusion creased Harry’s forehead.
Scarlett and Sirius exchanged a glance.
"I don’t know exactly why she hated him, I only joined Hogwarts in sixth year…" She shrugged, tossing the burden to Sirius. "Sirius is the one who knows…"
He huffed, rolling his eyes.
"Nah, she didn’t hate your dad," Sirius retorted, irritated. "She just got cross with him because she was friends with Snivellus." He twisted his nose in disgust.
"Friend is a very strong word." Scarlett gave a dry laugh. "They… tolerated each other, Harry."
Lily no longer smiled. Her eyes dimmed for a moment, as though recalling something so dark that even her radiant nature could not withstand it.
"He became a Death Eater and… well, I suppose they never spoke again." Scarlett turned the wheel, watching the boy through the rear-view. "I met your father because we were neighbours… in Godric’s Hollow." She shifted the subject, glancing at Sirius, whose fists were clenched tight.
If past mistakes were hardly corrected, quarrels and rivalries seemed destined to be eternal. Scarlett had never asked Sirius what had truly happened between him, Snape, and Remus in the Shrieking Shack.
"I lived in Switzerland until my parents decided to help Dumbledore in the war… we moved… and, on the very first day we arrived with the furniture, I met your father. And… I met your godfather as well." She fixed her eyes on Sirius, a shy, tender smile dancing upon her lips.
He brushed his finger along her arm, turning to Harry.
"Your grandparents invited us over to meet the family who’d moved into the house opposite, and your godmo— er, Scar…" He cleared his throat. "She was playing Pink Floyd on the piano."
Harry scratched at his scar, resting his chin on his hands.
"The Muggle band?!"
"Exactly!" Sirius straightened up. "And the first thing I said to her was… Pink Floyd?"
Scarlett shook her head, smiling too.
"So… you lot like Muggle music?" Harry was utterly absorbed in the subject.
"Yes—plenty. Your parents, though…" Sirius shifted in his seat, placing a hand over his chest. "Lily loved Genesis and… Prongs… was obsessed with the Beatles…"
"Reggie mentioned that to me… at Hogwarts…" Harry said, prompting Sirius to go on.
"Your dad loved the Beatles so much he sang to you every single night when he put you to bed…" Sirius’s excitement slowly drained away, the smile on his face fading in intensity. "Every night… without fail…"
Tears shimmered in his eyes, though he didn’t let them fall, pretending instead to study the view out the window.
"Have you got a Beatles tape here? Can I listen?" Harry gripped the backs of their seats, peering at the dashboard.
"No, no tape of them in the car, but… there should be at Sirius’s house," Scarlett said, steering into a parking space.
"Our house," Sirius corrected absent-mindedly.
"Well, either way… we’re here," she announced, twisting the key to turn off the engine.
The rain was still lashing down, streaming through the streets like a river. Scarlett climbed out of the car and hurried to the boot for Harry’s luggage, but Sirius took her trunk from her and gestured for her to head inside.
Harry threw a coat over Hedwig’s cage, and Scarlett turned towards the doorway just as a beam of yellow light cut through the bluish haze of the late afternoon. Regulus was there, his figure casting a long shadow across the pavement, pale eyes hardening, his expression twisting into something Scarlett chose not to decipher as she hurried towards him, arms ready to embrace.
Reg, however, simply turned away and went inside, ignoring her completely. Sirius said something to her and Harry, but all Scarlett could hear was her own breathing, her heart pounding in her chest, the thunder tearing through the sky. She focused on the rain soaking her clothes, drenching her through, trying to gather the courage to break from her stupor.
At last, she forced her legs towards the doorway and found her son sobbing uncontrollably between the sitting room and the hall.
Scarlett never forgot the sharp sting of guilt each time she made the people she loved cry. Every time she hurt them. Sirius haunted her the most of all… but seeing Reggie weeping because of her sent a crushing wave straight into her chest, shattering her in two as though she were made of glass. It was as if the world had begun to spin slower, tipping upside down. A sick lurch seized her stomach, and she drew what little breath she had left to say:
"Reg… I didn’t—"
"I don’t want to hear your excuses!" he cut her off, refusing to look back. "You didn’t come to fetch me at the platform, but you went for Harry?! What the hell’s wrong with you?"
"Reg…"
Regulus stormed into his room and slammed the door, the impact shaking the walls and making the freshly pinned Whitesnake poster on the wood rattle. Scarlett remained there before the closed door, dripping onto the floor until a small puddle formed at her feet. Warm tears mingled with the cold rain on her face.
From the kitchen, Remus, who had been watching, let the air out through his teeth in a hiss.
"Well… that was quick," he muttered.
"Harry… leave your things here…" Sirius’s voice in the background was fading further away.
Scarlett tried to hold back her tears, but soon pressed a hand to her mouth to muffle a sob. She leaned against the doorframe, as though she no longer trusted her own legs to hold her.
The worst part wasn’t Reg’s anger, his resentment, or his outburst. He was right. Scarlett knew he was. The worst part was that now she understood her mother. Not the way she behaved, of course, but she understood what it was to seem as though she hadn’t a clue what to do. And how Scar had searched every corner of the world for her mother’s love, yet could never find it in her own parent. How she had felt hated by Nyx, even knowing her mother had never truly wanted to hate her… that feeling never left her.
The worst part was looking into Regulus’s eyes and seeing herself at that age.
"Teenagers…" Red murmured beside her, his gaze fixed on the Whitesnake poster where a snake struck out. "Are you all right?"
Scarlett didn’t answer. She was too busy tearing herself to pieces.
"Do you remember when we talked at Grimmauld Place about how we’d raise our son, and you… you told me about your mother?" Regulus went on, not caring if he was heard or not. "And you said that… with our son… you’d do everything differently… that you’d do for him what you’d always wished had been done for you."
His words seeped slowly through the fog of her agitated mind. Scarlett glanced sideways at Red, the translucent ghost casting his glow against the dark poster, the malleable iron-grey of his eyes soft in that rare display of affection.
"If it were you in the same situation… what would you want your mother to have done?" He posed his rhetorical question before retreating, leaving Scarlett to reflect alone.
James and Lily were too caught up in Harry chatting pleasantly with Remus and Sirius in the kitchen. From there, Scarlett could hear the echoes of their voices, along with Reggie’s quiet sobbing on the other side of the door.
How many times had she been in the same position as him?
There weren’t enough fingers on her hand to count them.
Scarlett drew a breath, gripped the doorknob, and pushed past her hesitation as she opened the door slowly, confronted with the bedroom that should have belonged to Red.
Regulus had claimed the room with ease; the childhood toys were gone along with the boxes scattered in the corners, the dresser was crammed with assorted cassette tapes and a Walkman lay tossed on the bed, the sideboard still held photos of Scarlett and Sirius, and the wardrobe was now plastered with band stickers and crooked posters. The walls were covered with Slytherin banners.
Sitting on the floor with his head buried between his knees was Reggie, his shoulders shaking. Scarlett closed the door and sat down beside him, unconcerned by the chill seeping into her body from being soaked through. She dared to thread her fingers into his dark, slightly wavy hair, soft as silk. When she felt no resistance, she went on stroking his head. Closing her eyes, she tried to clear her mind, to untangle her words.
"You’ve every right to feel like this." Scarlett drew her legs up, resting her face on her knees as she looked at him, though she couldn’t see his face. "I fucked up… I dropped the ball. I should’ve gone to fetch you with Sirius."
"I don’t want to hear your excuses!" Reg’s voice came out muffled as he curled in tighter.
"You’re going to hear me anyway!" she shot back, firm but tender all the same.
Reg lifted his head just enough to glance at Scarlett from between his knees and his black fringe. She exhaled every bit of air from her lungs, gripping the wet fabric of her trousers tightly as she hugged her legs.
"I had you… in a very dark moment of my life. I don’t like to remember it." Scar sniffled, tears threatening again. "I never… knew you. Truth is, I thought… I thought I was going to die after giving birth… that’s what everyone said. That I’d lost too much blood… that I was going to die. And I wanted to die." She swallowed hard, tears cutting diagonal lines down her face.
Reg lifted his head further, frowning.
"But… I didn’t die. Still, I never had the chance to hold you… to… to see you. I never saw you, Reg. I didn’t know the colour of your hair or the colour of your eyes, whether you looked like me or like your father… and I spent fifteen years in Azkaban driving away any thought of you because I knew that… if I… if I tried to think… I wouldn’t survive it." She clenched her jaw, muscles taut with the effort of forcing out the confession.
"So I settled for the thought that Sirius was taking care of you and that you’d both be happy… but he… I didn’t know he was locked up… and still I avoided thinking of you… and I… I was afraid, Reg. I still am." She wiped her face against her damp trousers, not realising she had begun to shiver from the cold. "I… I don’t know what to do, Reg. You’ve grown into a wonderful boy without my interference in your upbringing and… I’m terrified. Can you forgive me?"
Reg’s devastated expression was so like Sirius’s that Scarlett lost her breath. Yes, he did resemble her—he had her freckles, the faint trace of blue in his eyes, even her nose. And yet… the whole of him was his father’s legacy—the medium lips, the thick lashes, the silvered gleam in his gaze. Even the dimples that appeared when he smiled had been given to him by Sirius! And now, the way his stern expression fractured until it broke… Reggie was very much his father’s son.
Regulus hugged her. Scarlett hadn’t expected the embrace. She gasped in surprise before relaxing and burying her face in his dark hair, wrapping him close, feeling the warmth of her son against the chill of her body. The scent he wore was sweet and refreshing, the same as Sirius’s, though tinged with subtle notes she couldn’t quite place. The fact that he resembled his father so closely tugged her heart clean in two.
Sirius had to know. Reg too. But the last time she had tried to tell them…
"Of course I forgive you, Mum." Reggie’s fragile voice resonated against Scarlett’s ribcage, where his face was pressed. "I’m sorry for saying those things to you!? I was just… hurt."
"It’s all right. You had a good reason." Scarlett kissed his hair, closing her eyes at the unnerving sensation of having her son in her arms. It was as though he were a piece of her, a part of her. Hers and Sirius’s. "I never wanted to hurt you… and I did anyway."
"It’s all right now." He shut his eyes, savouring the caress Scarlett traced along his scalp, focusing on the calm spreading through his body. "Mum… can I ask you something?"
"Mmhm…" she grunted, letting Reggie slip down against her chest until he lay fully in her lap, his face turned up, grey eyes dissecting her.
"Did you love my dad?"
The smile slipped from her face.
"He was my best friend." Scarlett shrugged, biting her lower lip.
"My girlfriend’s my best mate too," he countered, sheepish.
"No, no… I didn’t mean it like that." She let out a long sigh. "I did love him." She twined a strand of Reg’s hair around her finger, the bleached, wet locks sticking to her cheeks and dripping onto his face. "Just not the way he wanted. And not… not the way a woman ought to love her husband."
"Because you loved Sirius?!" The innocence in Reg’s voice was so stark it made Scarlett feel as though she were corrupting her own son by speaking of it.
"I still love him," she whispered, before forcing the air from her lungs. She hadn’t wanted to say it. "I mean, it’s… it’s complicated, Reg." She faltered, shaking her head.
"What happened between you two?" Regulus slipped off her lap and sat down beside her. He was taller than she was, though shorter than Sirius.
Scarlett pressed her lips together, eyes dropping to her soaked boots. Though her memories of Grimmauld Place were somewhat blurred, the summer of ’78 was clear in her mind.
She shuddered. A tremor that had nothing to do with the cold in her body.
"We tried to save each other and… ended up condemning ourselves," she confessed quietly.
Regulus gave a bewildered smile, his brows arching.
"That doesn’t make sense, Mum. I mean… you two… you loved each other…"
Scarlett cupped his sharp chin, then squeezed his cheek.
"Not everything has to make sense, Reg."
.
.
.
Sirius rested his elbows on the marble island in the kitchen, picking at an Exploding Bonbon while Remus and Harry chatted about Harry’s practical exam in DADA, the one he’d taken before Lupin had been sacked. The relaxed way his godson spoke with Remus was entirely different from his stiff body language at the Dursleys’ house.
Here, he gestured and smiled with ease, comfortable being himself in a place he already considered safe, even though it was unfamiliar.
Sirius crushed the sweet’s wrapper in his palm. He knew far too well what it was to feel unwanted in one’s own home, and if it was up to him, Harry would never feel that way again.
It was cruel enough that he lived with a family who didn’t care for him. Crueller still that he’d been so deeply loved by James and Lily, only to grow up… grow up with those stupid Muggles.
The thought made Sirius glance at Remus, who had just slid his shepherd’s pie into the oven. Why had he never been in Harry’s life before becoming a professor at Hogwarts?
That was a question for later, for Scarlett and Reggie entered the kitchen. She was still drenched from the rain, but her face was lit by a smile… whereas her son hurried to greet Harry with a sheepish look.
"Reg, is it all right if Harry sleeps in your room tonight? I still need to work up a spell to add another bedroom…" Sirius suggested, slinging an arm over the boy’s shoulders.
"Yeah, that’s fine." He raked a hand through his hair, eyes darting towards Scarlett, whose gaze kept straying to the door. Her arms were crossed, her face paler than usual. "You’re staying, aren’t you?!"
Scar took a few seconds to realise Reg was talking to her.
"What? Stay here?" Her brows shot up and her lips curved in a forced smile. "Er, I…" Her eyes darted to Sirius, but he only shrugged, refusing to help her find a way out. "I don’t… I don’t know…"
"Please?!" Reggie pressed his hands together as if in prayer. "You can sleep in my bed, I’ll take the sofa and—"
Scarlett fell silent, lips tightening. Merlin, he could be persistent. He’d got that from his father as well.
"Nah, no one’s sleeping on the sofa." Sirius clicked his tongue, drumming his fingers on the pale marble of the island. "Sleep with me and we’ll sort it tomorrow…" he said casually. Scarlett’s eyes widened, and Sirius raised his brows, daring her to say something about it.
She said nothing, heat rising to her cheeks. Sirius swallowed a laugh, and Remus, on the other side of the kitchen, simply shook his head and kept quiet.
"Is that Buckbeak?" Harry dashed through the sitting room, stopping before the wide windows that looked out onto the back garden.
"Yeah, he’s been here since my da— er… since Sirius and my mum escaped…" Regulus followed after him, casting a glance back at the kitchen before going on. "Want to feed him? Penny left some dead moles in the laundry…"
The two of them went out with an umbrella, leaving the sitting room door ajar: the wind howled outside, raindrops pattering against the roof.
"Does Dumbledore know about this?" Remus turned at once to the pair, planting his hands on his hips.
"He doesn’t need to know. Harry’s my godson," Sirius shot back insolently.
Remus’s brow furrowed deeper, his wrinkles standing out harsher than ever. His brown eyes glinted gold for the briefest moment.
"Are you two out of your minds?!" He tried to keep his voice down, though the question was nearly a shout. "You… you can’t…"
"Of course I can, I’ve rights over him!" Sirius’s voice rose, his arms crossing as he let out an exasperated sniff, his gaze veering towards the rain-lashed window.
"You don’t even know if he can be around Scarlett!" He pointed at her, voice ringing. "Sirius… we don’t know if he’s safe here!"
Scarlett lowered her gaze, shifting her weight uneasily at being spoken of like that.
"Why the hell wouldn’t he be?!" Sirius straightened, both hands pressing down on the pale surface of the island. A flash of lightning filled the window, reflecting across the marble counters, the glass of the appliances, and in Remus’s eyes as they darted between him and Scarlett. "Oh no, don’t start that!"
Scarlett blinked rapidly, as though bewildered.
"What the fuck, Lupin?!" she snarled, stepping towards him, but Sirius grabbed her arm as if he knew exactly what she meant to do. "I would never hurt him! Never!"
"You practically kidnapped Harry!" Remus gestured violently towards the sitting room.
"What? Of course not! I got him out of that sick, hostile environment and… and brought him somewhere he’ll be cared for and loved!" Sirius took on a defensive stance, his voice rising as his anger grew. He shoved Scarlett behind him. "Unlike you who… you never did anything for him! Didn’t even… even try to speak to him or… if you hadn’t been a teacher at Hogwarts, you’d never have met Harry!"
Remus’s grey face twisted into a bitter smile heavy with resentment, his scars casting crooked shadows across his wounded features.
"Why do you think I never went after Harry, Sirius?!" Remus made as if to step closer to his friend, but held himself in place. Scarlett backed away, the heated argument seemed to be stealing her breath, and she cracked the window open in search of air. "The Ministry would love a werewolf knocking on the Dursleys’ door so I could make contact with the most famous bloody boy in the wizarding world!" he hissed, dragging his hand harshly down his scars. "I’d have been locked up in a heartbeat!"
"You could’ve written letters, you could’ve—"
Remus slammed his hand against the kitchen island, cutting him off, nose twisted and lips drawn back.
"Everything seems so bloody simple to you, doesn’t it, Sirius?!" he roared, the quiet, observant boy Scarlett had known swallowed whole by the man who had the ground ripped out from beneath him at the very moment Voldemort’s fall was being celebrated. " Just send a letter… just go after Harry…"
A freezing draught swept through the kitchen, and Scarlett’s whole body shuddered at once in an involuntary reaction. Her eyes widened, her hands clenched into fists. She tried to look over her shoulder, tried to see—just to be sure of what was happening—but the cold seeped into her muscles, froze her bones, and strangled her breath.
"Dem… dem… d-d-d-…" She tried to warn them, but the air left her lungs and didn’t return, as though she no longer had control over her own body.
"Don’t give me that excuse of being a werewolf! You were his professor —why did it take you so long to say you were James’s friend?! That you were my friend?!" Sirius bellowed, refusing to back down.
Remus had the answer on the tip of his tongue, but the sight of Scarlett a little behind Sirius, clutching herself and stammering incoherently, disarmed him. He opened and closed his mouth a few times, his expression clearing as he tried to get her attention—but her blue eyes were glazed, her face ashen, her lips trembling.
Sirius glanced to the side, indignation vanishing into alarm as he grabbed Scarlett’s hands—only then realising how deathly cold she was.
"Scarlett? What is it?" He searched her eyes, but her gaze was fixed restlessly on the ceiling, as though something were about to emerge from above, as though— "No, no, you’re safe… there’s no Dementor." Sirius cupped her cold cheeks in both hands and she squeezed her eyes shut, lips tightening as if expecting him to hurt her. "Scarlett… Scarlett… look at me… look at me… I won’t hurt you…"
She tried to pull away, as though Sirius might drain all her happy memories, so he wrapped his arms around her and lifted her, carrying her awkwardly into the bathroom of his bedroom. The moment he set her down, Scarlett doubled over, both hands clutching the toilet as she vomited, coughing desperately for air, her whole body shaking violently.
Sirius held her by the arms and guided her into the shower still clothed, twisting the tap until hot water cascaded down. Scarlett stood there unmoving, the water slipping from her long lashes, dripping across her irises, running down her cheeks, skimming her lips. She was still breathing in ragged bursts as she lifted her head. Closing her eyes, she let the heat soothe her body and dissolve the subconscious reflexes Azkaban had etched into her bones.
Sirius didn’t want to think about how he and Scarlett would cope with the cold once winter came. The year before, in the Shrieking Shack, if she hadn’t shown him there were no Dementors nearby, he’d have fallen into the same state himself…
Scarlett had been drenched from the moment she set foot in the house and still hadn’t dried off. Why hadn’t she? Then again… he too was a little wet and had barely noticed.
For a long while, the only sound between them was the steady rhythm of falling water.
"Are you all right?" he asked, distress flickering in the mercury of his eyes.
She gave a faint nod, still reeling from the shock. Her lips parted as if to say something, then closed again, as though she had changed her mind. The salt of her tears mingled with the sweetness of the shower.
"I’ll get you some dry clothes and—" Sirius abandoned the thought as she began undressing slowly, each movement heavy with effort. "Need a hand?"
Scarlett nodded once more, moving closer to the shower’s edge, a cloud of steam rising around her. Sirius crouched in front of her, unfastening her jeans and easing them down carefully. She shifted to make it easier, and Sirius exhaled sharply at the sight of the bruise on her rounded arse.
Perhaps he had overdone it a bit the night before.
Scarlett glanced back over her shoulder and he cleared his throat, finishing tugging her jeans down and ignoring the near-transparent fabric of her knickers so close to his face. Sirius straightened and couldn’t help but watch as she shed the rest of her underthings, standing completely naked with her back to him.
His gaze travelled up the scars etched across her back, stark beneath the hot water. Her pale skin was slashed with countless marks in chaotic patterns, all starting from the rear of her torso. The circular scars made plain where the Cruciatus had struck, its rays spreading through her body, searing her flesh. Five scars across her left rib, two on the right, a dozen running the length of her spine, more near her hips.
And every single one of them had been cast upon her back.
Lifting his eyes, Sirius noticed the star-shaped glasses on her right shoulder blade, and the constellation of Canis Major just below her nape.
At least she wasn’t only marked by torture.
He thought that realisation might ease him, but instead it was another knife lodged in his chest. He needed to unravel the mystery of what they had done to Scarlett in Azkaban—why, and how. And what they had found, too.
Sirius left Scarlett in the bathroom, and Lily drew near, settling herself on the sink, watching her with those eyes capable of embracing even the most wretched of criminals.
"You need to buy him new clothes," she said, swinging her feet that didn’t reach the floor.
Scarlett ran her hand across the shower glass, clearing the steam so she could see her better.
"For Harry?" she asked softly, fearful Sirius might overhear.
"Exactly! Have you seen the size of the shirt he’s wearing?! And the coat… I’m certain Petunia makes him wear Dudley’s cast-offs! And… and he’s so thin!" She threw her arms wide in outrage.
"Wasn’t James just as thin at his age?" Scar switched off the shower, brushing the excess water from her hair.
"Well… yes… but…" Lily sighed. "Wait until Penny sees him… she’ll have a fit…"
"When did Sirius buy her?" Scarlett wrapped herself in a towel, trying to act as though it were natural, ignoring the fact that only minutes ago she’d thought she was under Dementor attack.
Lily’s calm expression clouded, her head tilting as she thought.
"A little after Effie and Fleamont passed…" she exhaled heavily. "James was devastated. Penny too. She couldn’t cope with the grief while working in our house at Godric’s Hollow, and Sirius needed more and more help and… well, she was very close to Reggie. One of the few things that cheered her. So James asked her opinion about working to look after Reg, and she said she’d very much like that… Sirius bought her. I wanted to free her, but she bit me. I think she was afraid that if we did, we’d send her away."
"She bit you?!" Scarlett frowned, daring a small smile. Penny had looked after Reggie. She needed to thank her for that, even if her heart twisted with the knowledge that… Remus, Orfy, Penny, Nate and Sirius had cared for her son and, when she had finally been given the chance…
She had run.
Scarlett had never imagined she could feel jealous of a house-elf.
But she felt it now.
Penny had had the chance to be with Reggie from the moment he was a newborn and… and she… she hadn’t even…
"I left the clothes at the foot of the bed," Sirius called from the doorway.
Scarlett stepped out of the bathroom, eyeing the The Doors T-shirt that had definitely once belonged to Sirius, along with the shorts and even a pair of boxers. The shirt would drown her — she’d look like Harry in those clothes that could fit three of him inside.
"Can you put it on for him?" Lily had made herself comfortable on the mattress, watching as Scarlett dressed. Her gaze held no malice, nor any amusement. It held guilt, a touch of pity, and worry. "The Beatles tape."
She pulled the shirt over quickly to conceal her scars. She hated receiving that look — it made her feel pitiful, and she was tired of feeling that way. The burn in her stomach was enough every time she looked into the mirror and realised that she… that she was herself.
That Scarlett was Scarlett Gaunt, and there wasn’t a spell, a charm, or an enchantment that could mend that. Nothing that could erase her mistakes and her crimes.
She opened the bathroom drawer, finding Sirius’s hairbrush and a stray polaroid lying face down. Her lips curved at the sight of a one-year-old Reggie in a little romper with the Pink Floyd prism on it. She tucked the photo away and picked up a rather odd-looking device, raising a brow as she studied it under the bathroom light.
"What’s that?" Lily pressed a finger to her delicate chin.
"No idea…" Scarlett plugged it in and the device began to vibrate. "I think it’s a… shaver?!" She immediately propped her foot up on the sink and ran the blade along her leg, gaping as the faint trace of hair vanished at once.
Of course, a simple spell would have rid her of the hair, but using that contraption was far more amusing, so Scarlett did the same to her other shin.
"Think it works on sensitive places too?" Lily’s lips curled in a wicked little smile, and Scarlett only shrugged, putting the device back into the drawer.
"I wouldn’t trust it…" Scar snorted a laugh and nosed through the items on the counter: a bottle of cologne, Sirius’s toothbrush, dental floss… several potion vials either empty or half-used… and a photograph.
A photograph tucked into the corner of the mirror, almost hidden behind the perfume. Scarlett narrowed her eyes, making out a large group of people on a beach.
She didn’t need to look any closer. She dabbed the perfume, brushed through her hair and, taking a deep breath, stepped out of the room to find Sirius and Remus laying the table for dinner. Regulus and Harry were already seated, chatting animatedly about the Quidditch season. James lounged on the sofa, watching his son with a foolish smile, chin propped in his hands. Regulus, on the other hand, observed the dynamic that had sprung up among the four with quiet unease. A wave of déjà vu hit him squarely; he had felt the very same way when visiting their home in Godric’s Hollow, at that dinner where his parents and Sirius…
Scarlett pushed the memory aside with a shake of her head, forcing a smile as she left the room and walked towards them.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 56: Nobody ever loved me like she does
Chapter Text
CXXIV
"Need help?!" She stared at Remus, who stood just a step away. He moved his wand, bringing over the enchanted kitchen utensils, and turned his face to the side, keeping in profile without meeting her eyes.
"No." He muttered curtly before moving away.
"You all right?" Sirius asked softly, positioning himself behind her, his lips nearly brushing her ear.
"Mm-hm." She grunted, stealing a quick glance at Reg and Harry, relaxing her shoulders when she noticed they seemed far too engrossed in talking about the Quidditch matches Harry had won.
"Did you put on my cologne?" Sirius inhaled the sweet fragrance rising from her neck.
Scarlett swallowed hard, intimidated by the presence of that tactile man, whose hands rested loosely on the curve of her waist.
"Mm-hm." She repeated without opening her mouth.
"Smells good on you." He murmured at the base of her ear. "But I prefer the vanilla one." He gave her waist a squeeze before letting go and settling back in his chair at the table.
Scarlett caught herself scratching her Signet, her gaze searching for the bottles of alcohol they used to keep near the fireplace, but that little corner had long since vanished over the years. She wet her lips and sat down beside Sirius, opposite Harry and Reggie, with Remus at the end.
"Help yourselves." Remus handed the spatula to Regulus, grabbing the jug of pumpkin juice and filling every glass in sight.
"What’s that?" Harry pointed to the back of his own hand, looking at Scar.
She lowered her eyes to where the Ouroboros shimmered under the yellowish light, the black scales glistening as though they belonged to a living serpent. Scarlett held out her hand to him, and Harry knelt on his chair to get a better look.
"It’s a Signet, Harry. A blood heirloom of my family. Everyone in it has one."
Harry made to touch it, but stopped halfway as if asking permission. Scarlett nodded. His calloused fingers traced the design of the serpent biting its own tail, rough against the warm, smooth surface of the scales.
"Wow… you’ve got one too?" He looked at Reggie, who pulled his wand from his pocket and cast Finite on the back of his left hand, revealing his Signet.
Scarlett craned her neck to see. She too had never laid eyes on the boy’s mark, and her eyes widened at the sight of the two entwined serpents forming an infinity in the middle, each biting the other’s tail at the ends.
"What does it do?!" Harry lifted his gaze to her, the green eyes identical to Lily’s making her heart skip a beat.
Scarlett looked at her ghosts on the sofa before shaking her head.
"I don’t know. I never found out." She bit the inside of her cheeks, her eyes lingering on the shepherd’s pie that gave off a mouth-watering aroma.
"Want me to serve you, Harry?" Remus changed the subject, taking his plate before giving him a chance to reply. "How big a slice?"
"Er…" Harry blinked rapidly, trying to think. "Not… not too much…"
"Not hungry?!" Despite the friendly smile Remus wore, his tone carried a hint of disappointment.
"No, that’s not it… it’s just… maybe…" He stammered awkwardly.
"Just give him a standard slice!" Sirius stood, personally cutting Harry’s portion. "Bloody Merlin…" He took Scarlett’s plate and served her before sitting back down.
Harry waited for the smallest sign that he could start eating. The first to tuck into the pie was Reggie, followed by Sirius, Remus, and Scarlett. The first two ate with such politeness, yet with such haste, that Harry chuckled. The latter two were cutting bite-sized pieces, as if savouring their last meal.
"Is Penny still working here?" Scarlett glanced sideways at Sirius, who wiped his lips before confirming with a grunt. "I need to talk to her tomorrow… about my clothes."
"Talk what?" Sirius sipped his juice.
"To have her wash my clothes… I’ve work early tomorrow… and a gig in the evening…"
"You’re working tomorrow?" He arched a brow.
Scarlett wrinkled her nose, dropping her fork noisily onto the plate.
"Why wouldn’t I be working tomorrow?" She glared at Sirius, almost eager to hear what answer he would dare give.
Sirius ran his tongue over his teeth and shrugged.
"It’s not as if you need to work…" He remarked offhandedly, stuffing a massive piece of pie into his mouth to shut himself up and stop tightening the noose around his own neck.
"You want me to just not work?!" Scarlett snatched up her cutlery again, clenching it between her fingers. "And who’s meant to support me then? You?!"
The eyes around the table shifted between Sirius and her, all three of them staring at him as though waiting for his comeback.
"All right. Forget I said anything." He surrendered, raising his hands. Scarlett let her shoulders loosen. "But yes, I’d support you without hesitation."
Scarlett snorted a bitter laugh.
"As much as you’d like to, Sirius, we both know I’m not the sort of woman who stays at home looking after the children." She went back to her meal, as though putting the subject to rest.
Remus fixed his gaze on the ceiling as he finished his juice, as if trying to ignore the shitty atmosphere that had settled over the table. The clink of cutlery against plates became the rest of the dinner’s soundtrack.
"What’s a gig?" Reggie broke the silence.
"It’s… it’s a performance, Reg." Scarlett aligned her cutlery neatly on her plate.
"Can I… can I watch?" He shifted in excitement, propping his elbows on the table.
"No…" She spoke without thinking, tugging at her lips when Reg’s eager expression quickly turned desolate. "I mean… I don’t think… it would be safe…"
"What do you perform?" Harry pushed his glasses up the bridge of his nose.
"I play keyboard in a band, Harry." Scarlett smiled tenderly.
"Why wouldn’t it be safe?" Reg adopted his rebellious tone, narrowing his eyes at his mother. "You picked Harry up from his house in a car, which was already risky enough…"
"No one saw us!" Sirius cut in, a little unsettled by his nephew’s attitude. "Why are you acting like this, Reg?"
"Why do you think, Sirius?!" He snapped, scrutinising him with such intensity that Sirius caught his breath, for the boy before him displayed every mannerism of his brother. The steel in the gaze, the contempt in the voice, the arrogance in the bearing.
At the end of the day, Reggie was still Regulus’s son, and the resemblance only grew sharper the more time they spent together. Before Sirius could open his mouth, Remus rose abruptly, scraping the chair loudly against the floor.
"Dessert. Chocolate pudding." He announced, strolling calmly into the kitchen. "Sirius, Scarlett… I need your help."
The two left the table at once, under the watch of the teenagers. Sirius exhaled all the air from his lungs as he stepped into the room, and Scarlett leaned against the island, knowing Remus didn’t need any help at all.
"Since when did Reggie become so… bloody terrifying?!" Sirius pulled a face, a hand pressed to his chest.
"Welcome to adolescence, Sirius. I can assure you, you were much worse at his age." Remus said, serious, though his lips tugged in an ironic smile.
"Could we… not argue our issues in front of them?" Scarlett shot Sirius a withering look.
"What? I didn’t…" He began to defend himself, even knowing he was in the wrong. Then Sirius clenched his jaw, drew a deep breath and conceded. "Fine."
"I’d thank you as well." Remus pulled the pudding from the fridge, stepped towards the sitting room and paused, glancing sideways at the pair. "I suggest you stop arguing anything at all in front of them. And no, that wasn’t a request." The brown of his gaze was flecked with gold as he delivered the sentence.
Remus gave his best smile as he returned to the sitting room. Scarlett carried the small plates, and Sirius the cutlery. The moment they stepped back in, Regulus hooked his arms over the back of his chair and watched them.
"Are you two back together?" The question was direct, clean, and so genuine that, had Scarlett not just been reprimanded by Remus, she would have dropped the plates straight onto the floor.
"No." She murmured without thinking.
"Yes." Sirius said at the same time.
The two of them immediately locked eyes.
"I think they are, they told me in the car they’re a couple…" Harry commented, shifting his attention to the pudding.
"Why don’t I put on some Beatles for you, Harry?!" Scarlett gave Sirius her most innocent smile, stacking the plates on the table with such force that one of them might have cracked. She didn’t care, striding to the cabinet where the record player was kept, chin tilted in an infatuated huff.
Sirius kept silent, opening his mouth only to eat pudding.
She wasn’t surprised to find a Beatles vinyl there, a copy of the Hey Jude album. It must have been from James’s collection, as the sleeve was already rather worn. Scarlett pulled out the record and set it on the turntable, lowering the needle before switching on the equipment.
Despite her distaste for the Beatles being entirely down to Dimitri—even though he’d been dead for over fifteen years—Scarlett could never warm to the band. The revulsion her old boyfriend had stirred in her was so strong that the group was ruined for her forever.
Still, she would endure listening without flinching, if only to please her godson. James was equally delighted, explaining to Regulus who the Beatles were and why, according to him, they were the greatest and best band in the world.
Scarlett gave a sound of disagreement, watching Sirius, Harry, Remus and Reggie caught up in light-hearted conversation at the table. A reluctant smile brushed her lips.
"I can’t believe you never knew your grandparents!" Sirius left the table, scratching his neck. "I’ll fetch something, Harry… back in a sec…" He disappeared down the corridor of the bedrooms.
Remus, Reggie and Harry soon moved to the sofas, where Sirius returned with a pile of albums tucked under his arm. He dropped them onto the coffee table and opened the first one; his easy expression swiftly turned embarrassed and he slammed the album shut with a thud, clutching it to his chest in a sudden movement.
"What was that?!" Harry shot a startled look at his godfather.
"Unless you want to see your godfather starkers, Harry…" Sirius gave a playful grin. Scarlett knew he wasn’t joking, but Harry didn’t seem to notice, too dumbstruck as Remus opened the other album—the wedding album of James and Lily.
"Those were your grandparents, Harry… Fleamont and Euphemia…" Remus kept his expression calm, not without first shooting Sirius a critical look.
"I didn’t remember them being that old." Reggie pressed his lips together, seeming amused.
"They had children quite late… very late…" Sirius explained, freeing one hand from the forbidden album to point at a particular photo, where a baby Regulus sat on Sirius’s lap, dressed in a tiny suit and gazing curiously at the camera. "I… I remember that day…" He furrowed his brows as a laugh slipped out. "Prongs and I went to buy that suit… the shop assistant thought we were a couple trying to dress our son."
"I remember that day too…" James murmured, sat by the fireplace with Lily in his arms. "You make such a lovely couple…" He mimicked the voice of an old lady.
Harry, Reg, and Remus laughed, as did Lily and Regulus. Scarlett moved closer to the sofa, resting her hands on the back so she could look at the photos as well. They turned another page, finding a picture of James and Lily waving, with Sirius holding little Reggie in his arms.
Scarlett felt her heart stretch painfully as she took in the happiness radiating from that moment. She slipped the photo out of the plastic to study it more closely, from Sirius’s jubilant expression to Jily’s beaming smiles. The inscription on the back read: Jily, the best man and the pageboy (who thought the rings were delicious, as he tried to eat them. Luckily, he didn’t have enough teeth for that). It was definitely James who had written it—his messy scrawl was unmistakable.
"Wish I’d been there." She sighed, trying to ease the pressure in her chest as she returned the photo. The smiles of her ghosts had faded, and Harry looked at her as though he wished the same.
"Where were you?" Reggie tried to change the subject, looking at Remus.
"I arrived late, but I was there!" He flipped through a few more pages, landing on a photo of himself singing on stage at the wedding while James and Lily waltzed at the front.
"You sing?!" Harry bounced on the sofa, astonished.
"Well… not much…"
"He sings bloody well." Scarlett cut Remus off, her interest fixed on the album Sirius guarded so fiercely.
"Ah… not really…" Remus waved a hand dismissively, brushing off the subject, though he looked pleased with the compliment. Even if it came from Scarlett.
"May I see?" She touched Sirius’s shoulder, and his face turned towards her. His pointed nose cast a gaunt shadow over his features, his eyes narrowing, lashes thick and curved, shading the suspicion in his silver gaze.
"You know perfectly well what’s in that album!" He shot back, his voice laden with accusation.
Remus, Reggie and Harry slipped into a side conversation, and Scarlett leaned on the back of the sofa, bringing her face closer to Sirius’s.
"Do I?" The question was so genuine it caught him off guard. Sirius raised his brows and handed her the album, albeit reluctantly.
The first page held a photo of herself lying on the bed in what looked like the Undercroft. Scarlett was naked, her breasts stiff and smeared with come that she was trying to lick, even knowing it wasn’t possible. In the picture below, Sirius had one hand in his hair, the other on his cock as he wanked, his star-bright eyes fixed straight on the camera.
It didn’t take much reflection for Scarlett to realise exactly what album it was. She slammed it shut so hard that she drew the sofa’s attention, shooting Sirius an exasperated glare. He only answered with a shameless grin.
"I hate this song." She muttered as a new track began, leaving the album with Sirius as she circled the sofa again, holding out her hand to Reg. "Come on, let’s dance."
"But don’t you hate this song?!" He accepted, though hesitantly.
"Well, yes, but you might make me like it…" Scarlett wrapped her arms around her son’s neck, leading him into the open space of the room.
They began to dance gently, and she took the moment to close her eyes and rest her head on Reggie’s shoulder. He exuded a scent so much like Sirius’s, yet at the same time so different… as though he were a piece of the man she loved entwined with a piece of herself.
Her fingers tangled in the fine, straight hair at his nape, the soft down along his strong jawline, the loose lobe of his ear. She felt her son’s racing heartbeat, the tension thrumming in his body as if he were trying to follow the music perfectly. As if he were afraid of disappointing her.
Scarlett wanted so badly to say the only disappointment there was her. They twirled through the room, and her gaze found Sirius, seated directly in her line of sight, taking a sip of his pumpkin juice, watching her over the rim of the glass with a searing look. Searing and wounded.
I always wanted our son to be named Sirius. But you gave my name to his son. To your son with him. I knew you were vengeful, Scarlett. But cruel? Why? You knew that… that was my dream. My dream. And you and Regulus stole it from me…
Her eyes brimmed with tears. Scarlett tilted her head back, letting the light play across the restrained weeping. Since fleeing Azkaban, she had felt constantly vulnerable in Sirius’s presence. To pull away from him was a balm for her insecurities, but Reggie… Reggie was the very embodiment of all her open wounds, her mistakes, her sins.
It was because of him that she had done what she had done. Because of him that Sirius hated her. Because of him that Sirius would never forgive her. And yet, all she could feel for him was something so tender and warm, so unlike the turbulent bond she and Sirius had always shared… it was a different kind of love, gentle, free of ties and obligations. But… at the same time… there was a reluctance there. Reggie was part of her—at least he had been part of her during those few months she had been pregnant. Scarlett despised herself; wouldn’t it be logical to despise him as well?
And yet… how could she possibly hate that boy with needy eyes and a craving for acceptance?
He was such a believable blend of her and Sirius that it was easy to see herself in the blue of his eyes, just as she saw Sirius in the silver of his gaze. And although she and Sirius had made every wrong choice in life… Scarlett was grateful that Reggie was alive. That he was there, with her, dancing to that ridiculous Beatles song. For… for being such a loving, affectionate boy. There was Sirius’s influence in him—of course there was—but she knew it wasn’t only because of him that Reg was that way.
Scarlett spun once more with Regulus, coming to a halt where she had a clear view of Remus. His expression, impenetrable and marked by scars, was thrown into sharp relief by the yellowish light of the room. She longed to thank him for everything he had done… but didn’t know how. He despised her—and she understood the feeling—but still… it had been he who had cared for her son in the years that followed. She didn’t need to be told it outright; the way Reg looked at him, with admiration and respect, was proof enough.
She brushed those thoughts aside as she closed her eyes again, focusing instead on Reggie’s fingers stroking gently across her back, banishing every one of her demons with a single touch. On the way his steps were clumsy, and the way his chest tightened when he smiled, glancing towards the conversation between Sirius, Remus and Harry on the sofa.
Scarlett didn’t know how much time had passed, but she opened her eyes when she felt movement at her back. She found Sirius standing beside them.
"May I?" There was gentleness in his question. Melancholy too.
"Of course." A shy smile crossed Reg’s lips as he slowly disentangled himself from Scarlett, meeting her with his grey-blue eyes. "And now? Hate the Beatles a bit less?" he teased, stepping away.
"Only a little…" Scarlett gestured with thumb and forefinger, just before Sirius took her son’s place, sliding his hand with confidence around her waist, pressing their bodies together and filling her core with that familiar sense of safety one can only feel with the person one loves.
With her other half, her man, her home.
[The Beatles — Don’t Let Me Down]
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Their gazes met in the midst of remorse and rancour, of sorrow and bitterness. Scarlett wound an arm around Sirius’s shoulders, and with her free hand entwined her fingers with his, clutching the rough, ring-laden hand as they swayed through the room. Immersed in the star-bright eyes, Scarlett allowed the tears pricking her eyes to fall, tracing a pale path across the freckles of her cheeks.
"Why are you crying?" Sirius’s voice barely came out. It didn’t need to.
"I never wanted… never wanted to hurt you." Scarlett whispered, bitter. "When… when I gave Reg your name, even drugged up… it wasn’t to steal your dream, Sirius… but to make it real."
Nobody ever loved me like she does
Oh, she does, yeah, she does
And if somebody loved me like she does
Oh, she does, yes, she does
Sirius’s irises turned golden as he stopped beneath the chandelier, drinking in the image of Scarlett into the void of his dark pupils. Then they vanished as Sirius sank into the darkness of his own eyelids, nodding as he swallowed hard. Digesting her words, letting them seep into his skin.
"He…" His lower lip trembled. "He’s not my son, Scar."
Scarlett ignored the dizzying wave that seized her.
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
"He’s as good as…" Her voice was choked by the magic of the pact. "He looks at you… as if…" She cleared her throat, fighting the tightness. "You told me that… that he called you Dad… when he was little…"
"He’s not a child any more." Sirius hissed, harsh, even though he longed to accept what Scarlett was offering. Even though he had already accepted it, deep down… Reggie’s resemblance to Regulus terrified him. Not just the mannerisms and appearance, but…
I’m in love for the first time
Don’t you know it’s gonna last
It’s a love that lasts forever
It’s a love that has no past
It was as though his brother’s presence still lingered, tormenting him, constantly reminding him of what had been stolen. Scarlett, Reg, and the twelve years they could have had together.
He wanted Reggie to be his son; he would do anything for it to be so.
But he wasn’t. His brother had won. Even dead, Regulus always seemed to win. Even with his brother gone, Sirius still felt betrayed by him. By Scarlett too, but especially by Regulus.
He knew Scarlett was his weakness, and Reg had stolen her with such ease that…
He clenched his fists.
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
"I need to talk to you." He said, blinking slowly as he opened his eyes, met by Scarlett’s oceanic irises, blue and dense. Tinged with the luminescent glow of the chandelier, lights that marked a path across open sea. Safe or perilous? Sirius wasn’t sure he wanted to find out. "But not now… later."
"About what?" Scarlett didn’t hesitate, meeting his gaze with equal intensity.
"About the past. Grimmauld Place… Regulus… Voldemort."
He felt Scarlett falter in his arms, her gaze turning stormy, throat constricting, muscles tensing.
And from the first time
That she really done me
Oh, she done me, she done me good
I guess nobody ever really done me
Oh, she done me, she done me good
"But not now…" He tried to soothe her, even knowing it was already too late. "I mean… huh, I need to ask you something. When we… we…" Sirius felt his heartbeat quicken. "When we shagged… the first time… I didn’t use any contraceptive charm and…"
"I didn’t get pregnant, if that’s what you’re asking." Scarlett murmured, a faint blush colouring her cheeks.
Sirius nodded, released the breath from his lungs and lost himself in his own tribulations. The silence stretched, but not uncomfortably. They were intimate enough to give each other space—and Scarlett felt an inexplicable closeness whenever they were like this, holding one another’s gaze, encompassed in each other’s presence, safe enough to ponder thorny matters.
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
Don’t let me down
"I know about your pact." He revealed, their shadow sliding across the dark carpet.
Scarlett’s eyes widened, and she wanted to push him away, but for some reason pulled him closer instead, letting their breaths mingle, the air laced with Sirius’s hungry exhalations flooding her lungs. He held her gaze, arching his brows in surprise at her reaction.
"What are you talking about?" She demanded, her eyes veiled by that layer of coldness Sirius knew too well.
"The day you fainted, Penny saw…" Sirius cleared his throat. "…that you’ve two blood pacts. One with me. Another with my family."
Scarlett stopped dancing, loosening her hold around him.
Sirius knew.
"Penny… saw?" she repeated, stunned. "What do you mean!?"
Sirius blinked several times, shaking his head.
"I’ve been researching and, apparently, house-elves perceive magic differently. Some wizards can see it too in particular cases and…"
"You know what pact I made with y—" Scarlett cut him off, but the words stuck, an invisible cord strangling her voice.
"I know what you did." Sirius caught her every reaction with fervour. "I know he tried to kill you that night… because you broke it."
Her heart clenched at the possibility of Sirius uncovering the truth and breaking the pact. It pounded so madly that Scarlett could feel it in her throat, in her arms, in her tendons… as though determined to burst from her chest.
She opened her mouth to say he could destroy it, that all he needed was to know the truth, but nothing spilled from her lips save a ragged gasp. Scarlett flared her nostrils in search of air, drowning in her own breath as she tried to speak to Sirius, as she tried to…
"Scarlett… stop." He whispered, cupping her face with both hands, though it was a command. "Scarlett!"
Pressing her lips together, Scarlett shut her eyes and gave up, as the magic clanging against the walls of her mind seemed ready to crush her skull. Yet there was something else there too. Another pact demanding dominance, its coloured cords weaving through the grey strand that insisted on silencing her, driving out the suffocating pressure with a warm, glowing wave, with a magic that set her chest alight and her body shivering, born of the feeling that surged from her very core and purged the effects of the promise she had made to Orion Black.
Scarlett lifted her lids to find Sirius’s eyes already open; piercing her, overturning her, binding her to those starry irises. She was dazed to realise the tether thrumming in her heart, beating and vivid as though fed by the organ itself, yet floating outward, tying her to another heart, another core… another soul.
"We’ve a pact as well." Sirius murmured, his words slipping across Scarlett’s lips with the closeness of their faces. "I feel it too… that thing… pulling me… drawing me to you… whenever we’re near…"
"Do we?" Scarlett’s voice came as a whisper, but Sirius knew exactly what she had said.
"We do… I reckon it was the night of the ball… our first time…"
Scarlett didn’t need to search her mind to summon Sirius’s words from that day to the surface of her thoughts.
"I want you… not just in the carnal way. I don’t just want to kiss you and shag you. I want your heart, I want your body, I want your presence. Your soul. I want the Scarlett you refuse to show. I want your traumas and your nightmares. I want every part of you… every piece, every fracture, every fear. I want your virginity and your depravity. Your tears and your moans. Say you’ll be mine, Scar… and I’ll be yours."
The cords tightened round Scarlett’s heart as the voices resounded in her mind.
You are mine… and I am yours.
With her mouth dry, she tried to ease the pressure in her chest even as she clung to Sirius as though her very life depended on it.
Mine, his voice echoed. Mine, mine, mine, mine, mine!
"Mine." Sirius whispered, as though he could hear her mind. "Yours."
"Mine." She agreed, the heat of Sirius’s presence spreading through her body. "Yours."
He brushed his nose against hers, intoxicated by the strange and mysterious phenomenon.
"So… does this mean that… that we…"
"We’re bound to each other." Sirius drew his lips close to Scarlett’s ear. "That’s why… why I can’t let you go…" A bitter, humourless laugh escaped his mouth. "Because of this bloody magic that… that you’re here. That we… that we’re together."
Scarlett smiled too, but with nostalgia and a trace of distress.
"And what is love, Sirius, if not magic?" Her fingers reached for his bearded chin, blue meeting silver, the tug in her heart wavering until it eased into a frothing, effervescent wave. "Do you want… to break it?"
The question was laden with hesitation. Scarlett didn’t want to know the answer, but she didn’t want Sirius chained to her either. She didn’t deserve that love, nor that man. She wasn’t worthy of happiness, no matter that she had agreed to at least try for his sake… it was far too heavy to keep bearing the weight that pressed on her shoulders every day. The crimes that marked her forever.
"I don’t… don’t know. I don’t know how to do that. I don’t know if I want to." Sirius confessed. Though the thought of Scarlett being bound to him too was somewhat pleasing, even knowing it was wrong, he disliked feeling chained to her. Not when he already felt so much that way.
Scarlett nodded slowly.
"I don’t think it’s fair. You deserve better than me." She gradually pulled herself away from him, taking advantage of Sirius’s stunned state at her reply.
She still didn’t know what to do with the discovery that she had made yet another pact in her life, even unconsciously. She didn’t know what to think… or what to feel.
"Mum!" Regulus’s call left her dazed for a few seconds, as though the world she and Sirius had been absorbed in was split in two.
She stumbled back, putting a safe distance between herself and Sirius without him resisting. In truth, he did nothing at all. There was nothing to be done. Scarlett had indirectly said she loved him, only to dismiss him straight after with her pathetic self-pity. He clenched his jaw, exasperated with her hypocritical ways. One moment everything was fine, and the next she simply…
Fuck, she simply acted as though there was nothing between them.
"I want to show you my tapes!" Regulus grabbed her hand, unaware of the electrified atmosphere between his parents. "Oh, Harry, bring your things to the room…" He waved to his friend.
Scarlett was practically carried off by her son to his room, once again. Her mind was still in turmoil when Reggie opened a drawer and pulled out a bundle of tapes, showing off a collection that her teenage self would have gone into raptures over. In that moment, though… all she could think of were the times she had felt that magic calling her to Sirius.
At the trial, for instance. Or… when she and a handful of Death Eaters had been part of a trap for the Order members… where Fabian and Gideon were killed. That was how she found Sirius, how she saved him, how she…
She barely realised her hand had gone to her chest, as though hoping to touch that thread, as if…
"Mum?" Regulus was watching her with those ever-shifting eyes, now blue, now silver, now leaden grey.
"Sorry, Reg, it’s just…" She huffed. "…you look so much like me at your age."
"Really?" He broke into a grin full of perfect teeth, as if the comparison were an honour. "What were your favourite bands? Besides Toto, ‘cause I already know that one…"
"Hmm…" Scar pressed her lips together in thought. "Pink Floyd. Queen… Rush! Fleetwood Mac… Rainbow… The Doors… Bowie, of course, Led Zeppelin…"
"Why don’t you like the Beatles?" It was Harry who asked, sitting on the edge of Reg’s bed as he looked over the collection. "Aren’t they, like, super famous?"
Scarlett let her gaze drift to her best friend’s son, the smile lingering on her lips even as memories of Dimitri bubbled up in her mind.
She told them about her time studying at Durmstrang, before Hogwarts, about her friends back then and how the systems between the schools were different. She explained about the Clans and how competition was far more intense, especially among members of the same Clan. Then, when the subject turned to Dimitri…
"He was my greatest rival. We ended up falling in love and… we loved listening to the Beatles together. They were his favourite band. Until… he hurt me, I was expelled from Durmstrang and… that’s how I ended up at Hogwarts." She shrugged.
"You were expelled?!" Reg frowned, and Harry adjusted his glasses on his face.
"I thought Orfy had told you that…"
"Who’s Orfy?!" Harry scrunched his nose, ruffling his already messy hair while his parents looked at him fondly from the other side of the room.
"My brother." She clarified, turning back to her son.
"What did you do to—"
"Right, that’s enough, time for bed." Sirius cut across, taking charge of the situation. "Scar and Moony have work early tomorrow, and we’re going to the arcade at the shopping centre… ever been to one before, Harry?"
"Huh… no." He dropped his gaze, embarrassed.
"You’ll love it. We need to buy your ring and…"
"Ring?" Scarlett looked at Sirius, raising her brows.
"Yes! Reggie’s in a proper relationship!" He rolled his eyes as though stating the obvious, pointing at his nephew, whose cheeks were flushed as his eyes darted across the posters on the wall as if he wanted to disappear.
"I can meet you at the shopping centre then." Scarlett didn’t let any reaction from her son escape her notice, nor Harry’s, who was eyeing him curiously.
Sirius flicked his wand, conjuring Harry’s bed into an empty space, dragging his nephew’s trunk beside it and setting the owl’s cage in a corner.
"That’s that then, good night, see you tomorrow!" He grabbed Scarlett’s wrist and pulled her out of the room in a sudden motion, shutting the door before she had the chance to say goodbye.
"What are you doing?!" She protested, yanking herself free. "I didn’t even—"
"Forcing the two of them to become friends!" Sirius folded his arms, blowing out a breath.
"They’re already friends." Remus replied from the sitting room.
"Not enough!" Sirius turned back to Scarlett, and as though looking at her were some sort of crime, he ducked his head and strode past her into his room, slamming the bathroom door behind him.
Scarlett stood motionless for a moment at the entrance, bewildered. Everything was still so new to her—but not in a bad way. She liked it. She liked how different was turning out to be good, how having her son and Harry so close was far less frightening than she’d thought, while being in the presence of Sirius and Remus made her nervous. They had too much history together, and they seemed a mixture bound to… explode, sooner or later.
She stepped into the room that had once been hers and Sirius’s. Where they had slept together and shared their dreams, where they had comforted and hurt one another. Scarlett rubbed at her Signet on the back of her hand incessantly, trying not to dwell on everything that had happened that day. Trying to hold on to the lightness filling her body, even with Sirius only a few steps away.
"Sirius…" She called, as he emerged from the bathroom wearing nothing but black boxer briefs.
Star-bright irises fixed on her, slowly anchoring into her own with an unusual reluctance. It was almost as though he were avoiding her, and Scarlett wondered if he was regretting the proposal he had made.
"I can sleep on the sofa as Whiskers."
"It’s fine, you can sleep here." He said grudgingly, casting a charm to dry his black hair, which now fell past his elbows.
It was impossible for Scarlett not to map every mark on Sirius in that moment. His torso was covered in tattoos, from runes to band crests, an all-too-obvious homage to the Marauders running down his right bicep, to the phases of the moon trailing across his left scapula. When he turned his back, every muscular movement emphasised the tattoos etched into his marble skin.
Scarlett didn’t know all of them, but one made her smile unconsciously the instant he leaned over the bathroom sink to brush his teeth: the constellation of Sagittarius just below his nape, half-hidden by the black hair. The dancing strawberry on his right shoulder blade. Toto’s sword on his left hand, and further up on his forearm the birth dates of Reg and Harry…
Sirius Black was a work of art unlike any other, and it was impossible not to admire him. Scarlett lost herself in the way the light played across his skin, over the defined muscles flexing each time he moved his arms, each time he walked, each time he breathed. Since the last time she had seen him bare, Sirius had gained both weight and muscle, though he still remained lean.
He was so beautiful. So beautiful it hurt. Hurt to know that man could never be hers again, no matter how much she longed, no matter how much she desired… fuck, she couldn’t…
She couldn’t hurt him again, she couldn’t…
"Thank you for not giving up on me… even… even when I had already given up." Her lips moved of their own accord.
Sirius stopped dead, as if struck by a Stunning Spell.
"Thank the pact, not me." The reply came dry, caustic. He stared at her through the blurred reflection of the mirror.
"It wasn’t because of the pact." She contradicted him firmly. "If it were that powerful, I’d never have been able to leave, you’d never have hurt me and… we… we’d never have split apart."
Sirius dried his beard in silence, as though unwilling to admit defeat.
"I’ve been where you are…" he said at last, stepping out of the bathroom without meeting her eyes. "We both need forgiveness."
Scarlett nibbled her lower lip, following him with her gaze. Sirius sat on the other side of the bed, his back to her, both hands gripping the edge, head bowed, until he turned his face slightly. His eyes, however, stayed fixed on some indefinite point on the bed.
"Why? Why are you doing all this for me?" she pressed on, and the question seemed to catch him off guard. His shoulders stiffened, and he glanced at her from the corner of his eyes.
"Because back then you looked at the arrogant boy who broke your heart, who made you cry…" He drew a long breath. "…and you showed him that love is the rainbow, not the storm."
Her lips parted in astonishment. She wanted to continue the subject, but Sirius lay down on the bed and extinguished the light, darkness swallowing the room so quickly she had no time to react.
The only glow came from a single window left bare of blinds, spilling leaden rays across the foot of the bed, casting over the white sheet and turning her and Sirius into almost ethereal figures, as if they were ghosts.
His black hair fell over the pale pillow like a reflection of the night sky. He kept his back to her, covering himself with the sheet, his shoulder rising and falling with each breath.
"Good night." Sirius murmured, though he hadn’t closed his eyes, not even ready for sleep. In truth, he doubted he would sleep, even feeling exhausted—exhausted by Scarlett and all the variables she contained. Tired of her indecision, her fears, the way she was too busy pitying herself.
What surprised him was that the weight pressing onto the mattress wasn’t a woman’s. A little black-and-white cat padded carefully across the sheet, kneading a particular spot before circling and curling up, purring, her tail brushing along his back.
Glancing over his shoulder, Sirius saw Whiskers lying with her back to him, tail stretched far enough to reach him. He felt a slow smile spread across his face, focusing on the calm tingling that dispersed through his body, steadying his racing heartbeat and soothing that poisoned thing coiled in his chest.
Resisting the urge to transform the cat back, to pin Scarlett beneath his body and shout at her to stop punishing herself, Sirius curled in on the bed. As much as he longed to show her what their love should have been, and though he yearned to have her in every possible way, to make certain she was his, his alone, for all eternity… there was still too much unresolved between them.
And those thorns were embedded so deeply in his heart they were hard to reach, harder still to tear out. However much he wished to live with her, to be a family…
He wondered if his decision to persist with Scarlett was because he truly wanted to help her, or merely a whim of his own petty ego.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 57: I love you, but I’m afraid to love you
Chapter Text
CXXV
"So… the basilisk thing… it really was… Voldemort?" The mention of the Dark Lord made Harry stiffen. Regulus shoved a handful of Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans into his mouth before raising his brows, waiting for an answer.
"It was… he used Ginny Weasley to carry out the basilisk attacks…" Harry stared at the packets of Sugar Quills scattered across his bed. "You know, the youngest Weasley daughter…"
"I only met her this year…" Regulus shrugged, crossing his legs. "Is it true you killed the basilisk?!"
Harry hesitated to answer, and at the same time felt such an irrational fear of being sent back to the Dursleys’ that he replied to all of Reg’s questions about the matter. For about fifteen minutes he spoke of everything that had happened on that fateful night: the invisible voice he heard through the pipes (and Reg admitted he sometimes heard it too), how Hermione finally realised he was hearing a basilisk in the plumbing; how he and Ron had followed the spiders into the forest, that Aragog had revealed where the basilisk’s last victim had died; how they had guessed that Moaning Myrtle had been that victim, and that the entrance to the Chamber of Secrets might be in the girls’ bathroom…
"Wait—Myrtle was killed by it?!" Reggie burst into laughter behind his hand. "And I thought I was the one doing illegal things in this school…"
Harry laughed, abashed. With his voice hoarse from so much talking, he went on about Tom Riddle’s memory from the diary, the providential arrival of Fawkes and of the Sorting Hat with the sword inside. Reg listened intently, holding a jelly bean without even raising it to his mouth, so caught up was he in the tale.
It was rather hard to believe all of it, but for some reason, Reggie knew Harry wasn’t lying. He couldn’t tell if it was a Gryffindor trait or if he simply had a soft spot for the boy because of the faint memories from when they were children, but in the end he was left gaping—and Harry, blushing.
And not only him. James, Lily, and Red were in the room too, exchanging glances when the story came to an end.
"He knows." It was the first thing she said, shivering in her husband’s arms. "Voldemort knows about my protection… Harry told him…"
"And what’s he going to do with that?! He’s dead…"
"For now." Red cut James off, taciturn. "That diary… with memories…" He let out his breath with a hiss. "It was a Horcrux as well."
"How can you be so sure?!" James tried to calm Lily, holding her tightly.
"He possessed the Weasley girl. Horcruxes are a fragment of a soul, and they have the ability to think and to influence whoever has them in their possession. That fragment of Voldemort’s soul fed on her all that time, and if it hadn’t been for Harry…" Regulus fell silent as he noticed something else strange in the story.
Harry was a Parselmouth. James and Lily were not, though Regulus wasn’t certain. He had seen Scarlett speak the strange snake-tongue before. Why did Harry speak it too? It made no sense.
His gaze lingered on the boy, who was laughing with Reggie about his Quidditch exploits that year, utterly embarrassed by the praise he was getting. Red drew nearer to the two, leaving James to deal with Lily’s distress. He stopped between the boys, staring at Harry’s face, studying the lightning-shaped scar.
The sniff he gave was full of perplexity. Voldemort hadn’t created only two Horcruxes… and not all of them were inanimate objects. The stunned expression never left his face as he rose, pulling away from the two and drifting through the wall of the bedroom, finding Remus in the sitting room, lost in his own thoughts.
He hurried out to the back garden, where Buckbeak was resting beneath the weeping willow. Regulus sat on one of the loungers and buried his face in his hands, wishing to scream as loud as he could, though he stayed silent.
Though dead, his heart hammered so fast it felt as if it might kill him a second time.
Harry Potter was a Horcrux.
Harry Potter was a Horcrux, and Voldemort would never be defeated.
Now, the prophecy about Reggie made perfect sense.
.
.
.
After all those days falling asleep with a good dose of alcohol in her blood, it was clear Scarlett wouldn’t be able to sleep, even in Whiskers’s skin. She knew nightmares would come, and though it was impossible to escape them for long, she still wanted to avoid them. She swivelled her ears to the side and glanced at Sirius, who lay with his back to her. Then she decided to slip out of bed quietly.
"Still awake?" Sirius’s drowsy voice made her shiver and give a little jump, turning her muzzle back as she saw him roll over in bed to face her.
The cat stretched and became a woman again.
"Sorry. I didn’t mean to wake you." Scarlett tucked the stray strands of hair behind her ears, hugging her knees to her chest.
Sirius scratched his nose, propped his elbow on the pillow and rested his chin in his palm.
"I wasn’t sleeping." He admitted, his handsome, sculpted face taking on an ambiguous expression in the half-light, which accentuated his aristocratic features. "I was… thinking."
Scarlett longed to fill her body with alcohol until she could barely stand, but she couldn’t leave the bed under Sirius’s petrifying gaze, his pupils glinting, enigmatic, in the night’s shadows.
"What were you thinking about?" she whispered, her throat dry.
Sirius turned his face upwards, to the tiny stars glimmering on the bedroom ceiling, as though trying to reach for a point as distant as those heavenly bodies in the universe.
"Don’t you ever feel lonely?" He tilted his face towards her. "Even… even when you’re surrounded by people?"
Scarlett closed her eyes and nodded, a smile that was a smile in form only curving her lips. The night had cast a bluish light across her eyelids, revealing the reddish-brown tint of her dark lashes and brushing over the freckles on her face.
"I’ve grown used to it. Since Azkaban… after spending fifteen years of my adult life steeped in absolute misery and in the most piercing solitude…" She shrugged. "What was it you once said about me? That if I don’t suffer, I don’t exist? That’s basically it." The irony in her words did not make Sirius laugh.
Quite the opposite. His eyes brimmed with concern.
"I know how you feel." Sirius admitted with sorrow. The shadow dimming the silver of his gaze was as heavy as his memories. "In Azkaban… there were nights when… when all I wanted was to be enveloped by the cold… and by the stupor of death. But… at the same time I… I couldn’t accept it. I couldn’t… it wasn’t fair. I was innocent and…"
The air left his lungs and he dragged a hand down his face, his fingers brushing over his own beard.
"You only truly discover loneliness in Azkaban." Scarlett finished, a sad smile touching her lips. "I had never felt that way before being imprisoned."
Sirius raised his brows slightly, his black hair soaking in the darkness of the room and falling over his shoulders like the River Styx, his silver irises shining with a sincerity laden with intent.
"Never? Not even when we were at Hogwarts… after you lost your parents?" Sirius’s hoarse voice carried a gentleness that only such a moment of exposure could reveal.
Scarlett’s blue eyes lifted back to his face, her dilated pupil dragging him into the unknown fissures of the abyss he knew all too well. Fifteen years had cracked those eyes in a way that unsettled him, and every fracture revealed the fragile side of the girl he had loved — and hated — with all his heart.
"I was angry… I was grieving. I didn’t know how to handle everything I was feeling… my moods were a rollercoaster that left me unbalanced… but none of those feelings was loneliness." She lifted her shoulders. "I never feel alone when I’m with you."
The sentence dragged Sirius violently into those blue eyes that were his favourite mirror. They didn’t only reflect his image; when they looked at each other that way, stripped of masks and lies, he could see Scarlett’s soul with absolute clarity. Even with some pieces missing, even with her reluctance and her habit of self-flagellation… the mere glimpse of the core of the woman he loved intoxicated him so completely he lost his breath.
"I felt alone during that month we spent apart. Alone and on edge." She licked her lips, blinking slowly. It was time to untangle the knot weighing on her chest and suffocating her heart. "I have to keep reminding myself to breathe. I have to remind myself that… I won’t be imprisoned again, that things aren’t going to go wrong, that… I won’t be swallowed by… by what I did. That no one is looking for me because I’m dead, and if they are, they won’t find me because my disguise is too good, and if they do find me…" Scarlett hissed, her breath sending stray strands of hair upwards. She ground her teeth, as if trying to contain everything that tormented her. "I have to remind myself that no one will hurt me, or that I won’t be forced to hurt anyone… which is so hard… the past will always haunt me."
"Scar…" Sirius whispered her name, but she didn’t stop.
"My crimes… will never be erased, and what I did… everything I did is stained on my soul forever. I can feel the void left by the deaths I caused and… I… I don’t deserve this, Sirius. A family. I betrayed you, I killed the McKinnons, Orfy is the way he is… I don’t want… I don’t want… you all to suffer because of me…"
"You’re not what you’ve done." Sirius replied softly. It was as though even he didn’t believe his own words. The calm ocean of Scarlett’s eyes was troubled by a storm, churning the dark filaments of her irises and engulfing her in that despair which infuriated him deeply, for it made her treat him as though he were a stranger.
And Sirius could be many things to Scarlett, but— unfortunately —none of them was a stranger.
"Of course I am! I’m a traitor. A murderer. I’m not worthy of a family, of love… of happiness. I’m a bad person, and bad things happen to bad people, and I want to protect you from that… all of you from that… you’re good, Sirius…" Her eyes wandered about the room, as if searching for something, an anchor or a lifeline either to drown her or to save her from her own torment.
"I’m good… and yet bad things happened in my life and yours long before Azkaban, Scarlett. You were good, and still…"
"I was! I was, but… it wasn’t enough, Sirius. It wasn’t enough. But you’re good! You’re… generous and… kind. You’re good and you deserve good things…" She faltered, slipping far from reality, digging her fingers into her scalp and tugging her hair hard.
It was frightening to witness how quickly Scarlett could unravel into a babbling, distressed storm. How much more vulnerable she was than she appeared, unstable and tearful, almost like a defenceless little girl.
Sirius sat on the bed with the intention of moving closer to her, but stayed put.
"Do you know how I know you’re not a bad person, Scar?"
Scarlett rubbed at her eyes, staring at him even though she wasn’t sure she wanted to hear it.
"Because you’re still punishing yourself for something you did fifteen, sixteen years ago, even after what you endured in Azkaban. Bad people don’t feel guilt, Scarlett—and if they do, a paltry excuse is enough to silence it. You… you wear your guilt on your face, it marks your skin… scourges your bones. You didn’t want to escape Azkaban. You… wanted… to remain… in that nightmare…" He panted, screwing his eyes shut and shaking his head as though the idea of leaving Scarlett in prison were absurd. "You’re not a bad person. When will you stop punishing yourself?"
"I don’t deserve you. I don’t deserve a family, I don’t deserve happiness…" She repeated, like a bloody broken record.
"You need to leave the past behind." He murmured, not knowing if he said it for her or for himself.
Perhaps for them both.
Scarlett laughed, a fierce, anguished laugh.
"It’s so ironic, you asking me that, Sirius. So hypocritical." She gasped, wiping her tears. "Have you left the past behind? Are you capable of leaving it?!"
Sirius wanted to say yes, wanted to say he had left the past and all its miseries behind. But the truth was he hadn’t. He hadn’t left it. And it was destroying him, just as it was destroying her. Perhaps that was why they were so alike—because they shared that synergy with no one else. Their struggles were the same, their shadows and their crimes as well.
"No… I don’t know." He admitted, tears stinging his eyes. "But I’m trying." He reached for her hand and stroked her fingers, brushing his thumb over the engagement ring on her fourth finger, the ring he had given her before their world had shattered beneath their feet. "I suggest you do the same."
Scarlett hid her face against her knees. The sudden touch was enough to set her heart racing and raise the hairs on her neck.
"And yet here I am." She sniffed. "Why would I go back to Azkaban if I’ve got you to torture me?" She lifted her head to the ceiling without opening her eyes, the dampness of her tears gleaming on her cheeks. "You’re cruel, Sirius. You torture me with the hope of a better life, a happy life, a life by your side." An incredulous smile curved her lips. "Torturing me with your kindness… with your support… your love." Her lashes fluttered open and shut, framing a haunted look. "You frighten me, Sirius Black. You always have. You know exactly what you’re doing and… and we… we’re the same as before. And we’ll destroy each other again. Because that’s what I do to you and that’s what you do to me. We make peace, then we fight, you ask me to stay and I leave." The blue of her eyes sought the starry silver of his, piercing it with an icy surface. "And, for some reason, even knowing all of this, I miss you."
Sirius stayed silent for a few seconds, letting Scarlett’s words tear all the rot from the depths of his heart. All the thoughts he buried in his chest so as not to lose his sanity.
"I… I’m here." It was all he could say, twining his fingers with hers until they fit together in that perfect way, as though her hand had been made to fit into his.
Scarlett shook her head.
"I miss… us." She confessed, her voice trembling. "Us together. Scarius. I miss Scarius."
Sirius drew his brows together, looking at her with that expression that always unnerved her. His grey eyes absorbed her with comprehension and indulgence, searing her soul with a hundred different feelings, none of them loneliness. Never loneliness. Selfishness, pettiness, jealousy… but never loneliness.
"And yet I wouldn’t do that to you. I’d never do that to you." She wiped her tears with the back of her free hand. "No matter what I feel. You deserve someone better than me."
There was Scarlett again, trying to run from the very situation she had put herself in. Sirius shifted on the bed, his head spinning. He loved the Scarlett who had left—but what of the Scarlett before him now? Was she still the woman he loved? Fifteen years later, was she still the same?
He knew she didn’t. The scars on her body said she didn’t, the fear rooted deep within said she didn’t, the mask she hid behind said she didn’t. But Sirius wanted to believe she did. That she loved him the same way he loved her, even though she had never once spoken the three little words. It was foolish and fleeting, he knew that, but it sent such a warm rush through his veins that he let that honeyed haze dance around him as he kept his gaze fixed on her.
"What do you want, Scarlett?" There was no softness left in his voice.
"What do you mean…"
"What do you want?" He cut her off abruptly.
Scarlett blinked a few times, not knowing what to say, her mouth opening and closing, but no word crossed her lips, as though everything running through her mind was the wrong answer. She had been trapped for so long that the very idea of simply wanting something was out of the question. She had grown used to wanting nothing, to accepting her condition because she had no other choice.
No choice at all, in truth.
"Do you want to go back to Azkaban? Do you want to kill yourself? Do you want to keep living as a waitress and a keyboardist? Do you want a family? What do you want?" The last question was repeated slowly, and the grey of Sirius’s eyes hardened into incisiveness and impatience.
"I… I don’t…"
"What’s the first thing that comes into your head when I ask you that?" He gave her no room to fill herself with doubts, nor to drain herself of certainties. "What do you want?"
The very first thought that came to her was: I want to die. But then, before her breath could scrape her vocal cords, a dozen words swept through her mind in a flood of repressed desires.
She parted her lips, then shut them again. Bit her lower lip and rubbed her thumb hard against the Signet, ashamed. Which was strange, because she had never felt that with Sirius before—not when she needed to show him the darkness of her heart. It was as if he already knew her, and yet…
They no longer knew each other. Not like before.
"I want a bottle of cold milk." A disbelieving, uneasy laugh slipped with the sentence. "I want… I want to go somewhere I can see the stars. I want choconuts ice cream. I want to go to a Toto concert. I want to sleep without nightmares…" The flow of answers was so vast Scarlett couldn’t filter them. "I want to leave the house without worrying someone’s following me or… I want to be certain I’ll never go back to Azkaban. I want… I want…" She hesitated, flaring her nostrils. "I want loneliness to abandon me. I want to make Reggie and Harry happy. I want you to find someone better than me. I want you to be happy."
"You want me to be happy but you don’t wish happiness for yourself." He pointed out, his attention turning ravenous.
"I don’t want… I don’t want to risk hurting you like I did in the past." Scarlett shuddered at the very possibility.
"Then we’ve a problem, because I don’t want someone better." Sirius tilted his head to the side, the night lights refracting in his eyes, shining like stars. "I want you."
Scarlett straightened, releasing the breath that already felt so scarce.
"Sirius… we can’t…" The plea tore from her throat with the same force as the agitation in her blood. Sirius’s response was to imprison her with the storm-grey of his irises. "Stop deceiving me… stop making me believe I’m worthy of love!"
Sirius’s eyes dropped to her lips, hypnotised by them, lost in the labyrinth of dubious pleas and sharp teeth. It was as if nothing she said mattered—Sirius was tired of fighting against what was far stronger than him.
"No one is worthy of love, Scarlett." He breathed softly, his face drawing close enough that the shadows between them dissolved into one. "Least of all the two of us."
Scarlett couldn’t move, couldn’t tear her eyes from his. She tilted her face slightly upwards, the air around her growing scarcer with every movement Sirius made, sliding across the bed closer to her. She couldn’t breathe anymore, not with the warm breath caressing her cheeks, the angular face so close to hers that she could almost taste his mouth.
"I don’t want to hurt you." Scarlett was practically begging.
"Then don’t hurt me." He countered, covering Scarlett’s hand with his own, making her gasp at the heat of his touch.
"Sirius… this love… this love will destroy us all over again…" She resisted, twisting her mouth as though fighting to stay, to flee, and to advance. Every version of every Scarlett in her fractured reflection trying to seize control of her at once.
"And we’ll survive it… all over again."
Her arguments had run dry. It was far too difficult to conjure a sentence that might make sense when swallowed by those star-filled eyes. Sirius Black was like that—gnawing at the edges until, by the time Scarlett noticed, she had already been devoured by him.
Their noses brushed, their foreheads grazed, and Sirius’s beard prickled her chin, yet he kept the scant distance of inches, as though waiting for her. Scarlett bit at her lower lip with the agony that man so effortlessly inflicted upon her, his chilling presence spreading through her body at the pace of her racing heart.
She gasped once more and Sirius heard her hold her breath, attuned to every reaction she let slip: the burning glow in her eyes, so dilated he saw only a bluish ring encircling the black pupils; the trembling in her body, evident even through the unbroken exchange of gazes; her hands clutching at the sheets as though straining not to reach for him in return.
Scarlett was afraid—well, at that point fear was the emotion he had seen her display most often—but he was too. At the same time, it was somewhat disconcerting how, though irrational, that hesitation made sense after all they had been through. Sirius was not one to be fearful—by Merlin, he was a Gryffindor, and fear was hardly among his traits—yet it unsettled him deeply how much Scarlett had been forced to live with it.
She was like a wounded, skittish animal. And he knew she had only two choices: fight or flee. It was staggering to witness both emotions warring within her so fiercely, mirrored in the tautness of her muscles and the widening of her eyes. Sirius didn’t want to force her into anything, so he simply turned his head aside, letting his hair spill over Scarlett’s face in a cascade of onyx and jet.
She closed her eyes, feeling the soft, silken strands brush across her cheeks, intoxicated by the scent of Sirius’s shampoo, the aftershave… the sweet cologne that seeped into her nostrils and climbed to her brain, intoxicating her with an indescribably warm, placid sensation. Memories, recollections and moments reverberated against the walls of her mind, echoing the laughter, the promises, the kisses and the moans.
Flooding her with the love she had striven so hard to bury in her chest, searing her with its crackling sparks and burning away her last drop of rationality.
Scarlett stopped fighting against the biting current that pulled her back to him.
Her lips rose to meet Sirius’s; the taste, the fervour, the end of any distance between them vibrated through all her senses, leaving her dizzy in the tattooed arms that crushed her against him, his fingers and palms charting every fevered inch of her body.
Scarlett was no less relentless, clutching a fistful of darkness-thick hair with one hand while the other roamed across the tense breadth of his chest, feeling it rise and fall in anticipation. There was no violence in the kiss, yet there was the urgency of a ravenous lover who seemed almost wistful to have her again. She wound her legs around Sirius’s waist, straddling his lap, grinding her hips deliberately against the bulge beneath his trousers.
Sirius exhaled in a shudder, pulling back, breathless. His face hovered dangerously close—mere inches away—his hands fixed at her waist, his eyes blazing with her reflection. Her brows knitted faintly as she watched Sirius’s long lashes lower when he bowed his head, seizing her hand and pressing it against his chest, over the Scarius tattoo. She could feel his heart hammering beneath the smooth skin, its rhythm reverberating through her entire body.
She smiled. The fingers of her other hand wandered along the valley of Sirius’s collarbone, tracing Odin’s Spear with her fingertips and raising the hair on his skin. Sirius’s hot breath bathed her cheeks and Scarlett tossed back his black hair, revealing the vein pulsing at his throat.
With a subtle lean forward, her lips found that vulnerable spot, sucking hard. Sirius let his temple fall against her shoulder, expelled the air from his lungs and closed his eyes, surrendering utterly to Scarlett as her mouth trailed across his neck. She slid down to his shoulder, up to his ear, nibbled at the lobe and painted his skin with her wicked saliva before returning to his lips. Sirius’s fingers seized the chance to slip beneath her T-shirt, spreading the intoxicating heat of his palms across the curves of her hips.
Scarlett rolled her hips against his lap, her lips curving into a smile mid-kiss. Sirius shuddered. Even through their clothes, he could feel the molten heat between her thighs brushing against his erection, his cock throbbing, desperate to bury itself inside her. Scar raked her nails down his chest, forcing him to suck in air and release it in a growl. He trembled, muscles drawn taut beneath her maddening touch.
With a sudden surge, Sirius shoved her, sending her crashing onto her back across the bed. Without giving her a chance to react, he tugged at her shirt and yanked it away. Scarlett lay spellbound, watching Sirius’s fingers descend and skim across her skin, tracing one of the scars that marred her ribs. Her entire body quivered at the brazen touch.
Unlike the first time, she felt no shame, no fear. All that ruled her was the relentless need to surrender herself to Sirius Black. To place her heart on a platter and offer it to him on her knees, to chain her soul to his, to moan his name so many times she’d be left voiceless. Sirius pinched one of her nipples between thumb and forefinger, his gaze locked on hers, his expression clear as daylight.
Sirius wanted to devour her, consume her. Possess her.
[Music: Jeff Buckley — So Real]
Scarlett exhaled through her mouth as he positioned himself over her, his warm tongue circling one nipple, hardening it before moving to the other, while his hand kept tracing a torrid path down her abdomen, her belly… fingers slipping past the waistband of the shorts he’d lent her, into the boxer briefs beneath, parting her folds in search of that bundle of nerves he knew so well.
Love, let me sleep tonight on your couch
And remember the smell of the fabric
Of your simple city dress
A sweaty, sinful fingertip found it soon enough, pressing with teasing inconsistency and lightness; just enough to send tremors shooting through her nerves, but not enough to make her moan. Sirius knew it, of course, and so his thumb took to her clit while his index and middle fingers sank into her soaked cunt, her wetness spreading across the fabric of the briefs Scarlett wore.
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Sirius pushed one finger in, then another, enraptured by the hot, tight walls pulsing around him, especially when his thumb circled her clit. Scarlett let out a frantic moan, her trembling legs clamping around his forearm. Sirius lifted his gaze to her face, letting her wrap her arms around his shoulders, their foreheads pressed together.
"Go slow…" she murmured, shifting beneath his body. "I need you to go slower than you did yesterday."
The mention of the night before unleashed a depraved flood of memories in Sirius’s mind, curling his lips into a smile. He claimed her mouth with more urgency than before, their tongues colliding, Scarlett’s moans swallowed by his kiss as his fingers began to thrust with deft rhythm, his wrist twisting so the friction against her clit grew ever more unpredictable…
We walked around 'til the moon got full like a plate
And the wind blew an invocation and I fell asleep at the gate
And I never stepped on the cracks 'cause I thought I'd hurt my mother
And I couldn't awake from the nightmare, that sucked me in and pulled me under
Pulled me under, oh
Scarlett rolled her eyes back, awestruck by what Sirius could do to her with just one hand. His eager fingers pushed as deep as they could, preparing her for what was to come, searching for that spot he had once found with such ease. Scar licked his lower lip, trying to pull him closer, delighting in the welcoming press of Sirius’s mouth against hers, in the tension stringing every muscle tight, and in the frantic certainty that a moment of clarity would wipe out this blinding passion and they would part again, full of regret.
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Her hands tangled in the hair at the nape of Sirius’s neck, tongues entwining, their moans coiling through her ribcage until the vibration tickled his mouth. Sirius went on fingering her with the calm of a man who had all the time in the world, as though he meant to savour every second of it.
Scarlett opened her eyes, swallowed by the pupils that drank her in greedily, extracting from her everything he wanted: her moans, her pleasure, her fate. She arched her back, lost in the sensations swelling inside her. Her toes curled into the sheets, breath hitching, her body quivering in anticipation of the orgasm rising.
"Look at me, Scarlett." Sirius commanded, lifting his face, his star-filled irises never leaving hers. "Come looking at me."
I love you
But I’m afraid to love you
It was so hard to keep her eyes open, but Scarlett forced herself to when the overwhelming wave of pleasure swept through every part of her body in involuntary, voluptuous spasms, moaning his name so loudly she feared someone else might hear. She felt herself unravel in Sirius’s arms, in the very frenzy prolonged by his fingers, which didn’t cease even as she reached her peak, only slowing little by little until they stopped.
I love you
But I’m afraid to love you
I’m afraid
Sirius brought his fingers to his mouth, tasting her release like a starving man, intoxicated by her sweet, poisonous flavour. Scarlett drew a deep breath, heart pounding, mind purged of any thought it might conjure. He stripped the rest of her clothes with precision, baring himself as well as he pushed his trousers down, freeing his hard cock from that morbid prison.
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Scarlett could have stopped right there, could have said they’d already gone too far, could have begged Sirius to let her go… but if she were to beg, every plea would be for him to claim her and make her his. For him to hold her and promise they would stay together… that he loved her.
Expecting any sort of rationality from Scarius, in that moment, was impossible.
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Real, real, real
Sex wasn’t just sex for them. It wasn’t merely intimacy or pleasure, devotion or fascination. It was… it was the connection they shared taking shape, making them one. It was the instant when all their prayers were answered, when all their fears turned to ashes and every longing became reality. It was the moment they felt truly complete.
Oh, that was so real
Oh, that was so real
Sirius stroked himself a few times, lowering his body over Scarlett’s, smearing his tip against her wet cunt before lining himself up and finding her eyes. He brushed a few bleached strands from her face, allowing the faint night light to seep into the blue of her eyes with a tinge of red, turning them violet.
He lowered his face to kiss her, but Scarlett wetted her lips and sank slightly into the mattress, steadying her breath as she tried to recover the words that slipped so easily away.
Oh, that was so real
"I… I love you too. I never stopped loving you, Sirius… not for a single second… not… not even when…" Scarlett couldn’t finish her sentence. Something whispered at the nape of her neck, lashing at her ears as though there was no need to say more. With the inevitability that Scarius’s fate was to be together, regardless of their personal wishes, regardless of choices or pacts; for better or worse Sirius belonged to Scarlett and Scarlett belonged to Sirius. Scarius was the natural order of things, it was inexorable, it had to be!
Sirius neither smiled nor wept. His gaze pierced her, burning her from the inside out, a shiver running down her spine, his sharp presence striking every sense with that force which both drew them in and repelled them, which dominated and subdued them to a bond filled with thorns, filled with flowers, with losses and with love.
Scarlett wondered if he could feel it too, if he could sense the threads of fate tangling around them, binding them into a knot impossible to untie, to loosen, to break. The only way out was with something very sharp, something beyond words or intentions. Something stronger than right and wrong.
She needed no verbal answer. The truth came when Sirius pressed his lips to hers and was lost in the sugared sigh that trembled in her mouth, swallowing it as he kissed her with adoration. Usurping Scarlett’s love, feeding his greedy hunger to have her only for himself, to be the only one who truly knew her, the only one to whom she surrendered, body and soul.
Sirius raised his torso without breaking the kiss. His hands spread and pushed Scarlett’s legs apart until her delicate knees were pressed against his shoulders, her ankles resting on his shoulder blades. She breathed heavily at the new position, still lying on the bed, on her back, utterly vulnerable with her hips lifted to him at an angle that would let him reach far deeper than his fingers ever had.
A cynical smile brushed his wicked lips as he caught sight of the bruises on Scarlett’s arse, shaped like his hand.
Slowly, Sirius thrust inside. Scarlett whimpered into his mouth, digging her nails into his back at the discomfort the intrusion caused, still sore from the night before. At her reaction, he drew his hips back, easing into her again with care, slow, his jaw tightening with the effort of not losing himself to the tight, molten heat of Scarlett. It was no easy task, but Sirius pressed on little by little, sinking deeper as the tension rippling through her thighs began to ebb away.
He scattered kisses across her flushed cheeks, an early apology as he withdrew in a languid motion, feeling Scarlett’s chest expand against his as he almost slipped out of her, only to push back in, swallowed by that warm interior, this time all the way, burying himself until every inch of his cock was cradled by the delicious squeeze of her walls.
Breath short, Scarlett brushed her lips against Sirius’s without kissing him, letting her body yield to his, growing accustomed to his length and thickness, rigid and hot, stretching her inebriatingly.
"All right?" he asked, hoarse, his long lashes framing those beautiful half-lidded eyes.
Scarlett only nodded, and Sirius kept his movements slow, his fingers pressing into the undersides of her thighs, her feet hooking around his neck in a bid to draw him closer. He lowered her legs, fitting them around his hips as he wrapped her in his arms.
Sirius shut his eyes, surrendering to the sensation of Scarlett’s body pressed to his, to the pleasure of taking her slowly, almost stopping, savouring the moment they were only one.
The moment that made them feel complete.
They weren’t fucking as they had after the show, nor was it reconciliation as it had been the first time they had slept together after fifteen years. This was… it was magical, it was tender, and it was addictive. It was sublime, indulgent, warm. Genuine. Natural and instinctive. It was body to body, skin to skin. Heart to heart. It was love, even if weary, even if rusted… even if dependent and obsessive.
It was Scarius in its purest form; fractured, relentless, and reckless. It was Scarius with all their fears and longings, Scarius seeking the comfort they could only ever find in one another. It was the second that made them infinite with the ferocity of their connection, it was the synchronised heartbeats, the gazes sinking into each other. It was the way the brightest star in the night sky fitted perfectly between her fingers, for it was her star, it was her man, it was her other half.
It was Sirius Black.
Her rainbow at the end of the storm.
Unable to resist Scarlett’s low moans, Sirius moved with more speed and firmness, making her revel in the moment as much as he did, bracing himself on one elbow while the other hand slid down to massage her clit, driven half-mad by the immediate, involuntary squeeze around his cock. Scarlett clutched at his long hair, dragging him into another desperate kiss, panting against his sinful lips at the havoc he wreaked upon her body.
With ragged grunts tearing from his throat, Sirius quickened the pace, heightening both his pleasure and Scarlett’s as his hand matched the rhythm with the motions on her clit, silencing her lustful cries by kissing her deeply, plunging his tongue into her mouth, his beard tickling the edges of her delicate lips.
Scarlett couldn’t react, couldn’t resist, couldn’t run. Everything she felt came from him: the incandescent trail of fire that ignited her body each time his cock dragged along her walls, the ruthless certainty that this was her place in the world, the torturous bliss that seized her senses and made her captive to that man with the name and eyes of a star.
Sirius’s pelvis struck against her hips with such force that Scarlett felt the bruises on her arse burn with each impact. He embraced her, letting the weight of his body rest against hers as he stole her breath in a kiss, Sirius’s lips moving over hers, coveting everything she gave him. Scarlett felt the sweat sticking their bodies together, the friction of his muscular chest on hers making her heart race in time with his, her legs locking tighter around Sirius’s waist, pulling him closer each time he thrust.
It was too much. Sirius Black was too much, he always had been; he had always held her in the palm of his hand. Scarlett stared into the infinite, silver depths of those eyes that were her undoing, finding the love she had longed for so desperately. The love that terrified her. The feeling was there, unblemished, raw, molten and scalding. Their lips parted and their temples pressed together.
Sirius Black was the fire in which Scarlett Gaunt deliciously burned.
She gave in. She gave herself to Sirius and to the euphoria that claimed her, trembling through every cell of her body, reaching her climax once more. Sirius stifled a guttural moan as he pressed his lips to her cheek while thrusting languidly, struck violently by the waves of pleasure and ecstasy. He swelled and pulsed inside Scarlett, spilling himself with a ragged sigh the instant her cunt clenched deliciously around his cock, strangling him.
Sirius slowed his pace, but did not stop. A dragging sigh left his throat and whipped across Scarlett’s neck. He buried his face there, his arms pulling her close in a possessive hold, the pressure of his movements making his thick cum overflow from her and run down the base of his cock to the insides of her weakened thighs that clung around his waist.
Scarlett pushed her head back into the pillow, her limbs still trembling from the orgasm that had swept her muscles and melted her in the purest bliss. Sirius’s body was hot against hers, his blood thundering rapidly beneath her skin, his chest rising and falling with broken breaths.
Sirius’s lips wandered over her neck, planting tender kisses on her sweaty skin. He collapsed onto Scarlett, still inside her, wishing never to leave as though they could simply fuse.
"I want you." Scarlett’s husky voice pulled him from his stupor. "I love you."
With a small, sated smile on his face, Sirius lifted his head and looked at her, seeing through the dizziness and the lethargy the flushed features of the woman he loved. He traced the tip of his finger gently across Scarlett’s brows, lingered on the thick curl of her lashes, slid down the freckled line of her nose, circled her lips and stopped at her jaw, where he cupped her face in his palm and kissed her.
"I love you too, kitten," he confessed, hiding his face back in her neck. Scarlett kissed his dark hair and trailed her fingers down Sirius’s damp back as he slipped out of her, still hard, and rolled onto the bed, drawing her into his arms as he shifted onto his back and let her settle on his chest.
For a few minutes, all they did was remain in perfect silence.
"If we’re going to keep doing this, you’d better give me more contraceptive potions. I can’t risk getting pregnant by you again," Scarlett murmured lazily, clinging to the presence of the man she loved.
Sirius dropped his gaze to her, avoiding the tangled thread of memory Scarlett was referring to. He didn’t want to spoil the moment, didn’t want to feel as wretched as he had in that recollection, so he simply chased the thought away with a breath through his nose and traced the scars on Scarlett’s back with his fingertips.
"I’ll buy more tomorrow." He replied, pressing his lips to Scarlett’s temple. "Tomorrow we’ll talk about it."
"Hm… mmhm. Tomorrow." The agreement came easily in the drowsy state he had lulled her into. "Sirius?"
"Hm?" he grunted, opening just one eye to look at her.
"Thank you."
Sirius furrowed his brows in a silent question, brushing the strands of hair stuck to Scarlett’s cheeks aside.
"For not giving up on me." She squeezed his hand, the other covering the word Scarius etched over his heart. "Even when I had already given up."
"You take care of me…" The words slipped across her bleached hair like little serpents. "And I take care of you."
Sirius laced his fingers with Scarlett’s and closed his eyes for a moment. A distracted smile softened his lips as he rested his hand on the nape of her neck, relaxing at the feel of blood pulsing beneath his palm.
And Scarlett drowned in the piercing safety Sirius poured into her, closing her eyes as she focused on the caress of his thumb just behind her ear. There was still so much they needed to say and resolve, but in that moment she fell asleep on his tattooed chest, hoping the steady beats of his heart might chase her nightmares away.
She hadn’t expected to be right, but it worked.
That night, Scarlett Gaunt surrendered to a dream where she was good and loved.
Good and loved.
Two of the things she begged for with the same intensity she abhorred.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 58: She hadn’t been able to save Orfy. And she couldn’t save Regulus either.
Chapter Text
CXXVI
Rumours spread quickly through Hogwarts. After Jim Avery turned up at the hospital wing with a broken arm, all eyes were on the Marauders. It was obvious this had been an act of retaliation and, even with James denying (truthfully) every accusation, the stares they received – even from their fellow Gryffindors – brimmed with suspicion.
The subject hadn’t yet been raised among them. For one thing, James was far too busy with his duties as Head Boy alongside Lily. For another, Remus seemed wrapped up in something that demanded his time, leaving Peter and Sirius to carry the group’s suspicions whilst feigning ignorance and using Scarlett as a shield.
Monday dawned grey, and though the weather was entirely unfavourable for a Quidditch practice, Scarlett managed to drag herself out of bed. Sirius had placed her trunk between his bed and James’s, and she was crouched before it, digging for her uniform beneath Peter’s faint snores.
A flicker in her peripheral vision told her Remus had woken, and in moments he was tiptoeing towards the bathroom. Still half-buried in blankets, Sirius lifted his head to look at her.
"Love…?" he muttered, rubbing his eyes with his knuckles.
"It’s all right, go back to sleep…" Scarlett glanced over her shoulder at him, clutching her robes and protective gear.
"What are you doing?" Crawling forward on the bed, Sirius sat on the edge, just behind her.
"Getting ready for practice…"
"What? I thought… I thought you…"
"I’m leaving the team," she cut him off, dissolving the argument before it could begin. "I just want to play one last time before that. Before… before I remember that…" She sighed, tipping her head back to keep the tears from falling. "Maybe it’ll help… me cope…"
"I’m not having a go at you." Sirius frowned, threading his fingers through Scarlett’s dark hair. "It’s fine if you want to go, I just don’t want you going alone…"
"Remus can take me. And Pan can… can watch the practice and—"
"No, Moony’s not taking you. I’ll take you." He grumbled, stretching.
"You don’t have to, Sirius, I’m not even going through the Great Hall…"
Sirius tossed his tangled hair back, his thick brows arching sharply as his lips twisted, blinking in confusion.
"It’s just that…" Scarlett opened and closed her mouth a few times, as though she’d forgotten how to speak. How could she tell Sirius that Quidditch was one of the few things she was good at on her own, without his help?
How could she explain that she wanted to feel good about being herself, not because she happened to be in his presence?
She’d spent the entire week lying in that damned bed whilst Sirius sheltered and protected her with such devotion she had no idea how to thank him.
She rose with her Quidditch uniform dangling from her arms. Meeting Sirius’s gaze, she rubbed the emerald and silver fabric over and over, as though it might somehow provide her with a clever answer – she was a Slytherin, after all.
Nothing came.
"Don’t you want me to come?" Sirius asked, his voice laced with fear. A trace of reluctance, too.
"No, no… it’s not that…" Scarlett swallowed hard, shoulders curling as she lowered her eyes to her bare feet on the crimson carpet of the dormitory. She crouched, pulling her Firebolt from the trunk. "I don’t know." She shook her head. "I just… need to do this on my own."
Even without looking at him, she knew perfectly well the hurt expression twisting his handsome features the moment her reply landed. He nodded slowly, glancing about as though unwilling to let his wounded gaze fall on her.
"Did I do something wrong?"
"No! No… Sirius… you most certainly didn’t…" Scarlett panted, her breath thinning.
"All right," he murmured, reluctant, before a small smile curved his lips. "I’ll have a bit more sleep, then."
Scarlett lifted her eyes to him, watching as he collapsed back onto the bed, wrapping himself in the sheets until all she could see was a scarlet-and-gold heap of blankets and a spill of black hair across the pillows.
"All right," she echoed, her heart easing at the sight of him so utterly at ease. She dared a smile, caught by Sirius as he peered at her between stray strands of black hair, his starry eyes glinting as though they hung in the sky itself. She moved closer and pressed a long kiss to his forehead. "I love you."
"Love you too, kitten." He winked at her before shutting his eyes.
She slipped into the bathroom just as Remus came out, already dressed for the day. He was waiting with his satchel slung across his back, his pallor telling her plainly that the full moon was near. Still, he greeted her with a crooked smile.
"Decided to leave the cave?" he asked softly, as they started towards the exit.
Scarlett cast one last glance at Sirius, still motionless in the bed, before being met with the smoky, musky scent of the Gryffindor common room. The looks that followed her Slytherin Quidditch uniform were plentiful, as though Scarlett were a magnet.
"Yeah… had to come out sooner or later," she quipped, brushing off the attention.
"And I’m your escort today?" Remus narrowed his eyes at a pair of second-years whose hands were full of stink pellets.
"Afraid so." She met Marlene’s gaze for barely a second before looking away.
Marl was in her Quidditch kit too, chatting with James and Lily. Scarlett greeted them with a smile and — thank Merlin — they walked straight past, slipping out of the room through the portrait hole.
Scar and Remus walked in complete silence for a few minutes, watching a first-year beg Peeves to give her books back, though the poltergeist was far too busy juggling them.
"It was Sirius, wasn’t it?" Remus kept his expression calm, though his tone was unmistakably accusatory.
"What are you on about?" She frowned, eyeing him sideways.
Remus studied her expression, narrowing his eyes slightly in that way he did when reality didn’t quite line up with his thoughts. He wetted his lips, scratched the scar on his chin, and let out a small huff of laughter.
"You don’t know." It wasn’t a question.
"No…?" Scarlett hoped Remus would explain what the bloody hell he was talking about.
He didn’t.
Scarlett wanted to press him, but held back. She wasn’t sure she even wanted to know what Sirius had done, even if it was nothing solid. She’d already spent so much energy digging up the courage in her chest that it made no sense to waste it now.
She chose silence instead. The whispers that followed them through the corridor were more than enough to shove the subject aside. They descended the Grand Staircase, hopped over the trick step, and Scarlett was about to head for the entrance to the Great Hall when Remus steered her down another flight that led lower, towards the path she’d usually take if she wanted the dungeons.
"Where are we going?!"
Remus didn’t answer. They turned left, crossed a door, and descended a set of stone steps that spilled into a corridor entirely different from the one that led to her common room: this one was broad, well-lit by torches, and decorated with colourful paintings, mostly of food.
"I’m showing you the most useful place in this castle, miss," he finally said, solemnly, though a thread of irony edged his tone.
"Does this have anything to do with Sirius?!" She frowned, walking close to him until they stopped before a fruit bowl.
"No." His answer was delivered with infuriating simplicity.
"Does it have to do with your vanishing act this week?" Narrowing her eyes, Scarlett gripped her Firebolt tight, her gaze fixed on Remus’s enigmatic expression.
"Nope." He reached out, stretched his forefinger, and tickled a large green pear. The fruit squirmed and giggled before transforming into a great greenish door handle. Remus seized it, swung the door open, and shoved Scarlett hard, forcing her inside.
"Remus, what are you—" Scarlett began to protest, clutching her broom in both hands, but her voice died in her throat.
The place was vast, its ceiling high, as large as the Great Hall just above, lined with stacks of brass cauldrons and pans along the stone walls, a massive brick oven at the far end, and dozens upon dozens of house-elves at work. Every one of them wore a tea towel stamped with the Hogwarts crest, tied about them like a toga.
"Welcome to the Hogwarts kitchens, Scar." Remus gave her a playful nudge, and Scarlett watched as the elves moved with abnormal speed, filling four long wooden tables – which surely stood beneath the four House tables upstairs in the Great Hall.
Dishes were piled high and whisked away upstairs with the soft pops of Apparition. There must have been at least a hundred elves, all so absorbed in their tasks they didn’t notice the pair standing there. All except… one. Her bat-like ears pricked the moment she spotted Remus, and she dropped the jug of pumpkin juice she’d been carrying to dash over to them, beaming.
"Master Lupin!" She hastily snatched a chocolate pudding from another elf’s hands, who grumbled under his breath but didn’t stop working.
"Penny!" Remus crouched down to her level, accepting the pudding with a kind smile. "I’ve told you to call me Remus…"
"And who is this lovely young lady?" the elf ignored his request. "Master Lupin is finally courting?!"
Scarlett let out a nervous laugh, while Remus dipped a finger into the pudding, shaking his head.
"Scarlett, Penny. Penny, Scarlett." He closed his eyes, as though the dessert were heavenly. "Scarlett’s Sirius’s girlfriend, Penny."
"Oh, Scarlett! Scarlett Gaunt!" the elf squealed, making Scarlett’s smile twist into a grimace. "What can I fetch for you, miss?!"
"Uhh…" Scarlett grunted, scanning the kitchen. "I’ve got Quidditch practice now, so…"
"Practice, is it?" Penny massaged her chin, then suddenly lifted a finger. "Penny knows!"
She vanished with a crack and reappeared amidst the tables, snatching up an apple, four sausages, a slice of herring pie, a great hunk of roast pork, and an entire steak-and-kidney pudding that wobbled like jelly as she rushed back, balancing the haul in her long, spindly arms before stopping in front of Scarlett.
All Scarlett could focus on was that revolting pudding bouncing about like some jack-in-the-box clown. Of all the odd dishes the British had come up with, that pudding was at the very top. She forced a smile as she accepted the utterly unconventional breakfast, though she wasn’t hungry anymore, having to juggle the plates while keeping hold of her broom in her left hand.
"And to drink?" Penny pressed on with a disturbingly eager smile, staring at Scarlett so intently it made her shift uncomfortably.
"Er…" She glanced at Remus for help as she struggled to hold the teetering pile of food, but her friend merely shrugged, his mouth still full of pudding, shovelling in another spoonful to avoid speaking. Where had he even found a spoon?
Scarlett hadn’t the faintest idea.
"I think nothing… this is alread—"
"Nonsense, Miss Gaunt, how will you get all this down and practise afterwards? No, no, no… Penny knows!" She vanished again and returned carrying a large silver tray laden with a teapot, teacups enough for her and likely the entire Slytherin team, a little jug of milk, and a plate of biscuits. "All done!" she sang, balancing the tray atop the already precarious stack Scarlett was holding. Then she stretched her back as though she’d just run a marathon.
"Thanks, Penny," Remus said, still chewing. "We’ll see you later."
"Of course, Master Lupin! Miss Gaunt!" Penny waved and darted back to her work.
Scarlett shot an exasperated look at Remus, whose only reply was a wide grin, teeth smeared with chocolate.
"Could you at least help me carry all this?!" She feigned annoyance, though a smile threatened to tug at her lips.
"No," Remus answered simply, setting aside his pudding and steering her out of the kitchen. "When you don’t want to be seen in the Great Hall, but you’re still hungry… just come straight to the kitchens and ask Penny. That’s how we got food for you the whole week." He explained, clearly amused by Scarlett’s struggle to balance everything. He plucked a sausage from the pile and bit into it, earning a furious glare.
"Why are you doing this?!" She climbed the stairs with difficulty, craning her neck to see where she was placing her feet.
"Because you need to eat, and I promised Sirius I’d look after you too." Remus grabbed another sausage, then stopped a little before the Grand Staircase, in front of a portrait of a woman in a wimple and gowns five centuries out of fashion. "Death to the usurper," he declared, and the painting clicked open, revealing a passage behind it. "Come on, or you’ll be late for your practice…"
"What?! There are secret passages not listed on the Marauder’s Map?!" Scarlett stepped into the cold, dark corridor.
"Well, yes, but they change with each new set of prefects, so… we didn’t think it would be useful to mark them on the map…" Remus’s voice echoed low against the stone walls.
"Makes sense…" she murmured, waiting for him to open the door. When she realised where they were, Scarlett’s eyes went wide.
They stepped out of a frame in the storeroom behind the Great Hall, where the furniture was draped in white sheets. Remus led her to the nearest exit, which opened into the courtyard within the Bell Towers wing. Because of the overcast sky, there weren’t many students about, though two first-year Slytherins were attempting to fly kites from the highest stretch of the grounds.
The two of them made their way to the infamous bench near Hufflepuff’s common room ceiling, where one could see the Black Lake and the woods skirting the Hogwarts grounds. Scarlett set the stack of dishes down on the bench and charmed them to float before settling in herself. She poured a cup of tea for both her and Remus, sampling a slice of her herring pie, leaving the steak-and-kidney pudding to him.
"What?" she asked with an awkward smile, realising the hungry attention he was giving her.
"You’re eating." He sipped his tea, spearing his pudding with a fork.
"Yes…?" Scarlett arched her brows, wiping the corner of her mouth with her thumb.
"Without being forced," he added, grunting as he licked his lips, as though that horrid pudding were exquisite.
"Not forced?!" Scarlett let out a genuine laugh, her whole body prickling with the release. "I had to carry a bloody pile of dishes up here… and you’re telling me I wasn’t forced?!"
"You could’ve chosen not to eat," he remarked drily, before his tone sobered.
"I’ve got practice." She shrugged, focusing back on her breakfast.
Remus continued to study her in that unbearably perceptive way of his. He always caught on to things he wasn’t meant to. Scarlett was hopeless at hiding her emotions, and he was a master at fishing them out.
What’s more, it was maddening how much he reminded her of Dimitri. Silent, eccentric, perceptive. Scarlett tried to steer his attention elsewhere.
"Full moon’s coming?" The question was casual, and Remus didn’t seem to notice the tactic behind her words. If he did, he gave no sign. He patted the pockets of his worn trousers and drew out half a joint.
"As it does every month…" he muttered, lighting it with a tap of his wand to the paper. He closed his eyes, inhaling deeply, leaning back against the carved stone bench and tipping his head towards the sky, the joint glowing at his lips.
Now it was Scarlett watching him. Unlike Regulus, Remus wasn’t the sort to go out of his way to conceal what he felt. No… it was all right there, etched into his face like the deep scars, declared quietly in the fine lines already cut at the corners of his eyes, marking the silent tragedy of his life. The bitter weight of being a werewolf, bound forever to the will of the moon’s phases.
Her gloved fingers spread across Remus’s hand, squeezing with a kind of strength she hadn’t thought she still possessed. His eyes opened slowly, brown irises glancing at her from the corner, the light slipping through his dark lashes brightening the brown until it burned to amber.
"Can I come with you?" She felt Remus’s fingers trace the leather across the back of her glove as he blew out the foul smoke hard. The pungent scent was familiar; it wasn’t cannabis, though it was something very similar: woodland herb. Wizarding weed.
"I don’t think… it’d be safe." He licked his lips, holding the joint between the fore and middle finger of his free hand. "Better not."
"Why?" Scarlett sipped her tea, draining it while it was still hot. "You… you think Dimitri…"
Remus clamped his mouth shut, jaw tight until his neck quivered.
"It’s not because of Dimitri, Scar." He half-closed his eyes, smoking. "The wolf… Moony…" He gave a sad smile at the mention of his other self. "He can feel it."
"Feel? Feel what?" She dabbed her lips with a napkin, not taking her eyes off him.
"The war." Remus dropped his gaze to their joined hands, circling the Slytherin crest on Scarlett’s glove. "The terror. The fear. The deaths… the wolf’s eager to join the war and, after Dimitri… after Dimitri came…"
He bit his lower lip, as though forcing himself to stop speaking. Scarlett urged him on with the gentlest pressure of her hand.
"What do you mean?"
"That night… when Dimitri and… and his mate came during the full moon… I woke with… blood in my mouth." His words were slow, deliberate. "And the wolf wants blood again, Scar."
"You killed?" The sentence shot out so fast Scarlett hadn’t time to filter it.
Remus turned his face away, dragging deep on his joint until the heat singed his fingers. He hissed, tossing it aside with a flick of his hand, exhaling smoke with a low curse.
"We killed." The admission came, fearful. His mouth opened and closed, swallowing hard, unable to look at her. "I don’t know what, but… we killed."
"Probably some beast from the Forbidden Forest." Scarlett tried to ease the tension weighing on her friend’s shoulders, a soft smile stretching her lips. "I hope it was a spider."
Remus didn’t smile, only shook his head vehemently, as though trying to banish an improper thought.
"I hope it wasn’t a spider." He forced a laugh, staring out over the Black Lake. Daylight brought colour back to his sickly face.
"But can I come?" Scarlett pressed. "I don’t want Sirius or James, or even Peter, to be pulled from you, especially with the wolf like this, the way you said and…"
"It’s different, Scar. They’re part of the pack." Remus sighed, draining his tea in one swallow. "You’re not."
"And how do I become part of the pack?! James is a stag and Pete—"
"I don’t know, I’m not the leader." He shrugged. "Padfoot is. Which is a good thing, because he’s the only one who can stop me completely. But… Moony… is very unstable and—"
"I can talk to him." Scarlett brushed aside his arguments as though they were irrelevant. "I want to be with you all." She squeezed Remus’s hand again. "I want to look after you… all of you. The same way you’ve been looking after me."
The smile that touched Remus’s lips was genuine. He nodded slowly, resting his head on her shoulder as the morning breeze toyed with his brown hair.
"Ask Sirius to introduce Whiskers to Moony as Padfoot does, as soon as I transform," he murmured, massaging Scarlett’s fingers.
"I’ll ask him." She agreed, resting her cheek against his hair, and Remus closed his eyes as her soft perfume clouded his senses. "I have to go."
She rose slowly, her Slytherin cloak billowing with the wind.
"Scar!" Remus called, just as she began climbing the stairs back to the Great Hall. She glanced at him sidelong, one dark brow arched. "Thank you."
"For what? You’re one of my best friends, Rem," she called back, loudly enough for the gusts not to snatch her words away.
Remus lowered his head, then looked at her again, moistening his lips.
"You’re my best friend too…" he whispered, only for himself, as Scarlett continued up the steps.
.
.
.
Scarlett thought she might be affected somehow when she reached the Quidditch pitch and found her teammates waiting. But there was an emptiness in her chest that neither shame nor fear could fill. The Slytherin team already had two positions unfilled since Heitor Selwyn and Emily Flint had graduated last year, leaving an opening for a Beater and the Keeper.
At her side, Regulus stayed silent, clutching his broom with deliberate accuracy. Scarlett’s eyes didn’t stray from him, dissecting the boy as though searching for answers to what he had done to her. For having fed the rumours about them, for having attacked her, for having entered her mind, for having…
A wave of revulsion hit her square in the chest, and Scarlett curled her lips when Regulus stared back at her, his face as blank as ever. Strands of black brushed his temple. He hadn’t cut his hair over the summer, so the wavy locks now formed a mane around his face, his fringe constantly slipping down before his eyes.
Regulus shook his head, tossing aside the strays, but never taking his eyes off Scarlett.
"Sirius…" It was the first word he spoke. The name of his elder brother came out as nothing more than a hesitant breath upon his lips. "Sirius told me you’d hurt your ankle. Is it better?" Reg composed himself quickly, his voice flat as ever.
"Yes." Her reply was curt, yet she didn’t look away; if anything, she tilted her chin higher. The stares from her teammates, standing further off, were bothersome. "You and Sirius are speaking again?" She made no attempt to hide the scorn in her tone.
"More or less." He sighed, unbothered by her bad temper.
Scarlett shook her head.
"I wonder how long that’ll last," she provoked. Regulus’s nostrils flared for the briefest instant, enough for Scarlett’s lips to curve at one corner. "How long before you disappoint him."
She expected Regulus to rise against her, to at least take a step closer, to fill his lungs and hurl insult after insult. But he wasn’t a Gryffindor – quite the opposite. Red was the most cunning and self-serving of Slytherins, and he saw through her provocation with ease. He turned his face, watching Rosier flying towards them on his broom, before looking back her way without meeting her gaze.
"I don’t know, Scar. How long before you disappoint him?" He spat his venom, and Scarlett felt heat rush to her face, her hands gripping her Firebolt until they trembled. "Hurts, doesn’t it? Saying what you please and hearing what you’d rather not…"
"Brilliant, we’re all here!" Rosier reached them, still astride his broom. Regulus fell silent, and the group drew closer, forming a circle in the middle of the pitch. "It was you, wasn’t it?!" His mocking gaze fell on Scarlett, who furrowed her brow, realising the question was aimed at her.
"What?" She knitted her brows together, defiant.
Rosier’s lips curled in insolence, his dark eyes layering with malice.
"You don’t know what happened to Avery?!" Her confusion only seemed to amuse him. "You really were locked up in Gryffindor Tower the whole of last week?"
"Come off it, Gaunt, everyone here knows you had a hand in it… especially after the prank they pulled on you…" Brandon Nott sneered, raising his elbow as though to rest it on her shoulder, but a single look from her was enough to make him drop the gesture.
"Can we discuss this later?" Barty sighed, bored. "I thought we were here to run the try-outs today…"
"And we are. I asked the hopefuls to come later so we could plan the tests… I was thinking of running the Keeper trial with our team against the reserve players and—"
Evan’s voice grew more distant the deeper Scarlett retreated into her own mind. What had happened to Avery? Was that what Remus had been asking her about earlier? Why wasn’t she nervous? She was surrounded by Death Eaters-in-the-making and felt nothing but the comforting thrill of being about to play Quidditch.
At least her excitement for the sport was still there, untouched. Or so it seemed. Her gaze drifted instinctively back to Regulus, who was listening intently to Evan’s explanation, though Scarlett knew full well he wasn’t truly there either. He was far away, in another day of another season, grey eyes boiling with memories that clearly weren’t pleasant. His lips twisted in a tic, and he raked his hands through his hair the same way Sirius did when nervous.
"What happened to Avery?" she asked softly, only for him. Those iron-grey eyes locked on her as though she’d just saved him from a storm.
"Broke his arm," Red murmured, licking his dry lips.
"Who did it?" Her gaze sharpened on him.
Regulus stayed expressionless, shrugging.
"Don’t know. Thought it was you."
Scarlett’s scorn turned into a faint laugh.
"Wish it had been me," she admitted, her mouth watering at the thought of Avery’s arm being snapped the way he’d done to her last year.
Red’s eyes curved faintly in that invisible smile only he could ever convey.
"He deserved it." Regulus straightened at once when Rosier’s attention landed on the pair of them.
"What’s the lovebirds’ secret chat about, then?!" Evan folded his arms, hovering on his broom with an air of smugness.
Scarlett hissed, rolling her eyes in disgust.
"We are not a couple. We never were." She growled, letting her broom float at her side as she drew the bat from the enchanted pocket of her cloak. "Tell him, Regulus. Tell your friends the truth about us…"
"For Merlin’s balls, Scarlett, I was only joking…" Evan shot back, laughing as though it were all one big jest.
Scarlett’s mouth tightened in distaste. She shook her head, taking a step back.
"Go on, Regulus, tell them…" She threw him a cutting look, fury blazing in her chest at his indifferent reaction, his face turned towards the pitch. "Say it, Regulus!" she pressed, her hand gripping the bat’s handle so hard the leather groaned. Rage seethed in her chest, molten and fast, fusing with her blood until not even the icy wind could cool it.
Scarlett lunged at Regulus in a flash, seizing him by the collar of his cloak with one hand, the other rising on instinct.
"SAY IT!"
Regulus’s reaction was to shut his eyes and flinch, as though bracing for a blow, while her roar carried across the entire Quidditch stadium, echoing even among their teammates. There was something dark in his expression, for the instant Red dared to look at her, he shuddered as if afraid. He might try to bury the feeling at all costs, but Scarlett could see it lurking at the edges of those guarded eyes.
"Going to stay quiet? Of course you are. Because that’s what you are: a coward!" she snarled, lowering her arm slowly.
"That’s enough of a show, Gaunt!" Evan raised his voice, laying a hand on her shoulder.
Scarlett jerked away, shaking her body free, her stance shifting to one of pure aggression.
"Don’t touch me, Death Eater!" The words dripped with such scorn she barely parted her lips, her teeth clenched tight. "Don’t touch me…"
"Or what?" Rosier licked his lower lip, insolence etched deep into his features.
She arched her brows, daring him. The Slytherin captain lifted his forefinger slowly, his grin widening with every inch closer it drew towards Scarlett, until it hovered just shy of her…
Evan recoiled with perfect reflex the moment Scarlett swung her bat at him, aiming for his arm.
"What the hell are you doing?" He threw both arms up, feigning confusion. "You’ve gone completely mental?"
"I have!" Scarlett bellowed, closing in on him dangerously. "I’ll kill every last one of you Death Eaters!"
"We weren’t the ones who killed your family." Evan’s revelation came with unsettling nonchalance.
"We?" The word shook on Scarlett’s lips. "What do you mean…"
"Use your head, Scarlett. Why the bloody hell would we kill your family if we wanted an alliance with your parents? If we were seeking their support?" He placed his hands on his hips, insolence sharpening his expression.
Scarlett blinked several times, his words sinking in, her breath choking in her throat. The bat slipped from her grasp, her eyes widening as the overcast world blurred, the players around her dissolving into shapeless figures. Then the fury struck like a blade, tearing her from within.
In the next instant, Scarlett leapt at Evan like a wildcat, seizing him by the collar and dragging him to the ground beneath the weight of her body.
"You’re one of them?!" she screamed, her glare demanding the truth.
Flat on the grass and gasping for air after the fall, Evan Rosier coughed a few times before flashing that infuriating smile, his dark eyes gleaming at Scarlett’s reaction. Her body was pressed atop his, hands crushing down on his throat, legs tangled with his so he couldn’t rise, her elbows digging into his chest. Her face was only inches from his own.
"Why so surprised?" he panted, his eyes darkening until there was no longer a difference between pupil and iris. "You’re already calling me that, thought I’d save you the trouble…"
Scarlett raised her fist, aiming a punch straight at Evan’s mouth to shut him up, but she was stopped when someone seized her from behind, hauling her off him as though she weighed no more than a feather. Struggling, Scarlett realised it was Brandon Nott, who threaded his arms beneath hers and clamped down on her wrists, forcing her still, while driving a knee into the backs of her legs to make her kneel.
"Let me go… fuck…" she snarled through gritted teeth, thrashing, but Brandon subdued her with ease, holding her in place even as she strained with all the strength she had. "LET ME GO, NOTT!"
"I know what you’re feeling." Evan ignored her screams, crouching before her and seizing her chin to force her gaze up. "My mother died when I was ten."
Scarlett thrashed harder, refusing to listen.
"I don’t give a fuck about your m—" Her voice was cut short by a silencing charm muttered by Rosier.
"For Merlin’s sake, Scarlett, shut your fucking mouth!" He raked a hand through his hair, exasperated, before gripping her jaw firmly, his shadowed eyes drilling into hers. "She died in childbirth. And I have never wanted to kill someone so badly as I wanted to kill my brother for taking her away from me… but, you know what they say… killing kin is one of the worst crimes ever committed. So, one fine day, my dear brother wanted to skate on the frozen lake near our home. I went along and watched the ice splinter and crack beneath his feet." The smile vanished from his face without a trace, leaving only the darkness in his eyes. "I watched him scream and beg and… when I finally moved to help him… it was too late. He drowned." He exhaled heavily.
Scarlett didn’t want to hear any of that shite, especially not when Rosier drew her into an embrace as though she needed comfort from him of all people. For some reason, the tears spilling down her face came faster, and she shrank in his arms when Brandon released her, the boy’s citrus scent making his words spiral chaotically through her mind.
"You… you let your brother die?!" She lifted her gaze to him, hand groping for her wand in the pocket of her Quidditch robes.
"Wasn’t it the same thing you did with yours?" The mockery in his tone was gone now, leaving only a softness Scarlett had never seen Rosier wear before. Was it genuine, or just another layer of deceit?
"What?" Scarlett tried to pull away from him on instinct, but Evan kept her in his arms.
"I saw the Boggart, Scarlett. And you called him. You called your brother. That means he was alive. And you let him die…" Evan narrowed his eyes, as though trying to drag the truth out of her.
"I did not let him die!" she snapped, shoving herself free. "You don’t know what you’re talking about, Death Eater!"
"Don’t I? Because from what I heard, he died along with your pa—"
Scarlett roared and lunged at Evan, striking him with wild punches and frantic shoves, her face flushed red with the fury blazing inside her.
"Shut up, shut up… SHUT UP!" she bellowed, burning through every breath in her lungs before stumbling and collapsing to her knees. "Shut your mouth, Rosier."
"This pain, Scar… it never gets better. It only worsens. If you don’t learn to handle it, it’ll eat you alive and destroy you." He picked up the bat from the grass and pressed it into her hand, forcing her fingers closed around it. "Put it out."
"I’ll put it out when I kill you!" Scarlett hurled herself at him, but Evan kicked open the Bludger chest, sending them bursting into the air before she could reach him.
"Murderer!"
"It wasn’t us!" He raised his hands as though swearing an oath. "There was no Dark Mark above your house – or did you see one?!"
"Liar!" she spat back, dodging and swinging at the Bludgers with difficulty. She was out of practice.
"I’ve proof of it." Evan’s smug smile returned.
Still batting Bludgers away, Scarlett shot him a look of disbelief.
"I don’t believe a word that comes out of your mouth!" she panted, the adrenaline coursing through her veins boiling her tears into pure rage. Her blood thundered in her ears.
"You don’t have to believe it," he said calmly. "But if you so much as open your mouth to say I’m a Death Eater, I’ll make sure Dumbledore hears it was Sirius who broke Avery’s arm."
She faltered for a moment, finally whipping out her wand to banish the Bludgers, which crashed back into the ground with heavy thuds.
"You don’t kn—"
"I’ve a witness." Evan cut her off, flicking a glance at Regulus.
Following his gaze, Scarlett turned to her brother-in-law, catching the fleeting instant where he lost control of his mask, panic flashing quicksilver through his iron-grey eyes.
Scarlett bit the inside of her cheek until she tasted blood. What was she even doing there? She knew all of them were Death Eaters, and those who weren’t… soon would be. Regulus among them. The same Regulus who had lied to her time and again, who had tried to poison her relationship with Sirius, who had crept into her mind and stolen her memories. The same Regulus who, moments earlier, had claimed to know nothing about Avery’s broken arm.
She stepped back, snatching up her broom on the way without once taking her eyes off Red.
She hadn’t been able to save Orfy.
And she couldn’t save Regulus either.
Scarlett turned on her heel and left the Quidditch pitch.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 59: I just want her back. The Scar I loved.
Chapter Text
CXXVII
Sirius Black wasn’t the sort to deny the things he did. Most of the time his pranks were harmless, like throwing dungbombs at unsuspecting students or casting a Trip Jinx whenever someone he disliked crossed his path.
The prank with Snape? That had been excessive, of course—he hadn’t truly wanted him dead, even though the possibility had been very real—nor had he wanted Remus to be the one to cause the Slytherin’s death! And what had happened with Avery? Well… Sirius couldn’t quite explain it, but there was something vile deep within his heart. Something no Gryffindor ought to feel, something putrid and corrosive. A twisted pleasure in hurting those who hurt the ones he loved. An inheritance of his rotten, pure blood, he supposed.
It was wrong, he knew that, yet the remorse he felt wasn’t genuine. He wasn’t troubled because he’d done it, but because he’d been caught. What weighed on him most was the resentment at not having planned it better so he wouldn’t now be forced to chew over his mistakes endlessly in his head.
Bloody hell, he should have checked they were alone in the Room of Requirement! Regulus had seen everything and now flatly refused to speak to him, as though he’d be the next to have his arm broken.
Sirius clenched his fists, forcing the most dissembling expression as he shook his head at Dumbledore’s question.
"I don’t know what you’re talking about, Headmaster," he muttered, curtly. "I was looking after Scarlett the whole time… I didn’t have a chance to go after Avery between classes!"
"It’s true, Headmaster, I didn’t see Sirius…" James began, leaping to his friend’s defence, but fell silent the moment Dumbledore raised his hand.
"You’d do anything to protect him." The Headmaster sighed, his tone accusatory. "Ask Horace to fetch Miss Gaunt here, if you would." He addressed a nearby portrait.
"Didn’t he fall from his broom?!" Remus scratched at his chin. He stood behind James, Peter and Sirius.
"Well, yes, but Mr Avery does have a history with Sirius and Scarlett…" Dumbledore stroked his beard with long, slender fingers. "I’d like to be certain he’s telling the truth."
Sirius pressed his lips together, projecting a calm he didn’t feel. He had no idea what punishment awaited if Dumbledore uncovered the truth—and the chances of Scarlett…
He didn’t want Scarlett to know it had been him. Beyond not knowing how she would react, he feared it might terrify her. And he knew all too well how frightened she already was. To be honest, it was difficult to recognise her beneath the layers of everything she was carrying.
And Sirius didn’t want her to go through one more thing.
It seemed to take an eternity before she arrived at the office, breathless and sweaty in her Quidditch robes; broom in one hand, bat in the other. Reading her expression was easier than Sirius had imagined—the tension running across her shoulders and the sharpness of her reflexes were enough to reveal that her Quidditch practice hadn’t been nearly as enjoyable as it should have been.
She had cried too. The redness at the tip of her nose betrayed it. That wasn’t unusual, though—rare were the days Scarlett didn’t cry, and though he had grown accustomed to it, he knew it wasn’t right. She needed a kind of help he simply couldn’t give.
Thinking on that left him even more frustrated than he already was.
He let out all the air in his lungs with the intent of standing, but she drew closer at a slow pace, forcing a smile for him.
"Did something happen?" Her tone was restrained. They were in Dumbledore’s presence; decorum was necessary. Yet Scarlett displayed that coldness with such natural ease that it left him bewildered.
"Yes, Miss Gaunt. I daresay you’ve heard of what happened with Mr Avery?" The Headmaster wore his usual, careless little smile, as though she could place her trust in him.
"It was mentioned during today’s practice…" She narrowed her gaze at Dumbledore, resting the broom against a small corner table. "He broke his arm, didn’t he?"
"Indeed, and that is why I asked you here." The wizard sighed deeply, adjusting the purple robes about his shoulders. "Do you, by any chance, know who was responsible?"
Sirius held his breath, his heart thundering in his chest as though he were about to be caught red-handed. As though his mother were climbing the stairs. As though his father had the whip in hand.
Scarlett closed the distance between them by slow degrees, stopping at his side and gripping his shoulder firmly. Sirius longed to meet her eyes, to understand what was going through her head, but that would have looked far too suspicious. He chose instead to face forward, stealing a glance at her through the metallic reflection of the clock on Dumbledore’s desk, all while wiping his sweaty palms against his trousers.
She lowered her gaze, her lashes casting a shadow across the blue of her eyes, darkening them with the grief clouding her heart. Then she raised her eyes again, and the shadow was dispelled by the golden glow of the candelabra, the warm tint staining the blue until it turned to green. Grief reforged itself into something else, something ominous and foul that made Sirius’s stomach burn.
Rage.
"I do." She brushed her thumb against the corner of her lips, as if to wipe away something invisible that threatened to spill from her mouth.
"Who, Miss Gaunt?!"
Scarlett fixed her gaze on him. She knew. Sirius’s eyes widened, his irises flickering as though begging her to stay silent. Yet there was a malignant aura catalysed in her stare, revealing a version of his Scarlett he didn’t like one bit. Her vengeful facet surfaced so swiftly Sirius hadn’t time to anticipate what she did next:
"Regulus." The name slipped so smoothly from her lips that even Dumbledore looked startled, his brows lifting beneath the half-moon spectacles.
Sirius opened his mouth to object, but Scarlett silenced him with a single look. What the bloody hell was she doing?
"Mr Black?!" Dumbledore’s lips parted, his voice pitched a note higher than usual. "Are you certain of this?!"
"I am." She spoke with such firmness that, had Sirius not known the truth, he would have believed her. "I had no idea what had happened, as I spent the whole week with Sirius… but Regulus told me during Quidditch practice earlier."
"Did he mention the reason?"
Scarlett shrugged, as if the motive meant nothing to her.
The Headmaster drew a deep breath, and for the first time Sirius noticed a line of exasperation crease his otherwise placid features.
"Summon Mr Black to my office, if you would," he asked of another portrait nearby. "Yes, the Slytherin one. The younger."
Taking advantage of the distraction, Sirius caught Scarlett’s hand and squeezed, leaving his fingerprints pressed deep. She met his stare with equal intensity, raising a brow. He furrowed his own, jaw tensing. Scarlett tugged at her lips and rolled her eyes with condescension. Sirius exhaled harshly, almost a hiss, and she clenched her chin, fingers gripping tightly at his Gryffindor cloak. He softened his hold, eased his brow, and brushed his thumb over the gloved knuckles of her hand. She suddenly glanced upwards, the corner of her mouth twitching as though she’d just done something terribly wrong.
Regulus didn’t take long to arrive. Like Scarlett, he was still clad in Slytherin Quidditch robes and carried his broom in his right hand. He set the Nimbus beside Scarlett’s Firebolt and raked a hand through his dark, faintly wavy hair, looking at Sirius with a clear, untroubled face.
"Headmaster… you asked for me?" His monotone voice jolted Sirius from his daze.
Sirius straightened at once. Bloody hell, Scarlett…
"Is it true that you were the one who broke Avery’s arm?"
Regulus was caught off guard, letting out an incredulous puff of air as though he’d just heard utter nonsense.
"Beg your pardon, Headmaster?" He furrowed his brow, folding his arms.
"Tell him what you said to me earlier, Red." Scarlett’s hiss made the nickname sound more insult than endearment. "About how you broke Avery’s arm."
Sirius watched his brother swallow hard, slowly, as though his saliva had turned thick. He had never seen Regulus falter like that before. Several muscles in his face slipped out of control as spasms twitched at his nose and cheeks, before he forced all expression from his features, donning a mask of confidence without once breaking his gaze from Scarlett, whose nostrils flared.
He said nothing. Not until his eyes hardened, turning to steel, sliding across the room until they locked onto Sirius. He didn’t need to open his mouth for Sirius to know the question his brother was asking.
No… it wasn’t a question. It was a choice.
And Sirius would always choose Scarlett. Regulus knew that, but it was as though he wanted to be proven wrong. What a foolish thought, to imagine Sirius would take the blame to shield him! No matter how many times he had done so in the past, the boy seated before him wasn’t his brother.
He was nothing more than Scarlett’s lapdog.
"Yes, it was me." The admission came terse, all eyes snapping to him.
Dumbledore rubbed at his eyelids and drew in a long breath, setting his spectacles once more on the bridge of his long nose.
"Leave us, if you would." The request was directed at the rest.
Sirius dragged Scarlett along with him the entire way, his head spinning from what he had just witnessed. He could hardly see where he was going until he halted in front of the prefects’ bathroom, James, Remus and Peter right behind him.
"What’s the password for the bathroom?!" The question sounded more like a demand.
"Ganache," Remus supplied, and the door creaked open.
"It wasn’t your brother, was it?" James didn’t bother hiding his scepticism as he adjusted his glasses.
Sirius ignored the question. He knew Wormtail hadn’t betrayed him, but James knew him too well to be fooled by excuses. He shoved Scarlett inside and locked the door behind them, his face hot and his expression lines drawn tight. He had promised himself he wouldn’t shout at her, and though there was plenty choking in his chest, Sirius would try his utmost to keep his word.
"Why?!" His voice came through gritted teeth, harsh and thick with tension.
The bathroom’s soft light came from the sunbeams filtering through the long linen curtains that covered the windows, bouncing off the splendid structure of pure white marble, from the walls to the empty pool. The mermaid in the portrait beside them was awake, giving a sly giggle at the sight of them there.
Scarlett’s face drained of colour. She hadn’t expected to be confronted—not like this—and her restless eyes avoided him fiercely, fixing instead on every piece of decoration around them.
"If he wants to be a liar, then he should at least to make a decent job of it…"
"What are you talking about?" Sirius cut across her, gripping her thin wrist tighter than he should, feeling the blood rush chaotically beneath his fingers.
"Regulus… he…" Scarlett let out a long breath, a failed attempt to calm herself. "He told me he had no idea who did that to Avery and then… Rosier said he saw everything!" She tried to yank her arm free, but Sirius didn’t yield. "He lied to me, Sirius, without even… without even hesitating!" Her face trembled as the words left her lips, sharp and ragged.
Sirius’s features twisted, incredulous.
"That doesn’t justify… you accused him of something I did and now… do you realise what my parents might do to him?!" he hissed, utterly dumbfounded. He still hadn’t managed to process any of what was happening.
Scarlett let out a bitter smile, scathing and laced with derision.
"Why aren’t you angry with him?! Regulus lied to me, Sirius, he saw you and… and… why are you taking his side?!" Her voice was already hoarse from shouting so much that day. Her eyes blazed with an indignation he had never seen in her before. "Isn’t this what you wanted? For me to stop making excuses for him? I don’t understand you!"
"I’m not taking his side, Reg was wrong, but that’s the bloody point! Two wrongs don’t make a right!" Sirius released her with a sudden jerk, stepping back, startled at how Scarlett’s pale face now burned scarlet.
"I DON’T CARE!" she exploded, a vein pulsing at her temple. Frustrated sparks shot from the blue of her eyes. "He’s a liar! He deserves to pay for it!"
Sirius felt his heart pounding painfully in his chest, blood hammering in his ears, his body stiff with a nervousness that left his palms slick with sweat. He couldn’t think straight, couldn’t speak straight—Merlin, he could hardly breathe. Scarlett had taken everything from him; his breath, his words, his reason.
"Who are you?" he whispered, his tone almost fearful. "I… I don’t recognise you anymore, Scarlett. Since what happened… you seem like someone else."
Scarlett wrapped her arms around herself, tears stinging her eyes and rolling down her cheeks, yet she didn’t cry. Her chest heaved, but no sob, no whimper left her lips. Something else was rising inside her, something feeding on grief and blinding her with a red haze across her blurred vision.
"That Scarlett is dead!" she spat, hurling her broom to the floor with force. "She died with her parents!"
She buried her hands in her hair, claws digging into her scalp, filling her lungs with every shred of air she could muster before screaming at the top of her voice. The sound made Sirius squeeze his eyes shut and clamp his hands over his ears, her raw cry bouncing off the marble walls and sending shivers skittering down his spine. It dragged that day back to the surface—the stench of fire, the fall of ashes, the darkness of smoke…
Thankfully, Scarlett stopped once the sobs began. She choked as her fury dissolved into that vulnerability which revealed the girl he knew, the one who had lost her family and lost herself.
Sirius shuddered, trying to expel from his body the sickening brush of memories from that day which refused to leave him be.
Even beneath layer upon layer of Slytherin Quidditch uniform, Sirius still saw Scarlett for who she was. Perhaps that was why she was so unsettled. He understood her drive, her grief, and he knew she knew just how wrong her actions had been.
"Revenge won’t bring your family back, Scar." Sirius raked a hesitant hand through his hair, the disappointment plain in his tone. "This isn’t fair. I know you’re in pain, but it isn’t fair."
Scarlett slowly collapsed to the side, lying down on the marble floor of the bathroom, using the emerald-green hem of her cloak to hide her face like a shamed child.
"I’m sorry." Her voice was muffled.
Sirius gave a discomfited sniff, massaging his temple with thumb and forefinger. There was a ringing in the back of his skull that seemed to conduct the boil rising inside him, that wanted to turn everything and everyone around him into shrapnel—Scarlett included. Especially Scarlett.
It was a whisper at his ear, it was all his demons roused by the woman he loved, it was his darkest desires crawling out from the inhospitable, cobwebbed corners of his heart.
He clenched his fists and shoved them deep into his trouser pockets, because it was safer that way. He would never hurt Scarlett, not even if it meant hurting himself.
"It’s not me you should be apologising to." Sirius panted, oxygen running thin.
Scarlett pushed herself up onto her elbows, raising her gaze to him, lips pressed into a cruel and unpleasant line as tremors wracked her body. She stared at him with grim resolve.
As though she were in Whiskers’s skin, she sprang to her feet, snatched her broom from the floor, and straightened her spine, her chin raised with the same arrogance Sirius himself could summon so easily.
"I won’t apologise to him!" She drew nearer, stumbling as though she hadn’t full control of her body. "He deserved it!"
Before Sirius had the chance to open his mouth, she darted him a look and quickened her pace towards the door, slamming it shut behind her. He remained there, frozen, staring at the place she had just vanished through. His insides churned and the air thinned. He was crying—he knew it—but it was as if he were merely a spectator of what was happening to his own body.
The pressure in his chest rose suddenly, driving the air from his lungs and refusing to let it return. His vision blurred and soon his legs gave way. Sirius braced his hands on his knees, struggling to steady what was happening to him, the ragged sound of his breath disturbing the bathroom’s calm.
Even with Scarlett right beside him, he felt he couldn’t reach her. It was as though she were metres away, as though the connection they shared, the one that had always been there, had tangled into some impossible knot. And the mere suggestion that he was losing her was suffocating.
His hands trembled violently; he wiped the back of one across his sweating brow, pressing the other to the wall. The stone was cool against his burning palm, against the fever that scorched through his body.
Someone spoke to him, but his heart pounded so loudly he could hear nothing but his own breathing. Pink-tipped fingers, nails perfectly painted orange, trailed through his beard, and all he could do was follow them to the face they belonged to.
"Sirius? Sirius, look at me." She knelt beside him, cupping his face with gentle hands, forcing his focus into her eyes. "Breathe slowly… breathe with me."
Sirius didn’t know what he was doing, and breathing was almost impossible beneath the furious waves crashing within him, turning his breaths into erratic, insufficient gasps. He had no idea how long it took before he began to follow Lily’s rhythm—it must have been several minutes, for it was so damned hard. So hard to swim back to the surface of that whirlpool, so terrifying to imagine that Scarlett… that… that she…
He choked on his own sobs, tangled with his panting gulps, snapping out of his daze as he collapsed into Lily’s arms, his shoulders shaking with uncontrollable weeping. Sirius no longer cared about seeming strong before her; he only wanted a place where he could feel safe.
"I don’t know what to do with her, Lily." His voice came out strangled. "She… she’s destroying herself and I… I… don’t know how to help her." He pressed himself against Lily’s body, seeking the same comfort he usually found in Scarlett’s embrace. He didn’t find it. Still, he searched desperately for anything that might ease the pain devouring him whole. "I… I j-just want her b-back… th-that Scar… the Scar I lo-loved… it f-feels like… l-like she’s… gone…" The words were torn apart by sobs. "I-I’m lo-sing her… d-d-don’t kn-know wh-what to do… she’s g-gonna l-leave me… she’s…"
Lily held Sirius tightly, her red hair tumbling like a cascade of lava over her shoulders. Her fingers dared to stroke through Sirius’s black locks, and he screwed his eyes shut, weeping uncontrollably. She had never realised how fragile Sirius Black could be. Scarlett had that power over him—she could reduce him to a little boy seeking a lap to curl into with the snap of her fingers.
"It’s all right… you’ll find a way." She whispered it with such conviction that Sirius believed her at once. "You always do."
.
.
.
Scarlett had been awake for some time, yet she remained still in Sirius’s arms, sinking into his presence. The calm she felt, coupled with the gentleness that pulsed through her heart as his warm body held hers… she couldn’t remember ever feeling anything like it before. The certainty that this was where she belonged, that she didn’t need to be afraid because she was safe, that none of her demons could reach her, for the light of the brightest star in the sky was enough to chase them away.
She closed her eyes and listened to Sirius’s heart beat steadily. His chest rose slowly and fell heavily, his breathing loud enough to sound almost like a snore. She opened her eyes again, slowly, gazing at the long, dark hair scattered across the pillow, a few strands falling over his closed eyes. His expression mirrored such profound peace that Scarlett was certain it was rare. As rare as a night without nightmares for her.
A discreet smile curved her lips as she lingered there, admiring the man she loved so deeply, wishing the moment would never end. That time could freeze, that Sirius’s serenity would never fade, and that she might always remain in his arms. It was as though she were inside a dream so sweet it could be nothing but an illusion.
She and Sirius, together again.
Her heart skipped a few beats.
When Scarlett leaned closer with gentle caution, just to study him more closely, Sirius’s breath hitched and he stirred.
"What are you doing?" he murmured, his voice husky, eyes still shut.
Scarlett sniffled a soft laugh, her cheeks burning as though they were still teenagers.
"Making sure this isn’t a dream," she murmured, pressing a tender kiss to the tattoo above Sirius’s heart.
He grunted, pulling her tighter against his body, grinding the bulge in his groin against her belly, dragging her closer by the waist as if he would never let her slip away.
"If it were a dream, it wouldn’t feel half as good as this," he said, lethargic, his hot breath brushing Scarlett’s temple.
"Liar," she teased, rolling her eyes.
Before she could say more, Sirius tilted his face to hers, pressing a kiss to her lips as he moved over her with a possessive weight, his body rubbing against hers with clear intent. Desire already thrummed through him, straining in the ache of his erection, so he took Scarlett’s hand and guided it to himself, closing her fingers around his cock.
"Sirius… I need to work…" Scarlett murmured against his mouth, her palm sliding up and down his length with delicious pressure.
"Work… can wait…" he gasped, a frustrated growl catching in his throat when she stopped stroking him. "Please…"
He didn’t need to ask twice. Scarlett began to move her fist again, tightening and twisting on the upstroke, easing on the way down. Sirius groaned loudly, his hands roaming Scarlett’s back before hitching one of her legs around his waist, letting her grind her cunt along the length of his cock as she pleasured him.
"Hmm… think your job can wait a little longer?" Sirius asked wickedly, mercury eyes flashing with pure mischief.
"You’re going to get me sacked…" Scarlett bit down on his lower lip, dragging her mouth against his.
"That’s the idea," he agreed, a sinful grin curling his lips as shivers of ecstasy coursed through his nerves, pulling him closer to the edge. "All the more…" He shifted his hips, lining himself at Scarlett’s entrance. "…if you go in today with my cum dripping down your thighs."
He pushed into her slowly, pulling out and sliding back in with such agonising slowness that Scarlett hauled him closer, clutching him tight against her body. Sirius kept to the dragging rhythm, chasing his own climax, surrendering to the overwhelming wave that rippled through him in an uncontrollable shudder.
It wasn’t long before his cock throbbed with bliss, spilling inside Scarlett as he loosed a string of desperate moans into her mouth.
Breathless, he buried his face against the curve of her neck, his hair falling over her shoulders as he thrust deeper, pushing his release as far into her as he could. She brushed his hair back from his face, blinking slowly as the soporific warmth washed over her, enfolding her in languid peace.
"I need to work…" She smiled, brushing him away with a gentle touch to his chest.
"No." Sirius let out a noise of displeasure, burying his head in the pillow in a dramatic attempt to stop her from getting up, unwilling to let her go.
"Sirius…" Scarlett laughed, pushing at him until she slipped free. The absence of her warm body and the loss of the tight heat of her cunt left him with a dreadful sense of desolation. "I’d really love to stay here all morning, but I can’t."
Sirius rolled over the sheets steeped in Scarlett’s scent. He barely realised he wore a foolish grin as he moved the pillow aside, gazing at her with a sleepy expression.
Scarlett bore all the marks of the previous night—hickeys on her neck and shoulder, along with the bruise on her arse from when he’d fucked her at the gig. His lips curved in arrogance as he admired his come still trickling from between her thighs while she retrieved her clothes from the floor one by one, pulling them on.
"You look good in my clothes, but you look even better in nothing," he remarked, propping his chin in his hand as he ogled her shamelessly.
Scarlett, half-dressed, looked at him with embarrassment tinged with amusement.
"Shut up…"
"What? I’m only telling the truth." He shrugged, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
"You’re only saying that because you shagged me," Scarlett scoffed, running her hands through her hair before stepping into the bathroom.
"Because I want to shag you again," he corrected, with a dark chuckle. "Twelve years without sex… worst bloody years of my life…"
"What are you complaining about?! I went fifteen without…"
"Actually… if we count the year we spent at Hogwarts… that makes thirteen and sixteen…" Sirius closed his eyes, moving his fingers as if to calculate. "Does it?"
"Sirius… it’s eight in the morning." She emerged from the bathroom with her hair combed, teeth brushed and face washed. "Go back to sleep."
"I can’t sleep any more," he grumbled, dragging himself out of bed with a yawn.
"Why not?" She slipped on her shoes, her eyes never leaving him.
Sirius shrugged.
"Dunno… there’s this strange sort of thrill in my chest… a buzzing in my heart as though… as though…"
As though I were hopelessly in love, he wanted to say, but stopped the thought midway.
Scarlett smiled—a true, shy smile that set all the butterflies in Sirius’s stomach fluttering. She tucked her platinum hair behind her ear and rose on tiptoe to press a kiss to his lips.
"I know how you feel," she whispered, and his heart thundered wildly in his chest.
It had been a long time since he’d seen that Scarlett. She had come to him now and again, but always hidden behind the skirts of guilt and fear. The woman before him now, however… she seemed different. Still the same Scarlett, yes, but she was smiling with such ease that Sirius found himself wrong-footed.
She left the room, and he stood staring at the door like an idiot, not knowing what to do. The weight in his chest was gone, leaving only the sweet memories of the night before—Scarlett telling him she wanted him, that she loved him. That she had never stopped loving him, not for a single second…
"For Merlin’s sake, why the bloody hell are you starkers?!" Reggie all but shouted from the doorway of his room.
Sirius slammed it shut with a wandless, wordless spell, leaping as though he’d just been struck by lightning.
He drew a deep breath and dragged a hand down his face, disoriented.
His heart nearly burst from his chest with the realisation of his dream.
.
.
.
Meanwhile, in the kitchen, Scarlett found Penny preparing breakfast. The elf cast her one of those naturally distrustful looks as she sliced up a handful of strawberries to garnish the pancakes.
"Penny, my clothes…"
"Penny left them on the sofa." She didn’t wait for Scarlett to finish speaking.
"Thank you." Scarlett left the kitchen and found the garments folded and clean upon the dark leather backrest.
"You’ll never guess what we found out about Harry!" James flung himself onto the sofa, radiating the same good humour Scarlett carried.
"What did you find out?" she asked quietly, slipping into the washroom to change.
He followed her in.
"Harry killed a basilisk!" His ghostly arms flailed, cutting straight through the sink and part of the wall. "And… and… do you remember Myrtle? She was killed by the basilisk and it nearly killed Hermione as well and—"
"James…" Scarlett lifted her hand after shrugging on her red leather jacket. It was far too warm for it, but so much was happening that she didn’t care. "Can we talk about this later?!"
"Argh… fine." He ruffled his hair. "But only because you and Sirius are back together again."
"We’re not…"
"Uh-huh, I’ll pretend I believe that." James folded his arms, adjusting his glasses on his face.
Scarlett felt her cheeks heat. She swept past the ghost in an instant, entering the kitchen where Sirius, Reggie, Harry and Remus stood, along with Penny, who looked rather moved.
"Young Master Potter looks so very much like his father…" She dabbed at the tears rolling from her enormous eyes. "That rat’s-nest hair…" Reggie choked at the elf’s remark. "That little nose… those round cheeks…" Her long, thin fingers brushed over Harry’s scar. "And those eyes full of kindness…" She cradled the boy’s face in both hands, leaving him utterly dumbstruck by her display. "The very same as my beloved Mistress Potter’s."
"You… you knew… my parents?!" Harry stammered, flustered.
Penny let him go and placed her hands on her hips, shaking her head as though the question were a personal insult.
"’Course I knew them! I changed your second nappy!" She scratched impatiently at one of her great, bat-like ears.
"I didn’t… I didn’t know that." Harry adjusted his glasses with the very same tic James had possessed.
"I know." She pinched the tip of his nose. "Now you do."
Harry flushed, especially when he noticed everyone watching him. He shifted his gaze to Scarlett, gave her a timid smile, and returned to his toast with jam.
"Does Mistress Black want anything?" Penny’s tennis-ball eyes turned to her, as she stood at the entrance of the kitchen.
"Want you to stop calling me Mistress Black," Scarlett muttered, crossing the room to the fridge and taking out a bottle of milk.
"I meant to eat…"
"No need, I’m already late for work." She checked her pocket watch, greeted by the photo of a young Sirius sticking out his tongue at her. Her lips curved at once, her gaze pulled to the man with the long black hair seated at the table.
A shiver ran up Scarlett’s neck when she realised Sirius was watching her too, through the rebellious strands falling into his face. His eyes were lit with that burning thing between them, electrifying the grey until it became molten silver. He was smiling too, and Scarlett marvelled at how he could look both the eighteen-year-old boy she had once known and, at the same time, the thirty-four-year-old man who, like his younger self, was still saving her from drowning in herself.
An overwhelming urge to cry seized her, though not from sadness. Scarlett let out a breathy little laugh, opening and closing her mouth, words fleeing her mind under the weight of those eyes that stripped her bare. Not merely of clothing, but of lies, pretence, masks.
Sirius saw her as she truly was—and that was terrifying.
"Something on my face?" he quipped, wiping his lips and beard with a napkin.
"I… er…" Scarlett swallowed hard, for now Harry and Regulus were staring at her as well. "My… my clothes. Where did you put them?"
"Your clothes?"
"Yes… f-from when…" She cleared her throat. "From before I… left…"
"Oh." Sirius raised his brows and tossed his hair back over his shoulder. Remus, who had seemed far too occupied with the Daily Prophet, glanced sidelong at his friend. "I… burned them."
Scarlett stood frozen for a few seconds, taking in what he had just said.
"You burned my clothes?" she repeated, with greater emphasis.
Reggie and Harry glanced back and forth between the two.
"I did." Sirius sipped his coffee and shrugged, dismissing the matter as unimportant.
Scarlett opened her mouth, eager to provoke him, but gave up when Remus turned a page of his newspaper with more force than necessary, casting her a warning look. She only let out a long breath to steady herself.
"Yeah… I suppose I’d have done the same if I were you," she admitted, her tone hesitant.
Sirius watched, astonished, as Scarlett’s aura dissolved and her aggressive stance softened. He hadn’t expected her to yield, not when he had been so certain they were about to argue, already having lined up several points in his head to defend himself.
"See you at the arcade then?!" She looked at him before glancing at Reggie and Harry.
"Yes, at the arcade!" her son answered with such enthusiasm that Scarlett quickly caught it herself.
"See you at three then." Scarlett hugged the bottle of milk to her chest, waved as she spun on her heel, and walked to the hall, ready to leave… until she realised the three of them were still staring at her in a silence that felt rather awkward. "What?"
"You’re leaving like that, without saying goodbye?" Sirius put a hand to his chest, mock-offended.
Scarlett let out a sharp breath, not quite sure how to respond. She went over to Reggie and kissed him fondly on the cheek.
"See you later, son." The radiant expression on his face made her heart skip a few beats.
"See you, Mum."
Then she kissed Harry on the cheek, and he pulled a face, touching the spot before smiling sheepishly.
"We’ll buy you some Beatles tapes at the shops today," she whispered to him. She straightened, ready to go, but her gaze landed on Sirius, standing before her with arms folded and foot tapping against the floor as though waiting for his turn.
Scarlett furrowed her brow, and Sirius narrowed his. She drew a deep breath and circled the table, leaning in to press a quick kiss to his cheek, but he turned his face.
Her lips met his. The touch lasted but a moment, yet it was enough to make her eyes widen and a dazed smile spread across her lips.
"Idiot," she murmured.
"You liked it." Sirius leaned back with his hands behind his head, thoroughly entertained. "And you, Moony, fancy a goodbye kiss as well?" he looked to his friend at the head of the table, whose eyes rolled at the suggestion.
"No." He straightened his newspaper, his foot bouncing emphatically on his knee.
Scarlett shook her head, unable to hide her smile. She gave Sirius a light pat on the shoulder, and he returned it with a wink.
"See you at three," she repeated, hurrying out of the house.
"I still don’t get it. You two ended up together… but she didn’t marry Reg’s dad?" Harry wrinkled his nose, sipping his pumpkin juice.
"Oh, Harry… don’t try to make sense of those two. They never make sense," Remus muttered, coffee cup in one hand while he flicked through the paper with the other.
Sirius only laughed at his friend’s grumble, unfazed by his grouchy state.
"It doesn’t need to make sense." He ruffled Harry’s hair and slung an arm around Reg’s shoulders.
It didn’t need to make sense. Scarius had always been the beginning, the middle, and the end. All the years he had spent suffering in Azkaban were finally gaining meaning—because now, he would be happy. Happy as he had never been before, even without his best friend by his side. He would be happy because he deserved to be happy, and he would seize that happiness with such ferocity that nothing in this broken world could ever take it away.
Sirius Black would be happy with his family. That was the incontestable truth he embraced, the foundation that gave his life meaning after all the hell he had endured.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 60: The ones who love us never truly leave us
Notes:
Hi, folks. Sorry for the delay. These past two weeks have been crazy and stressful. I translated this chapter a while ago but completely forgot to revise it. I hope you enjoy it and don’t give up on me <3
Chapter Text
CXXVIII
The streets of London in the summer were naturally filled with families strolling about and youngsters enjoying themselves. But that day was no ordinary one. Not for Scarlett Gaunt, who had just parked her Honda NSX beside the Hanging Man, stepping inside with a grin stretching from ear to ear. She greeted Danny with a wave and slipped on her apron almost mechanically.
"My God, what’s happened to you?" Danny asked, wiping down the drinks counter with his brows arched.
"What do you think, Danny?!" Lily looked at him with disdain.
"What d’you mean?" Scarlett furrowed her brow, casting a glance at the door to check whether any customers were arriving.
"Happy because your son’s on holiday?" He leaned on the wooden counter, his black hair tied in a ponytail falling across his shoulders.
"Yes!" She pressed her lips together as she gave the reply. It wasn’t entirely true — of course she was thrilled to have Reg and Harry around — but the real reason behind all that joy had a name and starry eyes.
"Fair enough…" Danny muttered.
Both straightened when the bell rang, announcing the arrival of a couple with two children. Scarlett hurried to serve them and observed the way the mother treated her boys. Speaking in a gentle tone, touching their faces with tenderness, and listening to them with undivided attention.
It made her think of her own mother and how she had been treated. Nyx had been rather tactile, but at the same time the distance between them had never been physical. There had been a gap between her and her mother that was never bridged, and no crossing ever seemed enough to close it. She didn’t want her bond with Reggie to be like that, nor with Harry.
She sighed. Thinking of Nyx brought a pang to her heart.
She weaved through the bar and left the order in the kitchen, wondering how to behave with Reggie and Harry. Reg was clearly like Sirius, eager for physical contact, whilst Harry… he didn’t seem particularly accustomed to that sort of affection. But then again… considering who his uncles were…
"How do you reckon Harry would like to be treated?" Scarlett murmured to Lily, who was trailing back and forth beside her with an exultant expression. James and Regulus were far too entertained watching the workings of the bar’s kitchen.
Lily stroked her delicate chin, tilting her head from side to side as if in thought.
"I mean… he doesn’t seem much of a fan of hugs," Scarlett added.
"Every child loves hugs, Scar. If he doesn’t, it’s because something very serious happened." Lily replied matter-of-factly, before throwing her head back as she connected what she had just said with Harry’s behaviour. "D-do you… do you think…"
Scarlett cast a tender glance at her friend.
"It doesn’t matter anymore. He doesn’t live with his uncles now." She whispered, trying to calm Lily, who seemed caught in a spiral of suppositions, as though so many things were suddenly beginning to make sense.
"I don’t… I can’t believe that…" She shook her head in disbelief, her red hair whipping from side to side. "My own sister…"
"We always knew Petunia was a bitch." Scarlett rubbed her nose, seething. "But not even I would’ve guessed she’d mistreat Harry…"
"Scar… will you promise me something?" Lily cut across her, placing her hands over her chest. "Look after him as if he were your own?"
Scarlett froze for a moment, then let out a flustered huff of a smile.
"’Course I will. Why’re you saying that as if… as if you might vanish?" she teased, grabbing the tray with the orders.
"I don’t know… what if your Signet stops working and…" Lily faltered. "It just makes me calmer knowing… because, you see, you’d have been his godmother if…"
Lily never finished the sentence. Not that she needed to. Scarlett served a table and turned back, hugging the tray to her chest. Her pale face was now taut with seriousness, though quickly a strained smile pulled at her lips.
"I know, Lils." Scarlett dropped her gaze to her shoes. "And I would’ve been."
"You can be, now."
Scarlett nodded, her eyes rising to the livid glow Lily emitted, the translucence of her friend twisting her heart. She was dead and could never touch her son. She could never live alongside Harry knowing she was there.
"I’m sorry for… for not…" She glanced around, making sure no one was paying her any attention. "For leaving. For missing your wedding to James… for…"
"It’s all right." Lily opened that smile that could melt anyone. Her eyes, ever so green and so vivid, radiated a gentleness intrinsic to her soul. "You’re here now. That’s what matters."
"I’ll make it up. Promise."
"I know you will." She tried to touch her friend’s face, only for her fingers to slip through the freckled cheeks.
Scarlett was wrenched from her daze when a customer called her over, and she rushed to them. Though she stood there, jotting down orders, collecting plates and cutlery from the table and serving, her mind was entirely elsewhere. Knowing that Lily and James could never play an active part in Harry’s life stung, but bloody hell, Scarlett had never even considered living what she was living now.
In Azkaban, there hadn’t been the faintest scrap of hope or possibility of escape. Least of all with Sirius.
Especially with Sirius.
And after everything they had been through…
They were together again.
Her whole body tingled and she shivered, carrying yet another round of orders on her tray, unable to hide the easy smiles and restless energy in each step she took.
Bloody hell, she and Sirius…
"Morning!" Mike strode through the door and waved at her, a cigarette between his lips.
"Morning." Scarlett flashed a smile that showed all her teeth, and Mike squinted at her, not dragging on his cigarette, staring at her as though he’d just spotted an alien. "You all right?"
"I’m great!" She tossed her hair back and dropped three orders off in the kitchen. "Why?"
"Shagged last night?" The drummer pulled the cigarette from his mouth and leaned an elbow on the bar counter, stroking the beard on his chin.
"What?" Scarlett burst into an awkward laugh, her face burning. "Where d’you get that from?"
"I’ve never seen you smiling at the walls like that…" Mike planted his hands on his hips, baffled.
"I’m like this because my son’s on… oh, you know what, Mike? Fuck off!" She flipped him the middle finger and spun on her heel, heading for the kitchen.
"What’s bitten her?" he asked Danny, who was behind the counter and let out a snorting laugh at the scene he’d just witnessed.
"Nothing, mate, she’s just happy ‘cause of her boy…" The guitarist snatched the cigarette from Mike and stubbed it out in the sink.
"Hundred quid says she shagged last night." The blond’s mouth stretched into a wicked grin.
"Jesus, Mike…" Danny rolled his eyes.
"With the bloke she hates, no less. What was his name again? The one who barged into her dressing room at the last gig?" Mike turned his head towards Scarlett, following her with his gaze.
"Her brother-in-law?!"
"Yeah, him."
"Mate, she hates her brother-in-law." Danny grabbed a pair of mugs and began filling them with beer.
"I know. Still betting a hundred they shagged." He pulled another cigarette from the packet in his pocket, only for Danny to snatch it away once more as he narrowed his eyes at his mate.
"Since you’re so keen to lose money…" The wager was sealed with a handshake.
.
.
.
"Think of it this way, Harry…" Sirius gestured. "What would you like to have in your room?"
Harry shook his head, as if he hadn’t the faintest clue. He’d never had the chance to choose anything. What to eat, what to wear, or what to do. With the Dursleys, everything had been imposed and mandatory, and his only option was to lower his head and accept it. Now, Sirius’s question sent such a chill through his stomach that…
"I reckon a bathroom’s important," Reggie suggested, leaning against the corridor wall behind them.
"What did my dad have in his room?" Harry pressed his lips together, staring at Sirius and Remus at his side.
"Posters of Puddlemere United… some of the banners they made for him from the matches we played… his medals for Best Player of the Year…"
"What d’you mean we played?!" Harry raised a single eyebrow, folding his arms.
"Sirius was Gryffindor’s Beater." It was Remus who replied, with a nostalgic smile as his fingers brushed over his full moustache.
"You played with my dad?" His expression turned to surprise. "He was a Seeker, wasn’t he?!"
"He also played as a Chaser." Sirius nodded, placing a hand on his godson’s shoulder. "You won the Cup this year, didn’t you?! James used to keep the medals on a shelf, and the Puddlemere United posters above the door…"
"We could get some Gryffindor banners too, like Reg’s room has Slytherin ones in his uncle’s house," Remus conjectured.
"And a Beatles poster for your door… to match mine with the Whitesnake one." Reg added, shoving his hands into his pockets.
"And… um…" Harry rubbed his face, embarrassed. "Some of the photos from their album you showed me… if… if that’s possible…"
"’Course it’s possible!" Sirius rolled his eyes, as if his godson’s insecurity were nonsense. "Ready, Moony?"
"Shall we mirror Reg’s room first and then shift the furniture about?!" Remus looked at Sirius, who answered with a nod. "Lads, give us some space."
Harry and Regulus stepped back to the start of the corridor, watching Sirius spin his wand in a spell they’d never seen before, whilst Remus aimed his at Reg’s door.
The corridor began to stretch as another door appeared between Regulus’s and Remus’s rooms. They heard the creak of the house’s wooden frame, dust fell from the ceiling, the floor cracked, and Harry’s doorway wavered, stretching until it reached a normal size, pushing the other rooms aside.
"Reparo," Reggie whispered, fixing the floating wooden floorboards.
"Looks like it worked." Sirius opened the door, revealing a room identical to Reg’s, only mirrored, from the entrance to the bathroom, to the wardrobes and the bed. He was the first to step in, stamping down firmly to make sure the room wouldn’t squeeze back in on itself.
That sometimes happened when the spell was poorly performed.
[Music: The Beatles — Here, There and Everywhere]
To lead a better life, I need my love to be here
Here, making each day of the year
Changing my life with a wave of her hand
Nobody can deny that there’s something there
Harry, however, barely noticed Sirius and Remus’s safety checks. His heart seemed determined to burst, beating so fast between his ribs that it dampened his eyes and set his stomach aflame. Something very strange was blooming in his chest, a stillness that pulled him from his natural state of alertness. He rolled his shoulders, feeling the tension melt away as a pleasant warmth radiated through his entire being.
There, running my hands through her hair
Both of us thinking how good it can be
Someone is speaking, but she doesn’t know he’s there
"Penny, bring Hedwig’s cage and Harry’s trunk!" Reggie’s voice echoed at the back of his mind.
He watched, absorbed and overwhelmed, as Sirius filled one of the little tables with photographs of his parents, conjuring frames and setting them with the images from the album. Remus, meanwhile, moved his wand to summon a bundle of scarlet and gold decorations from the attic — a streamer he fixed by the headboard of the bed, a huge Gryffindor banner that hung beside the wardrobe, and an animated poster of the entire Puddlemere United team that had once belonged to his father.
I want her everywhere
And if she’s beside me, I know I need never care
But to love her is to need her everywhere
Regulus joined them. He set Hedwig’s cage by the open window and mounted a stand on the wall so Harry could display his Firebolt. Sirius opened the wardrobe and asked if that space would be enough.
Harry couldn’t answer. It was as though he’d lost the ability to speak, so he only nodded awkwardly. Penny had begun to unpack his trunk, and he would have stopped her if he could move, but he was far too stunned, realising that this was his room. That these people weren’t there because they were obliged to put up with him…
Knowing that love is to share
Each one believing that love never dies
Watching her eyes and hoping I’m always there
They were there because… he was loved. Loved in a way he never had been before. It wasn’t like Ron and Hermione’s affection, nor the consideration Mr and Mrs Weasley had shown. It was the complete opposite of what he had endured with the Dursleys, who had rejected him from the day he was left on the doorstep of number four, Privet Drive.
Here, he was loved for who he was. Of course, he didn’t know Sirius, Remus and Reggie as well as he would have liked, but even so — even with only a superficial bond — the three of them simply accepted him in a way he had never been accepted before. Not for being Harry Potter, the Boy Who Lived, but…
I want her everywhere
And if she’s beside me, I know I need never care
But to love her is to need her everywhere
…simply for being Harry. Nothing more, nothing less.
To be loved for who he was stole his breath away. There was so much churning in his chest, so many feelings that had long been shut away in the back of a drawer, it was unsettling to feel them rise and feed the pleasant warmth dancing through his heart.
"You all right, Harry?" Sirius asked, watching him with such concern that he felt foolish for crying.
"Yeah." He murmured, lowering his gaze as he quickly wiped at his tears. "I… I just…"
Knowing that love is to share
Each one believing that love never dies
Watching her eyes and hoping I’m always there
"It’s all right to cry." His godfather’s arms wrapped around him, and Harry shrank at first, out of instinctive defence. Sirius held him tighter, and his restrained sobs turned into a torrent, overcome by the haunting sensation that touch gave him.
Something he rarely felt, even at Hogwarts.
Safety.
The certainty that nothing, absolutely nothing, would hurt him or threaten him now, because there was someone fit to look after him. Someone who would never humiliate him or force him to serve as a drudge, someone who valued him — who loved him.
I will be there and everywhere
Here, there, and everywhere
Merlin, Harry Potter was living with people who genuinely loved him! The very same love his mother had felt for him, which had shielded him from the wrath of the greatest Dark wizard in history… a love Voldemort would never comprehend. A love that had barred him from death.
Now, he understood what the Headmaster had meant.
Harry knew Sirius would never be his father, but in that moment he imagined he was. He let himself believe it was James holding him tight against his chest. Allowed himself to be cradled by a fatherly figure, clinging to his godfather’s waist as he wept without a word.
He rubbed at his eyes with his knuckles and, over Sirius’s tattooed arm, caught sight of a photograph in which James and Lily danced slowly, foreheads pressed together and eyes locked, as though the rest of the world had no meaning.
"I wish… I wish they were here." He whispered into his godfather’s dark shirt.
Sirius gave a sad sniff of laughter, loosening the embrace as he wiped away Harry’s tears, drawing those green eyes that so resembled Lily’s. To look at him hurt. It felt like being in James’s presence, and like staring at his friend, only to be struck again by the fact that both were gone.
"It’s cruel that I had so much time with James and Lily, and you so little." Sirius blinked, eyes glassy. He breathed deep, steadying his thoughts. "Harry… the ones who love us never truly leave us." He sniffed again, brushing another tear from his godson’s thin cheeks. "And you can always find them…" He lowered his hand to the boy’s trembling chest, feeling the frantic beat of his heart. "…here."
Harry only nodded, a little awkward for crying in front of them. Sirius offered a wistful smile and tweaked his nose, Remus ruffled his untidy hair, Reg brought over a stack of Super Nintendo tapes for him to choose from, and Penny asked what he’d like for lunch.
It was hard not to cry again as he accepted just how loved and cherished he was.
Harder still to realise that, at last, he knew the meaning of the word family.
.
.
.
James tucked the Marauder’s Map into the waistband of his trousers and mounted his Nimbus, rising swiftly past the towers of Hogwarts, scanning about for a girl with black hair and Slytherin Quidditch robes. According to the map, she ought to be at the top of one of the Bell Towers. He drew closer slowly, circled the terrace, and let out a frustrated sigh when he didn’t find her.
He tilted the broom handle slightly, moving on to the next tower. He lifted a hand to his brow to shield against the pale rays of sunlight spilling like curtains through the heavy clouds. Narrowing his eyes, his pupils caught a flutter of green fabric at the foot of a stone frog statue.
"Scar?" he called, his voice cutting through the sharp wind, but there was no reply. "Scarlett?"
He lay flat on his broom, gripping it with both hands as he slipped through the narrow gap between the balustrades and the roof. He dismounted as soon as he found Scarlett curled up in an almost hidden corner of the tower, arms locked round her legs and her head buried between them.
James propped his broom against the wall and rubbed his nose, exhaling as he sat down beside her, staring up at the tower’s stone ceiling. The cold wind whistled in his ears, determined to tug at his Quidditch cloak, so he folded the tail and tucked it behind his back.
He rested his hands on his crossed legs and sat there, watching the clouds conceal and reveal the golden strips of sunlight, which glinted in the castle’s windows and on the damp slate rooftops. He took off his glasses and cleaned them calmly on the hem of his shirt, then reached into the enchanted pocket of his trousers and pulled out an Exploding Bonbon, setting one down between Scarlett’s feet.
He unwrapped the foil and tossed the sweet into the air, catching it with his mouth as he knocked the back of his head against the wall. He let out a grunt of pain and rubbed the sore spot, feeling the sugar fizzing across his tongue.
He licked his fingers one by one, making plenty of noise. Out of the corner of his eye, he saw one of Scarlett’s hands loosen its grip on her Quidditch robes, slowly sliding down until it picked up the sweet, clenching it in her fist without opening it.
