1 - 20 of 39 Works in Brittnay Matthews
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
Shay knew that admitting her feelings for Mackenzie would lead to ridicule and worse, so she buried the feelings deep and hoped no one would ever notice how they ate her alive from the inside. Then, one day, her plan gets foiled, leading to an unwanted reveal.
Mackenzie often found that the best distraction from not getting what she wanted was having a boy toy who could give her the adoration she spent her whole life looking for. The last thing she expected was that kind of affirmation from her rival.
-
Love Someone For Lovin’ You (Instead of Someone Really Cool) by nollamano852
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
22 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
Brittnay doesn’t really know how to be a “good friend,” exactly. With the way Saison saved her ass in Paris, and the shit she’s given her over the last year and a half, she’ll sure fucking try to be.
Saison’s never hated Brittnay. Not really, anyway.
With the trauma of being kidnapped and tortured, she’s a little more of an emotional mess, and much more reserved. They do their best anyway.
[Blaine/Saison is temporary I prommy. Also this is kind of a character exploration for both Britt and Saison; ShayMack have their own background slow burn]
-
MPGIS: Summer Vacation by Rachel_Tice (nerdium)
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
05 Jan 2026
Tags
Summary
The Most Popular Girls in School are back home in Overland Park. After giving up their modeling contracts in Paris, the crew is back to finish the summer before their final year at Overland Park High School. Of course, nothing stays quiet for long when the most popular girls in school are back in town.
Series
- Part 1 of MPGIS Continued
-
And I Just Wanna Take you Home by Aloes_tide005
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
17 Apr 2025
Tags
Summary
The aftershocks of a scathing Facebook post/article made by a supposed "Jenna Darabond's PR manager" dead set on trashing every past member of the 2014 Overland Park High School Cheer Squad hit everyone, some more than others, it seems.
Series
- Part 1 of Jenna Darabond for President 2028
-
Tags
Summary
Taking place in between Season 4 and 5, the cheerleaders decide to seek out who killed Jenna Darabond and take revenge.
Rated M for extreme language.
-
the joys of marriage (now available in three easy installments of $19.99) by yikesbaby
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
03 Jan 2025
Tags
Summary
There was also, of course, the matter of Shay Van Buren.
Because even ten years after high-school, a degree in Fashion Merchandising and Business Management, and a minor in Journalism and Communications, Mackenzie simply could not fucking escape Shay Van Buren.
-
Tags
Summary
Brittnay squinted. “I think you fucking misheard me.”
“Ah, I do not think so.” Saison grinned. “I believe, in fact, I have heard you today clearer than ever before.”
a three chapter twenty centimeter deep exploration of abo dynamics and the world’s most complicated situationship
-
you make me feel like there's something that i never knew (i wanted) by shayvanburen
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
26 Apr 2024
Tags
Summary
After Trisha failed to get Mackenzie and Brittnay back as friends during the end-of-year party—mostly because Shay had somehow switched the footage back—everybody moved on. Brittnay started playing volleyball. Shay started coming to practice. Inevitably, their lives converge again.
This time Shay ignored her in earnest, but Brittnay made sure that she saw the middle finger flipped at her before Brittnay ran down the bleachers, sweat-damp hair fanning out behind her, backlit by the slowly setting sun.
-
left-face, right-face, about-face by yikesbaby
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
25 Dec 2023
Tags
Summary
“Well, you guys look like a fucking shit show.”
Mackenzie’s eye twitched. As if she wasn’t having enough of a rough day.
OR
I pretend I know anything about cheerleading for 3,800+ words straight.
-
Brittnay Matthews gets F@&ked by kayromantic for EK_Braveman
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
18 Dec 2023
Tags
Summary
Brittnay Matthews has Saison Marguerite right where she wants her, or so she thinks.
-
Tags
Summary
She wasn’t really sure how exactly she’d gotten in this situation.
also known as Im Not a Coward so I Wrote This
-
Tags
Summary
Mackenzie had been having a pretty okay day.
OR
Cheerleader captain says i love you for the first time. Shay reacts normally.
-
you have the backbone of a chocolate eclair by Anonymous
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
12 Nov 2023
Tags
Summary
The delicate power structure of Overland Park had been teetering on a dangerous slope, verging on total collapse, ever since key figures of the delicately curated hierarchy had begun presenting.
Also titled: The Fic Nobody Asked For But Every Fandom Has It So I Took It Upon Myself To Write It As A Joke And Then It Wasn’t A Joke.
-
Tags
Summary
It had been her own fault, if she really thought about it. Despite having double and triple checked the invite list, somehow, some way, through the cracks an unwelcome person had slipped by. Namely, Shay VanBuren’s ex-boyfriend, Chris Pecker.
OR
mackenzie jealousy fic. for you guys.
-
my girlfriend’s husband fights for your freedom by yikesbaby
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
21 Oct 2023
Tags
Summary
Brittnay Matthews despised her birthday.
OR
I force Brittnay Matthews to engage in family dynamics and then everybody claps
-
step into the room (like it’s a catwalk) by yikesbaby
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
17 Oct 2023
Tags
Summary
Mackenzie comes to a terrible realization: she has a crush on Shay VanBuren
OR
A oneshot that got too long so now it’s three chapters
-
Tags
Summary
She felt herself grow drowsy at the gentle lulls of a soft voice singing about… not… boys?
Hold on.
She furrowed her brows and looked down at the phone. There, written underneath the cover, Hayley Kiyoko.
Huh.
______
OR the one where Shay and Mackenzie stumble into being girlfriends by being enemies first
-
Will You Still Love Me Tomorrow? by CousinBraeburn00
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
01 Sep 2023
Tags
Summary
Brittnay was so outrageously fucking in love with her that she could add it to her tagline. Mackenzie Zales: Head cheerleader, homecoming queen, part-time model, the bitch that Brittnay Matthews worships.
~~~
This was only supposed to be like 8k words, but I went a little overboard and had way too much fun. There's not enough content for this fandom so here's my contribution. Rated M because of the crazy amount of swearing and sexual references. In fact, I believe there are 319 F-bombs in here.
-
Buttons, Sequins, and Glitter by NoonboryKedabory
Fandoms: The Most Popular Girls in School
12 Aug 2023
Tags
Summary
Mackenzie shows Brittnay the most recent outfits she's modeled.
100 Ships Challenge Prompt #43 - Yellow
Series
- Part 27 of 100 Ships Challenge
-
Tags
Summary
Her phone sprung up with a ring. She welcomed the distraction with a “Oh thank fuck.” and brought the phone up to her ear. “What the fuck do you want?”
“Ah, hello, Brittnay!”
Fuck. She should’ve stayed bored.
______
or the one where baby Britt has cheerleader tryouts