1 - 20 of 627 Works in Tobias Erin "Toby" Rogers | Ticci Toby/Reader
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
A sudden fixation is all it takes. Now he's crawled into her mind.
-
My Angel Of Death | Ticci Toby x Reader by Whackadoodledoo
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
05 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
The city of Libby has long been swiping its dirty secrets under the rug. But now with a new detective in town, there’s hope of peace. But as you slowly realize the truth, you may have bit off more than you can chew. And with the eerie phone calls, threatening letters and increasing evidence that the killer is hot on your trail, maybe you should have ran when you still had the chance…
This is my first ever fic i'm posting and english isn't my first nor second language sdo please bear with me ;-;
Constructive critisism is appreciated. -
Tags
Summary
Sweet, sweet Henniker, New Hampshire.
You’re a college student attending the town’s college. During the winter break, you’re told you have to stay or you’ll lose your job, and having no other choice, you’re stuck.
Thankfully, your friend offers their couch up for the next month. Now, you’re stuck house sitting for them while they’re in Florida with their family. What luck!
All is good and well until three strange men show up in town, sending you to your wit’s end.
Small town Marble Hornets, I love you.
Tall, chubby!reader
-
Collection of Headcanons & Drabbles (Various Creepypasta x F!Reader) by dirtyl0ver
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
03 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
A growing collection of Creepypasta x F!Reader headcanons featuring all your favorite killers.
Expect everything from cute moments to total angst!
(Includes Ticci Toby, Tim/Masky, Brian/Hoodie, Jeff the Killer, BEN Drowned, and Eyeless Jack)
-
Tags
-
Baby you're a haunted house (better find another superstition) by sweetlike
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom
03 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
Toby ruins everything he touches.
He gives into his own selfishness by letting you in. Not knowing it would ruin the both of you.
-
All These Things That I've Done by FreddyFazbearPizzeriaVoicemail
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
03 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
Y/n is still trying to figure out how to be a normal person, something that never came easily to her. After a get away weekend trip turns to murder, she discovers that her life will never be the same. A newfound bloodlust brings her to three (maybe not so) psycho killers and an age old creature hell bent on using her to further his legacy.
Maybe she can stop The Operator with the power of love, but a Ka-bar works so much better.
Basically just your typical Creepypasta fic.
Y/n and Female pronouns used.
Toby/Tim/Brian/Reader -
Tags
Summary
To know the worth of every life but your own can feel suffocating. After Y/N attempts to take her own life, she suddenly finds herself surrounded by other people just like her, tasked with keeping them compliant & happy by an eldritch being that acts more like a father than a monster. Does she listen & act as a therapist for these troubled souls? Or does she run off, and have fate bury its hands into her no-longer beating heart?
(This is my first ever time writing, so there will be lots of mistakes)
-
Tags
Summary
your kidnappers don’t seem to be at all interested in violence. you doubt they’ll let you go, anyway.
Series
- Part 9 of fresh n' organic filth
-
Tags
-
So About the Other Night: Toby Rogers x Reader by Star_Jelly
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
01 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
One odd night leads to another when a strange boy comes knocking--or rather crashing.
-
Tags
Summary
Cops and robbers. Its all harmless play. Guns made of sticks and hideouts in the bushes. The suburbs are a quaint place to grow with your best friend. Its not serious. Its just fake violence and a little make believe. Toby is just a bit busy. He's always sick but mom says he'll be fine.
Cops and robbers once more but now you're the cop, now and the stakes are real. When you grow up to be the detective your father always hoped you'd be, you're given a case on a series of murders. One strangely familiar to an old cold case of a long gone friend that sits in your desk. And this time its multiplayer.
-
Tags
Summary
READ DESCRIPTION
[Name] get a letter in the mail leading to a worrying problem that he does not think he can solve. Following the instructions in the letter, leads to one thing to another. Soon finding a new thing about themselves along with finding someone else in the mix seeing it as nothing at finish turning into something more.-Creepypasta Camp Au
-Reader is a trans male
-Will TRY and update every month
-I don't know how many chapters yet but there will be at least 40This is on my Wattpad account too. It was put on it first before I was able to get an account.
-
Tags
Summary
Juno thought going home would fix everything. Instead, college unravels her, old wounds reopen, and Tuscaloosa becomes a place she barely recognizes. When secrets rise to the surface, she learns the truth - she was never ordinary to begin with. Even worse, she's not the only one who knows.
-
Creepypasta/Marble hornets x male readers by creepy_marbl3hornets478
Fandoms: Marble Hornets, Creepypasta - Fandom
31 Dec 2025
Tags
-
Deer Season (Tim Wright/Masky x F!Reader) by dirtyl0ver
Fandoms: Creepypasta - Fandom, Marble Hornets
30 Dec 2025
Tags
Summary
It’s closing time in the shitty bar where you bartend, a place that should’ve stayed empty. Then he walks in, and suddenly you’re not sure if you’re serving a customer or feeding a predator.
"The evil is inside me. Inside all of us here. Let’s hope it doesn’t get you too."
-
Tags
Summary
You were born a hungry creature, tainted and unnatural, yearning for a bite. Your father made you to be beautiful, the perfect angel — a gift to God. But you've defied your purpose from the start. Running from divinity, from perfection. Letting sin corrupt your appetite. Now you roam the forest, cold and free. Not any longer lonely. Will they teach you how to feel human again?
────
A story in which you live as a man-eating beast in the forest. You're entirely alone — relying on your sharp thinking and even sharper teeth to keep yourself alive. Until you meet them. You refuse to be a slave again. You fight and claw your way out countless times. They're sick of it. Sick of you. But none of you have a choice. You're in this together wether you like it or not. And you'll learn to like it soon enough.
𑁍ࠬܓ
-
Tags
Summary
A peculiar interest with all things sharp and a generally bad mental health is a shit salad to deal with and when you’ve got literally all time on your hands and left home alone constantly you turn to the internet for company.
And fall in love with a certain killers axes.
-
Tags
Summary
You just wanted to have a good time with your friends. But everything went straight to hell when you made the mistake of staying at the wrong cabin.
Or, Toby does his job but takes a liking to you, and you quickly come to realize what that means for you. It’s a fight to survive and a fight to keep your humanity.
A/N: tags and warnings are subject to change as the story progresses. Please heed the tags!
-
Tags
Summary
In which a broke university student ends up having to walk an hour home after her car breaks down.
or
In which Toby ends up begging Tim and Brian to break into a pretty girls house because he wanted a bag of chips.- Language:
- English
- Words:
- 887
- Chapters:
- 1/?
- Kudos:
- 2
- Hits:
- 69