Work Text:
It was a subtle change. That’s the part no one tells you. No one wakes up one morning and decides to become the man in the recliner. It doesn’t happen all at once. There’s no villain speech. No dramatic turning point. Just small things. Missed moments. A slow dimming.
At one point Karen and I were young and in love. On our first date I was such a fumbling fool. I’d been so nervous to ask her out I rehearsed it in the mirror like an idiot. She was as gorgeous then as she is now, bright smile, hair catching the light like something out of a shampoo commercial. I remember thinking she was out of my league. I remember thinking if she said no, I’d never recover, but she said yes.
It wasn’t anything crazy. We went to the new drive-in theater and watched some movie I can’t even begin to remember because I was too focused on her. I kept stealing glances at her instead of the screen. Every time she laughed, I felt like I’d won something.
After I dropped her off at home, I gave her a quick kiss. My first kiss. If you’d asked me that night, I would’ve told you right then and there I was going to marry that girl. And I did.
Shortly after high school, I proposed. I didn’t have much, just a decent job lined up and a ring I saved for months to buy. She said yes anyway. When she walked down the aisle with her dad, who very much did not like me, I cried. Couldn’t help it. I wasn’t embarrassed. I was proud. It was one of the happiest moments of my life.
I was going to be a good husband, nothing like my good for nothing father.
Soon after, she had Nancy. My beautiful, smart daughter. When I held Nancy in my arms for the first time, she was wailing, terrified to be in this loud, bright world. But I held her. I remember whispering, “I’ve got you,” like I already knew what I was doing.
I cried then, too. Just as Nancy was no longer toddling, Michael made his entrance. I was terrified when he didn’t cry right away. I swear to you my heart stopped beating. The room felt too quiet. I looked at the doctor like he had personally betrayed me.
And then he wailed, when he wailed for the first time, it was the best noise I’d ever heard. So amazing that I would’ve sworn I’d never get sick of it. I did.
After many sleepless nights, the joy in it faded. That sound that once meant “he’s alive” started meaning “you won’t rest.” It meant work in four hours. It meant bills still unpaid. It meant responsibilities stacking up faster than I could handle.
We were happy for a while. Truly happy. Family dinners. Little league games. Bedtime stories where I’d do the voices. Karen and I would collapse into bed exhausted but satisfied, whispering about the future.
But like I said, it was subtle. The first time I ignored Michael crying, I was devastated. I remember lying there, staring at the ceiling, listening to him through the monitor. I told myself Karen would get him. I told myself he needed to learn to self-soothe. I told myself I had an early meeting.
After about thirty seconds of apathy, I sprung up and comforted him anyway. Held him. Rocked him. Apologized for his tiny hair even though he couldn’t understand me. Later I talked to Karen about the guilt. She assured me it was okay. “You’re tired,” she said. “We both are. It’s just a slip.”
It wasn’t a slip. Slowly, but surely, it became normal. Thirty seconds turned into a minute. A minute turned into five. Five turned into Karen getting up before I even considered it. Eventually, I stopped hearing it the same way. It became background noise. Something that would resolve itself without me.
Karen tried talking to me. She’d say, “I need you.” Not angrily. Not accusing. Just honest. And I would try again. For a little while. I’d make an effort. I’d show up to the school event. I’d sit on the floor and build blocks.
And then, just like before, I’d slip back into it. This didn’t just apply to the children. My marriage suffered too. Karen did.
We went from kissing goodbye when I left for work to muttering it as I waltzed out the door. From staying up late talking to sitting in the same room not saying anything at all. She’d try to tell me about her day and I’d nod without listening. I convinced myself that providing was enough. That going to work every day, that paying the mortgage, that keeping the lights on, that was love.
It was easier to be tired than to be vulnerable. That’s the part I don’t say out loud.
Loving them the way they deserved meant constantly facing the possibility of losing them. It meant acknowledging how fragile all of it was. The house. The kids. Karen’s laugh. The illusion that I was in control.
And somewhere along the way, I realized I wasn’t in control of anything. The promotions didn’t feel like victories. The bills never stopped. The world kept changing and I didn’t understand half of it. The kids grew into people with thoughts I couldn’t follow. Karen grew into someone who didn’t look at me the same way.