"Lost my Seeker spot to a fifth-year girl…" James let out a huff of laughter. "Butley, Fay and Ito all graduated last year. With two Chaser slots and a Keeper slot open, I ended up taking Ito’s place and this girl called Freya Hopper’s stepped in as Seeker, but we still haven’t decided who’s filling the other Chaser and Keeper spots…"
James scrunched the orange laminated wrapper of his sweet, twisting it between thumb and forefinger until it turned into a tiny ball.
"You’ve no idea who I caught in the library last Wednesday…" He wet his lips. "Emmeline Vance and Edmund Bones. She had her tongue so far down his throat I couldn’t hold back a laugh when I took points off Hufflepuff… it was bloody satisfying, all the more because Vance is Head Girl this year. And on Friday she had a row with Dirk Cresswell ‘cause he found out and thought they were going out…"
"James… I couldn’t care less about the lives of this school’s losers." Scarlett finally spoke, nasal and hoarse.
"Oh, sorry if I’m a loser for studying here." He grumbled, annoyed. Folding his arms, he let out a long sigh.
Scarlett turned her face gently to the side, narrowing her blue eyes, almost completely hidden behind her black hair.
"I didn’t… didn’t mean that," she gasped, hiding her head between her knees again.
"I know you didn’t. I’m only joking." He tried to keep his tone light, but the smile soon slipped from his face. He stared at his nails and nudged her sharply in the ribs. "I need a favour."
Scarlett tensed her shoulders before relaxing them, fixing her gaze back on him, the black strands clinging to her swollen, reddened face.
"What is it?" Her voice barely came out.
James fumbled through his enchanted pocket until he found a nail file.
"Need you to file my nail." He held the object out to her.
The wind swirled around them, carrying with it the earthy scent of rain.
Scarlett rubbed her eyes with the backs of her hands, raw and reddened. Her blue irises had that frosty sheen that once had been rare, but now… it was far more common than James wished. He had the impression Scarlett wanted to vanish just as much as she wanted to be held, and he never knew which one stood before him.
Though he didn’t know her as well as Sirius, the change in his friend was stark. He didn’t need to think much to see that this girl seemed to fight every day against herself, sometimes against her own friends — and she always looked as though she were losing. It was harrowing to watch her drown in herself, as if she were tormented by so much that all she could manage was to sit quiet and still, trying to forget she even existed just to rid herself of the pain flaying her heart.
James had never known that kind of agony, and watching Scarlett be torn apart by it was staggering. He didn’t know what to do — whether he ought to ask if she was all right or just stay silent. He didn’t know if she would explode, cry, or simply ignore him.
In that instant, however, Scarlett took the file and held his hand with such lightness her touch was almost non-existent. But then, little by little, she pressed firmer strength into her trembling fingers as she began to file his index nail, slowly, often missing the motion before getting it right.
He watched Scarlett’s expressions closely. The purse of her lips at each mistake, the faint attempt at a smile whenever she managed. At the same time, there was something glassy in her gaze, a darkness gnawing away at her soul, gaining ground and power over her with the intent of turning her into a hollow shell. He knew it was a form of self-defence, but one that was slowly killing her.
"Want some polish?" he asked, once Scarlett was nearly done with his left hand.
"Got any on you?" Scarlett looked at him for barely a second before feigning deep concentration again.
"Mm-hm." He grunted, fumbling with his free hand until he found the orange polish he’d nicked earlier from Lily’s room. She wouldn’t miss it — the Head Girl owned such a vast collection of colours that there were shades he’d never even heard of. Like… fuchsia. What the hell kind of name for a colour was that?
He handed the polish to Scarlett, who deftly opened it and began painting his nails. And truth be told, that orange did go well with his scarlet and gold Gryffindor cloak. It made sense Lily wore it too, since it matched the palette of her fiery hair, fair-rosy skin and green eyes.
"Why are you smiling like that?" Scar let the corners of her lips rise ever so slightly as she wiped away the polish she’d accidentally painted over his cuticle.
"Like what?" James furrowed his brows, pushing his glasses up his nose with his little finger.
"Thinking of Lily?"
"No." James clicked his tongue before grinning again and resting his head on Scarlett’s shoulder. "Yes."
"How are things in the private dormitory?" She drawled the last two words with mockery.
"We’ve separate rooms, but… well, I like that the first person I see after waking is her. And Merlin, her perfume…" He shut his eyes and ran a hand through his hair, mussing it up. "She tells me good morning and then disappears. But it’s enough to… you know when you start the day with a warm feeling in your chest?"
Scarlett leaned her cheek against her friend’s forehead.
"I know," she murmured, though she hadn’t felt that in quite some time.
Silence settled unpleasantly between them. She finished painting James’s nails and turned her gaze towards the horizon, where the sun was beginning to set. The hundreds of castle windows glittered with the lights flickering on, and the autumnal evening shadows draped the two of them in chill.
"He deserved it, Jamie." Scarlett rubbed the tip of her nose with the palm of her hand. "Regulus. He deserved it."
Lifting his head from her shoulder, James straightened as he drew in a breath, those hazel eyes analysing her so deeply that not even his round spectacles could shield it.
"Why?" The question came out laced with fear and a hint of disgust.
Scarlett’s lips tightened.
"He lied to me. He… he attacked me… blamed Snape… Sirius nearly got expelled because of him… he wiped my memory and… acted as if—"
"And you think accusing him of something he didn’t do is going to… going to fix anything?!" James deflated, bracing his elbows against his knees.
"Yes!" she shot back, as if it were obvious. "He lied to me!"
"And you make another mistake to… to make up for what he did?!"
"What would you have me say? That it was Sirius?"
"So it was Sirius, then…"
"It doesn’t matter who it was, Regulus is the one at fault now!" Scarlett panted, her nails digging into the fabric of her cloak. "The detention he’s getting… it’s nothing compared to—"
"It doesn’t matter who it was?" James cut across her, pushing himself onto his knees, his spine straight as a rod. His long shadow swallowed Scarlett whole. "Things don’t work like that!" The way he looked at her hurt. The way his naturally gentle eyes shrank in indignation and disdain. "Scar… you can’t try to fix something by making it worse."
"I wasn’t making it worse, I just… Jamie… he… Regulus…"
"I know what he did!" James sat directly in front of her, gripping her hands as though to make sure she was listening. "Where’s this going to end? When’s this going to end?"
"I just wanted… I…" Scarlett gasped, her face twisting with frustration. "Why do I have to suffer while he… he… I was only trying to help Sirius!"
"By hurting his brother?"
"Well, yes! Isn’t that exactly what he did to me the whole of last year? Using me for leverage, spreading lies to his little Death Eater mates…"
"Doesn’t matter, Scarlett. Right is right and wrong is wrong." James spoke each word slowly, as though trying to hammer them into her mind.
"Says the boy who’s been tormenting Snivellus since the moment he set foot in this school!" Scarlett countered with a cutting smile. "Don’t start preaching to me, James…"
"I don’t do that anymore. I… I promised Lily…"
"But you did."
"I don’t anymore!"
"You’re ridiculous, James."
"At least I’m trying to be better!"
"Oh… forgive me, James… if I’m a monster!" Scarlett’s laugh turned vicious. She pressed her fists hard against her chest.
James drew a deep breath, rubbing a few strands of hair between his thumb and forefinger.
"I didn’t say that, Scar. I’d never say that." He whispered gently, brushing her chin with his right hand. "You’re my best friend. And I want you to be all right…"
Scarlett closed her eyes, shaking her head. The anger that had flared in her was quickly washed away by melancholy.
"I don’t know if I’ll ever feel all right." She admitted, feeling that familiar pressure in her chest.
"You will… earlier today you… you were all right and—"
"And then my emotions are all over the place and I’m falling apart." Scarlett spoke each word softer than the last, until the final one was no more than a sigh. "I feel like I’m drowning in my own feelings."
James hugged her.
Scarlett didn’t return it.
"I love them so much that… it’s as if a piece of me’s been torn out. And I can’t get it back… and I keep searching for it… anything that might resemble it… a smile… a sound… anything to remind me…" She held her breath. She didn’t want to cry again. "I can’t, Jamie. I can’t accept that…"
"Letting go is love too, Scar." James kissed her hair, one hand rubbing her back, radiating a warmth that soothed. "And you need to let them go."
"I can’t." She sniffed, her voice splintering into pieces. "I can’t. They’re my family."
"I’m your family too." He threaded his fingers through her dyed-black hair, pulling her tighter against him. "And I’ll always look after you."
"Sometimes I feel like this is all a nightmare and… that I’m about to wake up… but I never do… why did this happen to me? What did I do… to deserve… this?"
"Death isn’t punishment. It just… happens." James caressed her nape with tenderness.
Scarlett buried her face in James’s Gryffindor robes, the soft fabric brushing against her aching cheeks.
"Sirius hates me, doesn’t he?!" she croaked, after a moment of silence.
"He doesn’t hate you. He’s mad about you, Scar." He brushed the strands stuck to her forehead. "He’s upset, but… well, I can’t take your side on this one. You messed up."
"I… I tried… tried to apologise, but…" Her voice came muffled against James’s chest. "He said it wasn’t him I ought to be apologising to."
"And he’s right."
Scarlett wanted desperately to be hurt by James’s clear preference, but she knew he was right. She knew she was making a mess of things, and even if she kept stubbornly clinging to her mistake, she wasn’t disingenuous enough to ignore the feelings of her best friend and her boyfriend. As much as she was wounded and constantly angry…
Letting go is love too.
No — she couldn’t accept that! She couldn’t accept that… that she would simply… she would never again…
"Will you come with me? Talk to Sirius?" she whimpered, even if no tears were actually falling from her eyes.
"I can come with you, but I can’t do it for you." James kissed her forehead and stood, picking up his broom and holding out his hand.
Scarlett accepted, rising with James’s pull. She grabbed her Firebolt beside the frog statue and followed her friend into the stairwell of the tower, descending so many flights that, by the end, her legs were burning. They passed through empty corridors lit by flickering torches and candelabra.
They climbed all the way up the Grand Staircase to Gryffindor Tower, and James covered her with his Invisibility Cloak. They entered through the portrait hole and crossed the circular common room, only to stop when Lily spotted him in the boys’ dormitory corridor.
"Did you find her?" The concern was plain in her eyes.
"Yeah, she’s with me." He pointed to the space where Scarlett stood beneath the cloak. "We’re going to—"
"I can go on my own." Scarlett muttered. She didn’t want to speak to Lily just then.
"We need to talk." Lily folded her arms, arching her brows as she glanced at James’s hands. "You painted your nails?!"
"Scar painted my nails." He rolled his eyes as though the question were absurd. "Didn’t you, Scar…?"
He stretched his arm to where she should have been, letting out a hiss of breath when he realised she had already gone into their dormitory.
"Right… anyway… we need to talk about those two. They…" Lily frowned. "Is that my nail polish?"
"Er… no." James answered with the tone of someone blatantly lying. "I… found it."
"Found it in my things?!" she pressed, clenching her jaw.
James sighed and rubbed his eyes with the back of his hands.
"Last summer, before this one… Scar used to paint my nails… we’d take the chance to talk about people, especially Sirius… I didn’t have any polish here, so I… nicked one of yours. And a file too. Sorry, I should’ve asked, but… you’d already left and…"
Lily’s stern gaze gradually softened, until she silenced him by placing a hand on his shoulder, the revolt in her expression shifting into lenience.
"It’s all right, James, just let me know next time." She turned her palm upwards, and James placed the polish and file into it. "Orange suits you." she teased, smiling shyly.
James gaped like an idiot, his face turning as red as Lily’s hair as words deserted him — for all he could focus on was the beautiful smile Lily Evans was showing him.
He thought his heart might burst out of his chest, but then he pulled himself together and shrugged his shoulders.
"You reckon?!" He shoved his hands into his trouser pockets and followed her into the Prefects’ dormitory.
The Marauders’ dormitory was quiet that night, a jarring contrast to the painful chaos Scarlett felt in her chest. Remus was working his way through a pile of Chocolate Frogs at his desk, and Peter lay on his bed reading a Muggle comic, legs propped up in the air. Sirius, however, seemed completely detached, focused on his homework, listening to his Heart tape on his Walkman.
He barely lifted his gaze when Scarlett stepped into the dormitory, slipping off James’s Invisibility Cloak. She shut the door behind her and approached with reluctant steps, sitting down on his bed beside his desk.
She gathered all the courage she had left in that moment — not much, but enough to make her voice come out:
"Can… can we talk?" she asked, fixing her eyes on him.
Sirius didn’t move, his black hair spilling thickly across the sides of his face as he kept his attention on what he was writing. It was as if he hadn’t even heard her. He scratched his forehead and, with an almost inaudible sigh, pulled the headphones off.
"What?" he said coldly, without looking at her.
Scarlett glanced around as she shifted her weight between her legs before meeting his gaze again.
"Can we talk?" she repeated.
He shook his head with an irritable flick.
"I’m busy." The reply carried a trace of disdain, and he bent back over his parchment as though his daft essay on non-verbal magic was the only thing that mattered.
Scarlett drew in a sharp breath, as if the air wasn’t filling her brain properly. She pressed her hand to her chest when that familiar tightness returned. She knew he was hurt — of course she did — but so was she. So, without another word, she rose slowly and walked to her trunk. She pulled out a change of clothes and went straight into the bathroom.
She turned on the tap and let hot water fill the tub. Steam rose as Scarlett undressed and sank into the bath, exhaling through her lungs in an effort to relax. But her mind kept circling back to the argument with Sirius, sharpening the acute pain gnawing at her chest.
By the time Scarlett finally stepped out of the bath, her fingers were already wrinkled. She left the bathroom dressed, returning to the dormitory, which was calmer and darker than before. Peter still read his comic, now lighting his bed with his wand since the lamps by his side had gone out. Remus was leafing through a book, though he seemed more interested in watching her.
And Sirius… lay in his bed, turned away from her, eyes closed. Her heart stretched and then shrank as though it were curling in on itself, about to vanish. She slipped into his bed and lay down beside him, drawing the canopy shut in a feeble attempt to shut the rest of the world out.
She rested her hands on her chest and stared at the carved wooden ceiling, casting the occasional glance at Sirius, who barely stirred. She lay still for a few minutes before slowly moving closer. Crawling across the mattress, she slid her arm around him, feeling the warmth of his skin against hers, the defined muscles tensing, and the air shifting in his ribcage.
Scarlett kissed the strawberry in dancing shoes of his shoulder blade, clutching tightly at his shoulder. With the embrace, she felt the strong beats of Sirius’s heart resound through her body. She closed her eyes and pressed her forehead just beneath the nape of his neck, where the Sagittarius tattoo was partly obscured by stray strands of black hair.
"I’m sorry, love…" The apology was almost inaudible.
For a long moment he didn’t respond, and Scarlett swallowed hard against the suffocating silence.
"It’s all right." Sirius answered quietly.
"No… it’s not." She shook her head, his scent overwhelming her senses. "Talk to me, Sirius."
He drew in a deep, reluctant breath.
"Talk about what?" The retort came with that worn-out arrogance, as though he were still trying to keep her at a distance.
"I… I just… just want to know what you’re feeling." Scarlett pressed, tightening her arm around him in an attempt to break down the barriers he had built. "You encouraged us to open up to one another — don’t shut me out like this."
Sirius delicately laced his fingers with hers, though he made no effort to soften the weary edge in his voice. He remained turned away from her.
"I’m scared… and frustrated." He gave her hand a light squeeze, his thumb sliding across the promise ring on her finger, letting the flickering light seeping through the canopy seams dance across the dark metal.
"Because of what I did?" she asked, her voice wavering between guilt and doubt. She shifted on the bed, propping an elbow against the pillow and her chin in her free hand, leaning in to see him better.
Sirius turned his face slightly towards her, his gaze trembling, apprehensive.
"That too," he confided with difficulty, blinking hard as if trying to push away some painful notion.
"I don’t know… I don’t know if I can be the person I used to be. I truly don’t…" Scarlett swallowed, stumbling over her words. "Do you still love me?"
There was so much fear, so much insecurity in her question that Sirius’s body grew even more rigid, and he suddenly rolled over to face her, eyes wide, an indignant fire blazing in his pupils as though she had just uttered blasphemy.
"Why wouldn’t I love you?!" He made no attempt to hide the incredulity in his voice, as if the very idea were absurd.
Scarlett mumbled a few unintelligible words, the blue of her eyes refracted by the pain that forever pursued her.
"You… you said you didn’t know who I was anymore and…"
Sirius shook his head suddenly, his expression heavy with tenderness.
"It doesn’t matter who you were or who you think you are now." He paused, his eyes gleaming with the same liquid silver that tinged the stars, shading his irises with piercing certainty. "You’re my girl, Scar. That’s all that matters to me."
Sirius’s expression softened, though animosity still lurked in the shadows of his gaze. His chest rose and fell as he let his thoughts breathe, tucking a handful of rebellious strands from her face behind her ear.
"I love you, Scar." His voice wavered, weighted with a vulnerability nearly suffocated by confusion. "I just… just don’t know… don’t know what to do."
Scarlett’s irises searched him. She knew he was telling the truth, and yet she feared he was lying. The dormitory’s single light went out, plunging them into silvery moonlight that turned Sirius’s eyes to platinum and Scarlett’s to ice.
"What do you mean?" She pulled him closer, laying her face against his defined shoulder, seeking the safety that always wrapped around her in his arms.
Sirius drew in a sharp breath before answering, his hand rising to caress her cheek, his thumb trailing sweetly over her freckles in a touch that made her close her eyes, enraptured.
"I don’t know what to do to make you feel better." He paused, tracing her soft skin. "If I could, I’d steal away all your pain and suffering." He confessed, in a fragile whisper.
Scarlett felt her heart skip in her chest, drowning in those silver, gleaming eyes in the hope they might purge all that tormented her. That they might tame the restlessness thrashing within her chest, that they might ease the disorienting void that had consumed so much of her core. She set grief aside to be comforted by the man who was her place in the world. The only place she belonged.
The man who was her home.
"I can’t bear to see you like this… hiding behind anger because you can’t stand the sorrow." He exhaled slowly. "I know what you’re doing, Scar, I know what it is to be consumed by that thing. And I don’t know how to react when I see you like this… I…" He rubbed his eyes with the heel of his hand, letting Scarlett see how exhausted he was, both physically and emotionally. "I just… don’t know what to do."
"It’s not your fault." Scarlett buried her face in his collarbone, her muffled voice resonating against his skin.
"I know." Sirius’s hand slid across her shoulders, his fingers brushing her arm, wandering down her back, fitting into the curve of her spine. "But I want to help you… do something. Anything."
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, fighting the tears that threatened to be born.
"I’m sorry," she murmured, her voice breaking.
"You don’t have to apologise for that, love." He tried to comfort her, though he knew full well there was no magic word, no act that could turn grief back into love. Even if it was that impossible kind of love, even if it was love that collected at the corner of one’s eyes, tightened in the throat, lodged deep in the heart.
What was grief, if not love lost, confused, diffuse… with nowhere to go?
"I feel guilty all the time…" she sniffled, dragging her hand across Sirius’s chest, feeling his pores bristle beneath her palm.
Sirius sighed softly and pulled her closer, his embrace as strong as it was tender. His body was warm against hers. Comforting. Safe.
Scarlett curled up, allowing Sirius to gather all her fragilities.
"Yeah… me too." He murmured, closing his eyes as he buried his face in her hair, the familiar scent of her shampoo bringing him that known sense of peace. Blooming in his chest was a comfort that, for some reason, always seemed just out of reach.
Sirius held Scarlett tightly against him, determined to protect her from everything… even from herself.
"It’s all right. I’m here."
"I know… I’m here too." She burrowed into her beloved’s chest, taking refuge in his heart. "I always will be."
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 61: Nothing ever lasts forever
Chapter Text
CXXIX
"Remember our gig tonight in Harrow?" Mike frowned, leaning his elbows on the escalator’s handrail as he watched Scarlett tie her bleached hair into a ponytail. She meticulously tucked the stray strands behind her ear and adjusted her fringe as she exhaled.
"Of course I do," she mumbled, pulling from the bag the red lipstick she had just bought on the ground floor of the shopping centre. She applied it carefully, rubbing her fingertips over the accidental smudges.
"Are you off to see your kid or your boyfriend?" he carried on, lips stretching into a grin when Scarlett shot him a murderous look.
"Shut up, Mike." It was Danny who complained, elbowing him in the ribs. "That colour suits you, Star."
"Cheers." She put the lipstick away, avoiding eye contact. She plucked an invisible thread from her black Toto tour shirt and adjusted her high-waisted tartan skirt upwards, only to tug it back down once she realised it had ridden up more than it should.
It felt oddly uncomfortable wearing it without tights.
"What my dear Danny here means… is that he fancies you." Mike lifted his cigarette case to his mouth, holding one between his lips before receiving another elbow, this time in the chest. "Ow, for fuck’s sake, I’m joking!"
Scarlett and Danny exchanged an awkward glance, turning their faces in opposite directions as the escalator reached the top.
"Wait a sec…" Mike lit the cigarette with a lighter, shoving it into the pocket of his denim jacket. "Have you two snogged?"
"No!" they both answered in unison.
Michael smoked slowly, the grin spreading across his face as he trailed after them through the shopping centre, already considerably crowded for the time of day.
"Oh my God… Lenny owes me thirty quid." He paused to tap the cigarette in an ashtray and quickened his pace to catch up.
"See you later!" Scarlett waved them off, slipping round a corner with such swiftness that they had no time to follow.
"Bloody hell, Mike, why do you have to be such a tosser every single time?!" Danny shot him an indignant look, earning only a shrug in return.
"What woman dolls herself up like that just to see her kid, Daniel?!" he retorted, inhaling deeply.
Danny only shook his head and kept walking, not caring whether Mike was still tagging along.
.
.
.
[Music: Tears For Fears — Everybody Wants to Rule The World]
The sweet scent of popcorn and fizzy drinks hit Scarlett like a slap. Memories bubbled up in her mind, floating to the surface of her consciousness. She shook her head, bursting them apart with an irrational dread. As though they might hurt her.
Welcome to your life
There's no turning back
Even while we sleep
We will find you
The colourful lights and the constant sound of buttons being hammered on the arcade machines tore her from her reverie, her heart pounding as she crossed the place. Her eyes searched for a tangle of rat’s nest hair and black locks with a slight wave. She passed by the fighting and racing games until her gaze caught something that sent a wave of nostalgia crashing into her chest: an old Space Invaders cabinet.
The very same machine she and Sirius had played in the fateful summer of ’76.
Acting on your best behaviour
Turn your back on Mother Nature
Everybody wants to rule the world
Her eyes stung under the neon glare of the nearby screens, silver, red and yellow painting her pale, freckled face. Scarlett shielded her eyes with the flat of her hand. She spotted Reggie and Harry playing boisterously at an arcade game she had never seen before. She hardly noticed herself walking towards them, her lips stretching into an absent-minded smile. She felt so dazed it seemed like a dream.
This couldn’t be real.
It's my own design
It's my own remorse
Help me to decide
Help me make the most
"Hi, boys!" The smile she wore brimmed with affection.
Reggie and Harry paused the game for a moment, both of them giving her their familiar embrace; her son squeezed her tightly and her godson wrapped just one arm round her, resting his forehead against her chest before pulling back, though he smiled just as fondly as Reg.
Scarlett felt her heart leap in her chest.
Of freedom and of pleasure
Nothing ever lasts forever
Everybody wants to rule the world
"Mum!" He straightened up, brimming with excitement. "We’re playing Street Fighter — d’you want to learn how it works?"
"I do… of course." Scarlett leaned her elbow on the machine, bending over it as she listened carefully to the detailed explanation of each button and the joystick, especially how to block or dodge attacks to counter them (and how Harry’s Hadouken was totally broken since he was playing as Ryu on the Brazil stage).
There's a room where the light won't find you
Holding hands while the walls come tumbling down
When they do I'll be right behind you
"Blanka’s Lua’s favourite character because he’s from her homeland." Reg folded his arms with a proud smile as Harry won both rounds without trouble.
"Alright, your turn." Harry stepped aside so Reggie could take over the controls, facing Chun Li with an utterly focused expression. "Sirius and Remus set up my room," he remarked, glancing about with a hint of embarrassment. "There’s… there’s a space to put up some posters and… could we pop by the music shop later? I wanted to grab a few things there."
So glad we’ve almost made it
So sad they had to fade it
Everybody wants to rule the world
"Of course we can!" Scar furrowed her brow, as though Harry’s shyness were misplaced, though she shared the feeling. "Where’s Sirius?" She swept the bustling arcade with her eyes in search of him.
"Went to buy food." Reggie shrugged, making room so Harry could face Guile on the United States stage.
"I still don’t understand how a box can… you know, show pictures and…" Red tilted his translucent head to the side, watching a group of lads play at the machine next to them.
James and Lily burst into genuine laughter.
"Sometimes I forget you didn’t have much contact with technology." She rested her elbow on his shoulder, making him raise a brow at the audacity of the gesture. "This box has electric circuits that—"
"Love… I don’t think he has the faintest idea what electricity even is." James pressed his lips together, holding Red by the other shoulder.
"He doesn’t need to know what electricity is to understand an arcade!"
Scarlett let her gaze drift back to Regulus and Harry, who were now fighting each other. Their easy laughter and deliberate elbow nudges were startling.
Since when were Reggie and Harry friends?
She barely noticed the rough way they moved the joystick. They began hammering the buttons with such force that it dragged Scarlett out of her reverie, and she could swear they were about to break the machine.
I can’t stand this indecision
Married with a lack of vision
Everybody wants to rule the world
Say that you’ll never, never, never, never need it
One headline — why believe it?
Everybody wants to rule the world
Her smile deepened, and for a few fleeting seconds she allowed the racket of the arcades and the thrill of the games to carry her back to a time that crumbled at her touch, to a peaceful summer that left an aftertaste of bittersweetness on her tongue.
The memory didn’t last. She felt the familiar tug at her heart, followed by a warm, delicate kiss pressed to her cheek. Scarlett startled upright, though she didn’t need to look back to know it was Sirius.
He handed a bag of popcorn to Harry and Reggie, along with fizzy drinks. His face was lit up with a dimpled smile.
All for freedom and for pleasure
Nothing ever lasts forever
Everybody wants to rule the world
"Here." He turned to her, offering a milkshake.
Scarlett instantly broke eye contact as she accepted, the cold drink clashing with the heat rising in her face. She didn’t want to keep staring at Sirius like some daft girl with her mouth hanging open, so she pretended to be utterly absorbed in watching the boys play, even though she felt his every movement. He positioned himself behind her, his arm snaking round her back until his fingers settled on her waist in a possessive, familiar gesture. His body brushed against hers, and Scarlett took a slow sip of the malted milkshake, trying to disguise all the effects that touch was wreaking upon her body.
Sirius’s chin rested lightly against her temple, his long black hair slipping over her shoulders and mingling with her platinum-blonde strands, like dusk engulfing sunlight.
Swallowing hard, Scarlett fought to keep her composure, trying to ignore the burn of Sirius’s presence spreading across her skin like fire on paper, stiffening her muscles with such intensity she felt petrified.
It was disconcerting how Sirius had the power to shut her away from the jagged edges of the world with nothing but his overwhelming presence, enclosing her in a bubble where every one of her problems turned to ash and all her desires floated in the palm of his hand.
Scarlett sipped her Ovaltine, sneaking a glance at Sirius. He wore an open black checked shirt with grey stripes, revealing a white T-shirt beneath. His black cargo trousers had a few chains hanging from the waist, and the commander boots gave him a few extra inches in height.
She frowned. Sirius had always been fashionable, but since when had he traded his leather coat and trousers for this? Granted, it was summer, and it made sense he wasn’t parading about like that — still, Scarlett never would have imagined him adopting a more modern look.
Her gaze climbed to the tattoo edging the base of his neck, visible thanks to the low collar of his white shirt. Focused on the boys’ game, he lowered his face slowly towards the straw of her milkshake. Scarlett raised her arm so he wouldn’t have to lean in quite so much, and he thanked her with that dimpled smile of his.
Scarlett blinked under the spell the man had ensnared her with, heightened by the sweet perfume that left her reeling. She buried her nose into the flannel fabric and shut her eyes. Even in the chaotic throng of the arcade, she could feel Sirius’s pulse thrumming against her back, his breath brushing across her brow, his presence searing itself into every inch of her body.
As though he knew exactly what she was doing, Sirius pulled her closer, his damp hand sliding over her abdomen, his little finger hooking around the strap of her high-waisted skirt as if to make sure she wouldn’t bolt.
A wise decision. Scarlett had lost control of her body in that moment, and there was a very real chance she might simply run.
"This is nice." She admitted, savouring her Ovaltine. She lifted her gaze to Sirius, who glanced at her sidelong and nodded in agreement.
"Star?" The familiar voice made her choke at once.
Scarlett tore herself away from Sirius in a sharp movement, her eyes snapping instantly to the source: Mike and Danny stood only a few metres away, surprised.
"Didn’t expect to see you here." The guitarist excused himself with a friendly smile, though his expression hardened the moment his eyes met Sirius’s.
She couldn’t answer, coughing endlessly into her hand. Sirius rolled his eyes when he realised it was Danny, casting a fleeting glance at Reggie and Harry, whose cry of celebration signalled they had finished their match.
The aversion etched across Reg’s face was so horrified that Scarlett cleared her throat, struggling against the damned Ovaltine determined to worsen the embarrassment of the moment.
"What are you doing here?" Regulus demanded, irritation staining every word. He flicked a glance at his mother, then back at Danny.
"What are you doing here?" Daniel shot back, just as confused as Reg. His gaze shifted from Scarlett to the boy, as if trying to piece things together. "Wait a sec — he’s your son?!"
Regulus stared at her with disbelief and shock. He placed his hands on his hips and tilted his chin with such arrogance that Scarlett gasped, startled, for aside from the short hair, he looked exactly like Sirius. His eyes lost any warmth they might have shown, filled instead with the glacial coldness he had inherited from her.
"How do you know my mum?" Impatience rang clear in his voice.
Before Scarlett could reply, Sirius searched her face intently, gripping her shoulders.
"You alright? You’ve gone pale…" Despite the question, there was a hint of satisfaction in his tone.
Scarlett narrowed her eyes at him in an attempt to steady her breathing, but it only increased the urge to punch that handsome face of his.
"She’s my keyboardist. Star plays in my band." Danny shrugged casually.
Regulus spun on her at once, outraged.
"I can’t believe you’re playing in DFL’s band!" he accused, scandalised.
Harry adjusted his glasses on the bridge of his nose, blinking in confusion at the tension crackling between Danny and Reggie.
"What’s going on?" He frowned.
Regulus huffed, clenching his jaw.
"This is DFL — the bloke whose record I smashed on Space Invaders last summer!" he explained, gesturing far more dramatically than needed.
"I’ve already beaten your score again, RSB. And next up is SOB’s!" Danny flashed a mocking grin.
"Oh no, not for long!" Regulus jabbed a finger at Daniel, his wounded pride plain. "I’ll beat you right now!" He raised his voice at the end of the sentence, drawing the attention of the surrounding players.
The murmur that followed the challenge drowned out the sounds of buttons being mashed and joysticks pushed. Comments rippled through every corner of the arcade as Regulus straightened and strode confidently towards the Space Invaders cabinet, Danny at his side. The group playing there stepped aside to make way for the two contenders, wide-eyed as though witnessing a duel of titans.
Harry hurried towards them and Scarlett followed him with her gaze, craning her neck to make sure she wouldn’t lose sight of him.
"That was… wow." Mike let out a nasal, carefree laugh. He stretched out his hand to Sirius. "Alright, mate? I’m Mike. Star must’ve mentioned me to you."
Sirius shook his hand, brow furrowed as though pretending he hadn’t the faintest idea who Michael was. Of course he knew. He knew the lives of every member of Scarlett’s ridiculous band ever since she’d decided to play at pretending she had no responsibilities. It had been easy to gather information on them, easier still to realise they were all harmless…
Except Michael. He fit the bad-boy mould Scarlett tended to like: womaniser, mean-spirited, popular. He already had a bit of a reputation in the music scene as a studio musician and had appeared on a few notable records.
The strangest thing of all was that Scarlett had kissed Danny and not him.
Sirius composed his face and hid behind a mask of presumption, returning Mike’s handshake.
"Not that I recall…" He pressed his lips together. "I’m Sirius."
"Sirius?! What sort of name is that?" Mike snorted with a laugh. "Were your parents hippies?"
"Something like that…" Sirius gave a dismissive sniff.
Why did every Muggle ask him that?
"Why didn’t you tell him about me?" Mike placed a hand on his chest as though wounded.
Scarlett shrank and let out an exasperated sigh.
"Why would I tell him about you?" she muttered, bad-tempered.
"Well… you told me about him." Mike’s grin sharpened into something sly.
"Did she now? What did she say?" Sirius didn’t suppress the question, reaching out to take Scarlett’s hand, but she pulled away, giving him a strained look.
"That you two hate each other."
"I never said that!" she denied, her voice a few tones higher than usual, eyes wide as she shook her head vehemently.
"Yes, you did!" Her fiery reaction only fuelled Mike’s laughter.
"I said we didn’t get along, not that we hated each other!" she corrected, smacking the drummer’s shoulder.
"And what’s the difference?" he shot back, lacing his hands lazily behind his head.
"Shut it, Mike!" Scarlett scolded, turning her eyes back to Reggie and Danny, who were immersed in their competition. Her heart thudded so hard the sounds of the machines were muffled by the buzzing in her ears.
"Did she tell you why we didn’t get along?" Sirius toyed with Scarlett’s ponytail, twining his fingers through the bleached strands, fully aware that Mike was scrutinising them with razor-sharp irony.
"Something about life not being strawberries?!" Mike waved a hand dismissively, as if it were hardly worth mentioning.
"I’ll see if Harry needs anything." Scarlett muttered, pulling away from Sirius and bumping deliberately into Mike as she passed.
"Oi!" He raised his hands in feigned surprise. "Bloody hell… now I get why you two didn’t get along."
"Why’s that?" Sirius ran a hand through his hair and sat down on the bench of an empty machine.
"Star’s mental, mate." He leaned against the pinball, positioning himself in front of Sirius. "Sorry about your brother, by the way. She told me he died."
The subject soured Sirius’s smile until it disappeared altogether.
Thinking of Regulus still hurt.
"It was a long time ago." His lips curved into a forced shape.
"Which makes it worse." Mike drummed his legs, throwing him a look tinged with pity. "The longer it’s been, the more we forget them."
Sirius pressed his lips together, twisting them as his mind pulled up his brother’s memory. Strange, to think of Regulus without cursing him or blaming him for all the shite in his life.
"She said you’re her brother-in-law… why didn’t you get along?" Mike pressed, refusing to look away.
Sirius forced himself to remain impassive, his silver eyes resisting the dark orbs of Michael’s, which hungered to dissect him. It was easy enough to stop him — a limited Muggle like that would never be able to see his vulnerabilities, and Sirius Black had spent far too many years being tortured by his parents not to learn a trick or two.
"We were young and stupid." Sirius smiled, a genuine smile, though stripped of the painful echoes that usually rose in his chest. "I fucked up, she fucked up…" He tilted his head from side to side as he spoke.
"Bloody hell, I always forget Star’s fifty." Mike gave a quick grin. "Is that true? She looks like she’s just finished sixth form."
"Yeah, we studied together." Sirius confirmed firmly. "We were born the same year."
"It’s mad, ‘cause if you really look, you could pass for thirty and she… eighteen. What’s the secret?"
"Virgin’s blood." He said it deadpan. "But it’s got to be collected during a lunar eclipse — while an albino goat dances the lambada."
Mike raised his eyebrows with an amused look.
"The toughest part is teaching the choreography to the goat," Sirius finished, as if it were obvious.
Mike laughed, rolling his eyes.
"Ah, now it all makes sense!" He shook his head and returned his attention to the crowd around the Space Invaders. "I think it’s nearly done… we’d better go…"
Sirius nodded and the two threaded through the onlookers towards the competitors. Regulus was giving it everything to beat the record and Harry, beside him, watched with clear anxiety. Scarlett kept stamping her foot and Danny bit his nails.
"I know your secret." Mike whispered into Scarlett’s ear, and she immediately stiffened at the sudden contact.
"What?"
"You’re so obvious, Star."
"What are you on about, Mike?!" Scarlett turned to stare at him, hands on her hips.
Mike put a hand to his mouth as if about to reveal the biggest scoop:
"You’re in love with your brother-in-law!"
"What? No, of course not!" She cleared her throat in an attempt to steady her voice, which was oddly high at that moment. "Where on earth did you get that from?"
"Well, who’d have thought?!" James scoffed, shoving a ghostly handful of popcorn into his mouth. He was standing a little apart, but didn’t need to strain to overhear the pair.
"Cut the act, I’ve seen it all." Mike gripped her shoulder and Scarlett tensed instantly. "Was that before or after you hooked up with his brother?!"
"Michael… I don’t know what you’re talking about." Scarlett hissed, glaring at him.
"I don’t know what the fuck’s going on between you two… but I suggest you sort it out, because he’s totally into you…" He dropped his voice into a sneer, blatantly looking over at Sirius. "Look, he’s staring at us…"
"Mike, stop!" Scarlett rebuked him, giving his arm a pinch.
"Is he the jealous type? Does he know you kissed Danny? Has he ever been jailed? He have more tattoos than a con…"
Mike didn’t finish because Scarlett landed a perfectly aimed elbow in his stomach. He clutched his belly and doubled over, exhaling all the air from his lungs.
"Okay, okay… I’ll stop…" he panted, leaning on a nearby pillar.
Sirius gave a long sigh and decided to step out from the wings, taking the empty spot to Reg’s right while Harry stood on his left.
"Reg… if you don’t open the safe zone on the right, you’ll lose." He whispered, pointing to the rows on the screen Reg was supposed to clear.
"But… if I do that, my right-hand barrier won’t hold."
"Exactly. There won’t be any alien to shoot at and if you destroy that section of the barrier… it’ll make a perfect gap for the bonus ship that’ll appear on your thirteenth shot."
Regulus furrowed his brows in scepticism but followed his uncle’s strategy, moving to the indicated spot and hitting the bonus ship.
"Now, the next bonus ship will appear every fifteen shots. Just keep firing from this safe zone and wait for it. Three hundred points each, and when the aliens are close enough, you’ll make the Death Wall and count the shots to the bonus."
Reg opened and closed his mouth, stunned at Sirius’s knowledge of the game.
"How do you know so much?"
"Hey! It’s not fair for you to give him hints!" Danny accused, craning his neck to get a better look at the scoreboard.
"Go on, Reg, you’re nearly there!" Harry cheered, snapping his fingers in nervousness.
Sirius’s strategy proved crucial for Regulus to beat Danny’s record. It wasn’t long before the crowd behind them began celebrating, cheering Reggie, who roared out a triumphant "suck it" at his rival. Danny laughed, raising his hands in defeat before congratulating him. Reg high-fived Harry, hugged Scarlett, and then focused all his admiration on Sirius, whose gaze brimmed with a pride that made his heart race.
"How did you…"
Sirius flashed an enigmatic smile. He glanced at the leaderboard, where the initials RSB had overtaken DFL, landing in second place. He then pointed to the very top, where the initials SOB were displayed, the score so high no one had ever managed to beat it.
"Because I’m SOB," he explained, as though it were the most obvious thing in the world.
"What?!" Regulus and Daniel gaped.
"Yeah… it’s the initials of my name. You never realised that?!" Sirius arched his brows, the smile softening over his perfectly shaped lips.
"But… SOB disappeared… a decade ago…" Danny scratched his neck, his eyes narrowing in suspicion.
Reggie’s expression flickered from astonishment, to admiration, and finally to frustration.
"Of course it’s your initials… why didn’t I ever think of that?!" he groaned, fidgeting nervously with the silver chain he wore.
"I can’t believe I’m standing in front of the god of this game…" Danny pressed his hands together, dumbfounded. "And you didn’t… how did you not know SOB was your uncle?! You practically live in this arcade!"
"Well… because…" Reg looked at Sirius, Harry, and finally his mother, seeking some sort of help.
"Sirius was in Switzerland with me… we… played… in the same band…" Scarlett improvised, trying to sound as assertive as possible.
"What’s your instrument?" Mike cut in, with oblique curiosity.
"Drums," Sirius answered casually. "And this is Harry… the son of our… erm, guitarist…"
"…who died in an accident, and the band broke up, so we came back to the UK." Scarlett added, pressing her lips together.
"And we brought Harry with us because he’s my… our… godson." He finished, resting a hand on Scarlett’s shoulder. She bit her lower lip and looked away, discomfort flickering across her features, enough to make Sirius knit his brows.
"Really? I’m sorry about your parents, Harry…" Danny didn’t seem suspicious — if he was, he didn’t show it. "What was the band’s name?"
"Sssscar…" Sirius began.
"Rius," Scarlett finished.
"Scarius? Never heard of it…" Mike stroked his beard, nodding.
"We were just a pub band." She shrugged.
"Yeah… nothing serious…"
Scarlett slipped free of Sirius and moved away from them, clutching the milkshake cup tighter than she should as she left the noisy arcade floor and reached a calmer spot where a few players were sitting and chatting quietly.
She drew in a sharp breath, releasing it slowly in an effort to calm the storm spiralling inside her, tugging at the collar of her T-shirt to ease the pressure on her throat. It felt as though her sandcastle was about to be demolished by a towering wave called reality.
Sirius followed. Of course he did — with those handsome features riddled with apprehension, lips poised to offer some logical solution to every damned problem in her life.
The moment he approached, intending to embrace her, Scarlett shoved him back abruptly, disgust flashing in the blue of her eyes like a tearing thunderbolt.
"You can’t be this close to me!" she burst out, without even looking at him.
Sirius’s lips curled into a malicious laugh.
"And why not?" he hissed, his voice dripping venom, his eyes locked on her like a predator sizing up its prey. "Afraid your little boyfriend will find out?"
He snatched her milkshake and took an exaggerated, angry gulp before tossing it straight into the bin.
"Danny is not my boyfriend," she shot back, firm.
Sirius exhaled in frustration, cornering Scarlett between his body and a pillar as they stepped out of the flow of people. She pressed her back hard against the stone behind her, as though trying to get as far from him as possible.
"Then what is it?" he pressed, gripping her chin and forcing her to look at him. "Because honestly, it looks like you ran from me the second those two idiots saw you!" The placid mercury sea of his irises solidified into a stare that demanded the truth.
"They’re my friends!" Scarlett lowered her voice, as though terrified someone might overhear. Her words brushed Sirius’s lips, their proximity scattering her breath across them. He curved his mouth into an acid smile.
"So what?!"
"And if… and if they… if they find out…"
"We’ll just obliviate them, simple as that!" Sirius tilted his head, as though it were the easiest thing in the world.
"Oh yeah? And then I’ll live locked inside your house as though I were dead?! Without being able to speak to anyone, without being able to have friends… without… without being able to…" The words tangled in her throat when her vocal cords became too busy expelling the sob she had been holding back.
"No, Scar… I… I didn’t…" He stammered, blinking rapidly, disoriented.
"And if… and if they find out… if someone finds out…" She faltered, her breath thinning. "Sirius… what if…" Scarlett lifted her gaze to him, anchoring herself in those two stars that had always guided her back to the man who was her home. "I’m scared."
"I know… I know." Sirius kissed the tip of her nose, resting his temple against hers, his black hair veiling them from the world around. "It’s alright. No one’s going to find out. You’re alright. You’re safe." He cupped her face with both hands, his warm breath brushing her lips. "You’re with me."
Scarlett shut her eyes, releasing the tears that had been stinging them.
"I’ll always live like a ghost, Sirius," she gasped through the crying.
"What do you mean?" Sirius couldn’t understand.
How could he understand?
"Will you ever introduce me to your friends?"
He furrowed his brows.
"You know I can’t do that."
"Exactly! You’ll never be able to introduce me to your friends. We… we’ll never…"
"I don’t care about that, Scarlett." Sirius shook his head, dragging his nose against hers.
"But… I care!" She sniffled, feeling his thumbs gently wiping away her tears. "We went out together and we were recognised and…"
"By your friends!" he cut in, his gaze locked onto hers. "Scarlett, you went fifteen years without seeing a single soul from the people we knew. Even if we were seen, they wouldn’t recognise you!"
"How can you be so sure of that?!" There was so much anguish, so much turmoil in her expression that Sirius felt his heart cave in.
"They won’t!" he insisted, obstinate. "I won’t allow it!"
The torment in Scarlett’s features boiled and flared until it became fury.
"Don’t promise me what you can’t keep!" Her hands fisted in the collar of his checked shirt. "Don’t do this to me!"
"Scarlett… I don’t care if you don’t believe me. But I will never, never, never allow you to go back to Azkaban. I promise." His hands pressed gently against her cheeks, as though trying to prove to her that he would keep that vow.
Scarlett opened her mouth to contradict him, but Sirius silenced the argument with a kiss, sealing his oath. He felt her jaw tense beneath his fingers, then ease, as her hands slipped from the collar of his shirt to his nape, pulling him closer. Scarlett parted her lips and bit his lower one, making Sirius push her body harder into the pillar with his own.
Breaking the touch with a gasp, Scarlett turned her face aside and lowered her head, her heart galloping with the effects their mouths together had sparked in her body: her legs had gone weak, her stomach filled with butterflies, and something incandescent and sublime flooded her chest with such force that she no longer even knew why she had been crying.
"Were you two kissing?!" Reg’s nearby voice made Sirius step sharply back with a long stride. Both of them stared at the boy — and Harry beside him — in shock.
"No!" The denial came in unison, and they glanced at each other before looking back at them.
"No?" Harry grinned — Lily’s very smile. "Didn’t know you liked wearing lipstick, Sirius." He teased, laughing with Reggie as Sirius wiped his thumb across his lips and stared at the smudge.
"Why are you lying? We’re the teenagers, that’s our job!" Regulus mocked, hands on his hips. "These youngsters today… all they think about is snogging…" He imitated an old man as he spoke to Harry.
"Says the one who lives in the broom cupboard with his girlfriend…" Harry quipped, watching with amusement as Reggie’s cheeks flushed.
"What’s this about?" Crossing her arms, Scarlett eyed the three of them, pretending to be put out at being the only one left out.
"We’ll talk about it at home." Sirius caught her hand, lacing their fingers together, and with his other arm he pulled Harry and Reg out of the arcade.
"Hm… alright…" Scarlett looked at them with suspicion, but she was far too wrapped up in the spell called Sirius Black to care.
The shopping centre was so packed that Scarlett felt sweat running down her spine as they wove their way through the crowd. It was as though half of London had gathered inside. She allowed herself a smile at the eyes upon them, pretending they were a family worthy of a magazine spread or a butter advert.
"You really ought to take Harry to a clothes shop…" Lily suggested, slipping past a group of children sharing a cone.
The remark made her glance at her godson, who was absorbed in thought as he scanned the shops around them, the reflections of passers-by flashing across his glasses as quickly as his thoughts. Harry wore a faded navy T-shirt with sleeves that reached past his elbows and shorts that hung below his knees. His socks were grimy at the ankles, and his trainers had part of the sole coming away as well as hanging loose.
Scarlett clenched her teeth as the conversation she and Lily had had the day before came back to her. About Harry and…
She stopped suddenly, causing a small pile-up of people and drawing confused looks from Sirius, Reg and Harry.
"Harry, what do you say we buy you some new clothes?" It wasn’t a suggestion.
It was an order.
"No, I’m fine, you don’t have to…"
"You do." Scarlett cut him off firmly, but with gentleness too.
"Reggie and I are off to the jeweller’s to buy his girlfriend’s ring," Sirius intervened before Harry could protest again. "Shall we meet in a bit?"
Regulus rolled his eyes, mortified by the idea, but he had no choice when Sirius tugged him along and Scarlett nodded for Harry to go with her.
He was a little taller than she was and would probably reach James’s height when he grew older. His wary gaze slid over the shopfronts with shyness, and he was constantly biting the inside of his cheek as he looked at the mannequins.
"Want to go in here?" Scarlett glanced up at the name of the designer shop. She swallowed, checking how many pounds she had in her purse, before looking back at Harry, waiting for his answer.
"S-suppose so." He cleared his throat, stepping into the shop without bothering to mask his discomfort.
Scarlett followed, as did her ghosts. Lily and James were the first to point towards various pieces hanging on the rails.
"Sweet Salazar, let the boy choose what he likes…" Red grumbled, stopping beside a lost-looking Harry.
"Pick a few things you like, Harry, and I’ll bring you some I think will suit you. Deal?"
Harry shoved his hands into his pockets and glanced about, nodding reluctantly.
"Alright."
He watched Scarlett sort through clothes so quickly he wasn’t sure whether she even realised what she was doing or if she was following some strange instinct. He pivoted on his heels and wandered the aisles filled with garments of every colour and fabric, his eyes landing here and there on plain, neutral pieces — the sort he usually liked: T-shirts without much print, dark jackets, and jeans.
Harry wiped his sweaty palms before picking up the first item, his fingers stroking the velvety fabric of the jumper. He sucked in his lower lip, tilting his head side to side. He checked the size and raised his brows at the price tag.
"Aren’t you Petunia’s nephew?!" The shop assistant’s question made Harry startle so hard he nearly dropped the garment. The woman looked him up and down with disdain. He couldn’t place her exactly — his aunt had always gone to lengths to hide him — but with the wobbling chin and biscuit face, he supposed she must be some relation of Uncle Vernon’s. "This establishment isn’t for… people like you." Her voice dripped with repulsive arrogance.
Harry swallowed hard, hung the garment back up, his heart racing. He searched for Scarlett among the racks, then glanced at the exit as if ready to bolt…
Yet… despite the discomfort and the rising desperation twisting inside him, why was he acting as though he’d done something wrong?
He looked back at the shop assistant, pushing his glasses up the bridge of his nose. With his aunt and uncle, he was used to bowing his head and keeping his mouth shut.
But Harry wasn’t with the Dursleys anymore.
"What do you mean, people like me?" He drew his brows together sharply, creasing his forehead.
The woman looked at him with disgust. She probably thought Harry attended St Brutus’s Secure Centre for Incurably Criminal Boys, like Aunt Marge.
"Riffraff," she spat.
Harry straightened, filling his lungs with air to answer back. He was a bloody Gryffindor — he wasn’t going to cower before this woman…
"What the fuck did you just say?" Scarlett hissed, hurling a heap of clothes to the floor with a crash. Her eyes widened, locking on the shop assistant, and Harry swore Scarlett was about to launch herself at her any second.
"Are you his mother? Because, last I checked, he didn’t have one…" She looked at her with the same contempt she’d shown Harry.
"Yes, I am!" Scarlett snarled, her stance swelling with threat as she strode towards the woman.
The assistant, however, only displayed a venomous smile.
"That explains a lot."
Harry had never seen Scarlett furious before. Her face flushed crimson, the veins in her neck bulging as she lifted her hand and slapped the cow so hard she went sprawling to the floor, tears springing from her plump face as she clutched her reddened cheek.
"You’re mad?!" the shop assistant whimpered, as stunned as Harry.
Scarlett leaned down towards her, an unhinged smile twisting her lips.
"I am! I’m fucking mad — and you’d better apologise right now, because you haven’t seen anything yet! No one talks like that to my godson!" She practically shouted, finger jabbing at the woman’s face. "Say sorry, now!"
Harry opened his mouth, meaning to step in and calm Scarlett, but fell silent as something strange began to coil through his chest. It was a warm sensation, almost sublime, that shut off all his alarmed instincts and steadied the pounding of his heart. It was… it was as though…
It was as though he wasn’t alone anymore. As though he no longer had to worry about his own safety or defend himself, because…
"We’re never setting foot in this pigsty again! You ought to be ashamed of yourself for treating a customer like that!" Scarlett bellowed over the woman’s pitiful excuse for an apology.
The commotion drew the attention of other customers and even a shopping-centre security guard, eyes watching the spat in astonishment while the woman wept on the floor.
Neither Scarlett nor Harry noticed that Sirius and Regulus had also come into the shop, as if they’d known perfectly well that the crowd had been caused by her.
Sirius frowned at the unconventional scene. Scarlett’s furious expression, however, told him everything.
"Bloody hell, my mum when she’s cross is terrifying…" Reg whispered, awed and frightened.
Sirius glanced around, touching his wand in the magic pocket of his trousers and murmuring a charm to scatter the Muggles nearby. Magically, the customers began checking their watches as if terribly late for some appointment, gradually emptying the shop. He then hurried down the aisles to Scarlett, wearing a smile as if nothing had happened, saying:
"Love, I looked for you all over the shopping centre!" His tone was so casual that Harry shot his godfather an anxious look, especially when he noticed the security guard still approaching.
Scarlett sighed, scorched the woman with her gaze and looked at Sirius over her shoulder.
"You knew bloody well we’d be here!" The reply came so exasperated that Sirius chose to keep quiet, fearing he’d become the target of Scarlett’s wrath. He gripped her hand, holding her palm tight so she wouldn’t pull away, and steered her away from the fallen shop assistant toward the exit, guiding Harry with his left hand.
The security guard inside the shop, however, reached them just before they left.
"Ma’am, we need you to stay here while we investigate the situation." He reached out to touch Scarlett’s shoulder, but one look from Sirius was enough to make him think twice.
"If you lay a finger on my wife, the only situation you’ll be investigating is a broken bone in hospital." Sirius threatened through his teeth.
The man, who wasn’t much taller than Sirius, hesitated. He ran a hand over his shiny pate and took a step back.
"Well, perhaps… we can let this go." He forced a smile when he noticed Regulus and Harry staring at him, as if endorsing Sirius’s warning.
Scarlett, though, lifted her chin, appraised the security guard from head to toe and then looked to the woman who was beginning to haul herself to her feet.
"Let it go? I’m not letting it go! That woman humiliated my godson!"
Before Sirius could react, Scarlett turned and shoved over one of the clothes rails, sending it crashing to the floor. She yanked Sirius by the hand, grabbed Reg with the other, and Harry with her free arm, and stormed out of the shop — her son impressed, her godson dumbfounded, and Sirius irritated.
He steered her into a quieter corridor, Harry and Reg close behind.
"You can’t go around hitting people like that, Scarlett!" Sirius scolded, glancing back before fixing his eyes on her again.
Scarlett drew a deep breath and rolled her eyes, folding her arms. Her blue eyes still sparked with outrage.
"She deserved it. She called Harry riffraff!" She clenched her jaw.
"It’s true," Harry admitted, lowering his gaze to his feet when Sirius and Reg turned to him. "She… she’s a relative of my uncle’s, I think."
"See?" Scarlett gave Sirius’s chest a light tap. "Besides, I’d have done the same for you and for Reggie." She said it with such matter-of-factness that Sirius caught himself smiling. "I protect the people I love. You know that. Especially my family." She reached out and ruffled Harry’s hair even more, earning a pursed-lip smile in reply.
Sirius hadn’t expected such conviction from Scarlett, but her words echoed through his chest with a force he couldn’t contend with. It all still felt like a dream, a sweet, delicate dream. And he wasn’t about to dwell on the moment it might end — no, he was far too busy drowning in the fact he finally had the family he’d always longed for. He nodded slowly, kissed Scarlett’s palm and gave Harry’s cheek a fond squeeze. Then he slung an arm over Reg’s shoulders.
They were a family, and nothing else mattered.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 62: All and none
Chapter Text
CXXX
Dear Ron,
You’re not going to believe this!
I didn’t even last a whole day at my aunt and uncle’s before Sirius and Scarlett turned up in this proper flashy sports car to get me! They took me to a diner and then we went to Sirius’s house—which is also where Remus and Regulus live.
I still don’t really get that part.
But Sirius said he’s making me my own room! And he showed me loads of photos from my parents’ wedding. He told me about my grandparents too, and I even listened to a Beatles tape (a Muggle band my parents liked).
Oh, and Buckbeak’s here as well!
Right now I’m staying in Regulus’s room. It’s a bit weird because he’s got all this Slytherin stuff up (gross) and his Quidditch medals, but besides that, he showed me how a Walkman works (it’s this box that plays music in your ears) and explained how he’s related to Remus.
Anyway, now that I’m here, we can actually hang out without my aunt and uncle getting in the way. I’m even leaving the landline number here in case you want to ring me again! Last year was a total disaster, but Reggie says it’s fine this time.
I heard Remus talking about having a barbecue this weekend, but I’ll check with him. What do you think about coming over? We could play Quidditch in the garden!
Harry.
P.S. Did your dad say anything about the Quidditch World Cup?
Mione,
You’re not going to believe this!
I didn’t even last a whole day at my aunt and uncle’s before Sirius and Scarlett turned up in this proper flashy sports car to get me…
… Reggie also gave me this orange nail polish that apparently belonged to my dad, and he said you’d know exactly what it’s for. Isn’t that a girl thing? Why would my dad have that sort of stuff?
Hedwig can go hunting now without any problem, and she and Buckbeak actually get along really well. Looks like Sirius is keeping him here until things calm down so Hagrid can come for him. Regulus asked me to send one of Buckbeak’s feathers with this letter to prove he’s being looked after.
How’s your holiday going? Did you go to France again? If you haven’t, Remus might be doing a barbecue this weekend, but I’ll check with him. I’ve already invited Ron, and of course you can come too. If you want, I’ll give you the Floo address, but you could also come by car with your parents (just tell me first, because I don’t think you’ll find the house without Remus or Sirius letting you).
Oh—almost forgot—you can call me now as well! I’ll put the number at the end of the letter.
Harry.
They came back home with so many bags that Harry’s room ended up crammed full of them, the bed covered in neatly folded clothes. Sirius had been crucial in choosing most of the outfits — which happened to be the same ones Scarlett had picked out. Reg had introduced him to the skater style of the time (massively baggy cargo trousers that left half your pants showing, odd beanies, and dungarees just like the ones Professor Sprout wore in her classes). He agreed to buy a pair of trousers and a beanie just to please Reg, but he was far more satisfied with his other purchases, enjoying the fresh smell of new clothes as he pulled them out of the bags.
It was almost impossible not to feel like an intruder among them. There was a sort of synergy between Sirius and Scarlett he still didn’t quite understand, and Regulus was so decent to him that Harry couldn’t help but feel a bit guilty about the way he’d treated him the year before, when he’d first learnt Sirius was innocent. Reg had been right all along.
“All right then, Harry, just tell me where you want me to put your jumpers so we can get this lot sorted quicker…” Sirius pulled him out of his daze, wand in hand.
Scarlett left the Walkman she’d given him on the bedside table along with the tapes before heading out when the phone rang. Regulus lay stretched out on the free corner of Harry’s bed, staring fixedly at the ring he’d bought for Victoria.
“Do you reckon she’ll like it?” Reg held out the little box to him. Harry glanced at the simple silver bands, one with a small stone to set the woman’s apart from the man’s.
He shrugged.
“Yeah, I think so.”
“What colour were your rings with my mum?” Reg turned his face to Sirius, who was making Harry’s clothes float into the drawers, folding themselves neatly.
“Black, tungsten.” Sirius held his hip with one hand, his wand flicking to and fro. “We liked black…”
“Yeah, that’s obvious,” Regulus muttered with a frown, sharing a grin with Harry.
“What? What’s so funny?” Sirius raised a brow, vanishing the empty bags.
“The two of you together… it’s just funny, that’s all.” He took the box back and shoved it into his pocket.
Down in the sitting room, Scarlett picked up the phone while watching Penny tend to Buckbeak in the garden.
“Huh, yeah, residence… of the… Blacks?!” She grimaced at her own words.
“HELLO! HELLO! CAN… CAN I SPEAK TO… HARRY POTTER?”
The boy shouted so loud Scarlett jumped, yanking the receiver away from her ear. She pressed a hand to her chest to steady her heart and drew in a long, very deep breath.
“WHY ARE YOU SHOUTING, LAD? ARE YOU BLOODY DEAF OR WHAT? IS THIS SOME KIND OF PRANK?!” Scarlett bellowed down the mouthpiece, exasperated.
“NO, NO, NO! IT’S ME, RON… HIS FRIEND…”
“HARRY, YOUR DEAF FRIEND’S ON THE PHONE!” She plonked the receiver down on the counter nearby, only to be met by a wide-eyed, pale Harry stepping out of the room. He froze, shoulders hunching as though bracing for a scolding.
Scarlett scratched the back of her neck.
“Think you… might’ve shouted a bit too much,” James muttered, as though trying to balance out her yelling.
“I… I… I forgot to say that… that I gave the number… of the house… to Ron…” Harry stammered, pushing his glasses nervously up his nose.
“It’s all right…” Scarlett fanned the air in front of her face with a smile. “Aren’t you going to answer?”
“Yeah… yeah, I will.” Harry, still tense, walked slowly up to the phone and lifted it to his ear with care, as though afraid it might break. “Hello? Hi, Ron… no, no, it’s fine… you don’t need to shout, just talk normal, I can hear you…”
Scarlett went back to Harry’s room, halting just before stepping inside when she saw Sirius and Regulus laughing at some silly remark. Her body eased at the sight, her gaze flicking between the two of them, though a sharp pang in her chest turned her smile into a grimace. Sirius had to know. He deserved to know. But how? How could she tell him?
A chill ran down her spine and she instinctively turned her head. Red was there too, watching them with that clear expression, though melancholy flickered in his iron-grey eyes. Then those pupils pierced into hers, cruel and sombre.
“If I hadn’t died… you’d have gone to him anyway, wouldn’t you?” he asked, his tone flat. “Even after promising me you wouldn’t… you’d have abandoned me for him.” It wasn’t a question.
Regulus needed no answer. Scarlett’s expression told him everything. Of course she would choose Sirius. She would always choose Sirius, and he would always be left aside.
“You know what the worst of it is, Scarlett? I did all of it for you. To protect you, to protect his son! I died for you both! And still…” He gave a sharp, venomous laugh, smiling like a viper.
“Stop lying. You didn’t do it for me!” Scarlett flared her nostrils, twisting her nose as she turned her face away abruptly.
“What?” Reggie asked from Harry’s bed, glancing at her sideways. “You all right, Mum?”
Scarlett forced a smile with a nod.
“I’m just… just… just thinking out loud.” She cleared her throat, moving away from the ghost to sit beside Reg on the bed.
“Harry’s on the phone?” Sirius’s gaze bore into her with such intensity that Scarlett wrapped her arms around herself, as if to shield against those eyes that could unearth her so easily.
“He is.”
“Good. The three of us need to have a serious talk.” He shut the door with a flick of his wand.
Scarlett’s heart picked up pace, pounding in her ears, hammering in her chest, making her fingers tremble. She could barely meet Sirius’s eyes, her breath catching at the thought that he might have found out the truth, that he knew…
“About what you did at Hogwarts, Reg.” Sirius turned his gaze to his nephew, leaning against Harry’s desk to face them.
Scarlett let out a rush of air in relief, though the knot in her throat didn’t loosen. She looked at her son, his pale face flushing until it turned crimson.
“But… but… I thought…”
“No, I’m talking about the talk.” Sirius shot a meaningful look at Scarlett, who blinked several times, not understanding at all.
“What talk?!” She frowned deeply.
“The same one your parents had with me… when… during the winter holidays…”
Scarlett gave a nervous laugh, throwing her hands up.
“I’m a woman, I’m not taking part in this!” She jumped off the bed, intent on leaving.
“My mum doesn’t have to be here!” Reg looked at Scarlett, then at Sirius, terror etched across his features. “Actually, Uncle Remus and Uncle Orfy…”
“I need your support here!” Sirius swallowed a laugh, raising his brows at her discomfort. “He’s your son!”
“And was my father your father when he had this talk with us?” she shot back, more sharply this time.
“Hang on… why would my grandparents…?” Reg’s expression twisted into disgust. “No, no, I don’t want to know!” He clamped his hands over his ears and screwed his eyes shut.
“Sirius… I… I don’t… I don’t even know what to say!” Scarlett stammered, her hands flailing in frustration.
“You don’t need to say anything! I just… I need your support. I need your presence.” He exhaled all the air from his lungs, shoulders sagging. “I need… I need you, that’s all.” With every word, his voice grew softer, until the last two were barely more than a whisper.
Regulus cracked one eye open, fixing Scarlett with those grey-blue irises. She pressed her lips together and nodded, moving closer to Sirius as she perched beside him on the desk. Her fingers traced the tattooed skin of his knuckles and the silver rings until Sirius laced his hand with hers, his gaze dropping to the engagement ring he’d given her so long ago. His smile, once playful, was now overcome with tenderness.
“I know you’re responsible, Reg, and even though Remus has already had this talk with you, I just want… I just want you to know you can trust us. I mean… the responsibility of a relationship covers a lot of things, and that includes intimacy.” Sirius’s fingertips traced the back of Scarlett’s hand before squeezing it. “I know you care about your girlfriend, but… this goes for every woman you shag…”
Regulus dragged his hand hard down his face, desperate to rid himself of the shame any way he could. When he realised it wasn’t going anywhere, he simply sagged, hugging his knees, shooting occasional glances at Sirius and Scarlett and nodding along. The mention of that last word, however, made him bury his head between his legs.
“When you do have sex… Regulus, look at me!” Sirius demanded, though not harshly. Reg lifted his head just enough to reveal his eyes. “You must be gentle and respectful. You need to listen to her and make sure she feels comfortable. And if she says no or changes her mind…”
“I know.” Reggie muttered, voice muffled. “But we… we’ve never…”
“Then what exactly were you doing in the broom cupboard?” Sirius’s face twisted in bemusement.
“No, it’s just… it’s just we… we never… never did everything, you know?” He bit his lower lip and gave a helpless little shrug.
Scarlett didn’t know whether to be impressed with Sirius’s mature approach or charmed by Reg’s reaction, so all she did was let out a short laugh.
“See?! Not half as bad as you thought it’d be.” Sirius said, looking at Scarlett, whose cheeks coloured faintly. The way he grinned at her, showing those perfect teeth and wicked dimples, sent the butterflies in her stomach into a frenzy.
“Right, I… I need to get to work.” Scarlett shook her head, caught in those starry eyes. “I can’t be late this time.”
“What time… what time does the gig finish?” Regulus cleared his throat, purposefully changing the subject.
“Late.” Scarlett pulled her lips into a pout. “Best not wait up for me.”
“And you’ve got work early tomorrow?!” The question came with an adorable little pout that instantly reminded her of Sirius back in the day.
“I’m off tomorrow.” She winked at him, and Reg stretched out on the bed in triumph. “I… is it all right if I…” Scar mumbled a few incoherent words while holding Sirius’s gaze, drowning in that silver sea.
“Yes, you can sleep here again.” He nodded, the tenderness in his eyes giving way to that familiar burn she knew so well. “You can sleep here whenever you want.”
“You don’t need to wait up for me either.” Scarlett rolled her eyes, smitten, leaning in to kiss his cheek, fully aware Sirius would do the same as that morning: he turned at the last second, sealing their lips in a kiss that said it all.
Reggie pretended to gag.
“I need to get some work things done anyway.” Sirius shot Reg a reproving look.
Scarlett pulled herself free of Sirius and kissed her son’s hair. She let that soothing calm spread through her whole body as she left Harry’s room, finding him sprawled on the sofa still on the phone, with Remus sat beside him reading the paper.
“Oh, yeah, Ron… hang on…” Harry pressed the receiver to his chest, looking anxiously at Scarlett. “Scar, can you ask Sirius about the barbecue on Sunday?”
Scarlett couldn’t hide her startled expression.
“Barbecue on Sunday?” She put a hand on her hip.
“I thought about having one this weekend, invite some of Harry’s and Reg’s friends…” It was Remus who explained, without bothering to look up at her.
“Oh.” Scarlett couldn’t quite feign enthusiasm, her gaze drifting over her ghosts scattered around the sitting room: James and Lily were watching Harry closely, the two of them leaning on the back of the sofa with those loving smiles that made Scarlett’s heart falter. Regulus, meanwhile, kept himself busy staring out of the window beside her piano, deliberately ignoring her. “I can… of course.”
She returned to Harry’s doorway, but didn’t step inside. In there, Sirius was still speaking to his nephew:
“I want you to know you can tell me everything. The girls you meet, the parties you go to, the drugs you try…” He grinned when Reggie blushed.
“Sirius!” Reg complained, looking away.
“I just want you to feel comfortable talking to me about those things. I did all of that, and I reckon you might too. Just… promise me you’ll talk to me.”
“Fine, but I’m never doing any of that.” Reggie gave an awkward smile, rubbing his forehead against his knee.
“That’s fine too. But if you do… you know.” Sirius stretched his arm out and ruffled the boy’s hair, so much like his brother’s. The smile on his lips faltered, but he left his fingers tangled in those black strands, trying to reach some good memory he still had of Regulus.
He couldn’t. It was something he was still working through with Dr Dimitrescu, while knowing he bore some guilt in it. He wasn’t sure if he even wanted to remember his brother with any sort of fondness — it was as if all he had set aside for Regulus was anger, bitterness, and disdain. Even knowing he felt far more for his brother… he was afraid.
Afraid, because he knew he should have done more for him, and he hadn’t.
He blamed himself for his brother’s fate and death in the same way he blamed himself for what had happened to Scarlett and to the Potters.
And he was already carrying far too much for…
“So… my grandfather caught the two of you together and still taught you how to ride a motorbike?!” The question yanked Sirius violently out of his reverie, and he blinked a few times, staring at his nephew in bewilderment.
“Er…” He ran a hand through his hair, licking his lips as the memory came back to him. “Your grandfather threatened me, said he’d… he’d throw me off the bike if I ever hurt her.” The grin returned to his lips, spreading to Reg.
“You were never thrown off the bike, so I take it you never did hurt her,” Reggie remarked, with pride.
Sirius felt a sharp pang in his chest, his laughter dimming even as the amusement lingered. He’d hurt Scarlett more times than he could count, and shame washed over him with force. Regulus didn’t seem to notice — or if he did, he said nothing.
He looked towards the door, to where Scarlett had just walked away. The thorny subject pushed against his chest, clawing to break out, but Sirius smothered it with a deep breath, anchoring himself in Regulus’s presence, in the smile of the boy who should have been his.
“I’ll teach you this summer… if you want, of course.” Sirius offered, folding his arms.
“You’re joking? ’Course I want to!”
Soon Harry and Remus joined in the conversation, and though Sirius did a fine job of pretending to enjoy the moment as much as they did, his mind was already occupied with the talk that would begin the instant Scarlett returned. There was so much to say, and he didn’t want to push too far — not when things finally seemed all right.
.
.
.
Scarlett was determined not to let her family’s tragedy turn her into something worse. She knew, though, that to make that happen, she needed to mend her mistakes.
And as much as she thought Regulus deserved it… it wasn’t right, and it wasn’t fair. So she forced herself not to listen to the whispers about her when they had breakfast in the Great Hall, ignored the owls delivering letters from everyone’s families, made herself take part in every class, and now, breathing deeply for courage, she walked the dark, squalid corridors at Remus’s side on the way to the dreaded Hall of Hieroglyphs.
“Want me to wait here?” Remus offered, glancing at her from the corner of his eye.
“Yes, I won’t be long.” Scarlett pressed her lips into a subtle smile and carried on, feeling her friend’s gaze lingering on her shoulders.
Regulus wasn’t far away. The lights along the walls stretched Red’s shadows across the space, moving ceaselessly as he polished one of the statues. His feet slid silently across the floor like a serpent, and yet his proud bearing and sharp nose gave him the look of a bird of prey.
Scarlett let out a loud sigh to draw his attention, but Regulus ignored her. His expressionless mask was so deeply carved into his features that he revealed nothing, not even surprise. He carried on with his task as if he were an inanimate object, as rigid, lifeless and powerless as the statue he was cleaning. His skin was paler than usual, and there were dark circles beneath his eyes.
She couldn’t help but wonder if Orion and Walburga had done something to him. For some reason, her gaze drifted to Red’s back, as though something in her subconscious whispered that if they had punished their son, the proof would be there — like Sirius once had whipped him.
“Red…” Her call too was ignored. The torches threw their flames into his eyes, turning the iron within them incandescent. Regulus went on polishing the statue’s foot with one hand, the other shoved deep into the pocket of his Slytherin cloak.
Scarlett moved closer, making him lessen the force of his repetitive movements. His face turned slightly towards her, yet he didn’t meet her eyes. He clenched his jaw and, though his expression remained impassive, Scarlett could feel some strange storm raging inside him.
She took a step back, her confidence shrivelling the moment fear began to grow — as if Regulus were on the verge of hurting her. She wetted her lips and straightened, folding her arms behind her back.
“I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have done that. I was… I was a coward, and… cruel.” Her voice rang out in the hall, trembling.
Regulus stopped what he was doing, moving only his eyes to glance at her sideways. For a moment Scarlett swore he was going to speak, but then, as if she didn’t exist at all, Red returned to his work, this time turning his back fully to her.
“I thought that… since you like lying so much…” She let out a sharp breath through her teeth. “Why did you lie to me, Regulus?”
The crackle of the candles was the only sound in the suffocating silence. Though Scarlett hadn’t demanded an answer, the lack of one soon began to gnaw at her.
“Why do you lie so much?”
Regulus stood still, his gaze lost somewhere across the hall, until at last he turned to Scarlett, catching her in the iron-grey of his harsh irises. He blinked slowly; the indifference cracked, giving way to that familiar volatility he would show on occasion, as if he were still the boy she once knew and cared for.
“Because…” Red began, softly, but the words died on his lips. He held his breath.
Scarlett made as if to go to him, to try and tear down the walls he had so deftly rebuilt. To try and rescue the boy who had once been her friend. But he vanished as quickly as he had surfaced, swallowed by layer upon layer of pretence and coldness, twisting the Slytherin’s features until all he showed was disdain.
She stood there, silent, watching Red gather his things, sling his bag over his shoulder and leave her behind, ashamed and dumbstruck. She forced the air from her lungs, rubbing her glove against the Signet, her gaze skimming over the dark floor, the bitter taste of failure and defeat coating her mouth.
Her eyes turned to the exit of the Hall. On her way back, Scarlett noticed something dragging along the floor, almost completely hidden by the shadows the statues cast across the chamber. She crouched down and picked up a crumpled scrap of parchment. Slowly, she unfolded it, coming face to face with handwriting so flawless it made her envious. It resembled Sirius’s somewhat, though his hand had never been quite so rounded.
Scarlett stepped closer to the nearest candelabrum and squinted to read:
I am a ship adrift
Driven by the fury of my progenitor,
Blown by the screams of my matriarch,
Run aground on the sorrows of my brother,
Wrecked upon the tragic expectations placed before my very birth.
I am the storm, but I am also the calm.
I am the one who holds the girl by her cloak, but also the one who pushes her away.
I am a coward, a craven, a traitor.
I am a brother, a son, a lover.
Unable to break free from the chains of being pure-blood,
Forever fated to be the second, the spare, the one left over.
The translucent shadow that will never truly take form,
Walking a path never carved for me.
I am the lion’s heart, the cat, and the red.
I am the solid iron, the liquid mercury, the dawn’s mist.
The executioner and the saviour.
Who am I?
I am all and none.
All and none.
— RAB
RAB? Scarlett lifted her gaze towards the path Regulus had taken. She folded the parchment and slipped it into her pocket before leaving the hall.
.
.
.
“How was it?” Sirius whispered in her ear, so close that Scarlett felt the warmth of the question brush against her cheek.
She sighed, her gaze drifting up to the thousands of candles floating in the air above the tables. The enchanted ceiling of the Great Hall flickered with sudden bursts of thunder. Conversations rippled all around: James confiding something to Peter, who gave his usual shrill laugh; Remus discussing that morning’s DADA lesson with Mary and Lily; and Marlene, further down, throwing her those pointed looks that Scarlett found anything but pleasant.
“He didn’t even look at me.” Scarlett pressed her lips together, turning her attention back to her boyfriend. The candles flickered across his pale face, his black lashes, his silver eyes.
Sirius gave her a crooked smile and kissed her cheek in that way that melted all her misfortunes.
“At least you tried.” He squeezed her waist, the other hand busy cutting into a slice of treacle tart.
Scarlett nodded, curling into him, resting her face on Sirius’s shoulder. For a long while she just stared at her chocolate cake, stabbing it absently with her fork. Then she craned her neck, peering past the Hufflepuff and Ravenclaw tables until her eyes landed on the Slytherins’. She caught sight of Regulus between Barty and Evan. Her fingers tightened around the fork until she dropped it, letting it clatter noisily onto her plate.
“What is it?” Sirius dabbed his mouth with a napkin, pulling her closer.
“Does Regulus have a middle name?” She looked at him without turning her head, her finger tracing the rim of her golden goblet of wine.
“He does. Why?” Setting his napkin aside, Sirius fixed his attention wholly on her.
“What is it?” Scarlett shot back, her tone edged, though the sharpness was masked by curiosity.
“Arcturus.” Sirius frowned, a line etching itself between his brows. “Has something happened?”
Scarlett’s lips trembled. It was maddening how easily Sirius could read her, especially at such proximity, as though they were breathing the same air.
“I just… I was curious. Regulus Arcturus Black.” She muttered it more to herself than to him.
“It’s my grandfather’s name…” Sirius’s piercing pupils locked onto hers. He reached out, tucking a stray strand of hair behind her ear. The simple gesture was enough to soothe her erratic heartbeat, to quiet the unrest, to dull the sharp edges of the anger gnawing at her from within, so that all it could do was prick her faintly. “Are you all right?”
At any other time, the question would have annoyed her. But Scarlett shut her eyes as Sirius’s hand — firm, adorned with rings and tattoos — came to rest against her face. The touch was so gentle, yet so meaningful, that she let it drown out the clamour around her, letting it resound through her body with the very feeling she had been searching for in those days.
Love is a strange thing. It was there; it had always been there. Scarlett had never stopped loving Sirius, but in that moment it felt more tangible. As though it were more real. As though it flowed from her heartbeat into his pulse without the need for a single word. And there was so much in her heart that it was hard to feel only love; hard to let only that seep through her skin, her glances, her gestures. Yet it was there, shimmering in Sirius’s starry eyes and brushing against the turbulent ocean of Scarlett’s own.
She wanted to cry, and she hadn’t the faintest idea why.
Before the first tear could fall, Dumbledore rose to his feet. The hum of conversation that filled the hall ceased almost at once, leaving only the patter of rain on the rooftops and the howl of the bitter wind.
“I must ask for your attention for a few announcements.” The Headmaster smiled, as though what he had to say was not at all grave. “The House Quidditch Cup has been postponed until the month of April.”
The entire Gryffindor team exchanged glances, though none of them spoke. They looked far too stunned for that. Scarlett swirled her goblet of wine and took a sip.
“This is owing to the Inter-School Quidditch Tournament which will take place in January, between Hogwarts and Durmstrang. This event has been conceived and arranged by both schools to foster unity and healthy competition among our students.” Dumbledore cast a warm smile over the hall. “Applications for the Hogwarts team trials will open as of tomorrow.”
Sirius raised his brows at James, who pushed his glasses up his nose as though already mapping out strategies in his mind.
“The finest players of each House will be entered based on the positions they hold as starters for their House teams. Following this, there shall be a selection, and only the most qualified will represent Hogwarts in this special event.” Dumbledore paused, allowing the buzz to swell again between the tables.
Now the eyes turned to Scarlett, the lone Slytherin at the Gryffindor table. Everyone — or at least most — knew she had studied at Durmstrang. She drew a deep breath, feeling Sirius’s hand press at her waist as if to assure her she was safe, though all the calm she had been clinging to seemed to slip like water through her fingers.
She did not notice the way her uncle watched her from the staff table, nor that Dumbledore’s gaze lingered on her amidst the lions. Her eyes were fixed upon the dark liquid in her goblet. Then, without a word, she rose abruptly, her Slytherin cloak billowing as she strode towards the exit.
Despite her clenched fists, Scarlett’s features were not twisted nor did fear bubble in her eyes. No. Quite the opposite.
A bitter smile stained her lips, fed by the frantic hammering of her heart. She ought to have been apprehensive, but… for some reason there bloomed a shameful excitement in her chest, something so vile she could not fully understand it.
She halted abruptly as she reached the ante-hall to the Great Hall. Her mouth watered, her hands trembled. The air felt thin.
That dark, venomous, corroding thing clung to the ramparts of her heart, scaling them and twisting the rest of her feelings until they bled.
She and Dimitri were to meet again.
He had information about what happened to her parents.
Scarlett licked her lips and laughed to herself, not caring that the portraits around her bore witness to her glimpse of revenge.
“Scar!” Sirius’s voice pulled her from the illusion and she glanced at him from the corner of her eye, still smiling.
“It’s fine.” Scarlett answered before he could ask. Facing him, though, she knew she couldn’t hide the ferocity tainting her gaze. “I need to—” She drew a deep breath. “I need to speak to Rosier.”
“Rosier?” Sirius raised an eyebrow. “Why?”
Scarlett held his look, lifting her nose with a touch of defiance.
“I’m going back on the Quidditch team.” she replied, as if it were obvious.
“What?” Sirius reacted at once, stepping forward to catch her arm gently. “Are you willing to train with Death Eaters?”
Under normal circumstances Scarlett would have conceded to Sirius’s point — after all, that was why she’d left the team. Rosier was a Death Eater; it wouldn’t be long before others joined Voldemort’s ranks. But… the sensations at her core were quickly numbed by the certainty that she would find Dimitri there, that she would take her revenge that…
No. It was not just that. It was something far deeper; it was…
The need for closure.
“I am.” Her voice wavered, as did her gaze. “Dimitri will be there and… and he… he has information about the death of my parents.” She panted, as if the mere mention of it might steal her breath. “And I will wrench it from him, whatever it takes.”
Worry washed over Sirius’s face. Scarlett did not flinch from his look; she stared back with equal intensity. He blinked several times, his mouth tightening as he began to shake his head.
“You’re not going to do that.” The resolute tone he used made her click her tongue. “It’s far too dangerous.”
Scarlett rolled her eyes, trying to pull away from Sirius, but he would not let her. His arms wrapped around her, drawing her into him until the air that had already been scarce thinned completely. It was clear he would resist; he would try to protect her however he could, and she knew he was right. Even though contradicting him would break her heart…
“Please, Sirius.” Her voice broke as her boyfriend’s face blurred before her eyes. “Please, just… just try to understand me.” She placed a hand over her chest, feeling Sirius’s thumb brush away her tears. “I need this… I need answers. I need… I need to know who killed my parents, I need closure. I need something… to numb this pain. I can’t… I can’t move on without it.”
The sobs rose in her throat and, no matter how she tried to smother them, the hiccups burst out of her control. Scarlett hated begging—God, no one likes begging—but she knew Sirius would understand, because only he could. He had seen her excesses and her mistakes, and he had chosen to love her all the same. He would understand. He always did.
“I just want peace.” Her voice came out as a thread.
Sirius drew a deep breath, tossing his wild hair out of his face.
“Peace? My love…” He huffed, clutching her tight against him, holding her chin as though their locked gaze alone could grant her some measure of sense. “You think you’ll find peace by going back on the Quidditch team? Especially when… when we…”
“Sirius… please.” Scarlett pleaded, hating herself for it. She knew she’d regret this decision, but she needed change. Any change. Sitting locked away in the Gryffindor common room crying would lead her nowhere but deeper into the pit of despair.
Sirius’s heart lurched. What she was suggesting terrified him. He glanced at James, Remus and Peter further off, then back to Scarlett, to her reddened eyes and freckled cheeks.
“I know how you feel…” he murmured, still hesitant. “But we’re going to do this together.” He finished, resolute.
Scarlett’s eyes widened, stunned. She had expected Sirius to try and dissuade her, to tell her not to get tangled up with Dimitri or the other Death Eaters.
“Yeah… or did you think we’d let you go alone into a nest of Death Eaters?!” James cut in before she could protest. “You heard Dumbledore — we’re all going to be part of the Hogwarts team, so…”
Scarlett glanced over her shoulder at him.
“And it’s not just Dimitri who might know something,” Remus added, brushing a hand over the scar on his chin.
“It’s too risky…” Peter was the only one to object, his eyes shifting uncertainly between Sirius and James. “But… if this really is what you want, Scar… you’ve got my support.” He shrugged.
Scarlett buried her face in the collar of Sirius’s shirt, and he held her so tightly it was as though she didn’t need to breathe.
“We’ll find the truth together,” he repeated in her ear.
Then James gave her a firm, encouraging pat on the shoulder before folding himself into the embrace, followed by Remus, and finally Peter.
And she cried, once more, for those she had lost.
Those she had lost… and those she had gained.
It was not conventional, nor what she had ever expected.
But it was her family now.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 63: And when was the last time you weren’t scared?
Chapter Text
CXXXI
It was nearly dawn when Scarlett parked her Honda haphazardly, headlights still on and the rear completely misaligned with the garage entrance. Even so, she felt so light she couldn’t bring herself to care. She staggered towards the front door and almost fell, tripping on the steps.
When she opened the door, however, she made an effort not to make a sound. She stepped carefully, very slowly, trying to keep her balance, but that dizzy lightness didn’t help. Leaning against the wall as she crossed the hallway, she blinked hard, trying not to bump into anything. It was dark and hard to see, though she had a fair idea where the furniture was — especially where Sirius’s room was.
"You’ve been drinking?" The voice behind her made her straighten up in fright. She turned slowly and found Sirius sitting in the armchair, a document in his lap and a pile of others on the table. The only light came from the floor lamp beside him, aimed directly at his face, forcing her to squint to see him properly.
Scarlett swallowed hard. She could barely stand the weight of Sirius’s hostile stare.
"Nooo..." she drawled, her voice sluggish, the tone clearly betraying the lie. Sirius narrowed his eyes, his brows knitting together. "Just had a little… I’m sober," she tried to correct herself, her wavering tone giving her away.
Sirius rose abruptly, exasperated, throwing the papers from his lap onto the table. As he stepped forward, the light faded, and he was swallowed by the darkness — only his eyes still gleamed like the stars outside.
"You do realise that when you drive drunk, you’re not only putting your own life at risk, don’t you, Scarlett?" he asked, his irascible tone dropping to a furious hiss.
Scarlett opened her mouth to justify herself, but no excuse could cut through the drunken fog clouding her mind. Sirius’s stern gaze made any argument die before it could form. She shifted her weight from one foot to the other, holding onto the sofa for balance, her body swaying back and forth like a pendulum.
"I think you’d better sleep on the sofa tonight," Sirius said flatly. He walked past her towards the bedroom without looking back. Before opening the door, he hesitated, expecting Scarlett to protest — to explode, as she normally would in any other situation.
Then he dared a sideways glance. Though he couldn’t say she was unaffected by the situation, she certainly didn’t seem as shaken as he thought she should be. Scarlett merely nodded, apathetic, and dropped onto the sofa, too tired — too drunk — to argue.
Sirius remained standing in the doorway, watching her. Scarlett looked so awkward, yet somehow so at ease, sprawled across the cushions, her face half-buried in them.
Her breathing soon grew heavy, signalling that she had fallen asleep, defeated by the alcohol.
He only sighed, running a hand through his hair as he looked at her. He couldn’t help the mix of worry and irritation pounding in his chest, especially because he’d hoped Scarlett might actually talk to him that night. He needed to speak about Orfy, about Regulus, about Reggie and… about… about everything.
He went back to the bedroom, grabbed a folded sheet from the bed, and returned quietly to the living room. As he approached Scarlett, he wrinkled his nose when the sharp scent of alcohol hit him. Shaking his head, he untied the laces of her boots, slipped them off, and gently draped the sheet over her, tucking it carefully around her feverish body. He pulled Scarlett’s legs straight so she wouldn’t be twisted on the sofa, then brushed his fingers across her pale forehead, moving aside a strand of hair stuck there.
Sirius squeezed his eyes shut and, resigned, leaned in to press a soft kiss to Scarlett’s temple. He didn’t want to do it, but it was stronger than him. He traced delicate circles with his thumb over her cheekbones, outlining her jaw right after. Scarlett’s facial muscles twitched, but she didn’t stir.
He watched her for a few more seconds. Then he sighed again, stood up, and returned to his room, closing the door quietly behind him.
.
.
.
No matter how much Scarlett buried her face into the leather sofa, the morning light still seemed to pierce through her skull with fine, sharp needles. Her head throbbed relentlessly, her stomach churned, and her mouth carried a bitter taste that only made her feel more nauseous.
"He made you sleep on the sofa?" Red’s voice echoed beside her, dripping with sarcasm.
"Looks that way," Scarlett grumbled, hiding her face from the brightness with a cushion.
He snorted a laugh, his ghostly form passing through Scarlett as he turned to watch the house-elf bringing cleaning supplies into the room. Red folded his arms across his chest, eyeing Scarlett with biting amusement.
"If I were you, I’d get out of there…" he advised, nodding toward the pile of documents scattered over the table.
She didn’t listen. She was far too drowsy for that… but soon, the loud and deliberate noise of Penny cleaning the house made it impossible to go back to sleep.
"Up you get, Mistress Black, you stink," Penny said without a hint of restraint, sweeping the floor hard around the sofa.
Scarlett barely moved, though her headache worsened with the elf’s racket. It didn’t take long before Penny, growing impatient, grabbed her arm and Disapparated her straight into Sirius’s bedroom.
The whole world compressed and spun as if she were on a carousel at two hundred kilometres an hour. When she reappeared, Scarlett landed heavily on Sirius’s bed, her body rolling across the sheets. She blinked slowly, swaying between stupor and pain, not realising Sirius was in the room, shirtless, brushing his teeth. On seeing her, he placed a hand on his hip, his brows knitting as he turned to Penny, about to demand what the hell she thought she was doing.
Before he had the chance, the elf Disapparated, and Scarlett suddenly pushed herself up from the bed, stumbling all the way to the bathroom. She dropped to her knees in front of the toilet and began to vomit. Sirius, toothbrush still in his mouth, came over and held her dyed hair back as she emptied the contents of her stomach. She went on until there was nothing left, and when she finally stopped, she let her face rest against the toilet lid, breathing heavily.
Sirius handed her a piece of tissue so she could wipe her face.
"Do you want a bath?" he asked, his voice laced with concern.
Scarlett grimaced. Why was he being so gentle with her? She closed her eyes, focusing only on breathing, trying to gather the strength to stand.
She couldn’t.
"No need… I’m fine," she mumbled in a whisper.
Sirius went back to the sink, finishing brushing his teeth without taking his eyes off her.
"You need a bath…"
"I said I’m fine," Scarlett cut in, repeating herself.
Sirius wrinkled his nose in a doubtful expression. Without another word, he went to the bath, turning on the tap to fill it with hot water. He knew Scarlett; he knew she was stubborn, and he couldn’t leave her like this. Besides, as much as he didn’t want to, he knew exactly what she was going through.
"I don’t want Reggie and Harry to see you like this," he said, his tone carrying the severity he knew would reach her.
Scarlett covered her face with her hands, as if she could hold back the shame rising in her chest.
Why had she drunk so much?
Oh, yes… they’d been celebrating. Celebrating what, exactly? Harry and Reg’s holidays? No, it couldn’t be just that, it couldn’t…
She tried to recall the night before, but her head throbbed just at the thought.
"Fine." The agreement came out fragile.
Scarlett drew in a deep breath, catching Sirius’s reflection in the mirror behind her, his expression softening bit by bit. He tried to help her stand, but she refused with a gesture, swaying to the side as she braced herself against the nearby wall.
"You need—"
"Could you just leave me alone? I don’t want you to see me like this either," Scarlett cut him off, her voice pitched two tones higher than usual.
Sirius meant that he already knew all her facets, had seen every version of her, but there was something so raw and humiliating in her request that he didn’t even try to argue. He simply exhaled loudly through his nose and stared at an indistinct point in the bathroom before turning back to her. His mouth opened, and several seconds passed before the words came out:
"I’ll ask Penny to brew a hangover potion." He left the bathroom without waiting for a response.
As soon as the door closed, Scarlett felt tears streaming down her face. Her body ached, her stomach churned, and bloody hell, her head… what the hell was she doing?!
She undressed, her knees trembling under the weight of her own body. As she stepped into the bath, she sloshed water onto the floor but didn’t care. She let her muscles sink into the hot water, eyes closing as the steam rose and dampened her face. The nausea was still there, though the discomfort was beginning to be eased by the comforting heat.
Scarlett submerged her head under the water as if she were being swept away by a tide, far from the painful reality. Her bleached hair floated around her face; bubbles rose from her nostrils; and a ghostly, displeased face stared back at her from the surface — hazel eyes, round glasses, and a crease between the brows.
She surfaced, staring at the white ceiling of the bathroom, then at the large window beside the bath that looked out onto the garden. The day outside was beautiful, the sky a clear blue and the sun determined to scorch anyone daring enough to step out.
"You need to stop drinking." It wasn’t a request. James rarely used that condescending tone, and Scarlett wasn’t in the mood to deal with him.
"Why?" she practically spat, defensive, putting a hand over her eyes against the sting of the brightness.
"Is this the second… third… fourth time you’ve driven drunk?!" He raked his messy hair with his fingers the way he always did when agitated.
"I’m alive, aren’t I?!"
"By a miracle!" he shouted, his voice scraping at her eardrums. Scarlett winced at the sound.
"James… could you not… do this now?" she pleaded, her voice dragging.
He laughed, breathless. It wasn’t good humour.
"No, I’m going to do this now!" he snapped, jabbing a finger at her face. "You can’t keep drinking like this!"
"Can’t I? Why not? Just because… when I drink… I can finally get rid of you three?" She pinched her temples between thumb and forefinger, trying to dull the sharp stabbing in her vision.
"Oh, so that’s what you want? To get rid of us?" James’s upper lip curled, his brows twisting. "Why didn’t you say so? I can sort that out right now!"
"No, Jamie, I didn’t—" Scarlett tried to argue, exhausted, but James had already walked through the wall, disappearing.
She would have cried if she weren’t so worn out. It was true that she drank to have a moment free from her ghosts, but that was only part of it. The alcohol made everything more bearable — her past, her mistakes… her crimes. It numbed the guilt and the anger she felt towards herself. It softened the torment of simply being… herself.
Of being Scarlett Gaunt.
It made her hate herself a little less, too.
It was an easy, comfortable escape from all her problems. How could she refuse to get drunk when what she got in return were smiles, flawless performances, and not a single trace of self-pity? No remorse.
And the consequences… pfft, what consequences? Sirius had made her sleep on the sofa, but they’d make up soon enough and everything would be fine. He’d make her feel safe and loved, probably give her a lecture about coming home drunk (she couldn’t remember if he’d already done that when he sent her to the sofa), and then they’d kiss, have sex and boom! A great day for Scarius, thank you very much.
With that thought, Scarlett drifted off in the bath, her head resting against the soft cushion at the edge.
When she woke, she heard sounds coming from outside — laughter. She frowned, blinking lazily to bring her vision into focus. Lifting her head, she groaned at the pain in her neck and looked out the window. Outside, Sirius was shirtless, showing his motorbike to Reggie and Harry. They were laughing, animated, while Buckbeak stood curiously beneath his willow, watching everything with interest.
Sirius grabbed a hose and began washing the bike, explaining something to the boys, who listened in fascination. Reggie slung an arm around Harry’s shoulders, and Harry laughed in a way Scarlett had never seen before. James and Lily watched the scene from the chairs by the poolside, and Regulus was nowhere in sight.
Scarlett felt a stab to the heart as she looked at her best friends, powerless before the scene. She knew how much they’d give anything to be part of it and, though it was selfish of her…
She climbed out of the bath with a herculean effort, slipping on the wet floor and landing on her knees. Luckily, her whole body already hurt, so the pain in her knee didn’t make much difference. She wrapped herself in a towel and drank the hangover potion Penny had left on Sirius’s bedside table, her gaze falling to the stone basin beside it. She traced the carved runes along the rim with her fingertips, grimacing as the potion’s bitter taste clung to her palate.
She had noticed the basin before, of course, but hadn’t had the time to think about what it was — she’d been far too occupied with Sirius undressing her. But now…
Her gaze was drawn to the silvery substance inside — neither liquid nor gas — shimmering faintly within the object. She tilted her head to the side, leaning closer as if seeing it from a different angle might somehow answer her questions.
"Mistress Black?!" The call made Scarlett straighten at once, as though a steel rod had been driven up her spine. She turned to see Penny standing at the bedroom door. "Get dressed. Breakfast is served," the elf grumbled, eyeing her from head to toe before shutting the door.
Scarlett did as she was told, slipping reluctantly into another set of Sirius’s clothes and heading to the kitchen, even though every step cost her more energy than she could spare. Her attention, however, caught on Remus leaning against the doorway that opened onto the garden. He was watching the scene outside, the faint smile on his face fading the moment he spotted her. He stepped aside to let her pass, but Scarlett only backed away, settling at the table laden with food prepared by Penny.
She picked up a piece of toast and wrinkled her nose as the smell of coffee hit her, making the urge to vomit surge back with a vengeance. Resting her wrist on the table, still holding the toast, she breathed through her mouth in an effort to suppress the pain in her stomach.
"What?" Her voice came out shaky under Remus’s judgmental stare.
"The gig must’ve been brilliant if it left you in that state," he remarked, his tone light but laced with irony.
Scarlett huffed, rolling her eyes. She bit into the toast hard, ignoring him as fiercely as he stared at her. Remus said nothing more. He checked his pocket watch, picked up a folder from the mantel, and disappeared into the emerald flames after naming a primary wizarding school.
She chewed as much as she could and sipped some tea to help the dry bread go down. She gave up on a second bite, leaving the toast on the plate, completely oblivious to the heavy footsteps echoing through the house until Reggie came running in — and before she could react, he hugged her tightly, drawing a pained groan from her.
"Mum!" He kissed both her cheeks, not noticing her discomfort, and snatched a toast from the pile so fast Scarlett couldn’t follow his movements. He poured half the jar of jam over it as though it were ketchup and took a huge bite, leaving a purple moustache on his lips. "You won’t believe it — Sirius is going to teach me how to ride a motorbike!" he said, speaking through a mouthful.
Scarlett wanted so badly to share in his excitement that she forced herself to smile, doing her best to sound at least mildly interested.
"What? Aren’t you… a bit too young for that?!" she sipped her tea. "It’s dangerous, Reg."
Reggie finished chewing, and just as he opened his mouth to speak, he was interrupted by Sirius and Harry bursting into the house, laughing and talking loudly.
"… so, James and I were going way over the speed limit when two coppers started tailing us. We thought it was just a fine, but then… Death Eaters showed up out of nowhere and—"
Scarlett wanted to hear the rest of the story, she really did, but she couldn’t. Sirius’s voice pounded like a dozen nails being hammered into her skull as he spoke, and looking at him and Harry was painful with the sunlight behind them. So all she managed was a weak smile as she hugged her godson when he ran over, ignoring the protests of her own body as her teeth clenched from the effort.
"Mum thinks it’s dangerous for me to learn to ride a motorbike," Reggie said, wiping the jam from his face with his thumb.
Sirius shook his head, as if the very idea were ridiculous.
"I learnt at your age," he said offhandedly, though the glance he threw Scarlett’s way carried a hint of defiance.
She narrowed her eyes, resting her chin in her palm.
"Regulus is fifteen, Sirius. You learnt when you were of age — seventeen!"
Sirius let out a groan of annoyance, rolling his eyes in that dramatic way she knew all too well.
"Two years more or less make no difference," he waved her off stubbornly.
"If it makes no difference, can I learn too? I’m thirteen, and… and I’ll be fourteen in three weeks!"
Scarlett’s gaze flicked from Sirius to Harry and back again. She didn’t need to say a word — he already knew what that look meant. His reaction, however, was to huff in exasperation before softening his expression with a grin.
"’Course you can!" he declared cheerfully.
"Sirius!" Scarlett scolded, but he couldn’t care less, already leaving the kitchen, followed by Harry and Regulus, who darted out of the house as fast as a Quidditch broom.
Scarlett folded her arms and took a deep breath, massaging her forehead while wondering how long Penny’s potion would take to work. As if summoned by her thoughts, Penny climbed onto a chair at the table and poured herself some tea, adjusting her tiny top hat.
"Penny also thinks it’s dangerous," she said primly, adding milk to her cup with delicate grace. "But Penny also thinks there’s no point arguing with Master Black."
Nodding, Scarlett conceded defeat, closing her eyes.
"No… there really isn’t."
She wasn’t going to insist. She knew that trying to talk Sirius out of something once he’d made up his mind was as pointless as talking to a wall. She’d done it countless times before with the wild, idiotic ideas he and James used to have — and decided to spare herself the trouble this time.
She decided to leave the table when she heard Sirius wheeling the Ninja to the front of the house. Slipping on the aviator sunglasses from the vestibule, she settled on the front steps, watching Sirius dismount the motorbike as he spoke with the boys. The morning sun bathed his bare torso, highlighting the contrast between his pale skin and the dark tattoos inked across it — especially the Scarius over his heart.
An involuntary smile tugged at Scarlett’s lips.
Sirius kept explaining the basics of track safety to the two of them — gesturing with his hand to demonstrate acceleration, pointing at the brakes, and showing the gear with his foot. Then he stepped aside, watching as Regulus climbed onto the bike with a grin stretching from ear to ear.
"Sirius!" Scarlett called.
He stayed focused on Regulus, as if he hadn’t heard her.
"Sirius!" she repeated, louder this time, but he still didn’t look her way.
Scarlett clicked her tongue and drew a deep breath.
"SIRIUS!" she shouted.
"WHAT IS IT, WOMAN?!" he barked back over his shoulder, pretending to be irritated.
Scarlett narrowed her eyes, glaring daggers at him.
"Did you put on sunscreen?" she snapped, not bothering to hide her sharp tone.
"I don’t need bloody sunscreen!" Sirius shot back arrogantly.
"Penny," Scarlett called, and the elf appeared with a pop. "You’ve got sunscreen, haven’t you?"
"Penny thinks so…" She squinted, tapping her chin thoughtfully with one finger before vanishing — only to reappear seconds later holding the bottle out to Scarlett. "Don’t forget to put some on the boys as well…"
"Yeah, I know." Scarlett stood up, moving with a bit more ease now. The potion was finally taking effect.
She walked over slowly, brushing Sirius’s ponytail forward over his shoulder.
"For Merlin’s sake… I said I don’t need sunscreen," Sirius muttered, that familiar arrogance masking the smile threatening to appear.
"You do, or you’ll end up looking like a ruddy prawn again, just like in the summer of ’78, remember?" she said, spreading the lotion across his back, ignoring his scowl.
He rolled his shoulders in protest, as if trying to shake her off.
"No, I don’t remember!" he retorted gruffly, grumbling under his breath as Scarlett’s fingers moved lightly over his muscles, rubbing the sunscreen into his skin — and failing to hide the faint grin creeping at the corner of his lips.
Sirius was no longer the broad-shouldered, eighteen-year-old man in his prime, not after twelve years in Azkaban. Even so, he seemed to be regaining some of his old strength — his shoulders were well defined again, as were the muscles along his back, which Scarlett’s fingers carefully traced, covering every inch of skin with the lotion.
Harry and Reggie exchanged a glance before stifling their laughter at the sight of their godfather being completely undone like that. Sirius kept up his resistance, but his defences began to crumble the moment Scarlett moved around to apply the lotion to his face. His eyes stayed locked on her as she spread the white cream gently across his skin, then he shut them, feeling her delicate fingers glide over his features.
It was far too easy to disarm him that way. No matter how hard he tried to hide it, that half-smile lingered on his lips as Scarlett’s hands slid down his neck, reaching his collarbone and spreading across his chest. Then, in one swift, unthinking motion, Scarlett lowered her face and pressed her lips to the tattoo guarding his heart — whose beats instantly quickened at the touch.
The kiss was brief, yet enough to steal Sirius’s breath, to ignite that glowing, combustible rush spreading through every inch of his body, shattering once and for all the invisible wall that had shielded him from her. He was never safe around her — not when she held the key to his heart, not when she was his other half: his overflowing anguish, his yearning passion, his tormenting love.
Scarlett Gaunt had shown him that love could also be warm, indulgent, and calm. And because of that, she was his favourite drug. How could he not be obsessed with her? She wasn’t just intoxicating — she was addictive, narcotic, utterly consuming.
Before Sirius even realised it, his arms were around her waist, drawing her against him, his lips trailing kisses along her freckled cheek and slender neck. Scarlett’s laughter broke free — bright, delighted, so genuine that it made his whole body tremble.
He was so lost in her that he only noticed Reg and Harry when they made exaggerated noises of disgust, breaking the moment. Scarlett was still smiling, trying to wriggle out of his arms, but he refused to let her go, holding her even tighter against his bare chest.
"Let me go, Sirius!" she demanded between laughs, though it sounded more playful than stern.
Sirius bit his lower lip, eyes gleaming with mischief. Sliding his hands down to her waist, he suddenly lifted her off the ground and swung her over his shoulder as if she were a sack of potatoes.
"Not now — I’m keeping you here to make sure you don’t interrupt me again!" he teased, holding her with one arm and giving her a playful smack on the bum with the other.
"Sirius!" she squealed, her voice going shrill as she kicked her legs in protest. "Sirius, put me down! I’m serious, I’m going to throw up!"
Sirius grimaced and quickly set her back on her feet, still holding her by the waist. Scarlett clapped a hand over her mouth and retched — then burst into a loud, chaotic laugh when she saw him instinctively turn his head away to protect himself.
As soon as he realised it had been a joke, Sirius laughed along and closed the space between them, brushing his nose against hers. Their eyes locked, trapping one another in that magnetic pull as their smiles faded, replaced by the raw, unspoken ache of two hearts deeply haunted and broken in the same places.
Reggie cleared his throat dramatically, dragging them out of the blinding spell. Both stepped apart, flustered, and Sirius tried to mask his embarrassment by turning back to explain something to Reg and Harry as though nothing had happened — though the faint flush on his face betrayed him. Scarlett adjusted the clothes that were far too big for her and took a few steps back.
"What happened to your knee?" Harry asked, pointing to the purple bruise on her leg.
Scarlett pressed her lips together and shook her head, as if it were nothing.
"Slipped earlier. But… it’s fine…" She shifted her gaze towards Lily, who was watching her son fondly. "Do you want me to put some sunscreen on you…?"
Harry raised his brows in surprise, then nodded shyly. He took off his glasses and held them in his hand, revealing his face without the lenses. Scarlett felt the air leave her lungs and refuse to come back. Merlin, he looked so much like James. But when he looked up at her, her chest tightened — because those weren’t James’s eyes. The way he looked at her was Lily’s.
A flood of longing hit her, though her friends had never truly left her. Scarlett turned her gaze to James and Lily, a wave of nostalgia softening her expression, a melancholic smile forming on her lips.
She wanted so much to tell them how much Harry resembled them both — but she didn’t need to. They already knew.
She felt the soft warmth of his skin under her fingertips and noticed the slight hitch in his breathing, his muscles tensing at her touch. She brushed his messy fringe upward and spread the lotion across his forehead, right over the lightning-shaped scar.
"He got that scar the day we…" Lily stopped, swallowing hard.
The moment Scarlett’s fingers grazed the rough mark, they burned as if set aflame. She jerked her hand back instinctively, and a dark flash tore through her mind — a burst of phosphorescent green light, blinding, followed by the echo of a desperate scream that seemed to come from the depths of time itself. She staggered back, gasping, her fingers searing, her eyes wide.
Harry hurried to put his glasses back on, while Lily pressed a trembling hand to her chest, bending as though in pain. Her glow flickered, faint and unstable, and James caught her before she could fall. Scarlett kept staring at the lightning scar, her heart rising to her throat.
Her gaze slid down, almost unwillingly, to the back of her own left hand — where the intense tingling pulsed beneath her skin. The Ouroboros etched there seemed to shift… slowly turning, as if—
As if—
"Scar… are you all right?" Harry asked, his voice laced with concern that made her shake her head at once.
"Yeah, yeah, I’m fine…" She glanced back down at the Signet, but it was still. "Just… still a bit tired from last night, that’s all." She forced a smile, her gaze drifting toward James and Lily.
"What was that?" Lily’s green eyes searched hers. Scarlett gave a small shrug.
"Do you want me to get some ice for your knee?" Harry asked again, motioning to the purple bruise spreading across her leg. She was too stunned to answer. "I’ll get it, be right back," he said quickly, hurrying into the house.
Scarlett opened her mouth to speak to her ghosts, but Sirius beat her to it.
"Did you feel that?" His voice cut through the purr of the motorbike’s engine, and Scarlett turned to him, dazed. He had a hand pressed against his tattooed chest. "I felt… the pact…"
"Wait, what?" James looked from his best friend to Scarlett. "He felt it too?"
"Scarlett?" Red called from the doorway. "What happened?"
Scarlett’s only response was to stumble toward the entrance, climbing the stairs without bothering to reply. Red raised his hands toward James and Lily, as if trying to make sense of it all.
"I don’t know, she was putting sunscreen on Harry and then…," the ghost tried to explain, pushing his glasses up his nose. "Lily, she…"
"I felt… like I was dying… again…" Lily murmured, curling into James’s arms. "Do you remember when… when Scar…"
"Walked into the Veil?" Red finished for her, his expression darkening. "Yeah."
"It was the same feeling. And Sirius felt it too."
Regulus turned toward the door where Scarlett had just gone in, and Sirius looked that way as well, helping Reggie off the motorbike, his face lined with worry.
Wait, Sirius felt it too?
Regulus’s head snapped sharply toward his brother, now walking back to the house with that same infuriating confidence. His eyes travelled over Sirius from head to toe — always the show-off, especially now, covered in those ridiculous, gaudy tattoos. He knew he shouldn’t compare himself to Sirius — he was better than him, after all — but it was hard not to feel that familiar sting of envy. Even after Azkaban, Sirius was still magnetic, still unbearably handsome, still dazzling like the bloody sun itself.
And if Regulus were alive, he might have basked in the light of that star — the brightest in the Milky Way.
But he was only the moon. And the moon could only shine in the presence of its brother.
Darkness was his fate.
Regulus blinked, shaking off his thoughts as he stepped into the house.
"You disobeyed me, Sirius. You brought Harry into your home and, on top of that, exposed him to… to a convicted murderer."
Dumbledore stood in the middle of the room, his velvet robes gaudy and out of place, as though he were dressed for a masquerade. Yet his presence was so commanding that even Sirius instinctively adopted a defensive stance, placing himself protectively in front of Scarlett.
"Dumbledore… but… what—" Harry stammered. Red moved closer to the boy, his iron-grey eyes fixed on the lightning scar on his forehead.
"I have no choice, Sirius," Dumbledore replied grimly. "Scarlett is far too dangerous to remain near Harry, and this situation cannot continue."
Red exhaled through his teeth, a sharp hiss escaping him. He knew Harry was a Horcrux — but the truth had now been confirmed beyond doubt by that scar. Yes, of course, that’s why Scarlett had reacted the way she did. Horcruxes recognise one another. But why Sirius…?
"I… I can’t go back to Azkaban…" Scarlett stammered, barely breathing.
He needed to tell her somehow — without James and Lily realising.
"So this is because I disobeyed you, is that it? Then punish me instead!" Sirius straightened up, his chin lifting in that proud, defiant angle so typical of the pure-bloods when challenging authority. "Are you truly so heartless as to condemn a woman to be tortured by the Ministry over a whim of yours?!"
"Scarlett…" Red murmured, but she didn’t look at him. Her head was bowed, tears spilling from her eyes, her hands trembling. "Bloody hell…"
"This isn’t a whim, Sirius," Dumbledore replied calmly, though Scarlett looked on the verge of collapse, her breathing quick and ragged.
"Dumbledore, please…" she pleaded — but he cut her off.
"Lily and James would not have wanted Scarlett anywhere near Harry," the Headmaster said firmly.
Regulus studied the old fox with curiosity — and a trace of admiration.
"He knows," he murmured under his breath as the pieces clicked together.
"Lily and James wouldn’t have wanted Scarlett near Harry?" Sirius exploded, his voice cracking like a whip through the room. "And you know exactly what they would’ve wanted, do you, Dumbledore?!" He laughed — bitter, venomous. Dumbledore’s face didn’t so much as flinch. "You’ve spent years disregarding every wish they ever had! And I — I — am the one honouring their memory the only way I can!"
Red drifted forward, circling Dumbledore like a chained serpent coiling around its prey.
"Why can’t Scarlett stay near Harry?" he demanded, his gaze flicking toward the doorway just as Reggie appeared. "No… you don’t know about Regulus’s prophecy, do you? What is it that you know — that I don’t?"
It was impossible for Dumbledore to know about the Black of the Signet. Only he, Evan, Barty, and his father, Orion, ever knew. Not even his mother had been aware of it.
"I don’t want to go back to my aunt and uncle’s house, Professor. I want to stay here — with them." Harry’s timid voice made every head in the room turn toward him.
"Harry… I’m sorry, but the protection placed upon you by the Dursleys only holds within their home, and… that’s… that’s what your mother — what your parents — wanted."
"He’s spent enough time with them for the protection to endure!" Sirius snapped, his temper rising.
Harry touched Sirius’s arm gently, stepping forward to face Dumbledore without hesitation.
"They might be my family by blood, but they treat me like rubbish, Professor. Sirius, Scarlett, Reg, Remus… they don’t share my blood, but they treat me like family. That’s what I want!"
"Harry, please…" Dumbledore said softly, lowering his face until the light caught on his half-moon glasses, his gaze fixed on the scar on Harry’s forehead.
Red tilted his head to one side.
"No — I’m not going back there! I don’t want to live in a place where I have to beg to be treated like I belong!" Harry looked at Sirius, searching for courage — and found it. "My mum’s protection will still work, even if I stay here! It did when I spent the summer with the Weasleys, and it can work every year. What’s the point of my mum’s sacrifice, of her love, if I have to live with people who don’t actually care about me? I want to stay here!" he declared, his tone leaving no room for argument.
Dumbledore wet his lips. Clearly, he hadn’t expected Harry to be so firm — or so brave. For a brief second, Red could’ve sworn he saw a flicker of fear cross the old wizard’s face before it was quickly smoothed into a serene mask.
"Very well then, Harry. You may stay with Sirius," Dumbledore said, as though it were his decision to make. "But for that to happen, we must discuss the protective measures around the house and…" His piercing blue eyes fixed on Scarlett, who instinctively took a step back. "I will not hand you over to the Ministry, Mistress Black."
"Who the hell does Dumbledore think he is?!" James growled beside Sirius. "Scar… you can’t let him—"
Scarlett didn’t hear what James had to say. Nor did Red. He followed her up the stairs toward Sirius’s room, keeping a short distance behind.
Dumbledore knew Harry was a Horcrux. The old bastard was playing his sanctimonious act because…
"Scar… I need to tell you something," Red called from the doorway, but there was no answer.
He found her in the bathroom, sobbing uncontrollably, her breathing ragged and broken, her lips forming trembling, disconnected words. She sat on the floor, shaking her head again and again, eyes lost in a terrified delirium.
"Scarlett, look at me… listen to me… Harry—Harry is a Horcrux! Harry—"
Regulus fell silent under the burning, icy stare Scarlett threw at him.
"Shut up…" she gasped, her hunched posture slowly straightening. "Shut up, shut up, SHUT UP!" she screamed at the top of her lungs, her voice echoing through the bathroom, making Regulus flicker like a faulty light.
With her mind clouded, Scarlett’s blazing blue eyes locked onto the ring Dumbledore had given her when she escaped Hogwarts — the one forged to monitor her. She hissed, yanking at it with trembling fingers, trying to pull it off, but it wouldn’t budge. In desperation, she brought her hand to her mouth, biting at the metal as if she could tear it off with her teeth.
"Scar, please, you have to listen to me—if we’re going to defeat Vold—"
"GET OUT! LEAVE ME ALONE!" she panted, her mouth still clenched around the ring. She gave one last violent tug, a sharp crack snapping through her body as she cried out in pain — she had broken her finger.
"No." The answer didn’t come from Regulus.
Of course it didn’t.
Sirius knelt beside her, gripping her shoulders and forcing her to look at him.
"Scarlett, stop!" He cupped her face with one hand and held her wrist with the other to keep her from hurting herself further.
"I can’t… no, I-I can’t go back to… to Azkaban…" she babbled, her words trembling, almost trance-like.
"You’re not going back to Azkaban. I won’t let that happen. No one’s taking you away, Scar. You’re safe here," Sirius said, his voice so calm it made her wide, panic-dilated pupils finally focus on him.
He’d seen her like this before — though he couldn’t remember when.
"I… I… I’m s-scared…" Her voice was barely a whisper, frayed with anguish. "I can’t…"
Sirius wrapped his arms around her, holding her tightly — as if he could shield her from everything, even from the most powerful wizard alive. Scarlett’s tear-soaked face pressed into his neck, her sobs coming out in broken gasps, her body still tense with fear.
From the doorway, Regulus and Harry appeared, both shaken by the outburst.
"I… I don’t think that…" Harry rubbed the back of his neck, his skin flushed red. "Dumbledore… he wouldn’t do that to you, Scar."
Scarlett lifted her head, a bitter laugh spilling from her lips as she stared at nothing.
"Oh, he would," she said hoarsely. "You don’t know Dumbledore like I do…" She sniffed, burying her face once more in Sirius’s neck. "If he thought it was the right thing to do, he’d hand me over without a second thought."
Reggie patted Harry’s shoulder in quiet support, then looked at Sirius, his expression heavy — as though searching for a way to ease the weight of it all.
"How about… we watch a film? I, uh… I rented The Karate Kid. I can pop over to Uncle Nate’s through the Floo and grab it… have you seen The Karate Kid, Harry?"
"No." He rubbed the hem of his T-shirt, still shaken by Dumbledore’s sudden appearance.
"Right, I’ll… I’ll go get it then. Be back in a tick," Reg said, hurrying out of the room.
"Harry, could you check with Penny if lunch is ready?" Sirius asked, glancing at Scarlett, then at him in a way that made his intentions clear. Harry caught on immediately and left them alone.
Sirius trailed his hand from the small of Scarlett’s back up to her neck, threading his fingers through her platinum-blonde hair, the shadow of despair around her slowly dissolving under the warmth of his intoxicating presence.
"It’s all right. You’re safe," he murmured in her ear. "I’m here, and no one’s going to hurt you. You’re not going back to Azkaban."
Scarlett closed her eyes, sinking into Sirius. She was frightened — that much was obvious. Her thoughts were spinning so fast she could barely focus on anything except him — the heat of his body pressed against hers, his fingers combing through her hair, his breath turning into warm gusts brushing her cheek.
Sirius drew his wand and gently took her wrist, murmuring a spell to set her broken finger. Scarlett bit her lower lip as the bone clicked back into place. The pain was nothing compared to the storm inside her.
Leaning closer, Sirius’s lips met hers in a kiss that was soft, tender, laced with quiet reassurance — a gesture that gave form to that small, perilous word that made hearts race and eyes lock.
"Nothing bad’s going to happen to you, kitten," Sirius whispered, his silver eyes never leaving hers. "Not while I’m by your side. And that’s a promise I intend to keep." His tone was firm, resolute — he had failed her once before.
He intertwined his fingers with hers, touching the tip of his wand to the ring Dumbledore had given her. With a silent spell, the metal melted, slipping off her finger like liquid silver, turning to smoke before it even reached the floor.
Scarlett blinked, dazed. Sirius turned her hand over gently and kissed her palm, his fingers gliding down to the engagement ring — that tiny symbol binding the best moments of their lives to the darkest ones they’d endured.
"Who were you shouting at in the bathroom?" Sirius asked, his eyes still fixed on her.
For long seconds, Scarlett focused solely on breathing, intoxicated by the sense of safety Sirius so willingly infused her with. He made her feel the same kind of dizzy euphoria she felt when she was drunk — except she had never betrayed or hurt the drink the way she had hurt Sirius.
"No one," she breathed, the word barely more than a gasp. "Myself," she corrected softly, drawing back.
Sirius wet his lips and nodded slowly.
"I’m worried about you," he said, wiping away a stray tear that had escaped down her cheek. "I don’t think you’re all right, Scarlett."
"I’m just… just scared," she confessed, wilting in his arms, the blue of her eyes dimming into that withdrawn shade he’d come to recognise.
"And when was the last time you weren’t scared?" Sirius asked — not sharply, not demanding, yet Scarlett’s breath caught as if the question itself put her in danger.
"I don’t… I don’t know." The words came out strained, her voice breaking.
Since Azkaban, fear had been her constant companion. But somewhere deep inside — in the roots of her being — she knew it hadn’t begun there. The last time she hadn’t been afraid was…
"With you," she said before she could stop herself.
"With me? When we escaped from Azkaban?" Sirius frowned, his grey irises pulling her gaze into the darker depths of his pupils so intensely that it took her a moment to process his question.
"In the summer… our last summer together…" she murmured, feeling the tears threaten to return but refusing to let them fall. "On our trip…" She shook her head, as if to banish those days from her troubled mind. "I’ll be fine."
Sirius doubted that, but he kept silent. He was still reeling from what she’d said. He couldn’t remember that summer clearly — only through the photographs Remus had shown him — yet he knew it had been wonderful. And at the same time, it had been one of the worst periods of his life, because it was then… on one particular day within those three months… that Scarlett had left him.
And for her to admit that fear had begun after that trip…
"Mistress and Master Black… lunch is ready," Penny announced, breaking his train of thought.
"We’ll be right there," Sirius replied, once again shelving the long list of questions he still needed to ask Scarlett. He helped her to her feet, and together they made their way to the dining room.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 64: How willing are you to make the hard choices?
Chapter Text
CXXXII
The sky was overcast that Saturday morning. Slytherin’s Quidditch team had seized the occasion to carry on with the try-outs for Keeper and Beater positions. Evan Rosier was sitting on the bench beside Regulus and Barty when a figure they weren’t expecting appeared on the pitch, flying on her Firebolt.
Scarlett crossed the grass, ignoring the fierce match unfolding above her, and stopped right in front of Rosier without even greeting him.
“I’ve changed my mind. I’m not leaving the team anymore,” she announced, her tone dripping with insolence, enough to make Rosier raise an eyebrow.
“Too late, Scarlett. They’re fighting for your spot right now,” Evan said, folding his arms with a smug little grin.
She cast a look of pure disdain at the players before turning back to him, her face masked in an uncommon chill.
“You know perfectly well I’m better than all of them put together. Otherwise, we wouldn’t have beaten Gryffindor last season,” she shot back, her icy blue eyes freezing their reflection in her narrow pupils.
Her reply only deepened Evan’s smile. He was tired of seeing Scarlett as a dull, weepy girl—Merlin, she’d been far more entertaining the previous year—and watching her shed that frightened shell left him… intrigued.
“You are, indeed,” he admitted, exchanging a glance with Barty. “But what do I get out of it?”
Her lips curled in disdain as she shook her head, her black ponytail brushing against her flushed cheeks. Scarlett wasn’t an unattractive girl—quite the contrary, Evan would have married her without a second thought—but that look of hers was exasperating. Perhaps it was the glacial blue of her irises, perhaps the way her pupils seemed to pierce through him… or perhaps it was simply the fact that she was an incredibly powerful witch.
She wielded ancient magic and bore a Signet. If she ever stood by his side in the war… victory would be easy. Far too easy.
“I’m sure your Dark Lord would love my presence on the team,” she argued, as if reading his thoughts.
Evan’s dark eyes glinted at the suggestion. Scarlett’s interest in rejoining the team outweighed his own desire to have her there.
“Not enough,” he said flatly, pressing his lips into a line and shrugging.
“I know Durmstrang’s players’ style,” Scarlett went on, as if the words had been waiting on her tongue.
“Oh, my goal’s to beat Gryffindor,” Evan exhaled, drumming his fingers against his shoulder. “I couldn’t care less about the inter-house match.”
Scarlett clicked her tongue and glanced around, prompting Rosier to keep his expression firm. The smile on his damned lips turned cruel.
“My ex-boyfriend’s playing for Durmstrang, and he owes me a debt. I intend to collect it,” she revealed, her lips tightening.
Evan stared at her for a long moment, pretending to weigh her proposal. He already knew what his answer would be, but he wanted to make her squirm a bit longer—especially after she’d stormed off the previous week, vowing to kill him and ruining his upper hand over Sirius by accusing Regulus of breaking Avery’s arm.
“The spot’s yours…” he agreed at last, running a finger along his nose. Regulus shifted beside him, and Barty lit a cigarette, offering it to him. Evan took it. “If…” He took a drag before finishing, “you have a look at the evidence I’ve got clearing the Death Eaters of that terrible tragedy that befell your family.”
Scarlett blinked several times, as if she’d just been slapped. Her feet slid off the broom’s pedals to the ground, and she fixed him with a dark, uncertain glare.
“Deal.” She gripped her broom with both hands, turned on her heel, and shot off so fast there wasn’t even room for a reply.
“Seriously?” Barty shot him a sidelong look, snatching the cigarette from his fingers. “All that just to have Gaunt back on the team?”
“Having her on the team’s the least of it, B,” Rosier kept his wicked smile. “She’s got what we need.”
“Ancient magic?” Regulus flared his nostrils, as though the very idea was absurd.
“Rot in her soul,” Evan murmured darkly. “The more chances we give her to let it out, the closer she’ll get to us. Her family’s dead. The girl’s starving to pour her anger into someone… what better choice do we have than to sow hatred in her now, so we can reap loyalty later?”
Regulus shot to his feet as if struck by lightning, his fists clenched and shoulders taut.
“I won’t be part of this.” His mouth twisted until it became a harsh, rigid line.
Evan burst into a psychotic laugh, tossing back his black wavy fringe.
“How sweet, Reggie—you think you’ve got a choice!” He elbowed Barty, who laughed along. Regulus tensed his jaw and held his breath, not daring to meet his gaze. “Too late.”
Evan ran a hand over his left forearm, where the Dark Mark stained his pale skin. That seemed to be the fate of every sensible Slytherin: enlist in the Dark Lord’s ranks before it was too late—before they became traitors. Targets. Murder victims.
For Evan Rosier, it was simple. If he was going to die anyway, he might as well die fighting. That simplicity didn’t apply to Regulus, who spun on his heel and strode away, desperate to pretend he still had some sort of control—even if only the dreamlike illusion that his life wasn’t already mapped out, that his fate wasn’t yet sewn shut, and that he still had time to ask for help.
Or at the very least, to save whoever he could.
.
.
.
“How did it go?” Sirius found her in the Hogwarts courtyard beside James.
Heavy rainclouds swept overhead, driven by a fierce wind, though none had yet decided to spill a single drop. Scarlett tucked the stray locks of hair behind her ears and dismounted her broom.
“I’m back on the team, but… I haven’t mentioned anything yet about one of you keeping an eye on me, you know.” She shrugged. “Rosier was already pretty reluctant.”
“Well… that’s something at least.” Sirius smiled, slinging an arm around her shoulders.
“Oh, your uncle wanted to talk to you,” James said, pushing his glasses up his nose as he stood against the wind that whipped at his robes and seemed determined to steal his brown scarf away. “Sounded urgent.”
Scarlett groaned, burying her face in Sirius’s overcoat while his arm curled snugly around her waist.
“Can’t it wait until after Hogsmeade?” she complained, shooting James an irritable frown.
“He asked you to go to his chambers as soon as you… finished… training,” James said, pressing his lips together and lifting his shoulders helplessly.
“Come on, it can’t be that serious…” Sirius rolled his eyes, tugging Scarlett along and grabbing her Firebolt with his free hand.
.
.
.
But it was clear the matter was serious. So serious that Nate and Sirius had a heated argument about Scarlett hearing what her uncle had to say alone, since every other time that had happened she’d gotten rather worked up. So, after telling her boyfriend that she’d be fine and that she would listen to what Nate had to say, Sirius backed off with James’s tugs and wore a sullen expression when the door to the Defence Against the Dark Arts professor’s rooms closed.
Scarlett entered the anteroom with her arms folded; the lamps lit the spacious room her uncle kept there: a large sofa against the left wall, two more around the fireplace, Persian rugs covering the floor, a drinks cabinet, chests, a magic mirror and a longcase clock that gave a soft tick-tock with its pendulum.
“Want to sit?” Nate gestured towards the sofa.
“No… I can’t stay long. I’m going to Hogsmeade in a little while.” Scarlett stared at the floor, not bothering to hide her discomfort.
“Right, uh…” Nate leant on the back of the sofa, stroking his blond beard. “Apparently the inter-house match is a manoeuvre by Durmstrang and… and by You-Know-Who. I… I wanted to ask you to leave the Quidditch team. They’re going to try to recruit and—”
“I’m not leaving the team.” Scarlett practically spat the word with scorn. “Do you really think I’ll miss the chance to crush the tossers who studied with me?!”
“Scar… please…”
“No!” she cut him off sharply. “I’m not leaving the team.”
Thanatos raised his head, tugging at the beard on his chin as if trying to calm himself.
“They’re not here just for that, either…” he continued, fixing his gaze on her again. “The head of Durmstrang insisted that all the matches be held at Hogwarts… which means they want something that’s here.”
“Me?” She rubbed the red fabric of her coat sleeve between her fingers.
“No… if it were you, it would be easier to kidnap you if you played at Durmstrang… it’s something in the castle.”
It wasn’t very hard to put the pieces together after that.
“The artefact.” Scarlett tilted her head to one side, pondering. “Don’t worry, uncle, if I leave it where it is…”
“There are rumours that the head of Durmstrang forged a device that allows him to manipulate ancient magic. And, if that is true…” Nate raised his hands, then lowered them all at once.
“And why didn’t he hand that… contraption… over to You-Know-Who?” Scarlett narrowed her eyes in suspicion.
“Because, Scarly… the artefact at Hogwarts can turn ordinary magic into ancient magic. That would make him equal to the Sallow, perhaps surpass them with his knowledge of the Dark Arts and, with our family isolated on an island in Italy… no one would be able to stop him.” Nate closed his eyes. “Your mother couldn’t do it, let alone you…”
Scarlett felt something burning well up from the trembling hollow that had taken the place of her heart. She swallowed hard, her gaze sweeping the room as if the magical items that made up the décor could help her form an answer.
“I can’t do this.” She shook her head emphatically in denial. “I can’t.”
“Scar… we can’t let your parents’ and Orfy’s deaths go…”
“I… I don’t know.” She faltered, taking a few steps back. “I don’t…”
“Scarlett… you’re a brilliant witch. One of the most skilled of your generation.” Nate stepped closer, placing his hands on her shoulders. “You can do it. You just need to… take the artefact and give it to me. I’ll put it somewhere safe.”
Scarlett desperately wanted to ask how he knew that, yet her uncle Nate had been present for much of her life and, among the cousins, she, Terry, Rossy and Missy were prodigies. That’s what everyone said. That the four of them could bend the world.
What rot! Scarlett hadn’t even managed to bend the flames to save Orfy.
“I… I’ll think about it.” She nodded, lifting her eyes to her uncle with a look of painful resolve.
Nate reached out and took a parchment from the little table beside him, placing it carefully into Scarlett’s hand.
“No one can know, Scarly.” He whispered it, as if it were something terribly secret.
“I’m not going to hide it from Sirius, uncle.” Scarlett snorted in disbelief.
“It’s not a whim, my dear. Sirius can’t know, for his own good.” Thanatos’s naturally caramel-coloured eyes flared with the nearby flames until they looked amber.
Scarlett already regretted her decision, but said nothing. She simply shoved the parchment into her trouser pocket and turned on her heel, leaving Nate’s rooms with heavy steps.
.
.
.
“We could go as the Star Wars characters…” Peter suggested, the carriage jolting.
“It’s not fair, only you and Moony have seen Star Wars…” Sirius drew his brows together, holding Scarlett in his lap so she wouldn’t bang her head on the carriage roof.
“We can watch it this weekend… I mean, we’re of age. We can apparate to your house… I’ve got the tape of the film at mine.” Peter gave his mischievous little chuckle.
“I think that’s a brilliant idea, Wormtail.” James hugged his friend, ruffling his hair on purpose, making him laugh in his high voice. “I’m Luke Skywalker.”
“What? You haven’t even watched it!” Scarlett kicked their friend’s shin.
“Ow! No, but he’s on the cover!” He put his hands behind his head with a crooked smile.
“Then Moony can be Chewbacca because you two are both hairy…” Peter suggested, drawing a sceptical laugh from Remus.
“What, Chewbacca my arse!” He shoved Peter with his shoulder, offended that his friend had even considered such a possibility. “I’ll be Darth Vader. You lot sort the rest out…”
“What? No, of course not, I’m going as Vader!” Peter shot his friend a murderous glare.
“Why don’t you go as Chewbacca?” Remus quipped, which seemed to irritate him deeply.
“Because I don’t turn into a beast every full moon?!” he snapped, as if it were obvious.
“What the fuck, Pete?!” Sirius barked, swatting him hard on the arm.
“What the fuck, me? Padfoot, it’s your bloody fault Snivellus knows about Moony—” Peter went on, exasperated. “And if you lot hadn’t been so busy this summer, we could’ve watched Star Wars together!” He clenched his fists and ground his teeth, yanking the carriage door open before it had even stopped.
Wormtail’s outburst was so sudden that none of them managed to stop him. They were all too stunned to speak. Scarlett looked at Sirius in utter confusion, while James sat there gaping, watching Peter stomp down the cobbled path towards the back of the shops, disappearing between the little houses.
“What the hell was that?” James muttered, his long nose fogging up the window glass.
“No idea…” Remus turned his face away, and Scarlett had the distinct impression he did know why Peter had blown up.
“The little shit’s throwing a tantrum ‘cause he’s not the centre of attention anymore?” Sirius scoffed, shifting on the seat as Scarlett moved into Peter’s empty place.
“Stop talking about him like that, Sirius.” James sounded genuinely upset.
“Oh, come off it, James, stop defending him…” her boyfriend groaned, thudding his back against the padded seat. “All this over a bloody Halloween costume?”
“You know it’s not just that, Pads,” James murmured, lowering his gaze.
“Isn’t it? Because as far as I know, his life’s fucking perfect. Sure, his dad’s a bit absent, but tell me what problem Pete’s had this summer? While he was stuffing his bottomless gut with junk, I was— we were—” He broke off mid-sentence, leaning forward with his elbows on his knees, burying his face in his hands and focusing on his breathing.
Scarlett stroked his black hair gently.
“I’ll… I’ll go talk to him,” James muttered, climbing out of the carriage as soon as it stopped.
“I’d rather you didn’t. Not now,” Remus said, grabbing his friend’s arm as he stepped down too. “Let him… let him cool off a bit.”
Sirius and Scarlett followed next, met by the cold, damp air of Hogsmeade. Most of the Hogwarts students had already crossed the small bridge and were cramming into the shops or the Three Broomsticks.
“So… Zonko’s?” James suggested, glancing up at the sky just as a flash of lightning lit it up, the thunder cracking loudly around them.
“Yeah… let’s see what’s new…” Sirius wrapped his arms around Scarlett from behind, slipping his hands into the pockets of her overcoat as he guided her through the village. “You alright? You’ve gone quiet,” he murmured against her ear.
Scarlett nodded.
“Just… thinking.”
“Thinking thinking or thinking thinking?”
Scarlett laughed — a low, velvety sound that seemed to vibrate straight through Sirius’s soul.
“What’s the difference?” she asked, glancing at him sideways, her blue eyes gleaming between long, curved lashes.
“Well… the first is when you’re thinking about trivial things, like… how your day went or the Potions homework… the second’s when you’re thinking about what we’re going to do when Moony and Wormtail are asleep and we’re both starkers under the blanket…” With each word, Sirius’s voice dripped with that familiar wickedness.
Scarlett kept staring at him, her lips curved in a smile that hovered dangerously close to laughter.
“Sleep, obviously,” she sighed, dramatically.
“Obviously,” he echoed with mock superiority. “Ah, look who’s here! Lily and Pan!” he called out, far too cheerily for it to be natural, which made Scarlett lift an eyebrow.
“Hello, boys,” Pandora greeted with a wave. “Mind if we borrow Scar for a bit?”
“Of course not.” Sirius released her, that dazzling grin still playing across his handsome face, dimples and all. “Meet you at the Three Broomsticks later?”
“Deal!” Lily hooked her arm through Scarlett’s on one side, Pandora on the other, not giving her any chance to refuse.
Not that Scarlett was particularly bothered — in truth, she was trying to see through Sirius’s intention. She knew he was up to something; just the day before, she’d caught him whispering with Lily in the Gryffindor common room — both of them falling silent the second they saw her. She’d also spotted Sirius and Pan gossiping in the library — something she might’ve understood if James hadn’t been beside her complaining he was starving.
Honestly, Sirius rarely even stepped foot in the library, so what on earth could he have to discuss with Pandora?
Oh, the answer to that mystery was painfully obvious.
Sirius was planning something. Probably a prank — it usually was — but, Merlin’s beard, Scarlett hadn’t been sorted into Slytherin for nothing. It was rather obvious, really, that Sirius was going to propose to her.
She already knew it — she just didn’t know how, which only fuelled her suspicion of everything involving her boyfriend. And Scarlett played along beautifully, tossing in casual remarks about the clothes Lily admired in a shop window and the magical creatures that had Pandora utterly fascinated.
Their path soon veered toward a jeweller’s, its display glimmering with treasures. Scarlett squinted against the glare of the gemstones as the two girls steered her inside. Lily quickly fell in love with a set of golden necklaces, and Pan was enchanted by a sapphire ring that suited her perfectly.
“What a gorgeous ring. Such a shame it’s so expensive,” Pan pouted.
Scarlett let out a faint laugh and walked past the display, her eyes caught by a jewel set almost as if on an altar: a black diamond ring surrounded by tiny, shimmering stones that glittered like stars circling the night sky. Behind her, Pandora and Lily exchanged a knowing glance.
Although red was her favourite colour, there was something irresistibly alluring about that ring. Not just because of the rare, stunning diamond — it reminded her of Sirius. It made her lips curve into a smile, her palms grow damp, and her heart skip a few beats.
It made her think of her boy with starry eyes.
Scarlett left the shop in a daze, not noticing Marlene and Mary standing just outside, as though waiting for them. Lily and Pandora greeted the two, while Scarlett pretended to be far too absorbed in the shop window to notice. She liked Mary — they’d shared some fun times the year before — but Marlene…
She was hard to stomach.
“What a lovely pair of earrings. The sort your mother would’ve liked,” Marl tried to start, pointing to a piece in the window — only to be met with disapproving looks from Mary and Lily, as if she’d just said something utterly stupid.
And she had, because her comment came off like an attack — one Scarlett wasn’t about to let slide. Who the hell starts a bloody conversation like that?!
“Yes, I bet she would,” Scarlett muttered, her voice dripping with venom. “I bet she liked you too, McKinnon.”
It wasn’t hard to dislike Marl, really. With that perfect little face, golden curls and magazine-cover body, she was practically worshipped by the younger girls. At first, Scarlett couldn’t understand why Marlene’s looks exasperated her so much. Sure, jealousy over Sirius had a fair bit to do with it — but… it wasn’t just that.
Now she understood why.
“Scar, what do you think of—”
“I’m sorry, I didn’t… I didn’t mean to…” Marl cut Lily off, taking a step towards her. “I just wanted to say that… I know you two had your problems, and… she loved you, Scarlett. She just… didn’t know what to do.”
Marlene McKinnon was the perfect copy of Bonnie — if she were still alive. Her mother’s golden girl.
“Well, it doesn’t make any bloody difference now, does it? She’s dead,” Scarlett hissed, turning away to leave, but Marlene stepped closer, practically pinning her against the glass.
Lily made to intervene, but Pandora stopped her.
“Can we talk? Alone? I promise you’ll never have to look at my face again…”
“I don't want to talk to you.” Scarlett's voice cut through Marlene's. “I don't want to look at you either. I don't know… what sort of relationship you had with my mother, I don't know what she told you and I don't want to know. I want you out of my sight, McKinnon, or I swear I'll smash your pretty face in.” She clenched her jaw on the last word.
Marlene instinctively stepped back, visibly rattled.
“If you ever change your mind… you know where to find me.” She murmured before spinning on her heel and walking away. Mary glanced between them, then joined her friend.
“What was that?” Lily's green eyes met Scarlett's, one eyebrow raised.
“Apparently… she worked with my mother.” Scarlett muttered, picking up the pace and storming into Zonko's, kicking the door open as she entered.
“What do you mean, worked for your mother? She hasn't even graduated yet!” Pandora caught up with her, her pale eyes edged with worry.
Scarlett opened her mouth to reply, but Lily cut in.
“She mentioned something like that after the holidays…” She looked around to make sure they were alone. “That she worked with your mother fighting You-Know-Who.”
Scarlett pretended to be very taken with the coats on a nearby rail to avoid the conversation, so Pandora decided to change the subject:
“Have you lot decided what you're wearing for Halloween?”
There was a long silence.
“I was thinking of some Shakespeare character, but I'm not sure yet…” Lily picked up a pair of leather gloves, though her eyes were on Scarlett.
“Xen and I want to go as a couple, so I'll be Morgana and he'll be Arthur.” She brushed an invisible speck from the yellow coat.
“Morgana and Arthur were a couple? I thought they were half-siblings.” Scarlett made a face.
“They are. One thing doesn't necessarily rule the other out.” Pan said so casually that not even Lily could keep a straight face.
“Ugh, gross.” She covered her mouth. “Didn't they hate each other?!”
“No, she hated Merlin…” Pan waved a hand airily.
“But there's nothing saying she and Arthur were a couple!” Scarlett retorted, returning her attention to the clothes.
“Nor is there anything saying they weren't.” Pandora gave a crooked smile.
“This is… argh.” Lily gave a small, exasperated hop. “And you, Scar?”
Scarlett exhaled slowly.
“The boys want to go as the Star Wars characters…” She checked the label on a T-shirt. “Peter and Remus even argued about it earlier.”
“Oh, I would've gone too, but everyone's going…” Lily rolled her eyes and pretended to admire a traditional witch's dress, all frills and layers that would make her look like some tacky old duchess. “So you're going as Princess Leia?”
“Apparently…” Scarlett shrugged as she picked up a black leather jacket that was so like Sirius. “Do you think he’d like it if I gave it to him as a present?”
“That’s dragon-hide. He’d love it… especially because he likes to parade about like a Muggle.” Pandora ran her fingers over the scaled sleeves. “He’ll look properly stylish riding about on his bike with that…”
“What does he wear that isn’t stylish?” Lily complained, then smiled. “He’ll adore it. Have you lot decided what you’re doing for his birthday?”
“Probably… have sex until I’m sore or until he can’t come anymore,” Scarlett said with unnerving nonchalance. Lily’s eyes went wide and she flushed. Scar exchanged a wicked smile with Pandora. “What did you expect me to say?”
“I think you’re spending too much time with Sirius,” Pan observed, proud.
“Not that!” Lily covered her face in mortification. “I meant… what surprise will you cook up… since every year the boys, Marl and Mary plan something for him…”
The mention of Marlene’s name made Scarlett sigh. She put the jacket on the counter and waited for the shopkeeper to work out the price.
“Well… I don’t know. All I know is McKinnon’s out of that equation.” Scarlett pulled the Galleons from her purse and slammed them down on the wood, making an unpleasant clatter. “But I’ll think of something…”
“I hope it isn’t dangerous. In third year they tried to let a unicorn loose in the common room! McGonagall went mad!” Lily waited while the shopkeeper wrapped and stowed the present so they could step away from the counter.
“Wow… colour me surprised,” Pan scoffed, stepping out arm-in-arm with Scarlett.
They’d barely crossed the road when Regulus stopped in front of them, wearing his ulster coat that made him look as if he’d stepped straight out of a vampire film. His black hair was tousled, contrasting with a face paler than usual.
“We need to talk.” He announced, nodding to Lily and Pandora in a curt greeting. “It’s very serious.”
Scarlett tightened her grip on the bag. Couldn’t she walk in that damned village for two minutes without being hassled?! She pressed her lips together, feeling annoyed and put out.
“You’ve got five minutes.” She hoisted the bag up to her elbow and folded her arms, as if to shield herself from Regulus somehow.
He glanced at Pan and Lily, who didn’t leave his side until Scarlett merely nodded. The two of them moved to a bench on the other side of the street, but kept their eyes fixed on them.
“You have to leave the Quidditch team.” Regulus said it with such arrogance, authority and immediacy that Scarlett half-opened her mouth in surprise. She hadn’t expected him to be so blunt.
“I won’t.” Scarlett half-closed her eyes, looking him up and down with contempt. Then she drew a breath and let a cutting smile spread across her face. “No.”
Regulus let his emotions ripple across his features for the briefest moment — just long enough for Scarlett to see his unease.
“It’s serious. You’re going to tell Rosier you’re leaving the team again and—”
“I’m not bloody well doing anything!” she snapped aggressively. “Who do you think you are…”
“For Merlin’s sake, Scarlett, I’m trying to save you!” Losing control, Regulus’s features hardened with worry.
That might have disarmed Scarlett in the past. But she wasn’t the same person now and she wasn’t going to heed the orders of that insolent boy.
“Save me?” Scarlett let out a bitter laugh. “I don’t remember asking for your help, Red.” The nickname was spat with rancour. “Dimitri… he knows something about what happened to my parents. And I will find out what it is.”
Regulus snorted, running his hands through his hair harder than usual.
“He’s bluffing, Scarlett! He doesn’t know anything!” He lowered his voice, clenching his jaw.
“Does he? And how can you be so sure of that?” She adopted a threatening stance. “What are you hiding, Regulus?”
Red betrayed his calm façade as he ran a hand across his pale face.
“Isn’t it obvious? He only said that to use you. To hurt you!” he replied, oddly frustrated.
“I’ll ask you this once and I want you to be honest.” Scarlett drew a deep breath as she stepped closer to him. “Do you know anything?”
Regulus’s brows knit over his pale forehead and his eyes narrowed, as if wounded that she’d even considered it.
“No!” The answer came out on the tip of his tongue. “If I knew, I would’ve told you!”
Scarlett rubbed her eyes, giving the argument a moment to settle in her mind. Then she let her hands fall heavily to her sides and looked at him with icy composure.
“I’m not leaving the Quidditch team,” she decided, lifting her chin.
A terrible silence fell between them, punctuated by the murmurs of Hogwarts pupils strolling under the watchful eyes of the Aurors keeping Hogsmeade secure. Scarlett picked out Dixon among a group posted near the Three Broomsticks.
“I forgive you. For what happened… for everything that happened… and I also apologise for having…” She broke off, closing her eyes. “I’m not… the same person. But even so, I… I would like your friendship, Regulus. Besides, you’re practically my brother-in-law.”
When her eyelids lifted and her gaze caught Regulus standing before her, her only reaction was to frown. His mask cracked, and the armour he usually wore dissolved until he became what he truly was — a frightened, lost boy.
Then, without giving her a moment to react, Red pulled her into a fierce embrace, burying his face against her neck. Scarlett stiffened, tense at first, but her expression soon softened into a faint smile as she hugged him back, feeling his quick, uneven breaths warm the collar of her coat.
“I’m sorry… for what I did…” His voice came muffled against the red fabric. “I was scared of Sirius and… I’m sorry. I promise I’ll never hurt you again. Never get inside your head again. I’m sorry, Scar… I’m so sorry…” Red’s sentence splintered into fragments, as though he were fighting with everything he had not to cry.
Scarlett didn’t want to believe him — every instinct told her not to — but she silenced that voice and held him anyway, as if gathering up the bright shards of the days before the fire, trying to piece them back into some illusion of normality, some kinder version of reality where none of it had ever happened. Of course, it wouldn’t work. It was only a way to soothe the pain in her chest… but she tried all the same.
“It’s alright,” she murmured, though more to herself than to Regulus. “We both made mistakes.”
He only nodded, still holding her tight as if she were his only lifeline.
And in a way, she was.
They finally drew apart, and Scarlett leaned back against the shop window, catching Pan and Lily’s eyes across the street before turning to Red with a question that had itched at her since before the summer holidays.
“What did you and Pinch have last year?”
Regulus slipped a hand into his pocket and pulled out a small metal case bearing the Black family crest, holding a cigarette between his lips. He offered her one, then tucked it away when she shook her head.
“We just… fooled around.” He tossed his hair back in that same infuriatingly familiar way Sirius did.
“Define fooled around.” She lifted her chin as Red exhaled a plume of smoke to the side.
“She was two years older… I needed… instruction.”
“Instruction?!” Scarlett’s nostrils flared, and she flinched as the drizzle began to fall.
Regulus turned and leaned against the wall beside her, the cigarette glowing faintly between his lips.
“Yeah, Scarlett, we blokes aren’t born with a manual for…” He licked his lips and let out another smoky breath. “Well, you know what.” He looked away toward the street, the flicker of embarrassment in his steely eyes making her laugh.
“Sex?” Her brows rose, a trace of disbelief furrowing her forehead. “You lost your virginity to Pinch for instruction?!”
“It wasn’t my first time.” He sighed, holding the cigarette between his index and middle finger. “My cousin—”
“It wasn’t your first time.” She cut him off before he could finish. “What Bellatrix did… doesn’t count as your first time.” Her voice faded little by little.
Red looked at her from the corner of his eye. Even with his face devoid of expression, she could tell by the way he swallowed hard and drew again from his cigarette that he was uncomfortable, his gaze drifting between Hogsmeade’s main street and Scarlett.
“I suppose not.” He exhaled through his nose. “I’m sorry for what happened to your family.”
Scarlett sniffed as the cold wind swept past them, tossing her hair and blowing Regulus’s smoke into her face. She wrinkled her nose and covered it with the collar of her coat.
“Rosier’s a Death Eater.” She ignored his words, her lips tightening as if holding something back.
“I know,” he murmured, his tone heavy.
“Are you a Death Eater?”
Regulus blinked a few times, holding her gaze. He shook his head slowly, deliberately.
“Are you going to become one?” Scarlett pressed, her icy blue eyes sharpening as they bored into him.
“I… I don’t know,” he stammered, his voice faltering for just a few seconds. “I don’t know if I have the luxury of choosing.”
“Of course you do.” She showed no sympathy for his situation. The Scarlett of the past would have been shaken and tried to help him somehow, but this Scarlett had had her heart reforged on the anvil of grief and pain. “We always have a choice. The point is… how willing are you to make the hard ones, Regulus?”
Red let out a confused, hollow laugh. Scarlett wasn’t fooled by the act. She knew perfectly well he understood.
“If you become one of them…”
She didn’t finish the sentence. The words hung taut in the air, but Scarlett didn’t need to complete them. Red knew exactly what she would have said. They were well past that point.
“You dropped this during your detention…” She pulled a paper from the inner pocket of her red coat and handed it to Red, whose eyes widened the instant he read what he himself had written. “On the first or second day of class, I asked you who you were… and after reading this, I’m certain you still don’t know.” She wetted her lips, pushing away from the shop window. “Who you are and who you want to be aren’t mutually exclusive, nor are they far apart. It’s not that hard to become someone else, Regulus. It’s quite easy, actually…” She took a step forward, then stopped. “The hard part is staying who you are and hoping things will be different.”
Regulus stood frozen until the cigarette’s ember nearly burned his fingers and he dropped it reflexively, muttering a curse under his breath.
“See you on Monday.” Scarlett waved without looking back, quickening her pace to cross the street.
“Scar…” he called, and she looked over her shoulder. “Thank you.”
“For what?” She tucked her dark fringe behind her ear as the wind threatened to toss it about.
“You know what for.” R.A.B. smiled with his eyes.
Scarlett returned a faint, crooked smile and walked away.
Regulus Arcturus Black remained where he was, shaking his head in small, futile motions that did nothing to clear his thoughts. No. His mind was already tainted, and nothing could wash away the stains carved into his soul.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 65: And he found it. He always did.
Chapter Text
CXXXIII
It was already night when Sirius settled himself in the middle of the sofa, turning on the television while watching Reggie slot the Karate Kid VHS into the player. He knew that tape — in the past, he and James used to record Coronation Street when it aired on telly. It had been a habit they’d picked up after his friend lost his grandparents, then his parents, and later had to go into hiding in Godric’s Hollow because of the prophecy.
Harry’s prophecy. Dumbledore had shared it with only three people: him, James, and Lily. Of course, he’d never had much time to think about it — lately, his mind was an overburdened maze of thoughts to process. But the moment his godson appeared at the doorway, Sirius had wanted to call him closer.
Harry had defeated Voldemort on that tragic Halloween night. Yet Sirius knew that hadn’t been the end of the Dark wizard. Not just he, but the Ministry and Dumbledore knew it too. There would come a moment when...
Scarlett sat down beside him. Her scent reached him with such force that it wiped his mind clean. Her straight, bleached hair fell to one side, granting him a perfect view of her unguarded neck — he leaned in and pressed a kiss there, light as a butterfly landing on a petal. The look she gave him, full of shy fondness and bashful devotion, made his chest cave in.
He wrapped an arm around her shoulders, drawing her against his chest, letting her rest there with her face nestled over his heart. Sirius buried his nose in her hair, closing his eyes, lost in the sweet, vanillic haze that stirred up so many good memories from the precipice of his mind.
By Merlin, it was the very same fragrance he used to breathe in during the golden days of a far-off past — when Scarlett knew no fear and he didn’t have to live a double life to keep her safe. His hand drifted up, threading through the pale strands.
Regulus grabbed his bucket of popcorn from the table and flopped onto the sofa, spilling a few kernels over the upholstery. Sirius scooped up a handful, tossing them into the air and catching them with his mouth.
“Harry! Popcorn!” he called to his godson, who approached with a distant expression. He’d been like that since Dumbledore’s visit, and not even Penny’s lunch with his favourite dishes or the motorbike lessons — when Sirius took him for a spin and then Reg rode pillion — seemed to cheer him up. The boy arched his brows just as the popcorn landed in his messy hair. “You’ve got to open your mouth for it to work.”
“I don’t…”
“Your dad and I used to do this all the time.” Sirius didn’t give him the chance to dodge. “Go on, Harry…”
The mention of James made the boy scratch the scar on his forehead, force a smile, and ready himself for the next round. Sirius tossed another piece of popcorn; it traced a perfect arc through the air, but Harry was too slow to open his mouth, and it bounced off his chin before falling to the floor.
He pressed his lips together, shoulders twitching with awkward embarrassment.
“One more…”
“Sirius, stop.” Scarlett warned, gripping his wrist with a strength he didn’t quite understand.
“Just one more…” he insisted.
“Stop!” she repeated, her blue eyes blazing.
Sirius gave up, flashing an awkward smile. He exchanged a glance with Reggie, who merely shrugged and stuffed a fistful of popcorn into his mouth before sprawling lazily across Sirius’s lap.
“Come on, Harry, sit here…” Scarlett patted the empty space beside her on the sofa.
“Actually… I’m pretty tired, think I’ll turn in.” The boy scratched the back of his neck and stared at the floor as he headed for the hallway.
“No, Harry, you’ve got to see Mr Miyagi teaching Daniel karate!” Reg jumped up on the sofa, sending more popcorn flying. “Please!” He clasped his buttery, salty fingers together in a plea. “It’s brilliant, I swear!”
Harry’s gaze wandered around the room as he pressed his lips tight. Then those green eyes — Lily’s eyes — landed on the seat beside Scarlett. He walked back reluctantly and sat down, looking so uneasy it was as though he were doing something wrong.
Scarlett picked up the other popcorn bucket and offered it to him. Harry accepted, placing it between his thighs. He shifted, about to cross his legs, then seemed to change his mind and stayed in that slightly awkward position.
“You can put your feet up on the sofa, Harry,” Scar murmured once the film began. “It’s older than you are.”
Harry’s lips twitched in the faintest smile. He ate popcorn while the film flickered in the reflection of his glasses. Scarlett rested her head back on Sirius’s chest, while he kept tossing popcorn into the air — until he finally stopped, once a dozen unclaimed pieces had piled up atop Scar’s head.
He rested his hand over Regulus’s chest, rising and falling slowly with each breath. His gaze drifted to his nephew — to that intent expression as he watched the film: eyes fixed, lips drawn tight, nostrils slightly flared.
Reggie’s pale skin was brushed with the colours spilling from the television, dancing across his freckles, his angular jaw, the nose he’d inherited from Scarlett… and the black, slightly wavy hair that came from his brother. The way his brows tilted in that self-assured angle, the faint creases that formed at the corners of his eyelids when he squinted… the silvery tint that lived within the blue of his irises.
A rush of regret struck Sirius all at once.
What if… what if he’d done more for his brother…
His gaze inevitably slid to Scarlett — her long, thick lashes veiling eyes absorbed in the story unfolding on screen. He brushed her hair again, watching those ocean-coloured eyes rise slowly to meet his, as tempting as ever.
There was so much they needed to talk about. Fifteen years’ worth of unfinished words, and every time he thought of it, his stomach burned. He swallowed hard and made the herculean effort to break eye contact with his favourite shade of blue, pretending instead to focus on the telly.
The film was halfway through when Harry began leaning towards Scarlett, fidgeting on the sofa each time he tried. She caught on quickly — quicker still to pat her thigh twice in a silent invitation. Harry dismissed the gesture with a shake of his head, but Scar suddenly tugged him down, making him lie across her lap. Every muscle in his body went rigid, yet he stayed there, feeling her fingers thread gently through his perpetually untidy hair.
James’s hair.
Scarlett sighed. It was as if, for a moment, it were her friend lying there instead. The thought made her understand Sirius’s tenderness with Harry — and yet… it hurt. It hurt to see so much of James and Lily reflected in the boy, and it hurt not to have him there with them in the flesh.
She looked at James, his mop of hair resting on Lily’s lap as she sat on the floor. A sad smile touched Scarlett’s lips. It was almost like their last year at Hogwarts, when he used to rest his head on her lap like that… only now, James was still there, though only as a ghost.
Even so… it wasn’t the same.
It never would be.
Scarlett swallowed the tears burning at the corners of her eyes, glanced at Regulus, and buried her face against Sirius’s neck, searching for what she always did in the man she loved: her torn-off pieces, her restrained desires, and some way to stitch together her shattered soul. She knew it was only a palliative act, that it was impossible to bury what could not be buried… yet she carried on with her eternal task as a gravedigger, with the same relentless will as Sisyphus pushing his stone to the top of the mountain.
The credits had been rolling for a while when Sirius slowly shifted on the sofa, Scarlett asleep in his arms, her platinum hair veiling her face. Glancing to the side, he saw Harry fast asleep against Scarlett’s thigh, while Reggie, nestled in his lap, dozed peacefully.
He wished he could stop time — capture that moment and live in it forever. He regretted not having a camera to preserve it, especially to remember the gentle warmth blooming in his chest, so disorienting he barely recognised the reactions of his own body.
His heartbeat stayed calm, his breathing soft, and his gaze… the silver in his eyes had turned faint and luminous, like the night rain falling over the rooftops and windows of the house, its rhythmic patter resembling a lullaby.
He remained still for what felt like an eternity. He wanted to cry — not for the usual reasons, but because his chest overflowed with such piercing safety, belonging, and peace that they spilled from his eyes. This was his dream. His dream made real; so real he could touch it, see it, breathe it in.
James wasn’t there — but Harry was. Regulus wasn’t either — but Reggie was. And though he knew they could never replace their parents, Sirius wanted them to. He longed for their presence in this moment, when his spirit was fed by the echo of a time before the war, before discord, when he and Scarlett had been together.
It was wishful thinking — Sirius knew it was. That life would never return. James and Regulus were dead. So he contented himself with his godsons — fragments of those who were gone — clinging to their memory like a drowning man clutching an anchor, mistaking it for a buoy.
Prongs wasn’t Harry. Regulus wasn’t Reg.
As much as he wished… they weren’t the ones he’d lost. They never would be.
And yet, despite the absence of his best friend and the strange ache for his brother, Sirius felt whole. It was fleeting, ephemeral — but so powerful that all he could do was weep.
Sirius sniffed quietly, and that was enough to stir Scarlett. Her long lashes fluttered, as though she were trying to find her bearings, her eyes sweeping the room in sleepy recognition. She shifted slightly, careful not to wake Harry. Sirius took those few seconds to bury his tears in her hair and pressed a kiss to the pale strands.
Scarlett lifted her gaze to him, and Sirius pretended to busy himself waking Reggie. He didn’t want to be dissected by her eyes — not now — so he focused instead on his nephew, who stretched languidly on the sofa, yawning with half his face creased from sleep.
“Bloody hell, I’m parched…” Reggie muttered, rising slowly from the cushions. “I’ll get some water. You lot want any?”
“Grab me a glass… please…” Scarlett whispered, raising a finger.
He nodded and shuffled awkwardly toward the kitchen.
“Harry…” Sirius murmured, but the boy was so deeply asleep he only mumbled something and turned his head to the side — a bit too forcefully. His glasses made a faint cracking sound, though he didn’t stir.
Scarlett winced and removed them, one arm snapped clean in half. Sirius sighed and stood, his neck popping as he straightened. She reached for her wand to repair the glasses, but Sirius was quicker — he stooped down and scooped Harry up into his arms.
“Open his door for me,” he said to Scarlett, nodding toward the corridor. It didn’t take her long to step ahead, holding the door open and helping him so the boy’s head and legs wouldn’t bump the frame.
Sirius grunted as he bent to set Harry gently down on his bed. Scarlett removed his shoes and tucked him in, leaving the now-mended glasses on the dresser. She looked at the tall man on the other side of the bed, one hand on his back and a grimace twisting his face.
“I’m too old for this,” Sirius muttered with a laugh. She smiled as well. “At least I didn’t have to carry him up a flight of stairs…” He rolled his eyes, making Scarlett frown.
“What are you talking about?” Her voice came out hoarse.
Sirius only shook his head and kissed Harry’s forehead. Scarlett glanced from the door back to the boy, unsure what else to do, until she leaned down, kissed him too, and hurried out of the room, utterly flustered.
“I want to be carried too!” Regulus complained, handing his mother the glass of water and folding his arms expectantly.
“For Merlin’s sake… you two are going to wreck my back,” Sirius groaned, though he soon gave in and crouched to offer Reg his back.
“Reggie, better not,” Scarlett said, leaning against the sofa with an expression thick with mockery. “He’s far too old for that.”
“I am not!” Sirius shot back, his tone dripping with playful indignation. Scarlett raised both brows, narrowing her eyes at him.
“You literally said that to me about… ten seconds ago!” she retorted, keeping her voice low and pressing a hand to her chest in theatrical offence.
“Carrying someone in your arms and carrying them on your back are two entirely different things,” Sirius huffed, rolling his eyes with exaggerated self-importance.
Scarlett’s heart jolted, a chill blooming low in her stomach. She couldn’t tell whether it was because of the boyish gleam shimmering in the mercury of Sirius’s eyes, or because that same gleam flickered in Reg’s. Or perhaps it was the easy, unguarded joy they both wore on their faces.
She watched, mute and stunned, as Reggie walked past her and climbed onto Sirius’s back. Sirius let out a small laugh when his son bumped his knee against the side table and nearly sent a vase crashing to the floor. Reg clapped a hand over his mouth while Scarlett darted forward to steady it just in time.
Sirius made his way back down the corridor with some effort, Reg clinging to his neck and burying his face in his father’s long, dark hair. He waited for Scarlett to open the door, then crouched so the boy could slide off his back onto the bed, laughing.
“Now we’re only missing my mum…” Regulus said offhandedly.
“What?” Scarlett stammered, caught off guard.
“I’ve already done that once this week, Reg — I still haven’t recovered,” Sirius replied, biting his lower lip and rolling his shoulders.
“When did you carry me?” she asked, narrowing her eyes at him, brow furrowed.
“Good night, Reg,” Sirius said, ignoring the question. He pressed a kiss to the boy’s forehead, lingering just long enough for it to mean far more than it should.
Scarlett swallowed slowly, her heart collapsing under the weight of the moment — sublime and cruel all at once. Sirius was Regulus’s father.
For a fleeting second, she had the impression he knew. But if he did… she would’ve been able to say it aloud. And every time she thought about it, the magic of the pact she’d made tugged at her throat — a tightening reminder that the bargain still held.
Sirius wasn’t stupid. He could be reckless, blind, infuriatingly arrogant — but he wasn’t stupid. He would find out eventually. He had to. Yet at the same time… she doubted it. Everything that bound him and his brother was rooted in a hatred so old, so decayed and tangled, that she couldn’t reach that part of his soul. She couldn’t access that side of Sirius. She was a part of him — she knew she was — and still, she longed to tell him everything… she wanted to…
“Good night, Dad.” Regulus’s stubborn smile widened as Sirius gave his nose a playful squeeze before straightening up. “Mum?”
Scarlett blinked hard, snapped out of her spiral of guilt, and stepped toward her son almost without realising it.
“Good night, love.” She kissed his forehead, threading her fingers through his dark, slightly wavy hair. “Sleep well.”
“You know you’ll have to do that every night now, right?” Regulus demanded, kicking off his shoes.
“Well, Reg… I… I’m not sure if I…”
“You could live here,” he interrupted, curling up under the sheets in exactly the same way Sirius used to sleep.
Scarlett had no answer for that suggestion.
“I wish it were that simple…” she whispered, her cheeks flushed with guilt. “Good night, Reg.” That was all she managed before leaving the room.
Sirius tossed his hair back, looking at his godson with a flicker of impatience.
“That wasn’t very nice,” he scolded, raising a finger.
“I was only telling the truth! It’d be so much simpler for everyone since you’re together, wouldn’t it?!”
Sirius gave a dry laugh — not a pleasant one.
“There’s a lot between your mum and me, son.” He wetted his lips and pressed them together. “And none of it’s simple.”
“Yeah, because you two make everything complicated,” Reg shot back, rolling his eyes.
“One day, when you’re grown up… you’ll understand,” Sirius muttered, waving him off before leaving the boy’s room.
He found Scarlett sitting on the bed, holding a photograph of Reggie. It had been taken on his third birthday — just days before Sirius’s arrest. The boy wore a colourful party hat and a Sex Pistols T-shirt, grinning ear to ear, showing his tiny teeth beside the cake before him. The red-and-yellow icing and the Gryffindor lion on top made her smile unconsciously.
“Sex Pistols? Seriously?” Scarlett lifted the photo so he could see it in the bathroom mirror’s reflection. “Your Gryffindor brainwashing clearly didn’t work…”
He pretended to be utterly absorbed in brushing his teeth, avoiding an answer.
“Oh, I thought you were too busy wallowing in guilt to talk to me,” Sirius muttered, wearing that expression Scarlett despised — half serious, half sardonic.
“I can’t live here,” she said, taking a deep breath. “You know that.”
“Why not?”
Scarlett simply shook her head.
“When did you carry me?” she countered, her fingers caressing Reg’s chubby cheeks in the picture a little too firmly.
Sirius finished rinsing his beard and leaned against the bathroom doorway. He dried his face, considering how to reply.
“When you tried to…” He cleared his throat and corrected himself. “When you nearly crashed into that lamppost.”
The revelation left Scarlett speechless. Sirius continued into the silence.
“I carried you to your flat. You thought I was Regulus — my brother Regulus,” he clarified, to leave no room for misunderstanding. “You… you said you were scared. That you felt safe with me. That you wanted to sleep in peace — that you drank to forget me. To forget what you’d done.”
He tossed the towel onto the sink counter and sat down on the other side of the bed, his eyes never leaving her.
“That not all the McKinnons were meant to be there… that Regulus’s plan had gone wrong.”
Scarlett’s eyes, once narrowed, now widened. Her lashes cast a trembling shadow of disbelief across her irises, which flared into a burning ember at his confession. She swallowed hard, her previously relaxed posture collapsing as her shoulders drew in, cornered.
“I…” She dropped her gaze to the floor, turning Reggie’s photo face down. “I don’t… remember saying…”
“Of course you don’t. You were pissed out of your mind,” Sirius hissed sharply. “What did you mean by Regulus’s plan going wrong?”
Scarlett turned her head toward him slowly, as though his voice came from somewhere very far away.
“Can we… not do this now?” Her eyes drifted down the length of his body until they reached his beautifully angular face. “Please?”
The pleading tone disarmed him. Sirius deflated as the breath left his lungs, lying down beside her and slipping an arm beneath his pillow. His long black hair spread over the white sheets like ink bleeding through paper.
“We’re going to have to talk about it sooner or later, Scar,” he murmured, his voice low, as if afraid anyone else might hear.
“I know.” Scarlett set Reggie’s photo on the bedside table, settling onto the mattress with clear reluctance. “I just… don’t want to do it now.” The anguish that shimmered in her blue eyes cut through him like a blade.
Sirius shuddered and nodded. She seemed on the verge of saying something more, but changed her mind, her jaw tightening instead.
Another pause. Scarlett couldn’t hold his gaze.
“Why were you crying during the film?” The question slipped from his lips with the same rhythm as the surprise that flickered over her face.
Scarlett would rather have him believe she’d been torturing herself — that way, he wouldn’t interrogate her further.
“I…” She rubbed the Ouroboros on her skin hard enough to redden it. “I was thinking about James,” she admitted, her voice cracking.
“I miss him,” Sirius said, the words leaving his chest as if he’d opened a small box full of diamonds and let them catch the sunlight for only a few seconds before locking them away again.
“I do too… I miss him too, Sirius.” Scarlett looked down at the Ouroboros, as though she could tear a piece of herself away. “But Harry isn’t James.”
“I know…”
“It’s hard because they look so much alike, and it hurts to look at him, but… he’s not Jamie. No one is.” She twirled a strand of black hair around her finger, laying it beside her Signet — both dark as midnight.
“No one is.” The agreement escaped him before thought could catch it. A flash of regret crossed his eyes. “Every bloody day I think… why did I do it? Why did I come up with that idea? Why… did I suggest Peter?! We knew there was a spy in the Order and… bloody hell, how could I have been so stupid?! If I hadn’t suggested it… if… if…” He buried his face in the pillow to hide the tears. “Harry would still have his parents. I wouldn’t have spent twelve years…”
Sirius let out a long, heavy sigh.