Every time I tried to step back in, it felt like I was already too late.
So I leaned into what I could control: my chair. The television. The predictable drone of the evening news. The safety of being uninvolved. If I didn’t look too closely, I didn’t have to see the distance.
If I didn’t ask too many questions, I didn’t have to hear answers that proved I wasn’t needed. People think I stopped caring.
That’s not exactly it. Caring started to feel like standing in the middle of a storm without an umbrella. It felt like failing in slow motion. It felt like watching my wife’s disappointment harden into something quieter and more permanent.
So I chose something easier. I chose small. I chose comfort. I chose safety. One day I looked up from my recliner and realized the house was still full, but I was no longer at the center of it.
Then Karen told me she was pregnant. Again.
For a moment, I didn’t even process it. She said it like she was commenting on the weather, sitting across from me at the kitchen table with her hands wrapped around a mug of coffee. But I remember the way the words landed—like something cracked open inside my chest that I hadn’t realized had sealed shut.
I don’t know how to explain it without sounding ridiculous, but something about it brought new life back into me. Not in a dramatic way. Not like I suddenly became a different man overnight. It was quieter than that. More like a door I thought was permanently stuck finally shifting on its hinges. Suddenly I was trying again.
I got up from the recliner more. Not because I felt guilty, but because I felt present. Like I had been invited back into my own life and I was afraid if I waited too long, the invitation would expire. No more sitting in front of the television pretending the world ended at the edge of our living room.
I helped Michael with his homework again. At first it was awkward, him staring at me like I was speaking a language I used to know but had forgotten. Algebra that made no sense to either of us. History dates I got wrong and then laughed off like it didn’t matter. But I stayed there anyway.
I tried, really tried, to relate to Nancy, who was suddenly not a kid anymore. She had opinions now. Sharp ones. She looked at me like she was measuring whether I was worth explaining them to. I asked about school, about friends, about whatever boys were starting to show up in conversations I wasn’t invited into. Sometimes she answered. Sometimes she didn’t.
But I asked and I became, for a while, the husband I once was.
I noticed Karen again. Not just as someone moving through the same house, but as the person I had fallen in love with. I kissed her goodbye in the morning. I listened when she talked. I even started noticing when she was tired before she said anything.
It didn’t feel like effort at first. It felt like remembering. When Holly was born, something in me fully lit back up. That tiny spark I thought had burned out wasn’t gone after all, it had just been buried under too many years of silence and routine and suddenly it was roaring again.
I was right next to Karen the whole birth. I don’t think I left her side once. I gave her ice chips even when she said she didn’t want them anymore. I wiped her forehead with a wet cloth that kept slipping out of my hands because I was shaking. I let her squeeze my hand so tightly I was convinced something might actually break. I didn’t care. I remember thinking I’d let her crush every bone in my hand if it meant she felt even a fraction more comfortable.
When the doctor finally held Holly up, everything else disappeared. The noise. The machines. The exhaustion. The fear that always hums in hospitals. I immediately took her when they handed her to me. She was so small it didn’t feel real. Fragile in a way that made my throat tighten instantly. Like something that could be lost just by holding it wrong. And I just… broke.
I cried. It had been years since I’d cried like that. Years since anything had been able to reach that part of me so directly. But holding her, feeling her weight in my arms, seeing her face scrunch and move like she was already trying to figure out the world, how could I not?
For a while after that, I thought maybe this was it. Maybe this was the reset. Maybe I had finally gotten it right. Holly was maybe two months old when it started again.
Not all at once. Of course not. Nothing in my life ever shifts all at once. That would be too honest. It was small things. A delayed response when she cried. A moment too long before I got up. Karen was already standing there, already handling it, already knowing I was halfway somewhere else before I even moved.
I stopped trying. I know it wasn’t fair. I had promised Karen and myself that I wouldn’t be my dad and to my credit, I never laid a hand on my children.
No matter how much Michael pushed me. No matter how loud he got. No matter how much he reminded me of every part of myself I didn’t like, I never even debated it. Not once. Not even in the darkest moments. How could I ever hit the life I helped create?
My three kids are my very reason for living. I couldn’t imagine raising a hand to them. Whenever I think back to my dad and his belt, I physically recoil. The sound of it. The way the air changed before it happened. The waiting. How could a man do that to his child?