If, if, if. Too many ifs in that equation — and the sum was exhausting.
For a moment, Scarlett did nothing but look at him with those eyes that seemed to turn him inside out.
“Sirius… you can’t keep torturing yourself like this,” she whispered, her irises flickering.
His gaze cooled instantly.
“Why not? You do it too.”
Scarlett shook her head, heart pounding in her chest.
“It’s different.”
“It’s not different.”
“Your intention was never… never to kill them.” Scarlett drew in a sharp breath.
“And yours was, wasn’t it? Intention — that’s what defines the Unforgivables. To torture, to control, to kill.” There was a hidden roughness in his tone, sharpening every word like a thorn.
Scarlett closed her eyes and shook her head, staring up at the starry ceiling.
“Why do you always turn things back on me when we’re talking about you?”
“I could ask you the exact same thing, Scarlett,” Sirius shot back, sounding like an utter fool.
“Good night, Sirius.” She did what she did best — she fled the argument.
Sirius exhaled loudly, thrashing deliberately against the sheets.
“What you told me… when I visited you in the dressing room after the gig… was it true?” he pressed, fully aware she was still awake. “When you and Regulus…”
The blood drained from Scarlett’s face. She swallowed down the tide of disgust threatening to rise, refusing to engage. Long minutes passed before she rubbed her eyes hard with her knuckles. She didn’t want to say another word — not that night. But she knew she had no choice. Sirius could be relentless, and she always gave in.
It was the natural order of things.
“About me saying your name while I was with him?” Her voice trembled, hesitant. “Yes. It’s true.”
When she finally turned to look at him, she found those star-like eyes fixed on hers — though they no longer shone as before. They were dull. Fearful. Tarnished. His pale face was touched by a faint flush, and his lips parted as if to speak… but no sound came out.
“That’s one of the few things I still remember. I don’t recall much of what happened when I was at Grimmauld Place. Every time I try… it’s like I’m trapped in a fog… I can’t see a thing… and I’m certain that if I ever do, it’ll terrify me — and haunt me for the rest of my days.”
Sirius nodded slowly, his lips twisting into a faint grimace.
“I know how you feel. That place…” He exhaled through his mouth. “It’s like a nightmare that never ends.”
She gave a sad smile and averted her gaze.
“Do you think… Dumbledore will hand me over?”
“No.” The denial came almost at once. “He wouldn’t do that.” He tried to sound confident, though even he wasn’t sure. He reached for Scarlett’s hand, his thumb tracing the Signet against her pale skin. She faltered slightly. “Besides… you can’t be sent back to prison. We’ve two teenagers to raise.”
Scarlett scoffed, turning her face toward him, though her eyes drifted to some random point in the room.
“You’re their godfather, not me.”
“You’re the mother of one and you’d damn well be the godmother of the other!” Sirius snapped, propping his elbow on the mattress.
“I don’t think someone who’s killed five people is fit to raise two teenagers,” she muttered.
“It’s exactly the opposite. You’ve already killed five people — raising two teenagers can’t be that hard.” Sirius huffed, exasperated.
“So we’re always going to come back to this, aren’t we? My crimes.” She clenched her jaw so tightly Sirius could almost hear her teeth grind.
“You’re the one who brought it up,” he pointed out, his tone rising from frustrated to heated. “You’ve got to stop running and start taking responsibility, Scarlett.”
She hissed at his words, sitting up sharply. The fear vanished from her eyes, replaced by fury. She drew a deep breath, ready to unleash the torrent she’d buried in her chest… but the words died before they reached her lips. Scarlett deflated, covering her face with her hands.
“I can’t go back to Azkaban,” she whimpered, tears pricking her eyes.
And then, without asking, without thinking, without even breathing, Scarlett Gaunt sought shelter in the arms of the man she loved — her body collapsing against his tattooed chest as her sobs became uncontrollable.
“You won’t,” Sirius said again, this time with conviction, wrapping his arms around her waist and letting her warm body melt against his. “I promised you that, didn’t I?”
Scarlett had believed Sirius’s love would quiet the storm inside her — but in truth, it was the cause of it. That fierce, feverish, ungovernable thing; uncontrollable as fire, incandescent as lava, and tender as the best summer nights.
Sirius’s hands slipped beneath her shirt, resting against her spine, his thumbs tracing the scars that marked her skin. It was a tender gesture — yet it sent a tremor through her entire body. Scarlett lifted her gaze to him without moving her head, blue irises glimmering through the cascade of platinum hair that framed her face.
He looked at her with genuine concern — but then something else filled his eyes. Something that stung and stirred that familiar chill in her stomach. She placed her hands on his chest, fingers deliberately circling his nipple through the fabric while her legs slid to either side of his waist, feeling his cock harden even more beneath her.
She wanted so badly to believe that promise. But between them lay a trail of broken vows that clouded faith and blurred certainty. She blinked the tears from her eyes, focusing on Sirius’s beautiful face — his parted lips, his eyes fluttering shut as she pinched his hardened nipple between thumb and forefinger through the fabric, drawing a low, suggestive breath from him.
“You promised… but can you keep it?” she whispered, her other hand tugging his trousers down. Sirius braced his heels against the mattress and lifted his hips just enough for her to free him from the confinement of his clothes.
His lips curved as he wet them, hunger flickering across his features.
“I am keeping it, aren’t I?” he retorted, releasing Scarlett to pull his shirt over his head.
Her only answer was a sniffled breath. With her face still wet from tears, Scarlett lowered herself to his chest, spreading her hot saliva across the skin. His ribcage trembled beneath her tongue as she traced the tattoos along his sides, then the runes down his abdomen, continuing until she reached the dark trail of hair just below his navel.
Sirius’s whole body shivered. He tried to brush the hair from her face, but Scarlett moved first. Swift as a feline, her hands caught his wrists and pressed them against the headboard. She straddled him fully, their faces now so close the space between them merged their breaths and locked their eyes.
“Dunno. Are you?” Scarlett murmured with a wicked smile, tilting her head to kiss him — only to turn away a fraction before their lips met, diving into the curve of his neck, caressing it not only with her lips but with her trembling sighs.
Sirius drew in a deep breath, his head tilting slowly beneath the tension winding through his shoulders. He made no move to take control, letting Scarlett mark him with the same consuming desire that he longed to mark her with.
She released his wrists, and one of her hands wrapped around his throat while the other gripped his painfully hard cock. Scarlett retraced her path, scattering kisses along his neck, chin, and cheek until she claimed his lips with a ferocity fierce enough to burn away any argument they might have had. There was no violence in it—only the raw urgency of a lover aching with longing.
Scarlett’s tongue met no resistance as it slipped into Sirius’s mouth, dominating him with deft precision. She took advantage of being on top to grind her hips against his cock, feeling it throb with desire even through the layers of fabric that still separated it from her cunt. Her thumb brushed the tip, right where she knew he was most sensitive. A strangled groan escaped his throat, swallowed by Scarlett’s mouth in the middle of their kiss.
Sirius’s hands roamed her body as though trying to discover something new. They explored her back, kneaded her waist, seized her shorts and tugged them down. Scarlett helped him, kicking the fabric away until she was free. His rough fingers slid down the curve of her arse, gripping it tight and pulling her closer against him.
Scarlett broke the kiss, her lips grazing his in a soft, tender caress. Their gazes met and held, liquid silver stealing every bit of starlight as it shimmered and smoked against the reflection of her sky-blue eyes, deep as the universe itself. She wanted to tell Sirius everything—confess the truth and answer all the questions he’d asked that night—but at the same time, she felt she didn’t need to.
No matter what she said or did, Sirius would still love her, and she would still love him. It was her greatest gift—and her greatest curse as well.
A knowing smile curved her lips as she trailed down Sirius’s body, kissing every inch of bare skin with torturous slowness. She followed the lines of his tattoos, the rough pores, the shy dip of his navel.
Basking in the silver glow of his gaze, Scarlett sank lower. He could do nothing but gasp when her pink lips breathed warm air over his tip and took him into her mouth with wild, instinctive ease.
Sirius buried a hand in Scarlett’s hair, sweeping it from her freckled face. His eyes never left her—not even when she sucked his cock, sliding her head lower and lower, taking him in completely until he hit the back of her throat. A shameless moan of pleasure tore from Sirius’s lips.
His skin burned, his cock throbbed, his heart pounded. All because of the succubus between his legs, sucking him exactly the way she knew he liked it—applying that perfect, deliberate pressure as her tongue and the roof of her mouth teased his length, moving with a cruel rhythm: fast enough to make him tremble and grunt, slow enough to keep him from tipping over the edge.
Scarlett knew exactly what she was doing to him—she always had. She held far too much power over him, and Sirius, even knowing he’d get burned in the end, had no wish to let her go. He didn’t want to strip himself of that addicted kind of love, that caged desire, or that damned woman. Nothing else in the world made him feel the way she did—seen, accepted, loved. The bond he shared with Scarlett went far beyond the pleasure of flesh and the inevitability of a pact. It was the very matter that had forged their souls—the liquid steel in his eyes and the solid ice in hers; the cycle of excess, love, and dependence that swallowed them whole.
Sirius began to move his hips toward Scarlett’s face, dragging her against his pelvis, fucking her tight throat and revelling in the tears glistening at the corners of her eyes, the flush spreading across her breathless face, the pupils shimmering with subjugation—and glinting with submission.
But she didn’t let him take control for long. Scarlett pushed Sirius’s hips back down onto the mattress as she lifted her head, lips parted and shining so she could catch her breath, softly licking the damp tip. Her hand wrapped around his base and began to move, stroking him up and down, using the slick of her own saliva to make each motion glide. He tightened his grip on her hair, making her scalp sting.
“What’s wrong? Cat got your tongue?” she purred, a wicked smile curling her lips.
“Fuck, Scarlett…” Sirius panted, eyes locked on hers. “You drive me insane.”
“But I haven’t even had my fun yet…” she murmured, with that maddening air of condescension. Straightening up, she straddled his lap again, still holding his cock to guide it to her entrance. Sirius’s hands clamped hard on her waist, yanking her toward him impatiently, but Scarlett clicked her tongue in warning. “You don’t make the rules, love.”
Sirius let out a sharp huff of disdain, pulling her back again. Scarlett released his cock and caught his wrists, her nails digging into his perfect skin as she shoved them above his head, into the dark tangle of his black hair blending with the night-shadows of the headboard. He still glared up at her, defiant, so she lifted her hips, feeling the hot, swollen tip of him kiss her entrance.
Scarlett rolled her hips slowly, making him roll his eyes back and arch his spine in a desperate attempt to push into her—but she only tilted her pelvis forward, slipping just out of reach. Sirius exhaled a ragged, hungry moan.
“You like torturing me like this, don’t you, slut?” he hissed, the words leaving his mouth just before her hand cracked across his cheek, the sharp slap echoing through the room.
“Call me a slut again, and the next one’s going straight to your balls,” she warned, gripping his chin and forcing him to look up at her. “Got it?”
Despite the shock, his silver eyes gleamed with that wicked amusement only the two of them could ever understand. Scarlett brushed her nose against his rough beard and bit the cheek she’d just slapped, rubbing her hot cunt along the slick, chilled length of Sirius’s cock. He bit down on his lower lip, stifling a growl.
Sirius deliberately squeezed both cheeks of her arse, making her scrunch her nose from the soreness of the bruises still scattered across one of them.
“Yes, Ma’am,” he replied, insolence dripping from his tone.
She rolled her hips again, pressing her wetness against his cock. He thought Scarlett would tease him a bit longer—but when she suddenly sank down onto him, Sirius threw his head back so hard she could see the veins in his neck pulsing.
Scarlett released his hands once more, pinning them back to their place above his unruly hair. Her palms slid along his wrists to his hands, fingers intertwining until he gripped her back as she squeezed him inside her.
She always needed a moment to adjust to Sirius. She was still sore from the previous nights, and his size certainly didn’t make it easier. Yet it was exquisite—how he could fill her so completely, with pleasure and with pride. Yes, pride, because that lewd smirk curved his lips and that hunger burned in his eyes.
She claimed his mouth with unrestrained hunger, her warm body pressed tight against his, burning in the blaze of his starlit eyes. Scarlett began to ride him slowly, the whole world igniting in the fire fuelled by his wild, untamed heart beating against her chest. The kiss turned rough, desperate—binding them in that carnal, emotional tether they could never escape.
“You were made for me…” Sirius whispered shakily between kisses, drunk on the feeling of being completely inside her—enveloped, squeezed, drenched by the walls that only he knew so intimately. He pulled back just enough to look at her. “You’re mine.”
“You’re mine,” Scarlett moaned, breath hitching, cheeks flushed. “I love you, Sirius.”
“I love you too, Scar,” he murmured, licking and nipping at her lips. “I love fucking you.”
“Do you?” Her voice dripped with sin. Scarlett picked up the pace, slamming down hard and rolling her hips in that maddening way that drove him wild.
Her name echoed in Sirius’s chest in a low, desperate snarl as she set a punishing rhythm—almost stopping entirely—forcing him to grip her hips and meet her movement with shallow thrusts. He lifted his torso just enough for his tongue to reach Scarlett’s nipple, circling it slowly while she buried her face in his hair.
One of his hands slid up to knead her breast. Though she’d borne a child, Scarlett’s breasts were still firm—bigger now, but just as perfect. His lips closed around, sucking at her nipple, teasing it with the edge of his teeth until she shuddered atop him.
Sirius trailed his mouth up to her sharp collarbone, tasting the sweat that beaded on her pale skin like tiny stars mirrored on the surface of a frozen lake. The saltiness dulled his senses, made his head spin.
Scarlett moved her hips in deep, relentless rolls, riding him so hard Sirius felt his sanity being ripped away. It was as if she needed every piece of him, while he craved every piece of her in return—every crack, every flaw, every sin.
He wrapped an arm around her back, pulling her even closer, his eyes never leaving her face, drinking in the sublime expression she wore—those swollen lips, that hazy gaze. It felt as though if he dared to look away, she would vanish. As though he was on the verge of losing her again.
Their moans filled the air, breathy and ragged, Scarlett’s breasts sliding over the tattooed, taut muscle of Sirius’s chest. She ground her hips against him, rubbing her clit along his rough pelvis, lost in the height of ecstasy. His cock throbbed inside her, striking every tender point with each thrust.
“I love fucking you too,” she whispered in his ear, tracing the tip of her tongue along his earlobe just as her legs began to tremble with the nearness of release.
Scarlett brushed the black hair from Sirius’s face and looked at him; her hot breath met his sweat-slick skin as he tried to thrust harder. The world shivered and sparked around them, and Sirius knew it—it was her.
It had always been her—Scarlett was his beginning, his middle, his end. His life and his death. His joy and his sorrow. Nothing mattered beyond her—beyond that hungry cunt that drew him in so greedily, beyond the woman he loved with such burning passion and hated with such exquisite agony.
“I’m going to cum,” Sirius growled, intending to stop and ask if she was close, but his words only made her move faster, riding him with the skill and fury of a seasoned Amazon, drawing from him the purest form of bliss only an old, rusted, cracked love could give. “I’m gonna—fuck—Scarlett, I’m—”
Sirius pulled Scarlett tight against his waist with one hand, the other clasping her palm as if afraid she’d slip away. His eyes clenched shut in desperate pulses as he buried himself deep and came inside her, trembling between rapture and ruin.
Scarlett laughed—a light, frivolous sound. Sweet. Genuine. It was one of the few times since Azkaban that Sirius had heard that sound leave her lips. Moved by that innocent display, he pushed himself up and kissed her. Scarlett didn’t stop moving, keeping a demanding rhythm. She swallowed his ragged moans, his muffled pleas, his fevered words of love.
With every thrust, Sirius’s body trembled. Scarlett knew he was overstimulated, yet still she felt him hard and hot inside her, their mingled release making everything slicker, more intoxicating. She hadn’t come yet, so she used her weight to pin Sirius’s hand to the mattress, dragging the other up to join it—making him a captive of his own euphoria.
“Scarlett… bloody hell…” Sirius hissed, twisting beneath her. “We’re not… teenagers anymore…”
“Stop whining… and finger me,” she ordered, releasing only one of his hands while keeping the other entwined with hers.
Sirius let out a broken breath through his mouth. He obeyed, sliding his hand between Scarlett’s thighs, circling her swollen clit with the slick of his own come dripping down her pelvis. Her feverish cunt clenched cruelly around his tender cock at the stimulation.
Scarlett pressed her forehead to his, losing herself in those star-silver eyes like someone lost in the labyrinth of their own unshackled desires. Sparks climbed her spine every time Sirius’s cock dragged along her walls and nearly kissed the mouth of her womb. Heat spread through her in bubbling waves, turning to steam, burning her from within like molten lava erupting.
She had spent entire weeks condemning herself—calling herself a murderer, a traitor, a coward. Yet in that moment, Scarlett understood that if anything good still survived inside her, any fragment untouched by her sins, that piece belonged to Sirius. It had always belonged to him.
Reggie was proof of that.
“Come with me, Sirius…” Scarlett begged, her voice strangled. “Come with me…”
Sirius didn’t know if it was instinct or something far deeper that made him obey, but he couldn’t stop the overwhelming wave that tore through him, stripping away every restraint as he surrendered to her once more, spilling inside her in aching release. Scarlett’s nerves tightened and loosened in erratic pulses as she arched her back and clenched around his sensitive cock, their bodies shaking in the violent quake of shared climax.
She moaned so loudly that Sirius feared the boys might hear—but he couldn’t bring himself to silence her. He was far too entranced, drinking in every detail of the sight before him with ravenous pupils, intoxicated by the utter devotion with which Scarlett gave herself to him.
Sirius caught her before she collapsed onto him. Their hearts beat in sync, the flames dancing between them flaring in perfect resonance. He kissed her temple, then her cheek, her jawline, the tip of her nose, until his lips found hers. Scarlett was weak, her skin gleaming with sweat, her pale hair clinging to her neck and face.
As their breathing slowly steadied, Sirius slipped out of her, met by a small sound of protest from Scar. The separation seemed to wound her in a way that wasn’t quite physical nor emotional—as if she’d just lost another piece of her soul.
He pulled her into a tight embrace, their flushed, trembling bodies pressed together. The thick mixture of their release dripped freely down between her thighs.
Scarlett rested her head on his chest, her fingers tracing lazy patterns along his tattoos, just as she used to when they were teenagers. Sirius placed his palm at the base of her spine, stroking her in the same familiar way.
She closed her eyes, wishing that time hadn’t been washed away by the tides of war—back when she’d fuck something up and the only thing that could quiet the storm in her head was Sirius’s arms around her under a warm blanket. When the only sound, apart from their tired breathing, was the crackle of the fire between them losing breath, light, and fuel.
There was nothing left to burn. Everything had turned to ash.
Sirius reached for his wand on the nightstand, murmuring a spell Scarlett didn’t recognise—but she felt the soft tingle low in her belly.
“Contraceptive,” he said quietly, as though reading her mind.
Her reply was a drowsy hum.
“Scar…” Sirius called softly when she was nearly at the edge of sleep. She didn’t open her eyes, only adjusted her head against his chest and grumbled faintly.
“Hm?”
“Do you… do you think Harry…” His chest rose and fell heavily. “That Voldemort…”
Scarlett traced her fingers over his tattoos again, pausing over the one right above his heart.
“No matter what Harry has to face,” she murmured, her voice slow and heavy with sleep, “we’re a family… we’ll face it together.”
Sirius’s answer was to pull her even closer, as if he could fuse himself into her — seeking his safety in the woman he loved.
And he found it.
He always did.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 66: One day I’ll wake up and you’ll be gone
Chapter Text
CXXXIV
The Gryffindor common room wasn’t quite as noisy that night. Probably because James and Lily had sent all students up to the fourth year back to their dormitories, leaving only a few stragglers scattered around the place. The Marauders and their hangers-on had taken their usual spot — by the window and the fireplace.
Sirius had challenged Lily to a game of Wizard’s Chess, so the two of them occupied the only nearby table, low and round, which forced them to sit on cushions on the floor. On the sofa beside them, Scarlett was painting her nails black, James was tending to his Nimbus by trimming splinters and polishing the handle, and Remus had a parchment on his lap, making notes while savouring a cup of tea. Peter, sprawled on the floor and leaning against the sofa, was completely absorbed in a comic book called The Amazing Spider-Man.
Scarlett hadn’t the faintest idea what it was about, but it seemed terribly serious judging by Peter’s devastated expression. She glanced at the game before her, where Sirius and Lily stared each other down in sepulchral silence before ordering their pieces to move.
"Blimey… your feet are massive," Lily remarked absently as Sirius stretched his legs to change position on the floor.
He looked up at her with a smug grin. Before he could reply, Scarlett was quicker.
"Big feet, big cock," she said, without lifting her eyes from her nails.
Remus choked, the tea spurting back through his nose. James grimaced in pure disgust, lifted his head and shook it in disbelief. He wiped the splatter of tea that had landed on his arm with the same cloth he’d been using to polish his Nimbus.
"And what do you know about cock sizes?" James shot back, his tone dripping with sarcasm. "You’ve only ever seen one your whole life."
Scarlett narrowed her eyes, turned her attention away from her nails and looked at him with a touch of disdain.
"More than you have… I hope."
James frowned, about to respond, but Remus interrupted.
"Mine’s bigger," he muttered casually while drying his face.
The chessboard rattled when Sirius stammered his command, the knight lurching toward Lily’s bishop.
"That’s not true!" He opened his mouth and worked his jaw, as if trying to loosen it. "Just because mine curves upwards? In actual size… if it were completely straight… it’s bigger than yours!"
"But it isn’t straight!" Remus rolled his eyes, pretending to be exasperated.
"Wait, you’ve seen each other’s cocks?!" Scarlett elbowed him. "Was it during the threesome?"
"Oh, for Merlin’s sake… intimacy is bloody awful," Lily muttered, massaging her temple.
"Mm-hm. And if you and your boyfriend ever fancy—"
Remus didn’t get to finish. One of the pieces flew straight into his teacup, splashing the hot liquid across his face.
"What the fuck, Moony? Trying to poke my eye out?" Sirius snapped, irony and irritation colouring his voice as he shot his friend a warning look.
"Moony the cock-blocker…" Peter sing-songed without even glancing up from his comic.
"I’m joking!" Remus raised his hands in surrender, taking the opportunity to grab a biscuit from the nearby table.
Scarlett turned to Sirius and folded her arms, clearly indignant.
"What?" He arched a brow before she could say anything.
"That’s so bloody homosexual… seeing your mate starkers," she sighed, blowing on her nails.
Remus let out a muffled laugh and James burst out laughing, stowing away his tools in the Broom Maintenance Kit. Sirius remained impassive, merely shifting his posture as he crossed his legs atop the cushion.
"We shared a dorm for seven years, love," he dismissed her comment with a flick of his hand. "Besides, Lily and Pandora have already seen you naked… on the day of the funeral…"
He stopped himself there, realising too late he’d stepped into dangerous territory. His wary gaze found Scarlett’s, carefully studying her reaction.
She merely shrugged.
"I didn’t have a threesome with them."
Her response made Remus laugh even harder and drew a disgusted groan from James.
"I’d bloody love it if you did," Sirius muttered, the provocation right on the tip of his tongue. He ducked his head just in time to dodge a cushion hurled by his girlfriend. "What? You’re the one who suggested it!"
"I don’t like women!" she snapped, her voice shooting up two octaves.
"How d’you know? You’ve never tried!" James grinned, a challenge gleaming in his eyes.
Scarlett licked her lips, glaring at him with slit pupils. Sirius, Remus, and Lily all exchanged looks — even Peter set his comic aside to enjoy the show.
"I never had to eat shit to know it tastes foul," she retorted, cold as a blade.
Remus and Peter burst out laughing, and even Sirius, who had tried to maintain his composure, pressed a hand over his face and leaned his elbow on the chess table, laughing helplessly.
"Facts don’t lie," James said, lifting his broom upright to check if he’d trimmed all the splinters near the pedals.
"What d’you mean, facts don’t lie?" Lily turned to him, her brow furrowed and her lips parted as if he’d just committed the gravest of crimes. "So you agree that women are shit? Because that’s basically what Scarlett just said."
James, who’d been so relaxed a second ago fiddling with his broom, went instantly stiff. His neck flushed a violent shade of red, and the colour climbed fast to his ears and cheeks.
"No, I— that’s not— that’s not what I meant, Lily!" he stammered, running his hands frantically through his already messy hair. "I— I— what I meant was… well—"
James’s panic was too much for the rest of them. Sirius, Remus, Peter, and Scarlett burst out laughing until they could hardly breathe. Sirius threw himself backwards, collapsing onto the floor in hysterics, while Remus abandoned his tea entirely. Peter hugged his comic book to his chest, and Scarlett fanned her hands to dry her nail polish.
"And the award for biggest misogynist in the school—" Sirius wheezed between laughs, "goes to you, Prongs! Congratulations!"
Suddenly, even Lily joined in the laughter, her accusing expression shattering to pieces. If James had been embarrassed before, now he looked utterly mortified. Lily laughed so hard she held her stomach, tears forming at the corners of her eyes.
"Oh Merlin, James… you should’ve seen your face… red as a bloody tomato!" she gasped between fits of laughter.
James let out a long, defeated sigh.
"You’re the worst of the lot, Pads," he declared, flipping his friend the middle finger.
"Oi, I didn’t do anything," Sirius clicked his tongue and wagged his finger. "You hung yourself, mate."
"I’ll hang you later, that’s what," James huffed, spinning his broom as he checked the pedals again.
"Oi! That’s my job!" Scarlett bumped his shoulder playfully, the amusement on her face twisting into something more mischievous.
Sirius clearly shared the feeling — he sat up again, his silver eyes fixed on her, drinking her in with sheer adoration.
"I’m always available for a good hanging, love," he said with a wink.
Lily turned back to the game, moving her rook to take Sirius’s pawn.
"I do hope you two are being careful," she said in her usual authoritative tone, tossing her fiery hair over her shoulder.
Scarlett shrugged, leaning back against the sofa.
"Hogwarts has plenty of staircases if things go wrong."
The careless way she said that sent another wave of laughter rippling through her friends. James was the only one who didn’t join in; he pushed his glasses up the bridge of his nose with his pinky and looked at her oddly.
"I take it back," he said, deliberately ruffling her hair. "Scar’s definitely worse than Padfoot."
The atmosphere soon returned to normal — Lily was shaking her head in disapproval, muttering something about boys never growing up, while Sirius plotted his next move with an arrogant grin. Across the circular common room, a group of girls were whispering and casting disapproving looks in their direction.
Scarlett chose to ignore them, especially when she looked down at her own Slytherin uniform, which stood out rather starkly against her Gryffindor friends — and boyfriend.
It wasn’t long before Professor McGonagall appeared, gliding towards them with her velvet robes trailing across the carpets of the common room. She cleared her throat to get everyone’s attention, halting Sirius mid-move in his chess game. Her stern gaze and flawless posture were enough to make the surrounding students take the hint and scatter up the spiral stairs.
The Marauders, Scarlett and Lily, however, remained.
"Miss Gaunt," she said, her voice as irritable as ever. "I’ve received numerous complaints from students questioning your constant presence here in the Gryffindor common room. After all, you belong to Slytherin and—"
"But, Professor," James cut in, gripping his broom with both hands, "Dumbledore said she could stay here, as long as she left before curfew."
McGonagall adjusted her square spectacles with a precise, almost condescending motion.
"Mr Potter, we all know that Miss Gaunt rarely returns to the Slytherin common room…"
The professor’s attention shifted fully to Scarlett. She glanced at her boyfriend before lowering her head.
Sirius shot up from the floor, fists clenched, shoulders squared — the very picture of pure-blood defiance, chin lifted, eyes sharp as blades.
"I’m not leaving her alone in that nest of Death Eaters!" he barked furiously. "They killed her family!"
Remus rose from the sofa as well, placing a steadying hand in front of Sirius to keep him from doing something reckless.
"Sirius…" His brown eyes flashed gold for a moment before he turned to McGonagall. "Professor, we completely understand the situation. As Prefect, I apologise. This will be sorted out. Scarlett will return to the Slytherin common room as soon as possible."
Sirius whipped his head towards him so sharply that his neck cracked.
"What?" He drew in a deep breath — a sign everyone knew spelled trouble, because he looked on the verge of losing control.
"Trust me," Remus muttered without opening his mouth, his teeth clenched tight.
McGonagall pressed her lips together, gave them a thorough once-over, and then, apparently satisfied, turned on her heel and left.
Scarlett rose from the sofa and strode towards the portrait hole, the others trailing after her.
"Scar, wait!" James left his broom propped in a corner, while Sirius shot Remus a scalding look that lingered long before he followed his girlfriend.
"Love… don’t listen to what McGonagall said…" Sirius caught up with her just after James.
"Maybe… maybe I could turn into Whiskers and sleep somewhere around Hogwarts…" Scarlett murmured hesitantly. "Or in the Undercroft, but… I don’t… I don’t know if… I can…"
She gasped. She hadn’t visited the Undercroft since that day. It was nearly October now, and she was still too much of a coward to go back to the place that held so many memories of when she still had a family. It was easier to stay somewhere new — the Gryffindor dormitory — and not…
"You’re not hiding like a rat — no offence, Wormtail," Sirius gestured at Peter, who merely shrugged it off. "But you’re not sleeping in some random hole, Scar. That’s bloody ridiculous!"
"She’s not sleeping in any of those places!" Remus nearly shouted, his voice echoing through the empty corridor of the Gryffindor Tower. A few portraits woke up here and there, hurling century-old insults at him. The group fell silent, even Lily, who had just climbed out through the portrait hole. "I want to show you something," he said, tilting his head.
Scarlett, Sirius, James, Lily, and Peter followed Remus down the Grand Staircase and into the upper annex that led to the Defence Against the Dark Arts Tower.
"Where are we going?" Lily whispered, shrinking slightly as they stopped before the clock beneath the staircase.
Remus raised his wand, and a faint click echoed. He pulled open the face of the clock — which was actually a hidden door — and stepped through first.
"I wanted to surprise you all, but it seems now’s the right time." He pushed up the iron gate to the Undercroft, and it clanged loudly as it lifted.
When Scarlett reached the bottom of the stairs, she was greeted by a sight completely different from what she’d left behind before the summer holidays. Instead of the space that had once looked like a replica of her bedroom, there were now musical instruments where her bed had been. A guitar rested on its stand beside a bass; a drum set was assembled further back; and synthesizers were stacked on a pedestal. Microphones and cables crossed the floor in a strangely neat arrangement, giving the place the air of a professional studio.
The flames from the candelabras above them crackled softly, casting warm light across the hall. Remus had built partitions to divide the space — there was now a corridor leading to what must be her bedroom and bathroom. Yet the sofa remained where it always had, as did the side table and shelves — though the latter now displayed far more photographs than before, not only of her family, but also of her friends.
Stunned and speechless, Scarlett was the first to step forward. Her fingers brushed gently over the higher keyboard, her eyes glistening as she caressed the metallic Yamaha engraving. It was a CS-80. Her mind instantly drifted back to last Christmas, and she turned to James, utterly dazed.
"Belated birthday present…" He didn’t get to finish before she threw herself at him, wrapping him in a fierce hug.
"I can’t believe you lot—" Lily was looking around in astonishment.
"And the Minimoog on top, me and Pete chipped in for that," Remus added, joining the embrace.
Scarlett tried to speak, but it was as if she’d lost the ability entirely. She turned to Sirius, searching for some explanation of what was happening.
"Don’t look at me, I hadn’t a clue either!" His voice betrayed his irritation, though he chose to channel it at the drum kit, tapping a cymbal with his finger — it let out a sharp metallic ring. "How— how the hell did you get electricity down here?! There isn’t any in the castle!"
Remus ruffled Scarlett’s hair before stepping back, a proud smile spreading across his scar-marked face.
"Remember you told me last year there was a fuse box in the Theory of Magic classroom? I spoke to Dumbledore and the music teacher so we could draw power down here. Took a bit of work, but it did the trick."
Still in James’s arms, Scarlett looked between them, completely overwhelmed.
"So… all those times you disappeared…" she began, trying to process it. "You were…?"
"Setting this up for you. Me, Prongs, and Wormtail," Remus said, slinging an arm over James’s shoulders.
"Why didn’t any of you tell me?" Sirius’s face twisted, genuinely hurt. "Even you, Wormtail!"
Peter just ducked behind Remus and James.
"You were already doing enough, Padfoot," Remus said, pulling him in with his other arm. "We didn’t want to overburden you."
"You wouldn’t have overburdened me!" Sirius protested, eyebrows drawn together, lips pouting. "I’d have helped!"
"You still can help, love…" Scarlett slipped from James’s embrace and sank into Sirius’s chest. "We’re still missing the posters… and the polaroids you took, and… Merlin, there’s still loads to do before it looks decent…"
Her voice softened into that coaxing tone that always made Sirius melt — though the little sulky pout remained firmly in place on his handsome face.
"Yeah… there is still a lot missing…" he grumbled, sulky. "Even so… it’s… it’s bloody brilliant." He finally gave in, elbowing Remus in the ribs. "You lot did great."
Scarlett kissed Sirius, silencing any further argument he might have had. Then, like a child who had just discovered a mountain of presents under the Christmas tree, she ran back to her synthesisers and pressed the power button — but nothing happened.
"There’s no power…"
Remus walked over to the fuse box against the wall and pulled a lever with a loud click. The room was suddenly illuminated by rows of incandescent bulbs hanging from the ceiling, bathing everything in warm tones of amber and gold. The CS-80 and the Minimoog came to life, their lights blinking in perfect synchrony.
"Bloody hell… I can’t believe this…" Scarlett whispered, covering her mouth to keep from sobbing.
"I signed us up for ensemble practice and music theory lessons," Remus went on. "Don’t you want to see the bedroom?"
"What’s going on?" Lily whispered to Pete. He kept himself busy explaining the whole story of the Undercroft — how Scarlett’s family had once taken possession of it, and now how they had.
"Wait— you never actually slept in the Slytherin common room?!"
Scarlett smiled through her tears, wrapped in Sirius’s arms from behind. She looked at Lily and nodded.
"Only the first night… when someone put a snake in my bed…" She wiped her face with the sleeve of her cloak.
"So the rumours were true…" Lily murmured, alarmed. "That’s why you disappeared from the dorms." She pointed an accusing finger at Sirius.
"Oops, I’ve been found out," he said with a half-smile, pressing a kiss to the top of Scarlett’s head.
"Come on, let’s see the bedroom," Scar said, tugging him along down the corridor.
It was enormous — her great velvet-green bed untouched, but now with a new sofa at its foot, a wooden wardrobe, a heater, and a bookshelf filled with the very books she was certain had been stored away in a box at her and Sirius’s house, among the few things salvaged from the fire.
"What do you think about… putting The Doors poster right here?" Scarlett pointed to a spot on the wall.
Sirius, lost in thought, blinked a few times before returning to the moment.
"Er… yeah… sounds good," he murmured distractedly.
"You all right?" Scarlett brushed an invisible thread from the collar of his shirt, her eyes never leaving his.
"I just… dunno. Wish I’d been part of it," he said, tossing his hair back in that way that made younger girls swoon. "Didn’t feel great finding out after the fact… never mind."
"But you are part of it, love," Scarlett tried to reassure him — she understood exactly what he was feeling. "You’re going to decorate the bedroom, all right?"
Sirius hunched his shoulders slightly, took her hands in his, and kissed each one tenderly.
"All right."
The agreement came so easily, so gently, that for a few seconds Scarlett doubted the man standing before her was the ever-volatile Sirius Black.
Perhaps it was because the Undercroft stirred so many memories of their time together in that place — or perhaps it was because Sirius really had become someone else. Not in a bad way. He was more… restrained. Balanced. Vulnerable, yes, but more sure of himself. More… steady overall — especially in his relationships.
The Sirius from before would never have tolerated the teasing they’d done earlier. Nor would he have reacted that way to being left out by his three friends. Maybe the once-egocentric Sirius Black had finally realised the world didn’t revolve around him.
He was hurt — Scarlett could see it in his eyes, in the faint dark threads dulling the silver of his irises. But he wasn’t trying to take it out on anyone, nor demanding explanations from Remus.
All he did was… oh, Merlin — Sirius Black was looking at her like a lost puppy.
Scarlett pulled him into a fierce embrace, and he buried his face in the curve of her neck, holding her so tightly she was nearly smothered against his Gryffindor tie.
"It’s all right not to feel comfortable… I’m here for you, okay? We… we can talk to them and—"
"It’s not that. Not exactly," he mumbled, his warm breath sending shivers up her nape. "I just… I wanted to make you that happy too, like you were… when you saw the surprise. And I feel like… I can’t anymore…"
His voice cracked halfway through the sentence. He sniffed, though he didn’t seem to be crying — at least, not outwardly.
"Sirius… you make me happy every single day…"
"No… I don’t."
"Of course you do!"
"Stop lying."
Scarlett gently pushed him back, just enough to meet those star-bright eyes head-on.
"Sirius…" She spoke his name as if it were a plea. A prayer. "If it weren’t for you… I wouldn’t even be here."
He shook his head, wary, yet unable to escape her gaze. Scarlett reached up, took a lock of his dark hair that had fallen over his face, and slowly tucked it behind his ear.
"Even before my parents died… when we first met… every time I saw you, it felt like… watching the sunrise after a long, brutal winter." Her fingers glided over the soft skin of his face, flawless and warm. "And yes, you had your flaws, but… the way you were always so radiant, joyful, irreverent… I wanted to be like you. And the more I got to know you… the more you infuriated me and… fascinated me. You… you showed me the side of yourself you always tried to hide — your stupid, reckless, self-destructive side. And I still chose you. It might have been a foolish choice back then…" She smiled. Sirius did too. "But I don’t regret it. Because you saw my worst as well — you saw my chaos — and loved me anyway. You saved me…"
She squeezed her eyes shut to chase away the tears. "You stayed with me all this time… made me eat, made me bathe… made me see that even though I wanted to be buried with my family… I’m still here. Because you saved me."
Her lashes lifted, and her eyes — always so blue, always burning — stayed magnetically locked on his. "Because you love me. And you make me happy every single day with your presence, your care… your love. I know that every time I lie down, you’ll hold me close with your warmth and your safety. You held me back from the edge, you saved me from the Death Eaters — and from myself. How could I not be happy with you by my side? You’re the sun, Sirius. The world burns when you kiss me. It boils when you hold me. It disappears when you look at me that way. Because you are mine… and I am yours."
Sirius’s thumb brushed away her tears, his palms cupping her cold cheeks with gentle heat.
"Happiness isn’t just built from grand gestures, Sirius," she whispered. "One of the moments I feel happiest… is when we’re lying in bed, holding each other, and I can hear your heartbeat, your calm breathing… and see you sleeping peacefully. You make me happy just by being with me, my love. I don’t need surprises or gifts. I need you. Only you. And happiness is just the consequence of that — the consequence of us."
The kiss that followed was inevitable — as inevitable as the sparks that seemed to shimmer in the air around them. There was sweetness, tenderness, surrender. There was also fragility, desire, serenity. Scarlett dragged her lips against Sirius’s, tasting him, feeling the heat of his tongue, the roughness of his stubble. Her heart grew lighter, her chest loosened, her body unfolded — safe in the arms of the man she loved.
Someone cleared their throat several times at the doorway. Sirius’s hands, which had been gripping her arse, slid up to her waist. It took Scarlett a few seconds to wrestle her brain back under control and glance to the side — where James stood leaning against the doorframe with that awkward, sheepish grin of his.
"Apparently… Dumbledore’s reactivated the Floo fireplace down here in the Undercroft. That’s how Remus managed to bring over some of your things from home, so…" He scratched the back of his neck. "If you two… you know… want to go there…"
"Wait — we can go home from here?!" Sirius tugged Scarlett along with him out of the bedroom towards the fireplace.
It was in the most secluded corner of the gallery, the one even Scarlett rarely dared to visit. There stood a Pensieve and a triptych of Highland landscapes. The fireplace itself was cold and unlit, while the Floo powder stored in a clear glass jar shimmered, iridescent under the electric light.
"Yeah," James said, plunging his hand into the emerald powder and letting it run through his pinkish palm.
"I’ll just grab something really quick and be right back…" Scarlett took a handful of the powder and vanished into the green flames, leaving James and Sirius staring at the painted Highlands.
"Sorry for not telling you, Pads… it’s just—"
"It’s all right." Sirius clapped a hand on his best friend’s shoulder, a faint smile tugging at the corner of his mouth.
"Really?" James tried, and failed, to hide the note of scepticism in his voice.
"Yeah, I just…" Sirius took a deep breath, covering his mouth as he yawned. "I wouldn’t have had the headspace to plan any of this and… thanks, Prongs." He gripped James’s shoulder, his smile widening to reveal his dimples. "I mean it. She… she’s so happy and… thank you."
James simply pulled him into a hug.
"She’s our responsibility. Same as you," he murmured, rubbing his back the way he always did when Sirius broke down over his family — though Sirius would never admit to it.
"I love you, Prongs." Sirius closed his eyes and pressed his forehead to his. "Thank you."
James let out a quiet laugh.
"Love you too, Padfoot." He kissed his friend’s temple, holding him by the shoulders. "You didn’t used to say that before. Not seriously. Not before Scar."
Sirius opened his eyes and tilted his head, meeting those hazel eyes he adored, a faint blush rising to his cheeks.
"I was too scared to say it," he confessed softly, stepping back from his friend.
"Scared? Of what?" For a moment, James had the odd feeling they were talking about entirely different things.
"Of love." He pressed his lips together, exhaling through his nose. "Er… there’s something I need to tell you…" He shook his head slightly, as though trying to pull his thoughts into order. James still looked too taken aback by what he’d just said to reply, so Sirius went on. "Don’t tell Scar this… but… Avery’s a Death Eater. That’s one of the reasons… I broke his arm. Because…" He took a slow breath, trying to arrange his thoughts into something coherent. "Because…"
"It’s all right, Padfoot." James pinched his nose in that almost childish gesture that made Sirius smile again. "You shouldn’t have done it alone."
"What was I supposed to do? You wanted to tell Dumbledore!" He kept his voice low, running a hand through his hair.
"I know. And I was wrong," James admitted, planting his hands on his hips. "If Avery’s one of them, then that means…"
"Mulciber and Snape must be too," Sirius finished for him. "I can’t stand the thought of Scarlett not being able to walk safely through Hogwarts because of them… and the Durmstrang lot haven’t even arrived yet…" He rubbed his eyes with the palms of his hands.
"I’ve got a plan, Pads. But I’ll need your help. And Moony’s and Wormtail’s as well," James said with sharp certainty. He pushed his glasses up his nose with such determination that Sirius frowned.
"A plan? Against all three of them?" The question came out half as disbelief, half as curiosity.
"Yeah — no pranks or broken bones involved."
The seriousness in his friend’s tone confused him deeply; James only ever sounded like that when talking about Quidditch.
"So what does it involve, then?"
James’s expression darkened with something Sirius knew all too well — that unshakable need to protect, the audacity to never bow to what was wrong, that Gryffindor-born fire of courage and righteousness.
"Expulsion."
The pale face of his best friend was lit by a faint green gleam, reflected in the round lenses of his glasses, hiding the shadow in his eyes. Scarlett stepped out of the fireplace holding a framed picture, and both boys turned to look at her, their sombreness slipping unnoticed thanks to the bright excitement radiating from her.
"Here, you can start decorating our room now," Scarlett said, handing Sirius the framed The Doors poster. His grave expression softened into a quiet smile.
"Yes, ma’am," he murmured, pulling her close — though his eyes flicked briefly back to James.
"Since when did you grow?!" she frowned, glancing between her boyfriend and his friend. "You’re taller than James now!"
"What?" James’s dark eyebrows shot up in disbelief. "What d’you mean?!"
"Turn around," Scarlett ordered, pushing the two of them into position. "Stop lifting your heel!" She stamped on James’s foot, making him mutter a quiet curse. "Altitudo Revela!"
As soon as the spell was cast, a vertical line of light shot up between the two boys, revealing James’s height — an impressive 1.80 metres — and Sirius’s — 1.83.
"Yeah, three centimetres…" Scarlett placed her hands on her hips, eyeing the glowing line.
James jerked his head back and gaped in outrage, while Sirius merely turned his face towards his girlfriend, the black hair that brushed his shoulders sliding over his pale cheeks.
"Three centimetres… it’s not a big deal," he said casually, much to James’s dismay.
"Since when did you grow three centimetres?!" James’s voice was brimming with indignation.
"Dunno…"
"You can hardly tell, what with your hair, Jamie…" Scarlett said, smiling as she rested a hand on his shoulder.
"Yeah, it’s just three centimetres… shouldn’t make that much of a difference," Sirius added with his trademark insolent grin — and immediately earned a smack from James. "Oi, Prongs!"
"Three centimetres don’t make a difference to me!" James shot back, polishing his glasses on his Gryffindor cloak.
"Sure thing, short-arse…"
James looked up at him, laughing even as he pretended to scowl.
"Padfoot… there are growers and there are showers, all right? Just because it doesn’t look massive when soft doesn’t mean it isn’t!" he explained to Sirius as if addressing someone with a serious comprehension issue.
"Wait… we’re still talking about cocks?!" Scarlett raised her eyebrows.
"Yes!" both answered in unison.
"And why exactly are we having this conversation?" she asked, narrowing her eyes at them — though she was clearly amused.
Sirius and James exchanged a look.
"Well… erm…" Her boyfriend bit his lower lip, trying to come up with an explanation, but James cut him off with a sharp gesture.
"It’s nothing," he declared, not even bothering to sound convincing.
"Now I really want to know!" She stepped into their way, fingers drumming against her arms as she crossed them. "Come on, spill it!"
Wide-eyed, James turned to Sirius, silently begging for help. Scarlett silenced her boyfriend with a single glare.
"Out with it!" she stomped her foot. "What’s going on?"
"Edmund Bones," Sirius confessed, dodging James’s elbow by throwing his torso to the side. "There was a prank after Hufflepuff Quidditch practice… he ended up legging it stark naked across the pitch because someone nicked his clothes… and, well… no one knows who did it."
Scarlett’s eyes slid to James, whose hands were now buried in his hair, ruffling it furiously.
"Why did you steal his clothes?" she asked, so directly that it took him a few seconds to realise the question was aimed at him.
Sirius’s grin turned into a laugh. James opened and closed his fists as though physically restraining himself from strangling his best mate.
"I— I didn’t— argh! He keeps sending Lily little gifts!" he burst out dramatically, as if that alone justified a public humiliation.
Scarlett laughed too, covering her mouth with her hand.
"And you stole his clothes… why, exactly?"
"I asked the same thing," Sirius muttered, raising his hands in mock innocence when James shot him a murderous glare.
"I… I don’t know what to do, all right?!" James let out a long, defeated breath, his shoulders slumping. "I… I organise all the patrols, I stay up late writing McGonagall’s bloody reports, I even stick those colourful Muggle tabs she gave me so everything stays neat, but… she doesn’t talk to me. And I… I don’t know. I just don’t know." He trailed off, staring down at his shoes.
"Did you ask her out?" Scarlett slid an arm around his waist, with Sirius doing the same on the other side.
"No!" The denial came out as if it were the most obvious thing in the world. "She’d never say yes."
"Why not?"
"She’s never said yes before!"
"Before," Scarlett echoed pointedly. "Who’s to say she wouldn’t now?" She rested her cheek against his chest.
"You don’t understand, Scar… I… I’m so close and—"
"Prongs, if you don’t make a move, Bones will," Sirius warned. "And as funny as I find it that he legged it naked across the pitch, if Lily decides she wants him, that’s it. You’ll lose her for good."
James looked at them, his expression turning from worried to utterly stricken.
"Buy her a present and ask her out," Scarlett said before he could open his mouth.
"But… but she’ll say no…"
"Which is why we’ll make sure she’s in a situation where she can’t say no," Sirius cut him off smoothly.
"Jamie, Lily’s never going to compare the size of Bones’s cock to yours if she only goes out with you," Scarlett added matter-of-factly. "Stop being such a coward!"
"It’s not— it’s not that easy! I… I really like her!" His shoulders tensed as he nodded, struggling with the words.
"We know, Prongs. And we’re going to help you," Sirius said with such calm conviction that James had no choice but to believe him.
"Padfoot, Prongs…?" Peter’s voice made the three of them turn around. He stood by the entrance, looking uneasy. He’d never seen this part of the gallery before. "Curfew’s in a few minutes. We’ve got to head back to the common room…"
They said their goodbyes as they made their way back through the room filled with musical instruments. Sirius and Scarlett decided to stay — for obvious reasons — and James promised to bring their trunk the following morning.
Silence settled over the gallery, broken only by the wind rattling the chains of the torches above.
Sirius switched off the fuse box, and Scarlett lit the heater in the bedroom, watching him approach under the pale moonlight that streamed through the barred ceiling, bathing the room in silver. She handed him the framed poster, and Sirius took his time deciding where to place it, finally fixing it on the wall beside a bookshelf and just above the sideboard.
"Regulus picked that poster out when he came with me… to buy your birthday present." Scarlett pulled back the sheets and lay down on the bed.
Sirius arched an eyebrow, glancing at her over his shoulder.
"What do you mean?"
"Last year… I used the multi-key and he took me to the music shop near his house. The one by Grimmauld Place. I bought the Walkman and… he grabbed that poster to give you as a present. Said you used to have one just like it in your room — that you’d sneak out and take it with you to Muggle places…"
Sirius held her gaze, speechless for several long moments.
"You never told me that," he said at last, moving to sit on the edge of the bed.
"Why would I?" Scarlett’s body tensed.
"I… I don’t know. I really don’t." He was being honest. He hadn’t said it to accuse her — only because of that sharp sting in his chest upon hearing that she and his brother had gone out together. Kicking off his shoes, he flopped down beside her, crawling closer until he wrapped his arms around her over the blankets. "It’s just… sometimes I get this feeling… that one day I’ll wake up and… you’ll be gone."
"Gone?" Scarlett’s eyes — usually so open and warm — clouded with a trace of fear.
"Yeah… gone to him," he breathed out.
"Gone to Regulus? Why would that ever happen?" Her voice was confused, but deep down Scarlett knew all too well where her boyfriend’s insecurity came from.
"Because he told me it would." Sirius swallowed hard, slipping out of his cloak and pulling himself under the covers with her. "He said I’d ruin everything, and then… you’d run straight to him."
Scarlett stroked the beard along his jaw, her gaze steady on him. His silver eyes followed the motion of her thumb until they fluttered shut.
"I’d never do that, Sirius," she whispered, and he laid his hand over hers.
"I know." His lips parted as his jaw tightened, lashes lifting to reveal a tormented gleam beneath. "But still… it’s something that haunts me. It’s instinctive. I was raised to believe that… love is weakness. That you’re meant to repress every feeling, to be a statue — an inanimate shadow. I wasn’t allowed to be happy or sad… I wasn’t allowed to be anything but… but the perfect heir. A boy who only ever bowed his head and agreed with everything. My parents didn’t want a son — they wanted a puppet."
He pressed a kiss to the centre of her palm, holding it there against his face.
Scarlett frowned, her lips pressed tight as she watched Sirius rest his face against her stomach, rubbing it softly — the way he always did when he felt lost. His arms wrapped around her waist, pulling her in close, clinging to the warmth that seemed to shelter him from the cold of the world.
"They’re not entirely wrong about love…" she murmured, letting her pale fingers glide through his black hair. His eyes lifted to meet hers, brows slowly rising in curiosity. "Love makes us fragile… but being loved makes us strong. That’s why… there has to be balance between the two." She smiled — a soft, intimate smile — one he mirrored at once.
"That’s why I feel so safe with you. I love you," Sirius said, the confession spilling warm and golden against her Slytherin robes. "I think I’ll always love you."
Scarlett drew in a sharp breath, the air catching in her throat. His silver eyes, fascinated and feverish, pierced right through her as though they could dissolve her very soul.
"I love you too," she whispered, leaning down to kiss him deeply, slowly. "You make me stronger every day."
The daft smile stayed on Sirius’s flushed lips as he trailed kisses along her shirt, burying his face there once more.
"Stay with me forever?" he asked, his voice muffled, eyes shining like molten silver beneath the veil of his dark hair.
"I will." Scarlett looked back at him with the same intensity, meeting those black pupils until her soul could brush against his. "Today and always," she vowed — the sincerity of her heart fuelling the binding of their spirits.
Later in life, Sirius would remember that moment with a bitter taste. He hadn’t expected to be right — he’d always believed Scarlett’s love would fill the hollow inside him. That it would heal his scars and shield him from every cruelty of the world. That her love would be his sanctuary.
But love was never meant to be that.
Love could accept him, could help him understand himself — but it could not save him, nor protect him from what lived within: his pain, his flaws, his demons. Love is comprehension and respect, not escape or illusion. It isn’t a hiding place to bury what aches. It’s the force that strips away every hypocrisy, every mask, every lie. Love sees you for who you are, not who you wish to be.
Sirius Black was a frightened boy trying to play the part of a brave man.
A fearful, uncertain child disguised as a proud Gryffindor.
A man nearly grown who believed the girl he once tucked flowers into the hair of could redeem him.
Scarlett Gaunt was never his redemption.
In the end, she was his damnation.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 67: ‘Cause he knows it’s all worthwhile
Chapter Text
CXXXV
Scarlett spun the bat in her hands and struck the Bludger, sending it hurtling toward Slytherin’s new Beater, Lucinda Talkalot. She was tall for her age, dark-skinned, and always wore her tight curls up in a bun. Her build was formidable for a Beater — the muscles in her arms bulged even beneath her uniform every time she returned the iron ball to Scar.
The Keeper’s spot had been filled by Amycus Carrow, a pale, blond fifth-year who was far from the best candidate — Jacob Alcott, for instance, was a much better Keeper — but Rosier had insisted on his inclusion, and now the boy was being bombarded by the Quaffles Evan, Barty and Brandon were hurling at him.
Regulus was chasing the Snitch alongside Amycus’s twin sister, Alecto — a girl with coppery hair and hollow eyes. She kept glancing down at Scarlett from above, and it didn’t take long for the siblings’ presence on the team to become noticeable.
They were future Death Eaters, too. More than that, Rosier trusted them — it showed in the way he commanded the game. Scarlett’s attention drifted to Remus, sitting in the stands beside Mary. They’d told her they were going to work on the DADA essay Thanatos had assigned the day before, but she was quite certain they hadn’t even unrolled a bit of parchment, given she could see Remus’s tongue halfway down Mary’s throat from where she stood.
Rosier had allowed one of his friends to watch Slytherin’s practices as long as he wasn’t part of the Gryffindor team, so the duty had been passed to Remus and Peter. At first, being escorted all over the castle had been a little annoying, but Scarlett was grateful not to be alone. She felt that if she were, she’d fall apart. So she took all the turmoil in her chest, tucked it into a delicate little box, and buried it deep within her heart.
Everyone gathered once practice ended.
“Slughorn told me the selection for the inter-house team will happen midway through the month, so… if any of you want to take part, let me know so I can sign you up. Carrow, I want you two here half an hour early tomorrow. Gaunt, you’d better start eating some protein to regain your strength — your swings are still far too weak. Regulus, your dives are too stiff — you need to loosen up more on the broom. And Talkalot… what the bloody hell kind of surname is that?”
“Y-you can… you can call me Lucy,” the new girl stammered, clasping her hands behind her back and straightening up as though she were standing before a military general.
“Right. You’re all dismissed.”
Scarlett mounted her Firebolt and flew over to Remus and Mary, who sprang apart as if it weren’t already blatantly obvious what they’d been doing.
“I’m going to have a shower… you can stay here. I’ll meet Sirius at that place when his practice is over.” She glanced toward the entrance to the pitch, expecting the Gryffindor team to have arrived by now, but it was empty.
“Er… right, uh, I need to talk to you later,” Remus said, brushing his fingers over the scar on his chin, while Mary looked at the two of them with one eyebrow arched.
“All right.” Scarlett waved them goodbye and left the pitch without looking back.
She urged her broom forward and leaned down against the handle, the strong wind whipping her Quidditch robes as she sped through the Hogwarts grounds, where autumn was beginning to bloom. Scarlett soared over the Black Lake, watching as the giant squid’s tentacles rose into the air as though greeting her. Her lips curved softly into a smile and she tilted the broom downward, flying close to the surface of the water. It rippled up around her boots, trembling in violent waves stirred by her speed. She looked back to make sure no one was following before accelerating toward the opposite bank.
Scarlett dismounted slowly, her boots sinking into the soft ground. Her heart was pounding in her chest, in her wrists, in her ears. There was no peace to be found in the silence of the trees — not that she expected any — and her gaze wandered among autumn’s frozen relics, the reddish leaves swept up in piles by the wind, stiffened on the ground by the cold. The Black Lake would soon freeze, and the fields around it, once green and vivid, were already fading into shades of burnt yellow.
It was a gloomy day. The sky was dull, as if ready to snow, though it was far too early for that. It was only the beginning of October. For most of the wizarding world, it was the time of year to check on their pumpkins for Halloween — especially Hagrid, whose pumpkins in the garden were so enormous Scarlett suspected they weren’t entirely natural.
She took a deep breath, the icy air stabbing at her lungs. Her hands trembled, though not from the cold; it was the adrenaline still coursing through her veins. From her pocket, she pulled out a carefully folded map, checking for what felt like the thousandth time the familiar contours and symbols that told her she was in the right place. Her eyes swept the surroundings, alert to the slightest movement. She couldn’t afford to be discovered.
“Homenum Revelio.” She cast the spell.
Nothing.
Scarlett began stripping off her Quidditch robes, revealing a black swimsuit that was no match for the cold. The icy air made her skin prickle instantly, but she ignored the discomfort. She used to swim every morning in her first year at Durmstrang, even if that felt like a lifetime ago. She checked the map again and shoved it under her clothes, walking to the edge of the lake.
Her dancing reflection stared back at her. Scarlett held her wand between her teeth and tilted her head to one side. There were dark circles around her eyes and her cheeks were flushed from the cold. She took a few steps back, stretched her arms and dived in headfirst.
True, she’d done this before at Durmstrang, but bloody hell she’d forgotten how awful the sensation of thousands of needles pricking her nerves from the temperature really was. She surfaced and steadied her rapid breathing, arms and legs working vigorously, moving away from the bank as she swam toward the spot marked on the map.
It wasn’t very far. The good part was that it was far enough from the castle that no one would find her… although, come to think of it, that wasn’t entirely comforting.
Scarlett shook her head, patting her cold cheeks. She needed to focus!
There was a gentle current tugging her down. Swimming around it, she realised it was a whirlpool. She took three deep breaths, gripped her wand with one hand and dove, allowing herself to be taken by the current.
Everything went dark. The pressure of the water began to compress her organs and Scarlett felt every muscle in her body fight as she was sucked through the passage. Her lungs started to burn, but she held on. It was all psychological control — if she started panicking she’d drown, so she emptied her mind and grit her teeth, clenching the wand in her palm. If she ran out of air, she could disapparate…
But, hang on — she was on Hogwarts grounds, so would she manage it?! What if she couldn’t? She didn’t have her multi-key, so it would be impossible to get out of there, unless…
If she could have opened her hands and applauded, she would have.
Well done, Scarlett. You’re going to drown.
A bit ironic for someone whose whole family had been burned.
The thought didn’t last long, fortunately.
Scarlett burst forth, violently hurled into a damp cavern. She tumbled across the rocks before coming to a stop on her front, coughing and choking on the water that had flooded her lungs.
Gasping, she lay motionless until she had the strength to push herself up onto her knees, never letting go of her wand. Despite the disorientation caused by the lack of oxygen, she could feel magic pulsing through the rocks and inscriptions on the walls glowed in shades of blue and gold, whispering in her ear.
Ancient magic.
She stretched out her hand and touched one of the runes. Energy coursed through her body, making her fingers tingle. Scarlett straightened up, rising slowly, absorbing part of that ancient magic and storing it within her core. The ground shimmered with a blue laced in gold, tracing a path before her.
“Would you look at that, Uncle… you were right,” she murmured to herself, her voice echoing along the damp walls.
Right, right, right.
Her gaze inevitably fell to the Signet on her hand — the symbol of the Sallow family, her mother’s bloodline. The Ouroboros, as she called it for the serpent’s shape in the back of her hand, resonated with the magic of that place. Scarlett had never encountered so much ancient magic gathered in one spot, and even with the cold, her body barely trembled.
She followed the glowing path until it ended before what seemed to be an altar — something should have been resting upon it, yet it stood empty. She placed her hand on the dusky stone, and words began to take form, as though an invisible hand were writing them into existence, gleaming faintly. Each letter whispered into her mind as it appeared:
“What you seek demands communion,
The strength of three in true connection.
Three curses, three braziers, three flames,
The House of Triplets and their games.
A Gaunt must guide the way within,
But never alone should they begin.
Should one the path alone pursue,
Then death shall surely follow too.”
Scarlett stepped back, imprinting the words into her memory, her heart thundering in her chest. The glowing script wavered on the stone, its light fading gradually until only the dull carvings remained.
“Of course it had to involve death… why in Merlin’s name did I think it would be simple?!” she grumbled, wrapping her frozen arms around herself. A sound echoed from further ahead, and daylight broke through a small, distant opening.
Scarlett flicked her wand to dry herself and left the cave, the words still winding through her thoughts. The House of Triplets — clearly a reference to her family, to Melanie and Sebastian Sallow’s first three children. And all three had been Slytherins, so it had to be connected to her own House. Union, three people, a Gaunt…
She massaged her temple. She’d need time to think this through properly — and all sense of calm vanished the moment her eyes landed a few metres away, where Sirius and James stood with Minerva McGonagall, who looked visibly irritated at the condescending tone her boyfriend was using with her.
.
.
.
“Where’s she off to?” Sirius elbowed James, drawing his attention to the Marauder’s Map.
His friend, who’d been giving instructions for that morning’s Quidditch practice, let out a long sigh before turning to him, pushing his glasses up his nose in annoyance.
“What is it, Pads?” He planted his hands on his hips and glanced down at the little dot labelled Scarlett Gaunt moving swiftly across the Black Lake. “She’s just going for a fly…” He turned back to the team. “Right, everyone! Let’s start with the offensive formation! Sirius, you and Marl will handle the Bludgers while Ezra and I work on short passes. Richard, keep warming up for now…”
Sirius barely listened. The new recruits — Morgan McGonagall, a distant niece of Minerva who had come to watch her aunt’s practice, and Raymond King, the new Keeper — hardly tore their eyes from James, as if they were standing before a living legend.
Morgan was an eccentric girl, with hair cropped so short she almost looked like a boy, and dark eyes that matched her locks. Her skin was pale, especially in the cold, and though she was small, her shoulders were broad. Raymond (or Ray, as his mates called him), on the other hand, had olive skin, greenish eyes and a sharp nose. His sturdy build gave him a clear advantage at goal, and he was Daisy’s backup until she graduated.
Sirius crouched on the grass with the Marauder’s Map open across his knees, eyes fixed on Scarlett’s dot. He leaned closer as though that would somehow help him understand her better. Was she exploring or what?
“She’s probably just flying about. She does that sometimes, Pads. Relax.” James shrugged, waving the rest of the team into formation.
But Sirius couldn’t relax. He forced himself to fold the map and joined Marl, who was already in position with his bat. Even as he stretched and tried to focus on the session, his eyes kept darting toward the edge of the pitch, in the direction of the lake. He raised his bat and began warming up, leaving the map on the bench beside him. No one seemed to mind that his attention wasn’t entirely on the training — after all, the focus was on the rookies.
Before long, Marl called for a break, and Sirius seized the chance to glance at the map again. The dot representing Scarlett had moved along the bank, drifted over the lake… and vanished.
Sirius dropped his bat, his heart hammering in his chest.
“James! She’s gone!” he shouted, eyes wide and locked on his friend.
James shot into the air, ignoring Ray’s pass, and landed neatly beside him to check the map in his hands.
“What is going on here?!” Minerva approached, and Sirius instantly snatched the map from James’s hands and stuffed it down his trousers before she could see what they were doing.
“It’s… it’s… erm… Scarlett. She… she was at the lake and… and vanished!” Sirius stammered. He didn’t want to expose the existence of the map, but his girlfriend’s safety mattered far more.
Minerva frowned, her sharp eyes probing him with their usual sternness. She didn’t seem convinced, but upon noticing just how desperate he looked, she simply nodded.
“Very well. Black, Potter, with me. We’ll investigate the situation.” She seized Marlene’s broom, while Marlene herself just stood there, puzzled, looking at James.
The three of them took off. Sirius barely noticed how deftly McGonagall handled a broom — he was far too focused on scanning the shore marked on the map for any sign of Scarlett. He descended quickly, skidding through the shallows of the Black Lake as he dismounted, stumbling onto the bed of dead leaves beneath the nearby trees.
He spotted Scarlett’s Quidditch robes discarded a few feet away, his eyes darting wildly around as his breath caught in his throat. No, no, no, no — he couldn’t lose her, he couldn’t—
“Scar?” James called out, his voice echoing through the trees and shattering the eerie stillness. “Scarlett?”
“Miss Gaunt?” Minerva added, joining in the calls.
“She drowned, she drowned, she drowned…” Sirius muttered, his remaining breath trembling as his legs stiffened at the sight of the trail showing she had, indeed, dived in. “No, no, no…”
Then, a sound from between the trees drew their attention. Scarlett emerged, walking slowly, her damp hair plastered to her face, bare feet sinking into the earth, arms crossed tightly over her body as if to shield herself from the cold. She wore only a swimsuit and looked quite startled by the commotion.
“What are you all do—”
She didn’t get to finish. Sirius sprinted towards her, crashing into her in a crushing embrace that nearly knocked the air out of her lungs.
“Have you gone completely mad?!” he shouted, anger laced with barely contained fear. “You can’t just disappear without telling anyone!”
Minerva merely sighed, turning her severe gaze upon Scarlett.
“Miss Gaunt, you know perfectly well you’re not allowed to swim in the Black Lake without permission. It’s dangerous — both for its depth and for the creatures within. Fifteen points will be taken from Slytherin.”
Scarlett just stared down at her bare feet, saying nothing, trembling with cold. Sirius still clung to her, while James only shook his head in disbelief.
“For Merlin’s sake, Scar… you’re going to give Sirius a heart attack one of these days,” he scolded, his tone that infuriating mix of fond and exasperated.
“Get dressed,” Sirius ordered almost gruffly, grabbing her clothes off the ground.
Scarlett covered herself quickly while Minerva and James said their goodbyes and returned to the Quidditch pitch, leaving the two of them alone. Sirius didn’t move an inch away, watching her as if to make absolutely sure nothing else would happen.
He pulled out her Firebolt and released it with a flick of his hand.
“Get on,” he ordered, his tone edged with impatience. Even so, Scarlett obeyed without hesitation. He mounted his own broom, and together they cut through the morning sky toward the Clock Tower courtyard.
The sensation of freedom was clouded by the unbearable weight of Sirius’s gaze upon her. When they arrived, he landed first, helping her down as though she needed it. There was no gentleness in his movements, though — only the residue of frustration. Scarlett opened her mouth to try and explain, but he was faster.
“What were you doing?”
Scarlett hesitated, the words tangling in her throat. She faltered, rubbing the Signet anxiously with her fingers, her gaze slipping away from his. The frustration on his face was unmistakable; those grey eyes darkened to the shade of lead, fuelled by anger. He took a step back and exhaled slowly, as if restraining himself.
“Of course you’re not going to say anything. You know you’ve fucked up,” he snapped, his ragged breath blowing stray strands of hair from his face. “Why do I even… you just do whatever the hell you want, don’t you, Scarlett?!”
“I can’t swim in the bloody lake anymore?” Scarlett roared back, fists tightening around the broom handle. “For Merlin’s sake, Sirius, I… I just— you’re suffocating me!”
Sirius narrowed his eyes, his eyelids twitching. His lips pressed into a thin line — and yes, he was offended.
“No, caring about you isn’t suffocating!” he barked, moving again after standing frozen for several tense seconds. “But… I’m not your punching bag either!”
Before she could reply, Sirius climbed onto his broom with a sharp motion and took off without looking back. Scarlett watched, speechless, as he disappeared in the direction of the Quidditch pitch. She swallowed hard, only now realising she was surrounded by students.
“What does Sirius Black even see in her?”
“She’s a Slytherin. They never should’ve started seeing each other.”
“Hope that’s the end of them.”
“Maybe he’s finally realised she’s not right for him.”
“Either way, it won’t last. Black ditched McKinnon for her, and he’ll dump her for someone else — just wait.”
Scarlett could have retaliated, but it was as if the cold shaking her body had numbed her to everything around. So all she did was walk unsteadily through the castle until she reached the Undercroft. She stepped into the bathroom, turned on the hot water, and let her clothes fall to the floor. If she cried, she didn’t notice. The scalding water burned her skin until it turned red.
After her shower, she fetched a roll of parchment and carefully noted down the message that had appeared to her in the cave. She tried to unravel the riddle, but her mind kept drifting to Sirius — and, if she dared to admit it, to her family. She didn’t want to be trapped in that spiral of thoughts, so before she even realised it, she was sitting in front of her Yamaha CS-80 and her Minimoog. Her fingers moved deftly across the keys, unconsciously playing a David Bowie song that always brought her back to Sirius.
She closed her eyes tightly and let the melody flow through the gallery.
No matter what she did, it was as if the universe always pulled him back to her.
.
.
.
[Music: David Bowie — Starman]
Sirius Black’s day couldn’t have been better. He’d woken up beside the woman he loved, promised to keep up the motorbike lessons for Reg and Harry before leaving the house, and sorted everything he needed to with Dumbledore regarding Scarlett and his godson spending the summer with him. Of course, the Headmaster hadn’t been pleased with what he’d done — but really, what choice had he had?
Didn't know what time it was, the lights were low
I leaned back on my radio
Some cat was layin' down some rock 'n' roll
Lotta soul, he said
Dumbledore’s decisions couldn’t override Harry’s own wishes; it would have been absurd to force the boy to spend the summer with his aunt and uncle after Sirius had proved it wasn’t necessary.
Either way, there he was — in Scarlett’s bedroom, his Walkman freshly rescued from one of the countless boxes in the attic, playing his favourite David Bowie tape.
Then the loud sound did seem to fade
Came back like a slow voice on a wave of phase
That weren’t no DJ, that was hazy cosmic jive
Listening to Starman again after twelve years without music was pure magic. Dazzling. Orgasmic. Sirius hummed the tune under his breath and opened Scarlett’s wardrobe, running his fingers along the two lone shirts hanging inside.
There's a Starman waiting in the sky
He'd like to come and meet us
But he thinks he'd blow our minds
“What’s he doing here, then?!” Regulus — the brother he’d spent years despising — was perched on Scarlett’s bed, strumming a ghostly guitar.
“Like the look,” Lily said, ignoring him as she twirled a strand of red hair and eyed Sirius’s outfit — high-waisted leather trousers that clung in all the right places, and a black leather vest with silver spikes on the lapels.
That was all he wore, leaving the tattoos that sprawled across his arms, torso and abdomen on full display. His hair, tied back in a low ponytail, spilled down his back — glossy and soft, as if Azkaban had never touched it.
“So… you’ve got a thing for bad boys, then?” James grinned wickedly, giving his wife’s arse a squeeze.
Regulus immediately grimaced, throwing a hand over his face — he did not want to see whatever James was doing to Lily at that moment. Existing as a ghost had taught him a few things; namely, that even in death, they could still…
I had to phone someone, so I picked on you
Hey, that's far out, so you heard him too?
Switch on the TV, we may pick him up on channel two
His thoughts were cut short when Sirius began rummaging through Scarlett’s drawers, swaying his body to the rhythm of the song — the leather of his trousers creaking as he bent in a way that left his arse practically in his brother’s face.
Regulus set the guitar aside and turned toward the opposite end of the bed.
“What the bloody hell is he doing?!” This time it was James who asked, holding a half-dressed Lily in his arms.
Look out your window, I can see his light
If we can sparkle, he may land tonight
Don't tell your poppa or he'll get us locked up in fright
Sirius rummaged through an empty drawer and raised an eyebrow. He opened and shut the others in quick succession, hands landing on his hips at the clear lack of clothes inside. His eyes swept around the room until they fell on what looked like a laundry basket behind the door.
“Looking for one of Scarlett’s dirty knickers to sniff?!” Regulus sneered, though there was a hint of genuine alarm in his voice.
“He’d never do that…” James said quickly, flashing an uneasy smile.
“Oh, that’s definitely something he’d do,” Lily shot back, laughing as her husband gave her a scandalised look. “I remember him saying he used to nick her knickers after—”
There's a Starman waiting in the sky
He's told us not to blow it
'Cause he knows it's all worthwhile, he told me
Let the children lose it
Let the children use it
Let all the children boogie
“For Salazar’s sake, too much detail!” Regulus groaned, clapping his hands over his ears but still watching as his brother picked up each piece of clothing, muttering under his breath. “I know what he’s doing…”
“You don’t mind, then?” James asked, slinging an arm over his shoulders in that infuriatingly familiar way, making him flinch.
“Mind what?” Red shot him a sideways glance, his expression sliding into defiance.
“The two of them… together.”
Regulus bit down on his lower lip and stepped away abruptly.
“It doesn’t matter. I’m dead,” he muttered, almost to himself. “And we all know she can’t stay away from him.”
“No… she really can’t,” Lily murmured, pulling away from her husband and slipping to Regulus’s other side, pressing her lips close to his ear. “Ah! We know that too…” she added with a nasal giggle.
Regulus glanced at James, then turned toward Lily — only to be swallowed by those green eyes that were no longer soft, inviting, or kind. No. They were full of weeds, thorns, and poisonous bloom.
Lily took his chin between her fingers, leaving him no chance to escape.
“About Reggie.”
There's a Starman waiting in the sky
He's told us not to blow it
'Cause he knows it's all worthwhile, he told me
Let the children lose it
Let the children use it
Let all the children boogie
Sirius, utterly oblivious to the ghostly exchange unfolding in the room, left it just in time to find Penny cleaning Scarlett’s flat. He Disapparated back home, where he found Remus setting up an aviary in the garden for Buckbeak with Harry and Reggie’s help. Moments later, he was astride his Ninja, racing toward the shopping centre, his Walkman never leaving his ears.
When he parked — diagonally, across two spaces, of course — he strolled through the aisles drawing every eye in the place. Sirius was stunning, but it wasn’t just that; he looked like he’d just walked off a rock stage, and that alone was enough to command attention. The housewives eyed him with barely concealed lust, the husbands with envy tinged by curiosity, and the daughters… well, most of them couldn’t even close their mouths — because that specimen was exactly the kind of man they’d shamelessly call daddy.
He couldn’t have cared less, especially when he stepped into the women’s clothing shop. Two sales assistants approached him, their gazes trailing over his leather vest, tattoos, messy ponytail, and scuffed boots.
“Can we help you?” one of them asked, smiling in a way that went far beyond professionalism.
Sirius theatrically removed his aviator sunglasses and hooked them on his vest.
“Yes, I’m looking for clothes for my woman,” he said, glancing around. “She’s in a rock band, so I need things that fit that vibe. Oh, and some casual pieces too.”
The saleswomen exchanged glances as though standing before a Greek god.
“What… what size is she?” the other asked, clearing her throat and trying — and failing — to keep her eyes at face level.
“Somewhere between eight and ten. Twelve, depending on the fabric.” He bit his lower lip thoughtfully and leaned over the accessories display. “She likes dresses that show off her legs. Leather trousers — definitely leather trousers. Skirts. Jackets. And shoes. Combat boots, high boots… that sort of thing.”
“And tops?”
“She likes ones that show her shoulders… but nothing too low-cut. And clothes for cold weather — tight and comfortable.”
The saleswomen nodded, and the hunt began. Sirius meant to follow them, but his gaze drifted to the accessories displayed just beneath his elbows: leather gloves, wristbands, belts draped in chains, scarves, fishnet tights… there were so many options that he got momentarily lost among them.
The saleswomen returned carrying a mountain of clothes — bodycon dresses with lace details, an enormous variety of skirts, leather trousers and jackets, strappy tops… there were so many pieces that he could hardly take them all in, but just imagining Scarlett wearing them…
“No bright colours,” he added. “She prefers black… green… and red.”
“And… um… will she be needing… undergarments?” one of the saleswomen asked, sorting through the pile while carefully avoiding his eyes.
“You mean…”
“Lingerie, sir,” the other supplied quickly, her eager smile refusing to fade. It was painfully obvious how hopelessly smitten she was.
He frowned slightly and stepped toward the section, running his fingers over the options, picking out the ones that matched Scarlett’s style — black and red lace, thin bras with daring details, and satin nightgowns that caught his attention, though he much preferred when she slept completely naked against him.
“These… and these…” he pointed out the sets.
After an hour of not-so-difficult choices, Sirius Black was loaded with shopping bags in both arms. The saleswomen — victims of the brightest star in the night sky — still couldn’t take their eyes off him.
“Thank you, ladies,” he said, leaving a generous tip on the counter before walking out of the shop the way he liked best: as the centre of attention.
Ah, Sirius Black did love a spotlight. For a moment, it was almost as if he were eighteen again.
Almost.
That Sirius, however, was only a fractured echo of the man he used to be. His smile faltered, his shoulders loosened, his heart quickened. A strange insecurity bloomed in his chest, growing and twisting as though his blood were the very sunlight it craved.
Would Scarlett even like any of it? He hadn’t said a word to her. He didn’t want to bring up the fact that he’d burnt her old clothes — that would only drag them back to the past, to Regulus, to the Death Eaters, to Marlene…
He cleared his throat, lifted his chin, and swallowed the thorns in his chest before they could choke him.
It would be impossible to reach Scarlett’s flat by motorbike with all those bags, so he found a quiet corner of the shopping centre — one without any cameras (those Muggle devices that filmed people doing the wrong things in the most hidden places) — and Disapparated.
He reappeared right in Scarlett’s bedroom, the impact of his arrival sending the clothes flying into the air as if a grenade of fabric had just gone off — lingerie sets and skirts spinning mid-air like confetti.
“Bloody hell…” he muttered, drawing his wand and giving it a flick.
The shirts neatly folded themselves into perfect piles, the jackets hung from hangers, the lingerie slipped into drawers, and the shoes tucked themselves into the only space he thought they might fit. Scarlett’s wardrobe was now bursting with pieces in all her favourite colours.
Sirius took a step back, admiring his work with a satisfied grin.
“He bought her clothes…” Regulus tried to dodge Jily’s interrogation, but the pair didn’t even blink.
“Why didn’t you tell us that before?!” James demanded, using his height to intimidate the younger ghost.
Sirius suddenly heard voices coming from the living room.
“What are you doing here, Penny?!” — Scarlett’s voice.
“Cleaning this filth you call a home, Mistress Black,” Penny retorted in her shrill, sarcastic tone.
Sirius’s eyes widened as he looked around in panic. He couldn’t Disapparate — Scarlett would hear it — but he also didn’t fancy being told off, not when everything was going so well… he knew her; she’d be embarrassed the moment she saw what he’d done. So he transformed into Padfoot and dashed under the bed, heart pounding wildly like he was a teenager again, caught in one of his old pranks.
Scarlett came in soon after, wearing that withdrawn, guilty expression that had become her trademark in recent weeks. She closed the door behind her — and froze when she saw the wardrobe. Padfoot scratched his ear, realising he’d forgotten to shut the doors before transforming.
She placed one hand on her hip and covered her mouth with the other. For a few seconds she just stood there, motionless, unable to believe her eyes. Tears welled up at the corners, sliding down her cheeks. Then Scarlett shook her head, pressing her other hand against her lower back as a faint, barely-there smile curved her lips.
“Idiot…” she whispered, biting the corner of her mouth to fight off the smile — but it persisted, and she gave up when a strange smell hit her nose. “Why does it smell like wet dog…?”
She stepped closer to the bed, her worn boots circling it — to Padfoot’s sheer horror. He froze beneath her, trying to stay perfectly still, though his tail betrayed him, swishing anxiously from side to side.
“Hm…” Scarlett grunted. And then, all of a sudden, that pair of boots turned into two soft, furry little paws.
Whiskers leapt onto Padfoot, landing squarely on his back. He yelped in surprise, and she bit his ear. The dog growled in protest and tried to shake her off, but the cat clung to his fur like a tick — no matter how much he twisted and writhed, she wouldn’t let go.
Padfoot gave in at last, nipping at the back of one of her legs. She bolted toward the door, springing onto the handle to push it open. The dog darted after her, his fur bristling with the thrill of the chase.
They both skidded straight into Penny, who had just finished cleaning the living room. The elf froze, broom in hand, her eyes doubling in size as she watched them tearing around the sofa.
“Mister Black! Mistress Black! You’ll mess everything up again!” she scolded, exasperated.
Whiskers let out a teasing sound of defiance, darting faster, while Padfoot slid across the freshly polished floor in pursuit. Penny chuckled quietly despite herself, brandishing the broom in mock annoyance as she tried to chase them off. But the two of them easily evaded her, weaving in zigzags around the sofa and leaping over the coffee table.
The elf soon gave up, resting the broom against the floor. Her bat-like ears flapped wildly with each exasperated shake of her head.
“You two… are impossible… at least you’re enjoying yourselves…”
Whiskers jumped onto the sofa and transformed back into Scarlett mid-air, landing with unearthly grace. Padfoot followed suit, though with far less elegance — he transformed mid-leap and landed squarely on top of her, his arms wrapping her in a tight embrace as they both burst into laughter.
“Ow, Sirius!” Scarlett protested, pretending to be hurt but unable to stop laughing. “You’re heavy!”
“No, I’m not… you’re just too frail!” he shot back, biting her shoulder with that roguish, dimpled grin.
Scarlett barely had time to turn her face toward him before Sirius caught her lips in a kiss — full of heat and exhilaration — his fingers threading through her hair, his body pinning hers beneath him. She smiled against his mouth, landing a playful slap on his arse.
“I need… to get back… to work,” she murmured between kisses, her tongue caught eagerly by his.
“You can be a few minutes late… no one will notice,” he muttered lazily, his hands roaming over her body with expert familiarity — squeezing her curves, tracing her scars, teasing the places he knew would make her squirm.
Scarlett tried to resist… but who could resist Sirius Black? She hadn’t managed it in the past, and she couldn’t now. He was far too persuasive — with his mouth, with his hands, with the way his body fit perfectly over hers, as though he’d been made for this. For them to fit together whether they were naked, clothed, or worlds apart.
She didn’t need to be stripped of her clothes to feel bare in Sirius’s presence; his gaze alone was enough to undress her.
“Sirius…” His name left her lips as a breathy moan when one of his hands crept between her thighs. “Please…”
The dragged, trembling tone confused him — it was as if Scarlett was yearning for more and begging for less all at once.
“I need… I need to work.” The argument slipped from her mouth, her hot breath mingling with his — their faces so close they almost shared the same air.
Sirius locked his eyes on hers; that blue — always so warm, heavy and tempting — drew him deeper into the dark dilation of her pupils. He kissed the tip of her freckled nose, then her pink lips, and finally her delicate chin.
“I’m having lunch at the Leaky Cauldron… shall we meet later?” he murmured, tracing his tongue along the curve of her smile, making her grin even wider.
“Yes. I’m playing tonight… but it ends early. Shall we meet at eleven?” It was easy to hold his gaze, because Sirius’s eyes were so vivid that nothing else seemed to matter.
“At eleven,” he agreed with a soft growl as she wrapped her legs around his waist. “Keep that up and you won’t be working at all today.”
They both glanced to the side when Penny appeared in their line of sight, muttering something about how much extra cleaning she’d have to do with the two of them carrying on indecently in plain sight.
Sirius tried to keep a straight face, though the corners of his mouth betrayed him. He fought it — but then they both burst into laughter. Unrestrained, effortless laughter — free of resentment or guilt. It was just… laughter. A sound so different, yet so achingly familiar. Sirius wanted to live inside Scarlett’s smile.
Then he stood up. Even though every part of him wanted to remain shipwrecked in her — like a weary man coming home to the woman who always welcomed him back without question.
“Thank you, love.” She sat up on the sofa, her smile turning shy. “For… for the clothes and…”
“You don’t need to thank me, kitten.” Sirius kissed her once more, this time without hunger — only tenderness. “I love you.”
“I love you too, Georgy Porgy.” Scarlett lowered her gaze, her cheeks lightly flushed, like a teenager again. “See you later.”
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 68: She will be your living end
Chapter Text
CXXXVI
Scarlett was smiling at the walls as she went up to her flat after lunch, eager to better admire the gifts Sirius had given her. Her blood ran freely through her veins — restless and tumultuous. She opened the door and came face to face with Lily and James standing there, in front of a cross-armed Regulus sitting on the sofa.
Her smile vanished without a trace.
“What happened?” She hadn’t meant to ask, but couldn’t stop the words leaving her lips.
Lily looked at her, clearly exasperated. Scarlett had only seen her like that a few times, and every single one of them had been terrifying.
“We need to talk!” Lily pointed an accusing finger inches from her face, the orange nail trembling dangerously close to her cheek. “Sit. Now!”
Like a child being scolded by her mum, Scarlett did as she was told and sat beside Red. James didn’t look happy either, but his eyes were fixed entirely on Regulus.
“But wh—”
“Reggie! Reggie is Sirius’s son!” Lily thundered, gesturing so violently that, had she not been dead, Scarlett would’ve shrunk into the sofa to avoid becoming the target of her fury. “All this time!”
“Why did you hide it?” James pushed his glasses up his nose, his eyes brimming with suspicion.
“I didn’t—”
“All this time, Scarlett, if you’d just told the truth…” Lily cut her off, ignoring her protests. “Why? What do you get out of this? Can’t you see how much Sirius—”
“She can’t!” Regulus shot up from the sofa, his shout silencing Lily. “You’re so bloody clever about some things, Evans, and so bloody thick about others! Scarlett can’t tell the truth!”
“But you can!” Lily took a step towards Red, puffing up her chest to make up for being shorter than him. “Why didn’t you tell us anything before?”
The youthful lines that shaped Regulus’s beautiful face — always so composed, so soft — had now turned as rigid as the steel that forged his eyes.
“Why would I?” The words came out laced with such disdain, such venom and insolence that Lily slapped him across the face so hard he was thrown back onto the sofa.
Something sticky trickled from his nose. Regulus touched it and saw it was blood. Colourless, scentless, cold. Still blood nonetheless.
“Tell them, Red,” Scarlett murmured, her blue eyes piercing into him with utter frigidity. Her insides churned under the impassive yet indignant gazes fixed upon him. “Tell them the things you say to me.”
Regulus hissed as though he were in Mittens’s skin.
“Because he’s all I’ve got…” he whispered, almost involuntarily. “You and him… you’re all I’ve got…” His eyes welled up with tears just as uncontrollably as his words, locking onto Scarlett. “You don’t understand, because all you ever see is Sirius, but—”
“And you knew that! You always knew that!” Scarlett burst out, springing from the sofa as if it were on fire. “Tell them what you used to do when we were together!”
Regulus heard her, but paid her no mind. He remained stiff, unyielding, motionless — just staring at her, his eyes blazing bronze, wild and wrathful against the marble pallor of his skin.
“It’s bloody obvious… that Sirius is Reg’s father. No matter how much we tried to cover it up…” he muttered, measured. Dry.
“Sirius might be a fool, but he’s not stupid. Sooner or later… he’ll find out…”
“And yet, he’ll never believe Reggie’s his son.” He cut Lily off, wiping the blood above his lip with the back of his hand, his eyes never leaving Scarlett. “Do you know why? Because Sirius will never forgive you, and he’ll never stop hating me. And in the end, whether you like it or not, that hatred will always fall on Reggie.”
Scarlett stepped closer, raising her hand instinctively as Lily had done earlier. Regulus didn’t flinch. His eyes were spark and steel, defiant as a cornered serpent, coiled and ready to strike. Scarlett’s furious pupils burned into him, and tears traced the sharp surface of her irises.
“No. Sirius… would never do that.” She cleared her throat, trying to keep her voice steady. “You… you don’t know what you’re saying. He… he’ll forgive me… I know him far better than you ever could…”
“Do you?” His face turned to stone. “Then what do you think he’ll do when he finds out about our kiss before you graduated?”
Scarlett’s hand came down fast, and Regulus, as if expecting a blow, shut his eyes. But she stopped her fist midway and stepped back, turning her face aside. As poisonous as his words were, she wouldn’t play that game. She wouldn’t give him that satisfaction.
“You’re pathetic,” she hissed, sorrow dripping from her tone. The kind that wounded — his eyes flew open, his lips curling in disgust. “Back at Grimmauld Place… all the promises I made to you… were empty. I only made them because I pitied you. I wanted to manipulate you to get out of there. We both knew I’d go back to Sirius… that I’d leave you.” Her words rubbed salt deep into that raw wound. “Because that’s what you are, Regulus. The spare.”
And with that, Scarlett turned on her heel and walked away.
Regulus made a move to stand, but James didn’t let him. Using his height to intimidate him, he stepped right in front of him, his face twisted in a mixture of disappointment and disgust unlike anything Regulus had ever seen before.
Lily placed a hand on her husband’s shoulder, but he stayed where he was, nostrils flaring, eyes hard.
“When Sirius told me you were a shadow… I didn’t want to believe it. But… he was right. He was right all along about you. Red… you are a shadow. You’ve spent your whole life trying to fit into the ideals of a society that accepted nothing but the twisted and the sick. You castrated yourself to please people who never cared for you, chasing a kind of love you’ll never find. It’s ironic how much you crave something you’re incapable of giving.” James shuddered, his fists clenching. “You’re always chasing a mirage. Scarlett’s love, Sirius’s love, your parents’ love. And in the end… you’ve ended up with none. Can’t you see the problem’s you? I thought you were smarter than that, Red. You’ve no idea how much Sirius suffered… how much—bloody hell! Reggie’s been his this whole time!” he roared, his face turning crimson.
“That’s why you can’t love Reg… because he isn’t yours,” Lily added, arms crossed, her gaze distant. “Have you ever stopped to think of how much harm you’ve done to your brother?”
“I… I… I did it to protect him!” Regulus tried to argue, but the words seemed to choke him. “He and Scarlett…”
“Did you? Did you really?” she raised her voice, cutting him off. “Or did you just seize the chance to hurt your brother?”
“I only wanted to save her. The way she tried to save me.” For the first time that morning, Regulus sounded sincere. “I just… just wanted to end the war…”
“And in the end, it ended you,” James muttered, shutting his eyes and stepping back quickly, as if he couldn’t bear to remain in the same room as him.
“Don’t pull that face, Regulus, I know there’s a lot more you’re not telling us… and I’ll find out. Reggie’s parentage was only the first.” Lily smiled — a sly, unstable smile. “If I didn’t need you to help my son…” She sighed in exasperation. “I don’t understand you. We’re not your enemies!”
Regulus placed a hand over his chest. There were no heartbeats, no blood running, no trace of life within it.
So why did he feel everything but dead?!
“I know you’re not,” he said at last, still sitting, his shoulders slowly hunching. “There are things you can’t know… no one can know…”
“Are you afraid we’ll find out who you really are? Because that, I already know.” She swallowed hard, her eyes locked on him with burning intensity.
“I don’t want to be hated… not more than I already am…” He hid his face in his hands. “I took Reggie in to protect him, I married Scarlett to protect her… and in the end, what do I get? Reg never even knew who I was. And Scarlett… she’s never going to love me.”
“James and I were murdered on Halloween. Sirius spent twelve years wrongfully imprisoned. Scarlett was tortured in Azkaban. What did we get out of that?” Lily turned her gaze to the window, where the sun bathed her — its pale light mingling intensely with gold, giving her an angelic, almost sacred appearance. Then she looked back at him, the green fields of her eyes split by the dark filaments in her irises. “It was a war, Regulus. That’s what war does. It twists boys until they become men… or corpses.”
He exhaled all the air from his lungs, all his defiance dissolving into a mental exhaustion he’d never allow himself to show under normal circumstances. But Lily Potter was a stubborn Gryffindor — claws out, teeth bared.
“It doesn’t matter anymore…”
“Scarlett isn’t some little toy for you and Sirius to play tug-of-war with,” Lily pressed on. “She’s a human being, Regulus, with feelings and desires. Her not loving you doesn’t make you less, just as your loving her doesn’t make you more. And she… my God, she cares for you. She loves you. Not in the way you want, but not everything is about what you want!”
Regulus didn’t answer. How could he? He still saw the world through a narrow lens, one where everything revolved around himself. He still struggled with the fact that love can’t be begged for, commanded, or forced. He wasn’t capable of winning someone’s heart because everything he’d ever achieved had been through imposition — just as his parents, grandparents, and great-grandparents had done before him.
Love was still uncharted territory for Regulus Black — a land he’d only ever glimpsed through crumbs.
And it was far too terrifying to explore.
.
.
.
The full moon would fall on the Wednesday of the penultimate week of October, and Remus had already been feeling ill since Saturday. Between classes and the Hogsmeade visit, Scarlett and Sirius still hadn’t resolved their tension. Not that they were behaving oddly — he still kept his arm around her shoulders as they walked from one class to another, held her hand, or leaned against her leg. As tactile as ever, Sirius merely avoided looking at her whenever they sat side by side at the Gryffindor table in the Great Hall.
“So, who’s going as Vader for Halloween, then?” Scarlett brought up the subject, catching the attention of James and Peter, who sat down across from her.
“No one,” James decided, the Head Boy badge gleaming proudly on his chest. “Right, Wormtail?”
Peter let out a long, exasperated sigh, dropping his cutlery onto the plate with a loud clatter. He scratched his upturned nose and nodded, not without rolling his eyes first.
“Did Moony say what he’s going as?” he asked, his shrill voice full of irritation.
“Obi-Wan,” Sirius replied. “We’ll have the pleasure of dyeing his hair white…”
“White? Does it have to be?” Scarlett frowned.
“But… but if Moony’s going as Obi-Wan, then why can’t I…” Peter’s protest died off the moment he caught James’s look. “Fine.”
“Go as Chewbacca, then,” Sirius teased, flashing a wicked grin.
Scarlett had only learnt about the characters after they’d watched the film at their place over the weekend — Peter owned an absurdly expensive tape he’d bought from a cinema on the verge of bankruptcy. It had been easy to get there without anyone bothering them thanks to the reactivated Floo fireplace in the Undercroft.
“You go as him,” Peter shot back, making an irritable noise.
“Wormtail… for Merlin’s balls, mate… enough already… it’s just a film…” James tried to smooth things over, which only seemed to rile his friend further.
“It’s not just a film!” Peter burst out, the cutlery clinking on the table as he jerked up in outrage. “It’s the greatest science-fiction film ever made!”
“Star Wars is brilliant, but it was clearly inspired by Dune, and both drew from the amazing Arthur C. Clarke and his science-fiction short stories,” Lily chimed in, pouring herself a glass of elf wine.
“Yeah… Arthur Clarke, genius…” James echoed like a parrot.
“What are you going as for Halloween, Lily?” Sirius changed the subject quickly, hoping to spare his best friend further embarrassment.
“I haven’t decided yet…” She shrugged. “If you’re not going as Darth Vader, then what are you going as? If it’s R2-D2, I could help with the costume…”
“Exactly! He’s going as a robot!” James agreed so fast that Peter didn’t even have time to protest, throwing a desperate look at his friend.
“Oh, lovely, we could order the fabrics from Twilfitt and Tatting’s…” Lily mused, tapping her chin with her finger.
Scarlett instinctively looked at Sirius — who was already looking at her.
“Why don’t we just buy it ready-made? Much easier…” he murmured quietly to her, since James seemed far too excited to hear anything that wasn’t coming from Lily’s mouth.
“Yeah, well, we could order ours and let James make his own…” Scarlett smiled, resting her head on her boyfriend’s shoulder.
“Deal.”
After dinner, the group headed down to the Undercroft. Peter was far from pleased with James’s idea, setting up his wizard’s chessboard on the sofa with a loud huff. Sirius went off to shower while James finished the patrol report at the desk.
Scarlett sat on the sofa beside Peter, resting her elbow on the back as she watched him place each piece meticulously, perfectly aligned.
“You know you can say no, right?” she whispered. Peter raised an eyebrow, and she nodded towards James. “About the costume.”
The boy exhaled and deflated, scratching the back of his neck as he opened his mouth. His eyelids fluttered, but he said nothing, turning his attention back to the ivory pieces gleaming under the incandescent ceiling lights.
“It’s fine,” he mumbled, polishing the top of a pawn with his thumb. “I don’t mind going as R2-D2.”
“That’s the point, Pete. You should mind…”
“You don’t get it, Scar. You came here too late…” He rubbed his small, tear-brimmed eyes with his knuckles.
“What do you mean by that?” Though Scarlett tried to keep her tone calm, the question came out sharper than she intended.
Peter shrank back.
“Nothing, forget it…” He fixed his focus on that stupid game again, making her sigh loudly.
“Got the cloak, Prongs?” Sirius emerged from the corridor, crossing past the instruments with his hair still wet.
“Yes, Mr Padfoot,” James replied without looking up from his notes.
“You’re going to the Shrieking Shack?” Scarlett straightened, staring at her boyfriend, who raised his eyebrows at the question.
“It’s the full moon, Scar,” Peter confirmed, admiring his set-up board.
She rose from the sofa, rubbing the gloved hand with the Signet, shifting her weight from one foot to the other.
“Then I’m going too,” she decided. “Remus said I could, and he confirmed it again before he started feeling sick… he told me how you could get us in—”
“No, you’re not.” Sirius cut her off, his tone sharp and unyielding. “You’re staying here. Peter’s staying with you.”
“What?!” Scar and Pete protested in unison.
Though he seemed just as reluctant as his friend, Scarlett was far more so. She folded her arms, scorching her boyfriend with her glare.
“This is for your own safety, Scar,” he explained, leaving no room for argument. “Moony’s been really restless lately. I don’t want to put you in danger.”
Scarlett laughed — that cold, sarcastic laugh she always gave when someone told her no.
“I didn’t ask you to protect me, Sirius.”
Sirius stepped closer, the lights catching the silver in his eyes until they burned gold.
“I’m your boyfriend, Scarlett. It’s part of my duty,” he said, in that tone that refused contradiction.
Scarlett’s laugh turned sharp and cutting in the way that always made Sirius’s chest tighten.
“What’s so funny?” The question came out more like a demand on his irritated lips. Scarlett stopped laughing at once. She turned her face away, letting the shadows cast by her hair fall across her cheeks.
“Nothing,” she murmured, flatly.
“No, go on — say it.” Sirius pressed, frustration carving lines into his face. “Say it to my face.”
Scarlett lifted her gaze to him, her blue irises speckled with the light from the gallery ceiling — like floating lanterns in the sky, each carrying a different kind of sorrow.
“I said it’s nothing.” She wet her lips, ready to continue, then changed her mind.
Sirius drew a deep, steadying breath and took another step towards her, his hands finding her narrow waist.
“Scar… I don’t know how Moony’s going to be, alright? I just… I don’t want to put you in danger. Not more than you already do yourself.” The last words came out bitterly.
Ah, saying that was like tossing a match into gunpowder. The effect was instant: Scarlett’s eyes narrowed, her nostrils flared, her fists clenched, and her chin rose as she stared him down, her irises trembling with tears.
“I only went for a swim!” she shouted, her voice echoing off the gallery walls.
Sirius tried to pull her into his arms, but Scarlett slipped away from him quickly, wiping her tears on the sleeve of her Slytherin cloak. He made a move to approach again, but a single wave of her hand stopped him.
“Just… go, Sirius.” She dropped onto the sofa, covering her face with her hands. “Remus needs you.”
Sirius merely exhaled, long and heavy.
“Peter, keep an eye on her,” he said as he climbed the stairs. “Stay here, both of you!”
He and James ducked under the Invisibility Cloak and left.
The silence that followed was muffled only by the crackle of the fire and the faint clinking of the chains holding the ceiling lamps. Scarlett remained on the sofa for a while longer, swallowing back the urge to cry. Then she lowered her hands from her face and stared at the floor.
“You can go too,” she said, without looking at him. “I’ll stay here.”
“Scar… a-are you sure?” Peter blinked, surprised.
Scarlett lifted her face and met his eyes, nodding once.
“Go on, then.”
.
.
.
That full-moon night, Regulus Arcturus Black had been assigned to patrol the Astronomy Tower. It was the favourite spot for Hogwarts couples — often used for dinners, dates, or, for the bolder ones like his brother, shagging. Yet whenever it was him on patrol, no one dared set foot there, especially not on the open terrace.
With his transfigured copy of Crime and Punishment in hand, he climbed the spiral staircase all the way to where Astronomy lessons were held. He crossed through the desks, star maps and armillary spheres until he reached the telescopes in the open area. Above him, the full moon was drifting away from the mountains that framed it, as if searching for something distant, beyond — the deep darkness of the infinite universe, searching…
Regulus’s gaze followed the silver rays spilling generously across the terrace, gleaming off the brass of the telescopes, the polished stone floor — and the dark hair of a girl dangerously seated on the rounded edge of one of the parapets.
She, too, was staring at the moon — clear as crystal, solemn, as though the sky itself were part of her realm and mere earthbound mortals her subjects.
Regulus swallowed hard. He knew very well who that girl was — headphones on, cloak billowing in the night breeze. He walked slowly, fearing she might fall if he made any sudden move. He leaned on the balustrade beside her, resting his elbows on the cold stone.
Scarlett didn’t look at him. She seemed far too entranced by the celestial body to divide her attention, bathed in that ethereal light which paled her freckled face even more, brushed across her lashes, and turned her ocean-blue eyes into pools of pure platinum.
Something strange coiled itself around Regulus’s heart, quickening its beat and making his hands tingle. Scarlett blinked slowly, twisted her lips, and — discreetly — slid her gaze toward him. It was a fleeting movement, yet to him it felt like it lasted an eternity. He drank in the defined curve of her lashes, the subtle sheen of her lips, the delicate heart-shape of her face.
What was this thing that blew all his worries away, summoning a hazy latency that dulled his reactions and stirred his darker thoughts?
“You’re not taking more points off Slytherin, are you? I already lost fifteen last week…” She pushed one earphone aside, her dark hair floating about her cheeks like shadows dancing in the moonlight.
“No.” The word escaped him before he could think. It was as though he’d lost the ability to do so. He swallowed hard, clearing his throat and loosening his tie against the sudden tightness. “I thought… I thought you’d be with them. For the full moon…”
Scarlett’s serene expression darkened under a melancholy that Red couldn’t quite grasp. She pressed her lips together and drew in her shoulders, her gaze slipping down to the Walkman resting in her lap.
“Yeah… me too.” She stretched her mouth into an empty smile.
Something odd stirred in his blood at that, as though Scarlett’s discontent were somehow his own. As if she…
“What happened?” Regulus asked bluntly.
He didn’t need to measure his words.
Scarlett exhaled slowly through her nose, shaking her head as if she didn’t want to talk about it. Her irises flickered, catching something deep within his chest. He couldn’t name it, but he didn’t care to. Scarlett was so easy to read, so utterly sincere with her feelings that he felt undeserving of her presence. Of her trust.
Of her gaze.
“Did Sirius do something?” he pressed.
The autumn breeze whistled between them, prompting Scarlett to tuck a handful of strands behind her ear.
“He’s upset because… according to him… I put myself in danger unnecessarily.” She rolled her beautiful eyes, placing both hands on the ledge of the parapet.
“Well… he’s not entirely wrong,” Regulus remarked, frowning as he emphasised the fact that she was sitting right on the ledge.
Scarlett let out a nasal laugh.
“I can’t believe you — you — just said your brother’s right!” She nudged him lightly with her elbow.
“That’s not what I said, Scar.” Red leaned away from her, only to drift back moments later. “Is that why you’re sitting up here? To prove him wrong?”
“Precisely, Mr Black.” She swung her legs. “Ah, I love this song…” She closed her eyes.
“What song?” He looked again at the Walkman, as if he could somehow guess what was playing.
Scarlett, however, removed the headphones and placed them over his ears. The melody instantly numbed his pretence and peeled away his composure, dragging him into a place where he couldn’t feel nothing because he felt everything.
[Music: David Bowie — Lady Grinning Soul]
Regulus Black felt his lips curling against his will. He watched the girl before him — Scarlett wasn’t the most beautiful of women, but she wasn’t plain either. She had fine features, a pale face sprinkled with freckles, and there was an air of command in her expression — something lurking at the corners of her mouth, in the shape of her cheekbones, the edge of her eyes.
She’ll come, she’ll go
She’ll lay belief on you
Skin sweet with musky odour
The lady from another grinning soul
Her straight hair was of a colour that didn’t normally attract him, and her sharp, rough-edged personality would have driven him away like the devil from the cross. So why was he there, arm brushing against hers, listening to that stupid Muggle song and staring at her so intently?
The stars swayed in Scarlett’s eyes like flowers stirred by the wind. Regulus noticed — almost by accident — the faint trace of green near her pupils. His heart reacted at once, as though its strings were being tugged by Scarlett’s slender fingers. As though she were lifting him gently in her warm palms.
The image of Scarlett before him slowly began to fade as the moon hid deep within the breast of a cloud. Darkness enveloped them.
And when the clothes are strewn
Don't be afraid of the room
Touch the fullness of her breast
Feel the love of her caress
She will be your living end
Regulus pulled her into his arms.
Scarlett returned the embrace, resting her chin atop his head. Red’s ear was pressed to her chest, listening to the serene rhythm of her heartbeat, so unlike the wild disorder of his own.
How many times had Sirius broken Scarlett’s heart? He didn’t know — but he could hear the cracks with every throb. Oh, if only he could, he would steal Scarlett’s heart away and mend every wound his brother had inflicted. Not that he was a saint — Regulus knew very well the things he’d done to her — but none of them, not a single one, were as harmful as Sirius’s mere existence.
At least, not as far as she knew.
Still, Regulus listened to that heart beating, nestled within Scarlett’s chest as snugly as he was — like a bird settling into its home.
She'll come, she'll go
She'll lay belief on you
But she won't stake her life on you
How can life become her point of view
He lifted his gaze to her. Even in the piercing darkness, Red could see that her eyes were closed, tears tumbling from her lashes like the falling stars above them.
“I miss them so much…” she said, though he didn’t truly hear the words. He didn’t need to. It was all written across her face. “I don’t know what to do.”
And when the clothes are strewn
Don’t be afraid of the room
Touch the fullness of her breast
Feel the love of her caress
Regulus’s ribs clenched around his heart, as though yearning to drive their sharp tips into the decaying flesh and bleed him dry from within. His fingers gripped tightly at Scarlett’s billowing cloak, his eyes dropping to her pink lips.
What did her lips taste like? He had kissed her once before, long ago — but he hadn’t had the chance to savour it. Scarlett had been too quick to trick him. But now, beneath the stars…
What was it that drew Sirius to her? Was it that unsettling green glimmer in her eyes, those misty pupils, or that intoxicating aura around her? Regulus couldn’t say — only that, before he knew it, it was already too late. He was imprisoned in those ocean eyes, drowning in their violent tide, dragged down to die at the bottom of the sea.
She will be your living end
She will be your living end
She will be your living end
She will be your living end
She will be your living
And Regulus died. Regulus Black died in those eyes as one who inhales saltwater, lets the lungs burn and the limbs thrash — one who accepts death, unlike the body that still fights to live. He wanted to tell her he’d never make her cry, not the way Sirius would, but that he could never love her the way Sirius did either. He didn’t know love — and he couldn’t allow the prophecy to come true.
He couldn’t allow the existence of a Black of the Signet.
So he fantasised, imagining his lips converging with Scarlett Gaunt’s — his tongue exploring her mouth, stealing every promise she’d ever made to his brother and claiming them for himself. He’d pull her close, lift her from the parapet, pin her body to the ground beneath his own. He’d fill her ear with meaningless vows, squeeze her firm breasts in his hands and slide down to the little place that had so enthralled his brother it had turned him into nothing but a loyal little dog.
Regulus Black would never bend to Scarlett the way Sirius did; on the contrary, he would subdue her to his will, parade her at pure-blood soirées, and use her as a shield against the Dark Lord.
Scarlett had no idea how much happier she’d be with him.
But that would never happen. It was out of the question. Sirius would never let Scarlett go, and Regulus — well, he might’ve been many things, but stupid wasn’t one of them. To give in to his masculine impulses as his brother so often did would only drive her further away. So he broke the embrace suddenly, pushing Scarlett aside.
Scarlett — who was sitting on the bloody parapet.
The moon emerged once more from its corridor of clouds, solemn and majestic, dissolving the shadows with its silver curtains of light.
“Regulus!” she cried, flinging out her arms and seizing his shoulders. “Regulus, I… I’m going to fall!”
Red’s eyes widened as he filled his lungs with air, hands groping for her and pulling her instantly back onto the safety of the terrace. She bent forward, breathing fast, one hand pressed against her pounding heart.
“Bloody hell… bloody hell… fuck…” Her trembling voice betrayed the fright.
Regulus barely noticed the headphones slipping down to his neck.
“Are you alright?” he asked, his tone neutral, though his body shook at the thought that he’d almost — almost — thrown her from the Astronomy Tower. His gaze fixed unavoidably on his trembling hands, their pale, sweaty palms the evidence of his near-crime.
“Bloody hell… turns out Sirius was right, wasn’t he?” Scarlett straightened up, still shaken, but her lips curved into a smile.
Regulus didn’t move his mouth, but his iron-grey eyes smiled.
“Ah… if he finds out… he’s going to kill me…” she sniffled, drying her face by rubbing it against her shoulder.
“I won’t tell him,” Red said — no filter, no thought. Why was he even saying that?
Scarlett let out a nervous laugh and nodded, shaking her head. Was she suspicious of him again?
“Did you… did you like it? The song?”
It was one of those rare moments when Regulus hesitated. He hadn’t expected the question, and so he remained silent for a moment. The moon’s bright gleam above them deepened the shadows that hid in the corners of his lips, beneath his eyes, and in the depths of his heart.
Scarlett wondered if he’d even understood her.
“I did,” he said honestly, feeling his face flush.
He wasn’t talking about the song.
“Yeah, David Bowie’s… he’s brilliant,” she remarked, watching him slip the headphones from his neck. “You’ve never listened to Muggle music before?”
Regulus blinked a few times and shook his head. He was far more concerned with dissecting Scarlett — wondering if she blamed him for what had just happened. If she did, she didn’t show it. She merely looped the headphones back around her neck and pressed a button on the Walkman.
“Remember Sirius’s costume last Halloween? That was him — David Bowie, from the album cover of this song. He’s a British legend…”
Whatever Scarlett said after that didn’t reach Regulus’s ears. All he could do was watch the way she so carefully folded the melancholy that haunted her and tucked it back into her heart as though it were something precious. As though she needed to feel sad now and then, to remember what she’d lost — and keep the guilt from devouring her whole.
“I should… I should escort you back to the Undercroft,” Regulus cut in. “If Sirius gets back and finds you’re not there… he’ll worry.”
The spark of excitement that had once lit Scarlett’s eyes quickly dimmed. She simply nodded, glancing sideways — first at the parapet, then at him.
Regulus clenched his jaw at the thought she might believe he’d pushed her rather than that she’d lost her balance. Because clearly, it had been her fault — she was the one who’d made him lose balance.
Luckily — or perhaps not — she stayed silent the entire walk back to the Undercroft.
.
.
.
Sirius had already planned out most of his day — leaf through the three hundred bloody documents Shacklebolt had dumped on him about everything concerning Scarlett, then she’d show up, they’d shag, and fall asleep naked and tangled together as they always did.
As it always should be.
That day was meant to be a good one… according to his plan.
Everything, of course, went to hell the moment Tonks invited June to lunch without warning him — and, naturally, brought her boyfriend along. Orfy. Not that their friendship bothered him — they’d studied together at Hogwarts, apparently unravelling some nonsense about “Cursed Vaults” (he’d been far too drunk to properly process that story when she’d told it one night) — but for fuck’s sake!
Tonks was his partner in the exams. June’s partner was… well, he didn’t know, but surely someone irrelevant! Either way, Sirius only wanted to have a quiet chat with his cousin without Orfy and June there. With all due respect, he loved the bloke — but bloody hell!
He just wanted that lunch to end.
Instead, it dragged on for hours — especially since Orfy and Tonks had started a ridiculous contest to see who could drink more, leaving him and June stuck trying to talk them out of it.
Sirius was fairly certain Tom would throw them out of the pub any minute now.
“So… Siiiirius…” Orfeu sing-songed, his freckled cheeks as flushed as his sister’s and his green eyes sparkling with amusement. “You’re living with James’s kid? Reggie told me.”
Tonks and June turned towards him.
“Harry’s at your place?” Orfy’s girlfriend looked surprised.
“You know him?” Sirius frowned, stopping Tonks from downing yet another Butterbeer by catching her wrist.
“Yeah, he started Hogwarts in my last year. Back in ’92, my mates and I helped Hagrid smuggle a dragon to the dragon sanctuary in Romania… good lad, Harry Potter…” she said — a bit tipsy, though not quite as much as Orfeu or his cousin.
“Oh, Sssirius… stop being sso uptight…” Tonks burped, clapping a hand over her mouth. Her hair shifted from violent purple to blinding green. “I think I’m gonna— gonna puke.”
“You are not going to puke!” Sirius snapped, disgust plain on his face. “Wait — what d’you mean, Hagrid had a dragon? And why didn’t you tell me you’d gone to school with Harry before?”
“W-well… I didn’t really talk to him much…” June shrugged, brushing it off.
“I, for one, never even spoke to him… though I wanted to. Hearing Reggie’s stories about him was… enough.” Orfeu spoke slowly, blinking languidly.
“Why not?” Sirius leaned his elbows on the table, a familiar tug pulling at his chest. He glanced quickly over his shoulder, but the pub was packed — too crowded to spot anyone.
“Dumbledore.” Orfeu leaned back in his chair, crossing one leg over the other. “He never… let any of us… get close to him…” His lips twisted slightly. “Me… Rem… Nate… no one… from the past. That’s why… why Reg’s a year ahead. The only advanced student… in Hogwarts…”
“What do you mean?” Sirius asked, deliberately ignoring Tonks’s retching.
Why had Dumbledore gone to such lengths to keep everyone away from Harry?
“He said it was for the best… so the boy wouldn’t grow up arrogant…” Orfeu rolled his eyes, as if the very idea was absurd. Sirius shared the sentiment.
“That… that doesn’t make any sense,” he muttered, his mind racing with everything he’d witnessed from Dumbledore in recent days.
His insistence on supervising Scarlett, forbidding Harry from spending the summer with him, that piercing look he’d given earlier when they’d discussed her contact with his godson… what was that old man hiding? Dumbledore had always been secretive when it came to Voldemort — at least, that was how Sirius remembered him during the Wizarding War. Yet, in this case, his concern over Scarlett’s recklessness almost seemed justified.
After all, showing up at their house skidding about in a sports car wasn’t exactly the behaviour of someone trying to stay hidden. He’d even managed to get his hands on some very illegal materials to create a fixed portal between a garage near Scarlett’s workplace and theirs. It was safe — only she had access — and perfectly inconspicuous, since no one would see her turning up at four in the morning in her Honda NSX.
Still, there had been something in Dumbledore’s eyes that unsettled him deeply.
Sirius was yanked from his thoughts when Nymphadora Tonks vomited on her own feet.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 69: Love will tear us apart... again
Chapter Text
CXXXVII
The Hanged Man was packed that morning. Which was good, because Scarlett wasn’t capable of brooding over the discovery about James and Lily… and bad, because she was aching to. To open up, to try and explain, to say why she’d done it all… so they could understand her.
At the same time, she tried not to be shaken by what Regulus had told her. It wasn’t true. Sirius wasn’t the same as before—he’d changed, hadn’t he? He’d become an infinitely more mature version of the boy she’d once dated… hadn’t he?
When her break came, she leaned against the alley wall by one of the bar’s exits and exhaled deeply to calm herself. It didn’t work. She stared at her trembling hands, her pale fingers, the ring Sirius had given her glinting beneath the fine drizzle that insisted on falling that morning. Her gaze drifted far, very far, as if searching for a star among the cars and pedestrians moving through the heart of the city.
Scarlett checked her pocket watch.
"Why d’you carry that old thing around?!" Danny’s question made her jump sideways in fright. "Don’t you have a wristwatch?"
"It’s a family relic, you nosy git," she muttered, watching him take a huge bite out of a double-cheese sandwich.
"How’s your boyfriend?" Wiping the corner of his mouth with his thumb, Danny flashed a grin at the bewildered look Scarlett shot him. "Mike already told me everything…"
"Mike’s a bloody liar," she cut him off, folding her arms and pressing her lips together. "Sirius and I are not dating."
"I never said he was your boyfriend." Danny showed a teasing grin that Scarlett nearly wiped off his face with a punch. "Alright, alright, relax, Star—just having a laugh…" He went back to his lunch, which made her drop the idea.
"Think you could cover my shift this afternoon? I’ve got something to sort out… I’ll cover yours tomorrow." She offered, rubbing the back of her hand where the Signet was hidden by a charm.
Danny chewed, chewed, and chewed as if the answer were terribly hard to figure out. Then he swallowed, gave her a huge smile, and tilted his head towards her, looking at her with such easy warmth that she couldn’t help but smile back.
"Sure, no problem." He tossed the wrapper into a bin. "But only if you invite your boyfriend to one of our gigs. He plays drums, doesn’t he?"
"Not a chance." Scarlett pushed herself off the wall.
"Just to watch us play…"
"Not bloody likely."
"It’d be fun! You could even tell him we’re opening for Pearl Jam…"
"He’s not my boyfriend, I’m not inviting him to anything of ours, and I’m not going on the bloody tour! End of story." She brushed off his arguments with a casual wave. "Now, you’re covering me today, and I’ll cover you tomorrow."
Danny grunted in dissatisfaction but merely shrugged. It wasn’t as if he had much of a choice.
.
.
.
Voices, chairs scraping, cutlery clinking. Whiskers sniffed the air instinctively, catching the delicious scent of herring pie, butterbeer, and chocolate mousse. Sweat, excitement, and deodorant well past its expiry date. Which made sense, seeing as it was summer. She kept walking, her heart drawn towards a specific spot in the pub. Her blue eyes swept across the room, lingering on the quiet man. A sweet perfume, laced with tobacco and leather, teased her senses, pricked her ears, and made the fur along her spine stand on end.
Whiskers wanted to take a step forward but stayed still, drinking in more notes: Orfeu’s woody scent, Tonks’s spicy perfume, and the fresh fragrance of yet another woman with them. The same one who’d been there on Mike’s birthday, the day she’d come here, when Sirius…
She crouched at the feet of a witch with stinking boots. Sirius was standing, holding by the shoulders that girl who was always far too close to him. Whiskers wrinkled her nose at the foul stench of vomit, but her eyes were far too busy watching Sirius to notice anything else.
Sirius Black was the sun, after all—blinding everything around him, burning anyone who got too close, and pulling Whiskers towards him as though gravity itself had gathered in his body alone. She dug her claws into the stone floor in an effort to resist, her slit pupils widening as he practically carried Tonks out of the bar.
Whiskers followed them, darted out through the side exit, and peered into the alley, cloaked in the shadows cast by the restaurant building, whose windows gleamed with sunlight spilling across Diagon Alley.
Tonks was on her knees. Sirius ran a hand down her back in a slower rhythm than Whiskers cared to admit. His ringed fingers stroked the maroon fabric of her cloak; the other hand caressed the spiky hair that ran through every colour in the spectrum.
Whiskers felt her fur bristle, her stomach burn, and her claws snap out of her tiny paws as though she were in danger. She hissed softly, shrinking back, feeling that tug in her chest towards Sirius, whose face turned slowly over his shoulder. The cat flattened herself against the pub wall, pressing into the languid darkness to hide.
Sirius turned back to Tonks, who spat out another gush of food onto the pavement. Whiskers heard a sound coming their way; her ears pricked up, swivelling like satellite dishes catching a signal.
"I’m taking you home." That tone in Sirius’s voice didn’t please her one bit.
"I can… go back… by Floo…" she managed between gasps.
He gave one of his trademark snorts of disbelief.
"You can barely stand, Nymphadora," Sirius spat the words with disdain. "I’m not letting you get home in that state."
Nymphadora Tonks. Where had she heard that awful name before?
She might have sought help from her ghosts if they weren’t furiously arguing somewhere nearby about the events of the Wizarding War. She could almost hear James’s irritable voice echoing down the walls of an empty corridor.
It was rare to see her friend in such a state.
"Oh, right… and you think… you’re going to get a taxi and… take me home?! You know… that I live… in…" She took a few deep breaths before finishing, "Devon…?"
"I’ll take you on the bike." The suggestion came so quickly that both Whiskers and Tonks took a moment to process what he’d said.
"Don’t be… an idiot, Sirius." Tonks rested her head on his shoulder. "It’ll take about… four hours…"
Whiskers flicked her tail irritably. Sirius had never invited her to ride the motorbike since Azkaban. Thinking about it made her heart skip a few beats.
"That’s why we’ll be flying," he said, rising and pulling Tonks up with him. "Here, drink this." He pulled a potion from his pocket.
Whiskers heard Tonks click her tongue but say nothing as she sipped the Sobering Potion. Sirius also handed her a handkerchief, which she used to wipe her face. Despite the girl’s serious expression, she soon smiled — which made Sirius smile too.
His dimpled smile.
Whiskers felt her body freeze as if she’d just been thrown into an icy lake. The cold climbed across her skin, seeped into her flesh, and reached her bones. Translucent icicles stabbed through her heart.
She didn’t dare stay to see the rest — she couldn’t bear it. At least, she thought she couldn’t. Besides, it wasn’t as though she had any right to feel anything. Sirius was a free man. She had no claim to anything.
How she left Diagon Alley, she couldn’t recall. It was as though, in the very next instant, all that pain was being poured into her synthesiser on the stage of some pub in Putney. She’d lost count of the glasses the waiter kept leaving in the narrow space beside the synth panel, between knobs and switchers.
At first, he’d ask: whisky, wine, gin, or rum?
Scarlett merely shrugged. What difference did it make? Alcohol was alcohol. So she downed the amber, the ruby, the crystal, and the golden — one after another — until her vision blurred and the stage lights blinded her to the crowd. She felt Danny tug her up so they could take their bow, the encore reverberating through her body with the same force as the audience’s cheers.
She couldn’t even remember which songs they’d played. Mike was counting the beat before striking the drums, and she was already fingering the keys without realising it. From Fleetwood Mac to Journey, The Cure to Tears for Fears — Merlin, they’d even played Joy Division.
Perhaps that was why she felt so wretchedly melancholic on her way home.
Well, it did make perfect sense that Ian Curtis had downed a handful of pills after writing one of the most depressing songs she’d ever heard in her life—it was so bleak it reminded her of Azkaban.
Scarlett switched the radio six times, played through the entire A-ha tape that was in the car, pulled it out and replaced it with one from Heart, then slid in a New Order cassette. When the light turned red, she stared for a long moment at the Joy Division case lying on the passenger seat.
Who the hell had left that shit there?
Argh, must’ve been Lenny. Or Mike. Or Danny.
Who the fuck had been in her car earlier, anyway?
She hadn’t a clue.
She shifted into first gear and crawled up the garage ramp slowly, careful not to rev the engine and wake anyone. Turning the ignition off, she climbed out, staggering a little, blinking hard when she noticed a bin knocked over in the middle of the street. That definitely wasn’t her doing. Gripping the handrail, she hauled herself up the steps, fumbling for the doorknob until her fingers found and turned it.
The foyer was dark, but a faint glow spilled from the sitting room beyond. She stopped, patting her shoulders to shrug off her red leather jacket—except she wasn’t wearing it. It was summer, of course she wasn’t, but it still felt wrong to walk through the place without leaving a piece of clothing behind. So she banged her head lightly against the wall while untying her combat boots, kicked them into a corner, and let out a laugh before staggering into the living room.
The electronic music from Mega Man X hammered through her skull as she paused to steady herself. Harry and Regulus were playing on the Super Nintendo, sitting on the floor, while Sirius lounged behind them on the sofa, a stack of open folders spread across his lap. His eyes were fixed on the boys, but he looked up when he noticed her there. A smile tugged at his lips, though he kept his expression stern.
"Hellooo…" Scarlett tried to sound casual, approaching clumsily.
Both boys turned their heads at once, the sound of explosions from the game filling the heavy silence radiating from Sirius. Regulus frowned, and Harry smiled.
"Mum… you alright?" he asked, setting his controller on the floor.
Scarlett burst into a loud laugh, bracing her hands on the arm of the sofa—but tripped and fell backwards, her head landing squarely in Sirius’s lap, knocking most of the folders to the floor.
"I’m great!" she declared, sitting up quickly, ignoring the dizziness that made her sway from side to side. "What’re you lot playing?"
"Mega Man X," Harry replied, getting swept into Scarlett’s arms and receiving a loud kiss on the forehead that made him blush.
"How was the gig?" Reggie crawled over to join them, slipping into the hug.
Sirius set the rest of the folders down on the side table with more force than necessary and stood up, jaw tightening. He switched off the television.
"Bedtime, boys."
Regulus and Harry exchanged glances.
"But we’re in the middle of the level…" Harry protested, pulling away from a kiss-happy Scarlett whose weight he was barely managing to hold up. "We’re almost past the boss!"
"Now," Sirius ordered, though his gaze never left Scarlett.
Harry looked at him, then at her, hesitating. Then he stood, straightened his glasses, and wished both Scarlett and Sirius goodnight. Regulus followed, though it was clear from the worried look in his eyes that he’d sensed something was wrong when he turned to Sirius.
"Goodnight, Uncle," he murmured, grimacing when Scarlett pulled him into another tight hug. "Goodnight, Mum…"
"Goodnight, love…" The alcohol on her breath was the confirmation he’d been looking for.
Regulus disentangled himself and walked slowly towards his room. He cast a sideways glance at the two of them before stepping inside and closing the door softly.
Leaving them alone.
Sirius stared down at his shoes for a few seconds, uncertain what to do. Then, as if struck by a jolt, he straightened and grabbed Scarlett by the arm, practically dragging her towards his room. She didn’t resist—didn’t even try to pretend she was sober—she simply let herself be led.
He slammed the door shut behind them so hard the walls trembled.
She staggered to the bed and threw herself onto the mattress, making it creak.
"You’re drunk. Again. Why?" Sirius crossed his arms and leaned against the door.
Scarlett huffed, trying to come up with something terribly clever that would prove him wrong—but what could she say? There wasn’t a spell in the world that could purge the alcohol from her blood and bring her back to sobriety. She avoided his gaze, staring instead at the ceiling covered in faintly glowing star stickers. Though the light was on, they still shimmered softly.
"Because… it makes me feel good," she said truthfully.
Sirius sighed, running a hand through his long loose hair. It slid over his bare shoulders beneath the vest he wore, over the tattoos on his chest, over the exhaustion etched into his features.
"Alcohol’s a depressant, Scarlett. It makes you feel good now and then drags you straight to hell."
"I’m fine!" she insisted, her voice several tones higher than usual, shrugging as if it were nothing.
Sirius let out a bitter laugh, shaking his head in disapproval.
"You wouldn’t be if I told you to sleep on the sofa."
Scarlett looked at him for a moment, then laughed—a hollow, embarrassed hiss of a sound.
"This has to stop, Scarlett." He went on, pushing himself away from the door, which creaked from the sudden release of pressure.
"I’ll stop," she muttered, rolling her eyes as if it were the easiest thing in the world.
"You won’t," he whispered calmly, sitting down on the edge of the bed.
"I will, I already said I will!" she insisted, rubbing her face so hard that her cheeks turned even redder than they already were.
"You won’t. I’ve been there, Scar, and that’s not how it works." He lifted his gaze to her.
"You and I aren’t that much alike, Sirius," Scarlett shot back with a hint of disdain.
For a moment, Sirius’s only answer was silence. Scarlett could hear her own heartbeat; she felt it thundering in her chest, pounding through her veins, buzzing in her ears. Her fingers trembled with each rapid pulse.
"We are," Sirius murmured—"more than I’d like to admit." His words were barely audible, yet they made her heart gallop wildly, like a stallion across scorched grass. There was sorrow in his tone.
And understanding, too.
Scarlett bit her lower lip. The image of Sirius before her rippled as tears stung her eyes. She blinked hard, rubbing them away with her knuckles, hoping shame would finish the job. But nothing burned through her chest like erupting lava. It was as if she couldn’t feel shame at all, as though the feeling had been dissolved—pulverised—by the alcohol.
Something else took its place. Heavy as lead, tasting of rust, it made her clutch her stomach as though she might vomit. The crying filled her mouth and her eyes, and the lightness of the alcohol turned into unbearable weight.
"Do you want to take a bath?" Sirius’s question drifted through her mind, lashing against the walls of her consciousness and echoing regret deep within her core.
"No." She didn’t even know how she’d managed to answer.
She rolled slowly onto her side, curling her knees to her chest. The sheets coiled around her like waves, swallowing her whole and dragging her down into the depths of the ocean—into that desolate, dark, crushing place inside herself. It was peaceful there, because there were no nightmares, no memories, no relief… but there were fingers. So many fingers pointed at her, their nails painted in so many colours she didn’t know which to look at first.
Was it the black one with little stars, accusing her of having stolen his dream? Or the one painted orange, blaming her for being such a fucking coward? Perhaps it was the whole hand—reaching for her, shouting, desperate to make her face her demons, her trauma, her yearning—so she could finally live.
All she did was shrink away and ignore them. They’d get tired eventually, she told herself. Or she’d drown. Or better yet—she’d swim back to the surface and leave it all behind.
A ridiculous, utopian idea. Scarlett Gaunt was a hoarder — she would never let anything, absolutely anything, slip away. She would use every single thing that offended her to sharpen her own self-judgement until all that remained of her was regret.
Then, a tattooed hand seized her and hauled her out of the current — out of the tide and the foam of waves crashing against her. Sirius tore the sheet from her face with roughness. Not out of anger, but because Scarlett was gripping the fabric too tightly.
"Here, Scarlett." The light above them caught on the potion bottle and stung her eyes, forcing her to squint. She licked her lips and parted them slightly, her trembling hand reaching for the glass, but Sirius was quicker, tipping the liquid into her mouth himself.
It tasted bittersweet, like some tropical fruit, and she shut her eyes, taking a deep breath and letting her head sink into the pillow as her neck relaxed.
"I know why you’re doing this… because I did the same once, didn’t I!?" Jealousy took control of her mouth, tingling in her throat, vibrating through her vocal cords.
Sirius clenched his jaw at the rhetorical question, pressing his lips together so tightly they vanished beneath his beard.
"You’d better sleep before you say something you’ll regret," he warned.
"I just wanted to get rid of the guilt for a while… like you used to." Her voice was slurred. When she noticed Sirius wasn’t answering, she went on, "Do you still love me? You said you did — remember!?"
She heard him exhale slowly through his mouth, then circle the bed to lie down beside her.
"It’s too late, Sirius," she murmured now, her voice dragging. "There’s no going back from love."
"That’s your problem, Scarlett." He ignored her provocations, speaking with that infuriating calm that always got under her skin. "If we felt guilty for every mistake we’ve made… guilt’s all we’d have left."
"What’s that supposed to mean?" she challenged, though her tone carried a hint of fear.
"That drinking to numb your guilt won’t fix it. It’ll make it worse." He paused, reaching to switch off the light. The stars on the ceiling glowed to life, and his gaze followed the constellations mapped out above them. "And by the time you realise it, it’ll be too late. You’ll have lost the person you love most."
He swallowed hard and shut his eyes, feeling her curl into his waist as though seeking some kind of safety.
"You drove drunk again…"
"Argh, I had to get home!" she tried to sound assertive, but failed.
"Home? So this is your home?" Sirius wanted desperately to stay angry with her, but his lips were quick to betray him.
Scarlett’s expression twisted as she shook her head, her face pressed to his abdomen.
"You," she growled, climbing over him and burying herself in his warmth until she reached his heart. "You are my home, Sirius Black."
That disarmed him completely. Sirius could feel Scarlett’s body pressed against his, the alcohol on her breath, the haze in her gaze. Everything about her was hypnotic, captivating, sedating. From the flush on her cheeks to the warmth of her skin; the sweat on her body and the weariness in her eyelids. Everything about Scarlett held him captive—because she was his home too.
And Sirius might have been lying there with her, breathing in the lingering vanilla scent of her hair and tracing the base of her spine through her shirt—but his soul was on its knees.
He didn’t know whether Scarlett Gaunt was the weight on his shoulders forcing him to kneel or the refuge keeping him from collapsing altogether.
Why not both?
He wanted her, and he wished he didn’t.
"I remember," he murmured, though Scarlett was already asleep. "You said you loved me too."
Love’s a bloody curse, Sirius. It makes your head relive what your heart can’t forget.
Sirius Black fell asleep holding the woman who was both his sorrow and his love.
.
.
.
Scarlett buried her face in her hands. Her head throbbed as though Mike were battering it with his drumsticks. She turned onto her side, feeling the sheet against her skin—warm and soft.
Too warm. Too soft.
Frowning, Scar slowly lifted her head and realised it was Sirius lying beside her, his back turned, the tattoos shifting as his chest rose and fell in peaceful rhythm. Scarlett’s eyes found the strawberry on his back, the ink still vivid as if freshly drawn. Then they slid to the constellation of Sagittarius, following the tiny stars scattered among others—symbols and words she couldn’t quite decipher.
She pushed herself up slightly, careful not to rest her arms on Sirius’s hair, which was spread across the pillow, and studied his relaxed expression. Then she lay back down, massaging her temples. What had happened last night? She tried to fish out any fragment of memory, but they slipped away before she could catch them. Only disjointed flashes passed through her mind: the bar, laughter, music and… nothing.
She barely noticed Sirius had got up until the sound of the bathroom door closing startled her out of her daze. Sitting up in bed, Scarlett took long gulps from the glass of water on the bedside table, hoping the liquid might clear her head.
The bathroom door opened with a click, and Sirius came out, his black hair tied back in that careless bun. He was still shirtless. He didn’t even glance at her—just walked to the wardrobe and stared, for a long time, at the neat row of shirts before him.
"What did I do last night?" Her voice was hoarse and weary.
Sirius pushed one T-shirt aside, then another, before finally deciding to toss one over his shoulder. He was still avoiding eye contact.
"You came home completely pissed. Scared the hell out of Reggie and Harry. I put you to bed before you could do something stupid." He drew a deep breath, slowly turning until he finally looked at her. There was a shadow of strain etched into every line of his face. "What are you doing, Scarlett?"
Her eyes widened slightly. She hadn’t expected such a direct question from him—not when her head felt like it had been crushed in a mill. Thinking hurt, even existing hurt, though not as much as the silence stretching between them: the disappointment colouring Sirius’s eyes, the frustration striking straight through her chest.
"I… I don’t know," she sighed. "I think… I’m just waiting for you to save me."
Sirius closed his eyes, rubbing them with his thumb and forefinger as if he could wipe away the sight of Scarlett before him, erase her and all the mess she carried along.
"Only you can save yourself, Scarlett." He stepped to the dresser beside the bed, took a small vial of potion, and handed it to her. "This can’t go on."
Scarlett wanted so badly to list the reasons she’d ended up like that, but she couldn’t think of a single one.
"I’m… sorry," she murmured, holding the cold glass with a trembling hand.
Sirius pulled his shirt over his head and started for the door, then stopped before leaving. He glanced back at her, black hair falling around his pale, disappointed face.
"You’re so much more than this." There was bitterness in his voice—the kind that tried to sound gentle, but no matter how much honey was poured over it, the hurt was far stronger.
Sirius left her alone.
Scarlett stayed there, clutching the chilled vial as daylight crept into the room through the blinds, painting the furniture gold—the carved wooden headboard, the polished bedside tables, the glass of the picture frames. Guilt and shame tried to climb her chest, but she forced them back with each trembling breath. Then she drank the potion and gathered the strength to stand.
In the bathroom, she forced herself to vomit, showered, and brushed her teeth so hard she tasted blood.
Staring into the fogged mirror, the reason for her drunkenness hit her like a punch. Jealousy.
Jealousy of Sirius and Tonks.
She searched for her ghosts with her eyes, but there was no sign of them. What had happened after Lily and James’s discovery?
Her head was a dizzying, exhausting salad.
When she left the room, she found Remus, Reggie, and Harry carrying dead ferrets at the back of the garden, standing before what looked like a glass greenhouse. Scarlett knew that place well—it wasn’t a real greenhouse, though it looked like one from the outside. It was a magical creature aviary: once inside, it would reveal a vast meadow where Buckbeak was likely kept.
The three of them stepped through the door, and Scarlett turned toward the kitchen, sitting down at the small table. Sirius, his back to her, was preparing breakfast at the counter. His movements were restrained, touched with that mannerism inherited from being born into one of the purest families of the Sacred Twenty-Eight. It was ingrained in him, impossible to shake off. It was different when Remus cracked eggs, for instance.
Sirius didn’t just do everything with maddening precision, but also with the grace of someone clearly not made for domestic work—or perhaps it was simply that he was upset, his irritation punctuated each time he struck an egg against the pan’s edge, breaking it entirely. Half fell into the skillet, the other half splattered across the stove.
Muttering curses under his breath, Sirius wordlessly used Evanesco and started over: added two spoonfuls of butter, waited for it to melt, and tried cracking another egg.
Scarlett glanced at the carton. Of thirty eggs, ten were already gone.
"Need a hand?" she asked, her voice fragile.
"No." His reply was curt.
Scarlett sighed, pulling her legs up onto the chair. She hugged her knees, resting her chin on them, watching Sirius as her thoughts spiralled back to the reason for her drinking. What was really going on between him and Tonks?
The kettle whistled, making her flinch upright. Sirius turned it off. He reached across the table for something and, for a brief instant, their eyes met. Scarlett quickly looked away, clearing her throat as a knot formed in her chest.
"Sirius… what are we?"
He froze mid-motion, spatula suspended in the air. Turning his head, he met her gaze.
"We’re a couple. You said that yourself—to Harry."
Scarlett let out a sharp, sarcastic laugh, scratching at her Ouroboros ring with too much force.
"Yeah? Then why don’t you tell that to your pink-haired friend?"
Sirius laughed too—a breathless, incredulous sound.
"So, you’re spying on me now?" He arched a brow, his gaze cutting into her. "You know I can’t tell her that."
Scarlett ignored the weight pressing down on her chest, masking the discomfort with an empty smile.
"I bet you do," she said flatly, standing motionless for a moment. Then, with a sudden movement, she left the chair and came to stand beside him, watching his failed attempts to crack the eggs into the pan. "For Merlin’s sake, Sirius. You have to crack the egg on a flat surface." She grabbed one from the carton and tapped it against the counter, opening it neatly with one hand over a glass bowl. Checking for shell fragments, she poured it into the pan and repeated the motion.
Sirius watched her from the corner of his eye but said nothing. He simply took the spatula and flipped the eggs when the time came. The sizzle of frying and the buttery scent were all that existed between them.
"Why are you following me around?" he asked, eyes still on the pan, pretending to be far too focused to look at her.
"I’m not—I just… wanted to talk to you." Scarlett pursed her lips, the words tumbling out too quickly.
"About what?"
"The talk." She rubbed her fingertips restlessly along the edge of the counter. "About… about everything."
Sirius licked his lips and shook his head.
"That why you came home drunk last night?"
A dreadful silence followed, and the only sign that Scarlett had heard him was the dark, fiery rage that sparked in her eyes.
"Oh, sorry if you were too busy driving Miss Pink-Hair home! Next time, I’ll get in line," she snapped, the serpentine smile curling on her lips just as poisonous as her words. She grabbed another egg, pretending to keep at what she was doing.
"Really!?" Sirius drew his brows together in that infuriatingly arrogant way. "After everything you’ve done, you think you’ve got the right to be jealous of me?!"
Scarlett crushed the egg in her hand, feeling it burst between her fingers—and she had the sickening sense that it wouldn’t be the only thing broken that morning.
"Oh, come on, Sirius — let’s not pretend you didn’t go and betray me the moment I walked out of this house!" Her fury rose inside her as quickly as it flared in him.
"Yeah, I slept with other women!" Sirius admitted, his face flushed purple. "I was trying to forget you—" He scrubbed his face on his shoulder, hard. "But none of them was the one person you hated most in the fucking world!"
"You can’t be serious…" Scarlett’s heart pounded, and then, suddenly, she smiled again—a cruel, cutting smile that made Sirius step back, because he knew what she was about to say, and he was afraid he’d hurt her when he heard it. "Poor Sirius Black! Oh, poor thing. Life’s always so bloody unfair to him!"
Sirius felt his throat tighten, the air thinning in his lungs. He wasn’t sure how he managed to speak—or even breathe—but somehow, the words clawed their way out of him.
"You want to talk to me about injustice?!" Despite his tone, Scarlett felt a chill run down her spine. This wasn’t about Azkaban. No.
It was about Reggie. About Red.
"You had a child!" Sirius went on, confirming her worst suspicion.
"Orfy—"
"Orfy doesn’t justify Reggie!" he snapped, his son’s name tearing through his voice.
Scarlett drew in as much air as her lungs would allow, her ragged breath stuttering in her chest as she roared back,
"IT WAS A BLOODY WAR! WHAT DID YOU EXPECT ME TO DO?!" The fury inside her festered like a spreading plague, gnawing at her fingertips, twisting her stomach, boiling her skin as if she might combust from within.
"Maybe not shag my brother?!" he retorted, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world. "You could’ve fucked any of those Death Eaters—but Regulus…"
Scarlett clenched her fists, fighting the urge to slap the self-righteousness off his face. The heat building in her body was so fierce that beads of sweat rolled down the back of her neck.
"For Merlin’s sake, Sirius, this isn’t about you! My life doesn’t bloody revolve around you!" Her voice splintered into shards.
"You were my fiancée, Scarlett! You knew we had problems—and you were one of them! How am I supposed to forgive you when… when—"
She wiped her trembling hand on her clothes. The sobs pressed against her ribs like a tsunami, tears pooling in her eyes. She didn’t want to cry, but how could she not? She tried to swallow the ache down, and that alone unleashed the words from her throat like arrows:
"When what, Sirius? Go on—say it!"
He raised his gaze to her, defiance trembling in his eyes. He was crying too.
"You gave him everything I ever asked for!" he shouted, fury knotted into every fragment of his face, every syllable of the sentence—from the steel-grey blaze in his eyes to the tears breaking across his cheeks.
That was fifteen years’ worth of bitterness, all at once.
A child. A family. Sirius was so blinded by his resentment toward his brother that he couldn’t see beyond it. Regulus might have been called Red—but he also bore his name. It had been Sirius’s dream she tried to fulfil, believing herself dead, believing she’d never escape Azkaban.
"And judging by your reaction, I’m starting to think I made the right choice," Scarlett shot back, her tone cutting like a whip. Sirius took another step back. "I know what I did to you, Sirius. And I regret it—deeply. But if to you I’ll always be the woman who betrayed you with your brother, then it’s best… it’s best we end this—whatever this is between us. I don’t want to hurt you anymore. I’ve done that enough." The words tore from her like shrapnel. She shut her eyes, pressing a trembling hand to her chest, as if her own heartbeat had become unbearable.
Sirius opened his mouth to respond, to meet her anger with something equal—but nothing came out. He stood there, speechless, though Scarlett waited, her gaze pleading for him to deny her words.
"What would you have done in my place?" A flash of remorse flickered through his eyes, but Sirius held her gaze with such stubborn pride that Scarlett finally loosed the chains of her demons with the same force she expelled the breath from her lungs. Tremors rippled through her body—too strong to contain.
It wasn’t just the sobbing; it was the weight of injustice shackled to her feet, the judgement—spoken and unspoken—the endless suffering she’d endured, the things she’d sacrificed to protect the people she loved. And for what?
No, Sirius Black. Scarlett Gaunt knew far more about injustice than you ever could.
Her blue eyes narrowed until they were nearly closed, and like a river bursting its banks, the tears carved a sordid path down the freckles of her cheeks.
"I would’ve forgiven you. Because that’s what I always did, Sirius. I always forgave your shit. Always… always believed in you. Don’t you see that!?" she cried, brow furrowed, her piercing gaze making Sirius pale. "Of course you don’t see it—because everything I did, everything I—" she gasped, trying to order her thoughts, wiping her cheeks with the back of her hand. "I sacrificed myself to save you! When Fab and Gid died… I was going to use my cloak to escape, but I didn’t—I gave up my chance of freedom for you! And all your selfish mind can think about is how cruel I was to betray you… but you never saw the bloody signs, you never stopped to wonder if something was wrong!"
Her tears, raw and scalding, turned swiftly into heaving breaths of rage.
"You never doubted it—because your hatred for Regulus has always been greater than your love for me!"
Scarlett’s voice came out so cold, so resolute, and so wounded that she barely recognised it herself. Sirius was stunned into silence. Still, Scarlett waited—desperately—for him to say something, anything that might mend what had just been shattered. To tell her he loved her more than he hated Red. To erase the past, rewrite the future, stitch together the present. But he only stared at her, lost, as though he couldn’t find a single way to save what remained between them—love, anger, grief.
And was there even a difference anymore?
Her expression—hard, fearful, and somehow still hopeful—crumbled into tears. Scarlett’s shoulders sagged; she buried her face in her hands and wept, silently but uncontrollably, fighting the sounds that tried to escape her throat.
The dance of Scarius’s demons had ended, leaving its familiar trail of ruin wherever their cursed feet had waltzed: smoke coiled against the kitchen ceiling, heat spread across the cupboards, and the acrid scent of burning filled her nostrils.
Sirius tried to step closer, tried to touch her, but Scarlett slapped his hand away, retreating with each thunderbeat of her heart until her back hit the wall behind her. He froze there, fingers trembling midair as though still reaching for her.
It was always the same with Sirius. The good memories returned… and so did the bad. And she—she just couldn’t. No matter how hard she tried, she couldn’t.
Scarlett shrank against the wall like a cornered animal, trying to dry her tears, but it was useless. They spread across her face, as irredeemable as every choice she’d made and could no longer undo. She kept her eyes fixed on the floor, unable to face him any longer—and then she diminished into Whiskers.
Sirius stood frozen, helpless, watching Whiskers disappear as she turned down the corridor toward the exit.
There was something playing faintly in the distance, but Sirius couldn’t hear it. Truth be told, he could barely stand. His breathing hitched, trapped beneath the weight of something dredging up sharp-edged memories from the depths of his mind, and yet all he could do was stare at the door—waiting, somehow, for her to come back.
Scarlett didn’t come back. Of course she didn’t.
Why had he expected otherwise? He wouldn’t have come back either, if he were her.
"What the bloody hell happened here, Sirius?!" Remus’s alarmed shout split through the haze of the kitchen, his panicked eyes darting from the stove to the smoke curling toward the ceiling, and finally to Sirius.
With a flick of his wand, Remus shut off the fire and flung the windows open, summoning a rush of cold air to chase out the smoke. The shrill wail of the fire alarm pierced the air, relentless, but Sirius remained unmoving—unaware of everything around him.
He just stood there, eyes glazed, fixed on the doorway…
As if…
As if…
Sirius ran a hand down his face, utterly spent. Without a word, he left the kitchen, fingers brushing the burn scar on his forearm, his eyes still wet. He shut the bedroom door carelessly and stumbled to his bed, collapsing onto it, his gaze wandering across the star-studded ceiling. He had no strength, no courage, no will to deal with any of it just then.
His heart, however, disagreed.
He’d lost control of it long ago.
[Joy Division — “Love Will Tear Us Apart”]
He bit hard into his lower lip as the sob rose up his throat, harsh and guttural, escaping in low, broken sounds he couldn’t hold back. His head spun; it was impossible to make sense of that argument—because what Scarlett had said couldn’t be true.
It couldn’t be true.
Sirius loved her—he always had. Scarlett was more than his heart; she was the air in his lungs, the music in his ears, the blood running through his veins. She was the fear haunting his insides and the cold water soothing his wounds. The shattered glass of his reflection. The fragile fissure tearing through his soul. Scarlett was his love. A bruised, weary, addicted love. Stained, scarred… forced. And still—his love.
Wasn’t that enough?
Then love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Sirius gripped the sheet beneath him, pulled it close, and buried his face in the white fabric that still carried her scent: vanilla laced with alcohol. His shoulders shook, his toes curled, and his chest was crushed beneath the annihilating flood of the past.
It wasn’t true.
Why is the bedroom so cold? You've turned away on your side
Is my timing that flawed? Our respect runs so dry
Yes, Sirius hated Regulus—but that was just brotherly hate, wasn’t it? He had definitely hunted his brother during the Wizarding War, ready to kill him when he saw their wedding in the paper. Of course he had. But he wouldn’t have actually killed him—it had only been rage clouding his judgement. Obviously, he didn’t hate Regulus that much…
That was normal between brothers.
Wasn’t it?
Sirius wanted so badly to be a hypocrite, to lie to himself—but he knew it wasn’t true. Yet it wasn’t entirely false either. It lay somewhere in between—a lying truth?
He sniffed, drawing in a deep breath through his mouth.
Scarlett hadn’t been completely wrong. And if he wanted Reggie and Harry’s bond to be that of true brothers, like the one he and James had shared… then he had to accept that he and Regulus were everything but brothers.
Brothers don’t hate each other. Or at least—they shouldn’t.
And he had hated Regulus for far too long. Maybe… maybe it was time to… let him go?
How could he, though, when Reggie was his mirror image—from his looks to his mannerisms? And… and what he’d done…
What he and Scarlett had done…
Sirius clenched his jaw. No. That only proved her point. And Scarlett wasn’t right. She couldn’t be right. He loved her, for fuck’s sake—he loved her!
Then love, love will tear us apart again
Love, love will tear us apart again
Then love, love will tear it apart again
Love, love will tear it apart again
He hated Regulus too. But more than he loved Scarlett? No. That—never.
Then why hadn’t he told her that when he had the chance?
He rolled over in bed, pressing his face into her pillow, wishing she were there.
Like a burnt child still drawn to the flame, Sirius Black was a forsaken man addicted to abandonment.
He wanted so badly to have the power to undo all the shit between them. He didn’t resent Scarlett just because of Regulus. She’d left because she’d wanted to—because he’d made her go—because he’d been destroying himself the same way she was doing now.
He regretted opening his mouth, regretted letting her provoke him, regretted saying the things he didn’t mean. Not really. He hadn’t wanted to accuse her. Not like that. But Scarlett had a way of stripping him bare—his judgement, his restraint, his limits—until nothing was left. She could burn through every wall he built and drag his chaos to the surface. And with her, it was almost impossible to stop—whether it was the love, the fury, or the tears.
Scarlett Gaunt shattered his defences and left him at the mercy of his own feelings.
He shook his head. That wasn’t true.
Sirius Black wanted to love with the same ease he hated.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 70: But in the end, it was she who saved you
Chapter Text
CXXXVIII
Scarlett had barely managed to get out of bed that morning. Sirius had insisted on staying with her, but Scarlett had sent him off to the Great Hall with James, Remus, and Peter. She had said she needed some time alone, but in truth, she only wanted him to enjoy the day, even if she couldn’t do the same.
It was Halloween, after all.
Rolling across the mattress in complete despondency, Scarlett let out a long sigh and dragged herself to the trunk at the foot of the bed. On top lay her Princess Leia costume, which Sirius and the others had fetched for her the day before from Gladrags Wizardwear. The inside was filled with a jumble of clothes, and she pushed a few garments aside, rummaging through the rest until she found something she didn’t even remember putting in there: a set of black lace lingerie.
Her fingers traced the delicate lace fabric, the seams of the corset and the suspender belt that already came with a pair of thigh-high stockings.
Sirius had bought it for her over the summer, but Scarlett had never had the courage to wear it. She hesitated before taking the lingerie and hopping out of bed. She walked over to the full-length mirror, held the piece by the straps and placed it in front of her body. She slipped it on quickly, ignoring the chill of the gallery at that hour.
The lingerie was beautiful: the black lace corset bore intricate arabesques, and the sheer fabric accentuated the sharp lines of her curves. The suspender belt sat perfectly at her waist, fastening to the stockings that reached just above her knees.
She had never worn anything so daring before. It was… different.
She lifted her gaze to the mirror. The girl staring back at her wasn’t someone pretty, sensual, or confident. She looked more like someone worn out. Her eyes lowered to the lace framing her medium-sized breasts and the curve of her waist. She tried to smile. Unsuccessfully.
In truth, she looked rather ridiculous in that bloody thing.
The dormitory door opened abruptly. Sirius walked in, laughing at something James had said as he spoke:
“If it were me, I’d…” He stopped mid-sentence, his voice dying as he took in the sight of Scarlett standing like that.
Sirius froze, and so did she.
“Has my birthday arrived and I somehow missed it?” he murmured, his eyes wide as he drank in the sight before him.
“What is it?” James asked from the corridor, craning his neck to see. Remus and Peter also tried to look past him.
Scarlett instinctively covered herself with her arms, her face burning with embarrassment. Sirius immediately glanced back, shooting a murderous look at his friends.
“Out. Now.” he ordered, and he shut the door in their faces before any of them could say a word.
The quiet of the room was gentled by the clinking of chains, the crackling of the heater’s embers, the soft howl of the wind drifting down from the ceiling. Scarlett stepped back in an attempt to hide herself, but there wasn’t much she could do. Sirius turned slowly, taking her in as though she were a mirage that might vanish at any moment.
“I… you weren’t meant to see this.” she whispered, looking anywhere but at him. Sirius opened his mouth to reply, but Scarlett went on: “Can I ask you something, and will you promise to tell me the truth?”
Sirius blinked, baffled by the question and even more by her tone.
“Of course…” Sirius cleared his throat.
Scarlett swallowed hard, her eyes drifting to the floor.
“Do you think I’m pretty?”
The question was so absurd that Sirius couldn’t fathom how to react. He blinked, his mouth opening and closing a few times before he finally shook his head in disbelief.
“Pretty?” He laughed, though not mockingly. The question was so ridiculous it shouldn’t have needed asking. He took a few steps forward, his eyes softening, his brows knitting just slightly. “My love, you’re the most beautiful thing I’ve ever seen. You always have been.”
Scarlett’s eyes lifted to his, hesitant, shining with the tears she refused to let fall.
“Don’t lie to me.”
“I would never lie about that.” He stopped in front of her and raised a hand, his fingers brushing gently along her arm as though asking permission to touch her. “Why would you ever doubt it? Look at you, kitten.” His hand slid up to her shoulder and he turned her slowly, positioning her before the mirror as he remained behind her. “You… you’re breathtaking. Even… even now. Even on a bad day, Scar.”
Scarlett trembled, forcing out a breath as though trying to expel the despair clawing at her chest. It wasn’t enough to stop the tears, though.
“I can’t see it, Sirius.”
“Then let me show you.” he whispered against the shell of her ear, nibbling it. Scarlett felt her body shiver, her neck lashed by the warmth of Sirius’s breath.
The truth was… she couldn’t feel much of anything. Her heart had been swallowed by an impenetrable void that stole every want, every desire, every spark of life.
“You’re only saying that because I turn you on.” Scarlett muttered, closing her eyes as Sirius’s lips traced the curve of her neck, marking her skin with kisses and hickeys, before dragging his teeth where her blood pulsed.
He laughed, the sound vibrating through her jugular and thrumming through her veins until it split open the catatonic cage encircling her heart.
“And why should one thing cancel out the other?” Sirius purred, his hands rising to cup her breasts, feeling the softness of the lace over her hardened nipples.
Scarlett shook her head, Sirius’s erection growing harder against her back with every passing second.
“And what if I asked you to stop?” She fisted a handful of Sirius’s black hair, watching in the mirror’s reflection as his long dark lashes fluttered open like a pair of fans, revealing his ravenous stare, his pupils so blown they swallowed everything: the grey of his irises, his self-control, and the sight of Scarlett in front of him.
“Then I stop.” Sirius drew his lips slightly away from her marked skin, saliva glistening all over her neck. “Do you want me to stop?”
Scarlett’s shoulders tensed at the loss of contact.
“No.” The word shattered any trace of hesitation Sirius might have shown.
She might have been numb to many things, but none of them included her star-eyed man. He lifted her with a single arm and carried her to the bed, settling her onto the mattress as his body came over hers, his clothes growing fewer with every passing moment as his touches multiplied: he pinched her breasts, scratched her abdomen, smacked her arse.
His hands seemed to be everywhere at once, always keeping the lingerie exactly where it was, and his lips worshipped her through the lace. He licked her nipples without pulling the corset down and teased them with his teeth, the dampness on the almost-transparent fabric cooling as Sirius moved lower, spreading slippery kisses over her ribs and biting every inch of skin until he had marked her as his.
“You look so fucking gorgeous like this…” He smiled, his velvet voice thick with need sending a rush of heat straight to her belly. Scarlett made a move to take the corset off, but Sirius caught her wrist. “No, no, no… I’m going to fuck you just like this.”
“D-dressed?” Scarlett stammered, her face still flushed from the situation.
Sirius’s roguish smile deepened, accentuating his dimples and baring his perfect teeth. He hooked her knickers to the side using his mouth, unbothered by his rough stubble snagging the lace. His hungry gaze slid from Scarlett’s face to her aching cunt, pleasing her with a long, languid lick from bottom to top.
Scarlett exhaled all at once, bracing herself on her elbows to get a better look at him, but Sirius shifted and lay on his back, patting his own chest for her to climb up. Arching her brows, she complied, her heart racing at the mischief glinting around her boyfriend’s handsome, dimpled face.
“That’s it, sit on my face.” he murmured, though in a tone of command. Scarlett rolled her eyes and tightened her thighs around his face.
“Shut up…” she muttered, earning bites along the inside of her thighs in retaliation. “What, do you want me to suffocate you?”
Despite the playful tone, the way Sirius’s brows relaxed at her question made her believe he would be more than pleased if she actually did it, so she braced herself against the headboard and watched, open-mouthed, as Sirius sucked one of her lips, then the other, his tongue dragging over the painfully sensitive places where she had no choice but to tremble and gasp.
She could feel the corners of Sirius’s mouth curl into a smile against her cunt before he landed another smack on her arse. Scarlett straightened, tightening her legs, but loosened again when he deliberately rubbed his stubble against her inner thigh. He knew exactly what he was doing, especially when he returned to licking her with hunger, teasing her clit with the tip of his tongue and plunging deeper as he buried his face between her legs.
Scarlett clenched her fists against the carved wood, making it creak. Sirius wrapped his arms around her thighs, pulling her further onto his chest, and she took full advantage of the position to grind on his mouth, letting her weight pin him down while the pleasure climbed through her body, chasing him every time he pleased her and growled, driving her mad.
Sirius’s tattooed hands travelled up her body, massaging her waist, her breasts, fitting themselves around her neck and applying that familiar pressure that assured him he would always be in control. And Scarlett adored it; Sirius Black’s fist was her favourite necklace.
She pushed the straps of the corset down, freeing her breasts from the bra. She cupped them and pinched her nipples between her fingertips. The orgasm was being engineered by the most skilled of builders; Sirius knew exactly when to repeat a movement with his tongue or when to switch it up, alternating rhythm and pressure.
It didn’t take long for Scarlett’s breath to grow uneven and for the moans she tried to stifle to escape needily from her lips. Her feet sank into the blankets, and Sirius, with one free hand, pulled her even harder against his face. Her thighs began to tremble with mounting euphoria. Noticing it, Sirius quickened his pace aggressively. Her moans became cries, and the tremor turned into an earthquake, blacking out her mind and surrendering her to Sirius’s tongue as it dragged her into an explosive climax.
The electrifying sensation softened her muscles and eased her consciousness, giving her the impression she was about to float, though something still anchored her to the world: Sirius’s mouth savouring her pleasure with a certain desperation, as though afraid to waste even a drop, summoning fresh tremors through her body like thunder in a storm. She was still moaning, though more faintly. Sirius’s grip on her throat and the hand at her waist were the only things keeping her in place.
Drawing in air through her nose and releasing it through her mouth, Scarlett managed to push herself off and collapse beside him, her breathing shallow and her heart hammering in her chest. Sirius sat up, looking at her with such devotion that Scarlett had the impression he had come as well, even though his trousers were still dry.
He pulled his lips into his mouth, the lower half of his face wet with her release. Scarlett reached out to wipe him clean, but he caught her forearm and sucked all of her climax from her fingers like a starving man.
“You taste so fucking good like this…” Sirius confessed, his voice thick with lust. He crawled towards Scarlett, covering her languid body with his own.
She licked her own release from his beard until Sirius caught her tongue with his mouth and sucked on it, dragging her into a dizzying kiss. He lowered his hips, grinding them against Scarlett’s pelvis without caring about smearing his trousers.
“You’re only saying that… because you want to fuck me.” Scarlett said between kisses, their noses brushing every time their mouths slid against each other.
“Mm-hm…” he growled, feeling her hands undoing his belt. “I want to fuck you every day. With or without lingerie, you’re delicious, my love.” The heated declaration scraped against her lips, and Scarlett bit his lower one.
“You mean… I make you hard… with or without lingerie?” She opened Sirius’s trousers and dragged them down with palpable desperation, freeing his cock from his pants.
“My cock is as much a gentleman as I am, love. It always stands when a lady wishes to sit.” he drawled, never fully breaking the kiss.
Scarlett stroked him a few times, guiding him to her drenched entrance, and Sirius brushed the lace aside with his fingers to push it further out of the way before sinking slowly into Scar with a precise thrust.
“Oh… fuck…” he groaned into her mouth, his fists tightening in Scarlett’s hair as her heartbeat faltered out of rhythm. He pulled out slowly, his knees shaking on the mattress, her legs hooking around his waist. Then he pushed back in, his eyes fluttering shut as her hot, slick insides squeezed around him deliciously.
Sirius settled into a drawn-out, torturous rhythm, his breath and expression of pure ecstasy betraying that, if not for his enviable self-control, he would have given in to his feral impulses and ignored Scarlett’s pleasure entirely. But when he thrust into her again, he let his head fall into the delicate curve of her shoulder and worshipped it with his mouth, drawing a warm trail of saliva there.
Scarlett moaned his name and tightened her walls around him, ripping a whimper from him. Wicked as he was, Sirius deliberately drew his hips back until only his tip remained inside her, then slid in again with firm insistence, filling her to the hilt and coaxing from her a strangled gasp of want. He heard her knuckles crack, felt the sting of her sharpened nails along his back, and allowed her to aid his thrusts by bracing her heels at the base of his thigh.
Then, when he was unbearably close, Sirius stopped, still buried inside her. Impatient, Scarlett braced her elbows on the bed and shoved him, flipping their positions and ending up on top. Her nails raked across his shoulder blades, his shoulder and his chest, making him widen his eyes, devouring her with his stare, letting it slide down her slender body to where they were still joined, his cock fully sheathed inside Scarlett.
“Wait, I’m going to cu—” Sirius didn’t manage to finish.
Planting both hands on his chest, Scarlett levered herself up and down, stealing from him the ability to speak or react to anything at all, bending him to her whims. Sirius grabbed her by the corset, trying to hold her still, but Scarlett rose and dropped without an ounce of shame, sinking herself onto him with such force that Sirius screwed up his face, as though trying to summon every last shred of concentration not to come.
Her fun didn’t last. As much as she liked revenge, Scarlett was still weakened from her earlier orgasm, so she smiled and gave one last roll of her hips around Sirius’s cock before sinking down fully, feeling him strike every delicious spot inside her cunt.
“Did you cum?” she asked against his ear, laughing—a low, wicked laugh.
Sirius clenched his jaw and smiled as well, retaking control by flipping Scarlett onto the mattress, stomach down. She was so relaxed she didn’t even resist, and he admired her black hair spilling down her pale back. He stroked her soft, sweaty skin with his rough palm until he reached the nape of her neck, closing his hand around her silky strands.
“On all fours.” he demanded, almost breathless, pulling her by the hair until she faced the carved wooden canopy overhead. He smacked each round cheek hard, marking them with his hand. “Fuck, I should’ve started with this position… you look bloody gorgeous…” he praised, his fingertips sliding along her suspender belt until they reached her knickers, pulling them aside once more.
He gripped his cock by the base and pushed back into Scarlett, but this time with a rhythm steeped in desperation. She planted her hands on the headboard, which scraped against the wall with the force of his thrusts, muffling their rough moans. That angle made Sirius’s cock drag so deeply inside her that Scarlett felt intoxicated.
He kept his grip on her hair and leaned in, his ragged breath misting her neck until he bit her shoulder, his bare chest rising and falling heavily as he eased the pace of his hips until he stopped. His free hand threaded his fingers through Scarlett’s where they held the headboard, and he pressed kisses along her nape, over the Canis Major tattoo and the star just above her shoulder blade.
“Don’t you want to cum today?” Scarlett asked with difficulty, shifting her hips in an attempt to pleasure herself, rocking back and forth. Sirius let go of her hand and lifted his torso, kneeling on the bed, fitting his thumb into the little hollow at the base of her spine and marking her waist with the rest of his fingers as he guided her forwards and back.
“I want to cum with you… but it’s really hard. I’m so… close…” He laughed and then groaned, snapping his hips as he struck her, his fingertips searching Scarlett’s groin for her clit. “Are you close?”
“I’ve already cum, Sirius.” Scarlett murmured, languid.
“That’s not what I asked.” He punctuated each word with a slap to her thigh.
“I am.”
The admission was enough for him to resume his brutal rhythm, the sound of their bodies colliding and their ragged moans weaving the melody of their ecstasy. Even close and slightly tired, Sirius drove into her with vigour, masturbating Scarlett to the same pace.
He was the first to reach climax, announcing it with a desperate groan, though he didn’t stop possessing her. Scarlett looked at him over her shoulder, admiring him in pure rapture: one hand still in her hair, the other between her legs; those full lips parted, spilling unrestrained moans, and his black hair plastered to his sweaty face.
Scarlett pushed her hips forward and back, helping him ride out his high as she reached her own with the help of his fingers working her with practiced skill. Seeing him like that was intoxicating. Soon her body was once again overtaken by a wave of pleasure that purged every one of her senses. Her walls clutched around Sirius’s still-hard cock, his hot, sticky release making everything even more divine.
Closing her eyes, Scarlett felt his body collapse over hers, his chest flattening against her back, his arms wrapping around her waist, his mouth dragging along her throat. She smiled, hearing him growl, and tried to shield her neck with her shoulder when he scraped his stubble over her sensitive patch of skin.
Sirius slipped out of her, but didn’t let her go. His black hair was tangled with hers, his tattooed fingers toying with the joints of her hand, his restless lips placing gentle kisses along her nape.
Scarlett’s smile broke into tears.
“What is it, my love?” he asked, worried.
Scarlett only sniffed, shaking her head as she shoved her arm under the covers and buried her face there.
“Did I hurt you?” Sirius braced himself on his elbows and knees to lift his weight off her.
“No. It’s not you.” Her muffled voice barely made it out.
“What is it, then?” He wove his fingertips through her hair in a touch full of care.
“I… I don’t know.”
His reaction was to pull her into his arms with all the strength he had, as though trying to steal that unknown, terrifying, morbid feeling away from her and bear it himself. He couldn’t, he rarely could, but it didn’t mean he would give up or abandon her.
“I’m here for you.” he reaffirmed, holding her even tighter.
“I’m here too, love.” Scarlett raised her face just enough for her blue eyes to gleam between the black strands of hair falling over her features. “I’m here too.”
In the future, Sirius would remember that moment with bitterness. He hadn’t expected to be right—he had always believed that the love of Scarius could withstand anything. That rule, however, only applies to those who love and are loved the right way. To love that hasn’t been tainted by vices, regrets, and loss.
“She was grieving.” Asca tapped her quill against the clipboard. Her gaze, however, never left him. “When people Scarlett’s age lose someone very close, it’s common for them to develop a depressive state linked to a complicated grief. And you… you dealt with grief in your own way.”
Sirius rubbed his eyes with his knuckles, shaking his head repeatedly in denial.
“I wasn’t grieving.”
“You were. You told me you started drinking after Halloween, didn’t you?” She consulted a few sheets on the parchment clipped to the board.
“I wasn’t grieving—how could I possibly grieve for a child who didn’t even exist?!” he shot back, irritated, spitting the words out.
“Well, see, I never said grief was the only reason. Your Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder was also decisive. But the two together…”
Sirius held his face in his hands, focusing solely on breathing.
“I was pissed off because… that was our chance to have a family. To… to maybe… save Scarlett from what she was going through…”
“And who saved you, Sirius? Who did you look at and decide to give up drinking and drugs for?”
His heart skipped a beat as he lifted his gaze to her.
“Reggie.”
Asca’s smile bloomed, warm and full of tenderness.
“You wanted to save Scarlett… but in the end, it was she who saved you.”
.
.
.
Sirius no longer knew what to do… or what to say, nor how to react. Scarlett had fallen asleep in his arms, tears still slipping from her damp lashes even though her expression was peaceful. He had never dealt with anything like this before—had no idea when grief would leave or return, no clue whether a smile would be followed by tears as it had earlier.
He was exhausted. Not by the situation itself, but Scarlett’s irritability and instability left him deeply worried, and the sense of helplessness made him feel like shit. What kind of man couldn’t make his girlfriend happy? Was he even the right bloke for her? Would she… be happier with someone else?
No. It didn’t matter what probable futures or improbable pasts existed—Scarlett had chosen him just as he had chosen her. Brooding over it would only drain him further.