I never hit my kids, but I’m still failing them. That’s the part I can’t escape.
I know things aren’t normal around here. Hawkins has always been strange. Even when I was a kid, there were things you didn’t talk about too long. Missing posters that faded but never really disappeared. Woods you didn’t go into after dark. Stories that adults laughed off a little too quickly.
The shadows were something different, even then. The kind of difference you don’t name out loud because naming it makes it real. I’d never admit it out loud, not even to Karen, but I knew there was something. Something wrong with the way this town sits on top of itself like it’s covering a crack in the earth. Like something underneath it is pushing up, trying to be noticed.
Now my kids are living in it. That’s the part that keeps me up more than anything else. Not just that I’ve stopped trying, but that I stopped trying while something in this town was still very much trying back.
Sometimes I look over from the recliner and see Karen drinking wine straight from the bottle. Not in a dramatic, movie like way. Not slouched on the floor crying or anything like that. Just standing in the kitchen, usually after dinner, when the house has gone quiet in that way that feels heavier than noise ever did. The bottle comes out of the fridge, and she doesn’t even bother with a glass anymore.
Sometimes we even lock eyes. Just for a second. Long enough for it to mean something. Short enough for neither of us to deal with it and I don’t say anything.
That’s the part that used to confuse me when I thought about other people’s lives, how things get bad without anyone ever actually saying they’re bad, but I understand it now, because I’m part of it.
I see her. I see the way her shoulders are a little tighter than they used to be. The way she exhales before she drinks like she’s preparing herself for something that isn’t just alcohol. The way she cleans up after everyone, handles everything, keeps the house from collapsing in on itself while I sit there pretending not to notice.
Then I say nothing. I don’t tell her she should stop. I don’t tell her she’s drinking too much. Not when it happens. I only bring it up when we fight. That’s the worst part of it, if I’m honest with myself.
It’s like I’m collecting evidence instead of caring. Holding onto pieces of information like ammunition instead of concern. Waiting for the right moment to deploy it instead of addressing it when it actually matters.
She’ll say I’m not trying anymore.
And I’ll say she’s drinking too much.
Like that somehow balances the scales. Like pain can be traded in arguments and whoever lands the sharper line wins something. It never feels like winning afterward. Just damage control dressed up as conversation.
I still love Karen. God, I love the woman with my entire soul. That’s the part that makes this worse, not better. Because it isn’t indifference. It isn’t hate. It isn’t even apathy in the pure sense of the word.
It’s something slower. Something tired, but maybe love just isn’t enough anymore. Maybe it never was, not without effort behind it. Not without attention. Not without showing up in ways that actually matter. I know she deserves better.
I know that with a clarity that almost makes it worse that I don’t change anything. She deserves someone who sees her before she has to disappear into herself. Someone who notices when she’s drowning instead of waiting until it becomes inconvenient.
I know it isn’t fair and I know I should get off my ass and participate in my life. In my family. In the small daily things that actually hold everything together, but knowing it and doing it feel like two completely different languages now.
Every time I try to step back in fully, I feel like I’m already behind. It’s like I missed too many years of practice. Like the rhythm of this house moved on without me and I’m just trying not to disrupt it further. My kids are growing up and I’m barely there. Not physically, most days. I’m in the house. I hear them. I see them pass through rooms like I’m part of the furniture. I’m not in it. Not really and that’s what I can’t seem to fix.
It’s easier to sit in the recliner because the recliner doesn’t ask anything of me. It doesn’t demand I be better. It doesn’t react when I fall short. It just holds me in place and lets the day pass without judgment. Trying means risking failure in real time. Trying means seeing disappointment on Karen’s face without a buffer. Trying means hearing my kids and realizing I don’t know them as well as I should. So I don’t.
I tell myself it’s exhausting. That I’ll do better tomorrow. That work is stressful. That life is complicated. However the truth is simpler and harder to admit, I’ve gotten used to not reaching. Not stepping forward and not interfering. If I stay still, nothing breaks in a way I have to fix immediately. Still, every so often, I catch Karen looking at me like she used to. Not angry or pleading. Just waiting.
Like there’s still a version of me she remembers that might decide to come back and I don’t know how to tell her that I see him too. I just can’t seem to reach him anymore.