He slipped out of the bed carefully so as not to wake her, taking clean clothes with him to the bathroom. When he opened the door, a towel slung over his shoulder and his hair still damp, he came face to face with Remus, James, and Peter entering the gallery.
“Is it safe now?” James asked, a teasing grin on his face.
Sirius stopped beside the table, drying his hair with his wand, smug under their attention.
“It’s safe.” he confirmed, his lips spreading as though the memory were more a trophy than a mere mishap.
“Lucky you…” Peter muttered, sighing.
“I brought you a surprise. Asked Penny to make brownies…” he said, with a half-smile. “A whole tray.” He extended it to Sirius, who raised a brow and accepted it.
“Pot brownies, huh? Moony, you’re a genius.” He didn’t wait for permission to take a piece and bite into it, offering the tray to the others. “Can barely taste it…” He nodded, impressed.
James and Peter took one, as did Remus. The four of them enjoyed the brownie while still standing, until Sirius reached for a second piece and set the tray on the table, motioning for them to follow him to the sofa.
“So… you lot didn’t see anything, did you? About Scar?” he asked between bites, his silver eyes sweeping over his friends with a veiled threat.
“See what?” Peter was the first to answer, chewing hastily.
“Absolutely nothing. Don’t even recall you mentioning it, Mr Pads.” James added, rolling his eyes.
Sirius huffed, satisfied. He brushed the crumbs from the collar of his shirt.
“Good. Then I won’t have to rip your eyes out today.” he said, serious, though his lips quickly curved back into a smile.
Remus shook his head, going through the bags Peter and James had brought. James noticed Sirius’s folded costume on the corner sideboard and ran a hand through his messy hair.
“Pads, do you happen to have that magazine Scar used to change your hair colour last year? I wanna go blond for the costume…”
“Ah…” Sirius looked around, catching sight of Scarlett with her messy hair, wearing one of his The Doors shirts and holding a piece of brownie, her pale face twisting in disgust.
“What a weird taste…” she grumbled, taking another bite.
Sirius’s eyes flew wide and he choked immediately. He leapt off the sofa, his heart racing in panic.
“No, no, no, SPIT THAT OUT!” He slapped the brownie from Scarlett’s hand, sending it to the floor. “Spit it out!”
Scarlett only furrowed her brow, refusing to obey as she slowly stopped chewing.
“No.” She swallowed, her eyebrows pulling together in defiance. “What do you think I am, a dog you can just order to spit things out?”
“Yeah, Padfoot, she’s already bitten it. Now you’ll have to tell her…” Remus seemed entertained as he unwrapped his costume.
“Weed.” Sirius muttered. “There’s weed in the brownie.”
Scarlett blinked a few times, incredulous. Then her nostrils flared and her eyes widened.
“There’s what?” She put her hands on her hips, narrowing her gaze at her boyfriend.
“Wee—”
“Are you lot taking the piss out of me?!” Scar cut Sirius off with a shout. “This is the second bloody Halloween in a row someone drugs me without consent!” She gesticulated furiously, glaring at each of them.
Remus opened his mouth to try to explain why he had brought that particular dessert to the Undercroft, but fell silent when Scarlett took another bite of the brownie.
“I’m hungry.” she explained before anyone could ask. She ignored Sirius’s astonished stare as she went to fetch a glass of water.
“You can’t eat too much, Scarlett, you’ll get sick.” He grabbed a tray of muffins Peter had brought the night before. “Here, have this instead…”
Scarlett’s blue eyes narrowed with suspicion, but she accepted the muffin and tossed the brownie into the bin. She left the room and headed to the bathroom, closing the door behind her. Sirius let out a long breath, folding his arms as he sat on the armrest of the sofa.
“What’s wrong with her today?” James asked, resting his chin on Sirius’s leg.
“No idea.” He shrugged. “And we shagged—imagine if we hadn’t…”
Peter and Remus made disgusted noises. The bathroom door opened and Scarlett reappeared, brushing her hair with far more force than necessary.
“What are you saying about me?” She frowned, not taking her eyes off them.
“Nothing.” all four answered in unison, in a tone that clearly meant they were lying.
She only grunted and returned to the bedroom to get dressed for the Halloween party.
Sirius put on his Han Solo costume. He settled on the sofa and rested his feet on the chair where James’s things were. He slowly drew his blaster from the holster, recreating the infamous scene of Han shooting Greedo in the Mos Eisley cantina.
“Stupid costume…” Peter grumbled, tugging at a part of the trousers that were far too tight. “Why do I have to be the bloody droid?”
“Because none of us were going to be Vader and we didn’t have a better idea.” James retorted bluntly, laughing at his friend’s frustration.
Remus shot James a reproachful look, already dressed in Obi-Wan’s robes. He used magic to make his lightsabre glow just like in the films.
It didn’t take long for Scarlett to emerge from the bedroom, her dress so white that Sirius needed a few seconds for his vision to adjust as he stared, slack-jawed, at his girlfriend. The dress didn’t just fall perfectly along her body; the buns (which he personally found ridiculous in the films) suited the delicate shape of her face surprisingly well.
“Wow.” he said, a roguish grin spreading across his face. “You look magnificent.”
Scarlett tilted her head to the sides and her lips stretched in a shy smile. She stepped closer and kissed him, her heart beating so fast she feared everyone in the gallery could hear it. Sirius wrapped his arms around her and she rested her face against his chest, her hands circling his waist. For a moment, it felt as though she were simply that girl he had once tucked flowers into the hair of.
“You look like you were born to be Han.” Scar admitted, tracing Sirius’s vest with her fingertips.
“Handsome, fit, and a scoundrel?” Sirius spun the blaster around his finger, catching it just in time before pretending to shoot Remus.
“And with the ego to match.” She gave a small nasal laugh, picking up her blaster from the table beside her. “Who do you think she ends up with?”
“Who? Leia?” He holstered his weapon, lowering his gaze to his girlfriend.
“Yes.” Scarlett stepped out of his arms.
“Luke.” He rolled his eyes. “She kissed him…”
“To piss off Han.” she finished, folding her arms behind her back.
“Scar, can you help me with my beard?” Remus asked, examining himself in a handheld mirror. “I need it to look fuller.”
“Of course.” Scarlett winked at Sirius, spun on her heel and stopped beside her friend.
“Make it a bit thicker, I’ll trim it after…” Remus suggested, running a hand over his face.
Scarlett drew her wand. With a flourish, Remus’s light-brown beard grew thicker, giving him an older appearance. Her gaze travelled over the scars on his face—the ones cutting from his forehead to his cheek and the ones along his chin, responsible for the patchiness in his facial hair. Then her eyes stopped on his dark irises, threaded with flickers of gold. He looked at himself in the mirror again.
“What are you thinking about?” Remus asked, his eyes absorbing all the light around them, brightening until his irises turned honey-coloured.
Scarlett bit her lower lip. What was she thinking about?
Not even she knew.
“You don’t think… I don’t know, strange that we were drugged last year?” she finally said, softly. “I mean… we never went after whoever did it.”
He stopped trimming his beard, his gaze wandering across the gallery before returning to her.
“James and Sirius are certain it was that little Slytherin trio. You know what they’re like… always trying to screw us over…” He picked up a pair of scissors to trim the strands.
Scarlett looked over at Sirius, James, and Peter, who were playing with their costumes like three children.
“And what if it wasn’t them?” Scarlett pressed, her voice so low Remus almost didn’t hear it.
He met her eyes through the mirror’s reflection.
“Who would it have been, then?”
Scarlett scratched her Signet (disguised with a spell), traced the burn scar on her forearm and shifted her weight from one foot to the other.
“It was Peter who served the drinks. So maybe he…”
“You mean it was Pete?” Remus cut her off, laughing as he turned towards her in disbelief.
“No, no, that’s not what I meant.” Scarlett denied vehemently. “Just… that he might have seen who spiked the bottle!”
Remus fell silent, pressing his lips together. He was the cleverest of the group, and he would certainly consider her words, but then he dismissed her reasoning with a condescending wave.
“If he’d seen anything, he’d have said so.”
Would he?
Scarlett only nodded before stepping away.
.
.
.
With Voldemort’s advances in the war, there was a considerable number of Aurors responsible for Hogsmeade’s security. They stood out among the witches and wizards for being the only ones without costumes, though a few here and there dared to wear masks or paint their faces. Sirius waved to Dixon, who was standing beside a floating pumpkin-shaped lantern.
Scarecrows stretched out their arms trying to grab passers-by, bats swooped over them in swarms, and the shop windows were decorated with glittering cobwebs, bubbling potions and ghostly images. The fine snow, cleared from the main road, piled up along the corners of the pavements. Eerie music played from instruments that moved on their own, interspersed with the laughter and whispers of Hogwarts students wandering the village in their costumes.
The Auror waved back. Sirius slipped his arm around Scar’s shoulders while James and Remus swung their lightsabres around, imitating the sound. Peter walked a little behind, muttering something to himself.
“Look at that, that’s brilliant…” Sirius pointed at the disturbingly realistic dementor floating above the queue at Madame Puddifoot’s.
“Wow… careful or it’ll suck you dry.” Scarlett pinched her boyfriend’s ribs, making him twist entirely as he laughed, his breath condensing over his lips.
“I’ve been sucked enough for today…” he joked, his attention now fully drawn to Quality Quidditch Supplies.
Unlike the others, the shop window wasn’t filled with frightening details, but there was one particular broom on display: the handle was made of reddish brazilwood, and gold inlays were set into the finish, giving it Gryffindor colours carved into the body. The tail twigs were dark, as were the footrests.
“Release from Brazil?” Scarlett smiled, that smile that made Sirius’s heart stutter in his chest. “It’s really pretty…”
“Yeah, aerodynamic too…” James commented, his blue lightsabre gleaming against the glass and reflecting in his spectacles.
“Luke Skywalker!” A tall, imposing figure appeared just behind them, dressed in a black cloak and the iconic helmet inspired by samurai armour. The characteristic sound of the respirator made all four of them turn around, bewildered. “I’ve been looking for you!”
“Darth Vader?!” James glanced at his friends, speechless. “Looking for me?” He pointed at himself.
“Who else would I be looking for?” The distorted voice through the helmet was a bit unsettling.
James scratched the back of his neck, trying to smooth down the raised hairs, and shot a quick look at Sirius, who lifted his hands as if he had no idea who it was, then at Remus, who murmured:
“Could be a fan.”
It was normal for James to get that kind of attention when he was younger. He’d been a Quidditch prodigy and received plenty of interest from girls, though his overwhelming fascination with Lily Evans scared off most of the bold ones, leaving only those with a hopeless crush on him (and who sent him piles upon piles of bewitched chocolates on Valentine’s Day).
“Er… who… who are you again?” he asked, scrunching his nose.
The figure laughed, the sound muffled by the helmet. She removed it with unnecessary theatrics, and long red hair spilled over the black fabric of the Vader cloak.
“Don’t recognise me, James?” Lily asked, with a smile so teasing James’s brain froze for a few seconds.
“Of course I recognised you!” He tried to hold himself together, running a nervous hand through his hair. “I was just… just acting!”
Sirius let out a low whistle, wrapping his arms around Scarlett from behind.
“Your costume looks fantastic, Vader.” He buried his face in one of his girlfriend’s buns.
“So does yours, Solo.” Lily took her camera out of her pocket. “Let’s take a picture!”
They all gathered in front of the shop window to take advantage of the lights intertwined along the façades. Lily stood further to the left, holding her red lightsabre, its blade meeting James’s as he posed like Vader beside her. In the middle, Sirius drew his blaster and pointed it upwards, pulling Scarlett by the waist with his free hand. Remus struck the iconic Obi-Wan pose and Peter was so annoyed with his costume that he didn’t even smile.
Flash.
Lily put the helmet back on and hurried to catch her camera, which floated under an Aresto Momentum, but suddenly stumbled. James was quick to catch her, and she gripped his arm to steady herself.
“So…” she cleared her throat, her voice distorted by the modulator. “Haunted Maze?”
“Haunted Maze!” Scarlett agreed, with an unusual enthusiasm.
“Mazes are like life…” Remus put his hands behind his head, staring up at the starry sky. “Like, full of paths… and we never know where we’re going.” he said, very seriously, which made the four of them burst into laughter, while Lily simply held her hips, understanding nothing.
“Brownie hit?” Scarlett tapped her friend’s shoulder, and he looked at her with a faint smile.
“All right, philosopher, let’s go before you start talking to the stars…” Sirius pulled Remus along with his free arm.
“Or howling at them.” Scarlett murmured in her boyfriend’s ear, and he let out a laugh so loud it startled a few students on the street.
“What is wrong with you lot?” Lily kept staring at them. Her confused tone was amplified by the vocoder, which only made them laugh harder.
“You do know the Haunted Maze has that name for a reason, right?” Peter muttered, with his usual bad temper.
“You’re a droid, mate.” Sirius flicked the side of his friend’s helmet, earning a jab to the ribs in return. “Robots don’t feel fear!”
There were more giggles here and there, under Lily’s suspicious gaze. James approached Sirius and Scarlett, his hand cupped around his mouth.
“Pads… our hands touched.” James whispered to his friend loud enough for everyone to hear, his face going beet-red when he glanced at Lily.
Sirius gasped dramatically, placing a hand on his chest as his eyes widened.
“Sweet Merlin! Did you use protection?” he deadpanned, not bothering to lower his voice.
They erupted into more laughter and Lily made a noise of disgust, whacking James’s shins with her lightsabre so hard he hopped on the spot. They headed together towards the entrance of the Haunted Maze, where a line of students snaked along the cobbled path of Hogsmeade. The entrance to the maze was framed by twisted branches and lit by a spectral green glow, bathed in a thick mist that made it nearly impossible to see what lay inside.
Scarlett squeezed Sirius’s hand, wearing a smile so full that all he could do was press a soft kiss to her cheek, resting his chin on her shoulder as they waited their turn.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 71: She saved my life and came with me
Chapter Text
CXXXIX
Sirius shot James a lopsided, competitive grin.
“Hundred Galleons says you’ll be the first one to scream,” he said, brushing his cheek against the coiled plaits of Scarlett’s hairstyle.
James merely arched a disdainful eyebrow.
“A hundred? Honestly, Padfoot? Two hundred says it’ll be you.”
They shook on it, sealing the bet, while Remus rubbed his eyes and sighed.
“Can’t wait to watch the pair of you shrieking like little girls…” he muttered, promptly ignored by both.
“No screaming, Han Solo,” Scarlett murmured, licking her lips as she stroked her boyfriend’s beard.
Fifteen minutes later, they stepped into the maze. They were swallowed by a thick, muffling mist, where whispers seemed to come from everywhere and nowhere at once. The walls were made of twisting branches and hedges that creaked and shifted, constantly rearranging the layout.
A hooded figure dropped from above without warning, its eyes glowing, its cackle so shrill it stung their eardrums. James jerked back but bit down on his lip to keep any sound from escaping.
“Don’t even start — I did not scream!” he hissed, flipping Sirius the middle finger as the latter burst out laughing.
They pushed on. With every step, Scarlett’s grip on her boyfriend’s hand tightened. Crows watched them from afar, and scarecrows appeared at random along the path. Lily’s breathing somewhat ruined the immersion; having Darth Vader right beside them gave them a false sense of courage they absolutely shouldn’t have felt.
Well — that courage lasted right up until a giant spider tore out from one of the corridors, its long, agile legs shaking the ground beneath them.
Lily was the first to scream — so piercingly that not even the voice modulator could deepen it. Scarlett choked on a half-laugh, half-gasp, unsure whether to run or cackle, and Sirius yanked her along as the group scattered in all directions with the creature closing in dangerously.
Scarlett stumbled over Peter’s costume and was grabbed by Lily — still shrieking — who dragged her into one of the narrower paths. The two of them sprinted desperately while the clatter of the spider’s legs echoed behind them. Scar was laughing so hard she could barely breathe.
“Bloody hell, Lily… that scream…” she tried to say between fits of laughter. “I can’t — fucking hell…”
“Whose stupid idea was it to go into this bloody maze?!” Lily shot back, horrified by the chase.
They slowed once they realised the threat had fallen behind. But the moment Scarlett stopped to catch her breath, skeletal hands burst from the ground, clawing at their ankles.
“For Merlin’s sake!” Lily squealed again — another high-pitched, strangled sound — making Scarlett erupt in fresh, ringing laughter.
“Run, Vader!” Scarlett barked, dragging her friend away before the skeletons could grab them.
They split at a crossroads when a ghost materialised between the two. Scarlett darted one way, Lily the other.
“S-Scarlett?” Lily called, her modulated voice taking on a serious edge, tinged with panic. “Scar?”
“Mudblood.” A whisper.
Lily spun around, heart hammering against her ribs. The fog made it impossible to see more than a metre ahead, but she was quick to draw her wand, illuminating the mist with the glow of her red lightsaber.
“Filth… scum… freak of nature…”
The crimson light slid in broken shards across the black visor with every step she took — the saber trembling faintly in her left hand, her wand steady in her right. Her boots sank into the grass, which was beginning to turn to mud. Panic surged through her veins, burrowing all the way into her bones.
“You’re going to die, little Mudblood…”
Lily collided with something, steadied herself by stabbing the lightsaber into the ground, and raised her wand in a flawless, lightning-fast reflex.
The person before her was laughing — actually laughing — even in a situation like that.
“What’s wrong, Lils? This maze got you that scared?” Sirius braced his hands on his knees, breath coming fast.
Letting out every last bit of air in her lungs, Lily lowered her wand and clutched her chest as though she could physically tame her frantic heartbeat.
“Death Eaters… I… I think there are Death Eaters in here…” She gripped his arm tightly, as if trying to transfer the urgency vibrating in her voice straight into his skin.
Sirius’s smile vanished instantly. He straightened, wand drawn, grey eyes slicing through the mist as though searching for an exit.
“Stay behind me. We’ll find the others and get out.” His sober tone made her frown.
Lily was taken aback by his reaction. He hadn’t just taken charge — he’d believed her, without hesitation. He checked each turn with sharp caution, as if they were facing an actual threat. She could see the tension rippling down his shoulders, coiling tight around his neck.
The sound of distant voices and footsteps grew clearer the farther they walked, until at last a bright flare of light marked the exit.
And she watched — with startling, overwhelming swiftness — all that rigidity melt from Sirius’s stance the moment he saw Scarlett on the grass, doubled over in laughter. He practically sprinted towards her.
Lily had never imagined she’d see Sirius Black look at a girl as though she were his entire world. Something strange burst in her chest, making her swallow hard and shiver. Jealousy? Envy?
She wished someone would look at her like that.
.
.
.
Scarlett was the first to step out, adjusting the buns in her hair that had loosened during the sprint. She looked back, waiting for someone else to appear.
Soon enough, James emerged from the exit looking even paler than usual, one hand pressed to his abdomen.
“Jamie?” she called, breath still ragged. “Are you alright?”
He pulled a face, walking with his legs suspiciously far apart.
“I think I’ve shat myself.” He said it with such brutal honesty that Scarlett needed a few seconds of absolute silence just to process it.
Then she exploded into laughter.
And although James tried desperately to hold it together, he started laughing too.
Remus rounded a corner and stared at the pair of them, lips pressed into a thin line.
“What’s so funny?” he asked, shifting the hilt of his saber to adjust his costume.
The question sent Scarlett collapsing onto the ground, rolling with laughter. James attempted to answer, but was interrupted by a symphony of farts.
“For Merlin’s sake!” Remus yanked his sleeve over his nose. “Did you actually shit yourself?”
“I don’t know… I think so,” James replied, his face flushing scarlet.
Scarlett slapped her hands on the grass, unable to breathe or stop laughing.
Sirius and Lily stepped out of the maze.
He went straight to his girlfriend, worry softening into a grin as he reached her.
“What’s going on here?” He touched Scarlett’s shoulders, wiping the hysterical tears spilling from the corners of her eyes.
Scarlett managed to raise a trembling finger towards James, sniffling in her attempt to catch her breath.
“Jam— Jamie… shat himself!”
Sirius widened his eyes at her, incredulous, then at James — who was sweating buckets. He didn’t need to open his mouth; the involuntary farts spoke for him.
“You’re having me on, Prongs?!” Sirius refused to believe it, stepping closer to his friend.
James gave a strained, sheepish smile, wiping his brow with the back of his hand.
Lily folded her arms and marched several steps away to keep a safe distance.
“Good Lord, James, you stink!” Lily’s declaration — distorted by the modulator — made everything even funnier. She pulled off her helmet and fanned the air in front of her face.
Horror dawned across James’s features the instant he realised Lily had also come out of the maze — and had witnessed everything. His eyes doubled in size and he opened and closed his mouth repeatedly, trying to form a sentence that made sense.
“No— no— it’s not what it looks like!” he insisted, stuffing his hands into his pockets as if searching for his wand to Disapparate.
“Alright, alright,” Sirius said, gripping his shoulder and attempting to maintain composure. A mischievous smile, however, tugged unashamedly at the corner of his mouth. “Let’s find you a loo before you… kill everyone around you.” He half-carried his friend towards the nearest loo.
James glanced over his shoulder one last time, mortified to see Lily still watching him.
Scarlett, sprawled on the ground, focused solely on catching her breath — though the occasional stray laugh still escaped her.
Lily and Remus exchanged an amused look.
Peter appeared moments later, his costume slightly crushed along the sides. He was hyperventilating as though he’d just escaped a near-death situation. Sweat trickled down his sideburns and he leaned heavily against the nearest low wall for a moment’s rest.
“Where are Sirius and James?” he asked, lifting his gaze to the others.
“In the loo,” Remus said, nodding towards the bathrooms.
Peter took a few breaths before continuing:
“Why?”
Scarlett tried lifting her head to answer, but the moment she opened her mouth, laughter tore out of her again.
Covering her face with both hands, she wheezed:
“If I answer that question one more time… I’m going to die.”
Lily let out a short, disbelieving laugh, shaking her head.
“Apparently James had a… erm… gastrointestinal incident,” she said, wetting her lips.
Peter straightened, coming to stand beside Lily.
“Seriously?”
“Very,” Remus replied, twirling his saber in his hand. “Tragically serious.”
Peter hid a smile behind his hand, darting a wary glance at Lily.
“You didn’t hear…” He cleared his throat, shifting the subject with an exaggerated attempt at seriousness. “Anything strange in there? Like… things that didn’t feel like part of the attraction?”
“Yes, I heard it too. For a moment I thought they were Death Eaters,” she murmured, brows knitting.
Scarlett finally managed to stop laughing, propping herself up on her elbows as she looked at them. Remus raised his eyebrows, wondering whether he’d had the same experience as Peter and Lily.
“But… well… the Aurors are right there,” Scarlett pointed to the group on the opposite pavement. “It must’ve… must’ve been part of the attraction.”
She ought to feel quite unsettled by it all, but for some reason she couldn’t bring herself to care. In fact, she felt great — though there was a strange tingling in her fingertips and a peculiar quickness in her movements, especially when she stood.
Had Remus not grabbed her, she would’ve fallen flat on her face.
“I’m thirsty,” she murmured — one of the few sensations she could still identify.
“Let’s head to the Three Broomsticks,” Lily suggested.
“I’ll let Sirius and James know. See you there.” Peter waved and set off towards the loos.
“You alright?” Remus asked as they made their way towards the pub.
“Me? I’m… brilliant!” Scarlett answered — noticeably slower than usual.
“I can see that,” he said, offering her such a soft, gentle smile that Scarlett couldn’t help but smile back.
.
.
.
Scarlett was the first to sit down, leaning back against the bench with her eyes fixed on the enchanted ceiling of the Three Broomsticks. They had gone completely overboard with the Halloween decorations that year: the ceiling mimicked a star-scattered sky, with shooting stars gliding from one side to the other in a graceful, synchronised dance. Bats swooped overhead, tugging playfully at the hair of anyone who entered, and cobwebs clung to every corner as though the place had been abandoned for centuries.
She opened and closed her hands, trying to ease the tingling in her fingers. The lights shifted from the dance floor — now red, now blue, now pitch black. A bubbling cauldron took pride of place in the middle of the room, spilling thick vapour across the floor. On the pillars, skulls chatted idly and tickled anyone who leaned against them. Absorbed, she watched the strobing crimson lights slide across her white dress, giving the impression she was drenched in blood.
Scarlett placed a hand over her chest, watching the flickers shift towards a deep violet. She felt oddly detached from her friends, who were chatting around her, while everything else seemed painfully heightened. The glittering details on Pandora’s Morgana costume… the blinding shine of the crown Xenophilius wore as King Arthur…
Scarlett sighed.
She glanced at Remus, already wrapped around Mary, whispering something undoubtedly indecent into her ear — given that his hand was between her thighs — then at Peter, who was still sulking.
She parted her lips to try and talk to him, but someone touched her shoulder.
She turned her head slowly in the opposite direction, her brows knitting when she realised who it was.
Evan Rosier stood there in the same costume he’d worn the year before.
Barty was in an entirely purple suit, and she heard Peter exclaim in surprise that he’d come dressed as Kilgrave.
Regulus, standing between the two, had his hair tousled, dark sunglasses, a brown leather jacket, and a diatonic harmonica fitted into a neck holder.
She rubbed her eyes with her wrists as though needing confirmation of what she was seeing.
“Bob Dylan?!” she asked Regulus, who merely exhaled sharply through his nose and twisted his mouth in exasperation.
“Yeah, he lost a bet and had to come dressed like that…” Barty laughed, slinging an arm around Red’s shoulders. “Poor bastard.”
Scarlett couldn’t hold back a burst of laughter at Regulus’s discomfort with the costume. Bloody hell — if she didn’t know it was him, she might’ve asked for an autograph thinking he was Dylan.
It was strange how light she felt — the tingling in her hands spreading to her arms and even her toes. Things around her seemed to be happening a little slower, while she herself reacted a little too quickly.
“What’s so funny?” Evan asked, brows drawn together.
Scarlett simply waved it off, gesturing that it was nothing important.
“I dunno. I didn’t understand a bloody thing Crouch just said.” She let out a loud laugh.
“What did you take?” Barty seemed very interested, dragging Regulus a little closer to her. “Weed or forest herb?”
“I didn’t take anything. I don’t do drugs.” Scarlett dismissed his assumptions with a shrug, her gaze drifting to Red. “Have you lot been in the maze yet?”
“Not yet,” Regulus replied, taking off his sunglasses. “What’s so special about it?”
“I’m thirsty.” Scar completely ignored his question, making an attempt to stand.
“I’ll get you some water.” Red pressed his lips together, though his eyes were smiling.
“Well… see you around.” Evan stretched his mouth into a wicked little grin before melting into the crowd with Barty.
Sirius appeared moments later, flopping onto the bench beside her and pulling her under his arm. His handsome face was relaxed, full of easy smirks and mischievous glances.
“Prongs and Wormtail are on their way,” he announced, tugging Scarlett closer.
“Did you wash your hands after the loo?”
“Yes.” Sirius narrowed his eyes. He sniffed one hand. Then the other. Pressed his lips together in a guilty little pout.
“No.” he corrected himself — and dashed off as quickly as he’d arrived.
Regulus reappeared the moment his brother vanished. He set the glass down in front of Scarlett and sat exactly where Sirius had been.
“Are you having fun?” he asked, leaning his elbows on the table — expression as carefully measured as ever.
Scarlett nodded with a lazy smile.
“Loads.” She placed her hands behind her head. She felt like she hadn't had fun like this in ages.
Regulus looked genuinely pleased with her answer, even allowing himself a tiny smile. He didn’t have a chance to say more, though, because Sirius returned with James and Peter. And then — in that precise instant — the song playing (which Scarlett hadn’t paid the slightest attention to until now) made her jolt so violently she knocked all the drinks off the table.
[Toto — I’ll Supply the Love]
She didn’t care in the slightest. She threw her arms around Sirius with such force he almost lost his balance.
“Sirius!” she shouted. “TOTO!”
He laughed and nodded, scooping her up and spinning her towards the dance floor.
There was a blaze of excitement in Scarlett’s eyes — so pure, so raw, so visceral — that even as Sirius laughed, he felt an ache rise in his throat.
He wanted to cry.
When was the last time he’d seen her shine like that?
With such unguarded smiles, with that childlike, effortless lightness?
It was as though the heavy cloak of tragedy that had clung to Scarlett for months had finally been lifted from her shoulders, revealing the version of her he loved most: joyful, silly, laughing without restraint.
Sirius twirled her across the dance floor, the white fabric of her Leia costume flowing around her like the crest of gentle waves on a sun-lit afternoon. He couldn’t take his eyes off her — off her flushed cheeks, the freckles dusting her face, the clear blue of her eyes freed at last from everything she had been carrying since the summer.
It was like watching the sun rise after months of darkness.
Scarlett held onto his shoulders and he drew her close, fitting her body against his. His hands slid to her waist — the same place he had gripped earlier with such desperate force that he’d left marks. Heat pooled between them, driving their racing heartbeats and sharpening the way they looked at one another.
I met the girl across the sea
She saved my life and came with me
A tender night of dark persuasion
Could be my first and last occasion
Nothing else mattered, and soon the world around them ceased to exist.
Sirius took Scarlett’s face in both hands, diving into her eyes with the same fervour as a man burnt, broken, and condemned who finally glimpses salvation. He tilted his head and kissed her.
He kissed her the way flowers bloom in spring;
the way sunlight caresses a petal;
the way the wind carries fresh dew across a field of green.
People danced and spun and jumped around them, but the two of them scarcely moved.
They were statues — two lovers in the midst of a feverish crowd. There was no space between them; Sirius made sure of that. His movements were slow, drawing her into a reality that belonged only to the two of them. The brush of tongues, the drag of lips, the pounding of hearts — all perfectly synchronised. They had done this countless times, so it came instinctively, yet every kiss was its own universe.
And this one — this one wasn’t marked by urgency or fire; it was serenity, fulfilment.
There was desire, of course — there always was, a searing desire that slipped beneath the skin like ecstatic, aching splinters — but more than that, there was tenderness. There was belonging… and love.
Sirius’s tattooed, ring-laden hands glided down Scarlett’s shoulders, settling at the curve of her waist as he pulled her tighter against him, while she threaded her fingers through the soft hair at the nape of his neck, electricity crackling between their bodies like multicoloured sparks searching for flame.
Oh, if Sirius Black could, he would have dissolved both their clothes and taken her right there on the dance floor, in front of everyone.
He was an exhibitionist — he’d have no problem with that — but it wasn’t the moment.
He was aroused, of course he was; a single kiss from Scarlett was enough to make him hard. But more than the insistence in his cock, he was aware of the way his blood surged through his body, full and alive.
How long had it been since he’d felt like that — simply a man in love, with the woman he adored in his arms?
He tangled his tongue with hers before breaking the kiss, mouth still parted as he drank in the breath he’d lost, Scarlett’s damp lips so close to his that he inhaled the air leaving her lungs.
“I love you, Sirius,” she whispered, the three little words vibrating against his mouth and echoing through his heart. “I love you so much.”
“I love you too, kitten.” Sirius claimed her lips again with such longing that their teeth clicked, their tongues tangled, and their mouths smiled into one another. “Very much.”
Baby, I’ll supply the love
Baby, I’ll supply the—
I’ll supply the love
Scarlett let out a muffled laugh, her face adorably flushed.
Sirius seized the moment to spin her. This time, when she came back to him, he pulled her against his chest from behind, resting his chin on her shoulder, his arms wrapped possessively around her waist, his nose tracing the pulse running along her slender neck.
Scarlett shivered head to toe, her hands instinctively finding his and lacing their fingers just above her belly. She closed her eyes, letting herself drift with the moment as Sirius’s breath lashed warmly against her throat. The tempo of the song rose, but the two of them kept to a lazy sway, hips sliding side to side, entirely unbothered by the music’s urgency.
They barely noticed Lily — still at their table — taking her tenth photo of them.
When the song ended, Scarlett looked up at Sirius with a breathless, foolish grin.
“Can we go back? I’m dying of thirst.”
Sirius nodded, raking a hand through his impeccably unruly hair.
“Yeah, come on — I’m starving…”
They returned to the table.
James had just downed a massive tankard of Butterbeer, his expression still twisted in discomfort.
“For Merlin’s sake, Prongs, you’re shitting yourself and you’re drinking beer?” Sirius dropped into the chair beside him.
“Peter said it’d make me feel better!” James protested, jabbing a finger towards Wormtail.
“I–I mean… beer helps…”
“Of course it doesn’t help, Wormtail, have you gone mad?!” Sirius practically shouted, slamming his hand onto the table. Then he inhaled deeply, trying to summon that gentle calm that had wrapped around him earlier. “Come on, I’ll take you to the loo. Let’s sort this once and for all…”
Sirius dragged James through the crowd.
Scarlett bit the inside of her cheek, glancing at the watch on Remus’s wrist — since he was far too busy snogging Mary beside her to check the time himself:
22:02
“Here. Your water — the one you forgot.” Regulus set the glass on the table.
Scarlett smiled and downed it in one go.
“Cheers.” She wiped the sweat from her face with the sleeve of her dress.
On the other side of the table, Edmund Bones asked Lily to dance. She accepted with a smile and was soon swallowed by the moving crowd. Peter, quick to take her seat for himself, didn’t seem quite so bothered anymore. In fact, he even attempted a smile as he watched the couples on the dance floor.
Scarlett was about to ask him why he wasn’t sulking anymore when Regulus stole her attention by leaning forward across the table.
“So… I’ve been thinking…” He tilted his head, as though weighing his next words. “About what you said earlier… about me not knowing who I am.”
“And have you figured it out yet?” Scarlett spun her empty glass between her fingers.
“No… I don’t think so, but… when did you?”
Scarlett narrowed her eyes, lifting one brow.
“What do you mean?”
“How did you work out who you are?”
She scratched her chin, watching a bat swoop over the bobbing heads on the dance floor.
Who was she?
Scarlett Gaunt, of course — but… who was she truly? Beneath the masks, the pretence, the social expectations?
The first thing that came to mind was… the girl who’d lost her family. At least, that’s what everyone whispered when she walked the corridors of Hogwarts.
But she wasn’t only that, was she?
No. Of course not.
She was also Slytherin’s Beater, one of the best students in her year, Sirius’s girlfriend, a friend to James, Remus, Peter, Lily, Pandora… she was… she was Toto’s biggest fan, a skilled boxer, and above all, she was—
Why was it so hard to think about it?
She was only seventeen — she wasn’t supposed to know exactly who she was.
Just like she shouldn’t expect Regulus to know either. She’d said it because she didn’t believe he was capable of becoming a Death Eater — even if he walked with them. At the same time, she wanted him to see that…
“Red… you’re so much more than what your parents shaped you to be.” Scarlett tapped the back of his hand. “You’re… a frightened boy.” She stroked the rim of her glass with her thumb. “And frightened boys can be dangerous. Unpredictable, willing to do anything to survive — especially hurt the people who care about them.”
Regulus raised his eyebrows with that doubtful, unyielding expression of his, as though she were uttering blasphemy.
Scarlett was about to continue, but her mouth snapped shut as a strange sensation ran down her legs. She looked down — and saw a red stain blooming across the white of her dress.
“Ah, shit…” she muttered with a grimace. “You’ve got to be kidding me — I can’t be bloody menstruating now.”
“You alright?” Someone held her shoulder. Scarlett lifted her gaze slowly, realising it was Pandora. “You’ve been staring down for a while…”
Scarlett nodded, forcing a smile.
“Yeah, yeah… I just—” She cleared her throat. “I need some air.”
With a flick of her wand she cleaned herself up.
She had no idea how she left the Three Broomsticks — only noticed she was outside when a cold gust brushed her cheeks. She braced both hands on the low wall beside her, the stones icy against her palms. And then it happened again.
She looked down and hissed when another blot of red stained the white of her dress.
“I’m not supposed to be on my period today!” she snapped at herself, irritated.
She cast the spell again to clean it, almost uselessly — the blood returned.
“Scar… I don’t think that’s menstruation.” Pandora’s voice came from beside her, but sounded so distant that Scarlett jerked upright in shock when she realised her friend was actually there.
Scarlett blinked several times, trying to clear her vision, which was beginning to cloud.
“I… I’m fine,” she tried to smile, though it likely looked more like a grimace, her breathing far heavier than it should’ve been.
“You’re far too pale…” Regulus’s voice echoed.
She looked around for him, but everything was a blur. She could tell Pandora and Regulus were arguing, but she couldn’t understand a word.
Then something caught her and her head tipped back, eyes straining to focus on the autumn sky. The stars were there — she knew they were — but she couldn’t distinguish them, no matter how much she searched for the brightest one.
“Look… the stars… dancing…” Scarlett gasped and clung to a leather jacket.
Which was the brightest star in the night sky?
Sirius.
“Sirius… he… he went…” she murmured — but then the sky vanished, replaced by a padded ceiling.
She stretched a hand towards it, imagining how soft the fabric must feel, but she couldn’t reach. Then came staircases. Corridors. Characters in the portraits stared at her as though she were a dying woman. Something squeezed her numb hand.
“Scar, don’t faint, alright? Stay with me.” Pandora’s words lashed through her mind like a whip. With me, with me, with me.
“What?” Scarlett asked, laughing weakly through the pain. “I don’t… I didn’t… get it… Pan…”
“I’m right here.” The hand squeezed hers again.
Scarlett stared, distracted, at Pan’s nails — painted purple and black.
“Almost there,” Regulus said, drawing her gaze.
“Why’re you so serious? Relax… it’s just my period.” Scarlett lifted a finger and tapped the tip of his nose.
Unlike Sirius’s, Red’s was rounded, which gave him a slightly younger look. Not that he wasn’t young — he was two years younger than her and Sirius — but Regulus clearly didn’t have Sirius’s masculine, sharp features. No. His face was much more… delicate.
“Get her on the bed, now.” She recognised that voice.
Not the delicate kind of feminine, mind — even if Regulus had Sirius’s hair, he wouldn’t be mistaken for a girl. Or would he?
Scarlett’s eyes widened as he suddenly moved away, pulling her focus from his features. She laughed to herself at the thought.
“Bloody hell, Red… do you know what I just realised? If you grew your hair out—” She didn’t finish, because someone forced a potion down her throat, making her choke.
The strange, heavy taste made her consciousness lurch in a way she did not like. Her mind spun, lights around her warped, and Regulus and Pandora’s faces were nothing but smeared blots on her retinas.
“I don’t want to stay here.” She faltered. “Where’s Sirius?”
“…miscarriage.” That known-unknown voice thundered through her exhausted mind.
“What?” She rubbed her eyes, trying to understand.
When she finally saw Regulus and Pandora clearly again, they were looking at her the same way everyone had looked at her after she lost her parents. Like she was some poor, fragile thing.
“I want to go to my room.” She tried to stand, but a firm hand pushed her back onto the bed.
“You need to stay here for observation,” insisted the person behind her.
Scarlett shook her head over and over.
“I’m not staying here… not a fucking chance…” She forced herself up again, but her legs buckled. Regulus was quick enough to catch her before she hit the floor.
Scarlett dug her nails into his shirt, bringing her lips close to his ear.
“Don’t tell Sirius about this, please.”
“Alright,” he whispered, just for her.
“I’ll take her to the dormitory, Madam Pomfrey—”
“Good. She needs rest.”
Pomfrey?
Oh, of course it was Pomfrey.
Wait — if that was Pomfrey, then… she was in the hospital wing, which meant something had happened, which meant—
Miscarriage.
What?
No. That was impossible.
So impossible that Scarlett burst out laughing again as Regulus carried her towards the DCAT Tower, Pandora walking beside them and rambling about something Scarlett could not be bothered to care about.
“Did you hear me, Scar? The Draught of Melancholy affects the effectiveness of the Contraceptive Potion and—”
Wait a second — she took those two potions.
Yes, of course she had to take them, especially because…
Scarlett’s laugh turned wicked as she remembered what she and Sirius had done earlier.
“Where’s Sirius?” she asked. She recognised that hall — the one that led to the clock of the Undercroft. “I want to shag him again today.”
“Sweet Merlin…” Pandora muttered, hand over her mouth.
“What did those boys give her?”
“Weed… I think.”
Scarlett felt Regulus’s chest rise and fall beneath her cheek.
Her fingers toyed with the harmonica holder hanging from his neck, pulling it down to her face and then lifting it back towards Red’s chin.
“What happened?” Sirius’s voice made her stretch her legs.
He was standing in front of the clock, beside a thoroughly drained-looking James.
“I… don’t know,” Scarlett shrugged — with much less enthusiasm than she believed she was showing. “We were at the Three Broomsticks and now… we’re in Hogwarts!”
Sirius laughed — a sound that made her smile as well.
“Told you not to eat too many brownies — you’re completely off your head.” He shook his own, glancing at his brother, who looked nowhere near as happy as he did.
Regulus looked from James to Sirius. The older one understood at once, his smile withering as he turned to his friend.
“Go to the gallery, Prongs. I’ll meet you there.”
Scarlett barely noticed James stepping into the clock. No — she only had eyes for Sirius.
“I’m heading back to the party. Will you all be alright?” Pandora touched her shoulder, making Scarlett shift in Regulus’s arms as she tried to wriggle free.
“I’m going too!” Her expression lit up with anticipation.
Regulus held her firmly, not letting her slip away.
“No, you’re not,” he said, jaw tightening.
“What’s going on, Regulus?”
Scarlett watched, stunned, as Red licked his lips and adopted an unbearable, stony façade before saying:
“Scarlett had a miscarriage.”
Wait — what the fuck was he doing?!
She had literally told him not to say anything… what, fifteen minutes ago?
Scarlett opened her mouth, outraged, desperate to punch him — but the indignation in Sirius’s voice knocked her out of orbit for a few seconds.
“What?” he roared, the word ripping through the silent corridor.
“T-the Draught of Melancholy she takes…” Scarlett felt Regulus’s body shudder even though he showed no fear at all. “It interferes with the contraceptive potion. She should have been using more than one meth—”
“What do you mean, miscarriage?” Sirius ignored every other word, as though only the beginning of the sentence had registered.
Regulus rolled his eyes, mocking.
“You know perfectly well what that means, Sirius.” He put so much indifference into the words that Scarlett knew it was taking effort — monumental effort — for him to hold himself together. “You two cannot have a child!”
Scarlett wanted desperately to end the argument right there, but everything was happening too fast for her to react. The next moment, Sirius tore her from Regulus’s arms like a predator protecting his mate, his features twisting into arrogance and defiance so quickly Scarlett flinched.
There was something vicious lurking in the shadows of his beautiful, angular face.
“And why not?” he provoked, his tone dripping with venom.
Regulus stepped back, drawing his shoulders in.
If he had been in Mittens’s skin, he’d be flattening his ears, hissing, baring his teeth.
“You can’t!” he repeated, voice trembling.
Sirius tilted his head slightly, darkness slotting into place over his face — a cruel, unreadable mask he kept carefully stored and only ever donned when pain scraped raw at his heart.
“Afraid of being replaced, are you, Reg?” A wicked smile stained her boyfriend’s lips. “Because I’m certain Orion would replace you in a heartbeat…” He snapped his fingers. “With a Black of the Signet. That’s what he always wanted, isn’t it? A Black with the Signet.”
Regulus’s laugh was acidic — so acidic Scarlett felt as though the tips of her fingers were dissolving in the sound.
“For all that he liked you, Sirius, I doubt he’d ever put a blood-traitor back—”
“He never liked me!” Sirius roared, making Scarlett jump, his harsh voice frightening even the portraits nearby.
“Of course he did — you were his favourite! He did everything for you!”
“He didn’t like me! I never had anyone in that house! I was always alone. You had Walburga and Kreacher. I had no one! And now—” He looked at Scarlett, tightening his hold on her as though she might suddenly be ripped away from him. “And now that I finally have someone… you think you have the right to tell me what I can or can’t do?!”
Regulus swallowed hard, fists clenched, a vein standing out on his forehead.
“Stop lying, Sirius! You always had your friends!”
“Only after I came to Hogwarts!” Sirius fired back, yanking a barbed thread straight out of his chest. “Only after I started at this school did I learn what the word family meant!”
“Oh, right. Potter, Lupin, Pettigrew… Scarlett… they’re your family.”
“Exactly.” He spat the word — fast, sharp, like the crack of a whip.
Regulus took another step back as if he’d just been punched. His face drained of colour.
Scarlett finally managed to intervene, her hands gripping the leather of Sirius’s vest tightly to draw his attention.
“Love… can we… can we go to bed?”
Sirius leaned in to look at her, the indignation on his face softened by that raw, aching thing that bound them both.
He pressed a gentle kiss to her forehead, then to her hair, settling her carefully in his arms.
“Of course, kitten.” His voice was soft now, tender — as though someone entirely different were speaking through him.
He lifted his gaze to Regulus one last time, the silver of his eyes solid and sharp with a muted threat. Then, without another word, he turned and stepped through the clock with Scarlett in his arms.
Regulus remained where he was, watching the clock’s hands turn slowly until it closed again.
Until he was alone.
As always.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 72: Even with her becoming who she became
Chapter Text
CXL
"Do you need help?" Sirius asked, leaning against the bedpost as he watched Scarlett getting changed.
"No." She threw the white dress into a corner and pulled on the first T-shirt she found.
Sirius ran a hand through his hair, still wearing that ridiculous costume. He unbuckled the holster at his waist and tried to get his trousers off, but his fingers were far too numb for that.
"About the misscarriage…"
"I don’t want to talk about it." Scarlett silenced him, pretending not to care.
"But I want to." He insisted, his gaze drifting to the The Doors poster on the wall before returning to her. His eyes, previously softened, now held layers of vulnerability. "What are you feeling?"
Scarlett climbed onto the bed, lazily crawling across it before burrowing under the covers, considering what to say.
"Relief." She exhaled as she settled on the pillow, propping her face in her palm with her elbow on the mattress so she could look at him.
"Relief?" He didn’t hide the distressed tone. "Why?"
She massaged her temples. Scarlett was clearly out of sorts because of the brownie, but Sirius knew that the moment she closed her eyes, she would sleep like a corpse, and they’d only be able to talk about it the next morning.
And he couldn’t bear to wait the whole night for it.
"Well, Sirius, I don’t want to have a baby in the middle of a bloody war!" Despite her drowsy tone, the irritation was unmistakable in her sentence. "Sorry." She looked at him and wrapped her arms around herself, embarrassed.
But Sirius wanted it. He didn’t care about the war or the fact they hadn’t finished school yet. Of course it wasn’t ideal or planned, but… he wanted it. Wanted it so badly that Scarlett’s answer felt like a knife driven straight into his heart. He would have raised that child with all the love he never had, shown Orion and Walburga what a family actually was, and, most importantly, made the Black name something to be proud of and not… not something drenched in disgrace.
Sirius had his family, of course—his friends… yet he still longed to build his own.
"I would have." He whispered, hoping Scarlett was asleep.
She wasn’t.
"And you’d be an incredible father." She patted the mattress twice beside her. "You still will be."
She didn’t need to call him twice. Sirius lay down, diving through the blankets until he wrapped himself around Scarlett, resting his face against her stomach, feeling her thin, pale fingers threading through his hair in a soft, affectionate caress.
That was the memory lingering in his mind as the cold water lashed his back. His hands were braced against the white tiles, eyes fixed on the droplets sliding down his feet into the drain.
I would’ve forgiven you. Because that’s what I always did, Sirius. I always forgave your shit. Always… always believed in you, Scarlett’s voice lashed the walls of his conscience so violently he could feel them bleed, even though the only thing running down his face were tears mixed with water.
How could he forgive the woman he loved—who had destroyed him?
The answer was simple: he couldn’t.
I never wanted… never wanted to hurt you. When… when I gave Reg your name, even drugged up… it wasn’t to steal your dream, Sirius… but to make it real.
He clenched his fists against the freezing wall. Scarlett was so cruel she thought… she actually thought he would accept his brother’s child. And the worst part was that… he still desired her desperately. And he regretted, deeply, having opened his mouth that morning when they argued. He should have kept quiet, no matter how hard it was to hold back everything he’d wanted to unleash on Scarlett. No matter that… no matter that a part of him longed to hate her and take revenge on her with the same intensity.
Something Sirius would never do. He was far too much of a Gryffindor for that.
That was why he swallowed the tidal wave crashing against his chest and stepped out of the shower. He dried his hair with a charm, tied it into a ponytail, trimmed his beard close to the skin and pulled on his Queen T-shirt before leaving the bedroom.
"Penny, did you warn my mum to be careful today?" He heard Reggie ask, following his voice into the living room.
"Yes, Young Master." The elf turned her bulging eyes towards Sirius. "I also delivered your message, Master Sirius."
"What message?" Harry asked, his eyes glued to the telly while he faced one of the bosses on Mega Man X.
"Nothing important." Sirius put his hands on his hips as he watched his godson clear the stage with ease. "Did she reply?"
"She told Penny she’ll come to the barbecue as Whiskers." Penny gave a pleased little smile as she watched Reggie sit beside Harry.
"Right. Your guests should be arriving any minute now, shouldn’t they?!" Sirius checked his pocket watch, his nostrils flaring slightly at the smile he wore in the photo with Lily, James, Remus and Peter, with Reggie on his lap.
As if summoned by his question, the doorbell rang. Harry paused the game, and Regulus craned his neck in an attempt to see who had arrived. The door was opened by Remus.
A girl with very fluffy brown hair and rather large front teeth stood at the doorway, accompanied by her parents. She smiled as Remus greeted her.
"Professor Lupin!"
"Hello, Hermione. And you must be the parents…"
Sirius simply turned back towards the garden exit, greeted by the scorching sun and the muggy morning breeze. He shoved his hands into his trouser pockets and watched the rays of light scatter their glow across the freshly cleaned water. He had bought a house with a pool so Scarlett could swim and…
He curled his lips. Why was he still thinking about her? He should be lighting the bloody barbecue, not…
"What are you thinking about?" Tonks practically shouted beside him. Sirius shot her a murderous look and she grinned, her eyes shifting colour until they settled into a shade of green very similar to Harry’s. "Your dead fiancée?" She flashed a mocking smile, receiving an elbow in return. "Oi!"
"Oh, there you are!" A voice he hadn’t heard in a long while left him frozen.
The woman with dark brown eyes and light brown hair opened her arms, and Sirius didn’t hesitate to be enveloped by them as he embraced her back. Andromeda looked older—well, they all did—but even the small wrinkles at the corners of her eyes and mouth weren’t enough to take the kindness out of her large gaze.
Something her sisters certainly lacked. Unlike Bellatrix, who resembled Sirius quite a bit, Andromeda and he hardly looked related at all. There was almost nothing Black about her; she had inherited nearly all her looks from her mother’s Rosier side.
"You look gorgeous, Sirius!" She held his chin between her thumb and forefinger and planted a kiss on each cheek. "But those tattoos make you look like a delinquent!"
"It’s part of my charm, Dromeda." Grinning like a boy, Sirius stepped out of the hug and faced Ted Tonks, blond and pot-bellied as always. "Ted." He shook his hand firmly.
"Sirius." He smiled, glancing toward his daughter. "How are you?"
The question shouldn’t have caught him off guard, but Sirius had no answer for it, so he merely pretended to check on Harry, Reggie and Hermione as they entered the aviary to see Buckbeak, then turned his attention back to the three adults.
"So, we brought sausages and coleslaw." Andromeda pulled her wand from her pocket and guided the food towards the table by the pool. "How long has it been since I last came here?!"
"Fifteen years?" Ted looked at his wife, holding her by the waist.
"Merlin, you’re old." Nymphadora rolled her eyes. "I didn’t know you lived with more people… besides Regulus and Harry Potter." She nodded towards Remus, who joined the group with that naturally observant look of his.
"Dora, this is Remus Lupin. Moony, this is my cousin, Tonks." Sirius introduced them with disinterest. "We studied together."
"Oh, so this is the famous Moony!" Nymphadora flashed a radiant smile as she greeted him, her short purple hair shifting into a garish pink. "Pleasure."
"Likewise." Was all Remus said, without even looking at her.
Sirius frowned at him, his gaze travelling across the garden. He raised a hand and muttered that he was going to fetch the charcoal.
"He’s always been shy…" Andromeda smiled, pulling Sirius along with her to the sun loungers by the pool’s edge. She sat on one and forced him to sit beside her. "Oh, he looks so much like you…" Her smile was just the same as ever.
Sirius followed her line of sight, stopping where Reg, Harry and Hermione emerged from the aviary. The girl laughed loudly, throwing furtive glances at Reggie, who was far too busy explaining why Whitesnake was the greatest rock band of the moment.
"You think so?" Sirius looked at her sideways. "I’ve always thought he looked like Regulus."
Andromeda shook her head with a quiet laugh.
"You and Regulus were practically a copy of one another, Sirius."
"Which only proves my point." He lifted his chin with condescension, earning a slap on the back.
"I see you’re still as arrogant as ever." Andromeda drummed her painted nails on his shoulder, eyeing the tattoos on his arm.
"Runs in the family." Sirius retorted, with his innate cheekiness. He stood and waved for Reg and Harry to come over. "Boys, this is Andromeda, my cousin."
"Hi." Harry limited himself to a wave from afar.
Regulus, on the other hand, quickened his step and embraced her.
"I remember my gran pointing to your name on the burnt tapestry…" He received a kiss on his hair.
"Oh, if that isn’t an honour—being burned off that stupid tapestry." She shot Sirius an amused look, then turned back to him. "You look like your father."
"You knew him?!"
"Of course I knew him. Charming boy. Loved pancakes with strawberries."
Sirius let out a short laugh. He didn’t remember Regulus liking Uncle Alphard’s pancakes as well, but then, it wasn’t as if he recalled much of his childhood anyway. He looked back just in time to see Tonks trip and be caught by Remus before she could fall face-first onto the corner of the pool.
"I swear I don’t know how she’s still alive…" Andromeda admitted, and the two of them laughed.
"So this is where the barbecue is?" A dark-skinned girl with black eyes and black hair appeared through the side entrance to the garden, carrying a cooler under one arm and a stuffed bag under the other.
"Lua!" Regulus hurried over to his friend, followed by Harry and Hermione, whose conversation revolved around the boy’s stay at the house.
"If I see a vegetable on that grill, heads are going to roll!" she declared; the chains around her neck gleamed so brightly under the sun that it was nearly impossible to look directly at her. "Hello, Mr Black." She waved to Sirius, who merely nodded. "Uncle Remus!"
Sirius tapped his heel against the ground, smiling as he watched Harry turn to the side when Ron and the twins arrived, hugging them with a contagious excitement—though not quite enough to reach his godfather.
"So, Harry, what do you say to a game of Quidditch today? We brought our brooms!" Fred lifted the two brooms.
"Blimey, what a mansion!" George gripped the straps of his rucksack as he took in the garden. "Oi, Teixeira, fancy a sweet?" His lips twisted into a wicked grin.
Luana merely lifted her middle finger, far too focused on lighting the barbecue. Harry was telling Hermione, Ron and the twins how Sirius and… (he lowered his voice so no one would hear Scarlett’s name) had fetched him from the Dursleys’ house.
Victoria Rookwood was next to arrive, wearing an enormous hat, sunglasses, and an old-fashioned dress. Reggie dropped everything he was doing to hug her, which made Sirius press his lips together in a distracted smile.
The last ones were Orfy and June, who greeted Tonks and Remus and waved to Sirius and Andromeda. Their arrival made Sirius’s smile falter, and his uneasy gaze drifted over the apple trees and the pool as he rubbed his sweaty hands on his trousers.
"I’d forgotten Orfeu was Scarlett’s brother…" Andromeda whispered, narrowing her eyes at the boy with his hair tied back and those green eyes. "I remember her. You came… at Christmas? To our house."
Sirius swallowed hard, his neck so tense he barely managed to nod.
"Her parents… they were good people." She held one of his hands. "Did you know June and Nymphadora are best friends?! Never thought June would end up dating Orfeu, of all people."
"It’s hard for me to imagine he’s old enough for that…" Sirius stretched his lips in a timid smile. "Even Reg is dating…" He pointed towards his nephew and Victoria, still wrapped in a hug as they joined Harry’s group.
"And he’s old enough for that?" Andromeda furrowed her brow. "Metamorphmagus?"
"And pure-blood, from what I’ve heard." Sirius nodded. "Rookwood. She’s Augustus’s niece… you know, the Death Eater who was locked up…"
"There’s always a black sheep in the family." Andromeda pulled a tin case from her beige handbag and offered Sirius a cigarette.
He accepted.
"Or two." He added, lighting her cigarette first, then his own.
"But what about you?"
Sirius straightened, Andromeda’s oblique gaze slicing through all his defences as if they were made of paper.
"Me what?"
"Are you dating anyone?"
He choked on the smoke, coughing out a laugh at the same time. He used his wand to summon the ashtray from the table, tapping his cigarette against it.
"No."
"No?"
"No." He pressed his lips together and shrugged. "Nothing serious, at least."
"You’ve always been a promiscuous one."
Sirius placed a hand on his chest dramatically, giving her a sideways look.
"Me?"
"Yes, when you weren’t dating someone, you were out there snogging everyone you laid eyes on."
"I never did that."
"Of course you did. In fact, I was rather surprised you finally settled down with someone. Shame she wasn’t the person we thought she was. Her parents were so…" She sighed. "Well, apparently she was the black sheep of the family too."
Sirius exhaled smoke in a long stream.
"She wasn’t the black sheep of the family."
"How not?" Andromeda drew on her cigarette. "Her parents were members of the Order, did everything they could to defeat Voldemort, but she…"
He forced a smile. Behind it, his teeth ground together.
"She’s dead, Andromeda."
"I know." She blew the smoke out through her nose. "At least she left something good in the world." She looked at Reggie arguing about Quidditch with the twins. "Does it still bother you? What she did?"
Sirius narrowed his eyes slightly as he smoked. Since when had Andromeda become so nosy?
"Does it bother me that the great love of my life traded me for my brother? No, not at all." He lowered his gaze to his own restless feet.
"Oh, sweetheart…" Andromeda ran a gentle hand along his back. "I’m so sorry."
Sirius brought the cigarette back to his mouth, the tip glowing.
I know what I did to you, Sirius. And I regret it—deeply. But if to you I’ll always be the woman who betrayed you with your brother, then it’s best… it’s best we end this—whatever this is between us. I don’t want to hurt you anymore. I’ve done that enough.
"Yeah… me too."
.
.
.
There are two ways of avoiding a hangover: not drinking, or not stopping drinking.
Scarlett chose the second option.
That was why, when she woke up, she was already wrapped around a bottle of wine while her ghosts followed her through the flat with their eyes.
"Did you hear what Penny told you earlier?" James entered the bathroom with her, passing straight through the door without the slightest shame.
Scarlett got rid of her clothes, lifting her gaze to him; her glassy irises flickered faintly at his question.
"No." She turned the shower on, stepping under it and leaning her back against the cold wall.
James turned his back, and Scarlett left the frosted curtain open, water spraying across the entire bathroom. She didn’t need to look sideways to notice Lily’s presence. The two of them had been desperate to speak to her in the days following her fight with Sirius, but she had purposely ignored them.
"I can feel you pitying me from here." Scarlett said, scrubbing her face in an attempt to wake herself up.
"We didn’t know…" James began, but Lily silenced him by grabbing his arm.
"Why?" Lily drew closer, the droplets passing straight through her, her pale glow reflected on the colourful tiles of the shower stall.
Despite looking at her, it wasn’t Lily that Scarlett saw. No. She shuddered and lowered her head, watching the water slide across her ashen fingers, over her Ouroboros and the burn scar on her right forearm. She swallowed with difficulty, tension locking her jaw and tightening her expression. It was almost as though she were in pain.
She had never spoken about this with anyone other than Regulus.
Firstly, she couldn’t. The pact ensured she couldn’t. Secondly… it was such a gut-wrenching matter, one that made her feel so pathetic, that it was better to choke the words back. She had been so stupid, foolish and idiotic to think…
"I had a miscarriage on Halloween of ’77." Her voice came out low and wavering. "That was… the main reason Sirius started drinking. Then… Regulus…" She pressed her lips together and lifted one shoulder in a faint, defeated shrug. "became a Death Eater and… things got worse. I watched him drink himself senseless because he’d lost his brother… crying and blaming himself… then I found out I was pregnant. I tried… to tell him. But he was drunk all the time… I thought that… that if I saved Regulus…"
She closed her eyes, tilting her head subtly from side to side, the weight of the worst decision of her life crushing every feeling that tried to surface, leaving only regret. The clear water danced over her pale skin, trailing across her tattoos and scars. Gathering at the edge of her long lashes, the cold droplets mixing with her hot tears. Pushing her hair forward over her face.
"I wanted… to give him… the family he deserved."
Scarlett slid down the wall until she sat on the floor, hugging her knees with such force her nails were digging into her arms. She locked herself up, pushing away the sobs, the crying and the sniffling. Her anguished eyes stared at no particular point as water blurred her vision. Or was it the tears?
It didn’t matter.
Lily sat beside her on one side. James on the other.
"I knew." He murmured. "I always knew, I told Sirius, I… I told him Reg was his, that…"
"Marl knew." Lily revealed, in a failed attempt to embrace her. "That’s why… when we went to the beach…"
"That’s why she had to die, Lils." Her voice echoed, distorted, against the bathroom walls. "She knew. I just didn’t expect… the whole McKinnon family wasn’t supposed to be together that night."
Lily covered her face with her hands. She was crying too.
"Voldemort couldn’t know Sirius was Reg’s father." James pieced it together. "He’d have killed him…"
Scarlett nodded miserably.
"It was all for him… all this bloody mess… it was for him." She focused on the sound of the water running through her hair. "But he can’t see that. He’ll never be able to."
"No, Scar… you… you can…" James began to suggest, only for Scarlett to cut him off.
"I can’t tell him. I made a pact with Orion. I can only… after they find out about him. So that, in case I were tortured…" She massaged her throat. It felt as if a serpent were coiled around it, squeezing tighter and tighter. "I wouldn’t reveal the secret. And it worked, I didn’t speak even under torture in Azkaban…"
"They… asked you that?" James tried to support her, only for his hand to pass straight through.
"Everyone doubted Reg’s paternity, Jamie. All the Death Eaters." Scarlett let out a tortured breath. "Except Rosier and Crouch. I don’t know what Regulus told them, but both were very loyal to him. More than they were to Voldemort, I’d dare say. They were the only ones who stood by our side."
"Rosier? More loyal to Red than to Voldemort?" Lily murmured, sceptical. Then she shook her head as though to chase off her bubbling thoughts. "Scar… I’m sorry. For… for having…"
"For all the things we accused you of…" James continued when Lily stammered. "We… we didn’t know…"
"I know. It’s alright." Her lie was so honest the two of them stretched their arms out as if they wanted to embrace her.
"Scar… I’m sorry… truly… if we… if we’d known…" James’s shoulders shook as he could no longer hold back his tears.
"We should have done more… so much more…" Lily wiped her ghostly tears away in anger. "We… we shouldn’t have… oh, Scar, I’m so sorry!"
Scarlett lifted her head slightly, her vision tinged by the glow of the two of them, interlaced with the icy jet of water. As cold as the iron hand crushing her insides, as the boy’s hands she had tried to save, and the unforgiving eyes of the man she loved.
She opened her hands, watching the water pour between her fingers with the same ease with which she had let go of everything to protect Regulus, Orfeu… and Sirius. She should feel proud of that, yes, she had sacrificed herself for them, but…
Scarlett was a Slytherin. What she’d done went against her own self-preservation, so perhaps that was why she despised herself so much. She found no comfort in her noble act, nor in her nonexistent self-worth. Because, in doing so, she had caused immeasurable pain to the people she loved. A pain that, in Sirius’s case, would never be undone.
She regretted her choices and, at the same time, knew there had been no other option.
She let the harsh, suffering tears spill from her crushed heart.
"Yeah… me too." The words vibrated through her unsteady vocal cords and left her resentful lips. "I’m sorry too."
.
.
.
Hermione, Harry and Ron were sitting at the edge of the pool, their feet swaying in the clear water. The sun shone above them, warming their shoulders. Had they not put on sun cream, they would certainly have been burnt. The warm summer breeze brushed Hermione’s voluminous hair, and she looked sideways at Harry.
"So… how are you feeling?" She broke the comfortable silence between them. "I don’t think I’ve ever seen you so… relaxed."
Harry showed a distracted smile, the water reflecting the sunlight onto his glasses.
"It’s strange… feels like a dream, Mione." He admitted, watching the water crash softly against the pool edge. "I’ve got a bedroom just for me… with my things. With Quidditch posters, and Reg put a mount on the wall for my Firebolt. I don’t have to hide who I am anymore…"
"You deserve this, Harry." Ron said, giving him an encouraging pat on the shoulder.
"Do you think this year we’ll be able to celebrate your birthday together?" Hermione asked, hopeful.
Harry lifted his gaze to her, and a genuine smile stretched across his lips.
"That would be brilliant, wouldn’t it?"
"We could throw a themed party!" Ron suggested, pulling his feet out of the water with excitement.
"Themed?" Harry laughed, taken aback.
"Yeah! Like… the Quidditch World Cup? I dunno, something fun." He gestured enthusiastically.
"And we could play Quidditch all day!" Harry added, rubbing his chin. "And then at night, we could have a tournament on the Super Nintendo!"
"On the super what?" Ron raised an eyebrow.
"It’s a video game…" Hermione began to explain, but fell silent when a figure with red hair and dark eyes appeared at the garden entrance.
"Ginny? What are you doing here?" Fred, who had been trading jabs with Luana by the barbecue, immediately headed towards his sister.
George stopped his conversation with Victoria and Reggie to look over his shoulder, going rigid when he realised it was his youngest sister standing there.
"I followed you lot and Dad through the Floo fireplace to here, obviously." She answered, as though it were the most obvious thing in the world.
"You can’t stay here!" George practically shouted, pointing at her. "Mum will kill us if she finds out."
"You’re not going to tell her. Or I’ll tell her about the experiments you’re working on!" she retorted with a mischievous little smile.
The twins exchanged a look. They hadn’t expected a threat of that calibre.
"Are you blackmailing us?!" Fred crossed his arms, outraged.
"Blackmail? No. A deal." She corrected, lifting her chin with haughty confidence.
"You can’t stay, Ginny." Ron cut in, joined by Hermione and Harry.
"I’m not going back." She shot back, resolute. She raised her eyebrows in a subtle challenge.
"But… how are you going to keep your parents from noticing you’re not at home?" Hermione asked, twirling one of her curls around her finger as Reggie also approached.
"They think I’m with Luna. Our neighbour." She answered simply.
Harry pressed his lips together.
"Let her stay. I don’t see a problem with it." He shrugged.
Ginny’s triumphant smile was quickly replaced by embarrassment.
"Thanks, Harry."
"Of course you don’t see a problem, it’s not your head that’ll end up on a spike if Mum and Dad find out!" Fred continued protesting, earning an elbow from George straight to his stomach.
"All the more reason for her to stay, then." Regulus opened a mocking grin, receiving a middle finger from the twin in return. "Lua, is it ready yet?" he shouted to his friend, who was fanning the flames with the lid of a tupperware.
"Not yet!" She fanned even harder.
"I’m starving!" Victoria, lying on one of the sun loungers, placed her hands on her stomach.
"Looks like this barbecue’s only going to be ready tomorrow…" Harry joked.
Hermione tugged Ginny along with her to a corner, while Reggie returned to his girlfriend’s lounger. Harry fell into a heated argument with the twins and Ron about who would be the next captain of the Gryffindor Quidditch team.
Sirius sat at the adults’ table, with Ted Tonks already picking at his wife’s salad while Andromeda explained to Remus why she had never visited Reggie. Tonks and June were laughing loudly about one of their fellow auror trainees receiving a curse that turned his fingers into carrots, and Orfeu limited himself to sipping his beer, throwing occasional glances at Sirius, who pretended to be far too occupied with his fifth cigarette of the day.
Orfy pulled his chair closer, spinning the beer bottle between his fingers as he rested his elbows on his knees.
"I didn’t… I never imagined Reggie would end up with Victoria." He cleared his throat, glancing sideways at Sirius. "She’s our next-door neighbour and they’ve been friends… well, since Reg came to live with us."
"She’s your neighbour?" Sirius tapped his cigarette against the ashtray. "Didn’t know that."
"Nate never liked that friendship, because, well… she’s a Rookwood, but Rem and I always let them play together at the little park near home… of course her mother always tried to pair the two of them up… you know, pure-bloods and all that, but we never allowed any suggestion of that sort when they were younger… I suppose that’s why we never imagined that…" He raised his eyebrows quickly in a twitch, and Sirius answered with a half-smile.
"They’re a lovely couple." He said, exhaling smoke through his nose. His gaze shifted to Victoria, who was rubbing sun cream onto Reg’s pale back. "We bought a ring for him to give her… a promise ring."
Orfeu laughed before taking a long swig of his cold beer. The bottle sweated against his fingers and he dried them on the hem of his beige shorts.
"That’s so old-fashioned." He teased, grabbing a crisp from the snack bowl he’d brought. "You and my sister wore rings too."
Sirius followed the thin trail of smoke rising from his cigarette until it disappeared into the sky. The deep blue held not a trace of cloud, though the closer it came to the horizon, the more it faded. That shade of blue was the same that coloured Scarlett’s eyes when she was radiant.
He knew that because… well, he just knew. He had known Scarlett like the back of his hand, knew all her excesses and all her lacks, knew her crimes and…
No. Scarlett wasn’t the same girl he’d known in the past. As much as he wished to imagine she was, all the things she’d told him…
Sirius closed his eyes, trying to clear his mind. His heart was yanked backwards, as if an invisible thread were trying to tear it out of his chest.
"We did." He answered after a sharp silence. "Orfy… if she were alive… would you have forgiven her?" The words left him before he had time to think them through.
Orfeu pressed his lips together in distaste. He brought the beer to his mouth, but didn’t drink. The burn scars on his arms were evident due to the sleeveless shirt he wore, as was the Signet on his left hand: a serpent coiled upon itself.
"No." He drank the last swallow from the bottle and set it carefully on the table. "How could I?"
Sirius drew from his cigarette, asking himself the exact same question.
"So… you don’t think she would have deserved a second chance?"
"Did the McKinnons get a second chance?" Orfeu’s retort seemed to be already poised on his tongue by the speed with which he answered.
Sirius exhaled heavily, trying to pull his thoughts together. Orfeu didn’t have the full picture, but then, neither did he. Scarlett’s pact and the conversation they’d tried to have…
I sacrificed myself to save you! When Fab and Gid died… I was going to use my cloak to escape, but I didn’t—I gave up my chance of freedom for you! And all your selfish mind can think about is how cruel I was to betray you… but you never saw the bloody signs, you never stopped to wonder if something was wrong!
He squeezed his eyes shut, trying to remember that horrific day when the Prewetts died, but all his mind could summon were shredded, moth-eaten scraps of memory, eaten away by the dementors’ touch. He hadn’t reached that part of his life in therapy yet, and still, something deep in his consciousness told him Scarlett was right. At the same time, what signs would he have noticed? He had been drunk for most of that year. And if it hadn’t been for Reggie… he probably would have died of an overdose or cirrhosis.
"No… they didn’t." He admitted at last.
Another long silence. Sirius felt an endless chill in his stomach, his jaw standing out as he clenched it. He blew away his chaotic thoughts as if extinguishing a hundred candles, turning the rings on his fingers incessantly.
"But… if Regulus hadn’t saved me" Orpheus opened another beer, a soft, serpentine smile tinged with melancholy returning to his face "I wouldn’t be here."
"Regulus saved you." Sirius repeated quietly, as though he still struggled to believe it, even after seeing Nate’s memory.
You never doubted it—because your hatred for Regulus has always been greater than your love for me!
"Thank you, Sirius. For having loved my sister. Even if… even if she didn’t deserve it. Even with her becoming who she became." He gave him a pat on the leg, his sombre eyes fixed on the beer.
Sirius instinctively clenched his hands so tightly the knuckles turned white. He wanted to tell Orfy he hadn’t loved her enough. That his love hadn’t been enough to save her in the past or forgive her in the present.
That his hatred — or love, what difference was there? — for Regulus had blinded him and made him lose the woman he loved.
.
.
.
The sun was already beginning to dip toward the horizon when the barbecue was finally ready. Luana took charge of grilling the meat while Sirius cut it, pausing when she set her cassette player on the table and pressed play.
"Is that Tim Maia?" he asked, tossing the pieces onto a huge platter. Regulus, Harry and Ron were the first to reach in and grab a chunk. "Don’t forget there are more people here who are hungry…" he scolded the boys with a stern look.
"It is." Luana fanned the fire, glancing sideways at him. "Do you like Tim Maia, Mr. Black? It’s just… he’s Brazilian and…"
"I was given a vinyl of his a long time ago…" Sirius licked his fingers, still bloody, making Lua flush and lower her gaze to the meat on the grill. "Wouldn’t be my choice for a barbecue."
"What? Did you sit around listening to ‘Ela Partiu’ while crying because you missed Mrs. Black?!" she teased, making Sirius snort a mocking laugh.
Yes, Lua. That’s exactly what happened.
Luana’s gaze travelled over the tattoos on Sirius’s fingers, up his hand, forearm and triceps, until she found herself wondering when he was going to take his shirt off and jump into the pool.
She had no chance to strike up a conversation, because Sirius soon called all the guests for lunch. Luana sat beside Victoria and Hermione, watching the logistical chaos of hands moving everywhere to serve plates of food. She only managed to serve herself when Sirius handed her a plate of barbecue, which made her smile as her whole face felt like it was on fire.
What was happening to her?
Surely she wasn’t falling for Reggie’s godfather!
I mean, she’d had a crush on Remus the previous year — after all, he had always been kind to her — but bloody hell, Sirius Black was… wow. She didn’t even have words to describe him.
Victoria, beside her, stomped on her foot, making her jerk her legs against the table.
"Ow!" she murmured to her friend, confused.
"Stop staring." Mimi said, without even moving her lips. "Act normal, Lua."
Luana simply pressed her lips together and focused on eating, listening to Remus and Ted Tonks argue about the Quidditch World Cup. Tonks amused Hermione and Ginny by morphing her own nose between bites. Victoria cast her a look of bewilderment, almost disgust, and Regulus gripped her hand under the table.
"Did you talk to your parents about the box seats?" He finally brought up the subject they had been avoiding for days.
Victoria shook her head, and her white hair, tied back in a loose ponytail, slipped down to tickle his shoulder.
"Not yet." She aligned her cutlery perfectly on the plate once she finished, looking at Reg as if she had no desire to untangle that subject at the table. And he understood, so he stayed quiet.
When everyone finished lunch and relaxed, Fred, George and Ron jumped into the pool, causing a wave of water to splash onto Hermione, who was sitting on the edge beside Harry. Reggie and Luana were next, competing to see who could make the perfect dive. Andromeda and Ted said their goodbyes before Disapparating.
Tonks watched Penny with keen interest as the elf made all the dishes return to the kitchen on their own. She settled into the same sun lounger as Sirius and let her feet rest on the grass, laughing as she chatted with him. Sirius didn’t seem to share her good humour, always replying curtly and, at times, with sarcasm.
"So… Sirius. Is it true you broke into Hogwarts because you’re an Animagus?" It was Ginny who asked. She was the only one still out of the pool.
"It is." He replied simply, lighting another cigarette.
"Oh, show them, Sirius!" Harry called, looking at him over his shoulder.
"Padfoot!" Reggie sang, swimming. "Padfoot! Padfoot!"
Soon Luana, the twins, Ron and even Hermione joined in the chant. Sirius expelled the air from his lungs, exasperated.
"No." His answer came with an irritated sniff.
"Oh, come on, Sirius, stop being such a killjoy!" Tonks nudged him lightly with her shoulder, her pink hair growing more and more vivid.
Sirius looked at her with the sharp, impatient silver of his gaze, on the verge of unloading something that had been rotting inside his heart. Yet he limited himself to rising from the chair and taking a drag from his cigarette as he walked away.
Everyone fell silent. Reggie and Harry exchanged an uncomfortable smile and tried to smooth things over by striking up conversation with their friends, ignoring the insistent questions about their godfather’s foul mood. It was obvious Sirius was behaving that way after the fight between him and Scarlett — during which the house had nearly caught fire. Reg hadn’t even seen his mother since she’d left that day, and he knew it had been serious, given that Sirius refused to talk about it. At least Scarlett had been invited to the barbecue, and he waited patiently for her to come.
That she and Sirius would make up, and that she could live with them.
That his family… would stay together.
Just behind Reg, Victoria watched Fred and Luana start a competition to see who could hold their breath underwater the longest. They stared each other down with such intensity that Victoria could swear she saw sparks flying between them, and then both plunged beneath the surface, leaving her responsible for keeping time. After the first thirty seconds, Mimi spotted a head of red hair swimming towards them, colliding straight into Luana, making her resurface spluttering water.
"Argh, George!" she complained angrily, elbowing him so hard he choked. "You idiot!"
"Calm down, I’m just messing about!" the boy defended himself, clutching his stomach.
Fred surfaced a few seconds later, shaking his wet red hair from side to side and splashing everyone.
"Did I win?" he asked excitedly. Luana punched him on the shoulder, earning a loud groan — loud enough that Harry and Hermione burst out laughing. "Learn to lose, Teixeira!"
"How about a round of wrestling in the pool? Like, whoever manages to knock the other down." Reggie, floating nearby, ended the argument before it even began.
"I’m in!" Ginny jumped into the pool with both hands raised.
"Fred, you lift Luana," he continued, a mischievous smile brushing his lips at the thought. "I’ll take Ginny."
Fred opened his mouth to protest, but Regulus was already placing Ginny onto his shoulders. He let out a wheeze and sank, resurfacing with Luana perched firmly on top of him.
"Just letting you know you’re going to lose, Weasley number 235…" she grinned, confident.
"Not even in your dreams, filthy Brazilian." Rolling her eyes, Ginny braced herself for the attack.
The fight began. The girls shoved each other clumsily while Fred and Reggie struggled to keep their balance. Not that the game lasted long — Luana was tall and Fred was strong from being a Beater, and although Reggie was one as well, Ginny didn’t have nearly as much physical strength. She was quickly toppled, squeaking in surprise as she hit the water.
"I won!" Luana celebrated, raising her fists. She exchanged a proud look with Fred, then both quickly grew embarrassed. "Aren’t you going to crouch so I can get down?"
Fred’s answer was to shove her backwards off his shoulders, knocking her into the water without any warning. Regulus rubbed his eyes as the two of them immediately began to argue.
George swam to the edge, inspired by his brother.
"Hermione, come on! Let’s knock Fred and Teixeira over!"
"That doesn’t sound very safe…" She hugged herself. "I’d rather keep my feet on the ground, thank you."
"Oh, you’re so boring." George complained, rolling his eyes. "And you, Rookwood? Don’t you want to take a swing at your best friend?"
Victoria shot the Weasley such a dramatic look that he blinked several times.
"Definitely not."
"Come on, Rookwood, I know you’re a Slytherin, but you don’t have to be a coward!"
"Stop it, George." Harry kicked his feet in the water. "She said she doesn’t want to."
"Oh, come on, Harry! Are you taking the side of those Slytherins? Forgot we played Quidditch against Black the past few seasons?!"
"One thing has nothing to do with the other." It was Hermione who spoke, her dark eyes overflowing with exasperation.
George only frowned. He dove, disappearing from the three’s sight.
"He’s always so insis—" Victoria didn’t manage to finish. She was yanked down by the feet all at once.
The impact with the water was sudden and she vanished beneath the surface. George emerged, that characteristic wicked laugh of his ringing out as if he expected her to come up.
She didn’t come up.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 73: E agora eu fujo pra não sofrer (And now I run so I won’t suffer)
Chapter Text
CXLI
The faded rays of sunlight filtered through the window glass, but even they weren’t enough to bring colour to Scarlett’s drunken face. Her hands were skittish, gripping the steering wheel to stop herself from leaving the car. Her feet were still pressed on the brake and her tormented eyes wandered restlessly along the street.
She wouldn’t be foolish enough to park in front of Sirius’s house, knowing there were people inside who couldn’t know she existed. Because, technically, that was what she ought to be. It was what she was trying to be.
Non-existent.
She took a deep breath, searching within herself for the strength to get out of the car and do what she needed to do. She grabbed the small transparent bottle from the passenger seat and was met with a gust of hot wind when she opened the door, her bleached hair whipping against her cheeks.
She looked around, held the vial between her teeth and transformed into Whiskers. The tuxedo cat crossed the pavement in swift, languid steps, slipping into the garden of a house that made her fur bristle. She didn’t know if it was because of the memories, because of the laughter she heard from outside, or because of the impotence and distance she felt upon sneaking through the open window of the bedroom and climbing atop the bookcase.
Outside, she saw Orfeu stretch on a sun lounger, Remus talking to a girl she didn’t recognise, Sirius and Tonks sharing the same lounger, and Harry and Reggie wearing smiles so pure her heart caved in.
She could never give any of them that. No — her place was inside, hidden from the world, distant from everyone.
Whiskers gradually grew, giving way to the woman curled on top of the wardrobe, her eyes fixed on the windows, watching helplessly as the moment’s frailty unfolded. Her pupils were nothing more than a screen upon which her spectator’s soul witnessed happiness unfurl around her, while at the same time her eyes were her own prison — preventing her from touching that moment to make it eternal, limiting her to merely witness, never partake. She had no right to that. She couldn’t invade that safe space because she was the danger they all feared and despised. She was Sirius’s downfall, Remus’s resentment, Orfeu’s terror.
What a lonely concept that of the eyes. Her retinas could only capture, never engage. The moment reflected in the blue of her irises as though she were watching a film. Scarlett wasn’t part of that. She didn’t know why she had ever thought she would be. She had believed so blindly in Sirius’s pretentious words that now the disappointment was shooting straight through her heart.
She didn’t belong in that place.
In truth, Scarlett felt she didn’t belong anywhere.
She would always be a pariah. A soul with pieces missing, a body without a heart, a condemned murderer.
The house door opened. Penny came in carrying a plate, spotting her immediately on top of the furniture.
"Mistress Black, is everything… all right?" There was a kind of compassion in the elf’s voice that made her stiffen.
She didn’t want pity, nor sympathy. Her platinum hair began to turn black as she returned to her feline skin. Whiskers remained lying on her side, her snout resting on her right paw, her tail tapping against the wooden corner of the furniture.
"Where’s Reggie, I’m already going…" A voice she knew all too well echoed. Penny cast a nervous glance at Whiskers, then at Orfeu as he stepped through the doorway.
"P-Penny saw him by the pool…" She pointed outside and Orfeu followed her finger with his gaze.
"Reggie! I’m heading off!" he shouted, cupping a hand around his mouth.
Whiskers’s ears shot up at once, swivelling towards Orfeu like satellite dishes. She turned her head to him, the already moribund heart in her chest seeming to wither and shrink until it vanished.
Orfeu had become a handsome man. She had always known her brother would, but seeing him was different — especially when he wasn’t trying to kill her. His green eyes were different from Lily’s and Harry’s. There was a seriousness in them, a depth that Scarlett shared with her own blue gaze. The weight of being a Gaunt with a Signet, perhaps. But then her pupils traced over his arms, covered in scars, and it was very difficult to remain in her cat form. Orfy had burned in the night of the fire — not like she and Sirius, who bore only a single mark on their forearms… no.
His arms were covered, the disfigured skin marring the limbs she used to love pinching and biting. His reddish-brown hair was tied back in a ponytail, though half of it had already fallen loose over his shoulders. His freckled face reminded her of their mother. Orfeu resembled Nyx far more than she did, especially with the dusting of brown in the green of his eyes. Or in the shape of his lips, the curve of his nose, the fullness of his eyebrows.
Reggie appeared shortly afterwards, dripping wet from the pool. He hugged his uncle with the natural enthusiasm that belonged to him alone, his black hair soaking Orfeu’s shoulders. The man’s eyes closed in the embrace, and when they reopened, they were fixed directly on Whiskers.
The cat didn’t move. The light of the late afternoon spilled through the window, tinting Orfy’s irises with a rosé hue. One of his eyebrows lifted slightly and his lips parted as the cat bristled all over, hissing and baring her teeth.
"Since when do you lot have a cat?!" Orfeu lowered his gaze to his nephew, who gave an awkward smile.
"Well… sh-she’s Harry’s." Reggie said quickly. "This is… uh, Snuffles."
"I don’t think she likes me." He shoved his hands into his pockets, as though trying to reassure the cat that he meant no harm.
"She’s skittish." Reg pulled Orfeu with him towards the door, where a woman Whiskers didn’t recognise was waiting. "Bye, Uncle."
"Bye, kid." He pinched his nephew’s nose with a fond smile.
Whiskers lowered her fur and her ears, though the tension rippling through her body hadn’t dissipated. She looked around, as if searching for somewhere to hide, but then Reggie approached and she stared at him with dilated pupils.
"It’s all right. He’s not going to hurt you." He said it with such certainty that Whiskers might have believed him, were she not so distrustful.
Regulus’s gaze drifted from the cat to the window. A second later, he bolted towards the pool, leaving a trail of puddles in his wake. He dived like an Olympic athlete and surfaced with someone in his arms, a girl whose hair wouldn’t stop changing colour.
It was Victoria, of course, nestled against Reggie’s neck as if she were about to suffocate him. The boy carried her out of the pool, one of the twins following behind him.
"You’re an imbecile, George!" Regulus scolded, in a tone she had never heard from him before. It carried a sharpness that reminded her very much of a younger Sirius.
"Sorry, I… I didn’t know…"
"You’ve done enough today!" Reggie cut in, the blue swallowing the silver of his gaze with coldness.
"Are you all right? What happened?" Sirius approached at almost a run.
Whiskers slowly turned her gaze towards him, as though she were doing something forbidden.
"I’m taking her inside. She needs a moment." Reg murmured, carrying her into the house, heading straight for his bedroom without looking back.
Sirius followed him; however, as soon as he crossed the doorway he stopped as though he’d just been spellbound. Whiskers felt the familiar tug in her chest and he snapped his head towards her so quickly his neck cracked. The meeting of their eyes was like the sun’s gravity drawing the planets towards itself. Natural and inevitable. Inexorable.
There she was. The redeemer of his misery.
Whiskers was the first to move. She clamped the glass vial between her teeth and leapt from the bookshelf to the nearby wardrobe, landing on the floor with a grace only a cat could display. Sirius nodded for her to follow him, walking towards his bedroom, but the cat stopped in the corridor.
The feline’s shadow grew and Scarlett threw her body back, pressing her spine against the wall as though she didn’t trust her legs to hold her.
"The memories… you asked for…" she began, but caught her breath when Sirius looked at her over his shoulder. "of… of Azkaban…" She extended the vial, where a silvery light danced inside it.
Sirius turned, taking the bottle, daring to let his fingers brush her palm. Scarlett recoiled at once, as though she’d just been burnt.
"Y-you… you don’t want…" He stammered, blinking repeatedly. Scarlett had finally come, and there was so much he wanted to say… yet the words seemed to turn to ash in his mouth. It was because of the way she was looking at him. With those blue eyes full of fear, full of guilt and suffering. "What is it?"
Her lips moved several times, but the knot in her throat clamped her vocal cords shut. Scarlett drew a deep breath, trying to regain control of her own body as she clenched her fists. Sirius had that effect on her. Made her forget the most basic things, like breathing or speaking.
"I… the… the band…" She shook her head and squeezed her eyes shut, tightening her jaw. Hating the sound of her own voice, how it came out more like a plea than a warning. She swallowed slowly, composing herself. "Signed a big contract with… a band called Pearl Jam and… we’re opening their tour in Spain and France for two weeks." She kept her lips parted, as if she wanted to say something else… but hadn’t the slightest idea what.
Nor did Sirius know what to say. He had the impression the barbecue had turned to lead in his stomach. Unwelcome tears stung at his eyes and set his throat alight. He thought she… well, he wasn’t sure what he thought Scarlett would do. Certainly not that.
He knew she was a coward, but… bloody hell.
Sirius knew he had been wrong and was determined to fix it, to sort out all the unfinished business of fifteen years that had dragged like anchors around his feet. To tell her that… fuck, yes, he had suspected back then that Scarlett was being forced into all that shit that wasn’t in her nature, but every one of his doubts had turned to dust when she had Regulus’s child and was sent to prison.
Indignation buzzed in his ears, boiled his blood and dried out his mouth. All he wanted was to keep his fucking family together, and all she wanted was to run.
There was a moment, the tiniest fraction of a second, in which Sirius regretted breaking out of Azkaban with Scarlett. He should have left her there, because at least that way… she wouldn’t be able to hurt him. And, by Merlin, Scarlett Gaunt was one of the few things capable of dragging all his repressed facets to the surface, his rotten pure-blood heritage, the simmering rage that frothed and evaporated every bit of sense he had.
"Are you serious?!" The voice, though it sounded like Sirius’s, wasn’t his. Both of them turned their gaze very slowly towards the boy standing in front of his own half-open bedroom door, his wet body dripping steadily onto the floor. "You’re going on some stupid tour during our holidays?!"
Neither Scarlett nor Sirius had expected Regulus to be eavesdropping.
She opened her mouth in an attempt to justify herself, but Reggie stepped forward, his eyes turning to steel and his lips curling into a cutting smile.
"My Uncle Remus was right. Disappointing people is the only thing you’re good at!" He spat his poison, his lips pressed tight and his pupils stabbing into her like a blade.
Scarlett blinked several times, stunned. She had never imagined she would be so devastated by words spoken by anyone other than Sirius.
"I… I can’t… cancel it now. I-I need the money." She tried to defend herself.
"Then go away, Scarlett!" Regulus spat with such fury that Scarlett straightened sharply. "It’s the only thing you know how to do: abandon the people you love!"
The retort sank into her skin, flooded her veins and poisoned her blood with something pestilent, acidic, something that split her bones and gnawed at her heart. The pain shot through her nerve endings and Scarlett felt, even if only for an instant, as if she were being struck by the Cruciatus Curse again.
"Regulus, that’s enough." Sirius took a step forward, his tone threatening. "Apologise to your mother. Now!"
Reggie arched his eyebrows and beneath them his merciless eyes flashed, his pupils narrowing as the silver devoured the blue, his expression darkening like a carved mask. He drew himself up, in a gesture eerily similar to the one Sirius used when they were teenagers. He approached Scarlett, his nostrils flared and his lips trembling as though he were using every ounce of strength not to cry.
"I WISH YOU WERE DEAD!" Reggie’s voice soared and Scarlett crumbled.
"REGULUS! THAT’S ENOUGH!" Sirius roared, his voice echoing down the corridor like thunder reflecting the chaos boiling in his chest and tightening his muscles. "GO TO YOUR ROOM, NOW!" He didn’t wait for Reg to obey. No. Sirius dug his hand into the boy’s cold, wet shoulder and shoved him violently towards the room. "You’re just like your father! Exactly like Regulus!" The bitterness seized his vocal cords.
Regulus stumbled into the room and the door slammed shut as Sirius pushed it closed with trembling hands, his face deathly pale. He didn’t release the doorknob, his eyes fixed on the poster in front of him as he struggled to breathe.
"I do as well, Reg… I do as well." Scarlett murmured, almost only to herself as she squeezed her eyes shut. Her chest trembled, her heart being crushed beneath the unbearable oppression of always failing at everything she set out to do. At being a mother, a wife, at being part of a functional family.
Her legs moved on their own in her harsh walk towards the exit. She ought to speak with Sirius, ought to apologise to Reggie, but what would she argue? Regulus was right. It was better that…
"Scar, Reg… he didn’t mean it. He didn’t… he didn’t really mean it." It was Harry saying that. Scarlett looked back, startled, at the boy with Lily’s kind eyes and James’s cruel features. She’d barely realised she had left the corridor and now stood in the living room. "Why are you going away?"
Scarlett held her breath. It was the only way she found to stop the sharp suffering from continuing to scrape at her heart every time she moved, for the pressure of her ribs against her chest to ease even a little.
For a moment, she did nothing but stare at her godson.
"Harry, I…" She released the air from her lungs very slowly. "I’ve done bad things that can’t be undone and… they’re part of me now." She said at last, her voice hoarse and unrecognisable. She wiped a tear with the back of her hand. "And constantly… it feels as though they’re all I am."
Harry lowered his gaze, a crease forming between his eyebrows as though he were trying to understand her. Then, the boy who had always been far too timid to hug anyone properly stepped closer and wrapped his arms around her with force.
"I’m going to miss you, Scar." He murmured against the collar of her blouse.
Scarlett hesitated, surprised, but soon her arms relaxed and she returned the embrace, kissing his forehead tenderly and taking care around his scar. She wished Lily had seen that, had witnessed that her son was, slowly, learning about affection, but Scarlett made sure not to be haunted by her ghosts that day. She had drunk earlier and, although the effects of the alcohol were not so evident, they were the reason the pain tearing her apart inside felt muted.
Had she been sober, she would already have become a mess of tears, screaming and self-destruction.
Harry is a Horcrux.
"So will I, Harry. Behave yourself." She breathed, stroking Harry’s hair before stepping back towards the foyer.
When she lifted her gaze, she found Sirius emerging from the corridor, his troubled eyes turning to her as though drawn by a magnet. There were the silver irises she loved so deeply, completely oxidised and cracked. As broken as she was, as tormented as she was, as unbalanced as she was. Sirius Black was nothing more than the other side of her coin, the flame that had stayed alight through all those years — fuelled by the love or the hatred that seemed to consume them every time they were together.
Scarlett wanted to say so much, but she was certain that if she opened her mouth, they would end up arguing again. And what she had heard from Regulus that day had already hit her limit for humiliation and exhaustion, just as she was sure Sirius felt the same, because…
[Tim Maia — Me dê motivo]
He took exactly two long strides. The palm of his hand slid over her shoulders as though there were absolutely no barrier between them, no resentment, no obstacle. Only understanding. Despite everything, Scarlett was the only one who understood him and vice versa. He pulled her closer until there was no distance left at all, Scarlett’s shrunken, trembling body pressed against his tense and weakened one. Seeking that comfort in each other, that belonging and the relief they always found.
It was enough for Scarlett to cry, her hands clutching Sirius’s T-shirt with force. He buried his face in her hair, his arms tightening around her as though he didn’t want her to leave, even knowing it wouldn’t be enough to stop her.
It never was. Scarlett only ever did what she wanted; for better or for worse.
Reason hit him like a slap. Scarlett would be gone for two weeks. His mind snapped awake, sanity managing to break through the numbing haze she had wrapped around him, and he staggered a step back, the longing that had dragged them together transmuting into repulsion.
Scarlett sniffed and forced herself to look at his face, but at the same time didn’t allow herself to see him. She didn’t want to witness the disappointment in his expression. Not when she had already seen the same look on Reggie’s.
"Scarlett, I…" Sirius began, throwing his long hair back. He breathed. Or rather, he tried to breathe. The oxygen didn’t seem enough. Nothing did. "I just want… I just want you to feel safe." He stepped into her path, blocking her from moving forward. "I want you to stop feeling frightened."
Me dê motivo pra ir embora
Estou vendo a hora de te perder
Me dê motivo, vai ser agora
Estou indo embora, o que fazer?
Estou indo embora, não faz sentido
Ficar contigo, melhor assim
E é nessa hora que o homem chora
A dor é forte demais pra mim
She dared to fall into those silver pits. Sirius pushed her out from them again by looking away, as though even he couldn’t bear the weight of his own eyes. Scarlett didn’t deserve that, didn’t deserve his pity or his sympathy, no matter how much she longed for them.
She didn’t deserve his forgiveness, and Sirius was never going to forgive her.
"What’s the point, if you’re never going to forgive me?" she voiced her own thoughts.
That wasn’t true. He would, eventually, but… it wasn’t that simple. They needed to sort out so many things and… all Scarlett ever knew how to do was run.
She always ran.
And pretending that didn’t upset him was exhausting.
Scarlett sighed. It was even harder to keep walking. Even so, she didn’t feel afraid. Not when she was with Sirius, even with him looking at her that way, with hurt and uncertainty.
Perhaps that was why she was leaving.
She needed the fear. She needed the constant reminder that everything she lived with Sirius was a dream, a fleeting illusion, a summer night destined to fade with the dawn. And then reality would sweep her fantasy away like waves drowning the unwary and, when she was forced to face the consequences of her choices, she would be destroying the entire world just to keep him safe.
Everything she had done, everything she had ever done…
Was for Sirius Black.
She wouldn’t act differently this time.
How could she?
Her hand hovered over the doorknob, tension coiling around her shoulders. She focused on simply inhaling deeply, but she didn’t turn back.
"I did it to protect you." Scarlett pressed her lips together to stop the sob that wanted to climb up her throat. "To protect Reg and Orfy. And… you know what? I… I’m not going to apologise for it anymore, Sirius, because I would do it all again."
She turned her face just enough to show her profile, staring at him from the corner of her eye, a sinuous shadow sweeping across her tempestuous features. Sirius tensed and swallowed hard, his lips trembling as he pressed them together. Scarlett’s voice was stained with something unbreakable, feral, and it scraped her vocal cords against her will.
"If I had to lose you to keep you safe, then so be it. I’d do it without hesitation." She wiped her tears with her forearm.
Through all her hypocrisies, no human being in the world longed for love as much as Scarlett Gaunt did, especially the love of Sirius Black. He remained still, petrified, as though trying to make sense of all the pain clouding his heart, all the fury summoned by Scarlett’s words, all the confusion spiralling through his core.
"I would do anything for you, Sirius. Anything!" she gasped, though she used every ounce of strength left in her to stay upright. "And it’s frightening. Because I know I’ll never feel this for anyone else again. Never."
Me dê motivo, foi jogo sujo
E agora eu fujo pra não sofrer
Fui teu amigo, te dei o mundo
Você foi fundo, quis me perder
Agora é tarde, não tem mais jeito
O teu defeito não tem perdão
Eu vou à luta, que a vida é curta
Não vale a pena sofrer em vão
In the height of summer, winter’s chill descended upon Sirius. His skin prickled, his body froze and he shrank in on himself. Scarlett was looking at him with those ocean eyes that could so easily drown him, intoxicating him with her words like a siren’s call in the ears of a careless sailor. And he stared back in the same cadence, without retreating or wavering, though stripped entirely of his defences.
Sirius wanted to say he felt the same, but the words kept dying in his mouth, one after the other. He had the sensation that his lips had turned into a graveyard, burying every confession that wished to be born.
He wanted to ask her to stay.
He would beg, if he had to.
"She’s pretty." Scarlett broke the silence. "And she makes you smile in a way that… that I don’t…"
"She… is my cousin." Sirius cleared his throat, trying to break through the muteness that clung to him. Knowing exactly whom Scarlett meant.
"Your parents were cousins. So were mine." She shot back, so quickly it was as though she already knew what he would say. "That’s what you deserve, Sirius. Someone who doesn’t have to hide, someone who doesn’t carry all this… baggage… we carry… someone who will never hurt you the way I have." She blinked hard, forcing out the stubborn tears burning her eyes. "Someone who didn’t betray you with your brother."
Pode crer você pôs tudo a perder
Não podia me fazer o que fez
E por mais que você tente negar, me dê motivo
"Scar…"
"You deserve to be happy. And I can’t give you that. I can’t be happy myself, let alone make you happy…" She placed a hand over her heart and let out a harsh laugh. She gripped the doorknob tightly, a sob ripping free from her throat.
"You’ve just told me that… that you’ll never feel the same for anyone else…" Sirius tried to argue, taking an uncertain step towards her.
"It doesn’t matter… how I feel…"
"I don’t want anyone else, Scarlett, I want you!" Sirius gasped, his voice cracking with desperation. Once more he shattered the distance between them, slamming his hands against the door behind her.
Pode crer eu vou sair por aí
E mostrar que posso ser bem feliz
Encontrar alguém que saiba me dar
Me dar motivo
Me dar motivo
Scarlett shook her head vehemently, dodging his advances as he tried to press his face to hers.
"No, Sirius, you… you deserve… a woman who… who can be by your side in every situation! Who can be there with Reg and Harry!" Scarlett shoved him away with her free hand. "And I… am not that person! All I can do is… stay away." She drew a long, wrenching breath. "Watch you all be happy… from my window." She murmured, with a resignation that stabbed straight through his heart.
"Scar… don’t do this… please, kitten…" Sirius begged. He was rigid, petrified, making no movement at all except for the tears glinting in his eyes. His face pale, as though he had just escaped from Azkaban. His long, damp lashes framing a piercing, pleading, sparking gaze.
Scarlett didn’t answer. She didn’t need to. The answer was in her eyes. She stroked the beard along Sirius’s cheek, her fingertips brushing the coarse hair. She tucked a strand of black hair behind his ear and, with her right hand, turned the doorknob.
She wiped her tears with the back of her hand. Dared to look at Sirius one last time, smothered the tearing urge to stay… and left.
.
.
.
Harry had never been the nosy sort. Well, he managed it here and there at Hogwarts with his Invisibility Cloak, as he’d done throughout his three years at school, but he didn’t usually do that at home.
He hadn’t cared about the Dursleys. Living with them had been one of the worst experiences of his life (yes, worse than killing a basilisk), and now, at Sirius’s house, seeing that things weren’t as perfect as he’d imagined unsettled him a little. It didn’t disappoint him; he knew everyone had problems, but seeing Sirius like that made something very strange thrum in his chest.
In truth, witnessing that argument had left him rather thoughtful. He understood why Scarlett was hurt — after all, Reggie had said some very cruel things to her — but there was a context behind Sirius and Scar’s quarrel that he hadn’t fully grasped. What was it that Sirius would never forgive? The fact she’d cheated on him with his brother? And then she simply said she would stop apologising because she would do it all again. Do what, exactly? And then she’d felt jealous of Tonks — it could only be her, the cousin he’d mentioned, since Andromeda was married — and she left even when everything about her suggested she wanted to stay.
Blimey. Why were adults like that? He scratched his head. All he could do was hope Scarlett returned before his birthday.
"Harry!" Sirius started violently when he turned and noticed him there. He dragged a hand hard down his face, wiping away any trace that might betray his tears. "I didn’t… didn’t see you there." He cleared his throat, startled.
"I… I wanted to ask…" He pushed his glasses up his nose. The gesture made Sirius’s heart skip a beat. "If you’re… not going to get in… the pool." He thought quickly.
Sirius looked at Harry. It was painful, truly, to look at him. He was the constant reminder of those who were gone, the legacy of James and Lily. Sirius had never wanted so badly for James to be there now, so he could collapse into his arms. The urge pushed him a step closer to his godson, but he didn’t continue.
Scarlett had been right about Harry. He might look like James, but he wasn’t him. Besides, Sirius was the adult in this relationship; he shouldn’t be seeking comfort from his godson. No, it ought to be the other way around.
Which was why, like a master puppeteer manipulating his marionettes, Sirius locked each and every one of his feelings deep in the bottomless abyss of his heart and forced a smile. His response was a silent nod.
His mind was still ringing with the argument he’d had with Reggie and Scarlett when they reached the garden. Tonks and Remus were leading a fierce swimming competition between Luana and Ginny against Fred and George. Ron was sitting at the edge of the pool wrapped in a towel beside Hermione, the two of them talking and laughing.
Sirius pulled off his T-shirt, revealing his defined musculature and the countless tattoos that marked his skin. He tossed the garment onto the sun lounger and limited himself to taking a deep breath, smothering everything that had happened. Trying to access the lightness of that moment, even whilst feeling an unbearable weight on his chest and his heart crushed with every beat. He unbuttoned his trousers.
"Sirius… those scars… are they from Azkaban?" Harry’s question dragged him out of his personal chaos.
He hadn’t even realised he’d forgotten to use a charm to conceal them. He froze mid-motion, fingers tracing the long, uneven scars cutting across the pale skin of his thigh. He sighed, pulled his trousers back up, and resigned himself to sitting on the lounger, his hands covering his face.
Harry sat beside him. Sirius remained silent, massaging his temple as he gathered the courage to speak.
"No, Harry. They’re not from Azkaban." He exhaled deeply, still hiding his face. "They’re from when I was younger."
Harry shifted on the lounger, making it creak.
"What happened?"
Sirius slowly lowered his hands, glancing at him sidelong. A sad smile tightened his lips. His mind drifted to the lurid, shadowed memories of his childhood. All frayed by the dementors, but he still had a general sense of what it meant to be the heir to the Noble and Most Ancient House of Black.
"My parents were always obsessed with blood purity… lineage… and obedience. They wanted me to be the perfect heir. But… I was always the opposite of that. I disobeyed and questioned." Sirius removed his trousers, stretching out his leg so Harry could see the pale scars scoring his equally fair skin. "To them, that was unacceptable."
"They hurt you? Just because you… didn’t want to be like them?" Harry couldn’t hide the horror in his tone, nor in his expression.
"I’d say it was more than that, Harry. To them, I was a disgrace. A mistake. An… abomination. And I always made a point of being everything they hated. It was the only way I knew how to resist."
Harry pressed his lips into a thin line and gripped the edge of the lounger more tightly, his green eyes reluctantly drifting from the scars to Sirius.
"I didn’t… I didn’t know that," he murmured, pushing his glasses up again. "I’m sorry, Sirius."
"You’ve nothing to apologise for, Harry." Sirius placed a hand on his shoulder, giving it a light squeeze. "If it weren’t for your dad… for Remus… for Scarlett… I wouldn’t be here."
"Did your parents hit your brother too?"
The question made Sirius’s stomach churn.
"No." He shook his head. "Not exactly."
"What do you mean?"
Sirius wet his lips, working through the knot that insisted on forming in his throat.
"The only time Regulus was beaten… it was me who hit him. At my father’s command." Sirius drew his brows together at the thorny memory. "After that day, we… were never the same again."
Harry remained silent, which made Sirius continue:
"My father had a habit of… forcing his way into my mind. And he did that when I came back from spending the holidays at your dad’s house, right after I met Scarlett. He saw in there that… I’d fallen in love with her." He turned his gaze towards the pool, his grey eyes catching the flicker of the garden lamps that had lit up once night fell. "He wanted us to marry, but…" An involuntary laugh slipped from his lips. "I didn’t want to marry her, so I ran away from home."
"You ran away from home?" Harry asked, stunned.
"Mm. When I was sixteen." Sirius pushed his black hair behind his ears as a strong gust of wind swept through.
"And where did you go?" Harry placed his hands on his knees, not taking his eyes off his godfather.
Sirius drew in as much air as he could as sadness tried to seep once again into his features.
"To your dad’s place." He released the breath slowly. "Fleamont and Effie were really good about it; they sort of adopted me as a second son.
I basically camped out at your dad’s during the school holidays, and after I turned seventeen and… after Scarlett lost her family… I bought this house." He glanced towards the façade, his eyes replaying the fateful day he and Remus had visited and he’d closed the deal. "We lived here until… until she…" His voice trembled. "Left. And then I looked after myself." He omitted the part about alcohol and drugs. Harry didn’t need to know that. "When Scarlett had Reggie and was sent to prison, I…" He bit his lower lip, shaking his head as though trying to force her out of his thoughts. "We were always welcome at Mr. and Mrs. Potter’s for Sunday lunch, though."
"But… you left home because you didn’t want to marry Scarlett? And then you lived with her here?" Harry scratched the back of his neck.
Sirius smiled bitterly and ran his fingers through his long hair.
"Not just because of that. I hated the whole lot of them: my parents, with their pure-blood mania, convinced that to be a Black made you practically royal… and my idiot of a brother… who was soft enough to believe them."
"Your brother was a Death Eater," Harry added.
"Yeah."
"And Scar as well."
Sirius nodded, contemplating the shadows stretching before him; swallowing the apple trees, the box hedges, and the willow at the back of the garden.
"What do you mean Scar left?" Harry returned to the subject. "What happened when you two were living here?"
He hadn’t expected Harry to ask that question so directly. He straightened his posture, his fingertips twisting the rings on his fingers in a mechanical motion. His jaw tightened until the veins in his neck stood out. Then he slung an arm around his godson’s shoulders and lifted his gaze to the sky painted in cobalt.
"She… thought my brother was in danger and… wanted to save him."
"From the Death Eaters? But… if she was one of them…"
"No, Harry… she became one of them because she went after Regulus. Because… she wanted to save him and…" He faltered, drawing his brows together until a crease formed between them. "We argued that day because of Regulus and… she left, Harry. She left and never came back. She became a Death Eater. Married my brother. Had his child…"
Harry rested his head against Sirius’s chest, rubbing the hem of his own shirt between his thumb and forefinger as he absorbed what he was hearing.
"Is that why you two fought? Because she married your brother?" he asked quietly, as if no one else knew the reason.
"Yes… and no." Sirius shut his eyes, trying to keep his expression neutral. "Harry… you don’t need to worry about these things." He rested his chin on his godson’s hair. "What happened… is in the past. I survived, and now we’re a family. And that’s all that matters, all right?"
Harry nodded, although he knew those words weren’t true. Sirius was capable of hiding many things. Though his physical wounds had healed, it was clear the emotional ones still bled, while the deepest festered.
"I’ll be all right." Sirius reaffirmed it despite not being sure, pulling away from his godson as he put his clothes back on.
They didn’t have much more time to talk, as Hermione’s parents arrived, and Mr. Weasley appeared to pick up the boys, while Tonks said her annoyingly exuberant goodbye to Sirius by hugging him far too tightly. He watched Ginny follow Arthur and the twins down the road, and a large snowy owl dropped a letter through the kitchen window — from Victoria’s parents. Luana waited for Regulus to finally come out of his room so she could say goodbye, and left on her skateboard with Victoria beside her.
Sirius tried to speak to his nephew, but he simply shut himself back in his room.
"Give him time," Remus murmured, throwing himself onto the sofa. His face had begun to grey, emphasising his scars. "Give yourself time too."
"I don’t need time, Moony, I…" Sirius rubbed his eyes hard, opening them only to be met directly with the phial Scarlett had given him earlier. "I need your help."
"If this is about Scarlett, Sirius…" Remus drew in a deep breath and let his head fall back against the sofa, exhausted.
"She left the memories from Azkaban." He cut his friend off, picking up the cold phial, the silvery glow bouncing against the translucent surface. "I need your help to investigate her case. I won’t manage it on my own. I’ll pay you, Moony."
Remus merely turned his head towards him, his dark eyes glinting gold as if he were trying to decipher the truth behind Sirius’s proposal.
"I don’t want your money, Padfoot," he murmured, his voice cracked with exhaustion.
Sirius’s gaze followed Harry, who left the kitchen with a plate piled high with leftovers from the earlier barbecue. He sat on the floor and switched on the Super Nintendo, eating with one hand and playing with the other.
"All right. I brew the Wolfsbane Potion every month and you help me. Deal?"
Remus rolled his eyes and made a noise of displeasure.
"Deal." He marked his defeat with a long sigh.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 74: Mama, I don’t love you anymore
Chapter Text
CXLII
The hot jet spilled over her body, coating her chilled skin. Steam spiralled up to the bathroom ceiling, escaping through the small window. Victoria rested her forehead against the shower glass, the water running down her hair, which kept changing colour without pause, over her ears and shoulders. Splattering against fingers smeared with blood. Her unfocused gaze fixed on the door as it opened.
The blurred silhouette beyond the shower could only belong to a person. Victoria brushed her fingertips against the glass, trying to see more clearly, but all she saw was… the smudge of the towel, the mirror’s reflection, the door banging shut because of the strong wind.
Victoria Rookwood flinched.
"Reggie?" Her voice echoed through the damp bathroom walls, airy, anxious.
It was a stupid question. She knew it was — after all, the only reply she received was the favoured habit of ghosts: silence.
Why had she thought it would be Regulus?
She scrubbed her trembling hands hard with a sponge. Her arms too, until the reddened skin took on purplish tones. She stepped out of the bathroom on unsteady legs, bile burning her throat. Wrapping herself in a towel, she felt around the counter and grabbed the golden pocket watch resting on it.
She snapped it open.
There was Regulus, kissing her as though he were the most besotted boy in the world. She remembered as if it were yesterday the softness of his hair, the warmth of his skin travelling across hers, the taste of his kiss.
She shut the watch with a crack, wandering through the room with its filthy carpet and unmade bed. The fan creaked every time it turned, and she grabbed the television remote, turning the volume up.
“… this morning, Brockdale Bridge collapsed due to what Highways England describes as natural deterioration, killing a dozen people. The BBC’s correspondent visited the scene to show the destruction…”
She switched off the old tube television, the curved glass turning dark, reflecting the distorted, naked image of Victoria Rookwood as she put on a black robe and a metallic mask.
She pulled back the long sleeve slowly, revealing the skull with a serpent emerging from its mouth, inked as black as her clothing.
Victoria Rookwood Disapparated.
.
.
.
Her pale fingers drifted through his black strands with such slow, delicate movement that Regulus lifted his gaze to Victoria, her head resting against the wall behind her, white hair plastered to her cheeks. She lowered those dark irises to him, the caramel swallowed by the turmoil of her emotions, making the colour of her eyes flicker uncontrollably across the entire spectrum of hues — from opaque black to vitreous white.
"Vin likes to… hit me… when he’s frustrated." She murmured, voice barely there. "Vinny too. They help my parents hold me under in the ice bath if I don’t obey them." She swallowed with difficulty; her saliva had suddenly thickened. "My mother… well, I can’t say she isn’t delighted about us dating. She’s… over the moon. Already planning a wedding and everything."
Regulus allowed himself a smile, even though all he really wanted was to cry.
"Do you reckon she’ll still be over the moon when I kill your brothers?" The suggestion made all the pain in Victoria’s eyes shift into a morbid worry.
"You’re not going to do that, Reggie." She sniffed, wiping the back of her hand across her reddened nose. "But if you do, I’ll help you bury the bodies."
"Bury the bodies? I thought they’d be the guests of honour at our wedding. We could tie them to the chairs so they don’t topple over mid-ceremony…" His lips stretched wider with each word.
Victoria blinked, raising her eyebrows.
"You’re awful." She cleared her throat. "But I reckon tying them to the chairs would be dramatic enough for my mother."
"Dramatic is the bare minimum your family deserves," Reggie replied, his eyes gleaming with boyish mischief. "After all, they’re the Noble Rookwood Clan of the Highlands and the Most Ancient and Noble House of Black."
Victoria pressed a hand to her mouth to muffle her laugh, shaking her head in disbelief at how Regulus could turn her personal tragedy into something almost… bearable.
"If you keep talking like that, I’m going to end up believing you really are capable of doing it…"
Reggie rolled onto his back, grey-blue eyes infused with that familiar air of mockery.
"Believe me, Mimi, the rumours about me are all true. I’m mad like my uncle, dangerous like my mother, and exactly like my father. What Sirius meant by that? No fucking clue." He shrugged, letting out a rough, painful laugh.
Victoria’s fingers stilled in his hair, the colour of her eyes settling back into that deep light-brown, almost her usual caramel shade.
"Are you alright?"
The question made Regulus sit up from her lap in an instant, bracing his hands against the cold floor, his eyes fixed on some vague point in the room. He swallowed hard, dragged a hand roughly through his hair and stood, extending a hand to her.
Victoria was pulled up by him, enveloped in a tight, urgent embrace that chased away her tears as swiftly as it steadied the rhythm of her heart. His body was damp and cold, but none of that mattered with Regulus. Her fingers travelled along his bare back, feeling his skin shiver beneath the trail of fire left by her touch.
"They don’t have the right to make you feel like this…" Regulus pressed Mimi’s face to his chest. "Unworthy of love… just because you don’t do what they want."
"No, they don’t." Her voice cracked. "But… I still feel that way." She closed her eyes, suppressing the pain grinding at her heart at the knowledge that her parents would never love her unconditionally. "Why do I still feel bad about it?"
Regulus didn’t know either. Children were nothing but tools to pure-blood families. A bargaining chip. It had been that way in Sirius’s time, and nothing had changed in his.
"It’s alright. I’m here." he murmured, kissing her hair. "You deserve more, Mimi. So much more. You deserve to be free, to live without fear of disappointing people who don’t give a toss about you. And I intend to make sure of it."
Victoria opened her eyes — now crystal blue. A disbelieving laugh escaped her lips at the seriousness in Reg’s tone. It frightened her as much as it comforted her.
"How?"
"Date me?" He flashed a crooked, dimpled smile.
"Seriously? You’re rotten, Regulus…" Victoria rolled her eyes, untangling herself from him.
"I’m serious!" Regulus bit his lower lip, stopping himself from grinning. He grabbed his wand from the counter and, with an Accio, a little box floated neatly into his hand. When he opened it, Victoria narrowed her eyes at the sight of the two rings inside. "Date me?"
"We already are dating!" She put her hands on her hips, her pale face flushing in the most charming way.
"Do you want to date me for real?" Regulus repeated, struggling not to laugh with every word.
"So we’re dating for pretend?!" Mimi gaped at him, personally offended.
"For Merlin’s sake, Victoria, do you want to or not?!" He brushed off her protests, pulling her closer by the waist.
"I do!" Victoria straightened up and reached for the ring, but Reg snapped the box shut.
He clicked his tongue twice, smug.
"I’m the one who’s putting it on!" he complained, narrowing his eyes. "You weren’t in such a rush two seconds ago…"
"Regulus, get on with it." she growled through her teeth.
He obeyed her without hesitation. He picked up the silver commitment ring and slid it onto Victoria’s ring finger, his expression overtaken by a genuine smile. In return, she gave him a quick kiss — just enough to muddle his senses while she slipped the ring onto his finger.
"I now pronounce you husband and wife," Mimi said, pretending to be a priest. "You may kiss the bride, Mr Black."
"She’s already kissed me," Regulus complained, before pulling her in for another. This time, with no haste or embarrassment — only softness and surrender.
It was far too easy to carry her with him into the shower stall. Victoria was far too occupied trying to stop his tongue from invading her mouth, though she didn’t manage it for long. Regulus was not only persistent, but the careful, eager way his lips shaped themselves against hers was intoxicating, as if they had been made to worship her. She granted him passage; their warm tongues brushed, their hungry hands explored, and their breaths became one.
The kiss broke only when Reggie’s hands cupped Mimi’s arse, pulling her against him, her stomach brushing against his obvious erection. She pushed him away gently, leaning back against the cold wall, her chest rising and falling without pause, pupils blown wide, heart racing.
"Too fast." she whispered, her voice barely there.
"Sorry." Reg glanced down at his own groin, as if trying to hide how hard he was — a nearly impossible task given he was only in swim shorts. And even harder with Mimi standing right in front of him still wearing her dress clinging to her body, inside his bathroom, cheeks flushed and yellow eyes locked on his grey ones.
"It’s fine." Victoria hugged her own body. "Can I shower?"
Regulus opened and closed his mouth, but no sound came out. He’d lost the ability to speak.
"Uh… yeah. Yeah." He cleared his throat and backed out of the shower stall. "I-I’ll get you a towel and… do you want something to wear?"
"A T-shirt."
"Right." Reg left the bathroom, returned with the T-shirt and towel, and disappeared so fast he looked like a blur.
He sat on the bed, his heart hammering in his chest. Of all the things that had happened that day, having Victoria showering in his bathroom like that… argh, Regulus, think about something else!
I mean… it was completely predictable what Scarlett would do, wasn’t it?
As much as he refused to believe the things Remus, Nate and Orfy had told him about Scarlett, the overwhelming fear that they were right quickly seized control of his body.
And the way Scarlett’s gaze — always so succinct and yet so tragic — had been subdued by layers of a darkness he did not recognise… enraged him. Because he truly didn’t know his own mother. Not the way his uncles did. And realising they might have been right…
It was frightening. His mother wasn’t a monster, she couldn’t be a monster, she was just… just a woman. A woman who had left him with his uncle because she’d been imprisoned and who, even when free, abandoned him constantly. Regulus shuddered, flexing his toes. Why did she always leave?
What are monsters, if not the facets we fear in the people we love?
Regulus let his back fall onto the mattress, covering his eyes with his knuckles. He had never seen Sirius act so explosively with anyone before — least of all with him. Yet he had seen something in his eyes that he recognised instantly: fear.
Sirius was afraid.
"I heard the argument…" The sentence made him lift just one finger from his eyes, opening them slowly to find Mimi standing there, hair wet, wearing his Nirvana T-shirt. "With your mother and Sirius."
Regulus drew in a deep breath. Of course she’d heard. His reaction was to press his lips together.
Silence had always been welcome between them, yet Victoria stood there waiting for an answer, even knowing she wouldn’t get one. Reg’s expression was unreadable; she couldn’t tell whether it was because of the shadows gathered in the blue of his eyes or beneath his thick lashes.
She blew the air out of her lungs with a hiss.
"Reg…"
"Lie with me?" he cut her off, drumming his fingers beside him on the bed. "Please?"
Victoria remained frozen for what felt like an eternity. Then she nodded. What choice did she have? She crawled across the coverlet and lay against Reg’s arm, which wrapped around her. She buried her face over his heart. She felt his sharp jaw working, as though he were chewing the argument to make it more palatable, while his throat moved in the effort to swallow it all down. Victoria’s uneven breathing brushed against his bare chest. His other hand’s fingers tangled themselves in her white hair.
Regulus allowed himself to sink into Victoria — into her unblemished skin, the heat curling between their bodies, her heart that so willingly sheltered him. Surrounding him in safety and calm. The world could be falling apart, but it didn’t matter. She was the barrier that kept the violent waves from engulfing him and drowning him cruelly at the bottom of a sea of blue eyes, bleached hair and cowardly lips.
Two light knocks on the door made them both jerk their heads up in alarm, as if they were doing something wrong. Reggie rolled away on the bed just in time for it to open, revealing Remus, whose head tilted inside slowly, as though afraid of what he might find.
"Reg? Mimi’s parents sent a letter asking for her to come back." He looked just as uncomfortable with the situation as the two of them did. Mimi shot off the bed and slipped into the bathroom to change. "Everything alright?"
Regulus drew in a breath and lowered his gaze, lifting only one shoulder in a half-shrug. An uncomfortable silence settled between them, as though both wanted to speak but neither dared take the first step. Victoria left the bathroom and Reggie followed her out of the bedroom, Remus’s stare burning into the back of his neck.
As soon as he reached the sitting room, he was pulled into a hug by Luana, who was also on her way out. Reg walked them both to the front of the house. He kissed Mimi goodbye, a foolish smile pulling at his lips when he saw the ring on her finger. He watched Lua hop onto her skateboard and ride along the pavement, chattering about how she’d beaten Fred Weasley in the swimming competition Tonks and Remus had organised.
Victoria didn’t seem to care in the slightest, constantly glancing over her shoulder at Regulus until the two girls turned the corner. Regulus’s smile wilted. His eyes ran along the lit streetlamps, the asphalt still warm from the day, until they rested on the front of the garage. The marks from the tyres of Scarlett’s Honda streaked across the white ramp.
He clenched his fists, feeling his blood stir, his fingers tingle.
He barely noticed he was walking back inside. He shut the door and crossed the living room, unsettled. Why had Scarlett…
No. He wasn’t going to think about her. Not now.
"Reg…" The call made his steps quicken. Sirius was standing beside the fireplace, holding a small vial with something glowing inside.
Regulus didn’t listen. He simply quickened his pace and dashed into his bedroom, shutting himself in with desperation. His heart began battering against his ribs again, wild and uneven, and his stomach twisted. What had he meant by…
Regulus didn’t know how long he lay in his room, arms spread on the mattress, eyes fixed on the ceiling. Suddenly, he sat up, changed clothes, grabbed his skateboard from under the bed and his Walkman from the bedside table.
.
.
.
[Toto — Mama]
The skate park was poorly lit by old, flickering streetlamps, the night’s shadows stretching long across most of the course. His feet guided the board instinctively, but his mind was elsewhere. The Walkman sat clipped to his waistband, the beat of the song syncing with the spiral of emotions ricocheting through his chest like a school of fish being chased by a predator.
Mama, I don't love you anymore
He pushed off hard, knees bending as he dropped into the main bowl, his heart determined to burst out of his throat. The warm summer night breeze brushed his face when he picked up speed and executed a kickflip, the board spinning in the air before landing beneath his feet with perfect precision.
Regulus kept going, tension coiling in his muscles the same way thoughts piled up at his core.
It’s the only thing you know how to do: abandon the people you love!
He adjusted his headphones when the music failed to drown out the argument from earlier, the spark of decades of pain, embarrassment and resentment that had flashed in Scarlett’s eyes — and the way she tried to hide it behind the ice in them, only for it to escape through the cracks of her heart.
I wish you were dead.
Regulus swallowed hard. His blood rushed in his ears, tight with anguish and remorse. He hated himself for saying it. Hated himself even more for not ignoring the boiling rage that scorched his insides, splintering through his organs until it seethed in his bones.
He pushed the skateboard again, gaining more speed, trying to dissolve the unbearable pressure tightening in his chest. This time, he attempted a frontside air, the board rising with him into the air as he grabbed it, landing with a heavy thud.
A perfect landing.
The pressure didn’t ease.
Mama
Please throw me out in the cold
Regulus shifted direction aggressively, skating back the way he’d come and, as if flipping a coin, Scarlett’s image vanished from his mind — replaced by Sirius’s. The memory of his godfather shoving him, that furious look and those sharpened words made him shudder.
You’re just like your father!
He couldn’t get Sirius’s expression out of his head. That look of disgust, disappointment — and even fear. Fear? What was his uncle afraid of?
He expelled all the air from his lungs with the same force as the indignation and frustration exploded inside him. He turned up the Walkman’s volume and shot forward recklessly, David Paich’s keyboard solo echoing in his ears as he closed his eyes.
He attempted a 360 flip, but failed the back-foot scoop. The board spun wrong and he lost control, rolling along the ramp until he came to rest on his knees.
"Shit!" he muttered, lifting his scraped leg as he pushed himself upright on the warm concrete.
The Walkman hung from his neck, still playing, though the music sounded more distant now. Sweat slid down his forehead. He scrubbed his face with both hands, trying to stop the argument from clawing at him all over again. He breathed deeply; the sting of grazed skin was nothing compared to the tangle of emotions knotted in his heart.
He wasn’t like his father, was he?
And anyway, what the fuck was that supposed to mean? Everything he knew about his father was that he’d saved Orfeu from the Death Eaters and died right after. But he had been one of them, hadn’t he? Just like his mother. Just like Sirius supposedly had been too.
He bit his lower lip, trying to swallow whatever the hell was tightening his throat as he pushed himself up with both palms. The skateboard kept rolling away until it was stopped by a sudden movement — the sole of a leather boot pinning it in place.
Reggie looked up, his already aching heart squeezed harder by guilt.
Sirius.
Mama
I don't love you anymore
Sorry
I'm not the boy you're looking for
He stood there at the edge of the ramp, a lit cigarette dangling between his index and middle finger, his other hand shoved into the pocket of his leather trousers. Smoke curled in spirals across his face, but not enough to hide the grey of his eyes — eyes dense enough to swallow what little light the streetlamps managed to throw at him.
Neither of them spoke, so the only sound between them was the music leaking from the headphones of his Walkman.
Sirius leaned forward and nudged the skateboard back with a subtle movement of his foot. It slid across the concrete until Regulus caught it under his heel. His uncle brought the cigarette to his lips, its tip glowing before he lifted his head and exhaled the smoke.
"Are you going to stay there on the ground or are you going to try again?" Sirius asked, showing nothing. No coldness, no harshness, no outrage. Just… nothing. As though nothing had happened.
Regulus didn’t answer. He merely lowered his gaze to the skateboard, his lips tightening into a thin line. Sirius walked slowly to the nearby bleachers and sat with a heavy sigh, elbows resting on his knees. He kept watching.
Or waiting?
Regulus couldn’t tell. He remained still, fists clenched at his sides. He stepped onto the skateboard and inhaled deeply. The unmistakable night-time scent of London filled his nose: the smokiness of Sirius’s cigarette, the freshness of the newly cut grass edging the skate park, the ammonia from the ramp where the homeless usually pissed.
Even with Sirius’s gaze weighing on him, Reggie pushed off and glided across the park once more. He didn’t want to admit it, but his presence eased the suffocating pressure that had been choking him. Still, he was hurt. So he launched himself up a ramp skillfully, rising to the top before turning his body and descending in one smooth, fluid motion.
She’s gone away
She’s gone away (see the girl with the eyes on fire)
She’s gone away
His mind drifted far away.
To a day when he had been very little and doing something wrong. He had seen photos of his mother, of course. Before Sirius was imprisoned, he constantly showed Regulus pictures of Scarlett, and the habit carried on when Nate got custody of him — though less frequently.
He knew exactly what his mother looked like, yet on that fateful day, he had wandered into Uncle Orfeu’s studio. Painting helped Orfeu cope with the torture he’d suffered, but at that time Regulus had been strictly forbidden from entering that space. He hadn’t understood why, until the figure on the canvas hanging in a place of prominence on the wall stared back at him with a pair of unsettling blue eyes.
"Mummy?" His voice had been so delicate, so childlike that even Reg barely recognised it.
"Mummy?" Scarlett laughed. A scornful laugh. "How could someone as vile as me have given birth to such a sweet little creature like you?" She tilted her head, dissecting him with her icy gaze.
He stuck a finger into his mouth, sucking it as he approached very slowly, embarrassed.
"What’s vile?" He sat beside an empty easel.
She scoffed, her pale face swallowed by the room’s shadows.
"Despicable. Abominable. Wicked."
Reggie frowned.
"My mum isn’t wicked!"
Regulus lost his balance trying to slide along a rail and leapt off the board before he fell. The ground rushed up towards him, his hands breaking his fall as the skateboard rolled to the far corner of the park. He remained lying there for a moment, breathless. He turned his head slowly to the side, towards where the darkness consumed every scrap of light on the graffiti-covered walls.
He stood without hurry. Walked to the skateboard and picked it up with his scraped hand. He stood in the middle of the park, staring up at the dark sky, dotted with the rare stars that managed to outshine the city lights.
"Remus used to skate when we were teenagers." Sirius’s deep voice echoed across the park.
Regulus said nothing, the adrenaline quieting the sting of his cuts and dilating his pupils, which shifted back to his godfather. Sirius continued:
"He tried to teach me to skate, but… I was far too busy with the girls in the stands." He burst into a loud, showy laugh. The amusement faded quickly, though.
"He taught me to skate too…" Reg finally spoke. "We used to skate together… until he decided he was too grown-up for it."
He looked at his godfather. The angular face, the sharp jawlines and upturned nose were obscured by the smoke curling past his cheeks, the orange glow of the cigarette the only thing visible besides the starry-grey of his eyes.
The same grey shining in the stars above them.
The same grey embedded in his own, streaked with blue.
"Are you here to ground me?" Regulus lifted just one eyebrow, razor-sharp.
"No." The reply came simply, as Sirius exhaled smoke. He put out the cigarette by tapping it several times against the concrete, dropping the butt there. He let out a long sigh. "I understand your anger, Reg. Truly." His tone softened. "You’ve every right to feel this way… however, things aren’t as black and white as they seem. They never are."
Reggie walked over to him and sat at his side, letting the skateboard drop to the ground to use as a footrest. He rested his hands on the cold edge of the bench, his eyes drifting over the obstacles in the park as he imagined which tricks he could pull off there, allowing the quiet to stretch on into infinity.
This, too, was a conversation of silences. And that was good. Words didn’t always manage to express everything they felt.
"Why is she always drunk?" The question barely escaped him.
He wanted and didn’t want to know the answer.
Sirius wet his lips.
"Reg, your mother… still has a lot to sort out with herself. Things she can’t deal with. Things that…"
"The McKinnons?"
"That as well."
Regulus frowned, shaking his head.
"Am I not good enough for her?" The bitter question made Sirius straighten as if he’d just been slapped. "Maybe if… if I… if…"
"No." Sirius cut him off with conviction — and gentleness. His tattooed hand, heavy with rings, reached for Reg’s, fingers careful not to touch the raw skin of his palms. "Reg… look at me."
He obeyed, lifting his tormented gaze to his uncle’s.
"None of this has anything to do with you. Nothing. You’re not to blame for any of it." Sirius went on with such certainty that Reggie almost believed him. "On the contrary… you…" His thick brows drew together until a crease formed between them. "You’re the best part of this whole story, Regulus."
Reg squeezed his eyes shut, his features twisting into a grimace of tears. His shoulders shook. He rubbed his face hard against his arm in an attempt to dry the tears falling without shame or hesitation. It was stronger than him, though.
"Then why does it feel…" He let out a trembling gasp, his voice splintering into unintelligible falters. He drew a breath, trying to force some clarity back into his thoughts. "…like I’m losing her again? E-every… every time? Like she… she disappears… a little more every time she leaves?"
Sirius shut his eyes and nodded. He swallowed thickly as he tried to digest his nephew’s confession. He wasn’t the only one wounded by Scarlett — and that was what exasperated him most. He could endure being hurt by her; it was just another injury in his vast collection — but… Regulus didn’t deserve to go through this.
Not even he deserved it, to be honest. Yet it wasn’t as though he could rid himself of her. Scarlett was embedded so deeply in his heart that, if he dared pull her out, he would collapse with her.
That was why he’d got that stupid tattoo on his chest. Scarius. How could a single little word bring him so much happiness and so much misery? Could it still be the reason for his memory and his ruin; his longing, affection and guilt? His shame and his aching nostalgia? He rubbed his palm over his heart through his T-shirt, as though his skin were a drawing in the sand and his hand, a wave.
"I know how you feel," Sirius whispered, sliding an arm around Reggie’s shoulders, whose anguished gaze never left his. The grey now swallowed the blue so effortlessly that Sirius couldn’t help but think of his brother… though there was no steel in those needy irises, only silver and ice. "It always hurts to watch someone we love walk away."
Regulus buried his face against his chest, and Sirius wrapped him fully in his arms, his fingers travelling through the faint curls of hair as black as his own. He looked at the little swirl at the crown of Reg’s head — the same one he’d had since birth — and breathed in a scent so similar to his: sweet and fresh.
"I just wanted… I just wanted her to be properly dead." The confession was practically spat out; raw, biting and unyielding, weaving through Sirius’s chest as though trying to poison his heart. Because for a few moments — moments he was ashamed to admit even to himself — he too had wished Scarlett were dead. "At least then… I wouldn’t feel this pain. She’d only leave once."
Even though he shared that thought, he knew it was wrong. Merlin, Sirius would give anything for Scarlett simply to see herself. To see who she truly was. But he couldn’t make that happen. Sirius wasn’t anyone’s saviour. In truth, all he was capable of doing was helping her drown in that bottomless pit.
He had been an addict once. The decision had to come from her. And Sirius doubted it ever would. Scarlett was punishing herself in the worst way possible.
He understood her too — far more than he was willing to admit. That was the foundation of whatever it was that burned between them. Something that didn’t extinguish when he raged, when he spoke things he didn’t mean… when he was cynical and unbearable.
To be loved unconditionally like that, even with Scarlett always leaving, was… devastating. He knew she would come back, and even though he didn’t want that, his heart beat faster just knowing Scarlett would return.
Sirius Black was not someone easy to love, though Scarlett loved him with such natural devotion that it was hard to let her go. It was hard not to be affected by her as well.
"Do you think she hates me?" Regulus’s trembling question shattered Sirius’s train of thought into hundreds of pieces. "After… after what I said…"
"She would never hate you, son." Sirius ran his fingers once more through the boy’s hair — the boy he wished had been his. His other hand rubbed the back that rose and fell with the ragged sobs tearing out of Regulus’s throat. "We all say things we regret. What’s left for us to do is put our mistake right."
Regulus pulled away, avoiding Sirius’s gaze. He wiped his face with the backs of his hands and sniffed, hiccupping. His uncle kept his hand on his back; the warmth wasn’t enough to chase away the cold spreading through his ribcage and sinking into his heart.
"What did you mean earlier? When you said I’m like my father?" His incisive eyes snapped back to Sirius.
Sirius stayed still, not breaking eye contact — though now the polished silver of his irises bore scratches, creases, and stains that hadn’t been there before. Or perhaps they had, only hidden so well that Reg hadn’t noticed them.
"Your father and I… we didn’t…"
"Didn’t have a good relationship. I know. My uncle Remus told me." Regulus drew his own conclusions, pulling his legs up and wrapping his arms around them. He rested his chin on his knees. "What did you mean by it?"
Sirius inhaled sharply. It felt as though there wasn’t enough oxygen in his brain.
"Regulus used to say one thing and do another." He patted down his trousers with his free hand, searching for his packet of cigarettes. He clicked his tongue when he realised it was empty. "He was… unpredictable. And because he was unpredictable, he was someone very dangerous."
"You think I’m unpredictable?"
"No, Reg, I… I said that in anger. I’m sorry. You’ve got nothing to do with your father. You’re good, and brave, and kind. You’re nothing like him."
"And what was he like, then?"
Sirius flinched. What was Regulus like? Every time he thought of his brother, his throat closed. As if his body constantly reminded him he was walking a tightrope, on thin ice, moving toward the edge of a cliff.
"He liked reading Muggle books." Sirius smiled faintly at the gust of nostalgia that passed through him. "He was always a quiet child. Liked silence and did well on his own. We used to ice skate at Christmas on our uncle’s estate…" He scratched his beard near the corner of his mouth. "He played very well as a Seeker. He was clever."
"And how can someone like that be dangerous?"
"Do you know when… you hurt an animal and… it gets so frightened it would rather run into the road and be hit by a car than be saved by you? I hurt him, Reg. He never forgave me." His gaze lowered with the same weight that settled on his shoulders. "And he chose… to run to his death rather than be saved by me."
Regulus rested his head against his arm.
"How did you hurt him?"
Sirius clenched his hands hard, knuckles white and wrist trembling. His nails dug into his own palms.
"It’s late, Reg. We’d better head back." he murmured, standing up.
He didn’t wait for Reg to follow him. Before he even realised it, his legs were already moving, carrying him away from the skate park.
.
.
.
The sun sank between the trees, setting the landscape ablaze with rose and gold. Scarlett hardly moved. She was hiding from it: from its orange glow, from its reddened heat, from its black lethargy.
She tried to sleep.
She couldn’t.
Maybe it was the vibration of the bus, or the distant laughter of Mike and Lenny playing Donkey Kong on the Game Boy.
It wasn’t any of that, really. Scarlett knew the reason perfectly well, even if she would never admit it.
She poked her head out from under her blanket. She was lying in one of the beds at the back of the bus. They were made for bands and their tours. Scarlett pushed the curtain of her window slightly aside and watched the rising moon. Pale, almost like a ghost floating in the lilac sky.
Her gaze drifted to the aisle, searching for her dead friends and silently begging not to find them. She sighed and sank her head into the pillow, holding her breath as heat brushed the nape of her neck. She slowly rolled over and looked to the side — toward the slit in the opposite window’s curtain. Through it, the sun spilled a thin line of light that cut across her neck, glinting on her skin like red-hot iron.
She placed her hand over the ray of light, the gentle warmth dancing across her fingers in time with the rattle of the bus. Her eyes half-lidded, intoxicated, she raised her head just enough to feel the touch on her lips.
The sun kissed her.
Scarlett curled slowly back into the blankets. There was no ghost there. Even so, it was strange to be haunted by someone who was still alive.
The dreams she had under the effects of alcohol were almost always the same. Marl, Largo Grimmauld, the fire. Azkaban. They played and replayed in her mind like a film reel wound through a kaleidoscope with no beginning, middle or end. Events collided, stretched, and fought each other. Marlene watching her being tortured by the Unspeakables in the prison. Sirius trying to save her, even though there was no fire or immediate threat in the Black house. Regulus walking through the flames.
She awoke with her heart racing. Someone was holding her shoulder. A person with long hair and a gentle voice.
"Sirius?" she whispered, hoarse.
"You’ll ruin your tattoo if you keep scratching like that."
Scarlett rubbed her eyes, her vision sharpening enough to see Danny — completely stoned — lying on the bed across the aisle.
"What are you on about?" she muttered.
He simply pointed to his own left forearm.
"Your new tattoo. You’ll ruin it if you keep scratching. " the boy repeated, slowly. "Red, huh? Looks sick. But why’s it faded?"
Blinking as her eyes adjusted to the dim glow of the lamp above them, Scarlett stroked the area Danny had indicated. Her pale skin was now warm, raw and swollen. A half-faded design emerged from the irritated pores: a serpent slithering out of the jawbone of a skull.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 75: It was always about you and Regulus
Chapter Text
CXLIII
Pandora Malfoy laughed and shook her head at every word Dorcas and Xenophilius said, though she wasn’t truly listening. Her gaze drifted over the polished suits of armour on the opposite side of the corridor, then to the wizards in the portrait on the wall who were arguing about something utterly useless, and finally settled on the flowered glass of the nearby window. She blew on it and wiped it clean with the sleeve of her Slytherin cloak, peering out at the fields beyond the castle.
Everything seemed quiet and frozen stiff from the biting cold. Everything except…
Except a tall figure, black-haired, his hair falling a little past his shoulders, and a Gryffindor scarf hanging loosely down the sides of his body. His dark silhouette in the sea of snow was beginning to be dusted with the drifting flakes around him.
Sirius Black was humming a tune completely out of time, out of tune, and out of any recognisable lyrics. Not that he cared. The alcohol scrambled his senses and twisted his tongue. He staggered through the freezing cold as though he were strolling along the warm sands of a summer beach.
His birthday would be the next day. In the past, he’d have been lively and radiant, especially because Scarlett would be knee-deep in preparations from head to toe. But… now, it was as though…
He understood the pain she felt. Of course, it wasn’t like her grief of having lost her entire family, yet there was something gnawing at the edges of his heart.
In the beginning, it was easy to pretend he was fine while getting drunk, because alcohol dulled his pain so effortlessly.
Now, it was as though Sirius had only just realised the enormous piece of himself that had been torn away.
He breathed out, watching it turn to vapour. He placed a hand on his chest, searching for the part of himself he had lost.
He didn’t know how to find it again.
Scarlett was right. She should feel relieved. Having a child at that point in their lives would have been the most irresponsible and idiotic thing the two of them could possibly have done… and even if they were both of those things, everything had a limit. Even Scarius had a limit.
Didn’t it?
It made sense he was so affected. He had wanted that child so badly it felt as though something crucial had been stolen from him.
A future, perhaps? No, not a future.
A family.
How could he love something that hadn’t even… existed? And why did it hurt so much? He couldn’t understand.
Sirius shrank into himself, though not from the cold. Love could rarely be explained. It depended on many variables, and none of them behaved like a mathematical formula, nor a magical equation. Human nature does not function with such logical measures. Feelings must not be rationalised in such a visceral way.
He hadn’t understood that back then, and he wouldn’t understand it seventeen years later either, still shackled to the memories that hurt him, clinging to his pain as one clings to a loved one they can no longer release… even after the flames of youth have burned out, leaving only the shadow of the man he once was.
"Do you want to fall ill that badly before your birthday?"
His first reaction was to hide the bottle of Firewhisky beneath his coat. Then he glanced sideways at Pandora without turning his head. He flashed his most arrogant, carefree smile and shrugged.
"I don’t fall ill that easily." He boasted, folding his arms.
"With the amount you’ve drunk, you probably aren’t even feeling the cold," Xenophilius remarked, making him stiffen when he registered the presence of the Ravenclaw leaning against the castle’s damp stone wall.
Sirius opened and closed his mouth. He chose to remain silent, tightening his lips and shifting his gaze to the snow that twirled around them with calm, graceful ease.
"I didn’t get the chance to speak to you after Halloween." Pandora stepped closer, brushing the accumulated snow from his shoulders. Sirius felt his whole body go rigid, frozen. "Are you alright?"
"Yeah… yeah. Scar’s fine." The reply slipped off the tip of his tongue. He’d repeated it so many times to the Marauders those days that he barely needed to think before spitting it out.
He ran a hand through his messy hair.
"Are you alright?" she repeated, her sharp pupils searching for his elusive ones. "Sirius…" Pandora’s pale hand slid from his shoulder to his arm. "You can talk to me. I’m your friend too."
Sirius let out a disdainful huff of laughter, tilting his head until it rested on Pandora’s shoulder. Her long, silver-blonde hair released an earthy, woody scent that took him a moment to recognise as sandalwood.
"I’m brilliant." He rolled his eyes, as though Pan’s persistence were entirely irrelevant. "What are you lot doing out here anyway?"
"Making sure you don’t fall ill before your birthday." Xen answered, pushing himself off the wall as he approached them. "It’s bloody cold out here, Sirius."
"Oh, so now you’ve both become my babysitters?" Sirius snorted, sharp and mocking, stepping back. "I’m of age, I don’t need anyone hovering over me…"
"We’re worried, Sirius." Pandora cut in. "I’m serious."
"So am I." He tripped over something, grabbing hold of a pillar before he landed on his arse in the snow. "Everything’s perfectly wonderful."
The austerity lingered on Pandora’s face. It was an expression that didn’t suit her doll-like features at all—her cheeks and the tip of her nose were flushed red from the cold. She stepped carefully along the path toward him, and the concern and condescension framing her light eyes irritated him deeply.
"Come on, Sirius, stop acting like a little child and…"
He didn’t wait for her to finish. With his characteristic stubbornness, Sirius turned his back to Pandora, and his appearance shifted abruptly: his Gryffindor cloak became thick, black fur, his pale face darkened, and his upturned nose became a damp snout. Padfoot shot off into the distance, running carefree through the soft snow.
It was strange to feel the icy wind ruffling his fur and tearing at his lungs like that. The last time he had transformed into his canine form had been on the full moon, and he hadn’t had much time to enjoy himself with his friends. Moony had been far too irritable and violent, so he and Prongs had needed to restrain him in the Shrieking Shack for the entire night.
He threw himself into a pile of snow in the gardens, rolling and rubbing his back in it, belly-up as he grunted. His black coat marred the fluffy white landscape. Not even the pricking cold against his back was enough to chase away the sting gnawing at his heart. He stayed there, panting, the flakes melting over his warm, wet snout.
Something flew across his peripheral vision. The dog widened his eyes and watched the stick fall a few metres away.
"Go on, fetch it, Padfoot!"
He didn’t need to look to know it was Pandora encouraging him.
Sirius very much wanted to stay there, sprawled in the soft snow. But Padfoot did not. His canine instincts — or perhaps the desperate need to numb the unbearable pressure in his chest — made him leap up, slicing through the white blanket covering the gardens to clamp the stick between his teeth.
He returned to Pandora, tail swinging back and forth.
"Good boy." She murmured, taking the stick.
She threw it again.
Padfoot bolted off, carving through the fluffy white carpet. Xenophilius sniffed out a laugh, crouching as he shaped a snow goblin. The dog returned at full speed, twitched his ears, and deliberately ploughed through Xen’s creation.
"Oi!" He clapped his hands. "Naughty boy!"
Mouth wide in a doggish grin, Padfoot dropped the stick at Pandora’s feet, barked, and shot a mischievous look at Xenophilius. Panting heavily, the dog seemed to be exhaling a mocking smile at the Ravenclaw. Pan threw the stick once more.
Snow flew up around Padfoot as he skidded and launched himself forward. When he returned, he slowed, his ragged breathing producing clouds whipped away by the biting air. He dropped the stick on the ground and sat down, his fluffy tail wagging so wildly it looked as though he were trying to make a snow angel.
Pandora pulled her wand from the pocket of her cloak and cleared the roots of a nearby tree with a spell. She and Xenophilius settled there, three dark points in the muted landscape. Padfoot followed them, still panting. Beneath the mud, he found a tiny blue flower that had survived the blizzard.
Padfoot carefully uprooted the tiny specimen and rubbed his snout against Pandora’s arm to get her attention. She looked at him, her rosy lips curving into a gentle smile as she took the flower and placed it just above her right ear. The dog let out a satisfied sound and rested his head in her lap, lowering his ears. His silver, weary eyes drifted over the snow-covered garden before finally closing.
All Pan did was stroke his head slowly, her fingers gliding through his dark, tangled fur. Padfoot’s breathing gradually softened until it settled into a steady rhythm.
And together they watched, powerless, as the snow began to fall early on that rare autumn afternoon.
.
.
.
Sirius’s tattooed, ring-covered fingers traced the name on the document painfully slowly, as though he were reading it in braille.
Pandora Lovegood.
He took a sip of Firewhisky, which eased the dryness in his mouth and brought that familiar burn to his throat. He shouldn’t have been drinking, not as a former addict, but he knew no anaesthetic on earth would ever be enough to withstand Scarlett Gaunt.
He slammed the folder shut, massaging his temples.
He didn’t want to think about her, yet at the same time… he needed her so desperately. He hated her as well. Above all, he hated himself for allowing himself to love her, to want her even after everything she had done to him. She was his sweet poison, his drug, and Sirius was a bloody addict, incapable of letting her go.
He shook his head, trying to shake her from his thoughts.
It was an arduous task, and Sirius was exhausted.
He opened another folder and flipped through it until he reached the handwritten records:
30/12/1981
Applicant: Pandora Lovegood
Request: Annulment of conviction due to lack of formal trial of the defendant.
Status: Request Denied.
03/12/1982
Applicant: Pandora Lovegood
Request: Annulment of conviction due to lack of formal trial of the defendant.
Status: Request Denied.
Note: Similar requests were made annually until 1989, all denied on the basis of absence of new evidence.
Sirius reached for another folder, stopping on the same page of records:
06/12/1978
Applicant: Pandora Lovegood
Request: Permission to visit the convicted prisoner.
Status: Request Denied.
24/06/1979
Applicant: Pandora Lovegood
Request: Permission to visit the convicted prisoner.
Status: Request Denied.
15/02/1980
Applicant: Pandora Lovegood
Request: Permission to visit the convicted prisoner.
Status: Request Denied.
30/12/1981
Applicant: Pandora Lovegood
Request: Reopening and review of the case due to the recent exoneration of certain Death Eaters, under allegation of possible Imperius Curse control or coercion through threats to family members.
Status: Request Denied.
Justification: Absence of evidence demonstrating mind control or direct coercion at the time of sentencing.
Final Note: All requests archived in accordance with decree 321-B of the Department of Magical Law Enforcement.
Sirius wiped away a solitary tear before it could fall and stain the paper. He squeezed his eyes shut and pressed his lips together. The boys were in the back garden; Reg was teaching Harry how to skateboard. His eyes travelled around the studio, where he had set up his improvised office by stacking boxes and clearing enough space for his desk near the floor-to-ceiling window.
He watched the sun shine across the surface of his acrylic drum kit, reflecting in golden flashes over the cymbals and hi-hat. He ran a hand over his face until he pushed his hair back, tying it into a ponytail.
He didn’t remember saying goodbye to the boys or to Remus. When he realised, he was already soaring through the summer sky on his Ninja: the cool wind lashing against his beard, his hair, his loneliness. The sun majestically brushing the corridor of clouds ahead with strokes of ochre, salmon and lilac. Glinting on his aviators, on his leather jacket, on the dampness of his cheeks.
He had never felt so free and, at the same time, so imprisoned. He had traded Azkaban for a heart, traded the Dementors for Scarlett.
What difference did it make? It was as though he could only live with a chain around his neck.
The journey was long. The daylight began to fade beneath the coming dusk. The colours of the landscape below, always so vivid and crisp, now blurred as they shifted between pastel and shadowy tones.
Sirius began to lose altitude as soon as he spotted the small village of Ottery St Catchpole blossoming between the yellowing hills and the reed fields stirred by the gentle breeze, bordering the little river that crossed the village in a silver streak.
He leaned his body slightly forward, feeling the vibration of the engine as he descended. He narrowed his eyes as he caught the peculiar outline of the residence: a black, eccentric cylinder rising against the orange sky of twilight, the ghostly moon hanging behind it as the sun dipped towards the horizon.
The tyres hit the yellowed grass with a jolt. Sirius slowed gradually until he came to a complete stop beneath a huge willow. He dismounted and raised his wand, murmuring a spell that made the motorbike shimmer, distorting as though covered by a curtain of water before disappearing entirely.
The orchestra presented by the wind was played by the leaves of the trees, the chirping of crickets and the squeal of the rusted gate directly ahead. Sirius looked at the house for a moment before turning to the three signs fixed to the crooked iron railings, so bent they looked ready to collapse.
The first read: The Quibbler. Editor: X. Lovegood.
The second: Bring your own Gurdyroot.
And the third: Do not approach the dirigible plums.
Sirius furrowed his brows, his lips twisting into a sceptical smile. It was so characteristic, so typical of Xenophilius that it took him a few moments before he pushed the gate open. The zigzagging path leading to the house was crowded with strange plants, including a bush covered in very peculiar orange fruits.
He continued on, passing beneath a pair of crab-apple trees bowed under their own weight, and dense crowns of mistletoe with white berries standing guard on either side of the front door.
He knocked on the thick black door studded with iron nails, using a knocker shaped like an eagle. Sirius hadn’t even released the ring when the door flew open, and he was greeted—his heart lurching in his chest—by a girl with blonde, unevenly cut hair down to her waist, very light eyebrows, and a little face that looked like a porcelain doll. She radiated an overwhelming aura of unmistakable oddity.
An aura he knew all too well.
Perhaps it was because she kept her wand tucked behind her left ear, or because she wore radishes for earrings, or maybe it was those ridiculous glasses… no. It wasn’t because of any of that.
She was clearly Pandora and Xenophilius’s daughter.
A nauseating spasm twisted his stomach, bile scraping his throat. She looked so much like Pandora that it felt as though he were standing in her presence.
The same sensation he had when he was with Harry.
Even her scent was the same: sandalwood.
"Yes? How may I help you?" The girl was watching him through her enormous, multicoloured Spectrespecs. "Were you attacked by a Wrackspurt?"
"I was… was I what?" Sirius scratched the back of his neck, too disconcerted to form a coherent sentence.
"A Wrackspurt… they’re invisible, they enter through the ears and scramble one’s brain," she explained, her calm, gentle tone so like her mother’s. "I was hunting a few in the garden earlier… I sensed them drifting about."
Then, suddenly, the girl waved her hands in the air as though shooing away giant invisible moths from around Sirius’s face. He jerked his head back on reflex, eyes wide, entirely unsure of what the bloody hell she was doing.
"Luna… you’re frightening our poor visitor." The voice behind the door made every hair on Sirius’s body stand on end.
He remembered Xenophilius’s voice from his memories, but it wasn’t the same.
It was never the same.
Xenophilius Lovegood was barefoot, wearing overalls and a white T-shirt stained with soil. His long candyfloss hair was tied up, much like Sirius’s own, in a bun.
"Hello, Sirius." He greeted him with a gentle smile, opening the door fully so he could enter. "This is my daughter, Luna. Darling, this is…"
"Sirius Black. I know." Luna remarked off-handedly, hooking her Spectrespecs onto the collar of her terribly colourful dress as she stepped out of the house. "I’m going fishing!"
"Luna!" The reprimand made her glance over her shoulder without stopping.
"It was a pleasure, Mr Black!" She waved before vanishing into the garden’s vegetation.
"She’s…" Sirius began, but his voice died and refused to return.
"She is." Xenophilius agreed, the smile on his face speckled with sadness. "Come in, Sirius."
Nodding, Sirius stepped into the strangest kitchen he had ever seen. The room was perfectly circular, giving the impression of standing inside a gigantic pepper grinder. Everything curved to follow the walls: the stove, the sink, the cupboards, and all of it had been painted with flowers, insects and birds in bold primary colours. Pandora’s work, he dared assume.
In the middle of the floor, a spiral iron staircase led to the upper levels. A rhythmic thumping echoed from above, which made Sirius believe some sort of machine was operating. He was accustomed to hearing the machinery in the Ministry of Magic when passing through the corridors during his duties as an almost-Auror.
"It’s been a long time, hasn’t it?!" The question came with a cheerfulness Sirius couldn’t quite feel. "Come on, let’s go upstairs… I’ll stop the press so we can talk…" Xenophilius suggested, showing the way.
The upper room looked like a cross between a sitting room and a workshop and, as such, was even more cluttered than the kitchen. Though much smaller and entirely circular, the space was filled with piles and piles of books and papers stacked across nearly every surface. Delicate models of creatures Sirius didn’t recognise hung from the ceiling, all flapping their wings and opening and closing their jaws.
Then he spotted the source of the racket: a wooden contraption with magically turning cogwheels. It looked like some bizarre offspring of a workbench and an old shelving unit, but after a moment Sirius deduced it must be the press Xenophilius had mentioned—although he had no idea it was an extremely antiquated printing press producing issue after issue of The Quibbler.
"Give me a minute…" Xenophilius approached the machine, tugged a filthy tablecloth from beneath an immense stack of books and papers that collapsed and rolled across the floor, and draped the cloth over the press, muffling the thumps and grinding. "There, that’s better. Hello, Sirius." He extended his hand.
Sirius stared for several seconds at the calloused, soil-stained fingers. Then he straightened and shook his friend’s hand. Xenophilius looked even more cross-eyed than Sirius remembered, with one eye fixed squarely on his nose while the other regarded him with admiration and a certain respect—leaving Sirius utterly taken aback.
"Xen." A smile wavered across his lips, though not exactly one of happiness. It was the same feeling he’d had when he saw Remus in the Shrieking Shack after twelve years in prison. Nostalgia, perhaps?
"Would you like… tea?" Xenophilius pulled a face as he noticed the chaotic state of the room. "Come on, let’s drink it in the back garden, I’m replanting the dirigible plum tree…"
Sirius followed him, descending the stairs. A kettle floated on its own towards the stove, already lit, and a tray with mismatched cups and a lidless teapot waited beside it for the water to boil.
They stepped out into the back of the house, where countless plants grew upwards, sideways and along the very walls. Chairs of various sizes surrounded a hollow iron table shaped like a flower, where Sirius sat as Xenophilius brought over the plant he had been tending.
An awkward silence settled between them. Sirius pretended to observe the orange radishes — which he had learned were dirigible plums — on the plant Xenophilius was transferring into a larger pot.
"Pan…" Sirius cleared his throat. Xenophilius looked at him: one eye on the plant, the other on him. "I… I’m very sorry… for your loss."
Xenophilius gave a slight shake of his head, blowing the unruly strands of hair away from his face.
"I’m also very sorry for your loss." He scooped soil from one pot to the other using a crooked spoon. "Is that why you came here?"
Sirius tapped his fingers on the cold metal of the table. He shook his head.
"I came to… talk to you. About…" His mouth hung open, but the words refused to come. He exhaled slowly, eyes closing as he surrendered to defeat. "About everything."
"About the war?"
"Everything." Sirius repeated. "The war… Pan… Scarlett… Regulus…"
"She… always believed in you all." Xenophilius took his wand from his pocket, using Diffindo to prune the dried branches of the plant.
Sirius blinked and swallowed hard. He should have been accustomed by now to the dreadful sensation of his heart being strangled like a serpent killing its prey, but he wasn’t.
"Pan… why did she want so much to talk to Scar?! After… after the imprisonment…" The question finally tore itself free, but not without digging its spines into the flesh of his neck, scraping his throat raw. He lifted his gaze to his friend, fists clenching unconsciously. "Why?"
Xenophilius watched him for a moment far too long, setting the spoon beside the pot and wiping his hands on the pockets of his soil-stained overalls. Then one of his white eyebrows arched, as though the answer were painfully obvious.
"She wanted to understand. She needed to understand… why Scarlett had done… had done… everything… that she did…" His light eyes drifted over the plants around them before returning to Sirius in a way that felt uncomfortable, as though Sirius himself had never accepted everything Scarlett had been capable of doing.
"It wasn’t as if there was much to understand…" Sirius muttered, clicking his tongue when his voice wavered. "She betrayed me. She left. She got with my brother. Married him. Had a child with him."
The tray with the mismatched cups and the steaming teapot floated to the table, settling between them. Xenophilius didn’t move, not for several long seconds.
"Sirius… the Scarlett I knew was obsessed with you." He calmly poured the drink, crimson like beetroot juice. "She was even a bit blind to it, from what Pan used to tell me…"
"Blind?" He frowned at the statement.
Xenophilius nodded, serving the second cup with the same unnerving tranquillity.
"Indulgent with the things you did to her." He explained, placing the teapot back on the tray. "When all of this happened… with Regulus and her… Pan knew something was wrong. She always knew." He paused, staring intently at the steam rising from his tea, weighing the past. "However, Pan was afraid. We all were. Her father was killed… in the war, and before she could do anything… Scarlett was imprisoned and everything came to light."
Sirius wrapped his hand around the cup, feeling the heat radiate into his palms, gripping its edges without even tasting the tea. His gaze dropped to the thick liquid, to his reflection rippling across the red surface.
"Did she know something? Did Scar or Reg… speak to her?"
"No." Xenophilius denied without hesitation. "Not that I know of."
Sirius exhaled all the air from his lungs, his reflection swallowed by the churning current that overtook the tea.
"Then… why did Pan request a review of her sentence?"
Another pause. Xen added several sugar cubes to his tea and sipped it, watching Sirius over the rim of his cup, the golden filigree on the worn porcelain catching the light. There was a piercing seriousness in his narrowed pupils, shadowed by eyelashes so white they resembled snowflakes.
"Why did you never request a review of Scarlett’s sentence?"
The return blow struck Sirius like a punch to the stomach. His lower lip trembled, his eyes widened and he opened his mouth, searching for an answer he did not possess.
"Because…" Sirius gasped, confused. Wasn’t the reason obvious? "She betrayed me, she betrayed our friends…"
Xen’s lips parted slightly, his head tilting a little towards his right shoulder.
"Betrayed?" he repeated, the tone laden with scepticism. "And why would she do that, Sirius?"
"Because…" Sirius tried to explain, tried to summon all the superficial answers Scarlett had given him about the matter, but none of them felt sufficient.
Nothing was ever enough. Not with her. And Xenophilius saw straight through him with such natural ease that Sirius had no choice but to let his discomfort show, his shoulders tensing as he swallowed with difficulty. He didn’t like feeling exposed.
Not with someone who apparently knew him more than he had imagined.
"This was never about you and Scarlett." Xen set his cup back onto the uneven saucer. "It was always about you and Regulus."
Sirius let out a loud, incredulous laugh that only accentuated his foul mood. He wrinkled his nose in a dubious expression and rolled his eyes, folding his arms. Xenophilius did not share in his indignant amusement; all he did was study Sirius’s expression.
It was as though he saw far more than Sirius permitted him to. Since when had he been able to do that? The only person who had ever caught him off guard like that was Pandora. Surely her husband couldn’t possess the same ability!
Why was the past so transparent to everyone else and, to him, so murky? Especially his adolescent self. He didn’t have the same ease in reading his own past, which was ironic. He knew himself! He knew very well the man he had once been!
Did he? Did he really?
The ageless, ever-present scars of Azkaban disagreed.
Sirius shuddered. Scarlett had been right — he knew she had been right — but hearing it from someone else, from someone who didn’t even have the full picture of his suffering was…
Well, it was different.
Another stake driven straight into his heart, too.
"Scarlett loved you, Sirius." Xenophilius continued, his voice tinged with certainty. "She loved you so much she put up with you drunk, breaking things, talking rubbish, saying cruel things, being an arrogant prat. And she didn’t leave you — on the contrary, she tried to help you. She left… and she was right to leave, in my opinion."
Sirius felt his face ignite until it burned. Bitter, unsettling memories surged to the surface with Xen’s words.
Yes, because you can’t be ever content with just me, can you, Scar? You need both Blacks, don’t you? Just having one isn’t enough!
"She was right?" he heard himself say. Anger seized control of his voice without hesitation. "Right about what, Xen? Right about killing the McKinnons?"
"No." He shook his head, scratching the sparse beard on his chin. "She wasn’t right about that. But that’s not what we’re talking about."
"No?" Sirius hissed a laugh, his eyes sweeping the room with the same agitation that whipped dangerously through his thoughts. "Then tell me, what are we talking about, Xen?"
Xenophilius picked up a butter biscuit from the little plate on the tray and chewed it as he tilted his head.
"About your dead ex-fiancée." He replied, rolling his eyes as though the answer were painfully obvious.
Sirius massaged his eyes with his thumb and forefinger, his other hand gripping the edge of the table so tightly that his knuckles had turned white.
How was he supposed to tell Xenophilius that Scarlett was alive?
He exhaled slowly, purging from his body that latent, boiling, rancorous anger that flared the moment Scarlett’s name brushed his thoughts.
"She asked for a trial for me as well." He changed the subject, resting his elbow on the rough iron surface of the table. "Pan."
Xenophilius finished his tea, set the cup on the saucer, and spun it until it aligned perfectly.
"Pan always knew you were innocent." He whispered, resolute.
Sirius raised his eyebrows faintly, lips parting.
"You know… she had this gift… of seeing people for what they truly were." Xen pressed his mouth into a thin line before continuing: "Sirius betraying the Potters?" He shook his head, nostalgia softening his features. "Impossible. She knew there was more to your story. Just as she knew there was more to Scarlett’s."
Sirius rested his forehead against his hand, closing his eyes. It was clear there was more to Scarlett’s story, but what? The first time they tried discussing it, the two of them exploded as quickly as fire catching on a fuse. How was he supposed to find out if he was one of the people directly entangled in it?
He was tired. And the fatigue seeped into his veins, diluted his rationality, infiltrated his core. It fractured his certainties, already worn and splintered. It was as though everything he believed had happened was a lie. As though everything he had witnessed was just one piece, one shard of a much larger and far more complex mosaic.
He ventured to taste the tea, took a sip, and instantly regretted it as he nearly choked: the drink was foul, as if someone had liquefied Bertie Bott’s Every Flavour Beans with boggart-flavoured sludge. Yet even the vile taste coating his mouth wasn’t enough to overpower the bitterness on his palate.
"Scarlett is alive." Sirius revealed, without restraint or the slightest hint of reluctance. A confused crease formed on Xen’s forehead. "She escaped Azkaban with me."
And then, before his friend could ask, Sirius told him everything.
.
.
.
Click. The static faded.
"Hello?" The voice sounded muffled, discreet.
"Reg?" Scarlett asked, her tone trembling. A distorted hiss crackled over the sounds in the background.
"Hi, Mum." There was no excitement in his voice, no happiness, not even a trace of enthusiasm.
On the other end of the line, distant voices and urban sounds began to sharpen, as if Scarlett were somewhere very busy.
"Are–are you… are you alright? Is everything okay there?" Her hesitant voice was broken up by a brief burst of interference.
"Mm." The response took a while, dragged out on Reg’s lips.
The constant hum of the line filled the silence when both fell quiet.
"I… I-I’ve arrived in Madrid." Her confession came out rushed, as though she were saying something very important but was ashamed of it at the same time.
"Cool."
The noise of the telephone rose and fell in pulses, and distant voices echoed faintly from the other side. Regulus heard Scarlett sigh.
"Reg, look, I…"
"Sirius isn’t here." He cut her off, his voice sharp as steel.
"I…" Scarlett murmured, her voice cracking. "I wanted to ask you…"
"Harry wants to speak to you." Reg said, monotone.
"No, Reg, wait—"
There was the sound of a hand covering the receiver, followed by static before another voice filled the line:
"Hi, Scar." Harry let out a laugh through his nose.
"Hi… hi, Harry." She gasped, sniffing. "Are you alright? Are you okay?"
"Yeah, yeah, I’m fine." He replied quickly. "Uh, Reg, he…"
Scarlett swallowed slowly, holding her breath as if that could keep her from crying.
"Yeah… I noticed."
"He… he’s teaching me how to skateboard." Harry didn’t allow the silence to trap them.
Scarlett exhaled audibly.
"Be careful not to hurt yourself."
"Oh, it’s fine… I haven’t broken anything yet."
The hiss of the line mixed with Scarlett’s wavering laugh, emphasising the fragility in her voice.
"That’s good, Harry." She whispered affectionately, though a pungent despondency tightened around her vocal cords when she said his name. "I… I need to go."
"Alright." Harry covered the receiver. "Bye, Scar."
"Bye, Harry…" She cleared her throat. "Ah, Harry, wait. Can you put Reg back on?"
"Um, sure."
The line crackled again.
"What?" Reg asked, short and cold.
Scarlett wetted her lips.
"Can you tell Sirius that… um… tomorrow…"
Regulus’s breathing grew heavier before he cut her off abruptly:
"Are you drunk?"
Static was the only sound between them. Scarlett faltered, clearly unprepared to form a reply.
"R-Reg, I…"
Regulus did not wait for an explanation.
The final click rang loud. The line went dead.
Scarlett froze, stunned, her mouth open. The hand holding the telephone trembled.
"Star! You coming to the bar or what?" Mike shouted, crossing the street to the other side with Danny, Lenny and Stacy in tow.
She placed the receiver back in the phone box and hurried after her friends, unfocused. Her ears still rang with what had just happened. Why was she even surprised? It was the obvious result of all the shit she did: everyone was bound to hate her.
And that, unfortunately, included herself.
.
.
.
Xenophilius did not rise from the table. Sirius picked up one of the butter biscuits, feeling the rough surface against his fingertips, but he did not eat it. He waited for his friend to digest everything he had just told him. The heavy silence was broken by Luna’s arrival, carrying a box full of water and the very fish Xen had mentioned earlier.
"Is Mr Black having dinner with us?" She raised an eyebrow.
Darkness had already fallen around them. Lanterns were lit throughout the garden, and small glowing orbs drifted here and there from the magical creatures zipping between the plants. The yellow lights washed over Luna’s pale face, slipping across her harmonious features and grey-pale eyes. The look she gave Sirius was direct, inquisitive and, in a way, curious.
He squeezed the biscuit in his palm until it crumbled.
"No, I… I’m leaving now." Sirius declared, standing up slowly. His legs were numb.
"Oh… that’s a pity. Dad’s dilatex soup is lovely." Luna headed towards the kitchen, leaving the two men alone once more.
"Xen… no one can know about this."
"I know." He finally spoke, running a hand through the messy blond curls that had fallen over his forehead. "I just… does she know… about Pan?"
Sirius shrugged.
"I don’t think so."
Xen took a deep breath and crossed his arms, leaning back against the iron chair.
"Marlene, your brother and Orfy. Those are the three things you need to focus on if you want to understand the past." He listed each one, lifting a finger of his right hand. "Scarlett’s Signet, Azkaban and the Ministry are the other three you need to understand in order to unravel the present."
"I know. I just… I feel lost. Where to begin and…"
"Why do you hate Regulus?" Xen’s voice cut straight through his.
Sirius fell silent.
"Because he and Scarlett…"
"No, Sirius. Before that." Xen leaned his elbows on the table. "Long before we graduated from Hogwarts, you already hated him. Why?"
He knew why, but he didn’t want to know.
It was with that question hammering in his mind that Sirius Black mounted his Ninja, lightning gleaming in the sky and rain trembling upon the earth. His gaze fell upon a small blue flower resting on the dashboard above the speedometer. He held it by the stem and turned it between his fingers, breathing in the earthy, damp scent.
A smile tried to curve his lips, but he didn’t allow it. He tucked the flower above his ear and started the engine.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 76: Love is natural and real, but not for such as you and I, my love
Chapter Text
CXLIV
Sirius woke to Scarlett’s hands exploring his bare chest. He let out a lazy grunt without opening his eyes. He was far too focused on the warm fingers mapping every curve of his muscle, on the fingertips that slipped beneath his pants and stroked his already-hard cock.
He didn’t open his eyes, though a wicked smile curved his lips. Sirius stretched out an arm and slid it beneath the pillow, narrowing his gaze dangerously in Scarlett’s direction. She was already staring at him with a lascivious expression. She traced a blazing trail of kisses down his chest, across his abdomen, stopping at his groin. He helped her slide his pants off by lifting his hips, feeling her warm palm and slender fingers wrap around his cock with a firm grip and just the right pressure—enough that when Scarlett raised and lowered her wrist, it tore a grunt from him.
"Happy birthday." she murmured, slipping beneath the blanket. With his other hand, Sirius lifted it so he could watch her red, damp lips touch his swollen tip in a kiss that was sinfully chaste.
His cock throbbed when Scarlett’s hot breath brushed the sensitive skin. Her blue eyes never left his as she stroked the groove between the head and the shaft with her thumb, making him sigh. Then, without delay, her slick, warm tongue replaced her fingertip.
Sirius bit down on his lower lip, instinctively digging his heels into the mattress. He tossed the blanket aside and grabbed a fistful of her dyed-black hair, trying to take control, but Scarlett clicked her tongue in refusal.
"It’s my birthday." he justified, loftily raising just one eyebrow.
"But the present’s mine." Scarlett grumbled, taking him into her mouth without warning.
Sirius arched his back, holding his breath to keep the moan creeping up his throat from escaping. He slowly threaded his fingers through Scarlett’s hair as she ran her tongue along his entire length, kissing and nibbling before returning to suck him, her mouth applying the perfect constriction around his head.
Unable to contain himself any longer, Sirius thrust his hips forward and pulled Scarlett’s head down, feeling her gag around his cock, saliva spilling from the corners of her lips and tears threatening her eyes.
He held his hips still and let Scarlett find her own rhythm, taking him deeper each time, dragging out grunts that tightened the knot coiling through his body.
Impatient, Sirius pushed Scarlett by the shoulders, rolling with her in the blankets and leaving her beneath him. He forced her toned legs open with his knees and sank into her tight, already-wet cunt, growling loudly as he fucked her without restraint or hesitation, sliding in and out of her slowly to stay close to the edge.
She didn’t have much time to react. Sirius claimed her lips in another kiss, and Scarlett simply let herself be folded into his desires, moaning innocently into his mouth.
"You’re my present." Sirius murmured between kisses. "The best thing that’s ever happened to me."
Scarlett smiled, her sweet, lust-tinged smile echoing through Sirius’s whole body like a drug diluted in his bloodstream. He held the back of her neck with one hand, ensuring she wouldn’t escape him, then lowered his face to the valley between her breasts, drawing the letter S with the marks he left along her skin.
Before she could open her mouth to ask what he was doing, Sirius thrust all at once, feeling Scarlett’s legs tremble and the words slip out of her lips in a whimper. Her eyes rolled back when he increased his pace, the friction of his pelvis striking hers echoing through the Undercroft, their drawn-out moans joining the cacophony of pleasure and urgency.
Sirius braced his elbow on the bed, dragging his stubble along Scarlett’s neck, making her twist entirely beneath the sudden touch. He moved to a nipple and took it into his mouth, massaging the other with his hand. Scarlett tried to slide her fingers down to her clit, but he didn’t allow it, pushing her arm away with his own.
Then he raised his face again and rested his forehead against hers, tracing a torturously slow circle between her legs with his hand while he fucked her aggressively. He felt the immediate clench of her walls around his cock, sending him into madness.
Scarlett’s lashes fluttered as her eyes met his. Sirius plunged into her dilated pupils—so blown he could barely see the blue of her irises. She parted her lips and he kissed the corner of her mouth, increasing his movements frantically, burying himself deep inside her.
"You’re close?" Sirius grit through his teeth, dragging his mouth against Scarlett’s. "Tell me you are, because I’m close."
"It’s… it’s alright." she panted, keeping eye contact. "If you want… you can cum…"
"No…" he denied with a shake of his head. "You’re going to cum with me."
"Sirius…" Scarlett moaned his name, and it was nearly his undoing.
Sirius sacrificed rhythm for power, reducing the depth of each thrust but possessing Scarlett with such force that she shuddered with every intrusion. He lifted his torso, kneeling on the bed and pulling her against his hips, now with full access to Scarlett’s clitoris, where his thumb could work more easily. His other hand held her by the waist in that little spot already bruised from the previous nights.
The new angle made Sirius’s cock go even deeper inside her, striking her G-spot directly. Scarlett had no choice but to arch her back, clutch the sheets, and let Sirius push her into climax; her whole body went rigid and then convulsed, ecstasy dilating her blood vessels and her pupils. Pleasure vocalised by her vocal cords in Sirius’s favourite melody.
Scarlett writhed, her clitoris pulsing against Sirius’s fingertip, which kept stimulating her lazily, before he resumed the violent rhythm as he rose and held her with both hands gripping her hips, focusing on the swollen, slick walls dragging what sanity he had left until he reached his peak.
Sirius collapsed over Scarlett and spilled inside her, muffling his hoarse cry against the delicate skin of her curved neck as he thrust languidly until he stilled. She embraced him, their shallow breaths and heartbeats falling into sync. Sirius opened his eyes, feeling Scarlett’s nose brushing his cheek as she turned her face towards him, greeted by those oceanic eyes. She kissed him again, a long, languid kiss where tongues crossed and teeth scraped. Her sweaty fingers pushed the black strands away from his face, and he kissed her palm, his rough stubble tickling her skin.
Scarlett smiled with such softness that Sirius had no choice but to smile as well.
"Happy birthday, my love." she murmured against his lips, the blessing slipping through his stubble. "I love you."
"Thank you, kitten." Sirius closed his eyes, drinking in the vanilla scent of Scarlett’s hair. "I love you too."
.
.
.
The day passed quickly. It was exhausting pretending to be excited or interested, but Sirius was good at it. He was good at wearing a mask that had never belonged to him, even if it was just to please his friends and girlfriend. He’d done that for so long — ever since he’d met the Marauders — until they accepted him. Why wouldn’t he do the same on his bloody birthday? It was one of the few days where he could fuck up without being judged.
"You alright?" James asked him as they headed for the Undercroft.
Sirius frowned, went down the stairs and lifted the iron gate.
"I’m fine. Why wouldn’t I be?" He laughed, awkward, tossing his hair back.
"I dunno. You’ve been weird since Halloween." James adjusted his glasses on his face, those hazel eyes always seeing far more than Sirius was willing to show. "Was it something I did?"
"’Course not, Prongs." Sirius’s laughter soured in his mouth. "No… it’s nothing to do with you."
"Then what’s it about?"
"Sirius, do you want to open your presents here or in the Gryffindor common room?" Scarlett’s voice echoed from the bedroom until she came out carrying a box wrapped entirely in red and gold. "Hi, Jamie."
Sirius shrugged.
"Either’s fine."
James and Scarlett exchanged a glance for a moment.
"Are you alright?" she asked, her blue eyes threaded with concern.
Pretending to be fine for his friends was one thing; for James and Scarlett, it was something else entirely. They knew him like no one else.
"Yeah, just… can we go? I want to open my presents." Sirius diverted the subject with such mastery that Scarlett had no choice but to sigh, and James to give up.
He got ready for his birthday in considerable haste. He used a charm on his unruly black hair, tied his tie, wrinkled his jumper and put on a pair of chain-covered jeans that would certainly cost Gryffindor points if McGonagall saw him.
They left the Undercroft in silence. Holding Scarlett’s hand, Sirius constantly pretended to be lost in thought, squeezing his fingers into her warm palm.
"Mate, we outdid ourselves on your birthday this year." James remarked, a teasing smirk stretching his thin lips. "Seriously, you’re going to be shocked."
"Am I? What did you lot plan? Is there going to be a dwarf fight? A private Heart concert? Strippers?" The last suggestion earned him an elbow to the stomach from Scarlett.
"If you want me to gouge your eyes out…" she grumbled, the surrounding candles sharpening the shadows on her expression.
"It’s a joke, love." Sirius laughed, kissing her perfumed hair.
He closed his eyes for a moment, opening them again when they turned the corner that led to the Main Staircase. A group of students was coming from the other side, a trio he knew very well. Sirius’s heart gave a lurch as they approached, his eyes searching for Regulus’s attention. His brother was surrounded by Barty and Evan, whose whispers fell silent the moment they made eye contact.
Regulus’s iron eyes, always so cold and resolute, landed on Scarlett and took on an expression of disgust. It was subtle, almost imperceptible in the dim corridor light, but Sirius could distinguish it effortlessly. Regulus was still his brother; the rotten blood running through his veins was the same blood decomposing in Sirius’s.
Scarlett ignored him deliberately, turning her face to the opposite side as if he didn’t even exist. Sirius wrapped an arm around her shoulders in a protective gesture, drawing her close, catching his brother’s gaze.
"You alright, kitten?" he murmured into her ear, his silver eyes locked with those iron irises.
Regulus’s face twisted, assuming a mask of disdain, but his eyes couldn’t keep up with the strings he was pulling. Sirius clenched his teeth, the silver in his gaze turning to steel, sharp and cutting. A silent warning. Regulus’s nostrils flared in frustration and hurt, and he straightened like a raptor feeling threatened, slowing his stride, keeping behind Evan and Barty.
Sirius watched his brother’s movements like a wary predator, releasing the breath tangled in his chest only when Regulus finally disappeared down the corridor. He gave Scarlett’s shoulder a slight squeeze and kept walking. He felt Scarlett’s unease when she glanced at him from the corner of her eye, as though she wanted to ask what had happened between him and Regulus, while at the same time knowing exactly the answer.
She had been there; she had heard the argument perfectly well. And Sirius didn’t want to relive that night in his mind. He’d done it too many times already. That’s why he plastered a radiant smile on his face when they reached the Gryffindor common room and were greeted by a dozen voices shouting:
"Surprise!"
The room was decorated with golden and red garlands, floating candles and, in the centre atop a large table, sat a birthday cake with eighteen candles and the phrase: “Happy Birthday, Padfoot!” written in golden script.
Everyone was there: Remus, Peter, Lily, Mary, Marlene, the rest of the Quidditch team, some sixth-years and fifth-years, Pandora, Xenophilius, Dorcas…
"Happy birthday to you…" they began to sing.
His smile widened with each verse. Sirius missed being the centre of attention, missed the excitement radiating through his body, pulverising the stress of the past few days into the thrill that seemed scarcer with every birthday that passed.
When they finished singing, he leaned over the cake, filling his lungs with air to blow out the candles.
"Make a wish, Padfoot!" James shouted, his grin turning mischievous. He nudged Scarlett, who simply nodded.
Sirius closed his eyes for a brief moment. Many wishes floated through his mind like clouds drifting across the sky. There was his girl with flowers in her hair, there were his friends in their Animagus forms, there was… his brother trapped. Chained. Imprisoned by the choices he himself had made. Sirius reached out to try to grasp him, but it was impossible to touch a cloud from the ground. Just as it was impossible to touch Regulus when he was already soaked from head to toe in the legacy of the Most Ancient and Noble House of Black.
Regulus might not have been in the sky like the cloud, but he was certainly edging ever closer to hell.
That day, Sirius Black wished that he and his younger brother could be friends again one day. It didn’t need to be tomorrow, or the week after, but… that it might happen someday. Someday in a distant future.
A wish that would not come true. Sirius would remember that moment with bitterness. Why hadn’t he wished for a family with Scarlett? That was why he was suffering so much, wasn’t it? Because she had had an abortion?
No. Sirius had been hurting long before that, and he was far too selfish to let go. To accept that Regulus had been lost long ago, that if he and Scarlett had had a child then everything would have gone wrong, that he had literally all the tools in his hands to have done things differently, and yet he hadn’t.
His moment of contemplation was interrupted when he blew out the candles forcefully. Scarlett and James immediately shoved his face straight into the cake.
Sirius lifted his head, stunned, his hair covered in golden and scarlet icing and chunks of vanilla sponge with fresh strawberries. He wiped his eyes and blinked, completely bewildered. He glared at Scarlett and then at James.
"You pair of fucking arseholes!" he scolded, trying to look indignant, though the laughter escaping his lips gave him away.
"And you’re an idiot for falling for it." James replied, laughing so hard he had his hands on his stomach.
Scarlett burst out laughing. She scooped a bit of icing from Sirius’s face with her index finger and tasted it.
"Hmm… this is delicious." Scar grunted, nodding. "Happy birthday, love."
"Oh, thank you, my love!" Sirius grabbed her quickly, smearing his messy face against hers.
"Sirius, no!" Scarlett’s squeal came out several octaves higher as she tried to wriggle free, but it was too late. Her face and hair were also streaked with colourful icing by the time she broke away.
She opened her mouth again to complain, however Sirius pulled her back in and kissed her. Scarlett scrunched her nose, though she smiled. Remus captured the exact moment with the Polaroid Sirius had got the previous year.
"This one’s going straight into the album." he announced, taking the picture the camera spat out.
Sirius took advantage of James’s second of distraction (as he ran over to see the photo) and grabbed a huge piece of cake with one hand, the other still wrapped around Scarlett’s back. He winked at her, his lips widening into a boyish grin.
"Want some cake too, Prongs?" he asked, feigning innocence.
"I’m good, Padfoot." James looked at Sirius, unable to dodge the slice that was launched directly into his face, covering him in cream and sponge. "Sirius!" he laughed, removing his glasses which left a perfect round mark free of dessert around each eye.
"Sirius! You can’t do that in here!" Lily pointed a finger at him, glancing around to make sure McGonagall wasn’t present. "We can’t get th—"
She was interrupted when a generous slice hit her square in the face. The laughter faltered when they noticed Lily had frozen, icing dripping from her nose and chin.
"We can’t what, Miss Head Girl?!" Sirius shot her his most arrogant look, tilting his chin in that way only pure-bloods managed.
"Count yourself lucky today’s your birthday…" Lily cleaned her face with a flourish of her wand, struggling not to laugh. "or you’d be licking the floor clean." she threatened, placing her hands on her hips.
Sirius looked at Scarlett. She was pressing her pink lips together, a grin threatening to break into laughter. She shrugged, signalling he was on his own.
"Wouldn’t be the first time he licked the common room floor…" James remarked, as if it were nothing noteworthy.
"It’s true. On his fifteenth birthday, we spilled firewhisky on the floor and he licked—" Peter began, placing a finger on his chin as the memory came back to him.
"And he still said there was no problem drinking the whisky off the floor because the alcohol sterilised it." Remus laughed, sticking a finger into what was left of the cake and tasting it.
"Well… he’s not entirely wrong…" Scarlett teased, nudging her boyfriend with her shoulder as she cleaned their faces with a charm.
"You lot are absolute arseholes…" Sirius rolled his eyes, fond despite the memory.
"Relax, love, there’s still another surprise…" There was such lightness in Scarlett’s gaze that Sirius found himself smiling as well.
Sirius wanted to ask what it was, rubbing his hands together in excitement, but chose instead to focus on his presents: a dragon-leather jacket from Scarlett, its black scales reflecting a dark red in the light and heat-resistant so he could ride his motorbike around; a set of rock classics on vinyl from James, for when he got tired of the Walkman and wanted something for the gramophone; a pair of vintage motorbike goggles from Remus; an enchanted Rainbow poster from Lily; a collection of rare Led Zeppelin tapes from Marl and Mary; a shell necklace from Pan and Xen; and lastly, a box of Ogden’s Old from Peter.
The whisky was opened quickly. Sirius poured a bit for each of his friends, monopolising the rest of the bottle for himself. The alcohol heightened his excitement, strengthened his heartbeat, and numbed the tips of his fingers. He bobbed his head to the Queen song playing, watching Scarlett and James dance when Marl sat on the arm of the sofa beside him.
"Feeling better?" she asked, with an innocence weighed down by mischief. Sirius only raised his eyebrows. Marl took a small sip of her drink before continuing: "It’s just that you were acting strange these days… hardly spoke to anyone during Quidditch practice… and the rumours about Halloween…"
The alcohol softened his reaction. He breathed deeply, but the long exhale felt insufficient to steady him.
"What rumours?!"
Marl downed the rest of her whisky in one go.
"Oh, the usual… about Scarlett and your brother. Slytherin doesn’t go easy with that kind of shit."
Sirius’s hands clenched instantly, his fingers tightening so hard his knuckles went white.
"What?!"
If he hadn’t been so lethargic, he would have searched the entire bloody castle for Regulus to confront him about that shit. As if it wasn’t enough that he’d been an arse on Halloween, now he was spreading rumours about him and Scarlett?!
"Don’t mind them, Sirius. We know it’s all lies." Marl went on, unbothered. "Your brother’s always been an arse."
"Always." The confirmation escaped without him even thinking. He took a few more gulps of whisky straight from the bottle, letting the drink dull the tangled threads clawing at his chest and rising up his throat. "Regulus is…"
He stopped the sentence there. What was Regulus? No. He didn’t want to think about him. He shook his head until he was dizzy enough that his brother couldn’t remain at the forefront of his thoughts. It was his bloody birthday; he should be enjoying himself!
"But I’m glad you’re feeling better. Before, you were… too melancholic, I think. Melancholy doesn’t suit you." She gave him a light pat on the shoulder, her delicate face softened by a genuine smile.
Sirius looked at her sharply. What the hell was Marlene trying to say to him?! His mouth tightened into a wrinkle on his face and, without warning, he simply stood up from the sofa, crossed the makeshift dance floor, and stopped in front of the sweets table. His gaze wandered hopelessly over the ruined cake and settled on the fallen candles on the floor. He picked them up, turning them between his fingers as a memory flashed before his starry eyes.
His birthdays at Grimmauld Place had always been somewhat… dull. There were no smiles in the celebration of another year of a pure-blood heir. Everything was always too polished, too formal, too grey. His cousins were there, of course, but only Andromeda ever dared to break the pattern, risking a hidden smile at him at the dinner table.
His father would say a few empty words about the grand future of the House of Black, his uncles applauded, his grandfather gave him a present he would certainly never use, his aunts gazed at him with morbid admiration—and Reggie, at the back, was always hiding behind Walburga’s skirts.
He still remembered the soft whistle of the mansion’s gas lamps, the shadowy corridors, the macabre portraits. There was no colour, no noise, no trace of joy. It was Sirius’s birthday, and it felt much more like a funeral.
In a way, it was. Another year of his life in which he was buried under expectations, demands, and the absence of any support, safety, or love. He might as well have been lying on that table, holding a flower, laid in a coffin, for their expressions would have been the same. Their words too.
None of it mattered; he only existed for the future of a family doomed to extinction.
The cake was the only moment that differed from the Blacks’ annual ritual. There were candles; even if they were yellowed Victorian ones that Kreacher had probably found in a filthy box at the back of the attic, unlike the colourful candles that had decorated Regulus’s cake months before.
Sirius gestured for his brother to join him at the table by his side. Of course, in normal circumstances that would never have been allowed, but they were gathered as a family. At least, they were meant to act like one.
He always allowed Regulus to blow out his candles. Was that why none of his wishes ever came true? Because his brother blew his desires away?
Thinking about it now, perhaps it was. Yet at the time, he only did it because Reggie always laughed when the thin line of smoke drifted up from the wicks. He had always done everything for his younger brother. In return, he’d been rewarded with a knife in the back.
His heart twisted violently at the memory. Regulus’s smile was so distant it was untouchable. His brother had now become exactly what Orion Black had expected of him: a snake ready to strike.
He stretched out his arm and grabbed another bottle, opening it with his teeth. Guilt and longing danced in his oppressed chest much like James and Scarlett waltzed in front of him.
Sirius squeezed the candles in his palm, breaking them between his fingers. His and Regulus’s fate had been written long ago, long before their mother’s rotten womb could bind them together in the tragedy of being born into a cradle of blades. Into a hostile environment where he had to beg for the scraps of love Regulus received.
It was like the saying went: if love isn’t given on a silver spoon, you learn to lick it off the edge of a knife.
He gasped softly, taking another sip. Loving Regulus was just another way of hating himself and, by Merlin, Sirius had already hated far too much in his eighteen years.
His gaze instinctively drifted to Scarlett, who was laughing freely, moving in perfect sync with James. He didn’t want to interrupt the dance, but before he realised it, he was already on his feet, wrapping his arms around Scarlett as though the world were ending and she were his salvation.
The warmth of his drunken body radiated against her soft skin, and Sirius held her tighter, soaking in the safety — in the woman who was the home he had never known. He heard Scarlett’s laughter echo from his ribcage, vibrating through his face where it was buried between her breasts. Her delicate fingers slid through his black hair, making him close his eyes and listen to the placid rhythm of the little place where he so desperately wished to take shelter.
He wanted to step inside Scarlett’s heart and never leave again.
"You alright?" she murmured at the shell of his ear, her warm words brushing his lobe.
Sirius focused on the way her body fitted against his, on her arms around his torso, on the lips that pressed to his temple. Scarlett’s effects on him were far stronger than the alcohol. He confirmed with a nod.
"Ready for the surprise, then?" The question made Sirius’s lips stretch into a grin instantly.
"Born ready, kitten." His eyes traced her face, her slender nose, her delicate cheekbones, the vibrant blue of her eyes. His thumb slid along her jawline, stopping just behind her ear.
Sirius kissed Scarlett with tenderness, feeling the softness of her smiling lips against his, straightening up so he could pull her into his arms, plunging into that woman with such fervour that his personal torment was obliterated.
As much as he had an immense ease for hating, Sirius refused to be yet another product of his parents. He had not been born for hatred. If he had, then why did the curve of Scarlett’s neck seem sculpted for his face to rest there? Why did her hand fit so perfectly in his? Why did her waist fall so precisely beneath his palms?
Sirius Black had not been made for hatred. He had been made for love; above all, for the love of Scarlett Gaunt.
.
.
.
The rain began to fall.
The droplets quickly turned into icy needles against the exposed skin of his face. Sirius felt the cold seeping through his clothes, whipping his leather jacket, his trousers, the metal frame of the Ninja. He leaned his body back, accelerating as much as he could while the sky above was slashed by deafening lightning.
The motorbike cut through the currents of wind with ease thanks to its aerodynamics, but Sirius could feel the resistance of the air trying to throw him off. He kept climbing towards the clouds that rose above him like a fluffy, impenetrable wall.
The sky roared and flashed; a burst of light illuminated Sirius’s sober profile. His hair stuck to his face, his eyes unyielding, determination etched into every fibre of his being. His hands gripped the handlebars tightly as he swerved brutally away from the storm’s heaviest pockets.
With a final surge, Sirius burst through the clouds. The Ninja’s engine growled back at the fierce wind. The moon above him opened like a spotlight as he emerged into a clear, star-studded sky.
Moonlight cast its silvery threads over his drenched form; gleaming on his leather jacket, on his dishevelled hair, on his troubled eyes. The grey of his irises became platinum, the white of his skin, marble.
Below him, the dense clouds stretched like a snowy carpet unfurling to the horizon. Thunder rumbled low, and flashes of light flickered here and there, giving the impression that the fluffy nimbus beneath his feet were made of ice.
A smile tried to pull at his lips, but he didn’t allow it. A memory brushed the back of his consciousness, almost tickling him.
He yielded.
Another lightning strike.
"You can open your eyes now."
The enormous skating rink was empty, though all the lights were still on. Sirius looked at his friends and girlfriend, completely speechless.
"This… but… how…"
"Your surprise, Padfoot." James finished, smiling with satisfaction at his best friend’s reaction.
"We rented the rink just for you." Remus gave him a pat on the back.
"The whole night, even." Peter added, chewing an exploding bonbon.
Scarlett held his hand gently, kissing the back of it.
"Happy birthday, love." She handed him a pair of skates. "Go on, show us what you can do."
Still drunk, Sirius put on the skates and clumsily tied the laces. He stood, tested his balance, and stopped at the entrance to the rink, hands gripping the corner rail, eyes tracing the clean ice.
Another flash of lightning.
"I’m going to fall, Sirius." Regulus murmured, trembling with fear rather than cold, his new skates growing more unsteady on his small feet.
Sirius furrowed his brow, bringing his eyebrows together as if such a thing were absurd.
"You’re not, Reggie. I’m here. I’m not going to let you fall."
Regulus sucked in his lower lip and didn’t answer, his grey, uncertain eyes staring at the ice beneath his feet.
"Let’s do it this way, Reg." Sirius adjusted his posture and held his brother’s hand in an attempt to reassure him. "Just go slowly, one foot at a time. I won’t let go, I promise."
Regulus pressed his lips together and lifted his gaze to Sirius nervously. He was scared—of course he was; it was written in every line of his expression, in every inch of his posture. Even so, he dared to take a step. The skate slid softly, and he squeezed Sirius’s hand tightly, eyes widening.
"See?" Sirius encouraged, smiling. "That wasn’t so bad. Now the other foot."
Another timid movement, and Regulus travelled another centimetre. The grey in his eyes, still frightened, turned to Sirius with a flicker of excitement.
"L-like this?"
"Yeah, just like that, Reggie." Sirius didn’t hide the enthusiasm in his voice. "Go on, keep going."
Gradually, Regulus’s reluctant steps found their rhythm. He still held Sirius’s hands, but the fear was dissolving into shy confidence.
"I’m doing it, Sirius!" Reg exclaimed, with a liveliness Sirius could barely remember him ever having. He hardly seemed to believe what he was doing.
"’Course you are!" Sirius adopted his usual arrogant expression. "I told you you could, didn’t I?!"
The smile on Regulus’s face was so persistent it didn’t fade even when he finally let go of one of Sirius’s hands. He dared to glide in longer strokes, swinging his free arm enthusiastically to keep his balance. When he managed to steady himself, he looked at Sirius with an exultant smile.
A smile that…
That only a younger brother full of admiration for his elder could give.
"I’m skating!"
Sirius let go of the other hand and stepped back slightly, without taking his eyes off Regulus, his knees bent and ready to propel himself towards him in case he lost his balance.
"That’s it, Reggie!" he encouraged. "You’re skating on your own!"
Regulus laughed, daring to go further, however he lost confidence when he searched for Sirius around him. He was about to fall when he felt his brother steadying him by the shoulders from behind, helping him regain his balance.
"Whoops! Almost!" Sirius looked at Reggie, whose arms wrapped around him in a hug.
The kind of hug that was becoming rarer and rarer between them.
"Thank you, Sirius." Regulus murmured against his black overcoat, the tip of his rounded nose red from the cold.
"For what?" He laughed, flustered. His eyes lowered and found Regulus’s.
"For…" Reg blinked a few times, his long lashes framing an embarrassed look. "Er… for…"
For taking the beating in my place, Sirius supposed. For protecting me from Father. For making me smile, even though any hint of happiness is forbidden in the Most Noble House of Black. Even though… even though…
Even though in the future we’ll be strangers divided by the very concept of life and death.
The flash cut through the memory.
[Jeff Buckley — I Know It’s Over]
Sirius stepped onto the rink, his heart hammering in his chest. He crossed the ice with grace, even with the alcohol affecting his stability; however… there was no energy in his movements. The joy that had wrapped around him on his birthday began to melt away, and his smile was replaced by an expression of sorrow.
He looked at Scarlett at the edge of the rink. She smiled and waved at him.
He turned his attention back to the clear surface beneath his feet. It looked as thin as glass about to crack. His shoulders curved and he pushed off with a few determined strides, opening his arms briefly to keep balance as he leaned into a long, slow turn, his hand strangely colder than usual.
Sirius stretched his fingers and closed his eyes, listening to the delightful laughter of Regulus. Yet it fell silent, and his eyes opened only to find Reg’s tearful face.
"Why am I punished and he isn’t? He did worse… much worse… much worse…" Reggie sobbed through his crying.
"SHUT UP!" Sirius roared, his arm burning from the sheer force of the repeated swings, the whip cracking and hissing through the air, spraying blood onto the tapestry, onto the hem of his mother’s dress, onto his own cheeks. "SHUT UP, REGULUS!"
The blinding flash of another lightning bolt dragged him back to reality.
Sirius shuddered, but not from the cold. His gaze rose to the moon as the searing sensation flared through his body, pricking his nerves until everything hurt. His fingers, his shoulders, his chest.
He was a fucking liar. He hadn’t just failed to catch Regulus—he was the one who pushed him. On their parents’ orders. He’d always bragged and resented that he’d protected him from Orion and Walburga, but he hadn’t protected him when he struck him. On the contrary, after that day…
I’d rather die in Grimmauld Place than go live with you!
Regulus had kept his promise in the end. He lived through fear and died through courage. It was obvious he’d been killed for his defiance against Voldemort. Sirius just needed to be sure if it was truly because he saved Orfeu or for something more than that… but having to deal with Scarlett to find out was exhausting.
He sniffed. His eyes filled with tears, but none fell. Scarlett and Regulus were stones tied to his ankles. Forever dragging him towards his worst side, revealing his darkest layer, his most putrid facet. Love and hatred, guilt and resentment, hurt and dependency.
Sirius Black felt… constantly in mourning. Grieving all the future lost, grieving everything he could have been, grieving everything he never was. Grieving everyone he couldn’t save.
… If you're so funny,
why are you on your own tonight?
And if you're so clever
why are you on your own tonight?
And if you're so very entertaining
why are you on your own tonight?
And if you're so very good looking
why do you sleep alone tonight?
In a different life, he would be going to the market with Scarlett to buy ingredients for Sunday lunch, where he would welcome James and Lily, Remus and Mary… Regulus and Pandora.
That, however, was the only life he had. Chasing and blaming ghosts for his unhappiness. Chasing and blaming the woman he loved for his tragedy. Which was ironic, because even after Scarlett had gone away (again), there he was still hoping she felt the same. That she loved him with the same fervour. That she missed him with the same intensity.
Scarlett Gaunt would be the reason for his death and was the reason for his current misery and even so… ah, Sirius, even so there you were, flying above the clouds and wishing she were on the back of your Ninja, arms around your waist, whispering promises that would never be fulfilled into your ears, kissing your lips and giving herself entirely in the same way you wished to give yourself to her.
However, Scarlett had always been right about one thing: it was never Regulus’s fault. Orion and Walburga were the ones who should take the credit for having destroyed their children’s relationship, for having cultivated hatred and discord between the brothers. They had been so cruel and vile that Sirius couldn’t understand why two parents would do that to their own sons. The cycle of hatred rooted in the Blacks had not ended with him and Regulus, but he would make sure it ended there.
His nephew would not inherit that burden.
Sirius blinked the tears from his eyes, his heart shrinking with each beat, struck by sharp stabs of pain.
"I’m sorry, Reg…" He closed his eyes. Of course those few words would never ease the weight of everything his brother had done to him, but… he needed to let him go.
Regulus had disrupted his life enough.
… It's so easy to laugh
it's so easy to hate
it takes guts to be gentle and kind
over and over...
"I’m sorry for hitting you. For insulting you, for… for hurting you." His eyes lifted to the moon above him, bathing him in its pale glow. "I didn’t know how to be better. I didn’t… didn’t know much of anything, to be honest. I knew I loved you… but then that love turned to hatred. And after you and Scarlett…"
He limited himself to breathing deeply.
… Love is natural and real
but not for you my love
not tonight my love
Love is natural and real
but not for such as you and I my love
"I don’t know if I can forgive you for that. I’m trying, but it’s so hard…" he confessed, the cold wind lashing his soaked body. "All the pain… all… all the things between us… it’s not fair that you died." He gasped. "I wish I’d died too. It’s so much easier to disappear, isn’t it?! Than to deal with all the shit left behind…"
Sirius released one hand from the handlebars, using it to wipe his tears.
"I hate you for that. I hate you for dying. I wanted… I wanted to be able to tell you… everything I should’ve said. Everything that got stuck in my throat while we lived at Grimmauld Place. I wanted… I wanted you to trust me so that… so that I could’ve saved you."
He sobbed, sniffing hard.
"Did you at least know love before you died? I hope not. Love is fucking shit, Regulus. It destroys you before you even realise. It gives you everything you want and then leaves you with nothing."
Sirius pressed his trembling lips together, the cold shaking every muscle in his body.
"You died at seventeen. I’m almost twice your age now, I’ve lived twice as long… and I still feel lost. I still feel… like that boy… who wanted with every fibre of his being to be loved. Even… even knowing love will destroy me in the end… I don’t know what to do, Reg." He smiled. A ragged, breaking smile, accompanied by tears. "Every time she leaves… it’s like she takes my heart with her. And I… I keep… looking for it. Every time I wake up, my hand searches for hers in the bed. Every time I get up, my eyes look for the flicker of her in the room. Every time I breathe, my nose searches for her perfume in the air. I know I won’t find it, but… I keep looking."
The mists and the storm were now behind him. The lights of London appeared beneath his feet like a hundred falling stars. Sirius contemplated the shimmering reflection of the moon on the nearly dry chassis of the Ninja, and glanced at the satellite over his shoulder.
Oh yes, oh Mother, I can feel the soil falling over my head
Sirius wondered if Regulus had somehow found his way back to Pandora.
"I’m sorry, Regulus. For everything that happened between us." he murmured, tugging up the hook of the words anchored at the bottom of his heart. "I wish things had been different too."
Regulus was the moon. Sirius was the sun. Each trapped in his own dimension, destined never to meet again.
Oh Mother, I can feel
.
.
.
"Sirius?" Remus called the moment he stepped inside the house.
He took off his coat and soaked boots and crossed the vestibule, throwing himself onto the leather sofa without caring that he was still damp. He closed his eyes, trying to clear his mind, massaging his temple.
"Tough night?" his friend’s voice softened with the question.
Sirius let out a bitter laugh.
"They all have been, lately." he replied, his eyes flashing with an unrecognisable discomfort. "Can I ask you something, Moony?"
Remus parted his lips slightly, brushing his chin scar in surprise. He cast a quick glance down the corridor to make sure the boys were asleep.
"Of course you can, Padfoot."
"What’s your opinion of Regulus?" Sirius lowered his gaze to his wrinkled hands. "My brother?"
Remus tilted his head, weighing his answer.
"Well… ever since Reggie’s incessant questions about him, and after all this time… I think that… that we knew very well what he was going to become… and we did nothing about it." He shrugged, closing the book he’d been reading.
Sirius looked at him again, exhaling bitterness. He nodded slowly.
"It’s so… strange. We’re all that’s left." His features hardened as he sank back into the darkness of his eyelids. "They’re all gone. James… Lily… Regulus… Pandora… and we’re… still here."
Remus shifted in his armchair, opened the book again and flipped through it in search of a quotation.
“The world breaks everyone and afterward many are strong at the broken places. But those that will not break it kills. It kills the very good and the very gentle and the very brave impartially. If you are none of these you can be sure it will kill you too but there will be no special hurry.”
Sirius let the air slip through his teeth, imprisoning himself in an indivisible silence. Hemingway was the name on the cover.
Regulus had also enjoyed reading Muggle books. He had probably read that very one.
He shook his head.
His chilled body refused to follow the thread of his mind, where warm and vibrant moments tinted every point of his vision. The colourful past was devoured by the flames of reality until it was reduced to the ashes of the present.
"I thought you were like this because of Scarlett." Remus finally said, pulling him out of his tortuous spiral.
"In part." he confessed. "I don’t know when I’m going to stop being affected by her."
Remus stood and placed a flat hand on his frozen shoulder.
"When you stop loving her, mate." The understanding in his brown eyes was shaded with empathy. "When you stop loving her."
In other words, never.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 77: The echo of a distant time
Chapter Text
CXLV
[Pink Floyd — Echoes]
The cell looked much larger than it really was. Perhaps because there was a girl there, curled up so tightly in the corner that everything else seemed far too big, far too dark, far too frightening. The sound of chains clinking made her lift her gaze with great effort. Her hazel irises were almost completely hidden beneath her dark hair.
A shadow approached, sliding and stretching across the morbid prison walls. Slender, tall and indistinct: a woman walked slowly down the corridor, her tragic silhouette moving in the same chaotic rhythm as the waves of the North Sea breaking against Azkaban’s stone structure.
The only light entering the space came from afar, the faded, whitish rays bleaching every colour around, turning everything into mere shades of grey. Everything… except the woman’s eyes.
Blue.
Blue like death.
There was someone else as well, a blurred figure behind her, but indistinguishable at that distance.
"S-Scarlett?!" the girl asked.
No. She wasn’t a girl. She looked younger because she was hunched and curled in on herself, but looking more closely now, she realised she was the same age as them.
"Selwyn." Scarlett’s coarse voice scraped against the cell walls.
Helena flicked her gaze between her and the man. A loud click echoed, announcing the opening of the barred door.
"What… but… but what…"
Scarlett gripped one of the iron bars, pulling it slowly, the screech rattling the prisoner’s eardrums. The cold metal brushed her fingers. Scarlett’s relentless stare rose unforgivingly to Helena. She placed one foot inside the cell, then the other. Her striped, worn pyjamas were in better condition than Selwyn’s, whose hems were frayed and filthy.
"You tortured my brother." The words vibrated in Scarlett’s vocal cords, and she made no effort to hide the rancour in her voice.
"I… I didn’t have a choice!" Helena’s eyes widened, dragging herself across the floor in an attempt to get away, but the icy wall quickly met her back. "I… I-I… was forced to marry, Scarlett… I… I was…"
The slap Scarlett delivered to her face was so hard she tasted blood in her mouth. Bitter, metallic, warm. Helena touched her lower lip with unsteady fingers, her terrified eyes flickering with Scarlett’s reflection.
"I didn’t have a choice, Scarlett, please…"
"You tortured my brother." Scarlett repeated, now with tears in her eyes. "YOU KIDNAPPED HIM… AND TORTURED HIM!"
"No, Scarlett… it wasn’t me… who… who kidnapped him… and… I… I only… I… I needed to torture him… you… you think I didn’t also… Scarlett, they forced me to marry Avery… I also… didn’t have a choice…"
Scarlett blinked several times, shaking her head violently to stop Helena’s words from seeping into her mind.
"You’re not a fucking victim. You were part of it. All of it. You defended every single point of your Dark Lord!" she barked, tears glimmering in her eyes just as the trickling threads of water glinted along the cell’s cracked walls.
"No, but… I didn’t… I didn’t know… that… I didn’t know, Scarlett! He had my child! I had no choice… except… except…"
"You tortured my brother." She repeated it, so she wouldn’t forget why she was there.
"And you came to torture me too?!" Helena shrank even further, squeezing her eyes shut when Scarlett stretched the chains on her own wrists.
"Someone has to pay." Scarlett hissed like a cat.
"No… Scarlett… listen to me…"
"Someone will pay."
"Scarlett, please, listen to me…"
"All of you will pay."
"Scarlett… you need to hear me! Your m—"
The echo of a distant time
Comes willowing across the sand
And everything is green and submarine
Scarlett wound the chain of her shackles around Helena’s throat as fast as a serpent coiling around its prey. Helena choked, her face turning red from lack of air, her widened eyes beginning to bulge from their sockets. Scarlett did not loosen her grip.
Quite the opposite — she braced her foot against Helena’s chest to intensify the strangling and let out all the fury bubbling in her chest in a single scream. Helena had taken her brother hostage; because of her, Regulus had been forced to rescue Orfeu. If she were truly as helpless as she claimed, she would have asked for help. She would have run. She would have done something!
Scarlett watched, between heavy breaths, the putrid soul of Helena oozing out through her glassy hazel eyes. Eyes very similar to James’s. That only made Scarlett pull harder as Helena thrashed in vain. Selwyn had always been a delicate girl, a fucking pampered princess. She was never going to escape that.
She released her the moment her own wrists throbbed and her leg ached. Helena crashed to the floor with a harsh thud, motionless. Lifeless.
Dead.
"Very well, Gaunt." The man’s voice behind her echoed grimly through the cell. Scarlett froze, staring at the result of her frenzy. She brought a hand to her mouth, stumbling back. She couldn’t stop the surge of vomit that forced itself up, expelling everything.
Helena Selwyn was only a symptom of that cancer, the dark, ominous metastasis called the Death Eaters. And Scarlett would kill them one by one if possible, strip everything from them, destroy them. Just as they had done to her.
She spat on the floor, turned her back on Helena’s corpse, and glared at the man with clenched fists.
That man… Sirius knew that man. It was him — the one who had tried to kill him when Scarlett blew up the room in Azkaban, the one whose wand he’d taken possession of.
And do I take you by the hand?
And lead you through the land?
And help me understand the best I can?
.
.
.
And no one flies around the sun
"Hello?" She knew that tired tone all too well.
"Sirius?!" Scarlett asked quickly.
"Scar."
There was a pause. The buzzing on the line accompanied their nervous breaths.
"How… h-how are you?" She swallowed hard.
"Uh, I’m… I’m alright. And you?"
"Oh, I…" Scar cleared her throat, the harsh sound amplified by the connection. "I’ve just left the concert. It was… it was incredible. Pearl Jam… bloody hell, they’re fucking brilliant. I… I bought… some things for you and… for Reg and Harry and…" She tripped over her words, probably drunk. Sirius stayed silent, and a short, awkward laugh slipped from his lips. "Is Reggie still angry with me?"
"He’s avoiding the subject." Sirius clicked his tongue.
"Oh…" She exhaled slowly, the sound heavy with frustration and a deep sadness. "Look, Sirius, I… I wanted to apologise… for… for the things I said… about you and Red…"
"Don’t." He cut her off, firm. Taciturn. "You… you were right, Scarlett. About a lot of things."
Scarlett fell silent, her chaotic breathing misting the line. She cleared her throat again and sniffed.
"I wish you were here." She murmured, her voice cracking and splintering with every word.
Sirius pressed the phone harder against his ear but didn’t reply. A faint pop on the line indicated he had covered the microphone, his heavy breathing now barely audible.
"Harry wants to talk to you." His voice finally cut through the static.
Scarlett didn’t get the chance to say goodbye to Sirius.
"Hi, Scar!" Harry greeted her, cheerful.
"Hey, Harry." Scarlett tried to muster half his enthusiasm but failed. Her strained tone made her attempt to swallow tears even clearer. "Are you alright?"
"Yeah, I’m fine." Harry hesitated. "Earlier, Reggie and I played Quidditch in the garden. Hagrid’s coming to pick up Buckbeak before school starts, too… the Ministry’s not looking for him anymore."
"Oh… that’s good." She smiled. Did she? It sounded more like a huff, but the audio wasn’t the best. "Are you happy?"
Harry let out a confused little laugh. He didn’t seem prepared for that question.
"Yeah…"
"Good." Scarlett took a breath. "Your parents would want you to be happy."
"Oh, and Buckbeak broke my Walkman… I tried fixing it but spells don’t work on it and…" Harry stopped when muffled voices in the background called for Scarlett.
"Is Reggie there, Harry?"
"Yeah. Do you want me to get him?"
Scarlett’s breath scraped the mic, uncertain and reluctant.
"No… no need, Harry. Thank you. I… I have to hang up. There are more people waiting to use the phone…"
"Alright… okay then. Bye, Scar."
"Take care." She murmured, still on the line, as if hoping Sirius or Reggie might ask to speak to her.
The click indicated Harry had hung up. Scarlett glanced sideways at Mike and Danny, who had just bought a few bottles of absinthe from the little shop next door. She set the phone back in place and staggered towards them.
.
.
.
Scarlett lay face-down on the black marble floor, her blonde hair spilling like molten gold across the bleak stone. Blood glued the striped pyjamas to her back. Her fingers twitched in intermittent spasms and she struggled to breathe. Sweat trickled down her neck, her cheeks, and her nose. Sweat? Sweat and tears.
She moved her arm slowly, attempting to brace her elbow against the floor, but there was no strength left in her body. Her warm breath escaped her lips onto the polished surface, dampening it. One of the few indications she was still alive.
The wall sconces were not enough to illuminate the faces of the three witches and wizards in the room. Not that Sirius needed to see them, but his attention was fixed on the clipboard one of the women was writing on.
Where could those documents be?
"This… this is impossible, Sirius," Remus murmured, his voice wavering through the memory. "No one… no one would withstand…"
He fell silent when the man walked over to Scarlett and crouched beside her. He checked her pulse and lifted her shirt; the thick, dark blood painted her pale skin a deep, vivid red. With a flick of his wand, the blood vanished, though the wounds on her languid back still seeped. The lightning-shaped marks were stark, revealing the result of multiple Cruciatus Curses cast on the same part of her body in disconnected, random cuts and burns.
Sirius pressed a hand to his mouth. There was no smell in the memory, although, for some reason, he could sense the odour of burnt flesh and clotted blood. The shadowed atmosphere of Azkaban was quickly replaced by the comforting walls of his bedroom as he pulled his face from the Pensieve, throwing his body backwards, his legs so unsteady he stumbled and fell sitting onto the bed.
Remus, in front of him, braced his hands on the dresser, his fingernails digging into the beige wood, his eyes blinking incessantly.
It was… strange to see Scarlett like that. When they were in Azkaban it had been different, because he’d been so fucked in the head that the gravity of things couldn’t pull him into the right place. But now… he rubbed his eyes hard, trying to wipe the image of tortured Scarlett from his retinas.
"Was… was it in that place?" Remus’s voice sounded cracked, pretending he wasn’t on the brink of crying. "That you and Scarlett… escaped?"
Sirius removed his own memory of the day they fled Azkaban for Remus to watch. Lupin stared at the Pensieve’s silvery surface for long seconds before removing Scarlett’s and diffusing Sirius’s into it, plunging in immediately after.
It felt like only minutes had passed when Remus emerged. The silvery light, neither liquid nor gaseous, dripped from his long, scar-sliced nose. His dark eyes, glinting faintly with gold, turned back to Sirius.
"They should have suffered more… before dying." Remus hissed. "They…"
"It doesn’t matter anymore, Moony." Sirius sighed heavily. "She should have died."
"Or gone mad, at the very least." Remus added.
"No, not just in that case, Rem. When…" He drew a deep breath again. It was as though the air reached his brain less and less. "When she was having Reg and… James and I took her to St Mungo’s… she’d lost too much blood. Far too much. She was barely conscious. The mediwizards said she wouldn’t survive… and that the baby was probably dead."
Remus scratched his scar and held Sirius’s gaze without blinking, one eyebrow furrowing.
"What do you mean by that?"
"I don’t know." He said, expressionless. "I don’t know."
The telephone rang. They looked at each other for only a second. Sirius darted into the sitting room, fumbling across the sideboard until he yanked the phone off the hook.
"Hello? Scarlett?" He didn’t hide the urgency in his tone.
"Sssssirius… Ssssirius… Sssssirius…" She cackled on the other end. "Wassss… thinking… about you earlier. There’ssss… thissss Pearl Jam song… called Black…"
"She’s pissed again, isn’t she?" Regulus asked, sitting on the floor playing Mario Kart with Harry.
Sirius took the phone and pulled it into the kitchen.
"Scarlett, I…" He froze. What was he supposed to say? That he’d seen the memory of her being tortured until her skin was fried by Cruciatus?!
"You hate me, I… I know…" She let out a nasally laugh. "I ssshould ssstart a fan club… or maybe a hatersss’ club?!" She took long swigs of something and choked. "Oh, fuck… this ssshit’s sstrong…"
"I’ve told you I don’t hate you, Scarlett." He murmured, glancing towards the kitchen entrance.
"Uh, it’s alriiiight, Sssssirius." It was funny how his name curled on her tongue. "You don’t… need to… ssay that… just to make… me feel better. I don’t… don’t even know what that iss anyway. Really, Georgy Porrgy." She laughed at her own joke until the laughter broke into a trembling gasp followed by a silent sob. "I can’t… ssstop… misssssing… you… I feel it all the time, Ssssirius."
Sirius clenched his jaw so tightly his teeth scraped together. Tears scalded his eyes.
"Scar, I…"
"I love you, Ssssirius…" The confession cut him off, manifesting like a dagger driven straight into his heart. Sirius pressed a hand to his chest as if he could stop the bleeding from spreading through his whole body.
Too late.
Scarlett was already beneath his skin, crawling into his core.
"I’ve always loved you, Sssirius… even… even when… you were an arrogant arsehole…" She coughed. "Ssshit." The curse buzzed across the line. "I never… never stopped… wanting you. I wanted… wanted you here so badly. Fuck… I would… I’d ride you until… until I made you… sssee stars."
Sirius had no idea what to say. He’d been caught completely off guard; even though he knew drunk Scarlett well, her lack of inhibition still left him somewhat stunned.
"I wish I were there too." The cords of his heart controlled his lips. He wanted to punch himself in the face for saying it, but it was very difficult to see things clearly when the subject was Scarlett.
Especially after seeing her being tortured for hours on end.
"You wished?!" She smacked her lips. "Fuck, Sssssirius. I’d give anything… to ssuck… your cock right now."
Sirius laughed, incredulous. He very much wished he had some witty response to Scarlett’s words, though he could barely think about sex at that moment. All that occupied his mind was the image of Scarlett killing Selwyn and, a week later, collapsing after taking so many Cruciatus Curses.
"I… I was in one of your memories." He whispered, low.
"Memo… memories?!" Scarlett asked, disoriented.
"From Azkaban."
"Aaah…" Her breath crackled against the microphone. "I… need to go."
"Scar…"
She hung up.
Sirius held the receiver to his ear for a moment. He returned to the sitting room and set it back on the sideboard. Reggie glanced over his shoulder, his grey irises painted with the colours of the game, but they quickly hardened into steel like his father’s.
"What did she say? Is she alright, at least?"
Sirius’s lips trembled.
He didn’t know what to answer.
.
.
.
Moonlit nights were scarce in Azkaban. That night, however, the clouds that usually smothered the prison’s dark sky had thinned just enough to let the silver rays break through, pouring into the cell window in abundance. Gleaming on the damp stone floor, on the rusted iron bars, on the girl collapsed right by the entrance.
She had no strength to move. Barely had strength to breathe, truth be told, though her body refused to stop. Even when all she wanted most was for the air to cease entering her lungs.
Scarlett lifted her gaze to the pale, ethereal glow encircling her like a spotlight. Her fair skin turned to marble. Her eyes, to sapphires. Her tangled blonde hair, to molten gold. And she was confronted with the emptiness surrounding her in the same intensity as the moonlight.
She didn’t know how she managed to turn herself over, but when she realised it, she was lying on her back, eyes fixed on the window. Her trembling fingers stretched into the radiance, seeking to feel some warmth from it, even knowing it was moonlight.
The satellite had no warmth, nor pull. It was not the sun, however much Scarlett wished it were. Her hand cast a shadow across her face, shielding her eyes from the brightness. Her eyes were ice, but also ocean. Her chest, stone, yet flesh. Her heartbeat, rigid. Cacophonous.
Her mouth and chin were smeared with blood. It was already dry, dark upon her skin like the Dark Mark stained her left forearm. The acrid taste coated her tongue, acidic. Disgusting.
She had made her seventh victim that night.
She had grabbed Amanda Wilkes in the dining hall and bitten her neck until all the blood in that bitch drained out, and she collapsed on the floor trying, in vain, to press her jugular.
The Dementors had feasted on Scarlett. She had no idea how many had attacked her, but there were so many she truly thought she would die.
Yet she was there, collapsed in that damned cell. Alive.
She was alive even when all she wanted was to die.
Tears welled in her eyes and spilled down her cheeks, carving a path through the dried blood, trying to cleanse it from her skin.
They weren’t enough.
They would never be enough to wash the crimes embedded in her soul.
"Leave me alone." Scarlett’s voice echoed, faint. "Leave me alone, for fuck’s sake…"
The experiments continued. Some memories bled into others, probably because Scarlett no longer knew where they began or ended. Sirius could distinguish the passage of time by the colour of her hair. The spell she had used to make it blonde had faded over the years, contributing to her shadowed appearance. To the dark circles beneath her lashes. To the sparse gloom taking up more and more space in her gaze.
Sirius was able to navigate between them this way, though it was deeply disturbing to revisit and handpick which memory he wanted to view amid that atrocious jumble. One, in particular, drew his attention: there was the Veil, with Scarlett collapsed before it, and though the clipboard and the details of that experiment weren’t visible, the voice of the woman he still didn’t know echoed, grave and morbid: first of November, 1981.
The memory expanded at his mere touch, replacing everything around him with the ominous circular walls where the stone arch held the translucent curtain.
"Prepare for contact, Nicodemus." The order came directly from the unnamed woman. She was the one who led the team. "Liz, don’t let anything slip in the report."
Nicodemus approached Scarlett, who lay on her knees on the floor, her eyes wandering airily about, lost. But the moment the strong hands of the Nameless seized her, she began to hyperventilate, trying to break free, though her resistance was nowhere near enough to make him stop.
He dragged her across the floor as if she were a dog and rammed his elbow into her ribs to stop her from trying to bite him, forcing her entire body to recoil. He made her extend her left arm and seized her wrist.
Scarlett’s scream pierced his ears. Her fingers touched the Veil and Sirius could see them being caressed by the whitish curtains. It was a very delicate contact, so agonising for Scarlett that her face was turning purple from screaming, the veins in her neck bulging, her trembling legs rubbing against each other when they grew wet.
"What’s your name?" The woman’s voice sliced her scream in half.
She collapsed onto the floor, hugging her own knees in a quiet sob.
"Scarlett… Gaunt." She answered, breathless, her voice brittle.
"How old are you?"
Scarlett trembled incessantly, in shock.
"I… I don’t know."
"How old were you when you were imprisoned?"
"Nin… nineteen. Eighteen."
"Were you married?"
Scarlett clutched her hair, shuddering.
"Yes or no, prisoner?!" The insistence made her curl in on herself even more.
"Y-Yes… yes…" she stammered, gasping.
"She is lucid. Nico, force her to make contact with the veil again. The Signet is reacting."
"No, no, no, no…" Scarlett pleaded, though her voice barely left her throat.
Remus had his hand over his mouth, his tormented eyes darting aside when Scarlett was forced once more to stretch out her arm. Sirius felt his dinner constantly burning up his throat, threatening to rise, but he swallowed it back, took deep breaths, and continued.
The Ouroboros spun on the back of Scarlett’s hand, but it did not have the desired effect, for she lost consciousness and it stopped, frustrating the Unspeakable so deeply that Nicodemus broke her fingers, mending them afterwards with a spell only to break them again.
Both men emerged from the memory right after. It was enough for one day’s work. Sirius wanted to say a great deal about that sick, sadistic experiment, but every time he and Remus finished watching it, they were left speechless.
Hearing that Scarlett had been tortured was very different from seeing her being tortured. From witnessing, in such detail, how she had been treated as a laboratory rat by the Ministry of Magic. The fear she felt each time gained more shape, more outline, more faces.
Scarlett didn’t call that day. Nor the next.
She went five days without making contact, and Sirius still didn’t know what answer to give Regulus’s question, nor had any idea how to stop the sharp, twisted knot ravaging his chest from suffocating him with every breath.
He witnessed Scarlett killing Avery. Then, when she climbed into her cell, he watched her talk to herself. The words were blurry, misshapen, as if she didn’t want anyone to see her like that. Suppressed in the memory, but it didn’t change the fact that she did it.
It was already Monday when Sirius sat at the edge of the pool, lit a cigarette, and dipped his feet into the freezing water. Between having to analyse the memories, study for the final exams of Auror training, and look after Reg and Harry…
Sirius was exhausted. Physically and emotionally.
He hoped the nicotine might steady his heartbeat and lower his blood pressure. Yet even that wasn’t enough to contain the turmoil crashing inside his chest, trying to drown him in waves that grew higher and more violent each time. Corrosive tears burned his cheeks and guilt tore at his insides.
The cry clawed up his throat and spilled the build-up in his heart. Sirius squeezed the cigarette, crushing it in his hand, his chest shuddering relentlessly as it caved, clenched, loosened, and smoked.
"I should’ve done more." Sirius murmured, hearing Remus’s footsteps behind him. "When she was arrested, I… I should’ve… should’ve fought for her, Moony. Even after… I should’ve done something. Anything… to get her out when I had the chance…"
"They would never have allowed Scarlett to escape, Sirius." Remus sat beside him. "You only managed it because everyone involved in the experiment died."
"Pan… always believed there was something wrong about Scarlett’s story… Lily too. But I… I accepted with… with such ease… what she’d become… I… my hatred for Regulus… blinded me so completely…"
"It’s not your fault, Sirius."
Sirius let out a laugh. A bitter, thorned one. Piercing.
"I promised I’d protect her. I promised…"
"You didn’t know. I didn’t know either." Remus wiped the lone tear that slid down his scars. "None of us knew."
Sirius hunched his shoulders, covering his face with his hands.
"No, but… I let her go with… I should’ve done more, Rem."
"You nearly died because of her in the war, Sirius." He countered, with sorrow. With understanding, too. "Looking for her."
"I…" Sirius inhaled deeply as the suffocating pressure grew in his chest. "What was I supposed to do?!"
"It doesn’t matter, Sirius. What you should’ve done… what she should’ve done…" Remus tightened his grip on his shoulder. "You both have to let the past die."
"I don’t know…" He cleared his throat. "How to do that."
His friend looked at him, the garden lamplight drifting across his dark irises like a lighthouse cutting through the fog of everything they had faced together. From joy to elation, from suffering to pain. From war, from fear, from loss. From a sweet and radiant past that would never return.
He, Remus and Scarlett were all that remained.
"The past dies when you let it go, Padfoot."
Sirius stayed silent, ruminating over what he should have said. Or done. Or insisted upon. He sighed, watching the pool lights flicker against the gentle waves brushing his ankles, creating a tension on the surface that reflected his troubled image. His black hair falling over his shoulders, his rusted silver eyes, the anguish shadowing every line of his expression.
He could do nothing for her in the past, but he could do something for her now.
He stood abruptly from the pool and strode into the house.
And no one sings me lullabies
And no one makes me close my eyes
And so I throw the windows wide
Callin' you across the sky
.
.
.
Sirius studied Asca’s expression, searching for something, anything, in those eyes shielded by the square glasses. But she let nothing slip, as though her neutral expression were stamped permanently onto her face. The therapist twirled the quill she held, wrote on her clipboard, and pressed her lips together.
The list of disorders Asca mentioned sounded longer than he expected.
"It’s a picture similar to yours, but far more aggressive. It’s natural for anyone who spends so long in Azkaban to show the first two, but… this… combined with the torture and the traumas she suffered… creates layers of pain and distress that not even she fully understands. And in this… hypothetical scenario… the fact that she withdraws emotionally is part of this pattern. She believes that by distancing herself, she’s protecting you, Regulus and Harry. She also believes she’s not worthy of love or happiness."
"I… I don’t know what to do to help. I want to help her. I want her to feel she’s not alone, but… she uses alcohol to bury everything. The trauma, the pain, the guilt. It’s like it’s the only thing stopping everything from collapsing and… I don’t know what to do."
"Alcoholism is a destructive coping mechanism. Scarlett is using alcohol as a way to numb the memories and emotions she doesn’t know how to deal with. That’s common in people who have gone through severe trauma."
Sirius clenched his fists, his reddened nostrils flaring.
"And how do I… how do I make her stop?"
"You don’t, Sirius." Asca gave a sad smile. "Alcohol isn’t the problem. It’s the symptom. The real problem lies in the unresolved trauma. And dealing with someone who suffers from alcoholism… requires far more than emotional support."
Ah, he knew that. He knew that very well. He had already been in Scarlett’s place. Perhaps that was the worst part… because he knew exactly how alcohol made things more… bearable. Palatable. In the beginning, of course, drink wrapped him in euphoria, happiness, and a warmth so comforting it was easy to let himself drift. But then the euphoria would turn into melancholy, the happiness into guilt, and the warmth became so scorching that, before he realised it, he was burning.
"I don’t… I don’t know if…" He exhaled through his mouth, the sound rasping. "How do I do this without pushing her away?"
"By establishing boundaries." Asca tapped her black-painted nails against the edge of the clipboard. "Sirius… you need to understand that you cannot save Scarlett alone. The responsibility for her recovery is hers. What you can do is support her, but with well-defined limits. She needs to know that you’re willing to help her, but that her self-destructive behaviour also affects you, Regulus and Harry. And that you are not going to allow them to be harmed by it."
Sirius remained still, barely breathing.
"And if… if she refuses?"
"Then there isn’t much you can do." Asca’s reply made him straighten.
"I feel powerless. As though I’m losing her… every time she leaves, it’s like she’s dying a little more. And… and Reggie feels it too. And I don’t know how to help her. I don’t know how to help him."
"Sirius… you can try helping her see the impact the alcohol is having on her life and on yours." She answered succinctly. "You can talk to her about it, but without accusations. Show how her behaviour is affecting you and the boys, but without making her feel guilty, because guilt is what fuels the cycle of alcoholism."
"And… Reg…"
"Regulus needs to know that his mother’s behaviour has nothing to do with him. He needs to hear that from you, Sirius. He needs to know he is loved, that he is enough, and that what’s happening with Scarlett is not his fault. Children and teenagers often internalise these behaviours, believing they are to blame somehow."
Sirius buried his face in his hands. It was too much to process and too much to handle. He could no longer think, reason, or consider. He was far too tired for that.
"I hate myself, Asca." He murmured, hoarse. "I hate who I was. I hate having let Scarlett walk away. I hate having given up on her so easily. I hate… I hate having suggested Peter. I hate having hated my brother for so long. I hate every bloody decision that led me here."
Asca remained silent, encouraging him to continue, even when all he wanted was to collapse into tears. But he didn’t. He needed to be strong. If not for himself, then for Reg and Harry.
He lifted his gaze to her, his chest thundering with a blend of sadness, nostalgia and disappointment. He expelled the tears desperate to fall from his face and composed himself, inhaling slowly.
"If I had been better, maybe none of this would have happened. Maybe she wouldn’t have suffered so much. Maybe Reg… maybe he would have trusted me. Maybe the Potters would still be alive." He exhaled, his voice splitting into agony. "I just… I can’t forgive myself. I can’t."
Asca nodded slowly, picked up the quill again, made a note, and then said:
"Sirius… without your past, you wouldn’t be here. It made you who you are now. Without all the mistakes, the struggles and the pain, you would never have grown this much. Why would you hate the person who helped you become so much more than you were?"
"Because… because…"
"We can only get things right because we first get them wrong. There is no growth without pain, Sirius. Every scar, every regret, every moment you wish you could erase… they all make up who you are. And who you are now matters. Who you are now can make a difference. So why hate who you were? Without him, you would never have arrived here."
Sirius shook his head. If he… if he hadn’t… James and Lily… Scarlett and Regulus…
How could he expect Scarlett to rid herself of guilt if he couldn’t do it himself?
.
.
.
It was already late at night when Sirius arrived home. Most of the lights were off, except for the one in the vestibule. He took off his leather jacket and his boots, walking into the house on the tips of his toes. The only sound was the hum of the appliances, a noise Sirius had grown used to after escaping Azkaban. At first it had been strange, but now…
Things were different.
He made his way to the door with the Whitesnake poster. He pushed it gently, careful not to make noise. The light from the vestibule was faint, but even so Sirius could clearly see the boy sleeping peacefully, his hair as dark as his own staining the white pillow black.
Sirius went in and closed the door carefully. He sat on the edge of the bed, remaining in complete darkness. He took his wand from his pocket and with a small movement created a soft sphere of light near the window, so as not to wake Reg. His gaze travelled over the boy, the peaceful expression on his angular face, the steady breathing, the slight spasms that curled his fingers.
He extended a hand, stitching his fingertips through Reggie’s messy hair, tracing a tender, affectionate caress.
"You are loved, Reggie." Sirius whispered. "You are enough. And nothing that’s happening with Scarlett is your fault. None of this is about you."
Reggie shifted slightly, the long lashes framing his eyes fluttering like raven wings until he opened them.
"Sirius? Are you alright?" he asked, lethargic.
"Sorry, Reg. I… I didn’t mean to wake you." Sirius couldn’t help the shy smile that tugged at his lips. "Did you hear what I said?"
"Mm-hmm." He nodded languidly.
"I just needed to tell you that." Sirius made a small motion as though to stand, but didn’t move. Despite the rapid thudding of his heart, a strange confidence was flooding his veins. A feeling of repair overwhelming any fear or hesitation he might show. "You’re not to blame for anything, Reg. You shouldn’t carry a weight that isn’t yours. You’re the best thing that’s ever happened to me… and I dare say to your mother as well."
The pale light Sirius had conjured danced in Reg’s irises, brightening the grey and swallowing the blue, turning his finely shaped eyes to platinum and pushing away all the darkness trying to consume his pupils. He sat up on the bed, rubbing his eyelids with the backs of his hands.
"She… she called today." Reg cleared his throat to fight the huskiness.
Sirius raised his eyebrows, a hopeful crease forming on his forehead.
"What did she say?"
Reggie yawned, scratching the back of his neck.
"That she was fine. She asked about you. Said she wanted to come back… and… apologised to me. For leaving. Said she shouldn’t have done it." He shook his head. "Only… she sounded drunk."
"Did she say anything else?"
"Yeah." Reg brushed his fringe away from his face. "I asked why she was drinking like that. She said it makes things easier… I asked which things, but… she didn’t answer. She just changed the subject… asked to speak to Harry."
Sirius nodded, running his fingers through the rough stubble on his jaw. The chaotic knot in his chest was tamed by the sense of responsibility that only a man as patched together as he was could express.
It was time to tell the truth.
Reggie deserved that.
"When you asked me at the beginning of last week… about what Remus and I were doing and I said it was work-related… well, I lied." He shrugged with an awkward smile. Reg frowned. "There’s something about your mother I never told you. Something that might help you understand why she’s like this." He expelled the air from his lungs in a chaotic, necessary rush. "When she was in Azkaban, she… she was tortured."
Reggie’s grey eyes widened and his lips parted.
"Tortured?" He blinked several times, stunned. He kept his eyes on Sirius for long seconds, afraid to ask the question… but asked it anyway. "How?"
"Physically…" Sirius panted. "Psychologically… they used the Cruciatus Curse on her constantly. They forced her to do things that… that no one should ever have to do. Your mother is broken, Reg, and she… she never had a chance to heal."
Regulus furrowed his brows and narrowed his gaze. He wanted to doubt the words, even though he knew Sirius wasn’t lying.
"When you fought with Dumbledore and said… that he’d rather send her to Azkaban to be tortured… it was because of this?! But… but… what does that have to do… with what you and Remus…"
"On the day of the barbecue she brought her memories of Azkaban. Your uncle and I have been studying them to understand what the Ministry wanted…"
"A-And… and… d-did you… find anything out?" Reg stammered, struggling to keep his voice steady.
"They were studying her Signet." Sirius said, stopping himself by biting his lower lip. He didn’t want to go into further detail, not when Reg seemed so close to crying.
"Is that why she drinks? To forget?"
"Yes…" The agreement came diluted in anguish. "It’s her way of trying to escape. But… that’s not your responsibility, Reggie. What she went through… no one should go through. None of it is your fault. You’re the reason she’s still trying, even if it’s in her own way. And you’re the reason I’m here, trying too."
Reg sniffed, rubbing his nose to hold back the tears.
"I just wanted her to stay. I don’t want her to leave again."
"I know, son." Sirius kissed his forehead. "I do too."
Regulus hugged him, burying his face in Sirius’s chest, gripping him as if not to let him go. He wanted to hug Scarlett the same way. Sirius wrapped his arms around him and rested his chin atop the boy’s tousled hair. He closed his eyes and allowed Reggie to cry in his arms… just as he once cried in the arms of the boy he had wished so desperately were his.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 78: All been washed in Black
Chapter Text
CXLVI
The full moon drifted across the surface of the pool, swirling with the ripples Scarlett made as she ran her fingers through the water. She was lying along the edge, her other hand tucked beneath her head, her gaze fixed on her engagement ring submerged just under the surface, its shine refracted by the gentle serpentine movements she created. The party in the background had quietened, the laughter and music far more subdued than earlier.
Scarlett was used to being alone, but not to feeling this lonely.
She heard Mike approaching, and she didn’t need to look to know he was carrying his inseparable silk cigarette case that Dave Abbruzzese himself had given him. He glanced around and decided to sit beside her after pulling up a small stool.
“Want company or am I interrupting the drama?” He lit a cigarette while rolling another.
Scarlett shot him a blistering look without even moving.
“I’m used to your irritating presence.” She sighed, not bothering to hide her foul mood.
“Irritating? I prefer charming.” Mike smiled, watching her play with the water. “Why have you been like this the entire tour?”
“Like what?” Scarlett stopped moving her hand, her eyes locked on him.
“Thoughtful… quiet. More than usual.”
She desperately wanted a sharp answer to push Mike away, but she was far too drunk for that. Her attention drifted to the sky, where the stars tried to reach her even as the lights around them dimmed their presence.
“I bet your boyfriend wasn’t happy about the tour at all.” Mike kept on teasing, blowing smoke upwards.
Scarlett looked at him again, her blue eyes reflecting the moonlight dancing on the pool’s surface. She opened her mouth, ready to steer away from the subject, but… once Sirius Black slipped into her mind, it was hard to dislodge him. The alcohol helped, of course—it always did—but Mike’s words sank deeper than they should, pulling her under just like she felt she was sinking into a wild ocean.
She took a deep breath.
“We fought. As always.” She admitted, shrugging. “But… sooner or later… we’ll make peace.” Would they? She wasn’t sure, but she hoped so. “We’ve always… been like this, Mike. We fight, we shout at each other, we hurt each other… and then we go back.”
Mike raised an eyebrow and ran a hand through his blond hair. He kept rolling his joint carefully, though his eyes never left her.
“Sounds… exhausting.” He took a drag from the cigarette between his lips. “And what do you feel for him? I mean… is all that worth it?”
He sounded genuinely interested.
Scarlett reached for a lie, but the alcohol thinned her defences, dissolved her masks, and heightened her truths. It numbed the importance of what had been, what was, and what might still be.
Why had she drunk so much, anyway?
Days earlier, when she’d called home, Sirius had told her he’d seen her memories of Azkaban.
“I love him.” She murmured it as one leans over something both the simplest and most complicated thing in the whole world. “I’ve always loved him. Since we were teenagers… he was… he’s always been… everything to me.”
Mike let out a sound somewhere between a whistle and a laugh, though it wasn’t malicious, despite the shade of sarcasm.
“And what happened, then?” He stopped rolling the joint, watching her reaction closely. “Between you two?”
Scarlett shifted her gaze back to the water, to the moon casting a silver staircase across the calm, tightened surface. She inhaled deeply, drinking in the sweet scent of spilled alcohol on the ground, Mike’s tobacco smoke, and the pool’s chlorine.
“I made a mistake. Several mistakes, actually.” She laughed, but there was no joy in it. “It was my fault. All of it.”
Mike took one last drag from his cigarette, then put it out by tapping it against the pool’s edge. He finished rolling his weed joint and lit it with a chrome lighter, waiting for her to continue. The smell of cut grass made her wrinkle her nose and, realising she’d fallen silent, he took a chance:
“Does the mistake have to do with his brother?”
Scarlett nodded slowly, letting her arm sink into the water again as she looked up at the sky, nothing more than a dark, lonely dome. Mike took a long drag, half-closing his eyes.
“You know, Star, even after all those mistakes… Sirius is still with you.” He said it casually, like someone chatting about a triviality. But deep down, Scarlett knew it was true.
No matter how reluctant she was to accept it.
“But he’s never going to let it go. He’ll never let the past go.”
Mike blew out the smoke, watching it dissipate before turning to Scarlett, his dark eyes scrutinising her as if trying to read between the lines of her reply.
“The past… it’s like a shadow, Star.” He planted his elbow on his knee, mimicking a great philosopher’s pose. “It follows you, frightens you… keeps you on alert. But at the end of the day, that’s all it is. A shadow. Harmless.”
He took another drag, offering her the joint.
“I don’t smoke.” She refused with a murmur.
Mike smiled to himself. He already knew her answer.
“We’re the ones who give the shadow power. And we’re also the ones who take its power away. Sirius… just needs to learn that.”
“I doubt it.” Scarlett let out a humourless huff of a laugh.
“Well… no one’s born walking.”
Scarlett only shook her head and rolled her eyes, grateful that Mike had finally shut up. Her gaze landed on her own left forearm, where the scar of the Dark Mark lay. She traced it with her wet fingertip, a strange feeling stirring in her chest. Had she been like this before?
Something deep in her mind told her something was wrong, but she blew the feeling away as she released all the air from her lungs. The good part about being drunk was how easy it became to slip away from her problems, even if she would probably find them again at the bottom of the pit soon enough.
“Oi, Mike, Star!” Danny called, with an exaggerated shout. “We’re heading to the tattoo studio to get a group tattoo. Coming?”
Mike laughed, pulling the joint from his lips.
“Bet it’s another one of those brilliant ideas you’ll regret tomorrow.” He said, glancing at them over his shoulder.
“No, we won’t!” Lenny was already bouncing with excitement. “We’re getting the tour date tattooed on our arms.”
Scarlett sighed, lifting her hand from the pool, shaking it before flicking water at Mike.
“Tattooing the tour date? Wow, how creative.” She twisted her lips. “I’ll pass.”
“Oh, don’t give us that, Star!” Stacy was wobbling, leaning on Mike’s shoulders. “We’re the Space Travelers! We’re making history opening for Pearl Jam!”
Scarlett only shrugged in a weary gesture.
“Go make history yourselves. I’m not in the mood.”
“You’re staying here hiding by the pool?! Coward.” Mike goaded her, nudging her with the tip of his foot as he blew smoke from the corner of his mouth.
“I’m just not in the mood.” Scarlett grumbled, pulling her arm out of his reach. “What’s your problem, Mike?”
“Nothing. I just thought you weren’t afraid of needles.” He continued, taking a long drag.
Scarlett let out a derisive laugh, sitting upright.
“I’m not afraid of needles. I’ve had tattoos before.”
“Then come on. Stop being a pain.” Mike threw the joint on the floor and put it out with a stomp.
Unable to avoid it any longer, she finally gave in with an exasperated huff. She stood from the pool’s edge and rolled her eyes, annoyed.
“You lot are going to regret this tomorrow.” Scar repeated his own warning back at him, crossing her arms in irritation.
“Oh, we’ve already regretted loads of things, Star. One more isn’t going to kill anyone.” He gave her a wink, walking towards the van.
.
.
.
Scarlett was leaning against the wall of the studio, watching Stacy volunteer to go first. Her drunken smile widened when the girl got up and Danny took his turn.
She had brought along a bottle of wine, an overly fancy pinot they’d been given by some record label. She took long swigs of it, savouring the rich, delicate flavour.
When the tattooist asked what she wanted, Scarlett stayed silent as she approached the chair, shaking her head as she continued to mull it over.
“I don’t want that stupid date. I want something else.”
“Something else? Like… what?” The tattooist frowned.
Scarlett stroked the scar of the Dark Mark on her left forearm, letting her fingertips wander up to her bicep. The drunkenness bubbled banal ideas in her mind, each more idiotic and absurd than the last.
“A heart.” She bit her lower lip. “A heart with an arrow through it.” She corrected herself, raising a finger. “And write inside…” Her eyes widened, as if she’d just had a brilliant idea. “Scarius.”
The tattooist simply complied, unlike Mike and Danny, who burst into uncontrollable laughter.
“Scarius? What the fuck is that? Sounds like a bloody clothing brand.” The guitarist leaned on the counter beside them, watching the tattooist prepare the needle. “Is he that new Parisian designer no one’s ever heard of? Oh, have you seen Scarius’s new autumn collection? Très chic!”
Stacy cackled, and Lenny — who looked halfway gone already, slumped in the corner — let out a muffled snort. Mike smoked against the nearby wall, narrowing his eyes before giving her a slow, wicked smile.
“Scarius…” he repeated, staring at her.
“Just do it before I change my mind.” She looked at the tattooist with urgency.
Mike let out a subtle laugh and tilted his head, taking an unhurried drag.
“Wasn’t that the name of the band you had with your brother-in-law? I’d love to see his reaction when he sees this…”
Scarlett ignored the comment. Danny flicked through the studio’s tattoo catalogue before glancing back at her.
“Just don’t regret it.” Mike cupped a hand beside his mouth and whispered, as though sharing a secret. “Tattoos are forever.”
Scarlett looked at him, a lazy, insolent smile tugging at her lips.
“That’s the secret, Mikey. I’m always regretting something.” She lay back in the chair, making the tattooist’s job easier.
She closed her eyes, feeling the needle scrape her skin. The alcohol dulled part of her sensitivity, turning it into nothing more than a faint irritation. She brought the bottle to her lips with her free hand, drinking the wine that thrilled her tastebuds and numbed her feverish body.
Mike crouched down beside her, watching the tattooist work. Scarlett opened her eyes upon noticing him there.
“If the past is a shadow, Star, you’ve just turned yours into a permanent scar.” He wet his lips, his dark eyes studying her with such intensity she ought to have felt intimidated.
Under normal circumstances, she would have.
“At least it’s a scar I chose to have… unlike the others.” Her voice dropped lower with each word, the last escaping as nothing more than a whisper.
Later that day, Scarlett used the hotel phone to make her international call. Despite avoiding getting anywhere near a telephone for almost a whole week, longing had spoken louder than fear. It was rare for that to happen, so she seized the brief flare of courage and dialled the numbers she dreaded so much, her fingers trembling.
“Hello?”
Scarlett closed her eyes and released a long breath, an exhausted smile forming on her lips.
“Hi, Reg…” she murmured slowly. “Are you alright?”
He paused. Scarlett was ready to repeat the question, thinking he hadn’t heard her, but he answered soon enough:
“I’m fine.” His voice came out dry. Irritated. “You’re drunk.”
It wasn’t a question — it was an observation.
Scarlett pressed her lips together and ran a hand over her face, the accumulated stress and exhaustion beginning to take their toll.
“Since when did you become my father?!”
“Since you stopped acting like my mother.” He shot back, rude and cutting. Scarlett lost her breath, the smile slipping from her face. The truth in his accusation coiled in her throat, tightening until it choked her.
“Where… where’s Sirius?” she tried to ignore him, changing the subject.
“He went out.”
“Oh…”
Silence stretched. Scarlett took a deep breath to clear her head, repeating to herself that she was the adult in this conversation, that she ought to be the one holding the reins… yet in truth, she felt like a little girl caught misbehaving. Which was absurd — Regulus was her son, she was supposed to be the assertive one, not the other way round!
“I… I want to come home, Reg.”
He stayed quiet.
“Sorry for coming on this tour.” She continued, gathering every shard of courage she could find to keep speaking. “I shouldn’t have done it.”
There was a noise on the other end of the line and Scarlett imagined Reggie running a hand through his hair — that habit he’d inherited from Sirius.
“Then why did you go?”
Scarlett didn’t answer.
“And why are you drinking like this?” The question sounded more like a demand.
The laugh that left her lips this time was hollow.
“Drinking makes things… easier.”
“What things, Mum?!”
Scarlett opened her mouth to explain, but closed it again. She didn’t know what to say. She felt hot, dizzy, breathless — all at once.
She let out a discouraged, uneven sigh.
“Let me talk to Harry.” She asked, hearing him huff indignantly on the other end before calling him.
“Hi, Scar.” Harry said, his voice far more cheerful and welcoming than Reggie’s.
Scarlett smiled softly, despite everything.
“Hey, Harry… you alright?”
“Yeah.”
“What were you doing?”
“Oh, I’m playing Super Nintendo with Reggie. Mario Kart… dunno if you’ve heard of it… it’s a racing game…”
“And who’s winning?”
“Reggie, but only because he’s cheating.”
She heard her son call Harry a liar in the background, and a low laugh slipped past the knot in her throat, escaping sharply through her lips.
“Cheating? He’s just like his uncle, then… Orfy was a master at cheating in games…” Her smile died, leaving a decomposed taste in her mouth.
“I can tell.” Harry laughed as well, oblivious to her turmoil.
Scarlett ran her tongue over her lips, gripping the phone tightly in her palm.
“I’m sorry, Harry.”
“What for?”
She pulled in a breath through her mouth, staring up at the ceiling above her.
“For… for leaving. For not staying.”
“Then… then come back.” Harry countered, as if it were the most obvious thing in the world.
Scarlett grunted but didn’t respond.
“Scar…?”
“Keep an eye on Reggie and Sirius for me, alright?”
“Scar…”
She hung up.
.
.
.
Scarlett didn’t want to wake up. First, she’d gone to bed far too late after getting completely smashed. Second, her head felt heavy and hurt so much that even opening her eyes was excruciating. Third, something was burning and itching on her left bicep.
She placed a hand over her face and squinted, rolling between the sheets. She was sticking with sweat. The suffocating French heat wasn’t being eased by the air conditioning, even though it was blasting at full power. With her free hand, she fumbled along the bedside table until she reached the digital clock, which read 3 p.m.
She groaned. She crawled out of bed and stumbled into the bathroom, leaving a trail of clothes behind her. There was plastic wrapped around her bicep — something she couldn’t remove because of her trembling fingers and the congenital weakness the hangover spread through her body.
The woman staring back at her was… strange. She was used to the pallor of her skin and her constant dark circles, but she had lost weight. Not only had her face regained the hollow look she’d worn after escaping Azkaban, but her eyes…
The blue was glassy and dull, exhausted. Faded.
Scarlett plunged her face under the cold tap, feeling the sticky strands of her hair slide down her cheeks and the back of her neck. She scrubbed at her face with unsteady hands and dried it, rubbing her eyes hard in an attempt to chase away the fatigue.
It didn’t work.
She rummaged through her clothes thrown across the room, grabbed her coin purse, and put on her sunglasses, stumbling out while the tips of her bleached strands dripped onto the carpet. Scarlett braced herself against the filthy, sticky wall as she made her way to the nearest public telephone. She dug through her purse for coins and shoved them in one by one, dialling with imprecise fingers. She got it wrong at least three times before deciding she’d finally dialled the correct number and, when no one answered, redialled until somebody picked up.
“Hello?”
Scarlett cleared her throat, leaned against the wall, and rested her forehead on the iron support of the telephone.
“Sirius?” she asked, her voice brittle.
“No… no. It’s Remus.” The answer made sense. Although the weary tone resembled Sirius’s, Remus’s timbre had always been more serious, and his choice of words, more precise. “How are things there?”
“Uh… nothing… nothing much.” She cleared her throat again, trying to normalise her voice. “Everything alright over there?”
Remus hesitated for a second before replying:
“Yeah… yes. Listen, Scar… we… we were looking at your memories in the Pensieve and…”
“What do you mean we were?!” Scarlett cut him off harshly. “Sirius…”
“He asked for my help.” Remus admitted, unmoved by her foul mood. “And I… uh… I wanted to tell you that—”
“Can you put the boys on?” she interrupted again, this time rudely. “The call’s going to end soon.”
She heard Remus’s unsteady breath on the other end, and he agreed with a grunt. A few clicks indicated the phone being passed to another hand and, before Scarlett could speak, Reg was faster:
“Hi… hi, Mum.” He stammered. “Where… where have you been? Are you alright? It’s been two days without you calling…”
Scarlett opened her mouth, but nothing came out: no answer, no word, no sound. Two days? How had two days passed since she’d last spoken to Reg?! It made no sense. At the same time, she tried to search her memory for their last conversation, but everything was frayed and patchy, just flashes of random, euphoric moments.
“Yeah, yeah… it’s just…” She quickly thought of a lie. “It’s really busy here, end of the tour and… today’s the last show.”
“Is it?” Reggie sounded surprised. “So… you’re coming back…”
“After… after tomorrow. But I should only arrive in… three or four days…”
“Harry’s birthday is in three days, Mum.” He didn’t hide the indignation in his voice. “You can’t just—”
“Three?” Scarlett straightened up, knocking her forehead purposely against the wall. She had completely lost track of time. “Fuck… that’s right…” She exhaled loudly through her mouth. “Alright, I… I’ll get there earlier, then.” She tried to sound as assertive as possible, which wasn’t much, considering her voice was lethargic and cracked.
“Mum… I’m worried about you.” Reggie admitted slowly.
“What? Worried about me?!” She gave an uneasy laugh. “No need. Anyway… is Sirius there? I need… I need to talk to him.”
The line crackled before Reg answered:
“No, he went out with Tonks.” He murmured, distracted. “Mum, seriously, I—”
Reg’s words were swallowed by the frantic pounding of her heart. Sirius went out with Tonks.
Of course he did.
Why was she surprised?! She was the one who’d encouraged him to do it. A bitter laugh twisted through her voice and she squeezed her eyes shut so hard she saw stars behind her eyelids.
Her lacerated heart beat painfully, struggling to withstand the wounds she inflicted upon herself. It was useless. Rare were the moments when Scarlett managed to mend her own lashings, let alone bear the consequences of her illogical decisions regarding Sirius and everything surrounding them.
She placed a hand over her chest, trying to soothe the ache, but she was far too sober for that. Her feelings bubbled up and broke the surface with excruciating ease, stealing her breath and whatever control she had over her expression, whose lines folded inward with tears.
“Mum?” Reg’s distant call rippled through her personal pandemonium, pulling her subtly back to reality. “Mum?”
“I… I need to go, Reg.” Scarlett stammered, about to hang up.
“Wait!” Her son’s plea made her hesitate. “Why… why are you doing this?!”
Scarlett blinked the tears from her eyes, letting her gaze sweep the empty corridor before she looked again at the bland, grimy wall holding up the phone.
Why was she doing this?
She wasn’t sure whether the bitterness in her mouth came from the things she’d forgotten or the things she’d remembered.
“To stop hurting…” She tried to swallow, but the corrosive saliva refused to go down. Why, Scarlett? “To hurt as well. To forget all the judgement I get… and to justify all of it. To run… to face things. It doesn’t make sense, Reg… I know. But I think I’ve reached a point in life where sense doesn’t matter anymore.”
“Mum… please…”
“I’m fine, Reggie. Truly.” She didn’t bother sounding convincing. “I don’t want you worrying about me, alright? I… I…”
Regulus slammed the phone down so hard she heard the loud crack on the line.
“Daddy, why is there a naked lady in the hallway?!” a little girl’s voice echoed down the corridor, tugging at her father’s leg. He stared at Scarlett in horror.
She snorted, glancing down at her own… naked body.
That day was going to be spectacular.
.
.
.
The sound of the crowd would always astonish Scarlett. The vibration of voices singing in unison reverberating through her body was a magical, almost transcendent experience. Her fingers moved across the keys instinctively, her muscle memory so strong that not even Azkaban had been enough to shatter the music in her core.
The shows were always euphoric, but this one was a touch more special for being her last of the tour. Torn between the feeling that she should have stayed in London and the gratitude for having left, she joined the band so they could take their bow before stepping off stage to make way for the giant of the night: Pearl Jam.
Scarlett and the rest of the band hurried backstage, the atmosphere one of absolute celebration. Danny tossed his guitar to one of the roadies and opened a bottle of Scotch whisky straight into his mouth, laughing uproariously. Stacy and Lenny chatted excitedly about their favourite parts of the show, and Mike gripped Scarlett’s shoulder, balancing a cigarette between his lips as he pulled it straight from the pack.
“We’re bloody legends!” he exclaimed, fishing a lighter from his pocket.
Scar agreed with a smile and accepted a cup of straight vodka from one of the stagehands.
“Legends? No, Mike. We’re going to watch the legends now!”
They climbed up to the VIP box reserved for the band and their roadies, where bottles were already scattered around, ziplocs in different colours and weights, and that unmistakable scent of sweat and alcohol only a post-show environment could produce. The first riff of Alive made the crowd roar, and it was enough for everyone to match Eddie Vedder’s energy on stage.
Scarlett didn’t know how many songs or how many hours of the concert had passed, but she was already well and truly drunk, sunk into the worn leather sofa when a roadie joined her, stretching his arm along the backrest. He was blond, tall, and certainly several years younger than her. The man leaned in her direction.
“You play like you were born for it,” he said, his voice slowed by alcohol and whatever else he’d probably consumed.
Scarlett forced a smile and reached for another cup, using the movement to shift slightly away from him.
“I wasn’t born for it… practice. The name for that is practice.” She sipped the vodka, feeling it burn down her throat.
“And besides playing… what else do you do?” he pressed, inching closer as he shifted on the cushions.
Scarlett let out a rough, dry laugh and rolled her eyes, then stood abruptly from the sofa and steadied herself against the nearby pillar. She wanted to say she was taken, but she was far too high to lie.
“I run from inconvenient blokes.”
He laughed, though he didn’t seem pleased with the response.
Not that Scarlett gave a damn. He wasn’t the first and wouldn’t be the last. Her gaze swept across the VIP box, settling on Danny and Stacy crying with laughter; Lenny was sprawled on another sofa enjoying the breeze, and Mike was already on his fiftieth cigarette.
She’d seen this film before. It was always like this at the end of their shows: they loaded up on drugs, and she — on alcohol. It was the only thing capable of distorting the path of thoughts that led her to…
That led her to…
No, Scarlett, you can’t think about him!
Sirius was already moving on and…
The mere mention of his name in her mind felt like a nail driven into her skull. She placed a hand against her head, trying to soothe a wound that wasn’t even physical.
Pearl Jam performed their final song of the night.
[Pearl Jam — Black]
The first emotionally progressive chords.
The first verse.
The nail became a stake. The distance she’d managed to feel about anything related to Sirius shrank until it vanished, taking with it every scrap of happiness. The alcohol dragged her violently downwards, backwards, to the bottom. If before it had been an anaesthetic, now it was torture.
Sirius.
Sirius had chosen Tonks over her.
Sirius was happy with someone else.
Why was she crying? Wasn’t this what she’d wanted?
Scarlett closed her eyes, trying to concentrate, forcing herself to resist the avalanche of emotions determined to bury her. But she couldn’t. The tangle in her chest drew breath and spilled over. Everything she’d tried to flee from since she’d left, everything she’d tried to drown in cups and bottles…
She bolted out of the VIP box, stumbling.
“Star?” Mike called after her between drags.
She didn’t even look at him.
She had to get out.
Her feet carried her far from the box, down the narrow backstage corridors of the stadium. She scrubbed her face harshly, trying to force the thoughts away, but the dizziness only worsened. A hand grabbed her by the arm, and she turned abruptly, meeting the roadie from earlier.
His smile no longer held any awkwardness. No. There was something predatory in it — something that made her insides freeze.
Mmm, and all I taught her was everything
Mmm-hmm, I know she gave me all that she wore
“Leaving already?” His dubious smile deepened, and he gripped Scarlett’s arm harder than he should.
“Let go of me!” She tried to pull away, but the man was stronger.
He laughed, amused by her stupor, shoving her into an empty VIP box before she could even blink. The space was dark, horribly dark, desperately dark.
Scarlett felt her heart pounding in her throat, in her ears, at the tips of her fingers. The only light came from the corridor — red as blood.
And now my bitter hands chafe beneath the clouds
Of what was everything
All the pictures had all been washed in black
Tattooed everything
“Why are you avoiding me?!” he murmured, trying to kiss her. Scarlett turned her face away instinctively, feeling the foul stench of alcohol and cigarettes on his breath.
The roadie’s hands were on her shoulders, then slid down her waist, pressing her tightly. He tried to pull at her top, but Scarlett reacted instinctively: she bit his hand, sinking her teeth into the palm with such force she felt the flesh tearing and the snap of bones breaking.
So, why do I sear?
“You fucking bitch!” he snarled, letting her go.
Scarlett tried to pull back, but she was too drunk for that, so she didn’t anticipate the punch that hit her face squarely. The pain exploded around her right eye, and she staggered back, dazed. Her consciousness wavered for a second, and she swallowed hard, feeling the sudden nausea rise through her digestive system, the taste of alcohol burning her throat.
How quick the Sun can drop away?
She couldn’t get her hand to her mouth, nor could she find a bathroom.
Before she knew it, she was vomiting on him. The roadie cursed and tried to clean himself off, and that was the perfect distraction.
Scarlett ran.
Her feet stumbled on the ground, the lights blending in her vision, swallowing everything around her in a terrifying and discordant kaleidoscope. She didn’t know what she was doing or where she was going; she only knew she needed to escape.
Escape from the roadie.
Escape from the music.
Escape from Sirius.
She hardly knew how she managed to get out of the stadium, but when she realised it, she was running through the wet streets of Paris, stumbling on the slippery cobblestones. She looked around, dazed. Their shadows stared back at her, tormented. She moved her hand. They did, too.
Scarlett stepped back, distancing herself from them, but new shadows were closing in, stretching behind her with claws, teeth, skin, pleading, screams, prayers, and curses. The shadows took the shape of monsters, martyrs, the damned. Their dark eyes never left Scarlett, for they knew exactly they were a part of her soul.
All the love gone bad turned my world to black
But one — one in particular — did not look at her. Nor was it… projected by Scarlett. A man with midnight hair and starry eyes. He was looking at something else, at another… woman. A laughing woman who tripped over her own feet.
“Sirius… no…” Scarlett whispered, trying to move closer even though all she truly wanted was to move away. The shadow, however, vanished when two boys ran through it, playing tag.
I know you'll be a star in somebody else's sky
But why, why, why can't it be
Oh, can't it be mine?
The alcohol boiled her blood, and guilt crushed her chest.
She felt her heart racing, her breath ragged in time with the stabbing throbs in her right eye.
Something cold licked her hair, her skin, her tired breath. The sky wanted to punish her as well, pouring down thick drops that whipped her with the same intensity as she flogged herself. A thunderclap echoed across the grey canvas, throwing Sirius’s shadow against the wall of the shop beside her again, accompanied by the frantic sound of her own footsteps when she managed to resume her run.
She just wanted everything to stop.
She wanted to erase this night. This stupid tour.
She wanted to erase the past.
She had tried to run for so long, but the past… the past was like a shadow.
Always pursuing her.
Scarlett knew she couldn’t stop, not even with Sirius crawling inside her heart regardless of her state. Running. Still. Drowning. Imprisoned. Kneeling. Guilty.
It was too late. It had always been too late for Scarius.
Even knowing that, her trembling body kept forcing its way through the labyrinthine streets of Paris. The shadows were everywhere. In the black of the sky, in the red of the earth, in the scarlet lightning.
“Sirius…” Scarlett whispered, as if saying his name could magic him to her side. As if…
She missed Sirius so much that her body hurt.
She stumbled. Fell onto the wet ground, her knees cracking against the cold stones, her hands splashing into filthy, uneven puddles, her hair drenched by the fury of the clouds. The alcohol had now transmuted into a tidal wave — irritable, merciless. It tried to push her into the darkness, and she almost let it.
Scarlett blinked a few times, stunned, her intoxicated gaze following the dotted trail of golden lights rising before her. Her call had been answered. The stars navigated the grey path, flickering with the force of the wind but bravely resisting the rain.
The starlight bathed Scarlett’s face and body as she reached for them, trying to touch them, trying to grasp her star, but they were far too distant, too wavering, too swift.
“No, no, no… Sirius… please…” The cry rose through her throat and spilled out in uncontrollable sobs. “Don’t leave me here alone, Sirius… please…”
“The Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want…” the chorus of voices resonated in French through her ears, cutting through the rain.
Scarlett tried to stand, but her body refused to obey. Her eyelashes were too heavy and the rain blurred her vision.
“He maketh me to lie down in green pastures: he leadeth me beside the still waters…”
“Sirius…” She called him once more, but he didn’t stop. Didn’t even look at her.
“He restoreth my soul: he leadeth me in the paths of righteousness for his name’s sake.”
The procession passed by her, following the uneven rhythm of her heart.
“Yea, though I walk through the valley of the shadow of death, I will fear no evil: for thou art with me; thy rod and thy staff they comfort me.”
Something piercing suddenly crushed her heart. Scarlett placed a hand over it, trying to contain it, but it was imploding inside her.
“Thou preparest a table before me in the presence of mine enemies: thou anointest my head with oil; my cup runneth over.”
Scarlett gasped, her breath ragged. She was drowning, the waves of longing for Sirius pulling her under violently, desperate to drag her to the bottom of her own torment.
“Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life: and I will dwell in the house of the Lord forever.”
“Sirius…” Now his name left her lips like a final prayer. “I’m sorry… I… I’ll stop… I swear… I’ll stop…”
Would she, really? Scarlett wasn’t sure, but she was willing to try.
She would try. She would… she would try.
Scarlett tried, one last time, to reach Sirius. Her body was far too tired for that, polluting her vision with black dots, swallowing the wailing lights until everything…
All been washed in Black.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 79: Nobody ever really gets over their first love
Chapter Text
CXLVII
Regulus slammed the telephone back into its cradle with force.
“Oi, I wanted to talk to her!” Harry complained, looking at him over the back of the sofa.
Reggie didn’t reply.
Not because he couldn’t, he just couldn’t be arsed.
As a child, Regulus had always dreamed of the woman he’d never known. What her smile might have been like, her touch, her voice. Her affection. What it would feel like to be wrapped in her arms and nestled against her heart.
He didn’t know what it was like to have a mother.
Now, he wished he’d never found out.
Tears forced a burning path down his cheeks and he angrily wiped them away with the sleeve of his T-shirt. He stomped towards his bedroom. Slammed the door shut.
He opened his wardrobe, grabbed his rucksack and started stuffing it. Changes of clothes, his skate trainers and even his Quidditch kit. He snatched the Walkman from the bedside table and shoved a handful of tapes into the front pocket of the bag. He zipped it up and slung it over his shoulders, striding determinedly towards the window.
Someone knocked on his bedroom door, but he didn’t bother looking back. Maybe… maybe if he left and… if… if he…
“What are you doing?” Harry frowned, glancing over his shoulder as he closed the door behind him after noticing Remus wasn’t there.
“What do you think I’m doing, Harry?!” Regulus rolled his eyes with his innate condescension, yanking the window open.
“You’re seriously running away?” The disbelief in the boy’s voice made him straighten up.
Reg shot him an exasperated look.
“I can’t… I can’t stay in this house anymore. I’m clearly an intruder here.”
“What the hell are you talking about, Reg?!” Harry let the air out of his lungs and sat down in the desk chair.
Regulus dragged his hands through his black hair, messing it up even more. His breathing caught painfully in his chest, his gaze wandering around the room until it settled on the round glasses of the skinny boy in front of him.
“Everything’s fucked, Harry! Because of me!” He punched his chest, trying to vent the whirlwind twisting inside. “Sirius… and my mum…”
“Sirius and Scar’s problem has nothing to do with you,” Harry shot back, with an infuriating calm.
Reg flared his nostrils, clenching his fists.
“You… you don’t understand, Harry. You never would. My life… is shit!”
Harry laughed — a laugh that had nothing joyful about it. It was sour, steeped in irony and hurt.
“Yeah, Reg. Your life is shit,” he said, his voice dripping with sarcasm. “You play video games whenever you want, eat whenever you want, you’ve always had everything. Wow. Poor you.”
The rebellious look on Reg’s face clouded instantly. His eyes widened, his cheeks flushed, and his eyes burned with indignation.
“You don’t know what you’re talking about!” he almost shouted, anger boiling over in his tone. “If you’d been through everything I’ve been through, you’d want to run away too!”
Harry shook his head, taking off his glasses and cleaning them on the hem of the T-shirt Sirius and Scarlett had bought for him.
“No. I’d never run away from a home where people love me.” The sarcasm was replaced by bitterness. Regulus swallowed hard and Harry went on: “I’d never run away from a place where people look after me and treat me like a human being and not like a mangy dog.” He adjusted his glasses on his face, nudging them up the bridge of his nose with his little finger. “Where they don’t hit me or yell at me for no reason. Where they don’t make me sleep under the stairs. Where they don’t humiliate me because they hate my parents.” He sniffed disdainfully. “Yeah, Reg. Your life is really awful. You should definitely run away.” He stood up from the chair, ready to leave the room and end the conversation.
Just as Harry turned the handle and pulled the door open, however, a sharp crack echoed and it slammed shut on its own. He raised an eyebrow and glanced sideways at Reg, who was holding his wand aimed at the door, grey eyes full of sparks.
“What do you mean by that?”
Harry sighed, his stiff shoulders slumping as though the enormous weight lodged there had just evaporated. His vivid green eyes gained a layer of darkness that Reggie didn’t recognise, but that had always been there, hidden in the dark flecks of his irises, in the shadows of his dilated pupils.
“Did your aunt and uncle hit you?” Regulus insisted, stepping closer as Harry’s eyes filled with tears.
“No… I didn’t—”
“Tell me.” He cut him off, sitting on the bed and motioning for him to do the same. “Come on, Harry.”
Harry Potter looked at the window and then at the door. Not because he was shy, but because he regretted it. It was as if the simple act of showing any trace of vulnerability set off every alarm in his body, as though he were in danger. As though he were ready to run from whatever threatened him, even if it wasn’t real.
“Do you really want to know, Reg?” He swallowed hard, his gaze drifting down to his pair of red slippers.
Regulus grabbed Harry by the wrist and forced him to sit on the bed. There was no resistance — the boy dropped onto the mattress like a doll, even as his green eyes stubbornly refused to meet his.
“Tell me, Harry.”
Regulus Sirius Black had never been particularly close to Harry James Potter during their years at Hogwarts. First, because he had always known the entire story involving his godfather and the Potters. Second, because he was a vain Slytherin and Harry was a cocky Gryffindor. On top of that, two years separated them from daily contact. And after all the mess with the Chamber of Secrets, all the accusations he received because of his mother’s family at the same time that Harry was also blamed…
He had never imagined that the unbearable kid who drew all the school’s spotlight and was the most famous person in the wizarding world could have had such a miserable childhood. But… appearances deceive. Of course Harry’s behaviour at Hogwarts had always irritated him (and every other Slytherin), but over time he realised that many of Harry’s tics were nothing more than habits born of insecurity.
And why the fuck would Harry Potter be insecure, he used to ask himself.
Now he knew.
Regulus felt like a complete, utter arsehole — a spoiled child throwing tantrums over every little thing Harry told him about his aunt, uncle and cousin. How he was openly hated simply for being who he was, how they made his life a living hell, how they forced him to sleep in a cupboard under the stairs. Reg grew more and more horrified every time Harry opened his mouth.
Why the fuck did Dumbledore allow this? It was pure torture. No child deserved to grow up in a home where they were unwanted and mistreated.
By Merlin, there were days when Harry went without food!
This wasn’t funny. It might have been, if this were some childish story and half the people involved didn’t actually exist — but even so…
“And why didn’t you run away?!” Reggie asked. It sounded so obvious in his head until he realised it was just as stupid.
“Where would I have gone?!” Harry practically spat, nearly getting up from the bed, but Reg didn’t let him. “I don’t know if you’ve noticed, but I never had anyone.”
Harry blew all the air from his lungs, his shoulders slumping.
“You’re not alone anymore, Harry.” Reg held his hand in a fraternal gesture.
“I know.” The boy nodded, still unable to look at him. “That’s not what I meant.”
“Now I’m feeling like a spoiled twat.” Reggie tried to lighten the mood, letting out a snorting laugh.
“You are a spoiled twat.” Harry finally looked at him, his lips catching Reg’s laughter, until the amusement faded and the silence deepened. “But… what I meant is that… you have a home. You have people who care about you… Sirius loves you. And Scar… even… even with everything… well, even completely fucked up…” The swear word came out awkwardly for him. “She still wants to come back to you.”
“I know, Harry, I… I just…” Regulus tried to voice his pain, but all his problems seemed to turn to ashes after hearing about Harry’s childhood.
“Don’t say your life is shit, Reggie. You don’t know what that is,” Harry murmured, with a hint of impatience. And understanding, too.
Reg nodded, covering Harry’s hand with his own.
“I know. I’m so sorry for everything you went through, Harry. But… you’re not going to go through that anymore, alright?” He lifted his gaze to his friend, who only offered that shy smile. “We’re a family now.”
“I know.”
“And your aunt, uncle and cousin… they’re not your family, you know? They’re your mum’s family. But they’re not yours. Family are the people we love and choose, not the ones we’re forced to put up with just because we share the same blood. Look at my Uncle Remus — he divorced my Uncle Nate, but I’m closer to him than to anyone else… except Sirius, obviously.”
“Remus was married to your uncle?!” A crease of disbelief appeared on Harry’s forehead. “I didn’t know… um, well… I didn’t know he was… gay.”
Regulus burst out laughing.
“He’s not gay, Harry.” He rolled his eyes. “He’s bi.”
“Oh.” Harry hugged himself, startled. “Right.”
“What?”
“Nothing. I just… it’s just that… my aunt and uncle… they always said that… um, well, that gays and bisexuals… they’re freaks and… it’s stupid, Reg.”
“Oh yes, and the right thing to do is treat your nephew like absolute shit because he’s not like them. By Salazar, Harry, your aunt and uncle are pathetic.”
“I know.” Harry adjusted his glasses on his face.
Two soft knocks echoed at the door. It opened and, as if summoned, Remus’s face appeared in the gap.
“Harry, Ron’s just arrived, and Reg, Sirius too. He’s waiting outside for you so you can go to the shopping centre.”
“The shopping centre?!” Regulus raised a single eyebrow as he stood up from the bed.
“Yeah, because of the…” Remus cast a glance at Harry still sitting on the bed before looking back at Reg.
“Oh, right. Okay, I’m coming.” Regulus ran a hand over his face, making sure there was no trace of tears left. “See you later, Harry.”
“Alright.”
Regulus left the room and waved at Ron in the living room before heading out of the house. Harry’s birthday was in three days. Would Scarlett make it in time?
He clenched his jaw as he went down the front steps, the hollow in his chest stirring at the mere thought. His gaze settled on Sirius, leaning against his Ninja while smoking a cigarette. His long black hair was tied up in a bun, silver eyes hidden behind aviator sunglasses, lips blowing out smoke.
Behind him, the sun was beginning to set. Its orange rays stretched across the horizon in every direction, forcing him to half-close his eyes and raise a hand in front of his face as he looked towards the road.
Reggie approached, stopping beside the bike and watching the dusk cast its glow over the black, immaculately clean chassis. He watched Sirius exhale the smoke calmly, noticing his eyes resting on him.
“Can I have a smoke too?” he asked.
Sirius let out a short, disbelieving laugh, shaking his head.
“If I let you smoke, your mum will kill me.” He brought the cigarette back to his lips.
Reg, however, didn’t laugh. His expression remained flat, eyes fixed on the glowing tip of Sirius’s cigarette.
“She’s not even here. And it’s not like she cares…” he said apathetically.
Sirius’s smile was brutally murdered. He stared at his nephew for several long seconds before pulling the cigarette away with his index and middle fingers.
“Of course she cares,” Sirius shot back, though there wasn’t much conviction in his tone.
He hadn’t expected that from Reggie. Not after the conversation they’d just had.
“No, she doesn’t. She never did.” He rolled his eyes and sighed, irritated. “She won’t even manage to come back for Harry’s birthday.”
The wind picked up, loose strands of Sirius’s hair brushing against the hardened lines of his face. The cigarette burned between his fingers, but he barely noticed it.
“What do you mean?”
Regulus dropped his gaze, kicking an imaginary stone along the pavement as he shoved his hands into the pockets of his denim shorts.
“She rang.” He pressed his lips together in distaste. “Said she’d try to get back before the birthday. But I doubt it.” A humourless laugh followed the thought. “She probably won’t even remember.”
Sirius clicked his tongue and opened his mouth, ready to say something, but then seemed to think better of it. It was as if no words felt right, none of them enough to fill the hole of frustration Reggie was so effortlessly showing him.
“Stop it, Reg,” he said, wetting his lips.
“Stop what?” Regulus wrinkled his nose and raised his eyebrows.
Sirius flicked what remained of the cigarette to the ground and crushed it under the toe of his boot, grinding the sole against the asphalt until the butt was obliterated.
“You know exactly what,” he said, his tone paternal and authoritative.
It wasn’t enough to make Reggie back down. On the contrary, he flashed a sharp, cutting smile, very much like the one Scarlett wore when she was annoyed. At the same time, the way his eyes darkened like iron beneath an arrogant façade made him, inevitably, think of his younger brother.
“What, Sirius? Just because she was tortured, does that erase all the shit she’s pulling now?!” He practically shouted, his voice bouncing off the surrounding houses and parked cars, not giving a toss about the families walking along the pavement.
“No,” Sirius murmured, trying not to draw more attention than they already had. “I know that, Reg. But it’s not that simple.”
“It’s not that simple?” Regulus laughed sharply. “You know what else isn’t simple? Growing up thinking your mum was dead. Then finding out she’d been alive the whole time. And then watching her leave again. And again!”
“Reg—”
“No, Sirius, I don’t want your explanations anymore! I don’t even understand why you still… bother to—” It was hard to stop the tears from clawing their way up into his eyes.
Sirius dropped his head and closed his eyes, taking off his sunglasses.
“Because I understand her, Reg. I understand her like no one else does — just like she understands me too,” he confessed quietly. “I know what she’s going through.”
“Have you ever thought about yourself instead of her?!” Reg shot back harshly. “She dumped you and married your brother!”
Ah. He shouldn’t have said that. The silver in Sirius’s eyes turned to sharpened steel, his nostrils flared and his lips twisted, his throat working deliberately as he tried to swallow, forcing down the sharp retort that wanted to rise.
Sirius took a deep breath. Very deep. Repeating to himself that he was dealing with a teenager, and that he wouldn’t make the same mistakes with Reggie that he had with his brother. Reg didn’t know what he was talking about. At the same time, it was terrifying how much Reg resembled Regulus — always trying to shift the focus of the conversation whenever he felt threatened.
“Do you know why your mum left me, Reg?” Sirius took another deep breath, staring into those grey-blue eyes blazing with revolt. “Because I was just as drunk as she is now. I did and said things that… later, I couldn’t remember. I pushed people away. I sank because…” He exhaled through his mouth. “No. I can’t do the same thing to her.”
“Why not?! She did it to you!”
“She was trying to save your father.”
“Oh yeah?! And look at the bloody mess that made!”
Sirius crossed his arms and shook his head, ignoring every attempt anger made to undermine his rationality.
“No. I don’t regret it, Reg. Because without that, you wouldn’t have been born.” He drummed his fingers against his own biceps. “But… it wasn’t easy. Knowing that… that the woman I loved…” He paused, chasing away the dizzying sensation of suffocation that hit him. “Abandoned me. Because of me. If… if I’d insisted on your father, maybe…” He rubbed his eyes tiredly. “It doesn’t matter anymore. What’s done is done.”
He turned his back and grabbed the spare helmet, offering it to Reg. The boy’s needy eyes traced the polished visor, the plastic shell, and finally settled on his godfather’s tattooed, ring-laden fingers. He took the helmet, staring at his own blurred reflection in the glossy surface.
“Why does she keep hurting us?” The question came out raw, worn down. Exhausted.
The last light of day brushed over his godfather’s face — his aristocratic nose, his beard trimmed close to the skin, his aviator sunglasses. Sirius pressed his lips together and pulled him into an embrace, kissing his forehead.
“Hurt people tend to hurt other people, son,” he murmured, the words spilling over Reg’s temple. “We’ll sort this out, alright? I promise.”
Regulus didn’t want a hug. He didn’t want comfort. He wanted to go after his mother and scream at her, ask her what the fuck was wrong. He also wanted to hold her and tell her he was there. He wanted to fight and he wanted to shelter; he wanted to break things and he wanted to fix them. He didn’t know what to do with everything crashing around inside his chest and turning into tears and loud sobs. He buried his face in Sirius’s chest, trying to muffle the sound — after all, it was rather embarrassing to cry like that in the middle of the street.
Sirius rested his nose in his hair and held him tighter. Reggie let the crushing torrent ease in the arms of the man who, alongside Remus, was the closest thing to a father he had.
And he hugged Sirius again when they mounted the Ninja. He felt the wind at his fingertips, tugging at the sleeves of his T-shirt, the hem of his denim shorts. He let the dizzying speed with which Sirius tore through the streets of London leave Scarlett — and every feeling she stirred in him — behind. His mother wasn’t there, but his godfather was.
And even though there was a vast hollow in his heart, Sirius was more than capable of making him forget it for a night. He had a refreshing, revitalising aura that drew Reg in inexplicably — the kind of person so beautiful and radiant they outshone everyone else.
Sirius parked the bike and helped Reggie down, the late-afternoon heat rising from the asphalt and radiating off the mirrored buildings around them. They hurried inside the still-busy shopping centre.
“Have you decided what you’re getting Harry?” Sirius asked, pulling him close as he slung an arm over his shoulders.
“Er, well… there’s this new Super Nintendo game that just came out… it’s called Donkey Kong… I think Harry’ll like it…”
“A Muggle game?” Sirius arched an eyebrow, hooking his sunglasses into the collar of his black Rainbow shirt. His gaze swept over the surroundings. “Wouldn’t he want something… I don’t know, we could go to Diagon Alley…”
“He’s already got a Firebolt, what else do you want to give him?!” Reggie rolled his eyes, biting his lower lip.
“Want a Firebolt too, do you?” Sirius glanced at him sideways, squeezing his shoulder when Reg stayed quiet.
“No, it’s just… sorry.” He blew the air out of his lungs as he lifted his head, staring up at the shopping centre ceiling. “I think he’d actually prefer the game.”
“Great, because I already know what I’m getting him…” Sirius tugged Reggie along towards the music shop.
The place was packed, radios playing different snippets of songs while customers browsed shelves of CDs and cassette tapes. Sirius let go of Reggie and went straight to the counter, where a muscular man was flipping through a magazine. He looked to be in his mid-forties, wearing an Iron Maiden bandana on his head and a denim waistcoat covered in band patches.
He slowly lifted his gaze to Sirius without closing the magazine.
“Can I help you?”
“What Walkman options have you got?”
The attendant pulled out a shelf from beneath the counter and laid out a range of models in different colours and with different features.
“Blue, black, green, yellow…”
“Red,” Sirius cut in, pointing at the sporty-looking model. “Does it have Auto Reverse and Bass Boost?”
“It does, yeah. Good choice.” The man shrugged. “Any tapes to go with it?”
“A Beatles compilation. Greatest hits and… uh, Hey Jude.”
The attendant nodded and started picking out the tapes, noticing the look Sirius shot at Reg.
“Your son?” he asked casually, tapping the plastic cases as he cast Sirius a sideways glance.
“Er… yeah.” Clearing his throat, Sirius tried to act natural.
Reggie stepped closer to the counter, the bored look on his face quickly giving way to a distracted smile.
“Alright, Jack!” Regulus greeted him, slapping his hand in a casual high-five.
“Oi, kid, you here?!” Jack furrowed his brow, leaning his elbows on the counter.
Sirius knitted his brows, his gaze flicking between the two before settling on his godson.
“You know each other?”
“Yeah,” Jack answered, to Sirius’s displeasure. “He’s always in here over the summer looking for a new Whitesnake tape. Better taste in music than most adults.”
The smile that crossed Sirius’s lips was involuntary. Bloody hell, he looked so much like Scarlett…
“Hang on, I… I thought…” Jack blinked a few times, as if recalling something, then turned his attention to Sirius. “I thought your dad was dead.”
Sirius’s mouth tightened and his jaw clenched, trying to ignore the dizzying sensation that, not for a single moment, could he ever allow himself to imagine Regulus as his son.
“He’s my godfather,” Reggie explained, with bored nonchalance.
Sirius’s long, impatient sigh wasn’t enough to make Jack drop the subject; instead, he narrowed his eyes, trying to piece the puzzle together.
“Didn’t know you had a godfather, mate.” He raised his hands in a gesture of surrender.
“Yeah, he… came back recently… lived in another country, right?” Reg elbowed Sirius, nudging him out of his stupor.
“Yeah… that’s it…” Sirius agreed, mumbling disinterestedly.
Reggie went off to rummage through the clearance section, and Jack turned back to keep looking for the tapes. His gaze, however, soon drifted back to Sirius. More specifically, to his Rainbow T-shirt.
The attendant’s eyes practically doubled in size.
“Hang on… the Rainbow gig from the summer of ’76…” Jack murmured, scratching the patchy beard on his chin.
“What?” Sirius rubbed one eye, absent to the question.
“Mate… bloody hell. I remember you.” Jack laughed, clapping a hand over his mouth in sheer disbelief. “I worked at the shop round the corner in central London, near Piccadilly, remember?!”
“Huh?” Sirius didn’t hide the confusion in his grunt.
What the fuck was this idiot on about?
“You were neighbours with the girl I fancied back then!” he explained, with an enthusiasm Sirius didn’t share, even though he followed the line of thought. “What was her name again?!” He snapped his fingers, trying to remember.
Sirius licked his lips and smiled. No — smile wasn’t the right word. He stretched his lips.
“Scarlett.” The name came out softly, though it quickly soured in his mouth.
Jack slapped the counter, his laughter bursting into an animated guffaw.
“Exactly! Scarlett. I was obsessed with her. What are the odds?!”
Sirius remained completely still, pulling the strings of his face until it was stripped of any expression. He tugged at the corner of his mouth, but that was all.
“Funny how things work out, yeah? World’s bloody tiny.”
Sirius stayed silent. It seemed impossible to escape Scarlett for long — especially when he knew exactly what it was like to be obsessed with her.
“I never got the chance to return that punch you gave me,” he commented casually. Behind his lips, his teeth ground together.
Jack frowned in confusion.
“What are you tal—”
“You know exactly what I’m talking about,” Sirius cut him off arrogantly.
“Don’t know, mate. Sorry.” Jack kept smiling, though there was a hint of malice in his eyes. He finished packing the Walkman and tapes, totalling it up on the till. “That’ll be a hundred quid.”
Sirius drew a deep breath as he pulled his wallet from his trouser pocket, took out the note and tossed it onto the counter.
“Do you still keep in touch with Scarlett? Do you know what happened to her?” Jack tried to make conversation as he handed over the gift bag.
“She’s dead.” Sirius spat it out, sharp as a whip crack. He turned to his godson. “Come on, Reg.”
“Hang on, I swear I saw an old Rush tape here—”
Sirius clicked his tongue, already walking towards the exit.
“Regulus…”
“Calm down—”
“Regulus!” he called again, in an authoritative tone.
The boy let out a disgruntled sound and, reluctantly, abandoned the bargain section, hurrying after Sirius.
“What’s your problem?!” he grumbled, zigzagging past a couple as he caught up to his godfather, who didn’t even look at him. “What happened?”
“Nothing,” Sirius snapped, pretending to be far too busy reading the shopfronts. “Where’s the bloody shop you want to go to?”
“Why are you acting like this?” Reggie ignored the question, which only made Sirius even more irritated.
“Like what?” The words came out an octave higher than they should have.
“This. It’s because of my mum, isn’t it?”
Sirius sighed. He should’ve gone to the bloody shopping centre on his own.
“Reg… just show me where the bloody shop is.”
“Why don’t you talk to me about what you feel for her?” The question was asked with such sincerity that Sirius fell silent. His gaze drifted through Reggie’s grey-blue eyes, hovering over that mercury ocean, dodging the darkened flecks in his irises.
How could he talk about the reason behind his hatred for Scarlett?
Sirius didn’t hate Reg. No — quite the opposite. He loved him fiercely, as if he were his own. And that was the point. As if. Because he should have been. He should have been his and Scarlett’s, he should have been the fulfilment of his dream.
But he wasn’t. The grey of his eyes belonged to Regulus, the black of his hair belonged to Regulus, the curiosity disguised as biting sarcasm belonged to Regulus.
It was the first time since escaping Azkaban that Sirius felt eighteen again, staring at his younger brother while the words trampled over each other before they could even reach his vocal cords — too heavy for the air moving through his throat to bring them to the surface.
His hands curled into fists. As much as he wanted to pretend Scarlett’s absence didn’t affect him, the truth was that Sirius felt like an abandoned dog. Looking for her in every bleach-blonde woman who passed by, searching for her shadow in every music shop, scanning the sky for a cloud shaped like his girl with flowers in her hair.
He knew he wouldn’t find her. Scarlett was far away. He could feel it in the stretch of his muscles, in the murmur of his blood, in the pulse of his heart.
But he kept searching.
“She bewitched me, Reg… but… now…” Sirius sniffed, a shredded hiss tearing from his chest. “The spell’s broken.”
Regulus shoved his hands into his pockets, holding his godfather’s gaze as he weighed his confession.
“Love makes everyone a bit stupid,” he commented with a shrug, struck by the strange feeling that they were two teenagers talking about the girls they were in love with.
Sirius laughed. He hadn’t expected to. Laughter hadn’t been included in the range of expressions he’d approved for himself that afternoon. Not that it was forbidden — it just hadn’t occurred to him that something so soft could scrape past his vocal cords after all the overthinking about what to say to his nephew.
“First loves are a bloody nightmare…” Reg slung an arm over Sirius’s shoulders and guided him through the shopping centre corridors towards the video game shop.
“Who said she was my first love?!” Sirius raised a sharp eyebrow, lifting his nose in a sardonic gesture.
“Because nobody ever really gets over their first love.” He pushed the glass door open, making the bell jingle.
“True. To this day, I still haven’t got over Ann Wilson…” Sirius pressed a hand to his chest as if he’d just been mortally wounded there.
“Ann Wilson?! From Heart?” Regulus stared at him, incredulous.
“And who else would it be?!” Sirius narrowed his eyes at him, a crease forming at his temple.
Reg pressed his lips together, trying to stay serious, but his mouth quickly split into a grin. The two of them started laughing, and Sirius felt his whole body sway as the blue in his nephew’s eyes sparked, the grey lightening and glittering like stardust.
He couldn’t remember the last time he’d laughed with Reggie. A very strange feeling splashed across his chest — euphoria mixed with… acceptance? Sirius didn’t quite know what it was, but it felt good. Warm. Welcoming. He pulled his nephew in by the shoulder and kissed his forehead, feeling Reg’s arms wrap around him in a clumsy, tight hug.
“She’ll come back, Dad,” Reggie murmured against the collar of his Rainbow T-shirt.
Sirius’s smile turned into something quietly melancholy.
“I know,” he said, pulling back and ruffling Reg’s hair. “I know, son.”
.
.
.
Sirius licked the Belgian chocolate shell before the ice cream could drip down his fingers. Regulus, sitting opposite him, leaned forward to let two girls squeeze into the cramped, limited space of the ice cream parlour.
It was hot and stifling, and not even the ice cream managed to ease the oppressive heat of that hellish day.
A teenage couple sat near the window, sharing a banana split. A little girl tugged at her mother’s skirt, desperately pointing at the picture of a massive strawberry sundae, and a family deliberately excluded an introspective, withdrawn boy sitting at the back of the parlour.
Regulus ran his thumb over his chin and licked his fingertip.
“Harry told me some things,” he murmured, lifting his gaze back to his uncle.
It took Sirius a moment to process what Reg had said.
“Hm? What?!” he grunted, biting into his cone without caring about getting ice cream all over his beard. A woman on the other side of the parlour licked her ice cream while looking at him in a rather suggestive way.
Sirius pressed his lips together and furrowed his brows.
“About his aunt and uncle. And his cousin… how he was treated. Has he ever told you about that?” Reg sank the lime-green spoon into his ice cream dish.
“No…” The answer was barely more than a whisper.
He wasn’t sure he wanted to know. Of course, just looking at Harry made it obvious that he hadn’t been treated properly at his relatives’ house — but seeing him like that and knowing exactly what he’d been through were two completely different things.
“He slept in a cupboard under the stairs,” Reg said, as if it were the most normal thing in the world. “They lied about what happened to James and Lily until he got to Hogwarts and Hagrid told him the truth, and they treated him like a house-elf. He barely ate, for fuck’s sake. In the summer after his second year at Hogwarts, his uncle locked up his school things and tried to stop him from going back, putting bars on his windows and a lock on his door.”
Sirius barely noticed he’d crushed the cone in his fist, cold chocolate ice cream dripping between his hot, sweaty fingers. His teeth ground together and his muscles burned; his free hand moved instinctively to his thigh, rubbing over the fabric that covered his whip scars.
“I think he’s never really celebrated a birthday…” Regulus went on quietly, making sure no one else but Sirius could hear him. “I think we… well, I think we should make this birthday the most special one he’s ever had. What do you think?”
Sirius didn’t even hear the last words. All he wanted was to Apparate straight to the Dursleys’ house and make them pay for everything they’d done. As much as he wanted to, though, he wouldn’t. Revenge was sweet, yes — at first it could be sweet like any good poison.
Getting revenge on those idiotic Muggles wouldn’t change anything. It wouldn’t erase Harry’s suffering.
Just like Sirius' parents' deaths had never filled the burning void he felt in his chest. The absence of parental figures would always remain raw, almost undefinable. He couldn’t go back to the past and undo the shit he’d done, but he could be different in the present. Not just with the Dursleys, but also… also with Scarlett. With Regulus. With Harry.
He needed to leave his ghosts behind, strip them of the immense power they held and reduce them to exactly what they were: intangible, translucent, irrelevant. Dry, rotting leaves; abandoned graves overgrown with moss.
The past.
Sirius Black was no longer the same man he had been before. He gripped his Slytherin side the way one holds a snake by the throat and lifts it high, stopping it from coiling, from striking, from hurting. He reined in the impulsive, furious Gryffindor lion with a violent yank on its leash, forcing upon it the control that so often slipped through his fingers.
No.
“I think you’re right, Reg.” Sirius grabbed a handful of napkins and wiped his hand. “So… what does it take to make a perfect birthday?”
Reggie’s lips stretched into a smile. He knew exactly the answer to that question.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 80: HAPPY BIRTHDAY, HARRY!
Chapter Text
CXLVIII
Harry Potter woke up on the 31st of July, 1994, to the delicious smell of freshly made pancakes. His stomach growled before he even opened his eyes, rubbing them lazily as he let the beams of light break apart the room around him. His blurred gaze wandered over the animated Puddlemere United poster hanging beside his Firebolt on the wall, then to the enormous Gryffindor banner near his wardrobe and across the jumble of photos of his parents on the bedside tables.
He wasn’t sure whether he had just woken from a dream or a nightmare. Not that it mattered in that moment.
No, it didn’t.
It was his birthday. His first birthday spent with his family.
He allowed himself the luxury of staying under the sheets for a few extra minutes. It was another strange thing about living with Sirius, Remus and Reg: he had the freedom to get up whenever he wanted. To do whatever he felt like, whenever he felt like it. His wishes were respected, and so was his lack of them.
Correction: he was respected. Full stop.
He cleaned his round glasses on the hem of his T-shirt. It was much too big for him, but it wasn’t one of Dudley’s.
It had belonged to James. It was old and a little frayed at the sleeves, carrying a faint smell of mould and dust, but he hadn’t let Penny wash it. He wanted every last trace of his father to remain there.
He stretched before getting up, yawning widely. He cracked his neck and pulled on a pair of shorts, running a hand through his perpetually messy hair. He pushed the blind aside and peeked outside, looking for Scarlett’s car on the street… but all he saw was Sirius’s motorbike parked in front of the garage.
He left his bedroom and found the corridor empty. He crossed the sitting room and stopped at the kitchen door when a shower of confetti flew straight into his face and Sirius, Remus and Reg said, in unison:
"Happy birthday!"
He immediately looked down at the floor, and the smile on his face turned uncomfortable. Penny didn’t allow him to remain shy, tugging him by the hand to his seat at the table, where a mountain of stacked pancakes awaited him, along with boiled eggs, sausages with beans, crispy bacon, pumpkin juice and steaming tea.
"Eat!" The command was delivered with such authority that the boy had no choice but to stuff a pancake into his mouth under the watchful eyes of Remus, Sirius and Reg.
He barely noticed the red ribbons and colourful balloons floating near the kitchen ceiling or the music playing softly from the tape deck in the sitting room. After finishing chewing, still without saying a word, Sirius pulled a bag from the floor and placed it on his lap. His godfather’s handsome face was adorned with a crooked smile.
"I heard your Walkman broke. Thought you’d like a new one more than a broom this time."
Harry quickly opened the bag and unwrapped the present, staring in amazement at the red Walkman and the stack of Beatles tapes. He slipped the headphones around his neck and looked at Sirius, his heart beating so fast with happiness that he forgot to comment that yes, he would have loved another broom as well.
"Blimey, Sirius… thanks." He turned the Walkman over and over, looking for the button to open it, when a throat-clearing caught his attention.
"Your present, Harry." Regulus said, grinning from ear to ear.
"The new cartridge we saw in the magazine!" Harry practically bounced with excitement as he took the gift. "Wow, thanks, Reg. I’m going to play it loads!"
"We’re going to play!" Regulus corrected him, with a crooked smile.
"Of course not, the present’s mine!" Harry rolled his eyes.
"And the Super Nintendo’s mine!"
"Let Harry be, Reg…" Remus scolded his nephew indulgently. "Here’s your present, Harry. I hope you like it." He handed him a package that looked like a book. "It’s all the notes from the duelling club your father and I kept during our final year at Hogwarts…"
At the mention of James, Harry tore the wrapping open a bit roughly, revealing a light brown leather cover. He flipped through the book, finding Remus’s rounded, meticulously neat handwriting, completely at odds with the messy scrawl that belonged to his father.
"So, you won’t be able to go into the garden until later… we’re still finishing a few things…" Sirius drew his attention, spinning the rings on his fingers. "The Weasleys should be here soon… and Hagrid’s going to take the chance to pick up Buckbeak."
Harry scratched his messy hair, processing his godfather’s words until his gaze settled on the owl cage hidden beneath a white cloth in the hall.
"Is that for me too?" he asked, setting his presents aside to start breakfast.
"The owl? Oh, no." Sirius clicked his tongue. "It’s for your friend, Ron. After… after Wormtail…" His jaw tightened at the mention.
There was no time for Sirius to dwell on it, because the doorbell rang and Harry jumped out of his chair as if he’d been electrocuted, banging his knees on the table and making the cutlery clatter. He bolted for the hall.
The moment Harry Potter opened the door, he was hit by a tight hug.
"HAPPY BIRTHDAY, HARRY!" Ron nearly knocked him over, squeezing him hard.
"Ron!" Harry laughed, returning the hug, noticing Fred and George carrying a little bag full of sweets.
"Happy birthday, mate!" Fred waved, handing him the bag.
"We hope you like the present," George added, ruffling Harry’s hair.
"What’s this?" Harry frowned at the twins, whose only response was a shrug.
"You’ll find out later." Fred flashed his most wicked grin.
"I hope it’s not what I’m thinking, lad!" Mr Weasley appeared behind them with Ginny and narrowed his eyes at both twins, but his scowl quickly melted when he looked at Harry. "Hello, Harry. Happy birthday!"
"Thanks, Mr Weasley. Come in!" He stepped aside to let them through.
"Oh, thank you, Harry. We’d better come in indeed… before that boy’s parents complain to the Muggle authorities…" Arthur shot Fred and George a sharp look.
"Oh, Dad. We spent the whole summer looking for someone to test it on…"
"It wasn’t funny at all, Fred!" the patriarch cut his son off in a way Harry had never seen before. "What in Merlin’s name did you give that Muggle boy?!"
"I didn’t give him anything!" Fred put a hand to his chest, raising his eyebrows in outrage. "I only dropped the sweet… it was his fault if he picked it up and ate it, I didn’t tell him to!"
The looks bounced back and forth between Mr Weasley and Fred incessantly, until Sirius decided to step in.
"Arthur, how are you?" He put on his most charming smile, shaking his hand.
"Oh, Sirius, all good! And you lot?"
Harry motioned for them to follow him.
"Do you want to see the video game?" He didn’t bother hiding the excitement in his voice.
"Absolutely! We want to see this thing working!" George took the lead, plopping down on the sofa.
Mr Weasley followed, just as curious. He watched Reggie connect the Super Nintendo to the television and Harry turn it on, explaining how the controller buttons worked.
"This one’s to jump and this one’s to run…" Harry demonstrated, handing the controller to the twins, who were wrestling each other to decide who would play.
"Careful, careful not to fall in the hole!" Ginny warned, but it was already too late.
"Give it here, Fred, you’re rubbish." George snatched the controller from him.
The game wasn’t just the main attraction for the kids. Mr Weasley stood there gaping, completely fascinated, scrutinising the television in sheer astonishment.
"Incredible… a moving picture with control buttons…" he murmured to himself, trying to understand how the thing in George’s hands, connected by a wire to a box, which was then linked to the moving picture, made the little man jump and run.
"That’s because you haven’t seen Mario Kart yet…" Sirius commented, smiling at the boys’ excitement.
"Well, I must be off. I’ll be back for the party later this afternoon…" Mr Weasley adjusted his braces and cast one last glance at the Super Nintendo before heading for the door.
Sirius walked him out, hands in his pockets and a surprisingly calm smile on his lips.
"Remus mentioned Molly wanted to make dinner…" He stopped right beside Arthur. "No need, Penny’s already stressed because she wants to cook Harry’s birthday dinner…"
"Oh, really?!" Mr Weasley ran a hand over the thinning hair on his crown. "Molly’s already prepared a feast." He winked, adjusting his glasses.
Sirius pulled his hands out of his pockets and rested them on his hips, the smile on his lips disappearing as he pressed them together.
"Well… I hope the guests are hungry, then." He shrugged, knowing there wasn’t much choice. He didn’t want to get caught in an argument between Molly and Penny over who would serve dinner.
"Yeah, I hope so too!" Arthur gave him a pat on the back and said goodbye to everyone, receiving waves and smiles as he left the house.
As soon as the door closed, Sirius turned to Ron. He was completely hypnotised, eyes glued to the television.
"Ron." He called, motioning for him to come over.
The boy looked around, alert and startled, before standing up from the sofa and heading towards him.
"What is it?"
Sirius studied him for a moment, weighing his words. He picked up the small cage covered with a white cloth that was sitting in the hall and offered it to him.
"This is for you. Consider it payment for… uh, well, because of Wormtail…" He dipped his head slightly. "It’s my fault you don’t have a rat anymore."
Ron took the cage, pulled back the cloth and widened his eyes. The little owl began to hoot excitedly. She was tiny, smaller than he’d expected, with grey feathers and large, curious eyes. She tilted her head to the side, staring at him.
"She’s… small," he commented, awkward.
"And she makes a bloody racket." Sirius leaned in to get a better look at her. "But she’ll serve you well."
Ginny ran over to them, hands tucked behind her back as she examined the owl.
"She’s so cute!" She stretched out her index finger, and the bird closed her eyes as Ginny stroked her soft feathers.
"She’s not cute!" Ron grumbled, rolling his eyes.
"What are you going to call her?" Regulus also came closer, standing beside Sirius.
"She looks like a… Piggy!" Ginny said, and the owl hooted excitedly. "See? She liked it. Cute little Piggy…"
Fred and George heard the name and burst out laughing in the sitting room.
"Piggy?!" Fred left the controller with Harry to get a better look at his brother’s present.
"Sounds like the name of a stuffed toy," George added.
Ron pressed his lips together as the blush crept up his neck, ears and cheeks, setting them ablaze in a red as bright as his hair.
"She’s not going to be called Piggy!"
"I think she liked the name!" Ginny ignored him, taking the owl out of the cage. The bird immediately took flight and landed on her shoulder.
The doorbell rang again, muffling the disgruntled sound Ron made. It was Remus who opened the door, coming face to face with Hermione carrying a colourful bag and a grin from ear to ear.
"Hello, Professor," she greeted him cheerfully. Behind her, her parents smiled and waved warmly.
"Hello, Mr and Mrs Granger." Remus shook both their hands. "The kids are in the sitting room." He motioned for her to go in, remaining behind to chat amicably with the Grangers.
Hermione crossed the room in a flash and gave Harry a tight hug.
"Happy birthday, Harry!" She quickly handed him the present.
"Hi, Hermione! Thanks!" The boy tore into the colourful wrapping with enthusiasm: it was an official Ireland Quidditch team shirt. "That’s brilliant!"
Ron immediately abandoned his argument with Ginny about the owl’s name when he noticed Harry’s present.
"Hi, Regulus." Hermione stepped closer to the boy, dropping her gaze to the floor.
"Hey." He smiled, not paying her much attention. He was far too absorbed with Piggy and Ginny.
"Alright, kids." Sirius drew everyone’s attention with a clap. "Make yourselves at home. Remus and I still need to finish decorating the garden, and Penny’s making lunch." He paused dramatically. "Don’t blow up the house."
"And don’t touch anything you don’t know what it is," Remus warned, his eyes fixed on Fred, who was studying the tape deck on the sideboard.
"Can’t promise anything," the twin said, winking.
"Didn’t think so." Sirius clicked his tongue. "But I don’t think your dad would like knowing you’ve been fiddling with things you shouldn’t…"
Fred gave up on pressing the eject button and flopped onto the sofa with a bored groan. Remus and Sirius headed out to the back of the house, and Penny seemed far too busy in the kitchen to keep an eye on them.
"Since when did Sirius get so boring? He was the mad outlaw literally a few months ago!" Fred complained, propping a cushion behind his head to get a better view of George playing.
"Oh, actually…" Harry changed the subject, setting his shirt down with the other presents. "What was your dad on about earlier? That thing you gave the Muggle kid… what was it?"
"Ton-Tongue Toffee," Fred informed him eagerly. "George and I invented it! You should’ve seen it, Harry. The bloke’s tongue grew like half a metre long…"
"What are you talking about?" Hermione cut in, running a hand through her thick hair.
"Fred and I were walking a bit behind Dad, Ron and Ginny when this bloke started having a go at us… saying we looked like we’d just escaped from the circus because of our clothes… so I, well… Fred dropped a toffee… and he ate it…"
Regulus was the first to burst out laughing at the twins’ audacity, followed by Ginny, Ron and, lastly, Harry. He couldn’t even picture the situation properly—though he soon stopped laughing when he noticed Hermione was the only one not sharing in the amusement.
"That’s not funny," she muttered, arms crossed. "And it was dangerous, he was a Muggle! How did your dad deal with that?!"
"We didn’t give him the toffee because he’s a Muggle!" Fred shot back, folding his arms.
"We only did it because he was being a prat," George added, glancing sideways at them while he played. "And Dad handled it just fine. Used a Fumos while Fred shrank his tongue. No one saw anything… I think."
"You lot are brave… and stupid. You could’ve had your wands confiscated over that stunt," Reggie commented, though he was still laughing.
"Everything turned out fine and our wands didn’t get confiscated, so I call that a win," Fred shrugged, clearly unconcerned about the risk.
"Yeah, well, we’re not cowards like certain Slytherins…" George frowned at Regulus.
"Nor are you intelligent," Reg shot back, lifting his eyebrows in challenge.
"Considering Crabbe and Goyle are in Slytherin, I don’t think intelligence is exactly a requirement to get in," Hermione commented shyly.
"They’re clearly an exception." Rolling his eyes, Regulus perched on the arm of the sofa. "Come on then, Weasleys, I’m going to wipe the floor with you in Mario Kart…"
Ginny sat down beside Hermione, and Ron watched the showdown standing up. Harry adjusted his glasses and settled into the armchair. He couldn’t remember the last time he’d spent so long with a smile plastered on his face—not even when leafing through his parents’ photo album did he recall his cheeks aching from such a constant feeling.
It was… strange, everyone being there because of him. Not just because he’d never had a proper birthday, but also because… whenever Privet Drive was packed like this on Dudley’s birthday, it was always with those rowdy, foul-mouthed friends he knew from school and the neighbourhood. The boys made a point of pissing on the bathroom floor and stealing Aunt Petunia’s little trinkets, and Harry always got beaten for taking the blame.
Why the fuck would he steal the stupid porcelain swan his aunt got from some nobody? No matter how much he tried to explain it to Vernon and Petunia, the punishment always came. Regardless of the truth.
His gaze drifted around the sitting room, to the front door and then to the one leading out to the garden. He pinched his own wrist and looked back at Regulus and George. The two of them were elbowing each other, trying to throw the other off during the race. Hermione, Ginny and Ron were laughing at Fred’s desperate shouted advice.
Sirius had said he couldn’t call that place home because of his mother’s blood protection at number four, Privet Drive, but… that was where Harry belonged. Not just during the school year, but during the summer holidays as well. With his friends.
With his family.
With the people who truly cared about him.
.
.
.
The garden decorations were finished after everyone had eaten the delicious lunch Penny had prepared. Dessert was Harry’s favourite: caramel tart. He was already stuffed even hours later when Sirius poked just his head through the door, a wide grin on his face, and announced:
"You can come out now!"
Harry filled his lungs with air and ran for the door, followed by Regulus, Hermione, Fred, George and Ginny. Sirius stepped aside to let them through, and the first sight of the garden sparked a wave of surprised exclamations from the kids.
The improvised Quidditch pitch was what caught the eye first: enchanted hoops floating in the air, mimicking the real goalposts. Rows of chairs had been set up like stands around the oval space, and small tables were scattered across the garden with little candles in the centre so guests could sit down. In the corner, near the apple trees, there were more tables where dinner would likely be served.
"Wow!" was all Harry managed to say.
"It’s brilliant!" Ron murmured excitedly.
Buckbeak pawed at the ground, watching with curiosity a line of brooms neatly arranged beside the swimming pool.
Harry approached him, stroking the grey plume on his head, and the hippogriff let out a pleased sound. Hermione and Ron soon joined in, until the creature spread his wings and flopped onto his back on the grass.
"Those were our brooms back in our Hogwarts days." Sirius pointed at them nostalgically. "That was my first Nimbus." He nibbled his lower lip and ran his fingertips along the light brown handle of one of them, its bristles more worn and untidy. "That one there was your dad’s, Harry. I think he’d like you to fly on it today."
Harry ran his hand over the polished handle of the broom that had once belonged to James, his lips stretching into a soft, wistful smile for a time he had never lived.
"It was with that one he won the Quidditch Cup in our final year at Hogwarts. It was the fastest Nimbus of its time… these days it’s outdated, of course, but…" Sirius cut himself off halfway through, his gaze slipping from James’s old broom to the green grass beneath his feet.
"And which one did you use to win the Cup alongside him?!" Regulus cut in, running his fingers along the handles as he examined each broom.
Sirius stretched out his arm and grabbed one—a Nimbus very similar to James’s, but his had a black-painted handle and gold footrests. Reg opened his hand to take it, but Sirius didn’t let go.
"I’m playing with that one," he explained, nodding towards another broom. "That one over there was your mum’s Firebolt. Why don’t you play with it?"
Regulus’s gaze scrutinised the object, the silver in his irises wavering between rigidity and softness, the blue warming and cooling in turn. He clenched his jaw, tightened his fists and tensed his neck. He swallowed hard, slowly. The silver melted into mercury and the blue cleared. He looked at Sirius before acquiescing, though not a single word left his lips.
The handle was cold, worn. The bristles were dry, though still usable, and there were splinters that needed trimming all along the broom’s body, especially near the footrests. It was made of dark birch wood, almost the same materials as the broom Harry had received from Sirius, but carved in the style of the late seventies.
"I didn’t know there were other Firebolts," Harry remarked, admiration touching every line of his expression.
"It was discontinued in the UK in the early sixties," Sirius explained. "It was more famous in Central Europe."
Regulus merely drew in a loud breath, holding his mother’s old Firebolt.
"Let’s pick teams!" Harry tugged Regulus closer, throwing an arm around his shoulders. "Odds or evens, Reg?"
"Odds," he said, with far less enthusiasm than he ought to have had.
"Hold on, hold on!" Tonks’s animated voice rang out from the side entrance to the garden. "You’re not playing Quidditch without me!"
Andromeda and Ted arrived as well, greeting everyone and taking seats in the stands.
"You can pick whoever you want… but please don’t put me with Tonks," Sirius whispered to the two of them before forcing a smile as Tonks hugged him tightly.
"Hey, mate!" She pulled back and pinched Sirius’s perfect nose.
He pulled a face.
"Alright, I choose Sirius." Harry grabbed his godfather’s arm, and Sirius went over to his side of the pitch, shrugging at Reg.
Nymphadora crossed her arms, constantly shifting her weight from one leg to the other, staring fixedly at Regulus.
Reggie didn’t let himself be rattled by those wide eyes that changed colour every second, busying himself with surveying the pitch in search of a player. He scratched his chin and nodded towards the Weasleys.
"Ginny."
"Ginny?" Fred didn’t bother hiding the sarcasm in his voice, which earned him a sharp elbow right in the stomach from Ginny. "Oi!"
She proudly took her place beside Regulus, a smug look sweeping over her brothers for being the first one chosen.
"Fred," Harry picked.
"George," Reggie shot the twins a wicked look as he split them up.
"Oh, come on, Black!" George complained, grabbing a random broom as he joined Ginny, a scowl stamped across his face.
"Ron."
"I can’t believe I’m the one left over!" Tonks put her hands on her hips. "I’m not that bad!"
"Don’t go breaking anything, Nymphadora!" Andromeda warned with a shout.
Harry bit back a laugh at the murderous look Tonks shot at her mother.
"Alright, everyone ready?" Remus reluctantly took up the position of referee.
"We’re going to wipe the floor with you!" Fred grabbed a Beater’s bat and cracked his fingers as though preparing for a duel.
"Oh, good luck with that!" Regulus shot back, swinging a leg over Scarlett’s old Firebolt.
"Mount your brooms!" Remus instructed. The match set came from an old kit James had owned, along with the Quaffle and the Bludgers. He opened the box, and Penny, at his side, snapped her fingers to enchant the items. "Let the game begin!"
The Quaffle was tossed into the air.
All eight players immediately took flight. Harry slipped into his usual position, and Ginny did the same on the opposing team. After a brief argument with George, Regulus decided to play as a Chaser, just like Sirius, leaving the twins as Beaters. Ron took up the Keeper position on one side, and Tonks on the other.
The match was… pure chaos.
Sirius snatched the Quaffle with ease, feinting past Regulus and urging his old broom towards the hoops.
"Eat my dust, Reg!" Sirius laughed.
"Ready for your defeat, Padfoot?!" Tonks slammed her fists into her Keeper’s gloves.
Sirius didn’t spare her a glance. He hurled the Quaffle at the left hoop, making Tonks dive desperately… and miss completely, her broom handle wobbling wildly as she realised the Quaffle had sailed straight through the hoop.
Sirius threw his arms up in celebration.
"NOOO!" She expelled the air in a hiss and rubbed her eyes hard with her knuckles.
"Point for Harry’s team!" Penny cheered, flicking her fingers to update the floating scoreboard.
Regulus rolled his eyes, grabbed the Quaffle and kicked it towards Ginny.
"Tonks… I’m begging you…" he sighed. "Guard the hoops."
"I’m trying, but this broom’s awful!" she snapped back, straightening herself in mid-air.
"The problem isn’t the broom, it’s who’s riding it," Sirius taunted, winking at her when she raised her middle finger at him.
The game resumed. Ginny was surprisingly good on a broom, chasing the Golden Snitch while Harry stayed close, waiting for the right moment. Regulus stole the Quaffle and shot towards the opposing team’s hoops, Sirius hot on his heels.
"Clear off, Padfoot!" Reggie suddenly dived and dodged Harry, lining up his throw.
"I’m going to nick that Quaffle off you…" Sirius sing-songed, closing in on his nephew.
Fred and George were locked in a private Bludger war, batting them in every direction and nearly knocking Ron off his broom.
"WATCH IT! I’M ON YOUR TEAM, YOU IDIOT!" Ron yelled, swerving angrily away from his brothers.
Fred seized the distraction to smash a Bludger straight into Regulus, striking the back of his Firebolt at the exact same moment George sent one flying at Sirius, knocking him off balance. He nearly tumbled into the swimming pool.
Even after being hit, Reg still managed to throw the Quaffle. Ron was far too focused on not getting taken out by Fred’s friendly fire to defend the hoops.
"Point for Reg’s team!" Penny cheered, changing the scoreboard to ten all.
Sirius and Regulus went back to fighting over the Quaffle. Reg had inherited his parents’ competitiveness and elbowed Sirius to take possession, but his godfather saw right through the move: he threw his torso back to avoid the hit and overtook Reggie. He flattened himself against the handle of his broom and swooped down to the surface of the pool, the speed of his flight sending water spraying around him as he lined up the shot.
Tonks positioned herself in front of the left hoop, so Sirius aimed for the right. His cousin hurried to defend it, still wrestling with the broom, but she managed to move in time.
The Quaffle didn’t go through the hoop. It hit Tonks just above the stomach. She lost her balance, spun on her broom, let out an unguarded scream and fell straight into the pool.
"And there goes Tonks…" Regulus clapped a hand over his mouth as he laughed.
Andromeda snorted without a hint of surprise. Her daughter resurfaced, her once spiky, vivid purple hair now plastered to her face.
"I DEFENDED IT!" she cheered, clinging to the edge.
"Brilliant save, Tonks," Sirius drawled, reclaiming the Quaffle in mid-air.
"We’re going to lose like this," Regulus muttered, running a hand over his face as he whispered to Ginny.
Just as she opened her mouth to reply, she spotted the Golden Snitch glinting near the far edge of the pool. Harry noticed it at the exact same moment, and both of them accelerated, flying neck and neck in pursuit of the shimmering little ball.
They both stretched out their hands, shoving each other as much as they could to throw the other off, but the difference in experience was clear: Harry gave a sharp burst of speed and grabbed the Snitch.
"I got it!" he shouted, holding it aloft.
"Suck it, Tonks!" Sirius threw his arms up in celebration as Fred and Ron flew in circles. "Gryffindor wiping the floor with Hufflepuff and Slytherin!"
"Oh, Sirius, if this were a real match…"
"Your defeat would’ve been even more embarrassing," he cut in. "Gryffindor was always undefeated!"
Tonks made an annoyed noise and stuck her tongue out at him.
"Undefeated? Gryffindor lost the Cup to Slytherin in sixth year…" Regulus chimed in.
The scrutinising smile on Sirius’s face lingered, though he tilted his head dismissively.
"Nobody’s perfect."
"TIME TO EAT!"
Everyone turned towards the garden entrance, where a familiar figure appeared carrying a mountain of floating plates behind her.
Molly Weasley walked along the stone path, followed by what looked like a veritable army of serving dishes. The wonderful smell of roast meat, mashed potatoes and fruit pie took over the warm late-afternoon air, prompting a collective growl from empty stomachs. Arthur appeared right after her.
"What is this?" Penny squeaked, her voice jumping an octave.
"Dinner, of course! Harry deserves a proper birthday feast," Molly replied, as though it were obvious.
Penny’s already large eyes widened so much they looked ready to pop straight out of their sockets.
"Oh, shit…" Sirius dismounted his broom.
"PENNY COOKED ALL DAY FOR LITTLE MASTER POTTER!" the elf shrieked, beside herself.
Molly raised her eyebrows and took a step back.
"Well, I’m sure it was a lovely effort, dear, but—"
"EFFORT?!" Penny’s voice grew even shriller. "PENNY PREPARED A FULL BANQUET! PIES! ROASTS! PUDDINGS! PUMPKIN TARTS! PENNY ALREADY THREW A PARTY ALL BY HERSELF!!!"
"Well then, it’ll be a generous table! I really don’t see a problem with that," Molly gestured towards the dishes floating behind her.
"Penny does see a problem!" She pointed an accusing finger at Molly. "Penny is the cook of this house! Mrs Weasley cannot simply arrive here and replace Penny’s work!"
"How much do you want to bet on Mum?" Fred flew closer to George, murmuring behind his hand.
"Depends," George replied without taking his eyes off the argument. "That elf looks like she’s killed someone before."
Molly took a deep breath, trying to keep her composure, and forced a smile so fake she’d have been better off not bothering.
"Look, dear, I was only trying to help."
Penny pressed her lips together, folding her thin arms.
"Help?! Penny does not need help! Penny does everything on her own!"
"I’m only making sure Harry eats properly!"
"Penny’s food is worthy!"
"But I’m the mother of seven children, I know how to feed a large group!"
"Penny feeds three adults and two teenage boys! Penny knows how to cook for armies too!"
"Yes, but cooking for five is different from cooking for nine! There’s no need to go overboard—"
"MRS WEASLEY IS THE ONE GOING OVERBOARD!"
"THAT’S ENOUGH!" Sirius cut in, pressing his index finger and thumb to his temples. "Molly, I know you meant well. But this house already has someone who takes care of the kitchen!"
Molly pressed her lips together and let out an irritated hiss. Sirius turned to Penny, resting his hands on his knees as he crouched down to her level.
"Penny, I appreciate all the effort you put into Harry’s birthday, and we love your food. But we can have a bit of both. Besides, it’s your cooking Harry’s going to be eating for the rest of his life. There’s no need to be upset about this."
Penny grumbled, but soon agreed with a nod of her head.
Sirius resumed his smile and exchanged a look with Arthur, who was staring at his wife with a mix of shock and embarrassment.
"I’m only trying to make sure Harry is well looked after," Molly muttered, her tone accusatory.
Sirius had no desire whatsoever to argue. Not on his godson’s birthday. Not when everything had felt so light. But that lightness was quickly replaced by a sudden pull of gravity, and his gentle expression fractured into something sharp. His eyes were forged into cutting steel, his nose lifting immediately into his most insolent façade in the face of the matriarch’s insinuation.
"I know how to take care of him, Molly," he hissed, his jaw clenched so tightly he barely opened his mouth. "Harry is not your son."
Molly’s eyes flashed.
"He’s as good as," she shot back fiercely. "Who else does he have?"
What kind of bloody question was that?
Rage slammed into the core of Sirius, spreading its rotten roots through every cell of his body, every tremor in his hands, every thought in his mind. Arthur placed a hand on his wife’s shoulder, but Molly did not back down—nor did Sirius, whose body straightened as tension vibrated through his shoulders, his neck, his jaw. He didn’t blink. He scarcely seemed to breathe in the face of that acid question.
"He has me, Molly!" Sirius snarled, fists clenched. "He has me, and he always will!"
"He does," Molly agreed, her mouth tightening. "The problem is that it must’ve been rather difficult for you to look after him while you were locked away in Azkaban, wasn’t it?"
Sirius laughed and licked his lips, resisting every voice screaming at him to lash out at Mrs Weasley right there, in front of everyone. Above his smile, the look he fixed on Molly was sharpened with venom. His leg twitched, trying to step forward, but he mastered himself with effort, loosening the strings that fury had so easily pulled tight inside his mind.
"Alright, my dear. That’s enough," Arthur said, pulling Molly back towards him and breaking the eye contact between her and Sirius. "Harry deserves a special day, and we’re ruining it."
Sirius opened his mouth, ready to prolong the argument… but Arthur was right. So he said nothing, drawing in as much air as he could. For a moment, he’d forgotten entirely how to breathe, and feeling his lungs fill was enough to steady him.
He turned sideways to the kids, not looking at them.
"Put the brooms away and wash your hands. We’ll get everything ready for dinner." His order was obeyed at once.
Everyone hurried off, eager to finally escape the foul atmosphere that had settled over the garden.
Sirius remained frozen for a few seconds before moving abruptly and returning his broom to the pile beside the pool. Before he quite realised it, Penny was at his side, still sulking.
"Mr Black does not need Penny’s food to take care of Harry," she murmured with such sincerity that Sirius blinked, caught off guard.
A half-smile tugged at the corner of his mouth and he nodded.
"I know, Penny."
For some reason, his gaze drifted towards the garden entrance, searching for a comfort he knew he wouldn’t find. He placed a hand over his chest, hoping to feel the familiar tug of Scarlett’s presence there… but there was only the wide, aching, uncomfortable nothing.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 81: Why can’t we forget
Chapter Text
CXIX
“Oh, for fuck’s sake.” Luana huffed, folding her arms across her chest. “My day was going so well.”
Fred smiled maliciously.
“Believe me, Teixeira, I wasn’t expecting to have the displeasure of seeing you today either.”
“Don’t worry.” Victoria said with an irritating calm, her white hair pinned up in a braided bun straight out of the previous century. “Your table is far enough apart that there’s no risk of you accidentally kissing.”
Fred made a sound of disgust, and Luana shot her friend an exasperated look. Her loud, intense nature stood in sharp contrast to the elegance and presumption so commonly displayed by Victoria, whose eyes shifted colour as she sat down beside Regulus.
On the other side of the table, Remus and Sirius transfigured a chair to make it five times larger so Hagrid—who had just landed in the empty stretch of the garden on Sirius’s old motorbike—could sit comfortably.
Sirius, seated beside Andromeda, had barely noticed Victoria and Luana arriving minutes before dinner was served. He kept stuffing his mouth with more and more food just to avoid engaging in the conversations and laughter around him.
To be honest, Sirius was completely oblivious to everything happening around him. His body might have been there, but his mind was elsewhere.
“I didn’t think you’d want a…” Andromeda drew his attention, savouring her elf-made wine. Sirius slowly turned his gaze to her, lifting just one eyebrow in a silent question. “A house-elf.”
“She isn’t mine,” Sirius murmured, wiping his beard with a napkin. “She belonged to Reg, and he freed her.”
“He freed her?!” She parted her lips in surprise. “Yes. That does sound exactly like him.” She let out a pleasant laugh, looking at Regulus a few seats away. “His mother would be tearing her hair out if she knew what her grandson is like. He reminds me of you as a teenager.”
Sirius sniffed, attempting a laugh. He failed. Not that he cared—because the only thing that mattered in that moment was Harry, and the way his green eyes—vivid, cheerful, and kind, just like Lily’s—overflowed with a sparkling enthusiasm so intense it even affected Regulus. That carefree smile showed his success, even if only for a moment, in setting aside the anger he felt towards his mother.
“He looks like my little brother.”
Andromeda clicked her tongue twice, dismissing the remark.
“He looks like you, Sirius.” She pierced him with those sharp brown eyes. “The way he carries himself, the way he talks, even the way he eats. You might’ve been apart for twelve years, but he’s you, plain as day.”
Sirius let the air escape his lungs and slowly shook his head in denial.
“Where are you going with this, Dromeda?” He meticulously lined the cutlery up on his plate, silver facing brown.
“It’s curious, Sirius… the amount of time your ex-fiancée was pregnant…”
“She was forced to drink a potion to accelerate the pregnancy.” Sirius cut her off sharply. “I’ve already done what you’re doing, Andromeda. And Reg…” His gaze drifted across the table before returning to scrutinise his cousin. He opened his mouth to continue, but was interrupted by a sharp kick to the shin from Nymphadora across from him.
“Who’s the third adult?” The question was asked so casually that Sirius blinked a few times as it sank in.
“What?!” He frowned, watching Nymphadora’s purple hair slide into a bubblegum pink.
“Penny said she cooked for three adults. You, Remus and…?” She narrowed her eyes, their colour shifting from green to caramel.
“Sometimes Nate comes by for lunch…” Remus slipped into the conversation, answering so disingenuously that Sirius stared at him, still speechless.
“Nate?! Orfy’s uncle?!” Nymphadora let out an awkward little laugh.
“Yeah. My ex-husband.” Remus’s explanation didn’t seem to please her in the slightest, because the restless smile on her lips vanished at once.
“Oh…” Tonks murmured, trying to spear her single pea with her fork.
Dinner went on without many incidents, except for Fred and George sprinkling powdered pepper into Ron’s pie, which caused an immediate allergic reaction and forced Mrs Weasley to dig into her emergency potion collection while the poor sod choked.
While Arthur was telling off the twins, Sirius rose from his seat and checked that Reg was alright, then leaned down towards Harry, resting a hand on his shoulder.
“You alright?” he murmured. The garden lights reflected off the boy’s round glasses, hiding the green of his eyes and making him look exactly like James.
Sirius felt the dinner burn in his stomach.
“Yeah.” Harry looked up at him, the likeness to his best friend woven together with Lily’s mannerisms.
The burning threatened to erupt. Sirius cleared his throat.
“Shall we sing happy birthday, then?”
Harry’s gaze drifted around the garden. It lingered far too long on the entrance.
“Can we wait a little longer?” he murmured, without looking at him.
Sirius swallowed hard.
“I don’t think Scar’s going to show up, Harry.” He gently ruffled his godson’s perpetually messy hair. He wasn’t sure whether he was trying to comfort Harry or himself.
“She said she would.” Harry’s voice barely came out.
His wounded tone was the missing ingredient in the cauldron corroding Sirius’s stomach.
He had already grown used to Scarlett’s disappointments and, although he wanted to spare Harry the same pain, he knew it was something beyond his control.
Sirius let out a long sigh. He had hoped Scarlett would show up too.
“I know, but… maybe… maybe it’s better this way.”
Harry pressed his lips into a thin line, his gaze drifting over everyone at the table before returning to Sirius.
“Alright, then.” He shrugged with resignation. Sirius frowned, taken aback. “We can sing happy birthday.”
Why wasn’t Harry angry with Scarlett? Of course, it wasn’t that Sirius wanted him to be, but… he should have been.
Shouldn’t he?
At the very least, as upset as he and Reg were.
Harry, however, went back to chatting animatedly with Hermione and Ginny, laughing alongside Ron when the Weasley twins were grounded and forbidden from producing anything related to Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes (whatever the hell that meant).
Sirius couldn’t stop a distracted smile from spreading across his face. He looked at Regulus and watched him laugh carefree with Victoria at some joke Luana had told.
He smoothed the bitterness from his expression and waited for Molly and Penny to bring out the cakes. They were placed side by side, each with fourteen candles flickering in the gentle summer breeze.
One of them was perfectly decorated with three layers, covered in icing sprinkled with golden decorations and a neat cursive “Happy Birthday, Harry.” Clearly Molly’s.
The one Penny had made was a chocolate volcano with caramel topping, candles scattered around the centre that spat smoke every so often, on the verge of erupting.
Harry looked from one cake to the other. Reg leaned in beside him, grey-blue eyes drinking in the warm yellow glow the candles cast over his pale face.
“Well, you’ve got two cakes…” He rested his elbows on the table. “Which means you get to make two wishes.”
“Lucky you, Harry.” Fred nudged him with an elbow and shot George an indignant look. “George and I only get one cake on our birthday.”
“And that’s already too much, according to Mum,” George added dryly.
Molly shot them a murderous look, silencing them instantly. Tonks started the birthday song and was joined by Andromeda, Ted and Hermione until everyone joined the chorus.
When he lay on the makeshift bed in the cupboard under the stairs, Harry Potter used to torture himself imagining what it would be like to have a birthday. But to have a birthday, you needed a real family—people who cared about him and wanted to see him happy. It was stupid and something that would never happen, and yet… it could be real.
Especially in the mind of a dreamy ten-year-old boy, whose only comfort was his fertile imagination.
Power and being were very distant things to him. The former, he didn’t have. And the latter, he was an orphan. Which meant turning power and being into stepping stones that would lead him to reality was something utterly unreal.
That was why… Harry didn’t know what to do. Everyone smiled and sang an ode to yet another year of his life. His gaze wandered across the faces of his friends, his family, of everyone he held dear. What was he supposed to do while they sang? Smile? Sing along? Clap? He had never reached that part before, not even in his daydreams.
It was strange to be the birthday boy. It was bizarre to see that so many people liked him, even if they didn’t share a single drop of blood. It was unexpected… that feeling rising in his chest, strengthening the pounding of his heart and sending shivers down his spine.
Two tattooed, warm hands settled on his shoulders. Harry glanced sideways at Sirius behind him, his long black hair tied back, though a few strands escaped the bun, framing his godfather’s handsome face.
“Happy birthday, Harry. Lily and James would be very proud of you,” he whispered. “Just as I am.”
Harry adjusted his glasses in an attempt to hide his tears. His heart hammered in his ears, his tendons, the tips of his fingers. He looked at the flickering candles: twenty-eight in total, counting both cakes.
What more could he possibly wish for? He hadn’t needed any candle for one of his greatest wishes to come true and, unfortunately, his next fantasy could never become reality. It was impossible to bring the dead back to life.
That night, Harry James Potter contented himself with having fulfilled one of his two wishes, but he blew out the twenty-eight candles on both cakes hoping that, somehow, his parents might personally tell him how proud they were.
A selfish, impossible and feverish wish—one Harry was ashamed of—so he tucked it away in the deepest part of his heart, where the utopian scenarios his mind liked to weave were kept.
Applause echoed through the garden. He received congratulations from everyone. Hagrid, in particular, slapped him so hard on the back that Harry lost his breath and choked.
“Now… to what really matters.” Fred threw an arm around Harry’s shoulders.
“Cake!” George offered him an enormous knife that definitely wasn’t meant for that.
“No! Penny’s cutting the cake!” The elf snatched the knife from the twin, and Molly furrowed her brows, brandishing her own cake-slicing weapon.
“Hm, I’ll cut my cake and you cut yours… let’s see who cuts better…” the Weasley matriarch grumbled.
Sirius rolled his eyes, then rubbed them hard.
“I’m far too sober for this shit…”
Harry simply laughed, catching his godfather’s attention and making him smile too.
“What’s so funny?” Sirius pulled his cigarette case from his pocket.
“Dunno.” He shook his head. “I’m happy.”
That was the purest truth. For the first time in his life, Harry felt completely happy.
.
.
.
After the presents had been opened and an extremely unhealthy competition between Luana and Fred over who could handle sampling the largest amount of sweets from Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes without being sick (which Sirius discovered was the prank business the twins were planning—something utterly brilliant in his humble opinion), Hagrid took Buckbeak away with the saddle strapped to the handlebars of the BSA Lightning that had once belonged to Sirius.
Soon the parents began to leave. Hermione’s were the first, though they stayed for a good half hour chatting with Remus, Arthur and Molly. Victoria’s parents came next, practically ordering Sirius to come have dinner with Reggie and Harry at their house. Andromeda and Ted left soon after, leaving a rather giggly Nymphadora beside a visibly uncomfortable Remus.
It was nearly nine o’clock by the time Arthur and Molly departed with Tonks, so Sirius, Remus and Penny busied themselves tidying up the garden. Harry and Regulus were inspecting the presents; Harry’s favourite so far was the strange lamp he had only ever seen advertised in furniture catalogues.
“It’s a lava lamp, Harry,” Regulus explained, pulling the extension lead plugged into the house to switch it on in the garden.
In an instant, the red liquid inside formed glowing blobs, slowly rising and falling.
“Bloody hell… that’s wicked…” he breathed, wide-eyed and mesmerised.
“I had a green and black one in my room…” Reggie watched the placid movement of the blobs. “But I broke it by accident.”
Harry let out a small laugh.
“You broke it? Not even a Reparo would work?!”
“Ah, I didn’t even think of that at the time…”
Harry picked up Fred and George’s package. Written on the wrapping was: Special Surprise for Harry.
Regulus’s dark eyebrows drew together in suspicion.
“Dodgy,” he murmured, stroking the faint stubble on his chin.
Harry nodded, frowning.
“Definitely.” He opened the packet, stuffed with colourful sweets. “What d’you reckon they do?”
“Well… we saw a sample of the Weasleys’ inventions earlier…” Reg tilted his head. “But I doubt they’d give you sweets that make you burp frogs or stick your hair straight up.”
“God, Luana’s hair all standing on end, like she’d been electrocuted…” Harry’s chuckle turned into full-on laughter, and Reggie joined in. “I thought she was going to murder Fred.”
“Yeah, she would. Just not how you’re imagining.” Regulus stuck his hand into the packet and tossed a sweet into the air, catching it in his mouth. His face twisted—first into a grimace, then relaxed as he nodded. “The taste isn’t even that bad…” He stopped speaking immediately.
“The taste might not be bad, but your voice…” Harry nearly choked with laughter.
“Five points from Gryffindor, Mr Potter!” Regulus elbowed him, grinning, the sweet he’d eaten turning his voice identical to McGonagall’s. “And a year of detention!”
Harry picked up a sweet and chewed it, cleared his throat theatrically and raised his index finger with careless flair.
“Test… test…” He pressed his lips together to suppress a nasal laugh. “Minerva, don’t be so severe! Mr Potter has saved Hogwarts from unimaginable dangers! Therefore, one hundred points to Gryffindor!”
Regulus threw his head back, completely out of breath from laughing. He nearly fell off the bench.
“That’s so spot on…” He struggled to breathe, still speaking in the Deputy Headmistress’s voice. “That’s right, Albus… you’re quite right. Another three hundred points to Gryffindor.” He pretended to adjust imaginary spectacles just like Minerva did.
“I’m rarely wrong… Minerva.” Harry gave him a wink, stroking his non-existent beard.
“What the fuck is going on here?!” Sirius was standing behind them, organising a stack of chairs with a Wingardium Leviosa.
“Weasley present,” Harry explained.
“That does not concern you, Mr Black. Less talking and more work!” Regulus gestured around the garden with disdainful authority.
Sirius pressed his lips into a smile, then looked upwards as he pretended to adopt a stern expression.
“Easy there, Minnie!” He raised his arms in surrender. “Bloody hell, you lot sound exactly like them…”
“Minnie? You’ve called McGonagall that?!” Harry’s eyes widened, still with Dumbledore’s voice.
“Course I have.” Sirius sniffed, smug. “Loads of times.”
“And what did she do?” Reg grabbed one of the Exploding Bonbons Harry had received from Ron and Ginny and shoved the whole thing into his mouth; his voice had already returned to normal.
“Gave me detention. Took points from Gryffindor…” Sirius’s gaze drifted over the presents scattered across the bench. “Your dad… used to get so pissed off when I did that…” His dimples showed as his lips stretched, even his teeth appearing.
Harry wanted to keep going, wanted to ask about James, wanted to share with Sirius the longing he felt for a father he’d never truly known—but Reggie cut the moment short by tossing a package into his lap.
“Open Victoria’s present!”
A single glance from Harry at Regulus was enough for Sirius to go back to organising chairs and tables around the garden. Harry tried to call him, but changed his mind when he noticed the melancholy slipping into the scattered shadows of his godfather’s expression.
“New Quidditch gloves…” Harry said, with less enthusiasm than he should have had.
“You’ll need them when you lose to me next school year…” Reg commented with a smug smile.
His response was to roll his eyes, though he was clearly enjoying the provocation. He picked up the next present—Luana’s: a pair of flip-flops from a brand called Havaianas (which, for some reason, was Brazilian and not Hawaiian) and a self-writing quill with a small note attached:
“Dear Harry, I hope this quill helps you with your essays this school year. Even though it’s part of the endless list of items forbidden by Filch and the Ministry of Magic, no one will ever notice it’s different—after all, it’s only a crime if someone finds out. The quill is activated by the spell listed on the back of the box.”
“Why this quill—”
Harry shut his mouth as soon as they heard a sound coming from the garden entrance. Sirius, levitating the tables with his wand, froze like a statue, even though the spell broke and sent them crashing down with a bang. His neck seemed to turn to stone, so he moved his face as much as he could to the side and glanced, out of the corner of his eye, at that bloody stretch paved with fitted stones and flanked by two bushes trimmed into circular shapes.
Sirius pressed a hand to his chest with the familiar sensation of being shot right there.
“Of course… of course you knocked over the bloody present, Scarlett…”
Her bleached hair was loose, as usual. Her eyes were hidden behind red-framed, rectangular mirrored sunglasses. Her lips were stretched tight from ear to ear. Her body was clad in a leather waistcoat studded with spikes on the shoulders, a Black Sabbath T-shirt with sleeves reaching her elbows, a short skirt, fishnet tights and battered leather boots. In her arms, she carried an enormous present wrapped in floral pink paper, unmistakably shaped like a bicycle.
“HAPPY BIRTHDAY, HARRY!” Scarlett shouted, staggering forward as she let go of the present. It toppled onto its side with a crash.
“Scar!” Harry leapt up from the bench and ran to hug her.
.
.
.
Scarlett was supposed to be sober. In truth, she had tried to be sober. But everything hurt. Her body hurt, her head hurt, her core hurt. She didn’t know whether it was longing, guilt or regret. So, to avoid it all like a proper coward, she kept drinking in amounts she personally considered quite safe (a bottle of wine in the morning, a shot of brandy after lunch, and only five glasses of firewhisky or similar spirits before bed), certain she would make it to Harry’s birthday without any major incidents.
She bought the bicycle, had it wrapped, stuffed it into the boot of a taxi (after all, she wasn’t about to risk Sirius giving her another lecture about drunk driving), and threw herself into the back seat of the car. The city lights flashed across her pallid face in ever-faster bursts after she offered a hundred pounds if the driver would drop her off on Saltoun Street, number fourteen, before ten o’clock that night.
Her gaze lifted to the rear-view mirror, blue eyes locking onto the stranger staring back at her. Smudged make-up, fine lines sharpened by the neon shadows the city cast across her face, and the purple bruise spreading beneath her right eye.
She touched it with a trembling finger, wrinkled her nose, then covered her face with her hands.
She didn’t know exactly how she’d gotten the bruise.
She’d drunk too much, as always. Her mind had been reduced to a sequence of warped flashes: unsettling laughter, the heavy stink of cigarettes, hands where they shouldn’t have been. The bitter taste of bile creeping up her throat.
Scarlett massaged her temple, pushed the fragments from her mind as she exhaled through her mouth, then pulled her sunglasses from her bag and slid them onto her face. The dark lenses covered the bruise perfectly.
She caught one of the driver’s occasional glances through the mirror—a balding, middle-aged man with unshaven stubble. She turned to the window, watching the mirrored buildings give way to the houses of the city’s affluent district. Shadows sprawled across the asphalt, folded over the fading lights, and made Scarlett’s heart skip a few beats.
She didn’t want to think, yet the tightness in her chest was irrational. She checked the time on her pocket watch… that stupid watch where a tiny Sirius stuck his tongue out at her incessantly. Her eyes threatened to spill sudden tears.
Scarlett didn’t allow it. She buried the urge to cry the way one buries a putrid, worm-ridden corpse deep in dense, barren earth—so it wouldn’t take root, nor allow even the faintest trace of life to grow.
It was easy to do when she was drunk. Feelings were different in that state, easily drowned in the tide of disinhibition and numbness.
The party might not have been over yet, but it wasn’t as though she could walk straight into the middle of it. She was seven feet underground to most of the guests, and to the rest… the ones who knew she was alive…
They wanted to kill her, like Orfy. Or hurt her, like Remus. Or argue, like Reggie. Or… simply cast a steel-hard look that would make her regret every choice she’d ever made, right or wrong… like Sirius.
Seeing them would only remind her of what she could never have. Which, in turn, would remind her of the engulfing guilt she carried. Or make it worse. She shuddered at the thought of her ghosts. Reminders were unnecessary—she lived with them every day.
And it wasn’t as though she’d lost much anyway, because, frankly, Tonks was probably all over Sirius the entire bloody party, and Scarlett… well, she had no desire whatsoever to witness that again, thank you very much.
There was already far too much going on with her. Sirius and Tonks was the final nail in her coffin.
“We’re here.” The driver looked at her through the rear-view mirror.
Scarlett blinked slowly, orienting herself. She hadn’t noticed the car stopping until that moment. She opened the taxi door. Her eyes wandered over the house in front of her, the familiar façade bringing an unexpected sense of belonging and exile to the surface all at once.
She turned her face slowly towards the driver and rubbed her left eye with the back of her hand. Her fingers slid down her prominent cheekbones and she forced an empty smile. She opened her bag, fished out a few notes with unsteady fingers and handed them to him.
The driver raised his eyebrows.
“M-miss, this… this is far too—”
Scarlett didn’t hear him. She was too preoccupied with getting out of the car, walking around to the boot, and facing Harry’s present.
Why the fuck had she bought a bicycle? She could’ve bought something far simpler, like a top-of-the-line video game, roller skates, or hell, a LEGO set. Something she could carry easily in her numbed state.
“Fuck.” she muttered, taking a deep breath. She dragged the parcel out with difficulty, the weight of the present seeming determined to tip her forwards and steal her balance.
“Are you sure you can carry that on your own?” the driver leaned his head out of the window.
Scarlett’s forced smile this time showed teeth, sharp with biting irony.
“I am. It’s not the heaviest thing I carry.” She laughed, hugging the bike to herself as she headed for the side entrance of the house without even saying goodbye.
Those unsteady steps across the garden path took so long that Scarlett was genuinely tired of walking. It felt like an eternity before she tripped over a stupid shrub and sent the bike crashing to the ground with a clatter.
“Of course… of course you dropped the bloody present, Scarlett…” she grumbled as she picked it up, the familiar stab piercing her heart with the exact sensation of a hook catching it and yanking it violently towards that man with starry eyes.
She lifted the bike and pushed on. She squeezed her eyes shut against the number of lights lit in the garden, dancing in her vision like a dizzying kaleidoscope, until her irises finally focused on the birthday boy.
“HAPPY BIRTHDAY, HARRY!” She stretched out her arms, completely forgetting about the bike.
“Scar!”
A hug. Scarlett held Harry so tightly in her arms that she was close to suffocating him, but she didn’t care. She buried her face in his messy, James-like hair and dodged the longing for her ghosts.
Two weeks of drinking had freed her from them.
It was strange not to have them with her, and at the same time, it was good.
It was good to feel normal… even if only for two weeks.
What happened to them when she drank that much?
“I missed you, kid,” Scarlett whispered into her godson’s dark hair, his response a little laugh reverberating through her ribcage.
“I missed you too…” Harry was smiling in a way Scarlett had never seen before.
It was that same smile from when James—
No. She wasn’t doing this now.
She’d have plenty of time to torture herself later.
“Why don’t you open your present?!” she suggested, pulling away from Harry and giving him a light tap on the shoulder. “Bloody hell, did you grow in those two weeks or what?!”
“I grew?!” Harry tore into the wrapping with such innocent delight that Scarlett allowed herself—just for a few seconds—to enjoy it too.
She limited herself to witnessing Harry’s joy, even while feeling Sirius’s and Regulus’s scrutinising gazes on her. She didn’t know what to say, nor what to do, so she simply hugged herself and feigned a smile when Harry showed them the bike.
Scarlett followed her godson through the garden, but kept a slower pace, torn between drawing closer or leaving. With every step she took, she moved further from the exit and her heart beat faster in her chest.
“Hi, Reg. Sirius.” Scarlett greeted them, trying to sound as confident as possible. “How… was the party?”
Regulus straightened on the bench, ready to leave. Sirius placed a hand on his shoulder and he stayed put, staring at her with those icy eyes. The blue swallowed the grey of his irises and turned every emotion into pure revolt, made manifest by his knitted brows and flared nostrils.
“It was great,” Sirius answered, his voice measured and impassive. “There’s still cake. Want some?”
In the background, Remus froze when he saw her. Penny did too.
Scarlett and Sirius didn’t even exchange a look. Even so, she could feel the furious pounding of his heart resonating in the same rhythm as her own through the atrocious connection they shared.
“No… I’m not hungry. Thanks.” She swallowed hard, rubbing the back of her left hand where the Ouroboros was hidden by a charm.
Regulus looked away, towards Harry and the bike. He clenched his fists, twisting his mouth.
“That’s wicked!” Harry said, his cheeks flushed and smiling. “But… I don’t know… um, I don’t know how to ride a bike.”
Scarlett looked at Harry. Of course he didn’t. Merlin, Scarlett, what the hell had you been thinking these past twenty-four hours?
“You don’t?” she murmured, gripping the handlebars of the red-and-gold bike. “I… I can teach you.”
“Really?!”
“Of course. It’s instinctive. Once your body understands balance… you’ll never—”
“Scarlett, can I have a word with you?” Sirius cut in sharply.
She made the mistake of looking at him. She was pierced by the aggressive steel of his starry eyes. She opened her mouth to fire back a sharp reply, but all that left her lips was a shaky breath.
Sirius’s look tore her apart, pulverising every word that had formed in her mind. For the first time in a very long while, he didn’t look angry. He looked exhausted. Tired of fighting her and, above all, disappointed.
Scarlett’s reaction was a subtle nod. He gestured for her to follow, and the house seemed to draw closer at a speed far greater than normal.
The mild garden breeze was replaced by the air conditioning indoors, and the freshness of the grass mixed with the chlorine scent from the pool became an enigmatic, undefined smell that made the hairs on the back of her neck prickle.
She felt that this was her home, yet she also felt like an intruder. It should have been her home, it should have been her life and her future, and yet… it wasn’t.
She had lost fifteen years, and all she could do was watch the crumbs slip through the corners of her fingers while she tried to piece together shards and splinters of something she would never manage to assemble.
She took a deep breath, bracing herself to hear yet another of Sirius’s lectures about alcoholism, as though he were her bloody father. Sirius, however, walked into his bedroom, waited for her to step inside, and closed the door gently, still wearing that imperturbable façade—though she knew perfectly well his nerves were frayed to the bone.
Scarlett knew him. She knew the effect she had on him. She knew how she could awaken rage and affection at the same speed in the heart of the man who was her downfall.
Sirius said nothing. He wasn’t even sure what he was doing either.
Scarlett was the first to turn her face, taking him in through the dark lenses of her sunglasses at the exact moment he looked at her.
“I’m just living my fucking dream,” she finally said, bringing light to the twilight silence between them. “And it’s a bit hard… living my dream sober.” The corner of Scarlett’s mouth twisted. Sirius couldn’t tell if it was a smile or a grimace of pain. Maybe both. “I’m a fucked-up, headcase murderer who can’t live with her own consequences, let alone take care of two children… I should’ve died…”
Sirius didn’t soften his expression. On the contrary, he let out a sharp, biting laugh as his teeth ground together.
“Welcome to my life, Scarlett, because that’s exactly what happened to me when you were locked up and left me with Reg!” he exploded, grabbing a bottle from the bedside table. “And you’re not dead, so pull yourself together, drink this shit, get sober, and pretend you’re fucking loving Harry’s birthday!” He huffed, angrily throwing his unruly hair back.
It wasn’t a plea. It was an order.
Scarlett tried, but she couldn’t stop her body from flinching at every word he hurled at her. She desperately wanted to give up drinking the way Sirius had years ago, when he’d taken care of Reggie—but Scarlett wasn’t him. She didn’t have the same motivations he did.
In truth, she had no motivation at all.
She took the potion, head bowed, avoiding eye contact at all costs. The lenses of her sunglasses weren’t enough to filter the raw, flayed layers of her heart.
[Radiohead — Planet Telex]
“I feel that…” Her lips betrayed her when Sirius made to leave. He froze like a statue, petrified by her—by what she wanted to say. His face turned towards the door, but his eyes fixed on her. Sirius’s mere attention was enough to dissolve her defences and melt her inhibition. “I feel like I’m a ghost haunting the people I love. Wandering… looking for a cemetery. A grave. For… for a place… where I can finally find peace.”
Sirius sighed and swallowed the frustrated sound clawing at his throat. He opened the door, took a step outside, then stopped with his back to her. He couldn’t bear to look at her.
Her eyes were far too dangerous. Far too honest. Far too full of longing.
“Peace isn’t a place, Scarlett. It’s a state of mind.” Sirius turned slightly to the side and hid behind his eyelids as he closed his eyes. “And there’s nowhere in this world where you’ll find it except inside yourself.”
you can force it but it will not come
you can taste it but it will not form.
Scarlett wanted to say that was bullshit. That inner peace didn’t exist—that it was just some hippie invention, or whatever Asian religion had cooked up that stupid concept to con idiots out of their money.
Inner peace.
What rubbish!
you can crush it but it's always here
you can crush it but it's always near
chasing you home
That was why she drank. Because if that shit were real, she wouldn’t need to get drunk.
And also because… she felt trapped inside herself. Trapped in her trauma, in her emptiness.
Scarlett rubbed her eyes with her knuckles, exhausted. She let the air escape her lungs and downed the potion in one gulp.
everything is
The effect was immediate.
Being drunk was like sinking into a warm, comforting lake. She felt light, soft; words barely reached her and her demons couldn’t touch her. And being sober… being sober was fucking awful.
broken
everyone is
The surface rushed up violently. Scarlett was torn from her comfortable stupor. She staggered desperately into the bathroom and vomited until her stomach was completely empty.
broken.
Even so, she retched on, choking and gasping as her stomach convulsed involuntarily. Her body twisted, her skin prickling as if she’d just stepped from somewhere unbearably hot into somewhere freezing cold. She shuddered, reality crushing down on her shoulders, gravity weighing on her body, anxiety gnawing away at her sanity. She blinked, stunned and disoriented by the potion’s immediate effect.
It was as if the world were spinning backwards, as if Scarlett herself were an anomaly—unnatural.
you can walk it home straight from school
you can kiss it you can break all the rules
She was used to being on her knees in front of a toilet, vomiting—but this time it was different. First, the bathroom was impeccably clean. Second, there was no bottle in one of her hands. Third, everything she’d been forcing herself to forget was flooding back into her chest with a gurgling fury.
Sobriety was synonymous with longing. With pain. With remorse and guilt. And those sensations fought so viciously within her core that all she could do was curl up on the bathroom floor, her body trembling, her eyes battling the tears that threatened to spill.
No. It was Harry’s birthday. She couldn’t cry. She wouldn’t allow herself to—
“Scar? Are you alright?” The question slammed into her body in a wave of shame and fear.
Everything is broken
It was instinctive. Her troubled eyes fell upon the kindest hazel irises she had ever known. James sat down beside her, hugging his knees in the same way she was, his face—forever untouched by time—now edged with tenderness.
James Potter was one in a million. Always kind. Always understanding. Even when his wife was breathing fire, even when he wanted to wring his best friend’s brother’s neck with his own hands until he spat out every bloody secret he kept.
He reached out, pretending to drape his arm around Scarlett’s shoulders. She was in that catatonic state he knew so well, trapped in that hellish, self-destructive place inside herself.
“Today… today is…”
“I know,” James cut her off, though not harshly. He took his glasses off and rubbed at one eye, fixing them on Scarlett without judgement or accusation.
Something very strange bloomed in her heart—something only a very small number of people were ever able to reach.
Everyone is, everyone is broken
Comfort.
“I’m trying, but… they all hate me and…” Scarlett faltered, her voice breaking, her shoulders shaking as a sob she didn’t want to feed took hold of her anyway.
“They don’t hate you.” James brushed away one of her tears, watching it pass straight through his hand and fall onto the tiled floor.
“Even Reg hates me, Jamie… you… what he said to me…” She choked between sobs.
“Every teenager says they hate their parent, Scar. You’ve been one—you know what I’m talking about…” James sniffed out a small laugh.
“It’s different! And… and Sirius… and Remus…”
“Scar… look at me.” He demanded, shifting on the floor to face her fully, hazel eyes brimming with conviction. “It’s Harry’s birthday. Fuck Padfoot and Moony—you’re here because of him!”
Scarlett rubbed her eyes and wiped her nose with the back of her hand.
“F-fuck Sirius and Remus?” she repeated, frowning.
“Yeah. You care far too much about what they think of you.”
Scarlett shook her head and pressed her lips together.
“Do you hate me?” The question came out trembling.
James let out a sharp breath, as if the idea were ridiculous.
“Of course not. You’re my best friend.”
“Not even after… after two weeks…” Scarlett’s mouth kept moving, though her voice vanished halfway through the sentence.
Why can’t you forget?
James lifted his face and took a deep breath, thin lips touched with a smile that made Scarlett’s chest cave in. He slowly turned his face towards her, dark lashes framing a look full of complicity.
why can’t we forget?
“Aren’t friends for that?” He touched her face, ghostly fingers brushing her tear-soaked cheeks. “To forgive us and give us a chance to be better people?”
The urge to cry was driven away by James’s presence. Scarlett wanted to say yes, even as she wondered whether she was a friend to Sirius and Remus.
She hoped so.
why can’t you forget?
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 82: Why can't we give love that one more chance?
Chapter Text
CL
[Queen — Under Pressure (Part. David Bowie)]
Scarlett stopped in the middle of the garden, ignoring Harry and Reg’s puzzled looks, Sirius’s furrowed brow, and Remus scratching the back of his neck. No. Her eyes were fixed on James walking backwards, facing her, his feet moving in time with the music.
"You’re not coming?" James asked, placing his hands behind his back.
She shook her head, her heart hammering in her chest as she tried to ignore everyone else’s opinion of her.
"Fuck it," she murmured, closed her eyes, and surrendered to the music, snapping her fingers to the steady beat that governed the song. "Fuck it."
She walked past Lily and Regulus. Remus and Sirius.
She cracked her neck and took a deep breath, approaching James with hesitant steps. The yellowish garden lights rippled across the surface of the pool, slid over the dark lenses of her glasses, brushed her hands as she lifted them and moved her fingers in an attempt to touch the stars above her, even though she couldn’t see them.
She rolled her shoulders, letting her hips follow the flow, the tension that usually stiffened her neck easing to make room for the movement of her head, swaying from side to side as she ignored everything around her except the music and James keeping pace with her.
Scarlett opened her eyes, the groove controlling her body as it slid sideways, slowly, towards Reg and Harry. Both exchanged confused, shy looks. She stretched out her arms, and before Reggie could voice an opinion, her hand grabbed him along with Harry and pulled them into the middle of the garden.
"I don’t want to dance…" Regulus grumbled.
Scarlett ignored him, forcing him into a spin before tugging him back towards her, drawing an involuntary smile from her son.
"Who’s singing?" Harry asked, holding his glasses with one hand, because the other was intertwined with Scarlett’s. She made him spin twice before slinging an arm around his shoulders and pulling him into a tight hug, hearing James’s laughter right beside them.
"Freddie and Bowie," Scarlett replied, dragging Reggie into the embrace. "I’ve missed you so much."
Her son’s black hair smelled very much like Sirius’s, though it leaned more towards fresh notes than his father’s sweeter ones. The way he shrank into her arms in embarrassment and the face he pulled were her own traits passed down. Scarlett smiled at Reggie’s adorable reaction and shifted her attention to Harry, breathing in his eternally messy hair as its floral scent curled through her mind.
Harry and Reggie were the only good thing that cursed war had given her. It had taken far more than it had given, yes, but Scarlett was grateful to have them there, in her arms, even if forcibly.
"Mum… you’re going to suffocate us like this," Regulus muttered against her leather waistcoat.
"I love you." Scarlett ignored him once again, kissing each of their foreheads. "I’m sorry I left. I won’t do that anymore, I promise."
She gave them neither time nor room to react. She stepped away from both of them as she surrendered to the music, her body synchronised with the rising drumbeats and the surrounding lights casting five shadows of herself, all following the disordered, untethered choreography that reverberated through her body… until another shadow crossed hers, tall and slender, enveloping her with elegant, graceful steps.
Scarlett spun and collided with Sirius, whose arms caught her, knowing exactly that she would crash into him. She lifted her head just enough for their eyes to meet, even with her dark lenses in the way.
Her heart roared in her chest when Sirius fitted his palm to the small of her back, but he didn’t move. She was sweaty and breathless; he, warm and calm. Her entire body prickled with the hungry barbs his tattooed, warm hand infused into her skin. She plunged into those endless silver wells, into the graphite filaments of his pleading irises, into the gentleness only a remorseful lover could show.
Scarlett Gaunt wanted to say again all the things she had already said, but she didn’t need to. Her words were circling Sirius’s dilated pupils, creeping beneath his tattooed skin, buzzing through his veins. The heavy silence left by the end of the song was made for them. It was in the absence of words that she could show the immense space in her heart that would always belong to Sirius. Even if she fell in love with other people, even if she lived a thousand lives, even if she were never again capable of loving.
Insanity laughs, under pressure we're breaking
Can't we give ourselves one more chance
Why can't we give love that one more chance
Why can't we give love?
There would always be a space in Scarlett Gaunt’s heart that belonged only to Sirius Black.
Sirius knew that. Sirius had always known that. He was a thief of hearts, but he had failed to foresee that a girl with flowers in her hair would be his undoing. He wanted to believe that Scarlett was his soulmate, that they were meant to be together, that fate wanted so badly to make sure they stayed together that they even had a stupid pact, but… the truth was that…
'Cause love's such an old fashioned word
And love dares you to care for
The people on the edge of the night
And loves dares you to change our way of
Soulmates do not exist. Not in the way people think. They are not found by chance, not woven by three witches and a loom, nor defined even before they are born. If there is anything like soulmates, they are made. Honed. Built over time when two people are determined to be together.
Sirius wanted to build that with Scarlett. He wanted to grab the bloody threads of fate and stitch the inaccessible, murky future himself. He wanted Scarlett to be his soulmate because that was what he wished, because that was what they worked for, because that was how they made their fucking relationship work.
Love alone was not enough, but Sirius loved Scarlett with such intensity, such devotion and compulsion that he would make it enough. He would smother every poisonous thought of being comforted only by the person who hurt him and would make love save them from their crimes, their sins, and their fate.
Caring about ourselves
This is our last dance
This is our last dance
This is ourselves
Love was salvation.
It had to be.
Under pressure
Pressure
Sirius lifted his free hand to Scarlett’s face, hooking his finger into the strap of the stupid glasses she was wearing.
Why was she still wearing that crap?!
Scarlett shoved him before he could remove them. She raised her defences again as she straightened and stepped back, one step at a time. It was very hard to pull away from him. Sirius understood. It was laborious to resist the unconscious pull that surrounded them, fed by the pact and strengthened by their stubborn hearts.
The music ended. The stares ended too.
Sirius did not move. He was too numb from Scarlett’s closeness, from the adverse effects she had on him simply by existing, by breathing, by being close enough to be within his field of vision, yet far enough that his hands did not go to her. That his arms did not reach her. That their skins did not ignite.
Not again.
He limited himself to watching her. He had not expected Scarlett to react that way, not sober, but the light laughter and the carefree way she spoke to Harry and Reggie unsettled him. Not that it was a bad thing; however, he had been psychologically prepared to gather his brittle pieces after the confession she had made to him in the bedroom earlier.
Worst of all was that… he knew exactly what she was suffering from and had no idea how to help her. In the past, he had James, Lily, Remus and Peter to keep him on the rehabilitation track, even with relapses here and there.
Scarlett had no one. Her chances of quitting alcohol were the same as bringing the dead back to life: none.
"I think it’d be better if I teach you on the street, Harry…" She ran a hand through her bleached hair, the dark roots already visible among the pale strands.
Sirius didn’t think that colour suited her. In truth, that Scarlett still carried many remnants of the girl he had loved, but she was no longer the same person. It was strange to watch her step out of her dissociative shell and act like the woman he had always wanted her to be.
"Isn’t it dangerous?!" Harry grabbed the bicycle, following her along the side path of the garden that led to the front of the house.
"At this time there shouldn’t be anyone out on the street anymore…" Scarlett slipped her hands into the pockets of her waistcoat. "Why don’t you come with your skateboard, Reg?!"
Regulus sucked in his lower lip, running his fingers over the roughness of the sparse beard growing along his chin. Despite having danced with Scarlett, suspicion clung to every shadow of his expression. Sirius could read his nephew easily. The way he shrugged and gently lowered his head said it all.
He looked a lot like Scarlett, even without having been raised by her.
"Nah… I ate too much today…" He placed a hand on his stomach to sell the lie. "But I can watch you lot from the steps…"
Scarlett didn’t let disappointment show on her face. She smothered it quickly, scratching at her Signet the way she always did when she was nervous.
"Next time, then…" she whispered, pressing her lips into a thin line. She took a breath and gathered all the courage that was dwindling with impressive speed at her core to continue her sentence. "Sirius, Remus… I’m going to need your help."
She didn’t look at them, nor did she stay to hear whether they agreed.
.
.
.
Scarlett was right. Saltoun Street was deserted; after all, the clocks were edging close to midnight. The silence was so complete that even in the city it was possible to hear the chirping of crickets and the song of cicadas. She breathed in the scent of the poppies from the front garden of the house; the same flowers that once filled the front of her parents’ home in Godric’s Hollow.
"Right, Harry… I know you’re Gryffindor’s Seeker, but a bicycle is very different from a broom." She positioned herself beside the bike, holding it by the handlebars.
"Yeah… I’ve noticed…"
"Good." Scarlett ignored the ironic tone and continued. "You need to keep your balance the whole time, because unlike a broom, it doesn’t balance itself. And there’s no point trying to give it momentum with your body like we do in Quidditch, it won’t work."
"How about we put some stabilisers on before you try, Harry?" Regulus teased, sitting on the front steps of the house.
"Piss off, Reg!" Harry waved a hand in his direction.
"I don’t think that’s a bad idea," Sirius said, vaulting the wooden fence with Remus close behind him.
"I’m already fourteen! Stabiliser wheels are for kids!" Harry smiled, even if reluctantly.
Scarlett tapped the side of the bicycle seat.
"Up you get, birthday boy."
Harry obeyed, fitting his feet onto the pedals. Scarlett positioned herself behind him, holding one side of the handlebars and the back of the saddle to keep it steady.
"It’ll feel hard at first, but that’s normal. Remember, the faster you go, the easier it is to keep your balance…"
"But if I go faster, aren’t the chances of me falling higher?" Harry glanced at her from the corner of his eye, making sure his glasses were firmly hooked over his ears.
"Err, yes, but if you manage to balance properly, you won’t fall… and relax, you’ll pick it up really quickly. I learned in, like… an hour…"
Harry raised an eyebrow.
"Seriously?"
"Uh-huh. Broke a leg, but that’s part of it…" Scarlett shook her head sarcastically.
Harry blinked very slowly, incredulous.
"Wow, Scar… that was really encouraging." The boy muttered, but soon enough his radiant smile returned, the one that reminded her so much of James.
Scarlett’s gaze immediately drifted to her friend, who stood on the other side of the bicycle as if he were directly involved in the lesson. James wore the exact same smile as Harry, and her heart skipped a few beats.
A few steps away, Sirius placed himself strategically in the street so he could catch Harry if he fell, and Remus did the same on the other side. Scarlett looked back at her godson.
"Come on, Harry, for someone who killed a basilisk, this is nothing…"
"How do you know about that?" Harry frowned, eyeing her suspiciously.
Scarlett cleared her throat, her gaze flicking between her ghosts in a silent plea for help.
"Say that… er, that you heard the rumours while you were walking through the corridors of Hogwarts…" James said quickly.
"I heard the rumours… at Hogwarts…" she justified, rolling her eyes as if it were obvious. "Can we go?"
Harry didn’t doubt her words. He simply took a deep breath and started pedalling. Scarlett walked alongside him, keeping the bike from tipping over.
"That’s it, keep going!" she encouraged him.
"Would you look at that… he’s a natural cyclist…" James stayed right beside his son, his expression filled with pure admiration.
It didn’t take long for Scarlett to start feeling tired. As much as she was enjoying helping Harry like this, she was completely out of shape.
Once Harry gained enough confidence to correct himself whenever the bicycle wobbled, Scarlett dared to loosen her grip little by little, holding on again seconds later.
That was how Harry barely noticed when Scarlett let go and, without warning… didn’t catch him again. He was so absorbed in the moment that he hardly registered his godmother’s absence, moving forward down the street with his heart hammering in his chest. It wasn’t quite like flying on a broom, but it was just as fascinating.
Well, it was—until he started to tip to one side and realised he was alone.
His eyes widened and he whipped his head around sharply, searching for Scarlett as his feet stopped pedalling and he lost speed, the bicycle wobbling from side to side.
"Woah!" Sirius caught him before he hit the ground.
"What are you doing, Sirius?!" Harry jumped, sucking in as much air as he could, his startled gaze fixed on his godfather.
Sirius laughed—a laugh Harry rarely saw him give.
"Stopping you from getting hurt!" He gave him a pat on the back, his other hand gripping the handlebars in the middle. "Your dad would kill me if that happened."
Harry frowned.
"Where’s Scar?" He climbed off the bike with a huff. "Flying on a broom is way better."
"Oh, Harry, you weren’t born knowing how to fly." Scarlett hurried over to him, breathless.
"But it was much easier than this…" Harry complained, shoulders slumped.
"Even so, you still had to learn, didn’t you?" Sirius tightened his grip on Harry’s shoulder, drawing his attention. "And you did great, Harry."
"You almost got it on the first go." Scarlett drummed her fingers on the saddle. "Shall we try again?"
"Go on, Harry! You’re almost there!" Regulus shouted from the pavement, his mouth full of cake.
Harry let out a long sigh and nodded, climbing back onto the bicycle. Sirius took several steps back and Scarlett steadied him again as he began to pedal.
"That’s it, Harry, go!" Remus encouraged, clapping his hands.
Scarlett stayed with Harry until she felt his body had understood the movement, the balance falling into rhythm with the pedalling. She loosened her grip on the handlebars and the seat gradually, then lifted her hands and stopped running.
Harry looked at her in panic, but kept pedalling. Scarlett fell behind, as did Remus. Sirius broke into a wide smile as he stepped aside and let Harry pass him.
The warm, gentle wind kissed his cheeks, his shoulders, his hair. Harry breathed in deeply, sweaty hands gripping the handlebars tightly, his feet pedalling without pause.
He was riding a bicycle.
The streetlamps passed him more and more slowly, and he glanced over his shoulder. He was getting too far away.
"How… how… how do I get back?" he shouted, his body jolting with adrenaline just as fear tried to erode his balance.
"Turn!" Sirius and Remus yelled in unison.
Harry twisted the handlebars reluctantly, making a half-turn before reaching a speed bump. He rode all the way back breathing in through his nose and out through his mouth, his heart’s erratic pounding fuelling his determined pedalling.
"Slow the pedalling…" Scarlett instructed, bracing her hands on her bent knees.
He passed Sirius and then Remus, doing exactly as he was told.
"That’s great, now brake, Harry! I’ll catch you if anything happens…" She stayed where she was.
Harry squeezed the brake and the bicycle skidded on the tarmac. He hunched his shoulders in fright, but quickly regained his balance. His survival instinct, however, made him pedal faster instead of braking again. And he sped up… straight towards Scarlett.
She didn’t have time to react. The handlebars slammed into the right side of her torso and the ground rushed up all at once. The air was knocked from her lungs the moment she fell onto her back. Pain exploded through her ribs, sharp and searing. Her arms clutched the injured spot as she curled in on herself, gasping, jaw clenched to suppress a whimper.
Harry fell too, but Remus caught him quickly.
"Harry! Are you alright?!"
"I think… I think so…" he said, dazed, adjusting his glasses on his face.
Sirius went straight past them, picked up Scarlett’s sunglasses from where they had fallen nearby, and dropped to his knees beside her. Her face was hidden by her bleached hair, tossed upward with the force of the air she was expelling through her mouth.
"Scar…?"
"I’m… I’m fine," she whispered, her breathing uneven.
Scarlett closed her eyes, feeling Sirius’s index finger weave through her unruly strands to pull them away from her face. Then she looked at him, and he parted his lips slightly, staring fixedly at her right eye. Frowning, Scarlett tried to sit up, but gave up when a sharp stab tore through her torso.
Her attention slid to Sirius’s other hand, which was holding her dark glasses.
Her eyes widened as she looked back at him.
He saw the bruise, but said nothing. He didn’t need to. The storm in his gaze already said everything.
"Scar?!" Harry was the one who called out. "Are you okay?"
Scarlett swallowed hard. She didn’t answer right away; instead, she reached for Sirius’s hand to take back her glasses and put them on again, slipping back into the relaxed mask she’d worn that evening.
"I’m… great," she lied with a strained smile.
"If this is great for you, then I don’t even want to know what bad looks like…" Sirius’s expression hardened, his brows drawing together furiously in his sharp features. "Come on, I’m taking you inside…"
Scarlett ignored Sirius’s hand, trying to get up on her own. The simple movement of her torso brought a suffocating pain that almost made her scream. Almost. But she clamped her mouth shut and squeezed her eyes closed, breathing out through her nose as she hyperventilated.
"I can… I can… walk…"
"You can barely breathe," Sirius insisted, wrapping an arm around her waist. "Come on, Scarlett. You’re coming nicely or not."
"No… no need…" she babbled, breaking out in a cold sweat.
"There is. You’re clearly in pain," he shot back, ignoring her feeble protest.
Scarlett laughed. A laugh that sounded more like a pained howl, disappearing as quickly as it came.
"I’m used to being in pain," she whispered, her breath stuttering in her chest.
Sirius merely stared at her. He had no patience for this.
"Reggie, help me here with your mum…"
Scarlett didn’t know how she was carried into the house. Everything turned into a sudden blur and, before she realised it, she heard Harry’s voice behind her asking whether she would be alright. Remus assured him she would. She was sitting on the sofa, her left hand pressed over the injured spot, her body rocking back and forth.
"You… you’ve grazed yourself, Mistress Black." It was Penny who said it, though Scarlett could barely lift her eyes. She was staring fixedly at her own feet.
"It’s… it’s fine…" she repeated. She didn’t know why she said that, but she heard someone click their tongue.
Sirius. Probably Sirius.
"Penny, heal Scarlett’s injuries, please," he ordered, not sparing the arrogance in his voice.
Scarlett sighed, impatient, but didn’t flinch. In her peripheral vision, she could see Penny casting spells over her elbows and back.
It brought her no relief.
"Would you like a pain potion, Mistress?" Penny asked, in that shrill, irritating voice.
"No." Scarlett swallowed with difficulty. "I already said… that… that I’m… fine. Check on Harry, he… he fell too."
"I’m fine," she heard him say. "But I don’t think you are, Scar…"
Scarlett parted her lips and tried to take a deep breath to answer him, but the attempt earned her a wheeze.
A hand braced itself on the arm of the sofa beside her. Scarlett knew it was Sirius’s; the gleam of rings and the dark, diffuse marks against pale skin made it unmistakable. Sirius crouched to her level, concern flickering across his sharp, handsome features.
Scarlett blinked a few times until her vision focused on his face. On his eyes. On his irises. Then she braced herself on the sofa cushion and struggled to stand, letting out a soft groan as she did. At once, Sirius caught her by the arms, helping her upright.
"Where are you going?" The concern was not only on his face, but in his voice as well.
"Bath… bathroom." Scarlett wavered, shoving Sirius out of her way, but he didn’t budge.
"I’ll take you."
"Sirius!" she whimpered, and he heard a myriad of emotions in her tone: pleading, pain, shame, guilt, and fear.
It stunned him so completely that he couldn’t stop her from leaving the sitting room, hunched over and dragging her feet.
Scarlett wasn’t sure how she managed to reach the bathroom on her own—especially that bathroom. It was the farthest one from all the others, from the bedrooms and the sitting room. It was beside the laundry and close to the studio. She stopped, bracing herself against the counter, nausea prickling at her taste buds, twisting her stomach.
She didn’t know whether it was because of the pain or the rebound effect of the sobriety potion. Worst of all was that she could barely breathe. Every time she tried to expand her chest, an unbearable stabbing pain flared beneath her ribs.
"Scar… I think you’ve broken a rib," Lily said, standing near the bathroom door.
"I’d wager more than one," Regulus guessed, folding his arms. "Why did you lock yourself in the bathroom instead of accepting help?"
"And have you ever seen her accept help easily?!" her friend snapped, and Scarlett shot her an aggressive look before pushing herself off the counter and forcing herself to walk again.
She brushed past Lily and Red without caring about what they were saying to her. She endured the walk long enough to reach the studio, assaulted by the smell of mould, old wood, and dust. The instruments were still there, although now there was a table in one corner piled with folders, maps, notes, parchment, and quills.
Was Sirius working there now?
She crossed the room and sat down on the floor beside the drum kit, slowly leaning her back against the wall. She didn’t remember that drum kit, but many things had been moved around. On top of one of the synthesisers, she spotted the kitten plushie. She stretched her hand towards it.
"Accio… Accio plushie," she murmured, trying to do magic without a wand. "Accio kitten. Accio stuffed cat. Accio bloody stupid stuffed cat!"
Nothing.
"Fuck…" she gasped, wiping the back of her hand across her sweaty forehead.
Why was she isolating herself there? Lily and Regulus were right. She had certainly broken one — or more than one — rib. And yet all she could do was suppress the pain and pretend everything was fine, when clearly nothing was.
She was far too embarrassed to ask for help. She didn’t want to look weak. Asking for help meant admitting she had lost control of things, and as true as that was, she didn’t want to let go of the illusion that she could handle everything on her own.
She had done it for fifteen years in Azkaban — why couldn’t she do it after escaping?
Scarlett knew the exact second Sirius entered the studio.
She always knew. She had known when he walked into the courtroom, when he entered her cell… when he entered her heart. His presence was far too piercing to be ignored, far too radiant to go unnoticed, and far too suffocating to be even remotely comfortable in her current state.
Sirius said nothing, and somehow that irritated her. It irritated her because she knew exactly what he was thinking. It was the same thing she was thinking.
"I… I…" she stammered, breathing shallowly. "I needed… money… to… to help with… with the boys’ supplies…"
Sirius raised an eyebrow and twisted the corner of his mouth, his fingers disentangling the ends of his long black hair. He narrowed his gaze on her, the confused grey condensing years of old hurt.
"Scar… they don’t care about money." He leaned against the wall beside her, arms crossed. "They care about your presence. Harry might have liked the bike he got, but not more than you teaching him how to ride it… even if he did run you over…" Sirius cut himself off halfway through to stifle a smile.
Scarlett laughed too, but laughing hurt. Breathing hurt. Existing hurt as well. So she groaned in pain and curled in on herself even more, as if that might ease it.
It didn’t.
"You idealise me too much, Sirius."
"And you punish yourself too much, Scarlett."
The retort hurt her. It wasn’t the same pain as a broken rib or a Cruciatus, but still… it hurt. And yet, what could she say? Sirius wasn’t lying. As much as she told herself he was, that he had to be… she knew the truth. She knew she hated herself enough to destroy her own life because she wasn’t capable of moving on.
Not because of what she’d done, even if it had been to protect the people she loved. If she herself didn’t believe in her motivations, how could she expect anyone else to?
Scarlett Gaunt was a walking contradiction.
"I don’t understand you, Scarlett," Sirius broke the silence, sliding his back down the wall until he was sitting on the floor beside her, arms resting on his knees. "I swear I don’t."
"You do," she said softly. Just for him. "Out of everyone, you’re the only one who understands me."
Something in Sirius’s gaze… cracked. She couldn’t tell whether it was the rigidity of silver or the malleability of steel, but it was enough to make him fall silent in doubtful agreement. His dark, dangerous, guarded side understood her. For all his proud Gryffindor bravado, Sirius came from an unbroken line of natural Slytherins.
Even if he didn’t want to understand, he was used to the taste of injustice. Of loneliness. Of longing. It was different with Scarlett… it was always different with her. He knew her in the palm of his hand, and yet… she never stopped surprising him. For better or worse. And as much as he wanted to tell her no, that the years they’d spent apart had made them strangers… he knew that wasn’t entirely true.
The Scarlett who looked at him now, anguished, was the same one who had looked at him sixteen years earlier while playing The Great Gig in the Sky on the piano in Godric’s Hollow. A wounded girl whose greatest wish was to be helped, even though the mere mention of that tiny word was enough to send her running as if she were fleeing for her life.
"What happened to your eye?" Sirius asked, pulling those stupid glasses off her face. He wanted to look at her properly, wanted to dissect those ocean-blue irises, wanted to swim in them until he drowned.
"I… I… fell."
It was a lie. A lie she hadn’t even bothered to dress up properly.
Of course she would lie.
Sirius drew a very, very deep breath.
Dealing with Scarlett was always exhausting.
"Nice acrylic drum kit," she changed the subject, as usual, running her fingers along the metal stand of one of the toms. "What happened to the one I gave you?"
"It’s stored away," Sirius muttered roughly, tearing his gaze from those eyes before he lost himself in them.
Stored away. Like so many things they had given each other. Stored, covered in dust and cobwebs in that abandoned corner of the heart. Sometimes not even stored — just shoved there to be forgotten.
But if there was one thing in this world that could never forget, it was the heart. And all those objects piled up from the past would, sooner or later, be driven into the flesh of the pulsing organ until they hurt enough to be removed… or worse. Chewed over.
Like most things between them.
"The potion… for the pain…" Scarlett finally broke the silence. "I think I’ll take it."
Sirius only nodded. He stood, bracing a hand against the wall, and returned with the small vial of green liquid. Scarlett drank it all. She didn’t even taste it.
She was in too much pain for that.
"Can you… take me… to the en-suite bathroom? I… I’m not feeling very well."
"I can." Sirius took her hand. "Feeling sick?"
Scarlett only nodded vaguely, pale as a ghost. Sirius guided her to his bedroom. He had the impression Scarlett was in more pain than she let on, but he didn’t realise how much until she braced herself against the shower screen and smothered a cry of pain, jaw clenched tight.
She turned on the hot water and grimaced as she moved her arms, slipping off her leather waistcoat. Then she brought her hands to the hem of her shirt and tried to lift it. She couldn’t. An agonising stab flared beneath her ribs and she let out a guttural groan, giving up.
"Fuck…" she hissed, breath short. Her body trembling. Her shirt clinging to her sweaty skin. She lifted her gaze to Sirius, who was watching her without moving a muscle. "Can you… can you help me?"
"What happened to your eye?" he repeated, pulling his wand from his pocket.
"I already told you… what happened."
"What really happened?"
Scarlett cleared her throat, ready to speak, but there was a burning sensation behind her eyes that stopped her. She sobbed, opened her mouth… and gave up trying to explain. Maybe she shouldn’t say anything. But she had already run too many times, and there was a limit to her cowardice — even if that limit was higher than it should have been.
Her chest tightened. She hated all of this. She was tired — exhausted. Of lying to herself, of lying to others, of lying to Sirius. Of keeping all the hell she’d been through locked inside. She tried to draw breath, but breathing felt like the most painful act in the world.
She lifted her eyes to Sirius, resigned. Because the mouth speaks with words, and the eyes speak with feelings. And her eyes were full of terrible confessions.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 83: You see me as I am / A perfect day
Chapter Text
CLI
With a flourish of his wand, Sirius cut Scarlett’s blouse down the middle. He took care to remove it slowly so as not to hurt her.
"The McKinnons…" Her choked voice echoed off the bathroom walls. "They weren’t supposed to… for all of them… to be together that day." Her body shuddered as she nearly lost her balance, bracing her other hand against the icy shower stall.
Sirius’s gaze slid to her right flank, to the swelling visible beneath her ribs. Then he unclasped her bra and guided the straps down over her pale, freckled shoulders. There was something new on her left triceps, something he hadn’t noticed until that moment: a tattoo.
"Marl was my target," Scarlett went on. "She…" Her voice faded away.
Sirius slowly lifted his gaze to meet Scarlett’s, ignoring the bruise on her right brow so he could dive into those blue eyes spilling burning tears.
"What did you mean by… Regulus’s plan going wrong?" he asked, his unsteady fingers feeling for the zip at the waistband of her skirt, taking care that his fingertips didn’t brush Scarlett’s skin.
He couldn’t allow himself to touch her like that.
"I needed to join the Death Eaters, I… needed to prove my loyalty, that I was on their side even before… before… and Marl… she…"
"But why Marl?" Sirius held her gaze. The silver darkened, swallowed by lead. "You could have killed anyone in the Order."
"B… because… because…" she stammered, but couldn’t go on. The cords of the pact were quick to silence her. She cleared her throat. "They weren’t meant to be there. All of them."
Sirius sighed, recalling everything he’d learnt in auror interrogation training.
"Was there a specific reason she was your target?"
Scarlett nodded very slowly.
"I… I never… we never…" She tried to take a deep breath but ground her teeth and squeezed her eyes shut. "I was never loyal to him… Sirius… I only… did it for Orfy. For… for Reggie." For you, she tried to say, but the pact would not allow it. "I believed that… by saving Regulus… I would be saving you."
"Saving me?" Sirius broke eye contact, tugging her skirt down until it slid past her legs and fell onto the wet tiles of the shower stall. "Saving me from what?"
"From alcoholism."
Sirius’s nostrils flared. The stars in his eyes blazed like embers.
He looked at her for seconds that stretched into eternity. His expression lines tightened, turning him into a statue. Cold, inanimate, indifferent.
Scarlett turned her face toward the shower spraying hot water beside her, trying to gather any scrap of calm within herself, trying to appear in control when all she wanted was to collapse into his arms.
"I didn’t… I didn’t abandon you, Sirius. I didn’t leave intending not to come back. I wanted to come back. With Regulus. I… I wanted…" Scarlett laughed, then groaned in pain straight after. It was a weak, scornful laugh. "To bring him to our home and… save him, while at the same time saving you. And I… in my arrogance… hadn’t thought that… you can’t save someone who doesn’t want to be saved."
Sirius went back to moving mechanically, removing her tights, tugging them down until she was left only in her knickers.
At last, he left her completely naked.
He did not look at her. No. His gaze remained fixed on the wet clothes piled on the flooded shower floor. He couldn’t bring himself to look at her. He didn’t know what he might be capable of if he did. He didn’t know whether he would strangle her with the rage of his vengeful hands or with the welcome of his yearning arms.
Steam rose through the shower, slowly engulfing Scarlett, him, and the rest of the bathroom. The only sound between them was the hot water pouring down in resonance with the thunder of their hearts—frayed, inconsolable. Afflicted.
Scarlett watched him from beneath long dark lashes sprinkled with droplets that bounced off her and the misted glass beside her.
"Regulus captured me. He…" She bit down hard on her lower lip, chasing the words struggling to escape her mind. "He got into my head. He saw… he… I… I begged to run, but…" she stammered, struggling for breath through the pain. "Ros… Rosier was with him and… I didn’t… it was him or Regulus… and Regulus took me and… he said they had Orfy and I… I believed him, Sirius! I believed him… I was so bloody stupid… so fucking foolish…"
Sirius swallowed hard. It felt as though he’d just taken a punch to the gut. He wanted to cry just as fiercely as he wanted to embrace her and comfort her, but he resisted both, daring to look straight at her. With a flick of his wand, he conjured a bench right beneath the falling water. Scarlett’s shimmering eyes were like the ocean at midnight, spattered with stars whose reflections slid in tears across the freckles on her cheeks.
Scarlett sat down. She hugged herself, shoulders hunched, feet on the bench support, knees up to her navel. Her eyelids trembled before being veiled by the translucent curtain; her bleached hair snaked over her shoulders, the water sweeping the tears from her ashen face. She closed her eyes.
"I don’t understand. They didn’t have Orfy?" Sirius asked, trying to keep his tone detached, though he failed miserably. Not only did regret vibrate in his voice, but also fear and anger.
Fear of realising he had been wrong all this time.
Anger at the blinding hatred that had clouded his judgement in the past and made him give up on her so easily.
His legs gave out, so he braced one hand against the corner of the shower stall, water splashing over his clothes. Not that he cared. His mind was racing, his heart hammering in his chest, ready to burst through his throat, and his ears could barely catch anything beyond his own breathing—ever shorter—and Scarlett’s voice, ever more anguished.
"They did, but… I… no one knew… no one knew about Orfy. He was… he was a test subject and… Regulus only knew because… because he found out. But the Death Eaters… they didn’t know. And I… I didn’t know that they didn’t know. I didn’t… Regulus tricked me! He said that if I left, V–Voldemort… Voldemort would kill him. And that I needed to… to act… as if everything… as if I’d always been on their side…"
Scarlett panted, lifting her gaze to him. Not even the strands dancing in front of her face, nor the water gleaming on her cheeks, were enough to hide the ice-cold blue of her eyes.
"But… Rosier… he was there when Regulus captured you, wasn’t he?" Sirius asked, wishing his voice had sounded a bit more measured and a bit less affected. "How…"
She pressed her lips together, then parted them and let the air out slowly.
"Regulus convinced… Rosier and Crouch… they…" She struggled for breath. They knew, she wanted to say. They knew about Reggie. Yet she shook her head. "They were on our side. And they helped me… with Voldemort. Helped me… to back up… the lie that I’d always been on his side."
"Rosier and Crouch? Two of Voldemort’s most loyal Death Eaters?" he asked, though not distrustfully. There was a hint of scepticism in his voice, but it was mixed in and completely drowned by curiosity. "Why would they lie for you?"
"I… I don’t know." She half-closed her eyes, searching the depths of her mind for the answer… but there was nothing.
Sirius nibbled his lower lip. His feet were soaked, and the steam from the water crystallised into delicate droplets on the rebellious tips of his black hair, framing his angular face and speckling his thick lashes. He blinked hard to see her more clearly, though he didn’t need to in order to know Scarlett was still crying.
"Voldemort was a powerful Legilimens," he murmured, unmoving. He couldn’t break his restrained posture, couldn’t collapse into tears. Not now that Scarlett was finally able to speak about the past. "How did you… how did you all… fool him?"
Even with the scalding water lashing her back, Scarlett trembled frantically. It wasn’t from the cold. It wasn’t because of her broken ribs either. Sirius understood. Reliving the past was painful. Tugging at that rough, barbed thread carved deep in the heart was torture; as much as Scarlett wanted to tell him everything, the laceration was still there. Once numb; now, waking it was like trying to remove a metastatic tumour that had already rotted the organs, withered the muscles, and tainted the blood.
"Regulus used the Imperius Curse on me and then used… used a… another curse on me. A Black family curse. It… it closed off my mind… as if… as if I were an Occlumens… and with the Imperius, he made me show V–Voldemort… what he… wanted." Scarlett tried to draw a deep breath, but the pain was still there. She ignored the turmoil of her own pulse.
"Claustrum?" Sirius didn’t know how his voice came out, but somehow it rose above the relentless sound of the running water.
"I think… I think so." She merely moved her trembling lips.
Claustrum. Sirius remembered when his father had tried to teach him the spell. It had been created by his ancestor, Regulus Black. It was capable of stripping the target of their ability to access memories and emotions for a time. Back then, he hadn’t understood the need for such a curse—especially as an eight-year-old—but now…
Sirius rubbed his neck with his free hand, trying to ease the pressure building in his throat.
He had no idea what to say.
So he remained silent, watching Scarlett shrink in on herself with every word spoken. She looked so… fragile. Defenceless. Helpless. In the same way Scarlett had looked when she’d just lost her parents in the past.
"For killing the McKinnons… I earned the Dark Mark," she went on, her voice no more than a wavering, hoarse thread. "Voldemort wanted… a child with me. He ordered Wilkes to brew pregnancy-accelerating potions. Regulus… made a plan. To rescue Orfy… and get me out of Grimmauld Place before… before Reg turned into a test subject too. But I… I was… I needed to run. I couldn’t bear… staying in that hell… in that haunted house… alone…"
She began to shake convulsively, trying to hold back her sobs, but she was far too exhausted for that.
If before it had been a punch to the gut, now it was a knife to the chest. Scarlett was finally revealing the truth to him, and he had no idea what to do. It felt as though his heart was being fed into a meat grinder. Hearing all of this was excruciating.
How was he supposed to react upon realising that all the pain he had wished upon Scarlett had already been delivered to her with teeth, nails, and bites? That she, too, had endured hell at Grimmauld Place at the hands of his parents and his brother?
Sirius nearly choked on his own saliva. His stomach twisted, and bile burned his throat. His hundreds of justifications turned bitter on his tongue.
"I managed to get my cloak back… Kreacher had kept it… and all my things from when I was captured… including my multi-portkey… but before I could try to run, I was sent on a last-minute mission… to reinforce the attack on the Prewetts. Because I knew them, they thought…" The words spilled from Scarlett’s mouth so quickly she barely had time to make sense of them herself. "…that I’d know how to handle them. But when I got there… you… well, you know the rest."
The bleak shadows of Scarlett’s words made Sirius nod. She had thrown her Invisibility Cloak over him. That was how he’d made it out of that massacre alive. He’d lost Fabian and Gideon, though. In 1978, members of the Order were dying as fast as candles snuffed by the wind.
Losing the McKinnons and the Prewetts had been a brutal blow to the Order—one they would never recover from. He remembered Dorcas’s desperate, horrendous scream when she found out what had happened to Marlene.
Sirius didn’t remember it. Not until Scarlett dragged it back into the light.
"Without the cloak, I… had to…" She curled in on herself, the hand over her bruise clenching into a fist. "…wait for Regulus to save Orfy. Pretend I was on his side, that we were going to… run away somewhere remote to live happily ever after. He thought I loved him." She breathed in slowly through her mouth. Breathed out. "That I loved him… the way I loved you."
His body went taut. His muscles turned to stone. His lungs faltered. Sirius wanted desperately to believe Scarlett’s words—especially as they were already taking root in his mind, spreading through his core and blooming in his chest. But he wasn’t a fool; he wouldn’t be swept away by romantic declarations from that cunning woman, even if it was everything he wanted to hear in that moment.
He pinned his eyes on Scarlett’s, plunging into the violent, churning ocean of those wary irises. Eyes didn’t lie. The icy, feverish blue of her gaze could tell him every truth her tongue didn’t dare bring into being.
Sirius said nothing. He could barely breathe, let alone speak.
"Regulus died." It was as though Scarlett had stolen the breath, the courage, and the words for herself, because she carried on like a runaway train. "He left me a letter to warn me. That he died. He found out something about Voldemort and… and he had Kreacher return the multi-portkey to me. Told me to come back to you. When I found out he’d died, I went into labour and…" She let all the air out in a hiss, put her feet on the floor, and hid her face in her hands, sobbing. "I just… I was just trying to… survive. Even thinking I was going to die… I…"
Scarlett didn’t understand. Though her shoulders felt lighter and the weight on her chest eased, her heart remained tormented. Sirius was still silent, in exactly the same position: one hand braced against the damp glass, his feet inside the shower stall, his clothes slowly clinging to his body from the spray.
Perhaps it was because of the things she still hid in the darkest corners of her heart—things he sometimes glimpsed the remnants of in her eyes, yet they never seemed enough to piece together exactly what they were.
Sirius wetted his lips. His gaze wandered over Scarlett’s skin: the bruise along her ribs, the freckles on her shoulders, the numerous scars on her back. Her medium breasts, the rosy areolas, the taut peaks. The ridiculously blonde hair. The Ouroboros staring back at him because of the hand covering her eyes. The unsteady legs. The heaving chest.
There she was again, exposed. Exposed and weakened.
A hostage to his judgement. To his haunted gaze, to his bared demons.
That was why he unclenched his jaw and drew a deep breath, regaining control of his body as he undressed—shirt, trousers, then pants. His clothes joined the wet heap of hers.
Sirius trembled, but it wasn’t with anger or indignation as it so often was. Nor was it with excitement or joy as it had been earlier that day. It was… with sadness. With grief. He’d spent so long harbouring resentment toward Scarlett, torturing himself with that feeling that he needed to lay a little balm over the wound he himself had fed—in a petty attempt at self-soothing.
"When you left…" Sirius’s voice cracked. Tears gathered in his eyes but did not fall. Scarlett lowered her hands from her face to lock her gaze with his. "I turned London upside down looking for you. I… I nearly died trying to find you. When I realised you weren’t coming back… I panicked. I abused alcohol and drowned myself in drugs." He sniffed, staring at Scarlett in the same aching cadence. Opening those long-blocked roads of his heart again was hard work. Painful. "When I saw… in the Daily Prophet… that you and Regulus had got married… my world ended. I wanted to die."
Sirius lowered his face, half-closing his silver eyes, almost completely hidden by his black hair. But it wasn’t enough to smother the blinding gleam of his irises, nor the pain overflowing from his core, manifesting in sobs.
"Do you know what frustrates me most?" His thickened voice betrayed that he was crying. "I lost Regulus because I didn’t even try to save him, and when you tried to save him, I lost you as well."
Scarlett remained silent and let her gaze drop to her wet feet. Despite the unbearable pull of Sirius’s eyes, she didn’t want to look at him. Not again. Every time she allowed herself to stare into those starry depths, her heart faltered. And she was already in enough pain.
Wasn’t she?
No. She drew a breath and lifted her chin, looking at him for a long moment, watching the curtain of memories from the past dance across the pallor of his irises.
Sirius cleared his throat.
"I blamed you for many years, Scarlett. I hated you for many years. I thought we’d never see each other again after you were arrested… I resented the fact that you and Regulus…" He let the air out through his mouth, oxygenating his thoughts, organising the thread of them. "I thought I’d never see you again. Even after I was sent to Azkaban… I used to wonder whether you were paying fairly for your crimes, while I was rotting away unjustly." He wet his lips, trying to swallow the knot in his throat, but failed. "The truth is, I wanted you to suffer. As much as I suffered. It wasn’t justice for the McKinnons that I wanted—it was revenge for what you did to me. And meanwhile… you also…" The blood drained from his body as everything Scarlett had just said settled in his mind, seeped into his core, and drove itself into his flesh. "I should have searched harder. Insisted more on you."
Scarlett’s eyes narrowed in understanding.
"Should have, should have, should have… if we’re going to play that game, Sirius, I shouldn’t have left."
Sirius knelt in front of her. The starry eyes were exhausted, tarnished. He touched Scarlett’s chin; his index and middle fingers slid slowly along her jaw until they gripped the nape of her neck firmly, his fingers tangling in her heavy hair beneath the water.
Sirius Black was just a man ravaged by love for the woman who had wounded him—and yet there he was, longing to be comforted by her.
Longing to believe what she had said, even knowing that doing so meant admitting he was a bloody cruel monster. That he had hurt her too. And that, despite everything, Scarlett was still seeking his touch. His comfort. His solace.
There was an atrocious beauty in the way they still orbited one another—like shattered stars, bound by invisible threads. Still whole in what united them, still broken by what they had lost. So deeply scarred by the past and by each other… that closeness felt like both redemption and damnation.
"I forgive you. Hatred has already taken too much time from my life and too much space in my heart. I’ve lost too much to it already. I don’t want to lose you as well."
Scarlett’s pupils dilated. Her breath narrowed. Sirius Black managed to gather her shards with disconcerting ease, even though he too was shattered.
Those few little words were everything she had wanted to hear through all those cursed days, and when they were finally released into the world…
They didn’t manage to glue or mend her pieces. Just as her confession had not been enough to heal every fracture in Sirius’s heart.
But… perhaps…
This was Scarius’s way of loving: among the splinters, in the failed attempt to complete their warped mosaic, shadowed with light.
Scarlett closed her eyes, focusing on the subtle caress Sirius traced along the rim of her ear. She tipped her face forwards, out of the fall of water.
"You never lost me, Sirius." She sniffed softly, glittering drops sliding down her conflicted expression. "Even when I tried to get rid of you… you were everywhere. In the music I listened to, in the laughs I forced just to pretend everything was fine… in the stars above me. You… you were everywhere, and I’ve never wanted so badly for you to be—actually—by my side."
Tears blurred her vision. Sirius moved his hand to her right cheek, catching them before they could run over her freckles. Scarlett let out a soft hiss when he accidentally brushed the bruise on her face.
"I’m here now," he murmured, his heavy breath colliding with hers. "Who did this to your eye?"
Scarlett opened her mouth, but the words burst at the back of her throat, because they were a lie.
"I… I don’t… I don’t know." She didn’t hide the shame in her voice, shaking her head to push away the flashes of that day. "I don’t know. I was too drunk to…"
Her voice died. Not that she needed to finish the explanation—Sirius already understood. His hand settled, palm to the apple of her cheek, his index finger busying itself with a slow stroke as he dried her tears.
"Scar… this isn’t a way to live." He braced his other hand on the edge of the bench. "It’s a way to die. You… you’re literally killing yourself. You need to stop."
"I want… I want to stop. But I don’t know if…" She gasped, catching a sob. "I don’t know if I can."
"You can. You’ve done far worse…" Sirius tried to blunt the weight of the moment, but he couldn’t.
Really, it shouldn’t be that hard to give up drinking when she’d already killed five people. Killing people should be much harder than that, shouldn’t it?!
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut and rubbed them with her knuckles, ignoring the swelling and the pain in the right one.
That was exactly why she drank. Because she’d killed five people.
"I don’t… I don’t want… I don’t want to be a burden to you, Sirius. I don’t want you to fix me. I don’t want you to save me." Scarlett lifted her lids when Sirius’s hand dropped and hooked under her chin, tilting it up, forcing her to look at him.
The water behind her reflected in the silver of Sirius’s eyes, washing it until it turned to platinum, polishing it with her own image dancing in the calm, grey sea of his lacerating irises.
Scarlett watched the deep abyss of his dilated pupils. Like waves breaking on rocks, she threw herself into freefall in Sirius Black’s arms, allowing him to take what was rightfully his to break: her heart, her core, her soul.
He wrapped her in his arms, in his safety. Pressing her against his chest as if they could become just one; even if it meant uniting their pain, their hurt, and their regrets.
"All I want is for you to be by my side while I save myself. While… while I fix myself," she said softly, her voice muffled against Sirius’s bare chest, cutting through him like a sharp blade until it reached his heart. "Can you… I know I’ve no right at all to… to ask you this, but… Sirius… can you… can you give me another chance?"
"I don’t know, Scar." Sirius threaded his fingers through Scarlett’s hair in an affectionate caress. "I don’t think I’m the one you need to ask for a chance." He brought his other hand to the tattoo on her triceps—the word Scarius inside a heart pierced by an arrow. "Can you give yourself a chance?" he whispered. "Can you give yourself a chance to be happy?"
Scarlett wilted.
The shadows were still there, staring at her.
But so was Sirius, holding her and showing her that they were harmless and that the only one with the power to hurt anyone there was herself.
She pulled away from him in order to stand, but the muscles in her abdomen contracted with such involuntary force that she gasped and went rigid. She could barely remember that pain. Was it the effect of the potion, or the easing brought on by confessing to Sirius?
"I need to set your rib back in place, Scar."
Scarlett blinked a few times, shaking her head.
"No." She took a step back, almost tripping over the bench. "No."
Sirius stepped back too, reaching for his wand in the pocket of his wet trousers.
"I know it’s hard…" he said, approaching again. He slipped his arms around the curve of her waist, his eyes locked on hers. "But you need to forgive yourself."
[Jeff Buckley — Opened Once]
Scarlett wanted to go on martyring herself. Punishing herself. She wanted to suffer until everything finally ended… but she knew Sirius wouldn’t allow it.
And it was far too hard to say no to him again. Not when his strong arms drew her gently in and his warm hands touched her bruise with such care.
Scarlett had become a hostage without him needing to make any effort at all.
Sirius Black was like that: a mere glimmer of love was enough, and Scarlett surrendered. Completely. Captive in his arms.
I once was open and one with a travelling heart
I loved this sweet guide
Just like affection rushing in your riverbed
Arise like applause in my head
Even against her own will, she nodded. Sirius stepped back just enough to lift his wand. The spell sent a sudden sting racing through her nerve endings. Scarlett screamed, burying her face in his shoulder as her body went rigid with pain.
Sirius held her tighter, drawing her with him beneath the shower. She stayed still for long seconds, only their ragged breaths and erratic heartbeats falling into that familiar resonance.
Scarlett traced with her fingertips the Scarius tattoo just below her cheek where it rested against his chest, the hot water streaming over her bleached hair. He brushed it back, easing aside the wet strands stuck to her skin.
Feeling Sirius’s body—warm and bare—pressed against hers had always been intoxicating. The sharp sensation of belonging left her dizzy. Scarlett bathed in the comfort and safety only Sirius’s arms could offer, even as the water washed her demons away.
Sirius took the shampoo and worked his fingers into her scalp, massaging in slow, circular motions, lathering it into foam. Scarlett closed her eyes, letting herself relax beneath his touch. His hands slid over her shoulders, down her back with open palms until they settled in the small of her spine—the way he used to do when they were teenagers.
Scarlett breathed in—deeply, so very deeply. For the first time, the air entered without snagging on anguish, without catching on remorse or tripping over guilt. She felt fear skim across her skin, melting into the flames of the past, into the sting of scars and the glow of the choices she’d had to make. Each one burned its relentless path through her heart, her skin, her sinews until, finally, they were released from her hoarding, suffering nature. She watched them evaporate at her fingertips and dissolve into the thick, humid mist of the bathroom.
In the half-light where we both stand
In the half-light you saw me as I am
I am a railroad track abandoned
With the sunset forgetting I ever happened
That I ever happened
Their eyes searched for one another: silver clashed with ocean.
Silver clear, gleaming—the shade of grey responsible for stealing all the stars’ light.
A calm ocean, reflecting the sun. Warm. Deep.
Then came the flood. As grey as Sirius’s eyes was the storm that churned the scarlet sea. She dug her nails into his back. Every inch of her pale skin cracked with loud, voicing sobs. Sirius rested his forehead against Scarlett’s, the stars in his eyes falling, tracing bright paths down his cheeks.
"I’m so sorry you went through all of that," he whispered, his voice breaking.
"I’m sorry that you… went through… all of this too," Scarlett managed, her voice shrill. "I’m sorry… I’m so sorry…"
Sirius held her so tightly he no longer knew where he ended and she began. He couldn’t be sure whether the hand scratching at his back was Scarlett’s or his own; whether the heart thundering in his chest was his or hers; or whether the loud sob echoing off the tiles belonged to him.
It probably belonged to both of them.
Sirius found shelter in Scarlett and Scarlett found shelter in Sirius. They collapsed in each other’s arms when rancour twisted itself into longing. Longing to hold each other like that, to be honest with one another, to share fears and hopes as if they were still two teenagers dreaming of a future that would soon turn to ash.
They couldn’t make the pain go away. Not completely. But having each other… made things more bearable. Almost acceptable.
It was like going home. A house abandoned for more than a decade, covered in dust, taken over by cobwebs, eaten through by termites. Even once cleaned, it would never be the same. The dust and webs might be gone, yes, but the holes left by the termites, the damaged furniture… those could not be mended.
Even so, it was still the same house. The same foundation, the same wallpaper, the same furniture. Worn down, true, but nothing a fresh coat of paint and replacing a few pieces couldn’t fix… and the problem would be sorted.
Wouldn’t it?
Of course, the trail of erosion was still there. But it was still a home. They still loved the gleaming silver and the scorching scarlet. It was still their house. The only place in the world where they truly belonged.
They were still the two lost souls who had found one another, despite being cracked and torn. Traumatised and abandoned. Held and comforted.
They were still Scarius.
Now, however, they were Scarius willing to start over even after everything.
.
.
.
Scarlett left the bathroom wrapped in a towel, her mind racing. Lazy droplets slid down her collarbone, and her reddened, swollen eyes burned from crying.
That was why she blinked hard a few times when she found Regulus and Harry sprawled on the bed, Penny sitting on the edge of the mattress with the remote in her hand, and Remus crouched near the wall fiddling with the cables of the… newly installed television.
All four of them turned to look at her at the same time.
Sirius stepped out of the bathroom as well, right behind her, but he froze just as completely as she did in the middle of that painfully awkward moment.
He had a towel wrapped around his waist, his hair dripping onto the floor, and his face as red as hers—though it had nothing to do with the temperature of the water or the strangeness of the situation.
"What… are you… doing here?" Sirius asked, utterly wrong-footed.
"Harry wanted to finish his birthday with a film he got as a present," Penny replied casually, turning her eyes back to the telly. "And your room has the best bed."
"And the best acoustics," Reggie exaggerated, grabbing a pillow and shoving it under his head.
Sirius frowned. He placed his damp hand on Scarlett’s cold shoulder. She took a small step to the side, and he walked past her toward the dresser, fumbling through a few pieces of clothing with trembling hands.
He went back into the bathroom without saying anything, Harry, Reg, and Remus following him with their eyes.
"Here… go get changed." Sirius handed the clothes to Scarlett without looking at her. She nodded and closed the door.
"What… what happened to Scar’s eye?" Harry crossed his legs, settling next to Regulus and leaning back against the headboard.
"She fell," Sirius said quickly, rummaging for his own change of clothes.
Scarlett reappeared shortly after, dressed in one of Sirius’s T-shirts and a pair of shorts, her face pale, her eye bruised purple, the tip of her nose tinged pink.
"Feeling better, Mum?" Regulus turned his face toward her.
"Ah… yeah." Scarlett swallowed dryly and cleared her throat to rid the rasp from her voice. "Sirius… er… he put… put the rib back in place. It hurts a bit, but…"
She stopped talking when Remus suddenly stood up, bracing one hand on the TV. He looked at her for barely a second, wiped his hands on his trousers, and lowered his head as he picked up a small plate with a slice of cake. He offered it to her after a brief glance; the shadowed scars on his face and the gold in his eyes weren’t enough to dim the kindness of the gesture.
"You’d better have a piece before it’s gone," he suggested, his lips tugging into a shy half-smile. Then he turned on his heel and conjured an armchair beside the bed, dropping into it with a tired sigh.
Scarlett held the little gold plastic plate in both hands. Her eyes were fixed on the chocolate sponge covered in caramel, its edges steaming as if it were on fire. Penny managed to tune the cassette to the television, and Remus said something about the film they were going to watch being inspired by Hamlet.
"You don’t look like someone who’s happy," James whispered beside her, pretending to stick a finger into the cake for a taste. "Blimey, chocolate with caramel… I’d almost forgotten what that tasted like," he joked.
Scar gave a small, humourless sniff of laughter. She glanced sideways at him, catching Lily sitting on the sideboard in the corner and Red running a hand over the Pensieve.
"He knows. Everything. Except… except for…" Her voice barely came out.
"And what did he say?"
"That… he said that…"
The bathroom door opened. Sirius was wearing only a pair of sleep shorts. His black, unruly hair was already perfectly dry. He slipped an arm around her waist and drew her in, even as she still walked with difficulty. He sat down on the bed and settled next to Harry, piling a stack of pillows behind his back.
Scarlett remained standing, her fingers gripping the edges of the plastic plate so tightly they cracked.
"They’re here for you, Scar," Lily said, daring to look at her with the same kind, vivid eyes Harry had. "All of us are."
"Even if you pretend otherwise… you’re not alone, Scar," Red said, without looking at her. He shoved his hands into the pockets of his coat and closed his eyes, biting at the dry skin of his own mouth. "You were never alone. Not even in Azkaban."
Even though, in that moment, one of her wishes was to strangle Regulus for everything he’d done to her until he died again, all she did was slowly drag her index finger through the caramel topping of the cake.
She tasted it. It was sweet. Sweet like the summer of ’76, sweet like Christmas of ’77, sweet like Harry’s birthday in ’94. So sweet she caught herself smiling to herself.
"Like the cake?" Sirius asked, his lips stretching with that intimacy only the two of them understood.
"Mm-hm." Scarlett took another bite, this time with the fork.
"You’re not going to watch the film, Scar?!" Harry adjusted his glasses.
"Yeah, come watch the film, Mum," Reggie said, patting the bed twice.
Scarlett agreed and climbed onto the bed, crawling carefully because of the bruising along her ribs. She settled between Sirius’s legs, laying back against his torso. He wrapped one arm around her, the other stealing the fork from her hand to take a bite of the cake.
Reggie rolled over and rested his head on Scarlett’s leg. Harry grabbed a pillow and set it in her lap, sharing it with Reg.
The film started. Penny brought popcorn and sat on the edge of the bed.
Sirius set the cake plate aside when he and Scarlett finished, burying his face in the crook of her neck without taking his eyes off the telly, feeling her soft skin prickle at the mere touch.
Scarlett curled in on herself, both hands busy ruffling her son’s hair and her godson’s. It didn’t take long, though, for the pain potion Penny had given her earlier to take stronger effect, and she drifted off.
She wasn’t the only one. Regulus was already softly snoring while Simba watched his ancestors in the stars, and Harry laughed when he peeked over and realised only Sirius was still awake. He turned his attention back to the film, though he was soon tempted to become a subject of Morpheus. Even blinking hard and rubbing his eyes with his knuckles, sleep finally won.
That night, Harry James Potter fell asleep with a smile on his face.
For the first time, his birthday hadn’t been just another day.
It had been a perfect day.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 84: How long before the right one?
Chapter Text
CLII
It was a freezing autumn morning. The try-outs for the Hogwarts Quidditch team had been wrapped up, and some of the starters and reserves had been announced the night before. Professor Minerva had been responsible for the final word on the players, which resulted in a large number of Gryffindors among the starters.
At least, that was what Regulus assumed.
There had been a fierce argument between Scarlett and Marlene McKinnon over the remaining Beater position, since the other one had been secured by Sirius. In the end, Slughorn managed to convince McGonagall to keep Scarlett in the role and, albeit reluctantly, she gave in.
Besides them, James Potter, Evan Rosier and Emmeline Vance (the former Hufflepuff Chaser) had been chosen as Chasers.
The Keeper was some nobody from Ravenclaw called Gilderoy Lockhart or something like that. Regulus truly couldn’t have cared less.
And there he was, watching yet another argument between Minerva and Slughorn. This time, however, it was about who would be the Seeker: him or some girl called Freya Hopper, who had recently joined the Gryffindor team. It was obvious that he would be the starting Seeker; Freya didn’t have enough experience and, although she was small and could dodge players with ease, if a Beater got on her tail, the girl would be knocked out. Or, better yet, killed.
Anyone with two brain cells knew that, but Minerva wouldn’t accept three Slytherins as starters and only two Gryffindors, even if logic was against every single one of her arguments. Not even Potter seemed able to stomach the discussion unfolding in front of them, tapping his foot impatiently against the grass with his arms crossed. Scarlett, beside him, was looking at Sirius, who in turn laced his fingers through hers while smiling.
Regulus clenched his jaw.
He didn’t want to be there. But what choice did he have?
Rosier had ordered him to take part in that stupid circus Dumbledore had put together, so he obediently nodded and offered himself up as one of the clowns, even though it deeply annoyed him.
He tightened his grip around the handle of the state-of-the-art Nimbus in his palm so hard that the wood creaked.
He lifted his face to the sky, to the thick black clouds hanging over them. The wind lashed his hair and carried the fresh scent of rain, though the only thunder echoing across the Quidditch pitch was the flare of his own heart.
He looked back at Sirius and Scarlett barely a metre away from him. They embraced. Whispered to one another. Acted as though the bloody world wasn’t collapsing beneath their feet.
Regulus wanted to scream. He wanted to point a finger in both their faces and shout.
It was all their fault.
The world was going to be swallowed by Voldemort, and it was all their fault.
His core burned, boiled, and flared white-hot. Regulus twisted his lips in disgust. Sirius had been quick to abdicate his poisoned throne, his rusted chains, his warped responsibility.
Sirius ran away.
Regulus stayed.
And there he was—the heir to nothing, the spare part watching his brother be happy after chaining him to a position that had never truly been his.
Regulus had always been the good son, the perfect son.
But it wasn’t enough. It would never be enough. He had been rewarded with a chain around his neck and a tattoo on his forearm.
And Sirius… Sirius spat on his own bloodline and made a point of parading his trophy, steeped in a happiness so genuine Regulus had never seen anything like it before. He was loved, admired, revered. Happy. Even after fucking up his life, digging his own grave and burying Regulus inside it, clasped to the dying legacy of their Black ancestors, Sirius was happy.
Regulus let the air out slowly in a loud, bored hiss, trying to push those thoughts away. He couldn’t accept that Sirius was free. To do that, he would have to admit that he himself had chosen the prison. That he had preferred being condemned to the icy arms of their parents over the warm, ring-adorned hand of his older brother.
Besides, that wasn’t true. Regulus had never chosen any of this. It was all Sirius’s fault—it always had been. His brother wasn’t man enough to shoulder his responsibilities, and Regulus was always the one left to deal with the consequences of his reckless actions. It had always been like that… hadn’t it?
Of course it had. When Sirius hit him, it was because he couldn’t stand having his Hogwarts secrets exposed. That he ran around with the scum of the school. And what happened then? Sirius had whipped him until his back was scarred—marks he still carried to this day.
Sirius had been beaten too, that was true, but… he’d managed to get away with it. He always managed to get away with it.
Someone had to pay. Someone always had to pay. And it was Regulus who paid for his brother’s freedom.
A seething rage pulsed through his veins, widened his pupils and flared his nostrils. Regulus straightened. He scrutinised Scarlett. Watched the way she looked at Sirius, how her blue irises shone with devotion and fascination.
He wanted to be looked at like that.
Even in this, Sirius had stolen what had never belonged to him.
.
.
.
The world turned into an inconceivable blur when Scarlett got drunk. It was as though time stopped—or as though it slipped into a deep state of hibernation, even though ghosts didn’t sleep. Well, at least, that was what he thought.
That ghosts didn’t sleep.
Didn’t feel, didn’t live. Didn’t die.
If to die it’s enough to be alive, then what does it take to live?
Regulus couldn’t say. But he felt anything but dead. Even though his body passed through objects, even though his skin would never feel the warmth of the sun, and no living soul besides Scarlett could hear him…
It was still as though he were alive. It was the life he had before asking Kreacher to take him to that cursed cave. Wanting to be transparent, but seen. Loved, but never hurt. Adored.
Now that he wanted to be more… he could not be.
He lowered his gaze to his feet submerged in the pool water. He couldn’t feel its temperature, but his legs produced ghostly droplets every time he lifted them from the surface.
He had never been in a swimming pool while he was alive.
He had never celebrated. Never given thanks. Never loved.
Regulus Black didn’t know how to be anything other than a ghost.
Lily sat beside him, wrapping her arms around her shins and resting her chin on her knees. The sun was beginning to rise, its fleeting rays passing through them and scattering gold over the gentle ripples of the water. She was a beautiful woman, with fire-red hair and dew-green eyes. He had never really looked at her before—not with such attention as in that moment. He understood why James had fallen in love with her at a single glance.
"Do you think love… is capable of forgiving even the vilest of crimes?" he asked. His low voice was carried by a wind that did not exist, whose gusts caressed his hair and hardened his features.
Lily looked at him sidelong without moving. She didn’t say a word, which made him go on:
"Sirius forgave Scarlett."
She blinked a few times, her gaze gliding to the pool, whose glimmer shimmered in her green eyes and reflected her own inner turmoil.
"James said he loved me. Do you think he would forgive me?"
"Why didn’t you let Scarlett go?" Lily returned the question, her stare turning back to him sharply.
Regulus raised one eyebrow slightly. The sunlight, filtered through his thick lashes, wasn’t enough to soften the iron in his eyes.
Nothing was.
He narrowed his eyes at Lily, lifting his chin to stop her from prying out more than he was willing to reveal.
"It was… an accident." Regulus worried at the dry skin of his lower lip with his teeth. "Rosier activated my watch and… and I didn’t… I didn’t expect Scarlett to show up. He was with me at the time… I had to capture her. It was me or him. And I would never let Scar fall into his clutches."
"That’s not what I’m talking about. You used the information about Orfy to keep her with you! Why?"
Regulus stopped moving his legs in the pool. A mask of coldness covered his astonished face. He wasn’t prepared for that question; even though he had maintained his composure, his expression was beginning to crack.
"Why do you think, Evans? What do you think would have happened to me and my family if I had let her go?" he hissed, like a snake. "Voldemort was very generous with those who were loyal to him, just as he was extremely cruel to deserters. That was why he had hostages from every family whose loyalty he doubted. Selwyn was responsible for that." He shook his head. He didn’t want to revive those images of the past. "Orfy was an exception. They didn’t want anyone to know about him because the Signet was far too valuable."
"How did you manage to keep Rosier quiet?" Lily shot back, the words already on the tip of her tongue.
"We had a deal." The shadows in his eyes stretched across his face, carving out his impassive expression. "Besides, Scarlett was very valuable to the Dark Lord’s cause. Rosier knew that. Crouch did too."
"What was the deal about?"
Regulus rolled his eyes and snorted in scorn.
"I’m not telling you," he muttered, dripping with disdain.
It wasn’t Scarlett who was precious.
It was the child she carried.
Scarlett and Sirius’s child.
The one responsible for Red’s fall… and for the end of the world as well.
But he wasn’t going to say that. Revealing it would mean delving into Reggie’s prophecy, and if his hunch was right and Harry was a Horcrux, that would directly interfere with the child’s well-being. So he didn’t even flinch under the pair of inquisitive green eyes gleaming beneath Lily’s red brows.
"Marl knew. Why… why did you—"
"Because if our farce had even the slightest chance of going wrong… if she were captured by a Death Eater… Scar didn’t want to kill her. I convinced her to do it. It was Marlene or Reggie," Regulus cut her off impatiently. "It was a war. You, more than anyone, know that."
Lily’s rigidity cracked slowly. Her eyes filled with tears. Her lips trembled with grief.
Because she knew.
She knew it all too well.
After all, she had been one of its victims too.
"But you kept her prisoner in your house." The choked, wounded voice didn’t belong to Lily. James emerged between the apple trees, his kind eyes swallowed by the pale light of day reflecting off his glasses. "She wanted to leave and you kept her trapped."
"He would have killed my family!" Regulus snapped his head toward him, fast as a striking snake.
"Maybe they should have died," James went on, his tone so dark that Regulus shuddered. "Maybe…" His voice broke.
Regulus’s eyes widened and his brows arched in shock. James covered his face with his hands, muffling his restrained sob.
"Maybe," Red agreed with remorse. "But I died. I died to save Reggie. Orfy. Scar. I died… to save the bloody world!" His voice rose with every word. "But the death that saved the world was yours."
"It wasn’t just about your family. You never truly cared about your family," Lily said. There was more than pain resonating in her voice—there was remorse, revulsion, and indignation. "You kept her with you to torture your brother."
His mask split straight down the middle. Regulus laughed, shaking his head in denial. There was no humour in his laugh—only insolence, underscoring how absurd Lily’s accusation was. Blazing rage consumed him swiftly, and he had no time to filter his words, nor to control his gestures:
"This has nothing to do with Sirius!" he exploded, springing to his feet so rigid he looked as though he’d been electrocuted. "I wanted… I wanted… I wanted what they have!" he hissed, iron eyes being eaten away by steel tears. "I wanted to be loved… the way they love each other." He panted, clenching his hands into fists at his sides. "Look at what Scarlett did! She killed five people and Sirius forgave her! Sirius accused her of things she never did, hated her for years on end… and still… still they’re together! They love each other, they save each other! They choose each other! Every single time they choose each other! And every single time I’m left alone!" he spat, teeth clenched in a futile attempt to hold back his sobs. "They always leave me alone!"
Lily stood as well, though she didn’t approach him. Regulus now looked as fragile as porcelain, his long sobs accompanied by painful moans, as if that confession were lashing him physically.
Regulus stepped away from the pool’s edge and pressed a hand to his chest, trying to dull the unbearable weight lodged there, but it was impossible. His legs gave out and he dropped to his knees on the grass, curling in on himself and desperately trying to hold his pieces together, to stop his inevitable collapse.
"I just… wanted to be loved," he faltered between stuttering gasps. "I did… all of this… to be… loved… and everyone… hates me…"
"How did you think Scarlett would ever love you if you kept her trapped in your house? Love isn’t control, Regulus," Lily murmured, her voice trembling. She took a step towards him.
"Because if I let her go, she’d run straight back to Sirius!"
The slap that struck his face was so hard he toppled onto his side on the grass, his cheek burning and tingling, his dazed eyes lifting to Lily’s merciless stare.
She stood over him, her hand still raised in the air.
"Do you really think caging someone will make them love you?!" Her retort struck him like a bullet.
Regulus’s dilated pupils quivered beneath his black brows. Resentment, shame, fury, disgust, and rage all battled in the dark threads of his grey irises, but another feeling rose and won out—harshness and cynicism, resolute, smothering the conflict entirely and turning his expression to stone.
"No, but… this way… I wouldn’t be alone." He wiped the tears from his cheeks with more force than necessary. "I wouldn’t be abandoned." He cleared his throat, slowly composing himself. "Scarlett was never going to love me, because she already loved Sirius. I don’t know… I don’t know why I thought… she might be willing to love me."
Lily twisted her mouth. Of course Regulus thought that way. He believed love was a game of scarcity. That if Sirius had it, he couldn’t. If Scarlett loved his brother, then she wouldn’t be willing to love him.
"I… I just…" Regulus blinked hard. "I was only trying to be the man Sirius never was. To take on his son and—"
"No, Regulus…" Lily cut him off sharply. "Sirius is a real man. And you?" She leaned down until her face was level with his. "You’re just a boy with a god complex. A little boy afraid of love."
Her eyes were a vivid, intense green, on the verge of swallowing him in poison. Lily’s face turned as red as her hair. She straightened and stepped back very slowly, fighting the overwhelming urge to throttle him.
Lily walked into the house with heavy steps.
James stayed where he was, motionless for a moment while the lawn rippled with the morning’s gentle wind. He watched the sunbeams paint the crown of the weeping willow, its leaves casting a lace-like shadow over his lenses. He breathed in deeply, drawing in the illusory freshness of plants and the chlorine from the pool.
[The Smiths — Last Night I Dreamt That Somebody Loved Me]
He adjusted his glasses and sat down beside Regulus. Regulus’s eyes were as grey as James’s were brown. Both had black hair, but James’s was always a mess. Regulus’s, meticulously combed. His dark green coat was always immaculate, and his face had been trained to wipe every line clean of expression.
Why had Sirius loved one so much and despised the other so deeply?
Last night, I dreamt
That somebody loved me
No hope, no harm
Just another false alarm
For a second, James’s heart tightened. He couldn’t say why Sirius considered him more of a brother than Red would ever be; perhaps it was because James never cared to hide what he felt, perhaps because he cared too much about showing Sirius he wouldn’t be scrutinised for simply being himself. Perhaps it was because, when James met him, all Sirius Black had wanted was to be loved.
James had loved him.
And Sirius had loved him back with his whole heart.
He lowered his gaze to the boy curled up beside him. To his brother’s little brother.
If Sirius Black was the desire to love, then Regulus Black was the fear of being destroyed by it.
"You want to be loved, but you don’t believe you can be. So you destroy. Because that’s what you know how to do… destroy," James murmured. Beneath his veneer of calm, his tone was accusatory. "You destroyed your relationship with Pandora, with Sirius, with Scarlett. You pushed everyone away and then think you were abandoned?" He sighed in frustration. "No one abandoned you, Regulus. You’re the one who sent them away."
Regulus hugged his legs and buried his head between his knees. He covered his ears with his hands. He didn’t want to hear James’s lecture.
He wanted to feel loved without having to beg for it.
"Go away, James!" he shouted, humiliated.
So, tell me how long
Before the last one?
And tell me how long
Before the right one?
James didn’t move, staring at him with his brow knit in opposition. The space between them was filled by the murmur of the water rippling against the edges of the pool.
He wanted to leave. Regulus’s actions not only disappointed him, they disgusted him. Though he understood his pain—the unrequited love, the abandonment, the eternal comparison—the cruelty of his actions was irreconcilable with any justification he could offer, even if Regulus wasn’t cruel for pleasure. No.
Regulus was cruel out of self-defence, which made him even more dangerous.
The sun had already risen in the streaked sky, its rays falling over the house and spilling sinuous shadows across the garden, swallowing them in warmth—even though they couldn’t feel it.
James stretched his fingers over the shaded grass. His pale light illuminated where the sun could not reach.
"What were you more afraid of? Love, or loneliness?" James whispered, resting an elbow on his knee as he stretched out the other leg. "Actually, you don’t need to answer. You died with one… and without the other."
Regulus shuddered. He lifted his face just enough for his eyes to be seen, the iron cracked by bitterness.
"Do you… do you think…" He gasped, his voice low and hollow, like an echo. "Do you think love can redeem me?"
It was a stupid question. Regulus knew that, but for some reason… he wanted to be wrong. He begged to be wrong. Perhaps loving—being crushed and destroyed by the feeling—was the way to purge his demons. It would be the way to redeem himself with those he had hurt. It would be the way to, perhaps one day, learn how to love for real… with a love that shelters, not a love that suffocates.
"If there’s anything that can redeem you, Red…" James said softly, "it’s love. Possibly."
.
.
.
The Great Hall buzzed with its usual morning chaos of chatter, laughter, and the clinking of cutlery and goblets. Owls darted between the enchanted candles, dropping letters and parcels onto the tables of the four Houses.
Scarlett kept her eyes on her own plate, stabbing her fork into the duck pie until it completely fell apart.
A parcel landed in front of her, knocking over a goblet of wine onto Mary’s parchment (who let out an irritated shriek at the owl), and Remus caught his letter amid the mess of cake that had been thrown there.
Scarlett gripped her fork so tightly her knuckles turned white.
“…and then I said it was a toad, not a potion!” Peter blurted out, laughing with his mouth full of food.
She forced a laugh as her chest tightened. Across the table, Lily and James seemed very busy arguing about prefect patrols with an intimacy that made them look like a couple, even though Lily still vehemently denied her feelings for James.
“I’m not swapping my Thursday with Vance just because she wants to go out with Bones!” she crossed her arms.
James rubbed his eyes beneath his glasses.
“Lily… she always swaps with you. Just agree…” he replied, stuffing toast into his mouth as he yawned.
Beside Scarlett, Sirius kept his eyes fixed on the Slytherin table.
“Don’t do it,” Remus murmured, without taking his eyes off the letter he was reading.
“I’m not doing anything…” Sirius lifted his hands to prove his innocence.
That very second, at the Slytherin table, Snape’s pumpkin juice exploded in his face, splashing his sallow skin orange and staining his robes.
“Black!” Snape jumped to his feet.
“I didn’t do anything!” Sirius protested, slipping a hand around Scarlett’s waist as her distant gaze turned to him. “You saw me do something, love?”
“No,” she replied flatly.
“Sirius!” Lily left the table, furious. “You’re impossible!”
Sirius shrugged, fanning the air in front of his face as if Lily’s reaction were an exaggeration.
“I didn’t even have my wand in my hand…”
While the two of them argued and James and Peter tried to break it up, Remus remained absolutely silent. Scarlett watched him through the clamour of Lily and Sirius’s voices. His hands trembled as he finished reading, and his face suddenly drained of colour. Without a word, he folded the paper and stood up.
“Moony?” James called after him, frowning.
Remus didn’t answer. Scarlett also left the table, following him in an attempt to get away from the noise. She caught up with him in the gardens, beneath the livid sky heavy with clouds and flashes of thunder.
“Rem?” she called, coming closer. “Are you alright?”
He stopped, his back to her. The paper he had so carefully folded was crushed in his palm. He turned his face just enough to be in profile, but didn’t look at her.
“LEAVE ME ALONE!” Remus shouted, his voice lashing the stone fountain and sending the birds in the nearby trees flying.
Scarlett stiffened, her heart racing. She ran through every moment of the morning in her mind. Had she done something wrong?
She couldn’t bring herself to ask. Remus quickened his pace and walked away.
.
.
.
Scarlett didn’t get the chance to tell Sirius, James, and Peter about Remus’s behaviour. Her boyfriend was far too busy grumbling that he hadn’t been the one to blow up Snape’s juice (even though everyone knew he was lying), and James was clearly irritated that Sirius had done it and ruined his moment with Lily.
"What moment?!" Sirius asked acidly. "You were just talking."
"We were sorting out important things, Padfoot!"
"Oh, Prongs… let’s be honest, Lily wouldn’t even talk to you if you weren’t both Head Prefects…"
James stopped dead in the corridor leading to the Music Room. Peter crashed straight into him, dropping all his things onto the floor. Scarlett took a deep breath and helped him gather the scattered quills and ink pots, while James and Sirius didn’t even look at them.
"Seriously, Padfoot?!" He shoved his glasses up his nose hard, lips tightening. "Wow. Thanks for the support. You’re everyone’s best mate."
"No, I didn’t… I didn’t mean it like that, Prongs…"
James didn’t stay to hear his explanations. He straightened, spun on his heel, and strode off down the corridor towards the classroom with sharp, echoing steps, leaving the three of them behind.
"What’s wrong with him?!" Sirius complained, looking down at Scarlett and Peter crouched on the floor.
"What’s wrong with you?" Scarlett shot back brutally. "Listen to the things you say to him!"
"I… I…" Sirius’s eyes widened at his girlfriend’s reaction. He looked at Peter, searching for support, but he only shrugged.
Scarlett shook her head in disapproval and walked past the two of them.
Professor Mara was already waiting for them at the piano, tuning the instruments with her wand and arranging the floating sheet music.
The lesson passed in a blur.
Scarlett barely paid attention to the day’s music explanation. It was only the second week of music lessons they’d had, after Remus had successfully managed to bring energy into the Music Room and plug the electric instruments into the amplifiers. Not that Scarlett needed to pay attention—she could read sheet music backwards—but even James and Sirius didn’t seem to be taking in a word of what the professor was saying.
Scarlett’s gaze drifted around the room, stopping at Remus’s empty chair, his bass resting on its stand, the amp switched off. James played a few notes while hunting for the right distortion, and Sirius tapped at the drums any old way, on autopilot.
Scarlett ran her fingers over the piano keys, trying to go through a passage of Georgy Porgy, but missed one note after another. The keys felt unfamiliar beneath her fingers. No one was really there… except Peter, sitting in the corner of the room reading his stupid magazine about Muggle superheroes.
James leaned back and took the pick out of his mouth.
"Do you know where Moony is?"
Scarlett merely nodded, her eyes still on the piano.
"Where?"
She shrugged, swallowing with difficulty.
“I went after him… he shouted at me and disappeared.”
James straightened, shooting an urgent look at Sirius, who was tangled up in his drumming, tapping one of the sticks against the rim of the snare. Then he turned back to Scar.
“He shouted at you?”
“Yeah… I don’t know…” Scarlett caught her breath.
For some reason, she felt an absurd urge to cry.
She pressed down on a key, and the dissonant sound made her snatch her fingers back at once, as if she’d been burned.
.
.
.
Remus didn’t show up on the Marauder’s Map. James and Peter headed for the Undercroft, while Sirius and Scarlett climbed the Astronomy Tower towards the Room of Requirement.
The staircase was empty, lit by flickering torches that deepened the shadows of Scar and Sirius sliding over the steps. The light gilded Sirius’s pale face and the freckles on Scarlett’s cheeks.
They were wrapped in an unyielding silence.
Scarlett felt Sirius’s gaze swinging back and forth to her like a pendulum. They were holding hands, though it felt more like a formality than a gesture of affection. The icy wind howled along the walls and brushed their calves. Scarlett stopped climbing when Sirius frowned at a nearby painting of a ship in a raging sea.
He knocked on the frame twice.
“Safe harbour,” he whispered.
The frame cracked, and the painting swung open, revealing a passageway.
They looked at one another. Words hovered between them, but neither dared give them shape. Sirius knew when Scarlett wanted quiet, and as much as he wanted to unravel the thorns in the way she’d been acting, it was better to give her space.
Scarlett was starting to slip back into that catatonic and explosive version of herself that had been born after her parents’ death, and Sirius was still learning how to deal with her.
“I… I’ll check this passage,” Sirius broke the silence, his deep voice echoing off the walls.
She nodded.
“I’ll check the Room of Requirement and I’ll meet you in the Astronomy classroom.” She forced a tight smile. Sirius squeezed her hand before letting go and giving her one of his dimpled smiles, the kind that set butterflies loose in her stomach.
Dazed, Scarlett watched Sirius step into the passage and vanish among the shifting shadows. He followed it all the way through, emerging onto the terrace above the Charms classroom. He was met by the bitter afternoon wind, dry and abrasive as it heralded the end of autumn. His gaze swept over what should have been a crumbling room, damp slate tiles stretching out, until it stopped on a curled-up figure beside a column carved with lilies.
If it hadn’t been for the fire-red hair, Sirius might have sworn it was a statue.
But no. It was just Lily Evans sitting on the ground, her knees hugged to her chest, her face buried in her Gryffindor cloak.
Sirius cleared his throat before approaching. Lily quickly wiped her face with the back of her sleeve and forced a smile as false as the one Scarlett had given him moments earlier.
“Sirius… what—” She cleared her throat. “What are you doing here?”
He stopped a few steps away, lifting his gaze to the view: the tower windows glittered with the cascade of light the sun spilled over them, the stones gleaming like silver beneath the moonlight.
“I could ask you the same,” he replied calmly.
“This place can only be accessed by prefects. Unless… of course James told you the password to the passage!” she grumbled, irritable.
“We’re looking for Remus,” Sirius kept his tone even. “He vanished after breakfast.”
“Oh…” Lily looked away when he met her eyes. “He must be ill again…”
She tried to stuff the folded letter she was holding into her cloak pocket, but couldn’t seem to find it.
“Is that letter why you were crying?”
“No.” She lied, glancing at the letter and then back at Sirius. “Of course not…”
Lily knew Sirius could be tactless at times, but she hadn’t expected him to simply snatch the letter from her hand without a shred of decorum, completely ignoring her personal space and privacy. It happened so fast she barely had time to react beyond widening her eyes and parting her lips.
Sirius remained impassive. He merely crumpled the letter slowly, the paper creaking between his fingers. Then he tossed it upwards, drew his wand, and incinerated it before it could reach the ground. The ashes danced to the rhythm of the wind beneath Lily’s stunned gaze.
“She doesn’t deserve you.” He lowered his hand to Lily’s shoulder, where her red hair fell like lava. “Petunia doesn’t deserve you.”
Lily squeezed her eyes shut, her voice catching in her throat.
“I just…” She wiped her nose with the back of her hand. “I just wanted her to love me. That’s all. She’s my sister, for God’s sake. She should love me back!”
Sirius nodded. He crouched in front of her, his forehead so close it almost touched hers. It wasn’t romantic or invasive; it was more… the acknowledgement of a pain that bent both their hearts.
Of course… Potter, Lupin, Pettigrew… Scarlett… they are your family.
“I know how it feels,” he murmured hoarsely. “I wanted my brother to love me too.”
Lily looked at him with reddened eyes. In that green, Sirius saw the same resentment that gnawed at the silver of his own. Rejection hurt. Above all, rejection from someone you’ve loved since childhood, who now doesn’t return your feelings or your longing with the same intensity. As though shared blood or forced coexistence hadn’t been enough to sow the affection and regard siblings ought to have.
Sirius pulled her into a tight embrace.
.
.
.
Scarlett watched the door appear where the wall had been, carved from dark, heavy wood. She pushed it open with her shoulder.
The Room of Requirement looked exactly as the Dueling Club had left it: training dummies scattered along the walls, chairs arranged in front of a blackboard bearing Dorcas’s last explanation about effective spell sequences, and only the fireplace on the far side of the room lit. In the centre, Remus.
His scar-lined face was wet. His eyes were swollen. His breathing ragged. Wand in hand, he hissed one spell after another at a dummy already burnt, torn, and twisted. The target staggered and righted itself on its own, only to be struck again. And again. And again.
“Remus…?” Scarlett called, hesitation colouring her voice.
He stopped for a second. His arm trembled from gripping the wand. His chest heaved. His shoulders shook.
“Go away, Scarlett,” he gasped, without looking at her.
“What happened?” she pressed, taking a step forward.
Remus whipped his face round to her violently, the brown of his eyes eaten away by fury, turning gold. Tears spilled from them, gleaming on a face drained of all colour. He was white as a corpse.
“GO AWAY!”
Scarlett felt her blood thicken. Her body went rigid. She had never been afraid of Remus before—not until that moment. She knew it wasn’t him speaking, it was the wolf, but her survival instinct silenced every voice trying to rationalise the situation and made her step back.
“Moony…” she tried again, her voice shaking. “Tell me what’s going on. I… I’m here.”
“MY MUM DIED!” Remus bellowed at the top of his lungs, his voice tearing his throat apart. “SHE DIED, FUCK! HAPPY? NOW GO AWAY!”
Scarlett blinked a few times, stunned.
“Remus…”
He turned fully towards her. Remus was taller than all the Marauders. The way he straightened and raised his wand, as though he were about to attack her, made every hair on her body stand on end.
“ARE YOU DEAF, FOR FUCK’S SAKE?! GO AWAY!”
With her heart hammering in her chest, Scarlett ran. She ran like prey fleeing a hunter, not looking back, only darting glances to either side in search of another escape route.
The corridor outside the Room of Requirement seemed narrower, stretched out. Suffocating.
She leapt down the last steps to the Astronomy classroom, collapsing to her knees on the polished wood. Her stomach twisted, her body shook with terror.
Remus’s mother had died.
She swallowed hard. She knew what that was. She knew the sour taste of the emptiness no one could fill. She knew what it was like to want to go back in time just to be able to give one more hug, breathe in one more familiar scent, to be able to say I love you one more time.
Scarlett didn’t lift her head when she heard James approach. She simply squeezed her eyelids shut and turned her face away, with a completely unfounded sense of shame. She shouldn’t have felt that in her friend’s presence, but she had no control over the boiling spiral churning in her chest at that moment.
James sat down beside her. He stretched out an arm and pulled her closer. Scarlett didn’t resist. She let herself slide against him, her head resting on his narrow shoulder, hiding her face there, against his chest, while he wrapped both arms around her and rested his chin on the top of her head the way Sirius so often did.
"Did you find him?" The question came only after a long, long stretch of silence. Scarlett sobbed softly and nodded.
"We need… to go to the ice-cream parlour… in Diagon Alley." She lifted her gaze to James. Her request sounded more like a plea.
"You want to get ice cream… on a Wednesday before lunch?!" James raised his eyebrows, frowning.
"It’s not for me. It’s for Remus." That was all she said.
James simply nodded and helped her to her feet.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 85: Rainbow at the end of the storm
Chapter Text
CLIII
Sirius opened his eyes very slowly.
It took him a few seconds to take in where he was. Not out of disorientation, though. It was because of the strange sensation of waking without chaos flooding his mind before he was even fully conscious.
Daylight crept timidly into the bedroom through the subtle gaps in the blinds. It scattered small glimmers wherever it touched: the headboard, the Pensieve on the sideboard, the bleached hair spilling across his shoulder.
Scarlett’s unmistakable scent was interwoven with his own cologne that Regulus had used before Harry’s birthday and his godson’s natural smell, something floral that reminded him of Lily.
His gaze travelled slowly down the platinum strands, whose dark roots were already showing, trailing along the pale, almost translucent skin, dusted with freckles. Scarlett was still asleep, with gentle spasms in her pale lips. Her closed eyelids were sheltered by long, curved lashes of reddish-brown.
Scarlett slept deeply in his arms.
The warmth of her body flooded his chest, spread through his veins, and burrowed into his heart. The wave of peace that washed through his senses and his consciousness left a pleasant lingering feeling at his core—the kind that comes with having the person you love nestled against your chest.
Sirius ran his fingers delicately down her back, avoiding the ribs. It wasn’t a dream, it was real.
It was Scarlett Gaunt in the summer of 1994, there with him, snug in his arms as if it were the safest place in the whole world.
He slowly filled his lungs with air, afraid of waking her.
In the past, Sirius had loved Scarlett because of the part of himself he saw in her. Even though she was so much more than that, much more than a cracked reflection in the mirror, much more than his other half. People aren’t halves. Even if they were very alike, they were also somewhat different. They had been through different things and saw the world in different ways.
Sirius loved her all the same. He loved Scarlett as a whole. He was not a man of halves. That’s why he had drunk in her soul, her crimes and her fears as she confessed to him the previous night. He had taken on Scarlett’s nightmares, demons and mistakes as his own. He accepted her and forgave her. He sheltered her and loved her.
Just as she had always done with him. Scarlett had been right. No matter what shit he pulled, she was always there to forgive him and give him the chance to be someone better. Why couldn’t he do the same for her?
A murmur behind him pulled him out of his reverie. He turned his face to the side, noticing Regulus tangled in the sheet, curled up like a cocoon. The black wavy hair falling across his forehead and his lips whispering unintelligible words.
Sirius craned his neck to the other side, spotting Harry behind Scarlett. His glasses were squashed against his face and his mouth hung slightly open in heavy sleep. The scar on his forehead stared back at him.
He blinked hard, wondering why the hell they were all there…
Oh, that was right. They’d watched a film the previous night and the boys had fallen asleep in bed with them.
He couldn’t help the smile that tugged at his lips. Unlike the bitter smiles he had worn in those last days, this one was an expression of contentment. Joy.
He closed his eyes and buried his face in Scarlett’s hair, intoxicating himself with the scent that made the past project itself at the back of his mind with its golden, nostalgic aura. Of when he used to wake up in his dormitory or in the Undercroft with his girl with flowers in her hair sheltered in his heart.
A movement made him open his eyes again.
Harry took off his glasses and rubbed his eyes with his knuckles, disoriented. His hair stuck up in every possible direction. His gaze fixed on Scarlett in front of him, then on Sirius, and he controlled his breathing.
Reggie moved next, grumbling something about heat and cake. He screwed his eyes shut and pulled the pillow closer to his chest, stretching his legs.
Sirius raised his index finger to his lips, signalling for them to be quiet.
The potion he had given Scarlett the previous night would make her rest until late morning, unless she was stubborn and decided to wake up earlier. Her body needed it. Her mind as well.
Carefully, Sirius leaned his body to the side, laying Scarlett down onto the mattress bit by bit. His chest was numb, as was his right arm, but he worked around it by supporting her head with his left hand to swap his chest for the pillow. He slipped out of the bed and pulled the blanket from the foot of it and covered her. Scarlett shifted and licked her lips, but did not wake.
Sirius left the bedroom on tiptoe, followed by Reggie and Harry.
In the kitchen, Remus had one hand holding the newspaper, the other busy making coffee.
"Morning," he grunted, sleepy.
"Scar shouldn’t wake up early," Sirius warned, heading straight for the pan cupboard. "I gave her the strongest potion we had for pain and for sleeping."
"Are you going out?" Regulus asked, watching Harry set the table with plates and cutlery.
"I am." Sirius took the pancake batter and the eggs from the fridge. "I need to do the final assessment for the Department of Magical Law Enforcement exam."
Regulus grabbed a jar of strawberry jam and some maple syrup. He put the sliced bread in the toaster and sneakily stuck his finger into the jam to taste it.
Sirius poured the batter into the frying pan and felt around the counter for his metal cigarette case, but didn’t find it. He checked the highest shelf of the cupboard and the little kitchen table. Nothing.
"Have you seen my cigarette case?" He crouched down, rummaging through the drawers.
"No." Remus replied without taking his eyes off the coffee pot.
With a long sigh, Sirius gave up. He’d bought the case just over a week ago to keep his cigarettes from getting crushed. Maybe he’d left it in the bedroom. Or in the magical pocket of some trousers, which happened often. Maybe Penny herself had hidden it.
It wouldn’t be the first time.
He finished making the pancakes, stacking them on a plate. The smell was the same as Christmas mornings back when Uncle Alphard used to make pancakes with strawberries.
The smell of childhood. Of home.
The memory stretched his lips into another tender smile.
"Eat everything." He ordered, putting on a serious tone. "And if Scar wakes up, ask her to wait for me. Don’t let her do anything stupid." The order was aimed at Remus, who shot him a sideways look and rolled his eyes.
"She really is alright?" Harry jumped in surprise when the toast popped up. "I mean… after yesterday…"
"Relax, Harry, you only ran over my mum. It’s not a big deal." Regulus said dryly, giving him a pat on the shoulder.
Sirius’s smile turned into a laugh, and even Remus covered his mouth to hold it in.
Harry pressed his lips together, finding no humour in the three of them at first, but soon he was infected too and started laughing. Sirius downed a cup of coffee, shoved a piece of pancake into his mouth, and ruffled his hair as he passed by.
"She’s going to be fine, Harry." Sirius gave him a wink and returned to the bedroom.
.
.
.
The moment she opened her eyes, Scarlett regretted waking up. Her ribs hurt—less than the night before, still—but the bruise around her eye was swollen from crying, and her entire body throbbed in unison with her heart.
She blinked slowly; her eyes were heavy. The meagre light slipping through the blinds stung her retinas. As soon as her vision focused on the bedroom that was so familiar, her fingers immediately traced the T-shirt she was wearing.
Sirius’s T-shirt. The memory of her confession in the bath came back, stirring something warm through her body. She let the thought linger only until her fingertips released the wrinkled fabric.
No. She couldn’t think about that. Not now.
Even if a sense of peace—real or illusory—was spreading through her chest…
Her head ached. As if, with every pulse, a sledgehammer struck her.
Scarlett massaged her temples, her fingers cold and unsteady. Her hands wouldn’t stop shaking. She tried to steady them on her thigh, but the spasms were relentless.
"Shit," she murmured, closing her eyes. Her stomach was churning. She felt slightly sick, even though she’d barely eaten the day before. Or the days before.
The distant smell of coffee from the kitchen forced her to breathe in deeply to hold back the urge to bolt to the bathroom.
The air felt thinner. Breathing took effort, which made her ribs protest with immediate stabbing pains. She sat on the edge of the bed and forced herself to stand, barefoot. The wooden floor was cold beneath her sweaty feet. The silence in the house wasn’t unfamiliar to her. In the past, when she and Sirius had been alone there, it was common for the quiet to swallow most of the space.
But she and Sirius weren’t in the past, and they weren’t alone.
Each step demanded more energy than the last. Her ears rang and the light bothered her, even softened.
She found Harry in the sitting room playing Super Nintendo. His face was scrunched in concentration as Donkey Kong leapt from one platform to another, smashing the map while Mario tried to grab the key. A nearly empty can of fizzy drink sat beside him. The music grew louder and louder as she approached.
Too loud.
A fleeting bout of dizziness made her brace both hands on the sofa. The sound thundered inside her skull, pricking every note straight into her brain.
Harry noticed her, because he paused the game and looked over his shoulder.
"Scar! You’re awake. How are you feeling?"
"Like I’ve been run over by a bicycle," she muttered, hoarse, trying to laugh, but all she managed was a grimace. "And you? Enjoying the game?"
Harry didn’t seem to notice how unwell she was. If he did, he ignored it.
"I’m stuck on a level. I think I’m going to ask Reg to help me get past it. He went skateboarding with Luana."
"You shouldn’t be on your feet." Remus appeared from the kitchen, his eyes glued to the folder in his hands while a quill floated beside him.
The mention of Regulus made Scarlett’s head ache even more. She needed to talk to him. Needed to make peace. Apologise for having left. She fixed her gaze on Remus.
"Where’s Sirius?" She forced the question out, her lips tightening as a sharp stab shot through her ribs.
"At the Ministry. He’ll be back later." He leaned against the wooden doorway of the kitchen.
"What’s that?" She narrowed her eyes, trying to make sure the crest on the folder really was the Ministry’s.
"Reports. My business. Nothing important." Remus snapped the file shut at once. "I’ll call Reg, lunch is almost ready…"
"I’ll call him." Scarlett pushed herself away from the sofa and raised a hand in front of her face as she trudged towards the hall. "Where’s the skate park?"
Harry turned off the television.
"I’ll show you where it is."
"Scarlett… you shouldn’t go out." Remus’s warning was very clearly ignored.
Scarlett grabbed Sirius’s aviator sunglasses from the sideboard, slipped into his jacket, and Harry opened the door.
The sun hit her like a punch. The brutal, stifling, humid heat typical of the British summer at its peak seemed determined to scald her right there on the pavement. The streets were packed with families—utterly clueless, in Scarlett’s opinion—wandering about as if it were the best time of year and not literal hell.
Scarlett shoved the sunglasses against her face, searching for some protection from the light, even as brightness leaked in from the sides. The metal frames were already hot. She began to sweat and wasn’t sure whether it was the temperature itself or the internal heat that made her feel as though her skin was melting from the inside out, as if her core were on fire.
Harry walked beside her, animated by whatever it was he was chattering about—something involving a monkey talking to a lion that stared at the stars (she honestly didn’t quite get it). The words went in one ear and straight out the other.
She tried to listen to him. She really did. She wanted to.
But she simply couldn’t. It felt as though he were speaking Greek.
And there was that bizarre sensation that her body was floating… or sinking. She could no longer tell the difference. She stopped abruptly at a corner, squeezed her dry eyes shut, and clenched her fist.
"Scar? Are you alright?" Harry asked, his brows knitting with concern.
"I’m great." There was so much sarcasm in her voice that she mentally scolded herself for it. "Sorry, Harry, I’m just… tired."
"Is your rib hurting?"
"Mm-hm." Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut.
Harry nodded, but didn’t look convinced.
They turned right and headed down a narrower street, hemmed in by graffiti-covered walls.
She spotted Reggie and Luana easily.
Both were sitting on the edge of one of the ramps beneath the shadow cast by the side stand, skateboards discarded nearby, laughing about something Luana was saying. Something shone brightly in Regulus’s hand, forcing Scarlett to shut her eyes when the dizziness came back, hitting her with a skittish wave. She staggered sideways and leaned against Harry, who caught her quickly, eyes widening.
"Scar?"
Scarlett couldn’t answer. Nausea, vertigo and sickness hit her all at once and her heart began to race. The pressure in her chest surged like a furious tide, tightening around her throat, determined to suffocate her in every possible way.
Even so, she kept walking, shaking and unsteady. What was a bit of a hangover for someone who’d been fucked over for years in Azkaban?
Pfft. Nothing.
She wiped the back of her hand across her eyes without removing the sunglasses and looked back at Regulus, now more clearly. There was something strange in front of his face, a haze, and he put something to his mouth that made her stomach lurch.
Her trembling was now fuelled by fury, swallowing all her pain whole. What the hell was Regulus doing?!
Harry tried to follow her, but Scarlett raised a hand—an aggressive warning that made him step back.
The moment Reggie noticed her, the smile died on his lips. He stood up immediately, tossed the cigarette to the ground and crushed it under the sole of his trainer, hoping Scarlett hadn’t seen what he’d been doing.
"Fuck…" Luana glanced back and let out a nervous laugh.
"Regulus Sirius Black… are you smoking?!" Scarlett asked, her voice raw. She stopped a few steps away from them, lifting her chin to look at him properly through the smudged lenses.
"I… Mum… it’s nothing… it’s just…" He babbled a string of incomprehensible words and fell silent.
"Just what?" Scarlett took a step forward. Her skin pulsed, the pain in her ribs sharpening, the sweat unbearable. The humid heat crawled up her spine. "Was it you who gave him that?" Her face turned to Luana, whose shocked reaction was to shake her head in denial.
"I took it… I took it… Sirius’s cigarette case." Regulus swallowed hard, his gaze flickering.
"Regulus… for God’s sake…" Scarlett didn’t know how, but she let the air escape her mouth and tried to breathe in, though her head was spinning wildly. "You’re fifteen! You’re not old enough to be… sneaking around smoking!"
Regulus pulled his lips into his mouth, trying to hold something back. Then he practically spat it out:
"You drink until you pass out, so maybe the genetics just kick in, don’t they, Mum?!"
Scarlett put a hand to her stomach. Reggie’s retort had the same effect as an iron fist crushing her insides, churning her gut, strangling her words. Pain tore through every pore of her body, flaying every inch of skin. She gasped. She didn’t know whether what she was feeling was caused by Reggie’s provocation or the hangover.
No.
It wasn’t a hangover. Scarlett didn’t know what it was, but she knew it wasn’t a hangover.
"I never wanted… you to be like me." Scarlett snapped, her voice so low it was breaking. "I’m trying, Regulus. I’m trying, for fuck’s sake!"
Her mouth was dry. Her sweaty palms rubbed against each other incessantly, searching for something, trying to summon a cold glass bottle that would solve all her pain in a matter of minutes.
Her legs gave way and she grabbed the handrail beside her. She heard Harry running towards her. Luana stood up, her shadow shielding Scarlett from the sun.
"Mum?" Reggie called, and his worried voice echoed through her mind a hundred times over.
"Go home," Scarlett asked, her voice a thread. "Both of you, go home." She turned her face towards Harry. "You too, Luana."
"Scar…" Harry insisted, stretching his arm towards hers.
"Go home." Scarlett pleaded, teeth clenched. "Just go. Please."
Harry hesitated, and Reggie pulled him back. The two of them moved away slowly, still looking at her. Scarlett remained there under the sun, trembling. Sweat ran down her temples, her arms. Sirius’s T-shirt clung to her body.
She forced herself to walk.
The house seemed impossibly far away. Scarlett staggered along the pavement, her skin feeling as though it were being torn apart by the sun’s merciless glare and her oesophagus burning with nausea. It took real effort to take a single step on unsteady legs and orient herself through blurred vision. She felt as though she were inside a boiling pot.
She could barely believe it when she reached the door. Shade.
Finally, shade. She rested her face against the cool wood for a second, her brain trying to remember how a door handle worked.
She filled her lungs with air and went inside.
The smell of food being prepared tied her stomach in knots. She took off the sunglasses, set them on the sideboard, and stumbled into the sitting room. The house was cool compared to the outside, and the contrast made her skin prickle.
Remus appeared in the kitchen doorway.
"I told you not to go." He scolded her, slinging a tea towel over his shoulder.
Scarlett ignored him. She didn’t have the patience to deal with Remus right then.
"Where is he?" The question was directed at Harry, who sat on the sofa as if he’d done something wrong too.
"He’s out in the garden."
Scarlett nodded. She would talk to Regulus later. She walked straight past Harry and Remus and down the corridor to Sirius’s bedroom, stopping in the bathroom. She didn’t know exactly why she’d gone there; she only knew she needed something cold, silence, and a place where she could be left alone if her body simply decided to give up on everything.
She collapsed onto the white tiles, hot breath spilling from her lips and dampening the floor beneath her face. She was sweating cold. Her clothes were soaked through. Nausea swallowed everything—her breathing, her vision, her sense of touch.
Anguish sank its sharp claws into her heart. Scarlett felt it bleed, spilling through her chest, clogging her lungs and strangling her brain. She was crying, though her face was so wet with sweat she could no longer tell one from the other. Her hands wouldn’t stop shaking.
It was because of the pain. Or the guilt. Or the hunger.
Or the sun.
Or the confrontation with Regulus.
Maybe because of all of it together.
She closed her eyes. The cold floor reminded her of Azkaban, even though the tiles were white and dry, unlike the murky, slick stone she knew so well. Still, she had to force her eyelids open and convince herself she wasn’t imprisoned when a cascade of shivers made her writhe and the heat transformed into a slicing cold, giving her the sensation of being attacked by a Dementor.
It wasn’t Azkaban.
It wasn’t Azkaban.
It wasn’t Azkaban.
Being sober… felt the same as having been attacked by a Dementor for so long she no longer even knew her own name. It was the same sensation. The sweat, the palpitations, the shaking, the nausea.
Being sober was fucking awful.
.
.
.
Scarlett sighed. In one arm, a tub of ice cream. In the other hand, she held her wand, which glowed with Lumos. She waved to James outside the Room of Requirement and pushed the door open slowly so as not to make a sound, though the noise of it closing still announced her arrival.
Remus was curled up in the corner of the room, lying on his side on the floor, knees pulled to his chest, nose blocked. The pale light washed his light-brown hair into a whitish shade, making it resemble fine white beach sand. The little skin left uncovered by his uniform looked greyer than it already was and shone in a spectral way.
She didn’t say anything. She simply sat down at a considerable distance, cross-legged, and opened the tub. She pulled a spoon from her pocket and tasted the choconuts ice cream, closing her eyes when the sugary flavour danced across her palate. She savoured a few more spoonfuls and then pulled another utensil from her pocket, stabbing it into the ice cream.
Holding it between her teeth, she gave the tub a shove. It slid across the dirty floor and bumped into Remus’s shin.
He remained inert as a corpse.
Scarlett waited patiently.
Remus’s trembling hand moved slowly, feeling along the floor until it reached the tub. He pulled it closer and took hold of the spoon. He tilted his face upwards and squeezed his eyes shut, stifling a sob that threatened to spill from his lips as he put the utensil into his mouth.
He kept eating, slowly. Chewing, even though ice cream doesn’t need to be chewed. It wasn’t the ice cream he was chewing; it was longing. Grief. Anger. Guilt. The regret of not having said more, not having done more, not having been more.
Remus wept openly. His whole body shook, tears spilling uncontrollably. And still, he kept eating… as if, if he stopped, his mother would die all over again. She was already dead, but he refused to accept it. He didn’t want to understand. He didn’t want to grasp the concept of death because doing so would mean admitting that Hope Lupin would never smile at him again, never tell him she loved him, never pull him into her arms when the world turned to ash between his fingers like it was doing right now.
He dragged himself towards Scarlett as if swimming through a raging sea, trying to surface even as the current strained to pull him under, the waves trying to knock him down. He laid his head in her lap, his hands clutching desperately at the Slytherin cloak, his chest tightening with sharp, tearing sobs.
Scarlett placed a hand in his hair, her fingers tracing a soothing caress along his scalp. She leaned her head back against the wall and stared up at the dark ceiling of the Room of Requirement.
She stayed silent. There was nothing to be said.
There never was.
Seventeen years later, Scarlett opened her eyes when she sensed movement in the bathroom light.
Someone sat down beside her.
She blinked hard, trying to recognise him, but two bright shapes dazzled her vision. Then a hand. A hand marked with scars, long fingers, a rough palm.
The hand dug its fingertips into something and pulled off a lid, plunging the shimmering thing inside until it scooped something brown from within.
Remus held out a spoonful of ice cream to her.
Scarlett took it, with no idea how she managed to hold the cold utensil and savour the taste of chocolate with nuts. Her tongue burned from the intensity of the temperature contrast, but she didn’t care, extending the spoon back to him in a silent request.
Remus took another spoonful and handed it back to her, while he ate some himself.
How long had it been since she’d had choconuts ice cream?
She couldn’t say. In Azkaban, whenever she thought of that word—because, honestly, she could no longer remember what ice cream even was—her thoughts were swallowed by the memory of Remus.
Choconuts ice cream was his favourite.
She closed her eyes and lost herself in the sway of the past opening up to her like a flower, reliving a day when they had gone to the ice cream parlour and Sirius had flown into a rage when they got back home. Their relationship had already not been in the best shape, and after that day…
Well, it was a little before she left. A little after Mary had broken up with Remus. After the trip to Brighton.
The spoon slipped from her hand with an irritating clink. Her eyes rolled back. She tried to get up, but she was far too weak. The nausea surged violently. Remus caught her and Scarlett leaned forward and vomited. Some into the toilet, some onto the floor. He pulled her hair back. She kept retching until there was nothing left to bring up but sobs and tears.
"I can’t…" Scarlett cried, curling in on herself completely, pressing her face into her knees. "I can’t… do this…"
Remus’s fingers slid through her hair, stitching a gentle caress into the strands. With his other hand, he wiped her mouth with a tissue.
Scarlett heard the floorboards creak under chaotic, hurried footsteps. The bathroom door was flung open.
"Scar?"
Sirius.
She couldn’t turn her head to look at him. Her body refused to obey her.
"She’s going into a serious crisis, Sirius," Remus murmured, trying to sound calm. "We need a Healer."
"No." Sirius crouched beside her, touching her face with his cold hand. "Scar, look at me." He cupped her sweaty chin, forcing her to look at him. "I’m here. You’re going to be alright."
Scarlett sniffed, her breathing ragged.
"I just… I just wanted… I just wanted to see Reg…" she babbled, trying to focus her blurred vision on Sirius’s beautiful face, edged with worry. "I just… went to the skate park… and he… he was smoking and… I…" She coughed, nearly choking on her own saliva. "I… I can’t take it anymore, Sirius. I can’t. It hurts so much. I need… I need a drink… it hurts so much…"
"I know, Scar." He pulled her into him, her clammy skin against his. "I know. I’m here, alright?"
Scarlett only sobbed into his shoulder, and Sirius settled on the floor, his fingers touching her throat, then her nape, and then examining her eyes as he forced them open.
"I need Penny, Moony." Sirius locked eyes with Remus, who had already stood up and gathered the ice cream and spoons.
"Today’s her day off…" His voice dropped with every word as the urgency blazing in Sirius’s eyes became unmistakable.
"I know!" he snapped harshly. "I need her!" His declaration sounded more like a plea. "I need water too."
Remus only nodded and left them alone.
Sirius turned on the bath tap with his free hand and slid his arm beneath Scarlett’s legs, lifting her with him. She let out a guttural roar of pain and clung to Sirius as if he were a lifeboat and she were drowning.
He settled her into the bath as it continued to fill. She didn’t let go. Her fingers tangled in the fabric of Sirius’s shirt, anchoring herself to him.
"It’s alright. It’s just water. It’ll help bring your fever down." Sirius whispered into her ear.
Scarlett released him slowly, her body twisting in a spasm. She rested her head against the edge and stared at him; his face was nothing more than a blur framed by long, dark hair.
"I can’t… I can’t breathe properly." She murmured, her voice fragile.
She felt as though her body were rejecting its own blood.
Sirius undressed her carefully, unbuttoned her T-shirt and tugged her shorts down.
"I know," he said softly, with sorrow. With understanding, too. He sat down on the floor beside the bath. "I’ve been through this. You’re in withdrawal, Scar. Your body wants something you’re not going to give it. And it’s punishing you for that."
Scarlett shuddered.
"Withdrawal? But I… I… it hasn’t been that long… I haven’t had a drink since… since today!"
Sirius patiently brushed the strands away from her face. Gently. With the tenderness that came so naturally to the two of them. He didn’t know how to touch her any other way.
"You stopped yesterday, and your body had already been at its limit for days."
Scarlett started to cry. Again. A restrained, painful, desperate cry.
"I… I don’t want this, Sirius… I don’t want… to be like this…"
He moved a little closer. Pressed his forehead to the side of her head.
"You’re not like this. You’re just like this right now…"
"I hate this. I hate being like this. I wish I were dead… dying is easier than this. It’s easier than… having to deal with… with all the shit and… it’s easier than facing you every day… and knowing what I did…"
"You’re not going to die. Or run. Or hide." Sirius kissed her cheek lightly, and Scarlett thought it felt like a butterfly beating its wings near her face.
Remus appeared in the doorway again and handed him a bottle of water. Sirius opened it and tried to get Scarlett to hold it, but she was too weak for that. So he held it up to her instead.
"Drink."
"No… I’m going to… throw up…" Scarlett’s breathing came in sobs.
Sirius straightened. His jaw tightened, beard bristling with the tension.
"Scar… please. I need you to drink."
Scarlett tried to swallow; there was no saliva in her mouth. She acquiesced, closing her eyes and pushing the air from her lungs. She took short sips, pausing when she nearly choked.
"…it’d better really be an emerg—" Penny stopped short when she saw Scarlett in the bath. "What happened?"
"Penny, do you remember in ’78 when you did the detox with me?" Sirius looked at her from the corner of his eye, his forehead still resting against Scarlett’s cheek.
"Penny remembers. Why? Is Mistress Black also having a crisis from lack of pussy?"
Sirius blinked a few times, wrong-footed by what he’d just heard.
He decided to ignore the second question.
"I need you to make the same potions you made for me back then."
The elf pressed a finger to her lower lip, her gaze drifting around the bathroom as she wandered through the past.
"Stomach Stabiliser, Neurochemical Rebalancing Potion, Anti-Collapse and Revitalising Draught?" She lifted her long bat-like ears, waiting for confirmation.
"I think so."
"Penny wants to be paid triple for working on her day off."
"I’ll pay you a whole bloody month!" Sirius snapped.
Penny smiled, though she craned her neck to check on Scarlett.
"Deal!" She Disapparated.
Sirius pulled back from Scarlett just enough to look at her. Her face was ashen, lips colourless, the bruise staining the skin around her right eye. She tried to turn her head away, knowing exactly what he was doing, but Sirius didn’t allow it.
"No one is ever going to lay a finger on you again."
"Sirius…"
"Never again."
"No… don’t say that."
"Why not?"
"You… you can’t… protect me… from myself."
Scarlett’s eyelids grew heavy, but she knew exactly how Sirius would react. She heard the chaotic gusts of breath leaving his lips, his frantic heartbeat, heard the chime of the silver in his eyes that refused to believe it, even knowing it was true.
"I should’ve loved you more," he whispered, setting the bottle on the edge of the bath. His fingers sought the warm skin at the curve of Scarlett’s neck.
Scar forced a smile that looked far more like pain. The water had eased the trembling and, as far as she could tell, the sweating. But she still felt as though her organs were being pushed through a meat grinder every time her chest filled with air.
"You think… that… that you… loved me too little?" Her voice barely came out, but Sirius read her lips. She remained submerged in the darkness of her own eyelids.
"Mm-hm…" he sighed.
Scarlett shook her head slightly.
"I don’t think you… could’ve loved me more…" She half-opened her eyes and looked at Sirius through thick lashes. "Not because… you loved me too little." She moistened her lips. "You loved me… with all your heart… just like I loved you. I think that… I would have loved you better. It wasn’t… it wasn’t lack of love… that destroyed us, it was… it was immaturity. Insecurity. Fear. Especially fear. We were so afraid… of losing… each other that… we couldn’t see… anything clearly."
Sirius remained silent, absorbing her words. Then he shook his head, as if trying to rattle the thoughts out of it.
"It doesn’t matter anymore. The past is past. It can’t hurt you anymore." He cleared his throat, trying to sound resolute, even though Scarlett knew he didn’t quite believe it himself. "You’re not alone anymore. You’ve got me… you’ve got Remus… Harry. And Reg."
She squeezed her eyes shut at the sound of her son’s name, ignoring the pain of the bruise.
"He hates me." The reply was no more than a breath slipping past her lips.
"He’s hurt. But he doesn’t hate you." Sirius rested the palm of his hand against her cheek, and Scarlett opened her eyes again, just slightly.
"He does hate me."
"He doesn’t hate you. No one hates you. We love you, Scar… we… we love you…" He whispered, slowly, never taking his eyes off hers.
Scarlett had tried to say no to love. She’d tried to numb it with alcohol, and now she tried to push it away with the remorse that ate her up from the inside. She’d tried to kill it in her heart—but how do you kill love? It was nothing more than an undefined shadow, an intangible flower, feverish dreams from a brain intoxicated with oxytocin.
And love comes for everyone, Scarlett. Even those who don’t deserve it.
She cried, feeling so sheltered and safe that the tears she’d held back for so long finally spilled free.
She simply cried for everything.
For the alcohol. For the withdrawal. For Azkaban.
For James. For Lily. For Red.
For Remus. For Harry. For Reggie.
For Sirius.
But above all, Scarlett cried for herself, and Sirius held her.
Steady. Constant and unshakable. Her fixed point, her foundation, her rainbow at the end of the storm.
Scarlett foundered in Sirius.
And Sirius Black threw himself once more into the abyssal chasm called Scarlett Gaunt, wishing that things could be different this time.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 86: For we're like creatures in the wind, and wild is the wind
Chapter Text
CLIV
[David Bowie — Wild is the Wind]
Scarlett buried her face beneath the red scarf. Her eyes were stuck to the orange, stiffened leaves that blended into the mud beneath her feet.
It was a gloomy day. A fine drizzle fell from the leaden sky, opaque and melancholic.
Sirius, at her side, held an open umbrella, sharing it with her. His other hand was wrapped around Scar’s waist and hidden inside the pocket of her overcoat. His angular face was flushed from the cold.
The cemetery was unremarkable, surrounded by bare, frozen cypress trees. The simple ceremony had been organised in haste. Remus hadn’t managed to do absolutely anything, and Lyall Lupin seemed out of orbit. He stood motionless, his hands gripping his own hat so tightly the brim bent under the pressure. Holding it was the only thing keeping him upright, even though Thanatos stood beside him.
Near Scarlett and Sirius, James remained silent, between Fleamont and Euphemia, his expression distant. Lily and Mary were a little further back, as was Peter. Further away still, Fabian and Gideon stayed alert, wands in hand, and Dumbledore himself had also attended, his purple robe standing out amid the grey, decaying surroundings.
Remus stood frozen at the front of the coffin. The rain soaked his unkempt hair, unwashed for days. His empty eyes were fixed on the woman before him. The black cloak over his shoulders swayed gently with the mood of the wind.
Hope Lupin looked like a sleeping angel. Her dark hair spread around her head like the sun surrounded by its radiant rays. Her pale, smooth skin was dotted with tiny droplets. Her lips were softly painted pink. White flowers surrounded her. Lilies, stock, mallow, tulips and roses. The great variety did not seem to do justice to her vivacity, nor to her significance.
Flowers, so many flowers that Hope was a sleeping angel in a flowering field. The petals so white they looked like snow. Her small, delicate hands held a necklace shaped like a boggart Scarlett used to see in books.
Remus swallowed hard and took a step back. His father, on the other side of the coffin, didn’t even look at him. Nate offered him a handkerchief, and he didn’t take it.
Scarlett followed her friend with her eyes. He turned on his heels and continued walking away. James and Sirius stepped aside to let him pass between them, wandering through the cemetery as though searching for a way to undo the car accident that had taken his mother’s life. Trying to go back in time to sit in the passenger seat beside her, to die as well.
It was as if… as if…
Dumbledore said a few words about how dark times possessed no mercy. About how tragedies left marks that could never be healed.
Nonsense. Scarlett wanted to tell him to shut up. Instead, she simply turned her back on him and went after Remus. Sirius did too. As did James, Peter, Mary and Lily. They crossed the gravestones shrouded in neglect, the hibernating trees and the muddy path that spilled out before a solitary, sumptuous statue of white marble.
She had her eyes closed.
It was a tall woman, with a veil carved to cascade over her shoulders. Her hands stretched towards the ground, and her head was encircled by a laurel crown that had once been gilded. Now, it was almost unrecognisable beneath dirt and time. At her back, a toppled amphora spilled sculpted water in a continuous stream, flowing down to the base covered in slime.
Remus stopped in front of the statue. Scarlett did too. Beneath the woman's feet, there was an inscription partially swallowed by erosion. Scarlett tore off her glove with her teeth and rubbed her hand over the damp stone, scraping away the thick layer of moss until the Latin letters emerged.
Oblivio est refugium miseriae.
Remus knelt and pressed his forehead against the freshly cleaned base. His shoulders were already shaking. Scarlett stepped back and whispered:
"Lethe." Her voice was thick. "She is the goddess of forgetfulness." She cleared her throat. "The inscription says: forgetfulness is the refuge of misery."
When Remus heard the words, he broke down. The sob tore from his throat in a desperate scream, sharpening his searing suffering. His hands clenched into fists in the mud, his voice reverberating through the statue’s marble, the barren trees, the decaying cemetery.
He screamed so much it was as if he were trying to make his mother hear him from the other side. But as Scarlett already knew all too well, the dead do not hear, the dead do not see, and the dead do not speak. They do not feel pain, longing or melancholy. The dead simply go, leaving the living with an irreparable void and an excruciating grief.
To live through mourning is to die, but remain alive.
Sirius knelt beside him, pulling Remus into his arms in an attempt to shield him from the latent, tearing pain. James held him on the other side, supporting him alongside his best friend. Scarlett crouched in front of them, wrapping all three in her arms, her hands stroking Remus’s wet hair.
Mary joined the embrace. Lily and Peter did too.
Remus cried in their arms.
The rain thickened and turned to snow.
The first flakes fell over them, dusting white across the heavy cloaks, the intertwined hands and the multicoloured hair.
Scarlett kept her eyes on the inscription carved into the cold stone.
Forgetfulness is the refuge of misery.
She buried her face in Sirius’s shoulder, not letting go of the shared embrace.
Hope was gone.
.
.
.
The fire crackled in the fireplace of the bedroom in the Undercroft, reflecting off the ironwork and the marble cornice, gleaming on the stone floor and the polished wood of the bedposts. Scarlett took off her overcoat and scarf, tossing them aside anywhere. They still smelled of the cemetery: rain, earth and death. She sat on the edge of the mattress, slowly pulling off her damp boots. Sirius was lying behind her, chin propped on his elbow, the flickering flames sliding across the vast silver of his eyes.
"You’re quiet." he murmured.
Scarlett shrugged, her eyes fixed on her thick socks until she pulled them off as well.
"It’s just that… all of this is so familiar," she said, trying to hide the tremor in her voice. "Funeral. Silence… everyone trying to pretend everything’s fine, when it’s all completely fucked." She shook her head. "It’s like… like I’m watching myself from the outside." She drew her legs up onto the bed and hugged them, turning her face slightly towards Sirius, but not looking at him. The orange of the fire reflected in her irises incinerated every solid barrier she had built around herself since her parents’ deaths. "Remus today was me. Lying on the floor. Unable to breathe… screaming for someone who’s never coming back."
Sirius’s gaze swept the room before returning to Scarlett’s hunched figure in front of him.
"I still hear that scream sometimes." Sirius confessed. "In my nightmares."
Scarlett smiled. A sad smile, edged with longing.
"You saved me from the fire." She turned her face and lifted her eyes to his, through the dancing flames and the shifting shadows.
The grey of Sirius’s irises burned, melting into a lustrous silver that tinted the stars.
"When I noticed the smoke… I didn’t think about anything" he ran a hand through his hair, pushing it back. "Just about getting you out of there. And after it was over, I didn’t know what to say. I was… I was scared. So bloody scared that you’d wake up and… and realise what had happened. At the same time… there was this irrational fear that you’d disappear too, like them."
Scarlett sighed, her smile softening. Sirius moved closer, wrapping his arms around her. She let herself sink into his chest, into his warm, comforting embrace.
"I’m not going to disappear." she whispered against his neck.
Sirius rested his chin on the top of her head, his warm breath stirring her black hair.
"I know." he traced a caress at the base of her spine, fitting his hand there afterwards. "Do you think Moony will be alright?" he asked, after a pause.
Scarlett lifted her face just enough to look at him, blue eyes swallowed by the darkness cast by her long lashes. They shone nonetheless. Tiny points of light mingling with the tears like stars in a universe swallowed by supernovas.
"No." she admitted, in a breath. "I don’t think he’s going to be alright."
Sirius wiped away her tears and kissed the tip of her nose, resting his forehead against hers.
"Then you’d better put your clothes back on." He decided, tucking a strand of black hair behind her ear.
Scarlett arched an eyebrow. Of all the things Sirius Black usually asked for on nights like that, putting more clothes on was definitely not one of them.
"We’re sleeping in the Gryffindor Tower tonight." he explained, as if reading her mind.
.
.
.
The dormitory was steeped in bluish half-light from the snow piled up against the windows. With only a narrow gap in the canopy of his bed open, Remus lay on his back, motionless. Peter slept in the bed beside him, face buried in the pillow, his familiar snoring composing the sepulchral symphony of the place.
Sirius crossed the room to his own abandoned bed and hurled two pillows to Scarlett, who caught them mid-air. Then he brought the blanket with him as he calmly returned to where Remus was lying.
First, he tossed the blanket onto the mattress. Then he threw himself down.
"Get out of here!" Remus growled, without even turning over.
"No." Sirius said, giving two light pats to the space between himself and his friend, where Scarlett placed the pillows and crawled into bed until she nestled against him. "Moony, you’ve got three options: be crushed, accept affection, or…" He scratched his chin. "Well, there is no third option."
"There isn’t room for three people in this bed!" Remus grumbled, still staring up at the ceiling.
"There is, yeah. Worst case, Scarlett sleeps on top of me." Sirius gave a wicked little laugh. Scarlett slapped his shoulder. "Ow!"
"If you two shag in my bed, I swear I’ll—"
"You weren’t going to start the fun without me, were you?!" James appeared, hair eternally messy and his button-up pyjamas crumpled.
"My boy Prongs!" Sirius sang, pointing to the small empty space between himself and the mattress. "The more, the merrier."
James squeezed into the narrow gap, shoving Sirius to the side, who shoved Scarlett and, consequently, she shoved Remus.
"Four people don’t fit here!" Remus lifted his head to look at them. "I’m on the edge of the bed!"
"So am I!" James raised his arms.
"It’s tighter than the Hogwarts Express on back-to-school day." Sirius laughed, turning onto his side. He pulled Scarlett against him.
"Do you reckon there’s room for Pete as well?" Scarlett teased. "How many more people does this bed fit?"
"None." Remus let out an irritated sigh. "This bed only has room for me. For someone who’s just lost his bloody mum!"
"Perfect. Then we’re in the right place." Sirius said, pulling the blanket over everyone. "Except for Prongs, his mum’s still alive."
"So is yours!" James shot back, his voice a few octaves higher than normal.
"Yeah, but… mine doesn’t count."
Scarlett burst out laughing, clapping a hand over her mouth so she wouldn’t wake Peter in the bed beside them. Then she cried. Sirius threaded his fingers through her black hair and kissed her forehead.
"You’re suffocating me!" Remus stretched one leg out and planted his foot on the floor, ready to climb off the mattress, but the cold stone beneath his toes made him recoil on instinct, retreating back into the ever-shrinking space on his own bed.
"That’s the plan." James grunted, lying on the same pillow as Sirius and pushing his hair back.
"For fuck’s sake, I hate you lot!" Remus thrashed angrily on the bed, trying to claim more space, but failed.
"You don’t hate shit." Sirius said, giving his arm a light smack.
"Shhh." Scarlett murmured to Sirius, pressing her index finger to his lips. "Sleep."
Sirius bit her finger, making her laugh again. James hissed at her to shut up and threw his arm over both Sirius and Scarlett.
Remus simply took a deep breath. His body slowly relaxed, and he allowed his arm and legs to rest against Scarlett. Then he laid his face on her pillow, his cheek settling against her shoulder. He closed his eyes, the scent of vanilla flooding his senses.
Soon Peter’s snoring was joined by James’s.
Remus didn’t sleep, his eyes fixed on some random point between his friends.
"Thank you." He whispered, in the middle of the night.
Sirius turned his face towards him, silver eyes almost entirely hidden behind black lashes. His lips curved softly into a half-smile. Scarlett, beside him, felt across the mattress until she found his hand beneath the blanket. She held it tightly, though she still seemed asleep. Remus didn’t squeeze her palm back, but he didn’t pull away either.
.
.
.
That morning’s training was silent, except for McGonagall and Slughorn still arguing over who would be the starter: Regulus or Freya. Scarlett didn’t particularly care, since she’d stopped speaking to him after Halloween. Not that she was in the right, Regulus had done the right thing by telling Sirius about her misscarriage, but she had no patience left to deal with him.
Her gaze swept over the surrounding stands, searching for Remus and Mary. They always watched the Hogwarts team train, just like most of that school’s groupies, but he wasn’t there.
He didn’t even get out of bed when she, Sirius and James had to wake up for training. Although they’d insisted on staying with him in the dormitory, Remus begged to be left alone, even with Peter dead to the world in the next bed.
So there they were. Scarlett glanced sideways at Sirius, a few metres away, his broomstick resting against his shoulder as Freya Hopper chatted to him about the last professional season match.
She was a pretty girl, ebony-skinned, with black, curly hair and dark, piercing eyes. With every word she spoke, she stepped closer to him. In return, Sirius pretended to hear Scarlett calling him and took a step in the opposite direction.
He’d been doing that for so long that the distance between him and his girlfriend shrank drastically over the next few minutes.
"The Holyhead Harpies are definitely going to win the British championship this year… just imagine it, an all-women team lifting the cup."
"Uh… never thought about it…" Sirius stretched out his arm and suddenly pulled Scarlett in front of him, earning a startled squeak from her. "Hi, love. You know Hopper already? Hopper, this is Scar. Scar, Hopper."
"You can call me Freya." she said, forcing a tight smile. "So… you’re the famous Scarlett Gaunt. Are the Durmstrang rumours true?!"
"That I’m mad and nearly killed my ex-boyfriend?! Yes, they are." Scarlett slapped the broomstick against her own hand, a viperish smile curling her lips.
Freya’s laugh faltered and she blinked, clearing her throat.
"Oh… well, I hope your current boyfriend doesn’t give you a reason to repeat the experience." She said slyly, her eyes sliding to Sirius with insolent suggestion.
"He doesn’t." Scarlett rolled her eyes, as if the idea were absurd. "Sirius knows that if he does, I won’t hit him. I’ll kill him."
Sirius bit back a laugh, pressing his lips into a thin line. Freya blinked a few times, stunned, trying to process Scarlett’s answer.
"You’re completely unhinged, love…" He pulled her closer, wrapping his arms around her from behind. "And I’m mad about you."
Freya opened her mouth to say something, but her words were drowned out by the whistle. Slughorn clapped his hands, calling the team over for the final talk of training.
"Hmm, what a shame." Scarlett waved her broomstick in her direction. "Regulus got the Seeker spot. Better luck next time, Freya."
The girl knit her brows, lifted her chin and walked away without another word.
Unlike the other students, Sirius and Scarlett didn’t head over to the Head of Slytherin House. Sirius pulled Scarlett along with him to the boys’ changing room, taking advantage of the fact that it was empty and well lit.
As soon as they crossed the doorway, Sirius’s mouth captured hers in a searing kiss. Scarlett moved her lips, responding with fervour, while his hands roamed over her shoulders, then down her back to her waist, pulling her closer until his hips pressed into her belly, pinning her against the icy wall of the shower stall.
Scarlett slipped her arms around his shoulders, her hands sliding up his neck until they reached the thick beard—one quickly gripping a fistful of black hair, the other lingering there, caressing his cheek as their mouths fused and their tongues moved over one another with hunger and exhilaration.
Sirius slid his palms lower, cupping Scarlett’s arse, squeezing and grinding her hips against his, making her sigh when she felt his erection. He tugged her wrist beneath the thick fabric of his Quidditch uniform, under his pants. Scarlett stroked his glans with her thumb, the other fingers closing around his cock.
Without breaking the kiss, Scarlett moved her fist up and down, jerking him off, while Sirius also slipped his hand inside her trousers and teased her with his index and middle fingers, rubbing them over her lips without opening them, pressing his fingertips there in gentle circular motions that weren’t enough to make her moan, but were enough for her to part her legs in search of more friction.
Sirius smiled into the kiss. A cruel, wicked smile, before sucking her lower lip and trailing his mouth down to her neck, nipping and sucking. Scarlett melted in his arms, panting, squeezing his cock in retaliation.
He began stripping Scarlett of her clothes, tugging her trousers and knickers down in one go, his body following the movement. He kissed her thighs and her groin, then straightened, tangling his fingers in the hem of her Slytherin T-shirt. The moment he pulled it up, the tap beside them groaned and twisted open all at once, pouring hot water over Scarlett’s neck.
She stiffened and let out a little yelp, then laughed as she shrank back.
"Ouch, Sirius!" She searched for his gaze; the silver was as dark as his most primitive desires. "I don’t have my clothes here!"
"It’s not like you’re going to need them…" He turned the shower off and shoved her back against the wall, capturing her in another demanding, suffocating kiss.
Scarlett tried to protest, but Sirius snaked his fingers over her groin again. He parted her lips with his index and ring finger only to push his middle finger inside her, the cold rings and knuckle making her arch her back.
Without giving her a chance to prepare, he pushed another finger inside and started fucking her at an impatient pace. Scarlett writhed and moaned loudly, Sirius’s fingertips going deeper and deeper, spurring the delicious build-up of heat at the base of her spine. He pulled her other leg around his waist, fitting her there as he fingered her and kissed her desperately.
They’d been more careful since the Halloween incident. That is, they tried to practise pulling out. Although, to the surprise of absolutely no one, they couldn’t manage it. It was far too hard to pull out of Scarlett when he was that close, and she refused to let him come anywhere other than inside her. So they learned a spell to solve that… problem.
Sirius wanted to bring her to her peak before penetrating her, but Scarlett was so wet and so hot that he couldn’t stand it. He pulled his slick fingers out of her and used the moisture to lube his cock. She shoved her trousers down and he lifted her, holding her by the torso: Scarlett wrapped her legs around his waist and he pushed into her in one long, languid thrust, their hips meeting flush.
They both moaned, heavy breaths mingling. Scarlett rested her face against Sirius’s arm, one hand braced on his shoulder while the left slid down to her clit, touching herself as his hips began to move very slowly. Sirius held her firmly, cold fingers digging into her arse when she deliberately clenched around him.
"Fuck… Scar…" he growled, breathless. "You’re so fucking wet."
"Am I?" She flashed a vicious smile as she tightened around him again, making Sirius gasp. "Does it feel good?"
In retaliation, he brutally picked up the pace. He buried his face in the curve of Scarlett’s neck and hauled her against him with every thrust, wiping the smile from her face and replacing it with a needy gasp.
Scarlett bit her lower lip, resting her head against the wall behind her as she felt Sirius’s thick length rubbing depravedly against every sensitive spot inside her, the sound of skin on skin mixing with the cacophony of filthy moans and dragged-out groans echoing through the empty changing room.
It was incredibly hard to resist the knot stretching tight in her belly every time Sirius fucked her, on the verge of snapping. Scarlett felt her legs weaken and her body shudder, her eyes dropping and desperately seeking out Sirius’s, which were already fixed on her, watching every reaction, every depraved breath leaving her lips, every lustful flicker colouring the blue of her eyes.
"I’m close, I’m close, I’m close…" Scarlett repeated, her breathing ragged.
Sirius increased his thrusts, snarling into her mouth. She knew he was close too, could feel his cock swelling inside her after her confession, his thrusts losing their precision.
Even so, he kept the rhythm, his hips pumping back and forth frenetically. Scarlett dug her nails into his arm, tugged him by the hair and muffled his cry by claiming him in a hungry kiss, teeth knocking and tongues clashing.
The orgasm came, clouding her vision, her body writhing in euphoria. Sirius broke the kiss and clamped his hand over her mouth.
"So exhibitionist, my little slut…" He punctuated the nickname with a hard thrust, making her roll her eyes. "Moaning like a bitch in the men’s changing room…"
Three more thrusts and Sirius came too, lost in the contractions of Scarlett’s cunt sucking him in, pumping his thick, hot climax into her as he pushed as deep as he could.
He bore both Scarlett’s weight and his own as he pinned her to the wall. He pulled back slightly, sliding out of her, hearing her let out a whine of displeasure. He helped her stand and staggered back, watching black hair stuck to her cheek and her Quidditch shirt soaked across her shoulders and back.
Sirius took a few deep breaths to compose himself. He pulled his trousers back up and took out his two-way mirror.
"Prongs." He said, running trembling fingers over the glass to clear it.
His best friend’s face appeared instantly, the image framed by a cloudy sky.
"Pads? What is it? Aren’t you at training?! I saw you a few minutes ago…"
"Can you bring Scar’s bag to the men’s changing room? It’s in her locker in the girls’…"
James frowned.
"You shagged in the men’s changing room?!" He knit his brows and covered his mouth, whispering in case anyone else heard.
"Bring. The. Bag." Sirius emphasised, shoving the mirror back into his pocket.
Scarlett was still catching her breath, leaning against the wall, legs shaky, Sirius’s cum running down the insides of her thighs and dripping onto the floor. He smiled at the sight of the aftermath of their shared lust, helping her pull her trousers back on and holding her in his arms as he kissed her again—this time slowly. Tenderly.
"You alright?" he asked, still close enough to feel Scarlett’s breath against his face. He used his wand to dry her hair and shirt.
"All good." She smiled, her cheeks flushing, which nearly made Sirius’s ego burst. "What?"
"You embarrassed about getting fucked in the men’s changing room?!"
"What? No… of course not…" Scarlett shrugged.
"No?!" He lifted a single eyebrow.
Scarlett narrowed her eyes at him, grabbing him by the collar of his training top and pulling him close until their noses touched, brushing her mouth against his in a soft caress. Sirius nipped her lower lip, then traced the shape of her mouth with his tongue before asking for entry.
"Sirius?!" A voice echoed from his trousers. "Sirius… Sirius… grab the fucking mirror! It’s urgent!"
Sirius stepped back with an irritated sigh. He took the mirror again, and James’s image appeared, pale.
"Mate… you need to come here now." He said, eyes wide.
"What the fuck happened?"
"Someone put something in Scar’s bag. Hurry up!"
Sirius and Scarlett exchanged a look before leaving the men’s changing room.
James was standing beside the bench, his hair as dishevelled as ever, eyes blown wide. His left arm was trembling, the skin burned from wrist to elbow, red and already beginning to blister. Scarlett’s bag lay on the floor in front of him, its contents rummaged through, and the ashes of what looked like her Slytherin cloak scattered among them.
"It was sort of open… the cloak was falling out… I just went to shove it back in. And it…" James swallowed hard. "It went up in flames."
Scarlett pulled her wand from her pocket and cast a spell to ease James’s burn. Sirius crouched beside what remained of the cloak and cast Revelio, watching traces of magic crackle into purple sparks.
"Dark magic." Sirius murmured, stating the obvious.
"Fire." Scarlett growled, tightening her grip on her wand. "Bastards."
"Fire again." Sirius stood, folding his arms as he looked at James.
"Someone helped them. Someone with access to Scar’s locker… or the changing rooms…" James pressed his lips together.
"Oh, we know getting access to the changing rooms isn’t exactly hard." Sirius breathed, jaw flexing.
"Vance and Hopper were leaving when I came in." James adjusted his glasses with his little finger, glancing at the burn on his arm as it steadily eased once Scarlett cast another healing charm.
"And they hate me." She added, gently touching James’s arm to make sure the skin was no longer so inflamed.
Sirius shook his head.
"Hopper, maybe. Vance, no. She can be irritating, but she’s not stupid enough to mess with dark magic."
"Or skilled enough." Scarlett twisted her lips condescendingly.
"The answer’s obvious, Pads." James conceded.
"I know." Sirius picked up his girlfriend’s bag and shoved the remaining things inside. "They want to play with fire? Then let’s play with fire."
.
.
.
On the way to the hospital wing with James, Sirius left Scarlett where the Marauder’s Map indicated Remus’s position: on the benches atop the vaulted ceiling of the Hufflepuff common room. He was smoking a cigarette, and Mary had just disentangled herself from him, saying goodbye with a kiss to his cheek. She picked up her bag and headed to class, waving at Scarlett as she went.
The day was dreadful. Overcast, grey, cold, and threatening snow like it had that morning at Hope’s funeral. Scarlett took the spot Mary had vacated. She very much wanted to tell him about what had happened in the girls’ changing room. But Remus’s brown eyes… they didn’t absorb even the scant light of the place, nor did they glimmer at her presence. The words simply evaporated in Scarlett’s mouth.
The scars on his face accentuated the suffering in his expression: reddened eyes, a swollen nose, the incredulous crease in his brow.
From the corner of her eye, she watched Remus exhale cigarette smoke as he looked up at the clouds that had begun to spill snowflakes over them; tiny white specks falling lightly, carried by the wind that lashed their cheeks and made his shoulders shiver.
"I was thinking…" he said. "About the phrase. The one at the base of the statue." He took another drag of his cigarette, his gaze lost among the flakes. "Forgetfulness is the refuge of misery. It doesn’t… it doesn’t make sense."
"Doesn’t it?" Scarlett looked at him sideways.
"Forgetting…" he insisted, his voice thick. "Isn’t that what’s meant to heal our pain?"
Scarlett stroked her Ouroboros beneath her glove, watching the cigarette glow at his lips and shed ash into the wind.
"I don’t think it’s about pain, Rem." She murmured after a moment of contemplation. "I think it’s… about not forgetting them. Even if it hurts."
Scarlett understood that more than she wished to. She had tried to overcome grief in every possible way… including forgetting. She couldn’t. It isn’t something you forget. It’s something that must be felt, remembered, and kept alive.
"But wouldn’t it be easier?" Remus looked at her without turning his head. "To forget everything."
"Maybe." She lowered her gaze to her open palms, where snowflakes landed and melted. "But they’re still alive… in us. In our memory. And if we forget… that’s when they truly die."
Remus held her gaze, trying to give meaning to that unbearable ache in his chest. Trying to understand why death was so cruel, so inhuman and thankless. How could it take his mother away?
In truth, perhaps the question was the opposite. How could it not take her? Hope Lupin was better than most people in that world; kind, affectionate, and always smiling. She was like the rays of sunlight that parted the clouds and touched his skin, so subtly that the warmth barely reached him through all that cold, but… it was there. Gilding his skin, kissing his fingers, caressing his face.
Remus understood death now. His mother had been too good for this world. Too good for him as well.
"It’s a punishment," he lowered his face, shoulders rippling with torpor. He stayed silent for so long that Scarlett thought he wouldn’t continue. But then his voice came, trembling. "It’s a punishment… for what I did…"
"No, of course it isn’t." Scarlett took Remus’s hand. "Why would this be a punishment?!"
He swallowed with difficulty. The saliva wouldn’t go down. His throat had turned to stone.
"When Dimitri… Dimitri and Sasha came… I… we… we killed…"
"You killed an animal, Remus. That’s not exactly a big deal…"
"People." Remus cut her off. Scarlett froze, her heart racing. Her lower lip quivered, but he didn’t give her the chance to react. "We killed people."
Remus wasn’t looking at her anymore. He was looking at the past, at a day he would never forget; when terror and savagery corroded every remaining shred of humanity within him and opened the cage of the beast inside.
"And… d-do you… do you think…" Scarlett stammered, trying to wipe away the tears welling in her eyes without permission. "That your mother died because… you did that?!"
Remus took one last drag of the cigarette, though it had already gone out. His unsteady hand spilled ash onto his lap.
"I still remember…" he whispered, blinking rapidly. "The taste. The smell of blood. The screams… the voices… begging…"
Scarlett had no idea what to say. Back then, she’d believed Remus pulled away because of Dimitri and Sasha’s presence, but no… never… she would never have imagined he could do this. Even in werewolf form, with no control whatsoever over his actions or instincts.
Her stomach clenched sickeningly. She curled her hands into fists.
Remus turned his face to her. For the first time, he allowed her to truly see him as he saw himself: a culpable killer, a boy haunted by a beast, a man eternally chained to an aberration.
Tears in his brown eyes glimmered gold. A way for the wolf to say it was there too. That it was also part of Remus.
When Dimitri and Sasha left, Remus vehemently refused to speak to anyone… except Scarlett. Why her, she wanted to ask. The Marauders had been his friends since their first year at Hogwarts; why not Sirius? James? Or Peter?
The wind howled through the nearby towers and her skin prickled. Remus studied her expression, expecting her to run, to turn him in, to be afraid. Her lack of reaction, however, surprised him.
"I had never… never eaten anyone before." He closed his eyes and let the air leave his lungs in a hiss. "We… we ate our victims. When a werewolf tastes human flesh, he…" He pressed his lips together hard. "That’s all he’ll want on the full moon."
Remus’s face trembled. The restrained tears finally broke free: his shoulders caved in, his head bowed, and his voice—always so calm and perceptive—spilled out as an expression of pain, regret, and disgust. Disgust at himself, at his condition, at a future forever stained by the eternal presence of his own monstrous self.
Scarlett embraced him. Without judgement, without questions or reason. She simply held him as if she could purge all the pain and guilt he was feeling, as if she could heal his wounds, undo his regrets, and stitch closed his lacerations.
She couldn’t.
Even so, Remus buried his face in her shoulder and cried.
He cried for the mother he had lost. For the lives he had taken. For the innocence his condition had torn away when he was still just a child.
Forgetfulness was the refuge of misery.
But perhaps… it could also be the refuge of pain.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 87: Just stay with me
Chapter Text
CLV
Regulus’s gaze drifted over the garden before returning to the photograph slipping through his fingers. Scarlett wasn’t looking back at him; she was in Sirius’s arms, the two of them kissing as if tomorrow were nothing more than a dream so sweet, so joyful and perfect that nothing else mattered.
Everyone had lied about her. About how she was a monster, according to Orfeu, devious, according to Remus, loving, according to Sirius.
Scarlett was none of that.
She might have been, once—back when she was the naïve girl kissing his uncle in that stupid photo—but… she seemed to have come apart like a house of cards blown over by the wind.
Reggie didn’t know her, and it seemed no one around him did either. She was a complicated enigma to unravel, as though her ocean eyes had cracked into so many pieces that she was only an incomplete figure, a shadow, a fragment of what she once had been.
Almost… almost like a ghost of herself. An echo. A mirage.
When he found out she was alive, he wanted to turn all his fantasies into reality. Of what it was like to have a mother. A maternal, feminine presence in his life, spoiling him with praise, embarrassing him in front of his friends with too much affection, standing by his side when the world felt far too unfair for his rebellious nature.
Regulus wanted… he wanted to be loved unconditionally. He wanted a mother. Scarlett wasn’t a mother. He didn’t know exactly what she was, in truth, but she seemed to be everything except what he longed for.
Nor was she enough to fill the vertiginous void that had followed him since early childhood.
He wiped his tears away with his knuckles, nudging the skateboard across the grass with the tip of his foot. He threw himself onto it, arms spread wide, eyes on the clear blue sky where the sun sat at its zenith, its merciless rays gilding his pale cheeks.
He put the Walkman headphones over his ears, trying to ignore the tightness in his chest and the burning that came with the despair of realising he would never have the smiling girl as his mother. Only the bitter, alcoholic, battered woman of fifteen years later.
Not even the irritating, raw voice of Kurt Cobain was enough to soothe the sinkhole in his chest. He pressed a hand there, feeling his heart being torn apart by its own pounding.
How much it hurt to know things would never be the way he’d dreamed!
He covered his face with his hands, the pain turning more and more into tears that wouldn’t stop falling. He wanted to cry like this in Scarlett’s lap and hear that everything would be alright, that she would change, that she would be a better mother. He wanted her to stroke his hair and kiss his head. He wanted her to be enough. Able to calm the tide of the constant feeling of being a pariah that plagued him.
Regulus had never seemed to belong anywhere. He had always thought his mother’s arms would be his unquestionable answer. That her lap would be his safe harbour. That her words would be the most powerful enchantment in the world.
He didn’t need to open his eyes to know who the tall, gaunt shadow belonged to as it blocked the sun from his face. Even so, he didn’t move his fingers away from his eyes. He was far too busy suffering through his own tempests.
"Reg… why did you do that?" Sirius asked. The shadow crouched down beside him until it covered only his head.
Regulus took a deep breath through his mouth.
"I smoked a cigarette." He sniffed disdainfully. "Wow, what a crime. Lock me up in Azkaban."
The wind blew between them. Reg hadn’t wanted his answer to sound so bitter, but it was stronger than him. Pain dressed itself up as anger, and anger disguised itself as indignation. Sirius slid a hand into his black hair; tattooed fingers heavy with rings traced a gentle stroke along the tip of his ear, making him part his fingers and look at his uncle through them.
"I’m not talking about that, Regulus." He replied, sharp. Impatient. "Why did you say those things to your mother?"
"I only told the truth." He hissed, clenching his jaw. "There’s no point lying, Sirius. She called here loads of times, pissed out of her mind. She doesn’t even remember the conversations we had." He didn’t back down when his uncle’s silver eyes turned to steel. "It’s like she died and what’s left is… this. This shell that… that only knows how to hurt everyone who loves her."
Sirius let out a long sigh, running a hand through his own hair. The lawn rippled with the taste of the wind, carrying his loose strands and the hem of his unbuttoned black T-shirt.
"I know you’re hurt." Sirius murmured, with exasperating calm. "But your pain isn’t an excuse for cruelty."
"You have no right to tell me that!" Regulus drew his brows together, the crease between them full of arrogance. "You’re not even my dad. It was Regulus who married and got my mum pregnant, not you!"
Sweet Merlin. Sirius didn’t know who was more hard work: Scarlett in withdrawal or Regulus throwing a strop.
He didn’t look away from Reg. Nor did he answer straight away. It was frightening how much he reminded him of his brother. The grey of his eyes turning to iron, expelling any trace of blue they might have held. The mordant mask taking over his features, the tongue growing ever more forked, spitting venom without thinking of the consequences.
Just like Regulus when he felt threatened.
His eyes brimmed with unwelcome tears, but they didn’t fall. Sirius didn’t allow them to. He didn’t know if it was fear of admitting that Reggie was like his brother, or… worse. Like him.
Reg couldn’t possibly be like him. He wasn’t his son. No matter how much he tried to delude himself by calling him that, the truth would never be erased: Reggie was Regulus’s son. And he carried the very same habit of hurting everyone around him, only to complain afterwards that he’d been left alone.
"I might not be your biological father, Reg, but I’m your godfather!" Sirius snapped, resolute, his voice deep. "When your father died and your mother was imprisoned, I was the one who stayed with you. I had to raise the boy who was the son of the woman I loved and the brother I hated. And I love you, Reg. As if you were my own. So I might not have been the bloody sperm donor, but I was there when you needed me! And I always will be. Whether you want it or not!" He caught Regulus’s chin when he tried to turn his face away and avert his gaze. "I may have been gone for twelve years, but I’m here now. You have me, Reg…"
The blue of Regulus’s eyes shimmered until it spilled over into tears. They ran down his long lashes, over the freckles on his cheeks, the sideburns just beginning to grow on his pale skin.
Sirius pulled him into an embrace, crying too without even knowing why. He buried his face in the black, softly wavy hair, stroking the back of Reg’s neck while his other hand held him tight, feeling him shake as the crying broke into sobs.
"She… she didn’t… didn’t come to get me… at King’s Cross… b-but… but she picked up Harry and… then… then you argue and… and sh-she le-leaves and… and me? Where do… where do I… I fit in all th-this? I just… I just wanted… wanted her to c-cuddle me and…"
"She loves you, son." Sirius murmured, the words resonating through his hair.
"It… it doesn’t feel like it…"
Sirius pressed his lips together and shook his head.
"Life hasn’t been kind to her." He admitted, wiping his face on his own shoulder. "To any of us."
Reg nodded slowly, his face still buried in Sirius’s chest.
"I just wanted… a mum…"
"I know, son." Sirius kissed Reg’s forehead. "But there are better ways of showing that. And she’s fighting, Reg. And… I know it might be too late and that it doesn’t erase what happened, but she’s trying and… if she falls now, I don’t think she’ll get back up."
In the end, Sirius and Reggie were just two abandoned boys trying to rebuild a family. And it was hard work. Exhausting. But it was worth it.
It had to be.
The shared crying subsided, but Sirius didn’t let him go. Sunlight spilled down between them, kissing pale skin and softening rigidity into gentleness. Into shelter. Understanding.
Sirius stepped away from Reg, giving his shoulder a light pat. The boy settled beside him on the grass, legs folded, arms resting loosely around them, his gaze fixed on the blades of grass beginning to yellow with the summer.
"I expect you to have apologised to her by the time I get back." Sirius warned, stern. Gentle, too.
He stood up slowly.
Regulus opened his mouth, ready to argue, but no words left his lips. He lifted his gaze to Sirius, swallowing hard. He closed his eyes and took a deep breath, acquiescing.
"Alright."
"Alright…?" Sirius raised his eyebrows in his most incisive manner.
"Alright. I’ll talk to her."
The smile that curved Sirius’s lips was framed by dimples.
"Perfect. I love you, Reg. You’re the best part of all this." He ruffled his godson’s hair and took a step back.
"Where are you going?" Reg propped his hands on the grass behind him, his damp cheeks gleaming in the light.
"I need to sort out a problem." He shoved his hands into his trouser pockets, his hair floating around his face.
"What problem?" Reg insisted, frowning and holding his gaze.
Sirius could have made up a thousand lies Regulus would have believed every single one of them, but none were as tempting as the truth.
"Your mum’s black eye." Sirius turned his back on him, walking back into the house.
"Can I come too?" Raising his voice, Reg stood up. He flicked the skateboard up with his foot and tucked it between his arm and his waist.
"No." Sirius looked at him over his shoulder. "And if you disrespect your mother again, say goodbye to your Walkman, your Super Nintendo, and your skateboard." He warned, inflexible. "Are we clear?!"
Regulus scratched the back of his neck, which was starting to turn red, and nodded reluctantly.
"We are."
"Good. I shouldn’t be long." Sirius went inside, leaving him alone.
.
.
.
The Hanged Man was fairly busy that morning. The bell above the door chimed when Sirius stepped inside, hit at once by the familiar stench of frying oil, stale beer and tobacco. His gaze swept over the occupied tables before settling on Mike leaning against the bar, holding a dark beer and chatting idly with the barman.
Scarlett’s band’s drummer spotted him and waved him over.
"Mike…" Sirius called, with a certain urgency.
Mike’s eyes widened slightly and he straightened.
"Hey, Sirius." Mike took a sip of his beer. "Want a pint?"
"No… I’m not here to drink." Sirius planted his hands on the bar, leaning forward. "I’m here to ask what happened to Scarlett’s eye."
Mike swallowed.
"Mate, I…" He scratched his chin. "We tried asking her. Me and Danny." He took two long gulps of his drink, as if that might lend him some courage. "But she… dodged the subject. Every time. Said she’d tripped, hit a door… but… that wasn’t from a fall. Not a fucking chance."
Sirius narrowed his eyes, drumming his fingers against the wooden surface of the bar.
"And you believed her?"
"Of course not." Mike scoffed, glancing around to make sure no one was listening. "But the problem is, we didn’t have proof of anything. And…" He lowered his voice. "Before it happened, at the last gig we opened for Pearl Jam, I noticed one of the roadies… acting weird. Can’t remember his name. Think it was Trevor. Travis. Something like that."
Sirius folded his arms, the silver rings on his fingers drinking in the half-light and throwing dull glints across the beard shadowing his face.
"Weird how?"
"He was… agitated. Looking at Star in this kind of… wrong way." Mike went on. "Me and Danny tried fishing, see if he’d slip up, but he didn’t seem guilty. At least not… not as far as we could tell." He set his beer mug down on the bar and grabbed a notepad. "It’s not like we had any proof, you know? Nothing solid. And Star… she completely shut down. Stopped talking about it."
Sirius clenched his fists against the bar, jaw locked. His blood throbbed furiously at his temples.
"You know where I can find the bastard?"
Mike tore a sheet from the notepad and handed it to him.
"Last I heard, he was working on stage setup for this festival." Mike wet his lips and leaned his elbows on the bar. "It’s happening in Cardiff." He hesitated. "But… I don’t know if it’s a good idea going after him without proof."
Sirius smiled. A dark, malicious smile, edged with venom.
"Don’t worry. I’m not going to do anything illegal." He shoved the address into his pocket and tapped the bar twice.
"Be careful, Black. If you go after him and the bloke calls the police—"
Sirius’s smile twisted into something outright perverse.
"I am the police, Michael." His voice came out low and sharp, carrying a calm so threatening it made Mike shiver.
The bell chimed again as Sirius left. Mike swallowed hard, his hands sweating around the cold beer mug. He didn’t know if he was more worried about Stargazer or about anyone unlucky enough to cross Sirius’s path that day.
.
.
.
It wasn’t hard to find the festival. Sirius came out through a rarely used fireplace at the back of a pub in the city centre and followed the sound, checking the address Mike had written on the scrap of paper. He cast a Disguise Charm that altered his features: lighter hair, sparse stubble, a black T-shirt, jeans, and an improvised stagehand badge clipped to his waist.
He blended in with the roadies and technicians effortlessly. Not that anyone cared—the place was buzzing with people clamouring for Oasis to come on, while a selection of the best ’90s tracks blasted from the loudspeakers.
The band’s backstage area was frenetic. Equipment being dragged around, speaker cabinets stacked, professionals running back and forth. Sirius stopped beside a sound technician whose hands were patting his pockets in search of a lighter. Sirius pulled out his own and offered it, leaning against the massive amplifier behind them.
"The producer’s looking for Travis… or Trevor… the new stage crew roadie. Where is he?"
The man pointed towards one of the improvised dressing rooms.
"He’s in there, setting up the drum stand for Pulp."
"Good. Cheers." Sirius flashed a satisfied smile and headed for the indicated area.
The bloke inside was tall, blond, and much younger than him. Twenty at most. Sirius brushed his wand inside his pocket and whispered a Muggle-Repelling Charm around them. The bustle of the backstage drained away from the dressing room. Technicians diverted their paths without even knowing why.
Sirius went in.
"You the new desk tech?" Travis grunted, barely looking at him.
"Something like that." Sirius murmured, drawing his wand from the enchanted pocket. "Legilimens."
The world around him faded into a confused whirl of Trevor’s fragmented, distorted memories. Sirius followed the tide of flashes back to the dressing room at the last Pearl Jam gig: Scarlett drunk, slumped into a worn leather sofa. He approached her and was brushed off. Watched her all night, waiting for her to leave the room. A predator waiting for his prey. When she finally stood, he moved quickly through the stadium backstage, stealing glances at where Scarlett went. Then he slipped into an empty box and waited for her to pass.
Sirius hadn’t meant to see everything—only enough to incriminate him—but he couldn’t move when the man forced himself on her. The terror on her face. The bite she gave him. His rage exploding. The punch he landed, sending her stumbling back. The vomit. Her disappearing.
He severed the connection abruptly, a corrosive spasm tearing through his stomach. Sirius blinked hard to return to reality, pressure blooming in his head as his body locked rigid with every thud of his heart.
Travis staggered back, dazed. Sirius grabbed him by the collar of his jacket and dragged him across the dressing room. He tried to babble something, but Sirius slammed him against the wall, his face inches from his, the silver in his gaze forging itself into sharp steel—exalted, enraged.
Rage sank into his core and flooded his veins and tendons, tinting his vision red, his fists with fury, his breath ragged with bloodlust. The hatred so carefully cultivated in his pure-blood DNA unfurled through his body until it blinded him completely. His mouth watered, begging for blood.
[Music: Nirvana — Rape Me]
"You…" His voice came out low, rough, and dangerously placid. "You fucked with the wrong woman, you piece of shit."
Travis tried to react. He opened his mouth to scream, but Sirius struck him before any sound could vibrate through his vocal cords. A straight punch to the nose, reverberating in the same beat as the Nirvana song thundering onstage. Blood gushed and splattered across Sirius’s face, the hot, sticky liquid brushing his taste buds, the iron tang stoking his thirst for revenge.
Another punch, now to the mouth. The eye. Trevis dropped to his knees, spitting bloodied teeth onto the carpet.
Sirius didn’t stop.
Sirius didn’t stop.
Rage and hatred copulated until they gave birth to wrath, which mingled with pain, loss, and impotence, detonating in his chest like a caged animal finally set free. The wild, visceral impulse pulled the strings of his mind, controlling him as if he were nothing but a puppet.
The man being beaten beneath his fists was no longer Trevor or Trevis or whatever the bastard’s name was. It was himself—young, naïve Sirius, stupid and idiotic, young and arrogant, who thought he could protect everyone. It was Regulus, for joining the Death Eaters and dying, leaving all the shit behind. It was James, who accepted his half-baked idea of making Peter the Secret-Keeper.
It was Scarlett, who abandoned him, left, had a child, married, was imprisoned, tortured, mistreated, and always sought the relief that flirted with self-destruction. It was her, because she reminded him of himself when he was young—and his younger self was the one who had caused all of this.
It was his fault.
All his fault.
Sirius was crying without even knowing why. His knuckles split, throbbing, raw. He dropped the man to the floor, panting. His entire body trembling, the fury boiling in his veins. He didn’t know if he felt relief… or even more guilt.
Trevis raised one hand in a futile attempt to shield himself from Sirius’s wrath. Sirius smiled, licking the blood that had splashed onto his beard. He grabbed the hand and twisted the wrist until he felt the bone snap. Another scream. He took the other hand—the one that bore a dressing from Scarlett’s bite.
He twisted the arm until Trevis writhed completely, his howls of pain swallowed by the aggression of the music.
Sirius was no longer human. He was no longer made of flesh and bone, but of stone. Marble. His eyes were nothing more than ashen gems, cold and dark. Trevor thrashed about. He was no longer anything but a formless, blood-soaked heap laced with bone. Arms bent at horrific angles, swollen, nose shattered, lips split, eyes bulging. Disfigured.
He would never touch a woman again.
Blood had splashed across the floor, staining the carpet, sprayed over Sirius’s boots, the metal drum stands, the loose cables strewn around.
Sirius’s hands trembled with exhaustion. With excess. With that thing that poured inside him like dark tentacles implanted by his parents, unleashing something far too ancient, far too deep within his chest.
The music booming from the stage seemed farther and farther away, unintelligible, cacophonous. His shallow breathing caught in his throat. Sirius looked down at his own hands, at the skinned knuckles, the rings dyed red, giving the impression that the metal had become flesh.
It wasn’t enough to quell the surge of revolt that slammed into his chest. There was no punch, no broken bone, no torn skin that would bring James back. Or Lily. Or what Azkaban had ripped from him. Nor what Scarlett had lost. What Reggie had dreamed of… what Harry had never had.
He closed his eyes and took a deep breath.
It doesn’t matter anymore. The past is past. It can’t hurt you anymore.
Liar. Of course he can.
You’ve got me…
Another lie. Sirius wasn’t even sure he still had himself.
He opened his eyes. Trevis was still writhing in a pool of fluids and vomit, murmuring nonsense.
Sirius spat on him. The vacuum swallowed all the rage, the adrenaline, the agitation, filling him instead with a vertiginous emptiness in his chest and a silence… a devastating silence stitched together from everything that would never be fixed.
He turned on his heel, wiped the dirty sole of his boot into the carpet, and walked out without looking back.
.
.
.
It was nearly evening when Scarlett woke and managed to shower on her own. Her condition had stabilised after Penny’s potions and, though she still felt wrecked, she could move without trembling now, and her stomach didn’t knot itself every time she put something in her mouth. When she got dressed and stepped out of the bathroom with her hair still wet, Regulus was sitting on the bed, where a tray held a glass of water and a small plate piled with chopped fruit.
No sign of her ghosts.
Scarlett stopped a step into the room when she saw him there.
Regulus scratched the back of his neck and gently nudged the tray across the mattress towards her.
"Penny said fruit helps." He murmured, not looking at her. "I don’t know what you like, so… I cut up what I like. Strawberry, apple, banana and… er, watermelon."
Scarlett dabbed the ends of her hair with the towel, approaching slowly. She sat on the edge of the bed and picked up her wand, using a charm to dry it.
"Thanks, Reg." She murmured, her stomach tightening at the sight of the glass, begging it not to be water. Or, if it was, that it would taste bitter and burn on the way down. It didn’t, of course. It was just water, but it was easier to pretend when she took a sip. She gagged. Her body rejected it the instant it realised it wasn’t alcohol.
Scarlett choked and wiped her face with the towel, setting the glass back on the tray with a wavering hand. She drew a sharp breath, clearing her throat.
"You alright?" Reggie pulled his legs up onto the mattress, hugging his knees.
"Yeah, just…" Scarlett coughed, rubbing at her eyes with her knuckles. The bruise on her face was already starting to fade. Penny’s potion, she assumed. "Went down the wrong way."
Regulus nodded, watching her as he searched for the right words… and yet none of them felt correct enough or strong enough to mend the past, fix the present, and set the future on a better path.
"I… I shouldn’t have said that. Not like that." He licked his lips, his eyes sliding away from her. "But it’s just… it’s what I felt."
Scarlett tipped her head in a small, mute acknowledgement and rubbed the Ouroboros on her shorts.
"You… you were right, Reg. I’m not going to justify myself." She let out a deep sigh. "There’s no excuse."
Regulus lifted his head, finally looking at her. The grey and blue in his gaze danced in a perfect, painful balance of fear and vulnerability, resentment and hurt. He opened his mouth and closed it again, glanced to the sides, then looked back at her. Need and shame flickered in his pale irises.
"I waited for you. For a long time. I… I always wanted to have a mum." He admitted, the lines of his face soaked through with grief.
Scarlett pressed her lips together hard and tears welled in her eyes, but they didn’t fall. She held her son’s gaze. The disappointment aimed at herself was written into every line of her expression.
"I know." She swallowed with difficulty. She picked up the glass again, but didn’t tip it back. "And I… I… I hate myself for not being able to be what you want."
Regulus sniffed softly. He wiped away a stray tear that ran down his face, whose creases revealed layer upon layer of a pain that had been haunting him for far too long.
"I thought you were going to fix everything. That when I came back from Hogwarts… you’d hug me… tell me you loved me, that everything would be alright."
"I…" Her voice died halfway through the sentence. "I wasn’t alright. I wasn’t whole… I still am not."
Reggie squeezed his watery eyes shut, rubbing at them with the backs of his hands.
"I wanted a mum. Instead… I got a ghost."
Scarlett’s mouth twisted. Hearing that hurt. It hurt even more because it was true. She tried to hold back the crying, but it came anyway—unwanted—bursting through her vocal cords like a fountain spilling out of her heart.
"Is that what you think I am, Reg?" she asked, voice thick, cracked. Exhausted.
Regulus reached out as if to touch her, but never made it. His hand hovered in the air and he curled it into a fist, shaking his head as he bit his lower lip.
"I don’t know." He confessed. "I don’t know what you are." He cleared his throat. "Sometimes you seem alive. Sometimes it feels like you’ve given up on everything. I don’t know… I don’t know how to deal with that."
"I don’t…" Scarlett sobbed, trying to steady the crying, her body trembling. "I don’t want to give up anymore, Reg."
"Why?" His question was barely more than a whisper. "What changed?"
"You." Scarlett breathed, without thinking. "You, Harry, Sirius… I… I don’t… I…" She stammered, with no idea what to say. What had changed? Why was she willing to try now and not before?
Because Sirius knew the truth? No. He didn’t know the truth. Because Harry and Reg needed her? They’d always needed her, and she hadn’t been there for them.
Why, Scarlett? What changed?
"I don’t want to be… the shadow of what I once was anymore. And I… Reggie, I love you, I’m sorry if—"
"Then… you’re really going to try?" he cut in, urgency unavoidable.
"I am. Sirius is going to take me to AA when I’m feeling better and…"
Regulus cut her off again, hugging her so tightly Scarlett felt smothered. She didn’t push him away, though. Her body ached, her stomach churned, her muscles threatened to give out, but she didn’t let go.
"I love you too, it’s just… I’m so angry with you." he admitted, his voice muffled against the collar of the shirt that belonged to Sirius.
Scarlett closed her eyes and breathed in Reg’s scent—his hair, his tears, his love. She accepted him and sheltered him. Understood him and told him everything would be alright.
Like a mother should. Like a mother should always do for her child.
"I’m not going to run anymore, alright?" Scarlett felt Reggie nod against her. "Never again."
"Never again." he agreed, pulling his face back with a shy smile, full of affection.
Scarlett kissed her boy’s temple. The boy she had sacrificed everything to protect. And she hugged him again, making room for tenderness, chasing anger away with her presence.
The son she’d thought she’d lost to resentment was still there, in her arms, still wanting to be loved. And she still wanted to love him.
How he reminded her of Sirius when they were teenagers…
Just a boy wanting to be loved.
.
.
.
Sirius came home through the Floo. He crossed the sitting room like a wraith, shoulders slumped, legs unsteady. The weight of his own body was too much. His shirt was stuck to his chest with dried blood, his hair a mess with sweat, and the metallic smell was still fresh in his nostrils.
His blood-smeared hand shoved his bedroom door open, pulling it shut behind him. He straightened and went rigid, as if he’d just looked Medusa in the eye, but it was only Scarlett lying on the bed. Her blue eyes—always dense, always frightening—met his, searching him with intensity. Reading, with perfect clarity, every unspoken line of what his mouth would never manage to give shape to.
She rubbed at the deep dark circle beneath her left eye, blinking incessantly, trying to scrub the sight of Sirius like that from her vision with her eyelids. He looked like a demon bathed in his enemies’ blood.
A man who had just gone to hell and dragged it back with him.
"Sirius…?" she asked, her voice cracking in two.
He parted his lips, about to speak, but closed them again.
Sirius reached her in exactly four steps and dropped to his knees beside the bed. He buried his face in her stomach, his arms wrapping around her waist, anchoring himself to her in a futile attempt to keep from being swept away by the current of his own despair. Scarlett was the only thing stopping him from shattering into himself, from drowning in his own misfortune.
"It’s alright, I’m here…" Scarlett whispered as spasms spread through his body uncontrollably. Holding him the way he’d held her so many times.
Sirius was crying. Not a sound, not even a sob—just crying. Scarlett lifted her hands to his hair, stroking him softly, catching the sharp stink of blood clinging to him. She didn’t say anything else. He simply sank into the comfort of her presence, the sweetness of her consolation, the certainty that Scarlett would never come without the darkness hiding in her core.
Just as Sirius would never have her without her crimes.
If their demons couldn’t dance, then neither could they.
They wouldn’t give each other up. To do so would be to give up the air that filled their lungs, the light that entered through their retinas, the blood that ran through their veins—swift and hungry.
"You’re covered in blood, Sirius…" Scarlett finally said, her brows knitting with worry.
"I-it’s not mine…" Sirius murmured, his voice no more than a thread slipping through his worn vocal cords. "It’s not mine."
Scarlett absorbed his words without moving. She tilted her face and pressed her lips to his temple. Then she broke the silence at once, tightening him in her arms.
"Come here." She kissed his forehead. "Let’s get it off you."
Even weak and unsteady, Scarlett guided him into the bathroom. She turned the shower on, adjusting it to lukewarm. Sirius fumbled with the buttons of his shirt. His hands were filthy, scraped raw, swollen. The rings were stuck with dried blood. He simply stepped beneath the spray without even finishing undressing.
Water ran over his skin, carrying away grime, dissolving blood, stinging open flesh. Sirius hissed when it hit his aching knuckles. Scarlett took the soap and worked it carefully over his shoulders and neck, turning to wash his broad back, sliding down his arms until she reached his skinned, bruised hands. The iron scent rose with the hot steam of the shower.
"Do you want to tell me what happened?" The question was barely more than a trembling breath as her weakened hands washed his chest with the same gentleness as the foam blooming between her fingers.
Sirius, his gaze fixed on the floor, only let all the air spill from his lungs in a reluctant hiss and locked his jaw.
"Just…" The pain in his face vanished like a shadow dissolving under sunlight. "Just stay with me. Just… stay."
Scarlett nodded, though he wasn’t looking. She washed his face carefully, rinsing away the sweat and the fluids clinging to his beard. Sirius straightened. Spasms shook his hands beneath the water, whose temperature seemed determined to scald his bones.
She turned the shower off. Took a step back and grabbed the towel. She slipped his trousers off and dried his face, his arms, and finally his hands. She dried them gently, between his fingers, beneath his nails. Cleaned every wound, every scrape, every split in the skin. Kissed his knuckles.
"There." Scarlett wrapped him in the towel and dried herself beside him, fighting the dizziness that hit her every time she made a sudden movement. "Let’s lie down for a bit, alright?"
Sirius’s agreement came as a faint nod. He let himself be guided back to the bedroom, his gaze drifting over the unmade bed, the crumpled pillows, the coverlet half on the mattress, half on the floor.
How do you let the past go when it’s everywhere?
Scarlett lay down first. Sirius followed, settling his exhausted body beside hers. He pulled the covers up to their shoulders and stared at the ceiling, at the little glow-in-the-dark stars they had stuck there in a past so distant it felt unreal.
Sirius slid an arm around Scarlett’s waist. His body moulded to hers. His nose buried itself in her damp hair.
She turned onto her side to face him. Skin pressed to skin, his chest rising and falling slowly. His expression was calm, but his eyes carried a guilt Scarlett knew all too well. She reached out and traced her fingers along the rough shadow of his jaw, up to his temple. Kissed it. Then the tip of his nose. Finally, his mouth.
"I’m here." she said, firmly this time. "I’ll always be here."
Sirius smiled without meaning to, intoxicated by the shiver that curled through his body as Scarlett’s fingers threaded into his hair. He sank into the darkness behind his eyelids and let the world disappear.
There were no more words. No questions. No guilt or excuses. Just the need of two bodies that had found shelter in one another. That had seen each other’s excesses and absences and accepted them anyway. A love without despite, without but, without limits. Dancing along the thin line between acceptable and toxic, desired and forbidden.
Sirius and Scarlett were no longer lovers, nor ex–anything at all.
They were rubble. Shards. Fragments of something that neither begins nor ends. Two tired souls trying to find a little peace in one another, a home, trying to stitch their fissures together with pieces of each other—only to open more.
Two souls eternally dancing around the fire, until they burned and blamed one another. Until Scarlett was consumed by her favourite blaze.
Sirius tightened his hold on Scarlett, clutching her as if she were the angel who would save him from eternal damnation. Who would purge him of his congenital hatred, his intrinsic rage, his innate wrath.
Sirius Black wanted to be invaded by love as easily as he was by hate.
But love was not capable of that. Love was not capable of saving them.
It never would be enough to save them.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 88: Even when you hate yourself. Even when you think you don’t deserve my love
Chapter Text
CLVI
Sirius did not explain what had happened the day before, and Scarlett did not ask. She felt a little better upon waking that morning, nestled against him. They got up, and breakfast was already ready. Penny had prepared all her potions, and even though her body yearned for something none of them could give her, Scarlett drank every last one. She hugged and kissed Reg’s and Harry’s hair and laughed at their argument about the Quidditch match in which Harry had caught the Snitch and a Bludger had broken his arm.
She did not quite understand why the professor had made the bones in Harry’s arm vanish, but her thoughts were washed away when Sirius, at her side, rested his face against her shoulder and brought his lips close to her ear.
"There’s going to be a meeting at ten." He whispered, his warm breath brushing her lobe. "Do you want to come?"
Her body shivered. She did not know whether it was fear, excitement, or withdrawal.
Perhaps all three.
"I… I don’t know…"
"You can just listen." He insisted, kissing her neck tenderly.
Scarlett sighed, hunching her shoulder to protect herself from his advances.
"Alright… alright." She lowered her gaze, meeting those star-bright eyes.
Sirius smiled, dimples appearing among the thick strands of his beard.
"Mum, did you get a tattoo?!" Regulus bit into a piece of toast, elbowing Harry, who merely smiled shyly.
"Hm?" Scarlett glanced sideways at her son, stirring her tea with a clinking spoon. Sirius, tactile as ever, rested his chin on her shoulder again while cutting his pancake.
Reggie stretched an arm towards her and tugged at the oversized sleeve of the Sirius jumper she was wearing, revealing the tattoo she had gotten while drunk: Scarius, in the middle of a heart pierced by an arrow.
Her eyes widened. Her face flushed. She looked at her son, then at Sirius, whose smile lingered on his handsome features. He sipped his coffee and glanced at her from the corner of his eye, silver irises gleaming with contentment.
"You tattooed Scarius on your arm and you don’t take off the ring my uncle gave you. Are you married or what?!" He went on, immensely amused by the embarrassment growing across Scarlett’s face.
Sirius, who had just taken a massive gulp of coffee, choked. Remus raised a hand to his mouth to muffle a laugh. Harry frowned. Scarlett stammered something unintelligible. Regulus flashed a victorious grin.
"Four months." It was Penny who interrupted, snapping her fingers. The empty plates and cups floated to the sink. "Penny gives the Black couple four months to sort themselves out."
"But they’ve already sorted it out!" Reggie crossed his arms, staring at his parents. "Haven’t you?!"
Scarlett cleared her throat and looked away, scratching at the Ouroboros. Sirius was still wiping his face and nose with his napkin, snorting in disdain.
"You’ve reached your daily quota of nosiness, Reg." He scolded, getting up from the table abruptly.
"Alright, alright, I’m out, no one here said anything…" The boy raised his hands in surrender.
"How can it be? Barely raised together and he’s already just like a younger Sirius…" James commented to Lily, the two of them leaning against the kitchen doorway.
Scarlett lowered her gaze, trembling fingers tracing the burn scar on her forearm, her eyes drifting to her other arm, where the mark that lay there…
No. She wasn’t going to think about that now.
She rubbed the enchanted skin hard, teeth grinding.
"Ready?" Sirius pulled her out of her chaotic thoughts by drawing her into those ruinous pupils.
"I just… could we stop by the Leaky Cauldron first? I need to grab some clothes I left in the car." Scarlett said, surprised at how resolute her own voice sounded.
Sirius pouted and shrugged.
"Alright."
.
.
.
The taxi stopped in front of a grimy two-storey building, with small windows and a deteriorated façade. The paint on the outer walls was peeling away in flakes and cracks.
Scarlett rested her forehead against the window, feeling the cold against her warm skin. Outside, the sky carried heavy clouds, a pale grey that reminded her of Sirius’s eyes, though his were far more vivid.
Sirius paid the driver and walked around the car to open her door. Scarlett did not move, not at once. Her fingers were intertwined in her lap, nails pressing into her own skin.
"We can come back another day." He suggested, his eyes meeting hers. "It doesn’t have to be today."
"It has to be today." Scarlett corrected softly.
She stepped out of the car with unsteady legs. The air was damp and cold, smelling of scorched concrete. The scent mingled with that of the flowers in the building’s tiny front garden: white and yellow daisies, dried and brittle. After the sun of the day before, Scarlett was surprised they were not completely scorched.
Sirius guided her with his hand fitted to the curve of her waist. They stopped before a wooden door, where a sign displayed, in bold letters:
MORNING STAR GROUP — A.A.
Scarlett straightened and drew a very, very deep breath. Sirius cupped her face with both hands, his thumbs stroking her cheekbones. He kissed her forehead, the tip of her nose, her lips. The last lingered, heavy with affection, with promise, with longing.
"I love you." He said against her mouth. "Even when you hate yourself. Even when you think you don’t deserve my love."
Scarlett nodded and closed her eyes. A single tear slid down the side of her face. Sirius caught it with the pad of his thumb. The sun broke through the clouds, piercing them in a rain of light, wrapping them in gold and casting the shadow of both of them entwined on the pavement.
"You’re strong. You can do this." He rested his forehead against hers, kissing her once more. "I’ll be here when you’re done."
Her answer was to nod again. There was a knot in her throat that kept her from speaking. Her ghosts waited for her a few steps behind. Scarlett hugged Sirius tightly, trying to steal a little of his Gryffindor courage for herself, then let him go and gave him one last kiss.
They parted with some difficulty. It was as though neither of them wanted to let the other go. Scarlett, however, soon found herself pushing the door open and entering the building.
The AA room was on the first floor. The corridor smelled of reheated coffee (which immediately made her stomach protest), old paper, and disinfectant. The wooden floor creaked beneath her feet. At the end, a double door led into a large room, dimly lit by cold fluorescent lamps.
She removed her glasses, rubbing at her injured eye.
White plastic chairs were arranged in a circle, some empty, others occupied. No one stared at her for long. No one asked her name or said anything to her. It was good to pass unnoticed among so many people, without judgement or haste.
Scarlett chose a chair in the corner, close to a board bearing a prayer written in blue marker:
Grant me, Lord, the serenity to accept the things I cannot change,
the courage to change the things I can,
and the wisdom to know the difference.
Her eyes stopped, fixed on the word courage.
It was no use. She did not feel any braver for being there. Her gaze immediately darted to the door, hoping Sirius would appear to give her a thumbs-up or some kind of encouragement, but all she saw were her ghosts.
Her ghosts. Following her wherever she went. Except, of course, when she was drunk.
Her mouth watered. Her throat went dry. Her fingers stroked the diamond of her ring incessantly, the ring Sirius had given her when he asked her to marry him. Her thumb was already burning when she stopped, the pad nearly skinned raw.
A woman with greying hair pinned into a bun began the meeting. She read an introduction, explained how the meeting worked, and then opened the floor for people to share.
Scarlett sighed, ready to listen to stories from people who had nothing to do with her. None of them were a fucked-up witch, tortured, seeing her dead friends and who should be buried alongside them.
The first to speak was a man in his fifties, eyes cast down and hands that would not stop rubbing together. He said he had lost custody of his daughter because he had forgotten to pick her up from school for the tenth time. He had been drunk for so long that he had lost all sense of time.
Scarlett wanted to laugh. She had never been that drunk. Of course, at gigs it was a bit hard to know what day of the week it was because they weren’t important, since she played every other day, which meant that regardless of weekends, she was going to work, so… it wasn’t really that important to know what day of the week it was… right?!
The urge to laugh died.
James and Lily sat down beside her. Regulus remained standing behind them, ever taciturn. He was quieter than usual. Scarlett did not want to know why, did not even want to look at him. She wanted him to disappear. To die already. To stop haunting her.
That was too much to ask, she knew that. That was why she drank, too.
A young woman in a flat-brim cap spoke about her mother. About how she anguished and cried in secret when she got home and saw everything broken.
Scarlett felt her heart shrink so violently she feared it might vanish altogether. She pressed a hand to her chest, making sure it was still there, trying to force it to beat by pushing her palm into her skin, because it seemed to have given up.
A lad in a leather jacket much like hers said he was there by court order and told everyone to fuck off.
She sighed, weary after listening to testimonies from people who had everything to do with her. Even if she was a fucked-up witch, tortured, who saw her dead friends and should be buried with them.
She rubbed her eyes hard with her knuckles, trying to patch the cracks in her core where she hid the guilt, the disgust for herself, and the sadness with no name or face.
A man stood up. He wore a battered denim waistcoat, covered in metal band patches: Slayer, Black Sabbath, Megadeth, Metallica, Sepultura, Anthrax…
"Good morning. I’m Beto. I’m an alcoholic, and I’ve been sober for eleven years."
"Good morning, Beto." The others repeated in a morbid chorus.
He looked at everyone there, but when his dark eyes reached Scarlett, they stopped. She stayed rigid, begging the lack of oxygen to make her invisible.
"I don’t know the name of the blonde woman in the corner, and I don’t need to." He paused. "But I know how you feel."
Scarlett swallowed hard, her brows drawing together in indignation as her lips pressed into a thin, indivisible line.
"I know what it’s like to wake up and hate that you’re still alive. That the nausea doesn’t come just from the drink, but from the guilt. From the anger. From that pain you feel just from remembering you exist." He spoke calmly, as if he were giving her a bloody lecture. "I understand the fear of thinking that if you stop drinking, what will be left? What will be left of you?" He paused, his eyes shining with something she could not name.
He did not cry. For some reason, that made Scarlett want to.
"There will be a lot left. Especially the things we hate the most. Sometimes even more than we imagined. But what we love will be left too." He took a deep breath and lifted his coffee mug with both hands. "I’ll be over there, in the corner, after the meeting. If you want to talk to me, or just sit nearby… you can come."
Scarlett stood up. All eyes in the room were already on her. Her heart roaring in her chest. Her body shaking. Her hands searching for something, anything they could grab. Preferably a glass bottle. Full. It could be whisky. Or vodka. Or anything with at least thirteen per cent alcohol.
She turned her back and ran.
The corridor felt longer than she remembered. The door, heavier. The air outside was thick. Scarlett had to make an immense effort just to breathe. She went down the steps like someone descending a scaffold.
Sirius was leaning against the taxi, one hand shoved into his pocket, the other holding a cigarette. His eyes were fixed on the building entrance, and Scarlett’s reflection danced in his silver irises. His bare shoulders beneath the vest stiffened the instant she stumbled on the steps, folded forward, braced her hands on her knees, and vomited.
He was already there, holding her hair back.
When Scarlett stopped retching, Sirius offered her a handkerchief, kneeling beside her. She wiped her mouth harshly, angry at herself. The crying came straight after, a torrent that alternated between sobs and desperation.
"I’m sorry… I’m sorry…" She gasped, her voice lost in broken breaths.
Sirius only pulled her into him, pressing her trembling body against his chest. Scarlett buried her face in his collarbone and broke down, just as she had on Harry’s birthday. The crying shook her violently, and Scarlett held her breath, trying to smother it.
It didn’t work.
"It’s alright." Sirius murmured, kissing her forehead. "I’m here. Just breathe, love. Just breathe."
Scarlett dragged in as much air as she could through her mouth… which, considering she had just been sick, was not much. She gagged and forced the air out hard, spitting on the ground. The acrid taste coated her palate.
Sirius waited until her sobs lost their strength. Until the raw pain was honed into mute exhaustion.
When Scarlett’s shoulders stopped shaking and her body went slack in his arms, he held her more firmly. He placed one hand at the base of her spine and the other between her shoulder blades.
"Let’s go home."
Scarlett did not answer. Nor did she resist when he guided her to the waiting taxi. Sirius opened the door with his elbow and helped her into the back seat. She curled in on herself, knees drawn up, arms wrapped around her own body in a futile attempt at self-protection.
He got in after her, shut the door, and told the driver to take them back. The car pulled away, and the city dragged itself past in the pale, glazed tones of a summer rain day, the drops spilling over the bodywork of the car, over the crowded pavements, over the dark asphalt.
Sirius looked at Scarlett. Her head was resting against the window, lashes damp, eyelids fluttering as she fought against surrendering to sleep.
"Come here." He whispered, giving two light taps on the empty space beside him.
Scarlett lifted her eyes with effort. That simple act exhausted her. She slid across the leather seat towards him. Laid her head on his chest. Sirius wrapped an arm around her shoulders. His heartbeat was placid, but strong. Concise. Constant. Contagious.
Sirius’s tattooed, ring-laden fingers stroked her tangled, sweaty hair, still stuck to her temples.
"It’s alright. You can rest." He kissed her cheek. "I’m here."
Scarlett nodded and closed her eyes, focusing on the song of her favourite place in the entire world: the heart of the man she loved. The pulse echoed through her body, soothing her own heartbeat until they fell into resonance. Her body yielded. Her hands loosened. Her breathing slowed.
Sirius rested his chin on the crown of her head and closed his eyes too, becoming her shelter and safe harbour in the same way she had been for him the day before. In the same way they had always been for one another in this relationship of storm and calm.
She had fallen so deeply asleep in his arms that she did not notice when they arrived. The taxi stopped, then set off again. They did not get out. They circled the block until it was time for lunch. Sirius checked the time and woke Scar with a soft kiss on the cheek and a gentle stroke just behind her ear with his thumb.
"Hey, kitten… we’re here." He whispered, starry eyes lit by his dimpled smile. "Come on, it’s lunchtime…"
Scarlett, still drowsy, simply followed Sirius. He paid the taxi driver after adding a generous tip and led her inside the house.
.
.
.
Scarlett forced herself to eat at lunch. She pushed the empty plate away, her fingers still intertwined with Sirius’s beneath the table.
"I need to head out. My Auror exam is today." He murmured, but he did not let go of her hand, did not even make a move to stand. His black hair fell like a midnight sky over his shoulders, sleek and long. It was nearly reaching his waist now. His other hand stroked the beard on his chin.
"Today?!" Harry was eating the slice of caramel tart Penny had made just for him. "And you’re ready?"
Sirius let out a nasal laugh, pale eyes drifting from side to side as he shook his head.
"I’ve been ready since eighty-one, Harry." He licked his lips. "The difference is that this time I won’t get arrested before the exam… hopefully…"
Remus laughed too, as did Reggie.
"Nervous?" his nephew asked, nicking a piece of Harry’s tart.
"A bit." Sirius admitted, his smile deepening his dimples. "But… more confident than I thought I’d be."
"Sirius, relax. You’re brilliant, you’ll breeze through it…" Scarlett said, lining the cutlery up perfectly on her plate.
"You’d pass that exam without even breaking a sweat." He squeezed her hand beneath the table.
"Oh yeah? Why’s that?" Reg wiped his mouth with a napkin.
"Your mum was the most talented witch out of all of us, Reg." It was Remus who answered, with a gentleness Scarlett found strange. "The best in the duelling club."
"I joined the duelling club in second year!" Harry straightened up, suddenly animated. "But it was with Lockhart…"
"Oh, right." Reggie rolled his eyes. "Lockhart was the worst of the lot. Could barely cast a spell…"
"That’s how I found out I was a Parselmouth!" Harry added.
Sirius frowned.
"You’re a Parselmouth?!"
Scarlett swallowed hard. Her eyes searched the room for Red’s ghost, but she didn’t find him.
"Yeah… that’s how I talked to the basilisk!"
"To the what?!" Sirius raised his voice, alarmed and confused, already leaning over the table like he was about to conduct an interrogation.
"Sirius…" Scarlett intervened, squeezing his hand beneath the table.
He turned to her, the gleam tinting his grey irises now brimming with curiosity.
"You’ll have all the time in the world to talk to Harry about this later. But right now…" She smiled. "You need to get ready."
Sirius opened his mouth to argue, but Scarlett shut him up by arching an eyebrow.
"Go on, love." The request sounded more like an order. "You can’t be late."
"Ooh, the whip’s cracked, Padfoot…" Reggie joked, making Harry burst out laughing.
"Pulled his lead tight…" The boy adjusted his glasses with the same tic as his father.
Sirius merely sighed loudly and stood up, hands on his hips.
"Alright, alright… but we’re picking this conversation back up when I get back!"
"Fine." Harry shrugged.
Scarlett watched him leave the kitchen, not before he glanced back over his shoulder and winked at her. She smiled, her heart skipping a few beats. The smile did not last, however. Her gaze shifted to Lily and James commenting on how Harry now seemed more comfortable staying between them.
Red appeared in the kitchen doorway, his faint light blending with the brightness pouring in through the floor-to-ceiling windows.
Harry is a Horcrux.
Scarlett looked away towards the table, where Remus was telling Harry and Reggie about the first time he had heard the legend of the basilisk and the Chamber of Secrets at Hogwarts, and how he, Sirius, James and… Peter — he mentioned the last with visible discomfort — had searched for it in their early school years.
Sirius returned dressed in black from head to toe: his leather jacket and trousers, a plain T-shirt and combat boots. They went over to the fireplace, and Scarlett adjusted the collar of his jacket.
"Good luck, Sirius." Harry gave him a light tap on the arm.
"If you pass, are you going to arrest me if I’m smoking?" Reggie mocked, elbowing Sirius. "If so, I hope you fail."
"You’re feeling funny today, Reg…" Sirius slung an arm around his shoulders. "What happened? Did Victoria stop by yesterday and I didn’t hear about it?!"
Regulus opened his mouth to retort, but the blush rose faster across his cheeks.
"No… it’s just… argh, forget it!" He flopped onto the sofa, grabbing the telly remote.
"You don’t need luck." Remus gave him an encouraging slap on the shoulder.
Sirius snorted a quiet laugh and reached for the Floo powder jar.
"Wait." Scarlett caught his wrist and hugged him with all the strength she had. A full, unguarded embrace, her face tucked into his neck and her arms holding him as though trying to reclaim everything they had lost and everything that could still be saved.
"I love you, Sirius." She whispered against his skin. "You’re strong. You can do this. I’ll be here when you’re done."
Sirius pressed her against him, drinking in the scent of her hair, her skin, her presence. He pulled back just enough to look at her, starry eyes gleaming like polished silver.
"Thank you, kitten."
They parted with a kiss that said nothing and said everything.
He grabbed a handful of emerald-green powder and took one last look at everyone.
"Ministry of Magic." The flames swallowed him.
Scarlett’s fingers could still feel his warmth minutes after he had vanished.
"Come on, Reggie. Let’s play!" Harry called, switching on the Super Nintendo.
"Get ready to lose, Harry…"
Scarlett remained standing in front of the fireplace, her eyes tracing the marble surround. Then her feet carried her to the corner of the room, where the piano rested beside the windows veiled by curtains dancing to the rhythm of the wind.
She sat down and lifted the lid. Her fingers skimmed the ivory keys. Icy. Still. Polished. Her hand tensed, intending to play, but the impulse never reached her fingertips. The air tangled in her lungs.
Sixteen years.
Sixteen years without touching it.
She rested her hands on her thighs, rubbing her Ouroboros, her thumb brushing over the engagement ring.
"It feels like yesterday that we brought it here…" Remus murmured, walking towards her. He passed by her side and leaned over the polished lid, its surface reflecting his tired expression.
Scarlett did not look at him. Remus scratched at the scar on his chin and turned his face towards the view through the window, where a gap in the curtains revealed the street. Children rode bicycles with their parents’ help, couples strolled, friends laughed loudly.
"I saw… your memories." He revealed, lowering his voice. He did not want the boys nosing about, even though they were far away and absorbed in Mario Kart. "Despite what Sirius told me about Azkaban, seeing you go through those things…"
His mouth stopped, half open. He swallowed hard. He did not finish the sentence. He did not need to.
Scarlett closed the piano lid, biting her lower lip to keep herself quiet.
It did not work.
"And you came here to tell me you pity me?!" She did not hide the passive-aggressive edge in her taunt.
Remus closed his eyes and exhaled slowly, searching in the darkness of his eyelids for the perfect sentence he could say in that moment.
But it did not exist.
"No, I… I came here…" He ran a hand through his sand-coloured hair, flecked with grey. "I know what it’s like… to kill someone like that. Without having a choice and… I know… how… terrifying it is and…"
"No, Remus… you don’t know!" Scarlett cut him off sharply. "Because in your case, it was the wolf. In mine…" She licked her lips, smiling. A painful smile. "There’s no one to blame but myself. Is that all?"
Remus shook his head in denial, resting his elbows on the piano, blinking rapidly.
"Still, Scar… all these years…"
Scar. The nickname sounded like an insult. She looked away, not bothering to hide the discomfort on her face.
"I don’t want your pity, nor your feelings. Much less your apologies…"
"I want to make peace." He interrupted her.
"I don’t want to make peace with you!" Scarlett snapped with the delicacy of a kick.
"I don’t want to keep fighting with you in front of the boys!" Remus said, more controlled now, his voice still low.
"Of course, Remus, after saying a load of shit to me you don’t want to fight anymore." Her laugh turned bitter. "How convenient!"
"I didn’t want to… I didn’t want to have said those things. I was so angry and—"
"You were right." Scarlett cut him off once more. "A hundred years in Azkaban and I’d never deserve it… but I don’t care what you think or what you think you think. I love him. I love him with all my heart. With all my guilt… with everything that’s left of me. And I would kill as many times as necessary to keep my family safe. And… and I…"
Scarlett gasped, trying to bury the tears that insisted on rising to the surface.
Aren’t friends for that?”To forgive us and give us a chance to be better people?
"I was just trying to survive. And I… I’m alive and… and it’s the first time I actually want to live! What more do you want from me?!" She sniffed, refusing to cry.
She did not cry.
"I didn’t… I didn’t mean those things." A painful crease formed between Remus’s brows. "I was just… taking my frustrations out on you and… you… you were my best friend and… I’m sorry." He swallowed slowly, brown eyes now fixed on hers. "Truly. I wish that… I wish we could talk so that… so that I can understand, Scar. What happened. What you went through and… please. We need to get along… for the boys."
She crossed her arms and massaged her temple. Rubbed her eyes with the backs of her hands. Lowered her head. She did not want to talk about it. Not again. Telling Sirius had already been painful enough.
"I’m tired, Remus… of having to justify myself." Scarlett confessed, exhausted. "I’m tired…" She repeated, with less emphasis. She flexed her jaw and bit her lower lip, but she did not cry.
"Alright." He murmured, conciliatory. He stretched a hand towards her, meaning to touch her, but pulled back before doing so. "I’m sorry. I didn’t… I was angry. I was also… also left behind. I was alone too." His voice dropped lower with every word. It was a thorny subject for him as well.
"We all were." Scarlett filled her lungs slowly, before the sensation of suffocation could take hold. "We were a group of friends who loved each other, but… the more the war advanced… the more we hated… we hated the war, ourselves… each other…" She shook her head. "We’re all that’s left."
Remus watched, mute and stunned, as Scarlett stepped away from the piano. His gaze drifted across the room; to her back as she walked towards the gardens, to Reggie and Harry playing animatedly on the Super Nintendo… to his own open hands, covered in scars and trembling fingers.
He clenched them with the same force he used to squeeze his eyes shut. He forced out silent tears and went to the sofa, sitting in the armchair to watch the boys play.
.
.
.
Sirius pulled on his leather gloves, fastened his coat, and checked the time on his pocket watch. His own image in the photograph stared back at him, Reggie on his lap and his friends beside him. Except for Wormtail, whose face was burned.
He dropped into a chair in the waiting room, expelling the air from his lungs.
"Nervous?" Asked a calm voice.
Sirius looked up. Albus Dumbledore was watching him with that expression of someone who knew more than he ought to, hands clasped behind his back, his petrol-blue robes as striking as his thick greying beard.
"Not really." He forced a smile, running a hand through his hair to tie it back into a ponytail. "What are you doing here?"
"Overseeing some internal procedures." Dumbledore studied him through his half-moon spectacles. "I confess I also came to see how things are with our mutual friend."
Sirius’s smile vanished. His expression hardened, his lips twisted, his silver eyes sharpened into steel.
"When were you planning to tell me Harry is a Parselmouth?" He shot back, folding his arms with insolence.
"There were more pressing matters to attend to…" Dumbledore was still smiling, though now his lips were filled with gentleness.
A kind of gentleness that made Sirius grind his teeth.
"It’s far too peculiar an ability to be ignored, Albus." Sirius narrowed his eyes. "That’s not the sort of thing that just appears out of nowhere!"
"Not necessarily." Dumbledore stroked his moustache. "James descended from several wizarding bloodlines, some of them ancient… it would not surprise me if a distant connection to Salazar Slytherin had left such a legacy."
Sirius snorted an incredulous laugh.
"That makes no sense. That’s not how it works. Parseltongue is hereditary. It’s not something that just shows up out of nowhere!"
"And yet, in rare cases, it can skip generations."
"Skip what?! Six, seven generations?!" He scoffed harshly. "We both know that’s not how it works!"
The door to the room opened.
"Sirius Orion Black, you may proceed to the next stage." A voice called.
Sirius took a deep breath and stood, never taking his eyes off Dumbledore.
"What aren’t you telling me?"
Dumbledore remained still as a statue, his blue eyes cooling to such a degree that Sirius felt a shiver run through him.
"Sirius Orion Black!" The woman called again.
"You don’t have to tell me. I’ll find out myself." He whispered acidly, and left the room. Dumbledore’s gaze followed him until the door closed.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 89: Baby's breath
Chapter Text
CLVII
Lily Evans was considered radiant by everyone. Clever, yes, when she needed to be, but there was always kindness in her eyes and warmth in her words. The first-years saw her as an example to follow, and the third- and fourth-year girls envied her for being James Potter’s romantic interest.
She did not feel radiant at all that morning. Petunia rarely wrote to her, but whenever she did, it was always to show her just how happy she was without her. Her older sister had never forgiven her for going to Hogwarts and, even though it hadn’t been Lily’s choice, she punished her for not inviting her to her wedding, for calling her a freak, for cutting her out of her life entirely and for telling her friends that Lily studied at a boarding school because she was too troublesome and their parents couldn’t stand her.
None of it was true, of course, but it hurt all the same.
She wiped the tears from her flushed cheeks and crumpled the letter when she heard two light knocks on her bedroom door.
"Lily? Can I come in?" It was James.
Of course it was him. Who else would knock on her door when she was at her lowest point, at the strangest and most humiliating moment, in the one bloody hour she wanted to be alone?
She cleared her throat and tossed the crumpled paper into the fireplace, wiping beneath her eyes once more.
"You can." She adjusted herself in the chair, straightening her spine.
James pushed the door open and took an uncertain step inside, hazel eyes searching hers and looking for some kind of permission, even though she had already given it to him. He was tall, lanky, with eternally messy hair. He wore glasses now, but when she’d first met him, he hadn’t. When had he started wearing them? Third year? Or was it fourth?
Lily wasn’t sure.
He nudged the frames up the bridge of his long nose with his little finger and wet his lips, as if the words had simply evaporated into the air.
"Is Remus alright?" she asked, shifting in her chair and making it creak.
"He… he’ll be fine…" James scratched the back of his neck. "I don’t… I came… I… I need…" He stammered. He took a deep breath and let it out through his mouth. "Do you have the key to Slughorn’s office?"
Lily raised an eyebrow and her eyes narrowed with suspicion. The fire crackled between them, casting orange light over James, the dim glow dancing across his pale face and the lenses of his glasses.
"Why do you want to get into his office?" she asked bluntly, sighing.
James swallowed, his prominent Adam’s apple bobbing in his throat.
"I can’t tell you."
"It’s not as if I’d lend it to you anyway." She turned her face back to the parchments on the desk in front of her. "I’m not going to be part of your idiotic pranks…"
"No… no, it’s not for that. Not exactly." He took another step towards her, shoving his hands into his trouser pockets. "It’s… it’s just…" He shook his head, still not knowing what to say.
"What are you lot plotting?" She looked at him sideways again, folding her arms.
James bit his lower lip and let his gaze sweep across every piece of furniture in her room: the impeccably made bed, the chair and desk, the fireplace mantel, the bathroom door. Then he looked back at her, giving up on trying to convince her of something he himself wasn’t even sure was wise.
What he told her next was an absurd and reckless plan. Coming from the Marauders, that was hardly a surprise. By the end of it, she was gaping, every alarm in her head screaming at her to say no. And she would have said no, but for some reason, she hesitated.
Maybe it was because James stepped closer and his cinnamon scent stole her voice. Or because he smiled to himself, albeit reluctantly, as if he couldn’t quite believe he’d just told her the most idiotic plan she’d ever heard. Or perhaps it was because she laughed too.
James had that thing about him. It wasn’t exactly charm, but a mad, impulsive self-confidence that made people want to stand by his side.
The flames reflected in his glasses. Lily could see his irises through them, the hazel melting into copper, swallowed by the darkness of his pupils as they dilated on her.
And she agreed. Just like that. Without James needing to drop to his knees and beg. Something she was absolutely certain he would have done. It was so sudden that even he didn’t seem to believe what she’d said, his thin lips still parted and his eyes wide.
"I’ll rearrange the patrols so we can do ours in the dungeons tonight." She said, reaching for the quill nearby. "See you at eight, then?"
James was so stunned that he just stared at her for several seconds, his mind trying to process what she’d just said.
"See you at eight, then." He repeated, like a parrot.
Lily was still smiling when he left the room. She covered her face with her hands and forced her lips to relax, even though they refused to obey. She squeezed her cheeks hard until they puckered into a pout.
What was she doing? Why was she smiling? She couldn’t do this! That was James Potter, the curse of her existence ever since she’d set foot in that school, bullying her and her friends, pulling her hair, sticking chewing gum in it, sending her multiplying love notes on Valentine’s Day and ruining all her romantic relationships!
She couldn’t like him.
She didn’t like him.
She let out a long breath to calm herself and sniffed, rubbing her nose the same way she rubbed James out of her nervous system. She wiped the sweat from her palms, crushed the butterflies in her stomach and, above all, killed the smile on her face.
.
.
.
The Potions corridor was empty at that hour. The icy wind howled between the candelabra and the tapestries, lashing at Lily’s legs, protected by a thick layer of stockings. She checked her wristwatch and bit the inside of her cheek, arms crossed and foot tapping incessantly against the floor.
James arrived ten minutes late. Armed with an apologetic smile and the tic of constantly adjusting his glasses on his face, he was holding a tiny white flower, so small that Lily only realised he was offering it when he stood there for far too long without moving.
"Erm… Scar told me to give you this." He cleared his throat, straightening his posture. "She said you’d understand."
Lily lowered her gaze to the flower between James’s calloused fingers.
"Baby’s breath" She murmured, accepting the gift with a smile that tried to stretch her lips, but she didn’t allow it.
"What?" James frowned, his smile turning awkward.
"The name of the flower." Lily tucked it behind her ear. "Shall we?"
James merely nodded, pressing his lips into a thin line.
Lily took the Potions classroom key from the pocket of her cloak and unlocked the door, motioning for him to follow.
It wasn’t strange to her to enter the room when it was completely empty. She often took responsibility for a few favours for Slughorn and acted as something of his assistant in lessons, tutoring younger students who needed help. It wasn’t a secret to anyone that she was the professor’s favourite.
For Slughorn to like her more, she’d have had to be a Slytherin.
She lit the room with a Lumos. The white light slid over glass jars, dark stone walls and cauldrons stacked along the sides. Lily and James crossed between the tables to the entrance of the professor’s office, where she took out the keyring again and tried a few keys in the lock until the door clicked and swung open.
James had never been in there before.
The office was like any other place in Hogwarts: frozen in time. Tall cabinets lined the curved walls, crammed with dusty glass bottles containing preserved ingredients in viscous liquids: valerian roots, magical creatures’ brains, murtlap tentacles, occamy eggs and things Lily preferred not to identify.
The smell of dust was strong. In the centre, a solid oak desk displayed melted candles stuck into eccentric holders made from columns of dried vertebrae, and a quill floated above scribbled parchment. A blackened cauldron sat beside an unlit lantern. Under the flickering light of the Lumos, dust danced in the air, sparkling like fireflies.
"I think he kept it here…" Lily whispered, reaching the back of the room. There, half-hidden behind a cluster of bottles with corroded lids, stood a small locked cabinet.
She took out the keyring again and sifted through it until she held the smallest key of all. The lock gave with a click, and the little doors opened on their own.
The potion vial was there. Lily narrowed her eyes and checked its colour: thick sludge.
"How much are you going to need?" She looked at James over her shoulder.
He was only a few steps away, his eyes swallowed by the glow reflected in his glasses.
"All of it."
"I can’t give you everything! He’ll notice!" Lily scolded, trying to keep her voice down.
"But Sirius said—" James began to argue, only for the sound of footsteps on the other side of the door to cut him off.
He froze. Lily’s eyes widened and her lips pressed together.
Someone was outside the door.
They stared at each other in panic.
James grabbed her by the hand so fast Lily didn’t even have time to react. The two of them scrambled under the central table, between extinguished candles and stacks of musty books. It was tight, stifling and suffocating. Lily landed hard between James’s legs, her back pressed to his chest, the vial clutched in both hands.
He braced himself with one palm against the wood. With the other, he slowly reached out and tugged the hem of Lily’s cloak fully beneath the table. His breathing was slow and controlled, but Lily could feel his unruly heartbeat thundering against her back.
The door handle turned with a creak.
Lily caught James’s hand and squeezed it. They both held their breath. Footsteps echoed inside the room. The light of a wand sketched shadows through the gaps beneath the table.
She could feel every detail of it: the warmth of James’s body against the cold carpet she was sitting on, his warm breath brushing her hair, his fingers laced with hers. Rough, trembling. Strong.
The shape moved away. The footsteps retreated to the door, which clicked shut.
Lily let out her breath, though she was still breathing carefully. Immersed in darkness, her remaining senses sharpened. James brought his face closer to the nape of her neck, warm puffs of air now sending shivers through her entire body.
"Bloody hell… that was close." He murmured.
She nodded, even though he couldn’t see her. With her heart hammering in her throat and her hands slick with sweat, Lily Evans had no idea why she had agreed to help James Potter with that absurd, idiotic plan.
She was Head Girl of Gryffindor, for Merlin’s sake. Why was she acting like a reckless fool? And why did behaving this way make a delicious thrill spark through her veins and a smile spread across her lips?
She couldn’t do things like this. She was the model student of that school and not a… not a…
James cast Lumos, and the gloom was cut through by the pale, whitish light at the tip of his wand. Lily turned her face towards him, half-profile, watching him from the corner of her eye. The scent of cinnamon intensified so much that she didn’t even hear what he said. His thin lips, edged with a faint shadow of down, had never looked as attractive as they did in that moment.
Her heart was now pounding in her wrists, her fingertips, her ears. Her stomach flipped, and James’s warmth crept under her skin with such insistence that all she could do was look at him. Look at him looking at her while she tried to remember how to speak her own language, searching for the right word, for something that might simply end the embarrassing moment.
There had to be some spell for that.
James’s eyes widened once more, those hazel eyes she hated so much. She hated the brown circling his pupils and hated the gold dipped in green at the edges of his bewildered irises. She hated those ridiculous round glasses and the way that boy managed to look so utterly gormless.
She hated, most of all, how adorably flushed James was.
"What are you staring at, Potter?!" she snapped, crawling out from under the table with her heart nearly leaping out of her chest. "You pervert!"
"What? What did I do?!" James raised his hands in an attempt to prove his innocence, but Lily was already getting to her feet, breathless and flustered.
"You… you…" She faltered. She had no idea what he’d done either. "Just take the bloody potion already!" She thrust the vial at James without looking at him. Her face felt like it was on fire.
He was still under the table, staring at her in shock.
"But… you said I couldn’t take all of—"
"Just take it!" she insisted. She grabbed James’s hand and shoved the vial into it, huffing. "We nearly got caught! I can’t… I don’t know why I agreed to this!" she complained, fumbling in the pocket of her cloak for the keyring, her trembling hands rummaging through the keys for something she had no idea what even was.
"Alright, but we didn’t…" James crawled out from under the table and slapped his hand against his trousers. "Relax, Lily."
"Of course you’re not nervous. You’re a seasoned delinquent!" she shot back, exasperated, her face as red as her spark-bright hair.
James closed his mouth and merely nodded.
She still couldn’t look him in the eye, and he knew that anything he said now would only make things worse. Even so, James took a step towards her. Lily stiffened, her muscles locking as though they’d turned to stone. With two fingers, he gently adjusted the white flower hanging from her ear, freeing the strands of hair tangled in its petals.
Lily swallowed, her eyes tracking James’s fingers up to his face. She looked at him for exactly half a second. Too fast to be noticed, but long enough to scramble her synapses. Still, she wrestled her brain back under control, pulled the hood of her cloak up over her head and stormed out of the room, marching angrily between the potion cabinets.
James ran a hand through his hair, mussing it even further. The potion vial rested in his other hand, his heart hammering violently in his chest.
Merlin’s bloody bollocks, what the hell had just happened?!
.
.
.
Another morning, another Quidditch practice. This one, however, was one of the rare occasions when Slytherin had managed to secure the pitch exclusively for themselves. McGonagall had been making things difficult, as she wanted the field to be used only by the Hogwarts team, which irritated the Heads of the other Houses.
The Slytherin team had just taken a break, most of the players scattering to drink water or chat in small groups. Regulus, Barty and Rosier gathered in their usual clique with Nott and the Carrows. Lucinda sat down beside Scarlett’s substitute, a girl called Emma Vanity. The two were in the same year. Jacob Alcott made a move to sit next to Scar, but she paid no attention whatsoever to the boy’s chatter.
Scarlett leaned forward, both elbows resting on her broom, its handle floating lazily behind her. Her eyes were fixed on Evan Rosier. Her fingers drummed against one of the footrests.
Her gaze shifted to the stands, where Peter was chewing on a sugar quill. He waved at her and glanced towards Rosier.
Scar let all the air rush out of her lungs in a sharp hiss.
"Do you ever breathe?" she asked, eyebrows arching at Jacob’s relentless babbling.
"Uh… I do… breathe… yeah… I mean… sorry…" He gave an awkward smile and dropped his gaze. "Have you ever heard of the Cursed Vaults?"
Scarlett didn’t answer him.
She cast one last look at Peter. He was now chewing the quill so hard it looked like it was about to snap. Then she forced her legs to move. She crossed the pitch as the icy wind lashed her face. She passed Lucinda and Emma, ignoring their muffled giggles and drawing the attention of the rest of the team. She spared one final glance at the stands, where Peter had already disappeared.
He was probably already in his rat form.
Scarlett’s attention locked onto Rosier, whose sardonic grin was permanently etched onto his face as he spoke with Red and Barty. The two of them noticed her at the same instant. Crouch raised an eyebrow, but it was Regulus who seemed bothered. His face, usually impassive, hardened with another layer of rigidity in a silent warning.
Scarlett knew that look. An attempt to dissuade her. Regulus knew her well enough to recognise that her impulsive stance was a prelude to trouble. And she ignored him well enough to do it anyway.
"Evan." She called out. Her voice cut through the conversation like thunder splitting the sky.
Rosier slowly turned his face towards her, his smile sharpening until his teeth showed.
"Gaunt." He greeted her back. His dark, calculating eyes raked over her with intensity. "What do you want?"
"I’m here to collect." She shrugged, her expression carved from stone. "The evidence you promised me and never showed."
Rosier shot a fleeting look at Regulus and Barty, his lips loosening, though the perversion lingered in his shadowed gaze. Neither of them moved. They scarcely even seemed to breathe.
Scarlett didn’t back down, lifting her chin as she held his stare.
"Oh, that." Evan laughed, his voice honeyed. "I said I’d show you. But obviously I don’t walk around with confidential Ministry files in my pocket. That requires discretion. Planning. The Forbidden Forest, perhaps? At night. A little stroll by wandlight…"
"Why not now?" She stepped forward, the wind blowing so hard it tugged the hem of her cloak backwards.
Evan glanced upward and took a deep, irritated breath.
"Now?" He shoved his hands into his cloak pockets. "I don’t have anything on me."
"Of course you don’t." Scarlett hissed, striking fast like a coiled snake. "You can’t have what doesn’t exist."
She was close enough now to feel Evan’s breath brush her cheeks. He studied her with his usual malice, and the smile returned, his lips tightening in disdain. The citrus scent tried to invade her senses, but Scarlett exhaled sharply.
"Careful, Scarlett. Everyone’s watching." He murmured, that depraved amusement lacing his voice. "If you get any closer, they’ll think we’re together."
"They will?" She touched his jaw, feeling the roughness of stubble just beginning to grow. Evan was cold. As cold as any other Slytherin in that school. The blood in his veins was as frigid as a reptile’s.
Scarlett slid her fingers up to Evan’s ear, catching a lock of his black hair between her index and middle fingers. She rubbed them together there and let out a breath of contempt. Her mouth curved into a cruel smile. Her eyes cooled until they were nothing but twin stakes of ice.
"You’re the one who should be careful, you little Death Eater wanker." She hissed.
She shoved her hands into the pockets of her training trousers and backed away, feeling the stares of Regulus and Barty burning into the nape of her neck.
She mounted her broom, and the Quidditch pitch shrank into a tiny blur behind her. She dived and weaved between trees and students until she landed just before the castle entrance, where Pete was panting, hands braced on his knees and sweat dripping from his forehead, even though it was nearly the start of winter.
"You took your time." He panted. "Thought he was either going to kill you or kiss you."
Scarlett laughed. A cathartic laugh, almost desperate.
"Yeah. Me too, Pete…" She slung an arm over her friend’s shoulders and dragged him into the castle. "Me too…"
"I think it worked…" He pulled another sugar quill from his magically expanded pockets.
"What did you do?!" A curious crease appeared between Scarlett’s brows.
"Sirius asked me to distract him. But why distract when I can incapacitate?" He shrugged arrogantly.
"Brilliant, Wormtail." She flicked his ear, which earned her Pete’s shrill, delighted laugh.
.
.
.
Heavy rain poured down over Hogsmeade, painting the village’s cobblestones black as its residents hurried to take shelter beneath the slate roofs of the shops. Aurors clustered around the Hog’s Head.
"I don’t like this." Mary buried her face deeper into her scarf, quickening her pace towards an alley between the shops furthest from the centre.
Remus, right behind her, kept his head down, his hood shadowing his face. He glanced to either side and guided her across the bridge that led them to the more isolated part of the village, where vegetation outweighed human presence.
Despite being beneath Scarlett’s Invisibility Cloak, they’d disguised themselves in ordinary clothes and the classic defensive posture of any teenager doing something they shouldn’t. Rumours said some Aurors possessed monocles capable of seeing through cloaks, which made their operation, at the very least, even more dangerous.
The spot where they were meant to meet the seller lay near the back of Honeydukes. Remus’s gaze swept to the moss-covered stone wall, then back along the path they’d taken, the footprints sunk deep into the mud leading straight to them. He disguised them with a flourish of his wand, his arm snaking around Mary’s waist to pull her closer.
The rain softened into a drizzle.
"Are you alright?" she asked, her thick brows knitting with concern.
Mary MacDonald was a very pretty girl. Her face was square with delicate cheekbones, a defined chin and lips that were neither too full nor too thin. Her pale skin contrasted with her dark hair and eyes, and her lashes were long and arresting.
Remus Lupin forced a smile that was far more melancholic than joyful. He stroked her cheek tenderly with his thumb, stretching out the silence as he tried to come up with an answer that wouldn’t be negative.
"I’m tired of people asking me that." He dodged the question, shifting his gaze to anywhere that wasn’t her lovely face.
Mary pressed her lips together, not taking her eyes off him. She wrapped her arms around him, trying to offer whatever comfort she could. But… she knew Remus. She knew how closed-off he was about his personal matters and…
He was strange. Affectionate, loving, he made an effort to be with her before the tragedy of his mother’s death, but Mary had the impression that Remus never truly wanted to be by her side.
He didn’t seem to want to be anywhere, really. Quiet and observant, Remus Lupin looked as though he’d been born to watch the world around him, but never to take part in it.
There was a crackle from the undergrowth. Remus poked his head out from beneath the cloak. A hunched man, dressed in loose, torn clothes, with a filthy handkerchief hanging around his neck, emerged from the vegetation. Mundungus Fletcher scratched at his tangled ginger hair and grinned with yellowed teeth.
Mary tugged the Invisibility Cloak closer, glancing around suspiciously.
"There you are…" His voice was slurred. "You got the money?"
Remus pulled a pouch stuffed with Galleons from the inner pocket of his coat. Mundungus weighed it in his grimy hands, riffling through a few coins. He gave a satisfied little smile. In exchange, he pulled a dirty bundle from inside his overcoat and handed it to Remus.
"Careful with that, lad. An artefact like this… shouldn’t be in such young hands." His brown eyes narrowed with malice. "Or in anyone’s hands, if you ask me."
Remus opened his palm and unwrapped the cloth. The ring dropped and spun against his skin, icy cold. A simple golden band adorned with a blue stone at its centre.
"Is it cursed?" Mary asked with a casualness that made Remus frown.
"Mm-hm. Supremacist curse. Burns and fuses itself to the hand of Muggle-borns. Back in Grindelwald’s time, it was a way to identify them… only comes off if you cut the hand clean off." He scratched his nose and flicked a bogey into the tall grass. "That’s everything. Now, if you’ll excuse me…"
Mundungus disappeared back into the undergrowth and was gone.
Remus took a deep breath, his attention fixed on the jewellery in his hand. Droplets of rain splattered against it, the ominous gleam revealing its malignant aura the longer he held the ring. Mary took out a small box, and Remus dropped it inside, not daring to touch it again.
They looked at each other.
"Will you go out with me?" he asked, swallowing hard.
Mary blinked. She was about to laugh, but the smile faded on her lips, leaving only hesitation laced with vulnerability.
"Are you asking me out with a cursed ring?"
Remus glanced at the box in her hands and let out an awkward laugh.
It was always like this with him. He never seemed comfortable enough in her presence.
Mary handed him the cursed object and looked down at her own shoes, wet and caked with mud. Then back at Remus.
"I don’t think I thought this through very well…" he murmured, brushing the scar on his chin.
"I don’t know if… if I…" Mary faltered, tucking her dark hair behind her ear. "I don’t know."
Sadness touched Remus’s lips. But ever the gentleman, ever understanding, he nodded and caressed Mary’s cheek with his knuckles.
"Can we try?" he pressed. His brown eyes reflected the rain and his own hesitant image.
"I just… want to be entirely part of your life, Remus. Not… not just half of it."
"I know. And I don’t want to run from that anymore." He confessed, his expression wavering between weariness and relief.
Mary sucked in her lower lip and nodded.
"We can." The answer came wrapped in doubt, but laced with hope.
"I’m a werewolf." He revealed, jaw tightening. "That’s why… that’s why…"
"I know." Mary cut in, folding her arms. "I found out last year. When you… when you broke up with me."
The rain grew heavier. Remus smiled. A genuine smile. The first since Hope had died. Mary kissed him. The world, so quietly unhinged in recent weeks, seemed to realign itself. For a few seconds, everything made sense:
The sound of water running over leaves.
The scent of wet grass.
Mary’s warm body against his.
And the wolf inside him screamed. Howled. Thrashed in his core, but Remus ignored it. It wasn’t who he wanted to be. Even so, he wouldn’t give Moony what he wanted.
After all, Article Four of the Marauders’ code was clear: never nick a mate’s girl.
.
.
.
"Who do you reckon torched the Gaunts?" Jim Avery asked, taking a long drag from the joint. He stretched out his arm and offered it to Johnnie Mulciber, who caught it between his middle and ring fingers and brought it to his lips.
They were in Jim’s dormitory. As seventh-years, they had the privilege of a private room. It wasn’t unusual for them to be in each other’s rooms; despite the rumours about the two of them doing all sorts of unconventional things in there, nothing had ever happened beyond swapping girls or wanking each other.
Nothing more than that.
They were just friends.
Johnnie blew the smoke upwards, watching it dissolve in a slow spiral, lashes half-lowered. His mouth was dry. Very dry. His hand fumbled across the rug, but he’d forgotten to bring his water flask.
Fuck.
Sitting on the floor with his back against Jim’s bed, he lifted his arm and handed the joint back to his friend, whose elbows were propped on the mattress and whose body lay sprawled across the covers.
"I don’t know… but I’m certain Rosier does." John blinked slowly, eyes fixed on the lit fireplace, whose flames seemed to stretch lazily. "And if Evan knows, Barty knows too."
"Of course he does. Barty’s his lapdog." Jim puffed out smoke, keeping the joint between his lips. "My money’s on the Lestranges."
"Well… Bellatrix is certainly mad enough to pull something like that." Johnnie scratched at his shaven crown. The motion seemed to linger longer than it should have. "But it wasn’t them. My dad spoke to Hector’s father… said it was part of an initiation."
"Initiation?!" Jim frowned, taking the joint from his mouth. "Of who?"
"Must’ve been the Slavic lot." Johnnie reasoned. "Those Durmstrang pricks are all unhinged."
"Can’t wait for them to flatten the Hogwarts team in the Quidditch match…" Jim laughed lightly. Johnnie joined in. "Hope Rustov smacks a Bludger straight into Gaunt’s head…"
"And Black’s bollocks." Mulciber added, nicking the joint from his friend.
Their laughter ebbed away. The light in the room howled between them, shadows on the walls swaying back and forth.
"What if it was Rosier?" Johnnie ventured after a long pause. "That’s why he’s so high up among the Death Eaters. Because it was him!"
"Rosier’s been a Death Eater since last year." Jim dismissed the idea with a shake of his head. "Barty… Brandon?!"
"Amanda Wilkes has more balls than Brandon." Johnnie turned to face his friend, dark eyes gleaming with the firelight. "I’d bet on Barty. He’s cracked. If Rosier told him to eat shit, he would."
"That’s his boyfriend, innit." The malice in Jim’s tone made him laugh. "How did those two little fairies manage to earn the Dark Lord’s favour?!"
As if summoned by the mention of his name, the bedroom doorknob turned and the door creaked open.
Evan Rosier stepped inside.
His usual sardonic expression was stamped across his pale face, as was the contempt in his dark eyes. So dark it was almost impossible to tell iris from pupil.
He leaned against the threshold and folded his arms, brow furrowing.
"Evening, Rosier." Jim smiled lazily, pretending he hadn’t been slagging him off seconds earlier. "Fancy a drag?"
"No. That shit rots your brain." He said, running a hand through his hair. "And you’re going to need it working for what comes next."
Johnnie arched a brow and turned to look at him, lying back against the mattress. It was a bit rich coming from him, considering Rosier was the biggest fairy-dust snorter in the school. Johnnie couldn’t remember a single Quidditch match where Evan had been sober.
"What comes next?"
Rosier approached like a predator, scrutinising them with intensity. He tipped his nose up with an arrogance they knew well. His lips, usually curled into mocking, malicious smiles, didn’t move even once.
"Where’s Snape?"
Jim and Johnnie exchanged glances.
"Didn’t you hear? His mum died." It was Mulciber who answered, scratching his chin. "He’s been hiding in some hole since yesterday."
"But what do you want with him?" Jim was still smiling. "After bottling it when it came time to kill that Muggle… the Dark Lord still wants to give him a chance?"
Evan stopped beside the bed, slipping his hands into the pockets of his Slytherin cloak. He let out a long, bored sigh.
"The Dark Lord has a job for you." He said, indifferent. "And not just any halfwit gets an assignment like this."
"For us… or for Snape?" Jim scratched his pointed nose.
"Are you questioning me, Avery?!" Rosier shot him a dark, suspicious look, making him flinch.
"N-no…"
"A mission?" Johnnie drew Evan’s attention away, and Jim silently thanked him for it.
"A demonstration." Rosier corrected. He pulled a box from his pocket, placed it on the mattress and nudged it forward with two fingers. "The world is full of rotten creatures. And you’re going to show that no freak escapes scrutiny."
Jim opened the box. Inside, a golden ring gleamed, adorned with a blue stone.
"And where do you want us to put this?"
Rosier’s lips curved into one of his malicious smiles. Jim and Johnnie smiled too.
"In Mary MacDonald’s things, during Herbology after lunch today." He turned on his heel and walked towards the door. "It’ll be funny watching her cut her own hand off because of the ring…"
"Should we use the Dark Mark?" Johnnie asked, before Rosier crossed the threshold.
Evan looked back at him over his shoulder, his dark eyes lightening under the corridor’s glow. Mulciber blinked several times, just to be sure he was seeing it right, but apparently the drugs had got to his vision, because Rosier’s irises took on a greyish hue.
"No." That was all he said before hurrying off and leaving them alone.
Jim growled in displeasure and rubbed his face with both hands.
"That smug bastard thinks we’re his errand boys."
"We don’t have a choice." Johnnie stood, lethargic. "It’s this or getting fucked up the arse by him or someone above him."
James Stephen Avery took a deep breath and let it out through his mouth, stubbing the joint out in the ashtray on the table beside his bed.
"No… we don’t."
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 90: But she would remember
Chapter Text
CLVIII
Scarlett did not remember ever having run as much as she had that day, casting a spell with her wand in hand at every clock she identified. The hands spun and clicked into the time she wanted. Even the old clock in the corridor just before the entrance to the library, which never kept the right time because it was the favourite target of the fifth-year Ravenclaws’ experimental spells, had now been corrected.
She came upon a breathless Sirius at the entrance to the greenhouses. He smiled, giving her the universal sign that everything was going according to plan: a thumbs-up.
"Are you alright?" She moved closer to him, tucking a rebellious black strand of hair behind his ear.
"Mm." Sirius grunted, pulling her closer, his warm hand splayed over her waist. Even through layers of clothing, Scarlett could feel the heat radiating through the fabric. Sweat glued his fringe to his forehead but his star-bright eyes were alive, shining like liquid silver. "I thought I wouldn’t manage to fix the clock in the Great Hall. Filch nearly caught me red-handed."
Scarlett laughed, panting. She rested her forehead in the curve of his neck.
"Where’s James? And Lily?"
"They must be finishing the dungeon corridor." Sirius supposed, slipping his hand into the inner pocket of his cloak. He pulled out his Two-Way Mirror and murmured. "James."
The image of his best friend wavered and appeared on the polished glass. He pushed his glasses up his nose with his little finger and scratched it with the knuckle of his index finger.
"It worked. All the clocks showing 13:40. The idiots fell for it. They’re heading to the greenhouse." He whispered.
Sirius put the mirror away. Scarlett lifted her eyes to him, wrapping her arms around his waist.
"What if they get suspicious?"
"Oh, they definitely will." He shrugged. The gleam in his eyes refracted into something wicked. "But it’ll be too late."
Scarlett nodded, pressing her lips together. A shiver ran up the base of her spine. Unlike most of the shivers that had plagued her in those days, this one was not fear. It was anticipation. She felt her mouth water and her hands grow damp with sweat. She wiped them on her skirt.
Lily arrived shortly after, cheeks flushed and hair dishevelled. A rare sight for the Gryffindor Head Girl. Scarlett could not remember the last time she had seen her so… untidy.
"Done. The clocks on the Grand Staircase have been adjusted as well. Remus and Mary should be here any second." She brushed the hair out of her face and used a spell that gathered it into a perfect ponytail, ran her hands over the stiff collars of her shirt and tightened her tie. "I can’t believe you lot dragged me into this."
"As if you’re not enjoying yourself, Lils…" Sirius wrapped his index finger around her ponytail, which made her elbow him.
"It’s too late, Lily. You’ve already been contaminated by us…" Scarlett continued the teasing, pulling her into a hug.
Lily smiled, her stiff posture gradually relaxing in her friend’s arms.
"I only agreed because of what they did to you and Mary." She confessed, only for Scarlett.
Sirius heard it, however.
"They’re not going to do that again. To anyone." He declared, resolute.
The castle bell rang out at one o’clock sharp.
.
.
.
Peeves cackled like a psychopath after batting a stinking dung pellet from a third-year Hufflepuff straight into a huge group of first-year Slytherins. A few Ravenclaw boys stood up to defend the girl from the furious mob, but the scuffle was broken up when two desperate louts shoved everyone out of their way except the Slytherins. Those backed off without a single word needing to be said.
Jim Avery and Johnnie Mulciber could barely breathe. Not because they were out of shape, by Salazar—they had spent the entire summer trying to prove themselves to the Dark Lord—but getting kicked off the Quidditch team had made them a bit sedentary and careless with their fitness.
Avery’s layered mullet whipped against his neck with every stride, and Mulciber huffed behind him, his cloak slipping off his shoulders.
"We’re late! How the fuck is it already one forty?!" Jim barked, skidding around the bend of the corridor that led to the Great Hall.
"Because that wanker Rosier dumped this bloody task on us when we’re stoned!" Johnnie shoved him down the stairs, taking advantage of being taller than his mate.
They crossed into the entrance of the greenhouse antechamber and stopped in front of the room, panting as they tried to catch their breath.
"Why’s the greenhouse empty?" Johnnie murmured, peering into number three through the crack in the door.
"Outdoor lesson, maybe?!" Jim pushed the door open with his elbow and spotted a pile of bags on the tables. "Come on, move it, help me find MacDonald’s bag."
He pawed through them one by one, looking for the identifying keychains. As much as he would have loved to slip the cursed ring into Gaunt’s things or Black’s, doing that would’ve been shooting himself in the foot. Any shit that happened to those two was enough to earn them Dumbledore’s side-eye. Besides, they weren’t Muggle-born, and it was far more fun to hurt someone who usually didn’t fight back—like MacDonald.
He found Mary’s, her name written on a thistle-flower keychain.
"Found it!" he announced, lips stretching with malice.
He pulled the little box from his trouser pocket and shoved his fist into the rucksack.
"Wait!" Johnnie warned him, eyes wide as he shot an urgent look at his friend.
Jim’s scream tore through the quiet of the room as he struggled to yank his hand back. The rucksack split open like an attacking animal, the zip turning into sharp teeth that sank mercilessly into his wrist, the inside contracting around his fist, stopping him from opening it and planting the box inside.
"WHAT THE FUCK IS THIS?!" he howled, trying to break free. The bag refused, its straps lashing like tentacles, yanking his wrist about like a dog playing tug-of-war.
Johnnie whipped out his wand and fired a dozen spells at the bag, trying to force it open, but none of them had any effect. Every time magic struck it, it ricocheted across the room in bursts of coloured sparks.
"Oh, brilliant! The bloody rucksack’s got anti-spell runes. It’s a trap, you idiot!" he snapped, trying to restrain the murderous object. "Hold still, for fuck’s sake!"
"AND HOW WAS I SUPPOSED TO KNOW?!" Jim thrashed nonstop as his wrist was viciously chewed on. "GET THIS SHIT OFF ME, MULCIBER!"
The greenhouse door opened and the Herbology students arrived. They were met with the absurd scene unfolding before them: Jim Avery screaming with his hand trapped inside a demonic rucksack. Johnnie desperately trying to help him, eyes bulging, breath coming out in sharp, frantic bursts.
Standing beside Professor Sprout, Mary MacDonald raised an eyebrow.
"But what…?"
The professor shot the two boys a disapproving look.
"Mr Avery, may I ask why you are mutilating other students’ bags?! And… what is that smell of weed? Are you taking drugs at school?"
Jim’s only response was a whimper. The rucksack shook his wrist and blood sprayed all over the nearby workstation.
Mary flicked her wand and the bag snapped back to its normal state, dropping Jim’s wrist as it fell, lifeless, to the floor. He collapsed backwards, clutching his arm and roaring in pain. Professor Sprout immediately knelt to tend to the injury, ordering him to relax his hand.
Jim opened his fist and the little box rolled out between them.
"What is this, Mr Avery?!" the professor asked, not daring to touch the object.
Johnnie and Jim’s eyes widened and they exchanged a thoroughly guilty look.
Avery stammered, trying to grasp for a magical word that might get them out of that humiliating situation, but it was no longer necessary. Professor Sprout pulled back the sleeve of Jim’s robe to stem the bleeding at his wrist. Shocked gasps and murmurs rippled through the crowd of students, all eyes fixed on them.
On Jim Avery’s newly exposed arm was the dark design of a skull with a serpent emerging from its mouth.
The Dark Mark.
Lily, James, Scarlett and Sirius were peering through the side windows of the greenhouse, careful not to blind themselves with the cheerful movement of the little venomous tentacles. Lily did not hide the surprise on her face, bringing a hand to her mouth to stifle an incredulous laugh. James watched her from the corner of his eye, fascinated. Sirius and Scarlett smiled with pure cynicism.
"And would you look at that, the anti-spell runes actually worked?!" Scarlett clicked her tongue, savouring the stunned state the two idiots were in, right there in front of everyone. "Shame you can only pull that off once."
Stepping away from the window, Lily bit her lower lip and shook her head.
"It was a good plan." She admitted. "A very… marauderish plan."
The three of them held back their laughter.
"For Merlin’s balls, Lily, you’re spending far too much time with James. You’re making awful jokes just like him…" There was mischief in Scarlett’s eyes. Mischief and an implication Lily did not like one bit.
James stayed quiet. Thankfully. Lily did not even need to shoot him that furious look that would have silenced his descendants for three generations.
"I am not spending too much time with James!" She drew herself up and clenched her fists, offended.
"Relax, it’s just a joke…" Scarlett shrugged, dismissing the subject as if it meant nothing, even though her tone said otherwise. Then she cast Sirius a look dripping with malice.
He pressed his lips together, holding back a laugh as he remembered the night before, when he had deliberately wandered into the Potions classroom and caused disproportionate panic in James and Lily. He had lost his bet with Scarlett that the two of them would kiss that night, but that was fine.
There would be other chances.
.
.
.
The Great Hall buzzed with conversation, clinking cutlery and whispered gossip beneath the rain of golden light from the floating candles. Scarlett, head bowed, absently stabbed her fork into the lamb pie. Sirius, beside her, drummed his fingers incessantly on the table, his eyes snapping towards the entrance every time the doors opened. James adjusted his glasses every fifteen seconds. Lily toyed with a strand of red hair that had slipped free from her ponytail. Remus and Mary murmured to one another, and Peter… well, Peter chewed as though nothing were happening, though he was visibly puffed up with pride.
Scarlett’s gaze drifted to the Slytherin table, where Jim Avery was nowhere to be seen. Neither was Johnnie Mulciber. Regulus ate with his eyes fixed on his dinner. Barty laughed to himself, though he exchanged occasional looks with Rosier.
Evan stared at the Gryffindor table with the expression of someone on the verge of committing murder.
"Good evening, everyone." Dumbledore’s voice cracked through the noise, splitting it into a deathly silence. All eyes were drawn to him. The headmaster stroked his silvery beard and lifted his chin, trying to get a better view of the four tables. "I believe the events of this afternoon have raised some very reasonable concerns. So, allow me to clarify."
He ran long fingers over his magnificent dark green robes embroidered with moons and stars.
"Two students were caught attempting to plant a Dark artefact among a fellow student’s belongings in the Herbology greenhouses. An ancient, cursed artefact whose sole purpose is to harm."
Agitated whispers slithered across the tables. Scarlett swallowed hard.
"The attempt, fortunately, was thwarted." Dumbledore paused, his gaze sweeping across every student in Hogwarts before settling briefly on the Gryffindor table.
James masked a smile. Lily remained impassive. Sirius stabbed his steak with enthusiasm, wishing it were Jim Avery.
"Messrs Avery and Mulciber have been expelled from Hogwarts, and the Ministry of Magic has opened an inquiry into the incident."
The whispers swelled again.
Dumbledore raised a hand, cutting them off once more.
"We will not tolerate attempts at violence, prejudice, or the use of Dark magic among our students. The war will find no allies here. And I assure you: Hogwarts will not be the place where it begins." He lifted his nose; the half-moon lenses of his spectacles were not enough to filter the indignation blazing in his irises. "That said, I wish you all a peaceful meal and a very good night."
Dumbledore sat back down. The conversations did not resume. There were only looks filled with suspicion, shock or fear. No one moved, not even to pick up their cutlery.
A piece of parchment flew across the Gryffindor table, landing in front of James and Lily. The paper was blank. Slowly, however, words began to form:
“James Potter and Lily Evans, Gryffindor Head Students, are to escort Messrs Black, Lupin and Pettigrew and Misses Gaunt, MacDonald and Malfoy to my office after dinner.”
Dumbledore stared straight at them, his blue irises now stripped of any trace of warmth, filled instead with a bleak coldness.
Lily went pale. James blinked hard, as though trying to make sure of what he was reading. Sirius let out an exasperated sigh, rolling his eyes. He shoved the note aside. Mary froze with her spoon suspended mid-air. Remus looked away from his plate and Peter pulled a face.
"Oh, brilliant." Lily muttered, shooting James a murderous look.
"You’ve got to be taking the piss…" Sirius twirled his goblet of elf-made wine between his fingers. "We set up a perfect trap, Death Eaters fall right into it, and we’re still going to get fucked over for it?!"
"Sirius…" James tried to placate him.
"No, James!" he cut in, grey eyes sharpening into pure steel. "Avery and Mulciber are literally Death Eaters inside the bloody school. And now we’re going to be interrogated for it?!"
"Sirius, shut up!" Scarlett hissed, spearing him with her icy blue gaze. She grabbed his wrist hard. "People are staring!"
Which was true. And it wasn’t just the Gryffindor table.
Lily folded her arms and stared back, chasing their looks away.
"Did you really think there wouldn’t be consequences?" Lily shot back, indignant. "We made a plan behind the staff’s backs, Sirius. Of course there are consequences."
"An excellent plan, by the way." James added, only to be struck once again by Lily’s scorching glare.
"He might just be calling us in to thank us, right?" Peter ventured, between bites of his chocolate-sauce pudding. "Like… a secret congratulations meeting?"
Remus rubbed his eyes with his thumb and forefinger, huffing.
"Or a meeting to decide whether we’re still students."
Scarlett looked away from the group and fixed her gaze on the staff table. She searched for an answer, a clue, a direction… something. Anything. Thanatos did not so much as look at her. He was talking to Professor Sprout, and she could not tell whether it was about what had happened earlier or something utterly mundane.
Her stomach tightened.
When the plates vanished from the tables, no one in the group moved. Scarlett felt like a child who had done something wrong… and she would do it again. She would do it as many times as it took to get rid of those two sons of bitches. And they had gone easy on them.
It should have been much, much worse.
Sirius was the first to stand.
"Come on, then. If we’re getting a bollocking, might as well get it together."
Scarlett gestured for Pandora to come over to the Gryffindor table. She was still wiping the corners of her mouth, but she joined them soon enough. She didn’t look tense, nor nervous like the others.
"Don’t tell me we’ve been found out?!" she asked so calmly that Scarlett was left speechless.
"Let me do the talking. If it comes to it, I’ll take the blame." Sirius slung an arm around Scarlett’s shoulders.
"Oh, piss off, Padfoot…" James ruffled his hair. "We did this together, and we’ll get fucked together."
"I shouldn’t have listened to you lot…" Lily complained, lips tight, glancing around in case anyone else knew about her involvement.
"Bit late to cry now, Lils…" Pandora slipped an arm around her friend’s waist, tugging her along.
Scarlett didn’t know why, but she squeezed Sirius’s hand and smiled.
.
.
.
The gargoyle leapt aside as soon as James gave the password. The group climbed the spiral staircase. The headmaster’s office door was already open.
"Come in." Dumbledore’s voice reached them, flat and heavy.
Scarlett was the first to cross the threshold. The ticking of an ancient clock echoed through the circular walls, perched atop one of the shelves crammed with magical instruments and portraits pretending to sleep. The headmaster’s phoenix watched them from its perch.
Dumbledore was standing. There was no warmth in his expression, nor cruelty. Only that piercing gaze capable of dissolving even the truest of lies.
"You know why you are here."
James opened his mouth, but Dumbledore raised a hand.
"Mr Potter, as much as your instinct may be to confess, allow me to spare you the effort." He clasped his hands behind his back. "I know. I know it was Mr Lupin, along with Miss MacDonald, who acquired the cursed ring."
Remus flushed. Mary bit the inside of her cheek.
"I know the idea to use Polyjuice Potion came from Miss Gaunt, and that she was the one who stole a strand of Evan Rosier’s hair. I know it was Mr Black who used it and, with Miss Malfoy’s help, entered the Slytherin common room and gave orders to Messrs Avery and Mulciber. Mr Pettigrew was responsible for distracting Mr Rosier, who was indisposed in the lavatory the entire afternoon."
Sirius flashed a brazen grin. Scarlett dropped her gaze to the floor. Pandora tilted her head to the side. Peter shrugged.
"And of course, I know that you, Miss Evans, and you, Mr Potter, infiltrated Professor Slughorn’s office and took the potion." His blue eyes hovered over the Head Students. "I do hope you at least put everything back exactly as you found it."
Lily was so pale that Scarlett could not tell whether she was about to faint or, worse, be expelled.
James scratched the back of his neck.
Dumbledore sighed.
"You broke rules. You deceived professors. Manipulated timetables, stole potions and acquired an illegal item." He walked slowly to the window, gazing out at the starry night. "All of this so that they would reveal themselves as Death Eaters and be expelled. The history of Messrs Avery and Mulciber and of Mr Black and Miss Gaunt is a long one… I am surprised that Snape was not the target of this… prank… of yours."
"If you know all of this…" Sirius was the first to speak. "Then… you knew all along it was Avery who broke Scarlett’s arm last year, that they put a snake in her things, that Snape almost killed me—"
"But of course. I also know it was not your brother who broke Avery’s arm, but you yourself." Dumbledore replied, untouched by Sirius’s irascible tone. "I know everything that happens in this school, Mr Black."
Dumbledore’s gaze settled on Scarlett. She swallowed hard. Did he know about the Cruciatus she had cast on Mulciber?
No. He did not. If he did, she would have been expelled.
Wouldn’t she?
"Then why did you never expel Avery and Mulciber?! Even knowing they were Death Eaters?!" Lily spoke up, blinking in bewilderment. "That they cursed Mary in fifth year!"
Dumbledore remained still, his profile outlined against the stained glass of the enormous window. When he turned back to face them, the stars outside speckled his eyes.
"They were not Death Eaters at the time. I attempted to expel them last year, but their parents… held considerable power within the Ministry. Such an inquiry would never have been opened. No one believed Hogwarts students could be recruited by Voldemort back then." He spoke slowly. "But now, with evidence, witnesses, a cursed object and the Dark Mark on Mr Avery’s arm seen by several students… there is no longer any way to ignore it."
Scarlett saw Sirius swallow, his Adam’s apple bobbing in his throat.
"Your actions were reckless, dangerous… and admirable." Dumbledore smiled faintly. "The courage, cunning, loyalty and intelligence with which you acted… you accomplished in one afternoon what I could not in two years."
"That doesn’t make what happened to us fair." Scarlett murmured, lifting her eyes to the headmaster.
"No." He stroked his beard. "But justice and opportunity rarely walk hand in hand."
Sirius drew a deep breath, pulling Scarlett closer in an instinctive gesture.
"So you’re going to punish us?"
Dumbledore looked at him through his half-moon spectacles.
"All of you broke rules that, under normal circumstances, would warrant detention. Or expulsion." He paused. "But these are not normal circumstances."
The office door opened. Thanatos Gaunt stepped inside, caramel-coloured eyes sweeping over everyone present as he walked in with a parchment in hand, stopping in front of Scarlett.
"Excuse me." Dumbledore turned to the others. "We need to speak with Miss Gaunt in private. Just her."
The exchange of looks was inevitable.
"Why?" Sirius protested, stunned. His arm was still wrapped around his girlfriend’s waist. "If this is about the plan, everyone took part. If it’s about the Polyjuice, it was her idea, but—"
"It is not about the plan." Dumbledore cut him off with a politeness that barely masked bluntness. "You are dismissed."
"What do you mean, dismissed?! And what do you want with her?" Sirius pressed on, pulling her closer and closer in a protective reflex.
Scarlett lifted her face. Her eyes locked onto his. The blue was as intense as ever, but there was a darkness in his gaze she did not like at all. She placed her hands flat against his chest and forced a smile.
"It’s fine." She whispered. "Go. I’ll meet you in the Undercroft…"
Sirius hesitated. His hand still gripping Scarlett’s waist, fingers tangled in the Slytherin cloak. He clenched his jaw and shifted his gaze to Thanatos, his irises burning with suspicion.
"Sirius…" Scarlett urged, drawing his attention back to her. "It’s fine. Really."
He did not know why, but he let her go slowly. Perhaps it was because the shadows in his gaze dissolved in the reflection of himself in her dark pupils, or because of the warmth that touched her smile. Something else filled Scarlett’s features, something volatile and melancholic that he could not quite read.
"Come on, Padfoot." James tugged him by the shoulder.
They left one by one, confused and shaken. Sirius and Pandora were the last to cross the threshold, staring at Scarlett until she disappeared as the door closed.
.
.
.
As soon as Scarlett opened the clock to the Undercroft, she was greeted by chaos. She descended the staircase to the sound of a cacophonous, completely off-beat symphony of crashing drums, a possessed guitar and a bass that only played the same chord over and over.
"Weeee aaare the chaaampiooons… my frieeeeends…" Remus’s voice came out far too shrill through the microphone.
Scarlett stopped at the foot of the stairs, brow furrowed and arms crossed. All the gallery lights were on, bathing the musicians in a warm yellow-orange incandescent glow. James was standing atop an amplifier, shirt open and tie tied around his head. With every solo where he played literally any note at all, he leaned into the microphone and let out an off-key YEAH.
Peter, sprawled on the floor, drummed the air with Sirius’s spare drumsticks. And speaking of him, her boyfriend was shirtless, hunched over the drum kit, hammering the snare and cymbals with his eyes closed, pretending he knew exactly what he was playing.
Remus sang with his eyes half-shut, the only one who actually knew how to play anything there, but he sounded like a scratched record repeating the same arpeggio. He sang well, but the performance would have been far better if it were not completely out of time and out of tune.
"Seriously?" Scarlett muttered to herself. She could have shouted the question, but she was certain they would not hear her.
Sirius lifted his head and spotted her. His eyes widened, he dropped the drumsticks, tripped over the bass drum, nearly knocked one of the cymbal stands onto Peter and staggered towards her with his arms wide open and a radiant smile. His hair was plastered to his cheeks and sweaty neck.
"The baddest woman in Hogwarts…" he sang, wrapping her in an embrace and throwing all his body weight onto her. "My favourite troublemaker…"
Scarlett laughed. The smell of Firewhisky said it all. She wrapped her arms around his waist and pulled a face as Sirius scattered a cascade of kisses over her neck, her cheeks, her lips.
"Sirius…" she grumbled, but he did not care.
"Did you see? DID YOU SEE?" Sirius cupped her cheeks in his palms and pressed his damp forehead against hers, forcing her to look at him. "We ruined those wankers, Scar. They got expelled. Hogwarts is ours! WE ARE THE FUCKING MINISTRY!"
Scarlett really wanted to be annoyed, but it was difficult when Sirius looked so adorable with flushed cheeks and eyes fogged by drink. He buried his face in her neck, dragging his stubble across her sensitive skin, making her squirm.
"Ow, Sirius, not like that!"
"Exactly like that…" he purred, licking the curve of her neck.
Scarlett let out a little yelp.
"What the fuck is this?!" James shouted into the microphone, his voice higher than usual, pointing at them. "No snogging in here!"
"Prongs… you’re the one half naked here!" Sirius shot back, pointing at him.
"ONLY FROM THE WAIST UP!" James retorted, flipping Sirius off. He lost his balance atop the amplifier and flung himself backwards onto the sofa as he yelled, "WOOOOO!"
"No time for loooosers…" Peter sang, rolling onto his back on the rug beside the sofa.
"’CAUSE WE ARE THE CHAMPIONS…" James continued.
"OF THE WOOOOORLD!" Remus finished, slapping random notes on the bass.
"Did you talk to old Dumblez? Was he gobsmacked by the cunn… cunnin… cunni… cunni-ng of the Marauders?!" Sirius slurred, lips loose with his intoxicated grin.
"You do realise we nearly got expelled, don’t you?!" Scarlett sighed, catching Sirius before he tripped over James’s guitar cable.
"Ahhh, but he hasn’t got the nerve!" Sirius wagged his index finger. "Because he saw it, Scar… he saw that we’re bloody brilliant. If we can do this with a prank… imagine when we get into this war for real…"
"Get into this war for real?" Scarlett let her gaze pass over each of them before settling it back on Sirius.
"Order of the Phoenix! Order of the Phoenix! Order of the Phoenix!" Remus started chanting, the other three joining in.
"What about it?" Scarlett did not hide the irritation in her voice. "Why are you all pissed?!"
"We’re going to join it… and finish off every Death Eater… every single one!" Sirius’s eyes widened as if he were saying something terribly important.
"Do you need a reason to drink?" Peter said, sitting up and dropping the drumsticks noisily onto the floor.
"We’re celebrating, Scar… stop being such a killjoy…" James put his hands over his face, still sprawled on the sofa. "Why don’t you celebrate with us for once?"
"I’d celebrate if they were dead, not expelled." She shot back, wrinkling her nose. "What’s the point of them being expelled if they’re still going to go out there and kill people?!"
Scarlett’s bad mood seeped into the light atmosphere and weighed it down like lead. The smiles vanished, replaced by a bitter taste in everyone’s mouth. She took a step back to get away from Sirius, but he clung to her again, nearly knocking her over.
"You’re not running away from me, Scarlett Gaunt." he said, voice and body sticky. "Now you’re mine. Only mine. Nobody else’s."
"Sirius…" She threw her head back and turned her face away. "If you vomit on me, I’ll vomit on you."
"Would you still marry me if I vomited on you? Because I’d marry you if you vomited on me…"
"My boy Padfoot’s feeling very bold…" Remus laughed, sitting back on his stool, hugging the bass.
Scarlett pressed her lips together to try to stop the smile, but it appeared against her will. And against her will, she let Sirius carry her off to the bedroom, the weight of his body pushing hers until they both tumbled onto the bed.
Sirius struggled out of his trousers and tossed them onto the floor. He turned back to Scarlett with that mischievous smile edged with sweetness and slowly pulled her into his arms.
"Do you know what I thought about all day?" he murmured, the words slipping into her hair.
Scarlett lay against his chest and rested her chin on his collarbone, looking up at him.
"What?" she whispered, feeling the air move in and out of his chest beneath her.
"I want you forever." Sirius confessed, the tips of his fingers tracing the outline of her face. The silver in his eyes shimmered with vulnerability. "Not just today. Not just this year. Not just at Hogwarts. I want all of it. You waking up next to me every day. You, angry with me and hitting me. You looking at me like that every time I come out of the shower. You quiet and introspective. I want every version."
Scarlett blinked, feeling her face heat up at the sudden confession.
"Sirius…"
"Promise me." He cut her off, brows drawing together. His expression turned serious. "Promise you’ll stay with me forever."
"I promise." The answer slipped from her lips without effort. Without hesitation or reluctance.
Scarlett knew Sirius was her beginning, middle and end.
He smiled, satisfied. His hand travelled along her jaw, then her neck, her shoulders, slipped between her breasts and rested on her stomach, pressed against his abdomen.
"I want to have a family with you. A future… just the two of us. I want to make you happy every day. Marry me?"
Scarlett laughed, incredulous and flustered. She wanted to say yes, but she knew he would not even remember having asked.
"Aren’t you forgetting something, love?" she teased, trying to hold back her laughter as she raised her left hand and wiggled her ring finger.
"Forgetting?" Sirius frowned before lifting his brows as he realised what she meant. "The ring? Who said you need a ring to ask someone to marry you?!"
"Then no. I’m not marrying you." Scarlett rolled her eyes.
"You’ll only marry me if I give you a ring?" He placed a hand over his chest, feigning offence. "You’re terribly materialistic, Scarlett."
"Sirius… you’re drunk."
"So what? Everything I said is true."
Scarlett simply shook her head and lay back down on Sirius’s chest, listening to the frantic gallop of his heart. She wrapped herself in the safety of his warmth, curling into his arms as he pulled her tighter against him, tracing a lazy caress along the base of her spine.
"You didn’t ask me how the conversation with Dumbledore went." she whispered, listening to the quiet crackle of the fireplace.
"How did the conversation with Dumbledore go?" Sirius gave a half-smile, eyes almost closed.
Scarlett took a deep breath. She had prepared for this conversation the entire way from Dumbledore’s office to the Undercroft, but she had not anticipated the knot in her stomach, the sweat on her palms, nor the weight that settled in her chest.
"I need to tell you something." she murmured, with effort. "Something Nate asked me to do. And that I wasn’t allowed to tell anyone… not even you. But… we promised not to keep secrets and… I know I should have told you sooner, but…"
Sirius merely lowered his gaze to her, blinking and squinting slightly in an attempt to focus on her.
"What is it?"
"There is an artefact hidden in Hogwarts. Ancient, made by my ancestor, the same one who made the multi-portkey. It can convert ordinary magic into ancestral magic." She licked her lips. "I have to find it. I… I dove into the Black Lake that day because of this. I was looking for the first clue. Now I have to unravel the next part and… I wanted your help. I wanted us to do this together and…"
Scarlett faltered. A few unintelligible words stumbled out, but she did not know what else to say. Sirius’s silence made her heart lurch. Fear ran through her veins and tightened her muscles. She lifted her head and looked at him.
"Sirius?" she called softly, touching his feverish cheek.
The chest beneath her rose and fell slowly. He had fallen asleep.
Scarlett kept her eyes on him. Something squeezed painfully around her heart. It was not exactly anger, but it was not resentment either. It was more… disappointment. Part of her knew he was tired and drunk, but another part of her needed him to have heard.
This mattered to her. And what mattered to her should matter to him.
Shouldn’t it?
Remus and James had — thank Merlin — stopped playing.
The wind made the chains of the ceiling chandeliers chime faintly and howled through the stone walls. The fireplace went out.
Even with the heater on and Sirius’s body beneath hers, Scarlett shivered with cold. She swallowed hard and turned her face upward, but did not move from atop him. She stared at the wooden canopy above the bed, watching the carved arabesques spiralling in circular patterns.
She scratched the Ouroboros. A tear slid down her cheek.
It was the first time she had tried to share a piece of herself with Sirius… and she had been left alone with it in her hands. It was so natural to trade fears and secrets with him while they lay together, vulnerable, that not being able to do it now…
It hurt. She did not want it to hurt. It was not his fault… but it hurt all the same. She did not feel alone, not with him there… but she did not feel held. Not in the way she wanted, at least.
She wiped her face with the backs of her hands.
It was not as though he would remember everything he had said to her in the morning, anyway.
But she would remember.
Scarlett would.
.
.
.
Scarlett was sitting on the kitchen counter, her fist clenched around a glass of lemon water that she forced down her throat, imagining it was a martini. Or a shot of vodka. Or whisky.
Her mouth watered uncontrollably.
Penny was washing the dishes by hand, which was rare for her. James and Lily were eating chocolate, perched on the counter as if no one else were there. Regulus… well, she had no idea where he was and did not particularly care.
The phone rang. Scarlett slid off the counter, glass in hand, and walked over to the sideboard in the sitting room.
"Hello?"
"Staaaaar!" Mike’s mocking voice came through the line, stabbing straight into her eardrum. "You alive?"
"I’ve been better. I’ve also been worse." Scarlett tried to joke, but it fell flat. She let out an awkward laugh. "Who gave you my number?"
"Doesn’t matter." He laughed derisively, making her roll her eyes so hard she swore she saw her own brain. "Poker game tomorrow night at my place. I want you at the table."
Scarlett sighed and took a sip of water.
"Mike… I barely know how to play poker."
"Details, details." She heard the click of a lighter and a long drag. "No one there knows how to play. We just pretend while we bluff."
Scarlett twirled the coiled cord around her fingers, watching Harry and Regulus play on the Super Nintendo.
"I… I’ve stopped drinking. I’m in rehab." She admitted, trying to pour every ounce of courage she had into the sentence, which was not much.
"Relax, Star, we’ll bring other substances." Mike laughed. "So what’s the next excuse?"
She bit her lower lip, uneasy.
"I don’t know… I don’t know if it’s going to happen, Mike. I need… I need to take this seriously."
"And I’m glad you’re quitting. Really." Mike said, with a rare sincerity. "Sirius has something to do with it, yeah? You were in a bad place when we went on tour and—"
"He has everything to do with it." Scarlett cut him off, smiling. "He’s the one who’s… who’s helping me."
"Well…" Another drag. "You deserve it. You deserve to be happy, Star."
Scarlett was about to take another sip of water, but changed her mind. She squeezed the glass in her palm until her knuckles turned white, ignoring the acrobatic signals from her stomach begging for something stronger than lemon water.
She swallowed hard.
"Thank you, Mike."
"Right, then it’s settled: tomorrow, eight sharp. You remember the address. If you bring booze, I’m telling Sirius."
"I’ll think about it."
"Thinking doesn’t count. Show up!" He used a commanding tone, only to soften it immediately. "See you, Star."
"See you."
She placed the receiver back on the cradle, ending the call, but did not let go. Her breath hitched painfully in her chest as the first tear slipped free, burning over the almost-healed bruise and her cheeks, raw from crying so much.
You deserve to be happy.
Scarlett could not understand how four words so positive could feel so oppressive. She cried soundlessly, head bowed, shoulders trembling ever so slightly. She did not know whether it was some twisted form of gratitude, fear, or the eternal guilt simmering in her bones.
Did she deserve it? Did she really? She thought not. Mike only said that because he did not know her past, because if he did…
Why did she keep insisting on this? Why did she keep insisting on punishing herself?
"The man who has a conscience suffers whilst acknowledging his sin. That is his punishment as well as the prison." Regulus whispered, leaning against the wall beside her.
There he was, staring at the ceiling, a cigarette between his fingers, a book in his other hand, his face utterly placid. Scarlett read the cover, which said: Crime and Punishment.
The fireplace flared with emerald flames and Sirius appeared. Harry and Regulus immediately rushed to greet him, arguing about how Donkey Kong was harder than Mario. He hugged them both and kissed the tops of their heads.
Scarlett wiped her face in a hurry, hissing as the raw skin stung. She clenched her fists and took a deep breath. Sirius approached, his gaze fixed on her. Fragility still clung to her lashes, though the smile that coloured her lips was genuine.
Sirius frowned when he noticed the redness in her eyes. He pulled her into an embrace and held her tightly. Scarlett sank into him. His scent — tobacco, leather, and that unmistakable sweet perfume — scrambled her senses and sublimated her torment.
"Are you alright?" he asked softly, against her ear.
Scarlett closed her burning eyes and buried her face in the collar of his jacket, letting the phone slip from her fingers.
"I’m better now."
He brushed his lips through her hair, his strong arms wrapping around her as if trying to solder every crack back together. The chaos receded, and the fractures in both of them aligned perfectly, like binary stars orbiting the empty space between them, trying to join their broken pieces and stitch them back into their souls with the thread so cruelly woven by fate.
And they did.
They did.
Perhaps she did deserve a piece of happiness after all.
Even if it was just a tiny one. So small and thin it was almost insignificant.
But it was happiness all the same.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 91: Immerse your soul in love
Chapter Text
CLIX
Scarlett stared fixedly at her chicken soup. That disgusting slop Penny had made with what was probably food scraps scraped out of the sink drain had left her on the verge of throwing up. Her gaze slid to Reggie’s delicious carbonara beside her, the pungent smell of bacon making her stomach clench.
She swallowed. She didn’t know if it was reflux or hunger.
"So… how was the exam?" Harry asked, twirling his fork through the pasta. Penny had learned how to make carbonara from a Muggle cookbook that had once belonged to Euphemia.
Sirius finished chewing, wiped his lips and beard with a napkin, and flashed a victorious smile framed by dimples.
"You’re looking at the newest Auror in the Ministry of Magic." He pulled his badge from his trouser pocket and set it down on the table, sliding it towards the boys.
Reggie grabbed it immediately, gaping. Harry craned his neck to admire it as well. Remus said something about him deserving it, but Scarlett wasn’t listening.
She ran a hand across her forehead, feeling sweat trickle down the back of her neck.
"It was pretty easy." Sirius shrugged with condescension and took a sip of his pumpkin juice. "Even though Tonks nearly failed both of us in Stealth and Tracking… she made up for it in Concealment and Disguise, so…"
"Tonks passed?" Scarlett forced the words out, trying to sharpen the sourness in her voice as she propped her face on her arm, elbow on the table.
"Of course she did. She’s my partner. If she hadn’t passed, neither would I." He shot back, completely unfazed by her bad mood.
"Wow." She rolled her eyes insolently, her heart shrinking with every beat. "An Auror who trips over her own feet… I thought the Ministry’s standards were higher."
"Some of my colleagues didn’t like my approval… I reckon I’ll be on the front page of the Prophet tomorrow morning…" Sirius ignored her comment and went back to eating.
Scarlett held her spoon, but her hand was shaking so badly she’d spill the broth before it ever reached her mouth. She dropped it back into the bowl with a sharp clatter and stretched out her arm, lifting her glass of water, just as unsteady in her palm as the spoon had been.
She took a long breath in and let it out. She drew her feet up onto the chair and folded forward, burying her face between her knees, fingers running over her scalp until they closed tightly in her hair.
Someone touched her shoulder. She didn’t need to look to know who it was.
"Are you alright?"
Scarlett didn’t answer. She held her breath and dug her nails into her scalp, trying to rip out the nausea, the jealousy, the exhaustion, and the scream that no longer fit inside her.
"Scar… are you alright?" Sirius asked again, more quietly. Closer to her, too.
Scarlett hunched her shoulders, not lifting her head.
"I’m not hungry…" she murmured, her voice muffled between her legs. "I’m not feeling well…"
It wasn’t a complete lie. Nor a complete truth. Even with Penny’s potions, every time night began to fall it was as if her body knew that was the hour she used to drink, and it became harder and harder not to get drunk on the way her own organism punished her.
"I’m here if you need anything." Sirius held both her wrists, stroking them tenderly, the cold rings sticking to her feverish skin.
Scarlett only nodded.
The conversation carried on around her, distant. She couldn’t process what was being said because her brain kept ordering her salivary glands to work harder and harder, and Scarlett could barely endure that suffocating thirst.
Blood roared in her temples, in her ears, through her arms. So intensely she couldn’t find calm anywhere, especially when Reggie and Harry laughed at something Remus had said.
Innocent laughter. Light. Alive. Far too alive.
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, trying to purge the nausea as she forced all the air out of her lungs through her mouth.
It didn’t work.
"Do you want me to take you to the bedroom?" Sirius’s question seeped into her ears like water. Murky, wavering, shapeless. Scarlett lifted her glassy gaze to him. She wanted to say no. That she was fine, that she had enough strength to eat that disgusting thing Penny had made, that she was cheerful enough to laugh at whatever funny story Remus was telling.
But there was no strength, nor any happiness.
Scarlett would have given anything for a bottle of wine in that moment. Absolutely anything. She would have torn her own fingers off with her teeth if it meant she could get drunk.
She nodded.
Sirius helped her to her feet and they went to the bedroom. His bedroom. Their bedroom. Harry, Reggie and Remus’s voices echoed behind her like hauntings. Scarlett glanced over her shoulder at that other reality before she crossed the doorway and sat on the edge of the bed, her hands trembling and an unbearable cold crawling beneath her skin.
The room was warm. Sirius turned on the air conditioning and took the wand from his trouser pocket. With a flourish, the television on a little wheeled table in the corner of the room rolled itself over to the foot of the bed.
At first Scarlett thought it was the television from the sitting room, but it wasn’t. She hadn’t even noticed it in the corner until that moment. Sirius plugged it in and came closer, pulling off his T-shirt and trousers until he was left only in his boxer briefs, then sat beside her.
He picked up the remote, switched the telly on with a click, and changed channels with a focused expression, incessantly licking his lower lip.
Scarlett simply settled on the bed. Her hands still damp and shaking. She curled in on herself when a shiver ran through her entire body.
Sirius stopped changing channels, the glow of the grainy screen lighting up his starry eyes.
"No, Stan. No schemes. Every time you come up with a ‘maybe we could’, we end up worse than when we started." A woman’s voice came from the television.
Scar lifted her gaze to him, rubbing her injured eye with the back of her hand. Sirius patted his thigh twice and she lay down in his lap.
She grunted.
Sirius frowned and narrowed his eyes.
"What?" He cleared his throat, running his fingertips through the beard on his chin.
A laugh. "It’s true. But we always manage somehow, don’t we? We’re in this together, Hilda." Now it was a man’s voice.
"I didn’t know… you liked soap operas." Scarlett made to get up, but Sirius didn’t allow it. He dropped the remote somewhere, pulled his leg out from under her head, slid down the mattress behind her and wrapped an arm around her, the other bent with his elbow propped on the pillow and his face resting in his palm.
"That’s true, love." A sigh. "I suppose that’s what matters in the end, isn’t it? The two of us, facing the world together." A kettle whistled in the background.
"Don’t you remember I liked soap operas?" He furrowed one of his thick eyebrows. "I thought you would. It’s a very dark secret of mine…" He murmured, stroking her hair. "Prongs and I watched Coronation Street in the summer of ’73 when his grandmother died. All we did was lie on his sofa, eating popcorn and watching this rubbish…"
His lips curved into a pained smile, his hair falling over his cheeks, framing his pale, nostalgic face.
"I found out yesterday it’s still on television…" He shook his head. Scarlett lifted a lock of his black hair and gently tucked it behind his ear. Sirius kissed her fingers. "I watched it with you once as well, a long time ago… and after you were gone… I used to go round to Prongs’s house so we could watch it together… Reggie and Harry came along too. It was Lily’s time to herself…"
"Together. Today and always."
The episode ended with a closing theme and the television hissed, casting a white light speckled with dark particles over Sirius’s face, shadowing his expression. Scarlett turned to face him, resting her head against his heart, listening to it beat hard, letting the feverish warmth of her skin seep into his body.
He buried his nose in her hair and closed his eyes. Scarlett did too. Sirius’s caress drifted down to her back, his fingers tracing that random pattern of circles at the base of her spine, his touch melting the vertiginous sensation blooming in every one of her pores until the sweat on her skin was enough to ease her discomfort.
Scarlett couldn’t remember the last time she’d felt that kind of calm without the help of alcohol. It was latent, numbing, anaesthetising. Far better than getting drunk.
She curled into his arms as though that were the safest place in the world.
Because it was. The burning, overwhelming and atrocious feeling between them still existed, still tried to mend what had happened even though it was impossible. But they would keep trying. They were two stubborn, traumatised and proud people, destroying themselves in the name of love.
That was why she was there, taking refuge in the arms of the man who reduced her fears to ashes and turned her longings into reality.
"I need to tell you something…" she finally said, after so long that she’d thought Sirius had fallen asleep.
But he wasn’t asleep. Of course he wasn’t. His mind was just as disturbed as hers.
Scarlett steadied her breathing before continuing.
"Mike called me today."
Sirius kept his fingers brushing along her spine, not changing the rhythm.
"And…?"
"He invited me to a poker game at his place." She cleared her throat. "It’s tomorrow night."
Sirius lowered his face, looking at her. He parted his lips, then pressed them together.
"Are you sure you’re alright to do that?"
Scarlett lifted her gaze just enough for blue to meet silver. She looked away for a moment, then returned her eyes to Sirius.
"I don’t know."
He nodded slowly. There was no judgement on his face, though at first there was fear stitched along the edges of his gaze.
"And if you relapse?"
"I… I’ll come back." Scarlett tried to answer with as much certainty as she could muster, which wasn’t much. Still, the honesty in her words was enough for Sirius not to shut himself off completely from the idea. She held his gaze. "And I’ll tell you everything… without hiding anything."
She needed to do this. She refused to be a coward. She wasn’t a coward.
Sirius took a deep breath, eyes locked onto hers. The shadows of his expression lines hardened into concern. There was fear there, too.
"Does Mike know you’re in rehab?"
"He does." Scarlett tried to swallow. Failed. Her mouth was dry. "He promised that if I bring any drink, he’ll grass me up to you."
"I don’t know if I like that idea." Sirius looked away. "It’s too soon. Are you alright? Ready to face a night with your band in a place where you used to drink?"
No, she didn’t know. In truth, the chances of her relapsing were far too high.
"I need to try…" she murmured. She closed her eyes when she felt Sirius’s hand rise to her face, stroking the freckles scattered across her nose and cheeks with affection. "I need to know if I can say no even when I’m right in the middle of my temptations and…" She opened her eyes and looked at him. "I need to trust myself. And you need to as well."
Sirius clenched his jaw and tilted his face, resting his forehead against hers.
"Alright." The agreement came with such ease, such lightness and sweetness, that Scarlett was left stunned. "But… if you’re not home by two in the morning, I’m coming after you. I’ll embarrass you thoroughly in front of your friends… and I’ll drag you home and lock you in this bedroom until you quit this shit."
The ghost of a smile surfaced on Scarlett’s lips. A broken, shy smile. Even pressed against Sirius, she felt there was still an abyss between them. Even after telling him everything about her past, it was as if… as if the years they’d spent apart were still capable of destroying the fragile bridge that connected them.
"I won’t. I promise." She sealed her promise with a kiss to his lips.
Sirius showed a half-smile and lay back again as another episode of Coronation Street began.
.
.
.
"Are you sure… you’re alright to play poker?" James asked, draping his ghostly arm around her shoulders. "Being away from Sirius like this, so soon…"
The sway of the car made Scarlett’s head knock against the taxi window, but she didn’t mind. She’d just said goodbye to Sirius, Harry, Reg and Remus (who’d given her an oddly kind smile and an encouraging pat on the shoulder).
Scarlett shifted her eyes to him without moving her head. Lily was sitting beside James in the back seat, but she seemed oblivious to the conversation unfolding between them. Regulus, in the passenger seat, looked at her through the rear-view mirror.
"I can’t expect him to do everything for me, Jamie." She murmured, afraid the driver might hear her, though he seemed far too absorbed in the Michael Jackson song playing on the radio.
"It’s not that, Scar…" James ran a hand through his already messy hair, making it even worse. "When I took care of Sirius… when we took care of Sirius… he had a lot of relapses. A lot. Until Reg showed up and—"
"And you think I’m going to make the same mistakes he did?"
James tilted his head from side to side uncertainly.
"Wizards are more resistant to alcohol than Muggles, you know? Which means it takes a much higher amount than average to affect us… but it doesn’t cancel out the effects on the body. You’re a quarter Muggle, so you’re not as resistant. The Blacks have been pure-blood for centuries… do you remember how much whisky Sirius had to drink to get pissed? Now mix that with drugs… all of it to try to replace you. And it still wasn’t enough." He sniffed out a sad laugh. "Why do you drink?"
Scarlett swallowed hard, her fingers rubbing the Signet on the back of her hand, hidden by a charm, her eyes drifting to her forearm, where the scar of the Dark Mark grew more vivid beneath the concealment.
"Because I hate myself." She smiled too, a smile that could be anything but a sign of happiness.
The crease in James’s forehead softened, as did his hazel irises. He nudged his glasses up his nose with hesitation, though his eyes were filled with a piercing certainty.
"Do you really think punishing yourself helps anyone?" There was that patronising tone in his voice that Scarlett hated. "That running away will erase what you did?!" he hissed, shaking his head. "Scar… you still have a chance to do something with the life you’ve got left. Don’t throw it away!"
Scarlett wanted to look away, but she couldn’t. The translucent face of her friend, with his pointed nose and eyes set ablaze by the amber rays of the setting sun spilling into the car, grew more and more indistinct until it blurred completely.
She wiped her eyes with her knuckles.
"I won’t, Jamie." She forced the words out, even though her voice was barely more than a breath. "Not this time."
The taxi stopped. Scarlett paid and stepped out, her gaze climbing the building until it settled on Mike’s floor. She knew exactly which one it was; she’d been there for three different parties. The first one had even been his birthday.
The balcony was empty at that moment. Scarlett didn’t know how long she stood there watching the clouds and the sky painted with dusk reflected in the mirrored windows. She only knew that when she moved towards the entrance, Lily was leaning against the wall beside it, arms crossed.
"You can do this, Scar." She flashed that radiant smile, her vivid green eyes pulling Scarlett into the garden of her shimmering irises. "We love you."
The tears threatened to return, but Scarlett stifled them as she let the air out through her mouth.
"I love you too." She admitted, staring down at her feet. Despite feeling welcomed and held by Lily’s kindness, there was still a voice at the back of her mind screaming that she didn’t deserve it.
She went into the building. Pressed the button to call the lift. Glanced at the staircase beside it. The lift doors opened, the chime indicating it had stopped on that floor.
Scarlett took the stairs. Regulus followed close behind.
"What you did… wasn’t your fault." He panted, as though climbing all those flights somehow affected him. "Even if you feel like you should’ve done more, Scar…" He stopped by the handrail she was leaning on. Dizziness rippled violently through her body and, although her eyes flicked towards the lift beside them, she kept climbing the steps. "It was kill or be killed. And you chose to live."
Scarlett stopped, ragged breath tearing through her throat. Her sweaty hand braced against the wall covered in checkered wallpaper. Her eyes raked over him with coldness and resentment.
"Is that what you tell yourself…" she asked, lips stiffening, gaze narrowing as if Regulus’s words were dangerous, "when guilt tries to strangle you?"
He didn’t answer. His silence was his confession.
By the time she reached Mike’s flat door, she didn’t know whether the difficulty breathing was caused by the climb or by the anguish snapping at her heels. She closed her eyes and focused on the air filling and leaving her lungs, on the blood in its endless race through her veins, on the sweat beginning to dampen her Black Sabbath T-shirt beneath the spiked vest on her shoulders.
Penny had washed the clothes she’d worn on Harry’s birthday.
There was another sound there too. Music. It came from the flat in front of her, slipping under the door, through the lock, the bass reverberating through the walls.
The neighbours must adore him.
The door opened before she rang the bell.
"I was spying on you through the peephole." Mike greeted her with a smile that already gave away his altered state.
He was wearing a Pearl Jam tour shirt under a mismatched Hawaiian shirt. And sunglasses, even though it was already night.
Scarlett raised a suspicious eyebrow.
"And what did you see?"
"Sober Stargazer, which is new for me." He joked, stepping aside to give her room to come in.
The flat felt smaller than she remembered. Maybe because she’d been very drunk every time she’d been there. Or because it was usually packed with people, unlike the glaring emptiness now.
The music was loud, though not deafening. Some alternative rock she recognised: Oasis, Blur or Radiohead. Danny was on the sofa with a non-alcoholic beer in hand, fiddling with his guitar pedal. Lenny and Stacy were arguing about Kurt Cobain’s death. Scarlett heard her own name in the middle of the conversation and ignored it.
Mike shut the door behind her and followed her like a stalker.
"You didn’t bring any alcohol with you, did you?"
Scarlett took a very deep breath and looked at him, bored.
"No." She opened the fridge without ceremony.
"As you can see, I only bought drinks you like: Irn-Bru, Lucozade, Schweppes, and there’s Sprite too… we can make a decent lime and soda… want me to make one for you?" Mike held the fridge door open with his foot while waiting for her answer.
"Just still water with lemon is fine." She muttered, trying to focus on anything except the danse macabre her stomach was performing at that moment, begging for alcohol.
"Yes, ma’am." He kicked the door shut, grabbed a whisky glass and dropped two ice cubes into it.
The clink of them hitting the glass nipped at her ears and made her whole body bristle. She took a few steps back, staggering, and sat down beside Danny. She shoved her hands under her thigh to stop herself from doing something stupid.
"I completely understand Kurt…" the guitarist dropped the pedal on the floor. "If I were married to Courtney Love, I’d put a bullet in my head too… that woman’s unhinged…"
"Oh, Daniel, for God’s sake…" Stacy crossed her legs. "If we walked past a mental hospital, you’d come out with three nutters under each arm…"
Lenny laughed, clapping a hand over his mouth so he wouldn’t spit out his fizzy drink, his eyes fixed on Scarlett.
"Here. Your water." Mike handed her the glass.
"At least you didn’t stand us up today…" Danny commented, slinging his arm over the back of the sofa behind her.
"I was busy, Daniel." Scarlett snapped, taking a long gulp of her drink, imagining in every possible way that there was burning hidden in that sharp freshness.
"Remembered you’ve got a family, did you?!" He nudged her with his elbow, making her spill some water onto her skirt.
Scarlett breathed in very, very deeply.
She was far too sober to deal with her own band.
Stacy changed the subject, and the light conversation carried on until they decided to move to the gaming table. James, Lily and Regulus wandered around Mike’s flat with awed curiosity: framed, autographed vinyls from famous musicians like Eric Clapton, Rod Stewart and Jeff Beck lined the walls. A massive floor-to-ceiling shelf was crammed with countless other records and, beside it, an intricately carved mahogany cabinet housed a 1940s record player, similar to the ones at Hogwarts.
Hogwarts.
Thinking about Hogwarts was like imagining a house she would never visit again because it no longer existed. Not her Hogwarts, where she’d been such a happy, foolish girl. Where she and Sirius had cultivated their love like a weed and a myriad of wilted flowers in every colour.
Sirius.
Her gaze drifted around the room, looking for him. As if, by some miracle, he might knock on the door and join the game. She sipped her water and drew in a deep breath, trying to loosen the tightness in her chest.
Maybe he was right.
Maybe it was too soon and—
"You all know the rules." Mike said, shuffling with the same skilled rhythm he used to play the drums. He cut the deck into three little piles and brought them together in a random order, riffling the cards as he shuffled once more. He stuck an unlit cigarette between his lips. "But just to recap, I’ll deal two cards to each of you." He paused. "Then come the community cards. Three first, one after, and a final one. Whoever makes the best hand with five cards wins. Or whoever bluffs hard enough."
"So the liar wins?" Lenny grabbed the air-conditioning remote and turned it on, lacing his fingers behind his head as he leaned back in his chair.
"The prize will be announced at the end." Mike shot Scarlett a malicious grin as he dealt the cards.
"Oh, stop being mysterious… just say it already…" Stacy leaned her elbows on the table, narrowing her eyes at the drummer.
"Let’s just say that… whoever wins one out of five… is going to need a pair of sunglasses and a carry-on bag. At the very least."
Mike dealt one card to each player, going from Stacy to Scarlett last, repeating the process until everyone had two.
Scarlett wiped her hands on her skirt. When she lifted them to hold her cards, they were damp again, but they weren’t shaking as much as she’d expected. Progress. The result of the ridiculous number of potions Penny had forced her to drink.
She lifted her cards just enough for only her to see them.
Jack of Hearts. Queen of Hearts.
"Strong start…" James commented, draping himself over the back of her chair and resting his chin there. "Very strong…"
Scarlett wanted to ask whether James knew how to play poker and, if so, how, but she didn’t want to look mad in front of her bandmates. Not more than she already did. She raised her glass to her lips slowly. Neither the water nor the lemon could dilute the congenital strike that had taken over her salivary glands, whose sole demand was alcohol.
Danny snapped his fingers. Lenny poured himself more fizzy drink. Stacy pouted. Mike lit his cigarette.
Scarlett narrowed her eyes and ran a hand over her forehead, wiping away sweat that didn’t yet exist—but would. She knew it would.
The first round was played with symbolic bets, using chips that had no real value.
Mike revealed the first three community cards:
9♥, 10♥, 3♠.
Scarlett scratched her head, her heart racing. She looked at her cards again: Jack and Queen of Hearts. Two of the five cards she needed were already on the table.
"Fuck." Lenny muttered, fiddling with his own cards.
Danny clicked his tongue. Stacy gave a tight smile. Mike tapped ash into the ashtray. Scarlett tried to hide it, but her foot took on a life of its own, her heel bouncing relentlessly against the floor.
"Try to be less obvious." Regulus let out a long, indifferent sigh. "Mike’s hand is still better than yours."
Scarlett rolled her eyes and stared at the slice of lemon squeezed between the ice cubes in her glass. She stuck out her tongue and pulled one of the cubes into her mouth, rolling it endlessly with her tongue until it melted.
"Are we all going to the turn?" Mike shoved more symbolic chips into the middle of the table.
"You’re not, Scarlett. You’re going to lose." Lily teased, flicking her red hair over her shoulder.
"If you fold now, you don’t win the prize?" Lenny asked, rubbing his fingers through his black, gel-spiked hair.
"Yeah. You’re out." Mike turned his head to blow out smoke. Then he spun the deck in his palm and burned a card. He flipped the fourth:
Eight of Hearts.
Scarlett raised her eyebrows. Lenny grunted, weighing his next move. Stacy stayed in. Danny did too. After several long seconds of consideration, Lenny shrugged and pushed his chips in as well. Four pairs of living eyes and three ghostly ones turned to her.
The background music leaned heavily into grunge. It might really have been Radiohead; the singer’s vocal fry sounded just like Thom Yorke’s.
She glanced at her cards again, making sure they hadn’t somehow changed value. She drummed her fingers on the felt of the table.
What were the odds of having an eight, a nine and a ten of the same suit as her Queen and Jack? If Mike’s hand was better, what cards was he holding?
It wasn’t as if she cared. She didn’t want to win the bloody game. She drained the rest of her water, holding the glass with both hands in an attempt to hide how much they were shaking.
"Star, you in?" Mike asked, a calm smile brushing his lips before he blew out cigarette smoke.
"I’m in." She said flatly.
Mike burned another card while the tip of the cigarette hanging from his mouth glowed as he drew on it. He flipped the last card.
Six of Spades.
Scarlett scratched her nose. The back of her hand. The nape of her neck. She looked at her ghosts and then back to her cards. Jack and Queen of Hearts. On the table: 8♥, 9♥, 10♥, 3♠, 6♠.
She could make a Straight Flush in Hearts, which gave her:
8♥, 9♥, 10♥, J♥, Q♥.
A very rare hand, but not unbeatable.
She lifted her gaze to Mike, seated diagonally across from her.
If his hand was better than hers, then she was fucked. He’d have an Ace of Hearts and a King. A Royal Flush. Which was already an absurd hand and the only one capable of beating hers.
"You’re cheating." She muttered, sourly.
"Cheating?!" Mike put a hand to his chest in mock offence, his lips stained with a cynical smile. He drew on his cigarette slowly, savouring his anticipated victory. "Come on. All or nothing, Stargazer."
Regulus exchanged an enigmatic look with James. Lily pressed her lips together, trying to hold back a laugh. Scarlett merely let out an irritated sigh.
Stacy looked at Danny and Lenny before the three of them folded. Which made very little sense, given that they wouldn’t lose anything by going all in, since the chips had no actual value. Scarlett frowned and let her gaze slide over everyone at the table, stopping on Mike.
He now held the cigarette close to his face, smoke rising in serpentine curls beside his blond hair. His dark eyes were opaque enough to conceal his true intent.
The hand was lost, but for some reason her hands pushed the chips forward. Maybe it was the faint thread of hope trying to unspool from her chest, maybe it was because Scarlett wanted to win against all odds. Or maybe she was just stubborn, insisting on something she knew wouldn’t work.
"Moment of truth, ladies and gentlemen." Mike announced, turning over his own cards slowly.
Four of Diamonds. King of Spades.
Scarlett let the air leave her nose until it broke into a confused laugh.
The four was useless. The King, being Spades, killed any chance of a flush. She looked at Regulus, whose stone face was now carved with a proud smile edged with dissimulation. She raised her hand and James slapped it in celebration.
"You’re a terrible liar, Mike." Scarlett muttered, grumpy. She turned over her cards.
"And you’re actually a decent player when you’re not smashed on Chivas Regal or pinot noir." He mocked, snapping his fingers, the grin on his face growing wider.
"What’s the prize?" She ignored his acid remark.
Mike stood and went to the cabinet behind him. He pulled a blue envelope from one of the drawers and tossed it down in front of her with more force than necessary. Scarlett looked from one to the other, a doubtful crease forming on her forehead.
"Your prize, Star. Five days in Brighton. Four people. Presidential suite, facing the sea. At least try to smile when your feet hit the sand, will you?"
.
.
.
Scarlett unlocked her flat and stepped inside. She turned on the light. It wasn’t the way she’d left it. Not that she remembered exactly how she’d left it before the tour; she’d been far too drunk for that. Still, the pleasant scent of cleaning products and the complete absence of dust on every surface betrayed Penny’s regular visits.
Her eyes swept the sitting room, landing on the bags beside the sofa. She picked them up, lining them along her forearm. She counted them. Each one was a present for Sirius, Reggie, Harry, and even Remus.
She smiled to herself as she felt for the envelope in the pocket of her skirt and found it there. Mike was an idiot. Even so, she caught herself smiling on her own for having won that stupid, rigged game and being rewarded with a beach holiday. Not that she couldn’t do it of her own accord—she’d put aside a considerable amount of money after the tour—but she would never take it upon herself to spend the summer by the sea.
That was something Sirius would do, not her.
It was something Sirius had done in the past, in fact. The summer in Brighton. The moment before everything collapsed, the instant when they were riding the crest of the wave, when nothing had yet been blown away by the wind and slipped through their calloused fingers.
Something glinted in her peripheral vision. Her eyes snapped towards it involuntarily.
A bottle of wine.
A forgotten corpse. Translucent, livid, lethal. Her stomach reacted in an instant. Her body followed in a rush. Thirst dried out her mouth, her eyes, the persistent sweat along her spine, even the blood in her veins.
Scarlett shuddered. Her trembling hand stretched slowly towards it. Like Eve reaching for the forbidden fruit, ready to be cast out of Eden and taste the heretical pleasures the serpent whispered into her ears.
She closed her fingers carefully around the cold glass. It was light. So light it was easy to bring it closer, her nostrils flaring as she inhaled the scent of aged grapes threaded with alcohol already turned vinegary.
Her taste buds burned. Her throat tightened into a knot impossible to undo. She parted her lips and tipped the bottle back in one swift motion, but nothing came. It was empty. Still, there was hope in her chest that some residue might have been left behind. A drop. Just one drop, maybe…
Scarlett licked the mouth of the bottle.
The bitter, sour, metallic tang—dry traces of fermented grape and parched alcohol—flooded her mouth with saliva. It tasted like coagulated blood and fruit past its prime. The flavour sent shivers through every pore of her body, coiling an unfounded pleasure that the memories of addiction summoned in her mind.
The weight in her chest, the guilt and the regret, the past and the ghosts. It was astonishing how a bottle could make all of that disappear in long gulps and a few minutes. That one, however, was empty.
But there were others that weren’t.
Scarlett didn’t hear James shouting, Lily calling, or even Regulus’s warning. She didn’t notice their attempts to stop her, nor the sweat blooming across her body like a buried spring, finally rising to the surface and flooding everything that had been submerged.
She flung open every kitchen cupboard and threw everything out. Upwards. Downwards. Sideways. Anywhere, as long as it emptied them, as long as she found something with the shape of a glass bottle. Glasses, plates and ornaments shattered, cutlery clattered, pans screamed.
She tore through the entire flat. The bedroom wardrobe, the sitting-room cabinets, the bathroom cupboard. The fridge and the space on top of it. The case of her keyboards under the sofa. The board with her investigation into the Death Eaters…
Nothing. There was nothing.
"PENNY!" Scarlett screamed, breathless, steadying herself against the fireplace mantel.
The elf appeared with a crack.
"It had better be an emergency, Mistress Black, because it’s already past six and—"
"What did you do…" She could barely organise her own thoughts. "WHAT DID YOU DO WITH MY DRINKS???"
Penny fell silent. She looked around, her already large eyes growing even wider.
"Penny threw it out. All of it. Out." The elf replied insolently, drawing herself up.
"You… you couldn’t have done that! You can’t do that!" Scarlett’s face was crimson, the veins in her neck bulging beneath her skin with the effort of breathing and speaking at the same time. "You… you… you belong to Reggie, for fuck’s sake, not to me!"
The elf folded her little arms in defiance.
"Penny is a free elf. And Penny does what Penny thinks is best in Mistress Black’s house. Especially when Mistress Black is in this state!"
She vanished with a crack as sudden as her arrival.
[Radiohead — Street Spirit (Fade Out)]
Scarlett screamed, smashing her forehead against the wall beside her again and again until it burned and hot blood ran down over her freckles. The tears broke through the dam and poured out uncontrollably as she collapsed onto the floor, on top of the shards of what was left of a porcelain vase. The sharp fragments bit into her knees and her hands as she braced herself on the tiled floor, though they came nowhere near the agony and the frantic turmoil waging war inside her, desperate for relief.
She sat there, curling in on herself, hugging her knees. Her hands, her legs, her torn tights. She stared at her own palms, trying to focus her blurred vision on them, on the cuts where blood flowed. Fresh, metallic, scarlet. Painting her pale skin with its warm, sticky, intense hue. She tried to pull out the shard lodged near her thumb, but her other hand was sliced as well.
She threw herself backwards, slamming her back hard against the wall. She stared up at the ceiling of the flat. The patches of mould in the corners of the plasterwork. The flower-shaped stucco decorating the area around the ceiling light.
"What are you doing?!" Lily demanded, crouching in front of her.
What was she doing?!
Scarlett no longer had any idea.
She squeezed her eyes shut and steadied her breathing. She stood up. Grabbed the bags, ignoring the stinging in her hands and knees. Left the flat. Went down the stairs, colouring a trail of bloody droplets across the grubby carpet of the entrance hall. She flung her weight against the door and burst out of the building.
She found her car parked in its usual spot.
She dumped the bags on the back seat. On the way back, she didn’t look to either side. She didn’t look at the neon signs of off-licences, bars or supermarkets. The Honda NSX growled low beneath her cut fingers, but not even the car’s ferocious roar could dull the bubbling sensation rising in her chest.
She couldn’t even hear the hardcore punk blasting from the cassette player. It was as if her ears were stuffed full of the urgency and desperation flaying every fibre of her being.
She parked the car in the middle of the street. Stumbled up the steps. She didn’t know how she opened the door. Harry and Reg’s cheerful calls went in one ear and out the other. Scarlett crossed the sitting room straight to the corridor and opened the last door: the studio.
She was still clutching the bags. Sniffling, trying to breathe through her mouth, when the image of Sirius appeared—his back to her, standing there, analysing a pile of folders spread across the table.
As if he sensed her presence, he glanced at her over his shoulder.
"Ah, Scar… I was just about to—"
Scarlett dropped everything on the floor and wrapped her arms around him tightly. Her whole body straining to stop her inevitable collapse. And Sirius… Sirius was the only thing still whole enough to hold her. He caught his breath in surprise, then quickly enveloped her in the safety and protection of his tattooed arms.
His white T-shirt was stained by Scarlett. Sirius held her by the shoulders and eased her back just enough to look at her properly, though she didn’t even open her eyes. Her forehead, however, bore a cut and dried blood, with a bruise forming around it. Her cheeks were flushed, her hands trembling and bloodied.
Sirius drew his brows together, gently brushing a stray lock of hair off her cheek and tucking it behind her ear.
"Who did this to you?" he asked, so quietly that Scarlett had to read his lips to understand.
Scarlett swallowed. She didn’t know how, but she managed to swallow the almost solid knot of saliva, shame, courage and tangled effort lodged in her throat. She sagged into Sirius’s arms, the tension driven back by the searing presence of the man who embodied the sun itself, capable of numbing all the anguish and distress eager to consume her.
"Me."
Sirius nodded. He took her into the studio bathroom. Grabbed a wet towel and cleaned her hands, removing the shards of glass with immense care and gentleness, stopping every time Scarlett hissed in pain.
"I… I almost drank." It took a herculean effort to admit it; her swollen eyes could barely see Sirius’s face clearly. The constant tears wouldn’t allow it. "I almost… almost destroyed everything. Almost ruined everything."
"But you didn’t drink." Sirius murmured, whispering a spell to close her cuts.
"But I almost—"
"But you didn’t drink." He cut her off, firm and tender. "You didn’t drink."
Scarlett nodded. Sirius cleaned her knees and healed them, though she could barely stay upright. Her legs were shaking. He straightened and drew a slow breath, pulling her into his arms once more.
She entrenched herself in Sirius, wrecking herself against her man the way Eurydice looked back at Orpheus. Not in the hope of being rescued, but in that infinitesimal instant when their eyes met and she knew she would remain in hell forever. Loving him fiercely… even knowing that love was not enough to save her.
She cried. She cried in her safe harbour without a single judgement or harsh word. Only acceptance and shelter. Other arms and bodies joined the embrace, which made Scarlett curl in on herself, hoping she could disappear there. Disappear into that numbness, into the calm and the affection of the people she loved most in the world.
Disappear in the only place where she still felt whole.
Reggie kissed her hair. Harry rested his face on her shoulder. Sirius laid his chin on the top of her head.
"Everything alright, Mum?" her son whispered, pale fingers running through her platinum hair.
"Now it is." Scarlett sniffed, not opening her eyes. Not moving, not even breathing. "Now it is."
She didn’t want that moment to end. Ever.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 92: I wish that I was bulletproof
Chapter Text
CLX
Scarlett lay on her side in bed, wrapped around Sirius, who had nestled his back against her chest and was, at the moment, fast asleep. With his back to her was Reggie. Harry had dozed off with his face resting on Sirius’s outstretched arm. The four of them had slept together again, after Scarlett had pulled herself together and given them their presents.
Reggie got a skateboard deck signed by the Whitesnake frontman, as well as a Pearl Jam tour T-shirt and hoodie, which everyone else also received. He immediately grabbed a new set of wheels that were in the room and fitted them to his board, skating around the house, which made Remus and Sirius scold him almost in unison.
Harry wore an adorable crease of confusion between his brows when he received an autographed The Cure tape. Scarlett’s justification was that he looked like the singer. He leafed through one of Reggie’s Rolling Stones magazines and his face lit up with a shy smile. Robert Smith’s messy hair really wasn’t all that different from his. He put on the Pearl Jam hoodie and encouraged Reggie to skate, even with Remus shooting him a murderous look and Sirius nudging Scarlett with his elbow to ask whether she wasn’t going to do anything about it.
"No." She replied with a shrug.
She gave Remus a package of chocolates she’d bought in France: a box from Debauve & Gallais, Cacao Barry truffles and assorted Cémoi bars. He received the T-shirt and hoodie and smiled shyly. The brief eye contact was enough to make Scarlett uncomfortable, and she quickly turned her attention to Sirius.
His present was a tube of cigars from a fancy brand, an even more luxurious cutter, a mini travel humidor, and a metal cigarette case engraved with Georgy Porgy where monograms were usually placed.
Sirius’s sweet smile slipped through all her defences and cracked her sadness wide open. He didn’t bombard her with questions when she went to take a shower, nor when he noticed the bruises on her legs and knees.
Unlike her ghosts, Sirius didn’t lecture her about how life should be lived or how Scarlett was wasting it. He simply kept her company while Reggie and Harry talked about their day. Apparently, Reg’s girlfriend, Victoria, had paid a visit, and Remus had caught them in a very compromising situation in the boy’s bedroom, which earned him a punishment and an upcoming conversation about how to use condoms.
Scarlett didn’t remember exactly at what point in the conversation she had fallen asleep. But she closed her eyes as Regulus’s embarrassed laughter wrapped around her, Harry’s wicked chuckle lulled her, and Sirius’s restrained breath carried her onto the boat that took her into the world of dreams.
Now, she was there, watching the three of them with a silly smile on her face. She savoured the moment before the guilt had woken up, though she knew it would. And that certainty killed the smile on her lips, even as her gaze remained fixed on them; drifting over Reggie, then Harry, before diving into Sirius.
With his back to her, Sirius was shirtless, wearing only shorts. His white skin had gained some colour since Azkaban, though its pale, marble-like quality survived every attempt by the sun to bronze it. His hair, so long it was now almost reaching his waist, was spread across the top of his head. His beard had been trimmed close to his face the night before. He moved his mouth and Scarlett watched, fascinated, as his jaw tightened and relaxed.
His long lashes fluttered with his dreams, though his eyeballs didn’t move. His thick, dark eyebrows shifted now and then, and his nose, the beautiful, aristocratic, pointed nose that seemed to be the Black family’s hallmark, flared when she moved, trying to free herself from his arms.
Sirius swallowed and half-opened his eyes, star-bright irises gleaming through his thick lashes. He frowned and wet his lips, smiling soon after. Scarlett kissed his mouth, then his nose, and stroked the rough line of his jaw.
"I’m going to AA now, alright?" She murmured, growing ever more intoxicated by the warm silver of Sirius’s irises, whose glow intensified when he opened his eyes, blinking lazily.
"Now?" Sirius whispered, hoarse. He looked at Harry beside him. "Do you want me to go with you?"
"No. You don’t have to." Scarlett caught herself smiling. Being looked at by Sirius that morning, with affection and tenderness dancing in his pupils, sent the butterflies in her stomach soaring. "I think I need to do this on my own too."
Sirius didn’t take his eyes off her, even as Scarlett lowered her gaze to the tattoo just above his heart. Her slender fingers traced the word Scarius, making his soft skin prickle.
"Alright. Alright." He agreed, even if reluctantly. He swallowed slowly and tangled his fingers in Scarlett’s messy hair. "Penny… Penny told me what happened yesterday. Do you want her to clean your home and… put things back in order?"
"This is my home." Scarlett corrected him, hugging him tightly. "You are my home."
Sirius let out a nasal laugh and tucked a rebellious lock of hair behind her ear, kissing the spot on her neck where the strands had been moments before.
"I know." He brushed his beard there slowly, making her gasp.
"Sirius!" Scarlett scolded him, careful not to raise her voice.
"I know." He repeated, now frustrated, rubbing his latent erection against her abdomen. "I miss fucking you."
"Oh no… no… no… I can’t believe it’s six in the morning and I just heard that…" Regulus grumbled, grabbing a pillow and shoving his head underneath it.
Sirius and Scarlett laughed, waking Harry. The boy rubbed one eye and put on his glasses, which were on the bedside table.
"What time is it?!" He cleared his throat.
"Time to go back to sleep." Sirius ruffled his hair the way he used to do with James. "Sleep, Harry!"
"If you lot stop making noise, I will…" He complained, setting the glasses back on the table.
"Teenagers…" Sirius sighed.
"Teenagers." Scarlett agreed in the same tone. Then she kissed him once more.
Sirius’s warm lips touched hers with a tenderness so sharp it left Scarlett dizzy as she got out of bed. She kissed Harry’s cheek and then Reggie’s before grabbing her clothes and changing in the bathroom. She cast one last glance at them before leaving.
Remus was already awake, dressed in a light grey jacket and a pale blue shirt.
"Morning." He greeted her, sipping a cup of coffee.
"Morning." Scarlett replied, but didn’t look at him.
Penny hummed as she asked what Scarlett wanted. She opted for just black tea and toast, before taking her five potions for the day. She felt great so far, but mornings were always better.
Were they? They should be. The problem was nightfall.
That is, Scarlett used to drink at any hour of the day, but mornings and lunchtime never involved the same brutal amounts as the evening. So she filled her lungs with air, stood up, and left the house in her Honda NSX.
[Radiohead — Bullet Proof… I Wish I Was]
The sun was already up, but its rays still couldn’t compete with the cool morning breeze. Dew shimmered on the neighbours’ lawns around her, dissolving as houses gave way to the mirrored buildings of central London. She stopped at a traffic light, watching pedestrians cross. A father with a pram. A pregnant woman holding her husband’s hand. A teenage couple.
She arrived alone at the rundown two-storey building. Her ghosts were silent that morning. That was good. She needed peace, a kind of peace they weren’t capable of giving her.
No one was. No one but herself.
She heard more stories.
"I spent my whole life trying to save other people. I was a priest, then a teacher. But… I drank so much in the quiet of the nights that no one noticed I needed saving too." An elderly man spoke.
"They used to tell me I was beautiful, intelligent… talented. But I never felt that way. Not until I started drinking…" A young woman with impeccably pinned hair and manicured nails opened up, dabbing her tears with a linen handkerchief.
"I used to drink only when it rained. Then only on holidays. Then just to relax. Then… there wasn’t a single day I didn’t drink anymore." A middle-aged man commented, laughing at his own misery.
Scarlett kept twisting her wedding ring around her finger without stopping. The sweating hadn’t come for her that morning, but the shaking came and went the more she felt the urge to speak, even as shame spoke louder.
"Would you like to talk?" The facilitator asked, looking at her.
She knew the question was directed at her, but Scarlett glanced behind her just to be sure. Then she looked back at the woman. Her hands trembled and her heart sped up all at once.
"Er… yes." The shake reached her vocal cords. She cleared her throat. "My name’s Scar. I’ve been sober for…" She paused, lips parted as she tried to reason it out. How many days had passed since Harry’s birthday?
She had no idea.
She swallowed hard when embarrassment pricked at her heart.
"A little while." She lowered her eyes to her hands, rubbing her thumb hard against the black diamond of her ring. "Yesterday I… almost drank. I hit rock bottom… again." She smiled. A bitter smile. "Even after all the effort. Even knowing it would hurt the people I love." She tilted her head from side to side, nibbling at her bottom lip. "But I didn’t drink."
Another smile. Pallid and stifled this time. Her breathing came out in noisy bursts.
Scarlett had never felt comfortable being the centre of attention. Of course, as a musician, you got used to all eyes being on your band onstage, but this was different. That wasn’t Scarlett. That was Stargazer. It was a character she’d created, a performance, a mirage. Being seen for who she really was by so many people was disconcerting and frightening. Very frightening. Terrifyingly frightening.
She scratched at the Ouroboros.
"Not because I didn’t want to, but because I couldn’t. My… housekeeper… got rid of all the bottles in my house. I was so fucking angry… but… I didn’t drink. At the same time, it feels like not drinking isn’t enough. It feels like you have to forgive yourself for wanting to. And that’s hard as hell. Forgiving yourself… is harder than giving up the bloody alcohol."
She buried her face in her hands, massaging her temples with her fingertips, trying to ignore the trembling in her palms.
"I’m here today because… I need the part of me that wants to live to be bigger than the part that wants to disappear." Her voice broke halfway through the sentence, but it was either that or cry.
She was fed up. She was fed up with crying. So all she did was hold back the tears by stopping her breath and lowering her gaze to her hands again.
"Thank you for sharing, Scar." The facilitator offered her a look of understanding.
Since no one else wanted to speak, the meeting ended with the Serenity Prayer. Scarlett didn’t even open her mouth. She was far too busy staring at an oil stain on the floor of the room, right beside her combat boots. It looked like a black hole trying to swallow her shoes. She rubbed the sole of her foot over it.
Chairs scraped, footsteps echoed, disposable coffee cups were thrown away.
Everyone had already left when she lifted her gaze. James, Lily and Regulus were sitting behind her, but they remained silent.
Someone came back. Scarlett didn’t need to look to know who it was. The man sat down on the chair directly opposite hers, positioning himself facing her. It was the same bloke from the first meeting, wearing his battered denim waistcoat covered in metal band patches, his dark eyes fixed on her, though not in an uncomfortable way. She remembered his name.
"You stayed." Beto smiled. He must have been heading into middle age now.
Scarlett shrugged one shoulder, her gaze drifting around as she searched for the courage to look at him.
"Didn’t manage to run away in time this time." She pressed her lips together, forcing a smile.
"Sometimes… not managing to run away is what saves us." He said lightly.
Is it really? If Scarlett had managed to run away from Grimmauld Place…
"I almost drank. I licked the fucking inside of an empty bottle." She admitted, shaking her head in denial. "Christ, that’s so pathetic…"
Beto smiled too, and there was so much understanding in his eyes that Scarlett recoiled.
"I’ve seen one of your band’s shows." He tapped his fingers against the seat of the chair beside him. "You’re very good, but… if you keep going like this… you won’t have many years of a career left."
Scarlett let out a sharp, insolent huff, but Beto continued.
"Rock bottom has a basement, Stargazer. We think we’ve hit the limit, but then we find out we can dig deeper." He clicked his tongue and rested his elbows on his knees. "What saved me wasn’t strength or family support. It was stopping lying to myself." He stood up, slipping his hands into his pockets. "Are you ready to have someone you don’t need to lie to?"
.
.
.
"What are you thinking about?" James asked, sitting sideways in the passenger seat.
Scarlett didn’t even look at him. The reflection of the city rushed across the blue of her eyes and the black of her pupils. She’d already driven the same route five times, and there she was again, repeating it, trying to decide what she would do once she got home. She bit her bottom lip, drawing in a deep breath.
"Telling Sirius the truth."
"You’ve already told him the truth. Everything you could, at least." Lily countered from the back seat.
"I meant about you lot. I’m going to tell him about you." Scarlett confessed, her fists tightening on the steering wheel.
"Don’t." Regulus murmured, his tone authoritative. "He won’t believe you."
Scarlett parted her lips, a retort poised on the tip of her tongue… but she knew Regulus was right. Even though James disagreed, Lily herself admitted that the chances of Sirius thinking she was mad…
She rubbed her eyes with her knuckles. She was tired. Of lying, of pretending, of acting as if there weren’t three people there, constantly in her head. Leaving her alone only when she was drunk.
Maybe… maybe she really was mad. Maybe they were Azkaban aftereffects… even knowing that wasn’t true. Regulus had appeared to her back at Grimmauld Place, hours after he’d died. If James and Lily had died before she was imprisoned, the same thing would probably have happened. If Sirius died, then he’d join them and—
Her head throbbed. How was she supposed to find her so-called peace if she had three dead people haunting her constantly?
Either way, Red was right. She couldn’t tell Sirius. Which brought her back to what Beto had said. She didn’t want to stop lying to herself, and Sirius could see through her with ease, but… she could never be honest with him.
Not completely.
Which, unfortunately, led her straight back to the fact that she needed to stop lying to herself. It felt good to delude herself, pretending that everything would magically be fine the moment she quit drinking, but the truth was that… it was fucking hard. Being sober was fucking hard, and the frantic feeling that things would only get worse from that moment on made her hands sweat and her eyes search for some kind of relief in a clear bottle.
She parked the car in front of the garage and went inside, the scent of lunch being prepared filling the air. She stared for long seconds at her grand piano, protected by a black cover from the morning sun. Her fingers skimmed the rough surface of the dark fabric, her eyes roaming across the empty living room towards the kitchen.
The smell of roast potatoes with rosemary made Scarlett’s stomach growl. She leaned against the kitchen doorway and folded her arms, finding Sirius, Reg, Harry and Penny inside. Unlike the other days, the house-elf wasn’t in charge of lunch.
No, no, no.
Sirius was wearing a floral apron—rather ridiculous—which sparked fluorescent flashes in the back of Scarlett’s mind. He was massaging an enormous cut of meat, seasoning it straight after.
Harry, beside him, was chopping vegetables on a tray, shooting Sirius irritated looks whenever the meat’s myoglobin invaded his space.
"Sirius… you’re going to contaminate the onions." He grumbled in a grumpy way Scarlett had never seen before.
Reggie was at the hob. A pan bubbled with what was meant to be gravy. On the counter beside it lay three burnt Yorkshire puddings.
"Penny… is this thing supposed to be this colour?" He asked, lifting the ladle out of the sauce.
"This gravy has already turned into slop, my little master." The elf was sitting on the opposite counter, across from the puddings. She snapped her fingers and made the sauce vanish. "Best to start again…"
A muffled laugh escaped Scarlett’s lips. Sirius was the first to notice her. Of course he was. His eyes lifted to her and the smile that lit up his face was so intense it purged his shadows with suffocating light. Harry was next, smiling too, and then Reggie, glancing at her sideways.
"Hey, Mum!" The way his lips stretched was almost identical to Sirius’s, as was the silver that glinted in his eyes. "We’re making lunch for you."
"Oh, yeah?" Scarlett rested her cheek against the wall. "And what are you making?"
"Sunday roast." Sirius replied, placing the meat in a massive dish. "Give it about three hours and it’ll be ready…"
"With the oven turned off? I’d say four and a half… maybe five…" Scarlett nodded towards the newly switched-off appliance, which still had the tray of potatoes inside.
Sirius sighed and rolled his eyes. He rubbed the back of his hand over his forehead.
"Right, then. That’s that. We’re having lunch at the shopping centre. We need to buy things for the trip anyway…" He gave up, lifting his hands and stepping away from the island, leaning his weight against the counter behind him.
"Trip?" Scarlett frowned.
Harry and Reggie exchanged a look.
"Yeah… the trip… to Brighton…" Her son scratched his head with a sauce-stained hand. "That you won… in the poker game…"
"How—"
"Mike called." Sirius cut in, washing his hands. "And Penny found the tickets in the pocket of your skirt before putting it in the wash…"
Scarlett’s gaze drifted to the house-elf, far too busy grumbling about having to clean up the mess made by the three idiots, even after warning them they wouldn’t manage to cook the dish on their own… then back to Sirius.
She didn’t know what to say, so she stayed quiet. Her features softened, even though her heart rate didn’t match the façade of calm. In truth, she felt like she was about to throw up at her own feet.
"I thought you’d be happy, kitten…" Sirius set the apron aside and stepped closer to her. "You look terrified."
"I am." She admitted, her voice barely more than a thread. "I don’t know if I deserve a trip right now."
"I figured that was it." He caught a bleached strand that curled over her nose and tucked it behind her ear. "You always think you never deserve anything." He murmured, just loud enough for her to hear.
"I… I was going to tell you about that, but…" She tried to justify her helplessness, but… Sirius was right, and Scarlett was exhausted. Her features were carved over once more by those irritatingly familiar lines of sadness. Her mouth tasted of bile. "I’m sorry."
"It’s alright, love." Sirius’s eyes didn’t let her hide in that silent, punishing, shadowed place inside herself. "But I don’t think this is about deserving. It might be… about needing. And… I think you need this. All of us do."
"Sirius, I almost—" She looked away, embarrassment forcing its way to the surface. "Yesterday I almost relapsed."
Sirius traced her cheek, his cool, damp fingers brushing the apple of her face in a subtle caress.
"I know. We’re not going to celebrate you being fine… or cured. We’re going because you’re trying. Because… it’ll be good. Having some time just for us and the boys… getting out of here for a bit and… being a family." He swallowed and gave a small shake of his head. "We already are a family…" He corrected himself, pressing a soft kiss to her nose. "And we’re going to take a holiday like one."
Scarlett burrowed into Sirius’s chest, his tattooed arms closing around her. She shut her eyes and pressed her nose into the collar of the black T-shirt he was wearing, surrendering to the sweet scent that made her neurons spark with joy and her synapses flood with oxytocin.
She intoxicated herself on Sirius Black with the same intensity with which she wanted to poison herself with alcohol. His embrace was warm, firm, and comforting. He was strong. Tall. Confident. Scarlett dug her fingers into the fabric of his T-shirt, trying to absorb all those qualities she admired so much. The courage, the bravery, the chivalry.
She wished she’d fallen into Gryffindor instead of Slytherin.
"Ugh, living with you lot is a nightmare." Regulus complained after washing his hands.
"Come here, son." Scarlett whispered, loosening her embrace.
Regulus tilted his head to the side and stared at her in astonishment. A flicker of surprise marked the crease in Scarlett’s brow, but he quickly hurried over and stepped into the hug.
"What?" Scar threaded her fingers through his black, lightly wavy hair, which had already grown past his ears.
"You’ve never called me son before." Reg muttered, his face buried against her shoulder, his warm breath brushing the nape of her neck. "Even Sirius has called me son, but… but you…"
Scarlett shivered, and it wasn’t from withdrawal. She looked at him as she pulled back slightly, under Sirius’s gaze, whose arms were still wrapped around her.
"Do you want me to call you son more often?" She asked, before shame and guilt could cocoon her into that stunned, catatonic state.
Reggie barely nodded in answer. Scarlett saw it anyway. It was written all over the blue of his eyes, in the grey streaks of his irises, in his pleading pupils.
"Alright, son." She kissed his forehead in the way only a mother can kiss her child. "My boy." She smiled, though all she really wanted to do was cry. "I’m sorry, Reggie. I… I…"
"It’s alright, Mum." He wiped away a tear that slipped down his cheek. "Really. It’s alright."
Scarlett nodded, moistening her lips.
"Come here, Harry." She stretched out her other arm, making room for her godson.
The moment Harry was pulled into the embrace with Sirius, Scarlett and Reggie, Penny straightened abruptly and shouted:
"THE PUDDING!!!"
"The pudding…" Sirius echoed, with less than half the urgency the elf displayed. "I know how to deal with this, Penny. Come here." He called.
The elf eyed them with suspicion edging her enormous eyes.
"If Mr Black is thinking that Penny—"
"Stop being difficult and get in the hug already!" Sirius said, exuding his natural pure-blood confidence, cutting off any argument she might have made.
Penny merely huffed and obeyed.
The fourth Yorkshire pudding Reggie made that morning was burnt. The vegetables Harry had chopped were no use at all, having been contaminated by myoglobin, just as he’d warned. Sirius’s roast beef would need far too long to be ready—almost twelve years in Azkaban. The magical solution Scarlett thought she’d find in alcohol—or in Sirius—wasn’t there.
Of course, Sirius could calm her with his presence, but… he wouldn’t always be there with her. And her dependence, comfortable as it was, needed limits. He couldn’t fill the hungry void growing in her chest, nor the simmering anger she felt towards herself.
But he was there. They were there. Together, trying to make years of injustice, loneliness, longing, and fear serve as fuel for a pleasant, colourful, lukewarm future that would bring them happiness.
Because they were a family, and they would be happy together.
.
.
.
Children ran everywhere, crying, teenagers in their respective tribes crowded the ice cream queues, and parents shouted for their kids, screaming like mad in the middle of the throng.
Ah, nothing was quite as chaotic and stressful as the shopping centre in summer.
Sirius scanned the surroundings for anyone he might recognise, but the place was so packed that people barely seemed to notice them. Which was good—he didn’t want to put Scarlett’s safety at risk. His gaze dropped to her at his side, eyes half-lidded as she rubbed them repeatedly. Sweat ran down her cheeks. Her face was pale, emphasising the dark circles beneath her eyes.
He squeezed her hand, their fingers laced together. Scarlett glanced at him from the corner of her eye, that ocean-blue gaze pulling him into her unruly thoughts and visible discomfort.
"Let’s go in this one!" Reggie tugged them towards a retro streetwear shop before Sirius could refuse.
"Weren’t we going to look for beach clothes?!" Harry shoved his glasses up his nose as he rummaged through a rack full of enormous shorts.
"I’m going to get some water. I’ll be right back." Scarlett vanished as she stepped out of the shop.
Sirius sucked in his bottom lip as he followed her with his eyes. Then he simply let the air out of his lungs and set his hands on his hips, watching Reggie carry a pile of clothes towards the fitting rooms. He and Harry waited for him on the sofa in the middle of the shop. Scarlett reappeared with a bottle of water, her face looking paler by the second.
Regulus emerged from the fitting room wearing a pair of neon trousers straight out of the eighties.
"Not bad…" He said, studying himself in the mirror.
"It is bad." Sirius shot back, stretching his arms along the back of the sofa. He pulled Scarlett and Harry closer.
"You look like a highlighter." Harry commented, covering his mouth so he wouldn’t laugh.
Scarlett choked on her water, which came out through her nose. Regulus clutched his chest and gaped at them, outraged.
"I do not look like a—" He looked at himself again in the mirror, raising his eyebrows. Then he turned back to the three of them, lifting his index finger as if about to argue Harry’s point… and gave up, huffing out a breath. He stomped back to the fitting rooms, his footsteps loud against the floor.
"Are you alright?" Sirius asked Scarlett, who was wiping her face with her arm. An embarrassed smile curved her lips.
"I am. I just… I was thirsty." She shrugged, casting a distracted glance at the shop opposite, where a row of mannequins displayed women’s swimwear.
"Do you want to go into the other shop?"
Scarlett turned her gaze back to him. He was swallowed by those blue eyes—intense, searching, capable of turning him inside out. Sirius breathed slowly, a shiver crawling through his stomach. It was intimidating how he felt brought to his knees by the simple act of looking at her. Scarlett wasn’t just the most beautiful woman in the world; holding her in his arms brought him an inexplicable peace.
As if all the hell he’d been through no longer mattered, because he was in the presence of the woman he loved.
"I do." Scarlett rose suddenly, tearing him from the deep calm of her ocean eyes.
Sirius blinked a few times, disoriented.
"Then let’s go." He said, slipping an arm around her shoulders. "Harry, we’ll be in the shop opposite."
The beachwear shop smelled of coconut sun lotion and played instrumental bossa nova over the speakers. Scarlett wandered the aisles slowly, brushing her fingers along the racks heavy with bikinis and swimsuits. Sirius followed at a lazier pace, hands in the pockets of his jeans, eyes fixed on her as if she were the only thing he could see.
And she was.
Sirius watched her stop by one of the displays and examine the swimsuits. Her long lashes followed her gaze over the pieces. The shop lights, tuned to mimic seaside sun, gilded and painted the freckles on her face, softening her sickly pallor. Her chapped lips tightened into a thin line whenever she found a bikini she didn’t like, and her eyes softened as they lingered on a swimsuit that pleased her.
She gathered about five pieces under her arms. She could try them on as long as she kept her knickers on. Sirius stayed outside the fitting rooms, leaning against the wall with his arms crossed. Scarlett was in the first cubicle, so he could see her clothes piling up at her feet through the gap beneath the curtain as she changed.
"How is it?" He asked after a few seconds of silence.
Scarlett opened just a sliver of the curtain, wearing a black swimsuit that fit her body perfectly: the line of her hips, the curve of her breasts, the shape of her thighs. Sirius licked his lips, devouring her with his eyes without the slightest hint of shame.
His attention drifted to her reflection in the mirror, to her rounded arse, then to the deep cut of the back, whose opening laid bare every scar Scarlett carried—the marks he knew so well beneath the palm of his hand.
Sirius swallowed hard. Scarlett’s suffering had been carved into her skin with fire and curse. After her confession, after they’d opened themselves to each other, seeing her like that… made his heart constrict. His insides twisted.
The torture she’d endured would be etched into her skin forever.
And all he had done was blame her. He’d bathed in her torment in search of relief for his own wounds. He’d sought comfort and found regret. Perhaps, if he hadn’t wished her harm, then perhaps… if… if he… if he had…
"Sirius?" The voice of the redeemer of his misery yanked him violently out of his tangled reverie. "Why are you crying?"
Sirius blinked, which only sent more tears down his cheeks and into his beard. He sniffed and quickly wiped his face, a sad smile tearing across his aching lips.
"I just…" His voice wavered. He settled for drawing in a noisy breath and shaking his head. "It’s nothing. I’m… I’m just thinking."
"About what?" Scarlett leaned against the wall beside him, resting her chin on his arm.
Sirius ran a hand through his hair, forming the answer.
"About the conversation we had… about what happened during the war."
Scarlett nodded and lowered her gaze to the floor. It was still a thorny subject, with loose ends they both needed to tie up, but it was also the reason they were there. Together.
Together despite everything.
"Did you like this swimsuit?" Sirius changed the subject, clearing his throat.
Scarlett lifted her gaze to him, then looked at herself in the mirror behind her. Her eyes were veiled in that taciturn layer and were quickly washed over with shame.
A kind of shame Sirius knew all too well.
"No… too open at the back." Scarlett murmured, not hiding the remorse in her voice.
"You could just use a concealment charm, like I do on my legs—"
"No." She repeated, resolute. "It shows too much."
"Scar…" Sirius interrupted, cupping her freckled cheek in the palm of his hand. "You look beautiful in this."
"I don’t feel beautiful." She swallowed hard, her eyes flickering with tears. "I’m… I’m going to try another one." She slipped back into the fitting room and yanked the curtain shut.
Sirius simply drew in another breath, wiping his sweaty hands on his jeans. He understood her. He always had. He knew what it was like to feel ashamed of yourself, even when those scars hadn’t been caused by either of them. Perhaps it was precisely because of that. It was something they hadn’t chosen. They’d had no control. Trauma stamped into flesh and echoed in memory. He found himself stroking his thighs through the denim, memories of the beatings he’d endured bubbling up in his mind, threatening to taint the day.
He didn’t let them.
He wouldn’t let the past stain the present the way it had so many times before.
Scarlett came out of the fitting room wearing a dark blue swimsuit that covered everything. It didn’t leave her shoulders or neck bare, a model clearly aimed at women thirty years older than her.
Sirius followed her with his eyes. The way despondency threaded through her expression, how her gaze was constantly drawn to any glass bottle, the way she scratched at the Ouroboros or twisted the engagement ring he’d given her seventeen years earlier…
The shop assistant drew her into a conversation about the new collection. Sirius slipped into the fitting rooms and felt around for the pieces Scarlett had tried on, lifting the black, low-cut swimsuit with both hands. He looked at her, bleached hair swaying around her face as she awkwardly shook her head at the shop assistant’s attempts to push more options on her.
Sirius came out of the fitting rooms with one hand hidden behind his back.
"I’ll pay." He said, walking towards the till.
Scarlett opened her mouth to argue, but only let the air out through her teeth and handed the hanger of the swimsuit she’d chosen to the assistant.
Sirius didn’t take his eyes off Scarlett—not until she seemed distracted enough browsing costume jewellery on a nearby shelf. He placed the black swimsuit on the counter and pulled his wallet from his pocket with his other hand.
"I thought she was only taking this one…" The assistant commented, giving Sirius a smile that went beyond professional courtesy. "Do you want both in the same bag, or is the other one for… someone else?"
Sirius lifted an eyebrow in disdain. His star-bright eyes hardened into cutting steel.
"No. Both are for my wife." He replied flatly. He tossed the money onto the counter and glanced at Scarlett once more.
There were no further comments from the assistant. Sirius grabbed the bag, wrapped an arm around Scarlett’s waist, and steered her out of the shop. They headed back to where Reg and Harry were.
He beckoned them over with a gesture. They left the clothes behind and the four of them returned to the crowded corridors of the shopping centre. He held Scarlett’s hand, ignoring the mix of sweat in both their palms.
Their next stop was a unisex beachwear shop. Regulus and Harry shot off towards the surf section, Sirius stopped by the wall of Hawaiian shirts, and Scarlett, beside him, picked up a pink button-down with yellow palm prints.
"Do you remember the summer of ’78?" There was pain in her question, even though she was smiling.
Sirius moved slowly, holding the hanger without taking his eyes off Scarlett, studying her expression, drinking in the glimmers of light flickering at the edges of her nostalgic gaze.
"How could I forget?" He caught himself smiling too. "The calm before the storm."
"The holidays before the end of the world…" Scarlett laughed, wiping away a tear that slipped past her lashes. "It feels like it was all a dream. A dream inside a nightmare." Her eyes drifted to the other shirts, but were quickly drawn back to Sirius. "I woke up sixteen years later, but I’m still haunted by the sweet memories and the atrocious ones. We were so… light. So—"
"Childish?" he suggested, hugging the Hawaiian shirt to his chest.
"Yes, but… not in a bad way."
Sirius huffed out a laugh and nodded. His gaze drifted to Harry and Reggie, busy gathering an absurd number of pieces with ridiculous prints: shark T-shirts, floral ones, and a white one with red writing—save the hotties on the front and drown the uglies on the back. The two of them burst out laughing at the discovery.
"I’m afraid the same thing is happening now." Scarlett murmured, lifting another T-shirt on the rail, keeping her eyes on Sirius.
"What do you mean?" His smile softened, but didn’t disappear.
"You know… when you… when you’re afraid of something good happening because you think something bad is going to come straight after?" She nibbled at her bottom lip, forcing herself to breathe slowly.
"Anxiety." Sirius wiped his sweaty hands on his jeans. "It’s normal to feel that when we stop drinking…"
"That’s the thing, Sirius… I’ve never stopped feeling this." Every time that… that something good happens—"
"What was the last good thing that happened to you, Scar?" He cut in, eyes locked onto hers with an intensity that didn’t allow her to run.
"The escape from Azkaban… your innocence… Harry’s birthday… this stupid trip…" She scratched the back of her neck, embarrassed. "And all of that… was because of you. Even with me trying to ruin every single one of those moments." Her blue eyes slid over Sirius and settled on her boots, her right foot tapping restlessly against the floor. Her hands were agitated too, twisting her ring, her thumb pressing into the black diamond. The sting it sent back into her fingertip snapped her to the present. "I love you, Sirius, but…"
The words refused to leave her mouth.
Sirius watched her throat tighten and her teeth clench. His hands came to rest on her tense shoulders, then on her freckled cheeks, forcing her to look at him.
"Then just love me, Scar." He pulled her closer. "No more, no less. No but or however. No conditions or restraints. Just love me."
"I love you." She repeated, firmer now. "I love you, Sirius."
"I love you too, kitten." He pressed a tender kiss to her forehead. "I never stopped loving you."
Scarlett smiled and lifted her face, brushing her chapped lips against his. Sirius slid one hand into her bleached hair, gripping it gently as he sealed their mouths together. He kissed her once, twice, three times, until his confession sank into Scarlett’s scars and made them part of him as well.
"Seriously, are you doing this in public?!" Reggie complained, hands on his hips, his face twisted in disgust.
Scarlett and Sirius looked at him without turning away from each other and shared a smile full of intimacy.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 93: A family that doesn’t need healing
Chapter Text
CLXI
"We are not going to Brighton using the Floo!" Sirius burst into the house, carrying a dozen shopping bags in his arms.
"We can’t go in my car! People are going to get suspicious when they see four people in a sports car that quite obviously only seats two!" Scarlett gave him a scrutinising look.
"Well… there’s another car in the garage." He shrugged, separating Harry’s and Reg’s bags from his and Scarlett’s.
"What other—" She stopped mid-question because she already knew the answer. She wiped the sweat from her forehead and sighed. "How long has it been sitting there?"
Sirius pursed his lips and tilted his head, thinking. The boys’ gazes flicked between the two of them without either saying a word.
"Since seventy-eight…"
"Seriously? And you think it’s going to run tomorrow morning?!" Scarlett frowned and shot him a look dripping with condescension.
Sirius narrowed his eyes. She pressed her lips together. Then he rolled his eyes.
"It just needs a few parts replaced, and the cleaning can be done with magic. Easy as pie." He shrugged. "Besides, it’ll be fun for us to all go in the same car."
"If it works." Scarlett put plenty of emphasis on the first word.
"It’ll work."
"It will, Sirius." She agreed, in a tone that meant the exact opposite.
Sirius huffed. Scarlett was right, but he wasn’t about to admit it.
"Are they arguing or what?" Harry whispered to Reg.
"No idea…" The boy scratched the back of his neck.
"You two, with me. To the garage. Now." Sirius ordered, throwing an arm around each of their shoulders without leaving room for argument. "You too, Moony!" he yelled from the garden door.
Remus just leaned his head out of the kitchen, newspaper in hand.
"What is it this time?" he asked Scarlett, sipping his afternoon tea.
"Sirius thinks he can fix my dad’s car…" Her voice faltered. Thinking about her father stirred an ache in her chest that hadn’t visited her in a long time. She cleared her throat before continuing. "So we can travel tomorrow."
Remus’s smile was so genuine it chased away every shadow that tried to hide in the scars on his face.
"Does he know that car mechanics are different from motorbikes?" The question was asked with irony.
Scarlett allowed herself a smile as she rolled her shoulders.
"You know what he’s like… once he gets something into his head, there’s no shifting him…"
Remus’s lips softened. He nodded slowly, pouring the rest of his tea out of his cup.
"No. There isn’t." Remus took a deep breath and headed for the front door. He stopped on the threshold and glanced at her sideways. The sun filtered through the glass panel of the door and flooded his brown eyes with amber, golden flecks rippling in harmony with his placid expression. "Aren’t you coming?"
"Mm-hm." Scarlett grunted, but she didn’t go. She watched Remus leave the house, the warm rays spilling in curtains of light across the living room and kitchen, illuminating the dust drifting through the air.
She glanced at James and Lily beside her. They were happy, of course they were, but would that happiness last when the frustration of realising they would never be able to interact with their son truly set in? That they could only watch him, but never touch him, shelter him, love him? Then, for some reason, her gaze jumped to Red.
The promises he had made to her faded at the same speed he drowned in that cave.
"Mistress Black?" Penny asked, breaking her train of thought.
"What?" She lowered her gaze to the elf, who was cleaning the sitting room.
"Aren’t you going to the garage?"
Scarlett scratched at the Ouroboros. Twisted the ring. Wiped the sweat from her forehead again.
She went to the garage.
.
.
.
Sirius had pulled the cover back, revealing the Rover P6 beneath it. The navy-coloured bodywork was caked in years of dust, but nothing a spell couldn’t sort out. The problem, however, lay under the bonnet: he and Remus opened it and were met with cobwebs, countless rusted components, and the cloying smell of old oil. The engine was coated in a layer of grime and dry soot.
The electrical cables were brittle and cracked. The timing belt was in tatters and disintegrated with the slightest tug Sirius gave it. The radiator reservoir was empty and split, the carburettor was rusted on the inside, and the battery was swollen.
The fuse box… well, Sirius thought it best not to touch that just yet.
Remus let out a low whistle. Harry and Reggie inspected the state of the engine from a safe distance, half-expecting it to simply explode in their faces.
"Yeah, Sirius… that’s not moving even if a troll pushes it."
Sirius gave a half-smile and tilted his head to the side, as though seeing the situation from a different angle might help him solve it.
"It will move. It’s going to move. Even if I have to stay up all night."
"Try casting an Obliviate on it. Maybe it’ll forget how long it’s been sitting here…" Harry joked, pulling his wand from his pocket.
"Isn’t there some… I don’t know, Vehicular Resurrectum you can use?!" Reggie poked the dried-out wires with the tip of his wand and jumped back as if he’d been shocked.
"There is." Sirius crouched down and grabbed the toolbox. He opened it and handed Reggie a worn combination spanner. "Start loosening the bolts on the front of the radiator mount. Just the front ones." He jerked his chin to indicate them. "The rear ones are holding the block. If you undo those, you’ll give me a nice shower down here."
Reggie raised his eyebrows and took the spanner.
"Radiator mount. Front bolts. Sirius, shower: bad. Right. I think I’ve got it."
While he got to work, Sirius turned to Harry and Remus, whose brown eyes were studying the corroded parts.
"Harry, do you remember the cauldron-cleaning charm they teach in second year at Hogwarts?!"
"Uh… Desox Ferrum?" Harry asked, adjusting his glasses on the bridge of his nose.
"That’s the one." Remus flashed a proud smile, which made Sirius grin as well. "But focus on the Ferrum part. We want to strip the oxidation from the metal without dissolving what’s still usable."
"How do I cast it again?"
"Circular wand movement, like this." He demonstrated with a twist of his wrist. "And say the incantation while focusing only on the part you want to affect. And for Merlin’s balls, do not aim at the battery." He pointed at it.
"And if I accidentally do?"
Sirius gave him a pat on the shoulder.
"You’ll probably kill all of us." He said it with deeply unsettling casualness.
Harry laughed, aimed at one of the corroded carburettor connectors, and tested the spell. Thin smoke rose in spirals, gradually revealing the metallic sheen beneath the rusted crust.
"It worked!" He straightened up, thrilled.
Remus nodded, pleased.
"Good job, Harry. Now just repeat that about a hundred times and we might see the engine running by sunset."
"What do we get if this thing actually turns on again?" Reggie grumbled, muffling the cacophony of bolts clattering onto the floor.
"You get… hmm…" Sirius crouched to rummage through the toolbox. "I don’t know, my eternal respect?"
"No one wants your eternal respect, Sirius." Reg rolled his eyes with a gesture identical to his younger brother’s.
For some reason, Sirius smiled.
"Then let’s negotiate the car’s name. If it starts, you get to choose."
"DeLorean!" Harry blurted out.
"Millennium Falcon!" Remus suggested.
"You don’t count!" Reggie pointed his wand at his uncle. "Actually, have you told Sirius about what you and Ron did in second year, Harry?"
"About Arthur Weasley’s flying car?!" Sirius looked at both godsons. "I already know."
"Hogwarts Express: Tuned Edition." Harry ignored them both.
"Batmobile!" Regulus jabbed a finger at him.
"Nanananana, Sirius!" Harry sang, continuing to pour the spell over the parts without stopping.
Sirius lay back on the wheeled creeper and used a charm to lift the car just enough to slide underneath it. He held his wand in his mouth and tucked the engine manual under his arm.
"I don’t understand a bloody thing…" he complained, taking the wand back into his hand.
"Nanananana, Sirius!" Reg repeated. "The Knight of the Roads!"
"The Rust Exterminator!" Harry carried on.
"The Big Bat of the Garage! Terror of seized bolts!"
Remus let out a genuine laugh. A pair of feet in red flip-flops walked into Sirius’s field of vision, followed by Scarlett’s face and her platinum hair.
"What’s going on?" She was smiling so casually that Sirius felt his heart speed up.
"No idea…"
"You would if you watched Batman with us!" Regulus raised a spanner, making lightsaber noises every time he swung it. "Siriusman! With his faithful squire… Pobin!" He pointed at Harry.
"Pobin?"
"Yeah… Potter plus Robin. Hobin would sound weird. Or Rorry. Robber?" Reg scratched the back of his neck. "I’m the Riddler! And my Uncle Remus is Commissioner Gordon. Or retired Robin."
"Retired Robin?!" Remus laughed, swapping out the old engine wires.
"Alright… and Scar’s Catwoman." Harry just shrugged.
"Batman… who the hell even had comics of that shit?" Sirius asked, trying to read the manual in the dark.
"Wormtail." Scarlett dragged over a wheeled creeper that squeaked like an old wardrobe door and pushed herself in beside Sirius. She pulled her wand from her pocket and cast Lumos.
"Batman is a hero who fights crime using his trauma and weird bat fetishes. Clearly a Slytherin!" Reggie declared, dropping a few more bolts onto the floor.
"Slytherin?! He’s far too much of a gentleman to be a Slytherin…" Harry began to argue.
Sirius was dismantling the front suspension arms with strength and careful precision, freeing pieces seized by rust and time. He bit his lower lip, sweating, his hair tied up in an improvised bun that was already starting to come loose beneath his head. Scarlett watched the way the veins stood out along his forearms, taut under the magical light. His pale face, grey eyes, focused expression…
"You’re beautiful." She murmured softly. It wasn’t as though there was the slightest chance anyone would hear her; Harry and Reggie were far too busy debating which Hogwarts House Bruce Wayne would end up in.
Sirius froze for a moment. His eyes turned to her, the Lumos setting them alight with surprise and elation. The corners of his mouth curved into an indulgent smile.
Scarlett shuddered with the sensation that the world had stopped spinning, that time had frozen around them, and fate had granted them, if only for a few minutes, a moment where nothing else mattered.
She wasn’t lying. Sirius Black was the most beautiful man alive, and Scarlett Gaunt was the woman most hopelessly obsessed with him.
He lifted a grease-smeared finger and gently touched her nose, leaving a dark streak there. Scarlett raised an eyebrow and narrowed her eyes in disbelief.
"You’re beautiful too."
"Idiot…" She laughed, punching his shoulder.
Sirius took advantage of the closeness to sink his fingers into her hair and capture her lips in a slow kiss. Scarlett gasped, and it was the perfect opening for him to slip his tongue into her mouth. She tasted of sin. Of damnation. Their tongues met and waltzed, the wheeled creepers squeaking as Sirius pulled her closer, his fingers travelling along her back, stealing her breath, her soft laugh, her hesitation.
"Are you two going to keep snogging or are you going to help us fix the Batmobile?" Reggie asked suddenly, his face — a mix of Scarlett’s features and Sirius’s — popping up beside the wheel of the car.
They broke apart sharply. Scarlett banged her head on the Rover’s chassis.
"Ow, fuck!" She squeezed her eyes shut, and Sirius caught her face before she could hit it again somewhere else, his fingers brushing over her struck temple.
"Hey, did it hurt?" He asked with such genuine concern that Scarlett opened just one eye, looking at him through dark lashes. He lifted his head and kissed the sore spot, pulling her into a half-embrace. "It’s alright. It’ll heal."
Scarlett sniffed a laugh, even though hot tears burned at her eyes. She didn’t know why they were there. She wasn’t sure whether they were the prelude to joy or to sadness.
Maybe both.
Could it be both?
Sirius’s touch was capable of healing her and hurting her at the same time. Not because he wounded her, but because he reminded her of what she had lost. Of what she could still have. Of the love that still existed in the shadow of loss, of the echoes of happiness they chased in a world destroyed by war.
They pulled apart slowly. They didn’t want to. Scarlett wet her lips and slid out from beneath the car. She sat down on a folded beach chair in the corner of the garage and pressed a hand to the sore spot.
"Want me to get you some ice, Mum?" Reggie came closer, clapping his dust-covered hands together.
"No need, it’s fine, love." Scarlett smiled tenderly, leaning back against the chair.
She watched the four of them work on the car until night fell. The yellow garage light was switched on, but the cupboard beside her cast such a comforting shadow over her that Scarlett hugged herself, drew her legs up, rested her face against her shoulder, and closed her eyes. The laughter and overlapping conversations grew more distant. The exhaustion was still heavy on her because of the withdrawal, its effects still clear in her body.
"Hey, sleepyhead." Sirius whispered in her ear.
She woke with trembling hands, nausea, and a dry mouth. She mumbled something unintelligible but didn’t resist when he lifted her into his arms. Her head fell against his shoulder, her nostrils flaring as she breathed in his scent, threaded with sweat, making her shiver.
"You’re filthy." She murmured, lethargic.
"So are you." Sirius smiled.
The shower was warm and unhurried.
Water streamed over both of them as Scarlett rested her forehead against his chest, her eyes still heavy with sleep, her fingers tracing the tattoos on his skin. Sirius washed his hair, then hers, rubbed the grease stain from her freckled nose, and kissed her.
Scarlett left the bathroom wrapped in a towel. She dried her hair with a charm, got dressed, and went to Reggie’s bedroom door. She knocked twice before going in.
Reggie was packing his suitcase. Or rather, if packing meant throwing all his clothes inside and then pressing down until he could force it shut.
"Did you pack your swim shorts? Sunscreen? Your gala-night outfit?" Reggie nodded at each question. "Walkman? Skateboard? Sunglasses?"
"Packed, Mum." He yawned. It was already midnight. "I’ve been to the beach before with Orfy."
At the mention of his brother, the subtle smile that had been resting on her lips faded.
It was hard to believe Orfy had been alive all this time. It was easier to imagine he was dead. It hurt less that way… to think that… that he had never come back.
"Alright. Good night, love." She whispered, stepping closer and kissing his temple. "Don’t forget we’re getting up early tomorrow."
"Yes, ma’am." There was such sweetness in Reg’s smile she nearly melted on the spot.
He looked so much like his father.
She went to Harry’s room. Unlike Reg, he was actually trying to fold his clothes, and although they were still creased, they didn’t come close to the chaos Reggie had left in his suitcase. James and Lily were watching him so intently they barely noticed her presence.
"Harry, need any help?"
Green eyes flickered behind the round lenses of his glasses. His mouth tilted into a shy smile, and he simply shook his head.
"I think I’ve got everything."
"Is something bothering you?"
"I just… I was just thinking." He took off his glasses to rub at one eye. "Peter Pettigrew ran away, didn’t he?"
Scarlett drew her brows together, gripping the wooden doorframe. Letting that bastard live had resulted in Sirius’s innocence, but just imagining what he might be plotting now…
She clenched her fists.
"He did, but—"
"Do you think the Aurors will manage to catch him?"
She wanted to say yes. To say that even Sirius was focused on it, though he had barely become an Auror and would likely never be assigned something like that. Especially not when he was personally involved.
And well, everything to do with the Ministry of Magic boiled down to politics. They might have granted Sirius all these favours, but if they suspected him…
"Harry… you shouldn’t worry about that." Scarlett gave him her most reassuring smile, which didn’t help much, because Harry kept his lips pressed together and his eyes unsteady.
"Alright… alright." He bit the inside of his cheek.
"Don’t forget your sunglasses…" Scar reminded him, noticing his suitcase was almost completely packed.
"I won’t." Harry said dully.
"Harry… what is it?" she pressed, but that only made him retreat even further.
"Uh… I… I just…" He scratched the back of his neck. "I’m tired."
Scarlett looked at James, then at Lily.
"There’s something wrong." Her friend said, concern clouding the green of her eyes.
Harry is a Horcrux.
She simply nodded, leaned down, and kissed the top of his head.
"Good night, Harry."
Scarlett paused at Remus’s bedroom door. She curled her finger, intending to knock, but gave up. Things were too good for her to ruin them with an argument. Withdrawal aside… she could almost feel better. Or pretend to, at least.
She returned to Sirius’s room. Her gaze lingered on his silhouette in the bathroom doorway, combing his hair. Scarlett lay down on the bed and watched her own reflection in the aviator sunglasses set aside next to a pile of T-shirts. Her lips curved faintly, though she didn’t like what she saw.
There were deep shadows beneath her eyes, her lips were dry and pale. Her skin had the same grey, unhealthy cast Remus got when the full moon drew near.
She sighed. Sirius was right. Maybe she’d even get a tan at the beach.
The thought pulled her into the past, to the time they went to Brighton. The sun was blazing, the sky cloudless, and the sea broke into foam and salt spray. James and Lily were trying to eat a scoop of mint chocolate ice cream before it melted completely. Remus and Mary were beneath the parasol’s shade, he reading while she lay with her head in his lap.
Sirius grabbed Scarlett and slung her over his shoulder. She screamed, her glasses fell into the warm sand, and she was carried straight towards the sea. Marlene was already in the water, diving through the waves with Dorcas.
The water was freezing. Sirius’s laughter was sharp and loud, and he stumbled halfway, dragging her down with him. Scarlett swallowed a mouthful of saltwater before surfacing, spluttering it straight at Sirius. He could stand easily where they were, but Scarlett couldn’t touch the bottom.
"You idiot!" she accused him, even as laughter clung to her face.
"Hey! That’s your future husband you’re talking about!" Sirius straightened as a wave broke against his chest, lifting his chin.
"Exactly!"
When Sirius came out of the bathroom, Scarlett was curled up on the bed, one arm stretched out, his sunglasses caught loosely between her fingers. Her eyes were closed. Her breathing was soft.
With a flourish of his wand, all his belongings floated neatly into the suitcase. Sirius ran a hand through his hair and sat down on the edge of the bed.
He slowly touched his index finger to Scarlett’s fingers, loosened their grip, and slipped his sunglasses free. He set them on the bedside table and extinguished the lights with a non-verbal charm.
Darkness swallowed the room. Only a slanted beam of light cut through it, spilling in diagonally through the window and across the bed, bathing Scarlett’s torso in its leaden hue. Sirius tugged the sheet partly out from beneath her and then covered her.
She didn’t stir. She was sunk into such a deep sleep that her breathing had grown heavy, dense. Sirius kissed her forehead and settled in front of her. He slipped an arm beneath the pillow and watched her sleep. The light outside gradually faded, but it was still enough to highlight the pallor of her features.
Sirius could have watched her sleep forever. So peaceful and relaxed. So unlike the alert, irritated, restless woman she usually was. This new version of Scarlett was still strange to him, all the more so because of the alcoholism. He was used to the melancholy and the mood swings, but her self-flagellating nature when intertwined with alcohol…
She became someone else entirely, a vortex of self-destruction determined to leave nothing intact in her wake. And that frightened him. He had never thought Scarlett would scare him — not like that. She was unpredictable. She had tried to kill herself in two different ways. Directly, by accelerating into a lamppost, and indirectly, by drinking herself to the point of poisoning.
What would be next?
The tentacles of fear stretched across his chest, but Sirius refused to give them space. He purged them by sliding his arm around Scarlett’s waist, resting his hand in the curve shaped perfectly to receive his palm.
Sirius fell into the world of dreams with Scarlett in his arms.
He was pulled into that place. A place he no longer visited with the same regularity as he had in Azkaban.
It was cold. The heavy, clouded autumn sky loomed closer and closer. He was astride Nancy, the motorcycle vibrating beneath his legs, his hands gripping the handlebars tight, his eyes wide and blinking hard every time a tear threatened to fall. His heart didn’t even seem to be beating.
The bike skidded to a halt in front of the ruined house. A half-giant stood in the doorway, holding a baby. Sirius didn’t know how he dismounted, nor how he entered the house. But he did. He crossed the sitting room, ignoring the broken guitar he tripped over. His star-filled eyes locked onto the body at the foot of the stairs.
He began to shake, and it wasn’t from the cold. That crisp autumn wind couldn’t have rattled him like that, couldn’t have made his blood congeal, his breath fade away. No.
It was the effect of seeing the person he loved most in that fucking, cursed world lying dead.
Sirius had no breath left, but for some reason he managed to say his friend’s name. Even though he couldn’t hear him. Sirius couldn’t hear himself either. He had gone deaf. Sounds no longer made sense. Nothing made sense anymore.
With every step he took towards James, his soul was torn further apart. Stretched, split, shattered. His body stiffened more and more. His breathing tightened in his throat.
"Sirius!" Scarlett called out to him.
His tormented gaze couldn’t pull itself away from James. Even though he wanted to look for her, despair cancelled out any possibility of movement on his part — and that included his eyes.
"Scar… Scar… James… James…" he babbled, his vocal cords vibrating even though his ears couldn’t catch his words. His gaze returned to James and he placed a trembling hand over his chest.
"Sirius… Sirius… hey, look at me." Scarlett insisted.
Sirius blinked. James’s pale face was replaced by Scarlett’s blurred, worried expression. Tears pooled in his eyes and his breath lodged in his chest, refusing to come out.
"Sirius… breathe with me. Can you hear me?" Her hands were warm against his cheeks. She spoke so close that Sirius could feel the words sliding through his beard, but he couldn’t reach them.
He opened his mouth, but all that left his lips was a sob. Panic flooded his veins, throwing everything out of rhythm — his heart, his ability to speak, his muscles.
"I’m here. I’m here." Scarlett was crying too. She guided his tattooed hand to her chest, where her heart was beating hard. "Breathe with me. One, two… that’s it, follow me."
Sirius was hyperventilating. His lungs were far too determined to expel every breath the instant it entered, making everything even harder. Scarlett didn’t give up. She lay over him, pressed her chest to his ear, and wrapped him in her arms, trying to shelter him inside her heart.
"You’re not there anymore. It’s over. You’re with me." Scarlett whispered in his ear, eroding the terror eating away at his body. "It was just a nightmare. I’m here now and nothing’s going to happen to you."
The desperate sob climbed up his throat and Sirius didn’t have the strength to stop it. Tears burned his eyes and blurred everything around him — except her. Never her. Scarlett held him tightly, delaying his inevitable collapse.
Sirius replaced agony with belonging, drowning in the comfort of the woman he loved. He clutched Scarlett to him, fingers gripping her clothes desperately, feeling the fabric give. His shoulders spasmed and his throat forced out a raw, painful cry.
"He died…" he managed between sobs. "He died and it was my fault…"
"No, no, no. It wasn’t your fault, my love. It was never your fault." Scarlett murmured in his ear, scattering frantic kisses over his cheek. "It was never your fault."
"I don’t want… I don’t want to sleep again… I don’t… I don’t want to dream…" he babbled, not even sure what he was saying. The intensity of the pain split his heart open and muddled his thoughts. "I don’t want to…"
"It’s alright." She gently dried his tears with the fabric of her blouse. "You don’t have to sleep."
"I just… I just want you." He sniffed, burying his face in her chest.
"I’m here."
"Stay with me."
"I will." Scarlett sealed the promise with a kiss to his hair, her fingers threading through the dark strands, soothing him with gentle strokes. "Tomorrow we’re going to Brighton." She said softly, still hardly believing it herself. "You’ll see the sea, feel the wind. Spend some time just us and the boys… we’ll start again."
Sirius nodded slowly. He was afraid the tears would return if he tried to speak.
"We can’t go back to the past and change what’s already happened… but… we can do it differently this time. Better." Scarlett went on.
He heard her take a deep breath and swallow slowly.
"We have the chance to build our home without anger, without explosions, without shouting or doors slamming. A gentle, welcoming home. I’ll keep you safe, and you’ll be my foundation. No fear, no resentment, no anguish." Scarlett pulled back just enough for her piercing blue eyes to sink into his star-filled ones. "We were trapped for far too long in a place that was ominous and sick, but together… we can build something solid and stable. Heal ourselves… and create a family that doesn’t need healing."
The tears in his eyes now were no longer born of sadness. Hearing that from Scarlett was… it was something he had never known he needed to hear. He didn’t know whether it was a promise that they would stay together and that things would work out. Maybe it was the certainty that they would overcome everything, or that letting go of the past could stop the present from eroding away.
"What do you mean by that?" Sirius asked, not sure he actually wanted to hear the answer.
"Sirius… I love you. I love you so much and… we’ve been through a lot. A fucking lot. And I don’t… I know I’ve been the reason for your unhappiness, that I hurt you in ways that… that I don’t even know how to apologise for. But… I’m willing to try… if you are too."
Sirius held her gaze, intoxicated by the warmth filling Scarlett’s blue eyes, by how the vast, usually chaotic ocean had been tamed into calm and foam. Drawing him in with its gentle tide to a place where he didn’t need to pretend to be Auror Sirius, responsible Sirius, saviour Sirius. No. The water washed away all his coats and personas, leaving only the frightened boy whose only desires were to be loved by the woman who had left and to protect the best friends who had been killed.
"You… you want…" He stammered, stunned. "To pick up… where we left off?"
"No." Scarlett brushed away a tear that slid down his beard. "I don’t want to be the storm anymore. I want to be the rainbow. I don’t want to… I don’t want to run anymore. Even when it’s hard… when it hurts. I want… I want to be for you what you are for me too."
Sirius didn’t know what to say, so he stayed quiet. There were so many things pressing against his tongue, trying to force their way past his vocal cords, but none of them left his lips. Not because he wanted to punish Scarlett in any way, but because there was a fear embedded in his chest, a doubtful echo stirred by her words. It hurt. Every time she left…
It was like watching his heart being violently ripped from his chest.
He wanted to believe her. Truly, Sirius wanted to.
But he didn’t know how.
"You… you already are, love." Sirius whispered after a long pause. "You’re my home."
"What I mean is—"
"Why don’t we focus on your recovery first?" He cut in. There was no harshness in his voice, but there was a desperate need to dissolve the moment.
He was the one who suggested it and, for some reason, his heart began to race violently. His hands grew slick with sweat. His pupils dilated, swallowing the image of Scarlett above him like a starving void.
He could see the uncertainty hiding in every confused line of her expression. Sirius swallowed hard, trying to mask the flickering fear in the gleam of his starry eyes.
Sirius was afraid of Scarlett.
She blinked a few times, tearful eyes drifting away from him in disquiet. Her lips trembled and she smiled. A smile that looked far more like pain than joy.
"You’re right."
Sirius didn’t let her go, though. His arms stayed around her, rigid, as if the entire world would end if he loosened his grip. His shortened breaths spilled out in uneven bursts against the delicate fabric of her blouse, and he took advantage of that to hide his eyes there, where she couldn’t force him to tell the truth.
He knew their love was both refuge and ruin. It wasn’t easy; it was laden with pain, forgiveness, and bitterness. And the anxiety wearing Scarlett down about the future was the same thing corroding him. More than anything, he wanted to say yes. To say he wanted to build a home without trauma with her. That he wanted to give his boys what he had never had. It was what he was trying to do, after all.
Hesitation wouldn’t allow him to, and Sirius hated himself for it. He hated himself for fearing her with the same intensity that he loved her. Scarlett held too much power over him and could destroy him with a snap of her fingers and he…
He had already suffered enough. They both had been through too much.
So when Sirius finally fell asleep in the arms of the woman he loved and feared, he wished that some cosmic entity might grant him what he wanted, at least once in his life.
.
.
.
Scarlett didn’t sleep. Not because she didn’t want to, but… because she couldn’t. Maybe it was the withdrawal, maybe it was because she wanted to be there in case Sirius had another nightmare… but she knew none of that was entirely true.
When she had finally gathered enough courage to say what she wanted to say to Sirius, to open herself up about her feelings and what she envisioned for their future, he had simply…
She sighed when the frustration could no longer fit inside her chest. Morning arrived along with her tears, and Scarlett tried to disentangle herself from Sirius, but his arms were like iron, refusing to loosen even as she tried to pry them away.
"Love… it’s time." She murmured, hiding the edge of resentment in her voice.
Sirius only grunted and buried his face from the light in the hollow between her breasts.
"Sirius… wake up. It’s half five already." She insisted, running her fingers through the hair at the nape of his neck.
"Half five?" He mumbled, lethargic, rolling over and turning his back to Scarlett. "That’s way too early."
"We have to leave at half six." She murmured. The dryness in her throat burned. It felt like she’d just swallowed ash. She climbed out of bed with difficulty, stretching as she stood.
"Wake me up in half an hour." Sirius dragged the pillow over his face and went back to sleep.
Scarlett simply filled her lungs and let the air out loudly. She stared at the shape beneath the sheets, feeling foolish for having expected anything different. Sirius wanted to sleep wrapped around her every day, but when it came time to face the future together…
What the fuck were they doing, then? Everything he had said about wanting her to stay with him, about not wanting to lose her, about—
She rubbed at her eyes and went to the bathroom.
After her morning routine, she went to the kitchen and drank long gulps of water, pretending it was wine. Or whisky. Or liqueur. It could even have been absinthe. Unfortunately, it was just water.
"Morning." Reg was the first to get up, sitting down with his eyes still half-closed.
Penny appeared soon after and got on with preparing breakfast. Harry came in when the pancakes were ready, already dressed. Sirius was the last, hair dishevelled and sleep-heavy, leaning on the table when he slumped over it.
"Ready to drive?" He yawned.
It took Scarlett a moment to realise the question was meant for her.
"Mm-hm." She murmured and nodded, without looking at him.
"If you want, we can take turns—"
"It’s not necessary." She cut him off sharply.
"You look tired." Sirius went on, unfazed by her bad mood. "Didn’t manage to sleep last night?"
Scarlett pressed her lips together and scratched at the Ouroboros.
"I’ll drive." She replied firmly, leaving no room for argument.
"Alright then." Sirius frowned and poured himself some coffee, though his eyes stayed on her. Then he lowered his gaze and stirred his mug, staring at his boiled egg.
Scarlett wiped the sweat from her forehead with the back of her hand and left the kitchen when the wave of nausea hit her. She braced her hands on the bathroom sink and took a deep breath. She didn’t retch, but the bitter taste of disappointment lingered there, on her tongue, between her teeth, on her palate.
The day had started off brilliantly.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 94: A girl out there with love in her eyes and flowers in her hair
Chapter Text
CLXII
The last time Scarlett sat in the driver’s seat of that car had been in 1978. Remus could have used countless spells to get rid of the musty, dusty smell inside it, but there was a particular scent that hadn’t changed after all this time. She couldn’t tell whether it had seeped into the leather seats or the air filter, but it was something that carried her straight back to the past.
Why the hell did Sirius want to go in this rolling relic?
Scarlett forced a gulp of water down her throat and rubbed her eyes with her knuckles. The sun was faint outside, staining the sky in shades of purple and scarlet, and the chill of dawn still lingered in the streets. She, however, was sweating profusely. The Queen T-shirt she was wearing was already damp along her spine, and the back of her collar was beginning to soak through.
She adjusted the rear-view mirror, pulled the seat forward, and covered her mouth as she yawned.
"You don’t look like you slept well." James was the one who teased her, stretched out across the back seat with his legs up. "Looks like you had a good night, eh?" He grinned.
Scarlett remained apathetic.
"It was fucking shit, if you really want to know." She muttered, resting her forehead against the steering wheel. "For fuck’s sake, how long do you reckon it takes three princesses to finish packing?!"
The back door opened.
"...if I’d known you had a Game Boy, I’d have asked for one for my birthday!" Harry said, throwing himself onto the seat behind Scarlett.
"I didn’t even remember I had it." Reggie shrugged, getting in from the other side. "But you can play, if you want… there’s Super Mario Land, you’ll like it… instead of having to save Peach, the goal is to save Daisy…"
Scarlett thumped her forehead against the rim of the steering wheel, grinding her teeth.
"Mum?" Reg hugged the passenger seat. "Are you alright?"
"Where’s Sirius?" she asked, barely parting her lips.
As if summoned by name, Sirius climbed in. Scarlett blinked until her vision focused on him: on the outrageous Hawaiian shirt he was wearing, the ridiculous shell necklace, and the dark shorts.
"What the hell are you wearing?!" Harry was the first to react, slipping his headphones around his neck.
"You look like a drug dealer." Reggie tried to hold back a laugh, pulling his lips into his mouth.
"Do I?" Sirius looked at the two of them before turning his gaze to Scarlett, raising one eyebrow.
"Can we go?" Scarlett dismissed his question with a yawn.
"Yeah, I was putting the bags in the boot…" He didn’t take his eyes off her, even though Scarlett had turned her face away to open the garage with the remote. "Did you manage to get any sleep at all?"
"If you hadn’t been snoring in my ear all bloody night, Sirius… maybe I would have." She shot back, sharp as a whip.
Sirius swallowed hard.
"Ah, sorry. I didn’t know I was snoring! Why didn’t you wake me?" He put on his aviator sunglasses and folded his arms, shoving the seatbelt into place harder than necessary.
"Because you—" Scarlett was about to rise to the argument, but stopped herself. She lifted her eyes to the rear-view mirror, where Harry and Reggie were staring at the two of them, alarmed.
The moment they noticed her gaze on them, they immediately grabbed the Game Boy, put on their headphones and went back to playing Super Mario Land. Scarlett started the car, listening to it splutter on ignition. She gripped the steering wheel until her knuckles turned white, trying to ignore the scent that still lived there: a glimpse of the past that insisted on surviving everything, even time.
Sirius fiddled with the radio until it crackled to life and shoved in a Ramones tape. As soon as the music began, Scarlett hit the eject button hard and yanked the cassette out.
"I’m not listening to that American punk shite for the entire trip." Scarlett muttered, tossing the tape into Sirius’s lap without looking at him.
She heard him draw in a deep breath and release it in a sharp hiss.
"What do you want to listen to, then?" He didn’t bother hiding the impatience in his voice.
"Dunno…" She mumbled, flicking through the stations as she turned the dial with a trembling finger. She squinted at the sunrise.
They were crossing Battersea Bridge when the first station came through clearly:
"I don't wanna talk, about the things we’ve gone through…"
Scarlett scoffed and moved on.
"Swedish divorce at six in the morning. Brilliant."
The radio crackled and she kept turning the knob.
"In the day we sweat it out on the streets of a runaway American dream…"
She was about to switch again, but Sirius grabbed her wrist and pulled it away from the console.
"This one’s good, come on!" He tried to win her over with his most dazzling, dimpled smile, but Scarlett didn’t fall for it.
"No." That was all she said as she pulled free and changed the station.
"I'm on the hunt, I'm after you…"
"A scent and a sound, I'm lost and I'm found… and I’m hungry like the wolf…" Sirius sang along under his breath.
"Far too cheerful." Scarlett switched again, restless.
"Every breath you take, every move you make…"
"Ugh, I can’t stand Sting’s voice in this song."
"Time, he's waiting in the wings, he speaks of senseless things…"
Scarlett’s finger stilled. Bowie’s low piano made her glance at the mirror. James, Lily and Regulus were crammed into the boot, magically expanded with a charm. Reggie was lying across the seat with his head in Harry’s lap, whose attention was entirely absorbed by the Game Boy. Sirius’s voice joined Bowie’s.
She turned the dial again.
Sirius threw his hands up in confusion.
"Why did you skip it?!"
"Wish I knew what you were looking for… might have known what you would find…"
Scarlett took her hand off the console to change gear, which gave Sirius the perfect opportunity to switch the station back. Quick as a snake, she smacked his hand away and turned the radio off altogether.
Sirius twisted the numerous rings on his fingers and turned his face to the window, the motorway landscape sliding across the lenses of his aviator sunglasses.
She switched the radio on again.
[Led Zeppelin — Going to California]
Spent my days with a woman unkind
Smoked my stuff and drank all my wine
Made up my mind to make a new start
Scarlett snapped her fingers against the steering wheel and bit the corner of her mouth. Sirius looked at her. She kept her eyes on the road.
"Finally." He rolled his eyes, shifting in his seat.
Reggie pulled the Walkman headphones off and joined in with Plant, just like Sirius.
Going to California with an aching in my heart
Someone told me there's a girl out there
With love in her eyes and flowers in her hair
The morning sun shone over a landscape that shifted between thick clusters of trees and billboards at the entrance to towns branching off the motorway. Scarlett turned up the air conditioning, angled the vents towards herself and tossed her hair over her shoulder. None of it stopped the sweat already trickling down her forehead, nor did it ease the heaviness weighing on her eyelids.
The cold air against her face wasn’t enough to soothe the heat rising from within. A heat she had no idea how to relieve.
"Want me to drive?" Sirius asked after a few miles of silence.
"No." Scarlett huffed, biting at the dry skin of her lower lip.
Sirius shrugged in resignation. He unbuckled his seatbelt and rummaged through the pocket of his shorts, pulling out a black hair tie, worn loose from overuse. He folded one leg up on the seat and slowly stretched his arms, holding the elastic between his lips.
Scarlett glanced at him sideways, brow furrowing in suspicion.
"What are you doing?"
"Just focus on the road." Sirius murmured so naturally that she obeyed without thinking.
His tattooed fingers slid along her cheek, gathering the strands stuck to the side of her face with sweat. Sirius brushed the damp hair away from her forehead and patiently worked through the knots, his fingertips trailing through her bleached locks.
"It’s alright." He pressed a delicate kiss to the curve of her neck. "Just drive. I’ll sort this."
Scarlett looked at him again. Sirius’s mouth was slightly parted, his tongue running over his lips in concentration as he gathered her hair. His eyes absorbed all the light pouring through the car window, tinting the silver with a soft rosé hue. The sharp, aristocratic lines of his face softened when he met her gaze.
She shuddered. Her muscles tightened as though she’d just been struck by lightning, though it was only the brightest star in the night sky bathing her in his exasperating presence. Dragging her into his nauseating gravity.
It was difficult to look back at the road. Either that or crash the bloody car, and Scarlett wasn’t keen on killing everyone, though it was a monumental effort not to watch Sirius looping her platinum hair into a ponytail, her body prickling every time his fingertips brushed the nape of her neck.
He secured it with the elastic, twisting it three times.
Scarlett breathed in—deeply, painfully deeply—and tried to swallow, but her throat was dry. So was her mouth. She very much wanted to stay angry with Sirius and… no, she was angry with him, even if he knew it and was trying to disarm her with gestures laced with gentleness.
She pressed her lips into a stubborn line. She didn’t want to yield to that silent request for a truce, even if she was far too exhausted to keep fighting.
The green along the roadside gave way to scattered buildings, local shops, cafés with faded awnings and signs announcing the nearness of the coast. The sky brightened, the cerulean blue paling along the horizon. The clouds thinned, casting misshapen shadows over Brighton’s slanted rooftops.
Scarlett pressed the accelerator as they passed a junction, watching the city’s texture slip through the car windows: the Victorian façades of terraced houses, shop signs painted in delicate fonts, graffiti tucked into alleyways and bicycles left carelessly propped at corners.
Reggie was the first to roll down his window. The salty, heavy breeze flooded the car, the familiar scent of the sea seemingly untouched by time. The boy leaned his head out, wind whipping through his black hair and the headphone wires around his neck.
Harry lowered his window as well, followed by Sirius. Scarlett wiped the back of her hand across her forehead, brushing away the sweat gathered there.
The line of the sea appeared broad and gleaming beside the car, slicing the horizon into a wavering mirror of blue-green light. The reflection dancing on the water shimmered across the Rover’s bodywork, liquid brightness sliding into Scarlett’s lap. Seagulls circled above the promenade, which stretched on with its ornate railings and old lampposts.
The Grand Brighton Hotel loomed immense and white, adorned with columns and lace-like iron balconies glinting beneath the sun. Tall windows reflected the coastline and the sky. The golden lettering above the main entrance gleamed, framed by deep red awnings swaying in the wind.
Scarlett parked in front of the hotel and switched off the engine, which silenced the radio. The music gave way to the rustle of the sea breeze, the distant cry of a gull, the soft, hissing murmur of waves breaking against the pebble beach across the road.
Sirius was the first to open the door. He slipped on his black flip-flops and stepped out of the car, stretching his back with his hands on his hips. He adjusted his sunglasses and studied the hotel façade.
"Are we in the right place?" He looked at Scarlett over his shoulder.
"Yeah." She replied, unscrewing her bottle of water.
"It’s a bit… posh." Reggie commented, opening his door.
Scarlett took a deep breath and covered her mouth as she yawned. She stepped out of the car and cracked her neck.
"Let’s check in first, then we’ll grab the bags from the car…" She suggested, pulling the four invitations from her handbag. She smoothed her hands over the black dress she was wearing and walked into the hotel.
The lobby was so breathtaking it hardly seemed real. The polished beige marble floor reflected the Corinthian columns and the soaring vaulted ceilings. The corniced ceiling, adorned with gilded arabesques, supported a crystal chandelier that sparkled beneath the light filtering through the oval windows.
Scarlett heard her combat boots echo against the floor, such was the silence of the place. The towering walls exuded the scent of polished wood mingled with the refined perfume of fresh flowers in the central arrangements: lilies and hydrangeas set in silver vases.
Harry stopped a little behind her.
"This place is…" He pushed his glasses up his nose, unsure how to finish.
"Very posh." Reggie completed, scratching the back of his neck.
Sirius took the lead, stopped in front of the white marble counter and tapped the little bell three times with his index finger, resting his elbow there casually.
The receptionist appeared from behind the desk with a polished smile. She wore a burgundy waistcoat with gold buttons and an immaculate bun. For a brief moment, her eyes travelled over the group: Sirius in a Hawaiian shirt unbuttoned halfway down his chest, shell necklace and flip-flops, Scarlett in her black dress creased from the road, Harry and Reg in grubby Converse. One of her eyebrows twitched almost imperceptibly before she brightened her courteous smile.
"Good afternoon. How may I assist you?"
Scarlett stepped forward, pulling the envelope with the invitations from her bag.
"We have a reservation."
The woman arched her brows and opened the leather-bound register on the counter, carefully turning the pages until she found the number on the invitations. Her eyes widened and her smile gained a touch of nervous enthusiasm.
"Oh… of course!" she exclaimed, suddenly animated. "The Black family staying in the presidential suite. Naturally. Everything is perfectly prepared. We shall accommodate you with the utmost comfort."
Scarlett and Sirius exchanged a glance.
"The presidential wha—"
"On behalf of the entire Grand Harbour Hotel team, I would like to congratulate you on such a special occasion. Fifteen years of marriage! What an honour to welcome Mr Michael Murphy’s friends to celebrate such an important milestone in your union. The suite has been specially decorated for the date!" the receptionist continued, oblivious to having cut Scarlett off.
Scarlett blinked several times, confused. Sirius slipped an arm around her shoulders and bit his lower lip to suppress a laugh.
"What exactly do you mean by—"
"Yes, fifteen years of marriage. Can you believe it’s been that long already?!" Sirius cut in smoothly, concealing the sarcasm in his tone. "And these are our children. Will you need their documents?"
"That won’t be necessary."
The woman turned and rang a small bell elegantly. A middle-aged man emerged shortly after from a side door, dressed in a grey tailcoat, white gloves and a serene expression. His greying hair was slicked impeccably back, and a pocket watch hung from a chain at his waist.
"This is Mr Alaric. Our private butler for distinguished guests. He will accompany you to the suite and arrange anything you may require during your stay with us."
Alaric greeted them with a slight bow of his head.
"Mrs Black. Mr Black. Young masters." His voice carried a classic British timbre, each syllable crisply articulated. "Would you care for refreshments, or shall we have the luggage brought up before you ascend?"
Sirius straightened at once and slipped into a posture Scarlett hadn’t seen in quite some time: chin lifted, gaze sharpened, lips precise. His aristocratic side surfaced so naturally that she let out an incredulous laugh.
"Both." He replied smoothly, though there was a distinct note of authority in his tone.
"Excellent." Alaric gestured elegantly towards the lift at the back of the lobby. "This way, if you please."
Scarlett was practically pulled along by Sirius towards the lift, with Reg and Harry hurrying after them.
"I’m going to shove these invitations up Mike’s arse." She muttered under her breath so the butler wouldn’t hear.
"You’ll have plenty of time for that when we’re back in London." Sirius whispered against her ear, his warm breath raising goosebumps along her skin.
They stepped into a lift adorned with bevelled mirrors and amber lighting. At the top of the hotel, an empty corridor lined with burgundy carpet and gilded wall sconces led them to a pair of dark wooden double doors.
"Presidential Suite, number 701." Alaric announced, unlocking the doors with a golden key. "This way, Mr and Mrs Black."
The interior of the suite was a lavish amalgamation of a French palace and an Edwardian brothel. Crystal chandeliers, deep blue velvet curtains with golden tassels, faux columns along the walls and a grand piano in the corner of the sitting room. The sofas were so large one of the boys could easily sleep atop a single cushion. The thick carpet sank beneath their feet.
"Bloody hell, it’s bigger than our house." Reggie whispered to Harry, eyes glued to the chandeliers overhead.
"Reg, look at this!" Harry opened a door and discovered a separate sitting room with an electric fireplace, shelves lined with fake books and a minibar the size of a wardrobe. "There’s a secret room!"
"Harry, get out of there!" Sirius warned, following him, but the boy was already retreating.
"And through here…" Alaric continued, clearing his throat politely, entirely unflustered. He opened another set of double doors with a flourish. "The couple’s master suite."
Scarlett and Sirius entered first, followed by Reggie and Harry, who nearly collided in their eagerness to peek inside.
The bedroom was decorated with rose petals scattered across the floor and the bed, a silver bucket holding a bottle of champagne, two flutes and a tray of fresh strawberries. Sheer curtains framed the king-size bed. Mirrors covered the ceiling and walls. In one illuminated corner stood an unmistakable pole-dancing pole.
Scarlett massaged her temples with her thumb and forefinger.
"If you require anything, simply pull the cord." Alaric indicated the bell rope hanging from the ceiling in both the bedroom and the sitting room before slipping through one of the hidden doors built into the suite’s wall.
Regulus stepped forward timidly, then made his way to a box resting on the dressing table. He glanced at Sirius and Scarlett with a delighted grin, then lifted the lid. His smile widened with mischief.
"Harry, come here!" He pulled something out and began twirling a pair of leopard-print handcuffs around his fingers.
"Regulus!" Scarlett called in an attempt to scold him, but she was so stunned it came out weak.
"Why would anyone eat knickers?!" Harry grimaced, pulling out a packet of red jelly shaped like a pair of panties.
Regulus looked at Sirius, waiting for an explanation. But he looked just as horrified (and faintly entertained) as Scarlett, so it took him a few seconds to process what his nephew had said.
"What? What is it?" He frowned. "Why are you looking at me like that?"
"Because you’re someone I’m absolutely certain would eat a pair of knickers." Reg replied, which made Harry burst into laughter.
"What? Me? Never!" Sirius placed a hand on his chest as if deeply offended.
"That’s enough, you two!" Scarlett straightened and pulled them away from the box. "This is not… stuff… for you… Sirius! Do something!" She hissed through her teeth, peering into the box.
It wasn’t just the handcuffs and the edible underwear. There were vibrators, lubricants, a set of plastic balls Scarlett had no desire to identify, and a variety of other items clearly intended to spice up the relationship of a couple celebrating fifteen years together.
"What do you want me to do?!" Sirius put his hands on his hips, eyes darting between Reg, Harry and Scarlett.
Harry picked up a remote control and pressed a button. A television panel slid out from the wall and switched on to a programme that very clearly was not terrestrial.
On the screen, a woman in a gold bikini walked into what appeared to be a dentist’s surgery.
"Doctor… I think I’ve got very… deep… cavities…" she said, licking a red lollipop in an unmistakably suggestive manner.
The dentist, a man with a thick moustache wearing nothing but an open lab coat down to his navel and a stethoscope around his neck for reasons unknown, replied,
"Oh, my dear… you’ll need a thorough cleaning. Open wide and we’ll begin…" He undid another button on his coat.
"But doctor, I’m afraid of large drills…"
The television switched off abruptly. Sirius snatched the remote from Harry’s hand with excessive force.
"The two of you, to your room. Now!" Sirius said, his voice a few pitches higher than usual. He grabbed them by the arms and dragged them towards the door.
"Can we explore the hotel?" Regulus asked, biting his lips to hold back a laugh.
"No! One thing… in here! And don’t go into the drinks room!"
"But there’s nothing to do in here…" Harry grumbled, ruffling his hair even more once he was released.
"Just give me a few minutes, alright?! Go do… I don’t know, try saving Princess Paisy on the Game Boy!" Sirius shoved the two of them out and slammed the door shut.
Scarlett stared at her reflection in the mirrored ceiling, trying to ignore the awkward silence stretching between them. Then she lowered her gaze to the golden card resting on the bed and picked it up.
"Happy fifteenth wedding anniversary, Mr and Mrs Black. May your love continue burning intensely." She read in the tone of a bored lift attendant. "I’m going to kill Michael. I’m going to reception right now—"
"And say what?!" Sirius crossed his arms, positioning himself squarely in her path. A half-smile tugged at the corner of his lips. "That we’re not married? That we actually spent all that time locked up in a wizarding prison? We’re already in deep shit, Scar. Might as well unclench and go with it."
Scarlett glared at him, her brows knitting furiously at the centre of her forehead. Sirius tried to look serious, but the corners of his mouth lifted again. He attempted to turn away, yet both of them burst out laughing.
"Why the hell… did he put porn on the telly?!" Sirius asked between fits of laughter.
Scarlett merely shook her head, clutching her stomach as her breath grew scarce. She steadied herself against the pole beside the bed when her legs nearly gave way and wiped at the corner of her eyes. The laughter gradually faded, though her heart continued pounding loudly in her chest.
A yawn escaped her without warning and Scarlett drew in a long breath as she rubbed her eyes. Exhaustion hit her like a wave and she pressed her lips together as she looked up at Sirius, whose star-bright irises were already fixed on her.
"Go have a shower. Take a nap. That laugh did you good…" He shrugged, the smile lingering on his handsome face. "Go get some rest."
"Alright." She agreed, suddenly self-conscious. She knew why. Her gaze kept threatening to drift towards the ice bucket behind Sirius.
Her palms grew damp and her stomach twisted.
Sirius watched her walk into the bathroom and waited until he heard the shower switch on before leaving the bedroom.
.
.
.
Scarlett wanted to feel happy. She truly did. Yet when she looked at herself in the fogged mirror, all she saw in her own eyes was fear. Her mind strained to ignore any flicker of joy, clinging instead to fear as an act of self-preservation. As if happiness were dangerous. As if it could hurt her. Or worse, soak her in its softness and lightness, lifting her to the surface of the sea only for a wave to swallow her whole and the tide to drag her down to the ocean floor, making the suffocation and inevitable destruction far more painful than it ever needed to be.
No. She needed the fear, because fear would prepare her for it. When everything went wrong — again — Scarlett would be ready and she wouldn’t miss happiness.
After all, one cannot miss what one does not allow oneself to desire.
She dried her body and hair and slipped into the plush white dressing gown hanging beside the bath.
Scarlett searched for her wedding ring on the sink and slid it back onto her finger. She twisted it absently, scratching at the Ouroboros engraving, then wrapped her arms tightly around herself. It felt as though something inside her was on the verge of shattering if she made a single wrong move.
When she stepped out of the bathroom, her eyes were drawn once more to the bottle of champagne perched in its silver throne of ice, the cork still intact, the glass sweating in the warm air drifting through the half-open windows.
The dryness in her mouth scorched her throat, her tongue, the roof of her mouth. She blinked several times in an attempt to clear the bottle from her vision, but she couldn’t. Every time her eyelids fell and rose again, it was still there. Gleaming beneath the sunlight filtering through the curtains, the effervescence shimmering like flecks of gold within the pale liquid.
Scarlett didn’t like champagne because of the fizz. It was a pretentious drink for pompous idiots, usually used to celebrate equally idiotic occasions. She didn’t know which bastard had left it there, but if she did, she’d swear at him.
And thank him.
Her blood seemed to pulse slower with every step she took towards the bottle. Her fingers brushed the cold glass and a shiver licked its way across her skin. She bit her lower lip. Before she fully realised it, she had lifted it from the bucket and was clutching the champagne to her chest. Icy and wet against the fabric of her dressing gown. She could almost feel the bubbles bursting inside, even though it remained unopened.
She ran her thumb along the label. Thirteen per cent alcohol.
Her mouth watered, and the tremor that had haunted her hands these past few days returned in full force. The room around her receded into a dull hum at the back of her mind.
Scarlett was so acutely aware of herself that she could feel her temples throbbing in sync with the acceleration of her heart.
Just one sip.
Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip. Just one sip.
No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No. No.
Her arms tightened around the poor bottle of champagne, her fingers sliding over the damp, icy glass in a hesitant caress.
Her body was already anticipating the effects before she’d even tasted it. The sweet dizziness, the slippery relaxation. The world slowing down, lights splitting in two, feelings drowning.
Yesterday I… almost drank. I hit rock bottom… again.
Scarlett tried to let go. Tried to push her arm far enough away that the bottle would slip from her grasp and crash onto the thick carpet, shatter uselessly against the plush floor and seep down to hell, which was exactly where she belonged.
Where she should never have left.
I need the part of me that wants to live to be bigger than the part that wants to disappear.
She had only just stepped out of the shower and already she was sweating again. She pressed the bottle to her cheek and sank down to the floor, her mind fighting to think clearly while every neurotransmitter screamed at the sight of the forbidden fruit resting between her trembling fingers.
Just imagining the metallic taste laced with the cruel warmth of that toxic kiss she knew so well…
Scarlett felt sick. She didn’t know whether it was disgust at herself or disgust at what she was about to do.
Even knowing it would hurt the people I love.
She managed to free one hand from the bottle, letting it grope blindly along the furniture beside her in search of a corkscrew.
To her misfortune — or perhaps her salvation — she found none.
She rubbed her exhausted eyes harshly. When she opened them again, she was curled up beside a dark red four-poster bed in a house that whistled every night. The faint glow of gas lamps cast restless shadows across her anguished features.
Scarlett thought she understood fear.
She had truly learned fear at Grimmauld Place. It had been almost a rehearsal for the horrors she would later endure in Azkaban.
Her glassy gaze travelled across the bedroom walls. So many posters and photographs were plastered there that very little of the silver-grey silk beneath could be seen. Walburga and Kreacher had tried countless times to remove them, but the Permanent Sticking Charm had refused to yield. There was a collection of large red-and-gold Gryffindor banners. Numerous photographs of Muggle motorbikes and countless posters of Muggle bands and bikini-clad girls, all in stark contrast to the single wizarding image on the walls: four Hogwarts students standing arm in arm, laughing at the photographer.
Scarlett curled further inward, as if she could vanish inside herself. She couldn’t, of course. What else could she do? Sirius’s bedroom was the only place in that cursed house where she could—
Where she… where she… where she could…
"Scarlett?"
It was Sirius’s voice.
He’d finally come. He’d finally come to save her, he—
Scarlett lifted her head so abruptly that when she opened her eyes, she didn’t know where she was.
"What the hell do you think you’re doing?!" There was so much fury in his voice that Scarlett felt the heat drain from her face before she could even attempt an answer.
He stood in the doorway of the suite, expression hardened, chest rising and falling stiffly. Scarlett lowered her gaze to the bottle cradled in her arms.
She didn’t know what to say.
"Leave me alone, Sirius." She murmured, resting her cheek against the bottle again, seeking comfort disguised as destruction.
Sirius remained still in the threshold. Then he lifted one hand, two fingers pointed at her, and wet his lips.
"Evanesco."
He cast the charm without even needing a wand.
The bottle vanished from her arms, along with the invisible shards of whatever control she had left. Scarlett remained frozen in the same position. The absence of weight, of cold glass, of that broken promise of relief that even the mere sight of a bottle of alcohol could offer her—it was too much.
It was too much.
"No!" Scarlett forced the word through her throat, hoarse. "No, no, no, no…"
Her hands began to shake. Her shoulders followed. Her heart hammered violently in her chest, her palms slick with sweat, and the pain of being denied what she could never have erupted from her stomach and scorched her oesophagus. A knot formed in her throat. She tried to clear it with a cough, but the sob was already clawing its way up, tears pooling in her eyes before spilling over—warm and unstoppable.
It was her body. It was trying to purge the agony of craving her favourite poison. Withdrawal gnawed at every thought until they were reduced to a single, immeasurable urge for self-sabotage and ruin.
"What’s going on? Why have you been like this since this morning? Why the bloody face, eh?!" As if things weren’t already unbearable, Sirius bombarded her with questions.
Scarlett tried to speak, but the sob lodged in her chest wouldn’t let her. Her hands clenched into fists so tightly her knuckles blanched. A throbbing rage pulsed through her veins and her breathing turned into an angry, ragged pant.
"You… know perfectly well why!" she spat, biting into her own arm. "You know perfectly well, Sirius!"
"I’ve got two balls, Scarlett, but neither of them’s crystal!" he shot back, dropping to his knees in front of her. "Help me out here, for fuck’s sake, what’s going on?!"
Lips trembling, breath ragged and disoriented, Scarlett lifted her eyes to the incandescent silver of his.
"Why did you… why…" she tried, though shame and fury thickened her tongue. "Why did you… never come for me?"
Sirius brushed her hair away from her face, giving himself a clear view of her shattered expression. A confused crease formed between his brows, and he stayed silent for so long it felt like an entire decade had passed.
"What… what are you talking about?" he stammered, swallowing hard.
"When… I was at Grimmauld Place." Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut and sniffed, sobbing. There was venom in her voice, indignation soaked in hurt and desperation. "I… I waited. I waited so long. I… I thought… you were going to show up. That you’d get me out of there. That you’d save me… from them. From the Death Eaters. From your parents. From your brother."
Sirius’s throat closed. His body forgot how to breathe—that was the only explanation for the pressure building in his skull and the sudden lack of oxygen in his brain. He blinked several times as his vision blurred.
Scarlett had flipped the argument so abruptly that no defence seemed adequate. Nothing seemed enough.
"I… I… I wanted… wanted to do that." He faltered, struggling. Air left his lips and did not return. "I wanted to. I swear I did. And I… I tried. I nearly died looking for you, but… I… I was so angry, Scar…"
Sirius covered her trembling hands with his own. Fingers heavy with rings and ink wrapped tightly around hers, as if he could steal that pain for himself.
"Angry at…" Scarlett held his gaze, the ocean blue of her irises spilling over her long dark lashes. "At me?"
Sirius dragged a deep breath through his mouth, filling his lungs until his chest expanded fully, then let it out slowly.
"At everything. At you. At him. At myself." He confessed, lowering his head to their stitched hands. She opened her fingers, allowing him to rest his face in her damp palms. "You… you were right about my anger." His voice vibrated against her skin. "I… I hated Regulus. I hated him so much I couldn’t see anything else. Not you. Not what was really happening."
Scarlett’s chest collapsed rather than eased. As much as she wanted to understand Sirius, the resentment inside her was greater than that. Much greater. He had promised to protect her, promised to love her for the rest of their lives, promised her a life at his side.
But, like so many promises made in the past, Sirius had not kept it.
"The hatred… it rotted what I felt for you and… all I could feel was resentment. Because you left me. Because you chose him. Because you replaced me. You abandoned me."
Scarlett shook her head so violently her hair whipped from side to side with the motion.
"I never… did that." She choked on her own sobs. "I’m tired, Sirius. Tired of being accused of what I did… of what I didn’t do… Sirius, Reg… Reg…"
Her voice collapsed. Her son’s name snagged in her throat. The tears came in an uncontrollable torrent, so fierce she could barely breathe.
Sirius pulled her into his arms, flooding her with the overwhelming illusion that the scattered fragments of her could be gathered and pieced back together, that her collapse could be stopped—or at least postponed. Intoxicating her with the uncertain certainty that this man, with star-bright eyes and midnight hair, was the only thing standing between her and the inhospitable, lacerating abyss inside her. That he was not the architect of that place, but the exit.
"Come here… come here." He guided her to the bed, laying them both down upon the immaculately arranged duvet, now strewn with rose petals.
Scarlett hid against Sirius’s chest. She pressed her face there, wishing she could pass through his ribcage and finally take shelter inside his heart. She wiped her eyes and let herself be rocked by his scent, by the worry etched across his features, by the steady rise and fall of his breathing. It was Sirius there. Solid and real, arms wrapped around her, body pressed to hers, eyes drilling into her own.
The clear blue of Scarlett’s irises was no longer enough to conceal the horror, bewilderment and shock reverberating through her soul. She closed her eyes slowly, damp lashes meeting. Keeping them open required more energy than she possessed.
"Scar… I don’t think…" Sirius ran his fingers slowly through her hair. "That what you had with my brother was… consensual."
Scarlett let out a weak laugh that sounded more like revulsion.
"It was." She murmured, burying her face in the open space of Sirius’s Hawaiian shirt, feeling the shells of his necklace press against her forehead. "He would change… his appearance. He’d look exactly like you so that… so that we could be together. Because he wanted… he wanted what we had."
It was as if Sirius had been punched in the stomach. The air left his body once again and refused to return. He closed his eyes and buried his nose in Scarlett’s hair, anchoring himself to her, finding the only safety he knew—in the woman who had witnessed both his misery and his excesses.
"I know. And even so, Scar… even so, I don’t think you were capable of consenting. You were trapped in that house. Against your will." He swallowed thickly, somehow managing to clear his throat. One of his hands drifted down to the bed and caught a rose petal between his fingers, fresh and velvety. "Enduring things I can’t even imagine. Isolated. Vulnerable."
"Regulus was a… a bloody manipulative bastard, but… he… he never…" She gasped. "He never… he… he never…"
Her breathing faltered again and again. It snagged in her throat, hesitated in her chest, rooted itself in her lungs. She lifted her face and raised wide, stricken eyes to Sirius.
"It wasn’t right." He said softly. The silver of his gaze wrapping around her in warmth and tenderness. "What he did to you… it wasn’t right."
Sirius pulled the duvet over her. It wasn’t cold, but so many shivers were coursing through her body that she trembled uncontrollably. Perhaps from the relentless sobbing. Or because the words had run out, trapped somewhere in the folds of time, of intention and of the past, tangled in the frayed sheets of memory.
She wanted to justify what Regulus had done and she didn’t even know why. She wanted to claim it had been mutual — that she had benefited from what they’d had — but the truth was… Sirius was right. She had been little more than a captive.
Scarlett had lost so much that happiness had become a distant, untouchable memory.
"It’s alright." Sirius murmured, though he knew nothing was alright. Those two little words never seemed to apply to Scarlett. "I’m here. I’m here with you."
He didn’t pull away. He felt every tremor in her muscles, every tightening of her tendons, every sob shuddering through her chest. Her fevered, prickled skin brushing against his calm, steady warmth.
"You’re not there anymore." His words seeped into her mind and spread along her spine like creeping ivy, shaped like calm. "You got out. It’s over. It’s over, my love."
Scarlett sniffed again. Her body loosened, her jaw unclenched. Her eyelids remained closed, but Sirius knew she wasn’t asleep. He knew her far too well for that. He could feel the pulse of her blood and the fierce rhythm of her heart. She might feel exhausted, but she wouldn’t surrender to sleep. She was far too proud for that.
"Kitten… I want so badly to have a family with you. A family that doesn’t need fixing, but… you need to forgive yourself first." His voice was barely audible, yet she felt it slither through her hair, through her veins. Reverberating in her bones. "Either you end this… or it ends you."
Forgiving yourself… is harder than giving up the bloody alcohol.
Scarlett pressed herself tighter against Sirius’s chest, searching for relief, for absolution, for shelter.
And she found it.
She always did.
Love, however difficult and exhausting it could be, however fragile, exposing and humiliating, was also capable of blooming where pain had nowhere left to run.
True love does not save anyone… but it sustains, shelters and waits.
And love was all Scarlett Gaunt had ever sought.
It always had been.
Above all, the love of Sirius Black.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 95: However much I try, that isn’t going to change
Chapter Text
CLXIII
Harry shrank into the velvet sofa, far too fancy for his liking. Reggie, beside him, didn’t share the sentiment. He was sprawled out, bare feet propped up on the marble coffee table and a cherry soda balanced between his thighs.
Alaric, the middle-aged butler who looked more like a wizard thanks to his Victorian attire than a Muggle, had already served them fresh juices, nibbles and scented towels. Then he discreetly vanished through the double doors.
Harry picked up the silver ashtray from the side table, studying his distorted reflection in it: his nose looked so enormous it swallowed the rest of his face in the curved edges of the object.
"Reg…" He murmured, sipping his lemonade through the tiny umbrella straw. "I still… I still don’t get it."
Regulus scratched his nose and swung his feet lazily.
"Don’t get what?" He asked in a drawling voice without opening his eyes.
"That… that…" He took another sip of lemonade to help swallow the lump caught in his throat. "That edible knickers."
Reggie cracked one eye open, looking at him sideways. The chandelier refracted the morning light, scattering it over the boy’s freckled, aristocratic face in tiny sparkles.
"Oh. The jelly knickers." He grinned cheekily.
Harry drew his brows together in outrage.
"Why? Why would anyone… eat knickers?"
Reggie let out a nasal laugh and ran a hand through his black hair. With the other, he rotated his glass until the straw met his lips.
"Fetish." He shrugged.
Harry sighed and adjusted his glasses with a flicker of irritation.
"And what does that mean?!"
Sighing, Reggie straightened up on the sofa and placed his feet on the rug, making an irritating slurping sound as he continued sucking on the empty straw.
"It’s like… everyone’s got stuff that makes them… feel good. Turned on." He made a suggestive gesture with his hands. "Could be anything. Dunno. Whispering in someone’s ear. School uniform. Edible knickers. Being hung upside down. There’s no limit, Harry. The brain’s a bit… bizarre."
The grimace that spread across Harry’s face only deepened at the explanation.
"But that’s… that’s a bit… weird, isn’t it? Degrading?"
Reggie laughed and set his glass down on the coffee table.
"Yeah. But if it’s between adults who are both alright with it, there’s nothing wrong with it. It only gets awkward when you talk about it to someone who’s not… er, used to that sort of thing. It’s normal to think it’s odd at first, though, Harry."
Harry felt his face heat up and lowered his gaze to his lemonade, watching the ice cubes drift through the cloudy liquid.
He didn’t notice that Regulus was still watching him, grey-blue eyes studying him intently.
"Harry, do you know where babies come from?"
"Yeah." He grunted, using his straw to stir the ice in his glass. Then he lifted his gaze to Reg. "I heard Oliver and Percy talking about it… it’s when a man and a woman sleep naked."
Regulus stayed silent, waiting for Harry to continue the explanation. When he realised there was nothing more coming, he laughed so hard he started coughing and nearly knocked his glass off the table.
"Merlin’s balls, Harry!" He wiped the back of his hand across his mouth. "I knew Oliver and Percy were virgins, but now I’m absolutely certain!"
Harry flushed a deep crimson. He rolled his eyes and huffed at Reg’s reaction.
"No one’s ever explained any of it to me!"
Regulus composed himself. The mockery vanished from his expression without a trace, swiftly replaced by a disconcerting seriousness. He pressed his lips into a thin line and studied Harry for a moment, weighing what to say next.
"Right, Harry, I know who can help you. Sirius will love having that conversation with you…" He teased, though there was no real malice in his tone.
"What? Have you lost your mind?! Sirius telling me about… about sex?!" If Harry had been red before, now he went pale. "Not a chance!"
"Alright then. I can explain." Reggie moistened his lips and raised his index finger in a mock-teacherly manner. "When a man and a woman love each other very much—"
"I’ll do what?!" Sirius cut in, emerging from the bedroom with his hair in disarray and a crumpled Hawaiian shirt hanging off his shoulders.
"Nothing!" Harry squeaked, his voice shooting up two octaves. His face had gone as white as a corpse.
Reggie, on the other hand, wore a devilish grin. The sort of grin Sirius himself used to have when he was younger, right before pulling a prank that would land him and James in detention for a month.
Seeing his two godsons so at ease there made his heart warm.
"Well, I’ve calmed the beast." He said, shoving his hands into his dark shorts. "Fancy a wander round the hotel?"
"Yeah!" Reggie sprang up from the sofa in one leap. "And what d’you mean, calmed the beast? What was Mum cross about?!"
"Ah, Reg… if you’re feeling brave, you can go wake her up and find out…" Sirius shrugged one shoulder, his lips curving into a half-smile. "Come on, Harry, off the sofa and put your flip-flops on…" He stepped away and tugged the cord dangling from the ceiling beside the double doors to his and Scarlett’s room.
Harry slipped on his flip-flops, still thinking about the edible knickers, about what Reggie had said, and about the fact that maybe, just maybe, he really did need to have that conversation with Sirius.
Just in about ten years. Twenty years. Never.
Yes, never sounded like the right time.
Alaric appeared through a hidden door beside the minibar.
"Mr Black?!" he said, standing as straight as a stake, hands clasped behind his back and chin tilted forward.
Sirius cast a subtle glance at the boys and walked over to him, leaning against the wooden counter beside them.
"I need you to get rid of all the alcoholic drinks in the suite. All of them, Alaric." Sirius ordered in his usual arrogant tone, though it was laced with something else. It sounded like… shame? Caution? "You can replace them with non-alcoholic versions if you think it’s necessary to keep up appearances. But no alcohol. Not even one per cent."
Alaric inclined his head deferentially.
"Perfectly, Mr Black."
The lack of any questioning made Sirius arch an eyebrow, but then he merely resumed his façade of superiority, stitched so deeply into him by his parents that not even Azkaban had managed to tear it out.
"Right. Mrs Black is resting in the master bedroom." He said, glancing over his shoulder at the closed door behind him. "She’s not to be disturbed. But if she wakes… let her know we’ve gone down to explore the hotel. We’ll be about."
"Understood. I shall send our senior concierge to present the facilities to you."
"Perfect." Sirius turned to the boys. "Ready?"
Harry and Reggie nodded.
"Then let’s go."
.
.
.
"Welcome to our seaside palace, gentlemen. The Grand Brighton is one of the oldest hotels in continuous operation in the south of England. We opened in 1864 and have hosted everyone from music legends to acting ministers… and now, you." Cromwell, the concierge Alaric had mentioned, led the group.
Sirius walked down the corridor lined with arched stained-glass windows that poured coloured light onto the patterned carpet. The boys followed a step behind, laughing and whispering between themselves.
"This corridor leads to the tea lounge and the Cyan restaurant. Everything on the menu is included for the family."
"Everything included? Hope it’s not tasteless food with a fancy name." Reg muttered to Harry.
"Is there a pool here?!" the younger one asked, pushing his glasses up the bridge of his nose.
Cromwell’s thin lips curved slightly.
"We are currently undergoing renovations for the opening of a spa and hydrotherapy area. However, we have access to the pool and arcade at HarSpa, our partner establishment next door. I can arrange entry and supervision, should you wish."
"An arcade?!" Harry practically shouted. "Can we go, Sirius?!"
"Of course… at the end of the tour." He winked at his godson.
Cromwell led them to a glass door that opened onto a terrace overlooking the sea. The waves crashed rhythmically against the pebbled shore, where the stones shimmered beneath the sun and were already beginning to fill with visitors. Seagulls sliced through the sky, their cries carried on the wind.
"This place is massive." Reggie leaned against the intertwined iron railing. "If we get lost, what do we do?!"
"Shout. Alaric will probably pop out of a hole in the floor and escort you back to the suite…" Sirius joked, resting his shoulder against the wall. "I reckon he’s got a mental map of every guest in real time."
Cromwell sniffed what sounded like a laugh, though his lips didn’t move.
"Indeed. Alaric usually knows where everyone is. Including… should Mrs Black wake, I shall inform you at once." He gave a small bow and withdrew, granting them more privacy.
Sirius looked at the boys, tucking his hair behind his ear as the sea breeze relentlessly tousled it. He caught himself smiling and turned his gaze towards the horizon, squinting against the glare reflected off the water.
"Think you can survive five days being treated like royalty?" He turned back to them.
"No." Reggie muttered.
"Yes." Harry said at the same time.
The two glanced at each other.
"It’s too posh. There’s not even a skate park or a pool… we’ve got to go somewhere else just to have a swim!" Reg crossed his arms, resting them on the railing.
"Oh, I think it’s brilliant… and we can order room service whenever we like… and there’s cable telly!" Harry argued.
"Right… before we head off… we need to set a few rules. Technically, Scarlett and I are married and you two are our sons, so you’ll have to act like it in front of other people. You’re free to wander about, but you need to let me know first. Or ask Alaric to tell me."
"Yeah, yeah, yeah." Reggie waved his words away carelessly. "Can we go now?"
"What d’you mean, can we go now?! I’m coming with you!" Sirius put his hands on his hips.
"You are?" Reggie wrinkled his nose.
Sirius sighed.
"Course I am! Give me twenty minutes in the arcade and I’ll show you how to beat Space Invaders with a cigarette in my mouth and one hand in my pocket." He lifted his shoulders smugly.
.
.
.
Scarlett woke to the fresh scent of rose petals in her nose and a sweet warmth in her chest. She blinked a few times, orienting herself, her hands running over her white dressing gown as her gaze settled on the mirrored ceiling above the bed. The curtains were drawn, but the wind stirred the velvet fabric, allowing streaks of light to slip inside.
The glow that caught her attention, however, didn’t come from outside.
No.
It came from within the room, from one of the corners.
Regulus was sitting with his head resting against the wall, face tilted upwards, arms wrapped around his legs. Their gazes met in the reflection of the ceiling mirror. The iron in his stare, once so cold and rigid, was now stripped of its usual dissimulation.
"I remember…" Scarlett murmured, hoarse and lethargic. "When I played that song for you at Grimmauld Place. What I told you."
Regulus swallowed hard, his jaw tightening so fiercely the veins in his neck stood out.
"What did you tell me?" He asked after a moment. She had the distinct impression he both wanted and didn’t want to know.
Scarlett hesitated. She was reluctant to continue, and impatience sparked in Red’s iron-grey eyes.
"That the war had brought out the best in you." The words left a bitter residue in her mouth, followed by a scoff laced with disgust. "I was wrong." She kept her gaze fixed on Regulus, whose brow furrowed in opposition. "You used me."
"You used me as well." He echoed in a low, hollow voice.
"Regulus… you raped me."
Regulus’s face turned as white as Scarlett’s dressing gown. His marble features twisted, and his iron eyes corroded with tears.
"And you hit me!" He shot back, losing control of his voice for a few seconds, the crack in his tone betraying the fracture beneath.
"Because you deserved it." Scarlett hissed, her fingers digging into the plush fabric of her robe.
Red’s ghostly tears slid down his cheeks and vanished before they could reach the floor. His expression held indifference, but he was suffering from that conflict in his chest Scarlett had never managed to unravel.
It was what had made him wither since they were teenagers at Hogwarts.
"I didn’t… I didn’t rape you. You made me be him, because… if I wasn’t him…"
"You suggested it!" Her voice broke over his, cutting him off.
"I know. I wanted to be him." Regulus expelled air from lungs that no longer functioned. "I wanted to be Sirius."
"You will never be him." She replied flatly.
Scarlett studied his features, so similar to Sirius’s, graceful and sharp, yet tainted by something strange in their cold stillness. The permanently furrowed brow, the eyes that, no matter how bright or deep they seemed in any light, almost never softened. Regulus was imposing, yet powerless. Handsome, yet weak. Astute, yet hollow. He was the moon, forever dependent on something or someone else to make him more than what his parents had puffed him up to be.
A parasite searching for its next host.
"You left me alone with Bellatrix." His voice trembled through the silence. The words seemed to escape him against his will, because as soon as he spoke, he made a motion as if trying to snatch them back. He was still crying, even as he tried to bury the torment in his tone.
Scarlett shrank in on herself and felt tears sting her own eyes, though she refused to let them fall.
"Did she touch you?"
Regulus went pale again, but just as before, he mastered his emotions with clinical precision as he nodded. He pressed his palms against his temples and let his head fall towards his shoulder.
"I deserved it." He added. His grey eyes, sharp and watchful, never left hers.
"I regretted it… what I did. I tried… I tried to go back and… and open the door, but… it was too late." Scarlett gasped, choking on her own breath. "I tried, but Dimitri showed up and I… and I…" However much she forced it, her voice refused to obey, producing nothing but a strangled sound.
Regulus, mute, dragged trembling fingers over his cheeks in a futile attempt to wipe away the dampness that would not cease. A quarter of an hour passed, and their eyes remained locked, trying to dissect the truth from dark pupils and pedantic irises.
"We deserved each other." Scarlett concluded. "I’m sorry, Red."
"I didn’t… I didn’t know that… that what I was doing to you… I… I had some sense it was wrong, but… I… I didn’t mean to… I’m sorry…" He faltered, pressing his lips together tightly. Scarlett couldn’t tell whether he was shocked or furious. It was never easy to read his mind; Regulus manipulated his expression so she could only ever see what he chose to show.
And there was no remorse in the shadows of his face, nor in the rigidity of his gaze. Scarlett blinked, her attention drifting down to the petals beginning to wilt across the bed.
"No. I will never forgive you for what happened at Grimmauld Place." She lifted her eyes to him again. A serious, incisive, resolute look. "Never."
"I… I only…" Regulus tried, but the words tangled in his mouth, forming a knot that would not rise to his throat. "I was trying to save the world… destroy Voldemort… end the war…"
Scarlett rose from the bed, using the sleeves of her dressing gown to absorb her tears. She threw open the curtains, allowing light to flood the room. She could feel Regulus’s gaze burning against the back of her neck and glanced at him over her shoulder. His faint glow merged with the brightness, so intense he nearly vanished. It was not enough to erase those iron eyes, always so indifferent and unreadable.
"We all had that childish fantasy of being heroes in the war." Scarlett forced the sob back with a sharp exhale through clenched teeth. "In the end, we were the villains."
Regulus parted his lips, as if to speak. Yet he swallowed whatever words had been about to emerge. It wasn’t as though it would have made any difference.
Scarlett left the room before giving him any chance at all.
.
.
.
Scarlett was wearing sunglasses when she entered the Cyan restaurant. The hall of wide windows displayed countless tables laid with fine china, silver cutlery and arrangements of white flowers. As she crossed the double-height entrance, she slowed when she came face to face with a large group composed entirely of men in floral shirts, cameras hanging from their necks.
Dozens of eyes fixed on her, prompting her to glance towards the mirrored wall nearby, searching for some flaw in her patch-covered black waistcoat or pleated skirt. The crowd approached with an enthusiasm she genuinely did not understand.
"Madame Stargazer! C’est bien vous! The keyboardist of Space Travelers, who played in Bordeaux!" one of the men exclaimed, all in the language of Molière.
Scarlett blinked several times, stunned. It took her a moment to switch the language in her head.
"Ah… ahn…" She cleared her throat. "Merci bien."
"We saw the whole band… Saturn, Supernova, Nebula and Leo… ils sont là?"
The question made Scarlett twist her wedding ring around her finger. She barely remembered that the other band members also had codenames, since she always called them by their birth names, but it was amusing to hear the public refer to them that way.
"The show was incroyable!" A second tourist stepped forward, handing his camera to someone else in the group to take a photo.
"J’ai un dîner en famille, I’m truly sorry." Scarlett refused the request as she took a step back, pressing her lips into a polite smile.
"Une seule photo, s’il vous plaît?! My brother will want to die when he finds out I met you here…"
Scarlett clenched her fists and filled her lungs with air. She had no patience to deal with persistent fans, let alone a group of idiotic tourists. She opened her mouth to repeat that she already had an engagement, but the words never formed, because she felt a familiar tug in her chest.
"Messieurs, excusez-nous, mais Madame n’est pas disponible pour des autographes ce midi. Je vous remercie de la laisser passer."
She knew that deep voice well, in its authoritative tone laced with a trace of exasperation. A tattooed arm slipped around her waist with natural ease, pulling her gently against his body in a possessive gesture. The sweet scent of his cologne enveloped her in an unavoidable, piercing aura. Sirius’s presence climbed her spine and spread to her fingertips.
Scarlett merely released the breath she had been holding and scratched the back of her left hand, where her Ouroboros was concealed by a charm. She adjusted her sunglasses, pulling them slightly lower to hide the blush rising to her cheeks, and tilted her face towards his ear.
"Merci, mon cœur." She murmured, low enough that only he could hear.
Sirius answered by pressing a kiss to her temple. The stardust in his eyes hardened into steel as he kept his gaze fixed on the tourists, lifting his nose with innate arrogance and jutting his chin forward in the most threatening manner he could muster.
"Bon après-midi, messieurs." He growled, guiding Scarlett away.
They crossed the restaurant towards a reserved table in the sunniest corner. Reggie and Harry were leafing through the menu with feigned boredom, pretending to be far too occupied to notice what had just happened.
"Didn’t know you two spoke French." Harry remarked, casually setting his menu aside.
Scarlett merely sighed and sank into the chair beside Sirius.
"Oh, Uncle Orfy told me about that. He speaks fluent French as well… he and Mum lived in the Romandy part of Switzerland." Reg explained, resting his elbows on the table. "And Sirius—"
"My mother forced my brother and me to learn it from childhood." Sirius cut in, pouring water into their glasses.
"Oh, that’s right!" Reggie straightened in his seat. "I remember her going absolutely spare when she found out I’d never learnt!"
"You met your grandmother?!" Scarlett shifted in her chair.
"Uh, yeah. A bit before she died, at least." Reg shrugged and took a sip of water. "She used to say even Kreacher spoke two languages and I didn’t."
Sirius let out a snort of laughter. It wasn’t particularly amused.
"Kreacher?" Harry frowned in confusion.
"My mother’s mad house-elf." Sirius explained. The bun he wore was beginning to come undone, and long, thick black strands slipped down his neck in onyx waves, the sunlight striking them until the dark gleamed blue, almost cobalt.
Scarlett stared at his reflection in the impeccably polished cutlery arranged on either side of a pearl satin napkin.
"You had a house-elf?!" Harry stared at Sirius, the green of his eyes behind his clear lenses bright with interest. The same way his mother’s eyes, seated at the next table, were always fixed on her son.
"I did." Sirius rotated his glass between his fingers. "Unless Reg set him free at some point…"
"I think he died. He was already a bit barmy and old when I saw him, and I was about… five?!" Reg pressed his lips together and lifted his hands, uncertain.
The silence between them heightened the soundtrack of the Cyan restaurant, the typical dreary jazz played in fancy establishments that loop the same playlist endlessly.
"And you… Scar… you’re famous." Harry cleared his throat, turning towards Scarlett.
She dismissed the comment with a roll of her eyes.
"It’s nothing special."
Reggie huffed with a half-sarcastic smile.
"It’s nothing special… until someone recognises you in a luxury restaurant hundreds of miles away because you opened for Pearl Jam."
"It wasn’t me who opened, Reg. It was the band." Scarlett corrected him in a detached tone.
"I want to go to your next show!" he declared, his lips now lifting with pride.
"Me too!" Harry echoed Reg’s enthusiasm.
Scarlett downed her water in one go. Her hands had stopped trembling, but she swore the sweat was returning. Her eyes drifted towards the bar shelves behind Reggie, where all her impulsive temptations were neatly displayed. She tore her gaze away, only to fall straight into the trap of star-bright irises and black-hole pupils.
"There… there won’t be a next show." Scarlett whispered, trying to bury the strain in her voice.
Sirius raised an eyebrow.
"What do you mean?" The question slipped from his lips so quickly he hadn’t time to rationalise it.
Scarlett rubbed her damp palms against the hem of her skirt.
"Er, I… I’m leaving the band."
"Why?" Reg asked, just as stunned as his godfather.
Scarlett parted her lips, but whatever she had intended to say scattered before it could take shape.
"Good afternoon. Have you decided what you’d like for lunch?" The waiter, soft-voiced and dressed in an ivory jacket, approached with a trained smile. "Or would you prefer a few more minutes with the menus?"
Sirius moistened his lips and tucked a stray lock of hair behind his ear.
"I think we’ll need a few more minutes." He glanced at Scarlett, whose eyes had dropped to the cutlery.
"Of course, Mr Black." The waiter inclined his head slightly. "Should you have any questions abou—"
"Actually, I’m ready to order." Scarlett grabbed the menu with unsteady fingers, ignoring the chill that flickered down her spine beneath the looks she received. She needed control. She needed to prove she could manage. "I’ll have… the mushroom risotto with… er, white truffle oil and… and…"
The knot in her throat tightened. No matter how much she swallowed or forced it, it would not loosen. Worse, it was stealing her breath with it. The air thinned. Her fingers tingled and cold sweat prickled at the nape of her neck.
"Scar?" Sirius draped his arm over the back of her chair and leaned closer. "Are you alright?"
Scarlett wanted to answer, but her hands began trembling again.
"Excuse me…" was all she managed before standing, leaving the menu resting over the cutlery.
She staggered away from the table.
Harry and Reggie exchanged a bewildered look.
Two seconds. It took Sirius two seconds to rise and follow her with his eyes.
Scarlett disappeared down the corridors leading to the restaurant’s lavatories. The wooden doors adorned with frosted mirrors closed behind her. She locked herself in and leaned her back against the door, letting the weight of her head rest on the wood, her eyes fixed on somewhere and nowhere.
She tried to breathe.
For some reason, over the past few days, breathing had become far more difficult than it ought to be. As if she did not do it every day, as if it were not so instinctive she even did it in her sleep. Every time she thought about filling her lungs with air, they seemed to hear her intention and emptied themselves out in defiance, to torture her, to make her choke on her own urges. To intensify the unbearable pressure crushing her chest.
When Sirius reached the bathroom door, he curled his index finger and knocked with his knuckles.
"Scarlett? It’s me. Let me in." There was an unbearable note of vulnerability in his voice.
No answer.
He leaned his forehead against the door and lowered his tone.
"Love… let me in, please. I just want to know if you’re alright."
Nothing.
"Shit." Sirius muttered, glancing around to ensure no one was watching. He pointed his hand at the handle. "Alohomora."
The lock gave a soft click as it yielded, and Sirius stepped inside.
The bathroom was empty. The only sound was the drip of water from the tap. In the corner of the room, between the toilet and the marble wall, a small tuxedo cat was curled up. The watery blue eyes of Scarlett’s Animagus form scrutinised him, pupils blown wide, ears flattened, fur bristling.
Apprehension and relief tangled within him.
Even with fur and claws, there was something painfully human in those wide blue eyes.
"Ah, Whiskers…" Sirius exhaled with a hiss, his voice excruciatingly tender.
He sat down on the cold stone floor, leaning back against the wall with a long sigh. He stretched one leg out and bent the other. Then he extended his hand and waited.
The cat hesitated, but soon padded closer, settling into his lap. Her feathery tail curled around his wrist as he wrapped his arms around her. He stroked her with tattooed fingers, resting his chin atop the cat’s head.
"I know… I know…" he whispered, trying to soothe her. "I know, Whiskers."
Whiskers gave way to Scarlett.
She sat in Sirius’s lap, curled in on herself, arms wrapped around her bent legs, gripping so tightly it looked as though she might snap them. Her head hung low, eyes fixed on her knees, and her entire body shook with tremors.
Sirius pulled her closer. He scattered a dozen kisses across her temple, murmuring reassuring words in her ear, trying to comfort her with his presence alone.
And slowly, very slowly—he had no idea how much time had passed—he felt her muscles begin to loosen. Her breathing, though still uneven, was no longer quite so shallow.
When he felt she might be ready, Sirius slipped his hand beneath her chin and gently lifted her face, making her look at him.
"I used to hit him." Her voice came out cracked and haunted.
The bathroom lights shimmered in Scarlett’s ocean-blue eyes like ships adrift in a storm-tossed sea.
"Who?" Sirius brushed his thumb over her cheek in an affectionate caress.
"Regulus." She confessed. Tears pricked her eyes, blurring Sirius’s face just inches from hers.
Sirius drew his brows together, a note of bewilderment marking the crease between them.
"I hit you as well." Scarlett continued, ignoring the tightness trying to strangle her words. "When you were drunk."
Sirius filled his lungs with air, drawing in Scarlett’s intoxicating scent in the process. He tried to clear his mind, to assemble arguments, to drag forward some fragment of the past that might confirm what she was saying, but—
He merely exhaled, fighting the corrosion threatening to gnaw through his sanity. Which, he had to admit, was not enough.
Why had his heart begun pounding violently in his ears, each beat stabbing at him?
Sirius turned his head towards the other side of the bathroom. His gaze fixed on the dripping sink, though he did not truly see it. All he could see were the faded memories in his mind, waltzing around his consciousness in their vicious cycle, without beginning, middle or end.
Don’t make me hate you, Sirius. Loving you is painful enough. Scarlett’s voice echoed against the walls of his skull and, for some reason, he tasted blood in his mouth. He tried to grasp the fragments that drifted close enough to reach, but they were slippery. Fragile, dissolving too easily.
He swallowed hard. His stomach burned. His arms pulled Scarlett even closer and his face buried itself in her hair, finding comfort in the very person who had once been his tormentor.
"Do you still love me? Do you still want to be with me?" Scarlett asked, her insecurity now so raw it hollowed out his chest.
"Did I ever hit you?" Sirius shot back, turning abruptly to face her, though he feared and already knew the answer.
"You raised your hand to me once. You didn’t actually strike me… but… but I… I…" She began to sob, shaken by deep gulps of air as tears soaked the hand cupping her cheek.
"Scarlett… look at me." He demanded, imprisoning her blue eyes with his own. "When I told you I forgave you… I meant everything. Everything that happened between us." He pressed his forehead to hers. "I love you. In spite of myself… in spite of us. In spite of everything. And however much I try, that isn’t going to change."
"I love you too, Sirius… I’ll never stop loving you. I wasn’t… I wasn’t lying when I said I’d never feel this for anyone else again. I can’t love anyone but you…" Scarlett gasped, her voice trembling.
In answer, he kissed her. A fleeting touch of lips that dismissed any disagreement, reluctance or rebuttal. They remained in a comfortable silence for a moment, even with a tonne pressing down on their shoulders. Both staring at the dripping sink. When the seventh drop fell, Sirius released a slow breath.
"Are you feeling better?"
"I am." She replied, though it had not been her intention. The surprise was evident in her voice. "I think so."
Sirius tightened his arms around her.
"Do you want to go back to the room? Want me to make up some excuse?"
Scarlett searched the starlit eyes in the half-light, their surface reflecting the conflicting emotions gradually settling inside her.
"No, I just… I didn’t want them to see me like that." Her fingers traced the roughness of Sirius’s beard and he closed his eyes, focusing on the caress.
"They only saw a mum who went to the loo." He murmured, dragging his face along her fingers and kissing them softly.
No. They had seen more than that. But Scarlett did not wish to argue.
"You found me too quickly."
"I will always find you."
Scarlett laughed and drew in a deep, unhindered breath. The feeling of being in his arms, of hearing his voice, meeting his eyes, touching his hands and face, the feeling of loving him and being loved by him renewed itself with the same fervour as the warmth surrounding them, as did the hope of spending her life by his side.
"Shall we have lunch?" Sirius brushed his lips along the base of her ear, making her lift her shoulder in mock defence.
She nodded shyly.
.
.
.
The salty breeze from the English Channel licked along the edges of the promenade, spreading the scent of sea and caramelised sugar from the stalls. The sky was clear, streaked white by a solitary aeroplane. The sun, now lower, cast its gold across the blue-black surface of the waves, which sprayed foam as they broke along the shore.
Scarlett and Sirius walked side by side along the seafront. The wind blew fiercely. Sirius’s long, loose black hair caressed his face, sliding across the tense lines of his expression.
Ahead of them, Reggie helped Harry balance on the skateboard. The two laughed, stumbled and caught their breath as they stretched their arms out to feel the sea breeze. Scarlett’s eyes were fixed on them, though she was not truly there.
"Are you really certain?" Sirius asked, keeping his eyes on the sea. "You’re leaving the band?"
Scarlett brushed the sunglasses hanging from the collar of her blouse, meaning to put them on. Then she let her arm fall. Her fingers grazed Sirius’s. He did not pull his hand away.
"I am." She said after a long stretch of silence. "I’ve thought a lot about what you said… about me having to go to places with the band where I used to drink and… you’re right, Sirius. I can’t remember a single show I played sober. Not one. And after turning up with a black eye after the last one…"
She did not finish, but Sirius read the fear in the unspoken words. His grey eyes lifted to her troubled face. The silvery ring around his irises narrowed as his pupils widened. A vein stood out in his neck.
"You…" Sirius very much wanted to ask something, but a fraction of hesitation was enough for the words to die in his mouth. "Do you know where you’re going to live?"
It was not what he had intended to ask, but fear mixed with cowardice flooded his lungs and vibrated along his vocal cords faster than he could stop it.
Scarlett clenched her jaw. The sea breeze blew a bleached strand of hair from her face and she did not bother to fix it.
"Not yet." She lowered her gaze to the asphalt pavement, dissipating the frustration threatening to rise in her chest. "I’ve been thinking…" she continued after a moment, watching Reggie help Harry climb onto the skateboard again. "About using the tour money to open a studio. Recording synthesizers, pianos… I’ll stay away from the stage and become a session musician."
Sirius threaded his fingers through hers, fitting their hands together as though they had been made for one another.
"We can start looking for a place like that as soon as we’re back."
Scarlett answered with a nod. She moved closer to him, almost brushing shoulders, squeezing his hand. Feeling the roughness of his fingers and the cold press of his rings against her skin.
"So… if anyone asks whether I’m a police officer… you’re going to say yes." Sirius warned, releasing her hand to twist his unruly hair into a careless bun.
Scarlett arched her brows in disbelief.
"Since when are you a police officer?!"
Sirius laced his fingers with hers again and slipped his free hand into the pocket of his shorts. He withdrew a small black leather case and held it out to her. Scarlett frowned before accepting it.
The sun flashed against the engraved metal: a silver badge in the shape of a seven-pointed star enamelled in dark blue. At its centre, the royal coat of arms beneath St Edward’s Crown gleamed, and around it were the words: Special Branch — Metropolitan Police. Below, a small identification plate bore fine lettering:
Home Office Liaison — S.O. Black.
"Since they gave me a badge, obviously." He revealed his dimples as he smiled, squinting against the sun. "Aurors who work in London get one of these in case there’s any trouble on the streets…"
Scarlett shifted her gaze between the badge and Sirius.
"Home Office Liaison…" she murmured, frowning. "Sirius… that’s British intelligence!" She let out a laugh that was almost swallowed by the wind.
"Intelligence what?" He lifted his brows, visibly pleased with himself. "I thought it was just, you know, fancy London police. They gave me the badge and told me to show it if anyone asked questions."
"Merlin’s balls…" Scarlett pressed a hand to her forehead, still laughing in disbelief. "You’re an MI5 agent. Basically a government spy!"
"Oh, brilliant." He tilted his nose upward in that arrogant way only he could manage. "So technically, you’re married to a secret agent."
Scarlett burst into laughter, resting her head on his shoulder.
"I cannot believe you’re walking around pretending to be a spy."
"Secret agent." He corrected her seriously, earning an eye-roll.
They gradually slowed their pace.
"Are you happy?" she asked.
Sirius shrugged one shoulder in time with his crooked smile.
"I don’t know. I think so. Sometimes…" He shook his head slightly, as if to clear it. "What about you, happy being in music?"
"Musician." Scarlett corrected, pressing her lips together. The sun reflected off the damp paving stones of the promenade, forcing her to lift a hand to shield her eyes. "I should be. But the alcoholism… it feels like it wants to ruin everything. Even the thing I love most."
Sirius slipped the badge away, but kept looking at her. Scarlett held her breath beneath that intense stare, so overwhelming it felt as though it dissected her body and turned her soul inside out.
"I found out what happened to you at your last show. With your eye."
She stopped walking. So did Sirius.
Scarlett blinked, lips parted, thoughts drifting through his sentence, trying to decipher what lay beneath it. The chill that coiled through her insides made her straighten. Bile threatened to rise in her throat.
"Do you want to know?"
She looked away. The sea was still there, rolling over the pebbles. Cars, bicycles and children moved along the road beside them, sirens echoing in the distance, the sound of a harmonica drifting from some street performer. Ahead, Reggie was pushing Harry on the skateboard, laughing loudly, gesturing animatedly. On a nearby bench, Lily, James and Regulus sat in their swimwear, eating ice cream.
Scarlett filled her lungs and released the air slowly. She looked back at Sirius, at her star-eyed, dark-haired man.
"No." she answered simply.
Hand in hand, they resumed walking.
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 96: All that we’ve gained
Chapter Text
CLXIV
Sirius closed his eyes. He focused on the teeth of the combs grazing his scalp, on the slender, pale fingers winding through his soft strands, on the warm breath misting over the crown of his head.
"You’ve got more hair than I do and half the women in this hotel." Scarlett murmured, her subtle words slipping through his black locks.
His reply was to let the air escape through his nose with a soft hiss.
"How many greys?" he mumbled, a shiver prickling down his spine when Scarlett combed the hair at the top of his head again.
"I found three." She smiled.
Sirius grunted, adjusting his suit trousers, which did absolutely nothing to conceal his erection.
"Have you ever stopped to think we spent our entire twenties locked up in Azkaban?!" He tensed his shoulders, narrowing his eyes.
Sirius was seated in front of the bathroom mirror, the white ribbed shirt open over his lean chest, revealing part of his pectorals marked with ancient runes. He watched Scarlett’s reflection behind him, biting her lower lip and holding a handful of hairpins between her fingers.
"No." She lifted her gaze to meet his in the mirror.
"You haven’t changed at all. You still look…" Sirius moistened his lips. "You still look eighteen. And not… thirty-four?"
"Mm… I know…" Scarlett held a hairpin between her lips and threaded her fingers through his hair. "Can I do a braid and then a bun?"
"You can." Sirius didn’t take his eyes off her, watching her stitch the strands together. "I look thirty-four."
"I’d give you twenty-five at most." she replied, absorbed in her task.
"That’s because, despite looking young, your eyesight’s ancient…" Sirius huffed, folding his arms. "You can’t see the lines at the corners of my eyes."
"Sirius…" Scarlett let out a breath as she began another braid, now on the right side. "You’re still as handsome as ever."
No matter how tightly he pressed his lips together, a vain smile crept across his face and deepened his dimples.
"Oh, yeah?" He turned his face towards her, lifting his gaze to those ocean irises. "What do you think is handsome about me?"
Scarlett rolled her eyes, discarding his question and gripping his chin, forcing him to look back at the mirror as she twisted the two braids into a high bun, securing it with hairpins. The high collar of the shirt he was wearing would show off the hairstyle even more once it was buttoned up.
"Done." She ran her hand over his ears to make sure no strands had escaped and gave him two light pats on the shoulders.
"I think I’ll cut my hair when we get back." Sirius gave a lopsided smile as he rose from the chair. "I miss when yours was longer than mine. And when it was black."
"Don’t you think blonde suits me?!" Scarlett settled herself where he had been sitting and tossed her hair back.
"No." The sincerity in the simple reply made her let out a nasal little laugh. "Black looks far better on you."
Scarlett merely sucked on her lower lip and held her breath before lowering her eyes to her lap, her fingers toying with the fluffy belt of her white dressing gown.
"I asked Alaric to buy me something I think you’ll like. But… I’ll have to dye your hair black first." He went on, casually. "May I?"
She swallowed hard, uncomfortably, several times. The knot in her throat did not loosen, so she simply nodded.
Sirius drew his wand and whispered a spell. The bleached strands darkened, reaching the same deep black as his own. Scarlett felt her heart race and did everything she could to avoid looking at her reflection in the mirror.
Then he braided several thin sections and pinned the rest into a bun at the nape of her neck. He opened the dressing table drawer and took out a velvet package.
Scarlett frowned as he opened it. Inside were dozens of sterling silver hairpins studded with iridescent diamonds like stars.
"Was it expensive?" Scarlett touched one of them very slowly with the tip of her finger, careful. She did not want to damage them.
"Mhm." Sirius replied and a roguish smile deepened one of his dimples. "Sponsored by compensation from the Ministry of Magic."
Scarlett’s lips curved into the hint of a smile and her heart, already beating far too fast, quickened even more. Sirius fixed the ornaments among the braids and bun methodically, forming entire constellations with the tiny points of light.
"Finished." he murmured, admiring the result with a proud expression. "You can look in the mirror now."
Scarlett did not know why, but her eyes would not obey. Sirius was staring at her with such intensity that she was certain he could see her soul now, shattered through her tear-filled eyes.
She opened her mouth, but no sound came out. She clenched her jaw and stiffened her shoulders, bowing her head lower and lower. The urge to disappear consumed every other feeling, swelling so quickly that Scarlett felt strangled by it.
"I need help with my tie!" Reggie stuck his head through the crack in the bathroom door. "Oi, you’ve got a bath in your bathroom?! That’s wicked! Can I have a soak in it later?!"
"You’ve got a bath in your room as well." Sirius put his hands on his hips.
"It’s not as big as yours!" the boy insisted, nearly hugging the doorknob. His T-shirt was already crumpled.
"Negative, Reggie." Sirius sighed. "Go to the sitting room and I’ll do the knot on your tie…"
Regulus made the characteristic sound of a sulky teenager when told no and headed out of their bedroom.
Scarlett did not move. Sirius leaned down and kissed her hair. And she watched him, wordless, leave the bathroom.
She couldn’t look at herself. She couldn’t lift her eyes and see eighteen-year-old Scarlett about to open Pandora’s box and ruin everyone’s life. She held her breath for a moment and then released it in a trembling gasp, trying to keep herself under control. Her hands, however, were already shaking violently and the nausea rose up her oesophagus, spurring her throat.
She didn’t know how, but she left the bathroom.
Scarlett placed a hand against the wall to steady herself, keeping her eyes fixed on her own feet. She didn’t want anyone to see her like that. She didn’t want to be seen. She didn’t want to go to that bloody gala dinner.
Even so, she forced herself to leave the suite. She found Harry already dressed in a white shirt and black trousers, his bare feet on the carpet. He was trying to tame the stubbornness of his own hair in the mirror above the sideboard.
"Scar…" Harry called, catching sight of her in his peripheral vision. "Blimey, you dyed your hair. It looks good!" He smiled. The kind of smile that would warm anyone’s heart, but the effect on Scarlett’s was the opposite: it shrivelled, curling in on itself painfully. "Can you help me?"
Scarlett blinked hard and nodded. Nodded? She wasn’t certain she had actually moved her head, but she stepped closer to him all the same. She ran her hands through the dark strands, ignoring the heat of her own body gathering at her temples.
She used a straightening charm. The strands yielded… for half a second, before springing back and sticking out in every direction.
"Yeah… you inherited James’s hair." Scarlett whispered, forcing a smile. "There’s no brush, pomade or spell that’ll fix it, Harry."
Harry laughed shyly, glancing at her sideways through the mirror.
"You look pale, Scar. Are you feeling alright?"
She kept the smile that looked more like a grimace and shook her head frantically.
"I am, just a bit of a headache. It’s time to take the potions Penny sent as well… it’s nothing serious."
On the other side of the room, Sirius held the collar of Reggie’s white shirt with one hand while the other undid the tight knot of the silk tie.
"I don’t understand what you were trying to do here. Hang yourself?" he drawled, which made Reg arch his eyebrows and place a hand theatrically over his chest.
"It’s not like the bloody thing comes with an instruction manual!" He flicked his rebellious fringe back, but it fell straight over his forehead again.
"Right, the trick’s here." Sirius went on, unbothered by his fluster. "Cross over, under, fold the flaps, through the middle and pull." He demonstrated each step slowly, undoing it straight after. "Your turn."
"Ugh, seriously?! Couldn’t you just leave it done?!" Reggie grumbled. "We’re going to be here all night like this…"
Scarlett watched them from where she stood. The scene before her was framed in a honeyed haze: Sirius adjusting his son’s tie, Reggie huffing and complaining, Harry straightening the cuffs of his shirt. The ghosts watched the sea in the distance. She wanted to freeze that instant, lock it inside a glass locket, reflect it through a kaleidoscope, imprint it on her memory so she could remember that it was real. That she belonged there. That she deserved it.
She shivered. She did not know whether she was on the brink of redemption or destruction.
The sickness, however, swelled inside her chest and took shape when her stomach twisted. She cleared her throat and clapped a hand over her mouth. Backing into the suite, she dropped to her knees in front of the toilet and retched. Her body shook with chills and that familiar cold sweat returned, brushing her temples and spine.
She rose, still breathing unevenly. Leaning on the edge of the bath to reach the sink, she splashed water over her face, rinsed her mouth, scrubbed her teeth so hard her gums began to bleed. Then she lifted her gaze to her reflection.
There she was. Scarlett Gaunt, eighteen years old, staring back at her. Sirius and Remus had not lied when they said she had not aged at all, but it was different with another hair colour. It was almost a reminder that the version of her who had spent fifteen years in Azkaban was the blonde one and not… not the brunette. Not that Scarlett.
The air narrowed painfully in her chest. She did not want to be her. She did not want to suffer everything all over again, did not want to make the same choices, nor commit the same mistakes. She did not want to ruin everything, not when things were finally going well. They were working. She did not want to, did not want to and could not. She did not want to and she would not.
Her hands covered her head, fingers sinking into the intricate hairstyle. The sharp pricks biting into her palm dragged her back to reality while she blinked the tears away. She pulled her trembling hands from the black hair, black as the night sky… but that one, at least, was a sky full of stars.
The diamonds gleamed like midnight constellations, so bright she had to squint. She wiped the dampness from her eyes with the back of her hands, sniffling as she recognised the constellation of Canis Major crowning her head, Leo descending along the left side and Sagittarius on the right.
She closed her eyes and forced herself to breathe in through her nose and out through her mouth, counting to three. She looked at herself again. There was too much trapped inside her. Too many feelings. Too much confusion, hurt, anger, anguish, fear and despair. And no matter how much she tried to drink them down and bury them in the pit of her chest, they always found a way to rise at the worst possible moments.
She needed to let it all out. She simply had no idea how.
So, as always, Scarlett drew in a very deep breath, tucked every one of those feelings into their little velvet box and sank them into the most inhospitable and obscure corner of her heart, hoping they would not come calling that night.
She covered the pallor of her face with make-up and painted her lips red. She had no idea how to blend eyeshadow in any way that wasn’t haphazard like some rock star would, so she simply applied kohl liner, blusher and swapped the white dressing gown for a black velvet dress with a deep V neckline at the front and an open back. She used a charm to conceal her scars.
Scarlett gave herself one last look in the mirror before leaving the bathroom.
Sirius knew the exact second Scarlett returned to the sitting room. It was not because of the lurch his heart gave, nor because he felt the presence of her aura calling for his. It was not because the scent of vanilla invaded his nostrils or because her silhouette flowed across the mirrored surface beside him.
It was because he loved her. He loved her with tenderness and cruelty, with desire and resentment, forgiveness and fear. And the burn of that love spread through his core like the sun rising on the horizon, like the stars igniting at dusk, like clouds sailing across the sky… especially his cloud shaped like a girl with flowers in her hair.
Sirius stopped fastening the cuffs of Reggie’s dress coat, because all he could do was look at her, receive in his silver irises the hypnotising image of the woman with sea-mist eyes and star-strewn hair. It felt as though he were gazing at a beach at night, at pale sand, at the sea of Scarlett’s eyes beneath the star-scattered sky of her hair.
"I…" Sirius tried, but his voice failed. He moistened his lips and cleared his throat. "I’ve one more thing for you."
He went to the marble coffee table and picked up a velvet box. He opened it, revealing a necklace of black stones, a pair of earrings and a bracelet. The jewellery set he had given her… more than a decade ago.
The same ones she had worn to that idiotic Hogwarts ball when the two of them… when they…
The foolish smile crept across her face so slowly she had no time to stop it, nor the blush that rose to her cheeks.
Sirius stepped around her, placing the necklace carefully about her neck, his fingers brushing softly against her nape as he fastened the clasp. Her skin tingled at the loss of his touch and Scarlett drew in a breath when Sirius pressed a warm, delicate kiss there. As though trying to give form to the unspoken words and the emotions drifting between them.
Scarlett remained utterly still. He circled her, stopping in front of her and giving her the chance to admire his black evening tailcoat, double-breasted with satin lapels. She pretended to adjust the button of his brocade waistcoat, feeling the smoothness of the fabric beneath her fingertips. The silver rings he wore clashed with the formality of his attire, yet only heightened his irreverent beauty.
"You look stunning, love." He murmured, fastening the bracelet around her wrist. He lifted her hand to his lips and kissed it very slowly.
"Yeah… we do look rather dashing tonight." Scar finally said, her voice trembling and her face burning.
Reggie slipped into his tuxedo. His bow tie sat tight in a perfect knot over a white ribbed shirt like Sirius’s.
"Blah blah blah, too much romance, can we get a move on before we’re late…" he groaned, making a gagging sound.
Harry laughed and pulled on his graphite suit with burgundy detailing. He put on his brand-new shoes, never worn before, and ran a hand through his hair, trying once again to flatten it, but it was hopeless.
The front door opened and Alaric appeared, imposing in his equally impeccable attire. He adjusted the gloves on his hands and offered a courteous smile, though he seemed momentarily taken aback by the sudden change in Scarlett’s hair colour.
"Mr Black, Mrs Black… young masters." He gave a subtle bow. "The event is about to begin. I shall be responsible for your table. Do you require anything before we depart?"
"I do." Sirius strode back to the table and picked up his Polaroid. "I want you to take plenty of photos tonight. Starting now."
"As you wish, Mr Black."
The four of them gathered together. Sirius slid his tattooed hand around Scarlett’s waist and pulled her closer. He draped his other arm over Harry’s shoulder. Reggie positioned himself beside his mother and she gripped his shoulder.
"Smile!" Alaric instructed.
Flash.
Scarlett blinked several times, disoriented.
"Bloody hell, I’m blind…" Reggie complained, rubbing his eyes.
"That Polaroid must be about fifty years old…" Harry joked, earning a laugh from Sirius.
"I got it from Andromeda for my seventeenth birthday…" He shrugged. "But it still works like it’s brand new!"
"Follow me, sir." Alaric slipped the camera strap over his neck and gestured ahead.
Sirius offered her his arm.
"Shall we, Mrs Black?"
.
.
.
Scarlett descended one step at a time, guided by Sirius’s arm and by the blood pounding in her ears, anxious and unsteady. Her feet wobbled in the thin-heeled sandals and she wondered why the fuck she had chosen such idiotic shoes.
The Brighton Hotel’s grand ballroom was vast and glittering, its arched windows rising from floor to ceiling, framed by burgundy curtains cascading down in heavy folds, following the line of the seafront visible beyond: the reflection of dark waves mirrored in the glass panels. Enormous crystal chandeliers hung above them, scattering light over guests in tailcoats and long gowns. Round tables draped in white linen were spread across the space, decorated with arrangements of lilies and orchids in silver vases.
A jazz band, set up on a raised stage to the left, played a refined cover of Fly Me To The Moon. The musicians wore white tuxedos with black collars, and the trumpeter had a Panama hat tipped at a rakish angle.
Scarlett’s eyes travelled across the vaulted ceiling, the gilded paintings, the gleaming candelabra. The opulence of the place was so overwhelming it made her feel increasingly out of place.
"Impressive." Sirius murmured at her side, his deep voice so low it slithered along her collarbone in a shiver. He tilted his head and glanced at her sideways. "But you’re still the most beautiful girl here."
The flutter in her stomach made her tremble. She could not hold his gaze for long; her face, already warm, now burned.
"Spare us, please." Reggie muttered, shoving his hands into the pockets of his black tailored trousers, clearly uncomfortable.
Harry simply watched. The lights and pompous decorations slid across the lenses of his glasses as he turned his head.
Alaric guided them to a table near the dance floor, with a privileged view of the stage and where the sea, swallowed by night, could be seen through the half-drawn curtains. Scarlett’s chair was pulled back courteously and Sirius settled beside her. The boys sat opposite each other.
"Mr and Mrs Black, young masters." Alaric bowed after pouring the water. "Would you like wine to accompany dinner?"
"Yes." Sirius replied automatically.
Scarlett’s eyes widened when the crystal glass was placed before her. It felt as though she had just taken a punch to the stomach at the mere sight of the wine bottle the butler carried. Sirius placed a hand over the rim of her glass, stopping Alaric from filling it.
"Ah, I’d forgotten. She can’t drink." He offered an awkward smile. Scarlett shot him a murderous look. He cleared his throat and added, "She’s pregnant."
Harry and Reggie looked at Scarlett, then at Sirius, then back at her.
"What?!" they demanded in unison.
"Oh! My congratulations! Would madam like a non-alcoholic drink?" Alaric asked, withdrawing the wine bottle.
"You can bring one for me and one for her… strawberry?" Sirius looked at Scarlett.
"Mhm." With raised brows, she agreed without opening her mouth.
"Very good." The butler stepped away.
"Thank you." Scarlett whispered, though the weight of shame and the thirst that always came with the mention of alcohol throbbed painfully in her brain.
"You’re welcome." Sirius replied without looking at her. He squeezed her knee beneath the table.
"What’s this about pregnancy?!" Reg insisted, his voice climbing two octaves.
Harry kept shifting his gaze between Sirius and Scarlett. He suddenly stood from the table and scratched the back of his neck.
"I need… er… I need some air." he muttered, and Reggie followed him.
Scarlett and Sirius watched them cross the ballroom. They stopped beside the stage and Harry covered his face with his hands in an embarrassed gesture.
"Bloody hell, Reg… Sirius and Scar… they… they did…"
"What?!" Regulus folded his arms, completely lost.
"Sex! They had sex!"
Reggie let out a sound of pure disgust.
"I do not need reminding that they shag!" he huffed.
"Wait, you already knew that?!" Harry planted his hands on his hips.
"Course I did, what d’you think they do alone in their bedroom?!" Regulus frowned as though it were obvious.
"Watch… er… telly?!" Harry adjusted his glasses on the bridge of his nose.
"Sweet Salazar, Harry…" Reggie shifted his attention to the band. "Do you think it’s true?"
"No… I don’t know." Harry shrugged. "I don’t think so."
"Yeah… I don’t think so either." Regulus sucked on his lower lip. He glanced at his parents, then back at the band. "Fancy doing something funny?"
Harry’s eyes narrowed suspiciously.
"What?"
The non-alcoholic drinks had already arrived when the two of them returned to the table. The music shifted; the piano leapt into a swing rhythm and the double bass followed. One of the vocalists stepped up to the microphone, smiling.
"Ladies and gentlemen." he drawled, his crooner’s voice dragging the syllables charmingly. "We have a very special couple with us tonight." He inclined his head towards their table. "Celebrating fifteen years of marriage!"
Scarlett choked on her drink. Sirius frowned and shot a stunned look at Reggie and Harry, who were far too busy trying not to laugh.
"Exemplary parents… and very young too, I might add." the vocalist continued, drawing chuckles from the nearby guests.
Harry and Reggie were openly laughing now. Scarlett shot them a lethal glare, but she was far too flushed to seem truly threatening as she dabbed her face with a napkin. Her eyes widened in horror.
"I’m going to kill you both." she hissed through her teeth.
As if the situation were not ridiculous enough, the song the band began to perform made Scarlett stiffen, terror now blending with embarrassment.
[George Michael — Careless Whisper]
Scarlett sank lower in her chair. She wanted to evaporate. She wished she could remember how to Apparate without splinching, or perhaps cast a Blasting Curse and open a crater in the floor to crawl into. She swallowed hard. She would have hidden beneath the table if every eye in the ballroom had not been fixed on her.
"I’m not." she whispered, turning pale without even parting her lips.
"You are." Sirius rose and extended his hand with insufferable gallantry. "I’m a secret agent. You don’t want me to arrest you, do you?" The question dripped with mischief.
Scarlett wanted to point out that he was not a policeman, yet she could not stop the smile spreading across her mouth.
"Sirius…"
"It’s just a dance, Scarlett." He dismissed the plea with a roll of his eyes.
Her list of excuses had run out and, noticing her hesitation, Sirius tugged her hand. Scarlett stood with a resigned sigh, allowing herself to be led to the centre of the ballroom, her ankles struggling not to betray her in those stupid heels while her heart threatened to crack her ribs with the force of it.
Sirius positioned himself in front of her, slipped a warm hand around her bare lower back and drew her closer without the slightest modesty. His body brushed against hers, their breaths mingling, the world blurring at the edges where their gazes met.
Scarlett straightened, her entire body going rigid.
"I don’t remember how to dance." she almost whimpered, though there were no tears in her eyes.
"But I never forgot." Sirius whispered, his lips far too close to her ear. "Relax, love. Just follow me."
"Sirius, it’s been a long time…"
"Dancing’s like walking, Scar." His warm breath brushed her neck. "Once you learn, you never forget."
Scarlett did not know if that was true, but it did not matter. Sirius guided her with the ease of someone who had stood in many ballrooms, at many dances and in many arms — though none like hers.
Should’ve known better, yeah…
The entire hall was watching, but Scarlett saw only Sirius. Only his star-bright eyes that matched perfectly with his twilight-dark hair. Only his sharp nose and sculpted lips; his angular chin and pronounced jaw.
She could not help wondering what their lives might have been like if she had never left. With her and Sirius raising Reg, with James and Lily raising Harry. No Voldemort and no war, just the two of them building the family and the future they had once dreamed of together. A future destroyed, worn thin and shattered. And yet it was all she had in that moment, even if her fingers were raw from trying to piece those shards back together.
Would she and Sirius have stayed together until that day? Would Reggie be the same boy, or entirely different with her interference? And Harry… what would he have been like if James and Lily had never gone?
I feel so unsure
As I take your hand and lead you to the dance floor
As the music dies, something in your eyes
Calls to mind a silver screen
And all its sad goodbyes
It was… strange. To come face to face with the severed threads of fate that had once been a possibility, yet would never become reality.
She swayed slightly. As romantic as the melody of Careless Whisper might be, with its sensual saxophone and aching lyrics, Scarlett knew it was about betrayal. And it hurt. It felt as though it had been written for them and them alone. The mistakes, the kisses, the shouting, the addictions, the apologies and the desperate urge to try again.
It spoke of what they had been.
Of what they might have been, too.
Scarlett lowered her gaze to Sirius’s shoulder, fixing it there, feeling like a castaway adrift in a sea of memories.
What would it have been like if… if they had still stayed together?
Sirius spun her slowly and Scarlett closed her eyes.
"James was right. My love for you is my ruin." Scarlett murmured as she snapped the watch shut, pushing Sirius against the wall.
"Scar… don’t… please…" he begged in a whisper, fear intoxicating his body as fiercely as alcohol ever had.
Scarlett looked at the door. Then back at Sirius. A choice. She knew very well what the outcome would be if she walked through that door.
That was why she stayed.
Sirius gave up drinking. When she told him she was pregnant, he gave up drinking. They married in the autumn of 1978 as they had planned, and Reggie was born in due time, at the beginning of 1979. She never murdered the McKinnons. Regulus died after saving Orfy and destroying Voldemort’s horcrux.
By staying with Sirius, Scarlett accepted that his fate was already sealed and there was nothing to be done. Orfeu lived and grew up with her, even after everything he had suffered. She cared for him and loved him as fiercely as her parents had loved her. James and Lily married in 1979, and she and Sirius were their best man and maid of honour, just as they were for Harry after he was born the following year.
Scarlett was the Potters’ Secret Keeper, and they fought together in the war as they should have done. As it had always been meant to be, until Voldemort was defeated and the Death Eaters were destroyed.
Harry was a loving and confident boy. Reggie, reserved and understanding.
There would be no Grimmauld Place: no tear-soaked nights, no harrowing nightmares, no destructive relief. There would be no Azkaban, no torture, no scars. The traumas she carried would be only those of Dimitri and of losing her parents.
Scarlett squeezed her eyelids shut, not daring to abandon the safety of her darkness. She could not stop dancing, nor could she stop feeling the barbed guilt of love clutching her heart in its merciless fist. She was driven by something far stronger than will, resentment or agony.
Never without your love…
If once she had drowned herself in alcohol to forget, now she intoxicated herself with her perfect fantasy to remember. To punish herself. To resent that utopian future, everything they might have been, everything that was lost. Everything left behind.
Reggie and Harry were best friends and would grow up side by side. Sirius and she had more children, though they waited longer for that. He began his career as an Auror and she as a musician.
And then, on Scarius’s fifteenth anniversary, they truly were there. Celebrating with their friends and family.
Tonight the music seems so loud
I wish that we could lose this crowd
Maybe it's better this way
We'd hurt each other with the things we'd want to say
Sirius rose from the table of honour and tapped his fork against his crystal glass, drawing everyone’s attention. His black hair was tied back in a bun, though much of it had already escaped to his nape. Threads of grey were visible here and there, only adding to his charm. His silver eyes searched for Scarlett on the other side of the hall, seated beside Lily and a girl whose pink hair matched that of the little child in her lap.
A dimpled, lovestruck smile curved his lips with tenderness. He lifted his glass towards her.
We could have been so good together
We could have lived this dance forever
But now who's gonna dance with me?
Please, stay!
"I want to thank everyone who came today to celebrate the incredible fifteen years I’ve spent beside the love of my life…" His voice faltered with emotion, forcing him to pause. "The woman who gave me four wonderful children and the chance to have the loving and respectful family I always dreamed of."
"And gran—!" James tried to add, but Sirius silenced him by clapping a hand over his mouth.
Scarlett smiled and lifted her chin. Lily fanned her face with a hand fan, trying to help her hold back her tears. She failed and had to dab her eyes with a handkerchief already soaked through.
"I promised her I’d make a proper toast tonight." Sirius went on, revelling in the sight of his flushed, emotional wife, his heart pounding in his chest. "But, as you all know, this woman has a dreadful habit of stealing my words whenever she looks this beautiful."
Laughter rippled through the room.
"So I’ll just say this: kitten, thank you for not walking away. Thank you for staying. Thank you for choosing me. Again and again."
(Now that you're gone) now that you're gone
(Now that you're gone) what I did's so wrong, so wrong
That you had to leave me alone
Sirius, for his part, did not look away for a single second. He stared at her with devotion. It was Scarlett there, alive, in his arms, dancing beneath the constellations he himself had pinned into her hair.
"What are you thinking about, kitten?" Sirius pulled her from her reverie.
"All that we’ve lost." Scarlett felt the tears burn at the corners of her eyes, but she did not lift her head from his chest. "And you?"
She opened her eyes again, meeting his: silver, flickering like stars and as intense as a rainbow after a storm.
"All that we’ve gained." Sirius glanced towards Harry and Reg laughing and talking at the table, beside the ghostly silhouettes of James, Lily and Regulus.
They came to a stop in the centre of the ballroom. Sirius bent towards her, pressing a tender kiss to her forehead. The smile that slipped from her lips was genuine. She could hear the pounding of her own heart; or was that wild, furious sound coming from Sirius’s chest?
She could not tell.
Her illusion dissolved at the edge of reality, blending with the time that had passed and the opportunity she had seized. Applause circled them and Scarlett tightened her arms around Sirius’s neck, burying her face in his chest once more. He kissed the Scarius tattoo on her arm and stroked it with his thumb, keeping the smile lingering on her face.
"Well… and with that dance, we can officially say there are many more happy years ahead. Mr and Mrs Black, thank you for reminding us that love can still be beautiful! We wish you an incredible evening, and the same to all of you! Now, back to our musical programme…"
They returned to the table, where Reggie and Harry were pretending to be bored. Scarlett adjusted her dress before sitting down, still with a faint blush on her cheeks.
"Fifteen years, is it?!" Scarlett arched her brows as she sat. "You two just wait!"
"Oh, Mum, what?!" Reggie twisted his lips into the perfect mix of innocence and cheek. "We just helped create an unforgettable memory!" He elbowed Harry.
"Y-yeah… it’s true!" Harry bounced slightly in his chair, knocking his knees against the table.
"You’re grounded!" Scarlett declared, pointing a finger at her son.
"Love… no need to be dramatic. It was just a harmless joke." Sirius settled beside her, resting his arm along the back of her chair.
"Grounded?!" Reg and Harry exclaimed in unison.
Alaric appeared at the table, seemingly oblivious to what was unfolding — or perhaps already accustomed to family squabbles.
"Ladies and gentlemen, dinner will now be served. To begin, a velouté of wild mushrooms, followed by asparagus risotto with beef medallions in Dijon sauce. For the young masters, there is also the option of handmade ravioli with tomato and basil."
The four of them stared at the butler in complete silence.
"What’s velouté?" Harry whispered, leaning towards Reggie.
The boy did not want to drop the matter of being grounded, but a look from Sirius dissuaded him. He wasn’t sure whether it meant leave the beast to me or you’re fucked, mate. He sincerely hoped it was the first.
"No idea, sounds like a perfume." Reggie replied, and the two of them clapped their hands over their mouths to stifle their laughter.
"Your grandmother is turning in her grave right now because you don’t know what that is…" Sirius dragged his chair closer to Scarlett and rested his chin on her shoulder.
"Is that good or bad?!" Reggie leaned back in his seat, folding his arms.
"Good. Definitely good." Sirius nodded, which only made the boy more confused.
"But what is it?!" Harry removed his glasses and wiped them on the hem of his jacket.
"Velouté means velvety in French." Scarlett explained, trying to ignore Sirius’s warm breath brushing kisses against her neck. "It’s a sauce with a velvety texture."
Uniformed waiters began to circulate among the tables, placing the dishes neatly before each guest. The earthy aroma of fresh mushrooms made Scarlett’s mouth water, along with the scent of truffles and cream.
"Looks like soup." Harry muttered, peering at the shallow bowl: a dense, silky cream the colour of ivory, dotted with emerald drops of olive oil and shavings of sautéed mushrooms in the centre.
"Could’ve come with a baguette." Reggie commented, tasting a spoonful. He paused, closed his eyes and furrowed his brows. "Right… I take that back. This is bloody brilliant."
Scarlett laughed, twirling her water glass between her fingers before taking a sip. She waited a moment for the liquid to settle, expecting her stomach to protest, but nothing happened. Even so, she remained wary of her own recovery. It felt as though the discomfort might return at any second.
She let the air leave her lungs slowly and felt Sirius’s gaze studying her from the corner of his eye.
"They’re still grounded." she murmured, knowing exactly what was running through his mind.
Sirius laughed as well, dabbing his mouth and beard with a napkin.
"Mrs Black, please allow me to begin the defence of the accused." He retrieved one of the Polaroids Alaric had taken moments earlier. The photograph showed the two of them dancing: Scarlett with her face buried in his chest, while he smiled, eyes fixed on her. "Exhibit one."
"Sirius…" Scarlett bit her lower lip, but failed to stop the smile returning.
"Exhibit two." He picked up another Polaroid: the four of them gathered together before leaving the suite for dinner. The exuberant expressions, the sparkling eyes and the way James, Lily and Regulus had leaned over from the neighbouring table to look at the photo made Scarlett’s heart skip several beats and her stomach fill with butterflies.
James wiped the tears from the corners of his eyes, Lily pressed a hand to her heart and Regulus drew into himself, as he so often did in his many moments of introspection.
Dessert arrived in small oval bowls resting on white porcelain saucers. On a creamy base of vanilla and dark specks of pod sat a sphere of bittersweet chocolate. The moment the red berry sauce was poured over it, the outer shell melted slowly, revealing a heart of salted caramel.
"Wow…" Harry murmured.
"Yeah, that’s what being rich means, Harry." Reggie teased.
Sirius laughed. Scarlett did not.
She watched the faint steam from the sauce rise like mist on a winter morning, dissolving into the air. As fragile as the chocolate surrendering to the warm sweetness was that moment, because the hum at the back of her mind insisted on reminding her of everything that still stood between her and Sirius. Between her and Reggie. Between her and Harry.
She clenched her fist around the stem of her water glass.
For a moment, she felt ridiculous. Foolish. Defeated by a pair of star-bright eyes and a mountain of regrets she could no longer even name. There were so many. From so many places, so many years, so many scars, it seemed impossible to trace them back to their source.
Perhaps it was the boys’ laughter. The joy shimmering in Harry’s eyes. Or the way Reggie, trying to look aloof, could not quite hide the gleam of wonder. Perhaps it was Sirius’s touch at her waist when he finished his dessert, his thumb tracing slow circles over her iliac bone, his presence clinging to her, telling her that was where she belonged. Where she had always belonged: in his arms.
Scarlett swallowed hard. Sirius’s sweet scent mingled with the floral arrangement on the table, with the salty dampness drifting through the half-open window, with the good humour of her false husband at her side.
All of it was real. Not a mirage, not a daydream conjured in the heat of a dance where tired bodies sought shelter in one another.
Her recovery did not feel like the end of her suffering, but… at the same time… it was the beginning of something. Something new, possible. Of now.
"Alright. You’re off the hook this time." Scarlett relented, making Reg and Harry slap hands in celebration and Sirius pull her even closer. "But next time, you’re grounded. No video games."
"Yes, ma’am!" Reggie snapped a salute and Harry merely shot Sirius a grateful look.
.
.
.
The balcony of the Grand Brighton Hotel ballroom was washed in salty breeze, carrying the scent of sea air and freshly watered flowers from the garden below. The music from inside slipped through the half-open doors, muffled but recognisable: Misty, most likely. Ella Fitzgerald’s version.
Sirius lit another cigarette. The fourth of the night. He smoked slowly, elbows resting on the wrought-iron railing, watching the scene unfolding in the ballroom.
Scarlett and Harry were dancing.
She spun with a certain grace, her star-strewn black hair shimmering in resonance with the crystal chandeliers, her bare back outlined beneath the black dress. Harry smiled, enchanted, his steps still clumsy as he tried to imitate what he had seen his godfather do earlier. Sirius could not prevent the taste of continuity that dance brought to his tongue. Closure, too.
"I taught her to dance…" A voice echoed beside him, from another plane. James took a drag from his cigarette with exaggerated elegance, blowing smoke rings that dissolved into the chimerical wind. He leaned against Sirius’s shoulder, but the gesture passed through him like mist. "Now she’s teaching Harry. Who’d have thought you two would end up together again, eh, Padfoot?!"
James laughed. Sirius did not answer. Smoke slipped from his silent lips in soft, melancholic exhalations. The moon, sailing above the sea, carved his silhouette against the night’s glow, turning him into a shadow rimmed with silver.
Inside, Lily and Regulus were dancing as well. Slowly, laughing together. Regulus. Laughing. With Lily.
What a strange reality they inhabited.
The world felt suspended inside a crystal sphere.
"Remember when we chose you, to the surprise of absolutely no one, to be Harry’s godfather…" James went on, his voice thick with a longing marked by time. He tried again to rest his face against Sirius’s shoulder, but his touch went straight through. "You panicked because he needed a godmother too. Went out clubbing to find a bird and came back with a new tattoo over your heart."
James laughed louder and the sound echoed between the balcony columns. Sirius simply lowered his head, staring at his perfectly polished shoes. The silence stretched between them, not uncomfortable. James was accustomed to the solitude of the living.
Sirius took the watch from the inner pocket of his tailcoat: old, gold, its lid marked by scattered scratches. It chimed softly as he opened it. It was always that photograph. James beaming, Harry in his arms. Lily wrapped around them. Reggie still a baby, clinging to his neck. Remus seated on the floor and Peter… Peter was only a burnt silhouette, a black hole in the image.
He ran his thumb over his best friend’s smiling face. A sad smile touched his lips. With his other hand, still holding the cigarette between his index and middle fingers, he loosened his tie. He knew it would not help, but at least it allowed him to steady his breathing into a slow, deliberate rhythm.
Inhaling. Exhaling.
"He looks so much like you, Prongs…" His voice vibrated through the warmth of that summer night.
"Reg does too, Padfoot. You know that, don’t you?"
Sirius did not reply, his eyes fixed on the magical photograph, still moving, still repeating that moment lost in time. Sirius bouncing Reggie, Lily laughing, James holding Harry in his arms.
"We suspected it more than once, back then, but…" James kept his lips parted, moistening them before he continued. "We were so bloody angry at Scar that…" He closed his mouth and twisted it. "Only now… now it’s different and… it’s impossible that you’ve never considered… that he might be yours."
The snap of the watch clicking shut was Sirius’s answer. His gaze returned to the ballroom. Reggie was seated now, a glass of non-alcoholic drink in hand, his expression absorbed in the sight of his mother dancing with Harry, his eyes catching every step they took.
"I wish he were mine." Sirius admitted, his voice almost vanishing.
"Why haven’t you realised yet that he is?"
The question hung between them, veiled in cigarette smoke.
Sirius lowered his eyes again, crushed the cigarette against the stone parapet and brought his hands to his face. He rubbed his eyes hard. His chin trembled, his shoulders taut.
"I miss you." he confessed, his voice breaking. Rough. The words took effort, like someone speaking again after years of silence.
"I miss you too, Padfoot." James whispered, softer than he had. "I miss you too."
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧
Chapter 97: There’s nothing in our way, my love
Chapter Text
CLXV
Scarlett, seated at the bathroom dressing table, removed pin after pin from her hair, gradually releasing the strands that spilled down the nape of her neck in jet-black tendrils. The boys were already in their respective beds. She had helped Regulus take off his tie before he strangled himself in his sleep while Sirius carried a Harry far too tired to walk to his room.
Now, there she was.
Accompanied by her teenage, black-haired reflection in the mirrored surface beside her, stacking the crystal pendants into their velvet box. Her face was already free of make-up, which only accentuated her pallor.
She caught sight of Sirius entering the bathroom, no tie and his shirt open halfway down his chest. His hair was loose already, a midnight cascade of waves over his shoulders and back. He leaned against the wall behind her, watching her through the mirror’s reflection.
She did not need to look at him to know where his attention lay. The charm concealing the scars on her back had worn off, and they were painfully visible because of the deep V cut of her dress.
Scarlett shrank into the chair. She felt something tear inside her chest. Her heart, most likely, though she had grown so accustomed to the sensation that it was curious she still noticed it.
She swallowed very slowly.
"You…" Her voice faltered. She scratched at her Ouroboros. "You… do you still… still want me?"
Sirius let out a disconcerted laugh. That dimpled laugh that made her forget the most basic things, like how to breathe or walk. Had she not been sitting down, she might have fallen flat on her arse.
"I have never wanted anything else, Scarlett." He shot back hoarsely, fixing her with those fatal eyes. He pushed himself off the wall and cut the distance between them in half. "And you? Do you still want me?"
The question was so idiotic, because the answer was obvious. Scarlett felt foolish for having opened her mouth. Sirius had that power over her. He intimidated her with his cruel beauty and intoxicating self-assurance.
She sniffed out a laugh, dropping her gaze to her hands resting in her lap. Then she looked at him again through the mirror, his image growing larger with every step he took towards her.
"You are everything I have ever wanted." She confessed, feeling her cheeks flush.
[Jeff Buckley — Everybody Here Wants You]
Sirius smiled, stopping behind her. His fingers traced her neck, wandering along the delicate hollow of her collarbones, crossing her shoulders, sliding down her shoulder blades and stopping only when they reached the side zip of her dress. Without ever breaking eye contact with her reflection, he began to pull the zip down slowly, so that the opening grew wider and wider.
Scarlett watched his tattooed, ring-laden fingers, hypnotised as they grazed her skin. His index finger and thumb caught the strap of her dress and tugged. The fabric slipped from her shoulder, sliding down her arm. He did the same on the other side. The garment halted just before her elbows, the cut still shielding her breasts.
Sirius traced the seam with his index finger, the warm pad leaving a trail of shivers across her skin as it reached the centre of the neckline. He slowly pulled the fabric past the slight obstruction and, at last, allowed gravity to finish the task.
He inhaled deeply, a rough, salacious sound, watching the dress glide over the swell of her breasts as it revealed them and slipped along her pale skin. The black velvet pooled around her waist.
"What do you think about… instead of using your energy to punish yourself…" Sirius murmured, sliding his hand back up to her shoulder. "Using it to enjoy this moment here, with me?" He sweetened the proposal by gripping a handful of her hair and forcing her to tilt her face up to him, compelling her to meet his gaze.
Sirius stroked her cheek with his thumb, his body shuddering when he heard her sigh beneath his touch. He cupped her jaw with his free hand and bent over her, pressing her delicate face against his chest as his lips relieved the longing they felt for hers.
Demanding as ever, Sirius nipped and sucked at Scarlett’s lower lip, urging it to grant him entry, and she parted her mouth for him. His stubble tickled her skin in communion with his heated kiss. Urgent. His tongue tangled in that primitive dance, stole Scarlett’s breath and compelled her to answer him, to drag her lips against his, to battle his advances. Making her present in that kiss as much as he was, that she wanted him as fiercely as he desired her.
Kissing Sirius Black was like returning to a moment when she had once been happy, to a place where she could feel whole, like visiting the trigger of her fractures. Even so, Scarlett parted her eyes slightly, only to find his already open. Of course they were, his grey orbs—possessing every shade of grey in the world—glinting hungrily, stirring that heat she knew so well in her core.
The wicked gleam within them was enough to tell her yes, he still loved her. And yes, she still belonged to that sea of mercury as much as Sirius belonged to the translucent ocean of her irises.
And yes, Sirius was still as suffocating as the sun.
That was why Scarlett tried to break the kiss in search of air, but he did not allow it. He planted his hand at her throat, dominating her by controlling her flow of oxygen, while the other kneaded her left breast, its fullness fitting perfectly within his warm palm. The chair creaked beneath her, the backrest preventing the press of Sirius’s groin against her spine.
Scarlett rolled her eyes at the delicious way he kneaded her breast, trapping the hardened nipple between his index and middle finger and pinching it. Sirius broke the kiss with an indecent sound, trailing his lips along her cheek, down her neck and further to her collarbone. He kept her captive in his grip, the hand at her throat sliding up to her chin, imprinting the icy shape of his rings against her delicate skin.
"Sirius…" she asked. No. She begged.
"Relax…" he murmured, his warm, damp breath caressing her ear. "Let me take care of you."
A trembling gasp slipped from her lips when Sirius dragged his beard along her neck and found the place where her blood pulsed and throbbed, sucking at it greedily. Scarlett straightened and turned her face towards him, whose mouth claimed hers again, now impatient and selfish. The chair beneath her cracked in protest.
Sirius released her nipple and mapped every inch of skin he encountered along the way. He lifted her left leg and grasped her knee. Every pore of her body and any lingering trace of hesitation were set ablaze by the tortuous path Sirius’s hand, once at her chin, carved as it travelled down her throat, her collarbones, the valley between her breasts, her abdomen, the scars along her ribs, beneath the dress hugging her waist until it reached her groin.
His little finger hooked into her knickers and pushed them aside, while the rest of his fingers slid up and down her thighs, moving back and forth, hovering dangerously close yet never quite touching her directly, though Scarlett felt his presence there, the heat of his fingertips lingering over her needy cunt every time he shifted his wrist.
Her hips tilted towards him, pleading for his touch.
"What do you want, love?" Sirius purred against her lips without breaking the kiss, a wicked smile carved into the curve of his mouth.
"You." The answer rolled over Sirius’s tongue so quickly that she drew a deep breath and repeated it with more insistence into his mouth. "I always want you."
"How?" He traced his index finger and little finger along the inside of her thigh, around her vulva.
Scarlett’s legs tightened at once, pulsing with desire.
She very much wanted to answer, but Sirius deepened the kiss deliberately, sliding his tongue in deeply and, at the same time, thrusting two fingers inside her. The simultaneous penetration made her shudder, her breath stuttering in her chest as her back arched.
Her moan was swallowed by the debauched lips of Sirius Black.
Scarlett pulled away from him to gasp and reclaim her breath, so that his wet mouth dragged across her face. Her trembling hands searched for anything they could grasp: the chair seat, the edge of the dressing table, the linen shirt, the long black hair. The wrist between her thighs.
"Confess all your crimes to me…" Sirius planted a kiss at the base of her ear, his voice thick with eroticism, intoxicating her further as the shivering sensation blazing through her body intensified. "And let me love you anyway."
Scarlett wanted to cry. She wanted to go back in time and have stayed, wanted to have saved her family, wanted to have saved Regulus, wanted to have saved Sirius, wanted to have saved James and Lily and, most of all, wanted to have saved herself.
She thought of her crimes, one by one. Hating Sirius was the first that came to mind. What they had done to each other, the second. Those two alone were enough to unleash the avalanche that crashed into her chest, burying her beneath everything else: leaving, trusting Regulus, believing him, staying at Grimmauld Place. Marrying him. Killing the McKinnons.
Watching Fab and Gid die without reacting. Being so terrified that she could do nothing but curl up in Sirius’s bedroom and beg for him to appear and rescue her. Making that idiotic pact. Taking the blame for all her crimes without blinking. Killing Selwyn and Wilkes. Wanting to remain in Azkaban. Wanting to run from her family even when all she had ever longed for was to stay. Drowning herself in alcohol until she nearly went under.
To whom did Scarlett owe the greatest apology?
No one had ever been as cruel to her as she had been to herself.
"Just… let it go." Sirius’s voice slithered along her neck, warm and provocative, fucking her with his middle and ring finger in an agonising rhythm.
He pushed deeper, only to hear her whimper again.
Scarlett wanted to curse him, but all she managed was to tremble beneath him. It was all Sirius’s fault. He had condemned her the instant he had scrutinised her with those cruel eyes, the ones responsible for stealing the shine from every star.
With a single look, Sirius Black had annihilated her forever.
Nothing, absolutely nothing would ever compare to the sensation of his hands between her thighs, his fingers curling and bending inside her as they found the spot that made her writhe. Nothing would ever rival the way he devoured her with his gaze, how his smile burned incandescent.
Sirius knew perfectly well what he had done and what he was doing to her.
He braced his arm on her shoulder, and his lips—shaped by perversity—travelled along her nape. He kissed the Canis Major tattoo, then the star, and found the scars that marred her cervical spine.
Scarlett squeezed her eyes shut, breathless, trying with all her might to contain the tears… but it was too late. Sirius Black was already crawling beneath her skin, clouding her bones and intoxicating her bloodstream. From there, reaching her heart was easy. The fissures within it were so deep they had become chasms.
Sirius Black found where she was most broken and loved her anyway.
The moment Sirius pressed his thumb to her clitoris, with his middle and ring finger still inside her, her nails dug into the skin of his wrist while her other hand seized a fistful of black hair and dragged him down, guiding him back to her mouth.
Scarlett moaned against his lips, rocking her hips desperately towards the sensation, grinding against Sirius’s hand. He quickened the rhythm, driving her mad with the skill in which he moved his wrist in tandem with his rough thumb rubbing against her clit in random, torturous patterns.
Her entire body tensed in response to the combustion of her nerves. Scarlett writhed beneath him, her cunt tightening around the fingers that kept moving and sustaining the pressure on her swollen, sensitive clit, making her lose her senses and nearly drool in Sirius’s arms, drunk on euphoria. The orgasm spilled through every part of her body, twisting her crimes and regrets into irrelevant little things, because all that mattered was there, behind and inside her.
Sirius withdrew his fingers from her cunt and brought them to the kiss. Scarlett sucked his ring finger while he cleaned his middle one, never breaking eye contact, savouring the sinful taste of the woman he loved. He grew even harder than he already was.
With his other hand, Sirius unbuttoned his shirt and shoved it off his shoulders, his bare chest inked with tattoos tightening with every heavy, heated breath. Scarlett watched him through tear-damp lashes, observing as he stepped back and undid his belt, letting his trousers fall to the floor along with his pants.
He was already erect, the flushed head gleaming with pre-come. Sirius lifted her from the chair with disarming ease, freed her from the dress that clung stubbornly to her waist and pulled her against him. Scarlett wrapped her legs around his hips and he retreated across the bathroom with her in his arms, carrying her into the bedroom.
The expensive sheets embraced them when Sirius threw himself onto the bed, their lips joining again as he positioned himself between her legs. Their eyes met. Sirius pressed his hot tip against Scarlett’s drenched entrance, her legs tightening around his waist, urging him on.
She hissed and trembled when Sirius pushed into her, his length and thickness stretching her walls, filling her so intensely that her head fell back in a drawn-out moan at the intrusion. Scarlett felt everything: the veins along his cock pulsing against her slick heat, the swollen head driving deeper and deeper, and Sirius’s breathless groan vibrating against the curve of her throat. Her release coating the base of him and sliding between them.
Scarlett could not remember how long it had been since she had last had sex, but the burn provoked by Sirius’s size was always pleasurable. Even so, it was rare for him not to wait for her to adjust to the penetration. She wrapped herself around him and pulled him closer, as though that were still possible, feeling his feverish skin against hers while he began to move inside her, groaning when her cunt tightened around him, burning and boiling in voluptuous heat.
Sirius lay against her and rested his forehead to hers. He gripped her hair firmly, forcing her to look at him. Scarlett’s pupils were so dilated with arousal that the blue was only a faint ring around them, the darkness swallowing the image of Sirius above her. Enraptured by the sensation of every inch of him sliding along her walls, peeling delicious feeling after delicious feeling through her body, drawing needy moans from her throat.
The pace he adopted was slow, savouring the way her lower lips clung to his cock. There was no reason to hurry. The pleasure was not in the thrust of his hips nor in the drag of his length. It was not in the shared delight or in the bruised sentiment. There was hunger, though. Hunger from two souls that had waited too long to rediscover love without the thorns of pain.
Every touch was an apology: for surrendering to alcohol, for leaving, for never coming back, for accepting in silence, for trying to save someone who did not wish to be saved, for having to lie to protect, for wanting to ruin oneself in anything at all; even in that love that had so often flirted and lain with destruction.
And there, in the arms of the man she had lost, Scarlett found her freedom. Urging him to go faster and harder, pulling him into her with every roll of her hips, desperate for him to drive so deep that pleasure would be torn open by pain.
Scarlett wanted to memorise every inch of his cock nestled inside her numbed cunt.
Sirius granted part of her request and thrust harder, his eyes locked onto Scarlett’s, his arms caging her beneath him, heightening his need to always control her. It was as though he were trying, at the very least, to accept that he possessed some measure of dominion over her. Even if only for a night, or for the moment he was inside her; it was the need to demonstrate that she was his, his alone and no one else’s.
"I love you." Sirius declared with a growl, his pupils clouded with passion. "I love you so much."
Scarlett smiled against his lips and her nails dug into his back, making certain he could go nowhere but deeper inside her. There was that strange sensation simmering beneath the surface of pleasure. It was not merely about sex or any notion of release. On the contrary.
It was the biting promise that had bound their hearts with words spoken more than ten years ago on the idiotic night of an idiotic ball. It was the furtive glances that collided whenever they felt one another’s presence. It was the shared suffering that made them so obsessed with that worn, battered love.
She had traded one prison for another. Scarlett knew it… Sirius did too. Even so, they continued the oldest dance of all, at a rhythm so slow it was almost becoming torture. A delicious torture.
"I love you too, Sirius." Scarlett brushed her tongue over his parted lips. "Everyone knows that… that I don’t deserve you… and that includes myself, but… I… I…" She sucked his lower lip. "I love you anyway."
Those words were enough fuel for Sirius to increase the pace, turning the thrusting frantic and aggressive. Sweat trickled down his temple and his long black hair clung to his forehead. The sound of their hips colliding echoed in harmony with their increasingly loud, rhythmic moans.
Scarlett simply allowed herself to be dragged under by the current called Sirius Black, by the waves of euphoria that licked at her body with every thrust and sent spasms through her limbs, by the electrifying tension that tightened her muscles further and further, heightening her craving for the inevitable release.
"Let go. Let go with me, love…" Sirius urged, his lips brushing hers, the words spilling down her cheeks. "Come with me."
He teased her clitoris with his thumb and Scarlett obeyed with moans, tears, sobs, scratches and careless kisses. Her walls moulded greedily around him, milking his length while he maintained the brutal rhythm.
Sirius’s name burst from Scarlett’s throat. She lifted her hips and dug her heels into his arse, driving him forcefully into her.
The orgasm struck violently, undoing her thoughts, her anguish, scrambling every one of her senses. Sirius’s arms wrapped around her with an iron grip, holding her and fucking her without pause, drowning her in the frenzied current that made her explode and tremble in rapture. Scarlett continued shaking and moaning from the overstimulation.
Sirius clenched his teeth and took her harder, and then again, and again. Then he followed her, sinking languidly into Scarlett, feeling her cunt suffocating his cock with the overwhelming waves of her climax. He could not hold back any longer and pulsed inside her, jet after jet, his hot, unrestrained peak.
Scarlett rested her hands on his head, her fingers tangling in his hair. Sirius was still lying over her, still inside her. Their laboured breaths and thundering hearts replaced the depraved sounds from moments before.
They were exhausted. Their faces so close that Sirius’s exhale became Scarlett’s inhale. Their sweaty bodies stuck together.
"Fuck." She murmured hoarsely, the swear word brushing against Sirius’s lips. Her head throbbed with the pounding of her pulse.
"Mm." He grunted, burying his face in her neck, his ears ringing.
The heat soon became unbearable. Sirius slipped out of her and off her, but he did not move away. Scarlett curled into him, her back warmed by his tattooed chest, her body immobilised by the arm that snaked beneath her breasts, holding her against him.
Scarlett shivered. For the first time in a long while, it was not from cold or from abstinence.
She shivered from happiness.
Sirius kissed her neck and pulled her closer, sheltering her in his steadiness, being the foundation she so desperately needed.
He drew in a deep breath, losing himself in the muffled scent of tobacco, cologne and sweat clinging to her. In his release trickling between her thighs, mingled with hers. In the body that stitched his back together.
"Sorry." She asked, but could not continue.
Sorry for what? She had no idea. There was too much inside her core trying to take over, fighting desperately to escape.
"You don’t need to apologise to me, love." Sirius fitted his face into the crook of her neck, his warm breath misting her skin. His low voice vibrated against her ribcage through her back. "I’ve already forgiven you. It’s over."
"I know, but…" She inhaled very slowly and her lower lip trembled. "I still… I still feel that…"
It was very difficult to drag her self-flagellating thoughts back into her mind, because the orgasm and Sirius’s presence there had pushed them far away.
Perhaps her apology was not for him. Perhaps it was for everything they had been, everything they were and everything they had failed to become.
How many versions of herself had died for her to become who she was?
"I think that… because you were always drunk in the past… and how I accused you and blamed you… and then I did the same." She took another deep breath. The air began to feel thin. Sirius, behind her, did not move. His only reaction was the slight tightening of his fingers over her abdomen, encouraging her to go on.
Scarlett turned her face to look at him. The night lights slipped through the gaps in the curtains and spilled over Sirius’s profile: over his black hair framing his pale face, the sweat-damp beard, the tattoos across his chest rising and falling with his heavy breathing.
"I’m sorry for choosing the easy path."
Sirius touched her face with the tips of his fingers, brushing them over her cheekbones, along the arch of her brows and the shape of her nose. Along the line of her jaw. The corner of her lips. The dark shadows beneath her eyes.
Suddenly, Scarlett looked like a very tired girl. Sirius did too. Tired of trying to find a way to love and be loved without hurting each other so much.
"I don’t… want to go back to what we were, Sirius." Scarlett’s voice cracked and she swallowed hard, but continued. "I want to try to be better now. By your side."
Sirius filled his lungs with air, caught in the darkness of Scarlett’s pupils. He had always wanted to hear that, and now that he had, he did not know what to do with it.
"I do too…" Sirius murmured hoarsely. "I want to be a better person by your side, Scarlett." The syllables came out uneven. "I want a family that doesn’t need fixing. But… we need to fix ourselves first."
"It doesn’t have to be now." Scarlett tried to smile, but failed. "What I mean is… later on…"
"The only reason I don’t talk about the future with you, Scar, is because every time I do, you run." He cut her off, not harshly, but the frustration in his voice made Scarlett’s body wilt in his arms.
She parted her lips to argue, but Sirius was right. It was much easier to run to a place where she could pretend she was not a mother, nor an ex-prisoner, nor a lover, nor haunted.
"I didn’t just run from you, Sirius." Her voice finally came out. Thick. "I ran from myself too."
Sirius tilted his face and kissed the Scarius tattoo on Scarlett’s arm, his hand stroking her cheek. She closed her eyes and allowed herself to be pulled under by his protective touch. Then she gathered all the courage she had to strip her words of any lie and went on:
"Since I was imprisoned… I don’t believe I have a future anymore." She swallowed again, trying to ignore the painful stab in her chest at that admission. "My future was to rot in Azkaban, to be tortured until I died. That was it. That and nothing else."
The pause she took was long. It was the first time she had been honest about it with anyone who was not one of her ghosts. Making that confession to the only person in the world who would truly understand her was harder than she had imagined.
Her breathing came out in ragged bursts.
"Anything beyond that feels… wrong. Like it doesn’t belong to me… like it’s… borrowed. And you know, Sirius…" She let the weight of her face rest in his hand, holding his gaze, clouded with bitter memories neither of them could escape. "You know how dangerous hope is in Azkaban. How it starts by gnawing at the edges of you and, before you even realise it, you’re being devoured. How it attracts the Dementors."
Sirius nodded slowly. Not that he needed to offer her any sort of confirmation. He had been there for far too long as well.
"So tell me…" Her blue eyes hardened into ice and then melted into the warmth of a sea bathed in summer sunlight. "What kind of future do you see with me?"
Sirius blinked a few times. His gaze turned glassy, pulled somewhere distant. At the same time, it cut through every barrier Scarlett had with unnerving ease, seeing her soul as naked to him as her body had been moments before.
"I don’t want to be just the bloke who sleeps in your bed." His words stirred something deep within her heart. Like a serpent waking from a long slumber, the pact uncoiled through her body. "I want you… not only in a carnal way. I don’t just want to kiss you and shag you. I want your heart, I want your body, I want your presence. Your soul."
Scarlett let out an incredulous breath. She could feel Sirius’s heart pounding against her back, galloping as furiously as her own. The arm holding her tightened, pulling her closer. The magical cord that bound them vibrated beneath her skin, rippling and prickling along her sluggish nerve endings, as though trying to wake them from the haze of their climax.
"I want your traumas and your nightmares. I want every part of you, Sirius…" she continued, turning in his arms to face him and brushing her lips against his. "Every piece, every fracture, every fear. I want your pleasure and your orgasm. Your tears and your moans. Tell me you’ll be mine, love… and I’ll be yours."
"I am yours." He confirmed, parting his lips and kissing her slowly.
The kiss now was neither lustful nor desperate. It was the sealing of a promise, the joining of futures and the acceptance that this was the version of themselves they possessed. It was the confirmation that, at last, they had found the right rhythm after so many years of discord.
Sirius lifted his hand to her nape, threading his fingers through her hair and guiding her head down to the tattoo on his chest, stroking her gently. Scarlett allowed herself to be led, nestling into him despite the hot, stifling night. His arm remained wrapped around her waist and his palm settled in the familiar curve at the base of her spine, where it always belonged.
Their bodies aligned, legs entwined and breathing gradually steadied. The lazy trail Sirius’s fingertips traced along her spine, passing over her scars, was her undoing.
Scarlett was claimed by sleep in the arms of the man who, despite everything, was her home.
.
.
.
Sirius Black could not have woken to a better feeling. In fact, he scarcely remembered that warm, narcotic sensation that steadied his heartbeat and sent shivers across his skin. The weight of Scarlett asleep on his chest made him feel so light he might have been floating near the sky. He could almost touch the soft down of angel wings and hear the calm, harmonious hymn of celestial harps.
He held her carefully and rolled onto his side, slowly laying her down on the mattress. Scarlett grunted and buried her face in the pillow, searching for Sirius’s warmth in the sheets beside her.
His gaze travelled over her entire body, sprawled across the bed in a rather tempting position: face down, her arse perfectly arched as though inviting him to sink back into her. Her velvety skin shimmered in the subtle light filtering through the curtains and her long hair—now halfway down her back—lay tousled and wild across her face.
Sirius flexed his jaw and drew in a deep breath, restraining the wicked suggestions of his male instincts. Scarlett slept peacefully, and all he managed was a soft smile. He watched her for nearly half an hour before pressing a kiss to the star tattoo on her shoulder blade and rising.
He did not bother dressing. He simply grabbed his pocket watch and the packet of cigarettes from the bedside table and stepped out onto the bedroom balcony, whose view was breathtaking.
The English Channel stretched before Sirius, rippling in silver-grey foam, crashing against pale rocks speckled with glittering flecks, forcing him to raise a hand to shield his eyes even though the sun was gentle. The sky was clear, freshly polished by the dawn winds, deepening already into its faded summer blue, dotted here and there with seagulls lazily gliding above the sea.
The breeze was already heavy, yet cool enough to prickle his bare skin, carrying with it the peculiar silence only seaside mornings could offer: bubbling whispers of waves, the distant sound of bicycle wheels along the pavement, the metallic chime of wind bells from some far-off balcony, the shrill laughter of early-rising tourists and the rhythmic whistle of a ship slicing across the horizon.
Sirius lifted the packet to his mouth and held a cigarette between his lips, lighting it with a wandless spell. The ember flared in a soft orange glow and he drew in slowly, eyes fixed on the line of the horizon separating them from France. He leaned against the wrought-iron railing and narrowed his eyes.
He flicked open the watch with a snap, cradling it in his curved palm. His thumb found that particular spot on the photograph which, from being touched so often, had begun to smooth. James’s image, however, remained unchanged. Smiling in that way only he could: with his mouth, his teeth and his eyes, holding Harry in his arms.
He had achieved everything he had ever longed for… so why did it still feel as though something was missing?
"My life will never be the same without you." He murmured, exhaling the smoke slowly. "It wasn’t meant to happen like this. No… it wasn’t meant… to end… like this…" His voice broke and he stopped, straining with all his might to hold back the tears.
Sirius snapped the watch shut and clenched his fist tightly, lips pressed thin. Trying desperately to ignore the tears burning at the corners of his eyes.
"You should be here… with us… we’re finally together, but… but you’re not here… you’re not here…"
He covered his face with both hands, holding his breath. He ought to have been jumping with happiness, yet all he felt was the urge to cry.
Sirius did not want to cry. He knew that the moment he began, he would not be able to stop. Even knowing that the torrent of feelings rooted in his chest was aching to spill out… he could not.
He simply could not, because things were never meant to have happened this way. James and Lily were not supposed to have died. And while he wept, fate laughed. Its inexorable, merciless threads coiled around his neck in mockery.
It did not matter whether it was fair or unfair—things were as they were, and his happiness would never be complete without his best friend, his brother, his soulmate.
"I’m here, Padfoot…" James murmured in a thread of a voice, as tormented as he was. "I’m here."
His unsteady hand passed straight through Sirius with the same force that pain pierced his heart. His glasses slipped to the ground and his hands tried to catch the tears that poured relentlessly down his face. It was not supposed to hurt this much. For Merlin’s sake, James had died over a decade ago, yet it felt as though his heart still beat and his lungs still needed air.
To breathe and still feel dead was far worse than to be a ghost and feel nothing at all.
For a fleeting moment, he truly wished he were dead. On the other side, without the ties binding him to Scarlett. At least there, he would not have to see his best friend crying over his absence. Or would he?
He wanted to hug him. He wanted to be held by Sirius. He wanted to feel his best friend’s black hair beneath his fingers, wanted to see that intimate smile spreading across his lips every time they saw one another, and wanted to witness, truly witness, the man he was becoming.
James wanted to touch, wanted to hold, wanted to live. He was tired of being nothing more than a weight around Scarlett’s ankles, a haunting, a restless soul. He could no longer bear watching his son sleep peacefully while looking through their photo album and imagining what his life might have been like if he and Lily had never been murdered.
He wanted to live, for fuck’s sake. Was that too much to ask?
Was it too much to ask for the dead to return to life?
He knew it was. But James asked anyway.
Sirius turned slowly, resting his shoulders against the balcony railing. The sea breeze lashed at his tousled hair and the cigarette still burned forgotten between his fingers.
"Sirius… you’re going to get arrested for indecent exposure like that." Scarlett said, her voice rough with sleep. She was wrapped in her white dressing gown, her face creased from rest and her pupils narrowed against the brightness. "The pedestrians are already scandalised…"
He smiled, a small, sad smile, but it was all he could offer her. He stubbed the cigarette out against the railing and opened his arms. Scarlett came to him and he wrapped her up, burying his face in her tangled hair. In her marked neck. In her racing heart.
He did not know how long he stood there in the arms of the woman he loved. But the moment she kissed his lips and looked at him with compassion, his heart shrank. His mouth turned to stone and his words tangled in embarrassment. He should not have been feeling this way, not with Scarlett, but the pain was so vast that all he managed to do was loosen his hold, press a kiss to her forehead and retreat into the bathroom.
Not even the freezing water managed to soothe the vortex in his chest.
He stepped out of the shower, dried his hair with a spell and slipped into his dressing gown, tying it loosely around his waist. The cold water had left his skin bluish, mirroring the torrent of emotions bursting inside him after his failed attempt to dam them.
The summer heat tried to invade him, but it did not matter that he was already sweating after the shower, that the wind was heavy or that the sun blazed fiercely outside. It did not matter how many times he smiled, pretended or tried to shield himself within Scarlett…
James was no longer there.
He never would be again.
The realisation hurt far more than he expected. James had died nearly thirteen years ago and it ached as though he had died the day before. The wound of grief had never stopped bleeding, had never closed. It hurt as though he had just found his best friend lying at the foot of the stairs in Godric’s Hollow…
The increasingly scarce air carried a delicious scent. Something buttery mingled with the bitterness of coffee drew his gaze for a fleeting moment, absolving him from his personal hell. The room was overflowing with golden toast, creamy scrambled eggs, warm croissants. Sautéed mushrooms steamed beside fruit tarts and buttery little cakes, flanked by jugs of fresh juice, cold milk, artisan breads and small ramekins of jam, beans and sausages in thick sauce.
Harry and Reggie were already seated around the table, savouring croissants and muffins.
"I’m in heaven…" Reggie groaned, his mouth full of cake.
"I think I’ve found something better than Penny’s cooking…" Harry added, closing his eyes as he tasted the croissant with jam.
"Just don’t let Penny hear you say that…" Scarlett laughed, now wearing a dark red dress. "Or she’ll have a fit."
"Do you think if I ask Alaric, he’ll give me the croissant recipe?" Harry went on, licking his fingertips.
Sirius managed a shy smile as he joined them. Reggie laughed, and it was the perfect opportunity for Sirius to try to reach that joy and let himself be infected by it… yet soon his eyes drifted towards the bedroom doorway. Waiting for something… or someone. Waiting for fate to grant him one more wish. Just one more. Having Scarlett by his side was already more than perfect, but having James there too would be…
It would be magic.
Sirius lowered his gaze to some indistinct point on his gleamingly clean plate. The world unfolded around him like a film he could neither follow nor comprehend. Then a hand touched his arm and the familiar sensation tugged at his heart. His eyes immediately traced the pale, slender fingers, pausing on the black diamond ring encircled with small brilliant stones. He travelled up along the faint green veins on the back of her hand, along her forearm, to the Scarius tattoo inside a heart pierced by an arrow, to the shoulder wrapped in red fabric. To the freckled face, the long curved lashes.
He plunged into her ocean eyes and allowed them to cleanse him of his burdens, to wash away his pretences and strip him of his embarrassment. Scarlett poured his tea, added milk and offered it to him.
Sirius accepted, sipping the dark, sweetened infusion without taking his eyes off her.
"A very dear friend once told me…" Scarlett gave a half-smile. One that showed no teeth and did not stretch far, yet was filled with complicity and nostalgia. "That the things we lose always find their way back to us somehow. Maybe… not in the way we expect, but…"
Sirius was pulled from the warm sea of Scarlett’s eyes when she looked away. He followed her gaze.
Harry pushed his glasses up the bridge of his nose with the exact same tic James used to have. He scratched at his eternally untameable hair. The ironic little smirk tugging at the corner of his mouth as he teased Reggie carried the very same affectionate mischief James had always used on him.
It was reliving without truly reliving. It was James. Or at least, a piece of his friend there with him. It was different. Sirius did not want merely a fragment of his best mate — he wanted him whole — and yet…
Sirius let out a slow breath and looked at Scarlett. A smile, heavy yet genuine, bloomed across his pink lips.
Scarlett slipped her hand beneath the table, threading her fingers through his.
"Yeah…" he whispered, pressing a kiss to the back of her hand. "They always come back. Somehow… they come back."
✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧⋄⋆⋅⋆⋄✧

Pages Navigation
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Apr 2025 11:48AM UTC
Last Edited Tue 15 Apr 2025 11:48AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 1 Tue 15 Apr 2025 12:36PM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 1 Wed 16 Apr 2025 01:58AM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 1 Wed 16 Apr 2025 02:14AM UTC
Last Edited Wed 16 Apr 2025 02:15AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 1 Wed 16 Apr 2025 10:21AM UTC
Comment Actions
Jenifer (Guest) on Chapter 1 Tue 17 Feb 2026 02:09AM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 2 Thu 17 Apr 2025 01:49PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 2 Thu 17 Apr 2025 02:14PM UTC
Comment Actions
kittty99j on Chapter 2 Mon 02 Feb 2026 10:46AM UTC
Comment Actions
kittty99j on Chapter 2 Mon 02 Feb 2026 11:31AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 2 Mon 02 Feb 2026 11:15PM UTC
Comment Actions
Jen922 on Chapter 4 Tue 22 Apr 2025 01:00AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 4 Tue 22 Apr 2025 12:19PM UTC
Comment Actions
Jen922 on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 12:45PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 01:13PM UTC
Comment Actions
Jen922 on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 01:28PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 4 Wed 23 Apr 2025 02:53PM UTC
Comment Actions
Jen922 on Chapter 4 Sat 26 Apr 2025 02:39AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 4 Sat 26 Apr 2025 09:17PM UTC
Comment Actions
(Previous comment deleted.)
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 5 Fri 16 May 2025 08:54AM UTC
Comment Actions
aneet (Guest) on Chapter 10 Wed 07 May 2025 04:32PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 10 Wed 07 May 2025 07:48PM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 13 Mon 12 May 2025 01:47PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 13 Tue 13 May 2025 01:37PM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 14 Tue 13 May 2025 01:17PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 14 Tue 13 May 2025 01:41PM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 15 Thu 15 May 2025 08:44AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 15 Thu 15 May 2025 08:38PM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 17 Fri 16 May 2025 01:06PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 17 Fri 16 May 2025 03:44PM UTC
Comment Actions
aneet (Guest) on Chapter 17 Sun 18 May 2025 04:50PM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 17 Sun 18 May 2025 09:37PM UTC
Comment Actions
Aaliyah24 on Chapter 20 Wed 21 May 2025 10:46AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 20 Wed 21 May 2025 02:25PM UTC
Comment Actions
Covencrafted on Chapter 21 Fri 15 Aug 2025 04:49AM UTC
Comment Actions
RainhaVisenya on Chapter 21 Mon 18 Aug 2025 07:34PM UTC
Comment Actions
Pages Navigation